icann final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

143
"##$%&’()*+*’, (&- ./(&01(/2&#, (’ 34"55 "& 3&-212&-2&’ 627*28 "#$%& ’()*+, -.,*/(+ 012 0131

Upload: others

Post on 18-Jun-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

!

!

!

"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"55!!

"&!3&-212&-2&'!627*28!!

!

"#$%&!'()*+,!

!!!!-.,*/(+!012!0131!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

Page 2: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3A!

9:2#%'*72!;%<<(/,!

!"#$%&'()*#+,-,)*).,#

/.#%)0).,#1)-%23#/4566#7-2#,-8).#9*:&%,-.,#-0,9&.2;%-.<9.<#=%&*#29<.9=90-.,#:&(901#

07-.<)2#,&#=&%*-(#%)>9)?2;,&#9*:%&>)#9,2#-00&@.,-'9(9,13#,%-.2:-%).013#-.A#,7)#B@-(9,1#&=#

9,2#A)0929&.#*-89.<"#C)2:9,)#0&.29A)%-'()#)==&%,2#-.A#-08.&?()A<)A#9*:%&>)*).,23#/4566#

0&.,9.@)2#,&#2,%@<<()#?9,7#*-89.<#A)0929&.2#,7-,#,7)#<(&'-(#/.,)%.),#0&**@.9,1#0-.#

2@::&%,"##

8B(!C%$#D*&7!.B%&&($E(9!D*+!:;4<<2!*D,($!95CC%+#F(7!5$7(+!,B(!.*$.(),5%&!5C/+(&&%!*D!

%..*5$,%/#&#,62!7(+#>(!#$!&%+E(!)%+,!D+*C!#,9!E+*5$7#$E!#$!%!>%+#(,6!*D!7#>(+9(!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!C*7(&9G!!

"5$.,#*$%&&62!:;4<<!)(+D*+C9!C%$6!7#DD(+($,!+*&(92!#$.&57#$E!,(.B$#.%&!.**+7#$%,#*$!+*&(92!9*C(!

*D!?B#.B!%+(!%$%&*E*59!,*!,B*9(!*D!%!9,%$7%+79!/*762!%$7!#$!7*C%#$!$%C(!%&&*.%,#*$2!%!H5%9#I

+(E5&%,*+6!+*&(G!:;4<<!#9!.B%+E(7!?#,B!,%J#$E!%!D#75.#%+6!+*&(!,B%,!#9!+(9)*$9#>(!%$7!+(9)*$9#/&(!

,*!%!/+*%7!+%$E(!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+92!#$.&57#$E!)+#>%,(!9(.,*+!%.,*+9!%$7!E&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!59(+9G!:,!%&9*!

+(.(#>(9!#$)5,2!%7>#.(!%$7!9*C(,#C(9!)+(995+(!D+*C!E*>(+$C($,9G!:;4<<!B%9!%!C%$7%,(!,*!

D*&&*?!%!/*,,*CI5)2!.*$9($959I/%9(7!C*7(&G!:,!#9!%&9*!%!$*$)+*D#,!.*+)*+%,#*$!E*>(+$(7!/6!

;%&#D*+$#%!&%?G!K($.(2!:;4<<!#9!$*,!95))*+,(7!/62!$*+!7*(9!#,!&($7!#,9(&D!,*2!%!9#$E&(!,+%7#,#*$%&!

,B(*+6!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!:;4<<L9!.5++($,!&#%/#&#,6I!*+!9%$.,#*$I/%9(7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C92!

D*+!#$9,%$.(2!%+(!?(%JM!,B(+(!%+(!$*!/#$7#$E!%))(%&!C(.B%$#9C9!%$7!$*!7#+(.,!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!

+()&%.#$E!&(%7(+9B#)G!:$!&#(5!*D!9,+*$E(+!&#%/#&#,6I/%9(7!C(.B%$#9C92!:;4<<!+(&#(9!B(%>#&6!*$!

,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!,*!D*9,(+!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!!

!

D"#/.A):).A).,#E)>9)?#&=#F%-.2:-%).01#-.A#500&@.,-'9(9,1#-,#/4566##

52#:-%,#&=#-#(-%<)%#9.A):).A).,#%)>9)?#:%&0)223#=-0@(,1#-.A#%)2)-%07)%2#=%&*#,7)#G)%8*-.#

4).,)%#=&%#/.,)%.),#H#+&09),1#7->)#,-8).#&.#,7)#07-(().<)#&=#%)2)-%079.<#/4566I2#0@%%).,#

)==&%,2#,&#9*:%&>)#-00&@.,-'9(9,1#>9-#*)07-.92*2#&=#,%-.2:-%).013#:@'(90#:-%,909:-,9&.#-.A#

0&%:&%-,)#<&>)%.-.0)3#-.A#&=#-.-(1J9.<#8)1#:%&'()*2#-.A#922@)2#-0%&22#,7)2)#-%)-2"##

:;4<<!B%9!.*CC#,,(7!#$!#,9!4DD#+C%,#*$!*D!;*CC#,C($,9!N4*;O!?#,B!,B(!P$#,(7!Q,%,(9!

R()%+,C($,!*D!;*CC(+.(!,*!SC%#$,%#$!%$7!#C)+*>(!+*/59,!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!

%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.6!9*!%9!,*!($95+(!,B%,!,B(!*5,.*C(9!*D!#,9!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!?#&&!

+(D&(.,!,B(!)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!%$7!/(!%..*5$,%/&(!,*!%&&!9,%J(B*&7(+9T!%$7!,*!5$7(+E*!+(E5&%+!+(>#(?!

/6!%$!#$7()($7($,!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!'(>#(?!8(%C!N48'8OG!8B#9!+(9(%+.B!+()*+,!

#$D*+C9!,B(!?*+J!*D!,B(!48'82!?B#.B!#9!.B%+E(7!?#,B!%99(99#$E!:;4<<L9!(U(.5,#*$!*D!#,9!

.*CC#,C($,9!5$7(+!,B(!4*;=!!

8B(!+()*+,!+(D&(.,9!,?*!C*$,B9!*D!+(9(%+.B!%$7!#9!.*C)+#9(7!*D!,B+((!7(,%#&(7!.%9(!9,57#(9!

NE8VR92!GUUU2!R<QI;W'8O2!#$,(+>#(?92!%$7!%!+(>#(?!*D!%!?#7(!>%+#(,6!*D!9(.*$7%+6!C%,(+#%&9!

#$.&57#$E!:;4<<!7*.5C($,9!%$7!)+#*+!%.%7(C#.!?*+JG!!

Page 3: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0A!

X(!$*,(!,B%,!:;4<<L9!)+(9($,!%))+*%.B!,*!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!#9!,B(!95/Y(.,!*D!.*$9#7(+%/&(!.+#,#.#9CG!

8B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!7*(9!$*,!)+*>#7(!%!.*C)+(B($9#>(!95+>(6!*D!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!:;4<<L9!

.5++($,!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!9.B(C(!?*5&7!.*C)%+(!?#,B!)*99#/&(!D5,5+(!%&,(+$%,#>(9G!:$9,(%72!,B#9!

+()*+,2!?#,B#$!,B(!9.*)(!7(D#$(7!/6!,B(!4*;!%$7!48'82!*DD(+9!%$!%$%&69#9!%$7!%99(99C($,!*D!,B+((!

)#&&%+9!*D!:;4<<L9!.5++($,!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%))+*%.BZ,+%$9)%+($.62!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!%$7!

[*%+7!E*>(+$%$.(Z%$7!)+*>#7(9!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!7(9#E$(7!,*!#C)+*>(!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!,B+*5EB!

,B(9(!,B+((!C(.B%$#9C9G!

!

K"#L9.A9.<2#-.A#522)22*).,##

:$I7(),B!+(9(%+.B!#$,*!,B(!,B+((!D*.59!%+(%9!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!+(>(%&9!%!B#EB&6!.*C)&(U!)#.,5+(!?#,B!

C%$6!#$,(+%.,#$E!>%+#%/&(9!,B%,!C%J(!D%.,ID#$7#$E!.B%&&($E#$E!%$7!%&9*!+($7(+!9#C)&(!9*&5,#*$9!

#C)*99#/&(G!X#,B!,B#9!.*C)&(U#,6!#$!C#$72!%$7!+(D(++#$E!,*!,B(!C%#$!,(U,!*D!,B(!+()*+,!D*+!%!C*+(!

E+%$5&%+!%$%&69#92!,B(!D#$7#$E9!%$7!%99(99C($,9!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!.%$!/(!.*$7($9(7!%9!D*&&*?9G!!

/4566I2#:)%=&%*-.0)#%)<-%A9.<#,%-.2:-%).01#92#0@%%).,(1#.&,#*)),9.<#9,2#:&,).,9-(#-0%&22#

-((#-%)-2#%)>9)?)A#-.A#27&?2#A)=909,2#-(&.<#-#.@*')%#&=#A9*).29&.2"#/,#0-((2#=&%#0()-%(1#

A)=9.)A#9*:%&>)*).,2#-,#,7)#()>)(#&=#:&(9013#9.=&%*-,9&.#A)29<.3#-.A#A)0929&.#*-89.<"##

4&,B*5EB!:;4<<!#9!B#EB&6!,+%$9)%+($,!#$!9*C(!D%.(,9!*D!,B(!*+E%$#F%,#*$2!%!+(>#(?!*D!:;4<<L9!

,+%$9)%+($.6!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+%.,#.(9!+(>(%&9!7(D#.#,9!+(&%,(7!,*!%.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!N,B(!

C(.B%$#9C9!,B%,!%+(!59(7!,*!7(&#>(+!9,+5.,5+(7!#$D*+C%,#*$O2!)%99#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!N,B(!C(%$9!

/6!?B#.B!9,%J(B*&7(+9!.%$!+(H5(9,!#$D*+C%,#*$!D+*C!:;4<<O2!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!,+%$9)%+($.6!

N,B(!%))+*%.B(9!,B%,!($.*5+%E(!%.,#>(!#$>*&>(C($,!%$7!7#%&*E5(!?#,B!:;4<<OG!8+%$9)%+($.6!

#995(9!9,(C!D+*C!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!%!C%99#>(!%C*5$,!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!#9!)+(9($,(7M!,B(!&%.J!*D!

.&(%+!#$D*+C%,#*$!%/*5,!C(,B*79!,*!*/,%#$!5$)5/&#9B(7!#$D*+C%,#*$M!*>(+&6!/+*%7!,+%$9)%+($.6!

(U(C),#*$9!+(E%+7#$E!7*.5C($,!+(H5(9,9M!%$7!,B(!&%.J!*D!%!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,G!!

/4566#7-2#*-A)#29<.9=90-.,#:%&<%)22#9.#9*:%&>9.<#9,2#:@'(90#:-%,909:-,9&.#*)07-.92*2#-.A#

<),2#79<7#*-%82#%)<-%A9.<#9,2#&>)%-((#,%-M)0,&%1#9.#,792#%)<-%A"#E)*-9.9.<#0&.0)%.2#-'&@,#

,7)#:%-0,90-(#9*:-0,#&=#:@'(90#:-%,909:-,9&.#&.#G&-%A#A)0929&.2#-%)#')2,#-AA%)22)A#'1#

9.0%)-29.<#>929'9(9,1#-.A#,%-0)-'9(9,1#&=#9.A9>9A@-(#9.:@,23#9.#&%A)%#,&#0(-%9=1#7&?#,7)2)#9.:@,2#

@(,9*-,)(1#=-0,&%#9.,&#/4566#A)0929&.N*-89.<#:%&0)22)2"#

8B#9!+()*+,!+(.*E$#F(9!:;4<<L9!)+(>#*59!%$7!*$E*#$E!(DD*+,9!,*!#C)+*>(!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!

C(.B%$#9C9G!-5+!+(>#(?!%&9*!9B*?9!%!)(+>%9#>(!)(+.(),#*$!%C*$E!>%+#*59!9,%J(B*&7(+9!,B%,!

,B(6!%+(!$*,!S/(#$E!B(%+7T!/6!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!7(9)#,(!#$.+(%9#$E&6!9*)B#9,#.%,(7!C(.B%$#9C9!

%$7!,**&9!*D!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!8B#9!+()*+,L9!%$%&69#9!#7($,#D#(9!,B(!)*,($,#%&!D*+!#C)+*>(C($,!#$!

9*&#.#,#$E!)5/&#.!#$)5,M!95CC%+#F#$E2!%EE+(E%,#$E!%$7!%.J$*?&(7E#$E!)5/&#.!.*$,+#/5,#*$9M!

.&%+#D6#$E!B*?!)5/&#.!#$)5,!#9!+(D&(.,(7!#$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EM!%$7!($B%$.#$E!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!

%$7!,#C#$E!*D!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!#$,(+%.,#*$9G!!

/4566I2#<%)-,)2,#07-(().<)#-7)-A3#A)2:9,)#29<.9=90-.,#%)0).,#)==&%,23#%)*-9.2#0&%:&%-,)#-.A#

G&-%A#<&>)%.-.0)"#$%&:&2)A#*)-2@%)2#9A).,9=9)A#9.#,792#%):&%,#-9*#,&#9.0%)-2)#)==909).013#

Page 4: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\A!

,%-.2:-%).01#-.A#-00&@.,-'9(9,1#?9,79.#,7)#0@%%).,#0&.,)O,#-.A#9.#,7)#-'2).0)#&=#2,-.A-%A#

-00&@.,-'9(9,1#*)07-.92*2"#

W.B*#$E!,B(!.*$.(+$9!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!9.B*&%+92!,B#9!+()*+,!#7($,#D#(9!9(>(+%&!#995(9!,B%,!D%&&!

5$7(+!,B(!+5/+#.!*D!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(G![*%+7!E*>(+$%$.(!#$!)%+,#.5&%+!#9!%!)+#$.#)%&!

#$9,+5C($,!#$!:;4<<L9!,**&/*U!,*!9,+($E,B($!#,9!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!?#,B!9,+*$E!#C)&#.%,#*$9!D*+!

*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!.5&,5+(!%$7!>%&5(9G!8B#9!+()*+,L9!+(>#(?!*D!%!/+*%7!+%$E(!*D!#995(9!+%#9(7!/6!,B(!

.*CC5$#,6!B%9!&(7!,*!,B(!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!*D!J(6!#995(9!%$7!9B*+,.*C#$E9!#$!%+(%9!95.B!%9![*%+7!

.*C)*9#,#*$M![*%+7I9,%DD!#$,(+%.,#*$M!,B(![*%+7L9!#$,(+%.,#*$!?#,B!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(9M!

,+%$9)%+($.6!*D!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EM!%$7!,B(!)+*.(99(9!/6!?B#.B![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!.%$!/(!.B%&&($E(7!

%$7!+(>#(?(7G!!

!

P"#E)0&**).A-,9&.2##

F7)%)#92#.&#2,%-9<7,=&%?-%A#?-1#,&#-AA%)22#,7)#>-%9&@2#07-(().<)2#/4566#=-0)2"#F7)#

-::%&-07#@.A)%(19.<#,792#%):&%,I2#%)0&**).A-,9&.2#,-8)2#-.#)>&(@,9&.-%1#%-,7)%#,7-.#

%)>&(@,9&.-%1#:)%2:)0,9>)"#F792#-::%&-07#92#-9*)A#-,#0&.,9.@-((1#9*:%&>9.<#/4566I2#

-00&@.,-'9(9,1#2,):#'1#2,):3#'-2)A#&.#()22&.2#()-%.)A3#,7%&@<7#-#2)%9)2#&=#*)-2@%)A#

9.,)%>).,9&.23#%)9.=&%0)A#'1#*&.9,&%9.<#-.A#2@'2)B@).,#%)N)>-(@-,9&."##

"*+!(%.B!*D!,B(!,B+((!D*.%&!%+(%9!.*>(+(7!#$!,B#9!+()*+,!%$7!D*+!(%.B!*D!,B(!J(6!#995(9!%77+(99(72!

,B#9!+()*+,!95EE(9,9!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(!9,%,59!H5*!.%$!/(!#C)+*>(7G!Q*C(!*D!,B(9(!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!.%$!/(!#C)&(C($,(7!H5#.J&62!*,B(+9!+(H5#+(!)*&#.6!.B%$E(92!%$7!9,#&&!*,B(+9!

.%&&!D*+!C*+(!#$I7(),B!+(9(%+.B2!.*$95&,%,#*$!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#*$!%C*$E!,B(!#$>*&>(7!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!!

F792#%):&%,I2#%)0&**).A-,9&.2#>-%1#9.#89.A#-.A#&%9).,-,9&."#F7)1#).0&@%-<)#,7)#-A&:,9&.#

&=#')2,#:%-0,90)2#?7)%)#->-9(-'()#-.A#)O:)%9*).,-,9&.#?9,7#-::%&-07)2#-.A#,&&(2#?7)%)#

=)-29'()"#+)>)%-(#&=#,7)#%)0&**).A-,9&.2#-%)#-9*)A#-,#9*:%&>9.<#9.=&%*-,9&.#:%&0)229.<3#

0%)-,9&.3#A92,%9'@,9&.3#-.A#%)2:&.29>).)22#-,#A9==)%).,#()>)(2#&=#,7)#&%<-.9J-,9&."##

[5#&7#$E!5)*$!D#$7#$E9!D+*C!/*,B!,B(!)+#>%,(!%$7!)5/&#.!9(.,*+92!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!)+*)*9(!

>%+#*59!,**&92!,(.B$#H5(92!%$7!%.,#*$9!,*!D5+,B(+!9,+($E,B($!:;4<<L9!,+%$9)%+($.62!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!%$7!E*>(+$%$.(!C(.B%$#9C9G!8B(!9)(.,+5C!+%$E(9!D+*C!%$!*>(+B%5&!*D!:;4<<L9!

%))+*%.B!,*!#$D*+C%,#*$!7(9#E$!,*!%$!%7Y59,C($,!*D![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!.+#,(+#%!%$7!,B(!

+(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!*D!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&!N:']O!)+*.(99G!

Q(>(+%&!*D!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%77+(99!:;4<<!#$!#,9!.%)%.#,6!%9!%$!#$D*+C%,#*$IB%$7&#$E!($,#,6G!

]+*)*9(7!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!,B#9!.%,(E*+6!#$>*&>(!7#9.&*95+(!)*&#.#(9!%$7!7*.5C($,!B%$7&#$E!

)+%.,#.(9M!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%/*5,!/%9(&#$(!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!)5/&#.!

.*CC($,!)(+#*79M!,B(!+(H5(9,!D*+!C*+(!(U)&#.#,!%$7!7(,%#&(7!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!

D*+!7(.#9#*$9!/6!,B(![*%+7M!,+%$9)%+($.6!+(E%+7#$E![*%+7I9,%DD!#$,(+%.,#*$9M!%$7!#C)+*>(C($,9!

*D!,B(!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!/(,?(($![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((!N^4;OG!

"*&&*?#$E!,B(!)+*)*9(7!(>*&5,#*$%+6!%))+*%.B2!D5,5+(!:;4<<!+(>#(?9!9B*5&7!%99(99!,B(!(U,($,!

,*!?B#.B!,B(9(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9Z#D!#C)&(C($,(7ZB%>(!#C)+*>(7!,B(!9,%,59!H5*2!%$7!?B(,B(+!

Page 5: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_A!

*+!$*,!C*+(!+%7#.%&!C(%95+(9!,B%,!%+(!.5++($,&6!*5,9#7(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!$((7!,*!/(!

.*$9#7(+(72!95.B!%9!,B(!#$,+*75.,#*$!*D!%!9%$.,#*$I/%9(7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C!N(GEG2!%!

/#$7#$E!,B#+7I)%+,6!+(>#(?!)+*.(99OG!"#$%&&62!(>($!,B(!/(9,!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!

E*>(+$%$.(!+(&6!*$!%!.*CC#,C($,!/6![*%+7!%$7!9,%DD!%&#J(!,*!)5,!,B(9(!C(%95+(9!#$,*!)+%.,#.(G!

W$95+#$E!%!.5&,5+(!*D!*)($$(99!#9!%!$(.(99%+6!.*C)&(C($,!,*!,B(!9,+5.,5+%&!9,()9!+(.*CC($7(7!

#$!,B#9!+()*+,G!!

Page 6: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @`A!

4$&'/*)%'$/0!

!

8B#9!+()*+,2!?+#,,($!*$!%!.*C)&(U!95/Y(.,!%$7!*$!%$!%EE+(99#>(!,#C(&#$(2!+(H5#+(7!%!.**+7#$%,(7!

,(%C!(DD*+,G!;*$,+#/5,#*$9!,*!,B(!95/9,%$.(!*D!,B(!+(9(%+.B!.%C(!D+*C!%&&!.*+$(+9!%$7!&%6(+9!*D!

,B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!%$7!*5+!(U,($7(7!$(,?*+J2!#$.&57#$E!)+*Y(.,!%7>#9*+9!%$7!+(9(%+.B(+92!

[(+JC%$!;($,(+!9,%DD!%$7!95CC(+!#$,(+$92!+(9(%+.B(+9!D+*C!)%+,$(+!#$9,#,5,#*$92!%$7!)((+9!D+*C!

%.%7(C#%!%$7!/(6*$7G!X(!%+(!7(()&6!E+%,(D5&!D*+!%&&!*D!,B(!,B*5EB,D5&!#$)5,9!?(!+(.(#>(7!%$7!D*+!

,B(!B%+7!?*+J!%$7!95))*+,!*D!(>(+6*$(!#$>*&>(7G!!

!

4$>?/*&#*1(+!3&720'*@('$/0!

A/0!B(002/C!!"#$%&'()*(+#,%-)."/0(1#02'3!45"*60(."%7('"*02'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%

=%>2*("0?%!

D2/)2/'!E%/F2/'2!&'2<"//2'%2<%!#@3%A)(."'/(0?%2<%>0B%C#,,")3%&'"/($")0%2<%0D"%E"/"#'*D%

;")0"'%<2'%-)<2':#0(2)%!#@%!

G$H&!?(+I/2,C!F")'?%GB%4//%---%&'2<"//2'%2<%!#@3%H(*"%7"#)3%!(I'#'?%#)$%-)<2':#0(2)%

E"/26'*"/3%F#'.#'$%!#@%>*D22,3%J#*6,0?%;2K7('"*02'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%

>2*("0?%!

G$&('H(&!J*''/(*&C!&'2<"//2'%2<%!#@3%F#'.#'$%!#@%>*D22,3%F#'.#'$%L"))"$?%>*D22,%2<%

C2."'):")0C!&'2<"//2'%2<%;2:+60"'%>*(")*"3%F#'.#'$%>*D22,%2<%4)1()""'()1%#)$%M++,("$%

>*(")*"/C!;2KJ26)$"'%#)$%J#*6,0?%;2K7('"*02'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%!

!

?/$K2#'!"-7*0$/0!

G$H&!4$('20C!N2D)%JB%;21#)%N'B%&'2<"//2'%2<%!#@%#)$%4*2)2:(*/3%F#'.#'$%!#@%>*D22,%!

G(#F!B$+-0<*'HC!F")'?%!B%>D#006*9%&'2<"//2'%2<%!#@3%F#'.#'$%!#@%>*D22,O%J#*6,0?%;2K

7('"*02'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%!

L+*72/!B$$-2&$%@H3%&'2<"//2'%2<%!#@3%H"':2)0%!#@%>*D22,O%J#*6,0?%J",,2@3%8"'9:#)%

;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%!

M2&-,!;2+'N2/C!>")(2'%E"/"#'*D"'%#)$%J",,2@/D(+%M$.(/2'?%82#'$%P":I"'3%8"'9:#)%

;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%!

!

6202(/#H!.2(<!

6$)2/'!O(/*0C!E"/"#'*D%7('"*02'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?!

Page 7: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @aA!

62)2F(H!D2(#$#F2!E"/"#'*D"'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%!

P(%/(!Q*,(F(8(2!&'2Q"*0%P#)#1"'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%%

G$2,!Q$/&*&2!E"/"#'*D"'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%

4(/$+*&2!5$+(&2!&'2Q"*0%P#)#1"'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%! !

R(7*-!LSE/*2&2!E"/"#'*D"'3%8"'9:#)%;")0"'%<2'%-)0"')"0%=%>2*("0?%!

!

6202(/#H!;%11$/'!NP$#>(+9#,6!*D!Q,G!^%&&($O!

]B#&![%5C%$$2!b%$!^(+&%.B2!45+(&#%!8%Cc!

!

E2/F<(&!42&'2/!;%<<2/!TUVU!3&'2/&0!

b%.*/!4&/(+,2!^+(E*+6!49C*&*>2!W&#%$(![5.B(+2!47#!d%C7%+2!4$7+(%!>*$!d%($(&2!e*&&6!Q%5,(+2!

"f&#U!8+fE5(+!

!

E2/F<(&!42&'2/!;%11$/'!.2(<!

4C%+!49B%+2!;%+(6!4$7(+9*$2!;%,B(+#$(![+%.62!R%$!;*&&#9I]5+*2!Q%$7+%!;*+,(9#2!Q(/%9,#%$!R#%F2!

d%+6$!^&(C%572!R%$!b*$(92!b*$!e5+&(62!W7!]*)J*2![+5.(!W,&#$E2!;*&#$!e%.&%62!:9%%.!e(#9,(+2!

[(..%!8%/%9J62!b#&&#%$!g*+J2!Q(,B!g*5$E!

!

4$&0%+'2-!9:12/'0!

;B+#9![%>#,F2!b*#!:,*2!R%>#7!b*B$9*$2!<%,B%$!d%#9(+2!]B#&!e%&*$(2!;%,B%+#$%!e%+%.J(2!b5$!e5+%#2!

e#J(!'*/(+,92!'*&D!KG!X(/(+2!W&&#*,,!<*992!R%>#7!X(#$/(+E(+!

!

Q)(.#%&!,B%$J9!,*!e%+,B%!e#$*?2!R(%$!*D!K%+>%+7!V%?!Q.B**&2!"+%$!e.;+*99%$2!R(%$!D*+!

47C#$#9,+%,#*$2!K%+>%+7!V%?!Q.B**&2!%$7!R#%$(!WG!V*)(F2!]+%.,#.(!;**+7#$%,*+2!-DD#.(!*D!,B(!

^($(+%&!;*5$9(&2!K%+>%+7!P$#>(+9#,62!D*+!%7>#.(!%$7!95))*+,G!"5+,B(+!,B%$J9!,*!,B(!

"##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!627*28!.2(<2!?B*9(!J$*?&(7E(2!(U)(+,#9(2!%$7!.B%&&($E#$E!

H5(9,#*$9!.*$,+#/5,(7!#$!#C)*+,%$,!?%69!,*!,B(!D%.,ID#$7#$E!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#*$9!,B%,!?($,!#$,*!,B#9!

+(9(%+.BG!8B%$J9!%&9*!,*!,B(!34"55!0'(II!(&-!E$(/-!<2<)2/0!D*+!.*$,+#/5,#$E!,*!,B(!E*%&9!%$7!

)+*.(99!*D!,B#9!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!(DD*+,G!!

!

Page 8: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @hA!

.()+2!$I!4$&'2&'0!

3=!35.6LRA4.3L5========================================================================================================================================= VU!

4G!]'-[VWe!Q848WeW<8!4<R![4;d^'-P<R GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG31!

[G!e-8:i48:-<!4<R!'-VW!-"!8KW![W'de4<!;W<8W' GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG31!

;G!R:Q;V-QP'WQ GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG31!

33=!.";W!;.6A4.A69C!E";34!4L549?.;C!69;9"64D!XA9;.3L5;!"5R!Q9.DLRLPLBY====== VT!

4G!84Qd!Q8'P;8P'W GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG30!

[G![4Q:;!;-<;W]8Q=!4;;-P<84[:V:8g2!8'4<Q]4'W<;g2!]P[V:;!]4'8:;:]48:-<2!4<R!;-']-'48W!

^-iW'<4<;WGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG30!

RB%M**26)0#I(,(0?BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB RS!

SB%T'#)/+#'")*? BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB RU!

VB%&6I,(*%&#'0(*(+#0(2) BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBRW!

UB%;2'+2'#0"%C2."')#)*" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBRX!

;G!'WQW4';K!jPWQ8:-<Q GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG3h!

RG!'WQW4';K!eW8K-R-V-^g GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG3h!

333=!3;;A9;!3R95.3O34".3L5!"5R!3;;A9!4PA;.96; ========================================================================== VZ!

4G!4]]'-4;KGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG3k!

[G!QPee4':WQ!-"!;4QW!Q8PR:WQ GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG3k!

RB%TD"%-)0'2$6*0(2)%2<%G"@%1T!7/BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB RY!

SB%TD"%B555%72:#()%;#/"%#)$%-;MGG%7"*(/(2)KP#9()1%&'2*"//"/ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB RY!

VB%TD"%7G>K;4ET%&'2+2/#,BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSZ!

;G!:QQPW!;VPQ8W'Q GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG01!

RG!QWVW;8:-<!4<R!-iW'i:WX!-"!dWg!:QQPWQ GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG00!

3[=!W9Y!3;;A9;!"5"PY;3;!"5R!R3;4A;;3L5======================================================================================== T\!

4G!8'4<Q]4'W<;gGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG0\!

RB%C")"'#,%;2)/($"'#0(2)/BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSV!

SB%-//6"K>+"*(<(*%[I/"'.#0(2)/%#)$%E"*2::")$#0(2)/ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSU!

[G!]P[V:;!]4'8:;:]48:-< GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG0k!

RB%C")"'#,%;2)/($"'#0(2)/BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSY!

SB%-//6"K>+"*(<(*%[I/"'.#0(2)/%#)$%E"*2::")$#0(2)/ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVR!

;G![-4'R!^-iW'<4<;WZ;-']-'48W!^-iW'<4<;W!4<R![-4'R!4;8:i:8:WQ GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG\a!

RB%C")"'#,%;2)/($"'#0(2)/BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVX!

Page 9: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @lA!

SB%-//6"K>+"*(<(*%[I/"'.#0(2)/%#)$%E"*2::")$#0(2)/ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBV\!

"??95R3]!"^!ML6W?P"5 ========================================================================================================================= _`!

"??95R3]!E^!35.96[39M!Q9.DLRLPLBY========================================================================================= _a!

"??95R3]!4^!.D9!35.6LRA4.3L5!LO!59M!B.PR;========================================================================== bU!

"??95R3]!R^!.D9!=]]]!RLQ"35!4";9!"5R!34"55!R943;3L5>Q"W35B!?6L49;;9;============= ZU!

"??95R3]!9^!.D9!R5;>496.!?6L?L;"P ===========================================================================================VT_!

!

!

Page 10: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @kA!

62(-2/S0!B%*-2!

!

8B#9!+()*+,!/(E#$9!?#,B!%$!#$,+*75.,*+6!9(.,#*$!,B%,!%+,#.5&%,(9!/*,B!,B(!)+*/&(C!9,%,(C($,!%$7!

,B(!/%.JE+*5$7!*D!,B(!)+*Y(.,2!%$7!,B(!C*,#>%,#*$!%$7!+*&(!*D!,B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+G!!

Q(.,#*$!::!#$,+*75.(9!%$7!D+%C(9!,B(!/%9#.!.*$.(),9!,B%,!%+(!,B(!D*.%&!)*#$,!*D!*5+!#$H5#+6Z

%..*5$,%/#&#,62!,+%$9)%+($.62!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!%$7!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(Z%$7!7(9.+#/(9!,B(!

J(6!,B(*+(,#.%&!D+%C(?*+J9!%$7!H5(9,#*$9!D*+!(%.B!%9!,B(6!%))&6!,*!:;4<<G!8B#9!9(.,#*$!%&9*!

#$.&57(9!,B(!%+,#.5&%,#*$!*D!*5+!.($,+%&!+(9(%+.B!H5(9,#*$9!%$7!%!7(9.+#),#*$!*D!*5+!9,576!

C(,B*7*&*E6!N%77#,#*$%&!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(E%+7#$E!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C9L9!?*+J)&%$!%$7!%))+*%.B!

%+(!7(,%#&(7!#$!4))($7#.(9!4!%$7![OG!!

Q(.,#*$!:::!*DD(+9!%!95CC%+6!*D!,B(!%))+*%.B!59(7!,*!#7($,#D6!#995(9!D*+!&%,(+!%$%&69#9G!8B#9!#9!

D*&&*?(7!/6!9B*+,!95CC%+#(9!*D!,B(!,B+((!.%9(!9,57#(9=!,B(!:$,+*75.,#*$!*D!<(?!E8VR92!,B(!GUUU!

R*C%#$!;%9(!%$7!,B(!R<QI;W'8!]+*)*9%&G!8B(9(!.%9(!9,57#(9!)&%6!%!.($,+%&!+*&(!#$!(9,%/&#9B#$E!

,B(!D%.,5%&!/%9#9!D*+!,B(!+()*+,L9!%$%&69#9!%$7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!8B(!D5&&!.%9(!9,57#(9!%+(!#$!

4))($7#.(9!;2!R2!%$7!WG!!

8B(!/*76!*D!,B(!+()*+,2!Q(.,#*$!:i2!)+(9($,9!*5+!%$%&69#9!*D!,B(!#995(9!%$7!%99*.#%,(7!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!#$!,B+((!95/9(.,#*$9=!,+%$9)%+($.62!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!%$7!.*+)*+%,(!

E*>(+$%$.(G!W%.B!95/9(.,#*$!#$,+*75.(9!,B(!#995(92!95CC%+#F(9!,B(!D%.,5%&!*/9(+>%,#*$9!59(7!#$!

,B(!%$%&69#92!%$7!7#9.599(9!,B(!%+(%9!7(9(+>#$E!D5+,B(+!%,,($,#*$2!,B($!)+*>#7(9!%!.*$.#9(!

%+,#.5&%,#*$!*D!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!8B(![*%+7!^*>(+$%$.(!9(.,#*$!#$.&57(9!%$%&69#92!

7#9.599#*$!%$7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!+(&%,(7!,*!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!%$7!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!

^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((!N^4;OG!

!

Page 11: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @31A!

3=!3&'/$-%#'*$&!

!

5"#$%&'()*#+,-,)*).,#-.A#G-08<%&@.A##

:$!+(.($,!6(%+92!:;4<<!B%9!,%J($!#C)*+,%$,!%.,#*$9Z+%$E#$E!D+*C!9#E$#D#.%$,!)*&#.6!.B%$E(9!,*!

D*+C%&!+(>#(?9Z,*!#C)+*>(!#,9!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.62!%$7!,B(!H5%&#,6!*D!#,9!7(.#9#*$!

C%J#$EG!R(9)#,(!.*$9#7(+%/&(!(DD*+,9!%$7!%.J$*?&(7E(7!#C)+*>(C($,92!:;4<<!.*$,#$5(9!,*!B%>(!

)+*/&(C9!C%J#$E!7(.#9#*$9!,B%,!,B(!E&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!.*CC5$#,6!95))*+,9G!8B(!.+#,#H5(9!.*>(+!%!

/+*%7!+%$E(!*D!#995(92!#$.&57#$E!#$,(+$%&!D%.,*+9!NB*?!:;4<<L9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!C(.B%$#9C9!

B%>(!7(>(&*)(7!#$!+(9)*$9(!,*!#,9!*?$!#$,(+$%&!)+*.(99(9!%$7!(U,(+$%&!D((7/%.JO!%$7!(U,(+$%&!

D%.,*+9!NB*?!9,%J(B*&7(+9!.*CC5$#.%,(!?#,B!:;4<<!%$7!+(9)*$7!,*!95/9(H5($,!7(.#9#*$9O2!%&&!*D!

?B#.B!*..5+!?#,B#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!:;4<<L9!5$#H5(!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!9,+5.,5+(G!!

4E%#$9,!,B#9!/%.J7+*)2!:;4<<!B%9!.*CC#,,(7!#$!,B(!Q(),(C/(+!\12!011k!4DD#+C%,#*$!*D!

;*CC#,C($,9!N4*;O!/6!%$7!/(,?(($!,B(!P$#,(7!Q,%,(9!R()%+,C($,!*D!;*CC(+.(!%$7!:;4<<!,*!

SC%#$,%#$!%$7!#C)+*>(!+*/59,!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.6!9*!

%9!,*!($95+(!,B%,!,B(!*5,.*C(9!*D!#,9!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!?#&&!+(D&(.,!,B(!)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!%$7!/(!

%..*5$,%/&(!,*!%&&!9,%J(B*&7(+9GT3!]5+95%$,!,*!,B(!4*;2!,B(!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!

'(>#(?!8(%C!N48'8O!?%9!9(&(.,(7!/6!,B(!;B%#+!*D!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!%$7!,B(!;B%#+!*D!,B(!^4;!#$!

*+7(+!,*!)(+D*+C!%!+(>#(?!*D!:;4<<L9!(U(.5,#*$!*D!#,9!.*CC#,C($,9G02!\!!

8B(!48'8!#$#,#%,(7!#,9!+(>#(?!*$!4)+#&!302!0131_!%$7!9(&(.,(7!D%.5&,6!%$7!+(9(%+.B(+9!%,!,B(!

[(+JC%$!;($,(+!D*+!:$,(+$(,!m!Q*.#(,6!%,!K%+>%+7!P$#>(+9#,6!N+(D(++(7!,*!%9!,B(!S[(+JC%$!

,(%CTO!,*!%.,!%9!#$7()($7($,!(U)(+,9G`!8B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!?%9!%9J(7!/6!,B(!48'8!,*!)+*>#7(!#,9!

*?$!%$%&69#9!D*.59#$E!*$!,B(!)+*>#9#*$9!*D!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;2!/%9(7!*$!)+#C%+6!%$7!

9(.*$7%+6!+(9(%+.B2!#$.&57#$E!%!9(+#(9!*D!.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!#$,(+>#(?92!%$7!,*!95/C#,!%$!

#$7()($7($,!9(,!*D!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!#$!%..*+7%$.(!?#,B!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,!*D!

45E59,!`2!0131!/(,?(($!,B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!%$7!:;4<<Ga!:$!%77#,#*$2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!

)+*>#7(7!#$%D2*!#$)5,9!,*!,B(!48'8!*$!9)(.#D#.!+(9(%+.B!#995(9!%9!D5+,B(+!9)(.#D#(7!#$!4))($7#U!

4G!!

G"#Q&,9>-,9&.#-.A#E&()#&=#,7)#G)%8*-.#4).,)%#

8B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!?%9!D*5$7(7!,*!(U)&*+(!.6/(+9)%.(2!9B%+(!#$!#,9!9,5762!%$7!B(&)!)#*$((+!#,9!

7(>(&*)C($,G!:,!#9!.*CC#,,(7!,*!)+*75.#$E!+(9(%+.B!?#,B!#C)%.,G!:$!J(()#$E!?#,B!,B#9!C#99#*$!

9,%,(C($,2!D%.5&,62!D(&&*?92!%$7!9,%DD!C(C/(+9!%,!,B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!B%>(!9,57#(7!:;4<<!%$7!#,9!

#C)*+,%$,!)5/&#.!)*&#.6!D5$.,#*$9!9#$.(!#,9!D*5$7%,#*$G!8B(!?*+J!5$7(+!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,!

#9!C*,#>%,(7!/6!%$7!/5#&79!5)*$!,B#9!,+%7#,#*$!*D!+(9(%+.B!%$7!($E%E(C($,2!?B#.B!B%9!&%9,(7!

*>(+!%!7(.%7(!%$7!+(95&,(7!#$!%!9(+#(9!*D!9.B*&%+&6!%+,#.&(92!.*$E+(99#*$%&!,(9,#C*$62!%$7!,(%.B#$E!

C%,(+#%&92!%C*$E!*,B(+!,B#$E9Gh!

4"#C920(&2@%)2#

8B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!B%9!+(.(#>(7!PQR!0a`2ak0G11!D+*C!:;4<<!,*!.*$75.,!,B#9!9,5762!/%9(7!*$!

,B(!/57E(,!%$7!,B(!,(+C9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,Gl!8B(!/57E(,!.*$9#9,9!&%+E(&6!*D!

Page 12: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @33A!

9%&%+#(9!*D!D%.5&,6!%$7!9,%DD!+(9(%+.B(+92!#$.&57#$E!+(9(%+.B!%99#9,%$,92!?*+J9B*)!(U)($9(92!%$7!

,+%>(&!.*9,9G!!

8B(!#$7#>#75%&9!#$>*&>(7!#$!,B(!+(9(%+.B!(DD*+,9!%+(!&#9,(7!#$!,B(!%.J$*?&(7EC($,!)%E(!*D!,B#9!

+()*+,G!:$!,B#9!.*$,(U,2!)&(%9(!$*,(!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!7#9.&*95+(9=!!

• ]+*D(99*+!b*$%,B%$!n#,,+%#$2![(+JC%$!;($,(+!"%.5&,6!;*IR#+(.,*+!%$7!;*I]+#$.#)%&!

:$>(9,#E%,*+!*D!,B#9!+(>#(?2!#9!*$!,B(![*%+7!*D!R#+(.,*+9!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,!Q*.#(,6!N:Q-;OG!

8B(!R<QI;W'8!.%9(!9,576!)+*75.(7!/6!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!+(D(+9!,*!%!&(,,(+!D+*C!V6$$!

Q,G!4C*5+2!]+(9#7($,!%$7!;W-!*D!:Q-;2!#$!(9,%/&#9B#$E!,B(!D%.,5%&!/%9#9!*D!,B(!.%9(!9,576G!

• ]+*D(99*+!b%.J!^*&79C#,B2!K($+6!VG!QB%,,5.J!]+*D(99*+!*D!V%?2![(+JC%$!;($,(+!"%.5&,6!

;*IR#+(.,*+!%$7!C(C/(+!*D!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C2!B%9!95/C#,,(7!,(9,#C*$6!D*+!:;e!#$!,B(!

GUUU!.%9(G!K(!)+*>#7(7!.*CC($,9!*$!,B(!9.*)(!%$7!9,+5.,5+(!*D!%$!(%+&#(+!>(+9#*$!*D!,B(!

GUUU!.%9(!9,576G!!

• [(+JC%$!;($,(+!"(&&*?9B#)!47>#9*+6![*%+7!e(C/(+!%$7!Q($#*+!'(9(%+.B(+!X($76!

Q(&,F(+!#9!%!+()+(9($,%,#>(!*D!,B(!<*$I;*CC(+.#%&!P9(+9!;*$9,#,5($.6!,*!,B(!^<Q-!

;*5$.#&G!QB(!)+*>#7(7!.*CC($,9!*$!,B(!9.*)(!%$7!9,+5.,5+(!*D!,B(!,B+((!.%9(!9,57#(9!

%$7!#$)5,9!+(E%+7#$E!9)(.#D#.!D%.,5%&!H5(9,#*$9!/6!,B(![(+JC%$!.%9(!9,576!,(%CG!

• 8B(![(+JC%$!;($,(+!)+(>#*59&6!?*+J(7!?#,B!:;4<<!%$7!#,9!D*5$7#$E!C(C/(+9!,*!

)+*>#7(!%!>($5(!D*+!(%+&6!C((,#$E9!%$7Z)+#*+!,*!,B(!D*+C%,#*$!*D!:;4<<!#,9(&D2!#$!3kkl2!

%$7!%D,(+!#,9!D*5$7#$EZ,*!)+*>#7(!?(/.%9,!%$7!*,B(+!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!95))*+,G!8B(!

[(+JC%$!;($,(+L9!D*+C%&!#$>*&>(C($,!#$!,B#9!+(9)(.,!?#,B!:;4<<!($7(7!%D,(+!,B(!

<*>(C/(+!0113!:;4<<!C((,#$E!#$!e%+#$%!7(&!'%6G!!

!

!

Page 13: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @30A!

33=!.(0F!;'/%#'%/2C!E(0*#!4$&#21'0C!6202(/#H!X%20'*$&0!(&-!

Q2'H$-$+$@,!

!

5"#F-28#+,%@0,@%)##

8B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,!%9!#$,(+)+(,(7!/6!,B(!48'8!#$.&57(9!,?*!+(&%,(72!/5,!%$%&6,#.%&&6!

7#9,#$.,!?*+J9,+(%C9=!

(1) [(,?(($!45E59,!`2!0131!%$7!-.,*/(+!3\2!01312!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!9(+>(7!%9!%!S9*5$7#$E!

[*%+7T!D*+!,B(!?*+J!*D!,B(!48'8!%$7!#,9!?*+J#$E!E+*5)9!%$7!)+*>#7(7!#$%D2*!#$)5,9!*$!

9)(.#D#.!+(9(%+.B!#995(92!(9)(.#%&&6!#$!+(&%,#*$!,*!,B(!,B+((!.%9(!9,57#(9!,B%,!,B(!

[(+JC%$!,(%C!.*$75.,(7!N9((!/(&*?OG!!

(2) :$!)%+%&&(&2!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,!+(H5#+(7!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!,*!)+*>#7(!#,9!*?$!

%$%&69#9!/%9(7!*$!)+#C%+6!%$7!9(.*$7%+6!+(9(%+.B!%$7!,*!95/C#,!%$!#$7()($7($,!9(,!*D!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8G!!

4))($7#U!4!*5,&#$(9!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%CL9!?*+J)&%$!%$7!)+*>#7(9!%!7(,%#&(7!*>(+>#(?!*D!,B(!

>%+#*59!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!*5,)5,9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!,B(!+(9)(.,#>(!?*+J9,+(%C9G!8B#9!+()*+,!#9!,B(!J(6!

7(&#>(+%/&(!%$7!)+*>#7(9!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%CL9!#$7()($7($,!%$%&69#9!%$7!%99(99C($,!?#,B#$!,B(!

9.*)(!*D!4*;!kG3!%$7!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2!+(9)(.,#>(&6G!!

!

G"#G-290#4&.0):,2R#500&@.,-'9(9,13#F%-.2:-%).013#$@'(90#$-%,909:-,9&.3#-.A#

4&%:&%-,)#S&>)%.-.0)##

]%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;!#9!%#C(7!%,!($95+#$E!S%..*5$,%/#&#,62!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!,B(!#$,(+(9,9!*D!

E&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!59(+9T!%$7!9(,9!,B(!D+%C(!*D!+(D(+($.(!D*+!,B#9!+()*+,G!XB#&(!,B(!%+(%9!*D!+(>#(?!

%+(!D5+,B(+!9)(.#D#(7!#$!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!N%o7O!*D!,B(!4*;2!$*!.*C)+(B($9#>(!7(D#$#,#*$9!*D!,B(!J(6!

.*$.(),9!#**26)0#I(,(0?!%$7!0'#)/+#'")*?!%+(!)+*>#7(7G!4$6!+(>#(?!*D!:;4<<L9!)(+D*+C%$.(!#$!

,B(9(!%+(%9!B%9!,*!9,%+,!?#,B!%,!&(%9,!%!.&%+#D#.%,#*$!*D!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!5$7(+9,%$7#$E!*D!,B(9(!/%9#.!

.*$.(),9!%9!?(&&!%9!#$,(+%.,#$E!$*,#*$9!95.B!%9!+6I,(*%+#'0(*(+#0(2)!%$7!*2'+2'#0"%12."')#)*"!

,B%,!)&%6!%$!(H5%&&6!)+*C#$($,!+*&(!#$!,B(!4*;G!!

!

!"#500&@.,-'9(9,1##

"*+!,B#9!+()*+,2!9(>(+%&!,B(*+#(9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!B%>(!/(($!+(>#(?(7!%$7!,B(#+!)*99#/&(!

%))&#.%,#*$!,*!:;4<<!(U)&*+(7G!8B(!+(95&,!*D!,B#9!(DD*+,2!#$!95CC%+62!#9!,B%,!:;4<<!#9!$*,!

95))*+,(7!/62!$*+!7*(9!#,!&($7!#,9(&D!,*2!%!9#$E&(!,B(*+6!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!8B#9!9,(C9!D+*C!/*,B!,B(!

&%.J!*D!.&%+#,6!%,!,B(!.*$.(),5%&!&(>(&!%$7!:;4<<L9!B6/+#7!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!E+*5$7#$EG!R(9)#,(!,B(!

#C)*+,%$.(!%..*+7(7!,*!.*$9#7(+%,#*$9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!D*+!:;4<<2!,B(+(!#9!$(#,B(+!%!9,%$7%+7!

?*+J#$E!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!$*+!%E+((C($,!*$!C(,+#.9!,*!C*$#,*+!%$7!C(%95+(!)+*E+(99G!

Page 14: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3\A!

:;4<<L9!&(E%&!7*.5C($,9!%$7!)*&#.#(9!7*!$*,!*DD(+!%!.*$9#9,($,!%$7!B*&#9,#.!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!

D+%C(?*+J2!%&,B*5EB!9(>(+%&!7*.5C($,9Z#$.&57#$E!,B(![6&%?92!4$$5%&!'()*+,92!%$7!#$,(+$%&!

9,+%,(E6!)%)(+9ZC%J(!+(D(+($.(!,*!%..*5$,%/#&#,6Gk!"*+!#$9,%$.(2!:;4<<L9!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!

8+%$9)%+($.6!"+%C(?*+J9!%$7!]+#$.#)&(9!+(D(+!,*!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.6!%9!,B(!

D*5$7%,#*$9!,B%,!95))*+,!,B(!.*+)*+%,#*$L9!*)(+%,#$E!C*7(&2!%$7!7(D#$(!,B+((!,6)(9!*D!

%..*5$,%/#&#,6=31!!!

• &6I,(*%/+D"'"%#**26)0#I(,(0?2!?B#.B!7(%&9!?#,B!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!%995+#$E!9,%J(B*&7(+9!

,B%,!:;4<<!B%9!/(B%>(7!+(9)*$9#/&6M!!

• ;2'+2'#0"%#)$%,"1#,%#**26)0#I(,(0?2!?B#.B!.*>(+9!,B(!*/&#E%,#*$9!,B%,!:;4<<!B%9!,B+*5EB!

,B(!&(E%&!969,(C!%$7!5$7(+!#,9!/6&%?9M!%$7!!

• &#'0(*(+#0()1%*2::6)(0?%#**26)0#I(,(0?2!?B#.B!($95+(9!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!%$7!(U(.5,#>(!

)(+D*+C!D5$.,#*$9!#$!&#$(!?#,B!,B(!?#9B(9!%$7!(U)(.,%,#*$9!*D!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6G!!

4.+*99!,B(9(!%+(%92!:;4<<!B%9!7(>(&*)(7!%$7!#C)&(C($,(7!,B+((!J(6!C(.B%$#9C9!%#C(7!%,!

#C)&(C($,#$E!,B(!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!)+#$.#)&(9=!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!C(.B%$#9C92!,+%$9)%+($.6!

)+%.,#.(92!%$7!,B(!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!!

:$!)%+%&&(&!,*!:;4<<L9!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%!+(>#(?!*D!%.%7(C#.!&#,(+%,5+(!%$7!*,B(+!

/%.JE+*5$7!C%,(+#%&9!*DD(+9!9(>(+%&!*,B(+!D+%C(?*+J9!D*+!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!)+*>#7#$E!%77#,#*$%&2!

.*C)&(C($,%+62!%$7!9*C(,#C(9!.*C)(,#$E!)(+9)(.,#>(9G33![5#&7#$E!5)*$!(%+&#(+!%$%&69(92!,B(!

>%+#*59!7#C($9#*$9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%9!%))&#(7!,*!:;4<<!.%$!/(!95CC%+#F(7!%9!D*&&*?9=30!

• T'#)/+#'")*?!%9!%!D5$7%C($,%&!7#C($9#*$!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!%$!#$9,+5C($,!D*+!

%99(99#$E!:;4<<L9!)(+D*+C%$.(M!

• E"/+2)/(I(,(0?!%9!)(+,%#$#$E!,*!D*&&*?#$E!(U,(+$%&&6!%$7p*+!#$,(+$%&&6!(9,%/&#9B(7!+5&(92!

9,%$7%+792!%$7!/(9,!)+%.,#.(9M!!

• E"/+2)/(.")"//!%9!%$!*5,?%+7I&**J#$E!%9)(.,!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!,B%,!C(%95+(9!,B(!(U,($,!

,*!?B#.B!:;4<<!C((,9!,B(!7(C%$79!%$7!$((79!*D!,B(!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!#,!9(+>(9M!%$72!!

• !(#I(,(0?!#$!,B(!9($9(!*D!.*$9(H5($.(9!,B%,!C%6!9,(C!D+*C!#$%))+*)+#%,(!%.,#*$9!/6!

:;4<<!9,%DD!%$7![*%+72!(GEG2!,B#+7I)%+,6!+(>#(?2!9%$.,#*$92!*+!C(.B%$#9C9!,*!+()&%.(!

&(%7(+9B#)G!

8B(!D#+9,!,B+((!)+*.(75+%&!C(.B%$#9C9!%+(!?(&&I(9,%/&#9B(7!(&(C($,9!*D!:;4<<L9!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!

*)(+%,#*$9!%$7!.*$,+#/5,(!,*!#,9!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!8B(6!C%6!%.,!#$!.*C)&(C($,%+6!?%69G!"*+!

(U%C)&(2!,+%$9)%+($.6!C%6!/*,B!9(+>(!%9!%!.B(.J!*$!#$%))+*)+#%,(!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!($B%$.(!,B(!

(>%&5%,#*$!*D!+(9)*$9#/#&#,6I/%9(7!%$7!+(9)*$9#>($(99I/%9(7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!]5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!

.*$,+#/5,(9!,*!,B(!+(9)*$9#>($(99!C(%95+(!%9!#,!*DD(+9!%!>#(?!*D!.*CC5$#,6!)+(D(+($.(9G!!!!!!!

:;4<<L9!%))+*%.B!,*!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!B%9!/(($!.*$,(9,(72!B*?(>(+2!)%+,#.5&%+&6!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!

?(%J$(99!*D!9,%$7%+7!&#%/#&#,6I/%9(7!C(.B%$#9C9!#$!:;4<<q9!.5++($,!E*>(+$%$.(!C*7(&G!Q*C(!

9.B*&%+9!95EE(9,!,B%,!,B(!.*$,#$5*59!)+*&#D(+%,#*$!*D!!r$(?!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!)5/&#.!.*CC($,2!

)5/&#.!+(>#(?2!%$7!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$r!C%6!.+(%,(!%!)(+.(),#*$!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!,B%,!#9!#$!

%.,5%&#,6!%!)**+!95/9,#,5,(!D*+!C*+(!7#+(.,!D*+C9!*D!!+(.*5+9(!,*!:;4<<L9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!

)+*.(99(9G3\!"5+,B(+C*+(2!9*C(!%+E5(!,B%,!:;4<<L9!.5++($,!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C9!%+(!$*,!

Page 15: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3_A!

?(&&I95#,(7!,*!#,9!$((79!%$7!E*%&92!%$7!,B%,!#,!#9!D5$7%C($,%&&6!7#9.*$$(.,(7!D+*C!C*9,!*D!,B(!

9,%$7%+7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C9!,B%,!595%&&6!E*>(+$!%!.*C)%$6G3_!-,B(+9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!

,B%,!,B(!.5++($,!C(.B%$#9C!D*+!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!#9!#$%7(H5%,(G!8B(6!

%+E5(!,B%,!#,!7*(9!$*,!&(%7!,*!/#$7#$E!7(.#9#*$9!*+!9%$.,#*$92!#9!*>(+&6!/+*%7!#$!9.*)(2!/5,!,**!

$%++*?!%9!D%+!%9!(&#E#/#&#,6!*+!9,%$7#$E!#9!.*$.(+$(7!N,B(9(!#995(9!%+(!D5+,B(+!%77+(99(7!#$!

Q(.,#*$!:i!;G0G_!*D!,B#9!+()*+,OG3`!

XB#&(!%.J$*?&(7E#$E!,B(!.*C)(,#$E!,B(*+#(9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!,B#9!+()*+,!7*(9!$*,!7(>(&*)!%!

B*&#9,#.!,B(*+6!*+!$*+C%,#>(!>#(?!*D!:;4<<L9!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!8B(!D+%C(?*+J9!*5,&#$(7!%/*>(!

9(+>(!%9!+(D(+($.(!)*#$,9!,*!/5#&7!%$7!,(9,!?*+J#$E!B6)*,B(9(9!?#,B*5,!)+#*+#,#F#$E!%C*$E!,B(!

7#DD(+($,!$*,#*$9!%$7!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!^#>($!,B(!%99#E$C($,!%$7!C(,B*79!%9!

9)(.#D#(7!#$!,B(!4*;!%$7!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2!,B#9!+()*+,!%$%&6F(9!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C9!

%9!7(D#$(7!/6!:;4<<!#,9(&D!%$7!9((J9!,*!%$%&6F(!%$7!%99(99!?B(,B(+!:;4<<!B%9!&#>(7!5)!,*!#,9!

*?$!.*CC#,C($,9G!8B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!%.J$*?&(7E(9!,B%,!,%J#$E!*,B(+!$*,#*$9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!

%9!%!9,%+,#$E!)*#$,!%$7!D+%C(!D*+!+(>#(?!C%6!&(%7!,*!7#DD(+($,!%$7!(H5%&&6!&(E#,#C%,(!H5(9,#*$9!

,B%,!%+(!$*,!%77+(99(7!#$!,B#9!+()*+,G!8B#9!+()*+,L9!)+%EC%,#.!%))+*%.B!#9!$*,!%$!#C)&#.#,!

($7*+9(C($,!*D!*$(!.*$.(),!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!*>(+!,B(!*,B(+2!/5,!#9!/%9(7!*$!,B(!9)(.#D#.9!*D!,B(!

,%9J!%99#E$C($,!%$7!,%J(9!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(!.*$7#,#*$9!5$7(+!?B#.B!,B#9!+(>#(?!B%9!/(($!

)(+D*+C(72!#$.&57#$E!9#E$#D#.%$,!,#C(!.*$9,+%#$,9G!!

!

D"#F%-.2:-%).01##

:$!,B#9!+()*+,2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!,%J($!%!9#C#&%+!%))+*%.B!,*!,B(!,*)#.!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6G!4D,(+!

%!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!+(&(>%$,!&#,(+%,5+(!*$!,+%$9)%+($.6!.*$.(),9!#$!,B(!:;4<<!.*$,(U,!%$7!/(6*$723a!

,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!D*.59(7!*$!,B(!%$%&69#9!%$7!(>%&5%,#*$!*D!:;4<<L9!*>(+%&&!,+%$9)%+($.6!

9,+5.,5+(!%9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!>%+#*59!)*&#.#(9!%$7!*5,&#$(7!#$!#,9!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!m!8+%$9)%+($.6!

"+%C(?*+J9!%$7!]+#$.#)&(9G3h!

'(C%#$#$E!%?%+(!*D!,B(!B6/+#7!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!.B%+%.,(+!*D!:;4<<2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!/*++*?(7!

D+*C!.*$.(),5%&!C*7(&9!%$7!%))+*%.B(9!59(7!C%#$&6!,*!%$%&6F(!)5/&#.!9(.,*+!#$9,#,5,#*$9!#$!

*+7(+!,*!D+%C(!%$7!7#9.599!:;4<<L9!,+%$9)%+($.6!C(.B%$#9C9G!8B*5EB!D+((7*C!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!

&%?9!%$7!*,B(+!)5/&#.!9(.,*+!,+%$9)%+($.6!C*7(&9!7*!$*,!%))&6!,*!:;4<<!#$!,B(!9%C(!&(E%&!

C%$$(+!%9!,B(6!%))&6!,*!)5/&#.!*+!E*>(+$C($,%&!($,#,#(92!>%+#*59!*/9(+>(+9!B%>(!%E+((7!,B%,!,B(!

)5/&#.!9(.,*+!)+*>#7(9!59(D5&!C*7(&9!D*+!(>%&5%,#$E!:;4<<L9!#$D*+C%,#*$!)*&#.#(9G!!

:$!%77+(99#$E!,B(!.*+)*+%,(!(&(C($,9!#$!:;4<<L9!9,+5.,5+(2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!%&9*!,**J!#$,*!

%..*5$,!7(>(&*)C($,9!#$!,B(!.*+)*+%,(!D#(&72!?B(+(!,B(!,+%$9D(+!*D!)5/&#.I9(.,*+!D5$.,#*$9!,*!,B(!

)+#>%,(!9(.,*+!#9!*D,($!%..*C)%$#(7!/6!#C)*9#$E!+()*+,#$E!%$7!*,B(+!,+%$9)%+($.6!*/&#E%,#*$92!

%9!?(&&!%9!.*$95C(+I*+#($,(7!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5#+(C($,9G!XB#&(!,B(9(!%$7!*,B(+!#$D*+C%,#*$!

+(H5#+(C($,9!)+#C%+#&6!&(%7!,*!#$D*+C%,#*$!D&*?9!/(,?(($!.*+)*+%,#*$9!%$7!+(E5&%,*+6!/*7#(92!

#$!C%$6!D#(&79!.*+)*+%,#*$9!B%>(!7(>(&*)(7!%.,#>(!#$D*+C%,#*$!)*&#.#(9!,*!($95+(!7#+(.,!

.*CC5$#.%,#*$!?#,B!9,%J(B*&7(+!.*$9,#,5($.#(9G!!

[5#&7#$E!5)*$!,B#9!%$%&6,#.%&!D+%C(?*+J2!,B+((!,6)(9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!C(.B%$#9C9!.%$!/(!

7#9,#$E5#9B(7=!!

Page 16: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3`A!

• M*0(."%0'#)/+#'")*?=!:;4<<!%.,#>(&6!C%J(9!#$D*+C%,#*$!%$7!7*.5C($,9!)5/&#.&6!

%>%#&%/&(!*$!#,9!?(/9#,(G!

• &#//(."%0'#)/+#'")*?=!:;4<<!)+*>#7(9!7*.5C($,9!5)*$!+(H5(9,!D+*C!C(C/(+9!*D!,B(!

E($(+%&!)5/&#.G!!

• &#'0(*(+#02'?%0'#)/+#'")*?=!:;4<<!#$>*&>(9!,B(!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!,B(!E($(+%&!)5/&#.!#$!

#,9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9!/6!(&#.#,#$E!.*CC($,9!%$7!#$>#,#$E!.*$95&,%,#*$2!%$7!,B59!

9B%+(9!%$7!+(.(#>(9!#$D*+C%,#*$G!!

[%9(7!5)*$!,B(!.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!#$,(+>#(?92!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!#7($,#D#(7!,B(!D5$.,#*$%&!+*&(!*D!

,+%$9)%+($.6!%9!%$!%77#,#*$%&!7#C($9#*$!D*+!,B(!%$%&69#9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!*/&#E%,#*$9!%9!

7#9.599(7!&%,(+!#$!,B#9!+()*+,G!8B(9(!,+%$9)%+($.6!D5$.,#*$9!#$.&57(=!!

• -)/0(060(2)#,%0'#)/+#'")*?=!,+%$9)%+($.6!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!)+*.(99(9!%$7!9,+5.,5+(9!*D!

:;4<<2!B*?!>%+#*59!*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!(&(C($,9!#$,(+%.,2!%$7!?B%,!,B(#+!+(9)(.,#>(!

+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!%+(G!!

• T2+(*#,%0'#)/+#'")*?=!,B(!%E($7%2!B*?!,B(!%E($7%!#9!7(D#$(72!%$7!?B%,!D%&&9!?#,B#$!,B(!

9.*)(!*D!:;4<<!%.,#>#,#(9G!

• 7"*(/(2)K:#9()1%0'#)/+#'")*?=!B*?!7(.#9#*$9!%,!:;4<<!%+(!C%7(G!

• 4.($")0(#'?%0'#)/+#'")*?=!?B%,!#9!,B(!(>#7($,#%+6!/%9#9!D*+!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!B*?!#9!,B#9!

(9,%/&#9B(7G!

• ;2)/6,0#0(."%0'#)/+#'")*?=!B*?!*5,9#7(!#$)5,!%$7!,B(!)(+9)(.,#>(9!*D!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(9!

%$7!#$,(+(9,(7!)%+,#(9!%+(!#$.*+)*+%,(7!#$,*!:;4<<!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!!

4&&!*D!,B(9(!,+%$9)%+($.6!D5$.,#*$9!/(%+!*$!,B(!D+%C#$E!%$7!)(+D*+C%$.(!*D!%.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

WDD(.,#>(!%$7!.&(%+!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!%/*5,!?B%,!:;4<<!#9!%$7!7*(9!9B*5&7!/(!#$.&57(7!%C*$E!

:;4<<L9!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9G!8B(9(!D5$.,#*$9!%&9*!/(%+!*$!,B(!)(+D*+C%$.(!*D!)%99#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

:;4<<L9!%/#&#,6!,*!.&(%+&6!%$9?(+!,B(9(!H5(9,#*$9!#9!%$!#C)*+,%$,!C(%95+(!*D!#,9!*)($$(99!%$7!

+(9)*$9#>($(99G!477#,#*$%&&62!C%J#$E!,B(9(!)+*.(99(9!%$7!9,+5.,5+(9!,+%$9)%+($,!%$7!,B(+(/6!

%..(99#/&(!#9!%$!(99($,#%&!)+(+(H5#9#,(!D*+!(DD(.,#>(!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!

!

K"#$@'(90#$-%,909:-,9&.###

8B(!)+*.(99(9!/6!?B#.B!:;4<<!#$>#,(92!95CC%+#F(92!%$7!5&,#C%,(&6!#$,(+$%&#F(92!+(D&(.,92!*+!

+(Y(.,9!)5/&#.!#$)5,!%+(!#$,#C%,(&6!.*$$(.,(7!,*!,B(!7#C($9#*$9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!*5,&#$(7!#$!,B(!

)+(>#*59!9(.,#*$2!?#,B!%!)%+,#.5&%+!D*.59!*$!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!,+%$9)%+($.6G!"5+,B(+C*+(2!,B(!

(DD#.%.62!,#C(&#$(992!%$7!7(C*$9,+%/&(!#C)%.,!*D!95.B!#$)5,9!*$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!

)+*.(99(9!%+(!5$7(+E#+7(7!/6!C(.B%$#9C9!*D!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!,+%$9)%+($.62!%9!7(9.+#/(7!%/*>(G!49!

($9B+#$(7!#$!:;4<<L9!D*5$7#$E!7*.5C($,9!%$7!+(#,(+%,(7!/6!,B(!4*;2!(DD(.,#>(!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#9!%!D*5$7%,#*$%&!7#C($9#*$!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%9!#,!($95+(9!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!%$7!

9($#*+!9,%DD!)(+D*+C!D5$.,#*$9!#$!&#$(!?#,B!,B(!?#9B(9!%$7!(U)(.,%,#*$9!*D!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6G!

4!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!&#,(+%,5+(2!.%9(!9,57#(92!%$7!)5/&#.!#$)5,9!95EE(9,9!9#E$#D#.%$,!%7>%$.(9!#$!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!#$!+(.($,!6(%+9!%$7!%!$5C/(+!*D!)+*C#9#$E!#$#,#%,#>(9!,*!D5+,B(+!($B%$.(!

Page 17: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3aA!

,B(!,+%.(%/#&#,6!%$7!>#9#/#&#,6!*D!#$)5,9!#$!:;4<<!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!7(.#9#*$9G!K*?(>(+2!%9!$5C(+*59!

9.B*&%+9!B%>(!$*,(72!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!.%$$*,!/(!:;4<<L9!S.B#(D!&(E#,#C#F#$E!)+#$.#)&(2T!%$7!

C%6!$*,!%7(H5%,(&6!.*C)($9%,(!D*+!,B(!%/9($.(!*D!C*+(!7#+(.,!*+!SB%+7(+T!D*+C9!*D!

%..*5$,%/#&#,6G3l!!-,B(+9!%+E5(!,B%,!,B(!.*++(&%,#*$!/(,?(($!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!

)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!.*5&7!/(!>%9,&6!#C)+*>(7!>#%!.%)%.#,6I/5#&7#$E!%$7!($B%$.#$E!,B(!%/#&#,6!*D!

,B(!)5/&#.!,*!C(%$#$ED5&&6!%$7!(DD(.,#>(&6!($E%E(!#$!,(.B$#.%&!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9G!49!%$!

%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(%95+(2!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!C59,!,B(+(D*+(!95))*+,!,B(!%/#&#,6!*D!.#>#&!

9*.#(,6!,*=!SN#O!5$7(+9,%$7!%$7!.+#,#H5(!,(.B$#.%&!#995(92!N##O!NE%#$O!95DD#.#($,!J$*?&(7E(!*$!,B(!

E#>($!9,+5.,5+(9!%$7!)*,($,#%&92!%$7!N###O!N7(>(&*)O!95DD#.#($,!9J#&&9!,*!$(E*,#%,(!?#,B!C*+(!

)*?(+D5&!%.,*+9GT3k!

]5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!,B(*+#(9!%&9*!+%#9(!H5(9,#*$9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!5&,#C%,(!E*%&9!*D!95.B!)+*.(99(92!

%$7!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!/%&%$.(!/(,?(($!%!,B(*+6!*D!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!,B%,!#9!D*.59(7!*$!9*&#.#,#$E!%$!

(>(+I/+*%7($#$E!%$7!7#>(+9(!9(,!*D!)5/&#.!#$)5,9!%$7!%!9,+%,(E6!,B%,!#9!D*.59(7!*$!E%+$(+#$E!%$7!

5,#&#F#$E!,B(!C*9,!59(D5&!9(,!*D!,B*9(!#$)5,9G01!:;4<<L9!)%+,#.5&%+!7(D#$#,#*$!%$7!%))+*%.B!,*!

)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$Z,B(!(DD#.%.6!*D!?B#.B!#9!.&*9(&6!&#$J(7!,*!,+%$9)%+($.6Z%&9*!+%#9(9!

,($9#*$9G!4+(!)5/&#.!#$)5,!)+*.(99(9!#$,($7(7!,*!($%/&(!9,%J(B*&7(+9!,*!*/9(+>(2!#$!%!,#C(&62!

,+%$9)%+($,2!%$7!(%9#&6!%..(99#/&(!?%62!,B(!7(,%#&9!%$7!)+*.(99(9!,B%,!D%.,*+!#$,*!%!7(.#9#*$s!-+!#9!

,B(!E*%&!/(,,(+!7(D#$(7!%9!D%.#&#,%,#$E!,B(!.%)%.#,6!,*!S%DD(.,2!#$!%!C(%$#$ED5&!D%9B#*$T!,B%,!

7(.#9#*$s03!!!

8B#9!+(>#(?!#9!$*,!#$,($7(7!,*!+(9*&>(!,B*9(!.*C)(,#$E!,B(*+#(92!$*+!,*!7(,(+C#$(!?B(+(!,B(6!

%+(!,+5&6!%,!*779!%$7!?B%,!C(.B%$#9C9!C#EB,!D%.#&#,%,(!,B(#+!.*C#$E!,*E(,B(+!%,!7#DD(+($,!9,%E(9!

*D!,B(!)5/&#.!#$)5,!)+*.(99G!'%,B(+2!,B(!%$%&69#9!#9!D*.59(7!*$!,B(!>#9#/#&#,6!%$7!,+%.(%/#&#,6!*D!%$!

#$7#>#75%&!#$)5,!D+*C!S($7!,*!($7T!ND+*C!#$#,#%&!#$)5,!,*!+(&(>%$,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!*+!:;4<<!

%.,#>#,6O2!?B(,B(+!7#+(.,&62!%9!%$!#$7#>#75%&L9!#$)5,!,*!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!*+!D*+5C92!*+!#$7#+(.,&62!

>#%!,B(!.B%$$(&9!*DD(+(7!/6!,B(!7#DD(+($,!/*7#(9!,B%,!D((7!#$,*!,B(![*%+7L9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!

)+*.(99(9G!;*$D+*$,#$E!)(+.(),#*$9!*D!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!,B%,!,B(6!%+(!$*,!%.,5%&&6!S/(#$E!

B(%+7T!#9!D5$7%C($,%&!,*!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!%$7!,*!,B(#+!

#$,(+9(.,#*$!?#,B!(DD(.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!

!

P"#4&%:&%-,)#S&>)%.-.0)###

]%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;!C%J(9!9(>(+%&!+(D(+($.(9!,B%,!%+(!/(9,!95/95C(7!5$7(+!,B(!5C/+(&&%!

,(+C!S.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(GT!^*>(+$%$.(!*D!:;4<<!%.,#>#,#(9!9)%$9!%!.*C)&(U!%$7!7#>(+9(!9(,!*D!

D5$.,#*$%&!%.,#>#,#(92!+%$E#$E!D+*C!9,+#.,&6!,(.B$#.%&!%.,#>#,#(9!,*!,B(!%C/#,#*59!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!

(DD*+,!,*!9((J!.*$9($959!*$!)*&#.6!H5(9,#*$9!*D!E&*/%&!+(&(>%$.(G!:D!.*$9#7(+(7!9()%+%,(&62!(%.B!*D!

,B(!%.,#>#,#(9!5$7(+,%J($!%,!:;4<<!C%6!/(!/(9,!95))*+,(7!/6!#,9!*?$!7#9,#$.,!C*7(&!*D!.*+)*+%,(!

E*>(+$%$.(G!g(,!:;4<<!C59,!+(.*$.#&(!%&&!*D!,B(9(!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!,B(#+!E*>(+$%$.(!5$7(+!*$(!

D+%C(?*+J!%$7!%77+(99!,B(!%99*.#%,(7!,+%7(*DD9G!R(.#9#*$9!%$7!9,+5.,5+(9!%,!:;4<<!C59,!$*,!

*$&6!,%J(!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(!(DD#.#($.6!%$7!,#C(&#$(99!*D!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!/(!+(9)*$9#>(!,*!:;4<<!

9,%J(B*&7(+9!/5,!%&9*!%.B#(>(!,B(!B#EB(9,!9,%$7%+79!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!?B#&(!

*)(+%,#$E!?#,B#$!,B(!&(E%&!+(9,+#.,#*$9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!:;4<<L9!9,%,59!%9!%!$*$)+*D#,!.*+)*+%,#*$!

#$!,B(!9,%,(!*D!;%&#D*+$#%G!^#>($!#,9!&(E%&!9,%,592!,B(![*%+7!/(%+9!5&,#C%,(!+(9)*$9#/#&#,6!*>(+!,B(!

%.,#*$9!*D!:;4<<!%$7!#9!%,!,B(!.($,(+!*D!H5(9,#*$9!+(&%,(7!,*!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(2!#$.&57#$E!,B(!

Page 18: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3hA!

.*C)*9#,#*$!%$7!9J#&&!9(,!*D!,B(![*%+72!,B(!9(&(.,#*$!*D![*%+7!C(C/(+92!,B(!%&&*.%,#*$!*D!

+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!%$7!+(&%,#*$9B#)!/(,?(($!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!9,%DD2!%$7!,B(!&(>(&!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!

%99*.#%,(7!?#,B![*%+7!%$7!9,%DD!%.,#>#,#(92!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#*$G!!

](+B%)9!,B(!C*9,!.*$,($,#*59!*D!,B(!:;4<<L9!%.,#>#,#(9!#9!C%J#$E!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!

%&&*.%,#*$!*D!$(?!7*C%#$!$%C(9G!8B(9(!7(.#9#*$9!#$(>#,%/&6!+(95&,!#$!?#$$(+9!%$7!&*9(+92!%$7!,B(!

/($(D#,9!%$7!.*9,9!%+(!$*,!(%9#&6!.*C)%+(7G!:$!95.B!.%9(92!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!#9!.B%+E(7!?#,B!

?(#EB#$E!,B(9(!7#9)%+%,(!/($(D#,9!%$7!.*9,92!?B#.B!C%)!7#9)+*)*+,#*$%,(&6!%.+*99!7#DD(+($,!

9,%J(B*&7(+!E+*5)9G!XB($!95..(99D5&!%,!/+#7E#$E!%$7!+(.*$.#&#$E!,B(!$((79!*D!%!7#>(+9(!9(,!*D!

9,%J(B*&7(+92!:;4<<!95..((79!/6!)&%6#$E!%$!(DD(.,#>(!.*$D&#.,!+(9*&5,#*$!+*&(G!V%.J!*D!95..(99!

C%6!*D,($!B%>(!C*+(!,*!7*!?#,B!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!*D!,B(!7#9)5,(!+%,B(+!,B%$!,B(!(DD(.,#>($(99!*D!

:;4<<!%9!%$!%+/#,+%,*+G![(.%59(!*D!,B(!.*$,($,#*59!$%,5+(!*D!C%$6!:;4<<!7(.#9#*$92!,B(!&*9(+9!

*D,($!&(>(&!.B%+E(9!%E%#$9,!,B(!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(992!?B#&(!,B(!?#$$(+9!%+(!$*,!%),!,*!)*#$,!

*5,!%$6!)+*.(75+%&!9B*+,.*C#$E9!*+!D%.,5%&!E%)9G!"*+!:;4<<2!/*,B!)(+.(),#*$!%$7!95/9,%$.(!

?(#EB!*$!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!#,9!7(.#9#*$92!%$7!,B(!E*>(+$%$.(!.B%&&($E(!C59,!%77+(99!/*,BG!!

XB#&(!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!%+(!#C)*+,%$,2!9*!,**!#9!%!.5&,5+(!*D!E**7!E*>(+$%$.(G!8B(!

95..(99!*D!,B(!C(%95+(9!95EE(9,(7!#$!,B#9!+()*+,!7()($7!*$!,B(!/56I#$!*D!,B(!9,%DD!%$7![*%+7!*D!

:;4<<G!4!$5C/(+!*D!,B(!95EE(9,#*$9!)+(9($,(7!&%,(+!#$!,B#9!+()*+,!+(&%,(!,*!#C)+*>#$E!,B(!

%/#&#,#(9!*D!,B(!9,%DD!%$7![*%+7!,*!#C)&(C($,!E*>(+$%$.(!)+#$.#)&(9!#$!,B(#+!7%#&6!)+%.,#.(G!!

!

4"#E)2)-%07#T@)2,9&.2#

X#,B!,B#9!.*$.(),5%&!D+%C#$E!#$!C#$72!,B(!+(9(%+.B!H5(9,#*$9!,B%,!,B#9!+()*+,!9((J9!,*!%$9?(+!

%+(!%9!D*&&*?9=!

• [%9(7!*$!.%9(!9,576!%$%&69#9!%$7!%!+(>#(?!*D!%!7#>(+9(!9(,!*D!C%,(+#%&9Z#$.&57#$E!)5/&#.!

.*CC($,92!:;4<<!7*.5C($,92!%.%7(C#.!9,57#(92!C(7#%!+()*+,92!(U)(+,!*)#$#*$92!%$7!

#$,(+>#(?9Z?B%,!J(6!#995(9!(C(+E(!+(&%,(7!,*!:;4<<L9!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!

%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.6s!

• XB#.B!*D!,B(9(!#995(9!B%>(!/(($!*+!.%$!/(!%77+(99(72!%$7!/6!?B%,!C(%$92!#$!*+7(+!,*!

#C)+*>(!,B(!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.6!?#,B#$!,B(!

D+%C(?*+J!*D!,B(!4*;s!

C"#E)2)-%07#Q),7&A&(&<1##

:$!%..*+7%$.(!?#,B!,B(!C(,B*7*&*E#.%&!)+#$.#)&(9!*5,&#$(7!#$!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2!?B#.B!

C%J(9!(U)&#.#,!+(D(+($.(!,*!,B(!.%9(!9,576!C(,B*7!%$7!+(H5#+(9!%$6!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!,*!/(!

/%9(7!*$!D%.,92!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!.*C/#$(7!%!$5C/(+!*D!H5%&#,%,#>(!+(9(%+.B!C(,B*7*&*E#(9G!

8B(9(!(DD*+,9!#$.&57(2!%C*$E!*,B(+!,B#$E92!)+#C%+6!+(9(%+.B!#$.&57#$E!>%+#*59!9,+5.,5+(7!

NH5(9,#*$$%#+(I/%9(7O!#$,(+>#(?9!?#,B!(U)(+,9!%$7!9,%J(B*&7(+!+()+(9($,%,#>(92!9(.*$7%+6!

+(9(%+.B!*D!(U,($9#>(!X(/!%$7!7%,%/%9(!9(%+.B(92!%$!(U)&*+%,*+6!W$E&#9BI&%$E5%E(!&#,(+%,5+(!

+(>#(?2!%$7!,B(!7+%D,#$E!*D!.%9(!9,57#(9G!! !

Page 19: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3lA!

8B(!.%9(!9,57#(9!B%>(!)&%6(7!%!)%+,#.5&%+&6!#C)*+,%$,!+*&(!#$!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%CL9!?*+J2!E#>($!#,9!

C%$7%,(!7(9.+#/(7!#$!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,G!8B(!D*&&*?#$E!C(,B*79!B%>(!/(($!%))&#(7!#$!,B#9!

9)(.#D#.!.*$,(U,=!

• '(>#(?!*D!C%,(+#%&9=!"*&&*?#$E!,B(!C5&,#I9,()!C(,B*7*&*E#.%&!%))+*%.B!*5,&#$(7!#$!,B(!

Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2!,B(!7+%D,!.%9(!9,57#(9!%+(!9,+5.,5+(7!%9!H5%&#,%,#>(2!(U)&*+%,*+6!

.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!/%9(7!*$!%$!(U,($9#>(!+(>#(?!*D!%!7#>(+9(!+%$E(!*D!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(!

C%,(+#%&92!#$.&57#$E!)5/&#.!.*CC($,92!:;4<<!7*.5C($,92!%.%7(C#.!9,57#(92!C(7#%!

+()*+,92!%$7!(U)(+,!*)#$#*$9G!8B(!+(>#(?!9,%+,(7!?#,B!%!C%))#$E!*D!)5/&#.!95/C#99#*$9!

D+*C!b%$5%+6!011l!,*!b5$(!3h2!0131!%$7!#$.&57(72!%C*$E!*,B(+!,B#$E92!(U,($9#>(!X(/!

%$7!7%,%/%9(!9(%+.B(9!%#C(7!%,!#7($,#D6#$E!.%9(I9)(.#D#.!C%,(+#%&9!D+*C!>%+#*59!9*5+.(92!

#$.&57#$E!:;4<<L9!?(/9#,(G!W%.B!.%9(!9,576!)+*>#7(9!7(,%#&(7!+(D(+($.(9!,*!95.B!9)(.#D#.!

C%,(+#%&9!#$!,B(!D**,$*,(9G!

• :$,(+>#(?9=!:$!%77#,#*$!,*!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(!9*5+.(92!,B(!7+%D,!.%9(!9,57#(9!%+(!#$D*+C(7!

/6!*/9(+>%,#*$9!*D!,B(!9(&(.,(7!E+*5)!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!(U)(+,9!?B*!?(+(!

#$,(+>#(?(7!#$!,B(!.*5+9(!*D!7(>(&*)#$E!,B(!.%9(!(U%C)&(9G!8B(9(!#$,(+>#(?9!)+*>#7(!%$!

#C)*+,%$,!95))&(C($,%+6!D%.,5%&!/%9#9!D*+!,B#9!+()*+,!/(.%59(!,B(6!.*$>(6!*/9(+>%,#*$9!

+(E%+7#$E!,B(!)(+.(),#*$!%$7!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$!*D!:;4<<!7(.#9#*$9!/6!,B(!/+*%7(+!

.*CC5$#,6G!8B(!9,%,(C($,9!*D!#$,(+>#(?((9!7*!$*,!+(D&(.,!,B(!*)#$#*$9!*+!.*$.&59#*$9!*D!

,B(![(+JC%$!,(%CG!8B(!#$,(+>#(?9!?(+(!.*$75.,(7!*$!,B(!.*$7#,#*$!*D!.*$D#7($,#%&#,6M!

#$!,B(!.%9(!*D!,B(!H5(9,#*$$%#+(9!,*!^4;!C(C/(+92!+(9)*$7($,9!?(+(!%9J(7!,*!9)(.#D6!

?B(,B(+!,B(6!?#9B(7!,B(#+!%$9?(+9!,*!+(C%#$!.*$D#7($,#%&G!4&&!:;4<<!9,%DD!#$,(+>#(?9!

?(+(!.**+7#$%,(7!#$,(+$%&&6!?#,B#$!:;4<<!%$7!,B(!+(9)*$9(9!,*!,B(!H5(9,#*$$%#+(9!?(+(!

%EE+(E%,(7!/6!:;4<<L9!47>#9*+!,*!,B(!]+(9#7($,2!R($#9(!e#.B(&G!:;4<<L9!^($(+%&!

;*5$9(&2!b*B$!b(DD+(6!%,,($7(7!,B(!)B*$(!#$,(+>#(?9!?#,B!:;4<<!9,%DD!C(C/(+9!%,!B#9!

*?$!+(H5(9,G!"*+!C*+(!7(,%#&92!9((!4))($7#U![G!!

