דו שיח במגילת רות.pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
Bialik Institute, Jerusalem / ,
ON DIALOGUE AND SPEAKER STATUS IN THE SCROLL OF RUTH /:-Author(s): and Frank H. PolakSource: Beit Mikra: Journal for the Study of the Bible and Its World / - : ) , , )" - pp. 193-218Published by: Bialik Institute, Jerusalem / , Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/23508157 .Accessed: 15/01/2015 04:43
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
.
Bialik Institute, Jerusalem / , is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,preserve and extend access to Beit Mikra: Journal for the Study of the Bible and Its World / - :
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 83.137.211.198 on Thu, 15 Jan 2015 04:43:55 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
. -
.2 .'
505,43 '-'
C .J .A. :)6933.34( 059,41 ,) , (
werbeH eht fo seicneuqerF eht fo ydutS A :srebmuN dna sbreV ,jiehreV
nessA ,selcinorhC dna sgniK ,leumaS fo skooB eht ni smroF esneT labreV, 0991,
002 69- )' ( .pp. 63-23
H dna yaddaR .T .Y. :)6917.24( 14 , .
6944.24( pp ,5891 emoR ,ydutS pihsrohtuA nA ,siseneG ,erohS. 52-42.
" : - ' )
,321-831 ,)"( 8 ," :
,(" 6944.93 - .)3 ' ,431 ,
) ,( '-' .)3 ' ,431 ( 3.83 8 69- ,)321
'-' .)3.43 1 69( 833,21 , 759,53
, .)303,53 6577( 6979.12
,
. 3 , '
:" , ,
.452-552 ," , , '
,- ' , --
,"" , .98-29 ," ,
.
A .ecnedivorP eniviD fo yrotS A :hpesoJ ,ercagnoL .E .R
anoniW ,84-93 dna 73 siseneG fo sisylanA citsiugniltxeT dna laciteroehT txeT
.) , :( pp ,9891 ,ekaL. 502-141 . , dnoceS ,esruocsiD fo rammarG ehT -
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
491
, , ,
) ( :
.3 , ,
.4 ,
, ) : ,
) - ) ;
) :
.
. , .
,5 .
, ,
.
.1
) -(
.) , :( pp ,6991 ,kroY weN ,noitidE. 151-321
. ,- ," : - " , '
lacilbiB ni eugolaiD eht fo elytS ehT" ,kaloP .H .F ; 74-201 ,"
.sserp ni( 72 yteicoS nretsaE raeN tneicnA eht fo lanruoJ ,"evitarraN esorP(
.141-751 , , -
,)441-741 ( )ytilartnec(
.)661-761 ,641 ,ecnanimod( ,/
. .)671 ,( ,
L. : , ,
nessA ,rotalsnarT eht dna stxeT tnematseT dlO ni stnapicitraP ,tgeR ed .J 9991
'' .) , :(
, . ,)3-4 ( .8,05-15
:- )6917.46 ,58 55(
,6891 ,emoR ,.de .dn2 ,euqitegixe te euqigololihp eriatnemmoC :htuR ,noltoJ .P 1 .n ,21 .p; p : lacigololihP a htiw noitalsnarT weN A .htuR ,nossaS .M .J
,9891 ,dleiffehS ,.de dn2 ,noitaterpretnI tsirolkloF-tsilamroF a dna yratnemmoC 722 .p ) , :(; fo sgnidaeR yraretiL tsinimeF :evoL lahteL ,laB .M
87-77 .pp ,7891 ,notgnimoolB ,seirotS evoL lacilbiiJ
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
591
)sisylanA noitasrevnoC(
,)skcaS yevraH(
, .6
.riap ycnecajda(7( ," "
) - (
: ,) - (
;" " )( : ,"" )( " " )( ," " )( :) ,' (
" " )( " ' " )( ,)( )( " " , , , .) ,' ( :8 , "" ,""
" " )( ." "
" " )( j . . . ." "
)( , )( :
( .
( , , ,) , .rewsna derreferp(9 ,/ " " :
,)rewsna derreferpsid( " "
.
, - , dna ybhctuH naI
73-31 .pp ,8991 ,KU ,egdirbmaC ,sisylanA noitasrevnoC ,ttiffooW niboR.
,ppirT-nivrE .S ;34-93 .pp ,sisylanA noitasrevnoC ,ttiffooW dna ybhctuH ,.sde ,rentaR nietsnreB .N dna nosaelG okreB .J ni ,"esruocsiD lanoitasrevnoC"
252-942 .pp .pse ,072-832 .pp ,3991 ,XT htroW troF ,scitsiugnilohcys'J
.681 , : ,
.051 ,721-921 , ,
)671 ,661-761 ,141-751 ,( .) ( 72 , :
. ,"" )3-4,32-43 ,(
, )( , )( . / )(
,ppirT-nivrE .S ;74-34 .pp ,sisylanA noitasrevnoC ,ttiffooW dna ybhctuH 352-252 .pp ,"esruocsiD lanoitasrevnoC". " " "
,".
