Title
The prediction of physical activity levels of Hong Kongprimary six and secondary three students from theirattitudes toward physicalactivity: a partial test of Ajzen'stheory ofplanned behavior
Author(s) Hui, Shun-wing.; 許順榮.
Citation
Issue Date 2001
URL http://hdl.handle.net/10722/36489
Rights The author retains all proprietary rights, (such as patentrights) and the right to use in future works.
The prediction of physical activity levels of Hong Kong primary six and secondary
three students from their attitudes toward physical activity: A partial test of Ajzen's
Theory of Planned Behavior
Hui Shun Wing
Dissertation presented in partial-fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Master
of Science in Sports Science,The University of Hong Kong.
September,2001
• <c:s> 冷 f x
Declaration
I hereby declare that this dissertation represents my own work and that it has not been
previously submitted to this University or any other institution for any other
qualification.
(signature)
(September, 2001)
Acknowledgments
There are many people who kindly contributed their guidance, support and
encouragement to the completion of my dissertation. I deeply appreciate their
considerable time and effort.
I owe special thanks to my supervisor. Dr. K. J. Lindner. I am fortunate to have
him as a mentor. He provided invaluable ideas and constructive criticism throughout
this dissertation. Without him, this work may have never been completed.
I would also like to offer my sincere thanks to Kenneth Cheung, Terence Fong,
Eric Lam, Sam Lam, Vince Poon and my colleagues who helped me to administer and
collect the questionnaires from their students.
Abstract of thesis entitled
The prediction of physical activity levels of Hong Kong primary six and secondary
three students from their attitudes toward physical activity: A partial test of Ajzen's
Theory of Planned Behavior
submitted by
Hui Shun Wing
for the degree of Master of Science at the University of Hong Kong
September,2001
The aim of this study was to examine the utility of attitudes toward physical
activity (ATPA) for predicting the physical activity (PA) levels within the Hong Kong
primary six (P6) and secondary three (S3) students. More specifically,attitude (one of
the variables in the theory of planned behavior (TPB)) was employed to assess its
utility for predicting PA levels. Three hundred P6 and S3 students (average age range,
11 to 17 years) completed the revised Children's Attitudes Toward Physical Activity
(CATPA) inventory (Schutz,Smoll, Carre, & Mosher,1985) and a modified
Self-administered Physical Activity Checklist (SAPAC) (Sallis et al.,1996) in order to
assess their ATPA and their PA levels, respectively.
Results of multiple regression indicated that Hong Kong school children's ATPA
was a significant predictor of their PA levels. The eight subdomains of CATPA could
significantly predict PA levels of P6 and S3 students and account for 7-8% of the
variability in the measure of PA levels. In addition,the predictive power of CATPA to
PA levels for P6 students and for boys was stronger than that for S3 students and for
girls, respectively. The social growth and vertigo were two subdomains that
contributed significantly to the prediction of PA levels.
The findings of the present study revealed that attitude was a weak, but
significant predictor in the TPB. The TPB should be fully examined to test its
predictive utility in sport and exercise domains,especially in Hong Kong. In addition,
it was important to emphasize the social growth and vertigo subdomains of CATPA in
planning programs and curriculum for P6 and S3 students in order to motivate them to
participate in PA.
Table of Contents
Page
Declaration i
Acknowledgments i i
Table of Contents i i i
List of Appendices vi
List of Tables vii
Abbreviations ix
Chapter 1 Introduction
1 • 1 Motivation for the study
1.2 Purpose of the study
1.3 Hypotheses
1.4 Operational definitions
1.5 Delimitations
1.6 Limitations
1.7 Significance of the study
Chapter 2 Review of Literature
2.1 Measurement of attitudes
2.1.1 Thurstone-Chave
2.1.2 Likert
2.1.3 Semantic differential technique
2.2 Measurement of ATPA
2.2.1 The Kenyon's attitude inventory
2.2.2 The revised CATPA inventory
2.2.3 The Children's Attraction to Physical Activity (CAPA) 15
scale
2.3 Studies using the Kenyon's ATPA inventory and the revised 17
CATPA inventory
2.4 Measurement of PA 20
2.4.1 The SAPAC 23
2.4.2 Previous Day Physical Activity Recall (PDPAR) 25
2.5 Studies on the children's PA levels 26
2.5.1 Age-related trends 26
2.5.2 Gender-related trends 28
2.6 Relationship between attitude and behavior 29
2.7 Relationship between the ATPA and participation in PA 32
2.8 Overview of the TPB 35
2.9 Using attitudes to predict PA participation 3 8
2.10 Summary 44
Chapter 3 Methods and Procedures
3.1 Subjects 45
3.2 The instruments 45
3.3 Scoring 47
3.3.1 The modified SAPAC 47
3.3.2 The revised CATPA inventory 49
3.4 Dependent variables 50
3.5 Independent variables 50
3.6 Procedures 50
3.7 Data analysis 52
Chapter 4
4.1
Results
The students' ATPA 53
4.1.1 Gender differences 55
4.1.2 Grade level differences 55
4.2 The students' PA levels 56
4.2.1 Gender differences 56
4.2.2 Grade level differences 57
4 • 3 Predicting PA levels by CATPA 5 7
4.3.1 Gender differences in prediction 59
4.3.2 Grade level differences in prediction 61
4.3.3 Prediction for P6 boys and girls 63
4.3.4 Prediction for S3 boys and girls 66
4.4 Summary 68
Chapter 5 Discussion
5.1 The local students' ATPA 70
5.2 The local students' PA levels 72
5.3 The prediction of PA levels by CATPA 74
Chapter 6 Conclusions, Implications, and Recommendations
6.1 Conclusions 81
6.2 Implications 82
6.3 Recommendations 83
References 85
Appendices 114
List of Appendices
Page
Appendix 1 : Chinese version of the SAPAC and the revised CATPA inventory 114
Appendix 2 : The SAPAC (modified version) and the revised CATPA 120
inventory
Appendix 3 : The SAPAC (original version) 125
Appendix 4 : METs scoring table 127
Appendix 5 : Application letter to school principal 128
Appendix 6 : Parental consent letter 129
Appendix 7 : Instructions for the physical education teacher 130
List of Tables
Page
Table 1 : The mean and standard deviation scores of CATPA by gender and 54
grade.
Table 2 : The mean and standard deviation scores of SAPAC by gender and 56
grade.
Table 3 : Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA 58
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA.
Table 4 : Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted 59
MVPA METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA.
Table 5 : Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA 60
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for boys and girls.
Table 6 : Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted 61
MVPA METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for boys and girls.
Table 7 : Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA 62
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 and S3 students.
Table 8 : Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted 63
MVPA METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 and S3
students.
vii
Table 9 : Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA 64
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 boys and girls.
Table 10: Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted 65
MVPA METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 boys
and girls.
Table 11: Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA 67
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for S3 boys and
girls.
Table 12: Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs,and weighted 68
MVPA METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for S3 boys and
Abbreviations
Page
2. TRA
3. TPB
4. ATPA
5. CATPA
6. P6
7. S3
8. SAPAC
9. CAPA
10. MANOVA
11. CATCH
12. PACI
13. PDPAR
14. PBC
15. MET
Physical activity
Theory of reasoned action
Theory of planned behavior
Attitudes toward physical activity
Children's attitudes toward physical activity
Primary six
Secondary three
Self-administered physical activity checklist 6
Children's attraction to physical activity 15
Multivariate analysis of variance 18
Child and adolescent trial for cardiovascular 24
health
Physical activity checklist interview 24
Previous day physical activity recall 25
Perceived behavioral control 37
Multiple of the resting metabolic rate. 48
"One MET is equal to the resting
oxygen consumption of approximately
3.6 ml/kg"1/min'1" (McAxdle,Katch, &
Katch, 1991,p.l67)
16. Min of MVPA Minutes of moderate to vigorous PA 49
17. MVPA METs Physical activity MET score 49
18. Weighted MVPA METs Weighted activity MET score 49
19. SPSS Statistical packages for the social sciences 52
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Motivation for the study
Regular participation in physical activity (PA) is beneficial to health and
well-being in both adults and children (Powell, Caspersen, Koplan, & Ford, 1989;
Sallis & Patrick, 1994; U. S. Department of Health and Human Services, 1998).
Specifically,it has long been accepted that regular appropriate PA is important to
school-age children to maintain nonnal growth and development (Bar-Or, 1983;
Bar-Or & Malina, 1995) and develop lifelong PA habits (Armstrong & McMamxs,
1994; Pate, Baranowski, Dowda, & Trost,1996; Simons-Morton, Parcel,O'Hara,
Blair, & Pate, 1988; Yang, Telama,Leino,& Viikari,1999).
Unfortunately, few young people are taking advantage from the known
physiological and psychological benefits of regular exercise. Several studies have
reported that both boys and girls reduce their levels of PA strikingly as age or grade in
school increases and girls are less physically active than boys (Armstrong & Welsman,
1997; Health Education Authority, 1997; Pratt,Macera, & Blanton, 1999; Sallis &
Owen, 1999; U. S. Department of Health and Human Services,1998). Research
evidence in Hong Kong also suggests that most of the children exhibit low levels of
PA (Johns & Ha, 1999; Lindner, 1995,1998, 1999; Macfarlane,1997,1999;
McManus & Armstrong,1996; Ng,1996).
Recognizing these low levels of PA, research has focused on investigating the
determinants of PA participation in children. Although researchers have discovered a
long list of variables that affect involvement in PA (see Sallis, Prochaska, & Taylor,
2000,for a review), the study of attitudes is of high importance since it is believed that
the individuars behaviors are in accordance with them (Cooper & Croyle, 1984;
Kraus, 1995). Bentler and Speckart (1979) even indicated that attitude exerts a
significant direct effect on exercise behavior. Researchers have also pointed out that
attitude had a great impact on the study of PA behavior (Hagger,Cale,& Almond,
1997) and the study of attitudes and their relation to participation in PA has interested
sport and exercise scientists for a long time (Doganis & Theodorakis,1995).
However,the absence of a theoretical perspective was one of the major
criticisms of the study of attitudes (Smith & Biddle,1999). This descriptive approach
to the study of attitude "led researchers to question whether attitudes actually did
predict behaviors and to suggest an 'attitude-behavior discrepancy'" (Smith & Biddle,
1999,p.270).
Over the past three decades, several models have been proposed to explain the
relationship between attitudes and behavior (e.g.,the theoiy of reasoned action (TRA)
(Ajzen and Fishbein, 1980; Fishbein and Ajzen, 1975) and the theory of social
behavior (Triandis,1977)). The theory of planned behavior (TPB) (Ajzen, 1985,1988,
1991; Ajzen & Madden, 1986) is one of the models that has been found effective for
the prediction of behavior. The model received substantial attention in the area of
social psychology (Olson & Zanna,1993; Tesser & Shaffer,1990) and PA settings in
particular (Papaioannou & Theodorakis, 1996). It was chosen because of its
documented predictive validity in the exercise domain (Godin, 1993; McAuley &
Coumeya, 1993) and other behavioral domains (cf. Ajzen, 1991). Moreover,
considerable empirical evidence has supported the utility of the TPB in predicting and
explaining both the intention to exercise and actual exercise behavior (Blue, 1995;
Godin, 1993; Hausenblas, Carron & Mack, 1997).
According to Fishbein and Middlestadt (1987),understanding the variables that
influence behavior was the first step in the development of educational intervention to
modify that behavior. Understanding predictors of students' PA participation could
assist teachers and parents to find effective intervention approaches for encouraging
students to participate in PA regularly (Deng, 1998). Therefore, studies of the
predictors of students5 PA participation attract the attention of both researchers and
practitioners when seeking to motivate students to participate in regular PA (Deng,
1998). In fact, students5 attitudes toward PA (ATPA) provide valuable information
about what students think and feel about PA (Subramaniam & Silverman, 2000).
Although there has been a good deal of research examining the relationship
between children's attitudes toward PA (CATPA) and their PA behavior (e.g., Smoll,
Schutz, & Keeney,1976; Long & Haney, 1986), much of this work has yielded
inconsistent findings (Doganis & Theodorakis,1995). In order to have a better
understanding of the relationship between attitude and behavior, researchers examined
the predictive utility of all the variables in the TPB and reported that notable
differences were found in the contribution of attitude across gender (Biddle, Goudas,
& Page, 1994) and grade level (Mummery, Spence, & Hudec, 2000). In contrast,
several studies found no significant gender differences in the predictor variables in the
TPB (Van Ryn,Lytic, & Kirscht, 1996; Wankel, Mummery, Stephens, & Craig, 1994).
To date, only a few studies have been conducted in Hong Kong to investigate the
relationship between the CATPA and their PA involvement. For instance, Fung (1997)
studied the relationship between secondary one and two students' participation level
and their ATPA. However, a relative dearth of research has attempted to examine the
predictive utility of the CATPA in predicting the PA levels based on the TPB by using
primary and secondary students as subjects. Will there be any differences in
comparison with the foreign studies' findings?
h2 Purpose of the study
The present study had two main purposes. The first was to investigate the
predictive utility of attitude (one of the constructs in the TPB) in predicting PA levels
in a sample of Hong Kong primary and secondaiy students. The second was to
compare the predictive power of CATPA to PA levels between genders and grade
levels.
1.3 Hypotheses
The following hypotheses were tested at the 0.05 level of significance:
1. The eight subdomains of CATPA will significantly predict PA levels for Hong
Kong school children.
2. The predictive power of CATPA to PA levels for boys is stronger than for girls.
3. The predictive power of CATPA to PA levels for the primary six (P6) students is
stronger than for the secondary three (S3) students.
1.4 Operational definitions
Attitude: It was defined as "a mental and neural state of readiness,organized
through experience, exerting a directive or dynamic influence upon the individual's
response to all objects and situations with which it is related" (Allport, 1967,p.8). It is
“a psychological tendency that is expressed by evaluating a particular entity with
some degree of favor or disfavor" (Eagly & Chaiken, 1993,p.l). In this study, it was
measured by the Chinese version of the questioimaire (Appendix 1,Part two) which
was adapted and translated from the revised CATPA inventory (Schutz,Smoll,Carre
& Mosher, 1985) (Appendix 2,Part two).
PA: It was defined as "bodily movement produced by the contraction of skeletal
muscle that increases energy expenditure above the basal level" (U. S. Department of
Health and Human Services, 1998, p.20). The term in this study included not only
extra-curricular sports programs but also the physical activities which were
undertaken by the students during their leisure-time. However,physical activities
which are done during the physical education lessons are excluded because they are
usually planned beforehand and the lessons are mandatory for the students. It was
measured by the Chinese version of the questionnaire (Appendix 1,Part one) which
was modified and translated from the Self-administered Physical Activity Checklists
(SAPAC) (Sallis et al.,1996) (Appendix 3).
1.5 Delimitations
1. The sample was limited to 300 P6 and S3 school children.
2. The subjects were limited to boys and girls aged 11 to 17.
3. Only one self-administered questioimaire was used to examine the ATPA and the
PA level of the students.
4. Owing to the great diversity of physical activities,only 26 activities were
selected in the modified SAPAC in accordance with their popularity and
accessibility to Hong Kong school children. However, the subjects were allowed
to list up to 5 other activities in an open-ended item of the checklist.
1.6 Limitations
1. A l l the data in this study were self-reported. For example, the use of retrospective
self-reports, not objective instruments (such as direct observation or activity
monitoring) as a measure of PA levels. It was difficult to control the authenticity
of responses.
2. A convenience rather than random sample was used, which might not be
reflective of the population.
3. No inquiiy was made into factors such as the socioeconomic status and previous
experience which might affect the subjects' attitudes.
4. The ability of all the subjects to read and comprehend the statements in the
inventory could not be controlled. The statements might not be well understood
by all the respondents. The possible misunderstanding might affect the results of
the study.
5. Confirmatory factor analysis was not performed to examine whether the same
factor structure for the eight subdomains of the revised CATPA inventory is
applicable to Chinese students.
1.7 Significance of the study
Results of this study were thought to be useful in the following aspects:
It was hoped that findings from this study would provide the basis for further
investigation on a larger scale.
It was hoped that findings from this study would provide a picture for the degree
of contribution of attitude in the prediction of PA behavior in the context of the
TPB.
Understanding predictors of students' PA participation could assist teachers as
well as parents in designing PA interventions for encouraging students to get
involved in PA regularly (Deng, 1998). Teachers could also acquire the latest
information about changes in students' participation in PA by examining related
predictors (Deng, 1998). The degree of the contribution of the eight subdomains
of CATPA toward the PA participation levels is important in future curriculum
and educational planning. If the subdomains of CATPA contribute substantially to
the PA levels, physical educators should do more to develop and enhance these
subdomains for students so as to motivate them to participate in PA.
CHAPTER 2
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
For the purpose of this study,nine areas of literature were reviewed: (1)
measurement of attitudes, (2) measurement of ATPA, (3) studies using the Kenyon's
ATPA inventory and the revised CATPA inventory, (4) measurement of PA, (5) studies
on the children's PA levels, (6) relationship between attitude and behavior, (7)
relationship between the ATPA and participation in PA, (8) overview of the TPB, and
(9) using attitudes to predict PA participation.
2.1 Measurement of attitudes
Attitude, like personality trait, motivation and some other psychological
constructs, is hypothetical and inaccessible to direct observation (Ajzen, 1988). It
must be inferred from overt responses or indicators (Himmdfarb,1993). Most
common methods used to infer attitudes rely upon verbal responses to questionnaire
items (Ajzen, 1988). However, the measurement of attitudes has been characterized by
controversy and a variety of approaches. The following are some of the major attitude
scales.
2.1.1 Thurstone - Chave
In 1928,Thurstone wrote one of the earliest articles about attitude measurement
and developed one of the first popularly used formal scaling techniques of attitude
measurement (Schuessler, 1993). The Thurstone5s instrument has been used to help
students analyze their educational problems (Demmons,1993). In 1929,Thurstone
and Chave developed the methods of equal-appearing intervals for attitude
measurement (Eagly & Chaiken, 1993).
The Thurstone scale was made up of a number of independent statements of
beliefs about a particular problem. Each statement was numerically based on its
position on a continrnxm which ranges between five areas of expressed feelings: very
unfavorable, unfavorable, neutral, favorable, and very favorable (Demmons, 1993).
Subjects were asked to agree or disagree with each statement. The subject's attitude on
the problem was evaluated by checking the statements which the subject agreed with.
The score was the mean or median of the scale values of the statements that the
subject endorsed (Eagly & Chaiken, 1993).
2.1.2 Likert
In 1932,Likert developed his ‘‘method of summated ratings since he believed
that Thurstone's techniques were too cumbersome and time-consuming" (Eagly &
Chaiken, 1993, p.52). He attempted to create an attitude instrument that was a scale in
itself. Likert's method was "the first approach which measured the extent or intensity
of the subject's agreement with each item,rather than simply obtaining a "yes-no"
response" (Oskamp, 1991,p.54).
10
The Likert scale was made up of a set of belief statements concerning certain
issues. Subjects were asked to respond to the scale by marking one of the five
positions (i.e.,strongly agree, agree, undecided, disagree, or strongly disagree) (Eagly
& Chaiken, 1993). The position indicated was the score for that item. If the statement
was positively worded,the positive position mounted on higher score (e.g.,agree = 4).
Contrarily, if the statement was negatively worded,the scoring was reversed (e.g.,
agree = 2) (Demmons, 1993). The attitude score was calculated by summing up all
item scores.
2.13 Semantic differential technique
Osgood,Suci,and Tannenbaum (1957) developed the best-known multi-item
measure of attitude, the semantic differential method. "In contrast to the above
methods of constructing attitude scales, Osgood's semantic differential is actually a
scale in itself...This has the great advantage that one does not have to construct and
try out a new scale every time one wants to study a new topic” (Oskamp, 1991, p.59).
No doubt this method was the most popular way of measuring attitudes in confronting
a variety of research problems (Eagly & Chaiken, 1993).
