November, 2007
Mercer’s Global HR Transformation StudyIt’s all about the business
최종연 부사장, Ph. D.Mercer Korea
Mercer Korea 2
Today’s discussion
배경 - Background on Mercer’s Global HR Transformation Study
2003 연구 - Transformation v1.0: A look back to the beginning
Biz 중심 - The shift from HR-focused to business-focused transformation
HR의향후방향 - Transformation v2.0: Moving HR forward
Mercer Korea 3
Study background
Mercer Korea 4
2006 Global HR Transformation Study
1400명응답- Approximately 1,400 respondents in 2006– Up from nearly 1,100 respondents in 2003
지역 - Regions covered in 2006:– Asia– Australia– Europe– Latin America– New Zealand– North America (Canada and the US)
산업망라 - Broad cross-section of companies by industry
지역에걸친일관성 - Relatively consistent responses across geographies in 2006
Mercer Korea 5
Study participants by region in 2006
North America(Canada and US)
154
Latin America and Mexico
191
Asia 619
Australia and New Zealand
100
Europe 338
Mercer Korea 6
Defining HR transformationHR Transformation은 HR 기능을리엔지니어링, 리스트럭처링, HR시스템혁신, 아웃소싱, 코소싱등을통해재창조하는과정임. 이를통해 HR의공헌도를강화하기위함
HR transformation is the process of recreating or reinventing the HR function via
– reengineering – restructuring – implementing new systems or
a new HR service delivery model– outsourcing or – co-sourcing
with the intent of enhancing HR’s contribution to the business.
Mercer Korea 7
Key finding: HR is definitely busy transforming글로벌차원에서약 50%의회사들이 HR을 Transforming하거나, 끝냈음
50% globally
24%
19%
23%
16%
24%
50%
66%
47%
46%
8%
8%
11%
15%
9%
18%
7%
19%
23%
20%47%
NA
LA
Europe
Australia/NZ
Asia
Have completed an HRtransformation
Currently transforming
Plan to start a transformationin the next 12 months
No plans to transform
Mercer Korea 8
Key finding: Focus of HR transformation is shifting과거의포커스가운영차원에있었다면전략적이슈에대한부분에서사업파트너로서조직의탤런트관리및 Human Capital전략의실행에집중
Earlytransformation
focus
운영효율성중심Enhancing operational excellenceImproving service deliveryMaking technical process enhancements
Futuretransformation
focus
사업파트너, 인재경영, 인적자본전략실행Serving as business partner to leadershipManaging the organization’s talentImplementing the human capital strategy
Currentfocus
전략적이슈이동Delivering on operational expectationsGetting “house” in order so HR can focus on more strategic aspects
Transformation is not a one-time event!일회성이아니라, 지속적인활동
Mercer Korea 9
Critical questions for the future of HR and HR transformation – 핵심 질문
HR은진보하는지, 적절한방향으로가고있는지? Is HR making progress – and in the right direction?
HR의진보가이루어지지않은영역과, 이유는? Wherehas HR not made progress and why?
어떻게 HRT가지역별로차이가나타나는지? How does HR transformation vary around the world?
HRT의미래성공을위해조직을어떻게포지셔닝해야하는지? How can organizations position themselves for success in the next wave of HR transformation?
무엇이미래성공적인 HR 역할인지? What will the successful HR function of the future look like?
