Кучменев Л.С.-решение от 14.09.2011

5
|p. geno Ns2-2038I201| PEIIIEHI4E T4MEHEM PO CCWETCKO]'T OErePArI4r4 r. Bopryra Pecny6nurz Kovra 14cerrr6px 2011 rota Boprytancr<ufi ropogcroft cyA Pecrry6nurra Korraz B cocraBe IlpeAceAareJrbcrByroqero cy,4brr lIJr ac,TnHrrna U.B. ; rprr ceKperape 3aftqesofi -f,.O., paccMoTpeB B oTKpbrToM cy.4e6HoM 3aceAaHr,rr{ lptl)ItAaHcKoe AeJro IIo rrcKy Peruosanruofi o6rqecrnennofi opraHrrarlu[ <Ileur:p 3arrl]rrbr norpe6zrenefi> B 3a[Ir4Ty lpaB r4 3aKoHrrBrx r{mepecoB Kyurraeuera lleonu4a Crenanosr,r.ra r Arqzoueprouy KoMMepqecKoMy 6anrcy <<MocxoecKrft 6anr per<oncrpyKr\ur4 Lr p{r:Br{Trzr)(OAO) o B3brcKaHr4lr y6urr<on, [pr4qr,IHenu6x BKlIIoqeHrleM e rpegzrnrrfi ,qoroBop ycnorufi, ylqeMJrtloqax npaaa norpe6rareJlt, I{H,qeKcaqul{ 14 KoMrreHcaql{I,r, a raxl{e KoMnegcaur{It MopajrbHoro BpeAa, YCTAIIOBI{JI: POO <I{eurp 3arrlr4Tbr norpe6zr:eneft> o6parunau, c rrcKoM B 3arrlary npaB vr 3axoHrrbx vHTepecoB Kyulrenera JI.C. n orBerquKy o nprrMeueurzu nocne,qcrnuii ne4eficrnurenruocrr4 AoroBopa Ng. 7021/7 o'r 25.05.2007 ro.qa, HrrrrroxHoro B qacrrl o6r3aHnocr[ Kyruenera JI.C. onJrarbr B nonb3y AKE <MocroecKr.rfi 6anr peKoHcrpyKrlrzr4 lr pa3BLlTrrr^) (OAO) KoMuccuv 3a BeAeHr{e ccyrHoro cqera N9 40817810321020004334 B pa3Mepe 0,35 o/o or cyMMbr Kpe,qrrra, coorBErcrByro[lwx2S8T py6reft 50 roneer exeMecsquo, ocBo6o,qr4B ero c 01.08.2008 roaa or yxasaunofi o6{3aHHocrlr, o B3brcKaHzr4 y6bITKoB, [pI4qIzHeHHbrx BKJIIoqeHr4eM r rgpegrarHrrft AoroBop ycJroBr{fi, yrrleMrrrrorqux npara no:rpe6urerur B pa3Mepe101062 py6rcfi 50 KoneeK, r,rHAeKcaquu B piBMepe 10224py1rcil 64 roneer, KoMneHcaqlrr4 3a noirb3oBauae qyxr,rMr,r AeHerubrMr4 cpe,qcrBaMr,r B pa3Mepe 73 py6rcit 46 roneen, KoMrreucarlr{rl Moprurbrroro BpeAa B pa3Mepe 5000 py6nefi, urrpaQaB pa3Mepe 50%o or rpr4cyrKAeHHoft B [OJrb3y Kyruenena JI.C. cyrr.rvrr, c flepeq?rcJreHr,r ertt 50Yo cyMMbr 3Toro uTpaoa B nomay POO (IIeHTp 3arrlr4Tbr fiorpe6urereft>. B o6ocrosaHr.re 3urBJreuubrx rpe6oBaHfifi yKrrcrur,wo 25 vias 2007 fo,qa 6brn 3axrro.ren rpegrarHrrft AoroBop Ns 702117. Cornacno raHHoMy AoroBopy orBerqrzK IlpeAocraBrrJr r4crrly KpeAr4T B cyuue 825000 py6r-eir. noL 9Yo roAoBbrx,cpoKoM Bo3Bpara 25 *ras 2012 rola. B coorBercrBr4r4 n.n. 5.8 .{ororopa, a raKi(e rpa(br,rKoM rrJrarexefi, BITAaHHrIMorBerrII,IKoM norpe6nremo, npeAycMarprlB aJracb ofiJra'fa rIorpe6I4Te.,TeM exevec.flqHoft KoMr{ccr{r{ 3a BeAeHr4e ccy.qroro cuera (J\b 40817810321020004334) y pa3Mepe 0,35 % or cyMM6rKpelr4ra, To ecrB n3 pacqera 2887 py6rcfi, 50 lconeer. Vxa,eauuoe o6.f,garemc:rso Kyvlr.reneaurr.t JLC. ucnonnserc.t, KoMtrccr4lr 3a BeAeHr4e ccyAHoro cqera BrlnraqvrBaercs 3aeMrrlt4KoM BnJIorB Ao Hacrotlqero BpeMeHu.tr13 noJIoxeHIrI o flparznax Be.qenr'rr 6yxralrepcrcoro yrrera B KpeAzrHbrx opraHrcaqrrJrx,

