Transcript
Page 1: S k © Ã ) / O 0 Ú E (2)2017/03/22  · Good r f E C ý ý r × O F ( 0 ) C Ä 74 B ó ð È c ÷ « Dr. Robert Good + F % s ñ É % s d x ô C ô M Ð É ½ b Ð ¸ } M } ± h õ

(misconduct)

/ / / (http://

albertjenyihchu.blogspot.com/2014/07/blog-

post_81.html) 1

Summerlin Sloan-Kettering2

( Sc ience ) 3 , 4

( J A M A ) 5 T h e

Patchwork Mouse ( 1)6

Dr. Summerlin

( )

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

6 Cornella

Dr. Bardley Mondino

Dr. Summerlin Minnesota

(

2)

St. Louis Cardinal Glennon

(2)

1 .( https://www.

amazon.com/patchwork-mouse-Joseph-R-Hixson/dp/0385028520)

2017 61 3 78

Page 2: S k © Ã ) / O 0 Ú E (2)2017/03/22  · Good r f E C ý ý r × O F ( 0 ) C Ä 74 B ó ð È c ÷ « Dr. Robert Good + F % s ñ É % s d x ô C ô M Ð É ½ b Ð ¸ } M } ± h õ

(

2)

40

6

Dr.

Summerlin Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Medical

World News Clinical Trends

Interlibrary Loan Medical World

News 1974 Reject ion takes a

culture bath 7

( 2)

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Simmerlin

Dr. Summerlin

2. Medical World News 1974 Rejection takes a culture bath 7

( Interlibrary Loan Medical World News)

2017 61 3 79

Page 3: S k © Ã ) / O 0 Ú E (2)2017/03/22  · Good r f E C ý ý r × O F ( 0 ) C Ä 74 B ó ð È c ÷ « Dr. Robert Good + F % s ñ É % s d x ô C ô M Ð É ½ b Ð ¸ } M } ± h õ

D r . S u m m e r l i n h o n e s t

mistake

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Sloan-Ket te r ing Ins t i tu te

(Summerl in Peer Reviewing

Committee) Dr. Robert Good

Sloan Kettering

1946 Sloan-Kettering

C. Chester Stock, Ph.D.

The Patchwork Mouse6

Dr. Summerlin

(mislead)

Dr. Summerlin

(misunderstood and

consequently, unintentionally misrepresented

3. Dr. Summerlin( )( : http://www.delfi.lt/gyvenimas/archive/kodel-mokslininkai-sukciauja.d?id=21245123)

(

2)

2017 61 3 80

Page 4: S k © Ã ) / O 0 Ú E (2)2017/03/22  · Good r f E C ý ý r × O F ( 0 ) C Ä 74 B ó ð È c ÷ « Dr. Robert Good + F % s ñ É % s d x ô C ô M Ð É ½ b Ð ¸ } M } ± h õ

one of my collaborative projects)

Dr. Good

Dr. Good

6 1980

8

Dr. Good

Dr. Summer l in

Sloan-Kettering

($40,000) Conneticut

Darien

Science9 $40,000

Darien, Connecticut

tempting reward( ) Darien

S l o a n - K e t t e r i n g

Drs. John H. Raaf John L.

Ninnemann 10 Science 3,4

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerl in

honest mistake

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin11 Connecticut

Louisiana New Orleans area 10

Tulane University Medical School

1987 Arkansas

Summerlin Dermatology

40

Dr. Summerlin

Minnesota

honest mistake

JAMA5

Dr. Good

3-6 Dr. Summerlin

(his presentation

was lucid and convincing) Science

(

2)

2017 61 3 81

Page 5: S k © Ã ) / O 0 Ú E (2)2017/03/22  · Good r f E C ý ý r × O F ( 0 ) C Ä 74 B ó ð È c ÷ « Dr. Robert Good + F % s ñ É % s d x ô C ô M Ð É ½ b Ð ¸ } M } ± h õ

Dr. Summerlin2

Dr.

Summerlin

Drs. Raaf Ninnemann

(Dr.

Good)

S c i e n c e 2 4 D r .

Summerlin

Dr. Good

Dr. Good (a kind of

challenge, a gesture to test Dr. Good's attention

and acumen) Dr. Summerlin Dr.

Good ( )4

Dr. Robert Good

Science

Dr. Good

Dr. Good

(We can't let him be dragged down by this) 4

Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good Dr. Good

Dr. Good

Time (

4)

4. Dr . Rober t Good 1973 3 19( T i m e ) (

(http:/ /content.t ime.com/t ime/covers/0,16641,19730319,00.html)

(

2)

2017 61 3 82

Page 6: S k © Ã ) / O 0 Ú E (2)2017/03/22  · Good r f E C ý ý r × O F ( 0 ) C Ä 74 B ó ð È c ÷ « Dr. Robert Good + F % s ñ É % s d x ô C ô M Ð É ½ b Ð ¸ } M } ± h õ

Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good

Dr.

Good

Science

occasional 3

Sloan-Kettering

1. / /

/ : h t t p : / /

albertjenyihchu.blogspot.com/2014/07/blog-

post_81.html (2017.2.5)

2. (1)

2017; 61(1): 82-7.

3. Culliton BJ: The Sloan-Kettering Affair: A

story without a hero. Science 1974; 184: 644-

50.

4. Culliton BJ: The Sloan-Kettering Affair(II):

An uneasy resolution. Science 1974; 184:

1154-7.

5. Anon: The Sloan-Kettering Affair: Could it

have happened anywhere? JAMA 229; 1391-

410.

6. Hixson JR: The Patchwork Mouse. Anchor

Press/Doubleday. Garden City, NY; 1976.

7. Anon: Rejection takes a culture bath

Medical World News 1974; 15(11): 13-4.

8.

2016 12 21 http://

www.peoplenews.tw/news/be2d009f-f6fa-

4357-a219-4deef6edc699 (2017.2.5)

9. Faber BL: Letter. Science 1974; 185: 734.

10. Raaf JH, Ninnemann JL: Letter 1974; 185:

734.

11. W i l l i a m S u m m e r l i n , M . D .

h t t p s : / / w w w. f l i c k r. c o m / p e o p l e /

williamsummerlinmd (2017.2.5)

(

2)

2017 61 3 83


Top Related