miroslav ruzica - vlasi-drugacije citanje
Post on 29-Nov-2015
221 Views
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
-
, / / : ... ...
1018
miroslav.ruzica@gmail.com
: 316:314(497.11) : 1. 10. 2012.
/ /
/ / , ,
. - ,
. : , , , ,
, , ,
. , 1936
1989, - . -
( 7728) 1333 - / , ,
, - . / ,
. , , /
- . / , .
/ , - , -
. ( 1).
.
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1019
( ) , .
( , 2009: 159164). -
:
( irkovic, 1997: 178 182183). , - -
, .
. , .
/ ,
. , , -
, - . -
/ , . 1) - 2) , -
. .
, . -
. , , . -
. , -
, , , - ( , 2011: 1415).
, , , , , . .
, . , -
, . , , -
, ,
-
, / / : ... ...
1020
( , 1993: 156157, 200; , 1962: 3941). - 1774 ( , 2004: 533; Wolf, 2001). -
, ( , 2008: 64).
, , -
, , . , , ,
. ( ) 16. ( , ). , , -
, , - ( ) ( ) -
( , 2002: 7677). pastores romanorum ( , 1997: 166). - .
, ,
, . ,
( irkovic, 2004: 113114). ( ).
- ( ) , (1517. ).
( ) , ( , / , ). -
. / -
, ( , 2003: 7388).
,
. . - 18. . ,
, , ,
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1021
( , 2003, 2009; , 2011; Winnifrith, 1987; Schwandler-Sivers, 2004).
. , -
- ( ); -
, -,
(Geary, 2007: 2223; 5253); , - ; , -
. , ( )
, ,
, . -
- .
20. , , , -
, .
. -
, . (John Fine) :
, . - - . ,
, , - - , ,
. (Lindner, 1981; Fine, 2006: 25)
-, , ,
( )
- (Goldstein, 2003: 36, 41; Heather, 2009: 405406; Geary, 2007:
210212). - - , , , -
-
, / / : ... ...
1022
, , . 200.
1000. -
(McNeal and McNeal, 2003: 100103). , , , , , ,
, ,
-. , -
, , , .
: , , -. , ,
. , , , -
. .
- , . ,
. ; .
( . - )
, . , -
, ( , 2005:
3840). , , -, - , .
, - , ,
. , , , ,
, .
. ,
. -
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1023
- . - ( ) ( , 2008: 8182; , 2011: 20;
, 2009: 6067). , , -
- , , , - - , .
12. 13. ( , . .: 111113).
( , ) , - -
, - - , .
, - . , -
, , - 19. .
-, , (
) , . - , -
, , , , ; -
( ) . (stradiotti)
( , 2003: 103, 117121; , 1996: 5657). -
, - . , , ,
, , 16.
18. . , . , , .
.
,
, , - , -
, -
-
, / / : ... ...
1024
. -, , , -
. 86.000, 200.000 186.000 , 0,7 - 1,6 . , -
. 10.000 40.000 .
, -. , ( -
) 200.000. , - .
, - , .
, -, , -
. , - , , - -
, .
19. 20. . ,
, . -
, , - .
- - , , . ,
. , -
. , - , -
, , , . -
, . .
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1025
-
- , . - -
. .
, . ,
. , . :
, , , , , - (
, , ). , / , , , -
- -. ,
( ), , , -
, , , .
- , 150 - ( , 2001: 97104; ). - -
- 1.000 . -
- , ,
. 12. .
. 15. . -
. (1859) - . - , ( -
) . - .
-
, / / : ... ...
1026
- . -
, - ,
, .
. -
. ,
. - . , , -
, , - .
, : , , -
. , , -
, - . ,
, .
( ). ,
( , 2003). -
. , , ( )
(Via Egnatia) - ( ). ,
-, .
-. 5. .
, , - 7. . - - ,
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1027
. , ,
; , - .
. -
- ( , )
- , .
, , , , .
- ,
. , , -
, , , - . - , , - , ,
. , -
. - -
. -
( , ). , -
. - ( , 1980).
- - . - . ( ),
.
. . - , -
, , , ,
-
, / / : ... ...
1028
. , - ,
- 19. .
, , , , -
, . , , ,
. , , - , / -
( ) ( ).
. - ,
.
. , , , -
. , -
. - , .
. ,
. .
,
. ,
, , , -
. .
, , .
. , , . -
, -
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1029
18. 19. (Zbuchea, 2002: 715). -
, ( , 2011: 103).
, 60.000 ( 40.000 ).
2011, . 50 , , 1.500 102.000.
. . , 200.000 (
10.000 ). - , ,
, - . , ,
, -. , , . -
, .
: - , ,
. , .
, ( , , , -
). - 1934. .
, , .
, . , -
1990- .
, . (2000), - -
, ,
. - , ,
. -
-
, / / : ... ...
