伝熱 2012 012012 1 j. htsj, vol. 51, no. 214 864 ς max jakob max jakob memorial award archive :...
TRANSCRIPT
-
日本伝熱学会
創立50周年記念特別号
Vol. 51, No. 2142012. 1
◆特集:創立50周年を迎えて
-
��� 2012� 1� J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Max Jakob��������������
Max Jakob Memorial Award Archive : Professor Yasuo Mori
�
STUDY ON FORCED CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER IN CURVED PIPES
(3RD REPORT, THEORETICAL ANALYSIS UNDER THE CONDITION OF
UNIFORM WALL TEMPERATURE AND PRACTICAL FORMULAE)
YASUO MORI and WATARU NAKAYAMA
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan
Abstract—In the authors’ previous reports, the theoretical and experimental studies on flow and temperature
fields in a curved pipe were made under the condition of uniform heat flux. In the former part of the present
report, a theoretical analysis is made about temperature field far downstream from the pipe inlet under the
condition of uniform wall temperature, following the same procedure as in the previous papers. Nusselt number
is found to be remarkably affected by a secondary flow due to curvature. The result shows that in the first-order
approximation the Nusselt number of heat transfer in a curved pipe does not differ for uniform wall temperature
or uniform heat flux case, in both laminar and turbulent regions.
In the latter part, the formulae of Nusselt numbers obtained by the authors’ study are arranged so as to have
simpler expression for a practical use.
It is also investigated what temperature should be chosen in calculation of physical properties when these
Nusselt number formulae are used.
�Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer, Vol. 10, pp. 681-695 (1967). ���
���������������1988��Max Jakob�� �!"#$%�&
�'()*+,-.��&/01�2&345677'89:#;?
@"'�.��A'+-.BCDE.$
FG� HIJ�����K
Takayoshi INOUE (Tokyo Institute of Technology)
(a) Laminar region
( )2121
35.21
864.0−
+= KKNuc
ς
(b) Turbulent flow (For gases)
( )51
2
101
54
32
098.0
1
074.02.26
⎪⎭
⎪
⎬
⎫
⎪⎩
⎪
⎨
⎧
⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎝
⎛
+×⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎝
⎛
−
=
R
a
Re
R
a
Re
Pr
Pr
Nuc
http://www.htsj.or.jp/dennetsu/dennetsu51-j.html
-
Vol.51 2012
No.214 January
�� � �
�� �
��������������
50����
������
���������······························································································· 1
�50������������
�������� 50�������������
········································��� ��� !"�#�$%#&'� ()�*+#�$
,-� ./� !"�#�$%01� 23� !"�#�$
45� 67�89�:#�$%;�?@AB#�$ ··········· 16
���� 50�������
CDEF� 50�····························································G>� HI�JK+#�$ ··········· 21
��LM 50��NO····························································P9� Q�RS�T$ ··········· 30
UVWXYZ[\�]^_�`Xabcdefgh��A�ijk�ggl
··············································································mn� op�qrAB#�$ ··········· 51
���� �!"#$�
s_tuvwxy�(1901z1954)�{| ····························}~� ��?@#�$ ··········· 55
�%&'()�*���
4Z�y��dgh"� ················�� �#�$ ··········· 61
�+,-./0�
Max Jakob�Z pj ·················1� �?@AB#�$ ··········· ¡
�1234#5��········································································································· 63
�6789��
¢9��£¤�¥¦§·································································································· 64
49����]_¨©ª«�¥¦§·············································································· 66
¬®¯°_±�]^_� 49����]_¨©ª«$d²³´ ··································· 70
3"��wµ�¶«�¥¦§ ·················································································· 71
·¤`¸¹�º»�¼½»¾···························································································· 72
·¤`¸¹�[�¿········································································································ 77
-
Vol. 51��No. 214��January 2012
CONTENTS
�The 50th Anniversary�
The Fifty Years of the Heat Transfer Society of Japan ··························································································· 1
�Heat Transfer Seminar of HTSJ 50th Anniversary�
Report on the Heat Transfer Seminar of HTSJ 50th
Anniversary
Yoshio UTAKA1
, Hidetoshi OHKUBO2
, Takuto ARAKI1
, Seigo SAKAI1
Tatsunori ASAOKA3
, Shohji TSUSHIMA4
(1 Yokohama National Univ., 2 Tamagawa Univ., 3 Aoyama Gakuin Univ.
4 Tokyo Inst. of Tech.) ·············································································································· 16
�Special Issue�
A Review of Boiling Research in the Past Fifty Years
Masahiro SHOJI (Kanagawa University) ·················································································· 21
Advances in Heat Transfer Equipment in Fifty Years
Wataru NAKAYAMA (Honorary Member) ·············································································· 30
Thermal Engineering & Education Contributing to Sustainable Innovation Capability
Ayao TSUGE (Shibaura Institute of Technology) ····································································· 51
�Education Q�
A Meritorious Deed of Enrico Fermi (1901-1954)
Junichiro SHIOMI (The University of Tokyo) ·········································································· 55
�Report on International Conference�
Report on the 4th International Conference on Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow in Microscale
Koji TAKAHASHI (Kyushu University) ·················································································· 61
�Opening-page Gravure:heat-page�
Max Jakob Memorial Award Archive : Professor Yasuo Mori
Takayoshi INOUE (Tokyo Institute of Technology) ··············································· Opening Page
�Calendar�························································································································································ 63
��Announcements�� ·········································································································································· 66
�Note from the Editorial Board� ·············································································································· 77
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 1 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�������
�������
����
� �
��� ������
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 2 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������ � ����� � � ���� ������
1961 � 11 ����������������������������
� �!"�#$%&'()*�+,-./�'012345678�9:;
�2?@*A7BC�D!�EFGH'��'�IJ�KL7MN'O
�PQ7R�'9:�#$ST�UV�WC�&()*7XYZF�%T[�\
]^_`7a�[�bG[�cd�e'1994� 9��(f)!"��%T[�gP
�� '���h��&ijkgPT[�lG mnopT[�CGZcdp[�
"!'qH�rst 50u�7vN�dT&'w�xyz�E{Hx|CGZc}~��IJ�a
�[�r���'�7�GFS7bH'7N��J�7
L['^�%7ZFC%TCGZc('�IJ�� �nFS&'¡G
�dT�'j^¢£7¤¥[)�#$¦K�§�7¨©'f%�_tª«/¬�7l®Z
%7¯N� �CGZcd��p°±&'�²�dT)�f%�³ZF´Cµ¶¬·CGZci
9¸�!"��%&'¹p[�µ¶7º»['f%)¼ZF�IJ�½¾T#$¦K�_`7
¿À�a�[�Cr�%H��Á[CTÂpTdoHZc
dd�'Ã��%ÄTÅ�'"�%)��7ÆqÇr�����È@É��ÊËÌ=��T[
��7;ÍÎÀ��'()*�'¹[�9:�ÏÃKL�ÐÑZF�p'ÒÓ7ÔÕ['w
À�TÖ×Ø�Ù�ÊÚÛ7¬��ÜÝZFdT7ÞCGZc
���� Minnesota����� Richard J. Goldstein�
I am pleased to send greetings to the Heat Transfer Society of Japan on the
occasion of your 50th anniversary.
I have had many interactions with Japan’s heat transfer community dating back to
the mid ‘60’s when I made my first visit to Japan. Since then I have returned many times
including a stay at the University of Tokyo with a grant from the JSPS. I have also had
many excellent graduate advisees from Japan, all of whom returned to either teach, or
work in industry or government labs.
My respect for Japanese heat transfer research dates back many years. Recently I re-read (in English
translation) the elegant, classic and precise 1934 paper on the boiling curve by Shiro Nukiyama. Of course I
have used many other excellent works by Japanese researchers. I have also been privileged to interact with such
international luminaries in the thermal sciences as Professors Niichi Nishiwaki, Yoshiro Katto, Yasuo Mori,
Masaru Hirata and Kenjiro Suzuki.
I am honored to send my hearty congratulations on this particular occasion and wish you many more
years of continued success.
Sincerely,
Richard J. Goldstein
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 3 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
���� ������� �� ������������� ����� �������� ����������� �������� ��� ��������� ���
������������ ���� ����� �������� �������� �� ������ ��� ���������� ���� � !����� "����#� ����
������$������������������������%&''( �������������$���$����������������������������(�
����������(� ���� �������������� �� ������ ���������� ���� ����������� ��� ���� )������� �������� ��
������� �������� ���� �����������#� ������ ���� �������� ����(� ���� ����� ���� ���� �� ���$����
������ �� ���� �����(� �������������� ��� �������� ���� ���
������������� ����� ��������
���������������*������%&+,����(������$��������������-.���������������/������(�����������
�����0�������� ������������� ������������ ��� ������� �����������������������#� ���� ��)�����
1���������������������������������������������������������������2��������������3�(�
����� $���� ���� ������ ����� 4������� ����� �������� ���������� �� ������ ���� ����3��
������� �������� ���� 5����������� "�����(� ��)�� ������� ������ ��� ���� �� ���� ��"���
���������������������������������������������������������������������������)��������
���������������������������������$��������������������������#�
6�
�$����������������������� ����!%,� ���7����������8�(�������������*����$����������
����������������!%�����1��������- %,(�����������9��#�4�������1�����(���������9���������
������(���������������������������������������$���������������������������������������
�����#�
��������
�����������������������
�������� ���� �����������������
���������������
-
���������
��� 2012� 1� - 4 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�� �� ����� ����
� �������������� 50 ���������������
50�!"�#��$��%&'(�)
* ���+,���-&.�/.�1931�01234/5��#6789-
9:;&?2@A�BC�DEFG�(HI)��J�.K69-LM
NO=>&@PQRSTU&��(1934)G+4VWX9-MYZ=>&@[\
]^_&`ab^��c&��(l940)G��&����&de�fI���
g�)�����&��-&hc�ij��&�kl���mn��#&.Ko9-* pqr=>
�(HI)��st-��@��uv�wx�G 1953�yzKo�{|��#& pqr=>&
}~�4� &�(/��&9&=>�&������C_&wx����
��&�������&�&��uv�wx���������&��/��#)
���������#&. 1961 ��(/��������|&&��
* o9-* O=> 1964�o�{|���¡¢&C_&£¤�¥��
¦§¨�� 1��©ª�{|��j�)1966��.��-«�¬�-��®¯����°
�±²���³a´µ&¶·�³¸¹º&»¼�½#�#)�������&±·.¾³&�
���&¿�nÀ�Á��Â�l���£Ã&Äe�~Å��1974��. 5³¸���¬
( 1. 1951��ÆÇ�{|)�Ko�{|v�¨����&����&ÈÉÊ¡#)
* ����-�Ë·ÌÍ���Îs����-�����³¸Ï�mn��yÐ�Ñ�����
��Ò�nÀv����ÓÔv�)
�� �� ����� �����
� ÕÖ×ÌÍ�Ø&Ù�Ú�Ø4/�st-�&�ÛÜ&Ý��pqrhÞ�ß
àáhÞ�aâãrhÞ\&Ko9&hÞäå�ß&OhÞ�æqçh
Þ�èéèrhÞ�\ê�Ù�.K6ä&LMNOhÞ�ëìíhÞ�îaïr
hÞ�ð� ñ�òó�×Úñô¡&õ�hÞä(ö�ö�4�÷�����
�ÛÜ&Ý� øùú�j��ÛÜ�(#��cÛÜ�+j�û[ü&ý
-�l��þ��HI�.�j���jI¬Cõ���#)�z.Kß
6�ê�(#�R�phÞ&��~���I�����_�ü��HI�jI��n�
¡�&hÞä��ô�&q�O������â����â������\jhÞä �~�
����&� &¡�!��������������"��/���±·��#)#
jä&���~�g#$�%�)*
�
� �
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 5 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
��������
��ß à!"�#$%�át�âãäåß æçè�#$é 41êë�{
ß 1960� 6� 24! é;ì9íP%ß �î%ïðï
ß 1960� 10� 8! éñì9íP%ß �î%ïðï
ß 1960� 10� 14! òóôõH#$%
ß 1960� 12� 2! Ã*^ö÷��q�%øß �î%ïðï
ß 1961� 4� 4! KùP%ß zúûüý�þ�
ß 1961� 11� 22! !"�#$%é 1ì�%ß �î%ïðï
���
�����
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 6 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
� ������������
�
� ���������������� � � � �� � �! �"#$%�
�
&'�()*+� Max Jakob,-,����.%� � � ���/012����! � ! � �� 34 �"567%�
��89���:�
ß 1961� 8� 28!�9� 1!
