BLTBLT

shawn@blte.kr070-4100shawn@blte.kr

4100-0102

•

•Microsoft Certified Professional

• (2001)

• (2006)

• ETRI (2013)

• ]

• ]

• ]

• ,

• , , , )

2

)

shawn@BLTe.kr

3

. ,

,

.

< LG ) >

•

4

(NPE) …

?

5

• (1819 ~ 1867)

•...,

• , , ...

• 1854 ,

• (1867

1.

2.

. 4400$ )

3.

. (

-

+ (NPE) 1606

.(I.M. = )

.

.

~ )

160 …

!!!!

7

!!!!

8

• MOP (Management Of Patent)

MOP (Management of Patent)

M.O.P• Value Chain

•

• Value Chain

• , , , , , …

• ,

9

MOP (Management Of Patent)

M.O.P• , IP

• ,

• Value Chain

• ,

• , (NPE)

10

11

12

13

14

1998

15

1998

16

17

2004

18

2004

2004

19

2004

2009

20

2009

21

22

23

24

1, 2, 3,

,

13 125

1, 2, 3

.

1 2, 1

.

25

1, 2, 3

, ,

2 700 ppm , , ,

125 ppm ,

,

, ,

26

vs

27

.

15

.

CMP 'KCS-3100'

7,115,021 USP 7,871,308 .

vs

28

(CMP

6

USP

""

".

CMP

CMP STI

alphag@

vs

29

.

STI .

vs

30

vs

31

vs

32

vs

33

• , .

• (%) CeO2 .

• , SiO2 Si3N4 .

•,

.

vs

34

1. An abrasive comprising said particles having a crystal grain boundaryand having a maximum diameter of not large than 3000 nm.

2. The abrasive of claim 1, wherein a crystallite of said cerium oxide particles has a maximum diameter of not larger than 600 nm

3. The abrasive of claim 1, wherein said cerium oxide particles have pores

4. ~ 20.

vs

35

abrasive comprising cerium oxide particles, having a crystal grain boundary

having a maximum diameter of not large

The abrasive of claim 1, wherein a crystallite of said cerium oxide particles has a maximum diameter of not larger than 600 nm.The abrasive of claim 1, wherein said cerium oxide particles have pores.

vs

36

7. An abrasive comprising slurry including medium andcerium oxide particles dispersed in said medium, saidoxide particles constituted of at least two crystalliteshaving crystal grain boundarieswherein:cerium oxide particles with diameter not smaller thanoccupies at least 0.1% by weight of the total weight of thecerium oxide particles; andsaid cerium oxide particles havinghave characteristic of polishing target membercollapsing.

vs

37

7. An abrasive comprising slurry including medium anddispersed in said medium, said cerium

at least two crystallites andcrystal grain boundaries,

with diameter not smaller thanoccupies at least 0.1% by weight of the total weight of the

having crystal grain boundarieshave characteristic of polishing target member while

vs

38

Application/Filing Date: 2006-07-12

KC Tech cerium oxide “ceria”) slurry

Hitachi Chemical1. KCS-3100 ceria (ceria particle)2. KCS-3100 (dispersant)3. KCS-3100 ceria

.4. KCS-31005. KCS-3100

vs

39

ceria”) slurry KCS-3100..

KCS-3100 .(ceria particle) .

(dispersant) .(crystal grain boundaries)

ceria .ceria

.

vs

40

vs

41

vs

42

vs

43

44

45

•

•

•

(wilfulness) .

46

)

, ,

.

,

47

2(Doctrine ofEquivalents)

48

1 (All Element Rule)

2

3 ( File WrapperEstoppel)

vs ?

49

.

.

•

50

X

.

vs

51

cerium oxide particles

having crystal grain boundary

having maximum diameter of not largethan 3000 nm

• KCS-

cerium oxide particles,

having maximum diameter of not large

than 3000 nm

1. An abrasive comprising particles, said particles grain boundary and diameter of not large than 3000 nm.

52

cerium oxide particles

having crystal grain boundary

having maximum diameter of not largethan 3000 nm ?

-3100 US7,871,308

cerium oxide particles, having crystal grain boundary

having maximum diameter of not large

3000nm

.

An abrasive comprising cerium oxide , said particles having a crystal

and having a maximum diameter of not large than 3000 nm.

