. QmffiTB~.Ban banb Qlly djnb danb gia k~t qmitb\fc bi~n nbi~m Vl}cua cbu dAlltll',

Ban·QLDA cacdl}'andoBqtfll'lmg Bq GTVT qlly~t djnh dAlltll'

BD TRUONG BD GlAD THONG vAN TAl. . ., can eilNghi dinh s6 51/2008/ND-CP ngay 22 thang 4 narn 2008 eua Chinh phu

quy dinh ehile nang, nhi~rn V\l,quy~n h~n va ea efiu t6 ehile eua BC)Giao thong v?n h\i;

Can eil Nghi dinh s6 12/2009/ND-CP ngay 12/02/2009 eua Chinh phu vS qufm lyd\! an dAu tu xay d\Illg eong trinh va Nghi diM s6 83/2009/ND-CP ngay 15/10/2009eua Chinh phu v~ sua d6i b6 sung mC)ts6 di~u eua Nghi dinh 12/2009/ND-CP;

- ,

Can eil Nghi dinh s6 209/2004/ND-CP ngay 16/12/2004 eua Chinh phu vS qmin lyehfit IUQllgeong trinh xay d\Illg va Nghi dinh s6 49/2008/ND-CP ngay 18/4/2008 euaChinh phu v~ sua d6i b6 sungrnC)ts6 di~u eua Nghi dinh 20912004/ND-CP;

Can eil Thong tu s6 03/2009/TT-BXD ngay 26/3/2009 eua BC)Xay d\Illg quy dinhehi ti@tmQts6 nC)idung eua Nghi dinh 12/2009/ND-CPngay 12/2/2009 eua Chinh phil;

Theo d~ nghi eua V\l truOng V\l K@ho~eh dAutu,

QUYETDINH:

f)i~ll 1. Ban hanh kern theo Quy@tdiM nay "Quy dinh danh gia k@tqua th\!e hi~nnhi~m V\l eua ehu dAutu, Ban Quan ly d\f an eae d\! an do BC)truOng BC)GTVT quy@tdinh dAutu.

f)i~u2. Quy@tdinh nay eo hi~u IVekS illngay kYoTrong qua trinh thge hi~n n@ueo vuOng mfie, t6 ehile, ea nhan gui y ki@nvS B9

Giao thong v?n tai xem xet, giai quy@t. .. ' i)i~ll 3. Chanh Van phong, Chanh Thanh tra, V\l wOng eae V\l, T6ng eve truOng,

C\le iruOng eae Cve va Thu wOng eae don vi lien quan ehiu traeh nhi~m thi hanh quy@tdinh' ,

. naY·I·a/

No'inh~n:- Nhu £>iSu 3;- Cac Thu tnrcmg;- Cac Ban QLDA tn,fc thul)c Bl);~Cac SO'GTVT;~Luu VT, KHDT (06).

1

'- BO GIAOTHONG.V ~ TAl CONG HOA xA HOICmJ NGHiA. VI~T NAM .DQcl~p - Tl}'do - H~nh phuc

Quy.djnhdanhgia k~t·qua thl}'chi~n nhi~m V\lcuachu d§u tu,Ban Quan.lfd..r an'·

::-(Ban hanh kern theo Quyit djnh s8 2{oS7QlJ-BGTVT ngay21/10/2012)

Di~u 1. PhC;!mvi diSu chinh:'

Quy chS nay quy dinh vi~c danh gia kSt qua thvc hi~n nhi~m V\l cila chil dfiu tuho~c Ban Quan I;' dv an duQ'cBQ Giao thong v~ tai giao nhi~m V\l lam Chil dfiu tu(lio~c'Quan I;' dv an) cac dv an do BQtruOng BQGiao thong v~n tai quySt djnh dfiu tuho~c cac dv an do Thil tu6ng Chinh phil giao BQGiao thong v~n Uiilam chil dfiutu.

