مكافحة الفساد بين الدستور،،، والقانون ،،، والتطبيق
TRANSCRIPT
-
809 - : 20 /21595773: /
210 0711256 010 3367235: gro.wal-taam@ofni moc.oohay@wal_taam:
gro.ecaeptaam.www gro.wal-taam.www:
-
2
-
3
5
6
6
6 :
8 :
91 :
22 :
42
42
42
42
62: :
72: :
72: :
92:- :
92: :
13:
13
13 :
63 1791 :
73 :
73 :
73 : 1
05 - 2
15 -
45 -
45 :
75 :
85 :
06 :
06. -
16 -
-
4
16 :
26 :
36 -
56 -
56. - 1
76: - 2
86 - 3
96 :
27 :
57: :
77 8891 441 :
08 5791 26 :
38 4691 45 :
58 9791 34 :
49 :
69 -
78 - 1
89 - 2
09 - 3
101 - 4
301 :
401. :
011 :
411 :
811 :
331
631
341
-
5
. "
.
.
:
"
-
.
. .
-
) 62 (
.
.
. " "
-
6
:
!
3002
615141"
918171
221202
"52
: % -
.
.
% -
$
"." %
$
.
.
-
7
-
.
:
..1
.
:.2
.
-
8
:
:
-: .1
$91%$601%
.
.
-: .2
.
-: .3
-
9
.
:- .4
#31.220020991
.#21.4
.
#04#02
.
1.2
.03
5002
.$003%
-: . 5
:.:
.
-
01
6761
.
.
.
-: .6
--
$%
-"
"
$%
.
-: . 7
-
11
.
- : . 8300282
$333%$33%
#06
21
.
: . :
-: 1
""
.
"5991
"
-
21
"1002/0002
.
"
$2%
.$%
-.: 2
.
%
$
87.1
#1.92002
5.12002
#6.71002/000279/96
.5.91
1002
5991
.5991
-.: : 3
-
31
.
- : : 4
..
.
..
.
33333
.
- : : 5
""
...
.
-
41
.
"$91%8491
$.
.
- .: : - 6
699169
951
899131891
.
5791121
289192739185
5991392991793891991
$.6032034913912911918817812018968%
: : -: . 1
$%
/
/$%
.
-
51
- : . 2
$%
.
-: .3
0691
.
$%
%:
$
.
.
- :)( .4 $%
%
$
-
61
.
: : - : .1
.
:- .2
%
$%
.
: : :- 1
05
:
.
089150021791
70025002
43
.
-
71
2:-
;
.
3- :
.
$471%
.
: : -: .1
/
259181"
04
52
800315.73
95710791
82 000173
".!
-: .2
-
81
.$%
:- .3
91
.
:- . 4
.
.
01
.
-: . 5
.
-
91
:
.
: :
;: .
: .
:-
-
..
. -
. -
-
.
-
.
:
.
.
":
"
-
02
.
.
.
.
: 7002
.
.$%
:-
:
.:
.
:
579125179175
189105%979134
-
12
48889154178916012891621891861
$500287130026969915226991
-
/
"!"
..
14
#09
.
-
.
-
22
:
.
.
:-
: : .1
.
. .2
. .3
. .4
: : . .1
.2
.
. .3
. .4
. .5
: : . .1
. .2
. .3
-
32
. .4
..
./
.
: : . .1
. .2
. .3
. .4
. .5
-
42
. :
%
.$
:
.-1
.-2
.-3
.
.
.
-
.
7002-
.
.
.
-
52
.
.
:
..1
%.2
..$
.3
.
..4
.5
.
..6
..7
..8
.9
.
..01
.11
.
..21
-
62
:
. .1
. .2
:
::
.
"
".
.
.
: :
.$%
.
.
:
.
.
-
72
%
.
: :
.
:
. .1
. .2
. .3
.$% .4
. .5
: :
.
.
.
: : "2002
".
.
:
. .1
. .2
. .3
-
82
.
: -1
.
: -2
.
: -3
.
.: -4: -5
.
: -6 .
: -7 .
