2010 - nye - philippine political economy

8/10/2019 2010 - Nye - Philippine Political Economy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2010-nye-philippine-political-economy 1/21

"#$% &' (' )*+ ,- ./#0+--#/ #0 12#%#3,2- 4%5 6/757/,2 84-9,49 ($4,/ ,% .#:,9,24: 12#%#3* 49 ;+#/<+=4-#% >%,?+/-,9*'

Asian Development Review, ?#:' @AB %#' CB DD' C@C E @FCC G-,4% H+?+:#D3+%9 84%I

J4I,%< K%-9,9L9,#%- M+/,#L-:*NO+9$,%I,%< 9$+ .#:,9,24: 12#%#3*#0 H+?+:#D3+%9 ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-

"PQ) &' (' ) R1

H+-D,9+ 9$+ 2L//+%9 04-$,#% 0#/ ,--L+- -L2$ 4- ,%-9,9L9,#%4: 9/4%-D4/+%2* #/2#//LD9,#%B 9$+ 3#5+/% D#:,2* 5+?+:#D3+%9 :,9+/49L/+ 5#+- 9## :,99:+ 9#,%9+</49+ 9$+ 2#/+ ,5+4- #0 3#5+/% D#:,9,24: +2#%#3* S,9$ -94%54/5 +2#%#3,29$+#/*' T,99:+ ,- 5#%+ 9# 5,-9,%<L,-$ 9$+ 45?,2+ <,?+% 9# 5+?+:#D,%<2#L%9/,+- +-D+2,4::* #% 342/#+2#%#3,2 4<</+<49+- 0/#3 9$49 <,?+% 9#/,2$+/ %49,#%- S,9$ -9/#%<+/ ,%-9,9L9,#%4: +%?,/#%3+%9-' J$+ +--4* L-+- 9$+.$,:,DD,%+- 4- 4 24-+ -9L5* 9# -L<<+-9 S$49 ,- S/#%< S,9$ :+45,%<

D/+-2/,D9,#%-' K9 -L<<+-9- 4 0/43+S#/I 9$49 -94/9- 0/#3 4 U4-,2 4%4:*-,- #0-+29#/4: 5,-9#/9,#%- 9# ,5+%9,0* 9$+ 4/+4- S$+/+ ,5+4: /+0#/3- 4/+ :,I+:* 9# $4?+9$+ 3#-9 ,3D429 4%5 9$+% D4,/- -L2$ 4%4:*-,- S,9$ 3#/+ ,%-9,9L9,#%4::*2#%-,-9+%9 2#%-,5+/49,#%- 9# -++ S$,2$ -+2#%5 U+-9 /+0#/3- 4/+ 3#-9 :,I+:* 9#

U+ ,3D:+3+%9+5' J$+ 0#2L- -$#L:5 U+ #% ,%2+%9,?+ 2#3D49,U:+B -+:0V+%0#/2,%< D#:,2* 3+2$4%,-3- S$,2$ L-L4::* ,3D:* </+49+/ 34/I+9 422+-- 4%5

5+2+%9/4:,W+5 2#3D+9,9,#%'

JEL classification: PCFB PXYB PZY

I. INTRODUCTION

J$+ /,-+ #0 9$+ %+S ,%-9,9L9,#%4: +2#%#3,2- $4- 5#%+ 3L2$ 9# /+?,94:,W+9$,%I,%< #% 9$+ /#:+ #0 <#?+/%4%2+B -9/L29L/+B 4%5 D#:,2* ,% D/#3#9,%< #/$,%5+/,%< +2#%#3,2 5+?+:#D3+%9' K% D4/9,2L:4/ 9$+ S#/I #0 )#U+: :4L/+49+-

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

8L9 S$49 $4?+ S+ /+4::* :+4/%+5 4U#L9 ,%-9,9L9,#%-B 4%5 $#S 5# S+

/+2#%2,:+ 9$,- S,9$ 9$+ 2#/+ :+--#%- #0 %+#2:4--,24: 9$+#/* 9$49 -$#L:5 -9,:: -+/?+ 4-



@ G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

-94/9,%< D#,%9- 0#/ 4%* 5,-2L--,#% #0 L%5+/D+/0#/3,%< +2#%#3,+- 4%5 9$+ _L+-9 9#

+%2#L/4<+ </#S9$`J$,- D4D+/ /+?,+S- -#3+ #0 9$+ 3#-9 -4:,+%9 ,5+4- #0 9$+ %+S ,%-9,9L9,#%4:+2#%#3,2- 4%5 5,-2L--+- $#S 9$+-+ ,5+4- 24% U+ ,%9+/429+5 S,9$ 3#/+ -94%54/5%+#2:4--,24: 2#%2+D9- 9# -+/?+ 4- 4 U4-+:,%+ 0#/ 0/43,%< D#:,2*' K9 4/<L+- 9$49-+%-,9,?,9* 9# ,%-9,9L9,#%4: 4%5 D#:,9,24: +2#%#3* 2#%2+/%- 5#+- %#9 ,%?4:,549+ 9$+2#/+ ,5+4- #0 %+#2:4--,24: 9$+#/* UL9 -$#L:5 2$4%<+ 9$+ S4* S+ 4%4:*W+ #L/#D9,#%-' K9 S,:: 9$+% L-+ 9$+ D/#U:+3 #0 /+0#/3 ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- 4- 4% +a43D:+ 9#-$#S $#S 3L2$ U4-,2 +2#%#3,2 4%4:*-,- ,- +,9$+/ 3,--,%< #/ %+<:+29+5 ,% 2L//+%95+U49+-' K9 -L<<+-9- S$+/+ S+ 3,<$9 -94/9 9# 0,%5 S$49 S+ -9,:: %++5 9# I%#S 9#34I+ L-+0L: 4%5 +00+29,?+ D#:,2* /+2#33+%549,#%-'

II. THE BASIC INSIGHTS OF THE NEW INSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICSFOR DEVELOPMENT

J$+ 2#/+ ,5+4- #0 9$+ %+S ,%-9,9L9,#%4: +2#%#3,2- 4/+ 9$+ 3#5+/% 54*+a9+%-,#% #0 4 :#%<V-94%5,%< 5+U49+ 9$49 <#+- U42I 9# Q#UU+- 4%5 M3,9$'

G543 M3,9$b9$+ 0#L%5+/ #0 3#5+/% +2#%#3,2-b345+ ?#:L%94/*+a2$4%<+ 9$+ 2+%9+/D,+2+ #0 4:: S+4:9$V2/+49,%< 429,?,9* 4%5 +a9#::+5 9$+,3D#/94%2+ #0 -D+2,4:,W49,#% 4%5 5,?,-,#% #0 :4U#/' J$,- -L<<+-9- 9$49 S+ U+%+0,90/#3 9/45,%< S,9$ 9$#-+ S,9$ 5,00+/+%9 D/+0+/+%2+-B -I,::-B 4%5 +%5#S3+%9- 4-+:4U#/49+5 U* 9$+ +2#%#3,-9 H4?,5 O,24/5#' K%5++5B #%+ 3,<$9 -4* 9$49 9$+ 3#/+5,00+/+%9 9$#-+ S+ 9/45+ S,9$B 9$+ </+49+/ 9$+ D#9+%9,4: <4,%- 0/#3 9/45+'

8L9 M3,9$c- 4/<L3+%9- D/+-LDD#-+ 4 S#/:5 #0 ?#:L%94/* +a2$4%<+'>%0#/9L%49+:*B 4- M3,9$c- D/+5+2+--#/ J$#34- Q#UU+- 4/<L+5B 34% ,% $,- %49L/4:-949+ ,- D/#%+ 9# 5,-4</++3+%9 4%5 2#%0:,29b#09+% #0 9$+ %4-9,+-9 4%5 3#-9 U/L9,-$-#/9' G- 4 /+-L:9B 9$+ 34,%9+%4%2+ #0 ?#:L%94/* +a2$4%<+ 4%5 #L/ 4U,:,9* 9# </#S

D/#-D+/#L- ,- $+4?,:* 5+D+%5+%9 #% 9$+ 4U,:,9* 9# 34,%94,% D+42+ 4%5 #/5+/' J$,-

#/5+/ $#S+?+/B ,- +4-,+/ 9# #U94,% ,% </#LD- 9$49 4/+ $#3#<+%+#L- 4%5 :,I+V3,%5+5B 4%5 $4/5+/ 9# 34,%94,% S$+% </#LD- 4/+ 9## $+9+/#<+%+#L- ,% S4%9-B9+3D+/43+%9B #/ U42I</#L%5' G9 9$+ ?+/* :+4-9B +?+% S+::V3+4%,%< </#LD- 0,%5 ,9+aD+%-,?+ 9# 2##D+/49+ S$+/+ 9/4%-429,#%- 2#-9- 4/+ $,<$' G9 S#/-9B 2#%9,%L4:2#%0:,29 :+45- 9# ?,#:+%9 -9/L<<:+ 9$49 /L:+- #L9 -9+45* +2#%#3,2 </#S9$' J$+%+2+--,9* 0#/ #/5+/ DL9- Q#UU+-,4% %#/3- 49 #55- S,9$ M3,9$,4% /L:+- 0#/ S+4:9$2/+49,#%'

J$L- 9$+ 2+%9/4: D4/45#a #0 D#:,9,24: +2#%#3* 9$49 $4- U++% 49 9$+ 2#/+ #09$+ %+S ,%-9,9L9,#%4: +2#%#3,2- ,- 9$+ 2$#,2+ U+9S++% :+45+/- 9$49 D/#3#9+

D/#5L29,#% #/ D/+549,#%' >%0#/9L%49+:*B 4%* </#LD \:,I+ 9$+ -949+] 24D4U:+ #0+%0#/2,%< /L:+- #0 2##D+/49,#% 4%5 2#%9/429,%< ,- 4:-# D#S+/0L: +%#L<$ 9# 4UL-+9$#-+ /L:+- 0#/ ,9- #S% U+%+0,9' J$,- D4D+/ 24::- 9$,- D/#U:+3 9$+ 2$#,2+ #0 d34I+



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR Y

#/ 94I+Bf U* 4%4:#<* 9# 9$+ d34I+ #/ UL*f 5+2,-,#% ,% 9$+ (#4-,4% 9$+#/* #0 9$+

0,/3' J$,- ,- 9$+ $+4/9 #0 9$+ 2/+5,U:+ 2#33,93+%9 D/#U:+3 D#,%9+5:* $,<$:,<$9+5 U* )#/9$ 4%5 ^+,%<4-9c- 043#L- 4%4:*-,- #0 9$+ U+%+0,9- #0 9$+ ;:#/,#L-O+?#:L9,#% #0 CgAA 0#/ 1%<:4%5 \)#/9$ 4%5 ^+,%<4-9 ChAh]' 1?+% 4 -#?+/+,<%S$# S,-$+- 9# 5# <##5 S,:: U+ :,3,9+5 ,% $,- 499+3D9- 9# U#//#S #/ 9# +%<4<+ ,%2/+5,U:+ D#:,2* ,0 $,- D#S+/ ,- -# L%2#%-9/4,%+5 9$49 2,9,W+%- 4%5 ,%?+-9#/- 24% -++9$49 $+ 24% 4/U,9/4/,:* /+%+<+ #% 4</++3+%9- S,9$#L9 2#%-+_L+%2+'

K% 4% +4/:,+/ S#/IB )*+ \Chhi] 5,-2L--+5 $#S 4% +aD4%5+5 (#4-,4% 9$+#/*#0 9$+ -949+ L%5+/:,+- 3#-9 #0 H#L<:4-- )#/9$c- ,5+4- 4U#L9 D#:,9,24: 5+?+:#D3+%9'K% 4 %L9-$+::B 9$+ D#:,9,+- 9$49 4/+ -L-94,%4U:+ 49 4%* 9,3+ 4/+ 9$#-+ S$+/+ 9$+

U4:4%2+ #0 $,+/4/2$*B -949+ 2#%9/#:B 9+2$%,24: D/#5L29,#%B 4%5 D#:,9,24: 2#3D+9,9,#%4/+ -L2$ 9$49 5#3,%4%9 </#LD- $4?+ %# ,%2+%9,?+ 9# -S,92$ 9# 4:9+/%49,?+ -*-9+3-'8L9 9$,- 3+4%- 9$49 #9$+/S,-+ dL%D/#5L29,?+f #/ d:#S </#S9$f D#:,9,24:+2#%#3,+- 4/+ %#9 #%:* 0+4-,U:+ UL9 -94U:+B S$+/+ 9+2$%#:#<,24: U4//,+/- :,3,9 9$+

D#9+%9,4: 0#/ 0L/9$+/ </#S9$ 4%5 9$+ 5+34%5- #0 9$+ D#S+/0L: 24%%#9 U+ U#L<$9#00 U* 9$+ D#--,U,:,9* #0 $,<$+/ S+4:9$ ,% +a2$4%<+ 0#/ </+49+/ D#:,9,24:2#3D+9,9,#%' P%+ S4* #0 ?,+S,%< 9$+ /,-+ #0 9$+ 3#5+/%B 5+?+:#D+5 S#/:5 ,- 9#-++ $#S </#S,%< D/#-D+/,9* $4- <#%+ $4%5 ,% $4%5 S,9$ 3#/+ 2$+2I- 4%5

U4:4%2+- 4%5 4 -949+ 9$49 0#/ 4:: ,9- D/#U:+3- 4%5 2#//LD9,#%- ,- -9,:: 3#/+ U+$#:5+% 9# 9$+ 2,9,W+%/* ,% 9$+ /,2$+-9 2#L%9/,+- 9$4% ,% 3#-9 #0 9$+ S#/:5B 4%52+/94,%:* 3#/+ #D+% 9# 2#3D+9,9,#% 9$4% /L:+/- ,% +4/:,+/ 9,3+-' J# -#3+ +a9+%9B ,%9$+ S+4:9$* D4/9 #0 9$+ S#/:5B ,9 ,- 4:3#-9 4- ,0 S+ d$,/+f 9$+ <#?+/%3+%9 S+ S,-$S$,:+ -++I,%< 9# 2#%0,%+ 9$+3 9# 34%4<+/,4: 5L9,+- S+ 5+-,<% 0#/ 9$+3' 8L9 #02#L/-+ 9$,- 5#+- %#9 3+4% 9$49 4%* -949+ ,- ,33L%+ 9# 9$+ DL-$ 4%5 DL:: #0 ,%9+/+-9</#LD- -9/,?,%< 9# -I+S 9$+ D#:,9* 9# 04?#/ 9$+3 4%5 9$+,/ 4::,+-' )#/ 9$49 9$+-949+- 24% /,-+ 4U#?+ 9$+ 5+-,/+- 4%5 ,//49,#%4:,9,+- #0 9$+,/ L%5+/:*,%<

D#DL:49,#%-'8L9 4- )#/9$B ^4::,-B 4%5 ^+,%<4-9 \@FFh] $4?+ 4/<L+5 /+2+%9:* 9$+ 9*D,24:

%49L/4: -949+ 24% U+ -++% 4- 4 2#4:,9,#% #0 5#3,%4%9 +:,9+- S$# 24/?+ #L9 4 :,3,9+5422+-- #/5+/ 9# :,3,9 ?,#:+%9 2#%0:,29 43#%< +42$ #9$+/B 9# D/#9+29 9$+3-+:?+-0/#3 9$+ +%2/#42$3+%9 #0 9$+ 34--+-B 4%5 9# D/#?,5+ 4 -94U:+ D:490#/3 0#/

D/#3#9,%< +2#%#3,2 </#S9$ S,9$,% 9$+ 04?#/+5 </#LD-' K% +a2$4%<+ 0#/34,%94,%,%< #/5+/ 0#/ 9$+ 2#L%9/* 4- 4 S$#:+B D/#</+-- 0#/ 3#-9 ,- #U94,%+5 U*

D:4*,%< S,9$,% 9$+ /L:+- #0 4 -*-9+3 9$49 4/+ -I+S+5 9# 4 04?#/+5 0+S' J$,- ,- 9$+5+04L:9 D#-,9,#% #0 3#-9 2#L%9/,+- ,% 9$+ S#/:5'

