gsp capstone
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
1/26
Parsons 1
Courtney Parsons
GSP Capstone
Spring 2014
Examining Constraint Over Sexuality in Sula and The Virgin Suicides
The Virgin Suicides by Jeffrey Eugenides and Sula by oni !orrison are not t"o boo#s
t$at s%$olars "ould rea%$ for to %ompare& Sula is mostly loo#ed at for its ta#e on 'fri%an(
'meri%an female sexuality "$ile The Virgin Suicides is analy)ed for t$e mystery be$ind t$e
group of sisters sui%ides& $ese t"o novels are also set in very different time periods* Sula
mostly ta#ing pla%e in t$e 1+20,s and 1+-0,s in a small prominently 'fri%an('meri%an to"n
"$ile The Virgin Suicides ta#es pla%e in 1+.0,s suburbia& /ot$ of t$ese times periods* $o"ever*
are #no"n for t$eir in%rease in sexual freedom and liberation& 't t$e same time* bot$ stories
ex$ibit t$e result of %ommunity and family ba%#las$ on t$ese freedoms& /ot$ of t$ese novels
suggest t$at no matter t$e advan%ements t$roug$out $istory t$at "omen ma#e to"ards
expressing t$eir sexuality openly* t$ere "ill al"ays be some type of %ontrol over t$eir sexuality&
The 1970’s
/ot$ novels $ave t$e time period of t$e 1+.0,s in %ommon as Sula "as "ritten during
t$at time and The Virgin Suicides is set during t$at time& t is important to note t$at !orrison
"rote t$is novel in t$e .0,s* loo#ing ba%# in time to see $o" t$e 20,s and -0,s s$aped opinions
and paved t$e "ay for t$e so%ietal %$ange of t$e .0,s& Similarly* Eugenides "rote The Virgin
Suicides a generation after it is set&
$e 1+.0,s are often mar#ed in movies and television "it$ long $air* flo"ing %lot$es and
lots of flo"ers and floral patterns* mar#ing t$e end of t$e $ippie era "it$ 3oodsto%# o%%urring
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
2/26
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
3/26
Parsons -
"it$in married and non(married "omen,s lives& $e blatant exposure to sexuality t$at everyone
"as re%eiving around t$is time %reated a ne" role for "omen in so%iety& 3omen "ere no"
expe%ted to be eroti% %ounterparts to t$eir signifi%ant ot$er* but $usbands and "ives approa%$ed
t$e %onBugal bed "it$ "idely divergent expe%tations about t$e meaning of sex&A 3omen "ere
still pressured to believe t$at t$ey "ere t$ere to $ave %$ildren* "$ile men simply enBoyed t$e
eroti% pleasure& $ey also uestioned "omen,s sexuality and t$e o"ners$ip so%iety $ad over it&
8eminists "ere understanding t$at "omen "ere often only loo#ed at as sex obBe%ts and no matter
"$at t$ey did* t$ey reali)ed t$at married or not* Dt$eir bodies $ad o"ners$ip by many> men*
do%tors* %lot$es and %osmeti% manufa%turers* advertisers* %$ur%$es* s%$ools( everyone but
ourselves& $e goal of t$e feminist movement soon be%ame to gain freedom from t$e sexual
oppression t$at "omen fa%ed everyday of t$eir lives& Some "ays in "$i%$ t$e feminist
movement a%ted to"ards t$is freedom "as to drive for more %ontrol over birt$ %ontrol and
abortion& 6o"ever* t$ey "ere met "it$ t$e same type of roadblo%#s( men in %ontrol of t$e
positions t$at mandated t$ese t"o struggles&
The 1920’s
$e 1+.0,s "ere not t$e first time t$at t$e "ay 'meri%an so%iety expresses and governs sexuality
"as uestioned* $o"ever& Sula "as "ritten by oni !orrison in 1+.-* but it is set during anot$er
time of %$ange "it$in 'meri%an so%iety* t$e 1+20,s and 1+-0,s& 6er novel s$o"s t$at %$ange
doesn,t %ome "it$out some pre%edent& $e %$anges made in t$e 1+.0,s "ould not be possible
"it$out t$e %$anges made in t$e 1+20,s and 1+-0,s& $e 1+20,s in 'meri%an $istory stand out as
time "$en a substantial amount of %$ange began o%%urring in regards to female sexuality&
5 D’Emilio, Intimate Matters, 309
6 Ibid, 312
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
4/26
Parsons 4
'lt$oug$ daily life for males and females "as still separated into t"o distin%t sp$eres Fnopf* 1+94@* 1-9
12 7,Emilio* Intimate Matters* 240
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
5/26
Parsons A
8as$ion* musi% and movies "ere %$anging during t$e 1+20,s as "ell& 7resses "ere be%oming
s$orter and a rise in t$e popularity of dan%e $alls and musi% venues "as booming&1- ' ne" type
of "oman "as be%oming a part of t$e everyday life be%ause s$e smo#ed* dran#* dan%ed* and
voted& S$e %ut $er $air* "ore ma#e(up* and "ent to petting parties& S$e "as giddy and too# ris#s&
S$e "as a flapper&14 !usi% "as be%oming more %entered on love and sex& 8or example* a
popular song during t$is time "as t 6ad to /e =ou "$i%$ taug$t listeners love "as a
mysterious experien%e t$at o%%urred in a flas$ "$en t$e %$emistry "as rig$t1A !ovie titles
featured sensual "ords su%$ as flirts and lips enti%ing young vie"ers into t$e t$eaters to
experien%e "$at sex and love "as all about&
'rguably t$e most important advan%ement t$at %ame from t$is time period "as t$at of t$e
advan%ement of %ontra%eption& !argaret Sanger %ontinued to remain t$e fa%e of t$e
%ontra%eption movement for "omen into t$e 1+20,s and t$e 1+-0,s& 7uring t$is time* $o"ever*
s$e found t$at $er %ause "as be%oming more politi%i)ed t$at s$e t$oug$t it s$ould be& o fly
under t$e radar of politi%ians "anting to get involved* Sanger de%ided to %ampaign solely to
ma#e %ontra%eption freely available for "omen1 't t$e time* male politi%ians "ere "ary of
Sanger,s motives for %ontra%eption* so s$e felt t$at targeting %ontra%eption only for "omen
"ould $elp t$e gender group t$at s$e "as striving to $elp& 6o"ever* Sanger "as ultimately
13 3olo%$* omen and the American !xperience, 1-+
14 Jennifer 5osenberg
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
6/26
Parsons
su%%essful& 6er original %lini% in :e" =or# t$rived and many ot$er "omen,s %lini%s around t$e
nited States "ere modeled after $ers&1.
