geny.pdf

Upload: catalin0303

Post on 04-Jun-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    1/56

    A

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    89

    RECRUITING & RETAINING

    GENERATION PRODUCERS

    E R I K V O S

    Fixing the 9 holes

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    2/562

    RECRUITING AND RETAINING PRODUCTIVE NEW

    GENERATION Y ADVISORS

    For 25 years Erik Vos (1955, Amsterdam Holland) has been working with sales managers to meet the plans

    on recruitment and retention. He has worked for AIG, Aegon, Allianz, AXA, Generali, ING, Old Mutual,

    Manulife, Prudential and 112 regional companies. 265.000 managers and advisors have attended the

    keynotes and programs in 83 countries.

    He wrote: Referrals for your practice (1982). Return on investment marketing (1994). Sell it today (1998).

    Referrals (2003), Taking your business to the next level (2005) and Copy and Paste. (2010).

    Since 2003 he has been the Worlds bestselling author in life insurance. The eld books are now translated in

    18 languages.

    Internationally he delivers keynotes and programs in:

    English.

    Dutch in Holland and Belgium.

    French in Switzerland and Mauritius.

    German in Austria and Germany.

    Spanish in Spain and South America.

    Poor Hungarian in Hungary and Western Romania.

    Poor Afrikaans in South Africa and Namibia.

    In other countries the programs are done with an interpreter.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    3/56

    3

    Some of the information in this eld book might be outdated by the time you read this. For updated info go

    to erikvosinternational.com. Or mail [email protected] get the newsletter with the latest

    trends surveys and updates.

    Unfortunately this eldbook somewhat stereotypes GenY and Generation X. We all know that there are

    sometimes bigger differences within a generation than between generations. The purpose of this book is to

    help the manager to increase protability by being right like 80% of the time.

    If you have any ideas on how to make this eld book more useful to increase productivity for the managers

    please mail me at [email protected].

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    4/564

    CHAPTER 1

    HOW SOME COMPANIES ARE HURT BY THE 9 HOLES

    AND OTHERS ARE DOING BETTER THAN EVER.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    5/56

    5

    THE 9 HOLES IN THE AGENCY BUCKET.

    Everybody in the business knows that getting and keeping good

    advisors (retention) has been given managers a headache since

    anyone can remember. But now on top of the usual problems of

    recruitment and retention, a new generation, GenY, is joining the

    agency force. GenY are people born after 1980. Their managers are

    usually Generation X.Generation X are people born between 1965

    and 1980. The top managers of the company are usually Baby Boomers born between 1945 to 1965. The

    Silent Generation, 1925 to 1945 has practically disappeared.

    The Silent Generation, the Baby Boomers and Generation X got along quite well. Nobody remembers

    conicts between generations even being a topic, leave alone a problem. Until now.

    Managers around the World are complaining that some attitudes of GenY are causing holes in the agency

    bucket:

    Hole no.1.

    The I am so important but I still want to do things in a collective way hole.

    GenY is often called Generation Me. The most self-absorbed

    generation in history*. (Pew Research).On tests 82% of GenY

    answered yes to the question:

    Do you consider yourself an important person? Only 12% of

    advisors from generation X said the same when they took the same

    test at the same age.*(Twenge) Other than this there were no major

    differences in the answers to the tests. GenY has about the same

    qualities as GenerationX. GenY just feels much better about who they are.

    They are overcondent underachievers. Said Vladimir an agency manager from Moscow.

    I need to tell them 3 times a day how great they are. said Emil from Bucharest.

    They are just hopeless. They just want endless meetings with people like them. said Letitia from

    Botswana.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    6/566

    They think that they have all these great ideas on how to run the agency

    after 1 month on the job and making 1 sale. They all come up with the

    same brilliant idea: Lets put the agency on Facebook, improve our

    webpage, have less face to face meetings and more texting. Then they get

    upset with me that I am not interested in their brilliant ideas. said Bashar

    from Cairo.

    Hole no.2.

    The old hole

    GenY is often called Generation Next or Generation Now.

    *(Wikipedia).They dont trust old things and old systems.

    50% says they do not think so much of the abilities of older people.

    *(Pew research)

    75% expect that during their career they will have to go back to school

    again because their skills are outdated.*(Robert Half -Hotjobs survey)

    They look down on the older advisors in my agency. They think there is little they can learn from them that

    ts todays circumstances said Pavel from Prague.

    Hole no. 3.

    The cannot communicate hole.

    They love to think they can solve all the problems in this work with

    technology because they cannot communicate so well.

    But a new study by Limra shows that 94% of GenY clients get their

    nancial advisor through referrals.*

    Most of the new advisors have been texting their whole life and they

    are self-conscious when talking to people, so they do not know what to

    do to get referrals. said Hans from Berlin

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    7/56

    7

    Hole no. 4.

    The work - life balance hole.

    Even in China 37% of Chinese GenY agreed with: I dont think about

    the money and I just live a life that suits my tastes. * (Gallup)

    They just came from university. Now they want to have fun, trips and

    not work so many hours. All of this when starting a career.

    And on top of that in a career in nancial services where more than

    80% of the people do not make it into their 5thyear. said John from

    Seattle.

    Hole no.5

    The entitlement hole.

    A Limra- McKinsey study in 2010 found that people who feel entitled have a

    terrible success rate in the business.

    They feel they deserve lots of cash and stuff right now. Before they even sold

    anything. Just for showing up. Their parents and teachers kept telling them:

    You are great. Just get your diploma and everything will be ne.

    So now they have the diploma and say: OK, so wheres my IPhone, my IPad,

    my company car, my retirement fund, and how much paid vacation did you

    say I get? said Jan from Amsterdam.

    Selling nancial services is a long-term business and the rst year is rarely good. This I want it all and I

    want it now thinking is really hurting our recruitment and especially retention results here in Singapore

    said Li Chin.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    8/568

    Hole no.6.

    You are not my boss. I believe in peer-to-peer networks hole.

    When I interview someone for the job many times he turns it around and

    starts interviewing me said Tang from Singapore.

    They do not see me as their boss anymore and they do not listen to me. So

    how can I help them become successful? said Ivan from Moscow.

    When I tell a GenY advisor to do something they usually ask: Why? said

    Susan from Sydney.

    Hole no.7.

    The constant feedback hole.

    In a survey by 50% of GenY said they want daily meetings with their

    manager. Only10% said once a week was enough.*(Yahoo/Hotjobs)

    When I got started my manager said: Here is your rate book. Go out and

    sell some policies. See you in a week. Now I have to text each advisortwice a day. If I dont, they leave me because they think I do not care about

    them. said Abdul from Dubai.

    Hole no. 8.

    The loyalty hole.

    A recent study showed that GenY has 40% less empathy than Gen

    X.*(Twenge).The dictionary denes empathy as in that you care about the

    feelings and ideas of other people instead of only your own feelings.

    They are only loyal to the idea of proving how great they are. They are

    already looking at their next job after the job at my agency. The moment

    they feel they are not advancing they start planning their next move. said

    Rajeev from Mumbai

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    9/56

    9

    Hole no.9.

    They cannot handle anything not precise hole.

    If I tell them something and ask them do you understand they always say

    yes. And nothing happens. I have to explain it step by step and then ask.

    So how do you see yourself actually doing this? And I cannot be critical.

    They take criticism very badly. But of course they can be critical of me and

    the agency. If I do not tell them precisely and exactly what they have to do

    nothing happens. said Jane from Johannesburg.

