1'1ei1 eaidei4ce o ihe oi'1ea2 - nber · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1ei1 eaidei4ce o ihe...

47
bLoAiqGq JJf{ Tj1j1 cLqJ JucJfJqiu © 1JOPCG 12 /U O JJG 2011LCG 2IJOL 2GCJOIJ2 °L cx uo o xcccq ito bLLbp w pc dnofGq MJpom cxbjicij bcuJJT22iou © p)\ OI!"1 2 It\I!CPGII WIJJC2 bOGLPJ uq J/\j9iJ y Lapm2J(A yjj L1JJ2 Lc2LAGq OL jJJG 41OU fLLG1f1 O ECOUOW!C 2Lcp ECOJJOWJC2 ObIUTOU2 &LG }JO2 °L 1G rnPOL2 uq uo °L fG Ju2!uJTou2 MJp mpJcp tJJGA 1LG 2nbboI4 JJJJ2 bbL !2 °L I4BEK2 LG2G&LCJJ bLoLw2 JIJ \J1IJ V22G bL!C!U ruq bnPJ!C rnq couJuu ruq o pc ppjrnrou 2CPOOI (ii'i!cpG1IY q vc 142h q I'lPEK (boLp) LOL LG2GftC JApjG/\2J f'JLL? E oUqLqJ &uq /J1JL f1jOM2JU LOL pcJbLnJ JULOUJJJOU 2flG2pO1J2 AIC{OL EHCP2 OLGCUPGL LP°' OUG2 HU FflLG1J KOIJ1OLL Jf\IO2JJC J22T2WUCG MJW UJOLWJL q&w O opu ALC1 C21fl10 BGL JuJouq IU]FJUJJU L1Gq1JJ1U IPG 11}JOL2 LG LfLfl1 O GIJ LOMU TOL on2uqJu LC2CLC 22i2UC O hG1!C!!C BGII LOL buj 1ô IAIV 051 1020 tI22CPII2C{2 AGU11G ViVIIOI1VF DflKEVfl Oh ECOWOTIC ffE2EVCH ftO4UU bbGL p005 JLJ( ' L2JJM2JC? &UJ2 AJ bOLP Oll'' 2 IAI!CPCI1 IAOKLH Oh IkIDIAIDflVF VJ4I4flhIIE2 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2

Upload: others

Post on 27-Feb-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

bLoAiqGq JJf{ Tj1j1 cLqJ JucJfJqiu © 1JOPCG 12 /U O JJG 2011LCG

2IJOL 2GCJOIJ2 °L cx uo o xcccq ito bLLbp w pc dnofGq MJpom cxbjicij bcuJJT22iou© p)\ OI!"1 2 It\I!CPGII WIJJC2 bOGLPJ uq J/\j9iJ y Lapm2J(A yjj L1JJ2 Lc2LAGq

OL jJJG 41OU fLLG1f1 O ECOUOW!C 2LcpECOJJOWJC2 ObIUTOU2 &LG }JO2 °L 1G rnPOL2 uq uo °L fG Ju2!uJTou2 MJp mpJcp tJJGA 1LG2nbboI4 JJJJ2 bbL !2 °L I4BEK2 LG2G&LCJJ bLoLw2 JIJ \J1IJ V22G bL!C!U ruq bnPJ!Crnq couJuu ruq o pc ppjrnrou 2CPOOI (ii'i!cpG1IY q vc 142h q I'lPEK (boLp) LOL LG2GftCJApjG/\2J f'JLL? E oUqLqJ &uq /J1JL f1jOM2JU LOL pcJbLnJ JULOUJJJOU 2flG2pO1J2AIC{OL EHCP2 OLGCUPGL LP°' OUG2 HU FflLG1J KOIJ1OLL Jf\IO2JJCJ22T2WUCG MJW UJOLWJL q&w O opu ALC1 C21fl10 BGL JuJouq IU]FJUJJU L1Gq1JJ1UIPG 11}JOL2 LG LfLfl1 O GIJ LOMU TOL on2uqJu LC2CLC 22i2UC O hG1!C!!C BGII LOL

buj 1ôIAIV 051

1020 tI22CPII2C{2 AGU11GViVIIOI1VF DflKEVfl Oh ECOWOTIC ffE2EVCH

ftO4UU bbGL p005

JLJ( ' L2JJM2JC?

&UJ2 AJ bOLPOll'' 2 IAI!CPCI1

IAOKLH Oh IkIDIAIDflVF VJ4I4flhIIE21'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2

4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2

Page 2: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

lo rihoW noM f1i no 33n3biv3 w*f iiiunnA IBubivibill

.M jbrL3iM .2 131vi10

AawJ3r1wrnW .1. AmM bnis OO .01 13qT gnbhoW 513814

VQ1 !iiqA H D 1U f cT,4 J31 23imono33 3iIduq bni gni3ilq iA niA

TDMITUA

no attioiiqio 3uh1v btnuoib in31q b33qx3 3d1 no nohEm1o1ni w3n Iniq iqiiq airiT

mi iiuminii 1i1 3iiib3mmi muim3lq 3I8nia 3rh ai 3nimx3 3W 'iiunnui rff .aitiunrrn 1iI IEubivibni

n&bx3 ni aviI noaiq b313vo3 3mb aB mio1 au mua 13v31 Il3nimon u tuo auq lurli J3ubrnq 33nuluani

3f103ffl02 lo laii 3mb niugu noioiq al3TIo '1iunnu airiT .muifn3lq mu2-qmul Ithirii nii

IgioivurI3d lo 1umnia3 31dunoaB3l ioI .tivnoI uodu vJfniu)133nu n3vi nivua aid nivi1Iuo

ia3up3d luorliiw aiibi iurli oa b33hq 11nriu m hiUrIIIJ3 Iuubivibni ludi ouiu1& w irrmiuq

mboorria 01 aoiloThoq li3rlI nnuitno3 ni 3uIu1 tthinuadua lo ai3i1oq a3dX bniI bluoda avi1om

3viiJ313I .aiuoiiq1o 3u1uv binuo3aib rn3a1q b3133qx3 3rb flirli bnfi oahi 3W .noiqmuano 1n3m31i131

3mb no m3d anibni1 3a3rIT .3bu33b laul 3mb iwo b3aB313ni aBri 1iunnu 3mb 10 1ao huitini 3mb ol

.ninns1q trl3rn3lil3l ni 33nsi131-1I3 brui iorI3 isubivibrui Io 3!0 3mb nibm31 3iud3b i1oq

£d131o .M amnuI. 113f{oliM .2 uivi!O aimnono3 lo ln3mrluq30 Ioorb2 normrlW

vo1onrb3T lo 3lutilanI i3aubuaauM thnu3vfann3 lo 1ia13vinLJ O-3 moo2 AIW iau3oi Ià 3VilU hsilom3M O 81)$O1Q1 Aq uir1qI3bu1irN

VO-(1O AM 3bhdmuD 51384 bns 513814 bnu ub3.nn3qu.norrndwo13r131imn

ub3.1imnud13ioq

AawudamW .1. AmM '135D-AAIT

3ufI3VA biimIT OFV

O-V1OOI Yl ahoY w314 mo3.3nf13qiqamwmn

Page 3: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

21 313(11 11311w 13v51o1 3v11 2J3wL6 8lqo3q 3v132do uo 1W ;ezni2ud 2uoh v £ 2i 1iunnE 11A...m3di biEq 3d 01 1iunn$

lo bh nifl Ofl 21 513111 bnB viv ivo bnfi 13V0 23(1103 Ii (11-01 :Q1) n3ieuA 3n61 "ii

hodo3 21111 wod )1zs 01 ni,3d 3v611 1nB i1oq 1n3m3liisI n 2l3mood dsd 2A

niob iol mainsd33m nO .nivs ln3fnsIiist 211 nwob niwib lo zoiq 3di 1bnd 111w

3g116113X3 iii 311 iol mu 3ibon3q £ iuo zq lsth l3ubolq 3nwni its 1iunns 3111 3(11 21 21(11

3d1 2331151 213110 11 16(11 21 (3iUnflS 3111 3111 lo ls3qqs (116(11 3tIT .3g16113 muimiq £ iol

33n3n3qx3 iiItiom ni1ooq d 213226 113111 giiiviliuo 10 )IzrI 3111 1211LSJ6 311J2f1i 01 iinutloqqo

.21321u131uq (1ilJflflE 1o quoi 3(11 220136

nd 11shoi2jd 264 231ji b3linU &1i ni 23i11un11s 1il Ifwbivibni iol 1Aism r1T

1th1on j3bom 3b 31i1 b16bnsi2 3111 lo tX3ifl03 3111 fli f1D11oW 213113163251 2uoiv3lq .1161112

3Iqo3q w31 02 16111 ni1xsuq 2131 113th b3u1.s 3v1311 (0QQ1 88Q1) \()l2wErI2lsW bns nsmb3hq

ol nu3d 1ifl3331 2611 13)116111 2111T .231iiiJ11ff6 iol 13)hsm 3iEvflq 3(11 lo 23v132m3111 lisvs

1sioo 1o tulq 3361q31 01 2I2oqo1q nn3bizno3 320th rnoil 11011113116 181ifl13i2diJ2 13611113

01 oob ir1im 2IsIJbtvibrn sw 3110 onia 2inuoo3s gnivs 3n3m31i131 3iBvhq 1111w 11IJ33 ni2S1131uq d 21 au 1113111511131 113111 13V0 ZIfIUO3ol$ 323(11 ff1011 2iuocq 3(11 b1siq2

.2136111103 \iiuflflS IRubivibni

21 13)hsm 1iunns Isubivibril 3111 lo 3s12 b31hniI 3(11 iol nollsrlslqx3 b16bnsra 3111'

1hs1nu1ov odw 320111 zi23u2 n312uA moil 3vod6 noiiiioup 3111 2A .1101133132 3213vb6

i2um 3101313(11 2fIlulm3lq 33fl131U2fl1 ;3613v6 (113(11 13r101 3V11 01 bn3i m 23iiiunnE 3261f3luq

.213261131uq 1o 23i3116i33qX3 3111 13f101 3(11 101 2131U2111 3152113qrno3 01 duon3 r1id 132 3d

Isun3ioq 101 23Inunns 3111 1o 223n3v11361116 3(11 2331Jb31 1101133132 3213vb6 doidw 01 1n31x3 3IfT

.floLi23IJp Isohiqm3 115 21 2inSiiUflfIl3

513W lsrll 23IlilJflflS 3111 1ubivibiii 1o 31J1J$V 3(11 110 sisb W3fl in3231q 3W l3qsq 21111 a!

101 mr11hoIs b3i63ilzhlqo2 3lorn £ qol3v3b 3W .QQ1 ni 13)116m 3isvnq 3111 (U 3IdBlisvs

i3biw s 101 23iiiunns 3111 31niz niu1sv 'd Mow 2uoiv51q ni lsth nd1 11o1113u113v 1iunns

lo 31u13u112 mi31 £ 101 niwo11.s '(d 231flunnE ioviviue-bns-iniot gniulsv d 2313 1o 3gn.rrI

d bits 21uosq 3IJL6V 01 3161 123131111 (1fl3i-fl01 3111i2 13 f112U 'd (16(11 1311161 23161 123131111

21111 1qqs 3W .23LWnn.S mon bisq 31110311! 1o ln3missIl xst 1(3131)31 113133q2 3111 f1fl3bi2fl03

Page 4: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

01 as 11vi as ,3351q13)hsm 3111 ni 3Idslisvs (1in5r1u3 315 isrIl a3131!oq (iiunn5 03 mf1tho1s

no b3i131 noiJsulsv iijrnna lo aibuia zuoiv3lq .OQQ! bns 8Q1 111 b313u10 813W isth 23i3110q

153 fl1fl3V'I3tfl1 3113 ill bgns1f3 8vsd 2103351 nsm bns os 8bs3b £ nsdi iom moil sisb

2313n5133qX3 31i! ni 325813fl 1513n3g £ bns a.1si ia1ini lsnimon iii nibb q'isrla £ nibu13ni

Iciinsizdua £ 21 I3di ein3msvolqmi Ls3io1obor1ism iuo luofIjiw n3Va .ags I3bIo 8th Is

.noiiwlsv iiunns lo noiiaup sii nhiiakv-81 iol 81SuzoiiSl

ahq 3111 isth bnfl w in1 .anoiaubnoo Izi3vsa I ggua anibnfl Is*iiqrn3 mO

1iunns Iii 33n513111b f1T .13biw V15v (1iUfIfIS 8111 3iSib3fflffli (lUJIm3lq 31rn2 £ 101 blsf13

ifs a3insqmo3 xisiuani iuosq ie3woI ni 3111 bns iuosq Iai1id ni rb nwi3d eJiJosq

"bnuois gniqqof1& 1o zifl3n3d 8IiT .1fl3313q 0 01 32o13 21 b3gIsri3 muim8lq 000j rnq

1x3M .b3wani 8th lo xz d this gs d visv oats aiuosq iiunnz ru noial3qaib 8111 .3.1

lo 31115v b3inuoaib ineiq b31qx3 8(13 5111253111 03 Z8Ibsolqqs noiisulsv lo i3hsv £ 11!2U

.iinu wot3d 113w ai 3uIsv b31qx3 aith Isdi bnil w 1isllob miJim3q 1q aIn3msq iiunns

1ns3flini2 £ zs1 ai33qaolq iiIiiorn 35I3v5 1111w 8811331 I53iqi £ isrti z3iIqmI ziclT

.13n53 onsuuani L61313mmo3 £ molt iiunns 1sijbivibni 115 2325r131uq d Ii "12o3 noiJ3SaflEui"

32011w iiunns 3111 £ lo 32&blUq 8th rnJs1qm3ino3 b1o-is- 3S13VE 3113 11sz)fli33q

8 01 08 lo 3U15V 1n3231q £ thiw aiuo(sq 23V13331 bnod 1uas31T £ 21 1f18m123v111 3V1151fl3111$

21203 nhi3A1sm 13v03 leum aisliob muim3iq flinu3m31 3111' .2mU1m31q 1o isilob 13q 211133

a3V•I3a31 3n8nhino3 nsqmoo zuohsv 01 enoiiibbs axs1 3moOni bits bs3rfl8vo 3isioqio3

11si3n3 isilob muim3lq 13q 31115V .no1i33132 3213vb5 lo 1203 8th as 113w as aifloiq bits

1311i11 t153iqI 21 5 1o za31bis31 bns a3255I3fl1 13251131uq iiunns 1o 35 8th as 23n1133b

.118111 01 b3uaai 320th 101 115(11 aloviviue-bnS-ifuO1 bits nmow 01 b8ijaai z3thunns iol

aO8QI hB3 8th iii bnuol 320th thiw 231J15v s(liunns 1113nu3 lo anoansqmo 1110

ainioq 3s1n3313q €1 1(1uo1 ci n32h asri isilob muun3iq 13q 31111w iuosq Isth aI23U2

01 21203 110113s2fl511 3V1133113 8th Isdi 21a3u2 aifIT .lIsd £ bits 3bso3b last 8th nnub

3W 11sniL .bOrI3q airfi ni-wb b3ni1b 3vscf 13*Ism iiunns Isubivibni 8111 111 nuJBqi3Insq

1iunns (111w b3isiooazs sis Isth z3iiilidsiL xsl 3m0311i bitsi33q2 3113 niisioq1o3ni isdi bnil

.aiuosq iiunns lo 3ulsV b31nuoaib 1113a31q b8133qx8 8(11 133115 1Ins3flinia ion 23ob 311103fli

zn3blud xsI 3(13 33aIlo 13l5mix01qqB aJ3Uboiq IiiiflhtB f11fl13V0 e3hrl xsl 3111 3211538(1 2i 21111'

Page 5: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

.Asm ii1im zIi131 isdi ain3mi3vni l3dio no

r1j lo wivivo its bivoiq i2lfl dT .2flot33 fl3V3 oini b3bivib 21 iqsq 2IdT

inaiq b3iqx3 Li adh3b owr nothio .2ioubolq iiurrns Ijwbivibni idl i3*rsm

iunns moil aiuosq to rns5d2 3uIi 3uIsv 03 bzu fl3soiqqs (VUIa) 3u!Sv b31nuozib

thlfl 3rti ,liilw 1woI bits idi 2noiic ni b3dhb s bu aluqni sisb 3)L .ai3ubolq

bits aJslino3 iiunns Isubivibni no thJosq r1i lo VU13 3113 no 2i!ut 23n3231q noi ns u xiz noth .a3i3iIOq arli b 3203 muim3lq rti diiw zift3n3d b3333qx3 3isqmo3

ns nizsf131uq moit 1ili3u b 333qx3 b1odauor1 ni nis r1i 5IoIqx3 ol noii3ntit 1ili3u n3ilqx3

1n31n51 331 rlioornz ol 23i Istla 3villIrI3lIs niwo11o1 10 bsini iiunns lsubivibni

i3dmun s Js3ibni 23bu13no3 it332 nori33 .3m331i1 nsJl33nu its ni3sl niiw noriqmu2no3

Isnoiisn 03 d31s1 21c13 lo nsv3I31 3113 isibai brts 1532,i 3luiul iol anoiiiib to

isi biswoi vom 2m31as2 noizn3q isvhq bits 3ilduq diod 2A .2n133no3 (3i1oq in3m5I 351

iiijnns 1jubivibni 3111 ,ninns1q 1nam31ii5I ni 3si151-ll bits 3oiorb 1subivibni no zi2sfIqm3

.no)sIsqszq in3msL 331 Ijiubivibni it 3101 13is31 £ s1q sm 33*tsrn

I3A1RM tiunflA 93w,hq 9th to w31ri9vO .1

io fl0213 bomani its bits nsqmo snsiuni its nwi3d i3sIino3 StE 23iiiunnA

lu 23vi1 3d 2S gnol as muz Isunns rn 1dinom s viosi b51u2ni 81(3 rbidw ni enoel3q

d3idw is isb 3dT .eJn3msq muimstq lo wofl to in3msq rfluimslq 3m13-3no £ iol 8gf1s113x8

3(13 13f15 2lE rwm 23253 moe ni bits moi1 inst3Thb 3d 1153 fli3d 23uosq 13v81

10 kh di 1enths noiiioiq 13110 03 i iiunns 811310 3viio3ldo 3(11' .(2)335b in3msq .3mil3liI rnn1sm31 2111 luods (inst133nu fl3Vi flivs2 2111 nivi1iuo 3fl03ffl02

232sr1q i3nii2ib owl nhub zn3qqsi i11w 2311i33q2 Sllt$13f13 1351ifl03 (iiUflf1s 3ff!'