Upload: max-k

Post on 13-Mar-2016

227 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

DESCRIPTION

решение Воркутинского городского суда от 14.09.2011 по делу Кучменева Л.С.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Кучменев Л.С.-решение от 14.09.2011

|p. geno Ns2-2038I201|

PEIIIEHI4E

T4MEHEM PO CCWETCKO]'T OErePArI4r4

r. Bopryra Pecny6nurz Kovra 14 cerrr6px 2011 rota

Boprytancr<ufi ropogcroft cyA Pecrry6nurra Korraz B cocraBeIlpeAceAareJrbcrByroqero cy,4brr lIJr ac,TnHrrna U.B. ;

rprr ceKperape 3aftqesofi -f,.O.,paccMoTpeB B oTKpbrToM cy.4e6HoM 3aceAaHr,rr{ lptl)ItAaHcKoe AeJro IIo rrcKy

Peruosanruofi o6rqecrnennofi opraHrrarlu[ <Ileur:p 3arrl]rrbr norpe6zrenefi> B 3a[Ir4TylpaB r4 3aKoHrrBrx r{mepecoB Kyurraeuera lleonu4a Crenanosr,r.ra r ArqzoueprouyKoMMepqecKoMy 6anrcy <<MocxoecKrft 6anr per<oncrpyKr\ur4 Lr p{r:Br{Trzr) (OAO) oB3brcKaHr4lr y6urr<on, [pr4qr,IHenu6x BKlIIoqeHrleM e rpegzrnrrfi ,qoroBop ycnorufi,ylqeMJrtloqax npaaa norpe6rareJlt, I{H,qeKcaqul{ 14 KoMrreHcaql{I,r, a raxl{e KoMnegcaur{ItMopajrbHoro BpeAa,

YCTAIIOBI{JI:

POO <I{eurp 3arrlr4Tbr norpe6zr:eneft> o6parunau, c rrcKoM B 3arrlary npaB vr3axoHrrbx vHTepecoB Kyulrenera JI.C. n orBerquKy o nprrMeueurzu nocne,qcrnuiine4eficrnurenruocrr4 AoroBopa Ng. 7021/7 o'r 25.05.2007 ro.qa, HrrrrroxHoro B qacrrlo6r3aHnocr[ Kyruenera JI.C. onJrarbr B nonb3y AKE <MocroecKr.rfi 6anrpeKoHcrpyKrlrzr4 lr pa3BLlTrrr^) (OAO) KoMuccuv 3a BeAeHr{e ccyrHoro cqera N940817810321020004334 B pa3Mepe 0,35 o/o or cyMMbr Kpe,qrrra, coorBErcrByro[lwx2S8Tpy6reft 50 roneer exeMecsquo, ocBo6o,qr4B ero c 01.08.2008 roaa or yxasaunofio6{3aHHocrlr, o B3brcKaHzr4 y6bITKoB, [pI4qIzHeHHbrx BKJIIoqeHr4eM r rgpegrarHrrftAoroBop ycJroBr{fi, yrrleMrrrrorqux npara no:rpe6urerur B pa3Mepe 101062 py6rcfi 50KoneeK, r,rHAeKcaquu B piBMepe 10224 py1rcil 64 roneer, KoMneHcaqlrr4 3a noirb3oBauaeqyxr,rMr,r AeHerubrMr4 cpe,qcrBaMr,r B pa3Mepe 73 py6rcit 46 roneen, KoMrreucarlr{rlMoprurbrroro BpeAa B pa3Mepe 5000 py6nefi, urrpaQa B pa3Mepe 50%o or rpr4cyrKAeHHoftB [OJrb3y Kyruenena JI.C. cyrr.rvrr, c flepeq?rcJreHr,r ertt 50Yo cyMMbr 3Toro uTpaoa Bnomay POO (IIeHTp 3arrlr4Tbr fiorpe6urereft>.