'lt$oug$ t$is seemed to be t$riving time for "omen,s independen%e in t$e realm of sexuality*
t$is "as not true of bla%# "omen and men during t$is time& $e lega%y of slavery lay $eavily on
'fri%an('meri%ans s$oulders& 7uring slavery* it "as diffi%ult to form lasting monogamous
relations$ips be%ause one partner "as often sold and moved to anot$er plantation& $us t$e
"oman "as t$oug$t to be t$e %aregiver of t$e %$ildren and $ad to learn to raise a family by
$erself& /e%ause of t$is t$ere is an emp$asis on t$e "oman&
$ere "as a great taboo bet"een bla%#s and "$ites in regards to sex and many times*
bla%# males "ere lyn%$ed for being a%%used of $aving sex "it$ "$ite "omen
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
7/26
Parsons .
's t$e fear of overgro"t$ of t$e bla%# %ommunity be%ame more "idespread* soon did t$e
amount of money set aside Bust for %ontra%eption for bla%#s&21
Sula
n !orrison,s novel* Sula Pea%e and t$e ot$er members of t$e %ommunity of $e /ottom in
O$io experien%e t$e obvious divide bet"een t$e "$ite middle %lass and t$eir o"n rural
environment during t$is time& Sula lives in an un%onventional $ome "it$ $er grandmot$er* Eva
and $er mot$er* 6anna$& $e t$ree "omen represent e%onomi%ally and sexually independent
ladies "$o gain strengt$ from ea%$ ot$er in t$e absen%e of a male member22 /ot$ Eva and
6anna$ "ere flirtatious t$roug$out Sula,s %$ild$ood and Sula remembers %oming $ome from
s%$ool and finding different men in $er mot$er,s bed ea%$ day& $is %onstant in and out taug$t
Sula t$at sex "as pleasant and freuent but ot$er"ise unremar#able2- 6anna$ "ould almost
never $ave t$e men s$e $ad sex "it$ sleep over "it$ $er be%ause t$at implied a measure of trust
and a definite %ommitment* an idea t$at 6anna$ reBe%ted %ompletely&24 Sex "as sex to $er and
not$ing else& n %ontrast* Sula,s best friend* :el* gre" up in a more stru%tured $ouse$old "it$ $er
mot$er* 6elene& !ost members of t$eir family* "it$ t$e ex%eption of :el,s grandmot$er
5o%$elle* are %onventional Bust li#e :el and 6elene& $e t"o girls %ould not $ave more different
upbringings& 6o"ever* t$roug$out t$e boo# t$e t"o girls develop a %lose friends$ip& :el de%ides
to marry and Sula de%ides to leave $e /ottom to dis%over $erself& S$e lives independently and
openly* sleeping "it$ many men until s$e %omes ba%# to t$e /ottom sexually free& Sula $as no
21 bid&
22 6ira* 'li& Gender 'nalysis in oni !orrison,s Sula and "elo#ed & Middle$!ast %ournal ofScientific &esearch 1&10
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
8/26
Parsons 9
ego* t$at is s$e is not able to imagine $erself as %reated by $er %$oi%es& 2A S$e $as very fe"
boundaries* $o"ever* and ends up $aving sex "it$ :el,s beloved $usband* Jude& $e friends$ip
t$at t$e t"o "omen $ave "$en Sula moved ba%# is %ompletely bro#en no"* but Sula moves on
"it$ apparently little %are& :el sees t$is a%t as Sula trying to ta#e %ontrol over Jude* but Sula,s
attitude is t$at sex is merely for pleasure "it$out %ontrol& S$e $as no ot$er motives be$ind it&
Sula %ontinues to $ave sex t$roug$out t$e to"n "it$ many ot$er married men and t$e people of
$e /ottom begin to Budge and loo# do"n upon $er& $is establis$es a %$allenge to t$e
%onventional system of ex%$ange bet"een t"o people engaging in sex be%ause Sula is not as#ing
for anyt$ing in return* "$en in t$e %onventional arrangement* t$e "oman "ould usually as# for
somet$ing in return su%$ as $ousing* support or t$e li#e& $e Budgment rea%$es a ne" severity
"$en it is rumored t$at Sula $as been engaging in sex "it$ "$ite men* one of t$e "orst a%ts t$at
s$e %ould %ommit as a bla%# "oman& $e boundary t$at is being %rossed $ere is t$e fa%t t$at by
$aving relations "it$ a "$ite man* Sula is t$oug$t to be %onsorting "it$ t$e enemy& n t$is
instan%e* t$e "$ite man is s$o"ing o"ners$ip over t$e bla%# "oman,s body& $is is a travesty
t$at is refle%ted in t$e $istory of t$e time* t$ere "ere many problems asso%iated "it$ $aving sex
"it$ someone of anot$er ra%e* for bot$ bla%#s and "$ites& 6o"ever* Sula tries to #eep $er o"n
