Вопросы здоровья, питания и населения

17092

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

CTpaTerUH oTpacneBoro pa3BUTUH

BonpOChI 3lJOPOBh) nDTAHD) D HAPOlJOHACEnEHD)

OEhEAHHEHHE CnEUHAflHCTOB EAHKA B OEflACTH PA3BHTWI COUHAflhHhlX PECYPCOB

BCeMHpHhlH J)aHK

aBTopCKoe npaBo 1997 r Me)l(nYHaponHhlH EaHK PeKoHcTpYKUHH H Pa3BHTHw BCEMHPHbIH EAHK 1818 H Street NW Washington DC 20433 USA

Bce npaBa oxpaH~IOTc~ 3aKOHOM H3naHo B CoenHHeHHhlx lllTaTax AMepHKH TIepBhlH THpa)l( - ceHT~6ph 1997 r

UenhIO pa3pa60TKH cTpaTerHH oTpacneBoro pa3BHTH~ ~Bn~eTC~ nononHeHHe cTpaTerHH nOMOlllH cTpaHaM B lfaCTH Bhl~BneHH~ rIpeHMYlllecTBa BceMHpHoro EaHKa B cpaBHeHHH C npyrHMH opraHH3aUH~MH onpeneneHH~ 3gtgteKTHBHoCTH ero pa60Thl H npHopHTeTHhlx HanpaBneHHH B Ka)l(nOH oTnenhHoH oTpacnH

B CTpaTerHH oTpacneBoro pa3BHTH~ OCBelllaIOTC~ Bonpochl CTpaTerHH BceMHpHoro EaHKa no OTnenhHhlM ceKTopaM OCMhlcn~eTC~ OrIhlT npenhlnYllleH ne~enhHOCTH EaHKa B naHHoH OTpacnH Ha OCHOBe aHanH3a pe3ynhTaToB rIpOBeneHHoro CrIeUHanHCTaMH KaK caMoro EaHKa TaK H BHe ero onpenen~IOTC~ npHOpHTeThl HccnenOBaTenhCKOH pa60Thl KanpOBoro 06eCnelfeHH~ H Bhlpa60TKH COOTBeTCTBYIOllleH nonHTHKH a TaK)I(e onpenen~IOTC~ CTpaHhl HMeIOlllHe cephe3Hhle np06neMhl B pa3BHTHH TOH HnH HHOH OTpacnH ITO Hcnonh3yeTc~ npH COCTaBneHHH CTpaTerHH rIOMOlllH CTpaHe 3TH cTpaTerHH nOn)l(Hhl cnoc06cTBoBaTh nHanory Me)l(ny cTopoHaMH 3aHHTepeCOBaHHhlMH B pa3BHTHH TOH HnH HHOH OTpacnH

CTpaTerHH OTpacneBoro pa3BHTH~ 6ynYT nonroToBneHhl B 06nenHHeHH~x cneUHanHcToB EaHKa B 06nacTH pa3BHTH~ COUHanhHhlX pecypcoB 3KOHOMHlfeCKOrO ynpaBneHH~ H CHH)I(eHH~ ypOBH~ 6enHOCTH 3alllHThl OKpY)l(aIOllleH cpenhl H COUHanhHO-YCTOHlfHBOrO pa3BHTH~ gtHHaHCHpOBaHH~ lfaCTHOro ceKTopa H HHgtpaCTPYKTyphl ABTOphl Bhlpa)l(aIOT Hane)l(ny Ha TO ITO HHgtopMaUH~ conep)l(allla~c~ B rIpennaraeMOM H nocnenYIOlllHX TOMax 3TOH cepHH OKa)l(eTC~ none3HOH He TonhKO nn~ cneUHanHCTOB EaHKa HO H nn~ Me)l(nYHapOJlHhlX opraHH3aUHH 3aHHMaIOlllHXC~ BonpocaMH pa3BHTH~ a TaK)I(e H nn~ lllHpOKoro Kpyra lfHTaTeneH B CTpaHaX-lfneHaX EaHKa CTpaTerHH OTpacneBoro pa3BHTHR- nOn)l(Hhl paCCMaTpHBaThC~ KaK OTpa)l(eHHe cerOnH~lllHero BHneHH~ COOTBeTCTBYIOllleH OTpacnH H KaK BKnan B nHHaMHlfHhIH nHaflOr npaKTHKOB a TaK)I(e npH3BaHhl crIoc06cTBoBaTh KOHCTPYKTHBHhlM nHCKYCCH~M KOTophle CO BpeMeHeM npHBenyT K cOBepllleHCTBOBaHHIO nocnenYIOlllHX CTpaTerHH pa3BHTH~ ceKTopOB

rpaHHUhl TeppHTopHH Hcnonh30BaHHhle UBeTa neHe)l(Hhle enHHHUhl H npOlfa~ HHgtopMaUH~

yKa3aHHa~ Ha KapTax He 1l0n)l(Hhl nOHHMaThC~ KaK OTpa)l(eHHe KaKOH-nH60 n03HUHH BceMHpHoro EaHKa B OTHOllleHHH IOpHllHlfeCKOrO cTaTyca Kal(OH 6hl TO HH 6hlno TeppHTopHH HnH nOnllep)l(Ka HnH npH3HaHHe KaKHX 6hl TO HH 6hlno rpaHHU

ogtopMneHHe 06nmKKH rpynna CynoH nH3aHH BalllHHrTOH oKpyr KonYM6H~

COJ(EP)KAHME

BCTynlleHHe

nllarOnapHOCTh 3a YlJaCTHe

KpaTKOe COnep)l(aHHe

COKpallleHHjI

rRABA 1 JJIIHAMHtIHbIH MHP llPOEnEMbI H HAllPABnEHHH PA3BHTHH

BnelJaTlljlIOlllHe nOCTH)I(eHHjI H pe3YllhTaThI

np0611eMhlpa3BHTHjI

OCHoBHhle HanpaBlleHHjI nOllHTHKH

rRABA2 Ponb BCEMHPHOrO EAHKA PACllHPEHHE ytIACTHH H OCMbICnEHHE OllbITA

060CHOBaHHe YlJaCTHjI naHKa B 0611aCTH 3nH (3nopoBhe nHTaHHe H

HaponoHacelleHHe)

YlJaCTHe naHKa B 0611aCTH 3nH

OCMhIClleHHe OnhITa

rRABA3 B 21-M BEK HOBbiE OE5I3ATERbCTBA EAHKA

YTOlJHeHHe cTpaTerHlJeCKHX npHopHTeToB

nOBhIlIIeHHe pe3yllhTaTHBHOCTH

KanpoBoe 06eCnelJeHHe pa60ThI

YKpenlleHHe napTHepcTB

Or BHneHHjI npo611eM K neHcTBHIO

npl1flO)KEHI151 (HMeIOTCjI TOllhKO Ha aHfllHHCKOM jl3hIKe)

111

BCTYTIJIEHHE MaHllaTOM BCeMHpHOrO EaHKa jlBnjleTCjI

COlleHCTBHe npaBHTenbCTBaM pa3BHBaIOlllHXCjI

CTpaH B llOCTH)KeHHH YCTOHlJHBOrO nporpecca B

CHH)KeHHH ypOBHjI 6ellHOCTH B 06eCnelJeHHH

3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO pOCTa H ynYlJIlleHHH ycnoBHH

)KH3HH HaCeneHHjI Pa3pa6oTaHHbie B HaCTOjllllee

BpeMjI CTpaTerHH nOMOlllH 6ellHbiM CTpaHaM

OCHOBblBaIOTCjI Ha Tpex B3aHMOCBjl3aHHbiX

CPYHllaMeHTanbHblX npHHUHnax nonHTHKH

pa3BHTHjI

bull PaCllIHpeHHe B03MO)KHOCTeH nocpellCTBOM

IllHpoKoMacurra6Horo YCTOHlJHBOrO

3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO pOCTa HaueneHHoro B

lJaCTHOCTH Ha nOBblIlleHHe

npOH3BOllHTenbHOCTH TPYlla H C03llaHHe

pa60lJHX MeCT MjI 6ellHOH lJaCTH HaCeneHHjI

bull PaCIllHpeHHe 6ellHbiX cnoeB HaCeneHHjI K COUHanbHblM ycnyraM

cnoco6HbiM nOBblCHTb ypoBeHb 06pa30BaHHjI

y nylJIllHTb 3ll0pOBbe nHTaHHe a TaK)Ke

CHH3HTb ypOBeHb pO)KllaeMOCTH

bull npHeMneMble nporpaMMbl COUHanbHOH

3alllHTbl HaH60nee y jl3BHMbiX rpynn

HaCeneHHjI

Pa3YMH~ nonHTHKa B 06naCTH

YKpenneHHjI 3ll0POBbjl nHTaHHjI H

BocrrpOH3BOllCTBa HaCeneHHjI H 3cpcpeKTHBHoe

MellHUHHCKoe 06cnY)KHBaHHe jlBnjlIOTCjI

Ba)KHeHIllHMH 3BeHbjlMH nporpaMMbl

MepOnpHKrHH KOTopble n03BOnjlIOT CTpaHaM

pa30pBaTb nOpOlJHblH Kpyr 6ellHOCTH BblCOKOH

pO)KllaeMOCTH HealleKBaTHblX MellHUHHCKHX ycnyr

H HH3KHX TeMnOB 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO pOCTa H BOHTH

B n03HTHBHblH Kpyr pa3BHTHjI KOTOPblH

BblCOKOH

rrpOH3BOllHTenbHOCTbIO Tpylla HH3KOH

pO)KllaeMOCTbIO XOpOIllHMH nOKa3aTenjlMH

3ll0POBbjl H POCTOM llOXOllOB

B HaCTOjlllleH ny6nHKauHH H3naraeTCjI

CTpaTerHjI BceMHpHoro EaHKa B 06naCTH

3llpaBooxpaHeHHjI nHTaHHjI H HapOllOHaCeneHHjI

(3nH) B 3allalJH aBTopOB BXOllHno cnellYIOlllee

bull llaTb 0630p OCHOBHblX TeHlleHUHH H KnIOlJeBblX

npo6neM pa3BHTHjI OTpacnH 3nH a TaK)Ke

CTpaTerHH ee pecpopMHpOBaHHjI nonYlJHBIllHX

HaH6onbIllYIO nOllJlep)KKY

bull oueHHTb onblT pa60Tbi EaHKa B 06naCTH 3nH

B CTpaHax C HH3KHM H cpellHHM ypOBHeM

llOXOlla

bull onpellenHTb lJeTKYIO CTpaTerHIO llanbHeHilleH

lle~enbHOCTH EaHKa B 06naCTH 3nH

Ha nOKa3aTenH B 06naCTH 3ll0pOBbjl

nHTaHHjI H HapOllOHaCeneHHjI BnHjlIOT MHorHe

acneKTbl nonHTHKH pa3BHTHjI HanpjlMYIO He

CBjl3aHHbie C ceKTopOM 3llpaBooxpaHeHHjI HnH

MellHUHHCKHM 06cnY)KHBaHHeM HaCeneHHjI

HarrpHMep 06pa30BaHHe BOllOCHa6)KeHHe

KaHanH3aUHjI TpaHcnOpTHajl nonHTHKa H

KOHTponb 3a npOlla)KeH 0PY)KHjI OKa3blBaIOT

BnHjlHHe Ha 3ll0pOBbe HaCeneHHjI nonHTHKa B

06naCTH cenbCKoro X03j1HCTBa H npOH3BOllCTBa

nHllleBblX npOllYKTOB BnHjleT Ha nHTaHHe a

pa3nHlJHbie COUHanbHo-KynbTypHble cpaKTopbl

B03lleHCTBYIOT Ha POCT HaCeneHHjI CTpaTerHjI no

OTHOIlleHHIO K Me)KOTpaCneBbiM lleTepMHHaHTaM

nOKa3aTeneH B 06naCTH 3llpasooxpaHeHHjI

nHTaHHjI H HapOllOHaCeneHHjI 6ylleT H3nO)KeHa B

nocnellYIOlllHX aHanorHlJHblX ny6nHKaUHjlX EaHKa

npH pa3pa6oTKe CTpaTerHH EaHKa B

06naCTH 3nH HaH60nee 3HalJHMblMH jlBn5lJlHCb

cnellYIOlllHe npHHUHnbl

bull BHHMaHHe K COUHanbHblM cpaKTopaM

pa3BHTHjI

bull PearHpOBaHHe Ha 3anpOCbl KnHeHTOB

oco6eHHO 6ellHeHIllHX CTpaH

bull fny60KHH aHaJIH3 H ynop Ha pe3ynbTaT

bull npH3HaHHe nOnHTHlJeCKOrO acneKTa pecpopM

bull YBa)KeHHe K oco6eHHOCTjlM pa3nHlJHbiX CTpaH

H HapOllOB H HX COUHanbHOMY BbI60py

bull Heo6xOllHMOCTb YlJaCTHjI MecTHoro HaCeneHHjI

v

H YCTaHOBneHHe napTHepCKHX OTHoweHHH

DOKYMeHT no CTpaTerHH pa3BHTHjI B 06naCTH

3nH jlBnjleTCjI nepBhIM KpynHhIM pe3ynhTaToM

pa60ThI rpynnhI 3nH KOTOpaji BxonHT B COCTaB

HenaBHO C03naHHoro 06benHHeHHjI CneUHaflHCTOB

EaHKa B 06nacTH COUHaflhHOrO pa3BHTHjI 06mee

pYKOBonCTBO nonrOTOBKOH naHHOH CTpaTerHH

ocymecTBnjlnOCh OTpacneBhIM COBeTOM no

BonpocaM 3nH (CM npHnO)KeHHe 0 PHCYHOK

0) Ero peKOMeHnaUHH TeCHO CBjl3aHhI C npyrHMH

MepOnpHjlTHjlMH EaHKa HaueneHHhIMH Ha

nOBhlweHHe 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH pa60ThI H

OKa3hIBaIOmHMH ConeHCTBHe Ha Bcex njiTH

HanpaBneHHjlX pa60ThI OTpacneBoro COBeTa 3nH

pa3pa60TKa CTpaTerHH HHcpopMaUHOHHoe

06eCnelJeHHe npocpeCCHOHaflhHOe pa3BHTHe

KanpOB KOHTpOnh 3a KalJeCTBOM H

cOTpynHHlJeCTBO C npyrHMH opraHH3aUH5IMH

nO)lrOTOBKe naHHOrO nOKYMeHTa COnYTCTBOBafl

npouecc MHOrOCTOpOHHHX KOHcynhTaUHl1 co

CneUHaflHCTaMH H3 pa3nHlJHhIX nenapTaMeHTOB

EaHKa H rpynnhI 3nH a TaK)Ke H3 npyrHx

opraHH3aUHl1 CTpaTerHjI 6hlna on06peHa

pYKOBonCTBOM BceMHpHoro naHKa H COBeTOM

DHpeKTopoB DOKYMeHT no CTpaTerHH B OTpacnH

3nH He jlBnjleTC5I OKOHlJaTenhHhIM H3nO)KeHHeM

nejlTenhHOCTH EaHKa B 3TOH 06naCTH 3Ta

CTpaTerHjI 6yneT npOnOn)KaTh pa3BHBaThC5I H

nOnOnHjlThCjI

D3BHn De ltIgteppaHTH

n pencenaTenh 06benHHeHHjI

CneUHaflHCTOB naHKa B 06naCTH

pa3BHTHjI COUHaflhHhIX pecypcoB

PHlJapn D)KA ltIgtHlJeM

npencenaTenh ceKUHH

no np06neMaM 3nOpOBh5l

nHTaHHjI H HaCeneHHjI

Vl

EJIAfOLJAPHOCTb 3A YQACTI1E

QaHHbIH nOKYMeHT 6bln nOnrOTOBneH CneUHanHCTaMH ceKUHH no np06nCMaM 3nopOBMI nHTaHH5I H HaponOHaCeneHH5I (3nH) 51Bn5lIOLUeHC5I 4aCTbIO 06benHHCHH5I cnCUHanHCTOB naHKa B 06naCTH pa3BHTH5I COUHanbHbIX pecypCOB non PYKOBonCTBOM OTpacneBoro COBeTa 3nH MHorHe cOTpynHHKH H pYKOBonHTenH npyrHx OTnenOB BceMHpHoro naHKa 6blnH BOBne4eHbI B npouecc nonrOTOBKH nOKYMeHTa Pa60TY B03rnaBHnH AneKcaHnp C npeKep rnaBHbIH 3KOHOMHCT PH4apn Q)f(A ltlgtH4eM npencenaTenb ceKUHH 3nH H Q3BHn Qe ltlgteppaHTH npencenaTenb 06benHHeHH5I cneUHanHCTOB naHKa B 06nacTH cOUHanbHbIX pecypcOB QOKYMeHT 6bln OTpenaKTHpOBaH MenenHH Pocc H nonrOTOBneH K ne4aTH CaHKTOH EM YOTnH

Vll

KPATKOE CO)1EP)KAHME

HaCT05lIUa51 CTpaTerH5IOTpaCneBOro

pa3BHTH5I B 06naCTH 3nH COCTOHT H3 TpeX

OCHOBHhIX pa3nenOB nOnOnHeHHhIX

CTaTHCTHlJeCKHMH npHnO)teHH5IMH

IIpooJIeMhI H HanpaBJIeHHSI pa3BHTHSI

KaK OTMelJaeTC5I B rnaBe 1 20-H BeK

SlBn5leTC5I CBHJleTeneM HaH60nee KpynHhIx

ycnexoB B HCTOPHH lJenOBelJeCTBa B 06nacTH

3npaBooxpaHeHH5I nHTaHH5I H HapOJlOHaCeneHH5I

3TH ycnexH lJaCTHlJHO 6hInH Bh13BaHhl

POCTOM ypOBHeH JlOXOJlOB H 06pa30BaHHSI

ynYlJllleHHeM B 06nacTH 06eCnelJeHH5I HaCeneHH5I

npOnYKTaMH nHTaHHSI paClllHpeHHeM JlOcTyna K

npOTHB03alJaTOlJHhIM CpeJlCTBaM ynYlJllleHHeM

caHHTapHo-rHrHeHHlJeCKHX H )tHnHIUHhIX

ycnoBHH BOJlOCHa6)teHH5I H KaHanH3aUHH H

51BHnHCh pe3ynhTaToM nonYlJeHH5I HOBhlX

3HaHHH 0 npHlJHHaX 3a60neBaHHH HX

npOcpHnaKTHKH H nelJeHH5I a TaK)te npoBeneHH5I

onpeJleneHHhIX Mep KOTophle oTKphInH JlOcTyn

HaCeneHH5I K 3THM JlOCTH)teHH5IM

HeCMOTp51 Ha HMeIOIUHeC5I ycnexH OKono

2 MHnnHOHOB JleTeH e)terOJlHO yMHpalOT OT

60ne3HeH KOTophle MO)tHO 6hIno 6hI

npenoTBpaTHTh npHBHBKaMH 200 MHnnHOHOB

JleTeH B B03paCTe JlO poundHITH neT CTpaJlalOT OT

HeJlOeJlaHHJI 120 MHnnHOHOB ceMeH He HMelOT

Bhl60pa B nnaHHpOBaHHH KOnHlJeCTBa JleTeH 75 MHnnHOHOB JleTeH yMHpalOT e)terOJlHO B

MnaneHlJeCTBe 30 MHpoBoro HaCeneHH5I He

HMelOT JlOcTyna K 6e30naCHhIM HCTOlJHHKaM

Bonhi H KaHanH3aUHOHHhiM CHCTeMaM KpOMe

Toro 3a nOCneJlHee CToneTHe CYIUeCTBeHHO

H3MeHHnaCh KnHHHlJeCKa51 KapTHHa npOTeKaHH5I

MHorHX paHee H3YlJeHHhIX 3a60neBaHHH

Hcxon51 H3 MHpOBorO OnhITa OCHOBHhIe

yrp03hI XOpOllleMY 3nOpOBhlO nHTaHHIO H

nnaHHpOBaHHIO HapOnOHaCeneHH5I XOPOlllO

H3BeCTHhi H npHeMneMhle pellleHH5I lJaCTO MO)tHO

HaHTH OllHaKO BBHJly cna60ro nOTeHUHana

npaBHTenhCTB no peanH3aUHH npoeKTOB H

HeCOCT05ITenhHOCTH phIHKa B pellleHHH

onpeJleneHHhlX np06neM nOTeHUHanhHO

3cpcpeKTHBHhIe nOJlXOJlhl H nporpaMMhI lJaCTO He

npHHOC5IT ycnexa

PecpopMhI HanpaBneHHhle Ha peweHHe 3THX

np06neM 3alJaCTYlO Tpe6ylOT nepeCMOTpa ponH

rocyJlapCTBa H paClllHpeHH5I ero YlJaCTH5I B

peanH3aUHH 3JlpaBOOXpaHHTenhHhiX MepOnpH5ITHH

HMelOIUHX 3HalJHTenhHhiH BHelllHHH 3cpcpeKT B

06eCnelJeHHH JlOcTyna 6eJlHeHlllero HaCeneHH5I K

OCHOBHhlM MeJlHUHHCKHM ycnyraM npeJlOCTaBneHHH

HHcpopMaUHH nOJlJep)tKH HCCneJlOBaHH5IM H

pa3BHTHlO MenHUHHCKoro 06pa30BaHH5I

perynHpoBaHHH OTpacnH H npHBnelJeHHH

COOTBeTCTBYIOIUHX 06beMOB cpHHaHCHpOBaHH5I

TaK)te He06xoJlHMO BceMepHO YKpenn5lTh

napTHepCTBO C HerOCYJlapCTBeHHhlMH

opraHH3aUH5IMH

PacTymee YlaCTHe IiaHKa B OTpaCJIH 3IIH

B r naBe 2 naeTC5I 060cHoBaHHe TOro nOlJeMY

HHBeCTHUHH B lJenOBeKa 3aHHMalOT ueHTpanhHoe

MeCTO B cTpaTerHH MHpoBoro pa3BHTH5I

pa3pa60TaHHoH BO BceMHpHoM naHKe lJTO

OTpa)taeT npH3HaHHe Toro cpaKTa lJTO 6e3

3JlOpOBOro 06pa30BaHHoro H XOPOlllO nHTaIOIUerOC5I

HaceneHH5I HH OJlHa CTpaHa He MO)teT JlOCTHlJh

YCTOHlJHBOrO pOCTa 3KOHOMHKH HnH CHH3HTh

ypOBeHh 6enHOCTH nOCKonhKY HH OJlHa H3

Me)tJlYHapOJlHhIX opraHH3aUHH He MO)teT

caMOCT05lTenhHO pewaTh cnO)tHhle npo6neMhI

CT05lIUHe B 06naCTH 3JlpaBOOXpaHeHH5I nHTaHH5I H

HapOJlOHaCeneHHJI naHK nOJlJep)tHBaeT TeCHhIe

pa60lJHe KOHTaKThI co MHOrHMH opraHH3aUH5IMH

npeHMYIUeCTBO naHKa COCTOHT B ero rn06anhHOM

onhITe H cnoc06HOCTH COlJeTaTh

HccnenOBaTenhCKYIO pa60TY H aHanH3 KOHKpeTHhIX

CTpaH C M06HnH3aUHeH 3HalJHTenhHhIX cpHHaHCOBhIX

pecypCOB BO MHorHX OTpaCn5lX

IX

YlIaCHIe naHKa B OTpaCnH 3nH

HalJaBllleeCH B HalJane 1970-x r nepBOHalanbHO

3aKnIOIanOCb B npenOCTaBneHHH CTpaHaM

nOMOIUH B YKpenneHHH H paClllHpeHHH

HHcppaCTpYKTYPbI H MaTepHanbHOM 06eCneleHHH

OCHOBHbIX npOrpaMM XOTH CKPOMHbIH ycnex H

6bln nOCTHrHYT nOCpenCTBOM TaKOrO nonXona B

HaCTOHIUee BpeMH CTanO OleBHnHbIM lITO LlIlH

06eCneleHHH YCTOHlJHBOrO B03neHCTBHH Ha

6enHeHlllee HaCeneHHe nOBblllleHHH

3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH CHCTeM 3npaBOOXpaHeHHH H

CTa6HnbHOrO cpHHaHCHpOBaHHH Heo6xonHMbI

OpraHH3aUHOHHble H CHCTeMHble

npe06pa30BaHHH CTpaTerHH nOMoIUH CTpaHe

HBnHeTCH OCHOBHbIM HHCTpYMeHTOM

Mo6HnH3aUHH MHorooTpacneBOrO YlaCTHH

Heo6xonHMOrO nnH pellleHHH CHCTeMHbIX

np06neM

C MOMeHTa BbIJleneHHH nepBOrO 3aHMa B

06naCTH 3nH B 1970 rony neIDenbHOCTb naHKa

B 3TOM HanpaBneHHH pocna 6blCTPblMH TeMnaMH

H B HaCTOHIUee BpeMH n aHK HBnHeTCH

KpynHeHlllHM BHelllHHM HCTOlJHHKOM

cpHHaHcHpOBaHHH cTpaH C HH3KHM H cpenHHM

ypoBHeM noxona Ha CerOnHHlllHHH neHb

HaCIHTbIBaeTCH 154 neHCTBYIOIUHX H 94

3aBepllleHHbix npoeKTa B 06naCTH 3nH Ha

06IUYIO CYMMY B 135 Mnpn nonn CIIIA B ueHax

1996 rona B naHHOM nOKYMeHTe

paccMaTpHBaeTCH HaKonneHHbIH onbIT pa60TbI H

npo6neMbI CBH3aHHble C HenaBHHM CHH)KeHHeM

06beMa aHanHTHlJeCKOH pa6oTbI ocna6neHHeM

OCBeIUeHHH npo6neM B 06naCTH 3nH B

cTpaTerHHX nOMOIUH OTnenbHbIM cTpaHaM H

KOnHleCTBOM npoeKToB HaXOnHIUHXCH non

yrpo30H cpbIBa

CTpaTerml EaHKa B oTpacnH 3nH

B r naBe 3 npenCTaBneHbI paclllHpeHHble

06H3aTenbcTBa naHKa B oTpacnH 3nH npH

nepexone B 21-H BeK 3analH naHKa B OTpaCJJH

3nH no OKa3aHHIO nOMOIUH cTpaHaM-KnHeHTaM

BKnIOlaIOT

bull ynY1fllleHHe nOKa3aTeneH cpellH

oeAHeHlllHx cnoeB HaceneHHH B oonacTH

3nH H 3aIUHTa HaCeneHHH OT yrpo3bI

o6HHIUaHHH H3-3a 6one3HeH HenOenaHHH H

BbICOKOH pO)KnaeMOCTH

bull nOBhIllleHHe 3qqeKTHBHoCTH CHCTeM

3ApaBooxpaHeHHH nYTeM o6eCnelJeHHH

paBHoro nocTyna K ycnyraM B ccpepe nelJeHHH H

npocpHnaKTHKH 3a6oneBaHHH nHTaHHH H

nnaHHpOBaHHH HaCeneHHH 3TH ycnyrH

nOn)KHbI 6bITb HenoporHMH 3cpcpeKTHBHbIMH

KaleCTBeHHbIMH XOPOlllO opraHH30BaHHbIMH H

cooTBeTcTBYIOIUHMH nOTpe6HOCTHM HaCeneHHH

bull oOeCne1feHHe YCTOH1fHBOrO ypOBHH

qHHaHCHpOBaHHH 3ApaBooxpaHeHHH nYTeM

Mo6HnH3aUHH cooTBeTcTBYIOIUHX pecypcoB

C03naHHH lllHpOKOMaClllTa6HbIX MexaHH3MOB

CHH)KeHHH pHcKa H nonnep)KaHHH KOHTpOnH 3a

rocynapCTBeHHbIMH H lJaCTHblMH pacxonaMH

CTpaTerHH naHKa B oTpacnH 3nH 6yneT H

nanbllle nHHaMHIHO pa3BHBaTbCH C yleToM

nepenoBoro Me)KnYHaponHoro onblTa CnO)KHOCTb

OTpacnH 3nH H MeHHIOIUHeCH nO)lXonhl K

npo6neMaM 06bllHO He n03BOnHIOT Bblpa60TaTb pa3

H HaBcerna YCTaHOBneHHble peKOMeHnaUHH B CBH3H

C 3THM npH npenOCTaBneHHH KOHcynbTaUHH

peKOMeHnaUHl1 H cpHHaHCOBOH nOMOIUH Heo6xonHMO

HcxonHTb H3 KOHKpeTHblX ycnoBHH CTpaH

cocpenOTOIHB YCHnHH B cnenYIOIUHX leTblpex

HanpaBneHHHX

Y mOlHeHue cmpameluleCKUX npuopumemo8 naHK peKoMeHnyeT npaBHTenbCTBaM ITo6bl HX

nO)lXOnbl B OTHOllleHHH Bcex Tpex npHopHTeTHblX

3anal B 06naCTH 3nH OCHOBblBanHCb Ha

npHHUHnax neueHTpanH3aUHH YKpenneHHH

napTHepCTB C HrO H HenocpenCTBeHHoro

BOBneleHHH HaCeneHHH B 06eCneleHHe YCToHIHBoro

cpHHaHCHpOBaHHH PeKoMeHnyeTCH TaK)Ke 06paTHTb

BHHMaHHe Ha paHee HrHopHpyeMble 06naCTH

HMeIOIUHe BnHHHHe Ha pe3ynbTaTbi B 06naCTH 3nH

KaK-TO roponCKoe H cenbCKoe pa3BHTHe

06pa30BaHHe KOHTponb 3a Ta6aKoKypeHHeM H

3noynoTpe6neHHeM anKOrOnH arpapHaH nonHTHKa

OKpY)KaIOIUaH cpena BonOCHa6)KeHHe KaHanH3aUHH

H TpaHcnopT

x

CTpaTenm naHKa no nOMoruH

OTnenbHbIM CTpaHaM 6ynYT Hcnonb30BaHbI B

KacleCTBe OCHOBHbIX HHCTpYMeHTOB BeneHH5I

nHanora C pYKOBonCTBOM pa3nHcIHbIX CTpaH 0

BbIlueynoM5IHYTbIX 3anaclaX H HanpaBneHH5IX

pa60TbI naHKa oononHHTenbHble YCHnH5I 6ynYT

npennpHH5ITbI nn51 06eCnecleHH5I npouecca

nonrOTOBKH 3THX Ba)KHbIX nOKYMeHTOB

He06xonHMbIMH pecypcaMH H KanpaMH TaK)Ke

YCHnH5I 6ynYT HanpaBneHbI Ha nonKpenneHHe

KpenHTOB HccnenOBaTenbCKOH H aHanHTHcIeCKOH

pa60TOH cITO n03BonHT H36e)KaTb HeraTHBHbIX

nocnenCTBHH CBepTbIBaHH5I OTpacneBbIX

HccnenOBaHHH nporpaMMa HccnenOBaTenbCKHX

pa60T naHKa 6yneT npHB5I3aHa K npHopHTeTaM B

06nacTH 3nH COTpynHHKH naHKa nOn)KHbI

nOBbICHTb H36HpaTenbHOCTb nonxonOB Ha

OCHOBaHHH HX COOTBeTCTBH5I 3anaclaM nonHTHKH

B 06nacTH 3nH nOTeHUHanbHoro B03neHCTBH5I

Ha pa3BHTHe H npHBep)KeHHOCTH CTpaHshy

KnHeHTOB npoueccy pecpopM

IIOBblUteHUe pe3YlbmamuBHocmu KacleCTBO ycnyr

H HX COOTBeTCTBHe 3anpocaM CTpaH-KnHeHTOB

6ynYT ynYclllleHbI nYTeM YKpenneHH5I 6a3bI

3HaHHH B 06naCTH 3nH CHCTeMaTWleCKoro

Hcnonb30BaHH5I HaKonneHHoro onbITa

nOBbIllleHH5I KacleCTBa nonrOTOBKH npoeKTOB H

anp06auHH HOBbIX nonxonOB nOBbIllleHH5I

ypOBH5I KOHTpOn51 3a TeKYIllHMH npoeKTaMH

Hcnonb30BaHH5I nononHHTenbHbIX KpenHTHbIX

HHCTpYMeHTOB ynporueHH5I onepaUHOHHbIX

npoueCCOB H 3aKynoclHbIX npouenyp H

npOBeneHH5I onpOCOB nn51 BbI5IBneHH5I

ynoBneTBopeHHOCTH KacleCTBOM ycnyr B 3aBepllleHHH cneayeT OTMeTHTb cITO 6yaeT

B0306HOBneHa pa60Ta no YCHneHHIO KOHTpOn51 3a

npoeKTOB

YCOBepllleHCTBOBaHH5I KOHTponbHbIX

nOKa3aTeneH H BKnIOcIeHH5I KOHTponbHOshy

OueHOlHbIX MepOnpH5ITHH B CTpyKTYPY

npoeKTOB

KaopOBoe o6ecneeHue OeJlmelbHocmu

EaHKa B 06lacmu 3IIH PellleHHe Tpex KanpOBbIX

BonpOCOB 6yneT 51Bn5ITbC5I KnIOcIeBbIM

npHopHTeTOM B ne5ITenbHOCTH HOBoro

OrpacneBoro COBeTa 3nH oOCTaTOclHO nH B naHKe

cneUHanHCTOB B 06naCTH 3nH 06nanaIOT nH OHH

nOCTaTOclHOH KOMneTeHTHOCTbIO M5I pellleHH5I

nOCTaBneHHbIX 3anacl 3cpcpeKTHBHO nH HX

pacnpeneneHHe Me)Kny IllTa6-KBapTHpOH naHKa H

nOCT05lHHbIMH npenCTaBHTenbCTBaMH B CTpaHax B

naHHOM nOKYMeHTe npennaraIOTC5I nyTH nn51

YKpenneHH5I opraHH3aUHOHHorO nOTeHUHana naHKa

B 3TOM HanpaBneHHH nporpaMMbI nOBbIllleHH5I

KBanHcpHKaUHH COTpynHHKoB naHKa 6ynYT

nOCTpoeHbI C YcleTOM ynoM5IHYTbIX Tpex

CTpaTerHcIeCKHX HanpaBneHHH YcIe6Hble

nporpaMMbI 6ynYT paCCcIHTaHbI Ha YclaCTHe He

TonbKO COTpynHHKoB naHKa HO H npenCTaBHTeneH

CTpaH-KnHeHTOB TaK)Ke nnaHHpyeTc5I paClllHpHTb

YclaCTHe B 3THX nporpaMMax COTpynHHKoB

nOCT05lHHbIX npenCTaBHTenbCTB naHKa B

pa3nHcIHbIX CTpaHax H cneUHanHCTOB H3 npyrHx

ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX

B3aUMoomHOtueHUU naHK 6yneT npOnOn)KaTb

CTPOHTb OTHOIlleHH5I C napTHepaMH Ha OCHOBe

CBoero cpaBHHTenbHoro npeHMyrueCTBa B

onpeneneHHbIX Bonpocax H cIeTKOrO nOHHMaHH5I

CTopOHaMH CBOHX CPYHKUHH H poneH KaK 3TO HMeeT

MeCTO npH COTpYllHHIeCTBe C B03 H nporpaMMOH

OOH no 60Pb6e co CnHoOM naHK 6yneT CTPOHTb

OTHOllleHH5I Ha OCHOBe npenblaYIllHX nOCTH)KeHHH B

06naCTH KOHTpOn51 3a pelHOH cnenOTOH

nOnnep)KHBa51 HHHUHaTHBbI npyrHx

Me)KnYHaponHbIX opraHH3aUHH B 06naCTH 3nH

Bep05lTHble 06naCTH COTPYnHHIeCTBa BKnIOIaIOT

nonnep)l(KY CTpaH ACPPHKH B HX 60Pb6e

3nHneMH5IMH Man5lpHH pa60TY C B03 H npyrHMH

opraHH3aUH5IMH no 60Pb6e C naHaeMHeH

Ty6epKyne3a H no nponaraHne HHTerpHpOBaHHoro

nonxona K neleHHIO neTCKHX 3a6oneBaHHH a TaK)I(e

nonrOTOBKY COBMeCTHO C napTHepaMH BceMHpHoro

ltlgt0pYMa no MenHUHHCKHM HccnenOBaHH5IM

nOcpenCTBOM TaKHX Mep 6yneT paCIllHpeH

BKnan naHKa B YCHnH5I MHpOBoro co06rueCTBa no

COBepllleHCTBOBaHHIO COUHanbHoro pa3BHTH5I B

nepBoe neC5ITHneTHe 21-ro BeKa

xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC

ltlgtAO OOH BBTI BHTI

BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH

ltlgtoHOOH IOHHCEltlgt

B03

COKPAmEHH5I

AcpPHKaHCKHl1 EaHK Pa3BHTH5I

CHHLlPOM TIpHo6peTeHHoro HMMYHoLlecpHUHTa A3HaTCKHH EaHK Pa3BHTH5I

CTpaTerH5I nOMOlllH CTpaHe EBporreHcKHH EaHK PeKoHcTPYKUHH H Pa3BHTH5I

HHCTHTYT 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO Pa3BHTH5I EBporreHcKHH COI03

