012 . , - , #+, () * %&' · ˚˜1436 ˛ 2014 ˘ˇ , 3 , 26 , – 611 – ˚˜1436˛ 2014 ˘ˇ ,633...

23
, 26 , 3 , 2014 1436 611 , 26 , 3 , 611 633 , 2014 1436 1 , 2 25 01 1435 ; 27 03 1435 : , 58 2012 2013 , , 30 , 28 ; , , 082 , , , : , , , _________________________________________________________________________ ________ The Effect of using Reciprocal Teaching Strategy in Developing the Natural Intelligence by Students of Geography Department in the College of Basic Education University of Mosul Fadhil Khalil Ibrahim (1) and Rawaa Bahae Karkaje (2) University of Mosul (Received 28/11/2013; accepted 28/01/2014) Abstract: The research aims to identify the effect of using reciprocal teaching strategy in developing of natural intelligence among the students of the third grade / Department of Geography / College of Basic Education, university of Mosul. The research sample included (58) male and female students distributing randomly into two groups, the experimental group numbered (30) male and female students were taught by reciprocal teaching strategy, either the control group were included (28) male and female students were taught by the traditional Method. The researchers prepared a tool to measure the natural intelligence, introduced to a group of experts in the field of Education and Psychology to find the face validity; the reliability of the tool was (0.82). By conducting statistical treatments the results showed that there is statistically significant difference between the two groups in favor of the experimental group. In the light of the results the researchers recommended that the reciprocal teaching strategy should be used in the department of Geography. Further studies dealing with other variables were be recommended Key Words: I interactive learning, multiple I intelligence, Prediction Strategy, Geography Education. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ 1 , , , , 11089 (1) Pro of Education and Teaching Methods, College of Basic Education, University of Mosul. Mosul, Iraq, P.O. Box (11089). : [email protected] e-mail: 2 , , , , (2) Ass. Lec. of Teaching Geography, College of Basic Education, University of Mosul.

Upload: others

Post on 19-Feb-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 611 –

    �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� , 611 − 633 ������ ,�2014��1436���

    ��� ����� ������� ������ ������ � ����� ������ � ��!�� "�� ��#$

    %&' ��(��)*� ��#+, ��,��� ���-� � .�, /012�

    /3�( /�#4 %�5��,�618, :�;:� ��< =���� ����628

    "#��� ��$�% � & '(�� �)25�01�1435;��'(�� ",)- & 27�03�1435���

    2��?: �/ 01,�� /��2�� 34 �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB�� C�9,D�� E� �,�F GH) �9I��JK� � �9�A �9�� �9�8�8L� ��$�� "#��� ,M�?N- �(94 01,��� 58 � P�,��F P�,��F- Q$ E�2H�� 0��R�� & GHS�� T:�U ����� V�=�� 2012−2013 ,� W4X��$ ��S��D �4�9Y��Z 3�4

    W24�?� ,[-L� �9,��\ ]� ���4� 30 � P�,��F P�,��F- G: �^H�=: �9�9:�8_ ��,2�� ,��9`�R��- �D��a M?�a� 28 � P��,��F P��,��F- G�: �^H��=: �S��D�� ����924b� c��)- d�Re�,�� ��4_ f��6 g�9S� @�AB�� C�9,D�� G: �^a�4 34 �4�?� Q$ W?h1�� & ������ ����� ;�9Hi(��- ��jk lm�� n����o��

    ,�p G:- q�H2e� r�,R�� �S��D f��4; =�,2sb� ,09e ]� "$��$ t�,:=� d�8u� 0c82�, ��- r��,5 v��4 c��72�8�- =��,2sb� CY��2�� W�2(9�� W2�S2H�$ r�^w6 xY�2(�� ��%- l-�I r�U ��b� �9Y�me; W W24��?��� �1�m��- ���4�?�� ��9,���2�� ,y�I-- xY��2` 0�1,�� z-6 d��Re�,�� f=-{� ��72�8�

    �9�9:�8; ��,2�� �^i#� �9�9:�8; �R�e & GH) �9I��JK� r�9�h �9�� ,�98�8L� |}I Q4 @��%; ��~�� Q�$ r��8�=�� �9�,S2H��� G94�2� �9?(: @�AB�� C�9,D�� yI- r�9�9:�8� �R�e �s6Ec

    ��A�B2� CD#+��:4�i: G��: , �9�9:�8;,(2�� ,f��2�� r�@�AB�� ,�9I��JK� �9�� c _________________________________________________________________________________

    The Effect of using Reciprocal Teaching Strategy in Developing the Natural Intelligence by

    Students of Geography Department in the College of Basic Education University of Mosul

    Fadhil Khalil Ibrahim(1) and Rawaa Bahae Karkaje(2) University of Mosul

    (Received 28/11/2013; accepted 28/01/2014)

    Abstract: The research aims to identify the effect of using reciprocal teaching strategy in developing of natural intelligence among the students of the third grade / Department of Geography / College of Basic Education, university of Mosul. The research sample included (58)

    male and female students distributing randomly into two groups, the experimental group numbered (30) male and female students were

    taught by reciprocal teaching strategy, either the control group were included (28) male and female students were taught by the traditional Method. The researchers prepared a tool to measure the natural intelligence, introduced to a group of experts in the field of Education and

    Psychology to find the face validity; the reliability of the tool was (0.82). By conducting statistical treatments the results showed that there is

    statistically significant difference between the two groups in favor of the experimental group. In the light of the results the researchers recommended that the reciprocal teaching strategy should be used in the department of Geography. Further studies dealing with other

    variables were be recommended

    Key Words: I interactive learning, multiple I intelligence, Prediction Strategy, Geography Education.