ß �*������@2@
ß ��� 125�èp�!" 11�ë
ß èW�'1962� 1�'����ë
3�89���:�
ß 1966� 8� 8!�12!
ß �*�3��
ß ��� 177�èp�!" 12�ë
��89���:�
ß 1970� 8� 31!�9� 5!
ß �������2Ì1�
ß ���ß 355�èp�!" 17�ë
� 1� � 2� � 3� � 4� � 5�
� 6� � 7� � 8� � 9� � � � � � � 10�
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 7 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
� ������������
�
� �89���:�
�
�
� �
��89���:�
ß 1978� 8� 31!�9� 5!
ß �������
ß ��� 395�èp�!" 36�ë
� 11� � 12� � 13� � 14� � 15�
� 16� � 17� � 18� � 19� � 20�
�;/012���.4 � � � �� � �4 � � �"�?@*+� Max Jakob,-,���!�%
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 8 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
� ��� !"#!$!""%�
!�89���:�
ß 1982� 9� 6!�10!
ß �1!�"#�$�%ý�
ß ��� 454�èp�!" 44�ë
ß &@'@� 22�
.�89���:�
ß 1986� 8� 17!�22!
ß �*�Ì����3��
ß ��� 451�èp�!" 46�ë
ß &@'@� 28�
��89���:�
ß 1990� 8� 26!�31!
ß 1��=2�=2ÌØ(
ß ��� 415�èp�!" 46�ë
ß &@'@� 30�
����A�AB,CDB,EF���.�%�
G�HI*+ ASME Heat Transfer� Memorial
Award-,���.�%"JK�LK�MNOPQR ST,-,
���..%"UVW�XVPQY ,-,���..%�
� 21� � 22� � 23� � 24� � 25�
� 26� � 27� � 28� � 29� � 30�
��/012�
�Z[\ ��.� �"]
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 9 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
� ���������
�
�
�4 �89���:�
ß 1994� 8� 14!�18!
ß Ò*�)�1��
ß ��� 505�èp�!" 75�ë
ß &@'@� 30�
�� �89���:�
ß 1998� 8� 23!�28!
ß **�z+
ß ��� 525�èp�!" 94�ë
ß &@'@� 22�
Thermal Science and EngineeringE�����3%�
� g2hijkl�
ß ß ,- Ýè1993�1996, 1997�2001ë
ß ß . ���1996�1997�
ß ß ó/ 0�è2001�2005ë
ß ß 12 3è2005�2008ë
ß ß 4® 56è2008�ë
m ' � n * + ASME Heat Transfer
Memorial Award-,�����%�
�
op,qEF��44�"rstuXsO�vVtw xyqz{|
}~%�
� 31� � 32� � 33� � 34� � 35�
� 36� � 37� � 38� � 39� � 40�
�q�1996 %
FILGAP�F�1994%
A+��F�2000%
Cid2�������1996 %
� �
-
���������
��� 2012� 1� - 10 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������
&�'()�±²*1987+
����-�,&ñ-.Ù*1991+
/0Â12Ïz&34$5*1993+
±·6�*1994� 57 19�+
89:;Ï*1994� 97 20�+
�
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 11 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
��� � ���
������
A+�2��,�2001 %
E 40�ST�2002� 6� 4�%
� CD-ROM�2002%
�*+� h�b�A�89,-,��44�%�
JK�LK�MNOPQR ST,-,��44�%�
89��h2��IFHT%�
� 2004� 11� 24� 26�
ß �7ÈÌ@Ö 8@6ß �.ß 9: ´;
ß �� 150�'&@'@�ß �.ß ?@ A
ß �� 121�'&@'@�B�
� ¡*+� ¢N££s¤¥u¦s§tQ¤¨£ 89,
-,��44�%�
TSE q��©ªA�«¬� J. Thermal
Science and Technology%q®¯�2006 %
�� 41�� �� 42�� �� 43�� �� �� 44�� �� 45��
� 46� � 47� � � 48� � � 49� � � 50�
-
���������
��� 2012 � 1 � - 12 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
°±�²«*+� rO¤¤OV³�´sws¤ µ¶d-,��4�4%�
ß
�� �
����� ���
� ����������������������������� !"#$%&'()*�+,-./0�12�345
�678*�9:;?�;�@A��B$CDEFGHIJK-%5B$��-L0�MNO?�-·�w(-=B���a-¸¹NWÁ�=$ÂÃÄ�./Å n-ÆÇ#Pz=ÈÇ�\T�¸o("#$ÉÊ ËÌ
|Í�ÎÏ Ð"$°(78�VÑ�Ò-ÓÔjÕ6�����6Ö�¸¹�×ØÙ !"#$ÚÙ6ÛÙÎÏÜݯ
������ÎÏ�×Ø-Þß0�\
� ��$àá�����9:��+â¯ãW$3 Jä-CD 50 åJ æW�\w"5�ç(èé êë-$L¬ì�íî
�¬ï�ðñ(òó$��¯�ôõ}a-NWÁ�=�ö�h�÷øùúûü §±2-�Ç$E#��6����6ý
!¤#�>)*�2+,�Øþ-ý·�� é50w( ÂG0�|����\ � E
2008J 5� 22
�� �89���:�
ß 2002� 8� 18!�23!
ß �����Ê2'@)2
ß ��� 512�èp�!" 89�ë
ß &@'@� 30�
�3 �89���:�
ß 2006� 8� 23!�28!
ß 0@���È��3�C@
ß ��� 657�èp�!" 95�ë
ß &@'@� 33�
�� �89���:�
ß 2010� 8� 8!�13!
ß �*�D3��� DC
ß ��� 854�èp�!" 103�ë
ß &@'@� 31�
�� �89���:�
ß 2014� 8� 10!�15!
ß !"��7�
��A�·¸q¹ºq�»/��� �� �����
������"¼½¾"�44. � � � �� �%�
�� �����������¿À�"#$��44�%
-
���������
��� 2012� 1� - 13 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������������
��� ���� ��� �� ����
�� �� ��
��� ��
�� ��
�� �� � � � !" #$%&' �� ��(
�� �� �)�*��( +� ,- ./012 3
�
%45 �� ���
�) �� 6��*��) 78 9:;
�
(� ���
�� �� ���*�6� JK JK.LMNO PQ%RS �) �((
�� �� ���*�(� TU ,-
�
VNOWX YZ%[ �� �)(
�( �� )*�)�*��6 +� \]!"-" ^_%`a �� ���
�6 �� )*��(*6)� bc bc$\de/012 fgh%ij )�6 ��(
�� �) )*���*�6� kl mnop�NO q�%rs ))� �()
�� �� )*�)6*��� 78 9:;
() �( �( �*6��*)�� M| }~;
�
)�� (�(
(� �� �� (*(��*(�� +� ,- ./012
�
% )() ���
(� �� �� (*��)*66� TU
�
!" %js )6) ���
(� �)� �� �� �� 6*��)*��� kl o!" q�%rs )6� (�)
(( ��� �� �� �� 6*6��*��6
�
0
�
% )�� ��)
(6 �)� �� �) �� �*���*��� 78 O [H%' )�� ���
(� �)� �6 �� (� �*��)*��� ?@A BC
�
!" %' )�� (6�
(� �(� �6 �) �� 6*)��*��� JK JK0 ¡¢ Z%£ )�� ((�
(� ��� 6) �) (� 6*���*6�) � n�� n¤!" ¥¦%§ ��� 6��
6� ��) 6� �� (� 6*�6�*�6� +� ,- ./012
H%¨© )�� 6��
6) ��6 �( �� (� 6*���*(�� TU b\\eª«!" ¬%® ��� ���
6� )*�)� �) �� (( �*6�(*��� ¯H B°;;<±!" M%² ��� 6)(
6� )*�(( �� �� (� �*��)*���
�
¬Q;
�
!" ³%´' ��6 ��6
µ) )*��� )�( �� (� �*((�*6)� 78 9:¶^O ·%¸¹ ��� ���
� )*��) ))( �� (� �*6��*(() ?@A BC;
�
!" ºz%»j �() ���
� )*)(� )�� �� 6) �*(��*�)( JK JK2/0¼O ½Z%
¾ ��� ���
� )*)�6 )�� (� 6� )�*��)*)�6 bc bcn¤ª«/012 :%¿¦ ��� )��6
( )*)�� )�� () 6� )�*��)*�(� À À.�ÁÂÃ!" t
�
%»j ��� ���
6 )*��� )�� � (� 6� )(*6��*�)( TU b\ÄÂÃ!"\eª«!" JÅ%`^' ��� �6�
� )*)�) �� �� 6� �6 �(*(�6*(�( H� H�;ÆÇ!"H�;JÈ!" 9-%É ��� ��(
� )*�)6 �� )�) 6� �( ��*��(*��� oÊ oÊ;
� )*)�( �� ))� 6( �� �6*���*(�� 78 9:¶^O |
�
%²Ñ ��� ��6
)� )*)�� �� ))6 6( �� ��*�6�*�6� ?@A ?@An¤!Ò� Z
�
%4Ó ��� )���
)) )*)�� �� ))� (� 6� ��*���*6(6 Ô- ÕÕÖOÔ-Ô-
�
!" ×%Ø �)� ���
)� )*)�� �� )�� (� (� ��*�6(*��� M| M|n¤!Ò� Z%ÙÚ ()� )���
)� )*�)) ))� )�� (� (� ��*��(*�(� ÛÜÝÞ ßàáÌâã2 äå%æç �(� ���
)� )*�)� )�( )�� (� (( ��*���*)(� TU
�
!" èZ%^é ��� ��(
)( )*)�� )�� ))� �� (� ��*�)�*(�� kl kln¤!Ò� ê�ëìs ��( ���
)6 )*)�� )�� )�6 �� (� ��*���*(�� íH íHn¤!Ò�íH;
�
õëñ' ��� ���
�� )*��� )6� )�� �� �� ��*)��*666 TU TU�0�0â�0/012 ��ë[¦ �6� 6��
�� )*))� )6� )�� �� �6 KH KH�0�0â�0/012 ��%
�
��� �6�
,-�â0��
�!� r! \
�
! ?�! �%�
-
���������
��� 2012� 1� - 14 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������������
�����
�
����
� �� � ��
� ��� ��� � ���� �����
�
����
� ����� ��� ��
�
���� ���� !�"�
# $%�& '
�
�(� �) *+�,� -�./ !�"�
0
�
�1 '
�
�(� �2 ���34 �5�67 8��9
: ;
-
���������
��� 2012� 1� - 15 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�� 23� 117 26�
=101-0047Ko>?â@aAâ 1-18-11
89:;* ����-�
Tel. 03-3259-7919
http://www.htsj.or.jp
B* ������������������������� !"#$%&'�()*�+�,&-+
./01234$%56�7�'89���:;$
-
50���������
��� 2012� 1� - 16 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
��������
�������� 50 ���������
�� 23� 9� 30��10� 1���������
� !"#$%&%'���(�)*+,-./
01234567-(�89:�;
(?.@A,B/
���CD4EF����8 20 �GHI
JKLMN�(3O*+(?,B/PQ8�R+
SI�4T+(?.UVW����FX=Y
Z(�50�����[\-?UVW��=3
O-.?7]^,-./50����E_34`a
�FMN����=bcBdefMNe`a
�`ag7hij�kl-�50����E_34
`a�!"#mE��(�01no!"#��p
F�)=qr?.@A,-./st��uvFw
xFyz{=|}�34`a�=~�-��
Z,-./
no7-(8�2250�F
F%F�����JKP�,p���F
|}�Bd�=6(�R+K=c
-�JPF���F�Bdno7Bd
7��� 50 ��4EFk7-([\-?h
F7]^,-./-J-�_=K+
.yz{ph�g �T.dno=TJZ¡B
¢,7:d78JZ£A¤5p¥Z�¦
=!§A¨©?.@©dJHªJ}«p-./¬
?yz{F®i�"Z¯°�Z,-./
�� 50��=��Bd7?ª7p���
F±²7-( 100³´µ=¶·-,-./78?
