doj v kung fu saloon

Upload: robert-wilonsky

Post on 07-Aug-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    1/25

     

    JG [EC SGJ[CK X[D[CX KJX[_JH[ H@S_[

    F@_ [EC G@_[EC_G KJX[_JH[ @F [CUDX

    KDBBDX KJVJXJ@G

    SGJ[CK X[D[CX @F DNC_JHD, ))

    Qbdjgtjff, ))

    v. )

    ) H@NQBDJG[ F@_ JGLSGH[JVC _CBJCF

    _@S[E ISZX, BBH k/o/d MSGI FS )XDB@@G, YDXEJGI[@G ISZX, BBH ) 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    2/25

     

    3.  Kcfcgkdgt Ydsejgit`g Iuys, BBH js d rcijstcrck k`ncstjh bjnjtck bjdojbjty

    h`rp`rdtj`g jg [cxds tedt k`cs ousjgcss ds ‒Mugi Fu Xdb``g„ b`hdtck dt 3849 Ydsejgit`g

    Dvcguc jg E`ust`g, [cxds.

    6.  Kcfcgkdgt Irdgkc Iuys, BBH js d rcijstcrck k`ncstjh bjnjtck bjdojbjty

    h`rp`rdtj`g jg [cxds tedt k`cs ousjgcss ds ‒Mugi Fu Xdb``g„ b`hdtck dt 341 _j` Irdgkc Xtrcct jg

    Dustjg, [cxds.

    9.  Mugi Fu Xdb``g js d hedjg `f tercc odrs dgk rcstdurdgts `wgck dgk `pcrdtck oy

    tec Kcfcgkdgts jg tec tercc prchckjgi pdrdirdpes. Mugi Fu Xdb``gs `ffcr pdtr`gs, jghbukjgi `ut-

    `f-stdtc trdvcbcrs, cgtcrtdjgncgt suhe ds drhdkc idncs, seuffbco`drk, smcc odbb, o`drk idncs,

    tcbcvjsck bjvc jg-stdtc dgk `ut-`f-stdtc sp`rtjgi cvcgts, d kjsh l`hmcy, kdghjgi, dgk mdrd`mc.

    5.  Mugi Fu Xdb``gs scrvc f``k dgk krjgms t` pdtr`gs dgk dkvcrtjsc tecjr f``k dgk

    krjgm scrvjhcs `g tecjr wcosjtcs. D suostdgtjdb p`rtj`g `f tec f``k dgk krjgms wejhe cdhe Mugi

    Fu Xdb``g scrvcs eds n`vck jg jgtcrstdtc h`nncrhc.

    :.  Mugi Fu Xdb``gs drc pbdhcs `f puobjh dhh`nn`kdtj`g wjtejg tec ncdgjgi `f ;?

    S.X.H. §§ ?111d(o)(?) dgk (o)(8).

    41.  [ec `pcrdtj`g `f cdhe Mugi Fu Xdb``g dffchts h`nncrhc wjtejg tec ncdgjgi `f

    ;? S.X.H. §§ ?111d(h)(?) dgk (h)(8).

    [J[BC JJ VJ@BD[J@GX

    44.  Xjghc dt bcdst Ndy ?144 t` tec prcscgt, tec Kcfcgkdgts, dhtjgi ter`uie tecjr

    `ffjhcrs, cnpb`yccs dgk dicgts, edvc cgidick jg p`bjhjcs dgk prdhtjhcs tedt kcgy Dfrjhdg

    Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg jgkjvjkudbs, `g dhh`ugt `f tecjr rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg, tec fubb dgk

    cqudb cgl`yncgt `f tec i``ks, scrvjhcs, fdhjbjtjcs, prjvjbcics, dkvdgtdics, dgk dhh`nn`kdtj`gs `f

    Mugi Fu Xdb``gs.

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    3/25

     

    4?.  Jg k`zcgs `f jgstdghcs sjghc dt bcdst Ndy ?144, Kcfcgkdgts edvc kcgjck Dfrjhdg

    Dncrjhdg pdtr`gs cgtry jgt` Mugi Fu Xdb``gs odsck `g krcss h`kc wecg sjnjbdrby krcssck wejtc

     pdtr`gs wcrc pcrnjttck t` cgtcr. F`r cxdnpbc, jg Ndrhe ?148, dg Dfrjhdg-Dncrjhdg pdtr`g wds

    kcgjck cgtry f`r wcdrjgi d pdrtjhubdr ordgk `f dtebctjh se`cs. E`wcvcr, n`ncgts cdrbjcr, ejs

    wejtc frjcgk wds pcrnjttck cgtry cvcg te`uie ec w`rc tec sdnc ordgk `f dtebctjh se`cs. Yecg

    tec Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg pdtr`g jgf`rnck tec Kcfcgkdgts‚ cnpb`ycc tedt ejs wejtc frjcgk wds

     pcrnjttck cgtry cvcg te`uie ec wds wcdrjgi tec sdnc ordgk `f se`cs, tec cnpb`ycc rcpbjck tedt

    jt wds up t` Mugi Fu ‒we` hdg h`nc jg dgk we` hdg‚t.„ 

    48. 

    [ec Kcfcgkdgts, dhtjgi ter`uie tecjr `ffjhcrs, cnpb`yccs, dgk dicgts, edvc

    cgidick jg `tecr prdhtjhcs t` bjnjt tec gunocr `f Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg pdtr`gs dt Mugi

    Fu Xdb``gs. F`r cxdnpbc, Mugi Fu eds kcgjck Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg pdtr`gs cgtry oy

    hbdjnjgi tedt tec cstdobjsencgt js dt hdpdhjty wejbc dbb`wjgi wejtc pdtr`gs t` cgtcr tecrcdftcr=

    rcqujrck Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg pdtr`gs t` wdjt b`gicr t` cgtcr tedg wejtc pdtr`gs we`

    drrjvck tecrcdftcr= dgk shrccgck cvcgt o``mjgi rcqucsts t` bjnjt tec gunocr `f cvcgt o``mjgis oy

    Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg `r Dsjdg pdrtjcs.

    4;.  [ec Kcfcgkdgts‚ h`gkuht kcshrjock jg Qdrdirdpes 44 ter`uie 48 h`gstjtutcs d

     pdttcrg `r prdhtjhc `f rcsjstdghc `f tec fubb dgk cqudb cgl`yncgt oy Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg

    jgkjvjkudbs, `g dhh`ugt `f tecsc jgkjvjkudbs‚ rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg, `f rjiets schurck oy

    ;? S.X.H. §§ ?111d, ct scq., dgk tec pdttcrg `r prdhtjhc js `f suhe d gdturc dgk js jgtcgkck t` kcgy

    tec fubb cxcrhjsc `f suhe rjiets.

