*˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2...

13
! "#$ %&’( ) *#+, -.- / -0 12 1 -!1 *2 - 1- 34 % 15 . 6 7 -1+- .8 9 .:; <$ -= >$ $-1 ?@ * *=$ AB 6C /2 / ) / *+0/ 6DE! 6?FG +- A= +1 -0 1 *2 - -!1 A- -!B1 =$ 3E A/- - $1 HI1 / J +C 6K/LM N+- ! ) O/ O+- -.O" -0 1 -!1 *2 - AO12-1E PO1 ! 1 "1 ! E- 6Q R1E ! J NSO K/LOM NO+- ! O/ 1 -!1 A! * .C - ) / NS T"U 1 -!1 A! * ) - .C VWE / = X ./ Y OC - !W"- .+!12 *#+, N:-! J / N; *+0/ 6AFG A1 ) / *O# 3F$ *+0/ * AFG A# ZB [ * 0 . *\@ $-1 . +- J ]+" A! * .C NS * !-! A! * - .C ) / O2 )O 6.O\$ ZBO 6*BO1 6=1 .Q- ^_"B- --! *E ) -! N ! *E ) ) \ 6! ./ ) NS ) / +1O ‘ O N+1O$ *+0/ ) N+1$ . X C 6N:-! ab a c Y J NS 1 -!1 A! * O; NU$ -1; - . 3E ) - .C X O * Td -!1 * eG Y N ! ) / ! 1 A-! ./ ) NS - ^_"B- N+1" X 6N:-! C ab a c Y * A# \ ) / 1M 1S+! *+0/ 1 . J NS A! * >W$- ) - .C f C 1O _O ^_"OB- .OE *O -! gF\ - 6! ./ ) NS N ! 0 *+0/ ) / ! 1 ! -!B1 \E 3E AFG - * 6.O- +1 *+0/ N+1$ ) N+1$ ! X 6N:-! C ab a c Y J h- / . i - -0 6+ 1 -!1 6 6 *+0/ 6AFG 6P$-1 *# 3F$ !"!# $%& ’( )* + ," -* ’(./ )01/ )0"23 *1 4

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jan-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! /�"#�$%&'(

���

)�� *#+,���-.�- / �-0�� 1�2�1���-!1�*��2 �-

Eurotia ceratoides

1��- 34�% 1�5� .�� 67��-�1+- .�8� � 9

�.�:;

<�$ � ��-�= >�$ � ���� �$-1� ���� ?@� *� *=�$ � AB 6�C �/�2 /)��/� *+0/ �� 6D�E! 6?�FG ��+��- A�= �+1�-0�� �1�� � *��2 �- -!1� A�- �-!��B1� ��=�$ 3�E A��/- �- ��$1� H�I1� / . �+C�� 6K/�LM N+- �!)�� O/ ��O+��- ��-.O"�

�-0���1���-!1� *��2 �- E.ceratoides AO�12�-1E PO��1� !��� �1��� �"�1� �! �E-� 6Q R1E �! . N�S�O�� K/�LOM NO+- �! O/�1���-!1� A�! *� .�C �- �)��/ N�S��� � T�"U� �1���-!1� A�! *� )�� �- �.�C VWE/�=�� ) ./ ( ��O��C �- �!W"�- �

.+!12 *#+,� N:�-! .�/N�; � *+0/ 6AFG A�1�)��/ *�O#�� 3��F$ � *+0/ *� AFG A�#� ZB [�� *� 0�� �. *�\@� ��$-1�(AHP). ��+��- .

]+"� A�! *� �.�C N�S��� *� !-! ��� A�! *� �- �.�C )��/ � �O�2 )��O 6.O�\�$ ZBO 6*BO 1� ��� 6�=1� .Q-� ^_"B- -�-! *E� )�� ����-! N�� �! *E� )�� )�� �\� 6!�� ./ )�� N�S��� � )��/ �+1O� ���`� �O� � N+1O$

*+0/ )�� N+1$��. �) ����C 6N:�-!ab/a<P( .��N�S��1���-!1� A�! *� ��O�; N��U$ � -1; �- .�� � 3�E )�� �- �.�C ) O� *T�d� �-!1� *���� e��G( N�� �! )��/ !��� ���1�A -! ./ )�� N�S��� � -� ^_"B- N+1"�� ) 6N:�-! ����Cab/a< P(

*� A�#� �\�)��/ 1M 1S+! � *+0/���1���. � . N�S��� A�! *� >W$�- )�� �- �.�Cf �C 1O� ��_O� ��� ^_"OB- .OE� *O�����-! � ��� gF\ �- 6!�� ./ )�� N�S��� � N�� �! 0�� *+0/)��/ !��� ���1� �!�� �-!��B1� �\��E 3�E AFG �- *� 6.O�-

�+1�*+0/ �� � N+1$ )�� N+1$!��) 6N:�-! ����Cab/a<P(.

�h-� / .��� :�- �-0�� 6��+��1���-!1� 6 E.ceratoides 6*+0/ 6AFG 6P�$-1� *�#�� 3��F$

� .����� ��� ��� ��������� ��� ����� � ��� �!"!#� � $�%& �' (�

�.)* � � ��+���� ,"� � -* �� � ����'�(./ )�01/ ����� �)0"23 �*�1� ��4��

Page 2: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! / �"#�$%&'(

�56

*�.,�

�� � 7+ +�� �� -�8 -* $� ���9 �+�* -:* -:� ��:; <":=1� �

��� ��� �2"�� >�? � �@�"8 A;�B . <:(� ��@�C* � �D+

'C"� E""0� �� � � $� F��0� ��� * ��� (*�� * -:� 7:� �

�� ��"* �� �� � -�"G�� -9�%& �"G�� � ��/�;�* H:+ �� -�

�� 7;� * $� I��� � J ���� ��;)L .(N�� �:@� ���":O*

'C"� E""0� � *� (*�� * ��� ��P� � . �N���@ F��:�� �

-��* '�@�"8 � *� � -:��* -Q" �:� � N�� '�:� R:.S �:@ �

� T2S ��P�� U�.�� ��Q�J E"QV� � J � �0*W ��� �'��

N��Q:; � ��"8 N��Q; ��"G�� X?�; �-?�; � F�3 ��P �

� * $� � -S��)Y6�Y5 .(

N��SR.�@ �P�� �) E+��:� � �ZS ( F��:�� � � E+ :�

["#/ E+ �N���@ 'C"� ���� * �� (*�� * 7:� �)Y6�Y5

�Y� .( ���� F�:3 �� -:� �Z+ :; �� ��/ �� -* N�� E+

-�;� A+�� '�@�"8 J)Y� ( �1:;�* A:+�� �:S�9 �:+ �)Y� (

�� $����;.

���:9 H:"B � R�:\"B I:��� �Q:�J E"QV� N��)�](

�; U�* . E":* -G��0� H+ ���+ �N�� E+ 7S� '� * ^�* � *

�0S� ��!� � �@���� * � :(* �� :* T+�:0� � _�:/ � :* ��

E"QV� ��(1�"B �@; 7:� ��)��Y6 .( -:�Q �:�� �� � :"8 E:+

�� N�� �+ � �B ��� ��:? �:;�* ��:"8)�] .( >��:�)Y6 �Y5 (

-:�Q ��� -� ���� � � '�"*8 E":QV� N�� ��:;�* �:B � :"

-/ & � * �Q�J� �+ � �9�� ��� -* �0"23 ��@7� `"S�.

