sankina oil mills sdn. bhd. (takon production unit) 50450538 · dqs certification (m) sdn bhd...
Post on 26-Oct-2019
9 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
DQS Certification (M) Sdn Bhd (689316-X)
Suite 43-4 Setia Avenue, Jalan Setia Prima S U13/S, Setia Alam Seksyen U13, 40170 Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia. Tel: +603-3342 3259 (Hunting Line) - Fax: +603-3358 3299
MSPO CERTIFICATION
EXECUTIVE / PUBLIC SUMMARY
REPORT
Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production
Unit)
50450538
Unit 30-01, Mail Box 300, Menara Landmark, No.12, Jalan Ngee Heng, 80000 Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia
Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit)
5 - 7/3/2019
Annual Surveillance Audit 4
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 2 of 35
Contents
I. Public Summary Report ............................................................................ 4
1. Detail of Certification Assessment .................................................................................................................. 4
2. Details of Estates ............................................................................................................................................. 4
3. Assessment Process ......................................................................................................................................... 5
4. Summary of Audit Results ............................................................................................................................... 6
5. Audit findings ................................................................................................................................................... 6
II. Audit Report (Estate) .............................................................................. 7
1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 7 1.1 Objectives ................................................................................................................................................ 7 1.2 Scope of Certification ............................................................................................................................... 7
2. Audit Evaluation Process ................................................................................................................................. 8 2.1. Stage 1 ..................................................................................................................................................... 8 2.2. Annual Surveillance Audit 4 ..................................................................................................................... 8
3. Audit Information ............................................................................................................................................ 9 3.1. Contact Information ................................................................................................................................ 9 3.2. Audit Data .............................................................................................................................................. 10 3.3. Audit Result............................................................................................................................................ 12 3.4. Next Step ............................................................................................................................................... 13 3.5. Attached Documents ............................................................................................................................. 14
4. Audit Activities ............................................................................................................................................... 15 4.1. Stage 1 Audit .......................................................................................................................................... 15 4.2. Annual Surveillance Audit 4 ................................................................................................................... 15 4.3. Stakeholder’s Consultation .................................................................................................................... 18
5. Overview of Non-Conformity ......................................................................................................................... 19 5.1. Action Plan 1 .......................................................................................................................................... 19
MSPO Clause 5.3.2 stated that A waste management plan to avoid or reduce pollution shall be developed and
implemented. The waste management plan should include measures for: ............................................................ 19
c) Identifying and monitoring sources of waste and pollution ............................................................................... 19
d) Improving the efficiency of resource utilization and recycling of potential wastes as nutrients or
converting them into value-added by-products. Refer to Indicator as above. ........................................................ 19
Refer to Guideline on Wastes and Waste Products Identification and Disposal Plan for Estate and Mills (Doc.
Ref. No. F/007-06/2016) dated 22.12.2016 ............................................................................................................ 19
It was noted that there were action plans to control pollution, however, it was observed that it was not
effectively implemented as there was still evidence of diesel spillage on the ground at diesel storage tank and
used lubricant oil spillage from lubricant oil tray at general store which causes soil contamination and there was
no action taken to mitigate the pollution that has occurred. ................................................................................. 19
6. Conclusion / Recommendation ...................................................................................................................... 19
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 3 of 35
6.1. Opportunity for Improvement ............................................................................................................... 19 6.2. Concern Area for Next Year Audit ......................................................................................................... 19 6.3. Certification Recommendation .............................................................................................................. 20
7. Appendixes ..................................................................................................................................................... 22 7.1. Appendix 1: Group Certification Member and Address ........................................................................ 22 7.2. Appendix 2: Main business/processes at location ................................................................................. 23 7.3. Appendix 3: MPOB Licenses................................................................................................................... 24 7.4. Appendix 4: Order and Assessment Process Data ................................................................................. 25 7.5. Appendix 5: Map .................................................................................................................................... 26
III. Audit Plan ............................................................................................ 27
VI. Audit cycle plan ................................................................................... 34
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 4 of 35
I. Public Summary Report
1. Detail of Certification Assessment Date(s) of Audit: 5 to 7 March 2019
Type of Audit: Annual Surveillance Audit 4
Scope of MSPO certification: Oil Palm Plantations - Group certification
MSPO Standard: Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) in accordance to the MS 2530-3:2013 (Part 3): General principles for oil palm plantations and organized smallholders.
2. Details of Estates Management Contact Person: Kiu Heng Seng, Loh Soh Seang
Contact No: 013-3113442 0198835393
Email Address: ideal1_mgr@jcc.com.my,
MPOB License No, Scope of activity, Expiry date:
503994302000 Company: Ideal Enterprise Sdn Bhd (Takon Estate)
Click or tap here to enter text.
Activity 1: Menjual dan Mengalih FFB
Expiry date: 31/7/2019
BR No: 50450320
(For Estate has more than 1 site, please refer to Appendix 1)
Total land area Ha: 2,842.12
Certified area Ha: 2842.12
Planted area Ha: 2335.08
Estate - Estimated tonnages of annual FFB
Production:
Takon Est - 1.7.16 to 30.6.17 - 12mths FFB output: 45,151.06 mt.vs 53,090 mt. budget 1.7.18 to 30.6.18 - 12mths FFB output: 42,338.57 mt.vs 52,138 mt. budget MMP 1 - 1.7.16 to 30.6.17- 12mths FFB output: 48,714.27 mt. vs 51,307 mt. budget 1.7.17 to 30.6.18 -12mths FFB output: 51,014.94 mt. vs 51,653 mt. budget
Mill - Estimated certified palm oil (CSPO) and certified palm kernel (CSPK) and processing capacity:
23372.75 mt CPO from certified estates only 5373.27 mt PK from certified estate only
Current valid certificate: ☒ Yes - MSPO-3:2013
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 5 of 35
☐ No Date of Certification: 7/10/2015 Valid until: 6/10/2020
Other sustainability certifications: ☐ Yes (if “yes”, please specify)
☒ No Date of Certification: Valid until: Click or tap to enter a date.