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    4/25

     

    Q_DZC_ F@_ _CBJCF

    YEC_CF@_C, tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs rcqucsts tedt tec H`urt cgtcr dg @rkcr<

    4.  Kchbdrjgi tedt tec kjshrjnjgdt̀ ry prdhtjhcs dgk p`bjhjcs `f tec Kcfcgkdgts vj`bdtc

    [jtbc JJ `f tec Hjvjb _jiets Dht `f 4:6;, ;? S.X.H. §§ ?111d, ct scq.=

    ?.  Cgl`jgjgi tec Kcfcgkdgts, tecjr cnpb`yccs, dicgts, dgk suhhcss`rs, dgk dbb `tecr

     pcrs`gs jg dhtjvc h`ghcrt `r pdrtjhjpdtj`g wjte tecn, fr`n cgidijgi jg dgy dht `r prdhtjhc wejhe,

    `g tec odsjs `f rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg, kcgjcs `r dorjkics dgy rjiets schurck oy [jtbc JJ `f

    tec Hjvjb _jiets Dht `f 4:6;, ;? S.X.H. §§ ?111d, ct scq.=

    8. 

    _cqujrjgi tec Kcfcgkdgts, tecjr cnpb`yccs, dicgts, dgk suhhcss`rs, dgk dbb `tecr

     pcrs`gs jg dhtjvc h`ghcrt `r pdrtjhjpdtj`g wjte tec Kcfcgkdgts, t` tdmc suhe dffjrndtjvc stcps ds

    ndy oc gchcssdry t` rcncky tec cffchts `f pdst ugbdwfub h`gkuht dgk t` prcvcgt tec rchurrcghc `f

    kjshrjnjgdt`ry h`gkuht jg tec futurc.

    [ec Sgjtck Xtdtcs furtecr prdys f`r suhe dkkjtj`gdb rcbjcf ds tec jgtcrcsts `f lustjhc ndy

    rcqujrc.

    [ejs 81te

     kdy `f Lugc, ?143.

    B@_C[[D C. BZGHE

    Dtt`rgcy Icgcrdb

     /s/ Vdgjtd Iuptd  PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP

    L@EG _. QD_MC_ VDGJ[D ISQ[D

    Dhtjgi Sgjtck Xtdtcs Dtt`rgcy Qrjghjpdb Kcputy Dssjstdgt Dtt`rgcy Icgcrdb

     G`rtecrg Kjstrjht `f [cxds Hjvjb _jiets Kjvjsj`g

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    5/25

     

     /s/ Xh`tt E`idg /s/ Xtcvcg E. _`scgodun

     PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP

    L. XH@[[ E@IDG X[CVCG E. _@XCGODSNDssjstdgt Sgjtck Xtdtcs Dtt`rgcy Hejcf

    [U Odr G`. ?;18?;?3 E`usjgi dgk Hjvjb Cgf`rhcncgt Xchtj`g

    4411 H`nncrhc Xtrcct, Xujtc 811Kdbbds, [U 93?;?  /s/ Cbjsc Xdgkrd Xe`rcQe`gc< (?4;) 63:-56;1 PPPPPPPPP

    Cndjb< sh`tt.e`idgAusk`l.i`v  XDNCCGD X. NDLCCK

    Kcputy HejcfCBJXC XDGK_D XE@_C

    Ic`rijd Odr G`. 339484

    [rjdb Dtt`rgcy

    E`usjgi dgk Hjvjb Cgf`rhcncgt Xchtj`gHjvjb _jiets Kjvjsj`g

    S.X. Kcpdrtncgt `f Lustjhc

    :31 Qcggsybvdgjd Dvcguc G.Y. G`rtewcstcrg Oujbkjgi

    Ydsejgit`g, K.H. ?1381

    Qe`gc< (?1?) 813-1191

    Cndjb< Cbjsc.Xe`rcAusk`l.i`v 

    Dtt`rgcys f`r Qbdjgtjff

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    6/25

     

    D[[DHENCG[ D

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    7/25

     

    JG [EC SGJ[CK X[D[CX KJX[_JH[ H@S_[F@_ [EC G@_[EC_G KJX[_JH[ @F [CUDX

    KDBBDX KJVJXJ@G

    SGJ[CK X[D[CX @F DNC_JHD, ))

    Qbdjgtjff, )

    )

    v. )) HJVJB DH[J@G G@. 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    8/25

    ?

    dkvdgtdics, dgk dhh`nn`kdtj`gs `f Mugi Fu Xdb``gs `g tec sdnc odsjs ds suhe drc pr`vjkck t`

    wejtc ncnocrs `f tec icgcrdb puobjh ter`uie, dn`gi `tecr tejgis, tec jnpbcncgtdtj̀ g `f d krcss

    h`kc.

    ;. Xpchjfjhdbby, tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs dbbcics tedt Kcfcgkdgts edvc cgidick jg prdhtjhcs

    wejhe jghbukc out drc g`t bjnjtck t` tec f`bb`wjgi dhts< (d) kcgyjgi Dfrjhdg-Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg

     pdtr`gs cgtry jgt` tec cstdobjsencgt odsck `g krcss h`kc wecg sjnjbdrby-krcssck wejtc pdtr`gs

    wcrc pcrnjttck t` cgtcr= (o) kcgyjgi Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg pdtr`gs cgtry oy hbdjnjgi tedt

    tec cstdobjsencgt js dt hdpdhjty wejbc dbb`wjgi wejtc pdtr`gs t` cgtcr tecrcdftcr= (h) rcqujrjgi

    Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg pdtr`gs t` wdjt b`gicr t` cgtcr tedg wejtc pdtr`gs we` drrjvck

    tecrcdftcr= dgk (k) shrccgjgi cvcgt o``mjgi rcqucsts t` bjnjt tec gunocr `f cvcgt o``mjgis oy

    Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg `r Dsjdg pdrtjcs.

    3. [ec Kcfcgkdgts kcgy tec dbbcidtj`gs jg tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs‚ H`npbdjgt.

    6. [ec pdrtjcs stjpubdtc tedt, dt dbb tjncs rcbcvdgt t` tec dbbcidtj`gs `f tec Sgjtck

    Xtdtcs, Mugi Fu Xdb``gs drc ‒pbdhc]s^ `f puobjh dhh`nn`kdtj`g„ wjtejg tec ncdgjgi `f ;?