The semantic differential consisted of a set of bipolar adjective scales such as
good-bad, harmM-beneficial, pleasant-unpleasant, desirable-undesirable, and
awful-nice (Ajzen, 1988). Each of adjective pair was placed on opposite ends of a
11
7-pomt scale, and respondents were asked to indicate their evaluation of the attitude
object by placing a mark on one of the seven positions. Responses were scored from 1
on the negative side of each scale to 7 on the positive side (Demmons, 1993). The
scoring was reversed for negative statements. Scores on individual bipolar scales were
summed or averaged to get a total attitude score for each subject (Eagly & Chaiken,
1993).
2.2 Measurement of ATPA
There are a limited number of inventories that measured ATPA. The following
inventories have been used very extensively.
2.2.1 The Kenyon's attitude inventory
Kenyon (1968a) reported that most inventories or scales did not account for all
the general characterization of PA. These scales typically focused on attitudes toward
physical education, games or sports (Kenyon, 1968a). In order to overcome this
problem, Kenyon (1968b) developed attitude scales representing each of the
dimensions of a multidimensional model for characterizing PA. The inventory
assessed six subdomains (social experience, catharsis, health and fitness, pursuit of
vertigo, aesthetic experience, and ascetic experience) of ATPA (Kenyon, 1968b). The
six subdomains of Kenyon's ATPA inventory had been shown to be internally
consistent, with Hoyt reliabilities ranged from 0.72 (for the social experience) to 0.89
12
(for the pursuit of vertigo) among 215 female and 353 male college students (Kenyon,
1968b).
Researchers have used this inventory in sport and PA settings, such as assessing
attitudes among athletic groups (Alderman, 1970),comparing attitudes between
athletes and non-athletes (Hendry & Douglass, 1975),studying factors related to
attitude change (Sidney & Shephard, 1976),and comparing ATPA of delinquent and
non-delinquent junior high school age girls (Stxaub & Felock, 1974). However, the
inventory has only been frequently used with high school and college age subjects.
Kenyon (1968a and 1968b) failed to develop an instrument for assessing CATPA.
Because of the lack of an appropriate testing instrument, attitudes of elementary
school children toward PA have not been investigated.
2.2.2 The revised CATPA inventory
Simon and Smoll (1974) adapted the Kenyon's ATPA inventory (1968b) used for
elementary school students (grade 4 to 6) and renamed it,the CATPA inventory. The
inventory measured the disposition of children toward the multidimensional construct
of PA (Patterson & Faucette, 1990a). It "closely follows the form and content of
Kenyon's scales but substantial changes in wording made this instrument appropriate
for reading competencies in grades 4 through 6” (Schutz et al., 1985,p.257). Strong
internal consistency (Hoyt reliabilities ranging from .80 to .89 and test-retest
13
reliabilities of approximately .60) was established for all subdomains (Simon & Smoll,
1974).
Wood (1979) studied the data on 1752 subjects (903 males, 840 females, ages
10-12 years) to evaluate the psychometric properties of the CATPA inventory (cited in
Schutz et al.,1985). There were four phases in Wood's analysis of this inventory: “(a)
item analysis of the discriminating power of each of the eight bipolar adjectives of the
semantic differential scales and the degree to which they are comprehended, (b)
assessment of the internal consistency of the six CATPA scales, (c) evaluation of the
need for reweighting CATPA data, and (d) examination of the factor structure of the
CATPA domains" (Schutz et al., 1985,p.257). The results showed that three pairs
(bitter-sweet, dirty-clean, steady-nervous) were deleted from the inventory since they
were not well understood by the subjects (Schutz et al.,1985).
Based upon the above results a revised instrument was developed by Carre,
Mosher, and Schutz (1980) (cited in Schutz et al., 1985). They shortened the inventory
and improved it psychometrically so that CATPA could be measured more accurately.
They tested the CATPA inventory with 1015 grade 7 students and 864 grade 11
students. Six modifications were made: (1) the semantic differential scales were
reduced from eight to five bipolar adjective pairs,(2) the 7-point scale was replaced
by a 5-point scale for each adjective pair, (3) an CI do not understand this idea,
14
response category was added to each subdomain in order to reduce ambiguity of
interpreting a midpoint response, (4) the phrase 'Taking part in' was added to the
description of each attitude subdomain so as to add an action element to the statement,
(5) the social subdomain was split into two separate dimensions since it was
hypothesized that the descriptive phrase for the original subdomain contained two
concepts for which an individual could hold different attitudinal dispositions, and (6)
the health and fitness subdomain consisted of two factors (value and enjoyment) and
should be scored separately (Schutz et al., 1985).
The two latest versions of the CATPA inventory had been developed, the first
one for children in grade 3 and the second for grades 7 and 11 (Schutz et al.,1985).
The alpha reliability coefficients for the revised CATPA inventory for grades 7 and 11
ranged from .76 (health) to .91 (aesthetic) for grade 7 subjects (n = 1038 boys and
girls), and from .77 (health) to .94 (aesthetic) for grade 11 participants (n = 857 boys
and girls) (Ostrow, 1996).
2.2.3 The Children's Attraction to Physical Activity (CAPA) scale
Brustad (1991) reported that many researchers had relied heavily upon
adult-generated theories and measures to conduct research with the youth in both sport
and exercise domains. He criticized the CATPA inventoiy which was not a
developmentally based research measure and developed the CAPA scale (Brustad,
15
1993) to measure children's interest in exercise and PA.
The content of the CAPA scale was child-generated. Open-ended discussions
were held with third and fourth grade school children to identify various dimensions
of PA that they found attractive or unattractive (Brustad, 1998). The CAPA contained
22 items and five dimensions of attraction to PA: (a) vigorous PA, (b) liking of games
and sports, (c) importance of PA,(d) peer acceptance in games and sports, and (e) fiin
of physical exertion (Brustad, 1993). Items are presented “in a structured-alternative
format, and the subjects respond to each item using a four-choice response formaf'
(Ostrow, 1996,p. 122). CAPA is "conceptually similar to CATPA in that a
multidimensional perspective is taken toward PA,and considerable individual
variability is assumed" (Brustad, 1998,p.468). The internal reliability was acceptable
(alpha value = .60) and the alpha levels for each of the five subscales on the CAPA
ranged from .62 to .78 (Brustad, 1993). Unfortunately, the CAPA was utilized to
measure only grade four to six children's interest in exercise and PA settings (Brustad,
1993,1996). Further testing among children from a broader age range was not
conducted.
Kenyon's ATPA scale (1968b) and Brustad's CAPA scale (1993) were not used
in this study for three Teasons. First, the simplified wording in the revised CATPA
inventory made the statements clearer and easier to understand and reduced the
16
possibility of ambiguous or inconsistent interpretation. Second, it was considered
more time saving and psychometrically superior (Schutz, Smoll,& Wood, 1981) while
yielding equivalent results (Schutz & Smoll, 1977) in comparison with the Kenyon's
ATPA inventory. Finally, the CAPA was designed for children in grades four to six
which was not suitable for the S3 subjects in the present study.
2.3 Studies using the Kenyon's ATPA inventory and the revised CATPA
inventory
Research that used the Kenyon's ATPA and the revised CATPA inventories
“provided sufficient evidence of construct validity" (Schutz et al., 1985,p.258). Also,
Schutz and Smoll (1977) had established the concurrent validity of the CATPA
inventory relative to the ATPA inventoiy. Both of the inventories have been used
extensively in examining gender differences in ATPA.
Alderman (1970) investigated the ATPA of 136 Canadian athletes (81 males and
55 females) by Kenyon's (1968b) inventory. Significant differences were found
between male and female subjects in subdomains of social experience, pursuit of
vertigo and aesthetic experience. The athletes showed the strongest ATPA as an
aesthetic experience but a very low or weak response toward PA as an ascetic
experience.
Another study involved fourth and fifth grade children as their subjects.
17
Patterson and Faucette (1990a) examined ATPA of 215 boys and 199 girls by using the
revised CATPA inventory (Schutz et al” 1985). Multivariate analysis of variance
(MANOVA) showed significant differences in attitudes for boys and girls on
subdomains of aesthetic and vertigo. Boys had significantly higher scores on the latter,
while girls had significantly higher scores on the former. Patterson and Faucette
(1990b) also examined CATPA in classes taught by physical education specialists
versus nonspecialists by employing the CATPA inventory (Simon & Smoll, 1974).
Discriminant function analysis showed a significant difference in the CATPA between
two groups, with the cathartic domain being the best predictor.
Birtwistle and Brodie (1991) investigated 291 (144 boys and 147 girls)
secondary and 316 (149 boys and 167 girls) primary school children's ATPA and their
perceptions of physical education. They found that girls had significantly more
positive ATPA than boys but no differences in attitudes were found between the
socio-economic levels. Results also showed that girls had significantly more positive
attitudes than boys in the aesthetic domain. Differences were also found in social
growth and vertigo scores. All subjects ranked health and fitness objectives highly,
with a similar pattern of pupils,perceptions of physical education.
Researchers have also exaxnined the relations of the CATPA inventory with overt
behavior. Smoll et al. (1976) found a highly significant relationship between CATPA
18
and PA involvement. They suggested that grade 4 to 6 children are primarily involved
in those activities for which they hold the most positive attitudes. Additionally, Schutz
et al. (1985) reported a moderate attitude-behavior relationship, "indicating that the
ATPA and CATPA inventories are at least as strong as most social-psychological
measures in accounting for attitude-behavior relationships" (p.259). Furthermore,
Theodorakis, Doganis,Bagiatis, and Gouthas (1991) utilized the CATPA - grade 3
scale (Schutz et al.,1985) to assess the efficacy of TRA in predicting exercise
behavior of 56 children (10 to 11 years old). The results indicated that this attitude
instrument, in conjunction with the TEA,satisfactorily contribute to the explanation
of exercise behavior. Finally, Schutz and Smoll (1986) conducted a longitudinal study
(2-year period of time) in examining the stability of attitudes for 132 grade 10 children.
They reported that "even in the presence of stability of both attitudes and involvement,
the strength of the attitude-behavior relationship continues to be low" (Schutz &
Smoll,1986,p. 195).
Other researchers have investigated the relationship between attitudes and
exercise adherence behavior (Dishman,Ickes,& Morgan, 1980; Long & Haney, 1986;
Shephard,Berridge, Montelpare, Daniel, & Flowers, 1987). McCready and Long
(1985) have also exaxnined the relationship between exercise adherence and the
combined effects of locus of control and ATPA by using the revised CATPA inventory
19
(Schutz et al.,1981). They found that two attitude measures (social continuation and
catharsis) were the best predictors of exercise adherence for 61 females fitness
program participants (ages 15 to 57).
Only a few studies have investigated the relationship between ATPA and PA
levels for school children by using the revised CATPA (grades 7 and 11) inventory
(Schutz et al., 1985), especially in Hong Kong. For example, Fung (1997) investigated
the relationship between CATPA and their PA participation level. He found that the
eight subdomains of CATPA contributed 22% to the secondary one and two students'
PA participation; the aesthetic and catharsis subdomains were most influential in
contributing to the students' participation level. However, he examined the
relationship between CATPA and their PA participation level, neither based on
theoretical models nor using primaiy students as the subjects.
2.4 Measurement of PA
PA is difficult to measure since it is a complex behavior. It varied daily and was
not as stable as other traditional-type behaviors (Sallis & Owen, 1999). The
assessment of PA in youth is even more problematic (Armstrong, 1991; Baranowski &
Simons-Morton, 1991; Freedson et al., 1997; Saris, 1986; Welsman & Armstrong,
1997).
There are several types of techniques that have been used to assess PA in a
20
variety of population (e.g., self-report, activity monitors, pedometers, heart rate
monitors,doubly labeled water, and indirect calorimetry) and others that have been
developed specifically for children (direct observation) (Welk, Corbin, & Dale, 2000).
Each of the measures has specific advantages and disadvantages that must be
considered when selecting an instrument. When assessing the suitability of a
measuring technique for children, some important criteria should be considered. For
example, the technique used should be socially acceptable, it should not burden the
child with cumbersome equipment and it should not influence the child's normal PA
pattern (Armstrong, 1991; Welsman & Armstrong, 1997). A number of excellent
reviews of PA assessments for children had shown the relative merits of the different
techniques (Baranowski & Simons-Morton, 1991; Baranowski et al., 1992; Pate, 1993;
Riddoch & Boreham,1995; Rowlands, Eston, & Ingledew, 1997).
Although there is currently no 'gold standard' measure of PA (Ainsworth,
Montoye, & Leon,1994),self-report measures are the most widely used method
(Freedson & Melanson, 1996; Health Education Authority, 1997; Palmer, Burwitz,
Smith,& Collins,1999; Sallis,1991; Sallis & Saelens, 2000). Self-reports are
"convenient to administer, cost-effective, unobtrusive and non-reactive when
compared to other measures" (Cale,1994,p.440). In addition, "self-report measures
may cover details of activity for the previous days, weeks,months or even years and
21
can be used to measure a variety of physical activity variables over time and from one
source" (Cale, 1994,p.440).
According to Sallis (1991),there are four major types of self-report measures: (1)
self-administered recall,where children report their own activities on a pre-printed
form; (2) interview-administered recall,where an interviewer conducts a structured
interview session with a child in a one-on-one setting; (3) diary,where the child lists
PA throughout the day on a diary form; (4) proxy reports, where the teachers or
parents report the child's activity using any of the three previously mentioned formats.
Among these four types of self-report measures, self-administered recall questionnaire
was found to be one of the most valid and practical tool for data collection (Caspersen,
1989). Sallis, Buono, Roby, Micale,and Nelson (1993) also indicated that adequate
reliability and validity were reported in PA recall for the fifth grade children.
Recently, Sallis and Saelens (2000) reviewed some PA self-reports that were
developed or had been used in 1990s and reported that the validity correlations for
self-administered recalls ranged from .07 to .88. While a number of different
approaches had been tested,several reviews (Pate, 1993; Sallis, 1991; Sallis, et al.,
1993) generally accepted that "previous-day recall instruments offer the most promise
for use with children" (Welk et al., 2000,p.66). The repeated 24-hour activity recall
had been shown to provide the most reliable and valid reports from children
22
(Baranowski et al., 1984; Sallis et al.,1993). A number of different instruments are
now available for this type of assessment (e.g.,Sallis et al., 1996; Weston,Petosa,&
Pate, 1997).
However, it must be noted that numerous limitations of self-reports had also
been discussed (Ainsworth et al., 1994). The definitions of PA variables and the
human cognitive process (ability to recall) were two main sources of errors in
accurately measuring PA (Baranowski, 1988). Numerous concerns arose with
self-report questionnaires or activity checklists including inaccurate recall of activity
and the inability to capture all types of PA for children (Freedson et al.,1997).
Self-reports were also susceptible to several sources of bias. For example, “social
desirability bias can lead to over-reporting of PA (Wamecke, Johnson, Chavez,
Sudman, O'Rourke, Lacey,& Horm,1997). Recalling PA is a highly complex
cognitive task (Baranowski, 1988),and instruments vary in their cognitive demands,,
(cited in Welk, et al., 2000,p.59). Nevertheless, a number of investigators had found
self-report of exercise behavior to be both reliable and valid (Blair et al., 1985; Godin
& Shephard, 1986).
2.4.1 The SAPAC
The SAPAC is a 1-day self-report recall using checklist format (Sallis et al”
1996). The original checklist "required children to report minutes during previous day
23
they spent in 21 common physical activities that represented a range of intensities,
plus sedentary pursuits" (Sallis et al.,1996,p.840) (Appendix 3). It was developed to
measure PA outcomes in the Child and Adolescent Trial for Cardiovascular Health
(CATCH) multicenter school-based health promotion intervention study for fifth grade
children. The subjects reported the minutes they spent in each activity during three
segments of the previous day: before school,during school,and after school (Sallis et
al.,1996). The SAPAC provided information about three dimensions of PA: type,
intensity, and duration.
The intraclass correlations between the SAPAC and Physical Activity Checklist
Interview (PACI) demonstrated substantial similarity with coefficients ranging
from .64 (minutes of moderate to vigorous PA) to .79 (number of activities) (Sallis et
al., 1996). This result was within the range of test-retest reliabilities for other PA
self-report instruments (Sallis et al., 1996). To validate the recalls, heart rate
monitoring and Caltrac accelerometer were used. SAPAC was moderately and
significantly related with the two objective measures in both boys and girls. The
observed correlation between the SAPAC and Caltrac accelerometer and heart rate
monitoring was .30 and ,60, respectively. The heart rate correlations, ranging from .50
to .60,were higher than those in other published PA self-reports of fifth-grade children
(Sallis et a l , 1996). They concluded that SAPAC was more cost-effective in
24
comparison with the PACI (administered by interview) and received moderate support
for validity in all gender and ethnic subgroups.
2.4.2 Previous Day Physical Activity Recall (PDPAR)
The PDPAR is an instrument for measurement of PA in grades 7 to 12 students.
It is a self-report questionnaire that "required recall of the previous day's activities for
the after school hours (3:00 - 11:30pm) and their relative intensities" (Weston et al,
1997,p. 138). The instrument is divided into seventeen 30-inin intervals and used
contextual cues to improve the quality of the data recorded (Weston et al., 1997). The
instrument provides a numbered list of activities grouped into the following categories:
"eating, sleeping, bathing, transportation, work/school, spare time, play recreation,
and exercise/workout" (Weston et al., 1997,p.138).
The subjects are required to complete the activity mode portion by recording the
code number corresponding to the activity in which they were participated in during
the specific 30-min period. Then they rate the intensity levels (very light,light,and
hard) for the reported activity (Weston et al.,1997). The correlation between the
PDPAR and pedometer and Caltrac accelerometer was .88 and .77, respectively. The
test-retest reliability correlation coefficient for the PDPAR administered twice in one
hour was .98 (Weston et al., 1997). However, Trost, Ward, McGraw and Pate (1999)
reported that the PDPAR did not appear to provide useful estimates of moderate PA in
25
fifth-grade children.
The SAPAC was utilized in this study because it provided moderate validity for
all gender and ethnic groups. Moreover, SAPAC provided a fiill picture in quantifying
a whole day of PA behavior rather than the after-school (8.5 hours) period by PDPAR.
2.5 Studies on the children's PA levels
Due to the variation in definition of activity levels and methodology for
estimating PA levels, it is difficult to inteipret and compare the studies on children's
PA levels. But it is possible to examine a remarkably consistent age and gender-related
trends within and across studies (Armstrong & Welsman,1997; Pate, Long, & Heath,
1994).
2.5.1 Age-related trends
Increasing numbers of boys,and even more girls begin to drop out of active play
and participation in PA during adolescence (Armstrong & McManus,1994; Butcher,
1985; Fox, 1994; Rowland, 1990; Zakarian, Hovell, Hofstetter, Sallis, & Keating,
1994). Sallis (1993) had reviewed nine studies and reported that PA levels declined at
a rate of about 2.7% per year for boys and 7.4% per year for girls during school-age
years. Overall, there appeared to be a 50% decrease of PA between 6-16 year olds
(Rowland,1990). The total activity time gradually decreased from the ages of 11-13
till 17-18 for both girls and boys (Verschuur & Kemper, 1985). Researchers also found
26
that age was significantly and negatively correlated with the % time spent in moderate
and vigorous activity (Welsman & Armstrong, 2000)
Telama, Laakso, and Yang (1994) conducted a longitudinal study in Finland and
concluded that PA had its peak at the age of 12,after which age it was reduced
considerably. They also reported that PA during youth was a significant but weak
predictor of the PA that takes place 9 years later. The best predictors were the school
grade for physical education and participation in organized sports.
Riddoch and Boreham (1995) suggested that a young child's natural state of
activity might gradually deteriorate during adolescence,as children were habituated
into a sedentary lifestyle. They pointed out that young people spent much of their time
indoor at school and at home (doing homework, watching television,playing on
computers, etc.) and that this sedentary lifestyle might become the norm as they got
older.
In Hong Kong, the effect of age on PA participation has also been reported.