    _________________________________________________________________________________

    �1� �9�� U�286 �$����

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 612 –

    �.�E.:

    ^N d�S�� n��� '����-d- r�u�J: ���� �Se|2$- & 2N Ce�($ ,f�9� A d6 G��e GA����

    &���� Bs6 4�}2� �Y�:� ,f��~2$ �8�9) �� d�A T�9�4 �$L� & ��S��� ,�9�a��� ��U- "��i =�Z�2`� "Y��8-

    v�m��:b� ���R�� T��:�9(S:- f=���D2�� c"hZ��:- ���: r�uJ2�� r�� ��9S9Se ��9�� f����� 24����=�,

    f��L� ����4�i�� & �Z��(: ����i�� ���9?(:- T��:�=) ���9I���� ��=�^��- ,�9`�%���- ��4;- �9?�4 ����:- ��942%�- ,m��9� ���(4 ��5��$ & ��?2��� ��H��$ & @���( ���D:-c

    T9�4 SI M^\� �9�� f���� �1` ,G��2�� Q$ v|��s "��9�i: =-� & ���9�?��� ���9?9��2�� ,Z��$-T2A=� ����i�� �^9I ,|}I Q4 �^$2�� a���� r�9�9:��8�

    ��^,�� 2011��c d; �U n12�� �4� g=�� [; �9 �)���� �9?9��2�� C2�� "�\ Q$ ��D�� �=� ,�p �4- �S:G�

    �I���� f~��% T� T�I� [; uhi2�� v4;- "S��� c|}I Q4 ~�~�: �S��D�� ���=��� f=���S�� 3�4 �9��: ��hi��

    ,�,�� Q�?I d-� =���e b �%�� ,v�m�:� Q�$- d-� v�m:� b %�� G9��: ,v��I �)|���I ��=��� C2�� Z(:

    W g=�� ���D��- "��\ G��2��� ��(h �,n-�~���� 2010�c�

    d; ��%- Q��,2�� W �,�D�� G^4�(:- & 9��86 G^?��: &- f�D9H�� �9�$�� G2 34 fB:�86 ���$�K�

    ��728� �4 Q$ r�9�9:�8b� �9?9��2�� G�(2�� �$ r�@�AB�� f��2�� C2�� 2?2� � G^2,�F �^29?(:- d�h2�

    ��4�I & G�H2A� ��?K /=���� r�=�^��- ����hi�� & d�S�� ,�K� $ 9A2�� 34 �(2�� & ��72�8� ��:

    r�9�9:���8b� ���^i9w�:- ~���~�2� ��)���� ���9?��2�� �,"I�` 2010�c�

    ���:- ����$�K� =m��$ 9��D72��

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 613 –

    S�- ,#6

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 614 –

    ,~99?2�� ª«- =�hIL� �H9Y��� & ,�a��� C^I ��S: �#�I �12� r�$����� =�hIL�- �?^�� C2�� �^(?}�2�

    �a��� $ �� 34 "$�h2�� ���- W =��hIL� �,�9D4 2009�c�

    �D�- Q$ �,�D�� ¤97�: f�Si�� -6 ��DS�� C2�� ��$�) �@��S & "�¬ ��: Q�4 =��hIL� ��?^�� ,��^9I

    �U- �� �=�2�� 3�4 ��9�?4 ¤9�7�2�� Q�$ "�,) g=��- ,C� ��9�?4 ��D2: =��^w; t��S(�� �H�9Y��� �^D=- �^}�, CD�2� �m7�$ Q�4 ���DS�� -6 f��Si��

    �,? 2010�c� B�- �9�9:�8k� CD�: =�S�� ��#�I ��I���

    =�hIL� �H9Y��� & ,¤(�� ,��^?9o(:- G�^I- r��)|��� ,�^(9 |}I Q4 ���D: r�=) ��2��W? & ~9A�� 3�4

    yY�S� �$�p� ,W����- 3��I "9,�8 v��R�� �) v��S� g=�� ��D�� :s6 �$ d�A ���� ���� �($ d6

    /��: ?�Omari & Weshah, 20108c �$6 �9�9:��8; v©�H�2�� ��2I f=��^$ Q?}�2:

    9a�: ���}S�� ����- Q$ v|s x^($ ,@�mS28b� U; d; ��8L� T%�: 1`� r�$����� ,�$�p� G2��- �^2�9�#

    / 9��: r�$���$ ,f�% ��9#- ��8L� Q$ ",) ���,�D�� G^H��i`6 G�4�H��: & ���9�?4 G��2���� ,���9�4�i Qh?�- �=: �,�D�� 34 ��9# ���8L� Q�$ v|�s

    "�� Q�-�(��� �9�-L� �94�i��- =��hIL�- �H�9Y��� [;

    ,��86 ��%k�- �^(4- ,G^�9�Z: 3�4 �9��: ���8L� C2�� n�: [; "$�h: r�$����� ��S:- [; �9�?4 G�^i��

    �,n����� 2012�c�

    ?2�:- �9�9:�8; 9�a�2�� 3�4 ���9) ��,�D��

    ª�}928b� Q4 =��hI6 ��(9�$ -6 G9���i$ & ��a��� �m� G^9�4 �^?^I ,d6- /�p� V��8L� Q�$ B��

    �9�9:�8k� �94�i�� �� G�^I ��$�����,r �B�� ��: �(4 ^$ Q$ �(4 �9�9:�8k� �9���,2�� ,�� �p Q�$

    =-� G^$ & 9a�: E�2 �$ ;-©��S� 0�9e G�^��j d-~A�� 34 G^I E�21��- ,�$(4 ��S� �,�D�� 9a�2

    �$ -©�) G_I /�8 d�A=� E$ �$ �?^I Q$ f����� =�hIL�- ,|�I d�A=�- QF��$ ���m��� ���?J��-

    �,�9D4 2009�c� �$(4- "JZ(� =��S�� & 9�a�: ,¤(��� Q�$

    v|s � t�S` ���m�� ,T9I @��8 & r�1�Dm�� �6 G9����i�� �6 ,r�u��,�2�� d_��I �B��� @����%k� T��^%�� [;

    �9�9:�8k� ���,�� �J2�� 34 B� r���m��� |�$6 f��4_ f@��S�� -6 =��?28b� -6 �F f4�H��� ,d���� 2007� c�

    �$6 �9�9:�8; ,(2�� mS9I �� W�?  n���: �� T ��D�� Q4 T:��)�: �� Qh?� d6 d�h� M �B��

    d��(��� Q$ =��hI6 ��$- Q�h?� d6 T�K��� Q�$ ,���}�) �D2:- B� �9�9:�8k� Q$ ��D�� d6 ª�D� �a-�I

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 615 –

    �(9�$ v�e �$ Qh?� d6 T(?}2� ,��a��� ��:- B�� �-�i�� �� ��U ���R? /�� �H�� ���D�� [;