-8
.
-
92
: -9
-: : $%
.
.
.
: : .
.
) ( :
-
64--%-
$.2791
$.089159%-
8891441% -
$
$469145%-
-
469116% -
$8591711%-
899198:%-
189172117916212
-
03
379135:.379135-
$.1891721-
$.1791001%-
: -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
: -
-
-
-
-
-
13
:
--5991""""
""
.
.
.
;
.
.
.
.
:
-
23
.;-
.-
.:;-
.-
. -
:
:-
.
.-
.-
%-
.$
:;
"-
."
"-
""":""
.
$84%-
.
.-
-
.
06-
""
.;
-
33
-
.
1
52313213002
.
.
.
699192
799162
72
49991
3002219991
3002
.
-
43
25002
081
.
.
-
.
.
.
3:
.
-
53
:.4
400231/.
. 4002/32-22...5.4002/32-22...6 .7 ( 8
$
dceo799112
.799171
9$52%
.000251
01
. )A 106/15/ (
11
. $ 706/35/A(
) 685/45/A ( 21
.
31
. ) 395/55/A (
41
) 96.L/65/A (
-
63
1791 : $1791%
.
1791
.
: )3( "
".
: )46( "."
: )56( "."
-
.
:$8%
"."
: )31( ."
".
: )41( "
".
: )52( "."
-
73
: )92( :"
".
)33( .""
:
:
.
:1
..
.
:
$111%$301% -
.
)301( "
."
) 2691 02 ( )301(
.
-
83
) 401 (
. 301
) 2691 021 ( )401(
.
) 2691 021 ( )501(
.
)501(
.
) 601(
.
)601(
401
.
.
-
93
) ( )601(
.
.
) 701(
.
)701(
.
) 801(
.84
. )801(
.
) 2691 021 ( )901( ) 2691 021 ( )901(
.
-
04
) 2691 021 ( )901(
.
401
.501
) 011( .;
) 111( .
.-1
.-2
.-3
$7591211%-4
.-5
-6
%
$.2691021
.
.
.
.
.$301%
-
14
$401%
401%.
.$
$501%
.
$601%
$601%
.
901%
$
$901%
.$111%
$911%$211% -
.-
.
)5791 36 ( )211( -
: -
$ -
-
24
.$ -
.$ -
) 5791 36 ( )311( 911 -
.
-
.
-
.
-
911
.
) 5791 36 ( )311( -
.
-
.
) 411( -
.
) 5791 36 ( )511(
.
)4891 43 ( )511(
911
-
34
.
.
) 5791 36 ( )611(
.
.
) 5791 36 ( )611(
.
.
) 5791 36 ) ( ( )611(
.
.
) 5791 36 ) ( ( )611( $$289192%
.
.
.
-
44
) 5791 36 ) ( ( )611(
911
.
.
.
.
.
) 5791 36 ( )711( 911
..
) 5791 36 ( )711(
.
311311211
.
) 5791 36 ( )811( 311311211
711611611511411
511411311311211
.
) 5791 36 ( )811(
:
-
54
-1
.-2
.-3
.-4
.-5
) 5791 36 ) ( ( )811(
.-
.
)5791 36 ) ( ( )811(
.
.
211
.311311
) 5791 36 ( )911(
:
.$%
$%
.$%
$%
.$%
$%
-
64
$%
.
.$%
) 5791 36 ( )911( .
.$%
$%
.
$%
.$%
$%
.
$%
..
.
$%
.
2691333333396
579136279153
911%
$
$311%$211%
.
-
74
$511%.
$811%-
$333333333%
.
$521%$021% -
.
- ) 021(
.
%289192%
$
) 7591 211 ()121(
.501
) 221( .
-
84
.
) 2591 321 ( )321(
.
.
) 1591 42 ( )421(
.
.
.
1591 42 ) ( ()421()6002 741
421
.
.
.
-
94
) 1591 42 ) ( ()421( 421
.573
) 1591 42 ) ( ()421(
.
) 521(
.
.112
)4891 9 ( )112(
.