H+?+:#D3+%9 9$+#/* ,- 49 ,9- S+4I+-9 S$+% ,9 ,<%#/+- 9$+ -94U,:,9* #0 D/++a,-9,%< -#2,4: 4//4%<+3+%9- 4%5 9/+49- </#S9$ 4- 4 3+/+ 9+2$%#:#<,24: <43+

,% S$,2$ 24D,94:B :4U#/B /+-#L/2+-B 4%5 9+2$%#:#<* 4/+ 9# U+ /+4//4%<+5 -# 4- 9# D/#5L2+ 4 S+::VD:4%%+5 </#S9$ 342$,%+' )4,?+ ?+/-,#%- #0 9$,- ?,+SB +a2#/,49+5 U* %L3+/#L- #U-+/?+/- 4%5 %#94U:* U* D/#3,%+%9 /+-+4/2$+/- S,9$ /+-+4/2$



X G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

+aD+/,+%2+ ,% 9$+ ^#/:5 84%I 4%5 #9$+/ ,%-9,9L9,#%- \+'<'B 14-9+/:*B M$,/:+*]

9+%5+5 9# 5#3,%49+ 9$+ 9$,%I,%< #0 5+?+:#D3+%9 D#:,2* 9$/#L<$ 49 :+4-9 9$+ ChhF-'=#/+ /+2+%9:*B 9$+/+ $4- U++% 4 9L/% 9# 0#2L- #% <#?+/%4%2+ 4%5,%-9,9L9,#%- 4- 9$+ 34[#/ 5+?+:#D3+%9 4<+%2,+- $4?+ 2#3+ 9# /+4:,W+ 9$+ 0L9,:,9* #03+/+ 24D,94: 4%5 9+2$%#:#<* 9/4%-0+/- 4%5 4- %4j?+ ?,+S- #0 D:4%%,%< S$+9$+/ ,%9$+ 14-9 \0#/3+/ 2#33L%,-9 -949+-] #/ ,% 9$+ ^+-9 $4?+ 045+5'

8L9 ,%-9,9L9,#%4: ,--L+- 4/+ #09+% 5,-2L--+5 ,% 4 5,-[#,%9 4%5 45 $#2 04-$,#%4- ,0 ,%-9,9L9,#%4: ,3D/#?+3+%9 S+/+ 4 3499+/ #0 4 :+<4: ,%-9+45 #0 4 9+2$%#:#<,24:0,a' G9 ,9- S#/-9B 9$,- 9+%5- 9# 4 I,%5 #0 9+2$%,24: :+<4:,-3 ,% S$,2$ /+0#/3 ,- 4::4U#L9 U/,%<,%< dU+-9 D/429,2+f 453,%,-9/49,?+ -9*:+ #/ :+<4: /L:+- 9# 5+?+:#D,%<%49,#%-' G9 ,9- U+-9B 9$,- -#/9 #0 9$,%I,%< ,- -LD+/0,2,4: 9$#L<$ U+%,<%' G9 ,9- S#/-9B9$,- -#/9 #0 ,3D/#?+3+%9 9$/#L<$ U+99+/ 453,%,-9/49,?+ 34%4<+3+%9 9/+49- 9$+-949+ 4- 4 S+::V3+4%,%< UL9 3,-<L,5+5 +%9+/D/,-+ ,% S$,2$ D#:,9,2,4%- /+4::* S4%9$,<$ </#S9$ 4%5 5+?+:#D3+%9 UL9 4/+ [L-9 -9L2I S,9$ 4% 4%9,_L49+5 :+<4:4DD4/49L- 9$49 #%:* S4,9- 0#/ 3#5+/% LD</45+- 0/#3 9$+ /,2$+/ %49,#%-'

=#/+#?+/B ,0 9$+/+ ,- %# ,%9+</49,#% U+9S++% ,%-9,9L9,#%4: ,--L+- #0<#?+/%4%2+ S,9$ 9$+ -94%54/5 D/#U:+3- #0 2#/+ 5,-9#/9,#%- 4- $,<$:,<$9+5 U*%+#2:4--,24: 9$+#/*B S$,2$ 9$+% -+/?+ 9# +aD:4,% 9$+ 5,-9/,UL9,#% #0 U+%+0,9- 9$49-LDD#/9 9$+ +a,-9,%< D#:,9,24: +2#%#3*B ,9 ,- L%:,I+:* 9$49 \,] S+ S,:: +?+% ,5+%9,0*9$+ 4/+4- S$+/+ /+0#/3- 4/+ 9$+ 3#-9 -+?+/+:* %++5+5 4%5 \,,] S+ S,:: U+ 4U:+ 9#-9/L29L/+ /+0#/3- 9# 34I+ 9$+3 0+4-,U:+ 4%5 3#/+ ,3D#/94%9 -L-94,%4U:+ ,% 4%,%2+%9,?+V2#3D49,U:+ -+%-+ ,% 9$+ :#%<+/ /L%'

K%5++5B 9$+/+ 24% U+ 4 9+3D949,#% 9# 9/+49 <#?+/%4%2+ 4%5 -949+ 24D42,9*,%5+D+%5+%9 #0 9$+ 5,-9#/9,#%- #0 S$49 )#/9$B ^4::,- 4%5 ^+,%<4-9 24:: dJ$+

)49L/4: M949+f #0 :,3,9+5 422+-- 4%5 2#%-9/4,%+5 +:,9+ 2#%9/#:' 8L9 #0 2#L/-+B ,9 ,-9$+ ?+/* 5,-9#/9,#%- 9$49 -+/?+ 9# 2/+49+ 9$+ 2#%5,9,#%- 0#/ 9$+ +a,-9,%< -94U:+ #/5+/4%5 -# ,9 ,- %#9 +4-* 9# 5,-2L-- /+0#/3 S,9$#L9 ,5+%9,0*,%< 9$+ ,%2+%9,?+- 0#/5*-0L%29,#%4: <#?+/%3+%9 #/ L%5+/-94%5,%< S$* 5,00+/+%9 </#LD- 3,<$9 %#9-LDD#/9 #/ S,::,%<:* ,3D:+3+%9 D#:,2,+- 9$49 D/#3#9+ </+49+/ D#:,9,24: #/

+2#%#3,2 422+--'8L9 S$49 5#+- 9$,- 3+4% ,% D/429,2+` 6#/ /+4-#%- U#9$ #0 -+:0,-$ /+%9V

D/+-+/?49,#% 3#9,?+ 4%5 9$+ 5,00,2L:9* #0 D/#?,5,%< %49,#%4: DLU:,2 <##5- ,% 4%L%5+/5+?+:#D+5 2#L%9/*B *#L -++ 9$+ +2#%#3* 0L%29,#%,%< ,% 5,00+/+%9 D4/9,9,#%-BS,9$ -+29#/- #0 9$+ +2#%#3* -+</+<49+5 #/ 3#/+ /+45,:* 422+--,U:+ 9# 9$+ S+::V2#%%+29+5 +:,9+' (/+49,%< /L:+- 9$49 $#:5 +_L4::* 4%5 L%,?+/-4::* ,% D/429,2+B 4-S+:: 4- ,% 9$+#/*B 4/+ 5,00,2L:9 %#9 :+4-9 U+24L-+ ,9 ,- $4/5 0#/ %49,#%4: D#:,9,2- 9#/,-+ #?+/ :#24: D49/#%4<+' G%5 #0 2#L/-+ 9$+ -9/#%<+/ 9$+ 5+</++ #0 D+/-#%4:,W+5

D49/#%4<+B 9$+ 3#/+ 5,00,2L:9 ,9 ,- 9# +aD+29 S+::V#/5+/+5 L%,?+/-4: /L:+ #0 :4S' P/

D+/$4D- ,9 ,- 9$+ 2#%?+/-+b9$+ ?+/* 5,00,2L:9* #0 +-94U:,-$,%< +%0#/2+4U:+B/+4-#%4U:* L%U,4-+5 /L:+- DL-$+- </#LD- 9# ?4:L+ D49/#%4<+ /+:49,#%-$,D- +?+%3#/+'



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR Z

=#/+ #09+% 9$4% %#9B 9$,- -L-94,%4U:+ D#:,9,24: 5,-9#/9,#%b%#9 3+/+

,%0/4-9/L29L/+ #/ D##/ <+#</4D$*b2/+49+- S$49 S+ -++ 4- 5L4: +2#%#3,+- S,9$ 4-34:: D/#5L29,?+ W#%+ 4%5 4 :4/<+B 3#-9:* 4</,2L:9L/4: :#SVS4<+ +2#%#3*'K9 ,- %#9 L%2#33#% 0#/ 4</,2L:9L/+ 9# U+ +-D+2,4::* L%D/#</+--,?+ 4%5

U42IS4/5 U+24L-+ ,3D#/94%9 D#:,9,24: 0429,#%- U+%+0,9 0/#3 9$,- ,33#U,:,9*' R+99$+/+ ,- %# +4-* S4* 9# DL-$ 9$+ %49,#% #L9 #0 2L//+%9:* +a,-9,%< /+:49,#%- S,9$#L9LD+%5,%< 9$+ -#L/2+- #0 -94U,:,9* 4%5 #/5+/' G%5 ,9 ,- %#9 -L/D/,-,%< 9$49 -9/L29L/4:,3U4:4%2+- 4%5 34--,?+ -+29#/4: 5,-9#/9,#%- 4/+ 9$+ U4-+- 0#/ -L22+--0L: D/,?49+0#/9L%+-' =#/+#?+/B 9$+ 9$,2I+9 #0 :+<4: /L:+- 9$49 4/+ 2#3D:,249+5B $4/5 9#34%4<+B 4%5 ,3D+/0+29:* +%0#/2+5 4/+ +-D+2,4::* <##5 U4//,+/- 9# +%9/* 0#/ 9$#-+S,9$ 9$+ S+4:9$B D#S+/B 2#%%+29,#%-B 4%5 $,-9#/,24: 9,+- 9# 4L9$#/,9*' G99+3D9,%<9# -,3D:,0* 4%5 2:4/,0* +a,-9,%< /L:+- ,- ,% +00+29 4 5,3,%L9,#% #0 9$+ -D+2,4:

D/,?,:+<+- +4/%+5 U* 9$#-+ 9$49 $4?+ /,-+% LD ,% 9$+ 2L//+%9 -*-9+3'=#/+#?+/B #%+ -$#L:5 +aD+29 4::,4%2+- U+9S++% D#DL:,-9- 4%5 +:,9+-B 4- S+::

4- U* U:#2I,%< </#LD- :,I+ :4U#/ L%,#%- #/ 2+/94,% 9*D+- #0 429,?,-9 #/<4%,W49,#%-'ML22+--0L: +:,9+ </#LD- S,:: $4?+ 0#/<+5 9,+- 5+-,<%+5 9# S,9$-94%5 +4-* 2$4::+%<+,% U#9$ 5+3#2/42,+- 4%5 4L9#2/42,+-' P09+%B ,% S$49 9$+ +2#%#3,-9 8/L2+ R4%5:+24::+5 4 dU4D9,-9- 4%5 U##9:+<<+/-f D$+%#3+%#% \409+/ 9$+ -L22+--0L: 2#%0:L+%2+#0 -LDD#/9 0#/ ./#$,U,9,#% ,% G3+/,24 U* 9$+ /+:,<,#L- 4%5 9$+ ?+%4:]B 9$+,5+#:#<,24: D/+5,:+29,#%- #0 #%+ </#LD S,:: U+ -+:+29,?+:* -LDD#/9+5 S$+/+ ,934I+- 0#/ +4-* D/#0,9- U* #9$+/-' G 3#/+ #D+%B 2#3D+9,9,?+ -*-9+3 S,:: U+/+-,-9+5 4- ,9 S,:: U+ U#9$ D#:,9,24::* ,%2#//+29 4%5 4- *+9 L%-LDD#/9+5 U* %+S2$4::+%<+/- 9$49B 4:3#-9 U* 5+0,%,9,#%B $4?+ %#9 U++% 4U:+ 9# +3+/<+ *+9'

III. WHERE SHOULD PHILIPPINE REFORMS BEGIN?:THE LESSONS FROM ECONOMICS

M#3+9,3+- /+0+//+5 9# 4- 9$+ d-,2I 34% #0 G-,4fB 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3*

$4- U++% 34/I+5 U* -9+45* UL9 3+5,#2/+ </#S9$ D+/0#/34%2+ #?+/ 9$+ :4-9 0+S5+245+-' H+-D,9+ -+9U42I-B </#S9$ $4- -94*+5 ,% 9$+ /4%<+ #0 CkZ D+/2+%9 D+/ *+4/,% 9+/3- #0 /+4: </#-- 5#3+-9,2 D/#5L29 \;H.] 0#/ 9$+ :4-9 @ 5+245+-B S$,2$ $4-

U++% L-+0L: ,% 3,:5:* /+5L2,%< 4U-#:L9+ D#?+/9* ,% 4 %49,#% #0 #?+/ hF 3,::,#% D+#D:+' =#/+#?+/B 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- $4- %#9 -L00+/+5 9## #U?,#L-:* 0/#3 9$+ /+2+%90,%4%2,4: 2/,-,-' 8L9 9$,- ,- 3#/+ 4% ,%5,249,#% #0 9$+ S+4I%+-- #0 9$+ %49,#%4:+2#%#3* 9$4% 4 /+-L:9 #0 +-D+2,4::* <##5 D#:,2*' J$+ .$,:,DD,%+- $4- U++% 4:4<<4/5 ,% G-,4% </#S9$B S$+9$+/ ,% 2#3D4/,-#% 9# 9$+ .+#D:+c- O+DLU:,2 #0($,%4 \.O(]B 9$+ ?4/,#L- 14-9 G-,4% 9,<+/-B #/ 9# ,9- %+,<$U#/- ,% M#L9$ 14-9 G-,4'

G%5 S$* -$#L:5 9$49 U+`(#%-,5+/ S$49 ,- 9$#L<$9 9# U+ 9$+ 3#-9 D/+--,%< D/#U:+3 0#/ :#%<V9+/345[L-93+%9 #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3*B 9$+ -:#S 3#?+3+%9 #L9 #0 :#S D4,5 /L/4:4</,2L:9L/4: [#U- ,%9# 3#-9:* L/U4% 2#33+/2,4: 4%5 ,%5L-9/,4: [#U-' J$,- D/#U:+3



g G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

S4- 0#/34::* 5,-2L--+5 49 :+4-9 4- 04/ U42I 4- 9$+ +4/:* ChhF- S$+% ,9 S4-

$,<$:,<$9+5 ,% 4 [#,%9 /+D#/9 #% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- U* 4 9+43 #0 0#L/ +2#%#3,-9-$+45+5 U* .4L: e/L<34% \e/L<34% +9 4:' Chh@]' J$+ /+D#/9 0#2L-+5 #% 9$+d+a9/+3+ 5L4:,-3 #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3*' G 9,%* 34%L0429L/,%< -+29#/B+3D:#*,%< #%:* CF D+/2+%9 #0 9$+ :4U#/ 0#/2+b:+-- 9$4% ,% ChiFbD/#5L2+-/#L<$:* #%+ _L4/9+/ #0 ;H. 49 5#3+-9,2 D/,2+-' =+4%S$,:+B 4:3#-9 9S# 9$,/5- #09$+ :4U#/ 0#/2+ ,- +3D:#*+5 +,9$+/ ,% 4</,2L:9L/+ #/ ,% d#9$+/ -+/?,2+-f \D/,34/,:*34/<,%4: L/U4% [#U-]B <+%+/49,%< #%:* #%+V0,09$ 4- 3L2$ #L9DL9 D+/ S#/I+/\e/L<34%B +9 4:' Chh@B DD' hkCF]'f J$+ /+D#/9 9$+% S+%9 #% 9# 5+2/* 9$,- 5L4:,-34%5 DL9 D4/9 #0 9$+ U:43+ #% 9$+ $,<$ 94/,00- 4%5 D##/ +aD#/9 #/,+%949,#% #0 9$+.$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3*'

Q#S+?+/B -,%2+ 9$+% 94/,00- $4?+ 2#3+ 5#S% -LU-94%9,4::* 4%5 9$+/+ $4- U++% -#3+ ,3D/#?+3+%9B UL9 9$+ 5L4: %49L/+ #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3* $4-3#-9:* -94*+5 9$+ -43+ S,9$ #%:* 3#5+-9 2$4%<+-' J# 9$,- 54*B /#L<$:* #%+_L4/9+/ #0 9$+ S#/I0#/2+ ,- ,% ,%5L-9/* #/ 34%L0429L/,%< 4%5 9$/++ _L4/9+/- ,- ,%4</,2L:9L/+ #/ 0#/+-9/*B #/ ,% -+/?,2+-' ^$,:+ 4 0+S #0 9$+ -+/?,2+ [#U- 4/+ ,% $,<$V

