8/13/2019 De La Rama v. Ledesma (G.R. No. L-28498)

1/2

"#$%&''& #((& )* +,-.&"&/

!"#" %&" '()*+,* -./0 1+2 1,*3

45 '6 #676 8" '545976

!"#$%&$''() 96':64;# 45 '6 #676

+,',%-#%&) #6 ?34"- ?#4 ;;@ &:, 836A#%B (='',4,- -#6#>,( #%- :#- #%

#AA432,- 7#4 -#6#>, 8"#$6 7$&: &:, !:$"$AA$%, ?#4 +#6#>,

.366$(($3%< C:, (&389:3"-,4( 3' &:, 836A#%B -,8$-,- &:#& &:, '$4(&

A#B6,%& 73="- D, =(,- '34 &:, 4,A#$4 3' &:, ;4$( C:,#&,4 E=$"-$%>< !4$34

&3 &:, (,83%- A#B6,%&@ -, "# 5#6# (3"- :$( (:#4,( &3 :$( %,A:,7 5#'#,"

F,-,(6#< /"",>,-"B@ &:,4, $( #% #>4,,6,%& 7$&: D,&7,,% -, "# 5#6#

#%- F,-,(6# &:#& &:, '346,4 4,(,42,- &3 :$6(,"' :$( A43A34&$3%#&,

,G=$&B $% &:, 7#4 -#6#>, D,%,'$&( -=, 3% &:, (:#4,( :, (3"- 7:$8:F,-,(6# 73="- -,"$2,4 &3 -, "# 5#6# =A3% A#B6,%& DB &:, H34,$>%

."#$6 0,&&",6,%& .366$(($3% 3' &:, I%$&,- 0&,(< J,7 8,4&$'$8#&,( 3'

(&389 7,4, $((=,- $% &:, %#6, 3' F,-,(6#< 0=D(,G=,%&"B@ &:,

834A34#&$3% 4,8,$2,- &:, '$%#" A#B6,%& 3' $&( 7#4 -#6#>, 8"#$6 #%- &:,

E3#4- 3' +$4,8&34( -$(&4$D=&,- &:,(, #( -$2$-,%-( &3 $&( 8=44,%& 43(&,4 3'

(&389:3"-,4(< +, "# 5#6# &:,% -,6#%-,- A#B6,%& '436 F,-,(6# $%

#8834-#%8, 7$&: &:,$4 #"",>,- #>4,,6,%&@ D=& &:, "#&&,4 4,'=(,-< +, "#

5#6# &:,% '$",- # 8$2$" 8#(, #>#$%(& F,-,(6# 7:,4, -, "# 5#6# #$6( &3

A432, &:,$4 #"",>,- 2,4D#" #>4,,6,%&< F,-,(6# #2,4( &:#& &3 #""37 -, "#

5#6# &3 A432, &:,$4 #"",>,- ($6="%,3=( 34#" #>4,,6,%& 73="- 4=%

83=%&,4 &3 &:, !#43" 12$-,%8, 5=", 7:$8: A43:$D$&( &:, #-6$(($3% 3'

,2$-,%8, 83%8,4%$%> # A4$34 34 83%&,6A34#%,3=( 2,4D#" #>4,,6,%&

7:$8: 73="- :#2, &:, ,'',8& 3' 2#4B$%>@ 83%&4#-$8&$%> 34 -,',#&$%> &:,

3A,4#&$3% 3' # 2#"$- $%(&4=6,%& &:#& $( 7:3", $% $&(,"'< C:, 3%"B

,K8,A&$3% &3 &:$( 4=",@ $( 7:,% '4#=- 34 6$(, #8836A#%$,- &:,

,K,8=&$3% 3' (=8: $%(&4=6,%&

(=8: #% $6A34%& 4,(,42#&$3%M

+N.C5;J1) ;& $( # 7,"" #88,A&,- A4$%8$A", 3' "#7 &:#& ,2$-,%8, 3' # A4$34

34 83%&,6A34#%,3=( 2,4D#" #>4,,6,%& $( >,%,4#""B %3& #-6$(($D", &3

2#4B@ 83%&4#-$8& 34 -,',#& &:, 3A,4#&$3% 3' # 2#"$- $%(&4=6,%&< O/6,4$8#%

H#8&34( O!:$"