-
05
:
. $1
$2
.
$3
.
. $4
. $5
$6
"."
.- $7
. $8
= 2
.
.
.
..
-
15
.
-
:919791/11/71
"...
.
..
..
".
:862915691/1/72
"
"
"
".""
:"/.
".
.
5891711
.
.
000254789174
8591711
-
25
.
- 00025-4879174
.$18%$87%
: )87( "
".
: 3891 511 97 "
7742
".
: )08( . $1
. $2
- $3
.
. $4
. $5
. $6
. $7
. $8
. $9
.$ 01
:
. -1
. -2
. -3
-
35
. -4
: )18( ""
.
8591 711
.
: 8691 82 "
"
: )3( "
:
. -1
-2
.
-3
.
".
) : 4( "
"
:
-
45
" .
"
-
.
.....
.
: 2791 64
. . 801 39
: )39( "
".
): 89( "
.
".
: )99( "
.
".
-
55
: )001( "
".
: )801( ""
.
) 921( )521(
: )521( "."
: )621( "
.
.
.
"
: )721( 89"
"
: )821( ""
-
65
: )921( ."
".
.
) 461( ) 961(
: )461( "
"
"
)561( "
"
: )661( "
".
: )761( "
-
75
.
".
: ) 861( "
"
.
: 2791 74
) . 021( )211( : )211(
:"
"
: )311( "
"
: )021( :"
-
85
".
.
!!!.
.!!!!
.
:
-
.
-
-
.
.
-: 401
""
: 501
-
95
""
: )773(
"
:
.:
.:
.:
.:
.:
.
.$%$%$%
.
.
".
): 873(
$773%$%$%"
:
.:
.:
:
.
$773%$%
"
-
06
): 973(
$773%$%$%"
:
:
.
".:
:
-
-
.
-
-
.
:-
.-1
-2
.-3
-4
-
-
16
.
-
.
: :
: 731 ""
831
741641541441"
."151841801
"" -
-
879174$92%
.
-
26
:$82%
"
.
.
"
$53%$03%
.
: :
"
.
"
.
"
.
279174$42%
:
"
.
".
-
36
-
: 89
""
: )501(
""
:
: )39 (
."
.
.
"
: )401(
""
.2352
: )52(
"
:
. :
-
46
: .
. :
$%
.
.$%
".
: 62
"
."
: 72
"."
: 13
$773%$%"
".62
: 23
"
.
.
-
56
$773%$%
".
-
.
.
.
.
.
/.
.
:
.-1
:-2
-3
-1
:
-
: - 1
-
66
: )101(
"
.
".
: )201(
"
"
: -
: )231(
."
"
: -
: )531(
"
."
-)2(
: )631(
"
.
".
-
76
: -2
: )031(
""
: )921(
" "
: )421(
"
.
.
."
: )131(
"
.
."
: )521(
"
.
-
86
"
): 621(
."
.
".
): 721(
"
.
.
.
.
".
): 821(
."
".
- 3
"
.
.
-
96
.
.
:
:
:
:
.
.
"/
"""
6591 37 )3( :
:"
.-
.-
.-
.-
-
07
.
.
".
: )( )3(
:"
-
.
.-
.-
$5%-
279183
.
-
.
-
.
.-
.-
.-
.-
.-
67
"":"
-
17
.
:
.-
-
.-
.-
.-
.
.
.
.
.
.
-
27
.
.
39
:
"
.
".
-
"887002/3/62
.
.
"
:
"":
:
.
-1
279174
: )3(
:"
. -1
-
37
. -2
. -3
. -4
". -5
: )01(
:"
.$%
.$%
$%
.
.$%
.$%
.$%
.
.$%
$%
.
.$%
.$%
.$%
.$%
.$%
.$%
.
".
-
47
.
:
. -1
. -2
. -3
. -4
1891171
:8591711
"
"
.
-2
.
%
$
: 441
"
".
: 541
-
57
"."
:641
""
): 741(
"
"
.
: :
.
969118
179111
979184
.
.571471
: 471
""
: 571
-
67
"
".