'C"� ���� * �+� N��� (* �� :* �:P � �:�� N�� ��

7::� . ��::O� I::��� N�� E::+)Y� ( �::; -::a� . �::��

-�Q ��:"8 b�:cV� 7Q:OS H:+ N�� E+ �� � "8 �:1��

��"8 $�Q� �+ -� � �-S�����;�* � ��� �B -* ��" . ��@���

-:�8 � :* �P � '�8�:�8 �:�+�� F�D:; � d:%�V� ��:@

'�:1& -* ��"8 � ���� �+�* T#� @ �� � ��* �@�? ��.��

�� �S� $� ���.�� ���� -� ��; e�V� �P � �����; . E+

�P �� N��+ �� � :J F�:3 �� -:� ��:; -:�9 8 ��� -* ���

� ��+�� '�@�"8 �1;�* 7� �� F�� �� �+ �1;�* -�;. "f ��

E+ �+�* ��/ J ���� + �:+ �:�D F�:3 ��� �1J � A"* �

J ���� 8 �+�* �;�* �^�3 �+ ��� ����� T/�9 �� � :"8

� "8 ��/ .<@E"1J �� �����+ J �� �^�3 ���0� '��

��:Q 7:=9�#� :J � � �@��� � . �:�"* N�� E:+ � :*

-��* '�@�"8-��* -Q" � ���(1�"B �����;)g�Y6 � Y5.(

� �+� �D+N���@ 'C:"� ���� :* � � :(* �� :* N�� �

7� -?�; � F�3 .'�O%)�5 ( � *E"�OV ���� :* � * ��*

<"!�O� "f� (*�� * -��* '�@�"8 � -?�:; � F�:3 N�� � �

� � ���.�� . -:* ���:+� 7@�2; N�� E+ U�:.�� N�� W '��

:""h� i�:� * N�� E+ -� 7� E+ �� '� ��.� � ���

-?�; � F�3���;�* -�8 � * ��"* � � *��:� �2:�? ��:@

���. U�.�� N�� -� ����/ �� W � ��:"8 U�:.�� i�� * '��

���� '� ""h�; 7:� �� . F�:3 N�� ^�D:; � �:D+

EDQ� $� -� 7� E+ -?�; � j :* I!9 7� � ��:"8 ��:@

'��* ���V* -:� E+ -?�:; � U�:.�� ��� :* "kl:� ��m:�* .

'C:"� ���:� -�8 E+ �� E+ *�1* � :(* �� :* ���� :* :�Q� �

����; . -:* n�:2Z T:*�S ,:��1� o�2�� E�9�+ '� �+� TD��

�Z? -Z*� ��P���;�*)Y6�Y5.(

p:1"J �@ � T"��*)Y6�Y5 ( :"h�� �� � F�:3 � :ZS

�� � ���.�� '�� �+���"B � * .�� F�� @�+�*7OV U�

��; XV�� o�2�� . o�:2�� � I:*�� E:+ -:/ & �� �:@ ��:@

'��� � d%�V� "h�� � ��.�� ��@���1;�*.E+ *�1*�+�* @ ��

* '��� @ �+ -/ & -�� 8 -2��#� -�8�P ��3.

'� ::*)YY ( � �::"G�� X?�::; N��� ::* 'C::"� ���� ::*

� (*�� * � :� U�* �2�? '�@�"8 � . q":@ N�� E:+ �� -:�8

��� �Q ��/ ��� � "8� "8 . �����@)YL ( 7:;� '�:"*

'C"� ���� * � * �"G�� X?�; N�� -�� (*�� *-�8 � ��@

,��1� ��;�* X"V�� T*�S ���� -* �(� ���P �;� -� �*�J

7� . �0S� '�� N�� E+ �:Q E":QV� � ��; 7;� * �:�

��� �� ��� '�� �2O X?�; H+ ����;�*.

�+� �N���@ 'C"� ���� * �� (*�� * N��Q:; N�� �

7� -S�� . �����)�g ( E":* <"!�:O� -Z*� H+ -� 79�+��

Page 3: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

)�� *#+,���-.�- /�1�� �-0�� 1�2 *��2 �- �-!1�Eurotia ceratoides

�5Y

'C"�� (*�� * -S�:� ��:0� �:* � :J ��:@ ��� ��:P� ��:; .

���9 H"B � R�\"B)�] (� �:* -S�:� N��Q:; N�� -O+�!� �

N�� +�� r+�:� -s �1�9�+�� �@ 7:�� -:* N�� E:+ � ��:��

+�� �* ���+� t��?N���@ ��� )�u.(

U�.�� N�� �+� N��W 7:� '�� . G�: � � '�:����G

)�6 ( 7� o�2�� �� '�� �* <�� � <�� �* U�.�� -� �1�9�+��

���"B � * �+ �� '�� � � '�� � � ���.�� <�� . N�� E:+

�� � J � �;� U�.�� A@�� �/�� �� = � :"8 . N�� ��

U�.��W ��:"8 H+ � * ��+�� TD; -� 7� ��; v 9 '��

�G�� �� 7� 7*�k :""h� �:* �:.%& '�@�"8 ��+�� TD; -�

�� ""h� �@ � e� � ����+�� ��1�E+ *�1* �� ""h� @ ���+ �*

��+�� TD;�+�* '�� � U�.�� � * ��+�P -Z*� 7:�� -:*

���� . 7S� N�� E+ 7O" �%Q& ���1(B ��� �� � ���* "8 .

��::@��� � ::* 7::� ��::; w::&�* N�� E::+ �^�::* 7::S�

�Q -� �+�@�P �� � �@���+���� �:ZS � �:B T:?� <"�:�

�Q+ <"1� ���.�� '� � <")Yu.(

:�+� �:D+ C:" ��"8 N��Q; N�� �N�� �:@ ���� :* �

'C"�� (*�� * ����;�* . ��"8 N��Q; N��� N�� � �2"� �

U�.�� N�� � -S�� N��Q;W 7:� �Q:�J E":QV� �+ '��

)Y6�Y5 .( �1"O"� � ���@)Yg ( �:/�� E"* xZ*� -� �1�9�+��

�/�� �* ��� J '�@�"8� (*�� * * � - 7:� �:Z? ��/

�G� "8 �/�� E"* -Z*� E+ J '�@� �* ��; �/��� (*�� * �

* - �� -P�� � �Z? "f ��/���;�*.

-* -P�� �* E+ *�1* -� E+N���@ 'C:"� ���� :* ,��1� �

� (*�� * -�8 � * � y"� � ���P �+ � �@�"8 ��@ �@�"8 ��@

E+ �7� ��.�� d%�V�A@�zB �+���:� �:�� * ��:=1� -:*

N���@ 'C"� ���� * �� (* �� :* -:�8 � �E. ceratoides �

�+� 8 $�� �(� 7G�(� � 7& � �-1+C@ �7#/ -O+�!� .

)�� � !-��/

D�,F$ -1=- 3F� j+-1

� P T#�A@�zB �:1� -!Z1� �� �S� �1� n S �� '��:� (;

$ "Q� �:� �:;�* �+�:"9 hP F�:3 �� -:� �'u�o]Y � �S :;

�"9 hP v & �+'go5Y e�:1P � ���:%"� T(J �� � �G�Q;

7� ��+� 8 �S� $ "Q� '��� (; �S ; .

'��O�� �* F��0� e�3 � -Q" �-!Z1� <"%S � � ��@ 7:� .