and ignore t$e tal# around $er* instead %ontinuing $er open sexual relations$ips "it$ t$e men
t$roug$out t$e to"n& $e to"n seems to %ome toget$er over t$eir mutual $atred of Sula* but after
s$e dies
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
9/26
Parsons +
The Virgin Suicides ta#es pla%e rig$t in t$e middle of t$e Sexual 5evolution of t$e 1+.0,s
in Grosse Point* !i%$igan& 5onald and Sara Iisbon live "it$ t$eir five daug$ters in a Cat$oli%
6ouse$old& $e girls* Ce%ilia
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
10/26
Parsons 10
enters at all& $e $ouse begins to deteriorate and a strange smell is re%orded %oming from it& $e
Iisbon girls begin t$eir attempts at %ommuni%ating "it$ t$e neig$bor$ood boys t$at $ave al"ays
been fas%inated "it$ t$em& $ey send %ards "it$ %rypti% messages and use p$one %alls "it$
musi% re%ordings to %ommuni%ate& Soon* t$e girls tell t$e boys to %ome over to t$e $ouse late one
nig$t after t$eir parents are asleep& Iux invites t$em in and t$en goes to t$e garage to start t$e
%ar as t$e boys t$in# t$at t$ey are ta#ing t$e girls a"ay from t$eir $ome and !i%$igan all
toget$er& 6o"ever* t$ey venture do"nstairs and find t$at t$e girls $ave %ommitted sui%ide&
/onnie $as $anged $erself* Iux dies of %arbon monoxide poisoning by starting t$e %ar "it$ t$e
garage door %losed and $erese overdoses on sleeping pills& !ary tries to #ill $erself by sti%#ing
$er $ead in t$e oven but fails and lives anot$er t"o "ee#s in t$e desolate $ouse before s$e ta#es
too many sleeping pills* Bust li#e $erese& Soon after* !r& and !rs& Iisbon move out from t$e
$ouse in t$e middle of t$e nig$t and t$e $ouse is sold to a young %ouple& $e neig$bor$ood boys
%ontinue to s%rounge for eviden%e* most of "$i%$ t$ey find in t$e rubble left in t$e $ouse after
t$e Iisbons leave&
Comparison
/ot$ of t$ese novels s$are more t$an t$e similarities in t$eir time periods& $e 1+20,s and t$e
1+.0,s "ere a time of %$ange for sexuality* but t$ere are many more %omparisons t$at %an be
made bet"een t$ese t"o novels&
$e t"o novels s$are many t$emes of a strong religious ba%#ground t$at may $ave an
influen%e over $o" t$e "omen are vie"ed as t$ey express t$eir sexuality openly& 8or example*
t$e Iisbons stri%t %ontrol over t$eir daug$ters is a response to t$e freedom of t$e time& $e .0,s
"ere an age in "$i%$ teenagers "ere finding t$emselves in more openly sexual "ays* but it is
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
11/26
Parsons 11
per$aps t$e stri%t Cat$oli% religion "$i%$ t$e Iisbon family follo"s t$at $olds Sara and 5onald
ba%# from letting t$eir daug$ters explore t$emselves&
$e imagery of t$e irgin !ary %omes up often* "$i%$ is $eavy in symboli% meaning& n
C$ristian religion* !ary is said to $ave be%ome pregnant "it$ t$e Son of God* Jesus* t$roug$
mma%ulate Con%eption& S$e is regarded as $e irgin and is a prominent figure in t$e
Cat$oli% religion for $er role as t$e vessel for "$i%$ Jesus "as %arried& S$e is t$oug$t to be t$e
most pure and $oly for $er virginal status& 3$en it is time for !ary to leave t$e eart$* s$e
as%ends into t$e s#y and does not mortally die&
!ary is signifi%ant %$ara%ter t$roug$out $istory in t$at s$e represents t"o important roles
for "omen* one being t$e mot$er and t$e ot$er being t$e virgin& 6o"ever* "omen %annot
possibly possess bot$ of t$ese traits* as it is impossible& 8or t$is reason* t$e irgin !ary is
regarded as sa%red& $e image of t$e irgin !ary "it$in literature %an represent t$e virgin("$ore
di%$otomy* "$enever t$ere is a virgin* t$ere must be a "$ore and vise(versa& 3it$in literature t$e
t"o %an often ma#e up one %omplete person& 6o"ever* if a %$ara%ter de%ides to %$oose one side
or t$e ot$er* t$en t$ey are %utting a part of t$emselves off* "$i%$ is "$y t"o %$ara%ters are often
seen as one person&
$e "ord virgin s$o"s up immediately "it$in t$e title of The Virgin Suicides( 6o"ever
it is %urious t$at all of t$e girls remain ostensibly virginal "$en Iux $as been des%ribed as being
sexually a%tive t$roug$ $alf of t$e novel& $e symbolism of t$e irgin does not only s$o" up in
t$e title* $o"ever* be%ause small lamented %ards featuring a p$oto of !ary s$o" up often* and