Research showed that PA participation declined with increasing age from 24.5%
(11-13 year group) and 26.2% (14-15 year group) to 20.7% (16 or above year group)
(Ng, 1984,cited in Speak,Lindner, & Li, 1994). Lindner (1998) also examined the
rates and frequencies of sport participation between age and gender for Hong Kong
school children. The result indicated that “boys were slightly below the frequencies in
27
western countries and showed little decline over age levels, whereas the girls had quite
low participation frequencies and a sharp decline with age" (Lindner, 1998,p.27).
2.5.2 Gender-related trends
Gender differences in PA levels have been reported in numerous studies. Several
reports have shown a decline in adolescent PA of both females and males (Blair et al”
1985; Stephens,Jacobs, & White, 1985; Sallis,1993; Verschuur & Kemper, 1985). It
has been reported girls decrease their PA levels more than boys during adolescence
(Lindner, 1998; Ng,1984,cited in Speak, Lindner,& Li, 1994; Verschuur & Kemper,
1985). The decline of female participation was caused by a decreased number of hours
in physical education lesson and a drop in playing outdoors games (Verschuur &
Kemper, 1985). Klesges, Eck, Hanson, Haddock,and Klesges (1990) indicated that
society placed more of an emphasis on PA for boys than for girls which could account
for the decline in activity among females.
Males between the ages of 6 and 17 have been estimated to be 15-25% more
physically active than females of the same age (Sallis, 1993). During childhood and
adolescence both boys and girls reduce their PA as they grow older but the rate of
decline is 2.5 times greater in girls than in boys (Sallis, 1993).
Riddoch and Boreham (1995) have summarized data from large population
studies. These data indicate that PA levels peak in children aged around 13 to 14,and
28
then markedly decline. Boys are normally reported to be more active than girls,but
this difference is not significant when moderate activity alone is compared, indicating
that boys participate more often in vigorous activities than girls.
Significantly higher levels of PA in boys compared to girls in older children and
adolescents were extensively documented (Armstrong & Welsman,1997),but
observational studies have indicated no sex differences in the PA patterns of 5 to
11-year-old British school children (Sleap & Warburton, 1992). In contrast,American
studies have suggested that sex differences exist in as young as 3 to 4-year-old
children (Baranowski, Thompson, DuRant, Baranowski, & Puhl, 1993; DuRant et
al.,1993). Welsman and Armstrong (1997) found that sex differences in PA are
present in British children from 5 years old by using objective heart rate monitoring.
Armstrong, Balding, Gentle and Kirby (1990) demonstrated that boys' PA levels do
not decline significantly but girls' PA levels decrease progressively during their
secondary education. Welsman and Armstrong (1997) revealed that boys' activity
patterns are considerably higher during their initial primary education but a decline is
observed as they approach secondary education. The decline in girls' PA appears to be
a continuous trend which seems to start in the early years of primaxy education.
2.6 Relationship between attitude and behavior
Some theorists have agreed that there is a relationship between attitude and
29
behavior - behaviors reflect the attitudes (Bandura, 1986; Fishbein & Ajzen, 1975).
The expectation that attitudes enable us to predict behavior was a major reason for
being studied.
The relationship between attitudes and behavior has been the topic of
considerable debate since 1930's (Eagly & Chaiken, 1993). Virtually the only
empirical study of attitudes and behavior in this era was conducted by LaPiere (1934).
He concluded that attitudes could be easily and quantitatively measured but were
largely irrelevant to the prediction of behavior.
As time passed, there was 汪 growing sense that inconsistency between attitudes
and behavior was more common than was previously thought. The greatest challenge
to the attitude-behavior consistency was posed by Wicker's (1969) review of 47
empirical studies of the two components. He concluded that attitudes were generally
"unrelated or only slightly related to overt behaviors" (p.65) and that there was "little
evidence to support the postulated existence of stable,underlying attitudes within the
individual which influence both his verbal expressions and his actions" (p.75).
In contrast, several studies helped explain the relationship between attitude and
behavior (e.g., Bentler & Speckart,1979,1981). Kahle and Berman (1979) advocated
that attitudes exerted a significant direct effect on behavior. They reported that
attitudes had causal priority over behaviors. Bern (1972) and Kelman (1974)
30
suggested that attitudes and behavior affected each other - an attitude could shape
behavior and that behavior could build attitudes.
However, the inter-relationships between attitude and behavior are indeed
complex. Researchers suggested two major types of explanations for the apparently
widespread inconsistency between attitudes and behavior. They were "methodological
explanations, which attributed the inconsistency to poor methodology or measurement
techniques, and moderator variable explanations, which argued that the level of
consistency depends on other variables" (Kraus, 1995,p.60). The literature also
suggested that such inconsistencies might result from: (a) problems of attitude
definition and measurement (Kenyon, 1968a), (b) personal factors - such as interfering
attitudes, competing behaviors and the individual's response level (degree of apathy)
(Fishbein, 1967),and (c) situational factors - such as group pressures, societal norms
and expected rewards or consequences (Fishbein, 1967). Fishbein (1967) maintained
that the situational and personal variables might be more important in determining
behavior than the individuars attitude.
"Research efforts over the past three decades have reconfirmed the importance
of attitude as the prime theoretical construct in social psychology and they have
verified the relevance of attitude measurement as an indispensable tool for our
understanding of social behavior" (Ajzen, 1993,p.53). Numerous investigations have
31
supported the attitude-behavior link by showing that "attitudes correlate strongly with
behavior when they are assessed at the same level of generality or specificity as the
behavioral criterion in terms of action, target, context, and time elements" (Ajzen,
1996,p.385).
2.7 Relationship between the ATPA and participation in PA
It was often assumed that PA participation would be influenced by attitudes
towards,knowledge of, and beliefs about PA (Health Education Authority, 1997).
However, research findings indicated that it was not necessarily the case. For example,
ATPA was not strongly related to PA participation (Butcher, 1983; Ferguson, Yesalis,
Pomrehn, & Kirkpatrick, 1989; Smoll & Schutz,1980),accounting for less than 50%
of the variance in PA participation (Godin, & Shephard, 1986; Schutz & Smoll, 1986).
Appropriate attitudes or knowledge were weakly related with the PA behavior because
there were other factors to consider (Flora,Maibach,& Maccoby, 1989).
The research findings on attitudes and knowledge of PA have been inconsistent.
Knowledge, beliefs and attitudes about PA were reported as weak or inconsistent
correlates of PA (Garcia,Pender, Antonakos, & Ronis, 1998; Sallis et al.,1992).
Schutz and Smoll (1986) indicated that ATPA were found less stable in 10-12-year-
old children and the relationship between adolescents' attitude and PA involvement
was weak. They concluded that favorable PA attitudes did not necessarily indicate
32
active PA behavior. Similar findings were also found by Godin and Shephard (1986).
Brustad (1991) noted that a physically active lifestyle might not be developed even
though an individual possessed favorable attitudes toward, extensive knowledge about
benefits of,physical activity. Fox (1994) explained that the reason for weak
relationships between attitudes and actual PA was that PA became a choice of behavior
for adolescents and the act of decision-making was entirely personal. The perceived
and experienced beliefs, attitudes and values were used to base adolescents5 decisions
about PA.
A number of studies were conducted to determine the relationship between
ATPA and exercise participation in a wide range of age groups,from school children
(Greenockle, Lee, & Lomax,1990) to the rural elderly (Mobily et al, 1987). Smoll et
al. (1976) examined the nature and degree of the relationships among 127 boys and
137 girls in grade 4 to 6 children's ATPA, degree of primary involvement in different
physical activities and level of motor proficiency in running, jumping and throwing.
Canonical correlation analysis showed a strong linear relationship between the CATPA
domain and the involvement plus motor proficiency domain. Further analyses
indicated that the basis for the significant association was the strength of the
relationship between the CATPA and involvement.
Riddle (1980) examined the Fishbein's behavioral intention model by using the
33
beliefs,attitudes, and behavioral intentions of male and female toward regular jogging.
The subjects, 296 male and female joggers and non-exercisers, completed the
questionnaires. One way ANOVA showed that there were significant differences
between the joggers' and nonexercisers' beliefs. The result also supported the theory
upon the model based on. That is,"relationship between the intention to jog and the
jogging behavior was high (r ~ .82) and behavioral intention was predicted from an
attitudinal and a normative component alone (R = .742)" (Riddle, 1980, p.663).
However, it might be too specific to focus on the jogging only,other physical
activities should also be included. Deeter (1988) also found a positive relationship
between attitudinal commitment and the frequency and duration of high intensity
activities. The author concluded that the attitude of commitment could be used to
predict students,PA involvement even though other variables needed to be taken into
account.
Theodorakis et al. (1991) also examined the TRA to predict exercise behavior of
56 children (27 boys and 29 girls) aged 10 to 11. The CATPA (Schutz et al.,1985)
inventory and a questionnaire which was constructed using the TRA were utilized to
examine the efficacy of the instruments to predict exercise behavior of children. The
result showed that adding the subjects' past behavior as an external variable in the
analysis could increase the reasoned action model's efficacy. Also, attitude toward
34
behavior and subjective norm contributed significantly to the prediction of intention.
The beta weights for attitude toward behavior and subjective norm were .31 and .27,
respectively.
However, most of the studies mentioned above had suffered because several of
them had not based on appropriate theory. Researchers believed that predicting,
understanding and explaining PA behavior should be conducted within a theoretical
framework because it "enables us to build knowledge and understand how and why
people might be motivated or amotivated to adopt and/or maintain exercise" (Biddle
& Nigg,2000).
2.8 Overview of the TPB
Several models have been proposed to account for the relationship between
attitudes and behavior. One of these models that has been found effective is the
planned behavior model (Ajzen, 1985,1988,1991; Ajzen & Madden,1986).
Empirical research has provided evidence to support the TPB in a variety of
experimental and naturalistic settings (e.g., Ajzen & Driver, 1991,1992; Beck &
Ajzen, 1991) and shows that it has successfully predicted a variety of behaviors
(Ajzen,1988,1991,1996; Conner & Sparks, 1996; Godin & Kok,1996). The TPB
has been widely applied in behavioral domains such as students' class attendance and
academic achievement (Ajzen & Madden, 1986),dishonest actions (Beck & Ajzen,
35
1991),weight loss (Bagozzi & Kimmel, 1995; Schifter & Ajzen, 1985), sleeping,
listening to an album, taking vitamins and others (Madden, Ellen, & Ajzen, 1992).
A number of studies have also applied the TPB to sport and physical activity
settings (e.g., Gatch & Kendzierski, 1990; Godin, Valois,& Lepage,1993; Godin,
Vezina, & Leclerc, 1989; Greenockle et al.,1990; Kimiecik, 1992; Theodorakis, 1992).
[n addition, the theory is used to understand the behavioral determinants of exercise
and PA in a wide range of age groups ranging from school-aged children and
adolescents (Craig, Goldberg, & Dietz, 1996),adults (Kimiecik, 1992) to the elderly
(Coumeya, 1995). The usefulness of the theory has been both supported
(Dzewaltowski, Noble, & Shaw, 1990; Gatch & Kendzierski, 1990; Kimiecik, 1992;
Wankel et al., 1994) and refuted (Godin et al.,1993; Yordy & Lent, 1993). The theory
has been received increased attention in the sport and exercise psychology fields (e.g.,
Coumeya & McAuley, 1993; Dzewaltowski et al., 1990).
The TPB is an extension of the TRA (Ajzen & Fishbein, 1980; Fishbein & Ajzen,
1975) which "predicts volitional behavior from a person's intention to actually
perform a target behavior" (Kimiecik, 1992,p. 193). It provides details on the
determinants of an individual's decision to perform a particular behavior. These two
models were utilized “to provide parsimonious explanations of informational and
motivational influences on behavior5' (Conner & Armitage, 1998,p. 1430). Both of the
36
models imply that an individual makes behavioral decisions based on careful
consideration of available information.
In fact, the TPB is the same as the TRA but with the additional variable of
perceived behavioral control (PBC). The TPB proposes that the subject's intention is
the main determinant of behavior because “it captures certain motivational factors
such as how hard one is willing to try,’ (Coumeya, 1995,p. 81). It is a function of three
conceptually independent variables. First is a personal factor,termed attitude, focuses
on a positive or negative evaluation of the outcomes in performmg the behavior.
Second is a social one termed subjective norm. It reflects the perceived social pressure
that individuals may feel to perform or not perform the behavior. Third is PBC which
indicates the perceived ease or difficulty of performing the behavior (Coumeya, 1995).
Ajzen (1985) suggests that PBC is influenced by both internal and external factors.
Internal factors include variables such as skills, abilities, and individual differences in
willpower while external factors include “time,opportunity, and dependence on other
people,,(p.27). The notion of PBC is closely similar to Bandura's concept of
self-efficacy beliefs (Ajzen,1991; Ajzen & Madden, 1986) and to Triandis's concept
of ‘facilitating conditions' in his model of interpersonal behavior (Ajzen, 1985).
According to the TPB, PBC has both a direct effect on behavior and an indirect
effect on behavior through intentions (Ajzen, 1991; Ajzen & Madden,1986). PBC
37
may also be an immediate determinant of behavior i f the behavior is not completely
volitional (i.e., not free of practical constraints) (Ajzen, 1991; Ajzen & Madden, 1986).
The summarized proposition of TPB is that people “will intend to perform a behavior
when they evaluate it positively, believe that important others think they should
perform it, and perceive it to be under their own control,,(Coumeya & McAuley, 1995,
p.501).
The theory also specifies the determinants of the three variables mentioned
above. Attitude is determined by behavioral beliefs that refer to the perceived
advantages and disadvantages associated with the behavior. Subjective norm “is
determined by normative beliefs that center on whether specific individuals or groups
who are important to the individual think individual should perform the behavior"
(Coumeya, 1995,p.81). Finally, control beliefs underlie PBC and "focus on
opportunities and resources available for performing the behavior" (Coumeya,1995,
p.81).
2.9 Using attitudes to predict PA participation
While much earlier research was conducted to identify the factors associated
with participation in and withdrawal from physical activities, a number of relatively
recent investigations has focused mainly on the prediction of either intention to
participate or actual exercise participation (Doganis & Theodorakis, 1995). Many of
38
these studies were based on theoretical models aiming at predicting behavior from a
number of variables (Doganis & Theodorakis, 1995). It must be noted that the relative
importance of attitude, subjective norm, and PBC in the prediction of intention; and
that of intention and PBC in the prediction of behavior, were expected to vary across
behaviors and populations (Ajzen & Driver, 1992,p.210).
Researchers had claimed that attitude could not predict exercise behavior
(Dishman et al•,1980; Hale,1976). Dishman and Gettman (1980) concluded that
ATPA,as measured with the Kenyon (1968b) inventory, had little influence on actual
exercise behavior. They wrote: "...many people may believe exercise is a good thing,
but few people exercise. This discrepancy has been noted previously..., and although
a variety of reasons has been presented for its prevalence..., it may simply reflect the
inadequacy of attitude as a predictor of behavior in general" (p.306).
In contrast, Terry and O'Leary (1995) found that people's attitudes had a direct
effect on actual behavior. A number of researchers had found a direct effect of
attitudes on behavior without being mediated by intention (e.g., Manstead, Proffitt, &
Smart, 1983). As noted by Eagly and Chaiken (1993),such results possibly reflected
that an intention to perform certain behavior might not mediate between attitudes and
behavior. In other words,subjects might sometimes spontaneously act in accordance
with their attitudes (Fazio, 1990).
39
Attitude had also found to be a significant predictor of behavioral intention (e.g.,
Biddle et al., 1994; Collete,Godin, Bradet, & Gionet, 1995; Coumeya & McAuley,
1995; Dzewaltowski et al.,1990; Terry & O'Leary, 1995; Theodorakis, 1994; Wankel
et al., 1994) but the magnitude of this relationship had varied considerably across
studies.
A meta-analysis by Hausenblas et al. (1997) showed that intention had a large
effect on exercise behavior, and attitude had a large effect on intention. The effect of
attitude (the effect size: 1.22) was twice as bigger as subjective norm (the effect
size: .56). The direct effects of attitude and PBC on intention had also been well
documented (Godin, 1993,McAuley & Coumeya, 1993).
Yordy and Lent (1993) examined the utility of three theoretical models (TRA,
TPB, and social cognitive models) in predicting exercise intentions and behavior. The
sample consisted of 284 college students. Within the TPB, attitude accounted for a
veiy large portion of predictive variance (R2 change = .58),with subjective norm
adding a small but significant increment to the equation (R2 change = .01). The PBC
did not explain any further significant variance. Kemer and Grossman (1998)
investigated the efficacy of the TPB in predicting intention to exercise and amount of
exercise by using 73 members of fitness center as the subjects. The result indicated
that 26.6% of the variance of intention to exercise was contributed by both fitness
40
attitude and subjective norm. The contribution of fitness attitude (part r = .36) was
slightly greater than that of subjective norm (part r = .33).
Gatch and Kendzierski (1990) found that the PBC added significantly to the
prediction of intention to participate in an aerobics program beyond that obtained by
the two variables (attitude and subjective norm) of the TRA. The multiple correlation
of the three predictor variables with intention was .55,whereas the corresponding
value was .50 for the two original variables in the TRA. In this sample of 100 female
university students, attitude was the best single predictor of intention, followed by
PBC and subjective norm (respective regression coefficients = .30, .25,and .23).
Similar results were reported by Kimiecik (1992) in a study of 332 corporate
employees. Adding PBC to the original variables of the TRA increased the multiple
correlation from .59 to .66. Attitude was the best predictor (/3 = 65), followed by PBC
(/3=.35) and subjective norm (/3=01). Subjective norm was not significantly related
to intention in either the TRA or the TPB analysis.
In sum, the contribution of attitude and subjective norm has been shown to vary
in the prediction of intention to exercise (Gatch & Kendzierski, 1990; Wankel et al.,
1994; Yordy & Lent, 1993). The variance of intention to exercise explained by both
attitude and subjective norm has ranged from an R2 of .18 (p<.05) (Dzewaltowski et
al., 1990) to an R2 of .59 (p<.05) (Kimiecik, 1992). That is, attitude has been shown
41
to explain as little as 18% (p < .05) of the variance of intention to exercise
(Dzewaltowski et al.,1990). In contrast, Yordy and Lent (1993) and Kimiecik (1992)
showed that ATPA explained as much as 58% (pC.OOl) and 59% (pC.OOl) of the
variance of exercise, respectively.
Other studies had found that PBC contributed to the prediction of exercise
intentions over the effects of attitude and subjective norm. Dzewaltowski et al. (1990)
revealed that the more positive an individuars PBC for PA participation, the stronger
the intention to perform PA. However, PBC did not contribute to the prediction of
behavior expressed as the total energy expenditure spent over the 4-week period. Few
studies showed that the social norms contributed more strongly to predict intention
than attitude did (Greenockle et al.,1990; Theodorakis, 1992).
Ajzen (1988) indicated that variations in the relative contributions of the three
components in the TPB could be influenced by demographic variables, such as gender
or age. Wankel and Muimnery (1993) integrated TPB items into a large population
survey of over 4000 Canadians. In predicting PA intention, it was found that across the
different age and gender groups, variance in intention accounted for by attitudes,
subjective norm,and PBC ranged from 25-35%. In 狂 forther analysis of the same
survey (n = 3679),analyzing across four age groups set as 19 years and under, 20-39,
40-59,and 60 years and over, Wankel et al. (1994) showed that PBC predicted
42
intention differently across these age groups. Specifically, as age increased, PBC and
subjective norm became more important, and attitude less important.
Limited research had been conducted using the TPB to gain a better
understanding of the PA determinants in children or youth. Early research conducted
by Godin and Shephard (1986) used the TRA to study the factors that influence
exercise intention in Grade 7 and 9 participants. Results showed that measures of
attitude toward exercise and subjective norm explained 33% of the variance in
exercise intention. No differences between age or grade level were reported. Craig et
al. (1996) applied the TPB to studying the psychosocial correlates of PA in children in
Grades 5 and 8. Using the measures of attitude, subjective norm and PBC were able to
explain 30% of the variance in PA intention. Attitude, followed by PBC made the
largest contribution to the prediction. Consistent with the findings of Godin and
Shephard (1986),the measure of subjective norm failed to contribute in predicting PA
intention.