3(13 bits 23ls1um1Jo3s Isiiqso bits bisq 21 muim3lq 3(13 11311w Th1 m\t 31(3 (t3msn

101 2rllsq insI3Thb nsm 315 3131iT '.iuo bisq 515 zifl3n3d 3111 noiiw

mu qrnul frluim3lq 31ni2 £ iieoq3b 01 21 d3srnqqs 3110 .Istiqso 'iiunns 3111 qu nib1iud

2noi2ivolq 113(11 nidit3b 21osflno3 iiunns W0ISV lo vo1oq1 £ 23bivolq (VQ!) 5(11310qr

.2bon3q noiislumuo3b bits noiisIumu33s 3111 thod nnub

Page 6: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

A .bon3q no1 £ 13V0 1&iiqs 3is1umuxs 1IEubst oi i l3fIions ;ww2ni 3111 illiw both3m

-1wo1z s b 3lqmsx3 its as b3w3iv 3d a'sw 3moa iii ns nslq noiznq ifl3n3d b3nfl3b

iiunns li1 £ cth11o jsb isi s iv oals ns iiisq iuosq .3rIT .iiirnns fiJS1IJmU33s

oviviua-bns-1nioj £ zi ii Ii ioviviua ic1 ol bits 3m 3111 a'insiiunns 3(11 ivo ain3m\sq rIiiw

ain3msq isth oa nisfl na b l3dmun 31it02 1111w 3mii3IiI 2ifl51iuf1nfi 3111 iVO io iftn3d 3m1 lo i3dmiin nis3i £ izs1 Is ,o1 3IJnuinoo oi binzisu 315 21134 zirl io insliunits 3111 01

1Is3no1eiH .baqs13 2511 aboi-iq lo l3dmun eicfi Io13d 231b insiiunns 3(1111 fi3V3 aboiq ni züinnns 31d5 sv iud ami Isnimon ni bx11 aIn3msq 3ibon3q b31flo aiiiurrns Jaom

as 113u2 taas gnbh3bnu its no arnui3l 3111 01 bAni1 315 aiuosq io\bns 2nozislumu33s doicIw

.2153 1fl3331 fit isluqoq Ifli2S313fli 3r11033Cf 3v511 2)13012

101 ?Jn3nnJ1q muim5rq v)iunnz Iswbivibrti lo 3rniJIov 3111 fli bn3lJ 3(11 woi1 I 31UA

Isubivibiti lo a1sa Isiol isdi awoilail .3bs30b las! 3r11 vo tiaubni 33fl5llJZni 3111 5111113 3111

lo uIsv Issi 3111 311(1W 2QQI itt noillict OOI iisill 2231 (1lf1i12 01 b3lfllJOffI.S ai3ubolq 1iunns

01 3ub 21 iliwoig aidi lo iaom QQ1 bits 8Q1 nwi3d b3lduob hE3n aIsa liunns 1siibivibni

3VD36Ths SIB zl3zilnoo 33fl5Th2111 11s3inf130i 31111w ailiunns 3IdshsV r'w aiazs r1uor1l1A .noilsIumu3os 1aas lo miol b3gslnsvbs-xsl £ 3bivolq 3f11 aus30d I3jIsI

d oels nso di mio1 liunns in nwsibiIJiw 3d ff53 2135i1n03 liunns 3ldshsv in b1r1

laom 32u533H .zluosq mua-qmul lo rnssila £ fftiw 3Iqmsx3 iol 2\(EW dlo iii nwsibdliw

11332 3d 01 21115(1131 Ii 3asrfq fUo(5q 113(11 b31131331 13( Ion 3y5r1 2135111103 liunns 3Idsnsv

3(11' .noilqo luosq noilsiiiunns 3(11 32oo113 111w 2132s1131uq liunns 3ldsrlsv nsm 13111311w

iol brlsm3b gniwo1 £ 3is3ibni 1hsaasn Ion aob 3101313(11 23iliUnflB 3ldsrISv lo ifiwo .23IiiUflflS 1113(11311131 3isVnq

.l3)hltm iiunns Isubivibni 3111 lo 3X12 3(11 110 3v1133q213q 1.snoiiibbs a3bivolq 31ugiI

.QQ1 r1iioii1i RQI moil (aisliob 4Q1 1531 ni) 2ln3mssq muirniq Lsunns Islol ablo33i II

313w zo15z liunns Isubivibni aOQQI-bim 3111 111 isrIl ai wfl aidi moil nibnfl nithqiua 3dT

nI .anslq noian3q Ifl3n3d b3nfl3b moil 1nism 23asd3iuq liunns qiioi 25 3g151 25 1153fl

£ 1r1uoi 313W 513111 JEIII atloq3l (Q1) 3OnBluaflI 311J no li3flUoD ns3rI3rnA 3111 ,

2Q1

b32sd3luq 313W IsdI 23i311oq a3buI3ni 13(Jmun aidi io1 iii e3i3iloq liunn Isubivibni noillim

iol ain3msq b32imolq 13v03 01 23v-1323$1 .anslq noizn3q lfl3n3d b3nit3b rlliw noil3nulnoo iii

Page 7: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

niJo*tfiM snziuznl 11J 11i oi nib1o3 noi11id QV i booi 21fl3n3d 1iunnE 1J$ljbivibni

.(ÔQQI A5LMIJ) 1snoiiin3inI noiJJIi3ozzA d31sz3$1

is13n 213.s-Iino3 1iunns Its ion 13v3wod ioibni noiwzib niosio1 dJ A lo zad31uq aobul3ni emuimsiq 1iunn lo wofl ssigs i11 bnE aiuoaq 3iunn

01 liJIqI3fl 2111 inioq zicfi qol3v3b oT .ai3ubolq 13(110 as 113w as 23J1Unff5 31ib3Wmi

iiunrIB hwbivibni 3111 ru in3msq rnuim3lq lo qi 1fimhq owl 31S 513(11 iid1 inoo5I rrtui iii 915 z1nmsq muim3lq 3Idix3F1 .muimslq 31ni2 bits muimslq 31d1x311 :33s1q13*Ism

nri2ix3 iol ain3m(sq [5w31151 bits aiiiunns basI131uq 1w3n iol 2in3m'sq iifl olni b3bivib

bsrI3l3b muirn3lq 31gn12 oini b3bivib i io1sa rnuifnslq 31fli2 3flT .2135Ijno3 sijUflfl5

.(AIq) a11iunns 3isib3mmi muimslq 3fni2 bits (AU'12) aiiiunns

riliw bsisqmoo QQI iii noillid .ô1Z iol b3inuooos 2in3m(sq rnuimslq 31dix3II

iol b3inuoos i3v3Wod AIq .(Q! A5LMIJ) 21n3msq (1iunnB muim3lq 31n12 lo noilhid

.noi!hid E4 iol b31nuo335 2AU 31111w QI iii zin3msq mulm8lq 10 noilhid 1no

iiunn5 3iE331S 311110 i11woi 1fl3331 3111 15111 2123ggu2 aasd31uq AN lo 3rnuIov 11111112 3uIT

bits nsmb3hq ni 31qmJ3x3 iol b3wib 3!xuq nibnsi-no1 9111 b3vIo2st ion asri 13)hsm

.1111113w 113111 iJiunn 01 aoodo ion ob athubivibiti dw 10 (OQQI) wsilaisW

ruso iiJjnns 9111 £ c!ijo(1i!A .213111)1103 AN no 232u3o1 iqsq irhi lo l9bnLsrnsI 3111'

muimsuq lo aa31b1s31 a3iiiunns tsubivibni ils iol bolli3m noiisIumub i1i as b3au 3d

3W bns 2noLiqo 1uosq 13(110 13110 n3ilo zAI nsr11 131110 2111(103 iiunns qi in3mvjlq

ti! .a3rflurInz 131110 3111 101 ishlob muim3lq 13q z1uosq no noiisnnolni ns lo 315w5 IOn 315

inRni(nobslq 3111 21113231q31 1iunns 3111 3111 18111 worn! 3W AII 3111 101 I2E11nO3

bofIi3m noiis1umub

.13)hsm aiuli lo SIIJIE11 3111 no nothltrriolrn 311102 3bivOlq 213LJd iiunas lo 2\3V1U

211W QI 111 rnuimsrq AI 3S13V11 3111 )QQI) lsnOlisfrI3inI A5IMIJ 01 nib1o3oA

2AN f11h132 ainsqmo3 lo 3V1U2 €QQI IBnoilsm3lnI A5IMIJ b311ailduqnu its bits

-xsi s lo Iisq ion 313w (4V) aAN laoM .n3m ol bloz 313w a3tiiurInS Isubivibni lo

.gisb b3dailduqnu 323111 ifiiw 211 gnibivoiq iol AMMU lo thwoi1u 13115W Insdi 3W

Page 8: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

AIq Io noiiucfhiib s di awoda 3zuiI t.A511 as as rf3u nslq in3m31üi b3iliIJwp

us b lIsil nsrii iom bits 0V bits ô zs rti nowi3d ai 1325d31Uq Isbom 3d1 ;213251131Uq

.08 bits íô 10 ags 3d3 nw1d is iud AIq no ai isth a3tiiunns rnisqi3thsq-non no 1vi2u13X3 i iqsq aidi iii noiinl1s luO

rnlsqi3flSq .nlul3l b3xil s bits Isqi3nnq alnsIBu nsqmo nstuni 3rfi 313(1w alosilfioo

bits aln3msq nlul3l in3inlaviti muminim bits Isqi3nrlq insisu lzsIinoo iii a3iJiunns

nivIov3 a'nsqcno3 33nslueni iIl no bn3q3b Isill abn3bivib (111w a1n3msq 320111 in3m3Iqqua

3gIsI nisinthm 01 boon bonozas! s lb oausoofl .onohoqxo oznoqxo bits 1iLcl'iom 1nomlovni

rIiisqi3r1-Isq niuazi ioiuani as akh ioiiio bits inomlaovnioi 13V03 01 ioaoi 3n3ft1lnO3

.zl3Injno3 ni1sqi3 sq-non niuaai ono nsrli arrzuloi iodid flo 01 olds od bluode aiziJnoo

213511no3 iiunns niu2zi loluani ifloiq-non orti AAIT lb noilqooxo inonimolq out riliW

nrisqi3l1sq anoijuii1ani isozoi iibo-iq-non bits noiiB3lJbo iorgir1 iii iAiow ol 13vi2IJl3x3

.3151 515 23tIHJnfIs

-non rilod ol iasllrto3 it! .wolod aiaIsns orli ni aoiliunns o1dthv oiongi oats oW

lb oo1nritsu ns obivoiq ion ob aoiiiunns oldsnsv aoiliunns niJsqi3iflsq bits nilsqiaifl.sq

astiupol 5101313111 1iunns old.chsv s molt iuosq boioqxo orli niuIsV .rriuloi 10 Isqi3nulq

boxil £ niuIsv isdi sw s ni aolihuooa lb aoqi auonsv no airtulol oiuiul odi gniiasooiol

.lon aoob liunns

- *uOw9mIr1I ithoW 2'9IIoM 911T .

1n3231q boizoqxo 31(1 lb noils1u31s b1sw1obr1iz1iz 5 al aia1sns luo lo oooiqtolrroo oiIT

diiw outsv alit) oisqmoo oW .aoiliunns olsibommi 101 21uosq lb (VU3) oulsv boinuooaib

ooidl no abnoqob oulsv bolnuoaib lnoeoiq bol3oqxo odT .1iunns 3111 lo 1203 muimolq oiii

stulul inuo3aib 01 boau al Isiti ixi odi iiJosq iiunns or!) lb 3111 :aluqni

oil £ noaorlo bsrl zinsliunns AI1 lb sthoiEm oil) r1uodiIs oviua Q1 orti 01 nib1o3oA noliqo bnuloi inomilmani 10 ntsllO3 bonoq lo rrnol omoa boi3oloa ieom noiiqo ruosq liunas

.noilqo oliu lovi\rHJ2-bns-lniol £ bol3olo oF tno bits niulsi O1O 320(13 8 tno :113w as ouT .aogs ioblo biswol abnol hso13 oiui1 iii nwoifa ,zinsliunns lb noiludhiaib os ouT lb aiodrnun tiiilnsiadua obuloni sm O os wolod alrisiiunns nuo lb quoi ulsrna 1ovils1oi

.a)nomoliloa lso1 lo 1n3rnsq boiulouila ni aoiflunns niviooo1 1ubivibni

Page 9: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

V

3vLrsin3wIq3l di iadl iffidsdoiq 3113 1uqmo 03 bu isi 3t13 bni 1uoq .31sb 5w1u1 fl3vi £ 3E 3v11s sd 1112 111w 132&i3lLJq iiunns

3111 lo inuOmE 3113 21 fl013S1U31&) VU1 3113 lo in3noqmo3 bwio11disiiz i2om edT

RE 03 iuosq vjñinom ecu RO e1dt1isvs eia £isb wo1ed ee llzde ew zA .(A) iuoq 3iunnE

e*iq e2Edoluq 1.aiiini emo iol iiunnE 3111-3131112 ejEjbemmi RE 3nIaEdomq 1ubivibni

3W 2313110q 3f13 io1 lud ei3i1oq 3iunns zzots hsv inuoms zijif .iae n3v13 £ ni OOOOOI

.135131103 ¶(liUflhIE 311310 elil 3(13 101 2(11131 Isnimon 111 bxfl 2R1m3i 11 13bi2no3 111w

owl elsm 3w iriulu1 erli oini zboheq j b3viee1 zwofl r1zs I6nhnon 3nuoib oT

.zeisi le1etni Isnimon rrn33-liorfz iuiu1 1o 31ui31r132 ml3i 3113 iuods 2rloiqmuE2s 3vi nells

lo ehe emil eili eismii oi thnod V1U2J331T no 2b13i 10 31ui31r112 miei 3111 3W 3 taiiI 110112 Isnimon 3111 eion3b 01 I ezu 3W 33in 325133111 rrrlei-trorf2 tsnimon siuiu1 b3ioqx3

I bisq isilob eno 10 sboi 3uIsv b3inuoib ifIe2siq edT .eiulul 3113 oini aboheq! 33 (mel zth1th ic1i 03 noilibbs nI .[(i+ 1)* ... *(1i+ 1)]\1 3101513113 21 iu1u1 erli ni aboheq

3113 eIuqln03 3W .eJsi 325131111 ()12fl lo 511113U132 (11131 £ 13bi21103 0215 3W 511J13U1i2

viuassiT s no b13i 3111 bns bnod eiinopoo AA no b13i egsievs edi neewled sxieiellib

15111 3ff1U225 3W nedT .Isuinel3Thb b1ei aiiii eloneb ' lel ;thuisrn 03 2U33 (133 ifliw bnod

()12n lo sIui3u112 rrnei £ l3lrUzno3 w bns z3liriu1sm Its is 1115321103 21 muiuI3lq )1211 21(11

miel owl 3111 13(151 3W . + i lo e3s1 m131-tlod2 3Iuiul Isnirnon 3fli2U 23151 32313ini

.zwo11o1 Istiw RI etsioqioDTM bns "ehuassiT" 23Iul3u-1i2

iuo RI qei2 xelqmoo i2om 3113 23n3251q51 23351 ii1srtom iu1u1 beISqL3LlftE 3fthismliZEl

21 oslw Isubivibni blo-dinom-s as 111111 1i1idsdoiq 3111 eloneb ,J) 131 3W .noi1s1u31s vua noilsion zidi 31s112u11i oT .dinom isdi nhub ib 111w 3 dinom 10 3111nn133d edi is vi1

O1 V ! lo aei*niism bxfl 1111w 10 abnod no 2bleP( lsnimon 3111 eu 3W .eelsl 323131111 (11133110112 bel3eqxe lo 31U131J112 111131 3111 315(111123 01 21S3( O bas

15111 eis-i liodz Isnimon edi as boneq 3luiuI 11353 Ri 31st 110112 1snimon beieqxe erIl 31s1u3163

(11131-31101 in33sLbs owl edi iol elui3IrIla rinel edi 1o ioerii aflOlisi3eqxe 3111 v1ziisz bluow .abuiod

03 b1ei 3(11 beau bns 3lui3Inja (11133 isfl £ bemuazs (O(?Q1) 'çAwS11iEW bas nsmbenI 01 abnod 33siOqlo3 AAfl bns abnod viuaseiT tse-O€ abnod SU2S31T ise-O1 no inuism

1111w (1i1idsIsqmo3 io1 .aluosq (1iuru1s lo eulsv beinuooaib lneaelq bel3eqxe 3(11 belshJols3 .xibneqqs 115 iii aMuaei islimia tIoqel 3W 3nibnfl 113(11

Page 10: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

8

3d 01 thnom idJ iIsmion bns dJnom 21(11 21 sbdhid diô 32odw Iubivkbni ns 13b12no3

31311w 2! thnom 21111 3kb 111w Isubivibni 21(11 iarli iilidsdrnq 311T .3no rlinom isbn3Iso

3n5TIu3 3(11 lo bn3 3111 is 3vil.s 3d 11kw Isubivibni zirll isdi ii1idsdoiq 311T = 08V

i 2rllnom owl ni 3viLS 3d 1hz 11kw Isubivibni zidi isdi iifidsdoiq di bns (iosvP-1) Zi (11110(11

3(11 25 q rnnu13b d 33n3h3qx3 1i1stiom 31u11J1 rnsmmuz 3W .(xsvpI)*(Iosvpl)

1iunns ns z325&nuq 3(1 n3dw 3mii 3(1115 blo zts ) zi oriw 31103ffl02 15111 sii1idsdcnq

:zrlinom j 12531 Is iol 23v!V1u2

!)*...* J)* 1) =

oT .zis 1 I s bnod 23Vi1 3(10 011 15(11 110113fli251 3(11 Z32O11ll 1I31(IW 0 = q 132 3W

01 b33rI w QQ1 ni 32s1131uq Ir1irn b1o-is-? s isdi s1iunrrs ns 10 vuqa 3(11 3luqmo3

3111 213b12n03 wol3d iuol noi1o .zis1 ii1stiom m1i\, z 'Isubivibni zuli 12533101

.212533101 31ff1 (1iLBtIOm 1131J2 lo flO113LJ1J2flO3

d b32srbmq A 1uosq 1r1inom illiw 1iunns 31i1 £ lo vua 3(11 310fi3b 01 dV 3W 3W

Q1zwsd21sW ni Isdi moil 21311ib rbidw 3i51J1SV3 3W (1o12231qX3 3(IT 4 s lo Isubivibni ns

rin3l s ioI rnswoHs iuo ni 1hsmiiq (OQQI 88Q1) p1zwsdzisW bits nsmb3i1I bns (88Q1)

