Станислав Львовский. Прерванное кино
DESCRIPTION
Львовский С. (2014). Прерванное кино / Сеанс. № 55-56. С. 24-41TRANSCRIPT
-
.
55/56.
24
-
:
1 , -, 1957, - (1956, ..). , , , , . , -( ). :
, - . , - , -, .
, , . .
: ; , -, : , ! , , - . . - . - , -, , - . , ( (Riders to the Stars), , ) . , , . , ; , , , . , .
1 King S. Danse Macabre. N.Y.: Everest House, 1981. P.816.
. , ( , ), (- ) . - , : , nolens volens , - ( ) - . , , , . : ( ) 2, . , , - . , , , : , , - .
, .
2 , . - (Claudian De Raptu Proserpinae ii. 302). : -,/ , ,/ ! ,/ ; / (. -// . .: , 1982. C.258).
25
-
1956, 25 1956 ( - ) XX -. 18, , , . - , ; -, - 1968, .
-, 1957 . , -, - , , - XX - - 3.
-, , ,
3 XX . ...// XX . .1. C.3441.
, - -( ). - . 60-. , . , - . . , 4 . . . , , , -, - ( , - ); -, - ( , , , , )5.
, , , (
4 , , .5 ., . 60- . .: ,
1998. C.4345.
VI , 1957
55/56.
26
-
6). , , . :
1956 - . . - , - , 7.
, - , , - . , . ( - ).
6 , , 4 1950 , -(RFE) . - 1956, XX.
7 KolP. The Party As a New Utopia: Reshaping Communist Identity After Stalinism// Social History. 2012. N37(4). Nov. P.404.
( ), - ( , , ), , -, .
, ( ), , . , , , , ( - ) . - , , , . , , - - , .
, soft power -, . , , - . ,
27
-
( , XIV -, 19258) - , -, , . - , , , - ( - ). - , - . , XVII , : , - . ? , , , - 9.
:
-. , , - , . . - : , , - 10.
: -, , -, , , 11, ( ). - , 1938 (..-, ., ., .) (..), - , . , , - 19401941 - :
, ,
8 ., : -. ? : . .: , 1992. C.269278.
9 . XVII () 26 1934// C. .: , 1951. .13. C.347.
10 ., . . . .25.11 , : We dont
want to fight but by Jingo if we do/ Weve got the ships, weve got the men, weve got the money too/ Weve fought the Bear before, and while were Britons true/ The Russians shall not have Constantinople. By Jingo by Jesus. . URL: http://www.cyberussr.com/hcunn/q-jingo.html
.
(1935) :
, , ! , .
, . , , - : , -, 1939 : ,/ . - , 1933 : - 192012.
- - , - 13. XX , , - . , , , - - , . , -: 14.
, - - - . , , 1954 - - 1928 15. , , 19401950 - - , - , , - - ,
12 HellebustR. Aleksei Gastev and Metallization of the Revolutionary Body // Slavic Review. 1997. Vol.56. N3. P.517.
13 , , , , , , .
14 , (- ., . .; .-; ..), 4 1965, , , , .
15 . : . .: , 2001. C.281.
55/56.
28
-
- ( - ) . 1945 1950 35% , , 16. , , - per se , .
, ( 1956) ( 1968) , soft power17. ( ), -. , soft power -18 . :
16 . : . .: -,2009. C.304305.
17 . .: Nye J. Bound to Lead: The Changing Nature of American Power. N.Y.: Basic Books, 1990.
18 ,
- - , (-) , , , - . - , - . - (competitive coexistence), - 1950- 19.
, , : - ( ,
1922 . , , , - 1952, : , -, - (. // C. .: , 1997. C.224).
19 ., . . 19452008. .: , 2010, . 124.
. . , 1938
. . , 1936
. . , 1937
29
-
, ) - 19561968, , --, , - : , - - 20. - , , , , ( -) . - ( ) - -, .
tabula rasa, , XXII, , 21 - . , :
20 .
21 Boym S. The Future of Nostalgia. N.Y.: Basic Books, 2001. P.60.
, - 1960- (- , ), . : - , - (, ) (, ). - , , . - , - . -(backward-looking storytelling) - - 4 195722.
, -, ,
22 Siddiqi S. From Cosmic Enthusiasm to Nostalgia for the Future: A Tale of Soviet Space Culture// MaurerE., Richers J., RthersM., ScheideC. (ed.). Soviet Space Culture: Cosmic Enthusiasm in Socialist Societies. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2011. P.283284.
55/56.
30
-
, -( ) , , , , - ( ). :
, - , . , , , - , , . (-, )23.