Di~u 2. D6i tuQ'ngap d\lng:Quy dinh nay ap d\lng d6i v6i cac Co'quan, dan vi duQ'cBQ Giao thongv~n tai

giao.nhi~m V\l chil dfiu tu ho~c quan ly, t6 chuc thvc hi~n dv an do BQGiao thong v~ntai lam chil dfiu tu va cac ca quan tham muu (C\lC,V\l) trvc thuQc BQGiao thong v~ntai.

Di~u 3. M\lctieu cila vi~c danh gia:1. Danh gia kSt qua hang' nam nh~m"xac djnhnang Ivc cila .chil dfiu tu ho?c Ban

Qu~mly dv an. Tu kSt qua nay, phanloC;!itheo 4 nhom: A (Hoan thanh t6t nhi~m V\l),B(Hoan thanh nhi~m V\l);C (Chua hoan thanh nhi~m V\l);D (Nang Ivc ySu).

2. KSt qua danh gia, phan 10C;!ise duQ'cBQGiao thong v~ Utitham khao dS xemxet, quySt djnh tru6c khi giao nhi~m V\lho~c danh gia nang Ivc nguai dUng dfiu, BanLanh dC;!ocila chil dfiutu, cila Ban Quan ly"dVan ho~c quySt dinh xu I;' nSu cfin thiSt.

3. D6i v6i chil dfiu tu ho?c Ban Quan ly dv an, kSt qua danh gia la thu6c do dS cobi~n phap diSu chinh nh~m phat huy kSt qua t6t, hC;!nch~ va kh~c ph\lc nhUng thi~u sotdS cac dv an duqc thlJc hi~n v6'i chAtIUQ'ng,ti~n dQt6t hon.

Di~u 4. Dan vi thvc hi~n danh gia:1. Cac chil dfiu tu ho~c Ban Quan I;' dVan phai tv danh gia va bao cao giri vS bQ

Giao thong v~n tai theo PhVI\lc s6 2 kern theo.

2. Cac don vi thvc hi~n danh gia:a) Vv K~ hoC;!chdfiu tu thvc hi~n danh gia giai doC;!nchu~n bi dfiu tu va t6ng hQ'P

chung qua trinh danh gia;b) Cvc QLXD & CL CTGT chil tri ph6i hQ'Pv6i cac Vv An toan giao thong, Khoa

hQccong ngh~, Moi twang danh gia giai do~n th\Xchi~n dAutu;c) Vv KSt cAuhC;!tfing giao thong danh gia giai doC;!nv~n hanh, khai thac;

d) V\l Tai chinh danh gia giai doC;!nquy~t to8.ndVan hoan thanh.

3. Trong qua trinh thvc hi~n danh gia, my theo tinh hinh, BQGiao thong v~n Uticoth~ thanh l~p HQi d6ng danh gia k~t qua thvc hi~n nhi~m V\l cila cac Chil dfiu tu, BanQuan I;' dVan do mQtThu trucmg lam chil tich.

2

f)i~u? Tieu chi va thang di6m danh gia: .. .~ .~ ~

1. MBi d\! an danh gia thea cac giai da?ll:chuful bi dAutu,th\!c hi~n dAutu, quySttaan cong trinh - giai ngan, v~ hanh khai thac.

2. Tieu chi va thang diSm C\lthS thea Ph\! 11;19S61 kern thea Quy diM nay.

3. DiSm danh gia ClmmBi chli dAutu ha~c Ban Quan If d\! an la 86 di6m IBitrungbinh clia cac d\! an do don vi do quan If sau khi·da hi~u chinh thea h~ s6: D\! an nhomC nhan h~ s6 1,0; d\! an nhom B OOanh~ s6 0,9; d\!an OOomA co t6ng muc dAutu ill1500-10.000 tYdang OOanh~ s6 0,8 va ill 10.000 tYdang tr&len nhan h~ s6 0,75.

f)i~u 6. Phan Ia~i chli dAutu:Can cu diSm 16i trung binh sau khi OOanh~ s6 neu tren, cac chli dAutu ha~c ban