(Doctrine of Equivalents)

.

53

Doctrine of Equivalents)

.

2(Doctrine ofEquivalents)

54

1 (All Element Rule)

2

3 ( File WrapperEstoppel)

vs ?

(File Wrapper Estoppel)

55

Wrapper Estoppel)

(File Wrapper Estoppel)

"

,

,

“V"

(700)

,

56

Wrapper Estoppel)

(700)

(File Wrapper Estoppel)

95

1

.

. Y

57

Wrapper Estoppel)

95-4971

, 1998. 7. 22.

1

,

.

(File Wrapper Estoppel)

58

Wrapper Estoppel)

(File Wrapper Estoppel)

"

59

Wrapper Estoppel)

.

{( )

, (

.

60

61

62

10-2003-7005273 (20030415)

10-2000-7006683 (20000617)

10-2006-7024951 (20061127)

PCT/JP1998/005736(1998.12.18)

7,871,308

7,115,021

1997-349240

1998-083042

1998-083043

63

1997-349240

12 ,

5 250 nm

2

3 1 , 100

4 3 , 300

5

6 1 , 5 150 nm

7 6 , 10 50 nm

8 4 , 50 200 nm

9 1 ,

10 1 , 600 nm

11 1 ,

1211 ,

10 30 % .

1311 , B.J.H.(Barret, Joyner, Halende)/g .

14

15 1 , (bulk density)

16 15 , 5.0 g/ , 5.9 g/

17 1 , .

10-2000-7006683 (20000617)

64

100 1500 nm , .

100 1200 nm .

300 1OOO nm .

150 nm .

50 nm .

200 nm .

3000 nm .

.

.

X

0.02 0.05

(bulk density) 6.5 g/ .

, 5.9 g/ .

7006683 (20000617)

12 ,

5 250 nm

2

3 1 , 100

4 3 , 300

5

6 1 , 5 150 nm

7 6 , 10 50 nm

8 4 , 50 200 nm

9 1 ,

10 1 , 600 nm

11 1 ,

1211 ,

10 30 % .

1311 , B.J.H.(Barret, Joyner, Halende)/g .

14

15 1 , (bulk density)

16 15 , 5.0 g/ , 5.9 g/

17 1 , .

10-2000-7006683 (20000617)

65

100 1500 nm , .

100 1200 nm .

300 1OOO nm .

150 nm .

50 nm .

200 nm .

3000 nm .

.

.

X

0.02 0.05

(bulk density) 6.5 g/ .

, 5.9 g/ .

?

7006683 (20000617)

12100 1500 nm ,

1An abrasive comprising cerium oxide particleshaving crystal grain boundarydiameter of not large than 3000 nm.

10-2000-7006683 (20000617)

7,871,308

66

, 5 250 nm

.

cerium oxide particles said particleshaving crystal grain boundary and having maximumdiameter of not large than 3000 nm.

?

10-2000-7006683 (20000617)

67

68

A B

1 2

69

DC E

11 2

1An abrasive comprising cerium oxide particleshaving crystal grain boundarydiameter of not large than 3000 nm.

7,871,308

12100 1500 nm ,

10-2000-7006683 (20000617)

70

cerium oxide particles said particleshaving crystal grain boundary and having maximumdiameter of not large than 3000 nm.

?

, 5 250 nm

.

71

72

WIPS

Delphion

Total Patents 96 30

Aureka 22

Focust

Russian Academyof Sciences

73

WINTELIPS

PatentLap

30 Analytics

21 Patentweb

•• 100100 (30(30 Full text Full text

74

Full text (30)

Bibliographic(70)

))

Application/Filing Date: 2006

75

Application/Filing Date: 2006-07-12

76

77

78

79

80

;

;

,

.

81

;

;

;

;

;

;

82

83

A

C

B ?

B

?

84

vs

85

B24B 1/04 ( (tumbling)B24B 31/06;

B23B 37/00

C09C 1/68

C01F 17/00

C09K 3/14

H01L 21/304

H01L 21/3105

86

B24B 31/00;B24B 31/06; (superfinishing)

B24B 35/00)(

B24B 1/04)

(cutting)

87

CONTENTS

I

CONTENTS

1.

2.

3.

90

But,

Bell: VS

Dial Bell.

Bell , Dial .

];

; ,

.

