1. Heirs of Bertuldo Hinog vs. Melicor, 455 SCRA 460 (2005)2. People vs. Cawaling, 293 SCRA 267 (1998)3. Magpale vs. CSC, 215 SCRA 398 (1992)4. Sandoval vs. Caneba, 190 SCRA 77 (1991)5. Lumbuan vs. Ronqullo, G.R. No. 155713, May 5, 20066. Sun Insurance Office, Ltd. vs. Asuncion, 170 SCRA 274 (1989)

7. Joseph vs. Bautista, 170 SCRA 540 (1989)8. Del Rosario vs Far East Bank and Trust Co., G.R. No. 150134, Oct 31, 20079. Progressive Development Corp. vs. CA, 301 SCRA 367 (1999)10. CGR Corporation vs. Treyes, Jr., G.R. No. 170916, April 27, 200711. Enriquez vs. Ramos, 7 SCRA 265 (1963)12. Flores vs. Mallare-Phillipps, 144 SCRA 277 (1986)

13. Evangelista vs. Santiago, 475 SCRA 744 (2005)14. Domingo vs. Carague, 456 SCRA 450 (2005)15. Oposa vs. Factoran, 224 SCRA 792 (1993)16. Domingo vs. Scheer, 421 SCRA 468 (2004)17. Uy vs. CA, 494 SCRA 535 (2006)18. Laperal Devt. Corp. vs. CA, 223 SCRA 261 (1993)19. Mathay vs. Consolidated Bank, 58 SCRA 559 (1974)20. Heirs of Bertuldo Hinog vs. Melicor, 455 SCRA 460 (2005)21. De la Cruz vs. Joaquin, 464 SCRA 576 (2005)

22. Diaz vs. Adiong, 219 SCRA 631 (1993)23. Phil. Banking Corp. vs. Tensuan, 228 SCRA 385 (1993)24. Dacoycoy vs. IAC, 195 SCRA 641 (1993)25. Mathay vs. Consolidated Bank, 58 SCRA 559 (1974)26. PHILAMGEN vs. Sweet Lines, 212 SCRA 194 (1993)27. Korea Exchange Bank vs. Gonzales, 456 SCRA 224 (2005)28. BA Finance Corp. vs. Co, 224 SCRA 163 (1993)29. Ao-As vs. CA, 491 SCRA 353 (2006)30. PAL vs. Flight Attendants and Stewards Assn of the Phils., 479 SCRA 605 (2006)31. Barfel Devt. Corp. vs. CA, 223 SCRA 268 (1993)32. Swagman Hotels & Travel, Inc. vs. CA, G.R. No. 161135, April 8, 200533. Shoemart, Inc. vs. CA, 190 SCRA 189 (1990)34. Virata vs. Sandiganbayan, 221 SCRA 52 (1993)35. Tan vs. Sandiganbayan, 180 SCRA 34 (1989)36. Saw vs. CA, 195 SCRA 740 (1991)37. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. vs. Presiding Judge, 182 SCRA 820 (1990)

38. E.B Villarosa vs. Benito 312 SCRA 65 (1999)39. Northwest Orient Airlines vs. CA 241 SCRA 192 (1995)40. Robinson vs. Miralles GR No. 16358441. Valmonte vs. CA 252 SCRA 92 (1996)42. Perkin Elmer Singapore vs. Dakila Trading GR No. 17224243. De los Santos vs. Montesa 221 SCRA 15 (1993)44. Orion Security vs. Kalfam Enterprises GR No. 16328745. Lanto vs. Dimaporo 16 SCRA 59946. Vlason Enterprises vs. CA 330 SCRA 26

47. Boticano vs. Chu 148 SCRA 54148. Del Rosario vs. FEBTC GR 150134 537 SCRA 57149. Halimao vs. Villanueva 253 SCRA 150. Tan vs. CA 295 SCRA 24751. Asia Production Co. Inc. vs. Pano 205 SCRA 45852. Sunville Timber Products Inc. vs. Abad 206 SCRA 48253. Municipality of Biñan vs. CA 219 SCRA 6954. NPC vs. CA 185 SCRA 169

Rule 1755. OB Jovenir Construction vs. Macamir Realty GR 13580356. Cruz vs. CA GR 16479757. Pinga vs. Santiago GR 17035458. Perkin Elmer Singapore vs. Dakila Trading GR 172242 (repeat case)59. Ko vs. PNB 419 SCRA 298 2006

*include Rule 9 Section 360. Gajudo vs. Traders GR 15109861. Vlason Enterprises vs. CA 330 SCRA 26 1999 (repeat case)62. Ramnani vs. CA 221 SCRA 582 (1993)63. Martinez vs. Republic GR 16089564. Jao vs. CA 251 SCRA 391 (1995)65. Indiana Aerospace Inuversity vs. CHED 356 SCRA 367 (2001)

Rule 1866. LCK vs. Planters 170 SCRA 606 (2007)67. AM 03-1-09-SC68. Calalang 217 SCRA 41669. Citibank 220 SCRA 75