B o6ocrosaHr.re 3urBJreuubrx rpe6oBaHfifi yKrrcrur, wo 25 vias 2007 fo,qa 6brn3axrro.ren rpegrarHrrft AoroBop Ns 702117. Cornacno raHHoMy AoroBopy orBerqrzKIlpeAocraBrrJr r4crrly KpeAr4T B cyuue 825000 py6r-eir. noL 9Yo roAoBbrx, cpoKoM Bo3Bpara25 *ras 2012 rola. B coorBercrBr4r4 n.n. 5.8 .{ororopa, a raKi(e rpa(br,rKoM rrJrarexefi,BITAaHHrIM orBerrII,IKoM norpe6nremo, npeAycMarprlB aJracb ofiJra'fa rIorpe6I4Te.,TeMexevec.flqHoft KoMr{ccr{r{ 3a BeAeHr4e ccy.qroro cuera (J\b 40817810321020004334) ypa3Mepe 0,35 % or cyMM6r Kpelr4ra, To ecrB n3 pacqera 2887 py6rcfi, 50 lconeer.Vxa,eauuoe o6.f,garemc:rso Kyvlr.reneaurr.t JLC. ucnonnserc.t, KoMtrccr4lr 3a BeAeHr4eccyAHoro cqera BrlnraqvrBaercs 3aeMrrlt4KoM BnJIorB Ao Hacrotlqero BpeMeHu. tr13noJIoxeHIrI o flparznax Be.qenr'rr 6yxralrepcrcoro yrrera B KpeAzrHbrx opraHrcaqrrJrx,

Page 2: Кучменев Л.С.-решение от 14.09.2011

paclonoxeH'brx Ha repparopr4r4 POCCT4fiCKO i't @e!.paquu. cJreAyer, qro y'roBr4eMnpeAocraBreHr4s 14 rrora[reH]ur KpeAr.rra (xpe4raropcrax o6_ssauHoirr 6anKa)'seflfiercsorKpbrrl4e Lr BeAeHr,Ie 6anxorra ccyAHoro cvera. ccyAnbre cqera He ,BJUTTOTC'6alrnoscKrirau cqeraMr,r r4 noJr'3ylorcr AJI' orpu,Ke'I/It u 6-ur"" 6avxa olpasonauut uloralleHr4',r ccyAlrofr 3aAOJrX.HHOCTr', TO ecrS 0uepaquft to arpa4-oaruuo""",o3aeMrrlr'rKaM r4 BO3Bpary nMrr AeuexHbrx cpercrB (Kpeauros) u

"oot"*"""r" a3aKrroqeHH'IMrZ 4peAr4THbIMr4 AOTOBOpaMV. Tar<rau o6pasou, Aeftc'sv' 6a+rre no

. orKpBrrI4ro Ir BeaeHr,to ccyAHoro cqera HeJrb3r xranuQuquponarb KaK caMocro_rilenbrryro6aur<orcrylo ycrryry.