npOLloBonhcTBeHHa51 H CenhCKOX0351HCTBeHHa51 OpraHH3aUH5I OOH

BanOBOH BHYTpeHHHH npOLlYKT BanOBOH HaUHOHanhHhIH TIPOLlYKT

BHPYC HMYHHoLlecpHUHTa Me)l(JlYHapoLlHhIH EaHK PeKoHcTpYKUHH H Pa3BHTH5I

Me)KLlYHapoLlHa51 ACCOUHaUH5I Pa3BHTH5I Me)KaMepHKaHcKHH EaHK Pa3BHTH5I

Me)KLlYHapoLlHa51 ltlgtHHaHCOBa51 KoprropaUH5I

Me)KLlYHapoLlHa51 OpraHH3aUH5I TpYLla Me)KLlYHapoLlHhIH BanIOTHhIH ltlgtOHLl

UeHTp 06YlJeHH5I H nHLlepCTBa MHorocTopoHHee AreHTCTBO rro rapaHTHpoBaHHIO HHBeCTHUHH

HerocyLlapCTBeHHhle OpraHH3aUHH

OpraHH3aUH5I 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO COTPYLlHHlJeCTBa H Pa3BHTH5I OTLlen OueHKH oe5ITenhHOCTH naHaMepHKaHCKa51 opraHH3aUH5I 3LlpaBooxpaHeHH5I napHTeT nOKyrraTenhcKoH Crroco6HOCTH

nporpaMMa CrreUHanhHhIX rpaHToB TIporpaMMa OOH rro 6oph6e co CTIHoOM

nporpaMMa Pa3BHTH5I OOH ltlgtoHa HaceneHH5I OOH oeTcKHH ltlgtoHa OOH BceMHpHa51 OpraHH3aUH5I 3apaBooxpaHeHH5I

X11l

fJIABA I

uHHAMHqHhIH MHP npOIgtJIEMhI H HAnpABJIEHH~ PA3BHTH~

Bne~I3TnHIO~He aOCTH)KeHHH H

pe3ynbTaTbI

TIocneJlHHe HeCKonbKO

neCRTHneTHH 20-ro BeKa CTanH CBHneTemlMH

BnelaTnmoIUHx nOCTH)I(eHHH B 06naCTH

3npaBooxpaHeHHH nHTaHHH H HaCeneHHH (3nH )

3a nocnenHHe 40 neT pOCT npOnomKHTenbHOCTH )l(H3HH H CHH)I(eHHe ypOBHH pO)l(naeMOCTH no

BceMY MHPY npeBbICHnH pe3ynbTaTbI npenblnYIUHx 4000 neT nporH03bI nOKa3bIBaIOT ITO Ha 2000

ron npHneTCH cepenHHa CTOneTHH rn06anbHoro

nepexona OT BbICOKOH cMepTHocTH H

pO)l(naeMOCTH K HH3KOH cMepTHocTH H HH3KOH

pO)l(naeMocTH (CM PHcil KapTY no CHH)I(eHHIO

pO)l(naeMOCTH H KapTY no nOCTH)I(eHHHM B

06naCTH CHH)I(eHHH neTCKOH cMepTHocTH B npHnO)l(eHHH G)

~y1PfflltHtB~ gttltKH1HypoetRC~

6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D

KaK YKa3bIBaeTCH B lloKnane B03 0

COCTOHHHH 3nOpOBbH HaCeneHHH MHpa B 1996 r

COTHH MHnnHOHOB )l(HTeneH cTpaH C HH3KHM H

cpenHHM ypoBHeM noxona HaXOiljffCH Ha nopore

3pbI KOTOPM npHHeceT HM H36aBneHHe OT

CornaCHO nOKnany IOHHCEltlgt 0 nOnO)l(eHHH middot

neTeH B CTpaHax MHpa B 1996 r nonH neTeH

yMHpaIOIUHX B B03pacTe OT 0 no 5 neT COKpaTHnaCb B ilEa pa3a no cpaBHeHHIO C 1960

ronOM E)I(erOnHO BaKUHHaUHH cnacaeT OKono 3 M11H neTeH a neleHHe nHapeH - OKono 1

MHnnHOHa

3KOHOMHleCKHH nporpecc 20 BeKa BO

MHOrOM nOBnHrul Ha ycnexH B 06naCTH

3npaBooxpaHeHHH YnYlWeHHe nHTaHHH 6bInO

BbI3BaHO He TonbKO POCTOM npOH3BonCTBa

cenbCKOX03HHCTBeHHbIX nponYKTOB Ha nywy

HaCeneHHH H paCWHpeHHeM B03MO)l(HOCTeH CTpaH

60POTbCH C np06neMOH ronona Ha MeCTax HO H

60nee pa3Ho06pa3HOH CTpyKTypOH nHTaHHH

K031PIPHUHeHTbI HenOCTaTOlHOrO nHTaHHH cpenH

neTeH B CTpaHax C HH3KHM H cpenHHM ypOBHeM

nOXona Ha 20 HH)I(e ypOBHH TpHnuaTHneTHeH

naBHOCTH a HeKoTopble BHnbI 3a60neBaHHH

CBH3aHHble C HenoenaHHeM H HeXBaTKOH

onpeneneHHblx nHTaTenbHblX BeIUeCTB npaKTHleCKH HCle3nH B uenOM pMe cTpaH

TaK)I(e 3aMennmoTCH TeMnbI pOCTa

HaCeneHHH CpeJlHee KOnHleCTBO neTeH y )l(eHIUHH

neToponHoro B03paCTa (06IUHH nOKa3aTenb

pO)l(naeMOCTH) paBeH TpeM no cpaBHeHHIO C IDITbIO

B 1960 rony HeKoTopble cTpaHbI C HH3KHM H

cpenHHM ypoBHeM nOXona nOlTH nOCTHr nH ypOBHH BocnpOH3BonCTBa HaCeneHHH Te JlBa pe6eHKa Ha

ceMbIO AOCTH)I(eHHIO TaKHX pe3ynbTaToB

cnoc06CTBOBanH ueneHanpaBneHHble YCHnHH no

nnaHHpoBaHHIO ceMbH a TaK)I(e POCT noxonOB H

yp0BeHb 06pa30BaHHH aeBOleK-nOnpocTKoB H

)l(eHIUHH Hcnonb30BaHHe npoTHB03alaTOlHbIX

CpenCTB cpenH cynpY)l(ecKHx nap B TaKHX cTpaHax

Bblpocno C 10 B cepellHHe 1960-x rr no 55 B

1990rony

ltlgtaKTopbI onpe[(eJUIIOIQHe xopomee 3[(opoBbe H ypoBeHb 3a6oneBaeMocTH

HeKoTopbIX HaH60nee onaCHblX 3a60neBaHHH BapHaTHBHOCTb B

nOKa3aTen5lX 3nOpOBh5l nOnHOueHHOCTH nHTaHH5I

H pO)KnaeMOCTH Ha6monaeMa51 CpenH pa3nH4HhiX

rpynn HaCeneHH5I 3aBHCHT OT p5lna qaKTOpOB

BKnI04aIOIUHx

bull YpOBHH noxona H 6enHocTH

bull 06pa30BaHHe OC06eHHO neB04eK-nOnpOCTKOB

H )KeHIUHH

bull COOTBeTCTBYIOIUHH ypOBeHh nHTaHH5I 4HCTOTa

BOnhI H KaHanH3aUH5I

bull KynhTypa H nOBeneHHe

bull TIonHTHKa B 06naCTH 3npaBOOXpaHeHH5I

HaH60nee Ba)KHhIMH neTepMHHaHTaMH

xopOlllero COCT05lHH5I 3nOpOBh51 HaCeneHH5I B

CTpaHax C HH3KHMH nOXOnaMH OCTaIOTC5I POCT

)KOHOMHKH H CHH)KeHHe ypOBHeH 6enHOCTH

B03neHCTBYIOIUHe Ha OCHOBHhle nOTpe6HOCTH

HaCeneHH5I B nponyKTax nHTaHH5I )KHnhe

nocTyne K 4HCTOH BOne H KaHanH3aUHH

KaK nOKa3hIBaeT onhIT KHTa5l KOCTa-PHKH H

IllpH naHKH Ha4anhHoe 06pa30BaHHe neB04eKshy

nonpOCTKOB H )KeHIUHH TaK)Ke 6narOnpH5ITHO

CKa3hIBaeTC5I Ha COCT05lHHH 3nOpOBh51 HaCeneHH5I

06pa30BaHHoe HaceneHHe HMeeT TeHneHUHIO

BeCTH 60nee 3nopOBhIH 06pa3 )KH3HH 60nee )qqeKTHBHO Hcnonh30BaTh orpaHH4eHHhle

pecypchl BKnIOia51 nponOBonhCTBHe H

MenHUHHCKHe ycnyrH H H36eraTh pHCKa nn51

3nOpOBh5l CB5I3aHHOro CO 3noynoTpe6neHHeM

HHKOTHHa H anKOrOn51 H Hcnonh30BaHHeM

HapKOTHKOB B 60nhlllHHCTBe CTpaH npHH5IThle

HOpMhI B OTHOllleHHH neTOpO)KneHH5I H yxona 3a

neThMH CTaTYC )KeHIUHH nH4Ha51 rHrHeHa H

nonOBoe nOBeneHHe HMeIOT r ny60KHe KOpHH B

MeCTHOH KynhType H 06hI4a5lx H OKa3hIBaIOT

MOIUHoe B03neHCTBHe Ha COCT05lHHe 3nOpOBh51

HaCeneHH5I

TIpoqHnaKTHieCKHe MepOnpH5ITH5I cpenH

HaCeneHH5I TaKHe KaK BaKUHHaUH5I HrpaIOT

Ba)KHYIO ponh B CHH)KeHHH pHCKa 3a60neBaHHH B

TO BpeM51 KaK HenocpenCTBeHHO ne4e6Hhle ycnyrH

nOMoraIOT YCTpaHHTh nOCnellCTBH5I 60ne3HeH H

TpaBM [pyrHe MepOnpH5ITH5I B 06naCTH

06IUeCTBeHHoro 3ll0POBh51 TaK)Ke MoryT

cnoc06CTBOBaTh ynyillleHHIO COCT05lHH5I 3ll0POBh51

HaCeneHH5I coneHCTBY51 C03naHHIO 3nopOBOH

OKpY)KaIOIUeH Cpellhl npOnaraHllHpY51 60nee

3nopOBhlH 06pa3 )KH3HH KOHTponHpY51 onaCHhle H

BpenHhle BHnhl ne5ITenhHOCTH OTnenhHhlX nHU H

opraHH3aUHH Enaronap51 ycnelllHoH nonHTHKe

rocynapCTB B )TOH 06naCTH B HHnHH HanpHMep

CHH3HnC5I ypOBeHh 3arp5l3HeHH5I OKpY)KaIOIUeH

cpenhl noporH B MeKCHKe CTanH 60nee 6e30naCHh1MH B BenHK06pHTaHHH BBeneH

)KeCTKHH KOHTponh 3a npOlla)KeH OPY)KH5I B

TYPUHH yny4111eHhl CHCTeMhl BonOCHa6)KeHH5I H

KaHanH3aUHH a B HHnoHe3HH HanO)KeHhI

orpaHH4eHH5I Ha KypeHHe HapKOTHKH

nOTpe6neHHe anKOrOn5l Eonee pelllHTenhHhle

Mephl Tpe6YIOTC5I no npeKpaIUeHHIO npaKTHKH

nOBpe)KneHH5I reHHTanhHhIX opraHOB y )KeHIUHH

KaK pe3ynhTaT CnO)KHOH CHHeprHH

nOBhIllleHH5I ypOBH5I noxonOB 06pa30BaHH5I

noneneHH5I nonHTHKH rocynapcTBeHHhIX opraHOB

pa3BHTH5I 3npaBooxpaHeHH5I cpeilH5I5I

npOnOn)KHTenhHOCTh )KH3HH B MHpe

YBenH4HnaCh Teneph nIOilH BO BceM MHpe )KHByT B

CpellHeM nOiTH Ha 25 neT nonhllle 4eM B 1900 r (B

cpaBHeHHH C TeM)Ke ypoBHeM nonYllleBoro

noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000

IloAyweBoM AOXOA (A01V1apb11991)jlHC12

B03)JeHCTBHe Ha KaqeCTBO ~H3HH H

npOH3BO)JHTenbHOCTb TpY)Ja

XopOIUee COCT05lHHe 3ll0POBh51

6narOnpH5ITHO CKa3hIBaerC5I Ha KaieCTBe )KH3HH H

npOH3BOllHTenhHOCTH Tpyna MHorHe

3a60neBaHH5I He 5IBn5IJICh CMepTenhHhlMH MoryT

Bce )Ke npHBeCTH K nOTepe TpYllocnoco6HOCTH

2

OKono 200 MnHlfenOBeK no BceMY MHPY - 90 H3

KOTOPhIX )l(HBeT B cTpaHax UeHTpanhHOM H

IO)I(HOM ACPPHKH -- CTpallaIOT OT napa3HTHlfecKofo

lfepB5I-WHCT030Ma H 1 Mnpll lfenOBeK - OT aHeMHH

3KoHoMHlfecKHe np06neMhl Bhl3BaHHhle TaKHMH

3a60neBaHH5IMH BKnIOlfaIOT CHH)I(eHHe

npOH3BOllHTenhHocTH Tpyna BBHny nOCT05lHHOfO

lfYBcTBa YCTanocTH H npYfHx CHMnTOMOB nOTepIO

noxona nHlfHhle MenHUHHCKHe pacxonhl H

3aTpaThi Ha caMO nelfeHHe

Xopowee COCT05lHHe 3nOpOBh5l

cnoc06cTBY5I pa3BHTHIO lfenOBelfeCKOfO KanHTana

lfpe3BhllfaMHO Ba)l(HO nn51 3KOHOMHlfeCKOfO pOCTa

HanpHMep H3nelfeHHe OT r nHCTOB H3 CeMeMCTBa

HeMaTOnOB cpenH neTeM 3ananHOM HHnHH nYTeM

onHopa30BOM n03hl neKapCTBa pe3KO nOBhlCHnH

ycneBaeMOCTh B WKone npOH3BonHTenhHOCTh

TPYna B HHnOHe3HH H KeHHH Bhlpocna 6nafonap51

n06aBKaM B nHIUY )l(ene3a H nOBhIweHHIO ee

KanOpHMHOCTH TaK)I(e eCTh CBHneTenhCTBa TOMY

lfTO CHH)I(eHHe ypOBH5I pO)l(naeMOCTH H nonH

H)I(nHBeHueB MononOfO B03paCTa MO)l(eT HMeTh

nOnO)l(HTenhHhlM 3cpcpeKT Ha 3KOHOMHlfeCKHM

POCT ecnH 3TOT npouecc COnpOBO)l(naeTC5I POCTOM

BHYTpeHHHX c6epe)l(eHHM H HHBeCTHUHM B

lfenOBelfeCKHM KanHTan

npofineMhI pa3BHTJUI

YT06hI coxpaHHTh nOCTHfHYToe H

3cpcpeKTHBHhiM 06pa30M H36e)l(aTh np06neM B

6ynYIUeM npaBHTenhCTBa CTpaH C HH3KHM H

cpenHHM ypOBHeM nOXona nOn)l(Hhl BnnOTHYIO

3aH5IThC5I peweHHeM 3allalf KOTophle CTaBHT nepell

HHMH npOnOn)l(aIOIUa5lC5I 6ellHOCTh HellOellaHHe

BhICOKa51 pO)l(llaeMOCTh H nnoxoe 3nOpOBhe

HaCeneHH5I HeynoBneTBopHTenhHa51 pa60Ta

CHCTeMhI 3npaBooxpaHeHH5I HenOCTaTOlfHhIM

HiHnH HeYCTOMlfHBhlM ypOBeHh cpHHaHCHpOBaHH5I

BeAHOCTh HeAoeAaHlfe BhlCOKaH pO)KAaeMOCTh If IInoxoe 3AopOBhe

COfnaCHO oueHKaM BceMHpHOfO baHKa

nOlfTH lfeTBepTh MHPOBOfO HaCeneHH5I -- 13 Mnpn

lfenOBeK - npO)l(HBaeT B a6cOnIOTHOM HHlUeTe

3apa6aThIBa51 MeHee 1 nonnClllA B neHh B

L1oKnane 0 MHpOBOM pa3BHTHH Bmiddot 1993 f

HHBeCTHUHH B 3npaBooxpaHeHHe npHBeneHhl

HeKOTophIe paClfeThI KacaIOIUHeC5I yTpaThI

3nopOBhIX neT )l(H3HH OT 60nee 100 60ne3HeM H

TpaBM 93 MHPOBOfO 6peMeHH 3a60neBaHHM

npHXOnHTC5I Ha cTpaHhI C HH3KHM H CpellHHM

ypoBHeM noxona B TOM lfHcne nOlfTH 60 - Ha

KHTaM HHnHIO UeHTpanhHYIO H IO)I(HYIO

AcpPHKY

L1aBHHMH BparaMH 6enHeMWerO

HaCeneHH5I MHpa 51Bn5lIOTC5I HenoenaHHe neTCKHe

HHcpeKUHoHHhIe 3a60neBaHH5I nnoxoe 3nopoBhe Y

6epeMeHHhIx )l(eHIUHH H KOPM5IIUHX MaTepeM H

BhICOKa51 pO)l(naeMOCTh (cMKapTY B npHnO)l(eHHH

G no HenoenaHHIO cpenH neTeM) E)I(efOnHO B

MHpe pefHcTpHpyeTC5I 2 MnH cnYlfaeB neTCKOM

cMepTHocTH OT 60ne3HeM KOTophIe MO)l(HO

npenoTBpaTHTh BaKUHHaUHeM 200 MnH neTeM B

B03paCTe no n5ITH neT CTpanaIOT OT HenOenaHH5I H

aHeMHH 75 MnH neTeM yMHpaIOT e)l(efOnHO npH

pO)l(neHHH B OCHOBHOM H3-3a nnOXOfO COCT05lHH5I

3nOpOBh51 MaTepH H 30 MHPOBOfO HaCeneHH5I He

HMeIOT 6e30naCHhiX HCTOlfHHKOB BonhI H

KaHanH3aUHH 120 MnH CeMeM He HMeIOT

B03MO)l(HOCTH nnaHHpOBaTh ceMhIO H He nonYlfaIOT

ynoBneTBopHTenhHOfO 06cnY)I(HBaHH5I no oxpaHe

MaTepHHCTBa B CB5I3H C 3THM naTanOfHH

BhI3BaHHhIe 6epeMeHHOCThIO npHBOn5IT K CMepTH

OnHOM H3 Ka)l(nhlX 48 )l(eHIUHH (585000 CMepTeM B

fon) B cTpaHax C HH3KHM H cpenHHM ypoBHeM

noxona no cpaBHeHHIO C OnHOM Ha Ka)l(nhIe 4000 )l(eHIUHH B CTpaHax C BhICOKHM ypoBHeM noxona

HenocTaTolfHoe nHTaHHe neTeM B

YTp06HOM H paHHeM B03pacTe HeXBaTKa

MHKponHTaTenhHhlx BeweCTB ()I(ene3a Mona) HnH

HHlgteKUHH (llHapCSl MaI1SIpHSI) lfaCTO npHBOllSlT K

llI1HTeI1hHOM HnH He06paTHMOM OTCTanOCTH B

cpH3HlfecKoM H YMcTBeHHoM pa3BHTHH 3TO

oc06eHHo T5I)I(enO CKa3hIBaeTC5I Ha 6enHeMWHX

cn05lx HaCeneHH5I lfhH neTH B3pOCne51 H

CTaHOB5ICh lfaCThIO pa60lfeM CHnhI npOnOn)l(aIOT

HcnhIThIBaTh Ha ce6e 6peM5I np06neM HMeIOll(HX

KOpHH B neTCTBe

bhlCTPhlH POCT HaCeneHH5I TaK)I(e

OCnO)l(H5IeT pa3BHTHe MHOfHX 6enHhiX CTpaH H

nO)l(HTC5I T5I)I(enOM HOWeM Ha CHCTeMY

3npaBooxpaHeHH5I H COUHanhHhIX ycnyr L1a)l(e

Korna ypOBHH pO)l(naeMOCTH nOCTHraIOT ypOBH5I

BocnpoH3BonCTBa HaCeneHH5I (npHMepHO nBa

pe6eHKa Ha ceMhIO) pO)l(naeMOCTh 6yneT no

3

--

npe)fHeMY Onepe)faTh CMepTHOCTh BBHlIY

B03paCTHmi CTPYKTYPhl HaCeneHH5l Bhl3BaHHOH

npelIhllIYIUHMH BhlCOKHMH ypOBH5lMH

pO)flIaeMOCTH MHpOBOe HaCeneHHe MO)feT

BhlpaCTH C 53 MnplI lJenOBeK B 1990 r lIO 10 MnplI

lJenOBeK B 2100 rolIY HaHfionhmHH npHpocT

HaCeneHH5l O)fHlIaeTC5l B fielIHhlX cTpaHax

no Mepe CHH)feHH5l ypOBHeH pO)flIaeMOCTH

H CMepTHOCTH CTpYKTypa 3afioneBaHHH

xapaKTepHa5l lIn5l npomnoro BeKa npeTepneBaeT

onpelIeneHHhle H3MeHeHH5l TaK HanpHMep lIon5l HeHHtPeKUHOHHhlX 3afioneBaHHH (ceplIelJHO-

COCYl]HCThle HepBHO-nCHXHlJeCKHe

OHKOnOrHlJeCKHe 3afioneBaHH5l) BhlpaCTeT B MHpe C

36 B 1990 r lIO 57 B 2020 r a lIon5l HHtPeKUHOHHhlX 3afioneBaHHH naTonorHH

fiepeMeHHocTH H nepHHaTanhHhlx npofineM

CHH3HTC5l C 49 lIO 22 HOBhle 3nHlIeMHH a

TaK)fe n05lBneHHe MHKpofioB H napa3HToB

cnocofiHhlX npoTHBOCT05lTh neKapcTBaM fiYlIeT

CT05lTh Ha nepBoM MeCTe B p5llIY HHtPeKUHOHHhlX

3afioneBaHHH (CM KapTY B npHnO)feHHH G no

reorpatPHlJeCKoMY pacnpelIeneHHIO cnYlJaeB

Man5lpHH H 3atPHKcHpoBaHHhix pe3HcTeHTHhix

cnYlJaeB K nelJeHHIO CTaHlIapTHhlMH npenapaTaMH)

HeY~OBneTBopHTenbHa5l paOOTa MHorHX

CHCTeM 3~paBooxpaHeHH5l

)ln5l nonHoro nOHHMaHH5l tPaKToPOB

BnHgtIIOIUHX Ha CHCTeMhl 3lIpaBOOXpaHeHH5l

Tpe6yeTcR npoBeaeHHe ropa3ao 60nhwero lJHCna

HCCnelIOBaHHH Pa3nHlJHe nOKa3aTeneH 3lIOPOBh5l

nHTaHH5l H HapOlIOHaCeneHH5l (CMPHC13) B

cTpaHax HMelOIUHX CXOlIHhle ypoBHH lIOXOlIOB

MO)feT OTlJaCTH 5lBn5lThC5l pe3YnhTaTOM pa3nHlJHH

B 3tlJtPeKTHBHOCTH ofiIUeH cOUHanhHOH nonHTHKH H

CHCTeMhl 3lIpaBOOXpaHeHH5l OlJeBHlIHO lJTO

CTapeHHe HaCeneHH5l H POCT HeHHtPeKUHOHHhlX

3afioneBaHHH xapaKTepa B CTpaHax C HH3KHM H

CpelIHHM ypoBHeM lIoxolIa BnHgtIIOT Ha

npOH3BOlIHTenhHOCTh TpYlIa 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH

POCT H 3aTpaThi Ha CHCTeMY 3lIpaBOOXpaHeHH5l

KOTOpa5l lIOn)fHa alIanTHpOBaThC5l K HOBhlM BHlIaM

3afioneBaHHH H nelJeHH5l

4

nOKa3aTenH B c4lepe 3nH npH CXOAHblX ypOBHRX

AOXOAOB_0 -bO00ampamput~1It II~ --405

po~ cooopTlIOCTlo ~Ao5WT

KOAeTat ita Kon-eo ClllPTeM NA ICO~ npouMT C GAMY 100 000 OOOMTeM_

tteAOCT8TOtHaI ~AHWX~bHfIO ~PKTlt5

MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800

CpeAHHl ypoBHH AOXODll (AOIVLCWAI AYWY

pHc13 H8C8IIeHMRlroA)

Pa3nHlJH5l B )fHnHIllHhIX ycnOBH5lX B

lIOcTyne K lJHCTOH BOlIe H YlIOBneTBopHTenhHoH

CHCTeMe KaHanH3aUHH B ypOBHe ofipa30BaHH5l B

pacnpelIeneHHH lIOXOlIOB H B KynhTypHhlX

acneKTax BnHgtIIOT Ha BapHaTHBHOCTh 3THX

nOKa3aTeneH B ocofieHHOCTH B CTpaHax C HH3KHM

lIOXOlIOM BMeCTe C TeM TaKHe tPaKTOPhl KaK

3tPtPeKTHBHoe Hcnonh30BaHHe 3HaHHH H

HHtPopMaUHH 0 lIeTepMHHaHTax nnoxoro 3lIOPOBh5l

(HanpHMep 0 CB5l3H Me)flIY nHTaHHeM MaTepeH H

HH3KHM ypOBHeM Beca MJ1alIeHueB rHrHeHOH H

HHtPeKUH5lMH KypeHHeM H CeplIelJHhlMH

3afioneBaHH5lMH) H npOBelIeHHe HallJle)faIUHX

nelJefiHO-np0tPHnaKTHlJeCKHX MepOnpH5lTHH

(HanpHMep npHBHBKH perHlIpaUHOHHa5l TepanH5l

rHHeKOnOrHlJeCKHe ycnyrH MelIHKaMeHT03Hoe

nelJeHHe TyfiepKyne3a) TaK)fe HrpaIOT Ba)fHYIO

ponh B OfibRCHeHHH BapHaTHBHOCTH 3THX

nOKa3aTeneH

HepaBHOMepHOCTb ypOBHeH qHHaHCHpOBaHH5l

B 1994 r MHpoBhle paCXOAhI Ha

3lIpaBooxpaHeHHe COCTaBHnH OKono 2 330 MJ1plI

lIonnClllA (9 MHPOBoro BBIT) npeBpaTHB 3Ty

oTpacnh B OlIHH H3 KpynHeHllJHX ceKTopoB

MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH XOT5l Ha cTpaHhl C HH3KHM H

CpelIHHM ypoBHeM lIOXOlIa npHXOlIHTC5l Bcero

OKono 18 MHpOBOrO lIOXOlIa H 11 paCXOlIOB Ha

3lIpasooxpaHeHHe B MHpe (250 MJ1plI lIonn ClllA

HnH 4 BBIT pa3BHBaIOIUHXC5l CTpaH) HMeHHO B

3THX cTpaHax npO)fHBaeT 84 MHPOBOro

HaCeneHH5l Ha KOTophle npHXOlIHTC5l 93

ofiIUeMHpoBoro fipeMeHH 3afioneBaHHH CaM

pa3Mep OTpacnH H TOT tPaKT lITO POCT paCXOlIOB Ha

3lIpaBOOXpaHeHHe npeBhlmaeT POCT lIOXOlIOB

rOBOp5IT 0 Heo6xonHMOCTH YnemlTb oco6oe

BHHMaHHe rJ1y6oKOMY nOHHMaHHIO

3KOHOMHIeCKHX H MenHUHHCKHX nOCJ1enCTBHH

nOJ1HTHKH B 06J1aCTH cpHHaHCHpOBaHHjJ

3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ

3npaBooxpaHeHHe nono6HO 6J1araM

Bblcillero nopjJnKa (B 3KOHOMHIeCKOH

TepMHH0J10rHH) B 6enHbIX CTpaHax pacxonbl Ha

3npaBooxpaHeHHe KaK B npOueHTHOM OTHOllleHHH

K BBI1 TaK H Ha nYlllY HaCeJ1eHHjJ MeHbllle IeM B

60raThIX CTpaHax (CMPHC14) TaK)I(e C POCTOM

ypOBHjJ noxona paCTYT rocynapCTBeHHble pacxonbI

Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe KaK B a6C0J1IOTHOM TaK H B

