11903
11903
04820128
SHANGHAI UNIVERSITY
DOCTORAL DISSERTATION
1945-1965
20076
,
1945-1965
200706
A Dissertation Submitted to Shanghai University for the Degree of Doctor in Art Science
The Divisions, Splits and New Developments of
Shanghai Cinema Traditions (1945-1965)
The Affiliation and Tendencies of Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taiwans Cinema in the Perspectives of Institution, Personnel and Culture
Ph.DCandidateLiu Yuqing
SupervisorProf. Chen Xihe
MajorChinese Modern Culture
College of Liberal Arts, Shanghai University
June, 2007
8030
1945196580
1949
ABSTRACT
Since the 1980s, the cooperation of capital, personnel and production in cinema has become more and more frequent among the Mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan. On a mutually beneficial basisyears of political division and separation was finally broken and has now been replaced by the above-mentioned cooperation in every aspect fundpersonneland production. The thirty years gradually saw the blend and trend of regional integration. Film makers and scholars among the film circle has also reached the common understanding that Chinese film is a community by the joint efforts of the Mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan. And accordingly, the Chinese film is now named asfor political divergencethe Chinese language film.
At present, the integration of politics, economy and culture among the three regions become more and more stable, and the tripartite cooperation and production practice have become well blended as milk and water in complete harmony. As the film scholars greeting, they eventually form their research focus on Chinese language film, Rewriting the film history and Culture study. Compared with Chinese film, the so-called Chinese language film seems expanded in connotation; as a basic research category, Rewriting the film history is, effectively the logic starting point and the important final settling place, of the study and research of the discipline development; Culture study is a new worldwide cross-principal, cross-cultural approach and paradigm. If the three aspects are integrated, a more grand project is to be obtainedthe researchers are to achieve the general narration of the Chinese cinema history through adopting the of the culture study and rewrite the Chinese language film history.
Titled as The Divisions, Splits and New Developments of Shanghai Cinema Traditions (1945-1965),the present paper is actually about the affiliation and tendencies of Shanghai, Hong Kong and Taiwans cinema in the perspectives of institution, personnel and culture,It is also actually a sub-topic for the study and discussion of the Chinese cinema history. The present paper aims to study and interpret a detailed question and a specific duration of the general historywhich is like to build a genuine and sturdy brick in the Great Wall, to provide the future researchers and readers with the necessary proof and clue. Moreoverthe paper also aims to explore the spiritual source of the gradual converge of the three regions and the history and cultural reasons for the focus value of Shanghai cinema tradition in the study of the Chinese cinema history.
This dissertation can be divided into six parts. The Introduction part expounds reasons,value,and makes clear the writers position on this study and the main approaches adopted; Chapter One, The connotation and distinguishing features of Shanghai cinema tradition, analyzes the background and context which formed the tradition in three aspects institution, personnel and culture. The present paper points out that Shanghai cinemawhich characterizes as a private industry, with a personnel tradition of free employments, tends to form a dialectical polyphony of cultural conventions; Chapter Two,Shanghai cinema tradition and new Shanghais cinema, studies the changes Shanghai cinema has made since 1949 through three factors institution transformation, personnel adjustment, and thoughts rectification; Chapter Three centers on the who traveled southwardexplores the inheritance of Shanghai tradition by the Hong Kong film in every aspect institution, personnel and cultureaccording to time, and makes a deep comparison and analysis on realism which presented in both Hong Kong and Shanghai film; Chapter Four expounds the inheritance of the institution and culture of the Shanghai tradition and new changes made through the migrations from Shanghai to Taiwanor from Shanghai to Taiwan via Hong Kongwith a list of examples Propaganda film, Healthy Realistic filmthe Hui Huangmeifilm, and Qiongyao film; the writer achieves the conclusion in the last part of this paperShanghai cinema tradition has every reason to become the central value standard of the rewriting of the Chinese Cinema Historywhich characterizes as metal-cultural tradition; The common structural relations between the changes of the Shanghai cinema tradition and the several important turning of the development history of the Chinese cinema may be an important reference to the periodization of the Chinese cinema history.
The eventual aim and value of this dissertation is the very first step of the exploration of the rewriting of the Chinese Cinema History. Butas the research in a strict sense is still in its babyhood, the present conclusion could hardly be called an early conclusion.