Mercer Korea 10
Transformation v1.0A look back to the beginning
Mercer Korea 11
A look at early HR transformation efforts
5~10년전처음시작 - First wave started 5 to 10 years ago
포괄적조직변화에서시작 - Driven largely by broader organizational changes
HR의중요성상승 - Key goal was to get HR a “seat at the table”
Focus of change was heavily on HR infrastructure– 인트라넷활용 - More than three-quarters of organizations
globally deployed an intranet to support program and process delivery
– 기술과프로세스통합 - Two-thirds had integrated processes with changing technology
– 조직변화완료 - 50% had completed some form of HR organizational change
– 아웃소싱시작 - Outsourcing gained traction, but still seemed more opportunistic than strategic
FindingsfromMercer’s2003 study
Mercer Korea 12
A look at early HR transformation effortsAssessing the effectiveness of the HR function
Top transformation activities already completed by 2006:
HR조직체계의실행 - Implementation of a new HR organizational structure
HR고객니즈와요구사항의평가- Assessment of HR customers’needs/requirements
HR서비스제공전략설계 - Design of a new strategy for delivering HR services
HR기능효과성의측정 - Assessment of HR function’s effectiveness
현행 HRIS 기술의감사 - Audit of current HRIS technology
Mercer Korea 13
Transformation transformsShifting from HR-focused to business-focused transformation
Mercer Korea 14
What’s changing and why?HR priorities are evolving – it’s all about talent now
전략역할증대 - Human capital strategy as a principal function of HR jumps from 40% to 64% within two to three years
운영차원감소- Operational excellence as a principal function drops from 46% to 32%
Principal HR function (Top six as ranked by future priority) Now 2-3 years인적자원전략 - Human capital strategy 40% 64%
인재경영 - Talent management 49% 55%
리더십개발 - Leadership development 49% 52%
조직개발 - Organization development 35% 40%
변화관리 - Change management 42% 38%조직효율성 - Operational excellence within the HR function 46% 32%
Mercer Korea 15
What’s changing and why?Attention is turning to new transformation initiatives
Activities CompletedPlanning to complete in the next 12 months
Not under consideration for the next 12 months
Implementation of a new HR organizational structure 45% 41% 13%
Assessment of HR customers’ needs/requirements 44% 42% 14%
Design of a new strategy for delivering HR services 38% 51% 11%
Assessment of HR function’s effectiveness 38% 44% 18%
Audit of current HRIS technology 35% 39% 26%
Redesign of HR work processes 30% 60% 10%
Decentralization of selected programs to the business, e.g., performance management
27% 37% 36%
Evaluation/implementation of new HRIS technology 24% 50% 26%
Outsource any part of the HR function 24% 28% 48%
Strategy for attraction/retention of the HR staff 23% 47% 30%
Changes in reward strategy for HR staff 19% 35% 46%
Talent development strategy for improving skills within HR 18% 66% 16%
Mercer Korea 16
What’s changing and why?Top human capital challenges are consistent globally
Top human capital challenges Global AsiaAustralia
& NZ EuropeLatin
AmericaNorth
America
핵심인재확보 1
2
3
1 2 2 1
문화및행동변화 3 1 1 3
리더십역량구축 3 1 3 2 2
핵심인재유지 2 3
• Increasing workforce productivity• Headcount constraints (“making do with less”)• Resourcing/managing HR issues in new geographies• Reducing overall human capital costs • Coping with an aging workforce• Workforce planning• Succession planning• Increasing line managers’ people-management
capabilities
• Increasing ROI in remuneration• Measuring how human capital contributes to
business performance• Managing human capital during and after an
acquisition/merger • Lack of consensus on organization’s
strategy/direction• Implementing people changes due to
operational performance changes
Other human capital challenges not ranked in the top three:
Mercer Korea 17
What’s changing and why?Interest in outsourcing/co-sourcing is up, but varies globally –아웃소싱/코소싱필요성은증대
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Recruitment administration
Remuneration administration
Training administration
Performance mgmt. administration
Payroll
OHS&E
Pension administration
Benefits administration
HRIS
Asia
Europe
LA
NA
Percent co-sourced/outsourced*Australia/New Zealand data not included
