낙동강(4대강)사업 부산고등법원 판결문
DESCRIPTION
environmental,ecolawTRANSCRIPT
-
- 1 -
1
2011 228 , ( 1,788 ).
, , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , , ,
-
- 2 -
, 1. ,2.
,
6-2
, ,
1 2010. 12. 10. 2009 5672 2012. 1. 13. 2012. 2. 10.
1. 1 . . 2
-
- 3 -
. . 4
3 .
. 3 .
. 3 13 27 .
2. .
1 . 2009. 9. 4 (4 ) 2009. 11. 23. 20 ( , ), 22 ( ), 30 ( ), 2009.
11. 25. 5 ( 2 1 ), 16 ( 5 1 ), 19 ( 3 1 ), 2010. 2. 12. 25 ( 2 1 ), 31 ( 7 ), 2010. 5. 6. 22 ( ), 23 ( 3 3 ), 25 ( 2 1 ), 31 ( 7 ) ,
2009. 11. 12. 18 ( 2 1 ), 20
-
- 4 -
( ), 22 ( ), 23 ( 3 3 ), 24 ( ), 30 ( ), 32 ( ), 33 ( ),
2010. 2. 5. 21 ( 1 1 ), 29 ( 5 ), 34 ( 1 3 ), 36 ( 3 3 ), 2010. 3. 5. 2 ( 1 2 ), 6 ( 1 2 ), 7 ( 2 3 ), 8 ( 3 4 ), 9 ( 4 5 ), 10 ( 5 6 ), 11 ( 6 7 ), 12 ( 1 8 ), 13 ( 2 9 ), 35 ( 2 ), 38 ( 2
), 39 ( 3 ), 48 ( ), 2010. 4. 19. 41 ( ), 42 ( , ) ( ) ,
.
1. . 4
1) 4 ( 4 ) , , , , 4 , , (4 2 ).
2) (2009. 4. 22. 9629 22
-
- 5 -
) 2008. 12. 15. 4 .
3) 2008. 12. 15. 4 ( 4 ) .
4) 4 4 2009. 2. , 2009. 4. 4 .
5) , , , , , 2009. 4. 4 ,
2009. 5. 12 , 2 , 2 , .
6) , , , 4 2009. 6. 8. 4 4 , 4 2009. 8. 24. 4 . . 4
1) 4 4 , ,
, , ,
-
- 6 -
. 2) 4 4 ,
, , , 5 .
3) 4 ) 200 9.2
, 5.7 ( 0.5 , 4.4 , 0.5 , 0.3 ) , 5 , 620 , , 96 , 3 , .
) (2011 8 , 2016 10 )
13 , 16 ( ) ( 3 , 8 , 3 , 2 ), , , .
-
- 7 -
) 2015 ( , BOD 1) 3 /L)
2012 34 , , 353 T-P2) , 3) , 929 , .
)
, , , , , , , / , 1,728 , , , .
) 4 , ( , )
, 100 ~ 200 , 4 , 4 ,1) Biochemical Oxygen Demand( ), . .2) Total Phosphorus( ), . .3) , , , ,.
-
- 8 -
, 4 , 4 4 , 4 .
4) 4 4 , , .
4 , 2011 ( 2012 ) . 13 2012 . . ( ) , , , .
5) 4 4 22 2,000 ( 16 9,000 ,
5 3,000 ) , 4 , , 267 .
6) 4 , 4
-
- 9 -
4 , , 4 . .
1) 4 ( ) . 1 ( 1 1 ) , ( , ) 122.14 , 2 ( 2 2 ) , 180.67 .
2) , 6.1 ( 4.4 ), ( 0.8 ), (1.9 ), , ( ), (335
) , 10.2 8 ( , , , , , , , ) (6.7 ), ( , ) (2.5 ) ~ , 31 (1.0
) , 22 10 2012 BOD 96%(2006 82%), TP( )
-
- 10 -
0.089 / (2006 0.130 / ) , 74 179 TP , 23
33 , 9 , 15 , 407 , 743 , ,
862 148 , 50 , 5 9,379 .
3) , 27 < 1> ( ) ( 1 27 ).
1 2009-493 18 ( 2 1 ) , , 1
: 1
1
: 2009 10 ~12
2009 10 ~2010 2
2009.11.12.