Keywords: Shanghai Film Traditions, Institution, Personell, Culture
V
VIIABSTRACT
IX
1
1
9
15
17
18
21
24
28
29
31
33
35
38
40
41/
42
43
44
47
48
48
54
57
60
61
65
68-
73
74
85
94
95
95
96
97
100
10119371941
10619451949
113
114
120
125
127
131
136
137
142
142
143
144
145
146
146
148
151
153
164
170
174
182
183
183
188
193
197
198 1945
201 1949
206
206
211
213
214
9020
2005200520056101001210100
200442001120046/20022200112005320052
8090
2090
1949
1945194980 19491949China before 1949National CinemasChina After the Revolution, Popular Cinema in Hong Kong, Taiwanese New CinemaCinemas of The World
original work
1949205080
19451965708090194519652019491949
11911Middle Kingdom2(Republic China)319494194951898/
19204019491949194980 809080
19491945
1945
1234
1949194919491949
//
19452005019471948
190919495102030
,302030()()()()()1945
19223 /////
1928181928193150400250601930
193220
193512912121936127519367!1937
15142501330
19308193210253193019377717(14)2230
191919271929205/
1932
19341019354
/
/30
301949////
30
3040
/
/
1897
194930
1913201922319241925619252019271925175141 194930
//
102019131916319221925()
201926192630
1949
19314
202020/20 2010
101927341917191819201925192471019271930
19272017 192219241924()19406()()
1949()3()19341936
3040
filmiccinematicmoviesfilmiccinematicmovies
/cinematic/
/
1918204192279
19121916 1923
192814171932781949
30
19323078
30403040
30401950195060 3040/50
19498015519491949
1949/ 1949
/
1949
19491949195021
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
?
21
?
1948930 1949721919501101950
316
19507
1950112126
419501212846195019514629
1951
1949519514
195167
89119521 195323
19494285752762(1950)()()()
19491116()()()()()()()
19532219496195082019519195211
481949519522
195741(),,493:()()()()()()()()
1958101966197219771949196617215,,
/304019491949
194941949641231022195011111201950121955
325449130123
/1949
/
-
---123
19491949
1949
19491950
194958141949111952311013001953()()1500
5060
1
194911195231001949111619381957
2
1950
195032422195741()195368
195322()4019574()
1956()()()()60
3
5060()
4 5060
,50, 60196041196119633230,
5
195410671957104019585701958196420196321301964844019641110619671965940
6
19592501959201961330
1949/
194913002002004005005019511219522919511956
195315001300200205060
1
5019515
1958819591270,,8()
2
,
60
3
20
1957684619571961
196662178291031967116,82124122019683195167151122121012161969110132242362871970
-
1949/
1949
19491949
1949 1949
1949
/
1949
1949
1
1946
19571968
2
19461947
1954
3
19311938
4
19281930 1946
1957196782
5
19341938440
19522
1949194961955
/
501949101
19491949/
1949 1949
1944194519471948119487111/3194921508919491950
195012195134014283101819509
195145
195152049/
19515266
13195172328 88520
30 1110
1951111124112326
/19511952 1952101331953135195420103
19517231951
19471950100193119321947()1950
195637070
1959
1957
1
19491949
1956452 526
1114 17192021222326282930
121 1224
?
2
195612
19562319561221
3195738
1957515681022711
19571510
71213509
1957730
195712
1957302302302
46
19575119631964196630
19131925193719411949196719841997
19091937193719491950
1913
1937
1909715
191295
1913
19216
1922114422231017
1924
193142
1933
1935
1937
1925111219256192912
19262
193010251931
1937
20
201937
/
80
30
1937194119451949
19371941
19371941
1
/19341941
1934-1941
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940
1941
15
32
52
99
93
132
89
85
2
19371938
193719381939111941122519458
1937862519389328800
1939132194089194185
3
40
19386151938
19395
1940519416
4
19241926
20303019327
1935193819351 193619381939
1939
19451949
1945815
1945822
194611191947104111112930
19467194751019482
194619461948676349
1947120801949194819481949194919491949194919491949
1947194930
3030
19451949
194695419466194790731719471116121
19481481281819495018115724
1948110701000
1949164
19491013040
1956
1947
194811
30
19481951
1
194919491950
195013
301957
2
194919511952
1948193719481949719511952
1953Q195019821950195119521953195319561956Q19571957195819591962196519681976100
195350196019641964607080
601952110851957601967198270
194919481949195161630
195319541956
50//
1
20192419251928193419371925193712100
194619501949194920015030401950195770
195719601969235
703416070
2
19484195119531954
1956/
105060
1956196510219646201157
19643590
194919491949
50/
501951195019401950
5030//
12
1949301948
1949128 4050/
19491951131.
