i1&b’01:8%# 0

5
!"#$%&# () *+,-./0 121%3#"# () &4" 567 1#4 #89%% #1:8%"# ;(%%";&"< =>->?-@A )B(: &4" /:(B3 !9C"B 01:8%"# ;(%%";&"< D3 E(221 F9#"2D3 G7881%1;4912 6(9;"#HI1&1$J1 !9C"BK""8"BL 12< 121%3M"< D3 04"1 5$D"B&3N ,4E 12< +1B(% O1D31KN ,4E G7881%1;4912 0&1&" P29C"B#9&3L 0"<9:"2& !"#$% ’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

Upload: others

Post on 19-May-2020

13 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: I1&B’01:8%# 0

!"#$%&#'()'*+,-./0'121%3#"#'()'&4"'567'1#4'#89%%'#1:8%"#';(%%";&"<'=>->?-@A')B(:'&4"'/:(B3'!9C"B01:8%"#';(%%";&"<'D3'E(221'F9#"2D3'G7881%1;4912'6(9;"#HI1&1$J1'!9C"BK""8"BL'12<'121%3M"<'D3'04"1'5$D"B&3N',4E'12<'+1B(%'O1D31KN',4E''G7881%1;4912'0&1&"'P29C"B#9&3L

0"<9:"2&'

!"#$%&'()$&*%"++(), -.%,$&-""/ 0+123$%,& 0+123$%,

/%":"2& QRS

4567&/(8$+&

9"#)+:%$./

;5<4&/(8$+&

9"#)+:%$./

&=$.%&3%$.>1&

+(:$

=$.%&3%$.>1&

+(:$

E(:"#T;'

I1&"B'0$88%3

U9#4'V'7W$1T;'

X1Y9:$:'G+X+L Q(&"#

7B#"29; :"12 ;5?<@ ?5;@A 45;B? 4?<5A;< ;5;4; ;5?7; ?<&:"&?;;&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&9%()D(),&#.:$%&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5;@? ;5<FA ;5;BA 75?@? ?24;&C/$+&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

O1B9$: :"12 ;5B4B <5A@< F56;7 <B?5@;? A5;;; )L. A&:"&7&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&9%()D(),&#.:$%&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5A47 ;57A7 ;56A; 445<F@

+1<:9$: :"12 ;5;;4 ;5;47 ;5;;B ;56B< ;5;;< ;5;;A ;5A<&:"&?&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&9%()D(),&#.:$%&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5;;; ;5;;4 ;5;;; ;5;;A 72F&C/$+&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

+4B(:9$: :"12 ;5;76 ;5?F@ ;5?7< 765B<F ;54;; M ?5<&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&/.G&9%()D(),&#.:$%&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5;47 ;5;?? ;5;A? 45F?;

+(D1%& :"12 ;5;?4 ;546< ;5474 44547? )L. )L.

+:9&9$E ;5;;6 ;5;7A ;5;<6 454<A

+(88"B :"12 ;5;6< ;5@AA 45;A< B@5@A7 )L. ;5;4? F2F;&C/$+&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5;46 ;5;<B ;54A4 ?5A4F

*B(2 :"12 AB5;;7 4<4564F 4AA56BB 4BB765ABB )L. )L.

+:9&9$E 4;576F AA5<<7 4?57F4 4;;65?;<

F"1< :"12 ;5;A6 ;54?F ;5?4? A<56?4 ;5;;< ;5;@< @&:"&@;&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&/.G&9%()D(),&#.:$%&8(/(:

+:9&9$E ;5;;@ ;5;4B ;5;77 ;5B7A ;5<&:"&<&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

X12J12"#" :"12 454FA 4;5B6? 45F;< 6A5BF; )L. )L.

+:9&9$E ;5;;? ;5A76 ;5;;F A5F67

X"B;$B3 :"12 ;5;4; )":&9$:$>:$9 ;5;4F ;54F? ;5;;A ;5;;4 <&:"&B&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&/.G&9%()D(),&#.:$%&8(/(:

+:9&9$E ;5;4? ;5;AA ;5;BB F24A&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

X(%3D<"2$: :"12 ;5;AF ;54BA ;5;@4 75;?7 )L. )L.