91

Dial:

)

Bell ,

,

];

,

.

LED

92

LED

93

94

95

96

97

98

99

100

• 8

•

•

•

•

100

2000

1000

?

101 101

102

813,538 813,537

401,327 881,943

102

813,539 793,413

776,841 734,569

103 103

104 104

105

30(for every line-ups)

?

105

• 1990

• 10

• 70%

• 10

•

106

US 5,010,646

US 4,813,131US 4,785,534

106

US 5,027,511

US 5,430,939

US D377,237US 5,113,585

107 107

108

.

2-KEY

• ‘ ‘

-

109

-

2-KEY

• ‘ ‘

-

110

-

2-KEY

• ‘ ‘

-

111

2-KEY

• ‘ ‘

-

, , R&D

, 6HA

.

112

.

.

.

6HA - OPEN

(Element)

113

(Object)

(Problem)

lement) -

(Needs) -

6HA

6HA - OPEN

(Object)

(Problem)

(Element) -

(Needs) -

114

O

P

E

N

?

?

?

?

BLU 1

1 (450) (410)

2 ,

(450)(450)

(450)

3 (450)

4 (430)(440)

115

?

(410) O

(450)

(420)

O

(430)O

(450)(440)

O

BLU 1

(450) (410)

, (450)

(450)

(450)

(450)

(420)

(450)

(430)

(430)

(450) (440)

116

???

?

• BLU ?

• BLU ?

• BLU ?

• BLU ?

• ?

• ? LED ?

• BLU ?

• ??

(430)

• ?

• ?

• ? ??

• ?

• ?

• ??

•

!!!

117

•

!

118

119

120 120

121 121

122 122

123 123

124 124

125 125

!?

126 126

2006.02

CREATIVE

(UI part)

UI

2006.04 ~

2007.06

iPhone2G

2008.10

127 127

Smart Phone

2011.04

Apple

(UI part)

2008.10 ~

?

,

Copycat(

128 128

, LED)

,

•

129 129

,

= .

BLT

BLT Business, Law & Technology 130

(1999)

(2005) SS 40” (a-Si TFT)

(2002) SS 2.2”

(1997)

OLED

130

(2009)AMOLED

(2012) LG 55”

(2007) SS AMOLED

(2007) SONY 11”

OLED TV

(2009) LG, OLED

131

132

133

>

•

• /

• (It’s Fun~!!)

•

, 133

•

•

•

?

…

134 134

135

>

•

•

•

•

135

•

•

•

?

136

-(KR , PCT only)

136

137 137

• IP

• , <

M&A, NORTEL

•

Rockstar Bidco LP

•

138

7,812,8287,669,1346,493,0027,469,3817,844,9157,853,8917,863,533

’s IP

138

’s IP

139

>

• + CIPO

• <Value Up>

•

•

139

•

•

•

OA !

140

Reclaim

a Patent($0)

Star Patent($100M)

Idea Prosecute

Client

140

• – Value Up

Star Patent($100M)

Reclaiming, Claim charting, Reverse engineering for sophisticated standard IPs

Value-up Monetize

GDI

141 141

-(VU, )

142

>

•

• ,

• ,

•

142

•

•

• ,

1.

2.

3.

1]

, ,

.

?

: A+B+C+D :

: A+B+C :

Case 1

Case 2

144

]

,

.

1

23

4

5

145

1]

342437 :

1~

, (1) 9(3) ;

(1) (3)(2)

146

.

)

12 1

(2)11 ,

(3) (1), ~

.

1

VS.

147

;

,

148

“

, ”

(Estoppel)

149

150

1.2.3.

RF /

& SWSW

151

/

152

/

( )

/

/

/

/M&A( /

153

( )

( , , ,

/ )

1. R&D

2.

3.

4.

5.

Patent Map Power Patenting

Needs

Value Chain Analysis

Data Gathering /

Application Survey

Application

Market Status

- Size, Growth rate,

Competitor,

Market Research Co.

Application

Work Shop

Cowork

Process

Cowork

PRM TRM

Phase I -

D/Around

Phase II

- Phase I

Phase III -

- New Concept Tech.