/303020
1949-1955
1950
19501951 1950
1951
195019511952
3019501949/
30
1950
1951
19521955601954
1953 19541955
30405050
194940304019493080 5070
10605070194980
50
1895
1896
1901
1904126
1907
1921101719191923
1922
192356
19244
192552310
192681
192712
19288
1931
19369
1937525
1941
194519241940300
1947123
1909-1937192616192719321936193727
1913 -1997161932193919461948
1909-199219382819411943194419461992
1905-19831925201928
1905-1940192719351936
20
194653129
1946
1947130
1948730
194685
19475919
19481233152817
1947
1945
35 Bell & HowellEyemo16Filmo35Houston16Houston35RCA35Bell & Howell 16Bell & Howell Bell & Howell 3516 Leica419481229
19461948
19495
1949 4
1949
1949
500
19491945/
30
1945815 831920 4 10 1947416
19471949719461949()17
19323
1947
1949102819506501502150345
195081949
50301949195019546
/30
195019521953195436
3040
30303020193219331937752030203040
195012304060
19601970
/
20304050602019491950
/3030
1
1949302030
2020
1923192171 48522 42816
192819301927192712
192814174031928410811928
1930371119311916238193231781091115121
3019327
19327193322132
3030303040
2
5070803050703050607
50195011195481955
195030195119521949195350605000
1950501955
1957193010271341958()19157934
19491949194519491962
50150195619561956
70
194951952811952
505020/
196342418693072.28402010311131963
1963196419654
506019495060
1
50
1954195411955195814
195319556050601954
19571956
19581959121963
505060
2
/
20193719311948506050
/
19351940195419631954
195519633
194419521962196119621977
,19271940195519651979
60
1963
3040
1930194819481957
200121920
30403040
1937
3060//30603040/50//
////
a form in search of a content20/303040506040//
120
19211931 123
1924
1926/
23040
3019321932
30
4020()()()()()()
3040
3
502019562016
6019651983326496070196519705221965419663196771968719701
///
20
1949
204019451949194919501980
194519491949507090
191316373030
1
50801949304030
19491986/3040//195012
19311937
2
5061951/50
19511952
3019662303030196641419616
80
1
19822440135400316140
1983401984193030 Jay Leyda195919621937
2
90
801920
1930194519101920/
203030302030
1949123
501950
195019535
/
505060
19492040
19451945
1945
--
1945
194519321281630193777813201311101192334101112
1942412194251943450194226194322194311121943512
194519414194112251945838
1945815
19451930194519301945193019451920194519451960194519621945196219451962 -19301960The Post-War World1001018961918191719301927194019411945194519521952196019611970197119801981199019912000
201945
1949
19491949
19491949194917 194919491949
1949
194919256192912194112194581949194919451949
19491945194919451949
19451949601949
Arbitrary1945194519491949194519451949
1945198080203080198060601945196520
308019451949204080 30
A
1. 200351
2. 200531
3. 200561
4. 198082
5. 200711
6. 1999101
7. 19491979200661
8. 199691
9. 19491959200291
10. 1996 121
11. 1937 1945 200081
12. 200531
13. 2005121
14. 19051949200531
15. 2005121
16. 200531
17. 19451949199871
18. 20200311
19. 200221
20. 1991
21. 200361
22. 2005121
23. 1989
24. 199391
25. 802000111
26. () 1996() 1997() 1998()2000() 2001
27. 1994
28. 200611
29. 00
30. 12000
31. 2200111
32. 194919941998 1216
33. 19976
34. 20047
35. 1988
36. 200611
37. 2005111
38. 19986
39. 198312
40.
41. 2000101
42. 2002
43. 1936
44. C 1982
45. 200331
46. 2003101
47. 200621
48. 200741
49. 200631
50. 199711
51. 200611
52. 2004101
53. 1991121
54. C1997121
55. 2005111
56. 200381
57. 2000101
58. 200661
59. 1960200691
60. 1891200511
61. 200621
62. 200711
63. 1981198219831984
64. 19862006
65. 1959200619561959
B
66. 200281
67. 200342
68. 200471
69. 193019452001121
70. /200511
71. 200091
72. W1998101
73. 200311
74. 199891
75. B200521
76. 2003101
77. 200351
78. 200461
79. 200311
80. 200261
81. 199791
82. 19452000200561
83. 200191
84. 25200561
85. 200611
86. 200531
87. 200641
88. 200432
89. 2005121
90. 2004111
91. 1999111
92. 200151
93. 60200661
94. 200411
95. 200481
96. 200441
97. 2000121
98. 200071
99. 199911
100. 2000121
101. 200481
102. SheldonHsiao-peng,TransnationalChineseCinemas:Identity,Nationhood,Gender ,University of Hawaii Press, October 1997.
103. Sarah Pink, Yingjin Zhang, Chinese National Cinema, Taylor & Francis, Inc, July2004.
104. SheldonH.H.Lu, EmilieY.Yeh, Chinese-Language Film: Historiography, Poetics, Politics, University of Hawaii Press, January2004.