��Q�� ^�C I����5Y|�%"� I:���� � :� -P�� � ��

'� -�"G��YY ���� -P�� 7� � 8)| .( � ����:O+ �}� ��

`"Q& �%"? >�?) � A"*Y�6 ���� :�� ( �:%"9� B T:��D� �

7� e�? ~��2O . E"�1:� �:� I:���� >�:? 7:9�*) i� $�:G

��%"::�W��%"::� $�::G (-::� �>�::? '�Q�?�::� ��::1J �::+ � �

7::� �::(P� . y::"� ����::O+ �@�::"8 A::;�B ,::G�f y::"�

Bromus tomentallus /Eurotia ceratoides7:::::� . �

-�8� ��@ �:� ����O+ �0� -:�8 -:* '�:� ��:@Astragallus

cyclophylos � Stipa barbata�Polygonum salicornoides

��::Q ���::; . ���::� ����::O+ 7��::O�]66 ��::�D@ �::��::;�*

-:::* -:::�u -:::0ZS Y�u n :::S -:::0ZS H:::+ � ���:::�D@

<:::a�u :::@ $� � :::J � 7:::� ��:::; <":::O!� ���:::�D@

-::* �::0ZS �� �� T::c9 �� -G�::� $�::� �*��::1� ��::/

����;)].(

*�\@� !��� *��2

E. ceratoides -:Q" � �:+�B �'�"P�1.:� ����? � 7� �@�"8

-��* -* '� U�.�� -� �56 �� Y]6 ���:� �:� :�� ��� ��:��

-S�� -?�; �* ,0�1� ��"O* � ��0�� ��@ H+��* ��@ �:� �:;�*.

����O+ [Z� $�Q� �� ~�2+ !� -�8 E+ ��:1� B 7:� ��:;. ��

-:��* � :J $�:& 7%& -* <+� n S 7QOS ��:@E. ceratoides

��; -���� �(� �"G�� � A;�B �<� � ��*��; � � ��; �2�?

7::� . -::* ���::� -::!Z1� �� ��::"8 �+�::@ A::V* U�::.��

L6 ���� �� �� �-:!Z1� �� ��:"8 �:�+�� �:;� U� :; ��:��

E+��� 9 I�����;�* '�"�� � :* :(� :?� �� �m* - F�:3

������ . N�? $�& �-�8 E+ ���� �� 7"Q@ Ca�� �D �

A:+�� ���� T:+��� '� ����?) �:� 7:�(2+�� � E+��� :9

�� ? I�� (7�)].(

Page 4: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! / �"#�$%&'(

�5�

D�,F$ �8�- )��

� * ���� * $�� 7OV ����:O+ -� -0ZS �� ) 7��:O� -:*

Y�u ���D@ ( $� � J 7#� ��* � S -� -:� �#Z� � "8 � S

T:#� '�:1& -:* ���:* �:�� * ���:� -:�8 '� ,:G�f A;�B

-::�Q�::; e�::V� ��� ::* . E::+ �� -::�A@�z::B-::��* ��::@

E. ceratoides�+� 8 ��=1� ����� -0��P -GC1� -* .

��� * E+ ��N���@ 'C"� E""0� � � :(* �� :* -:� -:* �

��; <"O!� -��� :YW N�� R.S�@ �P�� �) � �ZS E+��:� (

-�Q ��� �* J � �0* � T2S � �B � "8�W U�:.�� N��

– � -S�::� N��Q::; ��::"G�� X?�::; ��Q::�J E"::QV� �'��

-�Q ��� �* ��"8 N��Q; -+�B H� �� "8)-��*(5W ��� N��

-�Q ��� �* -?�; � F�3 � �P �-?�; � � "8)-� �.(

�� �* �B [Z� �:� ��:"8 ���: E�9 :8 = �� �:�� * �

-+�B -%/�9 '� ��@)Y ( �; -�9 8 =�� �* � �� H+ .<@ E":1J

� -��� @ � *N���@ :G��0� � ���.�� �* -�8�P ��3 -* -Y

-::�Q �::�� i�::� ::* $�^ -::�Q ���:: E"::"0� � ::"8

�+� 8) F��PY:(

]Y [2

22

dstN =

-G��0� E+ �� -�N -:�Q �:�� ��:0� �:+ $�^ -:�Q ���:

���� *s � ��:; � :"8 ���: 7:"Qs R�:+�� x E"��:"�

-0G�Z� ���� 7"Qs 6t 6 t ���� -:P�� �:* 7��"�� )Yn- (�d

-G��0� � -s�)� 7�� -* �+�:

]� [x.kd =

-G��0� E+ �� -sk := ���:� e�:%Z� `:%Z� ��2�:; �:/�� �

)� -�Q ��� E""0� � * � �;�*Y6 ��:; -�9 8 = �� �/��

7�)Y6� Y5.(

VWE )�� �=�� /)N+��$ � �@E(

:J T:c9 U� :; � T:2S N�� E+ �� �9��:c� N�� -:*W

H"��Q�O"�|6 -:0G�Z� ���:� [Z:� �� �:0* � :�� H+ R.S

�; !�O� . ���:� -:�8 A;�B 'C"� -* -P�� �* R�� �:�� *

�� �B � H+ @ A:;�B I+ :; �* ���B ���; ��c#� ��@

�+� 8 e�V� ��� �B '�1& -* -*��� �@�"8 . '�:+�B � �:0*

'C"� �B ��� @ � * J Tc9 -9�%& � (*�� * � ��:; �

��; 7;� * -9�%& 'C"� <"O!�) ��:; J �B -9�%& T}�.�

��� J � ( -9�%& T� ��!� *) ��:c#� �:B -:9�%& ��!�

��; ( �:/�� 7+�( �� � �+� 8 -2��#� � :(* �� :*� � -:�8

���� ��� * F�0� �* 'C:"� � :"8 � :(* �� :* � H:+ :@ � �

�B� ��� ��@ -2��#�;.

-1=- �- .�� � 3�E )��

T:2S N�� -*��� C" N�� E+ �� 7:OVgY �:* ��� �:B

e�:V� :J T:c9 U� :; � T2S -*��� �@�"8 A;�B I+ ;

�;. �B � � � H+ �� �:"G�� 'C:"� :J U� :; � T:2S �@

-2:��#� '� H�? '�� � �ZS -0G�Z� ���� -�8 -�"G�� -9�%&

�+� 8 . * TQ& E+ �B $�� � � � * J Tc9 '�+�B � �0 �@

�; $�� C" ���� �S�* -9�%& 'C"� i�� * � . @ � * R��

�/�� ��; -0G�Z� �B ���� (*�� * �:* -� �+� 8 -2��#� �

F�0� ��& � � "8 7�� -* 'C"� ����� � :(* �� :* -:�8 � �

�; E""0� -0G�Z� ����.

���; N��U$ )��

+ �� N�� E7OV �:� ���� ^�:* � 9 '�� E"QV� )+��� �+�*

�:/�� �:+ ��:; 7:;� * -:9�%& ��!� ���* � :(* �� :* � �

�1s ���� * . ��=1� -* E"QV� _�/ H:Q� -:* ���; $�� ��@

-:::9�%& E+��:::� � �:::ZS � E":::QV�)-:::�Q N�� ��� :::*

d&��� ( ��Y6 ��":� 8� -:G��0� �-:0G�Z� ���:� ��:"8 -:+�B

,��1�7�� -*��� . � * � J ���� $�Q� � �0*|g -:��* E.

ceratoides�� 'C"� ��; J -!Z1� � :(* �� :* ��� E":QV� �

-G��0� HQ� -* � �; 7�� -* E"QV� +��!� ���� � _�:/ �@

F�0� � RB 'C"� �(� � � "8 � :(* �� :* -2:��#� E"��:"� �

�+� 8.