2 2009-497 20 ( ) , , 13 2009-498 22 ( ) , , 14 2009-494 23 ( 3 3 ) , , 15 2009-499 24 ( ) , , 16 2009-500 30 ( ) 1
7 2009-501 32 ( ) , 18 2009-502 33 ( ) , 1
< 1> ( )
-
- 11 -
4) , 2009. 9. 25. 4 .
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 , ) 10 5, 16, 18 25, 29 34, 36 , < 2> ( < 2>
9 2010-55 21 ( 1 1 ) , 1
2010.2. 5.10 2010-56 29 ( 5 ) 1
11 2010-57 34 ( 1 3 ) , 112 2010-58 36 ( 3 3 ) , 113 2010-137 2 ( 1 2 ) , -
2010.3. 5.
14 2010-138 6 ( 1 2 ) , -15 2010-139 7 ( 2 3 ) , -16 2010-140 8 ( 3 4 ) , -17 2010-141 9 ( 4 5 ) , -18 2010-142 10 ( 5 6 ) , -19 2010-143 11 ( 6 7 ) , , -20 2010-144 12 ( 1 8 ) , -21 2010-145 13 ( 2 9 ) , -22 2010-146 35 ( 2 ) , -23 2010-147 38 ( 2 ) -
24 2010-148 39 ( 3 ) -
25 2010-149 48 ( ) -
26 2010- 41 ( ) - 2010.4. 19.27 2010- 42 ( , ) -
-
- 12 -
, 1 27 ).
2009-1085 20 ( ) , , - : 1
2009.11. 23. 2009-1086 22 ( ) , , -
2009-1087 30 ( ) -
2009-1100 5 ( 2 1 ) , , , -
2009.11. 25. 2009-1101 16 ( 5 1 ) , - 2009-1102 19 ( 3 1 ) , - 2010-90 25 ( 2 1 ) , 1
: 1
2009.2. 12. 2010-91 31 ( 7 ) 1
2010-263 22 ( ) , , 2 ( ) 2010.
5. 6. 2010-264 23 ( 3 3 ) , , , 2 2010-265 25 ( 2 1 ) , 1
2010-266 31 ( 7 ) 1
< 2>
[ ] , 1 1 8, 2 1 6, 23 1 8, 24 1, 2, 25 1 15, 1, 2 ,
10 1, 2, 27 , 64 1 5 , 2. .
1) , 2009. 9. 4 , , ,
-
- 13 -
. 4 , .
2) , , ( 2011. 4. 21. 2010 111 , 2002. 5. 17. 2001 10578 ).
4 , 4 4 4 , , .
3) , . .
1) 9 12
-
- 14 -
. 2010. 5. 13. ( ) 9 12 .
2) , , , , 8 2 , 5 , 90 ( 2006. 4. 14. 2004 3847 ).
9 12 2010. 2. 5. ( ), 5 2010. 2. 11. , 9 12 2010. 2. 12. 90 2010. 5. 13.
. 3) 9 12
, . . ( ) 1 8
-
- 15 -
. , ,
( 2010. 4. 29. 2009 16879 ). 1 8
, , 2009. 11.
23. .
1 8 ( 1973. 12. 26. 70 91 ). 1 8
, [ 1 1 , 2009. 10.
2010. 2. , ( ) ( 2007. 4. 26. 2006 18409 ), ]. . ( 3 )
1)
-
- 16 -
3 , , , , , , (
2006. 3. 16. 2006 330 , 2006. 12. 22. 2006 14001 , 2010. 4. 15. 2007 16127 ).
, 32 1 56 1 , 18 1 , , 58 3 56 1 [ 1
-
- 17 -
2] 1 , . ( 2010. 4. 15. 2007 16127 ).
2) 1 , 13 , 14 1 , 16 , 19 1
, , , .
,
-
- 18 -
( 1998. 10. 20. 97 5503 ). 3) (2009. 6. 9. 9758
, ) 58 3 (2009. 11. 20. 21835 , ) 56 1 [
1] 1 2. . , .
( 2010. 4. 15. 2007 16127).
4) ) 4 , 3 2 [ 1] 9
, 10
-
- 19 -
. , 32 1 5 , 18 1 56 1 .
, 1 122.14 , 2
180.67 , .
4 , 3 2 [ 1] 9 .
) 3 1, 2, 10 1, 2 ,
, , , , , , , , , 1, 2 5 < 3>, < 4> ,
.