: 9791 84 )52(
:"
.:"
:
.
:
".
) : 62(
"
".
) : 72(
"
".
"
:
) 72 ( ) 92 ( ) 92 ( :
- ".
-
77
-
.
: -
.
$% -
$% -
$% -
$% -
-
.
-
.
.
8891441:
579126:
469145:
979134:
:
8891 441 : 8991/1/17518891441
:
"
".
-
87
:$2%
:"
-1
-2
". -3
:13
:"
-1
-2
.
-3
.#52
-4
. -5
-6
-7
"
:""$5%
:"
-1
.
:
-
".
:
"
#52
".$3%
-
97
:
"
....."
:$%
..""
:$%
"
"
:5
"
03
"
:6
"
33
".
:$51%
"
".
75188441-
89
.
-
08
.
.
.
.
40024861
.
5791 26 : -:579126$1%
:"
.. -1
-2
.
-
18
.
.
-3
.
-4
..
-5
.
.
. -6
.
-7
.
. -8
-9
.
379128 -01
.
".
-:$2%
"
.
".
-:$3%
-
28
"
".
-:$5%
"
:
-
.
-
.
-
".
:-$6%
"
".
:-$7%
"
.
469145
".
:-$01%
"
6591742
$5%
-
38
.
".
:-$81%
"
".
-
.
.
4691 45 : :-$1%
"
."
-:969117$%$2%
:"
-
.
. -
-
.
-
48
.
.
.
-
.
".
-$:3%
"
".
-$:4%
"
".
-$:5%
"
".
-$:6%
"
.
".
-$:8%
."
-
58
".0051
.
.
.
9791 34 : 179175
979134579125
54178916012891621891861189105%
$500287130026969915226991488891
: 161 "
.
" : ) 261 (
.
-
68
"
: )361( "
"
: 9791 34 := )2( "
"
- : )3 ( "
279183
.
.
".
-- : )21(
" .2
.
-
78
.
:
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
-6
-7
-8
-9
-01
-11
-21
-31
".
- :)81(
-
88
"
".
- :)91( "
.
.
.
".
:-)02( "
".
- :)42( "
".
- :)501( "
".
) - ( - -1
:-)14(
-
98
"
.
:
. -1
-2
-3
-4
-5
. -6
-7
- : ) 24 ( --"
.
413
.
".
-2- : ) 94 (
-"
".14$7-1%
-
09
- : ) 05( "
.
413
".
-3:- )16(
"
".14$7-1%
-4- :)86(
"
:
-1
-2
. -3
-4
-5
" -6
-
-
19
:- )201( $32%"
.
".
:-)301( "
"
:- 501 "
"
- : 601 "
.
02-91
".
/
.
-
29
.
14
"822
".
11
.
.06
45
.
005
616002475
#59#5
#76
.#33
52152
.
82#84
.
#37
#8.82
-
39
.
.#09
:
-
.
-
-
-
.
-
-
.
.-
.-
-
.
.-
-
-
.
.-
.-
-
.
-
49
-: $6%
:
.
.
.
:-
.1
.
.
.
/%
$-/
-
59
%:
$
.
.2
.
$%
.
$%
.
.
.3
$%
.
.
%
.$....
.
.
-
69
.
.
.
.
.
.$6%
$%
:
.
$%
$5%
.$5%
-
.$%
.
-
79
.
.
-: )3( "
".
- :)42( ""
:-)92( :"
".
-:)33( ""
-
.
$%
.
.
6591 37 : )1(
-
89
:"
:
::
-1
-2
-3
-4
"
$-%
- 1
0891
- : )602( ""
- : )702( "
".
6991 69 :- )1(
-
99
"
".
-: )3( "
"
-: )6( ""
-: )9( "
".
- : )54( ""
:- )55( "
".
-2) 1( 7791 04
-: "
".
:- )2(
-
001
"
."
- : )3( "
.
"
9 "
:
-1
-2
-3
".
- : )1( 9 $9%"
:
-1
"-2
- : )51( 669169"
".
- 3 -: )65(
."
