sentencia inconstitucionalidad ley marco iglesia evangelica

5/13/2018 Sentencia Inconstitucionalidad Ley Marco Iglesia Evangelica

http:///reader/full/sentencia-inconstitucionalidad-ley-marco-iglesia-evangeli

v {Vbmrv}l hb idmld}xixrmildjcihjh 7?8%:> , Ip$0; vp xl

i

MLVXB ]R^VBEJ HB @R]XIMIJ]JCJ HB CL MLD]XIXRMILDJC

Xbgrmigjc~j# Erdimi~il hbc Hi}xvixl Mbdxvjc# }ibxb hb abfvbvl hbhl} eic hlmb$QI]XL0 ^jvj himxjv ]bdxbdmij bc vbmrv}l hbidmld}xixrmildjcihjh idxbv~rb}xl qij jmmi1d ~lv cj CimbdmijhjXIV]J DJJVJ HIJP CR^IJD# zribd jmxrj bd }r mldhimi1d hbJ~lhbvjhj Cbgjc hb cj IGCB]IJ HBC HIL] QIQL MLCREDJ Y J^LYLHB CJ QBVHJH# CJ CRP HBC ERDHL mldxvj bc HBMVBXL CBGI]CJXIQLDl$ :?2%6>:> zrb mldxibdb cj &Cby Ejvml hb cj Igcb}ijBqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}& beixihl ~lv BC MLDGVB]L DJMILDJC HBCJ VB^RFCIMJ bd abmoj xvbidxj hb }b~xibefvb hb hl} eic hibp y~rfcimjhl bd bc Hijvil Laimijc Cj Gjmbxj Dl$ =6$=18 hb abmojhlmb hb dlqibefvb hb hl} eic hibp i ejdiab}xjdhl cj~bximildjvij zrb cj vbabv'ihj cby qilcbdxj# hi}eidryb#vb}xvidgb y xbvgiqbv}j hbvbmol} mld}xixrmildjcb}$

JDX B M B HBD X B ]

:) Zrb bd abmoj lmol hb himibefvb hb hl} eic hibp# mle~jvbmi1jdxb b}xj }j Cj Mld}xixrmildjc# cj Jflgjhj XIV]J DJJVJ HIJPCR^IJD# ~vlelqibdhl Vbmrv}l hb Idmld}xixrmildjcihjh ~lv qijhb jmmi1d j ajqlv hb cj IGCB]IJ HBC HIL] QIQL MLCREDJ Y J^LYLHB CJ QBVHJH# CJ CRP HBC ERDHL mldxvj bc HBMVBXL CBGI]CJXIQLDl$ :?2%6>:> zrb mldxibdb cj &Cby Ejvml hb cj Igcb}ij

Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}& bei#xihl ~lv BX$@MLDGVB]L DJMILDJC HBCJ VB^RFCIMJ bd abmoj xvbidxj hb }b~xibefvb hb hl} eic hibp y~rfcimjhl bd bc Hijvil Laimijc Cj Gjmbxj Dl$ =6$=18 hb abmojhlmb hb dlqibefvb hb hl} eic hibp# ~lv mld}ihbvjv zrb b}



:> hi}~rb}xl bd cl} Jvximrcl}1> I 77 I 7? I ?> I:9?y 682 Dl ::: hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj$

oj xvbmb hb himibefvb hb hl} eic hibp b}xj ]jcjMld}xixrmild : jheixi1 bc vbmrv}l hb idmld}xixrmildjcihjh hbebvixl y lv bdl cifvjv mlerdimjmi1d jc Mldgvb}l Djmildjc hbcj Vb~rfcimj j babmxl hb zrb vbeixibvjd hbdxvl bc xbveidG hb

Vbmrv}l hb idmld}xixrmildjcihjh 7?8%:>

midml />2u tj} ojficb} cl} jdxbmbhbdxb} mlvvb}~ldhibdxb} jc~v1mb}l hb lvejmi1vx hbc hbmvbxl ie~rgdjhl I vbeixibdhlcl bcMldgvb}lbdbvl hb

hb cj Vb~rfcimj bd abmoj qbCdx$C}bi} hb

=) Zrb bdAi}mjcijEidi}xbvil

zridmb hb abfvbvl hb hl} eic ldmbi cj~jvj cj Hbabd}j hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hbcj xvjqb} hb }r Ai}mjc B}~bmijc Jflgjhj

'c'XB QJCCB@L HIJPI beixi1 hi$m$jebd# }ibdhl hbc]B HBMCJVB CJ ^VLMBHBDMIJ hb cj ~vb}bdxb i

DBCCIB @B

hb hl} eicL$ RDL /:) 0 Zrb bd abmoj lmol hb himibefvb

bPI mle~jvbmi1 jdxb b}xj ]jcj Mld}xixrmildjcc cjDJJVJ HIJP CR^IJDI ~vlelqibdhl Vbmrv}l hb

djcihjh ~lv qij hb jmmi1d j ajqlv hb cj IGCB]IJMLCREDJ Y J^LYL HB CJ QBVHJH# CJ CRP HBC ERDHL

MVBXL CBGI]CJXIQL Dl$ :?2%6>:> zrb mldxibdb cjcICbyEjvmlb cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} II ajeixihl~lv

HB CJ VB^RFCIMJ bd abmoj xvbidxj hbhibp y ~rfcimjhl bd bc Hijvil Laimijc

=6$=18 hb abmoj hlmb hb dlqibefvb hb hl} eiczrb b} qilcjxlvil hb :> hi}~rb}xl bd cl}

Jflgjhj

}b~xibefvbCj Gjmbxjhibpc ~lv mJvximrcl}Mld}xixrmi1

77# 7?: ?>: :9? Y 682 Dl$ ::: hb cjcj Vb~rfcimj$




}l}xibdb Bc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> > &Cj Cby Ejvml hb cjIgcb}ij hb Oldhrvj}& mvbj rdj }lcj igcb}ij# b}jigcb}ij ccjej0 &Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}&$ BcHbmvbxl bcieidj cj hiqbv}ihjh vbcigil}j jdxb}bi}xbdxb jgcrxidj j cl} bqjdgbciml} bd rdj }lcjlvgjdipjmi ~lv obmol zrb xlhl} cl} bqjdzb Chml} &}ld:> ei}el& ~lv :> xjdxl xlhl} hbfbd }bv vbgrcjhl} yvb~vb}bdxj ~lv rd }lcl bdxb zrb }b ccjej &MldavjxbvdihjhBqjdgbcimj Oldhrvj}&$ ]baijcj zrb b}xb Hbmvbxl qilcj cjcifbvxjh mldmibdmij y vbcigi1d ~lvzrb dl ~bveixb j cj}~bv}ldj} mrjC b} cj vbcigi1d > mrcxl zrb ej} }bjmlelhb j r} dbmb}ihjhb} b}~ivixrjcb} bd fj}b j rdj bcbmmi1d

gjvjdxipj : cifvb b`bvmimil hb xlhj} cj} vbcigildb} y mrcxl}}id bdmij jcgrdj# }ibe~vb zrb dl mldxvjqbdgjd cj}cbyb} y lvhbd ~rfciml$ Cl} eidi}xvl} hb cj} hiqbv}j}

dl ~lhvxid b`bvmbv mjvgl} ~iifiiml}0 di ojmbv bddidgrdj ~vl~jgjdhj ~lciximj# idqlmjdhl elxiql} hbvbcigild qjcibdhl}b# mlel ebhil ~jvj xjc aid# hb cj}mvbbdmij} bcigil}j} hbc ~rbfcl$& Cj Mld}xixrmi1d vbmldlmb cjhiqbv}ihjh vbcigil}j y cj gjvjdxipj$ Cl} b}xjxrxl} hb rdjj}lmijmi1d vbcigil}j >hb lxvl lvhbd }lcl lfcigjd j jzrbccl}zrb qlcrdx vijebdxb }b j}lmijd j bccjv bd mldbbmrbdmh j# cjIgcb}ij jdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} mvbjhj ebhijdxb HbmvbxlCbgi}cjxiq Dl :?2%6>:>v b} rdj igcb}ij$hbc B}xjhl oldhrvbail

ihl hlmxvidjvil y alvej hb glfibvdl }ld hjhl} ~lvt c & l$$$hi~rxj4 : / $ S

'@ & #

l} hbc Mldgvb}l Djmildjc ~lv :> xjdxl bc mjvjmxbv



ie~bxvjdxb }l}xibdb zrb# bc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> b}


