43-61-134.pdf

74
- 61 - 中國文哲研究集刊 第四十三期 2013 9 61134 中央研究院中國文哲研究所 越南莫朝詩人阮秉謙 白雲庵詩集現地研究 簡錦松 (高雄)中山大學中文系教授 一、前言 阮秉謙 (Nguyễn Bỉnh Khiêm, 1491-1585) 是越南莫朝著名詩人 1 。本研究採 用現地研究法,首先利用越南國家圖書館(National Library of Vietnam,簡稱 NLV)所收藏的阮秉謙《白雲庵詩集》(Bạch Vân Am Thi Tập) 和多種越南古代 地理方志,分析阮秉謙詩文,再依據阮秉謙本人的敘述,進行衛星地圖的分析 擬測。在此期間,筆者曾於二○一三年七月十八日至二十二日,親赴越南進行 現地的調查。我先訪問了位在河內市的「越南社會科學院」,在該院所屬的「漢 喃研究所」中借閱了 NLV 館藏之外的十五種阮秉謙詩集,再於該院的哲學研 究所舉辦演講會,聽取河內阮秉謙研究學者的意見。隨後赴海防市,訪問曾對 阮秉謙〈中津觀碑記〉做過現地調查的吳登利教授。在吳教授的協助下,對海 防市區與海防所轄的建安縣、先朗縣、永寶縣、塗山郡的地形與交通細節,作 了深入的了解。最後,我以現地研究方法,對阮秉謙筆下的白雲庵相關地點, 進行了 GPS 測量與拍攝,完成現地驗證步驟。 本論文預期解決以下四個問題: (1) 了解《白雲庵詩集》的現存狀況,並指出誤入本集的他人詩作。 1 有關阮秉謙生平,可參考 Tạ Ngọc Liên, Renowned Vietnamese Intellectuals: Nguyễn Bỉnh Khiêm (Hà Nội: Thê Giới Publishers, 2004),還有專為阮秉謙介紹而架設的 Facebook 網頁:https://www.facebook.com/pages/Nguy C3 AA CC 83n-Bi CC 89nh-Kh C AAm/ 110758252351336

Upload: minh-hai

Post on 29-Sep-2015

10 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • - 61 -

    2013 9 61134

    (Nguyn Bnh Khim, 1491-1585) 1

    National Library of Vietnam

    NLV(Bch Vn Am Thi Tp)

    NLV

    GPS

    (1)

    1 T Ngc Lin, Renowned Vietnamese Intellectuals: Nguyn Bnh Khim (H Ni: Th Gii Publishers, 2004) Facebookhttps://www.facebook.com/pages/Nguy C3 AA CC 83n-Bi CC 89nh-Kh C AAm/ 110758252351336

  • - 62 -

    (2) GPS

    (3)

    (4)

    Google Earth Pro

  • - 63 -

    1.

    NLV

    NLV(Digital

    Collections of the Vietnamese, Nm Preservation Foundation) 2

    (1) R.2017NLVNPF-0083

    3

    (2) R.1917NLVNPF-0084

    (3) R.105NLVNPF-0081

    2 (National Library of Vietnam)http://lib.nomfoundation.org/collection/1/

    A.132

    3

  • - 64 -

    (4) R.101NLVNPF-0082

    (5) R.423NLVNPF-1241

    (6) R.1718NLVNPF-0515

    266 61 122

    73 73

    66 66

    110 110 110

    42 42

    515 286 340

    NLV

  • - 65 -

    4

    (1726-1784)

    1a

    1b

    (1852)

    VHc1952

    NLV

    NLV

    VHc1952 5

    4 1987 4 2 189-201

    5 VHc1952

    309

  • - 66 -

    6

    7

    1522-1527

    32 37

    8

    9

    6

    7 22b38a1248a

    8b27b

    30a

    abab 8 1248b

    1114a1162b12a

    9 1160a (1563)

    1163b

  • - 67 -

    10

    2.