-
- 20 -
4 1, 2, 10 1, 2 , , , , , < 1>, < 2> . < 1>, < 2> .
, 4 1, 2, 10 1, 2 , < 5> .
, < 5> ( 1 8 ), < 5> 3 7 ( , , , )
1 18 1 12 18 1 13 ( ) 23 24 23 25 23 26 23 27 30 28 33 8 2
< 5>
-
- 21 -
. ) 2
3 , ,
, ( 4 ).
) , , , 33 , , , ,.
(1) 35 1
, . , 6 . .
-
- 22 -
, , , .
, , , ( 1995. 5. 23. 94 2218 ), ( 1997. 7. 22. 96 56153 ,
1999. 7. 27. 98 47528 ), 6 .
.
(2) 33 33 ,
, , .
,
-
- 23 -
, 33 , , 1 , 33 .
33 . . ,
, 9 12 , 1 8 , 4 3
. , 1 12
( ) , , ( ) .
3.
-
- 24 -
, , , . .
1)
, . . , ( 2000. 3. 23. 98 2768 , 1996. 11. 29. 96 8567 ).
-
- 25 -
, , , , , , .
2) , ,
, , . 4 .
-
- 26 -
, . , , . .
.
, , , , ( 2001. 6. 29. 99 9902 , 2006. 3. 16. 2006
330 ). ,
-
- 27 -
, , .
, , ( ) , , .
3) 4
-
- 28 -
. 22 2,000
4 . , . . , ,
, , , , .
1) )
(1) 24 7 , 27 2 , , . , 4 , . 4.4 ( ,
-
- 29 -
, 4 4.4 ) . , .
(2) 24 4 , 25 5 . .
) 6 2 .
) (1) .
( ) 24 7 , 27 2 .
( ) 23 , 20 5 , 24
-
- 30 -
, , , 10 5 , 25 , 10 5 , 19 , 20 , 24 , , .
( ) , , , , , , 20 10 , 5 , , . , 24 7 , 27 2 , ,
-
- 31 -
, .
( ) , , ( 1998. 11. 27. 96 13927 , 2002. 10. 11. 2000 8226 , 2007. 4. 12. 2005 1893 ).
(2006 ~2020 ), (2009 ), (2009 ) .
(2) . ( ) , 24 4 ,
, 14, 15 , 4 1, 2, 5 1, 2 , 2006. 11. 23. 2006. 12. 22. , 2005 2007. 8. ,
2009. 5. 14. , , , 3 , 2009.
-
- 32 -
6. , , , , , , 2009. 6. 17. ( ) .
( ) , , , .
( ) , , .
(3)
. 2) ) ,
, , ,
-
- 33 -
, 23 3 38 6 ..
(2) 6 3 .(3) ( ) (2009. 12. 29. 9848 ,
) 21 3 (2009. 11. 26. 21852 , ) 38 4 38 19 , , , , , , .
38 4 , , , , ,
-
- 34 -
.
( 16 ), ( 17 ), ( 21 ) ( 22 ), ( 24 ), ( 25 ) , , .
, , 38 4 .
6 1, 2 , , , , , , , , , . , .
( ) , 2 1 2 4 , , , ,
-
- 35 -
, .
, 2 1 (2009. 12. 29. 9875 , ) 2 4 , , , , , , , .
, , 21 3 . 38 4 .
. ( ) ,
, , .
3) )
-
- 36 -
(1) 8 , 28 28 , , . 28 , 26 . 5, 16, 19, 20,
22, 30 .
(2) , ( ) . ( ) , 9 .
(3) 30 , 10 3 .
(4) , 2 .
) 6 4 .
-
- 37 -
) (1) 1 , 2 , 9 1 ,
, , , , . 9 1 1 , .
10 1 , 3 , 4 , 26 8 , 27 5 , , , , .
18 1 18 30 1 , 5 , 6 , ,
-
- 38 -
. (2) 2 1 6, 23 2, 3, 4, 6, 24 1, 2,
1, 2 , 10 5, 16, 19, 20, 22, 25, 30, 31 ( ) , , , , , .
, , , , , , ( , , , ) ( , )
-
- 39 -
, , , , 9 1 1 , 28 4 , 29 , 30 , , 1 , 2 , 9 11 , .
, , ,
, , ,
-
- 40 -
, , , , , , , .
) 30 26 , 30 , 61
1, 2 , 10 3 , , , , .
) 10 , 26 , 30 , .
