90b00080 ootlboœob 'v'og^^c^acroô bôjry'bg „80ba0030 c6...

32
90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6*3b0a)Ob V0655S?8fR0ô" 6(T).^8o,'>6ob ';]*f3ff^'y?)<^(r)o^ (j[]Co(o,"î';^g:^>o bv^b^'^O.^c^aïjj^'o (.^()(^|{(')^^'o boJ(3()v^) 'cJ^jo^jCoocScî .^.^^;j;'ù(^ob b^^boaï '3Q8fo^;,TjO '(l[]8^5Co^jfi^n(ir)^0(j): è-Bo ci. S^,\ fîîCO^^dObO,,Voy^bng)365o, i-Bo X ^'n(^06^06O, j-Bo b. ?)C0ôt)B^(^C')3.\ ?)-Bo ^. Je)3^G(oO, ?)-Bo J. 3^'^0D30, è-Bo ^. b3O0^8^6O, i-Go b. D. 5^0?>06bO, Rfob^Bùf^oojîo^Qàn, à-Bo b. BOO^bOGO, b^JQoob BfDogùBo, o8b5^^fî^>6 (^à ^^^3à(^f^fr)[]àoa) 2006 ^ci.^ob o.^Bjj^r^'Bo, ^68roo(5^^Bv^ ^oBo5Bjï)^?>6(^3 ^^Bo^R^Bo: 1. b.bb^8ùfoo)^fob \7oB.^'c)g ^'^d'^8 ^■■''^S^ôO^'^^**^ ^îJ^ (^"jb^oiob 8rojcig:^>tbjob, à-B -^ff^^db^o ^g^^Bob dy SobQoyi^ob (5'^B8(jbo5j:o^èQfr^>o) 8OQ{^ 2001 ^^^^ob 16 Bn^Bà^cob fo^gbyooob a)ùgob';]«gffn;)?).^a)6 i^^^gob yijCofo^'gffno JooBgyB^oob (jroB3(jB(3O05) 34-y a^ybf^o. 2. ^.^B8(3bc>i:o^i^gnnb, (^roBgffnb,^^ SÇ.i7]^[)bj:oo> hc^dà(n(nçi^i}h(no^o ^^^(330, Ç'.'^(^8r').-5i:D^;jBgoB3B 8r)bjfO[jbù J:D,^ BO^BO Bf035C7(^fOfo'3o Bros^njjùÇ"^ o'gCoobg^J^o: j-Bo ro. 'So^^^ff^'^^-^) ?>-6o o. bojvrot^rogo jvo^ j-Bo ;]. gcjBjxtngo^, „b^(jroa)0>'9fO{^obD t)*3Sï!^8^8^*^^^ ^"^Oti*^^*" o'^(^ob(5o, ^ôQCocnoùBQcS'gii^o bôB^o^fo^i^B. (n'^h^cnoh Bm^jjfocjè^bb (BcD^gfonà»^) ^^foSrOi'^fo^^Bfo^ i-Bo il îi^»635g,'jOj ùj:o68oc>Bob "J^Si^'^J^^^^ob (jQfoi^.^'gff^ b.bbc586foa)sînfo7)o {^'^bgwob 8oou[j(^icoaob ^o>fo8ro86po^^Bg(ï^o. 3. ^5B8(3bo^s:oQÏî)^K^>o 80^00oa>ocScoo), foro8 ^oB^b^^^foo po-^J-^nO^"^^ i^-^Vo^^G^tlf^'cJ*^^'*^*^ yroçrjBob j:ofo(»-)b, 0^)0 ."îofi^o(3oob norjoQC^QtSB.^ 6^o>8(]b, 8i:DQ(^{îi(^)?)oœo bj^jbob ,bfoO)b(^'3sz^i^^>(0(jùBob Ô'^'iD'^'^Ô^cJ^O^^^'^ poo5 8obo Bjjjff^i^^roiob .bs:noO)C^^(Sob BOTJBOO), (^ob '^Oï^OÔ'^i^'^G' '^<^Sï3[^o(3onb ^ùBj|f0Ç3oc^>;j?)ob a3C>B5^^foogo^B ^o^pnBfobg.-') iÇ^ by(^bg8^S^o g>o>o'bo6B6. c>b;)j];) J<^Bj]^)B(30ob 83-3 i:oo5 80-I3 S^jb^^'Q?)'^)^ ^6jjfos:oBf*7?)oa? 0^0 f)oroj:oô, (^008 ^ùBrodo^jàc .'^8 j'j'jmboa) 4. 5.'>B(3bùtoy?)6 5^CÇ-:5[)(3^ boib.^B.'>ffî(n^H«)b <3oc^[j^^^> ^odG*^^"^^ (^^"c) î^'ol^^*". -^7l^dÔ" ^'^^^ bùbo8ùfo(T)C!^>f)b f^Qô^'''^'^8^Ô")' '^^ ^8(i(3"*^^^ *S^'^<^(^Ci,'0i'9o bc^JBob (^*iBBboij[j;j|j;]Sii^»o 3cy^c:>fyù ^Cifiohù%^l](n^^ 26-^ B';]bjz:;^»ob l-^^'o '^'yB^-j(^ob 'S^b.^^cS.^Bobc^jTo. 5. 2004 \7^'ob 24 B^obb b.ib.^8ibfoo)c:^'rob BoB.bCoajo^ ùfoc)Boo>B()b \']'^Jiï^',']?>0*^'^^^ ?)(^0(3*^B''J^'8Ù o^cooib.^Bmùjjfoco&fo f'){^^i"^Bo1)o>(30ùB, (^i}Ç^(^'jh (^(^o>b(^8ù, oBolxnjjob, fo(o8 Bo^j^^io B^jbùB^ Bbi^co^gj ?)ù(^(r}i]oh f)^h^^&iO)^ù. ^(ni^%o^i]^^dà Bcoajbci^jBc^'by "^jc^Cno '^'jajbcn.^. (>B,^[jjT)(<7f')''j^»c^fo .l(oy'bo(Tj^B(^8>'^ (^l]^<^l\h (^f^-^l^Ô**^^ [)'Z)*^'^^'ÎNt)*^'^ ^c^S^ii^ogoîB,^ B(*70')b(o;jBob b()Si^>.>bp^u> "B^K^oriBob '3^]bu()p:^>0ig^MO?).^l)g, (^.^lw^(3 b,^('|8ob jiD.-^TJj^^jii-^ 'ijBi^.^ BfOt^j^j(^g^>ro^,.b.

Upload: others

Post on 16-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^ c aCROô

bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6*3b0a)Ob V0655S?8fR0ô"

6(T).^8o,'>6ob ';]*f3ff 'y?)< (r)o (j[]Co(o,"î'; g: >o bv^b ' O.^c^aïjj 'o (.^()( |{(')^ 'o boJ(3()v^) 'cJ jo jCoocScî .^.^^;j;'ù(^ob

b^^boaï '3Q8fo ;,TjO '(l[]8^5Co^jfi^n(ir)^0(j):

è-Bo ci. S ,\ fîîCO^^dObO,,Voy^bng)365o,

i-Bo X ^ ' n ( ^ 0 6 ^ 0 6 O ,

j-Bo b. ?)C0ôt)B^(^C')3.\

?)-Bo ^. Je)3^G(oO,

?)-Bo J. 3^ '^0D30,

è-Bo ^ . b 3 O 0 ^ 8 ^ 6 O ,

i-Go b. D. 5^0?>06bO, Rfob^Bùf^oojîo^Qàn,

à-Bo b. BOO^bOGO, b^JQoob BfDogùBo,

o8b5^^fî^>6 (^à ^^^3à(^f^fr)[]àoa) 2006 ^ci.^ob o.^Bjj^r^'Bo,

^68roo(5^^Bv^ ^oBo5Bjï)^?>6(^3 ^^Bo^R^Bo:

1. b.bb^8ùfoo)^fob \7oB. 'c)g ^'^d'^8 ^■■'' S^ôO ' ^**^ ^îJ^ (^"jb^oiob 8rojcig:^>tbjob, à-B -^ff^^db^o

^g^^Bob dy SobQoyi^ob (5'^B8(jbo5j:o^èQfr^>o) 8OQ{^ 2001 ^^^^ob 16 Bn^Bà^cob fo^gbyooob

a)ùgob';]«gffn;)?).^a)6 i^^^gob yijCofo^'gffno JooBgyB^oob (jroB3(jB(3O05) 34-y a^ybf^o.

2. ^.^B8(3bc>i:o^i^gnnb, (^roBgffnb,^^ SÇ.i7] [)bj:oo> hc^dà(n(nçi^i}h(no^o ^^^(330, Ç'.' ( 8r').-5i:D ;jBgoB3B

8r)bjfO[jbù J:D, BO^BO Bf035C7(^fOfo'3o Bros njjùÇ" o'gCoobg^J^o: j -Bo ro. 'So^^^ff ' ^-^) ?>-6o o.

bojvrot^rogo jvo j -Bo ;]. gcjBjxtngo^, „b^(jroa)0>'9fO{^obD t)*3Sï!^8^8^*^^^ ^"^Oti*^^*" o'^(^ob(5o,

^ôQCocnoùBQcS'gii^o bôB^o^fo^i^B. (n'^h^cnoh Bm^jjfocjè^bb (BcD^gfonà»^) ^^foSrOi'^fo^^Bfo^ i-Bo il

îi^»635g,'jOj ùj:o68oc>Bob "J^Si^'^J^^^^ob (jQfoi . 'gff^ b.bbc586foa)sînfo7)o {^'^bgwob 8oou[j(^icoaob

^o>fo8ro86po^^Bg(ï^o.

3. ^5B8(3bo^s:oQÏî) K^>o 80^00oa>ocScoo), foro8 ^oB^b^^^foo po-^J-^nO^"^^ i - Vo^^G tlf 'cJ*^ '*^*^ yroçrjBob

j:ofo(»-)b, 0^)0 ."îofi^o(3oob norjoQC^QtSB. 6^o>8(]b, 8i:DQ(^{îi(^)?)oœo bj^jbob ,bfoO)b(^'3sz^i^^>(0(jùBob

Ô'^'iD'^'^Ô^cJ^O^^^'^ poo5 8obo Bjjjff^i^^roiob .bs:noO)C^ (Sob BOTJBOO), (^ob '^Oï^OÔ'^i^'^G' ' <^Sï3[ o(3onb

^ùBj|f0Ç3oc^>;j?)ob a3C>B5 foogo B ^o^pnBfobg.-') iÇ^ by(^bg8^S^o g>o>o'bo6B6. c>b;)j];) J<^Bj]^)B(30ob

83-3 i:oo5 80-I3 S^jb^^'Q?)'^)^ ^6jjfos:oBf*7?)oa? 0^0 f)oroj:oô, (^008 ^ùBrodo^jàc .' 8 j'j 'jmboa)

4. 5.'>B(3bùtoy?)6 5^CÇ-:5[)(3^ boib.^B.'>ffî(n^H«)b <3oc [j ^ > ^odG*^^"^^ (^^"c) î^'ol^^*". -^7l^dÔ" ^'^^^

bùbo8ùfo(T)C!^>f)b f^Qô^'''^'^8^Ô")' '^^ ^8(i(3"*^^^ *S ' <^(^Ci,'0i'9o bc^JBob ( *iBBboij[j;j|j;]Sii »o 3cy^c:>fyù

^Cifiohù%^l](n^^ 26-^ B';]bjz:; »ob l-^^'o ' 'yB^-j(^ob 'S b. cS. Bobc jTo.

5. 2004 \7^ 'ob 24 B^obb b.ib.^8ibfoo)c:^'rob BoB.bCoajo ùfoc)Boo>B()b \']' Jiï ',']?>0* ' ^^ ? ) (^0(3*^B' ' J^ '8Ù

o^cooib. Bmùjjfoco&fo f'){^ i"^Bo1)o>(30ùB, (^i}Ç^(^'jh (^(^o>b(^8ù, oBolxnjjob, fo(o8 Bo j io B^jbùB^ Bbi^co^gj

?)ù(^(r}i]oh f)^h^^&iO)^ù. ^(ni^%o^i]^^dà Bcoajbci^jBc^'by "^jc^Cno '^'jajbcn.^. (>B, [jjT)(<7f')''j »c^fo

.l(oy'bo(Tj^B(^8>' (^l]^<^l\h ( f - l Ô** ^ [)'Z)* ' 'ÎNt)* ' ^c^S ii ogoîB, B(*70')b(o;jBob b()Si >.>bp u> "B^K oriBob

'3^]bu()p:^>0ig^MO?).^l)g, ( . lw^(3 b,^('|8ob jiD.- TJj jii- 'ijBi^.^ BfOt j j( g^>ro ,.b.

Page 2: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

6. 2004 ^ g ^ o b 7 (oj(^roB?)QC^b boib. 8.')Co(T)ji >f"7B ^ûB(3bùj:oQ?)ô Bu^o^^'ncSf^Sojj f^-^^^not^t)^^^

I. 5<^B8(3bo) jy?)[) :! >8oï fo^ Boaoi gCnoi - B bo -jBob c')'" t 3Bf03?)g?)%y Iw^j^)"^^^^" 8(obù^fog?>Q?)0

^6(^B(io^^»^oByb (59-(j 8';]b^^>o, 3'gBj5'^ l -^ 'o ) . coyg^coyb g^-^'^^Ô^'-^ 2)'^^*^8''*^B'^""' Çôf c>(î ^o6>:5

Bombfo^Bô ^;jfoo^nrr,?)O0>n jro8QB(5ib(^[j?)ob 7]y(^,bBob OQ. foiv- 'bQ. Bna)bf03B,^, oB,^3(T)fnfo7)f^6^,

fo' jb';'jsz >o c fOi- b - Bcooi c co x t focopjôBo'^i^(3o;]?)ob BO^C^OJQ OJJCO 'B[),']b;j?)'3iii^o, Bi a» 'i^nCoob, bù' o>cnfo

[]gC^7Sjooj(5ob YJ' 'E^^i'ob, ^^Brob Q^B^c^ob, or)'9jo^co-c)ff^>0)b C5fo. bo)8a). |jc fo?)(>7 foc^i^^Bo'b.^(3oob

„8ù86j.^(30 g),^ bL- B foa) g[:[ o", ^ 0, JJ ^ ) ^Rob c^jjiuBoi^Bob 'y73^'(]?>ùcn.^ GJ^Ô*^"*^ Bo^c^. 2004

^K^ob f?OJOfi?>G^'^o o")(^5.bBo'^)ù(303(!)b .1 Co3^0^:0^Bgob Bo^(^ BOQQÔOÏ ^gcoof^>ro(So(no o^fofoBoo)

8[]bô8(] BbôCojfo HôCooogob B()?)6(o(r>3.b (j<'^B3yB(3oob 36-Q B';^bf^>o, 3'^6J(3o 8^-2 ji c 44-;]

B 'yb^ 'o , «^■3BJ(5o Bg-2). B.bb '«^^Bpoy^, ^^(3 ^ B ' B « t' f f ' ^^fooff^fotSocno jroB^Bi^^^cogïSo

Booj:i^^b, ^<bBB(3bcifo^?)^^8,b S:OÙ 8000.30007^.^8 boij'j]07.-5coo Brobu^coo^^fSooo 'g.l^b'^bQb (8';^bffno

44-3, §5).

8. ^^ffn^f^^B Bb6(^;jQcSa)ùB jcoBb^gcii^^'^G^"^ ^^B^^^BÔ Ô' fÇ^^^BB^Ô' ' ^^^ bo>JBob ^6Co;)8coQio<Sob

(Do^ro^j 'bg BrobB;]B6 . fo o'jro b^Joc^co (59-3 ^TJ^f^^' § ^ infine).

I. b6d30b o^c^oanoioio

6. ^6B8Qb6çoQàpTr>ob V^^^^Ss^^O?) BoSôC^cD'gjino ^(^roQ^bo

9. ?)'^B8(3b6f03?)3^)o jio^ofSopou 1976 ^3ffi >b jo^ (3b(03fo(^)(Sb Bo^^Bo Br')35ro(^(oso7]o. 'B^bo^i^Bob

jjococob ob oyro b6^'l>ùro s:o3,^o>co5'^B3B5ob . Ico^ 'o^oob ro'30(33Coo. 1998 ^pt^ob 8 b3J5B^^B*^^^'

fofoj:D3b6(3 Ci(n 'bbco'gf^3?>too) bù8bùb'yC03?)(^o3 Bcog^s^nQ^ùb, ob fo, Bobo 83^00^^000 „(g",

?)ro5ro(^focobj7)o, B03B0 Brog^foco0)^^00b co3^ocôB'cîo '33b3CoB3B „Bb"-b, Bro^6fos:o ^roj^^i^Boib.

^.:)B8(3bo5s:o3(S3pm95 „3b"-b '33bof).^3c>'b6 a7.b3obo SOSBJCJBOCT) BogBo 6(03^070^7(OÇ:OÙ3(IO3 8033060.

10. 1998 ^i î^ob 10 b3J53B(S3C^b „8b"-b f03^o>8 ?>(o^o7Coo)cob3ob 3(og^'0(30ùb *::i(3B(o?)6 Bobo

Jùf^'0^830f^ob fo^,j,^co^3ob 733bùb3(!). 080^33 s^s^Qb, 16.00 b(j7.-^)3, ^'^68(3bùSÇ3?>3f^o sç«^0).1^5o8fo3b.

6b333 co«^«i365o8co3b ,,0^'* foo ^.bojj3ùB3b ?>f02)07(^07^:0bjob 3o7f^o(3oob 5^B307O^OK[^3?)6'(9O.

jjjùB8(3b6(:o3?>3^no ^ ^ „oj" 3o7f^>o(30ob 07030(3003?)8Ù „8b"-b 56'^jBoBùfo3èob a76oo?>o>Tj3 s:o6joa>b3b.

0^07^0700(3 p7.b6b, Bc5a)or73ob ?)Ooùp::no ciCo ^6';;]3363àoo^(T). foc)joa)b3ob '^QBJIOQ^ 3OO^O(30C>B

jijù68(3b6i:o3(S3jTinb b b 3 ^ îÇ<^j'3B36(^3?)a7ù6 30000.^^ P)ùBro60^a)3.^ 3o(^6j:oo7?yob 807^807?)^ poc

s:o6ùj.'53ù oboBo.

II. 1998 ^ ç ^ o b 10 bgJ^B^^*^"^^ b.^s::iù8o7b, 50568(3b0 :03?)jT>>ob bc>j.'5Ba>,:)6, Bobo '\>38^507Bo

o7YJO(33foo 8030CO6 poo) 6oB' ]si >ô b3U^'o 8(n3\730o."5 ^OBÙ foo(3b3oa), 1998 ^^^^ob 17 653ob5o7a)o,

^)5(r)60oosn3i';^C^ 5056(3bc5fu3?>6li3 b.^Bbùb^coo(:où6 5<iof7ù3ob7]«3g^»3?)ob '83bùb3(S.

12. 1998 ^^;>ob 11 b 3 J 5 B ^ ^ 3 ^ ^ 3(0ft: >0(300 8 ^^iPibcooj^b 5<^BB(3b6Si>3?>c^ob cSoBo , bc>b : >o bo)*j]3u^^'8o,

Ù3(^cou3,^oo3bo po6 BoBJ^Bd, bùivo5(3 o.-^o^u^'ob b.' Bo 3ù*b6.^ Ù5: 807 (70B.-:).

13. 1998 si^'ob 12 b3J5B^^B^l* ?)0)50)Co(o^bjôb B';')Bo(3o3o)p ' )Coo 3o7^'o(3oob Ik- BB.- 07030(33008^.

„B"-8, „5"-^5 S * ,,iî»"-8, ?)CO5O70o(o^bjob ,')^"^K,''iJob b^bo>8ciOo(y)^'07'3o, Bo)lw5B.'50o(x)^>3ba)ù6 3000)0^0,

„*^fo8o6ob5f^-^GO';'jg^>o 5'^s:où(3^(^Bob . 6505000*0)0*' '930(^.:)B.b. .- B .^B^o^oooTîob Bob3fD3oo7, 1998

^ ^ ' o b 11 b3J538(Sfoob lu^jinùBt^b, 5. 6B(3b. jxj3è3y^^>8o) t^^ „o3"-8 oojoBo^'Lob b.'>s75'30o'b3

„boB7l30(T>3 (X)^.iOos;'303b". oB.-533 C^ s;'3b, 8fob^8.'50o(r)ST )3B 5.^68(3b^fo3^3^)bo) fo, „*g"-l5 1998

^Si^ob 11 b3^']53Bè000^005B b"; or7o to^)oa) .i^BoBob(5coo!)(307jff^H) ^)..^j^33iù Bo^jb^^o^.

119

Page 3: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio coo>j.^33àob 5. BB. 3 )O7?)05 7)o, c)^h 5058"j^)B3?)oa) 3joa>b3(So7(X)636 „8b"-b ^05';']P)o6.^co3ôob 7]3bo^b3?). Bobo {y>JBoa), Bo)B 0 ,- ^3^036* ,3( 83 8coo(T7b(03^ o';')foob(^o, Boi fo. B Bobo 8070)60)36^ 7)05003(0^30^^» o -JBc).

15. 1998 ^/^^'ob 16 b3J(^38?)30ob rj(^p[j^'0(30^8 1998 ^^>ob 11 b3J(533?)0oob P)bo^)3job 'B3co350)ii> 6oi."ïf036 3^*l)63?)(r)^B sj;'.^j.^3'Booo3?)oa> (bobbg^'ob b^B.^(^(y)e^n)li b.'5 ]B3 N^68205) joooBoB6^>730^0 568o7Bo3?)0) so/50^;j(o. v 8 ^j000706.^(1)30b 5,'530sx)6 5<-^6B(3b.^^3?)K^'ob 6^8o6ob(^ooo>(307)p[;^»o (çOij05331')ob ^à^^ çoù 050 5.b6B3(oo^3?)0(;) B(o. (x).-53b3b b.i)3o5(5n8oo{^ Co<^^3b3?)7)Sii '3(S. 'Bo bobb^nob boiB.^oocogmob bo5(']83l)3. '0)38^05(03 ob 5•'>^05033,^63b K,*o j0533(Sob bb305 (3365f^'f^o, t i i '36o6bjob 3o7^'0(3oob c?33.bfO(568365ob o7)(^ob^oJ(3oob ^337), (^0783^^*0(3 bo> ']33'b3 o|](n 36b7]bob853?>3ii^'o.

16. .vl^^'oj.^Bgob 5.-56(3b.-5ST>3io(y), s 05j0533?>()b (336^00^^0 Bobo 5^^633.^606 '338^0)35 S27ùjoa7b33?)0 7)030007 06(^36607)000 s:o6 Bo)Sii ».bi:oo7?)Ooo3o 50565x105. 3Ù5.b :; '00705^0, 00.^8^036^30083 0307 '33Bo7b333ù, 0oo )(3.'5 3(o^i^>o(30ob 00030(30^3^0 Bùb b.bb3'9o TJf ÔB' ' U f B^ ^"^ ^05B3?)oa) 387) ']oo3?)OOfo636, Coo5(r)ô 8065.^6 „8b"-b Bj3^^'3^>o)(Sob 05^10. 003 . 5053o)3B. si >. (r). 330080)55, obo6o 387)^003600521636, 00008 Bob BoB^oooo 50580003363^)5x1636 35ii.>3('J5o^oo'Boojb 056 8(o.^a)053b3?)5:oB3B b.^j.^BTlo „5056bo>37)(r)003àoa) 8B083 o^3^o8ob joooBo6.b^'3b(y7056" 30 )a)o sx», O^COB5Ï^'3?)0(3 8056 8ooj5i»,:535:o636, 000050700(3 j o 5o?o53?)5X)636, OoooB ob 3o7i2^io(30ob 00030(33000 030).

17. 1998 ^g^ob 17 63J(^38?)30ob 50)68(3bo5^3(S3p^^>b '33635505 Bobo O7)0^ob5o, 000083^^0(3 0^0)8^036083 çoçQocn ."5 0(03 5o>6B(3bù553(S5i 'ob 553J505B 550)0^000^305 K^68295 bobb^^'ob bo5B.^o^a)^5ob bc5J83booo)6 55o>j053'8o0O3?)O(x). 5^6B(3b.b553(S5i;>ob 3063553007, 07)0^06(50^7056 550.^^151^506 5ù68o)35i507iù'3o 3o.B o>556o'(]Bo5, 00008 8obo 55630)33?)ob 60)855305150 8o*b3*bo „86"-b 5057)6o6<:50o3?)05 0300, oo."5^3(3 O7)0oob(53o5 7)3o:)b7)bo5, 00008 8.ib 05O0 'r]33d5i5oo 058 b.'>j8ob 05553 )0) O00555505B Boba)3ob 05O0 505^67)b55o.^o). 8(085533607 555536, 5.i68(3bù553(S5i:^>ob (r)j8oo), o7)0oob(5ob 30^053^^0 8^607056 3005150(3006 5,"58078803^35^0305 .'5jood6g^05.

18. 63o)boo?>057]o „<g"-8 3(^^o(3O05b 8ob(3.'5 P733B3CS05, 0^008 B.- bo), 007] 000050700 56O5';]3, (^07)(^05 5505 8o7j5i 'o> 505 6B(3bi'5553à35z: >8o5 „86". 805B 5.^8(03803^5^03^6 8o7)07oo),'5 ob 0555505^50, bo555.'5(3 55.:)3.'5iT53b „3b" ' b 530)Bo. 3(^^»o(30ob 5^57J'QBÙ O J 3300.^033000 030730).