    TS9S ,@��8 9A2 B� �-�i�� -6 �^}I= �,>���^,�� 2011�c�

    Q��h£- �9�9:���8; ��,(2�� ����D�� Q��$ ���9�?4 ��728� G9o(: ¤(�� �$(4 G��2� ,¦=�- d6 Q�-�(��� �9H��9Y��� ���94�i��- ����8L�- �(?}��2�� & ¤(���� ���:

    "Y�8- f9i$ )�2� �$ =-� T��e E�21�� & "A @~�% Q$ @�~%6 ¤(��� ,d��� 2007�c�

    Qh?�- B9i(: �9�9:�8; ��,2�� y�I- "e���� �9:¨�:

    − ����e��� [-L� :n���� g=���� =-� ,=����� y,D�- r�9�9:�8b� �94�i�� 34 fe�- Q$ r��Si��c

    − ��e��� �9`�R�� :�S� g=�� �%U�?`6 Eek �9:�8b�r�9 �94�i�� & m�� ��$6 �,�D�� Q$ v|s

    uhi2�� r�m ,v�4 a��- r�9�?��� ����hi�� C�2��

    ) �^$728� & "A �9�9:�8; t�Z(��- e�m�� �pc

    − ��e��� �R��R�� :��S� g=�� �X�2 ,r��)�D n�2 34 ��^�� �(?}2�� & r�9�9:��8b� ,��94�i��

    34 �,�D�� G�- & �h$G n��924b� & m��c − ��e��� ������� :���S� ��,�D�� f@���S r���SI

    ¤(�� ,M?m Q$- G�5 ���S� �9¬ ��,�D�� & m��� �A=�Z�� & r�=��� �SI- ��^?�� �%=�� & G�)�Dc

    − ��e��� �H$�� :��S� g=�� G9HS2 ��,�D�� [; r���4�?� ���9`-��: ���`�h$ Q��$ 3−5 q|��F ���SI-

    8|�r�9�9:� �94�i�� ���,2�� (Omari & Weshah, 2010)F

    S� a- �=��� �`�=�%� Gardner8 Q$ ��$�% ��I=�� �9h��$L� ���o` r�@�AB�� f��2�� 3�4 g��86

    d6 "A ��I 2?2� f�e�� -6 ��RA6 Q�$ B�� r�@�AB��� Qh�- r�%= ,�:-�i2$ �}e�� �B� ����o` @�AB��� ������ ,G9���; 2011�c�

    ��)- �`�=�% ¤97Z2 ��,8 r�@��AU & ���� =���#; T���2A ���F6 "��S��� 6Frames of mind8 ����4

    �1983��- ,W ���4L�� 1995−1999� �/��a6 ̄@��AU �($�5 T2��o(� y�F6- T9�4 @�AB�� ,C�9,D�� B�- ��`L� C� :@�AB�� �oi��� C– ,n��J��� @�AB���- °������ –

    ,CSD(�� @�AB��- ��h� – n,��- ,@�AB�� ,CS98��� @�AB����- C?H��K� – C��A��- ,@�AB���� ,±��7Z(9,�� @�AB��- ,²�B�� @�AB��- C�9,D��c

    d; e�# @�AB��� C��9,D�� T��� f=�S�� 3�4

    � 9(m:- @�9NL� f��%��� & ��9,D�� Q�$ r��,`

    =��X6- =��N6- r�`��9e- =�9F- ,%��- �B�� ��(�� Q���$ @�AB����� E���� W4=�~����� ³����$- r����`��9�

    W9%���9K�- @�4- =��5¨� W9I���JK�- C$72H�$- uw�(�� r��h8-�h9��-� W9?(J��, 2011�c�

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 616 –

    ���?5- rb���� f���4 Q��h?� /�Z��2A� @�AB���� C�9,D�� ~��~�:- E�� ��,�D�� Q�$ v|�s G=�R2�8�

    T��9%�:- G^$2���� [; ���$ T����2 ����9,D�� Q��$ �����o$ �(Y�A-r ,9��86- ��9e ,W`��S��- C2�� Gh12: �^9I ,�^($- ´�� & ��9,D�� uH��- 34 ,���)L� 9�D72��-

    r|e�� �9?�4 / [; y9S /��6 �9`�%- "R?2: �^�% & Q��h: r���\� �9�j; �1` �4 ��9,D��� ,"I�` 2010�c�

    Qh?�- ~�~�: �U @�AB�� �}�6 Q$ v|s �8�=� ���� ���K� §=�s f��e ��8�=�� ,-6 ��,)��$ =��9D��

    /��2��- 34 r�:�,(��, A Q�h?� g=�?�� d6 M�i�� =�o`6 ��,�D�� ��9,�� ��D91�� G� ��$- ��^9I Q�$ v��¬

    ,=�6- g�Hek�- ��e�� ����� C��9,D�� ���%��� Gp�e ,=- �B� =��Z�� � G2�� T�?��: "�s�� ��4�)

    g=�� T798� ~�~�:- Gµ�� ,W9?(J�� 2011��c E��- d�Re�,�� d6 �24� r�9�9:�8� ��R�e &

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 617 –

    [; ��8�=�� M��#�: W2�S2H$ W2(9�� CY�2�� =�,2sb���b� r�U l-�I ��%- r��%=� �8�2$ W �9Y�me;

    728� M8=� C2�� �9,���2�� �4�?��� ���9�9:��8; �D�}��� �4�?��� r�%=� 8�2$- >��,2��

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 618 –

    )- MI� �8�=� q�e� 2011� �C2�� M��%6 & d��4� d�=L� �����$�% ���`�2�~�� ,[; ���I��$ ���56

    �9�9:�8; G9��2�� >��,2�� & C4���� C�Y��S�� q|�D� m�� «���� V�8L� & ,d�=L� v�28�- =�,2sb� CY�2�� W2(9�� W2�S2H�$ M��#�: ��8�=�� [; ���%- l-�I r�U ��b� �9Y�me; & C4���� C�Y��S�� �1�m��

    �4�?��� ��9,���2�� C�2�� M�8=� �m�(�� ��9Y��S��

    8_�9�9:� G9��2�� ,>��,2�� r�^w- B� l-�i�� �(4

    q|D�� C�i:�$ "9m12��c ���$6 ���8�=� n�������� 2012� �C��2�� M����%6 &

    ��J� l����� ��SI MI�� [; d��9,: ��56 �9�9:��8; ��,2�� & "9m12�� �9?(:- r�=�^$ uhi2�� �$