    Action step: Which of these 9 holes is the biggest drain for retention in your agency?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    10/5610

    So how did the managers of the Famous 5 companies react to these problems

    and boost protability?

    Every year the business magazine Fortune surveys hundreds of leaders of the Worlds 15 biggest life

    insurance companies: How do you rate the Worlds 14 biggest life insurance companies on quality of

    management and innovation? (Of course they do not let you score your own company, only the competition.)

    The overall top 5 winners are often called the Famous 5*. (Fortune magazine 2011).

    Some companies like ING and Allianz, and a few others are not on this list because they are not just pure life

    insurance companies but also have other lines of business.

    In 2010 all the Famous 5 companies decided to update the way their managers recruited and retained

    advisors. Then they went on an aggressive recruitment campaign for GenY. Even the Wall Street Journal

    reported: One of the most traditional of professions is becoming cool again?*(Wall street Journal 2010)

    The sales managers of the famous 5 said:

    New York Life: Our managers recruited 3618 young advisors in 2009. More than we ever did in our history.

    Then in 2010 with our new advisors we increased turnover by 47% over 2009. And 2009 already was a

    record year. In 2010 our managers are on track to hire and retain even more advisors than in 2009.And 2009

    was already the best ever. said Mark Pfaff vice president for sales with a big smile on his face.

    Northwestern Mutual said: We recruited 2,340 nancial advisors in 2009. This was the most we ever

    recruited. Retention of the new generation of advisors was the best in 25 years. 2010 is trending even higher

    than 2009 so farsaid John Greene. *

    Mass Mutual: We recruited more than 2000 new agents. We have not seen anything like this in 20 years.

    Prudential Financial: We increased our sales force like never before. Since the nancial crisis we have built

    up reserves of $2.1 billion. This then gave us the cash to buy AIGs Japanese business.

    MetLife said: Business with our new advisors is so good that we were able to buy the Alico part of AIG for

    $16.1 billion.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    11/56

    11

    Each one of the Famous 5 also managed to push their 4 year retention rate for GenY advisors to over

    25%*, about 30% better than the industry average with the trend even much higher for the recently recruited

    advisors.

    Exercise: Why do you think the Famous 5 lately recruited and retained more Gen Y advisors?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    12/5612

    So how did the Famous 5 managers deal with the 9 holes?

    The Famous 5 managers gured they could not give up on GenY and still stay in business. So they gured

    out the operating system of GenY and updated their methods. They updated the way they did things to try to

    turn those 9 holes into 9 faucets (or at least stop the leaking).

    1. The important hole.

    I want you to reject anyone that ever made you feel you are not good enough, not

    smart enough, like you do not t in. You are a superstar. shouted Lady Gaga on a

    December 2010 concert in Italy. 50.000 people went wild.

    Fight back strategy: The Famous 5 managers are constantly talking and showing all the great things the

    company is achieving. They help the GenY advisors feel more important since they work for such an

    important company. (Chapter 4)

    Fight back strategy .By having more special meetings for GenY advisors

    than a couple of years ago the GenY advisors feel more important since they

    are getting more attention from the manager and also from the colleagues.

    (Chapter 5)

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    13/56

    13

    2. The old hole.

    Limra did a study on the image of life insurance advisors.* Results:

    75% said: You cannot trust someone who is trying to sell you life insurance.

    75% said: They are more interested in their commission than getting the right

    policy for me.

    84% said no! When asked: Would you talk with a life insurance advisor about

    nancial decisions?

    68% thought life insurance advisors cannot explain the products well.

    The image of the old life insurance is pretty awful.

    We feel uncomfortable to trust our future to people and things that look too much like the past. We do not

    feel comfortable with all those old people you have in your agency. All this 20th century stuff going on in

    your company and your agency scares me and makes me feel uncertain about my future with you. Lee an

    advisor from Singapore said.

    We all know technology is changing everything. But my manager

    has no clue. Would you believe the guy who calls himself my

    manager does not even have a Facebook account, sends e-mails

    instead of texting and wants me to wear a wrist watch? The agency

    does not even have a webpage. How can people nd it? said

    Kung (Hong Kong)

    I do not care so much about all those dinosaurs in the agency. I have nothing against them but sometimes

    I wonder what I can learn from them. Most are uneducated, pompous, and dress awful. Besides they

    are insincere and pushy. I wanted to say slimy and creepy. If I would talk to my friends the way they do

    everyone would laugh at me. said Attila (Budapest, Hungary)

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    14/5614

    Fight back strategy: Try to look more up to date and cool yourself so you

    look like the new life insurance not the old one. (Chapter 4)

    Fight back strategy: Show them that through your continuous training

    programs they stay updated and can stay Generation Now and do not have

    to move to another career. (Chapter 5)

    Fight back strategy: Update the agency or company webpage. Include a

    special section on careers in your company for GenY. (Chapter 5)

    Fight back strategy: Update your sales training to make it t more to todays circumstances.(Chapter 5)

    Fight back strategy: Hire more young advisors in a group at once. Do not hire and lose them one by one.

    (Chapter 2)

    3. The poor communication hole.

    We want to try to solve everything with technology because that is what we know. But

    we expect and appreciate your help to develop our communication skills. said Heinz

    from Vienna.Of course we know we are poor communicators. We do not have so much

    experience in life yet. Thats where you as a manager can help us develop skills we

    know we do not have. If you do this you are adding value to us. If you try to play little

    king or queen we see right away that this does not help us to get to where we want to

    go. said Chenghis from Almaty.

    The sales training I got in the agency is totally outdated. They try to teach me to be slimy. My manager

    always tells me: You have to convince people! She tries to teach me these stupid pushy objection handling

    techniques. Just like she learned when she was an agent. She does not understand that the world does not

    work that way anymore. You get business through referrals not through cold calls. said Betty from London.

    They think we like to read these boring books. They do not understand that we like hands-on learning,

    together with other young people that we feel comfortable with. said Jan from Warsaw.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    15/56

    15

    Fight back strategy: With your next group of new GenY advisors

    try to establish a learning culture. In other words try to get them

    used to learning more about the business, about sales, products

    and getting referrals to people outside their circle.(Chapter 5)

    4. The work-life balance hole.

    GenY in the Western world is more family oriented than anything seen in the

    last 50 years. The GenY fathers spend over an hour per day more with their

    children than their fathers did with them. *(Pew research)

    Our managers just dont get it: We do not want to be like them. They live to

    work. We young people work to live. They think they are someone because of

    the job they do. We do not dene ourselves by the work we do. said Rollie

    from Manila.I think I am someone because of all the cool things I do outside of work. I

    also need my friends. My manager does not seem to understand that I have other things to do than just work

    said Joe a GenY advisor from Sydney.

    Fight back strategy: Managers ask questions in the selection that lter out people right away who are not

    serious enough about making money. (Chapter 5)

    Fight back strategy: They hire similar people of similar ages and background so

    they can hang out with friends and talk about business and their careers. (Chapters

    2 and 3)

    Fight back strategy: The managers or the Home Ofce try to organize a good

    amount of stuff outside of work for GenY advisors. Much more than 3 years ago.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    16/5616

    5. I am entitled to make a lot of money because of who I am.

    A lot has changed since September 2008 but this is still a problem.

    I have a university diploma with a degree in economics. It took me four years to get it. I need to cash in on

    it right away. I need money now, now, now. said Abdul from Dubai.