OTHOCHTeJ1bHOM HCIHCJ1eHHH )TO OTpa)l(aeTCjJ B

60J1hIllHX pa3J1HIHjJX B nOJ1e HaUHOHaIlhHOrO BBI1

pacxonyeMoH CTpaHaMH Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe - OT

1 B HeKoTopbIX cTpaHax no 15 B CIIIA B

HeKoTopblX cTpaHax nonYIlleBhle pacxoJlhI Ha

3npaBooxpaHeHHe (KaK rocynapcTBeHHble pacxonhI

TaK H pacxonbl HaCeJ1eHHjJ) pa3J1HIaIOTcjJ nOITH B

1000 pa3- OT 3 no 5 nOJ1J1 CIIIA Ha nyllly

HaCeJ1eHHjJ B CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM noxona

KaK MaIlH no 3600 nOJ1J1 B CIIIA (CooTHoIlleHHe

paBHjJeTcjJ 225 npH HCn0J1h30BaHHH nOJ1J1apOB C

nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)

lPcoD C1jBIlI iii 3aTpSTb1 til 3J1PHXlXJD1He 13~--------------------

11 aoqo7odhal3ll1plT _ 9 l

1111 7

5

3

00

70

~ rayHiflC1lli1oIt 3II1pIT 50 ~

dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000

pc1A fBllIIlyenlyen taW1fHI (retltAIPYl 19q

CTpaHhI UeHTpaIlhHOH H IO)I(HOH ACPPHKH

IO)I(HOH H BOCTOIHOH A3HH H THXOOKeaHcKoro

6aCCeHHa TpaTSIT MeHhille BCeX Ha

3npaBOOXpaHeHHe B a6C0J1IOTHOM HCIHCJ1eHHH

(CMKapTY no PacxonaM Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe B

I1pHJ10)l(eHHH G) A B HeKoTopblX cTpaHax

npoHcxonHT cOKpallleHHe pacxonoB Ha

3npaBooxpaHeHHe Hecnoco6HoCTb o6eCneIHTb

co6HpaeMocTb HaIlOrOB H HH3KHe J1HIHble noxonbl

HaCeJ1eHHjJ cnoco6cTBYIOT TaKHM TeHneHUHjJM

HexBaTKa cpHHaHcHpoBaHHjJ 06blIHO npHBonHT K

HH3KOMY ypOBHIO HaKOnJ1eHHjJ KanHTaIlbHblX

cpoHnoB TaKHX KaK 60J1bHHIHble KOHKH H K

HeXBaTKe MenHUHHCKoro nepCOHaIla BKJ1IOIajJ

BpaIeH H MencecTep Da)l(e eCJ1H B ueJ10M B cTpaHe

HMeIOTCjJ nOCTaTOIHble KanHTaIlbHble cpoHnbl

nocTyn 6enHbix CJ10eB HaCeJ1eHHjJ K

MenHuHHcKOMY 06CJ1Y)l(HBaHHIO MO)l(eT

OCTaBaTbCjJ OrpaHHIeHHbIM H3-3a HepaBHoro

pacnpeneJ1eHHjJ pecypcoB ITO HMeeT MeCTO B

perHOHe EJ1H)I(HerO BOCTOKa H CeBepHOH ACPPHKH

B nOCJ1enHee BpeMjJ Bce 60J1hlllee IHCJ10

CTpaH CTaIlKHBaeTCjJ C np06J1eMOH 6blCTporo pOCTa

3aTpaT Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe B rocynapCTBeHHOM H

IaCTHOM ceKTope HeKOTophle CTpaHbl nOBbICHJ1H

pacxonbI C 3-5 BBI1 no 8-10 BBI1 3a nepHon B

HeCKOJ1hKO J1eT ApreHTHHa Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe

TpaTHT 60J1bllIYIO nOJ1IO BBI1 qeM KaHana

KOTopajJ Ha npOTjJ)I(eHHH MHorHX J1eT YCTynaIla

J1Hlllh CIIIA YacTo pa3MephI rocynapcTBeHHoro

cpHHaHCHpOBaHHjJ npeBbIIllaIOT CPHCKaIlhHO

pa3YMHble ypOBHH npH 3TOM 60J1hlllHe 06neMhI

nOnOJ1HHTeJ1hHhIX CpenCTB MoryT HanpaBJ151TbcjJ

Ha He3cpcpeKTHBHhle H nJ10XO opraHH30BaHHhle

yCJ1yrH HH3Koro KaIeCTBa PacTYlllHe 3aTpaThI Ha

3npaBOOXpaHeHHe caMH no ce6e He 06jJ3aTeJ1hHO

cnoco6CTBYIOT nporpeccy B 06J1aCTH 3I1H Bo

MHorHX CJ1YIajJx JlJ1jJ Toro IT06bl y J1yIIllHTb

nOKa3aTeJ1H 3nopOBhjJ Heo6xonHMO npe)l(ne Bcero

ynenHTb BHHMaHHe nOLlXonaM CBjJ3aHHhiM C

IllHpOKHM KpyroM neMorpacpHIeCKHX BonpocOB H

MepOnpH5ITHjJM B 06J1aCTH 06IUeCTBeHHoro

3nopOBhjJ

I1pHIHHaMH pOCTa 3aTpaT Ha

3npaBOOXpaHeHHe jJBJ1jJIQTCjJ pe3Koe nOBbIllleHHe

CTOHMOCTH HOBOH MenHUHHCKOH TeXH0J10rHH

3nHneMHOnOrHIeCKHe H3MeHeHHjJ B CTpyKType

3a6oJ1eBaHHH (POCT XpOHHIeCKHX H nOjJBJ1eHHe

HOBhIX HHcpeKUHOHHhlX 3a6oJ1eBaHHH) paCTYIUHe

3anpOChI HaCeJ1eHHjJ H nOjJBJ1eHHe nJ1aTHOH

MenHUHHhI H MenHUHHCKoro CTpaXOBaHHjJ npH

yqaCTHH TpeTheH CTOPOHbi

5

C Y4eTOM rOnOBOrO pOCTa MHpOBoro BBO (35) H HMeIOruHXC~ TeMnOB pOCTa nonyrueBoro noxona 3aTpaTbi Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe fiynYT yBenH-IHBaTbC~ e)KerOnHO Ha 82 Mnpn nonn CIlIA no BceMY MHpy H B TOM l-IHcne Ha 9 Mnpn nonn CIlIA B cTpaHax C HH3KHM H cpenHHM ypoBHeM noxona B npHHUHne 3THX cpencTB nOCTaT04HO nn~ ofiecne4eHH~ OCHOBHblMH ne4efiHo-npOilmnaKTH4ecKHMH ycnyraMH 900 MnH4enOBeK H3 13 Mflpn fienHeHlllero HaceneHH~ MHpa He HMeIOruero nOCTyna K TaKHM ycnyraM OnHaKO ecnH ceronH~lllHHe TeHneHUHH fiynyT npOnOn)KaTbC~ 3Ha4HTenbHa~ 4aCTb 3THX pecypcoB nOHneT TeM KTO Y)Ke HMeeT nocTyn H nonb3yeTc~ 3THMH ycnyraMH a He fienHblM cnO~M HaceneHH~

OCHOBHhle HanpaBneHHH nOnHTHKH

OCHOBHble yrp03bl xopOllleMY 3nopOBbIO nHTaHHIO H HaponOHaceneHHIO XOPOlllO H3BeCTHbl H 3a4aCTYIO npHeMneMble pellleHH~ Y)Ke HMeIOTC~ OnHaKO BBHny HecnocofiHOCTH npaBHTenbCTB ocyruecTBn~b HeofixonHMble

20 BBO) H opraHH3aUHoHHblH nOTeHUHan rocynapcTBeHHoro ceKTopa cnafi cpHHaHcHpoBaHHe H OKa3aHHe ycnyr B ofinacTH 30H B uenOM nO)KHTC~ Ha 4acTHblH ceKTop Bo MHorHX cTpaHax fionblllHe rpynnbl fienHoro HaceneHH~ no CHX nop He HMeIOT nocTyna K fia30BOMY MenHUHHCKOMY oficnY)KHBaHHIO HnH 31PIPeKTHBHbiM BHnaM ne4eHH~ no uenOMY p~ny npH4HH H3naraeMbiX HH)Ke

B fionblllHHCTBe pa3BHTbiX CTpaH H BO MHorHX CTpaHax co cpenHHM ypOBHeM noxona rocynapcTBO CTaJIO HrpaTb ueHTpaJIbHYIO ponb B COUHanbHOH nonHTHKe H 3npaBooxpaHeHHH Y4aCTHe rocynapcTBeHHoro ceKTopa onpaBnaHO H TeopeTH4eCKH H npaKTH4eCKH H HanpaBneHO Ha nOBblllleHHe (a) CnpaBeJ1JlHBOrO pacnpeJ1eJleHHSI nYTeM npenOCTaBneHH~

HaceneHHIO nOCTyna K ycnyraM B ofinaCTH 30H H (fi) 3centgtfjleKTHBHOCTH nYTeM HcnpaBneHH~

npOBaJIOB pblHKa B ocofieHHOCTH B cny4ae fionblUHX BHelllHHX 31PIPeKTOB (ofirueCTBeHHoe finaro) HnH cepbe3HbiX HHlPopMaUHOHHblX aCHMMeTpHH (MenHUHHCKoe CTpaXOBaHHe)

neHCTBH~ a TaK)Ke HeCOCTo~enbHOCTH pblHKa B 4aCTHOM ceKTope (ocofieHHO B OTHOllleHHH BonpOCOB ofiruecTBeHHoro finara H MeponpH~THH HMeIOIllHX 3Ha4HTenbHblH BHelllHHH 31PIPeKT) peKoMeHnyeMble CTpaTerHH 4aCTO He MoryT nOM04b fienHblM cnO~M HaceneHH~ He npHBon~ K yny4llleHHIO CHCTeMbl 3npaBOOXpaHeHH~ H He nonY4aIOT nOCTO~HHoro cpHHaHCHpOBaHH~ B naHHoM pa3nene H3naraIOTC~ OCHoBHble npHHUHnbl n03Bon~IOlllHe npOaHaJIH3HpOBaTb npOH30lUenlllHe H3MeHeHH~ B ponH rocynapcTBa H peIPOPMbI npOBonHMble MHorHMH CTpaHaMH B ofinaCTH 30H

MeHSIIOll(HeCSI POJIH rOCYJ1apCTBeHHoro H qaCTHOroceKTopOB

Ha npOT~)KeHHH BceH MHPOBOH HCTOpHH nIOnH nonb30BanHCb nOMalllHHMH neKapCTBaMH H ycnyraMH 4aCTHbiX Bpa4eH H npyrHx MenHUHHCKHX pafiOTHHKOB ne4HnHCb B 4aCTHbiX fionbHHuax YaCTO TonbKO fiora4H MornH n03BonHTb cefie

TaKoe oficnY)KHBaHHe npH 3TOM Hafiop 31PIPeKTHBHbiX ycnyr fibln OrpaHHleH CeronH~ B CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM nOXonb- r ne fiIOJl)KeTHble nocTynneHH~ HeBenHKH (4aCTO MeHee

OnHHM H3 HaHfionee CHnbHbIX aprYMeHTOB B nonb3Y lllHpOKoro y4acTH~ rocynapCTBa B ofinaCTH 30H HBn~eTC~ HeofixonHMOCTb B npOBeneHHH MeponpH~HH HMeIOruHx fionblllOH BHelllHHH 31PIPeKT (Bbironbi nn~ ofiruecTBa npeBbIlllaIOT CyMMy Bbironbi nn~ OTnenbHblX nHU) TaKHMH MeponpH~H~MH ~Bn~TC~ ofiecne4eHHe 4HCTOH BonOH ycnyraMH KaHaJIH3aUHH BeKTopHbIM KOHTpOneM MepbI no ofiecne4eHHIO fie30naCHOCTH nponOBonbCTBeHHblx TosapOB H p~n MenHUHHCKHX ycnyr (BaKUHHaUH~ nnaHHpOBaHHe ceMbH noponOBble H nocneponOBble ycnyrH fiopbfia C HHcpeKUHOHHbIMH 6one3H~MH

KypeHHeM anKoronH3MOM H HapKOMaHHeH) MenHUHHCKoe ofiY4eHHe H HccnenOBaHH~

~Bn~IOTC~ nsyM~ npyrHMH ofinaCT~MH rne B03MO)KHO aKTHBHoe Y4aCTHe rocynapCTBa

YaCTHoe nofipOBonbHoe MenHUHHCKoe CTpaxOBaHHe ~Bn~eTC~ ofinaCTbIO KOTopa~

ocofieHHO nOnBep)KeHa BnH~HHIO HenOCTaTKoB

pbIHKa MHorHe H3 KOTOPbIX CB~3aHbI

HHIPOpMaUHOHHOH aCHMMeTpHeH XOT~

CTpaxOBaHHe MO)KeT 3aruHTHTb HeKOTopbIX nHU OT OTnenbHbIX PHCKOB OHO He MO)KeT OXBaTHTb Bcex

6

C

)l(enalOIUHX 3aCTpaXOBaThCR H lJaCTO HCKlllOlJaeT

TeX KTO 60nbllle BCerO HY)l(aaeTCR B CTpaXOBaHHH

HnH HMeeT 60nee BhICOKHH PHCK 3a60neBaeMOCTH

)TO CBR3aHO C TeM lJTO CTpaXOBbIe KOMnaHHH

xonrr CTpaXOBaTh TOnhKO 3aOpOBhIX nlOaeH HnH

nlOaeH lJhe nelJeHHe He CTOHT cnHlllKOM aoporo

(TH OT60p pHCKa HnH CHHMaHHe cnHBOK)

qacTHhIe CTpaXOBhIe KOMnaHHH TaK)I(e CTpeM5ITCR

HCKnlOlJHTb aOporOCTORIUee nelJeHHe HnH CBeCTH

ao MHHHMyMa CBOH JgtHHaHCOBhIH PHCK nYTeM

OrpaHHlJeHH5I MaKCHManbHbIX pa3MepOB BbmnaT H

MHOrOlJHCneHHhIMH HCKnlOlJeHHRMH )TO

ocna6n5leT 3aIUHIUeHHOCTb OT HaH60nee

aOpOrOCT05lIUHX H TR)I(enbIX 3a60neBaHHH

TaK HanpHMep Te KTO Y)l(e 3HaeT 06

HMelOIUHXCR y HHX JgtaKTopax pHcKa TOro HnH

HHoro 3a60neBaHHR cTapalOTC5I BceMH cpeacTBaMH

CKphlTb CBoe JgtH3HlJeCKOe COCTORHHe (TH

HeraTHBHbIH oT60p) 3aopoBhIe nlOaH (HnH

GlJHTalOIUHe ce6R TaKoBhIMH) lJaCTO cTapalOTC5I

nnaTHTb KaK MO)l(HO 60nee HH3KHe cTpaxoBhIe

B3HOCbI )TO He n03BonReT CTpaXOBbIM

KOMnaHHRM c06paTb aOCTaTOlJHO cpeaCTB anR nOKpbITHR MeaHUHHCKHX paCXOaoB 3a60neBlllHX

HnH 60nhlllero KOnHlJeCTBa nHU H3 rpynnhI pHCKa

Eonee Toro 3aopOBhIH lJenOBeK MO)l(eT

C03HaTenbHO HeaOCTpaXOBaTh ce651 B Haae)l(ae Ha

6ecnnaTHoe nelJeHHe HnH nelJeHHe nOKpblBaeMoe

aOTaUHRMH B cnylJae 3a60neBaHHR (JgteHOMeH

6ecnnaTHoro npoe3aa) Koraa CTpaXOBKa

BhmnalHBaeTC5I TpeTheH CTOPOHOH

(pa60ToaaTeneM) HH 3aCTpaXOBaHHoe nHUO HH

MeaHUHHCKHe pa60THHKH He 3aHHTepeCOBaHhI B

CHH)I(eHHH pacxoaOB npH 3TOM HeKOTophIe nHua

MoryT H BOBce nepecTaTh 06paIUaTb BHHMaHHe Ha

rmllQep)l(aHHe CBoero 3aopOBhR )TO npHBO[IHT He

TonbKO K 60nbllleMY KOnHlJeCTBY Hcnonh3yeMoro

neleHHR (npHlHHa npH06peTeHHR CTpaXOBKH) HO

H MeHee 3JgtJgteKTHBHOMY nelJeHHIO HnH neleHHIO

KOTopoe 6hI He nOTpe6oBanOCh ecnH 6bI Bce

3a6oTHnHCb 0 CBoeM 3aopOBbe (JgteHOMeH

MopanhHoro pHCKa)

nOMHMO npOBanOB pbIHKa B 06naCTH

CTpaXOBaHHR HaceneHHIO TaK)I(e npHxoaHTCR

MHPHTbCR H C TeM lJTO npOH3BoaHTenH

MeaHUHHCKHX ycnyr 6epYT MaKCHManbHO

B03MO)l(HYlO B PbIHOlJHhIX ycnoBHRX nnaTy npH

OTCYTCTBHH perynHpoBaHHR H CHCTeMbI KOHTponR

KalJeCTBa naUHeHThI MoryT nOTpaTHTb

3HalJHTenhHYlO CyMMy nHlJHOrO aoxoaa Ha

He3JgtJgteKTHBHoe nelJeHHe EeaHbIe H MeHee

06pa30BaHHhIe rpynnhI HaceneHHR oc06eHHO lJaCTO

CTaHOB5ITCR )l(epTBOH norOHH lJaCTHhIX MeaHKOB 3a

npH6hInhIO BBHay HHJgtopMaUHOHHbIX aCHMMeTpHH

OCHOBHhIMH MepaMH npeanpHHHMaeMhIMH

rocyaapcTBOM no HcnpaBneHHIO npOBanOB pbIHKa

RBn5llOTCR (B nOp5laKe CTeneHH B03paCTaHH5I

YlaCTHR rocyaapCTBa) npeaOCTaBneHHe

HHJgtopMaUHH C uenblO H3MeHeHHR nOBeaeHH5I Bcex

YlJaCTHHKOB H aonrOCpOlJHOrO nporpecca B 06naCTH

3nH KOHTponb 3a BhmonHeHHeM nOnO)l(eHHH H

CHCTeMa cTHMynoB B03aeHCTBYlOwa51 Ha

ae5lTenhHOCTb rocyaapcTBeHHoro H lJaCTHoro

ceKTopa BbIaala MaHaaTOB Ha HenpRMoe

JgtHHaHCHpOBaHHe HnH OKa3aHHe ycnyr

JgtHHaHCHpOBaHHe HnH npeaOCTaBneHHe aOTaUHH

Ha onnaTY ycnyr HnH B03aeHCTBHe Ha ueHhI

HenocpeaCTBeHHoe npeaOCTaBneHHe rocyaapCTBoM

nele6HO-npoJgtHnaKTHleCKHX ycnyr

H 3KOHOMHleCKHe H 3MnHpHleCKHe

aaHHble nOKa3bIBa1OT ITO COleTaHHe YlaCTHR

rocyaapcTBeHHoro H laCTHOro ceKTopOB npHBOaHT

K HaHnyllllHM pe3ynbTaTaM B OTpacnH 3nH 06a

ceKTopa He 3JgtJgteKTHBHbI no OTaenhHOCTH H

HY)l(aaIOTC5I apyr B apyre H3nHlllHee HnH

HeaOCTaTOlJHOe YlJaCTHe oaHoro H3 ceKTopOB laCTO

npHBoaHT K B03HHKHOBeHHIO npo6neM

K CO)l(aneHHIO Hecnoc06HOCTh MHorHX

CTpaH C HH3KHM H cpeaHHM ypOBHeM aoxoaa

3JgtJgteKTHBHO pelllaTb aaMHHHCTpaTHBHhIe

npo6neMbI CB5I3aHHbIe C laCTHbIM ceKTopOM

laCTO npHBOaHT K H3nHlllHeMY BMewaTenbCTBY

rocyaapcTBa B HenocpeaCTBeHHoe OKa3aHHe

MeaHUHHCKHX ycnyr TaKoe H3nHlllHee

BMelllaTenhCTBO B npeaOCTaBneHHe MeaHUHHCKoro

06cnY)l(HBaHHR 06bIlJHO CBR3aHO C HeaOCTaTOlHbIM

YlaCTHeM rocyaapcTBa B npeaOCTaBneHHH

HHJgtopMaUHH 0 nHlHOH rHrHeHe 0 3aopOBOM

06pa3e )l(H3HH H npaBHnbHOM Hcnonb30BaHHH

MeaHuHHCKHX ycnyr a TaK)I(e B perynHpoBaHHH

laCTHOro ceKTopa JgtHHaHCHpOBaHHH Ba)l(HeHWHX

ycnyr 3apaBooxpaHeHH5I oc06eHHO an51 6eaHoro

HaceneHHR H B 06eCneleHHH aocTyna K

06weCTBeHHbIM 6naraM HMelOIUHM 3HalJHTenhHhIH

BHelllHHH 3JgtJgteKT 3aTparHBalOIUHH Bce HaceneHHe

[ln51 aOCTH)I(eHH5I onTHManhHoro COleTaHHR

7

YlJaCTHR rOCYJlapCTBeHHOrO H lJaCTHOrO CeKfOpOB B

CTpaHaX C pa3nHlJHhiM ypOBHeM JlOXOJla Tpe6YIOTCR

pa3nHlJHhie pecpOpMhl B ccpepe npeJlOCTaBneHHR

ycnyr H B 06naCTH cpHHaHCHpOBaHHR

3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHR HH)Ke 3TH pecpOpMhl

o6CY)KJlaIOTCR 60nee nOJlp06HO

COBpeMeHHbIe HanpaBJIeHHH pelJopM

HeYJlOBneTBopeHHOCTh pe3ynhTaTaMH B

06naCTH 3nH HH3KHM KalJeCTBOM

rocyJlapCTBeHHoro H lJaCTHOro 3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHR

H OTCYTCTBHeM YCTOHlJHBOrO cpHHaHCHpOBaHHR

HHnH POCTOM CTOHMOCTH npHBena K BonHe

pecpopM npOKaTHBweHCR no BceMY MHPY (CM

npHnO)KeHHH A)

YnYlJWeHHe pe3ynhTaToB 3nH JlflR 6eJlHOrO

HaceneHHR

no JlaHHhlM BceMHpHoro EaHKa 60nhwaR

lJaCTh 13 MI1PJl nIOJleH npo3R6aIOIUHx B

a6conIOTHoH HHIUeTe npH JlOXOJlax MeHee 1 JlonnCIliA B JleHh npO)KHBaeT B cTpaHax rJle

BeChMa OrpaHHlJeH JlOCTyn K 6e30nacHhiM

HCTOlJHHKaM nHTheBOH BOJlhl H CHCTeMe

KaHaflH3aUHH nonHoueHHOMY nHTaHHIO

3neMeHTapHhiM ycnoBHRM )KHnhR HalJaflhHoMY

o6pa30BaHHIO CpeJlCTBaM nnaHHpoBaHHR ceMhH H

OCHOBHhlM MeJlHUHHCKHM ycnyraM

B 6eJlHhiX CTpaHax a6conIOTHhiM

npHopHTeToM RBnReTCR pa3pa6oTKa cTpaTerHH H

nporpaMM o6eCnelJHBaIOIUHx JlOCTyn K OCHOBHhlM

ycnyraM B o6nacTH 3nH lJepe3 rocYJlapCTBeHHhle

HnH lJaCTHhle KaHaflhI (CM npHnO)KeHHe B JlnR o6cY)KJleHHR HHHUHaTHBhl OOH no OCHOBHblM COijUaITbHblM YClTYlaM OIT5I Bcex H npHnO)KeHHe C JlnR 60nee JleTaflhHOrO onHcaHHR OTJlenhHhlX

Ba)KHeHWHX MeponpHRTHH OOH) Bo MHorHX

cnYlJaRX WHpoKoHanpaBneHHhle H ueneBhle

cTpaTerHH JlOn)KHhl npOBOJlHThCR OJlHOBpeMeHHo

illUpOKOHanpaBlTeHHble noOXoObl OnhlT

pa3BHThiX CTpaH H CTpaH co CpeJlHHM ypOBHeM

JlOXOJla COCTOHT B TOM lJTO Bceo6IUHH JlOcTyn K

MeJlHUHHCKHM ycnyraM RBnReTCR OJlHHM H3

HaH60nee 3cpcpeKTHBHhiX cnOC060B OKa3aHHR

MeJlHUHHCKOH nOMOIUH 6eJlHOMY HaCeneHHIO

OJlHaKO npH WHpOKOHanpaBneHHhlX nOJlXOJlaX

CYIUecTByeT onaCHOCTh He3cpcpeKTHBHoH TpaThl

CpeJlCTB HeKoTophle cTpaHhl C HH3KHM ypoBHeM

JlOXOJla TpaTRT nOlJTH 4 BBn Ha

npOJlOBOnhCTBeHHhle JlOTaUHH KOTophle

npaKTHlJeCKH He OTpa)KaIOTCR Ha nHTaHHH

6eJlHRKOB B CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM JlOXOJlOB

cpHHaHCOBhle OrpaHHlJeHHR BhIHY)KJlaIOT CBOJlHTh

WHpOKOHanpaBneHHhie nporpaMMhl K OlJeHh

OrpaHHlJeHHOMY Kpyry ycnyr B 06naCTH

06IUeCTBeHHoro 3JlOPOBhR H 060raIUeHHR nHIUH

nHTaTenhHhlMH Jl06aBKaMH H HeCKonhKHM

HaH60nee Heo6xoJlHMhiM BHJlaM MeJlHUHHCKoro

06cnY)KHBaHHR

AOpeCHble noOXoObl~ lJnR 06eCnelJeHHR

B03JleHCTBHR Ba)KHeHWHX nporpaMM Ha HaH60nee

HY)KJlaIOIUHeCR rpynnhl HaceneHHR Heo6xoJlHMO

Hcnonh30BaTh ueneHanpaBneHHhle nOJlXOJlhI

npHBeJleHHhle HH)Ke lJeThlpe nOJlXOJla oco6eHHO

Ba)KHhl JlnR OTpacnH 3nH B CTpaHax C HH3KHM H

CpeJlHHM ypOBHeM JlOXOJla

bull HanpaBlTeHUe YCUlTUU Ha 6eOHeUUlue ClTOU HaCeITeHU5I Hau6oITee nooBepJKeHHble 3a6oITeBaHU5IM cmpaoaO~ue om HeOOeOaHU5I U OIT5I KOmoPbU xapaKmepHa BbKOKa51 pOJKOaeMOCmb nYTeM npHMeHeHHR MeTOJlOB

npOBepKH HY)KJlaeMOCTH JlflR BhlRBneHHR

KpaHHe HY)KJlaIOIJlHXCR H OKa3aHHR

6ecnnaTHhiX HnH JlOTaUHOHHhlX ycnyr TonhKO

TeM KTO no pe3ynhTaTaM )TOH npOBepKH

nOnaJlaeT B COOTBeTCTBYIOIUYIO KaTeropHIO

nonYlJaTeneH TaKoro 06cnY)KHBaHHR B

60nhWHHCTBe CTpaH C HH3KHM ypOBHeM

JlOXOJla npHMeHeHHe TaKoro nOlXOJla B

KpynHoM MacllITa6e HeB03MO)KHO H3-3a

TpYJlHOCTeH aJlMHHHCTpaTHBHoro xapaKTepa

bull HanpaBlTeHUe YCUlTUU Ha 6eOHeUUlue paUOHbl cmpaHbl UlTU lpynnbl HaCeITeHU5I (HanpHMep

)KeHIUHHhl JleTH H 3THHlJeCKHe

MeHhWHHCTBa) EonhwaR lJaCTh 13 MI1PJl

6eJlHeHWero HaceneHHR MHpa npO)KHBaeT B

IO)KHOH A3HH UeHTpaflhHOH H IO)KHOH

ACPPHKe H B HeKoTophlX CTpaHax JlPyrHx

perHOHOB (CMnpHnO)KeHHe A no rpynnaM

CTpaH) Ha ypOBHe OTJlenhHhlX CTpaH ynop

MO)KeT 6hITh CJlenaH Ha perHoHhl rOpOJlCKHe

HnH cenhCKHe paHoHhl B KOTOPhlX npO)KHBaeT

6eJlHOe HaceneHHe HnH KOHKpeTHhle

8

nOlfpynnbI B 3THX pMIOHaX (HanpHMep

npOrpaMMbI nHTaHH5I lln51 MaTepeH H

ManeHbKHX lleTeH B OTCTanbIX paHOHaX)

bull BHUMaHue K np06leMaM KaCalOf1UMC5I

MeOUlUHCKOlO 06ClYJKUBaHU5I nUmaHU5I U

pOJKOaeMOCmU cpeou 6eOHbIX ClOeB HaCeleHU5I

3TOT nollXOll n03BOn5leT BeCTH 60Pb6y C

llaBHHMH BparaMH 6ellHOTbI - HellOellaHHeM

HHqeKUHOHHbIMH 3a60neBaHH5IMH lleTCKHMH

60ne3H5IMH BblCOKOH pO)l(llaeMOCTbIO H

MaTepHHCKHMH H nepHHaTanbHblMH

naTanOrH5IMH (CMpHC15) nOnbllle nOnOBHHbl

cnyqaeB 3a60neBaHHH B UeHTpanbHOH H

IO)I(HOH AqpHKe H B IO)I(HOH A3HH MoryT

6bITb 3qqeKTHBHO YCTpaHeHbl nYTeM

npOBelleHH5I OnpelleneHHblX MepOnpH5ITHH Ha

MeCTax BKnIOqa51 BaKUHHaUHIO

llOnOnHHTenbHOe nHTaHHe

ueneHanpaBneHHble npOrpaMMbI nHTaHH5I

HHTerpHpOBaHHOe neqeHHe lleTCKHX 60ne3HeH

nnaHHpoBaHHe CeMbH oxpaHy 3ll0POBb51

MaTepeH H MellHUHHCKOe 06eCneqeHHe lleTeH B

06IUe06pa30BaTenbHblx yqpe)l(lleHH5IX (CM

ilpHnO)l(eHHe C) ITo Mepe CTapeHH5I

HaCeneHH5I 6blCTPO paCTeT llOn51

HeHHqeKUHOHHbIX 3a60neBaHHH H TpaBM B

CTpyKType 3a60neBaeMOCTH HaCeneHH5I

nellHOe H MaJIOrpaMOTHOe HaCeneHHe

OC06eHHO Y5l3BHMO nepell B03lleHCTBHeM

HeraTHBHbIX nOCnellCTBHH MaCCOBOH npOlla)l(H

Ta6aqHbiX H3llenHH anKOrOn51 H He3ll0pOBOH

nHIUH

bull Hau6olbLUee BHUMaHue K KamelOpU51M

npOU3BoOUmeleU yCl)i om KOmopbIX 6eOHble

ipynnbl HaCeleHU5I noTylaem 60lbLUyO IaCmb

MeOUlUHCKUX y Clyi Un51 3Toro Re06xollHMO

paClllHp5ITb ycnyrH (roCYllapCTBeHHble H

qaCTHble) B 06naCTH 3ITH npellOCTaBn5leMbie

)l(HTen5lM rOp0llCKHX TPYIU06 H cenbCKHX

paHOHOB C HH3KOH nnOTHOCTbIO HaCeneHH5I H

nOBbIlllaTb HX KaqeCTBO ITO nOllpa3YMeBaeT

ynyqllleHHe cHa6)1(eHH5I paCXOllHblMH

MaTepHanaMH H MellHKaMeHTaMH

COBepllleHCTBOBaHHe ynpaBneHH5I H

nOBbIllleHHe KOMneTeHTHOCTH nepCOHana

3apa3Hbie 3a6oneBaHHA

OCHOBHaA npH-IHHa CMepTHOCTH cpeAH 6eAHbIX

cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S

ilOBblllleHHe KaqeCTBa ycnyr B 06naCTH 3ilH

B TeqeHHH nOCnellHHX 10 ReT MHorHe

60raTble H 6ellHble CTpaHbI MHpa nbITanHCb

Bblpa60TaTb 3qqeKTHBHYIO nonHTHKY H

nporpaMMY peqOPM no ynyqllleHHIO KaqeCTBa

rOCYllapCTBeHHblX H qaCTHbIX CHCTeM

3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I

PerJopMbl iocyoapCmBeHHOU cucmeMbl

Bonpoc nOBblllleHH5I 3qqeKTHBHOCTH

rOCYllapCTBeHHblX CHCTeM 3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I

Tpe6yeT llanbHeHlllero H3yqeHH5I

rOCYllapCTBeHHa51 CHCTeMa 3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I BO

MHorHX CTpaHax MHpa llOn)l(Ha 6bITb

peqopMHpOBaHa B CnellYIOIUHx HanpaBneHH5IX

bull 06eCneleHUe paBHOiO oocmyna K p5lllY neqe6HOshy

npoqHnaKTHqeCKHX ycnyr nYTeM (1) CHH)I(eHH5I reorpaqHqeCKHX qHHaHCOBbIX

KynbTypHblX H npyrHx 6apbepoB (2) MepOnpH5ITHH HanpaBneHHblx Ha 60Pb6y C

pacnpocTpaHeHHblMH 3a60neBaHH5IMH He

Tpe6yIOIUHMH llOporocT05lIUero neqeHH5I (3) MepOnpH5ITHH HanpaBneHHblx Ha 60Pb6y C