8B(!+(>#(?!*D!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(!C%,(+#%&92!.%9(!9,57#(92!%$7!#$,(+>#(?9!B%>(!/(($!95))&(C($,(7!

/6!%!9(+#(9!*D!#$,(+$%&!C(C*+%$7%!?+#,,($!/6!D%.5&,6!C(C/(+9!&**J#$E!#$,*!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!

C(.B%$#9C92!,+%$9)%+($.6!#995(92!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!#995(92!%$7!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

]%$(&!C(.B%$#9CG!4&&!C%,(+#%&9!N(U.(),!,B(!.*$D#7($,#%&!#$,(+>#(?9O!B%>(!/(($!.*&&(.,(7!%$7!?#&&!

/(!C%7(!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(!#$!b%$5%+6!0133!#$!*+7(+!,*!95))*+,!%$7!($.*5+%E(!D5,5+(!+(9(%+.B!

(DD*+,9G!!

!

!

Page 20: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @3kA!

333=!300%20!3-2&'*I*#('*$&!(&-!300%2!4+%0'2/0!

!

5"#5::%&-07##

8B(!C%$7%,(!C($,#*$(7!%/*>(2!?B#.B!+(H5#+(9!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!,*!)+*>#7(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!

,B%,!%+(!(U.&59#>(&6!D%.,I/%9(72!#9!#$,(+)+(,(7!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B#9!D#$%&!+()*+,!95.B!,B%,=!

• #995(!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!C59,!/(!/%9(7!*$!D%.,9!%$7!*/9(+>%,#*$9M!!

• #995(!%$%&69#9!C59,!,%J(!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(!.5++($,!.*$,(U,!#$!?B#.B!:;4<<!*)(+%,(92!

#$.&57#$E!:;4<<L9!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!D+%C(?*+J!N(GEG2!%))&#.%/&(!)+*>#9#*$9!#$!,B(![6&%?9!%$7!

)*&#.#(9OM!%$7!,B%,!!

• .*$9#7(+%,#*$9!%$7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%+(!95))*+,(7!/6!,B(9(!*/9(+>%,#*$92!%$7!%&9*!

,%J(!#$,*!%..*5$,!:;4<<L9!)+(>#*59!(DD*+,9!%#C(7!%,!%77+(99#$E!,B(!+(9)(.,#>(!#995(9G!!

8B(!.%9(!9,57#(9!95CC%+#F(7!#$!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!9(.,#*$!)&%6!%!J(6!+*&(!?#,B#$!,B#9!C5&,#I)+*$E(7!

D%.,I/%9(7!%))+*%.BG00!8B(6!B%>(!E5#7(7!,B(!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!*D!J(6!#995(92!#$.&57#$E!.B%&&($E(9!

%$7!*))*+,5$#,#(92!%9!?(&&!%9!,B(!7#9.599#*$!*D!)*99#/&(!#C)+*>(C($,9G!:$!%77#,#*$!,*!,B(!.%9(!

9,57#(92!?(!B%>(!#7($,#D#(7!%$7!%$%&6F(7!#995(9!)5,!D*+?%+7!/%9(7!*$!%!+(>#(?!*D!)5/&#.&6!

%>%#&%/&(!C%,(+#%&92!#$,(+>#(?92!%$7!,B(!#$,(+$%&!)*&#.6I*+#($,(7!C(C*+%$7%G0\!!

!

G"#+@**-%9)2#&=#4-2)#+,@A9)2##

!"#F7)#/.,%&A@0,9&.#&=#6)?#<FUC2##

:$!b5$(!*D!011l2!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!5$%$#C*59&6!%7*),(7!,B(!^<Q-L9!)*&#.6!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!D*+!

,B(!#$,+*75.,#*$!*D!$(?!E($(+#.!,*)I&(>(&!7*C%#$!$%C(9!NE8VR9O!%$7!+(9*&>(7!,*!/(E#$!?*+J!*$!

,B(!#C)&(C($,%,#*$!*D!%!$(?!E8VR!%))&#.%,#*$!)+*.(99G!8B(!$(?!)+*E+%C2!#$#,#%&&6!9.B(75&(7!,*!

&%5$.B!#$!Q(),(C/(+!011k2!#9!9,#&&!5$7(+!7(>(&*)C($,G!!

8B(!)+*)*9(7!)+*.(99!B%9!/(($!D+%5EB,!?#,B!.*$,+*>(+962!#$.&57#$E!.+#,#.#9C9!*>(+!#,9!7(&%692!

?B(,B(+!:;4<<L9!C(,B*7!*D!)5/&#9B#$E!%$7!#$.*+)*+%,#$E!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!#9!95DD#.#($,&6!

,+%$9)%+($,!%$7!+(9)*$9#>(2!%$7!?B(,B(+!$(?!E8VR9!9B*5&7!(>($!(U#9,G!;+#,#.9!B%>(!%&9*!+%#9(7!%!

$5C/(+!*D!9)(.#D#.!95/9,%$,#>(!#995(92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!WU)+(99#*$!*D!:$,(+(9,!)+*)*9%&2!,+%7(C%+J!

)+*,(.,#*$2!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((2!,B(!)+*)*9(7!C*+%&#,6!%$7!)5/&#.!

*+7(+!9,%$7%+7!D*+!*/Y(.,#*$9!,*!$(?!E8VR92!%$7!>(+,#.%&!#$,(E+%,#*$G!

D"#F7)#"OOO#C&*-9.#4-2)#-.A#/4566#C)0929&.NQ-89.<#$%&0)22)2#

:$!01112!:;4<<!#$#,#%,(7!%!S)+**D!*D!.*$.(),T!9,%E(!,*!/(E#$!,B(!%7*),#*$!*D!$(?!E($(+#.!8VR9G!

:;e!'(E#9,+6!5$95..(99D5&&6!)+*)*9(7!GUUU!%$7!GJ#79G!:$!011\2!%D,(+!9*C(!(U.B%$E(9!?#,B!:;4<<!

+(E%+7#$E!#,9!D#+9,!)+*)*9%&2!:;e!95/C#,,(7!%!+(>#9(7!/#7!D*+!,B(!.+(%,#*$!*D!GUUU!D*+!:;4<<L9!.%&&!

Page 21: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @01A!

D*+!9)*$9*+(7!8VR!)+*)*9%&9G!8B(!:;4<<![*%+7!%7*),(7!%!+(9*&5,#*$!,*!/(E#$!$(E*,#%,#$E!,B(!

.*CC(+.#%&!%$7!,(.B$#.%&!,(+C9!*D!%!+(E#9,+6!%E+((C($,!?#,B!:;e!#$!b5$(!011`M!B*?(>(+2!5$7(+!

)+(995+(!D+*C!%!>%+#(,6!*D!.*$9,#,5($.#(92!:;4<<!+(>(+9(7!#,9!7(.#9#*$!%$7!7($#(7!:;eL9!)+*)*9%&!

#$!011hG!:;e!D#&(7!%!+(H5(9,!D*+!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!#$!011lZ,B(!D#+9,!95.B!+(H5(9,!,*!/(!B(%+7!

/(D*+(!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&!N:']O!#$!:;4<<L9!B#9,*+6G!:$!01312!%!,B+((I)(+9*$!)%$(&!*D!

%+/#,(+9!N?B#.B!.*C)+#9(7!,B(!:']O!7(.#7(7!#$!D%>*+!*D!:;eG!!

8B#9!.%9(!9,576!*5,&#$(9!,B(!J(6!(>($,9!95++*5$7#$E!,B(!GUUU!)+*)*9%&9!D+*C!0111!,*!b5$(!3h2!

01312!?#,B*5,!+(I(U%C#$#$E!,B(!C(+#,9!*D!,B(!%))&#.%,#*$!#,9(&DG!8B#9!.B+*$*&*E6!#9!7(9#E$(7!,*!

(U%C#$(!,?*!9)(.#D#.!7#C($9#*$9!*D!,B(!GUUU!)+*.(99=!N3O!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

]%$(&!N:']O2!%$7!N0O!,B(!#$,(+%.,#*$!/(,?(($!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!;*CC#,,((!N^4;O!%$7!

,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!75+#$E!:;4<<L9!(>%&5%,#*$!*D!,B(!:;e!GUUU!)+*)*9%&2!+(E#9,+6!%E+((C($,!

$(E*,#%,#*$9!?#,B!:;e2!%$7!5&,#C%,(!+(Y(.,#*$!*D!:;eL9!%))&#.%,#*$G!!

K"#F7)#C6+N4VEF#$%&:&2-(#

:;4<<L9!R<QI;W'8!)+*)*9%&!%7>*.%,(9!,B(!.+(%,#*$!*D!%$!*+E%$#F%,#*$!,*!%$%&6F(2!%99(992!%$7!

+(9)*$7!,*!E&*/%&!R<Q!9(.5+#,6!,B+(%,9G!8B#9!.%9(!9,576!/(E#$9!?#,B!%$!*>(+>#(?!*D!:;4<<L9!R<Q!

9(.5+#,6!C%$7%,(!%9!7(9.+#/(7!#$!#,9!e(C*+%$75C!*D!P$7(+9,%$7#$E!?#,B!,B(!P$#,(7!Q,%,(9!

R()%+,C($,!*D!;*CC(+.(2!#,9![6&%?92!%$7!#,9!011k!4*;G!4!95CC%+6!*D!,B(!R<QI;W'8!)+*)*9%&!

D*&&*?92!/%9(7!*$!:;4<<L9!S]+*)*9(7!Q,+%,(E#.!:$#,#%,#>(9!D*+!R<Q!Q(.5+#,62!Q,%/#&#,62!%$7!

'(9#&#($.6T!%$7!#,9!SR<QI;W'8![59#$(99!;%9(GT!8B(!9,576!,B($!,+%.(9!,B(!*+#E#$9!*D!,B(!

.*$,+*>(+96!95++*5$7#$E!,B(!R<QI;W'8!)+*)*9%&2!/(E#$$#$E!?#,B!:;4<<L9!)5/&#.%,#*$!*D!,B(!

)+*)*9%&!%$7!,B(!+(C%+J9!C%7(!#$!<%#+*/#!/6!#,9!;W-2!'*7![(.J9,+*C2!%$7!,B(!.*$,+*>(+96L9!

7(>(&*)C($,!,B+*5EB!)5/&#.!.*CC($,92!.*++(9)*$7($.(2!%$7!C%,(+#%&!E%,B(+(7!#$!#$,(+>#(?9!

?#,B!,B(!R<Q!.*CC5$#,6G!!

8B(!+(>#(?!*D!,B(9(!C%,(+#%&9!95EE(9,9!,B+((!J(6!#995(9!5$7(+&6#$E!,B(!.*$,+*>(+96=!N3O!,B(!

C(+#,9!%$7!.&%+#,6!*D!:;4<<L9!%99(99C($,!*D!,B(!.5++($,!9,%,(!*D!R<Q!9(.5+#,6!%$7!#,9!)+*)*9%&!D*+!

,B(!.+(%,#*$!*D!%!.($,+%&#F(7!;W'8M!N0O!>%+6#$E!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$9!*D!:;4<<L9!R<Q!9(.5+#,6!C%$7%,(M!

%$7!N\O!)+*.(75+%&!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!*)($$(992!,+%$9)%+($.62!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!%$7!9,%J(B*&7(+!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!

4"#/22@)#4(@2,)%2##

8B(!%$%&69#9!*D!,B(!,B+((!.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!%77#,#*$%&!.%9(!(U%C)&(92!,*E(,B(+!?#,B!%$!#$I7(),B!

+(>#(?!*D!>%+#*59!*,B(+!C%,(+#%&9!N#$.&57#$E!:;4<<L9!)*&#.#(9O2!95EE(9,9!%!7#>(+9(!+%$E(!*D!#995(9!

,B%,2!,*!>%+6#$E!7(E+((92!%+(!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!:;4<<L9!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!

,+%$9)%+($.62!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!%$7!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(G!Q*C(!*D!,B(9(!#995(9!%+(!

9,+5.,5+%&2!?B#&(!*,B(+!.*$.(+$9!%+(!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!95/9,%$.(!*D!:;4<<L9!?*+JM!9,#&&!*,B(+9!+(&%,(!

,*!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!*+!#$D*+C%,#*$!D&*?9G!8B(!D*&&*?#$E!,6)*&*E6!)+*>#7(9!

*$(!?%6!,*!.&59,(+!95.B!#995(9G!47C#,,(7&62!.%,(E*+#(9!%+(!C%7(2!$*,!D*5$7Z,B592!9(>(+%&!

Page 22: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @03A!

7#DD(+($,!?%69!(U#9,!,*!C%)!,B(!#995(9!,B%,!B%>(!/(($!#7($,#D#(7!#$!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!%/*>(I

C($,#*$(7!C%,(+#%&9G!8B(!D*&&*?#$E!,B+((!.%,(E*+#(9!.%$!/(!7#9,#$E5#9B(7=!

• >0'6*06'#,%(//6"/=!Q,+5.,5+%&!#995(9!%+(!+(&%,(7!,*!?B%,!*$(!C#EB,!7(9.+#/(!%9!,B(!SR<4T!

*D!:;4<<!%9!#,!C%$#D(9,9!#,9(&D!,*7%6G!8B#9!.%,(E*+6!#$.&57(9!$*,!*$&6!:;4<<L9!&(E%&!

9,+5.,5+(9!%9!%!;%&#D*+$#%I/%9(7!$*$)+*D#,!.*+)*+%,#*$!%$7!#,9!C#99#*$!9,%,(C($,2!/5,!

%&9*!#,9!/%9#.!*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!9,+5.,5+(=!,B(!7#DD(+($,!/*7#(92!95.B!%9!,B(![*%+7!*D!

R#+(.,*+92!-C/579C%$2!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&2!%$7!Q5))*+,#$E!-+E%$#F%,#*$92!%9!

?(&&!%9!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(![6&%?9!7(D#$(!,B(!#$,(+D%.(9!%C*$E!,B(9(!/*7#(9G!!

• &'2*"$6'#,%(//6"/=!4$%&6,#.%&&6!7#9,#$.,!D+*C!9,+5.,5+%&!#995(9!%+(!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!

)+*.(75+(9!?#,B#$!%!E#>($!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!D+%C(?*+JG!:995(9!#$!,B#9!.%,(E*+6!#$.&57(!

.*$.(+$9!%/*5,!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!?#,B#$!%!E#>($!9,+5.,5+(!N(GEG2!

.&%+#,62!,#C(&#$(992!*+!)+(7#.,%/#&#,6!*D!7(.#9#*$9O!%$7!?B($!%$7!B*?!#$D*+C%,#*$!D&*?92!

%$7!%,!?B%,!H5%&#,62!/(,?(($!,B(!7#DD(+($,!:;4<<!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!%$7!/*7#(9G!8B(!

#$,(+%.,#*$!/(,?(($!,B(!^4;!%$7!,B(![*%+7!#9!*$(!(U%C)&(!#$!,B#9!.%,(E*+6M!,B(!H5(9,#*$!

*D!N%.,#>(O!7#9.&*95+(!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!*+!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!(U.(),#*$9!%+(!%7C#$#9,(+(7!

#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!7#9.&*95+(!+(H5(9,9!#9!%$*,B(+G!!

• >6I/0#)0(."%(//6"/]%4!,B#+7!.%,(E*+6!*D!#995(9!.*$.(+$9!,B(!95/9,%$.(!*D!:;4<<!%.,#>#,#(9!

%$7!7(.#9#*$9G!86)#.%&&62!95.B!#995(9!.*$.(+$!,B(!*5,.*C(9!%$7!C(+#,9!*D!:;4<<L9!

7(.#9#*$9G!4$!(U%C)&(!#9!,B(!7#9%E+((C($,!%/*5,!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!

(>%&5%,(9!.(+,%#$!+#9J9!N(GEG2!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B(!.5++($,!9,%,(!*D!R<Q!9(.5+#,6OG!

8B(9(!,B+((!.&59,(+9%%+(!%$%&6,#.%&&6!7#9,#$.,!/5,!C%6!#$,(+%.,!?#,B!(%.B!*,B(+!#$!C5&,#)&(!?%69G!

8B(!9,+5.,5+%&!D+%C(?*+J!NB*?!:;4<<!#9!9(,!5)O2!D*+!#$9,%$.(2!9B%)(9!,B(!$((7!D*+!%$7!.B%+%.,(+!

*D!)+*.(75+(92!?B#.B!#$!,5+$!B%>(!%$!#C)*+,%$,!#C)%.,!*$!,B(!*5,.*C(9!*D!7(.#9#*$9G!8B(!.%9(!

9,57#(9!%$7!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!*,B(+!C%,(+#%&9!95EE(9,!,B%,!,B(!,B+((!,6)(9!*D!#995(9!%+(!%&C*9,!

#$(U,+#.%/&6!&#$J(7G!8B(!.+#,#H5(!*D!%!)%+,#.5&%+!7(.#9#*$!/6!,B(!:;4<<![*%+72!D*+!#$9,%$.(2!C%6!

/(!+**,(7!#$!%!7#DD(+($,!,%J(!*$!,B(!95/9,%$.(2!/5,!,B($!(U)+(99(7!/6!?%6!*D!.&%#C9!%/*5,!)+*.(99!

7(D#.#($.#(9!N(GEG2!&%.J!*D!.*$9#7(+%,#*$!*D!)5/&#.!#$)5,O!*+!?#,B!+(D(+($.(!,*!:;4<<L9!D*5$7%,#*$!

N(GEG2!#,9!B6/+#7!$%,5+(OG!!

4&,B*5EB!,B(!.&59,(+9!#$,(+%.,!#$!C5&,#)&(!?%692!#,!#9!#C)*+,%$,!,*!9()%+%,(!,B(C!#$!*+7(+!,*!

#7($,#D62!%$%&6F(2!%$7!%77+(99!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!.B%&&($E(9G!8B#9!+()*+,!D*.59(9!)+#C%+#&6!*$!

)+*.(75+%&!#995(92!%&,B*5EB!#,!%&9*!%77+(99(9!9(&(.,(7!9,+5.,5+%&!#995(9G!Q5/9,%$,#>(!#995(9!%+(!

D&%EE(7!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B(!.%9(!9,57#(9!/5,!(U.&57(7!D+*C!D5+,B(+!%$%&69#9!9#$.(!,B(9(!D%&&!

*5,9#7(!*D!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,G!:,!#9!#C)*+,%$,!,*!$*,(!,B%,!#995(9!#7($,#D#(7!

%.+*99!,B(!,B+((!.&59,(+9!#$.&57(!.*$,(9,(7!#995(9!%9!?(&&!%9!#995(9!*D!)(+.(),#*$G!8*!,B(!(U,($,!

,B%,!95.B!#995(9!B%>(!.+69,%&&#F(7!%$7!%+(!(U)+(99(7!#$!,B(!C%,(+#%&9!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!

+(>#(?(72!,B(6!$((7!,*!/(!%77+(99(7!#$!%))+*)+#%,(!?%692!D*+!(U%C)&(2!/6!/%&%$.#$E!#$D*+C%,#*$!

%96CC(,+#(9!#$!.%9(!*D!SC(+(T!)(+.(),#*$!#995(92!+(E%+7&(99!*D!,B(#+!95/9,%$,#>(!C(+#,9G!!

!

Page 23: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @00A!

C"#+)()0,9&.#-.A#W>)%>9)?#&=#X)1#/22@)2##

X#,B#$!(%.B!.&59,(+2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!9(&(.,(7!%!9(,!*D!J(6!#995(9G!Q5.B!%!+(75.,#*$!*D!

.*C)&(U#,6!+(H5#+(9!H5%&#,%,#>(!Y57EC($,9G!"*+!,B#9!+()*+,2!,B(!.+#,(+#%!D*+!,B(9(!Y57EC($,9!N*+!

SD#&,(+9TO!%+(!7(+#>(7!D+*C!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;G!X#,B!,B(9(!H5%&#,%,#>(!E5#7(&#$(9!#$!C#$72!

,B(!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!%$7!9(&(.,#*$!*D!#995(9!B%9!/(($!#$D*+C(7!/6!,B(!#$,(+>#(?9!.*$75.,(7!/6!,B(!

[(+JC%$!,(%C!%$7!B%9!/(($!9B%)(72!/5,!$*,!7(,(+C#$(72!/6!B(&)D5&!#$,(+%.,#*$9!?#,B!48'8G!

[%9(7!*$!,B(9(!#$,(+%.,#*$92!%$7!&**J#$E!%,!,B(!#995(9!C($,#*$(7!#$!,B(!)+(>#*59!9(.,#*$!,B+*5EB!

,B(!&($9!*D!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;2!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!.&59,(+!C%,+#U!(C(+E(9=!

! ;'/%#'%/(+! ?/$#2-%/(+! ;%)0'(&'*72!

!

./(&01(/2&#,!!

N.+*99I9(.,#*$%&O=!

4*;!kG3!

!

• 8+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,9! • :$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!!

• WU(C),#*$9!!

• :$D*+C%,#*$!7(9#E$!

N%.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6O!

?%)+*#!

?(/'*#*1('*$&C!

#$.&57#$E!)5/&#.!

#$)5,!C(.B%$#9C9!!

N.+*99I9(.,#*$%&O=!

4*;!kG3!%$7!kG3N.O!

!

• :$.*+)*+%,#$E!)5/&#.!

#$)5,!#$,*!:;4<<!

7(.#9#*$9!!!

• <((7!D*+!($B%$.(7!

.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!

7#%&*E5(!

!

• W&#.#,#$E!]5/&#.!:$)5,!

• 4EE+(E%,#$E!%$7!

'(9)*$7#$E!,*!]5/&#.!

:$)5,!

E$(/-!B$72/&(&#2C!

#$.&57#$E!,B(!:']!

%$7!9(&(.,(7!^4;!

%9)(.,9=!

4*;!kG32!kG3N%o/O!

!

• [*%+7!.*C)*9#,#*$!!

• :$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!

*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!!

• 8+%$9)%+($.6!*D![*%+7!

7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!

• [*%+7IQ,%DD!#$,(+%.,#*$!

• R(D#$#,#*$!*D!^4;!

%7>#.(!

• [*%+7I^4;!#$,(+%.,#*$!

!

-P8Q:RW!-"!

Q;-]W!-"!

'Wi:WX!

!

8B(!D*&&*?#$E!9(.,#*$!%77+(99(9!%&&!*D!,B(9(!J(6!#995(92!9,%+,#$E!?#,B!,B(!.+*99I9(.,#*$%&!,B(C%,#.!

%+(%9!%9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!)%+%E+%)B!kG3!*D!,B(!4*;Z,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!N#$.&57#$E!

)5/&#.!#$)5,!C(.B%$#9C9OZD*&&*?(7!/6!C*+(!9)(.#D#.!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*![*%+7!E*>(+$%$.(!%$7!

+*&(!*D!,B(!^4;!%9!9)(.#D#(7!#$!kG3!N%o/O!*D!,B(!4*;G!!

!

Page 24: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0\A!

3[=!W2,!300%20!"&(+,0*0!(&-!R*0#%00*$&!

8B(!(U)&*+%,#*$!*D!,B(!J(6!#995(9!C%))(7!%/*>(!%7*),9!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!9.B(C(=!#$!%!D#+9,!9,()2!(%.B!

.&59,(+!*D!#995(9!#9!)5,!#$,*!.*$,(U,!/6!)+*>#7#$E!9*C(!E($(+%&!.*$9#7(+%,#*$92!?B#.B!C%6!

%77+(99!.*$.(),5%&!H5(9,#*$9!*+!#$,+*75.(!/#EE(+!)#.,5+(!*/9(+>%,#*$9!%$7!7(D#$#,#*$%&!

(&(C($,9G!:$!%!9(.*$7!9,()2!#$7#>#75%&!#995(9!?#,B#$!(%.B!.&59,(+!?#&&!/(!(U)&*+(7!*$(!/6!*$(G!8B(!

(U)&*+%,#*$!9,%+,9!?#,B!%!.*$.#9(!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!,B(!#995(2!95))*+,(7!/6!D%.,5%&!*/9(+>%,#*$9!%$7!

D*&&*?(7!/6!%!7#9.599#*$!9(.,#*$2!?B#.B!D((7!#$,*!.*$.#9(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!

:,!#9!#C)*+,%$,!,*!5$7(+9,%$7!,B%,!,B#9!#995(!%$%&69#9!%$7!7#9.599#*$!#9!,B(!95CC%+6!*D!%!C5.B!

&%+E(+2!#$I7(),B!+(9(%+.B!(DD*+,!?B#.B!#$.&57(9!9(>(+%&!B5$7+(7!)%E(9!*D!.%9(!9,57#(92!.%9(!

(U%C)&(92!C(C*+%$7%2!%!&#,(+%,5+(!+(>#(?2!.B%+,9!*D!)5/&#.!95/C#99#*$92!%$7!C%$6!*,B(+!

7*.5C($,9G!Q*C(!*D!,B(9(!C%,(+#%&9!%+(!#$.&57(7!#$!,B(!4))($7#.(9M!*,B(+9!?#&&!/(!C%7(!

%>%#&%/&(!*$&#$(!#$!,B(!D5,5+(G!

!

5"#F%-.2:-%).01##

!"#S).)%-(#4&.29A)%-,9&.2#

:;4<<q9!B(%>6!+(&#%$.(!*$!,+%$9)%+($.6!D*+!(9,%/&#9B#$E!%$7!C%#$,%#$#$E!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!#9!%$!

#995(!,B%,!.%C(!5)!+()(%,(7&6!#$!*5+!+(9(%+.B!%$7!#$,(+>#(?9!%$7!#9!.($,+%&!,*!%&&!*D!,B(!

*/9(+>%,#*$9!%$7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!#$!,B#9!+()*+,G!8B#9!#9!)%+,#%&&6!%!+(D&(.,#*$!*D!:;4<<q9!

5$595%&!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!9,%$7#$E!%$7!,B(!%99*.#%,(7!&#C#,9!,*!,B(!%))&#.%,#*$!*D!%&,(+$%,#>(!

%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C9G0_!:,!#9!%&9*!%!+(D&(.,#*$!*D!:;4<<q9!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!D#75.#%+6!*/&#E%,#*$9!

%$7!#,9!)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!*+#($,%,#*$!,*!9(+>(!,B(!7(C%$79!%$7!$((79!*D!,B(!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!:$,(+$(,!

.*CC5$#,6G!!

8B#9!+(&#%$.(!*$!,+%$9)%+($.6!%&9*!7(+#>(9!D+*C!,B(!$(.(99#,6!*D!/%&%$.#$E!,B(!$((79!%$7!

#$,(+(9,9!*D!%!7#>(+9(!9(,!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!:;4<<L9!7(.#9#*$92!/6!7(9#E$2!*D,($!7#9)+*)*+,#*$%,(&6!

D%>*+!%$7!7#9D%>*+!7#DD(+($,!9(EC($,9!*D!:;4<<L9!.*$9,#,5($.6G!8B(!#995(!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6I/%9(7!

%..*5$,%/#&#,6!#9!C*9,!9%&#($,!?B($!.*$9#7(+#$E!7#DD#.5&,!7(.#9#*$9!C%7(!%,!,B(![*%+7!&(>(&2!?B#.B!

*D,($!+(H5#+(9!/%&%$.#$E!%!.*C)&(U!9(,!*D!#$.*CC($95+%/&(!D%.,9!%$7!#9!D+(H5($,&6!%..*C)%$#(7!

/6!95/9,%$,#%&!5$.(+,%#$,6G!8B#9!J(6!76$%C#.!#9!#$,+*75.(7!#$!,B#9!9(.,#*$!%$7!.%++#(7!,B+*5EB!,*!

,B(!9(.,#*$9!*$!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!%$7!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(M!7#9,#$.,!/5,!+(&%,(7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!

%+(!*DD(+(7!#$!%&&!,B+((!9(.,#*$9G!

"+*C!%!&*$E(+I,(+C!)(+9)(.,#>(!%$7!/(6*$7!,B(!9)(.#D#.!+(>#(?!D+%C(?*+J!*D!,B(!4*;2!,B(!

[(+JC%$!,(%C!95EE(9,9!?*+J#$E!,*?%+79!%!.*C)+(B($9#>(!.*$.(),!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!E+*5$7(7!#$!

%!,+%$9)%+($.6I!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$I*+#($,(7!C%$%E(C($,!%))+*%.B!,*!#$D*+C%,#*$!%$7!7*.5C($,!

.+(%,#*$2!)+*.(99#$E!%$7!.*CC5$#.%,#*$2!%$7!5&,#C%,(&6!#$,(E+%,#$E!,B(9(!7#DD(+($,!D%.(,9!*D!

,+%$9)%+($.6!#$,*!%!.*C)+(B($9#>(!%7Y59,(7!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!.*$.(),G!!

8+%$9)%+($.6!#9!%!.+*99I9(.,#*$%&!#995(!,B%,!)&%69!%!9)(.#D#.!+*&(!#$!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!%$7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EG!8B(!D*&&*?#$E!9(.,#*$!%77+(99(9!

Page 25: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0_A!

:;4<<L9!,+%$9)%+($.6!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+%.,#.(9G!8B(!)%+,#.5&%+!+(&%,#*$9B#)!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!,*!

)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#9!%77+(99(7!#$!%!&%,,(+!9(.,#*$M!,B(!#$D&5($.(!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!7(.#9#*$!

C%J#$E!#9!,%J($!5)!9()%+%,(&6!#$!,B(!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!9(.,#*$G!!

D"#/22@)N+:)09=90#W'2)%>-,9&.2#-.A#E)0&**).A-,9&.2#

T=V!3&I$/<('*$&!R20*@&!

c(d!300%20!

:;4<<!)5/&#9B(9!%!E+(%,!%C*5$,!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!*$!#,9!?(/9#,(G!;*CC($,9!95EE(9,2!B*?(>(+2!,B%,!

,B#9!#9!$*,!%!95DD#.#($,!%))+*%.B!,*!%.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6G!Q(>(+%&!*/9(+>(+9!B%>(!)*#$,(7!*5,!,B%,!

,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$!%>%#&%/&(!#9!$*,!%&?%69!9,+5.,5+(7!#$!?%69!,B%,!%+(!B(&)D5&!,*!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!%$7!

#$!9*C(!#$9,%$.(9!C%6!(>($!.%59(!S#$D*+C%,#*$!*>(+&*%7GT!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

:;4<<!)+*%.,#>(&6!)5/&#9B(9!.(+,%#$!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!.*$9#7(+(7!,*!/(!*D!J(6!

#C)*+,%$.(!D*+!,B(!:;4<<!)+*.(99!*$!#,9!?(/9#,(G!->(+!01!7#DD(+($,!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!)5/&#.&6!

%>%#&%/&(!#$D*+C%,#*$!%+(!&#9,(7!#$!,B(!R*.5C($,%+6!:$D*+C%,#*$!R#9.&*95+(!]*&#.6!NR:R]OG0`!

:$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!:;4<<!)5/&#9B(9!%$!%>%&%$.B(!*D!7(,%#&9!/5,!D%#&9!,*!C%J(!

#$D*+C%,#*$!)5/&#.!%,!%!B#EB(+!&(>(&2!D*+!(U%C)&(!/6!D%#&#$E!,*!9,%,(!.&(%+&6!#,9!E*%&9!%$7!)+#*+#,#(9!

%$7!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!/(B#$7!C%Y*+![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!:$,(+>#(?((9!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!.&(%+2!+(E5&%+!

)+*E+(99!+()*+,9!9,%,#$E!?B%,!7(.#9#*$9!B%>(!/(($!C%7(!%$7!?B62!?B%,!,B(!5).*C#$E!)+#*+#,#(9!

%+(2!%$7!?B%,!:;4<<!B*)(9!,*!%..*C)&#9B2!?*5&7!B(&)!#C)+*>(!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

:;4<<!B%9!,%J($!%.,#*$!,*!%77+(99!9*C(!*D!,B(!.*CC5$#,6L9!.*$.(+$9G!:$!b5&6!011a2!:;4<<!

%$$*5$.(7!#,!?*5&7!/(!+(>%C)#$E!#,9!?(/9#,(!,*!#$.+(%9(!%..(99#/#&#,6!%$7!/(,,(+!C((,!59(+9L!

$((79G0a!Q(>(+%&!.B%$E(9!B%>(!9#$.(!/(($!#$,+*75.(72!#$.&57#$E!9(%+.B!D5$.,#*$%&#,6!%$7!'QQ!

D((79!%$7!%!+(7(9#E$!*D!,B(!9#,(L9!D+*$,!)%E(G!:$!b5$(!011k2!:;4<<!.*$75.,(7!%!59%/#&#,6!95+>(6!,*!

7(,(+C#$(!?B%,!%77#,#*$%&!.B%$E(9!$((7(7!,*!/(!C%7(G0h!!:$!-.,*/(+!011k2!:;4<<!+(>(%&(7!

)&%$9!D*+!%!D5&&!+(7(9#E$!*$!#,9!/&*E2!#$.&57#$E!9.+(($9B*,92!+(95&,9!D+*C!,B(!95+>(62!%$7!%$!

#$7()($7($,!9#,(!%57#,G0l!!8B#9!+(7(9#E$!B%9!$*,!6(,!/(($!#C)&(C($,(72!/5,!#9!9,#&&!%!)+#*+#,6!#,(C!

*$!,B(!:;4<<!9,%DD!%E($7%2!%..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?((9G!:$!%77#,#*$2!:;4<<!9,%DD!B%>(!

(U)(+#C($,(7!?#,B!%!?#J#!D*+C%,!,B%,!#$.&57(9!S9(%+.B%/&(!?#J#!)%E(9!,*!)+*>#7(!,B(!)5/&#.!?#,B!

(%96I,*I%..(99!#$D*+C%,#*$!*$!(>(+6!95/9,%$,#>(!+(9*&5,#*$!%))+*>(7!/6!,B(![*%+7!*D!

R#+(.,*+9GT0k!!4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?((92!,B#9!)+*.(99!?#&&!9**$!/(!.*C)&(,(7G!8B(!?#J#!.5++($,&6!

)+(9($,9![*%+7!+(9*&5,#*$9!D+*C!011k!/6!.%,(E*+6!N(GEG2!E8VR9!*+!47C#$#9,+%,#*$!m![57E(,O2!

,B*5EB!#,!#9!$*,!(7#,%/&(!*+!#$,(+%.,#>(2!.*$,+%+6!,*!?B%,!*$(!C#EB,!(U)(.,!D+*C!%!?#J#!N,B(!?#J#!

+(D(+($.(9!%$!S477!;*CC($,T!/*U!,B%,!%))(%+9!,*!/(!C#99#$EOG!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

8B(!+(>#(?!*D!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+%.,#.(9!7(C*$9,+%,(9!,B%,!:;4<<L9!%.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%))+*%.B!

B%9!/(($!&%+E(&6!/%9(7!*$!)+*>#7#$E!7*.5C($,9!%9!&#9,9!*D!&#$J9!*$!#,9!?(/9#,(2!?#,B!$%>#E%,#*$!

,**&9!95.B!%9!,*)#.%&!.&59,(+92!J(6?*+792!%$7!9(%+.BG!Q5.B!#$D*+C%,#*$!7(9#E$!.B*#.(9!B%>(!%$!

Page 26: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0`A!

#C)%.,!*$!,+%$9)%+($.6G!8B(!(DD(.,#>(!%..(99#/#&#,6!*D!,B(!C%,(+#%&!,*!,B(!#$,(+(9,(7!)5/&#.!%,!

&%+E(!%9!?(&&!%9!*..%9#*$%&!%$7!$(?!59(+9Z%9!*))*9(7!,*!9)(.#%&#F(7!%$7!(U)(+#($.(7!:;4<<!

)+*D(99#*$%&9Z$((79!#C)+*>(C($,!#$!*+7(+!,*!/(,,(+!)(+D*+C!,B(!>%+#*59!#$D*+C%,#*$!D5$.,#*$9!

#7($,#D#(7!%/*>(G!!

:;4<<!.%$!D5+,B(+!#C)+*>(!#,9!#$D*+C%,#*$!%$7!7*.5C($,!B%$7&#$E!/6!%7*),#$E!)+*.(75+(9!%$7!

/(9,!)+%.,#.(9!D+*C!,B(!)5/&#.!%$7!.*+)*+%,(!9(.,*+9G!"*+!(U%C)&(2!#$.*C#$E!%$7!#$,(+$%&&6!

E($(+%,(7!7*.5C($,9!.*5&7!/(!,%EE(7!,*!7($*,(!,B(#+!&(>(&!*D!)5/&#.!%..(99#/#&#,6!N.&%99#D#.%,#*$OG!

8B(9(!,%E9!?*5&7!,B($!/(!+(E5&%+&6!+(>#(?(7!?#,B#$!,B(!&#D(!.6.&(!*D!(%.B!7*.5C($,G!8B#9!?*5&7!

B(&)!,*!/5#&7!%$!(U)(+#($.(I/%9(7!7#9.&*95+(!)*&#.6!%$7!D%.#&#,%,(!,B(!D&*?!%$7!%..(99#/#&#,6!*D!

#$D*+C%,#*$!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!%.,#>(2!)%99#>(2!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

"5+,B(+C*+(2!:;4<<!?*5&7!/($(D#,!D+*C!%$!5)E+%7(!%$7!+(7(9#E$!*D!#,9!?(/9#,(!#$!%!?%6!,B%,!

,%J(9!#$,*!%..*5$,!%&&!,B(!)+(>#*59&6!7(9.+#/(7!7#C($9#*$9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6G!-,B(+!,**&9!%$7!

7(9#E$!(&(C($,9!C%6!#$.&57(=!7*.5C($,!,%EE#$E!,(.B$#H5(9M!%!.&(%+!#$>($,*+6!*D!7*.5C($,9!

)+*>#7(7!5)*$!:;4<<q9!#$#,#%,#>(M!7*.5C($,9!,B%,!%+(!9,+5.,5+(7!#$!%!59(+ID+#($7&6!C%$$(+M!

.&%+#D6#$E!%$7!/(,,(+!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!,B(!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!+(H5(9,#$E!%$7!*/,%#$#$E!5$)5/&#9B(7!

#$D*+C%,#*$2!95.B!%9!%!D&*?.B%+,I&#J(!7(9.+#),#*$!*D!,B(!.*$7#,#*$9!%$7!)+*.(75+(92!#$.&57#$E!

+(>#(?!)+*.(75+(9M!%!7#%E+%CC%,#.!1")"'#,%$"/*'(+0(2)!*D!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!)+*.(75+(9!+(&%,(7!,*!

7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EM!%$7!%!9)(.#D#.!D&*?!.B%+,!?#,B!%$!5)I,*I7%,(!C%)!*D!,B(!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!

)+*.(75+(9!,B%,!%+(!.5++($,&6!5$7(+?%6G!P)E+%7#$E!,B(!?(/9#,(!#9!$*,!*$&6!%!H5(9,#*$!*D!

%(9,B(,#.9M!#,!#9!%!)+(.*$7#,#*$!,*!(DD(.,#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• :C)+*>(!#$D*+C%,#*$!%$7!7*.5C($,!B%$7&#$E!/6!%7*),#$E!)+*.(75+(9!%$7!/(9,!)+%.,#.(9!

D+*C!,B(!)5/&#.!%$7!.*+)*+%,(!9(.,*+9G!

• '(7(9#E$!:;4<<L9!?(/9#,(!,*!)+*C*,(2!D%.#&#,%,(2!%$7!&(>(+%E(!,B(!%.,#>(2!)%99#>(2!%$7!

)%+,#.#)%,*+6!%9)(.,9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

!

T=T!R3R?!62e%20'0!c*&I$/<('*$&f-$#%<2&'!/2e%20'0!I/$<!34"55!),!

<2<)2/0!$I!'H2!@2&2/(+!1%)+*#d!!

c(d!300%20!

XB#&(!:;4<<L9!,+%$9)%+($.6!D+%C(?*+J!#$.&57(9!,B(!)*99#/#&#,6!,*!+(H5(9,!#$D*+C%,#*$!,B%,!#9!

$*,!C%7(!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(2!,B(!.*$7#,#*$9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!*D!)%99#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%+(!$*,!

.&(%+&6!.*CC5$#.%,(7!,*!,B(!.*CC5$#,6G!"5+,B(+C*+(2!,B(!&#C#,%,#*$9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!,B(!

)+*.(75+(9!D*+!+(>#(?#$E!7(.#9#*$9!,*!7($6!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!C%6!B%>(!%!$(E%,#>(!#C)%.,!*$!

,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

4$6!C(C/(+!*D!,B(!)5/&#.!C%6!+(H5(9,!#$D*+C%,#*$!,B%,!#9!$*,!C%7(!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(!N)%99#>(!

,+%$9)%+($.6OG!8B(9(!+(H5(9,9!%+(!(C/(77(7!#$!%!9)(.#%&!)+*.(75+(!9(,!D*+,B!#$!:;4<<L9!

R*.5C($,%+6!:$D*+C%,#*$!R#9.&*95+(!]*&#.6!NR:R]OG!4..*+7#$E!,*!,B(!R:R]2!:;4<<!#9!$*,!

Page 27: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0aA!

+(H5#+(7!,*!.*C)#&(!#$D*+C%,#*$!95CC%+#(9!*+!+(9)*$7!,*!+(H5(9,9!D*+!#$D*+C%,#*$!,B%,!#9!

%&+(%76!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(G![*,B!,B(!R:R]!%$7!,B(!:;4<<![6&%?9!9,%,(!,B%,!,+%$9&%,#*$9!*D!

7*.5C($,9!C%6!/(!)*99#/&(G\1!

;*C)+(B($9#>(!9,%,#9,#.9!%$7!*,B(+!#$D*+C%,#*$Z%9!)%+,!*D!%!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,Z%/*5,!,B(!

H5%&#,62!D+(H5($.62!%$7!+(9)*$9(9!,*!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!%+(!$*,!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(G!4..*+7#$E!

,*!#$,(+>#(?9!%$7!%!+(>#(?!*D!>%+#*59!C%,(+#%&92!*$&6!%!9C%&&!$5C/(+!*D!<2':#,!R:R]!+(H5(9,9!

B%>(!/(($!D#&(7!9#$.(!,B(!C(.B%$#9C!B%9!/(($!#$,+*75.(72!7(9)#,(!%$(.7*,%&!(>#7($.(!,B%,!

95EE(9,9!%!&%+E(+!$5C/(+!*D!()<2':#,!+(H5(9,9!D*+!C*+(!#$D*+C%,#*$G!:,!C#EB,!%&9*!95EE(9,!,B%,!

,B(!.5++($,!C(.B%$#9C!D*+!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!,B(!%>%#&%/#&#,6!*D!,B#9!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,!D%.#&#,6!#9!

#$95DD#.#($,G!8B(!+(9)*$9(9!,*!95.B!+(H5(9,9!%+(!C%7(!%>%#&%/&(!*$!:;4<<L9!?(/9#,(M!*D!3\!D*+C%&!

+(H5(9,9!,B%,!B%>(!+(.(#>(7!+(9)*$9(92!h!B%>(!/(($!D5&&6!*+!)%+,#%&&6!7($#(7!/%9(7!*$!>%+#*59!

(U(C),#*$9!&#9,(7!#$!,B(!R:R]G\3!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

4!+(>#(?!*D!:;4<<L9!)%99#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!)*&#.#(9!#7($,#D#(9!,?*!C%#$!)+*/&(C!%+(%9!,B%,!

7(9(+>(!D5+,B(+!#$>(9,#E%,#*$G!"#+9,2!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(!.*$7#,#*$9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!*D!)%99#>(!

,+%$9)%+($.6!%+(!.*CC5$#.%,(7M!%$7!9(.*$72!,B(!&#C#,%,#*$9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!,B(!+(>#(?!)+*.(75+(9!

D*+!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!,B%,!%+(!$*,!%))+*>(7G!!

:$!)%+,#.5&%+2!:;4<<L9!?(/9#,(!7*(9!$*,!)+*>#7(!.&(%+!#$D*+C%,#*$!*$!,B#9!%&,(+$%,#>(!C(,B*7!*D!

*/,%#$#$E!#$D*+C%,#*$!D+*C!:;4<<G!4!.&(%+!7(9.+#),#*$!*D!,B(!.*$7#,#*$9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!,*!

%..(99!#$D*+C%,#*$!,B%,!:;4<<!B%9!$*,!*,B(+?#9(!)5/&#9B(7!*+!C%7(!%>%#&%/&(!?*5&7!C%J(!%$!

#C)*+,%$,!.*$,+#/5,#*$!,*!)%99#>(!,+%$9)%+($.6G!'(E%+7#$E!,B(!9(.*$7!%9)(.,2!#D!%!)5/&#.!+(H5(9,!

D*+!#$D*+C%,#*$!#9!+(D59(7!/6!:;4<<2!,B(!R:R]!9,%,(9!,B%,!%!+(H5(9,*+!C%6!%))(%&!,B(!7($#%&!

,B+*5EB!,B(!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,!)+*.(75+(9!*+!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!)+*.(75+(9!02%0D"%

"50")0%#++,(*#I,"G!K*?(>(+2!.*$,+%+6!,*!)5/&#.I9(.,*+!)+%.,#.(9!?B(+(!,B(!C(+(!+(D59%&!*D!%..(99!

#9!95DD#.#($,!,*!+(H5(9,!%!+(>#(?!/6!(#,B(+!%!.*5+,!*+!%$*,B(+!C(.B%$#9C2!/*,B!,B(!

'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,!%$7!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!%))(%&!)+*.(75+(9!%+(!*$&6!%>%#&%/&(!,*!

)(+9*$9!?B*!B%>(!/(($!SC%,(+#%&&6!%DD(.,(7T!/6!%$!%7>(+9(!7(.#9#*$G!N8B#9!+(D(+($.(!&(%79!,*!%!

)+*/&(C!#$!#$,(+)+(,#$E!?B%,!#9!C(%$,!/6!SC%,(+#%&&6!%DD(.,(72T!(9)(.#%&&6!#$!,B(!&#EB,!*D!4+,#.&(!:i!

Q(.,#*$!0G3!*D!,B(![6&%?9!>(+959!Q(.,#*$!0G02!?B#.B!9,%,(9!C*+(!E($(+%&&6!,B%,!,B*9(!?B*!SB%>(!

/(($!%7>(+9(&6!%DD(.,(7!/6T!%$!:;4<<!%.,#*$!*+!#$%.,#*$!C%6!+(H5(9,!%!+(>#(?GO!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• ]+*>#7(!.&(%+!%$7!(%9#&6!%..(99#/&(!#$D*+C%,#*$!%/*5,!,B(!,(+C9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!,*!

*/,%#$!#$D*+C%,#*$!D+*C!:;4<<!,B%,!B%9!$*,!%&+(%76!/(($!C%7(!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(G!!

• R(>(&*)!&(99!+(9,+#.,#>(!%$7!C*+(!#$7()($7($,!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!.%9(9!

?B(+(!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!%+(!+(D59(7G!

Page 28: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0hA!

T=\!9:2<1'*$&0!

c(d!300%20!

:;4<<L9!,+%$9)%+($.6!.*CC#,C($,!#9!95/Y(.,!,*!%!9#E$#D#.%$,!9(,!*D!(U(C),#*$9!,B%,!%))&6!,*!

%.,#>(2!)%99#>(2!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!,+%$9)%+($.6G!R5(!,*!,B(!&%.J!*D!%!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,2!#,!#9!

7#DD#.5&,!,*!%99(99!,B(!59(!*D!,B(!(U(C),#*$9G!K*?(>(+2!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!,B(!(U(C),#*$!)*&#.#(9!&(%79!

,*!9(>(+%&!.*$.(+$92!#$.&57#$E!.*$.(+$9!+(&%,(7!,*!9)(.#D#.!(U(C),#*$9!%$7!,B(!/+*%7$(99!*D!%!

S.%,.BI%&&T!,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!9(,!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$9!#9!&#9,(7!#$!,B(!R:R]!5$7(+!,B(!,#,&(!SR(D#$(7!;*$7#,#*$9!D*+!

<*$IR#9.&*95+(GT!4..*+7#$E!,*!,B(9(!+5&(9!,B(+(!#9!$*!*+!*$&6!&#C#,(7!,+%$9)%+($.6!?B(+(!:;4<<!

B%9!S#7($,#D#(7!G!G!G!.*$7#,#*$9!D*+!,B(!$*$7#9.&*95+(!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$GT\0!Q5.B!.*$7#,#*$9!.*C)+#9(!

%/*5,!%!7*F($!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$2!#$.&57#$E!#$D*+C%,#*$!,B%,!B%9!/(($!(U.B%$E(7!?#,B!

E*>(+$C($,9!*+!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!5$7(+!,B(!(U)(.,%,#*$!*D!.*$D#7($,#%&#,6M!#$,(+$%&!

#$D*+C%,#*$!%$7!#$D*+C%,#*$!(U.B%$E(7!?#,B!($,#,#(9!?#,B!?B#.B!:;4<<!#9!.**)(+%,#$E!,B%,!

?*5&7!.*C)+*C#9(!*+!?*5&7!/(!&#J(&6!,*!.*C)+*C#9(!:;4<<L9!#$,(+$%&!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!

)+*.(75+(9M!.*$D#7($,#%&!/59#$(99!#$D*+C%,#*$!%$7p*+!#$,(+$%&!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9M!%$7!

7+%D,9G!

:;4<<!C%6!*>(++#7(!,B(9(!(U(C),#*$9!S5$7(+!,B(!)%+,#.5&%+!.#+.5C9,%$.(9!t#$!?B#.Bu!,B(!)5/&#.!

#$,(+(9,!#$!7#9.&*9#$E!,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$!*5,?(#EB9!,B(!B%+C!,B%,!C%6!/(!.%59(7!/6!95.B!

7#9.&*95+(GT\\!"*+!%+(%9!*5,9#7(!,B(!(U(C),#*$9!&#9,(7!#$!,B(!%/*>(IC($,#*$(7!7*.5C($,2!:;4<<!

#$9,%&&9!%$!%77#,#*$%&!S.%,.BI%&&T!(U(C),#*$=!S:;4<<!+(9(+>(9!,B(!+#EB,!,*!7($6!7#9.&*95+(!*D!

#$D*+C%,#*$!5$7(+!.*$7#,#*$9!$*,!7(9#E$%,(7!%/*>(!#D!:;4<<!7(,(+C#$(9!,B%,!,B(!B%+C!#$!

7#9.&*9#$E!,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$!*5,?(#EB9!,B(!)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!#$!7#9.&*9#$E!,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$GT\_!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

4&,B*5EB!:;4<<L9!B6/+#7!*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!9,+5.,5+(!7#DD(+($,#%,(9!#,!D+*C!)5/&#.!($,#,#(92!:;4<<L9!

)+%.,#.(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!7(.#7#$E!?B#.B!#$D*+C%,#*$!,*!%.,#>(&6!9B%+(!?#,B!,B(!)5/&#.!*+!D*+!

7($6#$E!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(H5(9,9!.%$!9,#&&!/(!.*C)%+(7!,*!*,B(+!,+%$9)%+($.6!+(E#C(92!#$.&57#$E!%!

9(,!*D!+()+(9($,%,#>(!D+((7*C!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!&%?9G!8B#9!#9!$*,!C(%$,!,*!#C)&6!,B%,!95.B!&%?9!

%))&6!#$!,B(!9%C(!&(E%&!C%$$(+!%9!,B(6!?*5&7!%))&6!,*!)5/&#.!*+!E*>(+$C($,%&!($,#,#(9G!'%,B(+2!

:;4<<2!,B(!^4;2!%$7!(U,(+$%&!*/9(+>(+9!B%>(!%E+((7!,B%,!,B(!)5/&#.!9(.,*+!)+*>#7(9!%!59(D5&!

C*7(&%D*+!(>%&5%,#$E!:;4<<L9!#$D*+C%,#*$!)*&#.#(9B!4$!#$I7(),B!.*C)%+#9*$!*D!:;4<<L9!

,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$9!?#,B!%!9(,!*D!9(&(.,(7!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!D+((7*C!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(E#C(9!

&(%79!,*!,B(!.*$.&59#*$!,B%,!:;4<<L9!&#9,!*D!(U(C),#*$9!#9!D%#+&6!.*C)+(B($9#>(2!?B#&(!(%.B!*D!,B(!

(U(C),#*$9!#9!7(9.+#/(7!#$!+%,B(+!E($(+%&!,(+C9G!8B#9!*/9(+>%,#*$!)%+,#.5&%+&6!%))&#(9!,*!

(U(C),#*$9!)+*,(.,#$E!7+%D,9!%$7!#$,(+$%&!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!

Q*C(!*D!:;4<<L9!(U(C),#*$9!9,%$7!*5,!%9!9#$E5&%+!#$!,B(#+!/+*%7$(992!95.B!%9!)+*,(.,#$E!#$,(+$%&!

)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(92!,B(!(U.&59#*$!*D!D+#>*&*59!59(2!%$7!D#$%$.#%&!#$D*+C%,#*$!$*,!)5/&#.&6!

7#9.&*9(72!%$7!9((C!,*!/(!7+#>($!/6!%!7(D($9#>(!%))+*%.B!,*?%+79!,+%$9)%+($.6G!4,!&(%9,!9*C(!*D!

,B(9(!(U(C),#*$92!#$!)%+,#.5&%+!,B(!)+*,(.,#*$!*D!#$,(+$%&!7(&#/(+%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!%$7!,B(!+*&(!*D!

Page 29: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0lA!

7+%D,92!9B*5&7!/(!$%++*?(7!#$!*+7(+!,*!9,+($E,B($!:;4<<L9!,+%$9)%+($.62!(9)(.#%&&6!?B(+(!

7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!#9!.*$.(+$(7G!!

8B(!*>(+%&&!S)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!*>(++#7(2T!?B#.B!#9!#,9(&D!H5#,(!E($(+%&2!C%6!)+*>#7(!%$!*))*+,5$#,6!

,*!.*5$,(+/%&%$.(!,B(!/+*%7$(99!*D!,B(!(U(C),#*$92!#D!59(7!)+*)(+&6G!8B(+(!#9!$*!#$D*+C%,#*$!,*!

(>%&5%,(!,B(!59(!*D!,B#9!*>(++#7(!75(!,*!,B(!&%.J!*D!%!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,G!8B(!SB%+C9!,(9,T!

*>(++#7(2!B*?(>(+2!?#,B!?B#.B!:;4<<!E#>(9!#,9(&D!%5,B*+#,6!,*!?#,BB*&7!#$D*+C%,#*$!(>($!?B($!

$*$(!*D!,B(!(U(C),#*$9!%))&62!C%6!*/>#%,(!,B(!)5+)*9(!*D!D*+C5&%,#$E!(U(C),#*$!)*&#.#(9!

%&,*E(,B(+G!!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&!

• <%++*?!,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$9!+(E%+7#$E!#$,(+$%&!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9!%$7!

7+%D,9G!W&#C#$%,(!,B(!.%,.BI%&&!,+%$9)%+($.6!(U(C),#*$!#$!,B(!R:R]G!!

!

T=`!./(&01(/2&#,!"%-*'!

c(d!300%20!

8B(!&%.J!*D!%!.*C)+(B($9#>(!%57#,!*D!:;4<<L9!#$D*+C%,#*$!%.,#>#,#(9!C%J(9!#,!7#DD#.5&,!,*!%99(99!

#,9!)+%.,#.(9!%.+*99!%.,#>(2!)%99#>(2!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!,+%$9)%+($.6G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!011h!-$(!X*+&7!8+59,!+(>#(?!7(9.+#/(9!%$!:;4<<!#$#,#%,#>(!S,*!.*$75.,!%$!%$$5%&!%57#,!*D!

9,%$7%+79!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!,+%$9)%+($.62!#$.&57#$E!%$!%57#,!*D!,B(!.*CC#,C($,9!C%7(!#$!

,B(9(!e%$%E(C($,!-)(+%,#$E!]+#$.#)&(9!G!G!G!/6!%$!(U,(+$%&!)%+,6T!?#,B!,B(!+(95&,9!*D!,B(!%57#,!

S)5/&#9B(7!#$!,B(!4$$5%&!'()*+,GT\`!8B(!&%9,!%$$5%&!+()*+,!7*(9!$*,!.*$,%#$!95.B!%$!%57#,G!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

:;4<<!.5++($,&6!&%.J9!%$!5)I,*I7%,(2!)5/&#.&6!%>%#&%/&(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,G!8B#9!C%J(9!#,!7#DD#.5&,!

,*!C%J(!95/9,%$,#>(!%99(99C($,9!*D!:;4<<L9!)+%.,#.(9!%9!,B(6!+(&%,(!,*!%.,#>(2!)%99#>(2!%$7!

)%+,#.#)%,*+6!,+%$9)%+($.6G!8B(!&%.J!*D!(C)#+#.%&!C%,(+#%&!N(GEG2!*$!,B(!,#C(!7(&%69!#$!,B(!

)5/&#.%,#*$!*D!7*.5C($,9O!.5++($,&6!D*+.(9!+(>#(?(+9!,*!&**J!D*+!.*$.(),5%&2!9,+5.,5+%&2!%$7!

)+*.(75+%&!7(D#.#($.#(9!#$!*+7(+!,*!#7($,#D6!#D2!?B(+(2!%$7!B*?!,B(+(!%+(!#$.*$9#9,($.#(9!/(,?(($!

E5#7#$E!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+%.,#.(9G!4!.*C)+(B($9#>(!%57#,2!#$!.*$,+%9,2!?*5&7!%&&*?!D*+!)(+#*7#.2!

D%.,9I/%9(72!#$,(+$%&!%$7!(U,(+$%&!+(>#(?#$E!%$7!/($.BC%+J#$EM!:;4<<!.*5&7!E+(%,&6!/($(D#,!

D+*C!,B#9!?B($!D5+,B(+!#C)+*>#$E!#,9!#$D*+C%,#*$!)*&#.#(9G!!

Q5.B!%!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,!$((79!,*!/(!E*>(+$(7!/6!.&(%+!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+*.(99(92!?B#.B!9(,!D*+,B!

,B(!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!)(+,#$($,!,*!95.B!%$!%57#,2!%C*$E!*,B(+!,B#$E9G!"*&&*?#$E!%$!(%+&#(+!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$!/6!,B(!-$(!X*+&7!8+59,!+(>#(?2!,B(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,!9B*5&7!/(!)5/&#9B(7!#$!

,B(!4$$5%&!'()*+,G!:$!%77#,#*$2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!95EE(9,9!,B%,!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!7%,%!/(!+(&(%9(7!

%9!)%+,!*D!,B(!R%9B/*%+7p:;4<<!](+D*+C%$.(!e(,+#.9G\a!!

Page 30: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @0kA!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&!

• ;+(%,(!%$7!#C)&(C($,!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+*.(99(9!D*+!.*$75.,#$E!%$7!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!+(E5&%+!

,+%$9)%+($.6!%57#,9G!

G"#$@'(90#$-%,909:-,9&.#

!"#S).)%-(#4&.29A)%-,9&.2#

]5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#9!.($,+%&!,*!:;4<<L9!#7($,#,6G!8B(!)%+,#.#)%,*+6!(,B*9!*D!,B(!(%+&6!:$,(+$(,2!

(U(C)&#D#(7!/6!7(C*.+%,#.!%$7!.*$9($959I7+#>($!,(.B$#.%&!/*7#(92!#9!(C/(77(7!#$!:;4<<L9!R<42!

D+*C!#,9!*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!(%+&6!B#9,*+6!,*!#,9!9,%,(7!)+#$.#)&(9G!\h!4$!%C/#,#*59!

S(U)(+#C($,!#$!7(C*.+%,#.!E*>(+$%$.(!*$!%!E&*/%&!9.%&(2T!:;4<<!9((J9!,*!#$.&57(!,B(!)5/&#.Z,B(!

E&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!59(+!.*CC5$#,62!,B(!)+#>%,(!9(.,*+2!E*>(+$C($,92!%$7!*,B(+!9,%J(B*&7(+9Z#$!#,9!

7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9GT\l!!

:;4<<L9!.*CC#,C($,!,*!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#9!.&(%+&6!9,%,(7!#$!#,9![6&%?9=!,B(!D*5+,B!*D!#,9!.*+(!

>%&5(9!#9!S9((J#$E!%$7!95))*+,#$E!/+*%72!#$D*+C(7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!+(D&(.,#$E!,B(!D5$.,#*$%&2!

E(*E+%)B#.2!%$7!.5&,5+%&!7#>(+9#,6!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,!%,!%&&!&(>(&9!*D!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!%$7!7(.#9#*$!

C%J#$EGT\k!4+,#.&(!:::!+(H5#+(9!:;4<<!,*!)+*>#7(!$*,#.(!%$7!%&&*?!D*+!)5/&#.!.*CC($,!*$!%$6!

)*&#.#(9!5$7(+![*%+7!.*$9#7(+%,#*$!S,B%,!95/9,%$,#%&&6!%DD(.,!,B(!*)(+%,#*$!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,!*+!

,B#+7!)%+,#(92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!#C)*9#,#*$!*D!%$6!D((9!*+!.B%+E(9GT_1!8B(9(!/%9#.!.*CC#,C($,9!%+(!

#C)&(C($,(7!%$7!D5+,B(+!9)(.#D#(7!#$!:;4<<L9!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!"+%C(?*+J!m!

]+#$.#)&(9_3!%$7!R*.5C($,!]5/&#.%,#*$!-)(+%,#*$%&!]*&#.6G_0!!!

:$!,B(!4*;2!:;4<<!B%9!.*CC#,,(7!,*!SC%#$,%#$!%$7!#C)+*>(!+*/59,!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,!G!

G!G!,*!($95+(!,B%,!,B(!*5,.*C(9!*D!#,9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99!?#&&!+(D&(.,!,B(!)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!%$7!

/(!%..*5$,%/&(!,*!%&&!9,%J(B*&7(+9GT_\!:$!+(.($,!6(%+92!:;4<<!B%9!(C/%+J(7!*$!%!$5C/(+!*D!

)+*Y(.,9!%$7!#$#,#%,#>(9!%#C(7!%,!#C)+*>#$E!+(&(>%$,!*))*+,5$#,#(9!%$7!C(.B%$#9C9G!8B(!

D*&&*?#$E!%.,#*$92!%C*$E!*,B(+92!%+(!$*,(?*+,B6=!

• :;4<<L9!S<(?![6&%?92T!%))+*>(7!*$!R(.(C/(+!3`2!01102!#$,+*75.(7!%!9,%DD!)*9#,#*$!

+(9)*$9#/&(!D*+!S.**+7#$%,#$E!,B(!>%+#*59!%9)(.,9!*D!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!:;4<<2!

#$.&57#$E!,B(!?(/9#,(!%$7!>%+#*59!*,B(+!C(%$9!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!?#,B!%$7!+(.(#>#$E!

#$)5,!D+*C!,B(!E($(+%&!.*CC5$#,6!*D!:$,(+$(,!59(+9GT__!

• 8B(![*%+7!]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!;*CC#,,((2!.+(%,(7!#$!<*>(C/(+!011l2!($9B+#$(9!

:;4<<L9!.*CC#,C($,!,*!(DD(.,#>(!)5/&#.!#$)5,!%,!,B(![*%+7!&(>(&G!:$!0131!#,!.*$,+#/5,(7!

,*!,B(!7(>(&*)C($,!*D!%!C*+(!9,%$7%+7#F(7!%))+*%.B!,*!+(C*,(!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!,B(!

:;4<<!C((,#$E!#$!<%#+*/#_`!%$7!B(&7!,?*!*$&#$(!#$D*+C%,#*$!9(99#*$9!*$!:;4<<L9!)&%$9!

D*+!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!8B(!.*CC#,,((L9!$(U,!E*%&9!%&*$E!9#C#&%+!&#$(9!%+(!*5,&#$(7!#$!#,9!

)&%$!D*+!0131o0133G_a!

• 4$*,B(+!*$E*#$E!)+*.(99!#$.&57(9!,B(!?*+J!*D!,B(!]*&#.6!R(>(&*)C($,!]+*.(99!X*+J!

8(%C!N]R]IX8O2!#$#,#%,(7!#$!011l!%9!)%+,!*D!,B(!^<Q-!:C)+*>(C($,9!)+*.(99G!8B(!

,(%CL9!:$#,#%&!'()*+,2!)5/&#9B(7!#$!e%6!01312!.*$,%#$9!)+*)*9%&9!+(E%+7#$E!*)(+%,#$E!

)+#$.#)&(92!+5&(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!%!$(?!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!)+*.(99G!8B(!%$,#.#)%,(7!

Page 31: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\1A!

$(U,!9,()!D*+!,B(!]R]IX8!?#&&!D*.59!*$!%$!#C)&(C($,%,#*$!%$7!,+%$9#,#*$!)&%$!D*+!,B(#+!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!

• 4&9*!?#,B#$!,B(!^<Q-2!,B(!;*CC5$#.%,#*$!%$7!;**+7#$%,#*$!8(%C!N;;8OZ.B%+,(+(7!#$!

e%+.B!011kZ#9!,%9J(7!?#,B!#C)+*>#$E!,B(!^<Q-L9!?(/9#,(!%$7!#,9!%/#&#,6!,*!9*&#.#,!

C(%$#$ED5&!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!%C*$E!*,B(+!,B#$E9G_h!:$!b5$(!01312!,B(!^<Q-!;*5$.#&!%))+*>(7!

,B(!;;8L9!D#$%&!+()*+,!%$7!7#+(.,(7!^<Q-!9,%DD!,*!/(E#$!#C)&(C($,#$E!#,9!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G_l!

R(9)#,(!,B(9(!C%+J(7!%$7!E($(+%&&6!%.J$*?&(7E(7!)+*.(99!%7>%$.(92!B*?(>(+2!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!

9.B*&%+9!%&#J(!95EE(9,!,B%,!,B(!)+%.,#.%&!#C)%.,!*D!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!*$!%.,5%&![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!

+(C%#$9!&#C#,(7G!XB#&(!:;4<<!E(,9!B#EB!C%+J9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!*>(+%&&!,+%Y(.,*+6!*D!#,9!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(92!#$.+(%9(7!>#9#/#&#,6!%$7!,+%.(%/#&#,6!*D!%$!#$7#>#75%&!#$)5,!D+*C!S($7!,*!

($7T!ND+*C!#$#,#%&!#$)5,!,*!+(&(>%$,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!*+!:;4<<!%.,#>#,6O!C%6!B(&)!,*!.*$D+*$,!

)(+>%9#>(!)(+.(),#*$9!*D!$*,!%.,5%&&6!S/(#$E!B(%+7GT!W%+&6!($E%E(C($,!?#,B!+(&(>%$,!

.*$9,#,5($.#(9!%$7!.&(%+(+!,#C(&#$(9!D*+!#$)5,9!C%6!%&9*!D%.#&#,%,(!,B#9!)+*.(99G!!

;*$,#$5(7!(U)(+#C($,%,#*$!?#,B!$(?!C(,B*79!%$7!.B%$$(&9!D*+!9*&#.#,#$E2!95CC%+#F#$E!%$7!

+(D&(.,#$E!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!.%$!%&9*!)+(9($,!$(?!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!/+*%7(+!%$7!C*+(!(DD#.#($,!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9G!:;4<<q9!59(!*D!%!95+>(6!,**&!%9!)%+,!*D!#,9!.*$95&,%,#*$!)+*.(99!D*+!,B(!

7(>(&*)C($,!*D!#,9!b5&6!0131ob5$(!013\!Q,+%,(E#.!]&%$!#9!%!)%+,#.5&%+&6!9%&#($,!(U%C)&(2!%9!#9!,B(!

,+#%&!%))+*%.B!,*!#$)5,9!#$,*!,B(!R+%D,!4))&#.%$,!^5#7(/**JG_k!WC(+E#$E!C*7(&9!D+*C!*,B(+!

*+E%$#F%,#*$92!95.B!%9!,B(!WP!'5&(C%J#$E!%$7!X#J#C(7#%!-)($!Q,+%,(E#.!]&%$$#$E2!C%6!%&9*!

)+*>#7(!59(D5&!%$%&*E9!,*!7+%?!5)*$G`1!-)($!#$$*>%,#*$!&#,(+%,5+(!%$7!)+#$.#)&(9!%&9*!)+*>#7(!

59(D5&!D+%C(?*+J9M!?B#&(!,B(+(!%+(!/*,B!/($(D#,9!%$7!,+%7(I*DD9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!)5/&#.!

)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!(DD(.,#>(!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+%.,#.(9!.%$!.*$D(+!&(E#,#C%.6!*$!%$7!95))*+,!D*+!7(.#9#*$I

C%J#$E!)+*.(99(9!%$7!+(95&,92!#D!)%+,#.#)%$,9!D((&!,B(6!B%>(!/(($!D%#+&6!B(%+7G`3!!!!

e%$6!*D!*5+!J(6!D#$7#$E9!D+*C!/*,B!,B(!.%9(!9,57#(9!%$7!,B(!#$,(+>#(?9!D*.59!*$!7#+(.,!

C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!.*CC5$#,6!+()+(9($,%,#*$2!95.B!%9!#$)5,!,*!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!%$7!)5/&#.!D*+5C9G!

K*?(>(+2!,B(9(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%&9*!B%>(!+(&(>%$.(!D*+!S#$7#+(.,!+()+(9($,%,#*$TZ%$!

#$7#>#75%&L9!#$)5,!>#%!,B(!>%+#*59!95))*+,#$E!%$7!%7>#9*+6!/*7#(9Z%$7!#$!)%+,#.5&%+2!,B+*5EB!

9,%J(B*&7(+!E+*5)9!#$!,B(!^<Q-!;*5$.#&G!"#$7#$E9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!>#9#/#&#,6!%$7!,+%.(%/#&#,6!*D!%$!

#$7#>#75%&!#$)5,!C59,!%&9*!%))&6!,*!,B(9(!.B%$$(&9G!

4E%#$9,!,B#9!/%.J7+*)2!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!#995(9!%$%&69#9!D*.59(9!&%+E(&6!*$!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!

,(+C9!*D!#$7#>#75%&9!%$7!($,#,#(9!)+*>#7#$E!.*CC($,92!?#,B!%!9C%&&(+!D*.59!*$!+()+(9($,%,#*$!/62!

*+!7#+(.,!#$>*&>(C($,!#$2!>%+#*59!95))*+,#$E!*+E%$#F%,#*$!%$7!%7>#9*+6!.*CC#,,((!%.,#>#,#(9G!8B(!

[(+JC%$!,(%CL9!%$%&69#9!.($,(+9!*$!,B(!)+#C%+6!9,()9!,B%,!.B%$$(&!%$!#$7#>#75%&L9!.*$,+#/5,#*$=!

3O!(&#.#,#$E!#$)5,M!0O!%EE+(E%,#$E!%$7!+(9)*$7#$E!,*!#,M!%$7!\O!#$.*+)*+%,#$E!#,!#$,*![*%+7!

7(.#9#*$9G!:$!,B(!D#$%&!+(.*CC($7%,#*$2!?(!D*.59!*$!(%+&6!($E%E(C($,!?#,B!>%+#*59!

.*$9,#,5($.#(9!>#%!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(G!

Page 32: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\3A!

D"#/22@)N+:)09=90#W'2)%>-,9&.2#-.A#E)0&**).A-,9&.2#

T=V!9+*#*'*&@!?%)+*#!3&1%'!

c(d!300%20!

:995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!>*&5C(2!9,+5.,5+(2!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!:;4<<L9!D*+5C9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,!.%$!/(!%!

/%++#(+!,*!(DD(.,#>(!%$7!C(%$#$ED5&!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!V%.J!*D!.*$9#9,($.6!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!%..(99#/#&#,6!

N#$!/*,B!&%$E5%E(!%$7!.&%+#,6O!%$7!9,+5.,5+(!N(%9(!*D!$%>#E%,#*$O!*D!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!C(.B%$#9C9!

.%$!%&9*!)+(>($,!)5/&#.!#$)5,G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

49!$*,(7!%/*>(2!:;4<<!B%9!C%7(!%!$5C/(+!*D!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!,B(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!#,!*DD(+9!D*+!

)5/&#.!#$)5,G!:$,(+>#(?((9!#$7#.%,(7!,B%,!,B(!$(?!E8VR!)+*.(99!B%9!/(($!9#E$#D#.%$,&6!C*+(!

.*$95&,%,#>(!,B%$!)+(>#*59!:;4<<!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9G!:;4<<!B%9!%&9*!/(E5$!*DD(+#$E!7#9,%$.(!

&(%+$#$E!+(E%+7#$E!J(6!:;4<<!)*&#.6!#$#,#%,#>(9M!#,9!D(&&*?9!)+*E+%C!#9!%!$*,(7!*5,+(%.B!)+#*+#,6!

*D!,B(!;W-G`0!;*$9#7(+%/&(!)+*E+(99!B%9!/(($!C%7(!,*!#C)+*>(!+(C*,(!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!*),#*$9!D*+!

/*,B!)5/&#.!D*+5C9!%$7!*,B(+!C((,#$E9!>#%!.B%,!+**C9!%$7!&#>(!%57#*!D((79G`\!! !

R(9)#,(!,B(9(!%7>%$.(92!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!:;4<<L9!)5/&#.!C((,#$E9!%+(!&(99!

#$.&59#>(!,B%$!,B(6!9B*5&7!/(Z&*.%,#*$9!%+(!%$$*5$.(7!,**!&%,(!,*!%&&*?!%,,($7((9!%$7!

*+E%$#F(+9!,*!)&%$!%B(%72!%$7!)%+,#.#)%$,9!*)(+%,(!#$!S9#&*9T!?#,B*5,!95DD#.#($,!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!

7#9.599#*$G!:$,(+>#(?((9!%&9*!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!:;4<<!7*(9!$*,!%&&*?!D*+!S.%95%&!

#$>*&>(C($,T=!,B*9(!?B*!C%6!/(!#$,(+(9,(7!#$!*$(!%9)(.,!*D!:;4<<!/5,!%+(!5$%/&(!,*!.*CC#,!

95/9,%$,#%&!%C*5$,9!*D!,#C(!,*!,B(!)+*.(99!C%6!/(!,**!*>(+?B(&C(7!/6!,B(!.*C)&(U#,6!*D!

:;4<<L9!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!,*!E(,!#$>*&>(7G!:$!+(D&(.,#$E!*$!B#9!

,(+C!%9!:;4<<L9!^($(+%&!e%$%E(+!*D!]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$2!d#(+($!e.;%+,B6!$*,(7!*$!B#9!/&*E!,B%,!

B(!?#9B(7!B(!B%7!+(.*CC($7(7!,B%,!:;4<<!7(>(&*)!S%!+%$E(!*D!9#C)&(+!#$)5,!C(.B%$#9C9Z

95.B!%9!)*&&9Z,B%,!%+(!$*,!+(&#%$,!*$!)(*)&(!+(%7#$E!?B*&(!+()*+,9!%$7!+(9)*$7#$E!,*!9)(.#D#.!

?*+7#$ET!#$!*+7(+!,*!($.*5+%E(!#$.+(%9(7!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G`_!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

477#,#*$%&!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!)+*.(99(9!C59,!D*.59!*$!&*?(+#$E!,B(!/%++#(+9!

D*+!.*$9,+5.,#>(!.*$,+#/5,#*$9!,*!:;4<<G!;*$.(+$9!+(E%+7#$E!,#C#$E!*D!.*CC($,!D*+5C92!,B(!

$5C/(+!*D!95/9,%$,#>(!#995(9!,B%,!%+(!)*9,(7!9#C5&,%$(*59&62!%$7!B*?!?#7(&6!,B(9(!D*+5C9!%+(!

)5/&#.#F(7!%C*$E!7#>(+9(!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!C%6!/(!%77+(99(7!/6!(9,%/&#9B#$E!9,%$7%+79!D*+!

,#C#$E2!9,+5.,5+(2!%$7!*5,+(%.BG!8B(9(!$((7!$*,!/(!(UB%59,#>(G!'%,B(+2!,B(6!?*5&7!)+(9($,!9*C(!

9($9(!*D!%!.*$9#9,($,!/%9(&#$(!N*>(+%+.B#$E!,#C(D+%C(!D*+!,B(!)+*.(99M!.B%$$(&9!*D!7#9,+#/5,#*$M!

)+*,*.*&9!D*+!.*CC($,!95CC%+#F%,#*$M!%>%#&%/#&#,6!*D!,+%$9&%,#*$9O!%$7!9*C(!C($5!*D!*),#*$9!

N(GEG2!)*99#/&(!,**&92!)(+B%)9!,%#&*+(7!,*!,B(!,6)(!%$7!5+E($.6!*D!,B(!7(.#9#*$OG!8B(!.*$7#,#*$9!*+!

7#DD(+($,!.%,(E*+#(9!*D!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9!,B%,!C#EB,!?%++%$,!)5/&#.!#$)5,!C#EB,!%&9*!/(!

7#DD(+($,#%,(7G``!

XB#&(!:;4<<!9,%DD!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(6!%+(!#$>(9,#E%,#$E!#$$*>%,#>(!$(?!,**&9!D*+!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!

#$.&57#$E!>%+#*59!9*.#%&!C(7#%!%$7!95+>(6!7*.5C($,92!,*!7%,(!,B(6!B%>(!$*,!/(($!?#7(&6!,(9,(7G!

e5&,#)&(!#$,(+>#(?((9!.*CC($,(7!*$!,B(!)*,($,#%&!*D!,B+(%7(7!9,+%#$9!*D!7#%&*E5(2!?B#.B!?*5&7!

Page 33: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\0A!

%&&*?!.*$>(+9%,#*$9!#$!,B(!.*CC($,!D*+5C9!,*!/(!(%9#&6!,+%.J(7!%$7!*/9(+>(7!/6!)%+,#.#)%$,9G!

-$(!)*99#/&(!$(?!C(.B%$#9C!C#EB,!/(!%&&*?#$E!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!,*!%77!,B+(%7(7!

.*CC($,9!7#+(.,&6!,*!9)(.#D#.!9(.,#*$9!*D!%!7*.5C($,!*+!)+*)*9%&G!e5&,#I+*5$7!.*CC($,9!

)(+#*792!?B(+(!.*CC($,%,*+9!%+(!(U)&#.#,&6!%9J(7!,*!.*CC($,!*$!)+#*+!.*CC($,92!?*5&7!%&9*!

($.*5+%E(!C(C/(+9!*D!,B(!)5/&#.!,*!($E%E(!?#,B!(%.B!*,B(+9L!%+E5C($,9!%$7!)*9#,#*$9G!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• W9,%/&#9B!%$7!*/9(+>(!/%9(&#$(!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,B(!9,+5.,5+(!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!)5/&#.!

.*CC($,!)(+#*79G!R#DD(+($,#%,(!/(,?(($!,B(!)5/&#.!#$)5,!+(H5#+(C($,9!D*+!7#DD(+($,!

,6)(9!*D!:;4<<!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!7(.#9#*$9!N(GEG2!+(H5(9,9!D*+!#$D*+C%,#*$2!)*&#.6IC%J#$E!

)+*)*9%&92!7+%D,!7*.5C($,9O!%$7!.+(%,(!9,%$7%+79!%..*+7#$E&6G!!

• W$95+(!,B%,!,B(+(!#9!%7(H5%,(!.**+7#$%,#*$!/6!:;4<<!9,%DD!%$7!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(9!*D!,B(!

7#DD(+($,!.*CC($,!)(+#*79!,*!/(,,(+!%77+(99!,B(!>*&5C(!%$7!,#C#$E!*D!)5/&#.!.*CC($,!

)(+#*79G!!

• Q*&#.#,!)5/&#.!#$)5,!%$7!9,+5.,5+(!.*CC($,!)(+#*79!?#,B!,**&9!,B%,!/(,,(+!D*9,(+!7#%&*E5(!

%C*$E!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!?#,B!,B(!:;4<<!9,%DDM!(U)&*+(2!(>%&5%,(!%$7!#C)&(C($,!95.B!

C(.B%$#9C9!#$!*+7(+!,*!7(>(&*)!.*$>(+9%,#*$9!/(,?(($!#$7#>#75%&92!,B(#+!

.*$9,#,5($.#(92!,B(!9,%DD2!%$7!5&,#C%,(&6!,B(![*%+7G!

• ;*$,#$5(!,*!#C)+*>(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!,*!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$!:;4<<!C((,#$E9!/6!%$$*5$.#$E!,B(!

9)(.#D#.!&*.%,#*$9!*D!,B(9(!C((,#$E!D5+,B(+!#$!%7>%$.(G!

• ;*$,#$5(!,*!#C)+*>(!,B(!H5%&#,6!%$7!,#C(&6!)5/&#.%,#*$!*D!,+%$9&%,#*$9!*D!+(&(>%$,!

C%,(+#%&9!%$7!.*CC($,9G!WU)&*+(!C(,B*79!*D!($E%E#$E!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!>*&5$,((+9!#$!

,+%$9&%,#*$G!

!

T=T!"@@/2@('*&@!(&-!6201$&-*&@!'$!?%)+*#!3&1%'!

c(d!300%20!

:;4<<!9,%DD!C(C/(+9!%+(!,%9J(7!?#,B!#$,(+)+(,#$E2!)+*.(99#$E!%$7!*+E%$#F#$E!.*CC($,92!/5,!

,B(+(!%))(%+9!,*!/(!$*!.*$9#9,($,!)+%.,#.(2!C(,B*7*&*E62!*+!,#C(,%/&(!D*+!,B#9!)+*.(99G!Q,%$7%+79!

,B%,!7*!(U#9,!%+(!$*,!(>#7($,!,*!(U,(+$%&!)%+,#.#)%$,9G!"((7/%.J!*$!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#9!?(%JM!#,!

#9!7#DD#.5&,2!#D!$*,!#C)*99#/&(2!D*+!.*$,+#/5,*+9!,*!J$*?!B*?!%$7!?B($!.*CC($,9!B%>(!/(($!

%EE+(E%,(72!95CC%+#F(7!%$7!#$.*+)*+%,(7!#$,*!7(.#9#*$9G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!95CC%+#F%,#*$!%$7!%$%&69#9!*D!.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,9!>%+6!%.+*99!7#DD(+($,!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!

D*+5C9G!e5&,#)&(!.B%&&($E(9!(U#9,!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!S+#EB,!)+*.(99T!D*+!%..5+%,(&6!%$%&6F#$E!)5/&#.!

.*CC($,9G!"#+9,2!#,!#9!7#DD#.5&,!,*!E%5E(!)5/&#.!9($,#C($,!/%9(7!*$!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9G!8B#9!#9!

.*C)&#.%,(7!/6!&(,,(+I?+#,#$E!.%C)%#E$9!*+!)%+,#.5&%+&6!F(%&*59!.*$,+#/5,*+9G!:$7#>#75%&!

.*CC($,9!C%6!/(!C*+(!59(D5&!*+!#C)&(C($,%/&(!,B%$!.*CC*$!>#(?)*#$,9G!Q(.*$72!,B(!>*&5C(2!

&($E,B!%$7!H5%&#,6!*D!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!>%+6!?#&7&6G!"5+,B(+C*+(2!9*C(!.*CC($,9!%+(!95/C#,,(7!

,*!,B(!#$.*++(.,!D*+5CM!.*CC($,9!,B%,!?*5&7!/(,,(+!95#,!,*)#.I9)(.#D#.!D*+5C9!ND*+!(U%C)&(2!

Page 34: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\\A!

9,+#$E!.*$,($,#*$!)+*.(75+(9!#$!,B(!$(?!E8VR!)+*E+%CO!%+(!95/C#,,(7!,*!E($(+%&!D*+5C9!ND*+!

(U%C)&(2!,B(!.*CC($,!D*+5C!D*+!,B(!($,#+(!R+%D,!4))&#.%$,!^5#7(/**JOG!! !

XB#&(!%.J$*?&(7E#$E!,B(!7#DD#.5&,6!*D!%..5+%,(&6!%$%&6F#$E!,B(!+%$E(!*D!)5/&#.!#$)5,92!

#$,(+>#(?((9!%$7!95/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!C%$6!.5++($,!95CC%+#(9!

*C#,!.(+,%#$!.*CC($,92!%$7!,B%,!.*CC($,9!%+(!5$D%#+&6!?(#EB,(7!ND*+!(U%C)&(2!%!D*+C!&(,,(+!

9#E$(7!/6!9(>(+%&!,+%7(C%+J!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!C%6!.*5$,!%9!C5&,#)&(!#$7#>#75%&!.*CC($,92!?B#&(!%!

D*+C!&(,,(+!9#E$(7!/6!C5&,#)&(!#$7#>#75%&9!C%6!*$&6!.*5$,!%9!%!9#$E&(!.*CC($,OG!Q*C(!