t$e girls eventually use t$ese %ards to %ommuni%ate "it$ t$e neig$bor$ood boys& $e %ards first
s$o" up "$en one is %lut%$ed in Ce%ilia,s $ands after $er first sui%ide attempt&2 Iater* t$e boys
26 Jeffrey Eugenides& The Virgin Suicides& :e" =or#> 8arrar Straus Giroux* 1++-* 2
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
12/26
Parsons 12
find t$e %ards in t$eir mailboxes* and one boy $eard an unfamiliar "$irring in $is bi%y%le tires
one day and loo#ed do"n to see a irgin pi%ture taped bet"een t$e sto#es&2. $e adults find t$e
%ards as "ell* but not #no"ing t$eir meaning* usually toss t$em aside& $ere is also t$e fa%t t$at
in traditionally %at$oli% $omes* a %ru%ifix $angs above ea%$ bed& Peter Sissen* t$e only boy t$at
$as ever been allo"ed in t$e Iisbon $ome* goes on a sear%$ for t$e bat$room and finds* in one of
t$e bedrooms* amongst ot$er t$ings* a %ru%ifix draped "it$ a brassiere&29 $is %ould symboli)e
Iux,s rebellion against $er mot$er,s %at$oli% tea%$ings* t$e bra symboli)ing sexuality and t$e
%ru%ifix symboli)ing t$e Cat$oli% religion&
$e imagery of t$e irgin !ary in Sula is a little more blatant& 3$en 6elene is being raised* $er
grandmot$er prays to t$e multi%olored irgin !ary for $er daug$ter to gro" up more pure
t$an $er o"n mot$er is&2+ 6elene is t$e %onventional "oman& S$e "ants t$e best for $er
daug$ter* so as an example* s$e lives tig$tlipped and asexual as $er $usband is a"ay at sea& S$e
is trying to be t$e virgin* but s$e %annot be be%ause s$e is a mot$er* so it is impossible for $er
to be %ompletely pure& 6er mot$er* 5o%$elle* %ompletes t$e "$ore role* so 6elene for%es
$erself %losed& 't one moment* :el admires $er mot$ers dress and t$e folds t$at $ide t$eir s#in&
S$e "is$es* Bust for a moment* to see underneat$ t$e dress so s$e %ould see t$e s#in t$at $er
mot$er and s$e s$are* t$e rare moment t$at $er mot$er mig$t let some s#in slip and %ome undone
from $er uptig$t nature %ompletely&-0
27 Eugenides, The Virgin Suicides, 183
28 Ibid, 7
29 Morrison, Sula, 17
30 Morrison, Sula, 22
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
13/26
Parsons 1-
$e title irgin !ary is also used to define t$e four "omen t$at are spo#en of at :el,s
great(grandmot$er,s
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
14/26
Parsons 14
s$ort lives& !ary is t$e perfe%t image of a "oman and t$ere is no "ay t$at t$e sisters %an live up
to t$is example& $e un(exposure of Sula and of t$e Iisbon sisters only exists for a s$ort time&
'lt$oug$ Sula is exposed to sex from very early on in $er life* s$e is inno%ent to t$e fa%t t$at sex
is a matter of ex%$ange& Iux* $o"ever* loses $er inno%en%e "$en s$e embar#s on $er first sexual
en%ounter "it$ rip 8ontaine& 'll of t$e Iisbon girls lose some sort of inno%en%e as "ell "$en
Ce%ilia first attempts sui%ideL t$ere is more t$an one "ay of defining a loss of inno%en%e&
/ot$ novels s$are t$e imagery of t$e "edding dress as "ell& 6o"ever* instead of a ne"
beginning as a "edding dress "ould most typi%ally seem to symboli)e* bot$ novels portray t$e
"edding dress as a symbol of deat$& n The Virgin Suicides Ce%ilia "ears a vintage "edding
dress %onstantly t$roug$out $er s$ort life and s$e is t$e first to %ommit sui%ide& n Sula, 6anna$
dreams of a red "edding dress* "$i%$ is alarming and t$e red in t$e "edding dress %onfuses
$er&-2 6o"ever* t$e red "edding dress seems to alludes to 6anna$,s deat$ by fire* "$i%$ o%%urrs
s$ortly after 6anna$ $ad t$e dream& Eva re%alls as s$e "aits in $ospital t$at* Din dreams
"eddings al"ays meant deat$& 'nd t$e red go"n* "ell t$at "as t$e fire* as s$e s$ould $ave
#no"n&--
3eddings "ould also deat$ be%ause "$en t"o people get married* t$ey are de%iding to
lose a part of t$emselves to give it up to t$e ot$er person& n Sula* it is mentioned t$at* in terms
of Jude and :el* 3it$out t$at someone D:el $e "as a "aiter $anging around a #it%$en li#e a
"oman& 3it$ $er $e "as $ead of a $ouse$old pinned to an unsatisfa%tory Bob out of ne%essity&
$e t"o of t$em toget$er "ould ma#e one Jude&-4 /efore :el found Jude* Sula and :el $ad