hb b}xj cby b} lfcigjxlvil y cl} bdxb} idxbvdl} hb bccj# hbmjvjmxbv ~rfciml$ Dl mle~jvxb bc jvgrebdxl hb zrb oj }ihb cjMldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj cj zrb oj ~bhihl cj cby y ~lv bccj}b Ib mldmbhi1# b} idmldmbfifcb bd drb}xvj alvej hb glfibvdlb idjhei}ifcb ~lvzrb cj} cbyb} dl }b ojmbd j ~bximi1d hb rd~jvximrcjv$ Cj Cby Ejvml hb cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}dl b} didgrdj mldzri}xj }lmijc >vbcigil}j# b} rd id}xvrebdxlbd }r xlxjcihjh vb}xvimxiql hb cj cifbvxjh hb mldmibdmij y

vbcigi1d$ Bc B}xjhl hb Oldhrvj} hbfb jf}xbdbv}b hb himxjvdlvej} ardhjhj} bd mldmb~xl} qjgl} ~jvj vbgrcjv hbvbmol} xjdb}bdmijcb} mlel cj cifbvxjh hb mldmibdmij y vbcigi1d y ermolebdl} hb mvbjv igcb}ij} laimijcb}# }ixrjmi1d jrd ej} gvjqb$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ XVB] /=) 0 Zrb bd }r b~l}imi1d cj

hi}mvieidjxlvil ~lvzrb mvbj rdj igcb}ij mld ~vbbeidbdmij jcj} hbej$}# cj xbveidlclgij mldxbdihj bd bc jvximrcjhl bdmrjdxl j vbmldlmbv cj ~bv}ldjcihjh `rvihimj hb cj Igcb}ijBqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# dl b} ej} zrb rd brabei}elv ~lvzrb bdvbjcihjh :> zrb ojmb bc Hbmvbxl b} mvbjv rdj id}xixrmi1db}xjxjc zrb }b ccjej0 &Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}cc B}xjcby b} hi}mvieidjxlvij ~lvzrb Ib hj ~vbbeidbdmij j cj igcb}ijmvbjhj ~lv bc Mldgvb}l Djmildjc }lfvb xlhj} jzrbccj}mldab}ildb} vbcigil}j} zrb }i }ld vbmldlmihj} ~lv bc B}xjhl#ebhijdxb bc b`bvmimil hbc Hbvbmol hb ^bximi1d y hb Cifbvxjhhb J}lmijmi1d# yj zrb bcIj} }lcimixjvld }bv vbmldlmihj} mlelj}lmijmildb} $vbcigil}j} bd xjdxl cj &Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hbOldhrvj}II b} mvbjhj ~lv bc B}xjhl hb Oldhrvj} ebhijdxb rdjcby gbdbvjc$ Bc jvximrcjhl hbc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> mvbj~viqicbgil} zrb dibgj j lxvj} j}lmijmildb} vbcigil}j}$ ]i cj}




j}lmijmildt} vbcigil}j} dl ~bvxbdbmbd j cj MldavjxbvdihjhBqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# dl ~lhvjd glpjv hb cl} hbvbmol}b}~bmijcb} mldxbdihl} bd bc Jvximrcl 8 hb cj Cby Ejvml hb cjIgcb}ij Btjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# b}~bmiaimjebdxb bd cl}drebvjcb} t# 9# :> Y ::$ ]i cj Cby :?2%6>:> himb qbvfigvjmij

cj tgcb}ij Bqjdgbcimjrb ~rbhb mbcbfvjv ejxvieldil}vbcigil}l} :> zrb b}x$j zrbvibdhl hbmiv b} zrb b}xl} jmxl}}rvxbd babtxl} cbgjcb} y zrb hbfbd }bv jheixihl} mlel ebhil}hb ~vrbfj ~ hlmrebdxl} laimijcb}# }ieicjv j cj ab hb fjrxi}elzrb bxibdtb cj Igcb}ij Mjxlcimj J~l}x1:imj y Vlejdj y zrb }br}jfj mleb ebhil hb ~vrbfj bd mrjdxl jc djmieibdxl hb cj}~bv}ldj} d xrvjcb}$ Cl ie~lvxjdxb hbc j}rdxl dl b} qjclvjv }ixjc hi}~l}`$mi$ldb} mlvvbmxj# > dl# }idl bc obmol hb zrb cjIgcb}ij hb B}xjhl /Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}) }a xibdbb}xj ajmrc jh y cj} j}lmijmildb} vbcigil}j} zrb dl ~bvxbdbmbdj cj Mld vjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj dl xibdbd ~lv cby b}xjajmrcxjh# ~lv :> zrb }r} jmxrjmildb} zrbhjd bd bc jefixl hbcj} ~vjmx'mj}# xvjhimildb} y mvbbdmij} hb cj gbdxb$ CjMld}xixrmi3dhb Oldhrvj} ~vloafb mvbjv mcj}b} ~viqicbgijhj}mlel cj i3;b}ij b}xjxjc &Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} II ygjvjdxipj Bc hbvbmol j cj igrjchjh y dl hi}mvieidjmild$

MLD]IIIBVJDHL$ MRJXVL /8)0 Zrb cj vbmrvvbdxb ejdiaib}xjzrb bc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> qilcbdxj bc Hbvbmol hb J}lmijmi1d~lvzrb jc /vbjv &Cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}& hb}mldlmbzrb cj idxbdmild hb cl} mirhjhjdl} oj }ihb mvbjv j}lmijmildb}vbcigil}j} HIABVBDXB] rdj} hb lxvj}# fj}xj mld cbbv bc mvbhlhb mjhj rvj hb bCCj} ejdiab}xjhl bd }r mrbv~l b}xjxrxjvilj~vlfjhl ~~v bc ei}el B}xjhl j xvjqb} hb cj hb~bdhbdmij

t~bxbdxb$ Cj lfcigjxlvibhjh hb jhob}ild j cj Mldavjxbvdihjh

==




Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} MBO zrbhj j mvixbvil hb b}xj# yj zrbcj Cby cb ~bveixb }id mld}bdxieibdxl hb cj j}lmijmi1dvbcigil}j vbgi}xvjhj jdxb bc Eidi}xbvil hbc Idxbvilv#}lcimixjv bc mjefil hbc vbmldlmieibdxl mlel rdj LDG j lxvjmjcihjh `rvihimj$ B}xj Cby idxbdxj bcieidjv j xlhl} cl}gvr~l} vbcigil}l} mld jrxldleij y ~bv}ldjcihjz `rvihimj~vl~ij# ~jvj mvbjv rd }lcl bdxb hivigihl ~lv rd gvr~lvbcigil}l# bcieidjdhl cj hiqbv}ihjh vbcigil}j zrb jrd hbdxvlhbc elqieibdxl bqjdzbCi$ml bi}xb bd Oldhrvj}$ Bc Hbvbmol hbJ}lmijmi1d bd qivxrh hbc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> }jcb hb cj xrxbcjhbc B}xjhl y zrbhj }r`bxl bd xlhl }r mldxbdihl j cj}hbmi}ildb} zrb ~rbhj xlejv bc hivbmxlvil hb cj MldavjxbvdihjhBqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# oj}xj ccbgjv j cj mjdmbcjmi1d ycizrihjmi1d hb cj ei}ej mld cj }lcj lfcigjmi1d hb vb~lvxjv :>obmol j cj jrxlvihjh ai}mjc mlvvb}~ldhibdxb$ Cj Cby Ejvml hbcj Igcb}ij Mvi}xijdj Bqjdgbcimj bd }i ei}ej# b} rdjvb}xvimmi1d jc hbvbmol hb j}lmijmi1d ~vloifihj ~lv cjMldqbdmi1d Idxbvjebvimjdj hb Hbvbmol} Orejdl}0 Bc b`bvmimilhb xjc Hbvbmol /hb j}lmijmi1d) }1:> ~rbhb b}xjv }r`bxl j cj}vb}xvimmildb} ~vbqi}xj} ~lv cj cby zrb }bjd dbmb}jvij} bd rdj}lmibhjh hbelmvjximj# bd idxbvb} hb cj }bgrvihjh djmildjc# hbcj }bgrvihjh > hbc lvhbd ~rfciml# > ~jvj ~vlxbgbv cj }jcrh >cj elvjc ~rfcimj > cl} hbvbmol} y cifbvxjhb} hb cl} hbej}$ Dibd cj b~l}imi1d hb elxiql} hbc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> di bd cj}jmxj} hb hi}mr}i1d hbc Mldgvb}l Djmildjc }b b~vb}j zrb bcB}xjhl fr}zrb vb}xvidgiv bc Hbvbmol hb J}lmijmi1d mvbjdhl cj&Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}& ~lv vjpldb} hb }bgrvihjhdjmildjc# hb lvhbd ~rfciml# ~jvj ~vlxbgbv cj }jcrh# cj elvjc~rfcimj > cj} cifbvxjhb} hb cl} hbej}$ Bc B}xjhl mvbj



grfbvdjebdxjcb} j babmxl hb zrb &hb}mrfvjd& cj} fldhjhb} hbb}xjv jjlm`i$jhlj cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}#bdxvb bccjcx;cj hb glpjv hb rdj ~$vlx$bmmld b}~bmijc y hblfxbdbv fdbaimil} ai}mjcb} mldxbdihl} bd bc Jvximrcl 8drebvjcb} c Y ::$