:zi 231sI 12313111! 10 31u131nIz

OOo'7 l=\— (1÷ I)'1i

3(11 i3bnu 211u23i 1 1ioqi 3W xibn3qqs ns ni z32s(1sns 1311153 1111w noahsqmo3 ioI 123131111 Lsnimon luods znoiiqmuzzs 331111 13b(w bus 1sfl 21 31u13tr112 (11131 3(11 isrIl noiiqmuzzs

-1131 3111 2L6up3 boh3q (1353 ioI 3151 123131(11 rTrI3l-tIOdz rb ibidw ni zzso i3bi21103 3W .23151

bnod 31s-ioqioo AAfl 3111 bns b13i bnod viuzs3iT 1E3(-(11ith 3111 b13i bnod iu2s31T i53 .b13i

(1iunns Xsl-13ft6 r1uoth 113V3 noia23iqx3 noilsulsv zidi ui b3buI3ni ion 315 23x5T

iqqu 3111 luods znoiiqmuzzs 01 3v1112n32n1 (13viis131 315 wol3d b3tiOq3l 2fl01151u3153 3dT lo z31smiiz3 111 ai1uzi au 1 1 lo bs31zni 2153( 001 1 3u1sv s nimuzzA .flBqz3IiI no limil

.wol3d b3tIoq3l 320(11 lo 0. niiliiw 3u15V b3111U0321b In3z31q b3133qX3 3111

Page 11: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

Q

dT .21z&b1uq iiunnE Isubivibni 10 iiinufloqqo noiiqmuano3 3111 nirrn3i3b zin3mq

51S 1131(1W zliri lo i bitsbq s d b3rri3vo zi 231 iwnnE lo infn13ii XIII 13b31

no2viauD bnII ruuuntbhT bns (OQQI) fl1O niinuoA 1sn3D ..U 3111 d b3dh3b 3111 2311133q2 331V18 3LJfl3V351 Ism3inI 3111 i3S1Jr1OO iiuflnE (11E 1o1 .213(110 fl0ffl6 QQI)

1&isl 3W .zifl3n3d 3vi3351 01 133qx3 ns inIiunns 3(11 fbilIw ivo 21S lo dmun b31qx3

Isubivibril C8QI 3111 niau $H 3111 d b3nim113b 21 ii; T bori3q iuosq b3iqx3 21111

n3fIw 3mri 3(11 Is gs 2'1nJiunns lIIubivibni 3111 bits 3IdsT 1iIstioM (x32inU) insliunnA

(A) oiiEI noizubni its 3is1u31 ol woil 23dh3231q wsl xsi di 'T ni2U .rn3d thJosq

3(11 ni b3bul3ni 3d taum isdI bort3q (1353 (Ii a1n3m'sq iiunn 10 315(12 3± 23fliffl1313b 113111w

(1353 1o noli3slI 3(11 3lUZS3ffl 01 b3niz3b 21 oilsi noi2ukni 31ff .moni 3ldsxsi 2e1n31q1331

iiunns 3111 lo 3u15v nLis1umu33s 3(11 no 3rno3ni Isiiqso 3111 zfl31 15111 iuosq \(liUflhIE

10 213 'T 121fl 3111 nnub rrnJim31q OOOOO1 £ 1111w (3i1oq \(iiunfl& (IS iol .ffluim3lq

:'d b3nfl3b 21 oiisi 21111 1uosq 000001

— =

.3(1103(11 31d5X51 ni b3bul3ni 315 (3i10q (1i1JflflS 3(11 moil 21uosq 1L is 'T l3flA

10 3151 xsi 3mo3ni IsnigIsin 31512 bns 1g13b31 b3nidmo3 £ 23351 IfISiiuIUIS 3111 IEuIi nimu22A

:21 ('V) 3UISV 'iitiflfl5 ioI n012251qx3 b3i2UlbII-X51 3111

— 1)

+ *k*(*J,

— 1)

= N (*(7—1)+1)fl 1+'.t*1- (*(—1)÷1)1fl '

3111 gfli3SI 3151 125131111 X51-13ft5 3(11 21 3151 123131rn 8151 qoqqs 3111 noiJS1u31S3 xIIi-18115 3111 uI

1UC) ni ,

tdV bus dV 2noiishJo1so xsi-i81th bns xsi-31o13d 3111 iliod tioqsi 3W .lnsiiunns

3s is 2IJIubivibrn 01 b31311o 315 isili 2313110q iiunfis 13bi21103 oafs 3W .wol3d aia'1sns

.23E 323111 01 1ias3 2311s13fl3 3VOdS b3di1a3b )how3msll 11110W 2'(3fl01fl 3(11 ;V bull à oaIs a' Ii 2iuo(llq iiunns 1o 3u1sV b3inuoozib in8zsIq b3138qX3 3111 110 2u301 3W 311(1W

tsrn3lni 3111 niiuqmo3 d 23V11Effl3iIS in3mia3vni 13±0 (111W a3IiiUflflS 51EfflO3 01 3IdiaeOq

10 1203 sill Isups 111w 2iuosq (1iunns 1o 3u15v b3inuo32ib 1n3231q 3(11 &.thlw 15 IflUi3l lo 3151

ainuoms auth 13bi21103 3W IsfIl aAN 000001Z bsibisbns1a 3111 ioI .3i10q 3111 gnizsrloiuq

Page 12: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

0!

:zflzii iE(!i aso xi-fis r1i 101 TA\ bn as xsi-on 311i io1 u1Ev th nibnfl 01

_____ = oooooi

birn

— I) —

1) —

1+

iniq rEi nBr!i i3lql3ini ol d m mu131 lo 2iin Ifn13ini i11 aoqiuq moz 1Oi

.2iuosq iiunni lo 3uIiv binuozib

tuoi'I bnE itI y)iUHflA no idsU £ -i t-so* £ niasrbwq niis1qrn3inoo i Iubivibni n i&ii muzas 3W

.nsqmoo 33nSlu2ni li1 Iio13mmnoo molt

ion ob bni biniEu bnj$ b3xfl i in3mEq 3fl3n3d ii iidi nsm "gfliifxji3thBq-flOW'

ii1EtIom iliiw 33f13I3X3 b3isqbiimnu ln3up3zdu2 2"(fuiqmo3 onjiuni ufi b1151

£ sq 1oivni 3111 isfIl nsm "3isib3mmi 1nuim31q-31ni" .n3qx3 to mui31 in3mivni

dinom 1x311 3111 ni±iw ainrnsq 1iunns nivii anigd noili bits mU!m5Iq 3mi-3no

ili iscli ensm "1sijbivibnl" .n32oib 3n3up311 in3m(sq 3111 no nibn3q3b io 13nsup

oid io 1n3s its sly ll1rI3n3 (nsqmo3 33flSllJZflt ns molt 1i331ib b3asd3wq ai iiunns

-13o1qm3 its d b3nwo iiunns quo £ IIuo1di b3ntsido ion ai bits 1o3a3ini b3msn 3111 iol

.ns1q noianq beioanoqa

01 b32imolq 315 zin3rnsq isdi ansm iiunns "31i1" .s ai iiuriru rts isdi se oT

2.U 3buIoni "a3ifll3qmo3 3znlnuani 3111 1rnn3mmoT 8.Omul3IiI 2loiZ3vfll 3111 iol 3Ufl111103

tud foils 12as13 cfin5rl2 liil3asnlI bits a3li3imob asia ils lo a3insqmo3 A3o12 bits Lsuium

3111 r1w 3Iquo3 £ d b3z5113Iuq 1iunns 3111 "loviviua-bns-iniol" s l3biano3 oats 3W wo1EV .3viLS 21 31q11o3 di 1o l3dm3m 3fl0 as no1 as 3unrinoo a1n3msq ifl3n3d 13v31

"nisti boh3q-b3xft" s iol ain3msq insisu isili aiosiino3 iiunns l3biano3 ion ob 3W8

3Isns 01 )how3mzil rittow nom -iuo bn3ix3 01 biswiolidgistie 3d bluow ii rfuo11its .2135131103 323111

Page 13: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

It

zquIal3dmn3m 3v511 isili 1floiq-non llI3n3 noilsinsio nswzni 1i1 3r11 lo laom 3bu13x3

.gniquo1 Isnoiaa3lolq to aUoi!15t Ishizubni biIsiqa iii

b3IJzi znoiisoilduq euoirnun ni 11siboh3q b3tzoq3l ts a3iliunns 1i1 to1 amuim3lq

ii1 10 gnst 3biw s cI b31311o akiIoq liunns no slth b313dis ,W .1a38 .M .A 'd 1iI 31nia ib3mmi iol slab b3l11o3 9W 2QQI baa OQQ1 8Qi ni zmiil srurtuani

b3noq3l w3lb 3w OQI bns 8Q1 ioI .aiiunns ioviviua-bns-lnioj as 113w as a3liUnfIS

Q1ZwEfI2lBW d b3au tuoa 3d1 zi doidw bn3qmo flzi3liFI ala8 moR amuim3lq liIJnns

amuim3lq ioI .'81 rfuoidl 1Q1 boil3q 31(1 ivo ahq 1iunns lo zia1sns aid ni (88Q1)

i a'123a 513(1W w3iv3$I a'123a lo 311221 QQ1 1u1. i1l moR slab b32u w (?.QQI ni b3lsik)

muim3Iq 31 gnia niuazi z3insqmoo 3nE1u2ni lo 3V1u2 Isuans 211 lo alIut 3111 nihoq31 Won

s riliw 23liIinns muim3lq 31niz ol btioqa5noo sisb 2l23H 3rfT .aiiiunns tsib3mmi

ol thio'sq liunns lo olisi i1i wod no noilsrrnolni ',ns 3v511 ion ob 3w ;muim3iq 000O01

2iiiunns 23b1113x3 1ñ slab 311T .23nsd3 muimsrq 3± lo 3Ni2 3111 as ahsv muim3lq 3f11

oi1diiq Isi3n 3111 01 3Idslisvs Ion sIs a3i3iIoq ar1i Isdi abnuoig 3111 no AAIT d b01311o

muim5rq-31ni2 1311o ion 230b AAIT lsrb bits a3i3i1oq 1iunns nilsqioiflsq 515 (3f1l idl .23iiUflflS 3Isib3fflmi

.2i3' 3111 I3Vo anav 325d slab 1iunns 2'Ia3 3111 uI 2insqmo lo l3dmun 311T

a'sw1s sis aman 31dsino351 I3lsib3mmi bus it3251 Isnoilsn £ 1(11w alsIuani 3111 31&I

io ani1oo1 t3molau3 1anoi3-I 11n51sqqs ainsqmo llama narn rlliw noLs b3bu13ni

V* 313W 3131(1 31qmsx3 ioI 8QI nI .zonil i3ubolq sxtstuzni Isioqa iasdqm3 isril airriut

.001 Q1 ni bris b3ls3qqs a3inEqmoo &1 0QQ1 ni ;3asdsisb ala38 .M.A 3111 lii 231fl503 ammmsiq liiinns b313dis 3W 1B3( QQ1 3111 moil slab 1111w luo b3iTtso ia1sris ioI

V bus 23S Is al3ubolq 823111 niasd3iuq aolquoo bits nmow 113m 01 bIsd3

amuim3lq no 1no slab b3l11o3 3W 3mU 13V0 ziz1sns 3visiSqrno3 3111 iol .13viloqa31

232B3 Its nI .anoris3ilduq 0Q1 bus 8Q1 3di gniau n3m b1o-ia-ô 01 b3uaai a3Illunns ioI

3mooni 31512 bits 15131)31 as 113w as 23xa1 muim3lq 31512 lo 2ao1 315 b3dailduq amuim3lq 3111

lo 3lui3IrIia rrn3i 31(1 3211 3W bits sM lo ninnig3d 3(1115 b313ub1loo 21 3VIU2 a'123fl 3ftT 3211 3W 15111 2101351 lnuo3eib 3± niis1uDIs3 ui sM 1o A33W iaiuI 3± ioI 2b13i( (HJZS31T

.wol3d

Page 14: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

£1

°'.2wofl iiunnE 3di no buiq d Jaum isrti axt 1d1nom f1 iibni I kIiT aioiIoq iiunns no noiirrio1ni viJmn3zulli bivoiq oT

bits nm nie 03 2Q1 iii buzi itiijnns tol muim3lq 10 000, IZ tq 1n3msq 3mo3ni

gtvs di zbiot 31ds3 di ni I3nsq itfl 311T .a3s 3n3t3Thb lo zIquo3 03 bits fl3ifl0W

s 31qrnsx3 to1 .325d sisb d1 ni einsqmo3 1L d b3t311o Inmsq (iiunns 1rIinom

01 izqx bluow à s is iiunns muim3lq 1niz 00000I 1soiqi s niasrbtuq nsrn blo

3v11 nrnow usofl .3111 tol ts t.q 8Q to 10 in3m'sq Idinom S 3v!3351

bluow muim3lq 000001Z 8ffl62 3(11 nisq nsmow blo 153'- £ 33E13VS no nm nsf(i ino1 ii niud 3Iquoo b1o-is-à A .(t0ô8 LRunnhi) V1V Idinom s tol ,zI OI iuods vioi

3Ini2 £ nsth e1 81 iuocfs to MJnom 8Z 3vi1 bluow iiunns Iovivtua-bns-iniol

.3Isrn

03 3Iquoo to LBubivibni 3(11 10 3S 3(13 rIliw 325513n1 0215 21n3msq iiunns 1d1noM

its tol 000001 nisq nsm blo is-V £ 1qmSx3 to1 .b3uazi zi 1iunns rb modw

21(1 115(11 3Iom btidi-3rro i2omth ,

dinom tq 0, I 10 iuosq £ 3v13351 bluow 1iunns

1iunns 3(11 lo 3uLBv r1J 32i1rI 0215 nis nmow ioI .loinui 2ili 2u 01 tIsqt3inuo3

£ nsmow 3(11 ns± tom 1no vit nsmow blo is-V :1 d lud iuosq 23nBr13 Isiln3l3lIib iuosq iiunnE 315m31\315m r1i isili wod o2ls I 3IdsT .tnuo 3bsob

tol 320(13 nsrli t3113i11 1n3313q x12 315 Isili 2iuosq tiunns 3v13331 nm 35 IA .gs illiw

3rIT .nmow tol is± ns± 1311icl 41 21 (13(11 01 Irwom.s Ii1inom 3111 V s d lud nmow s 23vi3331 3Iquo3 3(11 s IA .es illiw nsf1o oEIs eln3m%sq lfl3n3d tovi'nue bits 111101

1iunns 2'3Iquoo 3(11 V s cf lud nsm 3Ini2 £ 01 bisq isdi wol3d U 1i13113d Mlnom

di tol ern3iiEq ii1sltom 1611n51311ib ifl31 2frI3lisq In3msq 3adT .t3woI 21 inuoms

.21325113tuq ii1Jf1f1S 1o 2qi 2u05V

d bisq 21fl3n3d 1o gnst 3biw 13±51 3(11 ie3u2 I IdsT ni 213n5q owl lx8n 311T

(Iiunns iuo\sq-i23dir1 01 3(11 n33w13d thiosq 1o nst 3dT .32sdsisb z'i28 ni 23insqmo3

in3msq muim3tq 000001Z s no Isnoiiibnoo us (23ioiIoq iuo(sq-I2owo1 01 3(11 bits 213s11no3

oqrni ob di li nv rnuim5iq iiunn xsi Ion ob 231E12 i2om isfIl zfloq5I (ÔQQI) olluis°' .23a&rl3luq 33n51u2ni 3111 (10 xsi muim3lq £

Page 15: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

(1

3vi333I 1f1im nm b1o-is-?.à A nm b1o-i-ô wi 81 i r1 (13111w moii nqmo 3(11 io iiin3bi 3111 ff0 nibn3q3b 1thnom V8 01 moil

lo risi 311T .1QV zsw 13ar131uq E 1131J2 ioi 3g613VS finfi-Ils 8IiT .iiunns rft beasthxiuq

iuodB) nm b1o-1(-eV ioi nsi 3111 iwfi l3woI 1i(1i1e i nm blo -ô lol 21uoq

i3u2 isb 3rIT .(! iuods) nmow blo iol idi nsth wi1id 1iI2 bn '.xs d bns s d (iSV 3!1oq iiunns ns ioi "bnuois niqqoi1z 10 zifln3d 3(11 isili

2133fl51 2ith isth 21 2iuosq (1iunns iii noilsFisv 1i wi noilsnslqx3 3Idia2oq A i isilT .a3itiunns 3111 nu1182 z3insqmOo 33flSlU2fli 311110 (iilid5i2 L6i3flsflfl 3(11 ni 3n813i1ib

31111w 21nuoms iiunnE 13w01 ysq bhiow 81(1512 iom s bisi 2131112111 isdi 31dsvinoz) 2111

01 21113113(1 'hhinom 13did 'sq ol ihsm 3111 'd booioi 3d ir1im 131! s beiin 23insqmoo

ni 1nsq ilnijol 3(11 &11ffl5X8 ol 21 31r11 21 21111 13±311w bu1 01 Ew oitO .2loie3vni is1lis bAns1-123ifiLi in3wi di d 3bsm 2in3msq iiunns 3swvs iuo 2l ff3111 w ,

I 3IdsT

1511m12 315 21111231 311T ' .f1ino 112 113131151111 lo x3bni (I) '±1fl oi nib1o33s 231115qm03

s sq ion ob 2loj23vni iiuncu3 isth 323ggu2 11i bus ,

I 3IdsT 10 WOi qol 3111 111 oi11 01

3s13vS-3v0cfS us (111w mill s moil iiunns its ni.sr131uq 11311w *iq ir1i11 ll.6iinsiadu2

01 3(11 d 8bsm zin3msq 2woli2 1131(1w ,

I 8IdsT 10 l3nsq ljnuI 3111' .niisi Lci3nsnul

as 13*15111 iiunns Isubivibni 3± 111 3113(12 13*Isin i231S1 3± rfiiw a3insqmo 9OfIBiU2fli

3(IT .3i2 miii 01 1q231 1111w noiaul3noo islimia s 21gu2 (Q1) 123H .M.A d b3ttOqsI

.2m111 ils iol is± 01 1131im12 2i amiil 3lBl 3111 iol 33nq 313V5

ats5l ilstio}II b9b3o1 bna fI9TIIJD no 1sU .4

1f1SV315I 3(11 luods 2110115i33qX3 31111111 niithmioi 231111p31 1n53112 iiunns its niu1sV

ii1srtom 31111111 33fli .3IqtJO3 10 in51iurins Istibivibiti its nis1 23liilidBdOlq (ii1si1om