    @�=- &���� E� r�,��F m�� ���� ³�L� ��f� G�4 2%b� cv�28�- =�,2sb� CY�2�� W�2(9�� W2�S2H�$ M�#�: �8�=�� [; ��%- l-�I r�U ��b� �9Y�m�e;

    (4 E�2H$ ��b�� 0.05� W 8�2$ r�%=� r��,��F ���4�?��� ���9,���2�� ���4�?���- �D�}���� & g���9S$

    r�=�^$ uhi2�� ��$ @�=- &����� n��,�� & rb����� �5|R�� ��I��$ ,�I���� G9o(: ,�I���� ��K��$ ��I�����,

    �1�m�- r�,��F �4�?��� �9,���2�� c �$6 ��8�=� C�j�i�� �2013� �C�2�� M���%6 &

    ��J� l����� �SI MI� [; �I��$ ��56 C29�9:��8; ��,2�� ��8L�- ���iZ�� �e�2i�� ���%k� &

    "9m �,�F m���

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 619 –

    p >��,2�� u5: ³�j; E�� G�^i��- f@���S�� 3�4 u,A Q$ W?��2��E�2H$ d-�8�2�� c

    ���-- d� �8�=� M�8- �Pan & Wu, 2013 8C��2�� M����%6 & �Wm���� � [;���I��$ u5��: ��72��8�

    �S�� G^i�� ~�~�: & >��,2��

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 620 –

    r�9(S:- v�m:b� �R��- ,��,�� -�h�k� G9���2�� G��2��- 34 9�# E�21�� r�9�¨�-c

    d; )���� ���� ¢�1L ���� v©�H2�� ²¨� :

    "� 728b�� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� u5: & �9?(: @�AB�� C�9,D�� E� �,�F GH) �9I��JK� & �9�A

    �9�� ?�98�8L�c J�5 HI��� K�3�(::

    /��µ 0��1,�� [; /����2�� 3��4 ���56 ��72��8� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & ��9?(: @�AB��� C��9,D��

    E� �,�F � GH�) ��9I��JK�� ��9�A ����9 �9�8�8L� ��$�� "#���c

    Q��$- "��%6 y��9S /��� 0��1,�� G��: ��9��# �9a�i�� ���im�� �9:¨�:

    − » b ��%�: l-���I r�U ����b� �9Y�m��e; ��(4 E�2H��$ ����b�� 0.05 �W�� ��8�2$ l���i�� r�%=���

    @�AB�� C�9,D�� E�� ��,�F ��4�?��� ��9,���2�� C�2�� M8=� y�I- �9�9:��8; ���,2�� �8�2$-

    �l�i� r�%=� @�AB�� C�9,D�� E� �4�?��� �D�}�� C2�� M8=� yI- �S��D�� ����924b� & Q�=�,2sb� ,S��

    n�,��-¼c ��L� HI��� :

    Q?h: �96 01,�� & ²¨�: 1 − T�-�(: �9�9:�8k �R�e �?Y�) 3�4 v���,:

    �9�?4 G��2�� G9��2��- W U�28L� ��D��- C�$�K� � ��jT �~A�$ �9�?�� G��2��c

    2− T���2�-� �����\ �9�9:����8k� & ����9,��

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 621 –

    ,�9�$�K� �#�s- & ¤m  ��9I��JK� 3�4- E�2H�$ �9�A �9�� �9�8�8L� C�2�� ��: W�?��$

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 622 –

    �9�9:�8; �9H�=: ���S: 3�4 t�Z�` C�?9��: v��,2� T9I =�-�6 "�A Q�$ U�2�86 f���$ ���9I��J% ��9,��

    ¢��2��- ��,�F- GH) �9I��JK� -6 W ��F ��F- -6 W ���F �Y�)- ��4�?��� ,-6 W� ����I6 ����4�?�

    G^}� ¾�,��� y�I- "�e��$ �=6 C�� :¤9�7�2�� ,

    9��:- ��8L� ,,(2��- ,9a�2��-c

    2− ������ � ��!��: − �`�i4 =�`X��- �2003�:� »f=��S�� 3��4 /����2�� ~��99?2��- 9(m��2��- r�:�,(�� ,r�`��9�- U; "9?� ���IL� [; @�}) M)- &

    §=�� �oe|$- r��:�,(�� ���-�- 9�# �,r��`��9 �2?28b�- r���#L� C�2�� �^5� ����� ,C��9,D�� ���oe|$- r���)|��� & ����9,D�� ��=�m��:- ¼�,���`�i4

    ,=�`X��- 2003,� 10�c − "I�` �2007�:� »f=S�� 34 G^I r�(Y�h�� �9�9,D�� Q�$ r��:�,`

    ,r���`��9e- Q?}��2�- �}���6 �98�H��� ���\ ������o�� �9�9,D�� E�sL� |R�$ :9hZ�:r| 1H��� v��,K�- c

    �7NL�- d-~9?2�� �B (m�� Q$ @�AB��� Gµ��J: r�(Y�h�� �9� �^2oe|$- 9(m:- @�9NL� ,��9�9,D��

    d�,- ��%��� & ��9,D�� ¼�,"I�` 2007,� 3c� − ?� 2008�:� »�` Q$ ��`6 @�AB�� nB�� v-��(2� ¦�=�; t�`6

    r�@�AB�� ��,H�� E�sL� & �^2)|4 ��(�� �i�27�� & ��9,D�� ,Q$- r8- ¤Y�ms �$ ~9?2� �B ?(���

    Q��$ @�AB���� ���� �2���b� r���94�(�� E���sL� Q��$ ,r��)��7�� �2��b�- ��9,�� ��$�4 ¼�,��? 2008,�

    230�c − /���- d�Re�,�� @�AB�� C�9,D�� T`:

    f=) ��F GH) �9I��JK� 34 G�^i�� ,~�99?2��- �BA- �,��� & |�Fb� uH�i:- �����o�� ��i�27��

    f��%��� & ��9,D�� �$- T�� B� �����o�� Q�$ X��$= r�94�:- r�=�N;- X�J�6- ,��i�2¹ g��S�- ��%=��

    C2�� "m �^9�4 E�� T2��2�8� 3�4 g��9S$ @�AB��� C�9,D�� ��� ���L 01,�� >��c

    C����P� HI���:

    Q?}��2: r�@����%; 0��1,�� :��� ��G9?m��2 ,C,���2�� ?2�- 0�1,�� ,T�2(94- I��h:- C24��?� ,0��1,�� ����4;- f��6 0��1,�� ,T:�$~�2H��$- =���92s�- "Y�8��� �9Y�mek� ,�,8�(�� G5 y9,D: ���2��c %��N�� ������:

    ��?24� d���Re�,�� G9?m��2�� C��,���2�� ?H���� »G9?m: =�,2sb� ,�S�� =��,2sb�- n��,�� �$ ���%-

    �4�?� a�D�¼, U; M�8=� ��4�?��� ��9,���2�� y�I- �9�9:�8; ��,2�� M8=�- �4�?��� �D�}��

    yI- �S��D�� ,����924b� A- �� a�$ & D7�� �1:�

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 623 –

    Q!�2�6 18F %��N�� ������ HI�#�F

    �;1�2� ���4R� S�E�� T)2� /E&2� ���4R� U� ���

    �9,���2�� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� �D�}��

    g�9S$ AB��@� C�9,D�� �S��D�� ����924b�

    g�9S$ @�AB�� C�9,D��

    V�W HI��� K��;::

    Q?}2� ?2� 01,�� 9¬ �,�F GH) �9I��JK� & �9�A �9�� �98�8L� – ��$�% ,"#��� ]��,��- G���4

    �308 ���F �,��F- ����� V�=�� 2012 −2013�c ��:-G ��� ���,�F E�2H���� 0����R�� Q��$ GH��)

    �9I��JK� ��`�h9� �(94 ,01,�� ]���,��- G���4� 100 ���F ,�,��F- �U- d�h� @b�� ��,�D�� �) ����D) P�F�N & �8�=� G�4 ,�9I��JK� |}I Q4 �,8�($ E�2 f������ f=���S�� ,�����2�� �B��A d���A ��e6 WRe���,��

    ��Re�,�� ��U�286 E�2H?�� �R��0� c�- ���,28� �,�D�� W,8���� ]� �4 ���I6 �4�?��� �9,���2��� 30 ���,��F ,�,��F- ���I6- �4�?��� �D�}�� �28 ���,��F ,��,��F-

    G:- G^H�=: Q$ ",) e6 WRe�,��� �Re�,���, =��2s�- d�Re�,�� �S��D�� �9Y��Z��� �,�Z�� �6� d�h2� �4�?���

    ,�9,���2�� �,�Z���- �q ��d��h2 ��4�?��� �D�}��� ,A- a�$ & v-K�� 1c�

    X:�*�6 18F ���; HI��� � Y;1�2� ������� �!,�Z��:F

    �;1�2� "1&2� �� G�� ��; ��#!��

    �9,���2�� 0��R�� 6 30

    �D�}�� 0��R�� q 28

    [(�+� �;1�W HI���:

    ��) d��Re�,�� I��h2 W24��?��� & r�u�J2�� 9:¨�� :,

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 624 –

    2 – T). �� �� :

    "��%L ��A2�� Q��$ I���h: W24���?��� & u��J2$ ,�?��� G: v�m� 34 r�`�9 =46 ���I6 �(9��� �^NL�

    Q�$ v|�s f=2�8� ��#�s M�4X- 3�4 ��,�D��� ��(94 01,���, G5 MK�4 ��728� b�=�,2s CY�2�� �t - test �

    W��2(9�� ,W2�S2H��$ r���^w6- xY���2(�� d6 ���?9S�� ���9Y�2�� ��H1�� �0.107 �C�- ")6 Q$ ��?9S�� ��9Y�2�� ��9�-K�

    �J��,�� �2.004� (4 E�2H$ ��b� �0.05 ��%=- ���e �56�, �B�- C�(�� ��4 ���%- l��I v�� �9Y�m�e; W�

    W24�?��� & uJ2$ ,�?��� A- & v-K�� 3c�

    X:�*�6 38F \]�^ ���4R� �]��� T)2 �� �� F

    ���E�� ��]��� �;1�2� �� �� Q12� _�&`� J��I^R� U��� 2�

    �,1&I2� ���:�*� "1&. ��R���

    ������� 30 268.033 12.562 �!,�Z�� 28 268.392 13.019

    0.107 2.004 u v��

    3 – .T) ������ :

    ��?24� d���Re�,�� & u��J2$ @�AB���� 3��4 =���,2s� r�I�im�� ���22�� nB�� 46 �Q�I�=�, Q(�S��- ��9,��

    �9)����� Q$ ",)� ,À��� 1983� c�g�9S�- �%=� @��AU "��A ����F & ���(9��� C��D46 "��h� ����F �7H��` Q��$

    =�,2sb� $ �)=- ,��%Á� �- d6 G: 91m: r��%;

    �,�D�� M£ �K��$ r�`�9,�� ��72�8� =��,2sb� CY��2�� W2(9�� ,W2�S2H$ r��^w6- xY��2(�� d6 ��?9S�� ��9Y�2��

    ��H1�� MJ�� 0.345 �C�- ")6 Q$ �?9S�� ��9�-K� �2.004 ���(4 E�2H��$ ����b� �0.05 ����%=- �����e �56�, uZ�- �U [; �4 ��%- l-�I & uJ2$ @�AB��

    W W24�?��� A & v-K�� 4c�

    X:�*�6 48F \]�^ ���4R� �]��� T)2 ������F ���E�� ��]���

    �;1�2� �� �� Q12� _�&`� J��I^R� U��� 2� �,1&I2� ���:�*�

    "1&. ��R���

    ������� 30 366 c33 9.980

    �!,�Z�� 28 285 c34 10.295 0.345 2.004 u v��

    4 – R����4 S�E��:

    y,F d�Re�,�� =�,2s� @�AB�� C�9,D�� ,�S�� 3�4 �,�F ,W24��?���- ]�� �8�2$ r��%=� ��4�?���

    �9,���2�� & =�,2s� @�AB�� C�9,D��� 111.70�, 8�2$-

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 625 –

    r�%=� �4�?��� �D�}��� 111.96�, (4- ��72�8� �t- test �W2(9�� W2�S2H$ ��I��� l��i�� W� r��%=�

    �,�F C24��?� W,:,0�1,�� ��4 ���%- l-��I r�U ��b� �9Y�m�e; �(4 E�2H�$ ���b�� 0.05�, U; M�`�A

    ���?9S�� ���9Y�2�� ��H��1�� �0.024�, "��)6 Q��$ ���?9S�� �9�-K� �2.042�, ��%=- ����e �56�, �B��- C�(��

    I���h: C24���?� 0��1,�� & =���,2sb� ,,��S�� ��A & v-K�� 5c�

    X:�*�6 58F \]�^ ���4R� �]��� [(�+� Y;1�W HI��� � �P�� ���4R� S�E�� ����#� � ��!��F

    ���E�� ��]��� �;1�2� �� �� Q12� _�&`� J��I^R� U��� 2�

    �,1&I2� ���:�*� "1&. ��R���

    ������� 30 111.70 41.885 �!,�Z�� 28 111.96 41.360

    0.024 2.042 u v��

    ���M a��2� ���# ��: r�e f����� ��9?���� y�I- r�4��a�$ f���$

    ��9I��J% ��9,�� ¢���2��- �f=��S�� 3�4 ��,�F m��� 0��R�� "mi�� V�=�� ,��R�� M�?�N- r�4��a���

    �9:¨�: − �$S$ ��9¿=�: ,���^i$ G��4 ��9,�� ,���^i$

    ��o(�� C9,�� ,��^i$ dX���2�� C�9,�� , ���^i$ /|�J�� �n�9 ,�)|4 G�4 �9,�� ������ E�sL�, -��I G��4

    �9,�� :G�4 �9,�� �9Y��� ,G�4 �9,�� �H�9�� ,uJ2�� C�9,�� =��2��- C9,�� ,�9��4 r�uJ2�� ,�99,�� 9A�: ���o(��

    C9,�� :r�`�h�� u� ��9Y�9ek� ,r��`�h�� ��9Y�9ek�, �?o`L� �99,�� u ��$�h�� ,@�Z` o(���� C9,�� =�D:- ,

    r���\b� �R�� & G�4 �9,�� ,yF��(�� ��99,�� ����� �9Y���- ,¢��2�� C9,��c

    ���;� Q!b� ��&�����:

    G: ��4; D� �9H��=2�� ��2�h� W24��?��� :�4�?��� �9,���2�� yI- �9�9:�8; ���,2��

    �4�?���- �D�}�� yI- ��S��D�� ����924b�,� M�J�- �4 D� C2�� G: ����4;� 16 ��Ds �9H�=: ��2�h�

    ,W24�?��� )��- W2me & "A �,86c ���;� a��� HI���6 c��E. ������ � ��!��:8

    ��o` ��� ��%- g�9S$ ~���% g��9S� @�AB��� ,C�9,D�� SI ��) d�Re�,�� ��4_ g�9S$ GY|� ���e��� �9�$�K� �U- � |Fb� 43 �4 Q$ r�9�L� C2�� M�-�(: r��9R9e @�AB��� C��9,D�� T�:b��- T�:b�S$-

    �WH��e ,2008;� ,"��I�` 2010;� ,d���8�$ 2006�� ,yI-- �U À�# d�Re�,��� 40 �f�SI ,g�9S?�� M�S6

    � �H "Y� ���28|� C�� :���%= fu�,A ,��%

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 626 –

    �%= ,fu,A �%= ,�D8�2$ ��%= ,���9�) ��%= 9�)�� �%�, �9^2�- g�9S�� y9,D2�� G: @��%; ²¨�:

    � de�N�� U�5�f�� c��E�#�:

    ��J� A2�� Q$ lm�� n���o�� g�9S?�� G: Ta�4 34 �(K Q�$ W�?h1�� Wm�m72�� & �������

    ����� ,�9Hi(��- yI-- r�oe|$ Wh1�� G: "���: ¾� r��Si�� Q$ 09e ��9m�� �9oi��� ��9�b��- &

    ,g�9S�� d-� @�J�; ��6 ,�f�SI �B�- ,�#6 g��9S�� P�)��# P�~��%- y9,D2�� C4|D28b� c

    g dh��!�� �;i!R� c��E�#�:

    ��J� @��%; y9,D2�� C4|D28b� g�9S� @�AB�� ,C�9,D�� =�2s� d��Re�,��� 30 ���,��F ��,��F- Q�$ ��,�F

    �(H���� ���R��R�� GH��) ���9I��JK� T��:�U Q��$ u�� 9������( U;,�9,���2�� ��) d��Re�,�� ^H�i`6 y�9,D2 g��9S�� 3�4

    �(9��� �94|D28b� Ã�=�2 3�2�2013,� G:- Q$ T��|s "9�H: Q$X @�^2`� v-6 ��F Q$ ���%k� 3�4 r���SI g�9S�� ]�-� 40 �,�S9)� Q$X- @��^2`� ��s¸ ���F ���

    �50 ��S9)�- ,� q�He 8�2�� C($~�� %- d6 Q$~�� H��l�J2 v�Ak ���%k� ��� �45 �,��S9)� ���- Q�$X

    8�(� M)- ,f¶�1�� A W,: ª�a- r��SI g��9S�� ���IL �(9��� �94|D28b� Q$ 09e ��9m�� ��b��-c

    jd k�IN� c��E2�:

    ��J� 91m: g�9S�� G: �a-� 5 �r��%=�

    "�,�� �%= fu,A ,�% -�4 �r�%=� "�,�� �%= ,u,A -�3 �r��%=� "��,�� ��%= ,�D�8�2$ -�2 �

    d�2%=� "�,�� �%= ��9�)- ,�1 ��%=� "�,�� �%= ��9�) �%- ,�B Me-��: r�%=� g�9S�� W� �40− 200 ��%=�c

    �d C��� c��E. ������ � ��!��: ��) d�Re�,�� A2�� Q�$ r��,5 g��9S�� ��U-

    ����S��D =����,2sb� f�����4;- =����,2sb�, Test-Retest ��6 ,�|4 2002��, U; y,F d�Re�,�� g�9S�� 34 �(9���

    �94|D28b� & f��� [-L� �=�2 13�2�2013,� �- =-�$ W4�,86 Q$ y9,D: g�9S�� ��46 d�Re�,�� T�S9,D:

    f�$ E�s6 34 �(9��� �^Hi` �=�2 28�2�2013� M- /-�o�� ,�^Hi` �- y9,D: ������$ t��,:=� ,d��8u

    ]� "$��$ r�,R��� 0.82�, ��- r��,5 v��4 �,n���K� 2011��, �B- 4 g�9S�� P�~��% y9,D2��c ��B�� �,���:

    r6 ���2�� ��� 3�3�2013,� U; G�:

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 627 –

    ���4�?� ,0��9e M��$�) r���4�?��� f@����S ���a��� q�2h�� & �)=- "�?��� ��4X��� G^9��4 |72�8�- G9��i�� �98�8L� �^($ ,G5 �D�� Q$ =�S$ "A �4�?�

    �AU =�hIL� �98�8L� C�2�� M��#�: ��^9�; T�24�?� ,����� M��$�) r���4�?��� ��a� ����86 ¤��7�?��

    ��%k�- �^9�4 9I G^(9 ,G�5 ���) =��S$ "�A ��4�?� ª�D ��8L� C2�� �^2�# ,T24�?� G:- �Z)�($ §U`

    Q$ �: ��8L� $ �9S 9$���� �$ f��4��$ M�)��� ,�AU- "A �$ ��� u� ���^i$ & ��a��� ,T19�a�:-

    ¦�N� ,r�4�?��� $ 9�Z�: fU�2�8L� ���Re�,��� �,�D�� 34 ª�F G9��i$ f�% Qh?� =-��12�� ��p�e

    d�h:- r�U ��# �a��� ,G5 M�$�) ª��D v�H��� ²¨� 3��4 r���4�?���: ���$ =���hIL� -6 G9����i�� C��2��

    d��)�2: ���-=- & �a��� ?���S�� ,09e M$�) "�A �4�?� ��2h ��=�hI6 ��,(2�� $ 9A2�� 3�4 G9���i��

    �98�8L� )�2�� �@��) & �a��� >��2�� "�,) ��X�: �)=- "?��� C2�� Q?}2: E�2 �a��� �K� c

    ���$6 �,H��(�� [; ���4�?��� �D�}���� ��SI G��: �^H�=: 34 �1(�� ²¨�:

    M$�) �Re�,�� @�D4_ �$S$ fum) Q4 �a��� �9^2� d���U6 ��,�D�� ,T���e |}�I Q�4 T�D= y�H�

    Gs ª�F- ¾� ��8L� ���AB2�� ,����- M�$�) G9HS2 �a��� [; ,=-� ª«- "A =� �`��2�8b�

    "Y�8��� �9?9��2�� ,�,�8�(�� �$ f=��5; ¾�� ���8L� ^2Z)�($-� $ �,�D�� ,&- ��2s f¶�1�� Me�F ¾�

    ��8L� 34 �,�D�� �I��� E�$ G��92�8� ��a�?�� ,@�D4;- ¾� �DZ`L� f¶�1?�� �9��2��c

    E����%- vh2���8� y���9,D: ������2�� ������ 5�5�2013�c

    l�; \]���� �mG'��.::

    G29��8 ����4 xY���2(�� �^2Z��)�($- y��I- /��� 01,�� T29a�I-c

    /��� 0��1,�� ���2��/� 3��4 ���56 �9�9:���8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB�� C�9,D�� E� �,�F GH) �9I��JK� & �9�A �9�� �9�8�8L�� ���$�% "�#��� c�

    ¤(:- �9a�I 01,�� 34 ²¨�: »b ��%�: l-���I r�U ����b� �9Y�m��e; ��(4 E�2H$� 0.05 �W� �8�2$ l��i�� r�%=�� @�AB��� C�9,D�� E� ��4�?��� ���9,���2� C�2�� M�8=� y�I-

    �9�9:�8; ��,2�� 8�2$- l�i�� r�%=�� @�AB�� C�9,D�� E� �4�?��� �D�}��� C�2�� M�8=�

    yI- �S��D�� ����924b� & Q�=�,2sb� ,S�� n�,��-¼c yS12��- Q$ B� �9a�i�� G: q�H�e �8�2$

    l���i�� ���4�?�?�� ���9,���2�� nB����- ]���� 31.466 �`�-/��1 n=�9�$ =)� 39.996�, & We ]� 8�2$

    l�i�� �4�?�?�� �D�}��� 4.714 �/��1`�- n=�9�$

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 628 –

    =)� 51.169 c��^o�- d6 ¦�(� l�I u,A W CD8�2$ l�i�� & ,W24�?��� ��- >��e� 26.752�, ���J�- �I��$ "�� ¦��(� ���b� �9Y�m�e; & ��U l��i�� G�:

    ��728� =�,2sb� CY�2�� �W�2(9� W2�S2H�$ M�%=�6- xY�2(�� & v-K�� 6c�

    X:�*�668F \]�^ ���4R� �]��� ��R�� e�B�� Y, Y;1�2� ������� �!,�Z��: � ����� ������ � ��!��F

    ���E�� ��]��� �;1�2� �� �� Q1. e�B�� J��I^R� U��� 2�

    �,1&I2� ���:�*� ��R���

    �����n 30 31.466 39.996 �!,�3 28 4.714 51.169

    2.227 2.004 v��

    W,2� Q$ v-K�� 6 �d6 �?9S�� �9Y�2�� ��H�1�� �2.227 �3��46 Q��$ ���?9S�� ���9Y�2�� ���9�-K� ���J��,��- �2.004 ���(4 E�2H��$ ����b�� 0.05 ����%=- �����e �56�, � v� 34 ��%- l-�I r�U ��b� �9Y�me; W

    24�?�C 0�1,�� & ��9?(: @�AB��� C��9,D�� �1�m��- �4�?��� ,�9,���2�� �B- ¾I�: �9�a�i�� ���im���

    ",S:- �9a�i�� ���,��c Qh?�- uHi: ��92` �9a�i�� ���im�� ²¨�:

    1− d; �9�9:�8; ���,2�� �) r��I- ��)���� ���9?��2�� C��2�� M��(h$ Q��$ ���p|s ���,�D�� & ¤m  �9I��JK� Q$ �9?(: G�=�) & v��� q��92�8� G9��i$ ��9,D�� f=�R28�- G^Y�AU C��9,D�� ��1` ��9,�� ,

