general cui fen’s fresco-walled tomb of northern qi period ... archaeology/general cui fen's...

10
125 Volume 3 Cui Fen 崔芬, style name Bomao 伯茂, was born in Dongwucheng 东武城, Qinghe 清河 (the present-day Wucheng 武城 County). During the Northern Wei period, he took the post of the commandery gongcao 功曹 and prefecture zhubo 主簿. In the 5th year of Wuding 武定 reign period of the Eastern Wei Dynasty (AD 547 ), he took the office of biejia 别驾 of his prefecture. In the 8th year of Wuding reign period, he was conferred the title of Illustrious General and assumed the office of Zhangshi 长史 under Military Commander of the Southern Campaign. He died at the age of 84 on October 19th, 550, the 1st year of Tianbao 天保 reign period of the Northern Qi Dynasty. On October 9th in the 2nd year of Tianbao reign period he was buried on the south slope of Mount Fu 浮山, to the south of Spring Ye 冶泉 (the present-day south slope of Mount Haifu 海浮山, Yeyuan 冶源 Township, Linqu 临朐 County). Cui’s tomb was discovered on April 2nd, 1986 and the salvage excava- tion was made from April 16th to May 16th. I. Tomb Structure The tomb is constructed at 150 degrees on the compass and consists of the tomb passage, aisle, and chamber. It is shaped like the Chinese character “甲” in profile (Fig. 1). The joining place between the northern end of the remaining slope-shaped tomb passageway and the aisle is slightly out-curving and flanked by a short earth wall on either side while the bottom is flat and horizontal. The aisle is paved with stone slabs and flanked by walls made of a single stone slab on both sides and covered by a slab on the ceiling. At the south end is a General Cui Fen’s Fresco-walled Tomb of Northern Qi Period in Linqu, Shandong Shandong Provincial Institute of Antiquity and Archaeology and Linqu County Museum Keywords: Cui Fen tomb structure burial accessories fresco stone-cut door with two panels. The door is sealed with 10 pieces of irregular stone outside at the lower section. On the inner side of the door are engraved four rows of bas-reliefs of acanthus or lotus design, each with five diamond or ring patterns for decoration. On the upper and lower ends of the door are carved acanthus designs in band pattern; round the iron doorknocker are lotus and acanthus relieves with interlocking branches and leaves. The tomb chamber is neatly layered with rectan- gular stone blocks and the cracks between the stone blocks are filled with lime. It is square in profile, measuring 3.58 m in side length. The center of the upper section of the four walls is slightly out-curving and the ceiling of the chamber is shaped like an inverted funnel, measuring 3.32 m in height. The chamber is paved with stone slabs on the bottom. In the center of the lower section on the south wall is a door leading to the aisle. The flank of the gatepost bears acanthus patterns in line carving. On the upper section of the eastern gatepost are two Chinese characters in regular script “□统”and on the eastern end of the threshold is an incised inscription“大.The door opens inward. Its decoration is roughly the same as that of the stone-cut tomb door, only with an addition of flying clouds pattern in the middle section. The north and west walls each feature an inset niche in the center of the lower section (the side room). In the west section of the tomb chamber is a coffin platform, most slabs of which had been removed from their original places. The wooden coffin painted black with flying clouds patterns in red had long decayed with the skeleton inside.

Upload: others

Post on 03-Feb-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 125Volume 3

    Cui Fen 崔芬, style name Bomao 伯茂, was born in

    Dongwucheng 东武城, Qinghe 清河 (the present-day

    Wucheng 武城 County). During the Northern Wei period,

    he took the post of the commandery gongcao 功曹 and

    prefecture zhubo 主簿. In the 5th year of Wuding 武定

    reign period of the Eastern Wei Dynasty (AD 547 ), he

    took the office of biejia 别驾 of his prefecture. In the 8th

    year of Wuding reign period, he was conferred the title

    of Illustrious General and assumed the office of Zhangshi

    长史 under Military Commander of the Southern

    Campaign. He died at the age of 84 on October 19th,

    550, the 1st year of Tianbao 天保 reign period of the

    Northern Qi Dynasty. On October 9th in the 2nd year of

    Tianbao reign period he was buried on the south slope of

    Mount Fu 浮山, to the south of Spring Ye 冶泉 (the

    present-day south slope of Mount Haifu 海浮山, Yeyuan

    冶源 Township, Linqu 临朐 County). Cui’s tomb was

    discovered on April 2nd, 1986 and the salvage excava-

    tion was made from April 16th to May 16th.