18 anrycra 2011 ro4a rrocrynliJro yrovndnuoe [cKoBoe 3urBJreHrre, o npr4Me'e'Hr'nocreAcrszft Hegeficrrarenrrocrz 40ronopa J\b 702u7 0r 2s"05.i007 rola,Hr'rrrrox'oro B rracrLr o6qgansocru Kyrlreuena JI.c. onnarrr n nonrsy AKE<MocxoscKr4fi 6ann pexoncrpyKrlrr' r.r pa3Bvruar> (oAo) rouzc awr 3a BeAeHr{e ;ccyrHoro cqera Ns 40817810321020004334 B pi*Mepe }s;s % or cyMM'r Kperura,coorBercrByrouux 2887 py1rcir 50 xoneen exeMecrqHo, oceo60gua ero c 01.0g.200groAa or yxasauuoft o6.asaurocrz, o B36ICKaHUI{ y6rn:rcoe, npaqr,rHeHH6IX BKrrroqeHr{eM BKp9Ar4TH6rii AofoBop ycno&rfi, yrqeMrrrroqux npaaa norpl6"renx n pa.uepe 101062py6tefi,50 rconee6 rrHAe*carlrrr4 B pa:iMepe r04i6 py6tei 76 r<oneer,'norn#.uu", .urroJrb3'BaHr're qyxr4Mr' re'exHBrMrr cpeAcrBaMr4 B pa3Mepe 7g7g py6rcir 0g xoueer<,KoM[eHcaquv Mop,ur'Hofo- BpeAa B pffiMepe 5000 py6neft, rmpaQa n pa3Mepe 500/o ornpzcyrrlerHoft B noJrb3y Kyuuenena JLC. cyulrrr, c repeq'creHr4iu sob

"yinr", ,ro.o

urpaQa B rrorrl3y POO <IdeH:rp 3arqarbr norpe6rar:enefi>.

flpe4craenre,rr Poo <If,enrp 3arrlr4T6r norpe6ur:e.rei> r cy4e6uoe 3aceAaHae HefrBu c'', o Mecre H BpeMeHr, paccMorpe'wr Aena 6r'o zsrerq€u HaAJrexarrlvM o6pa.:ou .cyae6nofi nosecrKofi' ,.{o cyge6noro 3acena*r4s npoAcraBr{Jr B cy.4 Bo3piDK e'r,, HaOT3EIB OTBeTqI{Ka' IIe yKaSiUI, rITO IOBOABI OTBeTql4Ka, I{3JIOX9HH6IS B OT3hrBe, HeocHoBarrbr Ha 3aKOHe. rlocxonrry ne scrKufi AoroBop Mexry cropo'aMr,r coorBer.crByerrpeooaaunrrr,r 3aKoHa .nu6o HopMarzBHhIx aKToB. Hz.rroNHocTb c,ueJIKu HeCOOTBETCTBYIOqCfi SATOHAN,{ I4 AHBIM HOPMATI,IBHbIM IIPABOB'IM AKIAM, HC MOXETnpeo.qoJreBarbcx ccrnrofi Ha cno6o.4y AoroBopa. Orsoczrenrso ,qoBo,{ orBerrruKa onporrycKe vcrrloM cpoxa zcxoaoft AaBHocrI4 yKa3aJr, qTo B coorBercrB nu co cray,Ei,t 311lpaxgaucr<oro Ko.4eKca p@ 4onycraerca Bo3MoxHocr6 r4crroJr'e'r' o6sgare*crsa noqacrf,M' qro r4Meer Mecro B .4aHHOM Cryqae. cnegonarenruo, no o6xsareJl'cTBaM Co[peAeneHHbIM cpoKoM I4crroJIHeHLu reqeHr4e ncrogofi AaBHocrIr Haqr4Haerc, IIooKoHqaHLII4 CpOKa VCnOJIHeIIII,T.

llcreq Kyvlrenen JI.c. rB Berq rc.rr o BpeMeHr4 r4 Mecre paccMorpeHrrr AeJracyge6:roft nonecrrofi, Koropzu BepHyJracb c orurerrcofi 3a r4creqeHaeM cpoKa xpaHe'rrr.Cornacuo crarr,e 118 fpax4arcroro fipoqeccyanb'oro KoAeKca poccufrcr<off

