1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Jos6 de Jesfis Rivera, SBN. 004604Nathan J. Fidel, SBN 025136HARALSON, MILLER, PITT,FELDMAN & MCANALLY, P.L.C.2800 N. Central Ave., Suite 840Phoenix, AZ 85004Telephone: 602-266-5557Facsimile: 602-266-2223jrivera~_~__pmlaw.comnfidel@hm_pmlaw.comj_!~r.s_en~@.,hmpmlaw.com (for minute entries)

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA

IN AND FOR COUNTY OF MARICOPA

ABEL BADILLO and BIBIANAVAZQUEZ,

Cross-Plaintiffs,

VS.

STATE OF ARIZONA ex rel. AttorneyGeneral Thomas C. Horne,

Cross-Defendant.

CASE NO. 2013-009093

MOTION TO ASSOCIATE COUNSELPRO HAC VICE

(Assigned to the Hon. Arthur Anderson)

Jos6 de JesOs Rivera, pursuant to Rule 38(a), Ariz. R. Sup. Cto, moves the court to

associate Victor Viramontes and Martha L. G6mez as counsel pro hac vice in this action. In

support of this motion and pursuant to Rule 38(a)(3)(C), the following original documents

are attached:

1. Verified Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice;

2. Certificate(s) of Good Standing; and

3. State Bar of Arizona Notice of Receipt of Complete Application.

kwiktag * 077 584 545

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Jos6 de Jesfis Rivera hereby agrees to serve as local counsel in this matter and accepts

the responsibilities detailed in Rule 39(a)(2), Ariz. R. Sup. Ct.

DATED this 16t~ day of December, 2013.

HARALSON, MILLER, PITT,FELDMAN & McANALLY, PLC

/S/Jos6 de Jesfis Rivera

Jos6 de Jesfis Rivera

THE FOREGOING has been electronicallyFiled this 164 day of December, 2013

COPY mailed and e-mailed this 16th dayof December, 2013, to:

Honorable Arthur AndersonMaricopa County Superior CourtEast Court Building101 West Jefferson Street5th Floor, Courtroom 511Phoenix, AZ 85003

Victor ViramontesMartha L. GmezMEXICAN AMERICAN LEGAL DEFENSEAND EDUCATIONAL FUND634 S. Spring Street, 11tu FloorLos Angeles, CA 90014Attorneys For Proposed Intervenor-Defendants

DANIEL R. ORTE3GA, JR.Ortega law firmA professional corporation361 E. CORONADO ROADPHOENIX, AZ 85004-1525Attorneys For Proposed Intervenor-Defendants

2

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Kevin D. RayLeslie Kyman CooperJinju ParkAssistant Attorneys General1275 W. Washington St.Phoenix, AZ 85007Attorneys for the State of Arizona ex tel.Attorney General Thomas c. Horne

Mary O’GradyLynne AdamsGrace E. ReblingOSBORN MALEDON, P.A.2929 N. Central Avenue, 21st FloorPhoenix, AZ 85012Attorneys for M. C. C. C.D.

By Jennie Larsen

For Official Use.O~d.£ _App# I 0 (~’~.c~

At/m: Pro Hac Vice Dept4201 N. 24~ St., Ste 100Phoenix, AZ 85016-6266Phone: 602-340-7239

PART I: Applicant InformationApplication for Appearance Pro Hac Vice

Name of Applicant:.......Victor Viramontes

Firm/Company Name: Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund

Office Address: 634 S. Spring Street, 1 lth Floor, Los Angeles, California 90014

213-629-2512 ,,Fax:. _ 213-629-0266Telephone:.