^�+@©F¸¹¦º=»Bd��
=¼i-��½h¾¿À�¥d7J
K��)Á7-(8R+K�[\-?¢FÃÄ
ÅÆ=Ç-(!Z,-./ÈÉ7-(��
�8 2Ê�u? 189³�ËÌ��h 142³FÃÄ
=?.@A,-./���p8F"ª�Â
¢F{�ÃÄ?.@A�7 ³F¦�"dÍ 1
�F�!?(8�ÎÏ77h�����
F�bFÐ=Ñ9�K£?�ÒÓ=*>(?
.@¢7�pA,-./*K�ËÌ�!"#Ô
ÕÖ×�=Ø9(�ÙÚ8kÛ�Z�¢?Ü?
ÝÞ�T.d�aFßàáâF½7-(iãä
Jå.7]^(!Z,B/� 5æ�J+(F
FÔÕÖ×�p8ç%è�%=?.@A
�K�¦74éFyz{=|}�äê,pÂ
¢Fwx2|ëìíîïðñòFóô×õ8ö
hFp-./,.���p8÷:(F WEB �"
dïø«ù=3O-�ÃÄ�ú-?{û�hü
\?.-,-./
£é=É.-(¢@*?,-.¦Fyz{�
ä¢Ñý?.-,B/,.���F01JK
3O�T.Z�þ�ç���=?.@?.�
���I�g����g�)7-(��
�½F��=�å(?.@?.�������
!"#ÔÕÖ×F4é=!§A¨©?.@A,
-.yz{�®¢!��-��,B/,.�Ã
ÄFÎÏ77h�£��-?��=�7�p
A.7�34`ak�Ñý?.-,B/S��
���F�� ï!!"#3O"#=�-
,B/
�������� 50��������
�)� ������
)� ������$%MN�������
�����
9� 30� ���������
10:15~10:30
��&34`a�`ag £'( �)
*+&, 50�g ��
10:30~12:00-.2/0��óôF 50�
������� � ������������ Report on the Heat Transfer Seminar of HTSJ 50
th
Anniversary
12� ã� 1�£'(� �) 2�3� 45 1�67� 89 1�:;� ?� @A 4
1��V�£��2BC£��3DE�F£��4%GH_£�
Yoshio UTAKA1
, Hidetoshi OHKUBO2
, Takuto ARAKI1
, Seigo SAKAI1
, Tatsunori ASAOKA3
, Shohji TSUSHIMA4
(1 Yokohama National Univ., 2 Tamagawa Univ., 3 Aoyama Gakuin Univ., 4 Tokyo Inst. of Tech.)
-
50���������
��� 2012� 1� - 17 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
IA JK%G£�³LMN�OPC£�MN
�Q RAST£�³LMN
12:00~12:45U¢V��óôF 50�
W XY%GH_£�³LMN
Z[
14:00~15:30Ó\2]^üâ��óôF 50�
g _`³abH_£�³LMN
cd efST£�³LMN
15:45~16:30�g��óôF 50�
h kijkãl£�MN
16:30~17:15���m 50�F
|E C%GH_£�³LMN
17:15~17:30 n�
Z[2op
18:30~20:30 ËÌ�$%&%'��
20:30~ ��ÔÕÖ×�$%&%'��
10� 1� 7:00~ qr
��
01�
�� st����E_34`a�MNe`a��
ef� u$v£�
wE�x%y£�
�� st����E_34`a��
12�ã��V£�
�� st������34`a��
£'(��)BC£�
34`a�
£'( �)BC£� `ag
3 45�V£� � zE
67 89�V£� � zE
:; ? @A%H£� � `a
wE x%y£ `a
� A�V£� � `a
ÔÕÖ×456
Q �zG£
ó
£
Q SH£
�G£
%H£
2� ST£
� q %G£
� ¡E¢�£
2Q (fST£
�����
�������������
PQ�WEB�"d��Fïø«ù=4?
,-./«ù8 USTREAM�"Z4?�34`a
�7-(磤ð=¥¦-,-./�½pF
ð�§¨©Fª«834`a�p-.
Wi-Fi �"Z4?,-./¬�?(8�¦
Fyz{F®¯Fh7���mE��(Ü¢°
�Bd7?ª{±�²·*+�&�³��H�"
d¬\´8¶©µ�«ù=4?,-./� 1�3
¶�«ù*+.1·pB/¸¹�205´µF{�
¬-(?.@?(!Z�"Z2ºµpF«ù
�?(
-
50���������
��� 2012� 1� - 18 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
� 2� ��ÊËFÏÑ
PQF��p8�pAd@©Ü?ÝÞF{
�¦Fyz{F!Ò=Ó?(?.@A.?7?
ªÔ?�¥Z,-./RF.:F¥Z"Ð7-(�
ÙÚª?å.���Õ=Ö×��F¼?
�zFÎ*Ø�hÃÄ=Ù#J©�¼-phÃÄ
-¡B¢d"ªÃÄÚ=kÛ"ZhÜ¢¶·-
,-./,.�kÛJKh¢F{�ÃÄ-(?
.@¢.:��FÐFÃÄÚ8ÝÞ7-,-
./RF�Éh¥Z���8Ü?ÝÞ�T.
å(.¢*ØF{�ÃÄ?.@¢7�pA,
-./34`ak�£�ß-¢Ñ9(!Z,B/
��6�8��JKËÌ��ÔÕÖ×
�,p�ñà¡ñáh¢�!�â�4ª7�
pA,-./ÃÄÅFÎÏ�8�����ã
ià�äå¢@*?,-.7�,.�ÃÄæ
ÌF¶�8�!ç-?|EIFæÌ7ÃÄÚF!
èé�äå¢@*?,-.7��ê:(!�
=�-��,B/,.�F��=ÖëBd
�¥.Z��¨ìF�z*Ø.í��I�JK
-�6�8sqJK¨î�'��'�ïn
H£�ðñ=-(¢+,-./òKFäå�ü-
(hF½p!�=?T>(?.@A.?7Ô?
,B/
� 3� ¨îFÏÑ
�����������
�������
� 50 ��F=!Ò-?.@¢�µ7Ý?Î
p¥Z�pAd´Z-åJZ-.Þ
=¼i-.?7?ª7p�6�FÞ�8óô
-
50���������
��� 2012� 1� - 19 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Wp8¢Þ�µdhF=õö2÷�-�
«ø*>(?.@¢77-,-./!ç-?
J�¦Fyz{�8ùú=s:�ûî?.@?
..:�6��Bü(FFÞ=¼iBd
7�pA,-./ê:,-(¦Fyz{�®¢
ý��-��,B/
� ¦Fyz{�¼i-(?.@?.ùúFno
8þ�K-¢�+JKF�F 50�hÃÄÅFÎ
ÏF!x�?(?.@©d@©F��F¥d
hF�å.J7Ô?,B/
������
�������
����F£A�p¥d�8���
������ F�p4T+,-.� 4/
���gF*+F�7³F¦Fyz{JK�
[�Ï���U¢V���üâ����
g����m��FL�!©d�Ý�
�T.d=!Ò-?.@A,-./
� 4� �FÏÑ
��F=R++F�Zp���J
�Ò=*+.¦Fyz{FÒ�§Aé,+(?
¢|p�y5.íF�*+.Õ�F£A*=ßd
7�pA�F��F�àFkp¥d 50
�F�É=�d7�É.>.7Ôå(?,B/
¦Fyz{�8�PQFF.:�¢F¹
=�?(?.@?.7�ê:(!��-��
,B/
Fno8UVJKÃÄ-(?.@?.
{û��í�å.�Ñ�,7:,-.���
�10 ��Vol.50,No.213�8�/0��F
50 �7]^üâ��óô 50 �FQ���
�*+(!Z��F�$-(h�����
���*+d�·pB/
��� !"�
�������
�������� pF�� 50 ������
���F�q�½�=$%&%'��
�o-�ËÌ��4T+,-./
34`a�£'(`agFA�4p�6÷F
�·ØZ 18:30 ��,Z,-./89:��34
`a�=Þ�-(01=56-.12`aK#
��gJK*+=?.@A�«?(�
�34`a�Fwx$ð��= !-(?.@A
,-./ !�wx$ð���A�=§A"#�
|EC%GH_£�³LMN�$%F&'=(
)?.@?(�* 50 FË+7�r�oZ,-
./RF��� 50��=èZ,d.:��LM
NJK-.?.@?.ÇÈ=ì/ç%�!7
-(�'0�ð��Þ��1-���34`
a�F12yz�efyz�wEyz"Z�ÇÈ
|Fyz{F !¡ÊËF¶F234��H=
!Ò?.@A,-./ÎÇÈ=-.?.@
?.{û��®¢ý��-��,B/ì/ç%
�!F !�q���p?.@?.
yz{=Þ�-(�QyzJK$¨��5=?.
