8/13/2019 Dalion v. CA (G.R. No. 78903)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dalion-v-ca-gr-no-78903 1/2

!"#$! &'($!)! *+,-. / +,-01 "))23 4"2 5"6#6 !"7)'"(6

4"89$##$ "77$ (:)'$44$;

!"#" %&" '()*+ ,-./01/2 3(4 5))*

6789:% ;" <7

!"#$%&$''() +,-.(/( +012345 467853 634 0!896386 +6:0+6;0<467853

4/'/%=#%&) >?0 ?535@6:70 A52@> 59 6!!067+ 634 @2!0@>5

+6:0+6;0B ;@C

!-%/%&/) D/=$#"=/#B !"

A6+0) +#E/(#F/ (./= &- G/H-I/G -J%/G(K$, -' "#%= &K#& J#( (-"= &- K$L

EM 4#"$-%C 4#"$-% =/%$/( &K/ (#"/B #%= H"#$L( &K#& +#E/(#F/ $( -%"M

,G//L,&$%N 4#"$-%O( &KG/#& &- (./ '-G .%,#$= H-LL$(($-% -% (#"/( -'

H-,G# #%= #E#H# &K#& ,/&$&$-%/G (,-.(/( /#G%/= JK/% &K/M J/G/

#=L$%$(&/G$%N P ,#GH/"( -' "#%= '-G 7/-%#G=- +#E/(#F/C

>K/ +.,G/L/ A-.G& G."/= &K#& &K/ #.&K/%&$H$&M -' &K/ (#"/ K#( E//%

,G-I/= #HH-G=$%N"M ($%H/ J$&%/((/( ,-($&$I/"M &/(&$'$/= &- &K/

#.&K/%&$H$&M -' &K/ (#"/B #%= &K/ ($N%#&.G/ &K/G/-% J#( ,G-I/= &- E/

#.&K/%&$HC >K/ A-.G& #"(- G."/= &K#& /Q/H.&$-% -' &K/ (#"/ $% # ,.E"$H

=-H.L/%& $( %-& # '#&#" =/'/H& #( # H-%&G#H& -' (#"/ $( H-%(/%(.#"C

45A>@830) >K#& # =//= -' (#"/ $( /Q/H.&/= -% # ,.E"$H $%(&G.L/%& $( -%"M

'-G H-%I/%$/%H/ #%= %-& '-G I#"$=$&M -G /%'-GH/#E$"$&MB E/H#.(/ #

H-%&G#H& -' (#"/ $( H-%(/%(.#" #%= ,/G'/H&/= EM L/G/ H-%(/%&C

=7<>!#:?%6@

•  D#M RSB TUVW! +#E/(#F/ (./= &- G/H-I/G -J%/G(K$, -' # ,#GH/"