3. Assessment Process Lead Auditor: Sahudin bin Sapiin
Qualification: Tertiary Working Experience: Minimum 10 years
Co-Auditor: Johari bin Mohd Nor Qualification: Tertiary Working Experience: Minimum 10 years
Co-Auditor: Borhan bin Abd Aziz Qualification: Tertiary Working Experience: Minimum 10 years
Observer: Noorainie binti Awang Anak Qualification: N/A Working Experience: N/A
Proposed dates of next audit: March 2020 Recertification Audit
Information on certified entities to be audited in five years cycle:
To be more focus on Good Agriculture Practice according to Principle 6, an effectiveness of safety and health and also environmental aspects.
Note: Auditors listed are meeting with competency criteria according to clause 3 (Table 1) of Competency
Requirement for Certification Body of Operating Oil Palm Management Certification Under the Malaysian
Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) Certification Scheme (ACB – OPMC 1, Issue 1, 01 August 2017) and clause 7
of ISO/IEC 17021 Requirements for The Accreditation of Certification Bodies.
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 6 of 35
4. Summary of Audit Results Audit summary and recommendation for certification.
This report details the audit results including strengths, opportunities, and weaknesses.
These results were presented to your management at the closing meeting of the audit.
You can use these results to improve the effectiveness of your management system. We
look forward to continuing our partnership towards sustainable business success
In reference to MS 2530-3:2013, the audit team recommends to DQS:
☐ Issuance of the certificate
☐ Issuance of the certificate as soon as implementation of corrective actions has been
demonstrated
☐ Maintenance of the certificate
☒ Maintenance of the certificate as soon as implementation of corrective actions has been
demonstrated
☐ Not applicable, due to extraordinary type of report
5. Audit findings Type of Findings Total number Responses from entities
Major 0 (Nil) Official signed-off
Minor
1 (one) Official signed-off
OFI 3 (three) Acknowledged
Issues raised during stakeholder consultation
To have regular interaction & relationship with local stakeholders - Jabatan Pertanian.
Notified
Official Sign-off of the assessment findings:
Lead Auditor Signature:
Name: Sahudin bin Sapiin Date:15 March 2019
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 7 of 35
II. Audit Report (Estate)
1. Introduction The Assessments conducted under agreement with Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon
Production Unit) at their production units to certify that audited sites comply with the
requirements of Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) in accordance to the MS 2530-
3:2013 (Part 3): General principles for oil palm plantations and organized smallholders.
1.1 Objectives The objectives of Annual Surveillance Audit 4 are as follows:
Surveillance audit
1. Changes to the certified client and its management system
2. Verification continuous management system implementation
3. Review of effectiveness of measures arising from the previous audit (if applicable)
4. Confirmation of fulfillment of certification requirements
5. Enquiries on aspects of certification (Complaints)
6. Review of any client's statements with respect to its certified operations (e.g. promotional
material, website, use of DQS logos and marks, use of the certificate)
7. Customer specific requirements
8. Others:
1.2 Scope of Certification This Audit Report details the evaluations of audit process and actual onsite audit activities of
Auditors to collect evidences basing on the requirement of seven principles in according to
Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) in accordance to the MS 2530-3:2013 (Part 3):
General principles for oil palm plantations and organized smallholders.
Audit result determines compliance of audited sites in the overview of Non-Conformity and
Opportunity for Improvement. The outcomes have been described from 939-D2-MSPO Guidance
- Part 3 (estate) checklist of each sampled estates.
Recommendation of Certificate releases in consideration of relevant issues raised by stakeholder
groups to gauge level of compliance against the requirements of Malaysian Sustainable Palm
Oil (MSPO).
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 8 of 35
2. Audit Evaluation Process 2.1. Stage 1
Stage 1 has been carried out to meet with the requirement of MSPO certification procedure. The
result shows that the organization has demonstrated their readiness to go for certification
2.2. Annual Surveillance Audit 4 This is an Annual Surveillance Audit 4 being planned and executed according to MS2530-3
standard reference.
Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit) is registered to function as group
management for certification where, the management system has been regulated within one unit
operation
This is Annual Surveillance Audit 4 audit after successful achievement of previous year
surveillance audit conducted 6th-9th March 2018 and organization has demonstrated their
maintenance of good sustainability management system.
Therefore, the summary report will describe the effectiveness of the Company’s implementation
and management of the principles and criteria of MSPO together with the documentation of the
company’s current management system.
The audit criteria are the certification standards as documented in the audit schedule as well as
the current management system documentation of the company.
Assessment has been executed at the site area with below GPS no (refer to Appendix 2)
Site(s) has been sampled and assessed as per inspection plan (refer to Appendix 1)
Notes: Sampling process was not applied due to site was registered for individual certification
Takon Palm Oil Mill is registered to function as group management where legal document, internal
audit, final management review has been retrieved from this unit. It was however, the process of
internal audit has been executed by Sustainability section based in headquarter at Johor Bahru,
Johor.