    I. Tomb Structure

    The tomb is constructed at 150 degrees on the

    compass and consists of the tomb passage, aisle, and

    chamber. It is shaped like the Chinese character“甲” in

    profile (Fig. 1). The joining place between the northern

    end of the remaining slope-shaped tomb passageway

    and the aisle is slightly out-curving and flanked by a

    short earth wall on either side while the bottom is flat and

    horizontal.

    The aisle is paved with stone slabs and flanked by

    walls made of a single stone slab on both sides and

    covered by a slab on the ceiling. At the south end is a

    General Cui Fen’s Fresco-walled Tombof Northern Qi Period in Linqu,

    Shandong

    Shandong Provincial Institute of Antiquity and Archaeology

    and

    Linqu County Museum

    Keywords: Cui Fen tomb structure burial accessories fresco

    stone-cut door with two panels. The door is sealed with

    10 pieces of irregular stone outside at the lower section.

    On the inner side of the door are engraved four rows of

    bas-reliefs of acanthus or lotus design, each with five

    diamond or ring patterns for decoration. On the upper

    and lower ends of the door are carved acanthus designs

    in band pattern; round the iron doorknocker are lotus

    and acanthus relieves with interlocking branches and

    leaves.

    The tomb chamber is neatly layered with rectan-

    gular stone blocks and the cracks between the stone

    blocks are filled with lime. It is square in profile,

    measuring 3.58 m in side length. The center of the

    upper section of the four walls is slightly out-curving

    and the ceiling of the chamber is shaped like an inverted

    funnel, measuring 3.32 m in height. The chamber is

    paved with stone slabs on the bottom. In the center of the

    lower section on the south wall is a door leading to the

    aisle. The flank of the gatepost bears acanthus patterns

    in line carving. On the upper section of the eastern

    gatepost are two Chinese characters in regular script

    “□统”and on the eastern end of the threshold is an

    incised inscription“大.”The door opens inward. Its

    decoration is roughly the same as that of the stone-cut

    tomb door, only with an addition of flying clouds pattern

    in the middle section. The north and west walls each

    feature an inset niche in the center of the lower section

    (the side room). In the west section of the tomb chamber

    is a coffin platform, most slabs of which had been

    removed from their original places. The wooden coffin

    painted black with flying clouds patterns in red had long

    decayed with the skeleton inside.

  • 126 Chinese Archaeology

    II. Burial Accessories

    The remaining burial accessories include celadon,

    pottery, bronze and silver wares and stone epitaphs.

    A celadon jar. Small upright mouth, round belly

    and flat bottom. On the shoulder are symmetrically

    arrayed four bridge-shaped loop handles and two kneaded

    dual loop handles. The shoulder and belly are both

    covered with reverted and upturned lotus patterns and

    flying clouds patterns, green glazed, 28.2 cm in height

    (Fig. 2).

    A celadon pot with chicken-headed spout. Dish-

    shaped mouth, deep thin neck, deep round belly, flat

    bottom, with chicken-headed spout. The joining section

    between the double bar-shaped handle and the dish-

    shaped mouth is gone. Two bridge-shaped loop handles

    on either side, four bands of line patterns on the neck in

    intaglio for decoration. Green glazed both inside and

    outside. The remaining height is 29.1 cm (Fig. 3).

    Two pieces of celadon dou-pedestral stand. Shal-

    Fig. 1 Plan and elevation of Cui Fen’s burial

    0 1 M

    N

    low disk, trumpet-shaped tall ring foot, fully green

    glazed, 16 cm in disk diameter (Fig. 4).

    A celadon bowl. Slightly contracted mouth, curved

    belly, solid ring foot slightly curved inwardly, green

    glazed, 12.2 cm in mouth diameter (Fig. 5).

    A bowl with porcelain body. Pointed mouth, no lid,

    short ring foot, 14.5 cm in mouth diameter.

    32 pieces of mud coins. Circular or approximately

    oval-shaped, a round hole in the center, kneaded by

    hand.

    A bronze mirror with patterns of mythological

    creatures. With a hemispherical knob on a round seat.