Rules 21-29 (Modes of Discovery)70. People vs. Webb 312 SCRA 57371. Dasmariñas Garments vs. Reyes 225 SCRA 62272. Republic vs. Sandiganbayan 204 SCRA 21273. Po vs. CA 164 SCRA 66874. AM No. 03-1-09-SC75. Hyatt Industrial vs. Ley Construction GR No. 147143

Rules 30-3476. Republic vs. Tuvera GR 14824677. Manila Banking Corporation vs. University of Baguio GR 15918978. Meneses vs. Secretary of Agrarian Reform GR 156304 Oct 23 200679. Diman vs. Alumbres 299 SCRA 459 (1989) GR 131466

Rule 3580. Ontimare vs. Elep GR 159224 Jan 20 200681. Asian Construction and Development Corp. vs. PCIB GR 153827 April 25 2006

Rule 36-3782. BA Finance vs. CA 229S566

83. Eternal Gardens vs. IAC 165S43984. Nunal vs. CA 221S26

85. Industrial Timber vs. NLRC 233S59786. Esquivel vs. Alegre 172S31587. Cardoza vs. Singson 181S4588. Del Rosario vs. Far East Bank GR 15013489. Griffith vs. Estur GR 16177790. Marina Properties vs. CA 294S27391. Provost vs. CA GR 16040692. Encarnacion vs. Amigo GR 16979393. Manila Memorial Park vs. CA 344S76994. Neypes vs. CA 469S63395. TransInternational vs. CA 285S4996. Kho vs. Camacho 204S15097. Custodio vs. CA 253S48398. Citytrust vs. CA 196S55399. Ross Rica Sales vs. Ong GR 132197100. Macawiwili Gold Mining vs. CA 297S602101. Ditching vs. CA 263S343102. Fabian vs. Desierto 295S440103. Garcia-R ueda vs. Pascasio 278S269104. St. Martin vs. NLRC 295S494105. Santos vs. Go 473S350106. Fortich vs. Corona 289S624107. Lapid vs. CA 334S738108. Swagman case

Rule 38109. Escueta vs Lim GR 137162, Jan 24 2007110. Alvendia vs IAC 181 SCRA 252

Skip Rule 39 first

Rules 41-44

Rule 45111. Nunez vs GSIS 47 SCRA 305112. China Road vs CA 348 SCRA 401

Rule 46 provisions

Rule 47113. People vs Bitanga GR 159222, June 26 2007114. Fraginal vs Heirs of Parangal GR 150207, Feb 22 2007115. Grande vs UP GR 148456, Sept 15 2006116. Cosmic Lumber vs CA 265 SCRA 166 (1996)117. Marcelino vs CA 210 SCRA 444 (1992)118. Islamic Da’wah vs CA 178 SCRA 178

Rules 48-55 provisions

Rule 65119. Jamer vs NLRC 278 SCRA 632120. Day vs RTC of Zamboanga 191 SCRA 610121. Romy’s Freight Service vs Castro 490 SCRA 165

122. Gerardo vs Dela Pena 192 SCRA 691123. Banco Filipino Savings vs CA 334 SCRA 305124. Fajardo vs Bautista 232 SCRA 292125. Jaca vs Davao Lumber Co. 113 SCRA 107126. Tan vs CA 275 SCRA 568

Rule 39127. OCA vs. Corpuz 412 SCRA 1 (2003)128. Balajonda vs. COMELEC GR 166032 28 Feb 2005129. Jalandoni vs. PNB 108 SCRA 102 (1981)130. Fiestan vs. CA 185 S 751 (1990)131. Dagooc vs. Erlina AM P-04-1851 March 16, 2005132. Campillo vs. CA 129 S 513 (1984)133. Manila Remnant vs. CA 231 S 281 (1994)134. Malonzo vs. Mariano 170 S 667 (1989)135. Del Rosario vs. FEBTC GR 150134 31 October 2007

Rule 57136. Davao Light and Power Co. vs. CA 204 S 340137. Olib vs. Pastoral 188 S 692 (1990)138. Valmonte vs CA 252 S 92 (1994)139. Traders Royal Bank vs. IAC 133 S 141 (1984)140. Pacis vs. COMELEC 29 S 24 (1969)

Rule 58141. Hernandez vs. NAPOCOR 145 S 328 23 March 2006142. Sabalones vs. CA 239 S 79 (1994)143. Ulang vs. CA 225 S 637 (1993)144. Decano vs. Edu 99 S 410 (1981)145. Versoza vs. CA 299 S 100 (1998)146. Tay Chun Suy vs. CA 229 S 151 (1994)147. Federation of Land Reform Farmers of the Phils vs. CA 246 S 175 (1995)

Rule 59148. Normandy vs. Duque 29 S 385 (1969)

Rule 60149. BA Finance vs. CA 258 S 102 (1996)150. Chiao Ling Tan vs. CA 228 S 75 (1993)151. Northern Motors vs. Herrera 49 S 392