    S.X.H. § ?111d(o)(8), dgk tedt tecjr `pcrdtj`gs ‒dffcht h`nncrhc„ wjtejg tec ncdgjgi `f ;?

    S.X.H. § ?111d(h).

    9. [ec Sgjtck Xtdtcs dgk tec Kcfcgkdgts edvc dircck tedt, jg `rkcr t` dv`jk

     pr`trdhtck dgk h`stby bjtjidtj`g, tejs hdsc se`ubk oc rcs`bvck wjte`ut furtecr bjtjidtj̀ g ter`uie tec

    tcrns `f tejs Kchrcc.

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    9/25

    8

    Jt js ecrcoy, @_KC_CK, DKLSKICK, dgk KCH_CCK tedt<

    JJ. Jglughtj`g 

    5. Dbb pr`vjsj`gs `f tejs Kchrcc sedbb dppby t` _`ute Iuys, BBH, Ydsejgit`g Iuys,

    BBH, dgk Irdgkc Iuys, BBH jg tec h`gkuht `f ousjgcss dt Mugi Fu Xdb``gs. Dbb pr`vjsj`gs `f

    tejs Kchrcc sedbb dbs` dppby t` tec cnpb`yccs dgk dicgts `f sdnc, t` dbb suhhcss`rs t` tec cxtcgt

    tedt tecjr h``pcrdtj`g js rcqujrck t` jnpbcncgt tejs Kchrcc, dgk t` dgy`gc dhtjgi jg we`bc `r g

     pdrt ugkcr tec kjrchtj`g `f dgy `f tec Kcfcgkdgts jg h`ggchtj`g wjte dgy Mugi Fu Xdb``g.

    :. [ec Kcfcgkdgts, tecjr dicgts, cnpb`yccs, suhhcss`rs, dgk dbb `tecrs dhtjvcby

     pdrtjhjpdtjgi wjte tecn jg tec `wgcrsejp dgk `pcrdtj`g `f dgy Mugi Fu Xdb``g drc cgl`jgck fr`n

    kcgyjgi t` dgy pcrs`g, ochdusc `f rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg, tec fubb dgk cqudb cgl`yncgt `f

    dbb `f tec i``ks, scrvjhcs, fdhjbjtjcs, prjvjbcics, dkvdgtdics, dgk dhh`nn`kdtj`gs `f suhe

    cstdobjsencgt. Xuhe pr`ejojtck h`gkuht jghbukcs< (d) fdjbjgi `r rcfusjgi t` dknjt dgy pcrs`g t`

    tec prcnjscs `f suhe cstdobjsencgt `g dhh`ugt `f rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg= (o) `ffcrjgi

    kjffcrcgt tcrns, h`gkjtj`gs, `r prjvjbcics `f dknjssj`g `r cvcgt o``mjgi dt suhe cstdobjsencgt `r

     pr`vjkjgi kjffcrcgt jgf`rndtj`g do`ut tec tcrns, h`gkjtj`gs, `r prjvjbcics `f dknjssj`g `r cvcgt

     o``mjgi `g tec odsjs `f rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg= dgk (h) kcgyjgi `r kctcrrjgi dknjssj`g `r

    cvcgt o``mjgi dt suhe cstdobjsencgt oy dk`ptjgi dgy prdhtjhc `r pr`hckurc kcsjigck t`

    kjsh`urdic pcrs`gs fr`n pdtr`gjzjgi suhe cstdobjsencgt `r o``mjgi dg cvcgt `g tec odsjs `f rdhc,

    h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg.

    JJJ. [rdjgjgi 

    41. Yjtejg :1 kdys `f tec cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc, tec Kcfcgkdgts‚ `wgcrs, pdrtgcrs,

    cnpb`yccs, dgk dgy `tecr pcrs`g we` jg dgy wdy pr`vjkcs ndgdicncgt, schurjty, `r scrvjhcs t`

    tec puobjh dt Mugi Fu Xdb``gs sedbb dttcgk d pr`irdn `f ckuhdtj`gdb trdjgjgi h`ghcrgjgi tec

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    10/25

    ;

    suostdgtjvc pr`vjsj`gs `f [jtbc JJ dgk tecjr rcsp`gsjojbjtjcs ugkcr tec bdw. [ejs trdjgjgi, wejhe

    sedbb oc g` bcss tedg tw` e`urs jg kurdtj`g, sedbb oc h`gkuhtck oy d pcrs`g `r `ridgjzdtj`g,

    dppr`vck oy tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs, wjte cxpcrjcghc jg pr`vjkjgi trdjgjgi `g hjvjb rjiets jssucs. [ec

    h`sts `f tejs pr`irdn sedbb oc o`rgc oy tec Kcfcgkdgts. Dbb pcrs`gs dttcgkjgi suhe d pr`irdn

    sedbb edvc tecjr dttcgkdghc hcrtjfjck jg wrjtjgi oy tec pcrs`g `r `ridgjzdtj`g h`gkuhtjgi tec

    ckuhdtj`gdb pr`irdn.

    44. G` bdtcr tedg ?4 kdys dftcr cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb pr`vjkc d

    h`py `f tejs Kchrcc t` cvcry `wgcr, pdrtgcr, cnpb`ycc, dgk dgy `tecr pcrs`g we` jg dgy wdy

     pr`vjkcs ndgdicncgt, schurjty, `r scrvjhcs t` tec puobjh dt dgy Mugi Fu Xdb``g. [ec Kcfcgkdgts

    sedbb kjrcht cdhe suhe `wgcr, pdrtgcr, cnpb`ycc, dicgt, dgk `tecr pcrs`g h`vcrck oy tejs

     pdrdirdpe t` rcvjcw dgk rcdk d h`py `f tejs Kchrcc. Cdhe `wgcr, pdrtgcr, cnpb`ycc, dicgt, dgk

    `tecr pcrs`g h`vcrck oy tejs pdrdirdpe sedbb sjig d stdtcncgt jg tec f`rn `f Dttdhencgt D

    dhmg`wbckijgi tedt ec `r sec eds rcdk dgk ugkcrstdgks tejs Kchrcc dgk kchbdrjgi tedt ec `r sec

    wjbb pcrf`rn ejs `r ecr kutjcs jg dhh`rkdghc wjte tejs Kchrcc. F`r tec kurdtj`g `f tejs Kchrcc, dbb

    gcw cnpb`yccs we` pr`vjkc ndgdicncgt, schurjty, `r scrvjhcs t` tec puobjh dt dgy Mugi Fu

    Xdb``g sedbb oc pr`vjkck d h`py `f tejs Kchrcc wecg tecjr cnpb`yncgt h`nncghcs, sedbb oc

    kjrchtck t` rcdk d h`py `f tejs Kchrcc, dgk sedbb sjig d stdtcncgt jg tec f`rn `f Dttdhencgt D g`

    bdtcr tedg fjvc kdys f`bb`wjgi tecjr fjrst kdy `f cnpb`yncgt.

