0123 · 2018-06-10 · eucefsa)european food safety authority.cï> scientific opinion addressing...
TRANSCRIPT
!"#$%&'()*+,-./012345'(6789:New Plant Breeding Techniques;<1=>4
?@AB:CDEFGHIJK)!"#LMNOPQ;
)!"#$%&'()*+:*+RS(,TU;1VWXYZ[A\]1^_`a:bcPdefgh1i1jklmno=>;)NBT1pq1rs[EUltu.vwxEUyzQ{1|})2011~9�l_��O������NBT�Q�^���)��ltu.=>t��EUltu.=>
)��1��)�r��
!"#$ !"#$!"%$
&'()*+,-.&'()*+/01234567
89:;<1=>?@ABCDE%$F:GHIJHKLMN
OPQR6OPQR6OSQR6
$%&��,*������1�1VWX��
!"#$%&*+ *+RS(1VWX��
¡¢ltu.!"#$%&G(£:LMO;1VWXYZ1�¤1¥$¦)j§
¨©ªF« ¬®¯« °G±²« ³´¯µ« IJ«
IJ¶·��:¸¹7º»;
��¼½�1º» ¯µº»:¬®¯;��VWX
¯µº»:*+¾*+RS(¾¿À+£;
¯µº»:Áµº»;
ÂÃÄÅ��»��xÆÇ1º»)ÈÉ
*+xÆÇ1º»)ÈÉ$%&ÊG(£l�ËÇÌÍ���*+RS(xÆÇ1º»)ÈÉ
ÎÏФÑÒ,ÆÓÔÕµ½º»
Õµ½º»)Ö×ÈÉ
ØÙÚLMO1ÛÜ)ÄÅ£1ÝÞ*+ßGfgJASfl�.}à
ØÙÚLMO1áâPãOä:ÛÜå;:Ö×ÈÉå;
��VWfæç«
LMO,º»Æ�ècéQc1ÌÍ
êëìí
bcPdef
bcPdef
*+ßGf
bcPdef
Àîf
ècéQcîµf
bcPdef
*+VWm¢f
bcPdefbcPdef
*+VWïðñ
bcPdef�òIJ¶·��,óô
NABATA1A³AAõ
)EU�ò¾2007~ö÷¾NBTløù.pq,ú¤¾2011~¾JRC-IPTSxJRC-
IHCP1ûü�¾ýþÿ:New plant breeding techniques : State-of-the-art
and prospects for commercial development;,|}!
)h1"#�ò¾$%&�r}��ÇÔ.q¨g'(,)�.xx*l¾�rñ+<1,-./)0£,óËÇ-�!)1123ò¾451�g67�89�-.*1�òÓo¾$%�pqù.:;<=.x1>qxÓË�!)'?1�1ø@ìlABËÇ*÷Ô¾ªF½pq1¦,ù.:j§h1*1løù.pqòÆÓÔ;1xxÓË�!)¡¢l=ÆÇò¾JRCö÷¾¡¢ö÷1CSì1DEFG<=/¾?@xH@
<CSù.1xxÓË�!)23,IJø@ìlKLƾMp,Æ�N�¾?@xH@<_��O1NOãè�������Q�^���:2011~9�;lCSÆ�!
AAAAAAJRC (the European Commission’s Joint Research Center)
AAAAAAIPTS (Institute for Prospective Technological Studies)
AAAAAAIHCP (Institute for Health and Consumer Prospection)
PQýþÿl=.RSTUVWXYZU[\SS]^Y_U`SabY^cdSe
:¹;f^YaUg^Y_S\UYdaWSXeSUZSabYhWh_i:jkalA;AAAA:mo¾nÁo�yèQpnÁo�yèQpxÆÇ=>;:qmrs,tu��.;AA¹;fvRwx:yz»rs,{Ü�|¾fvR!"#1¦,{Üù.×};AA~;fvRw�:yz»rsxfvR!"#,{Üƾ�qmÒ%ù.×};AA�;fvRw�:���1qmrs,TUyz»rsxfvR!"#,AAAA{Üƾ���1qmrs<©�'�½l{Ü��.×};:~;�W^_hYdaWShZ^]SU]^\SaZS]U�dZX_SYSe^e:���;:fvRw�gfvRw�x��;:�;�^e_SYSe^ex�YZ\X_SYSe^eAAAA:ü7)!"#�%��7�]!"#1¦,{Üù.;AA¹;�^e_SYSe^e:��áQPgPQ��QP£*t�ÆÓÔ;AA~;�YZ\X_SYSe^e:��áQPgPQ��QP£,$¦}��Çt�ù.;:�;�R�w]S�SY]SYZU�R�U�SZbiWXZ^hY:�]��;:��jkalA;AAAA:qmrs,tu��|¾�R�1��cu2�1¦,tu��.;: ;: ;$%&¡,»Ô�¢£¤$%&¡,»Ô�¢£¤:_\XgZ^Y_UhYU¥�U\hhZeZha¦;:§;:§;�S¨S\eSU[\SS]^Y_�S¨S\eSU[\SS]^Y_:Ã]!"#l�ËÇ©ª¡«¬ü$%&£,§Æ�N�¾AAAA®¯Å°£l�ËǼ½!"#,±á�²5³¡,´µù.×}£;
