rhic 能区的集体流和能量扫描
Post on 11-Jan-2016
95 Views
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
1Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
RHIC能区的集体流和能量扫描
马余刚中国科学院上海应用物理研究所
Outline:•Flow Introduction •Results (1): Flow measurements at RHIC•Results (2): Flow Theory•Summary•Outlook
3Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Elliptic flow v2 Elliptic flow v2
x
zy
px
py
y
x
● Non-central A+A collisions: azimuthally anisotropic distribution of particles in coordinate-space● Density gradients and interactions between the particles: an asymmetry in momentum-space● Signal is self-quenching with time – early time observable! ● Measurement: Fourier expansion of the azimuthal angle (φ-Ψ) distributions
(mid-rapidity)
4Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Azimuthal Distributions
Systematic measurements as a function of particle mass and taking into account time scale
• v0 Radial flow integrated over evolution • v1 Directed flow early• v2 Elliptic flow early• vn ……..
Fourier Analysis of azimuthal particle distribution
v1, v2, vn largest at intermediate impact parameters, zero at b = 0 and b = 2R
5Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Flow (radial, directed and elliptic)
x
y
x
y
z
x
• Only type of transverse flow in central collision (b=0) is radial flow.
• Integrates pressure history over complete expansion phase
• Elliptic flow, caused by anisotropic initial overlap region (b > 0).
• More weight towards early stage of expansion.
• Directed flow, sensitive to earliest collision stage (pre-equilibrium, b > 0)
6Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
RHIC
v1,v2,v4
LHC
v1,v2,v4,...
and elliptic flow
2009
7Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Part II:
Flow measurements at RHIC:
8Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Directed flow at RHIC
rapidity
v1
Looking for the ‘wiggle’:
Directed flow is most sensitive to the initial conditions
z
x
Radial flow <x px> > 0
rapidity
px, v1
R. Snellings, H. Sorge, S.V., F. Wang, Nu Xu, PRL 84 (2000) 2803
x
rapidity
px
xBaryon stopping
“ wiggle”
v1 is found being independent of collision systems.
PRL 101, 252301 (2008)
9Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Longitudinal scaling for v1
PHOBOS: Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 012301 (2006)
1. v1~0 at mid rapidity and decrease with eta till Ybeam, then turnover at larger eta: probably the proton and nucl frag dominate identified hadron v1 requested
2. The same curve for different size system and energyLimiting fragmentation holds for different energies, collision systems and harmonics.
3. No model is successful to reproduce the above scaling: AMPT can only predicted approximate scaling for each colliding species separately. theory to be developed.
STAR: Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 252301 (2008)
= η - ybeam
Ymid
Pro
ton
& n
ucl f
rag.
dom
inat
10
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Elliptic Flow
y
x
py
px
coordinate-space-anisotropy ⇔ momentum-space-anisotropy
Established by geometry - early timesFirst observed at BEVALAC and at SATURNE
11
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
v2 Excitation Function
Rich structure:
Transition from in-plane to out-of-plane and back to in-plane emission:
Low Ebeam: rotational behavior;Mid Ebeam: squeeze-outHigh Ebeam: pressure-induced in-plane emission
12
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
STAR, PRL90 032301 (2003)
b ≈ 4 fm
“central” collisions
b ≈ 6.5 fm
midcentral collisions
Resulting azimuthal distributionsResulting azimuthal distributions
13
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
STAR, PRL90 032301 (2003)
b ≈ 4 fmb ≈ 6.5 fmb ≈ 10 fm
peripheral collisions
Resulting azimuthal distributionsResulting azimuthal distributions
14
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
STAR, PRL90 032301 (2003)
“v2”
observed momentum anisotropy is largely elliptic deformation; its amplitude is denoted v2
RHIC v2 reaches large values yielded by hydro (unlike lower energies)Hydrodynamiccalculation ofsystem evolution
Elliptic flowElliptic flow
15
Low pt: mass splitting
•Ideal hydro can describe the data very well, QGP EoS is a reasonable choice•Blast wave model can also fit the data with a set of four parameters.
16
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
KET = (mT-m0)/nq
PRL. 98, 162301 (2007)
1. Number-of-constituent-quark scaling (meson vs baryon)
2. v2(pT) /nquark vs. KET/nquark becomes one curve independent of particle species.
