5/20/2018 Ang v. Castro

1/2

!"#$%&' $%)%' &$*%+, -%.#!* /0123401256 &**78 9+:.# ;#'+

:&$

!"#" %&" '())*+, -./ ,01 ,230

4%! 5" 6478#9

:9%;%8;< #;'9=41!"

>46?!#9@%A

!"#$%&$' )*+, ! -'%./0" -/1 234$0 ./ .0%3/356'.63#$

7"%84.3/6 .1.3/56 9:01$ 9"5$ ;< =.56'" 3/ 6>$ ?2237$ "2 6>$

;'$530$/63.4 -55356./6 "/ @$1.4 -22.3'5 2"' 31/"'./7$ "2 6>$ 4.AB

1'"55 3/$C7:5.&4$ /$1431$/7$ 7"/7$'/3/1 =3#34 =.5$ !"< DE,FGHH"A 7.:5$ A>L >$ 5>":40 /"6 &$

8:/35>$0 2"' 7"/6$%86 "2 7":'6B 2"' %.4373":5B 3/5"4$/6B

3/$C7:5.&4$ 035'$58$76 ./0 7"/6$%86:":5 .6636:0$ 6"A.'05 6>$7":'6 ./0 6"A.'05 >3%3% 6" F 0.L5 3%8'35"/%$/6B ./0 "'0$'$0 >35 .''$56

2"' >35 2.34:'$B 0$5836$ /"637$B 6" .88$.' "/ 6>$ 57>$0:4$0

>$.'3/1 "2 6>$ 7"/6$%86 7>.'1$ .1.3/56 >3%$ "/$ 234$0 A36> 6>$ ?2237$ "2 6>$

;'$530$/6Q$'$.26$'B -/1 234$0 . 8$6363"/ 2"' 7$'63"'.'3B 8'">3&363"/ ./0

%./0.%:5 3/ 6>$ N:8'$%$ =":'6 .5S3/1 P)Q 2"' 6>$ "'0$'

>"403/1 >3% 3/ 7"/6$%86 6" &$ 5$6 .530$B PJQ 6" $/T"3/ 9:01$

=.56'" 2'"% $/2"'73/1 6>$ "'0$' "2 .''$56 "2 -/1 "/ 6>$ 1'":/0

"2 7"/6$%86B P,Q 6" '$56'.3/ '$58"/0$/6 -55356./6 M357.4 !.'735"

R< -63$/U. "2 D:$U"/ =36L 2'"% 7"/0:763/1 8'$43%3/.'L

3/#$5631.63"/ "/ 6>$ 43&$4 7>.'1$ 234$0 .1.3/56 >3% &L '$58"/0$/6

T:01$$ RX? A.5 355:$0< !"#$ &'()$$&*+, -).

"/,' ") 0$")(1 "/, (.,+&'&23.4 &25,$"&63"&)2 *,738$,

"/, $3', /39 3+.,394 *,,2 7)27+89,9:

K8"/ 4$.'/3/1 "2 6>$ 3/2"'%.63"/ "2 43&$4 234$0 .1.3/56 >3%B -/1

234$0 . 5:884$%$/6.4 8$6363"/ A>37> 7"/6.3/$0 >35 '$O:$56 PGQ 6"

8'">3&36 '$58"/0$/6 9:01$ 9"5$ ;< -''" "2 6>$ X$13"/.4 R'3.4

=":'6 "2 X3U.4B Y'./7> =ZZZB D:$U"/ =36L 2'"% 8'"7$$03/1 ./0["'

7"/0:763/1 . >$.'3/1 "/ 6>$ 7'3%3/.4 7"%84.3/6 2"' 43&$4

\.'7> FB )*+G !. RX? A.5 355:$0 $/T"3/3/1 9:01$ -''" 2'"%

8'"7$$03/1 A36> 6>$ 7'3%3/.4 7.5$ 2"' 43&$4; #;79'=;A

)$6>$' "' /"6 -/1 %.L &$ >$40 2"' 7"/6$%86 "/ 6>$ &.535 "2

6>$ 4./1:.1$ >$ :5$0 3/ >35 4$66$' 7"%84.3/65 6" 6>$ ?2237$ "2 6>$

;'$530$/6 ./0 6" 6>$ N:8'$%$ =":'6.6 2.34:'$ "2 8$6363"/$' 6" .88$.'B 0$5836$

/"637$B "/ 6>$ 57>$0:4$0 >$.'3/1 "2 6>$ 7"/6$%86 7>.'1$ 2"' 6>$

:5$ "2 0$'"1.6"'L 4./1:.1$ 3/ >35 6A" 4$66$'5 .00'$55$0 6" 6>$

?2237$ "2 6>$ ;'$530$/63.4 -55356./6 "/ @$1.4 -22.3'5 ./0 6" 6>35=":'6 3/ ./ .0%3/356'.63#$ 7"%84.3/6 .1.3/56 >3%B 7"/5636:6$5

03'$76 7"/6$%86 .5 6>$ .765 .76:.44L 3%8$0$0B $%&.''.55$0 ./0

"&56':76$0 >3% 3/ 6>$ .0%3/356'.63"/ "2 T:5637$$ :5$ "2 035'$58$762:4 "' 7"/6$%86:":5

4./1:.1$ .1.3/56 . 8.'637:4.' T:01$ 3/ 84$.03/15 8'$5$/6$0 3/

./"6>$' 7":'6 "' 8'"7$$03/1 35 3/03'$76B /"6 03'$76B 7"/6$%86 .5

36 35 /"6 6./6.%":/6 6" . %35&$>.#3"' 3/ 6>$ 8'$5$/7$ "2 "' 5"

/$.' . 7":'6 "' T:01$ .5 6" 3/6$'':86 6>$ .0%3/356'.63"/ "2

T:5637$< N6.6$0 0322$'$/64LB 32 6>$ 84$.03/1 7"/6.3/3/1 0$'"1.6"'LB

"22$/53#$ "' %.4373":5 56.6$%$/65 35 5:&%366$0 3/ 6>$ 5.%$7":'6 "' T:01$ 3/ A>37> 6>$ 8'"7$$03/15 .'$ 8$/03/1B 36 35 03'$76

7"/6$%86 &$7.:5$ 36 35 $O:3#.4$/6 6" . %35&$>.#3"' 7"%%366$0

3/ 6>$ 8'$5$/7$ "2 "' 5" /$.' . 7":'6 "' T:01$ .5 6" 3/6$'':86 6>$

.0%3/356'.63"/ "2 T:5637$$ 7"%%:/37.63"/ >.5 ./ 3/6$'$56 "' 7"/7$'/3/1 A>37> >$ >.5

. 0:6L 35 8'3#34$1$0 32 %.0$ 6" . 8$'5"/ >.#3/1 . 7"''$58"/03/1

3/6$'$56 "' 0:6LB .46>":1> 36 7"/6.3/5 3/7'3%3/.6"'L "'

0$'"1.6"'L %.66$' A>37> A36>":6 6>$ 8'3#34$1$ A":40 &$

43&$4":5 ./0 .763"/.&4$` C C C 6>.6 8.'63$5B 7":/5$4 ./0 A36/$55$5

.'$ $C$%86$0 2'"% 43.&3436L 3/ 43&$4 "' 54./0$' 2"' A"'05

"6>$'A35$ 0$2.%.6"'L 8:&435>$0 3/ 6>$ 7":'5$ "2 T:0373.4

8'"7$$03/15B 8'"#30$0 6>$ 56.6$%$/65 .'$ 8$'63/$/6 "' '$4$#./6

6" 6>$ 7.5$