    Between the six circular nipples in the inner section are

    decorated celestial beings and celestial animals. In the

    outer section the square and hemispherical mei-project-

    ing knobs are arrayed alternatively. On the square mei

    are inscriptions“吾作明镜,幽 三商,大吉兮”

    (meaning that I made the mirror for merchandizing. It’s

    a great auspicious thing). On the rim of the mirror are

    decorated dragons, birds, animals, and clouds patterns.

    The mirror is 11.5 cm in diameter (Fig. 6).

    A bronze bell. It is shaped like a globe, hollow

    inside, with a small knob on the upper end, open on the

    lower end, a movable small ball inside its belly.

    69 bronze coins. All are wuzhu 五铢 coins of the

    Eastern Han Dynasty, and a majority of their outer edges

    have been cut.

    A stone grinding-tool. Shaped like a short ox horn,

    pointed on the upper end, curved on the lower end. The

    lower section and the grinding surface of the tool are

    painted red.

    A box of epitaph. Made of bluestone. The cover is

    square, bearing no inscriptions. The epitaph stone is

    square-shaped with 663 Chinese characters written in

    tablet inscription style entitled“魏威烈将军行台府

    长史崔公之墓颂” (meaning the Epitaph of Lord Cui in

    Weilie General’s Office of Wei) on the top.

    Apart from these, there are also bronze rings, iron

    rings, silver hairpins and shells. It is said that under the

    east wall of the tomb chamber there had been painted

    figurines of warriors, mounted figures, attendants, and

    servant-maids originally. Yet now only the heads of 10

    maidservant figurines remain, whose faces are painted

    red and whose hair is dressed in double buns.

    III. The Mural Paintings

    The walls of the aisle, the passageway, and the

    tomb chamber are covered in a thin layer of white lime-

    wash, over which are painted magnificent colored murals.

  • 127Volume 3

    Fig. 4 Celadon dou-pedestral stand

    Fig. 5 Celadon bowl

    Fig. 6 Bronze mirror

    Fig. 2 Celadon jar

    Fig. 3 Celadon pot with chicken-headed spout

  • 128 Chinese Archaeology

    The murals will be introduced according to their themes

    (Fig. 7).

    1. The image of the warriors (Nos. 1 and 2). The

    walls of the aisle each feature the painted image of a

    barefoot, armored warrior. The two warriors are dressed

    in helmets, armored breast-plates, kirtles and riding

    breeches, with leather girdles around their waists. Their

    upper arms are bound in cloth. Each rests one hand on a

    shield. Both also have swords suspended on their wrists.

    The walls of the aisle also bear two engraved images of

    door guards wearing small caps and standing with their

    hands clasped in front of their chests. They are attired in

    loose robes and trousers, and shoes with upturned toes

    (Figs. 8 and 9).

    2. The Four Spirits and the 28 Constellations

    The Green Dragon and the Seven Eastern Constel-

    lations (No. 8) painted on the upper register of the east

    wall and the lower register of the ceiling of the tomb

    chamber. This image depicts a female deity wearing a

    “flower-crown”and riding on the Green Dragon, in

    front of which are two feathered beings who appear to be

    guiding it, a sun-disc and trees. Behind the dragon are

    Fangxingshi 方相士, trees, and mountains. Above this

    image are the seven Eastern Constellations painted in

    ink dots, namely, jiao 角, kang 亢, di 氐, fang 房, xin 心,

    wei 尾, and ji 箕 (Fig. 10).

    The White Tiger and the Seven Western

    Constelllations (No. 6) painted on the upper register of

    the west wall and the lower register of the ceiling. The

    image depicts a female deity wearing a“flower-crown”

    riding on a white tiger, in front of which are the moon

    disc and trees and behind which are one Fangxiangshi

    and small trees. Above this image are Seven Western

    Constellations in ink dots, namely, kui 奎, lou 娄, wei

    胃, ang 昂, bi 毕, zi 觜, and shen 参 (Fig. 11).

    The Black Warrior and the Seven Northern Con-

    stellations (No. 7) painted on the upper register of the

    north wall, the niche top and the lower register of the

    ceiling. The image depicts a short-bearded male riding

    on the back of the intertwining black tortoise and snake.

    In front of the Black Warrior are three Fangxiangshi.

    Above this image are the Seven Northern Constellations

    in ink dots, namely, dou 斗, niu 牛, nü女, xu 虚, wei 危,

    shi 室, and bi 壁 (Fig. 12).

    The Red Bird and the Southern Constellations (No.