32 Morrison, Sula, 74
33 Ibid.
34 Morrison, Sula, 83
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
15/26
Parsons 1A
bonded over an event in t$e past but "$en Sula* :el,s old $alf* left* it symboli)ed t$e deat$ of
t$e person t$ey formed toget$er& $us* :el is no longer %omplete and must bond "it$ Jude
t$roug$ t$eir marriage to form a %omplete person&
t is important to analy)e $o" ea%$ %$ara%ter in t$e t"o novels $as gro"n from t$eir
upbringing and use t$is to understand t$eir sexuality& 6anna$* Sula and Iux all seem to $ave all
t$e %ontrol in t$e "orld over t$eir sexuality& 'll t$ree "omen are open about t$eir sexuality* even
t$oug$ t$ey seem to get a negative response to it& 6o"ever bot$ novels suggest t$at t$ese sexual
experien%es may Bust be t$ere to deal "it$ t$e $ards$ips t$at t$ey $ave been for%ed to en%ounter
over t$e %ourse of t$eir lives&
Iux,s $eartbrea# %ame in t$e form of t$e only boy s$e ever $ad t$e %$an%e to form a
$ealt$y romanti% relations$ip "it$ leaving $er& 6er sexual exploration began after rip left $er
alone on t$e football field after t$e $ome%oming dan%e& Soon after $e left* s$e begins to $ave sex
"it$ many* random men on $er rooftop& One boy* 3illard* re%alls t$at s$e as#ed $im after t$ey
$ad $ad sex if $e t$oug$t "$at t$ey did "as dirty and t$en pro%eeded to as# you li#e me* don,t,
youM $is indi%ates t$at sex is not Bust sex to Iux but rat$er s$e "ants some emotion in return&
Iux also $ad sex "it$ t$ese men often in t$e "inter as t$e neig$bor$ood boys began to noti%e&
$ey reali)ed t$at $aving sex outside in t$e free)ing "eat$er suggested derangement*
desperation* self(destru%tiveness far in ex%ess of any pleasure snat%$ed beneat$ t$e dripping
trees&-A Iux "as often portrayed as impervious to anyt$ing* but t$e boys %ould see t$roug$ t$is
faNade& 6er promis%uity is seen as a problem& Iux is using $er promis%uity to try and fix $er
emotional despair&
35 Eugenides* The Virgin Suicides* 144&
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
16/26
Parsons 1
$e :eig$bor$ood boys "ere not t$e only ones t$at t$oug$t t$is& 7r& 6orni%#er* t$e
family t$erapist t$eori)ed t$at* Iux %onfused t$e sexual a%t "it$ love& 8or $er* sex be%ame a
substitute for t$e %omfort s$e needed as a result of $er sister,s sui%ide&- 6ere* t$e fo%us on
Iux,s promis%uity does not fall on rip,s s$oulders* but rat$er on t$e fa%t t$at Iux is torn up over
Ce%ilia,s deat$& Eit$er "ay* $er promis%uity is a "ay to let out $er emotions in $er time of
$ards$ip&
7avis "rites in $er arti%le* Self* So%iety and !yt$* t$at !orrison,s "omen %an free
t$emselves* li#e Sula* and be self defined and dis%onne%ted&-. 6o"ever* 6anna$ seems to be
similar to Iux in t$at* after 5e#us, D$er $usband deat$ $ad a steady seuen%e of lovers* mostly
t$e $usbands of $er friends and neig$bors %oming in and out t$roug$ t$e $ouse&-9 t "as obvious
t$at t$ese relations$ips "ere not t$ere to last* sin%e* as previously mentioned* s$e did not li#e for
t$e men to sleep over as it "ould suggest a %ommitment s$e "as not loo#ing for& S$e does not
expe%t anyt$ing in ex%$ange for t$e sexual a%t* Bust t$e pleasure from sex itself& 6anna$*
$o"ever* seems to be in %ontrol of $er sexuality but s$e is ignorant of t$e fa%t t$at s$e is Bust
being regarded as sexual obBe%t& S$e is not regarded as negatively as $er daug$ter "ill be
regarded in t$e future* $o"ever& S$e is not $ated be%ause s$e does not demand anyt$ing from
t$em Dt$e menL $er aim is to simply get some tou%$ing every day&-+
8ollo"ing in $er mot$er,s footsteps* Sula "ent to bed "it$ men as freuently as s$e %ould& t
"as t$e only pla%e "$ere s$e %ould find "$at s$e "as loo#ing for> misery and t$e ability to feel
36 Eugenides, The Virgin Suicides, 84
37 Dais, !"el#, "o$ie%& and M&%' in (oni Morrison’s )i$%ion*, 341
38 !orrison* Sula* 42
39 /irgit 'as 6olms* 2010& Sexuality in Toni Morrison)s or*s& D!aster,s $esis in Englis$Iiterature t$esis* niversity of romso& 20
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
17/26
Parsons 1.
