20th german norwegian energy forum

20th German Norwegian Energy Forum

The Paris Agreement - Risks and Opportunities for the Energy Sector

Gemeinschaftshaus der Nordischen Botschaften Berlin October 27, 2016

Photo: Thinkstock/cookelma

The Paris Agreement calls on us to take action for the climate. Each country that ratifies the agreement will be required to set targets for emission reduction and pursue efforts to limit warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.

Norway has set the target to reduce emission of 40 percent until 2030 compared to 1990. Germany has the goal to reduce emission of 40 percent until 2020 compared to 1990. As a long term goal, Norway and Germany want to become low-emission societies. To ensure the transition of societies, industries and economies to clean energy, governments develop national climate policies and policy instruments.

The German Energiewende and the Green Shift in Norway are the drivers for innovation, competitiveness and economic growth. In the years to come, we will see new technologi-cal solutions we do not know of yet. The energy system will transform to a digitalized and decentralized system and electrification may bring about restructuring in other sectors.

“The Paris Agreement – Risks and Opportunities for the Energy Sector” is the title of the 20th German Norwegian Energy Forum. From the very beginning of the German Norwegian Energy Forum, our mission has been to connect representatives from politics, science, institutions and businesses.

Over the years, the Forum has developed into a platform where Norwegian and German play-ers meet to identify business opportunities and how they can beneficially support each other through this market transformation.

Innovation Norway, the Norwegian Embassy in Berlin with actors from Norway and Germany will continue the work on creating a bilateral business network to strengthen the German Norwegian energy partnership for a sustainable and secure energy supply in Europe. Gerda Geyer

Project Leader German Norwegian Energy Forum

Editorial

2 The Paris Agreement - Risks and Opportunities for the Energy Sector 3

MODERATOR: JØRGEN FESTERVOLL, ADAPT CONSULTING AS

12:00 Registration, Refreshments and Finger Food

12:30 Welcome and Opening Remarks Kjell-Børge Freiberg, State Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum and Energy

12:50 Energy Policy after the Paris Climate Agreement Dr. Barbara Praetorius, Deputy Executive Director, Agora Energiewende

13:20 Summary of the First German Norwegian Energy CEO & Executive Round Table Dr. Werner Brinker

13:30 Climate Goals – Impacts and Challenges for the Energy and Industry Sector Panel discussion Dr. Karsten Wildberger (EON), Volker Backs (Norsk Hydro), Auke Lont (Statnett), Jan Karl Karlsen (Statoil), Auguste Willems, (Wacker Chemie)

14:10 Coffee Break

14:50 Generation 2025 – the Medium-Term Role of Conventional and Renewable Energy in Germany Dr. Andreas Schröter, Executive Vice President & Regional Manager Central Europe & Mediterranean DNV GL - Energy

15:10 Is the Disruption of the Energy Industry yet to come? Introductory remarks and discussion by Jørgen Kildahl & Eimund Nygaard, CEO, Lyse AS

16:00 Coffee Break

16:40 What the EU State Aid Guideline means for the Expansion of Renewables Janosch Abegg, Head of Market Access Renewables, Statkraft Markets GmbH

16:55 Cross Border Flows. Importance for the European Power-Price-Building Mechanisms Dr. Błażej Radomski, Head of Analysis - Germany, Markedskraft

17:10 The Business Sector as Change Agent for Energy Transition Tom Lindberg, Managing Director, ECOHZ

17:25 Hydrogen as an Integrated Part of the Future Energy and Transport System Bjørn Simonsen, Vice President, Market Development Nel Hydrogen

17:40 Q&A Session

17:50 Closing Remarks Elisabeth Walaas, Norwegian Ambassador to Germany

18:00 Reception and Buffet Dinner hosted by Elisabeth Walaas, Norwegian Ambassador to Germany

4 The Paris Agreement - Risks and Opportunities for the Energy Sector

Programme

Speakers

5

Kjell-Børge FreibergState Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum and Energy

Kjell-Børge Freiberg was appointed Deputy Minister in the Norwegian Ministry of Petroleum and Energy on October 23rd 2015. He was previously the Mayor of Hadsel municipality, a position he had held since 2007. He had different roles in the Progress Party from 1999, among them County Chair for Nord-land county and Party Secretary with responsibility for Nordland, Troms and Finnmark counties. Before becoming a full time politician, Freiberg worked for different companies in the Norwegian fishing and aquaculture industry.