D4*,%< 4/+4-B 0#/ 9$+ 3#-9 D4/9 -+/?,2+- 4/+ -9,:: 5#3,%49+5 U* :#S D/#5L29,?,9*B#09+% 34/<,%4: [#U-' ^$49 24% D#--,U:* 422#L%9 0#/ 9$,- -94<%49,#% ,% 9$+3#?+3+%9 #0 :4U#/ 0/#3 9$+ /+:49,?+:* L%D/#5L29,?+ D4/9 #0 9$+ +2#%#3* 9# 9$+3#/+ D/#5L29,?+ 4%5 9+2$%#:#<,24::* 3#/+ 45?4%2+5 -+29#/-`

P% 9$,- 3#-9 #U-+/?+/- $4?+ U++% /+:49,?+:* -,:+%9' J$+/+ ,- -#3+5,-2L--,#% #0 :42I #0 2#3D+9,9,?+%+-- #0 .$,:,DD,%+ ,%5L-9/* 4%5 9$+ 9+%5+%2* #0.$,:,DD,%+ 34%L0429L/,%< 9# 04,: 9# +aD#/9B 9$#L<$ 9$+/+ ,- %# 5+94,:+5 5,-2L--,#%#0 0,/-9 D/,%2,D:+-' J$+ ^#/:5 84%Ic- .$,:,DD,%+- H,-2L--,#% )#9+ #% 12#%#3,2;/#S9$ \^#/:5 84%I @FCF] $,<$:,<$9- 9$+ <4D U+9S++% ,%5L-9/,4: 4%5 4</,2L:9L/4:

D/#5L29,?,9* S,9$#L9 +aD:4,%,%< 9$+ -#L/2+ #0 9$,- 5,-9#/9,#%' K9 ,- 9$+/+0#/+-L/D/,-,%< 9$49 S$+% 5,-2L--,%< D#--,U:+ /+0#/3-B +3D$4-,- ,- D:42+5 #% 0,-24:,3D/#?+3+%9-B ,%0/4-9/L29L/+ 5+?+:#D3+%9B 4%5 ,3D/#?,%< <#?+/%4%2+' ^$,:+9$+/+ ,- /+0+/+%2+ 9# dU4//,+/- 9# 0429#/ 3#U,:,9*f \^#/:5 84%IB @FCFB CF] S+ 4/+

%#9 9#:5 S$49 9$+-+ U4//,+/- 2#%-,-9 #0' )#/ 5# S+ :+4/% S$* 9$+ 9$/++ 4/+4- D/#3#9+5 0#/ </#S9$ S#L:5 5# 3L2$ 9# #?+/2#3+ -9/L29L/4: ,3D+5,3+%9-B$#S+?+/ S+:: 9$+* 34* -+/?+ 4- D/429,24: -L<<+-9,#%- 0#/ /+0#/3'

R+9 -#3+ 2:L+- 9# 9$+ D/#U:+3- 042,%< .$,:,DD,%+ ,%5L-9/* 34* U+ <:+4%+50/#3 S#/I U* .$,:,DD,%+ :4U#/ -D+2,4:,-9-' 6#/ +a43D:+B 5+-D,9+ 9$+ $,<$+/

D/#5L29,?,9* ,% 9$+ L/U4% ,%5L-9/,4: -+29#/ 4%5 9$+ %++5 0#/ $,<$:* -I,::+5 S#/I+/-B9$+ L%+3D:#*3+%9 /49+ ,- $,<$+/ 0#/ 2#::+<+V+5L249+5 -9L5+%9- 9$4% :+-- +5L249+5S#/I+/-' K% @FFAB 9$+ 2#::+<+V+5L249+5 $45 4 CF'g D+/2+%9 L%+3D:#*3+%9 /49+2#3D4/+5 9# A'g D+/2+%9 0#/ 9$#-+ S,9$ #%:* $,<$ -2$##: 5+</++-B Y'Y D+/2+%9 0#/

9$#-+ S,9$ +:+3+%94/* +5L249,#%B 4%5 @'C D+/2+%9 0#/ 9$#-+ S,9$ %# +:+3+%94/*-2$##:,%< 49 4:: \-++ J4U:+ C]' J$,- ,- -# 3L2$ 9$+ #DD#-,9+ #0 S$49 ,- 9*D,24: ,%9$+ 5+?+:#D+5 +2#%#3,+- 9$49 ,9 -L<<+-9- 9$+ ,3D#/94%2+ #0 $,<$ U4//,+/- 9# +%9/*



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR i

,% 9$+ 0#/34: [#U 34/I+9 9$49 4/+ %#9 U,%5,%< ,% 9$+ :#SVS4<+B $+4?,:* ,%0#/34:

-+/?,2+ 4%5 4</,2L:9L/4: -+29#/- 9$49 4/+ 3#/+ :,I+:* 9# +3D:#* 9$+ :+4-9 +5L249+5'

J4U:+ C' Unemployment in the Philippines by Educational Attainment, 2008EducationalAttainment

Labor force(thousands)

UnemploymentRate (percent)

Share (percent)

G:: YgBAFZ i'X CFF )# </45+ ggF @'C F'Z1:+3+%94/* CCBX@Z Y'Y CX'FQ,<$ -2$##: CXBXZi A'g XZ'F(#::+<+l CFB@gY CF'g Yh'h

M#L/2+N 1-<L+//4 \@FCF]'

8L9 S$49 4/+ 9$+-+ U4//,+/-`1-<L+//4 \@FCF] D#,%9- 9# 9S# 0+49L/+- #0 .$,:,DD,%+ ,%5L-9/* 9$49 S#L:5

5/4349,24::* ,%$,U,9 [#U 2/+49,#%N \,] 4 $,<$ ,%5L-9/,4: 3,%,3L3 S4<+ 4%5\,,] -9/,29 +3D:#*3+%9 D/#9+29,#%' )#9+ 9$49 9$+-+ /L:+- 4/+ #%:* U,%5,%< #% 9$+,%5L-9/* -+29#/ 4%5 %#9 #% +,9$+/ 4</,2L:9L/+ %#/ 9$+ UL:I #0 9$+ -+/?,2+- -+29#/'=#/+#+?+/B ,9 ,- :,I+:* 9$49 9$+-+ /L:+- S#L:5 U+ 3#/+ -9/,29:* +%0#/2+5 9$+ 3#/+?,-,U:+ 4%5 0#/34: 9$+ +%9+/D/,-+B S$,2$ #%+ S#L:5 +aD+29 #0 9$+ :4/<+-9 %49,#%4:4%5 3L:9,%49,#%4: +%9+/D/,-+-'

1-<L+//4 2#%9,%L+- 9$49 #L9 #0 CYF 2#L%9/,+-B 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- $45 9$+ @A9$ $,<$+-9 3,%,3L3 S4<+ ,% 9$+ S#/:5 ,% @FFi 49 DL/2$4-,%< D#S+/ D4/,9* \...]/49+-B 4%5 9$+ A9$ $,<$+-9 3,%,3L3 S4<+ #L9 #0 4 </#LD #0 4U#L9 YF 5+?+:#D,%<4%5 9/4%-,9,#% +2#%#3,+-'

K% 455,9,#%B /+<L:4/,W49,#% /L:+- 0#/2+ 2#3D4%,+- 9# 2#%?+/9 +3D:#*++- ,%9#0L::V9,3+ S#/I+/- 4%5 34I+ ,9 ?,/9L4::* ,3D#--,U:+ 0#/ 0,/3- 9# 0,/+ S#/I+/- 409+//+<L:4/,W49,#%' J$+ D/+5,294U:+ +00+29 ,- 9$49 0,/3- $4?+ 4 :4/<+ %L3U+/ #0+3D:#*++- $,/+5 #% 4 :#SVS4<+B -$#/9V9+/3 9/42IB S,9$ 3#-9 :+9 <# 409+/ #%:* Y #/X 3#%9$-' G -34::+/ </#LD #0 $,<$VD/#5L29,?,9*B $,<$+/VD4,5 S#/I+/- 34I+ LD 9$+

D+/34%+%9 +3D:#*3+%9 2#/+'

J$+-+ 9S# 0+49L/+- 4:#%+ S#L:5 U+ +%#L<$ 9# +aD:4,% 4 :4/<+ <4D U+9S++%9$+ :4U#/ 34/I+9- #0 9$+ ,%5L-9/* 4%5 -+/?,2+- -+29#/- #/ 9$+ 4</,2L:9L/+ -+29#/'OL/4: S#/I+/- 4/+ %#9 U#L%5 U* 9$+-+ :4S-B 4%5 0#/ 9$+ 3#-9 D4/9 %+,9$+/ ,- 9$+-+/?,2+ -+29#/' =#/+#?+/B ,9 S#L:5 U+ $4/5 9# 3#%,9#/ 4%5 +%0#/2+ -L2$ /L:+- +?+%S+/+ 9$+* 4/+ 9# U+ L%,?+/-4::* 4DD:,+5'

Q+%2+B ,9 ,- %#S +4-* 9# L%5+/-94%5 9$49 $,<$ 3,%,3L3 S4<+- 4%52#3D:,249+5 4%5 D/#9+29,?+ S#/I /L:+-C -+/?+ 4- 4 94a #% 9$+ 3#-9 D/#5L29,?+ 4%5

D/#</+--,?+ D4/9 #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3*B -LDD#/9,%< 9$+ 5L4:,9* 5+2/,+5 U*+aD+/9- 0#/ 9$+ :4-9 -+?+/4: 5+245+-' >%0#/9L%49+:*B 34%* +aD+/9 4%4:*-+- $4?+

,5+%9,0,+5 :4U#/ 34/I+9 /,<,5,9,+- 4- U+,%< 2/,9,24: 9# .$,:,DD,%+ L%5+/5+?+:#D3+%9S$,:+ 3,-L%5+/-94%5,%< $#S D#:,2,+-B :,I+ 9$+ L/U4% 3,%,3L3 S4<+ 4%5 #9$+/

CJ$+-+ 4/+ #%:* 9$+ 3#-9 D/#3,%+%9 #%+-' G 3#/+ 5+94,:+5 -9L5* 3,<$9 /+?+4: 9$+ 3L:9,D:+ :4*+/- #02#%-9/4,%9-'



A G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

d$,<$ S4<+f D#:,2,+-B 429L4::* 2#%9/,UL9+ 9# 9$+ D/#U:+3 #0 :#S S4<+- ,% 9$+

#?+/4:: +2#%#3* 4%5 $,<$ L%+3D:#*3+%9'@

K%5++5B 9$+ /+<L:49,#%- #% :4U#/b+-D+2,4::* #% 9$+ 3#-9 45?4%2+5B *+9 D/#9+29+5 L/U4% :4U#/ 49 9$+ 2+%9+/ #0 3#5+/% 5+?+:#D3+%9b4/+ 4 34[#/2#3D#%+%9 ,% +a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

D#-9-+2#%54/* +5L249,#%' K0 +5L249,#% 5,5 %#9 D4*B ,9 S#L:5 34I+ -+%-+ 0#/ 3#-99# -,3D:* 0#/+<# 2#::+<+'

8L9 #0 2#L/-+ 9$,- D499+/% ,- 2#%-,-9+%9 S,9$ S$49 S+ S#L:5 +aD+29 0/#3 4$,<$:* -+<3+%9+5 S#/I0#/2+ D/#5L2+5 U* /+<L:49#/* U4//,+/-' K% +00+29B 9$+ 3,a #0$,<$ 3,%,3L3 S4<+-B 2#3U,%+5 S,9$ /+<L:4/,W49,#% /L:+- 4%5 #9$+/ D#:,2,+-5+-,<%+5 9# :,3,9 0,/,%< #0 S#/I+/- ,% 9$+ 0#/34: -+29#/B 2#%9/,UL9+- 9# 40#/3,54U:+ U4//,+/ 9# +%9/* ,%9# 9$+ 3#-9 $,<$:* D4,5 [#U-' J$L- 0,/3- $4?+ 9$+,%2+%9,?+ 9# 2/+49+ 9S# 9,+/- #0 S#/I+/-b9$+ 0+S S$# 4/+ /+:49,?+:* S+:: D4,5 4%5$4/5 9# 0,/+B 4%5 9$+ 34%* S$# 4/+ :#SVD4,5B 9+3D#/4/* S#/I+/- 9# U+ /+:+4-+5409+/ 4 0+S 3#%9$-B -# 4- %#9 9# /L% 40#L: #0 9$+ :4S 34%549,%< /+<L:4/,W49,#% 4%5<L4/4%9++5 +3D:#*3+%9 409+/ g 3#%9$-' J$49 3+4%- 9$49 *#L +%2#L/4<+ _L+L+,%<,% 9$+ 0#/34: -+29#/ S$,:+ :4U#/ ,- 0:+a,U:+ UL9 D##/:* 2#3D+%-49+5 ,% 9$+ /L/4:4%5 ,%0#/34: -+/?,2+ -+29#/-' K% +00+29B 2#::+<+ S#/I+/- 4/+ D4/9,2,D49,%< ,% 4:#99+/* ,% S$,2$ ,9 D4*- 9# U+ +5L249+5 #% 4?+/4<+ +?+% ,0 9$+ :,I+:,$##5 9$49 *#LS,:: U+ 0,/+5 ,- $,<$+/ 9$4% ,0 *#L D#--+-- #%:* +:+3+%94/* +5L249,#%' J$,- -#/9 #0_L+L+,%< 4:-# /+-+3U:+- S$49 #%+ #U-+/?+- ,% /L/4: 4/+4- S$+/+ D##/ S#/I+/-_L+L+ LD 0#/ +3D:#*3+%9 4U/#45B 4%5 ,9 #09+% D4*- 0#/ 9#S%- 9# $4?+ 4 0+S

S#/I+/- $,<$:* D4,5 4U/#45 S,9$ 34%* 3#/+ L%+3D:#*+5 4%5 S4,9,%<B 9$4% 9#$4?+ 4:: S#/I+/- 3#/+ <4,%0L::* +3D:#*+5 49 $#3+' mL+L+,%< ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+0#/34: +2#%#3* 4%5 _L+L+,%< 0#/ #?+/-+4- D#-,9,#%- -$4/+ -#3+ #0 9$+ -43+5*-0L%29,#%- 4/,-,%< 0/#3 4% +00,2,+%9 4%5 $,<$:* /+<L:49+5 :4U#/ 34/I+92#3D:+3+%9+5 U* D##/ 2#3D+9,9,#% ,% -4:+-B /+94,:B D/#5L29,#%B 4%5 ,% 9$+4--#2,49+5 24D,94: 4%5 :4%5 34/I+9-'

@6#/ +a43D:+B 84:,-424% \ChhX] 2#//+29:* ,5+%9,0,+5 :4U#/ 34/I+9 /,<,5,9,+- 4- 2#%9/,UL9,%< 9# 9$+ 5L4:%49L/+ #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3*' R+9 $+ -9/4%<+:* 5+2/,+5 9$+ 0429 9$49 3,%,3L3 S4<+ :4S- 4/+ %#9 +00+29,?+:*+%0#/2+5 #L9-,5+ 9$+ L%,#%,W+5 ,%5L-9/,4: -+29#/' 8L9 9$49 ,- 4 U+%+0,9 #0 9$+ -*-9+3' O49$+/B 9$+ :4a +%0#/2+3+%9 ,-<##5 0#/ +%2#L/4<,%< #?+/4:: </#S9$ UL9 U45 0#/ 9$+ -+29#/ 3#-9 9,+5 9# 9$+ /+<L:49,#%'