AAAAA:67,¶·u��.<¾6¸Æ�+7&l¾Ã]!"#,¹�ÓÔ;:º;�_\hw^Yg^WZ\XZ^hYAA¹;X_\hw^Yg^WZ\XZ^hYU»eSYedUeZ\^aZh»:¡¼½$¾�¿À½lÁÂÃXÄÅ,{Ü;AA~;~;X_\hw^YhadWXZ^hYX_\hw^YhadWXZ^hY::X_\hw^YgSaZ^hYX_\hw^YgSaZ^hY;;U:¡¼½$¾lÆÇc_£,{Ü;AA�;gWh\XWU]^�:!"#$%&'()#*+,1¢7;:È$É�$%&¡,´µ;:Ê;ËiYZbSZ^aU¥SYh�^ae
ñp��Ìl¾Í�ìö÷ýþ,Τ÷�ÇÔ�îÏ
)Ð�1j§1ÑyQa�Q�)ÒÓ:GMO=.Ôòevent£;1?Ô
)ÕåÖ�1NBTl=ù.vw23
)��1×ØÙÚ:ÛÜÝQÞQCS;
_��O1NOãè�2011~9�l�����NBT�Q�^���
¢£¤
ߤ[GM
:àáâãäåX£;
æ¤[çèéê+7:non-GM;
7#,ëÔÇ6Ç��ÉìòGM¾non-GMí
GMxnon-GM1¢£¤l�.ìG¯
îïG¯g+7ðêltu../ñÔí
ÓËÇÔ.îLòGM¾non-GMí
òARNAgPOó�ô<õ�
³¡W¡xÆÇò��ö'(xÆÇGMñÔ
Ã]!"#÷Æ
Ã]!"#÷Æ
øùÆ�LòGM¾non-GMí
¢£¤
(a) (b)
pi
se
pest
ovuova
(c) B
TUVW7?XY?Q(3Z[?\]P^_W
`a.bcGde?,BfgNhi1jJ?T
UV1kQlmE7\^_noppNh
FT&'(Bqr9Es<3tuvN>?3Z
SwxnoWcGdbjJ?kQlm1yz{
|G}~9E�b:N>��uKLMNh
Construction of ALSV vector
FT!"#FT&'(Bqr9Es<3tuvNi>W
dMjc1c�BR�L��uv?���w
x[E7�X1,G:�?���1Q(=>
Kjh���W7)*+���y7��uK
:Mh=���?TUV����E��&'
(7��uK:Mh
Þöªîï671úûüu: ý~, 4¹ý~lþ;
�r�É'(òGM¾non-GMí
ÆÇc_,»Ô�!"#{Ü
Ã]!"#÷Æ
X_\hw^YhadWXZ^hY
nÁo�yèQp,»Ô�jkalA
!"DNA
#$
%&'()*+,-(.
/0123
456789:
GM
GM
non-GM;
!"DNA<=678>?@/01236AB8#$/01DNACDE)F.
)GHIJKLMNO.
>?@P/0123CQRSTUCDEVWXCYZC[\]^8_-)`abaDcde]^fg8.VL+0hi&\]^8_-)i&j6e78\k`abaDcde]^fg8.V>?@6lmPnMo5pqrstu6<=v8_-)!"wxyJz\{|v8m}kGMO6~�v8.
/0123�!6�k!"������P�
#$
non-GM;
!"DNA<=678>?@/01236AB8#$/01DNACDE)�.
!"DNA /0123
456789:
GM
GM
GM
%&'()*+,-(.
!"DNAC��\�P_
�6=�UT��m_-
/0123�!k!"���e!"�����e
��P�
/0123�!6k!"�����q��
)GHIJKLMNO.
WX5pYZL+0hi&
!"DNA
#$ ��
������
�
45
����������(C� @¡¢Oq£¤6v8���)¥@67�U¡¦.
§ ¨ © ª § ¨ © ª§ ¨ © ª
!"���q«mP��(q¡¢
§ ¨ © ª
§ ¨ © ª
¬6®¯U°±²45
¥@C³´(µ¶q«·�(q¡¢
Reverse¸¨¹ºº»¼�½678¾�¿�
ÀÁÂÃÁ���¸)F1Ä���C
� @ÅÆ.