    Fight back strategy: Since there is still so much entitlement thinking, Famous 5 managers use questions

    that lter out people who have an entitlement mentality and are therefore guaranteed to have a high risk of

    failure as advisors. (Chapter 4)

    Fight back strategy: They show the GenY advisors exactly what they have to do to get referrals. They have

    twice as many role-plays in the unit with GenY advisors than 5 years ago. (Chapter 5)

    6. The you are not my boss hole.

    We do not understand authority and position very well. We grew up

    with computers. In computers there is no head computer. It is just one

    computer connected with another. Peer to peer. said Pierre a French

    advisor.

    My manager wants me to respect him. But why should I respect him

    when he has not earned my respect? The way we see it is that respect is

    earned because of the stuff you can do not because of your place in some hierarchy said Tang a Malaysian

    advisor.

    I am starting my new career. My manager thinks he is my boss. But he is just playing important.

    He does not understand that we live in the 21stcentury. He should just do his job and transfer whatever up to

    date knowledge he has to us said Diana from Athens.

    One of the most popular websites at the moment is ratemyteacher.com *. Millions of students who will

    be tomorrows advisors from all over the world are now busy rating their teachers instead of doing their

    homework. The students rate the teachers on:

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    17/56

    17

    1. How helpful they are.

    2. How easy they are to understand.

    Reading the ratings it is impressing how fair and objective the ratings were coming from teenagers. Teachers

    who are helpful and easy to understand get excellent ratings. Surprisingly GenY cooperates better than

    Generation X at the same age with anybody who acts like a teacher or coach and not like a boss. GenY is

    closer to their teachers than any other previous generation. * (Pew research).

    Fight back strategy: The managers of the Famous 5 have changed their management style. They now act like

    coaches and less bossy. GenY responds to this by being more motivated and productive.

    7. The constant feedback hole

    We will leave you when we feel you stop adding value to us said

    Jake a young advisor from Atlanta.Fight back strategy: After themanager hired the right people(Chapter 2) they made sure the new

    advisors were getting constant feedback from them and also in the

    group meetings. So they rst get the most talented people. After

    they got the most talented people they do high maintenance on them

    especially in the rst 6 months.

    8. Loyalty hole

    In 2010 I did a survey in 19 countries on the different continents amongst 800 top 20% GenY advisors who

    had been with the company between 1 and 4 years. Who is the main person you talk with about whats going

    on in your business? The new advisors(less than 1 year) said:

    1. My manager. 55%.

    2. My colleagues. 35%.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    18/5618

    3. A friend: 5%

    4. My partner 5%.

    GenY advisors who had been with the agency over 4 years said:

    1. My colleagues: 84%:

    2. My partner: 7% (3 times more men than women discuss their business with their partner)

    3. A friend: 5%

    4. The manager: 4%

    So they will listen and be somewhat loyal to you for about 6 months

    (or maximum a year). After that they listen to their colleagues.

    Therefore your job in the rst 6 months is to get them to form a group

    or rather a tribe as fast as possible. Since they apparently will not be

    loyal to you, you need to create something they will be loyal to: a tribe.

    Their friends, colleagues who they can discuss what is going on in the

    business with. (Chapter 5)

    Fight back strategy: Managers who are successful with GenY advisors have 3 meetings with the group

    of new GenY advisors per week. In the meetings there are lots of role-plays and everyone gets feedback.

    (Chapter 5)

    Fight back strategy: Special events for GenY advisors are successful to improve retention.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    19/56

    19

    9. The imprecise hole.

    My manager has a very precise operating system:

    Step 1. He puts on his Old Spice after shave.

    Step 2. He makes sure his hair is in order.

    Step 3. He checks to see that his shoes are as shiny as a mirror.

    Step 4. He puts a smile on his face.

    Step 5. He storms into the meeting room and shouts: Be passionate! Be passionate! Be passionate! Then he

    disappears.

    The next week he repeats the same routine.

    In 2011 I feel we young advisors deserve a little bit better than that said Pavel from Prague.

    She says these vague things like: There are great opportunities here! But then she is imprecise and evasive

    about exactly what I need to do to get the advantages. I do not have forever to build up my career and yes,

    we young people do not have patience. an advisor in Mumbai said.

    Fight back strategy: Show them precisely how much money is being made by people a couple of years

    older than they are. Show them precisely what they have to do to get what they want. Mentor them and give

    constant precise feedback and have role-plays where everything is demonstrated. Just make sure that the

    person, you are doing all this time-consuming work with, has the potential to be a top producer by selecting

    well in the recruitment phase.

    Fight back strategy: Show them through many group discussions and role-plays exactly how they are

    supposed to sell and prospect and get referrals. Do not depend on GenYs creativity, initiative and logic.

    Fight back strategy: Get them to see the business as a numbers game. GenY respects numbers and program

    steps much better than generation X. Show them the business is a science not an art. (Chapter 4)

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    20/5620

    CHAPTER 2.

    HOW MANAGERS CAN PREDICT BETTER HOW

    SUCCESSFUL THE APPLICANT WILL BE IN THE FUTURE

    BY CHECKING OUT HIS PAST.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    21/56

    21

    People with a college or university degree.

    A 2009 Limra-Mc Kinsey* study showed people who have advanced education have a 40% higher income

    in nancial services than those who do not. Very useful information for the industry. Then the second

    question is: Are some degrees better than others for the agency?

    In 2010 I asked 1850 high producing (top 20%) GenY advisors in 19 countries: What did you study? In

    country after county close to70 to 80% of the top 20% GenY producers had a nancial or a technical

    background.

    People with a nancial background. Desirability: 10.

    A nancial background could be anything from having studied things like

    economy, business administration, actuarial sciences or accounting. (But notmarketing)

    It does not require a lot of imagination to predict that people with a nancial

    background do well in nancial services. What is amazing is the imagination

    of average and below average managers who believe that people from other

    backgrounds will do well. The development over the last 5 years is that

    people with a nancial background have taken over our industry. At least

    with the Famous 5 companies and in other fast growing companies in the

    world from Poland to Malaysia. Even in Zambia (no kidding). It makes sense if you look at it. Out of all the

    things someone could study they chose to study nances.

    When nancial people talk about money they sound right. They sound like eh, a nancial professional.

    Because they know what they are talking about they can handle rejection better since they do not take

    rejection as personal. Since they know what they can do for people they also manage to get more referrals.

    They get seen as the nancial advisor in a certain circle because they look like a nancial advisor, sound like

    one, and act like one. They are not surprisingly very good and fast with numbers and they can think with

    numbers. And they get to do what they studied for: Deal with nances.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    22/5622

    Pros 1: They are comfortable discussing nances.

    Pros 2.They are easy to train in new products.

    Pros 3: They are worth investing in because their chance of being successful is much higher

    Pros 4: They do get referrals.

    Cons1: Not many but they are harder to recruit and retain if you have an agency full of older non-educated

    people

    People with a technical background. Desirability: 9.9.

    A technical background could be anything from computer science,

    physics, statistics, mathematics and any type of engineering. In

    my surveys with agency managers I could not nd any technical

    background that did better than another technical backgrounds. For the

    agency it does not seem to matter. A computer programmer according to

    the managers will not give better or worse results than a mathematician.

    It seems easier to teach a technical person the numbers and logic behind our business than it is to teach a

    salesperson to think logically and to listen to the needs of the clients. Internationally people with a technical

    background comprise about 4% of the GenY recruits. They make up about 15% of the top 20% producers.