19. 1998 "^p^ob 19 63^'](53B?)30^b 50568(3605553cS35i >o io-^oyjooobo) ^^0^6066306 3075150(30011 50>63070305T!5>3cSo57)o 000)85536033 3o7c^>0(30060» ^05 3(^(^37]00o.(57)<^ob b35i5B()5530563^10 3ofo3?)ob o)o>65x>^b^fo3?)oa>, 8o>ff) 'Soofoob 033636 „o" (3fo^>o(3oob "^o^C^çoho 50)8fo8Bo3?)35ï5o), „b" ('BoBo55.' 6 boiJB3(x)0) bô8o6ob(5o^o7b 055550^»07^)0^030 bo)8b.^b7)0oob 7)030^07bob 8ooo>po5og53), „Boo" (o^350foBo)S3i5'7]Ooo 3oo0737)00O70oob 8000)5550^53), 600500000)55bjob joiji^ùjob 3000037)0007000 556 Si53Bo6bjob 3o75i50(3oob 55330500(^^336(5015 3o)5ï50(303f^i3?>ob 5^^0o3337]pi5o 0^60055360060).

20. 56BB(3bo)553cS5i5ob 8(530(33600), ob 0) .-58311 oBobor)3ob, 00008 5505355o.b(57)00360601 ,,^3""^^ 055500)00360). 50568(36055536^5ob ' >('j3o(r7, b.>Bo53 050 b3iio6oooo305i:[ '36oo7 0^550) b3.^3"b3, 3005x50(3001) 06633^(500003686 „3"-8 556 „(o"-8 Bob 8o8. 0o(y) 50->B(oo3363b 35^*3JôoonTloojo 83(505^'ob 3P^>o3b36o(y7, 00078^1360(3 36 3a7 7)5i:[ >o(r) 37)0)*b3 .^^(06556 80300073673g^'o. ^8 «^300008000, 5668(36655363^>o foo585T.36^3(^83 6^6836. 3^6 .^b333 387)^J0036(0^636 b ^ b g o j o (3380a) 55. b6b^']3b(o 0)005660036*1)3 3S5,*3J(5*^''^'^'^B^^^ 568(^3363600). 3(^(r)-30o{n86 3(^)^>o(3035i5B6.866 7)0)bo^6, oofoB 3b 7]3^^66b363^'o 3606 663^)63366 5'>Bo7o\7 333556 556 B060 6BoOj')6p)36, 86005x )0055 o6551^ '06730^0 ^068060)6300) 56655360)556 'o)366()^53635i^'o.

21. 5668(36655365x506 8063553007, 3iX5'3j'](5' ' ' '3o7300) \76B3666 3ooo737)006(57j(^ob 635x^)83553663sx 'o 3000360 6O0 3b\?oo36(osiB3B. 6855366^, 06 000 * 300 5'^o)33o>636 3(050)0(3006 5'.")63ooo3op^'36o6 83(0003 oo(r)6b71o, 1)65^)6(3 5>^B'yÇ'333(55X503 03001636(^^06 '1)380066800(7735x5osxx 'o 3000360b,

120

Page 4: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

566b637]oy70^3^'^^' „8oo*'-b B0300. 50568(366^3635x586 (37)5505^ 80033000060b (X76oo66*\)3 „8oo"-b

'B3b6o3ç^-b, 8650068 63 7130566bj635x^1 b 6O0 ,' •jooBo6 0060B3 0^305 (306 556 Oooo553b6(3

56BB(3b6^363gi5B6 33ç^v^3 7)60oo m^^c^ „Bli"-b B33^x'3i ' <^"^^ 6^10600366113, „8oo"-B ,'ioof[50(30ob

(oo3o(30o36b 7)6o ')8666, 5668(3b6si3635xx.>o 56333666O) „oJ, 660^666(3 80030^6".

22. 5668(366553635x586 5666(366556, 00008 6556O0 '8338^5(0 83(50 \|?6B36ob 6(50566 556 300000

\77)CTioo) 7)37)0^655553600^ ^^*^Ô*^B3^c)^'"' o)63ob 3(0335X5ob 301)6007 3oop50(30ob 5663070305x0360b

B307003 b60oo)7)5X5ob 0366*^0005566 565566(56. ob 55-' 3(30 3l)oo7)o 50: 6300367)5x5 3o7ci50(30ob

300(500(3035x51)3 55 ^ b3fob3B65onO 5560l)0666.

23. 50)BB(3b6[5363sx5o 0663335(00^ „3 ' -b o)666p:5>36oo) ^057)3003636^)03 5' 55' "U8' f B^

6003507000)5506 (^6000606 N233 b6636553307»>3O7'Bo, 66556(3 050 56bo6^6 3J0BB6 „8"-8. 866

55665550B6 0366*^0005566 5655800360055606 "3355350)55 bb36556bb36 556l)0663636ob 60011360066,

0^6(3 800000)655655 606663600556 b3Cob38foiob 5530o8b6 556 86800800633635x5 bob(5386l)3.

24. 5o^68(3b6553635x50 08633 S^^NO^ &' f?^"BB' ^3^^ K09 b66365583000307'30. 56BB(3b6co365X5ob

553CO6 B030556 11663655830003007)0 556 3J08 „3"-b bo)boo36 b633f50(3o6oo 556b33B6'3o 6553Bo'866

5668(3b655365X5ob 37)0036^)3 ^68^300006011 60^b36oo66. Bobo (j7bo7366 73600307O30fî5 oj^à.

^35568 08633 o^booyBoo) BoB60oo)6 b6636^83ooo307b 8(r)6360o 3JoBb6 556 3^08 „b"-b, 000083^0)0(3

36b7]bob85363^'o 0307 5668(36655365X5ob b6J83l)3. B6b 8o7(y)bo73B6l)3 36b7)bo 6O0 807)5506.

25. 1998 ^f!5ob 19 b3j(53B630ob, 56B8(3b65536sx5ob 03665^000^66 5655636005550b 55S53b, „Bb"

7)363635x50 5566o^7]Bf06 b6b5X5'3o. 866 56686(^5'^' < ooB 1998 ^5X5ob 8 b3J(53B6ooob 55683b

56B8(3b6553635X586 o763obo B6BJ6B007 851)63000066 '33bo7636l)6, 0061)3(3 ob ^06006668556.

6o;^6o 6003500^00055*30 00008 803055636, 5668(36655363^586 B6b b6b5X5'3o ^6Bob 565^f^3^'^

bo7boo36, B650068 366 736000 7)07bo 76 556 505B8(3b6553635x586 ob 505737136. „8b" 603B0 6003507000755*30

8(3boo3Co36 07630b 83507600360066 ^630^06. 6J ob 0^68^036083 5555007 556O066 0113, c ooB

55355ob6oo3ob ^■5555op^b6B3( 0335x50 6O0 '337)(53oo6o636o6.

26. 1998 ^ffoob 21 b3j(538630ob 5668(3b65536^)ob 556363360b 3300000550 ojoooo36p57](^655

f06boo7)f[5556. 1998 ^5X5ob 22 li3JÔ3^^0^^* ^^^ b30^b33çx5ob 0033006(306 P767)5o50^556.

666365583070300710 oil 1999 ^5X5ob 3 0^3630^35x568553 08300033607556. 1998 ^'f[5ob 25 b3j(538630oli

556ob7)(^6 Ne22346 bolibsx5ob b6860oo)5X5ob b6383, 000083^0(3 3b36oo556 „Bb"-b 800)007367)^

5673365o7)(^366b6 556 B335X53f^o766b, o)7)B(36 50558(3b655363S5o 56b556 N522414 bobb^nob

b6360oo75X5ob b638ob 3^380(56605x50. B6b 60^6^50 3553600556 „8b"-b 3o7(56(3366'3o.

27. 1999 ^5x506 1 860O(5b '83^3556 bobbfi5ob b6B60o00^15ob 5680080366 06006550b 361)63606

7)366ro6oo 8o35Tn»oo63^5(o66l)3, O0655566 860)o 655Bo763Bob 550^oob, 5663(3b6553635x50 3(^^>o(3oob

00030(300011 016663^360766173 87)716076556 556 685536655, .5(')oo6556 06O065506 03 x5006011 7)*^C!5366.

2000 '5x5011 1 B60o(5b (80)63000066 o^55536b 5056bb363367)5X5 (y)60oo55b — 2000 ^5i5ob 10 86obo),

556067)006 „8b"-b 8oo(56(336ob b6,'|B3(3; 0065556B 5668(366553635x586 06 8000760736060066633

567)7136.

6. (37)55^55 807330^006660066 5505363*300^367)^^0 ooo30(306p57j(^o 5680080366

28. 1998 ^'^>ob 21 b3J(538630ob 5X536o6b3ob 0o6o(oB(7b 3oôoo37)0o6(57)0oob 568078803635x586,

1998 "\/^)ob 19 b3;]53B630ob (66383 N268241) 565B(3b6^36g[5ob 03665^0005566 56si66ôo)Bob

o)6(o66l)3, bobb5x^>ob-1)636000)5x53600030 568(080366 556o\?*3oo.

29. .568(0880363^186 55630(r7b6 51536066306 Oo60oo6ob 3(05x50(30011 h'^œo (0030(33000,00008 :5360(3

1998 ^5x50!) 19 b33(5B86ooob 55>63oo)b3671o 8(066 /05x1 )30)655636. 86O) 5666(36651^131), 00( 78 obo6o

121

Page 5: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

50568(366^0363^x5^* *^^G ^"300)006 8(0330^006066 (37)55 )55 ^ 6 600(3 "^ 7)66663(y), o ooB 866 30683 (37)55655 800 (3300556. 3o)5x '0(3oo6 07030(3003606 566(3665536000, 55630006306 5506006, 06633^50^^^''^ „3"-8 5668(366553635x56 7)(n6oo6, o ooB B0686 8350066O0B6 „*y"-8 80(338735x5 63363667)0 5666(366556, 0 7008 55606666 00(05000^ 5667)365o7)0o6 556 80035x56 5668(366^53635x536 „Bb". o6633j(5foo6o6 OÎ763300), 3060)306 ^330667)060 0^636(0556 3550606360B6 3b. 55630(y)b36 P)6ob 56B07 '836306556. b6B68 00030(306360 6606 B(oB1)65536ocy) 033B36 55* 3053367)5x '6o, 50568(366553635x50 Boo7)p50)55635x >655 636B05566 ^6B(o6(56, YI'^^^^^^'-MB'^ 5*^"t'lG ' '37j'36 6668530606 556 565566505.

30. 568(o38o3635xx.*B6 ^6333 556300066 „Yj'\ 0607835x586(3 65560^366, 0600B 8060)306 5668(3665536^'o6 ^06665585535 (30673 63363606 80(3386 6066306 55' 7]365x[ '36o6. ,,^"-8 5666(366556, 06008 866 5668(366553635x50 3j35«^o^3'33 8006606 556866*363350 „86"-6 567j6o660^366'3o.

31. 56Boo8803635X;'86 7)385535 556300)66 N" 39 66636fi '83(oo3oob 3J080 , ,3", 0600835x586(3 5668(36655363^0 1998 \75x;'ob 19 63t')Ô8f^^B*^"l ' B^ ' ^ BBB" * "^B f Bô 5 '5bo65^6. 3Jo3B6 55665566573(^6, 06008 '338(y)6333ob ^^'jh 5668(3665536^06 55BC?' 9 3Sï;»3dÔ^^ '-^* 'V3f ' '' ' 6bb3B6 '33oc[: >ob 37)0636^63, 00738(36 5.^BB^b6553635x5b 333e5<:> 55-^17066366 03 565 0605566 56556b5ooBo6 "335535655 655360*363600556. 6683550(30600 6666^3063606 66037)833^0'1)3, 5668(366553635x511 37)0^361)3 35X53t'|5^*" f?*^9^8' ^^^*^ ^^ 6553607)63600556.

32. N^39 666365583070307*30 5663(36655365x506 365X565o5'3o 8300030 „6", 66333 (5*^0300)66. „6" b67)6o^o76556 5668(3b65536^>o6 37) 636113 60^6367)5x5 5568 /300006666 556 <' Boo5^35^off[' • 55505X '36l73, ^•^G 8Ki:Bdô ' S5* f ÔU* ' ^ 7)3o3ffn36o7556 568073^306. „6"-8 5666(366^56, 0 078 06 3Si5BdÔ ' B*' ^ ^ ^ 87)716076^6 556 6B55366C0, 0(300556, 077) 066 713^350 6J3b 3ff?3J5(^oos56o65386b.

33. 568008803635x586 566B(3b65536f^ob b6b6B606oo^'(^ 11683^0(30600 7)3800^8366 Bo7oo7bo736. 1998 ^5X5ob 26 ooj5*^^9^^*^^ b6b686f6o)C5oo 6656060*80 -^55536556, 06008 5668(366^363^56 ^^006556 ^0^05x5006360 07630b 1)38(0 66^05x5710, 660366^6360 "37)65x5113 55* 363606 60*86360 3661)3. 5568^*306006360 66 35XX,'3J5* * " ' * Ô8 ^ ^ 6636 6660b 33<^P5o 606 0300 655^30605x1,'o.

34. 1998 ^5X5ob 21 55333B63o6b, 568008803635x586 3oo^)0(3oob ooo30(30^36ob ^0666558^35 ^ÔJ"GB^c)^3^*^^* 6635x53600606 56800 66J806Ç606800366 '33^33o5'^- 866 5566555066, 06008 56B8(3b6553635x^o 1998 5x5011 10 b3J5B963(^b „3b"-b 567)6o66o6366bo>6B ço6363'3oo^36ooo 5566365oBo63b. 1998 ^^ [oob 11 63J539630^b 300^:50(3068 6665050^6 6bo^336 56B8(3b655365X5ob 866^666^30 f06 655800660B6 060^65506 6680 361)56. 50)68(366553635150 556 „o^" ^3633 55i53b 56607630b7)035x53b, 007)8(36 36(y)o 50500630117)035x53605566 365x )333, 6ro5O70^oo[D63o6 3005x50(3006 07030(330686 „B"-B ^30605x5006000 566(36)6553636*30 066B553B0B3 o36J5*^^*^^B^ 7)1)7)b5ro66 655Boo6F)o66. oB633 'j5o^o636o „B" 556 ,,55" 50x^33636 5668(366553635x56 556 ob 0630B05I706 665557)061)3 655807660636. 5 '568(3b6^363f!5)o 5'i33S535i: »36b '837)066(363070355- . <^^^'> '33i58ô'^^'^G "ô*^ BBS '- B 55' * ' ' Ô"^^B^^ i?-^ 83(0063 fo^3b boB7l3055ob' 55-^^*^883"^ b60373835x5007 6553060650^05(307)5x50 365oBo6o)66 '837)036065536. 1998 ^5x506 16 b3J53^^B*^^* B66j666'3o B63003B 06066550b 361)6360)66 556363*80o636o(y7 806 ^06665585535 6665x50 6o6b5xx.'ob b68606(y)p:5ob 116^83 655080^6. 1998 ^^5ob 19 1*3^539^8^^*' ^^ « 665x50 b6037)335x5000, 568000(36 5563650806360b 0006553060. ob 08633 ^ ^ 8 ^ Ô*^C?' *^UB' ^B'-' 5x536066306 06600767)^10 3oo^)0(3oob 5663(00^05x5366*80, 66556(3 050 ^6300066 3oo^'0(^30ob 066B5536083 00030(330686, 8600 '8000606, o6633J5^f^3^36 , ,3"-3 55*^ »o^"-8. ^0630006306 '8385535 50)B3(36655363eoo 7)3(300655 ^"6807656 63680^166, 50)5366 03665 6066 556 50555665* . 06 55'' 7)30o36365X! >o3 56^60336636 ]Nr09 66636551B30003077I0. '36" 08633 ^i^3^ ' b6b^)71o 5566067)6556.

35. 56B(oB8o363ff;^86 5 6 6 0 6 0 ^ 6 3(^5x '0(30o6 0)030(30636066 556 3J0B „3"-b 633636360, N"539 666365583(00^(^6 6683550(3060) 6666^306360 556 1998 ^"^506 26 O7j(5(o86o6o6 b6b68606o)^5O7

122

Page 6: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

11683550(30600 6656060*80. 866 66333 8(oobBo66 11683550(30600 3^633065 „b"-b 6l)06o, o6o7Bm 'ob Bob3553ooo6(3 3fi53Jô ' ' ^ ' *^ÔB^ ' ^^ B' ' ^B 55053^3060066 7)6556 55053(5*" 88^^^ - 5058003803635x586 7]57)^>363K '307 „6"-b r)336366, 006^566 68 -,')3666b3635x5b „606 «^Jo76^6 633(3065x57)060 b6B3550(3o6(^ 3075566". 56800880363^^^0 B030556 5561333668553, 0600B 5668(3665536^1^06 Bo(y)0(r)366 ^7683661)3 600660663600)0 0300 556 050 (yi30(yi833g5>3g:50)6ob 8(35535x5006011 36b7)b655 „556(33ob 83^6601)86" ^6068(^655536556.

36. 1999 \?'^5ob 25 0663606b 3o6oo37)o6657)o6ob 063500067)^86 00030686 566666^^)6 b6j']B3 556 7)33555(030 56Boo8o36ob6(r)3ob 08633 568(08803635x511 5655611(36. 1999 ^ ^ ' o b 25 (y73630636tx5b 568(o88o363f^'B6, 08633 *^Ô3*^GB 'Z) 'B^3 ' 8 ^5^306556(0600) 556 0553657)060 60533360b 5630)33636000, b6JBob^606B(O366 ob33 '83^33056. 366 5566865^, 06008 1999 ^p5ob 25 0663606b, 8(y)636o6o 306003730 (00606 B0306 66bb3636o 665630)803607 667)736^536360 1998 ^35x56 7)333 5680733636735x50 030). 5668(3665536^1506 5^66Bo^o73C[50o6ob 8^0500860630060b 560)365x506^06360(0, "337)85x5363^50 03(^ 666^150 6656800803600 B3(^]65o1)836ob 56B00336366, 06005(0060(366 5563006011300636360 556 b6b68606oog[5O7 '8330)^836360.

37. 1999 ^5x50!) 1 S5333863o6b 0B633 l73556Bb355335x536 3060037)06000686 b6J83 56666b5X56 556 60686B6 56063337)^^0 b6568oo8o36o7 33J6Bo1)B36ob 556B65366, 8600 *3o7o6ob, 5668(3b655365X5ob b683550(3o6ro '83307^8366 556 Bobo oB 3oo5X50(3oob 00030(306360)66 5563oo6ob3oo6366, 06008^53686(3, 8oo)0(r)36ob Bob3553007, 5668(366553635x50 6^6B3b. b6JB3 bb36 568ooB8o363f^ib 56^063(36. 2000 ^f!5ob 24 oo363o636Ç[5b 568(^8803635x586 "33^33056 b6j8ob^6063oo366, 1998 'çx5ob 21 ^ 3 3 3 ^ ^ ^ " ^ (!)'^f?'^?U88Ô"^'8^'^'^" 8007000367)5x00 b6037)835X536ob '33036b36ob 8b563b '^3?3'^^3^^^3 556306556006000.

38. 2000 ^fmob 10 B6o65b 0B633 1i3to68b35533^iB6 3060037)06000686 8311683^0 56B66bjx56 66^83 556 56666bou533^'6^ bb36 568(^88o363^ib 56q76b(36.

39. 68 *33Bo7b3336'8o 55603ooob6 56B8(3b655365X5ob ^53556. 366 5666(366556, 06008 1998 ^5x50!! 19 b3J5336306b ob B030556 b66365583070307'3o 556 66b6, o6oo3 3ob '330ffob 37)06360 .1^0)6556 55617066367)5x50. 866 3o7ocobro36 556l)0663636ob 556O3oJbo0^366, 8650668 Bobo 800006)00366 66636^083000307b 330886 7)606300, 0665556B „68 '338o)b3336l)3 oBb5o67)j(306 . 07655607 8O55367)K;»O".

40. 56800880363^586 6b333 5563ooob6 N539 b663655B3ooo30ob 5568b^o63 3oo6o 556 oooobo 3J080, 060085x53686(3 6b333 7)60633311 O30565s o o5566 5655800360655B001 8055367) 010 556l)06B3636ob 5606556, bb36 ^617066363606 606b36o76ob <g635< - ^-^9 b66365583000300b 30607-3060086 36(3036586 5566556b57)o66, 06008 5668(366553635x50 366 3b67)6o66 3^^5335^'^'^'^3*^^ ^6336ob '83b6b36; 077)3(36 36(3036586 56B6(3b6556, 06008 B6b 56BB(3b65536f^ob 37)^636113 ^6B36ob 336^0)0 606 '337)3663306. „o3"-3, 060783^ *86(3 566B(3b6^3635X5o b66365oB30703oo7)o B( )oB6b7)ff '6, 5666(366^6, 0600B 5668(3fc6553635X5o B6b 3667)6066 \?6B36ob 0060)66173, 8650668 B6b1)3 ^6836ob 6066660060 336^:50 60^ 7137360*36636.

41. '838555008B6 807^838, 3005x50(3006 08 b6'5l)60) 553360656836506 80)6360686 0^730(330686, 66556(3 5668(36)6553635x50 55636508063668^)3 87)*36(o6556, 568(0880363^*6 ^6067)555066 56B8(3b65536fi5ob „o3boJ( 75X5oo507)o6o 306070305x50" 556 55666)6606006 0607507063 b7)b5o 30060036366. 568(08803635:536 66333 8005500 08 o3boJ(05X5oo5o"jo6o 5B^^Ô*^^ ' BtÇB'ôB ' ) 0600835x503 5668366503632536 b65l)6(^ 3(0^^50306*80 ^>6Bo'3366B^3 56O6066. 58^^Ô^'^ G^'^^U^' 0600B 566836655363^^0 ^j^^TÎ^'^.iÔB^"^^ 0)6305566 63051536066336 Bn55o633oux.»o fii6 56063807 o36j5* "'* B* " ^ 80B6060) 85068600606063 556 5567)333^150 03(0".

42. 116^3(76 \/'60oBoo366 2000 ^7^'oli 21 o35i >o6b '33\73556. 568(^783o363^>86 56633006 ^663366, o6(oB 5668(366^13635x50 0 , ^* ,0605566 b637)O)606o 67)063O5ix'oo) 565^)6656, „Bolio 300600363606

Page 7: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

o3bo;]o75X50O5o7)06o 866>6bo60)36gi5'36oli b333oo30305566 56800B55066063, 6057)63006 3oo6o)3B7)5xx 'o 7I303C563606 660373833^1;. 1)3".

43. 2000 \7U >o6 10 6(03863066 66^83 56666^)^6 6636 1>3556B63^335x;'o 3( 0037)06000606 80306. ,,03" b35x;»665x;'6 506030(y)66, 685^306655 „<g"-B 633B366 Bob36, o6(o8 6o75ooo6o755b3ob 3oo5x;>o3oob 5663(0030^»366'3o ob I13386 oBb33J(5o^^36 „6"-8, o8oli6(y)3ob, 06008 B035507 „3b"-b 833^535x5("'>6ob 6550606366. 16- )66 19 63^53360668553 ob 56B7)55)B36o(y) O3ooob36(0556 6oj^6o 60)3507060055*30 5XX.'3BoB63oli o66oo)67)^> 3(Y)5X;'030O6 56630)03OJX;»366*80. 556300)630666 366 „o"-B, 307^)03006 8(y)636o6B6 568008803635x^)86, 56606536. „*i3"-B 66333 6t56o'3B6, 0600B 6655600 55)666*367)5x506 6^1060^3606 Bo1)6ocy) 366 35ï53J5'^^'^^'-'^^Ô8*^"^ 83*333076007 6^*683655636. ,,03" 66333 55630(r)66 0635000665x57)060 3o6(037)06o)0606 Boo655505X!,'38 „8o6"-8. 1998 '5x;'o6 18 63^53^63066 ,,'^"-3 63p^>o 8006^3006 65506063666 556 067336113 ob 65550^:503 30 8oob6l)6, 1165563 ooooojoob 866 55)6 566836655363^)86 536B0 55686^36.

44. 7)63557)060 '338o)b333ob 71385535 „o3"-8 566B3b6553635X5o b66365583ooc3oo'3o 80006667)5x56. 5668366503635x586 866 35x53^5*^*^*^^3^^ ^683606 7^366636 73006066, 36b7)b655 30 „'g*'-B 65573^3(^6 ob 0003033(^0, 0600835x503 B6b 6Boo7 6'3o636s56. 5663366^03635x586 5566556657)006, 0 008 06 0300 05033 0703033060, (^00835x503 80066^0^^3076556 1998 ^5x506 19 b3J5o3*^*^*^^^ 5563oo)636'3o. 08633 ^3S5b, 8(05306636000, 366 680b '33b6b36 7)oobo66 56Boo3803635x5b ^^68241 b6J3ob ^6(^5511536710, 007)836 56^06^3556, 06008 3b 56B3b6553636o 606 P)63^30^6oo 070303065x57)06 f76B6Ç'3o63671o.