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR h

IV. PROBLEMS WITH URBANIZATION STUDIES AND LIMITS

ON IDENTIFYING THE PROBLEM

P%+ #0 9$+ U,<<+-9 ,--L+- S,9$ L%5+/-94%5,%< 9$+ 9/4%-0#/349,#% #0 9$+.$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3* ,- ,5+%9,0*,%< 9$+ -#L/2+- #0 5,-9#/9,#% ,% :,3,9,%< :4U#/c-9/4%-,9,#% 0/#3 :#SVD/#5L29,?,9* 9# $,<$VD/#5L29,?,9* -+29#/-' K% 9$+ :,9+/49L/+B 9$,-,- L-L4::* 9/+49+5 4- 4 -LU-+9 #0 9$+ D/#U:+3 #0 /L/4: 9# L/U4% 3,</49,#%' 8L9 9$+/+4/+ U#9$ D/429,24: 4%5 2#%2+D9L4: D/#U:+3- S,9$ 9$,-'

G- %#9+5 +4/:,+/B 34%* #0 9$+ 3#-9 5,-9#/9,#%4/* :4U#/ 34/I+9 /+<L:49,#%-5# %#9 400+29 9$+ <4D U+9S++% L/U4% 4%5 /L/4: 34/I+9- D+/ -+ -# 3L2$ 4- 9$+*400+29 9$+ 5,00+/+%2+ U+9S++% 9$+ L/U4%,W+5 2#33+/2,4: 4%5 ,%5L-9/,4: -+29#/ 4%5

U#9$ /L/4: 4</,2L:9L/+ 4%5 L/U4% -+/?,2+ ,%5L-9/,+-' J$L-B 9$+ S4<+ 4%5 D/#5L29,?,9* <4D- U/#L<$9 4U#L9 4%5 -L-94,%+5 U* :4U#/ 34/I+9 /+<L:49,#%- 4/+#09+% :+-- 2:+4/:* 9# U+ -++% ,% 9$+ 34/I+9 0#/ L%-I,::+5 L/U4% ?+/-L- /L/4: :4U#/'O49$+/B 9$+ <4D- 4/+ :,I+:* 9# U+ 3#-9 -+?+/+ S$+% 2#%-,5+/,%< +3D:#*3+%9 ,% 9$+5+?+:#D+5 2#33+/2,4:n,%5L-9/,4: -+29#/ ?+/-L- U#9$ L/U4% 4%5 /L/4: -+29#/- %#92#?+/+5 U* 9$+-+ /+<L:49,#%-'

6L/9$+/3#/+B +?+% 9$+ +a,-9,%< /L/4: L/U4% S4<+ <4D- 9$49 4/+ -9,:: ?,-,U:+,% 9$+ 4<</+<49+ 342/#+2#%#3,2 -949,-9,2- 4/+ 34-I+5 U* 9$+ 2#%0L-,%< 5+0,%,9,#%#0 L/U4% -+29#/- L-+5 U* 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ -949,-9,24: 4L9$#/,9,+-' G- "#%+- %#9+5 ,%$,- -L/?+* #0 L/U4%,W49,#% ,% G-,4 \@FF@] 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ 5+0,%,9,#% #0 L/U4% 4/+4-,- -# ,%2:L-,?+ 9$49 +?+% -34:: ?,::4<+- S,9$ 4 3+/+ CBFFF D+#D:+ 4/+ 2#%-,5+/+5L/U4%' J$L-B 2#3D4/49,?+ -949,-9,2- #% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- 4%5 J$4,:4%5 #?+/ 9$+ :4-90+S 5+245+- <,?+- 9$+ 2#L%9+/,%9L,9,?+ ,3D/+--,#% 9$49 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- ,- 3#/+L/U4%,W+5 4%5 3#/+ /4D,5:* L/U4%,W,%< 9$4% J$4,:4%5 5+-D,9+ 9$+ :499+/c- </+49+/-L22+-- ,% D/#3#9,%< </#S9$ 4%5 ,%5L-9/,4:,W49,#%' 8L9 ,9 9L/%- #L9 9$49 9$,-0,%5,%< ,- 4:3#-9 -L/+:* 4% 4/9,0429 #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-c U/#45 5+0,%,9,#% #0 L/U4%4/+4- 4%5 J$4,:4%5c- 3#/+ /+-9/,29,?+ 5+0,%,9,#%B :4U+:,%< -#3+ 4/+4- #0 3#/+ 9$4%@FBFFF D+#D:+ 4- U+,%< /L/4:' Q+%2+B %# -9L5* *+9 +a,-9- 9$49 D/#D+/:* 24D9L/+- 9$+

-24:+ #0 9$+ L/U4% 3,</49,#% D/#U:+3 ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- ,% S4*- 9$49 3492$ #L/ U4-,2 ,%9L,9,#%- 4%5 45+_L49+:* 2#//+29 0#/ 5+0,%,9,#%4: D/#U:+3-'

P0 2#L/-+B 9$+/+ ,- 4 0L/9$+/ D/#U:+3 9$49 ,9 34%* D/,?49+ 0,/3- I%#S,%<:*-I,/9 9$+ +a,-9,%< /L:+- 4%5 /+<L:49,#%- 4%5 -# :4U#/ 34/I+9 2#%-9/4,%9- 34* %#9 U+0L::* U,%5,%< \20' M_L,/+ 4%5 ML9$,S4/9V)4/L+DL9 Chhi]' )#%+9$+:+--B 9$+ ,%?+/9+5

D499+/% #0 L%+3D:#*3+%9 U* +5L249,#%B 9$+ #U?,#L- 0#/3- #0 _L+L,%< ,% :#24:,%5L-9/* 0#/ [#U-B 4%5 9$+ L-+ #0 -$#/9V9+/3 ,%5L-9/,4: +3D:#*3+%9 2#%9/429- 9#4?#,5 9$+ gV3#%9$ /L:+ #% /+<L:4/,W49,#% 34I+ 2:+4/ 9$49 9$+ +a,-9,%< /+<L:49,#%-$4?+ /+4: #U-+/?4U:+ +00+29-' ^$49 ,- %#9 *+9 +-94U:,-$+5 ,- $#S U/#45 9$+ +00+29-

4/+ 4%5 $#S ,3D#/94%9 9$+ 5+45S+,<$9 :#--+- 0/#3 -L2$ 5,-9#/9,#%- 4/+ /+:49,?+ 9##9$+/ 5,-9#/9,#%-'=#/+#?+/B 9$+-+ 4/+ %#9 9$+ #%:* ,3D+5,3+%9- 9# -9/L29L/4: 45[L-93+%9-'

P9$+/ /L:+- 4%5 /+<L:49,#%- ,%9+/429 S,9$ :4U#/ 34/I+9 2#%-9/4,%9- 9# 34,%94,%



CF G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

-+<3+%9+5 :4U#/ 4%5 24D,94: 34/I+9- 4%5 :,3,9 9$+ +00,2,+%9 4::#249,#% #0 24D,94:

4%5 :4U#/ S$,:+ :+--+%,%< ,%?+-93+%9 D/#-D+29-'G- ,- S+:: I%#S%B 2#3D+9,9,#% 4%5 ,%?+-93+%9 4/+ $43D+/+5 U*2#%-9,9L9,#%4: /L:+- 9$49 :,3,9 0#/+,<% D4/9,2,D49,#% ,% :#24: UL-,%+-- 9# 3,%#/,9*-949L- 4%5 9$49 D/#$,U,9 0#/+,<%+/- 0/#3 #S%,%< D/#D+/9* S,9$ 4 0+S :,3,9+5+a2+D9,#%- -L2$ 4- ,%$+/,94%2+' J$,- -+?+/+:* /+-9/,29- 9$+ +%9/* #0 0,/3- S,9$ 9$+</+49+-9 I%#S$#S 4%5 34%4<+/,4: +aD+/,+%2+ 9$49 S#L:5 U+%+0,9 9$+ .$,:,DD,%++2#%#3*'

K9 ,- %#9 4 -L/D/,-+ 9$49 -I,::+5 S#/I+/- 4/+ 43#%< 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-c- :4/<+-9+aD#/9-' P?+/-+4- S#/I+/- #% 4 ?4/,+9* #0 9+3D#/4/* 4--,<%3+%9- 24%%#9 0,%5+3D:#*3+%9 ,% 9$+,/ $#3+ 2#L%9/* U+24L-+ +%9+/D/,-+- 4/+ $+4?,:* 2#%-9/4,%+5 ,%9$+,/ 4U,:,9* 9# +%9+/' K9 ,- -,3D:+/ 9# $,/+ 6,:,D,%#- 4U/#45 9$4% 49 $#3+ S,9$

D/+5,294U:+ 2#-9- 0#/ </#S9$ 4%5 5+?+:#D3+%94: D/#</+--'o#%,%< #0 :4%5 455- 4 0L/9$+/ 5,3+%-,#% #0 ,33#U,:,9* 4%5 ,%+00,2,+%2*'

T4%5- 5+-,<%49+5 4- 4</,2L:9L/4: 24%%#9 U+ +aD:#,9+5 4- 2#33+/2,4: D/#D+/9*B$,%5+/,%< +aD4%-,#% 4%5 #%2+ 4<4,% :,3,9,%< 2#3D+9,9,#% ,% 9$+ L/U4% /+<,#%-S$+/+ D/#5L29,?,9* ,- $,<$+-9'

P0 2#L/-+B 9$,- 0L/9$+/ 2#%9/,UL9+- 9# 9$+ #?+/2+%9/4:,W49,#% #0 +2#%#3,2429,?,9* ,% 9$+ +-94U:,-$+5 /+<,#%-' 8#9$ D$*-,24: ,%0/4-9/L29L/+ 4%5 -#2,4:%+9S#/I- S,:: 04?#/ +a,-9,%< :+45+/-' T42I #0 2#3D+9,9,#% ,% :4%5 4%5 :4U#/34/I+9-B 4- S+:: 4- 9/4%-D#/949,#% 2#-9- 5L+ 9# U#9$ ,%0/4-9/L29L/+ 4%5 /+<,#%4:

D/#9+29,#%B S,:: 4:-# <# 4<4,%-9 4%* 34/I+9V2#//+29,%< 9+%5+%2,+- 9# -$,09/+-#L/2+- 4%5 ,%?+-93+%9 #L9-,5+ 9$+ )49,#%4: (4D,94: O+<,#% \)(O]' K%5++5B 9$+<4D ,% ;H. D+/ 24D,94 U+9S++% 9$+ )(O 4%5 9$+ 4?+/4<+ #0 9$+ 9$/++ &,-4*4%/+<,#%- /+34,%+5 49 /#L<$:* 9$/++ 9# #%+ U+9S++% ChAZ 4%5 @FFF S,9$ %# -,<%- #02#%?+/<+%2+ \(4DL%# @FCF]'

T4%5 /+0#/3B S$,2$ $45 9$+ #-9+%-,U:+ <#4:- #0 U/+4I,%< LD 9$+ :4/<+-9+-949+- 4%5 9/4%-0+//,%< #S%+/-$,D 9# D##/ 04/3+/- $4- $45 L%,%9+%5+52#%-+_L+%2+- 4- 5+94,:+5 U* 64U+::4 \@FFh]' 8+24L-+ :4%5 9/4%-0+/- 5# 3#/+ 9$4%

<,?+ :4%5 9# 04/3+/- UL9 429L4::* /+-9/,29 9$+,/ 4U,:,9* 9# /+-+:: 9$+ :4%5- S$,:+#09+% 2#%-9/4,%,%< 9$+3 9# D:#9- 9$49 4/+ U+:#S 9$+ 3,%,3L3 -,W+ %+2+--4/* 0#/0L::* +00,2,+%9 04/3,%< ,% 9$+ 34/I+9D:42+B 04/3+/- 5# %#9 U+%+0,9 4- 3L2$ 0/#39$+ 9/4%-0+/- 4- #%+ S#L:5 9$,%I' =#/+#?+/B 9$+ /+-9/,29,#%- 9$49 S+/+ 5+-,<%+5 9#:,3,9 :4/<+ :4%5$#:5+/-c 4U,:,9* 9# /+2#%-#:,549+ 9$+ :4%5- 409+/ 9/4%-0+/ 5# :,99:+ 9#$,%5+/ 9$+ D#S+/ #0 9$+ :4/<+-9 +-949+ $#:5+/- S$,:+ 34I,%< 9$+ 4</,2L:9L/4: -+29#/+?+% 3#/+ L%2#3D+9,9,?+ 4%5 ,33#U,:+ 9$4% ,9 4:/+45* ,-' K% 34%* 24-+-B 04/3+/-,%0#/34::* /+-+:: 9$+ :4%5- 9# 9$+ 5#3,%4%9 :4%5$#:5+/- 49 U+:#S 34/I+9 D/,2+-'P%:* 9$+ :4/<+-9 4%5 3#-9 D#:,9,24::* 2#%%+29+5 043,:,+- $4?+ 9$+ 24D42,9* 9# UL*

U42I 9$+ :4%5 4%5 ,%0#/34::* 2#%9/#: 9$+,/ D/#D+/9* /,<$9- S,9$#L9 U+%+0,9 #0 :+<4:-4%29,#%' J$+ %+9 +00+29 ,- 9$+ #DD#-,9+ #0 S$49 S4- ,%9+%5+5' G:9$#L<$,%2#%?+%,+%2+5B 9$+ :4/<+ :4%5$#:5+/- /+#U94,% 9$+-+ :4%5- UL9 %#S U+%+0,9 0/#39$+ :,3,9+5 2#3D+9,9,#% ,% 9$,- :4%5 34/I+9' ^$*` 8+24L-+ -34::+/ #/ :+--



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR CC

D#S+/0L: </#LD- -++I,%< 9# UL* 9$+-+ :4%5- S#L:5 %#9 U+ 4U:+ 9# 5# -# :+<4::* 4%5

5# %#9 $4?+ 9$+ -#2,4: D#S+/ 9# ,%0#/34::* +%0#/2+ 5+ 0429# D/#D+/9* /,<$9-\64U+::4 @FFh]'K%5++5B <,?+% 9$+ D/#U:+3- S,9$ U#9$ ,%9+//+<,#%4: 2#3D+9,9,#% 4%5 S,9$

-,5+:,%,%< :#SVD/#5L29,?,9* 4</,2L:9L/4: :4%5 4%5 -$,09,%< ,9 9# 2#33+/2,4: 4%5,%5L-9/,4: D/#5L29,#%B ,9 ,- %# -L/D/,-+ 9$49 /+-+4/2$+/- $4?+ 0#L%5 4% ,%2/+4-+ ,%9$+ 5,?+/<+%2+ #0 :4%5 D/,2+- U+9S++% 4%5 S,9$,% 9$+ L/U4% 4%5 D/#?,%2,4: /+<,#%-\(4DL%# @FCF]' G9 U+-9 9$+ :,3,9+5 :#24: D/,2+ 2#%?+/<+%2+ #% -#3+ :,3,9+55,3+%-,#%- 2#LD:+5 S,9$ 3,%#/ <+#</4D$,2 -D,::#?+/- -$#S $#S :,99:+ D/#</+--9$+ 2#L%9/* $4- 345+ ,% 3#?,%< 9#S4/5 4 -,%<:+ ,%9+</49+5 .$,:,DD,%+ 5#3+-9,234/I+9'

G:: 9$+-+ /,<,5,9,+-bS$+9$+/ 5+:,U+/49+:* 2/+49+5 U* -+:0V,%9+/+-9+5 +:,9+-#/ S$+9$+/ 9$+* 4/+ $#:5#?+/- 0/#3 $,-9#/,24: 422,5+%9-b2#%9/,UL9+ 9# 4 %49,#% #0S4-9+5 #DD#/9L%,9,+- 4%5 D+/-,-9+%9 /+%9 -++I,%<' K9 ,- D/+2,-+:* 9$+-+ -#/9- #05,-9#/9,#%- 9$49 4/+ S+:: +aD:#,9+5 U* 9$+ 3#-9 S+::V9/4,%+5B U+-9 2#%%+29+5B 4%53#-9 ,%0:L+%9,4: D/+0+//+5 </#LD- 9$49 )#/9$B ^4::,-B 4%5 ^+,%<4-9 \@FFh]5+-2/,U+ 4- 9*D,24: #0 9$+ :,3,9+5 422+-- #/5+/'

V. WHAT ARE THE MOST COMMONLY RECOMMENDED REFORMS?

H+-D,9+ 9$+ 2:+4/ 4%5 <:4/,%< D/#U:+3- 9$49 9$+-+ 4%5 #9$+/ 5,-9#/9,#%-/+D/+-+%9B S$49 4/+ 9S# #0 9$+ 3#-9 $,<$:* D/#3#9+5 /+0#/3- #09+% -L<<+-9+5 0#/9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-`