Dr. Barbara PraetoriusDeputy Executive Director, Agora Energiewende

Dr. Barbara Praetorius is energy economist and policy scientist by training. Before joining Agora Energiewende, she headed the division Strategy and Key Policy Issues of the German Association of Local Public Utilities (VKU). She has been Senior Researcher and Project Lead in the division Energy, Transport, Environment at DIW Berlin (the German Institute for Economic Research). She was head of an interdisciplinary team of scientists from different research institutes, with focus on the technical, organisational-political and behaviou-ral innovations within the power system.

Dr. Werner BrinkerFormer CEO of EWE AG

Werner Brinker has been in the German energy business from 1978 until his retirement as CEO of EWE AG in October 2015. He started his career at EWE and held different leading positions in the natural gas and waste management department. From 1993 until 1996 he was engaged with Preussen Elektra AG. In 1996 he became Member of the Executive Board of EWE AG and CEO in 1998. Today Werner Brinker holds a professorship at the University of Oldenburg. He is engaged in several supervisory boards and as a Senior Adviser within Rothschild Global Advisory.


Speakers

Volker BacksSenior Vice President Sourcing, Rolled Products, Norsk Hydro

Volker Backs started his career in 1991 with different position at VWA which became Hydro Aluminum in 2002. Since then he is a member of the Manage-ment Team Hydro Aluminum Rolled Products. In 2009 he became board mem-ber of Aluminum Norf GmbH. Since 2015 he is Senior Vice President Sourcing Hydro Aluminum Rolled Products. Norsk Hydro is biggest producer of primary aluminium and rolling-mill-products in Europe.

Jan Karl Karlsen Vice President, Head of Berlin Office, Statoil

The Statoil Government Affairs office in Berlin is headed by Vice President Jan Karl Karlsen. He came to Berlin from a position as Head of Government Af-fairs at the Statoil Washington DC office. Prior to his secondment to Washing-ton DC he was in charge of the Statoil Corporate Strategy function. He has also been responsible for Statoil’s global trading and supply in crude oil and wet products and the portfolio of Statoil’s gas sales contracts to Europe.

Auke LontChief Executive Officer, Statnett

Auke Lont has been CEO at Statnett since 2009. He began his career in 1984 as a Market Analyst in Natural Gas at Statoil and after occupying a variety of positions there, he became their Vice President of Business Development in 1992. From 1994 to 1999 he was the Managing Director of Naturkraft AS in Norway. He then moved to Cape Town, South Africa, where he was the Senior Economist and Managing Director of Econ Analysis from 1999 to 2000. After this Auke Lont returned to Statoil as Senior Vice President – a post he occupi-ed from 2001 to 2005. From 2005 to 2009 Auke Lont worked as Managing Di-rector of Econ Pövry Analysis in Norway. He has held several Board Positions, both in Norway and Sweden and is a member of the board of of Bane NOR (the National Railway Infrastructure Company, and SPEKTER (The employer`s Association). He is also an appointed member of the Commission Expert Group on Electricity Interconnection Targets, Brussels.

Dr. Karsten WildbergerChief Markets Officer, E.ON SE

Karsten Wildberger has been a member of the Board of Management of E.ON SE since April 2016. As Chief Markets Officer he is responsible for Renewa-bles, Marketing, Digital Transformation, Innovation and Customer Solutions. With a consulting background (Boston Consulting Group) he entered the telecommunication industry and held international leadership positions with T-Mobile and then Vodafone. Before joining E.ON, he served from 2013 to 2016 as a member of the Management Board of the Telstra Group, an Australian telecommunications company based in Melbourne.

