8/13/2019 Cir v. Suter (g.r. L-25532)

1/2

!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!># !$$# "0+.#**#?

!"#" %&'(()' *+,-./-0 '12 3454

67# 8+-9.9 :;

>?6@!#A;BCD

! STVP!5 "$K$&:; B#F&%:F(A$B I#( 'CFK:; #%; &A:$FHCFF:(BC%;$%W HC%&F$DJ&$C%( #F: #( 'C""CI( [&A$( I#( /1+

F:W$(&:F:;\)

o /J&:F !AB MRNRRR>RR!^:%:F#" B#F&%:Fo =J"$# /B$F$W !AB SQNRRR>RR!6$K$&:; B#F&%:Fo ^J(G +#F"(C% !AB MNRRR>RR!6$K$&:; B#F&%:F

! 4A: '$FK :%W#W:; $% &A: $KBCF&$C%N K#F_:&$%WN ;$(&F$DJ&$C%#%; CB:F#&$C% C' #J&CK#&$H BAC%CWF#BA(N F#;$C(N &:":G$($C% (:&(

#%; #KJ(:K:%& K#HA$%:(N &A:$F B#F&( #%; #HH:((CF$:(>

! 4A: "$K$&:; B#F&%:F(A$B A#; D::% '$"$%W $&( $%HCK: L F:&JF%( #(# HCFBCF#&$C%>

! STVQ ! /J&:F #%; /B$F$W WC& K#FF$:; #%; &A:F:#'&:FN +#F"(C%(C"; A$( (A#F: &C &A:K> 4A: (#": I#( F:HCF;:; $% /1+>

! STUT!+.2 ;:H"#F:; # ;:'$H$:%HE $%HCK: L #W#$%(& F:(BC%;:%&/J&:F $% &A: #KCJ%& C' !MN OPQ>RO 'CF STUV #%; !VN UOP>RR 'CF

STUU>

! /J&:F BFC&:(&:; DJ& +.2 ;:%$:; &A: (#K: (C &A: 'CFK:F#BB:#":; &C +CJF& C' 4#L 5BB:#"( IA$HA F:G:F(:; &A: ;:H$($C% C'

&A: "#&&:F>

7::;=: = #=:A%E=CD

S> .((J: S) RR DE RR DE =J"$# /B$F$W #%;

%:$&A:F C%: C' &A:K I#( #% $%;J(&F$#" B#F&%:F

! 4A: HCFBCF#&: B:F(C%#"$&E C' &A: B#F&%:F(A$B (ACJ"; %C& D:;$(F:W#F;:; %:$&A:F $& $( ;$((C"G:; DE CB:F#&$C% C' "#I D:H#J(: $&

I#( %C& # B#F&%:F(A$B &A#& (BCJ(:( I:F: 'CFD$;;:% &C :%&:F DE

5F&$H": SOPP C' &A: +$G$" +C;: C' SQQT>

-#]CF !C$%& M) 4A: ;$'':F:%H: $% L F#&:( D:&I::% &A: $%HCK: C' &A:

"$K$&:; B#F&%:F(A$B D:$%W HC%(C"$;#&:; I$&AN #%; IA:% (B"$& 'FCK &A:

$%HCK: C' &A: (BCJ(:(N $( %C& # ]J(&$'$H#&$C% 'CF F:YJ$F$%W HC%(C"$;#&$C%

+.2 $( %C& #J&ACF$a:; #%; :G:% D#FF:; &C F:YJ$F: &A: "$K$&:;B#F&%:F(A$B &C B#E L C% $&( CI% $%HCK:>

8/13/2019 Cir v. Suter (g.r. L-25532)

2/2

!"#$%&' )!*+$#*,-.) !$/ +*0,+, /."#,+, 12345 6 23478 !++&9 :;!># !$$# "0+.#**#?

7::;= ' 0C

-#]CF !C$%& S C' .((J: M) !#F&%:F(A$B A#( # ]JF$;$H#" B:F(C%#"$&E C' $&(

CI%N ;$(&$%H& #%; (:B#F#&: 'FCK &A#& C' $&( B#F&%:F(

! -#FF$#W: C' B#F&%:F( $( %C& %KCJ%& &C HC%G:F($C% &C ($%W":BFCBF$:&CF(A$B

o +C%&F$DJ&$C%( F:K#$%:; &A:$F F:(B:H&$G: (:B#F#&:BFCB:F&E J%;:F &A: /B#%$(A +$G$" +C;: [5F&$H": SbTO\

*7B?% E=#C76