J4a 2#::+29,#% \#/ 0,-24: /+0#/3] 4%5 ,%0/4-9/L29L/+ 5+?+:#D3+%9'Y G% L%U,4-+5 #U-+/?+/ S#L:5 U+ $4/5 D/+--+5 9# -++ S$* 9$+-+ /+0#/3- 0:#S

%49L/4::* 0/#3 9$+ D/#U:+3- S+ $4?+ ,5+%9,0,+5'^$49c- S/#%< S,9$ 9$+-+ /+0#/3-` G:9$#L<$ 9$+-+ -L<<+-9,#%- $4?+ :#%<

4%5 5,-9,%<L,-$+5 D+5,</++-B 4%5 ,0 ,3D:+3+%9+5 #09+% S#L:5 ,3D/#?+ 9$+ :#9 #0

3#-9 L%5+/5+?+:#D+5 %49,#%-B 49 :+4-9 0/#3 9$+ -94%5D#,%9 #0 342/# -94U,:,9*B ,9 ,-%+?+/ 345+ 2:+4/ U* 9$+ ?4/,#L- ,%?+-9,<49,%< 4<+%2,+- S$* 9$+-+ 4/+ 9$+ 0,/-9/+0#/3- L-L4::* D/#3#9+5 0#/ .$,:,DD,%+- 4%5 34%* -,3,:4/ %49,#%-' K- ,9 4%,3D:,2,9 453,--,#% #0 ,3D#9+%2+ ,% 9$+ 042+ #0 3#/+ -+/,#L- -9/L29L/4: 5,-9#/9,#%-`H#+- ,9 /+0:+29 4 0,%4%2,4:n0,-24: U,4- #% 9$+ D4/9 #0 #/<4%,W49,#%- :,I+ 9$+ ^#/:584%I #/ K=6 9$49 0#2L- #?+/ -9/+%L#L-:* #% 9$+ 5,/+29 5+9+/3,%4%9- #0 -$#/9 9+/3,%?+-93+%9` K- 9$+/+ -#3+ 5,/+ 0,-24: 2/,-,- 9$49 ,- ,33,%+%9` J$49 9$+/+ 4/+ %#2#%?,%2,%< 4%-S+/- 9# 9$,- -L<<+-9 9$49 9$+ 0#2L- #0 4%4:*-,- $4- U++% 3,-D:42+5'J$+/+ ,- %+?+/ 4 2:+4/ :,%I 345+ U+9S++% 9$+ 3#/+ 0L%543+%94: 5,-9#/9,#%- ,% 9$+

YK%2/+4-,%< 94a /+?+%L+- 4/+ 9$+ D/,34/* /+0#/3- 5,-2L--+5 U* 9$+ K%9+/%49,#%4: =#%+94/* 6L%5c-\K=6]G/#/4 \@FCF] ,% 5,-2L--,%< -L<<+-9,#%- 0#/ D/#3#9,%< ,%?+-93+%9 ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-' J$+* 4/+ 4:-# 0,/-9 #%9$+ :,-9 #0 </#S9$VD/#3#9,%< /+0#/3- ,% K=6 \@FCF]' R+9 %+,9$+/ D/#D#-4: 5/4S- 4 9,<$9 :,%I U+9S++% 9$+5*-0L%29,#%- #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3* 4%5 94a 2#::+29,#%'



C@ G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

.$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3* 4%5 9$+-+ D/#D#-4:-' GU#?+ 4::B 9$+/+ $4- %+?+/ U++% 4

2#3D/+$+%-,?+ +00#/9 9# +-9,349+ _L4%9,949,?+:* 9$+ 4/+4- S$+/+ 5,-9#/9,#%- 4/+</+49+-9 4%5 S$+/+ /+0#/3 ,- #0 </+49+-9 ,3D#/9 %#/ 9# 4/<L+ S$* 9$+-+ /+0#/3- 4/+:,4U:+ 9# 34I+ 4 :4/<+ 3+4-L/4U:+ 5,00+/+%2+ -$#L:5 9$+* U+ -L22+--0L::*,3D:+3+%9+5' K%5++5B 9$+/+ $4?+ U++% 0+SB ,0 4%*B %49,#%- ,% $,-9#/* 9$49 S+/+4U:+ 9# D/#3#9+ -L22+--0L: :#%<V9+/3 5+?+:#D3+%9 D/,34/,:* U* U+<,%%,%< S,9$0,-24: /+-9/L29L/,%<' G9 U+-9B 0,-24: /+0#/3 422#3D4%,+5 3#/+ 0L%543+%94:2$4%<+- 9$49 [L3D-94/9+5 9$+ +2#%#3*'

8+24L-+ 9$+ %49L/+ #0 .$,:,DD,%+ 5,-9#/9,#%- $4?+ %#9 U++% S+::V-9L5,+5B+-D+2,4::* 0/#3 4 _L4%9,949,?+ -94%5D#,%9B ,9 ,- %#9 D#--,U:+ 9# -4* ,0 9$+ :4U#/34/I+9 2#%-9/4,%9- #/ 9$#-+ #% 4</,2L:9L/4: :4%5-B #/ #% W#%,%<B #/ #% 0#/+,<%#S%+/-$,D 4/+ 9$+ 3#-9 ,3D#/94%9 -#L/2+- #0 L%2#3D+9,9,?+%+-- 4%5 0429#/ 34/I+9,%+00,2,+%2* ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-' 8L9 9$+* 4/+ 4:3#-9 2+/94,%:* 3#/+ D:4L-,U:+24%5,549+- 0#/ :42I #0 -9/L29L/4: 45[L-93+%9- 9$4% 9$+ #09V2,9+5 D/#U:+3- #0 D##/94a 2#::+29,#% #/ D##/ ,%0/4-9/L29L/+' R+-B :#S /+?+%L+- $4/3 9$+ <#?+/%3+%9c-4U,:,9* 9# -LDD:* DLU:,2 <##5-B UL9 ,9 ,- L%:,I+:* 9$49 3#/+ /+?+%L+ D+/ -+ S#L:55# 3L2$ 9# U/,5<+ 9$+ <4D U+9S++% ,%5L-9/* 4%5 4</,2L:9L/+ ,0 ,9 ,- -,3D:* %#90+4-,U:+ 9# $,/+ S#/I+/- 9# 9$+ D#,%9 S+/+ 9$+ S4<+ <4D U+9S++% 9$+ 9S# S#L:5-,3D:* 5,-4DD+4/' G<4,%B ,%0/4-9/L29L/+ 24% 2#%9/,UL9+ 9# +4-,%< 9$+ :42I #02#3D+9,9,#%B UL9 ,9 ,- 2#%-9/4,%+5 U* 4 S#/:5 ,% S$,2$ L%2#3D+9,9,?+%+-- 4%53#%#D#:* 4/+ UL,:9 ,%9# 9$+ :4S- 4%5 4,5+5 U* D##/ ,%-9,9L9,#%- 4%5 2#//LD9

D#:,9,2-' )#S ,0 S+ 9L/% 9# 4%#9$+/ 2#33#% /+0#/3b9$+ /+5L29,#% #0 2#//LD9,#%

4%5 042,:,949,%< ,3D/#?+5 <#?+/%4%2+b9$,%<- <+9 ,%9+/+-9,%<'K9 ,- 4:3#-9 2+/94,%:* 9$+ 24-+ 9$49 D/#U:+3- #0 <#?+/%4%2+ 4%5 D##/

,%-9,9L9,#%4: 4//4%<+3+%9- 422#L%9 0#/ 34%* #0 9$+ ,::%+--+- 042+5 U* 5+?+:#D,%<%49,#%-' 8L9 #09+% <#?+/%4%2+ ,- 5,-2L--+5 ,% DL/+:* 9+2$%#2/49,2 04-$,#%' 8L9 4-/+-+4/2$+/- #% 2#//LD9,#% $4?+ %#9+5B 2#//LD9,#% ,- 4 3L:9,042+9+5 D$+%#3+%#%B4%5 499+3D9,%< 9# -,3D:* /+5L2+ 2#//LD9,#% S,9$#L9 /+<4/5 9# ,9- -#L/2+- #/

?4/,+9,+- ,- #09+% 4D9 9# 34I+ 9$+ #?+/4:: D/#U:+3 S#/-+'K%5++5B S+ %++5 9# U+ /+3,%5+5 9$49 S$,:+ -*-9+3,2 2#//LD9,#% ,- U45B

,%5,?,5L4: 429- #0 2#//LD9,#% #09+% $4?+ L9,:,9* ,% 5*-0L%29,#%4: +%?,/#%3+%9-' dK%-$#/9B ,0 9$+ D/+?4,:,%< -*-9+3 ,- U45B 9$+% 2#//LD9,#% 34* U+ <##5f \e:,9<44/5ChAAB YY]' 6#/ +a43D:+B -*-9+3- S,9$ ?+/* 5+0+29,?+ /+<L:49,#%-B -L2$ 4- $,<$,3D#/9 94/,00- #/ 3#%#D#:* +%$4%2,%< /+<L:49,#%-B 34* 5+-9/#* -# 3L2$ D#9+%9,4:9/45+ 4%5 ,%?+-93+%9 9$49 2#//LD9,#% ,- 429L4::* 4 -+%-,U:+ 4%5 /+:49,?+:* +00,2,+%93+2$4%,-3 0#/ D4/9,4::* 5+0+49,%< 9$+ S#/-9 /+<L:49,#%-' >%0#/9L%49+:* #0 2#L/-+B2#//LD9,#%B +?+% ,0 ,%5,?,5L4::* +00,2,+%9B 2#%9/,UL9+- 9# 9$+ 5+:,<,9,3,W49,#% #0 9$+

+%9,/+ :+<4: 4%5 D#:,9,24: -*-9+3 4%5 ,% -# 5#,%<B 34I+- ,9 $4/5 0#/ 4 -949+ 9#/+4--+/9 ,9- 4L9$#/,9* ,% 3L2$ %++5+5 4/+4-B S$+9$+/ ,% :4S 4%5 #/5+/B #/ 2#%9/429+%0#/2+3+%9B #/ ,% -#2,4: 4,5 9# 4::+?,49+ D#?+/9* #/ D/#3#9+ DLU:,2 $+4:9$'



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR CY

K9 ,- ,%9+/+-9,%< 9$49 #%+ #0 e:,9<44/5c- 24-+ -9L5,+- ,% $,- U##IControlling

Corruption \ChAA] 0#2L-+5 #% 9$+ S#/I #0 "L-9,2+ .:4%4 ,% $,- 499+3D9- 9# /+,% ,%2#//LD9,#% ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-c- #S% 8L/+4L #0 K%9+/%4: O+?+%L+ \8KO]' K%5,-2L--,%< 9$+ :,3,9- #0 4%9,2#//LD9,#% 3+4-L/+-B e:,9<44/5 42I%#S:+5<+5 9$49.:4%4c- /+0#/3- -++3+5 9# S#/I U+-9 0#/ 4 :,3,9+5 D+/,#5 #0 9,3+B 4%5 9$49

U42I-:,5,%< S4- 9*D,24: 0/#3 9$+ ChAF- #%' )#%+9$+:+-- $+ D/4,-+5 .:4%4c- +00#/9-4%5 -L<<+-9+5 4 0/43+S#/I 0#/ /+0#/3 2+%9+/+5 #% -+:+29,%< 4DD/#D/,49+ 4<+%9-B2$4%<,%< 9$+,/ /+S4/5 -9/L29L/+B <49$+/,%< U+99+/ ,%0#/349,#%B /+-9/L29L/,%< 9$+4<+%9k2:,+%9 /+:49,#%-$,D 9# 3,%,3,W+ 3#%#D#:* D#S+/B 4%5 2$4%<,%< 499,9L5+-4U#L9 2#//LD9,#%' P0 9$+-+ 3+4-L/+-B 9$+ 0,/-9 9$/++ -++3 2:#-+:* 9,+5 9# 49+2$%#2/49,2 -#:L9,#% S,9$,% +a,-9,%< 4<+%2,+- S$,:+ 9$+ :499+/ 9S# D#,%9- -++3S+:: #L9-,5+ 9$+ U#L%5- #0 4%* D4/9,2L:4/ U/4%2$ #0 9$+ <#?+/%3+%9' K% 9$49 -+%-+B9$+ D#,%9 4U#L9 :,3,9,%< 3#%#D#:* D#S+/ ,- %#9 4U#L9 9$+ 94-I #0 4%* -D+2,0,24<+%2* UL9 4U#L9 2$4%<,%< 9$+ D#:,2* /+<L:49,#%- 9$+3-+:?+-' K0 9$+ <#?+/%3+%9,- 4-I+5 9# 5# 9## 3L2$B 4%5 ,0 9$+ 94-I- 9$49 9$+ <#?+/%3+%9 +00+29,?+:* L/<+- ,9--+/?4%9- 9# D+/0#/3 4/+ 0#2L-+5 #% :,3,9,%< 422+-- 9# UL-,%+-- 4%5 U:#2I,%< #D+%2#33+/2+B ,9 S,:: ,%+?,94U:* :+45 9# 5+-D4,/ 4- $L<+ ,%2+%9,?+- S,:: UL,:5 LD 9#+?45,%< #/ ,<%#/,%< 9$+ -9/,29L/+-' G- 0#/ 9$+ 2L:9L/+ #0 2#//LD9,#%B ,9 ,- /49$+/5,00,2L:9 9# -++ $#S 3L2$ #0 9$,- ,- 5L+ 9# -#2,4: #/ $,-9#/,24: $4U,9- 9$49 4/+5,00,2L:9 9# 2$4%<+B 4%5 $#S 3L2$ ,- 4 /+-L:9 #0 04,:+5 +%0#/2+3+%9 :+45,%< 9# 4-+%-+ 9$49 4%9,2#//LD9,#% ,- 4 -$#/9V/L% <4,% S$#-+ U+%+0,9- 4/+ 9## -34:: 9# U+-L-94,%4U:+ ,% 9$+ :#%< /L% S,9$#L9 2$4%<,%< 9$+ #?+/4:: /L:+-'

K% 9$49 -+%-+B ,9 ,- $4/5 9# -++ $#S :,3,9,%< 2#//LD9,#% 24% U+ 4 <+%+/4:-9/49+<*' O49$+/B 2#%9/#::,%< 2#//LD9,#% ,- :,I+ 2L/,%< 9$+ 2#33#% 2#:5' J$+/+ 4/+4 $L<+ %L3U+/ #0 0#/3- #0 2#//LD9,#% 4%5 /+4-#%- 0#/ ,9- +a,-9+%2+ [L-9 4- 9$+/+4/+ 4 3L:9,9L5+ #0 2#:5V24L-,%< ?,/L-+-' J$L- 2#%9/#::,%< -D+2,0,2 9*D+- #02#//LD9,#% +%94,:- 4 [#,%9 D/#5L29 #0 /+0#/3,%< 4 D4/9,2L:4/ -+29#/ #0 9$+ /+<L:49#/*4%5 0,-24: -9/L29L/+ -,3L:94%+#L-:* S,9$ 4 /+%+S+5 +00#/9 9# +%0#/2+ -+:+29+5 :4S-4%5 /L:+-' GU-+%9 4 -S++D,%< 2$4%<+ ,% S$49 ,- U+,%< 94a+5B 2#%9/#::+5B #/

2#::+29+5B ,9 ,- L%:,I+:* 9$49 4 3+/+ U:4%I+9 +%5#/-+3+%9 #0 </+49+/ -9/,29%+--9#S4/5 UL/+4L2/49- S,:: /+-L:9 ,% :4-9,%< ?,29#/,+-'

=#/+#?+/B ,9 -$#L:5 U+ 2:+4/+/ 9$49 _L4%9,949,?+:* +-9,349,%< S$,2$ -+29#/-S#L:5 3#-9 U+%+0,9 0/#3 ,3D/#?+5 +%0#/2+3+%9 4%5 S$,2$ -+29#/- 4/+ :,I+:* 9#