@A,-./*K��3�����gJKh
$¨��5=?.@A�6��s7Q£�2
Qyz�"d�� 50 ����89Fïn7e
fyzF$¨��5F�G:�·ØZF 20:30
�n�;
-
50���������
��� 2012� 1� - 20 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�K/ÔÕÖ×�8�¦Fyz{�ü
â�-.2/0�U¢V��g���
�mF 5æ�J+(?.@A�,.�¦F
yzJKwx,p�!�âüÒ�pAd"ª�
LNb 2³FL�jMFä?yz�4
56=!N?-,-./
� 6�8?µ+FNbhG:Oæp¥Z��0ð
'P�ÕZµQ|p£A�CÄRBdH=Z
��å.ÏÑp-./US7-(�õ×=TJ¢
U^dVWX�¥Z�wx¡�z�YZà�(<
-(?.7�õ[��Z,-./
� ¦Fyz{�8Í F7ËÌ�F7?
ª7h¥Z�¤58£AJå.J7\9,B
��ÎÏ�ê]¢,pÃÄ?.@A,-./¥
Z�7ª^?,-./,.�Ö×�US�X=
«å(?.@?.�456Fyz{�hý��
-��,B/
������
� 1� �������� 50��������ÔÕÖ×
�½&$%&%'��
3O56_`a
!"#¦ N� b 456 Eb4
Ó\üâì]^üâ
g_`³H£³LMN
cdefST£³LMN
412}æ Q�zG£
ó
{;|}~£
-.ì/0
IAJK%G£³LMN��
OPC£MN�
�QRAST£³LMN
413}æ £
QSH£
� A�V£
U¢V
WXY%H£³LMN
401DX-Twin �G£
%H£
6789�V£
�g
hkijk£MN
501DX-Twin 2� ST£
� q%G£
:;?@A%H£
US4&12ã��V£�£'(�)BC£�345�V£
%��&'()����*+,-./�
�� 50����E_8�cdJKef=g
dhph¥d7Ô?,B/��FKij�Fh
8OÕ-(?.@©.p-kªJ/
l�µ�50����E_Fk7-(UVWF
����=3OBd7�²,Z�mµ7
¢��p`a�=�A�`a�F8|¹npÒ
-ò?,-./}«Fo8pA?hFp�9 �
21 ��%����q-.rsp8t6£u
Frs 15��$%=Øc-����F��
|v�å.wx��=Ó?.¹�8�6�Fy
X�zÜ�Z,-./¬?�y{�h|,+�
�������� JK$%&%'��©Fop
h��F¿}=�-Ð�K���Fn=~
?(?.@©.Fp8?J7Ôå(?,B/
�½7å.�������� 8£JFÞ
�à?Fkp¥Z�VFØp�rü(�
�¢d�b8p¥Z�rü?h>Ð
?h34`a�Fwx$��d7
�Z�ß-?=¥�d7�Z,-./
6��PQF�������JJTå(
?.@?.Bü(FÎÏ��ê:(!��-��
,B/
��� !"�
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 21 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
��������
�����[1]����������� !"
#$%& 75�'()*&�+,� 20-�# �
��./#0.1' 23�������456
7'()*��8-9:;��# 1960�?
@3�AB'(C &�#DABE 50�F'()*
G�HI'�����J8�KL�!"#MN
OPQ�R)*
��#STUV'WX��YZ�>;['()
�\M? ]K1?^I_R`�'(C a>]
b1?`cde`�'()*&Q�f?gh%i
? DSa'?��jklkm�Q�no�>
Kp���-# 20-qr?st*]K?uvQ
�` 2q-wr ��xy?z��(boiling){|
}`�?uvQ�` &�-#~? 1qr�
)*'?�B�>x# &�B�
����Q &��dhG�'
()*'()*QAQR?`1?#
1960�KU KU�Q�Q &�
AB����� ¡?
¢= £¤ ¥¦e8B`�����§¨©3
�ª>*a> «¬�KL' `�y�>
)��?®h)G�8'ª>*G�%i?¯1
e��N78�����!"N7�°±²³Q�
R)*´# &�%ie7�����?µh
)1e¶�·[¸?Q>`�'()G
� ¹º+,?$»CQ�$ª>R*&Q�
# ���¸¼½¾¿k�À[�Q�Áx#
ÂkÃ��?uC &�`ÄÅ��ÆÇ?ÈR
�ÉÊËkÃ��?ÌR�#Í��ReR*
rÎAB# Ï-#ÐeR��HÑÒ3
>*QAQ F�%i?Óe-��� &
�§ÔÕÖh)�Q�`AeC�×-8Ød'
()*R?`KL 30��Æ�Ù` DÚ�\
Û���Ü�ÝÞ8(C z�����
ß ;à á¤{�xQ>â�ãQ>*&
G' cäåæ Ï-�çèé1? ´#
ê�Q�&�f� 20 �?ëéQ>��
h)G��Q>*ìí?Q>��`9-?î)>
= ×-�ïEAB �ðñ2ò'óQ>`�#
&�ìô�ðõö��hG��Q>*a>
?µQ�'()8 �ðñ2ò£÷` 1996�
?z������ø¤ùx{�úh)â�ñ3ò
óû�R)*&�ü'`ýM�����
Q�R)*´'#�þ'`����cä
åæ)%i�=>*a> �/#�¦�ReRG
��Q>*�/?ÌR�#F´()R#DÚ�K
L�� 50��Æ��kñ4ò��ìô�
R>R*dh)?´# &��'#�� �
�>��e3�ReR*GiQ>�3
>G�?�=����$ª>R*a> ��#
���;[�§Ì'(C z����{#��;
[����§Ì § þ?!eR*��?#"
#¦Ke$%�9:� þ8()*&3� r�
AB�B�>ùxy#z������� 50
�{'(3>8 &�´ó�xy?��o
û�R>'R>*G�?µQ�`$»CQ�$
ª>R*
����������
��a�=)F? G�a'���-(
��À[&�%µ)*��+,-Y�$ª
>R*.�� 1?&�,-gh*#G�
a'/0� �����# 1970�AB 1980�8
1kË'(3� ��V2#&�f34"I'(
C ��-#è5�6Ñ?()�73�R>*Q
AQ� 1Y)uC 8Ù#&i'#eRG�8
ÐA)*J8«?$æ)������9:#9:
�;² ¹º�?@A'BC./o��
R)*&Q� &�./���-#DA?¡�è
56Ñ?()*G�E'#�Fæ)·[�\
�'()*QAQ«Ù1?Y)� G#H:I
������� A Review of Boiling Research in the Past Fifty Years
JK� LMNOPK
Masahiro SHOJI (Kanagawa University)
e-mail: [email protected]
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 22 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
e3�R)*heÐQ KpR?./o�)��
µS���-# ¡�TU?VWQ�R)*� 1
�XkY#WebZ['�>`�'(C &�-#
\�Q>Z[É]^?%3�Ie)�7i8 K
pR Z[É]^?%Bº ��-#��O?
_BA?VW6Ñ?()*&�`a# ���b
�8cdefg(h]Ëi�Xj]k lmh
]Ëi;[�n�23>&¤?oR9p 9�þ
?sq'R)>=�7i8 QAQ§� "8A
Ceµ)`rs'ª)*heÐQ¡� «ÙKp
R�-`tu?V��$C G�?)2Q���
-8V��R)�'#eRA �`í�B�)*
G�8��-VW�ê>)vw�h�� ��-
�VW6Ñ#xQ?���.y��zÌæ)G�
?{8Ua�)*
|R(Source)?µ)Q ���E}-¡:8 2
Ì�êdKpR heÐQ International Journal of
Heat and Mass Transfer, A Journal of Heat Transfer
?~óo��R)G�8ÐA)*¡� G�8
9' &�?o�()?(3�
G�8# ()HIPCR`�'()*î
� 2R?ëéQ�$æ� 5e:�`�����
y#���)'(iAB'()*
�`(� � 1AB �����y()R#
?µQ RR�G�8Y��)*
����������
RKU(��AB ���K?ÙQ µ
)�ð8(aC?`9: $�h��R
AÐABeR ÌR�#Ød+çu��ðÕÖ
Q�:�eRA��o�)G�8()*a>
����?ÌR� 10r�cd?Q�/1
e��gQ�:�eRA ���`Fæ)*
QRÝÞ'(C�'()*G�'æ�'�
��9R;['()*?Q�BoeR9#
5e: `Q>`��AC ��rs#
%:`�'ª)*G�?#9?��;[��I
�8vwQ�R%i*ÌaC ���`�?#¹
º��k^kk�`�8Ød'(C ä
|e;['()'æ? `���`?%3�
aQaQ'()*Q>83� ::BR
�7RC8oR� ¡'¢£Ì�æ�eR
2010
1990
1980
1970
1960
1950
1940
1930
2000
Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer
J. Heat Transfer
Nuc. Eng. Design
Exp. Thermal Fluid Science
Int. J. Multiphase Flow
Cryogenics
Int. J. Refrigeration
Int. Comm. Heat Mass Transfer
Int. J. Thermal Science
Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow
Others
39.2%
16.5
9.1
6.7
5.2
5.0
5.0
4.4
3.1
2.6
3.2
Journals68
135
29
��(�����
Jakob(���
37
196
�������
(1243)
INT. J. Heat
Mass Transfer
(943)
INSPEC
(8881)
Science Direct
(2080)
Journal
(68)
Zuber(CHF���
�������
Int.J.Heat Mass
Transfer���
Ist IHTC
Sci.Direct
Boiling 240000
Boiling in Engineering 24300
Boiling in Title 2085
INSPEC(1970-2004)
Boiling in Title 8881
Ist ICNMMC
PWR(1957)
�����BWR(1959)
��� Sulzer(1931)
�!(1973)
"���#$%&'()
*!(1978)
+,-./01
���23./
�4523
�6�%78
Ist Boiling Conf.