The member of group certification is listed as per appendix 1 of this document. Company
ownership has been demonstrated by official document released by the headquarter office. It
would be sufficient enough to demonstrate the relationship between holding group company
against operational unit.
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 9 of 35
3. Audit Information 3.1. Contact Information Management Representative at site
Name : Kiu Heng Seng
Title: Estate Junior Manager
(Takon Estate)
Name: Click or tap here to enter text.
Title: HQ Management Representative
Name: Loh Soh Seang
Title: Estate Manager (Muis
Melewar Plantation 1)
Tel:+6013-3113442
Email:ideal1_mgr@jcc.com.my
Tel:
Email:
Tel: +6019-8835393
Email:muis1_mgr@jcc.com.my
Audit team
Name: Sahudin bin Sapiin
Title: Audit Team Leader
Name: Johari bin Mohd
Nor
Title: Co-Auditor
Name: Borhan bin Abd
Aziz
Title: Co-Auditor
Name: Noorainie binti
Awang Anak
Title: Observer
Tel +603-3342 3259
Email:sahudeng.spekiee@gmail.com
Tel +603-3342 3259
Email: johari.mohdnor@dqs.com.my
Tel +603-3342 3259
Email:borhan.abdaziz@yahoo.com
Tel +603-3342 3259
Email noorainie1405@gmail.com
Contact person at DQS
Ili Arina Anuar
Tel +603-3342 3259
Email: cse3@dqs.com.my
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 10 of 35
3.2. Audit Data Audited sites and sampling basis
Click or tap here to enter text. Ref. No: 50450320 Shifts: NA
Site 2: Muis Melewar Plantation 1, CL 105426784,
KM 45, Jalan Merotai, Merotai Besar, W.D.T.66,
91009 Tawau, Sabah
Ref. No: 50450320 Shifts: NA
Please refer to Appendix 3
Main business/processes at location, please specify: Oil Palm Plantations - Group certification
Please refer to Appendix 2
Estate size (ha) FFB Production (MT) Geo-coordinate data
Site name Certified
Area
Planted
area
12 month Production
(Financial Year)
North (N) East (E)
Click or tap here to enter text.
2842.12 2335.08 42,338.57 mt. 5° 05’
2.2344”
118° 48’ 49.9”
Muis Melewar Plantation 1
2320.00 2056.01 51,014.94 mt. 4° 27’
33.1848”
117° 50’
54.1068”
Sampling site in case of group certification is applied? ☒ Yes ☐No
Complete below section if ‘Yes’
Sampling process is meeting with Malaysian Sustainable Palm
Oil (MSPO) Certification System Procedure?
Site sample; S = r√n
S = sample size
n = number of group members
r = Risk factor (Low, medium or high)
☒ Yes ☒ No
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 11 of 35
List of the site Audit Year 2019
No Site Name Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y5
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
1 Click or tap here to enter text. ☒ ☐ ☒ ☐ ☒
2 Muis Melewar Plantation 1 ☒ ☐ ☒ ☐ ☒
Please refer to Appendix 1
Date Agenda sent to Client:
Audit sequence: ☒ The audit schedule was maintained
☐ The audit schedule was altered as follows:
Meeting of audit objectives: ☒ The audit objectives have been met
☐ The following audit objectives could not be met:
Closing meeting: A closing meeting was performed with the organization’s management. Audit results were presented, explained and, where necessary, discussed. Findings and corrective action plans were agreed upon with the respective managers, as necessary.
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 12 of 35
3.3. Audit Result
Current scope of registration: Oil Palm Plantations - Group certification
The top level of Management System manual and related management system documentation were reviewed and found to conform to all applicable standard requirements for documentation.
Current revision of manual:
☒ Yes ☐ No
Remarks:
In case of surveillance audit
Changes to the management system, its documentation, processes, or structures have been implemented.
☐ Yes ☒ No
Remarks: There is no changes to the management system.
In case of recertification audit
The overall system performance for the past certification cycle demonstrates the continued effectiveness of the system. (two criteria for evaluation)
☒ Yes, management review records
indicate achievement of established objectives and continuous improvement.
☒ Yes, trends of corrective action records
indicate effectiveness and continuous improvement.
☐ No, see remarks and corrective action
plan
Remarks: Refer to the internal audit report and all the report has been reviewed by top management.
Internal audits and corrective action records show continued conformance of the management system to selected standards.
☒ Yes ☐ No
Remarks: All findings had been closed within a week as per SOP.
In the past certification period, similar findings were identified repeatedly
☐ Yes ☒ No
Remarks:
In the past certification period, the certification was placed under probation or suspension or special audits were performed to address deficiencies
☐ Yes ☒ No
Remarks:
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 13 of 35
The management system is effective and fulfil the requirements:
☐ Yes
☒ Only partly – see corrective action plans
☐ No – see corrective action plans
Number of findings: Major nonconformities: 0 (Nil)
Minor nonconformities: 1 (one)
On site verification of nonconforming needed via follow-up / special audits:
☐ Yes ☒ No
The agreed corrective actions of the previous audits are
☒ Effectively implemented
☐ Not effectively implemented
Remarks:
☐ This appraisal is not applicable.
The current registration certificate was reviewed and found to be accurate.
expiration date : 6/10/2020
☒ Yes ☐ No
Remarks:
The Registered Firm Mark & Accreditation Body Marks are being used appropriately.