+:9&9$E ;5;4A ;5;F< ;5;;7 ;5;66

Q9;K"% :"12 ;5;7@ ;5??6 ;5?@? 7;5;4@ ;54;; ;57F; ?&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&/.G&9%()D(),&#.:$%&8(/(:

+:9&9$E ;5;4A ;5;A@ ;5;7? 457?;

0"%"29$: :"12 ;5;;< ;5;?@ ;5;7A A5<6B ;5;<; ;5;A; ;5A<&:"&A&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5;;4 ;5;;F ;5;4? ;5<<B

09%C"B :"12 )":&9$:$>:$9 )":&9$:$>:$9 )":&9$:$>:$9 ;5;A4 )L. )L.

+:9&9$E ;5;;B

541%%9$: :"12 )":&9$:$>:$9 ;5;;@ ;5;;B ;5B;B ;5;;A )L. ?&:"&7&C/$+&1(,1$%&:1.)&/.G&9%()D(),&#.:$%&8(/(:

+:9&9$E ;5;;; ;5;;? ;5776

6121<9$: :"12 ;546@ 45AB; 45?BB 4A75;F7 )L. )L.

+:9&9$E ;5;<; ;54AB ;547< ?5A<F

Z92; :"12 ;54@7 ;56FF ;5@46 F45476 )L. ;54A; 45<&:"&B&:1$&/.G&H=&.IJ.C>&8(K$&>%(:$%(.

+:9&9$E ;5;7< ;5;<< ;5;AA <5<B7

)":&9$:$>:$9&N&)"&8$E$8+&#$%$&K"J)9&.:&:1$&8(/(:+&"K&"J%&.).8OC>.8&()+:%J/$):.C") P./Q8$&$G>$$9+&")$&"%&/"%$&H=&#.:$%&IJ.8(:O&>%(:$%(.

)L.&N&:1$%$&.%$&)"&%$,J8.:$9&8$E$8+&"K&:1$+$&$8$/$):+&()&9%()D(),&#.:$% R$+>%(QC")&"K&9"/$+C>&9%()D(),&#.:$%&>%(:$%(.&$G>$$9$)>$

MS(+1&.)9&0IJ.C>&>%(:$%(.&.%$&+Q$>(.:$9&():"&*"&TTT&.)9&*"&TU&3J:&+./Q8$+&.%$&)":&+Q$>(.:$9 R$+>%(QC")&"K&V+1&.)9&.IJ.C>&>%(:$%(.&$G>$$9$)>$

5Q'I1&"B'[$1%9&3'0&12<1B<#'

G:JHF'(B'88:L

I1&"B'01:8%"#

Page 2: I1&B’01:8%# 0

TVA Ash Spill Sample Locations

Chattanooga

Knoxville

Page 3: I1&B’01:8%# 0

Results of ICP-OES analyses of the TVA ash spill samples collected 12-27-08 from the Emory RiverSamples collected by Donna Lisenby (Appalachian Voices/Watauga Riverkeeper)

Samples analyzed by Professor Shea Tuberty, PhD and Professor Carol Babyak, PhD - Appalachian State University

Each field sample was used to prepare 3 replicate samples for analyses, means and standard deviations were calculated from these three replicates