295:����;
295:����;�5
MEMS01
Fritz(?@ABC�
Rohsenow(����;�
DE��
2010
1990
1980
1970
1960
1950
1940
1930
2000
Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer
J. Heat Transfer
Nuc. Eng. Design
Exp. Thermal Fluid Science
Int. J. Multiphase Flow
Cryogenics
Int. J. Refrigeration
Int. Comm. Heat Mass Transfer
Int. J. Thermal Science
Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow
Others
39.2%
16.5
9.1
6.7
5.2
5.0
5.0
4.4
3.1
2.6
3.2
Journals68
135
29
��(�����
Jakob(���
37
196
�������
(1243)
INT. J. Heat
Mass Transfer
(943)
INSPEC
(8881)
Science Direct
(2080)
Journal
(68)
Zuber(CHF���
�������
Int.J.Heat Mass
Transfer���
Ist IHTC
Sci.Direct
Boiling 240000
Boiling in Engineering 24300
Boiling in Title 2085
INSPEC(1970-2004)
Boiling in Title 8881
Ist ICNMMC
PWR(1957)
�����BWR(1959)
��� Sulzer(1931)
�!(1973)
"���#$%&'()
*!(1978)
+,-./01
���23./
�4523
�6�%78
Ist Boiling Conf.
295:����;
295:����;�5
MEMS01
Fritz(?@ABC�
Rohsenow(����;�
DE��
� 1� ������-szµ)*��,-
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 23 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
¤e$æ)`�'#eR*��# &i23�
`2'#eR¥�;['AB'()*&�'`
ß?# ~�>½¾¿k��( ¦#-
9:n§o��R)*&G' ´¨©?ª«�
Q� �)¬' &�B�ðG�a�
=�gQ�()*K(K�Ù�ìí?e)�
7i*
�������� !"#$%&
��# ®�� ¯-�� °��� 3Ì�±
km�²?+o� &�±km�³´?u
´�µ¶ CHFCritical Heat Flux���µ¶
MHFMinimum Heat Flux8·àh)�Q�
�`(`�8eo��ª>*u´�µ¶#
3�#zjk=¸@^�µ¶{�¹���R>
8 cºE»¼�;²e$'#غQ`&�E'
½ª�8U�eRG�AB ;à'#u´�µ
¶�¹t�8T��e3>G�#��G�'(
)*a> ��µ¶?ÀbQ�u´�µ¶z�
�µ¶{�¹tG�`¾¿'(i8 (aC
�ReR*b�î ÀÁ�ÂÃ?�zÌ:�µ¶
�Ri���>='()*
���űkm���?ÌR�# G�a'
9:�±XÃ(`Æ8ÇÈo��ª>8 ;à
É:B��RB��R)�# £�±XÃ(
`Æ'()*®��'# ��Ê
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 24 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Shoji����k[29]�'(C &�%9R*
/01234)56 !"
��,N?ÇÈo�>í�# "#8W�þ
�R��Ó� !²?")�: u´8U
�)�h) Rohsenow-Griffith [17]?/o�)"
#��±XÃ'()*()R##$�ÆAB.
Ï�n?%3�`Æ%ª 8�1?v-v
=> Kutateladze�&�Æ [8]8%:B�)*&
�f Zuber[11] ?%3�µ�¦K1�'v?¸
(R>`�±XÃ8ÇÈo� &�`�1)Qo
� �:1?F Kutateladze�Æ8Y?%A�
>G�AB É:*+o� , ÔÕ-�.�e
$/�1?\� yÊo�>[30][31][32]*§�
-ÐÑ[12] # c012?%)ê��34e
�AB 8Ù�u´�µ¶E���8
Zuber �2i²�e3�ReRG� ²�"#
5?·àh)Ó°®��Ó6�ûü?%3�
u´8U��R)¾¿�rs vÒ-[13] #
&�í�vÆ�Q�78hËiÓ°±XÃí
9Q>*G�hËiÓ°±XÃ#u´�µ¶?u
Bº c�µ¶®����(¯-����`
_'ª)G� ÔÕ:(;xW�þ: oB?
#µ2��:-�Ì�?Ç
'(3>*QAQ@A1+¡?e3� Ú>eí
�(±XÃ8Çno��R)*FN�µ¦±XÃ
�hËiÓ°±XÃ# ��2M7.y1?
B�)`�'()8 W�þî���;[Ó�
�"#�C7D�x�Q�B� &�D�
PCÛ8®���#E� u´�µ¶`v=)
�h)í�����]±XÃ8 Dhir-Liaw
[27][28] ?%3�F�B�>*a> Í©-GH-
Îü[33][34] # É��]¸W�þ�IþAB�
;[�AB W�þî�"JÓ 3�´þ�³´
êo8u´v=)�Q>í� a>K-VL-
MÎ[35][36] # &� 3�´þ�cR�µ¶# 1
."#5Ô?·àh)�ËiÓ°�ó.8#$Q
�R)��nQ�R)*GiQ>ÚQRÇÈ
Fæ Rº��±XÃ8Ný'()A# ;à
O��Pü?()8 űXÃ?#&�Q�x
#()�Q�` Rº�`\§�;[R3�$
C &�Q�`�()ê='(C غQ`9
S§'()Ød#oR*W�þî�;[2B
�)�Q�` &�Q�8T3>UÈ(T3>k
VkÃ';[¢=�R)*W�þABË�>U
È'�µ�2?ëéQ>`� W�þî�Óã
WhËi?B�%i�Q>`� �Ëi?4A
:B�>`� Û�'()*$�R�±XÃ@
AZXQ� Y§1?Z[h)\í�8ØdA`
Q�eR*
u´�µ¶�.U?ÌR�# %?`ão�>
ùx8() &¤�±XÃ�Rº�` ô��e
$�W�þ��ùú#|a��ReR*QAQ
8�1?#u´�µ¶#W�þ�ô��?%
3�ª:��h)[37]*§� hËiÓ°±X
Ã?ÌR�2�� Ó°�í9]��^A�8
_D'e: vÒ-[13] #"Ó´þ�µ�¦K
1�'v?%)�Q�R)8 +¡�8���'
# 1 ."#�²�?%)��Y�8R
[23][24][25][38][39][40]*Rº�?Q�` ���
��é_�`2�)u´�µ¶?µQ á'�H
?`�'ª�R)�#2RR*
78���)9:;?.
æT ��`a?$R�¯-����# u´
�µ¶E���µ¶E�t�'/;o�)*
QAQ;[1?2�� G�/;#�Æ1e`�
'(3�b�o? æ)*¯-��;[#JÓ�
®Í8M71?uQ:�2h)cvT��R�
've`�'()*��%i?��`a?%)
/;?#M71dã|aeR*Q>83� �
�`a'# ûRdRÂa/;?%3� e1e
f�gh�8u´'(3� ��`aî?
¯-��/;h)G�#v`1?�¾¿eG�
'()*
¯-�����%:B�>/;�Q�.�
Kalinin�Æ8()[41][42]*
( )FqFqqFN
−+⋅= 1 � � � 1
GG?N
q F
q #&�Q����µ¶ °���
µ'()*N
q F
q �Q�RAe)f��h)
A?ÌR�#O�89R*N
q �Q�u´�µ¶
�C F
q �Q���µ¶�)í� ()
R#¯-���?ÀbQ>®��gê`a�
f�°��gê`a�f)í�8()*¯-
��?$æ)W�þÞ��µ¶�M71f3
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 25 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
4?�vQ>�:[43][44] ?%�� f�í�
?¡R`�� W�þÞ`M�h���Q�$
C &�LQ:/;h)�#QR*e$ F
�f?ÌR�# G�a'9:��v8eo�
$$%&�f#ÐA3�R)[45][46][47]*
§� ®Íi�9f�F®Íi�fj®Í
i?a¤Q� ¯-��`a?`9f�2
�`a8;�)��ê=8 Lienahard –Wittei?
%CÇno�[48] §MN&�#kh)��`
no�>[49][50] 8 &�f�34e�v?%3
� &�l8mvo�>[51][52]*&��: ¯
-���9f�?ÌR��O�#¡(aCeo
�eR*
¯-��# $�%ieëì'Ó�8W�þ?
®Í'ª)ôBh�A $�%ieëì?e
)�Ó�8W�þôBoe:e)�A�2i
Ó��¤�?`µ)Q>�eJÓ®Í�x�
:µ)Q�R)*G�HI' �����?$
R�zô�{�x#�_?êRM7dh)A
`�eR*
e$ ¯-��?µh)G�a'�/1e�
��h)�.�%ie`�8()*��?
µh)`�[14][19][53][54][55] JÓ®Í?µh)
`�[45][46][47] /þ�e$ùúwø?µh)
`�[56][57][58] Ö'()*
@AB234)9:;?.
��µ¶v=)í�? ª:23�nÌ
8()*&�§Ì# Berenson[59] ?/o�)�
µ¶#$±XÃ'(C %�§Ì# Spiegler[60]
(Í©[61] ?/o�)Þ#$±XÃ'()*
��%i?F�í�# °���ó"°o
kh)?# W�þABÓ�-+çu���pq
8Ød' &�+�f8��µ¶�h)`�
'()*G�?ÀQf�í�# Ó���u
´�`µ)Q ()Þ'Ó�#¤�1?cÞþ
?#®ÍQ:ô�: &�Þ'��µ
¶E8vaC �µ¶#&�Þ?$æ)°��
��?�ýh)�h)`�'()*G�$QB
8LQRA ãÆe8BRº��í�?�3�`
$$%&r>f8��o�sÌæR�'()
8 f��8t_'`�Q¡R*
§� :�u¦������8�v3>
Sakura B[62][63] ?%�� çu'���µ¶
#F�±XÃ?%)f?¡: :�u¦8î8
)?Ì� f�±XÃ?%)f?¡(:��r
s8()*��µ¶#°��8wxQ�.Uh
)`�'()*°��8wxh)?# &�^
yk�e)`a;7�z78e:�#eBe
R*æT ��µ¶��v8�#Pu�ªo
�W�þ W��{(4a�R�vÐ�)*
W�þ8Pu'(�� غ&�³´8(C &
G'#|æ W�þ#Ó�?}��R)*&3�
&�Ô8^yk�e3�°�wx8~G)
�í�)G�8n¤%i*8Ù W�þ�³´�
Þc:okh)] ()R#�Äe�'
W�þ�ô�R'()� ��µ¶�f#
ª:e)[64][65]*oB?# Ó��]k
êê#)A?�>ªeW�þ
()R#}�RW�þ'# ��µ¶E#ç
Þ ?ª:-2Q &3���µ¶�f8c
T?o:e)���`()[66]*G�%i?