☒ Yes ☐ No
Remarks:
Risk Assessment justification Current Risk justified;
☐ High ☐ Medium ☒ Low
Lead auditor justification
☐ High ☐ Medium ☒ Low
Remarks:
3.4. Next Step Activity of the customer
Corrective actions: ☐ Corrective actions not necessary
☒ Corrective actions will be implemented and reviewed
for effectiveness as agreed by 6/4/2019.
Opportunities for Improvement: Identified improvement potential will be evaluated internally and incorporated into the continual improvement process if deemed beneficial.
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 14 of 35
Nonconformities, identified during an audit, shall be closed with evidence of effectiveness within
defined time lines. Otherwise, certificates may be put on hold or be withdrawn.
Activity of DQS
Type of the next assessment: MS 2530-3:2013 ☐ ☒
Advancement / Surveillance
Re-certification
Deadline of the next assessment: By March 2020
Next assessment data: (non-binding estimate of person days)
Planned date for next assessment: March 2020 (week or month, if appropriate)
For __4___person-day(s)
By ___2___auditor(s)
Main emphasis will be on the following subjects:
As per MSPO audit checklist
Customer requests: ☐ Information on
☐ Quotation for
☐ Telephone call from Customer Service Representative
Additional remarks:
3.5. Attached Documents
☒ Action Plans (corrective action requests) Number: 1
For DQS-internal use only:
☒ Basic Data
☒ Verified draft or current certificates
☒ Audit Schedule
☒ General Principles for Oil Palm Plantation
Audit Checklist
☒ Participant List(s) – opening and closing
☐ Further standard specific documents [if applicable]
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 15 of 35
☒ Stakeholder Consultation Report
☐ Others
4. Audit Activities 4.1. Stage 1 Audit Stage 1 has been carried out to meet with the requirement of MSPO certification procedure.
The result shows that the organization has demonstrated their readiness to go for certification
4.2. Annual Surveillance Audit 4 Surveillance audit was conducted on 5 to 7 March 2019 with total 5.0 man-days was allocated
according to MSPO Certification Procedure.
In summary, we have evaluated your management system as follows:
Annual Surveillance Audit 4
Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) Principle Principle 1
Management Commitment & Responsibility
A policy for the implementation of MSPO has been established by the top management of and emphasized on the commitment to continual improvement. Internal audit has been conducted timely as usual on annual basis with records of all the findings.These findings were closed in formatted forms showing the strong and weak points with certain potential areas for further improvement had been planned. Takon Estate and Muis Melewar Plantation 1 were audited internally following the latest Guideline for Internal Auditing and Management Review of the Sustainability and Supply Chain System (Doc.Ref.No T/001-03/2018). The Internal audit was well documented with Findings, Root Cause and remedial actions (corrective actions). Reception of report on 25/6/2018 and Reply has been done within the approve standard of 1 week. Internal audit report was made available to the management for their review. The continuous Improvement plan has been set and established by the estates focusing on the social and environmental aspects and that the implementations of the plan in ongoing as the weekly inspection of worker quarters, safety work condition in spraying of chemicals, manuring and FFB harvesting, handling of chemicals and diesel, management of domestic waste and its recycling, etc.
Principle 2
Transparency
The Standard of Operating Procedure on Consultation for Employees & other Stakeholders has been established. Representatives have been appointed to be responsible. The estate Stakeholders List is available and all records of consultation, communication and actions were updated and maintained. Takon Estate has established the guideline on traceability of harvested FFB whereby the inspection processes were done by Traceability Officer using the Traceability Checklist. At the same time, the FFB ripeness inspection was monitored based on "Harvesting In Field Grading" which was carried out on daily basis. The Daily Internal Transport and External Transport book was available where the recording of the driver's name,
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 16 of 35
time (in & out), block no., total bunches, gross, tare & net weight and comparison of the FFB weight between the estate's weighbridge with the mill's weighbridge were recorded. The Daily FFB Book Report was also well maintained.
Principle 3 Compliance to legal
requirement
The Standard OperatingProcedure on Mechanism to trace changes in
Legal Requirements were sighted and all operations were in compliance
with regulations for example the MPOB, SSM, Compressor License and
‘Perakuan Penentuan Timbangan dan Sukat’ – Akta Timbang dan Sukat
1972. Perimeter boundary was marked clearly on the ground and a Free
Prior Informed Consent (FPIC) also been applied where, the company
agreed to resurvey the land CL 11539892 and excise the disputed land
legally for the 42 claimants to apply their title from the authority.
Principle 4 Social
responsibility, health, safety and
employment condition.
Takon Production Unit has established Environmental Social Improvement
Plan-Sabah -N/009-1/2018 (Dated : 17/08/2018) together with the
implementation and action plan and assessment for further improvement.
updated on 05/09/2018.
The social improvement plan emphasizes aspects and impact identification
covering Pay & Living Condition; Communication & Consultancy; Fair
Pricing; Soil (Erosion, soil management, etc); about Water (water source,
rainfall etc); Energy; Operational Procedure; Training; Compliance to Law
Regulation; Local Development; Water Course & wetland; HCV; Pollution;
and Waste; human and reproductive right, complaint and grivances.
Sighted the Stakeholder Request Record Book and Stakeholder
Complaints/Grievances Record Book are well implemented. The latest
request by stakeholder has been recorded on 21/01/2019 and date
resolved on 28/02/2019. The grievance was about the requisition for the
sanitation of the grave area at Kg Murotai. No complaint and grievances
were received so far. Complaint and grievances form available. The box is
located outside the office. (Refer to "Record of suggestion box opening by
estate manager/assistant Manager).