MeHee pacnpocTpaHeHHble 3a60neBaHH5I

KOTopble OllHaKO B 60nbllleH CTeneHH Bpell5lT

3ll0POBbIO H Tpe6yIOT 60nee llOporocT05lIUHX

Mep HO KOTopble Bce )l(e HaXOll5lTC5I B

npellenax qHHaHcoBbIX B03MO)l(HOCTeH CTpaHbl

bull IIOBblmeHUe 3rJrJeKmuBHocmu ucnolb30BaHU5I

CKYOHblX peCYPCOB nYTeM ynyqllleHH5I npouecca

npHH5ITH5I pellleHHH ynpaBneHH5I nOOIUpeHH5I

PbIHOqHblX CTHMynOB lleueHTpanH3aUHH H

yqeTa

9

bull nOBbUUeHUe 3centcenteKmUBHOCmU 60Pb6bl C norOHe 3a npH6hlnhIO rOTOB OKa3aTh XOT5I H

3a6oleBaHU5IMU Ha OCHOBe nOBbUUeHU5I npocenteCCUOHalU3Ma MeOUfUHCKUX U

ynpaBleHleCKUX KaOpOB B 06naCTH

COCTaBneHH5I 6a30BhlX Ha60pOB nelJe6HOshy

npoqmnaKTHlJeCKHX ycnyr BHeLlpeHH5I

31PIPeKTHBHhiX CXeM nelJeHH5I oT60pa HOBhlX

MeTOLlOB H TeXHOnOrHl1 nOLlrOTOBKH

lPapMaKOnOrHlJeCKHX CnpaBOlJHHKOB

OrpaHHlJeHHhlX OCHOBHhlMH neKapCTBeHHhlMH

CpeLlCTBaMH 06YlJeHH5I H nOLlrOTOBKH

nepCOHana H HCCneLlOBaTenhCKOH pa60Tbi no

31PIPeKTHBHOCTH H 3aTpaTHOCTH pa3nHlJHhiX

MepOnpH5ITHH

bull IIOBbuueHue KalecmBa MeOUfUHCKUX ycly

nYTeM BBeLleHH5I pa3nHlJHhiX cTHMynoB

LlononHHTenhHOH HHlPopMaUHH 06YlJeHH5I

KaLlpOB aKKpeLlHTaUHH (Lln51 pa60THHKOB H

opraHH3aUHH B 06naCTH 3ITH)

B3aHMOKOHTpOn5l npOBepOK H nOCT05lHHOrO

HaLl30pa

bull MaKCUMU3afU5I cmeneHU YOOBlemeOpeHHocmu

nompe6umeleu nOlYleHHblM 06ClYJl(UBaHueM

nYTeM C03LlaHH5I LlononHHTenhHhlX

B03MO)l(HOCTeH Lln51 caMOCT05lTenhHOro

Bhl60pa a TaK)I(e BHHMaHH5I K 3aMelJaHH5IM

KnHeHTOB

OpaHUIeHHbIU xapaKmep pecentopM ocyoapcmeeHHOO

ceKmopa PelPOPMhl rOCYLlapCTBeHHOH CHCTeMhl

3LlpaBooxpaHeHH5I lJaCTO HeLlOCTaTOlJHhl Lln51

YCTpaHeHH5I r ny60Ko YKopeHHBlllHXC5I np06neM

HeCMOTp5I Ha npHHHMaeMhle Ha npOT5I)f(eHHH

MHorHX neT Mephl H npeLlOCTaBn5leMhie

HHBeCTHUHH MHorHe rocyLlapCTBeHHhle CHCTeMhl

3LlpaBooxpaHeHH5I npOLlOn)l(alOT LlaBaTh

HeYLlOBneTBopHTel1hHhie pe3ynhTaThi H

HeLlononYlJaTh He06xOLlHMoro IPHHaHCHpOBaHH5I

Bo MHorHX cnYlJa5lX OHH He 06eCnelJHBaIOT

)I(enaeMOro ypOBH5I LlocTyna HaCeneHH5I K ycnyraM

a TaK)I(e He nOMoralOT B LlOCTH)I(eHHH

He06xOLlHMoro ypOBH5I 31PIPeKTHBHOCTH

3KOHOMHlJHOCTH H KalJeCTBa 06cnY)l(HBaHH5I La)l(e

B 6eLlHeHlllHX CTpaHax naUHeHThl BhIHY)l(LleHhl

lJaCTO 06paIUaThC5I K lJaCTHhlM BpalJaM Te KTO

MO)f(eT n03BonHTh ce6e 3annaTHTh BhlCOKYIO ueHY

3a nelJeHHe HHorLla MoryT nonYlJHTh H Tpe6yeMoe

KalJeCTBO TaM rLle OTCYTCTBYIOT MexaHH3Mhi no

perynHpoBaHHIO phlHKa MeLlHUHHCKHX ycnyr

6eLlH5IKH lJaCTO OKa3hIBaIOTC5I Ll06hllJeH Tex KTO B

LlellleBoe HO He31PIPeKTHBHoe nelJeHHe

EOlee C6alaHCUpOBaHHoe ylQcmue

ocyoapcmea U IQCmHOO ceKmopa XOT5I Bhl60p

onTHManhHoro 6anaHca Me)l(LlY YlJaCTHeM

rocYLlapcTBa H lJaCTHOro ceKTopa 3aBHCHT OT

cneUHIPHKH cTpaHhl H Lln51 CHCTeMhl

IPHHaHcHpOBaHH5I 3TOT 6anaHc MO)l(eT 6hlTh

LlpyrHM lJeM Lln51 clPephl npeLlocTaBneHH5I ycnyr

MHorHe H3 npoBoLlHMhlX B nocneLlHee BpeM5I

pelPoPM 6hlnH cocpeLlOTOlJeHhl Ha BOCCTaHOBneHHH

cnpaBeLlnHBocTH H 31PIPeKTHBHoCTH KOTophle

6hlnH YTpalJeHhl B pe3ynhTaTe LlHc6anaHca B

CTOPOHY rocyLlapcTBeHHoro HnH lJaCTHOro

YlJaCTH5I (CMITpHnO)l(eHHe A H PHc16)

Bo MHorHX cTpaHax rLle npaBHTenhcTBa

HalJanH npoBoLlHTh ycnelllHhle npe06pa30BaHH5I

oTpacnH nOBhlCHnaCh CTeneHh YlJaCTH5I

rocyLlapcTBa B npeLlocTaBneHHH HHIPOpMaUHH

perynHpoBaHHH oTpacnH BhlLlalJe MaHLlaTOB H

npeLlocTaBneHHH IPHHaHcHpOBaHH5I Hap5lLlY

nOLlLlep)l(KOH YlJaCTH5I HrO MeCTHhlX

opraHH3aUHH H lJaCTHOro ceKTopa B

npeLlocTaBneHHH ycnyr npaBHTenhcTBa B TaKHX

cTpaHax nepeHecnH CBoe BHHMaHHe H HMelOfUHeC5I

B HX pacnOp5l)l(eHHH CKYLlHhie pecypchl Ha

06eCnelJeHHe LlocTyna Bcero HaCeneHH5I K

ycnyraM HMelOIUHM 3HalJHTenhHhiH BHelllHHH

31PIPeKT (npeBeHTHBHoe 3LlpaBooxpaHeHHe) Ha

npeLloCTaBneHHe OCHOBHhlX ycnyr B 06naCTH 3ITH

Lln51 6eLlHoro HaCeneHH5I a TaK)I(e npHH5InH Ha

ce651 06513aHHocTH no PYKOBOLlCTBY cHcTeMoH

IPHHaHcHpOBaHH5I 3LlpaBooxpaHeHH5I

MeLlHUHHCKoro 06pa30BaHH5I HccneLloBaTenhcKoH

pa60ToH H 06eCnelJeHH5I KalJeCTBa ycnyr (CM

npaBylO Ta6nHUY B PHc16 H 06cY)l(LleHHe

BonpocoB IPHHaHcHpOBaHH5I B cneLlYIOIUeM

pa3Llene)

10

C

Pomt rOCYAapCTE~a B cclgtepe 3nH

HapyWettHA B pacnpepeneH paneK

pHC16

I R M F P

17epBoHa~aAbHaR BOAHa pe~OpM ~aCTO

BKmO~aeT B ce6~ nepena~y rocynapCTBeHHOH C06CTBeHHOCTH HnH npHBaTH3aIlHIO KOTOpa~

OXBaThIBaeT KOMMep~eCKHe npennpH~H~ Ycnex B nOH 06naCTH Bne~eT BmopylO BOAHY - nepena~y B ~aCTHhIH CeKTOp rocynapCTBeHHOH HH~paCTpYKTYPhl H KOMMYHanhHhlX ycnyr no Mepe nOCTH)KeHH~ ycnexa B 3THX nsyx 06nacT~x nepena~a rocynapCTBeHHOH cofiCTBeHHOCTH B ~aCTHhIH ceKTOp nponOn)KaeTC~ C ynopoM Ha HerocynapcTBeHHoe H ~aCTHoe ynpaBneHHe H HHBecTHpoBaHHe cpenCTB B 3npaBooxpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe H neHCHOHHoe 06ecne~eHHe- mpembR BOAHa

KaK Y)Ke nOKa3an onhlT B npyrHx OTpacn~x npOlllenUlHX TaKOH npouecc H B c~epe 3npaBooxpaHeHH~ B CTpaHax 03CP POCT Herocy napcTBeHHoro y~acTH~ He OO~3aTenhHO

03Ha~aeT npocTO npona)KY rocynapcTBeHHOH c06cTBeHHOCTH HanpOTHB TaKOH npouecc MO)KeT BKnIO-laTh HHHUHaTHBhl nOBhllllaIOIUHe ypOBeHh y~acTH~ ~aCTHoro ceKTopa KaK TO COBMeCTHoe ~HHaHCHpoBaHHe ycnyr KOHTpaKThI Ha ynpaBneHHe HaeM ~aCTHhIX KOMnaHHH nn~

OKa3aHH~ onpeneneHHhIX ycnyr H C03naHHe TpaCTOB nepena~a rocynapCTBeHHOH COOCTBeHHocTH TpeoyeT B03paCTaHH~ a He yMeHhllleHH~ KOHTponHpYIOmeH ponH rocynapcTBa B uen~x ooecne~eHH~ Ka~eCTBa ycnyr cnpasennHBoH KOHKypeHUHH H HenonymeHH~

MaXHHaUHH

Yny~llleHHe ~HHaHCHpOBaHH~ 3npaBooxpaHeHH~

B ~HHaHCHpOBaHHH 3npaBooxpaHeHH~

cnena~ Bepa B PhlHOK TaK)Ke He cnoc06Ha pa3pelllHTh np06neMhl CTo~mHe nepen OTpacnhIO KaK H HaHBHa~ Bepa B rocynapCTBO nonxonhl Hcnonh3yeMhie nn~ 06benHHeHH~ PHCKOB 3aooneBaHH~ pa3nH~Hhlx rpynn HaceneHH~

06ecne~eHH~ yCTOH~HBoro ~HHaHCHpOBaHH~

Cnep)KHBaHH~ pocTa pacxonOB H 6anaHCHpOBaHH~ 6IOll)KeTa B c~epe 3nH OTnH~aIOTC~ OT nonxonoB Hcnonh3yeMhlx nn~ yKpenneHH~ napTHepcTBa C Herocy napcTBeHHhIMH H ~aCTHhlMH

npOH3BonHTen~MH ycnyr (CM npHnO)KeHHe A no rpynnaM cTpaH HcnhlThIBaIOmHM np06neMhI C 06ecne~eHHeM He06xonHMoro ypOBH~

~HHaHcHpoBaHH~ HnH Cnep)KHBaHHeM pocTa pacxonoB)

060eiJuHeHue PUCKOB 3a6oAeBaeMocmu

HeKoTophle nIOnu ropa3no ~ame 6oneIOT ~eM

npyrHe OObenuHeHHe PHCKOB 3aooneBaeMocTH cpenu rpynn HaceneHH~ HBn~eTC~

OCHOBononaraIOIUHM acneKTOM cOUHanhHoH 3aIUHThI B c~epe 3nH YcnyraMH MenuUHHhI ~ame Bcero nonh3yIOTc~ B neTCKOM B03pacTe npH 6epeMeHHoCTH H B cTapoCTH - Korna nIOnu MeHee nponyKTHBHhI C 3KoHoMH~ecKoH TO~KH 3peHH~ Crna)KHBaHHe ypoBHeH noxona Ha npOT~)KeHHH

)KH3HH TaK)Ke MO)KeT BHeCTH BKnan B cOUHanhHYIO 3amHTY B c~epe 3nH

B HaCTO~mee Bpe~ TaK)Ke KaK H B EBpone 19-ro BeKa Korna CHCTeMa 3npasooxpaHeHH~ Haxonunach Ha npHMHTHBHOM ypoBHe pa3BHTH~ HaceneHHe BO MHorHX CTpaHax C HH3KHM H cpenHHM ypoBHeM noxona nponon)KaeT HeCTH np~Mhle pacxonhI no onnaTe MenHUHHCKHX ycnyr PacxollhI ceMeH Ha MenuUHHcKHe ycnyrH MoryT COCTaBn~h nO~H 80 Bcero ceMeHHoro OIOll)KeTa BKnIO~~ nnaTe)KH (ocpHUHanhHhle H Heo~HUHanhHhle) B3HMaeMhle B rocynapcTBeHHhlx MenHUHHCKHX y~pe)KneHH~X oonhlllHe nononHHTenhHhle nnaTe)KH TpeoyeMbIe MenHUHHCKHMH CTpaxoBKaMH H nnaTY 3a ~aCTHhle MenuUHHCKHe ycnyrH npenOCTaBn~eMhle B 6onhHHuax KnHHHKaX nuarHoCTH~eCKHX

ueHTpax onnaTY MenHKaMeHTOB H nocemeHH~

11

1aCTHhIX BpaieH TeM CaMhlM OCnaOnReTCR

pYHKUHR COUHanhHOH 3amHThi HaCeneHHR

KOTOpylO Morna Ohl BhInOnHRTh OTpacnb 3nH

oaJKe B CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM ooxooa

KaK nOKa3hlBaeT onhlT HeoOxooHMhl

pelllHTenhHhle oeHCTBHR co CTOPOHbl

rocyoapCTBeHHoro ceKTopa no Hcnonb30BaHHIO

3HalHTenhHh1X peCYPCOB KOTophle MorYT OblTh

MOOHnH30BaHhi 1epe3 1aCTHhle KaHanhl H

OoHOBpeMeHHOMY ooeCneleHHIO COUHanhHOH

3aIUHIUeHHOCTH YR3BHMhIX rpynn HaCeneHHR 1-13shy3a BhlCOKOH CTOHMOCTH H RBHOH

HeCOCTORTenhHOCTH phlHKa npoRBnmomeHCR B

MeoHUHHCKOM 1aCTHOM CTpaXOBaHHH TaKOH

BapHaHT oOneoHHeHHR PHCKOB 3aooneBaHHR He

npeoCTaBnReTCR B03MO)lHhiM MR CTpaH C HH3KHM

H CpeoHHM ypOBHeM ooxooa

06eCneleHUe Heo6xoiJuMOiO ypOBHJl

centUHaHCUpOBaHUJl B oonhlllHHcTBe cTpaH

pelllHTenhHoe H HenocpeocTBeHHoe

BMelllaTenhCTBO racyoapcTBa HeooxooHMO onR pHHaHCHpOBaHHR rocyoapcTBeHHoro

3opaBooxpaHeHHR H ooeCneleHHR HaCeneHHR

OCHOBHhlMH ycnyraMH B cpepe 3nH a TaK)Ie onR 3aIUHThi OT oOHHmaHHR B cnylae TR)KenOH

oone3HH

B cTpaHax C HH3KHM ypoBHeM ooxooa

oOmaR ooxooHaR 1aCTh OlOl)IeTa MO)leT

COCTaBnRTh 20 BBn H HH)Ie CTpaHa C

nooYllleBhlM oOXOoOM B 300-800 oonn CIIIA

oon)lHa 6yoeT pacxoooBaTh OT 15-3 BBn

(3KBHBaneHT 75-15 OlOl)IeTHhlX nOCTynneHHH)

MR pHHaHcHpOBaHHR MHHHManhHoro ypOBHR

npopHnaKTHKH H neleHHR 3aooneBaHHH ~HorHe

CTpaHhl C HH3KHM ypoBHeM ooxooa pacxooYIOT

ropa3oo MeHhllle npaBHTenhcTBa TaKHX cTpaH

HY)loaIOTCR B MooHnH3aUHH oononHHTenhHhlX

cpeoCTB OT HaCeneHHR H Me)loYHapooHhlX

oOHOPOB MR pHHaHcHpOBaHHR MelHUHHCKHX

ycnyr HMelOIUHX oonhllloH BHelllHHH 3ppeKT a

TaK)Ie MR BaJKHeHlllHX nporpaMM MR oeoHoro

HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)

Coop noc-rynneHVlI7t cna6bll7t nOTeHUVlan cTpaH C HVl3KVlM QOXOQOM

100 bull ~BKTenbCTB8 MHOrlO

CTJlIH MOryT coOpaTb ~ Mettee 20 BBn B BHA8 80rOCYAolPCTBeHHbIX

nocrynnettMH ii 60 bull HanOr0B8R CTpytCTypa eo i~c

MttOrHX CTpllHU C i middot 0

HwJI( JJlOIJI)M IIBIIA8TCA perJMICCH_ 20

0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj

~tJr - -d ~ IT noAyweeoM SBO

pHc1 7

B CTpaHaX co CpellHHM ypOBHeM ooxooa

roe nOoYllleBOH oOXOo npeBhllllaeT 800 oonn CIIIA oa)le npH HH3KHX ypOBHRX coopa HanoraB

npaBHTenhCTBa MoryT pacxooOBaTh 3-5 BBn Ha

3opaBooxpaHeHHe TaKOH OOheM cpeoCTB oon)leH

OhlTh oonee 1eM oOCTaTOleH MR o6ecneleHHR

oeoHhlx cnoeB HaCeneHHR neleOHO-

npopHnaKTHIeCKHMH ycnyraMH KOTophle

BhIXOlRT oaneKO 3a paMKH OCHOBHoro Haoopa

ycnyr

B TaKHX cTpaHax Ha nepBblH nnaH MoryT

BhlHTH 3aoalH opyroro xapaKTepa HanpHMep

aoamaUHR pa3Hooopa3Hhix pHHaHcoBhIX

HHCTpYMeHTOB K HHoHBHoyanhHbIM ycnOBHRM

KOHKpeTHOH CTpaHhl BaJKHeHlllHMH paKTopaMH B

3TOM cnylae cTaHyr o6ecnelelme cnpaBeMHBocTH

H 3ppeKTHBHoCTH MexaHH3MOB coopa HanorOB

oonee npoCThle cxeMhl H MeTOLlhI ynpaBneHHjJ

OlOl)IeTHhie MexaHH3Mhl coep)lHBaHHe poCTa

pacxooOB rOTOBHocTh HaCeneHHR nnaTHTh 3a

ycnyrH npHeMneMOCTh Haoopa ycnyr H

MaKp03KOHOMHIeCKaR CTaOHnhHOCTh TaK)Ie

HeOOXOlHMO OOeCnelHTh nonYleHHe oonhlllOH

oonH pHHaHCHpOBaHHR H3 npeoonnaleHHOra

HCTOlHHKa nocTynneHHH (OOhelHHeHHe PHCKOB

nYTeM OOIUHX OlOl)IeTHhlX nocTynneHHH HlHnH

COUHanhHoe HnH OOR3aTenhHoe MeoHUHHCKoe

CTpaXOBaHHe YlHThlBalOmee MeCTHhle ycnOBHR) C

TeM 1TOOhl H36e)laTh HapYllleHHH COUHanhHOH

cnpaBeMHBOCTH H CHH)IeHHR 3ppeKTHBHOCTH H3shy

3a H3nHlllHeH 3aBHCHMOCTH OT onnaTbl 3a ycnyrH

COep)f(UBaHUe ponna paCXoiJOB U

6JOi))f(emHaJl OUCijUnflUHa Qa)le B CTpaHax C

HH3KHM H CpeoHHM ypOBHeM ooxooa 3aTpaThi Ha

12

3npaBooxpaHeHHe cocTasnmoT 3HalfHTenbHYlO nOnlO HaUHOHanbHOro nponyKTa H pecypCOB XOTSI KOHKpeTHOrO npenena Ha 3npaBOoxpaHeHHe He YCTaHOBneHO H3BeCTHO IfTO ecnH ofiJlUie paCXOllb1 Ha 3npasooxpaHeHHe npeBbllllalOT 6-7 BBn HnH ecnH OHH paCTyT fiblCTPblMH TeMnaMH TO eCTb onaCHOCTb B03HHKHOBeHHSI npofineM filOJUKeTHOrO xapaKTepa Bo MHorHX cTpaHax 3HalfHTenbHbie filOJUKeTHble cpenCTBa HanpaBnSlIOTCSI Ha cpHHaHCHpOBaHHe He3cpcpeKTHBHbIX ycnyr JlflSl MeHblllHHCTBa HaCeneHHSI B TO BpeMSl KaK fionblllHHCTBO HaCeneHHSI He HMeeT nOCTyna K fia30BOMY MenHUHHCKOMY 06cnY)KHBaHHIO B TOM cnylfae Korna TpefiyeTcSI HananHTb KOHTponb 3a pacXonaMH B paCnOpSI)KeHHH npasHTenbCTB MoryT fibITb TpH BapHaHTa nonHTHKH

bull Cnep)KHBaHHe poCTa pacxonOB B

rocynapcTBeHHoM ceKTope nYTeM KOHTponHpOBaHHSI cnpoca npennO)KeHHSI H ueH

bull PerynHpoBaHHe lfaCTHOrO ceKTopa OTKa3 OT Hcnonb30BaHHSI KOMneHCHpYlOlliero CTpaXOBaHHSI H nooIUpeHHe nonYllieBoH onnaTbI a He 3a ycnyry

bull YKpenneHHSI KOHTponSl H CHCTeMbI OTCne)KHBaHHSI 3aTpalfeHHbiX rocynapcTBeHHbIX cpenCTB (Hcnonb3YSl ClfeTa 3npaBooxpaHeHHSI)

YnyllUeHUe 6JOiJJKenmoii npaKmuKu U pacnpeoeleHuJ pecypcoB K CO)KaneHHIO B fionbllloM KOnHlfeCTBe cTpaH C HH3KHM H cpenHHM ypoBHeM noxona OnHa H3 KnlOlfeBbIX npofineM cpHHaHcHpOBaHHSI 3npasooxpaHeHHSI - 3TO HH HeXBaTKa HeofixonHMblx pecypcoB H HH paCTYIUHe pacxonbl a HeynoBneTBopHTenbHaSl filOn)KeTHaSI npaKTHKa nOpO)KnalOIUaSI npHBbIIfKy necpHUHTHoro IPHHaHcHpoBaHHSI H pacnpeneneHHSI cKynHblx pecypcoB Ha He3cpcpeKTHBHoe nelfeHHe TPH CTpaTerHH MoryT nOMOlfb CTpaHaM cfianaHcHpoBaTb filOn)KeT

bull 06ecnelfeHHe 3HalfHTenbHoro npeBblllleHHSI ypOBHSI nOCTynneHHH H3 Bcex HCTOIfHHKOB Han O)KHnaeMbiM ofiIUHM ypOBHeM pacxonoB (3-5) nOCTaTOIfHOrO nnSl nOKpbITHSI pacxonoB Ha

aMopTH3aUHlO H o6cnY)KHBaHHe npHMeHeHHe caHKUHH K ofipa30BaHHlObull necpHUHTa filOJUKeTa H HaKonneHHIO

HenorallleHHblX nonrOB H

bull BblneneHHe fionblllOH nonH filOJUKeTHblX

cpenCTB Ha 3cpcpeKTHBHbie MepOnpHSITHSI

y nYlflllalOJlUie nOKa3aTenH

Ponb EaHKa B OKa3aHHH nOMOlUH cTpaHaM B pellleHHH naHHblX BonpocoB H npoBeneHHH HeofixonHMblx npeofipa30BaHHH H3naraeTCSI B rnaBe 2

13

rnABA II

POJIh EAHKA PACIlIHPEHHE YQACTHR H OCMhICJIEHHE ODhITA

060CHOBaHue yqaCTUR EaHKa B ccjJepe 3DH

HHBeCTHUHH B moneH HaxonRTC~ B ueHTpe CTpaTerHH pa3BHTH~ KOTOPOH 6yneT cnenOBaTh BceMHpHhlH EaHK npH nepexone B 21-H BeK 3TO rOBopHT 0 npH3HaHHH Toro lgtaKTa ITO HH OnHa CTpaHa He MO)KeT 06eCnelJHTh YCTOHlfHBhlH 3KOHOMHlfeCKHH POCT HnH CHH3HTh ypOBeHh 6enHOCTH amp3 3nopOBoro XOP01l10 nHTaIOIUerOC~ H 06pa30BaHHoro HaceneHH~

KaKHe ltJaKTopbI no MHeHHIO pa3BHBaIOmHXC~ CTpaH HeooxOAHMbI An~ ynyqllIeHH~ cltJepbl 3n8

EOnhll1HHCTBO CTpaH YTBep)KnaeT lJTO nn~ pell1eHH~ npo6neM B clgtepe 3nH HcnhlThIBaeMhlX 6enHhlMH cnO~MH HaceneHH~ a TaK)Ke nn~

nOBhlll1eHH~ ypOBH~ MenHUHHCKHX ycnyr H 06eCnelJeHH~ YCTOHlfHBoro H npHeMneMOrO ypOBH~ IgtHHaHCHpOBaHH~ HM Heo6xonHMa nOMOIUh Me)KnYHaponHoro coo6IUeCTBa B BHne nepenalfH onhlTa KOHKpeTHhlX KOHcynhTaUHH COBeTOB H IgtHHaHCHpOBaHH~

OnHaKO pearHpOBaHHe Ha 3anpOCbl KnHeHTOB B OTpacnH 3nH neno BeChMa HenpOCToe Bo-nepBhIX Heo6xonHMO cornaCOBaTh pa3Hoo6pa3Hhie H pa3nHlfalOIUHec~ MHeHH~

3aHHTepeCOBaHHhiX rpynn - KnHeHTOB EaHKa (KaK npaBHno MHHHCTPOB 3npaBOOXpaHeHH~ H IgtHHaHCOB) MeCTHOrG HaceneHH~

npOH3BonHTeneH ycnyr H CTpaXOBhlX KOMnaHHH nOTpe6HTeneH (naUHeHTOB 6enHhiX cnoeB HaceneHH~ )KeHIUHH neTeH H npyrHx y~3BHMhIX rpynn) H npOlfHX napTHepoB B nene pa3BHTH~

BO-BTOPhIX MHorHe CTpaHhl HcnhlThIBalOT npo6neMhi B 06naCTH 3nH Bh13BaHHhle npOBeneHHeM B )KH3Hh HeBepHhlX CTpaTerHH TaK)Ke MHorHe npaBHTenhCTBa He CMornH peanH30BaTh nOTeHUHan npaBHnhHOH nonHTHKH H Hcnonh30BaTh Herocy napCTBeHHhle

pecypchl 31gtIgteKTHBHhiM 06pa30M He6onhll1He H3MeHeHH~ B nOKa3aTen~x MoryT 3aHRTh OT 10 no 15 neT - CPOK npeBhlll1alOIUHH nOnHOMOlJH~ MHorHX npaBHTenhcTB H HX npHBep)KeHHOCTh pelgt0pMaM

H nocnenHee Korna IgtHHaHcoB~ nOMOIUh OTpacnH 3nH nocTynaeT B BHne KpenHToB H 3aHMoB TaKa~ cTpaTerH~ nOn)KHa 6hlTh TIUaTenhHO c6anaHcHpoBaHa C oTnalfeH KOTopa~ MO)KeT 6hlTh nonYlfeHa OT TaKHX HHBecTHUHH B cpenHecpolfHoH nepcneKTHBe H H3nep)KKaMH HepeanH30BaHHhix B03MO)KHOCTeH KOTophle MornH 6hl OTKPhIThC~ npH HHBecTHpoBaHHH B Te o6naCTH 3KOHOMHKH KOTophle BnH~IOT Ha clgtepy 3nH

Ponb MegtKAYHapoAHoro CoOomeCTBa

HH onHa H3 Me)KnYHaponHhlx opraHH3aUHH B OTnenhHOCTH He MO)KeT pell1HTh CnO)KHhle npo6neMhl HaKOnHBll1HeC~ B clgtepe 3nH 3TO oco6eHHO BepHO ceHlfac Korna ypOBeHh HHOCTpaHHOH nOMOIUH pa3BHBaIOIUHMC~ CTpaHaM npenOCTaBn~eMhlH 60raTeHlllHMH crpaHaMH MHpa CHH3HnCSI no 03 HX COBMeCTHoro BBfI - caMbIH HH3KHH ypoBeHh 3a 20 neT

EaHK pa60TaeT B cOTpynHHlfecTBe CO MHorHMH Me)KnYHapOnHhIMH opraHH3aUH~MH

(ltDAO MOT CnH)l OOH npOOH ltD)lHOOH B03) perHoHanhHhlMH 6aHKaMH (AEP AIgtEP EEPP H MEP) EC nBycTopOHHHMH opraHH3aUH~MH H HfO H lJaCTHhlM ceKTopoM 3a nocnenHee BpeM~ cOTpynHHlJeCTBO H napTHepcTBo co MHorHMH opraHH3aUH~MH y nYlJll1HnOCh onHaKO eIUe MHoroe npencToHT cnenaTh Ha 3TOM nyTH

CHnhHhlMH cTopoHaMH EaHKa ~Bn~IOTC~ aKKYMynHpoBaHHe B ce6e onhlTa H 3HaHH~

MHpOBoro coo6IUecTBa nonxon K npo6neMaM Ka)KnOH OTnenhHoH cTpaHhl MaKpo3KOHOMHlJeCKOH H MHorooTpacneBoH TOlJeK

14

C

3peHHR a TaK)Ke cnoc06HOCTh M06HnH30BaTh KpynHhle cpHHaHCOBhle pecypchI (nH60 HenocpenCTBeHHO nH60 nYTeM napTHepCTB) B Bonpocax npenOCTaBneHHR TeXHH4eCKOH nOMOWH B KOHKpeTHhIX 06naCTRX OTpacnH 3I1H KaK TO 60ph6a C 3a60neBaHHRMH naHK nonaraeTCR Ha coneHCTBHe cneUHanH3HpOBaHHhIX Y4pe)KneHHH OOH H npyrHx Me)KnYHaponHhIX napTHepOB

YqaCTlle liaHKa B ccJepe 3TIH

Ponh naHKa B ccpepe 3flH B Te4eHHe npOll1nhIX 25 neT CTana onHHM H3 npHMepOB paCll1HpeHHR Y4aCTHR H HaKonneHHR onhITa B nByx Ba)KHhIX acneKTax

bull Bo-nepBhIX naHK BHec CBOH BKnan B HaKonneHHe H pacnpOCTpaHeHHe MHpOBoro onhITa no BonpocaM 3TIH nYTeM npOBeneHHR MHPOBhIX H perHOHanhHhIX H3Y4eHHH HccnenOBaHHH H aHanH3a H 06MeHa onhITOM C npyrHMH Me)KnYHaponHhIMH opraHH3aUHRMH

bull BO-BTOPhIX BoopY)KeHHhIH 3HaHHRMH HaKonneHHhIMH B xone CBoeH neRTenhHOCTH naHK Hrpan ponh KaTanH3aTopa B ocywecTBneHHH He06xonHMhIX npe06pa30BaHHH nYTeM nepena4H CTpaHaM KpenHTOB H np04HX MeponpHRTHH HeKpellHTHoro xapaKTepa (H3naraeMhIX nanee)

IIonyqeHHe H paCilpOCTpaHeHHe r no6anhHhIX 3HaHHH

TIepeKpeCTHhle HccnenOBaHHR

MHorHe npenhIJlYWHe HccnenOBaHHR naHKa B OTpacnH 3TIH 6hlnH cocpenOT04eHhI Ha ponH rocynapCTBa H Herocy napCTBeHHoro ceKTopa B 06ecne4eHHH nOTpe6HOCTeH ManoHMywero HaceneHHR B ycnyrax ccpephI 3TIH B pa60Te CHCTeMhI 3npaBooxpaHeHHR H 06ecne4eHHH YCTOH4HBoro cpHHaHCHpOBaHHR

