รองศาสตราจารย ดร.เรณู พุกบุญมี
ประธานคณะกรรมการผู�บริหารวิทยาลัยการพยาบาลและการผดุงครรภขั้นสูง สภาการพยาบาล
ผู�อํานวยการโรงเรียนพยาบาลรามาธิบดี
28 พฤศจิกายน 2016
How to formulate research question from practice?
1 2
เขา้ใจลกัษณะและความรบัผิดชอบของวชิาชีพการพยาบาล
3 4
5 6
7 8
9 10
11Research 12
How to formulate research question from practice?
IDENTIFYING CLINICAL RESEARCH QUESTIONSTHAT FIT PRACTICE
Identify Good Research Questions
How to find good clinical questions for research?
Finding a Clinical Research Question
มองหาคําถามวิจัย ….� ผู�ปZวยและการดูแลท่ีผู�ปZวยได�รับ
� การระดมสมองเพื่อนร̂วมงาน
� Research agendas
เริ่มต�นด�วยถามตัวเราเองว̂า……• Do we have the science to support patient care
decisions?• Do we know where to find it and how to use it?
ผูป่้วยและการดูแลที ผูป่้วยไดร้บั
การระดมสมองเพื อนรว่มงาน16
Example of Clinical Question
17
Example of Clinical Question
�Health promotion
�Nursing‐sensitive patient outcomes� Patient Safety
�Cancer symptoms and side effects
� Psychosocial and family issues
� End of life issues
EXAMPLES OF IDENTIFIED RESEARCH PRIORITIES
FROM PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE
Research Agendas
19
IDENTIFYING CLINICAL RESEARCH QUESTIONSTHAT FIT PRACTICE PRIORITIES
Prioritizing The Questions…
How to prioritize clinical questions for potential research projects?
Process for Evaluating Questions
– “Triaging” the clinical questions– Focusing questions– Prioritizing questions
Be Pragmatic When Prioritizing
The most ideal clinical questions are those with:
� High institutional priority
– Addresses regulatory requirements
– Meets key organizational goals / objectives
– Addresses balanced score card targets
� Large number of subjects available
� Important clinical outcomes
� No requirement for additional funding or equipment
� Existing tools for measurement (questionnaires)
� The least amount of outside work required (outside usual care routines)
พิจารณาคําถามวิจัยจากปรากฏการณท่ี....
� High risk
� High volume
� High benefit
� Something that excites you!
การวเิคราะหป์ญัหาวจิยั
�สภาพการณ์เกี ยวกบัปญัหาทางคลนิิกที สนใจ�ความจรงิเกี ยวกบัปญัหาทางคลนิิกที สนใจ�คาํอธิบายเกี ยวกบัปญัหาทางคลนิิกที สนใจ
สิ่งท่ีต�องการทราบคอือะไร? ....…
� Evaluate quality of care delivery systems?
� Evaluate a process change for improvement?
� Develop new knowledge or address a gap in science?
� Evaluate how existing knowledge is being used?
Focus your question คําถามท่ีต�องการคําตอบนั้นเปmนคาํถามชนิดไหน?.......
1. Need to evaluate processes of care or improve care delivery….� Process Improvement questions� Quality assurance; quality improvement questions� Healthcare delivery science questions2. Need to answer something new or generate new knowledge about patient care .....� Research questions� Scientific inquiry questions3. How well existing science is used in care…..� Evidence-based practice questions� Implementation science questions
29
What is Evidence-Based Practice (EBP)?
� The conscientious, explicit, and judicious
use of [existing] scientific evidence to make decisions about the care of individual patients.
30
EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE FRAMEWORK
� Step 1: Formulate a well-built question
� Step 2: Identify articles and other evidence-based resources
that answer the question
� Step 3: Critically appraise the existing evidence to assess its
validity
� Step 4: Apply the evidence
� Step 5: Re-evaluate the application of evidence and areas for improvement
31 32
33
Formulating the EBP Question
� Use PICO :
� The Patient’s disorder or disease
� The Intervention or finding under review
� A Comparison intervention (if applicable—not always present)
� The Outcome
PICOT: ….. T = Time ……
34
What is Process Improvement (PI/QI)?
The use of analytical decision making tools to
� make observations of care processes and
� determine when these processes are working effectively and when they are not.
Variation is present in any process; deciding
� when the variation is acceptable and when it
� needs correction is the key to quality control.
PROCESS/QUALITY IMPROVEMENT FRAMEWORK
For quality and process evaluation use a systematic approach:
� D – Define the problem
� M – Measure existing practice and identify gaps
� A – Analyze
� I - Implement a process change
� C – Control the long term implementation of change
37
What is Research?
�A systematic investigation (including development, testing and evaluation) designed to develop or contribute to new, generalizable knowledge.”
38
The Research and PI Processes
Use A Similar Systematic Approach:
1. Identify and focus the clinical question
2. Review existing literature and validate the gap in science
3. Develop a feasible and realistic protocol to address the gap
4. Collect and manage data (enrollment processes)
5. Analyze the results
6. Discuss results in the context of existing science
7. Implement new knowledge into practice and monitor effects over time!
39
PI and Research: Same or Different?
PI:� Identify a system or process
problem
� Track the clinical problem
� Goal: to identify trends in practice
� Results used for improved
performance at the site
Example:
– Smoking cessation
– Peripheral IV dressings
Research:� Intent to publish!
� Usually clinical problem or gap in
knowledge
� Using what we know (existing
data) to explore, compare or test a
new concept or intervention
� Use existing data before gathering
new data:
– PI data, Pilot studies
– The Literature
40
EBNP
41
การวเิคราะหป์ญัหาวจิยั
� สภาพการณ์เกี ยวกบัปญัหาทางคลนิิกที สนใจ
� ความจรงิเกี ยวกบัปญัหาทางคลนิิกที สนใจ
� คาํอธิบายเกี ยวกบัปญัหาทางคลนิิกที สนใจ
� Significance of making it interesting and relevant
� Conducting literature review
� Refining research question
43 44
45