(Degepaquz, n?rqa, yqacrB).rorqr4e B AeJre, o6.flsaH' "oo6rq"'u "ygy

o .r"paroa auoa.oaApeca Bo BpeMir rrpor.r3BoAcrBa rro aeny. flpu orcyrcrBr4r{ ranoro coo6rqi uut cyge1aaxIIOBECTKA LTT', TIHOE CY4C6HOC U3BCIICHI'E IIOCEIJIZTIOTC' IIO I,OCJIENHEMY I43BCC..HOMYCYTY MCCTY XHTEJIBCTBA 'u'fiI MCCTY HAXOXAEHI4S AAPECATA fi ',-TA}OTC.AOcraBJreHHbrMr' xorr 6rr a4pecar rro sToMy agpecy 60nee He rrpoxr{Baer Dru HeHaxonrrTct.

Page 3: Кучменев Л.С.-решение от 14.09.2011

.t

llpegcranz'rerb orBerqnKa B cy,qe6Hoe saceranue He rBr,rJrcr, [pocLrJr paccMorperB,4eJIo 6e3 yrracrl,dr rrpeAcraBrrreJr-fi orBerqrrKa. B orgrree Ha r4cKoBoe 3uIBJIeHrre yKa3iul,.rro 4eftcmyroulee 3aKoHo.{areJlbcrBo Ha MoMerrr 3aKllloqeHrur cIeJrKr{ He co,uep)KanoI,IMlepaTIIBHbIx HOpM, 3allpelqarcIl{llrx Ha OCHOBO CODIaCOBaHHbIX CTOpOHaMI4 yC;rOrzii

.qoroBopa, flpeAycMarpr,rBarb ycJroBr4rr o AoflorHr,rremnofr rolruencaUr4r,r pacxoAoB6ama. flognucaB Epe1r{Tubrfi AoroBop, rrcreu reM caMrrM ,qocrrr co rarueur.ur c 6aHKoMtto BceM ero yciroBr4JrM, Brsrroqar ynnary rapr.rQa 3a BeIeHve ccyAHoro cqera. Tarxeyrul3brBaer, qro 3aKoH (O 3arrl\4Te npaB fiorpe6r4Tefieft> fipu paccMorpeHlrr.r AaHHoroAeJra He [pI4MeHrrM. BogloNenue Ha norpe6llTenfi od.f,gaHHocru onJlarlfrb orrepauno noBeleur4ro ccyAHoro cqera [pr4 npeAocraBJreHr,rrz KpeAHTa Hapyuaer 3anon <O 3aruurenpan uorpe6urenefi>> lznr B ToM cryqae, ecJrr{ 3aeMqr4r He 6bur npouulpoplrzporan oTaKoil olrare Ao 3aKrroqeHurr KpeAr4THoro AoroBopa. ?Iu$oprvraqrzr o6 ycnonruxKpeAr4Ta 6rura AoeeAeua Ao r,rcrrla .qo noArrvcaur{Jr .qoroBopa, qro rro,urBepxAaerctno.qn[caHHoii 24.05.2007 r4crrloM 3a{BireHrreM-aHxerofi na 4peAr,rr, B Koropoft B T.rr.6rruu o:rpaxeurl ycJIoBIzf, o B3r,rMaHHr4 exelrecs.ruofi KoMrrccrrr4 3a BeAeHr4e ccyAHorocrlera B pa3Mepe 0,35%o. Tawnvr o6pa3oM, rrcrell npr4 3aKJrroqeHr4r{ KpeAr{THoro AoroBopaNp Ifr{-7 02117 6rrn osnaxorareH, 6brrr corJraceH c ycJloBrarrMrr npeAocraBJreHrur Kpenvra LlrrrlKaKr{x Bo3paxeHraft He rrpeAcraBr,rJr. tr4meq B r4cKoBoM 3iurBJreHnr{ flpocrlT npor,BBecrrrIIHAeKCaIII{IO CyMM, a TaKXe B3BICKaTb KOMIeHCaIIIIO 3a rrOJrb3OBaHIre qyxrrMr4