#$,(+>#(?((9!/(&#(>(!%$%&69(9!*D!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!?(+(!*>(+9#C)&#D#(7G!! !

R(9)#,(!,B(9(!7#DD#.5&,#(92!9(>(+%&!*D!,B*9(!#$,(+>#(?(7!)*#$,(7!,*!,B(!C%+J(7!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!

#$.*+)*+%,#$E!)5/&#.!#$)5,!%$7!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!:;4<<L9!+(9)*$9(!/%.J!,*!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!#$!,B(!

C*+(!+(.($,!+*5$79!*D!+(>#9#*$9!,*!,B(!$(?!E8VR!R+%D,!4))&#.%$,!^5#7(/**J!NR4^OG!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

4&,B*5EB!,B(+(!.%$!/(!$*!(U%.,!9.#($.(!D*+!,B(!95CC%+#F%,#*$!*D!)5/&#.!.*CC($,92!7(>(&*)#$E!

%$7!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!/%9(&#$(!9,%$7%+79!D*+!,B(!)+*.(99!.%$!B(&)!9,+($E,B($!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!,B(!

D#$%&!%$%&69#9G!^5#7(&#$(92!C*+(!7(D#$(7!,(C)&%,(92!%$7!(U)&#.#,!.B%$$(&9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,!.%$!B(&)!

.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!,*!/(!.&(%+!*$!,B(!D&*?!*D!,B(#+!.*$,+#/5,#*$9G!

:;4<<L9!)+%.,#.(!*D!)+*>#7#$E!%!95CC%+6p%$%&69#9!%&*$E!?#,B!%!D5&&!%+.B#>(!*D!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!

#9!%$!#C)*+,%$,!C(%$9!*D!9B*?#$E!,B%,!.*CC($,9!B%>(!/(($!+(.(#>(7!%$7!.*$9#7(+(7G!K*?(>(+2!

*))*+,5$#,#(9!,*!,+%.J!*$(L9!.*CC($,9!%&*$E!,B(!&#D(.6.&(!*D!%!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99!.*5&7!/(!

#C)+*>(7G!W$E%E#$E!,B(!S.+*?7TZ?#,B!?(&&!7(D#$(7!+5&(9!D*+!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!*+7(+!,*!)+(>($,!

%/59(Z,*!B(&)!,*!.%,(E*+#F(2!D#&,(+2!#$,(+)+(,!%$7!%EE+(E%,(!.*CC($,92!)*#$,!,*!+(75$7%$.#(92!

%$7!E5#7(!)%+,#.#)%$,9!,*!+(9*5+.(9!*+!%$9?(+9!C%6!(%9(!,B(!/5+7($!*$!:;4<<!9,%DD!%$7!($B%$.(!

,B(!)(+.(),#*$!,B%,!)5/&#.!#$)5,9!%+(!/(#$E!.*$9#7(+(7G`a!!!

8B(!59(!*D!$(?!)+*.(99(9!,*!/+#$E!)5/&#.!#$)5,!,*!/(%+!*$!J(6!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9!#9!%$!*))*+,5$#,6!

,*!%7>%$.(!,B(!(DD#.%.6!*D!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!"*+!(U%C)&(2!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B(!$(?!E8VR!

)+*E+%C2!%!$(?!)5/&#.!.*CC($,!%$%&69#9!C*7(&!?%9!,+#%&(7!#$!?B#.B!95CC%+6p%$%&69#9!

7*.5C($,9!%+(!9,+5.,5+(7!/6!.%,(E*+#(9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!7#DD(+($,!)+*)*9%&92!#$!*+7(+!,*!7(>(&*)!

%C($7C($,9!,*!,B(!R4^G!Q(.,#*$9!*D!,B(!R4^!,B%,!B%>(!/(($!.B%$E(7!#$!+(9)*$9(!,*!.*CC($,9!

%+(!$*,(7!#$!,B(!D**,$*,(9G!Q#C#&%+!*),#*$9!.*5&7!/(!,%#&*+(7!%..*+7#$E!,B(!)%+,#.5&%+!*/Y(.,#>(9!

*D!,B(!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!)+*.(99!#$!H5(9,#*$G!!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• R(>(&*)!%$7!.*CC5$#.%,(!/%9(&#$(!)+*.(75+(9!%$7!E5#7(&#$(9!D*+!95CC%+#F#$E!%$7!

%$%&6F#$E!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9G!;*$,#$5(!,*!)+*>#7(!95))*+,!%$7!,+%#$#$E!D*+!9,%DD!#$!,B(#+!

59(G!

• ;*$,#$5(!,*!(U)(+#C($,!?#,B!7#DD(+($,!)5/&#.!#$)5,!+(9)*$9(!C(.B%$#9C9M!(U)&*+(2!

(>%&5%,(2!%$7!(9,%/&#9B!C(.B%$#9C9!,*!#C)+*>(!,B(!%/#&#,6!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+9!,*!,+%.J!,B(!

&#D(I.6.&(!*D!,B(#+!#$)5,!#$,*!:;4<<!)*&#.6IC%J#$E!%$7!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!Q5.B!

(DD*+,9!9B*5&7!/(!5$7(+,%J($!?#,B!.&(%+!E*%&9!#$!C#$72!,*?%+79!($B%$.#$E!,B(!(DD#.#($.6!

*D!(U#9,#$E!)+*.(99(92!*+!%77+(99#$E!J(6!E%)9!*+!#C)+*>(C($,92!5$7(+!?(&&I7(D#$(7!%$7!

?(&&I.*CC5$#.%,(7!.*$7#,#*$9G!

Page 35: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\_A!

• WU)&*+(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!%$7!,**&9!,*!($E%E(!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!#$!,B(!95CC%+#F%,#*$!

%$7!%$%&69#9!*D!.*CC($,9G!

T=\!3&#$/1$/('*&@!?%)+*#!3&1%'!*&'$!34"55!-2#*0*$&0!!!

c(d!300%20!

R(9)#,(!,B(!C5&,#)&(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!)5/&#.!#$)5,!+(E%+7#$E!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$92!.*CC5$#,6!

C(C/(+9!B%>(!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!#,!#9!7#DD#.5&,!D*+!,B(C!,*!J$*?!B*?!%$7!?B($!,B(#+!

.*CC($,9!B%>(!/(($!#$.*+)*+%,(7!%$7!+(D&(.,(7!#$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!477#,#*$%&!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!

,B(!,+%$9)%+($.6!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!%+(!*5,&#$(7!#$!Q(.,#*$!:i!;G0G\G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!48'8!+(.(#>(7!%!&%+E(!$5C/(+!*D!.*CC($,9!.*$.(+$#$E!,B(!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!*D!,B(![*%+7M!

C*9,!(U)+(99(7!,B(!*)#$#*$!,B%,!,B(!S[*%+7L9!7(.#9#*$9!9B*5&7!/(!/(,,(+!Y59,#D#(7!%$7!(U)&%#$(7!

,*!,B(!.*CC5$#,6GT`h!!:$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!,B%,!9((C(7!,*!

.*$,+%7#.,!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!?(+(!$*,!95DD#.#($,&6!(U)&%#$(7G!-$(!(U%C)&(!C($,#*$(7!?%9!,B(!

WU)+(99#*$!*D!:$,(+(9,!)+*)*9%&2!?B#.B!C%$6!.*CC($,%,*+9!95))*+,(7!(#,B(+!D5&&6!*+!

.*$7#,#*$%&&6!/5,!?%9!5&,#C%,(&6!+(Y(.,(7!/6!,B(![*%+7G!4..*+7#$E!,*!.*CC($,9!,*!,B(!48'82!

%$*,B(+!*..%9#*$!?B(+(!,B(!(U)&%$%,#*$!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!?%9!Y57E(7!#$95DD#.#($,!#9!

+(7(&(E%,#*$!7(.#9#*$9G!

4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?92!9,%DD!#7(%9!.5++($,&6!5$7(+!7#9.599#*$!D*+!#C)+*>#$E!,B(![*%+7L9!

.*CC5$#.%,#*$!*D!#,9!7(.#9#*$9!,*!,B(!)5/&#.!#$.&57(!.+(%,#$E!%$!(U)&%$%,#*$!,(C)&%,(!D*+!,B(!

[*%+7!,*!.*C)&(,(!%$7!)5/&#9B!%D,(+!(%.B!7(.#9#*$!%$7!7(>(&*)#$E!%!C%,+#U!,*!(U)&%#$!B*?!

.*CC($,9!B%>(!/(($!.*$9#7(+(7!%$7!?B(+(!%$7!B*?!,B(9(!B%>(!#$D&5($.(7!7(.#9#*$9G!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

4!&%.J!*D!.&%+#,6!+(E%+7#$E!B*?!)5/&#.!#$)5,!#9!+(D&(.,(7!#$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E2!)%+,#.5&%+&6!#$!

.%9(9!?B($![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!C%6!%))(%+!,*!7(>#%,(!D+*C!,B(!*)#$#*$9!(U)+(99(7!/6!,B(!C%Y*+#,6!

*D!,B*9(!?B*!B%>(!95/C#,,(7!)5/&#.!#$)5,2!.%$!/(!7(,+#C($,%&!,*!:;4<<L9!&(E#,#C%.6G!;*CC5$#,6!

C(C/(+9!?B*!/(&#(>(!,B(#+!#$)5,!#9!/(#$E!5$7(+>%&5(7!*+!7#9+(E%+7(7!C%6!/(!&(99!&#J(&6!,*!

.*$,+#/5,(!#$!,B(!D5,5+(G!8B(6!C%6!%&9*!/(!&(99!&#J(&6!,*!,+59,!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!,*!C%J(!7(.#9#*$9!

#$!,B(!)5/&#.!#$,(+(9,!*+!(&(.,!,*!,%J(!,B(#+!.*C)&%#$,9!,*!*,B(+2!(U,(+$%&!D*+5C92!95.B!%9!,B(!

.*5+,9!*+!$%,#*$%&!E*>(+$C($,9G!WC)#+#.%&!9,57#(9!#$!D#(&79!,B%,!#$>*&>(!%7>(+9%+#%&!)+*.(99(9!

%$7!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!B%>(!9B*?$!,B%,!?B($!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!%+(!%/&(!,*!+(.*E$#F(!,B%,!

,B(#+!#$,(+(9,9!B%>(!/(($!,B*5EB,D5&&6!.*$9#7(+(72!,B(6!%+(!E($(+%&&6!C*+(!9%,#9D#(72!+(E%+7&(99!

*D!,B(!5&,#C%,(!*5,.*C(G`l!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• ]+*>#7(!C*+(!(U)&#.#,!%$7!7(,%#&(7!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!D*+!7(.#9#*$9!/6!

,B(![*%+72!#$.&57#$E!,B(!+(%9*$9!?B6!.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,!C%6!B%>(!/(($!+(Y(.,(7!*+!

#$.*+)*+%,(7!#$!,B(!D#$%&!*5,.*C(G!

Page 36: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\`A!

T=`!522-!I$/!9&H(&#2-!4/$00>4$<<%&*',!R*(+$@%2!

c(d!300%20!

:;4<<!B%9!.*CC#,,(7!#,9(&D!,*!S%99(99#$E!,B(!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!)+*.(99!,*!D%.#&#,%,(!($B%$.(7!

.+*99!.*CC5$#,6!7(&#/(+%,#*$9GT`k!!4$(.7*,%&!(>#7($.(!95EE(9,9!,B%,!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!,B(!

(U#9,#$E!.B%$$(&9!%$7!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!.+*99!.*CC5$#,6!7(&#/(+%,#*$92!/*,B!D*+C%&!%$7!#$D*+C%&2!

%+(!9,#&&!$((7(7!%,!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!$((7!D*+!/(,,(+!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(!%,!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!%+*9(!C5&,#)&(!

,#C(9!#$!,B(!#$,(+>#(?9G!:$,(+>#(?((9!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!7(&%69!*D,($!9,(C!D+*C!

.%9(9!?B(+(!7#DD(+($,!E+*5)9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6!9)(%J!5)!*$!#995(9!,**!&%,(2!%D,(+!

,B(9(!#995(9!B%>(!/(($!$(%+&6!D#$%&#F(7G!:$!,B(!>#(?!*D!,B(9(!#$,(+>#(?((92!(%+&6!#$,(+%.,#*$!

/(,?(($!,B(9(!E+*5)9!&(%79!,*!C*+(!(DD#.#($,!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!%$7!#9!C*+(!.*$75.#>(!,*!

.*$9($959!%$7!/+*%7(+!#$.&59#*$G!

Q*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!E+*5)9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6!.5++($,&6!

*)(+%,(!9()%+%,(&6!D+*C!*$(!%$*,B(+=!%!9#$E&(!E+*5)!)5/&#9B(9!%!7*.5C($,2!*,B(+!E+*5)9!

.*CC($,!*$!#,2!%$7!,B($!,B(!9,%DD!%$7![*%+7!7(.#7(!?B%,!9,()9!,*!,%J(!$(U,G!8B(9(!#$,(+>#(?((9!

%7>*.%,(7!D*+!C*+(!.*CC5$#,6I?#7(!7#9.599#*$!/(D*+(!7*.5C($,9!%+(!)5/&#9B(72!#$!*+7(+!,*!

)+(>($,!,B#9!&%,(+!S)#$EI)*$ET!(DD(.,G!

:$!9*C(!#$9,%$.(92!:;4<<!B%9!#C)&(C($,(7!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!?*+J#$E!E+*5)9!,*!%77+(99!9)(.#D#.!

#995(9G!-$(!(U%C)&(!#9!,B(!?*+J#$E!E+*5)!*$!+(.*CC($7%,#*$!a!*D!,B(!$(?!E8VR!)+*E+%C!

N?B#.B!%77+(99(9!SC*+%&#,6!%$7!)5/&#.!*+7(+TOGa1!8B#9!E+*5)!.*$,%#$9!+()+(9($,%,#>(9!D+*C!,B(!

4V4;2!,B(!^<Q-2!%$7!,B(!^4;G!:$,(+>#(?((9!)*#$,(7!,*!,B#9!E+*5)!%9!%!)*9#,#>(!(U%C)&(!*D!

7#%&*E5(!/(,?(($!>%+#*59!E+*5)9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6M!B*?(>(+2!,B(6!%&9*!(U)+(99(7!

,B(!*)#$#*$!,B%,!,B#9!E+*5)!.%C(!,**!&%,(!#$!,B(!)+*.(992!#G(G2!,B%,!#,!?%9!(9,%/&#9B(7!,*!9*&>(!%!

)+*/&(C!.%59(7!/6!%!&%.J!*D!95DD#.#($,!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(!(%+&#(+!#$!,B(!7(>(&*)C($,!*D!

,B(!$(?!E8VR!)+*E+%CG!

!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&#

4!&%.J!*D!95DD#.#($,!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7(&#/(+%,#*$!%,!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!)*&#.6!7#9.599#*$9!C%6!.%59(!

7(&%69!/6!)+(>($,#$E!>%+#*59!9,%J(B*&7(+9!?#,B#$!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6!D+*C!.*$,+#/5,#$E!,*!

,B(!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!*D!C%Y*+!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!%!9)(.#D#.!)*&#.6G!"*+!(U%C)&(2!C*+(!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!

7#%&*E5(!/(D*+(!,B(!)5/&#.%,#*$!*D!,B(!D#+9,!>(+9#*$!*D!,B(!R+%D,!4))&#.%$,!^5#7(/**J!D*+!,B(!$(?!

E8VR!)+*E+%C!C%6!B%>(!B(&)(7!#7($,#D6!,B(!S*>(+%+.B#$E!#995(9T!%$7!*,B(+!.*$,+*>(+9#%&!#995(9!

,B%,!95/9(H5($,&6!%+*9(G!!

8B(!(9,%/&#9BC($,!*D!?*+J#$E!E+*5)9!.*$,%#$#$E!+()+(9($,%,#>(9!D+*C!C5&,#)&(!47>#9*+6!

;*CC#,,((9!N4;9O!%$7!Q5))*+,#$E!-+E%$#F%,#*$9!NQ-9O!/(D*+(!,B(!D#$%&#F%,#*$!*D!)*&#.6!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!C%6!B(&)!#7($,#D6!%$7!+(9*&>(!SB*,!/5,,*$T!#995(9G!:$.+(%9#$E!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!

Page 37: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\aA!

.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!#$,(+%.,#*$!%,!:;4<<!C((,#$E9!C%6!B(&)!)+*>#7(!.&(%+!.B%$$(&9!D*+!7#9.599#*$!

%C*$E!>%+#*59!:;4<<!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(9G!!

X(!+(.*E$#F(!,B%,!($B%$.#$E!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(!?#&&!$*,!)+(.&57(!7#99%,#9D#(7!

)%+,#.#)%$,9!D+*C!&**J#$E!D*+!%77#,#*$%&!>($5(9!,*!(U)+(99!,B(#+!7#99($,2!(GEG2!/6!&*//6#$E![*%+7!

C(C/(+9!,*!%77+(99!,B(#+!.*$.(+$9!*+!+(*)($!%9)(.,9!*D!,B(!)*&#.6IC%J#$E!)*&#.6G!<*+!7*!?(!

/(&#(>(!,B%,!95.B!%.,#*$9!%+(!#$%))+*)+#%,(!#$!%&&!#$9,%$.(9G!

Q((J#$E!%77#,#*$%&!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7#%&*E5(2!/*,B!D*+C%&&6!%$7!#$D*+C%&&62!#9!

#$,($7(7!,*!/(!Y57#.#*59&6!%))&#(7!%9!%!.*C)&(C($,!,*!,B(!>%+#*59!*,B(+!(9,%/&#9B(7!C(.B%$#9C9!

D*+!/5#&7#$E!.*$9($959!%$7!.*&&(.,#>(!7(&#/(+%,#*$G!

!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&!

• W$.*5+%E(!:;4<<L9!>%+#*59!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(9!,*!($E%E(!#$!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!

#$,(+%.,#*$9!#$!(%+&6!9,%E(9!*D!)*&#.6!#$#,#%,#>(92!7#9.599#*$92!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#*$9G!WU)&*+(!

(U)&#.#,!)*&#.#(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!,+#EE(+#$E!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!7(&#/(+%,#*$!%C*$E!

:;4<<L9!>%+#*59!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(9G!!

4"#G&-%A#S&>)%.-.0);4&%:&%-,)#S&>)%.-.0)#-.A#G&-%A#50,9>9,9)2#

!"#S).)%-(#4&.29A)%-,9&.2#

:;4<<!D%.(9!%!$5C/(+!*D!.B%&&($E(9!%,!,B(!$(U59!*D!,+%$9)%+($.62!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%$7!

E*>(+$%$.(G!8B(9(!.B%&&($E(9!+(D&(.,!#,9!5$#H5(!)*9#,#*$!9,+%77&#$E!,B(!)5/&#.I)+#>%,(!7#>#7(2!,B(!

C%$6!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!%$7!9,%J(B*&7(+!E+*5)9!#$>*&>(72!,B(!E&*/%&!$%,5+(!*D!#,9!.B%+E(2!,B(!7(9#+(!

,*!+(,%#$!,B(!.*$9($95%&!/%9#9!*D!#,9!E*>(+$%$.(2!%$7!,B(!,($9#*$9!%$7!C#99#*$!.*$D&#.,9!#$B(+($,!

?#,B#$!:;4<<!#,9(&DG!;*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!)*&#.#(9!%+(!.($,+%&!,*!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!

%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%,!:;4<<G!4$6!+(D*+C9!7(9#E$(7!,*!#C)+*>(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C59,!

%&9*!,%J(!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(!$((7!,*!C%J(!9*5$7!7(.#9#*$9!#$!%$!(DD#.#($,!%$7!,#C(&6!C%$$(+G!!

4,!,B(!B(%+,!*D!#,9!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!.B%&&($E(!#9!,B(!D%.,!,B%,!:;4<<!+()+(9($,9!%$!*>(+&%6!*D!

C5&,#)&(!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!C*7(&9G!:;4<<!?%9!(9,%/&#9B(7!,*!%.,!%9!%!/*,,*CI5)!.*$9($959I/%9(7!

*+E%$#F%,#*$!+()+(9($,%,#>(!*D!E&*/%&!#$,(+(9,9G!:;4<<!#9!%&9*!%!;%&#D*+$#%!$*$)+*D#,!.*+)*+%,#*$G!

8B(9(!,?*!C*7(&9!%+(!.5++($,&6!+(.*$.#&(7!?#,B!,B(!5$7(+9,%$7#$E!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!#9!5&,#C%,(&6!

+(9)*$9#/&(!D*+!,B(!%.,#*$9!*D!,B(!*+E%$#F%,#*$Z9,(CC#$E!D+*C!;%&#D*+$#%!&%?Z%$7!C59,!

,B(+(D*+(2!#$!J(()#$E!?#,B!#,9!E&*/%&!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(92!)+*)(+&6!*>(+9((!%$7!#C)&(C($,!,B(!

/*,,*CI5)!.*$9($95%&!C*7(&G!8B#9!#C)&#(9!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!C59,!/(!#$!,B(!)*9#,#*$!,*!D5&&6!

5$7(+9,%$72!#$,(+)+(,2!%$7!%.,!#$!%..*+7%$.(!?#,B!,B(!#$,(+(9,9!%$7!)+(D(+($.(9!*D!,B(!:;4<<!

.*CC5$#,6!%$7!/+*%7(+!9(,!*D!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!8B#9!%))&#(9!$*,!*$&6!?B($!,B(+(!#9!.*$9($959!/5,!

%&9*!?B($!.*$9($959!#9!$*,!+(%.B(7G!XB($!*)(+%,#$E!?#,B#$!,B(!.5++($,!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C*7(&!

.*$9,+5.,(7!*$!,+%$9)%+($.62!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!%$7!)+*.(75+(2!($95+#$E!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!B%9!,B(!

.%)%.#,6!%$7!+(9*5+.(9!,*!)+*)(+&6!(>%&5%,(!%$7!#$,(+)+(,!,B(!$((79!%$7!#$)5,!*D!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!

#9!.+#,#.%&G!!

Page 38: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\hA!

^#>($!:;4<<L9!5$#H5(!9(,!*D!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!%$7!7#>(+9(!D5$.,#*$%&!+*&(92!,B(!&(99*$9!%$7!/(9,!

)+%.,#.(9!D+*C!,B(!D#(&7!*D!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!.%$$*,!/(!7#+(.,&6!%))&#(7!,*!:;4<<!?#,B*5,!

,%J#$E!#$,*!%..*5$,!#,9!9)(.#D#.!#$9,#,5,#*$%&!.*$,(U,G!!

8B(!>%+#*59!$*,#*$9!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,62!%9!7(9.+#/(7!#$!Q(.,#*$!::![G3!2!+(&%,(!/*,B!,*!:;4<<L9!&(E%&!

D*5$7%,#*$9!5$7(+!;%&#D*+$#%!&%?!%$7!%&9*!#,9!/+*%7(+!+(9)*$9#/#&#,6!,*!:$,(+$(,!59(+9!%+*5$7!,B(!

E&*/(G!8B(![*%+7!)&%69!%!.($,+%&!+*&(!#$!/*,BG!8B#9!(U,($79!,*!,B(!.*C)*9#,#*$!*D!,B(![*%+72!,B(!

+(&%,#*$9B#)!*D!,B(![*%+7!?#,B!,B(!9,%DD!%$7!,B(!#$,(+%.,#*$!?#,B!.*$9,#,5($,!/*7#(92!D*+!(U%C)&(!

,B(!^4;G!:,!%&9*!(U,($79!,*!%&,(+$%,#>(9!C*7(&9!D*+!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!*D!:;4<<!7(.#9#*$9G!!

;*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(!#$.&57(9!$*,!*$&6!9,+5.,5+(2!+5&(9!%$7!)+*.(75+(9!/5,!%&9*!,B(!.5&,5+%&!

>%&5(9!%$7!$*+C9!*D!,B(!*+E%$#F%,#*$!%$7!,B(!C%$$(+!#$!?B#.B!,B(6!%+(!(U)+(99(7!#$!7%6I,*I7%6!

%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!#$,(+%.,#*$9!?#,B!9,%J(B*&7(+9G![*,B!%9)(.,9!)&%6!%!.*C)&(C($,%+6!%$7!(99($,#%&!

+*&(!#$!,B(!,+%$9)%+($.62!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!(DD(.,#>($(99!*D!,B(!*+E%$#F%,#*$G!!

:;4<<!9B*5&7!.*$,#$5(!,*!/(!%!&(%7(+!#$!%))&6#$E!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!,*!

#C)+*>(!E*>(+$%$.(G!8B(!:$,(+$(,!%$7!*,B(+!7#E#,%&!C(%$9!*D!#$,(+%.,#*$!%$7!#$D*+C%,#*$!

9B%+#$E!%+(!.+(%,#$E!$(?!*))*+,5$#,#(9!,*!#C)+*>(!*$!*&7(+!C*7(&92!/5,!C5.B!*D!,B#9!,(++%#$!#9!

5$.B%+,(7G!:;4<<!.%$!%$7!9B*5&7!/(!(U)(+#C($,#$E!?#,B!7#DD(+($,!.*$.(),#*$9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!

%$7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!%99(99#$E!,B(!+(95&,9!+(E5&%+&6G!P9#$E!,B(9(!(U)(+#C($,9!,*!#C)+*>(!

:;4<<L9!*>(+%&&!)+%.,#.(!?#&&!#$>*&>(!.%+(D5&!7(9#E$2!*$E*#$E!C*$#,*+#$E2!%$7!%!?#&&#$E$(99!,*!

%..(),!,B%,!9*C(!*D!,B(!(U)(+#C($,%&!C(%95+(9!,+#(7!?#&&!/(!5$95..(99D5&G!

D"#/22@)N+:)09=90#W'2)%>-,9&.2#-.A#E)0&**).A-,9&.2#

T=V!E$(/-!#$<1$0*'*$&!

c(d!300%20!

:$!#$,(+>#(?9!%$7!#$!>%+#*59!)5/&#.!95/C#99#*$92!.*$.(+$9!B%>(!/(($!(U)+(99(7!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!

.*C)*9#,#*$!*D!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7G!8B(+(!%+(!,?*!J(6!%9)(.,9!+(&%,(7!,*!:;4<<L9![*%+7!

.*C)*9#,#*$=!,B(!(U)(+,#9(!%$7!9J#&&!9(,9!+()+(9($,(7!*$!,B(![*%+7!%$7!%7(H5%,(!+()+(9($,%,#*$!

*D!,B(!>%+#*59!9,%J(B*&7(+92!#$.&57#$E!+()+(9($,%,#*$!*D!7#DD(+($,!E(*E+%)B#.!+(E#*$9!%$7!

.*CC(+.#%&!%$7!$*$I.*CC(+.#%&!#$,(+(9,9G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

;*$.(+$9!?(+(!(U)+(99(7!#$!#$,(+>#(?9!?B(,B(+!,B(!)+*)(+!+%$E(!*D!9J#&&9!?(+(!%7(H5%,(&6!

+()+(9($,(7!*$!,B(![*%+7G!Q5/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!(U)+(99(7!,B(!7(9#+(!D*+!S/+*%7(+!/59#$(99!

(U)(+,#9(!%$7!E($7(+!7#>(+9#,6T!#$!,B(![*%+7G!]5/&#.!95/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!#$7#.%,(!,B%,!9*C(!

.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!D((&!,B%,!%,!&(%9,!.(+,%#$!%9)(.,9!*D!,B(![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!)+*.(992!D*+!#$9,%$.(!

?#,B!+(E%+7!,*!9(&(.,#*$!.+#,(+#%!59(72!%+(!$*,!,+%$9)%+($,!($*5EBM!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!

.*$.(+$9!,B%,!,B(!%.,#>#,#(9!%$7!7(.#9#*$9!*D!,B(!<*C#$%,#$E!;*CC#,,((!%+(!$*,!%9!(DD(.,#>(!%9!

,B(6!.*5&7!/(G!!

Page 39: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\lA!

:;4<<L9![6&%?9!.*$,%#$!+%,B(+!7(,%#&(7!+5&(9!%/*5,!,B(!9(&(.,#*$!*D!,B(!,*,%&!3`![*%+7!C(C/(+9!

/6!,B(!<*C#$%,#$E!;*CC#,,((2!,B(!477+(99!Q5))*+,#$E!-+E%$#F%,#*$2!,B(!;*5$,+6I;*7(!<%C(9!

Q5))*+,#$E!-+E%$#F%,#*$2!%$7!,B(!^($(+#.!<%C(9!Q5))*+,#$E!-+E%$#F%,#*$G61!"*+!(%.B!.%,(E*+6!*D!

9(%,92!,B(![6&%?9!9,#)5&%,(!%!7#>(+9(!9(,!*D![*%+7!C(C/(+9B#)!.+#,(+#%G!:C)*+,%$,&62!,B(!

<*C#$%,#$E!;*CC#,,((!S9B%&&!9((J!,*!($95+(!,B%,!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!#9!.*C)*9(7!*D!C(C/(+9!?B*!

#$!,B(!%EE+(E%,(!7#9)&%6!7#>(+9#,6!#$!E(*E+%)B62!.5&,5+(2!9J#&&92!(U)(+#($.(2!%$7!)(+9)(.,#>(T!/6!

%))&6#$E!%!+#.B!9(,!*D!9(&(.,#*$!.+#,(+#%2!?B#.B!#$.&57(!S#$?%+7I&**J#$ET!N(GEG2!#$,(E+#,62!

#$,(&&#E($.(O!%$7!C*+(!S*5,?%+7!D%.#$ET!9(&(.,#*$!.+#,(+#%!N(GEG2!.5&,5+%&!%$7!E(*E+%)B#.!

7#>(+9#,6OG62!

[*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!)+*.(99(9!%$7!.*C)*9#,#*$!#995(92!+(9)(.,#>(&62!B%>(!/(($!95/Y(.,!,*!(U,($9#>(!

#$,(+$%&!%$7!(U,(+$%&!+(>#(?9G![*,B!,B(!<*C#$%,#$E!;*CC#,,((!%$7!,B(![*%+7!B%>(!5$7(+E*$(!

%$!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!/6!(U,(+$%&!(U)(+,92!?B#.B!+(95&,(7!#$!%!9(+#(9!*D!*>(+&%))#$E!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?92!9(>(+%&!*D!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9Z(9)(.#%&&6!?#,B!

+(E%+7!,*!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!9J#&&92!(U)(+#($.(2!%$7!#$7()($7($.(Z%+(!.5++($,&6!/(#$E!#C)&(C($,(7G!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

Q#$.(!,B(!#C)&(C($,%,#*$!*D!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!*D!)+(>#*59!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?9!#9!9,#&&!

*$E*#$E2!#,!#9!,**!(%+&6!,*!)+*>#7(!%!D#$%&!%99(99C($,!*D!,B(!C(%95+(9!5$7(+?%6!,B%,!%+(!#$,($7(7!

,*!+(9*&>(!,B(!#995(9!#7($,#D#(7!#$!,B#9!9(.,#*$!*+!,*!7(,(+C#$(!?B(,B(+!%77#,#*$%&!+(C(7#(9!B%>(!

,*!/(!.*$9#7(+(7G!:$!%77#,#*$!,*!*,B(+!9J#&&!9(,9!/(#$E!.*$9#7(+(7!D*+!,B(![*%+72!?(!/(&#(>(!,B%,!

,B(+(!9B*5&7!/(!C*+(!(C)B%9#9!#$![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!*$!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(2!.*&&(.,#>(!7(.#9#*$I

C%J#$E2!$(E*,#%,#*$2!%$7!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!9J#&&9!,*!B(&)!,B(![*%+7!7(%&!C*+(!(DD(.,#>(&6!?#,B!

.*$D&#.,#$E!>%&5(9!%$7!#$,(+(9,9!#$!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6G!X(!.*$.5+!?#,B!)+#*+!

+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!,B%,!95EE(9,!.*C)($9%,#$E![*%+7!C(C/(+9!%$7!+(.+5#,#$E!)+*D(99#*$%&!

7#+(.,*+9!,*!D#&&!9)(.#D#.!9J#&&!$((79G!->(+%&&2!,B(!(DD*+,9!5$7(+?%6!7(C*$9,+%,(!:;4<<L9!

.*CC#,C($,!,*!%99(99!%$7!#C)+*>(!:;4<<L9![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!C(.B%$#9C!%9!+(H5#+(7!/6!

)%+%E+%)B!kG3N%O!*D!,B(!4*;G!

8B(!+(>#(?!*D!C%,(+#%&9!95EE(9,9!%!.5++($,!D*.59!*$![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!#995(9!#$!*+7(+!,*!($95+(!

,B%,!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!#9!.*C)*9(7!*D!C(C/(+9!,B%,!B%>(!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!9J#&&9!%$7!+()+(9($,!

,B(!>%+#*59!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!K*?(>(+2!&**J#$E!%,!,B(!7(C%$7#$E!%$7!#$!9*C(!#$9,%$.(9!)*,($,#%&&6!

.*$D&#.,#$E!E*%&9!*D!:;4<<2!*$(!C#EB,!.*$9#7(+!9B#D,#$E!,B(!(C)B%9#9!*>(+!,#C(!D+*C![*%+7!

/","*0(2)!,*![*%+7!$".",2+:")0!)+*.(99(92!(9)(.#%&&6!#$!&#EB,!*D!.B%$E#$E!$((79!+(E%+7#$E!9J#&&!

9(,9!%9!:;4<<L9!(.*$*C#.!%$7!,(.B$*&*E#.%&!.*$,(U,!(>*&>(9G!"*+!9#C#&%+!)5+)*9(92!C%Y*+!

$*$)+*D#,!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!N(GEG2!,B(!P$#,(7!Q,%,(9!^#+&!Q.*5,9!%$7!,B(!4C(+#.%$!'(7!;+*99O!B%>(!

(9,%/&#9B(7![*%+7!7(>(&*)C($,!.*CC#,,((9G!4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?((92!:;4<<!B%9!%&+(%76!

,%J($!D#+9,!9,()9!#$,*!,B#9!7#+(.,#*$!N(GEG2!?#,B!9)(.#%&!,+%#$#$E!9(99#*$9!*$!)%+,#.5&%+!#995(9!D*+!

[*%+7!C(C/(+9!/%9(7!*$!95+>(6I/%9(7!9(&D!(>%&5%,#*$OG!!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• :C)&(C($,!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!*D!)+#*+!9,57#(9!,*!D*.59!C*+(!%,,($,#*$!*$![*%+7!

.*C)*9#,#*$!%$7!9J#&&92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!+(.*CC($7%,#*$!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!(9,%/&#9BC($,!*D!%!

C(.B%$#9C!D*+!#7($,#D6#$E!,B(!.*&&(.,#>(!9J#&&I9(,!+(H5#+(7!/6!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!%$7!D*+!

Page 40: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @\kA!

.*$95&,#$E!?#,B!9,%J(B*&7(+9!*$!,B#9!#995(G!](+#*7#.%&&6!(>%&5%,(!)+*E+(99!*$!,B(9(!

#995(9G!

• ]+*>#7(!C*+(!(C)B%9#9!#$![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!*$!.*+)*+%,(!E*>(+$%$.(2!.*&&(.,#>(!7(.#9#*$I

C%J#$E2!$(E*,#%,#*$2!%$7!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!9J#&&9G!!

• ;*$9#7(+!+(.+5#,#$E!)+*D(99#*$%&!7#+(.,*+9!,*!D#&&!9)(.#D#.!9J#&&!$((79G!!

• :$.+(%9(!,B(!,+%$9)%+($.6!*D!,B(!?*+J!*D!,B(!<*C#$%,#$E!;*CC#,,((!%9!D%+!%9!9(&(.,#*$!

.+#,(+#%!%$7!9(&(.,#*$!C(.B%$#9C9!%+(!.*$.(+$(7M!,B(!7(&#/(+%,#*$9!*>(+!#$7#>#75%&!

.%$7#7%,(92!B*?(>(+2!9B*5&7!+(C%#$!.*$D#7($,#%&G!

• [5#&7#$E!5)*$!.5++($,!(DD*+,92!.*$9#7(+!,B(!(U)%$9#*$!*D![*%+7!9(&(.,#*$!)+*.(99(9!,*!

#$.&57(![*%+7!$".",2+:")0!%.,#>#,#(9!/6!(9,%/&#9B#$E!%![*%+7!7(>(&*)C($,!.*CC#,,((G!

T=T!E$(/->;'(II!/2+('*$&0H*1!

c(d!300%20!

;*$.(+$9!B%>(!/(($!(U)+(99(7!#$!9*C(!#$,(+>#(?9!%$7!#$!%!$5C/(+!*D!)5/&#.!95/C#99#*$9!,B%,!

,B(!+(&%,#*$9B#)!/(,?(($!:;4<<!9,%DD!C(C/(+9!%$7!,B(![*%+7!#9!$*,!9,+5.,5+(7!#$!%!?%6!,B%,!#9!

.*$75.#>(!,*!($95+#$E!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!(DD(.,#>(&6!#$.*+)*+%,(9!%$7!+(9)*$79!,*!,B(!D5&&!+%$E(!*D!

.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,9G!8B(+(!#9!%!?#7(9)+(%7!)(+.(),#*$!,B%,!,B(!9,%DD!)&%69!%$!*>(+&6!7*C#$%$,!+*&(!

#$!9(,,#$E!,B(!%E($7%!%$7!9B%)#$E!,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$%&!/%9#9!*D![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!

8B(!/+*%7!9.*)(!%$7!.*C)&(U#,6!*D!:;4<<!%.,#>#,#(9!+(95&,9!#$!%!7(C%$7#$E!?*+J&*%7!D*+!:;4<<!

[*%+7!C(C/(+92!?B#.B!#$!,5+$!+%#9(9!H5(9,#*$9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(#+!%/#&#,6!,*!7(>*,(!95DD#.#($,!,#C(!

,*!)+*%.,#>(&6!*>(+9((!,B(!%.,#>#,#(9!*D!,B(!9,%DD!%$7!E5#7(!,B(!9,+%,(E#.!7#+(.,#*$!*D!,B(!

*+E%$#F%,#*$G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!)(+.(),#*$!,B%,!?%9!>*#.(7!+()(%,(7&6!#$!,B(!#$,(+>#(?9!?%9!,B%,!,B(!9,%DD!%+(!,%J#$E!,**!

C%$6!5$#&%,(+%&!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!%+(!#$%))+*)+#%,(&6!D#&,(+#$E!.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,2!?(%J($#$E!,B(!

/*,,*CI5)!.*$95&,%,#>(!%$7!)*&#.6IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!-$(!+(.($,!(U%C)&(!)5,!D*+,B!?%9!,B(!

#$.&59#*$!#$!,B(!R4^!*D!.*$$(.,#*$9!,*!,(++*+#9,!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!%9!%!$(?!.+#,(+#*$!D*+!7($6#$E!

%))&#.%,#*$9!D*+!$(?!E8VR9M!,B#9!)+*>#9#*$!?%9!+()*+,(7!,*!/(!$*,!,B(!)+*75.,!*D!,B(!/*,,*CI5)!

)*&#.6IC%J#$E!)+*.(99!/5,!#$9(+,(7!/6!,B(!9,%DDG!:$,(+>#(?((9!%$7!)5/&#.!95/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!

48'8!#$7#.%,(7!%!.*CC5$#,6!)(+.(),#*$!,B%,!,B(!:;4<<!9,%DD!7#9C#99(9!#995(9!*D!.*$.(+$!,*!,B(!

.*CC5$#,6!?#,B!?B#.B!,B(!9,%DD!7*(9!$*,!%E+((M!#$,(+>#(?((9!(U)+(99(7!*$E*#$E!D+59,+%,#*$!?#,B!

,B#9!)(+.(#>(7!9#,5%,#*$G!

:$!.*$,+%9,2!9*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!.*$9#7(+!,B(!E8VR!.%9(!%$!(U%C)&(!*D!+(.($,!#C)+*>(C($,9!#$!

,B(!D&*?!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!D+*C!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!,*!9,%DD!,*![*%+72!)%+,#.5&%+&6!?#,B!+(9)(.,!,*!B*?!

)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!*$!,B(!E8VR!)+*.(99!%+(!95CC%+#F(7!%$7!)%99(7!,*!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!/6!9,%DD!

N(GEG2!.*CC($,9!%+(!%,,+#/5,(7!,*!9)(.#D#.!)(*)&(!%$7!&#$J9!,*!*+#E#$%&!9*5+.(9!%+(!)+*>#7(7OG!

Page 41: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_1A!

;*$,#$5(7!(>*&5,#*$!*D!,B(![*%+7!;*CC#,,((!C*7(&!C%6!%&9*!)+*>#7(!.B%$$(&9!,*!#7($,#D6!%$7!

($E%E(!?#,B!*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!)+#*+#,#(92!($.*5+%E(![*%+7!#$,(+%.,#*$!?#,B!%$%&*E*59!(DD*+,9!

*..5++#$E!%,!/*,B!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!%$7!9,%DD!&(>(&2!%$7!B(&)!C%J(!,B(![*%+7L9!?*+J!C*+(!(DD#.#($,G!

4!)+*%.,#>(!%))+*%.B!#9!(>#7($,!#$!,B(!(9,%/&#9BC($,!*D!<(?![*%+7!;*CC#,,((9!#$!011l2!%$7!,B(!

7#99*&5,#*$!*D!.(+,%#$!(U#9,#$E![*%+7!.*CC#,,((9!#$!*+7(+!,*!9(+>(!S,B(!/(9,!#$,(+(9,9!*D!

:;4<<GTa\!<(?![*%+7!.*CC#,,((9!#$.&57(!,B(!:4<4!;*CC#,,((2!,B(!]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!

;*CC#,,((2!,B(!'#9J!;*CC#,,((2!%$7!,B(!Q,+5.,5+%&!:C)+*>(C($,9!;*CC#,,((Ga_!

]+#*+!+()*+,9!%$7!#$,(+>#(?!+(9)*$9(9!B%>(!B#EB&#EB,(7!,B(!#995(9!%99*.#%,(7!?#,B!%!7(C%$7#$E!

?*+J!&*%7!D*+!,B(![*%+7!%&*$E!?#,B!,B(!.B%&&($E(9!*D!9(,,#$E!)+#*+#,#(9!%C*$E!C%$6!7#9)%+%,(!

%.,#>#,#(9Ga`!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

8B(!#995(!%77+(99(7!#$!,B#9!9(.,#*$!D*.59(9!*$!,B(!7#9,+#/5,#*$!*D!%E($7%I9(,,#$E!%$7!7(.#9#*$I

C%J#$E!+(9)*$9#/#&#,6!/(,?(($!:;4<<!9,%DD!%$7![*%+7!%$7!,B(!H5(9,#*$!*D!B*?!,B(!#$,(+%.,#*$9!

/(,?(($!9,%DD!%$7![*%+7!C%6!/(!9,+5.,5+(7!#$!*+7(+!,*!($95+(!,B%,!.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,9!%+(!/(9,!

5$7(+9,**7!%$7!,%J($!#$,*!%..*5$,!#$!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!!

8B(!H5(9,#*$!*D!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!+(&%,#*$9B#)Z%$7!(DD(.,#>(!#$,(+%.,#*$Z/(,?(($!9,%DD!%$7!

[*%+7!#9!%!H5(9,#*$!,B%,!.B%&&($E(9!C%$6!*+E%$#F%,#*$9G!:$!C*9,!.*+)*+%,#*$9!*D!%$6!9#F(2!,B(!

9,%DD!B%9!%$!#C)*+,%$,2!%$7!*D,($!)+(7*C#$%$,2!+*&(!/*,B!#$!,B(!7%6I,*I7%6!C%$%E(C($,!*D!,B(!

*+E%$#F%,#*$!%$7!#$!9(,,#$E!#,9!&%+E(+!%E($7%G!:$!,B(!D*+I)+*D#,!9)B(+(2!,B#9!#$.+(%9(7!)*?(+!*D!,B(!

(U(.5,#>(!9,%DD!B%9!/(.*C(!%..(),(72!,*!,B(!(U,($,!,B%,!,B(!M:"'(*#)%!#@%-)/0(060"%&'()*(+,"/%2<%

;2'+2'#0"%C2."')#)*"2!%))&#.%/&(!,*!)5/&#.!.*C)%$#(92!9,%,(9=!S8B(!C%$%E(C($,!*D!,B(!/59#$(99!

*D!%!)5/&#.&6!B(&7!.*+)*+%,#*$!9B*5&7!/(!.*$75.,(7!/6!*+!5$7(+!,B(!95)(+>#9#*$!*D!95.B!)+#$.#)%&!

9($#*+!(U(.5,#>(9!%9!%+(!7(9#E$%,(7!/6!,B(![*%+7!*D!7#+(.,*+9GTaa!

8B(!,+($7!#$!$*$)+*D#,9!#9!/+*%7&6!9#C#&%+G!49!*$(!,(U,!*$!$*$)+*D#,!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!9,%,(9=!

P#)#1":")0%2<%)2)+'2<(0%2'1#)(^#0(2)/%)2':#,,?%(/%."/0"$%()%(0/%/")(2'%":+,2?""/B%M%I#/(*%

<6)*0(2)%2<%0D"%82#'$%(/%02%/","*0%0D"/"%"5"*60(."/%#)$%02%2."'/""%0D"('%+"'<2':#)*"B%B%B%B%-0%

D#/%I"")%/611"/0"$%0D#0%#%82#'$_/%:2/0%(:+2'0#)0%Q6$1:")0%(/%0D"%*2)0")0%2<%(0/%#1")$#3%

0D#0%(/3%0D"%$"*(/(2)%#/%02%@D#0%(0%@(,,%0")$%02%#)$%D2@%(0%@(,,%#,,2*#0"%0D"%,(:(0"$%'"/26'*"/%

#)$%0(:"%#.#(,#I,"B%B%B%B%A/6#,,?%:#)#1":")0%'#0D"'%0D#)%0D"%82#'$%/"0/%0D"%#1")$#%<2'%

82#'$%*2)/($"'#0(2)B%TD6/3%0D"%82#'$%(/%:2'"%2<0")%'"#*0(."%0D#)%()(0(#02'?B%TD"%,#'1"'%0D"%

)2)+'2<(0%2'1#)(^#0(2)3%0D"%:2'"%*2:+,"5%#)$%$(."'/"%@(,,%I"%(0/%#*0(.(0("/%#)$%0D"%,"//%

,(9",?%#%82#'$%@(,,%I"*2:"%().2,."$%()%#%+#'0(*6,#'%$"*(/(2)B67%%

8B(+(!%+(!.*C)(,#$E!,B(*+#(9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!9,+($E,B!%$7!&(>(&!*D!($E%E(C($,!*D![*%+79G!

-)(+%,#*$%&!%9)(.,9!*D!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!%+(!$*+C%&&6!7(&(E%,(7!,*!9,%DD!%&*$E!?#,B!%C)&(!&%,#,57(!,*!

C%J(!*)(+%,#*$%&!7(.#9#*$9!/%.J(7!5)!/6!9,+%,(E#.!E5#7%$.(!D+*C!,B(![*%+7G!"*+!:;4<<2!,B(!

(U,($9#>(!*)(+%,#*$%&!%9)(.,9!*D!,B(!*+E%$#F%,#*$!%))(%+9!95#,(7!,*!95.B!%!C*7(&G!K*?(>(+2!,B(!

7(.#9#*$9!C%7(!/6!:;4<<2!D*+!?B#.B!,B(![*%+7!#9!5&,#C%,(&6!+(9)*$9#/&(2!)%+,#.5&%+&6!+(&%,(7!,*!

,B(!.*C)(,#$E!59(!*D!9.%+.(!+(9*5+.(9!%$7!.*C)(,#$E!#$,(+(9,9!?#,B#$!,B(!.*CC5$#,62!95EE(9,9!

,B(!$((7!D*+!9,+*$E(+![*%+7!#$>*&>(C($,!.*C)%+(7!,*!*,B(+!*+E%$#F%,#*$9G!!

Page 42: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_3A!

:$.+(%9#$E!,B(!.%)%.#,6!*D!,B(![*%+7!,*!(DD(.,#>(&6!#$.*+)*+%,(!%$7!+(9)*$7!,*!,B(!D5&&!+%$E(!*D!

#$)5,9!E($(+%,(7!#$!,B(!/*,,*CI5)!)+*.(99(9!*D!:;4<<!?#&&!&#J(&6!+(H5#+(!#$.+(%9#$E!/*,B!,B(!

%C*5$,!%$7!,B(!(DD(.,#>($(99!*D!,#C(!9)($,!/6![*%+7!C(C/(+9!*$!:;4<<L9!%DD%#+9!?B#&(!+(&6#$E!

&(99!*$!,B(!9,%DD!,*!E%5E(!,B(!9($,#C($,9!*D!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!%$7!,*!)+*)(+&6!#$,(+)+(,!,B(#+!#$)5,!

%$7!%7>#.(G!8B#9!#C)&#(9!$*,!%$!(U)%$7(7!+*&(!D*+!,B(![*%+7!/5,!7(()(+!#$>*&>(C($,!#$!#,9!

.5++($,!%.,#>#,#(9G!4!?(&&I#$D*+C(7![*%+7!#9!($,#+(&6!.*$9#9,($,!?#,B!,B(!/*,,*CI5)!$%,5+(!*D!,B(!

*+E%$#F%,#*$M!,B(![*%+7!C59,!/(!#$!%!)*9#,#*$!,*!9)(%J!%..5+%,(&6!%$7!(DD(.,#>(&6!,*!%&&!,B(!

)(+9)(.,#>(9!*D!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6G!e%J#$E!(>($!/(,,(+!59(!*D![*%+7!.*CC#,,((9!.%$!B(&)!

#$.+(%9(!,B(!(DD(.,#>($(99!*D!,B(![*%+7G!-$(!.*5$,(+>%#&#$E!.*$.(+$!#9!,B(!$((7!,*!/(!95+(!,B%,!

.*CC#,,((9!%+(!%7(H5%,(&6!+()+(9($,%,#>(!%.+*99!9,%J(B*&7(+!E+*5)9G!!

:$.+(%9(7!,+%$9)%+($.6!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!9,%DDI[*%+7!+(&%,#*$9B#)!#9!&#J(&6!,*!/*,B!95))*+,!,B(!

%))+*)+#%,(!7#>#9#*$!*D!&%/*+!%$7!+(9)(.,#>(!&(>(&9!*D!+(9)*$9#/#&#,6!%$7!.*$,+*&!/(,?(($!9,%DD!

%$7![*%+72!%$7!%77+(99!,B(!)(+.(),#*$!#995(9!(U)+(99(7!/6!)%+,9!*D!,B(!:;4<<!.*CC5$#,6G!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• ;*$,#$5(!,*!9,+($E,B($!,B(!.%)%.#,6!*D!,B(![*%+7!,*!)+*%.,#>(&6!%$7!>#9#/&6!9,((+!:;4<<!

%.,#>#,#(9G!!

• 477+(99!.*$.(+$9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!%C*5$,!%$7!(DD(.,#>($(99!*D!,#C(!9)($,!/6![*%+7!

C(C/(+9!*$!+(&(>%$,!D%.,ID#$7#$E2!7(&#/(+%,#*$2!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!%$7!*>(+9#EB,!

%.,#>#,#(9G!!

• :$.+(%9(!,B(!&(>(&!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!9,%DDI[*%+7!#$,(+%.,#*$9!,*!D5+,B(+!#$.+(%9(!

)(+D*+C%$.(!%$7!%77+(99!)(+.(),#*$!#995(9!+(E%+7#$E!)*,($,#%&!9,%DD!.%),5+(G!

T=\!./(&01(/2&#,!$I!-2#*0*$&!<(F*&@!

c(d!300%20!

Q*C(!9,%J(B*&7(+9!B%>(!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!?#,B*5,!)+*)(+&6!

,%J#$E!#$,*!%..*5$,!,B(#+!#$)5,!%$7!,B(+(D*+(!?#,B*5,!.*$9#7(+#$E!,B(!D5&&!9(,!*D!+(&(>%$,!D%.,9G!

e5&,#)&(!*))*+,5$#,#(9!D*+!#$)5,!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!B%>(!$*,!+(9*&>(7!,B(!)(+.(),#*$9!,B%,!

9,%J(B*&7(+9!%+(!$*,!/(#$E!D%#+&6!+()+(9($,(7G!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

R(9)#,(!+(.($,!9,()9!,%J($!,*!#$.+(%9(!,+%$9)%+($.6!%/*5,![*%+7!)+*.(99(92!C%$6!#$,(+>#(?((9!

+()*+,(7!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99!#9!*)%H5(!%$7!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!D*+!7(.#9#*$9!$*,!

D5&&6!%+,#.5&%,(7G!XB#&(!,B(!C#$5,(9!*D![*%+7!C((,#$E!%+(!)5/&#9B(7!*$!,B(!:;4<<!?(/9#,(2!9*C(!

#$,(+>#(?!+(9)*$7($,9!+()*+,!,B%,!,B(!C#$5,(9!$(#,B(+!.%),5+(!,B(!D5&&!/%9#9!D*+!7(.#9#*$9!$*+!

)+*>#7(!95DD#.#($,!7(,%#&G!Q5/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'8!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!%+(!

$*,!,+%$9)%+($,=!S7(.#9#*$9!%+(!C%7(!?#,B*5,!%$6*$(!/(#$E!%?%+(!*D!,B(!&*E#.!59(7!,*!%++#>(!%,!

,B(C!%$7!(U)&%$%,#*$9!*D!7(.#9#*$92!#D!%$62!%+(!#$%7(H5%,(GTal!

Page 43: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_0A!

8B(![*%+7!+(.($,&6!7(.#7(7!,*!)5/&#9B!,B(!$*$I.*$D#7($,#%&!9(.,#*$9!*D![*%+7!/+#(D#$E!C%,(+#%&9!

)+()%+(7!/6!,B(!9,%DDG69!;+#,#.9!B%>(!(U)+(99(7!9J(),#.#9C!%/*5,!,B(!,+%$9)%+($.6!(DD(.,2!

B*?(>(+2!9#$.(!%!9#E$#D#.%$,!%C*5$,!*D!#$D*+C%,#*$!B%9!/(($!+(7%.,(7G70!!

4!+(.($,&6!&%5$.B(7!:;4<<!)+*Y(.,!#9!D*.59(7!*$!.+(%,#$E!%!?#J#!,B%,!?#&&!)+*>#7(!S,B(!)5/&#.!

?#,B!(%96I,*I%..(99!#$D*+C%,#*$!*$!(>(+6!95/9,%$,#>(!+(9*&5,#*$!%))+*>(7!/6!,B(![*%+7!*D!

R#+(.,*+9T!%&*$E!?#,B!/%9#.!#$D*+C%,#*$!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!9,%,59!*D!,B(9(!+(9*&5,#*$9G71!4..*+7#$E!,*!

#$,(+>#(?((92!,B#9!)+*.(99!?#&&!9**$!/(!.*C)&(,(7M!*$(!#$,(+>#(?((!9,%,(7!,B%,!,B(!7%,%/%9(!*D!

+(9*&5,#*$9!#9!&#J(&6!,*!/(!&#$J(7!*>(+!,#C(!,*!#C)&(C($,%,#*$!C(%95+(9!,%J($!%,!,B(!9,%DD!&(>(&G!

8B(!?#J#!.5++($,&6!)+(9($,9![*%+7!+(9*&5,#*$9!D+*C!011kG!:,!#9!$*,!(7#,%/&(!*+!#$,(+%.,#>(!%,!,B#9!

9,%E(!N,B(!?#J#!+(D(+($.(9!%$!S477!;*CC($,T!/*U!,B%,!%))(%+9!,*!/(!C#99#$EO2!,B*5EB!*$(!?*5&7!

(U)(.,!,B(9(!D(%,5+(9!#$!%!?#J#G!

!c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

:;4<<!+(&#(9!C*+(!*$!,+%$9)%+($.6!D*+!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!&(E#,#C%.6!,B%$!*,B(+!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!

%$7!,B(+(D*+(!9B*5&7!%+E5%/&6!*DD(+!E+(%,(+!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!#,9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!

K*?(>(+2!,B(!#995(9!%+*5$7!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E!%+(!.*C)&(U!%$7!#$>*&>(!.*$D&#.,#$E!

E*%&9!%$7!$((79G!:$!9*C(!#$9,%$.(92!95.B!%9!)*&#.6!C%J#$E!/6!,B(!"(7(+%&!'(9(+>(!%$7!7(.#9#*$!

C%J#$E!/6!Y5+#(9!%$7!Y57#.#%&!)%$(&92!,B(+(!#9!%!,+%7#,#*$!D*+!J(()#$E!7(&#/(+%,#*$9!#$,($,#*$%&&6!

)+#>%,(G!:$!*,B(+!#$9,%$.(92!95.B!%9!&(E#9&%,#*$2!9*I.%&&(7!S95$9B#$(!&%?9T!%7*),(7!/6!C%$6!9,%,(9!

%+(!#$,($7(7!,*!E#>(!*)($$(99!,*!C%$6!)*&#.6IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!8B(!&(99*$9!*D!.*+)*+%,(!

E*>(+$%$.(!7*!$*,!.&(%+&6!(9,%/&#9B!)*9#,#>(!#C)%.,!*D!E+(%,(+!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!,B(!7(&#/(+%,#>(!

9,%E(9!*D!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$EG!8+%$9)%+($.6!#$!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9!9B*5&7!/(!.*$9#7(+(7!

.%+(D5&&62!9*!%9!,*!)+(9(+>(!,B(!%/#&#,6!*D!,B(![*%+7!,*!7#9.599!C%,,(+9!.%$7#7&6!%$7!,*!C%J(!

.*$9($959!7(.#9#*$9!?B(+(!%))+*)+#%,(G%:$!.*$,(U,9!95.B!%9!)(+9*$$(&!7(.#9#*$9!*+!,B(!.%$7#7!

)*&#.6I9(,,#$E!7(&#/(+%,#*$92!,B(+(!C%6!/(!/($(D#,9!,*!9*C(!C(%95+(!*D!*)%.#,6G!!

:$!,B(!#$D*+C%,#*$IE%,B(+#$E!)B%9(!*D!%!7(.#9#*$2!,+%$9)%+($.6!*$!C%,(+#%&9!95/C#,,(72!

E($(+%,(72!%$7!.*$95&,(7!#9!7(9#+%/&(G!e%J#$E!95.B!C%,(+#%&9!)5/&#.!.%$!B(&)!,*!)+*>*J(!,B(!

)+*>#9#*$!*D!D5+,B(+!C%,(+#%&9!,B%,!C#EB,!*,B(+?#9(!/(!*>(+&**J(7G!"%.,IE%,B(+#$E!B(%+#$E9!#$!

&(E#9&%,#>(!%$7!*,B(+!)*&#.6!.*$,(U,9!%+(!,6)#.%&&6!*)($!,*!,B(!)5/&#.G!!

8B(+(!%+(!.*$,($7#$E!%+E5C($,9!%/*5,!,B(!/($(D#,9!*D!,+%$9)%+($.6!#$!,B(!7(&#/(+%,#*$9!

,B(C9(&>(92!%$7!,B(!.*C)%+%,#>(!)+%.,#.(9!#$!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!95.B!%9!,B(!X*+&7![%$J!%$7!,B(!49#%!

R(>(&*)C($,![%$J!9B*?!7(&#/(+%,(!%$7!/+*%7!(U.(),#*$9!D*+!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#>(!

)+*.(99(9!D+*C!C*+(!E($(+%&&6!%))&#.%/&(!,+%$9)%+($.6!9,%$7%+79!%$7!.*CC#,C($,9G!:$!%!

.*$,(U,!?B(+(!+()+(9($,%,#>(9!D*+!.*$,($7#$E!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!%+(!,+6#$E!,*!D*+E(!%$!*5,.*C(!D*+!

,B(!.*CC*$!E**72!D*+!#$9,%$.(2!,+%$9)%+($.6!.%$!&(%7!,*!.*$9,#,5($.6!)+(995+(!,*!B%+7($!

)*9#,#*$9!%$7!,B59!C%J(!)*9#,#>(!*5,.*C(9!&(99!&#J(&6!,*!*..5+G!-$!,B(!*,B(+!B%$72!.*$9,#,5($.#(9!

C%6!/(!959)#.#*59!,B%,!,B(6!B%>(!/(($!S9*&7!*5,T!#$!%!.*C)+*C#9(!,B%,!*..5+9!#$!%$!*)%H5(!

D%9B#*$G!8B#9!959)#.#*$!.%$!/(!&(99($(7!/6!,B(!.&(%+!($5$.#%,#*$!*D!+(%9*$9!D*+!%!7(.#9#*$!)*9,!

D%.,*!%$7!/6!95DD#.#($,!,+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!($E%E(C($,!/6!,B(![*%+7!#$!,B(!5)ID+*$,!)+*.(992!9*!

,B%,!,B(+(!#9!%$!%995+%$.(!,B%,!,B(!&*9#$E!%+E5C($,9!%$7!#$D*+C%,#*$!?(+(!#$!D%.,!B(%+7!%$7!

C(%$#$ED5&&6!.*$9#7(+(7G!!

Page 44: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_\A!

P$&#J(!C%$6!*,B(+!*+E%$#F%,#*$92!:;4<<!7*(9!$*,!B%>(!,B(!&5U5+6!*D!+(&6#$E!)+(7*C#$%$,&6!*$!

*5,.*C(I/%9(7!C(%95+(9!*D!(DD#.%.6!,*!C%#$,%#$!,B(!.*$D#7($.(!*D!#,9!)%+,#.#)%$,9!%$7!

9,%J(B*&7(+9G!]+*.(99!%$7!)(+.(),#*$!%+(!#C)*+,%$,G!XB#&(!$*,#$E!,B%,!#,!#9!#C)*99#/&(!D*+!:;4<<!

,*!9%,#9D6!%&&!*D!#,9!9,%J(B*&7(+9!%$7!.+#,#.92!,B(!)(+.(),#*$!*D!%$6!#C)+*)+#(,62!?B(,B(+!Y59,#D#(7!

*+!$*,2!+(75.(9!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!,B#9!.*$9($959I/%9(7!*+E%$#F%,#*$G!XB#&(!E+(%,(+!,+%$9)%+($.6!

?#&&!$*,!+(9*&>(!%&&!*D!,B(9(!H5(9,#*$92!#,!#9!%$!#C)*+,%$,!9,()!%$7!%!?*+,B?B#&(!(DD*+,G!!

:C)+*>#$E!,B(!,+%$9)%+($.6!*D!7(.#9#*$9!(U,($79!/(6*$7![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9G!:;4<<!9B*5&7!

.*$,#$5(!,*!.*7#D6!%$7!.&%+#D6!#$,(+$%&!?*+J#$E!)+*.(75+(9!%9!,B(6!.*$,+#/5,(!,*!/(,,(+!.*+)*+%,(!

E*>(+$%$.(G!e*7(&9!D+*C!WP!%$7!PQ!%7C#$#9,+%,#>(!&%?9ZD*+!#$9,%$.(2!+(E%+7#$E!.*$95&,%,#*$!

*+!+5&(C%J#$E!)+*.(99(9Z%$7!,B(#+!(H5#>%&($,9!#$!C%$6!.*5$,+#(9!C%6!9(+>(!%9!9,%+,#$E!)*#$,92!

%&,B*5EB!&(99!.*C)&(U!)+*.(75+(9!?#&&!)+*/%/&6!95#,!,B(!$((79!*D!:;4<<G!](+#*7#.!(>%&5%,#*$9!*D!

#$,(+$%&!.*C)&#%$.(!?#,B!(9,%/&#9B(7!)+*.(75+(9!/6!%!7(7#.%,(7!9,%DD!C(C/(+!%+(!%$!(99($,#%&!

9,()G!!

:;4<<!#9!)%+,!*D!%$!(U)&*+%,#*$!*D!$(?!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(!:$,(+$(,!%$7!*,B(+!7#E#,#F(7!%>($5(9!

.%$!#C)+*>(!*$!,+%7#,#*$%&!E*>(+$%$.(!D*+C9G!:;4<<!9B*5&7!($E%E(!?#,B!,B(!&%+E(+!.*CC5$#,6!

(U)&*+#$E!(I+5&(C%J#$E!%$7!(IE*>(+$%$.(!%,!>%+#*59!&(>(&9!%$7!.*$75.,!(U)&#.#,!(U)(+#C($,9!

?#,B#$!:;4<<L9!)+*.(75+(9G!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&0!

• [(,,(+!7(&#$(%,(!%+(%9!*D!B#EB2!C(7#5C2!%$7!&#C#,(7!7#9.&*95+(!*D![*%+7!#$)5,92!

7(&#/(+%,#*$92!%$7!7(.#9#*$92!%$7!,B(!+%,#*$%&(!D*+!(%.BG!!

• ]+*>#7(!7(,%#&(7!(U)&%$%,#*$9!*D!,B(!+(%9*$9!D*+!,%J#$E!>%+#*59!7(.#9#*$92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!

C%$$(+!#$!?B#.B!(U)(+,!*)#$#*$!%$7!.*CC5$#,6!#$)5,!%+(!D%.,*+(7!#$,*!,B(9(!7(.#9#*$9G!

'(9)(.,D5&&6!+(.%)#,5&%,#$E!,B(!&*9#$E!%+E5C($,9!C%6!/(!59(D5&G!

T=`!3&-212&-2&'!627*28!

B2&2/(+!4$&0*-2/('*$&0!

:;4<<!)+*>#7(9!,B+((!%>($5(9!D*+!+(>#(?!*D![*%+7!%$7!9,%DD!7(.#9#*$9=!,B(!-C/579C%$2!

'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,92!%$7!,B(!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&!N:']OGh0!8*!>%+6#$E!7(E+((92!(%.B!

C(.B%$#9C!#9!%#C(7!%,!#$.+(%9#$E!:;4<<L9!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!4..*+7#$E!,*!,B(![6&%?92!

'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,9!%$7!,B(!:']!S%+(!#$,($7(7!,*!+(#$D*+.(!,B(!>%+#*59!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!

C(.B%$#9C9!*,B(+?#9(!9(,!D*+,BGTh\!8B(!-C/579C%$!S9B%&&!9(+>(!%9!%$!%7>*.%,(!D*+!D%#+$(99T!#$!

.%9(9!#$!?B#.B!,B(!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,!%$7!:']!)+*.(75+(9!B%>(!$*,!/(($!#$>*J(7Gh_!8B(9(!

C(.B%$#9C9!7*!$*,!D*&&*?!%!9)(.#D#.!B#(+%+.B6!*+!9(H5($.(!*D!%.,#>%,#*$M!#$!)+%.,#.(2!B*?(>(+2!

,B(6!#$,(+%.,!?#,B!(%.B!*,B(+!%$7!C%6!/(!#$,(+)+(,(7!%9!%$!S(9.%&%,#*$!C*7(&GT!

8B(!:']!)+*.(99!#$!)%+,#.5&%+!?%9!(U)&#.#,&6!#$,+*75.(7!,*!#$.+(%9(!:;4<<L9!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!:$!

9.B*&%+9B#)!%$7!#$,(+>#(?92!7#DD(+($,!>#(?9!B%>(!/(($!(U)+(99(7!%9!,*!?B%,!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!

+%,#*$%&(!*D!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!#9!%$7!?B%,!J#$7!*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!#,!)+*>#7(9!,*!?B*CG!8B(!

7#9%E+((C($,!%/*5,!,B(!)%+,#.5&%+!+*&(!,B%,!,B(!:']!7*(9!*+!9B*5&7!)&%6!?#,B#$!7#DD(+($,!,B(*+#(9!

*D!%..*5$,%/#&#,6h`!B%9!,+%$9&%,(7!#$,*!)+%.,#.%&!#995(9!,B%,!95+D%.(7!#$!,B(!C%,(+#%&9!+(>#(?92!

Page 45: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @__A!

#$.&57#$E!,B(!H5(9,#*$!*D!?B*!9B*5&7!*+!9B*5&7!$*,!B%>(!9,%$7#$E!5$7(+!,B(!:']!+5&(92!?B%,!,B(!

%))+*)+#%,(!)%$(&!9,+5.,5+(!#92!%$7!?B(,B(+!,B(!7(.#9#*$!/6!,B(!)%$(&!.*5&7!*+!9B*5&7!/(!/#$7#$E!

*+!$*,G!

4&,(+$%,#>(!)+*)*9%&9!D*+!#$7()($7($,!+(>#(?!)+*.(99(9!B%>(!/(($!)5,!D*+,BG!-$(!)+*)*9%&!

?*5&7!#$9,#,5,(!%!.*CC5$#,6!+(I>*,(!C(.B%$#9CG!4$*,B(+!)+*)*9%&!?*5&7!.+(%,(!%!/#$7#$E!

%+/#,+%,#*$!+(E#C(!?#,B!%$!#$7()($7($,!9,%$7#$E!)%$(&!,B%,!?*5&7!9(+>(!%9!%!C(.B%$#9C!,*!

*>(+,5+$![*%+7!7(.#9#*$92!#$.&57#$E!%!)+*>#9#*$!,B%,!?*5&7!*DD(+!,B#+7!)%+,#(92!95.B!%9!

+(E#9,+%$,92!9,%$7#$EGha!:,!#9!*5,9#7(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+()*+,!,*!(U)&*+(!#$!7(,%#&!,B(!C(+#,9!%$7!

7(C(+#,9!*D!,B(9(!+(9)(.,#>(!)+*)*9%&9G![%9(7!*$!,B(!7(,%#&(7!(U)&*+%,#*$!*D!,B(!GUUU!.%9(!+(>#(?!

)+*.(99!%9!+(H5(9,(7!#$!,B(!Q(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!B%9!D*.59(7!*$!,B(!+(>#(?!*D!

,B(!(U#9,#$E!:']!)+*.(992!?#,B!%$!(6(!,*?%+79!,B(!-C/579C%$!%$7!,B(!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,!

)+*.(75+(9!%9!%>($5(9!D*+!(%+&6I9,%E(!7#9)5,(!)+(>($,#*$!%$7!+(9*&5,#*$G!

c(d!300%20!

8B(!:']!)+*.(99!#$!,B(!GUUU!.%9(Z,B(!D#+9,!%$72!,*!7%,(2!*$&6!.%9(!#$!?B#.B!,B(!:']!B%9!/(($!

(C)&*6(7ZB%9!+%#9(7!.*$.(+$9!%/*5,!,B(!.*9,!%$7!%..(99#/#&#,6!*D!,B(!)+*.(99!%$7!#,9!5,#&#,6!%9!

%$!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9CG!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

Q(>(+%&!#$,(+>#(?((9!#$7#.%,(7!,B%,!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!.%$!/(!.*$9#7(+(7!%!95..(992!#$!,B%,!#,!

)+*C),(7!%!+(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!*D!,B(!.%9(2!.*C)(&&(7!:;4<<!,*!)5/&#.&6!7(D($7!,B(!/%9#9!D*+!#,9!

7(.#9#*$2!%$7!.*$>#$.(7!,B(![*%+7!,*!/(E#$!%!$(?!+*5$7!*D!.*$,+%.,!$(E*,#%,#*$9!D*+!%!GUUU!

+(E#9,+6!%E+((C($,!?#,B!:;eG!<*$(,B(&(992!*,B(+!*/9(+>(+9!B%>(!#$7#.%,(7!,B%,!,B(!GUUU!.%9(!

+(>(%&(7!%!$5C/(+!*D!7#DD#.5&,#(9!%$7!&#C#,%,#*$9!#$!,B(!:']2!#$.&57#$E!#,9!.*9,&#$(992!%!&%.J!*D!.&(%+!

)+*.(75+(92!%$7!,B(!)+*/%/&(!7#DD#.5&,6!*D!(C)&*6#$E!,B(!:']!/6!$*$.*CC(+.#%&!#$,(+(9,9G!

:$,(+>#(?((9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!,B(!.*9,2!#$%..(99#/#&#,62!%$7!$*$/#$7#$E!$%,5+(!*D!,B(!+5&#$E9!

*D!,B(!:']!9#E$#D#.%$,&6!+(75.(!,B(!&#J(&#B**7!,B%,!7#9)5,%$,9Z(>($!.*CC(+.#%&!7#9)5,%$,9!?#,B!

%7(H5%,(!+(9*5+.(9Z?#&&!,5+$!,*!,B(!:']!%9!%!C(%$9!*D!+(9*&>#$E!,B(#+!7#9)5,(9G!'%,B(+2!

#$,(+>#(?((9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!,B%,!#,!?*5&7!/(!)+(D(+%/&(!,*!)+*.((7!7#+(.,&6!,*!&#,#E%,#*$!#$!

;%&#D*+$#%!.*5+,9G!:,!B%9!/(($!%+E5(7!,B%,!,B#9!9,%,(!*D!%DD%#+9!D5+,B(+!+(75.(9!,B(!59(D5&$(99!*D!,B(!

:']!%9!%$!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!C(.B%$#9C2!)&%.(9!D5+,B(+!/5+7($9!N#$!,(+C9!*D!,#C(2!+(9*5+.(92!)5/&#.!

#C%E(2!%$7!9*!D*+,BO!*$!%&&!)%+,#(9!#$>*&>(72!%$7!+(75.(9!,B(!%..(99#/#&#,6!*D!%))+*)+#%,(!7#9)5,(!

+(9*&5,#*$!)+*.(99(9!,*!$*$IPQ!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!

:$!&#EB,!*D!,B(!:']L9!D#$7#$E!#$!:;e!>G!:;4<<!,B%,!,B(!:']L9!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9!%+(!$*$I/#$7#$E!*$!

,B(!:;4<<![*%+72!H5(9,#*$9!B%>(!/(($!+%#9(7!*>(+!,B(!)*99#/#&#,6!*D!#$9,#,5,#$E!%!/#$7#$E!

(U,(+$%&!+(>#(?!)+*.(99G!:$7()($7($,!(U)(+,9!B%>(!(U)+(99(7!9,+*$E!7*5/,9!?B(,B(+!%!/#$7#$E!

>(+9#*$!*D!,B(!.5++($,!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C!N?B#.B!%&&*?9!D*+!+(>#(?!*D!%$6![*%+7!%.,#*$9O!?*5&7!

B*&7!5)!5$7(+!;%&#D*+$#%$!.*+)*+%,(!&%?2!%&,B*5EB!%&,(+$%,#>(!7(9#E$9!C%6!?(&&!7*!9*G!8B#9!

#$,(+)+(,%,#*$!#9!95))*+,(7!/6!%!+(.($,!:;4<<!C(C*+%$75C!*$!,B#+7I)%+,6!+(>#(?!*D![*%+7!

%.,#*$9G77!!8B(!C(C*+%$75C!(U)&%#$9!,B%,!,B(!;%&#D*+$#%!;*+)*+%,(!;*7(!)(+C#,9!,B(![*%+7!*D!

R#+(.,*+9!,*!7(&(E%,(!.(+,%#$!C%$%E(C($,!D5$.,#*$9!,*!(C)&*6((92!.*CC#,,((92!%$7!*,B(+!,B#+7!

)%+,#(92!9*!&*$E!%9!,B(!.*+)*+%,(!)*?(+9!%+(!(U(+.#9(7!5$7(+!,B(!5&,#C%,(!7#+(.,#*$!*D!,B(![*%+7G!

K*?(>(+2!%..*+7#$E!,*!,B(!C(C*+%$75C2!,B(![*%+7!#9!)+*B#/#,(7!D+*C!(C)*?(+#$E!%$6!*,B(+!

Page 46: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_`A!

($,#,6!?#,B!%/#&#,6!,*!*>(+,5+$!,B(![*%+7L9!%.,#*$9!*+!7(.#9#*$92!%&,B*5EB!,B(!C(C*+%$75C!7*(9!

+(.*E$#F(!,B(!>%&#7#,6!*D!($,(+#$E!#$,*!/#$7#$E!%+/#,+%,#*$!,B%,!#9!C*+(!$%++*?&6!7(D#$(7!%$7!

/%9(7!*$!.*$,+%.,5%&!%E+((C($,9G!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

Q*C(!*D!,B(!7#99%,#9D%.,#*$!(U)+(99(7!#$!#$,(+>#(?9!%$7!#$!+(>#(?(7!C%,(+#%&9!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!GUUU!

.%9(!%))(%+9!,*!/(!,B(!#$(>#,%/&(!/6)+*75.,!*D!%!7#DD#.5&,2!.*$,(9,(7!#995(G!e%,,(+9!+(&%,(7!,*!9(U!

%$7!D+((!9)((.B!%+(!.B%&&($E#$E!,*!)*&#.6!C%J(+9!#$!%&C*9,!%$6!.*$,(U,!%$7!#$>*J(!9,+*$E2!%$7!

$*,!%&?%69!.*B(+($,2!)*&#,#.%&!.*$9#7(+%,#*$9!#$!C%$6!.*5$,+#(9!%$7!,+%7#,#*$9G!8B(9(!

95/9,%$,#>(!.*$.(+$9!%+(!*5,9#7(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+(>#(?G!K*?(>(+2!,B(!%$(.7*,%&!(>#7($.(!

.*&&(.,(7!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B(!GUUU!.%9(!9,576!.*$D#+C9!,B(!.*$.(+$!(U)+(99(7!#$!)%+,9!*D!,B(!

.*CC5$#,6!,B%,!,B(!.*9,9!*D!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!C%6!/(!)+*B#/#,#>(&6!B#EB!D*+!.(+,%#$!9,%J(B*&7(+9G!

R(9)#,(!,B(!D%.,!,B%,!95.B!%$!*/9(+>%,#*$!#9!.5++($,&6!/%9(7!*$!*$&6!*$(!%))&#.%,#*$!*D!,B(!:']!

)+*.(992!#,!#9!%7>#9%/&(!,*!.&%+#D6!#,9!9.*)(!%$72!#D!$(.(99%+62!,*!.*$9#7(+!%!&(99!/5+7($9*C(!%$7!

.*9,&6!%&,(+$%,#>(G!!

;*$9#7(+#$E!,B(!7(9#E$!*D!,B(!(U#9,#$E!:']!)+*.(99!#$!E($(+%&!%$7!,B(!.5++($,!N/+*%7O!9.*)(!*D!

:']!+(>#(?!%9!9(,!D*+,B!#$!,B(![6&%?9!#$!)%+,#.5&%+2!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!.*$.&57(9!,B%,!#,!#9!$*,!

%7>#9%/&(!,*!#C)&(C($,!95.B!%!/+*%7I+(%.B#$E!/#$7#$E!,B#+7I)%+,6!+(>#(?!*D!%$6![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!

%$7!%.,#*$9G!"#+9,2!%$7!&(E%&!.*$9,+%#$,9!$*,?#,B9,%$7#$E2!#,!#9!H5(9,#*$%/&(!D+*C!%!$*+C%,#>(!

)*&#.6!%$7!E*>(+$%$.(!)(+9)(.,#>(!?B(,B(+!%!/#$7#$E!E($(+%&!,B#+7I)%+,6!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C!

%))&#.%/&(!,*!%&&![*%+7!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!%.,#*$9!?*5&7!#C)+*>(!,B(!9,%,59!H5*G!Q(.*$72!#,!+(C%#$9!

7*5/,D5&!?B(,B(+!95.B!%!/+*%7!+(E#C(!?*5&7!B*&7!5$7(+!;%&#D*+$#%$!.*+)*+%,(!&%?G!e*+(!

)+*C#9#$E2!D+*C!/*,B!&(E%&!%$7!$*+C%,#>(!)(+9)(.,#>(92!%+(!)+*)*9%&9!D*+!/#$7#$E!%+/#,+%,#*$I

/%9(7!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C9!,B%,!%+(!$%++*?(+!#$!,(+C9!*D!,B(#+!9.*)(!*D!+(>#(?M!,B(!7(,%#&(7!

(>%&5%,#*$!*D!95.B!)+*)*9%&92!B*?(>(+2!#9!*5,9#7(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B#9!+()*+,G!8B%,!/(#$E!9%#72!,B(!

$*$I/#$7#$E!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C9!?#,B#$!,B(!.5++($,!9,+5.,5+(!.%$!/(!C%7(!C*+(!(DD(.,#>(!/6!

B%>#$E!,B(![*%+7!C%J(!%!.5&,5+%&!%$7!)+*.(75+%&!.*CC#,C($,!,*!B(%+#$E!#,!*5,!%$7!7(%&#$E!?#,B!

#,!9(+#*59&6G!!

8B(!&(E%&!%$7!)+%.,#.%&!&#C#,%,#*$9!*$!,B(!:']!)+*.(99!B#EB&#EB,!,B(!#C)*+,%$.(!*D!"5%#)0"!

7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!;+(%,#$E!C*+(!+*/59,!%$7!/(,,(+I7(D#$(7!)+*.(99(9!5)!D+*$,!D*+!

)*&#.6!%$7!*,B(+!7(.#9#*$!C%J#$E2!%&*$E!,B(!&#$(9!7#9.599(7!%,!Q(.,#*$!:i!;G0G\N.O!%/*>(2!?#&&!

+(75.(!,B(!$((7!D*+!/%.JI($7!+(>#(?G!R#9)5,(!%>*#7%$.(!#9!E($(+%&&6!/(,,(+!,B%$!"5%+2/0!7#9)5,(!

+(9*&5,#*$G!XB(+(!7#9)5,(9!(C(+E(2!#,!#9!%7>#9%/&(!,*!%77+(99!,B(C!%,!,B(!(%+&#(9,!)*99#/&(!9,%E(!

%$7!,*!($.*5+%E(!%&,(+$%,#>(!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!C(.B%$#9C9ZD*+!#$9,%$.(2!.*$.#&#%,#*$2!

$(E*,#%,#*$2!%$7!C(7#%,#*$Z,*!C#$#C#F(!,B(!(9.%&%,#*$!*D!7#9)5,(9!,*!,B(!)*#$,!?B(+(!%$!:']!

B(%+#$E!?*5&7!/(!$((7(7G!:$!,B#9!.*$,(U,2!#,!#9!%7>#9%/&(!,*!#C)+*>(!,B(!)5/&#.L9!)(+.(),#*$!*D!,B(!

>%+#*59!7#9)5,(!+(9*&5,#*$!C(.B%$#9C92!,*!9,+($E,B($!,B(!-C/579C%$L9!+*&(2!%$7!(U)%$7!,B(!

E+*5$79!*$!?B#.B!%!7#9)5,%$,!.%$!#$#,#%,(!%!'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,G!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&!

• [(,,(+!7(D#$(!,B(!9.*)(!*D!,B(!:']!)+*.(99(92!?#,B!%$!(6(!$*,!*$&6!,*!/(,,(+!%..(99!%$7!

D%#+$(992!/5,!%&9*!,*!.*9,!.*$,%#$C($,!%$7!(%+&6!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!*D!#995(9!,B%,!9B*5&7!/(!

D5&&6!%+E5(7!%$7!/+#(D(7!%$7!,B*9(!,B%,!.%$!/(!+(9*&>(7!%,!%!C*+(!95CC%+6!&(>(&G!

Page 47: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_aA!

!

T=_!E$(/-!(&-!/$+2!$I!'H2!B"4!

B2&2/(+!4$&0*-2/('*$&0!

8B(!^4;!)&%69!%$!#C)*+,%$,!/5,!*D,($!5$.&(%+2!5$.(+,%#$2!%$7!*..%9#*$%&&6!.*$,($,#*59!+*&(!#$!

:;4<<!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9G!8B#9!9(.,#*$!D*.59(9!*$!,B(!?%69!#$!?B#.B!,B(![*%+7!#$,(+%.,9!

?#,B!,B(!^4;!%$7!.*$9#7(+9!#,9!#$)5,9G!

-$!9(>(+%&!*..%9#*$92!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;!B%>(!(U)+(99(7!7#DD(+($,!>#(?9!*$!?B%,!.*$9,#,5,(9!

^4;!%7>#.(!%$7!B*?!^4;!#$)5,9!,*!,B(![*%+7!9B*5&7!/(!B%$7&(7G!:$!)%+,#.5&%+2!C%$6!/(&#(>(!,B%,!

#$!.(+,%#$!#$9,%$.(92!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7!B%9!$(#,B(+!)+*)(+&6!B((7(7!,B(!%7>#.(!*D!,B(!^4;!$*+!

*DD(+(7!,B(!^4;!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!&(>(&!*D!7(D(+($.(G!8B(!%C/#E5#,#(9!95++*5$7#$E!,B(![*%+7I^4;!

+(&%,#*$9B#)!+%#9(!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!,+%$9)%+($.62!%$7!#$>*&>(!.*C)&(U!H5(9,#*$9!+(&%,(7!,*!

7#9)%+%,(!*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!.5&,5+(92!,B(!.B%&&($E(9!*D!%&#E$#$E!#$,(+$%&!)+*.(99(9!%.+*99!C5&,#)&(!