Quan If d\! an duqc xSp h?llg thanh cac nhorn OOusau:Nhorn A - Raan thanh t6t nhi~rn V\lco s6 diSrn IBitrung binh ill 0-10 diSrn;

Nhorn B - Raan thanh nhi~rn V\lco s6 di6rn IBitrung binh ill 11-25 diSrn;

Nhorn C - Chua haan thaOOOOi~mV\lco s6 di6rn I6i trung biOOill 25-50 di6rn;

Nhorn D - Nang hIc ySu co s6 diSrn IBitrung binh > 50 diSm.

f)i~u 7. T6 chuc daOOgia:1. Danh gia IAndAu:BQ se b~t dAudanh gia kSt qua th\!c hi~n nhi~m V\lclia cac

Chli dAutu ho~cBan Quan If d\! an d6i v6i cac d\! an th\!c hi~n ill narn 2008 dSnnay.

2. Danh gia diOOkYhang narn:a) Tru6c ngay 20 thang 11 hang narn, cac chli dAutu, Ban Quan If d\! an baa caa

danh gia qua trinh triSn khai cac d\! an duqc BQGiaa thong v~n Uligiaa nhi~rn V\ldAutu ha~c Ban Quan If d\! an thea Ph\lI\lc 2 kern thea Quy diOOnay gi:rivS BQGiaa thongv~n tai.

b) TuAn dAuclia thang 12 hang narn, V\l KS ha~ch dAutu chu td Ifty f kiSn cacdon vi quy diOOt~i diSm a khaan 2 DiSu 4 kern thea baa caa clia cac Chli dAutu, BanQuan 1:9 cl\!an.

c) Trang thai gian 20 ngay, kS tu ngay oo~ duqc van ban xin f kiSn, cac don viphai gi:rikSt qua daOOgia b~ng van ban vSV\l KS ha~ch dAutu dS t6ng hqp.

d) V\l KS ha~ch dAutu t6ng hqp danh gia, xSp Ia~i va baa caa BQGiaa thong v~ntai tru6c ngay 25 thang 12 hang narn.

3. Quy triOOdanh gia:a) Cac chu dAutu, Ban Quan If cl\!an gi:ribaa caa daOOgia qua triOOtriSn khai

cac cl\!an gi:riB9 GTVT (qua V\! KS ha~ch dAutu).b) V\l KS ha~ch dAutu t6ng hqp baa caa daOOgia qua trinh triSn khai cac cl\!an

cua cac chu dAutu, Ban Quan If d\! an va gui cac don vi th\Xchi~n danh gia dil neu t~idiem a khoan 2 Di~u 4.

c) V\l KS ho~ch t6ng hqp kSt qua daOOgia cua cac don v( va I~pbaa caa t6n~ h9'Ptrinh Lanh d~o B9 xem xet, quySt dinh (ho~c thong qua RQi dong danh gia chu dau tu,Ban Quan Iy cl\!an nSu duqc thaOOI~p).

d) Qua trinh danh gia chli co moi cac chli dAutu, Ban QUID ly d\! an dBlam ra cacnQidung ·lienquan.

: J)i~u8.Cong bBva su dl)l1gkSt qua danh gia:

1. v\! KS ho~ch dAutu ph6i hQP·.v6'iTrung tam cong ngh~ thong tin. dang tai kStqua danh gia th\Ic hi~n nhi~m Vl) clia cac Chli dAutu, Ban QUID ly d\! an tren trangT~ong tin di~n tUcua BQGiao thong v~ tai.

2: KSt qua danh gia kSt qua th\Ic hi~n nhi~m Vl)la mQt trong cac tieu chi dBquyStdinh giao' chu dAutu, thay thS chli dAutu; xem xet danh hi~u thi dua -t~pthBcua cacChli dAutu, Ban QUID ly d\! an; danh gia nang l\Ic can bQ Lanh d~o dieu hanh d\! an(cfip truOng, cfippho don vi ph\! trach).