45. 2000 ^sx5ob 29 55333B630^b 3o6o737)0^657)o6ob 568008803635x^86 5680080366 332563 7)3^^33056. 56BB3b655365X5ob 56b6p7O30^36ob '8385535, 2001 ^5X5ob 27 B6065b, Bo^Bo 600350006005506, 60^605000607556306 (^600067)5x586 b6b68606oo5X5ooB 3060737306657)^66b bo^Bob '3385050080 5680080366 556636^)6. b6b68606o)K50oB, inter alia, 655607166, 06008 566836655365x506 633B36360 f yoo 556^06367)5x50 506 5535' ff?'L)* * i?- 66^006(0 0300 66^^806 7)^o6o7 8363060 5680)80366. 666686060)5x5008 60^8666 08 6663655830703076 6636 36303B53606 556300)636, 665063 800336B36 56B83b6553635X50. 66668606005x5078 66333 66^0060055 8006B06 3^63306506 8030^ 56BB3b655365i[x 'ob «gb0^0650607)5x50 506 O3bojoo5«)07507)0^o '83800^*8366.

46. 3o6oo33bo 56506835x5556. 685^306655, 3o60037)0^657)f6ob 5680088036351586 556300066 3jo3o „8", 0^078351503 Ne33 b66365o830o«go)'3o 87)'360765O6 506 b65063 56B83b6503635x;^o 7)63507)060 *338o76333oba)66633 565560336B3b. 3J0886 56B63b65D6, o ooB 86b 566836650365x50b 37)0636173 5061)066366 606 *337)60*86636. 05033 560B3000636 3J083686 „3"-B 506 „6"-8. 00060338 50665505657)066, 0 008 56683b655365X5ob 553556 36oo boobo73506, 56B8307063600) *3338o7^836o66o7 '3305][5oboo3ob 37)06360, 8650^68 8600 5061706636360 606 *33';DBo'8B63(y7. N^39 6663655830703006 b7)O70 36303650 685x533506 ^3363666, o6ooB 56BB3b65O3635x;>0 B607 3b67)6(^6 Bob 80860600 35x53^5^*^^'^^8"*'^ ^6836011 '33b6b36, B650668 8600 Bob 37)0^36173 0660B3 506110663606 3365xi 'o 6f6 7137)86633060). ^'à^?^^ IBf B^ ^ B0636 „o3"-8.

47. 568008803635x586 66333 Ô'^^^G^'^i^B^^"^ O3bojoo5x507507)0^o 556 O3bojo65<^o7)5o>o *338oo^836ob 566360657)5x5366 56b36. '83807^83668 663366, 06008 5668366503635x50 ^60^037)06650 030) 55^^*^8' i B '3K?fi. 8650668 50663B6 8o)55367)5x; >o . ^006556 7)63557)0^0 *338o)6333ob "3385535, o^ob ^33503565563 . ']o76556 5665(^80060000 "360^037)060 ^8350737)66(^0066. '83807^83606 50( 006 566836650365x;'o6 B36565i;>7306o 8505(0860630066 5066660600556 3o«33000607)5150 0636^3036000, 835oo6o67'35xx_'o 5068003055367)5x536007, 3B00307J06006000 51)6 35x;»o3o6 8006(0363661)3 5568(030503-6';^5mj5o(r), 663(y)65o 55666635x1 .506 5035068060. 07300)8335x53515(06066336 80510)0633051;'366 8 606 568007)8^^556363606. 6B56o6o'3'3o 506030^600^506, 0600B '337)85i;>3635x;'o 0300 56BB(3665D365X;'O B36565i;'7)(^o 8505(^860630)606 '830366366 736350)7)060 '8380)633306 800836(50660)306.

124

.-5 11

1

Page 8: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

48. 2001 5ï5* ^ 1^ B6obb b6JBob^6o68oo366 713^3506 08633 6O37)835X50(y7, o6o(y)63 650063.

49. 2002 5X5ob 5 653011500b B03B0 600350006005006 3060037)06657)0606 063500)67)5x586 66Bb6b7)o6B6 5668366553635x;'b 3o6o5X50oy7 6360066, 06008 B060 66jBob 568(080366 3351563 56B6b5i5556 556 50686536o(y7o 56800803601160)3011,'33b6668obo oB6(5'^7);J3036o(y), 515360B6306 3o6003730665 j<^>ob b68b6b'go6b 5655635116366. 566B(3b6503635X586 N339 666365583000)0011 3o6o)-3o6(y)o 363036506, „3"-b, 55630(y)636 Bo70(y)bo)36.

50. 2002 ^5x5ob 5 b3j5B36306b 3o6(^37)o6657)f^ob b6Bb6b7)f686 '33V33o5 '> 56B0080366 506 5066555066, 060)8 6o6666oo^o 306080665x57)060 ^33500)66 606 03(0 66503605150 506 8o"j o7oo76, inter alio, 06078 '837)85153635150 0300 „3"-b 3003B6 80b b63boo3063635i5 650505xoùb. 5680088036351536 ' ^BSB tÇ ' '-MB "' ' *^^3 5668366503651506 B000000366 ^683661)3, B6005150050 8060 80766363636000 0300 5683606367)5150, (^63 56B(^3o36ob 5668635x500667)0 8003003367)5150 6b36 85303367)515363606 66037)8335051)3 6O6 655B00655O6 36060065X1.»o.

51. 030)55636 006, 06008 ,,3" 03(0 ^83507)7)66060) 506 600066515360660 Ii636o685xi ob 8ooBb86o63635o^o, 56683665036515011 ^60^80086555365x1^360 5567)363'300650636 86b 506 56053b, 06008 Bobo 5063ooob36 5566365x53b oBb33J5<^f^ î,ro"-b, ^68366*30 F)6( o)7)5i5 3o6(r)-3o6(y) 000303306b. oB633J5*^*^36 ,,00"-8 5666366506, 0600B ob 066850365^3(^83 '83336556 „3"-6oy766 50636371006366b, 865(^68 3306 '83851500 Bobo 8ob686o6oo1j3 300366. 2002 ^5x506 26 b3j58^^B*^^ »3""^ 67)bb66 56683b655365150b Ç6o6B(o865D53B5xi.*36b, 06008 306(7)63515, 3060)86 6506806686, 06(1033515863 B66 07630 ^6(^7)505066 0600500063 568(08803635x586, 5567)06336 556 7)0)6o66, ( 008 7)65000506 B060 506300)636. ,,3" 556006668556 5663b65536ob 5633003661)3, 865066B "3385050)3 3b 650680660 866 655606 *33b8o6636o6.

52. 2002 ^51506 28 O7 ']5oo863c6b B0360 6003500060055ob 3o60037)06657)0^ob (oo3ob86 2002 ^5X5ob ^ ^BtJÔB^^^"^ 56506^^33350525366 5667)j86. 2002 y5x;'ob 28 6003863066 5X536o6b3ob 06600760b 3o60037)0665730606 b68b6b7)o6B6 Ii6j8oby6o68oo366 ob33 08633 66037)83515000 ^83^33056. 56B83b65D3635ï586 b6J8ob^60^8oo36ob '83^8330*^^^ oo60o66l)3 56556^333505x5366 566b6p)03o66. 2003 ^5i5ob 24 o35i5obob ^30605x5000 56683b6503635i5b 33B0766, ooooB Bo^Bo 600350006005006 063500067)5150 3o60037)066(57)060b b68b6b7)0686 3306 B6b6 b6JBob '33^3335ob 565D6^3335o5i536ob *33335i5ob 8o1)3lio.

53. 8o736b7)b3 80063060760b 8063553000, 063500767)51586 3060037)06000686 6556555066 5680)80366 2003 ^51506 6 6003863066 556 66^83 5X53BoBb3oli o66oooBob 3o6(037)06657)(^ob b68b6b7)06b 56506b36. (^00500063 66Bb, 2003 ^fn^ob 55333B6o6ob 6(05X5oob b6JB3 ob33 5O6ob7)066. 5668366553651506 8ob3503ooo, 2004 ^5i5ob 19 0663606b 5680080366 56B6b5i5506. 2004 ^5150!! 26 06636066, b6j']83 5i536oBb3ob 06600060b 3060037)06657)f6ob b68b6b7)06o5O6B 56556351)6366 063500067)5150 3o6oo37)0^657)o6ob 5O336065683B5ob b6Bb6b7)06b, 06008351503 8b563bo 86o'33B35i5oo6ob 8^0063 b6(']8336b 08036506.

^^- "73*' 3"*N88 3^o')b35i5 5060300)66. 8obo 633B36007,5i536o6b3ob 00515 7)0 „Bb"-b 5673606606360b (T)6oo66l)3 556300063011611 050 b33B3b 3(05X5O3oob 00*^303063686, 060085153603 6I1333 387) ^06360055636 35ï5J5<^t^'3o73o6 56B0033B36000.

55. 2004 ^5x506 19 O')363o6365i5b 553360656836506 5630088036351586 0633 55667)066 66J83 5066336000, 06( 8 606 606636006506 56683b655365i5ob B0860607 37)55 650 Bo73306o76ob 55686556b-573063635x50 85303367)5x536360 556 06008 3005150300b (0030306360I1 JB3500766 36600603060 0300. 2004 ^51506 4 86(656 b6JB3 3351563 56666515506 B6568, 66668 ob 335^563 556ob7)o636oo556 2004 \ 5X5ob 4 o35X5obb. 2004 ^5i5ob 3 653ob5f'^b hàjd'^] 5666b5x; '506 0635000665157)060 3060037)06657) ^06 b68b6b7)06ob 8030^. 2004 ^5X5ob 6 b3j'](53863f6b b6j83 556067)066. ob 7)385535 ob33 5666b5ii '556

125

Page 9: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

556 8o76306o)6o6 ^60655506363606 '33B5035, 2004 \?5i5o6 20 (^)j(5(o8630^)b, ob33 506067)066. 2004 Ç5X5ob 22 6(03863066 063500067)51586 3o (037)06ooo686 0633 5666665x56 568(^80366. Bo76306(o6ob 8ob3503oo), 5680080360b 6005x500 3650655 2005 ^*5i5ob 2 630605x50 566o66'b553o66.

56. 2005 \i*5xi 'ob 5667)661)553063515 555: *36 3o6o737)0^)657J(^o6 668666730686 6o665xi 'o 7*6733366 (006 3oo5x '03035ii '6 „3"-6 556 „b8"-b, o6(o85xi '36o3 1998 \7'5ii;>ob 19 63j(53B63o66 566836651 )365x1;ob 5r'63oo)b36'3o 8o)66\7 05x;>30o65o636. 66J8o6 86665xx.'36o, 60665x506 ^63363606 55<'i37)3365o^66 3060)655, b66oo5ii '0)oo5o 56666605x5335x5650 56506351)6366 5153B066306 ( 7515 06 B03B0 B07350)-0^oo5oob b6b68606o75i50ob.

57. b6b68606oi5ix 'O7 8001183606 5506006 b6b686060)515008 8066365x50 8oo\?83 5O630(pb6. 6b333 5063ooob6 , ,3" 556 „b8" 506 3oo5i5030ob bb36 oob7)o)835o oo«i]033o6o, 060085153603 1998 \7'5i5ob 19 li3J5B36o6ob 5063oo7b36'3o 3(^66^05153650636, 66 oB 555536 0830003360055636 5i536o6b3ob 3oo5x^'03oob 566300030515366"Bo. 566B3b65D365X5ob ^6836011 YJ'^dÔ"'*^^ 6Bob (y76oo66'63 oBç3(^o6B6306 33351568 7)606300. b6b6B60600515ooB '8385535 5563oo7b6 ,,33", 3oo5i503oob 3000305150 56Bo7B8o3635x^>o, 0600835x503 36b7)bobB53635x: >o 03( 7 56683665536511^.06 66^83173, 8650068 Bob 5063oo)b36*3o 80066^05x530066 606 80735506. 8obo 63363600), 366 30*")5x53536066566 565367)5150 1 -1076556, OoooB 5668366503635x50 03665^0605066, 35x1 *3;J5* ' ' ^ ''8* * * ^683606 56800 56556656.

58. b6b6B6o600515ooB 6b333 3o7ob8o66 56BB3b655365X5ob, Bobo 553550b, „«3"'b, „8b"-b 506 08 b66365oB3ooo3oob 3jo836ob 633636360, 665063 ob 7)63557)060 '338(y7b333ob '33B5035 Boo6oo63b3b. 3600 0063066000 3006335x56550 633B36360 5566506657)0636. 661168606005x507b ^066713 ^6(665556 3j']b33o65o 300^*83. 866 5666366506, 06078 3253^5^^'^'^*^3^'^ ô' *^3887Jf ' 300600636*80 6506806B06 6637)5x5173 '83085x5366 3365150 606 5565o^30ob. b6b6B6o600515ooB 6b333 5O63007b6 „3l)", (^00835x503 1998 ^5X5ob 653ob5('>'3o 515360663011 3oo5x; >o(30o6 56B3000305x *366"80 800336B36, 0600500063 J7)o65ofo66'3o 3J3B056B05150. „3l)"-6 8ob3503oo), 050 556300066 0x686 3005x5030351 »36 556 ' a' P^Bô * ^B3B • V' 36 35ï >3 ']5*^o '3o'73oo), 0607500063 6866 5668366553635150 655^306506.

59. b61168606075x5008 3o)7)bBo66 bb36 300^33361163 506 *3368oo\?86 ^o66b^606o 5680080360b 50( oob '33506073367)5x50 b65636o 556 8666515360. 11666860600515008 6b333 ^603ooob6 Ns39 b66365083000307*30 56B83b65O3635i50066 30^0)655 365i5656'3o B307030 „6"-6, „3"-66 556 „6"-6 633B36360 506 '836807^36 3jb3306536ob 80306 5668366503651506 668350030600 506 0360^065060735x50 '83307^836011 "335035360. b61)6860^005x5008 6b333 '836800^86 J65565X555ob 037)06335x50,0600835x1^03 030033b oB o7*Qobob 6bo^33ob 500607b,b65563 1998 5X5ob 19 b3J5336306b 506030(y)b6 56BB3b6503635X5o. ob 8000363556 1998 ^5i5ob 10 b3j5386o6ob 8oo35X53B36ob, o6o7503b63 567360660^556 „81i", 5567)80063063635x5 655^3o66b b6oo67)06o(y) ,,6366307035150760070 6500606366". 80)35x50 5Bd^Ô" 566836650365x506 8030^ 0300 556^30605150.

60. 1)380000 655^30605x50 85303367)5x5363606 li6037)8335ix '1)3 b6b6B606o)5i5O78 5566555066, o6o)8 1998 V ^ ^ ^ 19 63j5B3?>3*^b 5668366553635x50 ^60336636 5x5360663011 3005150300b 5663000)0)-5x5366*80, 1)65063 ob 50603ooob6 3005x50300116 506 3o6o)37)06657)06ob 066855360B3 635i5885036635i >o 3oo6o6 80306. obo6o 866 600600350636 3550606360B6 „86"-6 5673365o';]0636ob6 556 8335x5355.'0060b 73' dô' * ^'^ B MB B * * 36ooo)3ob ob 655505xx 'o, 1165563 53680 556860666. 566836655365x5066566 65506063606 801)65536650, 3(05x50300!! 000303063686 „3"-B 556 „b8"-8 5680)033636 35i53('|5*^* ' ' *' 8"' 0063 56B0006656 37)' 3?>1i3 635x566^3006 303060)3600). b6b686o6o75xi '(o 65560*86636, o6(oB 3006335x5650 6336366*80 5668366503635x50 63665036b, o ( B ob 6^683!) o6633j5'^''*^3^'^^^ "B""*^ 556 „(o"-8. 0)7)836 05036(500^0363006 665606360I1 5oo6( )b, 56683b6553635x;>86 68(^03600 ,,68", 06005(0063 3o6oo-3o6cy)o 08 (0060 (00303060506B, 0^(085x53603 86b 6^683650636. 30660506B 06 3355606. 7)85ii'36556 58"3"^*'^' à'-' ^^G '''"^ \B^3 ' ^"^ 65506063661)3 (r)6668(o66 5666(366556, B650668 30^0) 8ooB365'8o ';')373066505536(050 5 )60663605x1 '36, 0 , ^5 .(605566 5650665o'''Boo) 0)63(76 30)335x *6 56556^33056. oil 31)00* 80 B5556O6 800(50030351511 5563(36 556 b306b3865ii 'o 556o1)0666.

126

Page 10: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

61. 2005^5^5"^ ■^^ Boo3863o6b B03B0 60035000607500b 5X536oBb3ob 06600)67)5x586 b6b6860600515078

,,3" 556 „!)8" 506866*363336655 3600 6obb5X5ob b68606(y75i5ob 30O5O3 ]bob 286-3 87)b5i5ob B3-3

37)6^')5ob (6) 506 (6) (JBB'^'a^iiÔB^"^ ^^^^*3'3^88 ' *B (or>66685536o76ob 6(006005655 5680733B366,

56800b65735150 865156500060b 5680033B36007 66 63060(01)7)5150 '3355350b 568o)\73330o7). B600

Bo3li65^6o) ( 70)bo ^51500) O763ob7)035i536o!i 655333006 506 '83b6663ob65o, b686o60)65x1.'5568363

(0065660036*30 B7]'860760b b6B^5i506Bo 6306B651536. li6b6B606o)5X5O7bo)3ob b35X5Bo!i6^35oooBo

0603(^06863006 Bob35D3oo7, 2005 ^5ix 'oli 30 6073360^011 56666360 5 306 606 6(^oli b66o)5X5(o(n.

5. 1998 ^5i5ob 10-19 b3J583?>f^ob 8oo35X53B36ob 606600«g03065x1^7)60 5680080366

62. 1999 ^51506 1)60367)5x57)0 65068o6Bob 7)73^^8^3*^^^ 063500)665157)060 60666680)6306(06(0

000656601)6(3006 (60360 60)350006( 5006 ^683606 116^0666558503500 30o3o535") 0006B6 6^']5o3oli586,

5668366503651506 80306 56b6P703o6367)515 1998 ^5i5ob b3^^589^*^"^ 80035153636006B 506363'3oo636oo),

B33B366 668076060036 066B5036083 650680666. B6000 667)66060 66 30605x1 )0 0300 3050300668^306173.

63. 63 06(5306307)36*80 ,,03" 63665036506, 06008 050 55663633b 1998 ^5X5ob 10 1^3 (538630611.

b6365o8o6oo'3o 3ooo3Bob6b B6b b33B5o636 506 387)^06360050636 „86"-b 8335x535150760b 6550606360b

Bolibooo. 1998 ^5x506 17 63353^^*^3*^^ ^^'^ 506030o)b6 3(^5X503oob 8006360^0 568ooB8o365X5ob

„o"-b 80306, 06008351503 B6b o33bb 7)065368556 556 387)3063600556 3o^ob333'36 b636B'3o 6655536000,

665063 86b b33B5o636 506 0)365x53606 506bob65i5066366B553 6^633655636 35ï53d5^*^'^*^M^^-

64. 1998 ^51506 18 b3J53363o6b „03"-b6 506 56683b65D3635i5b '3ooo6ob B0735153 5063oo6ob3006366

665606506. „°3""3 5666366506, 0600B 56683b650365i5ob 3ob3061)3 ■3360*866 bobb5X5r)6J33336o.

b6556Boob ,,03" ob33 5563oo7b3b, 6B36B650 0^3500067)5x50 3(60037)0600060b 800650505153 „Bo6"-B,

600500060750b30b 365x5630b 3o6o737)06ooo6B6 506 3005150300b 00685036083 00030330686. '806" 366

6*80636506 ,,60^36113 56503367)5x5 306080665x5360066" 30600650 116366*80 6655036007, 0600B5153603

B6b 5667336507)063650636, 65o63(r733, 5*3^B^8c)^*^'^**^^ t5 '-"5B65o367)515006 66366*80 66b8oo7.

obobo, 6I1333, 387)306360050636, 06008 (y)7) ,,03" 5655606636(0506 66366*30, B6b 8o7)b5*^o5D636

00350667)0)^5x5066 365oBo6o766b, 66 6033500515000 506b5^6b.

65. „o3"-B 56633I76503635X5076B 3060065D 500500B66 567)36507)0^366 556 83351535x50066 65506C66.

„8o6"-b Booooboo36ooo 866 556666635156 ob 655505x50, b65563 53680 506865xi 3b. b656Boo3o36oo

5^573030 56051)6366 800000)367)5x5 650505156I1, 8650668 33(^6033060 655800660636. 1998 ^51506 20

^BdÔB^^B^^^' 5* ?) ' '-' ^ b6b5X5'3o 55660^7)63606 '8385035, ,,03" 566o763ob7)035ï58^i-

66. „6"-!i 56B3b65036oo7, 0600835x503 ^ 0 9 b66365o83ooo3oo'3o 5668366503635x50066 30600650

08300033600506 36515656*80, 666365083070300'80 8o336Bob6b 56683665536351586 B6b 8007)336

Bobo 506365080636017 5606380036360b, 330680055, 3515335*^* ' *^3*^^^ \768360b '33b6b36.

5668366553635x586 „6"-6 6P73366 5568^306076360 37)0^1i3, ^ 6 3 ,,5561)0051505150 67)060)3603000"

56800037)0636( 7556. b663655B30703oob bb36 36303650b, „B"-b 806)3553000, b6B68 56BB3b6503635X5b

80)0336655636, 3(05x1^03068 3306600665150 566030600b05x1^6, 06008 3o73363506(y) li6'3o71o 5068667)633.

3306b(oB65i5b 8oobo7bo733b 5563B651560) 333^^^*6660( 0 3 0635x1 0 83565x50b b656Bo. „8"-b (y)3Boo),

56683b6503635xi^b 37)0^361)3 110^0075153 6553607)636(0556, „o)oo73o7b 306B38 37)06360 8073666".

866 66333 56066366, 06078 566B36655365i5o!i 5535068 33^^366 713051: )06 37)f636ob '33300^*8366

b(r7boo36, 865066B 86000 073800x7, 333^156033060 ^3110^057)0 03(0. „3"-3 5066506b57)^6, 06008

b66365083000300*30 3(oo3Bob6b 5668366553635x586 36b 7)oobo66 Ç6836ob *33b6b36 506 556oB6b6

060)50006 b(y7boo3506 553506Bo!)o 33*^336b *3305i5obo73oli 37)06360!) '338o)^B366b. „3"-8 611333

55665O6b57)066, 0600B 5663366503635156 37306360 55617066367)5150 33(06556, B65066B 0600500(^3

86b 6bboo3b, ob 606 .^563506 '33!io367)5i5!).

67. 6066b6807630600607 (0065660IJ6300!) 63(5030653^86 6336366 66333 P)68oo6o6(y)33b „5X5"-b6

506 „3"-b, 566836655365x506 8663660I) 660^)3306 8(o\?8336b.

127

Page 11: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

68. 2000 75ii»ob 55333863067)0 6o66!i6Boo630 ( )6oo 000656601)63006 635"3'^^5ÔB^^^ 8''"' *88 3 0 635x5 55630(y)b36 ,,03", 08 Bo1)6oo), 0600B 6553003036)306600 ob ^06665535535006360, 006(3 606636006506 00U3030655 ''; 060 568(0803606 86b65xx'36b6 556 835ooob6 506 6o66b68o)63o6(o6(o 0^)0656601)6300116-o)3ob 803387)515 Bob 5663665536366 7I00060I1. „o3"-8 56663b6506, o6o)8 B060 5i^)6300)b3o6 5506006, 568ooB8o365xx »3686 7357)5153635x53336 8060 5663665036360 „Bo6"-6 1998 5x .06 b33(5386o6ob 8oo35xi »3636'3o 66060)7)5x1 '00606 076(066113.

50. 1998 ^5X5ob 10-19 b335836o^ob 800351536360b O76o>66l)3 56B83b65o365i5ob 8030^ \76(^8o75553605x50 bb36 30^0033507)06360

69. 1998 ^5o;'ob 5567)555363515 505536, 3o6(03';')o6ooo6B6 5655651)6366 8000)60)366 1998 \751506 12 ^BdÔB^^f^"'^ ^^ ?)^^^^^U3l}Ô^^U^^^^ !i6l)3556ab350335i5>oo 565566355361)3, 0^0085x500763 5668366503635x5!) 803665^^6 b73oo5055066o 65580606506630';]5x50 36508060)66. 1998 ^5i5ob 2 5O333B6306b, 6o;j6o 60035000607500b 063500067)5150 b6li68606(y75i5oob 30631705036586 3076655066 68 566663606 66735x5006366. 30631)05036586 65560*866, 06008 56666360 3737)863600556 6o7507o6(05oli3ob 3005x50300b ooo3030^36ob o6o3ooo6B6306b, 0600835150)6 3000007360b 07666b8650, 5668366503635x50 06306051)06 b65557]061)3 1998 ^5X5ob 11 b335B363o6b 55663633!). 007)836 68 5006070b60730b 566B366553635150 03635*^^* f 3*^S5 66365oBo6oo'3o o83oo»>336oo506 „8b"-6 567)60660636660)66 556363*800636007.

70. 2000 ^5x506 23 86065b 3o6oo37)o6( o^B6 6o7507o6oo5ob3oli 3075150300b b63o 070303060b ^06665585035, 566B36655365X506 06306051)06 665057)06*80 556363366bor)65 5563637100636007 (^(^"^ ^'38^8^^^^ 80338011 56800, 6558066 bobb5X5ob b6B606o)5X5ob b6383 (b6383 Ns310503). 3o6oo37)o6657)o6ob 568008803635x586 5566506b57)*^6, 06008 56683^6503635150 1998 ^5x50!) 11 b335B36306b 606 08300033600506 0630605170b b65557)o6li3, 00655566 68 5006006 (56363367)5150 0307. 0x77)836 2000 ^5X5ob 3 6(^733630^!), „bo57)630ob 7l3335i56boo66 556363'3oo636ooo", 8(^b506 6o^65ix 'oli V ' BB^S ' ' B 716o6ob 003B6, 06655566 30^00-306000 30051503035x50 5660)630117)035x53!) ^•^B-^BB^TIS '" 006668503600605066, boo5x: >oo 00060 '8066566 663830)6 66806065*^00*30 6636 0)6668503600661)3 56506033663b.

