أدب الاختلافات الفقهية وأثره في العمل الإسلامي...

26

Upload: anistsrb

Post on 17-Dec-2015

233 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

أدب الاختلافات الفقهية وأثره في العمل الإسلامي المعاصرتأليف: د. طلعت محمد عفيفي

TRANSCRIPT

  • !"

    #

    $%&'()*+ ,- .*/0

    12/23 4 56$7/2$8/ 9.

    :+;?

    C"D/5:+E?

    F5G8G* , G*3 H ,(

    .I1& 9.:+J=>?

    !;CA%$K%86!L'/$%0M5*H

    :+E@ABE=E>?

    "

    #NOPJQ! R%SJE

    $ %

    '() *

  • !

    "#$%&'

    !()

    *

    #+,$ -.

    )/0 1,2/

    0

    345 &%0678(9%5

    :);()2!?@+A

    B>3=+>(/0C,D E2

    8=+>(/!$>?H%&

    *

    0!IJ&KLM

    N

    O(P,(9.QI2@

    +/R-.S4,-.0KT0

    U/V=+>?(U%UW

    Q ,-IVXE),.0!3%-Y6

    CV3K-ZKT0,-.=+>?

    [\/V$%&

    \9IM#S),.VUCV(9/,

    !I ]SW/;P!^L4

    !G_9J']!$

    `

    a

    b

    R

    c

    !0K(5/V!(g

    e>h7L4

  • 7, VmL VJ'"&,!

    7Lj%0,!k7(g@"%?

    0n VO! Ve4;

    moIV3pIMe>hV&^%l

    ,0 V>U V

    !"#$%&'(

    q!-e>324 /!f%#@

    R=+>(5E%r

    C;0)g5!06A

    L/C/&

    `

    C

    s

    VXR(K te%

    u3)f;@K^79

    !+e>h4 324 /!-e>324 /,

    -!-e>324 /!-e>324 /.

  • (9!QRJ'[7L07-@

    |RIMB>h3V&)i@

    aW7Vi!U^8!"IV

    we%!U @e!-&K0R

    X,m&@"%?=Q>80n V

    OIM\(X/O

    @S,(4F9U,D,@SW

    MIW0/K3O(+,#

    !Z(9n%!%h@

    &V(e>h

    4 (/@S%j%

    UI,C

    "

    #$%&'

    U-27+,Qe>h

    4 hK%m5(0()\V

    (0^5|K5E%&~(}8

    ,$

  • @,87"-&!3n XM

    e>3 V@3 V7"-&X/4/

    60(K |I%

    *

    &,8=(?09U//]q/!"(9

    7Li,K7(,

    *

    (

    i

    &(4+,8

    @$5

  • (JX%2\KK5D

    *

    >eS!X45

    0 M(9JX%!+e>h0

    4 h

    04 ?J'+/]

    6A!B)CD

    i!IMe>h!f%Z4\%

    =+>(5yUnK(9!"\?

    Q -2n;(9!E)0 !

    &M,SZQ IV@U6CLR

    \V/ +,l7-7Q

    %Q/~+KAH/%J'

    &,8X,&,+z%j]

    qe>hw

  • &,8=(?I,@X0]

    =Sh@0/+We>h

    ]

    qXCz&4,@!ER%/

    1Xe>3 V@!7(%&9/%#

    e>h%h

    "87E)0]5B7F:G1

    HI?F8=BH487JK3deM

    0n V0I%KV&SR

    @0K5

    %&HV-e,8;S>.Ud8

    OIM\>?-.+P8

    @HG0K5%&!-ZS>."

    -eR V&\9J'@0K5

    %&3RK5(9X>4%&

    Q -#

    `

    J'(9+,8

    %

    *

    Q,Q -@

    4%k+IME)0

    +,8

    3\&)0/K V

    B>h@(gRIM#CLR-!&K8

    J'(9!e,U V

    !e%/ 5@C\%Z9

    !8]q(%!E)%+,8

    XKC3%3KSLV(K4^%

    (KV(KS%3V&WSLV

    4^%4^%SLV

    S%VVS%r

    !(B>hK 5K3 ,(X@

    7E,8LMez0

    !E)0Q ,7(324 /E

    E!-e>324 /!-e>324 /E

    %Q6MX,]0U&!