deep sorro"&40 6o"ever* unli#e $er mot$er and Iux* Sula used sex as a game* somet$ing t$ere
to uen%$ $er loneliness of $uman %ompanions$ip in any form* not Bust t$at of a lover& $e entire
to"n "as against $er at t$is point* and by ta#ing ot$er,s lovers s$e found a great sense of po"er&
5ita /ergen$olt) as#s an important uestion in $er arti%le* oni !orrison,s Sula> ' Satire on
/inary $in#ing& S$e uestions* S$ould "e admire Sula,s %ourage* $er determination to be
free to ma#e $erselfM Or s$ould "e loat$e $er for engaging in %asual sex "it$ $er best friend,s
$usbandM41 $ese "omen dealt "it$ different $ards$ips over t$e %ourse of t$eir lives* but t$ey
all seem to use sex to $elp ease t$e pain in t$e same "ay&
/e%ause of :el,s grandmot$er,s past* $er mot$er* 6elene* "ants to #eep :el on t$e straig$t and
narro" pat$ so s$e "ill not be as promis%uous as $er an%estors& $us* 6elene proBe%ts and
%$annels fear of $er o"n mot$er,s outla", sexuality into a %ontrolling repression of :el,s
sexuality42 6elene $as built $erself up "it$in t$e bottom as a proper "oman and s$e "ants :el
to follo" t$is pat$& Fno"ing Sula,s family $istory* s$e disli#es t$e friends$ip t$at is formed
bet"een t$e t"o girls* but :el finds refuge in Sula,s $ome4- :el finds t$is refuge be%ause in
$er $ome s$e %annot express $erself& Sula,s $ome provides a relief from t$is tension* $o"ever* at
t$e same time* Sula,s $ome is anot$er extreme& $is $ome is free and open "$ile :el,s is stri%t
and %onforming& $ere is not a $appy medium&
Sara Iisbon also $as a $and in repressing $er daug$ter,s sexuality& $is %ould be per$aps
of t$e gro"ing sexual nature of t$e 'meri%an %ommunity during t$is time or %ould be a result of
40 !orrison* Sula* 122
41 5ita '& /ergenbolt)& H' Satire on /inary $in#ing&H Toni Morrison+s Sula& /y 6arold /loom&P$iladelp$ia> C$elsea 6ouse* 1+++* .
42 7emetra#opoulos* A-
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
18/26
Parsons 19
t$e stri%t religion t$at s$e $as t$e girls follo"& :evert$eless* t$e girls are never allo"ed to leave
t$e $ouse "it$ boys and after Iux brea#s %urfe"* t$e girls are never allo"ed t$e leave t$e $ouse
at all& 3$en rip 8ontaine entered t$e $ome for t$e first and only time* !rs& Iisbon sat in
bet"een $im and Iux* stopping any p$ysi%al %onta%t bet"een t$e t"o& 6e re%alls later t$at all
t$ey did "as "at%$ t$e 7isney spe%ial t$at "as on television* $e didn,t get to sit next to Iux*
nor spea# to $er* nor even loo# at $er&44 $e diffi%ulty over rip ta#ing Iux as $is date to t$e
$ome%oming dan%e is anot$er instan%e in "$i%$ t$e girl,s sexuality is being repressed& !r&
Iisbon even Bo#es "it$ rip after $e as#s $is permission t$at* even if $e "anted to $is "ife
"ouldn,t let $im* $a $a&
4A
rip %ould %ome over and "at%$ television again* but ta#ing Iux out*
in a %ar espe%ially* "as out of t$e uestion&
Even t$e girl,s %lot$es are %losely monitored& 'fter Iux "rites t$e name of a %rus$ on
$er under"ear* !rs& Iisbon blea%$es out t$e pen on all $er under"ear* mu%$ to Iux,s dismay&
'lso* after pi%#ing out t$e dress patterns t$at t$e girls "ere to "ear at t$e $ome%oming dan%e*
!rs& Iisbon se"ed up t$e dresses for t$e sisters but t$ey all turned out to be t$e same s$apeless
dress& $e girls "ere not t$e only ones t$at t$oug$t t$eir la%# of %onta%t "it$ t$e opposite sex
"as repressive& 'fter Ce%ilia,s first attempt at sui%ide* t$e t$erapist suggested to !r& and !rs&
Iisbon t$at at t$irteen* Ce%ilia s$ould be allo"ed to "ear t$e sort of ma#eup popular amongst
girls $er age "earK4 as "ell as parti%ipate in ot$er a%tivities "it$ ot$er %$ildren $er age&
!rs& Iisbon denies t$e idea t$at $er daug$ters la%#ed love or attention from t$e opposite
sex* even into $er older age& S$e tells one of t$e neig$bor$ood boys in an intervie" t$at* :one
44 Eugenides* The Virgin Suicides* 91
45 bid* 109
46 Eugenides* The Virgin Suicides, -0
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
19/26
Parsons 1+
of any of my daug$ters la%#ed for any love& 3e $ad plenty of love in our $ouse&4. 3$at !rs&
Iisbon is missing* $o"ever* is t$e differen%e bet"een familial love and eroti% love& 6er
daug$ters may not be la%#ing in familial love* but t$ey are not exposed to any amount of eroti%
or romanti% love eit$er& S$e may not be blind to t$e fa%t t$at $er stri%tness over $er daug$ter,s
sexuality $as $urt t$em& S$e $as made t$em ignorant* "$i%$ is "$y Iux may $ave $ad $er
