search for double-kaonic nuclear cluster (k - k - pp) using p+p reaction

search for double-kaonic nuclear cluster (K-K-pp)using p+p reaction

F.Sakuma, RIKEN

discussion is based on •Proc. Jpn. Acad., Ser. B, 87 (2011) 362-370., and•Phys. Rev. C 84 (2011) 015207[M. Hassanvand, Y. Akaishi and T. Yamazaki]

10GeV 陽子陽子衝突における二重Ｋ中間子核の生成 --- 実験フィージビリティ ---

1

experimental principle

8GeV

decay

the produced K-K-pp can be identified by bothmissing-mass spectrum M(K+K+)invariant-mass spectrum M()

2

production

expected K-K-pp cross-section• The free production CS in p+p collision is known to be

~ 10-3 x total ~ 50b

• The free * production CS at 2.83GeV is known to be* ~4.5b ~ 0.1 x

• The double- production CS is expected to be ~ 0.001 x ~ 50nb (= 10-3 x 10-3 x total)

• Thus, the double-* production CS is expected to be ~ 0.01 x ~ 0.5nb

• The DISTO result indicates the K-pp production CS is as much as * production CS, so we simply assume K-K-pp production CS to beK-K-pp ~ ~ 0.5nb

Of course, these are very rough estimations Of course, these are very rough estimations and depend on incident energyand depend on incident energy 3

8-10GeV proton yield @ high-p

Prof. Noumi

If yield of proton is assume to be as same as that of pion,

~108 proton/spill(6s) is expected with pp~8-10GeV 4

production-yield estimation

• CS : K-K-pp ~ 0.5nb

• Beam : 8 GeV proton 108 / 6s x 1 month (30d) = 4x1013

• Target : LH2 target 0.85 g/cm2

(= SKS target, 0.0708 g/cm3 12 cm)

~104 / month K-K-pp5

kinematics

[momentum vs. cos(lab)]

p(K+2) vs. p(K+

1)

cos(lab)(K+2) vs.

cos(lab)(K+1)

cos(lab)(2) vs.cos(lab)(1)

p(2) vs. p(1)

production & decays are assumed to be isotropic

6

B.E = 200MeV

K+

[momentum vs. cos(lab)]

kinematics (Cont’d)

- from [momentum vs. cos(lab)]

p from [momentum vs. cos(lab)]

cos(lab)(p) vs.cos(lab)() p(p) vs. p(-)

7

B.E = 200MeV

requirements for detector• wide-coverage forward-

detector in order to detect double-K+ and double- (0-60 degrees)

• good kaon separation in trigger level (pK<~4GeV/c)

• high-resolution and high-rate detector

8

n=1.008

n=1.026

KEK-PS E248 (AIDA)Past Experiment …Past Experiment …

9

12GeV p+p K++K++X

experiment @ J-PARCfor example …

+15

-15

+15

-15+45 -45

e+e- acceptance

K+K- acceptance

E16 spectrometer + hadron-spectrometerwith 108 ppp

10

acceptance calculation• As a first step, acceptance without magnetic

field is evaluated.• Angular distribution at the generated point is

used.

+15

-15

+15

-15+45 -45

e+e- acceptance

K+K- acceptance11

acceptance calculation (Cont’d)

detectoracceptance

(degree)

(deg

ree)

K+

- p

generated events

Acceptance will enlarge in horizontal direction if magnetic field is applied?

12

B.E = 200MeV

acceptance calculation (Cont’d)

detectoracceptance

(degree)

(deg

ree)

K+

- p

double-K+ accepted (~16%)

13

B.E = 200MeV

acceptance calculation (Cont’d)

detectoracceptance

(degree)

(deg

ree)

K+

- p

double- accepted (~0.7%)

14

B.E = 200MeV

summary of acceptance calculation

acceptance for the exclusive measurement is 0.0%with this experimental setup w/o magnetic field

double-K+ accepted event double- accepted event

15

acceptance = 16% 1600 / month acceptance = 0.7% 30 / month

K+

[mom vs. cos(lab)]

- from [mom vs. cos(lab)]

p from [mom vs. cos(lab)]

K+

[mom vs. cos(lab)]

- from [mom vs. cos(lab)]

p from [mom vs. cos(lab)]

decay :100% pp-- decay: 40%

Kaon identification

16

n=1.02

K+

[mom vs. cos(lab)]

however, proton contamination is … ???

experiment @ J-PARCother choice?

New proposed spectrometer with 108 ppp

17

kaon identification in trigger levelHigh resolutionHigh detection rate

anyway …

are elemental requirements.

from the Construction Proposal

summary• Feasibility of search for double kaonic-nuclear-cluster, K-K-pp,

using 8-10 GeV proton beam is discussed.• Experimental principle is:– 8GeV p+p K++K++X K++K+++– missing mass of K+K+ and/or invariant mass of

• Requirements for detectors are:– wide-coverage forward-detector (0-60 degrees)– good kaon separation in trigger level (pK<~4GeV/c)

– high-resolution and high-rate detector• With the upgraded E16 spectrometer, if double-K+ trigger is

realized in momentum region < 4 GeV/c then inclusive K+K+ measurement could be possible.

18

19

we will open new door to the high density matter physics, like the inside of neutron stars

Kaonic Nuclear Cluster (KNC)

20

T.Yamazaki, A.Dote, Y.Akiaishi, PLB587, 167 (2004).

Density [1/fm

3]

the density of the KNC is predicted to be high high densitydensity more than normal nuclear-density (0)

KKbarbarN interaction N interaction is clarified to be strongly attractive strongly attractive by Kaonic-atom experiments in 20th.

This leads the prediction of deeply-bound kaonic deeply-bound kaonic nuclear cluster (KNC)nuclear cluster (KNC), as many theorists pointed out.

21

Experimental Situation of KNC

FINUDA@DANE

We need more evidences in various channels!

DISTO@SATURENPRL, 94, 212303 (2005) PRL,104,132502 (2010)

stopped-K- + A ( + p) + X 2.85GeV-p + p ( + p) + K+

B.E. = 115MeV = 67MeV

B.E. = 103MeV = 118MeV

Because there is a discrepancy between THEORETICAL PREDICTIONS and EXPERIMENTAL OBSERVATIONS…

KK--ppppp?p?KK--ppppp?p?

22

Double-Kaonic Nuclear Cluster (DKNC)The double-kaonic nuclear clusters have been predicted theoretically.

How to produce the double-kaonic nuclear cluster?heavy ion collision(K-,K+) reactionpbarA annihilation

another choice, p+p collision

PL,B587,167 (2004).

The double-kaonic clusters have much stronger binding energy and a much higher density than single ones.(AMD calc.)

ppn

ppnK-

ppnK-K-

J-PARC LoI

8GeVdecay

23