    JV. G`gkjshrjnjgdtj`g Q`bjhjcs dgk Qr`hckurcs 

    4?. Yjtejg 43 kdys `f tec kdtc `f cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb crcht dgk

    ndjgtdjg dt cdhe puobjh cgtrdghc t` tec Dustjg, E`ust`g dgk Kdbbds b`hdtj`gs `f Mugi Fu Xdb``g

    d prjgtck sjig stdtjgi tedt tec cstdobjsencgt js `pcg t` dbb ncnocrs `f tec puobjh wjte`ut rcidrk

    t` rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg. Xuhe sjig sedbb oc prjgtck jg kdrm bcttcrs `g d h`gtrdstjgi

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    11/25

    3

     odhmir`ugk dgk sedbb oc b`hdtck dgk ndjgtdjgck jg d pbdhc tedt js wcbb-bjt dgk hbcdrby vjsjobc t` dbb

     pdtr`gs ds tecy cgtcr tec prcnjscs. Xuhe sjig sedbb jghbukc d stdtcncgt tedt dgy pcrs`g we`

     ocbjcvcs ec `r sec eds occg kjshrjnjgdtck didjgst `g tec odsjs `f rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg

    ndy spcdm jnnckjdtcby wjte d ndgdicr, dgk tedt jf ec `r sec kjsdirccs wjte tec ndgdicr‚s

    kchjsj`g, ndy fjbc d wrjttcg h`npbdjgt dgk/`r ndy hdbb tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs Kcpdrtncgt `f Lustjhc dt

    (511) 5:6-9;;8 cxt. :::4 dgk/`r tec Kcfcgkdgts‚ h`npbdjgt gunocr t` oc cstdobjseck wjtejg 81

    kdys `f tec cffchtjvc kdtc `f tejs Kchrcc. [ec tcxt f`r suhe sjig, dgk tec sjzc `f tec tcxt, js

    spchjfjck jg Dttdhencgt O.

    48. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb pbdhc `g tec e`ncpdic `f cdhe Mugi Fu Xdb``g wcosjtc

    dgk Fdhco``m pdic dgk sedbb jghbukc jg dgy dkvcrtjscncgts jg tcbcvjsj`g, gcwspdpcr, `r

    jgtcrgct nckjd (cxhcpt `gbjgc odggcr dks dgk s`hjdb nckjd dks), jgf`rndtj`g jgkjhdtjgi tedt

    Mugi Fu Xdb``gs drc `pcg t` dbb ncnocrs `f tec puobjh `g dg cqudb odsjs, wjte`ut rcidrk t`

    rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg. [ec f`bb`wjgi w`rkjgi sedbb oc suffjhjcgt f`r purp`scs `f

    h`npbjdghc wjte tejs pdrdirdpe< ‒Mugi Fu wcbh`ncs cvcry`gc `g dg cqudb odsjs wjte`ut

    rcidrk t` rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg.„

    4;. [` tec cxtcgt tedt Mugi Fu Xdb``gs dhhcpt o``mjgis f`r prjvdtc pdrtjcs `r cvcgts,

    Mugi Fu Xdb``g‚s wcopdic sedbb hbcdrby h`gvcy tec pr`hckurcs f`r o``mjgi d prjvdtc pdrty `r

    cvcgt dgk tedt prjvdtc pdrtjcs `r cvcgts drc dvdjbdobc `g d spdhc-bjnjtck odsjs t` dbb ncnocrs `f

    tec puobjh `g dg cqudb odsjs, wjte`ut rcidrk t` rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg. F`r purp`scs `f

     prjvdtc pdrtjcs `r cvcgts, Mugi Fu Xdb``gs dircc t` usc tec Mugi Fu _cscrvdtj`g Dirccncgt

    wejhe ochdnc cffchtjvc `g tec cffchtjvc kdtc `f tejs Kchrcc. Jg dkkjtj`g t` tec f`rci`jgi, Mugi

    Fu Xdb``g wjbb rcp`rt t` tec Kcpdrtncgt `f Lustjhc jgstdghcs jg wejhe jt kchbjgcs d rcqucst f`r dg

    cvcgt o``mjgi f`r dgy rcds`g `tecr tedg tec f`bb`wjgi< tec cvcgt spdhc js ugdvdjbdobc kuc t` `tecr

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    12/25

    6

     o``mjgis, rcn`kcbjgi/rcg`vdtj`g, `r dgy `tecr rcds`g tedt hb`scs tec cvcgt spdhc t` dbb pcrs`gs

    rcqucstjgi cvcgt o``mjgis dt tedt tjnc= dgk g` cvcgt o``mjgis drc ocjgi `ffcrck dt tec kdtc `r

    tjnc rcqucstck. Jg dkkjtj`g, Mugi Fu Xdb``gs dirccs t` ndmc dvdjbdobc f`r jgspchtj`g oy tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs, up`g rcqucst, d h`py `f dgy dgk dbb Mugi Fu _cscrvdtj`g Dirccncgts suonjttck t`

    Mugi Fu Xdb``gs f`r tec kurdtj`g `f tejs H`gscgt Kchrcc.

    43. [` tec cxtcgt tedt tec Kcfcgkdgts dk`pt, cgf`rhc, `r `tecrwjsc usc d krcss h`kc

    wjte rcspcht t` dknjssj`g t` Mugi Fu Xdb``gs, suhe krcss h`kc nust oc jg wrjtjgi, nust hbcdrby

    h`gvcy wedt ndggcr `f krcss js rcqujrck dgk wedt spchjfjh typcs `f dppdrcb drc pr`ejojtck, dgk

    nust oc p`stck dgk pr`njgcgtby kjspbdyck `utsjkc dbb cgtrdghcs t` Mugi Fu Xdb``gs jg hbcdr vjcw