!"#$%&'($)*+,'(

!"#$%&'()$&*%"++(), -.%,$&-""/ 0+123$%, 0+123$%,

-'(+(./ /,45,&6%7&.+1&#8

!0"(.&1 0.380 3.711 0.989 135.691

0.285 2.635 1.116 139.304

0.403 2.839 1.142 130.619

+(*. 23456 43267 83294 8453725

"/:$:(; 23264 235<7 23297 =3464

>*0&?+ 9:;<= >:?>9 @:=A; >?9:BAA

9:>?B A:;=> @:<@@ >@;:;9<

9:;=> >:9?; =:@?= >;9:==>

+(*. 23989 53765 <3@2= 5943624

"/:$:(; 2378= 23=7= 23@72 8835<6

A*:+&?+ 0.001 0.015 0.009 0.987

0.001 0.013 0.009 0.985

0.001 0.013 0.008 0.983

+(*. 23228 2328= 23229 23@95

"/:$:(; 23222 23228 23222 23227

A#0B+&?+ 0.055 0.414 0.329 48.901

0.033 0.358 0.371 48.815

0.058 0.356 0.336 51.854

+(*. 232=@ 234<6 234=5 =@395<

"/:$:(; 2328= 23244 23274 83<42

ABC*'/ 0.035 0.169 0.207 9.891

0.021 0.243 0.121 12.158

0.037 0.172 0.094 11.381

+(*. 23248 238@5 238=8 8838=4

D*/(0$)*+,'("$E0B+$-+B0F$G&;(0$)&/("

C.8$%&D.EF$+&.%$&$GH%$++$6&()&/,4'&I"%&H.%8+&H$%&/(EE(")J

Page 4: I1&B’01:8%# 0

"/:$:(; 2322@ 232=7 2325@ 83857

AB,,(0 0.105 0.689 1.120 83.573

0.073 0.581 1.066 89.985

0.108 0.596 0.890 86.314

+(*. 232@5 23677 83275 96367=

"/:$:(; 2328@ 23259 23878 4378<

H0B. 32.638 177.875 117.263 18575.140

15.988 137.125 138.375 18005.377

35.388 140.750 113.325 19967.345

+(*. 79322= 8583@8< 8773@99 899=@3799

"/:$:(; 823=@< 77355= 843=<8 822@3425

I(*: 0.031 0.157 0.347 25.070

0.023 0.126 0.329 26.752

0.035 0.128 0.264 25.970

+(*. 2327@ 2384< 23484 753@48

"/:$:(; 23226 23289 232== 239=7

J*.K*.("( 1.179 11.075 1.758 89.838

1.144 10.609 1.729 93.430

1.193 10.994 1.630 95.342

+(*. 838<7 8239@4 83<25 @739<2

"/:$:(; 23275 237=@ 2326< 73<@=

J(01?0F 0.020 not detected 0.042 0.273

0.001 not detected 0.006 0.141

not detected not detected 0.004 0.105

+(*. 23282 2328< 238<4

"/:$:(; 23284 23277 23299

JB'FC:(.?+ 0.032 0.267 0.060 4.082

0.012 0.127 0.057 4.100

0.035 0.153 0.065 3.920

+(*. 2327< 23897 23268 =324=

"/:$:(; 23287 232<5 2322= 232@@

Page 5: I1&B’01:8%# 0

L&1M(' 0.052 0.369 0.395 38.479

0.033 0.322 0.380 40.262

0.055 0.328 0.313 41.308

+(*. 232=6 2344@ 23464 =23286

"/:$:(; 23287 23276 232=4 83=42

)('(.&?+ 0.006 0.044 0.026 2.275

0.004 0.030 0.049 3.242

0.006 0.035 0.050 2.277

+(*. 23225 23246 232=7 735@9

"/:$:(; 23228 2322< 23284 23559

)&';(0 not detected not detected not detected 0.027

not detected not detected not detected 0.012

not detected not detected not detected 0.024

+(*. 23278

"/:$:(; 23229

N#*''&?+ not detected 0.006 0.007 1.158

not detected 0.006 0.007 0.965

not detected 0.006 0.011 0.302

+(*. 23226 23229 23929

"/:$:(; 23222 23224 23==@

O*.*:&?+ 2378@ 1.426 1.221 120.404

2384@ 1.188 1.479 126.617

23742 1.225 1.464 125.202

+(*. 238@6 83792 83499 87=32<=

"/:$:(; 23252 23879 238=5 4375<

P&.1 0.182 1.037 0.644 65.887

0.113 0.930 0.612 70.551

0.198 0.964 0.602 77.007

+(*. 2386= 23@<< 2368@ <838=@

"/:$:(; 232=5 23255 23277 5359=