    NLV

    11

    NLV

    12

    1 A.2256 R2017

    R2017

    2 A.2591 56 (1828)

    1161b 10

    (9a)(8b)118b

    11

    12 http://140.109.24.175/pasweb/

    A.296/1-2

    VHc1952-1953

  • - 68 -

    3 VHc1952-1953

    645

    R2017

    NLV

    4 A.1350 R2017

    R2017

    5 VHv.1453a 354 R2017

    VHv.1453b

  • - 69 -

    6 VHv.1453b 514 R2017

    7 VHv.144 427 R1917 (1868)

    8 VHv.850 272

    R2017R1917

  • - 70 -

    9 VHv.1794 540

    10 VHv.2081

    11 VHv.188 209

    12 VHv.2615

    13 AB.309AB.157

    12

    14 AB.365MF.2373

    13

    15 A.132 266

  • - 71 -

    NLV

    VHc1952VHv1794

    VHc1952 VHv850

    NLV

    13

    NLV

    NLV

    NLV

    14

    12107

    15

    16

    13 VHc1952

    14

    15 16 Nguyn Ti Cn, Th Phn Dnh Th Nm Nguyn Tri V Th Nm Nguyn Bnh Khim

    In Nguyn Bnh Khim-v tc gi v tc phm , ed. Trn Th Bng Thanh and V Thanh (H Ni: Nh xut bn Gio dc, 2001), pp. 524-538 Nguyn Tri (1380-1442)Nguyn Ti Cn

  • - 72 -

    R2017

  • - 73 -

    VHs1952

    17

    18

    1128a

    19

    17 VHc1952 307-308

    18 11 27b-28a 19

  • - 74 -

    20

    VHc19521984-1986 16 860 (1566)

    20 1162a40a40a1162b40a

    R2017

  • - 75 -

    VHc1952

    VHc1952

    (1550)

  • - 76 -

    21

    21 2b-3a (1550)

    851

    (1556) 855

    R2017

  • - 77 -

    22

    23

    24

    (1532) (1535)

    25

    22

    23 11 49a48b 24

    119b

    1249a

    25 VHc1952

  • - 78 -

    26

    27

    28

    26 11 48b48a 27 VHc1952

    28 1975 76 1736

  • - 79 -

    29

    30

    1 1157a

    2 1157a

    3 1239a

    4 1239a-b

    5 1248b

    6 43a

    7 28b

    29 1121a

    30

  • - 80 -

    8 30b

    9 32a

    10 32a

    11 32b

    12 40b-41a

    13 1141a

    14 1127b

    15 1128a

    16 1161a

    31

    17 1163a

    31 VHc1952

  • - 81 -

    18 1163a

    19 1164a

    20 1230b-31a

    32

    21 29a

    22 29a

    23 29b

    24 40a

    25 40b

    26 44a

    27 1148b

    28 1149a

    29 1157b

    32

  • - 82 -

    GPS

    Ng Quang Li

    33

    (1542)

    34

    33 Ng Quang LiMt Vi Kin V Vn Bn Hc- Bi K Bia Qun Trung Tm Ca Nguyn Bnh KhimTrn Th Bng Thanh, V Thanh, Nguyn Bnh Khim-v tc gi v tc phm () (H Ni: Nh xut bn Gio dc, 2001), pp. 178-181

    Mt S Vn V Thn Th V S Nghip Ca Nguyn Bnh Khim 42-53

    34 VHv144

  • - 83 -

    35

    36

    37

    35 11 3b-4a 35 Database of Comprehensive Urbanism of Hanoi, Vietnam

    36 37 Center for Southeast Asian Studies and Center for Integrated Area Studies http://area.net.cias.kyoto-u.ac.jp/hanoidb/index.html2012 6 20

    37 1b-2a

  • - 84 -

    Sng Vn c

  • - 85 -

    Sng Ha

    38

    (1) 11

    18a1156b

    (2) 11

    8b1131a

    1126a

    (3)