01 1)313110 2111111 i1131311ib 113111 2iuosq 3VliJ$131 3111 (II 110115131103 11$11fl512dU2 bnuol 8W'1

i23f1id 3± 1)513110 isiEl 2(11111 01 3111 lo if1i8 31qmsx3 ioI .28S 1113-1311kb lo eiasiiunns 1231IgUI 31(1 flfl31I0 2111111 01 8111 noms 0215 313W 2irt51iunns 315m b1o-is-ô ol 2iuosq

.alflsiiunns 3lsm b1o-ls- oi 21uosq 1o owl 12.133115 molt af11lE1 f1i11 '(13V fIiVi3331 2111111 110 23211301 flOfl3irI3 (Q!) a1ii13'

bits aqI3d bits iiuCl a'booM 2'00q bits btsbasi arrnfl RIJE1 3isvnq 1015(11 11101 3111

.2213W

Page 16: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

03 3isi v)ilsiiom izsq no siith 3ldslisvs au 01 (Iszz33n 2i ii nwon! ion 515 siiilidsdoiq

.2siJrI $HJJJJI iS35IOt

sth isflsi is iifl silT .asiii!idsdoiq ii1stiom b asq'i insvslsi owl sis 'd bsissl3 asidsi iilthom no bozsd sill lo snsnsqxs 1iLsiiom bsioqxs

sis sIdsi ssrlT .noiizii2inimbA inuzs Isbo . .U sill is 1sui3A sill 1 sfl1O sill

sill bo noli2oq Isionsitfi iuiuI sill 135 oiq 01 attoqs5l 2sSiZulT ihii Lsi3o Isunas sift ni

iiliiom b sqxs p.i35flsl 1s bnos silT .2m3i2 33115'lUZfl! ISi3O 10am 2flO!lSff

insiiunnA iti sasrloiuq isili noilsluqoq sift 10 iszduz sill to zsiiilidsdoiq

516 bits 23 sui3A lo isi3o sift cI sldslisvs sbsm a,Idst no bssd SIE sisb iiIjihom

snziuni sill b notlslu3lR3 sift ni szu ioI bsoqoiq to bsij llsuias stsb dftiw insiai2noo

.ai3ubolq 1iunns Isubivibni ioi esvssi 'nsqmoo 1iunns Isubivibni ml bits noiisluqoq Istsns sill iol siii!idsdoiq ii1siioM

sill i1oilo3 bits issy sms2 sill nictiiw bsisqmo3 nsrlW .insisilib l1nsflingi s-is -iszsrknuq

sic ss isvs is noiisluqoq zisns sri) ni nsmow bits nsm rliod ioi siiilidsdoiq ii1stiom

or sub sd zm s3nslsiIib aiiIT .issrkiuq iiunns iol 2siliIidsdolq 1ilithom rli nsdi isrigid

isgnol svil sm ithow isn sgsisvs nsrfi isilgid rfiiw 2lsubivibni :2101351 sviwl3xsnori owl

25iiiunns Isubivibni szsiloiuq oilw zisubivibni sili bits alsz2s li3i)nsl2du2 iuorftiw soiii itsili

noil3sls2 s2lSvbs lo sq'i isilsi silT .lon ob orlw s2oill nsili sgstsvs no isgnol svil 'sm iwo1 s3si 2lsubivibni isiiftlssw lsth iilidizaoq sill iol gniwolls isils nsvs iuo bluoo

.aAth iils1iom

sill srfl IsAiI ai ii iilcflom in&tiunrts bits aiitcsw nsswisd IniI sill 01 335q251 illiW

\(1huos Isi3o d nsvig isdi bnossd m53112 1iunns its bnscnsb orlw 2sIquoo bits lsubivibni

2.511 113155231 1(133351 .rltiow isn sgs-isvs-nsill-isilgid svsil nslq noinsq slsvriq nsm bits

isgnol isflwsmo2 svil lLcubs ilhiow isn sgslsvs nsdi isilgiil rlhiw 2lsubivibni lsrlh bsl2sggu2

thiW .(QQ1 ,

esqqs1 ;QQ1 sn'oH bits oiasnsliA s32) sgisI is noilsluqoq sill nsth

nsrb isdgiil rliiw 2lsubivibni isrll sldiz2oq i ii noi)33132 s2lsvbs lo sq(J isrfto oh bosq2sl

ooi 315 2SJiurIns isdi sbuI3noo assnlli auoris 4)1w saoili 2Ji il3u2 1th siiLciiom sgsisvs hiLsflom sgs-tsvs sift sonsH .3ni3i3sqx3 li1 IIi1 usd1 nsvig msdi ioi svieasqxs

sonsiu2nI .bsis3nuii 21 2siiiunns sasrbiuq 01 asbiosb lsrli quoig sill lo 'iIidsdoiq

Page 17: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

3th i ni3nq ibu ;bnim ni nori3nu1J iift diw ziiiunnfi hq iuoo 10 iiuqmoo d b3qol3vsb a13iiim snziuani 3viiiJ3qmo3 th muFldiliup3 lo ieIsn 3di lo 3noi19moo

.(08Q1) noIiW briE (ÔVQ!) sii1i briE blicbzdioM

1iI '213asd3wq iiiirxna to noilEhiqoq in w oi sIidw nibib oi noiiibbs nI

JiLsflom iooiq oi 1cJE1 li1 oi\o to tioiiç u oi 1r1i3riw 3bib o1s izum 3ri0 z!d1 3Iqo3q lo quo E lo 33n3fl3qx3 1i1siiom 3fL1 ain3Iq31 3Id1 bori3q A .iniiunnE iol aizi

io Jiodoo £ ias1jno3 I ' s I!suau mii 10 bon3q 1iod2 !3viJa1i £ nhub

s nhub mod noiq lo iiorloo s lo 33n3h3qx3 iiIahom 3m113111 in351q31 31d11 noiisi3n moil b3liqmoo 3d ns 1di flodo3 viIs ino1 on 31S Isdi znorlo3 io1 '.is lBIu3nEq

3IdEi horloo £ f1I131TIi2flO3 (13v3W011 ?J1OdO3 grnVi1-(Li1I5rIu3 toI .23!dKj boh3q lasq

.1dsi bon3q 3-iuflñ b3ljo1q as 113w as lasq molt noil&rriolni nibn31d 25flU31

(3th usd a1dsi flodo3 au 01 !suilsa 2332 ii 23U15v 1iunns gniiE!1J31E3 (13(1W

ni 1qqs I3)!i1 bluow I,wbivibni nb1oo1-b1Ewio1 Isnoiigi £ isili 23iiilidsdolq 3(11 iosfl3i

-3s bioiq 3111 isdi 31oM .1iunns ns lo zsrI31uq 3111 nuiri3no3 noi2iob 21ff nbthm

lo flui s as 3rnii ivo nsrb sm tiorloo nvi s ni 2IslJbivibni iol 3151 1i1thom 3fli33q2

3!qrnsx3 io1 .3ns133qx3 31i1 bris 2niisq 1i1sriom Isubivibni RI ebnii no noiiamiomni wn 1n31311ib £ worle bluow OQI 111 mod zisubivibni tol 31d51 1iIsiiom iiodoo Oô1 3111

risili OOO 1E3( 3(11 fl OV 3s b3113551 Ii (13(1W quotg 21111 10 3151 (fl1sl1om 3(11 tol noi1oiq bluow 31d51 OQQI 3rIT .110(103 311152 di tol 31d51 ii1stiom tiodoo OQI di bluow

b3l3ibrnqnu fsi1niedu2 3r11 lo i1U251 s es 3151 (iiIthOffl b3i33o1q 13W01 £ woffe Idsmuz31q

.OQ1 bns OI nwi3d 23b533b 33ti1i 3111 rij e3nih)3b 3151 ii1s1tom

3(10 .sisb iiIji,om 1o z3qi 1n313Thb owl 3W 3W wo13d 2noi151u3183 VC1EI 3(11 ru

'd b3liqmo3 as nolsluqoq 1s13n3 3111 tol e3Idsi 1i1stiom 110(103 b3133oiq 3W 01 21 dosotqqs

915 a31d51 iiLsflom 3a3ilT 2QQI ni tsuioA 311110 fl10 noilsileinimbA thu3 Isi3oe 3111

enot33o1q noq35I e31einT ihuz 1J313o2 ÔQQI 3(11 io1 beu ileiisie br1ei!duqnu no b3asd

as z31dsi 1huo I5i3o 311102 bus 231(151 C3rIEIJI3A lo 13i3o 3(11 ni (13)153 i (l3solqqs eidT' .(1 .q f1) .Is 13 118 d b3nIslqx3

.noiistieinimbA thu3 Isi3o 3111 d b3eu e3mLt3moa ozls ci dsotqqs bnoe CII1T'

Page 18: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

of

3w QI rn zbf iE- oi b31311o iiunn niuLcv ioI '.flodo3 dhid UWv3131 d iol

O1'Q1 311i tol tsb 3211 w QQ1 iii 2b1o-- io1 .23ililid&Jolq ilodo3 diiid 0F21 3rIi u rf nI .flodo3 fftüd OQI cfi molt z3itilidsdotq 32U w 2bIo-1o(-eV tol bnt flOdO3 rftiid

gIorIo3 3a3(fi tol n3h3qx3 iiLflom 5111J111 3rii to 2noIJoo1q QQ1 2'A2 no (131 3w 3B3

viiLstiom tsngs tuods noiismiolni msz 3th no b32sd 3d bIuort2 2noi33o1q d3u2 3211533(1

.a3rJiIrnnS 113th nionq ni u ir1im a3insqmo3 nstu2ni isrft bn3IJ

noiis1uqoq insliunas 3111 to? 1dsi bon3q u 01 i woflol ozls w bsoiqqs bno A

1torloo QQ1 3(11 lb 23ismiiz nwo 1110 i3IrIjzno3 ol 31ds1 tIollo3 A2 dJ (131w noli3nulno3 ni

(1HJfln5 rtJ to? 3IdsIlsvsnu 315 231(153 tiodoD .ainsiiunns Ltwbivibni to? 1dsl 1itstnom

ni alnsliunn.s to? 231(153 boh3q 3(11 03 2in3m1zubs 3)15(11 i2tIm 3W 02 noiis1uqoq nIzsf13luq

QQ1 1110 Ill .31(153 iior1o £10 2313T3qolq nb1oo1-bisvno1 31thr1123b 3(13 3lmim 03 13bto

OOO iiunnA w3i5dH b(12i1duqnu 3(13 molt nolisrinolni 3211 3W 31qmsx3 to? 2flO1JS11J3I&3

3ffl' .aJnstiunns Isubivibni tol 21n3335q 3i1siiorn 310(103 31(3 3lsm 323 03 31df13 boh3q

3113 ni 33n3n3qx3 1i1sflom ifISliunnE br33o1q 333fl51 03 b3ni23b 21 1dst 3111 OOO 1iunnA

oT " .hsu13A 10 (i3i3o dj lo 33ilimmo3 £ d b3ui '(11n3351 aSW Ii ;OOO tB3'

.sisb 323111 nibivoiq to? noiizii2inimbA ihu33 tfii30 3(1110 113a 31fl311&1 )1fUi(1i 3W' as iuorftiw 33fl3FI3X3 V132ubn1 molt bnno1 31d53 1i1thom £ ns3rn ix3lfIo3 21(13 111

"31258"°'

31d53 £ bns 31(153 "3lasd" £ n33v133d 33n3t3Thb 3dT .m2risrn2no3 to? nitsm Isnoiiibbs f1i has A 3IdsT MAI 8QI 31(1' .n13nq Oiunns to? bsol ii3Ilqmi (IC 21 l3illbom 2013 iuoifiiw

.101351 bsol O1 £ d 131?Ib 3lqmsx8 to? ,231d51 A 3125fl 1iunnA Isubivibnl 8Q1 .2lB3 2UOI1SV 101 231(151 3iaSd inSliufinE 3211 3W 2flO1iS1U3IC3 1110 1U0f11J01dT

no b32sd asw 31(151 1iunns 8Q1 3fIT .vioieuf nhi23131fli as asd 1d OOO 1iunnA 3dT' -IVQI boh3q 3(13 13V0 a3insqmo3 lo quoI 3g151 £ ni 33f13n3qx3 (3i1stIom '2lnstiunns ICui3s

Isubivibnl 3hzu13A 10 i3i3o 3(11' .2noijibno3 F81 133o1q bns 133fl3i 03 b3isbqu ôV lb quoi llsme s lb 33n8n3qx3 iiunas 3(11 b&bui (Q-1QQ1) 33flimmoD 33n3fl3qx 1iunnA

3(13 to? eisIJp3b.S zsw 31d53 8Q1 3111 IsdI b3bubno3 has ô8-ôVQ1 boh3q 3(11 13V0 23insqmo3 noilffU2inimbA thu33 Isi3o 3(11 molt 2311211532 '1i1siiom noiiiiluqoq 3113331 3loM .208Q1

quot 3(11 ni znoilibnoo niv1ov3 1131w no1s a3z12i1s1 r1iIsH to? 131n3D 1noi1M rfj bns sf11 ni b3vlovni 13vI13E 15ui35 as (ôQ!) fl32flsrlot b33nivno3 13v3Wbf1 19*ICm (iiunnE

3fl133q2 2111 Ion rtuoth1s 1153 iH .31(153 1iunns taubivibal W311 s to? 1163 01 23ibu12 1311153

25W 33111mmo3 23115U33A lo t3i3o s bris 13V11Su1flfl1S b313W2fi5 25W znoL1sbn3mmo331 3biw-vlizubni lo z3ibul2 1113331 OR 315 313(11 32U1333fl .1331(1112 3(11 13b12n03 01 b3ll3Vflo3

C8QI 312.5(1 3113 3211 03 (1qm12 b3bi33b 33lIimmo3 3111 13v3wo11 33113rI3qX3 i(iilahom lnsiiunns 210135? ln3m3votqmi 1i1s31om nizu OOO 153\( 31(1 01 btsvno? b3I33o1q 31d53 1iunas

3(10 lo isuIl as 113w as noilsluqoq 1s13n3 3(11 ?o 33113I3X3 1113331 31(1 1(iiw ln3l2i2noo

Page 19: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

VI

di nv,i3d 3isloqi3ini i1fl w ainiiunnE Q1 iol 31d1 3)liI-lloILo3 ioiniznoo

w3M bn3mmoM oi flimmoD di ni b3tIoq3l A 3ItkT 8QI 31i bnB 3ldsi OOO iiunnA

insv3!51 lo aoi1ji 3111 ndT .(!8I) noiiEulsV iiunnA 1nbivibnI io1 ziafl iiIthoM

ihu3 1jho QQ1 di 01 3!dii flodo3 3hu 1si3o Q! di moi1 iii1idsdoiq iilirioin

3mu2.2s 1131(1W nothnoa zidT .3!dsi bon3q iiunns QQf ,ifi ol boilqqs 315 31d14 boh3q

io1 isrli s 311152 3(11 3(1 Iliw zinsiiunns ioI tn3m3volqmi ii1stiom 10 3151 3vio3qeolq 3(11 Isril

.31(151 1i1sflom lnstiunns 3Li1-11of1o3 QQ1 £ 2b13i noiis1uqoq in 3(11

13bn3 d e31si iiliflom lnstiirnns bits noiisluqoq QQ1 nfflu231 3(11 2worte 3ldsT

3111' .notisluqoq insflunns 3(11 io1 23151 (1i15flom 13W01 3111 231511w11i ii bits 3s bits

3(11 niwo11o1 1 ib3rnmi s is b1ilil-3no nsth 31dsIon l2om ai 1511n313Thb

.1f13rn311131 10 35 lsnoilib51i

wo 2153 1n913Thb iii zJiJosq iiwins lo 3uIv bslnuoozib be133qx3 3(11 U1ffl03 oT

bits 8Q! ioI z3iiilidsdolq li1stiorn noilsluqoq Lc13n3 3AiI-tIofIo3 25llU31 0215 2i215I1S

31(1111 bon3q ihu3 1si3o OQQI di 3bsm 3W OQQ1 ioI 2i1sns iuo Iuo ns oT 8XØQQ1

1svivlu2 1sunn b3io1q ni1qqs d 31d111 3!iI-110d03 £ 01(11 (QQ1) .Is 13 118 ni

lfI3m3vOlqIfli 3231ff .13vileqe31 nmow bits nn io1 OO.I bits V.O b eln3m3volqmi

88QI) I2wJ1d21sW bits nsmb3hl bits (88(?!) yI2wsd21sW d bu I2uoiv31q 313W 23151

1o1 .boh3q is-eI 1Ofl 3(11 nhub b3vt32do 23151 Isulos 3111 1111r1 I(18231q31 bits (OQQI

boriq thu3 1sioo O81 3r11 nwi3d ni1s1oqi31ni d 31(1111 boh3q £ b315513 w 8Q1 31(151 bonq 81 nui1uz51 311T .31(151 bon3q OQQI 3(11 bits (8Q1) i3dsI ni nhs3qqs 31d51

.2315-I 1n3rn3voIqm1 ISVKV'1U2 3(1152 3111 nis1qqs d 3Aif-t101103 3bsm 113(11 25W

(nLsnom lnsliunns 3)111410(103 33ubolq 01 b32u 25 oIobof113m isfimiz A

25W A 3IdsT 31258 iilsnoM 1iunnA Isubivibnl 8Q1 3(11' .21E3( 1311153 101 a3fluIldsdolq

23151 ln3m3volqmi ljlviv1u2 noitsluqoq 1s-I3n3 d OQQI bits 8QI 01 b15wio1 ir1uoid

113111 313W 231d51 bon3q 32311T .231d111 bon3q 33ubolq 01 2boh3q Insv3I5I 3(11 13V0 b'rn2do

.3vods b3nolin3rn 23151 ln3m3vrnqmi lsvivu12 b3l33Lolq 3111 ni1qqs d 3)1114101103 3bsrn

.Z23ni2Ud liurins [thlnsi2duz illiw (itJIffl03 (1huoe 1si3O 3(11 d b32u 231(161 1iorloo 15u135 3d1 nisIdo 01 3Idi2ZOq Ion 25W 118J

.2n0q351 t25312LJ1T IQQI bits 8Q1 3(11 iusqiq ni noLI5-ti2rnimbA

Page 20: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

81

iIuS1 dhoW vnoM iifl . vocn nft bna QQ1 tol znibni1 bli.i3b 311i riliw i!ut to vi&nmuz ujo nid W

di tol z3u!v iiunns in3atq rIuotcft 231 diT .21E3 13ih3 tol 2fIoIi1U3t63 niq oi no