Oc06yIO Ba)KHOCTh HMeIOT CTpaTerH4eCKHe nOKYMeHThI naHKa TaKHe KaK (a) OmpaCleBble

npOipaMMbl (1970 i) U iJoKYMeHInbl no nolumuKe

COCTORWHe H3 peKoMeHnaUHH no nonHTHKe B 06naCTH HaponoHaceneHHR (6) OmpaCleBa51

npOipaMMa (1973 i) no MepaM B 06naCTH

06ecne4eHHR nponoBonhcTBHeM H (B) [JOlumuKa B

o6lacmu 3iJpaBooxpaHeHU5I (1975)

jJOKYMeHm no nOlumuKe B o6lacmu

3iJpaBooxpaHeHU51 (1980 i) RBnRnCR nepBoH nonhITKOH 060CHOBaTh HHBeCTHUHH naHKa B oTpacnh 3npaBooxpaHeHHR H CBR3h Me)Kny 3npaBooxpaHeHHeM HCKopeHeHHeM 6enHocTH H nnaHHpoBaHHeM ceMhH Omtem 0 BceMupHOM

pa3Bumuu coualbHblX pecypCOB (1980 r) nponeMoHcTpHpoBan Ba)KHOCTh 3npaBooxpaHeHHR HapRny C 06pa30BaHHeM H cOUHanhHoH 3aWHToH nnR cTpaTerHH HCKopeHeHHR 6enHocTH

jJOKlaiJ 0 BceMupHOM pa3Bumuu 1984 i

HapoiJoHaCeleHUe u pa3Bumue non4epKHYn ponh rocynapcTBa B CHH)KeHHH ypoBHeH cMepTHocTH H pO)KnaeMocTH I1ccnenoBaHHe npoBeneHHoe B 1987 r (fJuHaHcupoBaHue yClyi 3iJpaBooxpaHeHU51 B

pa3BUBalOlqUXC5I cmpaHax [JpOipaMMa perJ0pM

KacanOCh He3cpcpeKTHBHoCTH H HecnpaBennHBoro xapaKTepa pacxonoBaHHR rocynapcTBeHHhlx cpencTB Ha 3npaBooxpaHeHHe a TaK)Ke BonpocoB cpHHaHcHpoBaHHR TeKYWHX 3aTpaT

TeMa ponH rocynapcTBa 6hlna BHOBh 3aTpoHYTa B npyroM nOKYMeHTe naHKa no np06neMaM B 06naCTH 3TIH jJoKlaiJ 0 BceMupHOM

pa3Bumuu B 1993 i HHBecmuuu B

3iJpaBooxpaHeHue 3TOT nOKnaJ] Y)Ke OKa3an

3Ha4HTenhHoe BnHRHHe Ha BHyTpeHHHe H Me)KnYHaponHhle ne6aThI no BonpocaM nonHTHKH 3npaBooxpaHeHHR cTpaH C HH3KHMH H cpenHHMH noxonaMH H npHopHTeToB pa60ThI naHKa jJoKlaiJ

no pa3BumulO u 3alqUlne oKpYJKalOlqeu cpeiJbl (1992 r) llOKflall Om lleHmpalbHOiO flIaHUpOBaHU5I K

PblHKY (1996 r) H nOKJ1an POlb iOcyiJapcmea (1997 r) TaK)Ke 3aTparHBanH BonpochI ccpephI 3TIH

TIOMHMO 3THX KpynHhlx nOKYMeHToB H OT4eTOB naHK TaK)Ke ony6nHKoBan MHO)KeCTBO KHHr ClaTeH H pa604Hx nOKYMeHTOB no BonpocaM 3TIH - K KOHUY 1996 cpHHaHcoBoro rona 6hlno ony6nHKoBaHo 163 TaKHX pa60ThI TaK)Ke 6hln onp060BaH MeTon nonrOTOBKH He60nhll1HX HccnenoBaHHH 60nee Y3KOH cneUHanH3aUHH H MeHee noporocToRWHX a TaK)Ke npHBne4eHHe npyrHx OpraHH3aUHH K npoBeneHHIO HccnenoBaHHH no onpeneneHHoH TeMaTHKe (HanpHMep H CCleiJoBaHue M(fJK np06leM uHBecmupoBaHU51 B

15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)

OnepaUHOHHbie HCCnenOBaHH5I H aHanH3

B 1996 IPHHaHcoBoM rony Ha MCpOnpH5ITH5I B ofinaCTH 3nH fiblno Hcnonb30BaHO OKono 20 MnH nonnCIIIA H3 nOliTH 80 MHnnHOHOB BblneneHHblX Ha nporpaMMY cneUHanbHblX rpaHTOB (ncr) EaHKa HenaBHHe nporpaMMbl no BonpocaM 3nH KOTopble fiblnH nonnep)KaHbl nOH nporpaMMoH BKnlOlialOT B cefiSl CneUHanbHYIO nporpaMMY HccnenoBaHHH pa3BHTHSI H ofiYlIeHHSI no BonpocaM BocnpoH3BoncTBa HaCeneHHSI nporpaMMY HccnenOBaHHH TponHlIecKHx fione3HeH B03tnP OOHIBceMHpHoro EaHKa Me)KnYHaponHYIO nporpaMMY no nonHTHKe B ofinaCTH 3npaBooxpaHeHHSI I-bYlIeHHe B03 MenHUHHCKHX HccnenoBaHHH H r nofianbHYIO HHHUHaTHBY no MHKponHTaTenbHblM BellleCTBaM

B nocnenHee BpeMSI Ha HccnenOBaHHSI H aHanH3 npofineM B ofinaCTH 3nH B KOHKpeTHblX cTpaHax e)KerOnHO BblnenSleTCSI H3 cpencTB 3aHMOB H KpenHToB npenOCTaBnSleMblX EaHKoM 50-75 MnH nonn CIIIA liTO COCTaBnSleT 5-6 OT Bcero OfibeMa KpenHTOBaHHSI SIBnSlSlCb KpynHblM HCTOllHHKOM IPHHaHcHpOBaHHSI HccnenOBaTenbCKHX pafioT B ofinaCTH 3nH npoBOnHMblX B cTpaHax-KnHeHTax

B cOCTaB OTnena EaHKa no CTpaTerHlIeCKHM HccnenOBaHHSIM BXOilSlT HeCKonbKO CneUHaflHCTOB no BonpocaM 3TIH 3a nocnenHHe ronbl )TOT OTnen npoBen PM HccnenoBaHHH B ofinaCTH 3nH H3pacXOnOBaB OKono 11 MnHnonnCIIIA HnH 8 ofilllero filOn)KeTa Ha HccnenOBaHHSI paBHOrO 145 MnHnonnCIIIA OnHoH H3 nocnenHHX KpynHblx pafioT KOTOPOH 3aHHManCSI )TOT OTnen fiblna nonrOTOBKa nOKnana no CflHJy U BonpocaM

pa3Bumu51 HccnenoBaTenbcKHH COBeT TaK)Ke OKa3bIBaeT nOnnep)KKY npOBeneHHIO HccnenOBaHHH B ofinaCTH 3nH Ha KOHKypCHOH OCHOBe

H3YlIeHHe Me)KnYHaponHoro onblTa

HHCTHTYT 3KOHOMHlIeCKoro Pa3BHTHSI EaHKa (H3P) OKa3blBaeT ycnyrH no ofiYlIeHHIO H npOBonHT ceMHHapbl MSI npaBHTenbCTBeHHblX

pafiOTHHKOB cTpaH-KnHeHTOB OTBeTcTBeHHblx 3a 1P0pMHpOBaHHe nonHTHKH B clPepe 3nH UeHTp ofiYlIeHH5I H nHnepCTBa EaHKa 3aHHMaeTC51 nOBblweHHeM KBanHIPHKaUHH cOTpynHHKoB EaHKa rpynna 3nH SIBnSllOluaSlCSI lIaCTblO OfibenHHeHHSI cneUHanHCTOB EaHKa B ofinaCTH pa3BHTHSI COUHanbHblX pecypcoB fiblna C03naHa B 1996 r H B03r naBHna pafioTY no ynpaBneHHIO HHlPopMaUHeH B ofinaCTH 3nH Bce TpH rpynnbl Hcnonb3YlOT )neKTpOHHble TeXHonorHH H pa3BHBalOT napTHepcTBo nnSl MaKCHMH3aUHH )lPlPeKTHBHoCTH CBoeH pafioTbl

OCHOBHOH YllefiHblH KypC no TeMe PerjJ0pMupoBaHue U ycmouluBoe rjJuHaHcupoBaHue

30paBooXpaHeHUJI nonroToBneHHblH oceHblO 1997 OfibenHHeHHeM cneUHanHCTOB EaHKa B ofinaCTH COUHanbHblX pecypcoB H cOTpynHHKaMH H3P npH coneHCTBHH weCTH perHOHanbHblX HHCTHTYTOBshynapTHepoB CKOHueHTpHpOBaH Ha Bonpocax )KOHOMHKH nonHTHlieCKOH )KOHOMHH H HHCTHTYUHOHanbHblX npofineMax 3aHHMalOlllHX ueHTpanbHoe MeCTO B pelPopMax oTpacnH 3nH 3a npOlUenUIHe nsa rona B paMKax HenenbHoro nOBbllUeHHSI KBanHIPHKaUHH cOTpynHHKoB EaHKa npoBonHMoro UeHTpOM ofiYlleHHSI fiblna npOBeneHa HHTeHCHBHaSl nonrOTOBKa C ynopoM Ha Ba)KHeHIUHe Bonpocbl oTpacnH 3nH

Me)KnYHaponHble KOHlPepeHUHH H HaYllHble ceMHHapbl opraHH3yeMbie EaHKoM H JlPyrHMH opraHH3aUHRMH TaKJKe COJleHcTBYIOT nOBbllUeHHIO KBanHIPHKaUHH cOTpynHHKoB EaHKa H cTpaH-KnHeHToB EaHK npHHSIn YliaCTHe BO BceMHpHoM COBelllaHHH no BonpocaM neTCTBa npoBonHMoM K)HHCEltIgt B 1990 B HblO-HopKe B Me)KnYHapOnHOH napTHepcKoH BCTpelie no oxpaHe MaTepHHcTBa B BallIHHITOHe oKpyr KonYMfiHSI B 1991 B Me)KnYHaponHoH KOHlaquoPepeHuHH no BonpocaM HapOnoHaCeneHHSI H pa3BHTHSI B KaHpe B 1994 BO BceMHpHoH KOHlPepeHUHH no BonpocaM )KeHlllHH B ileKHHe B 1995 H B Me)KnYHaponHoH KOHlPepeHUHH no BonpocaM paHHero MaTepHHCTBa B ATnaHTe B 1996 TaK)Ke B 1997 r EaHK opraHH30Ban H npOBen Me)KnYHaponHYIO KOHlPepeHUHIO no IPHHaHcHpoBaHHIO 3npaBooxpaHeHHSI B BaIUHHITOHe oKpyr KonYMfiHSI

16

EaHK BceMepHO nOOIUpsleT y-aCTHe crpaHshy

KnHeHTOB B TaKHX Me)lnYHaponHbIX

KOH$epeHUHsIX H HaYlJHbIX CHMn03HYMax B uenslx

yKpenneHHsI opraHH3aUHOHHoro nOTeHUHaJIa H

06MeHa onbITOM

OCHOBHble HanpaBneHHsI COBepll1eHCTBOBaHHe

nejITenbHOCTH EaHKa B KalJeCTBe MHpOBoro

nOCpelHHKa npH nepena-lH HH$opMaUHH

~HorHe CTpaTerHlJeCKHe HccnenOBaHHsI

EaHKa OKa3aJIH nOnO)lHTenbHoe BnHsIHHe Ha

COUHaJIbHO-3KOHOMHlJeCKOe pa3BHTHe CTpaH

BMeCTe C TeM B nocnenHee BpeMsI onpeneneHHYIO

TpeBory CTaJIH BbI3bIBaTb TaKHe $aKTbI KaK

HenOCTaTO-lHasl onepaTHBHasl HanpaBneHHOCTb

HeKOTopbIX HccnenOBaHHH 3HalJHTenbHoe

KOnHlJeCTBO BpeMeHH H 3HalJHTenbHbIH 06beM

pecypcoB 3aTpalJeHHble Ha nonrOTOBKY

60nbll1HHCTBa H3 HHX BKnIOlJasl

HenocpenCTBeHHble 3aTpaTbI H npOlJHe pacxonbI Ha

nepcOHaJI OTpbIBaeMbIH OT npyrHx npslMbIX

06s13aHHOCTeH HccnenOBaTenbCKM pa60Ta H

MepOnpHjlTHsI no nonrOTOBKe KanpOB

npOBonHMbIe HenocpenCTBeHHO EaHKOM HnH

nOnnep)lHBaeMble ero KpenHTaMH H 3aHMaMH

nOn)lHbI HOCHTb ueneHanpaBneHHbIH xapaKTep H

OTpa)laTb npHopHTeTbI pa3BHTHsI B OTpacnH 3nH

H nOTpe6HOCTH nepCOHaJIa EaHKa H CTpaHshy

KnHeHTOB B HaCTOslIUee BpeMsI nnaHHpoBaHHe H

KoopnHHaUHsI HccnenOBaTenbCKOH pa60TbI

npoBonHMOH C nOMOIUbIO KpenHTOBaHHsI KaK

npaBHno BbInOnHsIeTCsI COTpYLlHHKaMH He

HMeIOIUHMH CneUHaJIbHOH nonrOTOBKH B

npOBeneHHH HccnenOBaHHH HenaBHee COKpaIUeHHe

6IOn)l(eTa H np06neMbI onepaUHOHHoro xapaKTepa

lJaCTO 3aTpynHsIIOT nonHoe Hcnonb30BaHHe Bcex

B03MO)lHOCTeH no nOBbIll1eHHIO KBaJIH$HKaUHH

HMeIOIUHXCsI B EaHKe HnH npenOCTaBnsleMbIX

npyrHMH opraHH3aUHsIMH

KaTaJlH3aTOp pelPOPM B OTQeJILHO B3s1TOH

CTpaHe

HMeHHO Ha ypOBHe CTpaHbI npoHCXOnHT

COBMeIUeHHe rn06aJIbHoro OnbITa EaHKa ero

MHorOOTpacneBoro MaKpoypoBHeBOro $OKyca H

$HHaHCOBbIX pecypcOB npH OKa3aHHH coneHCTBHsI

npe06pa30BaHHsIM B c$epe 3nH l1nsl nOnnep)lKH

CHCTeMHbIX pe$opM B CTpaHe H MaKCHMH3aUHH

B03neHCTBHsI peKOMeHnaUHH Hcnonb3yeTcsI He

TonbKO KpenHTOBaHHe B BHne 3aHMOB KpenHTOB H

rpaHTOB HO H 3KOHOMHlJeCKHe H OTpacneBhle

aHaJIH3bI BbInOnHeHHble no naHHOH CTpaHe

KOHKpeTHble peKOMeHnaUHH H nHaJIOr co

CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH

CTpaTerHsI nOMOIUH CTpaHe (CnC) CTana

OCHOBHbIM HHCTpYMeHTOM nOMOIUH pa3BHTHIO

CTpaH C HH3KHM H cpenHHM ypOBHeM noxona OHa

naeT B03MO)lHOCTb BbIsIBHTb 3aCTapenble

Me)lOTpaCneBble np06neMbI H YCTaHOBHTb Ba)lHble

CBsI3H Me)lny OTpacnbIO 3nH H He06xonHMbIMH

MepaMH B 6IOn)leTHO-HaJIOrOBOH c$epe H no

CHH)IeHHIO ypOBHsI 6enHOCTH TaK KaK B cnc

nOn)lHbI 6bITb OTpa)leHbI HanpaBneHHsI

naJIbHeHll1eH pa60TbI EaHKa B oTpacnH 3nH

(aHanH3 np06neM H KpenHTOBaHHe) KpHTH-leCKH

Ba)lHOH lJaCTbIO npouecca nonrOTOBKH cnc

sIBnslIOTCsI oTpacneBoH aHaJIH3 npoBeneHHbIH no

naHHoH cTpaHe H oueHKa 3$$eKTHBHOCTH paHee

BblneneHHblX $HHaHcoBbIX cpencTB

cnc no ~aJIaBH B 1996 $HHaHcoBoM rony

sIBnsleTCsI nOKa3aTenbHbIM npHMepoM Toro KaK

KnIOlJeBble BonpOCbI HeynOBneTBopHTenbHoro

COCTOslHHsI 3npaBooxpaHeHHsI H OTCYTCTBHsI

3nopOBbIX ycnOBl-iH )lH3HH (HeXBaTKa

KaHaJIH3aUHH nHTbeBOH BonbI OCHOBHoro

06pa30BaHHsI H HH3KHe ypOBHH noxona) MoryT

6bITb npenCTaBneHbI B Cnc OxpaHa

penp0LlYKTHBHOrO 3LlOPOBbsl H pa3BHTHe

COUHaJIbHbIX peCypCOB 6blnH BbIsIBneHbI B

Ka-leCTBe npHopHTeTHbIX HanpaBneHHH

He06xonHMbIX nnsl 06ecnelJeHHsI 6ynYIUero pOCTa

3KOHOMHKH H pa3BHTHsI CTpaHbi Ha OCHOBaHHH

3TOro aHaJIH3a B cnc 6blna npennO)leHa

CTpaTerHsI pe$opM B c$epe 3nH npHBsI3aHHasl K

MaKp03KOHOMHlJeCKOH 06cTaHoBKe H

YlJHTbIBaIOIUasl HenOCTaTKH B npaBHTenbcTBeHHoH

nonHTHKe B 3TOH 06naCTH

B uenslx 06eCnelJeHHsI He06xonHMblx

CBsI3eH Me)l(ny oTpacnbIO 3nH H

MaKp03KOHOMHlJeCKHMH cTpaTerHsIMH EaHKa no

HCKopeHeHHIO 6enHocTH nepcoHany 3nH

He06xonHMO 60nee TeCHO pa60TaTb C npyrHMH

17

COTpynHHKaMH H3 06benHHeHHjI CneUHaJ1HCTOB

DaHKa B 06J1aCTH COUHaJIhHhlX peCypCOB H

CTpaHOBhlMH OTneJ1aMH HanpHMep

aHaJIHTHlleCKHe paMKH HCn0J1h3yeMhle nJ1j1

nOnnep)KKH peKOMeHnaUHH cnc He BKJ1IOIHUOT

KOJ1HlJecTBeHHhle nepeMeHHhle no lJeJ10BelJeCKOMY

KanHTaJIY HJ1H npOH3BOnHTeJ1hHOCTH Tpyna B TO

BpeM$l KaK 06a 3THX nOKa3aTeJ1j1 3aBHCfl OT

pe3YJ1hTaTOB 3nH H pOCTa 06pa30BaTeJ1hHOrO

ypOBHjI DOJ1ee Toro He)KeJ1aHHe pelllaTh

nOJ1HTHlJeCKH lJYBCTBHTeJ1hHhle BonpoChl lJaCTO

HBJ1j1eTCjI OCHOBHOH npHlJHHOH HrHopHpOBaHHjI

r J1y60KO YKOpeHHBlllHXCjI npo6J1eM BJ1HjJJOI1lHX Ha

OTpaCJ1h 3nH TaKHe np06J1eMhl nonphIBaIOT

cpaBHHTeJ1hHOe npeHMYruecTBo DaHKa KaK

MHorOOTpaCJ1eBOH opraHH3aUHH H CHH)KaIOT

ypOBeHh B03neHCTBHjI ero MaKp03KOHOMHlJeCKOH

HanpaBJ1eHHOCTH Ha OTpaCJ1h 3nH

B KalJeCTBe npHMepa TaKHX npo6J1eM

MO)KHO npHBeCTH TOT qaKT lJTO BO MHorHX cnc

BonpOChl YCTOHlJHBOCTH rPHHaHCHpoBaHHjI H

COUHaJIhHhlX pecypCOB B OTpaCJ1H 3nH He

HBJ1jJJOTCjI HHTerpHpOBaHHOH lJaCThIO np06J1eMhl

peqopMHpOBaHHjI rocynapcTBeHHoro

qHHaHCHpOBaHHjI H rocynapcTBeHHOH CJ1Y)K6hl

cnc MorJ1H 6hl 6hlTh 60J1ee jlCHhlMH B CBOHX

peKOMeHnaUHjlX CTpaHaM OTKa3aThCjI OT

npenOCTaBJ1eHHjI nOTaUHH He3nopOBhlM

CeJ1hCKox03jJjiCTBeHHhIM nponYKTaM H

pa36a3apHBaHHjI 06weCTBeHHhiX pecypcoB Ha

nporpaMMhl KOMneHcaUHH nponYKTOB nHTaHHjI He

HOCjll1lHe ueJ1eHanpaBJ1eHHhIH xapaKTep B 3aBepllleHHH CJ1enYeT OTMeTHTh lJTO YlJHThIBa$I

POCT XpOHHlJeCKHX 3nHneMHH HeKOTophlX

3a60J1eBaHHH He06xonHMO noorupflh CTpaHhlshy

KJ1HeHThl K HCn0J1h30BaHHIO HHCTpYMeHTOB

HaJIoro06J10)KeHHjI llI1j1 6oph6hl C KypeHHeM

DOJ1hllla$l nOJ1j1 peKOMeHnaUHH DaHKa B

OTpaCJ1H 3nH 6a3HpyeTcjI Ha Me)KllYHaponHOM

onhlTe Hero npHMeHeHHH B KOHKpeTHhlX

YCJ10BHjlX CTpaH-KJ1HeHTOB HanpHMep nonxon K

BonpocaM HaponOHaCeJ1eHHjI B ueJ10M

OCHOBhlBaeTCjI Ha peKOMeHnaUHjlX

Me)KnYHaponHOH KOHqepeHUHH no BonpocaM

HaponOHaCeJ1eHHjI H pa3BHTHjI B KaHpe B 1994 (CMnpHJ10)KeHHe B) non06Hhie nOnXOllhl

HCn0J1h3YIOTCjI B 60Ph6e C pa3J1HlJHh1MH

3a60J1eBaHHjlMH H B Bonpocax

18

HaH60J1ee nonXOnjlWHe npH pellleHHH CJ10)KHhIX

BonpocoB OTpaCJ1H 3nH lTo KaCaeTCjI Mep no

60ph6e C KypeHHeM HaHJ1YlJlllajl Me)KnYHaponHajl

npaKTHKa KaCaIOwajlCjI 3Toro Bonpoca 6hlJ1a

OTpa)KeHa B nOJ1HTHKe DaHKa 1992 rona

npenycMaTpHBaIOweH OTKa3 OT BCjlKOH

nOnnep)KKH npoH3BoncTBY 06pa60TKe H npona)Ke

Ta6aKa Hapjlny co BceMepHhlM noowpeHHeM

KOHTPOJ1j1 B 3TOH 06J1aCTH (OnepaTHBHa$I

AHpeKTHBa 476)

B 6ynyrueM 60J1hllle BHHMaHHjI

He06xonHMO yneJ1flh BonpocaM KacaIOWHMCjI

nOJ1HTHlJeCKOH 3KOHOMHH npe06pa30BaHHH

H3MeHeHHjI nOBeneHlJeCKHX npHBhllJeK H

COUHaJIhHOrO MapKeTHHra 06j13aTeJ1hHhIM

YCJ10BHeM YJ1YlJIlIeHHjI B 3TOH 06J1aCTH jlBJ1jJJOTCjI

ueJ1eHanpaBJ1eHHhle YCHJ1HjI COTPYnHHKOB DaHKa

no pellleHHIO npaKTHlJeCKHX BonpOCOB

KOTOPhlMH CTaJIKHBaIOTCjI nOJ1HTHKH H

anMHHHcTpaTHBHhlH annapaT B CTpaHax

npOBOnjll1lHx perPopMhl B cqepe 3nH

AHaJIHTHlJeCKHe HccnenOBaHHjI B cTpaHax

AHaJIHTHlJeCKHe HCCJ1enOBaHHjI no

OTneJ1hHhiM CTpaHaM BKJ1IOlJajl 3KOHOMHlJeCKHe H

OTpaCJ1eBhle aHaJIH3hl jlBJ1j1IOTCjI Ba)KHOH

COCTaBHOH lJaCThIO HeqHHaHcoBoH neflCJ1hHOCTH

DaHKa B 06J1aCTH 3nH 3TH HCCJ1enOBaHHjI

n03B0J1jJJOT nonYlJHTh HHrPopMaUHIO no BonpocaM

3DH H HHBeCTHUHOHHhlM nOTpe6HOCTjlM B

CTpaHaX-KJ1HeHTaX a TaK)Ke npenOCTaBJ1jJJOT

HCKJ1IOlJHTeJ1hHO Ba)KHhle naHHhle nJ1j1 nonrOTOBKH

CTpaTerHH nOMOI1lH H BeneHHjI nHaJIOra co

CTpaHOH-KJ1HeHTOM B TOM lJT06hl HMeTh

B03MO)KHOCTh nocTyna K aHaJIHTHlJeCKOMY onhlTy

HaKanJ1HBaeMOMY DaHKOM B xone nonrOTOBKH

HHBeCTHUHOHHhlX npoeKTOB 3aHHTepeCOBaHO

60J1hlllOe KOJ1HlJeCTBO CTpaH-KJ1HeHTOB HMeIOIl(Hx

J1Hlllh cpenHHe rPHHaHCOBhle nOTpe6HOCTH

nOMHMO 210 OTpaCJ1eBhIX HCCJ1enOBaHHH

no OTneJ1hHhlM cTpaHaM H nOKJ1anOB no

3KcnepTH3e npoeKToB COCTaBJ1eHHhIX K KOHUY

1996 rPHHaHcoBoro rona 6hlJ1H nOnrOTOBJ1eHhl

COTHH cpaBHHTeJ1hHO He60J1hlllHX pa60lJHX

nOKYMeHTOB H cTpaTerHH no CTpaHaM-KIlHeHTaM

no OTneJ1hHhiM BonpocaM 3nH TaKHe

HCCJ1enOBaHHjI 6hlJ1H npOBeneHhl HenaBHO B

C

ApreHTHHe Epa3HnHH YHnH HopuaHHH

KHprH3CTaHe HHUHH ManaBH MeKCHKe H

TYHHCe

B OUHOM H3 HCCneUOBaHHH B03ueHCTBHjf

ueHTenbHOCTH EaHKa uenaeTCjf BblBOU 0 TOM lJTO

60nbll1M lJaCTb 3apy6eJKHOH nOMoIUH

nocTynaIOlileH B OTpaCnb 3nH npOCTO 3aMelilaeT

rocyuapCTBeHHble paCXOUbl B CBjf3H C 3THM

peanbHblM HCTOlJHHKOM 3cpcpeKTHBHOH nOMOlllH B

OTpaCnH 3nH jfBnjfIOTCjf He CTonbKO caMH 3aHMbl

CKonbKO Te peCPOPMbl KOTopble npOBOUHTCjf Ha

OCHOBe peKOMeHuaUHH EaHKa uonOnHjfiOIUHX

KpeUHTOBaHHe B CBeTe TaKoro BblBoua HMeBll1ee

MeCTO H 6yUYIUHe COKpallleHHjf 6IOUJKeTa H

nepcOHanO-BpeMeHH BbluenjfeMblX Ha

aHanHTHlJeCKYIO pa60Ty jlBnjfIOTCjf TpeBOJKHblM

CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)

Y_bW8HMe ~IOAJIlteTll 6aHKlI lUI 3KOHOIIM__

M OTp8cneBbie MCCIl8AOBBHMA B c4gtepe 3nH

pHc21

B npOllInOM npH nO[rOTOBKe

aHanHTHlJeCKHX HccneUOBaHHH B OTpacnH 3nH

HeUOCTaTOlJHO BHHMaHHjf y uen~OCb BonpocaM

nOnHTHlJeCKOH 3KOHOMHH H 3KOHOMHlJeCKHM

npaBOBblM H opraHH3aUHOHHbiM OCHOBaM peCPOpM

He06xoUHMbi uononHHTenbHble YCHnHjf [njf Toro

lJT06bl Ha OCHOBe MeJKUYHapOUHoro onblTa B

npOBeueHHH peCPOPM pa3pa6aTbiBanHCb 6bl

npaKTHlJeCKHe Mepbl [njf peanH3aUHH B

KOHKPeTHblX MeCTHblX ycnoBHAA llaJKe B Tex

cnylJajfX Koma B orpOMHOH HHcpopMaUHOHHOH

6a3e EaHKe HMenaCb HHcpopMaUHjf 0 nylJll1HX

npHMepax MeJKUYHapOUHOH npaKTHKH B

HeKOTopblX 06naCTjfX OTblCKaTb ee 6bInO nopOH

UOBonbHO CnOJKHO

ltlgtHHaHCOBajf nOllJlepJKKa EaHKa pa3BHTHIO

COUHanbHblX pecypCOB HalJanaCb C KpeUHTOBaHHjf

06pa30BaHHjf B 1960-x r 3a KOTOPblM B 1970-x H

1980-x r nocneUOBano KpeUHTOBaHHe OTpacnH

3nH B nocneUHHe rOUbl 06naCTb KpeUHTOBaHHjf

paCll1HpHnaCb B06paB B ce6jf cpHHaHCOBYIO

nOuuepJKKy CPOHUOB COUHanbHblX HHBeCTHUHH

CPOHUOB 3aHHTOCTH nporpaMM 06YlJeHHjf

COUHanbHblX TpaHccpepTOB (neHCHOHHoro

06eCnelJeHHjf H COUHanbHOH 3alllHTbl) H nporpaMM

pa3BHTHjf UeTeH

K KOHUY 1996 cpHHaHcoBoro roua 24

eJKero[Horo 06beMa HOBoro KpeUHTOBaHHjf

COCTaBHBlilero 21 MnpU uonn CIlIA 6blno

HanpasneHo Ha ccpepy 3nH o6pa30BaHHe H

nporpaMMbl cOUHanbHoH 3alllHTbi nOMHMO

HenocpeucTBeHHoH ueHTenbHOCTH no pa3BHTHIO

cOUHanbHoH ccpepbl 23 KpeUHTOB EaHKa

Hcnonb3yeTCjf B OTpaCnjfX cenbCKoro X03jfHCTBa

BOUOCHa6JKeHHjf H KaHanH3aUHH OKpYJKaIOlileH

cpeUbl H ropoucKorocenbcKoro pa3BHTHjf

KOTopble TaKJKe B03ueHcTBYIOT Ha 3nH

C MOMeHTa BblueneHHjf nepBoro 3aHMa B

pa3Mepe 2 MnHuonnCIllA Ha MepOnpHHTHjf no

nnaHHpoBaHHIO ceMbH B 51MaHKe B 1970 r

ueHTenbHOCTb EaHKa B oTpacnH 3nH Bblpocna UO

TaKoro ypOBHjf npH KOTOPOM OH CTan

KpynHeHll1HM BHellIHHM HCTOlJHHKOM cpHHaHcoBblX

cpeUCTB [njf CTpaH C HH3KHM H Cpe[HHM ypoBHeM

uoxoua 06111M CTOHMOCTb KpeUHTHoro nopTcpenjf

COCTaBHna l35 MnpuuonnCIlIA B ueHax 1996

roua (CMPHC22)

KYMynRTHBHblM POCT KpeAHTOBaHHR B ccllepe 3nH H np08KTbI (U8HbI 1996)

250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22

ltlgtHHaHcHpOBaHHe (KpeJlHTbl 3aHMbi H rpaHTbl)

B 1976 rouy nepBblH 3aeM Ha uenH 06eCnelJeHHjf

19

1

HaceneHIUl npOIlOBOnbCTBHeM 6bln BbIlleneH Epa3HnHH a B 1981 rOilY TYHHC CTan nepBoH cTpaHoH nonYlJHBllleH 3aeM Ha paclllHpeHHe OCHOBHbIX ycnyr 3IlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI

B KOHue 1996 qHHaHcoBoro rOlla HaClJHTbIBaJIOCb 154 lleHcTBYIOmHx npoeKToB B oTpacnH 3nH B 82 CTpaHax C 06mHM ypoBHeM qHHaHcHpOBaHHjI B 92 Mnpll1l0nnCIllA (ueHbI 1996) H 94 3aBepllleHHblx npoeKTa (CM npHnO)KeHHe G )eHCTBYIOmHe H 6YIlymHe npoeKTbI qHHaHcHpyeMble EaHKoMlMAP) C 1994 110 1996 rr qHHaHcoBoro rOlla OKono 48 qHHaHcHpOBaHHjI EaHKa COCTaBnjlnH KpellHTbI MAP npellOCTaBnjleMble 6ellHeHlllHM cTpaHaM MHpa 06IUHH 06neM HHocTpaHHoH nOMOIUH oTpacnH 3nH 3a nepHoll C 1985 no 1993 rOlla COCTaBHn OKono 2 MnpllllonnCIllA e)KerOIlHO B ueHax 1996 (3a HCKnIOlJeHHeM 3aHMOB EaHKa)