#$9,#,5,#*$92!%$7!.*C)&(U!.+*99I.*CC5$#,6!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!C(.B%$#9C9G!!

:$!b5$(!011k2!,B(![*%+7!(9,%/&#9B(7!%!Y*#$,![*%+7I^4;!?*+J#$E!E+*5)!,*!+(>#(?!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!

^4;!#$!:;4<<2!.*$9#7(+!B*?!,*!/(,,(+!95))*+,!,B(!^4;L9!?*+J2!%$7!7(>(&*)!)+*)*9%&9!D*+!B*?!,*!

#C)+*>(!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!%C*$E!,B(![*%+72!,B(!^4;2!#$7#>#75%&!E*>(+$C($,92!%$7!,B(!:;4<<!

.*CC5$#,6G!X#,B!,B#9!#$!C#$72!,B(!D*&&*?#$E!9(.,#*$!D*.59(9!*$!,?*!9)(.#D#.!#995(9=!,B(!H5(9,#*$!

*D!?B%,!.*$9,#,5,(9!^4;!%7>#.(!%$7!B*?!,B(![*%+7!.%$!#C)+*>(!#,9!#$,(+%.,#*$!?#,B!,B(!^4;!

?#,B#$!,B(!.5++($,!D+%C(?*+J2!)+*.(99(92!%$7!+(9)(.,#>(!+*&(9!%$7!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9G!!

!

T=_=V!R2I*&*'*$&!$I!gB"4!(-7*#2h!

c(d!300%20!

:,!#9!5$.&(%+!?B%,!,6)(9!*D!^4;!#$)5,9!.*$9,#,5,(!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$9!%$7!?B%,!%+(!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!

.B%$$(&9!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!D*+!95/C#,,#$E!^4;!#$)5,!,*!,B(![*%+7G!8B(!^4;!%$7!,B(![*%+7!7*!

$*,!B%>(!C5,5%&!7(D#$#,#*$9!D*+!,B(9(!,(+C9!%$7!7*!$*,!%E+((!*$!%..(),%/&(!C(,B*79!*D!

.*CC5$#.%,#$E!,B(9(!#$)5,9G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

4..*+7#$E!,*!,B(!:;4<<![6&%?92!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!^4;!#9!,*!S.*$9#7(+!%$7!)+*>#7(!%7>#.(!*$!,B(!

%.,#>#,#(9!*D!:;4<<T!?B#.B!+(&%,(!,*!,B(!.*$.(+$9!*D!E*>(+$C($,92!S)%+,#.5&%+&6!?B(+(!,B(+(!C%6!

/(!%$!#$,(+%.,#*$!/(,?(($!:;4<<L9!)*&#.#(9!%$7!>%+#*59!&%?9!%$7!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!%E+((C($,9!*+!

?B(+(!,B(6!C%6!%DD(.,!)5/&#.!)*&#.6!#995(9GT78!!!"5+,B(+C*+(2!,B(!^4;!.%$!95/C#,!%7>#.(!S/6!

)5,,t#$Eu!#995(9!,*!,B(![*%+7!7#+(.,&62!(#,B(+!/6!?%6!*D!.*CC($,!*+!)+#*+!%7>#.(T!*+!/6!

S9)(.#D#.%&&6!+(.*CC($7#$E!%.,#*$!*+!$(?!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!*+!+(>#9#*$!,*!(U#9,#$E!)*&#.#(9GThk!!

K*?(>(+2!,B(![6&%?9!#$.*$9#9,($,&6!9,%,(!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!#9!+(H5#+(7!,*!S+(H5(9,!,B(!2+()(2)T!*D!

,B(!^4;!*$!%$6!)*&#.6!,B%,!S95/9,%$,#%&&6!%DD(.,t9u!,B(!*)(+%,#*$!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,!*+!,B#+7!)%+,#(9T!

*+!S)5/&#.!)*&#.6!.*$.(+$9GTl1!!!

Page 48: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_hA!

8B(!:;4<<![6&%?9!7*!$*,!9)(.#D6!B*?!^4;!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$9!9B*5&7!/(!.*CC5$#.%,(7!,*!,B(!

:;4<<![*%+7Gl3!!Q)(.#D#.%&&62!,B(6!7*!$*,!7(9#E$%,(!%$!#$7#>#75%&!D+*C!,B(!^4;!?B*!#9!

+(9)*$9#/&(!D*+!.*CC5$#.%,#$E!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$!*+!%!7(9#E$%,(7!#$7#>#75%&!D+*C!,B(!:;4<<!

[*%+7!?B*!#9!+(9)*$9#/&(!D*+!+(.(#>#$E!,B(!^4;!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$G!477#,#*$%&&62!,B(![6&%?9!7*!

$*,!.#+.5C9.+#/(!,B(!)(+C#99#/&(!C(7#5C9!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$2!,B%,!#92!,B%,!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!*D!^4;!

#$)5,!?*5&7!2),?%/(!%..(),%/&(!,B+*5EB!&(,,(+9!D+*C!,B(!^4;!;B%#+!%$7!%7*),(7!;*CC5$#H5f9G!!!

4..*+7#$E!,*!#$,(+>#(?9!.*$75.,(7!/6!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!%$7!)5/&#.!95/C#99#*$9!,*!,B(!48'82!

^4;!C(C/(+9!E($(+%&&6!/(&#(>(!,B%,!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$9!.%$!/(!95/C#,,(7!,B+*5EB!%!>%+#(,6!*D!

C(%$92!#$.&57#$E!(IC%#&2!&(,,(+92!#$I)(+9*$!/+#(D#$E9!%,!)5/&#.!%$7!)+#>%,(!Y*#$,!C((,#$E92!%$7!

;*CC5$#H5f9G!"*+!(U%C)&(2!#$!,B(!.*$,(U,!*D!,B(!E8VR!.%9(2!,B(!^4;!9,%,(7!#,9!)*9#,#*$!*$!,B(!

59(!*D!E(*E+%)B#.!$%C(9!%9!,*)I&(>(&!7*C%#$9!#$!9(>($!9()%+%,(!;*CC5$#H5f9!%$7!,?*!&(,,(+9!,*!

,B(![*%+7!/(,?(($!-.,*/(+!011h!%$7!e%+.B!0131G!g(,2!*,B(+!#$,(+>#(?((9!9,%,(7!,B%,!9*C(!

[*%+7!C(C/(+9!/(&#(>(!,B%,!,B(!^4;L9!>#(?!*D!B*?!%7>#.(!%$7!*)#$#*$!.%$!/(!.*CC5$#.%,(7!#9!

*>(+&6!(U)%$9#>(!%$7!,B%,!%7>#.(!9B*5&7!*$&6!.*C(!D+*C!,B(!^4;!;B%#+!#$!?+#,,($!D*+CG!

:$,(+>#(?((9!%&9*!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!#9!*..%9#*$%&&6!/+#(D(7!/6!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!

75+#$E!C((,#$E9M!B*?(>(+2!#,!?%9!5$.&(%+!#D!95.B!/+#(D#$E9!?(+(!#$,($7(7!,*!9(+>(!%9!%$!*DD#.#%&!

.*CC5$#.%,#*$!*D!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$Gl0!!!

8B+*5EB*5,!011_o011h2!?B#&(!,B(!GUUU!98VR!%))&#.%,#*$!?%9!)($7#$E!/(D*+(!,B(![*%+72!9(>(+%&!

C(C/(+9!*D!,B(!^4;2!#$.&57#$E!,B(!^4;!;B%#+2!9($,!7#+(.,!.*++(9)*$7($.(!,*!,B(![*%+7!+(E%+7#$E!

,B(!.%9(Gl\!!Q*C(!&(,,(+9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!%))&#.%,#*$!%$7!*,B(+9!#$,#C%,(7!,B%,!

,B(![*%+7L9!%.,#*$9!?(+(!#$.*$9#9,($,!?#,B!)+#*+!^4;!%7>#.(2![6&%?9!)+*.(75+(92!*+!B%7!$*,!6(,!

/(($!%7(H5%,(&6!%77+(99(7!/6!,B(!^4;2!%$7!+(H5(9,(7!(U)&%$%,#*$!*D!%.,#*$9Gl_!!8B+*5EB*5,!,B#9!

,#C(!)(+#*72!,B(!^4;!#995(7!C5&,#)&(!;*CC5$#H5f9!,B%,!)+*>#7(7!>%+#*59!D*+C9!*D!D((7/%.J!,*!

,B(![*%+7!*$!,B(!GUUU!%))&#.%,#*$Gl`!!:$,(+>#(?((9!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(!.*$D&#.,#$E!$%,5+(!*D!,B(!&(,,(+9!

/6!,B(!^4;!#9!)+*/&(C%,#.2!%9!,B(!.%)%.#,6!*D!,B(!?+#,(+!?%9!$*,!.&(%+&6!7(D#$(7!N#G(G2!?B(,B(+!#,!

?%9!?+#,,($!*$!/(B%&D!*D!,B(!^4;!*+!%9!%$!#$7#>#75%&!C(C/(+!*D!,B(!^4;OG!:$,(+>#(?((9!?(+(!

5$.(+,%#$!B*?!,B(![*%+7!>#(?(7!,B(9(!#$,(+%.,#*$92!%$7!?B(,B(+!,B(![6&%?9!+(H5#+(7!%$!*DD#.#%&!

[*%+7!+(9)*$9(G!:$!9(>(+%&!.%9(92!,B(!^4;!C(C/(+9!?(+(!7#99%,#9D#(7!?#,B!+(9)*$9(9!+(.(#>(7G!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

:,!#9!.&(%+!,B(+(!%+(!7#9.+()%$.#(9!/(,?(($!B*?!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;!#$,(+)+(,!,B(!:;4<<!

[6&%?9G!:$!)%+,#.5&%+2!/*,B!,B(!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!^4;!%7>#.(!%$7!,B(!%))+*)+#%,(!C(,B*7!*D!

.*CC5$#.%,#$E!*D!,B%,!%7>#.(!,*!,B(![*%+7!%+(!.*$,(9,(7G!:$!%77#,#*$!,*!&%.J#$E!%!)+(.#9(!

7(D#$#,#*$!*D!,B(!,(+C!S%7>#.(2T!,B(![6&%?9!59(!S*)#$#*$T!%$7!S.*CC($,T!#$!%!C%$$(+!,B%,!#C)&#(9!

,B(!,(+C9!%+(!#$,(+.B%$E(%/&(G!:,!#9!5$.&(%+!?B(,B(+!,B(9(!,(+C9!?(+(!#$,($7(7!,*!/(!#7($,#.%&!

%$7!%))&6!,*!%$!(H5%&!9.*)(!*D!95/Y(.,!C%,,(+G!!

8B(![6&%?9!7*!$*,!7(9.+#/(!,B(!C(,B*79!/6!?B#.B!,B(!^4;!#9!)(+C#,,(7!,*!95/C#,!#,9!%7>#.(!*+!

*)#$#*$!,*!,B(![*%+7G!:,!#9!%&9*!5$.&(%+!?B#.B!C(,B*79!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!,+#EE(+!,B(![*%+7L9!

*/&#E%,#*$9!#$!,B(![6&%?9!,*!,%J(!,B(!^4;L9!%7>#.(!#$,*!%..*5$,2!,*!)+*>#7(!$*,#.(!%$7!

(U)&%$%,#*$!,*!,B(!^4;!?B($!,B(![*%+7!7(.&#$(9!,*!D*&&*?!^4;!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$2!%$7!,*!?*+J!

?#,B!,B(!^4;!,*!.*C(!,*!%!C5,5%&&6!9%,#9D%.,*+6!.*C)+*C#9(G86!!!

Page 49: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_lA!

W>($,9!7*.5C($,(7!#$!:;4<<!.*++(9)*$7($.(!%$7!^4;!;*CC5$#H5f9!75+#$E!,B(!GUUU!

%))&#.%,#*$!)+*.(99!#$7#.%,(!,B%,!,B(!&%.J!*D!7#9.(+$%/&(!/*5$7%+#(9!D*+!.B%$$(&9!*D!

.*CC5$#.%,#*$!.%59(7!.*$D59#*$!?B($!C5&,#)&(!^4;!C(C/(+9!95/C#,,(7!.*++(9)*$7($.(!,*!,B(!

[*%+7!.*$.5++($,&62!*D,($!(U)+(99#$E!.*$D&#.,#$E!>#(?9!?#,B!)+#*+!%7>#.(!*+!*)#$#*$G!Q*C(!^4;!

C(C/(+9!D(&,!,B(6!B%7!$*,!/(($!E#>($!%7(H5%,(!*))*+,5$#,6!,*!7#9.599!>#(?)*#$,9!?#,B!,B(!

[*%+7!%$7!*,B(+9!D(&,!,B(#+!%7>#.(!?%9!$*,!D*&&*?(7!?#,B*5,!(U)&%$%,#*$G!!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&!

• :$!.&*9(!.*$95&,%,#*$!?#,B!,B(!^4;2!.&%+#D6!?B%,!.*$9,#,5,(9!^4;!S%7>#.(T!*+!S*)#$#*$T!

%$7!.&%+#D6!,B(!C*9,!(DD(.,#>(!.B%$$(&9!*D!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!D*+!95/C#,,#$E!^4;!%7>#.(!,*!

,B(![*%+7G!!

!

T=_=T!!E$(/->B"4!3&'2/(#'*$&!

c(d!300%20!

;*CC5$#.%,#*$!/(,?(($!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;!#9!$*,!%&?%69!9,+*$E2!,#C(&62!*+!(DD#.#($,G!!

c)d!L)02/7('*$&0!

8B(!:;4<<![6&%?9!+(H5#+(!,B(![*%+7!,*!S$*,#D6!,B(!;B%#+!*D!,B(!t^4;u!#$!%!,#C(&6!C%$$(+!*D!%$6!

)+*)*9%&!+%#9#$E!)5/&#.!)*&#.6!#995(9!*$!?B#.B!#,!*+!%$6!*D!:;4<<L9!95))*+,#$E!*+E%$#F%,#*$9!*+!

%7>#9*+6!.*CC#,,((9!9((J9!)5/&#.!.*CC($,GTlh!!8B(![*%+7!#9!%&9*!+(H5#+(7!S,*!+(H5(9,!,B(!

*)#$#*$!*D!,B(!^4;T!*$!S%$6!)*&#.#(9!,B%,!%+(!/(#$E!.*$9#7(+(7!/6!,B(![*%+7!D*+!%7*),#*$!,B%,!

95/9,%$,#%&&6!%DD(.,!,B(!*)(+%,#*$!*D!,B(!#$,(+$(,!*+!,B#+7!)%+,#(9T!*+!S)5/&#.!)*&#.6!.*$.(+$9GTll!

:$!.%9(9!?B(+(!,B(!^4;!#995(9!%7>#.(lk!,*!,B(![*%+72!+(E%+7&(99!*D!?B(,B(+!95.B!%7>#.(!#9!

+(H5(9,(72!,B(!%7>#.(!C59,!/(!S75&6!,%J($!#$,*!%..*5$,2!/*,B!#$!,B(!D*+C5&%,#*$!%$7!%7*),#*$!*D!

)*&#.#(9T!/6!,B(![*%+7Gk1!!:D!,B(![*%+7!S7(,(+C#$(9!,*!,%J(!%$!%.,#*$!,B%,!#9!#$.*$9#9,($,!?#,B!,B(!

t^4;L9u!%7>#.(T!,B(![*%+7!C59,!S9,%,(!,B(!+(%9*$9!?B6!#,!7(.#7(7!$*,!,*!D*&&*?!,B%,!%7>#.(T!%$7!

,+6!,*!D#$7!%!SC5,5%&&6!%..(),%/&(!9*&5,#*$GTk3!!:D!$*!9*&5,#*$!#9!D*5$72!,B(![*%+7!#9!+(H5#+(7!,*!

9,%,(!,B(!+(%9*$9!?B6!,B(!^4;!%7>#.(!?%9!$*,!D*&&*?(7!#$!#,9!D#$%&!7(.#9#*$Gk0!

8B(!^4;!%))*#$,9!%!S$*$I>*,#$E!&#%#9*$!,*!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7T!%$$5%&&6Gk\!!8B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!#9!

($,#,&(7!,*!%,,($7![*%+7!C((,#$E92!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$![*%+7!7#9.599#*$9!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#*$92!%$7!B%>(!

%..(99!,*!.(+,%#$!+(&%,(7![*%+7!/+#(D#$E!C%,(+#%&9Gk_!V#%#9*$9!,*!,B(![*%+7!%+(!%&9*!)(+C#,,(7!,*!

S59(!%$6!C%,(+#%&9!)+*>#7(7!,*!,B(C!G!G!G!D*+!,B(!)5+)*9(!*D!.*$95&,#$E!?#,B!,B(#+!+(9)(.,#>(!

.*CC#,,((!*+!*+E%$#F%,#*$GTk`!!Q*C(!#$,(+>#(?((9!$*,(7!,B%,!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!*..%9#*$%&&6!/+#(D9!

,B(![*%+7!*$!#995(9!*D!.*$.(+$!,*!^4;!C(C/(+9!%$7!,B%,!,B(+(!#9!%!E($(+%&!(U)(.,%,#*$!,B%,!,B(!

^4;!V#%#9*$!/+#(D9!^4;!C(C/(+9!*$!)($7#$E!#995(9!/(D*+(!,B(![*%+72!(U.(),!#$!#$9,%$.(9!?B(+(!

.*$D#7($,#%&#,6!#9!+(H5#+(7G!8B(!^4;!B%9!.*$9#9,($,&6!%))*#$,(7!,B(!^4;!;B%#+!%9!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!

,B(![*%+7Gka!

:$,(+>#(?((9!C%7(!.&(%+!,B%,!,B(!C%Y*+#,6!*D![*%+7!C(C/(+9!/(&#(>(!)+(9($.(!*D!,B(!^4;!

V#%#9*$!75+#$E![*%+7!C((,#$E9!#9!95DD#.#($,!,*!)5,!,B(!^4;!*$!S$*,#.(T!*D!)+*)*9%&9!,B%,!+%#9(!

)5/&#.!)*&#.6!#995(9!%9!#9!+(H5#+(7!#$!,B(![6&%?9Gkh!!K*?(>(+2!*,B(+!#$,(+>#(?((9!$*,(7!,B%,!^4;!

Page 50: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @_kA!

C(C/(+9!B%>(!#$,(+)+(,(7!,B#9![6&%?!)+*>#9#*$!,*!+(H5#+(!C*+(!9)(.#D#.!$*,#.(!#$!C*+(!D*+C%&!

.*++(9)*$7($.(!,*!,B(!^4;!;B%#+2!95.B!%9!%!?+#,,($!&(,,(+G!Q*C(!^4;!C(C/(+9!B%>(!%&9*!

(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!$*,#.(!D+*C!,B(![*%+7!*D!)+*)*9(7!)*&#.6!7(.#9#*$9!#9!$*,!%&?%69!,#C(&6G!

:$!95.B!.%9(92!+(.(#>#$E!%!&%,(!$*,#.(!%7>(+9(&6!%DD(.,(7!,B(!^4;L9!%/#&#,6!,*!(DD(.,#>(&6!)+*>#7(!

%7>#.(!*$!)($7#$E!#995(9!#$!%!,#C(&6!C%$$(+G!477#,#*$%&&62!^4;!C(C/(+9!B%>(!(U)+(99(7!

.*$.(+$9!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!7*(9!$*,!)+*>#7(!D((7/%.J!*$!^4;!%7>#.(!,B%,!B%9!%&+(%76!/(($!

95/C#,,(7!,*!,B(![*%+72!#$.&57#$E!?B(,B(+!%77#,#*$%&!^4;!%7>#.(!?*5&7!/(!B(&)D5&G!!

8B(9(!*/9(+>%,#*$9!%+(!#$7()($7($,&6!95))*+,(7!/6!:;4<<!7*.5C($,9G!"*+!#$9,%$.(2!D*&&*?#$E!

,B(!b5$(!32!011`![*%+7!+(9*&5,#*$!,*!/(E#$!$(E*,#%,#$E!,B(!,(+C9!*D!%!+(E#9,+6!%E+((C($,!D*+!,B(!

GUUU!)+*)*9%&2!9(>(+%&!^4;!C(C/(+9!(U)+(99(7!.*$.(+$9!,B%,!,B(!GUUU!)+*)*9%&!B%7!S9#E$#D#.%$,!

#C)%.,9!#$!&*.%&!.*$.(+$9T!%$7!,B%,!,B(!^4;!B%7!#$%7(H5%,(!,#C(!,*!.*$9#7(+!C(+#,9!*D!,B(!

)+*)*9%&Gkl!!Q()%+%,(&62!,B+*5EB*5,!011ho0131!,B(!^4;!#995(7!9(>($!;*CC5$#H5f9!+()(%,#$E!#,9!

%7>#.(!+(E%+7#$E!,B(!59(!*D!E(*E+%)B#.!,*)I&(>(&!7*C%#$9G!

4&,B*5EB!,B(![6&%?9!9)(.#D6!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!S9B%&&!$*,#D6!,B(!;B%#+!*D!,B(!^*>(+$C($,%&!47>#9*+6!

;*CC#,,((!G!G!G!*D!%$6!)+*)*9%&9!+%#9#$E!)5/&#.!)*&#.6!#995(92Tkk!,B(![6&%?9!7*!$*,!9)(.#D6!,B(!&(>(&!

*D!7(,%#&!+(H5#+(7!#$!,B(!$*,#D#.%,#*$!^4;!;B%#+!N#G(G2!?B(,B(+!,B(!$*,#D#.%,#*$!C(+(&6!+(H5#+(9!%!

E($(+%&!$*,#.(!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!#9!.*$9#7(+#$E!%!)+*)*9%&2!*+!?B(,B(+!,B(!$*,#D#.%,#*$!C59,!

7(9.+#/(!9)(.#D#.9!+(&%,(7!,*!,B(!)+*)*9%&OG!!

c#d!R*0#%00*$&!

8B(!&%.J!*D!.&(%+!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!,B(!,#C(&6!%.J$*?&(7EC($,!*D!%$7!+(9)*$9(!,*!,B(!+%$E(!*D!^4;!

#$)5,9!/6!,B(![*%+7!C%6!#C)(7(!,B(!)*&#.6!7(>(&*)C($,!)+*.(992!%9!,B(!^4;!C%6!D((&!.*C)(&&(7!

,*!+(9,%,(!#,9!)*9#,#*$9!?B($!#,!B%9!$*,!+(.(#>(7!%!95DD#.#($,!+(9)*$9(G!'(.(#>#$E!,#C(&6!$*,#.(!*D!

)($7#$E!)+*)*9%&9!%&9*!%))(%+9!,*!/(!%$!%+(%!$((7#$E!)+*.(75+%&!%$7!95/9,%$,#>(!

#C)+*>(C($,9G!8B(!^4;L9!+()(%,(7!;*CC5$#H5f9!*$!,B(!59(!*D!E(*E+%)B#.!$%C(9!%9!,*)I&(>(&!

7*C%#$9!#$7#.%,(!#,!B%7!$*,!+(.(#>(7!%!95DD#.#($,!+(9)*$9(!D+*C!,B(![*%+7!*$!,B#9!#995(G!

8B(!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!*D!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!%+(!%C/#E5*59G!8B(![6&%?9!7*!$*,!9)(.#D6!

,B(!)+*%.,#>(!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!*D!,B(!V#%#9*$9!/(6*$7!/(#$E!S>*&5$,((+9T!?#,B!,B(!%/#&#,6!,*!

S%,,($7![*%+7!C((,#$E92!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$![*%+7!7#9.599#*$9!%$7!7(&#/(+%,#*$9T!%$7!%..(99!

SC%,(+#%&9GT311!!:,!9((C9!&#J(&6!,B%,!,B(![*%+7!%$7!,B(!^4;L9!7#DD(+#$E!#$,(+)+(,%,#*$9!*D!V#%#9*$!

+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!C%6!5$7(+&#(!9*C(!*D!,B(!.*CC5$#.%,#*$!)+*/&(C9!#7($,#D#(7!%/*>(G!

c-d!62#$<<2&-('*$&!

• '(>#9(!%$7!*/9(+>(!)+*.(75+(9!D*+!,#C(&6![*%+7!+(9)*$9(9!,*!^4;!95/C#99#*$9G!

R(,(+C#$(!?B(,B(+!,B(![*%+7!%$7!^4;!?*5&7!/($(D#,!D+*C!C*+(!D+(H5($,!Y*#$,!

C((,#$E9G!;&%+#D6!+*&(9!%$7!+(9)*$9#/#&#,#(9!#$!.*CC5$#.%,#$E![*%+7!+(H5(9,9!D*+!^4;!

%7>#.(2!#$.&57#$E!,B(!+*&(!*D!,B(!^4;!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!#$!,B#9!)+*.(99G!

!

Page 51: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @`1A!

95R5L.9;!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

3!:;4<<2!4DD#+C%,#*$!*D!;*CC#,C($,92!)%+%E+%)B!kG32!Q(),(C/(+!\12!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p7*.5C($,9p%DD#+C%,#*$I*DI.*CC#,C($,9I\19()1kI($GB,CG!

0!:;4<<2!S4))&#.%,#*$9!'(.(#>(7!D*+!,B(!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!'(>#(?2T!4)+#&!302!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p+(>#(?I3I%))&#.%,#*$9I($GB,CG!

\!:;4<<2!4*;2!)%+%E+%)B!kG3G!

_!:;4<<2!S4.,#>#,#(9!*D!,B(!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!'(>#(?!8(%C2T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p%.,#>#,#(9I3I($GB,CG!

`!:;4<<2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!'(>#(?!8(%CZQ(&(.,#*$!*D!:$7()($7($,!WU)(+,!%$7!P)7%,(!*$!48'8!'(>#(?2T!45E59,!312!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I31%5E31I($GB,CG!!

a!:;4<<2!SQ(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2T!45E59,!`2!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$pB%+>%+7I9(+>#.(9I

%E+((C($,I1`%5E31I($G)7DG!

h!Q((2!(GEG2!b*$%,B%$!n#,,+%#$G!r:;4<<=![(,?(($!,B(!]5/&#.!%$7!,B(!]+#>%,(2r!8"'9","?%T"*D)2,21?%!#@%N26')#,!3_!N3kkkO!

%$7!b*B$!]%&D+(62!S8B(!W$7!*D!,B(!WU)(+#C($,=!K*?!:;4<<L9!"*+%6!#$,*!^&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!R(C*.+%.6!"%#&(72T!F#'.#'$%N26')#,%2<%!#@%#)$%T"*D)2,21?!3h!N011_OG!!

l!:;4<<2!SQ(+>#.(9!4E+((C($,2T!45E59,!`2!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$pB%+>%+7I9(+>#.(9I%E+((C($,I1`%5E31I($G)7DG!

k!'*&D!KG!X(/(+2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!#$!:$,(+$(,!^*>(+$%$.(2T!-)0"')#0(2)#,%N26')#,%2<%;2::6)(*#0(2)/%!#@%=%&2,(*?!3\!

N011kO=!3`\I3ahG!

31!:;4<<2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!"+%C(?*+J9!%$7!]+#$.#)&(92T!%))+*>(7!"(/+5%+6!3`2!011l2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%..*5$,%/#&#,6pD+%C(?*+J9I)+#$.#)&(9p.*$,($,9I*>(+>#(?GB,CG!

33!Q((!b*$%,B%$!^Q!d*))(&&2!S]%,B*&*E#(9!*D!4..*5$,%/#&#,6=!:;4<<!%$7!,B(!;B%&&($E(!*D!ve5&,#)&(!4..*5$,%/#&#,#(9!

R#9*+7(+2LT!&6I,(*%M$:()(/0'#0(2)%E".("@!a`!N011`O=!k_o31lM!b*B$!]%&D+(62!TD"%4)$%2<%0D"%45+"'(:")0]%F2@%-;MGG`/%J2'#?%

()02%C,2I#,%-)0"')"0%7":2*'#*?%J#(,"$2!K%+>%+7!]5/&#.!V%?!X*+J#$E!]%)(+!<*G!k\p[(+JC%$!;($,(+!'(9(%+.B!]5/&#.%,#*$!

<*G!011_I10!N011_OM!e#&,*$!e5(&&(+2!S:;4<<2!:$.G=!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!,B(!E*>(+$%$.(!*D!.+#,#.%&!:$,(+$(,!

+(9*5+.(92T!:$,(+$(,!^*>(+$%$.(!]+*Y(.,2!<*>(C/(+!3a2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#$,(+$(,E*>(+$%$.(G*+Ep)7Dp:;4<<:$.G)7DM!

%$7!'*&D!KG!X(/(+2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!#$!:$,(+$(,!^*>(+$%$.(2T!-)0"')#0(2)#,%N26')#,%2<%;2::6)(*#0(2)/%!#@%=%&2,(*?!3\!N011kO=!3`\I3ahG!

30!Q((!b*$%,B%$!^Q!d*))(&&2!S]%,B*&*E#(9!*D!4..*5$,%/#&#,6=!:;4<<!%$7!,B(!;B%&&($E(!*D!ve5&,#)&(!4..*5$,%/#&#,#(9!R#9*+7(+2LT!&6I,(*%M$:()(/0'#0(2)%E".("@!a`!N011`O=!k_o31lG!

3\!e#&,*$!e5(&&(+2!S:;4<<2!:$.G=!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!,B(!E*>(+$%$.(!*D!.+#,#.%&!:$,(+$(,!+(9*5+.(92T!:$,(+$(,!^*>(+$%$.(!]+*Y(.,2!<*>(C/(+!3a!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#$,(+$(,E*>(+$%$.(G*+Ep)7Dp:;4<<:$.G)7D2!3G!

3_!:/#7G2!aG!

3`!Q((!'G!QB%?$!^5$$%+9*$2!S4!"+(9B!Q,%+,!D*+!:;4<<2T!d#+,*$!m!e.;*$J#(2!b5$(!32!01312!

B,,)=pp???G,(.B)*&#.6#$9,#,5,(G*+EpD#&(9pE5$$%+9*$w#.%$$x01?B#,(x01)%)(+G)7D2!03G!^5$$%+9*$!%+E5(9!,B%,!:;4<<q9!

*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!9,+5.,5+(!#9!#$.*C)%,#/&(!?#,B!E($5#$(!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!,*!,B(!:$,(+$(,!.*CC5$#,6=!SG!G!G!9,+5.,5+(!?#&&!7(D(%,!

%$6!(DD*+,!,*!+(9*&>(!,B(9(!)(+9#9,($,!.+#,#.#9C9G!8B(!D%5&,!&#(9!$*,!#$!%!9#$E&(!)(+9*$!*+!)*&#.62!/5,!#$!:;4<<L9!

*+E%$#F%,#*$%&!9,+5.,5+(G!:,9!/*%+7!*D!7#+(.,*+9!B*&79!5$+(>#(?%/&(!)*?(+!*>(+!?B%,!#92!%D,(+!%&&2!%!)+#>%,(!.*+)*+%,#*$G!:,9!

*+#E#$9!.%9,!7*5/,!*$!,B(!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!#,9!%5,B*+#,6GT!!Q#C#&%+&62!%!)*&#.6!7*.5C($,!D+*C!,B(!W5+*)(%$!P$#*$!%+E5(9!,B%,!

E($5#$(!%..*5$,%/#&#,6!D*+!:;4<<!B#$E(9!*$!S(DD(.,#>(!C(.B%$#9C9!D*+!#$7()($7($,!9.+5,#$6!%$7!+(>#(?!*D!#,9![*%+7!

7(.#9#*$9!%$7!#$7()($7($,!%))(%&!C(.B%$#9C9!G!G!G!/%9(7!*$!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!&%?GT!Q((!;*5$.#&!*D!,B(!W5+*)(%$!P$#*$2!

:$,(+$%,#*$%&!e%$%E(C($,!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,!R*C%#$!<%C(!Q69,(C2!R*.G!33ka1p1k2!4$$(U2!b5&6!3_2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G9(011kG(5p)*&*)*&6wD9p3G3h000yC($5p9,%$7%+7pD#&(p;*+()(+x01^5#7(&#$(9x01*$x01:$,(+$(,G)7D2!_G!

3a!'*&D!KG!X(/(+2!S:$,(+$(,!E*>(+$%$.(=!8+%$9)%+($.6!%$7!,B(!E*>(+$%$.(!*D!,B(!:$,(+$(,2T!;2:+60"'%!#@%=%>"*6'(0?%E"+2'0!0_!N011lO=!\_0o\_lG!

3h!:;4<<2!S:;4<<!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!m!8+%$9)%+($.6!"+%C(?*+J9!%$7!]+#$.#)&(92T!%))+*>(7!"(/+5%+6!3`2!011l2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p,+%$9)%+($.6p%..,I,+%$9ID+%C(?*+J9I)+#$.#)&(9I31Y%$1lG)7DG!!

3l!e#&,*$!e5(&&(+2!S:;4<<2!:$.G=!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!,B(!E*>(+$%$.(!*D!.+#,#.%&!:$,(+$(,!+(9*5+.(92T!:$,(+$(,!

^*>(+$%$.(!]+*Y(.,2!<*>(C/(+!3a2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#$,(+$(,E*>(+$%$.(G*+Ep)7Dp:;4<<:$.G)7D2!3lG!4&9*!9((!b*B$!

]%&D+(62!S8B(!W$7!*D!,B(!WU)(+#C($,=!K*?!:;4<<L9!"*+%6!#$,*!^&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!R(C*.+%.6!"%#&(72T!F#'.#'$%N26')#,%2<%!#@%#)$%T"*D)2,21?!3h!N011_OG!

3k!'*&D!KG!X(/(+2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!#$!:$,(+$(,!^*>(+$%$.(2T!-)0"')#0(2)#,%N26')#,%2<%;2::6)(*#0(2)/%!#@%=%&2,(*?!3\!N011kO=!3`\I3ahG!

01!e#&,*$!e5(&&(+2!S:;4<<2!:$.G=!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!#$!,B(!E*>(+$%$.(!*D!.+#,#.%&!:$,(+$(,!+(9*5+.(92T!:$,(+$(,!^*>(+$%$.(!]+*Y(.,2!<*>(C/(+!3a2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#$,(+$(,E*>(+$%$.(G*+Ep)7Dp:;4<<:$.G)7DG!

03!b*B$!]%&D+(62!S8B(!W$7!*D!,B(!WU)(+#C($,=!K*?!:;4<<L9!"*+%6!#$,*!^&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!R(C*.+%.6!"%#&(72T!F#'.#'$%N26')#,%

2<%!#@%#)$%T"*D)2,21?!3h!N011_O2!3`G!

00!Q((!4))($7#.(9!;oW!D*+!D5&&!>(+9#*$9G!!

Page 52: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @`3A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

0\!Q((!4))($7#.(9!4!%$7![!D*+!7(,%#&9G!

0_!Q((!Q(.,#*$!::![G3G!

0`!:;4<<2!SR*.5C($,%+6!:$D*+C%,#*$!R#9.&*95+(!]*&#.62T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p,+%$9)%+($.6p7#7)I($GB,CG!

0a!:;4<<2!SX(!<((7!g*5+!:$)5,!,*!;B%$E(!,B(!:;4<<!X(/9#,(2T!b5&6!0l2!011a2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p?(/9#,(I($B%$.(C($,I0lY5&1aGB,CG!

0h!d#(+($!e.;%+,B62!SK(&)!59!,*!#C)+*>(!,B(!:;4<<!?(/9#,(Z*$&#$(!95+>(62T!-;MGG%8,212!b5$(!3k2!011k2!B,,)=pp/&*EG#.%$$G*+Ep011kp1apB(&)I59I,*I#C)+*>(I,B(I#.%$$I?(/9#,(I*$&#$(I95+>(6pG!

0l!d#(+($!e.;%+,B62!SP)7%,(!*$!?(/9#,(!+(>%C)2T!-;MGG%8,212!-.,*/(+!012!011k2!B,,)=pp/&*EG#.%$$G*+Ep011kp31p5)7%,(I*$I?(/9#,(I+(>%C)pG!

0k!:;4<<2!S:;4<<![*%+7!'(9*&5,#*$9!X#J#!V%5$.B(7Z]5/&#.!;*CC($,!W$.*5+%E(72T!b5$(!032!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I03Y5$31I($GB,CG!

\1!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!hG!!

\3!:;4<<2!SR:R]!'(H5(9,9!%$7!'(9)*$9(92T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p,+%$9)%+($.6p7#7)I+(H5(9,9I%$7I+(9)*$9(9I($GB,CG!

\0!:;4<<2!SR*.5C($,%+6!:$D*+C%,#*$!R#9.&*95+(!]*&#.62T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p,+%$9)%+($.6p7#7)I($GB,CG!

\\!:/#7G!

\_!:/#7G!

\`!:;4<<2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!"+%C(?*+J9!%$7!]+#$.#)&(9=!4..*5$,%/#&#,6!#$!,B(!]5/&#.!Q)B(+(2T!%))+*>(7!"(/+5%+6!3`2!011l2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G.*Cp($p%..*5$,%/#&#,6pD+%C(?*+J9I)+#$.#)&(9p)5/&#.I9)B(+(GB,CG!

\a!:;4<<2!SR%9B/*%+7=!:;4<<!](+D*+C%$.(!e(,+#.9Z'(D+(9B(72T!B,,)9=pp.B%+,9G#.%$$G*+Ep)5/&#.pG!

\h!b*B$!]%&D+(62!S8B(!W$7!*D!,B(!WU)(+#C($,=!K*?!:;4<<L9!"*+%6!#$,*!^&*/%&!:$,(+$(,!R(C*.+%.6!"%#&(72T!F#'.#'$%NB%2<%!B%#)$%T"*DB!3h!N011_OG!

\l!:/#7G2!\G!

\k!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!:2!Q(.,#*$!0G_2!45E59,!`2!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($pE($(+%&p/6&%?9GB,CG!

_1!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!aG!4+,#.&(!:::!%&9*!.*$,%#$9!)+*>#9#*$9!+(&%,(7!,*!%!e%$%E(+!*D!]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!%$7!,B(!

C%#$,($%$.(!*D!,B(!:;4<<!?(/9#,(G!4$$(U(9!4!%$7![!%77+(99!9,%$7%+79!D*+!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!?#,B#$!,B(!^<Q-!%$7!..<Q-!]*&#.6!R(>(&*)C($,!]+*.(99(9G!

_3!:;4<<2!S4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!"+%C(?*+J9!%$7!]+#$.#)&(92T!%))+*>(7!"(/+5%+6!3`2!011l2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep,+%$9)%+($.6p%..,I,+%$9ID+%C(?*+J9I)+#$.#)&(9I31Y%$1lG)7DG!

_0!:;4<<2!SR*.5C($,!]5/&#.%,#*$!-)(+%,#*$%&!]*&#.62T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p)%+,#.#)%,(p7+%D,I7*.5C($,I

)5/&#.%,#*$I*)(+%,#*$%&I)*&#.6I($G)7DG!8B(!)*&#.6!S($.*5+%E(t9u!,B(!(%+&6!9B%+#$E!*D!7*.5C($,%,#*$GGGD*+!)5/&#.!+(>#(?!

%$7!7#9.599#*$T!%,!:;4<<!C((,#$E9G!

_\!:;4<<2!4*;2!)%+%E+%)B!kG3G!

__!:;4<<![6&%?9!NS<(?![6&%?9TO2!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!\2!R(.(C/(+!3`2!01102!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($pE($(+%&p%+.B#>(I/6&%?9p/6&%?9I3`7(.10GB,CG!

_`!<#.J!49B,*$IK%+,2!S'(C*,(!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!D*+!<%#+*/#=!R(,%#&9!4>%#&%/&(2T!-;MGG%8,212!"(/+5%+6!3a2!01312!B,,)=pp/&*EG#.%$$G*+Ep0131p10p+(C*,(I)%+,#.#)%,#*$ID*+I$%#+*/#I7(,%#&9I%>%#&%/&(pG!

_a!:;4<<2!S]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!;*CC#,,((!*D!,B(![*%+7=!]+*)*9(7!X*+J!]+*E+%CC(!D*+!0131p01332T!e%+.B!302!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*CC#,,((9p)%+,#.#)%,#*$p)+*)*9(7I?*+JI)+*E+%CC(ID*+I0131I0133I30C%+31I($G)7DG!

_h!^<Q-2!S;;8!"#$%&!;*$9*&#7%,(7!'(.*CC($7%,#*$92T!4)+#&!k2!01312!B,,)=ppE$9*G#.%$$G*+Ep7+%D,9p..,I.*$9*&#7%,(7I+()*+,ID#$%&I1k%)+31I($G)7DG!

_l!^<Q-2!S;*5$.#&!'(9*&5,#*$92T!b5$(!0\2!01312!B,,)=ppE$9*G#.%$$G*+Ep+(9*&5,#*$9pz01311aG!

_k!:;4<<2!SQ,+%,(E#.!]&%$!Q5+>(62T!<*>(C/(+!3k2!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I3k$*>1kI($GB,CG!

`1!Q((!W5+*)(%$!;*CC#99#*$2!S;*7(.#9#*$=!-+7#$%+6!V(E#9&%,#>(!]+*.(75+(!vQ,()!/6!Q,()L2T!

B,,)=pp(.G(5+*)%G(5p.*7(.#9#*$p9,()/69,()p,(U,p#$7(Uw($GB,Cz3M!%$7!W5+*)(%$!;*CC#99#*$2!SQ,()9!#$!,B(!Q,+%,(E6=!

Q,+%,(E#.!]&%$$#$E!%$7!]+*E+%CC#$E2T!B,,)=pp(.G(5+*)%G(5p%,?*+Jp9,+%,(E#.)&%$$#$Ep#$7(Uw($GB,CG!Q((!%&9*!X#J#C(7#%2!

SQ,+%,(E#.!]&%$$#$E!]+*.(992T!B,,)=pp9,+%,(E6G?#J#C(7#%G*+Ep?#J#p]+*.(99M!%$7!X#J#C(7#%2!SQ,+%,(E#.!]&%$!]+#*+#,#(92T!B,,)=pp9,+%,(E6G?#J#C(7#%G*+Ep?#J#pQ,+%,(E#.w]&%$pe*>(C($,w]+#*+#,#(9G!

`3!Q((!K($+6!;B(9/+*5EB2![+")%-))2.#0(2)]%TD"%G"@%-:+"'#0(."%J2'%;'"#0()1%#)$%&'2<(0()1%J'2:%T"*D)2,21?!!!N[*9,*$=!

K%+>%+7![59#$(99!Q.B**&!]+(992!011aOG!

`0!:;4<<2!S:;4<<!e((,#$E!"(&&*?9B#)92T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($pD(&&*?9B#)9pG!Q((!%&9*!:;4<<2!SX(/#$%+92T!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p&(%+$#$Ep?(/#$%+9GB,CM!:;4<<2!S]+(&#C#$%+6!'()*+,=!'(9*&5,#*$9!*D!Q)(.#%&![*%+7!e((,#$E2T!e%6!032!011k2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($pC#$5,(9p)+(&#CI+()*+,I03C%61kGB,CG!!

`\!:;4<<2!S]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!;*CC#,,((!*D!,B(![*%+7=!]+*)*9(7!X*+J!]+*E+%CC(!D*+!0131p01332T!e%+.B!302!01312!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*CC#,,((9p)%+,#.#)%,#*$p)+*)*9(7I?*+JI)+*E+%CC(ID*+I0131I0133I30C%+31I($G)7DG!

Page 53: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @`0A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

e5.B!*D!:;4<<L9!?*+J!B%))($9!+(C*,(&6Z%..*+7#$E!,*!,B(![*%+7!]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$!;*CC#,,((2!S,B(!&%+E(9,!

)+*)*+,#*$!*D!#$,(+%.,#*$!/(,?(($!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!B%))($9!#$,(+9(99#*$%&&6!?B(+(!,B(!)%+,#.#)%$,9!%+(!#,,!+(C*,(!)%+,#.#)%$,9GT!

`_!d#(+($!e.;%+,B62!S]5/&#.!]%+,#.#)%,#*$=!C6!:;4<<!&(%>#$E!+()*+,2T!R(.(C/(+!32!011k2!B,,)=ppJ#(+($C..%+,B6G.*Cp011kp30p13p)5/&#.I)%+,#.#)%,#*$IC6I#.%$$I&(%>#$EI+()*+,pG!

``!8B(!^<Q-!]*&#.6!R(>(&*)C($,!]+*.(99!X*+J!8(%C!#9!.*$9#7(+#$E!%!SD%9,I,+%.JT!*),#*$!,*!($%/&(!5+E($,!%.,#*$!?B(+(!

$((7(7!?B#&(!9,#&&!($95+#$E!/+*%7!.*CC5$#,6!)%+,#.#)%,#*$G!8B#9!)+*)*9%&!#9!95))*+,(7!/6!,B(!4V4;=!9((!:;4<<2!S4,IV%+E(!^<Q-!V#%#9*$2T!B,,)9=pp9,G#.%$$G*+EpE$9*I&#%#9*$p#$7(UG.E#s%,w&%+E(wE$9*w&#%#9*$G!

`a!"*+!(U%C)&(2!,B(!P$#,(7!Q,%,(9!E*>(+$C($,L9!*$&#$(!)5/&#.!)%+,#.#)%,#*$!D*+5C9!%&&*?!)%+,#.#)%$,9!,*!>*,(!.*CC($,9!

%$7!95EE(9,#*$9!5)!%$7!7*?$!%$7!,*!+(9)*$7!,*!#$7#>#75%&!95/C#99#*$9G!;*CC($,9!%+(!,%EE(7!%..*+7#$E!,*!.%,(E*+62!

+%$J(7!%..*+7#$E!,*!,B(!%C*5$,!*D!59(+!%.,#>#,6!,B(6!E($(+%,(2!%$7!E#>($!%!9.*+(!*$!%!S.*$,+*>(+96!C(,(+T!,B%,!#$7#.%,(9!

,B(!+%,#*!/(,?(($!,B(!$5C/(+!*D!5)!%$7!7*?$!>*,(9!,B(6!+(.(#>(G!;*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9!C%6!%&9*!/(!($E%E(7!#$!,B(!,+%$9&%,#*$!*D!.*CC($,9!%$7!+(&%,(7!7*.5C($,9G!Q((!-)($!^*>(+$C($,!R#%&*E5(2!B,,)=pp*)($E*>G#7(%9.%&(G.*CG!

`h!:;4<<2!S]5/&#.!;*CC($,9!:$7(U!4E%#$9,!48'8!X*+J!8(%C9!%$7!K#EB&#EB,92T!45E59,!012!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p#$7(UI*DI)5/&#.I.*CC($,9I01%5E31I($G)7DG!

`l!Q((!'*9(&&(!VG!X#99&(+2!S;*5+,I;*$$(.,(7!e(7#%,#*$!:$!^($(+%&!;#>#&!;%9(9=!XB%,!X(!d$*?!D+*C!WC)#+#.%&!'(9(%+.B2T!

[D(2%>0#0"%N26')#,%2)%7(/+60"%E"/2,60(2)!3h!N0110O2!a_3oak1G!X#99&(+!.*$.&57(9!,B%,!)(*)&(!D(&,!,B%,!S,B(6!B%7!%$!

*))*+,5$#,6!,*!,(&&!,B(#+!9#7(!*D!,B(!9,*+62!,B(6!)%+,#.#)%,(7!%.,#>(&6!#$!,B(!)+*.(992!,B(6!B%7!.*$9#7(+%/&(!#$)5,!#$!

7(,(+C#$#$E!,B(!*5,.*C(!*D!,B(!7#9)5,(!%$7!,B(6!?(+(!$*,!)+(99(7!/6!,B(!C(7#%,*+!*+!*,B(+9!,*!9(,,&(GT!Q((!%&9*!]%,+#.J!

"#(&72!(,!%&G2!S:$,(E+%,#$E!e(7#%,#*$!#$!V%$7!P9(!R(.#9#*$!e%J#$E2T!;*$9($959![5#&7#$E!:$9,#,5,(2!b%$5%+6!01312!\lG!"#(&7!

D#$79!,B%,!C(7#%,#*$!)%+,#.#)%$,9!B%7!%!S?#&&#$E$(99!,*!)%+,#.#)%,(!#$!C(7#%,#*$!7(9)#,(!#$7#.%,#*$9!/6!C%$6!,B%,!,B(#+!C*9,!+(.($,!(U)(+#($.(!?#,B!C(7#%,#*$!7#7!$*,!+(95&,!#$!%$!%E+((C($,!,B%,!9%,#9D#(7!,B(CGT!

`k!:;4<<2!4*;2!)%+%E+%)B!kG3N(OG!

a1!:;4<<2!S]5/&#.!;*CC($,=!;*CC5$#,6!X*+J#$E!^+*5)!'()*+,!*$!:C)&(C($,%,#*$!*D!^<Q-!<(?!E8VR!'(.*CC($7%,#*$!<5C/(+!a2T!Q(),(C/(+!002!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I0I009()31I($GB,CG!

a3!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!i:2!Q(.,#*$!0G!

a0!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!:i2!Q(.,#*$!\G!

a\!:;4<<2!S47*),(7![*%+7!'(9*&5,#*$92!;%#+*2T!<*>(C/(+!h2!011l2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($pC#$5,(9p+(9*&5,#*$9I

1h$*>1lGB,Czw8*.lhal0`h`G!"*+!%!&#9,!*D!.5++($,![*%+7!.*CC#,,((92!9((=!:;4<<2!S[*%+7!;*CC#,,((92T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*CC#,,((9p/*%+7w.*CC#,,((9GB,C&G!

a_!:/#7GG!

a`!8B(![*9,*$!;*$95&,#$E!^+*5)!%$7!;*&#$!;%+,(+!m!499*.#%,(92!-)$"+")$")0%E".("@%2<%0D"%82#'$%2<%-;MGG3!011lG!!

aa!&'()*(+,"/%2<%;2'+2'#0"%C2."')#)*"!N4C(+#.%$!V%?!:$9,#,5,(=!3kk_O2!{!\G13G!

ah!!b%C(9!"#9BC%$!%$7!Q,()B($!Q.B?%+F2!G2)+'2<(0%['1#)(^#0(2)/]%>0#060"/3%E"16,#0(2)/3%#)$%J2':/!N<(?!g*+J=!"*5$7%,#*$!]+(99M!011aO2!3_0I3_\G!

al!:;4<<2!S]5/&#.!;*CC($,9!:$7(U!4E%#$9,!48'8!X*+J!8(%C9!%$7!K#EB&#EB,92T!45E59,!012!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p#$7(UI*DI)5/&#.I.*CC($,9I01%5E31I($G)7DG!

ak!:;4<<2!S47*),(7![*%+7!'(9*&5,#*$9!|![+599(&92T!b5$(!0`2!01312!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($pC#$5,(9p+(9*&5,#*$9I0`Y5$31I($GB,CG!!

h1!d#(+($!e.;%+,B62!S:;4<<!/*%+7!/+#(D#$E!C%,(+#%&9M!C*+(!.*>(+!)%E(9!,B%$!#$D*+C%,#*$2T!45E59,!3h2!01312!B,,)=ppJ#(+($C..%+,B6G.*Cp0131p1lp3hp#.%$$I/*%+7I/+#(D#$EIC%,(+#%&9IC*+(I.*>(+I)%E(9I,B%$I#$D*+C%,#*$pG!

h3!:;4<<2!S:;4<<![*%+7!'(9*&5,#*$9ZR+%D,Z011k2T!B,,)9=pp.*CC5$#,6G#.%$$G*+Ep7#9)&%6p.,%)p[*%+7}'(9*&5,#*$9G!

8B(!?#J#!#9!9,#&&!#$!7+%D,!D*+C!%$7!7*(9!$*,!%))(%+!,*!/(!*)($!,*!7#+(.,!#$)5,!D+*C!.*CC5$#,6!C(C/(+9G!;*CC($,9!%+(!

#$>#,(7!>#%!%$!!S477!;*CC($,9S!/*U!*$!,B(!?#J#2!?B#.B!#9!$*,!%>%#&%/&(!%9!*D!-.,*/(+!h2!01312!*+!>#%!%!)5/&#.!.*CC($,9!

D*+5C!N,B(!)(+#*7!&%9,(7!D+*C!b5$(!03ob5&6!0a2!0131M!$*!.*CC($,9!?(+(!95/C#,,(7OG!8B(!)+*Y(.,(7!7%,(!D*+!.*C)&(,#*$!#9!R(.(C/(+!`o312!01312!75+#$E!:;4<<L9!\k,B!:$,(+$%,#*$%&!]5/&#.!e((,#$E!#$!;%+,%E($%G!

h0!:;4<<L9![6&%?9!7(9.+#/(!(%.B!C(.B%$#9C=!4+,#.&(!i!N-C/579C%$OM!4+,#.&(!:i2!Q(.,#*$!0!N'(.*$9#7(+%,#*$!'(H5(9,9OM!%$7!4+,#.&(!:i2!Q(.,#*$!\!N:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!]%$(&OG!

h\!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!:i2!Q(.,#*$!3G!

h_!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!i2!Q(.,#*$!0G!

h`!Q((!Q(.,#*$!::![G0G!

ha!:;4<<!)+*)*9(7!,B(!.*CC5$#,6!+(I>*,(!)+*.(99!#$!b5&6!011k2!)*9,#$E!%!7+%D,!D*+!)5/&#.!.*CC($,!%,!:;4<<2!S]5/&#.!

;*CC($,=!]+*)*9(7![6&%?!;B%$E(9!,*!:C)+*>(!4..*5$,%/#&#,62T!b5&6!0h2!011k2!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p%$$*5$.(C($,9p%$$*5$.(C($,I0hY5&1kI($GB,CG!:$,(+>#(?((9!B%>(!95EE(9,(7!%!>%+#(,6!*D!

%77#,#*$%&!+(>#(?!C(.B%$#9C92!#$.&57#$E!,B(!.*$.(),!*D!%$!#$7()($7($,!Y57#.#%+6!/*76!,%9J(7!?#,B!B(%+#$E!%$7!

(>%&5%,#$E!%+E5C($,9!%/*5,!,B(!:;4<<![*%+7L9!7(.#9#*$9!%$7!%.,#>#,#(9G!'*&D!KG!X(/(+!%$7!,B(!;($,(+!D*+!R(C*.+%.6!m!

8(.B$*&*E6!B%>(!/*,B!.%&&(7!D*+!,B(!.+(%,#*$!*D!%!9#C#&%+!Y57#.#%&!+(>#(?!)+*.(99!/%9(7!*$!#$,(+$%,#*$%&!&%?M!9((!X(/(+2!

>D#+()1%-)0"')"0%C2."')#)*"]%E"16,#02'?%;D#,,")1"/!N<(?!g*+J=!Q)+#$E(+2!0131O2!31\!%$7!;($,(+!D*+!R(C*.+%.6!m!

Page 54: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @`\A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

8(.B$*&*E62!S:$7()($7($.(!%$7!4..*5$,%/#&#,6=!8B(!"5,5+(!*D!:;4<<2T!b5$(!l2!011k2!

B,,)=pp???G.7,G*+Ep#$,(+$%,#*$%&p011k1a1lw#.%$$G)7DG!!Q((!%&9*!'G!QB%?$!^5$$%+9*$2!S4!"+(9B!Q,%+,!D*+!:;4<<2T!d#+,*$!m!e.;*$J#(2!b5$(!32!01312!B,,)=pp???G,(.B)*&#.6#$9,#,5,(G*+EpD#&(9pE5$$%+9*$w#.%$$x01?B#,(x01)%)(+G)7DG!

hh!:;4<<2!SV#C#,%,#*$9!*$!8B#+7!]%+,6!'(>#(?!*D!;*+)*+%,(![*%+7!4.,#*$9!5$7(+!;%&#D*+$#%!V%?=!Q5))&#(7!/6!:;4<<2T!45E59,!\32!01312!B,,)=pp#.%$$G*+Ep($p+(>#(?9p%DD#+C%,#*$p,B#+7I)%+,6I+(>#(?I*DI[*%+7I%.,#*$9I\3%5E31I($G)7DG!

hl!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3N%OG!

hk!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3N#OG!

l1!;*C)%+(!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!aG3N.O!N(C)B%9#9!95))&#(7O!?#,B!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3N%OG!!

l3!Q((!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!a!(,!9(HG2!%$7!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G32!(,!9(HG!

l0!Q((!:;4<<2!S;*++(9)*$7($.(2T!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(!%$7!^4;2!S;*CC5$#H5f92T!

B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep.*CC5$#H5(9G!8*!7%,(2!,B(!^4;!B%9!#995(7!\l!;*CC5$#H5f9!%$7!95/C#,,(7!0\!&(,,(+9!%77+(99(7!,*!,B(![*%+72!#$7#>#75%&![*%+7!C(C/(+92!%$7!:;4<<G!

l\!Q((!(GEG2!e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#!,*!]%5&!8?*C(62!4)+#&!\2!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p,%+C#F#I,*I,?*C(6I1\%)+1`G)7DM!e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#!,*!:;4<<![*%+7!

*D!R#+(.,*+92!45E59,!302!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p,%+C#F#I,*I/*%+7I

30%5E1`GB,CM!](,(+!n%$E&!,*!i#$,!;(+D2!Q(),(C/(+!3a2!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(pF%$E&I,*I.(+DI3a9()1`G)7DM!b*$%9![Y(&D>($9,%C!,*!]%5&!8?*C(62!<*>(C/(+!

0\2!011`G!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p/Y(&D>($9,%CI,*I,?*C(6I0\$*>1`GB,CM!

](,(+!n%$E&!,*!i#$,!;(+D2!e%+.B!3h2!011a2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(pF%$E&I,*I

.(+DI3hC%+1aG)7DM!e%+,#$![*6&(!,*!i#$,*$!;(+D2!e%6!_2!011a2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p/*6&(I,*I.(+DI1kC%61aGB,CM!%$7!K(&($!;**$%$!,*!i#$,!;(+D2!"(/+5%+6!0l2!011h2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p.**$%$I,*I.(+DI0lD(/011hG)7DG!

l_!Q((!(GEG2!e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#!,*!]%5&!8?*C(62!4)+#&!\2!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p,%+C#F#I,*I,?*C(6I1\%)+1`G)7DM!](,(+!n%$E&!,*!i#$,*$!;(+D2!Q(),(C/(+!3a2!

011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(pF%$E&I,*I.(+DI3a9()1`G)7DM!b*$%9!

[Y(&D>($9,%C!,*!]%5&!8?*C(62!<*>(C/(+!0\2!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!

B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p/Y(&D>($9,%CI,*I,?*C(6I0\$*>1`GB,CM!%$7!](,(+!n%$E&!,*!i#$,!;(+D2!e%+.B!3h2!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep.*++(9)*$7($.(pF%$E&I,*I.(+DI3hC%+1aG)7DG!!!

l`!^4;2!S^4;!;*CC5$#H5fZV5U(C/*5+E2T!b5&6!302!011`2!B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep969,(CpD#&(9p^4;w0\wV5U(C/*5+EG)7DM!

^4;2!S^4;!;*CC5$#H5fZi%$.*5>(+2T!R(.(C/(+!011`2!

B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep969,(CpD#&(9p^4;w0_wi%$.*5>(+w;*CC5$#H5(G)7DM!^4;2!S^4;!;*CC5$#H5fZX(&&#$E,*$2T!e%+.B!

0l2!011a2!B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep969,(CpD#&(9p^4;w0`wX(&&#$E,*$w;*CC5$#H5(G)7DM!^4;2!S^4;!;*CC5$#H5fZV#9/*$2T!e%+.B!0l2!011h2!B,,)=ppE%.G#.%$$G*+Ep969,(CpD#&(9p^4;w0lwV#9/*$w;*CC5$#H5(G)7DG!

la!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NBO2!NYO2!NJOG!

lh!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NBOG!

ll!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!:::2!Q(.,#*$!aG3N.OG!

lk!49!7#9.599(7!#$!,B(!)+(>#*59!9(.,#*$2!,B(!7(D#$#,#*$!*D!S%7>#.(T!#9!$*,!)+(.#9(&6!7(D#$(7!#$!,B(![6&%?92!%$7!#$!9*C(!

&#C#,(7!.%9(9!,B#9!,(+C!#9!59(7!#$,(+.B%$E(%/&6!?#,B!S*)#$#*$GT!!"*+!,B(!)5+)*9(9!*D!,B#9!9(.,#*$2!,B#9!+()*+,!59(9!,B(!,(+C!S%7>#.(T!,*!($.*C)%99!/*,B!%7>#.(!%$7!*)#$#*$!%9!#$,($7(7!#$!,B(![6&%?9G!!

k1!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NYOG!

k3!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NYOG!

k0!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NJOG!

k\!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!kG3N%OM!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NDOG!

k_!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!i:2!Q(.,#*$!kG`G!

k`!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!i:2!Q(.,#*$!kG`G!

ka!8B(!.5++($,!#$,(+#C!^4;!;B%#+!%$7!V#%#9*$!,*!,B(![*%+7!#9!K(%,B(+!R+67($=!:;4<<2!SK(%,B(+!R+67($![#*E+%)B62T!

B,,)=pp#.%$$G*+Ep($p/#*Ep7+67($GB,CG!]+(>#*59!^4;!;B%#+!)(+9*$9!%$7!V#%#9*$9!?(+(!b%$#9!d%+J&#$9!N011hI!0131O2!

e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#!N0110I011hO2!%$7!]%5&!8?*C(6!N3kkkI0110OG!;DG!:;4<<2!S[#*E+%)B6!*D!4C/%99%7*+!b%$#9!

d%+J&#$92T!B,,)=pp#.%$$G*+Ep($p/#*EpJ%+J&#$9GB,C&M!:;4<<2!S[#*E+%)B6!*D!e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#2T!B,,)=pp#.%$$G*+Ep($p/#*Ep,%+C#F#GB,CM!:;4<<2!S[#*E+%)B62!]%5&!8?*C(62T!B,,)=pp#.%$$G*+Ep($p/#*Ep,?*C(6GB,CG!

kh!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NBOG!

kl!Q((!(GEG2!e%+.(&*!7(!;%+>%&B*!V*)(9!,*!e*B%C(7!QB%+#&!8%+C#F#2!Q(),(C/(+!a2!011`2!:;4<<!;*++(9)*$7($.(2!B,,)=pp???G#.%$$G*+Ep($p.*++(9)*$7($.(p&*)(FI,*I,%+C#F#I1a9()1`G)7DG!

kk!:;4<<![6&%?92!4+,#.&(!~:2!Q(.,#*$!0G3NBOG!

311!:/#7G2!4+,#.&(!i:2!Q(.,#*$!kG`G!

Page 55: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4<<=!4$!:$7()($7($,!'(>#(?!

! @`_A!

"112&-*:!"^!M$/F1+(&!

!

$%&M)0,#$7-2)2## #

8B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!*5,&#$(7!%!,B+((!)B%9(!)+*.(99=!!]B%9(!3Z)+*/&(C!#7($,#D#.%,#*$=!.%9(!

9,57#(9M!]B%9(!0Z)+*/&(C!7#9.599#*$!%$7!#7($,#D#.%,#*$!*D!)*,($,#%&!9*&5,#*$9M!%$7!]B%9(!\Z

96$,B(9#9!%$7!+(.*CC($7%,#*$9G!!

• :$!]B%9(!3!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!#$#,#%,(7!%!C5&,#I&%6(+(7!D%.,ID#$7#$E!)+*.(99!%#C(7!%,!

#7($,#D6#$E!J(6!#995(92!.B%&&($E(92!%$7!%+(%9!*D!7#9%E+((C($,!+(&%,(7!,*!+(.($,!7(.#9#*$9!

%$7!%.,#*$9!/6!:;4<<2!?#,B!%$!(C)B%9#9!*$!#995(9!+(&%,(7!,*!)%+,#.#)%,#*$2!,+%$9)%+($.62!

%$7!%..*5$,%/#&#,6G!!

• :$!]B%9(!02!,B(![(+JC%$!,(%C!.*$75.,(7!#$,(+>#(?9!?#,B!9(&(.,!(U)(+,92!9,%DD!C(C/(+92!

%$7!9,%J(B*&7(+9!,*!7#9.599!,B(!)+*/&(C!%+(%9!#7($,#D#(7!#$!]B%9(!3!%$7!,*!(U)&*+(!

)*,($,#%&!9*&5,#*$9G!]B%9(!0!#7($,#D#(7!F*$(9!*D!.*$>(+E($.(!%$7!7#>(+E($.(!+(E%+7#$E!

/*,B!,B(!)(+.(#>(7!H5%&#,6!*D!:;4<<L9!7(.#9#*$9!%&*$E!,B(9(!>%+#*59!7#C($9#*$9!%$7!

)*,($,#%&!9*&5,#*$9!,*!7(%&!?#,B!,B(!5$7(+&6#$E!.B%&&($E(9G!

• [%9(7!*$!%!+#.B!/*76!*D!%.%7(C#.!&#,(+%,5+(2!]B%9(!\!*D!,B(!9,576!7(>(&*)(7!%$!

(U)&*+%,*+6!C*7(&!#$,($7(7!,*!B(&)!(U%C#$(!,B(!>%+#*59!D%.,*+9!,B%,!9B%)(!,B(!

)(+.(#>(7!&(E#,#C%.6!*D!:;4<<!%$7!#,9!7(.#9#*$IC%J#$E!)+*.(99(9!%$7!,*!C%J(!>#9#/&(!

,B(!#$,(+)&%6!%C*$E!,B(9(!>%+#%/&(9G!8B(!7#%E$*9,#.!C*7(&!#$.&57(9!%!,%U*$*C6!*D!#995(9!

%$7!.B%&&($E(9!#7($,#D#(7!#$!]B%9(9!3!%$7!02!7(9.+#/(7!#$!C*+(!7(),B!#$!Q(.,#*$!:::!;!

%/*>(G!!

Page 56: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

!""#$%&'()*)&+,'%-,./'%01'/2%"+,'&,34!556,!%,3%-212%-2%&,728)29,

, :;;<,

!"#$"%#&'()'*+,%"%,%#-'./0'!1,21,-'

! "#$%&%$%'(! )*+,$!-.$/.$(! 0-1(.2$+$%-1!

34+('!5! • 7'1)-=,)%)&)'*,/28)29,#>,1$(*)",0$(?)00)#%0,>/#?,@'%$'/+,

ABBC,&#,@$%2,DE=,ABDB,)%,#/-2/,&#,)-2%&)>+,?')%,'/2'0,#>,

"#%"2/%,2F1/2002-,(+,8'/)#$0,0&'G2H#*-2/0,'%-,"/2'&)#%,#>,

',&2%&'&)82,)00$20,?'1,&H'&,)%>#/?0,&H2,>'"&I>)%-)%J,

1/#"200,K2LJL=,&H2,-/'>&)%J,#>,'%,)%&2/8)29,M$20&)#%%')/2=,

022,(2*#9NL,,

• 3%)&)'*,/28)29,#>,02*2"&2-,'"'-2?)",'/&)"*20,'%-,0"H#*'/*+,

9#/G0=,1*$0,&H2,"/2'&)#%,#>,'%,)%)&)'*,'%%#&'&2-,

()(*)#J/'1H+,&H'&,)%>#/?0=,(#&H,-)/2"&*+,#/,)%-)/2"&*+=,&H2,

&2'?O0,9#/G,'0,)&,/2*'&20,&#,&H2,/28)29,1/#"200L,

• P%J'J2-,)%,&H2,"#**2"&)#%,#>,',/21/202%&'&)82,0'?1*2,#>,

?'&2/)'*0,K)%"*$-)%J=,>#/,2F'?1*2=,34!55,1$(*)"'&)#%0=,

)%-212%-2%&,/21#/&0,'%-,/28)290=,'%-,1$(*)","#??2%&0N,

&H'&,2%'(*2,',(#&&#?I$1,'%-,1/#(*2?I#/)2%&2-,'%'*+0)0L,

• Q/'>&2-,)%&2/8)29,M$20&)#%%')/20,/2*'&2-,&#,&H2,&H/22,"'02,0&$-)20L

,

!$JL,AE=,ABDB,R/#J/200,721#/&6,

• Q/'>&,3%&2/8)29,R/#&#"#*,'%-,

S$20&)#%%')/20,,

• Q/'>&,R$(*)",3%1$&,T2?#,

• Q/'>&,U#/G)%J,V+1#&H2020,

• R/2*)?)%'/+,!%%#&'&2-,

W)(*)#J/'1H+,

• X22-('"G,#%,!.7.,Y$/82+,&#,

&H2,4#??$%)&+,

,

• !$JL,DZ=,ABDB6,,

!.7.,?22&)%J,

• !$JL,A[=,\B=,ABDB6,,

!.7.,W2)])%J,

9#/G0H#1,

• Y21&,Z=,ABDB6,,!.7.,

?22&)%J,

Page 57: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

!""#$%&'()*)&+,'%-,./'%01'/2%"+,'&,34!556,!%,3%-212%-2%&,728)29,

, :;<=,

,

! "#$%&%$%'(! )*+,$!-.$/.$(! 0-1(.2$+$%-1!

34+('!5! • 728)02-,&>2,-/'?&,)%&2/8)29,@$20&)#%%')/20,?#/,0&'??A,

/2*'&2-,&#,&>2,&>/22,"'02,0&$-)20A,)%,&>2,*)B>&,#?,&>2,

?22-('"C,/2"2)82-,(+,!.7.,)%,&>2,"#%&2D&,#?,&>2,

E2)F)%B,G22&)%BH,

• I20)B%2-,',9/)&&2%,@$20&)#%%')/2,&>'&,)0,012")?)"'**+,

B2'/2-,&#9'/-0,J!4,G2G(2/0H,

• 4/2'&)%B,"$0&#G)K2-,@$20&)#%%')/20L('02-,#%,

012")?)",'/2'0,#?,2D12/&)02,#/,2D12/)2%"2L?#/,%#%M

0&'??,G2G(2/0H,

• I)0&/)($&2-,0&'??,'%-,J!4,@$20&)#%%')/20H,

• I282*#12-,"/)&2/)',?#/,)%&2/8)2922,%#G)%'&)#%0,'%-,

0>'/2-,',*)0&,#?,1/#1#02-,)%&2/8)29220,9)&>,&>2,

!.7.H,

• 4#%-$"&2-,#82/,NO,)%&2/8)290H,

• 728)292-,'%-,"#GG2%&2-,#%,&>2,PJ,&2G1*'&2,

-282*#12-,(+,&>2,!.7.H,

• 728)292-,'%-,"#GG2%&2-,#%,&>2,-/'?&,)00$20,

1'12/0,1/21'/2-,(+,&>2,!.7.Q0,PJ0H,

• I2?)%2-,&>2,)%&2/?'"20,(2&922%,&>2,E2/CG'%,&2'G,

'%-,&>2,!.7.Q0,PJ0,9)&>)%,&>2,?22-('"C,#%,&>2,

/2"2)82-,PJ,-/'?&,)00$20,1'12/0,RPJ,STA,UA,'%-,NVH,

• W/21'/2-,',G2G#/'%-$G,#%,&/'%01'/2%"+,)00$20H,

• W/21'/2-,',-/'?&,"'02,0&$-+,#%,&>2,)%&/#-$"&)#%,#?,

%29,B.XI0H,

,

Y21&H,TZA,UOTO6,,[)-&2/G,721#/&6,

• \22-('"C,#%,&>2,!.7.Q0,P#/C)%B,

J/#$1,.2G1*'&2,

• \22-('"C,#%,300$20,721#/&0,(+,&>2,

!.7.Q0,P#/C)%B,J/#$10,

• I/'?&,X)0&,#?,W/#1#02-,3%&2/8)29220,

• 728)02-,3%&2/8)29,W/#&#"#*,'%-,

]$20&)#%%')/20,?#/,Y&'??,'%-,&>2,J!4,

• I/'?&,4'02,Y&$-+,#%,&>2,3%&/#-$"&)#%,#?,

529,B.XI0,

• I/'?&,./'%01'/2%"+,[2G#/'%-$G,Y21&H,

ZOA,UOTO6,,I/'?&,4'02,0&$-)206,

• .>2,)%&/#-$"&)#%,#?,%29,B.XI0A,

012")?)"'**+A,&>2,^D1/200)#%,#?,

3%&2/20&,1/#1#0'*A,&>2,

3G1*2G2%&'&)#%,72"#GG2%-'&)#%,

.2'GA,&>2,/#*2,#?,&>2,J#82/%G2%&'*,

!-8)0#/+,4#GG)&&22,RJ!4VA,'%-,

82/&)"'*,)%&2B/'&)#%,

• .>2,HDDD,&#1M*282*,-#G')%A,

012")?)"'**+A,&>2,/28)29,1/#"200,

R3%-212%-2%&,728)29,W'%2*V,'%-,

)%&2/'"&)#%,(2&922%,&>2,J!4,'%-,&>2,

E#'/-,

• .>2,I5YM4^7.,1/#1#0'*,

• Y21&H,TNA,UOTO6,

!.7.,G22&)%B,

• Y21&,UOA,UOTO6,,

!.7.,G22&)%B,

• Y21&H,U_A,UOTO6,,

!.7.,G22&)%B,

,

Page 58: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

!""#$%&'()*)&+,'%-,./'%01'/2%"+,'&,34!556,!%,3%-212%-2%&,728)29,

, :;<=,

,

! "#$%&%$%'(! )*+,$!-.$/.$(! 0-1(.2$+$%-1!

34+('!5! • >/'?&,/2"#@@2%-'&)#%0A,

• 728)292-,/2"#@@2%-'&)#%0,9)&B,!.7.A,

• 728)292-,/2"#@@2%-'&)#%0,9)&B,0$(C2"&,@'&&2/,

2D12/&0A,

• 4#%-$"&2-,)%&2/8)290,9)&B,E#'/-,@2@(2/0F,4GH,'%-,

I2%2/'*,4#$%02*A,

H"&A,JF,KLML6,,N#/O)%P,-#"$@2%&6,

• 72"#@@2%-'&)#%0,

• 4'02,0&$-)20,

,

H"&A,KLF,KLML6,,Q)%'*,/21#/&6,

• 72"#@@2%-'&)#%0,

• 4'02,0&$-)20,

• R2&B#-#*#P)20,

,

• H"&A,SF,KLML6,,E2/O@'%,

@22&)%P,9)&B,!.7.,"B')/,

• H"&,MMTMUF,KLML6,,!.7.,

E#0&#%,@22&)%P,

,

,

Page 59: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!""#$%&'()*(+$,#-.&#/(0#,12%23245(

!

3&!(--*'*$&!'$!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!0$%/#20>!'?2!#(02!0'%-*20!(/2!*&@$/A2-!),!'?2!$)02/8('*$&0!$@!(!

02+2#'2->!-*82/02!B/$%1!$@!0'(C2?$+-2/0!(&-!2D12/'0!9?$!?(82!)22&!*&'2/8*292-!-%/*&B!'?2!

#$%/02!$@!$%/!(&(+,0*0E!.?202!*&'2/8*290!1/$8*-2!(&!*A1$/'(&'!0%11+2A2&'(+!0$%/#2!$@!

*&@$/A('*$&!)2#(%02!'?2,!#$&82,!$)02/8('*$&0!/2B(/-*&B!'?2!12/#21'*$&!(&-!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$@!

34"55!-2#*0*$&0!),!'?2!)/$(-2/!#$AA%&*',>!*&!(--*'*$&!'$!#$&@*/A*&B!'?2!@(#'0!$@!2(#?!#(02E!.?2!

0'('2A2&'0!$@!*&'2/8*29220!-$!&$'!/2@+2#'!'?2!$1*&*$&0!$/!#$&#+%0*$&0!$@!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(AE!!

G/$A!H21'2A)2/!IJKL#'$)2/!IM>!NJIJ!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!#$&-%#'2-!O;!*&'2/8*290E!L%/!

*&'2/8*29220!*&#+%-2-!/21/202&'('*820!@/$A!'?2!P5HL!#$&0'*'%2&#*20>!'?2!P"4>!34"55!0'(@@>!

##.QR0!(&-!A(&,!A$/2E!.?2/2!92/2!SN!*&'2/8*29220!9?$!-*0#%002-!'?2!&29!B.QR!1/$#200>!I;!

*&'2/8*29220!9?$!-*0#%002-!'?2!R5HT4U7.!1/$1$0(+>!(&-!V!*&'2/8*29220!9?$!-*0#%002-!(012#'0!

$@!'?2!EDDD!1/$#200>!9*'?!0$A2!*&'2/8*29220!(--/200*&B!W%20'*$&0!/2+('2-!'$!A$/2!'?(&!$&2!#(02!

0'%-,E!3&!(--*'*$&>!92!/2#2*82-!#$A1+2'2-!W%20'*$&&(*/20!@/$A!M!P"4!/21/202&'('*820E!

X?*+2!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!?(0!A(-2!282/,!2@@$/'!'$!/2A$82!@(#'%(+!*&(##%/(#*20>!*'!-$20!&$'!(''20'!

'$!'?2!(##%/(#,!$@!'?2!$)02/8('*$&0!$@@2/2-!),!*&'2/8*29220E!

!"#$%&'$()*%+#+,+-)

3&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!),!'2+21?$&2!),!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!%0*&B!W%20'*$&&(*/20!#%0'$A*Y2-!

@$/!'?2!*&-*8*-%(+!*&'2/8*2922E!4$&0*-2/()+2!+('*'%-2!9(0!$@@2/2-!'$!*&'2/8*29220!'$!(++$9!'?2A!'$!

2D1+$/2!'$1*#0!(&-!*00%20!'?('!'?2,!@2+'!92/2!/2+28(&'!(&-!*A1$/'(&'!'$!'?2!F2/CA(&!42&'2/!

0'%-,E!.?2!*&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!$&!'?2!#$&-*'*$&!$@!#$&@*-2&'*(+*',E!4$A1/2?2&0*82!&$'20!

92/2!'(C2&!-%/*&B!'?2!*&'2/8*290!(&-!0%)02W%2&'+,!0%AA(/*Y2-!@$/!'?2!/202(/#?!'2(AE!.?2!

&(A20!$@!'?2!*&'2/8*29220!?(82!)22&!/2A$82-!@/$A!'?2!&$'20!(&-!0%AA(/*20E!!

.?%0!@(/>!34"55!0'(@@!*&'2/8*290!?(82!'(C2&!1+(#2!(0!(!'9$T0'21!1/$#200>!9*'?!'?2!$11$/'%&*',!'$!

1/$8*-2!9/*''2&!/201$&020!'$!$%/!#%0'$A*Y2-!W%20'*$&&(*/20>!@$++$92-!),!(!1?$&2!#(++!9*'?!'?2!

F2/CA(&!42&'2/!'2(A>!-20*B&2-!'$!#+(/*@,>!9?2/2!&2#200(/,>!0$A2!$@!'?2!9/*''2&!(&092/0!(&-!'$!

-*B!-2212/!*&'$!9/*''2&!/201$&020E!3&!'?2!#(02!$@!'?2!P"4>!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!'$$C!(!)/$(-T)(02-!

(11/$(#?!),!-*0'/*)%'*&B!(!9/*''2&!W%20'*$&&(*/2>!9*'?!'?2!(*A!$@!@$++$9*&B!%1!-*/2#'+,>!9?2/2!

1$00*)+2>!9*'?!1(/'*#%+(/!A2A)2/0!9?$!A(,!?(82!?(-!A$/2!0%)0'(&'*(+!*&8$+82A2&'!*&!'?2!#(020E!

"++!34"55!0'(@@!*&'2/8*290!(&-!9/*''2&!/201$&020!'$!W%20'*$&&(*/20!?(82!)22&!#$$/-*&('2-!),!

34"55Z0!"-8*0$/!'$!'?2![/20*-2&'>!R2&*02!\*#?2+E!.?2!/201$&020!'$!'?2!W%20'*$&&(*/20!92/2!

#$++2#'2-!(&-!(BB/2B('2-!),!34"55!1/*$/!'$!0%)A*00*$&!'$!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(AE!34"55Z0!P2&2/(+!

4$%&02+>!]$?&!]2@@/2,>!?(0!(''2&-2-!'?2!1?$&2!*&'2/8*290!9*'?!34"55!0'(@@!A2A)2/0!('!?*0!

/2W%20'E!

!"#$%&'$().$-$,#'+")

G$/!2(#?!#(02!0'%-,>!'?2!F2/CA(&!'2(A!*-2&'*@*2-!#/*'2/*(!),!9?*#?!'$!02+2#'!*&'2/8*29220!^@$/!

@%/'?2/!-2'(*+0>!022!'?2!_H2+2#'*$&!4/*'2/*(!(&-![/$1$02-!3&'2/8*29220`!A2A$!*&!'?2!\*-'2/A!

Page 60: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

721$/'!'$!".7.>?!.@2!1/$1$02-!*&'2/8*29!#(&-*-('20!9@$!A2'!'@202!#/*'2/*(!92/2!'@2&!#,#+2-!

9*'@!".7.!A2A)2/0!(0!92++!(0!B2&*02!C*#@2+!D34"55!0'(EE>!E$/!(--*'*$&(+!&$A*&('*$&0?!.@2!

F2/GA(&!'2(A!#$&'(#'2-!2(#@!$E!'@202!HI!#(&-*-('20J!E$++$92-!%1!'$!2&0%/2!92!@(-!*&'2/8*29220!

9@$!A2'!2(#@!$E!'@2!02+2#'*$&!#/*'2/*(?!

!"#$%&'$($$)*'+#)

B$&&(!"%0'*&! B(8*-!C(@2/!

7$-!F2#G0'/$A! K/(&G!C(/#@!

B$%L!F/2&'! M*2/2&!C#4(/'@,!!

N/*#!F/%&&2/OP*++*(A0! Q'282!C2'(+*'R!

F2#G,!F%//! B2&*02!C*#@2+!

S*&'!42/E! C(/L*2!C*+(A!

N-A$&!4@%&L! M2*'@!C*'#@2++!

C(0$&!4$+2! 7(A!C$@(&!

T20+2,!4$9+2,! C*+'$&!C%2++2/!

Q'282!4/$#G2/! U2'2/!52''+2E$+-!

M2*'@!B(8*-0$&! V$&!5282''!

"8/*!B$/*(! C*G2!U(+(L2!

W(@*-!V(A*+! M%/'!U/*'R!

V$@&!V2EE/2,! X/2L!7(''/(,!

7$-&2,!V$EE2! M/*0'*&(!7$02''2!

B(&!M(A*&0G,! X2$/L2!Q(-$90G,!

M('@,!M+2*A(&! Q%R(&&2!Q2&2!

V$@&!M&2%2/! P2/&2/!Q'(%)!

M$&0'(&'*&$0!M$A(*'*0! V2(&OV(#Y%20!Q%)/2&('!

B*/G!M/*0#@2&$90G*!! F/%#2!.$&G*&!

F2/'/(&-!-2!T(!4@(12++2!!! M(/+(!S(+2&'2!

Q'%(/'!T(9+2,! "&'$&,!S(&!4$%82/*&L!

M(/2&!T2&'R! !

!

!

!

Page 61: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!""#$%&'()*(+,#(-$./0%12.&0$(03(4#5(6+789(

!

!"#$%&'$(

3&!>%&2!$?!@<<AB!'C2!34"55!D$(/-!%&(&*E$%0+,!(-$1'2-!'C2!F5GHI0!1$+*#,!/2#$EE2&-('*$&0!?$/!

'C2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!&29!J2&2/*#!'$1K+282+!-$E(*&!&(E20!LJ.MN0O!(&-!/20$+82-!'$!)2J*&!9$/P!$&!

'C2!*E1+2E2&'('*$&!$?!(!&29!J.MN!(11+*#('*$&!1/$#200Q!.C2!&29!1/$J/(EB!*&*'*(++,!0#C2-%+2-!'$!

+(%&#C!*&!G21'2E)2/!@<<RB!*0!0'*++!%&-2/!-282+$1E2&'Q!!

.C2!1/$1$02-!1/$#200!C(0!)22&!?/(%JC'!9*'C!#$&'/$82/0,B!*&#+%-*&J!#/*'*#*0E0!$82/!*'0!-2+(,0B!

9C2'C2/!34"55I0!E2'C$-!$?!1%)+*0C*&J!(&-!*&#$/1$/('*&J!1%)+*#!#$EE2&'0!*0!0%??*#*2&'+,!

'/(&01(/2&'!(&-!/201$&0*82B!(&-!9C2'C2/!&29!J.MN0!0C$%+-!282&!2S*0'Q!4/*'*#0!C(82!(+0$!/(*02-!(!

&%E)2/!$?!012#*?*#!0%)0'(&'*82!*00%20B!*&#+%-*&J!'C2!TS1/200*$&!$?!3&'2/20'!1/$1$0(+B!'/(-2E(/P!