D/#5L2+ </+49+/ /+-,-94%2+ 0#/ 3,%,34: <4,% ,- 2/,9,24: 9# 4%* -+/,#L- D:4% #0429,#%' G- 9$+ .:4%4 /+0#/3- 2+%9+/+5 #% 9$+ 8KO 4%5 #% 94a 2#::+29,#%B S$* ,- 9$+8KO 9$+ 3#-9 ,3D#/94%9 -#L/2+ #0 2#//LD9,#% 4%5 $#S 3L2$ #0 ,9- D/#U:+3-S#L:5 U+ 3,%,3,W+5 ,0 34%* 94a+- S+/+ 9# U+ /+3#?+5 #/ -,3D:,0,+5` J$+_L,a#9,2 5+-,/+ 0#/ ,%2/+4-+5 /+?+%L+ S,9$#L9 2$4%<,%< ,%2+%9,?+- 0#/ +00,2,+%9

D/#5L29,#% -++3- 49 U+-9 34/<,%4:B 4%5 49 S#/-9B %#9 2:+4/:* -LDD#/9+5 U*$,-9#/,24: S#/I #% 9$+ /,-+ #0 -L22+--0L: +2#%#3,+-'



CX G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

VI. UNDERSTANDING SUCCESSFUL REFORM

Q#S -$#L:5 S+ 4%4:*W+ 5+?+:#D3+%9 D/#D#-4:-` H#+- ,5+%9,0*,%< 9$+34[#/ 4/+4- #0 5,-9#/9,#% 9+:: L- S$+/+ S+ -$#L:5 0#2L- #L/ /+0#/3 D/#D#-4:-`J$,- ,- S$+/+ 4% 4S4/+%+-- #0 ,%-9,9L9,#%4: 2#%5,9,#%- 4%5 D#:,9,24: ,%9+/+-9-9+3D+/- 9$+ 2/L5+ :+--#%- #0 4 %+#2:4--,24: 4%4:*-,- #0 +2#%#3,2 5,-9#/9,#%-' "L-9

U+24L-+ -+29#/ G #/ /+<,#% p ,- 9$+ 34[#/ -#L/2+ #0 D##/ D+/0#/34%2+ 5#+- %#9,3D:* 9$49 9$+ D/+0+//+5 D/#D#-4: ,- 9# -,3D:* /+3#?+ -4,5 5,-9#/9,#%' 1?+% ,0 4/+0#/3 9# 9$+ ,5+4: 0,/-9VU+-9 -#:L9,#% +a,-9- ,% 9$+#/*B 9$+/+ 4/+ 34%* D#:,9,24: 4%5,%-9,9L9,#%4: /+4-#%- S$* ,9 ,- L%:,I+:* 9$49 34%* 0,/-9VU+-9 /+0#/3- 4/+ +,9$+/,%0+4-,U:+ #/ L%-L-94,%4U:+ S,9$ 2L//+%9 -#2,4: 4%5 D#:,9,24: 4//4%<+3+%9-'

J$#L<$ 5+?+:#D,%< 4%5 ,3D:+3+%9,%< 429L4: /+0#/3- ,- %#9 4 #%+V#00 D/#D#-4:B 9$+ 0#::#S,%< -$#L:5 <L,5+ L- 4- 2#%-9/4,%9- ,% #L/ 429,#%N

6,/-9B 5+?+:#D3+%9 4%5 +a9+/%4: 4,5 4<+%2,+- 4/+ %#9 #%:* :,3,9+5 ,% 9$+,/ D#S+/ 4%5 24D42,9* 9# ,%-,-9 #% /+0#/3B UL9 +?+% S$+% 9$+* 4/+ +3D#S+/+5b D+/$4D- 9$/#L<$ 2#%5,9,#%4:,9* #/ 9$/#L<$ -#3+ 0#/9L,9#L- D#:,9,24:2,/2L3-94%2+-b9# D/#3#9+ D4/9,2L:4/ 2$4%<+-B 9$+* 4/+ ,::V-L,9+5 9# 3#%,9#/ -L2$/+0#/3- ,% 9$+ :#%< /L%' K%5++5B 9$+ S,::,%<%+-- 9# <,?+ 4,5 #% 9$+ D4/9 #0,%5,?,5L4:- 4%5 #0 5#%#/ %49,#%- ,- %#9 3492$+5 U* 4% +_L,?4:+%9 S,::,%<%+-- 9#34I+ -L/+ 9$49 9$+ 4,5 ,- D/#D+/:* L-+5 4%5 9/L:* U+%+0,9- 9$+ ,%9+%5+5 /+2,D,+%9-'J$L-B S+ -$#L:5 U+ -I+D9,24: #0 4%* D/#D#-4:- 9$49 S#L:5 #%:* S#/I ,0 4%,5+4:,W+5 +a9+/%4: UL/+4L2/42*b,9-+:0 U+$#:5+% 9# D#:,9,24: ,%9+/+-9- 0/#3 5#%#/2#L%9/,+-bS+/+ 9# 3#%,9#/ 4%5 +%0#/2+ /+0#/3- #% 4 /+<L:4/ U4-,-'

M+2#%5B U+24L-+ +a,-9,%< 2#%5,9,#%-B ,%2:L5,%< 9$+ ?+/* 5,-9#/9,#%- 9$49-+/?+ 4- 9$+ U,<<+-9 #U-942:+- 9# 4 %49L/4: 5+?+:#D3+%9 D49$B 4/+ 4% +_L,:,U/,L3-LDD#/9+5 U* 2#4:,9,#%- #0 +:,9+- 4%5 ,3D#/94%9 -+<3+%9- #0 9$+ 34--+- ,9 ,- :,I+:*9$49 4%* 9/L:* L-+0L: /+0#/3 S,:: #%:* 2#3+ 4U#L9 ,0 4 2/,9,24: -LU-+9 #0 9$#-+2#4:,9,#%- -++- 9$49 9$+ %+S /+0#/3- 4/+ ,% 9$+,/ U+-9 ,%9+/+-9-' J$,- L-L4::* 2#3+-4U#L9 ,0 9$+/+ 4/+ +a9+/%4: -$#2I-B -L2$ 4- 4 34[#/ 9+2$%#:#<,24: 2$4%<+B -#3+

-#/9 #0 D#:,9,24: +2#%#3,2 2/,-,-B #/ 4 2$4%<+ ,% ,%9+/%49,#%4: 2#%5,9,#%- #0 9/45+B#/ D+/$4D- +?+% 4 -$,09 ,% DLU:,2 #D,%,#% 9$49 4::#S- 0#/ /+0#/3- 9$49 L%5+/3,%+9$+ +a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aD4%5 /+0#/3-'

G- -9/+--+5 ,% 4 D/+?,#L- -+29,#%B :,3,9,%< 2#//LD9,#% S,9$#L9 /+0#/3,%< 4:+<4: 4%5 /+<L:49#/* -*-9+3 9$49 +%2#L/4<+- 4%5 -LDD#/9- 4 5,-9#/9+5 +2#%#3,2-*-9+3 ,- U#9$ 0L9,:+ 4%5 ,- :,I+:*B +?+% S,9$ D4/9,4: -L22+--B 9# +%2#L/4<+ :#%<+/V/L% 5*-0L%29,#%- U* ,%2/+4-,%< 9$+ -9/4,% U+9S++% S$49 ,- 5+34%5+5 4%5 S$49



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR CZ

#DD#/9L%,9,+- 4/+ U+,%< U*D4--+5' J$+ :4/<+/ 9$+ #DD#/9L%,9* 2#-9- #0 34/I+9

5+-9/#*,%< /L:+- 4%5 /+<L:49,#%-B 9$+ </+49+/ 3L-9 D#:,9,24: D49/#%4<+ 4%5 /+%9V-++I,%< U+ 9# 9,+ 9$+ ,%9+/+-9- #0 9$+ 2/,9,24: 2#4:,9,#%- 9# +a,-9,%< 4//4%<+3+%9-'J$,- ,- S$* -L55+% 9+2$%,24: ,%%#?49,#%- #/ -$,09- ,% 9$+ %49L/+ #0 S#/:5 UL-,%+--$4?+ #09+% U++% 9$+ 2494:*-9- 0#/ -L-94,%+5 /+0#/3 S$+/+ S+::V3+4%,%<B :#%<+/V/L% :+<4: +00#/9- $4?+ D/+?,#L-:* 04,:+5'

G <##5 +a43D:+ 24% U+ -++% ,% 9$+ S#/:5 #0 9+:+2#33L%,249,#%-' G:: #?+/9$+ S#/:5 9$+ D499+/% 0#/ 3#-9 #0 9$+ @F9$ 2+%9L/* S4- #%+ #0 4 $,<$:* 2+%9/4:,W+5%49,#%4: 3#%#D#:* #% 9+:+D$#%+ -+/?,2+B 9*D,24::* S,9$ D/,2,%< 4//4%<+5 -# 9$49:#%< 5,-94%2+ 24::- -LU-,5,W+5 :#24: -+/?,2+' K% 3#-9 D##/ 4%5 +?+% 34%*5+?+:#D+5 %49,#%-B 422+-- 9# 9+:+D$#%+- S4- -+?+/+:* :,3,9+5' =#/+#?+/B#U94,%,%< 4%5 D4*,%< 0#/ 4 D$#%+ :,%+ S4- 34/I+5 U* U#9$ :#%< _L+L+- 4%5 #09+%4 %++5 0#/ -,5+ D4*3+%9- 4%5n#/ D#:,9,24: ,%0:L+%2+' &4/,#L- D/#</43- #0 /+0#/3S+/+ 0/+_L+%9:* 5,-2L--+5 0/#3 9$+ ChgF- 9$/#L<$ 9$+ +4/:* ChAF-B UL9 3#-92#L%9/,+- 5,5 :,99:+ 9# :,U+/4:,W+ 9+:+2#3-'

J$+ .$,:,DD,%+- S4- ,% +-D+2,4::* U45 -$4D+ S,9$ :+-- 9$4% #%+ 0,a+5 :4%5:,%+ 0#/ +?+/* $L%5/+5 D+#D:+ 4- :49+ 4- ChhFb4 /49,# 9$49 $45 2$4%<+5 ?+/* :,99:+-,%2+ 4 5+245+ #/ 9S# +4/:,+/ \=#/4:+- @FCF]' Q#S+?+/ 4 2#3U,%49,#% #0<#?+/%3+%9 /+0#/3- 4,3+5 49 :,U+/4:,W,%< 9+:+2#33L%,249,#%- 2#3U,%+5 S,9$ 9$+4//,?4: #0 3#U,:+ 9+:+D$#%* ,% ChhY 4%5 409+/ -+/?+5 9# 5/4349,24::* 2$4%<+ 9$+:4%5-24D+ #0 D+/-#%4: 4%5 UL-,%+-- 2#33L%,249,#%-' ^,9$,% CF *+4/-B :4%5 :,%+9+:+5+%-,9* $45 ,%2/+4-+5 9# 4U#L9 h D+/ CFF D+#D:+' 8L9 3#/+ ,3D#/94%9:*B3#U,:+ 9+:+D$#%* /+4::* -+/?+5 4- 9$+ </+49 +_L4:,W+/B /4D,5:* #?+/94I,%< :4%5:,%+- ,% ,3D#/94%2+ 4%5 L-+ U* @FFF' K%5++5B 2#3D4/+5 9# ,9- %+,<$U#/- ,%GM1G)B 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- S+%9 0/#3 U+,%< -LU-94%9,4::* U+:#S 4?+/4<+ ,%9+:+D$#%+ 422+-- 9# $4?,%< </+49+/ 9$4% 4?+/4<+ 2#?+/4<+ ,% @FFF' =#/+#?+/B ,9S4- %+4/:* 4:#%+ ,% $4?,%< 4U#L9 9S,2+ 4- 34%* 3#U,:+ -LU-2/,U+/- 4- :4%5 :,%+-'8* @FFhB 9$+/+ S+/+ /#L<$:* iF 3,::,#% 3#U,:+ D$#%+ -LU-2/,D9,#%- ,% 9$+.$,:,DD,%+- 0#/ 4 2#L%9/* #0 h@ 3,::,#% D+#D:+B S$,2$ 3+4%9 U+,%< 2:#-+ 9#

L%,?+/-4: 422+-- +?+% S$+% 94I,%< ,%9# 2#%-,5+/49,#% 9$+ -LU-94%9,4: %L3U+/- #0 D+#D:+ S,9$ 3L:9,D:+ 2+:: D$#%+- \=#/4:+- @FCF]'

P0 2#L/-+B 9$,- ,- %#9 9# -4* 9$49 9+:+2#33L%,249,#%- ,- +,9$+/ 0L::* #D+% #/0L::* 2#3D+9,9,?+ ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-' K9 ,- -9,:: 4 $,<$:* /+<L:49+5 4%5 -#3+S$492:#-+5 ,%5L-9/*' 8L9 9$+ L-+0L:%+-- #0 9$+ +a43D:+ ,- 9# ,::L-9/49+ $#S 4 34[#/9+2$%#:#<,24: ,%%#?49,#% 2#3U,%+5 S,9$ +?+% ,3D+/0+29 /+<L:49#/* /+0#/3- 24%2#3U,%+ 9# 5/4349,24::* ,%2/+4-+ 422+-- 4%5 2#3D+9,9,#% ,% 4 S4* 9$49 ,-

D#:,9,24::* -L-94,%4U:+' G:3#-9 4:: 2#L%9/,+- 9$49 #D+%+5 LD 9# 3#U,:+ 9+:+D$#%*-4S 9$+ 3#%#D#:* /+%9- 0/#3 :4%5 :,%+- +/#5+' 8L9 ,% 9$,- 24-+ 9$+ #DD#/9L%,9*

2#-9 S4- -# $L<+ 9$49 3#-9 -949+- 042+5 4 -94/I 2$#,2+B +,9$+/ :#-+ 9$+ U+%+0,9- #0 40L::* 2#%9/#::+5 <#?+/%3+%9 3#%#D#:* #% 9+:+2#3- #/ :#-+ #L9 #% 9$+ $L<+ U+%+0,9- #0 3#U,:+ 9+:+D$#%*' J$L-B +?+% S$+/+ 9$+ ,%9/#5L29,#% #0 3#U,:+9+:+D$#%* /+_L,/+5 2#%2+--,#%- 9# D#S+/0L: :#24: ,%9+/+-9- 9$49 2/+49+5 %+S



Cg G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

3#%#D#:* /+%9-B 9$+ <+%+/4::* </+49+/ 2#3D+9,9,?+%+-- 4%5 $L<+ 2#%-L3+/ -L/D:L-

9# U+ 5+/,?+5 0/#3 S,5+-D/+45 D$#%+ 422+-- <L4/4%9++5 9$49 4 -+2#%5VU+-9-#:L9,#% S#L:5 ,%+?,94U:* :+45 9# </+49+/ 2#%-L3+/ S+:04/+B 4%5 ,% 9$+ :#%< /L%-D,:: #?+/ 9# ,3D/#?+5 2#3D+9,9,#% ,% UL-,%+--+- 4%5 ,%5L-9/,+-b0/#3 2#3DL9+/-B9# 34/I+9,%<B 9# #L9-#L/2+5 -+/?,2+- 9$49 4/+ 5+D+%5+%9 #% ,3D/#?+5 D$#%+,%0/4-9/L29L/+' =#/+ ,3D#/94%9:*B ,9 4:,<%- UL-,%+-- 4%5 2#%-L3+/ ,%9+/+-9- S,9$,3D/#?+5 2#33L%,249,#%-' J$,- ,- 4% ,3D#/94%9 :+--#% 4U#L9 +%2#L/4<,%<-+2#%5VU+-9 -#:L9,#%- 9$49 D/#3#9+ </+49+/ #D+%%+-- ,% 9$+ :#%<+/ /L% +?+% ,0 9$+*-++3 9# U+ -9/L29L/4::* 0:4S+5 ,% 9$+ -$#/9 /L%'

VII. FRAMING SOLUTIONS

G:9$#L<$ S+ $4?+ /+:,+5 $+4?,:* #% 9$+ +a43D:+ #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- ,% 9$,-+--4*B 2+/94,% D/,%2,D:+- 24% U+ L-+5 9# 0/43+ 3#-9 D/#U:+3- #0 5+?+:#D3+%9