    The percentage of recruits with a technical background in our industry varies enormously from country to

    country from less than 1% in Kenya to 60% in Croatia.

    Pros.1: Many make it in the top 20%.

    Pros. 2: After they get it they just run it as a program. You do not have to teach them the same thing again

    next week.

    Pros. 3: Relatively low maintenance.

    Pros. 4: Since they are good at looking and asking questions and nding real needs they tend to have much

    higher persistence rates on their policies.

    Pros. 5: They get referrals.

    Cons 1: In many markets there is strong competition for these people from other companies.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    23/56

    23

    Other backgrounds.

    Marketing. Desirability: Women 9.0.Men 3.0.

    Usually what the person studied before is a better predictor for success than whether

    the person is a man or a woman. The ndings are surprising since the percentage of

    women recruited in the agencies has been going down slowly since 2005 after rising

    for 15 years straight. (Limra)

    The men who studied marketing are about 2% of recruits. But less than 0.5% of top

    20% producers.

    Women are about 3% of recruits. But about 7% of top 20% advisors.

    The men are always thinking. How can I package my message so people will bite? Have you noticed that

    the women who studied marketing are nearly always the best packaged in the agency said Vladimir from

    Moscow.

    Pros. 1: The women are often in the top 20%.

    Pros. 2: Easier to get than technical people in most markets.

    Cons 1: The men in are big trouble for the agency and leave fast.

    People who worked at banks. Desirability: 8.0

    About 95% are women. Ask them: Why would you like to join our team?

    If they answer: I want to make more money and not be stuck in the bank all

    day you should probably hire them. They comprise about 2% of the network

    and are 3% of the top 20%. Retention is somewhere around 40%, much

    higher than average.

    Maybe they tend to stick around with you much longer since they usually end

    up making about twice as much as they were making at the bank. They also

    tend to add stability and friendliness to your team.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    24/5624

    Pros. 1: They are not surprisingly, very comfortable talking about money. When an ex-salesperson talks

    about money they invariably gets dollar signs in their eyes and their voice goes higher. Of course clients

    notice this.When ex-bank people talk about money they do it in a relaxed way. They sound right. Easy for

    them to do. Whenever they talked with clients in the past about money it was always the banks money not

    their own commission. People seem to instantly recognize this too.

    Pros. 2: Since they come from the nancial world they tend to understand the need to dress like a nancial

    professional.

    Cons. 1: They usually do not have the educational background to understand more complex nancial

    products. In more advanced markets the business is moving towards nancial planning and they do not do so

    well.

    Nurses. Desirability: 7.0

    Nurses do surprisingly well. They comprise about 1.5% of GenY recruits and

    about 1.5% of top 20%.

    Pros. 1: They tend to be good at asking questions. They also tend to have good

    empathy. They do well at selling simple protection products to middle class

    people. They have a positive effect on the group dynamic.

    Most of them are good closers. Maybe that is because they do not seem to mind

    that the payments are going to hurt a little.

    Cons 1: Rarely effective in selling more complex nancial products to richer clients.

    Cons 2: In many parts of the world salaries for nurses are going up and they are not as easy to recruit as 3

    years ago.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    25/56

    25

    Lawyers: Desirability 6.5.

    Pros: Intelligent, understand complex products. In most companies about 3%

    of GenY advisors have gone to law school and they are 2% of the top 20%

    producers.

    Cons: Difcult to manage, tend to say yes but a lot. Below average retention. If

    you insist on having lawyers in your agency then try to have not more than one or

    two maximum.

    Psychologist: Desirability 6.0

    Underperform. Internationally I estimate the percentage of GenY psychologist

    working in nancial services is about 2%. They comprise about 1% of the top

    20%.

    Pros: Emphatic, easy to recruit .Rarely troublemakers (unlike the lawyers.)Cons 1: They tend to Think too much especially about obvious things.

    Usually poor closers since often their clients also have to think about it.

    Cons 2:Usually difcult for the manager to get them to dress and look like a real nancial professional.

    Teachers: Desirability 5.5.

    Underperform. Usually struggling to get average results. In most countries they

    comprise about 15% of the sales force and about 2% of the top 20%.

    Note: ex-mathematics and science teachers and to a certain extent biology

    teachers do not count as teachers but as technical people. They seem to get

    nearly similar results to other people with a precision background.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    26/5626

    Ex-teachers used to be a reasonable choice in most markets 15 years ago. Then people listened better

    and respected authority. Most teachers quickly became unit managers (rarely agency managers) of very

    lively small units with medium to low productivity. They often recruit poorly qualied people with lots of

    problems. They are usually convinced that their leadership will help the advisors overcome a lack of talent

    and aptitude. This of course rarely happens. But they rarely give up and are nice people.

    Pros 1: Most of them talk too much. On my programs about 50% of teachers agreed with I talk too much

    and listen too little. Therefore they can handle rejection well. Their earnings in life insurance are better than

    teachers pay in many countries. So even if they are rarely in the top 20% they usually make more than when

    they were teachers.

    Cons 1: They talk too much. Almost impossible to teach them to ask questions instead of teaching. (Not true

    for teachers of exact sciences)

    Cons 2: Difcult to get them to dress like an elegant nancial professional. The opposite of the marketing

    people.

    Backgrounds from hell.

    These backgrounds are not included because any serious manager would hire people like this. Sometimes it

    helps to get what you are looking for by seeing the opposite.

    Ex-government people: Desirability 1.0

    Pros: I cannot think of any pros. Except if they know a lot of

    government people they could sell to. Current or Ex-government

    people are probably less than 1% of full time advisors in the world.

    Except in Vietnam, India, Thailand and Indonesia where they sell

    insurance part time instead of doing their government job.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    27/56

    27

    Cons: Work ethic, tend to be on the slow side. Non-existent in the top 20%. Not 1 manager in the in my

    2010 19 country survey said that one of the top 20% advisors he or she hired in the last 2 years was ex-

    government.

    Ex-police ofcers. 2.0

    Pros 1: Sometimes in rural areas they know a lot of people.

    Cons1: Giant underperformers. Sometimes they do sell but they tend to have high

    lapse rates. Maybe their previous job taught them that the customer is always

    wrong.

    Cons 2: They tend to integrate poorly with people from a nancial background.

    They are useless if you are selling to higher income and higher education.

    People sent from the unemployment ofce. 1.5

    Pros: Possibly if you instruct the unemployment ofce you want to talk with

    people with a technical and nancial university education this could work.

    (Untested, no data)

    Cons: Many go on the interview because if not they could lose benets. Not

    one manager in 19 countries reported hiring a top 20% advisor from the

    unemployment ofce.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    28/5628

    Ex-electronics and car salespeople. 2.0

    A 2009 study showed that to their surprise people who came from the

    sales world had a 40% lower retention rate than the average*(Limra-

    McKinsey 2009). The situation since the Limra study has probably

    only gotten worse. A July 8 2010 study from Prudential showed that

    60% of GenY clients want to purchase life insurance in the next 3

    years. 80% of GenY clients also say how much they hate being sold*.

    (newsprudential.com)

    As early as 2003 there are reports that about 10% of nancial services rms forbade hiring ex-salespeople.

    *(Limra) In my survey less than 1% of people in the top 20% had a sales background.

    Pros: Can you think of any?

    Cons: Salespeople usually feel they can talk well. They are interesting extroverts. Technical people like

    engineers and computer nerds are interested introverts. They see the business as a system and understand

    the value of asking questions.