    +V(^

    &JX%#=(?@E)/)]X

    ai0(%Q6K5(97"G(%Q0K5

    %&()E%U&IV!e%Q(CV04]q %r

    08qS%rQ]X -C/%

    0-.0aGU!IV7(%&9j

  • %+

    !Q>

    *

    +dL>

    *

    ]5

    !Q!IRV{

    *

    "&g

    *

    (4@

    0O!(,IV3 R&C VJ'

    8]3;]e>h(9Q

    !"I]()%?!,8J'@we%

    8]3e>h%?

    ;]XR(!?

    0P@X0

    !C/(KS,E

    *

    0/

    K

    *

    V&)R

    e>h3/9(X(9J'

    &)Rd&R&/+

    *

    3MIW

    d8!&!(K&)B%

    !/Te43/H/%#V!R

    &n/x/j/xB>h@KS,

    8]3 R@IM"PU3%'

    0e>3/9

    ;]8

    U@J?4%]

    /K]8QRfKo#]

    m8%]3M?

    e>h3/Qh04 h!IR7I,lm-3/&5

    %hIM#n,0vU\Vw-

    +L

    !&PKF9&C,

    ,83/,!"CK

    L3

    *

    "!MN9O)CDh

    4 Q -

    i?\%!59%Q,k

    xJ!&9%324 /!-e>324 /E,

    E-!-e>324 /!-e>324 /E.

    %Q6MX,]Q]

    iDf/?i-%

  • i9CLR5Ug/%

    aW4K

    0IM=&P,-4S/R

    3K,8]

    V&GV!"(97L!(JIW/

    (97,8"50+,8

    !

    (9V&deM0d, V3 ,

    N

    mfV&C)x

    ,0(9

    1Q @[%

    xS,3/I,(K59(9

    7-%/!((I,^53V

    &)3/0/K Ve>h3/

    ^>

    *

    (9IMKV&G?!"

    (97LH/%#0,Q,Uk!&

    0RQ,@7(%3C)39!-

    !&deM0%!& V3J'(9!Z

    K4CH/%J'3>j/%I,(!$%

    /@K^7

    @IUS(9"/.Q

    (9X7LY &9I]=(?

    ('=(?!"09"KR(&}X

    IM#/

    3JX%@U%Q=(?('!

    !0Q4%KS,+#@!&)R

    KT7eMy@(,Dd#">

    *

    !

    &

    c

    c

    `

    ,(+,#(9Q -27,8

    X-=(?('IM%

    I,%3OL>

    *

    ]q&!(/%}(KU4R

    3pKT+;/ V!&R+,

    !"-&&2!eMXR,?y

    +x/ V,0-,0(9

    e>h!E)+,8

    H/%IV

    c

    -

    IV#$&

    3kKT(IV/(eXR0

    74C Vr

    Q

    *

    +d9(Cd@^>l

    38]qJ3&)Kr8

    CLR]!35!"0d&)K

    &K5]&S~q3dQ0=(?L>

    *

    ]

    V-(9&4/r

    3,XG?KT0Q -(I,

    S,-/!"=((\9

    Q 3OG?KT0a/%(

    !G( V

    0&}X(JX%#@

    K^7I,?G?we%&9y

    &%#0K4C!y&K#(9

    !,8=(?(&%Q~&E,!&

    !H/%#

    0!-e>324 /!-e>324 //

    E!-e>324 /!-e>324 /

    Q(60/V3n]Q]

    E44,Z45C45]

    !"09"%5iDfg+KI

    i\W=+>(5i0/%20)/x()E%

    &975

  • &4%k9IM#K^G?7L

    0?K/6(4/ V59

    U ?we%&900k!B%9Q-.

    S,,E53/0/K V36

    >?9ezH/%#@7(,5I5

    ()R>Q -I,(!$%/@K^

    g/0K,U%=\43/

    I,()R>Q -

    &,8=(?K,]q\3/7!"MI

    XR(P (S/WIMI,K

    Xg/%(9!!Xg%IVMIW

    we%]S/W"^H/%(

    K=fV(%3,kK\90

    Q KS/)B%(9B>h3 ,

    "C9(),(K30%3x3p

    hJV&G?(Ke>80CK!