D#:,2*'6,/-9B 34I+ 0L:: L-+ #0 -94%54/5 +2#%#3,2 9$+#/* 9# 5+?+:#D 4 /,<#/#L-B

_L4%9,949,?+ 4%4:*-,- #0 9$+ 34[#/ -9/L29L/4: 5,-9#/9,#%- #0 4 <,?+% +2#%#3*' 6#/9$+ 3#-9 D4/9B 9$,- ,- ?4:L4U:+ 0#/ 4:: %49,#%- 49 S$49+?+/ -94<+ #0 5+?+:#D3+%9'Q#S+?+/B 9$,- S,:: U+ +-D+2,4::* L-+0L: 0#/ :+-- 5+?+:#D+5 +2#%#3,+-' ^$*`8+24L-+ 4U-#:L9+ D/+2,-,#% ,- :+-- ,3D#/94%9 9$4% ,5+%9,0*,%< 9$+ 34[#/,3U4:4%2+- ,% 9$+ +2#%#3* 4%5 4--,<%,%< /#L<$ +-9,349+- #0 9$+,/ #?+/4:: 2#-9-'G:3#-9 U* 5+0,%,9,#%B 4 ?+/* D##/ 2#L%9/* ,- #D+/49,%< 04/ 4S4* 0/#3 9$+ 2L//+%99+2$%#:#<,24: D/#5L29,#% 0/#%9,+/' J$,- /+_L,/+- 9$49 34[#/ #U-942:+- 3L-9 U+ ,%

D:42+ 9$49 D/+?+%9 24D,94: 4%5 :4U#/ 0/#3 U+,%< /+4::#249+5 3#/+ D/#5L29,?+:*'K%5++5B 4- -$#L:5 U+ 2:+4/ 0/#3 9$+ 24-+ #0 9$+ .O( 4%5 34%* D##/ %49,#%- 9$49$4?+ -L55+%:* -++% /4D,5 +2#%#3,2 </#S9$B +?+% D4/9,4: /+0#/3- 9$49 -,3D:*4::#S 4 /+4::#249,#% #0 :4U#/ 9# 9$+ 3#/+ D/#5L29,?+ -+29#/-B 4%5 4 :,3,9+5 #D+%,%<LD #0 9$+ +2#%#3* 9# 9$+ S#/:5 34/I+9 24% D/#5L2+ +a9/4#/5,%4/* ,3D/#?+3+%9-

,% 4 -$#/9 9,3+ U+24L-+ 9$+ 9+2$%#:#<* 4:/+45* +a,-9- 9# U+ 2#D,+5 #/ 45#D9+5 ,%9$+ /,<$9 ,%-9,9L9,#%4: 2#%9+a9'

GU-+%9 -L2$ 4% 4%4:*-,- #0 +2#%#3,2 5,-9#/9,#%-B S$,2$ 3,<$9 /+_L,/+ 9$+-LDD#/9 #0 4 34[#/ %49,#%4: 4<+%2* #/ #0 </#LD- :,I+ GH8B 9$+ ^#/:5 84%IB #/ 9$+K=6B 3#-9 /+0#/3 D/#D#-4:- #% 2#L%9/,+- :,I+ 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- 4/+ 0:*,%< U:,%5'M,%2+ S+ 5# %#9 I%#S S$,2$ 5,-9#/9,#%- 3499+/ 3#-9B S+ S,:: U+ $4/5 D/+--+5 9#L%5+/-94%5 S$,2$ #0 #L/ D/#D#-4:- 4/+ D/,34/,:* 4U#L9 5+?+:#D3+%9 #/ 4U#L9$L34%,94/,4% 4--,-94%2+B 4%5 S$,2$ #%+- 4/+ :,I+:* 9# D/#?,5+ <##5 dU4%< 0#/ 9$+

UL2If \U+%+0,9k2#-9 /49,#] +?+% /+:49,?+ 9# ,5+4: 2#%5,9,#%-' 8L9 9$,- ,- #%:* 9$+

0,/-9 -9+D' e%#S,%< S$49 9$+ 34[#/ 5,-9#/9,#%- 4/+ 5#+- )PJ %+2+--4/,:* 9+:: L-S$+/+ D#:,2* -$#L:5 U+ 5,/+29+5B +-D+2,4::* ,% 9$+ 4U-+%2+ #0 U+99+/ D#:,9,24: 4%5,%-9,9L9,#%4: I%#S:+5<+'



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR Ci

J$+ -+2#%5 S#L:5 U+ 9# ,5+%9,0* S$+/+ D#--,U:+ 9$+ U/#45 </#LD- 9$49

U+%+0,9 4%5 -L00+/ 9$+ 3#-9 0/#3 9$+ +a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a 3,a #0 -#2,4:B 2L:9L/4:B 4%5 ,5+#:#<,24: 2#%-,5+/49,#%- 34* 4:-# +aD:4,%

DLU:,2 -LDD#/9 0#/ D4/9,2L:4/ D#:,2,+- #/ D/#D#-4:- 9$49 -+/?+ 9# 94a 9$+ %49,#%c-+2#%#3,2 5+?+:#D3+%9' K% -#3+ 24-+- S+ 34* 0,%5 9$49 U45 /L:+- 4/+ #09+% 4-LU-9,9L9+ 0#/ D##/:* 5+?+:#D+5 -949+ 24D42,9* 9# +%0#/2+ #/5+/ #/ 4/+ 4 U*D/#5L29#0 D#:,9,24: 2#3D/#3,-+- S#/I+5 #L9 9# +%-L/+ 9$+ D+42+' G9 9$+ -43+ 9,3+B

D#:,2,+- 9$49 S+/+ 3,-94I+%:* D/#D#-+5 9# -#:?+ #:5 D/#U:+3- UL9 S$,2$ #%:*2/+49+5 %+S #%+- S,:: $4?+ -D4S%+5 34:454D9,?+ UL-,%+-- 4%5 D#:,9,24:4//4%<+3+%9- 4- </#LD- 4%5 ,%5,?,5L4:- -#L<$9 S4*- 9# D/#0,9 S$,:+422#33#549,%< 9$+3-+:?+- 9# 9$+ %+S /L:+-' J$,- #0 2#L/-+ S,:: 2/+49+ %+S /+%9-4%5 -D+2,4: ,%9+/+-9- 9$49 S,:: S#/I 9# D/+-+/?+ 9$#-+ ,%+00,2,+%2,+- 9$49 4/+ %#S

U+,%< +aD:#,9+5 0#/ ,%5,?,5L4: U+%+0,9' K5+4::*B 9$+ ,5+%9,0,249,#% #0 5,-9#/9,#%- ,%9$+ 0,/-9 -94<+ 4%5 #0 4--#2,49+5 ,%9+/+-9 </#LD- ,% 9$+ -+2#%5 S,:: $+:D 3492$

D/#D#-+5 /+0#/3- 9# 4/+4- S$+/+ /+-,-94%2+ ,- :,I+:* 9# U+ S+4I+/ #/ S$,2$ 24% U+3#/+ +4-,:* /+5,/+29+5 4:#%< D4/4::+: :,%+-'

J$,/5 4%5 3#-9 5,00,2L:9 ,- 9# 4--+-- 4%5 D/#D#-+ D#:,2,+- 9$49 9/* 9# 455/+--9$+ 34[#/ 5,-9#/9,#%- ,% S4*- 9$49 4/+ U#9$ D#:,9,24::* 4%5 ,%-9,9L9,#%4::* 0+4-,U:+'J$,- 3+4%- U+,%< 4S4/+ #0 9$+ 2#%-9/4,%9- #% 9$+ D4/9 #0 9$+ /+0#/3VD/#3#9,%<4<+%2* 4%5 #0 9$+ <#?+/%3+%9 4%5 D/,?49+ 429#/- 2$4/<+5 S,9$ +%0#/2,%< 9$+

/+0#/3- 4%5 D/#3#9,%< 9$+,/ 2#%9,%L+5 #D+/49,#%' J$+ ,5+4: /+0#/3- S,:: %#9 #%:*:+45 9# </+49+/ 2#3D+9,9,#% UL9 S,:: 2/+49+ :#24: ,%9+/+-9- S,9$ 4 -9/#%< -94I+ ,%-++,%< 9# ,9 9$49 9$+ 3#/+ D#-,9,?+ 4-D+29- #0 9$+ 2$4%<+ 4/+ 34,%94,%+5 4%5

U/#45+%+5 S$+%+?+/ D#--,U:+' ./#[+29- 9$49 2/+49+ 5+3#%-9/49,#% +00+29- #/ 9$49-+/?+ 4- ,%2+%9,?+- 9# #9$+/ /+<,#%-B 4<+%2,+-B #/ </#LD- 9# D+/0#/3 U+99+/ 4/++-D+2,4::* 5+-,/4U:+' =4/I+9V#D+%,%< /+0#/3- 4/+ 9# U+ D/,W+5 %#9 #L9 #0 -#3+-+%-+ #0 ,5+4:,-9,2 45$+/+%2+ 9# :,U+/4: D/,%2,D:+- UL9 #L9 #0 4% 4S4/+%+-- 9$49 0#/4 -34:: 2#L%9/* S,9$ S+4I ,%-9,9L9,#%-B %#9$,%< ,- 3#/+ ,3D#/94%9 9$4% 9# :,3,9 9$+5,-2/+9,#% #0 :#24: D#:,9,24: #/<4%,W49,#%- S,9$ /+<4/5 9# 3499+/- D+/94,%,%< 9#

,%?+-93+%9 4%5 9$+ +2#%#3*' ^,9$ #%:* :,3,9+5 2#%9/#: #0 9$+ 9/45+ ,% 4 D/#5L29#/ -+/?,2+B ,9 U+2#3+- $4/5+/ 0#/ 2#//LD9,#% 9# 0:#L/,-$ #/ 0#/ </#LD- 9# U++a2:L5+5' =#/+#?+/B #D+% ,%9+/%49,#%4: 2#3D+9,9,#% 34I+- 9$+ 2#-9- 4%5 U+%+0,9-



CA G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

#0 ,%+00+29,?+ D#:,2* 3#/+ 9/4%-D4/+%9 4- 9$+ S#/-9 0#/3- #0 ,%9+/0+/+%2+ :+45 9#

,33+5,49+ 4%5 $,<$:* ?,-,U:+ 2#-9-'K5+4::* /+0#/3- 4/+ -94/9+5 S$+/+ /+-,-94%2+ ,- S+4I+-9 4%5 S$+/+ 2$4%<+- U+2#3+ -+:0V-L-94,%,%< 4%5 $4/5 9# /+-,-9 #%2+ L%5+/ S4*'

J$+ /4%<+ #0 D#--,U:+ ,5+4- 9$49 3,<$9 U+ D/#3#9+5 -$#L:5 4 3#/+ 24/+0L:4%4:*-,- #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+ +2#%#3* U+ L%5+/94I+% 3L-9 U+ 2#%-,5+/+5' =4%* #09$+-+ $4?+ 4:/+45* U++% D/#D#-+5 U* ?4/,#L- 4,5 4<+%2,+- #/ 4/+ ?4/,4%9- #%+a,-9,%< ,5+4- ,% 9$+ :,9+/49L/+ UL9 9$+* 94I+ #% %+S 3+4%,%< S$+% -++% ,% 9$,-0/43+S#/I'

P%+ ,--L+ 2#33#%:* D/#3#9+5 #/ 5,-2L--+5 ,- +%2#L/4<,%< 0+5+/4:,-3 #/5+2+%9/4:,W49,#%' Q#S+?+/ ,9 $4- 9# U+ U#/%+ ,% 3,%5 9$49 ,9 ,- /4/+:* 9$+ 24-+ 9$499$+-+ D#:,9,24: 5+2,-,#%- 4/+ L%5+/94I+% 5+ %#?# #/ ,%5+D+%5+%9:* #0 #9$+/ D#:,2*2$4%<+-' J$+ ,3D#/94%9 ,--L+ 9# 0#2L- #% ,- 9$+ 2/+49,#% #0 3#/+ #DD#/9L%,9,+- 0#/

D#:,9,24: 4%5 -#2,4: +aD+/,3+%949,#% 4%5 9# 2/+49+ 3#/+ D#--,U,:,9,+- 0#/ </+49+/422+-- 9# D#:,9,24: 4%5 +2#%#3,2 2#3D+9,9,#%' J$+ :+--#% #0 9$+ .O(c- 2#4-94:/+0#/3- -$#L:5 %#9 U+ 9$49 9$+ .O( 2$#-+ 9$+ #%+ 9/L+ 3+9$#5 #0 #D+%,%< LD 42:#-+5 -*-9+3B UL9 9$49 9$+* 345+ ,9 D#--,U:+ 9# 9/* #L9 ?4/,49,#%-B 4%5 9$+%2#33,99+5 9# D/#9+29,%< 9$+ /+<,#%- 9$49 -L22+--0L::* /+0#/3+5 U* 4::#S,%< 9$+39# I++D #D+%,%< LD 4%5 /+94,%,%< 2#%9/#: #0 9$+,/ %+S:* 2/+49+5 /+?+%L+-' J$,- ,-L-L4::* 9$+ D/#U:+3 S,9$ 3#-9 +aD+/,3+%9- S,9$ -# 24::+5 0/++ 9/45+ W#%+-' K%3#-9 24-+- 9$+/+ ,- ?+/* :,99:+ 429L4: 4L9#%#3* </4%9+5B 9$+/+ ,- #%:* 3,%,34:/+-D,9+ 0/#3 +a,-9,%< /+<L:49,#%-B 4%5 9$+/+ ,- %# 2/+5,U:+ 2#33,93+%9 9$49:#%<+/V9+/3 ,%?+-93+%9B +-D+2,4::* U* 0#/+,<%+/-B S,:: U+ D/#9+29+5 0/#3#DD#/9L%,-9,2 D/+549,#% U* 9$+ -949+' P09+% 4 :#S+/ 94a /49+ 4%5 -#3+ 3,:5/+<L:49#/* +a+3D9,#%- 4/+ 9/+49+5 4- -L00,2,+%9 9# 5+2:4/+ 4% 4/+4 4 d0/++ 9/45+W#%+'f J$L-B 4% ,%9+/+-9,%< D#--,U,:,9* ,- 9# D/#3#9+ 3#/+ <+%L,%+:* #D+% 9/45,%<W#%+- ,% 2#L%9/,+- :,I+ 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-B S$+/+ /L:+- 4U#L9 +%9/*B ,%?+-93+%9B94a49,#%B :4U#/ /+<L:49,#%B 4%5 #S%+/-$,D \+?+% ,33,</49,#%] 4/+ $+4?,:*:,U+/4:,W+5 ,% +a2$4%<+ 0#/ :#%<+/ 9+/3 2#33,93+%9- 4%5 9$+ D/#?,-,#% #0

,%0/4-9/L29L/+ 4%5 #9$+/ ,%?+-93+%9- #% 9$+ D4/9 #0 0#/+,<% 0,/3-'1?+% $+/+ S+ 3L-9 U+ /+4:,-9,2' J$+/+ ,- 4 /+4-#% S$* 9$+ 34[#/ 2+%9+/-

#L9-,5+ 9$+ 24D,94: 4/+ %#9 ?,4U:+ 4:9+/%49,?+- 0#/ 3#-9 ,%?+-9#/-' )+S ?+%9L/+-3L-9 U+ U42I+5 U* -L00,2,+%9 D#:,9,24: 4%5 -#2,4: 4L9$#/,9* 9$49 2/+5,U,:,9* S,:: U+#U?,#L- 9# D#9+%9,4: +%9/4%9-' J$,- #09+% 3+4%- 4::*,%< S,9$ D/#3,%+%9 043,:,+- #/0429,#%- ,% 9$+ 2#L%9/* 9$49 3,<$9 U+%+0,9 5,00+/+%9,4::*' J$+ 2/,9,24: ,--L+ ,- 9$49+?+/* 2#%2+--,#% </4%9+5 -$#L:5 U+ -9/L29L/+5 ,% +a2$4%<+ 0#/ </+49+/ #D+%%+--4%5 +%$4%2+5 9/45+ ,% 9$+ 0L9L/+'