Auguste WillemsMember of the Executive Board, Wacker Chemie AG

Auguste Willems studied bioscience at the University of Leuven (Belgium). After graduating, he joined Henkel, holding various sales and marketing posi-tions. He then spent several years in Indonesia and the USA, with overall ope-rational responsibility. In 2002, he became group Vice President of Functional Products at Cognis and a member of Cognis’ Corporate Executive Committee

Dr. Andreas SchröterExecutive Vice President & Regional Manager Central Europe & Mediterranean DNV GL – Energy

Andreas Schröter has been appointed as Executive Vice President Advisory Central Europe & Mediterranean February 2015 being responsible for all renewable and traditional energy advisory services. Before joining GL in 2011 he had spent more than 15 years in the telecommunications industry working for Siemens, Nokia Siemens Networks and Rohde & Schwarz where he held a variety of engineering, sales, service, management and country CEO positions. During his various assignments he gained experiences in managing growth and international expansion as well as restructuring.

7


Speakers

Eimund Nygaard CEO, Lyse AS

Eimund Nygaard is the group CEO of the Norwegian multi utility company Lyse AS. Lyse is a company within renewable energy and fiber based broadband. Nygaard has been the CEO since 1999. Nygaard is also the chairman of the board of EnergiNoge, which is the association of Norwegian renewable energy companies.

Janosch AbeggHead of Market Access Renewables, Statkraft Markets GmbH

Janosch Abegg runs Statkraft‘s direct sales activities In Germany and neighbouring countries since 2012. Before that he held positions as Head of Origination Western Europe and as Power Trader. Janosch is an economist by education and holds an MBA in European Utility Industry.

Dr. Błażej RadomskiHead of Analysis - Germany, Markedskraft

Dr. Błażej Radomski is working as Head of Analysis - Germany in the Berlin office of MKonline, which is an independent analysis service for the European energy market. Coming from academia he joined MKonline’s mother company Markedskraft in 2008 and is since then working with analysis of electricity markets, modeling of fundamental and price forecasting models, statistics, econometrics and technical analysis.

Tom Lindberg Managing Director, ECOHZ

Tom Lindberg works to develop solutions that help companies and societies transition to renewable energy, while building profitable and sustainable business models. As Managing Director of ECOHZ, board member of RECS In-ternational and The International REC Standard, member of the Advisory Board of EKOenergy, and Chairman of the Board of ECOHZ Renewable Energy Foun-dation, Lindberg works to raise awareness of how companies can become

energy neutral by consuming renewable energy with Guarantees of Origin in Europe, RECs in North America and I-RECs internationally.

Bjørn Simonsen Vice President Market Development, Nel Hydrogen

Bjørn Simonsen joined Nel Hydrogen September 2014. He has experience from the hydrogen sector since 2008, and began as a research engineer at Institute for Energy Technology (IFE), followed by key positions in the HyNor-project, The Norwegian Hydrogen Council and Norwegian Hydrogen Forum. He holds a MSc in Energy and Environmental Science from the Norwegian University of Science and Technology.

Jørgen FestervollPartner, ADAPT Consulting AS

Jørgen Festervoll is a partner at ADAPT, a consulting firm specializing in energy and climate related issues. As a trusted advisor for a range of Norwegian and international clients, he has provided advise on issues ranging from strategy and business development, M&A, to PPA negotiations, regulatory issues and market design.

Jørgen Kildahl Jørgen Kildahl is one of the pioneers driving the liberalisation of the European energy markets. The last 17 years he has held executive positions at the management boards of Statkraft and E.ON SE being responsible for trading & origination, optimisation, power generation, gas, E&P and renewables. He is currently Chairman of the Supervisory Board of eSmart Systems, Supervisory Board Member of Hoegh LNG, advisor to two Horizon 2020 projects and Energy Fellow at EWI (Institute of Energy Economics at the University of Cologne).