•71. 80x763( 0766 63b650365D6, 06008 2001 ^5X5ob 25 B6obb 306080665x57)060 b6383 NO10503 5656b515506 3o60037)066573*^ob b68b6b7)06ob 80306 556 '83850507B0 56Boo8o36ob6{yi3ob 5650635I76366 3635i >o73b3ob 365i563ob 3o6oo37)0^o706ob b68b6b7)06b. 2002 ^5x50!) 20 oo3(5oo863o6b bobb5X5o!i b68606o75X5ob b63B3 5O6ob7)066 3(05xx'O30o!i 00030306360b bobb5i5ob-b6B606o)5X536o6o3 50336660766 506363*800636001 66380 b b6 655 61)87)5x5 0060 b 36550 b 561135x50b 56B00. 3 b ô*^C?*^^833Ô^^B<^*^ (N- Vld* * d S *'-' d * 3o6o737)o6o7o6ob 80306 556 b6383 ob33 566665x^.556. 2004 ^51506 1 63o^o5X5b b63o 3oo5i503035X5ob bobb5i5ob b68606(y75i5ob b6383, 60665x50b ^63363606 iN' i oB^^Si 'B* " ^ '" ^ 3 0 *650, 56556351)6366 3006335150 0611566300b 666686(^0051^.(ob. 2004 ^51506 27 63f6o5X! »6 116383 "33^3506 60665x555367)5x53606 8oB606oo 110665x506 b6B606(y)5i5ob !i638ob^6o68o736ob 366076000 5565053605150 36503606 56b35i56boo66 556363*800^3600). 2004 ^5x506 19 600386306b 063500067)5x1 86 b6b686o6(y75i5oo8 56673386 3b 56556^333(505x5366 556 I16383 3oo6335X! >o 061156630011 b6b686060)5x500b 56556b36. 0600500063 8(o36b^,]63 8(x)63o6oo66 •^G^^i^B^^' ^ - d B JB '- ' B 8(05ii 'oo55o67)o6.

72. 2001 5X5'o6 19 ^53333^3^66 5668366503635x586 *33o5666 6680)365x .6300 b60 P)35X5o 60360 6(^)3500060)5006 5Xî '3606630b 0^600067)5x5 li6b686o6ox)5x; >07*80 556 Boooo7bo736 3(0833666306 6ooo6o7(5655 6o686o6(x)7)5xi»o 568(08(7360!), b68b6b7)06oli 506360653011, 3obo b63'^o70636oli 660633011, Bobo 55636336ob6 556 3005x5o(3oob 860605566 37)55655 80733060060I) 568(0. 566836650365x506 07)0606586 b6b6B606oo5i5(^li bo)b(036 3o60)37)06657306ob b6Bb6b'jo6o5066 80030)60736 !)638o6 96665x5360 N568241, NO10503 556 N"?68341. 566B3b65O3635X50 506 Bobo 0730601150 6(3b650365o636,

128

Page 12: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

OoooB 3o6o)37)o6657]o6ob B0306 "83506003367)5150 B6b65X536o b6^oo6oo 0300 b68o7365X53oo b606n35X5ob 6o6b36o(y)o 66 705x5011 50 6668(5303365xi_*65o. 2002 "y5x506 22 630 )05x5!) 60360 60035000600500b 5i;>36o663o6 0660( 76735x586 li6b68606(05x00)8 568070(060036 116383360 3o6o7373o6657)*^ob 7)3b6668obo b6Bb6b7^o6o5066. 2002 5xi 'ob 27 o35X5obli 156383360 b6b636o6o)5i5oob \76063505066. 2002 5Xi,'ob 1 653o!)5ooli 3o6oo37)o6o>o6ob Booo)b(036oo) !)63Bo!i 3666515360 3060037306657)066710

5566067)6556. 2002 '5x506 23 0035*^3630611 56683b655365xx 'ob 07)06011586 b6b68606oo55 'O7b b63Bob 5650655366 8o7boobo736.

73. 1998 \75150b 17 6530I1500070 556(r76o6o55367)5xi,H) 635x50366(506 56636655366, b63b66^7)0605566 56(063ob7)03fm^6ob 0)60066173, 567)38556 556 5668366553635150 (06668503600661)3 6556505063b. Bobo 56636650360!! ^066 060363000 5560)6060553661)3 36li73bo!i853635X5o 00030306360 55011(3035x5067)0^ 36b7)b(7li85365X50766b 556333385036606636,(07)8(36 606735x50 383557)7)660 )00606 56B00, 5668366503635x50 o87)5xi,>367)5150 566506 55635*^33^066 b65l)60) 3o)5x: '0306.

3. 56B83b650365i5ob 68368065035x50 85050)86(^30066

74. 566B3b65D3635X5o 606ob 3^B 'Z)'(!1 '-' ' *^ f?" ' ^ b6037)83515007 b6b35i58^oo3oob6566 05536!) 336bo6b. 80063060066B 5066555066, 06008 8o78b5O606 '338oob3336bo766 5O6363'3o0636oo) 566B3b6503635X586 66556175533300 3008336116300b 66I5000 b6635i58^oo307b566 8005500 3060)0660 oo66b6, 066863 7)36555066 60 302 o67)b7)5X5o 067)65x1 0 (50ô6b5xi o)36oo7 1 740 330600b 3330365153650 B0850066063 37)(^booo).

75. 56533b6503635i586 ^60680)6505066 2004 ^5X5ob 29 6oo3B6o6ob 6656o6o'3o, 506^30605150 !i6b68606oo5X5( 8355030606 6333065X1,'o!)50b 3308 5x1,». 86567)500366 80306. 65560*367)5x1 0 66560607I0 655536506, 06008 56683665036351^.!i 33006556 835x50b 53* '6ob 6607366, 7336360 33006506 3606651501)367)5x50, 03(0 3'^3^71'e)^'^^'^'^' 05665^3607506 B36'^ob 0)06566003606 8363060 'aTi'zi^dG"^^^*^^^' - sç*^3*^*^&'a^^ * ^ d ^ ^ ^ ' ^ i^3d^'3'^^^''?i^" Ti'zif^dG*^^- " ^ ^*^^'^à3'Z)^*" « a* 66 0051511 506 87)55803655 b6joo6o)36506 800835x53515b, 006006 506b86o636oo556 '8606500b 6';^'3(5ol)6 506 37]^-66^5i563ob bob533ob 50635x56*30. 56683b65O3635X50 08300033600506 l)303bobob o6ob3ob 333'3. ob 8ooooob( 73506 b663655B3oo0307b 300600636*80 87)50803 568(0335i5336b, 3335156173 30056 ^35x50^650'80 00065 306 66 b685^3(^.

II. '90b66680b0 "BO^b b5baf^8^^073r9a6(*7030 b^a6(^0)^K?0

6. b65^6(^oo 8oo 1535153360b 8030^ 7136607600 3 ^ 8 ^ ^ ^ " ^ b6^o6665585035ro b68o7365156300 b686(^075x5360^030 833^^0*^3360

76. o67)b3(oob 733553066300b b63oo365i563oo 3* 5533 ** 5 06(0835150(3 865x56*30 '3330556 1996 ^5i5ob 1 86065b, 3oo8336b6306b oo7365i5ob^o636b li6b35i5Byotgoo!) B0306 33355*^<^ob 66 7)8(03835500606 568(0 56800^337)5x50 1)066o660)3oli (1069-3 37)65150). b6B0)365x .6300 30O5! i33bob I5I-3 506 1099-1101-3 B7)b5ii;'36o o(0365X5obÇo63636 3003336663066 60^)63653*^065x573060 1)066o66(03ob. 1099-3 37)65x1 0 6005366, o6(o8 60668653*^065x573060 1)066o6 666'li5O67')06366 7)6556 80065036 865306065x573060 l7066ob 6661)55673063606 807)635563650.

6. b65^6(^o) 8o7b35i5336ob 803(6 7)365006(0 398JÇ*^^"^ b6^o5665535D35oo bobb5i5ob-b6360^o75X536(^o3o 833^60178360

77. o67)b3(ooli 733(53066300!) liobb^>ob b68606o)5i: 'ob 30")5533 i* ^ l^^'B B7)b5i5ob 8300063 66^05x506 (a) dBB-' Tl dÔ^ ^ o7666b865o, ^68366 065^366 7)3050 ^5il>6B553 O)63ob7)035i58' ^^^ ^ 'BBB^ ' oo. 30)5533bo!i IIO-3 873b5X50 (03oo)B335X5350'0)6ob b5o87)5i5o(^36ob 635"^^ r7685036b 67)00 ^51568503

129

Page 13: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

o)63ob7)035ix'3^f>^ 65;.333(o6b 7)O36065O36b. 286-3 87)b5i;.ob (6) 506 (6) 338^^'36dÔB^" b68b6b7)0^03-606030 8(0365153006011 6000600(5650 568003363606 3 BP?B* ' ' 365x; 65Doo6o(o 66 0^6863 568000^306 b306oo7l)';'35i 'o '8350350, 63obo636b 607 Vff:** 3553 (0630b7)035».360b 6553330)6b.

5. 5D666'367)5X536ob 000303065x57)060 5680080366

78. 1960 \75x50l1 bo!ib5X5ob b68606o75i5ob b63o6oo33li(o 30O5o33bob (865x567)06 2002 \75i568503) IO8-3 506 125-3 87)b5i536ob 8ob3553(){y7, bo!i65i5ob-b6B6o6o)5X536o6o3o 5680080366 060300636735x50 7)6506 03(06 3o6oo37)o6657)o6ob 568008803650)011 B0306 330680) 3oo )ob 8o707boo35ob 1*6037)8335151)3, 66 116568(0803600 b35x5ob73035xx »360b 30006550 060306503000. 30O5O33bob 53-3 87)65150 6555366, 06008 3oo6!i, 0600835x51163 1)066o 55666*367)5X5oil b6037)3335xi'1)3 8065556, 7)6556 80333b 8bb330o35X5ob b5657)6o 506 '337)851506 '337)306(r75O3li bobb5i5ob-li6B60oo)5i536o6o3 3060033557)066b 0600500063 b6800365x56300 8b6o63. 56Boo8o36ob 5668635x50766*80 8bb330635i5b 7)37)85x506 \760665050600b ^ÔB^GB^ci^B^B^" S?* '33056600I1 b606635xi 'o; 0^075(0063 30 5680)80366 556b(^7)51555366, 8bb330o35i5b 336366 6( 735150 506*83366 b638ob 36b65x; '36(066.

79. 30O5O33bob 2IO-3 556 2II-3 87)b5i536ob b6«337)833515113 3060037)0 ( 060 36b7)bob853635i50 0300 b638ob 5630080360b 8066365x58b(^03 5680080366173. 330680)50, 3o6o737)o6ooo6b '33335x500 5063365x536066 6333065x57)060 b656Boo8o36o7 8336601183606 568(0336366, b638ob 30^000 56800880365x505066 830oo6ob6oo3ob 565063386 66 b638ob 566605153011 56666515366.

80. 30)5533bob 209-3 *^7]^^'^'B 5f?6yo65o5o76ooo, oB 56Boo88o3635X5b, 3063 6560^36556 5680080366b, '83385x500 b638ob 'fl3^33356 55 f '367)5x50b 85303367)5i53636ob 6635x53607606 66037)8335151)3. 8b563bo 56556\('3335o5X5366 736556 56b66o3065O3!i b6b636o6005x500*80 66 80063606 3060037)0600060066. 66668606(0515(06 '333850.(0 6oiib5X5ob 1168606075150b 5680080360b 566665x0360b 7l3b6b36 606865360b 563386, (y77) 56556^3335556, 06008 5680080366 P)656065O6 606611067)5x53070305x5650.

81. 30o5533bob 2IO-3 87)65150 oo)365i5(7b^o6366, o6(oB 663B3 7I3085X5366 5666b5o»503b 3( o737)o6ooo6ob 80306, ,,0073 6o6b36oo6b 680b 66037)8335x50". 8bo75X5075o 568o)b68o3635X5o 506667)67)5X5ob b665061787)5x1^0060b 36500b 56b35X5ob '838505078 6O6 '83085x5366 b638ob 566665x5366.

82. 30O5O33bob I6I-3 87)b5i5o ooo365X5ob^o536b, 06008 06005(0063 I70056500 VB^*^' 568o)8o36ob 500600b 800307336735x50 0603000686306 60 6(^ob b65^6o6oo. 6b3ooo 0503000686300b 56bb56, '83b685xi'3635x506 8bo75X5oo5o b656Boo8o36oo 635x501173035x536011 636606(03007, (yiT) 050 b35X5b 60^ '337)*85i5o!i 56Boo8o36ob 11^00( 650 ^6o686o6o736b 506 606 '835xx *6b63b 3o6o733b71o 660607735150 866063360I1 7]735i53636b6 556 11686060)515360^03 o653063bli. 0603(00686306 8b6o6336ob 30006550 3b(O30636ob '83b6b36 606 *33o35i5366 56b503b b65^606oo 86000 o765bBo76ob 56063*33.

I. dr)6806GOOb 8G-3 a-abP^Ob 800)00)a6'3ff?0 ^^5(^^803^

83. 566B366503635Xx.'o 6000506, o6o)8 30051503067)0 5563633601166 86b 3'i')5565o 80033306636, 566li637)(x)o636oo7 5o^»36o663o6 3( 5xx^»03ooli 566300O3O5ix '366'3o 1998 \/5x1 06 19 !)335B36O6O6 5563007630b 500600b. 68633 5oo^oob, 68 37)0)boo) '60686( 077)5150 5630080366 606 03(0 3733dÔcl^^-ob 556330650)6(0 83-3 87)65i;'6, o6o7835ix '03 0073651506^7063611:

87)b5ii_>o 3 — ^683606 6306865x536

,,6066306 ' 83085x5366 56b503li ^76836011, 6066650680667)060, 501-586830063635x50 B0733060760 506!)5^o6 8663306351^)0*'.

130

Page 14: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

6. 8oo63(^o76ob ^o66b^6(6o 3 0 6 3 5 3 ^ ^ " ^

84. 8(X)63o6o7668 56663b6506 , 06(08 8(03387)511^.0 !i638ob 3oo)60636ob 5680)80366 01133

80850066063(0611 506 '80556 Ii6b35i58^oo3io36o6o3 5500631)3 5^306 56506\73335o5xi,>366 606 60 )ob

8055367)5150. 68 73635*^*3 80(00(03600), 06(760 6853033636, 0600B 566B3b6503635i586 606 6Boo'y7)066

*3o5D6 b6635i5B^oo3(')36o6o30 8336601)8360 (3'^55655 80033060760b b66(73606{O66 5563637I00636001.

'33b666Bob655, 6665506330 0300 Bobo b66o3606o 56Boo8o36ob 800)000367)515 60663O33357lf^*'^^''^'^\T

85. 5668366503635150 63 800661)063666 606 55630066686. oil 63665536506, f6(oB b6!i6860^)O)5i5(o'3o

Bobo 3000335x1 )0 116603060b b6037)8335i5l)3 liobb5i5ob b68606oo5X5ob 5680080366 7)3^^355^^ 50.::)

5666b5i5506 '830505^306. 60^)656oo6o 6b655,M7 85303367]5X!;*3636o 606 036366 8(08036-35150 506

b638o!i 568(o3o36ob 3335x56 *338505(o8o (3556 036366 7)116065365150). 56B0780366 5650^)83515506

■33050 ^35x51)3 8 3 5 ■b666 556 666(0515000750, 506506657)06556, 06008 5006000b O7365x:;'b6l)o6oboo), 05(7

6066303335^1 ^'^- 61)333, 566836655365150b 800)00)360(0, ob 606 606ob 3651555367)5150 55635x50)5500!)

568o)8o36ob 50611067)5x1 )36611.

86. b6b68606o75i5O) 68 37)ooboo7 63b650361>, 06008 06o75O3b63 30060036366 '8305666 60657383550-

06367)515 !)66o36061i 3005x1^030011 B0306 860*83635150736650 37355650 807330607606 oo6(o66l)3,

bolib5i5ob-b6B6o6o)5X536o^o3o b66o36o6o '83085x5366 8o6637)5xi,> 03636 30063363006 35-3 B7)65xi 'ob

I-5150 37)635oox) 56(0365i5ob^o636'^5X^' *^S5838'-^Ôc)*^ 1)0)865o (ob . ôhuGoi^jo fv.^ bh^yjc^o

d^frnQ,^f^j(r?olj ^o/^.^ô^'/^^j^.N^24160m, 1996 ^5150!^ 27 o36obo, DR 86-6 ,53 . 71). b6b35X58^oo3oob

o^6b633oo6335X506, 7)6556 303336 b638ob 56Bo73o36ob6 506 30070003673515 ^560655333361)3

06365006360!) B(ob5036ob 753116351536515(066. 63633 Sï''^'^^' "5*^^93b6503635x;ib 606 b^oo655366

08 8336601)83606 568(0336366, 060085x1 )3603 (03000607)515650, 86070 66bo6ooob506 8073635063650,

06365150066*30 606 085x1^336 800)00)367)5x50 5560650333011 3078336b63ooli '33b685xi^365X5(o66b"

{or7s^>^f^o w^^rojjœolî \7o6ùi^^>fi^\'j^), Nê26973/95, 1997 '5x5011 13 06636060; ob. 66333 ^jçoo[^:>(^o

jcp6 hh^Q?)0 a)'^](^JQ(r}oh ^/oSôù^ifJ^u^, 1996 ^5i5ob 30 65301150711 56506^33350515366, •(^^>SàP)Q6Q6oh

Xp6 ^*'>^'^\7^%']U(^of^\')6jioh àGQ.'^r^oTJo 1996-IV, 53. 1210, 373635*^ 68)- 7)7) 60^637)5150 667)7)65x1^366

0)3000607)515650 650333657)060 0300, 8650668 5006000)6 5668635x5(066*80 556506657)06506 Bobo

60^63033357)060066, 56683b65D3635xi^'o 655606 6o6ob 365i55536';')5ii.'o, 68o7^7)06oob 050 (ob . g/)3j

(n^f^Jjœoh foSù.\çoSjr>jg, 27244/95, 3ooBoboob 1996 Ç5150I1 25 600386060b 56506^3335o5X!;'36v^).

87. b6b6B606005x5008 8006606, 06008 56683b655365X5ob 03665^^0605566 565580036065560b 56063B0736360

3860b 37)55650 80733060060!) „R,^65O6b57)063665o 55636b"; 865 5680003366 333515-^ '33b6B5153635150

B3366o1)8o bobb5X5ob-b6B6o6 00515 3606 03 b 6380 b^606 800366*30 1166030* ) ob 56556338000

b35xi^oli7303jxx?36ob oB 000656600360!) b35X5'3o, 060085x53603 3003335365*3*^3^0 606066 8b563b

176383*30 506 807)635563650 6Bob6, b63B3 335x563 B(05X5oi5oo6'8o6. 6335566 56800855066063,

56556^'3335o5X5366'3o 556*83366550)606 *33b6b36, b6b686o6o)5i5oo8 8006606, o6(o8 8oo63o6(o6ob

68 30635361700b 566bo5xi^36 7)6556 8006503b b638ob B6b65xi^36oo66 3060x7655.

88. b6b686o6(05xi^oo 8006633b, (^(oB 30)63060060!) ^o66b^7606o 30635361106 ^6o68o77)(o6b 11630006)3611,

06(^85x53603 5668366503651506 B0306 800)000367)5x1^ B' ' ^BB^^G"^^^ 6(66360(0 55367)51536360)66

3060)650 736556 03636 566bo5i57)5xi;>o. 3b li63oo)bo, 7Î3!i666Boli65o, 33B3O">(I'> 036366 566605157)5150.

89. 2005 ^5X5oli 29 ^53338630611 8(0630600668 !i6b68606o)5xi^o7b 6360066 60360 60)35(0060)5506

511^»3606630!) 0660(067)5150 b6b68606{O5i5(ob 2005 \75x .ob 30 6(0386o6ob 56506^3335o5X53^^ob

7)3b6b36, 5668(36655365x^.06 8o860^io) 3(05x503006 80306 37)55650 8oo33o6oo6o!i 73635^-^^

506363*300636007 (ob. § 61). 8006306(066 63b65036506, o6(o8 565O6\7333505X5366 '^i](^^ 606 0300

1)66(05X50700 506 obo6o '3385550080 566300)6063606 "3366636 636(063650636 Ii6b686o6o)5i5iob.

31

Page 15: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

90. 807)635^63655 o8o66, 0600B 80)6306(066 606 3306506006(0506 63 Yl'^dÔ^' 666686060)5x5008

■836800^86, 06685536655 8003B35036506 6b5ix '65o 5663O(y>606367)5i5o 85050)860630066 566836650365150I1

8663306351^)06 6565716113 30'i63363oo6 34-3 873651506 O36o655xi >3671o. 68 o)365ii;'b6l)06obooo,

1)61168600o>5x; >(oB Boo65o6, 0600B 56683665536515011 b61)6065365x50)55 305536735150 56556^3335050^.366

606 6o6ob b6386o6obo Bobo)3ob 8bb330635ii;.ob b5657]6o!i 66307660600833650, b666B 7)0506

635x^.067)03^.366 60663600)655 66 568006657)515655 606 566360060306366 506 3005335300b

556065;i333ob6(O3ob 3(o8336b6306b 606 56506'jb5oob B6b (ob. 865.: ^>8^j(6o bùo^foôBQijœoh

ï'oS.^'K'^f^Oi')^ 1996 '5x;>ob 25 o35obob 5*^^ ' \niBBÔ<^ '3^^ ' QùSOofiijduàob^ fvù d'^^^'^^UiWO^^'J-

Ajâoh ù6^ù&)o'dQ?)o 1996-III, 53. 846, 37)635*^ 36 506 ^>Ù^>6..^SO (oyjfioB^œob foBùà^yS^iQ'^ [GC],

N^'28114/95, 373635^1 44, 6506Bo66ob 7)735153636011 33060037)51; 'o 3006336306 1999-VI). 80)3387)5x1^

663837)0 b6b686o6(05i;'oo 65550*36636: 3006335x50, 2005 ^51 .06 30 5003B60606 56556 '333505x1,»366

6O6 6o6ob b66oo5ix '0oo7 506 '8308515366 *3303365x1 '00b 63355^'630ob 500600b; 8307063, 8073635063650

oBob6, 06008 3ooo335i5'o 06I15663006 Ii66686o6o)5xi >(ob 80306 55655506556 37)55655 80033060060b

0363(50, 5668366553635ix^'6 80336367)5x50 1)065o66o)3o6 300833666306 606 801133806; B3b683,

2005 \7 5xx 'ob 30 600386060b 56506^3335o5xi,'366 *833636oo506 36005x )0050 37355655 800330607606

036356 556 606603306b 686oo65T.6 5680780360I1 ^6o6B6o6(y)3ob *^33b6b36, 0663 56583b655365i5ob

800600)6550 3oo(y)6oo366 0300 8003387)5x5 li6383'3o. 685036655, 8073635063655 o8ob6, o6(oB

56556^333505x5366 7)650)6 66001365x5006 568078036011 B(0 636o6 66^05x5655, 06 663806

56063B00363606 806350300) 606 80738350366 566836650365x5017 8bb33o635X5ob b5657)6l73, Bob

80860607 56307336367)5x50 865xi '655076o6o3o d93C?0'>636ob 568(0.

6. 5680080360b 8000000367)5x50 '337)b6663oo636o

91. 8o)63o6o766b 606 V' * 'Z) &B * ' 6066660060 BoBoo6o5xx '36 li606635X[.ob 736353^*^^^ * * &3f ** 3-

7)030600 B3503, 5O686536007O 060300068630066 556 550^37)83656300!) 80^00503606 0760766l)3

b6b636o6o)5X5oob 8o7o)boo366^b3, 80)630^00668 7)6060 7)006066 6666B60600515006 1998 ^5x 'ob 19

113358^^*^*^^ '338o)b3336b(o66 556 30051503006 80306 635x1^0366506 80860600 37)55655 800330600606

03635*^*^ ^ 556363*3006360(0 66380I1 8666511 .36011 80^^0750366173. B6(y7 807)07000311 bobb5X5oli

b686o6o75i5ob 30O5O33bob I6I-3 87)b5X5l73, o6oo835ix '03 650536b, 0600B ^o56b656Boo3o36o7 b638ob

861165x5360b b65^6o6(055 566)li66 '8308515366 860)5x50055 11656800303607 63515067)035x53606

006668006000 506 86075x50050 08 '8380063336*80, (07) 3b 606 '337j'35i5ob b35i5b 5680080366b 506

606 55660655333b bobb5X5ob b6B606o)5i5ob b63Bob 3b6o6336ob 7)7351536361).

92. 5668366553635x50 6000556, 0600B !i6b35xi 8^oo3(o8 55660655306 Bobo 3(o1)o5o7)0^o 36511.'5536735x5366,

I16383 568073806 B3-3 B7)b5X5ob < 6o655x >3671o. Bobo 03665^0605066 565080036O650606 560638(036360,

'y30507)0636 *338(o63336*80, Bo(y)oo)367)5i5 37)55655 807330607661)3 556506b57)<^3?i65D 55636b

'p'60o8(o7)o)65x >6. 8oo36b7)b3 b6b351;'8\700300 365x;>558^71 '" "^T^ 87î3dÔ7J " S3? '- 33630^650

568003806 Bobo 800)0(036360. 0)7)836 b63Bob 56Boob68o365X565o 30056 0^68 5633(0556 556

B055367)511 *0 17008360 6066303335'y^f^ Cl* '-'''' ' ' S^BBB'-^Ôt)^" 6558(066506.