    I know of no training that cured them of sounding like a salesperson.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    29/56

    29

    CHAPTER 3

    FROM WHICH SOURCES ARE THE FAMOUS FIVE

    MANAGERS FILLING THEIR AGENCY BUCKETS NOW?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    30/5630

    The 10 sources.

    Some sources have stayed the same in recruitment. Some have changed. The managers are now getting top

    producing GenY advisors from:

    1. You got them.

    25% of advisors who were recruited were contacts of the manager. This percentage has held steady for the

    last 15 years*(Limra)

    Pros: They chose you. Therefore their loyalty and persistence is above average.

    Cons: Managers who have been on the job for a while report it is harder for them to meet new people to

    recruit.

    2. Your advisors referred them.

    Limra research since 1995 keeps showing that the existing advisors steadily keep on bringing in about 20%

    of recruits.

    When I asked managers in my recruitment and retention programs where the advisors had come from who

    later become top20% advisors, an interesting picture emerged. Over 95% of recruits who became top 20%

    advisors were referred by top 20% advisors.

    Getting top advisors to refer the agency does not go automatically. You have to get them to feel part of the

    agency and the company. The agency manager taking out the top 20%, say every month or two months,

    is probably the investment with the best return on investment today in life insurance. After lunch (say at

    dessert) you can bring up how they could maybe support the mood of the agency by getting some qualied

    people in the door. You might want to talk a little bit about which age and educational background your

    agency is looking for. To give top 20% advisors a commission after the applicant is still in the agency after 3

    months is cost effective and workable.

    Pros 1: A great source for recruits if you make them come from your top20% advisors.

    Pros 2: Often the top advisors also do some mentoring which helps persistency and productivity of the

    recruits.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    31/56

    31

    Cons 1: Sometimes your top people enjoy all the attention and respect they get in the agency. They are not

    always on re to drag other people into the agency that could be as good as or better than they are.

    Its like asking my wife to introduce me to a younger prettier woman said Nikos from Athens.

    With GenY I noticed it seems easier to get referrals for your agency than GenerationX. Could this be

    because they are not as sensitive to hierarchy in the agency as GenX advisors or maybe it is that GenY

    expects to get everything they need through referrals?

    Second generation from top 20% of advisors is also interesting.

    Pros1: In my experience they often outperform their parents at a younger age. The retention rate on the

    second generation seems over 50% and they tend to add a lot of stability to the team. Since their family

    worked for your company logic dictates and experience shows that they are much more likely to remain

    loyal than other GenY recruits. You rarely go wrong with second generation. Unfortunately less than 1% of

    the GenY recruits are second generation and about 2% of top GenY advisors.

    Pros 2: It makes your agency look awfully good if you can say to a GenY applicant that you have second

    generation GenY advisors that are doing very well.

    Cons 1: There do not seem to be enough of them.

    3. Someone from outside referred your agency.

    This could be one of your contacts, someone you know at the university, other employers you know or even

    clients of the agency. Older surveys * put this percentage as high as 10% of applicants. In my surveys today

    it does not score more than 5% or even less.

    Pros: If the contacts are established and working and cost little to maintain, great!

    Cons: Maybe the percentage of this source seems to be going down because people are spending more time

    on the internet and less time face to face.

    Quality of people they refer to you can be a problem. Although this source is about 5% of recruits I estimate

    less than 1% of top 20% GenY came from this source.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    32/5632

    4. Job boards and newspaper ads.

    Results from Newspaper ads are declining badly nearly everywhere. They are

    useless or close to useless. Fewer and fewer GenY even have a newspaper

    subscription. Quality of applicants is the lowest of all the sources*. No top

    manager uses this as an important source of recruits and when they try it, it

    does not work.

    Job boards: The growth trend not surprisingly is very much tilted to online

    in nearly all markets. Applicants from job boards are rising sharply all over

    the world. Even if the method seems the same as newspaper ads the boards

    often produce results where the newspaper ads do not. There is a big variation per market but in developed

    countries 20% of people who get appointed come from this source. This does not mean that they also

    comprise 20% of top GenY advisors. I do not have hard gures on this but retention seems much lower than

    average. A guess would be 30% lower than other sources. The reason for this seems pretty obvious. They

    saw an ad, they came, they joined, then they saw another ad and left.

    Managers mention the effectiveness of job boards goes up by like 500% or more if you back it up with an

    effective up to date agency or company website that appeals to educated GenY advisors. If the ad on the

    job board catches their interest they go to your website and check your agency out. If they like your site the

    good ones will contact you.

    Pros: Cheap.

    Cons: Many unqualied people, if you do not put on the job board that you are looking for people with a

    technical or nancial backgrounds.

    6. The company and or agency website

    The fastest growing source of recruits. *Over 50% of the candidates check out the company and agency

    website. This one is not getting bigger by the year. It seems to get bigger by the month. From the point of

    view of return on your investment, your agency website should be your biggest priority.

    Pros: It is the thing that is pulling everywhere at the moment.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    33/56

    33

    Cons: It cost time and money to develop. But everybody I speak with in all developed markets (Dubai,

    Singapore, the Netherlands) and also most developing markets (Russia, Vietnam) said it was worth it.

    Recommendation: Get busy upgrading your agency website. Just do it.

    7. Facebook and LinkedIn

    Facebook is growing by the month everywhere in the world.

    Pros: Cheap.

    Cons: takes a good amount of time.

    8. They just walked into the agency.

    Surprisingly about 8% of candidates used to comes from people who just walked in.*Or called in or mailed

    in without the manager doing anything.The quality of people who just come in instead of being dragged in is surprisingly good. *(Limra) Maybe

    this is because in our line of work you have to have initiative. The client will never call you. You have to call

    them.

    Therefore successful managers have a rule: You can always make time to talk with a person that walked into

    your agency or contacted you before you contacted them.

    Pros: Quality of applicants is usually quite high. Good retention too. They volunteered, didnt they?

    Cons: It is not easy to control the ow of people who just walk into your agency. A good webpage and

    Facebook presence helps.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    34/5634

    9. They came (or you stole them) from another company.

    This used to be as high as 28% of all people hired in 2005.* A recent study shows it has now dropped

    to18%.*

    Pros 1: The productivity of experienced advisors is higher because although they sell about 20% less policies

    then new advisors their premiums are 30% higher.*

    Pros 2: Their cancellation rates are lower.

    Pros 3: In 2005 they used to be about as loyal as newly hired advisors. A dismal 12% was still there after 4

    years. Now retention is close to 30% after 4 years.

    Pros 4: It saves on training costs.

    Cons 1: They can have a negative effect on your newly recruited GenY advisors. They usually say things

    like: I work smart not hard like you. Their lack of enthusiasm is contagious and demoralizing if you are also

    building up a predominantly GenY team.

    All your new GenY advisors can do is work hard and be enthusiastic before they also learn to work smart.

    Cons 2: Kristy from MetLife AIG Romania once put it this way: There are people from ING here in

    Romania that I would love to talk to. But the people that I would love to talk to from ING do not want to

    talk to me. And I do not want to talk to the ING advisors that want to talk to me.

    The more companies the advisor has been with, the less you want them on your team.