4) ) , 4
, (2 ) 4 ,
-
- 41 -
23 , 4 , .
) 6 5 .
) (1) (2009. 1. 31. 9401 ,
) 91 1 (2009. 8. 28. 2009-73 , ) 2 1 , ( ) , , , , .
91 2 (2009. 4. 21. 120 , ) 80 , 3 , , .
81 2 15 2, 8 ,
-
- 42 -
, , , 20 .
, 7 3 , ( ) , .
(2) 14 2, 15 , 23 ( 220 ) 4
( 294 ) 2009. 2. 13. 2009. 5. 4. 81 , 2009. 7. 23. 2009. 8. 21. 4 , , , , 4 , , 1 , 1 , 3 2009. 10. 5. 4 ,
-
- 43 -
2010. 2. 3. 2010. 3. 6. 30 , 2010. 6. 10. 2010. 6. 29. 20
.
, 4 (20 ) 4 , , 4 .
(3) , , , .
5) ) , (
) , , ,
-
- 44 -
, .
(1) , , .
(2) (18 , 22 ) .
(3) ( ) .
(4) 2005 , 4 1 .
(5) , , , , .
(6) .
-
- 45 -
(7) , .
(9) EL. 7.5m EL. 5.0m ,
. (10) 2009. 12. 31.
EL. 7.5m, 5.0m 3.0m , EL. 3.0m , EL. 5.0m.
(11) , 302 , 4.4 , , .
) 6 7 .
)
-
- 46 -
, , . , , , , .
) (1)
( ) 2009. 7. 17. , 23.(2 ) 24.(1 ) .
( ) 2009. 7. 31. , .
( ) 2009. 8. 5. , (2009. 8. 14.) (2009. 9. 1.) , 2009. 8. 5. 2009. 8. 28. , 2009. 8. 14. 1 , 2
-
- 47 -
, 2009. 8. 25. 2009 -207, 208 ( ) 2009. 9. 10. (1 ) (2 ) .
( ) 2009. 9. 30. , 2009. 10. 21.(2 ),
2009. 10. 23.(1 ) 10. 26.(2 ), 10. 29.(1 ) , 2009. 11. 6. .
(2) ( ) ( ,
), ( , ), ( , , ), ( , ), ( , , ), ( , , ) , , .
( ) , ( , , , , ), , , , ,
-
- 48 -
, . ( )
. ( ) - : , , ,
, , - : ,
( )
- : , , , , ( 5 ) , ,
,
- : , , , ,
, , , , COD, T-P , ,
( ) - : 2 ,
, , ,
- : , ,
,
, ( )
- ,
( )
- : , ,
- :
-
- 49 -
( )
-
( )
- : , ,
, ( )
( ) - : , , , ,
,
( ) - : ( ), ,
( , )
- : , , , , , ,
( )
- ( , ) , (
, 2009. 7.), , ,
, , ( ),
( , ), ( , ), ( , , , , ), ( , , ), ( , ) ( )
- : , , ,
, ,
- : ( ), ( )
-
- 50 -
( ) - , , , ,
( ) - , , ,
, , ( , , )
- , , , , ( ) ,
, ( ) , , , , , , 1:5 , , , 3 , , , .
-
- 51 -
( ) , , , , , , , .
( ) , , , , , , , , , .
(3) ( ) , ( , ,
) , ( 2 ), ( 2 ), (2 ), (2 ), (1 ), ( 2 ), ( 1 ), ( 2 ), ( 2 ) .
( ) , ( , ) 2003. 12. ~ 2009. 5. ,
2008 , 2008 ,
-
- 52 -
2008. 5. ~ 2008. 10. 2008 .
(4)( ) 4 ,
, 2006 .
( ) , 4 ( ) ( ) , ( ) .
( ) 22 9 ( , , , ,, , , , ) 3 /(EFDC4) Full Version) , 3 1 (Qual-ko) 2 ,
4) EFDC , , 3 , 3 , CE-QUAL-ICM , Chesapeak Bay 3 CE-QUAL-ICM .
-
- 53 -
, .
( ) SWAT , -
HEC-LAS , EFDC / , EFDC , .
( ) , EFDC , EFDC SWAT , HEC
-LAS , EFDC / . EFDC EFDC Hydro
Version EFDC Full Version 2 , EFDC-Hydro Version , EFDC Full Version , EFDC Full
Version . ( ) EFDC Full Version Hydrodynamic Module( )
Water Quality Module( ) Hydrodynamic Module Water Quality Module
, EFDC Full Version
-
- 54 -
( , ) ( ) .