    ,k@e>hme%r

    &,8=(?!0,"(aG5]

    qY (IVX V(M

    0n V(S/,(K

    0n V

    &X,S/@!"7Q%&9

    3KE V(0/ V!&

    !&SW0n V(60O+/

    S/W&XR"(K V&9

    !(S/WX,Q (C3%@

    3e4@Q -3) !

    &S5XR"(K 5

    H;|K!&\z\#

    %j%jE"7V

    &\z+8(,QW|K!(

    +8K

    3>&/

    !"r

    V&\9IM\>?%&

    3)CW0R

    $47L0S%32+,X/2

    /-;G( V\(R0 M

    \>?(g8J'(JX%#.7L0n Vez0O-

    \3JX%!=(?!0"K/4

    !E)035H/%IVX,&S,

    ez!L&K(9\/H/%IV

    ! VX,&%!C+%

    Q %

    *

    E%$/((

    *

    i"PVi

    3S=(?!0,&,+ze4V&

    X=(?('!3#0dj,324 /!-e>324 /

    +!-e>324 /!-e>324 /,

    E)/~(CV0%K,Q]

    i^S%&i0U&

    C^TC/V]i+C

    g3=+>(/i-+K?

  • ,j,
  • 0c

    c

    xC5!Cr

    me%n,0v5!$%/ i

    Q

    *

    3/+xi"%4 #%"nQ -/@7X

    L

    (9fV

    V&

    c

    )

    `

    R

    IM

    E!-e>324 /!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /!-e>324 /

    E4S4,.]Q]09,

    iD0+K?i-%30/%2

    !e>l

  • e>h0/K V0UA,

    U-8!+m&2W"%?

    j%!LK@IMY8!(g

    L&^,8)Q

    ,!U/;/

    Q/

    *

    +/

    J!-!%h

    X3(I%IM#w-U,+K@&%-

    7(g/ \KK5iD

    *

    >eSi

    !S%f>f(I%3v M#w-

    (6(&}XI(9!(g(9"/.7L

    70ij,

    / Vim(>

    *

    !

    &\, 7f%^/W@4,T&9

    M#MIW3/,SWM

    &3 V(KE324 /!-e>324 /,

    -!-e>324 /!-e>324 /.

    G?Uk(MIW7L"C

    *

    4,j

    &K/]()(iDfg

    +KIi-7SiI%.

    "/

  • !&n

    *

    K]qXR(@X5"fK5

    g3 ,!"09"KRr

    i"%?-83/0/K V]

    "%?MUSz07L

    -/Rme%(X,&\K,@,0 V

    (9"WQ>80n VO

    (9!(gIM"%?(&5]

    !iR9=(?35!

    8]qXK;!E4~,0&

    ('E4)

    *

    3/

    *

    I/>

    &C6 r

    i(97(gXM'(JX%!

    =(?35ES~%&

    *

    (9

    (%.=(?!05"K/43V&K;

    Ud-0

    *

    IM&K! V(X,

    &)%(,7"/

  • 0R,j~(9+/%.7L

    UdX/IVLVUA,f/x

    0\CKR-KT

    -L

    *

    /

    &,8=(?35]qV!+6

    !"

    *

    CV!C(

    V&)\5e>3*@!

    3%

    UUk!(%+,8

    C/V

    \3p

    UV&PR7"

    0#U&G?,8QR

    80\

    !+K+,8

    (+,IU6

    3%

    /K(90K,8

    B%9+,8

    r

    (9fV

    %7L0/K-+,8

    0)/

    &S,@Q-+,#j%

    (9j% R,(9!,n>

    &,8>(j509!05G

    K45]q(9USW,"(H/%K5

    X('!05"K/435

    !"!Z!,8IMI,S,

    M&Ka5U-,87L

    3 ,QIR

    j8

    !&PW

    KTU-H/%#(9I}-

    H/%#3 MI,M39USW,"

    (97L-3 ,yKG(9USW

    ,"(9S)0-X%3n5

    /5MUSW5-

    B4f3 MD%&x!IR7I,(3/r

    \9G"

    !HVj,IM

    7(%UdX/7L4

  • i/VP/Rw

    *

    ]&%(\W!"K45

    @!SW&)R

    !E)0!"/

    *

    U\M

    +,8

    KE%.MIW!-

    -!-e>324 /!-e>324 /.