QuarkMatter2009
NCQ scaling in middle Pt
17
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Multi-strange particle v2: Partonic Collectivity
Final word on partonic collectivity at RHIC!
STAR data (S. Shi et al)
PHENIX π and p: nucl-ex/0604011v1NQ inspired fit: X. Dong et al. Phy. Let. B 597 (2004) 328-332
J. Zuo, J.Y.Chen,X. Cai, YGM, F. Liu et al., EPJC 55,463(2008)
18
High Pt region: non-flow effect, such as partonic Eloss induced correlation
STAR
•Different path-length of parton travserse the medium induced Partonic Eloss azimuthal anisotropy•Data: Au+Au peripheral, dAu, pp similar (left) non-flow correlation•Different methods to subtract the non-flow effects were developed, such as 4-particle correlation
Y.G. Ma, Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
19
Exploring the non-flow in elliptic flow
g0 (hydro dominance), CFB1g1 (jet dominance), CFB0
A backwar-forward v2 correlation provides an experimentally accessible observable which distinguish collective and nonflow contribution.
Liao&Koch, PRL103 (2009)042302
Black solid line: collective flow-only; colored long-dashed: jet-only;Dashed-dotted: weighted contribution (1-g)<v2_F> (black) and g<v2_J> (colored)
20
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14QuarkMatter2009
Scaling generally holds in Cu+Cu at 200GeV.Some deviation at more peripheral collisions.
phenix preliminary
KET/nq [GeV/c] KET/nq [GeV/c] KET/nq [GeV/c]
KET/nq [GeV/c] KET/nq [GeV/c]
NCQ Scaling in Small System(PHENIX)
21
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
NQ roughly works at forward rapidity
NCQ Scaling, Forward Rapidity
QM09 talk by S. Sander
BRAHMS Preliminary
22
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
ρ0 v2, Probe Late Stage Dynamics
Long lifetime, balance between daughter rescattering and ρ0 regeneration.Sensitive to dynamics between chemical and kinetic freeze-out.Significant ρ0 v2 observed.(n=2, quark level; n=4, hadronic level; preliminary n=4.7 with large error, no conlusion yet)
QM09 talk by P. Fachini
23
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Test Hydro in Small System Ideal hydro: P. Huovinen
pT < 2 GeV/c Smaller v2 for heavier
hadrons as expected from hydrodynamics.
Sizable v2(Ξ) even in small system
Ideal hydro fails to reproduce the data
Fluctuation of v2? Viscosity ? Incomplete thermalization ?
STAR preliminary
24
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
v2 in Cu + Cu (Au +Au) at 200 and 62.4 GeV are comparable within statistical errors
v2 at Cu + Cu 62.4 GeV ~ 12.5 M events- Same procedure used for 200 GeV. - Event plane resolution is 0.088 0.004 in 0 - 60 %, about factor 2 smaller than that in 200 GeV due to lower multiplicity.
STAR Au + Au 200 GeV : PRC77, 054901 (2008) Au + Au 62.4 GeV : PRC75, 054906 (2007)
Energy Dependence
STAR preliminary
25
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
STAR preliminary
Au + Au at 200 GeV
Au + Au : PRC77, 054901 (2008)
System Size Dependence
Does v2 in most central reach ideal hydrodynamic limit ?
v2 scaled by eccentricityRemove the initial geometry effect
v2 seems solely depending on initial geometry and number of participant in 200 GeV collisions
v2 ∝ v2(ε, Npart)
27
Centrality dependence of v2
• Partonic transport model can describe the v2(b)• But, a large parton cross section is needed!