1/$'2#'*$&B!'C2!/$+2!$?!'C2!F$82/&E2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$EE*''22B!'C2!1/$1$02-!E$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!

$/-2/!0'(&-(/-!?$/!$)U2#'*$&0!'$!&29!J.MN0B!(&-!82/'*#(+!*&'2J/('*$&Q!

)&#*(+$,-.(+/,%'*#(&0-(1*$2/-/3/4.(

!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"($"($",#$-",#.&-$*(/$%&+0"/"1"234$51&*-&$-&&$655&(/'7$68$

.C*0!#(02!0'%-,!*0!)(02-!$&!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!E('2/*(+0B!*&#+%-*&J!1%)+*#!#$EE2&'0B!34"55!

-$#%E2&'0B!(#(-2E*#!0'%-*20B!E2-*(!/21$/'0!(&-!2S12/'!$1*&*$&0Q!3'!1/$8*-20!(!0%EE(/,!$?!'C2!

?(#'0!/2J(/-*&J!'C2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!&29!J.MN0Q!"0!12/!TSC*)*'!DB!02#'*$&!V!$?!'C2!G2/8*#20!

"J/22E2&'!)2'922&!'C2!D2/PE(&!42&'2/!(&-!34"55B!*'0!J$(+!*0!'$!C2+1!*-2&'*?,!P2,!*00%20B!

#C(++2&J20!(&-!(/2(0!$?!-*0(J/22E2&'!/2+('2-!'$!'C2!&29!J2&2/*#!'$1K+282+!-$E(*&!&(E2!LJ.MNO!

1/$J/(EQ!.C2!$)02/8('*$&0!)2+$9!9*++!#$&'/*)%'2!'$!'C2!D2/PE(&!'2(EI0!?*&(+!/21$/'Q!

3&!(--*'*$&!'$!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!0$%/#20B!'C*0!#(02!0'%-,!*&#+%-20!0'('2E2&'0B!$1*&*$&0!(&-!

12/#21'*$&0!$?!'C$02!92!*&'2/8*292-!*&!'C2!#$%/02!$?!-282+$1*&J!'C*0!#(02Q!.C202!12/#21'*$&0!(&-!

$1*&*$&0!1+(,!(&!*E1$/'(&'!/$+2!*&!'C2!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$?!34"55!-2#*0*$&0!(&-!'C2*/!/2#21'*$&!),!

'C2!#$EE%&*',Q!.C2!0'('2E2&'0!$?!*&'2/8*29220!-$!&$'!/2?+2#'!'C2!$1*&*$&0!$/!#$&#+%0*$&0!$?!'C2!

0'%-,!'2(EQ!WC*+2!92!C(82!E(-2!282/,!2??$/'!'$!/2E$82!?(#'%(+!*&(##%/(#*20B!92!-$!&$'!(''20'!'$!

'C2!(##%/(#,!$?!'C2!$1*&*$&0!$??2/2-!),!*&'2/8*29220Q!.C2!*&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!$&!'C2!

#$&-*'*$&!$?!#$&?*-2&'*(++,Q!

9"+&:!"0!12/!'C2!G2/8*#20!"J/22E2&'B!'C*0!#(02!0'%-,!?$#%020!$&!282&'0!1/*$/!'$!>%&2!VXB!@<V<Q!

Y$9282/B!'C2!&29!J.MN!1/$J/(E!*0!0'*++!28$+8*&JQ!"0!0%#CB!'C*0!0'%-,!E(,!&$'!/2?+2#'!'C2!E$0'!

/2#2&'!-282+$1E2&'0!*&!'C*0!#(02Q!

(

!

Page 62: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&

-&&./!0123)!.1/4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444456!

6&&70171892&:77;.):!.1/&701)988 44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444456!

<&&=:>10&.88398 444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445?!

>?<!.3@AB35A ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????;C!

>?D!!EFGA7"74H35I!3JJKAJL ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????;;!

"#$#%!!&'()*+(',!-'./*0/1.2 #####################################################################################################################################33!

"#$#$!!-./*2/1(4!5.'!6(4101.78!9.2)70/ ##################################################################################################################3:!

"#$#"!!;*07'1/<!(2)!;/(=141/<>?../[email protected]*!;0(412A ############################################################################################### 3:!

"#$#B!!&CD!D*+(2)!(2)!E0.2.+10!F2(4<818########################################################################################################3:!

>?>!!AMN7AJJ3F5!FO!35.A7AJ.!N7FNFJ"B ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????PQ!

>?R!!.7"SA@"7T!3JJKAJ!"5S!.HA!3@NBA@A5.".3F5!7A4F@@A5S".3F5!.A"@ ?????????????????????????????????????????????????P>!

>?C!!.HA!7FBA!FO!.HA!IFGA75@A5."B!"SG3JF7U!4F@@3..AA??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????PV!

"#G#%!!H*.A'(IJ10!K(+*8 ############################################################################################################################################:L!

"#G#$!!EMI'*881.2!.5!N2/*'*8/!-'.I.8(4 ###################################################################################################################O%!

"#G#"!!PQ*'('0J12A!N887*8 ############################################################################################################################################O%!

>?;!!.HA!@F7"B3.U!"5S!NKWB34!F7SA7!J."5S"7S ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????VD!

>?P!!GA7.34"B!35.AI7".3F5????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????V>!

>?V!!35.A75".3F5"B3XAS!SF@"35!5"@AJ ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????VP!

Page 63: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!""#$%&'()*%+'$"

>&2!$?!34"55@0!/$+20A!(0!(/'*#%+('2-!*&!*'0!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&A!*0!B12/?$/C*&D!(&-!$82/022*&D!

?%&#'*$&0!/2+('2-!'$!'E2!#$$/-*&('*$&!$?!'E2!3&'2/&2'!-$C(*&!&(C2!0,0'2C!FBG5HIJA!*&#+%-*&D!'E2!

-282+$1C2&'!$?!1$+*#*20!?$/!-2'2/C*&*&D!'E2!#*/#%C0'(&#20!%&-2/!9E*#E!&29!'$1K+282+!-$C(*&0!

(/2!(--2-!'$!'E2!G5H!/$$'!0,0'2CLIM!H*&#2!'E2!MNOP0A!'E2!G5H!E(0!#$&'(*&2-!0282&!D.QG0!FL#$CA!

L2-%A!LD$8A!L*&'A!LC*+A!L&2'A!(&-!L$/DJA!'E/22!$?!9E*#ERL#$CA!L&2'A!(&-!L$/DR(/2!$12&!?$/!1%)+*#!

/2D*0'/('*$&L<!!3&!<PPPA!34"55!*00%2-!(!#(++!?$/!1/$1$0(+0!?$/!&29!D.QG0L!S2'922&!+('2!<PPP!(&-!

<PPTA!*'!*&'/$-%#2-!0282&!&29!D.QG06!L(2/$A!L)*UA!L#$$1A!L*&?$A!LC%02%CA!L&(C2!(&-!L1/$L!3&!<PPVA!

34"55!(&&$%&#2-!?*82!C$/2!(11/$82-!01$&0$/2-!.QG0RL#('A!LW$)0A!LC$)*A!L'2+A!(&-!L'/(82+R

)/*&D*&D!'E2!'$'(+!&%C)2/!'$!'92&',K$&2LX!!

3&!>#'$)2/!<PPY!'E2!Z2&2/*#!5(C20!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&!FZ5H>JT!?*&(+*U2-!(!+*0'!$?!1$+*#,!

/2#$CC2&-('*$&0!$&!'E2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!&29!D.QG0AV!*&!+*&2!9*'E!34"55@0!0'('2-!#$CC*'C2&'!'$!

B*&'/$-%#*&D!(&-!1/$C$'*&D!#$C12'*'*$&!*&!'E2!/2D*0'/('*$&!$?!-$C(*&!&(C20!9E2/2!1/(#'*#()+2!

(&-!)2&2?*#*(+!*&!'E2!1%)+*#!*&'2/20'LI;!!.E2!34"55!S$(/-!(11/$82-!'E202!/2#$CC2&-('*$&0!*&!

[%&2!<PPOA!(&-!0'(??!)2D(&!9$/\!$&!(!&29!G/(?'!"11+*#(&'!Z%*-2)$$\!FG"ZJ!?$%/!C$&'E0!+('2/L!!

.E2!G"Z!*0!#%//2&'+,!*&!*'0!?$%/'E!*'2/('*$&A!1%)+*0E2-!$&!](,!XMA!<PMPL!.E2!'*C2+*&2!$&!'E2!529!

D.QG!^/$D/(C!02#'*$&!$?!34"55@0!92)0*'2!20'*C('20!'E('!'E2!?*&(+!"11+*#(&'!Z%*-2)$$\!9*++!)2!

1%)+*0E2-!0$C2!'*C2!*&!<PMP!(&-!+*0'0!'E2!-('2!$?!1/$D/(C!+(%&#E!(0!B'$!)2!-2'2/C*&2-LIY!

,""-&'.'/0("1..2+*3%+'$"-&'*0//"

"##$/-*&D!'$!'E2!#%//2&'!F?$%/'EJ!82/0*$&!$?!'E2!G"ZA!(11+*#(&'0!?$/!&29!D.QG0!C%0'!#$C1+2'2!

'E2!?$++$9*&D!0'2106!

ML! 72D*0'2/!?$/!'E2!.QG!"11+*#('*$&!H,0'2CL!

<L! H%)C*'!(!1(/'*(+!-21$0*'!$?!_VPPP!?$/!2(#E!D.QG!-20*/2-L!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

M!34"55A!B"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&A`!/28*02-!5$82C)2/!<MA!MNNOA!E''16aa999L*#(&&L$/Da2&aD2&2/(+a(/'*#+20LE'Cb!c&*'2-!

H'('20!G21(/'C2&'!$?!4$CC2/#2A!H'('2C2&'!$?!^$+*#,!$&!'E2!](&(D2C2&'!$?!3&'2/&2'!5(C20!(&-!"--/20020A![%&2!VA!MNNOA!E''16aa999L*#(&&L$/Da2&aD2&2/(+a9E*'2K1(12/KPVW%&NOLE'CL!

<!"!012#*(+*U2-!.QGA!L(/1(A!*0!/202/82-!?$/!B'2#E&*#(+!*&?/(0'/%#'%/2!1%/1$020LI!!>82/!<VP!#$%&'/,!#$-2!.QG0!F2LDLA!L%\!$/!L/%J!(+0$!2d*0'L!34"55A!B.$1KQ282+!G$C(*&0!FD.QG0JAI!E''16aa999L*#(&&L$/Da2&a'+-0aL!

X!>&!G2#2C)2/!MMA!<PPNA!34"55!2&'2/2-!*&'$!(!.QG!01$&0$/0E*1!(D/22C2&'!9*'E!'E2!c&*82/0(+!^$0'(+!c&*$&!Fc^cJA!%&-2/!9E*#E!'E2!c^c!01$&0$/0!'E2!L1$0'!D.QGL!.E2!-$C(*&!E(0!&$'!,2'!)22&!(--2-!'$!'E2!/$$'L!34"55A!BL^>H.!H1$&0$/2-!.QG!"D/22C2&'A`!G2#2C)2/!MMA!<PPNA!E''16aa999L*#(&&L$/Da2&a'+-0a(D/22C2&'0a1$0'aL!

T!.E2!Z5H>!*0!$&2!$?!'E/22!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&0!F'E2!$'E2/0!)2*&D!'E2!"--/200!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&!(&-!'E2!4$%&'/,!4$-2!5(C20!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&J!'E('!-282+$1!(&-!/2#$CC2&-!1$+*#*20!'$!'E2!34"55!S$(/-L!e(#E!H%11$/'*&D!>/D(&*U('*$&!(+0$!(11$*&'0!'9$!8$'*&D!C2C)2/0!'$!'E2!S$(/-L!

V!Z5H>A!Bf*&(+!721$/'!K!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!529!Z2&2/*#!.$1KQ282+!G$C(*&0AI!"%D%0'!OA!<PPYA!E''16aaD&0$L*#(&&L$/Da*00%20a&29KD'+-0a1-1K-2#PVK?/K1(/'(KPO(%DPYLE'CL!

;!34"55A!BS,+(90!?$/!3&'2/&2'!4$/1$/('*$&!?$/!"00*D&2-!5(C20!(&-!5%C)2/0AI!(C2&-2-![%&2!<VA!<PMPA!E''16aa999L*#(&&L$/Da2&aD2&2/(+a),+(90LE'CL!

Y!34"55A!B529!D.QG!^/$D/(C6!529!'$!'E2!^/$D/(Cg!!H'(/'!h2/2i!A`!E''16aa999L*#(&&L$/Da2&a'$1*#0a&29KD'+-0a1/$D/(CK2&LE'CL!

Page 64: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

<>! 4$?1+2'2!'@2!A%++!B.CD!(11+*#('*$&!(&-!0%)?*'!'@2!/2?(*&-2/!$A!'@2!28(+%('*$&!A22!

EFGHIJIIIJ!A$/!(!'$'(+!#$0'!$A!FGHKJIIIL>!

M>! N(00!28(+%('*$&0!*&#+%-*&B6!

• 28(+%('*$&!$A!'@2!/2O%20'2-!0'/*&B!E'$!-2'2/?*&2!'@('!*'!P*0!&$'!+*Q2+,!'$!#(%02!

02#%/*',!$/!0'()*+*',!1/$)+2?0!*&!'@2!D5RSLT!

• 0#/22&*&B!A$/!0'/*&B!0*?*+(/*',J!*&#+%-*&B!1/$)+2?0!#(%02-!),!P0*?*+(/*',!'$!

2U*0'*&B!.CD0!$/!/202/82-!&(?20ST!

• 0#/22&*&B!$A!'@2!(11+*#(&'!E'$!-2'2/?*&2!P9@2'@2/!'@2!(11+*#(&'!@(0!'@2!

/2O%*0*'2!'2#@&*#(+J!$12/('*$&(+!(&-!A*&(&#*(+!#(1()*+*'*20!'$!$12/('2!(!/2B*0'/,SLT!

(&-!

• (!)(#QB/$%&-!#@2#Q!A$/!'@2!$12/('$/!(&-!Q2,!?2?)2/0>!

K>! 3A!(11+*#()+2J!0%AA*#*2&'+,!(--/200!(&,!$)V2#'*$&0!?(-2!$&!'@2!B/$%&-0!$A!P0'/*&B!

#$&A%0*$&J!+2B(+!/*B@'0J!?$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!(&-W$/!#$??%&*',>S!

;>! X&-2/B$!(!MKY-(,!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!12/*$->!

Z>! N(00!(!02#$&-(/,![U'2&-2-![8(+%('*$&!*A!'@2!(11+*#('*$&!-$20!&$'!?22'!'@2!#/*'2/*(!A$/!

'@2!*&*'*(+!28(+%('*$&>!

H>! ./(&0*'*$&!'$!-2+2B('*$&6!4$?1+2'2!(!/2B*0'/,!(B/22?2&'!9*'@!34"55!(&-!1(00!(!02/*20!$A!

'2#@&*#(+!'20'0>H!

5$'!(++!$A!'@202!0'210!(/2!&2#200(/,!A$/!(++!(11+*#(&'0J!(&-!(++!$A!'@202!0'210!(/2!0%)V2#'!'$!#@(&B2!

)2A$/2!'@2!1/$#200!*0!A*&(+*\2-!(&-!'@2!B.CD!1/$B/(?!*0!A$/?(++,!+(%&#@2->!.@2!A$%/'@!82/0*$&!$A!

'@2!D"]!*++%0'/('20!'@2!1/$#200!(0!A$++$906!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

H!34"55J!PD/(A'!"11+*#(&'!]%*-2)$$QJ!^2/0*$&!MJS!_(,!<GJ!`IGIJ!@''16WW999>*#(&&>$/BW2&W'$1*#0W&29YB'+-0W-/(A'Y/A1Y#+2(&Y`H?(,GIY2&>1-A>!

Page 65: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!

!

!""#$%&'"())*+)"

34"55>0!-2#*0*$&!'$!)2?*&!9$/@!$&!(!&29!?.AB!(11+*#('*$&!1/$#200!C2'!9*'D!$11$0*'*$&!E/$C!

0$C2!*&!'D2!?+$)(+!)%0*&200!#$CC%&*',F!*&#+%-*&?!'/(-2C(/@!D$+-2/0!(&-!C2C)2/0!$E!'D2!

E*&(&#*(+!02#'$/F!(0!92++!(0!(!&%C)2/!$E!?$82/&C2&'0GH!I11$&2&'0!(/?%2-!'D('!(!?.AB!2J1(&0*$&!

9$%+-!K#/2('2!C$/(+*',F!'/(-2C(/@!(&-!?2$?/(1D*#!1/$)+2C0!('!'D2!'$1L+282+FM!#$&E%0*&?!

#$&0%C2/0!(&-!1+(#*&?!(!?/2('!E*&(&#*(+!)%/-2&!$&!)%0*&200!$9&2/0!9D$!9$%+-!)2!E$/#2-!'$!

-2E2&0*82+,!/2?*0'2/!)$'D!.AB0!(&-!02#$&-!+282+!-$C(*&0!*&!&29!.AB0!'$!1/$'2#'!'D2*/!)/(&-0GNO!

I'D2/!#$&#2/&0!*&#+%-2-!E2(/0!'D('!*&#/2(0*&?!'D2!&%C)2/!$E!?.AB0!9$%+-!'D/2('2&!'D2!0'()*+*',!

$E!'D2!B5PF!'D('!'D2!2J12#'2-!)2&2E*'!'$!#$&0%C2/0!'D/$%?D!?/2('2/!#$C12'*'*$&!9$%+-!&$'!

$%'92*?D!'D2!#$0'0!(00$#*('2-!9*'D!0%#D!(&!2J1(&0*$&F!(&-!'D('!'D2!&29!1/$?/(C!C(,!*&8*'2!(&!

*&#/2(02!*&!#/*C*&(+!#$&-%#'!0%#D!(0!1D*0D*&?F!C(+9(/2!(&-!)$'&2'0G!I'D2/0F!),!#$&'/(0'F!

#$C1+(*&2-!$E!34"55>0!0+$9&200!'$!#$CC2&#2!'D*0!1/$1$02-!2J1(&0*$&F!(/?%*&?!'D('!$&?$*&?!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

H!Q*#D(2+!R(+(?2F!K34"55>0!?.AB!R/$1$0(+!S*'0!(!T(++6!5$9!TD('UFM!!"#$%&'(&#))$*$+&##,'-$+'./,012'/$%++$34'(F!B2#2C)2/!VVF!VOOWF!D''16XX)+$?G1EEG$/?X(/#D*820XVOOWXNVX*#(&&0Y?'+-Y1/$GD'C+G!

NO!7*#D(/-!Z!.*&-(+F!KP9*'#D*&?!$&!'D2!A*?D'6![J1/200*$&!$E!3&'2/20'!E$/!529!.AB0FM!52&64#$78F!\2)/%(/,!V]F!VONOF!D''16XX999G#*/#+2*-G#$CX1$0'0X09*'#D*&?Y$&Y'D2Y+*?D'Y2J1/200*$&Y$EY*&'2/20'Y'+-0XG!

Page 66: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

/20'/*#'*$&!$>!'?2!@5A!&(B2!01(#2!*0!(&'*C#$B12'*'*82!$/!'?('!'?2!1/$#200!*0!)2*&D!?2+-!%1!),!(!

>29!1$92/>%+!8$*#20!'?('!-$!&$'!/21/202&'!'?2!9*-2/!34"55!#$BB%&*',EFF!

!"#$%&'()&*($

34"55G0!'*B2+*&2!>$/!'?2!+(%&#?!$>!'?2!&29!D.H@!1/$D/(B!?(0!)22&!1%0?2-!)(#I!/212('2-+,E!3&!

J%&2!KLLMN!34"55!20'*B('2-!'?('!'?2!"11+*#(&'!O%*-2)$$I!9$%+-!)2!>*&(+*P2-!),!5$82B)2/!KLLM!

(&-!'?('!'?2!1/$D/(B!9$%+-!+(%&#?!),!2(/+,!KLLQEFK!3&!/201$&02!'$!#$BB2&'0!$&!'?2!>*/0'!-/(>'!$>!

'?2!D%*-2)$$I!*&-*#('*&D!'?('!'?2!1/$1$02-!'*B2+*&2!9(0!'$$!(DD/200*82N!*&!R2)/%(/,!KLLQN!

34"55!2S'2&-2-!'?2!+(%&#?!-('2!'$!@2#2B)2/!KLLQE!.?/22!B$&'?0!+('2/N!34"55!/28*02-!'?2!

'*B2+*&2!(D(*&N!1+2-D*&D!'$!)2D*&!(##21'*&D!(11+*#('*$&0!*&!2(/+,!KLFLEFT!!

"'!'?2!U#'$)2/!KLLQ!34"55!B22'*&D!*&!A2$%+N!34"55!>(#2-!#/*'*#*0B!>/$B!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'0!

9?$!#+(*B2-N!V'?2!'*B2'()+2!?(0&G'!0+*112-N!)%'!?(0!)22&!()(&-$&2-W!(&-!*B1+$/2-!34"55!'$!

VX%0'!1*#I!(!-('2EW!VY2G/2!+$0*&D!>(*'?!*&!'?*0!1/$#200!(0!92!022!-2+(,!(>'2/!-2+(,!(>'2/!-2+(,NW!0(*-!

$&2EFZ!!3&'2/8*29220!0%DD20'2-!'?('!'?202!-2+(,0!B(,!)2!-%2!'$!'?2!*&>+%2&#2!$>!1$92/>%+!

0'(I2?$+-2/0!9?$!(/2!>%&-(B2&'(++,!$11$02-!'$!'?2!9*-201/2(-!2S1(&0*$&!$>!'?2!-$B(*&!&(B2!

01(#2E!A$B2!*&'2/8*29220!1$*&'2-!'$!'?2!$&D$*&D!-*0#%00*$&!$>!'/(-2B(/I!1/$'2#'*$&!*&!&29!

D.H@0!(0!(&!2S(B1+2!$>!(&!*00%2!9?2/2!(!012#*>*#!*&'2/20'!D/$%1N!*&!'?*0!#(02!'/(-2B(/I!?$+-2/0!

/21/202&'2-!*&!'?2!O5AU!3&'2++2#'%(+![/$12/',!4$&0'*'%2&#,!\3[4]N!-2+(,2-!'?2!1/$D/200!$>!'?2!

&29!D.H@!1/$D/(BE!.?*0!-2)('2!)2D(&!9*'?!'?2!O5AU!Y$/I*&D!O/$%1!$&![/$'2#'*&D!'?2!7*D?'0!$>!

U'?2/0!*&!^(,!KLL_!(&-!B$82-!'?/$%D?!'?2!3B1+2B2&'('*$&!72#$BB2&-('*$&!.2(B!(&-!'?2!

O5AU!A12#*(+!./(-2B(/I!300%20!Y$/I*&D!O/$%1N!9?*#?!0%)B*''2-!*'0!>*&(+!/21$/'!*&!R2)/%(/,!

KLFLEF<!./(-2B(/I!?$+-2/0!?(82!0'('2-!'?2*/!$11$0*'*$&!'$!'?2!9*-201/2(-!2S1(&0*$&!$>!D.H@0`!

'?2!3[4!?(0!%/D2-!'?2!+*B*'('*$&!$>!'?*0!2S1(&0*$&EF;!!3&!*'0!J%&2!KLLQ!4$BB%&*a%b!'$!'?2!c$(/-N!

'?2!O"4!(+0$!0'/2002-!V'?2!&22-!>$/!B$/2!2>>2#'*82!1/$'2#'*$&!>$/!*&'2++2#'%(+!1/$12/',!/*D?'0W!

9?*+2!0'('*&D!*'0!0%11$/'!>$/!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!&29!D.H@0EF_!!

U'?2/!*&'2/8*29220!>2+'!'?2!-2+(,0!B(,!)2!-%2!'$!'?2!$82/C#$&0*-2/('*$&!$>!1%)+*#!*&1%'!$/!'$!'?2!

c$(/-G0!*&-2#*0*82&200!9?2&!>(#2-!),!(!+(#I!$>!1%)+*#!#$&02&0%0E!.?202!#$BB2&'('$/0!-20#/*)2-!

>/%0'/('*$&!('!022*&D!*00%20!'?('!?(-!)22&!12/#2*82-!$/!282&!2S1+*#*'+,!B(/I2-!(0!#+$02-!

0%)02a%2&'+,!/2$12&2-E!A%#?!*00%20!*&#+%-2!'?2!B$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!0'(&-(/-!>$/!

D$82/&B2&'(+!$)X2#'*$&0!'$!&29!D.H@0N!9?*#?!9(0!-2)('2-!9*'?*&!'?2!O5AUN!*&02/'2-!*&'$!'?2!

>*/0'!82/0*$&!$>!'?2!@"ON!(&-!+('2/!(+'2/2-!*&!/201$&02!'$!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!\'?202!(+'2/('*$&0!(&-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

FF!"&-/29!"++2B(&N!V529!D.H@!.*B2+*&2!A+*10N!R/%0'/('*$&!c$*+0!U82/!*&!A2$%+NW!!"#$%&'($#)'*%+)N!U#'$)2/!K;N!KLLQN!?''16dd-$B(*&&(B29*/2E#$BdKLLQdFLdK;d&29CD'+-C'*B2+*&2C0+*10C>/%0'/('*$&C)$*+0C$82/C*&C02$%+dE!!

FK!34"55N!V529!D.H@![/$D/(B6!Y?('!I*&-!$>!*&'2/&2'!-$!,$%!9(&'e!NW!J%&2!KTN!KLLMN!?''16dd1(/E*#(&&E$/Dd>*+20d1(/*0dc""f3&'/$f529O.H@0f[(/*0fKTJ%&LME1->E!

FT!34"55N!V529!D.H@![/$D/(B!g1-('2NW!^(,!TFN!KLLQN!?''16dd999E*#(&&E$/Dd2&d(&&$%&#2B2&'0d(&&$%&#2B2&'CL_B(,LQC2&E?'BE!

FZ!34"55N!V529!D.H@!U82/8*296!34"55!^22'*&DN!A2$%+N!h$/2(NW!U#'$)2/!K;N!KLLQN!?''16dd02+E*#(&&E$/DdB22'*&D0d02$%+KLLQd'/(&0#/*1'C&29CD'+-0C1/$D/(BC$82/8*29CK;$#'LQC2&E'S'E!

F<!3&'2/8*290N!A21'2B)2/!KLFLE!

F;!3&'2/&('*$&(+!./(-2B(/I!"00$#*('*$&N!V4/2('*$&!$>!529!D.H@0!(&-!./(-2B(/I![/$'2#'*$&Ni!J%+,!MN!KLLQN!?''16dd999E*&'(E$/Dd*&-2SE1?1e$1'*$&j#$Bf#$&'2&'k'(0Ij8*29k*-jKLL<k3'2B*-jF<TkD2'#$&'2&'jE!

F_!O"4N!VO"4!4$BB%&*a%blA,-&2,NW!J%&2!KZN!KLLQN!?''16ddD(#E*#(&&E$/Dd0,0'2Bd>*+20dA,-&2,mKL4$BB%&*a%2E1->E!

Page 67: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<!

'=2!*&*'*(+!/2(0$&*&>!)2=*&-!'=2!0'(&-(/-!(/2!-20#/*)2-!*&!'9$!2?1+(&('$/,!@2@$/(&-(!1%)+*0=2-!

),!34"55!*&!A#'$)2/!BCCD!(&-!E(,!BCCFGDHIGF!!3&!'=2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!'$!'=2!'=*/-!82/0*$&!$J!'=2!K"LM!

1%)+*0=2-!*&!A#'$)2/!BCCFM!34"55!N/20*-2&'!7$-!O2#P0'/$@!+*0'0!Q28(+%('*$&!#/*'2/*(M!-*01%'2!

/20$+%'*$&!0'(&-(/-0!(&-!1/$#2-%/20M!(&-!#$&'2&'*$&!/20$+%'*$&!1/$#2-%/20R!(0!)2*&>!(@$&>!'=2!

(/2(0!Q9=2/2!'=2!1/$#200!$J!#$&'*&%$%0!*'2/('*$&!(&-!#$@@%&*',!J22-)(#P!*0!2002&'*(++,!

#$@1+2'2IRBC!!S$9282/M!*&!*'0!E(/#=!BCGC!4$@@%&*T%U0!'$!'=2!O$(/-M!'=2!L$82/&@2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!

4$@@*''22!VL"4H!0'('2-!'=('!*'!Q)2+*282W-X!'=*0!*'2@!0=$%+-!&$'!)2!+*0'2-!$&!'=2!Y#+$02-!*'2@0Z!+*0'!

9*'=!/2012#'!'$!'=2!&29!>.[K!1/$#200MR!(/>%2-!'=('!'=2!0'(&-(/-!9(0!*&(11/$1/*('2M!(&-!

/2T%20'2-!@$/2!-2'(*+!J/$@!34"55!0'(JJ!$&!=$9!'=2!0'(&-(/-!9$%+-!)2!*@1+2@2&'2-IBG!

A'=2/!*&'2/8*29220!2?1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'=('!),!1/$#22-*&>!9*'=!*@1+2@2&'('*$&!$J!'=2!L5\A!

/2#$@@2&-('*$&0!)2J$/2!'=$/$%>=+,!/201$&-*&>!'$!#$@@%&*',!#$&#2/&0!$82/!'=2!&2#200*',!J$/!(!

>.[K!2?1(&0*$&]9=*#=!9$%+-!*&#+%-2!(!'=$/$%>=!2#$&$@*#!(&(+,0*0!(&-!-2@$&0'/('*&>!'=2!

#(1()*+*',!$J!'=2!/$$'!'$!0#(+2!0%##200J%++,]34"55!=(0!#/2('2-!#$&'/$82/0*20!'=('!#$%+-!=(82!

)22&!(8$*-2-IBB!

3&!$'=2/!*&'2/8*290M!*'!9(0!0%>>20'2-!'=('!'=2!-2+(,0!(/2!(!&2#200(/,!1(/'!$J!'=2!)$''$@^%1M!@%+'*^

0'(P2=$+-2/!(11/$(#=!'$!9=*#=!34"55!*0!#$@@*''2-IB_!!

!"#$$%&'()*)+,-./$0112(13$

O(02-!$&!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'0!$&!'=2!J*/0'!82/0*$&!$J!'=2!K/(J'!"11+*#(&'!L%*-2)$$PM!34"55!

*-2&'*J*2-!J$%/!QA82/(/#=*&>!300%20R!/2+('2-!'$!'=2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$J!&29!>.[K06!GH!./(-2@(/P!

N/$'2#'*$&`!BH!N$'2&'*(+!J$/!E(+*#*$%0!4$&-%#'`!_H!\2#%/*',!(&-!\'()*+*',a7$$'!b$&2!\#(+*&>`!(&-!

cH!.[K!K2@(&-!(&-!d#$&$@*#!"&(+,0*0IBc!

!"#"4$$5)*6(7*)8$9):;(+;-:.$

3&!/201$&02!'$!'/(-2@(/P^/2+('2-!#$&#2/&0!/(*02-!*&!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'0!$&!'=2!J*/0'!-/(J'!$J!'=2!

K"LM!34"55!1+2->2-!'$!-*0#%00!'/(-2@(/P!*00%20!0'2@@*&>!J/$@!'=2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$J!&29!>.[K0!

Q9*'=!(++!/2+28(&'!1(/'*20R!(&-!9*'=!3&'2++2#'%(+!N/$12/',!$/>(&*e('*$&0!(/$%&-!'=2!9$/+-I!A&!

E(/#=!;M!BCCFM!'=2!34"55!O$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!-*/2#'!'=2!L5\AZ0!3&'2++2#'%(+!N/$12/',!

4$&0'*'%2&#,M!*&!#$&f%&#'*$&!9*'=!34"55!0'(JJM!'$!J$/@!(&!3@1+2@2&'('*$&!72#$@@2&-('*$&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GD!34"55M!Q529!>.[K!N/$>/(@!d?1+(&('$/,!E2@$/(&-%@6!E$/(+*',!(&-!N%)+*#!A/-2/!A)f2#'*$&!4$&0*-2/('*$&0!*&!529!>.[K0MR!A#'$)2/!BFM!BCCDM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a@$/(+*',^1%)+*#^$/-2/^-/(J'^BF$#'CD^2&I1-J`!34"55M!Q529!>.[K!N/$>/(@!d?1+(&('$/,!E2@$/(&-%@6!\'(&-(/-0!J$/!E$/(+*',!(&-!N%)+*#!A/-2/!7202(/#=MR!E(,!_CM!BCCFM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a@$/(+*',^1%)+*#^$/-2/^_C@(,CF^2&I1-JI!

GF!3&'2/8*290M!\21'2@)2/!BCGCI!

BC!34"55M!QK/(J'!"11+*#(&'!L%*-2)$$PM!g2/0*$&!_MR!A#'$)2/!cM!BCCFM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a-/(J'^/J1^#+2(&^Cc$#'CF^2&I1-JI!

BG!QL"4!4$@@%&*T%U]5(*/$)*MR!E(/#=!GCM!BCGCM!=''16aa>(#I*#(&&I$/>a0,0'2@aJ*+20a5(*/$)*h4$@@%&*T%2I1-JI!

BB!3&'2/8*290M!\21'2@)2/!BCGCI!

B_!3&'2/8*290M!\21'2@)2/!BCGCI!

Bc!34"55M!Q529!>.[K!K/(J'!"11+*#(&'!L%*-2)$$P6!"&(+,0*0!$J!N%)+*#!4$@@2&'Mi!j2)/%(/,!GDM!BCCFM!=''16aa999I*#(&&I$/>a2&a'$1*#0a&29^>'+-0a(>8G^(&(+,0*0^1%)+*#^#$@@2&'0^GDJ2)CF^2&I1-JI!

Page 68: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

.2(>!?37.@!'$!(--/200!'/(-2>(/A!#$&#2/&0BCD!E$/!(--*'*$&(+!*&F$/>('*$&!$&!'G2!37.H!1+2(02!022!

02#'*$&!IBI!$F!'G*0!/21$/'B!

!"#"#$$%&'()'*+,$-&.$/+,*0*&12$3&)410'$

3&!E2)/%(/,!CJJKH!34"55!1/$>*02-!'$!L(#'*82+,!0$+*#*'MN!F22-)(#AO!$&!'G2!1$'2&'*(+!F$/!>(+*#*$%0!

#$&-%#'!?012#*F*#(++,!#/*>*&(+!#$&-%#'6!1G*0G*&PH!1G(/>*&PH!>(+9(/2H!)$'&2'0@!*&!'G2!&29!Q5R!

&(>201(#2BC;!34"55!02'!%1!(!9*A*!'$!(--/200!(++!F$%/!L$82/(/#G*&P!*00%20O!*&!"1/*+!CJJKS!(0!$F!

>*-T"%P%0'!CJUJ!$&+,!'9$!#$>>2&'0!G(-!)22&!1$0'2-!-*/2#'+,!'$!'G2!9*A*BC<!3&!Q2#2>)2/!CJJKH!

34"55!0'(FF!(&&$%&#2-!'G('!*'!9$%+-!20'()+*0G!'9$!'2>1$/(/,!P/$%10!$F!2V12/'0!'$!(--/200!'G202!

*00%20BCW!.G202!'9$!P/$%10H!'G2!X$&2!E*+2!"##200!?XE"@!"-8*0$/,!Y/$%1!(&-!'G2!Z*PG!R2#%/*',!$1T

[282+!Q$>(*&!"-8*0$/,!Y/$%1!?ZR.[Q@H!1%)+*0G2-!(!02'!$F!-$#%>2&'0!$&!>(+*#*$%0!#$&-%#'!

9*'G*&!&29!P.[Q0!(&-!G2+-!'9$!9$/A0G$10!('!'G2!\(/#G!CJUJ!34"55!>22'*&P!*&!5(*/$)*BCK!

!"#"!$$5(01.*'6$+)4$5'+7*,*'689&&'$:&)($50+,*);$

.G2!34"55!]$(/-!-2+2P('2-!9$/A!$&!'G2!02#%/*',!(&-!0'()*+*',!*00%2!'$!'G2!R2#%/*',!(&-!R'()*+*',!

"-8*0$/,!4$>>*''22!(&-!'G2!7$$'!R2/82/!R,0'2>!"-8*0$/,!4$>>*''22H!9G*#G!^$*&'+,!#$&-%#'2-!(!

0'%-,!(&(+,_*&P!'G2!*>1(#'!$F!'G2!1/$1$02-!P.[Q!2V1(&0*$&!$&!02#%/*',!(&-!0'()*+*',!9*'G*&!'G2!

Q5R!/$$'!02/82/!0,0'2>B!"!/21$/'!$&!/$$'!0#(+*&P!9(0!1%)+*0G2-!$&!"%P%0'!IUH!CJJKS!(!0'%-,!$&!

/$$'!_$&2!(%P>2&'('*$&!(&-!*>1(#'!(&(+,0*0!F$++$92-!$&!R21'2>)2/!U<H!CJJKBIJ!

!"#"<$$=>?$?(@+)4$+)4$A0&)&@*0$B)+,62*2$

3&!`#'$)2/!CJJ;H!'G2!34"55!]$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!-*/2#'!'G2!a/20*-2&'!$F!34"55!'$6!

!"##$%%$"&'(&'$&)*+*&)*&,'%,-).'/.'('0*+-,(/1*'*!"&"#$!'!"&%-1,$&2'3$0#'"0'

"02(&$4(,$"&',"')*1$5*0'3$&)$&2%'"&'*!"&"#$!'6-*%,$"&%'0*1(,$&2',"',7*')"#($&'

0*2$%,0(,$"&'#(08*,9'%-!7'(%:'

;' <7*,7*0',7*')"#($&'0*2$%,0(,$"&'#(08*,'$%'"&*'#(08*,'"0'<7*,7*0'*(!7'

=>?'3-&!,$"&%'(%'('%*+(0(,*'#(08*,9''

;' <7*,7*0'0*2$%,0(,$"&%'$&')$33*0*&,'=>?%'(0*'%-/%,$,-,(/1*9''

;' <7(,'(0*',7*'*33*!,%'"&'!"&%-#*0'(&)'+0$!$&2'/*7(5$"0'"3',7*'%<$,!7$&2'

!"%,%'$&5"15*)'$&'#"5$&2'30"#'"&*'=>?',"'(&",7*09''

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

CD!34"55H!L"-$1'2-!]$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!b!\2V*#$Hc!\(/#G!;H!CJJKH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d>*&%'20d/20$+%'*$&0TJ;>(/JKBG'>B!

C;!34"55H!L529!P.[Q!Q/(F'!"11+*#(&'!Y%*-2)$$A6!"&(+,0*0!$F!a%)+*#!4$>>2&'Hc!E2)/%(/,!UWH!CJJKH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d'$1*#0d&29TP'+-0d(P8UT(&(+,0*0T1%)+*#T#$>>2&'0TUWF2)JKT2&B1-FB!

C<!34"55H!L529!P.[Q!`82/(/#G*&P!300%20HO!G''16dd0'B*#(&&B$/Pd&29TP'+-T$82/(/#G*&PT*00%20d*&-2VB#P*e&29fP'+-f$82/(/#G*&Pf*00%20B!

CW!34"55H!L.2>1$/(/,!gV12/'!"-8*0$/,!Y/$%10!E$/>2-!$&!529!P.[Q!\(+*#*$%0!4$&-%#'!3&*'*('*820Hc!Q2#2>)2/!IH!CJJKH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d(&&$%&#2>2&'0d(&&$%&#2>2&'TJI-2#JKT2&BG'>B!

CK!34"55H!L\*'*P('*&P!\(+*#*$%0!4$&-%#'!*&!529!P.[QbX$&2!E*+2!"##200!(&-!Z*PG!R2#%/*',!X$&2!.[QHc!E2)/%(/,!CCH!CJUJH!G''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Pd2&d(&&$%&#2>2&'0d(&&$%&#2>2&'TCCF2)UJT2&BG'>B!

IJ!34"55H!LR2#%/*',!(&-!R'()*+*',6!7$$'!X$&2!R#(+*&PHc!G''106dd0'B*#(&&B$/Pd&29TP'+-T$82/(/#G*&PT*00%20d*&-2VB#P*e02#%/*',f(&-f0'()*+*',f/$$'f_$&2f0#(+*&PB!

Page 69: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!" #$%&"'("&$)")**)+&",*"&$)"-%./)&"(&.0+&0.)"%12"3.'+'14",1"1)#"567"

)1&.%1&(8"%12""

!" #$)&$)."&$).)"%.)",&$)."-%./)&("#'&$"('-'9%."'((0)(8"%12"'*"(,"$,#"%.)"

&$)()"'((0)("%22.)(()2"%12":;"#$,<=>"!

3&!*'0!/20$+%'*$&>!'?2!@$(/-!0'('2-!'?('!*'0!-2#*0*$&!'$!#(++!A$/!(&!*&-212&-2&'!0'%-,!9(0!B$'*8('2-!

),!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!C#$&#2/&*&D!#$B12'*'*$&E/2+('2-!*00%20!0%#?!(0!-*AA2/2&'*(+!1/*#*&DF!9*'?!

/2012#'!'$!1/$1$02-!&29!/2D*0'/,!(D/22B2&'0!)2'922&!34"55!(&-!'?2!$12/('$/0!$A!'?2!G)*H>!G*&A$!

(&-!G$/D!/2D*0'/*20>!9?*#?!?(-!)22&!1$0'2-!A$/!#$BB2&'!*&!I%+,!JKK;GLJ!

3&!(!M2#2B)2/!N<>!JKK<!+2''2/!'$!34"55O0!4PQ!(&-!@$(/-!4?(*/B(&>!'?2!R&*'2-!S'('20!

M21(/'B2&'!$A!4$BB2/#2>!$&!)2?(+A!$A!'?2!RS!D$82/&B2&'>!2T1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'?('!'?2!

1%)+*#('*$&!$A!'?2!A*/0'!-/(A'!$A!'?2!M"U!?(-!1/2#2-2-!'?2!#$B1+2'*$&!$A!'?*0!0'%-,GLL!S282/(+!$'?2/!

D/$%10>!*&#+%-*&D!'?2!5('*$&(+!"00$#*('*$&!$A!V(&%A(#'%/2/0>LW!".X.>LY!(&-!'?2!3&'2/&2'!

4$BB2/#2!4$(+*'*$&L;!(+0$!2T1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'?('!34"55!?(-!&$'!,2'!A*++2-!*'0!$)+*D('*$&!'$!

#$&-%#'!(!'?$/$%D?!2#$&$B*#!0'%-,!1/*$/!'$!/2+2(0*&D!'?2!M"UGLZ!!!

S$B2!*&'2/8*29220!(+0$!2T1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'?('!'?*0!(&(+,0*0!0'*++!/2B(*&0!'$!)2!0('*0A(#'$/*+,!

#$&-%#'2->!9?*+2!$'?2/0!)2+*282-!'?2!2#$&$B*#!0'%-*20!34"55!?(0!#$BB*00*$&2-!?(82!)22&!

?2+1A%+!*&!*&A$/B*&D!'?2!-2)('2!$82/!82/'*#(+!*&'2D/('*$&!)2'922&!/2D*0'/*20!(&-!/2D*0'/(/0![A$/!

B$/2!*&A$/B('*$&!$&!'?*0!-2)('2>!022!C\2/'*#(+!3&'2D/('*$&F!)2+$9]GL<!!

3&!V(/#?!JKK^>!34"55!/2+2(02-!'9$!0'%-*20!),!R&*82/0*',!$A!4?*#(D$!2#$&$B*0'!M2&&*0!4(/+'$&>!

$&2!$&!'?2!*B1(#'!$A!D._M0!$&!#$&0%B2/!92+A(/2!(&-!$&2!$&!'?2!1$00*)*+*',!$A!1/*#2!#(10!$&!'?2!

1/*#20!#?(/D2-!),!&29!D._M!/2D*0'/*20!A$/!02#$&-!+282+!-$B(*&0G!3&!'?202!0'%-*20>!4(/+'$&!

#$&#+%-2-!'?('!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$A!&29!D._M0!9$%+-!C*B1/$82!#$&0%B2/!92+A(/2!),!A(#*+*'('*&D!

2&'/,!(&-!#/2('*&D!&29!#$B12'*'*$&GGGG!.?2!+*`2+,!2AA2#'!$A!34"55O0!1/$1$0(+!*0!'$!*&#/2(02!$%'1%'>!

+$92/!1/*#2!(&-!*&#/2(02!*&&$8('*$&GF!a2!(+0$!0'('2-!'?('!1/*#2!#(10!$&!&29!._M0!92/2!

C%&&2#200(/,F!(&-!'?('!*B1$0*&D!1/*#2!#(10!B(,!?(/B!'?2!B(/`2'1+(#2!),!1+(#*&D!+*B*'0!$&!'?2!

1/*#*&D!A+2T*)*+*',!$A!&29!/2D*0'/*20!9*'?$%'!1/$8*-*&D!B(&,!)2&2A*'0!'$!/2D*0'/(&'0GL^!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LN!34"55>!C"-$1'2-!720$+%'*$&0!A/$B!34"55!@$(/-!V22'*&D>b!Q#'$)2/!N<>!JKK;>!?''16cc999G*#(&&G$/Dc2&cB*&%'20c/20$+%'*$&0EN<$#'K;G?'BG!

LJ!34"55>!Cd/$1$02-!G@3e>!G35fQ!(&-!GQ7U!D._M!72D*0'/,!"D/22B2&'0>F!I%+,!J<>!JKK;>!?''16cc999G*#(&&G$/Dc2&c(&&$%&#2B2&'0c(&&$%&#2B2&'EJEJ<g%+K;G?'BG!

LL!V2/2-*'?!"G!@(`2/>!R&*'2-!S'('20!M21(/'B2&'!$A!4$BB2/#2>!C_2''2/!'$!4?(*/B(&!M2&D('2E.?/%0?>b!M2#2B)2/!N<>!JKK<>!?''16cc999G*#(&&G$/Dc#$//201$&-2&#2c)(`2/E'$E-2&D('2E'?/%0?EN<-2#K<E2&G1-AG!

LW!5('*$&(+!"00$#*('*$&!$A!V(&%A(#'%/2/0>!C3&-%0'/,!4$BB2&'0!'$!'?2!529!U._M!d/$D/(B!(&-!d/$#200>b!M2#2B)2/!NY>!JKK^>!?''16ccA$/%BG*#(&&G$/Dc+*0'0cD'+-ED%*-2c1-AZTD9hi@.+;G1-AG!

LY!".X.>!C".X.!4$BB2&'0!$&!529!D._M!U%*-2)$$`>b!M2#2B)2/!NY>!JKK<>!?''16ccA$/%BG*#(&&G$/Dc+*0'0cD'+-ED%*-2c-$#85^UILeV4-G-$#G!

L;!3&'2/&2'!4$BB2/#2!4$(+*'*$&>!C4$BB2&'0!$&!'?2!529!D._M!d/$D/(B!(&-!d/$#200>b!M2#2B)2/!NY>!JKK<>!?''16ccA$/%BG*#(&&G$/Dc+*0'0cD'+-ED%*-2c1-A9*@H77)RN"G1-AG!

LZ!V*#?(2+!d(+(D2>!C34"55!O0!P#$&$B*#!721$/'06!f*&-*&D!'?2!V*00*&D!d*2#20!'$!'?2!d%HH+2>b!?.,4.)(("@1%3($,&!YGW>!"1/*+!JKK^>!?''16cc1(12/0G00/&G#$Bc0$+LcM2+*82/,G#ABcSS75j3MNW^W;ZNj#$-2ZY^ZYZG1-Ak()0'/(#'*-lNW^W;ZNXB*/*-lNG!

L<!3&'2/8*290>!S21'2B)2/!JKNKG!

L^!34"55>!C529!D._M0md/2+*B*&(/,!721$/'0!$&!4$B12'*'*$&!(&-!d/*#*&D>F!V(/#?!W>!JKK^>!?''16cc999G*#(&&G$/Dc2&c(&&$%&#2B2&'0c(&&$%&#2B2&'EKWB(/K^E2&G?'BG!

Page 70: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

">'2/!1%)+*0?*&@!'?2!/21$/'0A!34"55!$12&2-!(!BCD-(,!1%)+*#!#$EE2&'!>$/%EA!*&!9?*#?!'?2,!92/2!

9*-2+,!#/*'*#*F2-GBH!"&-/29!"++2E(&!$>!'?2!I$E(*&!5(E2!J*/2!)+$@!(##%02-!34"55!$>!

K9?*'29(0?L*&@MN!*'0!$9&!1$0*'*$&0!$&!&[email protected]!(&-!1$*&'2-!$%'!'?('!4(/+'$&!#$&'/(-*#'2-!

?*E02+>!*&!'?2!/21$/'0!),!0(,*&@!&[email protected]!9$%+-!)2&2>*'!#$&0%E2/0!),!#/2('*&@!#$E12'*'*$&!)%'!

'?('!'?2,!9$%+-!&$'!)2!0%##200>%+!2&$%@?!'$!1$02!(!'?/2('!'$!'/(-2E(/P!?$+-2/0GBQ!R&*82/0*',!$>!

S*(E*!+(9!1/$>200$/!(&-!+$&@D'*E2!34"55!9('#?2/!S*#?(2+!T/$$EP*&!#(++2-!'?2!0'%-*20!K&(U82N!

(&-!#?(++2&@2-!4(/+'$&V0!#/2-*)*+*',A!1$*&'*&@!$%'!'?('!'?2!0'%-*20!*&#+%-2-!82/,!+*''+2!W%(&'*'('*82!

-('(!'$!)(#P!%1!'?2*/!#$&#+%0*$&0GBX!!

3&!Y%&2!XHH<A!34"55!#$EE*00*$&2-!4(/+'$&!'$!9/*'2!'9$!&29!1(12/0!/201$&-*&@!'$!'?202!

#/*'*#*0E0G!72(#'*$&0!92/2!E*Z2-A!9*'?!'?$02!9?$!#/*'*#*F2-!'?2!$/*@*&(+!1(12/0!%&E$82-!(&-!

$'?2/0[*&#+%-*&@!0282/(+!1$'2&'*([email protected]!(11+*#(&'0[0%11$/'*&@!'?2!1(12/0GB\!]2'922&!Y%&2!

XHH<!(&-!S(/#?!XHQHA!'?2!^"4!2E1?(0*F2-!'?2!K+(#P!$>!#$E1/2?2&0*82!(&(+,0*0!$>!2#$&$E*#!(&-!

#$E12'*'*$&!*E1(#'0N!$>!'?2!&[email protected]!1/$@/(E!*&!'?/22!4$EE%&*W%_0!'$!'?2!]$(/-!(&-!(!

021(/('2!+2''2/!'$!`2'2/!I2&@('2D.?/%0?G!3&!Y%+,!XHH<A!'?2!3&'2/&('*$&(+!./(-2E(/P!"00$#*('*$&!

]$(/-!$>!I*/2#'$/0!1(002-!(!/20$+%'*$&!0'('*&@!'?('!K34"55!?(0!,2'!'$!#$EE*00*$&!'?2!

*&-212&-2&'A!#$E1/2?2&0*82!2#$&$E*#!0'%-,!$>!'?2!-$E(*&!&(E2!/2@*0'/('*$&!E(/P2'!#(++2-!>$/!

),!*'0!]$(/-!$>!I*/2#'$/0!*&!XHH;N!(&-!'?('A!K(##$/-*&@+,A!34"55!?(0!-2E$&0'/('2-!&$!(-2W%('2!

2#$&$E*#!$/!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!a%0'*>*#('*$&!>$/!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!&[email protected]!!

3&!b21'2E)2/!XHH<A!O(//,!bE*'?!(&-!c$9(/-!4$)+2A!)$'?!E2E)2/0!$>!'?2!R&*'2-!b'('20!c$%02!$>!

721/202&'('*820V!Y%-*#*(/,!4$EE*''22A!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!7$-!]2#P0'/$E!0'('*&@!'?('!K'?2!$&+,!

2#$&$E*#!a%0'*>*#('*$&!1%'!>$/'?!'?%0!>(/!?(0!)22&!(&!34"55D#$E*00*$&2-!/21$/'!'?('!?(0!)22&!

9*-2+,!#/*'*#*F2-!>$/!>(*+*&@!'$!*&#+%-2!2E1*/*#(+!-('(!$/!(&(+,0*0N!(&-!(0P*&@!9?2'?2/!34"55!

*&'2&-2-!'$!>$++$9!'?/$%@?!$&!*'0!#$EE*'E2&'!'$!#(//,!$%'!(&!2#$&$E*#!0'%-,GBC!]2#P0'/$E!

/201$&-2-!),!1$*&'*&@!'$!'?2!'9$!/21$/'0!),!4(/+'$&!(&-!(&!d#'$)2/!XHHe!0'%-,!$&!82/'*#(+!

*&'2@/('*$&!),!47"!3&'2/&('*$&(+G!c2!0'('2-!'?('!Kf82&!9*'?!9?('!(112(/0!'$!)2!'?2!#$E12++*&@!

)2&2>*'0!$>!#$E12'*'*$&A!34"55V0!#$EE*'E2&'!'$!$12&!(&-!'/(&01(/2&'!1/$#20020!/2W%*/20!

>%/'?2/!(#'*$&!$&!34"55V0!1(/'N!(&-!-2#+(/2-!'?('!34"55!9$%+-!K/2'(*&!2#$&$E*0'0!'$!/28*29!(&-!

0%EE(/*F2!9$/P!'$!-('2!/2@(/-*&@!'?2!#$0'0!(&-!)2&2>*'0!$>!&[email protected](&-!'?2&!28(+%('2!

9?2'?2/!(--*'*$&(+!0'%-,!*0!/2W%*/2-GNB;!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BH!34"55A!KL#$E12'*'*$&@D1/*#*&@D1/2+*EM!4?/$&$+$@*#(+!3&-2ZAN!?''16gg>$/%EG*#(&&G$/@g+*0'0g#$E12'*'*$&D1/*#*&@D1/2+*EgG!

BQ!"&-/29!"++2E(&&A!K34"55!72+2(020!.9$!VJ?*'29(0?V!721$/'0!'$!I2>2&-!*'0!`$0*'*$&0!$&!&[email protected]!!"#$%&'($#)'*%+)A!S(/#?!CA!XHH<A!?''16gg-$E(*&&(E29*/2G#$EgXHH<gH\gHCg*#(&&D/2+2(020D'9$D9?*'29(0?D/21$/'0D'$D-2>2&-D*'0D1$0*'*$&0D$&D&29D@'+-0gG!

BX!S*#?(2+!T/$$EP*&A!KI221+,A!-221+,!>+(92-!2#$&$E*#!/21$/'!(&-!(&(+,0*0AN!,-.(('*$/01A!S(/#?!BA!XHH<A!?''16gg999G*#(&&9('#?G$/@g(/'*#+2G1+h0*-iH<gH\gHCgHXBeX\QG!

B\!34"55A!KL#$E12'*'*$&@D1/*#*&@D1/2+*EM!4?/$&$+$@*#(+!3&-2ZAN!?''16gg>$/%EG*#(&&G$/@g+*0'0g#$E12'*'*$&D1/*#*&@D1/2+*EgG!

BB!3&'2/&('*$&(+!./(-2E(/P!"00$#*('*$&A!K4/2('*$&!$>[email protected]!(&-!./(-2E(/P!`/$'2#'*$&Aj!Y%+,!eA!XHH<A!?''16gg999G*&'(G$/@g*&-2ZG1?1h$1'*$&i#$Ek#$&'2&'l'(0Pi8*29l*-iXHHCl3'2E*-iQC\l@2'#$&'2&'iG!

BC!O(E(/!bE*'?!(&-!c$9(/-!4$)+2A!O2''2/!'$!7$-!]2#P0'/$EA!b21'2E)2/!QCA!XHH<A!?''16gg999G*#(&&G$/@g#$//201$&-2&#2g0E*'?D#$)+2D'$D)2#P0'/$EDQC021H<D2&G1->G!

B;!7$-!]2#P0'/$EA!O2''2/!'$!O(E(/!bE*'?!(&-!c$9(/-!4$)+2A!b21'2E)2/!XXA!XHH<A!?''16gg999G-$E(*&&(E2&290G#$Eg91D#$&'2&'g%1+$(-0gXHH<gH<gXHH<DH<DXXD+2''2/D>/$ED/$-D)2#P0'/$EG1->G!

Page 71: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!"!##$%&'())*+,#+-#.,/('()/#0'+&+)12#

.>2!#$&#21'!$?!(&!@A1/200*$&!$?!3&'2/20'!B@C3D!E$-2+F!*&!9>*#>!1/$012#'*82!(11+*#(&'0!#$%+-!

2A1/200!G*&'2/20'H!*&!'$1I+282+!-$E(*&!0'/*&J0!)2?$/2!?*+*&J!#$E1+2'2!?$/E(+!(11+*#('*$&0F!9(0!

(-8(&#2-!('!'>2!C#'$)2/!K<<L!34"55!E22'*&J!*&!M2$%+!),!8(/*$%0!1(/'*#*1(&'0F!1/*E(/*+,!

1/$012#'*82!(11+*#(&'0!?/%0'/('2-!('!'>2!-2+(,0!(&-!%&#2/'(*&',!0%//$%&-*&J!'>2!J.NO!1/$J/(E!

(&-!#$&#2/&2-!'>('!'>2!1/$#200F!9>*#>!9(0!)2#$E*&J!*&#/2(0*&J+,!2A12&0*82F!E(,!)2!1%'!$??!

*&-2?*&*'2+,PQ;!"&!@C3!E$-2+!9$%+-!02/82!(0!(!0*J&!$?!1/$J/200F!>2+1*&J!'$!E$82!'>2!1/$#200!

?$/9(/-P!"'!'>2!E22'*&JF!'>2!34"55!R$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!-*/2#'!34"55!0'(??!'$!G0'%-,!'>2!1$'2&'*(+!

*E1(#'!$?!(!#(++!?$/!?$/E(+!S2A1/200*$&0!$?!*&'2/20'FTH!(&-!'$!0%)E*'!(!-/(?'!1/$1$0(+!?$/!R$(/-!

#$&0*-2/('*$&!('!'>2!O2#2E)2/!K<<L!R$(/-!E22'*&JPQU!.>2!R$(/-!&$'2-!'>('!'>2!E$-2+!G#$%+-!

(00*0'!'>2!/20$+%'*$&!$?!'>2!/2E(*&*&J!*00%20!(&-!(00*0'!34"55!*&!1+(&&*&J!?$/!'>2!#$E*&J!&29!

J.NO!/$%&-H!(&-!G9*++!+*V2+,!#$&'/*)%'2!'$!(!)2''2/!%&-2/0'(&-*&J!$?6!WD!'>2!2#$&$E*#!-2E(&-!?$/!

&29!J.NO0X!KD!'>2!&%E)2/!$?!J.NO0!'>('!(/2!+*V2+,!'$!)2!(11+*2-!?$/X!(&-F!YD!/2+28(&'!*&-%0'/,!

-('(PHQL!

C&!5$82E)2/!WWF!K<<LF!34"55!(&&$%&#2-!*'!9(0!#$&0*-2/*&J!0$+*#*'*&J!2A1/200*$&0!$?!*&'2/20'!*&!

&29!J.NO0PZ<!34"55!$12&2-!(!E$&'>I+$&J!1%)+*#!#$EE2&'!12/*$-!)2'922&!5$82E)2/!WW!(&-!

O2#2E)2/!WWF!K<<L!(&-!(0V2-!?$/!*&1%'!$&!'>2!?$/E!(&!@C3!E$-2+!E*J>'!'(V2P!B5$'26!*&!'>*0!

(&&$%&#2E2&'F!34"55!0'('2-!'>('!'>$02!9>$!9(&'2-!'$!>(82!'>2*/!#$EE2&'0!#$&0*-2/2-!),!'>2!

34"55!R$(/-!-%/*&J!*'0!O2#2E)2/!E22'*&J!0>$%+-!0%)E*'!#$EE2&'0!&$!+('2/!'>(&!5$82E)2/!

K;PDZW!!

3&!'>*0!/$%&-!$?!1%)+*#!#$EE2&'0F!0%11$/'2/0!$?!(&!@C3!E$-2+!*&#+%-2-!(!&%E)2/!$?!3&'2/&2'!

E(/V2'*&J!#$E1(&*20F!.NO!#$&0%+'*&J!?*/E0F!02+?I*-2&'*?*2-!1$'2&'*(+!J.NO!(11+*#(&'0!B*&#+%-*&J!

)%0*&200!(&-!#*8*+!0$#*2',!$/J(&*[('*$&0DF!(&-!\$O(--,P!.>2,!(/J%2-!*'!9$%+-!V*#VI0'(/'!'>2!

(11+*#('*$&!1/$#200!(&-!2&0%/2!'>('!$&+,!02/*$%0!(11+*#(&'0!92/2!*&8$+82-P!]$'2&'*(+!J.NO!

(11+*#(&'!M'21>2&!7%0V$90V*T0!#$EE2&'!*0!',1*#(+!$?!'>2!02&'*E2&'0!2A1/2002-!),!@C3!

1/$1$&2&'06!

!"#$%&'($")*$")+,-./,+$-&0",-1",//+'2$"'3",-0".&+$$-")*,)"*$%/."$-.4+$",%%"

,//%5&,-).",+$".$+5'4.6"25,7%$6",-1"#$%%85-)$-)5'-$19":$.)+5&)5-;")*$"+'4-1")'")*'.$"

#*'"*,2$"/,+)5&5/,)$1"5-")*$"3'+(,%"<=!">#5)*",))$-1,-)"3$$.6")'#,+1")*$"34%%"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Q;!34"55F!G529!J.NO!C82/8*296!34"55!^22'*&JF!M2$%+F!_$/2(FH!C#'$)2/!K`F!K<<LF!>''16aa02+P*#(&&P$/JaE22'*&J0a02$%+K<<La'/(&0#/*1'I&29IJ'+-0I1/$J/(EI$82/8*29IK`$#'<LI2&P'A'P!"!0(E1+2!#$EE2&'!?/$E!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'!R/2'!b(%02''!*0!*&-*#('*82!$?!'>*0!#$&#2/&6!G.>2/2!(/2!12$1+2!9>$!(/2!)%/&*&J!E$&2,!'/,*&J!'$!)%*+-!)%0*&20020!$&!'>*0!34"55!1+('?$/EF!(&-!*'T0!82/,!-*??*#%+'!9>2&!,$%!-$&T'!V&$9!9>('!'>2!'(/J2'!*0PH!

QU!34"55F!G"-$1'2-!R$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!c!M2$%+FH!C#'$)2/!Y<F!K<<LF!>''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&aE*&%'20a/20$+%'*$&0IY<$#'<LI2&P>'EP!

QL!34"55F!G"-$1'2-!R$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!c!M2$%+FH!C#'$)2/!Y<F!K<<LF!>''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&aE*&%'20a/20$+%'*$&0IY<$#'<LI2&P>'EP!

Z<!34"55F!G@A1/200*$&0!$?!3&'2/20'!*&!&29!J.NO06!34"55!022V0!*&1%'!(&-!(-8*#2FH!5$82E)2/!WWF!K<<LF!>''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&a(&&$%&#2E2&'0a(&&$%&#2E2&'IWW&$8<LI2&P>'EP!

ZW!34"55F!G@A1/200*$&0!$?!3&'2/20'!*&!529!J.NO0FH!>''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&a1%)+*#I#$EE2&'a1%)+*#I#$EE2&'I

K<<LWKP>'Ed2$*I&29IJ'+-0X!34"55F!Ge2$*I&29IJ'+-0f!4>/$&$+$J*#(+!3&-2AFH!>''16aa?$/%EP*#(&&P$/Ja+*0'0a2$*I&29IJ'+-0aX!34"55F!G@A1/200*$&0!$?!3&'2/20'!*&!529!J.NO06!M%EE(/,!$?!4$EE2&'0!BWW!5$82E)2/!'$!WW!O2#2E)2/!K<<LDFH!g(&%(/,!QF!K<W<F!>''16aa999P*#(&&P$/Ja2&a'$1*#0a&29IJ'+-0a0%EE(/,I(&(+,0*0I2$*I<Qh(&W<I2&P1-?P!

Page 72: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!""#$%!&$'()*++,)-'.#/)+0&!1#$02)!)3$($3.3)#+4+#)'*)%'33$&3+(&)!(/)5')!)#'(5)

-!6)&'-!7/)+(0.7$(5)&2+)$(&+57$&68)'7/+78)!(/)3!(!5+!1$#$&6)'*)&2+)!""#$%!&$'()

"7'%+009):#0'8)3!;$(5)&2+0+)<=>0)".1#$%)-'.#/)"7'3'&+)+!7#6)%'(*#$%&)7+0'#.&$'()

!(/)"+72!"0)2+#")0'3+)57'."0)!(/)$(/$4$/.!#0)!4'$/)3'7+)0+7$'.0)7$0;)!0)&2+6)

1+%'3+)!-!7+)'*)1+&&+7?"'0$&$'(+/8)3'7+)+@"+7$+(%+/)%'3"+&$&$'(9AB)

>&!?2#2@)2/!<AB!CDDEB!34"55!1%)+*0F2-!(!-/(G'!H>3!@$-2+B!9F*#F!9$%+-!/2I%*/2!1/$012#'*82!

(11+*#(&'0!'$!0%)@*'!*&G$/@('*$&!()$%'!'F2@02+820!(&-!'F2!/2I%20'2-!.J?B!(0!92++!(0!(!KLLBDDD!

-21$0*'B!*&!$/-2/!'$!1(/'*#*1('2!*&!'F2!G*/0'!/$%&-!$G!M.J?!(11+*#('*$&0N!.F$02!9F$!-*-!&$'!

1(/'*#*1('2!*&!'F2!H>3!9$%+-!&$'!)2!2+*M*)+2!'$!0%)@*'!(!M.J?!(11+*#('*$&!%&'*+!+('2/!/$%&-0NLO!

34"55!$12&2-!(!02#$&-!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'!12/*$-!$&!'F*0!@$-2+!'F/$%MF!P(&%(/,!C;B!CD<DN!

"/M%@2&'0!(M(*&0'!'F2!1/$1$02-!@$-2+!#+%0'2/2-!(/$%&-!G$%/!@(*&!1$*&'06!2GG2#'*82&200B!#$0'B!

1$00*)+2!G(8$/*'*0@!'$9(/-!34"55!*&0*-2/0B!(&-!*'0!1$'2&'*(+!'$!#/2('2!(!02#$&-(/,!@(/Q2'!G$/!

.J?!0+$'0NLR!

!"# $%%&'()*&+&,,-!3&!*'0!(&&$%&#2@2&'!$G!'F2!H>3!-/(G'!1/$1$0(+B!34"55!0'('2-!'F('!'F2!M$(+!

$G!'F2!H>3!9(0!'$!M('F2/!*&G$/@('*$&!()$%'!'F2!1$'2&'*(+!&%@)2/!$G!(11+*#('*$&0!*'!9$%+-!

282&'%(++,!/2#2*82N!>11$&2&'0!(/M%2-!'F('!@(&,!02/*$%0!(11+*#(&'0!9$%+-!0'(,!$%'!$G!'F2!

H>3!1/$#200!'$!(8$*-!/282(+*&M!'F2*/!*-2(0!G$/!(!0'/*&MB!1/282&'*&M!%&9(&'2-!#$@12'*'*$&!

S'F2!1/$1$02-!H>3!(11+*2-!$&+,!'$!'F2!G*/0'!/$%&-!$G!(11+*#(&'0T!+('2/!/$%&-0!92/2!$12&!

'$!(&,$&2UN!>'F2/0!)2+*282-!'F2!H>3!@$-2+!9(0!1/2@('%/2!M*82&!'F('!-/(G'!0'('%0!$G!'F2!

"11+*#(&'!V%*-2)$$Q!(&-!'F('!9$%+-!G%/'F2/!-2+(,!'F2!(11+*#('*$&!1/$#200!9F*+2!1%++*&M!

(''2&'*$&!(9(,!G/$@!'F2!$'F2/B!@$/2!02/*$%0!W$82/(/#F*&M!*00%20NX!!

! Y%11$/'2/0!(/M%2-!'F2!H>3!@$-2+!9$%+-!W*++%@*&('2X!'F2!M.J?!+(&-0#(12B!1/$8*-*&M!(!

)2''2/!1*#'%/2!$G!'F2!1/$012#'*82!(11+*#(&'0B!F2+1*&M!(8$*-!#$&G+*#'*&M!(11+*#('*$&0!(&-!

)2''2/!*&G$/@*&M!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'0!$G!(&,!02/*$%0!'F/2('0!'$!'F2*/!(11+*#('*$&0N!

."# /0,(-!Z$/!@(&,B!'F2!KLLBDDD!H>3!G22!0'$$-!$%'!*&!0F(/1!#$&'/(0'!'$!'F2!+(#Q!$G!(!0*@*+(/!

G22!-%/*&M!'F2!H>3!1F(02!$G!G*/0'!/$%&-!$G!M.J?!1/$1$0(+0!*&!CDDDNLL!>11$&2&'0!$G!'F2!G22!

9$//*2-!'F('!&$&[1/$G*'0B!(11+*#(&'0!G/$@!'F2!-282+$1*&M!9$/+-B!$/!'F$02!9F$!F(-!)22&!

(GG2#'2-!),!'F2!2#$&$@*#!#/*0*0!9$%+-!)2!2GG2#'*82+,!1/*#2-!$%'!$G!(11+,*&MN!>&2!#$@@2&'!

0'('2-!'F('!'F2!1/$M/(@!W0F$%+-!&$'!)2!%02-!(0!(!/282&%2!/(*0*&M!'$$+!G$/!34"55NX!

! Y%11$/'2/0!$G!'F2!G22B!9F*#F!*&#+%-2-!@(&,!02+G[*-2&'*G*2-!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'0B!)2+*282-!

*'!9$%+-!2GG2#'*82+,!1/282&'!&$&[02/*$%0!1/$1$0(+0N!.F2,!(+0$!&$'2-!'F('!'F2!KLLBDDD!H>3!

G22!9$%+-!)2!(11+*2-!'$!'F2!K<ALBDDD!28(+%('*$&!G22!/2I%*/2-!G$/!(&,!.J?!(11+*#('*$&!

(&-!'F('!'F2!'$'(+!#$0'!$G!2&'2/*&M!(!&29!.J?!*&'$!'F2!/$$'!*0!(/$%&-!KLDDBDDDB!@(Q*&M!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LC!Y'21F2&!7%0Q$90Q*B!WH>3BX!5$82@)2/!<;B!CDDEB!F''16\\G$/%@N*#(&&N$/M\+*0'0\2$*[&29[M'+-0\@0MDDDDENF'@+N!

LO!34"55B!W529!M.J?!]/$M/(@6!"012#'0!$G!(&!H^1/200*$&0!$G!3&'2/20'!(&-!]/2[72M*0'/('*$&!_$-2+B`!?2#2@)2/!<AB!CDDEB!F''16\\999N*#(&&N$/M\2&\'$1*#0\&29[M'+-0\2$*[@$-2+[<A-2#DE[2&N1-GN!

LR!34"55B!WH^1/200*$&0!$G!3&'2/20'!SH>3U!*&!529!M.J?06!]%)+*#!4$@@2&'0!Y%@@(/,!(&-!"&(+,0*0!S<<!5$8N!'$!<<!?2#N!CDDE!(&-!<A!?2#N!CDDE!'$!C;!P(&N!CD<DUBX!F''16\\999N*#(&&N$/M\2&\'$1*#0\&29[M'+-0\0%@@(/,[(&(+,0*0[2$*[<LG2)<D[2&N1-GN!

LL!3&!CDDDB!*&'2/20'2-!1(/'*20!92/2!*&0'/%#'2-!'$!0%)@*'!(!)/*2G!S&$!@$/2!'F(&!'2&!1(M20U!-20#/*1'*$&!$G!'F2*/!1/$1$0(+!

*&-*#('*&M!F$9!+*Q2+,!'F2,!92/2!'$!G$/@(++,!(11+,N!5$!G22!9(0!(002002-!%&'*+!(&!(11+*#(&'!$GG*#*(++,!(11+*2-N!34"55B!W34"55!a$Q$F(@(!_22'*&M!.$1*#6!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$G!529!.$1[J282+!?$@(*&0B`!P%&2!<OB!CDDDB!F''16\\999N*#(&&N$/M\2&\@22'*&M0\,$Q$F(@(\&29['+-['$1*#NF'@bcN!

Page 73: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

'>2!?@3!A22!(!/2+('*82+,!0B(++!1(/'!$A!'>2!1/$#200C!.>$02!9>$!#(&&$'!(AA$/-!'>2!?@3!A22!

+*D2+,!#(&&$'!(AA$/-!'$!(11+,!A$/!$/!B(&(E2!(!.FGH!'>2,!(/E%2-C!

!"# $%&&'()*#+,-%.'/'&0#/%1,.2#34566#'7&'2*.&8!@11$&2&'0!'$!'>2!?@3!1/$1$0(+!A2(/2-!

'>('!*'!9$%+-!E*82!'>$02!9>$!'2&-!'$!)2!B$/2!*&8$+82-!*&!34"55!(&!%&A(*/!(-8(&'(E2!

$82/!E2&2/(+!3&'2/&2'!%02/0!*&!(11+,*&E!A$/!&29!E.FG0C!?/*#!I/%&&2/JK*++*(B0H!'>2!4>*2A!

.2#>&$+$E,!@AA*#2/!$A!4$/2!3&'2/&2'!4$%&#*+!$A!72E*0'/(/0H!012#*A*#(++,!8$*#2-!'>*0!

#$&#2/&H!#+(*B*&E!'>2!?@3!*-2(!L/(*020!1/$A$%&-!(&'*J#$B12'*'*82!(&-!*&0'*'%'*$&(+!

#$&A*-2&#2!*00%20!A/$B!34"55!*'02+A!E(B*&E!'>2!/%+20!'$!)2&2A*'!(!E/$%1!$A!1(/'*#*1(&'0!

'>('!2&E(E2!*&!34"55M0!1/$#20020!'$!(!E/2('2/!2N'2&'!'>(&!3&'2/&2'!%02/0!E2&2/(++,COPQ!!

! R/$1$&2&'0H!*&#+%-*&E!7*#>(/-!.*&-(+!ST2&*$/!U*#2!R/20*-2&'!$A!-$B(*&!&(B2!/2E*0'/(/!

25@VWH!1$*&'2-!$%'!'>('!'>2!/%+20!A$/!$)'(*&*&E!(!&29!E.FG!92/2!'>2!0(B2!&$!B(''2/!

9>$!9(0!(11+,*&E!(&-!'>('!(!92++J2N2#%'2-!#$BB%&*#('*$&0!#(B1(*E&!9$%+-!2&0%/2!

'>('!(++!9>$!B*E>'!9(&'!'$!0%)B*'!(&!?@3!9$%+-!)2!()+2!'$!-$!0$CP;!!

! 3&!*'0!(&(+,0*0!$A!'>2!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0H!34"55!&$'2-!'>('!*A!'>2!I$(/-!92/2!'$!(11/$82!

'>2!?@3!1/$1$0(+H!*'!9$%+-!&22-!'$!$/E(&*X2!(!9*-201/2(-!*&A$/B('*$&!#(B1(*E&!'$!

2&0%/2!'>('!(++!1$'2&'*(+!(11+*#(&'0!92/2!(9(/2!$A!'>2!1/$E/(BCPY!

9"# $%/*7/',)#/%#:.*,/*#,#&*:%72,.;#<=>#0,.?*/8!T$B2!$11$&2&'0H!*&#+%-*&E!V*#/$0$A'!

(&-!.*B2!K(/&2/H!2N1/2002-!#$&#2/&!'>('!(11+*#(&'0!9$%+-!'/,!'$!LE(B2!'>2!0,0'2BO!),!

A*/0'!0%)B*''*&E!B%+'*1+2!?@30!(&-!'>2&!'%/&*&E!(/$%&-!(&-!02++*&E!'>2!/20%+'*&E!.FG0!'$!

'>$02!9*'>!/2(+!*&'2/20'!*&!B(*&'(*&*&E!'>2B!(&-!'>2!()*+*',!'$!1(,!B$/2!'>(&!'>2!$/*E*&(+!

#$0'C!.>$02!*&!A(8$/!$A!'>2!?@3!0,0'2BH!*&#+%-*&E!7*#>(/-!.*&-(+H!&$'2-!'>('!2(#>!?@3!

#$0'0!ZPPH[[[!(&-!1/$8*-20!&$!E%(/(&'22!'>('!'>2!-20*/2-!.FG!9*++!(#'%(++,!)2!$)'(*&2-H!

0$!'>2!+*D2+*>$$-!'>('!0$B2$&2!9*++!-2#*-2!'>2!1$00*)+2!(-8(&'(E20!$%'92*E>!'>2!

A*&(&#*(+!/*0D0!*0!\%*'2!0B(++CP]!

34"55!/2#2*82-!&2(/+,!^[[!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!-%/*&E!*'0!'9$!$12&!A$/%B0!$&!'>2!?@3!1/$1$0(+C!3&!

*'0!(&(+,0*0!$A!'>202!#$BB2&'0H!34"55!0'(AA!&$'2-!'>('!9>*+2!LB(&,!/201$&020!2N1/200*&E!

$11$0*'*$&!(#'%(++,!0'('2!'>2!?@3!*0!(##21'()+2!*A!#$&-%#'2-!*&!(!#2/'(*&!9(,HO!'>2/2!9(0!(!LE2&2/(+!

#$&02&0%0!'>('!#2/'(*&!$'>2/!$82/(/#>*&E!*00%20!0>$%+-!)2!(--/2002-!1/*$/!'$!'>2!+(%&#>!$A!'>2!

?@3!$/!E.FG!1/$E/(BCOQ[!!

34"55!>2+-!(!1%)+*#!-*0#%00*$&!$&!'>2!?@3!1/$1$0(+!-%/*&E!'>2!V(/#>!<[_[!B22'*&E!*&!5(*/$)*H!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

PQ!34"55H!L?N1/200*$&0!$A!3&'2/20'!*&!529!E.FG06!T%BB(/,!$A!4$BB2&'0!S__!5$82B)2/!'$!__!G2#2B)2/!<[[]WHO!`(&%(/,!^H!<[_[H!>''16aa999C*#(&&C$/Ea2&a'$1*#0a&29JE'+-0a0%BB(/,J(&(+,0*0J2$*J[^b(&_[J2&C1-AC!

P;!7*#>(/-!`!.*&-(+H!LT9*'#>*&E!$&!'>2!F*E>'6!?N1/200*$&!$A!3&'2/20'!A$/!529!.FG0HO!!"#$%&'()H!c2)/%(/,!<PH!<[_[H!>''16aa999C#*/#+2*-C#$Ba1$0'0a09*'#>*&Ed$&d'>2d+*E>'d2N1/200*$&d$Ad*&'2/20'd'+-0aC!

PY!34"55H!L?N1/200*$&0!$A!3&'2/20'!S?@3W!*&!529!E.FG06!R%)+*#!4$BB2&'0!T%BB(/,!(&-!"&(+,0*0!S__!5$8C!'$!__!G2#C!<[[]!(&-!_Y!G2#C!<[[]!'$!<;!`(&C!<[_[WHO!>''16aa999C*#(&&C$/Ea2&a'$1*#0a&29JE'+-0a0%BB(/,J(&(+,0*0J2$*J_PA2)_[J2&C1-AC!

P]!7*#>(/-!`!.*&-(+H!LT9*'#>*&E!$&!'>2!F*E>'6!?N1/200*$&!$A!3&'2/20'!A$/!529!.FG0HO!!"#$%&'()H!c2)/%(/,!<PH!<[_[H!>''16aa999C#*/#+2*-C#$Ba1$0'0a09*'#>*&Ed$&d'>2d+*E>'d2N1/200*$&d$Ad*&'2/20'd'+-0aC!

Q[!34"55H!L?N1/200*$&0!$A!3&'2/20'!S?@3W!*&!529!E.FG06!R%)+*#!4$BB2&'0!T%BB(/,!(&-!"&(+,0*0!S__!5$8C!'$!__!G2#C!<[[]!(&-!_Y!G2#C!<[[]!'$!<;!`(&C!<[_[WHO!>''16aa999C*#(&&C$/Ea2&a'$1*#0a&29JE'+-0a0%BB(/,J(&(+,0*0J2$*J_PA2)_[J2&C1-AC!

Page 74: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

-%/*&>!9?*#?!'?2/2!9(0!82/,!+*''+2!#$&02&0%0@AB!.?2!C"4!(+0$!?2+-!(!-*0#%00*$&!$D!'?2!EF3!(&-!

0%)G*''2-!(!4$GG%&*H%I!'$!'?2!J$(/-!*&!9?*#?!*'!KH%20'*$&L2-M!'?2!)2&2D*'0!$D!1%/0%*&>!D%/'?2/!

(!021(/('2!EF3!1/$#200N!9?*#?!#$%+-!-*0'/(#'!(''2&'*$&!(&-!/20$%/#20!D/$G!D*&(+*O*&>!'?2!&29!

>.PQ!1/$>/(G@RAS!!"'!'?('!G22'*&>N!'?2!34"55!J$(/-!8$'2-!(>(*&0'!*G1+2G2&'*&>!(&!EF3!G$-2+N!

#+(*G*&>!*'!9$%+-!#(%02!%&&2#200(/,!#$&D%0*$&!(&-!-2+(,!(&-!'?('!*'!9$%+-!'(T2!/20$%/#20!(9(,!

D/$G!$'?2/!#/*'*#(+!*00%20@A<!34"55!4EF!(&-!1/20*-2&'!7$-!J2#T0'/$G!0(*-!'?('!'?2!EF3!1/$1$0(+N!

*D!2&(#'2-N!9$%+-!?(82!K(--2-!(&$'?2/!0'21N!(&$'?2/!1/$#200N!(&$'?2/!02'!$D!#$GG%&*',!

-*0#%00*$&0!(&-!-2)('2R!'$!'?2!>.PQ!1/$#200@AU!!V$G2!*&'2/8*29220!9?$!?(-!0%)G*''2-!1%)+*#!

#$GG2&'0!2W1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'?('!'?*0!2W1+(&('*$&!D$/!'?2!J$(/-X0!-2#*0*$&!9(0!&$'!(-2H%('2N!

>*82&!'?2!D(#'!'?('!G(&,!$D!'?2!0%)G*00*$&0!-*-!*&!D(#'!2W1/200!0%11$/'!D$/!'?2!EF3@AY!!!

!"#$$%&'()*'&+$,--.)-$'/($01)$,*23)*)/0'045/$6)75**)/('045/$%)'*$

FD!'?2!D$%/!K$82/(/#?*&>!*00%20R!*-2&'*D*2-!),!34"55!0'(DD!8*(!'?2!#$GG2&'0!$&!'?2!D*/0'!82/0*$&!$D!

'?2!Q"CN!*00%20!/2+('2-!'$!'/(-2G(/T!1/$'2#'*$&!?(82!2+*#*'2-!'?2!G$0'!1%)+*#!(''2&'*$&@!!

Z$/!G(&,!'/(-2G(/T!?$+-2/0N!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$D!&29!>.PQ0!/(*020!#$&#2/&0!()$%'!'/(-2G(/T!

1/$'2#'*$&@!34"55!*0!'(T*&>!'?202!#$&#2/&0!02/*$%0+,[!$D!'?2!'92&',!1/*&#*1+20!+(*-!$%'!*&!'?2!

C5VF!/2#$GG2&-('*$&0N!'?2!&22-!'$!1/$'2#'!2W*0'*&>!'/(-2G(/T0!*0!+*0'2-!'?*/-N!()$82!'?2!&22-!

'$!1/282&'!'2#?&*#(+!*&0'()*+*',!9*'?*&!'?2!Q5V!(&-!'?2!&22-!'$!#$G1+,!9*'?!*&'2/&('*$&(+!?%G(&!

/*>?'0!&$/G0@AA!!

.?2!C5VF!/2#$GG2&-('*$&0!(+0$!*&#+%-2!'?2!&22-!'$!1/282&'!.PQ0!'?('!(/2!K#$&D%0*&>+,!0*G*+(/R!

'$!2W*0'*&>!'$1\+282+!-$G(*&0!$/!7202/82-!5(G20[!'?*0!/2#$GG2&-('*$&!*0!+*0'2-!02#$&-@!]?*+2!