9


aanderud media consulting Kai-Axel Aenderudacatech Ralf BehnAdapt Consulting AS Lene OrvikAdapt Consulting AS Jørgen FestervollAdvancy GmbH Olaf GeyerAF Gruppen Tor OlsenAgder Energi Vannkraft AS Robert PalmeAgora Energiewende Dr. Barbara PraetoriusArgus Media Chloe JardineBayWa r.e. Wind GmbH Martin ReckmannBC CARE Matthias DornfeldtBecker Büttner Held Dr. Lina BerezgovaBecker Büttner Held Christian HeldBergen Energi Heiner WalbaumBI Norwegian Business School Ola Øivind OmmedalBischoff & Ditze Energy GmbH Oliver GermerothBischoff & Ditze Energy GmbH Julia PöslBloomberg News Brian ParkinBourbaki UG Guido AxmannBP Europa SE Dr. Ruprecht BrandisBundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie Ursula BorakBundesverband Kraft-Wärme-Kopplung e.V. Jennifer HammelBurson-Marsteller GmbH Martin BeckerBurson-Marsteller GmbH Marco LietzBurson-Marsteller GmbH Christian ThamsBurson-Marsteller Oslo Peter GitmarkBusinessPortal Norwegen Dr. Jutta FalknerBündnis 90 / Die Grünen Horst SchiermeyerCebyc AS Øyvind LudvigsenCEZ Group Katerina Smrckovaconenergy agentur Stefanie HammCovestro Frank HoltrupCovestro Dr. Christoph SieveringDEA AG Isabel WeissDEA AG Frank MeyerDEA AG Anja BischofDEKRA e.V. Stephan BraunDLA Piper Anders LenborgDNV GL-Energy Dr. Andreas SchröterDNV GL-Energy Claas F. HülsenDow Deutschland Inc Birgit OrtliebE.ON Climate & Renewables Holger Matthiesen

Participants

11

E.ON SE Dr. Karsten WildbergerECG Energie Consulting GmbH Jürgen Josepheclareon Robert BrückmannECOHZ David Philipp ZwickECOHZ Tom LindbergEmbassy of Denmark Simona RensEmbassy of Denmark Henning Schlaikjer-PetersenEmbassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands Albert FaberEmbassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands Julia WolffEmbassy of the Republic of Poland Iwona Jakuszko/DudkaEnergie & Management Peter FochtEnervis Julius Eckeenervis energy advisors GmbH Sebastian KleinEnovos Luxembourg S.A. Roger RuetzeenviMV e.V. Rostock, MV Olaf SchätzchenErste Lesung GmbH Jonas QuinckeErste Lesung GmbH Christian WenningEuropean Commission Martin StasekEuropean Energy Exchange Timo SchulzEXAA Ronald GjurkowitschExxonMobil Axel von MaltzahnFederal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy Thorsten HerdanFesil Rana Metall Helge StanghelleFichtner Management Consulting AG Sabine SiebaldFlensburg University Irina StamoFU Berlin Lutz MezGas- und Energiegenossenschaft Ost- und Mitteldeutschland eG Rene SchmidtGePe Geoservice GmbH Katarzyna MarksGerman Association for Marine Technology (GMT e.V.) Lars EngelmannGerman Foreign Office Thomas Hermann MeisterGerman Maritime LNG Platform Tessa RodewaldtGerman-Norwegian Chamber of Commerce Carine GronholzGermany Trade & Invest Heiko Staubitzglobal gas partners gmbh Daniel MuthmannGO2-markets GmbH Garzay AhmadiGO2-markets GmbH Paul PetereitGO2-markets GmbH Jennifer RosnerGWI Bauunternehmung GmbH Karl-Jürgen AthensHAMBURG WASSER/HAMBURG ENERGIE Michael BeckertHeinrich-Boell-Stiftung Rebecca BertramHertie School of Governance Michael Davies-VennHKW Nora Kronemeyer


