data source: scival spotlight map 2010, sciverse scopus – 15 th november 2011 działalność...
TRANSCRIPT
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Działalność naukowa UMK(na tle innych uniwersytetów)
Andrzej Tretyn, UMKPiotr Gołkiewicz, Elsevier B.V.
Jorg Hellwig, Elsevier B.V.
29.11.2011
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Działalność publikacyjna pracowników UMK
Sub title
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Publication output 2006-2010
• Publication output stable over 6 years• International co-authorship slightly
increasing over time
International Co-authorship defined in this case as articles
published with an author from one of the most prolific 11
countries worldwide, according to the Royal Society Report:
http://royalsociety.org/policy/projects/knowledge-networks-nations/report/
Countries are: United States, China, United Kingdom,
Germany, Japan, France, Spain, Italy, Canada, India, Russia,
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Metodologia
Richard Klavansa & Kevin W. Boyack
SciTech Strategies, Inc., Berwyn, PA 19312 USA
Sub title
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Methodology: how we defined “strengths”
Definition ③:” State-of-the-Art” Leadership
• State-of-the-Art (SOA) helps to measure thought leadership by indicating the “recentness” of articles cited by the institution’s articles within each research area
Definition ③:” State-of-the-Art” Leadership
• State-of-the-Art (SOA) helps to measure thought leadership by indicating the “recentness” of articles cited by the institution’s articles within each research area
Defined as “Competency” if researchers from NCU are
#1 or #2 in either of the three definitions in the research area
Defined as “Competency” if researchers from NCU are
#1 or #2 in either of the three definitions in the research area
Definition ①:” Publication” Leadership
• “Share” of number of publications by researchers from NCU is relatively high compared to other universities publishing papers in the same research area
Definition ①:” Publication” Leadership
• “Share” of number of publications by researchers from NCU is relatively high compared to other universities publishing papers in the same research area
Definition ②:” Reference” Leadership
• “Share” of citations gained by papers published by researchers from NCU is relatively high compared to other universities publishing papers in the same research area
Definition ②:” Reference” Leadership
• “Share” of citations gained by papers published by researchers from NCU is relatively high compared to other universities publishing papers in the same research area
5
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Research Strength and Focus Areas of NCU
NCU is already leading these specific competencies or is on the edge of becoming leader
Most of „interdisciplinary bubbles” do have blue bar
• Chemistry has the highest degree of inter-disciplinarity and connects several fields such as Medicine, Engineering, Biotechnology
Research Strength • Math&Physics, Chemistry, Medicine and
Biology/Biotechnology
MEDICINE BIOTECHNOLOGY
INFECTIOUS DISEASE
BIOLOGY
EARTH SCIENCE
ENGINEERING
CHEMISTRY
MATH & PHYSICS
COMPUTER SCIENCE
SOCIAL SCIENCE
BRAIN RESEARCH
HEALTH SCIENCE
HUMANITIE
S
Interdisciplinary
Research Areas
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Research Strengths – Torun and Bydgoszcz
MEDICINE BIOTECHNOLOGY
INFECTIOUS DISEASE
BIOLOGY
EARTH SCIENCE
ENGINEERING
CHEMISTRY
MATH & PHYSICS
COMPUTER SCIENCE
SOCIAL SCIENCE
BRAIN RESEARCH
HEALTH SCIENCE
HUMANITIE
S
Interdisciplinary
Research Areas
35 competencies
UMK
CM
65 competencies
43 competencies
Less competencies in total in the
result of shared competencies
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Article Output per Subject Area
• 18.5% of published articles are within
Math&Physics, however
Math&Physics contribute to 35% of
the competency articles
• Medicine (Health Sciences, Med.
Specialities, Brain Research, Health
ciences) contribute 41.2% to
publications vs. 22.9% to
competencies
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Table View of Compentencies
NCU is publishing heavily and very recent in their Research Strength• 20 Research Strength with Publication Leadership, 21 with Innovation Leadership
Publication Impact in terms of citations is rather low (5 Citation Leadership)
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Matrix View
Question Marks
How can we increase our market
share in these research areas?
Active “Recruitment”
Stars
How can we defend our presence
in these research areas?
“Retain” key talent
Cash Cows
How can we get the highest
impact out of these research
areas?
Dogs
Research areas that are
internationally declining with low
article share
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Porównanie działalności naukowej UMK z konkurencyjnymi
uniwersytetamiSub title
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Quantity vs. Quality
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Polish publications: Top 12 contributing institutions
• NCU contributes to 3.5% of all polish articles• Citations per Article (CPA) of NCU shows usual pattern of low international collaboration
• High degree of international co-authorship is related with higher citation counts• Strong focus on medicine corresponds with high citation numbers as well
• 31% of articles are co-authored international, however only 26% are co-authored with Top publishing countries
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
International Collaboration
* International are the Top 11 publishing countries worldwide: United States, United Kingdom, China, Japan, Germany, France, Spain, Canada, Italy, Russia, India
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Number and structure of competencies
Number of CompetenciesWarsaw 81Jagiellonian 99NCU 65AMU 53Wroclaw 40
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
General numbers
Some Facts on NCU and it's peers
Size Total
Number of Researchers 2010
Publications Total (2006-2010)
Number of Competencies
Publications per Researcher
Competencies per 100 Researchers
NCU 40,000 2,000 3,818 65 1.91 3.25
Warsaw 60,000 3,240 6,213 81 1.92 2.50
Jagiellonian 55,000 3,650 8,023 99 2.20 2.71
AMU 53,000 3,000 4,168 53 1.39 1.77
Wroclaw 45,000 1,700 3,560 40 2.09 2.35
If normalized, in terms of article output NCU is comparable with
other universites Normalization per 100 Researchers shows excellent rate of
Competencies in comparison with peers
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Growth potential
Data source: SciVal Spotlight Map 2010, SciVerse Scopus – 15 th November 2011
Conclusions
NCU is publishing heavily and has good recency in terms of referenced papers
However, citation impact is the area for improvement
2/3 of NCU Competencies are in growing fields (article output increases annually worldwide)
NCU has less competencies than Warsaw and Jagiellonian universities, but normalization per 100 Researchers shows excellent rate of competencies in comparison with peers
Warsaw and Jagiellonian are most prolific and most effective Research Organisations
NCU similar to Wroclaw and AMU in article output, but due to quality of reseach and diversity shows more competencies than both of them