Bungum,Dowda, Weston,Trost, and Pate (2000) examined associations
between psychosocial factors and PA in grade 8 to 12 school children. Regression
models indicated that ATPA predicted moderate to vigorous activity among males but
not females, although females' ATPA were significantly more favorable than males'.
These findings were consistent with those of Trost et al. (1996),who noted several
43
important gender differences in the determinants of PA in preadolescent children.
They reported that beliefs about PA outcomes predicted PA behavior in boys but not
girls,while enjoyment of school physical education and perception of the mother's PA
(active vs. sedentary) predicted activity behavior in girls but not boys.
2.10 Summary
Although a number of studies have been conducted to assess the efficacy of the
TPB in predicting exercise or PA intention as well as behavior, there has been a
relative dearth of research in PA or exercise examining whether there are differences
across gender and grade level in the contribution of the variables in the TPB to the
participation in PA. On the other hand, it is generally accepted that attitudes have a
significant direct effect on behavior (Bentler & Speckart, 1979,1981; Kahle &
Berman, 1979; Kxaus, 1995). Thus, research into the predictive utility of the attitude
in predicting the primary and secondary school students' PA levels is still important
even after all these studies.
CHAPTERS
METHODS AND PROCEDURES
3.1 Subjects
The subjects in this study comprised 214 primary and 194 secondary school
children (206 boys and 213 girls) ranging in age from 11-15 and 13-17, respectively.
Three primary and three secondary schools were selected by convenience sampling.
These schools included five aided co-educational schools and one government
co-educational schools. One of the schools was located on Hong Kong Island and the
others were located in the New Territories.
Among the 419 subjects, 408 subjects were selected after deletions for missing
data or outliers. Moreover, 108 of the subjects were found that they had physical
education classes the day before. According to the definition of PA in Chapter One,
physical activities which were done during the physical education lessons were
excluded because they were usually planned beforehand and the lessons were
mandatory for the students. Therefore, 108 subjects were further eliminated and
finally 213 primary and 87 secondary school children's responses (149 boys and 151
girls, 11 to 17 years of age) entered the analysis.
3.2 The instruments
Two self-administered questionnaires were used in this study. The revised
45
CATPA inventory (Schutz et aL,1985) and the modified SAPAC (Sallis et al., 1996)
were employed to assess the CATPA and their PA level respectively. The alpha
reliability coefficients for the revised CATPA inventory for grades 7 and 11 ranged
from .76 (health) to .91 (aesthetic) for grade 7 subjects (n = 1038 boys and girls), and
from .77 (health) to .94 (aesthetic) for grade 11 participants (n = 857 boys and girls)
(Ostrow, 1996). The test stability coefficients also ranged from .80 to .87 over a 2-year
period of time (6-month test-retest intervals) among grades 10 and 11 students (Schutz
& Smoll, 1986). The construct validity of the seven hypothesized attitude subdomains
was supported through principal component factor analyses among the grade 7 (n =
1038 boys and girls) and grade 11 (n = 857 boys and girls) students (Ostrow, 1996).
For the SAPAC, the validity coefficient (weighted mean) was .60 and .32 in
comparison with the heart rate and Caltrac accelerometer measure, respectively (Sallis
& Saelens, 2000). The test-retest reliability ranged from .64 (minutes of moderate to
vigorous PA) to .79 (number of activities) in comparison with the PACI on the same
day (Sallis et al•,1996).
Both of the questionnaires were combined into one single questioimaire which
consisted of two parts (Appendix 2,Part one and two). The first part asked questions
related to PA participation on the previous day, such as type, duration and intensity of
specific activities. It was adapted from the SAPAC but some modifications had been
46
made to suit the design of this study. Firstly, some activities (e.g., American football)
were deleted from the list of the PA since they were uncoimnon in Hong Kong in
comparison with other activities. In return, several activities were added into the list
(e.g.,table tennis, hockey, athletics and wu shu) because these activities were more
common. As a result, the form consisted of a list of 26 physical activities and space for
listing up to five other activities. Secondly, the section for reporting television/video
viewing and video/computer game playing was deleted because that was not the aim
of this study.
The second part inquired about the subjects' ATPA. The revised CATPA
inventory was adapted from Schutz et al. (1985). Both questioimaires were translated
into Chinese and checked for accuracy and clarity through back translation by a
professional translator.
3.3 Scoring
3.3,1 The modified SAPAC
In the modified SAPAC, the subjects reported the minutes they spent in each
activity during three time periods of the previous day: before, during and after school
(Sallis et al” 1996). Four types of data were collected on this checklist: “(a) number of
activities,(b) minutes in physical activities that the subjects participated, (c) overall
volume of PA,and (d) weighted intensity of PA” (Fung, 1997,p.40).
47
The subjects were instructed to report engagement in an activity only i f they
spent 5 minutes or more “at one time". The total minutes of PA were the second
summary measure. The overall volume of PA was computed with MET values taken
from a published compendium (Ainsworth et al” 1993). “MET is a multiple of resting
metabolic rate, so MET values reflect the energy cost of activities" (Sallis et al.,1996,
p. 843).
A given child could participate in an activity vigorously or with a minimum of
exertion. The child's rating of intensity, based on symptoms of exertion (i.e., breath
hard or feel tired), might reflect individual differences in intensity. In this study,
different weighting rules were applied to activities of different intensities in order to
obtain weighted activity MET scores. "If an activity was light to moderate, heavy
breathing was not expected, so activities in the 1.1-5.9 MET range were multiplied by
1.1 if they reported being out of breath "some" of the time and by 1.25 if they reported
being out of breath “most,,of the time. For activities that were hard (i.e., 6 METs or
higher, based on the categorization of Jacobs, Ainsworth, Hartman, and Leon (1993)),
heavy breathing was expected at least some of the time. If they reported being out of
breath “most,,of the time, the MET score was multiplied by 1.25. However, if they
reported being out of breath “none,,of the time,the activity was less vigorous than
expected, and the MET value was multiplied by 0.75" (Sallis et al., 1996,p.843). A
48
METs scoring table is shown in Appendix 4.
In summary, the self-reported data were represented by the following four
variables: “(a) number of activities reported; (b) minutes of moderate to vigorous PA
(min of MVPA); (c) PA MET score (MVPA METs) (min of activity x MET value); (d)
weighted activity MET score (weighted MVPA METs) (min of activity x MET value
x intensity rating)" (Sallis et al•,1996,p.843).
3.3.2 The revised CATPA inventory
The revised CATPA inventory developed by Schutz et al. (1985) was based on
Kenyon's (1968a) multidimensional model of PA. The inventory consists of 8
subdomains: social growth, social continuation, health and fitness for value, health
and fitness for enjoyment, vertigo, catharsis, aesthetic, and ascetic (Schutz et al”
1985). Subjects are required to rate these subdomains of PA on a 5-point semantic
differential scale with five bipolar adjectives. They place a tick in the space that best
reflects the expressed attitude toward each pair. Each subdomain “is scored using a
5-point scale,with 5 always being associated with the positive adjective and 1 with
the negative adjective of the word pair" (Schutz et al” 1985,p.263). The word pairs 1,
4,and 5 were put in reverse order in comparison to word pairs 2 and 3.
The scores from 5 word pairs were added to yield a total score out of 25 for all
subdomains except health and fitness. "This subdomain is scored as health and fitness:
49
value (with a maximum score of 10,based on the word pairs good-bad and of no
use-useM), and as health and fitness: enjoyment (with a maximum score of 15, based
on the remaining three word pairs,not pleasant-pleasant, nice-awfiil, happy-sad). For
intersubdomains comparisons,these two health and fitness components should be
rescaled to a value out of 25 by multiplying the scores by 2.5 and 1.67” (Schutz et al.,
1985,p.263).
3.4 Dependent variables
The min of MVPA, MVPA METs and weighted MVPA METs were selected as
the criterion (dependent) variable to be measured.
3.5 Independent variables
The eight subdomains of CATPA acted as predictor (independent) variables.
Moreover, sex and grade level were also chosen as independent variables during the
prediction.
3.6 Procedures
Selected schools were contacted by letter to gain initial approval from the
principal (Appendix 5) and the students' parents for student participation in the study
(Appendix 6). After the initial contact, their physical education teachers were
contacted to make arrangements for the administration of the questioimaires. A
briefing of the administration procedures of the questionnaires and an instruction sheet
50
(Appendix 7) were given to the teacher concerned beforehand. Each school selected
two classes in P6 or S3 to take part in the study.
During the physical education classes, children who participated in the study
completed the questionnaires in their classrooms. Before the subjects had started Part
one, the teacher read aloud the administration instructions to the whole class
(Appendix 7). Also,the children were given a brief introductory presentation (about 5
minutes) to remind them the definition of PA and to think of all the physical activities
they did yesterday. They reported the starting and ending of the previous school day,
along with the amount of time spent in physical education class and/or recess. To
provide some guidelines for estimating time, students were asked to name events that
were longer than 5 minutes (e.g., having recess) and shorter than 5 minutes (e.g.,
watching TV commercials) by using open-ended questions (Fung, 1997). Then they
were asked to report the time they were "actually" active and excluding the time for
rest or waiting to play.
After the subjects had completed Part one,the teacher read aloud the
administration instructions and a sample page of the inventory was shown at the
overhead projector to demonstrate how to fill in the inventory in Part two. The teacher
also read the items in Part two so that the subjects did not solely rely on their own
reading skills to interpret the ideas. During the lesson, the teacher walked around the
room to check students' responses and provided further explanations when needed.
3.7 Data analysis
The completed questionnaires were checked, numbered, and coded and the data
were entered into computer files. A l l data were analyzed with the Statistical Packages
for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 8.0. Descriptive data about the CATPA and
their PA levels were shown through calculation of means and standard deviations.
MANOVA was utilized to examine whether there was any significant difference in the
eight subdomains of CATPA and the PA levels between boys and girls,P6 and S3
students, respectively. Multiple regression analyses were performed in order to
examine the contribution of eight subdomains of CATPA for predicting PA levels. The
predictive power of CATPA was also compared between boys and girls, P6 and S3
students, respectively.
52
CHAPTER 4
RESULTS
The purpose of this study was to examine the predictive power of the ATPA of
primary and secondary students to their PA levels. In addition, it was a purpose of the
study to determine whether there are any gender and/or grade differences in predicting
PA levels by the CATPA.
This chapter was divided into three sections. The subjects' ATPA data were
presented in the first section, the second section showed the subjects5 PA levels, and
the third section was devoted to the analysis of multiple regression designed to answer
the research questions related to predicting PA levels.
4.1 The students' ATPA
For the revised CATPA inventory, possible scores for each subdomain ranged
from the lowest score of 5 to the highest score of 25. Table 1 summarizes the CATPA
scores by gender and grade.
53
Table 1. The mean and standard deviation scores of CATPA by gender and grade.
Subdomains Boys Girls Primaiy 6 Secondary 3
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
Social Growth 19.97 3.30 19.50 3.61 20.33* 3.40 18.27 3.18
Social Continuation 19.75 3.53 19.34 3.57 20.07* 3.59 18.28 3.11
Health and Fitness: 22.47 3.86 21.89 3.73 22.29 3.76 21.90 3.89
Value
Health and Fitness: 20.00 4.53 19.42 4.01 20.21* 4.46 18.47 3.51
Enjoyment
Vertigo 16.38 4.62 16.46 4.02 16.52 4.70 16.18 3.23
Aesthetic 17.25 4.77 18.09 4.33 18.09* 4.94 16.63 3.31
Catharsis 19.16 4.66 18.33 4.23 19.21* 4.58 17.60 3.96
Ascetic 16.47 5.02 15.98 4.24 16.35 4.85 15.91 4.09
*p<0.05
The mean scores for eight subdomains were above the neutral score of 15 points.
The health and fitness: value subdomain had the highest mean score for boys and girls.
The ascetic subdomain had the lowest mean score for boys and girls.
Like the CATPA scores for boys and girls, the mean scores for eight subdomains
were also above the neutral score of 15 points for P6 and S3 students. The health and
54
fitness: value subdomain had the highest mean score for P6 and S3 students. The
ascetic subdomain had the lowest mean score for P6 and S3 students.
4.1.1 Gender differences
MANOVA was used to test the mean difference between the levels of the two
independent variables (gender and grade) for the eight dependent variables (the eight
subdomains of CATPA). The results showed that there was no significant difference
between boys and girls overall (Wilks Lambda = .986, F (8,289) = .500,p > .05).
4.1.2 Grade level differences
MANOVA was used to test the mean difference between the levels of the two
independent variables (gender and grade) for the eight dependent variables (the eight
subdomains of CATPA). The results showed that there was significant overall
difference between P6 and S3 students (Wilks Lambda = .897,F (8,289) — 4.131, p
< .05). Among the eight subdomains, the social growth, social continuation, health
and fitness: enjoyment, aesthetic, and catharsis subdomains scores in P6 were
significantly higher than that in S3 (Table 1). MANOVA was also used to examine the
gender and grade interaction, and a significant interaction effect was found (Wilks
Lambda = .933,F (8,289) = 2.584,/?〈.05). Both the health and fitness: value and
aesthetic subdomains scores in P6 and S3 indicated significant interactions (p<.05).
55
4.2 The students' PA levels
The SAPAC was a one-day recall questionnaire which was used to assess the
three dimensions of PA (type, intensity and duration). The subjects' participation
profile in PA is summarized in Table 2.
Table 2. The mean and standard deviation scores of SAPAC by gender and grade.
Variables Boys Girls Primary 6 Secondary 3
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
No. o f Activities 1.79 1.61 1.84 1.76 1.97* 1.79 1.44 1.34
M i n o f M V P A 67.45* 77.91 57.83 70.07 62.03 69.17 64.02 85.39
M V P A METs 378.11* 497.58 259.89 309.76 298.81 348.55 367.07 550.27
Weighted M V P A METs 392.28* 531.49 277,32 332.28 312.85 365.79 387.21 597.02
*p<0.05
On average, there was no significant difference between the boys and girls in the
number of activities that they participated.
4.2.1 Gender differences
MANOVA was utilized to test the mean difference between the levels of the two
independent variables (gender and grade) for the four dependent variables (number of
activities, min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs). The results
56
showed that there was a significant difference between boys and girls (Wilks Lambda
=.893,F (4,293) = 8.751, p<.05). The min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted
MVPA METs for boys were significantly higher than for girls.
4.2.2 Grade level differences
MANOVA was also used for testing the mean difference between the levels of
the two independent variables (gender and grade) for the four dependent variables
(number of activities, min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs). The
results showed that there was significant difference between P6 and S3 students
(Wilks Lambda = .911,F (4,293) = 7.121,/><.05). The number of activities that P6
students participated in on the previous day were significantly higher than S3 students.
When examining the gender and grade interaction, MANOVA indicated a significant
interaction effect (Wilks Lambda = .950,F (4, 293) = 3.864,尸〈.05). A l l four
dependent variables (number of activities, min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted
MVPA METs) in P6 and S3 indicated significant interactions of gender and grade
level (/?<.05).
4.3 Predicting PA levels by CATPA
Multiple regression analyses were performed to determine the contribution of
attitude components to the prediction of the PA levels. The analysis was computed by
using the min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and the total weighted MVPA METs as the
57
dependent variables and the eight subdomains of CATPA as the independent variables.
Results are shown in Table 3.
Table 3. Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs by
the eight subdomains of CATPA.
Variables D f F Sig. R R 2
Min of MVPA 8,291 3.072 .002* .279 .078
MVPA METs 8,291 2.981 .003* .275 .076
Weighted MVPA METs 8,291 2.679 .007* .262 .069
*p<0.05
The linear combination of CATPA measures was significantly related to the min
of MVPA and MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation coefficient indicated that
approximately 8% of the variance of the min of MVPA and MVPA METs in the
sample could be accounted for by the linear combination of CATPA measures. The
linear combination of CATPA measures was also significantly related to the weighted
MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation coefficient indicated that
approximately 7% of the variance of the weighted MVPA METs in the sample could
be accounted for by the linear combination of CATPA measures.
The eight subdomains were analyzed by stepwise multiple regression. In
58
predicting the min of MVPA, the MVPA METs and the weighted MVPA METs, the
social growth and vertigo subdomains had the strongest influence. Overall, only these
two subdomains were below the .05 significant level (see Table 4).
Table 4. Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA.
Subdomains Min of MVPA MVPA METs Weighted MVPA
Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig.
Social Growth .211 2.687 .008* .168 2.130 .034* .163 2.064 .040*
Vertigo .156 2.426 .016* .167 2.593 .010* .156 2.415 .016*
*p<0.05
4.3.1 Gender differences in prediction
For boys, the linear combination of CATPA measures was significantly related to
the min of MVPA and MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation coefficient
indicated that approximately 14% and 13% of the variance of the min of MVPA and
the MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear combination of
CATPA measures, respectively. The linear combination of CATPA measures was also
significantly related to the weighted MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation
59
coefficient indicated that approximately 12% of the variance of the weighted MVPA
METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear combination of CATPA
measures. However,the linear combination of CATPA measures was not significantly
related to the min of MVPA, the MVPA METs, and the weighted MVPA METs for the
girls. Table 5 shows the results for boys and girls.
Table 5. Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs by
the eight subdomains of CATPA for boys and girls.
Boys Girls
Variables df F Sig. R R2 df F Sig. R R2
Min of MVPA 8,140 2.788 .007* .371 .137 8,142 1.270 .264 .258 .067
MVPA METs 8, 140 2.630 .010* .361 .131 8, 142 1.373 .213 .268 ,072
Weighted MVPA METs 8,140 2.367 .020* .345 .119 8,142 1,321 .238 .263 .069
*p<0.05
The eight subdomains were analyzed by multiple regression. In predicting the
min of MVPA for boys,the social growth and vertigo subdomains had the strongest
influence. For the MVPA METs, the vertigo subdomain for boys also had the strongest
influence. In predicting min of MVPA and the weighted MVPA METs for girls, the
60
vertigo subdomain had the strongest influence. Overall,all of the subdomains
mentioned above were below the .05 significant level (see Table 6).
Table 6. Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for boys and girls.
Subdomains Min of MVPA MVPA METs Weighted MVPA
METs
Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig.
Boys
Social Growth .233 2.247 .026* .164 1.578 .117 .151 1.442 .151
Vertigo .182 2.072 .040* .185 2.103 .037* .171 1.928 .056
Girls
Vertigo .166 1.650 .101 .214 2.133 .035* .205 2.040 .043*
*p<0.05
4.3.2 Grade level differences in prediction
For P6 students, the linear combination of CATPA measures was significantly
related to the min of MVPA and the MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation
coefficient indicated that approximately 10% and 11% of the variance of the min of
MVPA and the MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combination of CATPA measures, respectively. The linear combination of CATPA
61
measures was also significantly related to the weighted MVPA METs. The sample
multiple correlation coefficient indicated that approximately 11% of the variance of
the weighted MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combination of CATPA measures (Table 7).
Table 7. Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs by
the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 and S3 students.
Primary 6 Secondary 3
Variables df F Sig. R R2 df F Sig. R R2
Min of MVPA 8,204 2.836 .005* .316 .100 8,78 1.937 .066 .407 .166
MVPA METs 8,204 3.103 .003* .329 .108 8,78 2.077 .048* .419 .176
Weighted MVPA METs 8,204 2.984 .003* .324 .105 8,78 2.003 .057 .413 .170
*p<0.05
However, the linear combination of CATPA measure was not significantly
related to the three dependent variables except the MVPA METs for S3 students. The
linear combination of CATPA measures was significantly related to the MVPA METs.
The sample multiple correlation coefficient indicated that approximately 18% of the
variance of the MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combination of CATPA measures (Table 7).