K% -#3+ S4*-B 9$+ ($4/9+/ (,9,+- 2#%2+D9 #0 .4L: O#3+/ \@FCC] ,- 4%

+a9/+3+ ?+/-,#% #0 9$,- ,5+4' K% +00+29 9$+ %49,#% 2+5+- 453,%,-9/49,?+ 2#%9/#: #0-#3+ 4/+4 #0 9$+ 2#L%9/* 4%5 4::#S- 4%#9$+/ %49,#% \D/+-L34U:* #%+ 9$49 ,-5+?+:#D+5 4%5 $4- 4 /+DL949,#% 0#/ <##5 ,%-9,9L9,#%-] 9# 453,%,-9+/ 9$+ 9+//,9#/*0#/ 4 :,3,9+5 D+/,#5 #0 9,3+ 0/++ #0 ,%9+/0+/+%2+ 0/#3 9$+ $#3+ 2#L%9/*' J$+ <#4:



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR Ch

,- 9# 2/+49+ 3,%, ?+/-,#%- #0 Q#%< e#%<B ($,%4 S,9$,% +a,-9,%< %49,#%4:

9+//,9#/,+-'G::#S,%< 0#/ 4 -+3,4L9#%#3#L- /+<,#% S,9$,% 4 <,?+% %49,#% -949+ 9$49 ,--9,:: 453,%,-9+/+5 U* 9$+ %49,#%4: <#?+/%3+%9 ,- 4% ,%9+/3+5,49+ -#:L9,#% 9$49 5#+-%#9 -++3 9# 2#3D/#3,-+ :#24: 4L9$#/,9* 4- 3L2$ 4%5 34* U+ +4-,+/ 9# -LDD#/9

D#:,9,24::*' G9 9$+ -43+ 9,3+B 9$+ ?+/* 0429 9$49 -L2$ /+<,#%- S#L:5 %#S U+ 9,+5 9#9$+ +a,-9,%< %49,#%4: <#?+/%3+%9 34I+- 9$+,/ D/#3,-+- #0 ,%5+D+%5+%2+ :+--2/+5,U:+' J$L-B 9$+ O#3+/ -#:L9,#% S#L:5 -++3 9# U+ U+-9B UL9 #%:* ,0 S+ ,<%#/+9$+ $,<$ D#:,9,24: $L/5:+- 9# U+ #?+/2#3+' R+9 -,3D:* U+,%< 4U:+ 9# 4DD/#42$ 9$,-:,3,9,%< 24-+ S,9$ S+4I+/ 4DD/#a,349,#%- -$#L:5 U+ 4% ,--L+ 9$49 3#/+ 4<+%2,+--$#L:5 D/#3#9+B %#9 :+4-9 U+24L-+ 3L:9,D:+ +aD+/,3+%9- S,9$ -+3,V4L9#%#3* ,%2#L%9/,+- S,9$ </+49 </#S9$ D#9+%9,4: S#L:5 U+ 4% +00+29,?+ 3+4%- #0 9/*,%< #L9%+S ,5+4- 4%5 9+-9,%< 9$+ :,3,9- #0 D#:,9,24: 9#:+/4%2+ 9# </+49+/ </#S9$'

(#%-,5+/ 4 -+3,-+/,#L- -L<<+-9,#%b+aD4%5,%< 9$+ /4%<+ #0 -$#DD,%<34::- 9# +%9,/+ 9#S%- #/ 2#33L%,9,+-' K0 #%+ :##I- 4/#L%5 G-,4B ,9 ,- 2:+4/ 9$49 9$+/,-+ #0 9$+ :4/<+ 34:: ,- 4% +a+/2,-+ %#9 #%:* ,% 04-$,#%4U:+ /+94,: UL9 4 3+4%- #02/+49,%< DLU:,2 <##5- S,9$,% 4 ?+/* 5+:,3,9+5 D$*-,24: 4%5 2#%9/429L4: -D42+' P%9$+ #%+ $4%5B 9$+ :4/<+ 34::- D/+?4:+%9 ,% 2#L%9/,+- :,I+ 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- S#L:5-++3 9# U+:,+ 9$+ D/#U:+3- #0 ,%-+2L/+ D/#D+/9* /,<$9- 4%5 $,<$ 2#%-9/4,%9- #%+00,2,+%9 2#::+29,?+ 429,#% 9*D,24: #0 5+?+:#D,%< %49,#%-' 8L9 ,9 ,- #U?,#L- 9$49 9$+-L22+--0L: :4/<+ 34::- 4/+ 9$#-+ S$+/+ 9$+,/ U42I+/- $4?+ 4:/+45* -#:?+5 34%* #09$+ U4-,2 D/#U:+3- #0 /+<L:49#/* #?+/-,<$9 4%5 2/+5,U:+ 2#33,93+%9 9# :#%<+/V9+/3 D/#D+/9* /,<$9-' J$,- 5#+- %#9 ,3D:* +,9$+/ 2#//LD9,#% #/ 2/#%*,-3 4:9$#L<$,9 +aD:4,%- S$* 9,<$9 D#:,9,24: 9,+- S#L:5 U+ %+2+--4/* #/ 5+-,/4U:+' P%:* 9$+-9/#%<+-9 #/ 3#-9 D#S+/0L: D49/#%- 2#L:5 D/#?,5+ 9$+ %+2+--4/* U42I,%< 9# 34I+9$+ ?+%9L/+ 2/+5,U:+' P%2+ ,% D:42+ $#S+?+/B ,9 -+/?+- 4- 4% #4-,- #0 3#-9:*-3##9$ 0L%29,#%,%< 0#/34: :4S S,9$ %+9S#/I +a9+/%4:,9,+-B 4- S+:: +a9+/%4:,9,+- #0-24:+ 4%5 -2#D+ ,% D/#?,5,%< <##5- 4%5 -+/?,2+-'

^+ -$#L:5 2#%-,5+/ S$+9$+/ 9$,- ,- 4 ?,4U:+ 3#5+: 0#/ +%2#L/4<,%<

/+<,#%4: 5+?+:#D3+%9 +-D+2,4::* #L9-,5+ 9$+ 4:/+45* #?+/2/#S5+5 24D,94: 2,9*2+%9+/-' J# 4 :4/<+ +a9+%9 9$+ <#4: S#L:5 U+ 9# +%2#L/4<+ +?+/ :4/<+/ /+<,#%4:2+%9+/- S,9$ +%#L<$ D/,?49,W49,#% 9# D/#?,5+ 2/+5,U:+ D/#9+29,#% 0#/ U#9$ :4/<+4%5 -34:: ,%?+-9#/- ,% 9$+ 4/+4' .4/9,2,D49,#% U* :#24: 4%5 0#/+,<% 2#3D4%,+-S#L:5 U+ +%2#L/4<+5 ,% +a2$4%<+ 0#/ 2##/5,%49+5 D/#?,-,#% #/ -LU-,5,W49,#% #0%+2+--4/* ,%0/4-9/L29L/+' J$+ <#4: #0 2#L/-+ ,- %#9 [L-9 9# -D/+45 L/U4%5+?+:#D3+%9 U+*#%5 9$+ L-L4: 2+%9+/-B UL9 2/+49+ +%#L<$ 4:9+/%49,?+- 9# 9$++a,-9,%< 2,9,+- -# 9$49 +?+% 4//4%<+3+%9- 9$49 34* U+<,% 0/#3 4 -+3,3#%#D#:,-9,2

U4-,- 3,<$9 -9,:: D/#3#9+ </+49+/ +2#%#3,2 4%5 D#:,9,24: 2#3D+9,9,#%'

M,3,:4/:* 9$+/+ -$#L:5 U+ 4 3+4%- 9# +%2#L/4<+ 3#/+ 4</,2L:9L/4:,%?+-93+%9- 9$49 94I+ ,%9# 422#L%9 9$+ /+4:,9* #0 %+2+--4/* -24:+ +2#%#3,+- 4%59$+ 5,00,2L:9* #0 +aD+29,%< -34:: $#:5+/- 9# U+ <+%L,%+:* 2#3D+9,9,?+ #%2+ 4::

D#:,9,24: #U-942:+- 4/+ 94I+% ,%9# 2#%-,5+/49,#%' )#%+9$+:+--B 0,%5,%< S4*- 9#



@F G MKG) H 1&1TP.=1)J O 1&K1^

+%2#L/4<+ :4/<+/ ,%?+-9#/- 0#/ S$#3 </+49+/ 422+-- ,- </4%9+5 49 9$+ +aD+%-+ #0

,%2/+4-+5 2#3D+9,9,#% 0/#3 U#9$ :#24: 4%5 ,%9+/%49,#%4: 2#3D4%,+- S#L:5 U+-9+D- ,% 9$+ /,<$9 5,/+29,#%'>:9,349+:*B 9$+ ,--L+ ,- %#9 #%+ #0 4%* <,?+% /+0#/3' J$+ <#4: ,- %#9 9#

D/+[L5<+ 9$+ 342/#+2#%#3,2 -949L- #0 4%* D4/9,2L:4/ 45[L-93+%9' J$+ ,5+4 ,- 9#/+4:,<% ,%2+%9,?+- 9# D+/3,9 </+49+/ +%9/*B </+49+/ 422#L%94U,:,9*B 4%5 4 2/+5,U:+2#33,93+%9 9# 0L/9$+/ #D+%%+-- 4%5 2#%9,%L+5 /+0#/3 5+-D,9+ 9$+ %+4/ 2+/94,%9*9$49 9$#-+ ,% 4 D#-,9,#% 9# U+%+0,9 0/#3 2L//+%9 /+-9/,29,#%- S,:: S4%9 9$#-+/+-9/,29,#%- 9# 2#%9,%L+' ^+ 9$+/+0#/+ $4?+ 9# 4-I $#S 9# -$#S 9$+3 9$49 /+:4a,%<9$#-+ 2#%-9/4,%9- +,9$+/ UL*- 9$+3 3#/+ #/ 0,%5 S4*- 9# +%2#L/4<+ 2#3D+9,9,#%9$49 24%%#9 U+ +4-,:* _L4-$+5' J$,- ,- %#9 4 2#L%-+: #0 5+-D4,/ UL9 4 -L<<+-9,#%9$49 4 /+4:,-9,2 ,%9+</49,#% #0 +2#%#3,2 _L4%9,0,249,#% 4%5 D#:,9,24: 4%4:*-,- ,- 4%+2+--4/* D/+2#%5,9,#% 0#/ 4 /+:,4U:+ 4--+--3+%9 #0 </#S9$ D/#3#9,%< ,%,9,49,?+-'

J$L-B 4%* /+0#/3 +?4:L49,#% -$#L:5 ,%?#:?+ 4 D/#D+/ 422#L%9,%< #0 9$+/+:49,?+ _L4%9,949,?+ ,3D#/94%2+ #0 5,00+/+%9 5,-9#/9,#%-B 4% #/5+/,%< #0 0+4-,U:+/+0#/3- 9$49 455/+-- 9$+ 34[#/ 5,-9#/9,#%-B 4%5 4 2#%-,5+/49,#% #0 S$,2$

D#:,9,24::* 422+D94U:+ /+0#/3- 4/+ :,4U:+ 9# :+45 9# :#%< 9+/3 ,%9+/+-9- -L-94,%,%<5+-,/+5 2$4%<+- 4%5 +%2#L/4<,%< 0L/9$+/ /+0#/3'

REFERENCES

G2+3#<:LB H'B M' "#$%-#%B 4%5 "' G' O#U,%-#% @FFC' dJ$+ (#:#%,4: P/,<,%- #0 (#3D4/49,?+H+?+:#D3+%9N G% 13D,/,24: K%?+-9,<49,#%'fThe American Economic Review hC\Z]NCYghkCXFC'

G/#/4B &' @FCF' dM9/+%<9$+%,%< ;/#S9$ ./#-D+29- ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-'fUniversity of the Philippines Forum "L:*N >%DLU:,-$+5 .#S+/D#,%9'

84:,-424%B G' ChhX' Poverty, Urbanization, and Development Policy: A Philippine Perspective 'H,:,34%N >%,?+/-,9* #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- ./+--'

84:,-424%B G'B 4%5 Q' Q,::B +5-' @FFY'The Philippine Economy: Development Policies, and

Challenges 'mL+W#% (,9*N G9+%+# 5+ =4%,:4 >%,?+/-,9* ./+--'(4DL%#B "'"' @FCF' MD49,4: H+?+:#D3+%9 4%5 9$+ T4S #0 P%+ ./,2+N 1?,5+%2+ #0 (#%?+/<+%2+

#0 T4%5 &4:L+-' >.M1 H,-2L--,#% .4D+/ )#' @FCFkFCB >%,?+/-,9* #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-M2$##: #0 12#%#3,2-B H,:,34%B mL+W#% (,9*'

1-<L+//4B 1' @FCF' d"#U (/+49,#%N ^$49c- T4U#/ ;#9 9# H# S,9$ K9`f >%,?+/-,9* #0 9$+.$,:,DD,%+-' >%DLU:,-$+5'

64U+::4B O' @FFh' (GO. ^,9$#L9 (#4-+N O+5,-9/,UL9,%< .#?+/9* ,% 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+-' ^#/I,%<.4D+/B >%,?+/-,9* #0 9$+ .$,:,DD,%+- M2$##: #0 12#%#3,2-B H,:,34%B mL+W#% (,9*'

QL4%<B R' @FFA'Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics ' (43U/,5<+N (43U/,5<+ >%,?+/-,9*./+--'

"#%+-B ;' ^' @FF@' d>/U4%,W49,#% J/+%5- ,% G-,4N J$+ (#%2+D9L4: 4%5 H+0,%,9,#%4:($4::+%<+-'f .4D+/ D/+-+%9+5 ,% 9$+ 2#%0+/+%2+ #% )+S 6#/3- #0 >/U4%,W49,#%N(#%2+D9L4:,W,%< 4%5 =+4-L/,%< QL34% M+99:+3+%9 ,% 9$+ JS+%9*V6,/-9 (+%9L/*B K>MM.^#/I,%< ;/#LD #% >/U4%,W49,#%B CCVCZ =4/2$B 8+::4<,#B K94:*'

e:,9<44/5B O' ChAA'Controlling Corruption ' 8+/I+:+*N >%,?+/-,9* #0 (4:,0#/%,4 ./+--'



J GeK); K )MJKJ>JK P)M M1OKP>MTR @C

e/L<34%B .'B "' G:3-B M' (#::,%-B 4%5 1' O+3#:#%4' Chh@' Transforming the Philippine Economy ' mL+W#% (,9*N G.P ./#5L29,#% >%,9'

=#/4:+-B "' @FCF' >%:+4-,%< 9$+ .#S+/ #0 O+0#/3N J$+ .$,:,DD,%+- J+:+2#33L%,249,#%-O+0#/3 M9#/*' ^#/I,%< .4D+/B >%,9+5 M949+- G<+%2* 0#/ K%9+/%49,#%4: H+?+:#D3+%9\>MGKH] k .$,:,DD,%+-'

)#/9$B H'B "' ^4::,-B 4%5 8' ^+,%<4-9' @FFh' Violence and Social Orders ' (43U/,5<+N(43U/,5<+ >%,?+/-,9* ./+--'

)#/9$B H'B 4%5 8' ^+,%<4-9 ChAh' d(#%-9,9L9,#%- 4%5 (#33,93+%9N 9$+ 1?#:L9,#% #0K%-9,9L9,#%4: ;#?+/%,%< .LU:,2 ($#,2+ ,% M+?+%9++%9$ (+%9L/* 1%<:4%5'f Journal of

Economic History Xh\X]NAFYkAY@'O#5/,IB H'B G' MLU/434%,4%B 4%5 6' J/+UU, @FFX' dK%-9,9L9,#%- OL:+N J$+ ./,342* #0

K%-9,9L9,#%- #?+/ ;+#</4D$* 4%5 K%9+</49,#% ,% 12#%#3,2 H+?+:#D3+%9'f Journal of

Economic Growth h\@]NCYCkCgZ'O#3+/B .' @FCC' ($4/9+/ (,9,+-' G?4,:4U:+N SSS'2$49+/2,9,+-'#/<'M_L,/+B T'B 4%5 M' ML9$,S4/9V)4/L+DL9' Chhi' dJ$+ K3D429 #0 T4U#/ =4/I+9 O+<L:49,#%-'f

World Bank Economic Review CC\C]NCChkXY'^#/:5 84%I' @FCF' 12#%#3,2 ;/#S9$' .$,:,DD,%+ H,-2L--,#% )#9+ )#' CB ^4-$,%<9#%B H('

2010 - nye - philippine political economy

Documents