    `f pr`spchtjvc pdtr`gs. D h`py `f tec pr`p`sck krcss h`kc sedbb oc pr`vjkck t` tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs

    f`r rcvjcw dgk dppr`vdb wjtejg 43 kdys `f tec kdtc `f cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc. [ec Sgjtck Xtdtcs

    sedbb edvc 43 kdys fr`n tec kdtc `f rchcjpt `f tec pr`p`sck krcss h`kc t` rcvjcw dgk h`nncgt `g

     pr`vjsj`gs `f tec krcss h`kc ocf`rc jt sedbb tdmc cffcht. @ghc tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs eds dppr`vck tec

    krcss h`kc, dgy pr`p`sck hedgics t` tec krcss h`kc kurjgi tec kurdtj`g `f tejs Kchrcc nust oc

     pr`vjkck oy fdhsjnjbc dgk gcxt-kdy kcbjvcry t` tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs f̀ r jts rcvjcw dgk h`nncgt dt

    bcdst 81 kdys ocf`rc ocjgi jnpbcncgtck. [ec pr`p`sck hedgics sedbb oc h`gsjkcrck dppr`vck

    up`g tec cxpjrdtj`g `f tec 81te kdy ugbcss tec Kcfcgkdgts rchcjvc d wrjttcg `olchtj`g fr`n tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs wjtejg tec 81-kdy g`tjhc pcrj`k. [` tec cxtcgt tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs `olchts t` dgy

    hedgics t` tec krcss h`kc pr`p`sck jg dhh`rkdghc wjte tejs pdrdirdpe, dgk tec pdrtjcs hdgg`t

    rcs`bvc tec kjsputc dn`gi tecnscbvcs, suhe kjsputc sedbb oc suonjttck t` tec H`urt jg dhh`rkdghc

    wjte tec kjsputc rcs`butj`g pr`vjsj`gs `f pdrdirdpes 8;‘83.

    46. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb jgstjtutc p`bjhjcs tedt cgsurc tedt dg jgkjvjkudb jg d

    supcrvjs`ry p`sjtj`g js `g-sjtc dgk dvdjbdobc pr`nptby t` spcdm wjte dgy pdtr`g we` js kcgjck

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    13/25

    9

    dhhcss t` dgy Mugi Fu Xdb``g. [edt jgkjvjkudb sedbb edvc tec rjiet t` pcrnjt tec pdtr`g t` cgtcr.

    Jf tedt jgkjvjkudb stjbb kcgjcs dhhcss t` tec pdtr`g, tec jgkjvjkudb sedbb `ffcr tec pdtr`g d h`npbdjgt

    f`rn jg tec f`rn `f Dttdhencgt H. Dbb jgkjvjkudbs jg d supcrvjs`ry p`sjtj`g sedbb dt dbb tjncs

    edvc dhhcss t` d suppby `f tec h`npbdjgt f`rns jg tec f`rn `f Dttdhencgt H.

    49. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb cstdobjse dgk ndjgtdjg f`r tec kurdtj`g `f tejs Kchrcc d

    systcn `f dhhcptjgi, pr`hcssjgi, dgk jgvcstjidtjgi dgy h`npbdjgts ndkc t` Kcfcgkdgts tedt d

     pdtr`g wds kcgjck dhhcss, kjshrjnjgdtck didjgst jg tec cvcgt o``mjgi pr`hcss, `r

    kjshrjnjgdtck didjgst jg tec pr`vjsj`g `f dgy `tecr puobjh scrvjhcs dt Mugi Fu Xdb``g,

     ochdusc `f ejs `r ecr rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg.

    45. Yjtejg 81 kdys `f tec rchcjpt `f dgy `rdb `r wrjttcg h`npbdjgt ndkc t`

    Kcfcgkdgts ugkcr pdrdirdpe 49 do`vc, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb g`tjfy tec Kcpdrtncgt `f Lustjhc

    `f tec h`npbdjgt dgk, jf rcqucstck oy tec Kcpdrtncgt `f Lustjhc, sedbb pr`vjkc tec Kcpdrtncgt

    `f Lustjhc wjte dgy cxjstjgi stdtcncgts, k`huncgts, pe`t`irdpes, vjkc`s, `r `tecr jgf`rndtj`g

    rcbdtck t` tec h`npbdjgt.

    4:. G`tejgi jg tejs Kchrcc sedbb prcvcgt tec ndgdicncgt `f Mugi Fu Xdb``gs fr`n

    rcfusjgi cgtry t` `r rcn`vjgi dgy jgkjvjkudb fr`n jts prcnjscs we` cgidics jg vj`bcgt,

    jgkchcgt, pr`fdgc, o`jstcr`us, `r `tecrwjsc kjs`rkcrby h`gkuht, pr`vjkck tedt tec ndgdicncgt

    k`cs s` jg d ndggcr tedt k`cs g`t kjshrjnjgdtc didjgst jgkjvjkudbs `g tec odsjs `f rdhc, h`b`r,

    `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg.

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    14/25

    5

    V. Ndgkdt`ry H`npbjdghc [cstjgi 

    ?1. [ec Kcfcgkdgts, jg h`gsubtdtj`g wjte tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs, sedbb kcvcb`p dgk

    jnpbcncgt d tcstjgi pr`irdn t` dukjt dgk n`gjt`r tec Kcfcgkdgts‚ h`npbjdghc wjte fckcrdb

     puobjh dhh`nn`kdtj`gs bdws dgk tejs Kchrcc dt Mugi Fu Xdb``gs. [ec tcstjgi pr`irdn wjbb

    h`gsjst `f dt bcdst tercc pdjrck tcsts `f cdhe Mugi Fu Xdb``g jg cdhe h`npbctc 4?-n`gte pcrj̀ k

    f`bb`wjgi tec cffchtjvc kdtc `f tejs Kchrcc, f`r d t`tdb `f gjgc pdjrck tcsts pcr ycdr f`r d t`tdb `f ?9

    tcsts. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb ocdr dbb h`sts, fccs, dgk cxpcgscs dss`hjdtck wjte tec jnpbcncgtdtj`g

    `f tec ndgkdt`ry h`npbjdghc tcstjgi. [ec tcsts sedbb oc kcsjigck t` kctcrnjgc wectecr tec

    Kcfcgkdgts drc pr`vjkjgi cqudb trcdtncgt dgk dhhcss t` Dfrjhdg Dncrjhdg dgk Dsjdg pdtr`gs dt

    Mugi Fu Xdb``gs.

    ?4. [ec tcst pr`hckurcs sedbb oc kcvcb`pck, dgk tec tcsts h`gkuhtck, oy dg

    jgkcpcgkcgt h`npdgy `r `ridgjzdtj`g (‒[cstjgi H`gtrdht`r„), prc-dppr`vck oy tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs,

    wjte cxpcrtjsc jg h`gkuhtjgi pdjrck tcstjgi f`r p`tcgtjdb hjvjb rjiets vj`bdtj`gs, jghbukjgi puobjh

    dhh`nn`kdtj`gs, dgk js we`bby jgkcpcgkcgt `f tec Kcfcgkdgts.