    - �^9I Q$ r�(Y�A �9:�,` ,��9`��9e- �����w- ��9�9,F G^2��% d�A=� uRA Q$ yY�S� r�U ��m�� ,��9,D��

    d�h�2?�- r�=) 9(m2�� �����o�c

    2 − d; �9�9:�8; ��,2�� ) M1H�I v���� ��D�� dL =-� v���,2�- ��I���� �$ fU�2�86

    f���� Q$ �^% ,$- ���I6 �4�?��� �9`-��2�� Q�$ ��^% ,E�s6 |}I Q4 �6 M1(8 T� �#�i�� f���9S� ��4�¬

    fuJ���#- ,>����2�� ,���#6 =-� |4����I & ����9�?��� ,�9H�=2�� M`�A- �#�I �,�8�($ 2�i� d���U6 ��,�D��

    v�e �$ n�j & ��9,D�� �^i#� d�9�� CS9S� G���� ,�9I��JK� @��8 �9I��JK� �9�9,D�� �6 ,��',�� �9I��JK�-

    ����m2)b� �9I��J%- Ä�(��c �B� T�A Q1�N – 3�4 ��$ -,� – Q$ r�=S�� C2�� �^h�2?� ��9,�6 ��,�D�� v��e

    �o(�� [; �$ T�� ��9,D�� ,y?� 8- ��=� ,d���$;- �hi�� ^9I�c

    3 − ���^o� d6 r�9�9:���8b� ���94�i�� ��=L� ��,2�� ) M�(h$ ��,�F GH�) ��9I��JK� Q�$

    f=�^$ ¤97�: =�hIL� ~�99?2��- W� G9���i�� �H�9Y���

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 629 –

    ���94�i��- ,��A G^2��1($ ���#�i�� v©�H��2�� ��a-- �-�i�� G^2��%- �RA6 �}S9: �I��?�� ��9I��JK�c ��$6

    �9�9:�8; ,(2�� SI �1($G^2 ��i)�$ ��9?9��: & ���� �9L� b6 ��- )�2�� �� T�? �B�� d���(��� -6 ¦�U -6

    B� f�hi�� -6 �: Q$ d��$ rbb�- �S,H$ cd; B�� r�9�9:�8b� d�A �p =-�� a���� & �9?(: r�=�)

    �,�F �4�?��� �9,���2�� ��1` �8 =�� ���9,D�� ��$- T�� Q$ ����wc

    4 − -,� d6 ���S��D� �����924b� C�2�� G�: ��^9I

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 630 –

    �9I��JK� & �9�A �9�� �98�8L� c 3 – �$�); Æ=- �9,�=: @�}4L �9p� �9H�=2��

    & GH) �9I��JK� �9�h �9�� ;�98�8L� �^?o(� ~�A�$ yY��F ��,2�� & C4����

    CY��S�� q|D� m�� «���� V�8L� & d�=L�c ���� ������ ,����� 5� 38�, 40−64c

    ,³�e @86 v|�� c2012�� c�56 ��728� �9�9:�8k� ��9?9��2�� �K.w.l �& ¦|2$� r��,��F ���e��� �D�8�2�� r�@�AB���

    f��2�� & f��$ r�9a�����c ���8= u2H%�$ u ,f=�Z�($ �9�A �9�� ,�98�8L� ��$�K� ,��(2H�� ��Jc

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 631 –

    WHe, @�9 QHe� c2011�� c�56 �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & "9m r��,��F m���

  • "a�I "9�s G9���;, -�4-= @� Q��� C�A�A: �56 ��728� �9�9:�8; ��,2�� & �9?(: @�AB��ccc

    – 632 –

    f��$ G�4 @�9ek�c ���8= u2H�%�$ u� ,f=�Z�($ ��9�A �9��� Q� GR9p��, ��$�% ��Jc

    J��,W9?( v�($ ? 4� c2011�� Fr�%=� r�@�AB��� f���2�� E� �,�F ��$�% WH� Q v|F- ��^2)|4 "9m�12��

    V�=�� Gµ�F ��$�% ,�:$ ,¦�h�� d�=L�c ,C��j�i�� ��4 X���9(A QH��ec �2013�� F���9�4�I C29�9:���8;

    ��,2�� ��8L�- ���iZ��� ��e�2i�� ���%k� & "9m q|F m��

  • �� �������� ���� ���� ,26 ���� ,�3� ������ ,�2014��1436���

    – 633 –

    thesis,University of Virginian.

    Harb , Majid. (2011).The impact of reciprocal learning

    strategy in reading awareness For the students of

    elementary tenth grade in Jordan (in Arabic).

    Journal of Educational Sciences, (5) 38.40-64.

    Jafarigohar, M., S., H. & Soliemni, Z. (2013). The Effects

    of Reciprocal Teaching vs. Think- Aloud on

    Reading Comprehension of Pre-Intermediate

    Students in Iran. International Journal of English

    and Education,2(1) 191-202 Maiman, HindAhmed. (2013). The effect of

    usingReciprocal Teaching on Reading

    Comprehension and their attitudes toward reading

    at a seventh-grade students in Kuwait(in Arabic). Journal of Educational and Psychological Studies

    in Sultan Qaboos University 7 (3), 344-354. Oczkus, L., D. (2003).Reciprocal Teaching at work

    Strategies for improving reading comprehension. New York: International Reading Association.

    Omari, H. A. & weshah, H.A.2010 (Using the Reciprocal

    Teaching Method by Teachers at Jordanian Schools)European Journal of social

    sciences,1(15).34-44.

    Pan, C. & Wu, H. (2013). The cooperation learning effects

    on English reading comprehension and learning

    motivation of EFL freshmen. Teaching and Teacher

    Education,6(5).1327.

    Shabib, Ahmed. (2000). The influence of training on self-

    questions strategy (Independent – Cooperation) on understanding the lecture by university students and

    their appreciation for the degree of their self-

    effectiveness(in Arabic). Journal of Education (Azhar University), 95.89 -110

    Yang,Y. F. (2010),"Developing a reciprocal teaching

    /learning system for college remedial reading instructionJournal of computers and Education,

    10(3).56-67

    * * *