$01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

10
"# $ %&’()*+ ,-*(. $ /.-)#$01 ,-*1#2 30 45$6)$(&-0 -7 "07-*8$(&-0 39$*+0+## :&#;6$<# "#$%&’()#*$ +,-.*/ 0(11 2%,,*$/ -31 4(#3 5’-&6( "(,,*7* (8 "(9).’%37 : ;<= "*3’*$ ;*($7%- >3&’%’.’* (8 0*?#3(,(7@ A’,-3’-/ ;A BCBBD E),-.*/ ’(9%,,*$/ &’-&6(FG??H7-’*?#H*1. !"#$%&’$ I#-’ 9-6*& - )*$%)#*$-, ($ -9J%*3’ 1%&),-@ 9($* *8K 8*?’%L* -’ )$*&*3’%37 -M-$*3*&& %38($9-’%(3 ’#-3 -3K (’#*$N +$*&*3’,@/ ,%’’,* %& 63(M3 %3 ’#%& $*7-$1 -31 ’*?#3%O.*& 8($ *L-,.-’%37 ’#*&* ’@)*& (8 1%&),-@& -$* P.&’ J*7%33%37 ’( J* 1*L*,()*1H >3 ’#%& -$’%?,*/ M* 8(?.& (3 (3* -&)*?’ (8 - )*$%)#*$-, 1%&),-@Q& *88*?’%L*3*&&R %’& -J%,%’@ ’( ?(99.3%?-’* %38($9-’%(3 -’ - 7,-3?*H I* ?(31.?’*1 -3 *L-,.-’%(3 (8 ’#* >38("-3L-&/ - )*$%)#*$-, 1%&),-@ ’#-’ ?(3L*@& -M-$*3*&& %38($9-’%(3 7$-)#%?-,,@ -& - 8($9 (8 %38($9-’%(3 -$’/ J@ -&&*&&%37 #(M M*,, )*(),* $*?-,, %38($9-’%(3 M#*3 %’ %& )$*&*3’*1 8($ - J$%*8 )*$%(1 (8 ’%9*H I* ?(9)-$* )*$8($9-3?* (8 ’#* >38("-3L-& ’( ’M( (’#*$ *,*?’$(3%? %38($9-’%(3 1%&K ),-@&/ - I*J )($’-, &’@,* -31 - ’*S’KJ-&*1 1%&),-@/ M#*3 *-?# 1%&),-@ M-& L%*M*1 8($ - &#($’ )*$%(1 (8 ’%9*H I* 8(.31 ’#-’ )-$’%?%)-3’& 3(’*1 -31 $*?-,,*1 &%73%8%?-3’,@ 9($* %38($9-’%(3 M#*3 )$*&*3’*1 J@ ’#* >38("-3L-& ’#-3 J@ *%’#*$ (8 ’#* (’#*$ 1%&),-@& 1*&)%’* #-L%37 ’( ,*-$3 ’#* -11%’%(3-, 7$-)#%?-, $*)$*&*3’-’%(3& *9),(@*1 J@ ’#* >38("-3L-&H )*+ ,-%.#/ 0*%123*%&4 .1#24&+5 &6"1*7$ .1#24&+5 178-%9 6&$1-7 :1#;&41<&$1-75 &,&%*7*## 178-%6&$1-75 *621%1’&4 *:&4;&$1-7 = "0(*-1)’(&-0 +*$%)#*$-, -M-$*3*&& 1%&),-@& -$* &@&’*9& ’#-’ $*&%1* %3 - .&*$Q& *3L%$(39*3’ M%’#%3 ’#* )*$%)#*$@ (8 ’#* .&*$Q& -’’*3’%(3H A& &.?#/ ’#* ).$)(&* (8 ’#*&* 1%&),-@& %& 3(’ 8($ 9(3%’($%37 L%’-, ’-&6&H T-’#*$/ )*$%)#*$-, 1%&),-@& J*&’ &*$L* -& ?(99.3%?-’%(3 9*1%- ’#-’ )*(),* ?-3 ())($’.3%&’%?-,,@ *S-9%3* ’( 9-%3’-%3 %38($9-’%(3 -M-$*3*&& UVV/ VWXH 0#* ’*$9 &6"1*7$ .1#24&+ UDDX #-& J**3 .&*1 ’( 1*K &?$%J* &@&’*9& ,%6* ’#%& -& M*,,/ J.’ ’( -L(%1 ?(38.&%(3/ ’#$(.7#(.’ ’#%& 1(?.9*3’ M* .&* ’#%& ’*$9 ’( 1*&?$%J* )*$%)#*$-, -M-$*3*&& &@&’*9& ’#-’ 7*3*$-,,@ ?(3L*@ (3,@ (3* )%*?* (8 %38($9-’%(3H I* .&* ’#* ’*$9 2*%1239 *%&4 .1#24&+ ’( 1*&?$%J* )*$%)#*$-, -M-$*3*&& &@&’*9& ’#-’ 9-@ )$*&*3’ 9.,’%),* %38($9-’%(3 %’*9&H Y(’# )*K $%)#*$-, -31 -9J%*3’ 1%&),-@& -$* 1*&%73*1 3(’ ’( 1%&K ’$-?’ )*(),* 8$(9 ’#*%$ ’-&6& -’ #-31/ J.’ ’( J* &.J’,*/ ?-,9 $*9%31*$& ’#-’ ?-3 J* (??-&%(3-,,@ 3(’%?*1H >3 -11%’%(3 ’( )$*&*3’%37 %38($9-’%(3/ ’#* 1%&),-@& -,&( 8$*O.*3’,@ ?(3’$%J.’* ’( ’#* -*&’#*’%?& (8 ’#* ,(?-,* %3 M#%?# ’#*@ -$* 1*),(@*1 UVXH Z([*3& (8 )*$%)#*$-,:-9J%*3’ 1%&),-@& #-L* J**3 ?$*-’*1 %3 9-3@ &#-)*& -31 8($9 8-?’($&H 5(9* 1%&K ),-@&/ &.?# -& ’#* 1-37,%37 &’$%37 UDVX/ ’-37%J,* 1%&),-@& %3?,.1%37 M-’*$ ,-9)& -31 )%3M#**,& U\X/ -31 ’#* >3K 8($9-’%(3 +*$?(,-’($ UWX #-L* .’%,%[*1 )#@&%?-, ]-31 (8’*3 *L*$@1-@^ (JP*?’&H _’#*$ 1%&),-@&/ &.?# -& >38($K 9-’%L* A$’M($6 U‘X -31 ’#* Z%7%’-, a-9%,@ +($’$-%’ UVbX .&* *,*?’$(3%? 1%&),-@& ’( $*)$*&*3’ %38($9-’%(3 %3 - 7$-)#%?-, 9-33*$H A,, ’#*&* &@&’*9& )$%9-$%,@ ?(99.K 3%?-’* (3* %’*9 (8 %38($9-’%(3H _’#*$ )*$%)#*$-,:-9J%*3’ 1%&),-@& *S%&’ ’#-’ -$* ?-K )-J,* (8 ?(3L*@%37 9($* ’#-3 (3* %38($9-’%(3 %’*9 &%9.,’-3*(.&,@H 0#* Z%7%’-, a-9%,@ +($’$-%’/ -,’#(.7# )$%9-$%,@ %3’*31*1 ’( -,,(M 7*(7$-)#%?-,,@ &*)-$-’*1 8-9%,@ 9*9J*$& 9-%3’-%3 -M-$*3*&& (8 *-?# (’#*$/ -,K ,(M& 8($ ’#* ()’%(3-, 1%&),-@%37 (8 -11%’%(3-, %38($9-K ’%(3 &.?# -& M*-’#*$ UVbXH A.1%( ?.*&/ %3&’*-1 (8 L%&.-, 1%&),-@&/ #-L* -,&( J**3 .’%,%[*1 %3 )*$%)#*$-, 1%&),-@& ’( ?(3L*@ 9.,’%),* 3.77*’& (8 %38($9-’%(3 %3 ’#* A.1%( A.$- &@&’*9 UVcXH 0#* d-31%3&6@ &@&’*9 UcX -’’*9)’& ’( ?$*-’* -$’%&’%? ?(,,-7*& (8 L-$%(.& )%*?*& (8 %38($9-K ’%(3/ -31 ’#* 5?()* &@&’*9 %& -3 -J&’$-?’ L%&.-,%[-’%(3 1%&),-@%37 3(’%8%?-’%(3 %38($9-’%(3 8$(9 9.,’%),* &(.$?*& UVeXH 5%1*5#(M UBX )$(L%1*& - 1%&),-@ &%1*J-$ ?(3’-%3%37 9.,’%),* -M-$*3*&& %?(3& &.?# -& ’$-88%? -31 M*-’#*$ %31%?-’($&H 0#* >38("-3L-& UV\X/ ’#* 8(?.& (8 ’#%& -$’%?,*/ 1%8K 8*$& 8$(9 ’#* %3%’%-, &*’ (8 &@&’*9& -J(L* J@ *S),%?%’,@ )$(9(’%37 ’#* ?(3L*@-3?* (8 9.,’%),* )%*?*& (8 %38($K 9-’%(3 ?(3?.$$*3’,@H >’ 1%88*$& 8$(9 ’#* ,-’’*$ &*’ (8

Upload: others

Post on 11-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

!

"#!$!%&'()*+!,-*(.!$!/.-)#$01!,-*1#2!30!45$6)$(&-0!-7!"07-*8$(&-0!39$*+0+##!:&#;6$<#!

!! ! ! ! !

"#$%&'()#*$!+,-.*/!0(11!2%,,*$/!-31!4(#3!5'-&6(!!

"(,,*7*!(8!"(9).'%37!:!;<=!"*3'*$!;*($7%-!>3&'%'.'*!(8!0*?#3(,(7@!