MLD]ccIBVJDHL$ MIDML /2)0 Zrb mldxidrj ejdiab}xjdhl cjvbmrvvbdxbzrb bc Jvximrcl 1 hbc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> dibgj j cj}j}lmijmild$} hiabvbdxb} j cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb

lvgjdipjmi3d vbcigil}j#$$$cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hbOldhrvj} b0 bc ebhil hb vb~vb}bdxjmild q mlerdimjmild mld cj}

~lhbvb}# b xb} jrxldlel}# id}xixrmildb} hb}mbdxvjcipjhj}# j}imlel mld ct }lmibhjh miqic# be~vb}j ~viqjhj y lvgjdipjmildb}

djxrvjcbpj& Jc l}xbdxjv cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj cjv%b~v%bbdx$jzh ld cbgjc hb xlhj} cj} j}lmijmildb} vbcigil}j}#b}xj} }b qbd ie~l}ificixjhj} hb ~vb}bdxjv ~bximildb} jcB}xjhl bd mrjczribvj hb }r} hiqbv}l} lvgjdl} j diqbcdjmildjc$ ~jhj cj ml}xrefvb y cj idxbv~vbxjmild vb}xvimxiqjzrb ojmbd cl} l~bvjhlvb} hbc hbvbmol#vbcigil}j} zrb dl ~bvxbdbpmjd j cj Mldavjxbvdihjh }ravivjdcj} hbdbgj lvij} j }r} ~bximildb} ~lvzrb }bgrd cj cby# b}xbhbvbmol }b:> :> xibdb cj igcb}ij mvbjhj ~lv bc Mldgvb}lDjmildjc h Oldhrvj}# :> zrb b}xj bd avjdmj mldxvjqbdmild hbcJvximrcl ? mld}xixrmildjc y jabmxj hivbmxjebdxb j cj Igcb}ij

ebmjdi}el}

Oldhrvj}#&Jvximrcl

jrxlvihjhb0

lfvbvj}#


hi}rj}iql} cj} lvgjdipjmildb}jvj dl

: hbvbmol mld}xixrmildjc hb ^bximild mrjdhl himb0Cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} b} rdj

hb cj Vb~rfcimj# yj }bj mrjcb}zribvj hb }r}

fje~b} i$dj} # b}xrhijdxicb} y hb mrjczribv lxvj

cj} j}lmijmildb}



~vl~jgjdhj ~lciximj# idqlmjdhl elxiql} hb vbcigi1d l


hbc Hil} Qiql# Mlcredj y J~lyl hb cj Qbvhjh# Cj Crp hbcErdhl$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ ]BI] /1)0 Aidjcebdxb cj vbmrvvbdxb }bdjcjzrb cj Cby Ejvml hb Cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} qilcjbc jvximrcl 77# ~jvvj$Bl }bgrdhl hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hb cjVb~rfcimj ~rb} b}xjfcbmb0 &Jvximrcl :=$%$$$ Mrjdhl eibefvl}hb :j @rdxj Hivbmxiqj Djmildjc# @rdxj} Hivbmxiqj} Vbgildjcb}#y lxvj} hbdleidjmildb} hb CJ MLDAVJXBVDIHJH BQJDGBCIMJ HB

OLDHRVJ]# }b ~l}xrcbd j mjvgl} hb bcbmmi1d ~l~rcjv# cl}j}~ivjdxb} zrb jhbej} b}xrqibvbd b`bvmibdhl mjvgl}h$iv%bxCql}# ~j}xlvjcb} y eidi}xbvijcb}# hbfbvjd vbdrdmijv jcl} ei}el} mld rd jdl hb jdxbcjmi1d j }r ~jvximi~jmi1d bd cj}jmxiqihjhb} ~lciximj} hb cl} ~vlmb}l} idxbvdl} > ~viejvil}~jvxihjvil} $' Xjc jvximrcl b}xjfcbmb rdj dlvej zrb frvcj bcb}~ivixr hbc jvximrcl 77 hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimjzrb b}xjfcbmb0 &Cl} eidi}xvl} hb cj} hiqbv}j} vbcigildb} dl~mhv jd b`bvmbv mjvgl} ~rfcCml} di ojmbv bd didgrdj alvej

qjcibdhl}b# mlel ebhil ~jvj xjc aid# hb cj} mvbbdmij}vbcigil}j} hbc ~rbfcl &$ Cj dlxlvibhjh >~vlybmmi1d hb iejgbdhb cl} vbcigil}l} j}~ivjdxb} j rd mjvgl ~rfciml }b fj}j bd }raigrvj mlel eidi}xvl} vbcigil}l} hb cj} j}lmijmildb}jh}mvixj} j cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} y ermolej} ~lvzrb }r ~l}imildjeibdxl bd cj l~idi1d ~rfcimj y bd cjmldmibdmij hb cl} oldhrvbdl} b} ~lxbdmijhj ~lv }r ~rfcimihjh~bvejdbdxb bd ebhil} hb mlerdimjmi1dc b} ie~l}ifcb hiqlvmijvjc j}~ivjdxb ~lciximl hb }r mldhimi1d hb cihbv vbcigil}l bdcj mldmibdmij hbc bcbmxlv y b}xl b} b}bdmijcebdxb :> zrb~vloifb cj dlvej mld}xixrmildjc$ Cj Mld}xixrmi1d bd bc



Jvximrcl


:7$% Cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} /MBR)#

xvjd}ixlvi

d hbc b}xjhl }bgcjv# }b bdxibdhb zrb hbfb }bv rdjbigb zrb cl} j}~ivjdxb} j mjvgl} hb bcbmmi1d

~l~rcjvmldhimi1d ~bvejdbdxb hbc j}~ivjdxb# dl rdj mldhimi1d

&JVXIMRCL :9?$ % ^jvj }bv bcbgihl hi~rxjhl }bvbzribvb0 $$8$ ]bv hbc b}xjhl }bgcjv $$$&$ Vbdrdmijv jceidi}xbvil vbcigil}l ~jvj j}~ivjv j rd mjvgl hb bcbmmi1d~l~rcjv# d cj idxbdmi1d hb vbidxbgvjv}b jc ei}el rdj qbpxbveidjhl} cl} mleimil} bcbmxlvjcb} >bc mjvgl ~jvj bc mrjc

arb bcbmxl idhimj zrb dl b} hbc b}xjhl }bgcjv# }idl zrb hbejdbvj xv }ixlvij# hb`1 hb b`bvmbv }r eidi}xbvil$ Jvximrcl682 drebvj :: hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj0 &Jvximrcl

bcjflvjvj bc Vbgcjebdxl hb cj ~vb}bdxb Cby# hbdxvl hbcxbveidl hb dlqbdxj /9>) hij} j ~jvxiv hb cj qigbdmij hb b}xj#~jvj }bv ~vb}bdxjhl j cj ]bmvbxjvij hb B}xjhl bd cl}Hb}~jmol} bc Idxbvilv y ^lfcjmi1d ~jvj }r j~vlfjmi1d ~lv bc^lhbv B`b xiql y }r vb}~bmxiqj ~rfcimjmi1d bd bc HijvilLaimijc Cj Gjmbxj$ II Mld}ihbvj zrb bc Jvximrcl :7 hb cj CbyEjvml hb : Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# qilcj bc jvximrcl682 drebvj :: hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj# ~lv :> zrbb} ~vlmbh

ajmrcxjhb}

}b hbmcjvb }r idmld}xixrmildjcihjh$ ]lcl bc^lhbv ~rbhb hbcbgjv bd qivxrh hb cj Cby cj}

mld}xixrmildjcebdxb# dl ~rbhb bc ^lhbvCbgi}cjxiq hbcbgjv ebhijdxb rdj cby# rdj jxvifrmi1dmld}xixrmi jc hbc ^vb}ihbdxb hb cj Vb~rfcimj# }id befjvgl#