62
The eight subdomains were analyzed by multiple regression. In predicting the
min of MVPA, the MVPA METs and the weighted MVPA METs for P6 students, the
social growth and vertigo subdomains had the strongest influence. In predicting min
of MVPA and the weighted MVPA METs for S3 students,the catharsis subdomain had
the strongest influence. Overall, all of the subdomains mentioned above were below
the .05 significant level (see Table 8).
Table 8. Multiple regression of min of MVPA,MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 and S3 students.
Subdomains Min of MVPA MVPA METs Weighted MVPA METs
Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig.
Primary 6
Social Growth .260 2.869 .005* .265 2.938 .004* .271 3.003 .003*
Vertigo .219 2.866 .005* .250 3.283 •OOP .234 3.068 .002*
Secondary 3
Catharsis •257 1.717 .090 .326 2.191 •031* .335 2.243 .028*
*p<0.05
4.3.3 Prediction for P6 boys and girls
When dividing the subjects by grade and sex, multiple regression analyses were
63
performed again to determine the contribution of attitudes component to predict PA
levels. For P6 boys,the linear combination of CATPA measures was significantly
related to the min of MVPA and the MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation
coefficient indicated that approximately 19% and 18% of the variance of the min of
MVPA and the MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combination of CATPA measures, respectively. The linear combination of CATPA
measures was also significantly related to the weighted MVPA METs. The sample
multiple correlation coefficient indicated that approximately 17% of the variance of
the weighted MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combination of CATPA measures. However, the linear combination of CATPA
measures was not significantly related to the min of MVPA, the MVPA METs, and the
weighted MVPA METs for the P6 girls (Table 9).
Table 9. Prediction of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs by
the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 boys and girls.
Boys (Primary 6) Girls (Primary 6)
Variables df F Sig. R R2 df F Sig, R R2
Min of MVPA 8,95 2.705 .010* .431 .186 8, 100 1.007 .436 .273 .075
MVPA METS 8,95 2.535 .015* .419 .176 8, 100 1.113 .361 .286 .082
Weighted MVPA METS 8,95 2.483 .017* .416 .173 8,100 1.058 .399 .279 .078
*p<0.05
The eight subdomains were analyzed by multiple regression. In predicting the
min of MVPA for P6 boys,the social growth, social continuation, and vertigo
subdomains had the strongest influence. For the MVPA METs, the social growth
subdomain for boys had the strongest influence. For the weighted MVPA METs, the
social growth and vertigo subdomains for boys had the strongest influence. In
predicting min of MVPA and the weighted MYPA METs for P6 girls, the vertigo
subdomain had the strongest influence. Overall, all of the subdomains mentioned
above were below the .05 significant level (see Table 10).
Table 10. Multiple regression of min of MVPA,MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for P6 boys and girls.
Subdomains Min of MVPA MVPA METs Weighted MVPA METs
Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig.
Boys
Social Growth .280 2.398 .018* .270 .304 .023* .271 2.307 .023*
Social Continuation -.246 -2.172 .032* -.128 -1.126 .263 -.123 -1.079 .283
Vertigo .265 2.528 .013* .287 2.722 .008 .266 2.523 .031*
Girls
Vertigo .221 1.811 .073 .262 2.152 .034* .252 2.068 .041*
^<0.05
65
4.3.4 Prediction for S3 boys and girls
For S3 boys, the linear combination of CATPA measures was significantly
related to the min of MVPA and the MVPA METs. The sample multiple correlation
coefficient indicated that approximately 40% and 41% of the variance of the min of
MVPA and the MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combination of CATPA measures,respectively. The linear combination of CATPA
measures was also significantly related to the weighted MVPA METs. The sample
multiple correlation coefficient indicated that approximately 39% of the variance of
the weighted MVPA METs in the sample could be accounted for by the linear
combmation of CATPA measures. However, the linear combmation of CATPA
measures was not significantly related to the min of MVPA, the MVPA METs, and the
weighted MVPA METs for S3 girls (Table 11).
66
Table 11. Prediction of min. of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs by
the eight subdomains of CATPA for S3 boys and girls.
Boys (Secondary 3) Girls (Secondary 3)
Variables df F Sig. R R2 df F Sig. R
Min of MVPA 8,36 2.973 .012* .631 .398 8,33 .799 .607 .403 .162
MVPA METs 8,36 3.095 .009* .638 .408 8,33 .732 .663 .388 .151
Weighted MVPA METs 8,36 2.878 .014* .625 .390 8,33 .739 .657 .390 .152
*p<0.05
The eight subdomains were analyzed by multiple regression. In predicting the
min of MVPA for S3 boys, the social growth, health and fitness: value, and catharsis
subdomains had the strongest influence. For the MVPA METs and the weighted
MVPA METs, the health and fitness: value, and catharsis subdomain for boys had the
strongest influence. Overall,all of the subdomains mentioned above were below
the .05 significant level (see Table 12).
67
Table 12. Multiple regression of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA
METs by the eight subdomains of CATPA for S3 boys and girls.
Subdomains Min of MVPA MVPA METs Weighted MVPA
METs
Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig. Beta t-value Sig.
Boys
Social Growth .430 2.273 .029* .342 1.826 .076 .320 1.684 .101
Health and -.379 -2.272 .029* -.413 -2.495 .017* -.423 -2.52 .016*
Fitness: value
Catharsis .514 2.650 .012* .573 2.976 .005* .570 2.919 .006*
*p<0.05
4.4 Summary
In this study, there was no significant difference between the boys and girls with
respect to their ATPA but the ATPA scores of P6 students were significantly higher
than those of S3 students. Moreover,the PA levels for boys and P6 students were
significantly higher than the girls and S3 students, respectively.
The results also showed that the Hong Kong school students' PA levels were
significantly predicted by the eight subdomains of CATPA and therefore the first
hypothesis was not rejected. The social growth and vertigo subdomains had the
68
strongest influence in predicting PA levels.
When examining the prediction of PA levels by gender, the predictive power of
CATPA to PA levels for boys was significantly stronger than that for girls and hence
the second hypothesis was not rejected. Both social growth and vertigo subdomains
had contributed significantly to the prediction of children's PA levels.
When examining the prediction of PA levels by grade level, the predictive power
of CATPA to PA levels was significant for P6 students but not for S3 students and
hence the third hypothesis was not rejected. Both social growth and vertigo
subdomains had contributed significantly to the prediction of P6 students' PA levels.
Catharsis subdomain had contributed significantly to the prediction of S3 students' PA
levels.
69
CHAPTERS
DISCUSSION
Explaining PA in all its complexity is a difficult task, as is explaining any aspect
of human behavior (Sallis & Owen,1999). The primary purpose of the present study
was to investigate to what extent the students' ATPA contributes to their PA levels.
5.1 The local students5 ATPA
An examination of the CATPA mean scores for eight subdomains revealed that
both boys and girls reported positive ATPA, as reflected by scores generally above the
middle of the range of possible scores. Similar findings were obtained by Tsang and
Chan (1993),Chung and Leung (1998), and Hagger et al. (1997). Data obtained in all
these studies were encouraging to current physical educators since favorable attitudes
were believed to play an important role in motivating students to participate in PA.
The result of this study found no significant difference between boys and girls in
their ATPA. This finding also matched the results reported by Keogh (1962),Johnson
and Pargman (1987),and Hagger et al. (1997), but was contrary to the results reported
by Alderman (1970),Birtwistle and Brodie (1991),Chung and Leung (1998),
Patterson and Faucette (1990a),and Speak and Lindner (1996). However,it was
difficult to make comparisons between this study and the previous ones because these
studies used different inventories for measuring ATPA.
70
The absence of significant gender difference in CATPA might be attributed to
similar beliefs of physical activities. Attitudes are formed through beliefs (Silverman
& Subramaniam, 1999). An individual's belief is developed from his/her past
experiences and the belief developed will further lead to the development of attitudes
(Fung, 1997). Johns and Ha (1999) reported that the physical and social environment
factors in Hong Kong influence the extent and level of children's PA. Hong Kong
children have limited assess to high quality sport facilities and physical activities
outside physical education lessons (Fu, 1994; Fung, 1997). As a result, similar
attitudes were formed through their similar experiences in physical activities.
Nowadays, most of the physical activities are becoming gender-integrated in
order to provide equal opportunities for both sexes. Also,there has been a great
increase in organized programs for girls. These might contribute to the finding of
similarities between boys and girls with regard to participation attitudes. Sivan and
Roberston (1996) also found that there were some similarities in both the content and
the context of sport activities between males and females. The most popular sport
activities to both sexes were badminton, cycling, basketball and swimming.
On the other hand, there were significant differences in ATPA scores for S3 and
P6 students on the social growth,social continuation, health and fitness: enjoyment,
aesthetic, and catharsis subdomains. P6 students had a significantly higher ATPA
71
scores that corroborated findings of other studies (e.g., Chung & Leung, 1998; Fu,
1993,1994; Haladyna & Thomas, 1979; Schempp,ChefFers, & Zaichkowsky, 1983).
The significant differences in ATPA between P6 and S3 students could be explained
by the increasing emphasis on academic and career success in Hong Kong (Lindner,
1999). The S3 students might be more willing to use their time for study or other
sub-culture activities rather than for participating in PA.
As Fu (1994) pointed out, "children have an innate desire to move freely and
will take advantage of any free time in school to play" (p.73). However, “with the
onset of puberty, children are becoming more self-conscious and vulnerable to peer
pressure, especially in front of the opposite sex" (p.73-74). Therefore, the ATPA of
secondary school students was still favorable but not as much as their younger
counterparts.
5.2 The local students' PA levels
The results from MANOVA also showed that there were significant differences
between boys and girls in min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and the weighted MVPA
METs. Boys had a significantly higher duration and intensity of physical activities
than girls. This finding concurred with the findings reported by Armstrong (1989),
Armstrong et al. (1990),Armstrong, Balding, Gentle, Williams and Kirby (1990) and
Lindner (1998). It must be noted for the min of MVPA that boys and girls reported in
72
this study were less than the amounts reported in Sallis et al. (1996) study. The big
difference was due to different definitions of PA. In Sallis et al. (1996) study, physical
activities which were done in the physical education lessons were included but they
were excluded in this study. Thus a lower min of MVPA for the Hong Kong children
was expected.
For the MVPA METs and the weighted MVPA METs, the value reported for
boys and girls were also much lower than the value reported by Sallis et al. (1996).
This indicated that the local students spent lesser amounts of energy in performing
physical activities. The result of this study was supported by Macfarlane (1997) and
Wong (1997),who found that Hong Kong children possessed the lowest levels of
habitual PA in comparison with other countries. McManus and Armstrong (1996) and
Chui (1997) also reported that very few children in Hong Kong experienced those
levels of PA associated with the promotion of aerobic fitness,especially the girls in
primary school.
A significant difference in number of activities between P6 and S3 students was
also found in this study. P6 students had a significantly higher in number of activities
they participated than S3 students. However, the number of activities that reported for
P6 and S3 students were much lower than the study by Sallis et al. (1996).
Indeed, Hong Kong children had a smaller variety of physical activities to
73
choose in comparison with the children in the United States. This might be attributed
to the lack of open space or sport facilities and resources in Hong Kong. In addition,
the children in Hong Kong would like to participate in a few activities which are
promoted or advocated by mass media as well as their physical educators. This
proposition deserved further research attention.
5.3 The prediction of PA levels by CATPA
The results from multiple linear regression analysis supported the basic tenets of
Ajzen's (1988) theoretical approaches to the prediction of behavior. That is,in
accordance with Ajzen's prediction, an attitude towards the target behavior
(participation in PA) was a significant predictor in the TPB. In this study, the PA levels
of Hong Kong P6 and S3 students could be significantly predicted by the eight
subdomains of CATPA. Therefore, the first hypothesis was supported.
However, the contribution of the 8 subdomains of CATPA to the prediction of
children's PA levels was not strong. The 8 subdomains could only account for
approximately 7-8% of the variance of children's PA levels which was expressed in
terms of min of MVPA, MVPA METs, and weighted MVPA METs. In fact,it was a
rather weak predictor because the remaining 92-93% of the variance in PA
participation is still unknown. The direct measures of subjective norm and PBC were
not included in this study, the TPB was not fully operationalized in accordance with
74
the recommendations of Ajzen (1988,1991). This study showed that attitude was a
weak but significant predictor in the TPB.
There were three factors that could explain the weakness. Firstly, this study
measured CATPA and PA levels by self-report questioimaire. The social desirability
bias could influence the subjects to over-report the PA levels. Secondly,as Ajzen
(1991) stated, the TPB is open to further elaboration if further important proximal
determinants were identified. Some researchers had proposed that adding exogenous
variables to the TPB would increase its predictive ability. For example, researchers
(Chamg, Piliavin, & Callero,1988; Sparks & Shephard,1992) introduced the concept
of role identity as a mediating factor in attitude-behavior relationship. Another
variable that had been shown to enhance the attitude-behavior relationship was
attitude strength (Liska,1984; Raden, 1985). Theodorakis (1994) and Theodorakis,
Bagiatis, and Goudas (1995) noted that the variables of role identity and attitude
strength increased the predictive ability of the TPB. Thirdly,the other two variables in
the TPB, as well as facilitating factors (accessibility,availability of resources and
environmental) (Godin & Shephard, 1990) which might have influence upon the Hong
Kong children were not assessed in this study. Therefore future study is needed to
examine the predictive ability of the TPB fully.
Ajzen (1988) indicated that variations in the relative contributions of the three
75
components in the TPB could be influenced by demographic variables, such as gender.
The results of this study showed that the predictive power of CATPA to PA levels was
significant for boys but not for girls. The second hypothesis in this study was also
supported by the data.
Similar were the results from a study by Biddle et al. (1994) who reported
significant gender differences in the predictor variables for the actual and intended PA.
In their study, subjects were fiill time employees in a university campus. They found
that 11% and 2% of the variance in strenuous PA was explained for men and women,
respectively. Moreover,attitude significantly predicted strenuous PA for men but not
for women. Mummery et al. (2000) also reported that attitude was the strongest
predictor of activity intention among boys, while PBC was the largest contributor to
predict intention for girls. However, the present findings were inconsistent with some
previous researchers (e.g., Bozionelos & Bennett, 1999; Van Ryn, et al., 1996; Wankel,
et al., 1994) who found no significant gender differences in any of the predictor
variables of TPB.
The results of this study which were consistent with previous findings
(Mummery et al., 2000) also showed that the predictive power of CATPA to PA levels
for P6 students was stronger than for the S3 students. In other words, the third
hypothesis in this study was also supported.
76
Mummery et al. (2000) investigated the efficacy of the TPB in predicting PA
intentions among Canadian children (grade 3,5,8,and 11). Although they examined
the intention rather than behavior, they found that the contribution of attitude to
predicting PA intention for grade 5 subjects was significantly greater than for grade 8
and 11. Wankel and Mummery (1993) also examined the relative importance to
behavioral intention of the three direct predictors of the TPB for the various
population groups. They pointed out that "perceived behavioral control increased in
importance relative to the other two predictors across age while attitude decreased in
relative importance. Subjective norm/social support although generally the weakest
surpassed attitude as a predictor of intention in the oldest age group" (p.173). The
present findings did not match the results reported by Craig et al. (1996),who found
that the predictive power of CATPA to PA level for grade 8 students (r = Al) was
slightly stronger than for grade 5 students (r = .43).
The beta weights for social growth and vertigo were significant (p<.05) in this
study. These two subdomains contributed significantly to the prediction of the
children's PA levels. Both of the subdomains were positively related to the min of
MVPA, MVPA METs,and the weighted MVPA METs. This means that Hong Kong
school children who want to meet new people and to seek excitement tend to have a
higher degree of participation in PA.
77
When dividing the subjects by grade and sex,the predictive power of CATPA to
PA levels for boys in S3 was significantly stronger than the boys in P6. CATPA was a
large contributor to the prediction of PA levels for boys in S3 in comparison with boys
in P6. The results contradicted the findings of Mummery et al. (2000), who indicated
that attitude was the largest contributor to predicting intention for boys in grade 5
compared with grade 11. In the present study, the social growth, social continuation,
and vertigo were three subdomains which contributed significantly to the P6 boys’ PA
levels. Meanwhile,the social growth, health and fitness: value, and catharsis
subdomains contributed significantly to the S3 boys' PA levels.
The present results revealed that experience of social exchange, excitement and
personal challenge were important contributors to the prediction of children's PA
levels. Griffin (1998) suggested that sport was a primary context for social
development, especially for many youngsters. Young people “think of sport
participation as the best way to achieve popularity" (Griffin,1998, p.28). Researchers
also reported that peers played an important role in determining adotescenf s PA levels
(Anderssen & Wold, 1992; Brennan & Blealdey, 1997; Greenockle et al., 1990).
Indeed,children liked challenges and they were drawn to anything that provided fun
and excitement (Griffin,1998). For some young people, "there is little else other than
sports that offers the possibility of these kind of experiences" (Griffin, 1998,p.34).
78
The catharsis subdomain was also one of the significant predictors for S3 boys' PA
levels. Nowadays, the school children still face greater stress from the examination
and their academic performance. Participation in PA might be a good mean to release
tension.
From a theoretical perspective, the results of this study provided support for the
TPB in that attitude was a weak, but significant predictors for the exercise behavior.
According to the TPB, the direct determinant of behavior was the intention or PBC
(when actual control over the behavior is low). However, the measures of subjective
norm and PBC were not included in this study. Therefore a whole picture for the
degree of contribution of three variables in the TPB in the prediction of PA behavior
was not provided. What is needed is a long-term study using within-subjects
longitudinal designs to find out the factors which contribute to the local students' PA
levels.
From a practical perspective, although ATPA was found to relate weakly to PA
behavior, teachers and parents should not discount the importance of positive ATPA. It
was because "attitude influences whether we begin or continue with certain
activities - and whether we achieve in certain areas" (Silverman & Subramaniam,
1999,p.97). However, further investigations are needed to deterniine whether
subjective norm (the social pressure on the subject to perform or not to perform the
79
behavior) and PBC (the perception of how easy or difficult to perform a behavior) in
the TPB play key roles in predicting the children's PA levels or not. If it is true, the
professionals in the field thus seem to provide 狂 conducive situation or environment
which emphasizes these two aspects in planning the programs and curriculum.
80
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSIONS,IMPLICATIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS
6.1 Conclusions
The purpose of this study was to assess the power of CATPA to predict the PA
levels of Hong Kong primary and secondary school children under the established
theoretical framework of the TPB (Ajzen, 1985, 1988, 1991). Based on the data
collected as well as within the limitations of this study, the following conclusions were
1 • The school children in this study showed a favorable ATPA. No gender difference
was found in ATPA between boys and girls. The result could be attributed to the
similarity of experiences that they gained in PA. When dividing the subjects by
grade level attained, the P6 students' ATPA scores were significantly higher than
those of S3 students. The subjects also reported relative low PA levels in
comparison with the Western countries.
2. The results of this study showed that the eight subdomains of CATPA could
collectively significantly predict PA levels of Hong Kong school children.
However, only 7-8% of the variability in the measure of PA levels could be
explained by the eight subdomains of CATPA. Indeed,participation in PA is
determined or influenced by a variety of factors (Dishman & Dunn, 1988; Sallis
81
et al.,1992). No single determinant or category of deteiminants has been found
to be the sole explanation of young people's PA levels.
3. The predictive power of CATPA to PA levels for P6 students and for boys was
significantly higher than for S3 students and for girls, respectively. In addition,
the predictive power of CATPA for boys in S3 was significantly stranger than for
boys in P6. Generally, the social growth and vertigo were two subdomains which
contributed significantly to the prediction of school children's PA levels.