Mercer Korea 18
What’s not changing?Drivers of HR transformation remain the same –조직변화에대한대응중요
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
Company-wide cost reduction mandate
Responding to changes in the organization
It was part of a broader organization-widetransformation process
Change in domestic market environment or regulation
CEO/business leader mandate for change in the HRand/or other staff functions
Leadership changes in the HR function
HR was not adding value in its existing role Australia/New Zealand
Asia
Europe
LA
NA
Mercer Korea 19
What’s not changing?Time spent on various HR activities –전략기능투입증대에대한요구는있으나실제적인변화는안됨
전략파트너
HR프로그램 시스템설계
Mercer Korea 20
What’s not changing?HR staff skills sets misaligned with future needs – HR 스킬은변화가별로없음
Strongest skills currently Weak Sufficient Strong
Interpersonal skills 9% 43% 48%
Team skills 12% 44% 45%
Recordkeeping/data maintenance 10% 48% 43%
Functional HR experience team skills 15% 45% 40%
Customer service 15% 47% 39%
Interviewing and assessment 19% 44% 37%
Client relationship management 26% 49% 26%
Knowledge of compliance / corporate governance 25% 50% 25%
Counseling 33% 43% 24%
Leadership 28% 48% 23%
Consultation/negotiation skills 30% 48% 23%
Technology understanding 31% 52% 17%
Vendor management 34% 52% 14%
Mercer Korea 21
What’s not changing?HR staff skills sets misaligned with future needs –미래조직의요구사항/사업및조직변화에대한대응부족
Weakest skills currently Weak Sufficient Strong
Financial skills(재무) 51% 40% 9%
Business strategy skills(전략) 50% 37% 13%
Organizational assessment/organizational design(조직) 48% 38% 14%
Cross-functional expertise(다기능) 47% 41% 11%
Cost analysis and measurement(비용분석측정) 47% 39% 14%
Cultural change/ transformation skills(문화변화) 44% 39% 17%
Change management (변화관리) 44% 39% 17%
Project management(프로젝트관리) 40% 45% 15%
HRIS data analysis and reporting 37% 44% 18%
Process management/ process improvement 36% 45% 19%
Business understanding 35% 45% 20%
Coaching/facilitation 34% 43% 23%
Conflict management 34% 44% 22%
Mercer Korea 22
What’s driving these changes? – 변화 추동인
글로벌화 - Globalization of business
인적자원전략의중요성대두 - Human capital strategy is more top-of-mind– 60% of respondents have long-term strategy linked to
organizational goals– 80% of those respondents have that strategy documented and
socialized with management
인재는사업성공에중요요소 - Talent is even more critical to business success: attraction, retention, motivation
인구통계적변화 - Demographic shifts– Aging workforce, especially in certain industries– Skill shortages in many countries and regions– Generational issues: At least four generations in the work force
Mercer Korea 23
So what? Conclusions and contradictions
HR 스텝의스킬보완 - No comprehensive plans to address HR staffs’ skill deficits– High resistance to replacing HR staff who lack necessary skill
sets for the future
전략의실행미비 - “Talking” strategy, but “walking”transactions
HR지표미비 - HR wants to deliver value, but it is neglecting to use metrics to document and demonstrate value
HR 구조, 스텝, 프로세스, 기술지원미비 - Articulated human capital strategy not being delivered on due to shortcomings with HR structure, staff, processes and technology
Mercer Korea 24
Transformation 2.0Moving HR forward
Mercer Korea 25
What should HR focus on now? – HR의 미래촛점
전략적역할증대 - Upgrading HR skills broadly to support the function’s strategic mandate
인적자원전략의실행 - Operationalizing the human capital strategy throughout the organization
HR의역할배분 - Considering the splitting of HR into two critical roles
HR성과지표 - Developing and using better metrics to evaluate HR’s performance and its impact on the business
글로벌관점 - Gaining a truly global perspective
효과적인 HR지배구조 - Establishing effective HRgovernance
Mercer Korea 26
Upgrading HR skillsHR leaders already on the strategic path
HR리더는 10년이상 HR경험보유 - New crop of HR leaders: Two-thirds in current position 4 or fewer years (but three-fourths in HR for more than 8 years)
67% report directly to the CEO; 59% have significant board contact beyond compensation
Mercer Korea 27
Upgrading HR skillsHR leaders bring a wealth of experience –다양한경험획득필요
51% 38% 12%
56% 27% 17%
57% 26% 17%
41% 41% 17%
55% 28% 17%
51% 28% 22%