( ) EFDC ( ) .
( ) EFDC , , (1~4 ) . 1( ) , 2, 3( , ) 90% .
( ) , 2 , .
( ) , , 5km .
(5) ( ) MODFLOW
, 1m , ,
-
- 55 -
, 2~4m (EL.) 16~25m , .
( ) , . , 18 , ( ) . [ ] , 4 1, 2, 6 1, 2, 7 1
4, 2, 3, 8, 35, 44, 45, 47, 48, 49, 60 , 7 1, 2, 10 1 5, 46 1 8, 50 1 3, 51 1 8, 65 1, 2 , 1 , , , , ,
)
, 3 ,
-
- 56 -
. . ( ) , .
(1) 16 2 , 17 1 23 1 [ 1] 9 , , , , , , (
2008-223 ) , , , , .
(2)
-
- 57 -
, .
(3) , , , , .
(4) , , 2008 , 2008 2003 2009 , 4 , .
-
- 58 -
(5) , , , , , , . , 4 4 , 4 4 .
(6) , .
(7) , , , , .
(8) EL. 7.5m 4 ,
-
- 59 -
, EL.
5.0m , , ( 21 ) ( 22 ) [ , 4 , , , ]. , , , , , EL. 6.0m , EL. 5.0m .
(9) III( 8 , 140 ) , , , 5
-
- 60 -
, , , , ( ) .
(10) .
6) )
(1) 38 1 . 4 , , ,
(Package Project) , 4 500 , 500 .
13 2 6 ,
-
- 61 -
, 13 2 6 .
(2) ,
13 2 6 7 , , , , .
4 .
) (2009. 5. 27. 9712 , )
1 ( ) . 38 ( )
. 1 .
-
- 62 -
2009. 3. 25. 21360 ( )
13 ( ) 38 1 " " 500 300 . 1. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. ,
2009. 3. 25. 21360 ( ) 13 ( )
38 1 " " 500 300 . 1. 1. , , 2. 3. 4. 5. ,
6. , ,
-
- 63 -
7. 8. , 9. , 10. ,
) (1) 4 2009. 3. 25.
13 2 .
(2) 4 , .
, , , , : 13 2
6
: 215 500 8 ( ,
, , , , , , 3 ) : 1,728 500 743
: 3 2 ( , )
: 96 500 6 ( , ,
, , , )
: 13 2 7
(3) 13 2 ,
-
- 64 -
, , .
(4) , 38 4 2009 , 9 1 , 3 , (Package Project) , 4 , , 2 2 .
(5) 4 , , , , , 4 , . [ ] , 1 ,
-
- 65 -
) , 13 2 6
, , , , . , 38 1 .
, .
. (1) ( ) 1999
( 9 2), 2006 2007. 1. 1. .
-
- 66 -
( ) , .
, , .
, ,
, ,
-
- 67 -
. ( ) , , ,
, , , , , , , (AHP)5) .
( ) ,
, , , , , , ( , , ) , . .
( )5) Analytic Hierarchy Process( ), . , , , AHP ,. 0.5 .
-
- 68 -
1999 2008 378 162 (43%) .
(2) , 13
2 6 , ( ) , .
. ( ) ,
1 , , 13 2 6 4 , .
4 ( / ) 2.3 0.05~0.28 , / , 13 2 2009. 3. 25. 4
-
- 69 -
, 4 , 4 4 2009 , 2009. 3. 25. , 4 13 2 13 2 6
. 4
, 4 , , , , 5 , ( , , , , ) , 4 2009 9 4 2 , .
, 13 2 5
-
- 70 -
.
, , / / 0.26 0.11 , .
( ) , .
1999 500 300 4 .
13 2 6
-
- 71 -
, .
(3) 4 ,
8 (6) ), . , , , .
, , , , .
. (4) ,
, 6) , / flow .
-
- 72 -
2008 6 , 2009 3~4 , 22 2,000 6
, , , 200 , 2m , , , 6 , 4 , .
38 1.
-
- 73 -
(5)
, , , .
, , , , , , .
, , , ,
-
- 74 -
, .
. ) 38 1
. 7)
, , , .
) 3.
, , .
-
- 75 -
, , , , , , .