    3) painted on the lower register of the west side of the

    south wall, the Red Bird is flying between colorful

    clouds and mountains, with one lotus in its beak. On the

    eastern end of the lower register of the ceiling are

    painted 12 stars. They seem to be one of the seven

    constellations left uncompleted.

    3. The procession scene of the tomb occupant and

    his wives (No. 9) painted on the panel over the niche of

    the west wall. Solemn and dignified, the tomb occupant

    Cui Fen wears a short beard and his hair is bound in cloth

    and covered with a formal official’s cap. He is attired in

    a long robe with curved collar and billowing sleeves,

    and shoes with upturned toes, and attended by two male

    servants. His wife has elaborately coiffed hair dressed

    with ornamental hairpins and wears loose, flowing

    robes with red sashes tied around her waist. A boy

    servant and 11 maidservants attend them (Fig. 13).

    4. The simulated screen featuring the Seven Sages

    of the Bamboo Grove and Rong Qiqi 荣启期 (see Fig.

    10).

    The first image (No. 22) painted on the third panel

    from the right on the lower register of the east wall. It

    depicts a man with a short beard sitting on a square rush

    mat, wearing a double-eared cap, a loose robe with wide

    sleeves and a leather belt around his waist. His chest and

    arms are exposed, with a small basin landscape in his

    hands. In front of him is a maidservant. In the back-

    ground are two locust trees and some ornamental rocks.

    The second image (No. 21) painted on the fourth

    panel from the right on the lower register of the east wall.

    It depicts a man leaning against a rush cushion with his

    back to the viewer, half reclining on a square rush mat.

    His hair is dressed in two topknots. In front of him are

    a basin and a vase. To his right is a maidservant, and in

    the background are locust trees and ornamental rocks.

    The third image (No. 20) is painted on the fifth

    panel from the right on the lower register of the east wall.

    It depicts a man with his right leg tucked beneath him,

    left leg twisted, sitting on a square rush mat. His right

    hand is cradling his cheek. He wears a drunken look. To

    his left is a male servant and to his right a maidservant

    standing sideways. In the background are locust trees

    and some ornamental rocks.

    The fourth image (No. 19) painted on the second

    panel from the left on the lower register of the east wall

    of the tomb chamber. It depicts a man in loose robe with

    wide sleeves sitting cross-legged on a square rush mat

    and leaning against a rush cushion to his left. To his right

    is a maidservant. In the background are a locust tree,

    ornamental rocks, and a large parti-colored vase.

    The fifth image (No. 13) painted on the first panel

    from the right on the lower register of the west wall in the

    tomb chamber. It depicts a man sitting cross-legged on

  • 129Volume 3

    Fig. 7 Serial number of Cui Fen’s burial

    1 2 4 53

    12 1310 11 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23

    6 7 8

    24

    9

    Aisle

    Fig. 8 Mural on the east wall of aisle (No. 1) Fig. 9 Mural on the west of aisle (No. 2)

    South wall West wall North wall East wall

  • 130 Chinese Archaeology

    a square rush mat. His hair is bound into a topknot and

    fastened with a piece of cloth. He wears a reposed aspect

    with his chest and arms exposed. To his left is a

    maidservant. In the background are ornamental rocks,

    locust trees, and a large parti-colored vase (see Fig. 11).

    The sixth image (No. 16) painted on the second

    panel from the right on the lower register of the north

    wall in the tomb chamber. It depicts a man half reclining

    on a square rush mat, leaning against a rush cushion.

    Bare-footed, he looks much at ease with his chest and

    arms exposed. In the background are a large vase, locust

    trees, and some ornamental rocks (Fig. 14).

    The seventh image (No. 15) painted on the second

    panel from the left in the lower register of the north wall

    in the tomb chamber. It depicts a man sitting on a square

    rush mat. His hair is dressed in two topknots. Before him

    is a low writing desk and he holds a brush in one hand

    in the act of painting or writing. On the left a maidser-

    vant is holding a lamp to illuminate his work. In the

    background are a locust tree and some ornamental rocks

    (see Fig. 14)

    The eighth image (No. 14) painted on the first

    panel from the left on the lower register of the north wall

    in the tomb chamber. It depicts a man sitting on a square

    rush mat slightly leaning forward with both hands

    resting on the mat. His hair is dressed in two topknots.

    Behind him a maidservant is massaging his back. In the

    background are locust trees and some ornamental rocks

    (see Fig. 14).