6.2 Implications
The present results revealed that the CATPA could significantly predict the PA
levels of the subjects but the eight subdomains of CATPA could account for only 7-8%
of the variance in the children's PA levels. The remaining 92-93% was still
unexplained. According to the TPB, subjective norm and PBC are two other predictor
constructs for the prediction of a person's intention to perform a behavior. These
variables might make a larger contribution to the prediction. Moreover, PA
participation in young people “is influenced by a great number of interacting
biological, psychological, social,and environmental factors" (Aimstrong & Welsman,
1997,p.257),and those factors might be important for different groups at different
periods of time (Dishman & Dunn,1988; Sallis,et al.,1992). Some researchers have
proposed that adding exogenous variables to the TPB to improve its predictive ability
82
(Conner & Axmitage, 1998; Theodorakis, 1994).
The present results also indicated that the social growth and vertigo subdomains
played key roles in the prediction of PA levels in Hong Kong school children. It is
desirable to emphasize the social growth and vertigo subdomains of CATPA in
planning programs and curriculum for P6 and S3 students. Indeed, other significant
predictors associated with PA levels for children (such as parental influence,
accessibility and availability of resources) should not be ignored.
6.3 Recommendations
A longitudinal study (using within-subjects) of students' ATPA and their PA
levels should be conducted to determine i f there is any change in attitudes and PA
levels as students' progress from primary to secondary school. Further study is needed
to find out the factors which contribute greatly to PA participation of Hong Kong
school children, especially for girls and S3 students.
Moreover, more studies should be conducted to examine the full TPB to test its
predictive ability in sport and exercise settings in the future, especially in Hong Kong.
Based on the findings of the present study, it would seem reasonable that future
investigations with the population of school children should focus on further
development of this theory and examine how well it can predict and explain PA
behavior.
83
One must consider the relative small sample size of S3 students (213 primary in
comparison with and 87 secondary school children) that may have had an impact on
the results. Moreover, subjective self-report measures may be compromised by
inaccurate recall or response biases. It would be valuable to replicate these findings
while employing objective indices of PA behavior and distributing the samples
(primary and secondary students) more equally. To increase the validity and
generalizability, more reliable methods such as random sampling should be adopted.
Based on the findings of the present study, it must be emphasized that no causal
relationship between the students' ATPA and their PA levels are warranted. If this
causal relationship was found in the future study, it would seem that enhancement of
ATPA might be more effective in promoting PA in boys and P6 students than girls and
S3 students, respectively. The high contribution for the social growth and vertigo
subdomains to the prediction of school children's PA levels implies that providing a
social environment and exciting physical activities that reinforces PA may be a
particularly effective strategy to boys and P6 students but not girls and S3 students in
order to motivate them to participate in PA.
84
REFERENCES
Ainsworth, B. E.,Haskell, W. L.,Leon, A. S.,Jacobs, D. R.,Montoye, H. J.,
Sallis, J. F.,& Paffenbarger, R. S. (1993). Compendium of physical activities:
Classification of energy costs of human physical activities. Medicine and Science in
Sports and Exercise, 25(1),71-80.
Ainsworth, B. E,5 Montoye, H. J.5 & Leon, A. S. (1994). Methods of assessing
physical activity during leisure and work. In C. Bouchard, R. J. Shephard, & T.
Stephens (Eds.),Physical activity , fitness and health: International proceedings and
consensus statement (pp. 146-159). Champaign, EL: Human Kinetics.
Ajzen, I. (1985). From intentions to actions: A theory of planned behavior. In J.
Kuhl & J. Beckman (Eds.),Action-control: From cognition to behavior (pp.11-39).
Heidlberg, Germany: Springer.
Ajzen, I. (1988). Attitudes, personality , and behavior. Milton Keynes: Open
University Press.
Ajzen, I. (1991). The theory of planned behavior. Organizational Behavior and
Human Decision Processes, 50(2), 179-211.
Ajzen, I. (1993). Attitude theory and the attitude-behavior relation. In D. Krebs,
& P. Schmidt (Eds.),New directions in attitude measurement (pp.41-57). Berlin:
Walter de Gruyter.
85
Ajzen, I (1996). The directive influence of attitudes on behavior. In R M.
Gollwitzer, & J. A . Bargh (Eds.), The psychology of action: Linking cognition and
motivation to behavior (pp.385-403). New York: Guilford Press.
Ajzen, 1., & Driver, B. L. (1991). Prediction of leisure participation from
behavioral, normative, and control beliefs: A n application of the theoiy of planned
behavior. Leisure Sciences, 73(3), 185-204.
Ajzen, I.,& Driver, B. L. (1992). Application of the theory of planned behavior
to leisure choice. Journal of Leisure Research, 24(^), 207-224.
Ajzen, I.,& Fishbein, M. (1980). Understanding attitudes and predicting social
behavior. Englewood Cliffs,NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Ajzen, L, & Madden, T. J. (1986). Prediction of goal-directed behavior: Attitudes,
intentions, and perceived behavioral control. Journal of Experimental Social
Psychology , 22(5),453-474.
Alderman, R. B. (1970). A sociopsychological assessment of attitude toward
physical activity in champion athletes. Research Quarterly, 41{\\ 1-9.
Allport, G. W. (1967). Attitudes. In M. Fishbein (Ed.),Readings in attitude
theory and measurement (pp.3-13). New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc.
Anderssen, N” & Wold,B. (1992). Parental and peer influences on leisure time
physical activity in young adolescents. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,
86
63(4), 341-348.
Armstrong, N. (1989). Children are fit but not active! Education and Health ,
7(2),28-32.
Armstrong,N. (1991). Health-related physical activity. In N. Armstrong & A.
Sparkes (Eds.), Issues in physical education (pp. 139-154). London: Cassell.
Armstrong, N.,Balding,J.,Gentle, R, & Kirby, B. (1990). Patterns of physical
activity among 11 to 16 year old British children. British Medical Journal, 301 ,
203-205.
Armstrong, N.,Balding,J” Gentle, R,Williams,J.,& Kirby, B. (1990). Peak
oxygen uptake and habitual physical activity in 11 to 16 year olds. Pediatric Exercise
Science, 2(4), 349-358.
Armstrong, N.? & McManus,A. (1994). Children's fitness and physical activity:
A challenge for physical education. The British Journal of Physical Education, -25(1),
20-26.
Armstrong,N., & Welsman, J. (1997). Young people & physical activity. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Bagozzi, R. P., & Kimmel, S. K. (1995). A comparison of leading theories for
the prediction of goal-directed behaviors. British Journal of Social Psychology, 34{A)t
437-461.
87
Bandura, A. (1986). Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive
theory. Englewood Cliffs,NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Baranowski, T. (1988). Validity and reliability of self-report measures of
physical activity: An information-processing perspective. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport , 59(4), 314-327.
Baranowski, T.,Bouchard, C.,Bar-Or, O.,Bricker,T.,Heath, G,Kimm,S. Y. S.,
Malina, R.,Obarzanek,E.,Pate, R” Strong, W. B.,Truman, B.,& Washington, R.
(1992). Assessment, prevalence, and cardiovascular benefits of physical activity and
fitness in youth. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2莩(suppl.),S237-S247.
Baranowski, T.,Dworkin, R.,Cieslik, C,Hooks, P., Clearman, D.,Ray, C.,Dunn,
J. K., & Nader, P. (1984). Reliability and validity of self report of aerobic activity:
Family health project. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 55(4), 309-317.
Baranowski, T.,& Simons-Morton, B. G. (1991). Dietary and physical activity
assessment in school-aged children: Measurement issues. Journal of School Health,
61(51 195-197.
Baranowski, T.,Thompson, W. 0., DuRant, R. H.,Baranowski, J.,& Puhl, J.
(1993). Observations on physical activity in physical locations: Age, gender, ethnicity
and month effects. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 64(2 ), 127-133.
Bar-Or, O. (1983). Pediatric sports medicine for the practitioner: From
88
physiological principles to clinical applications. New York: Springer Verlag.
Bar-Or, 0 ” & Malina,R. M. (1995). Activity, fitness, and health of children and
adolescents. In L. W. Y. Cheung, & J. B. Richmond (Eds.), Child health, nutrition, and
physical activity (pp. 79-123). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Beck, L.,& Ajzen, L (1991). Predicting dishonest actions using the theory of
planned behavior. Journal of Research in Personality , 25(3), 285-301.
Bern, D. J. (1972). Self-perception theory. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.),Advances in
experimental social psychology (Vol. 6,pp. 1-62). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
Bentler, P. M.,& Speckart, G. (1979). Models of attitude-behavior relations.
Psychological Review, 86{5)y 452-464.
Bentler, P. M.,& Speckart, G. (1981). Attitudes "cause" behaviors: A structural
equation analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,岑 0(2),226-238.
Biddle, S.,Goudas, M.,& Page, A. (1994). Social-psychological predictors of
self-reported actual and intended physical activity in a university workforce sample.
British Journal of Sports Medicine, 25(3), 160-163.
Biddle,S. J. H.,& Nigg, C. R. (2000). Theories of exercise behavior.
International Journal of Sport Psychology, 3/(2),290-304.
Birtwistle,G. E.,& Brodie, D. A. (1991). Children's attitudes towards activity
and perceptions of physical education. Health Education Research, <5(4),465-478.
89
Blair,S. N” Haskell, W. L.,Ho, P., Paffenbarger, R. S.,Vranizan, K. M.,
Farquhar, J. W.,& Wood, P. D. (1985). Assessment of habitual physical activity by a
7-day recall in a community survey and controlled experiments. American Journal of
Epidemiology, 122(5), 794-804.
Blue,C. L. (1995). The predictive capacity of the theory of reasoned action and
the theory of planned behavior in exercise research: An integrated literature review.
Research in Nursing & Health, /5(2),105-121.
Bozionelos,G.,& Bexmett, P. (1999). The theory of planned behaviour as
predictor of exercise: The moderating influence of beliefs and personality variables.
Journal of Health Psychology, 517-529.
Brennan, D.,& Bleakley, E. W. (1997). Predictors, patterns and policies for
post-school participation. In J. Kremer,K. Trew, & S. Ogle (Eds.),Young people's
involvement in sport (pp.78-97). London: Routledge.
Brustad, R. J. (1991). Children's perspectives on exercise and physical activity:
Measurement issues and concerns. Journal of School Health , 61(5), 228-230.
Brustad, R. J. (1993). Who will go out and play? Parental and Psychological
influences on children's attraction to physical activity. Pediatric Exercise Science, 5(3),
210-223.
Brustad,R. J. (1996). Attraction to physical activity in urban schoolchildren:
90
Parental socialization and gender influences. Research Quarterly for Exercise and
Sport, 67(3),316睡323.
Brustad, R. J. (1998). Developmental considerations in sport and exercise
psychology measurement. In J. L. Duda (Ed.), Advances in sport and exercise
psychology measurement (pp. 461-470). Morgantown, WV: Fitness Information
Technology Inc.
Bungum, T.,Dowda, M.,Weston,A.,Trost, S. G,& Pate, R. R. (2000).
Correlates of physical activity in male and female youth. Pediatric Exercise Science ,
12(1% 71-79.
Butcher, J. (1983). Socialization of adolescent girls into physical activity.
Adolescence, 18(12), 753-766.
Butcher, J. (1985). Longitudinal analysis of adolescent girls' participation of
physical activity. Sociology of Sport Journal, 2(2), 130-143.
Cale, L. (1994). Self-report measures of children's physical activity:
Recommendations for future development and a new alternative measure. Health
Education Journal, 55(4), 439-453.
Caspersen,C. J. (1989). Physical activity epidemiology: Concepts, methods, and
applications to exercise science. In K. Pandolf (Ed.), Exercise and Sport Science
Reviews (Vol. 17,pp.423-473). Baltimore, MD: Williams andWilkins.
91
Chamg, H. W.,Piliavin, J. A.,& Callero, P. L. (1988). Role identity and
reasoned action in the prediction of repeated behavior. Social Psychology Quarterly,
5/(4),303-317.
Chui, H. C. (1997). Physical activity patterns of primary school children in
urban and rural areas in Hong Kong. Unpublished master's thesis, University of
Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
Chung, P. K.,& Leung, M. L. (1998). Attitudes toward physical activity among
primary school children in Hong Kong and Taiwan. Journal of the International
Council for Health, Physical Education’ Recreation , Sport and Dance, 34(4), 32-37.
Collete,M.,Godin, G.,Bradet, R.,& Gionet, N. J. (1995). Active living in
communities: Understanding the intention to take up physical activity as an everyday
way of life. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 85’ 418-421.
Conner, M.,& Armitage, C. J. (1998). Extending the theory of planned behavior:
A review and avenues for further research. Journal of Applied Social Psychology,
25(15), 1429-1464.
Conner, M.,& Sparks, P. (1996). The theory of planned behavior and health
behaviors. In M. Conner, & P. Norman (Eds.),Predicting health behavior
(pp. 121-162). Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
Cooper, J” & Croyle, T. R. (1984). Attitudes and attitude change. Annual Review
92
of Psychology, 35, 395-426.
Coumeya, K. S. (1995). Understanding readiness for regular physical activity in
older individuals: A n application of the theory of planned behavior. Health Psychology,
14(11 80-87.
Coumeya,K. S” & McAuley, E. (1993). Predicting physical activity from
intention: Conceptual and methodological issues. Journal of Sport & Exercise
Psychology, 75(1), 50-62.
Coumeya, K. S.,& McAuley, E. (1995). Cognitive mediators of the social
influence-exercise adherence relationship: A test of the theory of planned behavior.
Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 18(5), 499-515.
Craig, S.,Goldberg,J.,& Dietz, W. H. (1996). Psychosocial correlates of
physical activity among fifth and eighth graders. Preventive Medicine , 25(5), 506-513.
Deeter, T. E. (1988). Does attitudinal commitment predict physical activity
participation. Journal of Sport Behavior, "(4),177-192.
Demmons, S. R. (1993). Attitudes towards physical activity in New Brunswick
physical education. Unpublished master's thesis. University of New Brunswick,
Canada.
Deng, X. F. (1998). Can physical activity participation be predicted by
attitudinal commitment? Journal of Physical Education, Recreation and Dance , 69(7),
93
11.
Dishman, R. K.,& Dunn, A. L. (1988). Exercise adherence in children and youth:
Implications for adulthood. In R. K. Dishman (Ed.), Exercise adherence: Its impact on
public health (pp. 155-200). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Dishman,R. K.,& Gettman, L. R. (1980). Psychobiologic influences on exercise
adherence. Journal of Sport Psychology, 2, 295-310.
Dishman, R. K.,Ickes, W” & Morgan, W. P. (1980). Self-motivation and
adherence to habitual physical activity. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 10(2),
115-132.
Doganis,G ., & Theodorakis, Y. (1995). The influence of attitude on exercise
participation. In S. J. H. Biddle (Ed.), European perspectives on exercise and sport
psychology (pp.26-49). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
DuRant, R. H.,Baranowski,T.,Rhodes, T.,Gutin, B.,Thompson, W. 0., Carroll,
R.,Puhl, J., & Greaves, K. A. (1993). Association among serum lipid and lipoprotein
concentrations and physical activity, physical fitness and body composition in young
children. Journal of Pediatrics, 123, 185-192.
Dzewaltowski, D. A” Noble, J. M.,& Shaw, J. M. (1990). Physical activity
participation: Social cognitive theory versus the theories of reasoned action and
planned behavior. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 12{A\ 388-405.
94
Eagly,A. H” & Chaiken, S. (1993). The psychology of attitudes. Philadelphia:
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Fazio,R. H. (1990). Multiple processes by which attitudes guide behavior: The
mode model as an integrative framework. In M. P. Zaima (Ed.), Advances in
experimental social psychology (Vol. 23, pp.75-109). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
Ferguson, K., Yesalis, C” Pomrehn, R,& ICirkpatrick, M. (1989). Attitudes,
knowledge and beliefs as predictors of exercise intent and behavior in schoolchildren.
Journal of School Health, 59(3),112-115.
Fishbein, M. A. (1967). Attitude and prediction of behavior. In M. Fishbein (Ed),
Readings in attitude theory and measurement (pp.477-492). New York: Wiley and
Sons Inc.
Fishbein,M. A., & Ajzen, L (1975). Belief, attitude, intention and behavior: An
introduction to theory and research. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Fishbein,M.,& Middlestadt, S. (1987). Using the theory of reasoned action to
develop educational interventions: Applications to illicit drug use. Health Education
Research, 2(4), 361-371.
Flora,I A.,Maibach, E. W.,& Maccoby,N. (1989). The role of media across
four levels of health promotion intervention. Annual Review of Public Health 10,
181-201.
95
Fox,K. (1994). Understanding young people and their decisions about physical
activity. The British Journal of Physical Education , 25(1), 15-19.
Freedson, P. S.,& Melanson, E. L. (1996). Measuring physical activity. In D.
Docherty (Ed.), Measurement in pediatric exercise science (pp. 261-283). Champaign,
IL: Human Kinetics.
Freedson, P. S ., Sirard, J.,Debold,N.,Pate, R.,Dowda, M.,& Sallis, J. (1997).
Validity of two physical activity monitors in children and adolescents. In N.
Armstrong, B. J. Kirby, & J. R. Welsman (Eds.), Children and exercise xix: Promoting
health and well-being (pp.127-131). London: E & FN Spon.
Fu, F. H. (1993). The development of sport culture in the Hong Kong Chinese.
Hong Kong: Hong Kong Baptist College.
Fu, F. H. (1994). Health fitness parameters of Hong Kong school children. Hong
Kong: Hong Kong Baptist College.
Fung, T. K. (1997). The relationship between students 'participation level and
attitude toward physical activity. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Hong
Kong, Hong Kong.
Garcia, A. W.,Pender, N. J.,Antonakos, C. L” & Ronis,D. L. (1998). Changes
in physical activity beliefs and behaviors of boys and girls across the transition to
junior high school. Journal of Adolescent Health , 22(5), 394-402.
96
Gatch, C. L.,& Kendzierski, D. (1990). Predicting exercise intentions: The
theory of planned behavior. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, <5/(1),
100-102.
Godin, G. (1993). The theories of reasoned action and plaxmed behavior:
Overview of findings, emerging research problems and useMness for exercise
promotion. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 5(2), 141-157.
Godin, G.,& Kok, G. (1996). The theory of planned behavior: A review of its
applications to health-related behaviors. American Journal of Health Promotion , //(2),
87-98.
Godin, G.,& Shephard, R. J. (1986). Psychosocial factors influencing intentions
to exercise of young students from grades 7 to 9. Research Quarterly for Exercise and
Sport, 57(1),41-52.
Godin, G.,& Shephard, R. J. (1990). Use of attitude-behavior models in exercise
promotion. Sports Medicine, 10(2), 103-121.
Godin, G.,Valois, R,& Lepage, L. (1993). The pattern of influence of perceived
behavioral control upon exercise behavior: An application of Ajzen's theory of
planned behavior. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 16(\\ 81-102.
Godin, G,Vezina, L.,& Leclerc,O. (1989). Factors influencing intentions of
pregnant women to exercise after giving birth. Public Health Reports, 104, 188-196.
97
Greenockle, K. M.,Lee, A. A.,& Lomax, R. (1990). The relationship between
selected student characteristics and activity patterns in a required high school physical
education class. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 61{\\ 59-69.
Griffin,R. S. (1998). Sports in the lives of children and adolescents: Success on
the field and in life. London: Praeger.
Hagger, M.,Cale, L.,& Almond, L. (1997). Children's physical activity levels
and attitudes towards physical activity. European Physical Education Review, 3(2),
144-164.
Haladyna, T.,& Thomas,G. (1979). The attitudes of elementaiy school children
toward school and subject matters. Journal of Experimental Education , 48(1), 18-23.
Hale, M. A. (1976). Sport and physical activity in the lives of Canadian women.
In R. S. Gmneau,& J. G. Albinson (Eds.),Canadian sport: Sociological perspectives
(pp. 170-199). Don Mills,Ontario: Addison-Wesley.
Hausenblas, H. A.,Canon, A. V.,& Mack, D. E. (1997). Application of the
theories of reasoned action and planned behavior to exercise behavior: A
meta-analysis. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 19(1), 36-51.