-. , , 24, , , , , - , () . - :
23 . vs : vs (2)// Prague Watchdog: Reporting on the conflict in the North Caucasus. 2009. 16. URL: http://www.watchdog.cz/index.php?show=000000-000024-000008-000004
24 ., : McCannonJ. Tabula Rasa in the North: The Soviet Arctic and Mythic Landscapes in Stalinist Popular Culture// DobrenkoE., NaimanE.(ed.). The Landscape of Stalinism: The Art and Ideology of Soviet Space. University of Washington Press, 2003. P.241260.
[] - , . - - : tabula rasa, - , . 1930- , , -, 25.
:
XVII, - . - , . , -, , , . , - , . - , . , , - , - , 26.
25 Ibid. P.251.26 . . . ,
.
1958-1963
!. . , 1960
31
-
, ? - , :
, , , - . . . - . . . . , , - . , - , , , , . .
. - , . . . - .
, -, . , - , . , . . . ! . - , . - !27
, , , , , - . , - , , - , - : . - : , , ; , - , , . - , , (. 3:2123).
, , - , 28. , , , ,
27 . . .: , 1974. C. 7175. 1965.
28 -, , . ., : GladJ. Extrapolations from Dystopia: ACritical Study of Soviet Science Fiction. New Jersey: Kingston Press, 1981; Griffiths J. Three Tomorrows: American, British, and Soviet Science Fiction. New Jersey: Barnes and Noble Books, 1980; - Science Fiction Studies: 2004. N94 (Special Issue: Soviet Science Fiction: the Thaw and After). Vol.31. Part3. Nov.
, , - - , , . - , XXII , , 29. , XXII , 30( , , ). , -, , , - . , - 1950- . - 1960- - , , - . : , , - -. , 31.
- , 1962 , , , , . - 1957 - , , 32 .33. 1968 ( , , - ) 34, , - - , -196835. , .-36, 1959
29 Csicsery-Ronay(Jr.)I. Science fiction and the Thaw// Science Fiction Studies. 2004. Nov. N94. P.337344.
30 . .: , 1961.31 ..
- - 2011. : . // - . 2011. 4(60). C.3744.
32 . . -. .: , 1908.33 . : // . 1914. 2.34 ., . // . 1968. 1 C.3572; 2. C.4071.35 . // -1968. .: , 1969. .8091.36 . 1920- // -
.. 2002. 9. . URL: http://www.bogdinst.
55/56.
32
-
, , , , - .
- - , - , pulp fiction, , , - -. - - , - , - 37. , , - , , ( - ). , , , -, , , , - , , , - ( - ) .
ru/HTML/Resources/Bulletin/9/Shushpanov.htm37 Csicsery-Ronay (Jr.) I. Op. cit. P.342.
, , -, () , . 1960 - , , , , - - 38. , -- , , . - 1962 - , , . , -, 39. - , , , - .
38 Zubok. Zhivagos Children. Harvard University Press, 2009. P.140.39 .: Ibid. P.276.
. . , 1965
33
-
, , - . . . (1963, ..-, .):
. : , .
, , - - 1950 40. , - , 196141, . : , : ; , -,/ . , -
. - . , , -, - ,
.
- : - - , -, 42.
. . . :
,, , . , .
40 Bradbury R. Green Morning // The Martian Chronicles. Garden City: Doubleday, 1950. P.96100.
41 . // . 1961. 11. C.2324.42 . // . 2. .: , 1972. .2. C.71. , -
, , - , : , - , . , - , ; , -, , : , -. , (golden apples of the sun) .. (..), - . (1953).
. . :
, , , . , .
, - :
- ,-, - , , 43.
, ; - . - , - . - -- , , - 44.
: - , , , . , , -, , -, , -. , , .
. , , - , . XVII - terra nullius, 45. 46 , , , - , terra nullius .
terra nullius - , , - (homestead principle),
43 // . 1957. 5.44 ., : StitesR. Revolutionary Dreams: Utopian Vision and Experimental
Life in the Russian Revolution. Oxford University Press, 1991. P.165189.45 ., : ConnorM. The Invention of Terra Nullius: Historical and Legal
Fictions on the Foundation of Australia. Sydney, Macleay Press, 2005. Sydney.46 Hill R., Gaddy C. The Siberian Curse: How Communist Planners Left Russia Out in the Cold.
Brookings Institution Press, 2003. P.65.
55/56.
34
-
, 47. -, - , - , , tabula rasa , . , -, 48, - -, .
. Terra nullius, , , ( -) . - ( ) , , , - , . - .
, , , - , , - , , .
- , -, . - ( ): - -1 . - , , . , -2 . - :
, , , , ! - - . -. !49
. - . :
- , . . . . 50.
47 ., : .-. // . 2004. 6 (21). URL: http://www.strana-oz.ru/2004/6/o-konechnom-obosnovanii-etiki-chastnoy-sobstvennosti
48 . . // .: , 2013. C.144.