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
691
, . p
:)- ,' (
" " )(
"... "
" " )(
" " .
:)- ' ;2-( ,
" " )2-(
"... "
:) '(
" (" )2-(
,
" : .01"-"
, . ,) ,("
.) ,(" " :-
, - , ,
.- - ,
,)""( ""
"" , . ,
(
, " "
, ." , ,) ,'
- , ""
,21"- " .
."- -
"-" .01 )citsiugnilarap( "-" ': )citsiugnil-artxe( ,sisylanA rof ledoM A :esruocsiD nekopS ,nosdnomdE .W
73-43 .pp ,1891 ,nodnoL. - )321-421 ," "( .11
.
.581-681 , , .21
, . , , , .31
)302 ,( , .531-731 ,
. ," "
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
791 -
," " , . ,- ,
. -
:) '(
"" )(
" , ^ " :) '(
" " )(
" " " "
", "
.
:) ' ;- (
." " )(
,)"" (
, .) (
'(" :!" :)- ( .)
.2 -
. . . ,
,
, . , , , . , .
) ,' ( - , . ."" - ) '( , , ,
.) ( ( ,-/
,41) ,egnahcxe( " " ,)
( . .41 ( ) " " :
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
891
.-
. , .
. ,
, , - ,
, , , .
. ,
, ,
, ( , . ,51)
. ,
, "" --
, . ,
" : , .
: .) ,' "("
'( ." "
: .)
, ?
.) '( " " :
, ,
. , , .
.) '( " "
.
,- ""
, .
.
(
" " )- ,'
, .)- '(
" : .)- '(
.)" " : 7" " :
, , . ,
egnahcxe )791 ,( .
.) ( -
kaloP, )- ," "( .51
.)3 ( "eugolaiD eht fo elytS ehT"
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
991 -
, .) '("
.
; '(
,) ,' " ,
, , ." ? "
.61 ,
,
.)" ' '(
,
.
, ,
. .71 , ,
,) ," '(
" .) ;- '( ,) '(" / )" "( .)- '(
" : . )( , .) '("
:)- ,' '( :" " )(
" ? ' "
"... " :" " )(
" " :"" )(
," " "... " " "
. ' " .pp ,5891; ,nodnoL ,.de dn2 ,sisylanA esruocsiD ot noitcudortnI nA ,drahtluoC .M
921-321 ;.de ,drahtluoC .M ni ,"erutcurtS egnahcxE" ,lizarB .D dna drahtluoC .M 87-05 .pp ,2991 ,nodnoL ,sisylanA esruocsiD nekopS ni secnavdA
. , ,
. ,
. ,
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
002
.81 , .)- , '( , ,
.
)( ,) ,' (" " )( , ,
:91) '( .) '(
:"" )(
," "
" "
, ,"" . .
, .
:)- ,'(
:" " )(
" "
" "
" "
" ) :( "
:"" )(
" "
, , ,
,02 , .
:)- '(" "
:" " )2( " "
) : ) ,' "( )( .81
.) '( ) ;) '( .)- ,'( .91
, .02
.
. ,
:) ' , (
( "
" : :( )
.) (" )"
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
102
)22 :( ]12 :[ "
"
:" " )2(
" "
" ? ?"
'( , ,
:32)-
:" " )3(
" " " "
" "
" ... "
. ,' .12 . ,
" . , ."
, ." " " ... " ." / " :
.) '( .)" "( , "" .22
" : . ""
.77 ," , ,"
, ,
' . ,
,' ." ! "
: / " - ,' .""
.) =( / - ,' ;) =( ! " : ,' , ,"( ""
.) ," : ," , , ,' :" ," " ) '( . - ' .32
" : , .66-86 ,55-96 ,)"(" ," - , ,
, , .) ," '(
ieb diE reD ,nesredeP .J : ,
eid eiwos negnuniehcsrE netdnawrev uz sintlhreV menies ni netimeS ned
, pp ,4191 ,grubssartS ,malsI mi sediE sed gnulletS. 35-15
'-' " :
.74-84 ,54-94 ,)"( ,"
. , ,
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
202
:)- '(
:" " )3-(
" ' "
" "
" "
.3
.
.)- ,'(
.
:) ,'( ,
"
, ."
" :
,)""( ," .)" "(
.)" "( ,)" "( :
)1( " ,"... )4( )3( )2( ... " )1(
." )2(
." )2( )1(" :
,
. ,42
.52
.62 ,
.