��µ¶.U�x`J��®Í�x8µ
Q�R)>= ;à'`á�å�x85eAB
ºão��R)*
��µ¶E# b�?µQ�2�� ó"
.�.U( t0fg?$æ)Ë=Þ?µ
Sh)*GiQ>b�x# cvT���x
'()>= x#%Cä|e`��eC �å
hª*#9:ão��R)*
CD��)2E-�FG
°��# Ó��W�u´#)A?�>W
�þÞ'U�)`�'()*&�>= Ó�#
ó"6}�'·àh)*heÐQ W�þ�
Ó��x®1e®Í#e: Ó6 ó"68Ë
�Q>����²'()>= ®��(¯-
��?@ ##)A?'(C 8�
�?$R�`væC'()>= �ý�O�`
e: ão�>x`5eR*GiQ>e�
²'()>= �����@A1Rýþ'e
o�> Berenson%, W�þ[67][68][69][70]
( Bromley %;xW�þ(, ÔÕ
[16][17][71][72][73][74] Hendricks-Baumeister{
W�����[75]�9:8DS'`&�a
a��'�RB��R)*>'Q ;xW�þ�
;²# ó"6´þ��'vê?`µSQ�
)1?§Ûeó"°#�9o�º ��^8
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 26 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
n¤)��±XÃ[76][77]8no��R)8 ̧
1?#I�x'#eR*
G�%i?°��#@A1`�Q(hR���
²'()8 ��µ¶?¡(:� �ß#
(�JÓ�®Í88Ù?#U�*
��#M7C71?�ä|eca��µ�;[
'()*&Q� 1990��*G�
±XÃ#Ú'#(3>8 v�1'8Ù1e`
�'#eA3>*��%i?��?# î 3
Ì�¤`���'e: "#�.U#W�þ�
"#®AB`U�)G� "Ó�´þ?#�'v
;[8·àh)* Î�±XÃ?# &�B8
¨Q�R>*&G'B# &�B�dãW
IQ ��*&�e±Xã¤��:# ©:
:8Ù�;[(µ)wø�ùú;'ª)`�
'(3>[80]*§� &iQ>±XÃí9�\M
? 8���;[8&`&`��k2'()
AmA?ÌR�{8(3>>= ¥4a?%
)8����kª»Þ�2¸^ËY�í9
v3��>�G DA?��k12gQ
>[81]*«CQ` ¬«�ik¸±k��7'
# Nelsonü\? c�µ¶®���®eMC
7�n±XÃ7íü'(C a>�Ëk�¯
kmK'# Kenningü\? W�þÞ�3
4eMC7£�v3�R>>= 3 8O\'
���ä|����viG��e3>*O\�
�#-�°o� &�9:#½¾¿k��[82]
�Q��Q>*&��:a�=)� ��k
ª»?%3�DA?���ä|�vW1?±²
'ª;[�`�#q'8 ãÆe8B��k¦
K�2�$ (:a'§Ì��n³kÃ?!º
&�£3�x8xQ?�å'ª)`�'#e
RG�8´_Q>*�³kÃ�Q��c0�
]�.�8 &�aa;[��_?)8BeR
��G#H:\�'()*dh)?���#
(:a'Å�¸]X¸(í�8¸'()*
HHQR��STUVO
¡�#µøÀÁÚ¶��/�VW(½k·Ö
¸KÀÁ�Þ×¹�®�� ()R#ÅpÀÁ
�¥�h]Ëi�?ºi�àá(Þ×¹
�»pd¼�>= �de�cR��-�N½
8É83�R)*G�>=MEMS(h]Ëi¾
¿Ã�R>�Xj]k�Ê.(�¿Ñî?Ñæ
>������ ()R#Àk^Á]Â(¥
c¦?$æ)�� c�ÂÃ?()¥µ¶
-�b�í�>¥4���MEBMicro Bubble
Emission Boiling ��¿Ñî�>=?ÄÅÆ
�e$�Dz�R%i�h)�����
�e$8Áx�e3� ����8V"(R�R
)*G�B�^1Ë?ÌR�#��8;àv
ü'(C &�9:a�=)ýþ�#e3�R
eR*Df�9:N½Q>R*
H����WXYZ[?
¡������# Åpb�î�d¼8(3�
ÈÐRYû�R)8 Kp1 ¸¼1ex?
ÌR�2�� ão�>ªeùx�Q�£�
3 Ì)G�8n¤)*É 1 #èo(j¾¾
Ê�e$"#�.U�®�U9?AAÐ)W
�þ��1D'�K1e/�x'
()*G�x#��;[��_?�3�+?
Q�+cd�á�åex'()*É 2#JÓ�
®Í ô�;[?µh)¤`1�_'()*G�
x��åe:Q�¯-��(��µ¶�LQ
R`�#(C�eR*É 3#���
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 27 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Ë= &���-�Ì��x'()*G�?#
î�W�þ��x�AC'e: "#®�
��("Ó´þ�ëì"#�²�ëì(ùúw
ø�`�8Ød�¾ '(C QRx'#
()8 -f£¤#-f8��Q�V�'ª �
v�QRW(*8�B� &�?%3���
�`�8Íý?}G�8N½'ª)*ø¤�(
)RÚ���?N½h)�G'()*
H�\]^
´#ÂkÃ��?uC &�`ÄÅ����
ÆÇ? a�8ª?Q>%i? GG 20��
����Q>*9?%8C'
�Î�Ô89R?TReR*Lx2�� ´
ÏÐh)? ѯ�`?9Ò�MN�ceC
�Î?M78�eA3>*QAQ G�8¿¦
�u´�2i`�'(C ÓQÔe: $ÕzQ
>R*
_`a A)���b]�cde
1) Tong, L.S., Boiling Heat Transfer and Two-Phase
Flow, John Wiley & Sons (1965).
2) ���� SÀÖKL (1965).
3) Hahne, E. and Grigull, U., Heat Transfer in Boiling,
Academic Press (1977).
4) Van Stralen, S. and Cole, R., Boiling Phenomena,
Hemisphere (1979).
5) Delhaye et al., Thermodynamics of Two-Phase
Systems for Industrial Design and Nuclear
Engineering, McGraw-Hill (1981).
6) �����fg SÀÖKL, (1989).
7) Lahey, R.T. ed., Boiling Heat Transfer, Elsevier
(1992).
8) Carey, V.P., Liquid-Vapor Phase-Change
Phenomena, Hemisphere Publishing Co. (1992)..
9) Tong, L.S. and Tang, Y.S., Boiling Heat Transfer
and Two-Phase Flow, Taylor and Francis (1997).
10) Kandlikar, S.G., Shoji, M. and Dhir, V.K.,
Handbook of Phase Change, Boiling and
Condensation, Taylor & Francis (1999).
ñ£#¦�+�Üò
11) Jakob, M., Heat Transfer, Chap.26: Local Boiling,
1957, 580-584.
12) Holman, J.P., Heat Transfer, 7th
Edition, Chap.9:
Condensation and Boiling Heat Transfer, 507-540.
12) ÍPmÎ �]K�×y É 2 Ø ®�
� ÙÚÛ (1974), 1-115.
14) �K `]KÜ (1982) É 9 Ü���
210-254.
15) % 3y �K�� É 4Ü����
ÙÚÛ(1984) 125-182.
_`a B)���b]�fghijke
������� Advances in Heat Transfer, Academic Press
Annual Review�
1) Leppert, G. and Pitts., C.C., Vol.1(1963),Boiling,
185-267.
2) Siegel, R., Vol.4 (1967), Effects of Reduced Gravity
on Heat Transfer, 144-228.
3) Jordan, D.P., Vol.5 (1968), Film and Transition
Boiling, 55-128.
4) Clark, J.A., Vol.5 (1968), Cryogenic Heat Transfer,
325-518.
5) Cole, R., Vol.10 (1974), Boiling Nucleation,
86-166.
6) Afgan, N.H., Vol.11 (1975), Boiling Liquid
Superheat, 1-50.
7) Sprieger, G.S., Vol.14 (1978), Homogeneous
Nucleation, 281-346.
8) Thome, J.R. and Shock, A.W., Vol.16 (1984),
Boiling of Multicomponent Liquid Mixtures,
60-157.
9) Cooper, M.G., Vol.16 (1984), Heat Flow Rates in
Saturated Nucleate Pool Boiling, 158-241,
10) Katto, Y., Vol.17 (1985), Critical Heat Flux, 2-64.
11) Kalinin et al., Vol.18 (1987), Transition Boiling
Heat Transfer, 241-323.
12) Nishikawa, K. and Fujuita, Y., Vol.20 (1990),
Nucleate Boiling Heat Transfer and Its Application,
1-82.
13) Wolf, D.H. et al., Vol.23 (1993), Jet Impingement
Boiling, 1-132,
14) Dhir, V.K., Vol.29 (1997), Heat Transfer from
Heat Generating Pools and Particulate Beds, 1-58.
15) Yagoobi, S.Y. and Bryan, J.E., Vol.33 (1999),
Enhancement of Heat Transfer and Mass Transport
in Single-Phase and Two-Phase Flows with
Electrohydrodynamics, 95-186.
16) Ghiaasian, S.M. and Khalik, S.I.A., Vol.34 (2001),
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 28 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Two-Phase Flow in Microchanells, 145-255.
17) Straub, J., Vol.35 (2001), Boiling Heat Transfer
and Bubble Dynamics in Microgravity, 58-172.
����
�������� Ref-(***) �����Vol.32, No.124
(1993)����� 30���������������� !�
"#$��%����(***)&'(
[1] Nukiyama, S., The maximum and Minimum
Values of the Heat Transmitted from Metal to
Boiling Water under Atmospheric Pressure, J.
Japanese Society of Mechanical Engineers,
37(1934), 367-374. or Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer, 9
(1966)�1419-1433.
[2] ��, �������������� ��
���32-124(1993), 193-104.
[3] ��, ������!�"# �����
34-137(1995),16-17.
[4] ��������� 50 � �$%�&' 50
��()*+,-./0*��1234()5�
(2011-10). &'Web673089
[5] Hsu, Y.Y. and Graham, R.W., Ref-(23)
[6] Friz, W., Maximum Volume of Vapor Bubbles,
Physic. Zeitschz., 36(1935), 379-354.
[7] Rohsenow, W.M., Ref-(24)
[8] Kutateladze, S.S., Ref-(25)
[9] Nishikawa, K. and Yamagata, K., Ref-(26)
[10] :;��?&�@A�B 2C�DE
F�1974�p.1049
[11] Zuber, N., Ref- (53)
[12] Katto, Y. and Yokoya, S., Ref- (32)
[13] Haramura, Y., Ref- (50)
[14] Kalinin, E.K. et al., Ref- (80)
[15] Berenson, P.J., Experiments on Pool Boiling Heat
Transfer, Int.J. Heat Mass Transfer, 5(1962),
985-999.
[16] Bromley, L.A., Ref- (101)
[17] Rohsenow, W. and Griffith, P., Ref- (52)
[18] Moore, F.D. and Mesler, F.D., Ref- (27)
[19] Berenson, P.J., Ref- (70)
[20] Gaertner, R.F., Ref- (19)
[21] Graham, R.W. and Hendricks, R.C., Ref- (28)
[22] Nishikawa, K. and Fujita, Y., Ref- (45)
[23] Bhat, A.M. et al., Ref- (33)
[24] Bhat, A.M. et al., Ref- (34)
[25] Bhat, A.M. et al., Ref- (35)
[26] Nishikawa, K. et al., Ref- (21)
[27] Liaw, S. P. and Dhir, V.K., Ref- (41)
[28] Dhir, V.K. and Liaw, S.P., Ref- (42)
[29] Shoji, M., et al., Chaos in boiling on a small-size
heater, Proceedings of the Fourth ASME-JSME
Thermal Engineering Joint Conference, Maui,
vol.2, 1995, pp.225-232.