A',-3'-/!;A!BCBBD!E),-.*/!'(9%,,*$/!&'-&6(FG??H7-'*?#H*1.!

!!!

!"#$%&'$(

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

)*+(,-%.#/(0*%123*%&4(.1#24&+5(&6"1*7$(.1#24&+5( 178-%9

6&$1-7(:1#;&41<&$1-75(&,&%*7*##(178-%6&$1-75(*621%1'&4(

*:&4;&$1-7(

=! "0(*-1)'(&-0!

+*$%)#*$-,!-M-$*3*&&!1%&),-@&!-$*!&@&'*9&!'#-'!$*&%1*!%3!-!.&*$Q&!*3L%$(39*3'!M%'#%3!'#*!)*$%)#*$@!(8!'#*!.&*$Q&!-''*3'%(3H!A&!&.?#/! '#*!).$)(&*!(8! '#*&*!1%&),-@&!%&!3('!8($!9(3%'($%37!L%'-,! '-&6&H! !T-'#*$/! )*$%)#*$-,! 1%&),-@&!J*&'! &*$L*! -&! ?(99.3%?-'%(3! 9*1%-! '#-'! )*(),*! ?-3!())($'.3%&'%?-,,@! *S-9%3*! '(! 9-%3'-%3! %38($9-'%(3!-M-$*3*&&!UVV/!VWXH!!!! 0#*!'*$9!&6"1*7$(.1#24&+!UDDX!#-&!J**3!.&*1!'(!1*K&?$%J*!&@&'*9&!,%6*!'#%&!-&!M*,,/!J.'!'(!-L(%1!?(38.&%(3/!'#$(.7#(.'! '#%&!1(?.9*3'!M*!.&*! '#%&! '*$9( '(!1*&?$%J*!)*$%)#*$-,! -M-$*3*&&! &@&'*9&! '#-'! 7*3*$-,,@! ?(3L*@!

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`X!-31!'#*!Z%7%'-,!a-9%,@!+($'$-%'!UVbX!.&*! *,*?'$(3%?! 1%&),-@&! '(! $*)$*&*3'! %38($9-'%(3! %3! -!7$-)#%?-,!9-33*$H!!A,,!'#*&*!&@&'*9&!)$%9-$%,@!?(99.K3%?-'*!(3*!%'*9!(8!%38($9-'%(3H! !! _'#*$!)*$%)#*$-,:-9J%*3'!1%&),-@&!*S%&'! '#-'!-$*!?-K)-J,*! (8! ?(3L*@%37! 9($*! '#-3! (3*! %38($9-'%(3! %'*9!&%9.,'-3*(.&,@H! !0#*!Z%7%'-,! a-9%,@!+($'$-%'/! -,'#(.7#!)$%9-$%,@! %3'*31*1! '(! -,,(M! 7*(7$-)#%?-,,@! &*)-$-'*1!8-9%,@!9*9J*$&!9-%3'-%3! -M-$*3*&&!(8! *-?#!('#*$/! -,K,(M&!8($! '#*!()'%(3-,!1%&),-@%37!(8!-11%'%(3-,! %38($9-K'%(3!&.?#!-&!M*-'#*$!UVbXH!!A.1%(!?.*&/!%3&'*-1!(8!L%&.-,!1%&),-@&/!#-L*!-,&(!J**3!.'%,%[*1! %3!)*$%)#*$-,!1%&),-@&!'(!?(3L*@!9.,'%),*!3.77*'&!(8!%38($9-'%(3!%3!'#*!A.1%(!A.$-!&@&'*9!UVcXH!!!0#*!d-31%3&6@!&@&'*9!UcX!-''*9)'&!'(!?$*-'*!-$'%&'%?!?(,,-7*&!(8!L-$%(.&!)%*?*&!(8! %38($9-K'%(3/! -31! '#*!5?()*! &@&'*9! %&! -3! -J&'$-?'! L%&.-,%[-'%(3!1%&),-@%37! 3('%8%?-'%(3! %38($9-'%(3! 8$(9! 9.,'%),*!&(.$?*&!UVeXH! !5%1*5#(M!UBX!)$(L%1*&!-!1%&),-@!&%1*J-$!?(3'-%3%37!9.,'%),*!-M-$*3*&&!%?(3&!&.?#!-&!'$-88%?!-31!M*-'#*$!%31%?-'($&H!! 0#*! >38("-3L-&! UV\X/! '#*! 8(?.&! (8! '#%&! -$'%?,*/! 1%8K8*$&! 8$(9! '#*! %3%'%-,! &*'!(8! &@&'*9&!-J(L*!J@!*S),%?%',@!)$(9('%37! '#*! ?(3L*@-3?*!(8!9.,'%),*!)%*?*&!(8! %38($K9-'%(3! ?(3?.$$*3',@H! ! >'! 1%88*$&! 8$(9! '#*! ,-''*$! &*'! (8!

Page 2: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

&@&'*9&! %3!)$(9('%37!7$*-'*$! 8,*S%J%,%'@!(8! %38($9-'%(3!9(3%'($*1! -31! %'&! &.J&*O.*3'! L%&.-,! $*)$*&*3'-'%(3/! -&!M*,,! -&! -,,(M%37! 8($! 7$*-'*$! .&*$! ?(3'$(,! %3! &)*?%8@%37!'#(&*!9-))%37&H!! A,'#(.7#!9-3@!'@)*&!(8!1%&),-@&!*S%&'!-31!3*M!(3*&!-$*!J*%37!1*L*,()*1/!,%'',*!%&!63(M3!-J(.'!M#-'!9-6*&!-!)-$'%?.,-$!)*$%)#*$-,:-9J%*3'!1%&),-@!9($*!&.??*&&8.,!-'!)$*&*3'%37!%38($9-'%(3!'#-3!-3('#*$!UVCXH!!a.$'#*$9($*/!&.?#! 1%&),-@&! -$*! %3#*$*3',@! 1%88%?.,'! '(! *L-,.-'*! 8($K9-,,@! &%3?*! '#*@! -$*! 1*&%73*1! 3('! '(! 1%&'$-?'! '#*! .&*$H!!A&!-!$*&.,'/!*L-,.-'%(3!'*?#3%O.*&!#-L*!J**3!,%9%'*1/!-&!2-36(88! *$( &4=! 3('*! UVCX/! '(! 8($9-'%L*! *'#3(7$-)#%*&!UVbX! -31! M%'#%3K,-J! &'.1%*&! M#*$*! 1%&),-@&! -$*! 1*L*,K()*1! -31! &.J&*O.*3',@! $*8%3*1! (L*$! '%9*! J@! '#*%$! 1*K&%73*$&! UbXH! !f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`X!)$(P*?'&!9-6*!.&*!(8!1@3-9%?!)%*?*&!(8!*,*?K'$(3%?! -$'M($6! '(! $*)$*&*3'! %38($9-'%(3! %3! -3! *@*K-))*-,%37!9-33*$H! ! 5.?#! 1%&),-@&! -$*! ),-?*1!M%'#%3! -!)*$&(3Q&! M($6! *3L%$(39*3'! ($! -$*! ).J,%?,@! 1%&),-@*1/!*3-J,%37!-'K-K7,-3?*!%38($9-'%(3!-M-$*3*&&H!!f(M!M*,,!'#*!&@&'*9&!?(3L*@!%38($9-'%(3!%&!3('!63(M3/!#(M*L*$H!!! g('*! '#-'! '#*! &.??*&&! (8! -! )*$%)#*$-,:-9J%*3'! 1%&K),-@!%3L(,L*&!9($*!'#-3!&%9),*!%38($9-'%(3!-?O.%&%'%(3H!!Y*?-.&*!'#*&*!1%&),-@&!-$*!)(&%'%(3*1!%3!)*(),*Q&!*3L%K$(39*3'&/!-*&'#*'%?&!-31!-''$-?'%L*3*&&! %38,.*3?*!-1()K

'%(3! -&! M*,,H! 0#*! $*&*-$?#! $*)($'*1! #*$*/! '#(.7#/! 8(K?.&*&! &(,*,@!(3! &.?#!1%&),-@&Q! -J%,%'@! '(! ?(3L*@! %38($K9-'%(3H!!>3!-!?(9)-3%(3!&'.1@/!'#*!%&&.*&!(8!-*&'#*'%?&!-31!,(37*$K'*$9!.&*!(8!'#*!>38("-3L-&!&@&'*9!-$*!?.$K$*3',@!J*%37!*S),($*1H!

>! 4?;+*&8+0($6!:+#&@0!

0#%&!&'.1@!*S-9%3*&!%8!-3!*,*?'$(3%?!)%?'.$*!h%&!M($'#!-!'#(.&-31!M($1&Hi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

>A=! B$(+*&$6#!