pregnan%y s%are& /e%ause s$e "as not exposed to anyt$ing sexual as a %$ild* s$e did not #no"
$o" pregnan%y "or#ed&
/ot$ of t$ese novels explore and imagine t$e idea t$at a "oman %an be in %$arge of $er
o"n sexuality& 6o"ever* "$en t$e "omen begin to be promis%uous* it is presented as t$e result
of somet$ing negative& $us* sexual freedom is presented as a problem and not a freedom& $e
%onstraints on sexuality t$roug$out t$e novel $ave been presented previously and t$e idea t$at
"omen are being poli%ed by so%iety is anot$er "ay t$at t$e novels s$o" t$is idea&
3omen $ave al"ays been poli%ed by so%iety* espe%ially in terms of t$eir sexuality& !en
are t$e ones in %ontrol and t$ey even $ave t$e po"er of loo#ing* t$e po"er of t$e ga)e& 3omen
are al"ays being "at%$ed* %ontrolled and regulated by t$e ga)e& $is simple a%t of loo#ing is
repressive of "omen be%ause t$ey %annot es%ape t$e fa%t t$at t$ey are al"ays being "at%$ed and
Budged by t$e male figures around t$em&
$e male ga)e* a term originally %oined by Iaura !ulvey in $er arti%le isual Pleasure
and :arrative Cinema des%ribes t$e t$e ga)e as simply* t$e a%t of loo#ing& 6o"ever* t$is a%t
is detrimental to "omen in visual and non(visual texts& 3omen are being loo#ed at as obBe%ts*
t$ey are being obBe%tified for t$eir parts& :ot only is t$is negative in itself* anot$er produ%t of t$e
47 bid* 94
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
20/26
Parsons 20
male ga)e is t$at t$e "omen turn t$is ga)e on t$emselves and loo# at t$emselves as obBe%ts&
Sometimes* "omen %an often find t$is obBe%tifi%ation as pleasurable&
$is idea is developed from voyeurism* "$i%$ is t$e sexual interest or a%t of spying on
individuals engaged in a private a%t* eit$er "$ere t$e person is simply vulnerable* su%$ as na#ed
or engaged in a sexual a%t& !ulvey develops t$is idea furt$er and ma#es t$e point t$at t$e male is
al"ays t$e observer position* "$ile t$e female is t$e one al"ays being observed& $is* s$e
argues* is derived from t$e idea t$at t$e male is t$e a%tive one "it$in t$e sexual relations$ip
"$ile t$e female is t$e passive&49 7avis goes a step furt$er and ma#es t$e point t$at*
3oman$ood* li#e bla%#ness* is Ot$er in t$is so%iety* and t$e dilemma of a "oman in a
patriar%$al so%iety is parallel to t$at of bla%#s in a ra%ist one> $ey are made to feel most real
"$en seen4+
Guerrero argues in $is arti%le* ra%#ing $e Ioo# in $e :ovels of oni !orrison*
t$at !orrison s$ifts $er fo%us on t$e loo# to exploring in t$e a%tions of $er %$ara%ters t$e
et$i%al differen%es bet"een t$e verbs to see and to atch(A0 $e a%t of loo#ing as a male a%t is
made blatantly obvious in Sula "$en 'Bax first %alls out to $er and :el t$e "ords pig meat&
'Bax is des%ribed at t$is point in t$e novel as a t"enty(one(year(old pool $aunt of sinister
beauty&A1 6e rarely %urses and "$en $e does it is for good reason& So "$en $e %alls out to Sula
and :el* t$ey guarded t$eir eyes lest someone see t$eir delig$t& A2 $ey revel in t$e fa%t t$at
48 Iaura !ulvey& Hisual Pleasure and :arrative Cinema&H Screen 1&- .
49 7avis* Self, Society and Myth in Toni Morrison)s -iction* -2+
50 Guerrero* Ed"ard& Hra%#ing H$e Ioo#H in $e :ovels of oni !orrison&H "lac* American 'iterature -orum 24&4 .
51 !orrison* Sula* A0
52 !orrison* Sula* 4.
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
21/26
Parsons 21
one* 'Bax "ould noti%e t$em and t"o t$at $e "ould s$out somet$ing vulgar at t$em to relay t$e
fa%t t$at $e noti%ed t$eir bodies& $is is an instan%e in "$i%$ t$e young girls turned t$is
obBe%tifi%ation into pleasure& 'Bax "as noti%ing t$em as simply a pie%e of
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
22/26
Parsons 22
begin to "at%$ t$em intensely&AA Iux is loo#ed at as an obBe%t "$en t$e boys ta#e out a teles%ope
and "at%$ $er $aving sex on t$e roof& $e young men t$at Iux "as sleeping "it$ also expressed
t$roug$ t$eir %onversations "it$ t$e neig$bor$ood boys t$at t$ey "ere ga)ing at $er as "ell&
$ey analy)ed $er body* noting $er Butting ribs* t$e insubstantiality of $er t$ig$s and one even
noted t$at $er %ollarbones %olle%ted "ater "$en it began raining&A $e neig$bor$ood boys also
point out t$at t$ey often spy on Iisbon girls sitting in t$eir yard
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
23/26
Parsons 2-
$e differen%e bet"een t$e boys in The Virgin Suicides and 'Bax in Sula is t$at t$e boys
try and ma#e t$e argument t$at by doing t$is spying t$ey are really trying to get to #no" t$e girls