105. Ying Zhu, Chinese Cinema during the Era of Reform: The Ingenuity of the System, Greenwood Publishing Group, Incorporated, August2003.
106. PoshekFu, MichaelMarme, Between Shanghai and Hong Kong: The Politics of Chinese Cinemas, Stanford University Press, October2003.
107. JeromeSilbergeld, China into Film: Frames of Reference in Contemporary Chinese Cinema, Reaktion Books, Limited, March2000.
108. XuDong Zhang, Chinese Modernism in the Era of Reforms: Cultural Fever, Avant-Garde Fiction and the New Chinese Cinema, Duke University Press, October1996.
109. Yinjing Zhang, Screening China: Critical Interventions, Cinematic Reconfigurations, and the Transnational Imaginary in Contemporary Chinese Cinema, Center for Chinese Studies Publications, March2002.
110. Nick Brown, New Chinese Cinemas: Forms, Identities, Politics, Cambridge University Press, January1994.
111. Rey Chow, Primitive Passions: Visuality, Sexuality, Ethnography, and Contemporary Chinese Cinema, Columbia University Press, February1995.
112. Chris Berry, Postsocialist Cinema in Post-Mao China: The Cultural Revolution after the Cultural Revolution, Taylor & Francis, Inc, June2004.
113. Shuqin Cui, Women through the Lens: Gender and Nation in a Century of Chinese Cinema, University of Hawaii Press, the, January2003.
114. Law Kar, Frank Bren, Hong Kong Cinema: A Cross-Cultural View, Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. October2004.
115. Yingchi Chu, Hong Kong Cinema: Coloniser, Motherland and Self, Taylor & Francis, Inc, December2002.
116. Paul Clark, Chinese Cinema: Culture and Politics since 1949, Cambridge University Press, April1988.
117. Michael Berry, Speaking in Images: Interviews with Contemporary Chinese Filmmakers, Columbia University Press, September2005.
118. Zhang Zhen, Amorous History of the Silver Screen: Shanghai Cinema, 1896-1937, University of Chicago Press, February2006.
119. Gerald Mast, Bruce F.Kawin. The Movies: A Short History, Macmillan Publishing Company,a division of Macmillan,Inc.1992.
120. Geoffrey Nowell-Smith Edited, The Oxford History of Word Cinema, Oxford University Press, 1996.
12007120073
220071
320055
42006
520065
6.2005520056
720055
820056
920055
1020056
11200512
121 4/200541
13200531
142 1200641
152004
16
171930200620069
18Spring Silkworm and the Memory of Films in 1930s China()20065
120071
220071
3/20045
420046 2005220053
520055200512
620055
72006
820062
920063
1020064
11 20064
1220064
120078
2200710
120079
2200710
3200710
1 200512
22005
3
4
530
20076
200555-9
9022002259
2007186
HYPERLINK "http://search.barnesandnoble.com/booksearch/results.asp?z=y&ath=Sheldon+H%2E+H%2E+Lu" SheldonH.H.LuEmilie YehChinese-Language Film: Historiography, Poetics, PoliticsHonolulu: University of Hawaii Press, October 2004]University of Hawaii Press, January2004
9022002259
2005132007320073
20071
Gerald Mast, The Movies: a Short Story, A Simon & Schuster Company, 1996.
Geoffrey Nowell-Smith Edited, The Oxford History of Word Cinema, Oxford University Press, 1996.