0*3! %'*9&! (8! %38($9-'%(3! M*$*! &*,*?'*1! '(! J*! 9(3%K'($*1j! '%9*! (8! 1-@/! -! M*-'#*$! 8($*?-&'/! -! '*9)*$-'.$*!8($*?-&'/! '$-88%?! ?(31%'%(3&/! -! 3*M&! #*-1,%3*/! '#*! Z(M!4(3*&! &'(?6! %31*S!L-,.*/! -3! -%$8-$*! )$%?*/! .)1-'*&! '(! -!I*J!&%'*/!-!?(.3'!(8!3*M!*9-%,&/!-31!-!J-&*J-,,!&?($*H!!0#*&*! %'*9&! -$*! *S-9),*&! (8! %38($9-'%(3! )*(),*! '@)%K?-,,@!&**6!'(!9-%3'-%3!-M-$*3*&&!(8!UV\XH!! 0#$**! %38($9-'%(3!&?$**3&!M*$*!1*&%73*1! %3?,.1%37!-3! >38("-3L-&! J*-?#! &?*3*/! -! 9%3%9-,%&'! '*S'KJ-&*1!1%&),-@/! -31! -! I*J! )($'-,K,%6*! 1%&),-@H! ! 0#*&*! '#$**!1%&),-@&!M*$*!?#(&*3!'(!$*)$*&*3'!%3'*$*&'%37!)(%3'&!%3!-!&)*?'$.9! (8! )(&&%J%,%'%*&/! -&! 1*)%?'*1! %3! a%7.$*! V/! 8($!$*)$*&*3'%37!-M-$*3*&&!%38($9-'%(3!(3!*,*?'$(3%?!-9J%K*3'! 1%&),-@&H! !5'@,*&! $-37*! 8$(9!).$*! '*S'.-,! )$*&*3'-K'%(3&! '(! #%7#,@! -J&'$-?'/! 7$-)#%?-,! %9-7*$@H! 0#*! >38(K"-3L-&! -31! '#*! 0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@! %3#-J%'! )(&%'%(3&!3*-$! '#*! *31)(%3'&! (8! '#-'! &)*?'$.9H! ! 0#*!I*J! +($'-,!1%&),-@!M-&!1*&%73*1!'(!%3?($)($-'*!-!#@J$%1!(8!'*S'.$-,!-31!7$-)#%?-,!$*)$*&*3'-'%(3&/!-31!$*&*9J,*!'#*!'@)*&!(8!I*J! h&'-$'! )-7*&i! '#-'! )*(),*! 8$*O.*3',@! .&*! '(!9-%3K'-%3!%38($9-'%(3!-M-$*3*&&!'(1-@!UV\XH!! _'#*$! %3'*$*&'%37! )(%3'&! %3! '#*! &)*?'$.9! %3?,.1*!9($*!1%$*?'!7$-)#%?-,! ]'@)%?-,,@! %?(3%?^! $*)$*&*3'-'%(3&!(8! %38($9-'%(3! -&! *9J(1%*1! J@! &@&'*9&! &.?#! -&! 5%1*K&#(M! UBX/! -31! ?(.,1! J*! '#*! &.JP*?'! (8! 8.'.$*! *S)*$%K9*3'&H! ! a($! '#%&! &'.1@/!M*! ?(9)-$*! '#*! >38("-3L-&! '(!'M(! M%1*,@! 1*),(@*1! '@)*&/!I*J! )($'-,&! ]*H7H!2@k-K#((l^!-31!'*S'K#*-L@!3*M&!&.99-$%*&!($!I*J!)-7*&H!!!

!

!"#$%&'()*+,-%'

!!!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

"#$%&'#(')!./01

2"3)4$56'.71

*+,!-%./'0

8&'9-$55:

1+2/34')+5

;<=5>?-+"@)'A>+65>B'.C1!"#$%&'D>-E$"F-%'

>1?;%*( @/( ( !( #2*'$%;6( -8( &,&%*7*##( .1#24&+#( %&7?17?(

8%-6($*A$;&4($-(?%&231'&4(2%*#*7$&$1-7#(-8(178-%6&$1-7=(

Page 3: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

! A,,! '#$**!1%&),-@&!%3! '#*!&'.1@!M*$*!1*&%73*1!&**6K%37! -! J-,-3?*! (8! *S)*$%9*3'-,! ?(3'$(,! -31! $*)$*&*3'-K'%(3! (8! *?(,(7%?-,,@! L-,%1! $*-,KM($,1! .&*H! mS'*3&%L*!)%,('! '*&'%37! -31! $*1*&%73!M-&! .&*1! '(! $*8%3*! '#*%$! -)K)*-$-3?*H!!I*!1*&%73*1!'#*!'#$**!1%&),-@&!'(!*3?(1*!'#*!'*3!)%*?*&!(8! %38($9-'%(3! %3!-3!-))$()$%-'*!9-33*$!8($!'#-'! 1%&),-@! &'@,*H! ! >3! -,,! '#$**/! M*! -11*1! -! &9-,,!-9(.3'! (8! *S'$-! %38($9-'%(3! J*@(31! '#*! '*3! O.*$%*1!%38($9-'%(3!L-,.*&/!9.?#!-&!&%9%,-$!$*-,!M($,1!1%&),-@&!M(.,1!.31(.J'*1,@!1(H!! A,,! 1%&),-@&! M*$*! )$*&*3'*1! 8.,,K&?$**3! (3! -!<%*M&(3%?!Vci!n"Z!1%&),-@!$.33%37!-'!-! $*&(,.'%(3!(8!VCD\! S! Wb`H! ! 0#*! >38("-3L-&! .&*1! '#*! *3'%$*! &?$**3!-$*-/!-31!'#*!('#*$!'M(!1%&),-@&!.&*1!&,%7#',@!,*&&!(8!'#*!*3'%$*! 1%&),-@! -&!M%,,! J*! *S),-%3*1! J*,(MH! ! >3! '#*! 8(,K,(M%37!&.J&*?'%(3&/!M*!1*&?$%J*!*-?#!(8!'#*!1%&),-@&!%3!9($*!1*'-%,H!

"07-C$05$#!:&#;6$<!

0#*! >38("-3L-&! &@&'*9! &.))($'&! -! L-$%*'@! (8! -$'%&'%?!&?*3*&! ($! '#*9*&H! !I*! ?#(&*! '(! .&*! -! J*-?#! &?*3*! -&!&#(M3!%3!a%7.$*!D!8($!'#*!*S)*$%9*3'!1.*!'(!%'&!)().,-$K%'@!M%'#!'$%-,!.&*$&H!>31%L%1.-,!(JP*?'&!%3!'#*!&?*3*!$*)K$*&*3'*1!'#*!'*3!1-'-!L-,.*&!-&!8(,,(M&j!

"'3&*7$*+! ;*&'+j! T*)$*&*3'*1! J@! '#*! L*$'%?-,! #*%7#'!(8! '#*! 6%'*! %3! '#*! &6@! 8$(9! oC! ]3*-$! '#*! M-'*$!,*L*,^!'(!o\CC!]'()!(8!'#*!&?$**3^H!

"'D+9#! .+$16&0+j! 5#(M3! (3! '#*! J-33*$! J*#%31! '#*!),-3*H!

"'/&8+!-7!1$<j!Z*3('*1!J@!'#*!&-%,J(-'!9(L%37!8$(9!'#*!,*8'!&%1*!]VDjCV!A2^!'(!'#*!$%7#'!&%1*!]VVjce!+2^H!!

"',+E!#&(+!);1$(+j!T*)$*&*3'*1!J@!'#*!?(,($!(8! '#*!,*-L*&!(3!'#*!)-,9!'$**/!7$**3!%31%?-'*&!-!$*?*3'!.)1-'*!-31!J$(M3!%31%?-'*&!3(!$*?*3'!?#-37*&H!

"',+$(.+*! 7-*+'$#(j! >,,.&'$-'*1! '#$(.7#! '#*! -?'.-,!M*-'#*$!&#(M3!%3!'#*!&6@!]*H7H/!?,(.1&!$*)$*&*3'&!-!8($*?-&'!(8!?,(.1@!M*-'#*$^H!

"'/+8;+*$()*+!7-*+'$#(j!T*)$*&*3'*1!J@!'#*!#*%7#'!(8! '#*! ,-$7*!&*-7.,,! %3! '#*! &6@/! $-37%37! 8$(9!cC!1*7$**&!-'!M-'*$!,*L*,!'(!eC!1*7$**&!-'!'#*!'()!(8!'#*!&?$**3H!

"':-9! F-0+#! #(-'G! 8$*G+(! '.$0@+j! Z%&),-@*1! J@!'#*! -$$-37*9*3'! (8! &*-&#*,,&! (3! '#*! &#($*,%3*H!!5#*,,&! 8($9!-3!-$$(M!'(! %31%?-'*!M#*'#*$!&'(?6&!-$*! .)! ($! 1(M3! -31! '#*! O.-3'%'@! (8! &#*,,&! %31%K?-'*&!'#*!L-,.*!]'#$**!&#*,,&!%31%?-'*!-!?#-37*!(8!C! p! cC! )(%3'&/! 8%L*! &#*,,&! %31%?-'*! -! ?#-37*! (8!9($*!'#-3!cC!)(%3'&^H!

"'D+9! +8$&6! 8+##$@+#j! Z*)%?'*1! J@! '#*! #*%7#'! (8!,%O.%1! %3! '#*! 7,-&&! $-37%37! 8$(9! C! 3*M! *9-%,&!]*9)'@!7,-&&^!'(!DC!3*M!*9-%,&!]-!8.,,!7,-&&^H!

"'C)**+0(!(*$77&'!#;++1!-0!$! 6-'$6!*-$19$<j!5@9KJ(,%[*1!J@!'#*!?(,($!(8!'#*!M(9-3Q&!J-'#%37!&.%'!M%'#!$*1!%31%?-'%37!&)**1!,*&&!'#-3!Dc!2+f/!@*,K,(M!%31%?-'%37!-!&)**1!J*'M**3!Dc!-31!cC!2+f/!-31! 7$**3! %31%?-'%37! -! &)**1! 7$*-'*$! '#-3! cC!2+fH!

"'H$#+E$66! #'-*+j! 5#(M3! J@! '#*! &%[*! (8! 'M(! J*-?#!J-,,&j!!A!,-$7*$!J-,,!%31%?-'*&!-!M%33%37!'*-9!-31!%1*3'%?-,!J-,,!&%[*&!%31%?-'*!-!'%*1!&?($*H!!"(,($!%&!.&*1!'(!1%&'%37.%&#!'#*!'M(!'*-9&H!

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a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a($! *S-9),*/! '#*! 1%88*$*3'! &#*,,! -$$-37*9*3'&!$*)$*&*3'%37! '#*!Z(M!4(3*&! &'(?6!.)1-'*! %31%?-'*! 8(.$!1%88*$*3'!$-37*&!(8!L-,.*&H!0#*!%9),%?-'%(3&!(8!'#%&!1%8K8*$*3?*!M%,,!J*!*S),($*1!9($*!8.,,@!,-'*$!M#*3!1*&?$%JK%37!'#*!O.*&'%(33-%$*!8($9-'&H!