[30] Sun, K.H. and Lienhard, J.H., Ref- (54)
[31] Lienhard, J.H. and Dhir, V.K., Ref- (55)
[32] Lienhard, J.H. and Eichorn, R., Ref- (56)
[33] :GY��-de
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 29 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
[53] Drew, T.B. and Mueller, C., Ref- (68)
[54] Westwater, J.W. and Santangelo, J.C., Ref- (69)
[55] Kalinin, E.K. et al., Ref- (80)
[56] Lin, D.Y.T. and Westwater, J.W., Ref- (89)
[57] Peyayopanakul, W. and Westwater, J.W., Ref-
(90)
[58] Irving, M.E. and Westwater, J.W., Ref- (91)
[59] Berenson, P.J., Ref- (93)
[60] Spiegler, P. et al., Ref- (95)
[61] Í© Ref- (96)
[62] Sakurai, A., Ref- (16)
[63] Sakurai, A. and Shiotsu, M., Ref- (17)
[64] JKmÝÎ z, W�ÔÕ�ÄÅ°���
��µ¶?µh)��{ S�
1986 B211 217-219*
[65] ÍPB Ref- (98)
[66] JKm»ø z, W�þî�ÄÅ°���
��µ¶?µh)��{ S�
1986, B222 220-222*
[67] Berenson, P.J., Ref- (101)
[68] Ruckenstein, E., Ref- (102)
[69] Lao, Y.J., Ref- (103)
[70] Chang, Y.P., Ref- (104)
[71] Sakurai, A. et al., Ref- (123)
[72] Bromley, L.A., Ref- (109)
[73] Bromley, L.A., Ref- (118)
[74] Bromley, L.A. et al., Ref- (124)
[75] Hendricks, R.C. and Baumeister, K.J., Ref- (128)
[76] Bui, T.D. and Dhir, V.K., Ref- (116)
[77] Nishio, S. and Ohtake, K., Ref- (117)
[78] Yanagita,T., Coupled Map Lattice Model of
Boiling,, Physical Letters. A, 165 (5/6) (1992)
405-408
[79] Yanagita, T. and Kaneko, K., Coupled Map
Lattice Model for Convection, Physical Letters.
175A (1993) 415-420.
[80] Shoji, M., Boiling Simulator, A Simple
Theorethical Model of Boiling, KN paper 3rd
ICMF’98 , Lyon, CD-ROM
[81] Shoji, M., Chaos in Boiling on a Small-Size
Heater, Proc. Fourth ASME-JSME Thermal Joint
Conference, Maui, 2(1995), 225-232.
[82] Shoji, M., Studies of Boiling Chaos, A review, Int.
J. Heat Mass Transfer, 47(2004), 1105-1128.
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 30 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
��������
��� 50 ���������������
� !"#$%&'()#*+�,-./�
012345 678&29:;?@#
AB�CDEFGH�IJ$K;LMN�12)
� OPQ%�RQ3STUV�W2X��'Y
�X;Z�.�[\]�1/�#O.3^�_Q
;,`a2b_1%'c�)� b;d1�Z
��W23
efg��hi�
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 31 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
����������������
� i� 50 ����jC[1]�µ%#'�IJ;
�N���� ����X;\��T2%�
�23�hi�IJ$K;X)&
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 32 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�¨�;< 77��=�&�eY2
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 33 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
^#O.3[Tx\MN�1.)�-�µ%;
6��~�Õw R-12 O.36��~��
$K¥×5
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 34 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
IJ< 1980��;�.�Ӹ�a23�x;
·~hÕ�CDi�¹¾ º°;µN23·
�CDi�¼ÐÑ;Ù-.()IJXÓ�'
��6�%bX¢£�K* ²b&._Q;µN
23��ýÙ�þ�CDi�ÐѪ
Â;Ù-.�ØÙ� »û'F¼½J;_ܵ8
&�1.[18]3Y2'¾¿Jb<�B¦îï
AB�CDi;Û¤-}�ØÙ���
1.[19]3
IJ�F���ÙÚ�a2X��d;'
�·;_.�B¦ O.[20]3�;_.
�B¦#ß¹��Û�.(�[;-��23
Ë}ð-�
©ªé�ê���XÚÛ�2[25, 26]3
� ���FîïÛ�.êj>Aîï
-�ìíù ç
�a23MEMSîï�Kª
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 35 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Eì�Iµ^ ÙÚ�a23�CDi
�½¾¼ÐÑ
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 36 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
hi��E�<�EIJKH�'w�
�E�;µN23
� 2000��;<��L��¨ê ¦W'U¶;
V.>A��·� (�8&')�(�
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 37 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
#O. 'ð�[À Àx'~J��
½01 vxHÕ8&�1.323ýÙ�þA%
vÞ��³$8Ê.3hú Fì�p
&'Xæ¹µ>Â#O.3hú Fì#O.
�wÍ$
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 38 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
t 11� ·~Õ�CDi;V.
�B¦îï[46, 47, 48]
×;°�x\0�µ1X�UP[ ON2
[50]3Y2'©ê�*³��,îïX¦ë�':
Ð�¼Ki*³�VÐ ÔÕ8&�1
.[51]3
)�*+�,����-./0��12345�
� ¾ê·~Õ�*h;
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 39 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
� 13� ��������������
� 14� ����������� !"
� 15� High Flux# GEWA-T$�% � ��
������&�'()*+�,-)./012
+345��)6789:;#?@AB
CDE.F#GHI3JKDE)=L>MN81
� 13 ������������=OPQ�RS
��T�)U0VWXY�Z0[\]^�_`
.FM=�abMN/01+HG>Z.cd=3
ef���9:MghiD#j(iD��$
P�kl8m#)N/01
� �������noD).Vpqrs#3t
u���vw'(nxyMGz()./01
Wielandy[{]HF= GEWA-T|}�~n(%
� 16� u% ��MF0`
[R-11,� 0.1 MPa]
01mMe)U�Z0�B
|}�~�3� 15)� 7)�
�M+0G�MN81�������#.V3
%�J##=+0Mf.n/
�81� 16)u% ��MF0�
71������� E# GEWA-T�
�)=' ¡¢n£¤+�8#-�F81
������� EM=¥){�+0' n¦§
¨©MªV3«¬�T®¯#%°J±²�
³´µ¶·+�8[53]1e¸ GEWA-T�
' M=j«¬(¹�º�»��n.V3
�)£¤+�8�HG¼.1ghi
D�$�������C�=�B$
[18 fins/inch])½¾3�¿À)+� 3ÁHF 4
ÁMN8[54]1
� 17)ÂR�ÃÄhÅ+0Æ71Â
R�Å?)=$Ç ���ÈH3ÉnÊ8$±
)GË~9Y��ÌÍ�V3F)ÎhR
ÏÐ+0m#GÑÒ+�8103ÎhRH
F)Ók78ÔÕÖn�$)×Ø7£
¤GK¾01ÙÚ% ��)=oDÛ)ÜÝ
V78�M=.H#�Þßne)=N81à
3JKR)U83áÖâ@ABCM
ãU8äå=Ó#+��æç+�ªV3
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 40 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
t 17� ���ê�HÕ;_.*höÜ
�á½
�mY��n
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 41 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
- 8&.3)&b�ªh ;ð
;µN�1.%-¶
ee{gJ~� �|}JÕâg
hi���}�DÕ-��¶-
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 42 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
t 22� [¾·|�ü
e=�M680 '1985�K*g[60]
t 23� Ëêýý�JÙ�ê�({
�N e=�M880,1990�[60]g
� 1980 ��;
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 43 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
b CMOS��"ÜD��a23)&;
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 44 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
°y±l#T.âR.;`ab&�1µ13�
F'�IJ5�ãQ
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 45 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
t 29� MEMS>-�ÍÜìíù[69]
ÑV�1.et 29g3)�µ%#�øs�m
nÏQ�¨}F¹%bmnrsõ�Áx0-.;
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 46 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
���¥.v³Ü²��1.3¶���³Ü 1
m2��³Z�.�')��³Ý�Ký±�
v£Aí îù;ïÜ
ETA-10
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 47 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
@ÁØ?�Qô; 300°C¿�.�x08
&�1.3¸ýKì< homogeneous nucleation#'
�³Ý�x¤W&�ÈÉ O.3)�pq
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 48 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
¢£;b&.3�hi;Ù-.IJ
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 49 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�, 47-200 (2008) 27.
[36]M½8µ�hiN, �, 44-186 (2005).
[37] ���hi�, �, 47-199 (2008).
[38] ���X�)xÜ , � , 41-171 (2002),
42-172 (2003), 42-173 (2003).
[39] ���ìíîï�� , � , 45-193(2006),
46-195 (2007).
[40] ���>Aø�#��Ë�J�, �,
49-207 (2010).
[41] ÜN;, LMÕN, ;V.~J��
½�lçeWg, ÒlÓîï, 32-8 (1978) 758.
[42] [BO5ã%, 6��©ðÕ�CDi�
*îï , ���G6ê�¾Ù� , 4-2
(1999) 22.
[43] PQñ, 1ÜO5, RS3, �CDi
Õ�*³�ª±, *, 54-615 (1979)
11.
[44] T¼�- , ·~Õ�CDi�\U , * ,
75-878 (2000) 14.
[45] F½5ã%, ·~Õ�CDi�Ó�ØÐÑ
Åߤ¥�Â�$Kelf¹'W��EÙ
�ê�Õ7g, =�h��uP�eBòg,
69-677 (2003) 94.
[46] VF|, M/W3, ¶³bÊ=WX �
Rd�ª�7¯K, =�h��uP�
(Bò), 45-389 (1979) 118.
[47] YZÃ[ã%, Q�Rï(wrn� �
¼ÐÑelf¹�,u´fgg, �EI
JKHuP�, 34-1 (1997) 299.
[48] ¶Ü\]ã%, Q�Rï(wrn� �
¼ÐÑel 2¹�Ó�´fgg, �EI
JKHuP�, 34-1 (1997) 301.
[49] Mori, Y. and Nakayama, W., Recent Advances in
Compact Heat Exchangers in Japan, ASME HTD,
10 (1980) 5.
[50] VF|, �B¦ �$K;2K8MN�,
�, 42-174 (2003) 31.
[51] ^Ü!, ·~Õ�CDi�¼ÐÑ;V.
IJ$K, =�h����ðÅ�
F, 07-5 (2007).
[52] def, ¼ÐÑRd� M���
êN�IJ$KÈ��§ , �, 47-200 (2008)
53.
[53] Nakayama, W., Daikoku, T., and Nakajima, T.,
Effects of Pore Diameters and System Pressure on
Nucleate Boiling Heat Transfer from Porous
Surfaces, ASME Journal of Heat Transfer, 104-2
(1982) 286.
[54] Nakayama, W., Takahashi, K., Senshu, T., and
Yoshida, H., Heat Transfer Analysis of
Shell-and-Tube Condensers with Shell-Side
Enhancement, Trans. ASHRAE, 90-1 (1984) 60.