Health Education Authority. (1997). Young people and physical activity: A
literature review. London: Author.
Hendiy,L. B.,& Douglass,L. (1975). University students: Attainment and sport.
98
British Journal of Educational Psychology, 45, 299-306.
Himmelfarb,S. (1993). The measurement of attitudes. In A. H. Eagly,& S.
Chaiken (Eds.), The psychology of attitudes (pp.23-87). Philadelphia: Harcourt Brace
Jovanovich.
Jacobs,D. R.,Ainsworth, B.E., Hartman, T. J.,& Leon,A. S. (1993). A
simultaneous evaluation of 10 commonly used physical activity questionnaires.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 25(1), 81-91.
Johns, D. R,& Ha, A. S. (1999). Home and recess physical activity of Hong
Kong children. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport , 70(3),319-323.
Johnson, R,& Pargman, D. (1987). Achievement motivation and pre-collegiate
success levels in competing collegiate tennis players. Journal of Applied Research in
Coaching and Athletics, 2, 4.
Kahle, L. R.,& Berman, J. J. (1979). Attitudes cause behaviors: A cross-lagged
panel analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37(3),315-321.
Kelman, H. C. (1974). Attitudes are alive and well and gainfully employed in the
sphere of action. American Psychologist, 29(5),310-324.
Kenyon, G. S. (1968a). A conceptual model for characterizing physical activity.
Research Quarterly, 39(1), 99-105.
Kenyon, G. S. (1968b). Six scales for assessing attitude toward physical activity.
99
Research Quarterly, 39(3),566-574.
Keogh,J. (1962). An analysis of general attitudes toward physical education.
Research Quarterly, 33(2), 239-244.
Kemer, M. S.,& Grossman, A. H. (1998). Attitudinal, social, and practical
correlates to fitness behavior: A test of the theory of planned behavior. Perceptual and
Motor Skills) 57(3),1139-1154.
Kimiecik, J. (1992). Predicting vigorous physical activity of corporate
employees: Comparing the theories of reasoned action and planned behavior. Journal
of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 14(2), 192-206.
Klesges, R. C.,Eck, L. H.,Hanson, C. L., Haddock, C. K.,& Klesges, L. M‘
(1990). Effects of obesity, social interactions, and physical environment on physical
activity in preschoolers. Health Psychology, 9(4),435-449.
Kraus,S. J. (1995). Attitudes and the prediction of behavior. Personality and
Social Psychology Bulletin, 27(1), 58-75.
LaPiere, R. T. (1934). Attitudes versus actions. Social Forces, 13(2), 230-237.
Lindner, K. J. (1995). Motivation factors in the promotion of sport participation.
Hong Kong Journal of Sports Medicine and Sports Science, 1 , 33-44.
Lindner,K. J. (1998). Sport and activity participation of Hong Kong school
children and youth 一 Part 1. Hong Kong Journal of Sports Medicine and Sports
100
Science, 6 , 16-28.
Lindner, K. J. (1999). Sport participation and perceived academic performance
of school children and youth. Pediatric Exercise Science, 11(2), 129-143.
Liska, A. E. (1984). A critical examination of the causal structure of the
Fishbein/Ajzen attitude-behavior model. Social Psychology Quarterly,萃7(1), 61-74.
Long,B. C.,& Haney, D. J. (1986). Enhancing physical activity in sedentary
women: Information, locus of control, and attitudes. Journal of Sport Psychology, 5(1),
8-23.
Macfarlane, D. J. (1997). Some disturbing trends in the level of habitual physical
activity in Hong Kong primary school children: Preliminary findings. Hong Kong
Journal of Sports Medicine and Sports Science, 5, 42-46.
Macfarlane, D. J. (1999). Pilot investigation on the tracking of physical activity
in Hong Kong young school children. Health Services Research Committee Report, 11,
1-4.
Madden,T. J” Ellen, P. S.,& Ajzen, I. (1992). A comparison of the theory of
planned behavior and the theory of reasoned action. Personality and Social
Psychology Bulletin, /5(1),3-9.
Manstead, A. S. R.,Proffitt, C.,& Smart, J. L. (1983). Predicting and
understanding mothers' infant-feeding intentions and behavior; Testing the theory of
101
reasoned action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 44(4% 657-671.
McArdle,W. D.,Katch, F. I., & Katch, V. L. (1991). Exercise physiology:
Energy, nutrition , and human performance (3rd ed.). Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger.
McAuley, R,& Coumeya, K. S. (1993). Adherence to exercise and physical
activity as health-promoting behaviors: Attitudinal and self-efficacy influences.
Applied & Preventive Psychology, 2(1), 65-77.
McCready, M. L.,& Long, B. C. (1985). Locus of control, attitudes toward
physical activity,and exercise adherence. Journal of Sport Psychology, 7(4),346-359.
McManus, A. M” & Armstrong, N. (1996). The physical activity patterns of
boys and girls. In D, J. Macfarlane (Ed.),Gender issues in sport and exercise (pp.
36-39). Hong Kong: The University of Hong Kong.
Mobily, K. E•,Lemke,J. H•,Drube, G. A., Wallace, R. B., Leslie, D. K ” &
Weissinger, E. (1987). Relationship between exercise attitudes and participation
among the rural elderly. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4{\), 38-50.
Mummery, W. K•,Spence, J. C.,& Hudec, J. C. (2000). Understanding physical
activity intention in Canadian school children and youth: An application of the theory
of planned behavior. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 7/(2),116-124.
Ng, 1. K. W. (1996). Physical activity profiles of Hong Kong secondary school
children. Hong Kong: Hong Kong Baptist University.
102
Olson, J. M,,& Zatma, M. P. (1993). Attitudes and attitude change. Annual
Review of Psychology, 44 , 117-154.
Osgood, C. E.,Suci, G. J.,& Tannenbaum, P. H. (1957). The measurement of
meaning. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Oskamp, S. (1991). Attitudes and opinions (2nd ed). Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
Ostrow, A. C, (1996). Directory of psychological tests in the sport and exercise
sciences (2nd ed.). Morgantown, WV: Fitness Information Technology Inc.
Palmer, C. L.,Burwitz, L.,Smith, N. C” & Collins, D. (1999). Adherence to
fitness training of elite netball players: A naturalistic inquiry. The Sport Psychologist,
73(3), 313-333.
Papaioannou, A., & Theodorakis, Y. (1996). A test of three models for the
prediction of intention for participation in physical education lessons. International
Journal of Sport Psychology, 27(4), 383-399.
Pate, R. R. (1993). Physical activity assessment in children and adolescents.
Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 33(4/5),321-326.
Pate, R. R.,Baranowski, T.,Dowda, M.,& Trost, S. G (1996). Tracking physical
activity in young children. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 25(1), 92-96.
Pate, R. R” Long, B. J., & Heath, G. (1994). Descriptive epidemiology of
103
physical activity in adolescents. Pediatric Exercise Science, 6(4),434-447.
Patterson, R,& Faucette, N. (1990a). Attitudes toward physical activity of fourth
and fifth grade boys and girls. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 6/(4),
415-418.
Patterson, R,& Faucette, N. (1990b). Children's attitudes toward physical
activity in classes taught by specialist versus nonspecialist P. E. teachers, Journal of
teaching in physical education , 9(4),324-331.
Powell, K. E.,Caspersen, C. J” Koplan, J. R,& Ford, R S. (1989). Physical
activity and chronic disease. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 49, 999-1006.
Pratt,M.,Macera, C. A., & Blanton, C. (1999). Levels of physical activity and
inactivity in children and adults in the United States: Current evidence and research
issues. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 37(11), S526-S533.
Raden,D. (1985). Strength-related attitude dimensions. Social Psychology
Quarterly, 48{A), 312-330.
Riddle,P. K. (1980). Attitudes, beliefs,behavioral intentions, and behaviors of
women and men toward regular jogging. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,
5i(4)? 663-674.
Riddoch, C. L,& Boreham, C. A. G (1995). The health-related physical activity
of children. Sports Medicine’ 9(2),86-102.
104
Rowland, T. W. (1990). Exercise and children's health. Champaign,IL: Human
Kinetics.
Rowlands, A. V” Eston,R. G.,& Ingledew, D. K. (1997). Measurement of
physical activity in children with particular reference to the use of heart rate and
pedometry. Sports Medicine, 24(4), 258-272.
Sallis, J. F. (1991). Self-report measures of children's physical activity. Journal
of School Health, 61(5), 215-219.
Sallis, J. F. (1993). Epidemiology of physical activity and fitness in children and
adolescents. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 33(4/5),403-408.
Sallis, J. F., Buono, M. J., Roby, J. J.,Micale, F. G,& Nelson,J. A. (1993).
Seven-day recall and other physical activity self-reports in children and adolescents.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 25(1), 99-108.
Sallis,J. R,& Owen, N. (1999). Physical activity & behavioral medicine.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Sallis,J. F” & Patrick, K. (1994). Physical activity guidelines for adolescents:
Consensus Statement. Pediatric Exercise Science, 6(4),302-314.
Sallis,J. R,Prochaska, J. J” & Taylor, W. C. (2000). A review of correlates of
physical activity of children and adolescents. Medicine and Science in Sports and
Exercise, 52(5), 963-975.
105
Sallis,J. R,& Saelens, B. E. (2000). Assessment of physical activity by
self-report: Status, limitations, and future directions. Research Quarterly for Exercise
and Sport, 77(2), 1-14.
Sallis, J. F.,Simons-Morton, B. G,Stone, E. J” Corbin, C. B.,Epstein, L. H•,
Faucette, N ” laxmotti, R. J.,Killen, J. D.,Klesges, R. C.,Petray,C. K.,Rowland, X
W.,& Taylor,W. C. (1992). Determinants of physical activity and interventions in
youth. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise , 24(Suppl. 6),S248-S257.
Sallis, J. F.5 Strikmiller, P. K.,Harsha,D. W., Fddtnan,H. A.,Ehlinger, S., Stone,
E. J” Williston, J.? & Woods, S. (1996). Validation of interviewer-and
self-administered physical activity checklists for fifth grade students. Medicine and
Science in Sports and Exercise, 28(1), 840-851.
Saris, W. H. M. (1986). Habitual physical activity in children: Methodology and
findings in health and disease. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 18(3),
253-263.
Schempp, P. G,ChefFers, J. T.,& Zaichkowsky, L. D. (1983). Influence of
decision-making on attitudes, creativity, motor skills and self-concept in elementary
children. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 5¥(2), 183-189.
Schifter, D. B.,& Ajzen, I (1985). Intention, perceived control, and weight loss:
An application of the theoiy of planned behavior. Journal of Personality and Social
106
Psychology, 49(3), 843-851.
Schuessler, K. F. (1993). Scaling social life feelings: Persistent Issues. In D.
Krebs, & P. Schmidt (Eds.),New directions in attitude measurement (pp.21-40).
Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Schutz, R. W.5 & Smoll,F. L. (1977). Equivalence of two inventories for
assessing attitudes toward physical activity. Psychological Reports, 40(3 "), 1031-1034.
Schutz, R. W.5 & Smoll, F. L. (1986). The (instability of attitudes toward
physical activity during childhood and adolescence. In B. D. McPherson (Ed.), Sport
and aging (pp. 187-197). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Schutz, R. W.,Smoll, F. L.,Carre, F. A., & Mosher, R. R (1985). Inventories and
norms for children's attitudes toward physical activity. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport, 5(5(2), 256-265.
Schutz, R. W.,Smoll, F. L” & Wood, T. M. (1981). A psychometric analysis of
an inventory for assessing children's attitudes toward physical activity. Journal of
Sport Psychology,窣(3),321-344.
Shephard, R. J” Berridge, M” Montelpare,W.,Daniel, J. V” & Flowers, J. R
(1987). Exercise compliance of elderly volunteers. Journal of Sports Medicine and
Physical Fitness, 27, 410-418.
Sidney, K. H.,& Shephard, R. J. (1976). Attitudes toward health and physical
107
activity in the elderly: Effects of a physical training program. Medicine and Science in
Sports’ 5(4), 246-252.
Silverman, S. & Subramaniam, R R. (1999). Student attitude toward physical
education and physical activity: A review of measurement issues and outcomes.
Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, J9(1), 97-125.
Simon, J. A.,& Smoll, R L. (1974). An instrument for assessing children's
attitudes toward physical activity. Research Quarterly, ^5(4), 407-415.
Simons-Morton, B. G.,Parcel, G. S •, O'Hara, N. M.,Blair, S. N.,& Pate, R. R.
(1988). Health-related physical fitness in childhood: Status and recommendations.
Annual Review of Public Health, 9, 403-425.
Sivan, A., & Roberston,R. W. (1996). Male and female sport participation in
Hong Kong. In D. J. Macfarlane (Ed.),Gender issues in sport and exercise (pp.56-62).
Hong Kong: The University of Hong Kong.
Sleap, M.,& Warburton, P. (1992). Physical activity levels of 5-11 year old
children in England determined by continuous observation. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport, 63(3), 238-245.
Smith, R. A” & Biddle,S. J. H. (1999). Attitudes and exercise adherence: Test of
the theories of reasoned action and planned behaviour. Journal of Sports Science ,
17(4), 269-281.
108
Smoll, F. L.,& Schutz, R. W. (1980). Children's attitudes towards physical
activity: A longitudinal analysis. Journal of Sport Psychology, 2, 144-154.
Smoll, F. L.,Schutz, R. W.,& Keeney, J. K. (1976). Relationships among
children's attitudes, involvement, and proficiency in physical activities. The Research
Quarterly, ^7(4), 797-803.
Sparks, P., & Shephard, R. (1992). Self-identity and the theory of planned
behavior: Assessing the role of identification with "green consumerism". Social
Psychology Quarterly, 55(4), 388-399.
Speak,M. A.,& Lindner, K. J. (1996). Participation in and attitudes towards
sport and physical activity by male and female students entering the university. In D. J.
Macfarlane (Ed.),Gender issues in sport and exercise (pp.87). Hong Kong: The
University of Hong Kong.
Speak,M_ A.,Lindner, K. J•,& Li,D. (1994). Sport participation by students
enrolling at the University of Hong Kong. In K. J. Lindner & M. A. Speak (Eds.),
Sport participation: Motivation and barriers (pp.3-18). Hong Kong: The University of
Hong Kong.
Stephens, T.,Jacobs, D. R” & White, C. C. (1985). A descriptive epidemiology
of leisure-time physical activity. Public Health Reports, 100, 147-158.
Straub, W. R, & Felock, T. (1974). Attitudes toward physical activity of
109
delinquent and nondelinquent junior high school age girls. Research Quarterly, 45(1)^
21-27.
Subramaniam, R R.,& Silverman, S. (2000). Validation of scores from an
instrument assessing student attitude toward physical education. Measurement in
Physical Education and Exercise Science, 4{\), 29-43.
Telama, R.,Laakso, L.,& Yang,X. (1994). Physical activity and participation in
sports of young people in Finland. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in
Sports, 4(1), 65-74.
Terry, D. J_,& O'Leary, J. E. (1995). The theory of planned behavior: The
effects of perceived behavioral control and self-efficacy. British Journal of Social
Psychology, 3^(part 2), 199-220.
Tesser, A.,& Shaffer,D. (1990). Attitudes and attitude change. Annual Review of
Psychology, 41, 479-523.
Theodorakis, Y. (1992). Prediction of athletic participation: A test of planned
behavior theory. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 74(2), 371-379.
Theodorakis, Y. (1994). Planned behavior, attitude strength, role identity, and the
prediction of exercise behavior. The Sport Psychologist, 5(2), 149-165.
Theodorakis, Y.,Bagiatis, K.,& Goudas,M. (1995). Attitudes toward teaching
individuals with disabilities: Application of planned behavior theory. Adapted
110
Physical Activity Quarterly, 12(2), 151-160.
Theodorakis, Y.,Doganis, G.,Bagiatis,K.,& Gouthas, M. (1991). Preliminary
study of the ability of reasoned action model in predicting exercise behavior of young
children. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 72(1), 51-58.
Triandis,H. C. (1977). Interpersonal behavior. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
Trost, S. G” Pate, R. R.,Dowda, M.,Saunders, R” Wrad, D.,& Felton, G. (1996).
Gender differences in physical activity and determinants of physical activity in rural
fifth grade children. Journal of School Health, 66{A)f 145-150.
Trost, S. G,Ward, D. S.,McGraw, B.,& Pate, R. R. (1999). Validity of the
previous day physical activity recall (PDPAR) in fifth-grade children. Pediatric
Exercise Science, 341-348.
Tsang, C. K. E.,& Chan, T. F. A. (1993). The relationship between physical
fitness and attitude towards physical activities of Hong Kong secondary school
students. In F. H. Fu,R. Eston, & L. Fung (Eds.),Synopsis of local researches in
sports science, 3, 151-156.
U. S. Department of Health and Human Services. (1998). Physical activity and
health: A report of the surgeon general Boston: Jones and Bartlett.
Van Ryn, M” Lytle,L. A” & Kirscht, J. P. (1996). A test of the theory of planned
behavior for two health-related practices. Journal of Applied Social Psychology,
111
26(10), 871-883.
Verschuur, R.,& Kemper, H. C. G (1985). Habitual physical activity. In H. C. G
Kemper (Ed.), Growth’ health, and fitness of teenagers: Longitudinal research in
international perspective (pp. 56-65). Basel: Karger.
Wankel, L. M.,& Mummeiy, W. K. (1993). Using national survey data
incorporating the theory of planned behavior: Implications for social marketing
strategies in physical activity. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 5(2), 158-177.
Wankel, L. M.,Mummeiy, W. K., Stephens, T.,& Craig, C. L. (1994). Prediction
of physical activity intention from social psychological variables: Results from the
Campell's survey of well-being. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 16{l\
56-59.
Wamecke, R. B.,Johnson, T. R,Chavez, N.,Sudman, S.,O'Rourke, D. R,Lacey,
L.,& Horm, J. (1997). Improving question wording in surveys of culturally diverse
populations. Annals of Epidemiology, 7,334-342.
Welk, G. J.,Corbin, C. B.,& Dale, D. (2000). Measurement issues in the
assessment of physical activity in children. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,
7/(2),59-73.
Welsman, J. R.,& Armstrong, N. (1997). Physical activity patterns of 5 to 11
year old children. InN. Armstrong, B. J. Kirby, & J. R. Welsman (Eds.),Children and
112
exercise xix: Promoting health and well-being (pp. 139-144). London: E & FN Spon.
Welsman, 1,& Armstrong, N. (2000). Physical activity patterns in secondary
school children. European Journal of Physical Education, 5(2), 147-157.
Weston, A. T.,Petosa, R.,& Pate, R. R. (1997). Validation of an instrument for
measurement of physical activity in youth. Medicine and Science in Sports and
Exercise, 29(1), 138-143.
Wicker, A. W. (1969). Attitude versus actions: The relationship of verbal and
overt behavioral responses to attitude objects. Journal of Social Issues, 25(4), 41-78.
Wong, T. K. (1997). Aspects of habitual physical activity in Hong Kong primary
school children. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Hong Kong,Hong Kong.
Yang, X.,Telama, R., Leino, M.,& Viikari, J. (1999). Factors explaining the
physical activity of young adults: The importance of early socialization. Scandinavian
Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports, 9(2),120-127.
Yordy, G A., & Lent, R. W. (1993). Predicting aerobic exercise participation:
Social cognitive, reasoned action,and planned behavior models. Journal of Sport &
Exercise Psychology, 75(4), 363-374.
Zakarian, J. M” Hovell, M. F.,Hofstetter, C. R.,Sallis, J. F.,& Keating, EL J.
(1994). Correlates of vigorous exercise in a predominantly low socioeconomic and
minority high school population. Preventive Medicine, 23(3),314-321.