47% 30% 23%
39% 35% 27%
37% 29% 34%
21% 41% 38%HR consulting
General management
Customer service
Operations management
Legal
Finance
Public relations / communication
Manufacturing
Information systems
Sales / marketing
No experience
< 5 years
> 5 years
Mercer Korea 28
Upgrading HR skillsAssessment of HR staffs remains disjointed
Staff weaknessesFinancial skillsBusiness strategyOrg. assessment/designCross-functional expertiseCost analysis/measurement
Staff strengthsInterpersonal skillsTeam skillsRecordkeepingFunctional HR expertiseCustomer service
AdvancedConsulting/negotiation (65%)Leadership (64%)Cultural change (60%)Business understanding (59%)Org. assessment/design (51%)Business strategy (49%)
Future “must have” skillsAt least basic
Financial (66%)Vendor management (61%)Technology understanding (60%)Cost analysis/measurement (59%)Cross-functional expertise (55%)Project management (55%)
Mercer Korea 29
Upgrading HR skillsSome wishful thinking – Skill Gap은교육으로보완
47% plan an attraction and retention program for HR staff in coming year (only 23% have one already)
Most plan to address HR skill deficits with training
Similar disconnect between goal and action in 2003
Method Global Aust/NZ Europe LA NA
Replace current staff with new hires 6% 3% 6% 9% 12%
Invest in skill development for existing staff 66% 71% 70% 67% 56%
Rotate HR staff to line roles 11% 10% 10% 7% 8%
Rotate line staff to HR roles 10% 12% 12% 8% 5%
Use outsourcing/external suppliersto supplement internal capability 17% 1% 18% 21% 16%
Mercer Korea 30
Operationalize the human capital strategy프로그램, 프로세스, Tool, 기술 등과의 연계 필요
Having a human capital strategy is nice, but it’s no better than a glossy mission statement if not implementedeffectively through the organization
Much work left to be done to connect critical parties –senior managers, line managers & supervisors, employees – to roles and responsibilities
Need right programs, processes, tools, training, communication, change management
Technology will play a vital role – need seamless management of recruiting, performance management, career, development, etc.
Mercer Korea 31
Linking human capital and HR function strategies to business strategy
Human capitalstrategy
How will we secure, manage and motivate a workforce that can execute business strategy?
HR functionstrategy
HR operating model
Sourcing(외부소싱)What activities will we do ourselves/ have others do?
InfrastructureWhat capabilities are needed to fulfill HR’s strategy?
Process
People Organization
Technology
Governance(Control체계)How will we lead the function and manage related investments?
Performance monitoring (HR scorecard)
How will we deliver expected value and contribution to the organization?
Businessstrategy/market
dynamics
What are the changing business priorities?
What new business designs will be operating?
Mercer Korea 32
Consider the bifurcation of HRSeparate strategic and transactional responsibilities(2가지 Role이중요해짐)
Both roles essential to a high-performing HR function
More than 40% of respondents already have HR controller position
Strategic responsibility
responsible for business alignment and human capital
strategy
Transactional/operational responsibility
responsible for managing HR budget, costs, vendors, metrics
and service delivery
Chief HR officerChief HR officer HR controllerHR controller
Mercer Korea 33
Consider the bifurcation of HR‘Strategic transacting’ is an important concept
Ensure that all transactions are done well and in alignment with overall human capital strategy
Example: if hiring and on-boarding are not handled well as transactions, they can become strategic problems quickly – higher turnover, talent drain, etc.
Strategic transaction
lens
Operationalized HR strategy
Mercer Korea 34
Develop and use hard metrics
Top measures of HR effectiveness Global Asia
Australia & NZ Europe
Latin America
North America
HR customer satisfaction 1
2
HR program effectiveness 3 2 3 3
Processes in place to lead/ facilitate org. change 3
1 1 1 1 2
HR cost 2 2 1
HR staff/employee ratio 3 3
Impact on business operations/outcomes 2
Is this how other functions, such as finance, measure their success?