93. 56683b6553635ix;>86 000303065x57)060 568oo()o36ob 7)680063 5537333ô' 'B Bo7)07ooo6. 8656515000650,

Bobo I168355030600 568(033515336 665606556 1998 \75ï5>ob 26 o)35*^36306b, 7)3Bo)b33305O66

306000 (030I1 '33B5035. o)7) 5630003651506^06360), 06078 68536060 830)00500(0 '\?6836o6 3365x >o

66386(055 B65i;>3 3f B * ' ô-^ ' MB^BB' 865x;>066 55* o!)8 >' f 8 *e) ' - B 'BdÔ* ' ' " ' *''*' * b ' f f ^BB'i'l f

7)6o5xi >63o 5561)066363606 506505366, 60075x5(05073060 6665x )ol7o6 66037)8335x5113, 06305036505066

0060 3300606 5668635x50066'80 7I3085X5366 80)65036. (07')836 566836650365x506 568(0335x5336

'8380000360655156 86065030 30177)65157)o6o '338(0^836000.

132

Page 16: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

94. 7)38505008, 56B0080366B 5*^^^G^'"^^3*^3^*^ ^'^ 3005x1^03006 ob 00030306360 060035x1 3603 86b 37355650 8(033306636 3060)8663076 606 5067)3oo6o!i3oo66. 68073600606 300073355730^6 665606506 06305036505066 (0060 \7 5x506 '33B5535. 568(08036011 3006335x5 35'^'^^B 86(05150755 00060 5568(07)305036351x -0 800^806 „6"-66 556 3308 „3"-b 506300)636 8ooV)506. 30600373066573^66 550500 6606 565B635x^(o6671o (1998 ^ '51506 21 63353860605566 2000 Vu;'o6 24 06630668553) 736066 63b65036506 N239 li66365o8307Y)oob 363035536ob6 556 330611(06651 '06 05536500)03006366116 506 5563000636173. 3!i 566600(^3035x5506 Bboo5x '0055 566836655365x1^»ob6 556 Bobo ^76068008650536-5153606 7')68o663o 66603060b '8385035, 0600503663 1998 ^75i5o!i '8380063336 800^8336011 86660030600605566 63515-635x1 '6 5630^6.

95. 56683665036351586 37)0665055366 566866305156 568008036011 5568007)3055365x5(0606 663515.3600-66l)3, 66b35X5B\7oo3(o 3060037)060006360!) 0006865 36b7)bobB5365xi^'(o66li3 606651555360176 556 56B(o8o36ob b\7(006655 V' *^* ' ^"^3' ^^ 3006506075x5011 (O6oo66l)3. 565B3b650365i5ob 116383*30 855507860630060b 567)606311366 56Booo'ç'306 08 0363536, 06008 3o^(037)o665'3f6oli b35xx »885536635x50 3oo6o ,,806", 0607B351503 36673606853635x50 0300 5668(36650365x1^011 1998 ^51506 19 b3358^^*^"^^ 55630006361)3, 6b067)5x536506 60360 60035000607550b 063500760b 3060037)06000606 8006505050.06 o6oo5xi 'b. 5668366553635x586 807)000006 „Y3"-6 2000 75x506 7 55333B6o6ob 566366503636113, 665063 866 00336, 0 008 ^o56 5563000636113 5630788036511;.36B6 7)57)U53<^35i5333!i 8060 5666366550, 1998 ^51506 10-19 b335836o^ob 80035153636*30 „Bo6"-!i 80066^05x53006660066 506363'3oo636oo7. ,,806" 6(^ 5563oo7b7)5i56 56B0780360I1 6(^3 30600 3Ô* ' ' *B C?* Bobo 5O630O7b36 6556(0(3 8oob50366, 00650566 050 560655603365x^.6 2002 ^51506 1)603b7)5X5'8o.

96. 2002 \75150b 653ob5oo'3o 5668366553635x586 306073730^657)0666 8oobo7boo36, N^39 b6635o8307O307b 8630365 >)3"-b 5563000636, 8650668 7)b60^5365150750. 2002 y5i5ob 5 b335B36306b 3060037)0665730668 b6383 oB Bol73l)0oo '83^33056, 06008, inter alia, '837)85153635150 0300 „3"-b 300366 Bob b63bo73063635i5 650505156b. 030050636 066, 0600B ,,3" 0300 3^8^717]^'^^^ i * 6000^65x5360660 1)6360685x506 8008b86063635x50, 56583b65O3635i50 556 Bobo ^6068(086555365x5360 5567)363*3050636 „3"-6 506 655800660636 '33850350: 5680088036351586 „6"-8, 3063 3667)6068536351^.0 0300 56683665036515011 66383173, 51536066306 3005150306b Bo7booboo36 „3"-b 80083666. 63 3o7(y)bo735ob '33bo^7)5X5366 5563365x56 „oo"-b, 3005150300b 08 (00303306b, 06008351503 6606007)5150 7)6506" 3(00305x1 0300 8000000367)515 37355650 8(o33(^o76ob o3635'3o. „oo"-8 5666366556, 0600B 366 006350365^^30683 636556 „3"-b 5063oo)b36, 8650068 330^ '8385x1 00 Bobo 300366 8ob6B606ool73. 2002 ^5X5ob 26 b33583630^b „3"-8 56583b655365i5ob ^606800865053651536!) 5667386(^5''^' 06008 6556806686, 0600835x5863 00630 ^60673505066 0600500063 568008803635x536, 03635" **** B* C? 3o6oy)b35i5 5567306336 506 7)o)bo66, ( 008 7)65500506 Bobo 55630o)b36. „3"-8 8*66553(00366 56673366506, 8650668 ^^•^03^*873*^^^ b67)6o6ob '83B5035 3b 655680660 655606 568ooF)36o5xx »6.

97. 63515036650b 6I706000, 5068(07)3050365150760b 663515360066 66667)5150 03(0 0600500063 ^ÔB^GB^Tli 'B^B^*^^^ "33506073366*30, ob3 56BooB8o365x536ob 8030^ 86000 7l3036b36oli oj(^(^86'8o3. 86565x5007650, 568(088036351586 7)57)5^53635x5300 5668366553635x50066 3060)650 365x;i656*3o 8300030 „6"-6 6336366. 866 66333 6o6656oo6o 860*33635x50066 606 8o66oj^6 6663655830003^015 bb36 3630355360!) 6336363611. 56B0730366 606 03(0 66386(^06650 8363060 08060730b, r6(o3 8(086.556060300 30^63363006 B3-3 506 83-13 87)651536(066 0)6663350066 506 635x50117)035x53606 860605566 606 B0003635D6 6o66560o6 63( 000177)5x5 B3365o1)81i, 0600B ^563555066 (07) 066 8006556 bo66850305i53'8o 5668(36650365x506 50636336066b. 3oo6o3ooo, ob 808606077)5150 0307, 03000336, 06008 8o363965i;'6 66503605x50 556567l67)5x;'o 506 5563336 3667)606853635x1^0 300 )360.

98. Ii66o75ii >oo(05o, 565B3b6503635X!,.86 5666366506, o6(o8 8(0630600606 56556 7333(505x1 *366, 606 \7606B(O35O5o56 3008365606360 ^635îl'^t'''65 506363'3oo636o(y), 5680780366*30 B307030 !ioli65ii 'o6 668606(o5xx 'o!i !i63Bo!i 866651^ )3606 \?6o655536oli 67)06305x *06 6063oo66li(y)66 3060)650. ' •)6556

Page 17: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

566o86o653^^C?0^* 06(050006(3 5668366503651506 3oo1)03oob 86606556^3006 506 3006336(30011 83-3 87)b5X5ob 6o61i36ooy)o 556 3060)33507)067)5x50 506b6^3obo.

J. B'jbùdij f)h<^(oob Q'^'^^(jb'^^lJ(^U<^o ^J^ chx}ù[j(^)n6ob .hbyjho

99. \T'3o6o5i5»oo6o(o 5663b65f»3636*8(7 0635506311 5*^66(586 8(00*8335x1 06 3306(037)5x50 l)6b686o6(05X5oob6 506 bb36 b63o6o)6'3ooo6o!)oo (oo6566()'663036ob 17(05651 .0 \73!i36o ^68360116 556 37)50655 8(o33o6(o6ob 636011803060 030006B06 6306865x5306 o>6(o66l)3. '(1385035 0635506311 (5* '' ' ^Ô ' '" 067363(006 65068o66oli 7)VJ \')**'B* * * SN' ^GB' ' 6o66li6B(x)63o6o)6o) 000656601)63068 '830066683-6735x1 .650 5666366553!!, 0607B o67)b3(oob b656Bo)8o36o) bob(53B36b 635x1 50600 800600)6550 30^0033507)067)5x50 556330b 3336601)3360, 0663 300633515 06057I0, 66503611 56807803667)0 8307030 3000360b 7)735ii.'3636ob 556330b 7)17067)6335x530003611 556 83(0063 0605*80, 03636 66568(0803600 b35i5ob7)035i536ob 8bo6o5x '66 ^'683606, 65 116)36 b6bob 37)55650 8o733o6(o6ob 8bb33o635xi o76 o553063b36b. 8600 6333650 56633(036 o86'b3, 06078 3o6635^3'^'3o, b6B606o)65i55o68363o 0006566003606 80306 37)55650 800330600606 736353^^'^'^^ 556363*3oo636o(x), 56B0780366 663B60050 b7)b565o 80850066063(06556, 8006000650650 0B05008, ( 008 568(0803666 ^683606 37)ooboo7 656(^36556 05033 b6563oo8o36oo 000656607,0607B351503, 8o(oooo36ob6836o^, 6606007)5150 0300 37)55655 Boo33o6oo6ob 635'3o. obobo 6b6b35x53650636 6636 o3635^'^^^'^3' <^oo835i503, 860)o '33b3507)5i536o(o, y0666656800303607 3o6o7 33b'^8o 606b367)5X5o 37)55650 8003306076017 ^3635^^ 56Boo8o36ob B7'3Bdô'e) f' ^^^^ 68300636506.

100. 8(0630607668 3003(5361)06 568oo(y)336 836683 866(^350 65550*86735x50 606666807630607600 000656601)6303606 80066^051530066173 6611686060)5x500*30 506 bo7boo36 b6b68606o75x; o7b 86000 3oob6l)0636360b 7)606307036 0600500063 66b5(^6357]Si5f'^'^ C?'' 73156065365x5(0bo. 80063060066B 61)333 6360766 li6b6B6o6o)5Xi »(ob, 06008 33!)6B3 8b606ob 5663665536066566 565bb36336oo7, o67)b3oo'3o 37)55650 30033060760I16565 5f'633ob 8336601)8360 6o6b36oo6b 506 1706506b 56603500b. 300633515 0^05*80, o67]b30)ol) 3006650571306 3068651563b 37)55650 Boo33o6o76ob 536ob8o3o6 o3O706B6b. 7)030600 83503 , b()bb5i5ob b68606(O5X5ob b63o6(033boo 30O5O33bo!i 83-9 87)b5o 'o 0(0365x1^011^0636556, 06008 6o6b5X5ob b68606o)5X5ob b638ob'\J'6o6Boo36ob- 8b6o6336o 606 7)6556 i ' BdSB^^B* ' ' ' ' ^ 865x56500066b 65 87]36o66b. 506B653600), o67)b307ob bobb5X5ob b6B606o75i5ob 3005533bo b6115^35x5b ooo365x:^o!i^o636b ^6836obo73ob (B7)b5i5o 117), b68b6b7)o636o6o3o 865X567)035X536ob 56556^6066367)5x5650 568o733636ob(03ob (B7)b5i5)o 286), B5303367)5X53636ob 8o338ob6b o87)5x536ob6003ob (B7)b5i50 302). 5066075x500b, b6Boo365i563oo 30* 5533 * ^ IO7O-3 B7)b5X5ob 8ob3503ooo, 7)36600600 55636508063600x7, 60665x555360(0 66 566686060)5x536000 80336367)5x50 1)066ob 6661)5567)003661)3 36li7)bob853635xi^o 6o6ob li6b35X5BVoo3oo, 8o7)b3506365o oBob6 6o6ob 007) 6006 P)6o6oo7)5i5o b6b35x53^00300 173515ob7)035x5360b 60 65153735150 36!)7)6ob85365X5(o66.

101. 5066(05i )(ob, 8o)63o6(o6o!i 5663b65536ooo, 60611367)5x50 668606(05x1^3606030 8336601)8360 300635*^8'" ^30 37333ô7)^'^t? ^IF^ S' ' ^BB^B^TIK,'*"'- '" 35536650, 2003-2004 ^5x536710 665 60600 3000037)060)^63686 6686(^00651550683630 0006566003606 O76668'3o600835x0006 80306 36600606 50606553330b 685 «36350 56bb63b, 060b ^83503565063, 350 b6b35ix_.3^oo307 8(ob35xi.>3 B0336 5oob30 3515067)06 36li73boli5366'3o. 2000 556 2004 ^5X536b '3(oo6ob b6b35x58 '0*3300 3o6o737)06657j(^ob b68!i6!773o636B6 b68606o)65ix '5O68363o 000656600360b 006563*306(0835x5076 ^05665585535, II7-3 87)65x506 83-2 37)635ob (50) b6037)8335i: »1)3 (^68366), 5 b63B3 "v"606655506311, 06o7835xx 'O)6565 O707bo b6b68606oo5X5O)b 5*6063555056. 08633 330600050*80, 302-3 B7)b5i5ob 66037)8335151)3 (6336360b 8o33Bob 087)515366) 6558067)5x50 42 b638o5566 25 66b6B606(O5i50ob 56506336. 73030000 83503, 3 388 156383 65508066 0065685036006015 600( 00(5655 568003363606 87)65x^000, ' 335035650 4 204 Bo)635x >ob 56b686o6o)5x536oo). 8(0630600668 \7'60^6555o66 00060 56556\73335o55_>36ob 330I70050360, 066(3 36O)0 56636655360(0, 6506b(57)f^3^6 113800(0 655607157)5x50 8336601)83606 37; 3dÔ71 ''' *' ' ^*' 8(y)6306(o668 61)333 8o7)070(06 bb36 b63B3361)3, 0^0)35x536*803 8006556 3(05xi '03oo!i 0003030636011 60686(5367)5x1 0

134

Page 18: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

6006515558* '' '" "30506 b6b35xi,>8^oo3(oli Ii6b68606oo5i5oo36ob6(03ob 86000 ^606555366, 30063363006 83-3 87)65x5017 06530630635630007, 37)55650 Boo33o6oo6ob 03, 35*^^ 56800.

4. bù bôdô(^œ^>fo b i ^ ^ 6 /7jf3.>

6. b6b6860600515oob 8030^ 8003387)5x50 b638ob 85303367)5X53636ob '33036b366

102. b6b686060051500 083000636b, OoooB 37)55655 8oo33o6o')6ob (y)6oo66l)3 80(7)00)366 56836(6367)5x1'o 7)6506 0300b 85303367)51536360(0 (oV). mutatis mutandis, j^'.^ùbo QDc68.)>f)oob \7o6ùùç^8fOQ^^ 1993 ^5î^'ob 22 b335386o6ob 5'^^'-'^'v'88BÔ"f^B^^' ^ 3 ^ * * . ^^269, 53. 17-18, 37)6350 30). ^^ÔB'^GB^Tl^'B^B^"^ '33660366365x5650, b6li68606o)5X5O7 3^606 B530336ob 11(5665560656 ,,500603067)5x50 3^306 B055B6", (07)836, 06005031163 8oo35x;'3536o 8(05x11066650 66 56 'o5i50060603 BdG83^ 63515067)0351536011 07)0^06500330011 '; )6o655x536*80, 0600500063, 86565xi 'oo)65o, b6365o8o6oo36*3o 8307030 300^360 606066 635x5ob7)035x5360b 30065*^005150b d88'3 (0600500063 8(03387)5x5 li6383'3o), b3060001)7)5x5650 505366 3o63l77)B»J33ooli b63ooobo, oB6bo)65 506363*300^3600), 06008 5561)06636360 6506Bo65b b^07(^35o 506363360I1 500600b B065056. 6I130) 7)3300633336*80, B530336ob 53*^^oof* b6b35i58^00300 b35xi_'ob7)035i536ob 000656600366 33011(^3660) 506 8600 3365x53660) ^606800650506(06 5068638630o«g05x53635x50 506 556865^3063635x50 56686065366 (ob. bô^ySôSo ao'yC^JQmoh foGàôi^^dçoQ^ [GC], N^ 21986/93, 37)635*^ 100, 6506Bo66ob 7)735i53636ob 3306003735x50 b6b68606o75X5O7 2000-VII). 6113070 56586065360b 6068007)505365x1 006011 '33Bo)b3336'3o, b6b686060051500b '337)85x506 566330000b (^3b3o750365o 8b6o6ob6oo3ob 6o66b6bo68oo35o7 506I13366 (ob. (V(6JÔBO afjcojjœob foGôop^Sço^Q, M25656/94, § 274, 2002 ^5i5ob 18 036060).

103. 8003387)515 66383*30, b6b6B606oo5i5Oo8, oBob6oo3ob, 06008 '836036bo7b 56683b655365i5ob b6f)O306ob b638ob 5606380736660, 5560^55333360b b6bo60)05066 568008500560^3, 8o)63o6oo66b 8oobo7boo36 306080665157)060 5680080360b b63Bob, 330680050, b63B3 M68241-ob 36b65X536ob 6b5ï536ob Bobo73ob 80^0050366. 800630600668, bobb5i5ob b686o6oo5xoob b63(^o733lio7 30O5o33bob I6I-3 87)650*173 506306506006000, 7)60^0 5667)366506 b6b686060)515o)b Booooboo36o5X5o 550^37)83553606 80^0050366113. 80063060)668 6!i333 b638o!i 6(^bo)65 5563637I00636000 606 ^6006555066 6066660060 80800605x536.

104. b6li6B606o75i5O78 565obo5i56 80063060060I1 B0306 8000000367)5150 bobb5X5ob b686o6oo5X[ ob b63o6oo33boo 30^5533^*^^ ^^^"3 87)b5X5o 556 5680080360b 86b65i536ob b6b686(^oo5X5ooboo3ob 5O6b7)0^3ob b630oobo b6568o7Bo36oo b35xi ob7)035x5360b 55ob30633Oob 333*^ S ' Ô*'' 8' - " ^ •^^333 C?' *-'>S55o56, o6oo3 b63Bob B6b65i536ob 5o6b7)0636 606 '8308515366 r76oo)365i507b 6063 568ooBo36ob b o70 765§ ^60^86o6oo3obo73ob b35i5ob 7l38'35x535x1 650 506 6(^3 3o6oo33bob Bb6o6336ob 730351536360b 65 o6530^3b36ob 5560655333650. 800630600668 60 566860656, 066 03000 8000 03636(0556 b6l)065oo 56Boo8o36obo73ob, 65 Pi606007)5x1 0 3oo636oboo3o!), 8ooo7bo73605x50 550^37)836(5630011 b6b68606o75X50ob6O73ob 5O6b7)0636. 8600 6I1333 606 807)30600 506865^3063635x50 66656 o8ob6, 077) 0665008 606 8o6\700503b b6b6B6o6o)5xi »(ob ob '33b666Bobo 55003738365360 556 0603000686306, 0600B51536I563 obobo 6*83606655 0351507650636.

105. 65550*357)5x5 560638003636*30 666686060)5x500 8oop7633b,' o ooB '837385x506 506b336ob 563300366 8o763(^oo6ob 3^3^*^^"^*^^ S56 6I1333 '837)85x506 5660605x5006 b638ob 5606380036360 566836650365x^.06 6(657)836563006 86665x1:36710 6o6b367)5i 'o 35!15B3B^ÔB^"^ ^ 7171* 33 *" 3' 807)635063650 oBob6, ( 078 566836650365ix,'ob 80306 'v'* o655536o5x: >o 550037)83656306 56o6333';')5x;» 0363036b 567)063333515650 500336b. b6b686o6(y)5x;.oo 6b333 8b350335n.o)66*8o Boo5536b 2005 ^5i5.ob 30 5(O386306b 60360 60)350006(05006 5x536066306 0660(06735150 b6b68606oo5i5oob 3oobB366l73 5656o5x '7)5xi.' 80766338366.

135

Page 19: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

6. 1998 ^5x506 19 b33ôB^^**'"^ '838oobg336bo765 55 6363*300*) 36735x50 5680080360b •^f^'^BT^adô'a*^^^^^

106. 0663 '333b366 568008036011 3733dô7]^ ' ' ^*" 661)686060051507 B6355335X! »(o66'3o 05536b 8311683 8b60 ')oi) 30^o5o36b 067)b3o)ob bol)b5i5ob b6B606(O5ix 'ob 116563008036(0 bob53Boii *33b6b36 506 8(7)63060)60!) b6\7o6665iiB5535(o 60657)336563066. 017)336 b6b686o6o)5X5oob 365x555367)5x5366 6O6 6o6ob 11005655650 bob(53Bob 553733dÔB**'' ^ '330)6b366. oli 37)0665055366b 566866305x53611 3076306357)5x5 Tj' ^dÔB^ ' 'B' f**"' 506650506006 03(0 (07) 6006 566836650365x506 80306 56!i66o3o6367)5xx,'o 56800803606 8635XX,'35150066 606630)3357)060 30'763363oob 83-3 87)b5i5ob 736065515367)0.

/. bù'jpi^jDfi^Hnc^iV 3r6o6o(jo,)j6o

107. b61)686060051500 oB3O70636b, 0600B 3oo6335x;;> 0605*30, 8003337)5150 5680030360b 556b33536o!i 6o6606b36o766 606 60*36636 Bob 6( 630333573f * '" -*- 56800B03606 3651550367)515366 6o6ob „6066 '8350350, 6O668350 b6'37)65xi;>366" (ob. 3r7p:^ poô (v^(6o u^fpcoff^b^do Qôj(6(r}m>6^?>'^jpî^>o bàdQ<Qcob ^o6ù^s^>8^jQ, N246477/99, § 71, 6556B06606 7)*Q5ï '36360b 33o6o737)5!!5o b6b6360^o)5X5oo 2002-11). 606 606ob b6365i55O367)5X5(0, 06008 3335xi;'6 568(080366 0300b ^606865367)5x1*0 506 38o)b33005O3b 8o)b60^635X5ob 80306 80035x535360b 655^3(^6b; 0073B36 30606303*80,06 7)6556 03006 663806 71' dÔB^*^^^ 55650536067)66060650 506 007) 800)0(036360 556506657)0655366, 713385x500b 36b73bob853635X5o 3006360b o55365o«go3or6366 506 55665^6 (ob. mutatis mutandis, dà^8'^(^ jc>où œ''jr6/]uayob {7o6<^i)>^B^jQ, Ne22535/93, § 124, 650680660b 7)735i53636ob 33060037)5150 b6b68606o75ï5o) 2000-III).

108. 6B5035650, 63060071)7)5x .0 35303366 37)55650 8oo33o6o)66bo)66 506363*300636000 836(3(^655 7)6506 03636 5680780367)5150, 0663 607I6636, 06008 635x5067)035x11366 8'35oBo3655 7)6506 35505x50065036 oBob 556555356b, 0773 066 Bo)b556 556 606 736556 556330655607I1 b^(^603 556 6o66byo7o6655 563300367)515 556b33636!i 6063 5680780360b 55667)o636boo66 506363*30063600) 556 6063 (^00500(^3 86(oo 56556^33355^^-3606 b6«37)fl335i5b (ob. ùb/jSo^jo ^r,^ ^KlJ^^ è^^^o^ùt^ijœob foGààçnS^D^, 1998 'p5i5ob 28 o)35o7B6(^ob 565Ï:'6Ç3335O5X5366, .^G^ùf^n'BQèo 1998-Vni, 37)6350 103 et. seq). 3600 7)6506 80050006 3335x56 7)36685153635x50 507603067)5x50 I700B6, ( 008 5D603365 '838006333660)65 5063637100^367]5150 85303367)5x1:36360, 8600 '8000^06, inter alia, 0030078605x5335x50 8o7'ç8ob 6336366, b6b6860 005X1107 B5303367)5i5'3636o, 506 6.'3. (ob. mutatis mutandis, bà^^dùGo œ^i^^j^œob p(9(566j;o( XP(7c3, *b38oooo 65560*35735150, 373635" 1^6, 6506B06606 73735^5363606 3306(037)5x50 b6b6860^o75i5oo 2000-VlI; (^^'^8c6oj'j^>^j œ'^jc^Jijœob foBùc^^id^Q^ [GC] N523763/94, 6556806606 7171 KL'8 3 * * 33 60037)5150 666686( 005x00) 1999-lV, 37)635^^ etseq.\ Q'^^'o œ^jro^j^'jœob ^OSÙ^^^S^^Q, N?22676/93, 37)6350 89, 2000 Vsi *ob 14 55333863060). 568o)8o36ob 63606803060 553-33350, 0600835x503 3^3333*3 6336366 80b 7l3b635xo365x1 (06611,50665050600b 1)066o!i 563073^3330 301731)360 65 807665506006 3667)bol 1853635x *0 3006360I1 050365003036306, 65560*367)5x5 11565506065b o6ob3oli

dBB* ^^33^3^^-

109. 7)0)06(0 835"G' 5680780366 Bo1)668o86o6oo';]5Xi 'o 736556 0300b 30063363006 83-2 506 B3-3 37)b5X536ob !56037)8335xi;>1)3 566605157)515 1)638336*30. 03, b65D63 00*303065x57)0^0 568(080360!) 303335''('1^^*^*^^^ b630(obo 05556, b6b6B606(05X5oo b'3oo665o 60361136506, 06685036655 6^06603655 506 71366668017 5506006 B076506 06365006366 66603060b 8055360!) '8385035 (06. fi^>ô?>0(^<.)> 0(^ô^>oob pV7( 66jc o ^ ^ [GC] 1^^26772/95, 37)635'^ ^^^ ^1 seq., 6556806606 7)*35X5366(06 330 073735x50 li6b68606o)5X5O7 2000-IV). Bli35533515006671o 036366 8055367)5150 56800B03606 556^33606 5506(0, 566(36650363606 56330)36ob6b 55^630)36366 (06. (^()8'^jro(^oho œyf^J^'jœob ^of}<\->^)8^^i^, N523531/ 94, 37<)63(5o 89, 6506806606 7)^)5153660)6 33060037)5x1 )0 li6b6B6o6o)5i50o 2000-VI 556 (^UJoBo (r)\^](n^jl](r)ob poj .vxç fVj r ^ j, 1998 ^5ii .oli 9 03606015 56556Ç'3335o5XX.'366, .^6^)Ù(^O'8/J?>O 1998-IV,

136

Page 20: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

373635^ 67) 55* ' 0)0^33^ ''"^^" 5'-' 9* ' 3o36ob 36556 (ob. o6^jp^>ojù(^f7 0(^ô^oob ^oBàù^tS^u^,

^01143/96, 37)6350 37, 2001 '?5il>ob 18 (03507B63060).