XOTjI 3a nocnellHHe 10 neT pa3Mep KpellHTHoro nopTqenji B 06naCTH 3nH pOC 6bICTPbIMH TeMnaMH Ha6nIOIlaJIHCb 3HalJHTenbHble Kone6aHHjI B ypOBHjlX e)KerOIlHOro qHHaHcHpOBaHHjI 1996 qHHaHcoBbIH rOil 6bln peKopllHo BbICOKHM C ypoBHeM B 24 Mnpll1l0nnCIllA HOBoro qHHaHcHpOBaHHjI no cpaBHeHHIO C 11 MnpllllonnCIllA B 1995 qHHaHcoBoM rOilY H 09 MnpllllonnCIllA B 1997 qHHaHcoBoM roilY 3aMeTHbIH POCT qHHaHCHpOBaHHjI B 1996 qHHaHcoBoM rOilY npoH30111en 6narollapjl YTBep)KlleHHIO njITH KpynHhlx 3aHMOB B pa3Mepe OT 270 MnH J]onn CIllA J]O 350 MnH Ilonn CIllA no cpaBHeHHIO co cpellHHM pa3MepoM 3aHMa B 50-60 MnH 1l0nn CIllA Ha npoeKT B 06naCTH 3nH H cpellHHM pa3MepoM 3aHMa EaHKa B 80 MnH Ilonn CIllA

Ha OCHOBaHHH nnaHHpyeMhlx npoeKToB MO)KHO CJ]enaTb BbIBOIl 0 TOM lJTO B TelJeHHH 1998shy2000 qHHaHcoBbIX rOJ]OB 6yJ]eT Ha6nIOIlaTbCjI

YCTOHlJHBoe paclllHpeHHe J]ejITenbHOCTH EaHKa B 06nacTH 3nH C O)KHllaeMbIM cpellHHM 06neMoM

qHHaHcHpOBaHHjI B 15 MnPIl Ilonn CIllA H 22 HOBblMH npoeKTaMH B roJ] nocne BbllJeTa 06bIlJHOrO 40-ro CHH)KeHHjI (CMnpHnO)KeHHe E)

)HHaMHKa pacxolloBaHHjI 3aeMHblX cpellcTB TaK)Ke cooTBeTcTByeT 3THM TeHlleHUHjlM 06neM H3pacxolloBaHHblx 3aeMHhlX CpellCTB BblpOC B njITb pa3 C 318 MnH1l0nnCIllA B 1992 qHHaHcoBoM

rOilY 110 15 MnpllllonnCIllA B 1997 qHHaHcoBoM rOilY B TelJeHHe cnellYIOlllHx TpeX neT POCT KpellHTHoro nopTqenji nOBnelJeT 3a C060H POCT B paCXOIlOBaHHH 3aeMHbIX cpellCTB 110 ypOBHjI HaMHoro npeBbIlllaIOmero OTMeTKY B Mnpll1l0nnCIllA

B KpellHTHoM nopTqene 3nH cymeCTBYIOT 60nbillHe perHoHanbHble pa3nHlJHjI (CMnpHnO)KeHHe G no perHOHaM EaHKa) PerHoHbI naTHHcKoH AMepHKH H KapH6cKoro 6acceHHa H IO)KHOH A3HH jlBn~HCb

KpynHeHlllHMH nonb30BaTenjlMH qHHaHcHpOBaHHjI cqepbI 3nH a H3 cTpaH KpynHeHlllHM KnHeHTOM EaHKa B 3TOH 06naCTH jlBnjleTCjI HHIlHjI BCTynneHHe B EaHK cTpaH perHoHa EBponbI H UeHTpaJIbHOH A3HH B HalJaJIe 1990-x rr npHBeno K llanbHeHllleMY paclllHpeHHIO 06j13aTenbcTB EaHKa TaK)Ke He06xollHMbI H HOBble nOIlXOllbI JlJIjI npellOTBpameHHjI nalleHHjI ypOBHjI KpellHTOBaHHR B HeKOTopbIX IlpyrHx perHOHax BKnIOlJajl KHTaH KOTOPbIH 60nee He MO)KeT nonYlJaTb KpellHTbI MAP

Pe3ynbTaTbI pa60TbI EaHKa B oTpacnH 3nH

npellblJlymaji nonHTHKa peKoMeHllaUHH H KpellHToBaHHe oTpacnH 3nH B OCHOBHOM 6blnH cocpellOTOlJeHbI Ha YKpenneHHH OCHOBHbIX nporpaMM 3nH B cTpaHaX~KfliHeHTax Bo MHorHX cnYlJajlx peqopMbI B oTpacnH 3nH llaBallH nOnO)KHTenbHble pe3ynbTaTbI TonbKO lJepe3 HeCKonbKO neT nocne npOBelleHHjI onpelleneHHbIX MepOnpHjlTHH nOCTOpOHHHe qaKTopbI TaK)Ke OKa3hIBaJIH CBoe BnHjlHHe B CBjl3H C 3THM 6hInO 3aTpYllHeHO onpelleneHHe npHlJHHHOH CBjl3H Me)KIlY ynYlJllleHHjlMH B cqepe 3nH npOH30111elllllHMH 3a nocnellHHe 20 neT H npOBelleHHbIMH KOHcynbTaUHjlMH H HHBeCTHUHjlMH EaHKa

B npOlllflOM YlJaCTHe EaHKa B OTpacnH 3nH 6bInO HaH60nee ycnelllHhIM B 06naCTH qHHaHCHpOBaHHjI He06xOllHMbiX KanHTaJIhHhlX 3aTpaT pa3BHTHjI HHqpaCTpYKTyphI H cHa6)KeHHjI

He06xOllHMbIMH paCXOJlHbIMH MaTepHaJIaMH TaK)Ke onpelleneHHbIH ycnex 6bln 1l0CTHrHYT B reorpaqHlJeCKOH HanpaBneHHOCTH HHBeCTHUHH H nelJeHHH onpelleneHHblX 3a60neBaHHH cpeJlH 6ellHoro HaCeneHHjI lJaCTHlJHO 6narollapjl TOMy lJTO KOHcynbTaUHH H KpeJlHThI BbIJlenjleMhle

20

MAP paHee aBTOManllleCKH HanpaBJUl11HCh B

6enHeHlllHe CTpaHhl TaKoH nonxon COBnana11 C

n011HTHKOH MHorHX rocynapcTB B oTpac11H 3nH H

lllHpOKHM Me)l(nYHaponHhlM KOHceHcycoM 0 TOM

liTO nOBhlllleHHe nocTyna K OCHOBHhlM ycnyraM

aBTOMaTHlIeCKH npHBonHT K y 11YllllleHHIO

nOKa3aTeneH

K CO)l(a11eHHIO KanHTa110B110)l(eHHj H

cHa6)1(eHHe pacxonHhlMH MaTepHa11aMH

COCTaB11jj]H TonhKO lIaCTh pellleHHj np0611eM

Ha11wmiddotme cnpoca TaK)I(e jB11jeTCj Ba)l(HhlM

qaKTopOM H60 TOBaphl H ycnyrH n011)1(Hhl 6hlTh

Hcn011h30BaHhl lIT06hl 6hlTh 3qqeKTHBHhIMH

MHeHHj Hace11eHHj 0 KalleCTBe H 3qqeKTHBHOCTH

11elleHHj OTHOllleHHe npOH3BonHTe11eH

MenHUHHCKHX yC11yr H Ha11HlIHe Ba)l(HeHlllHX

nOTpe6HTe11hCKHX TOBapOB BK11lOlIaj

MenHKaMeHThl BO MHOroM onpene11jIOT

3qIPeKTHBHOCTh Hcn011h30BaHHj cpenCTB

Xa11aTHOCTh npOjB11eHHaj B ynpaB11eHHH

nporpaMMaMH H B HX pea11H3aUHH KaK TO

KpaTKOBpeMeHHhlH pa3phIB B X0110nOBOH uenH

BaKUHHaUHH H11H OTCYTCTBHe CBoeBpeMeHHoro

pellleHHj 0 Bhlnalle HanpaB11eHHj Ha 11elleHHe

C110)l(HhIX rHHeKonorHlIeCKHX 3a6011eBaHHH TaK)I(e

MO)l(eT CBeCTH Ha HeT 3qqeKTHBHOCTh BceH

nporpaMMhl TaKHe qaKTophl Ha KOTophle B11HjeT

Ha11HlIHe qHHaHCOBhIX cpenCTB nnj nOKphITHj

TeKYlllHX 3aTpaT He nonYlla11H nOCTaTollHoro

BHHMaHHj B xone nepBOHalla11hHOrO YllaCTHj

EaHKa B OTpaC11H 3nH

0630Phl COCTaB11eHHhle OTne110M oueHKH

nejTe11hHOCTH (00[0 no 120 TeKYllUlX npoeKTaM

B 1970-1995 qHHaHcoBhIX ronax H npOllHe oueHKH

YKa3hIBalOT liTO HeCMOTpj Ha Ba)l(HOCTh

pecypCHoro 06ecnelleHHj TaKOH nonxon He

npHBonHT K opraHH3aUHOHHhlM ynpaB11eHlIeCKHM

H CHCTeMHhlM nepeMeHaM He06xonHMhiM nnj

YCTOHlIHBoro B03neHCTBHj npe06pa30BaHHH Ha

npOTj)I(eHHH pjna 11eT

Bo-nepBhlX T011hKO 17 3aBepllleHHhix

npoeKToB B 0611acTH 3nH 6hl11H

K11accHqHUHpoBaHhl KaK BHeClllHe 3HallHTe11hHh1H

BK11an B HHCTHTYUHOHa11hHOe pa3BHTHe Ehl11H

BhljB11eHhl c11enYlOllUIe qaKTophl nOBI1HjBlllHe Ha

TaKoH HH3KHH nOKa3aTe11h

HeYJloB11eTBopHTe11hHo onpene11eHHhle ue11H

pa3BHTHj OTCYTcTBHe npHBep)l(eHHOCTH

peqopMaM co CTOPOHhl cTpaHhl HenOCTaTOllHoe

B11aneHHe npoeKToM co CTOPOHhl 3aeMllIHKa

oc06eHHo B ce11hCKHX paHoHax c11a6hlH

nOTeHUHa11 n11aHHpoBaHHj H ynpaBneHHj

HenOCTaTOllHaj HopMaTHBHo-npaBoBoBaj 6a3a

HeXBaTKa CTHMY110B HHq0pMauHH H

KOMMYHHKaUHoHHhlX CTpaTerHH HenOCTaTOllHoe

YllacTHe HrO OTCYTcTBHe BHHMaHHj K KOHTponlO

H oueHKe [(pyrHMH qaKTopaMH jB11j11HCh

Hepea11hHhle 3anallH H C110)l(Haj CTpyKTypa

npoeKToB a TaK)I(e HeynOB11eTBopHTe11hHhIH

KOHTp011h

BO-BTOPhIX T011hKO 44 3aBepllleHHhix

npoeKToB B 0611acTH 3nH n011YllH11H peHTHHr

OTne11a 00[( KaK YCTOHlIHBhle OnHoH H3 npHlIHH

Heynall OCTa11hHhIX npoeKToB OKa3a110Ch

HenOCTaTOllHoe KalleCTBO 3KOHOMHlIeCKoro H

opraHH3aUHoHHoro aHa11H3a npone11aHHoro B xone

nonrOTOBKH npoeKTa a HMeHHO HeBHHMaHHe K

MaKp03KoHoMHlIecKHM qaKTopaM HenooueHKa

pa3Mepa TeKYlllHx pacxonoB H HenOCTaTOllHoro

ypOBHj qHHaHcHpoBaHHj 3aTpaT Ha

3Kcn11yaTaUHIO CTP0jllIHXCj Yllpe)l(neHHH

lIepeclIYP onTHMHCTHlIHhle nporH03hl

3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Bhlron HeynOB11eTBopHTe11hHoe

pellleHHe Me)l(OTpaC11eBhIX BonpOCOB BK11lOlIaj

CHCTeMY rocynapCTBeHHOH C11Y)l(6hl PhlHOK

pa60lleH CH11hl nOTaUHH Ha nHTaHHe H n011HTHKY

B 0611aCTH Ha11oro06110)l(eHHj Ta6allHbiX H3ne11HH

a11KOro11hHhiX HanHTKOB H nponOB011hCTBeHHhIX

TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

OTCYTCTBOBa11a CBj3h Me)l(ny OTpaC11eBhIMH

peKOMeHnaUHjMH EaHKa H COnep)l(aHHeM

npoeKTOB B cqepe 3nH He06xonHMO OTMeTHTh

liTO HeCMOTpj Ha TO liTO aHa11H3 ponH

HerocynapcTBeHHoro ceKTopa npOBonHTCj Teneph

B ropa3no 6011hllleM K011HlIeCTBe npoeKTOB HH B

onHOM H3 68 3aBeprneHHhiX npoeKToB B 0611aCTH

3nH He npenYCMaTpHBa110Ch qHHaHCHpOBaHHe

lIaCTHblX Yllpe)l(neHHH H11H MeponpHjTHH Eonee

TOro Bonpochl 3qqeKTHBHoCTH CHCTeMhl

3npaBooxpaHeHHj pellla11Hch B OCHOBHOM

nOMOlllhlO BOB11elleHHj rocynapcTBeHHoro ceKTopa

3KOHOMHKH H Ma110 BHHMaHHj y ne11j110Ch

3qqeKTY 3aMellleHHj liTO npHBOnH110 K

BhlTeCHeHHIO lIaCTHhlX npOH3BonHTe11eH

MenHUHHCKHX yC11yr BonpOChl ynpaB11eHHj

21

C

lfaCTHbIM CeKTOpOM H KOHTpOnR KalfeCTBa pellKO

nOnYlfaIlH HeOOXOllHMOe BHHMaHHe H nHlllb

HeKOTOpbIe npoeKTbl ObinH COCpellOTOlfeHbI Ha

BOnpocaX MOOHnH3aUHH peCypCOB

H nOCnellHee Ha ITO XOTenOCb ObI

OOpaTHTb BHHMaHHe 3TO TOT qaKT ITO KaK

nOKa3aIlH HellaBHHe 0030PbI 00[( OTlfeTOB 0

peaIlH3aUHH 68 npoeKTOB TOflbKO 59 npoeKToB

B oonaCTH 3nH nonYlfHnH Y1l0BneTBopHTenbHYIO

oueHKY no cpaBHeHHIO C 81 npoeKToB B oTpacnH

oopa30BaHHR H 58 npoeKToB B uenOM no BceMY

naHKY flHlllb HeKoTopbIe npoeKTbI npellocTaBHnH

OOneKTHBHYIO 1l0KYMeHTaUHIO 0 B0311dicTBHH

MeponpHRTHH npoeKTa Ha nOKa3aTenH 3110POBbR

HaceneHHR pO)KllaeMOCTH H nHTaHHR middot nOCKonbKY

BeCbMa TPYllHO COOTHeCTH npoHcxoMIUHe

H3MeHeHHR C B0311eHCTBHeM KOHKpeTHbIX

npoeKTHbIX MeponpHRTHH OTCne)KHBaIlHCb

nOKa3aTenH pecypcbIlnpoueccbIlpe3ynb-TaTbl a He

nocnellCTBHR OT npOBelleHHbIX MeponpHRTHH

TaKHe BblBOllbI 3aCTaBHnH naHK

COCpellOTOlfHTb 1l0nonHHTenbHoe BHHMaHHe Ha

CHCTeMHbIX peqopMax BKnIOlfaR

lllHpoKOMaClllTaOHbie npeoopa30BaHHR B 06naCTH

311paBooxpaHeHHwqHHaHCHpOBaHHR a TaK)Ke Ha

BbInOnHeHHH 60nee ueneHanpaBneHHblX lleHCTBHH

CeHlfac ewe paHO oueHHBaTh ycnex nOCKOflhKY

nHlllb He60nblllaR 1l0nR TaKHX npoeKToB ObU1a

3aBepllleHa rOIlOBOH 0630p pe3ynbTaToB pa60Tbi B

1996 qHHaHcoBoM rOilY nOKa3aIl ITO HenaBHO

HalfaTble npoeKTbl B 06naCTH 3nH HaXOllHnHCb Ha

80-OM cpellHeM ypOBHe naHKa no nOKa3aTen5IM

1l0CTH)KeHH5I 3allalf pa3BHTH5I H nporpecca B

peaIlH3aUHH

OnpelleneHHYIO TpeBory Bbl3bIBaIOT KonHlfeCTBO

npoeKTOB C HaIlHlfHeM qaKTopoB pHCKa

TeHlleHUH5I CHH)KeHH5I peHTHHrOB no Mepe

CTapeHHR KpellHTHoro nOpTqen5I H Hecnoc06HoCTb

HMeIOllleHC5I CHCTeMbl 0630poB npellOTBpaTHTh

TaKHe npo6neMbI nonee Toro B 1994-1996

qHHaHcoBbIX rOllax Ha6nIOilaIlOCb 3HalfHTenbHoe

cOKpallleHHe pecypcoB BbIllenReMblX Ha

KOHTponhHbIe MepOnpH5ITHR nnarOllap5I

HellaBHeMY POCTY BHHMaHHR K nOBblllleHHIO

KalfeCTBa TaKaR TeHlleHllH5I 6blna YCTPaHeHa B

1997 qHHaHcoBoM rOilY (CMnpHnO)KeHHe E llflR

60nee lleTaIlbHOrO aHaIlH3a)

22

nOMHMO oueHKH KOHKpeTHbIX

HHBeCTHUHOHHbIX npoeKToB none3HO BcnOMHHTb

ITO K KOHUY 1996 qHHaHcoBoro rOlla oonee lfeM B

100 npoeKTax naHKa HMenHCb KOMnOHeHTbI

CBR3aHHbIe C oTpacnbIO 3nH B 3THX npoeKTax

obIna npellnpHH5ITa nonbITKa pelllHTb CnO)KHbIe

Me)KOTpaCneBbIe H CHCTeMHbIe npooneMbI

BKnIOlfaR ueneHanpaBJJeHHOCTb Ha OellHeHlllHe

cnOH HaceneHHR peqopMY CHCTeMbI

rocYllapcTBeHHoH cnY)KObI YCTOHlfHBoe pa3BHTHe

cena lleueHTpanH3aUHIO nonHTHKY B oonacTH

npolloBonbcTBHR 3aWHTY COUHaIlbHbIX pacxolloB

Cllep)KHBaHHe pocTa pacxolloB H HanoroBYIO

nonHTHxy TwaTenbHaR oueHKa B0311eHcTBHR

TaKHX npoeKToB Ha cqepy 3nH ellle 1l0n)KHa OblTb

npoBelleHa

YpOKH H3BneqeHHhIe H3 onhITa

[(nR nOBblllleHHR pe3ynbTaTHBHocTH

KpellHTHoro nopTqenR H ynYlfllleHHR KalfeCTBa

HOBbIX npoeKToB He06xollHMO YlfHTbIBaTb BbIBOllbI

nonYlfeHHbIe B XOlle npoBelleHHR 0630pOB

KpellHTHoro nopTqenR rpynnoH ooecnelfeHHR

KalfeCTBa OTllenOM 00[( H llPYrHMH OTllenaMH B npOllInbIe rOllbI npH peCTpYKTypH3aUHH cTapbIx

npoeKToB HnH nnaHHpoBaHHH HOBbIX npoeKTOB He

CYllleCTBOBaIlO npaKTHKH CHCTeMaTHlfeCKoro

Hcnonb30BaHHR HaKonneHHoro onbITa BO

H36e)KaHHH nOBTopeHHR CTapbIX 01llH60K TaK)Ke

H3MeHeHH5I B KalfeCTBeHHOM COCTaBe nepCOHaIla

naHKa H COOTHOllleHHH nepCOHaIla K ypOBHIO

KpellHTOBaHHR He COOTBeTCTBOBaIlH TeMnaM

pa3BHTH5I KpellHTHoro nopTqen5I H HOBbIM

npHopHTeTaM

[(n5I cyruecTBYIOruero KpellHTHoro

nopTqenR 6bIna C0311aHa KOHuenUH5I llpoeKlnoB C

HalUIUeM PUCKOB n03BonRIOrua5I H3YlfHTb Te

acneKTbI KOTopbIe He MorYT OblTb BKnIOlfeHbl B

aHaIlH3 peaIlH3aUHH npoeKTa H peHTHHr

1l0CTH)KeHH5I 3analf pa3BHTHR OKono 44 KpellHTHoro nopTqefl5I B 06nacTH 3nH nonYlfHno

oueHKY c HaIlHlfHeM CTeneHH pHcKa B HalfaIle

1997 rOlla no cpaBHeHHIO C 30 B cepellHHe 1996

rOlla ITO YKa3bIBaeT Ha HeOOXOllHMOCTb B

npOBelleHHH nOCT05IHHOrO aHaIlH3a

PYKOBOllHTen5IMH OTllenOB ceHlfac

paCCMaTpHBaeTC5I Bonpoc 0 TOM KaK nepeCTpOHTb

HnH npeKpaTHTb peaIlH3aUHIO HeKOTopbIX

npoeKTOB BBHJly HaJIHlJHjJ np06neM CBjJ3aHHhIX C

BOnHeHHjJMH B 06IUeCTBe HnH nepeMeIUeHHeM

H npH npOlJHX JleueHTpaJIH30BaHHhIX ycnOBHjJX

np06neM C OpraHH3aUHOHHhIM nOTeHUHanOM

BBHJly CnmlltHOH CTpyKTyphI npOeKTa H np06neM B

npOBeJleHHH 3aKynoK HCnOnh30BaHHH 3aeMHhIX

CpeJlCTB H MeCTHOM Co-lgtHHaHcHpOBaHHH

MHorHe H3 nOnYlJeHHhIX ypOKOB nOnYlJHnH

JlOCTaTOlJHOe BHHMaHHe B npeJlhIJlyIUHX aHanH3aX

H B pa60lJeM JlOKYMeHTe no 06eCnelJeHHIO KalJeCTBa

(cMBKnaJlhIlll) HeKOTophle H3 peKOMeHJlaUHH

Tpe6yIOT H3MeHeHHH B HMeIOIUHXCjJ rrpaBHnax H

npOueJlypax OJlHaKO 60nhlllHHCTBO Tpe6yeT

KOHKpeTHhIX JleHCTBHH

npOllleJllllHe 10 neT CTaJIH CBHJleTeneM

6hICTporo pOCTa JlejJTenhHOCTH EaHKa B clgtepe

3nH H OCMhIcneHHjJ HaKonneHHoro onhITa B

6e)KeHueB MenneHHOH H HepOBHOH peaJIH3aUHeH

npoeKTOB B CTpaHax C lgteJlepaTHBHOH CTpyKTypOH

1980-x rr Ha Ka)KJlhIH nOTpalJeHHhIH Jlonnap

(aJlMHHHCTpaTHBHhIH 6IOJl)KeT EaHKa nnIOC

TpaCTOBhle lgtOHJlhI KOHcynhTaHTOB) Ha npoeKThI B

clgtepe 3nH 6hlno BhIJleneHO B KalJeCTBe KpeJlHTOB

35 JlonnClllA no cpaBHeHHIO C 60nee lJeM 60

JlonnClllA B 1996 lgtHHaHcoBoM rOJlY H 30 Jlonn ClllA B cpeJlHeM no EaHKY TpacToBhle lgtOHJlhI -shy

oco6eHHo jJnOHCKHe - Jl06aBHnH 60nee OJlHOH

TpeTH cpeJlcTB B aJlMHHHCTpaTHBHhIH 6IOJl)KeT

3nH TaKajJ TeHJleHUHjJ He MO)KeT HOCHTh

HeYCTOHlJHBhIH xapaKTep HacTynHno BpeMjJ JlnjJ

KOHCOnHJlaUHH KpeJlHTHOrO nopTlgtenjJ

HCn0J1h30BaHHjJ HaKonneHHoro onhITa

H36e)KaHHjJ nOBTopeHHjJ CTaphIX OlllH6oK H

B0306HOBneHHjJ npHBep)KeHHOCTH pelgt0pMaM B

OTpacnH 3nH B rnaBe 3 H3naraIOTCjJ cTpaTerHH

JlOCTH)KeHHjJ TaKHX 3aJlalJ

23

DpeAllaraeMhle nyTH AOCTH)KeHHB pe3YJIhTaTHBHOCTH npOeKTOB B OTpaCJIH 3DH

06eCneleHHe KaleCTBa B xone nOnrOTOBKH npoeKTa

bull PaCWHpeHHe YIaCTHB CTPaHhlmiddot38eM~HKa B nOnrOTOBKe npoeKTa bullbull JIJUI paClllHpeHHR BnaJleHHR

npoeKTOM CTPaHOH-KJIHeHTOM nOnYlfaTenRMH CpeJlCTB 3aHHTepecOBaHHblMH CTOpOHaMH

bull OTpaCJIeBOH aHaJIH3 -- JlJIR nOnYlfeHHR HHCPOPMauHH no H3yqaeMhiM npo6neMaM H BapHaHTaM HX

pellIeHHR JlJIR YBR3blBaHHR npoeKTa C MaKpo3KOHOMHIfeCKOH CHTyauueH B CTPaHe

bull 3KOHOMHIeCKHH aHaJIH3 -- JlJIR Bhl60pa OnTHMaJIhHOrO BapHaHTa C YlfeTOM H3Jlep)KeK H B03JleHCTBHR

bull OpraHH38DHOHHhlH aHaJIH3 -- JlJIR 06eCnelfeHHR peaJIHCTHIfHOH oueHKH HHCTHTYUUOHaJIhHOrO

nOTeHUHaJIa JlJIR npHHRTUR H peaJIH3aUHH pellIeHHH

bull AHaJIH3 YCTOHIHBOCTH -- IlIUI oueHKH cpHHaHCOBOH )KH3Hecnoc06HOCTH PHCKOB H aJIbTepHaTHB

BKJIIOIruI CTpaTefHH BblXOJla

~ MOHHTopHHr H oueHKa -- JlJIR o6ecnelfeHHR nOCTynaTenbHOCTH B peaJIH3aIlHH npoeKTa H H3BnelfeHIDI

ypoKOB H3 npaKTHlfeCKoro OIIbITa

AnannUHSI nOJIHTHKH H npouenyp KpenHTOBaHHSI K nOTpe6HOCTJIM KJIHeHTa

bull Anp06aUIDI npoeKTOB B MaJIOM MaCllITa6e (3KcnepHMeHTaJIhHhle npoeKThl) -- JlJIR H3YlfeHHR H

BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB

bull HcnOm~3OBaHHe AHHaMHIHoro a He CTaHAapTHOro nOIUOAa K npoeKTaM B 06nacTH 3JlPasooxpaaeHHR

bull Hcnonb30BaHHe 60nee WHpOKoro Ha60pa KpenHTHhlX HHCTpYMeHTOB

bull YIeT AeueUTpaJIB30BaUHoro xapaKTepa COUHaJIhHhlX CeKTOpOB

bull H3MeHeHHe 4lHHaaCHpoBaHHR TeKY~Hx pacxOAOB

bull BHeceHHe H3MeHeHHH B npaBHJIa npOBeAeHHSI 3aKynoK B COUHaJIbHOH c4lepe H 60nbllIruI fH6KOCTb B HX

npHMeHeHHH

bull YKpenneHHe KaapoBoro nOTeHUHaJIa nYTeM paCIIIHpeHHOH nOArOTOBKH 60JJee

CHCTeMhl CTHMynHpoBaHHSI Tpyna H HaHMa nyIWHx pa60THHKOB

COBepIlleHHOH

YKpenneHHe npocj)eCCHOHaJIhHhlX 06heAHHeHHH

B03Harpa)KAeHHe 38 OTnHqHYIO pa60TY

H CHCTeMhl 06MeHa HH(b opMaUHen H

03HaKOMJIeHHeJlpyrHx CneUHaJIHCTOB naHKa B OCo6eHHOCTH 388enylOlUHx CTpaHOBhlMH OTAenaMH H

COBeTHHKOB no 38KynKaM C BOnpocaMH B c4lepe 3nH

24

rJIABA III

B 21 BEK HOBbiE OliSl3ATEJIhCTBA IiAHKA

YTOqHeHHe cTpaTerHqeCKHX npHopHTeToB

CTpaTerHsI baHKa B oTpacmi 3nH 6yLleT

npOLlOn)f(aTh LlHHaMHlHO pa3BHBaThCsI B6Hpasl B

ce6s1 nYlIIIHH Me)f(LlYHapoLlHhIH onhIT CnO)f(HhIH

xapaKTep OTpacnH 3nH H MeHsIIOlUHecsI nOLlxOLlhI

K npo6neMaM 3nH B uenOM He nOLlLlaIOTCsI

CTaHLlapTHhIM peuemaM B CBsI3H C 3THM npH

Bhlpa60TKe peKOMeHLlaUHH H npeLlOCTaBneHHH

IJHHaHcoBOH nOMOiliH baHK 6yLleT npOLlOn)f(aTh

PYKOBOLlCTBOBaThCsI ycnoBHsIMH KOHKpeTHhlX

CTpaH B onpeLleneHHH nOLlXOLlOB K TpeM

Ba)f(HeHIIIHM npHopHTeTaM pa3BHTHsI B clJepe

3nH KOTophle 6hInH Y)f(e ynoMsIHYThI B r naBe 1 H

60nee nOLlpo6HO H3naraIOTCsI HH)f(e

npuopumem 1 B oOlacmu 3nH PaOOTaTl COBMeCTHO C rocYAapcTBaMH

no YJIyqmeHHIO nOKa3aTeJIeH B OOJIaCTH

3AOPOBbsl nHTaHHsI H npOOJIeM

HapoAoHaceJIeHHsI cpeAH oeAHhlx CJIOeB

MHpOBoro HaCeJIeHHsI H no 3aIJJHTe OT

yrp03bl oOHHIJJaHHsI B pe3YJIbTaTe

OOJIe3HeH HeAOeAaHHsI H BhlCOKOH

pO)KAaeMocTH

CTpaTerHsI Tpe6yeT 6onhillero

ynopa Ha nnaHHpoBaHHe H KOHTponh 3a

nporpaMMaMH KOTophle y nylIllaIOT nOKa3aTenH

cpeLlH 6eLlHeHIIIHx cnoeB HaCeneHHsI Llnsl

aLlanTaUHH TaKOH cTpaTerHH K ycnoBHsIM

KOHKpeTHoH cTpaHhI oco6eHHo K cTpaHaM C

HH3KHM ypoBHeM LlOXOLla rLle 6onhIllasl laCTh

cenhCKoro HaCeneHHsI npO)f(HBaeT 3a lepTOH

6eLlHocTH H cTpaHaM co cpeLlHHM ypoBHeM LlOXOLla

co 3HalHTenhHhlMH OCTaTKaMH 6eLlHocTH B

OTLlenhHhlX paHoHax He06xoLlHMhl pa3nHlHhle

nOLlXOLlhI baHK 6YLleT nOOIUpslTh Bhl6opOlHOe

Hcnonh30BaHHe ueneHanpaBneHHhlX nOLlXOLlOB

H3nO)f(eHHhIX B r naBe 1 BHHMaHHe 6yLleT

cocpeLlOTOleHO Ha nOTpe6HOCTsIX HaH60nee

Ysl3BHMbIX cnoeB HaCeneHHsI BKnIOlasl )f(eHIUHH H

LleTeH H Ha Te o6nacTH rLle CKYLlHble

rocyLlapCTBeHHble pecypcbl MoryT LlOCTHlb

HaH6onblllero pe3ynbTaTa HanpHMep

npolJHnaKTHleCKHe MepOnpHsITHsI co

3HalHTenhHhIM BHeIIIHHM 31JIJeKToM BKnIOlasl

3aIUHTy 6eLlHoro HaCeneHHsI OT nOBeLleHHsI

HecYIUero HaH60nblllHH pHCK KaK TO KypeHHe

nOTpe6neHHe anKOrOnsl H He3LlopOBOH nHlUH

BbICOKasl pO)f(LlaeMOCTb OCTaeTCsI rnaBHOH

MeLlHUHHCKOH H COUHanbHOH npo6neMOH B

CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM LlOXOLla baHK 6YLleT

npOLlOn)f(aTh LlenaTb ynop Ha Heo6xOLlHMOCTb B

31JIJeKTHBHOH nonHTHKe B 06naCTH

HapOLlOHaCeneHHsI H nHTaHHsI HanpaBneHHOH Ha

ynylllleHHe ycnyr B clJepe nnaHHpOBaHHsI ceMhH H

oxpaHbl penpOLlYKTHBHoro 3LlOPOBhsl KOTophle

cnoco6CTBYIOT coxpaHeHHIO He6onhllloro pa3Mepa

ceMbH H CHH)f(eHHIO He)f(enaTenbHOH

pO)f(LlaeMOCTH TaK)f(e B CTpaHax C HH3KHM

ypOBHeM LlOXOLla Mepbl HanpaBneHHble Ha

CHH)f(eHHe ueH Ha npOLlYKTbl nHTaHHsI

nOBblllleHHe 31JIJeKTHBHOCTH pa60Tbl

npOLlOBonbCTBeHHblX PbIHKOB nOLlLlep)f(aHHe

Heo6xOLlHMoro ypOBHsI nHTaHHsI y HeHMYIUHX

cnoeB HaCeneHHsI MoryT OKa3aTb ropa3Llo 60nbllle nOnO)f(HTenbHoro B03LleHCTBHsI Ha 3LlopOBbe