,qeHexHBrMrr cpeAcrBaMrr. Cqzraror IaHHbre rpe6oBaHr,rr He coorBercrByrorqrlMr4,qeficrByrolleMy 3aKoHo.{areJrbcrBy. TaKxe yra3aJr, rrro rrocKoJrBKy ocuoBaHrrft AJrtB3blcKanrxr y6rrmoe He r{Meerc-fl, To rr H,qeKcarlr4Jr, AeHe}KHar KoMneHcaqurr r4KoMleHcaqr,rJr Mopa;rbHoro rarcKe He rroAJrexar B3hrcKaHuro. Kponre roro, r4crrloMlponyqeH cpoK r{cKoBoft ,qaBHocrr.r no rpe6onanruo o flprrMeHeHrrr{ fiocre,{crBniine.{eft crglrremuocrl{ HITrIToxHofi cAerKfi .

B cootserc:rer4a co crarrdh 167 lpax<laHcKoro npoqeccyrurbuofo KoAeKcaPoccuficrofi @egepaquz, cyA paccMorpeii AeJro 6e3 yrracrprs. cropot.

Ilccre,{osas Marepr{rurrr ,qeJra, cyA rrprD(oAr4T K cireAyroqeMy BbrBo.qy.

Mex4y r,rcrrloM Kyrueuerrru JI.C. fi orserqurou 6ru 3aKJrroqen rpegutrrrfi.4oroBop Ns 7021n o'r 25 vras. 2007 rota. B coorsercrsrrrr c ycrroBrlrrMr,r AoroBopaorBerqr4Ky 6rrn npe.qocraureH KpeAr4r B pa3Mepe 825000 py6reft Ha rrpllo6pereHlreTpaHcrroprHoro cpeAcrBa Mitsubishi Galant noA 9 o/o rolosHx Ha cpoK lo 25 uas.2012roga. l'Is rryHKTa 3.1. goronopa cJreAyer, rrro Arr yqeTa npeAocraBJreHHoro 3aeMur.rKyKpeArra 6aur orrprraaer ccyAHbrft c.{dr. CornacHo rryHKry 5.8. gororopa,3a BeAeHIreccyAHoro cqeTa ex(eMecrqHo B3uMaercr KoMrrcczrr 0,35Yo or cyMMbr 4pe,qr4Ta,yra-:annofi B rryHKTe 1.1. goronopa. flpvroNeuueu Nsl r gororopy tBJlterct rpa$uxflJrarexeft, B KoropoM B T.rr. orpDKeHa exeMecrqHajr KoMrrccurr B pa3Mepe 2887 py6rcir50 roneer<.

llpe.4cranureJreM orBerquKa 3a{BJIeHo o npolycKe I4crIIoM cpoKa r{cKoBofiAaBHOCTT.T IIO TpeoOBaHr4rO O npnMeHeHrrr,r flocJleAcrBrrft ueAeficrer.rreJrbHocTl{Hr4rrroxHoia cAeJrKr,r, yKa36rBrur Ha ro, rrro loroBop 6rur earurrc.{€H 25 r'/.as 2007 rcI.a u'rpexrerHllfi cpoK co AHr ero 3arurm.reHl{q ficreK.

Page 4: Кучменев Л.С.-решение от 14.09.2011

B coorserctszr4 c rryHKroM 1 cran'u 200 lpaN.qauc*oro Ko.qeKca poccuficroft@e4epaqzz, Teqegrre cpora lrcronofi AaBgocrrr HaqrrHaerct co nrur, Korna Jrrrrlo y3'aJroI4JII4 AOJTXHO 6rr.no ysnarr o HapyrreHr{r{ cnoero npana. Llsl,fiT4'- I,r3 3TOrO npaBr4JraycraHaBJrzBarorcx lpax4ancrut rrl Ko,qeKcoM Poccuficrofi @egepaqr.rz v ujFIbr:Mrr3AKOHAMII,