    5. The dancing scene (No. 17) painted on the first

    panel from the right on the lower register of the north

    wall in the tomb chamber. It depicts two dancing girls

    with hair dressed in high coiffures who are dancing

    sideways back-to-back. They wear close-fitting gowns

    with narrow sleeves and long trousers, barefoot. In the

    background are locust trees and some ornamental rocks

    (see Fig. 14).

    6. The mounting scene (No. 18) painted on the first

    panel from the left on the lower register of east wall in

    the tomb chamber. It depicts a groom who is leading a

    saddled horse, with a broom in his right hand. In the

    background are the locust trees and some ornamental

    rocks (see Fig. 10).

    7. The scene of tying a horse (No. 12) painted on

    the second panel from the right on the lower register of

    the west wall in the tomb chamber. It depicts a saddled

    horse tied to the stem of a tree. On the background are

    locust trees and some ornamental rocks (see Fig. 11).

    8. Four scenes of locust trees and ornamental rocks

    (Nos. 23, 24, 10, 11) painted on the first panel from the

    left and second panel from the right respectively on the

    lower register of the east and west walls. Both depict

    locust trees and ornamental rocks (see Figs. 10 and 11).

    The mural paintings of Cui’s tomb are firstly

    outlined with ink lines and then filled with various

    colors such as red, umber, blue, green, yellow, orange,

    and white. Even now the outlines are still discernible

    and the murals are colorful. The images are highly

    proportionate, the moulds lively and the lines smooth

    and running. They possess high research value for the

    study of the painting art in the Northern and Southern

    Dynasties.

    The solemn and fierce warriors depicted on the

    tomb aisle most likely represent the legendary demon-

    quellers Shen Tu 神荼 and Yu Lei 郁垒, who are often

    portrayed in human form and positioned as door guards.

    The tomb occupant is praying the two deities to protect

    his tomb.

    The four parti-colored Supernatural Beings are

    deities guarding the four directions and exorcizing

    demons. They are also called si xiang 四象 or si ling 四

    灵 (four mythical animals). This accords with the mo-

    tion of the celestial bodies observed by ancient Chinese.

    In the procession scene the human figures are

    lively, the eyes and the eyebrows especially representa-

    tive of their character. Cui Fen’s dignity and solemnity,

    his lady’s dignity and grace and the cautious manners of

    the servants are all well depicted in the murals. Among

    the painting and sculptural works of the Northern Dy-

    nasty secular procession scenes like this is very rare.

    Of the screen-paintings of human figures in the

    background of locust trees and ornamental rocks, the

    main characters sitting on square rush mats in different

    posture are mostly slovenly dressed and unrestrained in

    manners. The eight persons represent the Seven Sages

    of the Bamboo Grove and the hermit Rong Qiqi of the

    Springs and Autumns Period. In the Eastern Jin and the

    Southern Dynasty, paintings with the theme of the

    Seven Sages of the Bamboo Grove are recorded in the

    Lidai Minghua Ji 历代名画记 (Famous Paintings of the

    Past) and Nanshi 南史 (History of the Southern Dynasty).

    The moulded brick relieves of the Seven Sages of the

    Bamboo Grove and Rong Qiqi are also discovered in the

    four large tombs of the Southern Dynasty in Xishanqiao

    西善桥, Nanjing南京, Hexian’ao 鹤仙坳 and Wujiacun

    吴家村, Danyang 丹阳, and Jinjiacun 金家村, Jianshan

    建山 excavated in the 1960s. All these indicated that

    paintings with the theme of the Seven Sages were very

  • 131Volume 3

    0 50 CM

    0 50 CM

    Fig. 10 Copy of mural on the east wall (the upper is No. 8; the lower is Nos. 18–24 from left to right)

    Fig. 11 Copy of mural on the west wall (the upper is No. 6; the lower is Nos. 10, 11, 9, 12, and 13)

  • 132 Chinese Archaeology

    Fig. 13 Mural on the west wall (No. 9)

    Fig. 12 The Black Warrior and the Seven Northern Constellations (No. 7)