Sighted that Takon Estate and MMP1 already communicate and implement
For safety and health purpose the management has fixed the emergency
shower and eye wash but it shall be prudent if the management could look
into the continuous functionality of the units so that it does not jeopardize
the function and ensure that it is in working order at all times..
The landfil was well managed by preparing scheduled dumpsite however it
could be better if the management can consider highlighting precaution
markers around dumping site to avoid potential accident.
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 17 of 35
Sighted the awareness and training programme have been organized and
been recorded. Evaluation assessment using the proper evaluation form
was usedfor the purpose.
In Muis Melewar Plantation1, the training evaluation summary are as
follows:
a) First Aid Training done at 21.06.2018 Participants : 26
b) Training SOP for Harvesting done at 14.10.2018 Participants : 99
c) Training for Driver done for every month from 12/7/18 and the latest is
16/2/19 with Participant : 34.
d) Chemical Handling done at 29.8/18 Participats:13
e) Rat Baiting done in Training of 'Pengurusan Haiwan dan Penyakit
Perosak secara Bersepadu" at 28/3/18 Participants : 11
f) Creche Ayah-"Cara bekerja dengan betul untuk Penjaga Kanak-kanak",
& "Cara Penggunaan Peti Kecemasan dan Pencuci Mata" at 04/3/19
Participants : 2
g) Workshop - "Jack" usage at 8/11/18 Participants : 34.
1. "Multiple oil trap" viewed on site for oil spillage containment.
2. "Systematic Oil waste and lubricant Storage Tank" been succesfull
implementeP and always been monitored.
Refer to SOP on Chemical Purchase, Storage, Handling & Disposal of
Used Chemical and Container. (Doc. No. H/005-02-2015) - 3.8.2015
CHRA was last done on 24/07/2018 by Klinik Mabello Paris Sdn Bhd.
Ref.No; HQ/17/ASS/00/26-2018/023.
Medical Surveillance to sprayer and manurers were conducted on
15/08/2018
Sighted that ERP Plan and Escape Plan for the Main Office and
Surrounding Building are available.
It was observed that office staff understands Emergency Response Plan
and knows how to escape if any emergency incident happen in the office.
The evidence of first aid kit at particular location during visit has complied
with requirements and found satisfactory.
Living quarters are provided with electricity and treated water - compliance
with the Workers' Minimum Standards Housing and Amenities Act 1990
(Act 446).
With Reference to the Guideline on Training Need (Matrix) for FY2018/19
which include all workers with the relevant document of training matrix,
material, attendances and assessment.
Example of trainings ;
1. Kerani store - 16.7 2018
2. Penyembur racun - 29.8.2018
3.SOP Sample air - 20.1.2019
4. Penjaga tempat kanak-kanak - 4.3.2019
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 18 of 35
Principle 5 Environment,
natural resources, biodiversity and
ecosystem
The Environmental Policy signed by the Plantation Director. Under the
Social and Environmental Improvement Plan (Takon Production Unit), the
Aspect and Impact were identified and action plans prepared, monitored
and implemented. Training on managing the environmental issues has
been conducted and every Wednesdays on each month at morning muster
call, the workers will be briefed on the importance of environment and their
social being as well.
Consumption of non-renewable energy was optimized and closely
monitored. Almost all the scheduled waste was managed following the
procedures available however mitigating the pollution aspect is still not
effective whereby there was evidence of diesel spillage on the ground at
the diesel storage tank and that there was no segregation of domestic
waste as well.
Land Use Change Analysis (LUCA) was prepared on 16.11.2017 for Takon
Estate and in Muis Melewar Plantation 1, Guidelines on Biodiversity
Conservation Management Plan For Estates was sighted. Common
species of wildlife has been sighted and recorded for all engagements or
sightings of rare,threatened and endangered species were available and on
13th May 2018 around 9am they sighted a herd of elephant at PM95A,
A08, 09 moving out from estate areas. Signboards on Prohibition on illegal
hunting and fishing were visible as well.
Principle 6 Best Practice
Standard operating procedures for best practices, business management
plans, pricing mechanism were available and consistently implemented and
monitored.
Ganoderma infected palms were observed during site visit however the
palms were left untreated.
Principle 7 Development of
new plantings
No new planting
4.3. Stakeholder’s Consultation Stakeholder consultation process carried out by taking a sample from the list of stakeholders
established by Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit). It was noted that the objective
of activity had met to capture the view, opinion and expectation of interested parties as a result of
operation run by the organization.
Details of the outcome from the sessions has been reported in 939-D4_MSPO Stakeholder
Consultation document.
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 19 of 35
5. Overview of Non-Conformity 5.1. Action Plan 1 MSPO Clause 5.3.2 stated that A waste management plan to avoid or reduce pollution shall be developed and implemented. The waste management plan should include measures for: c) Identifying and monitoring sources of waste and pollution d) Improving the efficiency of resource utilization and recycling of potential wastes as nutrients or converting them into value-added by-products. Refer to Indicator as above. Refer to Guideline on Wastes and Waste Products Identification and Disposal Plan for Estate and Mills (Doc. Ref. No. F/007-06/2016) dated 22.12.2016 It was noted that there were action plans to control pollution, however, it was observed that it was not effectively implemented as there was still evidence of diesel spillage on the ground at diesel storage tank and used lubricant oil spillage from lubricant oil tray at general store which causes soil contamination and there was no action taken to mitigate the pollution that has occurred.
6. Conclusion / Recommendation 6.1. Opportunity for Improvement
6.1.1. OFI 1
Sighted that Takon Estate and Muis Melewar Plantation 1 had communicated and
implemented safety and health procedures by fixing the emergency shower for emergency
purposes.