110. 5066005x1 00b, l56b6B606(y)5xi oo 083000636b, o8o!i6073ob, o (oB 568(080366 8O(OO(T)367)5XI^ GVl^*^^

Boo330o(o66bo766 55636371006360(0 03(06 3*?i33ô7l^"' * ^ 71 '* ^ 03(011 55680)7330553635x1 0 (ob.

fOQ'^jrrfo m'^c^J/jœob ^'o6àù^8^[f^, [GC] M'21954/93, 650680660b "303^5366076 33060037)5x50

!i6b686060)51500 1999-III, 37)6350 91-92; ob. 611333 ^D^^OÔ 0^^^ ^7)3^^0^*^ cry^jCnJQmob fo^àùf^^SçoQ-^^

N"40154/98, 37)6350 37, 2004 'v5^,'ob 20 o35X5obo). 7)3b666Bob655i, 5680780366!) 635x *06

5563(07)3055365xi '0o66, o6o7503b63 5680080366b 656063636 08633 b68860600335x500b, 65 b333oob

(0666B'8ooo785i536o, 060085X536I163 60665x5655 35036600 37355655 80033060066 (ob. Q^^^jjo oo'^cojjœob

foG,^ù^^8^^jQ, 1998 'sxx -ob 27 o35i^.oboli 56556^333(5o5Xi,'366, 6^ ,>o^(9Îyj3(? 1998-rV, 37)635^ ^0~

82). 56B00803606 5068007)3050365x5(066 568000665366 6066 86o65o'> 0306600307)55^ 556

0665057)3007665x57)06 363*8006*30, 60668350 3o6635*^J7)C5 C ' t B^ B (* '- 36565x500)650, jf^QO

(n^jt^^j^œob ^oS^)ù^i8^jQ, 1998 ^51506 28 o35xx.'obo!5 56556^33350515366, ùSQàc6o7]j6o 1998-IV,

' Tl dÔ*^ 83-84, 665063 665^6(600 3060037306(0060 0B036506, o))6355633ob 865xi 36ob6 556 PKK-b

'3356336ob6b 5005(0666 bo335oo5i5ob V363(5l S56 5680066(56 5068007)3050365150060b 6635x5360066,

06005031)63 30050.066655 556330650600 '33Boob333671o 6606007)5x50 ^655O606B36ob 80300 8o'çoo50367)5X5

0503000686306b).

2. 8VI(JQ8^^Ç^ bù^j8D'do Ù8 Mo6(jo3j?)ob (^à8(vijjBj6ô

111. 3006335x50, 606 '8308515366 oo)336b, 06008 b35x5ob7)035x5366 63 b63B3'3o 66bo75i57)57)o665o

36bo7)o6o 0300. 86565x500)650, 568008803635x1^86 5063oo)b6 5i535o5b3ob 3005x50300b

5663070305x1^360b 07030306360, ^ 3 3 506 N09 b66365oB3O)o30)36oli 33o6boo565xi o 506 36303653^0,

8005500 56683b655365ï5ob 850500860630060b b6835oo3o5(o 6666^3000 506 8obo 836565157)060 55

03bo3oo5i500507)060 85O5(o360^3O)6ob b6663606(051500 *838o7^336ob 66560 )0*30 556 6.71. 007383

568(0803606 86b65i536ob 7330055x50060b 7l38o7b3336*3o b6!)636o6oo5xi_>oob6oo3o!i '837)85153635x1.*

7l36036boob b6568o78o36o7 83366o1)B36ob '33bo67)5X536ob b606obbo, 0063 563000665366 086*80,

007) o^oo5oob 506 06075(006 0366 '83506003367)5x50 8530336735x536360, 066 30oob336o 55673b36

5680088036351586 33^*^8^03^^'^ ^"^ 8oo^8336b, 06685536655 byooo665o 0366 5655656605x1 .0 36ooo

36b7)b36o b6563o)8o36oo 3o6(033bob '835035650 '33386o5xi,> i5''^37l8355'3o 506 6.'3.

112. 8300063, 66b68606oo5i5O7b b35X5oo 60^b367)5X5o 86b6^36o , 330 )80055, 568o)88o365xoob

56506^333505x5366 b63Bob^60^8oo36ob '33Ç3335ob o)6oo66l)3 560)35X5b b5oob ^o66b^606o,

00030(3065x57)060 56800803606 50( oob 556*83367)5x1 360*3353^.07365 5650635500836b. 86565x1^00)650,

606 6656, 0300 007) 6(^6 835035x50066 5063505066(0 56633b650365x;iob ^6336ob6 506 71350350b

8000000367)5x50 5606380036360. Y}* dÔ"' < * B 6b30)o 80366 66560^367)5x50 0300 556 8ô3*^GB^73^B^*^^

86o'33635X5(0365o 66^05x50 (566836650365x5011 80306 556^30605x50 6550606366) 66300360 0300,

8boo5xi)oo5o 2005 ^5xi ob 30 6o)386o6ob Ii6b686o6o)5i5oob 56506^'3335o5ï5366'3o 0300 666636360.

563(o38o3635i5b 60^ 713 '* * B ^ B* ^"^ ^633oo)b6 ob 65568066360, 3063 56683b6503635i5O766

306(0655 0830003360)556 ^o56b^6(^o 506363360b b6366'8o 1998 ^51506 10-19 b33(5386306b 556

30I163 '833851500 .^3*^^^^^^*^ 1)6^006(0 0603000^86306 566B(3b65o3651506 3GBno^^ '33b6b36

0030078335x535x50760b B350351X.00668503; 6b333 6O0 665b, 506300066 007) 6066 06005501183

568008803635x1^86 5668366503635x50766 30600650 365i5656'3o 8307030 ,,3".

113. 836683, 7)6806630 b6568oo8o36oo b6'87)65i5366- b6386075o 55653066367)50^650 0366

5680033636735Xx''o. 86565x000)650, b6b6360^0)5x507 b6B35oo3o5oo '83300^3366 (O6O605550366 1998

^5X5ob 26 0)35*^3606000, 0663 8o(X)000367)5x1 0 37)55650 807330600605566 b7)0) 33oo66'b3. B3506.

56683b650365x50b B0306 (37355655 8oo3306o766'3o 3^^38056605150 000303063606 6807360066

'838(ob33305066 86005x50050 o)06o ^51506 '8385535 66(5606556. 635250366(506 553S56 86005x50050

137 ■

6

6

>06

Page 21: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

2001 ^3S^^ 5O6030O7b6, boo5xi oo N"03 b663655B307O)0'7li 33080 „8" 60^ 5563ooob7)5i56 2001

^5x568503, 8o7)b35063655 o8ob6, 0600B ob 0300 3000335x50 800^830065660, 3063 5668366553635x50

56b6 '338o)b333ob '8385535. 5680088036351586 N239 b663655830703cob 3306110)665x50 506 363036(5360

2000 ^5x506 06630668503 606 50630(066 („6"-66 506 3308 „3"-6 5606556, 0600835150)6 55630006363

B006506 3006335156550 568(0803606 500600!i). 506600515006, 565B3V)'650365xi .ob 03bo3o65*^0735x50

'83300^3366 566600063035x5556 36005x1 (050 2001 VB^ ^ ' J 307)635563650 08066, o6oo3 3obo 836565x57)060

850500860630066 b35xi ob7)035x >36ob 80306 0300 5606(07)51536735x50, 0^(0500063 oo3ooo83350)35X 'oo6ob

8(35535x50760b 56686065366 506 060050006(3 b63Bo!i^6o68oo36ob '33^3335ob 66037)8335x50.

114. 66b68606005x50) 6b333 65560*35636, (^008 56506^3335051536360 6638ob^6(^8(036ob

5656b5X536ob oo60o66l)3 800503600506 '3385050080 556 8350 736353*^*^^ 5680080360b 8o1)5ooo.

007)836 3I1 800000036360 568o788o365x[>36ob 8o3(^ y^8B^^3*^^ *^ 6067)5x1 »503607556. 685036650,

b638ob^6(^8o736ob '83^3335^^ '33b6b36 1999 ^5i5ob 25 003630 35x1 ob 56556^333505x5366

08633 b6037)835X536ooo 0307 5683606367)5x50, 0600063 1998 5xi ob 21 55ad836o6ob 56556^333505x5366.

2000 V5X5ob 24 oo363(^35X5ob 56556V333'ôf>K?B^*^ o)ooo38ob 075O3657)( 35303367)5X53636b6 556

8b5^^35x000636b 37371853607506. 2000 ^5x568503, b6563 b63B3 bb36 568078803635x5b 6(^ Ô' fÇBG'' '

5680080366 606 ^6b7)5i56 ^o5 506 6b65X5o 6065738365360 506 0603070686306 60^ 5663605x56

56800880365x506 56556^333505x5366*30. 685036650, 830060^660 550 (0 5060360656. b6b68606005x500b

'^B^B^Tlff^B^"^' '^366, 0600500063 8o7b65x5005D535i5o 0300, 5630080360b ^6(^865366173 6356507)0^0

BTlBdôf 0307606.

115. B307oob3, b6668606005x500 6555o'3663b, o6oo3 6'836o66 363*80(^0 6(^b36o76506 56800803661)3

36b73bob85363515 3oo636b6 556 8000000367)5x5 37355655 Boo33060066'3o 80 )66^05x53 3006366 'Booooob.

b6b6B60^005x500 63b65036b, ( 008 '338o)b333ob 55553b 56583b650365i5ob 5063ooob36 80850066-

063006556 5o;;)5o 6003500(^005006 5X536066306 06600)606 3075x50300b 5663070305x5366*30. 55630O)b36

5060^300 3075x50300b 807636O60 568o78Bo3?)5x^ob, '3bb 655505x5006(^030 566300030515360b '^(QC^cohoh

8o7655505X5ob6 506 3o6oo37)o6657)06ôb 00060 635x1 885536635x50 3oo6ob, 6oo5(Of6o75ob3ob 3' Pi ' 3*^^

3o60037)0600( ob6 556 063500767)5x50 3o60037)06000606 800650505x506, „8o6"-b 0066506b^0^36000. 635150-

366506 8063503000, 807)635563650 oBob6, 0 008 ,,806" 606 3b^(^36o7506-56583b650365X5ob ^6B366b,

86b 60 3300606 06363306 56683665036515ob b66o3606l73 37)55655 80033060066boo65 506363*300^36000.

7)030600 83503, f6o7553b63 56583b6503635X5B6 7)6060 5666366556 „8b"-b 3335i535i5oo6ob 65506O0366I73,

„3o6"-B ob b6^68365X565o ob33 3oo5X503035xi 36b 56506b36. 7)030600 83503, 807)635563650 o8ob6,

0 008 3607605x50 0300 1998 ^5X5ob 19 b335B9^<^07b 5563oo7b36'3o „8(*7"-b 80066^05x530060b

036350^^ 556 37350650 8oo3o6oo6ob 7l3b6636 b6r7O3606l73 06365006360b 6o66(^b36o76ob '33b6b36,

156383 563oo8o36ob6oo3ob 56506b33b 5og6o 60035(006005006 5i536o5b3ob o^6ooo5ob 3(^0037)066-

57)06oli b68b6b7)(^b, 0600835x503 3o(^5063oo6 33333553660636(0506 0^3500767)5150 3060037)0^00060b

Ii681i6b7){^b, b65063 „3(^"-b 33636 860*3363515003650 00656850360066. 7I3B5035 5X[*36'3o, 8073635063650

b63Bob 8066365 .5^306 556b7)o63ob6 556 5666651536066, 66383 56666605x533515650 B6063 08633

( 600067)5150 3o^oo37)(^657){^o6 b68b6b7)06b 33006506. 86075150050 2004 VB^?-^-. ' d^B ■ Ô' ' BG'

Bb563bo 850*33535x1^0060b b6568o78o36oo b638336ob 566860515335x5 5533606568365b, 077)836 ob

86063 08633 0^80"*^^"^ 3o6oo37)(^657]f^ob O7)o6ob5oo330ob 338*^ 0830703.3600556.

116. 5630080360b 8b35i5351500605065 6b333 f7666, 06008 3060737)06657)0^6 8 050060050 006668*806078-

5x5006506 5X536o5b3ob o66ooo5ob 3oo5X50306b{066. 0663335*''^'^ î.f^"-6, 06008351503 5668366-

5036351586 630003600 0600500063 30600-3(^000 8060 8Ç'6B36355;»o 1998 ^BSil^ ' JN'^BB'^^'^ 80)^83

„3"-6 800366. „oo''-B 3o^oo37)0^657](^ob b68b6b7)06b 6360766, o6o)8 06 „3"-6 800)00036735x5

8ob6860^o7l)3 3836506, 8650668 330^ 7I3B5X500 Bobo 56b36. 800530663600), „3*'-8 3ob36 r7335366,

06008 3005x^.03005066 6063 30 7335506 30683I1 Bobo b665X5'3o 8006667)5x^366. 685036655,

070303065x57)060 56B00803606 36o'33635X5(0366o 66605^^0 665536 00060 807636060 3^380566051505065

3o6o)-30^oob.

138

Page 22: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

117. b6b6B6o6o75i5oo 65560*3663!) 3o6oo37)06657)o6oli l)6Bb6b7)o6o!i 860605066 606633000 55; ?)' f^3387)S7?off5' C?' TI - ^TITI BK;**^ Bo5050)B6b 35303367)sx53636ob '335o6oo336ob6 556 7)3036b36ob

.006O066I73. b638ob co6b7)063ob 3006335x50 56556^333505x^366, 060)835x1 03 0060605550366 1998 \?5Xi,>ob 21 553338606000, 800600)655650 3037)8636(0506 3o)5o^03oob 08 00030306360b 633636366, 060035x1 *3603 66060)7)5x560 033636 1998 \J*5xi ob 19 553338630^)b 56683b650365xi^ob 5563007636*30 506 6B5036650, 606 '33085x5366 obobo 8073330 8(03635x1 800^8336650 6600036515005. 56800880363^586, 68633'500600!), 3b350335i5oo66'3o 606 B005500 635xi '03655o')65 30600650 365156567I0 B300030 „6"-b 5663665036360. 563008803635x586 „6"-b 633636360 7')60 )3oo, 306605066 86b 606 330)6556 b333O65x;,i7)0 7o b6835oo3o5o) 3075066 506 3306 5656bb36336506 35i533ô^''''^*'*8""^ 8055367)515 506B^3o6oo66b 03665^0605066 565o3oo36o65o6ob6b 8055367)5x50 506l70663636ob6566. 08635006(07)5x1 655, 568003803635x^0 3o7)ooooo36b b65l7607 3005x503067)0 566B3b650365X5ob 3000305x1 6355 .885536635x1 1)3, (^008350^03 63b65536506, 06008 5668366503635x50 b7)b5o 30060)36366 0307. 3b 6336366 56807880365x50b B0306 '333oo)b3ob 506bBob 560^3*83 0300 305536735150 556 83503, 305536735150 0300 000750)0^3 565068^33350 85303367)5x1^366, 3o7)b3506365o oBob6, 06008 68 bo53336ob 63500060 606 0300 30600033booo665150 03b030051507500b 65 O3bo3o65^oob bç33( "o7*3o.

118. '338555073, Bo7)b3506365o oBob6, 0600B b6835503o5oo *338oo '83668 1998 ^5x^ob 26 oo35<^36306b 330^ 5566505066 Bob 37)0636173 3p!533ô*^^f?'^*^V3^*~^^'^' "^ 86063 55655536051506, 06008 566B3b6503635i5b 366173 33006506 36350b 50*35360. 568078803635x1^0 606 566B6o6563b O OO5O K '83085x53600506 3b J060515006360 03665^0605566 5650800360650666-568003^306. 1998 ^51506 19 ^BdÔB^^^^^ 606600*303065x57)060 568o78o36ob6b (ob. § 62), „<3"-8 8ob36 6336366, ooooS 56800880365153686 7)57)5153635x5333b Bobo 56536.650366 1998 ^5i5ob 80035153636*30 063500067)5x1 0 3( oo37)0^07o6ob 800650505x1^ob „3o6"-b 80066^051530066173.

119. b6b686(^o75i5oo 560^333'g5i5^o5i565o 56003367351506 56807880365x50b 1998 ^5ï5ob 21 553,)386o6ob 6656o6o*3ob 036350^^^^(^30 8660^007. 568008803635x50 63b65036506,06008 1998 515011 11 b335336306b 56583b65O3635X50 560)630b7)035x5556 506363360b 011075x56507(605065, 865(668 7)385535 ob33 8006506 8obo 556363366 06306051706 b65057)(^'3o bo8'8305oob 55606553330b 56800. 500600006 5668635x00066*30 070303065157)06650 5065566573^556, 06008 o5b3335*^^8^^'^* ) f "-6, „5"~l^i^ ^-^ "tç""^* (^*'^835X5b63, (^075000^3 800)000367)5x506, 7)6506 5063365080636066 565B3b65O3635X50 (^3o5o5l7ob b65057)(^1)3) 6656o6o'836o 0300 807500605x50 506 oB 5506006 56683b6553635x^*0 3o75xi .o3ob b35i507 08300033600556. 865(^68 80735x535360b 3b ^30066 5683070 36735x1 0 03(0 1999 y5i5ob 25 003630635x^06 b638ob '33^3335ob 56556^333505x1^366*30. b6b686o6o)5xi oob 6l)(^oo), 3b O3635o> ^568007)30503635x50 C? ' 83"<^38 ff *^^ 07365x5'3o 3(06b5O35556 000303065157)0^0 5680080360b 5x50^5037]060760b 55ob3o635oo56306b.

120. b6!i68606005x500 6b333 633355b 6330036b o8 •3635*^*8' 06008 8o7)b350ù3655 56b660306367)5x50 80035153636066, 663838 b6b6B606oo5xi 'O7 b565oo6b 606 80655^06 '830500 ^5i5ob 5658635X50766'3o-^'o66b^6o6o 5680080366 "33^3506 506 566665x5506 O7b7)oo835l73 8355^3^6 556 566653606, 06008 63 b6ob 5658635x50766*30 b6563oo8o36o) 3o600335073(^6 0300 ' 60^65x500 - 03000^865150066, 306005600I7006366500 "33503500). 666005x0000050, b6b6B606o)5i5O7 6556o'3663b, 06008 2005 ^5X5ob 30 6003860^011 56506^33350515366 305033 606 6(^ob b66oo5X500(o.

121.17380000 66800073515o5X!;*o 11306000177)5x1 0 S537383ÔB^^^^ 56800, 5666637)000636000 56800803606 5oo6(ob, b6b63606oo5xi;»O) 6505366, 06008 ob 6O6 0300 650333657)0^0 66 b63B6(oob65o 37333ÔL1^*^-li6b6B6(6o)5i507 6b333 7)6063O7O3b 8o)630^oo6ob 3(^35361)06b *3o506 66b35153^003(03606030 b6'37365X53636ob 6Boo^7)o63ob' 6o660^b36oo6ob '33b6b36 506 6556o'3663b, o6(oB 5060065536 3006335300b 83-3 87)65x1 0 Bob 3( 0033507)067)515 66^05x5710, 0600835x1»'303 8ooooo7367)5X[;jo 37)55655 807330600606 oo6oo66l)3 66(56o6367)5xi,>o 5680080366 60663O333(57]f o 65580766506.

139

Page 23: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

5- 5^^^G^^J^3^8^"^ 8o86(^oo 8000000367)5150 37)55655 8oo33(*7oo66

122. 8(y)63o6o7668 68 37)0)600) 5661^050*36 606 ^6068006555066.

2. d-:>S8(jhù^ijèj^>o

123. 566836650365x506 B530336000, 3075x503068 050 6 7*636 556 37)55650 300333(000, 0600063 5560065536 30063363006 B3-3 37)65x1 *0. B(76o 8530336360b 556b650)6b573*^36515650, 866 ^6(66505066, 650680660b 7)735i53636ob 0635000665x57)060 6(^6668(0630600607 000656601)63006 00060 635*^3*^^0^^ B0306 1999 ^35i5b 665606367)5x50 1998 Ç'5xi,*ob 1I335B36O6O1I 8oo35x:;*3636ob 6066070303065x^*7)060 56Boo8o36ob6b 8003003367)5x50 „'3"-b („Bb"-b 800)000367)5x5 8335x535150066*30 3^38056605150), „6"-li, „B"-b6 506 „3"-b (N239 b66365oB30oo30771o 5668366503635150765 3(000655 365X5656'3o 8300030) I7330C60 6336363606 6666^7306360 ('335^63367]5x 'o I7380007 ,,736353^"^^" 66Ço5X5'3o). '33B5035 5663366503635x50 307)000(036506, 060)8 37)55650 80033060060b '3635*''^'^^ 5563637)006367)5x50 56Bo)Bo36ob6b, 3oo5xi^o3oob (0030306360b 80306 5633(0367)5x50 5663665536360, 0300 60065x1 075037)060 506 666b63506 635X5ob7)035xi 36ob6565 8o55367)5x * 800351535360I1 56(6007)5x5367)5x5 3306bo6b. Bobo 8o7b6l7063636ob 506b636365D, 5668366503635x586 (00303065x573060 56800803606 b63Bob 861165x1^3605066 7)6Bo663 55('^37)8355li3 8o73(y7oco6, 8650668 8600I73 86b 68j 6B65o 6f6 ^3(06506 506*83366.

124. 56683665036351586 50668656, 06008 66333 6o6b36oo65D6 37)55655 Boo33o6(o6ob 55686506b57)-063635x1 0 6(^6bÇ'(oo^o 853*^GB^c]ff?3*^B ' - BB*^*^^* ' '^^^ 56663b65D6, 0607B 556365080^3663503, Bobo 03011037)060 506 836565x57)060 350500B60630066 6oo(6B65X57)o6o 030) 86b 606 3300606 «3bo3oo5x500507)000 3oo'35i505xi »o766 66 3060765153B360, 066663 '83385x1 00 B060 B033656 003000-9J3K:?8K1'OO6O6 835535150)668503. 66333 606 65^350*363607556 37)55655 8073306(0606 300630^357)5x50 60*36360. I165I7607 3005150306*30 87)'36076o6 506^336ob6b, 865 56O6066 o3bo3<o5X5O75o7)0oo '33800^8366, 060083515B63 050 5O66b6bo6006, 0600500063 B505O66500 506 836565X1 7)06655 36(65 3555008606300667)0 8300030. 0773836 5563633605066 06635036083 50553*30 ob 5O60765b85O6, 355060636066 830063^515073650 50050756b 8335x535x50066 506 567336507)06366, b6*3o535i5o 5O656'367)5i50, 0^00835x503 36b 60 667)503606 (0663 660035x1 0 566506 8005306536007, o6o7553b63 „8l5" 7)363635150 5566007)6556 b6b5X5'3o), 060b "838503563 07630b 800335x56 b36506. •

125. 733B5035, 56583b650365xi,^o!i 80306 56558003387)5150 1998 5XX*oli 10-19 b33ô836o6ob 80035x536360 8oo36b7)b3 3o)63o6o766b 606 567)3o6(o53b53^o6. 80)630600668 3306 ^6(^6555066 bobb5xi>o!) b6-36(6075x006 56Bo7Bo36ob 36b65X536o, 0^63 5063b86o636oo506 b6b68606{O5X5(ob !i633ob 560638003636*30 560633336*80. bobb5X5ob b6860^075150b b63o6o733boo 30O5O33bob I6I-3 87)b5X5ob 06530^-^06356306 800630^00668 60066^*0006650 566330)6 506 7)030600 83503 , 30'i63363oob 34-3 87)b5i5ob6 556 38-3 87)b5X5ob 1-5x50 37)535f'*^> P?^^J*^^^^8^7]^* 365xi.'50367)5xx.»366lio766 7)37)6666800 0300.