, , --
"- " , : .42
),)"( , ," " !) 3 ,241-061 ,03-25 93-34, 151-451 ; "eugolaiD eht fo elytS"; .H .F
fo tnempoleveD eht dna scitsilytS ,xatnyS :nettirW eht dna larO ehT" ,kaloP
62 yteicoS nretsaE raeN tneicnA eht fo lanruoJ ",evitarraN esorP-lacilbiB
301-29 ,87-36 .pp .pse ,501-95 .pp ,)8991(. 52. 501-101 .pp ,"nettirW eht dna larO ehT" ,kaloP.
.62 .pp ,9691 ,nodnoL ,elytS hsilgnE gnitagitsevnI ,yvaD .D d,ja latsyrC .D
"- " , ; 712-391;"eugolaiD eht fo elytS".
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
302 -
.2)" " " "(
,)" "( ,
." " :
, .)" "(
, .92 ,82
. ,
. , ,
, , ,
:) ,'(
" "
" "
." "
, ," "
" ," "
,) 32 ( ." " ' . , , (
.- /! )
, ) (
.) , (
) ( ) ( : ehT" ,namhsiF .A .J
ot hcaorppA ecneicS laicoS yranilpicsidretnI nA :egaugnaL fo ygoloicoS
fo ygoloicoS eht ni secnavdA ,).de( namhsiF .A .J ni ,"yteicoS ni egaugnaL
142-632 .pp .pse ,404-712 .pp ,1791 ,eugaH ehT ,I ,egaugnal
)egaugnal lausac( " " , : elytS"
"eugolaiD eht fo, .K .A .M ;501-101 .pp ,"nettirW eht dna larO ehT" ,kaloP
ecafretnI ehT ,ydooG .J ;5891 ,drofxO ,egaugnaL nettirW dna nekopS ,yadillaH
.L .W ;462-262 .pp ,7891 ,KU/egdirbmaC ,larO eht dna nettirW eht neewteB
dna gnikaepS neewteB secnereffiD yb decudorP secnereffiD citsiugniL" ,efahC
ehT :gninraeL dna egaugnaL ,ycaretiL ,).sde( .la te noslO .R .D ni ",gnitirW
.pp ,7891 ,KU/egdirbmaC ,gnidaeR dna gnitirW fo secneuqesnoC dna erutaN
dna hsilgnE ni eciohC laitnerefeR" ,ycnalC .M .P ;111-801 .pp .pse ,321-501
:seirotS raeP ehT ,).de( efahC .L .W ni ,"esruocsiD evitarraN esenapaJ
,noitcudorP evitarraN fo stcepsA citsiugniL dna larutluC ,evitingoC
;891-791 ,571-761 ,331-721 .pp .pse ,102-721 .pp ,0891 ,JN/doowroN ecaF-ot-ecaF ni semaG gninialpxE :ytilarO dna sixieD" ,frodnesuaH .H
,nilreB ,noitacinummoC larO fo stcepsA ,).de( ffohtsauQ .M .U ni ,"noitcaretnI
791-181 .pp ,5991.
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
402
, , : ."
,) ,(
.03
:) '(
" "
" "
" )13" " :("
" "
:""
;)" "(
)" "(
.)" "(
" :
$ " ;) '( " " "
, , .) '( " .23 .
)""( , ." " :) ,'(
. ,
" : . , .) ,'( "
:" ":)- '( " , "
33" " , 42
. . 12-22
rewoP fo esruocsiD ehT :htuR" ,wokhsaR anoD
ot noinapmoC tsinimeF A ,).de( rennerB .A ni ,"esruocsiD fo rewoP eht dna
14 ,82 .pp .pse ,14-62 .pp ,3991 ,dleiffehS ,htuR : sudoxE ni yalpdroW fo noitaterpretnI nA :tiW s'orhteJ" ,nietsneerG .L .E
ni seidutS .heveniN ot yaW eht nO ,).sde( retniW .C .S dna kooC .L .S ni ,"81
461-751 .pp .pse ,171-551 .pp ,9991 ,atnaltA ,sednaL .M egroeG fo ronolJ
, , )74-84 ,(
.) " ;- ,'' '(
) ," : ,'' '(" "
.) ,' (" " ,
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
502 -
43 " , "
"(
, , , .)"
)"" ,""(
, .)" "(
, .)" "(
" " .
. ,53 " " ,
.63" "
" :)- '(
:"
" / "
" / "
" / " ' / " " / "
" : , .)"" ,"" ,""(
, ." " ," " ,"
,"" ,""( "
,3) '( , .)""