'?*0!/2#$GG2&-('*$&!-$20!&$'!012#*D*#(++,!/2D2/2&#2!'/(-2G(/T0N!'?2!(##$G1(&,*&>!&$'20!+(/>2+,!

#$&#2/&!'/(-2G(/T!+(9@!3&!(!#$GG2&'!$&!'?2!/2#$GG2&-('*$&N!"8/*!Q$/*(N!'?2&!4?(*/!$D!'?2!

C5VF!4$%&#*+N!2W1/2002-!?2/!#$&#2/&!9*'?!'?2!+(&>%(>2N!&$'*&>6!

!"#$%&'(#)*+,%#)-.)#+*/"#0'#)-*#/*(./#/.'($.(*#01#)+.2*,.+3#/.45#6#7*/&*8*#4*#-.8*#

9+*.)*2#.'#&,:/&9&)#+*2$'2.'9"#7*)4**'#+*90,,*'2.)&0'%#;#.'2#<=#6=*=5#6#7*/&*8*#

70)-#;#.'2#<#9.'#7*#$%*2#)0#:+0)*9)#)+.2*,.+3%#.'2#0)-*+#&')*//*9)$./#:+0:*+)"#

+&(-)%5#.'2#4-&/*#<#-.%#%:*9&1&9#/&,&).)&0'%5#;#+*,.&'%#0:*'#)0#1$//#.'2#8.+&*2#

&')*+:+*).)&0'=>?##

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

AB!34"55N!K529!>.PQ!^1-('2!(&-!EF3!_(&2+!Q*0#%00*$&NR!`(/#?!aN!SbBbN!?''16cc&)$@*#(&&@$/>c&$-2caa;;@!

AS!C"4N!KC"4!4$GG%&*H%Id5(*/$)*NR!`(/#?!BBN!SbBbN!?''16cc>(#@*#(&&@$/>c0,0'2GcD*+20c5(*/$)*e4$GG%&*H%2@1-D@!

A<!34"55N!K"-$1'2-!J$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!d!5(*/$)*NR!`(/#?!BSN!SbBbN!?''16cc999@*#(&&@$/>c2&cG*&%'20c/20$+%'*$&0\BSG(/Bb\2&@?'G[!E+*0(!4$$12/N!KE3N!E3!d!5Ff!NR!@&+9/*#6AN!`(/#?!BSN!SbBbN!?''16cc999@#*/#+2*-@#$Gc1$0'0cSbBbb<BSe*#(&&e2W1/200*$&e$De*&'2/20'e2*e2*e&$c@!

AU!"0#*$N!Kg*>?+*>?'0!D/$G!'?2!34"55!`22'*&>!;\BS!`(/#?d5(*/$)*N!h2&,(NR!`(/#?!SYN!SbBbN!?''16cc999@(0#*$@#$Gc52904$&'2&'@(01Wi*-jSkA@!

AY!3&'2/8*290N!V21'2G)2/!SbBb@!

AA!C5VFN!KZ*&(+!721$/'!\!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$D!529!C2&2/*#!.$1\P282+!Q$G(*&0NR!"%>%0'!aN!Sbb;N!?''16cc>&0$@*#(&&@$/>c*00%20c&29\>'+-0c1-1\-2#bY\D/\1(/'(\ba(%>b;@?'G@!

A;!C5VFN!KZ*&(+!721$/'!\!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$D!529!C2&2/*#!.$1\P282+!Q$G(*&0NR!D$$'&$'2!<kN!"%>%0'!aN!Sbb;N!?''16cc>&0$@*#(&&@$/>c*00%20c&29\>'+-0c1-1\-2#bY\D/\1(/'(\ba(%>b;@?'GleD'&<k@!

Page 75: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

>*'?*&!'/(-2@(/A!+(9B!'?2!#$&#21'!$C!D#$&C%0*&E+,!0*@*+(/F!?$+-0!(!-*CC2/2&'!+2E(+!0'(&-(/-!'?(&!

'?2!#$&#21'!$C!D+*A2+*?$$-!$C!#$&C%0*$&GF!.9$!&(@20H"#@2!I(/-9(/2!(&-!"#@2!72(+',H@(,!)2!

D#$&C%0*&E+,!0*@*+(/BF!)%'B!(0!'?2,!(/2!%02-!C$/!-*00*@*+(/!E$$-0!(&-!02/8*#20B!(/2!%&+*A2+,!'$!#(%02!

#$&C%0*$&!(&-!'?2/2C$/2!-$!&$'!*&C/*&E2!$&!$&2!(&$'?2/J0!'/(-2@(/AG!"@2/*#(&!K&*82/0*',!+(9!

1/$C200$/!4?/*0'*&2!L(/+2,!2M1+(*&0!'?('!*&!-$@(*&!&(@2!1$+*#,B!9?2/2!$&+,!'?2!/2N%20'2-!0'/*&E!

*0!)2*&E!#$&0*-2/2-B!D#$&C%0*&E+,!0*@*+(/F!*0!'?2!$&+,!0'(&-(/-!'?('!#(&!)2!(11+*2-!)2#(%02!

-$@(*&!&(@20!+(#A!'?2!/2(+O9$/+-!#$&'2M'!&2#200(/,!'$!-2'2/@*&2!D+*A2+*?$$-!$C!#$&C%0*$&GF!.?2!

P5QR!/2#$@@2&-('*$&!D2N%('20!-$@(*&!&(@20!9*'?!'/(-2@(/A0!(0!+2E(++,!1/$'2#'()+2!

1/$12/'*20BF!0?2!9/*'20B!1$*&'*&E!$%'!'?('!%&-2/!'?2!1/$1$02-!0'(&-(/-0!"@2/*#(&!K&*82/0*',B!

9?*#?!#%//2&'+,!$9&0!(@2/*#(&G2-%B!9$%+-!'?2$/2'*#(++,!)2!()+2!'$!1/282&'!(&,$&2!2+02!C/$@!

/2E*0'2/*&E!G(@2/*#(&G!L%/'?2/@$/2B!0?2!&$'20B!'/(-2@(/A0!(/2!+(/E2+,!/2E*$&(++,!(&-!@(/A2'O

)(02-B!9?2/2(0!-$@(*&!&(@20!(/2!E+$)(+S!(!D$&2O0*T2OC*'0O(++!(11/$(#?!9$%+-!+2(82!#$&0%@2/0!

#$&C%02-!*&!$&2!1+(#2B!9?*+2!%&U%0'*C*()+,!-2&,*&E!0122#?!/*E?'0!*&!(&$'?2/GFVW!!

R&!'?2!$'?2/!0*-2!$C!'?2!-2)('2!(/2!'/(-2@(/A!?$+-2/0B!9?$!C2(/!'?('!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$C!&29!

E.XY0!9*++!9$/02&!2M*0'*&E!1/$)+2@0!9*'?!'/(-2@(/A!*&C/*&E2@2&'!(&-!#,)2/0N%(''*&EG!.?2,!C2(/!

'?2,!9*++!)2!/2N%*/2-!'$!D-2C2&0*82+,!/2E*0'2/F!'?2*/!'/(-2@(/A0!(0!E.XY0H(!#$0'+,!1/$#200!('!

Z[W\B]]]!12/!E.XYH(0!92++!(0!1%/#?(02!02#$&-!+282+!-$@(*&0!*&!2(#?!&29!.XY!'$!1/$'2#'!'?2*/!

)/(&-0G!^$&*'$/*&E!(&-!2&C$/#*&E!'?2*/!'/(-2@(/A0!(#/$00!(!)/$(-!&29!09('?!$C!-$@(*&!

/2E*0'/*20!9*++!)2!$82/9?2+@*&EB!'?2,!(/E%2GV_!`5$'!(++!(E/22!9*'?!'?202!(002/'*$&0G!K0*&E!'2&!

,2(/0!$C!-('(!C/$@!#(020!-2#*-2-!(##$/-*&E!'$!'?2!K&*C$/@!Y*01%'2!720$+%'*$&!a$+*#,B!L/2-!

b/2%E2/!(&-!"&'$&,!c(&!4$%82/*&E!$C!^*&-0!d!^(#?*&20!20'*@('2!'?('!'?2!'$'(+!(&&%(+!#$0'!'$!

'/(-2@(/A!?$+-2/0!/20%+'*&E!C/$@!&29!E.XY0!@(,!)2!(0!+*''+2!(0!Z]G[]!12/!'/(-2@(/A!

9$/+-9*-2G;]e!

"'!'?2!^(/#?!f]]_!34"55!@22'*&E!*&!^2M*#$!4*',B!'?2!g$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!/2N%20'!'?('!'?2!P5QRJ0!

3&'2++2#'%(+!a/$12/',!4$&0'*'%2&#,!C$/@!(&!3@1+2@2&'('*$&!72#$@@2&-('*$&!.2(@!`37.e!'$!

D-282+$1!(&-!1/$1$02!0$+%'*$&0!'$!'?2!$82/(/#?*&E!*00%2!$C!'/(-2@(/A!1/$'2#'*$&!*&!#$&&2#'*$&!

9*'?!'?2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$C!&29!E.XY0GF;[!.?*0!/20$+%'*$&!9(0!*&!/201$&02!'$!(!1/$1$0(+!),!

D@2@)2/0!$C!'?2!#$@@%&*',!9*'?!A&$9+2-E2!(&-!2M12/'*02!*&!'?*0!(/2(GF;f!.?202!#$@@%&*',!

@2@)2/0!92/2!*-2&'*C*2-!*&!*&'2/8*290!(0!@2@)2/0!$C!'?2!P5QRJ0!3&'2++2#'%(+!a/$12/',!

4$&0'*'%2&#,!`3a4eG;h!.?2!37.!9(0!$/E(&*T2-!),!'?2!3a4!*&!#$&0%+'('*$&!9*'?!'?2!34"55!0'(CCG!

"##$/-*&E!'$!'?2!g$(/-!/20$+%'*$&B!'?2!'2(@!0?$%+-!)2!D#$@1/*02-!$C!(&!*&'2/&('*$&(++,!-*82/02!

E/$%1!$C!12/0$&0!9*'?!A&$9+2-E2B!2M12/'*02B!(&-!2M12/*2&#2!*&!'?2!C*2+-0!$C!'/(-2@(/AB!#$&0%@2/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

VW!4?/*0'*&2!I(*E?'!L(/+2,B!D4$&82/E2&#2!(&-!3&#$&E/%2&#26!./(-2@(/A!X(9!(&-!34"55J0!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$C!529!P2&2/*#!.$1OX282+!Y$@(*&0BF!>(0?*&E'$&!4$++2E2!$C!X(9!7202(/#?!a(12/!5$G!f]]_OffB!?''16ii00/&G#$@i()0'/(#'j[<]]h]<G!

V_!k$0?%(!QG!k(/8*0B!D529!E.XY0!Q'*++!R&!./(#A!Y201*'2!./(-2@(/A!4$&#2/&0BF!!"#$%&#"'(#)$(*+,-"./01(2#3(45+/B!"1/*+!fB!f][]B!?''16ii999G'/(-2@(/A(&-#$1,/*E?'+(9)+$EG#$@if][]i]<i(/'*#+20i-$@(*&O&(@20i&29OE'+-0O0'*++O$&O'/(#AO-201*'2O'/(-2@(/AO#$&#2/&0iG!

;]!L/2-!b/2%E2/!(&-!"&'$&,!c(&!4$%82/*&EB!D"!l%(&'*'('*82!"&(+,0*0!$C!./(-2@(/A!3&C/*&E2@2&'!(&-!4$0'!'$!./(-2@(/A!I$+-2/0!*&!529!E.XY0BF!^*&-0!d!^(#?*&20!>$/A*&E!a(12/!f][]O[B!L2)/%(/,![]B!f][]B!?''16ii999G@*&-0(&-@(#?*&20G#$@i91O#$&'2&'i%1+$(-0i^d^Ol%(&'*'('*82O"&(+,0*0O$CO4$0'O$CO529O.XY0O'$O./(-2@(/A0G1-CG!

;[!34"55B!D"-$1'2-!g$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!H!^2M*#$Bm!^(/#?!VB!f]]_B!?''16ii999G*#(&&G$/Ei2&i@*&%'20i/20$+%'*$&0O]V@(/]_G?'@G!

;f!3)*-G!

;h!3&'2/8*290B!Q21'2@)2/!f][]G!

Page 76: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

1/$'2#'*$&>!$/!#$?12'*'*$&!+(9>!(&-!'@2!*&'2/1+(,!$A!'/(-2?(/B0!(&-!'@2!-$?(*&!&(?2!0,0'2?CD!

.@2!/20$+%'*$&!(+0$!-*/2#'2-!'@2!37.!'$!E0$+*#*'!*&1%'!A/$?!'@2!*&'2/20'2-!#$&0'*'%2&#*20!1/*$/!'$!

*'0!A*/0'!0200*$&!'$!2&0%/2!)/$(-!#$??%&*',!*&1%'!('!'@2!$%'02'!$A!*'0!9$/BCD;F!!

.@2!37.!9(0!#/*'*#*G2-!),!'@2!-$?(*&!&(?2!*&-%0'/,!(&-!'@2!"H"4!A$/!#$&'(*&*&I!$&+,!'/(-2?(/B!

*&-%0'/,!/21/202&'('*820!(&-!2J#+%-*&I!#$&0%?2/0>!3&'2/&2'!%02/0!(&-!-$?(*&!&(?2!/2I*0'/(&'0C!

3&!(!0'('2?2&'!/2I(/-*&I!'@2!37.K0!A*&(+!/21$/'>!"H"4!0(*->!EL2!(/2!(9(/2!$A!(!&%?)2/!$A!M%(+*A*2-!

*&-*8*-%(+0!9@$!2J1/2002-!*&'2/20'!*&!1(/'*#*1('*&I!*&!'@2!37.!)%'!92/2!0%??(/*+,!/2A%02-!

9*'@$%'!/2(0$&CD;<!!.@202!02&'*?2&'0!92/2!2#@$2-!*&!0282/(+!*&'2/8*290C!3&'2/8*29220!(+0$!/(*02-!

M%20'*$&0!()$%'!'@2!1/$#200!)2@*&-!'@2!#/2('*$&!$A!'@2!37.>!1(/'*#%+(/+,!A$#%0*&I!$&!9@2'@2/!'@2!

#/2('*$&!$A!(!'2(?!$A!2J12/'0!02+2#'2-!A/$?!(!0%)02'!$A!'@2!N5OP!#$&0'*'%2&#,!9(0!#$&0*0'2&'!

9*'@!34"55K0!#$??*'?2&'!'$!(!)$''$?Q%1>!?%+'*Q0'(B2@$+-2/!(11/$(#@!'$!1$+*#,!?(B*&IC;R!!

.@2!37.!?2'!8*(!'2+2#$&A2/2&#2!(&-!@2+-!'9$!*&Q12/0$&!0200*$&0!S$&2!*&!L(0@*&I'$&>!TC4C!(&-!$&2!

*&!O(&!U/(&#*0#$>!)$'@!0%11$/'2-!),!34"55!0'(AAV!)2'922&!W(/#@!X<>!XYYZ!(&-!'@2!0%)?*00*$&!$A!

*'0!A*&(+!/21$/'!'$!'@2!34"55![$(/-!$&!W(,!R>!XYYZC!3'0!-/(A'!/21$/'>!1%)+*0@2-!$&!"1/*+!XF>!XYYZ>!

9(0!$12&!A$/!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!A/$?!"1/*+!XF\W(,!XF>!XYYZC!.@2!A*&(+!/21$/'!9(0!?(-2!(8(*+()+2!

A$/!#$??2&'!A/$?!W(,!XZ\]%&2!XZ>!XYYZ^!'@*0!12/*$-!9(0!+('2/!2J'2&-2-!'$!]%+,!R>!XYYZC!O$?2!

*&'2/8*29220!/(*02-!#$&#2/&0!$82/!34"55K0!/201$&02!'$!'@2!37.!A*&(+!/21$/'C!.@2,!&$'2-!'@('!

'@$%I@!'@2!34"55![$(/-!@(-!#$??*00*$&2-!(!/21$/'!A/$?!'@2!37.!EA$/!#$&0*-2/('*$&!),!'@2!

34"55!#$??%&*',!('!'@2!_]%&2!XYYZ`!O,-&2,!?22'*&I>D;;!'@2!37.!9(0!&$'!I*82&!(!#@(&#2!'$!?22'!

9*'@!'@2![$(/-!-*/2#'+,!('!'@*0!?22'*&IC;a!!S.@2!37.!/2#$??2&-('*$&0!92/2>!@$9282/>!-*0#%002-!

('!(!#$&0%+'('*$&!0200*$&!$&!'/(-2?(/B!1/$'2#'*$&!(&-!?(+*#*$%0!)2@(8*$/C;ZV!

.@2!37.K0!W(,!XYYZ!A*&(+!/21$/'!1/$1$02-!'@2!A$++$9*&I!?2#@(&*0?0!A$/!'/(-2?(/B!1/$'2#'*$&6!

b! 3c!4+2(/*&I@$%02>!N+$)(++,!c/$'2#'2-!W(/B0!H*0'!(&-!(00$#*('2-!7*I@'0!c/$'2#'*$&!

W2#@(&*0?0>!(&-!0'(&-(/-*G2-!1/2Q+(%&#@!/*I@'0!1/$'2#'*$&!?2#@(&*0?0^!!

b! d&*A$/?!7(1*-!O%012&0*$&!O,0'2?^!!

b! c$0'!-2+2I('*$&!-*01%'2!/20$+%'*$&!?2#@(&*0?0!ScTT7cV^!!

b! L@$*0!/2M%*/2?2&'0!A$/!&29!.HT0^!(&-!!

b! d02!$A!(+I$/*'@?!*&!0'/*&I!#$&A%0*$&!/28*29!-%/*&I!*&*'*(+!28(+%('*$&CaY!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;F!3)*-C!

;<!"H"4>!EO'('2?2&'!$A!'@2!4$??*''22!'$!'@2!c%)+*#!4$&0%+'('*$&!$&!'@2!3?1+2?2&'('*$&!72#$??2&-('*$&!.2(?!S37.V!U*&(+!721$/'!$A!XZ'@!W(,!XYYZ>e!]%+,!;>!XYYZ>!@''106ff999C('+(/I2C*#(&&C$/IfA*+20f('+(/I2f#$//201$&-2&#2QY;g%+YZQ2&C1-AC!

;R!3&'2/8*290>!O21'2?)2/!XYhYC!

;;!34"55>!E"-$1'2-![$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!i!W2J*#$>e!W(/#@!R>!XYYZ>!@''16ff999C*#(&&C$/If2&f?*&%'20f/20$+%'*$&0QYR?(/YZC@'?C!

;a!3&'2/8*290>!O21'2?)2/!XYhYC!

;Z!34"55>!E529!I.HT!c/$I/(?i4$&0%+'('*$&!O200*$&!$&!./(-2?(/B!c/$'2#'*$&!(&-!W(+*#*$%0![2@(8*$/>D!]%&2!XF>!XYYZ>!@''16ff0,-C*#(&&C$/If&$-2fj;aaC!

aY!34"55>!EU*&(+!721$/'!$&!./(-2?(/B!c/$'2#'*$&!*&!529!I.HT0>e!W(,!XZ>!XYYZ>!@''16ff999C*#(&&C$/If2&f'$1*#0f&29QI'+-0f*/'QA*&(+Q/21$/'Q'/(-2?(/BQ1/$'2#'*$&QXZ?(,YZQ2&C1-AC!

Page 77: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

.>202!/2#$??2&-('*$&0!>(82!/(*02-!?%+'*1+2!$)@2#'*$&0A!(0!-20#/*)2-!*&!'>2!34"55!0'(BB!(&(+,0*0!

$B!1%)+*#!#$??2&'0!$&!'>2!37.!B*&(+!/21$/'CDE!"?$&F!'>2?6!

EC! .>2!3&'2/&('*$&(+!./(-2?(/G!"00$#*('*$&!F2&2/(++,!1/(*02-!'>2!37.!/2#$??2&-('*$&0!

)%'!2H1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'>('!'>2,!I?(,!&$'!)2!(-2J%('2!'$!(--/200!'>2!1$'2&'*(+!

1/$)+2?0!(00$#*('2-!9*'>!(&!%&+*?*'2-!2H1(&0*$&!$B!5.KL0!M&29!F.KL0NCODP!!

PC! Q$?2!>(82!/(*02-!'>2!#$&#2/&!'>('!'>2!3R!4+2(/*&F>$%02A!9>*#>!9$%+-!(#'!(0!(!/21$0*'$/,!

$B!'/(-2?(/G!/*F>'0!S*&#+%-*&F!B(?*+,!&(?20A!'/(-2!&(?20A!%&/2F*0'2/2-!?(/G0!(&-!

F+$)(++,!1/$'2#'2-!?(/G0TA!?(,!I/21/202&'!(!0'21!'$9(/-0!(!9>$++,!&29!F+$)(+!/2F*0'2/2-!

'/(-2?(/G!0,0'2?AO!'>2!#/2('*$&!$B!9>*#>!I*0!$%'0*-2!34"55U0!0#$12!(&-!(%'>$/*',CO!

4$??2&'0!0%)?*''2-!),!'>2!54V4!(&-!"K"4!2H1/200!#$&#2/&0!'>('!'>2!#/2('*$&!$B!'>*0!

#+2(/*&F>$%02!I#$%+-!2BB2#'*82+,!-2/(*+!34"55CO!

WC! "!X+$)(++,!R/$'2#'2-!Y(/G0!K*0'!SXRYKT!9$%+-!1/282&'!'>2!/2F*0'/('*$&!$B!F.KL0!(&-!

02#$&-!+282+!-$?(*&!&(?20!?('#>*&F!(&,!$B!'>2!?(/G0!*'!#$&'(*&0C!.>2!+*0'!9$%+-!#$&'(*&!

$&+,!'>$02!?(/G0!/2F*0'2/2-!*&!#$%&'/*20!*&!2(#>!$B!'>2!B*82!F+$)(+!/2F*$&0!-2B*&2-!),!

34"55C!Z11$&2&'0!(/F%2!'>('!/2F*0'2/*&F!(!'/(-2?(/G!*&!2(#>!/2F*$&!*&!$/-2/!'$!*&#+%-2!

*'!*&!'>2!XRYK!9$%+-!#$&0'*'%'2!(!?(@$/!)%/-2&!$&!'/(-2?(/G!>$+-2/0!9>*+2!1/$8*-*&F!

/2+('*82+,!+*''+2!1/$'2#'*$&C!.>2!#%//2&'!82/0*$&!$B!'>2!L"X!?(G20!&$!?2&'*$&!$B!(!XRYKC!

[C! "!#$??2&'!0%)?*''2-!),!X2$/F2!\*/*G$0!#(++0!'>2!V&*B$/?!7(1*-!Q%012&0*$&!Q,0'2?!

SV7QT!(&!I2H'/2?*0'!8*29!$B!'/(-2?(/G!/*F>'0!B(8$/*&F!3R!*&'2/20'0!*&!#$?1(/*0$&!9*'>!

'>2!VL7RO!M34"55U0!2H*0'*&F!V&*B$/?!L$?(*&]5(?2!L*01%'2]720$+%'*$&!R$+*#,N!'>('!

IF$20!)2,$&-!9>('!*0!1/$'2#'2-!),!+(9!(&-!-%2!1/$#200CO!Z11$&2&'0!'$!'>2!V7Q!B2(/!*'!

#$%+-!)2#$?2!I(&!2(0,A!#>2(1!'$$+!B$/!7282/02!L$?(*&!5(?2!^*@(#G*&FCO!

_C! R/*8(#,!(-8$#('20!9$//,!'>('!'>2!`>$*0!/2J%*/2?2&'!?(,!1$02!(!'>/2('!'$!B/22!0122#>C!3&!

(!0'('2?2&'!-2+*82/2-!('!'>2!Q,-&2,!34"55!?22'*&F!*&!a%&2!PbbcA!'>2!"']K(/F2!

4$??%&*',A!'>2!"']K(/F2!"-8*0$/,!4$??*''22!(&-!'>2!5$&]4$??2/#*(+!V02/0!

4$&0'*'%2&#,!&$'2-!'>('!'>2!`>$*0!/2J%*/2?2&'!-*-!&$'!'(G2!*&'$!(##$%&'!*&'2/&('*$&(+!

1/*8(#,!0'(&-(/-0!$/!&('*$&(+!+(90!1/$'2#'*&F!1/*8(#,CDW!!

.>2!/21$/'!9(0!#/*'*#*d2-!(0!>2(8*+,!92*F>'2-!*&!B(8$/!$B!2H*0'*&F!3R!*&'2/20'0!(&-!$82/0'211*&F!

)$'>!'>2!)$%&-0!$B!2H*0'*&F!#$1,/*F>'!(&-!'/(-2?(/G!+(9!(&-!34"55U0!$9&!?(&-('2!),!(0G*&F!

'>('!34"55!'(G2!/201$&0*)*+*',!B$/!1$+*#*&F!*&0'(&#20!$B!'/(-2?(/G2-!'2/?0!*&!02#$&-!(&-!'>*/-!

+282+!-$?(*&0C!3&!'>2*/!@$*&'!0'('2?2&'!*&!a%&2!PbbcA!'>2!"']K(/F2!"-8*0$/,!4$??*''22!(&-!5$&]

4$??2/#*(+!V02/0!4$&0'*'%2&#,!#+(*?2-!'>('!I*&!'>2!#(02!$B!'>2!37.!721$/'A!92!>(-!&2*'>2/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DE!34"55A!IQ%??(/,!"&(+,0*0!$B!37.!e*&(+!721$/'!4$??2&'0!SR$0']-2+2F('*$&!R/$#200!(&-!$'>2/!4$??2&'0TAO!Z#'$)2/!PbbcA!>''106ff0'C*#(&&C$/Ff-('(f9$/G01(#20f&29]F'+-]$82/(/#>*&F]*00%20f(''(#>?2&'0f'/(-2?(/Gg1/$'2#'*$&6PbbcEbb<PP[bEb]b]ED;_f$/*F*&(+f0%??(/,](&(+,0*0]*/']B*&(+]/21$/']b[$#'bc]2&C1-BC!

DP!!"&'>$&,!aC!h*++2/!(&-!a2&&*B2/!h*0GA!I`>$!*0!X$*&F!'$!Z9&!L$'"?(d$&i!!.>2!R2&-*&F!L$?(*&!5(?2!K(&-!X/()AO!K(&-0+*-2!P!SPbbcTC!

DW!34"55A!Ia$*&'!Q'('2?2&'!B/$?!"K"4f"']K(/F2!(&-!54V4!?(-2!('!Q,-&2,!Y22'*&F!/2!37.!721$/'AO!a%&2!P_A!PbbcA!>''16ff0'C*#(&&C$/FfF&0$]+*(*0$&f*&-2HC#F*i('g+(/F2g*/'g1/$#200g9$/G*&FgF/$%1C!

Page 78: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<!

'/(&01(/2&#,!&$/!$12&&200=!(&-!(&&$%&#2-!'>2*/!?$/@(+!$11$0*'*$&!'$!'>2!ABCDE!F&*?$/@!7(1*-!

G%012&0*$&!G,0'2@!(&-!'>*#H!I>$*0!1/$1$0(+0JKL!!

M$++$9*&N!'>2!37.!/21$/'E!'>2!O$(/-!02&'!(!+2''2/!$&!P#'$)2/!QRE!RSST!'$!'>2!A5GP!4$%&#*+!?$/!

/(1*-!/28*29E!0(,*&N!*'!9$%+-!*@1+2@2&'!0282/(+!37.!/2#$@@2&-('*$&0!%&+200!'>2!A5GP!4$%&#*+!

8$'2-!$'>2/9*02JKU!P&!P#'$)2/!RKE!RSSTE!'>2!A5GP!#(++2-!?$/!1(/'*#*1(&'0!?/$@!(++!0'(H2>$+-2/!

N/$%10!'$!?$/@!(!)/$(-!VG12#*(+!./(-2@(/H!300%20=!9$/H*&N!N/$%1!WG.3XJ!.>2!G.3!9$/H2-!'$!

1/$-%#2!(!#$&02&0%0!/21/202&'*&N!'/(-2$??0!(&-!#$@1/$@*020!(@$&N!1$0*'*$&0J!3'0!Y2#2@)2/!QQE!

RSST!/21$/'KZ!9(0!(11/$82-!),!'>2!A5GP!4$%&#*+E!9>*#>!V/20$+82[-\!'>('!'>2!G.3!1/$1$0(+!'$!

#/2('2!(!./(-2@(/H!4+2(/*&N>$%02!(&-!(!F&*?$/@!7(1*-!G%012&0*$&!1/$#2-%/2!(0!-20#/*)2-!*&!

'>2!G.3!721$/'!(/2!@$/2!2??2#'*82!(&-!*@1+2@2&'()+2!0$+%'*$&0!'>(&!'>2!#$//201$&-*&N!0'(??!

*@1+2@2&'('*$&!@$-2+0!'>('!92/2!-20#/*)2-!*&!@2@$/(&-(!(##$@1(&,*&N!'>2!Y/(?'!"11+*#(&'!

A%*-2)$$H!]2/0*$&!^J=K;!.>2!A5GP!1$0'2-!'>2!G.3!/21$/'!?$/!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'!)2'922&!*'0!

Y2#2@)2/!RSST!@22'*&N!(&-!_(&%(/,!RZE!RSQSJ!

34"55!/28*02-!'>2!3B!#+2(/*&N>$%02!(&-!F&*?$/@!7(1*-!G%012&0*$&!G,0'2@!1/$1$0(+0!*&!'>2!Y"A!

'$!/2?+2#'!'>2!G.3!/2#$@@2&-('*$&0!(&-!1$0'2-!'>202!&29!1/$1$0(+0!?$/!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'!$&!

M2)/%(/,!QUE!RSQSJ!"'!'>2!C(/#>!RSQS!@22'*&NE!'>2!O$(/-!8$'2-!'$!(&(+,`2!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'0!$&!

'>2!&29!1/$1$0(+0!(&-!'$!#/2('2!N%*-2+*&20!(##$/-*&N+,!'$!(--!'$!'>2!Y/(?'!"11+*#(&'!A%*-2)$$H!

?$/!&29!N.DY!(11+*#(&'0J!.>2!O$(/-!(+0$!/20$+82-!'$!(&(+,`2!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'!$&!'>2!BYY7B!(&-!

'$!V0,&'>20*`2!'>$02!#$@@2&'0E!(0!(11/$1/*('2E=!*&!'>2!Y"AJKK!!

3&!'>2!$1*&*$&!$?!0$@2!*&'2/8*29220E!'>2!G.3!9$/H*&N!N/$%1!9(0!(&!2a(@1+2!$?!'>2!)$''$@b%1E!

@%+'*b0'(H2>$+-2/!@$-2+!$?!1$+*#,!-282+$1@2&'!'$!9>*#>!34"55!*0!#$@@*''2-J!G$@2!2a1/2002-!

'>2!8*29!'>('!34"55!0>$%+-!>(82!?$/@2-!'>2!G.3!9$/H*&N!N/$%1!*&!/201$&02!'$!*&*'*(+!#$&#2/&0!

$82/!'/(-2@(/H!1/$'2#'*$&E!/('>2/!'>(&!-2+2N('*&N!'>202!*00%20!'$!'>2!37.J!.>*0!8*29!9(0!

N2&2/(++,!'*2-!'$!'>2!)2+*2?!'>('E!(+'>$%N>!'>2!37.!9(0!$??*#*(++,!'(0H2-!9*'>!-282+$1*&N!

/2#$@@2&-('*$&0!/2+('*&N!'$!'>2!*@1+2@2&'('*$&!$?!'>2!'/(-2@(/H!1/$'2#'*$&!1$+*#*20!-282+$12-!

),!'>2!A5GPE!*&!/2(+*',E!*'0!9$/H!(+0$!*&#+%-2-!1$+*#,!-282+$1@2&'J!"0!'>2!A5GP!*0!'>2!)$-,!

/201$&0*)+2!?$/!!V-282+$1*&N!(&-!/2#$@@2&-*&N!'$!'>2!34"55!O$(/-!0%)0'(&'*82!1$+*#*20!/2+('*&N!

'$!N2&2/*#!'$1b+282+!-$@(*&0E=KT!0$@2!*&'2/8*29220!?2+'!'>('!'/(-2@(/H!*00%20!0>$%+-!>(82!)22&!

/2?2//2-!'$!'>2!A5GP!$&#2!0%)0'(&'*(+!#$&#2/&0!>(-!)22&!/(*02-!),!'>2!#$@@%&*',JTS!P'>2/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

KL!34"55E!V_$*&'!G'('2@2&'!?/$@!"D"4c"'bD(/N2!(&-!54F4!@(-2!('!G,-&2,!C22'*&N!/2!37.!721$/'E=!_%&2!RUE!RSSTE!>''16cc0'J*#(&&J$/NcN&0$b+*(*0$&c*&-2aJ#N*d('e+(/N2e*/'e1/$#200e9$/H*&NeN/$%1J!

KU!A5GPE!VD2''2/!?/$@!7$-!O2#H0'/$@!f!B2'2/!Y2&N('2!.>/%0>!'$!A5GP!4$%&#*+E=!P#'$)2/!QRE!RSSTE!>''16ccN&0$J*#(&&J$/Nc#$//201$&-2&#2c)2#H0'/$@b'$bN&0$b#$%&#*+bQR$#'STb2&J1-?J!

KZ!A5GPE!VG12#*(+!./(-2@(/H!300%20!728*29!.2(@!72#$@@2&-('*$&0E=!G12#*(+!./(-2@(/H!300%20!I$/H!.2(@E!Y2#2@)2/!QQE!RSSTE!>''16ccN&0$J*#(&&J$/Nc*00%20c0'*c0'*b9'b/2#$@@2&-('*$&0bQQ-2#STb2&J1-?J!

K;!A5GPE!VA5GP!4$%&#*+!C*&%'20E=!Y2#2@)2/!Q;E!RSSTE!>''16ccN&0$J*#(&&J$/Nc@22'*&N0c@*&%'20b#$%&#*+bQ;-2#STb2&J>'@J!

KK!34"55E!V"-$1'2-!O$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!g!5(*/$)*E=!C(/#>!QRE!RSQSE!>''16cc999J*#(&&J$/Nc2&c@*&%'20c/20$+%'*$&0bQR@(/QSb2&J>'@J!

KT!34"55E!VO,+(90!?$/!3&'2/&2'!4$/1$/('*$&!?$/!"00*N&2-!5(@20!(&-!5%@)2/0=E!(@2&-2-!_%&2!RUE!RSQSE!>''16cc999J*#(&&J$/Nc2&cN2&2/(+c),+(90J>'@J!

TS!3&'2/8*290E!G21'2@)2/!RSQSJ!

Page 79: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

*&'2/8*29220!>2+'!34"55!9(0!/*?@'!'$!#$&0%+'!2A12/'0!>$/!(-8*#2!$&!*B1+2B2&'*&?!'@2!C5DEF0!

1$+*#,!/2#$BB2&-('*$&!'@('!G0'/*&?0!B%0'!&$'!*&>/*&?2!'@2!2A*0'*&?!+2?(+!/*?@'0!$>!$'@2/0HIJK!

.@2!#%//2&'!82/0*$&!$>!'@2!L"C!0'('20!'@('!/2M%20'2-!?.NL0!9*++!)2!/28*292-!>$/!0*B*+(/*',!9*'@!

2A*0'*&?!.NL0O!/202/82-!&(B20!P(!+*0'!$>!QR!0'/*&?0!0%#@!(0!G2A(B1+2OI!G'20'I!(&-!G'+-ISO!(11+*2-T>$/!

?.NL0!(&-!0'/*&?0!/2M%20'2-!(0!3&'2/&('*$&(+*U2-!L$B(*&!5(B2!#$%&'/,!#$-2!.NL0H!D2#$&-!+282+!

-$B(*&0!9*++!&$'!)2!*&#+%-2-!*&!'@2!0'/*&?!0*B*+(/*',!/28*29!1/$#200H!./(-2B(/V!@$+-2/0!B(,!>*+2!

$)W2#'*$&0!'$!?.NL!(11+*#('*$&0!*&!(##$/-(&#2!9*'@!'@2!-/(>'!X3YE!7%+20!>$/!529!?.NL!L*01%'2!

720$+%'*$&H!

!"#$$%&'$()*'$)+$,&'$-).'/01'0,2*$34.56)/7$8)115,,''$

3&!Z(/#@![\\;O!'@2!C"4!0%)B*''2-!(!+*0'!$>!1/*&#*1+20!/2+('*&?!'$!&29!?.NL0!'$!'@2!34"55!

]$(/-HJ[!!.@2!1/2(B)+2!'$!'@*0!+*0'!2B1@(0*U20!'@2!G0$82/2*?&!/*?@'!$>!D'('20I!$82/!G*&'2/&('*$&(+!

3&'2/&2'T/2+('2-!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20I!(0!+(*-!$%'!*&!'@2![\\Q!X$/+-!D%BB*'!$&!'@2!3&>$/B('*$&!

D$#*2',!L2#+(/('*$&H!3'!(+0$!1$*&'0!'$!34"55F0!$9&!],+(90O!9@*#@!#$BB*'!'@2!$/?(&*U('*$&!'$!

G022V*&?!(&-!0%11$/'*&?!)/$(-O!*&>$/B2-!1(/'*#*1('*$&!/2>+2#'*&?!'@2!>%&#'*$&(+O!?2$?/(1@*#!(&-!

#%+'%/(+!-*82/0*',!$>!'@2!3&'2/&2'!('!(++!+282+0!$>!1$+*#,!-282+$1B2&'!(&-!-2#*0*$&!B(V*&?I!(&-!

G/2#$?&*U*&?!'@('!?$82/&B2&'0!(&-!1%)+*#!(%'@$/*'*20!(/2!/201$&0*)+2!>$/!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!(&-!-%+,!

'(V*&?!*&'$!(##$%&'!?$82/&B2&'0F!$/!1%)+*#!(%'@$/*'*20F!/2#$BB2&-('*$&0HI!^$++$9*&?!'@2!

1/2(B)+2!*0!(!+*0'!$>!1/*&#*1+20!'@('!'@2!C"4!0'('20!G&22-!'$!)2!/2012#'2-HIJQ!

.@2!>*&(+!02#'*$&!$>!'@2!-$#%B2&'!0'('20!'@('O!*&!+*&2!9*'@!34"55F0!],+(90O!G34"55!0@$%+-!#$&0%+'!

'@2!C"4O!(0!(11/$1/*('2O!/2?(/-*&?!(&,!M%20'*$&0!12/'(*&*&?!'$!'@2!*B1+2B2&'('*$&!$>!'@202!

1/*&#*1+20I!(&-!'@('!G*>!(&,!*&-*8*-%(+!C"4!B2B)2/0!$/!$'@2/!?$82/&B2&'0!2A1/200!>$/B(+!

#$&#2/&0!()$%'!(&,!*00%20!/2+('2-!'$!&29!?.NL0O!'@2!34"55!]$(/-!0@$%+-!>%++,!#$&0*-2/!'@$02!

#$&#2/&0!(&-!#+2(/+,!2A1+(*&!@$9!*'!9*++!(--/200!'@2BHIJR!

.@/$%?@$%'!'@2!-282+$1B2&'!$>!'@2!&29!?.NL!1/$?/(BO!'@2!C"4!@(0!0%)B*''2-!*&1%'0!'$!'@2!

34"55!]$(/-!8*(!(!&%B)2/!$>!-*>>2/2&'!#@(&&2+0O!*&#+%-*&?!'@2!Z(/#@![\\;!C"4!1/*&#*1+20!

-$#%B2&'O!4$BB%&*M%_0!1%)+*0@2-!(>'2/!2(#@!$>!*'0!B22'*&?0O!(&-!-*/2#'!+2''2/0H!

.@2!*&'2/8*290!@*?+*?@'2-!'2&0*$&0!(B$&?!8(/*$%0!0'(V2@$+-2/0!(0!'$!'@2!012#*>*#!/$+2!$>!'@2!C"4!

*&!'@2!-282+$1B2&'!$>!'@2!&29!?.NL!1/$?/(BH!D12#*>*#!*00%20!*&#+%-2-!'@2!'*B2+*&200!$>!C"4!

(-8*#2!'$!'@2!]$(/-O!'@2!+(#V!$>!0'(>>!(&-!]$(/-!/201$&0*82&200!'$!C"4!(-8*#2O!(&-!'@2!/$+2!$>!'@2!

C"4!*&!34"55F0!1$+*#,!-282+$1B2&'!1/$#200HJ`!

• !"#$%"&$''()*(+,-(./0"1$2!D$B2!*&'2/8*29220!2A1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'@('!'@2!C"4!9(0!

-2+(,*&?!'@2!1/$?/200!$>!'@2!&29!?.NL!1/$?/(B!),!1/$8*-*&?!*'0!(-8*#2!'$$!+('2!*&!'@2!

1/$#200a!>$/!2A(B1+2O!),!/(*0*&?!#$&#2/&0!()$%'!'@2!B$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!0'(&-(/-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

JK!3&'2/8*290O!D21'2B)2/![\K\a!C5DEO!G^*&(+!721$/'!T!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!529!C2&2/*#!.$1TN282+!L$B(*&0OI!"%?%0'!<O![\\;O!@''16bb?&0$H*#(&&H$/?b*00%20b&29T?'+-0b1-1T-2#\`T>/T1(/'(T\<(%?\;H@'BH!

J[!C"4O!GC"4!Y/*&#*1+20!72?(/-*&?!&29!?.NL0OI!Z(/#@![<O![\\;O!@''16bb?(#H*#(&&H$/?b0,0'2Bb>*+20b?.NLc1/*&#*1+20c\H1->H!

JQ!C"4O!GC"4!Y/*&#*1+20!72?(/-*&?!&29!?.NL0OI!Z(/#@![<O![\\;O!@''16bb?(#H*#(&&H$/?b0,0'2Bb>*+20b?.NLc1/*&#*1+20c\H1->H!

JR!3)*-H!

J`!3&'2/8*290O!D21'2B)2/![\K\H!

Page 80: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

>022!02#'*$&!?@AB!$/!),!#$CC%&*#('*&D!*'0!8*290!$&!$&2!82/0*$&!$E!'F2!G"H!(0!'F2!

0%)02I%2&'!82/0*$&!9(0!1%)+*0F2-@!J$C2!I%20'*$&2-!9F,K!9F2&!*&-*8*-%(+!H"4!

C2C)2/0!(''2&-2-!9$/L*&D!D/$%1!C22'*&D0K!'F2!H"4!(0!(!9F$+2!(112(/2-!%&*&E$/C2-!

()$%'!'F2!*00%20!-*0#%002-!*&!'F202!C22'*&D0K!/201$&-*&D!'$!012#*E*#!*00%20!C$&'F0!$/!*&!

0$C2!#(020!,2(/0!(E'2/!'F2,!92/2!E*/0'!*&'/$-%#2-@!M'F2/!*&'2/8*29220!&$'2-!'F('!'F2!H"4!

',1*#(++,!(''2C1'0!'$!-282+$1!#$&02&0%0!)2E$/2!1/$8*-*&D!(-8*#2!'$!'F2!N$(/-!(&-!'F('!

'F*0!1/$#200!*&8$+820!'*C2O#$&0%C*&D!#$&0%+'('*$&!9*'F!&('*$&(+!D$82/&C2&'0@!

3&'2/8*29220!0'('2-!'F('!'F*0!1/$#200!*0!$E'2&!#$C1+*#('2-!),!'F2!E(#'!'F('!'F2!H"4!

/2#2*820!+2&D'F,!-$#%C2&'0!'$!-*0#%00!P%0'!(!E29!922L0!1/*$/!'$!*'0!C22'*&D0K!C(L*&D!*'!

-*EE*#%+'!'$!/2(-!'F/$%DF!'F202!-$#%C2&'0!(&-!-*0#%00!'F2C!9*'F!&('*$&(+!D$82/&C2&'0!

*&!'*C2!'$!#$C2!'$!(!#$&02&0%0@!

• !"#$$%#&'%()#*'%*+,-)&,./+&+,,%")%012%#'/.3+4%J$C2!*&'2/8*29220!2Q1/2002-!

#$&#2/&0!'F('K!)2#(%02!'F2!N$(/-!1/*C(/*+,!/2#2*820!*'0!*&E$/C('*$&!E/$C!)/*2E*&D!

C('2/*(+0!1/21(/2-!),!'F2!0'(EE!(&-!)2#(%02!'F202!)/*2E*&D!C('2/*(+0!(/2!&$'!C(-2!1%)+*#K!

*'!*0!%&#+2(/!9F2'F2/!'F2!N$(/-!*0!(-2I%('2+,!*&E$/C2-!$E!H"4!(-8*#2@!J$C2!*&'2/8*29220!

2Q1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'F('!H"4!(-8*#2!F(0!)22&!+(/D2+,!*D&$/2-!),!'F2!N$(/-@!.F*0!9$%+-!

)2!('!$--0!9*'F!34"55R0!N,+(90K!9F*#F!/2I%*/2!'F2!N$(/-!'$!'(L2!H"4!(-8*#2!*&'$!

(##$%&'!*&!'F2!SE$/C%+('*$&!(&-!(-$1'*$&!$E!1$+*#*20T!(&-!'$!2Q1+(*&!(&,!-2#*0*$&!*'!

C(L20!'F('!#$&'/(-*#'0!H"4!(-8*#2@!

• 012%*)5+%.&%-)5.36%'+/+5)-7+&"4!"0!&$'2-!()$82K!0$C2!*&'2/8*29220!2Q1/2002-!

#$&#2/&0!'F('!H"4!(-8*#2!F(0!&$'!)22&!#$&0*-2/2-!*&!(!'*C2+,!C(&&2/!-%/*&D!'F2!

-282+$1C2&'!$E!'F2!&29!D.UG!1/$D/(C@!M&2!2Q(C1+2!*0!'F2!H"4R0!1$0*'*$&!$&!'F2!%02!$E!

D2$D/(1F*#!&(C20!(0!'$1O+282+!-$C(*&06!0282&!$EE*#*(+!4$CC%&*I%V0!(&-!'9$!+2''2/0!

E/$C!'F2!H"4!)2'922&!M#'$)2/!WXX;!(&-!"%D%0'!WXX<!2Q1/2002-!'F2!H"4R0!$11$0*'*$&!'$!

'F2!%&+*C*'2-!%02!$E!D2$D/(1F*#!&(C20!9*'F$%'!D$82/&C2&'!(11/$8(+!(&-!/2I%20'2-!

C$/2!0'/*&D2&'!1/$8*0*$&0!$&!'F*0!*00%2!*&!'F2!G"H@!M'F2/!*&'2/8*29220!2Q1/2002-!

#$&#2/&0!'F('!'F2!H"4!*0!$82/0'211*&D!*'0!)$%&-0!*&!'F2!(-8*#2!*'!F(0!#$&'/*)%'2-!'$!'F2!

D.UG!1/$#200!),!(''2C1'*&D!'$!C(L2!$/!*&E+%2&#2!1$+*#,!*&-212&-2&'+,!9F*+2!*D&$/*&D!

'F2!1$+*#,!/2#$CC2&-('*$&0!$E!'F2!H5JM@!3&'2/8*29220!(+0$!F(-!-*EE2/*&D!8*290!$&!'F2!

C2(&*&D!$E!'F2!H"4R0!(-8*0$/,!/$+26!0$C2!E2+'!'F2!H"4!*0!/*DF'E%++,!D*82&!C$/2!92*DF'!

'F(&!$'F2/!(-8*0$/,!#$CC*''220K!9F*+2!$'F2/0!E2+'!'F('!'F2!H"4!0F$%+-!1+(,!(!92(L2/!

/$+2@!M'F2/!*&'2/8*29220!E2+'!'F('!H"4!(-8*#2!*0!+200!F2+1E%+!'F(&!*'!#$%+-!)2K!2Q1/200*&D!

#$&#2/&0!'F('!'F2!H"4!$E'2&!0'('20!#2/'(*&!1/*&#*1+20!>E$/!2Q(C1+2K!'F2*/!8*290!$&!'F2!%02!

$E!D2$D/(1F*#!&(C20!(0!'$1O+282+!-$C(*&0B!9*'F$%'!1/$1$0*&D!0$+%'*$&0!E$/!F$9!'$!#(//,!

$%'!'F202!1/*&#*1+20!*&!1/(#'*#2@!

!"#"$%%&'()*+,-./%0+1'2%

.F2!H"4!1/*&#*1+20!$&!&29!D.UG0!0'('2!'F('!34"55!0F$%+-!S(8$*-!#$%&'/,K!'2//*'$/,!$/!1+(#2!

&(C20K!(&-!#$%&'/,K!'2//*'$/,!$/!/2D*$&(+!+(&D%(D2!$/!12$1+2!-20#/*1'*$&0K!%&+200!*&!(D/22C2&'!

9*'F!'F2!/2+28(&'!D$82/&C2&'0!$/!1%)+*#!(%'F$/*'*20T!(&-!'F('!(11+*#(&'!/2D*0'/*20!0F$%+-!1+2-D2!

Page 81: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

'$!)+$#>!?('!&$!#$0'!(&-!%1$&!-2@(&-!$A!B$82/&@2&'0CCC&(@20!9*'D!&('*$&(+!$/!B2$B/(1D*#!

0*B&*A*#(&#2!('!'D2!02#$&-!+282+!$A!(&,!&29!B.EFCGHI!

"##$/-*&B!'$!3&'2/&2'!B$82/&(&#2!0#D$+(/!(&-!5$&J4$@@2/#*(+!K02/0!4$&0'*'%2&#,!#$JA$%&-2/!

L*+'$&!L%2++2/M!'D2!N"4!D(0!+$&B!)22&!#$&#2/&2-!9*'D!'D2!%02!$A!'D2!&(@20!$A!#$%&'/*20M!/2B*$&0M!

+(&B%(B20!$/!12$1+20!(0!-$@(*&!&(@20C!O2!9/*'20!'D('!(0!2(/+,!(0!PHH;M!'D2!N"4!?-2@(&-2-CCC'D('!

34"55!()0'(*&G!A/$@!(00*B&*&B!'D202!&(@20CHQ!L%2++2/!0'('20!'D('!(A'2/!'D2!A*/0'!.EF!2R1(&0*$&!*&!

S<<<M!'D2!-*/2#'$/JB2&2/(+!$A!'D2!T%/$12(&!4$@@*00*$&!/21$/'2-+,!9/$'2!'$!34"55U0!V/20*-2&'!

(&-!(0>2-!'D('!B$82/&@2&'0!D(82!'D2!A*/0'!0D$'!('!/2B*0'2/*&B!3WX!#$%&'/,!#$-20!*&!'D2!&29!.EF0!

Y2R(@1+26!%>C)*Z!(&-!B)/C)*Z[C!3&!S<<PM!'D2!N"4!/2\%20'2-](&-!34"55!(11/$82-!'D*0!/2\%20']

'D('!(++!#$%&'/,!&(@20!)2!/202/82-!*&!'D2!C*&A$!.EF!A$/!B$82/&@2&'!%02C!L%2++2/!1$*&'0!$%'!'D('!

'D2!F$@(*&!5(@2!W%11$/'*&B!X/B(&*Z('*$&!Y'D2!1/2#%/0$/!'$!'D2!N5WX[!9(0!&$'!*&8$+82-!*&!'D*0!

-2#*0*$&M!-201*'2!)2*&B!/201$&0*)+2!A$/!0%BB20'*&B!1$+*#,!/2+('2-!'$!.EF0C!!

3&!*'0!X#'$)2/!S<<Q!4$@@%&*\%^M!'D2!N"4!2R1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'D('!'D2!N5WX!/2#$@@2&-('*$&0!

A$/!&29!B.EF0!-*-!&$'!?1/$12/+,!'(>2!*&'$!(##$%&'G!'D2!N"4!1/*&#*1+20!/2B(/-*&B!'D2!%02!$A!

#$%&'/,!&(@20!*&!&29!B.EF0CH;!.D2!N"4!2R1/2002-!'D*0!#$&#2/&!(B(*&!*&!*'0!_%&2!S<<;MHH!

5$82@)2/!S<<;MP<<!L(/#D!S<<HMP<P!_%&2!S<<HMP<S!X#'$)2/!S<<HP<`!(&-!L(/#D!S<P<P<a!

4$@@%&*\%^0M!(0!92++!(0!*&!+2''2/0!$&!"1/*+!SaP<b!(&-!"%B%0'!P;M!S<<HCP<I!

.D2!02#$&-!82/0*$&!$A!'D2!F"NM!1%)+*0D2-!$&!c2)/%(/,!PHM!S<<HM!/2\%*/2-!?28*-2&#2!$A!0%11$/'M!

$/!&$&J$)d2#'*$&!A/$@!'D2!/2+28(&'!B$82/&@2&'!$A!1%)+*#!(%'D$/*',G!A$/!(11+*#(&'0!A$/!B2$B/(1D*#!

&(@2J)(02-!B.EF0CP<Q!3&!#$@@%&*#('*$&0!'$!'D2!e$(/-!(A'2/!'D2!1%)+*#('*$&!$A!'D*0!-/(A'!$A!'D2!

F"NM!'D2!N"4!(#>&$9+2-B2-!'D('!*'!9(0!(&!*@1/$82@2&'!$&!'D2!A*/0'!82/0*$&!)%'!'D('!*'!-*-!&$'!

,2'!A%++,!/21/202&'!'D2!N"4U0!8*290CP<;!!3&!/201$&02M!/21/202&'('*820!$A!'D2!3&'2/&2'!4$@@2/#2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HI!N"4M!?N"4!V/*&#*1+20!72B(/-*&B!&29!B.EF0MG!L(/#D!S;M!S<<QM!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fB.EFg1/*&#*1+20g<C1-AC!

HQ!L*+'$&!L%2++2/M!?N$82/&@2&'0!(&-!4$%&'/,!5(@206!34"55U0!./(&0A$/@('*$&!*&'$!(&!3&'2/B$82/&@2&'(+!72B*@2MG!D''16ff*0'92)C0,/C2-%fh@%2++2/fB(#&(@20C1-AC!

H;!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]E$0!"&B2+20Mi!X#'$)2/!`PM!S<<QM!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fN"4g`<gE$0g"&B2+20g4$@@%&*\%2C1-AC!

HH!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]V(/*0Mi!_%&2!SIM!S<<;M!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fN"4g`SgV(/*0g4$@@%&*\%2C1-AC!

P<<!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]4(*/$Mi!5$82@)2/!bM!S<<;M!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fN"4g``g4(*/$g4$@@%&*\%2C1-AC!

P<P!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]L2R*#$!4*',Mi!L(/#D!bM!S<<HM!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fN"4g`agL2R*#$g4*',g4$@@%&*\%2gT&B+*0DC1-AC!

P<S!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]W,-&2,Mi!_%&2!SaM!S<<HM!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fW,-&2,jkS<4$@@%&*\%2C1-AC!

P<`!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]W2$%+Mi!X#'$)2/!;M!S<<HM!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20fW2$%+g#$@@%&*\%2C1-AC!

P<a!N"4M!?N"4!4$@@%&*\%^]5(*/$)*Mi!L(/#D!P<M!S<P<M!D''16ffB(#C*#(&&C$/Bf0,0'2@fA*+20f5(*/$)*g4$@@%&*\%2C1-AC!

P<b!E2''2/!A/$@!_(&*0!l(/>+*&0!'$!V(%+!.9$@2,M!"1/*+!SaM!S<<HM!D''16ff999C*#(&&C$/Bf#$//201$&-2&#2f>(/>+*&0J'$J'9$@2,JSa(1/<HC1-AC!

P<I!E2''2/!A/$@!_(&*0!l(/>+*&0M!'D2!4D(*/@(&!$A!'D2!N$82/&@2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$@@*''22M!"@)(00(-$/!$A!E('8*(!'$!c/(&#2!'$!V2'2/!F2&B('2!.D/%0DM!'D2!4D(*/@(&!$A!'D2!e$(/-M!"%B%0'!P;M!S<<HM!D''16ff999C*#(&&C$/Bf#$//201$&-2&#2f>(/>+*&0J'$J-2&B('2J'D/%0DJP;(%B<HJ2&C1-AC!

P<Q!34"55M!?F/(A'!"11+*#(&'!N%*-2)$$>M!82/0*$&!SMi!c2)/%(/,!PHM!S<<HM!D''16ff999C*#(&&C$/Bf2&f'$1*#0f&29JB'+-0f-/(A'J/A1J#+2(&JP;A2)<HJ2&C1-AC!

P<;!E2''2/!A/$@!_(&*0!l(/>+*&0M!'D2!4D(*/@(&!$A!'D2!N$82/&@2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$@@*''22M!"@)(00(-$/!$A!E('8*(!'$!c/(&#2!'$!V2'2/!F2&B('2!.D/%0DM!'D2!4D(*/@(&!$A!'D2!e$(/-M!"%B%0'!P;M!S<<HM!D''16ff999C*#(&&C$/Bf#$//201$&-2&#2f>(/>+*&0J'$J-2&B('2J'D/%0DJP;(%B<HJ2&C1-AC!

Page 82: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

"00$#*('*$&!-2>(&-2-!'$!?&$9!9@,!34"55!@(-!#@$02&!'@2!/2#$>>2&-('*$&0!$A!'@2!B"4!$82/!

'@$02!$A!'@2!B5CDE!*&!9@*#@!F2$F/(1@*#!&(>20!92/2!F*82&!+200!1/$'2#'*$&G<HI!

C$>2!*&'2/8*29220!0%11$/'2-!F$82/&>2&'J0!/*F@'0!'$!$)K2#'!'$!F2$F/(1@*#!&(>2!.LM0E!-2A2//*&F!

'$!F$82/&>2&'!0$82/2*F&',G!C$>2!0%11$/'2-!(!+*>*'!2N2/#*02!$A!'@202!/*F@'0E!A$/!2N(>1+2!9*'@!

/2012#'!'$!#*',!.LM0E!9@2/2!F$82/&>2&'!0$82/2*F&',!*0!#+2(/+,!-2A*&2-E!)%'!&$'!9*'@!/2012#'!'$!

/2F*$&(+!$/!$'@2/!.LM0E!9@2/2!0$82/2*F&',!*0!+200!#+2(/G!D'@2/0!2N1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'@('!

F$82/&>2&'(+!(11/$8(+!9*++!)2!'$$!#@(++2&F*&F!A$/!0$>2!.LM!(11+*#(&'0!'$!$)'(*&!O1(/'*#%+(/+,!*&!

'@2!-282+$1*&F!9$/+-PE!$/!'@('!F*8*&F!F$82/&>2&'0!'@2!/*F@'!'$!/2A%02!'$!12/>*'!F2$F/(1@*#!&(>2!

.LM0!F$20!)2,$&-!F$82/&>2&'0J!#%//2&'!/*F@'0!'$!$)K2#'!'$!'@2!%02!$A!F2$F/(1@*#!&(>20!*&!$'@2/!

(/2(0E!0%#@!(0!#$>>2/#*(+!82&'%/20G<<H!!!

!"#"$%%&'()*++,-.%-/%0.1*)*+1%2)-(-+34%

.@2!34"55!Q$(/-!*&'/$-%#2-!'@2!#$&#21'!$A!(&!RD3!(A'2/!'@2!B"4J0!D#'$)2/!SHHI!>22'*&FT!(A'2/!

/2#2*8*&F!(!-/(A'!RD3!1/$1$0(+!A/$>!34"55!0'(AA!('!*'0!M2#2>)2/!SHHI!>22'*&FE!'@2!Q$(/-!

/20$+82-!'$!-*/2#'!'@2!0'(AA!'$!1/21(/2!(!A*&(+!>$-2+!A$/!Q$(/-!(11/$8(+!('!*'0!U2)/%(/,!SH<H!

>22'*&FG<<<!.@*0!8$'2!9$%+-!@(82!'(?2&!1+(#2!)2A$/2!'@2!&2N'!*&V12/0$&!B"4!>22'*&FG!"!1%)+*#!

#$>>2&'!0%)>*''2-!),!B"4!>2>)2/!Q2/'/(&-!-2!+(!4@(12++2!$&!)2@(+A!$A!'@2!U/2&#@!F$82/&>2&'!

0'('2-!'@('!U/(&#2!@$12-!'@('!W&$!1/2>('%/2!-2#*0*$&!9*++!)2!'(?2&!),!'@2!Q$(/-!*&!U2)/%(/,GX<<S!

Y*#@(2+!Z(+(F2!@(0!&$'2-!'@('!"/'*#+2!333E!C2#'*$&![!$A!34"55J0!Q,+(90!/2\%*/20!34"55!'$!#$&0%+'!

'@2!B"4!W*&!'@$02!#(020!9@2/2!'@2!1$+*#,!(#'*$&!(AA2#'0!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!#$&#2/&0GX!Z(+(F2!1$*&'0!'$!

'@2!1$'2&'*(+!#/2('*$&!$A!(!02#$&-(/,!>(/?2'!A$/!.LM!0+$'0!(&-!'@2!1$'2&'*(+!RD3!A22!(0!2N(>1+20!

$A!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20!/(*02-!*&!'@2!RD3G!3&!](&%(/,!SH<HE!Z(+(F2!9/$'2!'@('!*A!'@2!34"55!Q$(/-!

92/2!'$!8$'2!$&!'@2!RD3!1/$1$0(+!-%/*&F!*'0!U2)/%(/,!SH<H!>22'*&FE!(0!*'!@(-!$/*F*&(++,!1/$1$02-E!

*'!9$%+-!)2!8*$+('*&F!'@202!Q,+(90G!.@2!Q$(/-!%+'*>('2+,!1$0'1$&2-!*'0!-2#*0*$&!$&!'@2!RD3!%&'*+!

*'0!Y(/#@!SH<H!>22'*&FG!

!"#"!%%56*)3)78,.9%0++:*+%

.@2!B"4!@(0!(+0$!2N1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!/2+('2-!'$!'@2!A$%/!W$82/(/#@*&F!*00%20X!*-2&'*A*2-!),!

34"55!0'(AA!*&!U2)/%(/,!SHHIG!3&!(&!"%F%0'!SHHI!+2''2/E!'@2!B"4!0'/2002-!'@2!*>1$/'(&#2!$A!(!

W#$&'/$++2-!(&-!1/%-2&'!2N1(&0*$&X!(&-!(!W>$/2!>2(0%/2-!/$++$%'EX!9$//*2-!'@('!'@2!1$'2&'*(+!

)2&2A*'0!'$!#$&0%>2/0!>*F@'!&$'!$%'92*F@!'@2!1$'2&'*(+!@(/>0!$A!0%#@!(&!2N1(&0*$&E!(&-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<HI!34"55E!WZ%)+*#!4$>>2&'!"&(+,0*0!721$/'6!M/(A'!"11+*#(&'!B%*-2)$$?E!82/0*$&!SE^!Y(,!_<E!SHHIE!@''16``999G*#(&&G$/F`2&`'$1*#0`&29VF'+-0`(F8SV(&(+,0*0V1%)+*#V#$>>2&'0V_<>(,HIV2&G1-AG!

<<H!3&'2/8*290E!C21'2>)2/!SH<HG!

<<<!34"55E!WZ/2+*>*&(/,!721$/'!$A!C12#*(+!Q$(/-!Y22'*&FEX!M2#2>)2/!IE!SHHIE!@''16``999G*#(&&G$/F`2&`>*&%'20`1/2+*>V/21$/'VHI-2#HIV2&G@'>G!

<<S!Q2/'/(&-!-2!+(!4@(12++2E!WU/$>!Q+(#?!(&-!a@*'2!'$!C@(-20!$A!Q+%2!b!4$>>2&'0!),!U/(&#2EX!](&%(/,!S;E!SH<HE!@''16``A$/%>G*#(&&G$/F`+*0'0`-/(A'V2$*V>$-2+`>0FHHSc[G@'>+G!

Page 83: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

2>1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'?('!&[email protected]!C*@?'!#$&D%02!#$&0%C2/0!(&-!+2(-!'$!E(!C%+'*'%-2!$D!

C$&$1$+*20F!/('?2/!'?(&!*&#/2(0*&@!#$C12'*'*$&GHIIJ!!

!"#$$%&'$()*+,-./$+01$234,-5$6*1'*$7.+01+*1$

.?2!K(/#?!<LLM!N"4!1/*&#*1+20!0'('2!'?('!&[email protected]!0?$%+-!/2012#'!&('*$&(+F!#%+'%/(+F!

@2$@/(1?*#!(&-!/2+*@*$%0!02&0*'*8*'*20GIIO!.?2!#%//2&'!(11/$(#?!'$!?(&-+*&@!@$82/&C2&'(+!

$)P2#'*$&0!'$!&('*$&(++,F!#%+'%/(++,!(&-!/2+*@*$%0+,!02&0*'*[email protected]!(11+*#('*$&0!*0!)(02-!$&!'?2!

Q(/*0!4$&82&'*$&!D$/!'?2!Q/$'2#'*$&!$D!3&-%0'/*(+!Q/$12/',F!(!IR'?!#2&'%/,!'/(-2C(/S!'/2(',!'?('!

(++$92-!&('*$&(+!@$82/&C2&'0!'$!/2D%02!'$!/2#$@&*T2!(!'/(-2C(/S!$&!'?2!@/$%&-0!'?('!*'!

#$&D+*#'2-!9*'?!'?2*/!+$#(+!-2D*&*'*$&!$D!EC$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/GHIIU!.?2!C$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!

$/-2/!0'(&-(/-!D*/0'!(112(/2-!*&!'?2!N5VW!D*&(+!/21$/'!$&!&[email protected]!'?2!/21$/'Y0!0*>'?!

/2#$CC2&-('*$&!0'('2-!'?('!E0'/*&@0!C%0'!&$'!)2!#$&'/(/,!'$!@2&2/(++,!(##21'2-!+2@(+!&$/C0!

/2+('*&@!'$!C$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!'?('!(/2!/2#$@&*T2-!%&-2/!*&'2/&('*$&(+!1/*&#*1+20!$D!+(9GH!

3&!*'0!&$'20!$&!'?*0!/2#$CC2&-('*$&F!'?2!N5VW!4$CC*''22!$&!529!.AB0!2>1+(*&2-!'?('!*'!?(-!

E2>(C*&2-!'?2!(11/$(#?!'(S2&!*&!(!9*-2!8(/*2',!$D!P%/*0-*#'*$&0!'$!*00%20!$D!C$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!

$/-2/H!(&-!?(-!E0$%@?'!'$!)2!#$&0*0'2&'!9*'?F!D$/!2>(C1+2F!"/'*#+2!J!ZI[!ZD[!$D!'?2!IR;;!\%/$12(&!

]&*$&!./(-2!K(/S!B*/2#'*82!;R^ILO^\\4!(&-!9*'?*&!"/'*#+2!M!ZI[!ZD[!$D!'?2!IRRJ!\%/$12(&!]&*$&!

./(-2!K(/S!72@%+('*$&!OL^ROGH!.?2!4$CC*''22!(+0$!0'('2-!'?('!'?2!/2D2/2&#2!'$!C$/(+*',!(&-!

1%)+*#!$/-2/!E/2C(*&0!/2+28(&'!'$!-$C(*&!&(C20!282&!'?$%@?F!9?2&!*'!9(0!-/(D'2-F!-$C(*&!

&(C20!92/2!#$C1+2'2+,!%&?2(/-!$DGHII_!

`$9282/F!'?2!0'(&-(/-!?(0!C2'!9*'?!$)P2#'*$&0!D/$C!)$'?!#*8*+!0$#*2',!(&-!'?2!N"4G!W11$&2&'0!

1$*&'!$%'!'?('!'?2/2!(/2!&$!@+$)(++,!(11+*#()+2!0'(&-(/-0!$D!EC$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/H!(&-!(/@%2!

'?('!'?2!1$+*#,!#$%+-!)2!%02-!'$!8*$+('2!D/22!2>1/200*$&!/*@?'0GIIM!a$/C2/!N5VW!4$%&#*+!4?(*/!"8/*!

B$/*(!0%)C*''2-!(!D$/C(+!#$CC2&'!$&!'?2!N5VW!/2#$CC2&-('*$&0!'?('!',1*D*20!'?202!$)P2#'*$&06!!

!"#$%&'()$%*#+,-.'$/"#$%#/01#'$2/#,3#.'',4.5'1#16&'(2$,%2#41#0.71#+.)1#/01#8,22$5'1#

16&'(2$,%#'$2/#$%)13$%$/1'"#'.-*1#.%)#0.71#2(591&/1)#/01#8-,&122#/,#/01#&,%2$)1-./$,%#,3#.''#

8,22$5'1#-1'$*$,(2#.%)#1/0$&.'#2"2/1+2:#;<=>>#,-#/01#8.%1'#,3#-17$141-2#4$''#.'2,#0.71#/,#

)1&$)1#51/411%#)$331-1%/#21/2#,3#+,-.'#8-$%&$8'12?#1:*?#.#+,-.'$/"#/0./#0,')2#/0./#81,8'1#

20,(')#51#3-11#/,#168-122#/01+21'712#$%#.''#3,-+2#,3#+1)$.#.%)#/0,21#40,#51'$171#/0./#81,8'1#

20,(')#51#3-11#3-,+#168,2(-1#/,#.%"#168-122$,%#/0./#$2#8-,0$5$/1)#5"#/01$-#3.$/0#,-#+,-.'#

8-$%&$8'12:#@0$2#-1&,++1%)./$,%#4$''#.'2,#2(591&/#/01#8-,&122#/,#/01#3.20$,%#.%)#,&&.2$,%.'#

)1+.*,*(1-"#,3#8,'$/$&.'#&,--1&/%122:#;#),#%,/#(%)1-2/.%)#0,4#;<=>>#,-#.%"#1681-/#8.%1'#

4$''#51#.5'1#/,#9()*1#/0./#2,+1/0$%*#20,(')#51#16&'()1)#5.21)#,%#-1.2,%2#,3#+,-.'$/"#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

IIJ!b(&*0!c(/S+*&0F!4?(*/C(&!$D!'?2!N$82/&C2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$CC*''22F!A2''2/!'$!Q2'2/!B2&@('2!.?/%0?F!4?(*/C(&!$D!'?2!d$(/-F!34"55F!"%@%0'!I;F!<LLRF!?''16^^999G*#(&&G$/@^#$//201$&-2&#2^S(/S+*&0e'$e-2&@('2e'?/%0?eI;(%@LRe2&G1-DG!

IIO!N"4F!EN"4!Q/*&#*1+20!72@(/-*&@!&[email protected]!K(/#?!<;F!<LLMF!?''16^^@(#G*#(&&G$/@^0,0'2C^D*+20^@.ABf1/*&#*1+20fLG1-DG!

IIU!Q(/*0!4$&82&'*$&!D$/!'?2!Q/$'2#'*$&!$D!3&-%0'/*(+!Q/$12/',F!K(/#?!<LF!I;;J!Z(C2&-2-!V21'2C)2/!<;F!IRMR[F!?''16^^999G9*1$G*&'^'/2('*20^2&^*1^1(/*0^'/'-$#0f9$L<LG?'C+G!

II_!N5VWF!Ea*&(+!721$/'g3&'/$-%#'*$&!$D!529!N2&2/*#!.$1eA282+!B$C(*&0FH!"%@%0'!;F!<LLMF!?''16^^@&0$G*#(&&G$/@^*00%20^&29e@'+-0^1-1e-2#LUeD/e1(/'(eL;(%@LMG?'CG!

IIM!K*+'$&!K%2++2/F!E34"55!(&-!N"4!-*0#%00!#2&0$/0?*1FH!;%/1-%1/#A,71-%.%&1#B-,91&/F!b%&2!<JF!<LILF!?''16^^)+$@G*&'2/&2'@$82/&(&#2G$/@^)+$@^f(/#?*820^<LIL^_^<J^OU_L_ROG?'C+G!

Page 84: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!"#$%&#'()*"+"+,-'.#'/).0#'()1*.2#%-'.+'34566'()*"+"#"%+'%*'7%8./"#9:''5+('!$"/)'3'.7'+%#'.'

0#8"2#'2%+0#8&2#"%+"0#'.+('0%7)#"7)0'.//%!'*%8'#$)';8%.()8'"+#)8<8)#.#"%+'%*'34566=0'

7"00"%+-'3'(%'+%#';)/")>)'"#'"+2/&()0'#$)'()*"+"#"%+'%*'.'090#)7'%*'7%8./"#9?@@A'

3&!>#'$)2/!?@@;A!34"55!1%)+*0B2-!(&!2C1+(&('$/,!D2D$/(&-%D!$&!'B2!D$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!

0'(&-(/-E!.B2!-$#%D2&'!0'('2-!'B('!34"55!9$%+-!+*F2+,!/20'/*#'!D$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!

$)G2#'*$&0!'$!'B/22!(/2(06!*&#*'2D2&'!'$!8*$+2&'!+(9+200!(#'*$&H!*&#*'2D2&'!'$!$/!1/$D$'*$&!$I!

-*0#/*D*&('*$&!)(02-!%1$&!/(#2A!#$+$/A!J2&-2/A!2'B&*#*',A!/2+*J*$&!$/!&('*$&(+!$/*J*&H!(&-!

*&#*'2D2&'!'$!$/!1/$D$'*$&!$I!#B*+-!1$/&$J/(1B,!$/!$'B2/!02C%(+!()%02!$I!#B*+-/2&EKKL!"!I$++$9M%1!

-$#%D2&'!/2+2(02-!*&!N(,!?@@L!(--2-!O(!-2'2/D*&('*$&!'B('!(&!(11+*2-MI$/!J.PQ!0'/*&J!9$%+-!

)2!#$&'/(/,!'$!2R%(++,!J2&2/(++,!(##21'2-!*-2&'*I*2-!+2J(+!&$/D0!/2+('*&J!'$!D$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!

$/-2/!'B('!(/2!/2#$J&*S2-!%&-2/!J2&2/(+!1/*&#*1+20!$I!*&'2/&('*$&(+!+(9T!'$!'B2!(##21'()+2!+*0'!$I!

D$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!$)G2#'*$&0EK?@!.B*0!-2I*&*'*$&!*0!#%//2&'+,!1(/'!$I!'B2!Q"UA!'B$%JB!

34"55!B(0!&$'!,2'!/201$&-2-!'$!#(++0!I/$D!'B2!54V4!(&-!$'B2/0!'B('!*'!-*0#+$02!'B2!+2J(+!(&(+,0*0!

),!9B*#B!*'!#$&#+%-20!'B('!'B2/2!(/2!0%#B!OJ2&2/(++,!(##21'2-!+2J(+!&$/D0ET!!

"0!2(/+,!(0!>#'$)2/!?@@LA!'B2!U"4!2C1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!()$%'!'B2!D$/(+*',!(&-!1%)+*#!$/-2/!

0'(&-(/-!(0!'B2!D2'B$-!$I!B(&-+*&J!J$82/&D2&'(+!$)G2#'*$&0!'$!1/$1$02-!.PQ0EK?K!!3&!*'0!N(/#B!

?@K@!4$DD%&*R%W!'$!'B2!34"55!X$(/-A!'B2!U"4!0'('2-6!

B$)'C54'D&)0#"%+0'#$)'.<<8%<8".#)+)00'%*'#$)'<$8.0)'E7%8./"#9'.+('<&;/"2'%8()8F'.+('"0'

&+2/).8'$%!'#$)'<8%<%0)('7)2$.+"07'!%&/('!%8G'"+'<8.2#"2)?'B$)'C54';)/")>)0'#$"0'"#)7'

0$%&/('+%#';)'/"0#)('%+'#$)'E2/%0)('"#)70F'/"0#'!"#$'8)0<)2#'#%'#$)'+)!',BHI'<8%2)00'.+('

8)D&)0#0'.'7%8)'()#."/)(';8")*"+,'*8%7'#$)'34566'0#.**'%+'#$)'.+#"2"<.#)('<8.2#"2./'

"7</)7)+#.#"%+'%*'#$)'.<<8%.2$?@JJ'

3&!*&'2/8*290A!0$D2!R%20'*$&2-!9B,!'B2!U"4!B(-!&$'!2C1/2002-!$)G2#'*$&0!'$!'B2!D$/(+*',!(&-!

1%)+*#!$/-2/!0'(&-(/-!9B2&!*'!9(0!I*/0'!1/$1$02-!*&!'B2!>#'$)2/!?@@Y!U5Z>!

/2#$DD2&-('*$&0EK?<!

!"#$$%&'()*+,$-.(&/'+()0.$

"!I%/'B2/!R%20'*$&!I(#*&J!34"55!*&!#$&G%&#'*$&!9*'B!'B2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$I!&29!J.PQ0!*0!9B2'B2/!

/2J*0'/*20!(&-!/2J*0'/(/0!0B$%+-!)2!I$/#2-!'$!/2D(*&!021(/('2E!4%//2&'!34"55!(J/22D2&'0![0*&#2!

?@@K\!9*'B!J.PQ!/2J*0'/*20!1/$B*)*'!/2J*0'/*20!I/$D!$9&*&J!D$/2!'B(&!K]!12/#2&'!$I!(!/2J*0'/(/E!

.B*0!1$+*#,!9(0!20'()+*0B2-!*&!/201$&02!'$!'B2!1/28*$%0!D$&$1$+,!1$0*'*$&!$I!52'9$/F!Z$+%'*$&0A!

9B*#B!1/$8*-2-!)$'B!/2J*0'/,!(&-!/2J*0'/(/!I%&#'*$&0!I$/!E#$DA!E&2'!(&-!E$/JE!3&!KLLLA!52'9$/F!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

KK;!U5Z>A!O^*&(+!721$/'_3&'/$-%#'*$&!$I!529!U2&2/*#!.$1MP282+!Q$D(*&0AT!"%J%0'!;A!?@@YA!B''16``J&0$E*#(&&E$/J`*00%20`&29MJ'+-0`1-1M-2#@]MI/M1(/'(M@;(%J@YEB'DE!

KKL!34"55A!O529!J.PQ!a/$J/(D!bC1+(&('$/,!N2D$/(&-%D6!N$/(+*',!(&-!a%)+*#!>/-2/!>)G2#'*$&!4$&0*-2/('*$&0!*&!529!J.PQ0AT!>#'$)2/!?LA!?@@;A!B''16``999E*#(&&E$/J`2&`'$1*#0`&29MJ'+-0`D$/(+*',M1%)+*#M$/-2/M-/(I'M?L$#'@;M2&E1-IE!

K?@!34"55A!O529!J.PQ!a/$J/(D!bC1+(&('$/,!N2D$/(&-%D6!Z'(&-(/-0!I$/!N$/(+*',!(&-!a%)+*#!>/-2/!7202(/#BAT!N(,!<@A!?@@LA!B''16``999E*#(&&E$/J`2&`'$1*#0`&29MJ'+-0`D$/(+*',M1%)+*#M$/-2/M<@D(,@LM2&E1-IE!

K?K!U"4A!OU"4!4$DD%&*R%W_Z2$%+Ac!>#'$)2/!;A!?@@LA!B''16``J(#E*#(&&E$/J`0,0'2D`I*+20`Z2$%+d#$DD%&*R%2E1-IE!

K??!!OU"4!4$DD%&*R%W_5(*/$)*AT!N(/#B!K@A!?@K@A!B''16``J(#E*#(&&E$/J`0,0'2D`I*+20`5(*/$)*d4$DD%&*R%2E1-IE!

K?<!3&'2/8*290A!Z21'2D)2/!?@K@E!

Page 85: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

>$+%'*$&0!(?/22-!'$!021(/('2!*'0!/2?*0'/,!(&-!/2?*0'/(/!@%&#'*$&0ABC<!!3&!CDDEF!G2/*>*?&!H9I*#I!I(-!

(#J%*/2-!52'9$/K!>$+%'*$&0!*&!CDDDL!0$+-!52'9$/K!>$+%'*$&0F!9I*#I!#$&'*&%2-!'$!$12/('2!0$+2+,!

(0!(!/2?*0'/(/A!G2/*>*?&!/2'(*&2-!'I2!/2?*0'/,!)%0*&200M!*'!(+0$!/2'(*&2-!(!BN!12/#2&'!0'(K2!*&!

52'9$/K!>$+%'*$&0ABCN!

>$O2!0'(K2I$+-2/0!/2#$OO2&-!(!#+2(/!1$+*#,!1/282&'*&?!/2?*0'/,!$12/('$/0!@/$O!(#'*&?!(0!

/2?*0'/(/!@$/!'I2*/!$9&!?.PQ0A!R11$&2&'0!$@!82/'*#(+!*&'2?/('*$&!(/?%2!'I('!34"55S0!#%//2&'!

1$+*#,!T2+*O*&('2-!'I2!#$&@+*#'!$@!*&'2/20'!*&I2/2&'!*&!'I2!0,0'2O!(&-!/20%+'2-!*&!/$)%0'F!

#$O12'*'*82!O(/K2'0!@$/!)$'I!/2?*0'/(/0!(&-!/2?*0'/*20F!0*?&*@*#(&'+,!+$92/!#$&0%O2/!1/*#20F!(&-!

-/(O('*#!Q5>!?/$9'IU9*'I$%'!V2$1(/-*W*&?!0'()*+*',!$/!02#%/*',AXBCY!.I2,!(/?%2!'I('!(++$9*&?!

/2?*0'/*20!'$!(#'!(0!/2?*0'/(/0!?*820!'I2O!'I2!$11$/'%&*',!'$!O*0%02!-('(!/2?(/-*&?!#$&0%O2/!

-2O(&-A!3&!1%)+*#!#$OO2&'0!$&!'I2!*00%2F!'I2!Z%)+*#!3&'2/20'!72?*0'/,!I(0!/2@2/2&#2-!(!0'%-,!),!

[$&('I(&!"A!\A!4(82!'I('!0'('20!'I('!#/$00]$9&2/0I*1!)2'922&!/2?*0'/*20!(&-!/2?*0'/(/0!O(,!?*82!

'I$02!/2?*0'/(/0!(&!%&@(*/!(-8(&'(?2!*&!&2?$'*('*&?!9*'I!$'I2/!/2?*0'/*20A!4(82!(+0$!(/?%20!'I('!

#$OO2/#*(+!/2?*0'/*20!'I('!$9&!/2?*0'/(/0!O(,!I(82!(&!%&@(*/!(-8(&'(?2!$82/!&$&]#$OO2/#*(+!

/2?*0'/*20!'I('!-$!&$'ABC^!

>%11$/'2/0!$@!82/'*#(+!*&'2?/('*$&!(/?%2!'I2!@$/#2-!021(/('*$&!)2'922&!/2?*0'/*20!(&-!/2?*0'/(/0!

*0!$%'-('2-ABC;!G2/'*#(+!*&'2?/('*$&F!'I2,!)2+*282F!#$%+-!*&!@(#'!+$92/!1/*#20!(&-!*&#/2(02!J%(+*',!$@!

02/8*#2!),!(++$9*&?!&29!/2?*0'/*20!'$!?(*&!(!@$$'I$+-!*&!'I2!O(/K2'!(&-!),!@$0'2/*&?!*&&$8('*$&!*&!

1/$-%#'!-282+$1O2&'ABC_!!!

34"55!I(0!#$OO*00*$&2-!'9$!*&-212&-2&'!0'%-*20!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2?/('*$&A!.I2!@*/0'F!(!/21$/'!),!

4I(/+20!7*82/!"00$#*('20!3&'2/&('*$&(+!H47"3LF!9(0!O(-2!(8(*+()+2!@$/!1%)+*#!#$OO2&'!$&!

R#'$)2/!C<F!CDD;ABED!3'!#$&'(*&2-!'9$!1/*O(/,!/2#$OO2&-('*$&06!BL!'I('!T0*&?+2!$/?(&*W('*$&X!

.PQ0!)2!12/O*''2-!'$!$12/('2!)$'I!'I2!/2?*0'/,!(&-!'I2!/2?*0'/(/!02++*&?!-$O(*&0!9*'I*&!'I('!.PQM!

(&-!CL!'I('!(!/2?*0'/,!O(,!$9&!(!/2?*0'/(/F!1/$8*-2-!'I('!'I2!/2?*0'/(/!-$20!&$'!02++!-$O(*&0!

9*'I*&!'I2!.PQ0!$12/('2-!),!'I2!/2?*0'/,A!34"55!/2#2*82-!EC!#$OO2&'0!$&!'I*0!/21$/'!)2'922&!

R#'$)2/!C<!(&-!Q2#2O)2/!CEF!CDD;ABEB!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BC<!34"55F!T"11/$82-!"?/22O2&'0!(O$&?!34"55F!'I2!`>!Q21(/'O2&'!$@!4$OO2/#2F!(&-!52'9$/K!>$+%'*$&0F!3&#AFX!5$82O)2/!BDF!B___F!I''16aa999A*#(&&A$/?a2&a&0*a&0*](?/22O2&'0AI'OA!