/+?(IH$#+1!:&#;6$<!

0#*! 0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@! ]&#(M3! %3! a%7.$*! D^! )$*1(9%K3-3',@! .&*&! '*S'! '(! 1%&),-@! %38($9-'%(3H! ! I*J! )-7*&!&.?#! -&! 2@k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mS'$-! %38($9-'%(3! J*@(31! '#*! '*3! 1-'-! L-,.*&! (3! '#%&!1%&),-@!%3?,.1*1!-!8*M!,%3*&!8$(9!-!3*M&!-$'%?,*!$*,-'*1!'(!'#*!?.$$*3'!#*-1,%3*/!'#*!?.$$*3'!1-'*/!-31!-11%'%(3-,!&'(?6!%38($9-'%(3!8($!'#*!5'-31-$1!q!+(($Q&!cCC!-31!!!

Page 4: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

!

((

!

!(

>1?;%*(B/(CA&624*#(-8($3*(D78-E&7:&#("*&'3(#'*7*(F$-2G5($*A$9"&#*.(F61..4*G5(&7.(H*"(0-%$&4(.1#24&+#(F"-$$-6G(

;#*.(17($3*(#$;.+=(

Page 5: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

gA5ZAr! %31%?*&R%'*9&! ,%6*,@! '(! -))*-$! (3! &.?#! -!1%&),-@H!!!! 0#*! 0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@! ?(3&%&'*1! (8! -! $*7%(3! eWC!)%S*,&!M%1*!'(!BBC!)%S*,&!#%7#!(3!'#*!&?$**3H!!+%,('!'*&'K%37! 8(.31! '#%&!&%[*!()'%9-,! %3!-,,(M%37! '#*!.&*!(8!?(,K.93&/!&*?'%(3!#*-1*$&/!-31!M#%'*!&)-?*!'(!9-6*!-3!*8K8*?'%L*! -31! L%&.-,,@! ),*-&%37! 1%&),-@H! ! a.$'#*$9($*/!)%,('!'*&'%37!%31%?-'*1!'#-'!%38($9-'%(3!$*?-,,!&.88*$*1!-&!'#*! 1%&),-@Q&! &%[*! %3?$*-&*1/! )*$#-)&! 1.*! '(! %3?$*-&*1!*@*!9(L*9*3'/!*L*3!'#(.7#!'#*!1-'-!*,*9*3'&!$*9-%3*1!,(?-'*1!%3!'#*!&-9*!)(&%'%(3H!!!

,+E!%-*($6!:&#;6$<!

0#*!I*J!+($'-,!1%&),-@!]&#(M3!%3!a%7.$*!D^!-,&(!9%9K%?6*1!'#*!,((6!-31!8**,!(8!)().,-$!3(K?(&'!h&'-$'i!I*J!)-7*&! &.?#! -&! 2@! k-#((H! f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eb`!)%S*,&!M%1*!J@!B`b!)%S*,&!#%7#!(3!'#*!1%&),-@H!A7-%3/!%'*$-'%L*!1*L*,()9*3'! -31! )%,('! '*&'%37! #*,)*1! 1*'*$9%3*! '#%&!&%[*!M-&! J*&'! '(! ?$*-'*! -! J-,-3?*1! -31! ($1*$*1! ,-@(.'!-31!J*!-3!*88*?'%L*!)$*&*3'*$!(8!%38($9-'%(3H!!A&!%3!'#*!0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@/! *-?#! *,*9*3'! (3! '#*! I*J! +($'-,!1%&),-@!$*9-%3*1!%3!'#*!&-9*!$*,-'%L*!)(&%'%(3H!

:+#&@0!C-0#&1+*$(&-0#!

A&!3('*1!-J(L*/!M#*$*L*$!M*!8-?*1!-!1*&%73!?#(%?*!%3!?$*-'%37! '#*! I*J! +($'-,! -31! 0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@&/! M*!-''*9)'*1! '(! ()'%9%[*! '#*! 1%&),-@! '(! )$(9('*! ?(9)$*K#*3&%(3H! !a($!*S-9),*/!J('#! '#*!I*J!+($'-,!-31!0*S'KJ-&*1!1%&),-@&!$*)$*&*3'!&.J&'-3'%-,!%9)$(L*9*3'&!(L*$!$*-,K,%8*! *S-9),*&H! ! 0#*!I*J! +($'-,! 1*&%73! ?(3'-%3*1!9($*!7$-)#%?&!-31! %9-7*&! '#-3!M#-'! '@)%?-,,@!-))*-$&!(3!'#*&*!I*J!)-7*&H!!+%,('!&.JP*?'&!8(.31!'#*&*!7$-)#K%?&! -31! %9-7*&! '(! J*! J*3*8%?%-,! %3! $*9*9J*$%37! %38($K9-'%(3H! ! !a.$'#*$9($*/! %31%L%1.-,! %'*9&!M*$*!9(1%8%*1!1.$%37! )%,('! '*&'%37! '(! -&&%&'! $*?-,,H! ! a($! *S-9),*/! M*!9-1*! '#*! &%[*! (8! '#*! M*-'#*$! 8($*?-&'! %9-7*! &.J&'-3K'%-,,@! ,-$7*$! '#-3!M#-'! %&! '@)%?-,,@! 8(.31!(3!I*J!)($K'-,&H!!!! n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f*3?*/!M*! $*1.?*1!'#*! &?$**3!-$*-!(??.)%*1!J@! '#(&*!1%&),-@&! '(!)$(9('*!?(9)$*#*3&%(3H!!a(,,(M%37!'#-'!,(7%?/!>38("-3L-&Q!,-$K7*$! &%[*! &#(.,1! #-L*! &*$L*1! '(! 3*7-'%L*,@! %9)-?'! %'&!)*$8($9-3?*/!%8!-3@'#%37H!

>A>! %$*(&'&;$0(#!

a($'@K3%3*!]VV!8*9-,*^! %31%L%1.-,&!M%'#!3($9-,!($!?($K$*?'*1K'(K3($9-,! *@*&%7#'! )-$'%?%)-'*1! %3! '#%&! &'.1@H!!!+-$'%?%)-3'&! $-37*1! 8$(9! V`! '(! bV! @*-$&! (8! -7*! ]9*-3!D\HD^H!!DW!M*$*!7$-1.-'*!&'.1*3'&/!VW!M*$*!.31*$7$-1.K-'*&/! -31! c!M*$*! 3(3K&'.1*3'&H! +-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*! ?(9K)*3&-'*1!oVC!8($!'#*%$!'%9*H!

>AJ! %*-'+1)*+!

0*&'%37! (??.$$*1! %3! %31%L%1.-,! &*&&%(3&! ,-&'%37! -)K)$(S%9-'*,@! \c! 9%3.'*&H! ! +-$'%?%)-3'&! &-'! 'M(! 8**'! %3!8$(3'! (8! '#*! n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a($!*-?#!(8! '#*! '#$**!1%&),-@&/!-3! %3K