J)i~u 9. Xu ly vi ph~m:.Cac don vi khong bao cao, danh gia qua trinh triBn khai d\! an theo tiSn dQquy

dinh t~i Dieu 7 se bi x~p vao l~i C - Chua hom thanh nhi~m Vl).I.

4

PH\JL\JC 1K~t qua danh gia thl}'Chi~n nhi~m V\l chii d~u tll', Ban QLDA

Chii d~u tll'/Ban QLDA:

1 Chat lzwng d1,t fm 10- KhongphaidiSuchinhdlJan,TMDT ho~cdiSuchinhdo nguyennhanbftt kM o

t-_+k_h_a_n..:::g:....::(N'-7g~h..:....i_dl:....:n_h_8_3_/2_0_0_9/N_D_-_C_P-")..::.,,_n"""gu....:y~e_n_n_h_a_n_k_h_ac_h_q...•.u_a_n_.--------t---- __-+ ~Giai, do~nllC\ychi danhgia ehfrt- PMi diSuchinhdlJan/TMDT. lugng,khongdanhgiatil~ndl;)doe6

f--++-D-i7S-u-c-h-in-h-do-n-g-uy-e-~n-n-h-an-c-hu-'-q-u-a-n-,t-a-n-g-T-M-D-T-.s-S-o/<-o.-----------t----I-_2---+-------lrM nhi@uy€ut6khaehquan,fu1h

f--+------;-------:;:.---'-----.......;:...---...::....-----------------t---------f--------jhuOng ti€ndl;)+ DiSuchinhdonguyennhanchuquan,tangTMDT .s20%. 3-5

+ DiSuchinhdonguyennhanchuquan,tangTMDT 2:30%. 6-10

2 Tutin thit trinh t1!XDCB: 51---t--:------:----:------------------------+--------1---- __-jCa quannM nuaetrongtruOnghQ'P

- CftpcothftmquySn,cacCvc,Vv danhgiadanhgiacotuanthu. 0 naylaKi~mtoannhanuae,Thanhtraf---t-_-C-a7.p-c-o-'-th-:ft-m---:qu....;y~S;-n-,-c-ac-C-v-c,-V-v-d-a-n-h....;;g-ia-·-ca~'n-r-u.;..t-k-in-h-n-g-h-i-~m-.--------t----

1-_

3---t-------j ChinhpM, ThanhtraefrpBl;)ho?cy

t---t---::"---;--"---:-----------:--------------t-------l--------lki€n dp,Bl;)(Bl;)TC,KHDT,XD).- CftpcothftmquySn,cacCvc,Vv dauhgiacAnxemxetxu ly trachnhi~m. 3-4

h==~==

+ DlJandambaoch~tluong,khongcokStlu~nvi ph~mch~tluqng. 0

+ Co' quancuaBQcoy kiSnvSvi ph~mchAtluqng,bi~nphapt6 chucthi cong.... 1-5l---t-+-L-a-n-=.h-d-g-o-B-Q-c...:.o-T-B--=,;...V-B-n-h~~:-c-v~S:-v-i'-p-h-g-m-c-h"7At:........::lu;:.;.·qn-g'-,-to::-'-ch-'u'-·c-th-i-c-o-n-g-.-..-.--:::---1----

6-_-

1-0

---+-------1 Trencasa ~'6llinviph~~,tmhchfrtl---t------------;-----;------;--------:---;------I--------+-----_-lvi p~~md~xemxetehodi~m. '

+ CacCO' quanThanhtra,ki~mtoan,diSutracokStlu~nvi phgmvSch&tluqng... 10-15 :',

2 Sv c6 cong trinh: 5 SlJc6CTlanhUng'huhOngvuQtquat--+-------------------------------+-------j--------jgiaih~an toanehopheplameong

- IUlongxayraslJc5congtrinh. 0 trinhc6nguycas~pd6,s~pd6ml;)tI---t--------------:.---------------------I--------I--------lphlin ho~ekhongsfrd\lngduge theo