BCN!b(''!c*&20F!TG2/*>*?&!02++0!$@@!-$O(*&!/2?*0'/(/FX!!"#$%"#&'F!R#'$)2/!BYF!CDDEF!I''16aa&290A#&2'A#$OaG2/*>*?&]02++0]$@@]-$O(*&]/2?*0'/(/aCBDD]BDCNdE]ND_CEBYAI'O+A!

BCY!>%11$/'*&?!./%2!3&'/(]72?*0'/,!>21(/('*$&!'$!c2+1!Z/282&'!3&0*-2/!./(-*&?F!TR12&!P2''2/!'$!34"55!*&!@(8$/!$@!S./%2!72?*0'/,]72?*0'/(/!>21(/('*$&FSSS!I''16aa*&'/('+-/2?*0'/,/2?*0'/(/021(/('*$&A$/?aA!

BC^!34"55F!T529!?.PQ!Z/$?/(O!ef1+(&('$/,!b2O$/(&-%O6!72?*0'/,]72?*0'/(/!>21(/('*$&FX!g2)/%(/,!B;F!CDD_F!I''16aa999A*#(&&A$/?a2&a'$1*#0a&29]?'+-0a/2?,]/2?/]021(/('*$&]B;@2)D_]2&A1-@A!

BC;!.$&,!\*/0#IF!T72?*0'/,a72?*0'/(/!>21(/('*$&6!4+(/*@,*&?!'I2!b200h!FX!()'*#+,'$-.F!g2)/%(/,!B^F!CDBDF!I''16aa999A(%0/2?*0'/,A#$Oa)+$?ai1jEDDA!

BC_!>'282&!4A!>(+$1!(&-![$0I%(!QA!k/*?I'F!T72?*0'/,]72?*0'/(/!>21(/('*$&6!G2/'*#(+!3&'2?/('*$&!R1'*$&0FX![(&%(/,!C;F!CDBDF!I''16aa999A*#(&&A$/?a2&a'$1*#0a&29]?'+-0a/2?*0'/,]/2?*0'/(/]021(/('*$&]82/'*#(+]*&'2?/('*$&]$1'*$&0]0(+$1]9/*?I']C;V(&BD]2&A1-@A!

BED!34"55F!TZ%)+*#!4$OO2&'6!47"3!721$/'!$&!?.PQ!72?*0'/*20!(&-!72?*0'/(/0Fl!R#'$)2/!C<F!CDD;F!I''16aa999A*#(&&A$/?a2&a(&&$%&#2O2&'0a(&&$%&#2O2&']C<$#'D;]2&AI'OA!

BEB!34"55F!T47"!721$/'6!728*0*'*&?!G2/'*#(+!>21(/('*$&!$@!72?*0'/*20!(&-!72?*0'/(/0!U!>%OO(/,!m!"&(+,0*0!$@!4$OO2&'0Fl![(&%(/,!BCF!CDD_F!I''16aa@$/%OA*#(&&A$/?a+*0'0a#/(*]/21$/'a1-@bn&>k932&QA1-@A!

Page 86: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

34"55>0!?2)/%(/,!@AAB!2C1+(&('$/,!D2D$/(&-%D!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2E/('*$&!#$&'(*&2-!(&!34"55!

0'(FF!0%DD(/,!$F!1%)+*#!#$DD2&'0!$&!'G2!47"3!/21$/'H!I$D2!#$DD2&'0!92/2!*&!F(8$/!$F!

#$&'*&%2-!1/$G*)*'*$&0!(E(*&0'!#/$00J$9&2/0G*1K!$'G2/0!0%11$/'2-!(!+*D*'2-!#/$00J$9&2/0G*1!

D$-2+K!(&-!$'G2/0!92/2!*&!F(8$/!$F!#$D1+2'2!82/'*#(+!*&'2E/('*$&H!.G2!0'(FF!0%DD(/,!$F!#$DD2&'0!

-20#/*)2-!0282/(+!1$00*)+2!$1'*$&06LM@!

!" #$%&&'()*+$&,-./0-*-1+23,$+&,%4526%5+47!3&!'G*0!D$-2+K!/2E*0'/*20!(&-!/2E*0'/(/0!

9$%+-!/2D(*&!+(/E2+,!021(/('2H!72E*0'/*20!9$%+-!)2!12/D*''2-!'$!02++!-$D(*&!&(D20!

'G/$%EG!(&!(FF*+*('2-!34"55!(##/2-*'2-!/2E*0'/(/!%1!'$!(!#2/'(*&!+*D*'!N0$D29G2/2!

)2'922&!@AKAAA!(&-!LAAKAAA!&(D20OH!.G*0!D$-2+!9$%+-!0%11$/'!0D(++!&29!/2E*0'/*20!

(&-!2&()+2!'G2D!'$!)2#$D2!#$D12'*'*82!*&!'G2!-$D(*&!&(D2!D(/P2'H!"!8(/*('*$&!$F!'G2!

D$-2+!9$%+-!(++$9!/2E*0'/*20!'$!02++!-$D(*&!&(D20!-*/2#'+,K!9*'G$%'!E$*&E!'G/$%EG!(!

/2E*0'/(/K!%1!'$!(!#2/'(*&!+*D*'!N<AKAAA!&(D20!9(0!0%EE20'2-OH!

8" #$%&&'()*+$&,-./9*4-:-1+523,$+&,%4526%5+47!3&!'G*0!D$-2+K!0%EE20'2-!),!Q2D(&-!

R2-*(K!&$!$9&2/0G*1!021(/('*$&!)2'922&!/2E*0'/*20!(&-!/2E*0'/(/0!9$%+-!)2!/2S%*/2-H!

72E*0'/(/0!9$%+-!)2!()+2!'$!$9&!(&-!02++!-$D(*&!&(D20!'G/$%EG!(!/2E*0'/,H!I%11$/'2/0!$F!

'G2!D$-2+K!*&#+%-*&E!T$Q(--,K!0'('2-!'G('!U*F!#/$00J$9&2/0G*1!9$/P0!F$/!'G2!F*/0'!<AKAAA!

&(D20K!'G2/2!*0!&$!0$%&-!/2(0$&!'$!+*D*'!*'!'G2/2HV!

;" #$%&&'()*+$&,-./<+$%23,$+&,%457!.G*0!D$-2+K!0%EE20'2-!),!52%I'(/K!/2#$DD2&-0!

'G('!/2E*0'/*20!)2!(++$92-!'$!$9&!/2E*0'/(/0K!(0!+$&E!(0!'G2!/2E*0'/(/0!-$!&$'!02++!-$D(*&!

&(D20!9*'G*&!'G2!.WQ!$9&2-!),!'G2!/2E*0'/,H!

=" 6>-*1+*>*?+2%@2A+B-&1$C'A+B-&1$>$2D+.>$>1-%*7!34"55>0!3&'2++2#'%(+!X/$12/',!

4$&0'*'%2&#,!N3X4O!2C1/2002-!9$//*20!'G('!'G2!/2+(C('*$&!$F!'G*0!/2S%*/2D2&'!D(,!F$/#2!

34"55!'$!(-$1'!(!D$/2!(#'*82!/$+2!*&!D$&*'$/*&E!(&-!2&F$/#*&E!#$D1+*(&#2H!.G2!X%)+*#!

3&'2/20'!72E*0'/,!(+0$!$)Y2#'2-!'$!82/'*#(+!*&'2E/('*$&!$&!'G2!E/$%&-0!'G('!U1%)+*#!*&'2/20'!

*&!0%11$/'*&E!#$D12'*'*$&!-$20!&$'!F(8$/!(!)/2(P-$9&!$F!'G2!#%//2&'!021(/('*$&!$F!

/2E*0'/,!(&-!/2E*0'/(/!$9&2/0G*1HV!

34"55!0'(FF!#$&0*-2/2-!'G202!$1'*$&0!(&-!1/$1$02-!(!D$-2+!'G('!9$%+-!0+*EG'+,!/2+(C!#/$00J

$9&2/0G*1!/20'/*#'*$&0H!Z&-2/!'G2!0'(FF!D$-2+K!E.WQ!/2E*0'/*20!9$%+-!)2!/2S%*/2-!'$!%02!34"55J

(##/2-*'2-!/2E*0'/(/0!(&-!'$!(8$*-!-*0#/*D*&('*&E!)2'922&!/2E*0'/(/0H!72E*0'/*20!9$%+-!(+0$!)2!

/2S%*/2-!'$!1/$8*-2!0*C!D$&'G0>!&$'*#2!)2F$/2!#G(&E*&E!1/*#20!F$/!-$D(*&!&(D2!/2&29(+0H!

72E*0'/(/0!9$%+-!)2!(++$92-!'$!02++!-$D(*&0!*&!(&!(FF*+*('2-!/2E*0'/,K!9*'G!(!+*D*'!$F!LAAKAAA!

-$D(*&!&(D20H!.G*0!D$-2+!9(0!*&#+%-2-!*&!'G2!02#$&-!82/0*$&!$F!'G2!Q/(F'!"11+*#(&'!T%*-2)$$PK!

1%)+*0G2-!$&!?2)/%(/,!L;K!@AABK!(0!1(/'!$F!'G2!1/$1$02-!-/(F'!/2E*0'/,!(E/22D2&'HLMM!

"'!'G2![%&2!@AAB!34"55!D22'*&E!*&!I,-&2,K!'9$!2#$&$D*#!#$&0%+'(&'0\I'282&!I(+$1K!X/$F200$/!

$F!]#$&$D*#0!(&-!W(9!('!T2$/E2'$9&!Z&*82/0*',K!(&-![$0G%(!^/*EG'K!"00*0'(&'!X/$F200$/!$F!W(9!

(&-!]#$&$D*#0!('!T2$/E2!R(0$&!Z&*82/0*',\E(82!(!1/202&'('*$&!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2E/('*$&!(&-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LM@!34"55K!U529!E.WQ!X/$E/(D!]C1+(&('$/,!R2D$/(&-%D6!72E*0'/,J72E*0'/(/!I21(/('*$&KV!?2)/%(/,!L;K!@AABK!G''16__999H*#(&&H$/E_2&_'$1*#0_&29JE'+-0_/2E,J/2E/J021(/('*$&JL;F2)ABJ2&H1-FH!

LMM!34"55K!U529!E.WQ!"E/22D2&'6!X/$1$02-!Q/(F'!N8@OKV!?2)/%(/,!L;K!@AABK!G''16__999H*#(&&H$/E_2&_'$1*#0_&29JE'+-0_-/(F'J(E/22D2&'J#+2(&JL;F2)ABJ2&H1-FH!

Page 87: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

1(/'*#*1('2-!*&!(!>%20'*$&!(&-!(&092/!0200*$&!$&!'?2!*@1+*#('*$&0!$A!/2B*0'/,C/2B*0'/(/!#/$00C

$9&2/0?*1DEFG!H(+$1!(&-!I/*B?'!92/2!+('2/!#$@@*00*$&2-!),!34"55!'$!1/$-%#2!(!/28*29!$A!

82/'*#(+!*&'2B/('*$&!$1'*$&0!*&!(-8(&#2!$A!34"55J0!K2)/%(/,!LMEM!N$(/-!@22'*&BD!.?2!1(12/!9(0!

@(-2!(8(*+()+2!'$!'?2!1%)+*#!*&!O(/#?!*&!$/-2/!'$!P*&A$/@!'?2!1%)+*#!-2)('2!$&!'?2!'$1*#DQEFR!.?2!

/28*29!/2#$@@2&-0!'?('!34"55!(-$1'!82/'*#(+!021(/('*$&!/%+20!/2B%+('*&B!9?2&!(!/2B*0'/,!$/!

/2B*0'/(/!@(,!(#>%*/2!$9&2/0?*1!*&'2/20'!*&!(&!2&'*',!('!'?2!$11$0*'2!+282+!(&-!'?('!'?202!/%+20!)2!

)(02-!$&!@(/S2'!0?(/2D!3'!A%/'?2/!/2#$@@2&-0!'?('!34"55T!/('?2/!'?(&!(%'$@('*#(++,!1/$?*)*'*&B!

/2B*0'/*20!(&-!/2B*0'/(/0!A/$@!(#>%*/*&B!'?*0!*&'2/20'!9?2&!'?2,!(/2!()$82!(!#2/'(*&!@(/S2'!0?(/2!

'?/20?$+-T!*&0'2(-!&$'*A,!'?2!(11/$1/*('2!B$82/&@2&'!(%'?$/*'*20!(&-!@(S2!'?2!%+'*@('2!-2#*0*$&!

'$!(++$9!$/!-*0(++$9!'?2!(#>%*0*'*$&!)(02-!$&!'?2*/!/201$&02D!!

"'!'?2!O(/#?!LMEM!34"55!@22'*&B!*&!5(*/$)*U+200!'?(&!(!922S!(A'2/!'?2!1(12/!9(0!@(-2!

1%)+*#U'?2!34"55!N$(/-!/20$+82-!'?('!P9*'?*&!'?2!#$&'2V'!$A!'?2!&29!B.WX!1/$#200T!'?2/2!9*++!

)2!0'/*#'!021(/('*$&!$A!2&'*'*20!$AA2/*&B!/2B*0'/,!02/8*#20!(&-!'?$02!(#'*&B!(0!/2B*0'/(/0D!5$!#$C

$9&2/0?*1!9*++!)2!(++$92-DQ!.?2!N$(/-!#*'2-!'?2!-20*/2!'$!(8$*-!#$&A+*#'0!9*'?!'?2!1$00*)+2!

-282+$1@2&'!$A!(!&29!Y5HZ!1$+*#,!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2B/('*$&!(0!92++!(0!'?2!&22-!'$!@$82!A$/9(/-!

9*'?!'?2!B.WX!1/$#200!(0!@([$/!A(#'$/0!*&!*'0!-2#*0*$&\!*'!0'('2-!'?('!*A!(!Y5HZ!1$+*#,!*0!-282+$12-!

(&-!(11/$82-!),!'?2!N$(/-!1/*$/!'$!'?2!+(%&#?!$A!&29!B.WX0T!'?('!1$+*#,!9*++!)2!*&#$/1$/('2-!

*&'$!'?2!&29!B.WX!1/$B/(@DEF<!3&!'?2!*&'2/8*290T!*'!9(0!0%BB20'2-!'?('!'?*0!/20$+%'*$&T!/('?2/!

'?(&!(!A*&(+!-2#*0*$&!),!'?2!N$(/-T!9(0!(!@2(0%/2!*&'2&-2-!@$82!'?2!B.WX!1/$#200!A$/9(/-!9?*+2!

A$/#*&B!0'(S2?$+-2/0!'$!9$/S!9*'?*&!'?2!Y5HZ!9$/S*&B!B/$%1!'$!-282+$1!(!#$&02&0%0DEF]!

.?2!Y5HZ!?(-!1/28*$%0+,!/2>%20'2-!'?('!34"55!0'(AA!1/21(/2!(&!*00%20!/21$/'!$&!82/'*#(+!

*&'2B/('*$&!A$/!0%)@*00*$&!'$!'?2!Y5HZ!4$%&#*+D!.?*0!/2>%20'!9(0!1/$@1'2-!),!(!/2>%20'!A/$@!

'?2!5$&#$@@2/#*(+!^02/0!4$&0'*'%2&#,!_54^4`D!.?2!54^4!/2>%20'T!@(-2!*&!H21'2@)2/!LMMaT!

/2A2//2-!'$!(&!"%B%0'!L]T!LMMa!0'('2@2&'!),!'?2!54^4!'?('!/2(-!*&!1(/'6!

!"#$%&'()*"+'#'$%,-),.)#"/%*$#%"*)'-0)#"/%*$#'#*)%*)')+,(%&1)%**2"3,-"),.)$4")5,*$)

.2-0'5"-$'()+,(%&%"*)2-0"#(1%-/)67899:*)#"/2('$%,-),.)$4")0,5'%-)-'5")%-02*$#1;)

8-0)1"$)$4%*)%5+,#$'-$)+,(%&1)&4'-/")%*)<"%-/)4'-0("0)'*)%.)%$)="#")'-)

>%5+("5"-$'$%,-?)0"&%*%,-)$4'$)&'-)<")%-*"#$"0)%-$,)-"=)/@AB)&,-$#'&$*;CDE)

3&!'?2!Y5HZ!*00%20!/21$/'T!1%)+*0?2-!$&!X2#2@)2/!EET!LMMaT!34"55!0'(AA!/2#$@@2&-2-!'?('!'?2!

Y5HZ!P-2+(,!(!bXb!c1$+*#,!-282+$1@2&'!1/$#200d!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2B/('*$&T!(&-!*&0'2(-DDD1/$8*-2!

A$#%02-!'*@2+,!*&1%'!'?/$%B?!'?2!*@1+2@2&'('*$&!1/$#200!'?('!*0!#%//2&'+,!%&-2/9(,!A$/!'?2!529!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EFG!H'282!H(+$1!(&-!e$0?%(!I/*B?'T!Pf2/'*#(+!3&'2B/('*$&!N2'922&!72B*0'/*20!(&-!72B*0'/(/0U.?2!g#$&$@*#!b/$0!(&-!4$&0TQ!e%&2!LLT!LMMaT!?''16hh0,-D*#(&&D$/BhA*+20h@22'*&B0h0,-&2,LMMah1/202&'('*$&C82/'*#(+C021(/('*$&CLL[%&MaC2&D1-AD!

EFR!e$?&!e2AA/2,T!Pf2/'*#(+!3&'2B/('*$&!Z1'*$&0!721$/'!"8(*+()+2!'$!4$@@%&*',TQ!67899)F(,/T!O(/#?!;T!LMEMT!?''16hh)+$BD*#(&&D$/BhLMEMhMFh82/'*#(+C*&'2B/('*$&C$1'*$&0C/21$/'C(8(*+()+2C'$C#$@@%&*',hD!

EF<!34"55T!P"-$1'2-!N$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!U!5(*/$)*TQ!O(/#?!ELT!LMEMT!?''16hh999D*#(&&D$/Bh2&h@*&%'20h/20$+%'*$&0CEL@(/EMC2&D?'@D!

EF]!3&'2/8*290T!H21'2@)2/!LMEMD!

EF;!54^4T!P5$&#$@@2/#*(+!^02/0!4$&0'*'%2&#,!0'('2@2&'!$&!82/'*#(+!021(/('*$&!$A!/2B*0'/*20!(&-!/2B*0'/(/0TQ!"%B%0'!L]T!

LMMaT!?''16hh+*0'02/8D0,/D2-%h0#/*1'0h9(D2V2i"Fj*&-MaM;kWj54HYC54^4CX3H4^HHkgj)(02<GkbjGaG<a;MkNjCClMMLl]R;LLgELRN4NaaGK;GG<;R;4GNEaKMX];KK4<X;RH^gmM]ONmMG(-0,lk.j(11+*#('*$&nLK1-A\nLM&(@2jnLL54^4C7,C7/C82/'*#(+D1-AnLLk5j54^4C7,C7/C82/'*#(+D1-Ak(''(#?@2&'j>D!

Page 88: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

>.?@!A/$>/(BCDEFG!!.H2!0'(II!(+0$!0'('2-!'H('!J0*&#2!'H2!K5LMN0!(11/$8(+!*0!&$'!/2O%*/2-P!/20$+8*&>!

'H2!82/'*#(+!*&'2>/2('*$&!*00%2!'H/$%>H!'H2!*B1+2B2&'('*$&!1/$#20020!'H('!(/2!#%//2&'+,!

%&-2/9(,!*&0'2(-!$I!'H/$%>H!(!A@A!9$%+-!)2!#$&0*0'2&'!9*'H!'H2!34"55!Q,+(90CD!!3&!(!)+$>!1$0'!

$&!'H2!3&'2/&2'!K$82/&(&#2!A/$R2#'P!S*+'$&!S%2++2/!#/*'*#*T2-!'H*0!-20#/*1'*$&!$I!H$9!82/'*#(+!

*&'2>/('*$&!0H$%+-!)2!H(&-+2-!9*'H*&!34"55P!9/*'*&>6!

!"#$%&'#"()#$%(*+,#*-#!./001#$%(#2034#%5'#"*#'6(7&-&7#6*8&7,#95:&";#+*8(<#!$'#'$5$='#

5'#$%(#>%*9(>#*+#'$5+$&";#6*&"$#*-#588#6*8&7&('#+(85$(?#$*#;("(+&7#"59('#&'#"*$#

("'%+&"(?#&"#$%(#@,85)'A#&$'#65+$&7&65$&*"#>&'#"*$#+(B=&+(?>#(&$%(+#$*#&"&$&5$(#*+#$*#

+5$&-,#6*8&7&('#6(+$5&"&";#$*#;("(+&7#"59('<#C%5$#$%&'#9(5"'1#-*+#$%*'(#*-#,*=#"*$#

'$((6(?#&"#!./00#5+75"51#&'#$%5$#$%(+(#&'#"*#'=7%#$%&";#5'#5#@*$$*9#=6#6+*7(''#&"#

!./00<#DEF#

.H2!K5LM!I$/B2-!(!82/'*#(+!*&'2>/('*$&!9$/U*&>!>/$%1!8*(!(!K5LM!4$%&#*+!/20$+%'*$&!$&!S(/#H!

EVP!WVEVC!Q2'922&!S(/#H!EW!(&-!S(/#H!FEP!WVEVP!*'!*00%2-!(!#(++!I$/!1(/'*#*1(&'0CEXE!!M&!S(/#H!

WGP!WVEVP!'H2!K5LM!4$%&#*+!(&&$%&#2-!'H('!'H2!Y2/'*#(+!3&'2>/('*$&!A@A!Z$/U*&>!K/$%1!9(0!

022U*&>!#$BB2&'0!J$&!(&,!(012#'!/2+('2-!'$!'H2!'$1*#!$I!82/'*#(+!*&'2>/('*$&!)2'922&!/2>*0'/*20!

(&-!/2>*0'/(/0!'H('![#$BB2&'2/0\!'H*&U!0H$%+-!)2!'(U2&!*&'$!(##$%&'!),!'H2!Z$/U*&>!K/$%1!(0!

1(/'!$I!*'0!-2+*)2/('*$&0CDEXW!!.H2!K5LM!2&#$%/(>2-!#$BB2&'0!$&!'H2!47"3!/21$/'!1%)+*0H2-!*&!

M#'$)2/!WVV;P!$&!'H2!0'%-,!1%)+*0H2-!),!L(+$1!(&-!Z/*>H'P!(&-!$&!'H2!S(/#H!WVEV!Q$(/-!

/20$+%'*$&C!.H2!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'!12/*$-!9(0!$12&!%&'*+!"1/*+!E;P!WVEVC!

.H2!34"55!0'(II!0%BB(/,!$I!'H202!#$BB2&'0!9(0!1%)+*0H2-!$&!"1/*+!WWP!WVEVC!L*]!#$BB2&'0!

92/2!/2#2*82-C!.H2!0%BB(/,!&$'2-!'H('!'H2!9$/U*&>!>/$%1!H(-!/2O%20'2-!'H('!#$&0'*'%2&#*20!

(&-!0'(U2H$+-2/!>/$%10!0%)B*'!'H2*/!0'('2B2&'0!),!S(,!^P!WVEVCEXF!

.H2!K5LMN0!9$/U!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2>/('*$&!*0!0'*++!%&-2/9(,C!"!0%BB(/,!$I!82/'*#(+!*&'2>/('*$&!

1/$1$0(+0!#%//2&'+,!)2*&>!#$&0*-2/2-!),!'H2!K5LM!9$/U*&>!>/$%1!#(&!)2!I$%&-!$&!'H2!34"55!

9*U*CEXX!"--*'*$&(+!K5LM!-$#%B2&'0!$&!82/'*#(+!*&'2>/('*$&!#(&!)2!I$%&-!$&!'H2!K5LM!0*'2CEX_!

!"#$$%&'()&*'+,&*-+.(/$0,1*+&$2*1(3$

3&'2/&('*$&(+*T2-!-$B(*&!&(B20!`3@50a!H(82!2]*0'2-!('!'H2!02#$&-!+282+P!*&!.?@0!0%#H!(0!C#&!(&-!

C'9P!0*&#2!WVVVC!"'!'H2!S(/#H!WVVF!34"55!B22'*&>P!34"55N0!3@5!72>*0'/,!3B1+2B2&'('*$&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EFG!K5LMP!JK5LM!300%20!721$/'!$&!Y2/'*#(+!3&'2>/('*$&!Q2'922&!72>*0'/*20!(&-!72>*0'/(/0PD!@2#2B)2/!EEP!WVVGP!H''16bb>&0$C*#(&&C$/>b*00%20b82/'*#(+c*&'2>/('*$&b/21$/'cVX-2#VGc2&C1-IC!

EXV!S*+'$&!S%2++2/P!J34"55!L'(II!I*&(++,!(-B*'0!*'6!.H2/2!*0!&$!)$''$B!%1!1/$#200!(&-!&$!-*II2/2&#2!)2'922&!d1$+*#,N!(&-!d*B1+2B2&'('*$&PND!!"$(+"($#2*G(+"5"7(#H+*I(7$#J8*;P!@2#2B)2/!EEP!WVVGP!H''16bb)+$>C*&'2/&2'>$82/&(&#2C$/>b)+$>be(/#H*820bWVVGbEWbEEbXXVW_^GCH'B+C!

EXE!K5LMP!J4(++!I$/!A(/'*#*1('*$&!$&!'H2!Y2/'*#(+!3&'2>/('*$&!A$+*#,!@282+$1B2&'!A/$#200!`A@Aa!Z$/U*&>!K/$%1PD!S(/#H!EWP!WVEVP!H''16bb>&0$C*#(&&C$/>b(&&$%&#2B2&'b(&&$%&#2B2&'cEWB(/EVc2&CH'BC!

EXW!34"55P!JA%)+*#!4$BB2&'6!K5LM!A$+*#,!@282+$1B2&'!A/$#200!$&!Y2/'*#(+!3&'2>/('*$&!Q2'922&!72>*0'/*20!(&-!72>*0'/(/0PD!S(/#H!WGP!WVEVP!H''16bb999C*#(&&C$/>b2&b(&&$%&#2B2&'0b(&&$%&#2B2&'cFcWGB(/EVc2&CH'BC!

EXF!34"55P!JL%BB(/,!$I!A%)+*#!4$BB2&'!$&!'H2!3&*'*('*$&!$I!'H2!K5LM!A$+*#,!@282+$1B2&'!A/$#200PD!"1/*+!WWP!WVEVP!H''16bbI$/%BC*#(&&C$/>b+*0'0b1-1c82/'*#(+c*&'2>/('*$&b1-I.fRL<,']"gC1-IC!

EXX!34"55P!JY2/'*#(+!3&'2>/('*$&!A@APD!H''106bb0'C*#(&&C$/>b82/'c*&'2>/('*$&c1-1b*&-2]C#>*hH''10e0'e*#(&&e$/>e82/'e*&'2>/('*$&e1-1e*&-2]e#>*e8*e/20$%/#20C!

EX_!K5LMP!J300%20PD!H''16bb>&0$C*#(&&C$/>b*00%20bC!

Page 89: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<!

4$==*''22!0%)=*''2-!(!02'!$>!!?%*-2+*&20!>$/!3@50A!"'!'B('!=22'*&?C!'B2!34"55!D$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!

2&-$/02!'B2!-/(>'C!'$!(%'B$/*E2!'B2!F/20*-2&'!'$!*=1+2=2&'!'B2!?%*-2+*&20!*'!#$&'(*&2-C!(&-!'$!

(++$9!34"55!'$!1/$#22-!9*'B!'B2!/2?*0'/('*$&!$>!3@50!*&!/2?*0'/*20!'B('!=(-2!(?/22=2&'0!9*'B!

34"55!)(02-!$&!'B2!?%*-2+*&20AGHI!.B2!?%*-2+*&20!92/2!>$/=(++,!1%)+*0B2-!$&!J%&2!KLC!KLLMAGHN!

O(&,!.P@0Q*&#+%-*&?!A=%02%=!(&-!A*&>$Q)2?(&!(##21'*&?!02#$&-!+282+!3@50!*&!KLLHAGH;!

3&!R21'2=)2/!KLLNC!'B2!##5RS!(11/$82-!'B2!+(%&#B!$>!(!1$+*#,!-282+$1=2&'!1/$#200!$&!3@5!

##.P@0AGHT!.B2!U5RS!/2#$==2&-('*$&0!>$/!&29!'$1V+282+!-$=(*&0C!(11/$82-!),!'B2!U5RS!

4$%&#*+!'B2!0(=2!=$&'BC!(+0$!0'('2-!'B('!W0$=2!&29!?2&2/*#!'$1V+282+!-$=(*&0!0B$%+-!)2!

*&'2/&('*$&(+*02-!-$=(*&!&(=20!X3@50Y!0%)Z2#'!'$!'B2!(11/$8(+!$>!3@50!)2*&?!(8(*+()+2!*&!'B2!

/$$'A[G\L!!.B2!#%//2&'!X>$%/'BY!82/0*$&!$>!'B2!@"U!(++$90!'B2!0%)=*00*$&!$>!(11+*#('*$&0!>$/!3@5!

?.P@0AG\G!

F/28*$%0+,C!*&!@2#2=)2/!KLLIC!'B2!34"55!D$(/-!B(-!/20$+82-!'$!/2]%20'!'B2!##5RS!(&-!'B2!U"4!

'$!1/$-%#2!(&!*00%20!1(12/!$&!'B2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!3@5!##.P@0!(00$#*('2-!9*'B!3RS!MGII!'9$V

+2''2/!#$%&'/,!#$-20!X'B202!#$-20!(/2!#%//2&'+,!%02-!*&!##.P@0C!>$/!2^(=1+2!A%0!$/!A%_YAG\K!!3&!J%&2!

KLLNC!(>'2/!'B2!##5RS!(&-!'B2!U"4!0%)=*''2-!(!+*0'!$>!]%20'*$&0!'$!'B2!D$(/-!'$!)2!#$&0*-2/2-!

)2>$/2!'B2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!3@5!##.P@0C!'B2!D$(/-!W/2012#'>%++,!/2]%20'`2-a!'B('!'B2!34"55!

#$==%&*',!*&#+%-*&?!'B2!U5RSC!##5RSC!U"4C!(&-!"P"4!#$&'*&%2!'$!9$/_!#$++()$/('*82+,C!'(_*&?!

'B2!'2#B&*#(+!+*=*'('*$&0!(&-!/2]%*/2=2&'0!*&'$!#$&0*-2/('*$&C!'$!2^1+$/2!)$'B!(&!*&'2/*=!(&-!(&!

$82/(++!(11/$(#B!'$!3@5!##.P@0!(00$#*('2-!9*'B!'B2!3RS!MGIIVG!'9$V+2''2/!#$-20!(&-!/2#$==2&-!

(!#$%/02!$>!(#'*$&!'$!'B2!D$(/-!*&!(!'*=2+,!=(&&2/A[G\M!

S&!S#'$)2/!MLC!KLLTC!'B2!34"55!D$(/-!(11/$82-!'B2!3@5!b(0'!./(#_!F/$#200C!9B*#B!(++$90!

&('*$&0!(&-!'2//*'$/*20!'$!/2?*0'2/!'$1V+282+!-$=(*&0!/2>+2#'*&?!'B2*/!&(=2!$/!#$%&'/,!#$-2!*&!

'B2*/!&('*$&(+!+(&?%(?20AG\H!.B2!1/$#200!>$/=(++,!+(%&#B2-!$&!5$82=)2/!GIC!KLLTC!(&-!'B2!>*/0'!

>$%/!3@5!##.P@0Q>$/!c?,1'C!'B2!7%00*(&!b2-2/('*$&C!R(%-*!"/()*(!(&-!'B2!d&*'2-!"/()!c=*/('20!

e92/2!(--2-!'$!'B2!/$$'!*&!O(,!KLGLAG\\!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GHI!34"55C!WO*&%'20C[!O(/#B!KNC!KLLMC!B''16ff999A*#(&&A$/?f2&f=*&%'20f=*&%'20VKN=(/LMAB'=g3&'2/&('*$&(+*E2-@$=(*&5(=20A!!

GHN!34"55C!WU%*-2+*&20!>$/!'B2!3=1+2=2&'('*$&!$>!3&'2/&('*$&(+*E2-!@$=(*&!5(=20C[!J%&2!KLC!KLLMC!B''16ff999A*#(&&A$/?f2&f?2&2/(+f*-&V?%*-2+*&20VKLZ%&LMAB'=A!

GH;!4B%#_!U$=20C!W.B2!hB,!i!j$9!$>!3@5!U2&2/*#!@$=(*&!5(=20C[!O(,!GMC!KLGLC!B''16ff/%00*(KLGLA*&'?$8A&2'f>*+20fU$=20Kk73UbKLGLA11'A!

GHT!##5RSC!W##5RS!4$%&#*+!O*&%'20C[!R21'2=)2/!NC!KLLNC!B''16ff##&0$A*#(&&A$/?f()$%'f=*&%'20f##&0$V=*&%'20VGK021LNA1->A!

G\L!U5RSC!Wb*&(+!721$/'!V!3&'/$-%#'*$&!$>!529!U2&2/*#!.$1VP282+!@$=(*&0C[!"%?%0'!;C!KLLNC!B''16ff?&0$A*#(&&A$/?f*00%20f&29V?'+-0f1-1V-2#L\V>/V1(/'(VL;(%?LNAB'=A!

G\G!34"55C!W@/(>'!"11+*#(&'!U%*-2)$$_C!l2/0*$&!HC[!O(,!MGC!KLGLC!B''16ff999A*#(&&A$/?f2&f'$1*#0f&29V?'+-0f-/(>'V/>1V#+2(&VK;=(,GLV2&A1->A!

G\K!34"55C!W"-$1'2-!720$+%'*$&0!>/$=!34"55!D$(/-!O22'*&?C[!@2#2=)2/!;C!KLLIC!B''16ff999A*#(&&A$/?f2&f=*&%'20f/20$+%'*$&0VL;-2#LIAB'=gk.$#KNGT;KTIA!

G\M!34"55C!W"-$1'2-!D$(/-!720$+%'*$&0QR(&!J%(&C!F%2/'$!7*#$C[!J%&2!KTC!KLLNC!B''16ff999A*#(&&A$/?f2&f=*&%'20f/20$+%'*$&0VKTZ%&LNAB'=g=A!

G\H!34"55C!W34"55!D/*&?*&?!'B2!P(&?%(?20!$>!'B2!h$/+-!'$!'B2!U+$)(+!3&'2/&2'C[!S#'$)2/!MLC!KLLTC!B''16ff999A*#(&&A$/?f2&f(&&$%&#2=2&'0f(&&$%&#2=2&'VML$#'LTV2&AB'=A!

G\\!.*&(!@(=C!W3@5!##[email protected]!b*/0'!b$%/C[!!"#$$%&'()C!O(,!GMC!KLGLC!B''16ff)+$?A*#(&&A$/?fKLGLfL\f*-&V##'+-0VmcKm;LmTMV'B2V>*/0'V>$%/fA!

Page 90: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

.>2!(&&$%&#2?2&'!$@!'>2!3A5!##.BA!C(0'!./(#D!E/$#200!1/$?1'2-!#$&#2/&0!'>('!3A5!F.BA0!

92/2!)2*&F!+2@'!)2>*&-G!H$?2!(''2&-220!('!'>2!1%)+*#!@$/%?!>2+-!-%/*&F!'>2!I#'$)2/!JKK<!34"55!

?22'*&F!2L1/2002-!9$//*20!'>('M!),!1%''*&F!##.BA0!@*/0'M!34"55!9(0!2002&'*(++,!@$/#*&F!(11+*#(&'0!

'$!0%)?*'!'>2*/!-$?(*&!&(?2!(11+*#('*$&0!'$!F$82/&?2&'0GNOP!!I'>2/0!&$'2-!'>('!)%0*&20020!9>$!

9(&'2-!'$!?(D2!'>2*/!92)!#$&'2&'!(##200*)+2!8*(!3A50!9$%+-!)2!/2Q%*/2-!'$!/2F*0'2/!?%+'*1+2!

-$?(*&0R$&2!*&!2(#>!##.BAR/('>2/!'>(&!/2F*0'2/*&F!(!0*&F+2!-$?(*&!*&!(&!3A5!F.BAGNOS!

H$?2!*&'2/8*29220!0%11$/'2-!34"55T0!-2#*0*$&!'$!021(/('2!'>2!1/$F/200!$@!3A5!##.BA0!@/$?!3A5!

F.BA0!*&!$/-2/!'$!(8$*-!%&&2#200(/*+,!-2+(,*&F!##.BA0!(&-!2L1/2002-!(11/2#*('*$&!@$/!'>2!0122-!

('!9>*#>!'>2!3A5!##.BA!C(0'!./(#D!E/$#200!9(0!-282+$12-G!3&!*&'2/8*290M!*'!9(0!0%FF20'2-!'>('!

'>2!-282+$1?2&'!$@!'>2!C(0'!./(#D!E/$#200!9(0!(!F$$-!2L(?1+2!$@!#/$00U#$??%&*',!#$++()$/('*$&!

)2'922&!'>2!##5HI!(&-!'>2!V"4G!H$?2!*&'2/8*29220!2L1/2002-!#$&#2/&0!'>('!1$+*#,!-282+$1?2&'!

@$/!3A50!>(-!1/2#22-2-!'>2!'>$/$%F>!02''*&F!(&-!28(+%('*$&!$@!'2#>&*#(+!0'(&-(/-0!@$/!3A50GNO;!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NOP!W8(&!7(?0'(-M!XH1(/D0!C+,!('!3#(&&!Y22'*&F!*&!H2$%+MZ!!"##$%&'((&$)*+',"#M!I#'$)2/!J<M!JKK<M!>''16[[)+$F0G90\G#$?[-*F*'0[JKK<[NK[J<[01(/D0U@+,U('U*#(&&U?22'*&FU*&U02$%+[G!

NOS!34"55M!X./(&0#/*1'6!E%)+*#!C$/%?MZ!I#'$)2/!J<M!JKK<M!>''16[[02+G*#(&&G$/F[?22'*&F0[02$%+JKK<['/(&0#/*1'U1%)+*#U@$/%?UJ<$#'K<U2&G'L'G!

NO;!3&'2/8*290M!H21'2?)2/!JKNKG!

Page 91: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!""#$%&'()*(+,#(-'''()./0&$(102#(0$%(31!44()#5&2&.$6708&$9(

:;.5#22#2(

!

"#$%&'(%!

3&!><<<?!34"55!*&*'*('2-!(!@1/$$A!$A!#$&#21'B!0'(C2!'$!)2C*&!'D2!(-$1'*$&!$A!&29!C2&2/*#!.EF0G!

34H!72C*0'/,!%&0%##200A%++,!1/$1$02-!GIII!(&-!GJ*-0G!3&!><<K?!(A'2/!0$L2!2I#D(&C20!9*'D!34"55!

/2C(/-*&C!*'0!A*/0'!1/$1$0(+?!34H!0%)L*''2-!(!/28*02-!)*-!A$/!'D2!#/2('*$&!$A!GIII!A$/!34"55M0!#(++!

A$/!01$&0$/2-!.EF!1/$1$0(+0G!.D2!34"55!N$(/-!(-$1'2-!(!/20$+%'*$&!'$!)2C*&!&2C$'*('*&C!'D2!

#$LL2/#*(+!(&-!'2#D&*#(+!'2/L0!$A!(!/2C*0'/,!(C/22L2&'!9*'D!34H!*&!O%&2!><<PQ!D$9282/?!%&-2/!

1/200%/2!A/$L!(!8(/*2',!$A!#$&0'*'%2&#*20?!34"55!/282/02-!*'0!-2#*0*$&!(&-!-2&*2-!34HM0!1/$1$0(+!

*&!><<RG!34H!A*+2-!(!/2S%20'!A$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!*&!><<TU'D2!A*/0'!0%#D!/2S%20'!'$!)2!D2(/-!

)2A$/2!'D2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!V(&2+!W37VX!*&!34"55M0!D*0'$/,G!3&!><Y<?!(!'D/22Z12/0$&!1(&2+!$A!

(/)*'2/0!W9D*#D!#$L1/*02-!'D2!37VX!-2#*-2-!*&!A(8$/!$A!34HG!!

.D*0!#(02!0'%-,!$%'+*&20!'D2!J2,!282&'0!0%//$%&-*&C!'D2!GIII!1/$1$0(+0!A/$L!><<<!'$!O%&2!YR?!

><Y<?!9*'D$%'!/2Z2I(L*&*&C!'D2!L2/*'0!$A!'D2!(11+*#('*$&!*'02+AG!.D*0!#D/$&$+$C,!*0!-20*C&2-!'$!

2I(L*&2!'9$!012#*A*#!-*L2&0*$&0!$A!'D2!GIII!1/$#2006!WYX!'D2!/$+2!$A!'D2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

V(&2+!W37VX?!(&-!W>X!'D2!*&'2/(#'*$&!)2'922&!'D2![$82/&L2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$LL*''22!W["4X!(&-!

'D2!34"55!N$(/-!-%/*&C!34"55M0!28(+%('*$&!$A!'D2!34H!GIII!1/$1$0(+?!/2C*0'/,!(C/22L2&'!

&2C$'*('*$&0!9*'D!34H!(&-?!%+'*L('2!/2\2#'*$&!$A!34HM0!(11+*#('*$&G!!

)'$*!+%,-.!+/,&(*$!'0-!1*%2/-/3/4.!

!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"($"($",#$-",#.&-$*(/$%&+0"/"1"234$51&*-&$-&&$655&(/'7$68$

.D*0!#(02!0'%-,!*0!)(02-!$&!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!L('2/*(+0?!*&#+%-*&C!1%)+*#!#$LL2&'0?!34"55!

-$#%L2&'0?!(#(-2L*#!0'%-*20?!L2-*(!/21$/'0?!(&-!2I12/'!$1*&*$&0G!3'!1/$8*-20!(!0%LL(/,!$A!'D2!

A(#'0!/2C(/-*&C!'D2!GIII!-$L(*&!1/$#200?!9*'D!(!012#*A*#!A$#%0!$&!'9$!(012#'0!$A!'D2!#(026!'D2!

3&-212&-2&'!728*29!V(&2+W37VX?!*&#+%-*&C!34HM0!/2S%20'!A$/!3&-212&'!728*29?!(&-!'D2!/$+2!$A!'D2!

[$82/&L2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$LL*''22!W["4X!'D/$%CD$%'!'D2!N$(/-M0!/28*29!$A!'D2!GIII!1/$1$0(+0?!

*&#+%-*&C!*'0!*&'2/(#'*$&!9*'D!'D2!N$(/-G!"0!12/!]ID*)*'!N?!^2#'*$&!Y!$A!'D2!^2/8*#20!"C/22L2&'!

)2'922&!'D2!N2/JL(&!42&'2/!(&-!34"55?!*'0!C$(+!*0!'$!D2+1!*-2&'*A,!J2,!*00%20?!#D(++2&C20!(&-!

(/2(0!$A!-*0(C/22L2&'!/2+('2-!'$!'D2!GIII!(11+*#('*$&!1/$#200G!.D2!$)02/8('*$&0!)2+$9!9*++!

#$&'/*)%'2!'$!'D2!N2/JL(&!'2(LM0!A*&(+!/21$/'G!

3&!(--*'*$&!'$!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!0$%/#20?!'D*0!#(02!0'%-,!*&#+%-20!0'('2L2&'0?!$1*&*$&0!(&-!

12/#21'*$&0!$A!'D$02!92!*&'2/8*292-!*&!'D2!#$%/02!$A!-282+$1*&C!'D*0!#(02G!.D202!12/#21'*$&0!(&-!

$1*&*$&0!1+(,!(&!*L1$/'(&'!/$+2!*&!'D2!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$A!34"55!-2#*0*$&0!(&-!'D2*/!/2#21'*$&!),!

'D2!#$LL%&*',G!.D2!0'('2L2&'0!$A!*&'2/8*29220!-$!&$'!/2A+2#'!'D2!$1*&*$&0!$/!#$&#+%0*$&0!$A!'D2!

0'%-,!'2(LG!_D*+2!92!D(82!L(-2!282/,!2AA$/'!'$!/2L$82!A(#'%(+!*&(##%/(#*20?!92!-$!&$'!(''20'!'$!

'D2!(##%/(#,!$A!'D2!$1*&*$&0!$AA2/2-!),!*&'2/8*29220G!.D2!*&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!$&!'D2!

#$&-*'*$&!$A!#$&A*-2&'*(++,G!

Page 92: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!"#$%!"0!12/!'>2!?2/8*#20!"@/22A2&'B!'>*0!#(02!0'%-,!C$#%020!$&!282&'0!1/*$/!'$!D%&2!<EB!FG<GH!

I$9282/B!(012#'0!$C!'>2!HJJJ!#(02!(/2!0'*++!28$+8*&@H!"0!0%#>B!'>*0!0'%-,!A(,!&$'!/2C+2#'!'>2!A$0'!

/2#2&'!-282+$1A2&'0!*&!'>*0!#(02H!

&'()*"(+,$6!K/$C200$/!D(#L!M$+-0A*'>B!I2&/,!NH!?>(''%#L!K/$C200$/!$C!N(9B!O2/LA(&!42&'2/!

P(#%+',!4$QR*/2#'$/!(&-!A2A)2/!$C!'>2!O2/LA(&!'2(AB!>(0!0%)A*''2-!'20'*A$&,!C$/!34S!*&!'>2!

HJJJ!#(02H!3&!'>2!#$&'2J'!$C!'>2!O2/LA(&Q*&'2/&(+!122/!/28*29!1/$#200B!>2!1/$8*-2-!#$AA2&'0!$&!

'>2!0#$12!(&-!0'/%#'%/2!$C!(&!2(/+*2/!-/(C'!$C!'>*0!#(02!0'%-,H!!

Page 93: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&

-&&.)/01&23424156&743&!89&:;;;&1!6< :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::=>!

>?>!!34"55@A!4"BB!CD7!5EF!G.BHA!35!<III????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????;J!

"#"#"!!$%&'%(&)!*+!,-&!./'**+!*+!0*12&3,4!5*617############################################################################################## 89!

"#"#:!!;0<=>!/'*3*>?@!+*'!#AAA!?17!#B(7> #################################################################################################################8C!

>?<!!34"55@A!7EKLEA.!CD7!M7DMDA"BA!CD7!5EF!A.BHA!35!<IIJ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????;N!

"#:#"!!$%&'%(&)!*+!,-&!5D/##########################################################################################################################################8E!

"#:#:!!;0<=>!/'*3*>?@!+*'!#AAA#####################################################################################################################################8F!

"#:#9!!;0GHH=>!5&%(&)!?17!;1(,(?@!G33'*%?@########################################################################################################8F!

?&&.@A46A9/9@!&47&!89&B5)&.@&!89&:;;;&234)911:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::==!

<?>!.OE!7DBE!DC!.OE!G"4!35!34"55???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????;;!

<?<!!.OE!7DBE!DC!.OE!G"4!35!.OE!?PPP!M7D4EAA6!<IIQ ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >I>!

<?J!!.OE!7DBE!DC!.OE!G"4!35!.OE!?PPP!M7D4EAA6!<IIR ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >I<!

<?Q!.OE!7DBE!DC!.OE!G"4!35!.OE!?PPP!M7D4EAA6!<IIN???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >IS!

<?R!.OE!7DBE!DC!.OE!G"4!35!.OE!?PPP!M7D4EAA6!<IIS???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >><!

<?N!!ME74EM.3D5A!DC!.OE!G"4@A!7DBE!35!.OE!?PPP!M7D4EAA!T"AEH!D5!TE7UV"5!4"AE!A.LHW!35.E7X3EFA

???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >>R!

>&&!89&.@<929@<9@!&39A.9C&25@96D&.)/&A:&.)5@@ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: --E!

J?>!35HEME5HE5.!7EX3EF!7EKLEA.A!"5H!.OE!35HEME5HE5.!7EX3EF!M"5EB!35!34"55@A!TWB"FA????????? >>N!

J?<!!34V@A!7EKLEA.!CD7!35HEME5HE5.!7EX3EF????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >>S!

J?J!!34"55@A!7EAMD5AE!.D!34V@A!7EKLEA.!CD7!35HEME5HE5.!7EX3EF?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? >>;!

J?Q!!EA."TB3AO35G!.OE!37M!M7D4EAA????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ><>!

J?R!!VEVD73"B!D5!.OE!VE73.AY!F3.5EAA!A.".EVE5.AY!"5H!EPME7.!7EMD7.A ????????????????????????????????????????????? ><<!

J?N!.OE!37M@A!HE4B"7".3D5 ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ><<!

J?S!!37M!M7D4EAA!DTAE7X".3D5A!T"AEH!D5!TE7UV"5!4"AE!A.LHW!35.E7X3EFA ?????????????????????????????????????????? ><J!

!

Page 94: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!""#$%&'"()*+*',-".*)"/01"2333"'456"

!"!##$%&''()#%*++#,-.#'/0#1234)#56#7888#

!"!"!##9:/.:5/0#-,#;</#=>.--,#-,#%-6?/@;A#B-C6D#

.>2!#$/2!$?!34"55@0!A*00*$&!*0!B'$!#$$/-*&('2C!('!'>2!$82/(++!+282+C!'>2!D+$)(+!3&'2/&2'@0!0,0'2A!$?!

%&*E%2!*-2&'*?*2/0CF!(!A(&-('2!'>('!*&#+%-20!/201$&0*)*+*',!?$/!'>2!(++$#('*$&!$?!-$A(*&!&(A20!

(&-!A(&(D2A2&'!$?!'>2!G$A(*&!5(A2!H,0'2A!IG5HJKL!H*&#2!'>2!L;MN0C!0282&!'$1O+282+!-$A(*&0!

I.PG0J!>(82!)22&!*&!'>2!G5H!IK#$AC!K2-%C!KD$8C!K*&'C!KA*+C!K&2'C!(&-!K$/DJC!$&+,!'>/22!$?!9>*#>!92/2!

(8(*+()+2!?$/!1%)+*#!/2D*0'/('*$&!9*'>$%'!/20'/*#'*$&!IK#$AC!K&2'C!(&-!K$/DJKQ!R/$A!'>2!$%'02'C!$&2!$?!

34"55@0!1/*A(/,!'(0S0!9(0!'$!-282+$1!(!02'!$?!1$+*#*20!(&-!)20'!1/(#'*#20!?$/!'>2!0$+*#*'('*$&C!

#/2('*$&C!(&-!A(&(D2A2&'!$?!&29!D2&2/*#!.PG0!ID.PG0JK<!

.>2!G$A(*&!5(A2!H%11$/'*&D!T/D(&*U('*$&!IG5HTJC!$&2!$?!34"55@0!$/*D*&(+!'>/22!0%11$/'*&D!

$/D(&*U('*$&0!I9>*#>!9(0!/21+(#2-!),!'>2!V2&2/*#!5(A20!H%11$/'*&D!T/D(&*U('*$&!IV5HTJ!*&!

G2#2A)2/!QNNQJC!W!9(0!/201$&0*)+2!?$/!A(S*&D!/2#$AA2&-('*$&0!$&!'>2!B$12/('*$&C!(00*D&A2&'C!

(&-!A(&(D2A2&'!$?!'>2!-$A(*&!&(A2!0,0'2A!(&-!$'>2/!/2+('2-!0%)X2#'0KFY!3&!L;;;C!'>2!G5HT!

'(0S2-!(!02'!$?!9$/S*&D!D/$%10!9*'>!0'%-,*&D!9>2'>2/!'>2!#/2('*$&!$?!&29!D.PG0!9$%+-!)2!

-20*/()+2C!*&!+*D>'!$?!*&'2++2#'%(+!1/$12/',!/*D>'0!(&-!$'>2/!*00%20KZ!T&!"1/*+!L;C!QNNNC!'>2!G5HT!

/2#$AA2&-2-!'>('!'>2!34"55![$(/-!-282+$1!(!02'!$?!1$+*#*20!'$!D%*-2!'>2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!(!

B+*A*'2-!&%A)2/F!$?!&29!D.PG0K\!.>2!34"55![$(/-!(-$1'2-!'>*0!/2#$AA2&-('*$&!$&!]%+,!LZC!

QNNNM!(&-!)2D(&!(##21'*&D!.PG!(11+*#('*$&0!$&!H21'2A)2/!YC!QNNNC!9*'>!'>2!D$(+!$?!#$A1+2'*&D!

/2D*0'/,!&2D$'*('*$&0!),!'>2!2&-!$?!'>2!,2(/K;!"11+*#(&'0!92/2!12/A*''2-!'$!0%)A*'!1/$1$0(+0!?$/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1!34"55![,+(90C!"/'*#+2!3C!H2#'*$&!LC!H21'2A)2/!<NC!QNN;C!>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^D2&2/(+^(/#>*82O),+(90^),+(90O<N021N;O2&K>'AK!2!34"55C!B.$1OP282+!G$A(*&0!ID.PG0JCF!_(,!ZC!QNN;C!!>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^'+-0K!T&2!$'>2/!012#*(+*U2-!.PG!>(-!(+0$!)22&!*A1+2A2&'2-6!K(/1(C!9>*#>!*0!/202/82-!'$!0%11$/'!'>2!3&'2/&2'!"/#>*'2#'%/2![$(/-@0!'2#>&*#(+!*&?/(0'/%#'%/2!1/$X2#'0!I022!>''16^^999K*(&(K$/D^-$A(*&0^(/1(^JK!_$/2!'>(&!QYN!#$%&'/,O#$-2!.PG0!I##.PG0J!(+0$!2`*0'C!(!>(&-?%+!$?!9>*#>!(/2!9/*''2&!*&!&$&OP('*&!#>(/(#'2/0!(&-!(/2!#('2D$/*U2-!(0!3&'2/&('*$&(+*U2-!G$A(*&!5(A20!I3G50JK!3!H22!34"55C!B.$1OP282+!G$A(*&0!ID.PG0JCF!_(,!ZC!QNN;C!>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^'+-0K!!4!.>2!G5HT!9(0!282&'%(++,!0%##22-2-!),!'>2!V2&2/*#!5(A20!H%11$/'*&D!T/D(&*U('*$&0!IV5HTJ!*&!QNN<K!H22!G5HTC!>''16^^999K-&0$K$/D^!5!34"55![,+(90C!"/'*#+2!a33C!H2#'*$&!<I(JC!5$82A)2/!ZC!L;;MC!>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^D2&2/(+^(/#>*82O),+(90^),+(90ONZ&$8;MK>'AK!6!"!L;;;!b3cT!/21$/'!0'('2-!'>('!&29!D.PG0!#$%+-!)2!*&'/$-%#2-!0+$9+,!*?!*&'2++2#'%(+!1/$12/',!/*D>'0!/2#2*82-!(-2E%('2!1/$'2#'*$&d!022!34"55C!B.>2!_(&(D2A2&'!$?!3&'2/&2'!5(A20!(&-!"--/200206!3&'2++2#'%(+!c/$12/',!300%20CF!"1/*+!<NC!L;;;C!

>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^9*1$^R*&(+721$/'eLK>'A+K!.>2!G5HT@0!b$/S*&D!V/$%10![!(&-!4!92/2!20'()+*0>2-!'$!(--/200!'>2!b3cT!/21$/'!(&-!$'>2/!*&'2++2#'%(+!1/$12/',!#$&#2/&0d!022!G5HTC!B_22'*&D!$?!'>2!5(A20!4$%&#*+!*&!H(&!]$02!$&!QY!]%&2!L;;;CF!]%&2!QYC!L;;;C!>''16^^999K-&0$K$/D^-&0$^&$'20^L;;;NZQYK540XO(-A*&K>'A+K!7!G5HTC!BG5HT!5(A20!4$%&#*+!H'('2A2&'!$&!&29!D.PG0CF!"1/*+!L;C!QNNNC!>''16^^999K-&0$K$/D^-&0$^&$'20^QNNNNWL;K54D'+-0O0'('2A2&'K>'A+K!8!34"55C!B720$+%'*$&0!$?!'>2!34"55![$(/-!$&!529!.PG0CF!]%+,!LZC!QNNNC!>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^'+-0^&29O'+-O/20$+%'*$&0OLZX%+NNK>'AK!9!34"55C!B529!.PG!"11+*#('*$&!c/$#200!T82/8*29CF!"%D%0'!<C!QNNNC!>''16^^999K*#(&&K$/D^2&^'+-0^(11+*#('*$&O1/$#200ON<(%DNNK>'AK!

Page 95: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

2*'>2/!(!?01$&0$/2-!.@AB!C0.@AD!$/!(&!?%&01$&0$/2-!.@ABEF!(&-!2(#>!(11+*#('*$&!9(0!/2G%*/2-!

'$!0('*0H,!&*&2!#/*'2/*(6! !

EI .>2!&22-!'$!J(*&'(*&!'>2!3&'2/&2'K0!0'()*+*',I!!

LI .>2!2M'2&'!'$!9>*#>!02+2#'*$&!$H!'>2!1/$1$0(+!9$%+-!+2(-!'$!(&!2HH2#'*82!?1/$$H!$H!

#$&#21'B!#$&#2/&*&N!'>2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$H!.@A0!*&!'>2!H%'%/2I!!

OI .>2!2&>(&#2J2&'!$H!#$J12'*'*$&!H$/!/2N*0'/('*$&!02/8*#20I!!

<I .>2!2&>(&#2J2&'!$H!'>2!%'*+*',!$H!'>2!A5PI!!

QI .>2!2M'2&'!'$!9>*#>!'>2!1/$1$0(+!9$%+-!J22'!1/28*$%0+,!%&J2'!',120!$H!&22-0I!!

RI .>2!2M'2&'!'$!9>*#>!'>2!1/$1$0(+!9$%+-!2&>(&#2!'>2!-*82/0*',!$H!'>2!A5P!(&-!$H!

/2N*0'/('*$&!02/8*#20!N2&2/(++,I!!

SI .>2!28(+%('*$&!$H!-2+2N('*$&!$H!1$+*#,TH$/J%+('*$&!H%&#'*$&0!H$/!012#*(+T1%/1$02!.@A0!'$!

(11/$1/*('2!$/N(&*U('*$&0I!!

VI "11/$1/*('2!1/$'2#'*$&0!$H!/*N>'0!$H!$'>2/0!*&!#$&&2#'*$&!9*'>!'>2!$12/('*$&!$H!'>2!.@AI!!

;I .>2!#$J1+2'2&200!$H!'>2!1/$1$0(+0!0%)J*''2-!(&-!'>2!2M'2&'!'$!9>*#>!'>2,!-2J$&0'/('2!

/2(+*0'*#!)%0*&200W!H*&(&#*(+W!'2#>&*#(+W!(&-!$12/('*$&(+!1+(&0!(&-!0$%&-!(&(+,0*0!$H!

J(/X2'!&22-0IEE!!

?Y2&2/(+TZ%/1$02B!.@A!1/$1$0(+0!92/2!N/$%12-!*&'$!H$%/!#('2N$/*206!?Y2&2/(+B!CH$/!&$&012#*H*#!

1/$1$0(+0W!*&#+%-*&N!I)*U!(&-!I*&H$DW!?Z2/0$&(+B!CH$/!12/0$&(+!#$&'2&'W!*&#+%-*&N!I&(J2!(&-!I0(&DW!

?720'/*#'2-!4$&'2&'B!CH$/!012#*H*#!',120!$H!#$&'2&'W!*&#+%-*&N!IMMM!(&-!IX*-0DW!(&-!?720'/*#'2-!

4$JJ2/#*(+B!C*&#+%-*&N!I+(9!(&-!I'/(82+DIEL!

!"!"#$$%&'()$*+,-,)./$0,+$"111$.23$"453)$

34"55!/2#2*82-!<S!(11+*#('*$&0!9*'>!1/$1$0(+0!H$/!&29!01$&0$/2-!(&-!%&01$&0$/2-!.@A0IEO!

.>/22!$/N(&*U('*$&0!0%)J*''2-!1/$1$0(+0!H$/!IMMMWE<!*&#+%-*&N!34[!72N*0'/,W!3&#I!C34[DW!9>*#>!

(11+*2-!'$!#/2('2!IMMM!(&-!IX*-0W!(/N%*&N!'>('W!'$N2'>2/W!'>2!1(*/!$H!&29!.@A0!9$%+-!2&>(&#2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

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

Page 96: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

$&+*&2!#>*+-!0(?2',!),!#+2(/+,!-2+*&2('*&@!#>*+-A?/*2&-+,!(&-!(-%+'A$&+,!#$&'2&'!(/2(0BC<!34D!(+0$!

#$&'2&-2-!'>('!)$'>!'>2!(-%+'!*&-%0'/,!(&-!#>*+-A?/*2&-+,!#$&'2&'!1/$-%#2/0!9$%+-!#$E1+,!9*'>!

34DF0!1$+*#*20!8$+%&'(/*+,G!#+(*E*&@!'>('!H(-%+'!#$&'2&'!+2(-2/0!?%++,!)(#I!'>2!20'()+*0>E2&'!$?!

'>202!.JK0L!(&-!'>('!H2E*&2&'!#>*+-/2&F0!2&'2/'(*&E2&'!(&-!2-%#('*$&(+!$/@(&*M('*$&0!(/2!

1/$E*0*&@!2N'2&0*82!*&820'E2&'0!*&!'>2!#>*+-A?/*2&-+,!-$E(*&BLCO!

P%'!$?!'>202!QR!(11+*#('*$&0G!34"55!02+2#'2-!0282&!-%/*&@!'>2!2N1+$/('$/,!1>(026!?$%/!

%&01$&0$/2-!.JK0!SB)*MG!B*&?$G!B&(E2G!B1/$T!(&-!'>/22!01$&0$/2-!SB(2/$G!B#$$1G!BE%02%ETBCR!3&!

(11+,*&@!'>2!28(+%('*$&!#/*'2/*(!'$!34DF0!BNNN!(11+*#('*$&G!34"55!-2'2/E*&2-!'>('!34DF0!1/$1$0(+!

?$/!(!BI*-0!.JK!-*-!E22'!%&E2'!&22-0!)%'!9(0!%&+*I2+,!'$!0%##22-!?/$E!(!)%0*&200!0'(&-1$*&'BCU!

34"55!(+0$!?$%&-!'>('!34D!-*-!&$'!1/$1$02!H(&,!)%0*&200!$/!'2#>&*#(+!E2'>$-0!'$!2??2#'*82+,!

/20'/*#'!#$&'2&'!?$/!(!BI*-0!.JKBLC;!72@(/-*&@!BNNNG!34"55!0'('2-6!HV3'W!-$20!&$'!(112(/!'$!E22'!

%&E2'!&22-0B!"-%+'!#$&'2&'!*0!/2(-*+,!(8(*+()+2!$&!'>2!3&'2/&2'B!.$!'>2!2N'2&'!'>('!0$E2!)2+*282!

'>('!(&!BNNN!.JK!9$%+-!02@/2@('2!(-%+'!#$&'2&'G!&$!E2#>(&*0E!S'2#>&*#(+!$/!&$&A'2#>&*#(+T!2N*0'0!

'$!/2X%*/2!(-%+'!#$&'2&'!'$!E*@/('2!?/$E!2N*0'*&@!.JK0!'$!(&!BNNN!.JKBL!34"55!(+0$!&$'2-!'>('!'>2!

#$&'/$82/0*(+!&('%/2!$?!(!02NA#2&'/*#!.JK!E(-2!*'!*++A0%*'2-!'$!'>2!@$(+0!$?!'>2!H1/$$?!$?!#$&#21'L!

1>(026!H'>2!28(+%('*$&!'2(E!#$&#+%-2-!'>('!('!'>*0!2(/+,!Y1/$$?!$?!#$&#21'F!0'(@2!9*'>!(!+*E*'2-!

&%E)2/!$?!&29!.JK0!#$&'2E1+('2-G!$'>2/!1/$1$02-!.JK0!9*'>$%'!'>2!#$&'/$82/0,!$?!(&!(-%+'!

.JK!9$%+-!)2''2/!02/82!'>2!@$(+0!$?!'>*0!*&*'*(+!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$?!&29!.JK0BLZ[!!

\+'*E('2+,G!34"55!-2#*-2-!'$!&$'!(##21'!34DF0!1/$1$0(+0!?$/!BNNN!(&-!BI*-0G!1/$8*-*&@!'>2!

?$++$9*&@!]%0'*?*#('*$&6!

!"#$%&"'()'*+"',-$."/%$#,"&',-'*+"'01(0(&".'*"#+-,#$2'$-.'3%&,-"&&'4"$&%1"&'*('$#*%$225'

01(4(*"'6,.7)1,"-.25'#(-*"-*8'*+"'"9$2%$*,(-'*"$4'.("&'-(*'1"#(44"-.'&"2"#*,-:'$';6,.&'

.(4$,-',-'*+"'#%11"-*'0+$&"'()'*+"'<=>'01(:1$4;'?-'$..,*,(-8'3"#$%&"'()'*+"'#(-*1(9"1&5'

&%11(%-.,-:8'$-.'0((1'."),-,*,(-'()'*+"'+(0".7)(1'3"-"),*&'()8';@@@8'A"'$2&('1"#(44"-.'

$:$,-&*',*&'&"2"#*,(-'$*'*+,&'*,4";BC''

3&!/201$&02G!34D!?*+2-!(!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!72X%20'!$&!K2#2E)2/!C<G!Z[[[G!/2X%20'*&@!H#+(/*?*#('*$&!

?/$E!'>2!^$(/-!9*'>!/2012#'!'$!*&(##%/('2!0'('2E2&'0!E(-2!*&8$+8*&@!V'>2!BNNNW!/2@*0'/,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

15!34"55G!H72@*0'/,!P12/('$/F0!_/$1$0(+!'$!34"55GL!`21'2E)2/!CUG!Z[[[G!>''16aa999B*#(&&B$/@a2&a'+-0aI*-0baK2?(%+'B>'EB!34DF0!(11+*#('*$&!(+0$!>,1$'>20*M2-!'>('!'>2!(-%+'!$/*2&'2-!#$&'2&'!$&!$'>2/!-$E(*&0!S2B@BG!(??*+*('2-!0*'20T!#$%+-!)2!2(0*+,!?*+'2/2-!),!3_!(--/20020!(&-!1/$1/*2'(/,!K5`!+*0'*&@0!*&!(--*'*$&!'$!?*+'2/*&@!'>2!BNNN!#$&'2&'B!3)*-B!16!34"55G!H72@*0'/,!P12/('$/F0!_/$1$0(+!'$!34"556!c$+%E2!ZGL!`21'2E)2/!CUG!Z[[[G!>''16aa999B*#(&&B$/@a2&a'+-0aI*-0bad.DJac$+%E2eZB>'E+B!17!34"55G!H`2#$&-!"&&%(+!D22'*&@!$?!'>2!^$(/-!D*&%'20GL!5$82E)2/!COG!Z[[[G!>''16aa999B*#(&&B$/@a2&aE*&%'20aE*&%'20A(&&%(+AE22'*&@ACO&$8[[B>'EB!18!34"55G!H721$/'!$&!.JK!"11+*#('*$&06!"11+*#('*$&!$?!'>2!"%@%0'!C<!4/*'2/*(!'$!f(#>!4('2@$/,!$/!g/$%1GL!5$82E)2/!;G!Z[[[G!>''16aa999B*#(&&B$/@a2&a'+-0a/21$/'a/21$/'A!***)C#A[;&$8[[B>'EB!!19!34"55G!H721$/'!$&!.JK!"11+*#('*$&06!"11+*#('*$&!$?!'>2!"%@%0'!C<!4/*'2/*(!'$!f(#>!4('2@$/,!$/!g/$%1GL!5$82E)2/!;G!Z[[[G!>''16aa999B*#(&&B$/@a2&a'+-0a/21$/'a/21$/'A!***)C#A[;&$8[[B>'EB!20!3)*-B!21!3)*-B!

Page 97: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

1/$1$0(+>?!@@!!A/*B(/*+,C!34D!'$$E!*00%2!9*'F!'F2!34"55!G$(/-H0!#+(*B!'F('!'F2!B(I$/*',!$J!'F2!

(-%+'!#$BB%&*',!-*-!&$'!0%11$/'!'F2!#/2('*$&!$J!>KKKC!(&-!(/L%2-!'F('!MB$0'?!(-%+'!#$&'2&'!

1/$8*-2/0!0%11$/'2-!'F2!-$B(*&>!34D!(+0$!B(*&'(*&2-!'F('!*'!1/$1$02-!'$!$12/('2!'F2!>E*-0!

/2L*0'/,!M$&+,!*&!'F2!282&'!'F('!'F2/2!9(0!&$!$'F2/!#/2-*)+2!0%)B*00*$&!J$/!(!>E*-0!/2L*0'/,>?@N!

O*&(++,C!34D!-*0(L/22-!9*'F!'F2!.PQ!28(+%('$/0H!#$&#+%0*$&!'F('!>KKK!-*-!&$'!B22'!(&!M%&B2'!

&22-C?!(/L%*&L!'F('!'F2!1/$+*J2/('*$&!$J!$&+*&2!(-%+'!B('2/*(+!&2#200*'('2-!'F2!#/2('*$&!$J!'F2!E*&-!

$J!-$B(*&!1$+*#*20!34D!F(-!1/$1$02->!

.F2!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!4$BB*''22!-2#*-2-!'$!'(E2!&$!(#'*$&C!0'('*&LC!M34D!72L*0'/,H0!

/2#$&0*-2/('*$&!/2R%20'!-$20!&$'!022E!/2#$&0*-2/('*$&!$J!'F2!G$(/-H0!5$82B)2/!S<C!@TTT!

-2#*0*$&!>!>!>!(##$/-*&L+,C!'F2/2!*0!&$!(#'*$&!J$/!'F2!G$(/-!'$!'(E2!9*'F!/2012#'!'$!'F2!G$(/-H0!(#'%(+!

-2#*0*$&!('!'F*0!'*B2>?24!3'!&$'2-!'F('!M&$!&29!.PQ!1/$1$0(+!F(0!)22&!/2I2#'2-!),!34"55?U!/('F2/C!

(!0B(++!02'!$J!1$'2&'*(++,!0%##200J%+!(11+*#(&'0!F(-!)22&!02+2#'2-!9*'F!'F2!(*B!$J!'20'*&L!(!

-*82/0*',!$J!(11/$(#F20!'$!'F2!#/2('*$&!$J!&29!.PQ0>!.F2!4$BB*''22!(+0$!&$'2-!'F('!M'F2!J(#'!'F('!

(!&29!.PQ!1/$1$0(+!9(0!&$'!02+2#'2-!%&-2/!'F$02!#*/#%B0'(&#20!0F$%+-!&$'!)2!*&'2/1/2'2-!(0!(!

&2L('*82!/2J+2#'*$&!$&!'F2!1/$1$0(+!$/!*'0!01$&0$/>?25!

!"#$$%&'(()*$+,-.,*/$012$32141*56*$012$(,7$*89:*$;<$#==>$

!"#"!$$?@,2@;,7$10$/A,$+B3$

V&!V#'$)2/!SWC!@TT@C!34"55!A/20*-2&'!X'%(/'!P,&&!*00%2-!(!/21$/'!'*'+2-!M"!A+(&!J$/!"#'*$&!

72L(/-*&L!529!.PQ0C?!9F*#F!(-8$#('2-!2K'2&-*&L!'F2!M1/$$J!$J!#$&#21'?!1F(02!),!(++$9*&L!

(11+*#(&'0!9F$!F(-!1(/'*#*1('2-!*&!'F2!@TTT!/$%&-!'$!/20%)B*'!'F2*/!.PQ!1/$1$0(+0>@<!V&!

Q2#2B)2/!SYC!@TT@C!*&!/201$&02!'$!'F2!MA+(&!J$/!"#'*$&C?!'F2!34"55!G$(/-!-*/2#'2-!34"55!0'(JJ!'$!

-282+$1!(!0'/('2L,!J$/!0$+*#*'*&L!J%/'F2/!.PQ!(11+*#('*$&0>@Z!.F*0!/20%+'2-!*&!(!-/(J'!72R%20'!J$/!

A/$1$0(+0![7OA\!J$/!'F2!#/2('*$&!$J!&29!01$&0$/2-!.PQ0C!1$0'2-!1%)+*#+,!$&!]%&2!@^C!@TTN>@W!!

.F2!@TTN!7OA!-*JJ2/2-!J/$B!'F2!@TTT!M1/$$J!$J!#$&#21'?!0$+*#*'('*$&!*&!'9$!*B1$/'(&'!9(,0>!O*/0'C!

*'!9(0!/20'/*#'2-!'$!1/$1$0(+0!J$/!!"#$!#%&'!.PQ0>!"11+*#(&'0!92/2!/2R%*/2-!'$!-2B$&0'/('2!'F('!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

22!34"55C!M72#$&0*-2/('*$&!72R%20'!TT_SYC?!Q2#2B)2/!S<C!@TTTC!

F''16``999>*#(&&>$/L`2&`#$BB*''220`/2#$&0*-2/('*$&`*#B_/2R%20'_S<-2#TT>F'B>!34"55H0!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!A$+*#,![9F*#F!F(0!0*&#2!)22&!0%12/02-2-\!F(-!)22&!20'()+*0F2-!'$!*B1+2B2&'!"/'*#+2!333C!X2#'*$&!^[(\!$J!'F2!$/*L*&(+!G,+(90>!34"55C!M72#$&0*-2/('*$&!A$+*#,C?!D(/#F!^C!S;;;C!F''16``999>!*#(&&>$/L`2&`#$BB*''220`/2#$&0*-2/('*$&`/2#$&_1$+*#,_T^B(/;;>F'B>!23!X22!M72#$&0*-2/('*$&!72R%20'C?!3)*->!24!"+'F$%LF!%&#+2(/!*&!'F2!72#$BB2&-('*$&C!*'!(112(/0!'F2!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!4$BB*''22H0!B(&-('2!*0!$&+,!'$!%&(#$!)'&%!-2#*0*$&0!(&-!*00%2!/2#$BB2&-('*$&0C!/('F2/!'F(&!#+(/*J,!G$(/-!-2#*0*$&0>!X22!34"55C!M72#$&0*-2/('*$&!72R%20'!TT_SY6!72#$BB2&-('*$&!$J!'F2!4$BB*''22![728*02-\C?!X21'2B)2/!ZC!@TTSC!F''16``999>*#(&&>$/L`2&`#$BB*''220`/2#$&0*-2/('*$&`/#TT_SY_S>F'B>!25!3)*->!26!34"55C!M"!A+(&!J$/!"#'*$&!72L(/-*&L!529!.PQ0C?!V#'$)2/!SWC!@TT@C!F''16``999>*#(&&>$/L`2&`#$BB*''220`&'211'J`&29_L'+-_(#'*$&_1+(&_SW$#'T@>F'B>!27!34"55C!M34"55!@TT@!"&&%(+!D22'*&L!*&!"B0'2/-(BC?!Q2#2B)2/!S^aSYC!@TT@C!F''16``999>*#(&&>$/L`2&`B22'*&L0`(B0'2/-(B>!28!34"55C!Mb0'()+*0FB2&'!$J!&29!0.PQ06!72R%20'!J$/!A/$1$0(+0![Q/(J'!J$/!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'\C?!]%&2!@^C!@TTNC!F''16``999>*#(&&>$/L`2&`'+-0`&29_0'+-_/J1`&29_0'+-_/J1_@^I%&TN>F'B>!

Page 98: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

'>2!0.?@!02/82-!'>2!&22-0!$A!(!92++B-2A*&2-!C01$&0$/2-!#$DD%&*',EF!(&-!'>2!1/$1$0(+!9(0!

/2G%*/2-!'$!#(//,!'>2!0%11$/'!$A!(!C01$&0$/*&H!$/H(&*I('*$&EF!9>*#>!9$%+-!(00%D2!#2/'(*&!

/201$&0*)*+*'*20!*&!-282+$1*&H!1$+*#*20!A$/!'>2!.?@J!K2#$&-E!'>2!34"55!L$(/-!9$%+-!&$'!28(+%('2!

(11+*#('*$&0!-*/2#'+,J!7('>2/E!(11+*#('*$&0!92/2!'$!)2!28(+%('2-!),!0282/(+!1(&2+0!$A!*&-212&-2&'!

28(+%('$/0!9>$!9$%+-!0%)D*'!/21$/'0!$&!2(#>!1/$1$0(+!'$!'>2!34"55!L$(/-M!'>2!/21$/'0E!9>*+2!

&$&)*&-*&HE!92/2!*&'2&-2-!'$!1+(,!(!0*H&*A*#(&'!/$+2!*&!0>(1*&H!'>2!L$(/-N0!-2#*0*$&0JO;!

P&!Q%&2!ORE!OSSTU'>2!-(,!(A'2/!'>2!-/(A'!7VW!9(0!1$0'2-!A$/!1%)+*#!#$DD2&'U34"55!>2+-!(!

1%)+*#!-*0#%00*$&!$&!'>2!-/(A'!D('2/*(+0!-%/*&H!(!W%)+*#!V$/%D!*&!X$&'/Y(+J!K$D2!#$DD2&'2/0!

(/H%2-!'>('!(!0*&H+2!-(,!9(0!*&(-2G%('2!A$/!1%)+*#!/28*29E!1(/'*#%+(/+,!H*82&!'>2!#$&'/$82/0,!'>('!

12/0*0'2-!(/$%&-!'>2!1/$1$02-!.?@!1$+*#*20JTS!P&!'>2!A$++$9*&H!-(,E!'>2!34"55!L$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!

2Z'2&-!'>2!1%)+*#!#$DD2&'!12/*$-!A$/!'9$!D$&'>0E!'>/$%H>!"%H%0'!ORE!OSSTJT[!

34"55!/2#2*82-!D$/2!'>(&!<S!/201$&020!),!2D(*+E!9>*#>!*'!1$0'2-!1%)+*#+,!-%/*&H!'>2!#$DD2&'!

12/*$-JTO!.>2!"'B?(/H2!"-8*0$/,!4$DD*''22!\"?"4]!(+0$!0%)D*''2-!(!A$/D(+!/201$&02E!

/2#$DD2&-*&H!0%)0'(&'*82!#>(&H20!'$!D(^2!'>2!7VW!D$/2!2G%*'()+2!(&-!1/$1$0*&H!(!02'!$A!

1/*&#*1+20!'$!H%*-2!'>2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$A!A%'%/2!H.?@0JTT!

P&!P#'$)2/![TE!OSSTE!'>2!34"55!L$(/-!-2#*-2-!*'!9$%+-!'2D1$/(/*+,!0>2+82!'>2!0.?@!(11+*#('*$&!

1/$#200E!#*'*&H!'>2!#$&0'/(*&'0!$A!'>2!/2#2&'!(D2&-D2&'0!'$!'>2!X2D$/(&-%D!$A!_&-2/0'(&-*&H!

9*'>!'>2!_&*'2-!K'('20!@21(/'D2&'!$A!4$DD2/#2U1(/'*#%+(/+,!'>2!/2G%*/2D2&'!'>('!34"55!

G%*#^+,!C#$DD2&#2!(!A%++!0#(+2!/28*29!$A!1$+*#,!*&!'>*0!(/2(JFT`!.>2!a2&2/*#!5(D20!K%11$/'*&H!

P/H(&*I('*$&!\a5KP]TR!0'/$&H+,!$)b2#'2-E!>$9282/E!(&-!$&!P#'$)2/!T[E!OSSTE!'>2!34"55!L$(/-!

/282/02-!*'0!-2#*0*$&!(&-!/20$+82-!'$!D$82!A$/9(/-!9*'>!'>2!0.?@!7VWJ!"--*'*$&(++,E!'>2!L$(/-!

/20$+82-!'$!/28*02!'>2!'2/D0!$A!'>2!7VW!)(02-!$&!#$DD2&'(/,!A/$D!'>2!"?"4E!'>2!a5KPE!(&-!'>2!

1%)+*#!('!+(/H2J!K12#*A*#(++,E!*'!/20$+82-!'>('!'>2!7VW!9$%+-!&$'!)2!+*D*'2-!'$!(11+*#(&'0!9>$!>(-!

0%)D*''2-!1/$1$0(+0!-%/*&H!'>2!OSSS!C1/$$A!$A!#$&#21'F!/$%&-!(&-!'>('!2+*H*)+2!01$&0$/*&H!

$/H(&*I('*$&0!&22-!&$'!)2!&$'BA$/B1/$A*'!2&'*'*20J!V*&(++,E!*'!/20$+82-!'>('!(!A*&(+!82/0*$&!$A!'>2!7VW!

9$%+-!)2!1$0'2-!$&!@2#2D)2/![RE!OSSTE!*&#+%-*&H!(&!(11+*#('*$&!'*D2+*&2E!'>2!-2'(*+0!$A!'>2!

02+2#'*$&!#/*'2/*(E!(&-!(&!2Z1+(&('*$&!$A!'>2!28(+%('*$&!1/$#200JTc!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

29!3)*-J!K22!(+0$!34"55E!C3&-212&-2&'!d8(+%('$/0!$A!0.?@!W/$1$0(+0EF!>''16ee*#(&&J$/He2&e'+-0e&29B0'+-B/A1e1(&2+J>'DJ!30!K22!d-9(/-!f(0)/$%#^E!CK1$&0$/2-!.?@!7VWEF!Q%&2!OcE!OSSTE!>''16ee>(0)/$%#^J$/He*#(&&eD$&'/2(+J>'D+J!31!34"55E!CW/2+*D*&(/,!721$/'6!72H%+(/!X22'*&H!$A!'>2!L$(/-!B!X$&'/Y(+EF!Q%&2!OcE!OSSTE!>''16ee999J*#(&&J$/He2&eD*&%'20e1/2+*DB/21$/'BOcb%&STJ>'DJ!32!34"55E!CK%)D*00*$&0!'$!'>2!0'+-B/A1B#$DD2&'0!A$/%DEF!>''16eeA$/%DJ*#(&&J$/HeD'HB#D'0e0'+-B/A1B#$DD2&'0eH2&2/(+e'>/2(-0J>'D+!\&$!-('2]J!33!34"55E!C"?"4!7201$&02!'$!'>2!W/$1$02-!0.?@!7VW!(&-!K%HH20'2-!W/*&#*1+20!A$/!529!.?@!W/$#20020EF!P#'$)2/!;E!OSSTE!>''16eeA$/%DJ*#(&&J$/HeD'HB#D'0e0'+-B/A1B#$DD2&'0eH2&2/(+eD0HSSSc<J>'D+J!34!34"55E!CW/2+*D*&(/,!721$/'6!K12#*(+!X22'*&H!$A!'>2!L$(/-EF!P#'$)2/![TE!OSSTE!>''16ee999J*#(&&J$/He2&eD*&%'20e1/2+*DB/21$/'B[T$#'STJ>'DJ!35!"0!$A!OSSTE!'>2!a5KP!)2#(D2!'>2!0%##200$/!'$!'>2!@5KPJ!K22!@5KP!92)0*'2E!>''16ee999J-&0$J$/HJ!36!34"55E!C34"55!L$(/-!720$+%'*$&0!*&!4(/'>(H2E!.%&*0*(EF!P#'$)2/!T[E!OSSTE!

>''16ee999J*#(&&J$/He2&e(&&$%&#2D2&'0e(-8*0$/,BT[$#'STJ>'DJ!.>2!A*&(+!82/0*$&!$A!'>2!0.?@!7VW!*0!(8(*+()+2!('!34"55E!C529!0.?@!"11+*#('*$&EF!@2#2D)2/![RE!OSSTE!>''16ee999J*#(&&J$/He2&e'+-0e&29B0'+-B/A1e&29B0'+-B(11+*#('*$&B1(/'(B[R-2#STJ>'DJ!

Page 99: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=!

!"#"#$$%&'()$*+,-,)./$0,+$"111$

34>!0%)?*''2-!*'0!@AAA!0.BC!1/$1$0(+!$&!>(/#D!EFG!HIIJ@!34>!&(?2-!'D2!K$&+*&2!(-%+'L

2&'2/'(*&?2&'!#$??%&*',M!(0!'D2!01$&0$/*&N!#$??%&*',G!-2O*&*&N!'D*0!#$??%&*',!(0!K'D$02!

*&-*8*-%(+0G!)%0*&20020G!(&-!2&'*'*20!'D('!1/$8*-2!02A%(++,L$/*2&'2-!*&O$/?('*$&G!02/8*#20G!$/!

1/$-%#'0!*&'2&-2-!O$/!#$&02&'*&N!(-%+'0!$/!O$/!'D2!#$??%&*',!*'02+O@MPQ!34>!&(?2-!'D2!