It will be better if Takon Estate management may consider to have regular routine checks on
the viability of all the emergency safety appliances to ensure the device are functional during
actual emergency.
6.1.2. OFI 2
Sighted that dumping site are well managed in terms of good landfill management by preparing
scheduled dumping site.
However, the management can consider extra initiatives to place precaution markers around
dumping site to avoid potential accident.
6.1.3. OFI 3
It was observed that there were ganoderma infected palms in the fields that were left
untreated and it would beprudent for the management consider treating these palms so as to
prolong their lifespan.
6.2. Concern Area for Next Year Audit 1. Employees safety and health
2. Waste management - recycling programme
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 20 of 35
3. Best Practice - IPM
6.3. Certification Recommendation This report details the audit results including strengths, opportunities, and weaknesses. These
results were presented to your management at the closing meeting of the audit. You can use
these results to improve the effectiveness of your management system. We look forward to
continuing our partnership towards sustainable business success
In reference to MS 2530-3:2013, the audit team recommends to DQS:
☐ Issuance of the certificate
☐ Issuance of the certificate as soon as implementation of corrective actions has been
demonstrated
☐ Maintenance of the certificate
☒ Maintenance of the certificate as soon as implementation of corrective action has been
demonstrated
☐ Not applicable, due to extraordinary type of report
Please remember to notify DQS about any significant change to your management system at
your earliest convenience. Together we will then coordinate appropriate measures to maintain
your current certification.
Report prepared on 15/3/2019
Sahudin bin Sapiin Lead Auditor for MS 2530-3:2013
6 May 2019 Shahrizal Ridzuan Ambak
Date Certification Decision Making on behalf of DQS
Click or tap to enter a date.
Date Document reviewing on behalf of DQS (Peer Reviewer 1)
Click or tap to enter a date.
Date Document reviewing on behalf of DQS (Peer Reviewer 2)
Remark: Not applicable in case of surveillance or special audit
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 21 of 35
Disclaimer: The contents of this report and all information received in association with the audit of the subject company will be maintained in the strictest
confidence by the members of the audit team and by DQS, in accordance with prior agreements.
DQS maintains ownership of this report. The content of this report and all information received in relation to the audit and certification of the
audited organization will be treated confidential and not disclosed to third parties. For exceptions e.g. disclosure to accreditation body refer to
DQS Certification and Assessment Regulations.
This report is considered as final by the audit team, if you do not get any adverse information from DQS within 14 days after the last audit day.
The recommendation of the audit team is subject to review and approval by DQS technical certification experts, who take binding certification
decision. An appeal process is defined in DQS Certification and Assessment Regulations. Should DQS obtain any information indicating
nonconformity of the certified management system, DQS will notify the certified organization timely and initiate investigation and evaluation of
such information.
Distribution
MS 2530-3:2013
DQS
Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit) - Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production
Unit)
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 22 of 35
7. Appendixes 7.1. Appendix 1: Group Certification Member and Address
Ref No.: 50450538 Company: (Sankina Oil Mills
Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit))
Date: 5 to 7
March 2019 Audit Year 2019
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
BR Number Name and address Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y5
50450320 Click or tap here to enter text. ☒ ☐ ☒ ☐ ☒
50450321 Pelita Estate, CL 115397496, Mukim Ulu Tungku, Lahad Datu, Sabah
☐ ☒ ☐ ☒ ☐
50450322 Muis Melewar Plantation 1 CL 105426784, Tawau, Sabah
☒ ☐ ☒ ☐ ☒
50450323 Muis Melewar Plantations 2 CL 245360523, Mukim Sungai Binuang, Ulu Tingkayu, Kunak, Sabah
☐ ☒ ☐ ☒ ☐
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 23 of 35
7.2. Appendix 2: Main business/processes at location Estate size (ha) FFB
Production (MT/ha/yr
Geo-coordinate data Coordinate No.
Site name Certified Area
Planted area
North (N) East (E)
Click or tap here to enter text.
2842.12 2335.08 18.13 5° 05’ 2.2344”
118° 48’ 49.9”
N5° 05’ 2.2344” E118° 48’ 49.9”
Pelita Estate 1100.90 1023.55 20.43 5° 8.803’ 56.006”
118° 56.006” N5° 08.803’ 56.006” E118° 56.006”
Muis Melewar Plantation 1 2320.00 2056.01 24.02 4° 27’ 33.1848”
117° 50’ 54.1068”
N4° 27’ 33.1848” E117° 50’ 54.1068”
Muis Melewar Plantation 2 1793.00 1481.00 21.84 4° 39’ 52” 117° 54’ 10” N4° 39’ 52” E117° 54’ 10”
Other sites, press tab to add more table and insert data manually
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 24 of 35
7.3. Appendix 3: MPOB Licenses Ref No.: 50450538 Company: Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon
Production Unit)