    +0!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /+/

    &IV!570S>

  • =(?,X5@X0]4,L

    Y,@7"-&,j,

    IM

    &]q&\,@!(5QR&8]

    ()09-&!j%!(5(9

    0/&\,@!(5QR&8]

    !0,"K/4I,+%!(5r

    &,8=(?,X5@U/

    IM&]qI,(,j,k@+K-#

    j](d(,09!"C5

    !"09

    ,&,j6

    !"Ir

    I\MHV,/&M0/K

    K59&\M/"R

    SW!E)0!&S,mJ V

    9x&,!/K VK&,

    (97"-&(!ERUd&/

    *

    MI VU/

    *

    @!SW&)R

    !E)0Uk ,Z@4,Z

    MX%!!"S7"Kh+R]

    IR&P,K45!&G(%!.$3/

    3dQL>

    *

    ]q&P,7 U'

    @{ r

    Qh,0 V@jh

    $,X V!(?!L V3S

    +La@!&& V

    &,8/=(?E~09()

    % /%04>5@0/IM#

    /]q(9Q!+UCv4%

    0O0>-a%%0>-

    %lXg%.SW4%l4

    0/K V@MIWH/%Ir

    +E!-e>324 /!-e>324 /+

    +!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /+

    %Q6MX,]]iD!

    +K?i(^CK&

    &%Z3/Q,,8%

  • _9IMSW!&n

    *

    Udf/%

    +5,.=+>?"/

    zS,"L>

    *

    --e,80O

    7QW@=+>?"QXR

    DL4U%Z!-.

    US~

    (MI V

    /\VIM#S]Q-

    /0rS,(5i"

    Ui(S]q!X-5

    +}8

    (9(C50>-/0(90.D,X/,

    !X@%l7S("E]

    ("/-&9=+>?fV((K

    MIWIR&G?(9U%h0&9

    =+>?!&MIW!"MIW

    70!]&\,(\/

    !"K4/

    !

    $3/

    !"K/

    !H/%I!&G?

    76@IMe>h/V

    Gke/V"/K!-.!3%-(9

    (K,73\(9Q8/0!

    &e,@-&9=+>?&%3,

    0%h={3%j,J'Q/

    C\LK@D,X/,38Q6

    (9!IR K]&Ka5!&(MIW

    =(?!05"K/47+%7(8

    Q6(9!IR/C/Q.&G?!

    &\,$3/

    3+6/0/,

    X>( VUP,Q

    [/%3/

    SE2(CdMIW+

    @

    D%&x+>( Vr

    (9fV

    07L324 /!-e>324 /+,

    +-!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /+.

    %Q6MX,]]iD

    f/+KIi\=+>(/ii

    7-0)/x+/V >5

    %Q6MX,]]0S%h

    &C/%E~09()% /%04>5

  • MIWH/%((3~0"2

    /.j%KS4~

    &MIW((!Q

    *

    (9

    %Q/~$%X0

    *

    (9XW

    &"

    c

    %

    hXR"&ez!&

    3/M!-2U8KTxH/%

    3/,8]qV0%&JU6

    @,-/KT@"\3p1

    U6(9"/I,V"XV0

    "XVynI(9Q !e%Z

    3 ,@/(9+,8

    9

    3/(K(0

    V0d0!H90d

    0(9Q X,(KS

    *

    )\V

    (^

    *

    J&g;J'7"

    /1I,f0;%&KG

    ,0!-e>324 /

    S?]Q]i0

    U&!+V(^

    !-e>324 /,/

    ,E!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /,

  • +,8

    f;J'K5

    "#-Bx(9Q -/R

    S%I!Q/6(&,!

    &4"xr

    (9IK!&KXg/%

    *

    (9KT,?

  • E%UC,WX3^2Y6

    (9$$/,Q8C(5

    eQ,!-In(5U hQ/

    *

    -.