( 1987. 12. 8. 87 861 ).
.
) ,
. (1) ,
, , , 2m , ,
-
- 76 -
, , .
(2) , 2006 2011 1.2 , 2016 1.4 , 4 2011 17 , 10.2
, , , 1 ( ) 8 , , 78.46% , 1 2~3 1 , , .
-
- 77 -
(3) , , , , , , , , , 5 6 , , , , ( , ) , 2012 ( 2 ) , , 20~30 /s , , ,
, , , ~ 1m ,
-
- 78 -
, ~ 6m 2.3m, ~ 3m , EL. 5.0m 4 , EL.
3.0m EL. 5.0m , (24.745 ) (13.603 ) 11.142 , 2.5m ,
, , , , , { (local scour) } , {
(headward erosion) . } , , , , , , , , , ,
-
- 79 -
, , , .
) ,
, , , , .
.
(1) , 4 , , , , 13, 15, 18, 19 , 16, 20 1, 2, 2, 3 , 16 1, 2 1 , 1
-
- 80 -
, , , { (EL. Nino), (La
Nina) } , , ,
2006 7) 63.27%, 16.34% 79.61% , 2008 74.34%, 15.21%, 10.45% , 2m 21.47 ,
3.39 2m , 2006 (PDF, Potential Flood Damage) , 30, 33, 21, 15,
14, 4 , , 2006 26.61m, 26.86m 25.66m , 2002 2003 , , 2002 , , 2003 2010 7) ( ) ( ) ,
-
- 81 -
34 6 , , , , , , , (4.4 ), , 0.9m~3.9m , 2011. 7. , 3.78m , ( ) , , .
(2) , , , 2 2011 79 / 67 / , 2006. 8. 28. 2006
-
- 82 -
-45 ( : ) 61 / , 4 , 2011 7.97 , 2016 9.75 , 4
2016 17 (2011 8 , 2016 10 ) , 13.0 (
10.2 ) , , , , 1 293 9%, 29%, 42% , (10 ) ,
1967 ~1968 27 / , 2009 50 , 2006 , (UNEP) (ESCAP) , 4 2006 , , 60 , 21 , 2006
-
- 83 -
10.2 , (67 / ) , 2006.
8. 28. (61 / ) , (79 / ) 4 2016 17 , 4 13 , , , ( 8 , 8 ), , ,
-
- 84 -
, 4 4 , , , , , , , , , , , , , .
(4) 5)
, . ( ) ,
, 4 , 22 COD, TP (10 ) (3 )
-
- 85 -
10 { 1 ( ), 3 ( , , ), 6 ( , , , , , )} COD, TP , COD, TP , TP ( ) , 10 ( , , , , ) , ( 23 , 33 ) , 9 , 34 , , BOD , , , , , , , , Sheet File ,
EFDC , , 90% , ,
-
- 86 -
5 , , , ( ) , , EFDC , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
-
- 87 -
, . ( ) 54, 55 , 10 1, 2 , 1
, , MODFLOW , I
1.2 , 1m 3.0 , II , , 1.6 , , , 2010 , ( > ) EL. 7.5m 13.76 4 , EL. 5.0m 0.744 ,
2011 8) ( ) {1:5,000 , 50m25m , 20m20m, 25m25m, 5m5m ( ) 2 (Layer) ,8) , , , .
-
- 88 -
} , 8.57
, 8.02 , 4 4.81 , ( 1m, 0.5m) 1.57 , 0.5m 0 ,
1m 0.025 , 1.57 , ,
2010 , 1:25,000 , 100m100m 1 , EL. 5.0m 4 , 2011 , 1:5,000 10m10m( 20m20m) ,
0.5m 6.29 , 1.0m 12.28 , 2.0m 22.84 , 0.5m 3.42 , 1.0m 7.55 , 2.0m 16.03 , 0.5m 0.22 , 1.0m 0.44 , 2.0m 0.82
, 0.5m 0.04 , 1.0m 0.15 , 2.0m 0.34 .
-
- 89 -
, , EL. 7.5m EL. 5.0m , , ( 1m ) , , , , 11 , , 4 4 , 1 , MODFLOW , Dry CELL9) , Dry CELL , Dry CELL ,
GL(Ground Level, ) -1.0m -0.5m , GL -0.5m 0.20 GL -1.0m 0.199) Dry CELL 1 , Dry CELL CELL ( , ) .
