mobility scooters for an ageing society presented by ling suen, icsa inc. canada authors: daniel...
Post on 14-Dec-2015
220 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
1
Mobility Scooters for an Ageing Society
Presented by Ling Suen, ICSA Inc. Canada
Authors: Daniel Blais, Transport Canada Uwe Rutenberg, Rutenberg Design Inc. Ling Suen, ICSA Inc.
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India 2
Two studies carried out in Canada • Province of Quebec Study• Focused on infrastructure and rights of way
• Considered ‘social mobility’ (mobility aids) vs. ‘civil mobility’ (personal transportation)
• Government of Canada (Transport Canada) Study• Investigated transportability of scooters on other modes
of transportation
3
Purpose
• In Canada the population is ageing
• Independent mobility important to seniors’ well being
• Mobility scooters preferred by seniors for ‘automobility’
• Study to provide guidance on regulations and/or frameworks for safe operation of mobility aids
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
5
Scope of the Study
• Analyze and assess the environment (physical and regulatory) for three- and four-wheel mobility scooters, and to identify future needs for safe operation
• Four parameters were examined: • The scooter
• The user
• The environment
• The key stakeholders
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
6
Parameter 1: The Scooter
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
large 3 wheel scooter
Segway T3 Motion E-Bike Vespa motor cycle
7
Parameter 2: The User
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
Recreation / shopping / medical trips
Semi ambulatory/ mobility reducedSeniors
Professional use
9
Parameter 4: The Key Stakeholders
• Agencies responsible for regulations
• Transportation operators
• Manufacturers and suppliers
• Users
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
10
Methodology
•National and International Literature Review
•Consultations with public and private stakeholders
•Expert forum in Qualicum Beach, British Columbia
•Analysis of results of literature review and consultations
•Formulation of recommendations and conclusions
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
11
Results of Literature Review • International review (Canada, USA, Europe, Asia, Australia and New
Zealand).• No regulations in most countries, scooters considered pedestrians by
default (except Hong Kong), • Lack of consistent or systematic recording of incidents (except for
Australia)• Some technological developments to increase manoeuvrability and
stability• Predominantly rear-facing securement (no tie-downs) systems in
Canada, Europe, Australia and Asia. Forward facing securement (with tie-downs) in the US.
• Study being conducted in QC in 2011 to distinguish between motorized mobility aids and motorized personal transportation devices
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
12
Results of Consultations
• Questionnaire– 14 questionnaires were completed: 2 by federal
govt depts, 5 by transportation providers, 1 CCMTA, 1 by FCM, 1 by manufacturer, 1 by CSA and 3 by users
• Qualicum Beach Forum– Expert forum including participants from the town
of Qualicum Beach, users, BC DOT, transportation providers, local law enforcement and dealers
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
13
Results of Consultations
• Use on sidewalks and roads should be allowed• Use on highways should not be allowed• Vehicle plating/registration should not be
required• Driver licensing should not be required• Speed should be limited to between 8 and 15
km/h• Maximum length should not exceed 1300 mm
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
14
Results of Consultations (cont’d)
• Maximum length should not exceed 1300 mm• Maximum turning radius should not exceed 1500
mm• Maximum weight should not exceed 140 kg• Training by dealer is strongly recommended but
not required• Safety features (e.g. a horn, signals,
lights/reflectors) should be required
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
16
Results of Qualicum Beach Forum
• Scooters used on daily basis mostly during the day for shopping, recreation and medical trips
• Operate on sidewalks, bicycle paths and laneways (can result in land-use/ROW conflicts)
• Speed should be defining criteria for ROW access
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
17
Results of Qualicum Beach Forum• Support standardization and safety features• Dealers strive to provide training and advice• Further assessment required by regulatory
agencies• Law enforcement treats scooters as
pedestrians • Law enforcement assigns priority on user
awareness of rules over training, safety features and size/speed of scooters
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
19
Analysis and Conclusion
Factors considered :– Laws on passenger and vehicle safety, – Jurisdictional (provincial vs. municipal)
responsibilities over vehicle use, highways, roads and pedestrian facilities
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
20
Conclusions
• Definition of mobility scooter needed• User training required for safe operation • Users need to receive up-to-date travel
information• Standards required to improve safety of users,
pedestrians and carrier staff• Data on sales not easily available, particularly
for second hand sales
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
21
Recommendations
Proposed draft definition “A mobility scooter is a powered device intended to facilitate
the transport, in a seated posture, of ambulatory, semi-ambulatory or persons with disabilities. A mobility scooter is equipped with a seat with arm rests, a means to maneuver safely on various surfaces, and appropriate safety features. A mobility scooter has a maximum speed of 10 km/hr and is designed with dimensions and securement anchorage that facilitate travel in public transportation modes. The first generation of scooters typically has 3 or 4 wheels and is steered by a tiller/handlebar.”
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
22
Recommendations
• Hold a national stakeholder forum to validate definition and chart next steps
• Design universal battery connectors • Update standards • Mandate safety features• Specify realistic payload requirements• Develop signage
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
23
Final Thoughts
• Definition should be flexible enough to adapt to new technology
• Stakeholder involvement in setting standards is key
• Both transportation providers and users share responsibility for ensuring safe PMD transportability
TRANSED 2012, Delhi, India
top related