HaCeneHHsI leM y nYlllleHHe pa60Tbl CHCTeMbI

MeLlHUHHCKoro 06cnY)f(HBaHHsI

PellleHHe 3THX npo6neM laCTO Tpe6yeT

lllHpOKoro Ha60pa anbTepHaTHB COUHanbHOH

nonHTHKH (HanpHMep 06eCneleHHe paBHoro

LlocTyna MY)f(lHH H )f(eHIUHH K nonYleHHIO

06pa30BaHHsI H y nYlIlleHHe cTaTyca )f(eHIUHH B

06IUeCTBe) ynyllllaIOlUHX H paCIIIHpslIOIUHX Bbl60p

)f(H3HeHHOH anbTepHaTHBbl Llnsl 6eLlHoro

HaCeneHHsI oco6eHHO MsI LleBOleK-nOLlpOCTKOB H

)f(eHIUHH B Tex cnylaslX KorLla )f(eHIUHHhI

pa60TaIOT Ba)f(HhIM lJaKTopOM B y nylllleHHH

COCTOslHHsI 3LlOPOBbsl LleTeH MO)f(eT sIBHTbCsI

LlOn)f(HbIH ypOBeHh YXOLla 3a HHMH BKnIOlasl

06eCneleHHe Heo6xOLlHMblMH MeLlHUHHCKHMH

ycnyraMH B cOBoKynHocTH C COOTBeTCTBYIOlUHM

nHTaHHeM H npolJHnaKTHleCKHMH

MeponpHsITHsIMH (HanpHMep BaKUHHaUHsI H YXOLl

3a 3y6aMH) npH peIlleHHH TaKHX npo6neM

Heo6xOLlHMO YlHTbIBaTb TpaLlHUHH H npHHsIThle

HOpMhl nOBeLleHHsI HanpHMep He)f(enaHHe

25

naUHeHTOB-)KeHlllHH nOnYlJaTb nelJeHHe Y

nOKTOpoB-MY)KlJHH HnH npenCTaBHTeneH 6enHoro

CenbCKOrO HaCeneHHSI nelJHTbCSI B HenpHBbllJHblX

rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX

He )KenaSl OnnalJHBaTb TpaHcnopTHble

pacxollbl H HeCTH HenocpencTBeHHble y6bITKH

6enHoe HaceneHHe 3alJaCTYlO npennOlJHTaeT He

06paUlaTbCSI 3a MenHUHHCKOH nOMOUlbIO B TOM

cnylJae ecnH MenHUHHCKoe YlJpe)KneHHe

HaxonHTCSI naneKO a KalJeCTBO npennaraeMoro TaM

MellHUHHCKoro 06cnY)KHBaHHSI XOTSI H

cy6cHnHpOBaHHoro B 3HalJHTenbHOH CTeneHH

rocynapcTBOM HaxonHTCSI Ha OlJeHb HH3KOM

ypOBHe EaHK HaMepeH nenaTb ynop Ha

Heo6xonHMbie Mepbl cTHMynHpylOUlHe

COOTBeTCTBYIOUlHH cnpoc H

MenHUHHCKHX ycnyr B TaKHX ycnoBHSlX YlJHTblBaSl

TpanHUHOHHble ceMeHHble KonneKTHBbl

npH OKa3aHHH nOMOlllH HaH60nee 6enHbiM

CTpaHaM Me)KnYHaponHoe coo6UleCTBO nOHopOB

nOn)KHO TaK)Ke nepeHTH OT OTnenbHblX

MeponpHflHH K 60nee CKoopnHHHpOBaHHblM

YCHnHSlM B MaCllITa6ax BceH OTpacnH

UeHTpanbHOH 3analJeH 6yneT SlBnflbCSI

YKpenneHHe npo~eCCHOHanbHoro

ynpaBneHlJeCKOrO H nOnHTHlJeCKOrO nOTeHUHana

CHH)KeHHe C TelJeHHeM BpeMeHH 3aBHCHMOCTH

CTpaHbl OT nOHopCKOH nOMOlllH H o6ecnelJeHHe

MHHHManbHo-npHeMneMoro ypOBHSI Ba)KHeHllIHX

ycnyr B cqepe 3npaBOOXpaHeHHSI nHTaHHSI H

nnaHHpOBaHHSI ceMbH KOTOPblH MO)KeT OKa3aTbCSI

H HH)Ke )KenaeMOro ypOBHSI HnH B03MO)KHOrO B

ycnoBHSlX 60nee 60raTbiX CTpaH B HeKOTopblX

CTpaHax npecnenYlOlllHX cpenHeCpOlJHble H

nonrOCpOlJHble 3analJH 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO pOCTa

Y)Ke B03HHKna CpOlJHaSl Heo6xOllHMOCTb B TaKHX

neHCTBHSIX C TeM lJTo6bl YCTpaHHTb

06pa30BaBllIHHCSI ne~HUHT B ~HHaHCHpOBaHHH

EaHK TaK)Ke MO)KeT BHeCTH 3aMeTHblH

BKnan B ynYlJllIeHHe COCTOSlHHSI 3nopOBbSl 6enHoro

HaceneHHSI Ha Me)KCTpaHOBOM H perHOHanbHOM

ypOBHe nporpaMMa KOHTponSl OHxouepK03a

KOMHTeT no HaponOHaceneHHIO A~PHKH H

3KcnepTHaSl rpynna no Y JIyIUJeHUIO 300POBb$l B

cmpaHax ArjJPUKU OKa3bIBalOT nOMOIUb B

npHMeHeHHH Me)KnYHapOnHbiX HHHUHaTHB B

peanHSlX A~PHKH H nepenalJe HHHUHaTHBbl B pyKH

caMHX aqpHKaHCKHX rocynapCTB KaK B Bonpocax

60Pb6bl C 3a6oneBaHHSlMH (ManSlpHSI) HnH

CHH)KeHHSI neqHUHTa MHKponHTaTenbHblX

BeUleCTB (HonHpOBaHHe conH)

Me)KrocynapCTBeHHble MeponpHSlTHSI HMelOT

3HalJHTenbHblH nOTeHUHan nnSl OKa3aHHSI nOMOUlH

6enHeHllIHM CTpaHaM MHpa

H nocnenHee EaHK 6yneT cTHMynHpoBaTb

rocynapcTBa K pellleHHIO lJaCTO HrHopHpyeMblx

Me)KOTpaCneBbiX npo6neM (BKnlOlJaSl

nponOBonbCTBeHHYIO H cenbCKOX03S1HCTBeHHYIO

nonHTHKy oxpaHy oKpY)KaIOUlei1 cpenbl

06eCnelJeHHe KaHanH3aUHeH BonOCHa6)KeHHeM H

TpaHcnopTOM) KOTopble HMelOT BnHSlHHe Ha

3nopOBbe nlOneH B lJaCTHOCTH EaHK 6yneT

nOOIUpflb npaBHTenbCTBa npOBonHTb

pelllHTenbHYIO nonHTHKY npOTHBOCTOSlHHSI

MaCCOBOH npOna)KH H nOTpe6neHHSI Ta6alJHbiX

H3nenHH H anKoronbHblX HanHTKOB HMelOIUHM

nary6Hoe B03neHCTBHe Ha 3nopOBbe HaceneHHSI

UnSl peanH3aUHH TaKOH CTpaTerHH EaHKY

Heo6xonHMO 60nee TeCHO cOTpynHHlJaTb He

TonbKO C MHHHCTepCTBaMH 3L1paBOOXpaHeHHSI HO

H npyrHMH MHHHCTepCTBaMH H

3aHHTepeCOBaHHblMH nHuaMH 3aHHMalOlllHMHCSI

npo6neMaMH 6enHocTH H HaponoHaceneHHSI a

TaK)Ke OCHOBHblMH BonpocaMH HH~paCTpYKTYPbl H

cenbCKHX paHOHOB B caMOM EaHKe 60nee TeCHbie

CBSl3H 6ynyT YCTaHOBneHbl Me)Kny

06benHHeHHSlMH cneUHanHCTOB EaHKa B 06nacTH

pa3BHTHSI COUHanbHblX pecypcoB CHH)KeHHSI

ypoBHSI 6enHOCTH 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO ynpaBneHHSI

3aUlHTbi OKpY)KaIOUleH cpenbl H COUHanbHO

YCTOHlJHBOrO pa3BHTHSI 3TO nOMO)KeT BKnlOlJHTb

nporpaMMbl nOMOUlH 6enHOMY HaceneHHIO B c~epe

3nH B CTpaTerHH HCKopeHeHHSI 6enHOCTH H

pa3BHTHSI cena

lIpuopumem 2 B cdiepe 31IH COTpY~HH1faTb C rocy~apcTBaMH no yny1fllleHHIO paooTbI CHCTeMbI 3~paBooxpaHeHHSI OKa3b1BaSl no~~ep)lKy B ooeCne1feHHH paBHoro ~ocTyna HaceneHHSI K ne1feOHOshynpoltpHnaKTH1feCKHM ycnyraM KOTopble ObUIH ObI He~oporHMH

26

3IPIPeKTUBHhlMU KaqeCTBeHHhlMU U

COOTBeTCTBOBanU Obi 3anpOCaM

KnUeHTOB

He06xoJlHMOCTh B npOBeJleHHH

llIHpOKOMaCllITa6HhIX OTpaCneBhIX peqopM lIaCTO

B03HHKaeT B CTpaHaX HMeIOll(HX cephe3Hhle

CHCTeMHhle HeJlOCTaTKH B ccpepe 3nH npH

HeKOTophIX COBnaJleHHjlX nOlXOJl Hcnonh3yeMhIH

B CTpaHaX C HH3KHM ypOBHeM JlOXOJla CKOpee BCerO

6yJleT OTnHlIaThCjI OT nOJlXOJla npHMeHHMOrO B

ycnoBHjlX CTpaH CO CpeJlHHM ypOBHeM JlOXOJla B

CTpaHaX C HH3KHM ypOBHeM JlOXOJla rJle lIaCTHhIH

ceKTOp lIaCTO JlOMHHHpyeT (CMnpHnOJKeHHe A nepelleHh CTpaH B KOTOPhIX Gonee 70 paCXOJlOB

Ha 3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHe npHXOJlHTCjI Ha lIaCTHhIH

ceKTOp) 6YJleT noorupjlThCjI COCpeJlOTOlleHHe

BHHMaHHjI rocYJlapCTBa Ha OKa3aHHH ycnyr

HMeIOll(HX IllHpOKOMaCllITa6HhIH 3cxlgteKT

(npocpHnaKTHlIecKHe MepOnpHjlTHjI C ccpepe

06ruecTBeHHoro 3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI)

npeJlOCTaBneHHH BaJKHeHllIHX ycnyr 6eJlHOMY

HaceneHHIO no nelleHHIO 3a60neBaHHH 60nee 3cpcpeKTHBHoM perynHpoBaHHH lIaCTHOro ceKTopa

YKpenneHHH ynpaBneHlIecKoro nOTeHUHana

nOJllepJKKe HccneJloBaTenhcKoH paGoThI H

MeJlHUHHCKOro 06pa30BaHHjI o6ecnelleHHH

YCToHlIHBoro cpHHaHcHpOBaHHjI (CM npHOpHTeT 3 B ccpepe 3nH) KalleCTBa H YJloBneTBopeHHocTH

nOTpe6HTeneH nonYlleHHhIMH ycnyraMH

EaHK 6yJleT nOOIUpjlTh npaBHTenhCTBa

HeKoTophIX cTpaHax C HH3KHM ypoBHeM JlOXOJla H

MHorHX cTpaH co cpeJlHHM ypoBHeM JlOXOJla r Jle

JlOMHHHpyeT rocYJlapCTBeHHhIH ceKTop

(CMnpHnOJKeHHe A nepelleHh CTpaH B KOTOPhlX

60nee 70 paCXOJlOB Ha 3JlpaBooxpaHeHHe

npHXOJlHTCjI Ha rocyJlapCTBeHHhlH ceKTop)

pa3Hoo6pa3HTh qoPMhI npeJlOCTaBneHHjI

MeJlHUHHCKHX ycnyr nYTeM npeJloCTaBneHHjI

cpHHaHcHpoBaHHjI Ha KOHKypeHTHOH OCHOBe

rocyJlapCTBeHHhIM H HerocyJlapcTBeHHhIM

npOH3BOJlHTenjlM He orpaHHlIHBaji npaKTHKy

cpHHaHCHpOBaHHjI npeJlOCTaBneHHeM CpeJlCTB nHIllh

rocyJlapCTBeHHhIM YllpeJKJleHHjlM Bo MHorHX

cnYllajlx BOCCTaHOBneHHe 6anaHca MeJKJlY

rocyJlapCTBOM H 4aCTHhIM ceKTopOM

npeJlnOllTHTenhHee npOCTOH npHBaTH3aUHH

rocyJlapCTBeHHOH co6CTBeHHOCTH

KBa3HphIHOllHhle MexaHH3MhI BKnIOlI~ Bayllephl

KOHTpaKTHpOBaHHe onpeJleneHHhIX ycnyr H

yCTaHoBJlCHHC 06paTHOH CBjl3H C nOTpe6HTenjlMH

MeJlHUHHCKHX ycnyr MoryT y nyllllIHTh

pe3ynhTaThI paGoThI roCYJlapCTBeHHoro ceKTopa H

nOBhICHTh 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTh YllaCTHjI lIaCTHOrO

ceKTopa

B Tex cnYllajlX KOrJla opraHH3aUHOHHhIH

nOTeHUHan Jlnjl cpHHaHCHpOBaHHjI H

perynHpoBaHHjI OTpacnH HeJlOCTaTOlleH

npeJlnOllTHTeneH nOCTeneHHhIH nOJlXOJl C ynopoM

Ha JleueHTpanH3aUHIO H BHyTpeHHHe phIHKH

HeJKenH lIeM aKTHBHaji nepeJlalla rocyJlapCTBeHHOH

c06CTBeHHOCTH B lIaCTHhle pyKH COnpOBOJKJlaeMaji

BceMH n0601lHhIMH KaJlpOBhIMH H nonHTHlIeCKHM

nocneJlCTBHjlMH B 60nee CHnhHhIX

opraHH3aUHOHHhIX ycnOBHjlX KOrJla HMeeTCjI

3cpcpeKTHBHhiH nOTeHUHan Jlnjl perynHpoBaHHjI H

ynpaBneHHjI OTpacnH MOJKeT noorupjIThCjI Gonee

aKTHBHOC YllaCTHe lIaCTHhIX npOH3BOJlHTeneH

ycnyr

npaBHTenhCTBa JlOnJKHhI CTaTh Gonee

3cpcpeKTHBHhIMH B pa3pa60TKe nonHTHKH

OTpacneBOM ynpaBneHHH oueHKe pe3ynhTaToB H

perYJ1HpOBaHHH He06xoJlHMO nOOIUpjITh

rOCYJlapCTBeHHhIH H HerOCYJlapCTBeHHhIH ceKTOp

(npocpeCCHOHanhHhle aCCOUHaUHH rpynnhI

nOTpe6HTeneH H aKaJleMHlIeCKHe HHCTHTYThI) B

HCCneJlOBaHHH BonpOCOB CBjI3aHHhIX C

y nYllIlleHHeM JlOcTyna 3cpcpeKTHBHOCThIO

OTJlenhHhIX MepOnpHjlTHH ynpaBneHHjI K0UTponjl

KalleCTBa H pearHpoBaHHjI Ha 3anpOChI KnHeHTOB

3cpcpeKTHBHhle CTHMYnhI H MexaHH3MhI onnaThI

ycnyr MoryT BHeCTH 3HallHTenhHhIH BKnaJl B

ynYllIlleHHe pe3ynhTaToB pa60ThI CHCTeM

3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI

[VIji peanH3aUHH 3TOH CTpaTerHH EaHK

JlOnJKeH Gonee TeCHO COTpYJlHHlIaTh He TonhKO C

MHHHCTepCTBaMH 3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI HO H C

MHHHCTepcTBaMH 3aHHMaIOll(HMHCjI BonpocaMH

cpHHaHCHpoBaHHjI npHBaTH3aUHH H

nnaHHpoBaHHjI B paMKax DaHKa 60nee TeCHhle

CBjl3H 6YJlYT YCTaHoBneHhI C MltlgtK H OrJlenOM

cpHHaHcHpoBaHHjI lIaCTHOro ceKTopa H

HHcppaCTpYKTYPhI liTO nocnYJKHT 60nee

3cpcpeKTHBHOMY Hcnonh30BaHHIO HaKonneHHoro

onhITa B 06naCTH nepeJlallH 06beKTOB COUHanhHOH

27

ClPephl B IaCTHhle PYKH H OKa)KeT COneHCTBHe B

npHTOKe IPHHaHCOBhlX CpenCTB B

HerocynapCTBeHHhlH CeKTOp

llpuopumem 3 B cgiepe 3llH Eonee

TeCHoe COTpYAHHIeCTBO C

rocYAapcTBaMH no ooeCneleHHlO

YCTOHIHBOrO qJHHaHcHpoBaHHSI

3ApaBooxpaHeHHSI nYTeM

MooHnH3aUHH HeooxoAHMblX pecypcoB

C03AaHHSI llIHpOKOMacllITaoHhlx

MexaHH3MOB COBMemeHHSI PHCKOB H

nOAAepgtKaHHSI 3qJqJeKTHBHoro

KOHTponSi 3a rocYAapcTBeHHblMH H

IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH

OnhlT 60nhlllHHcTBa CTpaH C HH3KHM H

cpenHHM ypoBHeM noxona H cTpaH 03CP

nOKa3hlBaeT ITO rocynapCTBO nOn)KHO HrpaTh

Ba)KHeHlll)1O ponh B IPHHaHCHpOBaHHH

3npaBooxpaHeHHjI nYTeM perynHpoBaHHjI BhlnalH

CneUHaJIhHhlX MaHnaTOB H npjlMOrO

CyOCHJlHpOBaHHjI LJa)Ke npH HaJIHIHH

3HalHTenhHh1X 1aCTHhIX pecypCOB He31PlPeKTHBHOe

rocynapCTBeHHoe ynpaBneHHe MO)KeT npHBeCTH

TOMY ITO 3TH pecypchl oynyT BnycTylO

nOTpaleHhl Ha He31PIPeKTHBHoe neleHHe

YIHThlBaji TaKOH onhlT EaHK nOn)KeH He

npOCTO npenOCTaBnjITh cpenCTBa Ha KanHTaJIhHhle

3aTpaThl a 3aHjlTh oonee aKTHBHYIO n03HUHIO B

OKa3aHHH nOMOlllH CTpaHaM no 06eCneleHHIO

YCTOHIHBOrO YPOBHjI IPHHaHCHpOBaHHjI nporpaMM B

oonaCTH 3nH OnpeneneHHoe COleTaHHe

HHCTpYMeHTOB HaJIOrOOOnO)KeHHjI (COUHaJIhHoe

CTpaXOBaHHe H OOlllHe OIOJl)KeTHhle nocTynneHHjI)

H 1aCTHIHOH onnaThl ycnyr nOTpeOHTenjlMH

nOn)KHO 3aBHceTh OT KOHKpeTHhlX ycnoBHH

Ka)KnOH CTpaHhI B CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM

noxona HeooxonHMO npHnO)KHTh 3HalHTenhHhle

YCHnHjI MjI nonOnHeHHjI rocynapcTBeHHoro

IPHHaHCHpOBaHHjI cpenCTBaMH H3

HerocynapcTBeHHhlX HCTOlHHKOB H

Me)i(nYHaponHOH nOMOlllH (CMnpHnO)KeHHe A nepeleHh CTpaH C HH3KHM ypOBHeM noxona He

cnOCOOHhlX 06ecnelHTh MHHHMaJIhHO-

HeooxonHMblH ypOBeHh IPHHaHCHpOBaHHjI

OCHOBHhlX ycnyr MjI oenuoro HaCeneHHjI) B

CTpaHax CO CpenuHM H BhlCOKHM ypoBHeM nOXona

HHCTpYMeHThl HaJIOrOOOnO)KeHHjI CTaHOBjlTCjI

oonee 31PIPCKTHBHhiM cpenCTBOM MOOHnH3aUHH

IPHHaHCOBhlX pecypcoB H paClllHpeHHjI npaKTHKH

COBMCllleHHjI pHCKOB Ocoooe BHHMaHHe oyneT

y neneHO nOOOlHhIM nocnenCTBHjlM Wljl OlOn)KeTa

H phlHKa paOOleH CHnhl (CMnpHnO)KeHHe A

nepeleHh CTpaH TpaTjllllHX oonblllHe OObeMhl

cpencTB H HMelOlllHe nOTeHUHanhHhle npooneMhl

IPHcKanhHoro xapaKTepa)

rocynapcTBa TaK)Ke oynYT nOnnep)KHBaTh

31PIPeKTHBHhiH KOHTponh 3a pacxonaMH H

oOeCnelHBaTh 31PIPeKTHBHoe Hcnonh30BaHHe

OIOJl)KeTHhIX CpencTB BhlnenjleMhlX Ha clPepy

3nH MjI OKa3aHHjI 31PIPeKTHBHoro H

KaleCTBeHHoro MenHUHHCKoro oocnY)KHBaHHjI

rpynn HaCeneHHjI HaHoonee B HeM HY)KnalOlllHXCjI

OnhlT nOKa3aJI ITO Korna CTpaHhl CO

cpenHHM ypOBHeM noxona paClllHpjllOT OObeM

OKa3hIBaeMhiX ycnyr H HalHHaIOT Hcnonh30BaTh

BeCh Haoop IPHHaHCOBhlX HHCTpYMeHTOB

HeooxonHMhl pelllHTenhHhle neHCTBHjI no

Cnep)KHBaHHIO CTpeMHTenhHoro pOCTa pacxonOB B

OTpacnH 3npaBooxpaHeHHjI KaK 3TO npoH30lllJlO B

ApreHTHHe lJelllcKoH PecnyonHKe HopnaHHH H

IO)KHOH AlPpHKe EaHK oyneT aKTHBHO H3YlaTh

BonpOChl KacalOlllHeCjI npenOCTaBneHHjI nOMOIllH

TaKHM CTPaHaM

LJnjl peanH3aUHH TaKOH CTpaTerHH EaHKY

HeooxonHMO oonee TeCHO cOTpynHHIaTh He

TonhKO C MHHHCTepcTBaMH 3npaBooxpaHeHHjI HO

H C MHHHCTepCTBaMH IPHHaHCOB H COUHaJIhHOH

3alllHThl jlBnjlI()lllHMHCjI OCHOBHhlMH

YlaCTHHKaMH B 3TOH 06nacTH rpynna no

BonpocaM 3nH oyneT TeCHO cOTpynHHIaTh C

OObenHHeHHeM CneUHaJIHCTOB EaHKa no BonpocaM

CHH)KeHHjI ypOBHjI oenHOCTH H ynpaBneHHjI

3KOHOMHKOH

YcuneHue B03AeucTBuR u nOBblmeHue pe3ynbTaTuBHOCTu

EaHK HalaJI paClllHpeHHe CBoeH nejITenhHOCTH B

oonaCTH 3nH IIpHMepHO neCjlTh neT Ha3an

BcnenCTBHe OhlCTPOrO pOCTa 1HCna npoeKTOB

Ohino nOBonhHO CnO)KHO OOeCnelHTh onHHaKOBoe

KaleCTBO TaK)Ke HaOnlOnaJIaCh HeKOTOp~

IPparMeHTapHOCTh nejITenhHOCTH OnHaKO

28

OCHOBHYIO TpeBory BhI3hlBaIOT B03LleHCTBHe H

pe3ynhTaTHBHOCTh npOeKTOB llnjl BhmOnHeHHjI

CTpaTerHH H3nO)KeHHOH B LlaHHoM LloKYMeHTe

MaKCHMH3aUHH B03LleHCTBHjI HHBeCTHUHH H

06eCneleHHjI nOnYIeHHjI KnHeHTaMH ycnyr

BhlCOKOrO KaleCTBa naHKY He06xOLlHMO

CneLloBaTh 1eThlpeM npHHUHnaM ynop Ha

CTpaTerHIeCKYIO HanpaBneHHOCTh nonHTHKH B

06naCTH 3nH nOLlKpenneHHe KpeLlHTOBaHHjI

aHanH30M H HCCneLlOBaHHjlMH 60nhlllaji

H36HpaTenhHOCTh B npOeKTaX H ynylllleHHe

06CnY)KHBaHHjI CTpaH-KnHeHTOB HH)Ke 3TH

npHHUHnhl npeLlCTaBneHhl B 60nee nOLlp06HOM

H3nO)KeHHH

Ynop Ha crpaTerHqeCKHe npHopHTeTbl

nOJIHTHKH B OOJIaCTH 3DH

CTpaTerHH pa3BHTHjI B 06naCTH 3nH

OXBaThlBaIOT nepHoLl OT 10 LlO 15 neT ITO

npeBhllllaeT UHKn 60nhlllHHCTBa npoeKToB (5-8 neT) H HHLlHBHLlyanhHhle 3aLlaHHjI COTPYLlHHKOB

naHKa (1-4 rOlla) YIHThIBaji TaKYIO np06neMY

1pe3BhllaHHO Ba)KHO coCpeLlOTOlHTh KOHKpeTHhle

CTpaTerHH B 06nacTH 3nH H3nO)KeHHhle B

Ka)KLlOH H3 CTpaTerHH nOMOIl(H CTpaHe (CnC) a

TaK)Ke peKoMeHLlaUHH KpeLlHToBaHHe H

HccneLlOBaHHjI Ha cpeLlHeCpOlHhiX 3aLlalaX H

KpaTKOCpOlHhIX Mepax cooTBeTCTBYIOIl(HX TpeM

npHopHTeTHhlM 06naCTjlM B clgtepe 3nH

H3nO)KeHHhIM Bhlllle

CDC 6YLleT Hcnonh30BaHa B KaleCTBe

KnIOIeBOrO HHCTpYMeHTa nepeLlalH MHeHHjI naHKa

o npHopHTeTax B clgtepe 3nH B XOLle LlHanora C

PYKOBOLlHTenjlMH CTpaH CneUHanHcThl naHKa B

06naCTH 3nH 6YLlYT pa60TaTh B TeCHOM

COTpYLlHHIeCTBe co CTpaHOBhlMH OTLlenaMH no

nOLlrOTOBKe CTpaTerHH nOMOIl(H TeM CTpaHaM B

KOTOPhlX HMeIOTCjI HaH60nee Cephe3Hhie

CHCTeMHhle np06neMhi B OTpacnH 3nH

(CMnpHnO)KeHHe A Llfljl peHTHHra cTpaH no

Ka)KLloH npHopHTeTHoH 06nacTH 3nH)

CneUHanHcThl B 06nacTH 3nH TaK)Ke 6YLleT

COTpYLlHHIaTh 60nee TeCHhlM 06pa30M co

cneUHanHCTaMH B 06nacTH 06pa30BaHHjI H

cOUHanhHoH 3aWHThl Llfljl pa3pa60TKH

KOnHIeCTBeHHhIX nOKa3aTeneH IgtopMHpOBaHHjI

1enOBeleCKOrO KanHTana H npoH3BoLlHTenhHoCTH

TpyLla KOTophle MoryT 6hlTh BKnIOIeHhl B

aHanHTHIeCKYIO OCHOBY peKmteHLlaUHH

npeLlnaraeMhlx B Cnc PYKOBOLlCTBO naHK-a 6YLleT

BhI60pOlHO KOHTpOnHpOBaTh xOLl npoeKToB

pe3ynhTaThi pa60Thi CHCTeM 3LlpaBooxpaHeHHjI H

nOKa3aTenH IgtHHaHcHpOBaHHjI oTpacnH B cTpaHax

KOTophle HMeIOT 60nee BhlCOKHH ypOBeHh pHcKa

DOAKpenJIeHHe KpeAHToBaHHB

aHaJIHTHQeCKOH paooToH H HCCJ1eAOBaHHBMH

nO Mepe TOro KaK naHK npOLlOn)KaeT

nepeHocHTh ynop B CBoeH LleBTenhHOCTH

IgtH3HIeCKHX aKTHBOB H pe3ynhTaToB Ha npouecc

He06xoLlHMO 3KcnepHMeHTHpoBaTh H

OCMhlcnHBaTh nonYleHHhlH onhlT llnB 3Toro

He06xoLlHMO TluaTenhHO pa3pa6aThiBaTh

3KcnepHMeHTanhHhie npoeKThl KOHTponHpoBaTh

HX peanH3aUHIO H aHanH3HpoBaTh pe3ynhTaThl a

TaK)Ke LlenaTh 60nhlllHH ynop Ha pa3pa60TKY H

KOHTpOnh 3a BhmonHeHHeM HccneLlOBaTenhCKHX

KOMnOHeHTOB HHBeCTHUHOHHhlX npoeKToB

CneLlyeT 06paTHTh 60nhlUe BHHMaHHB Ha

(a) Bonpochl pearHpOBaHHjI OTLlenhHhlX nHU H

ceMeH Ha ueHoBYIO nonHTHKY KaleCTBO LlocTyn

MeLlHUHHCKoro 06cnY)KHBaHHjI H oxpaHhl

3LlOPOBhjl HaCeneHHjI KOHKpeTHhle MepOnpHjlTHjI

COleTaHHe rocYLlapCTBaiaCTHoro ceKTopa H

pa3nHIHhle acneKThl MeLlHUHHCKHX ycnyr (6)

noompeHHe nHU H ceMeH 6paTh BCIO nonHoTY

OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH Ha ce6j1 3a CBoe 3LlopOBhe H

YlaCTBOBaTh B npouecce npHHSITHjI pellleHHH (B)

H3YQeHHe lgtaKTopoB BnHjlIOIl(HX Ha pe3ynhTaThi

pa60Thi CHCTeMhl 3LlpaBooxpaHeHHjI BKnIOIajl

nonHTHIeCKYIO 3KOHOMHIO pelgtopM ynpaBneHHe H

opraHH3aUHOHHhie acneKThl (r) H3YleHHe

npouecca 06eCneleHHjI YCTOHIHBoro ypOBHjI

IgtHHaHCHpoBaHHjI 3LlpaBooxpaHeHHjI H cOBMellleHHjI

PHCKOB H Toro KaK Hcnonh30BaTh pe3ynhTaThl

nonYleHHhle B XOLle 0630pOB 3aTpaT Ha

3LlpaBooxpaHeHHe (HaceneHHjI H H3

rOCYLlapcTBeHHoro 6IOLl)KeTa OT rOCYLlapCTBeHHhlX

npeLlnpHsITHH) Llnjl onpeLleneHHjI OTpacneBhlX

npHopHTeTOB (pellleHHH 0 pacnpeLleneHHH

pecypCOB H CLlep)KHBaHHH pOCTa paCXOLlOB) (Ll)

OCMhicneHHe onhlTa pelgtOpMHpOBaHHjI CHCTeM

3LlpaBooxpaHeHHjI B LlpyrHx CTpaHax Llnjl 60nee

1eTKOrO nOHHMaHHjI B3aHMOOTHOlUeHHH Me)KLlY

Me)KOTpaCneBhIMH nonHTHKaMH pa60TOH

CHCTeMhl 3LlpaBooxpaHeHHjI IgtHHaHcHpOBaHHeM H

29

C

0

PeaJlH3aUHR TaKOH npOrpaMMbl Tpe6yeT OTKa3a OT nOnHTHKH COKpalleHHR 6lOn)feTa Ha OTpaCneBOH aHaJlH3 pOCTa 61Oll)feTa Ha HccnenOBaTenbCKYIO pa60TY nponOpUHOHaJlbHO pa3Mepy KpenHTHOrO nopTllenR B 06naCTH 3nH H nOnOnHHTenbHOro BblneneHHR pecypCOB Ha nnaHHpOBaHHe H peaJlH3aUHIO HHHOBaUHOHHblX npoeKTOB B 6ynYlleM rpynna no BonpocaM 3nH 6yneT ConeHCTBOBaTb 60nee 31llleKTHBHOMY Hcnonb30BaHHIO COTpynHHKaMH naHKa HaKonneHHoro onblTa (KaK nOnO)fHTenbHoro TaK H OTpHuaTenbHoro)