Page 5: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

)�� *#+,���-.�- /�1�� �-0�� 1�2 *��2 �- �-!1�Eurotia ceratoides

�55

��.=%.k *���� ��-.�- �-!1� �1�� �-0�� !��C1� T�"U� / )�� �! ��

N����� * -�Q �����; -�9 8 -�Q ���$�^ -�Q ���

R.S�P�� ��@)�@�;(

J � �0* � T2S

�B

�B

Y66

Y66

|6

gY

�Q�J E"QV�-��*Y66|g

-S�� N��Q;-��*Y66�]

�"G�� X?�;-��*Y66g]

U�.��–'�� -��*Y66gY

��"8 N��Q;-��*Y66�Y

�P � ���-?�; ��66YY6

-?�; � F�3-?�; ��66�|

6]/6=α

>W$�- )��f ���

� :* '�� � U�:.�� -:Z*� E""0� -* ��" N�� E+ � P � *

-�8 @���;�* .E+ *�1* �:�* ]6 :* := ���:� ��:"8 � -:+�B -

� �9��c� ~���� ��/ '� U�:.�� � H:�? '�� � �; e�V

��� �+� 8 � "8 . �� R��L] �]6 � ��] :@ U�:.�� �:/��

� :* E+ *�:1* ��:+� 8 -2��#� 7QOS @ '�� � �; �ZS -+�B

U�:Q�� �� � '�� ��(J � U�.�� ��(J -+�B @�66 ��:& ���

U�.��W -+�B T� � * '�� ��; -0G�Z� ��@7�� -* -� ��� -:*

-%"�� U�:.�� ��":� 8� -:G��0� ��:& E:+W ���:Q � '��

U�.�� ""h�W �+� 8 �"G�� '�� . :J Tc9 '�+�B � �0*gY

-��*)-+�B ( �9��c� ��/ -*W �� � H:+ @ �� H"��Q�O"�

� ��; J -!Z1� ���: �:(� U�.�� � e�V� ��� J � :"8

�; .�* -Z*� � ���.�� 7�� -* � � ���� -:+�B U�.�� F�0 �� �:@

� ��; J 7QOS �S�* -9�%& '�� ,"� � -* ���� J � ����

�+� 8 -2��#� -9�%& T� '��. 7:;� * -9�%& 'C"� 7+�( ��

'C"� � ��;� (*�� *�; -2��#� �.

.�\�$ ZB )��

J Tc9 '�+�B �� N�� E+ ��g] -:0G�Z� ���:� -�8 � -+�B

* - �9��c� ��/W [Z� -+�B @ � * � e�V� H"��Q�O"�

-� � F�3 F�0� � A;�B ��� ��� ��� J ��@ �:; � :"8 .

@ � * �"G�� X?�; ���; -0G�Z� 7"Q� �� e } T/�� �

�+� 8 -2��#� -+�B . � ��:; 7;� * -9�%& �/�� ��!� R��

�� ��:!� E:+ e :} T:/�� � � �:; ��� E":QV� -:+�B @

��"G�� X?�; X?�; � (*�� * �:�� 7�� -* -+�B @ � * � .

X?�; <"O!� � 7+�( ��� (*�� * � :* �"G�� X?�; -* �

�/�� �-+�B @� (*�� * -:+�B � F�:0� � � -2:��#� �:@ � :"8

�/�� I���� ����� 7�� -* ��&� (* �� :* ���:� -:�8 � �

��� * ���� * ��;.

�=1� .Q-� )��

T2S �N�� E+ �� :J U� :; � YY6 �:�� '�:1& -:* -:� �

� �:+� 8 E":"0� �:(� H:�? '�� � e�V� �P �YY6 -:� �

� e�V� C" �(� -*��� -%"�� -* � E�O* XV:�� ��� ��@

�::; . H::�? '�� ::J T::c9 '�::+�B � R::BYY6 -::� �

7��& �+� 8 -2��#� ���; ��m8 . 7:;� * -9�%& '�� R��

-� � '�� T}�.� � ��; J � �0* � T2S �� �@ 7:�� -* �:��

-:� � '�� -:* ��:!� E:+ <"O!� � -� 'C:"� :J � T:2S �:@

� (*�� * 'C:"� E"��:"� � -� � @ � * � � :(* �� :* �YY6

�+� 8 -2��#� ���; e�V� -� � ���.

Page 6: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! / �"#�$%&'(

�5u

*B 1� ��� )��

-?�:; � '�� � F�:3 E":* -:Z*� E":"0� -* ��" N�� E+ ��

���;�* .7OV�66 * -� � - � e�:V� �9��c� ~���� ��/

�3�:!� � -?�:; � F�3 T� � * �(� F�3 � H�? '��L] �

]6 ��] ��:& ��� i�:� * � �+� 8 � "8 ��� F�3 �/��

7�� -* �:; E":"0� -?�:; � '�� � F�:3 -Z*� ���� . � :*

'C"� -2��#�� (*�� * �:�* :J T:c9 U� :; � T:2S ���|

��� � :J U� :; � T2S �(� � � � H+ �� � e�V� -� �

��� -?�; � F�3 J Tc9 '�+�B � �0* �+� � � �� � "8

-:9�%& T� '�� �-?�; � '�� � F�3 -Z*� � ���.�� �* � �;

) -?�; � '�� J U� ; � T2S �@ ( �S�* -9�%& T� '�� � ����

) -?�; � '�� :J Tc9 '�+�B � �0* �@ ( <":O!� � � -2:��#�

'C"� -9�%& T� '�� -* �� E+ T}�.�� (*�� *�+� 8 -2��#� �.

��2 )�� )��

7DO � F�3 �� J Tc9 '�+�B �� N�� E+ �� �:Z? ��:@

��; !�O�) F�3 �*Y] ��: � �� � �9�:� -:�Q ) F��:PY ((

-+�B ��0� � ��; J ��@ -:+�B :@ � :* � N��Q; ��� J

'C"� ��; J� (*�� * �; ��� E"QV� � . -+�B E"* -Z*� ��:@

'C"� �* ��� J � ��; J � :(* �� :* ��:& i�:� * � -:*

7�� 7D:O � � �+ @ � ���� �:+� 8 -2:��#� �:@ . R�:�

,��1� -Z*� �) -:+�B ��0� E"* -Z*� 'C:"� � ��:; :J ��:@

� (*�� *� ( E"QV� _�/ � * ��@ 7D:O � � H:+ @ �:@

'C"� F�0� 7+�( �� � �; ���.��� (*�� * ���� * ��;.

)��*E� )��

7D:O � F�:3 �� � J Tc9 '�+�B � RB N�� E+ �� ��:@

��; !�O�) �9�� -�Q ��� �* ( -S�� ��0� � ��:; :J ��@

� N��Q:; -+�B @ � * ��� J -S�:� ��:0� <":O!� � ��:@

J -S�� T� ��0� -* ��; �@) -S�� U�Q�� J � ��; J ��@

��� ( 'C"� � :(* �� :* -:+�B � �:; -2:��#� �:@ . � 7:+�( ��

F�0� ��& � "8 7�� -* 'C"� ���� � :(* �� :* I:���� � -:*

7����� .

*+0/� ��� *��F�

E+ ����� * -�Q �+���� E""0� ��=1� -* t :/ '��� �� "8

* ��; ��" ���� -�Q ��0� � ) ��; t / '��� �QP T/��

����:� � �+ #:/ �:@��� � * ( �:+� 8 -2:��#� . <:@ E":1J

-1+C@ -2��#� C"(�� -1+C@ i�� * ��@) � T+�:�� �+ ? -1+C@

�(� >�(�� ( ��� �� " -1+C@ �) 8��� � i�1;��� (�; $��.

)�� AFG ���1�/

�� -* N�� @ 7#/ ��� * �:; $�:� ��/ . F� 7:G��

-G��0� � ���.�� �7#/ ��� * ��@5 � u � ] ��:2& -� �:

�:

]5 [x

xdIa i 100×=

]u [xxxd ii −=

]][IaAc −= 100

-:G��0� E+ �� -� �:@ :x E"��:"� � :(* �� :* ��@�:; N�� �

ix E"��::"�� ::(*�� ::* �N�� ::@ �ixd E"��::"� t��::?