- Xayras~rc5congtrinh. 1-5 thi€tk€,

····~'!;,i~liji,i~!~jl~;I~?. :n,./L:.'; .::::};:.!' I"'?;;",',',."'"'' ,i,-'C,,, ~L ·'·c"H.;·.,.'!·J!;{!.",,·,.,

3 Dam baD giao thong, an tOCInlao Q9ng, rnoi trurJng 5 V¥ MT, ATGT ph6ih07J

+ Th\fC hi~n t6t dam bao giao thOng, ATLD, moi tfUOng. 0+ Co xay ra un t~c, tai n~mgiao thOng, mAt an toim lao dQng, S\f c6 moi tfUOng khong 1-2thi~t h~i v8 nguo-i.

+ Xay ra tai n~n, s\f c6 co thi~t h~i v8 nguoi 3-54 Tiin Q9 cong trinh: 5

- L'l,tach(m nhiz thtlu: 5I + Dung kS ho~ch dAu thAu duQ'c phe duy~t 0 TiIy thui)c s5 l§n di~u chinh va thai

gian di6u chinh d§ cho di§m+ Phai di8u chinh kS ho~ch dAu thAu 1-5- Thi cong cong trinh 15

+ D\f an hoan thanh dung tiSn dQtheo hqp dAng, cMm do khaeh quan 0+ CMm tiSn de) do ySu t6 chu quan < 10% thai gian hQ'PdAng. 1-3 Y€u t6 kMeh quan do mi)t trong cae

nguyen nhan: GPMB, ngufin v6n b5+ Ch~m tiSn de) do ySu t6 chu quan < 25% thai gian hQ'PdAng. 3-6 tri cMm va cac truang hgp b§t kM

+CMm tiSn de) do ySu t6 cM quan < 50% thai gian hQ'PdAng. 7-10 khang khac. Y€u t6 chil quan la cacy€u t5 con l<;1i.

+ CMm tiSn de) do ySu t6 chu quan2: 50% thai gian hQ'PdAng. 11-15 ':.•.

5 Tuan thit trinh t'l,tQtlu tu XDCB 5

- cAp co thAm quy8n, cac C\lC,V\l danh gia danh gia co tuan thu. 0 Ca quan Nha nu6'c c6 th~m quy6n- cAp co thAm quy8n, cac C\lC,V\l danh gia dn rut kinh nghi~m. 2-3 duqc quy dinh nhu 6'm\lc II-2

- cAp co thAm quy8n, cac C\le, V\l danh gia dn xem xet xu ly traeh nhi~m. 4-56 Ph8i h(JJJveyicac ca quan him quan: 10

- Cong tac GPMB: 5+ CM dQng ph6i hQ'Ptich C\fCv6'i cac ca quan lien quan, eong tae GPMB dam bao 0tiSn dQ d\f an.+ Chua ph6i hQ'P t6t v6'i dia phuong, cac don vi lien quan dSn d\! an, lam ch~m 1-3GPMB.+ Chua ph6i hQ'P t6t v6'i dia phuong, cae don vi lien quan, eh~m GPMB va co van 4-5ban nh~e nhO'. ./~)7~

- Cong Hic baa cao giam sat danh gia dl,l'an dftu tu, baa cao th6ng ke, cac baa caodinh ky, dQt xu~t, baa cao do cac cO'quan tham muu cua BQ yeu duo 5 Cae V¥ lien quan

0

1-5

7

0

1-34-75

0

1-2

3-5

3

0

12-3

6

0

1-23-45-64

0

1-22-4

+ Baa cao dung ti6n dQ, dam baa ch&t lUQ11g

j'.

"

. ..~'

+ Baocao cMm tiSn dQ, chua dam baa ch&t IU9ug

I Tiin tl(J quy~t toan- C6ng tac trinh duy~t quySt toan hO~ll1tMnh dung tiSn d9 quy djnh.- Cong tac trinh duy~t quySt toan cMm < 6 thang so vai ti6n d9 uy djnh.