-
101
"
"
.
3991001
59915
.
- 4:- )55(
"
"
-: )1 ( 2002 48 "
"
:- )11( "
:
. -1
. -2
-3
.
-4
".
-
201
- : )65( "
".$11%
- : ) 56( "
.
".
) : 84( 2002 871 $11%"
.
.
.
.
.
".
-
301
:
.:.:.: :
.
.
.
.
.
-
401
. :
.
: )37( "
."
: " )47(
."
: )78( "
.
.
."
: )101( "
.
."
: )201( "
.
."
: )601(
-
501
."
."
: )801( "
."
: )901( .""
: )211( .""
: )231( "
.
."
: )631( ."
..
."
)731( "."
: )831( "
.
741641541441
".151841801
-
601
: )931( ."
."
)141( "
".
)241( "
".
: )341( "
.".
) 441 ( "
."
)541( .""
: )641( .""
: )741( "
.
."
-
701
) 841 ( "
.
."
) 941 ( .""
) 051 ( ""
) 151 ( "
.
."
: )251( .""
) 351( ."
".
)651( "
1
2
3
4
5
6
-
801
7
".8
)751( "
".
)951( "
.
".
: )371(
"
".
: )281( $%"
."
: )481( ."
".
: )981( "
.
.
.
-
901
.
."
: )691( .$231%"
.
."
: )202( "
.
."
: )402( "
.
."
17
$%
17
.
"
"/.
.
-
011
.
.
.
: )68(
"
".
.
" )901( "
)211( "."
)311(
-
111
"
.
".
)441( "
"..
)541( "."
)641( "."
47 :
"
"
$%-
.
47
".
)801( "
-
211
".
)741( "
".
)841( "
".
"
84174180147
84174180147
1791
1791
.
: )78(
""
-
311
"
)621( ."
.
.
".
) 721( "
.
.
.
.
".
.
.
"
-
411
.
:$98%
" "
.
.
: - : )561(
"."
- : )661( "
".
- : )861( ".."
- : )371( "
".
- : )771( "
".
-
511
1791 -
-
.
-
.
-
.
-
.
-
.
/ . :
: .
: .
: :
.: :
.
-
611
.
. 39
"
"
)99( :-
"
$%"-
) 561 (
)07(
: "."
.
)71( :
"
-
711
-1
.
." -2
.
.
.:"
"..""
.
"
.
-
811
:
.
.
92 :"
".
.
.
. .6591 37 - 1
26 :
"
-
911
"
6591 37 :
26: )2(
: "6591 37:"
..1
..2
$%.3
.4
.
1514.5
.
.6
.
".$%.7
" )3( :
..1
..2
"..3
: )4(
-
021
"
".
-
.
:
.
:
.
659137:
.
- 2
.
-
121
/
:""
"
1791.
.$%
1791
84
.
1791
$012%
"."
$902%
.""
1791
.
.
-
221
979131-
.
699169: .1
.$54%
052
.
.2
$7/07%$1/07%
.
6986
.6991
:
63910201 .1
.
12 .2
.
91714131211174 .3
-
321
.
81: .4
;
891
.
:
8591261
:
.
5791121
069153
7691416591312
1791001879174
:739175
:5791121:
-
421
.
.
.
9791274
:
.
.
.
.
.
069153:
.
-
521
289182
:
.1
.
.2
.
. .3
46915191
.
.
7691416591313:
.
005001
.
879174:
7/77
.
.
-
621
1791001:
.
.
$%07
.
$%07
$07%
.
.
$%08$%08
.
..
001$%08
005
$%08.
.
$%07
58
.
-
721
.1
.
.2
.
.3
.
.4
.
739175: .1
98.
$%
.
.
191: .2
.
.
291 .3
.
091 .4
.
.
-
821
391: .5
.
.
.
3$%42: .6
421
$%421
.
-
.
419166-
1891
."
3991 001 - 3 )65(
."
.
".
.
-
921
3991001
.59915
: 5991 5 3991 001 3991001:
.
.
100271
50029121
.
:
.2665
.