,isi iuosq 3vs nqmo3-lls 3dt u I bnB a1dsT ill 2no1IiuqmoD .3a1thiith QQ1

2j3EIJno3 iiunn 1ubivibni diiw b i3o22 2inmnsq to mtie d1 3imii 031 3IdaT mon

QQI 3di eu trnoI 3113 isdi i 1 bns £ zIdsT nwbd n3t311ib 3ñT ..s bas x yd

3)111-1101103 nimuu QQ1 3(13 ii t311E1 3113 3tifiw 1ds3 (1iLflom 1101103

3111 mon u1sv 1iuruth 3n3251q 01 231ds1 1ilthom rilod u w 3fdsT nI .31ds3 n1riom

33n1nu2n1 b31I 1c1ic1 12om bns 1zgts1 3(11 R 113w as mifl iuoq-123wo1 0! bn i11if1 01

.z3rflunnE nu113 23inBqmoo

tsnimon mti-tior12 10 31u331r132 rrrI3i 3113 diod niw b3iuqmo3 3u ubv 1iunns hA

AA tol 3vui3 b13i b3iJ131 di bns v-iuo b13i bnod vIuzsiT 3(11 RI n3ilqmi 3Ijt 123131ni

on rijiw 231u23t 110q31 rItjoid3 z31d1T to 2nmulo3 owl lti1 31ff .2bnod 8izIoqro3

to 2in3mq 3iUflflB 13111i3 to nolEx1i Isno2l3q 31532 10 131)31 3(13 ol nvi noili$t3bi2n03

iiiiftrU no 23xS3 mhIim3tq 33512 tol wolli3 ob th duoift1s 2bnod no ain3msq 1a13ini

noiisIu3Ls3 utsv iiunns xsl-t3i15 1n3tq Lds1 r13s ni anmulo3 owl las! 311T '.23asth1uq

Oj xsi 3351a bru Im3bit b3nldrno3 s 23351 jwiiiunns 3(13 isdi nimu22s

(I iii muim3lq tshlob tq zin3m'sq 1iunns to 3uLsv 1na31q 3(13 awork 3IdsT

3111 nsrn b1o-ts-ô £ tol 3Iqrnsx3 toI .231d51 liIsJtom noilsluqoq L6t3fl3 niaU bJisIu3Is3

3w 15111 nimu2zs ô18.0 21 aizsd xsi-31o13d s no 1iunns 31i1 £ tol ishlob muim3lq 13q 3IJISv

(ff131 bnod 3lsloqtoo 3111 au w Ii bns rroiisu1sv Ri 3V11J3 b13h viuas5TT 3111 3211

V.0 bns 8.O is t3li3ir1 3ts 23ijlSv 3S135 3(11 35 3(13 lo nsmow £ io1 .31u131r112

3111 ig oT .

. 1 ai 3151 sivs 113111 ;amuim3tq iiufrns no axs1 3aoqmi 231512 1 1nO' 23151 xsi 33512 isubivibni 3(11 b3111(3W 3W LO 10 31St 1(51 muim3lq 31532 3513VS 1snoiisn Ansrli 3W .31512 ds ni nibia3t noilsluqoq blo-t --18vo-..U 3111 to 23Rin3313q 3113 d

.231(51 muim3tq 33512 no £151) 1131w au nibivotq tol olliIasD i3lEM 3113 a3n3iqi33t 1FuJ33 1si3o 3d oIs sm 21n31qi331 3mooni (iiunfls nsm 32uso8°

33512 bits 1I3b31 b3nidmo3 3(13 bx blu03 3mo3n1 123131ni to v)iunns no 3151 xsl Isnigtsm 3W .3mOonI 8Idsxsi ni a1113n3d (inu332 lsioo2 10 flOi2UI3fli 03 2b531 3m03n1 21113 Ii 3351 1(53

ns bniI Ion bib lud z3Jin xsi 1sniu$m t3r1id 01 ai1uzi tuo to 1iviii2n3a 3111 b3lolqx3 .31311 b3tIOq3t Z3flibflul 3113 01 3v115131 2ris(13 1i1n1du

Page 21: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

QI

113w 31 C 31(1ST ni FIin3 muifn3iq i3q 3u1Bv liz izth bs1 3(Ii j.sI3n3 nI .(13vi33q5I

z vinq bluow Eiqoiq (1i1zflom 3S13vS riliw 33Ij31 ls3iqi z isdi ei1qmi 00.1 woI3d

33nSlIJ2ni 1zi3!3mmo3 £ mail iiiJnnz its fli2SI131uq 11311w "io3 noi3zznfIi" 31ds3Jon

3rIi mail b3nurrn3i3b as 3iunnz ii.s1 1lzhzubs nz 1Iias1L31uq 01 in3ISviup3 ai aidT .imso 111153w no lo floLbsil 3moa qu vi ol nivsrf lud 31cJzi 'ii1siiom noiisfuqoq 11n3n33

.i3ubOlq iiunns airli iii l3bni.8m31 3111 111i23VfIi 31013(1

3111 3a!313x3 noiizutsv 3111 ni beau 315i inuozaib 3111 ii1id 3111 isrli awoda oats C 31(1ST

31.5 thJozq iiunns lo 3utsv b9inuoaib bobqx3 311T .muim3lq iq 3uIsv .9111 iwoI

nsill a1uozq inuoaib oi aizi iz.911ni 3isioqioo AAfl au 3w 11311w 1.9wol 11s3iJsm3iz2

iq u1zv isdi ai C 31(1ST mail noiaul3no3 1.9cIionA .5llJ13u12 ml3i v1uas5IT 3111 321J 3W 113(1W

:13bfl3 d isv oats au1sV .3izi inuoaib lo 2z31blz31 dliw 2.9nib.9b muimiq

bnz n.9mow lol islimia ai bits n3m iol ia3wol ai muim3tq iq 3ulzv lol n111o11f1O3

mu!m5Iq 1.9q .9uISv 3111 V bits à gs nm 01 b3uazi z3iiiunnz iol 1q33x3 IIsnil .231qU03

.9111 isdi 3ldizaoq ai ii .aiasd xRi-3iobd £ no nsdi 1.3f1ll1 1&Iw3moa 21 iad xSi-13iIS its no

.9th b.9isbnsm asri $1I .9111 iz1 di moil z3vn.9b anolJzIuol53 xsi-l3flS .9111 ol .9gsinzvbs 1tn fl0i2U13X3 (I1 lb no1iS11J3IB3 (IJ iii 1dsi MA! C8QI .9th .91dz1 1i1sriom boil.9q blo its 10 3w

.oi1zi

isdi nimu22S 2.9rflunns loViviua-brts-ifliol .9isulzV3 a.9lquo3 isdi amueas ia'1n iuO

ari1 d 11 £3231 1n1 13v.9woH .in3bnpbni .915 2.9iiilidsdolq ii1stiom laubivibni 11.9111

.33n.9bn.9q.9b 3viiiaoq aiididx.9 2.9VIW bits abasdaud 10 ii1sriom .9111 3z111 ziaua (ôQ1) .ls i ino1.9q vE1 iuods d bub.91 3d bluoda autsv iiunns isdi laua slsb ons1u2ni nzibsnsD

isili 21.9bom bisbnsia ni2u b.9iuqmo3 a.9ulsv .9th 01 3V1is15t ,a1.9bofn ii15iiom ifl3bn3q3b 11.911w

..93n3bn3q.9bni mueas (ii1thom insiiunns gniau aoilzi muim3lq 01 .9ulBv iiunns 21n3231q 31dsT

3VSII ainiiunns 3aus33fl .3VodS b3s(1snz 23151 fl1stiom Is13n.9 .9111 nsrtl 1.911151 a.9illlidsdolq

itsifi 1.9(1u1 1rrriolinu 515 t .91(1ST ni a3hln3 3111 a1nsiiunns-non nsrti z.913n513.9qx3 .9111 l3gIiol

.9th Ia w .9111 asiiup.91 sbsnzD .9un3v.9$I 1sbsnsD ni Isdi au b.9rmolni asd 12v311M 3d20M' .31(1ST MA! jQ1

Page 22: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

bobnjs-iou CJCflJp0U2 A9JflG bGL BLGUJIflW M2 10MC21 OL U1CU 11112 LG2flJI wA C 11G 10

GLG !2 Lor1pJA cowlxnsp!G OL wGu MOUJCU uq conbIG2 BA C0U11321 !U fiG GUGUf

GLfJC22 0 X p2!2 OL q12C011U1 L1G uq C0Ul10jj11J OL G1 AJflG bCL bLGW!I1W

WCWCL2 0J fiG CUGLJ bobnjipoif 12 LG1GL 0L 0JGL 1J11J 0L AonucL

q14JGLGUCG WIJA PC fIG 10 fIG TC1 fJ&1 fIG ISfO 0 fIG JflC GXbGC111UCG2 0 9UUfl!1J1J12' uq

CJjCffI11OUZ 0L IPG CLJGWJ b0bf1J1JOU MJJIIG bCL bLCwIflw qcCJiUC2 MI1p G jpI2

pS212 MJJGIJ J1J1JflIJ1 1JJOI411JA 12 n2Gq BA C0U1L21 IU fIG pG0LG X 9uq SjIGL 1X

1P1 !1.LG2bGCIIAC O V2COIW1 L1G AJJflG 1GL bLGWPW !UCL12 MIflJ SC OU C10LC 1X

AffJIIG CCflJ110U2 pGCOWG WOw 2GU21fAC 10 q1J,CLGUCG2 IU fIG q2C0J1U1 L1G MG J20 !1J

fiG SIJWUIA bOpCA 12 GA&JflCq fl211i fiG 1flJIJflIJ1 19pJC M!I]J J0UGL qfIL11O1J fiG bLG2cul

bobnjpou UJOI4IIJIIA L1C2 11112 12 CCfl2G fiG GGCfAG qnLqou 0 bA0f112 12 LG1CL MGU

C0Lb0LUC AIGJq CJILAG !11 fiG C2C nc UU11IPTU1 W0149JIIA bLopp1jiqG2 fJU GuGWJ

2np21nuIsfA wow fiG qiconur L1G CpuG2 tLOW fIG J.LGJ2faA AJCJq CflLAC 10

iu COWbUU jspjc2 uq MC uq 1p1 fIG AJJf1G bCL bLGwrnuJ UflLC2

g bCLCGUI 1 11J12 1!WG

AIGjq 011 -Ac jLc2nLA M92 bcLccuf EVY cothoL pouqa Aicjqcq u AG15C o

pouq m!fJJ ICU ACL2 10 WIfInUlA M2 bCLCGuI 1 pc pciuuiu o yA iiq fiG

bcLcGuI uq QØ bCLCGIJç jo bjcG flG2G LGUIUJ2 U bCL2bGCfAG fiG AIGIq 011 JLG2nLA

MJJGU MG A2C fiG 9U11(1!IIIUI WpJG LOL M0WGLJ fiG US00(T2 1U1GL1flI WIG2 0 LGIITLU LG J3

bLGW!IIW coai 'a bGLCGUI MACU MG flZC fiG bobnjou uJ0L11!1A WpJG miq Q3J bGLCcuI

GxbcclGq bLC2GUI q!°'1uq A9IIIG 0 U UUfli1A bojicA JU fIG pG0LG-WX C2G M1jJ ira

LCIflW OU 9IJUII!IA bOj!C1G2 EOL Q-AGL ojq WUe fiG 1flGUJ9j LSIG 0 LGUIUJ tIJ1 GdfTlfICa fIG

MG CU j20 bwut fIG !u0I.11fou !U JjG2 uq pA cowbnu piGuIj i.91G2 ojbobnjpou j,pjcv

oi bLcrnc uq jy bOaf IiIX AGL2fl2 083ô uq O84 LG2bGCfAG!A fl211J GUGUf

bobnjpou 2flLAIA9J LG2 EOL -AWL-OJq M0WflJ fiG VGI.G A9JITGZ LG 9!TU p1jJGL 1

C11I.AGe uq Ø5 9TJGL IPX. ip COWbLG2 jO o o ow (o814) fl2!1J CUGI3j

11PJG MOfljq 22G22 fiG A9JIIC bGL bLGUJIITW 2 ØJ 0u bwx P!2 1T2JU fIG JLG2nLA AIGJq

fJO2G 111 fiG bLGAIOfl2 WPJG LOL CXIJIJJIJJC' Q-AGL-0Jq wu fl2pJ fIG 1JUfl191J12 WOLI9J!IA

Page 23: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

0qiGLMI2G cou.c2bouq 10 UUJJ2 fI tc uoi cin9JA 2eJj1u bojiciG2 /G gcwb 10 qqtcnq P2C 9LC UOf CfU.LC1JqA i22f1!U b0j1C1G2 20 fIf fIG N0GLGq bi4cc dflOtC2 9LG qieq OLcuc dnG2pOu flJ9 9L12C2 M!fI fIG BC22 CW 12 MCfIGL 2OWG ULW2 qJ1 9LG J2rcq UI fIGGCCGGq , oj fIG ruuniiA btcwir,wwcjnqc COUJUII22!0U2 fO ffG1Jf2 911q L0JCCL2 911q LGJSfCf qiLGcf CXbC112G2 9LG UOf 9JJO/ACq 10

0L COWb91JIG2 JICCU2Gq fo M14C Pfl2UG22 111 J4GM AOL!C 2fG' W914CGfU C02f2

worjiiA bLop1Jp!jifG2 !PG GUf1TG2 UI fIG fpJG 2flG21 1M0 COUC!fl2!0U2 h!L2r fIGLG 9LG

Acrt-ojq UIGU ot L9uc oj,, qIGLGU !u2flLCL2' fl2!1J poip GUGUIJ bobnjou q mun!rcu

JJG bLG2cu ijne bet btcwrnw qojjL c9JcnIfou2 oL UUfffG2 0jeLcq (0 Q-

iuq!AJqnSJ'

guuni b&onf2 uq qic C02( o u JuqJAqnJ 91J1JflJ(A iow fIG 2imqbour o u icLe

cxbjnu tonpjA pj o qic q2b941A pciiiccu qie cxbectcq q2conuicq bLc2cu1 A9jnc o

2eJccpou M2 betceur tonjijA 2!w!19L o pc cnu.ciu CO2V yqAcLze 2GJGCføU bbc9u o

2CJGCf]OU 12 JO bGLCGIJI (j - gw) LOt (G JØ2 uq ctjA I8O2 fIG C02f o AG12GOL u sruuni(A 2oJq (0 111911 eq Q miq fl2!U fIG JLGI2nLA Aiejq Cf11.AG fIG C021 0 9AGL2C

GuqcL 9Uq l2fca fIG A9JIIG bet bLGuIInui UI102 iu .LP1c uq 4' joL cxwbjc

Eiu9J1A MG C911 cr1Cn!fc (G C02( o AGL2G 2GIGCIIOU iu pA cowb9uu oL jqe

J8O2

ML2PM2JA (jgg) Uq 2!U!UC91JflA 2W9JJGI. (p911 fIG flLG 0 J bctceu oL rpG c9qA

JSIJ fJJG nLG o, bcLccuf cowbnfeq oL we iaoa uq citjA jg pA I.iGqw9u uqA9U0fl2 cowb9uA cou1!ueucA LG2CUG2 uq bLoiv jpe jflLG2 c 2OWGM91 2W9JIGL

btew!nw2 (0 COAGL WGf!U C0212' COLbOL9IG 0AG4JG9 9uq lucowe WXG2 9qqifou2 (0

!wbl!G2 ip cowwGLcj !u2flLUCe Cowb9u!c2 U j 9JjOmCq 9pon( J4-Jg betceu o 9UUfl(A

Z2flW!U (1I( fJea (Ab1C9J botppo wAC2(wcu( 12 9 cothowc pouq i (p12 12 p.fle!(

wotjiiA IJq nIAG2iwGu(-LG(cq C02(2 (0 (C !U2flL9IICe COwb91JTC2 0j !221!U JflC 91JUfl!fG2

gQ CGU(2 bet qojjt lJAe2(Gq 11112 2G( O C9jCfIJ9(10U2 bLG2nw9pJA LebLG2cu ipc bnte

bnLcpeL2 u ipe c tucz G9UJ!UC pete onjq cxbccj 10 LCCGIAG b9Aon o pciwccu g

BIG LG2I1J(2 111 J9pJG 9 fl21U fIG COLbOL9Je (GUM 2PJICWLG !wbJX fJ9( 9IJUfl!(A

OL WGIJ JV9U Ot MOWCIJ

(jIG j,9C1 QJ9( fIG tO 0 (fe GXbGCWUCIG2 UI fIG 9UlJfl!19U( uq GUGL9j bobnjqouz (2 LG9(GL

Page 24: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

-31q s no sIqmEx ioI .23m&mo3 nSw2ni 22O13 mJJim3Iq iq zuthv ni zn313Thb iz! 3113 1d&i ji1thom noiiithjqoq 1gI3n 3di bns 3vuJ3 b13h iuzjiT di niw bn 2iaBd xi

iol e4V.O OS Wnsqmo3 Q8.O i .thJiunn nivq id nJ cb ioI muim3lq iq u1sv 3EI3 gifiuzzi z3in1qmoo od1 bno3 .inoq I lo &n513Thb £ -- Z3liiUflIIS grnq 1210w (133 3113

3loM .zznqx iol znigum !Imz Ivi1I5z 3vEd OS m aeitiunns gnisq izd n33 9113

bI3i 3iinocpo3 Ii bns 231ds5 iibtiom Sniiunns gmau muim3lq 13q 3U15v 9th ItsiIiqa noijibbs zanqx ioI tbI 316 'i6flob muim3lq 13q 23n33 9(1(1 iuodE !no idi oa OQ.O 9VW3

z5IuS3irIja 3203 wo! V13V 3v611 vsm ainEqmo3 adT .zilIoiq briE abniñ 3fl3gnino3 ol

111w th isrfi 3v3i1d sm di lo\bn6 gnui3h1m iiib dguoufi aiiiunn6 gnuII32 d aqsth3q

nI .b3muaz 3v611 w nEth 211u231 JiIsflom 10 231u251 ifl3mia3vni 13353d 33ri3fl3X3

£ nd asrf 313113 isriS noi2uI3nO3 3111 miiluioo a3lugft mlJim3lq iq 3utsv figHt 323(13 3(13V3

hE1u3iflEq b9vi1 3ulsv liunn1 bns bisq rnuim3lq n33w13d qsg 3111 ri 3g1nhfI2 b9*IEm