,- &:#& &:, ;%38,%&,( -, "# 5#6# ;%8< (='',4,--#6#>,( -=4$%> &:, "#(& 7#4 #%- :#- #% #AA432,- 7#4 -#6#>,

8"#$6 7$&: &:, !:$"$AA$%, ?#4 +#6#>, .366$(($3% $% &:, (=63' !UWX@WWW,

D,%,'$&( -=, 3% :$( URW (:#4,( 7:$8: F,-,(6# A436$(,- &3

-,"$2,4 &3 :$6 =A3% A#B6,%& DB &:, H34,$>% ."#$6 0,&&",6,%&

.366$(($3% 3' &:, I%$&,- 0&,(< J,7 8,4&$'$8#&,( 3' (&389 7,4,

$((=,- $% &:, %#6, 3' F,-,(6#, 8"#$6@ #%- &:, E3#4- 3' +$4,8&34( A#((,- #

4,(3"=&$3% -$(&4$D=&$%> &:, '$%#" A#B6,%& 4,8,$2,- DB (#$-

834A34#&$3% #63%> $&( (&389:3"-,4(

8/13/2019 De La Rama v. Ledesma (G.R. No. L-28498)

2/2

"#$%&''& #((& )* +,-.&"&/

o ?:,% F,-,(6# 4,8,$2,- &:, -$2$-,%-( A,4$%$%> &3 :$(&3" (:#4,:3"-$%> $%8"=-$%> &:, URW (:#4,( :, :#-

A=48:#(,- '436 +, "# 5#6#@ &:, "#&&,4 -,6#%-,- '436

&:, '346,4 &:, 4,&=4% #%- -,"$2,4B &3 :$6 3' :$(

8344,(A3%-$%> (:#4, $% &:, 8"#$6 $% G=,(&$3%,- &3 &:, 834A34#&$3% $&(,"' #%-%3& &3 $&( (&389:3"-,4( #%- (3 7#( &:, '$%#" A#B6,%&

7:$8: 7#( A#$- &3 &:, 834A34#&$3% $&(,"'@ '34 $&( E3#4- 3'

+$4,8&34( &3 -3 7:#& $& -,,6,- D,(&, !#B6,%& 6#-, DB &:, >32,4%6,%& 3'

&:, I%$&,- 0&,( &3 8"#$6#%&( $% &:, !:$"$AA$%,( 7:3

(='',4,- "3((,( -=4$%> ?34"- ?#4 ;; $( %3& # A43'$& 3' &:,

.34A34#&$3% 7:$8: 8#% D, -$(&4$D=&,- #( -$2$-,%-(] &:,

=(, #%- -$(A3($&$3% 3' (#$- '=%-( #( (A,8$'$,- DB &:,

!:$"$AA$%, 5,:#D$"$&$3% /8& 3' USRX #4, 4,(,42,- '34

&:3(, 7:3 (='',4,- "3((,( -=4$%> &:, 7#4 "$9, :$6(,"'4,,6,%& 3' &:, A#4&$,(83%8,4%$%> A"#$%&$''\( 4,(,42#&$3% 3' :$( 4$>:& &3 &:, D#"#%8, 3'

&:, 7#4 -#6#>, 8"#$6 #& &:, &$6, 3' &:, (#", 3' :$( (:#4,( &3 &:,

-,',%-#%&@ 8#% D, A432,% DB A#43" ,2$-,%8, =%-,4 &:, !#43"

12$-,%8, 5=", #%- &:, 0&=&, 3' H4#=-(4,,6,%& $( >,%,4#""B %3& #-6$(($D",

&3 2#4B@ 83%&4#-$8& 34 -,',#& &:, 3A,4#&$3% 3' # 2#"$- $%(&4=6,%&