126. 635x50366586 b6b6B606o75x;*o)!i 373( 65555366 611333 B0633060) Bobo 506363360b, 365o8o6oo6ob6 506 50630oob3ob 560633003636b, 0 763 Bobo '836355735x *3600) 66*836066336556 o65Do<33o6~355'35ii'o^666 6o)06865i57)06o 306003350730606 80860607, 06o75O3b63 56(0365x^*ob^o6367)5x; >o 736506 03(06 506B3630 833660I78360 (066685036(06011 6(006(0(5655 568003363606 ^06665585035, 060)500060366 8obo ' BB^B^ ' ' ÏN 80*^^*7]*^*^ B6\)'30^6, 650310365113 b35i5Bob6Ç'35oooBoo66 506 6. 71

3. bôb^>8^^(n(r)^cob ojyg'.^/jjt^.s

127. !i6b68606(o5i5O)8 80^636515 *338oob3336*3o 5608307(66, 06008 b35X5ob7)0351x *366 365x555367)5x1 06 5060336b 556363367)5x50 3oo6o!i 0301)0373060 b35X5'337)b365X5oo66. 06o75O3b63 30060036366 5563633-

140

Page 24: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

673fi *o6 5^658o6oo35i50)6ob 5o7o6B65xx'7")0 o 850500860630)600) 556 560763ob73035i536ob6b 650807-66655366 5061106636360, 66635x1*8\700307b 330boo366 3651550367)515366 ^606800650506006 5061)066363606 5680)8^3330 8o1)3l7ob 556865 ,3063635x50 6bb56 (ob. (^oèoWo .\']b(^(6oob ^oB.^ù^i8^QQ, 1995 ^51506 4 55333B6o6ob 56556^^333505x1^*366, b306o6 6, ^036 , 37)635^^ 34; ob. 66333 mutatis mutandis, bù^'8ùSo œ'^jco^jijmob ^of>^^à^^8ft)^^ [GC], N^21986/93, 373635" ^^^J 65068o65o6 7)035x1 3636015 3306073735150 b6b686(6o)5i50o 2000-VII). bb36 '338o)b3336*3o \768360b6 (J773 37350650 Boo33o6o76ob 73635"^ 8o)b6o6635xi 'oli 1)61160665365150750 56556^350366 556 b63ooobo 6550806366 3005335300b 83-3 87)b5X5ob !>6037)8335i5l)3.

128. b6b686o6o75X50o 65050*86636, 06008 B66063360 606 556300636 08 ^635^^3' ^ ^ 3 5668366503635x1^86 566036506 630^0001)7)5x50 5561)06636360 30)5x503006 56630003051x *3606 03^65^0605066 565oBo7b-5o78ob6b, (6650566 3b 866 {030(0006 66050066. 017)836 o86!)(065 5563637)006360(0, 007) 066B B0033666 5663366503635x^*0 oo3oo)3335xi>35Xi:( 6ob 835535x007668503, 8b6o6336b 565bb363367)5X5o 3306bo6 33' ' SÇ'-" *"- ^8^**^^*'y7JS^8 ' 8006633556, 06008 1998 ^51506 19 b335336o6oli 50630oob36 36607603(60 0300 506 5668366503635x50 (y73ooo8335xi 35x50760b 835035x1100668503 300065086 03bo3o75ii »00507)0686 306006515383686 80033666. 5668366503635x1^0 6(6 50630066686 68 6l)(6b. 866 56663b6506, 06008 06305036(568553 86!i 606 568o77)b6563b 836565x573060 6715x1 05x50060b 0660B3 6o*365o 556 866 0)6306 800335156 3boo5i5075o 0805008 56556^33056, 0600B 3355606 567)851500 \i*6B366!i 556 117)06506 5''^^5^3^^ 556bo67)515366.

129. b6b6B6o6oo5x500, 68 37)0)boo), 5660605x1'63b, 0607B 56BooBo36ob 3335x56 35' ' ' B ?) S33b65O3635X50 ^6(6300650536506 006630850330^7)515 506 5535*^^7)*^ 655^30066, 0073 306 6^686 506 060050)00. 2001 ^5i5ob 27 B6o65b 3b 73635*^ 7)0506 b6b686060051500863 65560*866. 566836650365150b 800)00036360 566836(^6 „6"-b 506 5668366503651501) 553500b 6336366863, 0^0085x1,'36863 56663b6503b, o ooB B600 50^066636 35i5335'^*^^'^^VB^^^'"^ 56583b650365x50b 37)o636b6 556 0763I73. 1166365533000300b bb36 .^6303653636 „3"-3 506 „B"-B 6b333 55* ' ' ^Ô73f B^ ' '^^^ (!)^^93b6503635xi,ib 37)(^36o 50617066367)5150 33006506. 5066075x500b, 1998 ^5X5ob 26 oo35f^36o6ob b6b68606oo5i5O7 6556o6o*3ob 306)3503000, 56683b6503635xi *6 33006506 363606 60*36360 366173, 506I7065366, 06008351503 00606655 ^30333^^3^^ 56583b650365X5ob 80306 565580)3387)515 8073^^*36361)3. „ç3''-8 80636 6336366, 0 008 3oo5i50306'8o 307035ob6b 36b 556387)306636 0B633 5*^-^"^ ^683600), 0663 655^3006 5668366503635x586. '3385035 865 0633 8ob36 6336366, o ooB b6365o3o6oo'3o, 86b b6b3*3o 7)06536850635 5D6 387)30^3^0^5:5635 567)36507)0636000 506 35i533ô*^* ' <^B"*^ ^6836000 (ob. § 58). Bo)35X53b6o65o 5063oo6ob3oo636ob 500600b, „<3"-B 56683b655365x1^ob 3ob3o6l73 5565x57)065^36360 506066b6.

130. 8300063 86(^03, 56683b65o365X1^ob 1998 Ç5i5ob 26 (o35^36o6ob b6b68600075x507 1163350030507 '83800^3366 6o66033( ob 686006b bb36 b6bob 5561)0663636173, 03665 0605566 565o8oo36o65o6ob6b 8055367)5150 5061)0663636015 5606506. boo5X500 N03 506 Wh9 b663655By00030036*80 56583b650365X5ob 8373( 66515 33o>836b 506 3307636b 606 6557)5o7)66300 35xi 335^ ' *^*^3*^ ^ 80306 5565*^88^7]^" 60*36360. b66365o83ooo30ob 06685036083 3630365B6 63363667)0 66333 6556o'356, o ooB 86O) 60^ '337)86633060) 566836650365x506 37)0^36'l)3 506 o)63l)3 606656oo6o 5568Ç3060066, (07)836 5668366503635x586 6b6366, o6o)B 050 3515335^*'^'^'^'^B^^'' "8*^ 66^68360.

131. 685036650, 8boo5X5oo5o b6b686(oo)5xi'oob b35X50) 6( b367)5xi o \/o56b656800803600 86665x1^3605066 8635x506 ,,50060306735x1 0 3^306 805586*' 556505065536,066 8oob506 bo66850305x1^3*80 5x1^360563011 o66ooo5ob 3005X50300I5 565yoo'305i536671o 1998 ^5x506 19 b335B86306b. 0B633 55( oob, b6! 168606005x1 07 6555o71563!i, 06008 8060 7)7)66o6oo66 5066505050015, 007) 066 8006506 63 808606007)51536000, 56800B-55056063006I1 635150673035x1.*360b '1^800383500)605565 37j33ô7)'^*^ ^ "- ' ' ^BBB' ÔT)^" 568008036011 6656C6360I5 (O365i5b6l)06obo(o 506 80063060060!) 7)60605566 b6568ooBo36(o 86b65xi*36ob Bo 'oo5036ob 0)607661)3-

141

Page 25: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

132. !)6b686o6oo5xi (ob 566605x1^3007, 5668366553635156 06305536568503 '831)6365330 B35565i57)(oo 3060065x538360 606 33006556. 0663 '8336366 Boll <3bo3oo5i5oo507)o6 850500860630066b, bo8606(O5xx *36 ob, 06008 Bob86 30600-3060)86 30^5153563 050 b7)b5 3006073636655 5D66b6b35X56. 55686536000, b68b6b7)C6*3o 5635x1 *051586 «3bo3oo5X500507)0086 53^*0* ''' 663366, oo(oB 566B3b6503635xi.*b 330)6556 3075035x50353^^^ 6(^05036066336 8050063305x1^366 556 03(0 B506B500606063 650680660. 077)836 3b 86b6bo6oo365X536o 67)305x5365x1,*650 606 57)5xi^obb8oo6b, 06008 B6b (y)3oooB335xi 35xi*(o6ob335 33076506 8055063305x5366, 060050006(3 6866 b35xi.iob7j035xi '366 O3o3(6o76b. 3oo6o3ooo, 0^30008335x53-5Xi 'oo6ob 66850305x1*0 835035x00066 80000060036 56063337)5x5 3oo6oo36'35xi* 60868633b. b6b6B6o6o75X50o '3385035 65560*86636, o6(o8 33' >" B* ÔB " * 80306 2001 ^35156 665606367)515*86 b6b68606(O5X5(o 568(033515*3368 (ob. § 47), 33( 7 56800635x5066 565B366503635i5''3o 0030008335x1^35x5006066335 8055063305x5366- *33b6668ob 5Dr6o7b. 68 8086(^0)7)5153600) 8(O6306o)6ob565 bb36 36b65xi^36ob 307)^(055365x50760b 563(0 b6b63600(7751500 8030506 506b33668553, o6o)8 65060*867)515 '338oob33368503 56583b6503635xi;)b 606 33o)5o6 066083 B35565Xi,*73o6o 55B718dÔ"' ^ 6 6 6 3 *33385250) 380)383556 68 b638ob '335035I73.

133. 636ob8o3{^ '338oob3336*8o, 5668366553635x1^0 5563333855366(^6 b6386075o b5o^3b7)5i5 bo5736306b, o6oo503b63 6o66b^ooo665o 0366 3^38056605x50 611300 b6'3o535X5 50666*867)5x1''3o. 007)836 6006560000 556865*^3063635x50 6bb56 6(0 0300 ^6(68005053605x50, 0073 0065008 b36556 00630b 800335x56 865, o6o7503b63 03(0556, 06008 60 0300 5o'6B66'333, 36'3o5, 060036, 0600500063 635x1 0117)035x5366 63b65036b, 6006660(6 087)515366 606 30)0305156.

134. 7)<3o6(o 83503 , b6b6B6o6oo5xi o) oo)365xi^ob^o636b 08 B5303367)5xi^366b, 0063 5xi^35o5b3ob 0^600)67)515 b6b686(^0)5x507'3o 0300 ^6065053605X1^0. 686boo66, I16I16B60600515008 8oo7)li8o66 ,,317"-b, 0^(0835x5863 56563b6506, 06008 l77)b565o 08633 8300005036000 6^683b 3515330^*^'^^3"*'^' 06005(0063 655^3066 56633b6503635i5B6. "3385035 b6b686(^(o5xi^078 5063ooob6 ,,33", 0 00835x1 863 5066506b573(^6, 0 008 B6b Bobo 30O5i53536ob566 36800506, 0600B 56683b6503635xi^B6 00630b 300335x5*6 b36506, 0^655566 86!i 6^683650635. b66005X1 070055, b6b68606o)5xi^o)8 '836800^86 56683b655365i5ob 80306 556^30605x50 ,,655060^366", 0663 6b333 65O6b57]0^365O6 8oo3b5060^ob 8ob^7)5X5 330^bo6b.

135. 63 56(^38003636'3o, 3o7)b3506365o oBob6, ( ooB 2005 5X5ob 30 600386(^06 56556^33350515366 5^3( 305033 606 6o6ob b66oo5X5oooo, b6b63606005x500 31)655 ^^^^ 8005500b, ( 008 56633b655363515b 365o3o6o766'3o 30oo35ob6b b30600017735x5650 37)55650 30033306635 b6b35x^8^oo3oo 3oob35X5336o 08 8o1)5oo7, o6o)8 8ob565 B03550000 6550606366 65 06*3000686306 08 55666*3735x1 173, 060b 6650366*803. 0300 3^38056605x1^0. Bob 3o36o6oo 56300336367)5x1^36 37355655 3oo33o6oo6ob 830000553686 568000^3076 ob3ooo 156*30635x50 03017037)060 556 8000665x573060 b5o63bo, o6o)8 56533b65536351536 00300)8335153-5x50066 b36506, 0^6863 568070^306 800636060 506 87)558030 03017037)060 333557)7]56o6oo66. 63 37)ooboo7, 6o6b367)5i5o 30063363006 306333503657)5150 668606015x506 3ob3503ooo 556 330^80050, bob6b5o3ob 3o6o53o6o73Bob6 506 37355655 Bo73306o76ob Bolibob 56oo365X5ob^o536oo7 (ob. bb36 635o^o636b 'Booo^ob, O^^^'JÙSO m'^cnJQœoh ^'o6àù^dfjo^^ [GC], N522277/93, § 85, 650680660b 7)035x5366006 33060737)5x1 0 b6b686( o)5X5oo 2000-VII), !56!)6B6f6oo5xi >oo 6b336ob, 0600B 65560*367)5x1*0 37)50650 800330^0066 56730)666606506 3006336300b 83-3 87)b5X50O7 560)365i5ob^o5367)5i5 ^6836ob 565366b.

136. '33b6663ob655, 68 b6*37)833515173 5560065036 83-3 87)b5xii o.

55. 66)36 b6Bo3c636o 83-3 87)b5i5ob 8063503000

137. 5653366503635x50 63665036506, ( ooB 65560*357)5x1 0 37)55650 80733060066 7136685513635150 56b6556, />7/era//(^, 306080665x57)060 568o)8o36ob 8b35xi,*35X5076ob6b 665536o5xi_.86 630600)177)5x1 36 306(033507)067)51536 ^606553333686, 0^63 556363*3006367)5X1»o 03(0 „8b"-b 567)60660^36660066.

142

Page 26: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

007)836 byBooo) 65560*357)5x0ob 5607365x1^015^0536007 1)6b68606005x500 b633ob 63 6b3335"^^

365x533 565bo5xx '36b 116 0000050 6(6 B0066336.

II. BC068a6GOOb 90-13 aTîbffî Ob aoœoa)067]P^O s^^(^K?303,^

138. 56683b6503635xi»o 6b333 68530336556, 0607B 7)6060 307336 3733357)06 b6*37)65X )366l73

37)55650 8oo33(^o76ob b6F)O3606o766 5063637)00636000 30063363006 83-I3 87)b5X5o6 *3366668o665o,

0607835x1 03 650536b:

87)65150 83-I3. 3Ç33357)^(^ b6'37)65X536ob 7)<35^366

"BBBfï?' *' a^^-^G S5'^B^^8'^ B^^BB^G"""^* 56o7365X 'obVo6367)5150 7) 35^536360 506 O763ob7)*35x53636o,

335366 373335*^1^" l707Bob Bo5536ob 73<35il.*366 30607367)5150 b35i5ob73035x .360b ^066*33, 007)65063

36 55606553336 66503605x5 03636 oB 3006360b 8030^, 0^(085x53603 807333503650636 000303065x573060

7)*35Xi 3663oobo5i536oo)".

366 56663b6506, 06008 83-3 87)b5i5ob b6^0666558553500 GTl^*^^ 8o)33o6oo6ob '333o)b3336*3o, 83-

13 87)b5xi ob *83b6668ob65o, b6b35xi 8^00307 b35xi ob7)035xi *366b 633b 365x *55367)5x1 366 5680080366

6^6o68o707b b^o66*365o 506 8o7)33o68oo365xi,>65o.

139. 80763060060b 60657)83653^0 68 b66o36(^7l73 60 566bb3635036o7506 3005336300b B3-3

9^l5jTT>ob-0060066I73 ^6063005053605x50 566636655066566.

140. !56b6B6o6oo5xi^oob,5663b65036oo), 30763363006 83-I3 87365150 b6b35X5B^oo3oob566 8ooooobo)3b,

06008, (^005O3b63 006553336 300633630000 56073651506^06367)5x1*0 306000 65 8350 87)b5i5o,

8bb330^35i5ob6oo3ob 736506 6o6b36oo6503b b35xi^8ob6^35oo78o 833660I780 55606553330b 568o'7

506633500b b6b35i58^o*3(o 8oob35X5ob, 65 000656500b 36b7)bob35365i5076ol5 b63oo)o6o.

b35X5'33833( 35X5 b6b35i58Vo*30736b 566660607 560^3337)5150 55063(63306 30063363006 68

50367)5i536ooo"t563o6o6367)5xi^o 3651550367)5153606 *33110 77) 5360b o3coo6B6boo66 506363*800036000.

(^00500(^3 I70056500 37)65250, 0073 306000 66*87)65x5366, 00630b 860603, 33^ 6386300«305x536b 83-

13 37)^5x5000 56oo365xi^o'b^o536735xi> 80000boo3536b, 3b 7)6556 7)11067)6335153076 '80556

1)6b35153^0*3003606030 83365o1)836ob 306000065x5000668 (ob> bb36 635o^o^3^b 'Booooob, j'^^p^^

t^cofmcoSQcnob foBc>ùfn8^QQ [GC] 1^00210/96, 37)635^ 157, 6556*806606 7)<35xi;*366oo6 33060037)5x110

b6b686(^oo5i5oo 2000-XI; ob. 6b333 QVOSJÔ ^Q^^oob ^o6ù^>i^8^jQ, N^ 51564/99, 37)63(5o 75,

650680660b 7)035x1 366076 330^0037)5x50 66b686(^005x500 2002-1).

141. 007)836, 83-13 87)65x1 007 5600365x5ob^06367)5x50 b6b35X58^0*300b j)65x555367)5x536360

56661^36350366 56583b65036jx5ob b66o30^ob b6bo6ooob 8063553007 556 5606333735x5 '33Bo7b33336*3o

3006336306 8ooooobo73b 3 ')630^35735150 b6*37)65X53636ob 56oo365xiiob^^o5366b. 86565x1^00)655,

b63333671o, b65563 b63j3076 bo335oo5i5ob 66 37)55655 807330600606 «36350, 55*='f S?887) "*^

*37)650633557)(^65o 860*83535x5073660 7)735153^3^0, (^0785153603 55 'G73ffL'* " B' ' BB^G""^^ ^B"^

556 83-3 87)651536007. 83-I3 87)b5i5o 8oooo7bo)3b (*33b6668obo 3oo8336b63oob ■5^5^6b506bo766

30^00650) 836306 556 3733307]^ 56800803666 36b7)bob853635i5o 3006360b 55650536007 506

506b5^oo7 (ob. àG^'^Qç^vi^ù dyfii>Qô(6^(r}ob ^oSàùç^8çoQ^^ ^68361.97, 37)6353^07 161-162, 6506Bo65ob

7)*35i5366oo6 33(60037)5150 b6b6360^o)5i5(o 2002-IV; ùbjSco^o J:OÙ bhjjP>o o'^^QôCoumob

fo6ù^>p^8^jQ, 1)3Bo)(o 56bb3536o, 37)6350^ ^ 4 etseq,; byjjo^ô 00^060 (rr^Sjjœob fo6àô^8^QQ^.

1^=25660/94, 37)6350 208, 2005 V55.»ob 24 86obo).

142. 8003387)515 b63B3*3o ^6(68005553605x50 3(5303367)5xi'3636ob b603';')8335i5l)3, b6116860600515008

5066505066, 0 008 56583b650365x50boo30b 1998 \75xifob 19 b3358^^8^^ ' ^ 'BB^B^VJSï "

143

Page 27: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

556l7066j636ob6oo3ob, 30''>63363oob 83-3 87)65x5011 b6037)3335x1^ 1^3, 36b'ybo!)35365xi,*o766 33obo^36oo506 b6b35xi'3 (70* 300 b35X5ob7)*35x5366b. 6B5036650, 566836655365x506 6660360^0, 68 37)0)6oo), 83-I3 B73b5xi ob 801)63605066 56807850056063 ,,11650630)" 0300 (ob. Px^jo^n) xpc, r^ùobo Qùjrnœo<^Bjd'jsj:^>o lh^8jojcob fo6ù<^i:n8QyuQ, 1988 ^5x506 27 630605x50b 56556^333505x5366, b3(^06 6, N^Dl, 53. 23, 37)535" 52). 6b3 06008, b35i;)ob73«35xi *366b 5666650*6 365x555367355,'366 66356(^36066 30333571(^0 568(080366 566836650365x1*011 *366*5 (005065 5650807360650606 5606380036360766 50*6363*8006360(0. 1)38000) 655607)6735150 8o1)3l)36oli 56800 (ob. 56506^73335o5xi '36ob 'b68606(y)5i5oli" 66^05x1*06 I 66 05x1 *0), 6066660060 5i *6B633630oo305xi >365i565o 37333(yjf^" 3o6o8o665xx.'7)0 >o 5680080366 606 665606367)5x^*6. 66668606(O5ix 'O78, 0)6306 860603, Si'*^ ' fl 5"5' ' 06008 5668366503635x^)6 7)6000 300336 1)63860606650 3*333571^" 568(0803606 6656o6366'b3 3oo5xi,*03oob 8bo6o5065 37)55655 30033060760b o)6oo66l)3 556 *33b6668ob65o, 63 Bbo6o3, 6360680306 !ib36 b35X58ob6^35D(o8 b6'37)65X5366l73, 3607 71o706ob, 3078335b630ob Bo5036ob 116(663515173.

143. "835535655, 68 8086(^007)5x53600), 5060065536 3(^53353oob 83-I3 B73b5xi o.

III. 3H6806GOOb 34-0 CR5 38-D 8*3bff?060b 800}00)06ï)ff:?0 ïR^(^K?3036

144. 56683b6503635xi^86, Bobo 506713366500760b '338505078 565bo5X5336*8o, 6b333 566b66o3o66, 06008 . 5680080360b 86b65x5360b 5566)7)0636 8oo36b7)b3 116635x1*8^0*300b Bb0605565 606 *333b666836oo506 30063363006 34-3 87)6515b 556 38-3 87)b5X5ob 1-3515 37)635^- ^^"3 87)65x *0 030016)366 '338503566006655:

„b6b6360^o75xijo7b 7)37)851506 8005500b 566636650360 536ob8o306o 3o(^ob6566, b68oo63{^o76oo oo(o566o1)63036ob 66 *3o1)O37)06o 3006066566, 06(085x53603 6853033636, o6oo3 oliobo 60 )o66 30600-306000 b35X5*33B330635x50 Bb606oli 80306 30063363000)6 506 Bobo 073836000 65006(6367)5x50 7)71^3^8^"^* C^ ' ^ ^BBS" ^ 8!ib330635xi_)5o. 865565x1 0 635x1^7)3833{^35xi'o 866063360 80036515360 606066 6(6 7l37)'365i5oo6 635150 68 7)'35X536ob 863bo865i57)o6 56807336366b".

38-3 B7)b5xi ob I-5150 (6) 37)635^^ 57)5i5o!ib3oo6b:

„1. 007)30 b6b6B6060051500 563oo63b650361), ooooB 56563b65Do 8055367)5x506, 050: 6) '837)505366 b63Bob 566605x5366 866(63006 ^6(^8008655536515360766 30^00650, 506 0)7330 66^0(^00 036366, 66656(^366 5680080366b, ( oo85xi ob 3733307]^^ 566600063035x5360660)306 '33b6663obo b6b35xijB'v'o'30)36o 7)11067)6335x530)0336 3335ïi.*6 67)305x53635x5 b67l7)65i5366b".

145. 86350335x500667)0 8005500 066 Bobo I7380007 556*303b006367)5x50 8b*^35X5006360 30^63363006 83-3 506 83-I3 87)65153606 8ob3503ooo 8055367)5x50 56556^333505x536360, b6b68606oo5xi oo 8ooF)533b, o )oo8 67)305x53635x1 *0 6(6 6o6ob 3o^63353oob 34-3 556 38-3 87)b5i536ob b6<37)8335xi*1>3 ^6065053605150 b6p)O306ob 365x533 566605x1^36.

IV. dn6306GpOb 41-0 8*3bK^0b 059(^906066

146. 30'753363oo6 4I-3 B7)b5x )o oo)365xi^)ob^o636b:

,,007)30 b61)68606005x1 *00 506650536b, 0600B 8oob506 3(0633630066 506 Bobo 0038360b 556(6553336, 506 007)30 865565x1 *0 635x1 *33833(635x:;)o Bb606ol) '80506 b6635x1^8^003(036(6030 b68606oo65X5o 8bo75X5oo5D 66^05x2 '006(6030 55638630)0305x1^3606 b6*37)65X5366b 085x5336, li6b686o6oo5X5oo, 67)305x536515006011 '338o7b3336'3o, 7)1>o6'36335xi'30oo36 5O6l)60665xx '367)5i5o 366c6oli 668606075x5066 506386307 0305x5366!".

6. 5668313650365^006 80000600356 66860*)005X5066 5563863000305x53661)3

144

Page 28: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

147. 300633^^50, 5'^^^(3^*'^^B^8^'*^'^ 8o70(ob(036 865306065157)060 1)066ob 6661)5567)06366 1998

5Xi 'o!7 19 !i335B36o6ob '83B(y)6333ob "335535650 8055367)5150 5001)0663636011 837)06665x500601160)3011.

366 566636650*^, (6(o8 1998 ^5x505566 bb365i.)6bb36 1563335x580)3835500 000^756601)630360 550

33(6800 500060006360 736(^6350636 Bobo 837)(6665xi oo6ob b606'^361i, B65066B B6b 606 '83385x500

86cy)0)3ob 87)50803655 5O6bB60636ob 006(0366. 680b 56B00, 86b 5566^006556 lib36 o63b7)0^b36ob

80083666. 3308 5x11. 86567350036b 6656o6o'3ob Bob35030(o (ob. 1)3Booo)),566B3b650365xi^oboo3ob

b66365o830)03(o71o 566306360b li6*36li73f6o, 0)7) 5630(0365x5011^/0636(0, 06078 86b 3b 50611^00650366

^35Xi^o^65oob 5668635X50)66'3o (oo6' 3o6 65 b6B*>f,306, "836505366 60 000 0 7)67)5x1 * o67)65xi_>li.