28
Pseudo-rapidity dependence of v2
v2(eta) roughly agrees with scaling proportional to the charged particle density
hydro+afterburner describe v2(eta) well
v2(eta-ybeam) scaling in frag region limiting fragmentation picture
29
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
STAR preliminary
v2/ε scaling: S. Voloshin (for STAR Collaboration), J.Phys.G34(2007)S883PHENIX π, K and p: nucl-ex/0604011v1CGC eccentricity: H.J. Drescher and Y. Nara, PRC 76 041903 (2007), H.J. Drescher and Y.Nara, PRC 75 034905 (2007)
Ideal Hydro Limit
STAR preliminary
Hydro limitΞΛ p K h
STAR preliminary
Ideal Hydro Limit Even in central Au + Au collisions, fitting results indicate that the
system is still away from hydro limit
30
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
most perfect liquid in the world?; Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 092301 (2007)
31
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Effective η/s Extracted from Model
Caveats:Transport model motivated~ best for dilute system of massless particles no phase transition
STAR preliminary
Data shows particle type dependence, not a built-in feature in the modelCan viscous hydrodynamics explain the particle type dependence ? Inferred η/s depends strongly on the eccentricity model
T: π spectra slope 200 MeVR: Glauber or CGC calculation
H. J. Drescher et al, PRC 76 024905 (2007)
32
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
v4/v22 – An Independent Test
v4/v22 ~ 0.5 in Ideal Hydro
Borghini & Ollitrault, PLB 642 227 (2006)
v4/v22 > 0.5 in data
K=0 in Ideal Hydro, K>0.5 in data.
Boltzmann calculation : Gombeaud and Ollitrault, private communication
Preliminary
PHENIX Preliminary
PHENIX Preliminary
33
Similar scaling was predicted in Fermi energies: nucleon number scaling & v4/v2^2 scaling
In hydro by Kolb et al, assuming that quarks have no higher-order anisotropic flows
If quarks also flow, one get
Similarly, if v4/v^2 = ½ for nucleon, then V4/v2^2(A=2) = ¼+1/2*1/2=1/2V4/v2^2(A=3) = 1/3+1/3*1/2=1/2This is the case for the right bottom plot!
V2/A vs Pt/A&
V4/V2^2 ~ cst
V4/A^2 vs (Pt/A)^2
It is interesting to check p, d, t, alpha v2,v4 @ RHIC!
T. Yan, YGM et al., PLB 638 (2006)50
p, d, t, alpha
34
Light Nuclei v2 at STAR
Baryon v2 -- X.Dong et al, Phys. Lett. B597 (2004) 328
BW parameters:F. Retiere, M. Lisa, Phys.Rev. C70 (2004) 044907
The 1st observation of negative v2 at RHIC.No model describes the data.
d v2 follows A scaling, 3He v2 shows some deviation, need more statistics. => Final state coalescence.
35
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Heavy Q elliptic flow
• J/ψ flow : possible test of regeneration– Electrons from open c and
b semileptonic decays show nonzero elliptic flow
– J/ψ regenerated from c quarks should inherit their flow
c & b (+ J/ψ)
• Main criticisms– Flow seen at NA50(*) and NA60(**) where net charm yield is not that highFlow seen at NA50(*) and NA60(**) where net charm yield is not that high
• Indication of other causes that induce J/ψ flowIndication of other causes that induce J/ψ flow
• But then...– Absence of J/ψ elliptic flow would weigh against regeneration models which all predict substantial flow
(**) R. Arnaldi@QM08
(*) F. Prino@HP08
PRL 98, 172301 (2007)
36
Flow of directed photons
Rich structure of photon flow (Gale et al., PRL96 (2006) 032302; Chatterjee et al., PRL96, 202302 (2006))(1)Thermal photons; (2)photons from high Pt parton fragmentation; (3) Bresstrahlung and jet consvertion etcBresstrahlung photon flow has been also studied in low Ebeam, anti-correlation with proton flow was found. See the following figures. (G. Liu, YGM et al., PLB 663, 312(2008))
38
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Success of ideal hydrodynamics
Ideal hydrodynamics has correctly reproduced the collective behaviour at RHIC when pT<2 GeV/c.
Perfect fluid ! sQGP !
PRL 92 (2004) 052302
How small the values of viscosities will be?
To extract viscosities from experimental data, we need viscous hydrodynamics.
P.F. Kolb and U. Heinz nucl-th/0305084
39
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
What viscosities will do?
Shear viscosity:
-The velocity gradient are directly related to viscous behavior of the fluid
-Viscosities reflect resistance to flow
Bulk viscosity:
40
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Extract η/s from experimental data:
When extract shear viscosity, bulk viscosity is set to be zero.Should we neglect the bulk viscosity?