� (*�� * 72O N�� @ � ��@�:; N�� -:* Ia)Inaccuracy(

� ���S� �* 'C"�Ac)Accuracy( N�� :@ 7#:/ �:� �:;�*

)Y6�Y5.(

���� :* �:}�+� N�� � ���.�� 7#/ ��� * $�� 7G��

-�Q ���)-G��0� ��@Y � � ( -:G��0� E:+ �� -:� ���* �:* �:@

e�%Z� `%Z� ��2�; �/�� �T��& +�� '��* XV�� -* -P��

(k) � * `:%Z� ��2�:; �:/�� �:* �:;�� � -2:��#� N�� @

�:� e�:V� :� ["#:/ N�� '�:1& -:* :�Q� e�%Z� ��:;

)Y6�Y5 .(

� *+08$�!-! 3��F$/

�� E+��� * ��=1� -* '�:��� ���* ��" ���� ^��0� N� *

��� '��* F�� I"#� �� �@)SAS( 79 8 $�� . N� * R��

Page 7: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

)�� *#+,���-.�- /�1�� �-0�� 1�2 *��2 �- �-!1�Eurotia ceratoides

�5]

� (* �* ^��0� � "8 '�"� N�� � �; $�� �Z? �*�+ . � RB

��� 'C"� � "8� (*�� * �N���@ -:O+�!� 7(P �d%�V� �

E"��"� � 7#/N���@ N�� � �:; ���.�� ED� '���� �

R.S�@�+� 8 ��=1� �@�; N�� '�1& -* �P�� �.

E+ :� -1+C@ <� � E+ � ["#/ �E+ � �+ � E""0� ��=1� -*

N��) E+ � ,��1� N�� ( 7#:/ 72O X?�; N�� �� �

F� N�� �� -:� �:; ���.�:� �2� � -%O%� T"%#�� -1+C@ -*

$�� N�� �� � -::1+C@ -::* 7#::/ 72::O X?�::; i�::� *

X?�; -2��#� i�� * 72�� -21P �* ��@) -G��0�| ( -21P �* �

�::::::.1�) -::::::G��0�L (�� �C::::::9 $C:::::: I"::::::#�

)AHPThe Analytical Hierarchy Process(,::��1� E+ ::�

�+� 8 e�V� N��.

]| [

∑=

=n

iij

ijj

r

rG

1

]L[

∑=

=n

i ij

ijj

r

rG

1

1

1

-G��0� E+ �� -��@ :ijr N�� X?�:;i � :* $ N�� j � $

Gj X?�; @ -2�� ���;�*) Y���5�u .(

� ]+"�mF�

r+�� ���� 7�� -* � * ^��0� N� * � N���@ E":QV� �

U�.�� �-?�; � F�3 ��Q�JW _ :; -:* ��:"8 N��Q; � '��

F�D;Y �� ]7� .

r+�� -O+�!� ��:�� 7�� -* � -:1+C@ �7#:/ �E"��:"� �

� :* ��; t / '�����N �:@ N�� �:* d:%�V� � R:.S �:@

�P��)�@�;(F��P _ ; -*�7� .

F��P i�� *� 'C"� ��& E+ ��"* � (*�� * -* o�* � �

U�.�� N��W -?�:; � F�:3 N�� -* o�* � E+ �Q� � '��

7� . N�� -:* o�:* � ��:; t / '��� E+ ��"* R:.S �:@ �

�:0* � T:2S N�� '� � �0* � T2S N�� '� � �0* � �P�� �

7� -S�� N��Q; N�� -* o�* � '��� E+ �Q� � � J . N��

R.S�@ -1+C@ B �P�� � � T:2S N�� '� � �:0* � N�� E+ �

-:1+C@ <� � 7� J � �0* -S�:� N��Q:; N�� �N�� E+ :�

7::� . N�� ��R::.S�::@::* �::P�� � - '��::* TD::�� T::"G�

R.S � :* '�:�� -^�� A+�� �����P � X"V�� � ��m8

� 7& � * � 7� <� ' - ��+� N�� E+ $�� -1+C@ T"G� E"Q@

���;�* -�"� -� 7�� -* r+�� �* ���� ��� *��@ ��:@ )Y| (

-� � � '�"* N�� �� R:.S �:@ :* �:P�� � - ���:��P T:"G�

-��* '�@�"8 � * -^�� A+�� -1+C@ B � * '��� �� �:� �:;�*

r+�� �* -� 7�� -* �� ��:�� E:+ A@�z:B 7:!*�Z� ��� )Y6 �

Y5��5 .( � �:ZS N�� �:1�Q@ C" � J � �0* � T2S N�� ��

* E+��� - T"G� -� E+ ���:� -�8 � * -^�� A+�� �����P

��� * -1+C@ B � * '��� ���;�* N�� E+ �� -� ��� � �G�

R.S -* ��" ��m8�Q�;�* E:+�� ��:; t :/ -1+C@ � '���

N�� -* 72O N��R.S�@� �P�� )�@�; (�+ � <:� � :�

-1+C@ �7� . '�O%)�5 ( ���:9 �:"B � R�\"B �)�] ( '�:"*

�� � F�:� E"& �� � ���� �;�� � J � �0* � T2S N�� -�

<� '� �� �cV; ��Z? 7� � �Q(� T��& ���� A+�� 8

�;�2� * - T"G� -� E+ -:* 72O N�� E+ � P -1+C@ � '���

N��R.S�@ P�� � �Q� ����1;�* �:� E+ *�1* ��:12� �:��

'C"� �*�+��� (*�� *� "8 � S �.

* -S�� N��Q; N�� �� - T"G�-� E+ 'C"� � (* �� :* � �

-S�� ��0� N��Q;�� -2��#� ��� J � ��; J ��@ � ��:;

E+��� �ZS � �B -* ���"�7O" <:� � �+ � N�� E+ *�1*

-1+C@ 7� �)�] .( �����)�g ( -:Z*� H:+ -:� 7:9�+��

�/�� E"* <"!�O�� (*�� * -S�� ��0� �* � ��P� ��; J ��@

�/�� N�� E+ �� -� ��� � 7;� '�"* � ��� � :(* �� :* �

-S�:� ��:0� N��Q:; `+ 3 � �(1� ��:� J � ��:; J ��:@

�� -2��#� 7� <� '� � P -1+C@ �E+ *�1* ��; . � R�:\"B

���9 �"B)�] ( +�� �* � -S�� N��Q; N��N���@ -:O+�!�

r+�:� -:� 79�+�� � � � 7:�� -:* ��� N�� E:+ � ��:��

t��?10�:���� �* : +�N���@� N�� �G� 7�: <� � �+

Page 8: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! / �"#�$%&'(

�5|

� (* ���� *��� *)�/��(-?�; � F�3)-� � (���� -* ��

3: % .�1�� !��C1� N�� �@B *@�-� ��E-� 1+!,� � �-!1�3: 7 .*B 1� ��� � ��� N�� *@�-�

� -* -+�B �+ -��* U�.�� ��� �� J '�@�"8 �/�� ���

3: & .*$�� ��� � >W$�- N�� *@�-�)*+M(3: n .�1�� .G�! � �.��-1; �/�2 .G�! N�� *@�-��. !��C1� �-!1�

3: b . -1; �/�2 .G�! N�� *@�-��1�� .G�! � �. �. !��C1� �-!1�

Page 9: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

)�� *#+,���-.�- /�1�� �-0�� 1�2 *��2 �- �-!1�Eurotia ceratoides

�5L

��.=7 .�. ^1G ��� � *+0/ 6AFG 6N�S��� �- *�GQ ]+"� *#+,�)�� -1�T�"U� /

VWE )�� � �=�� /)./ (

d+���@ N��E"��"�

��� * � (*

��; t / '���

) -!"S�(

��; t / -1+C@

) F�+�(

e�%Z� `%Z� ��2�;