Residence Address:

Email Address:. wiramontes@maldef.org

State of Arizona ex rel. Attorney Genaral Thomas C. Home, v.Title of cause or case where applicant seeks to appeer:. M.~.ricqp~.,County Community College District Board

Docket Number: CV2013-009093Court, Board, or Administrative Agency: Superior Court of Arizona Maricopa County

Party on whose behalf applicant seeks to appear: Abel Badillo and Bibiana Vazquez

Pursuant to Arizona Supreme Court Rule 38(a)(4), the applicant shall complete the information below:

Courts to Which Applic~t. Has Been. Admi.tt,ed: , Date of Admission: Bar Number:{Att:ac~ additiona~ page== :to ne~eaaary!Supreme Court of California 6116/2001 214158

[] Applicant b a member in good standing in such courts.

[] Applicant b not currently disbarred or suspended in any court.

Applicant I"lis / [~]is not (select one) currently subject to any pending disciplinary proceeding or investigation by any court, agencyor organizatibn authorized to discipline attorneys at law.

.In the preceding three (3) years, applicant has filed applications to appear as counsel under Ariz. R. Sup. Ct., Rule 38(a) in thefollowing:

Title of Matter: Docket #: Court or Agency: App Granted? (Y/N)

This case or cause [[]is / [~s not (select one) a related or consolidated matter for which applicant has previously applied to appearpro hao vice in Arizona. If this matter is a related or consolidated with any previous application, Applicant certifies that he/she willreview and comply with appropriate rules of procedure as required in the underlying cause.If applicable, please provide related or consolidated matter application or docket#

Revised 10/29/12

Page2

PART II: Local Counsel Information/ /

Name of Arizona Local Counsel: Jose de Jesus Rivera

State Bar of Arizona Number: 004604Haralson, Miller, Pitt, Feldman & Mcanally, P.L.C.

Address: 2800 N. Central Ave., Suite 840, Phoenix, AZ 85004

Telephone: 602-266-5557 .Fax:. 602-266-2223 Email Address: jrivera@hmpmlaw.corn

[] Local Counsel is a member ha good standing.

[]Local Counsel assooiatiag with a nonresident attorney ha a particular cause shall aceept johat responsibility with the nonresidentattorney to the client, to opposing parties and eounset, and to court, board, or administrative agency in that particular cause.

PARTII[: Parties and CertificationName(s) of each party in this cause and name and address of all counsel of record:

Party: Counsel of Record:State of Arizona Kevin D. Ray

Attorney General Thomas C. Horne Kevin D. Ray

Marieopa County Community College District BoardMary O’Grady

Abel Badillo (proposed Intervenor-Deft) Victor ViramontesBibiana Vazquez (proposed Intervenor-Deft) Victor Viramontes

Address: Assistant Attorneys General1275 West Washington Street, Phoenix, AZ 85007

same as above

Phoenix, AZ 85012

MALDEF, 634 S. Sprint Street, 11th Fir., LA., CA 90(same as above

Applicant is ineluding with this application a nonrofundable application fee, payable to the State Bar of Arizona, in the amount of$460.00. Fi~een percent of/he non-refundabIe application fee paid pursuant to this section shall be deposited into a civil legal

[] services fund to be distributed by the Arizona Foundation for Legal Services and Education entirely to approved legal services

organizations, as that term is defined in subparagraph (f)of this rule.

Applicant is furnishing a certificate from the state bar or from the clerk of the highest admitting court of each state, territory, orinsular possession of the United States in which the nonresident attorney has been admitted to practice law certifying thenonresident attorney’s date of admission to such jurisdiction and the current status of the nonresident attomoy’s membership oreligibility to practice therein. The certilieate furnished shall be no more than foay-five (45) days old.

Applicant e~rtifies the following:1o Applicant shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the courts and agencies of the State of Arizona and to the State Bar of Arizona

with respect to the law of this state governing the conduct of attorneys to the same extent as an active member of the StateBar of Arizona, as provided in Ariz. Re Sup. Ct. Rule 46(b).

2o Applicant will review and comply with appropriate rules of procedure as required in the underlying cause.3. Applicant understands and shall comply with the standards of conduct required of members of the State Bar of Arizona.