oAno us raKrrx r436rrr{ft ycrauonreno rrygKroM I crarsn 1g1 fpaxgancroroKOAeKca POccr.rftcrofi (De4epaqlru, corJracHo KoropoMy, cpor ucr<onoft AaBHocrr{ IIor:pe6oaanr,no o npnuenenrzz uocne.ucrsl,Ift ne4eficrnutenrHocrl{ Hrrrrroxnofi c4e,rr<zcocraBr-rer rprr rora. Teqenue cpoxa ucxoroft AaBHOCTT4 [O yKtBaHHOMy :rpe6onanrzroHaqnuaerct co IHJI, Kor.{a Haqiulocb ficnorHeH}te erofi caelru.

llpu srorrl yKa3aHHbIe troroxeuwl He iqonycKitror Bo3MoxHocrli ucqficJleHrrr cpoKaT.TCTOSOfi ,4ABHOCTI4 B 3ABI4CI,IMOCTI4 OT QAMOPA OCBEAOMJIEHHOCTI,I ]?rCTTJA OuegeficTBureffinocru (nr.rroNuocur) cgorxra, no3ToMy n :rpe6onauzru o qpvMeHeHrrr,rnocneAcrsuft ueAefictaurertHocrr4 Hlzqroxuofi cAenr<z He npLIMeruIIo rcs rrpaBprra, ,.ycraHoBJreHHbre craftdfi 200 lpaNlascKoro Ko,ueKca poccnficrofi @eAepauuu o HaqareTeqeHfiir cpoxa ucronoft AaBHocrIa.

zs rpegurnoro Ao.oBopa Ns 702u7 or 25 uas 2007 rom crreryer, qro y*d.asa€rrarqurorra KoMI4ccr4Ir 3a BeAeHrre ccyAHoro cv€ta npegyclra,rpr,rBaerct exeMec{qHoeBHeceHr4e cyMMBr B pa3Mepe 0,,35Yo or cyMMbr Kpe.qrir4 B qeJroM cocrannxrorqefi 2gg7py6reft 50 r<oneer, Ao ,4arbr onpegen€mlofi B npr4JroxeHhrl J\! 1 r 4oronopy.

Tarzu o6parorr,r, Teqerrne cpona ucr<onofi ,4aBgocrr.r no rpe6onagr.no o qprzMeneHrrrrnocre.4crsfift neAeilcrsuremEocrl,I Hr4rrroxnofi c4enr<ra HaquEaerc_{ co .qrur, KorAaHaqaJrocr r{crroJrueHr4e erofi cgelxz, To ecrb c25 tvras,2007 rona.

B coorsercrsuu c nyHrrroM 2 crarsu 199 fpax,4a'cKoro Ko.qeKca poccraftcroft ;

@eAepaquz, I{cKoBat ,4aBHocrB flplrMerulercq cyAoM ToJrbKo no 3a-rrBJIeHI4Io cropoHbr Bcflope, cAenaHHoMy i4O BbtHeoeErrr cy,qoM perrreHr4rr.

zcreqenue cpor<a ucnonoft AaBgocrr,r, o [pr4MeHeurzr4 xoropofi 3iurBJreHo croporrofiB CrIOpe, rBJUIerCt OCHOBaHI,IeM K BbIHeCeHUTO CyAOM pemeHr4s o6 0rxa3e g racre.

?Icr<osoe sarnreHr.re rroAauo r cyg 19 tlotts 20ll rota.