    16aVHc1952315

    (4) 1124a

    39

    40

    38 i Tm Du Vt ng Trng, Trn Hai B Sng Vnh Trinh Qu Kh Trinh Khc Nghin Nguyn Trung Hn Sng Tuyt,

    Sng Vnh Trinh Sng Ha Sng Vnh TrinhSng HaTrn Th Bng Thanh, and V Thanh, Nguyn Bnh Khim-v tc gi v tc phm, pp. 650-

    657 39 40 11

    25a1113a1132a

    VHc19521114b

  • - 86 -

    (1809)(1833)

    (1900)(1908)

    (1909) 41

    42

    (1435)43

    Sng Vn

    c

    Sng Vn c

    44

    1130b118b

    41 (Digital Collections of the Vietnamese, Nm Preservation Foundation)http://lib.nomfoundation.org/collection/1/

    2012 9 12 42 1908

    R.640NLVNPF-0111 37b 71b

    43 R2016NLVNPF-0167

    44 1960 426 4693

  • - 87 -

    45

    46

    47

    48

    Sng Vn c

    Sng Vn c

    Sng Vn c 49

    50

    Sng Vn c

    20 41'24.79" 106 39'27.57"

    Ph Dng o

    Sng Vn c

    Ph Dng o Sng Vn c

    45 11 6a

    46 13b

    47 48

    14a 49

    Sng Vn c 50

    14b

  • - 88 -

    Sng Vn c

    20 41'15.24" 106 42'0.89"Nam Hi

    51

    52 Sng Vn c

    Sng Vn c

    51 Sng Vn c Tram Quan Ly uong Sng Vn c 52 Sng Vn c

    Sng Vn c 20 41'15.24"

    106 42'0.89"E

  • - 89 -

    Sng

    Vn cSng Vn c

    Ph Dng

    o

    1.

    53

    54

    55

    56

    53 19a 54 12 47b-48a 55 24b 56 VHv1794 23a

    11 14b

  • - 90 -

    57

    58

    Sng Vn c

    Ph Dng o

    20 41'24.79"106 39'27.57"

    20 41'12.53" 106 39'22.26"

    57 11 10b-11a14b31a23b 58 11 16b19b

    11 67 VHc1952

  • - 91 -

    59

    20 41'

    56.214" 106 37'29.08"

    Ct

    B Island

    59 (1720-1729) Chinese Southern Diaspora Studies4 (2010): 163-175

    20 41'12.53" 106 39'22.26"

  • - 92 -

    Cha Thng Phuc

    60

    60 11a 11 14b

  • - 93 -

    S V

    (1)(2)

    (3)

  • - 94 -

    2.

    61

    62

    61 11 23a-b 16b

    62 11 9b19a59a10a13b-14a

  • - 95 -

    Sng Vn c

    3.

    20 41'56.25"106 37'28.56"

  • - 96 -

    63

    Sng Vn c

    4.

    64

    65

    Ph Dng o

    63 1995 6 561

    64 1987 382 3875 65

    20 40'

    37.69" 106 33'6.44"

  • - 97 -

    20 40'37.75"106 33'5.51"

    20 40'

    37.88" 106 33'5.15"

  • - 98 -

    66

    VHv850 VHc1952

    5.

    125a

    67

    66 19b 67 10a 11 33a-b

  • - 99 -

    4.98

    20 41'56.214" 106 37'29.08"

    540

    1.

  • - 100 -

    68

    [1542]

    25b69

    1119b

    VHc19524041

    20b118b

    1115b

    8b701121a

    71

    72

    68 11 22b 17 48b 69 12 6a 25b 70 14b 71

    VHv1794 16a

    72 11 23b

  • - 101 -

    73

    74

    75

    1116b

    1126b

    73

    11 9a-13b

    11 25a-b

    74 11 53a 26a-b 11 66b 75 30a

  • - 102 -

    76

    77

    10b

    2.

    78

    76 VHc1952 76 77 30a 78 11 19b

  • - 103 -

    79

    80

    81

    82

    83

    Sng Vn

    c

    3.