Page 6: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

'$(1.?'($@!'(.$/!)$*)-$-'%(3!'-&6/!-31!)$-?'%?*!'-&6!M*$*!7%L*3!)$%($!'(!)*$8($9%37!'#$**!-?'.-,!'$%-,&H!!! 0#*!%3'$(1.?'($@!&*&&%(3!%3?,.1*1!-3!*S),-3-'%(3!(8!'#*! 1%&),-@! -31! '#*! %38($9-'%(3! 8(.31! (3! %'H! ! a($! '#*!>38("-3L-&! -31!I*J!+($'-,! 1%&),-@&/! '#*! J*#-L%($&! (8!'#*!*,*9*3'&!(3!'#*!1%&),-@&!M*$*!-,&(!*S),-%3*1H!!Z.*!'(!'#*!1%&),-@Q&!9($*!?(9),*S!-31!1@3-9%?!3-'.$*/!'#*!%3'$(1.?'($@!'(.$!'((6!,(37*$!'(!)*$8($9!M%'#!'#*!>38(K"-3L-&/! -))$(S%9-'*,@! BHc! 9%3.'*&! %3! 1.$-'%(3/! '#-3!M%'#! '#*!I*J!+($'-,! -31!0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@/! J('#! -)K)$(S%9-'*,@!VHc!9%3.'*&!%3!1.$-'%(3H!!!! >3%'%-,,@/! *&)*?%-,,@! M%'#! >38("-3L-&/! M*! #-1! ?(3K?*$3&! '#-'! '#*!%3'$(1.?'($@! '(.$!9%7#'!3('!J*!&.88%?%*3'!'(!-,,(M!)-$'%?%)-3'&!'(!,*-$3!*-?#!1%&),-@H!!+%,('!'*&'%37/!#(M*L*$/!$*L*-,*1!'#-'!)-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*!-J,*!'(!O.%?6,@!,*-$3!'#*!%38($9-'%(3!9-))%37&H!!0(!8.$'#*$!*3&.$*!'#-'!M*! M(.,1! J*! '*&'%37! %38($9-'%(3! ?(9)$*#*3&%(3! -31!$*?-,,! J.'! 3('!9-))%37! $*?-,,!M%'#! $*&)*?'! '(! '#*! >38(K"-3L-&/!)-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*!-&6*1!'(!)(%3'!(.'!'#*!1%88*$K*3'!(JP*?'&!(3!-!&-9),*!1%&),-@!-31!&-@!-,(.1!M#-'!%3K8($9-'%(3! *-?#! (JP*?'! $*)$*&*3'*1H! !I*! -,&(! )$(L%1*1!)-$'%?%)-3'&! M%'#! -! $*8*$*3?*! &#**'! ,-J*,%37! '#*! 9-)K)%37&!J*'M**3!%38($9-'%(3!-31!(JP*?'&!(3!'#*!>38("-3KL-&H! ! >3! )$-?'%?*/! M*! 8(.31! '#-'! )-$'%?%)-3'&! &*,1(9!,((6*1!-'!'#*!&#**'!-31!&(9*!-?'.-,,@!'.$3*1!%'!(L*$H!! Z.$%37! '#*! )$*)-$-'%(3! '-&6/! )-$'%?%)-3'&! M*$*!&#(M3!-3!*S-9),*!1%&),-@!-31!%3&'$.?'*1!'(!?(9),*'*!-!&-9),*! $*?-,,! O.*&'%(33-%$*! ]*S),-%3*1! %3! 9($*! 1*'-%,!,-'*$! %3! '#%&!&*?'%(3^/!9.?#!-&! '#*@!M(.,1!%3! '#*!-?'.-,!'$%-,&H! ! >3! '#%&! )#-&*/! #(M*L*$/! 3(! '%9*! ,%9%'! M-&! *3K8($?*1!8($!L%*M%37!'#*!1%&),-@H!!0#%&!'-&6!'#*3!-,,(M*1!'#*!)-$'%?%)-3'! '(!J*''*$!8-9%,%-$%[*!#%9!($!#*$&*,8!M%'#!'#*! 1%&),-@/! '#*! O.*&'%(33-%$*! &'@,*/! -31! '(! -&6! -11%K'%(3-,!O.*&'%(3&! $*7-$1%37! '#*!1%&),-@/! -,,!M#%,*! %'!M-&!L%&%J,*H!! g*S'/!%3!'#*!)$-?'%?*!'-&6/!)-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*!*S)(&*1!'(!M#-'! '#*!-?'.-,! '$%-,&!M(.,1!J*! ,%6*H! !A!$*?-,,!O.*&K'%(33-%$*!M-&!),-?*1!'*S'!&%1*!1(M3!%3!8$(3'!(8!'#*!)-$K'%?%)-3'!-31!'#*3!-3!%38($9-'%(3!1%&),-@!M-&!&#(M3!8($!*%7#'!&*?(31&H! !+%,('! '*&'%37!1*'*$9%3*1!'#-'! '#%&!M-&!-!&.%'-J,*! -9(.3'! (8! *S)(&.$*! '%9*! '(! -L(%1! ?*%,%37! ($!8,(($! *88*?'&/! M%'#! $*?-,,! -L*$-7%37! -J(.'! 8%L*! ($! &%S!%'*9&H! ! a.$'#*$9($*/! )-$'%?%)-3'&! 1.$%37! )%,('! '*&'%37!8*,'!'#-'!'#%&!-9(.3'!(8!'%9*!M-&!%31%?-'%L*!(8!'#*!1.$-K'%(3!(8!-!7,-3?*!(8!-!)*$&(3!&**6%37!9.,'%),*! %38($9-K'%(3! .)1-'*&H! ! =)(3! ?(9),*'%(3! (8! '#*! *S)(&.$*/! '#*!?(9).'*$! )$(9)'*1! '#*! %31%L%1.-,! '(! '.$3! (L*$! -31!?(9),*'*! '#*! $*?-,,! &#**'H! !+-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*! %3&'$.?'*1!'(! 3('! 7.*&&!(3! '#*! $*?-,,! O.*&'%(33-%$*s! %8! '#*! )-$'%?%K)-3'!1%1!3('!$*9*9J*$!-3!%'*9!-'!-,,/!#*!($!&#*!,*8'!'#-'!%'*9!J,-36!(3!'#*!O.*&'%(33-%$*H!!!! 0#*!-?'.-,!'$%-,&!8(,,(M*1!'#*!)$-?'%?*!'-&6!-31!?(3K&%&'*1! (8! '#$**! *S)(&.$*! -31! $*?-,,! -?'%L%'%*&! %3L(,L%37!1%88*$*3'!1-'-!&*'&!-31!#*3?*!1-'-!1%&),-@&H!!A7-%3/!&)*K

?%8%?! *9)#-&%&!M-&!9-1*! '(! 1%&?(.$-7*! '#*! )-$'%?%)-3'!8$(9!7.*&&%37!(3!'#*!$*?-,,H!!0#*!&-9*!1-'-!L-,.*&!M*$*!.&*1!8($!*-?#!)(&%'%(3!(8!'#*!3%3*!'('-,!*S)*$%9*3'!'$%-,&!%31*)*31*3'!(8!'#*!1%&),-@!($1*$%37/!*3&.$%37!-!J-,-3?*!-?$(&&!'#*!*S)*$%9*3'H!! =)(3!?(9),*'%(3!(8!'#*!'#$**!1%88*$*3'!1%&),-@!?(3K1%'%(3&/!)-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*!7%L*3!&*L*$-,!?(3?,.1%37!&.$KL*@&!'#-'!?-)'.$*1!&.JP*?'%L*!8**1J-?6!8$(9!'#*!)-$'%?%K)-3'&! $*7-$1%37! )*$?*%L*1! )*$8($9-3?*! -31! 1%&),-@!)$*8*$*3?*&H!

K+'$66!/$#G!

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a($! -,,! O.*&'%(3&! -J(.'! '#*! 0*S'! -31!I*J! +($'-,! 1%&K),-@&/!-31!8($!'#*!9-P($%'@!(8!O.*&'%(3&!-J(.'!'#*!>38(K"-3L-&!1%&),-@/!'#*!O.*&'%(3!&'@,*!M-&!9.,'%),*K?#(%?*/!'@)%?-,,@! %3?,.1%37! 8(.$! *S-?'KL-,.*! -3&M*$&! &)$*-1!$*,-'%L*,@!*L*3,@!-?$(&&! '#*! $-37*!(8!)(&&%J,*!-3&M*$&H!!a($! %3&'-3?*/! '#*!)('*3'%-,!-3&M*$&!8($! '#*! '%9*!(8!1-@!9%7#'! #-L*! J**3! Bj\D-9/! `jBb-9/! cjCe)9/! -31!VCjVV)9H! !0#*!3*M&)-)*$!#*-1,%3*!O.*&'%(3!.&*1! 8(.$!)(&&%J,*! -3&M*$&! ?(3'-%3%37! &(9*! &%9%,-$%'@! ].&.-,,@!.&%37!'#*!&-9*!6*@!M($1&!&.?#!-&!h>$-Oi!($!h+$*&%1*3'!Y.&#i^! '(!*3&.$*! '#*! $*?-,,!(8! '#*!#*-1,%3*!J@!?(3'*S'/!3('!J@!$*?(73%'%(3!(8!-!6*@!M($1H!!0#*!I*J!&%'*!.)1-'*!O.*&'%(3! &%9),@! -&6*1! M#*'#*$! '#*! &%'*! #-1! J**3! .)K1-'*1/!M%'#!@*&!-31!3(!-&!'#*!)(&&%J,*!-3&M*$&H!!a%3-,,@/!'#*!J-&*J-,,!&?($*!O.*&'%(3!-&6*1!M#%?#!'*-9!M-&!?.$K$*3',@!M%33%37! -31! (88*$*1! '#*! ?#(%?*&! (8! '#*! Y$-L*&/!+%$-'*&/!($!'%*1!7-9*H!!0#*!1-'-!L-,.*&!.&*1!'(!7*3*$-'*!1%&),-@&! 8($! '#*! 3%3*! '$%-,&! -,&(! M*$*! ?#(&*3! '(! $-37*!-?$(&&!'#*!)(&&%J,*!&*'!(8!L-,.*&H!

L4?$'(!M$6)+N! ! LC$(+@-*&'$6N!G$-+'"4'+$)'4+-+,4'5='+$)'H56'I5<)4J'

! G$-+'"4'+$)'4+-+,4'5='+$)'H56'I5<)4J'

�''K'LM'E5"<+4'

�''K'0N'E5"<+4'

�''O'N'E5"<+4'

�''O'PQ'E5"<+4'

! �'!RE'5@)>'QS'E5"<+4'

�!!RE'S'T'QS'E5"<+4'

�!!H56<'S'T'QS'E5"<+4'

�!!H56<'5@)>'QS'E5"<+4'

!!

>1?;%*( I/( ( CA&624*( -8( *A&'$( :&4;*( &7.( '&$*?-%1'&4(

%*'&44(J;*#$1-7#=(

Page 7: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

! a($! '()%?&! '#-'! '#*!>38("-3L-&!)$*&*3'*1!?-'*7($%*&!($! $-37*&! (8! L-,.*&! ]*H7H/! '$-88%?! ?(31%'%(3&/! J-&*J-,,!&?($*/!-31!&'(?6!.)1-'*&^/! -3&M*$!?#(%?*&! '(! '#*! $*?-,,!O.*&'%(3&! M*$*! -,&(! )$*&*3'*1! %3! '#*! 8($9! (8! $-37*&H!!a%7.$*!B!&#(M&!-3!*S-9),*!(8!#(M!'#*&*!1%88*$*1!.&%37!&'(?6&! -&! -3! *S-9),*H! ! g('*! #(M! '#*! *S-?'KL-,.*! -3K&M*$&! ,%*! M%'#%3! '#*! %3'*$L-,&! .&*1s! '#*! O.*&'%(3&! -31!-3&M*$&! M*$*! 1*&%73*1! '(! J*! -&! &%9%,-$! -&! )(&&%J,*H!!a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h7.*&&%37! 8-?'($i! -31! %1*3'%8@! M#*'#*$! ?(38%1*3?*!M(.,1!),-@!-!9*-&.$*H!! a(,,(M%37! '#*! 3%3*! ?.9.,-'%L*! '$%-,&! 8($! -,,! '#$**!1%&),-@&/! )-$'%?%)-3'&! ?(9),*'*1! -! n%6*$'! &?-,*! &.$L*@!$-'%37! -,,! '#*! 1%&),-@&! 8($! 8-?%,%'-'%37! '#*! $*?-,,! (8! %3K8($9-'%(3/!J*%37!-3!*88*?'%L*!)$*&*3'*$!(8! %38($9-'%(3/!-31! L%&.-,! -))*-,H! ! >3! -11%'%(3/! )-$'%?%)-3'&! $-36K($1*$*1! *-?#! 1%&),-@! 8($! 8-?%,%'-'%37! $*?-,,! -31! L%&.-,!-))*-,H! ! n-&',@/! )-$'%?%)-3'&! $*&)(31*1! '(! ()*3K*31*1!O.*&'%(3&! $*7-$1%37!M#%?#! 1%&),-@! '#*@!M(.,1! *9),(@!-'! '#*%$!M($6&'-'%(3!($!(3!-!M-,,! %8!-!1*1%?-'*1!1%&),-@!M(.,1!J*!-L-%,-J,*H!