.agnibnul (88I) I2wsrIz16W bns nErnb3ril ifi 3113 ol b31Jqmo3 as

3113 OS b31911o 313W iir1i ai3ubolq 1iurins to 3u16v b3iqx3 9th b3nim5x3 gnivsH

13vo bgnid asd ziouboiq 329th lo 3uLsv b3Sqx3 rfi wod bianoo won w QQ1 ni 3ilduq

bIo-is-ô OS b313u10 a3ithuflflE 101 2110116Iu3153 muim3lq 13 3uIsv 9th awode ô 1dsT .3m13

isth isl ai SI .QI bns OQI 8QI 101 Juoq 3fi19VS nsqmoo-ffs aiafl th gniau ,n3m

wtg iiillob muim3lq q 3uIEv 2iaEd xsi io ,1d63 ii1stiom 33I inuo3aib siii lo 3v3qa5rIi

316 8QI iol a33firniiz3 1n3231q 3rIT .?QQI briE 8QI r139v/33d zlnioq 3gsinn3q ldgi9 1r1guo1

zi go1oboth3m 1UO isrb grnmIiInO3 8QI iol EfloliEIu3tS3 (88Q1) a'1zwsdz1sW 03 32013

iuo isfil 31011 oats 3W .2163( thE3fl iol aiIua5I 3IciElsqmo3 33s13n3g 03 rlguOrr3 islimie

znoq3i (88Q1) 1awsdeisW lsth isliob muim3iq iq z3uIsv dgicl 3(11 10 111332if1im31 315 231u231

(1iunns se3glsI 3(13 iliiw zirnit n31 9th iol znoiisludsi 31sq3a gnuln3z3lq d 3u221 aith .i3AlEm 9th (11 b9VIOVfli '(13V1i3S 3d OS l3)1i1 316 2ff1111 323(13 36(13 zbnuoig 3(13 (10 223ffi2Ud

n3ewS3d a3nog3iE3 "1210w 1133" bns "jz3d 1131" 3(13 fl zrrnil lo 33n332i213q 3(13 b3101qx3 3W' .QI bnE OQQI riiod ni 326(1 6561) z'123fl 3115 (Il Z3ifIBqmO3 Q 313W 31311T 2QI bris OQQI

VI .0+ asw n3m b1o-l6- ldI Z3SiunhiB (10 aiuosq 9th 33w13d notlsI3TioO )1fl61 3ffT 1no 0Q1 ill 3lIifHup 1uosq 52311g111 9th (Ii 231flE(flO3 3V13W1 3111 tO .2153 owl 3113 n33w33d

le3wol 9th (Ii z3UlsqfnO3 fl3V313 9th 10 bris QQI flu 3hiniup iuosq iz5flgiff 3th 11! 319W 331113

Isiinstzdue 3d OS 2153E 313113 wriT .(?1 1i 313th b3nism3l owl s1no 3liiniup 1uosq .z3i3iloq (3iUflnE 1i3113 110 13110 213111211i 15111 zfliosq 9th Ri nolisul3ufl

Page 25: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

.'OôQ1 bim this 'OQ1 hs O4Q1 di nibubni boh3q ihs iv tol

i tsllob muimtq 13q u!sv iiunns ni noii5ui3ufl h mon zhs istli noiizup A

3d1 oi b3js!51 3d bluodz hq iñT .zbsIino3 iiunns 10 ohq 1hsm 3dJ ninrI3t3b isffw

L&iimon lb ii!idthisv bns !3v31 3111 03 b3isIsI 3d 0215 sm ii lud z33E1 325133(11 15SI lb 13v31

oi 31ds 3d sm insqmo3 33n51u2n1 1dcJz bns wol 315 23i5I 325133(11 113(1W .231st 123131(11

nI .21n3m123vn1 3mo3ni-boxfl t3dio diiw 13v1IJ3qmo3 SlOffi 23iJiUflflS niisqioitIsc-non 33nq

01 ini3uIsI 3d sm 23insqmo3 3311stuani o1dsrisv bits i1id 315 231st 325I3U1i n3dw 1astino3

,ts lsth ni boua2i 23iiiunns lb noiistub 3111 tol bsniitini&n 3d Iliw ab13i lfl3flu3 15(13 smIJ2ZS

113111 rnoil 2bnul 13n 11103 tsis1 3liUpSI bits (13v 11321103 8lom 13s dJ 3101313(11 bns

.ni3rtq liunns

3IdsT ni 23111231 3(11 10 nOiisi3lqtslni 3(13 nini33no3 noiia3up tnslloqmi (11s1u3i11sq A

t3q 211J05q (1iUfiflJ3 lb 3IJISV b31nuo32ib 1n3251q b3i33qX3 3111 111 325313fl1 3111 13di3fIW i ô

1fi3i13(3 lo 13511115 as 10 21uosq 13rtid btswol bn3tl s lb 111125! 3(11 l isilob mlñrn3lq

nbdsfrflolfli 3(11 1111w 3v10231 10(11153 3W 15(11 311221 (IS 21 2ifIT .ru3nq iiuflfl (Ii 2flOliEUi3Ufl

.)how 31111111 ni 3IoIqx3 ol 3qorl w isili m3ldolq s tr Ii tud si3rl b31n3231q

1n3231q b3133qx3 3(11 1133w33d qirI2noLtsI3l 3111 (11 3(1111 l3Vb 23n5d3 01 noiiibb nI

23flSd3 (133(1 0215 3V511 313111 muim31q (3iUflflS 3113 bits aiiiosq i11Jflh1B 10 3IJIJIV b3lnuoo2ib

b1o-ts- 01 3ldslisvs 231311oq no ni2u3&I .13)h.sm 3(11 fI 233flq 1iunns lo 3fl51 3(11 (11

23S13VE 23iOiIoq 1uosq 1231i3ifl 1133 3(13 tol 3mo3nl 1thnom di 8Q1 cxi isiii bnil w flrn 3SI3VS 3(11 31111W 32Sd £15!) 2'323fl 3(11 111 23t3i10q lo 3IqfflS2 5111(13 3111 tol Isili 2311111 1 .1

3111 OQQ1 111 .3ZI8vS 31qm52 r1i mit 88.O zi 23insqmo3 1uosq 123wo1 1131 3111 tol 1uosq

bssiqz 3(11 udT .UQ.O bits SQO.1 QQI ni bits Q8.O bits VQO.1 313W 2311213532 21JOOLG(U1

bits OQQI bns 81 n33W13d b3nibb 23i3iloq 1iunns ruosq-wo1 bits -du1 3(11 fl33Wl3d

3ub 25W fliWbTiSff d1 lo ebtidi-owl iuodA bits OQQI n33wl3d 2231 d r1uoth1s ,niss

2iuo'(sq 1a3c1ir1 3(11 b3l3llo isill 2i3sIlnoo 1iunns 3(11 lo 21uo'5q 3V115131 3(11 111 3f1i133b 5 03

.isllob muimslq 13(1

floiiqmuEuoD 1n9mnhiM iftoom ol 2vIxW 9vihun3itA :"23iiiunnA bsiu2nI4I" .è

lb 9u1sv b31nuoo2ib 1n3231q b3133qx3 3(13 flO b32u3ol 2sf! n012211321b rIio31b1 3(11'

Page 26: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

3bivrnq 01 bniab 316 ziiiunns 1Sf11 3361 1EIifI33 3(11 213313fl 212\(1.Sfls 2u1T .aiuosq 1iuna6

Ion a3ob 2iuosq lo 3utsv b3iqx3 3(13 no IIo ni2u3oL .alsubivibni 01 33fl6w2th

£ qol3v3b oi i62fl i ii noiizup aiiIi 2231bbs oT .31u3631 insfloqmi 2i111 3!nO331 10 b i3iqx3 3(11 qmo ol bus nolj3nhII iili1u Isubivibni ii3iIqx3 us diiw nouJsIu3Is3

gnibsiqa iol 2noiiqo iiunns-non viisrn3fls moil isdi 1111w iiunns us nizsd31uq

.3mij 13v0 floiIqmu2no3

2u213v i3s1Jno3 iiunns iisl llshsu13s us nizsñ3wq isqmo w no1i332 2i(1j uI

bnozz 3111 lii 3sI12 nA .3isl1z nou1sijiunns "3311 2111-1132" 3Iqfniz s gniu2mq

ui 1163 noiiqmu2no3 lo 18v31 11id s 232ood3 Isubivibni ns 11 .smm3lib £ 23361 1o3is3

33ub51 1qw1 ol bno1 3d 111w rI mii no1 £ 3viI 01 iuo 2rrIui n3rli bus in3msIrJsI

hi dJ ni 13v31 wol 5 ol 3 21 noriqmu2noo ii (13vis(rI3i1A .zis 13161 ui noliqmu2no3

113111 ,b3vi1-no1 21 Isubivibni 3(11 Ii oiuost 1113i3fl1u2 3d 111w 313111 311111 o2 2153 1n3m311i31

n33d Jon 3vsrl isuli aiuoi LsiJnsIzdIJ2 (111w 3kb 111w [subivibni 3111 Isill 33116(13 £ 21 313111

b3fnu2no3 i ol 21 bon3q inom3liJ3l 3111 vo 1uoz51 nibs31q2 iol 31s1J2 31qm12 3110

:01 lsup3 £ 3S Is noriqmli2noo Isnimon

'H

231on3b 4 bus s boh3q lo ninni33d 3111 is 111153W 10 3U15V lJlfliffIOIl 3113 231on3b ,W 31311W

3111 as 23rn133b 3nsiqx3 3111 32115338 .5 3s Is (2ls ui) 3nsi33qx3 3111 e1subivibni 3113

326313111 111w boFisq 11369 111 b3mu2noo 3d 111w isHi 113163w lo n0U35ñ 3(13 23S Isubivibni

3111' .3I1 ifliw 1I6i1nsI2du2 3n1133b 111w ninismsr (11153w 10 13v3! 3113 lud riliw

is 113163w no noiisrinolni d b3nifrrI3I3b \13i31qmo3 ai nsIq noiqmu2noo 2tIsubivibrn

lo noiiulov3 i1i iol fIoiIsup3 niwo11o1 1i bus 3vods 3111! nolJqrnu2no3 3(13 3s Jn3fn3lli3l

:lx3n 3(11 01 bOrI3q 3110 moil thts3W

— 'H)*[(—1)+1] = ''H

(1iunns 3211113mq bIuod2 2lsubivibni 13111311W 1o 1101323up 3(11 lo 21n3ffl111511 1113351 io1 .(ôQ1) 12V31iM bits (€QQI) inivsiiri8 1sUnoo

Page 27: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

Ix,Aon bLoUje L0IIJJJA 111 I! M!p c isic O UjJTO1JbLobo2cq PA B!2 (j) uq iwbjcwcuicq pA nvv lu g' 9J!oM2 pL u !ucLcubjcc jocjjA onuq c obiwj brijr jpc isqcq bAwcu wcipoq uuniA bAon ULJftG LflCPOU 1U 'UII! .LP!2 12 GCfl2C JJC O IjJG LCJ COU2flWbliOU bLoJc jcccou2nwbqou bp q morqq pc obpwj pow tpc mnu 21Uqbo1u qocz uo jcq 10cou2nwbflou 211G9UJ2 IJ1 qccJiuc !II LGJ AJ1TG JIG qcAI OZJ tLOW fJJG COU2WIJI LGJ9UUffifIc2 uq 9JUJflAC LCJ IJUfil1A COUfl.ClT EAGII 1P0nIJ IVc UOW!U! UUf11C2 0jcL

pic qouc 2OWC CTjCflJi0U2 cowbL!u ip nf1!1A JACJ2 1joLqcq pA pcc uowJuqJ5!UCI!OU zbccijcq pcjom pc LCJ sIjcLix iuIcLc2I isc ciu c iuqAiqnsJ 12 [(j-)1-.t]

mc qcj1c uow1u cou2fluJbpOu UOM2 pA 1C bucc JCAGJ mpcu lpcA GUIcL ipc npjiiA

WJG Hi fI2!U IIJC 2OC!J 2GCflL!IA c0p014 J! wpjc 0L WCJJ pow iu

MC couibnlc pc c1rwI. 11A pIL uuniA bAon1 bcL bLcuirnw qoj () 0L -Ac ojqbCL ACL flJC2C n1J2JC !U0 LCJJ UURC2 I)J1 qGCJ!U Iii LGJ AJflC 1 IJJC2C WL2

MC C0U2!qCL 21UI1JOU2 M!1P COU21U1 1UJ10U L1G2 MC cOU2iqcL JUJ1TOU LC2 O poq 3 uq

MG 1111111 OflL IJSJA2!2 io uurnfA COUIISGI2 lxcA jxcq uowrn9 pcucj 2Lcw2 uq!uqic1oL upjc 12 qcucq lu cowbjcwciiwiA p!0u

Mp!cp ii uun11A !UCOWG 12 Iucjnqcq iii ixpc lucowe' uq cio otpcl.M12C jpc 1GL

lye i' 12 u !uqic1oL ii.pjc 2C1 cdmj o ouc oL G2 jG22 1p9u 1G qic

= [I— —

ruuniiA iuCOwG JJJR CU PC 2f1WUiuscq s:

bcuoqic uun!lA bAonl beL qopiL o bLcw!nw brXwciu ( uq lC x UIJG2 lpr 0ACW

qctci.uJiucq pA JJ!2 mcj1p 8 ipc pciuu!u o LG1LGWGU1 mp!cp mc cLOL lC 1uqiAqnJ mpo bnLcpc u uurulA uowiuJ cou2nwbflou lu ccy bcuoq 12

bLopp!jwc2

qcbcuq2 ou b9LsIJJcfcLa ot IJJC uqrA1qnJ njA nucpou uq jpc ITWC bqi ot woujuAPfll u 12 2!wb!c LflJC ly1 uqAqn1rJ2 unp cuijjA iwbjcwcur jyc obiwj uijc iii cucwobpw9j LIIJC OL COU2I1UJTII jxcq 2IOCJ O MG9Jq1 ni lye bLczcucc o woi.wjiA nuccumuO

CJCflJP0U2 IJJI 2C1 lye [X ISIC 10 GLO JJJC cou2nwbpoU WIG qc2cupcq pGLC 12 U01 (pG

1CJ IIUCLG2I U1(C2 9uq !13U1!OU L(C2 Hi OflL CJCfljOU2 PGIOM 9uq MC 9120 bLC2cul

jpc TUJOU uq l9i u qic 9wC u 91j bcuoqz MC cou2qcL i.uc o bo22ipJcMG 22flWG qJI (pG UOW!U91 HJICLGZI WIC (!) Gdfl9J2 (jiG ZflW 0j (jIG '91 !IUGL1 ISIC (L) uq

Page 28: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

:noiisup3 niwollo1 3d1 moi1 bnIl W .OQI

_________ = I + I)

i3q iuosq iiuims 3f11 nsdi idgii1 zi norJ5Iu313 21111 moñ niiIuwi lo 3Uhv 3111 isril 31014

.33s1q13*tsm 3111 in 3Idslisvs ILubs 315 isdi 231311oq tol isilob muim3lq

iiuruIs Isifls edi diiw beisi3ozs msetiE iithu beinuoib beieqxe edi etsqmo oT

eIdsq32-Ievtibbs vsr1 2lsubivibni 15113 emuzs ew noiiqo 1iunrw "enzw2ni-1Ie" e11i bus

:rrnol niwollo1 3113 lo 2noii3nlñ '3i!i1ii

(I-_1( )) t+I) + —

1)

10 eeeb euli oIs bus noiievs Izh 2'lsubivibni 3111 aenimte1b telemsisq 311T

euli d beisfl3b 21 wofl noiqmuzno3 Isnimon eriT .noitqmu2noo 111 llOliUili2dU2 Lsioqmstieini

.r+1) xbni e*iq

nolqmu2no3 lo mstia euft eiuqmo3 ew i21iI .eqei2 owl ui 2beeoIq nothsqmo3 mO

es gedesei oilw Isubivibni us tol 1i1iJu lo euLv beinuoeib 1113231q beiS!302Z5 edi bris

ie 3w) level rlilsew isiiiths us 1111w eisti2 noiisi3iunns eensw2ni-i1e edi euziuq bus

3113 ui U nr3siithve 10 iluzem ecu zi ii ;U d level iiliiu ziufi eloneb 3W .(I = ritisew emunoo 3111 niwolloI moil 211u2e1 isrti uiisq notqrnueno3 eull tol evods noi22elqxe

(VIUQaW) ô es is rlilsew 10 inuoms isdw lzs ew bnooe .elwz "3nsi3eqx3 eli! tevo

us niascthuq etew ed Ii U level iiliiu d353t 01 elds ed oi been bluow Isubivibni us niwol1o1 edi moiI hi3i!qmi tol bevloz ed use level dilsew 2idT .iiunns tisl llsrxsiiies

:noi225xqxe

'11\39H*6 El

— ))

* + l)*(

— I)

Page 29: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

Isubivibni its ioI nslq noilqmu2no3 1miiqo 3111 21 (1iUflfI5 1si ii 11hsu13s its fli2f131uI

311i ni .iniEflnu 31u1i11 z3rIio on bits (3mii3ui1 3i125113o12 £ sisi lnuooib oi £ 113kw

nollqmu2no3 lslimi2 13vi1s15I £ 21311o isbiano3 3W lsdi (liunns !.snimon iisl Ushsu13s

.5(10 (15(11 2231 3d 11kw VIUQ3W 15111 l3sqxs SW 1(153112

luods 2noilqmuzas ln31sThb owl lol 2no!151u3153 323(11 lb 211u23l 3111 zlnssiq V sldsT

3111 luods 2noiiqmu2as insisThb IKIsv32 ió1 bits ( = bits I = ) noiarsvs 1ah Isiibivibni

43111w 2n01161U3153 sasdT .asisi sn31313lq 3mil Isubivibni bits 23151 123131(11 1531 10 13v31

asiiiunns slsvnq lo 3253 sift iol (18Q1) 1sviq bits itoliIio)1 d bslnsasiq 320111 01 islirriia s alsiibivibni 15111 iasua asiliunns bsbivoiq-biIduq 10 sas 3(11 iol (V8QI) bisdduH bits

sasfl3luq 01 isbxo ni ilhIssw iisift lb 2noii3slI nsladua qu svi ol bsisqsiq sd bluoila

iol C 10 sIsi nokisflni its 111kw anoilslu3Iso xsl-siolsd 3(11 it! .esthurins iisI 1LsrIsIJl3s

lisili ni ô4 bits OC nsswlsd b noiJ3ubsl s lqszxs bluow alsubivibni 1SI11 bnil SW 31qff1sx3

sill sUaiUq (15(11 13(1151 asifliififls usi 11snstilss sasrl3luq 01 slds 313W 'sII1 Ii ) 3s Is 111153w

al osiol bluow algijbivibni Isift 111153w lb Inuoms sifT .