Date: 5 to 7 March 2019
License number Site registered
503994302000 Click or tap here to enter text.
Activity 1: Menjual dan Mengalih FFB
Expiry date: 31/7/2019
BR No: 50450320
503397002000
Pelita Estate
Activity : Menjual & mengalih buah sawit
Expiry date : 31/7/2019
BR No: 50450321
503926612020 Muis Melewar Plantation 1
Activity : Menjual & mengalih buah sawit
Expiry date : 31/5/2019
BR No: 50450322
503534402000
MuisMelewar Plantation 2
Activity : Menjual & mengalih buah sawit
Expiry date : 31/7/2019
BR No: 50450323
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 25 of 35
7.4. Appendix 4: Order and Assessment Process Data Audit Information
Certification No.: 50450538
Name of the company: Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit)
Operational unit 1. Takon Estate 2. Pelita Estate 3. Muis Melewar Plantation 1 4. Muis Melewar Plantation 2
HQ Holding company name (if apply): Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit)
Certified site address: Unit 30-01, Mail Box 300, Menara Landmark, No.12, Jalan Ngee Heng, 80000 Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia
Company Representative
Manager Kiu Heng Seng, Loh Soh Seang
Telephone Number 0133113442 0198835393
Email ideal1_mgr@jcc.com.my, muis1_mgr@jcc.com.my
Audit Team
Audit Team leader Sahudin bin Sapiin
Audited site
Site 1 Click or tap here to enter text.
In case of group management is applied
Site 1 Takon Estate
Site 2 Muis Melewar Plantation 1
Production Information:
Year of operation start 1995 - Takon Estate 1969 - Muis Melewar Plantation I
Total land area 2,842.12
Total planted area 2335.08
Soil type Peatland and mineral
First year of production (harvest) 1998 - Takon estate 1972 - Muis Melewar Plantation 1
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 26 of 35
7.5. Appendix 5: Map
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 27 of 35
III. Audit Plan
Version (date) 10/26/2018 Ref. no. 50450538
Company name Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit)
Site(s) Unit 30-01, Mail Box 300, Menara Landmark, No.12, Jalan Ngee Heng, 80000 Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia
Standard(s) Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) in accordance to the MS 2530-3:2013 (Part 3): General principles for oil palm plantations and organized smallholders.
Type of audit Annual Surveillance Audit 4
Audit team Sahudin bin Sapiin, Johari bin Mohd Nor, Borhan bin Abd
Aziz, Noorainie binti Awang Anak,
Audit scope Oil Palm Plantations - Group certification
Audit language English
Audit date
Audit criteria
— Requirements of the mentioned standard(s) above
— Relevant statutory, regulatory and contractual requirements for the management system
— Process documentation of the management system developed by the client
—
DQS Audit and certification regulations
Audit objective(s):
Surveillance audit
1. Changes to the certified client and its management system
2. Verification continuous management system implementation
3. Review of effectiveness of measures arising from the previous audit (if applicable)
4. Confirmation of fulfillment of certification requirements
5. Enquiries on aspects of certification (Complaints)
6. Review of any client's statements with respect to its certified operations (e.g. promotional material, website, use of DQS logos and marks, use of the certificate)
7. Customer specific requirements
8. Others:
Audit agenda Date / 5 March 2019
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 28 of 35
Time Subject; process Reference Unit; department Participants Auditor(s)
Date / Day 1 (05th. Mar. 2019) – Takon Estate
08:00
08:30 Audit process data
MPOB Licenses
Geo-coordinate, Basic Data, google
map
- Review of previous action plans
-usage of MSPO Logo
Management commitment and
Responsibility
Policies
Document reviews
Management Review
Internal audit
Continuous improvement
MS 2530-3
Principle 1
Estate
Estate
management
representative
JOH
08.30 Environment, Natural Resources,
Biodiversity & Ecosystem
(Environmental Management Plan)