49 . !// . 1957. 6.50 . // . 1957. 6.
.. - :
- , -. , , - 51.
-. :
, , , !
. 30 195752 - , - 6 1957. , , - .
, - : - . - , , , -. .. 53 . - . .. 54, - . - . 55, - :
!
, , !
, , 56.
51 : , !// . 1957. 6.
52 . // . 1957. 36. 30.53 . // . 1957. 12. C.49.54 . // . 1957. 11. C.9196.55 . // . 1957. 11.56 , , , -
, , -
35
-
, , - . , , , 1930- , ( ) - 1920-57. -, , - , -, , , , , - , . (, , , -) () , (-) , . , -, , : -, , ,
. , 1908.57 ., , .-
. . ( ) . .- 1937.
. - , -, .
, , , - - . wilderness58, ( - ), - -, terra nullius. , - wilderness: 1), 2) -( 10, ) 3). - , , - wilderness : wilderness , , : wilderness . , .
58 ., : . . .: Ad Marginem, 1995.
. . , 2000.
. . , 1962
55/56.
36
-
, , - ( , ). , 59, -. , wilderness, - 60.
, , wilderness, - -, . () - , . - , - , , terra nullius, - wilderness.
, , - . / ( !, . ,
59 ; . - ; (. 3:1718).
60 Stankey. G. Beyond the Campfires Light: Historical Roots of the Wilderness Concept// Natural Resources Journal. 1989. Vol.29, N1. Winter. P.1011.
., 1962); , / !/ / ! ( - , ., . .-, 1957); . . 1961 , , , , - : / ,/ , / . , - , 1975 , ..-- ( ) : - -/ ,/ , , , / - .
--- -. , (., ., 1962) . / !/ , / !, - : / - !. , - , , () XX :
37
-
,/ : !/ -, / !( - , . ., 1962). 1969 : ,/ -/ , ,/ , -, ! .- .: , ,/ - .
, - - ..-, : (1964), (1969) ,- , (1965). - . - . - 61, - - 62. ? ?
: -, , , , - , , , . -, , (- ; - . .). - , , - () -. , , - - , 63. , , , , .
, , - - . :
61 . , , -- .
62 ( , ) () , -, , , .
63 . 19601970- , // . 2007. 88. URL: http://magazines.russ.ru/nlo/2007/88/ku8.html
, - . -, : -. , , 64.
, , , - . - : , , - , , -, ( ) . .
, , , - . , - - , tabula rasa , terra nullius , - , wilderness, . , , . ?
- , 65, - . , - , , -, ( ), 66. - , , , . , - 67, , - , . , - . , -, .
- , , , - . , , - , , -, .
64 Private Letters of Edward Gibbon. London: J.Murray. Vol.2. P.251. . : . - . 17811997. .: ACT, 2010. C.17.
65 Harvey D. Spaces of Hope. University of California Press, 2000. P.159173.66 , ( , -) -
.67 Gould. C. Rethinking Democracy: Freedom and Social Cooperation in Politics, Economy, and
Society. Cambridge University Press, 1988.
55/56.
38
-
, , , - , , - - . . , - , -, 68 . -, , (. ) -- , , - . - , 69.
68 Marin L. Utopics: Spatial Play. New Jersey: Humanities Press, 1984.69 -
1930- , , , , -(-, , ..). , , - , - , .
XX 70, - - . , - , , . , - , , soft power. , -( , - soft power), - . , , -, - , . 1968 - 71.
70 .71 , ,
.
. . , 2013
39
-
19571968 , . , -, - . , , , , , . , , , , - , 72, 19891991, 73.
, , , - ( ):
. -, . : , - , ( , - , ). - , , - 74.
, , .
, -, 1946 V-2 105. 1959 Explorer6 - , . , , -8( , - ) 1968. , 75, , , , - . , - , , , , , - , , , , , , - , 76. - .
72 .. .73 . . Ab Imperio (Lipovetsky M. The
Poetics of ITR Discourse: In the 1960s and Today// Ab Imperio. 2013. N1, P.109139) - .
74 . . . C.93.75 ., : Harvey D. Op. cit. P.13; MiyoshiM. The Culture of Globalization. Durham;
London: Duke UP, 1997.76 MacLeish A. Riders on Earth Together, Brothers in Eternal Cold // New York Times. 1968.
25Dec.
, : - , , . . , -. : . ; : -, . ; . , ; - . . ; . . , - . -; . . - -. . - . , , : - , 77. 78.
, 1968 , , , , , . , - -, - .
, , - . , , - , , - 79.
, , . , , - - , - , , , .
.
77 : -1 // -. 2001. 10. URL: http://www.kommersant.ru/doc/253447
78 , , : , - , .
79 . // - . 2010. 1(9). C.14.
55/56.
40
-
,
41