istia noiisiliuirns "bstuarii lisa"

no 11153 1153 '311l isili IrtiJist lb slsl 3(11 111 f1i2S5I33b bits fl01213V5 )I2rI iii1l fli 11i25S13f1I

.2insmiasvni (IWO 113113

luoilhiw aisbom s133slh1 31125(13012 bsfluiqrnia ni isrit l2su2 2n011SIu3L63 sasilT

323(13 Ii IiSVs asthunns 325d3Iuq bluode atcubivibni niimixsm-liIiJu asviiom l2SIJpsd

sldsT ni anibni1 3(11 i3Iqlslni 01 (5W snO .213s111103 usl IIsnsu1aa usd1 310(11 1203 213511(103

10 isIlob isq OV.O 1no bsbIsh( svods bslnsasiq 2(101151113153 VU3 3111 Ii RSVS isril ak V

01 tslsiq Ilila bluow 31311 bslsbom saodi as rbua 2331151318Iq 41kw sIqo3q 1nsrnsq muimslq

.ibizn03 SW Isdi 3VLtSfl13l15 "33flSlIJ2fli-1132" sill f1D1s313bnU 2U213V 3iunns sill sasd3mq

s41 lzii1 .anOass1 IsISVS2 tol vto1sto1qxs as bswsiv 3d bluoda 21101151113153 sasrlT

isrIi 2Ja3u2 stu1siIi1 Isiinsladua £ r1ijod1 fl3VS asvtlom lasuped 10 1i1idieaoq Sill 310fli

doue smoz lassi Is lb 33fl8231 sill illiw 1(131212(103 315 Isill asw ni vsild alsubivibni

Ion ai bsisbiano3 svsul sw 15111 sls11a iiunns s3nziuani-l1sa sill bnoos .asvilom

Iulgi3i1 3111 01 anoiludFLtn03 1113331 Iitsastqsi (QQI) misilliW bns (QQI) 13ta1J1 bns l3nhisJ8 (88Q1) kws11aisW bits IsdA .asibula isihss 03 283(1313131 sbivoiq bits asvilom 1asupd no

sill libom 01 boau 3d bluo3 15111 sviiom lzsupsd sill lb anoiis3fli3sqa svilsurtslls 221132ib

Page 30: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

3n3m31ri31 riioomz llmuiqo oi nid ai oriw Isubivibni ns iol i1oq 1miiqo 3rb 1hn iiigim 2n1q noriqmu2no3 3vm311A .ium iiunn ns oi zzx juodjiw noiiqmu2no3

.Aiow 31u1111 ni b3loIqx3 3d bIuo3 th bni VITJQ3W lo a3uIsv isdiif 33zisn

*ioW iuIu1 buB 2noiwbnoD .V

ain3mq lo 3u11W b3inuooib ffiiq bqx 3di no xi3biv3 2in3e1q 13qsq 2iIfT

Isubivibni ns n!ari3wq 10 32o3 rii oi 323113 zisqmo3 bni 2Jfl3mVq z3iailoq (3iunns lol

thJosq bI3vi13b oi1oq 3iunns SiVB rIi ifi ai nibnfl fJrIin33 3rlT .i3rjno3 (11unnE

513(13 13r1tiuI .?QI ni rnuim3lq iiunnii o isilob q 21n 8 bnfi 08 nw33d is b3uIsv

muim3lq o isilob iq aiuosq 11i ni 2l3btvolq iiunns 220135 1ii3f13Oi313f1 IsLlf!532dU2 asw

21uosq 1iunns 10 3u1Cv b3inuozib in323lq b 3X3 3113 isdi sxt3biv3 bniI 3W .in3msq nhub 2inioq Jin3313q JfIgi3 131smixoiqqs d b3assi3ni a&1 ?Jn3maq mrnmiq 03 3v11513T

iiijnns Lcubivibni 21sf13iuq thiin3ioq lo inioqbns12 311i molt 2uf1T .3bsb izsI oift

.os zu nJ nsrii sboi ai3ubolq 3v 1351335 siom 3d 03 Isqqs at3zIinoo

11300(112 03 3211 ns elsijbivibni 313111 2noliqo no noiismiolni nibivoiq oi noiiibbs ii!

iii 3215 isrll 2311221 lo 132 £ 03 insv3IsI 0215 21 fI3t&3231 mo if13m31 13! m noiqmu2noz)

',13(13T!u3 21 ifism iiunnJ3 Isubivibni rfi duoifi1A .3iIoq in3m3lui3i Isnoiisn nini23b b3n-isnoo 213AEm oi1oq bns 2-131131133231 moil 323 I3ifli ISllnBiedU2 b333Z1i15 asd ti ll5m2 311up

lo 2110122u32ib 311311113 lo 1dit nI .noiaivolq 3moorn in3m311331 lo m3i2(a n1vIov3 di (131w

3isvnq noiiudhino3 b311fl3b 01 1113n3d b3niI3b moi1 iIid2 dj bns uno1si ihu2 1si30

al3ubolq iiunns Isubivibni ni 123133n1 b325313111 3d sm 313(13 lsrli 333q2112 3W znsfq noi2n3q

111 33n5il31-u132 bns siofb lsijbivibni 110 ziaEuIqm3 i3iS3l 3351q abfl3li in3rIuD .311J1U1 3113 111

iiunns ljiubivibni io1 basm3b 3(13 3213313111 'sm atn3rnqol3v3b 32311T .1n3m51133i tol ninns1q

ni b3isIurnu3os 2132zs lo noLIs!umiJ33b Isrnuiqo lo 2m3Idotq 3111 lnoItnoa 235n131 as atouboiq

.2n5!q 1n3m511131 2IJOflSV

nhiszJLsv3 tol instioqmi oals 315 31311 b33n3231q 320111 as 113112 2no11s11J3I133 noiisiilsV

13 2! n-tui ni eif1T .231111111115 Isubivibni 101 33*!Em 3111 111 fl01133132 3213VbJi 1o in3ix3 3(11

.3VOdIi b3i113231q ZflOIJJihJ3lB3

Page 31: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

fioüb 3n3vini bfuod in3mfn3vo 3rfi l3rti3dw rnb1g5I 3i&bb iIoq 3th m noii13bino3

w m31ev thu IiQo inu3 ,rIi 10 tIsq Ii Iooq yliufUifi IJf1OthUT £ 3icbnm bus

nE 3bivolq zfluzi dT .(Q! 51IT m3i2 f1vE 3isvnq yioisbnsm £ d b&s1q31

£ us3d noiius diiw bw3iv d bluonk 'di duorti1 zi Lsns efrfi iol iuqni lrisfloqmi

bus iiiunns niass1zxwq zisubivibul lo i 3th 13i15 bfuo3 obuiinsm 2infi b nsd3 '3i1oq

.i3uboq 3d1 10 gniahq 3di i3iIs 31o1i3th

instioqmi izom 3dT .otsi tuiu1 iol 2noiJa3up lo l3dmun £ isi znibnfl mO

Jn3Iq b3iqx3 3th nwd IRiin311ib 3di 10 noilsnsIqx3 3d1 1dsdrnq i uai nibnstiuo

sont3Thb emiT .a3i3iIoq 328th iol emuim5rq 8th bus thJozq iiunns lo 3IJISV b3inuo3eib

iuO .ziauboiq iiunns 13110 isrti e3inJ$qmoo wiueni di no 28xst oi 9ub 1iisq 3d sm 28iiiunns lo 3u1.Sv 3vri5151 3di no esxs 13v31-jnslrnnns lo iooII3 3d1 bxinoooi esul eie1sns

13v31 3iEloqlo3 8th ts e3xst woil nislqx3 oi b3hJ Ion asd ii lud oubo1q !si3nsnlI l3tho bus

bus muim3lq nwj,d 1siin3Thb th lo noinoq 131lJonA .28iiiLJnns 10 ni3rIq uIi 133115

ol b3iv3I g1Er13 to bso1 nsqmo onsiueni 8th 01 8IdstudiIfls ci wofl 1113n3d binuocib

nsqmo3-oi-nBqmo3 3d 'sm 313dT .ii1idsifloiq Isurrton bus 21203 noifl3tiainimbs 18V03

3fli33qe lo 3vi133fl31 noiishsv muim3lq mtfl-ezoio 8th nbIsm niihvrnbnu ni a33n31311ib

8th IsrIl 1351 3d1 2e3!3f!13no4 .31u1q53 L!u1 Ion 28ob noib3noo 11513vo mo isth z!ooq )1211

Iiunns 8th ni 2n0iih3qrni lsiin3ioq 15th 2iz3uz 3mJ ivo b3rleinimib asnl IsiIn3l3Thb

.Ihsm risiuani esbo1 ni b8isun3fls 3d sm os 28bso3b owl lo 228r1i2Ud

3IJlsv bus gni3hq 8th l3bienIo3 ol eiaLsns emil bn31x3 11u132u bhioo 113153251 5IuiLJ'I

quo 10 32iukIuq 8th ui in3l3ulni ni1ooq Iah 8th 10 32us3I .alzwbolq 1iunns quoi 10

ni noii33I3c 3218vb5 228! 3d ol I3Ai1 21 313th bnu1 noien3q £ iiuoin1i 3!qmsx3 lot fe3iiiunns

ol 133qx3 bluow w 33n3H .Ihsm 1iunns !iwbivibni 8th flI risdi 1Aism quoi 8th

8th iol aieo3 rnuim3lq bus e3uIsv b8inuo3zib in3zsIq b3133qx3 3111 n3ewl3d 233n31311!b 131151112

3110 .1hsm IiunnE lsubivibrii 8th 111 bnuol 3W nsi1i 21fl1iUflf1E quo iol bus noi1sluqoq

1133(1 1Lhoieiu! a&f i3iLSm 1iunns [subivibni 8th ni 3lulisl 13*Ism 101 fsiin3ioq 3riT bnornsiU .smoorn ln3mslLIsI lo noieivoiq 1n31nrn3vo -tol cnoas r1I lo no es b33ntsvbs

enoj3sl3ini th 1o ie1ns Isrniol £ c8bivolq (8QI) I3dA ;uzzi dull 232cucib (VVQI) .213)hsm iiunns 3lsvrIq bus errisoiq 1n3m311131 3ilduq n33wiad

Page 32: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

0€

3di no £ib b ndE 3rb i 1s!wn iiunn quoi di nIcns ni iJ1u3flhib Is-IJn3 3r1i lo

.z313iloq Jiunn quoig ioI 33nq in3mJ3

l3rtio bn Ith 3bu13n1 oi ziv1.snE mo bnsqx ol hñqbd 3d 0216 bluow ii

idJ b3mu2z 13viJ1i13 3vñ W .I1.s13n iom aoilothoq bIori3wort 10 2in3noqmo3

i&li bnE rtin3! i! 16ubivibni no 16noiiibno3 nat133 i3iino3 3iunn n mon thJoq iiiL6up-M3mi23vth io a3iihIJ viuaiT z daua a1a6 ab!th 1no zb!od Isubivibni 3di

0216 oifoThoq a'16ubivibni 3d3 II .j3jno3 iiunn as oi aviism3ith z 2bnod 1s1oqio3

ni2Efbwq nwd nothl3qmo3 3di n3rli iiiup3 ioq-io3 zs dou2 aiiFm Lah a3buI3ni

3dT .in3a8lq w no 3di moil l3ilib m 2i2s Isiaasnfl l3dio nibIod bifE iiunns us

-1! ti bus Jiunns 3Idshsv £ rliiw b £i30225 ms3iia iuosq 3111 nwi3d noarisqmo

tY .iloq3i 3w nozrisqmoo uf1 molt l3Ttib oafs bfuow 31311 b3l3bianoo "(iiuflh1S 33(W1u2n1

agrisc1o 01 befni! 2bI3i 111kw abnod 10 noiiouboilni 103331 3uft molt aahs (1ix31q(fl03 131110115

lo noiJuboiini 3111 01 bs1 sm "zbnod b3x3bni" z3r1T .x3bnl hq i3muarIoD 3111 ui

oats bluow au11 ;aiuosq Isnimon boxfl nsdi idJsi aiuosq 1si b3xfl ulliw 213511003 1iunns

lnfthoqmi n33d 3vsd 313111 11sni1 .rIoq3l w ano 3r11 rtsrli anoahsqmoo 1n313Thb 3vlovni

.b3siiiunns is oiuoai 1n3m31ii Isubivibni rloidw 01 1031x3 3111 ui 3m1 r1uoiufi 2311sfI3

biswol bn5U 1SW-laoq £ n33d as11 13r1J Isill 3v1ado (QQ1) 113W bits JtoLibo)1 rbsd13uA

aiuosq noian3q ifln3d b3nihb 1hu32 1si3o as 1i3b13 3111 to noiisiiiurins R1253i3fli

mi3drri3fl .aiuoa3i ,iuJi to noii3si1 £ 25 nwoi 3vSrl 3isoib3M b 3ulsv 3oasiuani 3111 bus

as ni 111163w 113111 lo anoiiazit 13ffuf 111kw ablod3auoll isdi 3303b1v3 moa abnit (IQ!) rbua tuodjiw ao11J isdi bus &ngiuzni 31i1 iom bnsm3b uriol "bi1iunns 11s1rI31x8"

i3dfluI lo 9ulsv 3113 nis1snA .z3iiiunns Isubivibni blorl 01 (13)liI 3lom 315 noi1siiuJnns

131211511 1n3mm3vo r1uoir1i noiisiiiunns lsiinsiadue lo oonaiq 3111 11k noiixiiiunns

.31J2IUq 01 fIOiZfl3iX3 Isiuiisn 131110115 21 amsioiq

Page 33: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

1€

aDagaJ2M "noii1 13vbA rijiw miJ31iJ nistinU bn noiiE1umuA IsiiqsD .a .w3ibnA dA

.VQO!-QVOI :(ô8Q! dfn3.tq3) 4 £3rti3mono3a

moñ a1iznI :niviO to ot 3d3 lo noi flio3q" .12wsdW hiM bnE w5IbnA I3dA

.QM-?.M (88!) OV 23ii2riEJ briE z3imono3 to wivSI ".miiriJ!A

:.D.U noiniriasW .1oo8 33E"I niuznI tiJ Q1 .nswznI 1iJ no li3nuoD n&*imA

.ÔQQI IJDA "noi1s1umuA thIcW briE iithioM ln3I3TliU" z,noH .W isliH briE oissiO oizsnsiiA

.QI M R .o14 1E nbhoW $1IflM

lo noii&thiunnA niasionI 3rIT" ji3W bivEU briE oAi11oX xniu&J ,

.t ni1A rI3Eth3uA

iilsup3nI 21312nBiT IsnoiEl3n3gI3inI iol anoiiB3ilqml bEn 3ismhi3 :h3bIa 3di

QQ I idoiO ,

8 I 1 qsq nbhoW $1E1814 H gniv IsnoitEM bris

nihrnA briE rizi1n3 10 vidiJ hu03IEH rfT .ii1idiri briE 1I .3nE1 R3i1JA

.QI nI bhoW briE 3Ia tiuoxuH :hoY w*t .QI .b 23i22SID

iA ihu3 Isi3o biinU 3rb iol IdET 1iJ" zoD 2 briE bI$W .A I llfl 31li lo fl1O noiJsiiinimbA ihu2 IEioo VOI .oM bui2 Ithsui3A "O8O - OOQI

.QQI 1zuiiA (tEui3A

.V-V QI l3doi3O (OI) (mLrIo naiunI dT "uI enuJs5J Isio3q" .b3 .t 11i138

lo ismi no ba&*I n3biva cviioM iupfl 31A noIi woH" ai$IuoU .fl miuIrnH

QQ mono JijiIp3 Ip thrrnot z3iiiIJrrnA briE nIu2nI 1iJ iol bnEmU 311i

.VQ-QQ8 (IQQI 13doO)

3r1i lo no 3B2fIE1T "nizU ift3n tiunnA 3IdsriEV iii viiEm3iIA" ,.H nutot gifl SI -Qt (QôQI dmvoM) I hsij1aA lo 'i3i3o

lEirtuot knu iiunnA lo nimiT di briE noi1u1o5I tnihonU" .ijA irnvEiLrIfl

QQI) O? imono33 3iIduI lo :tM 1uiD boow3In3 .I ristunI 1iJ .13qqb( .U b1oiH briE .IL [ft3flfl3N *1fl

.4QQI jIH jj1q fIgiH lo 2i3&t13 rIT :viiwbnl nIu2nI 311J f1i lo nOIjEXET isi .iiEM o1liJa)

.ÔQQI oimono33 TIM omiM ".riiwoiO miiI no Z3XET 1oiEi1Ji3$I briE oii23rnoU

Page 34: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

if

noq3$L" noiiuIsV 3iunnA IRubivibnl iol izfl iilafloM wM £ bnmmoSI oi flimmoD

18Q1 ziIs1fl3A 10 t3i3o2 3di 10 2flOIi3I2flElT 1dsT 8Q1 di b noiisvh3cl)

.RV - VÔ

3lIduq lo Isrnuot iz1nA 1hu tko2 iol how3mI ATM 1'Q1 .A 1j3q bnomiñU

.8Q-V :8 a3unono33

thi3o V8 .014 sbifl Iahu33A - OOQI :zt b3iinU 3di iol z3ldsT 311JTM .t id1 .8Q1 vIEui3A 3d1 lo ft1O ,noiiiniainicnbA thu

1i ni 1oivBr1fl nivs bns zWI VfiUIUIAM .kwirfW *uM bn nifnnH nsmb3h1

U fIi fli Eflo12ng iW .U bns n3vorI .1 ibofl .S nI biinU

.VV- .q<I .88Q1 25111 osii1D lo 1i21vinU :oE3ifID .monoo3

iol 2noiis3ilqmI :2iiiunnA 10 izoD IT .I2wsII2wW AisM bnB nImc13a nsmb3h1

suwid1 ,

1) 0I eimono lo 1mijot h3tIEuO .