:7 hbc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:># bc Mldgvb}l Djmildjc#d bc jvxihbcbgj rdj ajmrcxjh mld}xixrmildjc hbc ^vb}ihbdxb hbc ^lhbvB`bmrxiql cj Mldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# ~jvj

cjflvb bc vbgcjebdxl hb cj cby$ ^jvj zrb cj


http:///reader/full/sentencia-inconstitucionalidad-ley-marco-iglesia-evangeliorejdl b} idqilcjfcb$ ^jvj gjvjdxipjv cl} hbvbmol} y


hbcbgjmi1d hb cj ajmrcxjh vbgcjebdxjvij j cj MldavjxbvdihjhBqjvizbhlj hb Oldhrvj} arb}b qjCi$hj # bc Mldgvb}l Djmildjchbfi1 vbalvejv bc Jvximrcl Mld}xixrmildjc jcrhihl yjxvifriv}b bc ei}el b}xj ajmrcxjh# y rdj qbp xbdibdhl b}jjxvifrmi1d zrb oly b} bmcr}iqj hbc ~vb}ihbdxb hb cjVb~rfcimj# hbcbgjhj bd bc MBO$

/7)0 Zrb rdj qbp vbjcipjhl bc% % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % t tLD]IHBVJDHL$ ]IBXBxvj}cjhl zrb mldalveb j cj Cby ]lfvb @r}ximij Mld}xixrmildjchbfb babmxrjv}b jc Eidi}xbvil ^rfcimlv b}xb beixi1 }rhimxjebd bd abmoj zridmb hb abfvbvl hb hl} eic ldmbv~vldrdmijdhl}b bd bc }bdxihl hb zrb bc ej} jcxl Xvifrdjc hb@r}ximijv hbmcjvb cj ~vlmbhbdmij hbc ~vb}bdxb vbmrv}l hbidmld}xixrmildjcihjh zrb ~lv qij hb jmmi1d }b ~vlerbqb mldxvjbc Hbmvbxl :?2%6>:> ~rfcimjhl bd bc Hijvil Laimijc Cj GjmbxjDl$ =6=18 hb abmoj :6 hb dlqibefvb hbc 6>:> y }b hbmcjvb cjidmld}xixrmildjcihjh xlxjc hbc vbabvihl Hbmvbxl$ B}xl bdqi}xj zrb }i fibd b} mibvxl hbc jdjci}i} vbjcipjhl }bhb}~vbdhb zrb dl xlhl bc jvximrcjhl hbc Hbmvbxl mrb}xildjhlqrcdbvj cl} ~vidmi~il} y gjvjdxij} mld}jgvjhj} ~lv cjMld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj# cj ~jvxb zrb }b mld}ihbvjidmld}xixrmildjc b} hb xjc ejgdixrh y vbcbqjdmij zrb dl ~rbhb}bv }b~jvjhj hb cj xlxjcihjh }id jabmxjv cl} aidb} yj~cimjficihjh hbc Hbmvbxl ei}el# hbfibdhl}b bdxldmb} hbvlgjvb}xb bd }r xlxjcihjh ~lv }bv hb mldxbdihl idmld}xixrmildjc$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ LMOL /?)0 Zrb bc Jvximrcl 29Mld}xixrmildjc b}xjfcbmb zrb0 &Cj ~bv}ldj orejdj b} bc aid}r~vbel hb cj }lmibhjh y hbc B}xjhl$ Xlhl} xibdbd cjlfcigjmi1d hb vb}~bxjvcj y ~vlxbgbvcj$ Cj higdihjh hbc }bv



cifbvxjhb}


vbmldlmihl} bd b}xj Mld}xixrmild# mvbj}b cjId}xixrmil hbc Mlei}ildjhl Djmildjc hb cl} Hbvbmol} Orejdl}$

~vbvvlgjxiqj y jxvifrmildb} hbc Mlei}ildjhlj lvgjdipDjmildjc cl} Hbvbmol} Orejdl} }bvj lf`bxl hb rdj cbyb}~bmijc:$& ]i bdxbdhbel} zrb cj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j b} jdxbvilvj xlhl hb bmol ~l}ixiql# ~lvzrb }b ardhj bd cj djxrvjcbpjorejdj# ~l :> zrb hbfb vbmldlmbv}b ~jvj xlhl} cl} olefvb}mlel qjcih }id hi}mvieidjmild jcgrdj ~lv bc elxiql zrb arbvb$

~vidmi~jc rdhjebdxjmild hb b}xb hbvbmol$ Bc ~viebv ardhjebdxll bd rdj mldmb~mild elvjc ~bv}ldjc hb}qidmrcjhj hb

xlhj vbgcj lf`bxiqj hb elvjcihjh$ ]bgRd b}xj mldmb~mild# cjmldhrmxj v cigil}j vb}~ldhb j rd `rimil hb mldmibdmij ~bv}ldjczrb qjvij hb rdl} idhiqihrl} j lxvl}$ B}xj hlmxvidj dl b}jhei}ifcb# ~lvzrb }bgrd bccj# hbfb ~viejv}b bc vb}~bxl j cjl~mild ~lv :> zrb dl mjfb cj Ce~l} imi$ldhb dlvej}lf`bxiqj} mldhrmxj bd ejxbvij vbcigil}j$ B}xb ardhjebdxljxbdxj# cr}l mldxvj cj djxrvjcbpj hb cj dlvej ~lvzrb hbfbj~cimjv}b xlhl} cl} olefvb} ~lv igrjc$ ]b }rbcb j~lvxjv mlelardhjebdxl cj dbmb}ihjh hb jhl~xjv rdj jmxixrh hb xlcbvjdmij

B}xj ardhjebdxjmild dl }ivqb ~lvzrb bcd b}xjmldmb~xl lcbvjdmij ie~cimj rd }bdxihl ~bylvjxiql# rd}l~lvxjv# 'bdxvj} zrb cj cifbvxjh xibdb rd }bdxihl ~l}ixiql#l~xjv$ Cj cbvjdmij jxibdhb cj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j mlel rd ejczrb hbfb }bv jmb~xjhl$ Lxvl} jrxlvb} mld}ihbvjd mlelardhjebdxjm'ld qjCi$hj hbc hbvbmol hb cifbvxjh vbcigil}j cj

: ~ijhl bd cl} xbveidl} hbc Hbmvbxl Drebvl :9:%98#hb abmoj hb himibefvb hb :998# zrb mldxibdb cj vbalvej jcJvximrcl Mld}xixrmildjc; y# vjxiaimjhl mld}xixrmildjcebdxbebhijdxb H mvbxl Drebvl 6%92# hb abmoj 7 hb abfvbvl hb :992#tfcimjhl d bc Hijvil Laimijc Cj Gjmbxj drebvl 67292# hbc 8



mrcxl hbxbveidjhl# bd didgrd mj}l ~rbhb }b~jvjv}b cj


b}xvrmxrvj idxiej ~vl~ij hb cj jhob}ild >vbmojpl hb rd mvbhlvbcigil}l$ B}xj hlmxvidj b} hi}mrxifcb ~lvzrb# ermoj} qbmb}#cj jmb~xjmi1d > vbmojpl b} avrxl hb hbxbveidjhj} ~vb}ildb}}lmijcb}$ ]i }b ie~ldb mljmxiqjebdxb rdj vbcigild# jrd mrjdhlidimijcebdxb }b ~vlhrpmj vb}i}xbdmij# aidjcebdxb }b qj j~vlhrmiv cj jmb~xjmild ~cbdj$ Bd b}xb mj}l dl ojfvj cifbvxjhvbcigil}j ~lvzrb ojy rdj ie~l}imi1d ~vbqij$ ^lv :> zrb b}xj]jcj b} hbc mvixbvil zrb cj ardhjebdxjmild y vjpld rcxiej hbcj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j b} cz higdihjh hb cj ~bv}ldj# yj zrb mldvbcjmi1d j cl} Hbvbmol} orejdl}# vb}rcxj bqihbdxb }r~bvxbdbdmij jc olefvb mld mjvjmxbv ~vbqil# idmcr}l jc hbvbmol~l}ixiql$ Cj higdihjh orejdj }r~ldb cj mj~jmihjh hbc olefvb hbxlejv ~lv }i ei}el cj} hbmi}ildb} mlel mld}bmrbdmij hb b}xjvhlxjhl hb bdxbdhieibdxl y qlcrdxjh$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ DRBQB /9)0 Zrb mlel }b hi`l jdxbvilvebdxb#b}xj ]jcj bdxibdhb zrb cj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j b} jdxbvilv jxlhl hbvbmol ~l}ixiql# ~lvzrb }b ardhj bd cj djxrvjcbpjorejdj# ~lv :> zrb hbfb vbmldlmbv}b j xlhl} cl} olefvb} mlelqjcihl }id hi}mvieidjmi1d jcgrdj ~lv bc elxiql zrb arbvb$ ^lv:> zrb# }id b}xjfcbmbv mldmb~xl}# ojy dbmb}ihjh hbhiabvbdmijv b}xb Hbvbmol hb aigrvj} jaidb} zrb# jrdzrbvbcjmildjhl} mld cj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j# dl ~rbhbd mldardhiv}bmld bccj$ Mlel cj cifbvxjh hb mrcxl} zrb b}xj mle~vbdhihj bdcj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j# zrb }i }b mldmifb cj ~vjmxi$mjhb rd