-' "#%=B E#(/= -% # ,G$I#&/ =-H.L/%& -' #E(-".&/ (#"/B =#&/=

;."M TB TUXP Y0QK$E$& Z6Z[B #""/N/="M /Q/H.&/= EM 4#"$-%C

o  4#"$-% =/%$/= &K/ (#"/B H-%&/%=$%N &K#& &K/ =-H.L/%&

(./= .,-% $( '$H&$&$-.(B K$( ($N%#&.G/ &K/G/-%B # '-GN/GMB

#%= &K#& &K/ "#%= $( H-%F.N#" ,G-,/G&M #( /I$=/%H/= EM

Z0(HG$&.G# =/ \/%&# 6E(-".&#Z Y0QK$E$& Z:Z[C

•  4#"$-% #%= K$( J$'/ #"(- =/%$/= &K#& &K/M ,"/#=/= J$&K +#E/(#F/

&- #""-J &K/L &- #=L$%$(&/G &K/ "#%= E/H#.(/ 4#"$-% =$= %-&

K#I/ #%M L/#%( -' "$I/"$K--=C

o  ?5]0\0@B &K/ (,-.(/( #=L$&&/= &- #=L$%$(&/G$%N P

,#GH/"( -' "#%=(-' +#E/(#F/O( NG#%='#&K/GB 7/-%#G=-

($%H/ TUPSC >K/M %/I/G G/H/$I/= &K/$G #NG//= T^_ #%=TP_ H-LL$(($-% -% &K/ (#"/( -' H-,G# #%= #E#H#C

o  !/&$&$-%/G( H"#$L &K#& +#E/(#F/O( (.$& J#( $%&/%=/= &-

K#G#((B ,G//L,& #%= '-G/(&#"" 4#"$-%`( &KG/#& &- (./ '-G

&K/(/ .%,#$= H-LL$(($-%(C

9AA?BA C: =B #BA:8DB6@

TC  ]K/&K/G -G %-& &K/G/ J#( # I#"$= H-%&G#H& -' (#"/ -' &K/ "#%=C

RC  ]K/&K/G -G %-& # ,.E"$H =-H.L/%& J#( %/H/((#GM '-G &K/

&G#%('/G -' -J%/G(K$, &K/G/&-C

#BA:8?C9:%A 7%6 7#!?EB%CA

9AA?B 5 ]K/&K/G -G %-& &K/G/ J#( # I#"$= H-%&G#H& -' (#"/ -' &K/ "#%=

! a0+C

D#F-G !-$%& T) >K/ #.&K/%&$H$&M -' &K/ =//= -' (#"/ K#( E//% ,G-I/= $%

#HH-G=#%H/ J$&K A-F" 35 G 3+4 #0H- 5+3 &I JK- #-;LM-N #0H-M &I <&0/J5 

-  !$83 +-3 5<=>?@A B<=@=CDE =@F AGAHI@=JC ?CK ?I@LAC@=H=@ME LJB N<J>AK3OPAQJ<A ?CM

N<=>?@A B<=@=CD R?M SA <AHA=>AK =C A>=KACHAE =@F KIA AGAHI@=JC ?CK ?I@LAC@=H=@M RIF@

SA N<J>AK A=@LA<T*?1 PM ?CMJCA BLJ F?B @LA B<=@=CD AGAHI@AKUU

*S1 PM A>=KACHA JQ @LA DACI=CACAFF JQ @LA L?CKB<=@=CD JQ @LA R?VA<UU J<

*H1 PM ? FISFH<=S=CD B=@CAFF

GGG GGG GGG

!$83 +.3 9?CKB<=@=CDE LJB N<J>AK3 W )LA L?CKB<=@=CD JQ ? NA<FJC R?M SA N<J>AK

SM ?CM B=@CAFF BLJ SAX=A>AF =@ @J SA @LA L?CKB<=@=CD JQ FIHL NA<FJCE ?CK L?F FAAC

@LA NA<FJC B<=@AE J< L?F FAAC B<=@=CD NI<NJ<@=CD @J SA L=F INJC BL=HL @LA B=@CAFF

L?F ?H@AK J< SAAC HL?<DAKE ?CK L?F @LIF ?HYI=<AK VCJBXAKDA JQ @LA L?CKB<=@=CD JQ

FIHL NA<FJC3 $>=KACHA <AFNAH@=CD @LA L?CKB<=@=CD R?M ?XFJ SA D=>AC SM ?

HJRN?<=FJCE R?KA SM @LA B=@CAFF J< @LA HJI<@E B=@L B<=@=CDF ?KR=@@AK J< @<A?@AK ?F

8/13/2019 Dalion v. CA (G.R. No. 78903)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dalion-v-ca-gr-no-78903 2/2

!"#$! &'($!)! *+,-. / +,-01 "))23 4"2 5"6#6 !"7)'"(6

4"89$##$ "77$ (:)'$44$;

•  1/G#G=- DC 5N(-H ,-($&$I/"M &/(&$'$/= &- &K/ #.&K/%&$H$&M -' &K/

(#"/B #%= (#$= &K#& K/ K#= ,G/,#G/= (#$= =//= -' (#"/ #%= K#=

H-,$/= ,#G&( &K/G/-' 'G-L &K/ Z0(HG$&.G# 4/ \/%&# 6E(-".&#Z

Y0QK$E$& :[ (.HK #( &K/ E-.%=#G$/( &K/G/-' #%= &K/ %#L/ -'

#,,/""#%& +/N.%=- 4#"$-%`( J$'/C

•  9.G&K/G H-L,#G$(-% -' &K/ b./(&$-%/= ($N%#&.G/( #%= &K/(,/H$L/%( J$&K &K/ ($N%#&.G/( -' 4#"$-% G/#=$"M G/I/#" &K#& &K/

b./(&$-%/= ($N%#&.G/( #G/ &K/ ($N%#&.G/( -' 4#"$-%C

9AA?B 3 ]K/&K/G -G %-& # ,.E"$H =-H.L/%& J#( %/H/((#GM '-G &K/

&G#%('/G -' -J%/G(K$, &K/G/&-C! 35C >K/ ,G-I$($-% -' 7/J" 5+O( -% &K/

%/H/(($&M -' # ,.E"$H =-H.L/%& $( -%"M '-G H-%I/%$/%H/B %-& '-G I#"$=$&M

-G /%'-GH/#E$"$&MC

D#F-G !-$%& T) 8& $( %-& # G/b.$G/L/%& '-G &K/ I#"$=$&M -' # H-%&G#H& -'

(#"/ -' # ,#GH/" -' "#%= &K#& &K$( E/ /LE-=$/= $% # ,.E"$H $%(&G.L/%&C•  6 H-%&G#H& -' (#"/ $( # H-%(/%(.#" H-%&G#H&B JK$HK L/#%( &K#&

&K/ (#"/ $( ,/G'/H&/= EM L/G/ H-%(/%&C 3- ,#G&$H."#G '-GL $(

G/b.$G/= '-G $&( I#"$=$&MC 2,-% ,/G'/H&$-% -' &K/ H-%&G#H&B &K/

,#G&$/( L#M G/H$,G-H#""M =/L#%= ,/G'-GL#%H/ Y7/J" 5P'O4 %<<[B

$C/CB &K/ I/%=// L#M H-L,/" &G#%('/G -' -J%/G(K$, -' &K/ -EF/H&

-' &K/ (#"/B #%= &K/ I/%=-G L#M G/b.$G/ &K/ I/%=// &- ,#M &K/

&K$%N (-"= Y7/J" 5PO(4 %<<[C

,9%78 DB#69<C@ >K/ &G$#" H-.G& &K.( G$NK&"M #%= "/N#""M -G=/G/= 4#"$-% &-

=/"$I/G &- +#E/(#F/ &K/ ,#GH/" -' "#%= #%= &- /Q/H.&/ H-GG/(,-%=$%N

'-GL#" =//= -' H-%I/M#%H/ $% # ,.E"$H =-H.L/%&C

%: ABQ7#7CB :Q9%9:%A

DACI=CA SM @LA N?<@M ?D?=CF@ BLJR @LA A>=KACHA =F JQQA<AKE J< N<J>AK @J SA DACI=CA

@J @LA F?@=FQ?H@=JC JQ @LA ZIKDA3 *4IXA -.+E 4A>=FAK 4IXAF JQ 8JI<@1