M. Luzum and P. Romatschke, PRC 78 (2008) 034915
Glauber 0-0.08 ; CGC 0.08-0.16
shear viscosity effect on v2
41
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Equations in causal viscous hydrodynamicsConservation law:
Evolution equations for bulk viscous pressure and shear pressure tensor:
bulk viscous pressure shear pressure tensor
Avoid two problems in the first order theory:
causality probleminstabilities Hiscock & Lindblom, PRD 31 (1985) 725
Israel & Stewart, Ann.Phys 118 (1979) 341
42
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
-dissipate to other places at late time
-smaller relaxation time, larger effects
-time averaged bulk viscosity is more important
Efficient large peak leads to instability?
(a) shear viscosity only
(b) with bulk viscosity, larger peak, smaller width
(c) with bulk viscosity, smaller peak, larger width
-decelerate cooling process
b=0fm, Au+Au
J. W. Li, YGM,G.L. Ma, Chin Phys B (2009)
Shear viscosity:
Bulk viscosity:
Relaxation times:
or
2. Central collisions
43
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Viscous v2 suppression:
-At low transverse momentum, bulk viscosity will result in about 40% additional suppression. This suppression is enhanced at larger impact parameter.
-bulk viscosity can not be neglected especially at large impact parameter.
44
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
difference about bulk-viscous effect on v2
bulk viscosity effects:
(a) Change the flow profile during hydro evolution
(b) Additional spectra correction along freeze-out surface
Song & Heinz: v2 will decrease, flow corrections only (a), , at freeze-out Monnai & Hirano: v2 will increase, spectra corrections only(b), ideal hydro for evolution
ideal hydro visc. hydro:
20%30%
Song & Heinz QM09 talk
Monnai & Hirano QM09 talk
45
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Heavier Q flow
• Resonance recombination model + Langevin simulation gives good description to spectra and NCQ scaling for phi and J/Psi.
L. Ravagli, H. van Hees,* and R. Rapp, Phys. Rev. C 79, 064902 (2009)
47
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
Single electron v2
• Hirano et.al. can describe RAA but not v2 for single electrons with a relativistic Langevin equation + hydrodynamics. The reason is unclear and it needs further studies.
Yukinao Akamatsu, Tetsuo Hatsuda, and Tetsufumi Hirano, Phys. Rev. C 79, 054907 (2009)
48
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
IV: Summary
• The flow is measured plentifully at RHIC in the past decade, The flow is measured plentifully at RHIC in the past decade,
NCQ scaling studied works in lower energy, smaller system NCQ scaling studied works in lower energy, smaller system
and at forward region. and at forward region.
• The new matter created at RHIC is the most perfect liquid The new matter created at RHIC is the most perfect liquid
known so far, which has a small shear viscosity / entropy known so far, which has a small shear viscosity / entropy
(close to 1/4π).(close to 1/4π).
• When extracting QGP viscosity from experimental data, bulk When extracting QGP viscosity from experimental data, bulk
viscosity effect may not be neglectedviscosity effect may not be neglected
• The hydro-limit is not saturated by the new matter.The hydro-limit is not saturated by the new matter.
• Still a lot needs to be done (both at RHIC and at the LHC)Still a lot needs to be done (both at RHIC and at the LHC)
49
V. Outlook
• RHIC detector upgrade will give more precise flow information for identified particles
• Beam energy scan: critical phenomena: non-monotonic behavior, or scaling violation of v2/e
• U+U collision: larger energy density• Thermalization in partonic level?• LHC run
50
Barrel TOF-MRPC finished for STAR
run3
run4
run5
One TOFr Tray with 28 prototype MRPC modules installed in STAR
since Oct. 2002
1/2 3/4 5/6 7/8 11/129/10 1/2 3/4 5/6 7/8 11/129/10 1/2 3/4 5/6 7/82006 2007 2008
Prod. Start40 MRPCs
+192 MRPCs+326 MRPCs+326 MRPCs+326 MRPCs
After STAR Construction Readiness Review in April 2006, MRPC mass Production in China started.University of Sci. & Tech. of China (USTC) 1210 (30%*4032) MRPCsOther 70% produced by Tsinghua Univ.