    84

    79 11 22b 80 6a 81 29a 82 11 33b 83 12 51b-52a 84 11 9a31a11a VHc1952

  • - 104 -

    (3)

    85

    TL391

    1126a

    1126b

    86

    VHc1952

    85 11 23a-b 86 11 15a58b59a

  • - 105 -

    87

    88

    89

    1166b

    90

    91

    87 11 11b7b

    88 11 28b 89

    19b

    90 11 9b10b16a-b 91 227 2451

  • - 106 -

    92

    93

    92 126a-b1110a

    93 11 14a16a17b

  • - 107 -

    94

    95

    tp. Ung B Thng Yn Cng

    Cha ng 21 9'39.32" 106 42'54.23"

    Google Earth Pro

    21 11'9.94" 106 31'11.61"

    21 8'32.57" 106 52'45.90"

    94 1156b 21 3'30.06" 105 21'59.20"

    95 11 18a15a7b

  • - 108 -

    Cha

    ng

    Sng Vn c

    20 41'24.42"106 41'54.15"

    20 41'24.75"106 41'53.92"

    4.57

  • - 109 -

    Google Earth Pro

    96

    96 1987 101 (visibility in atmosphere)

  • - 110 -

    1.

    97

    (Ph Dng o)

    98

    (Ct B Island)

    99

    Ph Dng o

    Ph Dng o

    97 11 10a 98

    20 42'21.82" 106 46'44.75"Sng Lch TraySng Vn c

    99 11 9b1155b

  • - 111 -

    100

    2.

    101

    (An Lo)

    20 50'22.89" 106 34'5.07"

    (Khu DL Ni Voi)

    Tin Hi 20 49'17.88" 106 34'59.41"

    (Kin An)

    (i Thin Vn)

    100 101 22a 17 55

  • - 112 -

    20 47'41.26" 106 36'47.78" 130

    10.7

    (kin Thuy)20 48'21.17"106 37'49.67"

    20 41'53.86" 106 37'16.82"341.94

    20 41'53.86" 106 37'16.75"355.5

  • - 113 -

    20 48'50.51" 106 38'22.08"

    (Kin Thuy) Thanh

    20 41'53.87" 106 37'16.72"

    2.83

    20 41'53.87" 106 37'16.54"35.56

  • - 114 -

    Sn 20 44'41.59" 106 39'36.34"

    Cha Thng Phuc

  • - 115 -

    102

    103

    104

    102

    103 11 17a16b59a 22b104 11 11a 18b 11 19a64a

    27a

  • - 116 -

    105

    1137a

    105 12b 11 12a

  • - 117 -

    (1516-1522)

    (1522-1527)

    (1535)

    (1542)

    (1585)

    106

    106 1a-3b

  • - 118 -

    107

    107

  • - 119 -

    108

    109

    110

    111

    108 11 45b-46a65a-b46a109 [1540]

    8471974

    230

    110 35b111

    8334-8335

  • - 120 -

    112

    (1555) 113

    11:43a

    11:43b

    11:43b

    11:44a

    11:44a

    11:44b

    11:44b

    11:45a

    11:45a

    11:46b

    112 3a113

    16 853 [1555]

  • - 121 -

    11:48a

    11:48b

    11:49a

    11:49b

    11:49b

    11:50a

    11:50a

    11:50b

    11:50b-51a

    11:51a

    11:51a

    11:51b

    11:51b

    11:52a

    11:52a

    11:52b

    11:52b

    11:53a

    11:53b

    11:54a

  • - 122 -

    11:54b

    11:54b

    11:55a

    11:58b

    114

    1144a

    1152a

    1152b

    1153b-54a

    1154b

    1551

    115

    114 11 52a115 11 52b

  • - 123 -

    116

    (Tnh H Giang)

    (Tnh Yn Bi)

    116 1981 1b-2a

  • - 124 -

    117

    1151a

    1152b

    1150a

    1155a118

    119

    (1)

    (2)