flpu rarrax o6crosrerucrgax r4crrloM 6ee ynaxz:rerbgbrx npr4qriH rrporyrleHrpdxnerulrfi cpor o6paqenr4q B cy[ no rpe6onaarzrc o rrptrMerreurzra noc;regcrnzftHe,qefcrBI4TerbHocrr4 Hlzqrox(uofi c4enxr.r, B BIrAy qero Bce ncKoBhle rpe6ouauzx HerroAJlexaT y.4oBireTBopeHl{Io, KaK npOI43BOAHbIe OT IaIIHOTO,

cregorarenrno, AoBoAbr rrpe.{craBnreJrr poo <t{enrp 3ar{r.rr6r norpe6r.rrenefi> eTofi 'racrll, qro no o6ssaremcrsau c onpe4en6HH6lM cpoKoM r,rcrloJlHeHrlur reqeHneTCKOSOfi .qtIBIIOCTII l,]'AII:ri.HlAETC[ rIO OKOH'IAHI{14 CPOKA 14 CIIOJIIIEHII'I, B AAHHOM CTYqAC HCUOryT 6TNT IIPTzH'TrI CYAOM BO BHI4MAHNC, TAK KAK OCHOBAHrI HA HEBEPHOM TOJIKOBAHI4AHopM rrpaBa o rrpr4MeHeHrlu cporoB ncKoBo[ ganuocrt,r.

Ha ocronanzu r43Jroxeggoro u pyKoBoAcrByrcb crarbsMr4 lg4-l9g fpaxAaucr<orolpoqeccyrrJrbuoro r<ogenca Poccaficxoft (Degepaqura,

Page 5: Кучменев Л.С.-решение от 14.09.2011

PEII]I{JI:

B yroBJrerBope'lrr{ rrcKoBhrx rpe60nanufi perao'a,Truofi o6rqecrreHuoftopraHr43arlrra <<Ireu:rp 3arrr4Thr uorpe6zre'refi> B 3arrlr4Ty [paB r4 3aKOHHbrx r.rHTepecoBKy'ruenena JleouzAa crenanosu'ra o anq"*"p"ory KoMMepqec*oMy 6aury<Mocr<oecKrzfi 6aur pexonurpyKt\ur4_r1-pa3Bwr\n (o;-ot; ,il;;;;:":'" e*crBvirne4eftcrnzrenr'ocrz .qoroBop a Np Toil/l or zs.os.zool roAa, Hr,rqroxHoro B qacrr4o6lgaunocrra KyvlreHera ff .C. orrJrarrr "

-non"ay AKE <<MocxoecKrafi 6anrpeKoHcTpyKrIWI v pa3BLrtufl>> (OAO) r<oirauc cvrv sa Be.qeHr.re ccyn'oro cqera Ns40817810321020004334 B pa3Mepe 0,3,'5 o/o w

"yr"u, op.Arru, coorBercrByro nlux 2gg7py''eit 50 xoneer< exeMecrqHo, ocso60Naer,"r Kyurae'ena JI.c. c 01.0g.200g ro4a oryr<asanuofi o6rcanuocra, o.. B3bICKaHItr4 y6rnron, [p[qvHeHH6rX BKJIrOqeHr4eM BKpeAr'T'bri roroBop ycnorzfi, yqeMJrrroqr{x npara norpe6zr:"n"

" p*r"p" 101062py6rcir 50 xoneer, r'H'eKcaqrrr4 B pa3Mepe r042k py6rcft 76 xoneen, KoMrreHcarlr4z 3arroJr630Ba'r're qyxr'rMtl ..errex'brMrz cpeAcrBaMr.r r p*rapa 7g7g py6neft 0g roneer;B3brcxaHr4 r.r KoMrreHcar_lrnfi MopaJrbHoro BpeAa B pa3Mele 5000 py6lefi, urpaQa npa3Mepe 50%o or npucyNgeHnofi

" noo"ry Kyvneneea n.c.

"vr*ii " ,rJp.i#"nr",50% cp'ruH sroro urrpaoa r nonrsy Poo nd.ntp sarqurH no:rpe.ureneftir, - orKa3arb.

Pe'reure uoxer 6rrrr o6xa,ronauo n Bepxonurril cy,. pecny.rurz Kouz uepesBopxyrzucxrafi ropo4clcoft cya pecny6nzn" Ko"ll u """an""

gecnu pueit co ,qrurriprIHtrTIZr pelrreHrtr.

Ilpe4ce4are.nrcrnyorqzfi cy/It fl nf/ n rz24 l4.B.flJlacruuLInv