    Cons 3: The Famous 5 companies and market leaders anywhere in the world, never actively look for

    advisors from other companies to recruit. There has to be a reason for that. It is always the companies that

    have no culture, nothing to be proud of that a GenY advisor would want to join that try to compensate for all

    of this by offering a bit more money than the company they were working for. In the last 25 years working

    for the major insurance companies I have met 500 people who I knew before, from another company. In the

    breaks I always ask them the same question: Why did you leave ABC insurance? If the advisor was in the

    top 20% it was usually ego reasons. Medium and low advisors left for money.

    Lesson learned: You always want to be nice to your top 20% and really nice to your top 5%. It is also very

    foolish to spend too much on advisors who do not make good numbers.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    35/56

    35

    10. University students in their last year or before last year

    This method is used a lot in the US especially by the Famous 5.

    They hire students with a nancial and technical background

    (80%)*. Sometimes from another background (20%). They offer

    the students a 1 to 3 month internship in the summer vacation.

    They can make money and put the experience on their resume.

    The students like the money they make and feel that 3 months

    with a life insurance company during their economics study

    makes their resume look better after they graduate. They feel it increases their chance of getting a better job.

    About 50% of students who nish the 3 month summer internship at the Famous 5, got job offers. 2 out of

    3 accept the offer.*

    Pros 1: All Famous 5 have been active recruiting at universities

    for over 30 years. All have expanded the program in 2010.*

    Pros 2: 80% of the top producers and about 85% of the managers

    at the Famous 5 came from this student intern program.Cons 1: You lose a lot, about 65%after the 3 month internship

    Cons 2: It takes a lot of commitment, time and money. This does

    not work as a little program that you do this year. You really have

    to be a great company. The students are not fooled easily.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    36/5636

    CHAPTER 4

    HOW FAMOUS 5 MANAGERS STRUCTURE THEIR

    RECRUITMENT INTERVIEW.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    37/56

    37

    Structured interviews are a better way to predict how successful someone will be than unstructured ones. It

    is natural to want to see good things in the person across the table, especially if you need more productive

    people because you are behind your plan.

    Many managers still do not use structured interviews because they say: I know how to do this. I have been

    in the business for 10 years. Unfortunately their self-condence does not seem be backed up with higher

    than average production and retention rates.

    So the trend is structured interviews.

    Trust GenY to nd a way around this: They posted the questions the recruiters from the nancial service

    companies are asking on the internet. This way they could help each other give the right answers to your

    questions. Just like in school to get good grades with the teacher.

    You can nd the questions the Famous 5 are asking and GenY are sharing on a website called glassdoor.

    com. On glassdoor.com thousands of applicants from all over the world uploaded the questions the managers

    are asking.

    This is what the Famous 5 are asking. I have also included questions that would conform to the recent

    research ndings on retention.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    38/5638

    1. Entitlement hole lters.

    Retention of people in the industry who felt entitled was horrible said the Limra-Mc Kinsey study*. As

    you of course know from bitter experience, if you let a person who has a the world owes me a living

    mentality into your team, both you and they will end up unhappy and frustrated after they leave you with no

    production.So a question to lter for entitlement could be:

    What do you feel you deserve?

    Hopeful answer: As much as I produce and that will be a lot.

    Scary answer: The Company should provide me with this and that

    What do you want to get out of a company like Northwestern Mutual? (NW mutual)

    This is one of your questions to nd out about their entitlement thinking.

    Hopeful: I want to make a lot and this seems to be a good place.

    Scary: Well lets talk about my needs. I really need this and that

    On what factors does your success depend?

    A 2010 survey of top advisors found* (Limra 2008):

    80%: I became successful because of my drive.

    15%: You have to have the right products and technical support.

    5%: I am successful because of the support of my manager.

    Hopeful: I have a big drive for success. I need good products and good information technology backup.

    Scary: I need to be provided with the right salary, tools, training, mentoring and you need to set up all my

    appointments and preferably sit in on most of them.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    39/56

    39

    2. A pessimist lter.

    MetLife asked a famous professor, professor Seligman: Can you nd the

    one thing we can ask in the interview section of a candidate that can help

    us predict if the person will stay and be successful?The professor looked

    over all the psychological tests that people had taken and how successful

    they then became in the business.

    Then the professor boiled it down to just one thing: People who described

    themselves as optimists had a 40% better chance to be successful.

    The professor did not say this, but if you use logic then candidates who

    are pessimists would probably produce like 40% less. Then your job is to

    nd out if the person across from you is:

    1. An optimist. +40% production.

    2. Normal.0% average production.

    3. A pessimist. -40% production.

    The only experience GenY applicants have lots of, is in giving the right answers to teachers. Are you

    optimistic? They would all say: Oh yes, of course, I am very optimistic. Very few people who are

    pessimistic would say: Absolutely. I see a problem in every solution.

    So you have to use trick questions to get the real answers. Therefore you, based on your observations and

    listening to the answers that they give to your trick questions, have to determine how much of an optimist

    they are on a 1 to 10 scale.

    Do you sometimes get accused of staying too optimistic too long?

    Hopeful answer: If they are really optimistic they will say: Yes unfortunately I have a tendency to stay too

    optimistic too long. You hear: This must really be an optimistic person. Per professor Seligman you should

    now be more optimistic yourself about their chances.Scary: If they say: Oh no, nobody would accuse me of

    such a thing, you become suspicious.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    40/5640

    How would you see the long term chances in nancial services for young people?

    Hopeful: They say: If you want to learn what needs to be learned and work

    hard you will get ahead. You hear: I will work hard, learn my job, give good

    service and make money.

    Scary: They say: There are not so much opportunities for us. You hear: I do

    not have drive. I will give up fast and leave.

    What adjectives would your friends use to describe you?

    Hopeful: They say: Ambitious, hard worker, goal oriented, optimistic. You hear: I see the opportunities

    and I will soon be in the top 20% making a great income.

    Scary: They say: Easy going, cooperative, fun to be around.You hear: I have so many things going on that

    I will get distracted and give up.

    Do you have a Facebook account?

    (Better yet check it out before the interview) Try to answer the question: is this an optimist? Do his friends

    seem optimistic? Does he seem to have goals, does he and his friends seem to be ambitious? Do they

    sometimes talk about achieving something or is it all about being entertained.

    What you want to see is how many friends they have. If they have many friends this is a very good sign.

    A December 2010 study showed that the brains of people who have big Facebook accounts are wired

    differently than those that do not. Common sense would tell you that a candidate with a big Facebook or

    better LinkedIn account probably would do better in selling nancial services than someone who does not.

    Hopefully Limra will study this to get hard facts.

    Exercise: On a 1 to 10 scale how much of an optimist is the applicant.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    41/56

    41

    3. How desirable is the applicants background on a 1 to 10 scale?

    Do you have a university education?

    If no, big trouble. Remember this is -40%*. The answers to the other questions better be very convincing for

    you to guarantee a good chance of persistency with this person.

    What did you major in?

    If they have a technical and nancial background you should probably hire this person if the other questions

    are kind of ok too. If they only started with a nancial or technical subject but did not nish, you are still

    interested. You are probably not competing with big companies offering big salaries. Besides your agency

    is usually better off with a person who studied computer science for 2 years and then quit than a person who

    nished literature.

    Were you a salesperson?

    If someone sold cars or electronics before and has no university education in nances or exact science your

    chances for a successful advisor seem close to 0 anywhere in the world. Try to nish the interview as fast as

    possible, while of course staying polite.

    If you were to be ill or so how long could you survive nancially 1 week, 1 month, 1 year? (New York

    Life.)