)�/��(

YR.S ��@�P��)�@�;(a5/]|Yg||YL66L]WWWW

� J � �0* � T2Sau/]]Y]u|Y]]�Y]5/g

5�Q�J E"QV�a6/|6Y]65�|u5|/g

u U�.��W'�� a�/|Y5Lu5]6L5]/u

]-S�� N��Q;b|/u5Y5|Y5|5Y�/Y|

|�P � ���bcu/u65]�5L]Y]]/Y6

L�"G�� X?�;dc|/55u��u5�66]/Yg

g;��"8 N��Qdu/56�L5�L�ggu/�5

�-?�; � F�3d5/�]||||LY�uY/�]

N�� F�Q�� [Z� �� �� �10� t��? �S�9 > ��� t� � ��� ��@]�1;�* �� �/�� .

-1+C@ 'C"� -O+�!� � * � 7� �� (*�� * -:�8 H+ �2O �

�� 7:� ���.�� T*�S �+� F�� -* �G�� � ����+�� H+)Y6 �

Y5��u .( E+ r+�� -���� *�@ r+�� �* 7�� -* E:+ �� ��:��

A@�zB��� 7!*�Z� .

H+�1*��� � >��)Y5( C8�:@ � 1%"� �)�Y( � E:� p:1"%s �

C%+��)Y� ( N��R.S�@ F��:�� '�:1& -:* � �P�� � E+ :��

t� 0� ["#/ � E+ � 'C"� E""0� � * N�� E+ �� (* �� :* �

�� � �9 0� .� � ���� N�� E+ 7#/ -� ��� l �"a���;�* �

E+ *�1* 7#/ �*�+�� ��12� '�1& -* N���@�; e�V� �.

r+�� ���� 7�� -* E"��"� -O+�!� � � (*�� * � 7:�� -*

� ����N���@ U�:.�� ��Q:�J E"QV� � J � �0* � T2S �W

N�� �* '��R.S�@ �P�� �)�@�; ( ):10� t��:? �:S�9� �

���;�*) �ED� '����6]/6<P( . E"��"� E"* ��� (* �� :* �

7�� -* +�� � ���� N���@ t��? �@�; N�� �* �:10���

��+� �; ) F��P�.(

7#/ -O+�!�N���@ 'C:"� ���� :* � � :(* �� :* �) -:*

e�%Z� `%Z� ��2�; �/�� -2��#� N�� ( N�� -:s �� '�:�

U�.��W �0* � T2S �'�� �:* ,:"� � -:* �Q�J E"QV� � J �

]/u �5/g �|/g e�:%Z� `:%Z� ��2�:; �/�� �) � �:; -2:��#�

-G��0� ��@Y � �( ["#/ � N�� E+ ����;�*. :�+� ��2& -*

r+�� 7�� -* � ���� N���@ ��:"G�� X?�:; ��P � ��� �

$�^ 7#:/ �S�9 ��"8 N��Q; � -S�� N��Q; �-?�; � F�3

���;�*) F��P�.(

���:� � ["#:/ N�� � J � �0* � T2S N�� � 7:� �

'C::"� E"::"0� � ::* �::;�2 �::Q(� T::��& ��::�� A::+�� ::8

� (* �� :* �:� � 7:� �2:��1� N�� � �*�:+�� ��:12� �:��

� (*�� * � "8 � S � . C%+�� � E� p1"%s)Y� ( �:� � '�:"* -:�

N�� $�� 7:G�� � J � �0* � T2S N�� R:.S �:@ �:P�� �

�*�+�� ��12� � N�� E+ � 7�� (*�� *��� � S �.

r+�� -O+�!� ��:�� 7:�� -* E:+ � A@�z:B �:0G�Z� �:*

��Os)Y� ( r+�:� '��:* -*�:�� ��1@� '�� �:� �:;�* . N��

U�.��W -Z*� '���� 7�� -* � �0* � ��� ���+� 7#/ '��

E+��:� � �ZS -* ���" �'�� � U�.�� E"* �:Q* �:;�. E+ *�:1*

E"+�::B '� � ::P -::1+C@ � '�::��7::� . ��::���@)YL (N��

U�.��W 'C"� ���� * � * � '�� � (*�� * -1��� ��"8 � � -:*

��� ̂ �:* 7#/ � N�� E+ -� 7;� '�"* � � * + ����:? * �

Page 10: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! / �"#�$%&'(

�5g

� 7& � � 7� -* 72O '� -1+C@N���@ ,��1� �+� � :�

���;�* .C�9 8)Yu ( N�� U�.��W i :8 �:1J � :* � '��

,��1� �0� � �� X"V�� N�� E+ � . ��:O�)Y�( � >�:� �

H+�1*��::�)Y5 ( R�::\"B �)�u ( U�::.�� N��W �::* � '��

N��R.S�@ -O+�!� -S�� N��Q; � �Q�J E"QV� ��P�� �

� (* E"��"� -� �1�;� '�"* � �� � ��� * 7:�� -:* � ��:��

U�.�� N��W� '�� �:10� t��? �S�9 �Q�J E"QV� �:* ��

N��R.S�@ �P�� �)�@�; (7�) F��P5.(

-:1+C@ <� � �+ � );�� ��Q�J E"QV� N�� � 7:� �

��� ���O* i�1;��� '�� E"QV� �+��� -* '� 7#/ . $�(�*

)Y6( ���9 H"B � R�\"B �)�] ( E":QV� N�� -� �1�;� '�"*

� 7::� ,::��1�� �::����� N�� �Q::�J� 7& ::� 7::%& -::*

� �'� � P 7G�(� -� E+ ���:+� �:&�3 �:Q� '�:�� ��

�� <@ 9 ����� T"%#� � -+C�� � * ��1� E+ *�1* E":"0� � :*

�/��� (*�� *-/ & �� �@-�87� ,��1� d%�V� ��@.

-S�� ��0� �(1� '�J -S�� N��Q; N�� �� ��:; J ��:@

J 'C"� � ��; N��Q; ��� J � �� �:Q -�9 8 = ��:;�

�� $� E+ *�1* j * I!9 ���� ��0* �� � �@ '��* ���? E:+

-� -?�; � * "kl� E:+ �� �:Z? ���+ ,2� � E+ � ��m�*

�� N�� ��:; . ����:�)�g ( �:/�� E":* -:� 7:;� '�:"*

� (*�� * -S�� ��0� �* � ��� ��P� <"!�O� -Z*� ��; J ��@

��"� �G� E"� (* �� :* � 7:�� -:* ��� N�� E:+ � ��:��

t��?�10��� � �:0* � T2S N�� �* :J) N�� '�:1& -:*

�@�::; (��::* . R�::\"B)�u ( +�::� �::* � -S�::� N��Q::; N��

N���@ r+�� -� 79�+�� � � � -O+�!� 7:�� -* E:+ � ��:��

+�� �* N��N���@ t��? ��� ��10��� 7� )F��P5.(

�:�� ~̂ � :+� 7:� $�^ 7#/ �S�9 �P � ��� N��

�:�� ~�:"�k �7:� �:1@� �:P � �:�� '�1& -* ��; e�V�

7� EDQ� ��; e�V� -%"�� -* :� E:+ -:� ��:� J $�

-�Q �� �Z? ���+ ,2� )� � "8��; . ^�D:; �+� �� ��

-��* A+�� E�9 � = �Q �� E":* '��� F�3 �� �@ -: ��� :*

7� . � * �2��1� N�� -1+C@ � 7& � = � N�� E+ �G�

-�8 -��* ��@ �� +� 7� � ���: E""0� -* ���" N�� E+

7O" �B . 'C"�� (*�� * -:9�%& 'C:"� <"O!� � ~�Q"!�O� �

��� -9�%& T� 'C"� -* �P � ��� � ��; 7;� * �P � -:*

7�����+� . +� � T" ��)�� ( � �P � ��� N��R.S �:@ �

� :::(* 'C:::"� ���� :::* � :::* � �:::P�� -:::�8 ��� :::*

Ceratoids lannata��::� -::* �::/�� -::� �::1�9�+�� � �::� *

� (* �� :* � 7:�� -:* t��:? ��� N�� �� E:+ � ��:��

�10��� N�� 7#:/ � 7:S� -� �1�9 8 -�"� E+ *�1* �7�

7O" ��Q�& T*�S ��P � ���.