50686536000, 56683b6553635X5li Bo77) 'o6 50553*80 300-500 0 7)117)5x50 067)65x1 0!! 506b6(6^36

^685x536176 556 33c6boo665X57)06o 30503606 60301361)3. ^335035650, 668350030607 80176360(0

55656b6o6^36ob 8005x50660 0660750360766 7)36555366 '5xx'o7)06655 362 500 0 7)67)5x1 o67)65X5b. 68

566656000*3360(0 5668366503635150 oo)bo73b 23 562 500 o67)b7)5xi 0 7)65x1 *11, 066006 506*3606006

Bobo B0086365150 1168350030600 b6065^36o 65 ^5x568553.

148. 56583b650365X5ob (y)33oo), 86b 3006335x1 )0 b60oolibob 3B3557)7)56(^o76oli b5657]^^o 00*3030-

65x57)06650 80360^6. 86b 87)*860o6ob6 506 O37)^)ob Bo5536ob *33b685X5365x50066 606 33006556,

I1J00050366 373508030 800835x535150 506 306605066 Bob 07^6bb 606 33006506 68 8o)Bb6b7]o636o!)

b6*36b7)06ob 56506b5oob 116717)65x1 *366, 8obB6 553556B 55650036 b6Bb6b7)06o, (^60)6 8obo)3ob

Bo3b3506. 56583b65O3635xx,'0 6853033655^, (6078 Bobo (55355< l-0 7l3Bo7b635X5ob 5063606536 7)6556

660035x505x50300 865306065x07)06 5066636(^5650. *3385035 5668366503635x50 8000006003506 Bobo

30(66500 *33Boo6635x1^360b (66(05035oo6ob 656'b5567)(^366b. 655606o*3ob6b 556330650600 006

067)6300*30 *33li6663ob 500607b b6*87)65i5oo b35X5*36bob 00*303065157)0^ ^^Ô'^Ô'^^"Ô"8'3^ 8006633B366,

5668366503635x1^86 80700)60036 2 736 384 o67)b7)5x: 'o 0 7)65150 55636065735x1 0 *83Bo)b635xi oli

6561)5567306360b60030b 506 513 072 o67)b7)5xi o 067)65150 Bobo 3'3o765xi 'ob 556360657)5150

*33Booli635xi;job 3078335116300b 30I76007.

149. ^68*80 56683b6503635X5o 8(ooo7boo3506 27 351 812 o67)b7)5i5 o 7)65X5b 8653^065x57)060

I7066ob60)3ob (5o66b5X5oo36ooo 794 000 330600 60051500 00*303065157)060 37)o6booo).

150. 56583I76503635150 6b333 Boooooboo3506 606686(5306065x57)060 1)066ob 6561)5567)(6366b. ob

63b65536506, (6oo8 3005150300b 5663000305x1 *366*80 ob 6^68311 35X533ô ' ' *^B*^*' ' ■■" 363 563000^^306

b6b5o30 *3ol7O37)06o 506 8365651573(^0 b5o63bo. 73*3( 00 835"(3' ^^^^ *3665^o6o5065 565080736(^5066

'565060I760^506 865x5066 63060001)7)5x1 506 85303637)5x5 5*^*^336*80. 36b '33I5360 36o66ixi;)o1)367)5i5o

633b, 80080660066 "337)851506 8boo5i50)5o 6ooo665xi;36o66o b636( 85x1^000 506 "3305x5360 6o66boo553b

3300515366. bo307365x1^*ob 7)B353bo 66^05x1^0 866 bb36 b65X5b1)3 5568003050367)5x1 36 7)6506

56656C6o7b. 86li 60^ "837)851506 37)*360766 506 606 "837)85x1 06 360603060b 17(6506 65 3o6ooo33bo7)sx50

5663000606366. *336oo66b,b65063 oli 3boo306oo6!i 60 633b 5150*350 506 3oo335xi o73ob,o6oo503b63

5606300 56b35i56 b7)06b, 86b 3b 860*33635x500366 865x50b6833655 7)^55366. 0^7)b3o)*3o b6^606o)

7136076360b 7)8353bo)66b 606 5666606 6333065x57)060 '33b6B5X5365xi,'07636o 60)0665x5360660

b63606B5ï536o!) 8(08686063635x50760730!). "835035650, Bobo 3078(660066 556 11(03065x57)(60 30065635*^

865x x766 7131)557)557)5X1:0 0307. 333515*6 3b ^363507(60 0^333556 Bob 87)50803 506 b6b5o3 566'^\^36b.

151. 55660751500b, Boll 5' ^^B'-^^^ 67)6o63b365o6 b35xi:ob7)035X536ob Bob 80860607 6356507)060

50680730503673515366 506 36(oo 7)6o6o.8oo8b5060^o766 556363*80063600) b637)oo606o 36b7)bo!iB53-

65x50060!) 6550606360b 0760)661)3. " ^ 506b6b060)367)5x50 0300 0600500O63 83063330 b6bo6ooob

655680660, 06(0835x1^863 0030008335x535x1.*( 60b 835035x00060b 568606(0515366 b36506 3(05i503oob

00030306360b 55655666*867)5x^*36000. 060I1 56Bo7(3 5668366503635x586 0)630 05068607 5568300^3-

^7]ff ^ f5' 7]o835oo)5o 506 08355563067)367)^650.

152. 1)38(007 6556o'86<35xi,'o!i 66*37)8335x1:1)3, 6066865306065x5*3060 1)066ob 6116661)5567)0^36515655

5668(3665^*3635x1^0 8(00006003506 22 530 000 067)67)515 067)65156 (556665x500360(0 654 000 330607

6(05X1 (0 0)*3O3O65X! *7)( o 37)06!ioo7).

145

Page 29: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

6. 3oo63(*7ro6ob 3o7l)0306 b686(^005x50660 5563863000305x53606 3oo006003661)3

153. 566836650365x1*06 807006003636113 1)066o6 6661)5567)06360!) o>6oo66l)3 807630^00668 65560*366, 06008 56683b655365xi,'o6, 80306 0603006367)5x1:0 116800365x56300 66383 60^60 60735000^005006 5X536o6b3ob ( 6ooo67)5x * b6b636(6005x507*80 ^ 306 305533 8005x5005005*80 0300. 1)6383 "33630^367)5x50 0300 566836650365150b 8o7o)boo35ob b6037)8335x1 »I73 bobb5x;*ob b6360^(o5xi:ob 3o6o733bob '3355350b 8005x5(05005*30. 56B(o8o36ob 5D6bo6'y5x;'36ob 36500b'113556 1155306650 53530065x57)060 3o6o737)o6oo( ob 807655505x *38 566b6l)553066 2005 ^5ii;*ol) 2 630605x50. 685036650, 80)630600668, 506b336o6 666000, 5666366556, (^0)8 306605566 li63Bob 566605x536 60 5066(67)5x5367)5x1 )6 7)0506 66635153^0*30)360603 500063133, 556b(^7)5x5360b ^8335535 566B3b6503635X5b *837)85xi )06 8005507b 300833666306 650505x )0060^03 b6b68606oo5i5oo36'3o. 685036655, Bobo 8000060036360 l7066ob 666175567)06366173 8(07)8 0033635x31*0 0300.

154. 6b333 30063060066B 565B3b6503655:ob 3030^ Boo006003605x50 0660050360066 56506^6(66367)5x1»655 506 60^6(6365157)0^650 8oo65o6.

5. b6b686(^o)5]:50)b '33«36b366 x

/. 8ô(^u<^où^>^jr6o %oôBo

155. 06005000^3 b6b686o6oo5xi:oo8 556b6^3ob*3o 65550*356, ob 73635* ? o ooB 5668366553635x50 ob33 05536556 8033636735x50 365306065157)0^0 1)066ob 56800 '80506 b68606005x1^3606030 3(^0033507)0636000 5600365150b^06367)515 506bB6(^366b, 606 6(^00833506 B6b 7)735Xi:366b, 8oo307boo36' 3006336300b 4I-3 37)b5xi:ooo 5607365X5ob^o5367)5X5o 3078335b6306. b6b68606oo5X5O) 565obo5i563b 68 b630oobb, 807)635063650 o3ob6, 0 008 08633 66bo6ooob b63B3 655505x^*0)6( 03 b6b68606005x500'3o 3005x5005505'306; 30063363006 4I-3 37)b5i5ob 536obBo30^o bb36 56686065366 68 553^735153^66 6f663O333(5'30^b 56b5ooli (ob. mutatis mutandis, jvj jof^>ir>o, n?r78bo ^.> jjr^boJo èjpï^QOob foSààçodçoQ^ (307*305x50 5O-3 37)b5Xi,*o), 1972 V5i5ob 10 36065ob 56556^333505^5366, b3(^06 6, K^M, 37)63(50 14 etseq). . .

156. b6b686( oo5X507 "3385035 o830oo^36b, ( oo8 736506 6(^b36oo6553b 6'336(^6 8017317076(^030 363*80(^0 56533b65O365xi:ob6003ob 303363673515 I706666 506 30^63363006 55606553336b '3o7o6ob 506 65560*367)5150, '33b6663obo «300063000 736556 8000363503b 55636065735x50 '33800b63515ob jo)8335b63o6b (ob. èc>(^d^r6ù, 8^bù^^^ ^Ù ^ùdo7(^(^ jbàôGjœob fo6ùô^d^QQ (3000305x50 50-3 87)65150), 1994 ^5X5ob 13 O36obob 56556^333505x5366, b3(^06 6, N5285-5 37)6358^*^ 16-20).

157. b6b6360^005x5008 5066505066, o6o73-56633b6503635X5o 6^6836, 0606 '833553563 865 636556 00630b 800335x56. 685036650 b35i5ob7)*35i5366 36b7)bob853635xi:o 0300 1998 ^5ï5ob 19 b335B3^o^ob 0630503650.0) 56Bo7 337)5îx.* ^33503536173. 566B3b65O3635i50 7)73660^006 37)*36oo6ob oo365X5b6l7-(^obooo 506 850*33635x1:073660 0066666 66^0(^07 837)(^6651507606 56506835X536ob6oo3ob. '33b6668oli655, 606b36oo6b 801731)006(0030 363*80060 556555360515 556(^553336b6 506 5668366-^53^51506 '83807b635x5360b 35i5366b, 6b333 Bob 80086365x5 837)06565i5oo66b 'Sooo^ob (ob. b6^o66655B5035075o, 6ijr6j(^Do m'^r^JQmob foG^oçnBçoQ^^.Wll^^y^li, 37)635^^ 215, 2001 ^5i5ob I 860650, b65063 b6b6B6o6o75i5oob 80306 330^ 55650506506 33006660(60 801)317006(^030 363'3o(^o 37)50650 8003306006666 556 565B3b655365ï5ob *36030051500507)0^ 3060765x53836b 'Booo^ob).

158. b6b6B606(O5xi *o7 *333505oo8'3o o8(oo636b, 06008^7067)5x50 3oo8335b636ob60)3ob (restitucio in integrum) b6joo6o7 ^68ob b^ooo6o 5566656060*8366, 56683b650365xi>o66oo3o6 80336367)5150 3653^065X1^*7)0^0 55666360653606 b66o(o, 71308515366 6305x1:367)5x5 03636 5560^5533305066 56800850056(^3 6f6b36oco655 5667)6617553(^35x1:0 8666110600365x5000 (ob. OÙBQO, ^''>8gbo ^Ù

146

Page 30: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

[JO^l^ÔO^^^ ^àD(^(r}OàSQ?)'^^o bôdj^07b ^O6^>.)>^8^JQ (30^7305150 5O-3 87)65 150), 1982 ^5x50!! 18 oo35<' 36o6ob 56556^33350515366, b30^o6 6, M 55, 37)635*^ ^D- 5661161)553006 736556 80765036, 5065636(^536ob 7l3'36b366*3o P)606007)5x1:0 7)6806630 7)86o'33635X5oo 5535* î ** ^ 307)^35063655^ 06650566 0^63 7)1306(0 5005506 50( 000!) 116360066, 8o(o 7)'30 fo o6oo';'35X5o 566b6b6l755306o6 8o1)3l)0)6o6o3o 363*80060 55606553336116 556 l7066b *3ooo6ob (ob. roc63ô6o oy'^f^JQconb ^o6àù^8^Q-^, N^25656/94, 37)6350 426 etseq., 2002 "^^K^S 18 o35obo). 6b3(o b633336'3o 56506b6jo^35x^*0 116300)60 60oob 566B3b65O365xi 'oli60O3ol) 67)305x5365x1:655 565061763380 1)066ob 666115567)06360!) b606olibo, 0600500(63 ^6( 117)5x50, 611333 80086365x50 8653'^o65i57)o6o 1)065o5065 56800855066063, 0663 7)6556 56556^33o5oob b6b6B6o6o)5i5oo8 Bobo 55ob3o6330ob «360655x036*80 556 Bb350335xoo)66'3o 7)6556 8005500b 860)o 7)3b666Boli(o66 (ob. IU-^BÇOQO mo8ho Qùjf^œoôSjd'^jf^w bôdu^nb ^oBùô^B^Q^ (3000305150 5O-3 87)65x1:0), 1989 'y5xi:ob 6 6o)386o6ob'''56506\73335o5X5366, 113(606 6,

N"538,53. 9,37)635^^ 15; ff^ùb(^o6Q-3(^o6o ^ù (^OJOÔ^ ô'^O^^^^'^^O^TJ^^ bôBufjnb ^oS.^.^f^^B^DQ (37)b5i5o 41), N531417/96 506 lSr532377/96, 37)635360 22-23, 65063o65ob 7)<35Xi:366oo6 33( 0037)5x50 b6b686(^o75i507 2000).

159. b6b63606oo5xi:oo8 65560*366, 06008 56683b655365X5ob 80000607366 80)86365x1:0 668350030600 50656660^5^360b 556 '33800b635150b 50636(o53ob 0060066I73 3737)863600506 3308 . s^. 86567)5oo36b 6656o6o'3b, 0600835x503 655536506 5658036650365x506 ^5xifo7)o6o 837)06665x500606 506665x50036000 550o6367)5X5366b, o67)b3oo'3o 606b367)5i5 00*303065x1:7)06 8005633336b b6'37)65xi:o7 b35X5036bob O)60o66l73 556 36o667)5ob, 06008 36b 7)6556 563506835x1:36066 87)'36oo66 60 VKI:'^^S^3 ^'^ Bobo bo30O3b5ï5ob 66650685x1:030066 736556 307*305x1:0300 65 ^35150. 800630^700663 60^ ^6066505066 b68o78635i5oo 5O666l56065>^36ob 66 '338oob635X5ob 50636(65306 65x553066650735x50 568000735x56.

160. b6b636(ooo5xi:ro 8b5^35xijoo6b, (6008 (6685035083 ^066 66383*30, b65063 80786365x50 7)38o7b635xi:ob b63ooobo 565obo5Xi:3600506, b6b63606075x5008 568000035x56 5066037)866 56683665036515011 ^6(^300865553651506 8030^ ^6(^8005553605x1: 08 b6joo6o7 363o565X!^o6 568000735x536b, (^63 3116^0(600366 5606333735x50 5DO)5ob *338oob6365Xi:b (ob. ôj(^ùbo œ^f^Jjœob ^O6ÔÔ^8^IJQ, N524351/ 94, 37)635^ 350, 65068o65ob 73035x1:366076 33060037)5x50 b6b68606o75X5O7 2003-y 506 r>c6Jô6o œyc^JQcooh ^oGà^çnd^Q^, 17380007 65550*367)5x1:0 37)535" 433). 05033 805050086 736506 0353b 56800335367)5x1:0 80086365x1*0 50656b6(65^36ob 563o7(035X5obo73ob63. 8003387)5x1: b6383*3o, (^00500063 665b, 56583b650365x1:0b 8030^ 80000b003605x1:0 o765b6 568000035x1:05x1:0 0307 860^5"8'^co, 300335x5^5x5073( 0 b6835oo3o6o7 55666b606^3606 o 7)b3oo*3o bo30O3b5xi:ob b6*37)65xi:o) 15665( 85150-30)661)3 565068006351536007. 8008636515*30 8ob65536o *338o7b635X5ob 06600503600663 08633.7300068000 0300 5066656(^0*3367)5x50.

161. 685036650, 007)55063 506505o55D3b, 06008 56800003515360 506 90066338360 b^oo(^65o 6(6ob 800^0)50367)5x1:0 56683b655365150b 80306, b6b686( 005x1:07 8006533b, o6oo3 568000035150b 830000500 8003387)5x0 b63B3'3o 606 6o6ob '330763b3665oo b6b63606oo5i5nb 3o505oo86boo66, 80786365x5*30 8ob65536o '33300b635x1:360b 5563606530b 568000735x1:360b o)365xi:b6l)0^obooo. 7)*3o6oo 83503 , 55636065^35x50 '338oob635xi:36o 6O6 8(0O363b 383557)7)66(^0)606 56800 8o55367')5X5 336bo6b. 6335566 56800850056(63, b6b636(6005x500b 606 7)37)85x1:06 8005500b 566836650365x1:06 80306 8000)6003605x1:0 666005x1:0707 0^60050360066.

162. 007)836, 8005500 006 86350335x1:0066*30 56533b650365X5ob 8505ooB6o63oo6ob '337)b6668oo66 506 73635^5 * ^ 3 36b 7)5563(050 33f 3< f fÇ' b306oo7l)7)5X! o 86530^065x1:7)060 5066636065360, (^00500(63 11(67)5x1*0 333557)7)66(^076011 '8350350 506 b6^o(^o736b 87)50803 b6335oo3o5o7 337)06665x1:0066b, b6b63606oo5i5(^b Bo'b66*83^o)5o5xi:65o 8o665o6, 865300065157)0^0 l7065ob 6b666l75567)o63635i5o 56506b6333o (O66bob 0660055360066 565b6l7503(î7(ob 350500360630060b b637)O)606o '33'36b36ob b6*37)8335x5173 (ob. mutatis mutandis, ô[jb^^Cno m'^Co^jjmob ^oBy-yù^B^QQ, Ke25657/94, 37)635f> 442, 6506Bo66ob 7)735i;*3?'3^ob 33060737)5x1 *0 b6b6860 (O5xx_*o7 2001-VII; ,,'^"xp6 bh^ijèo ^àQC^moùB^è'^^o

147

Page 31: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

bùdQO]cob ^^oBc>^^^i8^^^ [GC], ]Sr?29392/95, 37)635*^ ^27, 6506B06606 7)73515363601) 33060037)5x1;*o b6b6B6060051507 2001-V 506 C'X^^^ÙGO œ^CoJ^mob pV7( >6jq') o^ , 1)380000 65560*867)5x50 37)635^ 438). 5668(366503651x^*06 850500860^30)606 63060071)7)51^*0)606, 63330650)7)060 506 87)508030 6683550306(0 837)066651x *076011 556 8ooB6365xi>*3o 373*8600606 b067)5x50 3^3^7)71 f * ' * ' 56o)365xi»ob^o636ooo, 666686060055 *00 5655666338 (066b6li 655536b 130 000 33060011 0055360060(0, 006663 7)6506 5563865006 68 066(0503600606 5O6I16635O60 (06566.

163. b6b6B6(^(05o*07 o83(oo636b, 0600B 05305536(50!) 55( 006 5663366553635x1;*o "3*^ ' 663060035x50 6b65X556l)065O6, 87)50803650 55611638367)51x *0 650680660. 8(05x50306*80 300*360666 06 5563333850366066 ^683666, 0^6863 568000^306 b6b5o3o 336565Xï,*7)o6o 506 0301)037)060 58^B"^^ - ' B^ ^ ^BBB* ^ "^B^f^Bô' ^65 b3f663365Xi,*1)3 56033006 06685036083 0733(66306. 68^68655 86b 55' B* < ô71ff?" *^d8^ 8o76o5xi''3o6oo66, b33b7)65x57)060 556 b6^oo6335i53 O7(6565oo36ob 737)63306, 606 '837)85x506 B7)7l6oo66 556 663*833606 3005x1:6. 366 ( 357)5x56067)5x5650 7)6506 5606(^006 668350030600 *338oo^B366 556 8060 8505078606300606 56(6007)5x1 *366 3003351507306 7l3b685xi'3635X506. b6b6860^o75X50o8 565b637)0)-06367)5x50 b3o6ooo1)7)5X5oo66 80660^6 066 1998 5x1*06 19 63353360606 80035x5363606 "8355356, 6(6686530^o65X57)(^o 170660660030b 56506b6338o o766b6 565661)553(06 120 000 330600b 075535006000, o66b63 7)6506 50638650^6 68 0660755350760b 506116635060 006666.

50. 6671(^630

164. b6b686o60051500 86( 00367)5x5650 8006633b, 0 008 b67)0o63o 556*37)36367)5150 7)6556 03076 506037386367)5x1:0 33(^oo3ob 33650065x57)060 66630b b6b3bboo 5656333000b 5*^ffi:^ b67)(^63o, o 707B35xi:b63 55* 8f ' ÔB ' ^ 3O^O'?33557)5Ï5O 37)6350.

^8 301)6060bCf)30b b.^b^860^0)^^098 Oo^mb8.S^

/. ^60^ r*7 80063060060b 3(635351)06 *3o506 b6b35i58^o*30736(^o3o b6*37)65xi*3636ob 63oo^7)(63ob oo6oo66l)3 506 8005500 56533b650365X5ob, (6075000^3 8000000367)5x1:0 55606553330b 8bb33o635x1:0b b5657)bo;

2. '•'^^^QBb, ( ooB 5060065536 30063363006 83-3 B7)b5i50, 1998 ^5x506 19 b33583630^b 56683b650365xi*ob 03^5^0^05566 56558(0360^506017 '3635'^B B7]8dÔ'o)^" 5680080360b 606606b36oo6ob 37)oobooo;

3. àçoQQBby 06008 5060065536 30063363006 83-3 87)65150 3005150306*80 50636336ob6b 80b B0B60600 37355655 80733060060b 56800;

4. àço'^DGb, O )oo8 1)33(oo) 655607157)5x505066 56800850056O63, 606 6o6ob b6joo6oo 56583b655365X5ob bb36 b66o30636ob 566605x1:36 30063363006 83-3 87)651 *05065 56800850066063;

5. ôpoQjSb, OoooB 5O60(65;>36 3(^63363006 83-I3 87)65x50 566660306367)5150 37)50655 800330600606 oo60)66l73 37333ô7)*^" l)6*37)65i]i*3636ob 6f6606b36o)6ob 56800;

6. à^QQ^b, 06078 6(6 6o6b36oo6b 56533b650365X5ob 80306 5611660306367)5x1 *0 34-3 37)65xi:oli6 556 38-3 87)b5Xi,*o!i I-5150 (6) 37)63(506 365x1*33 565bo5x;'3ob 67)305ix '365ii;*oo66;

48

Page 32: 90b00080 ootlbOœOb 'v'OG^^c^aCROô bôJRy'bg „80ba0030 c6 ...catalog.supremecourt.ge/blog/foto/160.pdf · 14. 5o^6B(3bùf03(Ss^>ob Bob3fo30(r), (S(05focoo7^)bjob 3fo^nn(3oob 5ô63O7C3osi^i3?)0i'cio

6) (6ooB Boo36b7)b3 b6b35i58^oo3oo8, 56506^3335osx536ob 1166075x1 000750 56Boo3b65036o5066 b68o 0730b 36506*80 3006336300b 44-3 87)b5i5ob 83-2 37)635*^^^ 7l3!i666Bo!i65o, 56583b6553635X5b 7)6506 565067)b65oo)b 5650633Bob 5555 » 3';306booo 306073673515 365x1:7)5• '3o 3oo633o65oo^367)5xx,'o *3385535o 0660050360766: 130 000 (6b 0)35066(00 6076bo) 330600 865306065x57)060 1)066o6

661)5567)06365x5650 506 120 000 (6b 0030 60)6bo) 33(^00 60668653(^065x1:7)060 1)066ob b656l)5ii67306365xi:655, o66b63 736556 55638650^'b 68 00607553600606 55666635(60 006666;

61)6

6

6) 06008 1)380007 65560*357)5x50 b68o o)3ob 56b35X5ob "8385035 56506b506B503, b6730663o "36556 5650665036 1)38oo6555o*367)5xi 'o 005036006000 b67)0663ob 56506b5ooli 5oo6ooob6(03o!) 33o6(o3ob 33650665x1^7)060 66530b b6b3bboo 56663330706 5^^*^* b67)0663ob 373(^bo(o, o6oo835i5b63 b67)(663ob 500600b 5563B65366 3 3(^o733657)5Xi,'o 37)635^^;

8. "jaroijroojb 56683b650365X5ob 80306 8oo(obo736o5i5o l7065ob 666175567)063606 5666b363366b.

'83bo67)515367)5x1:06 065515067300 3661)3 506 ^30605x1:00600) 713530^606366 8oob506 2006 ^5X5ob 26 0653606b, b6b686060051500b ^3b36ob 77-3 37)b5ioob B3-2 506 83-3 37)635B<^O)6 *33b6663ob65o.

bCOo OG 60i25b060 . . do60bôHb o^COI ^JObO 35503660 3(^31)0503650

149