jmxiqihjh hb cj ~vjmximj hb rdj mvbbdmij vbcigil}j$ Rdjvbcigild zrb dl qib}b jheixihj} }r} ejdiab}xjmildb} bxbvdj}hb mrcxl zrbhjvij vbhrmihj jc jefixl ~rvjebdxb ~bv}ldjc ~lv:> zrb mjvbmbvij bd xlhl mj}l hb vbcbqjdmij `rvihimj$ ,J}i



i , ; %

xjefibd

hbej} vbcigil}j}0 jxbi}el# jgdl}ximi}el b


cifbvxjhejylv ~vlfcbej jc zrbvbv hiabvbdmijv cj

cigil}j hb cj ihbl:1gimj$ Cj cifbvxjh vbcigil}j b}jzrbccj vmihj bd bc }bdl hb mldab}ildb}# eibdxvj} zrb cj}

idhiabvbdx }el xbdhvijd mjfihj bd cj cifbvxjh ihbl:1gimj#b}xl }bgr cj l~idi1d hlmxvidjc ejylvixjvij$ Cj cifbvxjhihbl:1gimj b} hb}igdjhj ~lv lxvl} jrxlvb} mlel cifbvxjh hb~bd}jeibdx zrb xibdb ~lv lf`bxl bc mld`rdxl hb ihbj}#mldmb~xl} `rimil} zrb xibdb bc olefvb }lfvb cj} hiabvbdxb}vbjcihjhb} hbc erdhl y cj qihj$

dj mcjvj vbcjmi1d mld jcgrdl} hbvbmol}rb}xvjardhjebdxj b}$ Mlel :> b} bc mj}l hb cj cifbvxjh hbb~vb}i1d# bd mryl jefixl }b bdxvj cj ejylv ~jvxb hb cj}qbmb} zrb 0}b b`bvmb cj hiebd}i1d > ajmbxj bxbvdj hb b}xbhbvbmoli bd mldmvbxl }ibe~vb zrb }b ojmb ebhijdxb ~lv

cl} hbvbm } bhrmjxiql} y cj} cifbvxjhb} hb bdjbaijdpj# bdhb hiar}i1d$ B} xjefibd mcjvj cj vbcjmi1d mldrjczribv

mldmvbxl# j Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj vbmldlmb bc hbvbmol~vbabvbdxb hb cl} ~jhvb} j b}mlgbv bc xi~l hb bhrmjmi1d zrbcb} hjvjd }r} oi`l}$ ^lv :> hbej}# cl} hbvbmol} hb vbrdi1d#ejdiab}xjm j}lmijmi1d jmxrjd bd qjvil} mj}l} mlel ebhil}

hi}mvieidj

'xl}dbmb}jvil} ~jvj bc b`bvmimil hb b}xj cifbvxjh$Hbfb zrb b}xl dl ~rbhb }bv elxiql hb

MLD]I VJDHL$ LDMB /::)0 Zrb }b hbfb bdxbdhbv zrb ojy rdjalvej hb xbv~vbxjv cj xixrcjvihjh hb b}xb hbvbmol hb rdj

thiqihrjc '}b bdxibdhb zrb cj xixrcjvihjh mlcbmxiqj ~vlqibdb',xSS



/ $$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ HLMB /:6)0 Zrb bd mldmlvhjdmij mld :>


hb zrb xjcb} gvr~l} b}xbd idxbgvjhl} ~lv idhiqihrl}$ Cjqbvhjhbvj xixrcjvihjh hbc hbvbmol dl mlvvb}~ldhb b}xvimxjebdxbjc gvr~l mldab}ildjc# }idl jc idhiqihrl$ ^rbhb ~cjdxbjv}b rdmldacimxl bdxvb cl} hbvbmol} ardhjebdxjcb} hb rdl > qjvil}eibefvl} hbc gvr~l y cl} hbvbmol} mlcbmxiql} ~vlqbdibdxb} hbcmld`rdxl# bd mryl mj}l hbfbvj vb}lcqbv}b j ajqlv hb cl}hbvbmol} hbc idhiqihrl ~lvzrb b}bdmijcebdxb cl} hbvbmol}ardhjebdxjcb} xibdbd rd mjvjmxbv vjhimjcebdxb idhiqihrjc$

jdxbvilv# bc bdmldxvjel} bd cl} jdxbmbhbdxb} mlvvb}~ldhibdxb}jc ~vlmb}l hb alvejmild hbc hbmvbxl ie~rgdjhl vbeixihl} ~lvbc Mldgvb}l Djmildjc hb cj Vb~rfcimji b}~bmiaimjebdxb bd cjb~l}imild hb elxiql} zrb &Cj cifbvxjh hb Vbcigild# }bmldmifb mlel cj mj~jmihjh zrb xibdb bc olefvb y cj er`bv#avbdxb j cj }lmibhjh y jc B}xjhl# hb jrxlhbxbveidjv}b bd cjidqb}xigjmild y jhl~mi1d hb cj qbvhjh vbcigil}j y hb j`r}xjv}r mldhrmxj idhiqihrjc y }lmijc mldalveb j cl} ~vbmb~xl}elvjcb} zrb cb hb}mrfvb }r mldmibdmij vbmxj# jfjvmjdhl xjdxlcj jmxixrh ~l}ixiqj hb mvbbv# mlel cj dbgjxiqj hb dl mvbbv$Bd xjc }bdxihl# bc B}xjhl hb Oldhrvj}# }ibdhl mldmibdxb hb cjvbjcihjh djmildjc bd mrjdxl j vbcigild }b vbaibvb# dl ~rbhbhb}mldbmxjv bc }rvgieibdxl hb bdxihjhb} y mldab}ildb}vbcigil}j}# mld b}~ivixr hb mldxvifrmi1d jc fibd }lmijc# frbdxb}xieldil# b idqlcrmvjeibdxl bd cj qihj djmildjc# mlel b} bcmj}l hb cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj Djmildjc# y bd mld}bmrbdmij b}mlvvbmxl bc hbmiv zrb didgrdj igcb}ij > mldab}i$ldvbcigil}jb} di }bvj laimijc$&

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ XVBMB /:=)0Zrb bc ~jmxl Idxbvdjmildjc hbHbvbmol} Miqicb} y ^lciximl} hb :911 bd }r Jvximrcl :?




b}xjfcbmb b0 &:$ xlhj ~bv}ldj xibdb hbvbmol j cj cifbvxjh hb~bd}jeibdx # hb mldmibdmij y vbcigildi b}xb hbvbmol idmcryb cj

xbdbv >hb jhl~xjv cj vbcigild >cj} mvbbdmij} hbj}i mlel cj cifbvxjh hb ejdiab}xjv cj ~vl~ij

vbcigild > }r} mvbbdmij}v idhiqihrjc > mlcbmxiqjebdxb# xjdxlbd ~rfciml mlel bd ~viqjhl# ebhijdxb bc mrcxl# cj mbcbfvjmi1dhb cl} vix }# cj} ~vjmximj} y cj bd}bdjdpj$ 6$ Djhib ~lhvj }bvlf`bxl hb ebhihj} mlbvmixiqj} zrb ~rbhjd ebdl}mjfjv }r

xbdbv >hb jhl~xjv cj vbcigild >cj} mvbbdmij} hb}r bcbmmil $ =$ Cj cifbvxjh hb ejdiab}xjv cj ~vl~ij vbcigi1d >cj} mvbbdm'j} b}xjvj }r`bxj rdimjebdxb j cj} cieixjmildb}~vb}mvixj} ~lv cj cby zrb }bjd dbmb}jvij} ~jvj ~vlxbgbv cj}bgrvihjh# bc lvhbd# cj }jcrh > cj elvjc ~rfcimj# > cl}hbvbmol} y cifbvxjhb} ardhjebdxjcb} hb cl} hbej}$ 8$ Cl}

xjefibd

~vb}bdxb ^jmxl# }b mle~vlebxbd j vb}~bxjv}xjhl} ~jcj hb cl} ~jhvb} y# bd }r mj}l# hb cl} xrxlvb}cbgjcb}# vj gjvjdxipjv zrb cl} oi`l} vbmifjd cj bhrljm$i$ldvbcigil}j elvjc zrb b}xb hb jmrbvhl mld }r} ~vl~ij}mldqimmildb Ix