J! K+#)6(#!

0-J,*! V! )$*&*3'&! '#*! 9*-3&! -31! &'-31-$1! 1*L%-'%(3&!-?$(&&! -,,! ?(31%'%(3&! (8! '#*! $-M!3.9J*$! (8! ?($$*?'! $*K&)(3&*&!8($!*-?#!(8! '#*!'#$**!'$%-,&!.31*$!*-?#!1%&),-@H!!A! $*)*-'*1! 9*-&.$*&! Ag_<A! %1*3'%8%*1! -3! (L*$-,,!*88*?'! (8! '#*! 1%&),-@! 8($! -??.$-'*,@! $*?-,,*1! %'*9&/!a]D/eb^!t!DDHDV/!25m!t!DHBV/!)!u!HCCCV/!-31!'#*$*!M-&!

3(! *88*?'! 8($! ($1*$H! ! A11%'%(3-,,@/! )-%$KM%&*! ?(9)-$%K&(3&!J*'M**3!1%&),-@! '@)*&! 8(.31! -3! -1L-3'-7*!(8! '#*!>38("-3L-&! 1%&),-@! (L*$! '#*! I*J! +($'-,/! a]V/\`^! t!V\Hbc/!25m!t!DHbb/!)!u!HCCCc^/!'#*!I*J!+($'-,!(L*$!'#*!0*S'KJ-&*1!1%&),-@/!a]V/\`^!t!`HVW/!25m!t!VHWb/! ! )!u!HCCW^/!-31!'#*!>38("-3L-&!(L*$!'#*!0*S'KJ-&*1!1%&),-@/!a]V/\`^!t!\CHCV/!25m!tDHcV/!)!u!HCCCV^H!! 0(! '-6*! %3'(! -??(.3'! )-$'%?%)-3'&Q! ?(38%1*3?*! (8!'#*%$!-3&M*$&/!-!&*?(31!9*'#(1!'(!*L-,.-'*!)*$8($9-3?*!M-&!1*L*,()*1H! !I*%7#'&!(8!L-,.*!B/!D/!-31!V!M*$*!-&K&%73*1!8($!'#*!#%7#/!9*1%.9/!-31!,(M!?(38%1*3?*!,*L*,&/!$*&)*?'%L*,@!]*H7H!-!?($$*?'!-3&M*$!M%'#!9*1%.9!?(38%K1*3?*!@%*,1*1!vD!)(%3'&/!M#%,*!-3!%3?($$*?'!-3&M*$!-,&(!M%'#! -! 9*1%.9! ?(38%1*3?*! @%*,1*1! pD! )(%3'&^H! r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a]D/eb^! t!VCH\C/!25m!t!DcHBc/!)!u!HCCV/!-31!-7-%3!'#*$*!M-&!3(!*88*?'! (8! ($1*$H! ! a.$'#*$9($*/! )-%$KM%&*! ?(9)-$%&(3&!J*'M**3! '#*! 1%&),-@&! -7-%3! 8(.31! -3! -1L-3'-7*! (8! '#*!>38("-3L-&! 1%&),-@! (L*$! '#*! I*J! +($'-,/! a]V/\`^! t!WHDe/!25m!t!BCHcb/! )!t! HCCec/! -31!(8! '#*! >38("-3L-&!1%&),-@! (L*$! '#*! 0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@/! a]V/\`^! t! DDHDV/!25m!t!DDHeB/!)!u!HCCCVH!!f(M*L*$/!'#*!M*%7#'*1!&?($*&!7-L*! 3(! -1L-3'-7*! (8! '#*! I*J! +($'-,! (L*$! '#*! 0*S'KJ-&*1!1%&),-@/!a]V/\`^!t!DHce/!25m!t!DHcV/!)!t!CHVVH!! a%7.$*!B!)$*&*3'&!-3!%'*9KJ@K%'*9!J$*-61(M3!(8!'#*!)*$?*3'-7*! (8! ?($$*?',@! -3&M*$*1! O.*&'%(3&! 8($! *-?#!1%&),-@H! ! 0#*! >38("-3L-&! #-1! '#*! #%7#*&'! -L*$-7*! (3!

!

4$#+!-7!"07-A!K+'$66! =! >! J! O! P! B+$0!

0*S'KY-&*1! W! V`! V\! VC! C! >AQ!R=AST!

I*J!+($'-,! V! `! V`! VW! c! JAJ!RSAUT!

>38("-3L-&! D! \! VB! DC! VC! JAV!R=AST!

!

477+'(&5+!:$($!%*+#A! =! >! J! O! P! B+$0!

0*S'KY-&*1! b! V`! Vb! W! D! >AQ!R=AST!

I*J!+($'-,! D! B! V\! D\! b! JAQ!RSAUT!

>38("-3L-&! c! e! VB! V`! \! JA=!R=A=T!

!M&#)$6!3;;+$6! =! >! J! O! P! B+$0!

0*S'KY-&*1! DC! Ve! `! D! C! =AW!RSAUT!

I*J!+($'-,! V! D! VD! DD! VD! JAU!RSAUT!

>38("-3L-&! V! V! VC! VW! DC! OA=!RSAUT!

K&"4*(I/((L1M*%$(#'&4*(%*#2-7#*#(8-%(.1#24&+('3&%&'9

$*%1#$1'#5(,1$3(@(N(4-,(%&$17?(&7.(O(N(31?3(%&$17?=!

! =#(!/*&$6! >01!/*&$6! J*1!/*&$6!

0*S'KY-&*1! cHV\!]VHce^! cHVD!]VHBB^! cHCD!]VHcW^

I*J!+($'-,! cHbW!]VHbV^! cHbc!]VHc\^! cHDe!]VH`e^

>38("-3L-&! bHDW!]VH`C^! bHDD!]VHWe^! bHBV!]VHWb^

K&"4*( @/( ( P*&7#( &7.( #$&7.&%.( .*:1&$1-7#( -8( '-%%*'$(

%*#2-7#*#(8-%($3%**($%1&4#(-8(*&'3(.1#24&+=(

! =#(!/*&$6! >01!/*&$6! J*1!/*&$6!

0*S'KY-&*1! VVH\W!]\HeD^! VVHW`!]\H`V^! VCHcW!]cHCD^!

I*J!+($'-,! VDH``!]cHCe^! VDHBc!]cH`\^! VVHDW!]bH\C^!

>38("-3L-&! VBH``!]cHeb^! V\HCD!]cH`e^! VBH`D!]bHbB^!(

K&"4*( B=( ( P*&7#( &7.( #$&7.&%.( .*:1&$1-7#( -8( '-%%*'$(

%*#2-7#*#(8-%(,*1?3$*.(#'-%*#(8-%($3%**($%1&4#(-8(*&'3(

.1#24&+!

Page 8: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

&*L*3! (8! '#*! '*3! %'*9&H! ! 0#*! I*J! +($'-,! &?($*! M-&!#%7#*$!(3!'#*!'%9*!-31!J-&*J-,,!%'*9&/!-31!'#*!0*S'!1%&K),-@!M-&!J*&'!8($!'#*!-%$8-$*!)$%?*H!!! 0-J,*!B!?(3'-%3&!-!J$*-61(M3!(8!)-$'%?%)-3'&Q!n%6*$'!$-'%37&! ?-)'.$*1! 1.$%37! '#*! )(&'K*S)*$%9*3'! &.$L*@&H!!0#*&*! $*&.,'&!9%$$($! '#*!)*$8($9-3?*!1-'-!M%'#! '#*! >3K8("-3L-&!7*3*$-,,@!J*%37! $-'*1!#%7#*$!M%'#! '#*!*S?*)K'%(3! '#-'! )-$'%?%)-3'&! 7*3*$-,,@! $-36*1! '#*!I*J! +($'-,!#%7#*$!-&!J*%37!-!9($*!*88*?'%L*!)$*&*3'*$!(8!1-'-H!!! +-$'%?%)-3'&Q!($1*$!$-36%37&!(8!'#*!'#$**!1%&),-@&!8($!8-?%,%'-'%(3!(8!$*?-,,!-31!)*$&(3-,!)$*8*$*3?*!-$*!&#(M3!%3! 0-J,*! \H! f*$*/! '#*! 0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@! 8-$*1! )(($,@!-,(37!J('#!1%9*3&%(3&H!!2($*!)-$'%?%)-3'&!)$*8*$$*1!'#*!I*J!+($'-,!J.'!$-'*1!'#*!>38("-3L-&!-&!J*&'!8($!$*?-,,H!!

O! :&#')##&-0!