1030
, , ( ) . - , -
( , 2002). , -
. , ,
. -
, . - -
. 2008, -
( , ). - , ,
- , , ,
. , , -
, , - , -
( , 2010).
- ( , ,
, , - ). , . , - , Ariadna Filum, - - . -
. , . .
, ,
. , -
. , , -
, a . -, , -
. web- .
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1031
, .
, . -
. ( ) , ,
. ,
, , - . - , ,
. - .
, . , -
. , .
, , , .
( )
. , - . -
, . - ( ) / , , -
. , . -
, , - , . - , , -
17. 19. (Stoianovich, 1960). , - . /
, . 18. -
, , - . -
, , . -
-
, / / : ... ...
1032
18. , , , -
. , , 18. .
. -
, . , -
. ,
. , - , , , - ,
- , - .
. -
, , , , , , , , (Stoiano-
vich, 1960). . , -
/ . -, .
, , .
( 1690) .
, -
. , , ( -
, , , ). , , . , -
( ). , , 19. ( , 1998).
/ , , -
. ( [ ] ), - , -
. : ( , )
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1033
, , . ( , 2011: 139).
, , -
.
, , . , , ( ) ,
. , , . , -
, , .
/ , , . - ,
19. , - .
, 10.000, , -
. 1991. - -
. , , , -
, , . , ,
. web-site (www.scd-lunjina.org) - . , -
, , . - - .
, , . -
, . , , ( -
) -, .
.
, -
-
, / / : ... ...
1034
. 10. 14. , , .
, . ( 1014, ) -
, , ,
. , , .
14. - , .
, . , ,
( , 1989: 147156). , ,
. , 14. ( , 2005: 3839, , 1996:
49). , . -, ,
( ) , .
, - , -,
, , . - , - .
( , ) . (14. 15. )
( irkovic, 2004: 6061). - , -
, , - , -
. , ,
( , ) ( , . ., , 2008). ,
( , 1996: 4950). , -
, -. -
, , .
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1035
15. 16. - , -
. , - .
- ,
. - ( , ), (
). ( ) ( , 19. ).
( 15, 16. 17. ) -
. , , .
( ) (Roksandic, 2002: 88102). , , -
( , ), - ( ) .
, - , , - , ( , 2007: 130; irkovic, 1997:
184; , 2008; , 2002: 106). -
. - , , -
, . - , . -
. ( , 2008: 6970) Transhumance ( ) ( ,
), , . -
. , ,
18. . .
?
?
- 14. 17. .
, ,
-
, / / : ... ...
1036
. , , .
- . , , , ,
. .
. - , ,
. . , -
, - , .
16. , - , . , , ,
. , - -
18. , -; , .
. - -
. 18.
- , - . ,
. - -
. , - - .
18. - . - . , , -
, -, , . -
. , - - . ,
- . .
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1037
, ,
( , 2002: 6567). , - -
( ). ,
, , , .
, -, .
,
. , , -
, ( ) ,
, , ( , ).
, .
. ( ,
2002: 67). , -
, - , , ;
( ), . ,
, - .
, , -, . -
, , - , , ,
, - . ( , 2008: 8182)
, ; , -- , -
, , -
-
, / / : ... ...
1038
, , , ( , 2003: 6871).
, -, , .
, - ( ) , ,
, , - . , - , -
, .
, . . - , - ,
. , - - , ( , 2008:
65). , : - ,
( , 2002: 101). - ,
- , .
- ( ),
. :
- ( ,
, , , - ). ,
, , , ; - ( ?) .
, ; -
, . , -
, , . (19911995), -
, , .
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1039
, - - . , -
. - ,
. , , 19. -
. : ( - ), , , -
, , , , .
, - . , -
, - , .
( )
. - -
17. . 18. . -
19. , .
, 1790. . -
/ - , , .
, . 19. .
, , 18. 19. . , ,
. 19. , , ,
. 19. . ,
, - , .
-
, / / : ... ...
1040
19. . , ,
, - .
. , - ,
, . , - - . , ,
, . , , -
, , ; , 1867,
- . , .
, , , -
( , , , -- ). -
1834. 6,1%, 1910. - 13% (Sundhausen, 2009: 163). 1887. -
35.000, 89.000 1910. , -
. . :
45 1885, 124 1910; 11 1885, 47 1910. -; 79 1885;
: 56 1885, 184 1910. 35 1885, 1914. 104 ( , 2008: 187189).
- , ; -
, . .
. . . ,
. , - , .
- ( ) , ,
. -- , , .
1880- . .
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1041
, , , .
. ,
, . -
. . - , -
1865. , . , 19. ,
, , . , /
, - . -
, , . -
. -, .
-, -, , .
-, .
, ( , ), , -
. ,
(1937). ( - , . 311480) ,
2.000 150 .