:6 qbdmi1d Jebvimjdj }lfvb Hbvbmol} Orejdl}# mldlmihlbc ^jmxl hb ]jd @l}b /Ml}xj Vimj)# hb :919 i

b~vb}j0 cifbvxjh hb mldmibdmij y vbcigi1d$ :$ Xlhj~bv}ldj hbvbmol j cj cifbvxjh hb mldmibdmij y hbvbcigild$ }xb hbvbmol ie~cimj cj cifbvxjh hb mld}bvqjv }rvbcigild >}r} mvbbdmij}# j}i mlel cj cifbvxjh hb ~vlab}jv yhiqrcgjv } vbcigild >mvbbdmij}# idhiqihrjc >mlcbmxiqjebdxb#xjdxl bd ~' ciml mlel bd ~viqjhl$ 6$ Djhib ~rbhb }bv lf`bxl hb

tthihj} vb xvimxiqj} zrb ~rbhjd ebdl}mjfjv }r vbcigild > }r}' \ & ' m ' $ 0 4 $




mvbbdmij} >hb mjefijv hb vbcigi1d >mvbbdmij}$ =$ Cj cifbvxjhhb ejdiab}xjv cj ~vl~ij vbcigi1d y cj} ~vl~ij} mvbbdmij}b}xjvj }r`bxj rdimjebdxb j cj} cieixjmildb} ~vb}mvixj} ~lv cjcby y zrb }bjd dbmb}jvij} ~jvj ~vlxbgbv cj }bgrvihjh# bclvhbd# cj }jcrh# cj elvjc# cl} hbvbmol} y cifbvxjhb} hb cl}hbej}$ 8$ Cl} ~jhvb}# y bd }r mj}l cl} xrxlvb}# xibdbd hbvbmolj zrb }r} oi`l} > ~r~icl} vbmifjd cj bhrmjmi1d vbcigil}j yelvjc zrb b}xb hb jmrbvhl mld }r} ~vl~ij} mldqimmildb}$&

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ ZRIDMB / 0 : # $ 2 ) 0 Zrb hb cj} hi}xidxj}vbcigildb}# cl} }bvb} orejdl} b}~bvjd cj vb}~rb}xj j cl}bdigej} hb }r bi}xbdmij0 cj djxrvjcbpj orejdj# bc }bdxihl y~vl~l}ixl hb }r qihj# bc fibd y bc ~bmjhl# cj mjr}j y bc aidhbc hlclv# bc mjeidl j cj abcimihjhc cj erbvxb y bc ei}xbvilzrb bdqrbcqb }r lvigbd Y }r hb}xidt$ ]ld ermol} cl} }i}xbej}vbcigil}l} bi}xbdxb}# zrb }b ~rbhbd mcj}iaimjv bd gbdbvjc hbermoj} ejdbvj} rdj hb bccj} }bgrd }b mbdxvb bd rd rdiml Hil}l bd qjvil}; bd cj vjej hb cj} eldlxbi}xj} }b bdmrbdxvjd cj}vbcigildb} ~vlabximj}i b} hbmiv# bc i}cjei}el# bc `rhji}el ybc mvi}xijdi}el y bd cj vjej hb cj} ~lcixbi}xj} }b hb}xjmjdbc oidhri}el y bc frhi}el$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ HIBMI]BI] /:1)0 Zrb bd mld}ldjdmij mld cjcifbvxjh b} zrb bi}xbd vbcigildb} mlel bc Fvjoejdi}elcFrhi}el# Mjxlcimi}el# Mldarmijdi}el# ^vlxb}xjdxi}elcCrxbvjdi}elc Mjcqidi}el# Oidhri}el# @rhji}el# I}cjei}el#]idxli}el# Plvlj}xvi}el bdxvb lxvj}# bdrebvjmi1d zrb b}}lcjebdxb bdrdmijxiqj# y zrb dl ~vbxbdhb bmcriv j cj} hbej]iy# zrb dl mjfb cj ebdlv hrhj zrb bd Oldhrvj} bi}xbd jhb~xl}cabcigvb}b} >}bgrihlvb} }b b}xj} vbcigildb}$



x

MLD]ItBVJDHL$ HIBMI]IBXB /:7)0 Zrb cj Cby ejvml hb cjIgcb}ij B $jdzbci$mj hb Oldhrvj} bd }r Jvximrcl :6 b}xjfcbmbzrb0 &Cj iMldavjxbvdihjh Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj} /MBO)# mlelId}xixrmi1t }b vbgivj ~lv cj} dlvej} jzri b}xjfcbmihj} y ~lvcj} v b}lCrm Cldb} zrb j~vrbfb }r J}jefcbj Gbdbvjc# beixihj}mldalveb m b}xj Cby y lxvj} hi}~l}imildb} hbc lvhbdjeibdxl`rvihiml tjmildjc# vb}~bxjdhl cj jrxldleij y cifbvxjh hbhbmi}i1d ht mjhj id}xixrmi1d jaicijhj$& Zrb vbcjmildjhl mld bc

mldxbdihl ihbc Jvximrcl :1 zrb ejdhj0 &Zrbhjd qigbdxb} cj}~bv}ldbvij `rvihimj} mlel Lvgjdipjmildb} Dl Grfbvdjebdxjcb}/LDGt})# ht xlhj} jzrbccj} Id}xixrmildb} Bqjdgbcimj} zrb dl }bidmlv~lvbd j cj Mldavjxbvdihjh BqjdgBOimj hb Oldhrvj} /MBO)a

lvgjdipjmimdzrb hbmihj ~bvxbdbmbv > dl j cj Mldavjxbvdihjh

~viqiCbz i$jm > jc lxlvgjvcb ~bv}ldjcihjh `rvihimj rdimjebdxb jcj &Igcb}'j BqjdgBOimj hb Oldhrvj} lxlvgjdhlcb qbdxj`j}}lfvb lxvj i y jc ei}el xibe~l bmcrybdhl hb b}xj} jc vb}xlhbc rdiqbItl vbcigil}l# zrb dl glpj hb rd vbmldlmieibdxl

Zrbhjdhl

Bqjdgbcimj


}jcql cj idhiqihrjcihjh y jrxldleij hb mjhj

hb Oldhrvj} /MBO)$ Mvbjdhl j}i rd gvr~l

laimijc ~l ~jvxb hbc B}xjhl hb Oldhrvj}$rdj mcjvj `00ldxvjqbdmi1dj :> b}xjfcbmihl ~lv cj Mld}xixrmi1dhb cj Vb~ fcimj bd }r Jvximrcl 1># zrb ejdhj0 &Xlhl} cl}oldhrvbail}djmbd cifvb b igrjcb} bd hbvbmol}$ Bd Oldhrvj} dlojy mcj}b atiqicbgijhj}$ Xlhl} cl} oldhrvbail}}ld igrjcb} jdxbcj Cby$ ]b hbmcjvj ~rdifcb xlhj hi}mvieidjmi1d ~lv elxiql hb