[55] Gaugler, R., Heat Transfer Devices, US Patent
2350348 (1944).
[56] Grover, G. M., Cotter, T. P., and Erickson, G. F.,
Structures of Very High Thermal Conductance,
Journal of Applied Physics, 35-6 (1964) 1990.
[57] =���F, 11-4 (1996) 96.
[58] Nakayama, W., Recent Japanese Thermal
Solutions for Portable Computers, Electronics
Cooling, 4-3 (1998) 14.
[59] Nakayama, W., Japanese Supercomputers in
Thermal Perspective, Chapter 4 of HIGH
PERFORMANCE COMPUTING IN JAPAN, ed.
Mendez, R., John Wiley & Sons Ltd. (1992) 55.
[60] Nakayama, W., Heat Transfer Engineering in
Systems Integration: Outlook for Closer Coupling
of Thermal and Electrical Designs of Computers,
IEEE Trans. Components, Packaging, and
Manufacturing Technology 3 Part A, 18-4 (1995)
818.
[61] Oktay, S., Hannemann, R., and Bar-Cohen, A.,
High Heat from A Small Package, ASME
Mechanical Engineering, 108-3 (1986 )36.
[62] =¨}, 5�µ (2002) 75.
[63] Jie W., Challenges in Cooling Design of CPU
Packages for High-Performance Servers, Heat
Transfer Engineering, 29-2 (2008) 178.
[64] def, �IJ�°_õ�+еb¦.
+Ð;Ù-.IJ, �, 48-205 (2009) 1.
[65] Kogge, P., The Tops in Flops, IEEE Spectrum,
48-2 (2011) 44.
[66] Kandlikar, S. and Grande W. J., Evolution of
Microchannel Flow Passages – Thermohydraulic
Performance and Fabrication Technology, Heat
Transfer Engineering, 24-1 (2003) 3.
[67] Tuckerman, D. B. and Pease, R. F. W.,
High-Performance Heat Sink for VLSI, IEEE
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 50 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
Electron Device Letters, 2 (1981) 126.
[68] ���Ë}�ýb�ê¶�l��ª,
=�h�����±Ù�F�½� ,
THERMAL ENGINEERING No.27.
[69] Marek, J., Top 30 MEMS companies: The big get
bigger, MEMS’ Trends, April, Issue 6 (2011).
[70] ���Ë}�h©½� , � , 47-201
(2008).
[71] Jain, A. and Goodson, K. E., Themral
Microdevices for Biological and Biomedical
Applications, Journal of Thermal Biology, 36
(2011) 209.
[72] d&`a, �����, �, 47-198
(2008) 40.
[73] Editorial: Special Issue on Multiscale Modeling
and Analysis in Computational Biology and
Medicine – Part 1, IEEE Trans. Biomedical
Engineering, 58-10 (2011) 2936.
[74] À¼H, ¨þêJû�h½�$K, µ
&, 24 (2005) 603.
[75] �ÁÚÛ, FÜÝç, ò�bà, Ký±³Á
ZÆ�2&Rd�ª�Þ,ì;d1�,
=�h��uP�, 41-347 (1975) 2141.
[76] Nakayama, W., Daikoku, T., Kuwahara, H., and
Nakajima, T., Dynamic Model of Enhanced
Boiling Heat Transfer on Porous Surfaces, Part – I:
Experimental Investigation, ASME Journal of Heat
Transfer, 102-3 (1980) 445.
[77] Carlson, D. M., Sullivan, D. C., Bach, R. E., and
Resnick, D. R., The ETA-10
Liquid-Nitrogen-Cooled Supercomputer System,
IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, 36-8 (1989) 1404.
[78] Nakayama, W., Nakajima, T., and Hirasawa, S.,
Heat Sink Studs Having Enhanced Boiling
Surfaces for Cooling Microelectronic Components,
ASME Paper No. 84-WA/HT-89 (1984).
[79] Honda, H., Takamatsu, H. and Wei, J. J.,
Enhanced Boiling of FC-72 on Silicon Chips With
Micro-Pin-Fins and Submicron-Scale Roughness,
ASME Journal of Heat Transfer, 124 (2002) 383.
[80] Peng, X. P. and Wang, B. -X., Forced Convection
and Flow Boiling Heat Transfer for Liquid
Flowing Through Microchannels, Int. Journal of
Heat and Mass Transfer, 36-14 (1993) 3421.
[81] Mizunuma, H., Behnia, M. and Nakayama, W.,
Heat Transfer from Micro-Finned Surfaces to Flow
of Flurinert Coolant in Reduced-Size Channels,
IEEE Trans. Components, Packaging, and
Manufacturing Technology – Part A, 20-2 (1997)
138.
[82] Asai, A., Bubble Dynamics in Boiling Under
High Heat Flux Pulse Heating, ASME Journal of
Heat Transfer, 113 (1991) 973.
[83] cû�, MEMS�³Õ12Rdh�
r, �, 48-202 (2009) 8.
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 51 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�������
21 ��������� 10 ���������
� !"#$% &'�()*+,-./012
3�456�78�9��:;?%0@A
�BC�DEFG6HIJK�GLMNOP�Q
RSTUV4W�X�1Y=Z#[\6]E�^
_`Sabc�de��fg-78�./hij
klmnopm6q�r�5W�
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 52 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������������������� �!
�"#$���%&'()�*�+,-./��
0-���1-���������23 2145
�����6�73����89�3:�
;-?@��AB7�CD�
��EFGH89IJ�=�KL��M����
�NOL,
�
���� ������������
� P��������7+QR��2�S�;-
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 53 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������ Differentiator����������
�������������“��� ���
������”�!��"#��
�$Differentiator��%&��'(Type-D
)'(�����*+�� ,�“��!$�-
��./01��$'(�2�3,�“�$45�
�-����”��,6#"7� ��01!�
����8+93,�:; !"�3�#$?��4@4@ABCDEFG$%���H
&'9�7�+� �
()�*+I,��-$J��K@"7LMN
"��4��MN��� Enabler ��OMN�
������������P$�QR,'(
Type-E)'(����./01��ST�-5�
��6#!$�-��UI01$./0V
�W'(�2�3,�
1���9+$:$�Q$>?STXY;Z
[\��2D3]45^6STE_`a�7�
b�� 8c�d9:Z[�Q)!$�beR
,#;;OBaseP'( Type-B'(����Qk?R,l��gh#;;'("
���
1�'9�7�+� '(�m��J@�Z[
�:no]Aom�p4�STXY;Z[�
QOABCDEFGP��'(�qB1$CD�
Σr�EF�8� Σ-)noNs'(����
��GH;�1�7 Type-D)ij Type-E)$
�$©�
�8�r[4]m�> 23 � 8 ��+��
94¥ 4ª01��#«Iec$y;���
z�4�¥ 4 ª01��#«Ie[5]�w �7�
01��{U�ABCDEFG{U./�m�
9=��'(v>{U$¬���� ��
${U�7�«� 3��%m4®¯«°±²
�³´H�+$¯«$p%��84l�
�W$ST;n$����84ABCD
EFG{U!e@94�
@�
-
����� 50����
�� 2012� 1� - 54 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
������������������� !�
������"#!$%!&'()�*+!,-
./012)34[6]
1456-789:;��!�������!<
'=>!$?
24@ABC!3D!�EFGHIJKLM
N�OP��QRS@A!BC!3D:TR!
UVIJW��*QRSXY:Z3O��EF
GHIJK!LMOS[\���=4�:]^
��_(`��N���_(!LMOS[\�
��=4
Z3*N�OP��QRS@Aab:cde
�3D!.#�f=4@ABC!3D!�EFG
HIJKLMgh3D:�i!jhSklm
nOop=4
[>:*q\>r��`stu!3D!.#
()�fOop=4vwx�yz
q\>!�������{|}~L"#!
�*N�!3D!�(`stu�t
(e��*�:��!'(!
:3l*7�(�jh4
:*���!N�a!':�
�D�l�(*T!��
:�¡);;¢*£7¤¥¦N�§¨©ª«!
�u¬h®�¯�q(D�°±e
�4²e�(*���³´µGe�°±
��()�¶·[¸�q(!¹pºw»:*£7
¤¥¦N�§¨©ª«�ue� 21 ¼½!¾
¿ ÀÁ ÂÃÄÅÆÇÃÈ Ér��
®�[7]()�ÊËÌÍ�*t(FG(N�Î
Ïe�Ð:�(��4
������
� 6-���!�� 50 ��Ñ:*20 ¼½!
6-(¼{!ÒÓÔÕSÅÆÇÃÈ :ÎÏ)*
:!Ö¬h×�Ø{!ÙÚ�`s
t)*Û2)�Ü3��!Ý�ÞÜßàá
°±)3�4
:*��!FG_���_|}t_
�*21 ¼½!6-!ÒÓÔÕSâ·:ãÍ3
t�FG�ÅÆÇÃÈ �2!äÊåæç¶(
�hN�aOèR¹éS���q(*[>
:!!ê)[!b°(ë3S�ìí(îï
OðD>\���
� “ñò�q! 10�*ó(îï��ô”!ìí
Ò�*6-���!ë3S� 10 �!ßà
õqh¯�lZ¸ö=4
�
�����
[1] 6-����*��_÷øùúª(û!ü
®ýþ�*��û!ü®�N�!3D!�
�:ãÍ��*v2007�z
[2] ����*ÒÓaÅÆÇÃÈ �2ÕÉ
:j�6-ë:ãÍ�*Beyond Innovation
�ÅÆÇÃÈ !�����*�Á
��ÀN*� 2�*p29*v2009z
[3] 6-����®�ýþ���*£7¤¥
¦N�§¨©ª«!�uÉ�����
��ÄÅÆÇÃÈ �2É:ãÍ�*
2011� 8�
[4] ���������������`sýþ�*
û±,�N�(��e�`s!tu(��!
�¶:ãÍ�*�u 21� 8�v2009z.
[5] ������,-��*�u 23� 8� �
C!v2011z
[6] ���������������C!*56
-789"Z�3� !�������"#
!$%!&'*�u 23� 5� 316
[7] ����*£7¤¥¦N�§¨©ª«!�
uÉ#��þ¿ ÀÁ ÂÃÄÅÆÇÃ
È !�uÉ�*��!�ã*2010�� 12*
p40
-
�������
�� 2012� 1� - 55 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
�
�
��������
�
��������
����������������� �!
"#�$%&'()*+,-./012345$
6&789�20:;$�?@ 1ABC
DEFG([1]HGI�#J'KL@MN$OPQ
BR,(STU,"#�?V'WXYFG(HZ
D7�[\?'27]@:
-
�������
�� 2012� 1� - 56 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
1911 �������������������
������ !"#$��%&�����'
()*������'()��+�,-."
-/�0��' 1�#�2�3'45�/6�
�78'9,:��';�'
-
�������
�� 2012� 1� - 57 - J. HTSJ, Vol. 51, No. 214
¥' ^©'$B8 Ns¥')&¤{�J'
�# |�¦6G