113
APPENDICES
APPENDIX 1 Part one: Chinese version of the SAPAC
香港大學教育學院
體 育 及 運 動 稱 部
(“)體育活動自我評核問卷(中文修訂版)
目的:本問卷是調查你在昨天的體育活動量,體育活動是指各種類型的活動,包
括:運動比賽,正規練習及非正規的活動,例如捉人遊戲、足球、緩步跑
和踏單車等0
塡寫程序:
1 )本問卷不是一項測驗,因此並沒有對或錯的答案。
2)最重要的是細閱指示,並誠實及準確地回答各問題。
3 )本問卷之調查結果絕不會影響你各科的成績,而全部資料將於調查報告完成
後銷毀。
多謝各同學合作!
甲部
個 人 麵 :
1 ) 性 別 : 男 女
2)年齡(計至2000年12月31日): 0 4
1 1
1 1 1 5
1 2 1 6
1 3
1 7
3 ) 就 讀 年 級 : 小學六年級 中學三年級
- 般 難
1)昨天你有沒有上體育課? 有 沒有
2)如果答有,那體育課的時間有多久? 分鐘
3 ) 昨 天 , 你 有 沒 撤 小 息 ? ( *被罰或替老師做事’観答沒有)有沒有
4)如果答有,那麼小息的時間有多久?
(第—次小息) 及鐘(第二次小息)
114
活動資料
1 )昨天你有沒有參與下列各項體育活動?如有,請於B、!>、F三欄內塡上你
的活動時間(如少於5分鐘,貝!J不用塡寫)。
2)請於C、E、G三欄內註明該項活動有否引致你呼吸急速或感到疲倦?
如沒有,請塡‘N,,小部分時間有請塡‘S,,大部分時間有請塡‘M, o
A•活動類型 B.上學前 (分鐘)
C. N,S andM
D.在校內 (分鐘)
E. N,S andM
R放學後 (分鐘)
GN5S andM
1 踏轉(非競賽性) 2 游泳(非競賽性) 3 田徑:賽跑練習
4 田徑:田賽練習(如跳遠、推鉛球) 5 體操:例如單、雙槓、彈網、翻筋斗
6 體能活動:如掌上壓、仰臥起坐
7 籃球:半場或全場比賽 8 棒球/壘球 9 足球
10 排球 11 辟 球
12 羽毛球 13 網球
14 壁球
15 曲棍球 16 球類遊戲:如數字球、射龍門、射籃
17 遊戲:如互相追逐、捉迷藏
18 溜冰、滾軸溜冰
19 跳繩 20 跳舞 21 健身舞 22 武術、空手道、跆拳道
23 戶外家務:如園藝、洗車
24 室內家務:如拖地板、吸麈、打掃
25 步行:如回校或回家
26 跑步:非田徑練習
27 其他:例如體育課、校隊練習或以上 未提及的,請註明活動類型
28 29 30 31
115
如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上“〃,並繼續回答下一S。
APPENDIX 1 Part two: Chinese version of the revised CATPA inventory
(二)青少年對體育活動態度問卷調查
目的:本問卷旨在調查你對體育活動的態度及意見,體育活動是指各種類型的活
動,包括:運動比賽,正規練習及非正規的活動,例如捉人遊戲、足球、
緩步跑和踏單車等。
塡寫程序:
1 )本問卷不是一項測驗’因此並沒有對或錯的答案。
2)請閱讀每題方格內所提出的意見,然後在每組字詞中最適當的位置上加
上“一”,以表示你對那意見的感覺。
3)果你不明白方格內的意見,請在“•”內加上,並繼續回答下一題。
4)請細閱指示,並誠實及準確地回答各問題。
5 )本問卷之調查結果絕不會影響你各科的成績,而全部資料將於調查報告完成
後銷毀。
多謝各同學合作!
甲部
請在下列各題每組字詞中最適當的位置上加上〜”,以表示你對各題方格內的
1•你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺?
參與細動能提供給你認識細
緊記方格內的意見
:的
;2?
*2?
*2?
6W
-6W
用
決
厭
壞
有
愉
討
SJ
用
快
趣
樂
沒
愉
有
快
3 4
116
如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上“ 一 ”,並繼續回答下一題°
你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺-
髏育活動延續社交關係
參與艘育活動能提供給你與朋友一起相聚的機會 ;
1 , , - • 〖
緊記方格內的意見
n
r —
一
l̂ill
¾¾ n
沒用的
不愉快的
有趣的
快樂的
有用的
愉快的
討厭的
mxmm 如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上 並繼續回答下一題
3•你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺?
髖育活動贱《康與艘雄 1
n
II
—
丨
<
_
m灌
mmm :¾
j
.
¾̂¾¾¾
S®S8
feo
0
•
•IIM
/
康
健
w
J 你
1
!〜
令
Is*
勤
r> vr̂
.
.
.
. .
*̂N
i -^̂-
緊記方格內的意見
的
的
的
的
齋
用
K
厭
力
壞
有
愉
討
钯
好
的
的
的
的
用
快
趣
樂
沒
愉
有
快
2
4 5
117
有用的
愉快的
討厭的
使 人 赔 的
如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上,並繼續回答下一題。
5.你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺?
如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上…,並繼續回答下一題。
緊記方格內的意見
4.你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺
:育活動令人緊張刺激,但有些危險
【是危險的‘因為你要快速地移動身想
緊記方格內的意見
?
^
6M
6W
An
Ap
用
快
趣
樂
沒
愉
有
Ik
的
的
的
I
用
陝
厭
义
壞
有
愉
討
使
好
的
的
的
的
用
快
趣
樂
沒
愉
荀
使
118
沒用的
不愉快的
有趣的
快樂的
緊記方格內的意見
有用的
愉快的
討厭的
使 人 鮮 的
如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上“v ”,並繼續回答下一題。
你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺?
緊記方格內的意見
如果你不明白方格內的意見,請在此方格內•塡上 。
問卷完
6•你對下列方格內的意見有何感覺? , : - … : :.;;; ;;7: . . : : . ; : ; : ; . . . . . . . . ‘
1" , . ; , “
1! ! "
1!
1: "
| , _. . . . . .
1 二.:!.;.
1
十...,; •: .... •‘-..: • : : : • . . . ; : ; . : … ;;• ; ; ' ; ; :•: ' . . .""‘ ... :“:厂;...•.,•-:„ , I-'./-';.;':": .... ....... : v.i . . - . : , : . . . , . .: ... ... .. •' . : , . .... ......,:.1 v,;,' -r .
髏 育 活 動 可 消 除 緊 張 的 情 緒 隱糧層̂ :::
參 與 髏 育 活 動 可 減 低 壓 力 或 令 你 避 開 一 些 你 將 面 對 的 問 題
的
的
的
直
用
快
厭
人
壞
有
愉
討
使
好
的
的
的
的
用
快
趣
樂
沒
愉
有
快
119
APPENDIX 2 Part one: The SAPAC (modified version)
The University of Hong Kong Faculty of Education
Physical Education and Sports Science Unit
Part 1: The self-administered physical activity checklists (SAPAC) (Modified version)
Purpose: To measure your physical activity level on previous day. Physical activity
refers to all kinds of activities, including sports,formal exercises, and informal activities,such as tag, soccer, jogging and cycling.
Procedures: 1. This is not a test, so there are no right or wrong answers. 2. Please read the instructions and answer all the questions as honestly and
accurately as you can - this is very important. 3. The results of this questionnaire will absolutely not affect your grades in any
subjects, and will be totally deleted after the completion of the investigation.
Thank you for your cooperation!!
Section A Personal Particulars: Please circle your answer in the following questions.
1. Sex: Male Female 2. Age (up to 31-12-2000): 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 3. Grade: Primary 6 Secondary 3 4. Did you participate in physical education class yesterday? Yes No 5. If yes, how many minutes would the class last? Minutes 6. Did you participate in recess yesterday? Yes No 7. If yes, how many minutes of recess did you have?
minutes for first recess minutes for second recess
120
Section B
1. Did you participate in the physical activities listed below? If yes, write down the number of minutes you were actually performing the activities in column B,D and F. (Only if you did the activity for 5 minutes or more)
2. Please also state whether the activity caused you to breathe hard or feel tired. Put an "N" for none of the time; “S,,for some of the time and “M,,for most of the time.
A. Activity B. Before school (Mins)
C. N,S and M
D. During School (Mins)
E. N,S and M
R After school (Mins)
G N s S and M
1 Bicycling (non competition) 2 Swimming (non competition) 3 Athletics: running events 4 Athletics: field events 5 Gymnastics: bars,trampoline 6 Exercise: push-ups, sit-ups 7 Basketball (half or full court) 8 Baseball/Softball 9 Soccer
10 Volleyball 11 Table tennis 12 Badminton 13 Tennis 14 Squash 15 Hockey 16 Ball games: dodge ball, shooting basket 17 Games: chase, hide and catch 18 Skiing and Roller skating 19 Rope jumping 20 Dancing 21 Aerobic dancing 22 Wu shu, karate, tae kwan tao 23 Outdoor chores: gardening, car washing 24 Indoor chores: mopping, vacuuming,
sweeping 25 Walking: to home or to school 26 Running: non athletics training 27 Others: (physical activity classes, lessons,
or teams) 28 29 30 31
121
APPENDIX 2 Part two: The revised CATPA inventory
The University of Hong Kong Faculty of Education
Physical Education and Sports Science Unit
PART 2: The revised children's attitudes toward physical activity (CATPA) inventory
Purpose: To find out how you feel about physical activity. Physical activity refers to
all kinds of activities, including sports,formal exercises, and informal activities, such as tag, soccer,jogging and cycling.
Procedures: 1. This is not a test, so there are no right or wrong answers. 2. Read the idea in the box for each question and then put a “ v,,on each word pairs
to show how you feel about the idea. 3. If you do not understand the idea in the box put a ” v " in the do not understand
box and go to the next page.
4. Please answer all the questions as honestly and accurately as you can — this is very important.
5. The results of this questionnaire will absolutely not affect your grades in any subjects, and will be totally deleted after the completion of the investigation.
Thank you for your cooperation!!
Please put a “ v ” on each word pairs to show how von feel about the idea.
1) How do you feel about the idea in the box? PHYSICAL ACTIVITY FOR SOCIAL GROWTH
Taking part in physical activities which give you a chance to meet new people. Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea,mark this box and go to the next question.
good bad of no use useM
not pleasant pleasant nice awful
happy sad
122
2) How do you feel about the idea in the box?
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY TO CONTINUE SOCIAL RELATIONS Taking part in physical activities which give you a chance to be with your friends.
Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea, mark this box and go to the next question.
1. good bad 2. of no use useful 3. not pleasant pleasant 4. nice awM 5. happy sad
3) How do you feel about the idea in the box?
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY FOR HEALTH AND FITNESS Taking part in physical activities to make your health better and to get your body in
better condition.
Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea, mark this box and go to the next question.
1. good bad
2. of no use useful 3. not pleasant pleasant 4. nice awful
5. happy sad
4) How do you feel about the idea in the box?
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AS A THRILL BUT INVOLVING SOME RISK Taking part in physical activities that could be dangerous because you move very fast
and must change direction quickly.
Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea, mark this box _ and go to the next question.
1 • good bad 2. of no use usefixl 3. not pleasant pleasant
4. nice a w M
5. happy s a d
123
5) How do you feel about the idea in the box?
PHY SIC A L ACTIVITY AS THE BEAUTY IN MOVEMENT Taking part in physical activities which have beautiful and graceful movements.
Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea,mark this box and go to the next question.
1. good bad 2. of no use useful 3. not pleasant pleasant 4. nice awful 5. happy sad
6) How do you feel about the idea in the box? PHYSICAL ACTIVITY FOR THE RELEASE OF TENSION
Taking part in physical activities to reduce stress or to get away from problems you might have.
Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea,mark this box and go to the next question.
1. good bad 2. of no use useM 3. not pleasant pleasant 4. nice awfol 5. happy sad
7) How do you feel about the idea in the box? PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AS LONG AND HARD TRAINING
Taking part in physical activities that have long and hard practices. To spend time in practice you need to give up other things you like to do.
Always think about the idea in the box.
If you do not understand this idea,mark this box |.
1 • good bad 2. of no use usefUl 3. not pleasant pleasant
4. nice a w f i l 1
5. happy s a d The End
124
APPENDIX 3 The SAPAC (original version)
Section A
Personal Particulars: Please circle your answer in the following questions.
1. Sex: Male Female
2. Age (up to 31-12-2000): 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
3. Grade: Primary 6 Secondary 3
4. Did you participate in physical education class yesterday? Yes No
5. If yes,how many minutes would the class last? Minutes
6. Did you participate in recess yesterday? Yes No
7. If yes,how many minutes of recess did you have?
Minutes for first recess minutes for second recess
125
Section B
1. Did you participate in the physical activities listed below? If yes, write down the number of minutes you were actually performing the activities in column B,D and R (Only if you did the activity for 5 minutes or more)
2. Please also state whether the activity caused you to breathe hard or feel tired. Put an “N” for none of the time; “S,,for some of the time and “M” for most of the time.
C.None,Some,Most E. None,Sonie,Most G Noiie,Some,Most A. Activity B. Before
school (Mins)
N,S and M
D. During School (Mins)
N,S and M
F. After school (Mins)
N, S and M
1 Bicycling 2 Swimming laps 3 Gymnastics:bars,beam,tumbling,trampoline 4 Exercise: push-ups, sit-ups jumping jacks 5 Basketball 6 Baseball/Softball 7 Football 8 Soccer 9 Volleyball
10 Racket sports: badminton, tennis 11 Ball playing: four square, dodge ball,
kickball 12 Games: chase, tag,hopscotch 13 Outdoor play: climbing trees, hide-and-seek 14 Water play: swimming pool, ocean, or lake 15 Jump rope 16 Dance 17 Outdoor: mowing, raking, gardening 18 Indoor chores; mopping, vacuuming,
sweeping 19 Mixed walking/ running 20 Walking 21 Running 22 Others: physical activity classes, lessons, or
teams 23 24 25
Before School After School
T.V.Mdeo H.l hours _ — hours
H.2 一 hours hours
Video Games & Computer Games...
H.3 hours —— hours
H.4 —hours — — hours
126
APPENDIX 4 METs scoring table A . Activity METs
Scores
Weighting Rules
1 Bicycling (non competition) 4.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 2 Swimming (non competition) 6.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 3 Athletics: running events 8.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 4 Athletics: field events 5.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 5 Gymnastics: bars, trampoline 4.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 6 Exercise: push-ups, sit-ups 4.5 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 7 Basketball (half or full court) 8.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 8 Baseball/Softball 5.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 9 Soccer 7.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25
10 Volleyball 3.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 11 Table tennis 4.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 12 Badminton 4.5 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 13 Tennis 7.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 14 Squash 12.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25
15 Hockey 8.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25
16 Ball games: dodge ball, shooting basket 4.5 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25
17 Games: chase,hide and catch 5.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 18 Skiing and Roller skating 7.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 19 Rope jumping 8.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 20 Dancing 4.5 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 21 Aerobic dancing 6.0 None x 0,75 Most x 1.25 22 Wu shu, karate, tae kwan tao 10.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25 23 Outdoor chores: gardening, car washing 4.5 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 24 Indoor chores: mopping, vacuuming,
sweeping
2.5 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25
25 Walking: to home or to school 4.0 Some x 1.1 Most x 1.25 26 Running: non athletics training 7.0 None x 0.75 Most x 1.25
27 Others: (physical activity classes, lessons,
or teams)
28 29
30
31
127
APPENDIX 5 Application letter to school principal
Dear Principal,
Application for permission to collect research data
My name is Hui Shun Wing and I am currently conducting a research study named: The prediction of physical activity levels of Hong Kong primary six and secondary three students from their attitudes toward physical activity: A partial test of Ajzen's Theory of Planned Behavior. It is a partial Mfillment to my part-time master degree course in physical education and sports science at the University of Hong Kong. I hereby request for your approval for me to collect the data in two classes in primary six / secondary three at your school.
The students will be given the children's attitudes toward physical activity inventory and self-administered physical activity checklists. The combined forms will take approximately 30 minutes to complete and will be administered during a physical education class. There are no risks to your students participating in the study.
If permission is gained, I shall contact the physical education teacher in your school to make the further arrangement. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me 26404033 (office). I will be happy to speak with you. Enclosed is the questionnaire that will be used in my study. Thank you for your attention.
Yours sincerely, Hui Shun Wing.
End.
128
APPENDIX 6 Parental consent letter
Dear Parent or Guardian,
My name is Hui Shun Wing and I am currently conducting a research study on students' attitudes toward physical activity and their physical activity levels in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a master degree in sports science at the University of Hong Kong. Your child is invited to act as subjects in this project
Your child will be asked to complete children's attitudes toward physical activity inventory and self-administered physical activity checklists. There are no risks to your child participating in this study. The responses of this questionnaire will not impact the grades in any subjects. You can be assured that all information obtained with this study will remain confidential.
If you have any concerns for this study, please feel free to contact Mr. Hui at 26404033 (office). Please have your child return the lower part of this page with your signed consent. I truly appreciate your attention to this project.
Yours sincerely, Hui Shun Wing.
(cut here)
(keep top portion, return bottom) Permission Slip
I have read the above and understand the nature of this study. I agree to have xny
child, participate in this study described above.
Student Name: Parent/Guardian Signature: Date:
129
APPENDIX 7 Instructions for the physical education teacher
First of all,thank you so much for agreeing to assist me in conducting my research. Your participation is invaluable!
Yours students will be completing children's attitudes toward physical activity inventory and self-administered physical activity checklists in a combined form.
To insure objectivity, please follow closely to all instructions. It is very important that all students are given the same instructions.
Preliminary information 1. The questionnaire will be given to primary six / secondary three students in any
two classes in your school. 2. Have the students complete the questionnaire anytime between now and Friday,2
March 2001. 3. It will be conducted during your students' regularly-schedules physical education
lessons. 4. The students will need a pen or pencil.
Test day 1. Distribute the questioimaire to the students and say: "Do not put your name on
your questionnaire. It has totally 6 pages and divides into two parts. Check it now”.
2. Read the purpose and instructions in Part one to the students and remind them to read each type of activity in Section B.
3. After all the students completing the Part one,read the following instructions and show a sample page (presented as an overhead) to entire class.
4. For each question in Part two,"there is a box,and in the box there is an idea. Down below the box are five different pairs of words. You will be marking these word pairs to show how you feel about the idea. Read the idea in the box (refer to the visual aid),for example, REFEREE. Now go down to the first pair words — Good-bad. How do you feel about Referees? If you think they are veiy good,you would put a “ v,,here (mark at the end of the scale by good) or, if you think that they are very bad, you would put a “ V ” here (mark at the end of the scale by bad). If you think that referees are pretty good but not super good you would put a “ V,,here (indicate) or if you thought that referees were sort of bad but not really bad you would put a “ v,,here (indicate). If you think that referees are neither good nor bad (i.e.,a neutral feeling) then put a “ V ” in the middle. If you
130
do not understand the idea in the box put a “ V ” in the do not understand box on the middle of the question. Then go to the next question. If you understand the idea in the box but not the word pair, leave the word pair the blank and go on to the next word pair. Do you have any questions?" (Schutz et al., 1985,p.262)
5. "It is important for you to remember several things. First of all, put your “ V ”
right in the middle of the space. Second, there are five pairs of words on each question, so how many “ V ”s will you have on each question? (Five).
6. When I tell you to begin,go through the questions page by page. Read the idea in the box on each question and fill in how you feel about all of the word pairs before you go on to the next question. Don't go back to a question after you have finished it; and don't try to remember how you answered the other questions. Think about each word pair by itself. As you go through the questionnaire go fairly quickly; don't worry or think too long about any word pair. Mark the first thing that comes into your mind, but don't be careless. Remember, the idea in the box at the top of each question is a new idea, so think only about that idea. When you ate all finished, put down your pen/pencil and go back through all the questions to make sure that you haven't left anything out by mistake. After you have finished checking, turn your questionnaire over and wait until everyone is finished. If you have any questions raise your hand and I will come around and help you. You may begin’’ (Schutz et a l , 1985,p.262).
7. After all the students completing both Part one and Part two, collect all questionnaires.
§ . •
131