Environmental Objective
Environmental Aspect & Impact
Waste identification & management
plan
Water management plan
Pollution assessment and action
plan
Energy Management
Non-renewable energy estimation
MS2530-3
Principle 5
Estate Estate
Representative
BOB
10:00 Best Practices
SOP, Economic and Financial
viability plan
Transparent & Fair pricing
- contracts
Contractor Management
Subcontractor List
MSPO Information
Contract Agreement
MS 2530-3
Principle 6
Estate
Estate
Representative
BOB
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 29 of 35
9:30 Social, Safety & Health
SIA
OSH Plan
HIRARC
Accident & emergency report
Complaint and grievances
Safety meeting
Contribution for sustainable
Employment condition
Training and Competency
MS 2530-3
Principle 4
Estate Estate
Representative
JOH
11:30 Site Management
Field Visit
MS2530-3 Estate Estate
Representative
JOH/BOB
1.00 Lunch Break
1.30 Stakeholder consultation JOH/BOB
2.30 CONT.
Social, Safety & Health
SIA
OSH Plan
HIRARC
Accident & emergency report
Complaint and grievances
Safety meeting
Contribution for sustainable
Employment condition
Training and Competency
MS2530-3 Estate Estate
Representative
JOH
2.30 CONT.
Best Practices
SOP, Economic and Financial
viability plan
Transparent & Fair pricing
- contracts
Contractor Management
Subcontractor List
MSPO Information
Contract Agreement
MS2530-3 Estate Estate
Representative
BOB
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 30 of 35
Audit agenda Date / 7 March 2019
3.30 Transparency
Information and Documentation
-Information from stakeholder
-Internal communication -
Stakeholder consultation,
procedures
Competent person
MS 2530-3
Principle 2
Estate
Estate
management
representative
JOH
3.30 Compliance to Legal
Requirements
Legal Register List, update
Compliance status
Land Used Right
Customary Right (if applicable)
MS 2530-3
Principle 3
Estate
Estate
management
representative
BOB
5:00 End of audit - - - -
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 31 of 35
Time Subject; process Reference Unit;
departme
nt
Participants Auditor(s)
Date / Day 3 (07th. Mar. 2019) – Muis Melewar Plantation 1
08.00 Opening Meeting
MS 2530-3
Estate
Estate
management
representative
SAH
8.30 Audit process data
MPOB Licenses
Geo-coordinate, Basic Data,
google map
- Review of previous action plans
-usage of MSPO Logo
Management commitment and
Responsibility
Policies
Document reviews
Management Review
Internal audit
Continuous improvement
MS 2530-3
Principle 1
Estate Estate
management
representative
SAH
08.30 Environment, Natural Resources,
Biodiversity & Ecosystem
(Environmental Management
Plan)
Environmental Objective
Environmental Aspect & Impact
Waste identification &
management plan
Water management plan
Pollution assessment and action
plan
Energy Management
Non-renewable energy estimation
MS2530-3
Principle 5
Estate Estate
Representative
BOB
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 32 of 35
10.00 Best Practices
SOP, Economic and Financial
viability plan
Transparent & Fair pricing
- contracts
Contractor Management
Subcontractor List
MSPO Information
Contract Agreement
MS 2530-3
Principle 6
Estate
Estate
Representative
BOB
08.30 Social, Safety & Health
SIA
OSH Plan
HIRARC
Accident & emergency report
Complaint and grievances
Safety meeting
Contribution for sustainable
Employment condition
Training and Competency
MS 2530-3
Principle 4
Estate Estate
Representative
JOH
11.00 Site Management
Field Visit
MS2530-3 Estate Estate
Representative
SAH/BOB/
JOH
12:30 Lunch Break
1.00 Stakeholder Consultation SAH/BOB/
JOH
2.00 CONT.
Best Practices
SOP, Economic and Financial
viability plan
Transparent & Fair pricing
- contracts
Contractor Management
Subcontractor List
MSPO Information
Contract Agreement
MS2530-3 Estate Estate
Representative
BOB
2.00 CONT.
Social, Safety & Health
SIA
MS2530-3 Estate Estate
Representative
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 33 of 35
OSH Plan
HIRARC
Accident & emergency report
Complaint and grievances
Safety meeting
Contribution for sustainable
Employment condition
Training and Competency
JOH
2.00 Transparency
Information and
Documentation
-Information from stakeholder
-Internal communication -
Stakeholder consultation,
procedures
Competent person
MS 2530-3
Principle 2
Estate
Estate
management
representative
BOB
2.00 Compliance to Legal
Requirements
Legal Register List, update
Compliance status
Land Used Right
Customary Right (if applicable)
MS 2530-3
Principle 3
Estate
Estate
management
representative
SAH
3.00 Preparation for closing All
4.00 Closing meeting - Estates MS2530 3
Estate Estate
management
representative
All
5:00 End of audit - - - -
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 34 of 35
VI. Audit cycle plan
MS2530-3:2013
Organized Plantation- Group Certification
Sta
ge
2 a
ud
it
Su
rveilla
nc
e
1st
Su
rveilla
nc
e
2n
d
Su
rveilla
nc
e
3rd
Su
rveilla
nc
e
4th
Recert
ific
ati
on
Ref. No. / AZ: 50450538 Date:
4 –
7
Ma
r
2019
Organization: Sankina Oil Mills Sdn. Bhd. (Takon Production Unit)
Lead auditor: (initials)
SA
H
4.1 Management Commitment and Responsibility
Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) 4.1.1
Internal Audit 4.1.2
Management Review 4.1.3
Continual Improvement 4.1.4
4.2 Transparency
Transparency of information and documents relevant to MSPO requirement
4.2.1
Transparent method of communication and consultation 4.2.2
Traceability 4.2.3
4.3 Compliance to Legal Requirement
Regulatory requirements 4.3.1
Land use rights 4.3.2 P
Customary rights 4.3.3 P
4.4 Social responsibility, health, safety and employment condition
Social impact assessment (SIA) 4.4.1 P
Complaints and grievances 4.4.2 P
Commitment to contribute to local sustainable development
4.4.3
Employees safety and health 4.4.4
Employment conditions 4.4.5
Training and competency 4.4.6
4.5 Environment, natural resources, biodiversity and ecosystem services
Environmental management plan 4.5.1 P
Efficiency of energy use and use of renewable energy 4.5.2 P
Waste management and disposal 4.5.3 P
Reduction of pollution and emission 4.5.4
Natural water resources 4.5.5
Status of rare, threatened or endangered species and high biodiversity value area.
4.5.6
Zero burning practices 4.5.7
AUDIT REPORT_ESTATE TPU AA4-2019 / 2019-02-14 All aspects of the audit are considered confidential
Page 35 of 35
MS2530-3:2013
Organized Plantation- Group Certification
Sta
ge
2 a
ud
it
Su
rveilla
nc
e
1st
Su
rveilla
nc
e
2n
d
Su
rveilla
nc
e
3rd
Su
rveilla
nc
e
4th
Recert
ific
ati
on
4.6 Best Practices
Site management 4.6.1 N
Economic and financial viability 4.6.2
Transparent and fair price dealing 4.6.3 X
Contractor 4.6.4
4.7 Development of new plantings
High biodiversity Value 4.7.1
Peat land 4.7.2
Social and Environment Impact Assessment (SEIA) 4.7.3
Soil and topographic information 4.7.4
Planting on steep terrain, marginal and fragile soils 4.7.5
Customary land 4.7.6
Use of DQS certificates, marks and symbols
Legend: P = required, to be planned; O= optional, to be audited when changes occurred or planned or previous NC; ✓ or X = audited N = nonconformity identified The lead auditor expands this planning individually.
(extend this table as needed to fit in all relevant processes)
top related