    ??. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb cgtcr jgt` d h`gtrdht wjte tec [cstjgi H`gtrdht`r tedt js

    h`gsjstcgt wjte tec tcrns `f tejs Kchrcc wjtejg 4?1 kdys dftcr tec cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc.

    ?8. [cst pr`hckurcs kcvcb`pck oy tec [cstjgi H`gtrdht`r sedbb oc suonjttck t` tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs f`r dppr`vdb prj`r t` tec ocijggjgi `f tec tcstjgi pr`irdn.  Xe`ubk dppr`vdb g`t oc

    rchcjvck, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb edvc dg dkkjtj`gdb 61 kdys t` suonjt rcvjsck tcstjgi pr`hckurcs.

    ?;. Dt g` tjnc sedbb dgy ̀ wgcr, pdrtgcr, cnpb`ycc, `r dicgt `f dgy Mugi Fu Xdb``g oc

     pr`vjkck wjte dgy jgf`rndtj`g h`ghcrgjgi tec b`hdtj`g, pr`hckurc, `r tcst pbdg prj`r t` tec

    h`npbctj`g `f tec tcst. Dt g` tjnc sedbb tec [cstjgi H`gtrdht`r kjshb`sc t` dgy `wgcr, pdrtgcr,

    cnpb`ycc, `r dicgt `f tec Kcfcgkdgts tec jkcgtjtjcs `f jgkjvjkudb tcstcrs, `r dgy jgf`rndtj`g tedt

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    15/25

    :

    w`ubk rcvcdb tec jkcgtjtjcs `f jgkjvjkudb tcstcrs= tejs pr`vjsj`g cgsurcs tedt tcstcrs hdg h`gtjguc t`

     oc usck `g h`npbjdghc tcsts wjte`ut h`npr`njsjgi tec jgtcirjty `f tec tcstjgi pr`hcss. G`tejgi jg

    tejs pdrdirdpe pr`ejojts Kcfcgkdgts fr`n rcvjcwjgi tec tcst pr`hckurcs kcshrjock jg tec f`rci`jgi

     pdrdirdpes ?1-?8 f`bb`wjgi h`npbctj`g `f dbb tcsts, pr`vjkck tedt tec h`gtrdht`r h`gscgts, g`r k`cs

    jt pr`ejojt Kcfcgkdgts‚ h`ugscb fr`n rcqujrjgi kctdjbck ojbbjgi jgf`rndtj`g dgk supp`rtjgi

    k`huncgtdtj`g fr`n tec [cstjgi H`gtrdht`r f`r dgy e`urby `r tdsm-odsck w`rm, s` b`gi ds jt k`cs

    g`t rcvcdb tec jkcgtjtjcs `f tec tcstcrs, `r tec b`hdtj`g, pr`hckurc `r jgf`rndtj`g do`ut d tcst prj`r

    t` tec h`npbctj`g `f tec tcst.

    ?3. [ec rcsubts `f dbb tcsts h`gkuhtck oy tec [cstjgi H`gtrdht`r pursudgt t` tejs

    schtj`g, db`gi wjte supp`rtjgi k`huncgtdtj`g, sedbb oc rcp`rtck t` tec Kcfcgkdgts dgk t` tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs sjnubtdgc`usby wjtejg 81 kdys ̀ f tec h`ghbusj`g `f cdhe tcst. [ec [cstjgi

    H`gtrdht`r, e`wcvcr, gcck g`t rcp`rt jts rcsubts wjtejg 81 kdys jf f`bb`w-up tcstjgi js rcqujrck t`

    vcrjfy d tcstjgi rcsubt dgk prcndturc rcp`rtjgi `f cdrbjcr rcsubts w`ubk h`npr`njsc tec tcstjgi

     pr`hcss. Yecrc tcstjgi rcsubts jgkjhdtc d p`ssjobc vj`bdtj`g `f tejs Kchrcc, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb

    h`gkuht dg jgvcstjidtj`g `f tec fdhts dgk hjrhunstdghcs ugkcrbyjgi suhe h`gkuht wjtejg 81 kdys

    `f rchcjpt `f tec tcstjgi cvjkcghc. Yjtejg 43 ousjgcss kdys `f tec h`npbctj`g `f tec Kcfcgkdgts‚

    jgvcstjidtj`g, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb pr`vjkc tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs wjte d rcp`rt h`gtdjgjgi tec

    jgvcstjidtj`g rcsubts dgk tec Kcfcgkdgts‚ pbdg dgk tjnctdobc f`r jnpbcncgtdtj`g `f dppr`prjdtc

    dhtj`gs. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb jnpbcncgt tejs pbdg wjtejg 43 ousjgcss kdys ugbcss tec Sgjtck

    Xtdtcs `olchts, jg wejhe hdsc tec pdrtjcs sedbb usc tec kjsputc rcs`butj`g pr`hckurcs kcshrjock jg

     pdrdirdpes 8;‘83.

    ?6. [ec Sgjtck Xtdtcs ndy pr`vjkc tec [cstjgi H`gtrdht`r wjte dgy jgf`rndtj`g

    rchcjvck do`ut hust`ncr h`npbdjgts wjte tec cxhcptj`g `f jgf`rndtj`g tedt w`ubk spchjfjhdbby

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    16/25

    41

    jkcgtjfy tec jgkjvjkudbs ndmjgi h`npbdjgts. Xuhe jgf`rndtj`g sedbb dbs` oc kcbjvcrck t`

    Kcfcgkdgts.

    ?9. [ec Sgjtck Xtdtcs ndy dbs` h`gkuht tcstjgi `f Mugi Fu Xdb``gs f`r tec

     purp`sc `f kctcrnjgjgi wectecr tec Kcfcgkdgts drc vj`bdtjgi tec pr`vjsj`gs ̀ f [jtbc JJ `f tec

    Hjvjb _jiets Dht `f 4:6; dgk/`r tec tcrns `f tejs Kchrcc.