���: -?�; � F�3 A@�� -?�; � F�3 N�� �� � :"8

�� � ��; J '�J "kl� �-�:;� -?�:; � F�:3 ���: �� �

� :(* 'C"� ���� * �� �Z? ���+ ,P�� N�� E:+ �� ��� :*

-?�; � +� �7� ��; j * � �& 9 ��@ $� � :J I��� �@

�� 7;� * J � ��; "kl� ��� -?�; � F�3 * � . H+�� 9

y"%"9 �)Y] ( � �:0* � T:2S N�� �:* � -?�:; � F�3 N��

J) �@�; '�1& -* ( -:O+�!� 7& :� � -:1+C@ �7#/ = �

-?�:; � F�3 N�� -1+C@ � 7& � -� �1�9 8 -�"� � �� s

,��1� J � �0* � T2S N�� -* 72O N�� �:G� �7:� :�

$�^ 7#/ �S�9 -?�; � F�3�� �:;�* . <:@ E":1J � 7"Q:�

R::�)�| ( 'C::"� E"::"0� � ::* � -?�::; � F�::3 N��

� (*�� * -�8 � -��* ��@ �-* ��:� E:+ -:� �:1�9�+�� � �:� *

$�^ 7#/ �S�9 N��7� T"G� -* �G� -� E+ �:0* E�9�:+ �

� �:ZS -:* ���" �+� -?�; � '�� � F�3 E"* ,��1� -Z*�

7O" -?�; � E+��� . '�D� �� �E+ *�1* 7+���:#� -:� �+�:@

7� -1+C@ <�� �+ � N�� ��� ��P� E+��� � �ZS.

E+ 7#/ +� 7� $�^ 7#/ �S�9 �"G�� X?�; N��

-� � F�3 ["#/ ���� * -* N�� -:9�%& �/�� � ��; J ��@

�::�� � � ��� ���::O* ��::; 7::;� * '�� N�� E::+ �� -::�

�Q -2��#� ��; 7;� * -9�%& �0S� E+ *�1* ��; N�� E:+

7� $�^ 7#/ �S�9 . '� *)YY ( � �"G�� X?�; N��� *

�/�� E""0�� (**:�� "8 �: �? '�@�: * �2: � � U� .���@: ��

)YL (�:�":�:":(* E:� ; N�� ���:?�:"G�� X: N�� �* � �

Page 11: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

)�� *#+,���-.�- /�1�� �-0�� 1�2 *��2 �- �-!1�Eurotia ceratoides

�5�

��.=& .�1�� .G�! *#+,� >W$�- )�� �-!1�f���

)�� ��� �-0�� N���$ 1S+! / �-!1� �1

N�� ��� * � (* �/��

E+��� � �ZSuY

-S�� N��Q;L6

U�.��W'�� u�

��11� ��@��� Y5�

�Q�J E"QV� ��11� ��@��� �u5

��11� ��@��� 5u�

R.S�@ �P�� �)�@�; ( � � � -O+�!�� � '�"* N�� E:+ -:�

�+ �� $�^ 7#/ �S�9 �G� 7�.

* ��"8 N��Q; N�� �� - T"G� -� E+ '�:@�"8 �:/�� �:(1�

�� ��� J � ��; J �� -�9 8 = := �� J 'C"� � ��;

�Q -�9 8 �Q �E+ *�1* ���; :�� :;�� �� � :* ��:Q�& T:*�S

'C"� E""0�� (*�� * �� -� ��� � �G� �;�* � ��:" N�� E+

E+��:� � �ZS � �B -* 7:O" -:1+C@ <:� � �+ :� N�� �

'�� '�� � * I!9 � 7�� (*�� * 7:� ,:��1� �2:O � .

'�:� �"B � �:%"9 p1+ ��)�L ( � :* � ��:"8 N��Q:; N��

'C"� E""0�� (**�� -:!Z1� �� � �:�0* � �:/���/ -:� �

i 8 * ���* ��; J �@ - � :(* E"QV� � �� * ��� ��� :* -:*

-%"�� I!9 N�� E+ 5] 'C:"� � :�Q� �:%"? -:� ��* �/��

� (*�� * N�� �R.S�@ �P�� �)�@�; ( ��:* . � E:� p:1"%�

C%+�::�)Y� (�::� � '�::"* 'C::"� ���� ::* � ::* N�� E::+ -::�

� (*� *� ���Q�& T*�S N�� ��Q �:;�* N�� �:G� � �+ :�

-1+C@ <�7� � .

<@ -O+�!� � r+�� '��� ���� 7�� -* �E"��:"� -:O+�!� �

�-::1+C@ � '�::�� �7#::/N���::@'C::"� ���� ::* d::%�V� �

� (*�� * �� -1+C@ -* 7#/ X?�; HQ� -* � ��:P -:* '��

-Q@ r+�� -O+�!�N���@ r+�� N���@�+ s �� �:(� 7#:/ -

E"��"� -O+�!� :* � ��:* ��; ��� X"V�� F�2S T*�S �@ - ��:s

� * .E+ *�1* E+ �� -Q@ �PN���@ -:�9 8 � :S -:O+�!� ����

7� . E:+ ��P� �* -S�� N��Q; N�� X?�:; E+ �:�"* -:s

� ):G� ��:* ��� b�:c�? ��:? -* � -1+C@ -* 7#/ 72O

$�^ 7#/ �S�9 -s ���7� �*E+ *�1 U�.�� N�� W -:* '��

�:� �Q� -1+C@ � ��+� 7& � � 7#/ 7%& '�:1& -:* �:��

,��1� ���� -�8 � * N�� E+ ���� *��; e�V� .

N���@ �+^�* 7#/ �Q�J E"QV� � J � �0* � T2S �

U�.�� N�� -* 72O �G� ��1�;�W :"8 7:S� '�� ) 7& :�

�Q� ( �1�:O@ -1+C@ B � .N�� :@� N��Q:; �-S�:� N��Q:; �

7#:/ �S�9 -?�; � F�3 � �"G�� X?�; ��P � ��� ���"8

-:1+C@ <:� � �+ :� �G� ���* $�^ �1�:O@ . TD:; ��| r+�:�

� * -1+C@ -* 7#/ X?�;N�� �:@ ��:; ����� d:%�V� �

7�) �ED� '����6]/6<P(.