+-$'%?%)-3'&!%3!'#*!&'.1@!$*?-,,*1!%38($9-'%(3!J*&'!.&%37!'#*!>38("-3L-&!1%&),-@!1*&)%'*!#-L%37! '#*!7$*-'*$!?(7K3%'%L*! ,(-1! (8! $*9*9J*$%37! 9-))%37&! -31! $*)$*&*3'-K'%(3&!.&*1!%3!'#*!-$'!)-$-1%79H!!0#%&!?(73%'%L*!,(-1!-,&(!%3?,.1*&! '$-3&,-'%37!)%?'($%-,! >38("-3L-&!(JP*?'&! '(! '#*!L-,.*&!.&*1!%3!'#*!$*?-,,!O.*&'%(3&/!M#%,*!'#*!'M(!('#*$!1%&),-@&!)$*&*3'*1!1-'-!L-,.*&!9($*!?,(&*,@! '(! '#*!8($K9-'! (8! '#*! O.*&'%(3&H! ! m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`XH!!a.$'#*$9($*/!h*?(,(7%?-,i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h9($*! )$(8*&&%(3-,! ,((6%37i! -31! h9($*! ?(99(3! '#-3!

'#*!('#*$!'M(Hi!!_'#*$!)-$'%?%)-3'&!)$-%&*1!'#*!I*J!+($K'-,!8($!%'&!-J%,%'@!'(!1%&),-@!%38($9-'%(3!%3!-!9($*!h,(7%K?-,!-31!)$*?%&*i!9-33*$!-31!)$(L%1%37!h-??.$-'*!%38($K9-'%(3! '#-'! %&! 3('! %38,.*3?*1! J@! 9@! %3'*$)$*'-'%(3Hi!!0#*&*!?(99*3'&!&**9!'(!%9),@!-!?(3&*$L-'%L*!-''%'.1*!-J(.'! -1()'%37! -! 3*M! -31! .3?(3L*3'%(3-,! '*?#3(,(7@!&.?#!-&!-3!-9J%*3'!1%&),-@!! _'#*$! )-$'%?%)-3'&! -))*-$*1! '(! ?-)'.$*! '#*! *&&*3?*!(8! )*$%)#*$-,:-9J%*3'! 1%&),-@&! -31! '#*%$! -J%,%'%*&! '(! J*!&.J',*! ?(99.3%?-'%(3! ?#-33*,&/! 3('! 1%&'$-?'%37! -! .&*$H!!_3*!)-$'%?%)-3'! $*9-$6*1! '#-'/! h>! '#%36! >!?(.,1!?#((&*!'(!%73($*!%'!U>38("-3L-&X!M#%,*!>!M-&!M($6%37H!!>!'#%36!(3?*!>!7('!.&*1!'(!M#-'!-,,!'#*!%?(3&!9*-3'!-31!M#-'!'#*!&?-,*&!M*$*/!>!?(.,1!*-&%,@!,((6!-'!%'!'(!&**!'#*!%38($9-K'%(3!>!M-&! %3'*$*&'*1! %3Hi! !_'#*$&!-,&(!*?#(*1! '#%&!&*3K'%9*3'j!hU>38("-3L-&X!%&!'#*!O.%?6*&'!-31!*-&%*&'!'(!&**!-'! -! 7,-3?*! '#*! %38($9-'%(3!@(.!M-3'i! -31! hU>38("-3KL-&X!%&!%38($9-'%L*!J.'!-,&(!$*,-S%37Hi!!a%3-,,@/!(3*!)-$K'%?%)-3'! &.99-$%[*1! '#*! J*3*8%'&! (8! '#*! >38("-3L-&! -&!J*%37! h-J,*! '(!6**)!M($6%37! -31!3('!7*'! 1%&'$-?'*1!J@!1*'-%,&s!U>38("-3L-&!%&X!8-&'*$!'(!&**!-31!%3'*$)$*'!8$(9!-!1%&'-3?*Hi!! >3! '#*! ?(3'*S'! (8! '#%&! &'.1@/! '#*! >38("-3L-&! M-&!*L-,.-'*1! (3! %'&! -J%,%'%*&! -&! -3! %38($9-'%(3! ).$L*@($H!!0#*!9-))%37&! J*'M**3! %38($9-'%(3! -31! 7$-)#%?-,! *,*K9*3'&!.&*1!%3!'#%&!&'.1@!M*$*!1*&%73*1!J@!'#*!-.'#($&/!-31! -&! &.?#/! 1%1! 3('! -,M-@&! 8**,! %3&'%3?'%L*! '(! )-$'%?%K)-3'&H! ! 5(9*!)-$'%?%)-3'&! %31%?-'*1! '#*@!#-1!1%88%?.,'@!%3!,*-$3%37!'#*!9-))%37&s!(3*!)-$'%?%)-3'!$*9-$6*1!'#-'!h>!&'$.77,*1!M%'#!'#*!L%&.-,!9-))%37&i!-31!-3('#*$!8*,'!'#-'! >38("-3L-&!M-&! h?(.3'*$%3'.%'%L*Hi! !A&!M-&!9*3K'%(3*1! *-$,%*$/! '#%&!M-&! -! ?(3?*$3! %3! '#*! 1*&%73! (8! '#*!

!" #!" $!" %!" &!" '!!"

G)U'2"+)'RE3-+)

G)-+$)>'V5>)F-4+

(>-=="F'W5<3"+"5<4

("?)'5='H-&

2+5FB'RE3-+)4

X)64'!)-3%"<)

X)6'Y?-"%

V5>)F-4+)3'()?E

Z-4)U-%%'2F5>)

A">=->)

()*+

,)-.

/012340546

>1?;%*( I=( ( P*&7( 2*%'*7$&?*( 8-%( '-%%*'$4+( %*'&44*.(

1$*6#(8-%(*&'3(.1#24&+($+2*(

!

Page 9: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

&'.1@RM(.,1! %31%L%1.-,&! *L*3! J*! -J,*! '(! ,*-$3! '#*&*!9-))%37&!%3!&.?#!-!&#($'!)*$%(1!(8!'%9*N!!+%,('!&'.1%*&!-31! '#*!8%3-,!&'.1@!1-'-!J('#! %31%?-'*1! '#-'!1*&)%'*!3('!J*%37!-J,*! '(!1*8%3*! '#*%$!(M3!9-))%37&! 8($! '#*! %38($K9-'%(3/! )-$'%?%)-3'&!M*$*! -J,*! '(! $*?-,,!9($*! %38($9-K'%(3!M#*3!)$*&*3'*1!(3!'#*!>38("-3L-&H!!!! A!?$.?%-,!%9),%?-'%(3!,%*&!%3!'#%&s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a%7.$*!BH!!a%$&'/!3('*!'#-'!(3!'#*!M#(,*/!'#*!>38("-3L-&!@%*,1*1!'#*! ,-$7*&'! )*$?*3'-7*! (8! ?($$*?',@! $*?-,,*1! %'*9&! )*$!?-'*7($@/!M%'#!'#*!*S?*)'%(3!(8!'#*!-%$8-$*/!'%9*!(8!1-@/!-31!J-&*J-,,!&?($*!%'*9&H!!f(M*L*$/!)*$8($9-3?*!(8!'#*!'#$**!1%&),-@&!(3!'#*!J-&*J-,,!&?($*!%'*9!M-&!?(9)-$-KJ,*/!-L*$-7%37!-!$*?-,,!$-'*!(8!b\KWCw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g*L*$'#*,*&&/!M*!&)*?.,-'*!'#-'!'#*!$*&.,'&!M(.,1!*S'*31!'(!('#*$!&%9%,-$!'@)*&!(8!1%&),-@&!-31!)*(),*!(8!1%88*$*3'!1*9(7$-)#%?&H!!!! 0#*!,*&&(3&!,*-$3*1!8$(9!'#%&!&'.1@!?(.,1!J*!-)),%*1!'(! '#*!1*&%73!(8!3*M! %38($9-'%(3! &@&'*9&H! !a($! *S-9K),*/! %3! 1*&%73%37! -! &@&'*9!.&%37! -! 1(?6*1!+ZA!-&! -3!%38($9-'%(3! 1%&),-@/! -! 7$-)#%?-,! $*)$*&*3'-'%(3! (8! %3K8($9-'%(3/!&.?#!-&!.&%37!-!9%3%-'.$*!>38("-3L-&/!9%7#'!?(3L*@! %38($9-'%(3!9($*! *88*?'%L*,@! '#-3! -! '$-1%'%(3-,!'*S'KJ-&*1!9-33*$H!

P! C-0'6)#&-0!$01!X)()*+!,-*G!

>3! '#%&!)-)*$/!M*!)$*&*3'! -! 8($9-,! *L-,.-'%(3!(8! %38($K9-'%(3! $*?-,,! 8$(9! '#$**! 1%88*$*3'! *,*?'$(3%?! %38($9-K'%(3!1%&),-@&/!'#*!>38("-3L-&/!-!I*J!+($'-,K,%6*/!-31!-!0*S'KJ-&*1!1%&),-@H! !I*!)$*&*3'! $*&.,'&! %31%?-'%37! '#-'!)-$'%?%)-3'&! ?(9)$*#*31*1! -31! $*?-,,*1! 9($*! -M-$*K3*&&! %38($9-'%(3!M#*3! %'!M-&! $*)$*&*3'*1! %3! 7$-)#%?-,!9-33*$&s! )-$'%?%)-3'&! $*?-,,*1! 9($*! %38($9-'%(3! 8$(9!'#*! >38("-3L-&!1%&),-@! '#-3! '#*!I*J!+($'-,! -31!0*S'KJ-&*1! 1%&),-@&H! ! n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k*'! -3('#*$! )(&&%J%,%'@! %&! '(! %3'$(K1.?*!-3!*S),%?%'!)$%9-$@! '-&6! '#.&!9-6%37! %38($9-'%(3!?(9)$*#*3&%(3! 9($*! '$.,@! )*$%)#*$-,H! ! a($! %3&'-3?*/!)-$'%?%)-3'&! ?(.,1! )*$8($9! -! )$%9-$@! '-&6! &.?#! -&!1(?.9*3'! *1%'%37! M#%,*! %38($9-'%(3! %&! )$*&*3'*1! 8($!?(9)$*#*3&%(3!-31!$*?-,,!(3!-!1%&),-@!%3!-3('#*$!,(?-K'%(3!-&!1(3*!%3!&*L*$-,!('#*$!&'.1%*&!Ue/VDXH!