-
- 90 -
, ( 52 ) ( 330 ) 52 , 0.26m, 1.24m , ( ) , , , 4 (13.6 )
(24.745 ) (11.142 ) ,
, , , , .
( ) , ,
, , , 2 , 10 1 4 , 4 ,
-
- 91 -
90 , , 45 , 50 ~200 , 20 9 28 , 5 19 , 10
0.97m , , , , .
4.
, 28 . , ( 2001. 1. 19. 99 9674 , 1997. 11. 11.
-
- 92 -
95 4902,4919 ).
.
. , 90%
. 100% , ( ) , , . , , ,
, . ,
,
-
- 93 -
. ,
, , ( , , , , , ) , , , , . ,
, . , 28
.5. , 2
, 4
-
- 94 -
3 . 3 , 28 1 3 13 27 , 1 .
_________________________
_________________________
_________________________
-
- 95 -
1 (1,789 ) ~
2
, . 2009. 11. 12. ,
1) 18 ( 2 1 ) , 2) 20 ( ) , 3) 22 ( ) , 4) 23 ( 3 3 ) , 5) 24 ( ) , 6) 30 ( ) , 7) 32 ( ) , 8) 33 ( ) ( 1 1 8 ),
. 2010. 2. 5. , 1) 21 ( 1 1 ) , 2) 29 ( 5 ) , 3) 34 ( 1 3 ) , 4) 36 ( 3 3 ) ( 1 9 12 ),
( ) .
3 ~
4. (464 ) ~
-
- 96 -
5
200m ,
300m
1km
5
5
5
,
( 1km ) ( 1km )
,
200m , ,
< 3> 1
-
- 97 -
( , ) 500m ,
300m
1km
,
( 1km ) ( 1km )
200m ,
,
< 4> 2
-
- 98 -
6
1.
1 ( ) . 4 ( )
( ) . 9. .
13 ( ) ( )
. 14 ( )
( ) . . 16 ( )
.
( ) , . . 19 ( )
. .
3 ( )
4 3 1 . [ 1] , ( 3 2 23
-
- 99 -
1 )
9.
2 5 10
1) 2 2
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 ) 1 ( ) ( ) . 2 ( ) .
2. 10 1 . 5. .
32 ( ) 27 , 30 5
31 ( ) 3 , , .
5. 30 ( 2 6 ), 56 , 86 88
33 ( )
..
1. 2.
-
- 100 -
3. 4. , 5. 6. 1 ( ) ,
. . 1. 13 2. 3. 4.
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 ) 18 ( )
10 ( ) 2 , .
1. 56 , 86 , 88
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 ) 56 ( )
( ) ( ) . , .
1. 2. ( ) 3. 4. ( 57 ) 5. 1
-
- 101 -
58 ( )
.
.
.
(2009. 11. 20. 21835 56 ( ) 58 3 1 2 . [ 1] ( 56 ) 1.
.
(2)
2. (2009. 6. 9. 9758 )
23 ( )
20 ( ) . 5
. .
, . 24 ( ) , ,
10 ( ) .
-
- 102 -
5 . , (
. ), , .
( 2 ) . 1 2
. 7 6 . , 25
. 25 ( )
10 . 1
. . 5
. .
. , . 9 2 . 7 6 .
27 ( ) ( 28 1 .
) ( ) . , .
-
- 103 -
.
.
30. . ,
.
. 1. 2.
5 6
. 7 5
. 9 5 .
30 ( ) 6 9 28
. , . 1
. . 1 . 1
. 1
. . 5 .
-
- 104 -
. , . 7 5
. 8 27 5
. 1 33 1 50 1 2
.
3. (2009. 12. 29. 9848 )
2 ( ) .
1. " " 2 4 . 21 3 ( ) ( "
" ) .
. .
(2009. 12. 29. 9875 ) 2 ( ) .
4. " " ( ), . , 1 . . . . .
-
- 105 -
(2009. 11. 26. 21852 ) 38 4 ( ) 21 3 38 5 38 19 . , .
1. 100 2. 3. 4. 5.
38 5 ( ) (
" " ) . 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
38 6 ( ) . , 500
. 1
, . 38 7 ( ) 38 6 ,
-
- 106 -
. 1. 2. 3. 4. (
) 5. 6.7. 8. ,
. .
. 1 4 ,
. 3 .
38 9 ( ) , , ,
( " " ) . , 1 . .