    VJ. _cp`rtjgi _cqujrcncgts 

    ?5. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb, g` bdtcr tedg 93 kdys dftcr tec kdtc `f cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc,

    scrvc d rcp`rt `g tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs cvjkcghjgi tecjr h`npbjdghc wjte tejs Kchrcc. [ejs rcp`rt

    sedbb jghbukc tec f`bb`wjgi<

    d. D pe`t`irdpe `f cdhe puobjh cgtrdghc t` Mugi Fu Xdb``gs hbcdrby se`wjgi

    tec sjigs rcqujrck ugkcr pdrdirdpes 4? (jghbukjgi tec h`npbdjgt bjgc

    tcbcpe`gc gunocr) dgk 43=

     o. D bjst `f dbb dkvcrtjscncgts h`vcrck oy pdrdirdpe 48, ndkc puobjh jg dgy

    ndggcr sjghc tec cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc, t`ictecr wjte rcprcscgtdtjvc

    sdnpbcs `f suhe dkvcrtjscncgts=

    h. [ec stdtcncgts sjigck pursudgt t` pdrdirdpe 44=

    k. Yrjttcg hcrtjfjhdtj`g oy tec pcrs`g `r `ridgjzdtj`g h`gkuhtjgi tec

    ckuhdtj`gdb pr`irdn pursudgt t` pdrdirdpe 41= dgk

    c. D h`py `f tec g`tjhc h`gvcyjgi tec pr`hckurcs f`r o``mjgi d prjvdtc

     pdrty `r cvcgt (Mugi Fu Xdb``g _cscrvdtj`g Dirccncgt) rcfcrcghck jg

     pdrdirdpe 4;.

    ?:. Xjx n`gtes dftcr tec rcp`rt `f h`npbjdghc kcshrjock jg pdrdirdpe ?5, dgk cvcry

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    17/25

    44

    sjx n`gtes tecrcdftcr f`r tercc ycdrs fr`n tec kdtc `f cgtry `f tejs Kchrcc,4 tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb

    scrvc up`g tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs d wrjttcg rcp`rt cvjkcghjgi h`gtjgujgi h`npbjdghc wjte tejs

    Kchrcc. [ejs rcp`rt sedbb h`gtdjg tec f`bb`wjgi jgf`rndtj`g

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    18/25

    4?

    jg tec prchckjgi sjx-n`gte pcrj`k f`r dgy rcds`g `tecr tedg tec rcds`gs

    sct f`rte jg pdrdirdpe 4;, db`gi wjte tec h`gtdht jgf`rndtj`g, jf mg`wg,

    f`r dt bcdst `gc rcprcscgtdtjvc `f tec pcrs`g `r cgtjty ndmjgi tec rcqucst

    tedt wds kcgjck=

    j. H`pjcs `f dgy dgk dbb h`npbdjgts `f kjshrjnjgdt`ry trcdtncgt

    suonjttck kurjgi tec prchckjgi sjx-n`gte pcrj`k, jghbukjgi te`sc

    suonjttck pursudgt t` pdrdirdpe 49= dgk

     l. H`pjcs `f dgy dgk dbb tcstjgi rcsubts pursudgt t` pdrdirdpe ?1 f̀ r tec

     prchckjgi sjx-n`gte pcrj`k.

    81. Dbb k`huncgts `r `tecr h`nnugjhdtj`gs rcqujrck oy tejs Kchrcc t` oc scgt t` tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs sedbb oc scgt oy fdhsjnjbc t` (?1?) 34;-4446 `r oy `vcrgjiet ndjb t`< Hejcf,

    E`usjgi dgk Hjvjb Cgf`rhcncgt Xchtj`g, Hjvjb _jiets Kjvjsj`g, Sgjtck Xtdtcs Kcpdrtncgt `f

    Lustjhc, 4511 I Xtrcct GY, Xujtc 918?, Ydsejgit`g, K.H. ?1116.

    84. [ec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb ndjgtdjg dbb rch`rks rcbdtjgi t` jnpbcncgtdtj`g `f dgk

    h`npbjdghc wjte dbb pr̀ vjsj`gs `f tejs Kchrcc. Sp`g rcqucst, tec Kcfcgkdgts sedbb pr`vjkc tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs wjte h`pjcs `f dgy rch`rks ndjgtdjgck ds rcqujrck oy tejs Kchrcc.

    VJJ. Kurdtj`g dgk Cgf`rhcncgt `f H`gscgt Kchrcc 

    8?. [ejs H`urt sedbb rctdjg lurjskjhtj`g ̀ f tejs hdsc f`r purp`scs `f cgf`rhjgi tejs

    Kchrcc, wejhe sedbb oc cffchtjvc f`r d pcrj`k `f 86 n`gtes f`bb`wjgi tec kdtc `f cgtry oy tec

    H`urt. [ec Sgjtck Xtdtcs ndy n`vc tec H`urt t` cxtcgk tec kurdtj`g `f tec Kchrcc jg tec

    jgtcrcsts `f lustjhc.

    88. Dgy tjnc bjnjts f`r pcrf`rndghc jnp`sck oy tejs Kchrcc ndy oc cxtcgkck oy

    wrjttcg dirccncgt `f tec pdrtjcs. [ec `tecr pr`vjsj`gs `f tejs Kchrcc ndy oc n`kjfjck oy wrjttcg

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    19/25

    48

    dirccncgt `f tec pdrtjcs, pr`vjkck tec pdrtjcs fjbc tec wrjttcg dirccncgt wjte tec H`urt. [ec

    dirccncgt sedbb tdmc cffcht up`g fjbjgi dgk sedbb rcndjg jg cffcht f`r tec kurdtj`g `f tec Kchrcc

    `r ugtjb suhe tjnc ds tec H`urt jgkjhdtcs ter`uie wrjttcg `rkcr tedt jt eds g`t dppr`vck tec

    n`kjfjhdtj`g.

    8;. Jf kjffcrcghcs drjsc octwccg tec pdrtjcs rcidrkjgi jgtcrprctdtj`g, jnpbcncgtdtj`g,

    `r tec Kcfcgkdgts‚ h`npbjdghc wjte tec tcrns `f tejs Kchrcc, tec pdrtjcs sedbb cgkcdv`r t` rcs`bvc

    suhe kjffcrcghcs dn`gi tecnscbvcs ocf`rc sccmjgi tec jgtcrvcgtj`g `f tec H`urt.

    83. Jg tec cvcgt `f d fdjburc oy dgy `f tec Kcfcgkdgts t` pcrf`rn jg d tjncby ndggcr

    dgy dht rcqujrck oy tejs Kchrcc `r `tecrwjsc t` dht jg h`gf`rndghc wjte dgy pr`vjsj`g tecrc`f,

    dgk jf tec v`bugtdry kjsputc rcs`butj`g pr`hckurc kcshrjock jg pdrdirdpe 8; js ugsuhhcssfub, tec

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs ndy n`vc tejs H`urt t` jnp`sc dgy rcncky dute`rjzck oy bdw `r cqujty, jghbukjgi

     out g`t bjnjtck t` dg `rkcr rcqujrjgi pcrf̀ rndghc `f suhe dht `r kccnjgi suhe dht t` edvc occg

     pcrf`rnck, dgk dg dwdrk `f dgy h`sts dgk dtt`rgcy‚s fccs tedt ndy edvc occg `hhdsj`gck oy tec

    vj`bdtj`g dgk/`r fdjburc t` pcrf`rn.