  • 133Volume 3

    popular in the Eastern Jin and Southern Dynasties. The

    tomb murals of the Northern Dynasties discovered in

    Shandong 山东 show a close stylistic link with the

    painting art of the Southern Dynasty. In another fresco-

    wall tomb excavated in Dongbaliwa 东八里洼, Jinan 济

    南, Shandong Province in 1986, four figures of the

    Seven Sages appear on a four-panel screen. The eight-

    panel human image screen of Cui’s tomb are similar

    with those discovered in Dongbaliwa and the moulded

    brick-relieves in the four tombs of the Southern Dynasty

    discovered in Jiangsu 江苏 Province in composition and

    facial features. Undoubtedly the content of them should

    also be the same. This fact indicates that paintings with

    the theme of the Seven Sages may be also popular in

    Shandong Province. The procession scene in Cui’s

    tomb highly resembles The Luoshen Fu Tu 洛神赋图

    (Nymph of the Luo River) attributed to Gu Kaizhi 顾恺

    之 in people’s expression and the composition of the

    whole painting. Additionally, the mural paintings of the

    Green Dragon and the White Tiger are also similar to the

    images depicted in the moulded brick relieves of the

    Southern Dynasty. Those mural paintings are unique in

    Central China of the same period. This points to the

    possibility that these paintings may well have been

    consciously modeled on works of the Eastern Jin and

    Southern Dynasties.

    IV. Conclusion

    During the Northern and Southern Dynasties period,

    Shandong was a main artery for cultural and material

    exchanges. The Cui clan based in the district of Qinghe

    played an important role in the exchanges. In the form-

    ing process of the Northern and Southern Dynasties and

    later, some important members of Cui’s clan moved

    back to their homeland in the north and were held in high

    esteem by the supreme rulers of the Northern Dynasties.

    For example, Cui Yao 崔尧 and Cui Liang 崔亮 were

    made prominent ministers of the court in the Northern

    Wei period. The tomb epitaph of Cui Guang 崔光 states:

    “Cui’s grandfather lived in Song of the Southern Dy-

    nasty and took part in governing the state. Since they

    came back to the north in the Northern Wei period they

    also assumed offices in their homeland.”When the

    social order had become comparatively steady, the

    branches and relatives of Cui’s clan would certainly

    communicate with each other through various means.

    As a result, the culture and art of the Southern Dynasty

    would surely spread to the north, especially in the

    0 50 CM

    Fig. 14 Copy of mural on the north wall (the upper is No. 7; the lower is Nos. 14 –17)

  • 134 Chinese Archaeology

    homeland of Cui’s clan in Shandong Province. There-

    fore it is no wonder that the mural paintings in Cui Fen’s

    tomb should have been modeled on the paintings of the

    Eastern Jin and Southern Dynasties.

    References

    1. Yang Hong 杨鸿 (1991).“Shandong Beichao

    mu renwu pingfeng bihua de xin qishi 山东北朝墓人物

    屏风壁画的新启示”. Wenwu Tiandi 文物天地 1991.

    3: 6–8.

    2. Nanjing Bowuyuan etc. 南京博物院等 (1960).

    “Nanjing Xishanqiao Nanchao mu jiqi zhuanke bihua

    南京西善桥南朝墓及其砖刻壁画”. Wenwu 文物

    1960.8: 37– 42.

    3. Luo Zongzhen 罗宗真 (1963).“Nanjing

    Xishanqiao Youfangcun Nanchao damu de fajue 南京

    西善桥油坊村南朝大墓的发掘”. Kaogu 考古 1963.

    6: 291–300.

    4. Nanjing Bowuyuan (1974).“Jiangsu Danyang

    Huqiao Nanchao damu ji zhuanke bihua 江苏丹阳胡桥

    南朝大墓及砖刻壁画”. Wenwu 1974.2: 44–56.

    5. Nanjing Bowuyuan (1980).“Jiangsu Danyang xian

    Huqiao, Jianshan liangzuo Nanchao muzang 江苏丹阳县

    胡桥、建山两座南朝墓葬”. Wenwu 1980.2: 1–7.

    6. Shandong Sheng Wenwu Kaogu Yanjiusuo 山

    东省文物考古研究所 (1989).“Jinan shi Dongbaliwa

    Beichao bihua mu 济南市东八里洼北朝壁画墓”.

    Wenwu 1989.4: 67–78.

    Note: The original report is published in Wenwu 2002.4: 4 –25, with 36 illustrations, including 10 photos and 18

    colored photos, written by Wu Wenqi 吴文祺, Gong Dejie 宫德杰. The present version, an abridgment from the

    original, is prepared by the first author and English-translated by Wang Shufang 王淑芳.