Verification

STATE OF California ,)

County of Los Angeles

I, Victor Viramontes , swear that all statements in the:pplieafion are true, co/~2et and complete tothebest of my knowledge and belief.

,,~ /

S SCR ED SWO ZO befo,e me this day by

No

R~vised I0~29112

14

FRANK A. McGU}RECourt Ac~ministramr and Clerk of the Supreme~ Court

CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK OF THE SUPREME COURT

OFTHE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

VICTOR GARCIA VIRAMONTES

I, FRANK A. McGUIRE, Clerk of the Supreme Court of the State of California, do hereby

certify that Victor Garcia Viramontes, #214158, was on the 16th day of June 2001 duly

admitted to practice as an attorney and counselor at law in all the courts of this state,

and is now listed on the Roll of Attorneys as a member of the bar of this state in good

standing.

Witness my hand and the seal of the court

on the 15th day of November 2013.

FRANK A. McGUIREClerk of the Supreme Court

\~asados, Supervising Deputy Clerk

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

Maricopa County Superior Court

State of Arizona ex rel Attorney GeneralThomas C Home,

v.

Maricopa County Community College DistrictBoard,

Defendant.

CASE # CV2013-009093

SBA AI3p #1007952

NOTICE OF RECEIPT OFCOMPLETE APPLICATION

NOTICE IS HEREBY given by THE STATE BAR OF ARIZONA that it has received theverified application and fee from Victor Viramontes.

In addition to this application, applicant has made the following applications to appear pro hacvice, pursuant to Rule38 (a), within the previous three (3) years:

Tide of Matter Court/Agency Date Granted?

Exhibit A, the original verified application and Exhibit B, the original Certificate(s) of GoodStanding are attached hereto.

DATED this 9t~ day of December 2013

Christina O’DonnellResource CenterState Bar of Arizona

Original Ma~ed on:this 9m day of December 2013 to:

Jose de Jesus RiveraHaralson Miller Pitt Feldman & McAnally PLCi2800 N Central Ave Ste 840Phoenix, AZ 85004-1069

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

Maricopa County Superior Court

State of Arizona ex tel Atty Gen Thomas C)Home, )

Plaintiff )

Vo

Maricopa County Community College District )Board, )

Defendant.

CASE # CV2013-009093

SBA App #1007953

NOTICE OF RECEIPT OFCOMPLETE APPLICATION

NOTICE IS HEREBY given by THE STATE BAR OF ARIZONA that it has received theverified application and fee from Martha Gomez.

In addition to this application, applicant has made the following applications to appear pro hacvice, pursuant to Rule38 (a), within the previous three (3) years:

Title of Matter Court/Agency Date Granted?

Exhibit A, the original verified application and Exhibit B, the original Certificate(s) of GoodStanding are attached hereto.

DATED this 9th day of December 2013

Christina O’DormellResource CenterState Bar of Arizona

Original Mailed on this 9e~ day of December 2013 to:

Jose de Jesus RiveraHaralson Miller Pitt Feldman & McAna~y PLC2800 N Central Ave Ste 840Phoenix, AZ 85004-1069

IF o~ O~Tleisl U~ ~nl~~# l~ ~’~-1~5B~V Nu’mbor# P Ic[ Z~>~.~-~Attn: Pm Hue Vice Dept4201 N. 24*h St,, Ste 100PI~oenix, AZ 85016.6266P~one: 602-340-7239

PART I: Amflicant InformationApplication for Appearance Pro Hue Vice

NameofApplicar~ Martha L,:,Gomez ..........

Firm/Compmty Naat=. Mexican Amedcan Legal Defense and Educational Fund

Office ..Address:. 634 S. Spring Street, t I th Floor, Los Angeles, California 90014

Telephone: 213-629-25t

Residence Address:.