, , -
, . - . ( , 1994) .
- , -
( , 2005). -, , .
-
, / / : ... ...
1042
-
, , - . -
. , , /
, , . ,
( , 2001) , - .
, , .
1989. , . Triplex Confinium
/ - . ,
, . , . , ,
. , , . ,
, .
. , -
, . - , -
. , -, . ,
, . , -
. , , .
- -
. , indigenous people.
,
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1043
, - .
( , , ) -
, . -
- . , ,
, , .
, . - - . ,
, - .
- ( ) , .
, . - , Farsaroul
Freiburg , .
. - , ,
. , , -
, , - - .
, - ,
, -
, . / ,
, . , / . , ,
. .
-
, / / : ... ...
1044
1. The Balkan Vlachs/Aromanians Avakening, National Policies, Assimilation, , ,
2006. , (20022004) .
: , vol. 5, 2, 2008 ( ), : www.scd-lunjina.org.
Abadzi, Helen: The Vlachs of Greece and their Misunderstood History (2003), www.farsarotul.org/n126_1.htm
Antonijevic, Dragoslav: Cattlebreeders Migration in the Balkans through Centuries, Migration in Balkan History, , 1989, . 147156; , , -
, : , Vol. 37, 2005: 3546. , , , : , 2004.
, , : , 2002. , , , , :
, : Equilibrium, 1997. irkovic, Sima, The Serbs, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2004.
Fine, J. A. Fine, When Ethnicity did not matter in the Balkans, Ann Arbor: The Uni-versity of Michigen Press, 2006.
Geary, Patrick, : , : -, 2007.
Goldstein, Ivo, , : , 2003. Heather, Peter: Empires and Barbarians: The Fall of Rome and the Birth of Europe,
Oxford University Press, 2009. , , 16.
20. , : , : , 1996, . 4981.
, , - , 2001; http://dokumenta.scd-lunjina.org/free/Cincari_i_elita.pdf
, , , -: , 1962.
, , : -, : , 2002.
, ., , , 1994. , , 1658. 1666.
, 32, 2007: 119182. Lindner, R.: What was a nomadic tribe?, Comparative Studies in Society and His-
tory, 1982, Vol. 24, No. 4, pp. 689711. Lote, Lois, L. (ed): Transylvania and the Theory of Daco-Roman-Rumanian Con-
tinuity, 1982; www.hungariahi.hustory/lib//trans/trans00.htm.
-
, Vol. XLVI (2012), no. 34, . 10181045
1045
, ., - , : , 2005.
, , , , , 2003. , , , :
, 2009. , ,
, http://mlicanin.weebly.com/uploads/3/0/9/1/3091963/ i.2.jusufmulic.pdf ( ), . 111146.
McNeill J. R. and William McNeill, The Human Web, New York: Norton, 2003. , . .,
, : , 1998. Praga, Giuseppe, History of Dalmatia, Pisa: Giardini Editori e Stampatori, 1993.
, , Triplex Confinium, : , 2003. Schwandner-Sievers, Stephanie: Times Past: References for the Construction of Lo-
cal Order in Present-day Albania, in: Todorova Maria (ed.), Balkan Identities, London: Hurst & Company, 2004, pp. 103128.
Stoianovich, Traian, The Conquering Balkan Orthodox Merchants, Journal of Eco-nomic History, Vol. 20, No. 2 (Juny, 1960), pp. 234313.
, , : - 18901914, : , 2008.
Tanasoca, Nikolae-Serban: Balkan Romanity, in: Theodorescu, R., and Barrows, L. C.: Politics and Change in Southeastern Europe, Bucharest: Unesco/Cepes, 2001.
, , , : , 2010. , : : , : , Vol. 6, . 6, 2008, . 5594.
Winnfrith, T. J., The Vlachs: The History of a Balkan People, New York: St. Martin Press, 1987. [ ], The Origins of the Rumanians, www.history.hu/lib/dunay/dunay/02.htm. Wolf, Larry, Venice and the Slavs: The Discovery of Dalmatia in the Age of Enlight-
enment, Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2011. , , 19. 21. , : Clio, 2009.
Zbuchea, Gheorghe, , Editura MIRTON, Timi oara, 2002 ( - ).
Miroslav Ruica Belgrade
S u m m a r y
Balkanian Vlachs/Aromanians/Tzintzars Theses for a Somewhat
Different Reading of Balkan and Serb History and Culture In this paper, the author delineates the historical development and contemporaty des-
tiny of Balkan Vlachs/Aromanians/Tzintzars, who have played a significant role in political, economical and cultural life in almost all Balkan countries. A special attention is paid to cur-rent controversies about Vlach identity and status in Balkan countries, including Serbia.
Key words: the Balkan Peninsula, Vlachs, Aromanians, history of Serbia, identity
top related