ÇÈÉÊÁ���)����C�ÈE.
ËÌ%&'ÍÎ���)ÏÐ�(C� @�¶.
Ñ�E����ÒÊ���)ÓÔP�(dÕ��vÖkÊqmÖÔ×ØBÔÙ8.
^CÚCÛÜÝ\�ÞF���ß6àáÔâm
JRC Scientific and Technical Reports
ãComparative regulatory approaches for
new plant breeding techniques
(Proceedings of September 2011 workshop)ä
)åæSçèC{áéê�JRC (Joint Research Center.CHP.
ëìv8íî�>ïO\èðñòó6ôõSàáÔâU�8Nature Biotechnology, Vol. 30, No. 3, March 2012
Agnostic about agriculture
Existing agbiotech traits continue global march
Confronting the Gordian knot
Agbiotech 2.0
Tiptoeing around transgenics
Deployment of new biotechnologies in plant breeding
öèC÷ø
Vù±úûSP�U�8üòdýþâmjÿC!"#$6·�UkX%@6&ÎCúûd�P�SC'�\(6PÔâU�8))^C*6·�U�k2012�+ßköèC,-.�/\"0TmÚ
61,23Tm.
ÿ4567\É{Tmüò)EXZACTTM4GHIJKLMNCF�.
dýþâm¾�O
8C9C:ÿ��;q<=http://www.aphis.usda.gov/biotechnology/reg_loi.shtml
EUCEFSA)European Food Safety Authority.Cï>
Scientific opinion addressing the safety assessment of plants developed
through cisgenesis and intragenesis. EFSA J., 2012; 10(2):2561
VX%@P?'@STUkintragenesisd�¶TmeCSÌAkcisgenesisd�¶Tme
CeEU&ÎCB"C&ÎCDoEDxdú®£¤kÔþP8&Î�Â
VF�GHDFMGd�I8\kDJxKrc@LÛ�MPÖUe��NOg)VcisgenesisSPQC��CeC�̯RSModI8)T@kintragenesis�PQC
%&'S̯7g6lmPRSMo\Ifg8)VmNTk�UâCüòdI�UeVÈÙWXY\If'k8CZ[�\[�D]Tg8eCdI8)T^@6k��_\dk`�TÖP�az�b²â8)cdCZ[))T^@PeGJfgC?'@qhi¸eGJC\[jRSMoC\[Xcdk.
!"#$%&#'#"()*#%#)%(+,,-$..#%/(&0$(.+'$&1(+..$..2$%&()'(*3+%&.,$4$3)*$,(5.#%/(6#%"(7#%/$-(85"3$+.$(9(+%,()&0$-(!#&$:;#-$"&$,
85"3$+.$.(<#&0(.#2#3+-('5%"&#)%=7!>(?@A(BCDBE(DCFDCGHBIJ9
VX%@P?'@STUkEU&ÎCB"C&ÎCDoEDxdú®£¤kÔþP
8&Î�ÂSTU�8)
le$Pí*
V”Detection”S”Identification”qm�TUnív8)
¸¸VopdqP�eC�;¸¸Vop�dq8\NBT678eCdI8^SqÌsdqP�
¸¸¸eC)baDcSm�\dqP�eC.�;
ùrCstVÉ{]u
V®iVviEstw²fdPÖkXxstdCüòÉ{Vyi\z{6|×d�8)VÔþ6lT�üòÉ{S8Cyi\}{ETU�8)V|~k�èdeëìüòq��ml¾��¶\z���d|}þâU�8�A)V!"w²fdPÖk]"deGHIJKLMNq��mv�#$C�¶�yi\z{6|×d�8)
TALENüòq��U�¶Ôâm
��iN�E�����)�\=�U�8.öèEPA67�Uk���%&'Å
"STUC&Îq�BP�eCSTU3sÔâk��ÔâU�8
�CN�E�����#$S���%&'#$)GloFish.)���STU(6�
�ÔâU�8.C4567�U�þâm��iN�E�����%#$eöèd��ÔâU�8
Cisgenesis
Intragenesis
Grafting
Agro-infiltration
>?@P��/0123
�
�
>?@P/0123
�
�
9:��dC!"���
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�sÔâ8'�
GM
GM
GM
GM
???
???
???
!"���<=Å"Cr�6AB8ÒAPDES8C9:
non-GM
ëìv8(�üòVËÌ%&'qyiTm/01¿DVRNAi678�~���C{|ÍÎ
V`abaDcC6��G,�)��6��G.V`a�³6��GC�����C<=)6��G Á.
RdDM
GHIJKLMN
ODM
Reverse Breeding/0123S��