.213-829-0266 ~mail Addresa: rtag°mez@ma!dCf’°gg-i-

State of Arizona ex tel. Attorney General Thomas C. Home, v.Title of cause or case where applicant ~eeks to appem*: Maricopa County Community ~l!~l~e District Board

Docket Number: CV2013-009093

Court, Board, or Administrative Agency: Superior Court 0fA~zona Maric0pa County

Party on whose behalf applicant ~eeks to appear:: ~be! Badillo and Bibiana Vazquez

Pursuant/o Arizona Supreme Court Rule 38(aX4), the applicant shall complete the informatin=t below:

Com’ts to Which AppHcan Admi d: Date of Admi~ion: Bar Numben

Supreme Court of California, 12105/2010 274024

E] Appll(mnt is a member in good standing in auoh eourts.

171 Appkant is not curren~ disbarred or suspended in any ~e~t.

Appllc~t Ilia !Elis not (s.’Jeet one) eurrentiy subject to any pendin8 disdpltnary proceeding or investigation by a~y ~ur~, sSer~yor organization authorized to discipline attorneys st law. "

In the preceding thr~¢ (3) ye~s, epplicant has fi]~d appli~tions to appear as counsel unde~ Adz. tL Sup. Ct., R~de 38(e) in/hefollowing:

Title of Malter:. Docket #: C~m or Agency: App (kented?

This vase or cause [-]is / ~t~ not (select one) = relate/or consolidated matter fvr which applicant has previously applied to appearpro hue vice in Arizona. If this matter is a rel~l or censofidated with any previous application, Applicent cerises that he/she willreview and comply with appropriate roles of procedure as required in the umderlying came.If applieeble, please prey/de related or consolidated matter application or docket#

Revised 10/29/12

Page 2

PART II: Local Counsel Information,

Narec of Arizona Local Counsoh Jos6 de Jest~s Rivers

State Bar of Arizona Nureber: 004604Haralson, Miller, Pill Felclm~n’ & M’carialiy, P.L.C.

Address: .2~OO.N¯ central Ave., Suite 840, Phoenix, AZ 85004

Telephone: 602-266-5557 Fax: 602-266-2223 Em~dl Address: jrivera@hmpmlaw.com

[] Local Counsel is a n~mber in good standing.

[~Local Counsel associating with a nonresident attorney in a particular cause shall accept joint responsibility with the nonresidentattorney to the client, to opposing parties and counsel, and to court, board, or administrative agency in that particular cause.

PART III: Parties and Certlfleati~Name(s) of each party in this cause and name and address of all counsel of record:

Party: Counsel of Re.cord:State of Arizona Kevin D. Ray

Attorney General Thomas C. Home Kcvin D. Ray

Maricopa County Community College District Board Mar3’ O’Grady

Abel Badillo (proposed Intervenor-Deft) Victor Viramontes

Bibiana Vazquez (proposed lntervenor-Dett) Victor Virmnontes

Address: Assistant Attorneys General

1275 West Washington Street, Phoenix, AZ 85007same as above

Osbom Maledon,’P,A’., zuzu N. ~entral Ave., 21st I-leerPhoeni.__x, Arizona 85012

MALDEF, 634 S. Spring Street~ 1 l th Floor, Los Angeles CA 90014same as above

Applicant is including with this application a nonrefundable application fee, payable to the State Bar of Arizona, tn the amount of

[]$460.00, Fifteen percent of the non-refundable application fee paid pursuant to this section shall be deposited into a civil legalservices fund to be distributed by the Arimna Foundation for Legal Services and Education entirely to approved legal servicesorganizations, as that term is defined in subparagraph (0 of this role.

Applicant is furnishing a certificate from the state bar or from the clerk of the highest admitting court of each state, territory, or[~insularposnession of the United States in which the nonresident attorney has been admitted to practice law eertifi./ing the

nonresident attorney’s date of admission to such jurisdi¢tion and the current status of the near, ideal attorney’s rr~rebership oreligibility to pmeflee therein. The certificate furnished shall be no more than forty-fwe (45) days old.