    S4,-.0KT$%k

    XXIKe>h07L4 ?,#3p

    !HWIM#2}+C2Uz

    3/0/K (CLR(9IMK,k(6

    U4 V@7E,8(

    "&n~80g8!+,ln/

    (9n&U4;2=+>(/

    0%( !E e4;@X/4/

    ^/x7(gR !I5n/,.

    UU%0/KT=+>?

    3$'3/!,.

    UU%0/KT=+>?/C;

    >

    *

    "G0/

    UK-0Q-

    Q!&S@/?03%&x

    -me%0RI5n/5&P6

    \R/ U+V%M

    &P60/K Q/

    *

    e>hD%L

    @4\/%(KIP @R

    (6U4l0X32

    }+C2=+>(/IM#n/

    &B>h0/K VL

    *

    @X/4/K4/M

    \,h0n V!8&K^,

    &,D/"/U V[/ 3

    +/Rg8S%U}f%0O2

    X4

  • \-"&%Zme%!IM(9$d!

    &%,.9e^ 7E5&P

    X%XUR"C0

    *

    \+WS~

    !Xg%(9!$5(/@

    (R(67Q G.\,(/L3/%Z

    O(\/e%lIM#7Q G.()

    +L/ !^/vK/V

    C/^%./ &%Zme%!J'&,

    ,.&xT

    I\M@(Ve>32L

    02=+>(/4@Y6

    %ZU4l0/K V7E,8

    e>hK _!7+,

    IM0+gKUC,WX3!0KhX+ Ve>h4 5

    {

    *

    0)/U%5(\2KT

    U42(\/U [email protected]%

    "80)/{\9!&K^x\R

    B(=+>?0PQ -@Y8M

    &%ZXR(K V4C3/

    iJXK!$%!D%h(9

    !-e>h07L4 324 /!-e>324 /-

    -!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /-

    %]g,0;a/%2@(C/%.R

    =+>(5E%]]-E>

    Si(^,DV(P,(9+LR

    &SI(%XG0),U^/x%&=+>(/

    0p+>?m0-i0XC

  • 3QR!&K@!JI!0Kh@%!07LV&^%l

    ,0 V>U V9&S~me%

    7(yE~0!

    iJXK!$%()0

    4 8(6@

    4x/TM@z3/

    V(9M?(8SMIW

    {X,(9"/&%3K

    U

    c

    S

    `

    KT9+/R

    (,

    *

    ?

    \/=+>(5G&x"U

    !Z(9K+W@e?IM

    )!!+,l(g>

    *

    /

    7"-.

    %X=+>(/E%.I,=(?

    "C9K"/+4-IM=(?

    /R(9e>324 /%I

    (e>

    *

    %$/R=+>(5E%

    K),M!$%/

    345+q-,UKr&MX%=(?

    "C9Kj%4%lj%.,".

    3/,8]q!V((K50C,

    4%B>h!+T(S%0

    W,".9&S~me%IM#

    7(yE~0! r

    fVU%i"

    Ui

    !+B>h@3%k&9!jh

    L>

    *

    ]q=Qk!(%"@

    3%k&9(^W(C)/R0RI,

    &K3(6D/&91&%&

    M

    &9!&&&C&%S,

    {$57(I, M+ R(%I

    Q,-3/U&r

    fV&j%.+4-.%X

    =+>(/(9IM,z3/,8]q

    IM3KMXRM9&4,K

    @0O4%/2%Z!IM

    B>h&\,!0

    *

    "L>

    *

    -UA

    ,!&K&IV(K

    =+>?C00d3nR"-#!+6

    (>U!CK(CIVXM'

    !CK)W!KG8"\VDK

    !4CKIV&),J'!CK(^

    0d)W=e,K()W74CK

    34/VB>hJJ&\,!&K

    (P

    *

    K%KIVX%!& VKJ

    4IV@Q,S4324 /!-e>324 /-,

    --!-e>324 /

    !-e>324 /-.

  • IK(&,4IV

    &n/zL>

    *

    ]qI}

    +,8

    X&z0n V

    0n

    *

    @=3

  • 1.PDF2.PDF3.PDF