Mercer Korea 35
Develop and use hard metrics
HR should capture and analyze data to show:
How turnover patterns and age demographics will affect growth plans
How well internal staff fit the skills profile needed
Whether the company’s development and succession plans are filling the pipeline with qualified future candidates
Whether the company is retaining its top performers
Where inside the company it can find the necessary skills and competencies for certain jobs
Whether certain HR policies, programs or practices are having the desired effect – or unintended consequences
Mercer Korea 36
Enhance your global perspective
Transformation v1.0 focused on domestic service delivery
For organizations that wish to compete globally, Transformation v2.0 must focus on understanding
– Scale/economics– Language– Cultural and regulatory requirements– How to structure centers of expertise– How to scale services to fit large and small markets– How to serve both mature and emerging markets
Mercer Korea 37
Establish effective HR governance
작동불능이유 - Transformation efforts don’t always work
HR지배구조 - Efforts often lack HR governance – CHRO or advisory committee oversight no longer enough
주요이해관계자개입 - Engage key stakeholders –business leaders, finance and IT leaders, line managers
적절한연계 - Properly aligned HR governance– Optimizes performance of human capital assets– Fulfills fiduciary responsibilities– Mitigates enterprise HR risk– Aligns function’s priorities with those of the business– Enables HR executive decision making
Mercer Korea 38
Establish effective HR governanceFive core elements
1. 구조및책임 - Structure and accountability for guiding group (council) – usually via a charter
2. 효과적인회의체운영 - Effective councils
3. 철학및운영원칙 - Philosophy and operating principles – setting out function’s risk tolerance, delegating authority, autonomy of business units or geographies
4. 핵심관리 체계 - Core management – strategy development, business planning, program oversight, resource allocation, HR staff development
5. 성과모니터링 - Performance monitoring – framework and metrics to evaluate function’s effectiveness and contribution
Mercer Korea 39
HR Transformation v2.0What will success look like?
인적자본전략은실행력확보필요 - Human capital strategy operationalized throughout business and functions
HR 스텝은보다전략적이슈이해필요 - HR staffunderstand business issues and needs and apply knowledge across all parts of their mission
관리는전략, 재무, 서비스목표와연계 - Administrationand recordkeeping done in line with strategic, financial and service goals
HR조직의목표명확화 - HR organization has clear goalsAND clear metrics for evaluating performance
사업성공을위한인재에초점 - HR professionals focus on identifying and managing talent to build the business
Mercer Korea 40
HR Measurement Model – Core Measures도시바
Organizational Effectiveness
Human Capital ROI 1.86 HC Value Added $110,429 Revenue Factor $236,507 Expense Factor $196,054 Income Factor $26,327 % employees satisfied with work environment % of new hires/promoted employees with
satisfactory performance after 6 months
Effectiveness of HC Practices
Turnover 19.7% Voluntary Turnover 14.3% Involuntary Turnover 5.6% Average performance rating of new hires Internal transfers/external hires for key jobs External Offer Acceptance Rate 88.4% % of employees satisfied with benefits program % of employees satisfied with compensation
program
HR Customer Satisfaction
% of HR customers who are satisfied with HRservice levels
% of line managers satisfied with the alignmentof HR strategy and business strategy
% of internal customers that rate staffingfunction highly
% of employees who feel that employeerelations issues are handled in a timely andresponsible manner
% of employees who are satisfied with the waychanges in HR programs are communicated
HR Department Effectiveness
Cost per hire – External/Internal $3,820/$4,324Time to fill – External/Internalnal36 days/51 days
Training Investment Factor $579 Training Cost Factor $698 Employees Trained % 161.6% Total Labor Cost Revenue % 30.3% Total Labor Cost Expense % 35.8% HR FTE Ratio 1:100 HR Investment Factor $787 HR Expense Percent .9% Time to investigate and resolve grievances
Mercer Korea 41
Mercer’s Global HR Transformation Study
Questions?
Visit mercerHR.com/globalhrtransformation to download our new global Point of View paper and regional reports on HR transformation.