Applicant certifies the following:1. Applicant shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the courts arid agenoies of the State of Arizona and to the State Bar of Arizon~

with respect to the law of this state goveraing the conduct of attorneys to the saree extent as an active reember of the StateB~r ofArizon~ ~s provided in Ariz. R. Sup. Ct. Rule 46(b).

2. Applicant will mvlew and comply with appropriate rules of procedure as required in the underlying cause.3, Applicam understands and sh~ll comply with the standards of conduct requh’ed

Ver~ficatmn

STATE OF California

County of Los Angeles

[,_Martha L. Gomoz , swear that all statements in the application are trae, correct and complete to thebest of my knowledge and belief,

N~’t~ry~Pubii,

]~visM 10/29i12

FRANK A. McGUIRE

Court Administrator and Clerk of the" Supreme Court

CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK OF THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

MAR THA LILIANA GOMEZ

I, FRANK A. McGUIRE, Clerk of the Supreme Court of the State of California, do hereby

certify that Martha Liliana Gomez, #274024, was on the 5th day of December 2010 duly

admitted to practice as an attorney and counselor at law in all the courts of this state,

and is now listed on the Roll of Attorneys as a member of the bar of this state in good

standing.

Witness my hand and the seal of the court

on the 15th day of November 2013.

FRANK A. McGUIREClerk of the Supreme Court

"~as~d’os, Supervising Deputy Clerk

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Jos6 de Jesfs Rivera, SBN. 004604Nathan J. Fidel, SBN 025136HARALSON, MILLER, PITT,FELDMAN & MCANALLY, P.L.C.2800 N. Central Ave., Suite 840Phoenix, AZ 85004Telephone: 602-266-5557Facsimile: 602-266-2223Email: jrivera@hmpmlaw.com

SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA

MARICOPA COUNTY

ABEL BADILLO and BIBIANAVAZQUEZ,

Cross-Plaintiffs,

VS.

STATE OF ARIZONA ex rel. AttorneyGeneral Thomas C. Home,

Cross-Defendant.

CASE NO. CV2013-009093

ORDER RE: MOTION TO ASSOCIATECOUNSEL PRO HAC VICE

(Assigned to the Hon. Arthur Anderson)

Based on the Motion to Associate Counsel Pro Hac Vice of Jos6 de Jesfls Rivera and

the consent of Jos6 de Jesfis Rivera to appear as local counsel, it is hereby ordered that Victor

Viramontes and Martha L. G6mez be admitted pro hac vice as counsel for ABEL BADILLO

and BIBIANA VAZQUEZ in this matter.

DATED this day of ., 2013.

Arthur AndersonMaricopa County Superior Court Judge

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Copies of the foregoing mailed/hand-deliveredthis __ day of ,2013, to:

Jos6 de Jesfis Rivera, SBN. 004604HARALSON, MILLER, PITT,FELDMAN & MCANALLY, P.L.C.2800 N. Central Ave., Suite 840Phoenix, AZ 85004Attorneys For Proposed lntervenor-Defendants

Victor ViramontesMartha L. G6mezMEXICAN AMERICAN LEGAL DEFENSEAND EDUCATIONAL FUND634 S. Spring Street, 11t~ FloorLos Angeles, CA 90014Attorneys For Proposed Intervenor-Defendants

Daniel R. Ortega, Jr.ORTEGA LAW FIRMA Professional Corporation361 E. Coronado RoadPhoenix, Az 85004-1525Attorneys For Proposed Intervenor-Defendants

Kevin D. RayLeslie Kyman CooperJinju ParkAssistant Attorneys General1275 W. Washington St.Phoenix, AZ 85007Attorneys for the State of Arizona ex tel.Attorney General Thomas c. Horne

Mary O’GradyLynne AdamsGrace E. ReblingOSBORN MALEDON, P.A.2929 N. Central Avenue, 21st FloorPhoenix, AZ 85012Attorneys for M. C. C. C.D.

2