    They want to nd out if the recruit has big debts that he has to pay. If they have too many debts, the probably

    low income will force them in trouble. It is probably ok to hire an engineer or computer technician even if

    they have a lot of debt.

    Action step: On a 1 to 10 scale how desirable is the persons background?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    42/5642

    4. Work life balance hole lter.

    What is something that would come between you and your success in your career? (New York Life)

    Hopeful: Nothing. They say this right away and did not have to think about it.

    Scary: A pause, they have to think about it. You think: If they have to think about it so much, this might be a

    sign that they are trying to give the right answer instead of the true answer.

    How many hours per week do you feel comfortable working?

    Hopeful: I have a lot of nancial goals and obligations that I need to meet. I am a hard worker, I have

    responsibilities and I need the money. I want to be successful. I am a single parent and I need to pay the

    bills. I want to give the best education for my children and that takes money. I promised my wife that we

    would get our own home.

    Scary: Well, I have a lot of things in my life that are important to me. I guess 35 hours would be ne. If

    they start talking about work life balance this is a red ag. Unfortunately this will happen a lot.

    What does work-life balance mean to you?

    Hopeful: If you hear something like nancial goals to get something, this is good. I want the best education

    for my kids.

    Scary: I want to fully develop myself in life in as many elds as possible.

    How do you think success in this business looks like? (MetLife)

    On a scale from 1 to 10, how hard is this person willing to work to be successful in your agency?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    43/56

    43

    5. Does the applicant really want to be nancially successful?

    Are you a competitive type of person or are you more like a team player?

    Promising: I guess I am competitive. If he is competitive, he will ght to get the client to get what is the

    right product for his circumstances and not be so afraid of rejection.

    Scary: I am team player. You hear: I am dedicated to and will agree with all the clients objections. To be

    liked is more important for me than to be effective. I will make sure not to ask the client any uncomfortable

    questions and therefore make few sales.

    Which abilities do you feel would help you in this position? (Northwestern Mutual)

    Hopeful: My drive, ambition, I am hard worker, success is important for me.

    Scary: My ability to get along with people.

    Which adversities did you have to overcome? (Northwestern Mutual)

    In many countries the best advisors in the whole network are immigrants who arrived broke. The bigger

    adversities they had to overcome, the more likely they are to overcome the adversities that a career in

    nancial services offers.

    What motivates you?(MetLife)

    I found that top producers are not surprisingly motivated by money and success. They want to use the money

    to have a standard of living that proves that they are the best. Childish? Maybe, but it works. *Limra survey.

    What does success mean to you?

    If they say something like I need a ton of money and I will sweat for it), great. If they say something like

    I want to be a balanced person, you know that their bank balance from working for your company will be

    close to 0.

    Are you willing to make a lower income for 1 to 2 years so you too, can be part of the 55% of advisors

    who makes over $75.000*per year? (Or whatever the percentage is in your country)

    Action step: Based on the answers, how success oriented is the applicant on a scale from 1 to 10?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    44/5644

    6. How comfortable is the applicant discussing peoples nancial situation?

    How easy is it to talk about peoples nances?

    Most people get nervous or embarrassed asking question about peoples

    nances. The reason people who worked at banks, and people with a

    nancial background do so well in nancial services is because they do

    not get nervous. Money is just money. Like air. If you have no air and no

    food, you get in trouble. Technical people make so much money because

    they are not nervous discussing peoples nances.

    Promising answer: To talk with people about their future nances is a very important thing to do.

    Scary answer: Well I am a little uncomfortable but I guess I could get used to it.

    Before we hire you, you have to do 10 surveys of peoples nancial situation.Is that a problem?

    (Northwestern Mutual)

    GenY applicants complain about this point because they say it is a trick to get them to sell to their friends.

    They are probably right but if a person does not want to talk about peoples nancial condition what are his

    chances for becoming a successful advisor?

    What do you know about selling nancial services?

    What do you know about ABC nancial?

    Exercise: Should you revise the questions you ask in your structured interview?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    45/56

    45

    CHAPTER 5

    WHAT FAMOUS FIVE MANAGERS ARE SAYING AFTER

    IT SEEMS THEY ARE TALKING TO THE RIGHT PERSON.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    46/5646

    Do you describe the career in a Generation X or a GenY way?

    GenY hates salespeople and anything that sounds like a salesperson.* (Limra

    research) A salesperson has only pros for his product or service. Some

    Generation X managers say: This is a great career and you can make a lot of

    money. Our products are the best in the industry. Just be passionate and you can

    do it.

    If you go on and on about the pros and never give any cons GenY applicants

    will get suspicious. They will suspect you of trying to sell them. The feedback

    forums on glassdoor.com are full of complaints of GenY applicants who

    complain that the Generation X manager only said positives things. They felt he was trying to sell them on

    the career instead of giving them fair and objective information. The moment they realized this, many on the

    forum commented that they stopped listening and just tried to nish the interview as fast as possible so they

    could get out of the room.*

    On any forum where GenY discusses products or services like new smartphones, IPad apps, or the benets

    of working for Prudential, it is expected that any reviewer includes pros and cons.

    So what do GenY recruit themselves see as the pros and cons of a career in nancial services?

    I went through 200 pros and cons on glassdoor.com and compiled the stats. Sometimes people gave more

    than 1 pro and con so the total is above 100%.

    Pros: 1.No limits on your earnings. 58 %. (They mean: I really am

    entitled. I need a lot of money hole.)

    2. Flexibility. 45%. (They mean: my work life balance.)

    3. Great to work for a company with a brand name, company has

    been in business 100 years. 25%. (I am important because I work

    for an important company.)

    4. Great team. 10% (They are collectivist: I want to be part of a team.)

    5. Great training is provided. Great further training is also provided. 7 %.(They mean: I will be also be

    Generation Now 10 years from now.)

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    47/56

    47

    The ndings are about the same as a 2007 Limra study which said: Income exibility and independence of

    the position is appreciated*

    Cons: 1. Commissions only. 60%. (They mean: I am very important. I think you should just pay me for

    being important.)

    2. No leads are provided by the company: 40%. (They mean: Wait a moment, I am great at giving the right

    answers to the professor, not in actually getting something done.)

    3. Rejection. 25%. (They mean: I am the greatest but I do not want to test it.)

    Therefore a manager could be more effective if he says:

    There are pros and cons to this job. The pros are that your earnings are unlimited. Half the people here

    with a technical background like you, are making over $xxx per year after 4 years.

    You have a lot of exibility with your time. You will represent a company which has been around for over

    100 years and which is a brand name.

    ABC nancial provides you with sales and product training at no cost to you. You will be trained on

    the most up to date products and most up to date ways to sell them. You will be mentored on the job by

    experienced advisors. Then after you have learned, your income should be just as high as that of the otherengineers.

    The Cons: You get paid what you are worth. In the rst 2 years most advisors struggle to get established. In

    four years after they are established, 50% of advisors have an income of over $xxx.

    Since you are not micromanaged you have to be smart to manage your time. Your mentor will make a

    marketing plan with you on how to build your business but you have to execute it.

    ABC nancial does not give you leads. Of course your mentor will train you how to get referrals and after

    you are established, your business will run by itself on referrals if you apply what you were taught in the

    training.

    Most people would rather spend all they have and then borrow as much as they can to buy stuff. So your

    message of savings and responsibility for the future is not always welcome. Usually you will face serious

    rejection for your message and solutions.