    117 11 22a-b 11 21a-22a

    118

    119 11 58b

  • - 125 -

    1248b

    1155a

    1128b-30a

  • - 126 -

    (1546)

    120

    121

    122

    1550

    (1550)

    123

    120 16850

    121 1966 331 6077

    122 347 6290123 16

  • - 127 -

    (1551)

    124

    1160a

    1155b-56a

    15511563

    125

    [1535]

    1163a

    852124 371 6636

    125 11 66b

  • - 128 -

    126

    127 [1564]

    1161b

    128

    126 11 26a-b1136b

    127 VHc1952

    128 12a-b 11 12a25a15a9a

    29b 1113b10b

  • - 129 -

    20 41'56.23 106 37'28.50"

  • - 130 -

  • - 131 -

    (1491-1585)

    (1)(2)

    GPS(3)

    (4)

  • - 132 -

    On-Site Research on Nguyn Bnh Khim, Vietnamese Poet of the Mc Dynasty,

    and His Bch Vn Am thi tp

    CHIEN Chin-sung

    Nguyn Bnh Khim (1491-1585) is a distinguished poet of the Mc Dynasty of

    Vietnam. The present study conducts on-site research into his Bch Vn Am thi tp. The

    aims of this research are to examine this collection and to identify works by other poets

    that are wrongly collected into it; to investigate the modern site of his Xue Jin Jiang; and

    to compare and contrast it with Zhongjin Yuedu, using GPS; to reconstruct the settings

    (including Bch Vn Am and Zhongjin Guan) and to explore the realism of his poems; and

    finally, to emend the biographical records and background information about the poet, as

    well as to review his role in the history of poetry.

    Keywords: Vietnamese Literature Nguyn Bnh Khim Bch Vn Am thi tpOn-Site Research

  • - 133 -

    1984http://hanji.sinica.edu.tw2012 6 9

    2010http://140.109.24.175/pasweb/default.asp2012 61

    1966

    1987

    R.423NLVNPF-1241

    1984-1986

    R.2017NLVNPF-0083

    R.1917NLVNPF-0084

    R.105NLVNPF-0081

    R.101NLVNPF-0082

    R.1718NLVNPF-0515

    VHc1952-1953

    VHv1794

    (1435)

    Center for Southeast Asian Studies and Center for Integrated Area StudiesDatabase

    of Comprehensive Urbanism of Hanoi, Vietnam

    http://area.net.cias.kyoto-u.ac.jp/hanoidb/L/index.html2012 6 20

    (1909)

    Chinese Southern Diaspora Studies

    4 (2010): 163-175

    1974

    (1908)

    1960

    (Digital Collections of the Vietnamese, Nm

    Preservation Foundation)http://lib.nomfoundation.org/collection/1/

    2012 6 1

    (1900)

  • - 134 -

    2002

    (1833)

    1981

    A132Google comGoogle Earth ProH Huy Gip. Tp Nghin Cu v Bnh Lun Vn Hc Chn Lc. H Ni:

    Nh Xut Bn H N, 2001.

    Ng ng Li, Nguyn Bnh Khim Danh Nhn Vn H. H Ni: B

    Vn Ha Thng Tin V Th Thao, 1991.

    Nguyn Hu Ch. Trng Trnh Nguyn Bnh Khim Hi Phng 1991. Hi Phng: Hi ng Lch

    s Hi Phng Vin Vn Hc Vit Nam, 2005.

    T Ngc Lin. Renowned Vietnamese Intellectuals: Nguyn Bnh Khim. H Ni: Th Gii

    Publishers, 2004.

    Trn Th Bng Thanh, and V Thanh. Nguyn Bnh Khim V Tc Gi V Tc Phm

    . H Ni: Nh Xut Bn Gio Dc, 2001.

    Vin Khoa Hc X Hi Thnh Ph H Ch Minh. Nguyn Bnh Khim Trong Lch S Pht Trin

    Vn Ha n Tc. Thnh Ph Ch Minh: Trung Tm Nghin Cu Hn Nm, 1991.