J)onbwaR H36HpaTenbHOCTb

nOCKonbKY naHK He MO)feT 3aHHMaTbCR BceM C onHHaKOBblM ycnexoM npHxonHTbCR nenaTb TpYnHblH Bbl60p B OTHOllleHHH Toro rne He06xOnHMo HenocpenCTBeHHoe YlaCTHe naHKa a rne 60nee pa3YMHO OKa3blBaTb nOnnep)fKY npyrHM opraHH3aUHRM HnH 1aCTHOMY ceKTopy n y neT npOnOn)feHO TecHoe cOTpynHHIecTBO C opraHH3aUHRMH-fiapTHepaMH TaKHMH KaK B03 B cornaCOBaHHH 1eTKOrO pa3neneHHR Tpyna Me)fny opraHH3aUHRMH ITO n03BOnHT nOnonHHTb neHTenbHOCTb npyr npyra H36eraR npH 3TOM ny6nHpOBaHHH KaleCTBO 6ynylUHx npoeKToB 6yneT ynylllleHO 6naronapR npouenypaM oroopa nonpa3YMeBalOllHM (a) conOCTaBneHHe npoeKTa C nOTpe6HOCTHMH CTpaHbl B TpeX npHOpHTeTHbIX 06naCTHx 3nH (6) 06neKTHBHYlO oueHKY nOTeHUHaJlbHblX BbIron (c ynopOM Ha MepOnpHHTHH HMelOllHe 3HalJHTenbHblH BHelllHHH 31l1leKT) H no6olJHbIX nOnHTHlJeCKHX 3KOHOMHIeCKHX H COUHaJlbHblX PHCKOB (B) 3aKnlOlJeHHe 0 HaJlHlJHH B CTpaHe npHBep)feHHOCTH npaBHTenbCTBa npoueccy pellopM

1136HpaTenbHblH nouxon B OTHOllleHHH nOTpe6HOCTeH CTpaH-KI1HeHTOB nOmKeH npHMeHHTbC~ co BCeH OCTOPO)fHOCTblO OnHHM H3 cnoco6oM y nylllleHHR nOnO)feHHR 6enHOrO HaCeneHHR B pe3ynbTaTe neHTenbHOCTH naHKa RBnReTCR KOHueHTpaUHR YCHHHH H pecypcoB Ha TeX CTpaHaX rne npO)fHBaeT 60nbllIaR nOnR 6enHoro HaCeneHHR (CMnpHnO)feHHe A fpynna CTpaH C HH3KHM ypOBHeM noxona)

llpyrHM cnoco6oM nOBblllleHHR 31llleKTHBHOCTH IlHHaHcHpOBaHHH CO CTOPOHbl naHKa RBnHeTCH H36HpaTenbHblH nouxon K IlHHaHCHpOBaHHIO npoeKTOB H MepOnpHHTHH YlHTbIBaIOIUHH CTeneHb BnHHHHH nHaJlOra nonHTHKe B o6nacTH IlHHaHcHpOBaHHH Me)fny naHKoM H npaBHTenbCTBoM cTpaHbl H MepOnpHHTHH npoeKTa Ha pacnpeneneHHe 61Oll)feTHbIX cpencTB CpenCTBa e)ferOnHO npenOCTaBnHeMble MAP HrpalOT 3HalHTenbHYIO ponb B 06lleM IlHHaHcHpoBaHHH 3npaBooxpaHeHHH B He60nblllHX 6enHbix CTpaHax (164 B CTpaHax IJeHTpaJlbHOH H IO)fHOH AllpHKH H 131 B cTpaHax IO)fHOH A3HH 3a HCKnlOIeHHeM HHnHH) HO He B KpynHblx CTpaHax (05 B KHTae H 07 B HHnHH) E)ferOnHaH nOMOllb MAP cTpaHaM co cpenHHM ypoBHeM noxona TaK)fe OTHOCHTenbHO HeBenHKa (06 B HopnaHHH 04 B nonbllIe

03 B ApreHTHHe H 02 B MeKcHKe)

B 3aBepllleHHH cnenyeT OTMeTHTb ITO cnc MO)feT CTaTb MOllHbIM HHCTpYMeHTOM nOBblllleHHR H36HpaTenbHOCTH neHTenbHOCTH naHKa nYTeM cocpenOTOleHHH Ha Tex Bonpocax B cllepe 3nH KOTopble Tpe6ylOT lllHpOKOMaCllITa6HbiX CHCTeMHblX H Me)fOTpacneBbIX MepOnpHHTHH H rne naHK HMeeT 60nblllee npeHMYlleCTBO no cpaBHeHHIO C npyrHMH opraHH3aUHHMH

YnYQWeHHe 06CJ1YgtKHBaHHH CTpaH-KJIHeHTOB

KalJeCTBO ycnyr npennaraeMbIX naHKOM CTpaHaM-KnHeHTaM B cllepe 3nH MO)feT 6blTb nOBblllleHO HeCKonbKHMH MeTonaMH Bo-nepBbIX naHK yKpenHT CBOIO HHIl0pMaUHOHHYIO 6a3y no 3nH 3TO BKI1lOlJaeT (a) C03naHHe TH nOCTOB nOMOllH no BonpocaM 3nH (6) C03naHHe KOMnblOTepHoH 6a3bl naHHblX no nOKYMeHTaM 0 nonHTHKe HaHnYlJllleH npaKTHKe 3neKTpoHHbiM ll0pYMaM TeXHHlJeCKHM 3anaHHHM npollHnlO nepCOHaJla H KOHcynbTaHToB BHelllHHM pecypcaM (B) C03naHHe 6a3bl naHHblX no TeHneHUHHM B paCXonOBaHHH cpenCTB Ha HY)fnbl 3npaBooxpaHeHHR H npenOCTaBneHHe npOlJeH HHllopMaUHH no cllepe 3nH H (r) C03naHHe 6a3bl naHHblX no npOlJHM acneKTaM cllepbI 3nH BKnlOIaR cnpoc H Hcnonb30BaHHe nOBeneHHe npOH3BonHTeneH H pblHKH 3npaBooxpaHeHHH

30

EaHK TaKJKe fiyneT OTCneJKHBaTb nYlJlllHe

npHMepbl MHPOBOH npaKTHKH B ccpepe 3nH a

TaKJKe TeHneHUHH pa3BHTHSI naHHOH OTpacnH

BO-BTOPblX HeofixonHMO TpaTHTb 60nbllle

BpeMeHH H YCHnHH Ha H3YlJeHHe pe3ynbTaToB

pafiOTbl KpenHTHoro nopTcpenSl H 60nee CHCTeMaTHlJeCKOe npHMeHeHHe H3BnelJeHHblX

ypOKOB B xone nnaHHpOBaHHSI H peanH3aUHH

npoeKTa AnSl 3Toro HeofixonHMO onpenenHTb Te

3neMeHTbl KOTopble ofieCnelJHBalOT

KalJeCTBeHHOCTb npoeKTa nYTeM npHMeHeHHSI

HMeIOIUHXCSI HHCTpYMeHTOB OTpacneBoro

3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO opraHH3aUHOHHoro aHanH3a H

oueHKH nOTeHUHanbHoro pHCKa Eonbllle BpeMeHH

HeofixonHMO ynenSITb anpofiaUHH HOBblX

nonxonoB BKnlOlJaSl IllHpOKOMaCllITafiHble

OTpacneBble peCPOPMbl H napTHepCTBO rocynapcTBa

H lJaCTHOro ceKTopa npoeKTbl KOTopble SIBHO He

ynanHcb H He CMornH BbInOnHHTb nOCTaBneHHble

3analJH pa3BHTHSI fiynyT peCTpYKTypHpOBaHbl HnH

npeKpaIUeHbl no HCTelJeHHH pa3yMHoshy

npHeMneMoro cpOKa Y CHnHSI fiynyT

npennpHHSITbl no H3YlJeHHlO B03neHCTBHSI

BHeIllHHX cpaKTopOB TaKHX KaK coxpaHeHHe

npHBepJKeHHOCTH K BblfipaHHOH nonHTHKe npH

CMeHe npaBHTenbCTB HHCTHTYUHOHanbHoe

npOTHBOCTOSlHHe pecpopMaM Korna HHTepeCbl

OTnenbHblX rpynn nOCTaBneHbl non yrp03y

npoueCCOM npeOfipa30BaHHH

B-TpeTbHX fiyneT onpofiOBaH fionee

rHfiKHH H IllHpOKHH Ha60p HHCTpYMeHTOB

KpenHTOBaHHSI JrO npenYCMaTpHBaeT fionbillee

Hcnonb30BaHHe IllHpoKHX OTpacneBblX nonXonOB H

3aHMOB MSI nOnnepJKKH CHCTeMHblX pecpopM

HOBblX MHKPO MHHH H ananTHpOBaHHblX

HHBeCTHUHOHHblX 3aHMOB no Mepe HX HanHlJHSI

Hcnonb30BaHHe fionee MenKHX H HHHOBaUHOHHblX

3aHMOB nOMOJKeT H3fieJKaTb CnOJKHblX

nonKOMnOHeHTOB HMeIOIUHXCSI B THnOBOH

CTpyKType cpHHaHcHpyeMoro EaHKOM npoeKTa

EaHK JKe npHcTynHn K H3YlJeHHlO Bonpoca ofi

Hcnonb30BaHHH fionee npOCTblX H rHfiKHX

npouenyp npH npOBeneHHH 3aKynoK H ofipa60TKH

nOKYMeHTaUHH

YlJHTblBaSl BaJKHOCTb KalJeCTBeHHOrO

npOBeneHHSI OueHOK nOTpefiHOCTeH nOTpefiHTeneH

H KOMMYHHKaUHOHHblX CTpaTerHH B ccpepe 3DH

fiynyT npOBOnHTbCSI onpOCbl HaCeneHHSI nnSl

BblSlCHeHHSI CTeneHH ynoBneTBopeHHSI ycnyraMH

Hx pC3ynbTaTbl fiynYT Hcnonb30BaTbCSI npH

pa3pafioTKe fiynYIUHX npoeKTOB

MOHHTopHHr B03AeiicTBHH AeHTenbHOCTH

EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe

KOHelJHOH 3analJeH neSITenbHOCTH EaHKa B

OTpacnH 3nH SIBnSleTCSI ynYlJllleHHe nOKa3aTeneH

B 3TOH ccpepe COBepIlleHCTBOBaHHe pafiOTbl CHCTeM

3npaBooxpaHeHHSI H HX cpHHaHCHpOBaHHSI EaHKY

HeofixonHMO npHHSITb Mepbl no YKpenneHHIO

cofiCTBeHHoro nOTeHUHana H nOTeHUHana

3aeMIUHKOB no npoBeneHHIO MOHHTopHHra H

aHanH3a nporpecca B nOCTHJKeHHH nOCTaBneHHblX

3analJ

B TafinHuax npHnOJKeHHSI A cofipaHa

HHcpopMaUHSI ofi OCHOBHblX npofineMax B ccpepe

3nH no BCeM cTpaHaM MHpa a TaKJKe OTnenbHO

no CTpaHaM C HH3KHM cpenHHM H BblCOKHM

ypoBHeM noxona H perHoHaM B KOTOPblX

3aneHcTBoBaH EaHK 3necb TaKJKe npHBeneHbl

pe3ynbTaTbl pafioTbl B Tpex npHopHTeTHblx

ofinacTSIx 3nH Ha OCHOBaHHH 06IUHX

3KOHOMHlJeCKHX H npOlJHX COUHanbHblX

neTepMHHaHTOB nOKa3aTeneH B ccpepe 3nOpOBbSl

nHTaHHSI HaponoHaCeneHHSI cpHHaHcHpoBaHHSI

CHCTeM 3npaBooxpaHeHHSI H npOlJHX naHHblX

YKa3blBalOIUHx Ha fiynYIUHe npofineMbl B ccpepe

3nH

nepelJeHb nOKa3aTeneH MSI oueHKH

pafioTbl CHCTeMbl 3npaBooxpaHeHHSI nOnJKeH fiblTb

ynYlJllleH B cOTpynHHlJeCTBe C npyrHMH

MeJKnYHap0nHblMH opraHH3aUHSIMH H cTpaHaMHshy

KnHeHTaMH E aHK nonrOTOBHT nepelJeHb 60nee 3cpcpeKTHBHblX nOKa3aTeneH a TaKJKe nponYMaeT

cHcTeMY cTHMynoB MSI noolUPeHHSI HX

Hcnonb30BaHHSI Ha rrpaKTHKe (npH3HaHHe

B03HarpaJKneHHe npoBepKH) H BKnlOlJHT

MOHHTopHHr H aHanH3 nocTHrHYTblx pe3ynbTaToB

B npoeKTbl KaK HeOTbeMneMYIO lJaCTb HX

CTpyKTYPbl DporH03bl 0 B03neHcTBHH npoeKTHblx

MepOnpHSITHH Ha 3TH nOKa3aTenH fiynyT

onpenenSITb COnepJKaHHe fiynyIUHx npoeKTOB H

peCTpYKTYpH3aUHlO HMeIOIUerOCSI KpellHTHOrO

nopTcpenSl

31

KaAPOBoe OfieCneqeHHe pafiOThI bull I

C03naHHe 06benHHeHH~ CneUHanHCTOB l3aHKa H COBeTa no pa3BHTHIO COUHanhHhlX pecypcoB rpynnhl no BonpocaM 3nH OrpacneBoro COBeTa H PerHOHanhHhlX ceKTopOB (cMPHcD2 B npHnO)l(eHHH D) 3anO)l(HnO OCHOBhl nn~ ynylfllleHH~ B 06naCTH npotPeccHoHanhHoro pa3BHTH~ nepcoHana H cOBepllleHcTBoBaHH~

ynpaBneHH~ OCHOBHhlMH KanpoBhlMH BonpocaMH CB~3aHHhIMH C YKpenneHHeM nOTeHUHana l3aHKa nn~ BhmonHeHH~ nOCTaBneHHhlX 3analf B OTpacnH 3nH ~Bn~IOTC~ KalfeCTBeHHhlH H KonHlfeCTBeHHhlH COCTaB KanpoB H HX pa3MemeHHe

Bo-nepBhIX 6ynYT H3MeHeHhi nonHTHKa HaHMa HOBhlX KanpoB B03MO)l(HOCTH 06ylfeHH~

nepcoHana H npotPeccHoHanhHhle Tpe60BaHH~ K cneUHanHCTaM B 06naCTH 3nH C TeM lfT06hl OHH OTpa)KanH KOHKpeTHhle cTpaTerHlfecKHe HanpaBneHH~ npHOpHTeTHoH 3analfeH ~Bn~eTC~ tPopMHpoBaHHe KanpoBoro COCTaBa 06nanaIOmero BceH nonHOTOH H lllHPOTOH np0tPeccHoHanhHhlx 3HaHHH H YMeHHH He06xonHMhix nn~

3tPtPeKTHBHoro pellleHH~ 60nhllloro KOnHlfeCTBa BonpocoB B Tpex npHopHTeTHhlx 06naCT~X 3nH OC06hlH ynop 6yneT cnenaH Ha pa60THHKOB 06nanaIOlllHx npaKTHlfecKHM onhlTOM B OTpacnH 3nH cnoc06HhiX pa60TaTh co CnO)KHhIMH np06neMaMH cTpaTerHlfecKoro xapaKTepa H nOHHMaIOmHX nonHTHlfeCKYIO 3KOHOMHIO npoueccoB petP0pM

Bo-BTOphIX He06xonHMo H3MeHHTh COOTHOllleHHe nepcoHana B oTpacnH 3nH nn~ Toro lfT06hl 06beM H TeMnhl pocTa KpenHTHoro nopTtPen~ B 3TOH 06naCTH 6hlnH 6hl 06ecnelfeHhl COOTBeTCTBYIOmHMH KanpaMH 3a npolllnhie 10 neT KpenHTOBaHHe B 06naCTH 3nH pocno 60nee BhlCOKHMH TeMnaMH lfeM KonHlfeCTBO nepCOHana nepCOHan cneUHanH3HpyIOmHHc~ B 06naCTH 3nH BhlpOC Ha 86 B 1986-1996 tPHHaHcoBhlX rr B TO BpeM~ KaK KpenHTOBaHHe Bhlpocno Ha 272 B nocnenHee BpeM~ cpenHeronoBoH TeMn pOCTa nepcoHana B 6 nponon)Kan OTCTaBaTh OT 13shyoro e)KerOnHOro pOCTa OObeMOB KpenHToBaHH~

npennonaraeTc~ lfTO HOBa~ CTpyKTypa np0tPeCCHOHanhHhlX 06benHHeHHH cneUHanHCTOB naHKa oyneT cnOCOOCTBOBaTh ynylllleHHIO

3tPtPeKTHBHOCTH pa60Thi nepCOHana Bonpoc KanpOBOH 06ecnelfeHHOCTH neTIenhHOCTH l3aHKa B ctPepe 3nH ~Bn~eTC~ onHOH H3 nepBOOlfcpenHhlX

3anal

B 3aBcpllleHHH cnenYCT OTMeTHTh He06xonHMOCTh nanhHeHlllero H3yleHH~ DBYX nonxonOB anpooHpyeMhlx B HaCTo~mee BpeM~ B uen~x yCTaHoBneHH~ 60nee TeCHoro cOTpynHHlfecTBa Me)Kny nepcOHanOM l3aHKa H CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH OnHH nonxon OCHOBhIBaeTC~ Ha onhlTe pa60Thi nOCTO~HHOH

MHCCHH B HHnHH H COCTOHT B TOM ITO B CTpaHe C03naeTC~ rpynna H3 MeCTHhlX cneUHanHCTOB a pYKOBonHTh ee paOOTOH Ha3HalfaeTC~ 6aHKOBCKHH COTPYnHHK CTaplllero 3BeHa llpyroH nonxon COCTOHT B KoopnHHaUHH pa60Thi nepCOHana HeCKonhKHX nOCTO~HHhIX MHCCHH lfepe3 perHOHanhHhlH lllTa6 l3aHKa npHMepOM TaKoro nonxona MO)KeT cnY)KHTh rpynna pa3BHTH~

COUHaIlhHhlX pecypcoB B nOCTO~HHOH MHCCHH B l3ynanelllTe B Tex cnylfa~x Korna np~MOH

KOHTaKT Me)Kny pa60THHKaMH lllTa6-KBapTHphl naHKa MHCCH~MH H KnHeHTaMH HeB03MO)KeH ynYlfllleHHhle cpenCTBa KOMMYHHKaUHOHHOH CB~3H HrpaIOT Ba)KHYIO ponh

YTO )Ke KacaeTC~ MepOnpHTIHH no 06YlfeHHIO rpynna 3nH nOMO)KeT yB~3aTh

nporpaMMhl nOBhlllleHH~ KBanHtPHKaUHH COTPYnHHKOB naHKa C ynoM~HyThlMH TpeM~

CTpaTerHlfeCKHMH HanpaBneHH~MH YlfeOHhle nporpaMMhl 6ynyT paCClfHTaHhl Ha YlfaCTHe He TonhKO cOTpynHHKoB l3aHKa HO H Ha npenCTaBHTeneH CTpaH-KnHeHTOB TaK)Ke nnaHHpyeTc~ paClllHpHTh YlfaCTHe B 3THX nporpaMMax COTPYnHHKOB nOCTO~HHhIX

npenCTaBHTenhCTB l3aHKa H3 pa3nHlfHhiX CTpaH H cneUHanHCTOB H3 npyrHx ceKTopOB

YKpenneHHe napTHepCTBa

un~ peanH3aUHH 3analf pa3BHTH~ 21 BeKa l3aHK Hy)KnaeTC~ B YKpenneHHH napTHepcTB co CBOHMH KllHeHTaMH rpa)KnaHCKHM oomecTBoM 3aHHTepecoBaHHhlMH cTopoHaMH H npyrHMH opraHH3aUH~MH TaK HanpHMep 3a nocnenHHe DBa rona OhIn nOCTHrHYT 60nhillOH nporpecc B pa3rpaHHlfeHHH neTIenhHOCTH Me)Kny naHKoM H

32

BceMHpHOH OpraHH3aUHeH 3npaBOOXpaHeHH~ KaJKna~ H3 nHX OpraHH3aUHH 6yneT 3aHHMaTbC~

TeMH BOnpOCaMH r ne OHa HMeeT CpaBHHTeJlbHOe

npeHMYlUeCTBO EblJlH npHJlOJKeHbl BCe yCHJlH~

nJl~ OnTHMH3aUHH COTpynHHlleCTBa 3THX nsyX

OpraHH3aUHH -ITO HeCOMHeHHO nOCJlYJKHT

HHTepeCaM CTpaH-KJlHeHTOB EOJlblllOe

paCnpOCTpaHeHHe nOJlY-IHJlH nBe OCHOBHble 1gt0PMbl

COTpynHH-IeCTBa (a) cOTpynHH-IeCTBO Ha ypOBHe

CTpaHbl Korna M06HJlH3yeTc~

CneUHaJlH3HpOBaHHblH onblT B03 nJl~ yJly-lllleHH~

COnepJKaHH~ npoeKTOB nOnnepJKHBaeMblX

EaHKOM KOHTpOJl~ H oueHKH HX peaJlH3aUHH H

(6) rn06aJlbHOe cOTpynHH-IeCTBO Korna B03 H

EaHK 06nenHH~IOT yCHJlH~ no nOCTHJKeHHIO

MeJKnYHaponHoro KOHceHcyca B Bonpocax 3nH

non06Hble yCHJlH~ 6blJIH npennpHH~bl B

OTHOllleHHH nporpaMMbl OOH no CnHLly

ltlgtLlHOOH IOHHCEltlgt H npyrHx opraHH3auHH

EyneT YKpenJleHO cOTpynHH-IecTBo EaHKa

C npyrHMH opraHH3aUH~MH B 06JlaCTH

MeJKnYHaponHblx HCCJlenOBaHHH Bo-nepBblx EaHK

6yneT npOnOJlJKaTb OKa3bIBaTb nOnnepJKKY

HenaBHO C03naHHOMY MeJKnYHaponHOMY IgtOPYMY

no HCCJlenOBaHHRM B 06JlaCTH 3npaBooxpaHeHHR

HCnOJlb3y~ Ha 3TH ueJlH CpenCTBa nporpaMMbl

CneUHaJlbHblX rpaHTOB ltlgtOPYM cnoc06cTByeT

cocpenOTO-leHHIO HCCJlenOBaTeJlbCKHX pecypcoB Ha

npHopHTeTHblX HanpaBJleHH~X BKJlIO-Ia~

npOBeneHHe HCCJlenOBaHHH H aHaJlH30B B 06JlaCTH

nOJlHTHKH 3npaBooxpaHeHH~ HH3K03aTpaTHoro

Jle-leHHR He3apa3HblX 3a60JleBaHHH H 3aMenneHH~

pacnpOCTpaHeHH~ MHKp060B cnoc06HblX

npOTHBOCTORTb BaKUHHaM BO-BTOPbIX 6yneT

noompRTbCJI npOllOJlJKeHHe IgtHHaHCHpOBaHH~ H3

cpenCTB rpaHTOB npHopHTeTHblX MeJKnYHaponHbIX

HHHUHaTHB yJly-llllalOlUHX 06MeH onblTOM B

06JlaCTH nHTaHH~ H penponYKTHBHoro 3ll0POBbR

B-TpeTbHX B napTHepCTBe C ltlgt0PYMOM EaHK 6yneT

COTPYnHH-IaTb C lgtapMaueBTH-IeCKOH BaKUHHHOH H

6HOTeXHOJlOrH-IeCKOH npOMbIlllJleHHOCTblO no

YKpenJleHHIO HCCJlenOBaHHH H nOJlY-leHHIO

nponYKTOB He06xollHMblX nnR 6enHoro HaCeJleHH5I

B CTpaHax C HH3KHM ypOBHeM noxona KaK- TO

HOBble JleKapCTBa OT MaJl5lpHH

npoTHBoTy6epKYJle3Hble BaKUHHbl 60Jlee

COBepllleHHble MeTonbl nHarHOCTHKH

BeHepH-IeCKHX 3a60JleBaHHH EaHK 6yneT TaKJKe

HCKaTb nyTH paClllHpeHH~ CBoeH nOnnepJKKH

MeJKnYHaponHOH HHHUHaTHBbl no pa3pa60TKe

BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla nporpaMMbl OOH no 60Pb6e

CO CnHLloM H -IaCTHOrO ceKTopa no pa3pa60TKe

BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla

TaKJKe 6ynYT npennpHH~bl naJlbHeHlllHe

yCHJlH~ no paClllHpeHHIO napTHepCTBa EaHKa C

npyrHMH opraHH3aUH~MH no 60Pb6e C 60Jle3HblO

pe-lHOH CJlenOTbl H B ueJl~X OKa3aHH~ nOnnepJKKH

npyrHM MeJKnYHaponHblM HHHUHaTHBaM B clgtepe

3nH nOTeHUHaJlbHO HMelOlUHM 3Ha-lHTeJlbHblH

BHelllHHH 31gt1gteKT B03MOJKHblMH HanpaBJleHH~MH

COTPYnHH-IeCTBa ~BJl~IOTC~ nOnnepJKKa CTpaH

AIgtPHKH B HX 60Pb6e C 3nHneMH~MH MaJl~PHH

pa60Ta C B03 H npyrHMH opraHH3aUH~MH no

60Pb6e C 3nHneMH~MH Ty6epKYJle3a H

nponaraHnHpOBaHHe HHTerpHpOBaHHoro nonxona K

Jle-leHHIO 3a60JleBaHHH neTCKoro B03paCTa

OT Bu~eHUB npooneM K ~eHCTBUIO

PeaJlH3aUHR CTpaTerHH B clgtepe 3nH

6yneT TeCHO CBR3aHa C HOBblM CTpaTerH-IeCKHM

corJlallleHHeM no opraHH3aUHOHHOMY pa3BHTHlO

EaHKa Ha OCHOBe nOCTaBJleHHblX 3ana-l H 06lUero

nJlaHa neHCTBHH OTpaCJleBOH COBeT pa3pa60TaeT B

COTPYnHH-IeCTBe C perHOHaJlbHblMH

nenapTaMeHTaMH CTpaTerH-IeCKYIO MaTpHUY

(npHJlOJKeHHe F) H nepe-lHH nOKa3aTeJleH

pe3YJlbTaTOB no KOTOPblM 6yneT oueHHBaTbC~

ne~eJlbHOCTb EaHKa npH nonrOTOBKe OTpaCJleBOH

cTpaTerHH B clgtepe 3nH Ha CJlenYlOlUHH nepHon

nOcpenCTBOM TaKHX Mep 6yneT paClllHpeH

BKJlan EaHKa B MeJKnYHaponHble yCHJlH~ no

YKpenJleHHIO COUHaJlbHOrO pa3BHTHR B nepBoe

neC~HJleTHe 21-ro BeKa EaHK HaMepeH H B

naJlbHeHllleM HHlgtopMHpoBaTb MHpOBylO

06lUeCTBeHHOCTb no BOnpocaM KacaIOIUHXC~

nOJlHTHKH B 06JlaCTH 3npaBooxpaHeHH~ OKa3bIBaR

CBoe BJlH~HHe Ha HanpaBJleHHe MeJKnYHapOnHblX

ne6aTOB 0 pa3BHTHH MHPOBblX CHCTeM

3npaBooxpaHeHH5I H yKpenJl~51 naPTHepCTBO H

cOTpynHH-IecTBO CO CBOHMH KJlHeHTaMH H npyrHMH

opraHH3aUH~MH

33

CTpaTerUH oTpacneBoro pa3BUTUH

BonpOChI 3lJOPOBh) nDTAHD) D HAPOlJOHACEnEHD)

OEhEAHHEHHE CnEUHAflHCTOB EAHKA B OEflACTH PA3BHTWI COUHAflhHhlX PECYPCOB

BCeMHpHhlH J)aHK









COJ(EP)KAHME

BCTynlleHHe



COKpallleHHjI



np0611eMhlpa3BHTHjI




HaponoHacelleHHe)


OCMhIClleHHe OnhITa








111










pa3BHTHjI













HaCeneHHjI











BblCOKOH














llOXOlla
























pa3BHTHjI








v





























nOnOnHjlThCjI






npencenaTenh ceKUHH



Vl



Vll













































npHHOC5IT ycnexa














opraHH3aUH5IMH





















IX


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33









COJ(EP)KAHME

BCTynlleHHe



COKpallleHHjI



np0611eMhlpa3BHTHjI




HaponoHacelleHHe)


OCMhIClleHHe OnhITa








111










pa3BHTHjI













HaCeneHHjI











BblCOKOH














llOXOlla
























pa3BHTHjI








v





























nOnOnHjlThCjI






npencenaTenh ceKUHH



Vl



Vll













































npHHOC5IT ycnexa














opraHH3aUH5IMH





















IX


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33










pa3BHTHjI













HaCeneHHjI











BblCOKOH














llOXOlla
























pa3BHTHjI








v





























nOnOnHjlThCjI






npencenaTenh ceKUHH



Vl



Vll













































npHHOC5IT ycnexa














opraHH3aUH5IMH





















IX


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33





























nOnOnHjlThCjI






npencenaTenh ceKUHH



Vl



Vll













































npHHOC5IT ycnexa














opraHH3aUH5IMH





















IX


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33



Vll













































npHHOC5IT ycnexa














opraHH3aUH5IMH





















IX


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33













































npHHOC5IT ycnexa














opraHH3aUH5IMH





















IX


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33


















np06neM


















yrpo30H cpbIBa






BKnIOlaIOT






























HanpaBneHHHX














H TpaHcnopT

x




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33




































npoeKTOB




npoeKTOB























ceKTopOB

napmHepCKUX
























xi

C

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

AcpEP

CTIHo A3EP

CTIC EEPP H3P

EC


BHo MEPP MAP

MEP MltlgtK

MOT MBltlgt

uon MArH

HrO 03CP

000 TIA03

TITIC TIcr

CTIHoOOH TIPOOH


B03

COKPAmEHH5I
















X11l

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

fJIABA I



pe3ynbTaTbI














6000

75 55 z

70 ~ ~ 50 ~ 65 ~

45 I ~ 00 ~ 40

855)E

~

8 i)

35 ~ 45 ia5wIe

30 8 ~40 gt 35

20

191O 00 70 00 00 3XX) 10 ltgtD4QmI

jraquoC11 roQbl

D










MHnnHOHa




























1990rony






BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33




BKnI04aIOIUHx



H )KeHIUHH




























HaCeneHH5I
































noxona) (CMPHc12)

80 1990 70 ~

~1960 shy

60 ~~1930 50 ~~1900 40

o 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000









2



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33



















































AcpPHKY

































KOpHH B neTCTBe








3

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

--










































4






MY

67 ManaBM

31 Bbe

US$ 180 US$ 700 US$ 800





















nOKa3aTeneH




















3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33





3npaBooxpaHeHHjJ




















nonpaBKoH Ha I1I1C)



1111 7

5

3

00

70


dhae 3II1pIT

10 Lamp__J-__L__---____L-__I

SXXl 10 000 15000 20 000












































3nopOBhjJ










5




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33




















6

C









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33









































MopanhHoro pHCKa)























































7














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33














npHnO)KeHHH A)


HaceneHHR





































06cnY)KHBaHHR






























8
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33
































nHIUH
















cnoeB HaceneHHA

plllc1S







3llpaBOOXpaHeHH5I






















yqeTa

9













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33













MepOnpH5ITHH







HaLl30pa






KnHeHTOB



























































pa3Llene)

10

C



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33



pHC16

I R M F P







MaXHHaUHH















11























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33























oone3HH
















HaCeneHHR (cMPHcl7)







0 100 1000 Itl OOO lOll 00

tI I

oj


pHc1 7









ycnyr

























12














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33














13

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

rnABA II



















14

C





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33





























15

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

IaCmHble 60lbHU4bl)












16





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33





06MeHa onbITOM



































CTpaHe












CTpaHaMH-KnHeHTaMH







































17















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33















































18










AHpeKTHBa 476)





































C



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33



TYHHCe














CHrHanOM (cMPHc21)



pHc21















UOBonbHO CnOJKHO











pa3BHTHjf UeTeH





















roua (CMPHC22)


250

200

150

100

50

1970 19961970 1996

pHc22



19

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

1















20







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33







nOKa3aTeneH





















































KOHTp011h



















TOBapOB

BO MHorHX

















21

C


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33


































peaIlH3aUHH














22
















npoBelleHa
















npHopHTeTaM

















































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33




































23
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33
















BHeJlpeHHR ypoKOB






npHMeHeHHH



COBepIlleHHOH






24

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

rJIABA III























pO)KAaeMocTH































































25




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33




rOponCKHX ycnoBHSlX
















































































pa3BHTHSI cena


26



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33



KnUeHTOB
















































ceKTopa














ycnyr















3JlpaBOOXpaHeHHjI












27














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33














IaCTHblMH pacxoAaMH


























































TaKHM CTPaHaM










3KOHOMHKOH








28














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33














H3nO)KeHHH
















































































29

C

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

0










30











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33











































nOKYMeHTaUHH









EaHKa Ha pa3BHTHe









3analJ














3nH















nopTcpenSl

31










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33










3anal











32




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33




















































BaKUHHbl OT CnHLla





































opraHH3aUH~MH

33

Вопросы здоровья, питания и населения

Documents