-
- 107 -
96 .< 2005.6.30, 2005.12.30> 38 12 ( ) .
38 13 ( ) 100
( " " ) 22 . , 100 .
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 ) 16 ( )
( ) ( ) ( ) . 17 ( ) , , ,
( ) [ ( ) ] . 21 ( ) , , ,
( ) .
4. (2009. 6. 9. 9758 )
1 ( ) . 2 ( ) ( ) . 9 ( )
-
- 108 -
. 1. ( )
. ( ). ,.
. . ( ) . 10 ( )
( ) 1 , 2 .
1. 9 1 1 2 , 5 5 2 7 8 11 2. 9 1 4 7 8 11 1 6
. 1
. 1 . 1
. ,.
5 1 4 . 18 ( )
10 ( ) 2 , .
18. 30 , 33 50 1
.
-
- 109 -
26 ( ) 8 27 5 10
. 1 27 6 75
.
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 ) 8 ( ) .
27 ( ) . ,
. 28 ( )
. 1 . 1 2 .
30 ( ) 6 9 28
. 1
. . 5 .
(2009. 7. 27. 21641 ) 28 ( )
28 2 " " .
28 2 3 .
1.
-
- 110 -
2.
3. 39 1
5. (2009. 1. 30. 9401 )
91 ( )
( " " ) . 1
, . .
1 , ,.
(2009. 4. 21. 120 ) 80 ( ) 91 2 ( " " )
, 15 . 81 2 ( ) 91 1 15 2 . [ 15 2] ( 81 2 )
.
2 2 : 27 : 30 5
(2009. 8. 28. 2009-73) 3 ( )
-
- 111 -
.
1. : 2. : ( )
7 ( ) 2 . , . ( )
, , 8 ( )
, , 20 . , , , .
, , .
6.
16 ( )
. ( )
, . . 17 ( )
16 2 .
1. 13 2 2.
21 ( )
-
- 112 -
18 , .
1. ( )
2. 22 ( )
21 .
23 ( )
16 1 2 1 . 31 ( )
21 1 1 " " 18 1 5 . 21 1 2 " " . 1. 18 1 30 (
30 . ) 2. 1 . ,
.
3. 7 [ 1] , ( 3 2 23 1 )
9.
) 8 : 27
) 8 (1) : 6 (2) : 30 2
-
- 113 -
8.
2 ( ) .
13. " ( )" ( ) . . ( )
. . 28 ( ) , , .
(2009. 6. 9. 9758 ) 2 ( ) .
1. 7 2 3 , .
2. 10 1 . 3.
. , . . ( ) ( ) . ( )
( ( ) ) ( )
. ( ) ( ) .
8.
-
- 114 -
.
(2009. 7. 27. 21641 ) 2 ( ) ( " " ) 2 3 " " ( )
, .
10 ( )
. 1 .
2 ( ) ( " " ) 10 2 1 . [ 1] ( 2 ) 3.
. (2)
( )
(pH)
(BOD)( /L)
(COD)( /L)
(SS)( /L)
(DO)( /L)
(T-P)( /L)
( /100mL)
Ia 6.5 8.5 1 2 25 7.5
0.02 50 10
Ib 6.5 8.5 2 4 25 5.0 0.04 500 100
II 6.5 8.5 3 5 25 5.0
0.1 1,000 200
III 6.5 8.5 5 7 25 5.0 0.2 5,000 1,000
-
- 115 -
. (2)
IV 6.0 8.5 8 9
100 2.0
0.3 - -
V 6.0 8.5 10 11
2.0 0.5 - -
VI - 10 11 - 2.0
0.5 - -
( )
(pH)
(COD)( /L)
(SS)( /L)
(DO)( /L)
(T-P)( /L)
(T-N)( /L)
-a(Chl-a)( / )
( /100mL)
Ia 6.5 8.5 2 1 7.5
0.01 0.2 5
50
10
Ib 6.5 8.5 3 5 5.0 0.02 0.3 9500
100
II 6.5 8.5 4 5 5.0
0.03 0.4 14
1,000
200
III 6.5 8.5 5 15 5.0 0.05 0.6 205,000
1,000
IV 6.0 8.5 8 15 2.0
0.10 1.0 35 - -
V 6.0 8.5 10
2.0 0.15 1.5 70 - -
VI - 10 - 2.0
0.15 1.5 70