Holcim Deutschland GmbH Werner CarstensenHUMBOLDT-VIADRINA Governance Platform Anne HoehHydro Inger Kristin HolmHydro Aluminium Rolled Products GmbH Thomas Mockib vogt Sebastian HackInnovation Norway - Germany Gerda GeyerInnovation Norway - Germany Katja KerschkeInnovation Norway - Germany Manuel KlieseINTPOW - Norwegian Renewable Energy Partners Jon DugstadIST GmbH Gesellschaft für angewandte Sozialwissenschaft Wolf SchluchterJB EMS Jürgen BeigelKfW IPEX-Bank GmbH Dr. Heinz StaakeKgl. Norwegische Botschaft Tobias SvenningsenKlimaINVEST Green Concepts GmbH Kai RistauKONGSTEIN A/S Erik PietschKONGSTEIN A/S Rune TvedtLeipziger Stadtwerke Michael DatheLichtBlick SE Anna KamlageLyse AS Ove JølboLyse AS Eimund NygaardMarkedskraft Anamaria ToebeMarkedskraft ASA / MKonline Johannes Lehmpfuhl HoldøMarkedskraft Deutschland GmbH Thomas EccardMarkedskraft Deutschland GmbH Dr. Błażej RadomskiMarquard & Bahls AG Katja FreitagMdB-Büro, Deutscher Bundestag Kathrin KortmannMeteomatics Lutz Bertrammgm consulting partners GmbH Christian von HammersteinMinistry of Petroleum and Energy Kjell-Børge FreibergMitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems Europe GmbH Robert KammelMKonline Dr. Carsten TrappMKonline Johannes StoiberMKonline - Markedskraft Espen ZachariassenMontel Nora Kamprath BuliMontel GmbH Joerg SchultheissNasdaq Konstantin LenzNasdaq Anja WeissnatGAS AG Armin FleignatGAS AG Michael Porrnavos Stephan Peter Hoarenavos Christian SimonNCE Smart Energy Markets Dr. Christian Kunze

Participants

13

Nel Hydrogen Bjørn SimonsenNord Pool Pietro RabassiNorsk Hydro Volker BacksNorwegian Consulate, Hamburg Detlef PalmNorwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs Knut-Are Okstadnymoen strategieberatung gmbh Kathrin GrafOtto-von-Guericke University Magdeburg Natalia Moskalenko Powel AG Klaus KiskeRolls-Royce Power Systems AG Karsten SuchierRWTH Aachen University Michael SchachSGS INSTITUT FRESENIUS GmbH Stefan SteinhardtShell Deutschland Oil GmbH Ursula MenhartSiemens Tore TomterSiemens AG Dr. Hans-Peter Böhm Siemens AG Victoria OrioliSimonsen Vogt Wiig Law Firm Frode A. BerntsenSimonsen Vogt Wiig Law Firm Frode VarebergSolvay GmbH Bernhard SchulteSouth Pole Group Michael WeberStadtwerke Kiel Timo AlznauerStadtwerke Leipzig Holger RudertStatkraft Markets GmbH Janosch AbeggStatnett Carl-Jørgen GreidungStatnett Tor Eigil HodneStatnett Auke LontStatoil Christian SchülkeStatoil ASA Jan Karl KarlsenStatoil ASA Tobias NaeschkeTenneT Markus NapelinskiTenneT TSO GmbH Mathias FischerTHEMA Consulting Group Eivind MagnusTocircle Industries Per BjorstadTRETTIN Rechtsanwaltskanzlei Dirk TrettinTÜV NORD CERT GmbH Rainer WinterUmweltbundesamt - German Environment Agency Mark NowakowskiUniversity of Stavanger Mohsen AssadiVattenfall Marcus BokermannVerlag Der Tagesspiegel Katja MoellerVi-Strategie GmbH Rainer OttoVNG - Verbundnetz Gas AG Ulf HeitmüllerVNG - Verbundnetz Gas AG Konstantin von OldenburgVNG - Verbundnetz Gas AG Mike Diekmann


Wacker Chemicals Norway AS Nicholas LundbergWacker Chemie AG Christian EssersWacker Chemie AG Jochen LedigerWacker Chemie AG Auguste WillemsWeltenergierat Deutschland e.V. Tobias PoeschlWINGAS GmbH Ludwig MoehringWintershall Holding GmbH Georg HiemannWintershall Holding GmbH Ludger RadermacherYounicos AG Alexander Schönfeldt Astrid Fischer Dr. Werner Brinker Jørgen Kildahl


Notes

In cooperation and with kind support of:

Organized by Innovation Norway Caffamacherreihe 5 D-20355 Hamburg www.innovationnorway.no

Contact: Gerda Geyer Head of Energy & Environment Telephone: (+49) 40 22 94 15 58 [email protected]

20th german norwegian energy forum

Documents