Tech Trend ( / /

)

Work Shop

Cowork / Review

Work Shop

Cowork / Review

Application

gap

(Make, Buy,

Collaboration)

/

Tech tree

OOOO

OOOO

OOOO

OOOO D

C

B

A

Needs

Background

157

IP-R&D

Spec

PLC Position

)

= + +

158

(PLC Position)

, ,

- ?? (?? , ??), ?? (?? ),

, , ), , )

+ Risk

A BA B

2001----44 60 100 1 8

2000-29---

2000-18-- 60-75 500 1 7

2008-04-5 60 100~2000 1 7

2001-16---1 50% 100 1 8

2001-26-- 55~65 420~2000 1 4

1998-15-- 75 12 4 9

1997-34-- 70~80% 100~2000 4 7

1996-26-- 70~80% 100~2000 4 7

2007-08--- 80 100~900 4 7

159

9 8 8 8 24

8 7 3 7 17

8 7 3 7 17

9 8 8 8 24

5 7 5 7 19

13 8 6 7 21

11 8 8 8 24

11 8 8 8 24

11 7 5 7 19

D

OOOC , D X : , Y :

,

160

D

C

B

A

C

)

( PRM-TRM )

,

->

-> )

/

161TRM )

/ / Parameter

Parameter

Matrix

)

(P1)

(P3)

(P2)

28

29

(P4)

(P15

(00 )

00 000 P21

000 P21

000 000 P16

(

E1 00

E10

E15

E32

E33

E49

E50

E62

E64

E71

E74

162

)

Check(-> 20% ).

[ ]

00

(00 )

00 (000mm )

000

/

Catch Up)

163

/

=> R&D

( , ?? , , )-->

164

???

??

salt

OO

=> OOOO

=> OOOO( )

165

OOO

, .

(( )

=>

)

OOO

00(00 00 000

00 00 00

0000

000

OOO OOO

O - 0.04

OOO

0.13 ~ 10 (OOO

OO

166

)

000 +

00

OO

.)

8

??

( : )

=> 000

00

167

,

Idea

R&D

Idea Idea

168

Idea

1990

Copyright 2011 Jung-Ho Kim

//

169

)

1991 ••• 2009 2010

//

--- ))

--- )

USD 70.00 USD 58.75

)

.

Copyright 2011 Jung-Ho Kim170

---

))

)

USD 52.50 )

170

,

100

a

b

c

d

e

f

g

h

A B C D E

171

a

b

c

d

e

f

g

h

A B C D E

172

Mix-Up

), )

Positives

Objections

What else

Enhancements

Remedies

: “THINK BETTER’ Tim Hurson, PP231-241)

173

?

bjections ?

hat else?

??

nhancements?

?

STEP QUESTIONS

Positive?

?

Objection?

?

What else

Value Chain ?

?

?

?

?

Enhancement

Remedy?

?

Idea Seed

Work Sheet for IdeationWork Sheet for Ideation

174

METHOD

?

/

) / )

/

?

5 Whys

.

•

Idea

)

NewRoadmap

175

Idea Idea

R&D

R&D

Seed

•

Idea

)

NewRoadmap

176

Idea Idea

R&D

R&D

Seed

Code

Silk S-1S-2S-3S-4

S-5S-6S-7S-8S-9S-10

Portfolio

--

177

( / )/

5 19 9

Know How Filtering

- R&D

178

(Literal Infringement)

(Doctrine of Equivalents )

(File Wrapper Estoppel)

•

•(All Elements Rule)

•

•

•

179

97 )

(elements)

,

JP2000-000000

1,

.

JP2000,

2 , JP2000

3 Yb Er JP2000Er

4 JP2000

4 JP2000

5 JP2000

6,

JP2000(11)(52)

JP2000-000000 1-6000000, JP2000-000000

,

180

JP2000-000000

.

JP2000-000000 JP00-000000.

JP2000-000000 JP00-000000.

JP2000-000000.

JP2000-000000.

JP2000-000000.

JP2000-000000(51, 54) WDM

(55) .

JP2000-000000, JP00-, , JP2000-000000

1-6 , .

IP-R&D

181

BLT Business, Law & Technology www.BLT

The only FIRM who cares your SUCCESS

BLTwww.fb.com/byunlisa

070-4100-0102, 0shawn@BLTe.kr

BLT

BLTe.kr 182

The only FIRM who cares your SUCCESS

BLTwww.fb.com/byunlisa

010-2393-5709shawn@BLTe.kr