<@E"1J -:1+C@� '��� �7#/ �E"��"� -O+�!� N�� �:@ �

�� * d%�V� 'C"� ��� (*�� * T:"%#� HQ� -* � -%:O%� ��:@

�2� �(AHP) ,:��1� -S�:� N��Q; N�� -� �� '�� E+ :�

N��7� -:* 7#:/ X?�:; 72:O �� -:s )%+^� -* )G�

� ���* $�^ 7#/ �S�9 N�� E+ �; '�"* -1+C@E+ *�1* N��

U�.��W :�Q� -:1+C@ � ��:+� 7& :� � 7#:/ 7%& -* '��

,::��1� E+ ::� -::0G�Z� ���::� -::�8 � ::* N��7::��

N���:::@ �Q:::�J E":::QV� � :::J � �:::0* � T:::2S �

U�::.�� N�� -::* 72::O �::G� ���::;� �+^�::* 7#::/W '��

-:1+C@ B � * '��� �1�:O@ . TD:; ��L -%:O%� T:"%#� r+�:�

� ::* �::2� �N���::@7::� ��::; ����� d::%�V� �)'�::���

�ED�6]/6<P(.

Page 12: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

����� ��� � ����� ��� � ���� / ����� / ��� ��! / �"#�$%&'(

�u6

3: o .ZB � *+0/ *� AFG A�#� p/ * A�!C)�� �- �.� T�"U� p/))��^�1Q p-�-! p/

P�� ^_"B- .E� q1"�� ��"Q- ?@� �! �-!b %P�. � .(

3: s .)�� �- �.�C A�! *� P�$-1� *�#�� 3��F$ ]+"� T�"U� p/))��^�1Q p-�-! p/

P�� ^_"B- .E� q1"�� ��"Q- ?@� �! �-!b %P�. �.(

*8�"� 1�2

�+ � -1+C@ <� � E+ � -:�8 � :* N�� E+ :� ���:� �:�� * �

7:� -S�� N��Q; N�� .N�� �:@ � :* $�^ 7#:/ ���

U�:.�� N�� T��; -0G�Z� ���� -�8W �Q:�J E":QV� �'��

)-�Q d&��� � "8( J � �0* � T2S � E+��� � �ZS � 7:�

N�� -� ��� � �R.S�@ �P�� �) E+��:� � �:ZS ( � T:2S �

-:1+C@ B � * '��� J � �0* �1�:O@� +�:� E":* �� E+ *�:1*

N���@ t��? �S�9 � �:10��� N�� �:* R:.S �:@ �:P�� �

)�@�; ( �� � 79 8 $�� '��� � 7& � �-1+C@ -O+�!� 7:+�(

<@ -O+�!� � r+�:� '�:�� :* ��:�� 7:�� - E"��:"� -:O+�!� �

'��� � -1+C@ �7#/N�� �:@ U�:.�� N�� �d:%�V� �W '��

,��1� '�1& -* ���� -�8 � * N�� E+ � �:�� * � e�:V�

�+� 8 �9 0�.

-1+C@ -* 7#/

Page 13: *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛- / ) *#+ ,...%&’ ( "# $ ˘ !˚ ˜ ˘ ˙˝˛ˇ ˆ ˘ *˛ 2 - -!1˚1˝ -0 12 ˚ -.˛-/) *#+ , 9˛- 1+-.8 7 15 .˝ 6 % 1 - 34 ˚.:; + -A ˝=+1ˆ * +0/˙

)�� *#+,���-.�- /�1�� �-0�� 1�2 *��2 �- �-!1�Eurotia ceratoides

�uY

����!W"�- !���

�.$ ���B h/.���� .<"Qc��8���"0� �1J ��.' (� ����� ���� .

�.U ���� .U �.��+��Q0� .����.AHP�D"1D��@� 8 � "8 <"Qc� � * E+� .7+ +�� A� ��:��W��.

�.U �`"9��.����.<"Qc�' +�� � * � "8.��01/ 7+ +�� '����� ���� ' (� �.

�. ��*��@..����. HQ� -* � "8 <"Qc�AHP. �+�1/ ���1(� )�: (��W�� .

�.'�����'�(./ '��� �8���� ��(P .����.��1� �m* "�D� � �!"!#� ����O+ �� �@�"8 A;�B ""h� 7"0}� N�C8 .

�.$ ��Q+ � .���� .'�(./ '��� ��@ � e� N�C8.-P��* � -�� * '����� '�(./ �.

�.�'�P �E+��1G�t .���� .�� � �� J 7+ +��)U xQP �.� �DJ�� '��DQ@(.�(�� � .

g. U ��G� . $ �. � "c* .���� . ��� 7(P ,��1� N�� e�V� � (* 'C"� � "8 �� -1��� �� ��� *. � �����:�s '�:19 � $�:%&

)0"23 �*�1��)� : (���W���.

9. Arzani, H. and G. King. 1994. A double sampling method for estimating forage production from cover measurement.pp. 201 - 202. In: proceeding of 8th Biennial Australian Rangeland conference.

10. Bonham, C. D. 1989. Measurements for Terrestrial Vegetation. John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York.11. Brown, D. 1954. Methods of surveying and measuring vegetation. Common Wealth Bureau of pastures and Field

Crops. Bulletin 42, Common weath Agric. Bur., Farnham Royal, Bucks, England. 223 pp.12. Cassady, J. T. 1941.A method of determining range forage utilization by sheep. J. Forest 39 (8): 667 - 671. 13. Cook, C. W. and W.Stubbendieek. 1986. Range Research: Basic Problems and Techniques. Society for Range

manage. Pub., Colorado. 14. Crafts, E. C. 1938. Height - volume distribution in range grasses. J. Forest 36 (12): 1182 - 1185. 15. Frederick, D. P. and J. U. Philip. 1981. Diameter - Length-Weight Relations for Black bush [Coleogyne ramosissima]

Branches. J. Range Manag. 34 (3): 215 - 217. 16.Heady, H. F. 1975. Range Manage. McGraw Hill Pub., New York. 17.Hormay, A. L. 1943. A method of estimating grazing use of bitterbrush. Research Note 35. USDA Forest

Service.California Forest and Range Experiment Station. 18.Hurd, R. M. and N. A. Kissinger, Jr. 1953. Estimating utilization of Idaho Fescue (Festuca idahocnsis) on cattle

range by percent of plants grazed. Paper No. 12: 1 - 5. Rocky Mount. Forest and Range Exp. Stat.19.Klingman, D. S. and R. Miles. 1943. The cage method for determining consumption and yield of pasture herbage. J.

Am. Soc. Agron. 35 (9): 739 - 746. 20. Lommason, T. and J. Crandler. 1938. Grass volume tables for determining range utilization. Sci. 87(22) 44 - 63.21.Milner, C. and R. E. Hughes. 1968. methods of the measurements of primary production of grassland. Black Well.

Sci. Pub., Oxford, England.22.Neil. W. and R. Diego. 1986. Reference unit based estimates of winterfat browse wights. J. Range Manag. 39(2):

187-189.23.Nelson, E. W. 1930. Methods of studying shrubby plants in relation to grazing. Ecol. 11: 764 - 769. 24. Pichance, J. F. 1936. Comments on the stem - count method of determining the percentage utilization of ranges.

Ecol. 17(2): 329 - 331. 25. Pechanec, J. F. and G. D. Pickford. 1937. A comparison of some methods used in determining percentage utilization

of range grasses. J. Agric. Res. 54: 753 - 765. 26. Smith, A. D. and P. J. Urness. 1962. Analysis of the twigslength method of determining utilization of browse. Utah

Stat Department of fish and Game Pub., U.S.A.27. Springfield, H. W. and G. Peterson. 1964. Use of the Grazed plant method for estimating utilization of some range grasses

in New Mexico. U.S Forest service, Rocky Mountain Forest and Range Exp. Stat. Res. Note R. M. 22. 6P. 28. Stoddart, L. A. 1935. Range capacity determination. Ecol. 16(3): 531 -533.