! /+?(IE$#+1! ,+E!%-*($6! "07-C$05$#!

Y*&'!T*?-,,!a-?%,%'-'($! D!]\w^! Vb!]BBw^! BV!]bBw^!

I($&'!T*?-,,!a-?%,%'-'($! \V!]`\w^! c!]VCw^! B!]bw^!

2(&'!+$*8*$$*1!! D!]\w^! Bc!]WVw^! VD!]Dcw^!

n*-&'!+$*8*$$*1!! Bc!]WVw^! D!]\w^! VD!]Dcw^!

K&"4*( Q/( ( R&7M17?#( -8( .1#24&+#( 8-%( 8&'141$&$17?( %*'&44(

&7.(2*%#-7&4(2%*8*%*7'*=(

Page 10: $01!,-*1#2john.stasko/papers/gi04... · 2004-09-24 · a">=->) ()*+,)-.!

3'G0-96+1@+8+0(#!

0#%&! $*&*-$?#! #-&! J**3! &.))($'*1! %3! )-$'! J@! -! 7$-3'!8$(9! '#*! g-'%(3-,! 5?%*3?*! a(.31-'%(3/! >>5KCVV`b`c!-31! '#*! 8%$&'! -.'#($Q&! gZ5m;! ;$-1.-'*! a*,,(M&#%)H!!0#*!-.'#($&!M(.,1!,%6*!'(!*S)$*&&!7$-'%'.1*!'(!T%?#-$1!"-'$-9J(3*! -31!2-$@!"[*$M%3&6%! 8($! )$(L%1%37! L-,.K-J,*! %3&%7#'&! %3'(! '#*!1*L*,()9*3'!-31!-3-,@&%&!(8! '#%&!&'.1@H!!!

K+7+*+0'+#!

UVX! !;HZH!AJ(M1/!*$(&4H!0#*!#.9-3!*S)*$%*3?*H! !DCCC(0*%:&#1:*( E-62;$17?H! ! V]V^/! ))H! \`KcW/! ! ! >mmm!"(9K).'*$!5(?%*'@/!DCCDH!UDX!!IH!A$6/!*$(&4H!!T*)$*&*3'-'%(3!9-''*$&j!0#*!*88*?'&!(8!BZ!(JP*?'&!-31!-!&)-'%-,!9*'-)#($!%3!-!7$-)#%?-,!.&*$!%3'*$8-?*H!!>3!+$(?H!(8!Y"5!f">!Qe`/!))H!DCeKDVeH!!UBX!4H4H!"-1%[/!*$(&4H!!Z*&%73%37!-31!1*),(@%37!-3!%38($K9-'%(3!-M-$*3*&&!%3'*$8-?*H!>3!+$(?H!(8!"5"I!xCD/!))H!BV\KBDBH!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCDH!U\X!!AH!Z-#,*@/!*$(&4=!!I-'*$!n-9)!-31!+%3M#**,&j!A9KJ%*3'!)$(P*?'%(3!(8!1%7%'-,!%38($9-'%(3!%3'(!-$?#%'*?'.$-,!&)-?*H!!>3!"f>!Qe`!5.99-$@/!))H!DbeKDWCH!!A"2!+$*&&/!Vee`H!UcX! 4H! a(7-$'@/! *'! -,H! ! A*&'#*'%?! %38($9-'%(3! ?(,,-7*&j!7*3*$-'%37!1*?($-'%L*!1%&),-@&!'#-'!?(3'-%3!%38($9-'%(3H!!>3!+$(?H!(8!=>50!QCVH!!))H!V\VKVcC/!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCVH!UbX! 5H!;$**3J*$7! -31!2H!T(.31%37H! ! 0#*!g('%8%?-'%(3!"(,,-7*j! +(&'%37! %38($9-'%(3! '(! ).J,%?! -31! )*$&(3-,!Z%&),-@&H!!!+$(?H!(8!"f>!QCC/!))H!cVcKcDVH!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCCH!UWX! 4H2H! f*%3*$/! *$( &4H! ! 0#*! >38($9-'%(3! +*$?(,-'($j!A9J%*3'!%38($9-'%(3!1%&),-@!%3!-!1*?($-'%L*!(JP*?'H!!>3!+$(?H!(8!=>50!xee/!))H!V\VKV\`H!!A"2!+$*&&/!VeeeH!U`X! nHmH!f(,9O.%&'! -31!0H! 56(7H! ! >38($9-'%L*! -$'j! >3K8($9-'%(3! L%&.-,%[-'%(3! %3! *L*$@1-@! *3L%$(39*3'&H! ! >3!+$(?H!(8!;$-)#%'*!QCB/!!))H!DDeKDBcH!!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCBH!UeX!+H+H!2-7,%(! -31!"H5H!"-9)J*,,H! !0$-1*(88&! %3!1%&K),-@%37! )*$%)#*$-,! %38($9-'%(3H! ! >3! +$(?H! (8! "f>! QCC/!!))H!!D\V!p!D\`H!!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCCH!UVCX!4H!2-36(88/!*$(&4H!!f*.$%&'%?!*L-,.-'%(3!(8!-9J%*3'!1%&),-@&H! ! >3! +$(?H! (8!"f>! QCB/! ))H! Vbe! p! VWbH! !A"2!+$*&&/!DCCBH!UVVX! !0H!2-''#*M&/!*$(&4=! !A!)*$%)#*$-,!1%&),-@! '((,6%'H!

0*?#3%?-,! T*)($'! 0TYK0TKCBKCV`/! >3'*,! T*&*-$?#/!DCCB!UVDX!ZH5H!2?"$%?6-$1/!*$(&4H!!m&'-J,%&#%37!'$-1*(88&!'#-'!,*L*$-7*! -''*3'%(3! 8($! .'%,%'@j! m9)%$%?-,,@! *L-,.-'%37!%38($9-'%(3!1%&),-@! %3!3('%8%?-'%(3! &@&'*9&H! ! D7$4=( S%74=(-8( T;6&79E-62;$*%( U$;.1*#/! c`]c^/! ))H! c\W! p! c`DH!!A?-1*9%?!+$*&&/!>3?H/!DCCB!UVBX!!ZH5H!2?"$%?6-$1/!*$(&4H!!A!9(1*,!8($!3('%8%?-'%(3!&@&'*9&!*L-,.-'%(3R-&&*&&%37!.&*$!7(-,&!8($!9.,'%'-&6K%37!-?'%L%'@!4(.$3-,!0%',*H! !A"2!0$-3&-?'%(3&!(3!"f>H!!VC]\^/!))H!BVDKBD`H!!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCBH!UV\X! 0H! 2%,,*$! -31! 4H! 5'-&6(H! ! A$'%&'%?-,,@! ?(3L*@%37!%38($9-'%(3!M%'#!>38("-3L-&H!!>3!+$(?H!(8!A<>!QCD/!!))H!\BKcCH!!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCD!UVcX!mH!2@3-''/!*'!-,H!!Z*&%73%37!-.1%(!-.$-H!!>3!+$(?H!(8!5>;"f>!Qe`/!))!cbbKcWBH!!A"2!+$*&&/!Vee`H!UVbX!mH!2@3-''/!*'!-,H! !Z%7%'-,! 8-9%,@!)($'$-%'&j!+$(L%1K%37! )*-?*! (8! 9%31! 8($! *S'*31*1! 8-9%,@! 9*9J*$&H! ! >3!+$(?H!(8!"f>!xCV/!))H!BBBKB\CH!!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCVH!UVWX!!mHTH!+*1*$&*3!-31!0H!5(6(,*$H!!AT_2Aj!-J&'$-?'!$*)$*&*3'-'%(3! (8! )$*&*3?*! &.))($'%37! 9.'.-,! -M-$*K3*&&H!!>3!+$(?!(8!"f>!QeW/!))!cVKc`H!!A"2!+$*&&/!VeeW!UV`X!!gH5H!=9-3-'#!-31!THIH!5?-9*,,H!!A3!*S)*$%9*3K'-,! *L-,.-'%(3! (8! '#*! %9)-?'! (8! 1-'-! 1%&),-@! 8($9-'! (3!$*?-,,! )*$8($9-3?*H! ! >3!E-66=( -8( $3*(!EP/! BV]c^/! ))!cbDKcWCH!!A"2!+$*&&/!Ve``H!UVeX! L-3! Z-3'[%?#/! 2H/! T(JJ%3&/! ZH/! f($L%'[/! mH/! -31!"[*$M%3&6%/!2H! !5?()*j!+$(L%1%37!-M-$*3*&&!(8!9.,'%K),*!3('%8%?-'%(3&!-'!-!7,-3?*H!>3!+$(?H!(8!'#*!A<>!yCDH!))!DbW!p!D`VH!!A"2!+$*&&/!DCCDH!UDCX! "H! I-$*H! ! D78-%6&$1-7( V1#;&41<&$1-7/( 0*%'*2$1-7(8-%(W*#1?7H!!A?-1*9%?!+$*&&/!DCCCH!UDVX!2H!I*%&*$! -31! 4H5H!Y$(M3H!Z*&%73%37!?-,9! '*?#K3(,(7@H!!#'')j::MMMH.J%OH?(9:M*%&*$:?-,9'*?#:?-,9'*?#H#'9!UDDX! "H! I%&3*&6%/! *$( &4=! ! A9J%*3'! 1%&),-@&j! 0.$3%37!-$?#%'*?'.$-,!&)-?*!%3'(!-3!%3'*$8-?*!J*'M**3!)*(),*!-31!1%7%'-,! %38($9-'%(3H! !>3!+$(?H!(8!"(Y.%,1/!Qe`H! !))H!DDKBD/!5)$%37*$!Vee`H!!

!