    Of course it helps that you work for a serious company like ABC Financial. But there is still the rejection

    and suspicion that you have to deal with every day. Most people cannot handle that.

    Exercise: What pros and cons will you give in your next recruitment meeting?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    48/5648

    Are you lling the 9 holes when you present the career?

    Every year Business Week magazine publishes a list of the 100 coolest companies for young people to start

    a career with. The winners:

    The big 4 accounting rms.

    Deloitte (1) Pricewaterhouse (2) Ernst and Young (3) and KPMG (4).

    The joke is that top 20% advisors make more money with us in

    after a couple of years than they can at one of the major accounting

    rms.* (BLS statistics) The big 4 accounting rms also ll the

    precise hole To make the career sound more attractive managers

    say:ABC is one of largest and strongest nancial institutions in

    the world. You consult clients on taking a long term look at their

    nancial situations because of the strength and expertise of ABC.

    You can assure your clients that their nancial affairs are in the

    hands of a strong organization. ABC has been there when it was needed for over 150 (that is how old most

    insurance companies are) years.

    Cool technology companies.

    Of course the winners of the past years Apple, Google and

    Microsoft are still hot. But surprisingly not as hot as the

    accounting rms. Managers of the Famous 5 have made

    themselves more attractive by stressing the progress they have

    made in technology.

    Managers say:At ABC nancial we employ cutting edge

    technology. With your IPad you directly access our data bank to

    search for optimum solutions for your clients. Our websites also helps you to keep your clients updated on

    solutions to their problems. After you have made the sale, you show the clients how to access his information

    online. Because of our highly automated systems you are able to offer the client cost effective solutions to

    their problems while still making a nice reward for yourself every time the client accepts your solution.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    49/56

    49

    The Chinese secret service, CIA, FBI.(Precise hole)

    In China, university graduates are queuing up to join the secret

    service. The Chinese secret service can only hire 1 out of 69

    university graduates who apply for the job. Who would have

    predicted 15 years ago that the FBI and CIA would be real cool

    places to work?

    Steve Jobs generation had a fascination with creating beautiful

    things. GenY seems to have a fascination with catching bad

    things. We have raised a generation of detectives and money counters. Sighed Hendrik from Amsterdam

    So you say: You go to many places where you investigate peoples real nancial condition. Many times

    you discover that their real nancial condition and their imagined condition do not match. The company

    will teach you precise questioning techniques at no cost to you. With your techniques you help your clients

    uncover where problems could occur. After you have identied potential catastrophes, youll show the client

    how they can easily prevent them. (You are important)You can do this because of the extensive training you

    receive in investigatory nancial procedure.Then you nd the missing points. Your knowledge of nancewhich you have acquired with the training that ABC Financial provides you the tools, to make a plan for

    your clients. You will provide peace of mind for families. And of course the more people you help the more

    money you make.

    United Nations Peace Corps, Teaching corps. (I am so great hole)

    It is often said that GenY as a generation is more socially

    conscious than Generation X. *(Twenge)

    GenY loves to think that they are more socially conscious, but

    research fails to nd this. Research shows there seems to be

    no real difference in social consciousness between boomers,

    Generation X, and GenY at the same age*. Generation X was

    about as socially conscious as GenY but they were just not as loud about it. One GenY advisor said he

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    50/5650

    could not come to the meeting because he was running a half marathon to alleviate hunger. Do you know

    what causes hunger the agency manager asked? No, but I sure am doing my part to ght against it said

    the GenY advisor. You could say: You help families in your community and older people. People like

    your parents (they are closer to their parents than Generation X)improve their long-term nancial outlook

    through your advice. You also ensure that the money for a good education will be there for the children.

    Since you will be a trained nancial professional, the quality of your advice has great impact on people you

    consult. Unfortunately sometimes people are a little bit closed minded. They believe that borrowing money

    to satisfy some urge they have at the moment will bring them lasting happiness. You however come in and

    through your probing questions get them to realize what is really important. Unfortunately some people

    are a little bit confused and emotional about their desire to keep on spending more than they have. So your

    efforts are not always appreciated. That is the bad part of the job. But the top people manage to get over the

    bad parts and nd the strength to carry on.

    BMW, Procter and Gamble, Nestle. (Important hole)

    GenY feels that if they work for a big respected brand they are

    more important. Generation X did not care as much about brands.

    They cared more about how much they earned.

    Give some statistics to show how important and well respected

    your company is. This is a bit of a paradox. On one hand they

    want to be Generation Now and hate old stuff but they love

    historic stuff. They also love to be part of history.

    You will represent a company that has been in business since 1848. ABC is one of the top 5 companies in this

    country. Here on the wall you see a photo of the ABC headquarters.

    Exercise: On your next recruitment presentation try make your opportunity sound as attractive as what the

    big guys are offering.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    51/56

    51

    Are you ghting the I am important hole by always talking about them?

    They have iPods, iPads, IPhones. GenMe only listen when you talk about them. I notice in many countries

    that those managers who are getting good results from GenY use the word You about 10 times more than

    managers who are getting poor results.One webpage to recruit GenY advisors from MetLife managed to use

    the word You 15 times in just 10 lines:

    Youalways control that you get paidyourworth. (Brilliant they are entitled and they are truly in control of

    all the income they make.)

    Youdevelopyour market and client base. (You are important)

    Youprot from businessesyouhave written in the past. (Entitlement)

    Asyouchange and grow,your career can also change withyou. (Education orientation)

    MetLife providesyoua variety of career paths with training and support to helpyousucceed at each step.

    (Each step means control and precision)

    Whetheryouwant to be the best possible Financial Services Representative as a generalist, seek an area of

    specialization, or decide to pursue a career in eld management or a corporate opportunity, MetLife will

    helpyou every step of the way. (MetLife is helpful like their favorite teacher was)

    Yourpotential for growth and income is inyourcontrol.

    Exercise: Are you sure you talk enough about them?

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    52/5652

    Are you compensating for terrible image of life insurance by looking cool and up

    to date?

    Obviously the industry is seen as so uncool. That is why successful

    managers have to sweat so much to look cool and up to date. This way

    they hope the GenY applicants will not associate them with the old life

    insurance. This is unfortunate since according to a Jan 2011 worldwide

    ING survey between 21 and 29% of people are looking for help on their

    nances, but they do not know where to get itGenY have little experience

    in anything. They do not know and understand so many things yet. So

    they look and judge you by the things they do know and understand. Your

    webpage, your smartphone, your laptop and your outt.

    Life insurance has such a bad reputation. How could a GenY recruit believe you that there is a great future

    for him in your company when you have a 3 year old low-end mobile phone.

    Exercise: How will you overcome the old life insurance stereotype by looking up to date?

    Are you doing enough to make sure they are successful so they stay?

    The usual procedure has been forever to get your new recruit to make a

    list of a 100 names that they can contact to discuss their possible nancial

    needs. This is incredibly unpopular with GenY. Many people on glassdoor.

    com complain about this. This has been called the natural market for as long

    as anybody can remember. But anybodys natural market is just so big. Per

    Limra, GenY even more than Generation X buys because of referrals. If you

    want to teach your GenY advisors how to get referrals, you can download

    the Referral course from erikvosinternational.com (free for managers). This

    is a course of about 30 one hour GenY meetings that teaches them how to get referrals after they exhausted

    their natural market.

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    53/56

    53

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    54/5654

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    55/56

    55

  • 8/14/2019 GenY.pdf

    56/56