:)-'(
:" "
" "
'' " .43: weN A :htuR ,llebpmaC .F .E .pp ,5791 ,kroY weN ,yratnemmoC dna setoN ,noitcudortnI htiw noitalsnarT
.) , :( 69-49 ( ,
. "" ,)VSA, SPJN .)" "( .53 ,)ssalc elddim rewol( .63
,) ,""(
ni egaugnaL fo ydutS ehT" ,vobaL .W : pp .pse ,612-251 .pp ,I ,secnavdA ,).de( namhsiF ni ,"txetnoC laicoS sti. 591-391, .) 82 ( 402-791
. .73
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
602
' " " "
" ' ' "
" "
( . .)" "( .)" "( )
"(
, .)" .)" "(
,
:) '( " "
)( ,)""( )( )4( )3( )2( )1(" :
."
, . , .83 .) '(
.
,93
, . ,
" . , ,
, "
, .04
" :
.) '("
.
:)- ,' ; (
" "
" / "
23 . , , 101-201.
" " :.A
rennerB .A ni ,"ymagoxE fo scitiloP eht dna rekroW ngieroF a sa htuR" ,rennerB
,)seireS dnoceS ,elbiB eht ot noinapmoC tsinimeF A( rehtsE dna htuR ,).de(
071-851 .pp ,9991 ,dleiffehS.
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
702 -
" ' )? :(" " "
" ^ ' " ," )2( )1( " :
)3( )2( )1( ": " )2( ' )1("
."." )4( )3( )2(' )1(?" : ;"
, ." " :
," " ," "(
.)" "
, .
" : ."
. .) '(" , ,
:)- '( , :" "
" / " " / "
" / " " / / ' "
,
.)" " ," " ," " ," / "(
,)" / "( ,
/ 24 ' " ," "
. ."
,
.
:) ,'(
.) ,- ,'( .14
)/( : , .24
; ,' : ,' " : ,'' : ' " : , ,' "( ."'"
" : .) , "
' " ;) ," ;- ," ,' ; , ( "
, , .) ," ' ! , : ,' ; ,' ( " : :) ," ' :- ," "(" ' " ,' ; ," : ,' ' : ,' : ," : ," ' ; ,' "(" . .) ," '
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
802
:" " )(
" ! "
" "
" " )(
. ,
( " " :
. .)
," "
: ;) ,' (" " :
;) ," "( ' -"
.34) ," "( " " :
." "
, , ." / "
,
, , .
,'( ,) ,- ,'( .),-
, , , . ,44 , . .)- ,'( ) ,'( ,
.
.4
,
-- . , , - .
, , , ,
: .54) ( -
.H, : ,'' : ,'' " : ,' " ! ,' ' ! ,' .34 yksnilrO .M
"lacilbiB ni noitcejretnI ro evitarepmI na retfa evissuJ dna evitatrohoC eht nO pp ,)14-0491( 13 RQJ ,"werbeH.. 283-173
.p ,evoL lahteL ,iaB. 87 .44
.
.) ,'(
.)- ," ( 681 , , .54
.) , (
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
902 -
" :64) ,' "( -
'( ."
." . ," :)-
, ,
, .
, , , .74
." "
. 84,) (
, -
: .94" " ,
, , , .
.
" :) ,' ( .
." /
, , ." [" ,
." " ,
" :)- '(
. '
."
,
," " : .
. .
, ( .64
. ,)- , :-
, , .)- , ( , ,
.31-91
.18-68 ," , , , .74
,"" , .84
" )3-4,59 ,( , .)48 , ,(
, , ,"
.) (
noitasrevnoC ,ttiffooW dna ybhctuH )gnikat nrut( - .94
, , pp ,sisylanA. 75-74 .82-13 , , ! 58-68
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
012
,
, .
:) '(
"... , " )1-(
-
.
. :
, , ,05 , : . .
,
.) ," "( " , " :
, .
( , ,
, : " :)
. .) '("
." " - , ,
, ,
) ( . , ,
, , , . .) (
, . -
, ,
.15
, ,
, ,
" " :)- '(
:)- (
." " )1-(
,) 8 ( .05
? , .
. 8 .15
, ,)06-76 ,(
. , , ,)gnikaep(
.)16-26 ,(
MA 55:34:40 5102 naJ 51 ,uhT no 891.112.731.38 morf dedaolnwod tnetnoc sihTsnoitidnoC dna smreT ROTSJ ot tcejbus esu llA
-
112 -
, ,
, ,
.
,
, : :) '<
."? " )2-(
:) '(
." " )2-(
, ,
. ,
, , ,
:)'(
" " )3-(
." " , , ,
:) '(
." " )3( ,
:)'( ." " )