- Cong tac trinh duy~t quySt toan ch~m ?: 6 thang so vai tiSn d9 quy djnh.

2 C6ng tac giai ngan- Tuan thii dung quy djnh, giai ngan ho<\n thanh cac k6 ho~ch nam

- Giai ngan khOng hoan thanh k6 ho~ch nam ho~c chua tuan tM quy djnh vS cong tacgiai ngan, quan ly tiSn t~m ung.- Giai ngan kh6ng hoan tMnh kS ho~ch nam va chua tuan thu quy djnh vS cong tac

giai ngan, quan ly tiSn t~m ung.

3 Blm giao tili li¢u cho tlO11 vj quan If khai thac- Ban giao dung thai h~n quy djnh

- Ban giao cMm so vai quy djnh < 2 thang

- Ban giao ch~m so vai quy djnh > 2 thangGirtnd6h"tr'Vilii,liiiri.li~w;kmii~t

I Trang thirigian baa himh

- Trang thai gian baa Mnh, khOng pMi sua chua.

- Trang thO'igian baa Mnh dn pMi sua chua, gia trj sua chua.::: 50% gia trj baa Mnh

2 Sau thirigian baa himh, trong vong 3 nam

- Kh6ng pMi sua chft'a

- C6ng trinh phili sua chua nh6

- C6ng trinh pMi sU'achu'a ]611

.,:.

PHl)LVC2Bao eao danh gia k~t qua !hl}.'ehi~n nhi~m Vl}.eiIa ehiI dAu tu', Ban Quan Iy dl}.'an

Ch" aau tu': .·Du' an ~ ~ : .. .'

BiSm IBi tt}',

TT Chi tieu thinh ghi Giiii trinh .. Ghi chudanh gia

I Giai do~n chufln b! dilu tU': Max= 151 Chdt IU(1ng chu6n bi dI! cm

- Khong phai di~u chinh dlJ an va TMDT ho~c di~u chinh do nguyen nhan b~t khakhang (thea Nghi dinh 83/2009/ND-CP).- Phai di~u chinh dlJ an/TMDT.

+ Di~u chinh do nguyen nhan chu quan, tang TMDT .:s 5%.+ Di~u chinh do nguyen nhan chu quan, tang TMDT .:s 20%.

+ Di~u ehinh do nguyen nhan chu quan, tang TMDT :::30%. ,

2 Tuan thil trinh tI! adu tu XDCB- Ca quan nha nUGCco thfim quy~n danh gia co tuan thu.

- Co' quan nha nUGeco thfim quy~n co y ki@ndin rut kinh nghi~m.

- Co' quan nha nUGCco thb quy~n co y ki~n xem xet xu ly trach nhi~m.

II Giai do~n th'!c hi~n diln tU': Max=60

1 Chdt IU(1ng dI! an max=15+ Dv an dam bao ch~t Im;mg, khong co k~t lu?n vi ph~m ch~t Im;mg.

+ Cae Co'quan tham mUll cua BQ co y ki~n v6 vi ph~m ch~t lUQTIg,bi~n phap t6chuc thi cong ....

+ Uinh d~o BQ co Thong bao, van ban v~ vi ph~m ch~t lU9'l1g, bi~n phap thieong ....+ Cac Co'quan Thanh tra, ki~m toan, di~u tra co k~t lu?n vi ph~ v~ ch~t lUQTIg,.,

2 SI! c6 cong trinh: max=5- Khong xay ra sv c5 cong trinh.

1

,

i - Xay ra SlJc5 cong trinh.

~ Dam baa giao thong, an toim lao a<}ng,moi truimg max=5 I

+ ThlJc hi~n t5t dam bao giao thong, an toan lao de>ng,moi tfUbng., + Co xay ra Un't~c, tai n~ giao thong, m~t an toan lao de>ng,SlJ c5 moi tfUbng

khong thi~t hl;live nguai.