and see into t$eir personalities and t$eir lives as a "$ole& $ey also find sola%e in t$e fa%t t$at
t$e girls $ad been loo#ing out as intensely as "e $ad been loo#ing inA9 's stated* t$e girls may
#no" t$at t$ey are being "at%$ed %losely* by bot$ t$e neig$bor$ood and t$eir parents* espe%ially
t$eir mot$er& $us* to %ountera%t t$is* t$e girls implement t$e a%t of loo#ing as "ell and use t$eir
ability to ga)e ba%#& $e boys noti%e during t$e lo%#do"n* t$at instead of t$e %urtains t$ey
t$oug$t t$ey "ere loo#ing at in t$e upstairs rooms of t$e Iisbon $ouse* "eren,t a%tually %urtains
at all but a film of dirt* "it$ spy $oles "iped %lean& $e best t$ing "as to see t$em ma#e one>
t$e pin# ba%# and fort$ of a $and flattening against t$e glass* t$en rubbing ba%# and fort$ to
un%over t$e brig$t mosai% of an eye* loo#ing out at us&A+ 3$en t$e lo%#do"n $appened* t$e girls
"anted to see out Bust as mu%$ as t$e boys "anted to see in* a refuge from t$eir solitude& $e dirt
%a#ed on t$e "indo" is a symbol of t$e girls entrapment& $e $ome t$at t$eir mot$er "anted to
ma#e "as a %lean* pure $ome* but t$e dirt %a#ed on t$e "indo"s s$o"s t$at t$is "as not t$e
%ase&
't t$e end of t$e novel* it is not made %lear "$y t$e girls a%tually %ommit sui%ide& $e
boys ponder numerous options* but even t$oug$ t$ey $ave gat$ered mu%$ eviden%e over t$e past
several years* t$ey still find t$emselves getting toget$er to go over t$e materials one more time&
6o"ever* it %an be t$eori)ed t$at t$e sui%ides are a result of t$e ga)e& $e girls are %onstantly
"at%$ed* by t$e neig$bor$ood boys* by t$eir parents* by t$e ne"s people after Ce%ilia,s deat$
and by all of t$eir peers at s%$ool& $ey %an never seem to es%ape t$e ga)e t$at follo"s t$em
58 Eugenides, The Virgin Suicides, 119.
59 Eugenides, The Virgin Suicides, 155
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
24/26
Parsons 24
"$erever t$ey go& t is obvious t$at t$ey try to fig$t t$e po"er of t$e male ga)e and in turn* loo#
out* but t$eir lo%#do"n prevents t$at from $appening& $eir fate is inevitable in t$e fa%t t$at t$ey
are %onstantly being "at%$ed&
$roug$out $istory* t$e idea of sexuality and $o" "omen %an present t$emselves
sexually $as %$anged over time& t $as been a slo" pro%ess and even no" "e do not really #no"
"$at terms li#e freedom and open expression really mean in regards to sexuality& t is no"
anot$er generation a$ead of "$en t$e t"o novels "ere "ritten& :eit$er novel is sexual freedom
for "omen a%$ieved or even a%$ievable& $roug$out ea%$ novel* t$e %$ara%ters are exposed to
t$e $ars$ reality t$at a "oman,s sexuality is %onstrained by so%iety and ea%$ %$ara%ter $as t$eir
o"n "ay of getting around t$at standard& t is made obvious in bot$ novels t$at "omen are not
going to a%$ieve sexual freedom& 3omen $ave %ome a long "ay in %ontemporary 'meri%an by
%$anging t$e "ay t$at sexuality loo#s and "$at %onstraints are put on it&
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
25/26
Parsons 2A
/ibliograp$y
'li* 6ira& HGender 'nalysis in oni !orrison;s /eloved and Sula&H Middle$!ast %ournal of Scientific
&esearch 1&10 141+(42-& 3eb&
/ergenbolt)* 5ita '& H' Satire on /inary $in#ing&H Toni Morrison+s Sula& /y 6arold /loom&
P$iladelp$ia> C$elsea 6ouse* 1+++& -(14& Print&
/lan#* 6anne& Virgin: The /ntouched History& :e" =or#> /loomsbury S'* 200.& Print&
7avis* Cynt$ia '& HSelf* So%iety* and !yt$ in oni !orrison;s 8i%tion&H Contemporary 'iterature 2-&-
-2-(42& Print&
7;Emilio* Jo$n* and Estelle /& 8reedman& Intimate Matters: A History of Sexuality in America& :e"
=or#> 6arper ? 5o"* 1+99& Print&
Eugenides* Jeffrey& The Virgin Suicides& :e" =or#> 8arrar Straus Giroux* 1++-& Print&
Guerrero* Ed"ard& Hra%#ing H$e Ioo#H in $e :ovels of oni !orrison&H "lac* American 'iterature
-orum 24&4 .1(.-& %ST0&& 3eb
6olms* /irgit '* 2010& Sexuality in Toni Morrison)s or*s& D!aster,s $esis in Englis$ Iiterature
t$esis* niversity of romso&
!onden* !asafumi& HContemplating in a 7ream(li#e 5oom> $e irgin Sui%ides and t$e 'est$eti%
magination of Girl$ood&H -ilm, -ashion 1 Consumption 2&2 1-+(A9& Print&
!orrison* oni& Sula& :e" =or#> Fnopf* 1+.4& Print&
5osenberg* J&
-
8/9/2019 GSP Capstone
26/26
Parsons 2
3andland* Iouise& 3e Couldn,t 8at$om $em 't 'll> $e Complex 5epresentation of 8emininity in
Jeffrey Eugenides, The Virgin Suicides. 1(21
3olo%$* :an%y& omen and the American !xperience& :e" =or#> Fnopf* 1+94& Print&