51
STAR Collaboration is planning for initial beam energy scan in Run 10 (fall 2009) Primary tool: search for anomalously large particle identified fluctuations with comprehensive particle identification for charged particles provided by TPC + TOFTPC + TOF
Fully China’s TOF complete in time for run 10 (fall 2009)
52
Fluctuations and the Critical Point search
Data sample 5k events
• 20 GeV data consistent with systematics observed at SPS
• Rise in fluctuations (K and -h) scale roughly with dN/d across energy and centrality – consistent with NA49
Ready for the Energy scan Critical point searchLarge acceptance means can do a lot with small amount of data
STAR Preliminary
53
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
A good tool looking for phase transition at low energy scan: the breaking of NCQ scaling of elliptic flow
• NCQ scaling for the identified-particle elliptic flow may serve as a probe for searching for critical point.
also see F. Liu’s talk (afternoon)
J. Tian, J. H. Chen, Y. G. Ma et. al., Phys. Rev. C 79, 067901 (2009)
55
Energy scan of v1 with AMPTJ.Y. Chen, J. X. Zuo, X. Cai, F. Liu, YGM, A. Tang et al., to be submitted
•AMPT gives larger $v_1$ at low energies than that at high energies, the same trend has been seen in data.
•The values are underestimated;
• The different sign of v_1 between pion and proton at low energies can be understood as nucleon shadowing and baryon stopping;
•when the transverse expansion is strong enough (e.g., at top RHIC energies), it overcomes the ``bounce-off'' motion and causes protons to change its sign of directed flow;
•Hadronic rescattering dose not change much on v1 with the melting version; but large extent with the default version;
•At Low Ebeam, the default result with short rescattering steps looks reasonable
56
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
predicted v2 increase at LHC
• 10% increase in v2 from RHIC to Pb+Pb at LHC is predicted by viscous hydrodynamics.
Matthew Luzum and Paul Romatschke, arXiv:0901.4588
Hirano et al W. Busza
57
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
predicted v2 decrease at LHC
• HYDJET++ Monte-Carlo model predicted a decrease in v2 from RHIC to Pb+Pb at LHC, due to more influential jets at LHC.
G. Eyyubova et. al., arXiv:0907.2190
58
V2 from 200GeV/c U+U at RHIC
V2(RP)(U+U) ~ v2(Au+Au)V2(PP)(U+U) ~30-60% larger than Au+Au at the most centrality
Masui,Mohanty,Xu, arxiv:0907.0202
59
Y.G.Ma Workshop on RHIC Physics and CSR physics, Weihai, 2009/8/9-14
elliptic flow to measure incomplete equilibration
• Even with 14 mb partonic interaction cross section in AMPT model, it still can not reach the hydro limit. It indicates that the local equilibration of the system is fully not achieved.
J. L. Liu et. al., Phys. Rev. C 79, 064905 (2009)
3 mb
6 mb
10 mb14 mb
Hydro limit
AMPT model with string melting
Au+Au 200 GeV b=8 fm
60
Heavy quark azimuthal momentum correlation as a sensitive probe of thermalization
• In high energy collisions of heavy nuclei, frequent interactions among partons of the medium and heavy quarks may lead to important modification of the initially existing correlations.
• On the other hand, hadronic interactiona at the later stage are insufficient to alter azimuthal correlation of DD-bar pairs.
• Hence, a decrease in the correlation strength when compared to pp collisions of heavy quark correlations in high energy collisions of heavy nuclei would indicate early thermalization among partons.
Tsiledaksi et al., arXiv:0908.0427
• A PYTHIA study for p+p at sqrt(s) = 14TeV, a base line:A PYTHIA study for p+p at sqrt(s) = 14TeV, a base line:• Modification or even the complete absence of initial existing correlations in Pb+Pb collisions Modification or even the complete absence of initial existing correlations in Pb+Pb collisions might indicate thermalization at the partonic levelmight indicate thermalization at the partonic level
62
V2 behavior can be understood as a thermal nature of produced particles
based on hydrodynamical behavior
V2 is proportional to the beta_T2: upper-left v2 only depend on eccentricity?Tf0: no difference between in-plane & out-of-plane, AuAu & CuCu; Different Npart different Tf0 v2 deps on Tf0
Phenix, arxiv.nucl/0908.0052
top related