"iupH bn ioivsd niv .41-1 :(OQQI

3iibmmI Isubivibnl l3bnU iiIstioM :tioq3$ITM thimrnoD 3onhqx3 jiunnA lEljbivibnl

ôV1 nwi1 iiiunnA b31-z13U b3luiBM 3rnoonl uiJ aiiiunnA - 1ioq5I -1QQ1 :huiA 10 v)i3o rIi lo 2noiinz1T "a8h13vinnA ô8Q1

.1 I

&boa . ii! ."nivs Isubivibnl bilE anoiznq z3rnii1iJ ninU .nn1D .51 biscJduH

lo Y)i2I3wnU :oizID .aimopo33 noiuWi ni 2uazI , .tho iW .U bits n3vorI2 .t

.ô0-V1 .q11 .V8QI 2q ogiiID

"IdsT jiIthoM iiunnA Isubivibnl €8Q1 10 3sup3bA 1o w3iv8SPe .51 nznsrioI

- 101 ôQQI V4 ,hsui3A lo 1i3oe di 1o 2n0133521151T

• "i*isM 2&iiunnA 3i3Iqmo3nI its s Iim&1 r1T .1sviq sivA bits .t 33n51u&1 11oIi1io)1

* I C-V€ : (1 8Q1 thqA) Q8 mono L&iji1oq lo Isinuot

-AAIT 10 bui A :m2iIrlJIA no nbiv3 wW ôQ1 13i2ut zsmodT .1 bits nilot niisJ .80Q-8 :ô8 w3iv51 3imono33 na*13mA 2Iii35i 3S1D

v)iunrzA •

"aiA bits e,1s2 - biisM iiunnA Isubivibni QQI IT .LsnoiJiurl3inl ASIMJJ

•ÔQQI Iut .IsnoiiscninI ASIMLJ :bioltisH .Ib1s3a351

oT :313D &tIJ di lo bn3 8d1 2blswoT noiJso1IA i2A IsmiiqO" •A 3rI2oM 12vthM

Page 35: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

[.QI asniwfl lo 1ootb iivinTJ A toY o9mim H iJiunnA oi ioi4 to iiiuctnA

3imono3oi3o nwifl 3i1&floM ni sthsqiU ftIeE13nI 3dT" QQI Js i .O sqqs Q 3rn3thM lo Ismuot bns1n3 wM "8Q1 bits OèQI Ist2 b3iinU 3dt flu quoiD

.QO1-€O1 8 1ut ) iqs nbhoW 5LELHM ".eist b3iinU 3rii ni ziiiunnA lo vioiaiH dT .M zmst sd13to

.VQI d3isM

nA :zi*tsM onswznI viii33qmoD flu rnuhdiiupH sJi1ii .t bits 1sibiM bIiibdioM

3imono3 to Isrrtuot htuwQ nolisrirtolnl 133u13qm1 lo 23imono3H di no sza - Qô VQI 1dm3voM OQ

3111 03 ttoqM lsnil .($lIT) znivs 3n3m31i3351 bits 3mo3nI iii zbniT no i3nsq !s3infIoT

ivi2 nsmuH bits rIi1sH lo ln8rntIsq3U U ji3nuoD ioivbA 3hu3 thi3o

.(vo.szz.www is 3IdsIiiwA) .Q1 cfm&U i13 .nsiuanI bits In3msnsM Ai5I QQ! novsiwD zibns bits mst nnsmthhT

.(nuf12i1duq 31!oD m3ia3W r1Juo :HO iisnni3niD) noiiibd

iiunnA bits ris'iunI 311J 10 in3rnls3lT xT OQQ1 ofl1O niinuoA 1svrI3D 2.U .(it1O niinuooA 1g13n30 2.U :noinii1zsW) .123133n1 b3LrIxA

bits 1a151 10 Irwot "ii bJinTJ 3cU iii i3I1sM iiunnA thqM .8-8R :(88Q1 13dm31q8) () 3ons1uriI

3113 nu1z3T :njrns3 'ali3H lo iT1 iii bits ioivgiH iup3H" ôQ1 FtsM mI3r11iW

.84V8 :ô8 w3iv$! 3imono33 ns3i-t3mA "aiup3fl lo bboM 3i1iLrxi1A

ik "noijz3I3 313vbA riiiw aioAisM iii muhdiliupH 10 iu1sk1 311T" O81 zhsdD no1iW

.OEI-801 :(rthq) 11 3OflO lo Isinuot

Page 36: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

QQ! bn A a joq 1iunnA ib3mmI :1 sIdT

V A à A

:33vA .z3iciqmoD hA

.OI 1QV n3M

VI.V n3moW

4QV 81'.ô 8V2 iovivw bns Iniot

:zivA .zuo! idiH flT V.8 8f.V n3M

oV.V 88. n3moW

O.8 VO.F iovisnu bn iniot

:i3vA .thjosq iawoJ nT 8Q2 n3M

n3moW

! 2 ioviv-iu bnB iniol

:ivA .errniI b3i$L 323rIiH vin3wT

8V.V n3M

VO.V n3rnoW

8.V ioviviu bn Iniot

:zivA .errni! v)iunrtA igi&1 nT 8QV n3M

I.V nmoW

QV.V ioviviu bits iniot

(i z31sibni 11n3 11353 2QQ! 1ut wiv35J '3a ni bobivoiq sisb iuosq JiunnA :33uo £ lo esli3mq 3111 no b3zsd asd31uq iiunns [sijini lo OOO! iq ish1ob ni 3fno3ni hcfinom i hq 325113wq OOOOO1 311T .(3i1oq iiunns 31i1 3lsib8mmi nuJim5Iq 31ni OOOOOI

.xsi muim5Iq iiunns rsi buI3x3 lud 2331 3i1oq lo 3viwI3ni

Page 37: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

ujoz.uA ISC2 ill WIPCL wU 000 ___________bLoqnccq o qic ocietA o yuunA yyJ &o1cci q1ncq o icjccqw,uLua we vcmn.A jJG ccouq CO1UJU ! qI2MU I.OW WOL1!1A wpie2o: Jjic U cojnwu i pcq ou nubnpjpeq WPflJ9OU2 bLoAIqGq pA pc 2oc!I cni4iA

sooioo

JXÔR 1?8't

101I

80

o•1J.8 hRTT4

MoWu

T0 804100 10I 51Q0

LX10

4Q11R 188

HRcu:

cuqc uq yc Gcucwi bobnjou r'c Jp1c1&10r!c

'up C0P014JJG OL

V1J'3"!'U

jpje : cucwj bobnJIou uq vuw UI WoLIJTIA jc (JcL JØOO bcL2ou boo

Page 38: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

3MST 3IiJ noi11uqo gthzlJ ?Q! ijlloU muim5lq iq u1sV 1iunnA : 3!dT

JsioqioD 3vIUD bI3iY

i-'K wasT

vujD bl3iY ioqioD

3vwD bI3iY

t o\I1 wsiT

3v1u bI3iY

:n3M

VV. 8. 88. oV. 118. V. !8. àgA CV. €8V. NV. VQV. ev

nmoW

IQV. 088. C4V. ?A8. 3A 8V. 48. Q8. QV. 8V. &8. V A

QV. Q88. I,V.

:ioviviu2

08.

bns iniot

?.3A QV. 88. 0V. 118. ô WV. ô48. ôV. 18. V A

13q aiuoq iiijnn th o 3u1cv b3inuoib 1f1231q b3133qx 31ft 2woli vlin3 13B :a3ioM 1iiinns ivs 3Iqfn2 nsqmo Its 31ft 3w afIOdEIu3ts3 11A .muim3lq flunI1E b isllob .i3sno3 iiuniis tsijbivibni rlliw b3tsi3ow zin3msq lo msoii fft 3tsmri3 oi z3iaT iuoq

Page 39: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

JSC2 O c21 wc jpc 211cw o, bAUJCU nocq Mi uqAqrtJ uurnA couii.civqojfi. o uun!O bLcw!nur yjj c9'JcfljOu if2C IpC 9j COwbIJA awbjc AG12C uuniA bAonio: cp cup.A 2poii qic ccbcctq bI.GcIU qiconuq AJflC o tpc uuni bXon bcL

oooVG Q

iOtu ug 2nLAIA0C

vc .gJv Q

8ô!

vc ?2 .8

jqq crn.!JLcI2nLA

AG!q crn.iCotho

i'iq cn'.'jLc12nLA

jqq CnIJCCoLbo

BS\0. ucuo '-Jpr 4: VU1JUI /.JJflG2 bCL bLCUJIITW D°IJ 1' fla!tJ V'J"!('U r!G J)cpjc

Page 40: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

8

ô A n3M ioI b5IflO aj3i1oq 3iunnA 10 (QQ1) illoU muim31 iq u1sV : 1dT

1sioqioD iopoD vwD b1iY 3vluD b!3iY 3vUJD b1iY 3viuD bIoiY

:231dT S1iJ noiiaIugo niU

ôV. MS. V. 18. i1qms2 HA vA 818. 188. 18. Q8. iH n3T

Z1uo6q

IOV. V. 8V. 1210W nT 21uo\q

V. 818. ô4V. 08. 1egi&J n3T ZfffliI (JflJflflA

108. VV. QQV. in3wT 2f1TIII iJ$L-i238

:IdsT 1iJ iniiunnA ni2U

C8. VQ. 8. IQ. 3Iqmi2 hA

€Q. 0O. I 0Q. ôO0. I i2 nT

IQV. c8. V. t8. 1210W n3T anJoE

V8. 1Q. Q8. 1Q. 1231s.J n3T 2uTfl1T iiunnA

Q8. 1Q Q08. 8Q8. 1n3wT 2m1i1 b3iJ$I-123fl

ish!ob iq aiuoq 1iunn rIi lo uIsv b3lnuo32ib 1ne1q b1o3qx3 34J 2WOff2 1crin ff3th :2104 .mu!m8lq '1IUnII lo

Page 41: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

Q-8QI -- A nM io1 b3i3I1O z3i3i1o iiunciA 10 iilloU muimi iq uLsV :ô 3ldsT

0gg oçioD

viuD bI3iY uzaiT

3vwD bbiY izioqioD

3vwD bI3iY iuzsT

3vw b!iY

OV. VV. oV.

4V. 18. M8.

VV. ô4V. 'JV.

:afdT 11J noiiBlugog niU

M8. ô18.

8Q! OQQI

QQI

OQV.

ô8. 8. ?ô8. ôQ. V.

O1V.

88. ?8.

:23IdsT 1iJ irwilunnA niU

V8. IQ. 1Q.

8Q! OQQI

Q! 3iunn 10 i11ob iq iuosq 1iunrw lo 3uIsv binuoib 1niq rfi wod ehin HA :ioM

31i! noiisluqoq dT .3a61131uq iiunru 3iRib3mmi muim31q-ni OOOOO1 s nunuz muim31q 33mb noiitiinimbA thu3 Isi3o borlailduqnu no b3asd 31B noii1u31 3d1 ni113bnu 3IdEi

Isubivibnl V! rit lo noiIjoiq wo no bd z1dii 31i! iniiunrw 311T isuioA 3(Ii 10 gnimuas bort1m (88Q1) 2kwEr1W no b3asd 2noibo1q diiw 1dii i1stioM insiiunnA

n012U13x3 311i !qqs 2noiisIu3Is3 x,fl-1311s 8QI 3dT .zin3m3vcnqmi 1ilhtiom -oi- inElZno3 boh3q iuoq fJ 10 ninnid rIi ii b3vi1 odi 1no rwrtJ 13rbs1 ziuosq 1iunrw us 01 oiisi

3r11 ni b3dhz3b 21 cioidw wf xsi QQ! 3d1 bns w1 xsi 8QI rIi n33wi3d 233n313Thb 1o u3d .iX31

Page 42: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

JJG pjc LOL WGU pow JU J3Ø i nacq JOL 9JJ C9!CflIOU2uq tG li2lccroLA oJ cou2nwb1ou IIUqGL tpc J—!un!.ucc, uurniA nnwbjou jpc y COOI4bSI.UJCICL L qCuofC2 1}JC LWJ !ULC2t MJJ!CJJ qC1GLwUC poq JJC CUTLJJA 1L U1Jfl!IA biAonqJAiqcq pA LGWU!U jqc cxbccucA jpc uJOu L91C !2 xcq 91 .L*!OO bcixut bCL Acv jpcIi 01. 11Ufl! 91!0U C0U2flWb1!0U CP bCUO1 !2 ° MC9JqJ

(j —)*Q +b)=+

(

cxp!pi iiuic-cbwpj nipiA flUC0U2 o ipc oun:bnLcp 2!u1G-bLcw!nw !wwcq191c ""! MIIJJ 1XG U0W!U9j bAont uqiqnTflflWG fy91 iuqiAiqrl9J2 psic cc fO u CffT149JJA L uuniiA w9qGi tu Mp!CJJ pA cuip onjq p LcdrnLcq to cpGA jcicj o cxbGctcxj jij.cnwc nfH!1A vii cjcrijiouwoic: cp cutLA uqc1c2 c isjnc o uuncq nctz I.fc1ou o uou--uuri q

= =I. = = 0J

= == 0 = OJ 804

=

L Ø' k =L = = 01L = = Ø3I. = = 01 QX3 4O

=

A91IT = I = = I =JLS!UJGfL u. N'-1'T1: C'\°

jpjc : jcjp Ednh1Jcucc, cticcu uunticq 9uq ou-uuntcq ct

40

Page 43: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

31IJiaini ml3T iH m2U Q1 11oU muim,iq iq u1zV 3iurrnA :1-A oIdJ3T

%u i-K AItfl Y-O iY-01

ioqioD waiT usT nu*

AA Y-0 1sioqioD

ici\ Y-O1 iuzT

EIJflAT NIJ I4OITAJUO :n3M

ô8V. 8. 8ô8. V. 148. ô8. Z ôôç. 18. 88. 8EV. !8. 8. ô 84V. 8V. OQF. CLV. 8QF. Q08. V A

n3cnoW 408. QV8. VQ8. 4ÔV. O8. 0V8.

VQV. ô8. 0V8. 4ÔV. 8. 8. ô 4.08. V48. V8. 8V. VE8. 08. V A

:ioviviu bas iniot

ô08. V88. 0Q. 18. VV8.

O8. 0V8. 88. IVV. 848. ô8. ô A 008. 848. 88. VVV. M8. O8. V A

LI8AT 311J ThATIiJT4MA :jjj

28. €.€Q. Q. 818. OIQ. .EQ. ?2 A ôô8. 0€Q. 44Q. 48. !4Q. ô 8ô8. £IQ. 1Q. ôô8. ôQ. 04Q. V 3A

:nmoW R8. ôQ. Q. 008. ôQ8. QIQ. 1ô8. QQ. 4.Q. 818. Q8. QIQ.

0V8. O. 1Q. VOQ 1Q. V A :oviviu bna iniot

V8. F&Q. Q4Q. 4'8V. €88. 80Q.

ô8. 1€Q. 84Q. 018. VQ8. 81Q.

Qô8. Q. 8€Q. V€8. ÔOQ. V A isilob iq thIosq JiiJnn di 10 3u1sv bJnuoib iniq b3Jqx3 3th 2wod (iin tbH :1o4

oi in Woq iiunnE Bt3v 1qmsz nsqmo Its 3di u noiJz1uo1s3 hA .muirn3lq iiunns 10 .ai3s1in03 iiunnj tsubivibni rhiw boisi3ozs 2ifl3fflsEq 10 IIU$5U2 311i 31Sm1J3

Page 44: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

?ô 3A n3M ioI b3flO kioi 1iunnA lo iallocl muirn1 iq zu1W :-A 3kiT 51u33u132 nn3T iH nizU 31u$1 QQ1-8Q1

AA Y-O1 t

AA iY-OI isioqioD iuzsiT wzT oqioD wzT 'wT

:1dsT 1iJ noii1ugo niU

EOV. 8àV. Q8Ô. V. VÔV. 8Q1 V. ô08. Q08. 18. 118. OQQI

ÔV. ô18. 88. VV. O8. 4C8. Q1

:zeldaT ,1U iniiunnA nkU

ô8V. F8. V8. V. 448. 8I Q18. 81Q. OQ. V8. 80Q. IIQ OQI ô8. 44Q. U.8. IQ. O1'Q.

1iunns b lEllob iq z1uoq iiunnE 1o 3uIsv binuooaib in3e1q rti wori hin3 hA :aio14 3111 noriIijqoq 311T .3ackYwq iiunn 3iib3mmi mu!m31q-31ni OOOOO1 £ nimua mUiffl31q

fl1O noiiIi2inimbA thu3 1si3o b1aiIduqnu no bsd noiis1u31s 3di nih3bnu 3IdE Isubivibnl VQ1 3th lo noiiioiq iuo no bid z1thJ 31i1 ifl5iiunnB 3111' £151) 15Ui3A 3111 lo

nimu2aR bortI3m (88Q1) 2'1ews1InW no b3asd 2noiioiq rtiiw 31dsi 1ithtioM insiiunnA .2in3fn3volqmi (1i!stIom 153 i-u33 lnSt2noo

Page 45: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

r eiuR

emiT

ie

vO

nem

ys

mui

mei

q yi

iunn

A

quoi

bn

s IB

ubiv

ibni

0000

Q

0000

8

0000

0000

8

oooo

a

0 00

00

000C

C

0000

oooo

r

0

S

elds

T

e)

sd,g

toq

:eoi

uo2

[7M

) iu

nnA

.vib

nI

(M)

ViiU

I1I1

A

qi

CO

C

O

-1

CU

C

O

- (0

-1

C

U

CO

C

O

.1

CU

-1

(0

-1

C

U

CO

0)

C

U

CU

C

U

CU

C

U

(0<

0(0(

0<0(

0<0<

0 C

O

(0(0

(0<

0(0(

0<0<

0<0<

0(0<

0<0

iseY

Page 46: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

0000

a)000

Co000

teer noiIIiH

C-000

CO000

Co000

4000

Cj)CD00

C/i000

000 00

0

C')0

a)

-I

4-0)0)CD

IT0)7-a)4-

Va)0

r0I> itCc ><

.10 -- eI— a)a)

a)(C)

WIC/i a)

CoCO

z

C)

CC

>,C')Ca

C)C')

IT0)

c/I

a)CoCo

CO I- a)aDa)

0>C)I-

I—

EC)

a; a,a,0 ,-

0)a)

ij 0)a)01

.I

C/I I-

0)0,C)

4

0 (C)

Page 47: 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 1'1EI1 EAIDEI4CE O IHE OI'1EA2 4BEK RiOKKIWJ bVbEI 2EffIE2. w*f 33n3biv3 no f1i noM rihoW lo IBubivibill iiiunnA 131vi10

U-10C-

C-)a)

a)

50

52

Vãe Ot VUUflf9Ufu- OPU2 8D8182 8p-ao

E!ALC 3

U

DfLPflOU O de ot VUU11IUf8 bflLCP!Li 2bIV !U aa