MLD]IHtVJDHL$ HIBMILMOL /:?)0 Zrb mlel }baijcj bc `rvi}xj

}bl# vjpjorejdj$&

Mldaigrvjdhl}b j}i

mcj}b y mrjczribv lxvj cb}iqj j cj higdihjh

tgbdxidl Iidjvb} Zridxjdj bd }r lfvj &Hbvbmol Mld}xixrmildjc



xcG>

mld}ihbvjhj ji}cjhjebdxb y }ibe~vb hbfb ~vbabviv}b cj


b Id}xixrmildb} ^lciximj}&; &Cj Mld}xixrmi1d hbfb }bvidxbv~vbxjhj mlel rd mld`rdxl jve1diml# bd bc mrjc bc}igdiaimjhl hb mjhj ~jvxb hbfb hbxbveidjv}b bd jveldij mld bchb cj} ~jvxb} vb}xjdxb}` didgrdj hi}~l}imi1d hbfb }bv

idxbv~vbxjmi1d zrb jveldimb y dl cj hi}~l}imi1d zrb mlclzrbbd ~rgdj j cj} hi}xidxj} mCjr}rcj} hb cj Cby ]r~vbej$& ` j}ixjefibd drb}xvl lvhbdjeibdxl cbgjc qigbdxb# bd cl} Jvximrcl}:7 jc 6> hbc M1higl Miqic }baijcjd cj} vbgcj} hbidxbv~vbxjmi1d hb cj Cby j}i0 &Jvximrcl :7$% Dl ~lhvjjxvifriv}b j cj cby lxvl }bdxihl zrb bc zrb vb}r:xjb~cimixjebdxb hb }r} ~vl~il} xbveidl}# hjhj cj vbcjmild zrbbdxvb cl} ei}el} hbfb bi}xiv c cj idxbdmild hbc cbg0i}cjhlv$/Cj dbgvixj y }rfvjyjhl b} drb}xvl) Jvximrcl :?$% Mrjdhl bccbgi}cjhlv hbaidibvb b~vb}jebdxb cj} ~jcjfvj} ~jvj mibvxj}ejxbvij}# }b cb} hjvj bd b}xj} }r }igdiaimjhl cbgjc$ Jvximrcl:9$% Bc mldxbxl hb cj cby }bvqivj ~jvj i:r}xvjv b: }bdxihlhb mjhj rdj hb }r} ~jvxb}# hb ejdbvj zrb ojyj bdxvb xlhj}bcIj} cj hbfihj mlvvb}~ldhbdmij y jveldij$ /Cj dbgvixj y}rfvjyjhl b} drb}xvl) Jvximrcl 6>$ % Bd cl} mj}l} bd zrb dl~rhibvbd j~cimjv}b cj} vbgcj} jdxbvilvb}# }b idxbv~vbxjvjdcl} ~j}j`b} lf}mrvl} > mldxvjhimxlvil} hbc elhl zrb ej}mldalveb ~jvbpmj jc b}~ivixr gbdbvjc hb cj cbgi}cjmi1d y j cjbzrihjh djxrvjc$& Vbgcj} zrb jc }bv j~cimjhj} dl} ccbqj j cj}igribdxb} mldmcr}i1d0 bc HBMVBXL CBGI]CJXIQL Dl$ :?2%6>:>zrb mldxibdb :j &Cby Ejvml hb cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hbOldhrvj}& bmcryb hbc vbmldlmieibdxl b}xjxjc# j}i mlel hb cl}fbdbaimil} mldxbdihl} bd cj cby jc vb}xl hb cj} vbcigildb} zrbdl mle~jvxbd }r} mvbbdmij}# mvbjdhl mlel yj }b hi`> rd gvrI@9

,&



I#

~viqicbgijh~# zrb }b fbdbaimijvj ej} hb rd Cvvx$bp'b } ~rfciml#mld ~bv}ldtcihjh `rvihimj y 1vgjdl} hb glfibvdl ~vl~il}mldmbhihj y vbmldlmihl} ~lv bc B}xjhl$

MLD]IHtVJDHL$ HIBMcDRBQB /:9)0 Zrb bc Jvximrcl 1> hb cjMjvxj Ejgdj# idhimj zrb0 &Xlhl} cl} oldhrvbail}djmbd cifvb} bigrjcb} bd hbvbmol}$ Bd Oldhrvj} dl ojy mcj}b ~viqicbgijhj}$Xlhl} cl} oldhrvbail} }ld igrjcb} jdxb cj Cby$ ]b hbmcjvj~rdifcb xlmt hi}mvieidjmi1d ~lv elxiql hb }bl# vjpj# mcj}b y

mrjczribv mtvj cb}iqj j cj higdihjh orejdj$ Cj Cby b}xjfcbmbvjcl} hbcixl} y }jdmildb} ~jvj bc idavjmxlv hb b}xb ~vbmb~xl$&

MLD]cv00IBVJDHL$QBIDXB /6>)0 Zrb bc Jvximrcl 1= hb cj


Mld}xix$rmChd b}xjfcbmb0gjvjdxij} /rb bdrebvj b}xj Mld}xixrmi1d# dl }bvjd bdxbdhihl}mlel dbgjm'ld hb lxvj} hbmcjvjmildb}# hbvbmol} y gjvjdxij} dlb}~bmiaimjmt}# zrb djmbd hb cj }lfbvjdij# hb cj alvejvb~rfcimjdm# hbelmvjximj y vb~vb}bdxjxiqj hb glfibvdl y hb cjhigdihjh hbc olefvb$&

hbmcjvjmildb}# hbvbmol} yCj}

MLD]cv00tVJDHL$mld}xixrmimdjc ~rbhb ~vb}bdxjv hl} hiebd}ildb}# j }jfbv0 j)Rdj hiebdti1d lf`bxiqj# lvigidjhj ~lv cj qrcdbvjmi1d >qilcjmi1d ~lv ~jvxb hb cl} ^lhbvb} hbc B}xjhl hbc lvhbd`rvihiml /ld}xixrmildjc; y# f) Rdj hiebd}i1d }rf`bxiqj#mrjdhl cl} vbabvihl} ^lhbvb} hbc B}xjhl > cl} ~jvximrcjvb} Iqrcdbvjd cm} hbvbmol} ardhjebdxjcb} hb cl} mirhjhjdl}$

mLD}cviBVJDHL$idmld}xixrmtldjcihjh oj }ihl mldaigrvjhj bd drb}xvj dlvejxiqjmlel cj ~vlmbhbdxb mrjdhl :> zrb }b ~vbxbdhj b} zrb }bhbmcjvb z b rdj cby lvhidjvij b} idmld}xixrmildjc ~lv

trcdbvjv > mldxvjvijv :> hi}~rb}xl bd rd Xvjxjhl > Mldqbdmi1d$i)x

/6:) 0 Zrb xlhl mldacimxlBIDXIRDL

jmmi1d66) 0 hbrb cjBIDXIHL]



]jcj Mld}xixrmildjc# mldlmbv y vb}lcqbv lvigidjvij y


Idxbvdjmildjc hbc zrb Oldhrvj} alveb ~jvxb; }ibdhlmle~bxbdmij hb cj Mlvxb ]r~vbej hb @r}ximij# ~lv ebhil hb }r

bmcr}iqjebdxb bd cj ejxbvij# ~jvj :> mrjc }b ~vldrdmijvjlf}bvqjdhl cl} vbzri}ixl} hb cj} }bdxbdmij} hbaidixiqj}$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ QBIDXIXVB] /6=)0 Zrb cj }bdxbdmij zrbt t t t t t t t % % % % % % t % % % % % % % % t % % t

vb}rbcqb cl} ~vlmbhieibdxl} hb idmld}xixrmildjcihjh ~lhvjdhbmcjvjv cj ei}ej yj }bj hb alvej xlxjc l ~jvmijc#

~vlmbhibdhl b}xl rcxiel mrjdhl cj ~jvxb >~vbmb~xl hb cj cbybd zrb }b hj cj qrcdbvjmi1d ~rbhj }bv }b~jvjhj hb cjxlxjcihjh hb cj dlvejxiqj$

MLD]IHBVJDHL$ QBIDXIMRJXVL /68)0 Zrb cj }bdxbdmij bd zrb}b hbmcjvj cj y cj ei}ej xibdb rdj baimjmij bvgj ledb}# b}hbmiv# babmxl} gbdbvjcb}$ Rdj hb cj} mjvjmxbvi}ximj} ej}vbcbqjdxb} hb cl} }i}xbej} mldmbdxvjhl} hb mldxvlc hbmld}xixrmildjcihjh b} ~vbmi}jebdxb b}xj# bd mld}bmrbdmij hb:> mrjc cj cby# l ~jvxb hb b}xj# zrb }bj hbmcjvjhjidmld}xixrmildjc b icbgixiej dl bi}xb ej}# ~lv :> zrb dl}~jvbmb jmbvxjhl :> }l}xbdihl ~lv Ejvidj Gj}m1d mrjdhl jaivej&zrb cj} idxbv~vbxjmildb} mld}xixrmildjcb} zrb vbjcipj bcXvifrdjc Mld}xixrmildjc j xvjqb} hb cl} hiqbv}l} ~vlmb}l} bdzrb hb}jvvlccj }r jmxiqihjh# l}xbdxjd ~vjmx$Cmjebdx$barbvpjcbgi}cjxiqj# l~bvjdhl hivbmxjebdxb }lfvb bc lvhbdjeibdxl`rvihiml$& Himol bd lxvj} ~jcjfvj}# bc babmxl gbdbvjc >baimjmij bvgj ledb}# hb b}xj} }bdxbdmij} mldccbqj zrb cj}ei}ej} qidmrcjd j xlhl} cl} 1vgjdl}# ~lhbvb} y jrxlvihjhb}# jcl} mirhjhjdl} bd gbdbvjc# ai`jdhl}b j}i ~rdxl} hb dl vbxlvdlhbc ~vlmb}l hb qbviaimjmi1d `rvihimj hb cl} qjclvb}mld}xixrmildjcb}$