.
": "
:
.2665:
-
031
:65: 65
".
"
:"-
.
:
.: :
65
.
: .
. - 4
.
: 7002 62
-
131
"
.
.
""
.
: "
".
"/
$%
"
-5200248
.............
35469123
9991
.
$%$%
.$24%
-
231
)11(
-2"
"
.
-
-$%-
.
$71%
.
.
.
.
.
-
331
.
.
.
:
.
. /
.
.
.
-
431
.
.
.
: .1
. .2
. .3
.
.4
. .5
. ) (
.6
.
-
531
. 7
.
3002 41 .8
.
. 9 .
.
-
631
82720922:
20720922
moc.abaker.www:
36222972:
76222972
30185972:
ge.vog.csdi@bejom:
00216862:
00316862
00616862
00716862
16816862:
ge.vog.fom.www:
ge.vog.1csdi@ecnanifom:
.2
00634972:
49112972
87112972
52055972:
78475972
ge.vog.itfm.www :
ge.vog.itm@itm:
-
731
22
32958473:
82958473
13958473
10958473:
69470673
ge.gro.ace@ofni:
96123042:
99042042:
6802:.
ge.vog.sampac.www:
1
29292972:
22292972:
28511:191:.
ge.ten.csdi@kcabdeef:
04037770:
: ge.gro.ebc@ofni:
: 69
88591:
48308353:
ge.vog.apc@ofni:
-
831
4
00044353:
55144353:
ge.vog.art@ofni:
ge.vog.art.www:
ge.vog.artn.www
1
57412432:
18412432:
gro.aretpyge@ofni:
moc.aretpyge.www
11811:3717:.
gro.aretpyge@ofni:
moc.aretpyge.www:
2
87112972:
78475972:
ge.vog.itm@itm:
1
24412972:
14412972
04412972
32412972:
ge.vog.ytilitu-gnisuoh.www:
ge.vog.ytilitu-gnisuoh@ofni:
-
931
2
78295972:
88295972
33295972
3
35655042:
25655042
15655042
53655042:
26511:
ge.vog.tnemtsevni@iom-tcatnoc:
ge.vog.tnemtsevni.www:
ge.vog.tnemailrap.www:
ge.vog.tnemailrap@rekaeps:
ge.vog.aruohs.www
ge.ten.csdi@21cias:
3111
03254752:
23254752
33254752
28354752
38354752
79474752:
-
041
ge.gro.nasni-rhcn@tpyge-rhcn:
ge.gro.rhcn.www:
00325972:
70885972
11195972
28606972:
14611:
ge.vog.imcsi@retnec:
ge.vog.tpygeiom.www:
-
141
-
-
-
:
0621297-162129726212970202397
59312976931297
gse.vog.lawma@tinubal :liamE
gro.obwcci@ccf
94823594:
16511:.:
4842743-04416435563743:
9606303:
41513939251393
13
ge.gro.ebc@ofni
ge.gro.ebc.www
ge.gro.rhcn@enasni
113111
03254752835475
8272092
3045192:
3525575-6657875
5
367113
86491
psa.tluafed/cibara/ge.vog.tpyge.www
-
241
se/tis+stnemtraped/cibara/ge.vog.tpygeiom.www
0401597""
2206497
4-1074633
2
7963497/
007/006/003/0021686:
1681686:
ge.vog.csdi@ecnanifom
ge.vog.fom.www
8272092
06212979832297
103-203-903-66381042
-
341
.1
333002
.2
414002
62 .3
329991
. .4
121002662 .5
100297 .6
07
/- .7
6339991/ .8
333362662. .9
.01
711-0111002
5002 .11
. .21
... .31
.41
027991
.51
.
903 .61
011.5014002903 .71
-
441
7312002/ .81
/- .91
.8639991/ .02
. .12
.
.8991
93834002903/ .22
.32
.254002
.42
7436991
5002 .52
25
3928526991/. .62
.4946991/ .72
530002/ .82
5725002 .92
/ .03
622
3845791/. .13
10249/ .23
.33
- .43