+ Xay ra tai n~, SlJc5 co thi~t hl;live nguai.4 Tiin a<}cong trinh: max=5

- Ll:rach9n nha thau:+ Dung k~ hOI;lChd~u thfiu dugc phe duy~t

, + Phai di~u chinh k~ hOl;lchd~u thfiu

'"

" ; - Thi cong cong trinh" + DlJ an hoan thanh dung ti~n de>theo hgp dfmg, ch~ do khach quan

.-

+ Ch~ ti~n de>do y~u t5 chu quan < 10% thai gian hgp dangI..

I + Ch~ ti~n de>do y~u t5 chu quan < 25% thai gian hgp dang.+ Ch~m tien de>do yeu to chu quan < 50% thai gian hgp dong.

, + Ch~ tien de>do yeu to chu quan::: 50% thai gian hgp dong.

<5 Tutin thit trinh tl;Caau tu XDCB max=5

- Ca quan nha nuac co thfun quyen danh gia co tmm thu.

- Ca quan nha nuac co thfun quy~n co y kiSn ck rut kinh nghi~m.

- Ca quan nha nuac co thfun quy~n co y kiSn xem xet xu ly trach nhi~m.6 Ph6i h(lJJv&i cae ca quan hicu quan: max=10

- Cong tac GPMB:

+ Chu de>ngph5i hgp tich ClJCvai cac ca quan lien quan, cong tac GPMB dam baotiSn de>dlJ an.

+ Chua ph5i hgp t6t v6'i dia phuang, dan vi lien quan d~n dl,l an lam ch~ GPMB.

+ Chua ph5i hgp t5t vai dia phuang, dan vi lien quan, ch~ GPMB va co van b<'mnh~c nha.

- Cong tac bao cao giam sat danh gia dl,l an dfiu tu, bao cao th5ng ke, cac bao cao

2

..:'dinh ley, dQtxwIt, baa CclO do cac ca quan tham muu CllaBQyeu diu.

+ Baa cao dung ti~n dQ, dam bilOch~t luQllg+ Baa cao ch~ ti~n dQ, chua dam baa ch~t luQllg

1 Tien a(J quyet toan- Cong tac trinh duy~t quy~t toan hoan thanh dUng ti~n dQquy dinh.

- Cong tac trinh duy~t quy~t toan ch~m < 6 thang so v6'i ti~n dQquy dinh. . .

- Cong tac trinh duy~t quy~t toan ch~m ~ 6 thang so v6'i ti~n dQquy dinh. ...

2 C6ng tac gild ngan.

.

- Tuan th11dung quy dinh, giai ngan hoan thanh cac k~ ho~ch nfun : ..

..Giii ngan khong hO~lI1 ,tha.11hk8 hm;lch nam ho~c chua tuan thll quy djnh v8 cong,

tac giai ngan, quan 19' tien t~n fu1g. ,

- Giai ngan khong hoan thanh k~ ho~ch nfnn va chua tWIn thl1 quy dinh v6 cong tac .. .':' ,

giai ngan, quan 19' ti~n t~m {mg.

3 Ban giao teli li?u cha dan vi quan If;khai thac- Ban giao dung thai h~n quy dinh- Ban giao ch~ so v6'i quy dinh < 2 thang

- Ban giao ch~m so v6'i quy dinh > 2 thang

IV Giai do~n v~n h~mh, Irnai thac: max= 10

1 Trang thai gian baa hanh I

- Trang thai gian baa hanh, khong phai sua chua.

- Trang thai gian baa hanh, phai sua chua do 1;' do khach quan. ..

- Trang thai gian baa hanh phai sua chua, gia tri sua chua ~ 50% gia tri baa hanh

- Trang thai gian baa hanh c~n phai sua chua, gia tri ~ 50% gia tri baa hanh I

2 Sau thcli gian baa himh, trang vong 3 niim

- Khong pMi Sll'achua I

- Cong trinh phai sua chua nho

- Cong trinh phai sua chual6'n

3