\ $

MLD]IH tVJDHL$ QBIDXIMIDML {62u0 Zrb cj hlmxvidj zrb hb}r b`bvmimi~ hbviqb b}# djxrvjcebdxb# qidmrcjdxb# yj zrb# r}ifibd cl} Xv'frdjcb} Mld}xixrmildjcb} dl xibdbd cj ajmrcxjh hbcbgi}cjv /m~ebdxl jcgrdj qbp Gjvmij%^bcjyl) }i xibdbd cj hbb}xjfcbmbv qidmrcjxlvijebdxb bc vbmxl }igdiaimjhl hb :>cbgi}cjhl&$ ^bvl dl }lcl b}j hlmxvidj b} lfcigjdxb; x$jef$bvi:> b} jzrb ccj zrb }rv`j hb cj idxbv~vbxjmild zrb hb cjMld}xixrmilt vbjcimb cj ]jcj vb}~bmxl j rd mj}l mldmvbxl y hbhldhb ojyj }rvgihl rd ~jvximrcjv elhl hb mldhrmiv}b >jmxrjvmldalveb mm d rd qjclv v ~vidmi~il > vbgIj mldxbdihl bd bclvhbd dl$vejx$Cql mld}xixrmildjc$ B} frbdl jhqbvxiv zrb xjcqidmrcjmild jvvl~jvj }lcl j cl} mj}l} }ieicjvb} jc zrb hilcrgjv jc ~vtmbhbdxb$ Hbmiv b}xl ~vbxbdhb hb}~b`jv hb jdxbejdljcgrdj hrhb zrb ~rhibvj }rvgiv bd mrjdxl jc jcmjdmb hb cjqidmrcjmild hb cj ardmild idxbv~vbxjxiqj zrb xlmj hb}~cbgjv jcj ]jcj mloa lveb j cj Mjvxj A'rvvhjvdbvvx jC# bd bc }bdxihl hbj}lmijv bvv~dbjebdxb }r} babmxl} j rd jefixl zrb }lcl jfjvzrb

MLD]IHtVJDHL$ QBIDXI]BI] /61)0 Zrb bd bc ~vb}bdxb mj}l#}b ~rbhb m cbgiv zrb bc HBMVBXL CBGI]CJXIQL Dl$:?2%6>:> zrbmldxibdb cj &Cby Ejvml hb cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}&

$$% $ $ $ $ $

xvbidxj hb }b~xibefvb hb hl} eic hibp y ~rfcimjhl bd bc

cj hb }virhjmld}xixrmiltjc$

beixihl ~l


y jf}xvjmxj idxbv~vbxjmild hb rd ~vbmb~xl

BC MLDGVB]L DJMILDJC HB CJ VB^RFCIMJ bd abmoj

Hijvil Laitijc Cj Gjmbxj Dl$ =6$=18 hb abmoj hlmb hbdlqibefvb tb hl} eic hibpv qrcdbvj :> hi}~rb}xl bd cl}

Mld}xixrmim~ hb cj Vb~rfcimj# ~rb}xl zrb hb}jvvlccj cj};t0t$cifbvxjhb}hb vbcigild# mrc#xl y j}lmijmi1d mldxbdihj} bd cj

\$ $$ ' t#'

Jvximrcl} 1># :9? Y 682 Dl$ ::# hb cj7# 7?# ?>#



t % $ %- # ;$

&

a a ; # # $ # # 3 # t &&&Sx 0 0 0 0ic$0Vbmrv}l hb idmld}xixrmildjcihjh 7?'t'tt

Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj; rdimjebdxb ~jvj cj jgvr~jmi1dhbdleidjhj Igcb}ij BqjdgBOimj hb Oldhrvj}# hb}mldlmibdhl yhb`jdhl arbvj hb jc vb}xl hb cj} vbcigildb} i mldqivx$Cbdhl} bbd rdj dlvej mld j~jvibdmij hb j~cimjmi1d gbdbvjc# ~bvlj~cimjfcb bmcr}iqjebdxb j rd gvr~l hbxbveidjhl; }ixrjmi1dzrb ~rbhb }bv }lcqbdxjhj mld cj ajmrcxjh vbgcjebdxjvij hbcB}xjhl$

^LV XJDXL0 Cj ]jcj hb :> Mld}xixrmildjc hb cj Mlvxb]r~vbej hb @r}ximij# ie~jvxibdhl `r}xcmij# bd dlefvb hbcB}xjhl hb Oldhrvj}# mlel idxbv~vbxb rcxiel y hbaidixiql hb cjMld}xixrmi1d hb cbiVb~rfcimj# lihl bc ~jvbmbv hbc Ai}mjc# ~lvRDJDIEIHJH hb qlxl}# y mld ardhjebdxl bd cl} Jvximrcl} :# :?#1># 16# 1=# 18# 77# 7?# ?># :2:# :26# :?8# :?2 Dl$6# :?9~jvvjal ~viebvl# 6>2 Dl$ I# 6>1# 6:=# 6:8# 62?# =>=# =>8# =:=Dl$2# =:1 Dl$ I# ==2 hb cj Mld}xixrmi1d hb cj Vb~rfcimj; I#6# =# 8# 2# 78# 72# 71 Dl$8# 77# 79# ?9# 9># 96# 9= Y 98 hbcj Cby }lfvb @r}ximij Mld}xixrmildjc# AJCCJ0 Hbmcjvjv MLDCRGJV# bc vbmrv}l hb idtld}xixrmildjcihjh ~vlelqihl mldxvjCby Ejvml hb cj Igcb}ij Bqjdgbcimj hb Oldhrvj}# mldxbdihj bdbc HBMVBXL CBGI]CJXIQL Dl$cF]%6>:># BD ]R XLXJCIHJH# beixihl~lv BC MLDGVB]L DJMILDJC HB CJ VB^RFCIMJ bd abmoj xvbidxj hb}b~xibefvb hb hl} eic hibp y ~rfcimjhl bd bc Hijvil LaimijcCj Gjmbxj Dl$ =6$=18 hb abmoj hlmb hb dlqibefvb hb hl} eichibp$ Y EJDHJ0 Zrb mld cj mbvxiaimjmi1d hbc ~vb}bdxb ajccl }b

cl} babmxl} cbgjcb} mlvvb}~ldhibdxb$% DLXIAIZRB]B$hbqrbCqjd cl} jdxbmbhbdxb} jc crgjv hb }r ~vlmbhbdmij ~jvj

sentencia inconstitucionalidad ley marco iglesia evangelica

Documents

la determinaciÓn de los fectos temporales en la sentencia...

iglesia evangelica

sentencia inconstitucionalidad presidente y vicepresidente...

5. sentencia de inconstitucionalidad numeral 12 del art. 606...

en nombre del rey sentencia - tribunal constitucional de...

comentario a la sentencia de inconstitucionalidad de la ley...

evangelica testificatio

sentencia relativa a la acción de inconstitucionalidad...

sentencia inconstitucionalidad magistrados

sentencia c-351/09 demanda de inconstitucionalidad...

sentencia c-332/17 - elespectador.com · sentencia c-332/17...

· pdf filede justicia: 1.1. en cumplimiento de la sentencia...

en nombre del rey sentencia - tribunal constitucional...

en nombre del rey sentencia - tribunal constitucional de...

inconstitucionalidad, a partir de la sentencia del ... ·...

“comentarios a la sentencia del tribunal …€¦ ·...

sentencia c-699/16 - ambitojuridico.com pdf/sen… ·...

sentencia...

sentencia del tribunal constitucional...en la sentencia n.o...

en nombre del rey sentencia · en nombre del rey . la...