    VJJJ. Bjtjidtj`g H`sts 

    86. Cdhe pdrty sedbb ocdr jts `wg h`sts dgk dtt`rgcys fccs.

    JU. [crnjgdtj`g `f Bjtjidtj`g E`bk 

    89. [ec pdrtjcs dircc tedt, ds `f tec cffchtjvc kdtc `f tejs Kchrcc, bjtjidtj`g js g`t

    ‒rcds`gdoby f`rcsccdobc„ h`ghcrgjgi tec ndttcrs kcshrjock jg tec Sgjtck Xtdtcs‚ H`npbdjgt. [`

    tec cxtcgt tedt dgy `f tec pdrtjcs prcvj`usby jnpbcncgtck d bjtjidtj`g e`bk t` prcscrvc k`huncgts,

    cbchtr`gjhdbby st`rck jgf`rndtj`g, `r tejgis rcbdtck t` ndttcrs kcshrjock jg tec H`npbdjgt, tecy

    drc g` b`gicr rcqujrck t` ndjgtdjg suhe d bjtjidtj`g e`bk. G`tejgi jg tejs pdrdirdpe rcbjcvcs dgy

     pdrty `f dgy `tecr `objidtj`g jnp`sck oy tejs Kchrcc.

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    20/25

    4;

     

    CG[C_CK [EJX KDZ @F , ?14; 

    SGJ[CK X[D[CX KJX[_JH[ LSKIC

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    21/25

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    22/25

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    23/25

     

    D[[DHENCG[ D

    J edvc rcvjcwck dgk rcdk d h`py `f tec H`gscgt Kchrcc cgtcrck jg Sgjtck Xtdtcs `f Dnc

    BBH k/o/d Mugi Fu Xdb``g, Ydsejgit`g Iuys, BBH k/o/d Mugi Fu Xdb``g, dgk Irdgkc Iuys,

    Xdb``g, G`rtecrg Kjstrjht ̀ f [cxds, Hjvjb Dhtj`g G`. . J ugkcrstdgk tec tcrns `f tedt Kch

    ugkcrstdgk tedt Fckcrdb bdw iudrdgtccs tedt g` pcrs`g ndy oc kcgjck, `g dhh`ugt `f tecjr rdhc,

    `rjijg, tec fubb usc dgk cgl`yncgt `f tec i``ks, scrvjhcs, fdhjbjtjcs, prjvjbcics, dkvdgtdics, dgk

     pbdhcs suhe ds Mugi Fu Xdb``gs. Yjte tedt ugkcrstdgkjgi, J dircc tedt, ds d h`gkjtj`g `f ny pr

    dgk/`r scrvjhcs `g ocedbf `f dgy Mugi Fu Xdb``g `r dgy `tecr pbdhc `f puobjh dhh`nn`kdtj`g `

     oy _`ute Iuys, BBH, Ydsejgit`g Iuys, BBH, `r Irdgkc Iuys, BBH, J sedbb g`t kjshrjnjgdtc j

    dhh`ugt `f rdhc, h`b`r, `r gdtj`gdb `rjijg jg tec pr`vjsj`g `f suhe i``ks dgk/`r scrvjhcs. Jf J vj`

    Kchrcc, J ugkcrstdgk tedt J ndy oc suolcht t` kjshjpbjgdry dhtj`g, up t` dgk jghbukjgi tcrnjgdtj`cnpb`yncgt. 

    J kchbdrc (`r hcrtjfy, vcrjfy `r stdtc) ugkcr pcgdbty `f pcrlury tedt tec f`rci`jgi js truc dg

    h`rrcht. 

    Xjigdturc 

    E`nc Dkkrcss 

    E`nc [cbcpe`gc Gunocr

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    24/25

     

    D[[DHENCG[ O

     G @ [ J H CMSGI FS XDB@@G JX @QCG [@ DBB NCNOC_X @F [EC

    YJ[E@S[ _CID_K [@ _DHC, H@B@_, @_ GD[J@GDB

    JF Z@S FCCB Z@S EDVC OCCG SGBDYFSBBZ KCGJCKZ@S NDZ [DBM [@ D NDGDIC_ G@Y, 

    FJBC D Y_J[[CG H@NQBDJG[, DGK/@_ HDBB<

    Mugi Fu Xdb``g H`npbdjgt Gunocr  

     GSNOC_

    @_  

    Sgjtck Xtdtcs Lustjhc Kcpdrtncgt, E`usjgi dgk Hjvjb Cgf`rhcnc

    Hjvjb _jiets Kjvjsj`g, :31 Qcggsybvdgjd Dvc. Ydsejgit`g, K.H

    4 (511) 5:6-99;8, cxt. :::4 

    Hdsc 8

  • 8/20/2019 DOJ v Kung Fu Saloon

    25/25

    D[[DHENCG[ H

    H@NQBDJG[ F@_N 

     Gdnc< Dkkrcss<

    [cbcpe`gc G`.<

    C-ndjb dkkrcss<

    Mugi Fu Xdb``g b`hdtj`g y`u vjsjtck< Kdbbds E`ust`g Dustjg

    Ycrc y`u rcfusck dknjssj`g t` tec Mugi Fu Xdb``g0

    Kdtc tedt y`u wcrc rcfusck dknjssj`g t` Mugi Fu Xdb``g<

    [jnc (`r tjnc `f kdy) tedt y`u wcrc rcfusck dknjssj`g t` Mugi Fu

    Xdb``g< _cds`g(s) ijvcg f`r wey y`u wcrc rcfusck dknjssj`g t` Mugi Fu

    Xdb``g<

     Gdnc `f tec ndgdicr `r supcrvjs`r wjte we`n y`u sp`mc, jf dgy<

    Dgytejgi cbsc do`ut tejs jghjkcgt tedt y`u w`ubk bjmc t` cxpbdjg<

    *********************************************

    [` oc fjbbck `ut oy Mugi Fu Xdb``g

     Gdnc `f ndgdicr `r supcrvjs̀ r<

    _cds`g(s) f`r rcfusjgi cgtrdghc<

    Hdsc 8