1998121623
2080
19491949
Spirit of NationNationalism
2000989
200310125126
2080
C19971289
602006237238
1987185
1913224F.R.20021
1949200342163730
11999101
1980818
131922525
1922
1922
19808133
1933511
193611
11999101
1934
198082332333
189795741897727
19351320200311199203
/19271905-20052007154
4192612
1980822
1980855
/19271905-200520071154
21945194921999101
192295
198081819
198082526
31925727
2192565
1995
1949
2004448
2004
19491979200664
1905-200520071239
19507122
1950727()()
1951520
1999477
200444445
1949111950820
1999101
17
1999101
1949-1959200292
2004449
19507122
2070- 2000101426
60
19811981198261227244
19808406
19808411
2 1999101
1950530147113219551195741116350417523
1946725,,50
1949-197920066198106
1951515194919661994101238246
195152019491966199410134
1951526
1951523
199471619491979200661195200
19511719491979200661114120
19517232819491979200661120160
1951 8819491979200661170190
1951826
19515219511110
19491979200661216
451951625
481951810
1949196619941015
1999477
1956613
19561114
19561129
1956121
1956123
1956124
1956126
1956127
1956127
19561224
19566
195623194919792006617882
19491979200661127
19577
195719
19577
2004111532
19968
200111
1913
1980810519267
Miriam HansenThe Mass Production of the Senses:Classical Cinema as Vernacular ModernismPopular Modernism/
190919131925193019334
1905-2005200711
1905-2005200711163
1996139140166167
193420200311229240
193511938
1935723
1905-200520071163
1939120062108
Yingchi Chu, Hong Kong Cinema: Colonizer, motherland and self ,RoutledgeCurzon,2003,P.20
21946
HYPERLINK "http://www.mov6.com/name/nm0000012/" \t "_blank" 1942194611
19383
1905-200520071189
20071110
6556
1946
20011112
200111255
193519351937()1954
194943
19494919451949199871135
32
2001111112
20011137
50
34
1958
199812167278
1928
1955
200621165169
2003102030
50
Leyda, Jay. Dianying: Electric Shadows, Mit, Cambridge, 1972.
198320
HYPERLINK "http://www.bookyes.cn/Search.Asp?Name=&Author=&Cbs=&Attribute=&MemberPrice1=&MemberPrice2=&CbDate_Year1=&CbDate_Month1=&CbDate_Day1=&CbDate_Year2=&CbDate_Month2=&CbDate_Day2=&Taxis=&SortId=" HYPERLINK "http://www.bookyes.cn/Search.Asp?Name=&Author=&Cbs=&Attribute=&MemberPrice1=&MemberPrice2=&CbDate_Year1=&CbDate_Month1=&CbDate_Day1=&CbDate_Year2=&CbDate_Month2=&CbDate_Day2=&Taxis=&SortId=" HYPERLINK "http://www.bookyes.cn/Search.Asp?Name=&Author=&Cbs=&Attribute=&MemberPrice1=&MemberPrice2=&CbDate_Year1=&CbDate_Month1=&CbDate_Day1=&CbDate_Year2=&CbDate_Month2=&CbDate_Day2=&Taxis=&SortId=" 199991
199762
19011127
100200661112115
1924-2005
200361131132
1924-2005
1905-2005200711231
19981216353637
19808146
19808146
193310,41937 7231938,103 HYPERLINK "http://www.hoodong.com/wiki/%E6%B2%88%E8%A5%BF%E8%8B%93" \t "_blank" 1939
1947219808146
6
193811936819384
1998121646
199812164550
20303040
1905-200520071240
1998121699
1920
19233181980845
19235122
/19271905-200520071155
19281905-20052007161
193420200311229240
3251611
19808196
19981216182183
19491959200291159164
164
1988116
Mary Farquhar and Chris Berry, Shadow Opera: Toward a New Archaeology of the Chinese Cinema, in Sheldon H. Lu and Emilie Yueh-yu Yeh,eds.,Chinese-Language Film: Historigraphy,Poetics,Politics,31.
19981216103-108
1945194950705020
19822-4401354001925
1980856
20002
198085556
2006613536
200621-3
1905-200520071427
19981216 353637
2003621
1905-200520071240
193329
19051949200536130200413942
1951826
1967529
196641
1966419
1966616
Roy Armes, Third World Film Making and the West, University of California Press, Berkeley, 1987.
Dianying (Electric Shadows): An Account of Films and the Film Audience in China, Leyda, Jay, 1972.
185186
2004144
1991121810
20048505506509
20001
100200661124
1941410
199592
HYPERLINK "http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/search-handle-url/103-2437828-1997402?%5Fencoding=UTF8&search-type=ss&index=books&field-author=Geoffrey%20Nowell-Smith" Geoffrey Nowell-Smith ed., The Oxford History of World Cinema, Oxford University Press, USA; February 1999.
10020066
199611357
3019311937730200413942
2080
2001570