3&'2/&('*$&(+!R$%&-('*$&!O$/!S&+*&2!7201$&0*)*+*',!T3RRS7U!(0!*'0!01$&0$/*&N!$/N(&*V('*$&@P<!.D2!

/$+2!$O!3RRS7G!(!4(&(-*(&!&$&L1/$O*'G!9$%+-!)2!'$!1/$'2#'!#D*+-!0(O2',G!N%(/-!'D2!0(O2',!(&-!

1/*8(#,!$O!%02/0G!(&-!1/$?$'2!/201$&0*)+2!)%0*&200!1/(#'*#20!*&!'D2!(-%+'!*&-%0'/,@!"##$/-*&N!'$!

'D2!1/$1$0(+G!34>!*&'2&-2-!'$!-$&('2!(!#2/'(*&!1$/'*$&!$O!2(#D!-$?(*&!/2N*0'/('*$&!O22!'$!

1/$?$'2!3RRS7W0!1$+*#,?(X*&N!(&-!(-8$#(#,!2OO$/'0@P;!

!"#"2$$%&344()$567869$.:;$%:8<8./$3--+,7./$

S&!>(/#D!E;G!HIIJG!34"55!1%)+*#+,!(&&$%&#2-!'D('!*'!D(-!/2#*82-!'2&!0.BC!(11+*#('*$&0!*&!

/201$&02!'$!*'0!7RY6!@(0*(G!@#('G!@Z$)0G!@?(*+G!@?$)*G!@1$0'G!@'2+!T52'5%?)2/G!3&#UG!@'2+!T.2+&*#!B'-@UG!

@'/(82+G!(&-!@AAA@!.D*0!(&&$%&#2?2&'!*&#+%-2-!*&8*'('*$&0!'$!1$0'!#$??2&'0!$&!012#*O*#!1/$1$0(+0G!

*&!(--*'*$&!'$!(!0$+*#*'('*$&!O$/!N2&2/(+!1%)+*#!#$??2&'0@!3'!(+0$!&$'2-!'D('!'D2!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!

12/*$-!9$%+-!)2!$12&!-%/*&N!'D2!?$&'D!$O!"1/*+!HIIJ!(&-!'D('!(11+*#('*$&0!9$%+-!)2!/28*292-!

),!*&-212&-2&'!28(+%('$/0!)2N*&&*&N!*&!>(,!$O!'D('!,2(/@JI!

3&!?*-L[%+,!HIIJG!'D2!*&-212&-2&'!28(+%('$/0!02&'!/21$/'0!$&!'D2!'2&!(11+*#('*$&0!'$!34"55!

*&-*#('*&N!'D('!$&+,!@#('!(&-!@1$0'!0('*0O*2-!'D2!O%++!/(&N2!$O!28(+%('*$&!#/*'2/*(@JE!.D2!/21$/'!

-2#+(/2-!'D('!34>W0!1/$1$0(+!0('*0O*2-!'D2!'2#D&*#(+G!)%0*&200G!(&-!O*&(&#*(+!#/*'2/*(G!)%'!O2++!0D$/'!

$O!?22'*&N!'D2!01$&0$/0D*1!#/*'2/*(@JH!3&!1(/'*#%+(/G!'D2!/21$/'!0'('2-!'D('!K'D2!-*OO*#%+',!$O!

20'()+*0D*&N!(!#+2(&!-2O*&*'*$&!$O!(-%+'!#$&'2&'!?(X20!*'!2\%(++,!-*OO*#%+'!'$!20'()+*0D!'D2!#$&'$%/0!

$O!'D2!(-%+'!#$??%&*',@!.D2,!-2'2/?*&2-G!?$/2$82/G!'D('!34>!KD,1$'D20*V20!(!02'!$O!*&'2/20'0!$&!

)2D(+O!$O!(!#$??%&*',!@!@!@!)%'!+*''+2!'20'*?$&,!O/$?!'D('!#$??%&*',!D(0!)22&!1/$8*-2-!*&!0%11$/'!

$O!2*'D2/!*'0!#$??$&!*&'2/20'0!$/!*'0!#$D20*82&200@MJP!R*&(++,G!'D2!28(+%('$/0!&$'2!'D('!(+'D$%ND!

'D2/2!9(0!0*N&*O*#(&'!0%11$/'!O$/!'D2!1/$1$0(+!O/$?!'D2!5$/'D!"?2/*#(&!#$??%&*',G!K8*/'%(++,!&$!

0%11$/'!9(0!(8(*+()+2!O/$?!'D2!/20'!$O!'D2!9$/+-@MJJ!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

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`H_@!

Page 100: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<!

34"55!(&&$%&#2-!'=('!*'!9$%+-!(++$9!0.>?!(11+*#(&'0!'$!1/$8*-2!0%11+2@2&'(+!@('2/*(+!*&!

/201$&02!'$!'=2!*&-212&-2&'!28(+%('$/0A!#$&#2/&0BCD!E/$@!F#'$)2/!'=/$%G=!5$82@)2/!HIICJ!34K!

0%)@*''2-!(!/(&G2!$L!0%11+2@2&'(+!(11+*#('*$&!@('2/*(+J!1/*@(/*+,!(--/200*&G!'=2!BMMM!1/$1$0(+A0!

-2L*#*2&#*20!/2G(/-*&G!01$&0$/0=*1!#/*'2/*(BCN!

!""#$%&'%()($*"&+"*,("-./"0$"*,("1222"34&5(66"

!"#$%&'$()*'$)+$,&'$-./$01$2/.33$

"##$/-*&G!'$!'=2!34"55!O,+(90J47!$&2!$L!'=2!1/*@(/,!1%/1$020!$L!'=2!P$82/&@2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!

4$@@*''22!QP"4R!*0!'$!S#$&0*-2/!(&-!1/$8*-2!(-8*#2!$&!'=2!(#'*8*'*20!$L!34"55!(0!'=2,!/2+('2!'$!

#$&#2/&0!$L!G$82/&@2&'0J!1(/'*#%+(/+,!@(''2/0!9=2/2!'=2/2!@(,!)2!(&!*&'2/(#'*$&!)2'922&!

34"55A0!1$+*#*20!(&-!8(/*$%0!+(90J!(&-!*&'2/&('*$&(+!(G/22@2&'0!$/!9=2/2!'=2,!@(,!(LL2#'!1%)+*#!

1$+*#,!*00%20BT48!!

.=2!P"4!@(,!0%)@*'!S*00%20!'$!'=2!O$(/-!-*/2#'+,J!2*'=2/!),!9(,!$L!#$@@2&'!$/!1/*$/!(-8*#2J!$/!

),!9(,!$L!012#*L*#(++,!/2#$@@2&-*&G!(#'*$&!$/!&29!1$+*#,!-282+$1@2&'!$/!/28*0*$&!'$!2M*0'*&G!

1$+*#*20BT49!"1(/'!L/$@!/2#2*8*&G!%&0$+*#*'2-!(-8*#2!$/!#$@@2&'J!'=2!O$(/-!*0!/2U%*/2-!'$!S&$'*L,!

'=2!4=(*/!$L!'=2!P"4!*&!(!'*@2+,!@(&&2/!$L!(&,!1/$1$0(+!/(*0*&G!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20!$&!9=*#=!*'!$/!

(&,!$L!34"55A0!0%11$/'*&G!$/G(&*V('*$&0!022W0!1%)+*#!#$@@2&'BT50!X21(/('2+,J!'=2!O$(/-!*0!

/2U%*/2-!'$!S/2U%20'!'=2!$1*&*$&T!$L!'=2!P"4!*&!#(020!9=2/2!S1$+*#,!(#'*$&!(LL2#'0!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!

#$&#2/&0T!(&-!'=2!1$+*#,!)2*&G!#$&0*-2/2-!L$/!(-$1'*$&!S0%)0'(&'*(++,!(LL2#'Y0Z!'=2!$12/('*$&!$L!

'=2!3&'2/&2'!$/!'=*/-!1(/'*20BT51!

72G(/-+200!$L!9=2'=2/!0$+*#*'2-!$/!&$'J!(&,!P"4!(-8*#2!S$&!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!@(''2/0T!'/*GG2/0!(!

O,+(9!1/$8*0*$&!9=2/2),!'=2!O$(/-!*0!/2U%*/2-!'$!'(W2!0%#=!(-8*#2!*&'$!(##$%&'!S)$'=!*&!'=2!

L$/@%+('*$&!(&-!(-$1'*$&!$L!1$+*#*20BT52!3L!'=2!O$(/-!-2#*-20!&$'!'$!L$++$9!'=*0!(-8*#2J!'=2!O$(/-!

*0!'=2&!/2U%*/2-!'$!&$'*L,!'=2!P"4!(&-!S0'('2!'=2!/2(0$&0!9=,!*'!-2#*-2-!&$'!'$!-$!0$T!(&-!S'/,J!*&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

45!34"55J!S34"55!K22'*&G0!*&![%(+(!>%@1%/JT!\%+,!H]J!HIICJ!=''16^^999B*#(&&B$/G^2&^@22'*&G0^W%(+(+%@1%/^#(1'*$&*&G_1%)+*#_L$/%@_H]`%+ICB='@B!46!34"55J!S"112&-*M!a!b!X%11+2@2&'(+^E$++$9_%1!K('2/*(+0JT!5$82@)2/!]IJ!HIIDJ!=''16^^999B*#(&&B$/G^2&^'+-0^0'+-_(110_c;@(/IC^"11a_]I&$8IDB1-LB!47!34"55!O,+(90J!"%G%0'!DJ!HIcIJ!=''16^^999B*#(&&B$/G^2&^G2&2/(+^),+(90B='@B!34"55A0!O,+(90!=(82!)22&!(@2&-2-!HN!'*@20!L/$@!'=2!$/*G*&(+!O,+(90B!"/#=*820!$L!1/28*$%0!82/0*$&0!(/2!(8(*+()+2!$&!'=2!34"55!92)0*'2!('!=''16^^999B*#(&&B$/G^2&^G2&2/(+^(/#=*82_),+(90B!48!3)*-BJ!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcQ(RB!34"55A0!$/*G*&(+!O,+(90!-*-!&$'!*&#+%-2!'=2!1=/(02!S9=2/2!'=2,!@(,!(LL2#'!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20JT!9=*#=!9(0!(112&-2-!'$!'=2!$/*G*&(+!*&!HIIHB!34"55!O,+(90J!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcQ(RJ!5$82@)2/!NJ!c;;eJ!=''16^^999B*#(&&B$/G^2&^G2&2/(+^(/#=*82_),+(90^),+(90_IN&$8;eB='@B!49!3)*-BJ!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcQ*RB!3'!*0!%&#+2(/!9=2'=2/!'=2!'2/@0!S#$@@2&'T!(&-!S(-8*#2T!(/2!-*0'*&#'!#$&#21'0!(&-!(/2!*&'2&-2-!'$!=(82!-*LL2/2&'!@2(&*&GB!!50!3)*-BJ!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcQ=RB!51!3)*-BJ!"/'*#+2!333J!X2#'*$&!NBcQ#RB!"+'=$%G=!'=*0!1/$8*0*$&!-$20!%02!'=2!'2/@!S(-8*#2JT!9=*#=!),!*'02+L!*0!#$&0*0'2&'!9*'=!'=2!%02!*&!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcf!S(-8*#2T!(112(/0!'$!)2!%02-!*&'2/#=(&G2()+,!9*'=!S$1*&*$&BT!4$&02U%2&'+,J!'=2!1/2#*02!0#$12!$L!'=*0!1/$8*0*$&!*0!%&#+2(/J!2012#*(++,!9*'=!/2G(/-!'$!=$9!*'!*&'2/1+(,0!9*'=!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcB!52!3)*-BJ!"/'*#+2!d3J!X2#'*$&!HBcQ`RB!g&+*W2!'=2!$'=2/!1/$8*0*$&0!*&!"/'*#+2!d3J!'=*0!1/$8*0*$&!%020!'=2!'2/@!S(-8*#2!$L!'=2!

P$82/&@2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$@@*''22T!2M1+*#*'+,B!.=*0!(112(/0!'$!0%GG20'!'=('!'=2!#*/#%@0'(&#20!9=2/2!'=2!O$(/-A0!/2U%*/2@2&'!'$!G*82!&$'*#2!(&-!2M1+(&('*$&!$L!(#'*$&0!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'=!(-8*#2!*0!+*@*'2-f!=$9282/J!*'!*0!0$@29=('!%&#+2(/!*L!'=('!9(0!'=2!*&'2&-2-!1%/1$02!$L!'=*0!1/$8*0*$&B!

Page 101: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<<=!

>$$-!?(*'@!(&-!*&!(!'*A2+,!(&-!2??*#*2&'!A(&&2/B!'$!?*&-!(!A%'%(++,!(##21'()+2!0$+%'*$&CD53!3?!&$!

0$+%'*$&!*0!/2(#@2-!)2'922&!'@2!E$(/-!(&-!'@2!F"4B!'@2!E$(/-!*0!/2G%*/2-!'$!H0'('2!*&!*'0!?*&(+!

-2#*0*$&!'@2!/2(0$&0!9@,D!'@2!(-8*#2!9(0!&$'!?$++$92-C!

.@2!34"55!E,+(90!(+0$!12/A*'!'@2!F"4!'$!H(11$*&'!$&2!&$&I8$'*&>!+*(*0$&!'$!'@2!34"55!E$(/-!$?!

J*/2#'$/0CD54!.@2!F"4!K*(*0$&!'$!'@2!E$(/-!*0!H2&'*'+2-!'$!(''2&-!E$(/-!L22'*&>0B!1(/'*#*1('2!*&!

E$(/-!-*0#%00*$&0!(&-!-2+*)2/('*$&0CD!.@2!K*(*0$&!@(0!H(##200!M%&-2/!#$&-*'*$&0!20'()+*0@2-!),!

'@2!E$(/-N!'$!A('2/*(+0!1/$8*-2-!'$!J*/2#'$/0!?$/!%02!*&!E$(/-!-*0#%00*$&0D!(&-!A(,!H%02!(&,!

A('2/*(+0!1/$8*-2-!'$!'@2A!1%/0%(&'!'$!'@*0!O2#'*$&!?$/!'@2!1%/1$02!$?!#$&0%+'*&>!9*'@!'@2*/!

/2012#'*82!#$AA*''22CD55!.@2!*&-*8*-%(+!2+2#'2-!(0!'@2!F"4!4@(*/!@(0!)22&!#$&0*0'2&'+,!(11$*&'2-!

'$!'@2!1$0*'*$&!$?!F"4!K*(*0$&!'$!'@2!E$(/-!@(0!#$&0*0'2&'+,!"+'@$%>@!&$'!-20#/*)2-!9*'@*&!'@2!

34"55!E,+(90!$/!'@2!F"4!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20B 56!*&'2/8*29220!0'('2-!'@('!'@2!F"4!K*(*0$&!'$!'@2!

E$(/-!*0!>2&2/(++,!2R12#'2-!'$!)/*2?!'@2!E$(/-!$&!*00%20!$?!#$&#2/&!(A$&>0'!F"4!A2A)2/0C57!3&!

(--*'*$&B!*&'2/8*29220!*&-*#('2-!'@('!'@2!E$(/-!)2+*2820!'@2!1/202&#2!$?!'@2!F"4!4@(*/!('!E$(/-!

L22'*&>0B!282&!*?!*&!'@2!#(1(#*',!$?!(!K*(*0$&!'$!'@2!E$(/-B!0('*0?*20!'@2!H&$'*?*#('*$&D!/2G%*/2A2&'!

?$/!1/$1$0(+0!/(*0*&>!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20!9*'@$%'!(--*'*$&(+!#$AA%&*#('*$&0C58!P'@2/!

*&'2/8*29220!G%20'*$&2-!'@*0!1/(#'*#2!(&-!0'('2-!'@('!'@*0!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$?!'@2!E,+(90!9(0!&$'!

0@(/2-!),!F"4!A2A)2/0C59!

"##$/-*&>!'$!'@2!F"4!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20B!'@2!F"4!(-8*020!'@2!E$(/-!$&!A(''2/0!/2+('*&>!'$!

H>$82/&A2&'0B!A%+'*&('*$&(+!>$82/&A2&'!$/>(&*S('*$&0!(&-!'/2(',!$/>(&*S('*$&0B!(&-!-*0'*&#'!

2#$&$A*20!(0!/2#$>&*S2-!*&!*&'2/&('*$&(+!?$/(CD60!.@2!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20!/2?+2#'!'@2!F"4T0!

*&'2/&(+!$12/('*&>!1/*&#*1+20!(&-!1/$#2-%/20B!@$9282/B!'@2!(/'*#%+('*$&0!9*'@*&!'@*0!-$#%A2&'!

(/2!&$'!&2#200(/*+,!)*&-*&>!$&!'@2!34"55!E$(/-C61!.@2!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20!012#*?*#(++,!0'('2!'@('!

H(-8*#2!?/$A!'@2!F"4!'$!'@2!E$(/-!*0!#$AA%&*#('2-!'@/$%>@!'@2!4@(*/CD62!U@2&!'@2!F"4!*0!

%&()+2!'$!/2(#@!(!#$&02&0%0B!'@2!4@(*/!*0!/2G%*/2-!'$!H#$&82,!'@2!?%++!/(&>2!$?!8*29!2R1/2002-!),!

L2A)2/0!'$!'@2!E$(/-CD63!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

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

*&'2/1/2'('*$&!)2'922&!'@2!1/*&#*1+20!02'!$%'!*&!'@202!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20!(&-!34"55T0!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!E,+(90CD!O22!(+0$!F"4!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20B!"/'*#+2!VYB!Q/*&#*1+2![^C!57!3&'2/8*290B!O21'2A)2/!(&-!P#'$)2/!W<;<C!58!3)*-C!59!3)*-C!60!F"4!P12/('*&>!Q/*&#*1+20B!"/'*#+2!3B!Q/*&#*1+2!;B!L(/#@!W<;<C!61!3)*-CB!"/'*#+2!VYB!Q/*&#*1+2![^C!62!3)*-CB!"/'*#+2!V33B!Q/*&#*1+2!^_C!63!3)*-CB!"/'*#+2!V33B!Q/*&#*1+2!^`C!

Page 102: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<;=!

!"!##$%&#'()&#(*#+%&#,-.#/0#+%&#"111#23(4&556#!778!

>2'922&!34?@0!0%)A*00*$&!$B!*'0!CDDD!1/$1$0(+!$&!?(/#E!;FG!H<<I!(&-!'E2!0%)A*00*$&!$B!'E2!

*&-212&-2&'!28(+%('$/0@!/21$/'!$&!J%+,!;KG!H<<IG!'E2/2!*0!+*''+2!-$#%A2&'2-!-*0#%00*$&!$B!'E2!

0.LM!(11+*#('*$&0!-%/*&N!34"55!>$(/-!(&-!O"4!A22'*&N0CPI!Q$++$9*&N!/2#2*1'!$B!'E*0!/21$/'G!'E2!

>$(/-!-2'2/A*&2-!'E('!0.LM!(11+*#(&'0!9$%+-!)2!12/A*''2-!'$!0%)A*'!0%11+2A2&'(+!*&B$/A('*$&!

'$!(--/200!'E2!28(+%('$/0@!#$&#2/&0G!)2N*&*&N!*&!"%N%0'!H<<IC!34?!)2N(&!0%)A*''*&N!

0%11+2A2&'(+!A('2/*(+0!*&!R#'$)2/!H<<ICPS!!

R&!R#'$)2/!;TG!H<<IG!'E2!34"55!>$(/-!E2+-!'E2!B*/0'!A22'*&N!0*&#2!J%+,!H<<I!-%/*&N!9E*#E!(!

-*0#%00*$&!$B!'E2!0.LM0!9(0!-$#%A2&'2-C!.E2!#$//201$&-*&N!A22'*&N!A*&%'20!*&-*#('2!'E('!UV%/'!

W/*'XG!'E2!34"55!Y*#2!W/20*-2&'!$B!>%0*&200!R12/('*$&0ZG[!1/$8*-2-!(!-2'(*+2-!0%AA(/,!$B!'E2!

#%//2&'!1/$#200!$B!(&-!0'('%0!/2N(/-*&N!'E2!'2&!01$&0$/2-!'$1\+282+!-$A(*&!(11+*#(&'0]!(&-!W(%+!

.9$A2,G!34"55@0!W/20*-2&'!(&-!4^RG!(+0$!1/$8*-2-!*&B$/A('*$&!$&!'E2!0.LM!(11+*#(&'0CPP!

?$E(A2-!_E(/*+!.(/A*X*G!4E(*/A(&!$B!'E2!O"4G!9(0!1/202&'!-%/*&N!'E*0!A22'*&N!(0!'E2!UO"4!

L*(*0$&C]P`!5$!#$//201$&-*&N!/20$+%'*$&0!92/2!A(-2!),!'E2!>$(/-!('!'E*0!A22'*&NCPT!"&$'E2/!

A22'*&N!9(0!E2+-!$&!5$82A)2/!;SG!H<<ICPF!.E2!A*&%'20!&$'2!'E('!UV%/'!W/*'X!(N(*&!1/$8*-2-!(&!

%1-('2!$&!'E2!0'('%0!$B!'E2!1/$#200!B$/!2(#E!$B!'E2!'2&!Z0.LM[!(11+*#(&'0G]!(&-!'E2/2!9(0!(!

U+*A*'2-!-*0#%00*$&!),!'E2!>$(/-!/2N(/-*&N!'E2!1/$#200!1$*&'0G]!)%'!&$!/20%+'*&N!/20$+%'*$&0C`<!

3&!(!B*82\1(N2!+2''2/!'$!.(/A*X*G!-('2-!M2#2A)2/!;G!H<<IG!M/C!.9$A2,!/2a%20'2-!U*&1%'!B/$A!'E2!

O"4!$&!'E2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!2+2A2&'0]!$&!0282/(+!*00%20!12&-*&N!)2B$/2!'E2!>$(/-C`;!.9$A2,!(+0$!

$)02/82/-!'E('G!U*'!022A0!'$!A2!'E('!'E2!*&'2/(#'*$&!)2'922&!'E2!O"4!(&-!34"55!0'(BB!9$%+-!

A2/*'!B/$A!0$A2!*&#/2(02!*&!*&'2&0*',]!(&-!0%NN20'2-!U20'()+*0EZ*&N[!(!O"4!1$0*'*$&!B$/!

'/(&0A*00*$&!'$!'E2!>$(/-!$&!'E2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!2+2A2&'0]!$B!*00%20!12&-*&N!)2B$/2!'E2!34"55!

>$(/-C`H!.9$A2,!(+0$!&$'2-!*&!'E*0!+2''2/!'E('!U*'!A(,!)2!9$/'E9E*+2!#$&0*-2/*&N!E$9!'E2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

64!>2'922&!?(/#E!(&-!J%+,!H<<IG!)$'E!'E2!>$(/-!(&-!'E2!O"4!E2+-!A22'*&N0G!)%'!-*-!&$'!-*0#%00!'E2!0.LM!(11+*#('*$&0!*&!

0*N&*B*#(&'!-2'(*+C!.E2!>$(/-!E2+-!A22'*&N0!$&!"1/*+!;FG!?(,!;;G!?(,!H;G!?(,!HSG!(&-!J%&2!HFG!H<<IC!_22!34"55G!UH<<I!>$(/-!?22'*&N!?*&%'20G]!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&bA*&%'20b*&-2D\H<<ICE'A+C!.E2!O"4!E2+-!A22'*&N0!$&!Q2)/%(/,!HF!c!?(/#E!KG!(&-!J%+,!;`!c!H<G!H<<IC!_22!O"4G!UO"4!?22'*&N0G]!E''16bbN(#C*#(&&C$/NbA22'*&N0C!_22!34"55G!U_'('%0!721$/'!$&!'E2!0.LM!^8(+%('*$&!W/$#200G]!M2#2A)2/!KG!H<<SG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&b'+-0b0'+-\(110\;FA(/<Ib0'+-\0'('%0\/21$/'C1-Bd!3&-212&-2&'!^8(+%('$/0G!U^8(+%('*$&!721$/'!$&!529!0.LM!"11+*#('*$&0G]!J%+,!;HG!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&b'+-0b0'+-\(110\;FA(/<IbW$0'"11MC1-BC!65!!34"55G!U"112&-*D!^!c!_%11+2A2&'(+bQ$++$9\%1!?('2/*(+0G]!5$82A)2/G!K<G!H<<SG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&b'+-0b0'+-\(110\;FA(/<Ib"11^\K<&$8<SC1-BC!!66!34"55G!U_12#*(+!?22'*&N!$B!'E2!>$(/-!?*&%'20G]!R#'$)2/!;TG!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&bA*&%'20bA*&%'20\;T$#'<ICE'AC!67!3)*-C!"!+*(*0$&!'$!'E2!>$(/-!*0!(!&$&\8$'*&N!A2A)2/G!9E$!*0!12/A*''2-!'$!(''2&-!>$(/-!A22'*&N0C!.E2!>,+(90!012#*B,!'E('!'E2!O"4!A%0'!(11$*&'!'E2!1$0*'*$&!$B!+*(*0$&!(&&%(++,C!_22!34"55!>,+(90!"/'C!Y3C!_2#C!FC!!68!34"55G!U_12#*(+!?22'*&N!$B!'E2!>$(/-!?*&%'20G]!R#'$)2/!;TG!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&bA*&%'20bA*&%'20\;T$#'<ICE'AC!68!34"55G!U_12#*(+!?22'*&N!$B!'E2!>$(/-!?*&%'20G]!R#'$)2/!;TG!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&bA*&%'20bA*&%'20\;T$#'<ICE'AC!!69!34"55G!U_12#*(+!?22'*&N!$B!'E2!>$(/-!?*&%'20G]!5$82A)2/!;SG!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb2&bA*&%'20bA*&%'20\;S&$8<ICE'AC!!70!3)*-C!71!W(%+!.9$A2,!'$!?$E(A2-!_E(/*+!.(/A*X*G!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2G!M2#2A)2/G!;!H<<IG!E''16bb999C*#(&&C$/Nb#$//201$&-2&#2b'9$A2,\'$\'(/A*X*\<;-2#<IC1-BC!!72!3)*-C!

Page 103: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

*&'2/(#'*$&!#$%+-!)2!*&#/2(02-!)2'922&!'?2!@"4!(&-!'?2!$'?2/!A%11$/'*&B!C/B(&*D('*$&0!(&-!

"-8*0$/,!4$EE*''220!F$/!'?2!E%'%(+!)2&2F*'!$F!)$'?!0*-20GHIJ!!

.?2!&2K'!02#'*$&!$F!'?*0!+2''2/!+(*-!$%'!'?2!*00%20!12&-*&B!)2F$/2!'?2!L$(/-!F$/!9?*#?!.9$E2,!

/2M%20'2-!@"4!*&1%'G!3&!'?2!F$++$9*&B!1(/(B/(1?N!.9$E2,!$%'+*&2-!'?2!0'('%0!$F!'?2!0.OP!

(11+*#('*$&06!

!"#$$%&'()*(+,-%)'%.'/,%0'12314%'(%)51,,%678%01'()-%*(%)5,%31,3%'0%!"#"$%&'()*+,"-".'

/)01%#29%:*1-)%'0%3;;<%0';;'2*(=%)5,%>?%3@@;*&3)*'(-%0'1%(,2%-@'(-'1,4%ABCD-%6-ABC-8%3(4%

)5,%,/3;+3)*'(%'0%)5,*1%E*4-%EF%*(4,@,(4,()%,/3;+3)'1-<%2,%53/,%&'..,(&,4%&'()13&)%

(,=')*3)*'(-%2*)5%)5,%3@@;*&3()-%0'1%9AG#HIB%3(4%9JKLA9%!(%@313;;,;<%)5,%3@@;*&3()-%31,%

1,-@'(4*(=%)'%)5,%1,@'1)-%'0%)5,%*(4,@,(4,()%,/3;+3)'1-<%3(4%*(%-'.,%*(-)3(&,%53/,%,(),1,4%

*()'%4*1,&)%4*-&+--*'(-%2*)5%)5,%,/3;+3)*'(%@3(,;-%*(%'14,1%)'%&;31*0F%-'.,%*--+,-9%#(F%

'+)-)3(4*(=%*--+,-%E,)2,,(%)5,%*(4,@,(4,()%@3(,;-%3(4%)5,%3@@;*&3()-%2*;;%E,%1,-';/,4%EF%

!"#$$D-%M'314%3(4%2,%,N@,&)%)'%.'/,%)'2314-%&'()13&)%(,=')*3)*'(-%2*)5%-'.,%')5,1%

3@@;*&3()-%3-%2,;;9%L,&'(4;F<%!"#$$%*-%3E'+)%)'%;3+(&5%)5,%1,OE*4%'0%)5,%9$IA%3=1,,.,()%3-%

0'1,-,,(%*(%)5,%1,;,/3()%&'()13&)9%P#"%.,.E,1-%&3(%0';;'2%)5,%@1'&,--%/*3%)5,%*(0'1.3)*'(%

2,%@'-)%)'%)5,%!"#$$%2,EO-*),9%A5*14;F<%3-%.,()*'(,4<%2,%53/,%@+E;*-5,4%)5,%4130)%'0%3%

L)13),=F%0'1%)5,%!()1'4+&)*'(%'0%$,2%=ABCD-9QR%%

345''(6"'7)."')8'96"':;<'%#'96"'4==='>$)&"22?'3@@A'

P201*'2!/2#2*8*&B!(!&%E)2/!$F!0%11+2E2&'(+!E('2/*(+0!F/$E!34Q!*&!0%11$/'!$F!*'0!(11+*#('*$&!*&!

+('2!=<<RN!(0!$F!2(/+,!=<<S!'?2!34"55!L$(/-!9(0!0'*++!%&#2/'(*&!'?('!34Q!?(-!0('*0F*2-!'?2!

/2M%*/2E2&'0!F$/!'?2!GKKK!0.OPG!C&!T(&%(/,!=RN!=<<SN!'?2!L$(/-!?2+-!(!012#*(+!E22'*&B!'$!-*0#%00!

'?2!0'('%0!$F!34QU0!(11+*#('*$&G!"'!'?*0!E22'*&BN!V%/'!W/*'D!X*&'/$-%#2-!'?2!GYYY!(11+*#('*$&!

E('2/*(+0N!28(+%('$/0U!/201$&020!(&-!'?2!(11+*#(&'U0!0%11+2E2&'(+!E('2/*(+0H!(&-!X'?2/2!9(0!

2K'2&0*82!L$(/-!-*0#%00*$&!/2B(/-*&B!'?2!(11+*#('*$&NH!F$#%02-!$&!34QU0!1/$1$02-!01$&0$/2-!

#$EE%&*',GIS!"##$/-*&B!'?2!E*&%'20N!'?2!L$(/-!-2'2/E*&2-!'?('!*'!9$%+-!)2!%02F%+!F$/!34Q!'$!

B*82!(!1/202&'('*$&!(&-!*&8*'2-!34Q!'$!-$!0$!('!(!+('2/!L$(/-!E22'*&BGIZ!34Q!-2+*82/2-!'?2!

1/202&'('*$&!$&!"1/*+!JN!=<<S!*&!Q(/!-2+!W+('(N!"/B2&'*&(N!(!F29!-(,0!1/*$/!'$!'?2!0#?2-%+2-!

34"55!L$(/-!E22'*&BNII!'$!(&!(%-*2&#2!$F!L$(/-!E2E)2/0!(&-!(!&%E)2/!$F!L$(/-!+*(*0$&0N!

*&#+%-*&B!.(/E*D*GI[!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

73!3)*-G!74!3)*-GN!R!\2E1?(0*0!*&!'?2!$/*B*&(+]G!75!34"55N!XA12#*(+!Q22'*&B!$F!'?2!L$(/-NH!T(&%(/,!=JN!=<<SN!?''16^^999G*#(&&G$/B^!2&^E*&%'20^E*&%'20_=R`(&<SG?'EG!!76!3)*-G!!77!.?2!34"55!L$(/-!?2+-!*'0!/2B%+(/!E22'*&B!*&!Q(/!-2+!W+('(N!"/B2&'*&(!$&!"1/*+![N!=<<SG!78!34QN!X72M%20'!F$/!37WNH!T%&2!ZN!=<<[N!('!=[N!?''16^^999G*#(&&G$/B^2&^*/1^*#E_8_*#(&&^*#E_*/1_/2M%20'_<Z`%&<[G1-FG!!

Page 104: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

4$&#%//2&'+,?!'@2!A"4!#$&82&2-!*&!B(/!-2+!C+('($&!"1/*+!DEF!*&!D<<F!G$/!'@2!G*/0'!$G!'@/22!

0#@2-%+2-!H22'*&I0!*&!D<<FJKL!.@2!B(/!-2+!C+('(!4$HH%&*M%N!-$20!&$'!*&-*#('2!'@('!'@2!A"4!

@2+-!(&,!-*0#%00*$&0!/2+('2-!'$!'@2!0.OP0!$/!'@2!JQQQ!(11+*#('*$&!012#*G*#(++,JR<!!

S&!"1/*+!=?!D<<F?R;!.(/H*T*!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!C(%+!.9$H2,!/201$&-*&I!'$!.9$H2,U0!1/28*$%0!

/2M%20'!G$/!A"4!*&1%'!$&!P2#2H)2/!;?!D<<VJRD!3&!'@*0!+2''2/?!.(/H*T*!0'('2-!'@('!'@2!A"4!@(-!&$!

$)W2#'*$&0!'$!(&,!$G!'@2!0.OP!(11+*#('*$&06!

!"#$%&#'(')(*+#,-.(#(/0*(++(1#+0(23432#*(+(*.-53"6+#"*#2"''(65+7#36#5,(#$%&7#-)"85#5,(#

-00932-53"6+#4"*#+:;<+#36#5,(#28**(65#*"861=#>"?(.(*#+,"891#+:;<+#8+(#@!AB7#5,-5#+,"891#

6"5#365(*4(*(#?35,#(+5-)93+,(1#365(*6-53"6-9#0"9323(+#4"*#5,(#@CDE#68')(*36F#+G+5('=#H&%!!#

+,"891#(6+8*(#5,-5#+0"6+"*+#"4#+:;<+#(62"'0-++#5,(#(653*(5G#"4#5,(#*(9(.-65#8+(*#

2"''8635G7#-61#5,-5#(.(658-9#13+5"*53"6+#"4#2"'0(5353"6#-*(#(44(253.(9G#-."31(1=IJ##

X$++$9*&I!'@2!"1/*+!=!012#*(+!Y$(/-!H22'*&I?!'@2!Y$(/-!H2'!(I(*&!G$/!(!/2I%+(/!H22'*&I!$&!"1/*+!

R?!D<<F!*&!B(/!-2+!C+('(JRV!.@2!H22'*&I!H*&%'20!/2G+2#'!'@('!'@2!Y$(/-!@$12-!'$!/2(#@!(!-2#*0*$&!

9*'@*&!'@*/',!-(,06!

K(#,-.(#,-1#-#4-3*9G#(/5(6+3.(#13+28++3"6#-)"85#=%LH%#-61#=MMM=#K(#2"65368(#5"#(.-98-5(#

5,"+(=#:,(#"5,(*+#?399#)(#-55(61(1#-+#?(#2-6#F(5#5"#5,('=#N857#H#?-65#5"#+-G#4"*#5,(#*(2"*17#

5,-5#?(#?399#-55('05#?35,36#5,(#6(/5#JO#1-G+#5"#2"'(#5"#-#2"6298+3"6#"6(#?-G#"*#5,(#"5,(*#

-)"85#=%LH%#-61#=MMM=IP###

"11/$Q*H('2+,!$&2!H$&'@!+('2/?!$&!B(,!=?!D<<F?!'@2!Y$(/-!@2+-!(&$'@2/!012#*(+!H22'*&I?!(&-!@(-!

(!Z)/$(-!-*0#%00*$&!J!J!J!9@2'@2/!$/!&$'!'@2![JQQQ!(11+*#('*$&\!H2'!'@2!#/*'2/*(!9*'@*&!'@2!7XC!

1(/'*#%+(/+,!/2+('*&I!'$!'@2!-2G*&*'*$&!(&-!#$@2/2&#2!$G!'@2!]01$&0$/2-!#$HH%&*',UJ^R_!5$!

#$&#+%0*$&!9(0!/2(#@2-!*&!'@202!H22'*&I0?!(&-!Z'@2!Y$(/-!(I/22-!*'!9$%+-!-*0#%00!'@*0!*00%2!

(I(*&!('!'@2!&2Q'!Y$(/-!H22'*&IJ^RK!

S&!`%&2!;?!D<<F?!'@2!Y$(/-!@2+-!(&$'@2/!012#*(+!H22'*&I!(&-!-*0#%002-!'@2!JQQQ!(11+*#('*$&!('!

+2&I'@!9*'@!(!Z1(/'*#%+(/!G$#%0!$&!'@2!]01$&0$/2-!#$HH%&*',U!*00%20J^!RR!"'!'@*0!H22'*&I?!'@2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

79!A"4?!ZB22'*&I!DD6!B(/!-2+!C+('(!4$HH%&*M%N?^!"1/*+!F?!D<<F?!@''16aaI(#J*#(&&J$/Ia0,0'2HaG*+20aA"4bDDbB(/b-2+bC+('(J1-GJ!.@2!$'@2/!H22'*&I0!0#@2-%+2-!G$/!D<<F!*&#+%-2-6!B22'*&I!D=6!O%Q2H)$%/I!$&!`%+,!Lc;D?!D<<F?!(&-!B22'*&I!DV6!d(&#$%82/!$&!5$82H)2/!DR!E!P2#2H)2/!;?!D<<FJ!4GJ!A"4?!ZB22'*&I0?^!@''16aaI(#J*#(&&J$/IaH22'*&I0J!80!3)*-J!81!.@2!34"55!H22'*&I!H*&%'20!$&!'@*0!-('2!(&-!'@2!.(/H*T*!+2''2/!-$!&$'!*&-*#('2!9@2'@2/!'@2!+2''2/!9(0!9/*''2&!(&-!02&'!)2G$/2!$/!(G'2/!'@2!Y$(/-!H22'*&I!$&!'@*0!-('2J!!82!B$@(H2-!e@(/*+!.(/H*T*!'$!C(%+!.9$H2,?!"1/*+!=?!D<<F?!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2?!@''16aa999J*#(&&J$/Ia#$//201$&-2&#2a'(/H*T*c'$c'9$H2,c<=(1/<FJ@'HJ!!83!3)*-J!!84!34"55?!ZB(/!P2+!C+('(!B22'*&I?^!"1/*+!R?!D<<F?!@''16aa999J*#(&&J$/Ia2&aH22'*&I0aH(/-2+1+('(a#(1'*$&*&IcY$PcH22'*&Ic<R(1/<FJ@'HJ!85!3)*-J!86!34"55?!Ze12#*(+!B22'*&I!$G!'@2!Y$(/-?^!B(,!=?!D<<F?!@''16aa999J*#(&&J$/Ia2&aH*&%'20aH*&%'20c<=H(,<FJ@'HJ!87!3)*-J!88!34"55?!Ze12#*(+!B22'*&I!$G!'@2!Y$(/-?^!`%&2!;?!D<<F?!@''16aa999J*#(&&J$/Ia2&aH*&%'20aH*&%'20c<;W%&<FJ@'HJ!

Page 105: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

?$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!2&'2/!*&'$!&2@$'*('*$&0!9*'A!34B!C$/!'A2!'2#A&*#(+!(&-!#$DD2/#*(+!'2/D0!$C!(!

#$&'/(#'%(+!(@/22D2&'!/2+('*&@!'$!'A2!-2+2@('*$&!$C!'A2!0.EFGHI!JA2'A2/!'A*0!/20$+%'*$&!*&-*#('2-!

'A('!34B!A(-!(-2K%('2+,!D2'!'A2!0.EF!01$&0$/0A*1!#/*'2/*(!+('2/!)2#(D2!(!C(#'%(+!-*01%'2!*&!'A2!

(/)*'/('*$&!1/$#22-*&@0!%&-2/!'A2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!L/$#200!)2@*&&*&@!*&!M<<HGI<!!

.A2!N"4!A2+-!*'0!02#$&-!D22'*&@!$C!'A2!,2(/!*&!E%O2D)$%/@!$&!P%+,!QR;MS!M<<TGI;!.A2!

E%O2D)$%/@!4$DD%&*K%U!-$20!&$'!012#*C*#(++,!D2&'*$&!34BV0!(11+*#('*$&S!'A2!1/$1$02-!GOOO!

0.EFS!$/!'A2!?$(/-V0!P%&2!;S!M<<T!/20$+%'*$&!'$!2&'2/!*&'$!#$&'/(#'!&2@('*$&0!9*'A!34BG!W$9282/S!

'A2!E%O2D)$%/@!4$DD%&*K%U!D(X20!'A2!C$++$9*&@!/2C2/2&#2!9*'A!/2@(/-!'$!Y&29!.EF0Z6!

!"#$%&'$()*#+$,-).$-#/#(*$#01#-2#(/#$*"3*$*"#$2(*-)45/*2)($),$(#6$!78+$/3($92:#$-2+#$*)$

+29(2,2/3(*$15;<2/$1)<2/=$2++5#+>$2(/<542(9$/)(*#(*?$&//)-42(9<=>$*"#$%&'$6#</).#+$*"#$

2(2*23*2:#$),$@'&AA$*)$")<4$/)(+5<*3*2)(+$62*"$-#+1#/*$*)$*"#$2.1<#.#(*3*2)($),$*"#$(#6$

!)1B<#:#<$8).32(+$+*-3*#9=?$!"#$%&'$<))C+$,)-63-4$*)$1-):242(9$34:2/#$*)$*"#$1-)/#++?$!"#$

%&'$3<+)$#(/)5-39#+$*"#$D)3-4$*)$3/*2:#<=$/)(+5<*$3<<$/)(+*2*5#(/2#+$62*"$-#93-4$*)$*"#$

4#:#<)1.#(*$),$*"2+$+*-3*#9=?EF$

.A*0!*0!'A2!$&+,!/2C2/2&#2!*&!'A2!E%O2D)$%/@!4$DD%&*K%U!'$!'A2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$C!&29!.EF0[!

'A2/2!(/2!&$!/2C2/2&#20!'$!0.EF0!012#*C*#(++,GI\!.A2!1A/(02!Y0*@&*C*#(&'!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20Z!*0!&$'!

-2C*&2-!C%/'A2/!*&!'A*0!-$#%D2&'GI=!

]$++$9*&@!'A2!E%O2D)$%/@!D22'*&@0S!'A2!34"55!?$(/-!D2'!*&!^21'2D)2/!(&-!/20$+82-!'A('!'A2!

34"55!N2&2/(+!4$%&02+!(&-!'A2!4_`!(&-!L/20*-2&'S!Y(/2!-*/2#'2-!'$!-*0#%00!1$00*)+2!(--*'*$&(+!

#$&'/(#'!1/$8*0*$&0!$/!D$-*C*#('*$&0!C$/!*&#+%-*$&!*&!'A2!GOOO!/2@*0'/,!(@/22D2&'Z!9A*#AS!(D$&@!

$'A2/!'A*&@0S!2&0%/2!'A2!Y-282+$1D2&'!(&-!*D1+2D2&'('*$&!$C!1$+*#*20!#$&0*0'2&'!9*'A!'A2!

1/*&#*1+20!*&!'A2!34B!(11+*#('*$&GZIT!.A2!34"55!?$(/-!1$0'2-!'A2!C*/0'!-/(C'!/2@*0'/,!(@/22D2&'!

C$/!'A2!GOOO!0.EF!$&!'A2!34"55!92)0*'2!C$/!1%)+*#!#$DD2&'!$&!"%@%0'!IS!M<<TGIa!!

.A/22!-(,0!+('2/S!$&!"%@%0'!;MS!*&!(!+2''2/!(--/2002-!'$!Y'A2!34"55!?$(/-SZ!.(/D*b*!2O1/2002-!'A2!

N"4V0!-*0#$DC$/'!9*'A!'A2!1$00*)*+*',!$C!(!GOOO!0.EF6!

@($)*"#-$%&'$+#++2)(+>$3$(5.;#-$),$)*"#-$9):#-(.#(*+$3<+)$#01-#++#4$+).#$/)(/#-($62*"$

*"#$1)*#(*23<$2(*-)45/*2)($),$*"2+$!78?$!"#$:2#6+$3-#$42:#-+#$3(4$624#$-3(92(9?$&<*")59"$

()*$(#/#++3-2<=$6#<<$3-*2/5<3*#4$2($750#.;)5-9>$3+$'"32-.3(>$@$;#<2#:#$*"#-#$-#.32(+$3$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

89!3)*-G!90!^22!34B!72K%20'!C$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!L/$#200S!P%&2!aS!M<<HS!A''16cc*#(&&G$/@c2&c*/1c*#Dd8d*#(&&c*#Dd*/1d/2K%20'd<ae%&<HG1-CG!!91!N"4S!YB22'*&@!M\6!E%O2D)$%/@!4$DD%&*K%USZ!P%+,!;MS!M<<TS!A''16cc@(#G*#(&&G$/@c0,0'2DcC*+20cN"4fM\fE%O2D)$%/@G1-CG!!92!3)*-G!93!3)*-G!94!3)*-G!95!34"55S!Y^12#*(+!B22'*&@!$C!'A2!?$(/-SZ!^21'2D)2/!;TS!M<<TS!A''16cc999G*#(&&G$/@c2&cD*&%'20cD*&%'20d;T021<TGA'DG!96!34B!(&-!34"55S!YGF/(C'!^1$&0$/2-!.EF!72@*0'/,!"@/22D2&'SZ!"%@%0'!;S!M<<TS!A''16cc999G*#(&&G$/@c2&c'+-0c(@/22D2&'0cOOOc1/$1$02-dOOOd(@D'd<I(%@<TG1-CG!!

Page 106: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!"#$%&'!(%!('$)'*+!,$-)$#"'+%'".('/01'23$4"'".('5678'%$"9+".!"2%*+%&'".('(:;<2%2"+$%!'"$'

*2"(=>?'''

.(/?*@*!-*0#+$02-!'A('!A2!A(-!)22&!B(11/$(#A2-!),!0$?2!$C!'A2!DE$82/&?2&'0!9*'A!#$&#2/&0FG!

(&-!A(-!B(-8*02-!'A2?!'A('!(1(/'!C/$?!'A2!(-8*#2!E*82&!*&!/2+('*$&!'$!'A2!#/2('*$&!$C!&29!E.HI0!

*&!'A2!H%J2?)$%E!4$??%&*K%L!'A('!*?1+*#*'+,!/2C2/0!'$!'A2!1/$1$02-!.HIM!0$82/2*E&!

E$82/&?2&'0!(/2!(+0$!C/22!'$!9/*'2!-*/2#+',!'$!34"55!()$%'!012#*C*#!#$&#2/&0NG!3&!'A2!0(?2!+2''2/M!

.(/?*@*!(+0$!(0O2-!'A2!P$(/-!'$!B(++$9!'*?2!C$/!(--*'*$&(+!E$82/&?2&'(+!(&-!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!

#$&#2/&0!'$!)2!2J1/2002-!)2C$/2!/2(#A*&E!(!C*&(+!-2#*0*$&NGQR!!

S$++$9*&E!'A*0M!T*#A(2+!U(++(EA2/M!"00*00'(&'!V2#/2'(/,!$C!'A2!WV!I21(/'?2&'!$C!4$??2/#2!(&-!

"-?*&*0'/('$/!$C!'A2!5.3"M!9/$'2!'$!X*&'!42/C!B'$!%/E2!'A2!P$(/-!'$!2&0%/2!'A('!'A2!#$&#2/&0!$C!(++!

?2?)2/0!A(82!)22&!(-2K%('2+,!A2(/-!(&-!/20$+82-!)2C$/2!'A2!P$(/-!'(O20!(#'*$&!$&!D'A2!NJJJF!

(11+*#('*$&NGQQ!.A2!34"55!92)0*'2Y0!B4$//201$&-2&#2G!1(E2;<<!#%//2&'+,!-('20!'A*0!+2''2/!"%E%0'!

;=M!Z<<=N;<;!.A2!1$0'2-!-*E*'(+!#$1,!$C!'A*0!+2''2/!A(0!'9$!-('2!0'(?10!$&!*'6!"%E%0'!;;!(&-!

B/2#2*82-!"%E%0'!;=NG;<Z!.A*0!+2''2/!(--*'*$&(++,!&$'2-!'A('!'A2!I21(/'?2&'!$C!4$??2/#2!A(-!

/2#2*82-!(!+(/E2!&%?)2/!$C!&2E('*82!#$??2&'0!C/$?!'A2!1%)+*#!/2E(/-*&E!'A2!1/$1$02-!0.HIN;<[!

\&!"%E%0'!;=M!'A2!0(?2!-(,!'A2!U(++(EA2/!+2''2/!9(0!1$0'2-!'$!34"55Y0!92)0*'2M!34T!$CC*#*(++,!

/2K%20'2-!(&!(--*'*$&(+!?$&'A!'$!(++$9!34"55!'$!(--/200!'A2!#$&#2/&0!/(*02-!),!'A2!U"4N;<]!

4$&02K%2&'+,M!#$&0*-2/('*$&!$C!'A2!1/$1$02-!(E/22?2&'!9(0!1$0'1$&2-!%&'*+!'A2!V21'2?)2/!

Z<<=!P$(/-!?22'*&EN;<=!

\&!V21'2?)2/!^M!Z<<=M!T(/#2+$!-2!4(/(+A$!H$120M!'A2!V2#/2'(/,!$C!3&C$/?('*$&!.2#A&$+$E,!_$+*#,!

$C!P/(@*+M!9/$'2!'$!T$A(?2-!VA(/*+!.(/?*@*!(&-!0'('2-!'A('!B0*E&*C*#(&'!*?1(#'0!*&!+$#(+!#$&#2/&0!

A(82!)22&!*&'/$-%#2-!D(0!(!/20%+'!$C!'A2!NJJJ!1/$1$0(+F!9*'A$%'!(-2K%('2!#$&0%+'('*$&!9*'A!

&('*$&(+!E$82/&?2&'0NG;<^!H$120!(+0$!/2K%20'2-!'A('!B(&,!&29!-2#*0*$&!#$&#2/&*&E!'A2!

*&'/$-%#'*$&!$C!(&,!$'A2/!.HI0!0A$%+-!$&+,!)2!'(O2&!(C'2/!(!#(/2C%+!(&(+,0*0!$C!'A2!/2(+!&22-!C$/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

97!T$A(?2-!VA(/*+!.(/?*@*!'$!34"55!P$(/-M!!"%E%0'!;ZM!Z<<=M!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2`'(/?*@*a'$a)$(/-a;Z(%E<=NA'?N!!98!!3)*-N!!99!T*#A(2+!U(++(EA2/!'$!X*&'!42/CM!"%E%0'!;=M!Z<<=M!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2M!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2`E(++(EA2/a'$a#2/Ca;=(%E<=N1-CN!100!34"55M!B4$//201$&-2&#2MG!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2N!101!3)*-N!102!I%/*&E!'A2!P2/O?(&!'2(?Y0!*&'2/8*29!1/$#200M!0$?2!*&'2/8*29220!&$'2-!'A2/2!9(0!#$&C%0*$&!(0!'$!9A2'A2/!'A2!+2''2/!9(0!/2#2*82-!$&!"%E%0'!;;!$/!$&!"%E%0'!;=M!Z<<=N!4$?1(/2!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2`E(++(EA2/a'$a#2/Ca;=(%E<=N1-C!9*'A!'A2!4$//201$&-2&#2!_(E2!-('26!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2N!!103!3)*-N!!104!V'%(/'!H(9+2,!'$!X*&'!42/CM!"%E%0'!;=M!Z<<=M!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2M!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2`+(9+2,a'$a'9$?2,a;=(%E<=N1-CN!V22!(+0$!34TM!B72K%20'!C$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!_/$#200MG!b%&2!^M!Z<;<M!1![]M!A''16``*#(&&N$/E`2&`*/1`*#?a8a*#(&&`*#?a*/1a/2K%20'a<^c%&<RN1-CN!!105!3)*-N!!106!T(/#2+$!-2!4(/8(+A$!H$120!'$!T$A(?2-!VA(/*+!.(/?*@*M!V21'2?)2/!^M!Z<<=M!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2M!A''16``999N*#(&&N$/E`#$//201$&-2&#2`+$12@a'$a'(/?*@*a<^021<=N1-CN!!

Page 107: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

0%#?!*&'/$-%#'*$&!9*'?*&!'?2!3&'2/&2'!(&-!-%2!#$&0%+'('*$&@!9*'?!(++!(AA2#'2-!1(/'*20!(&-!

B$82/&C2&'0D;<E!!

3&!(!012#*(+!C22'*&B!$&!F21'2C)2/!;GH!I<<GH!'?2!J$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!#$&'*&%2!-*0#%00*$&0!9*'?!34K!

(&-!'$!(--/200!L(--*'*$&(+!1/$8*0*$&0!$/!C$-*A*#('*$&0!A$/!*&#+%0*$&@!*&!'?2!(B/22C2&'!L'$!2&0%/2!

'?2/2!(/2!2AA2#'*82!1/$8*0*$&0!/2M%*/*&B!-282+$1C2&'!(&-!*C1+2C2&'('*$&!$A!1$+*#*20!#$&0*0'2&'!

9*'?!'?2!1/*&#*1+20!*&!'?2!34K!(11+*#('*$&D@;<N!O&!F21'2C)2/!;=H!P2'2/!Q(&B+H!R21%',!R*/2#'$/!$A!

'?2!S%/$12(&!4$CC*00*$&T0!3&A$/C('*$&!F$#*2',H!K2-*(!R*/2#'$/('2!U2&2/(+!(&-!(!C2C)2/!$A!'?2!

U"4H!9/$'2!'$!V*&'!42/A!(&-!(0W2-!34"55!'$!(++$9!'?2!U"4!'$!/28*29!'?2!*&-212&-2&'!28(+%('$/0T!

/21$/'0!$&!'?2!0.XR!1/$1$0(+0!)2A$/2!'?2!J$(/-!/2(#?2-!(!A*&(+!-2#*0*$&!$&!DYYYD!Q(&B+!(+0$!

/2M%20'2-!'?('!'?2!34"55!J$(/-!2Y1+(*&!'?2*/!/2(0$&0!A$/!(##21'*&B!'?2!34KT0!(11+*#('*$&!*&!

/201$&02!'$!'?2!I<<Z!7[P!/$%&-!(A'2/!*'!9(0!-2&*2-!*&!'?2!I<<<!L1/$$A!$A!#$&#21'@!/$%&-D;<\!"!

/201$&02!'$!'?*0!+2''2/!9(0!&$'!*00%2-!%&'*+!C*-]^(&%(/,!I<<=D;;<!

"+'?$%B?!'?2!1/$1$02-!DYYY!/2B*0'/,!(B/22C2&'!9(0!(B(*&!$&!'?2!(B2&-(!A$/!-*0#%00*$&!('!'?2!

012#*(+!C22'*&B!$A!'?2!J$(/-!?2+-!$&!O#'$)2/!;IH!I<<GH!'?2!C22'*&B!C*&%'20!-$!&$'!/2#$%&'!(&,!

-*0#%00*$&!#$&#2/&*&B!'?2!(B/22C2&'H!34KH!$/!DYYYD;;;!_$9282/H!'?2!C*&%'20!&$'2!'?('!L'?2/2!9(0!

-*0#%00*$&!/2B(/-*&B!'?2!&('%/2!$A!$'?2/!C(''2/0!$&!'?2!J$(/-T0!(B2&-(!(&-!'?2!/2C(*&*&B!

(B2&-(!*'2C0!92/2!1%'!$82/!%&'*+!'?2!&2Y'!1$00*)+2!'*C2!A$/!'?2!J$(/-!'$!'(W2!%1!0%#?!C(''2/0D@;;I!

P/*$/!'$!'?2!2&-!$A!I<<GH!'?2!34"55!J$(/-!?2+-!'?/22!C$/2!C22'*&B06!(!012#*(+!C22'*&B!$&!

O#'$)2/!I`H!(!012#*(+!C22'*&B!$&!5$82C)2/!NH!(&-!'?2!V(&#$%82/!K22'*&B!*&!2(/+,!R2#2C)2/D;;Z!

.?2!DYYY!0.XR!(&-!1/$1$02-!/2B*0'/,!(B/22C2&'!92/2!&$'!+*0'2-!$&!'?2!(B2&-(0!A$/!'?202!

C22'*&B0!&$/!C2&'*$&2-!*&!'?2!C22'*&B!C*&%'20D!

3&!(!+2''2/!'$!P(%+!.9$C2,!-('2-!5$82C)2/!IZH!I<<GH!^$&(0!Ja2+A82&0'(CH!'?2!F'('2!F2#/2'(/,!A$/!

4$CC%&*#('*$&0!(&-!72B*$&(+!P$+*#,!*&!F92-2&H!2Y1/2002-!'?2!F92-*0?!-*0(11/$8(+!A$/!'?2!DYYY!

-$C(*&D!Ja2+A82&0'(C!(+C$0'!C(-2!'?2!A$++$9*&B!/2C(/W0!/2B(/-*&B!'?2!U"4T0!/$+2!*&!'?2!34"55!

-2#*0*$&]C(W*&B!1/$#2006!

!"#$%&"'()'")**"+,-")..*/0)'/%$1")23"43)*'"&/'("/$".2%0345231"%.3$"'%"36327%$3"8%2"

0%993$':";%&3632<"/$")"0)13"*/#3"'(/1<"&(323".5=*/0"/$'3231'1"0*3)2*7")23"/$6%*634<"&3"833*"/'"

0%5*4"()63"=33$")..2%.2/)'3"8%2"!>?@@"'%"23A531'")46/03"82%9"B?>:"?49/''34*7<"B?>"0%5*4"

()63"C/63$")46/03"'%"!>?@@")$7&)7")'")$7".%/$'"/$"'/93"%8"'(3".2%0311")$4"'%"97"

#$%&*34C3<"$%"B?>"939=321"()63"2)/134"'(3"A531'/%$"=38%23"'(3"B?>"933'/$C"D5*7"E"F"GH<"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

107!3)*-D!!108!34"55H!LF12#*(+!K22'*&B!$A!'?2!J$(/-H@!F21'2C)2/!;GH!I<<GH!?''16bb999D*#(&&D$/Bb#$//201$&-2&#2b+$12c]'$]'(/C*c*]<=021<GD1-AD!!109!P2'2/!Q(&B+!'$!V*&'!42/AH!F21'2C)2/!;=H!I<<GH!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2H!?''16bb999D*#(&&D$/Bb#$//201$&-2&#2bc(&B+]'$]#2/A];=021<GD1-AD!!110!V*&'!42/A!'$!P2'2/!Q(&B+H!^(&%(/,!Z<H!I<<GH!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2H!?''16bb999D*#(&&D$/Bb#$//201$&-2&#2b#2/A]'$]c(&B+]Z<a(&<=D1-AD!111!34"55H!LF12#*(+!K22'*&B!$A!'?2!J$(/-H@!O#'$)2/!;IH!I<<GH!?''16bb999D*#(&&D$/Bb2&bC*&%'20bC*&%'20];I$#'<GD?'CD!!112!3)*-D!!113!F22!34"55H!LI<<G!J$(/-!K22'*&B0H@I<<GH!?''16bb999D*#(&&D$/Bb2&bC*&%'20b*&-2Y]I<<GD?'C+D!!

Page 108: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!""#$%&'%()*+,-.)/01%2.3+4+/$%3+%566%7/.-5-68%/+9:+;%599)/+%:<5:%=>?@@A9%'+05:&4+%

.7&'&.'%.'%1***$%+*7/+99+;%&'%!"""$%3.)6;%9:5';1%%

B/.,%:<+%=>?@@%;+C&9&.'%.'%D)'+%E$%!""#$%:<+/+%359%:..%6&::6+%:&,+%F./%G?>%:.%<54+%5'%

&'F./,+;%;&9C)99&.'%.'%:<+%9)-H+C:%5:%&:9%()*+,-.)/0%9),,+/%,++:&'0I%.'+%,.':<%3.)6;%

-+%&'9)FF&C&+':%:&,+%F./%0.4+/',+':9%:.%&';+7+';+':68%C.'9&;+/%5';%/+97.';%:.%:<+%9)-H+C:%

,5::+/1%='%:<&9%97+C&F&C%C59+$%9+4+/56%C.)':/&+9%/5&9+;%9+/&.)9%C.'C+/'9%5:%:<+%G?>%,++:&'01%

2.3+4+/$%:<+/+%359%:..%6&::6+%&'F./,5:&.'%5:%<5';%:.%<54+%5'%&'F./,+;%5';%F/)&:F)6%

;&9C)99&.'%5';%<+'C+%'.%C.'C6)9&.'9%3+/+%/+5C<+;%.'%:<+%9)-H+C:1EEJ%%

.?2!+2''2/!/2@%20'2-!'?('!'?2!34"55!A$(/-!B1$0'1$&2!#$&#+%0*82!-*0#%00*$&!$&!CDDD!%&'*+!(E'2/!'?2!

%1#$F*&G!H"4!F22'*&G!*&!5$82F)2/!IJKL<M!I<<NM!*&!O(&#$%82/P!0$!'?('!'?2!H"4!#$%+-!-*0#%00!

F(''2/0C!AQ2+E82&0'(F!(0R2-!'?2!A$(/-!'$!1/$8*-2!B*&!-2'(*+!?$9!*'!F2(&0!CDDD!E%+E*+0!'?2!#/*'2/*(!

02'!*&!(-8(&#2!ST#/*'2/*(!E$/!3&-212&-2&'!U8(+%('$/0VWCP;;N!!

X&!'?2!0(F2!-(,M!5$82F)2/!ILM!Y(%+!.9$F2,!/201$&-2-!'$!AQ2+E82&0'(FV0!+2''2/C;;Z!3&!?*0!

/201$&02M!.9$F2,!2D1+(*&2-!'?('!'?2!34"55!A$(/-!?(-!1%'!$EE!B(&,!-2#*0*$&!$&!['?2!CDDD\!

(11+*#('*$&!%&'*+!('!+2(0'!'?2!34"55!A$(/-!F22'*&G!$&!]!^2#2F)2/!I<<NCP;;=!

.?2!H"4V0!'?*/-!(&-!E*&(+!F22'*&G!*&!I<<N!9(0!?2+-!$82/!5$82F)2/!I_K^2#2F)2/!;!*&!

O(&#$%82/M!A/*'*0?!4$+%F)*(C!3&!'?2!H"4V0!O(&#$%82/!4$FF%&*@%`M!'?2!$&+,!/2+28(&'!&$'2!$&!'?2!

CDDD!(11+*#('*$&!9(0!'?2!E$++$9*&G6!

K<+%G?>%569.%3+6C.,+;%5%/+7./:%F/.,%=>?@@%.'%:<+%9:5:)9%.F%L.5/;%577/.456%.F%97.'9./+;%

K(M9$%59%3+66%59%:<+%N456)5:&.'%O+7./:%/+P)+9:+;%-8%G?>%,+,-+/91%='%:<5:%/+05/;$%:<+%G?>%

3+6C.,+;%:<+%;+C&9&.'%:.%7.9:7.'+%:<+%L.5/;A9%C.'9&;+/5:&.'%.F%:<+%1QQQ%5776&C5:&.'%F/.,%

&:9%M+C+,-+/%J:<$%!""#%,++:&'0%)':&6%9)C<%:&,+%59%:<+%G?>%<59%-++'%5-6+%:.%/+4&+3%:<+%

N456)5:&.'%O+7./:%5';%:<+%5;;&:&.'56%&'F./,5:&.'%/+P)+9:+;%F/.,%=>?@@1EER%%

!"#$%&'$()*'$)+$,&'$-./$01$,&'$"222$34)5'667$!889$

"0!$E!a(&%(/,!;M!I<<ZM!'?2!A$(/-!?(-!&$'!,2'!8$'2-!$&!'?2!12&-*&G!CDDD!/2G*0'/,!(G/22F2&'C!.?2!

&2D'!0*G&*E*#(&'!282&'0!$##%/2-!E$++$9*&G!'?2!H"4V0!F22'*&G!*&!b2++*&G'$&!*&!c(/#?C!d&'*+!'?2&M!

34"55!#$&'*&%2-!'$!&2G$'*('2!'?2!'2/F0!E$/!'?2!1/$1$02-!CDDD!/2G*0'/,!(G/22F2&'!9?*+2!

/201$&-*&G!'$!9/*''2&!#$FF%&*#('*$&!E/$F!'?2!F2F)2/0!$E!'?2!#$FF%&*',C!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

114!a$&(0!AQ2+E82&0'(F!'$!Y(%+!.9$F2,M!5$82F)2/!ILM!I<<NM!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2M!?''16ee999C*#(&&C$/Ge#$//201$&-2&#2e)Q2+E82&0'(Ff'$f'9$F2,fIL&$8<NC?'FC!!115!3)*-C!!116!Y(%+!.9$F2,!'$!a$&(0!AQ2+E82&0'(FM!5$82F)2/!ILM!I<<NM!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2M!?''16ee999C*#(&&C$/Ge#$//201$&-2&#2e'9$F2,f'$f)Q2+E82&0'(FfIL&$8<NC1-EC!!117!3)*-C!!118!H"4M!B4$FF%&*@%`!I]gO(&#$%82/MP!^2#2F)2/!;M!I<<NM!?''16eeG(#C*#(&&C$/Ge0,0'2FeE*+20eH"4hI]hO(&#$%82/h4$FF%&*@%2C1-EC!!

Page 109: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

?&!@(&%(/,!;AB!C<<DB!E*&'!42/F!*00%2-!(!0282&G1(H2!+2''2/!/201$&-*&H!'$!I2'2/!J(&H+K0!L21'2M)2/!

;DB!C<<N!+2''2/O;;P!3&!'Q*0!+2''2/B!42/F!Q*HQ+*HQ'2-!0$M2!$F!'Q2!1/$#2-%/(+!(&-!0%)0'(&'*82!

-*FF2/2&#20!)2'922&!'Q2!C<<<!R1/$$F!$F!#$&#21'S!/$%&-!(&-!'Q2!C<<T!7UI!(&-!(--/2002-!(!

&%M)2/!$F!*00%20!/2+('2-!'$!'Q2!V"4!'Q('!92/2!/(*02-!*&!J(&H+K0!$/*H*&(+!+2''2/O!42/F!2W1+(*&2-!'Q('!

'Q2!V"4!9(0!F*/0'!F$/M(++,!*&F$/M2-!$F!'Q2!12&-*&H!0.XY!(11+*#('*$&0!*&!(!R;!Y2#2M)2/!C<<Z!

+2''2/!F/$M!Y/O!.9$M2,S!'$!'Q2!V"4!9Q*#Q!R/2[%20'\2-]!*&1%'!$&!'Q2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!2+2M2&'0!$F!(!

&%M)2/!$F!*00%20!(&-!Q*HQ+*HQ'*&H!M(^$/!-282+$1M2&'0!*&!34"55OS;C<!42/F!0'('2-!'Q('!R'Q2!

4Q(*/M(&!$F!'Q2!V"4!/201$&-2-!'$!Y/O!.9$M2,!$&!T!"1/*+!C<<NBS!(&-!R&$'2-!\*&!'Q*0!+2''2/]!'Q('B!

(0!$F!'Q('!-('2B!_\&]$!V"4!M2M)2/0!Q(82!2W1/2002-!012#*F*#!/202/8('*$&0!$/!#$MM2&'0B!*&!'Q2!V"4B!

()$%'!'Q2!(11+*#('*$&0!F$/!0.XY0!*&!'Q2!#%//2&'!/$%&-OKS;C;!42/F!'Q2&!&$'2-!'Q('!R$&!;!@%&2!C<<NB!

'Q2!`$(/-!8$'2-!'$!)2H*&!-*0#%00*$&!$F!1/$1$02-!#$MM2/#*(+!(&-!'2#Q&*#(+!'2/M0!9*'Q!34aS!(&-!

'Q('!R'Q*0!-2#*0*$&!H2&2/('2-!M$/2!V"4!*&'2/20'!*&!'Q2!(11+*#('*$&!'Q(&!Q(-!)22&!0Q$9&!

2(/+*2/OS;CC!42/F!(+0$!0'('2-!'Q('!-%/*&H!'Q*0!'*M2!12/*$-B!I(%+!.9$M2,!/21$/'2-!'$!'Q2!V"4!'Q('!

R&$!#$MM2&'0!Q(-!)22&!/2#2*82-!F/$M!H$82/&M2&'0!/2H(/-*&H!'Q2!(11+*#('*$&S!(&-!'Q2!V"4!Q(-!

&$'!R/(*02-!'Q2!*00%2!*&!(&,!F$/M(+!#$MM2&'!'$!34"55B!0%#Q!(0!),!*&#+%0*$&!*&!(!4$MM%&*[%bOS;CT!

U*&(++,B!42/F!1$*&'2-!$%'!'Q('!'Q2!&2W'!F$/M(+!#$//201$&-2&#2!/2#2*82-!),!34"55!9(0!'Q2!"%H%0'!

;CB!C<<N!+2''2/!F/$M!'Q2!V"4!4Q(*/M(&!'Q('!-20#/*)2-!'Q2!$82/(++!-*0#$MF$/'!$F!'Q2!V"4O;CZ!

?&!U2)/%(/,!;;B!C<<DB!I(%+!.9$M2,!02&'!a$Q(M2-!LQ(/*+!.(/M*c*!(!+2''2/!'Q('!9(0!2002&'*(++,!

*-2&'*#(+!*&!0%)0'(&#2!'$!'Q2!+2''2/!E*&'!42/F!02&'!'$!I2'2/!J(&H+!$&!@(&%(/,!;AO;CN!3&!(--*'*$&!'$!

0%MM(/*c*&H!'Q2!`$(/-K0!*&'2/(#'*$&!9*'Q!'Q2!V"4!'$!-('2B!'Q2!.9$M2,!+2''2/!(+0$!&$'2-!'Q('!

34"55!Q(-!R/2#2*82-!+2''2/0!F/$M!0$M2!M2M)2/0!$F!'Q2!V$82/&M2&'(+!"-8*0$/,!4$MM*''22!

dV"4e!()$%'!'Q2!O!O!O!(11+*#('*$&!0%)M*''2-!),!34a!72H*0'/,!F$/!OWWWS!(&-!0%MM(/*c2-!'Q2!34a!

(11+*#('*$&!(&-!'Q2!`$(/-K0!*&'2/(#'*$&!9*'Q!'Q2!V"4!0*&#2!'Q2!(11+*#('*$&!9(0!/2#2*82-!*&!

C<<ZO;CD!!

?&!a(/#Q!;AB!C<<DB!I2'2/!J(&H+!/21+*2-!'$!E*&'!42/FK0!@(&%(/,!;AB!C<<D!+2''2/O;CA!3&!Q*0!+2''2/B!

J(&H+!'Q(&f2-!42/F!F$/!'Q2!/21+,!(&-!(#f&$9+2-H2-!'Q('!34"55!*0!/201$&0*)+2!F$/!M(f*&H!'Q2!

F*&(+!-2#*0*$&O!J(&H+!(+0$!M(-2!'Q2!F$++$9*&H!/2M(/f06!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

119!E*&'!42/F!'$!I2'2/!J(&H+B!@(&%(/,O!;AB!C<<DB!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2B!Q''16gg999O*#(&&O$/Hg#$//201$&-2&#2g#2/FG'$Gc(&H+GT<^(&<DO1-FO!L22!(+0$!I2'2/!J(&H+!'$!E*&'!42/FB!L21'2M)2/!;DB!C<<NB!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2B!Q''16gg999O*#(&&O$/Hg2&g#$//201$&-2&#2gc(&H+G'$G#2/FG;D021<NO1-FO!120!3)*-OB!CO!.Q2!+2''2/!(+0$!*&#+%-20!(!Q,12/+*&f!'$!'Q2!I(%+!.9$M2,!+2''2/!02&'!'$!a$Q(M2-!LQ(/*+!.(/M*c*!$&!Y2#2M)2/!;B!C<<ZO!!121!3)*-OB!CGT!d0$M2!1%&#'%('*$&!$M*''2-eO!!122!3)*-OB!TO!!123!3)*-O!!124!3)*-O!!125!I(%+!.9$M2,!'$!a$Q(M2-!LQ(/*+!.(/M*c*B!U2)/%(/,!;;B!C<<DB!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2B!Q''16gg999O*#(&&O$/Hg#$//201$&-2&#2g'9$M2,G'$G'(/M*c*G;DF2)<DO1-FO!4FO!E*&'!42/F!'$!I2'2/!J(&H+B!@(&%(/,!;AB!C<<DB!Q''16gg999O*#(&&O$/Hg2&g#$//201$&-2&#2g#2/FG'$Gc(&H+GT<^(&<DO1-FO!!126!3)*-O!!127!I2'2/!J(&H+!'$!E*&'$&!42/FB!a(/#Q!;AB!C<<DB!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2B!Q''16gg999O*#(&&O$/Hg2&g#$//201$&-2&#2gc(&H+G'$G#2/FG;AM(/<DO1-FO!L22!(+0$!E*&'!42/FB!'$!I2'2/!J(&H+B!@(&%(/,!;AB!C<<DB!Q''16gg999O*#(&&O$/Hg2&g#$//201$&-2&#2g#2/FG'$Gc(&H+GT<^(&<DO1-FO!!

Page 110: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!"#$%&'"()*+,-./("+$#(0(1"2+,2"2+("1(3%(-2"4$1",''.2.$5,&".54$1),2.$5"),'("67"2+("89:".5"

;,5<$%0(1"1(-%&2-"41$)"2+("<$5<&%-.$5"$4"2+("(0,&%,2.$5"2(,)"2+,2","5%)6(1"$4"2+("

,**&.<,2.$5-=".5<&%'.5>"?@@@"A'$"5$2")((2",&&"$4"2+("-(&(<2.$5"<1.2(1.,B",5'"2+,2=")$1($0(1="

2+(.1"A'(4.<.(5<.(-"<,55$2"6("1()('.('"#.2+.5"2+(",**&.<,52B-"*1$*$-('"41,)(#$1CB?"

!)*$12,52&7="2+("(0,&%,2$1-"A1(<$))(5'"2+,2"!:9DD"5$2"<$5-.'(1"2+(-(",**&.<,2.$5-"

4%12+(1B?"

!5"$1'(1"2$"<,117",6$%2"$%1"'%2.(-"(44(<2.0(&7".5"2+("89:"2+(1(4$1(="7$%"#.&&"%5'(1-2,5'"#+7"

.2"#$%&'"6("%-(4%&"2$"C5$#"#+7"2+("E$,1'"'(<.'('"2$"*1$<(('"#.2+"2+(",**&.<,2.$5=".5"

*,12.<%&,1">.0(5"-%<+"(@*&.<.2",'0.<("41$)"2+("(0,&%,2$1-?"!"5$2(",5'",**1(<.,2("2+("

(@2(5-.0(".54$1),2.$5"7$%"+,0("*1$0.'('".5"7$%1"&(22(1",6$%2"2+("E$,1'B-"'(&.6(1,2.$5-="6%2"

!"'$"5$2"4((&"2+,2"2+.-"-*(<.4.<"3%(-2.$5".-"-%<<.5<2&7",''1(--('?"!"#$%&'"6(">1,2(4%&"2+(1(4$1("

.4"2+(1(".-",''.2.$5,&".54$1),2.$5"2+,2"7$%="$5"6(+,&4"$4"2+("E$,1'="<,5"-+,1("#.2+"%-"$5"

2+(-(".--%(-?""

?&!@(/#A!B<C!B<<DC!E$A&!@F!7F!G&2%2/C!'A2!"#'*&H!"00*0'(&'!I2#/2'(/,!('!'A2!JI!K21(/'L2&'!$M!

4$LL2/#2!(&-!"#'*&H!"00*0'(&'!I2#/2'(/,!M$/!'A2!5.3"C!9/$'2!'$!@$A(L2-!IA(/*+!.(/L*N*F;BO!P*0!

+2''2/!(-8*02-!'A2!Q"4!'A('!'A2!1/$1$02-!FRRR!/2H*0'/,!(H/22L2&'!-*-!&$'!/2M+2#'!(!&%L)2/!$M!S2,!

#$LL*'L2&'0!$MM2/2-!),!34@!9*'A*&!'A2!#$&'/(#'T0!1/$8*0*$&0!(&-!/2U%20'2-!'A('!'A2!Q"4!)/*&H!

'A*0!'$!'A2!(''2&'*$&!$M!'A2!34"55!V$(/-!1/*$/!'$!'A2!W2++*&H'$&C!529!X2(+(&-!L22'*&HF;B=!.A2!

+2''2/!(+0$!*&#+%-2-!(!-20#/*1'*$&!$M!'A2!1/$8*0*$&0!'A('!'A2!5.3"!0(*-!92/2!&$'!/2M+2#'2-!*&!'A2!

(H/22L2&'F;Y<!!

?&!@(/#A!BZC!B<<DC!I'%(/'![(9+2,C!34@T0!4\?C!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!.(/L*N*!/201$&-*&H!'$!'A2!

#$LL2&'0!L(-2!),!'A2!5.3"!$&!@(/#A!B<F;Y;!3&!'A*0!+2''2/C![(9+2,!0'('2-!'A('!'A2!+2''2/!M/$L!'A2!

5.3"!9(0!*&#$//2#'!(&-!(/H%2-!'A('!'A2!*00%20!/(*02-!),!'A2!5.3"!92/2!(+/2(-,!(--/2002-!),!(!

&%L)2/!$M!012#*M*#!#$LL*'L2&'0!'A('!A(-!)22&!&2H$'*('2-!)2'922&!34"55!(&-!34@F;YB!

"!M29!-(,0!(M'2/!'A2!2R#A(&H2!$M!+2''2/0C!'A2!Q"4!L2'!*&!W2++*&H'$&C!529!X2(+(&-F;YY!.A2!

W2++*&H'$&!4$LL%&*U%]!2R1/2002-!'A2!L$0'!#/*'*#(+!/2L(/S0!9*'A!/2H(/-!'$!'A2!FRRR!(11+*#('*$&!

'$!-('2!),!'A2!Q"4F!3&!1(/'*#%+(/C!'A2!4$LL%&*U%]!0'('2-!'A('!^'A2!Q"4!-$20!&$'!)2+*282!'A2!

_2)/%(/,!;;!+2''2/!1/$8*-20!0%MM*#*2&'!-2'(*+!/2H(/-*&H!'A2!/('*$&(+2!M$/!'A2!V$(/-!-2'2/L*&('*$&!

'A('!'A2!(11+*#('*$&!A(-!$82/#$L2!'A2!-2M*#*2&#*20!&$'2-!*&!'A2!\R(L*&('*$&!721$/'F`;Ya!.A2!

4$LL%&*U%]!M%/'A2/!/2U%20'2-!^(!9/*''2&!2R1+(&('*$&!$M!'A2!V$(/-!-2#*0*$&C!1(/'*#%+(/+,!9*'A!

/2H(/-!'$!'A2!01$&0$/2-!#$LL%&*',!(&-!1%)+*#!*&'2/20'!#/*'2/*(!$%'+*&2-!*&!'A2!01$&0$/2-!'$1b

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

128!E$A&!@F!7F!G&2%2/!'$!@$A(L2-!IA(/*+!.(/L*N*C!@(/#A!B<C!B<<DC!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2C!A''16cc999F*#(&&F$/Hc#$//201$&-2&#2cS&2%2/b'$b'(/L*N*bB<L(/<DF1-MF!!129!3)*-F!!130!3)*-F!!131!I'%(/'![(9+2,!'$!@$A(L2-!IA(/*+!.(/L*N*C!@(/#A!BZC!B<<DC!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2C!A''16cc999F*#(&&F$/Hc#$//201$&-2&#2c+(9+2,b'$b'(/L*N*bBZL(/<DF1-MF!!132!3)*-F!133!Q"4C!^4$LL%&*U%]!BZdW2++*&H'$&C`!@(/#A!BOC!B<<DC!A''16ccH(#F*#(&&F$/Hc0,0'2LcM*+20cQ"4eBZeW2++*&H'$&e4$LL%&*U%2F1-MF!134!3)*-FC!YF!I22!(+0$!f(%+!.9$L2,!'$!@$A(L2-!IA(/*+!.(/L*N*C!_2)/%(/,!;DC!B<<DC!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2C!A''16cc999F*#(&&F$/Hc2&c#$//201$&-2&#2c'9$L2,b'$b'(/L*N*b;DM2)<DF1-MF!!

Page 111: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

+282+!-$>(*&!02+2#'*$&!#/*'2/*(?@;AB!.C2!4$>>%&*D%E!(+0$!0'('2-!'C('!34F!#$>>*''2-!'$!G(!/(&H2!

$I!1%)+*#!*&'2/20'!)2&2I*'0!(0!1(/'!$I!'C2!)*-!'$!$12/('2!'C2!?JJJ!-$>(*&@!(&-!'C('!G'C202!

%&-2/'(K*&H0!C(82!&$'!,2'!)22&!*&#+%-2-!(0!34F!$)+*H('*$&0!*&!'C2!1/$1$02-!?JJJ!72H*0'/,!

"H/22>2&'?@!3'!(+0$!+*0'2-!(!&%>)2/!$I!0%#C!1/$8*0*$&0!'C('!'C2!L"4!9(&'2-!'$!)2!(--/2002-?;AM!

3&!(!021(/('2!02#'*$&!$I!'C2!N2++*&H'$&!4$>>%&*D%EO!'*'+2-!GL"4P34"55!Q$(/-!4$$12/('*$&O@!'C2!

4$>>%&*D%E!&$'2-!'C('!G'C2!L"4!(#K&$9+2-H20!'C('!'C2/2!*0!(!&22-!I$/!'C2!L"4!'$!#$&0*-2/!

#C(&H20!*&!*'0!9$/K*&H!>2'C$-0!*&!$/-2/!'$!2&()+2!*'!'$!*&'2/(#'!>$/2!/$%'*&2+,!9*'C!'C2!34"55!

Q$(/-!(&-!'C2!#$>>%&*',?@;AR!

.C2!-(,!(I'2/!'C2!L"4!4$>>%&*D%E!9(0!*00%2-O!'C2!34"55!Q$(/-!C2+-!*'0!/2H%+(/!>22'*&H!*&!

N2++*&H'$&?;AS!"'!'C*0!>22'*&HO!'C2!Q$(/-!/20$+82-!'C('!G'C2!T/20*-2&'!(&-!'C2!L2&2/(+!4$%&02+!

(/2!-*/2#'2-!'$!(&(+,U2!(++!1%)+*#+,!/2#2*82-!*&1%'0@!(&-!G'$!#$&'*&%2!&2H$'*('*$&0!9*'C!V34FW?@;AX!

.C2!/20$+%'*$&!0'('2-!'C('!'C2!T/20*-2&'!(&-!L2&2/(+!4$%&02+!(+0$!(/2!G'$!2&0%/2!'C('!'C2!.YZ!

01$&0$/!9*++!C(82!*&!1+(#2!(-2D%('2!>2#C(&*0>0!'$!(--/200!(&,!1$'2&'*(+!/2H*0'/(&'!8*$+('*$&0!$I!

'C2!01$&0$/[0!1$+*#*20O@!28(+%('2!'C2!1/$1$02-!(>2&->2&'0!'$!'C2!/2H*0'/,!(H/22>2&'!(&-!

1/$8*-2!'C2!Q$(/-!9*'C!/2#$>>2&-('*$&0?;\<!

]&!"1/*+!^SO!^<<MO!'C2!34"55!Q$(/-!C2+-!(!012#*(+!>22'*&H!(&-!-*0#%002-O!(>$&H!$'C2/!'C*&H0O!

'C2!0'('%0!$I!'C2!1/$1$02-!?JJJ!0.YZ!/2H*0'/,!(H/22>2&'?;\;!_$C&!_2II/2,O!'C2!34"55!L2&2/(+!

4$%&02+O!1/$8*-2-!(&!%1-('2!$&!'C2!&2H$'*('*$&0!(&-!'C2!#C(&H20!'C('!C(-!)22&!>(-2!'$!'C2!

1/$1$02-!/2H*0'/,!(H/22>2&'!0*&#2!'C2!N2++*&H'$&!>22'*&H0?!_2II/2,!&$'2-!'C('!34F!C(-!1/$8*-2-!

G(!I*&(+!82/0*$&!$I!'C2*/!1/$1$0(+!I$/!(!/201$&02!'$!(++!#$&#2/&0!I/$>!'C2!#$>>%&*',!(&-!/2+('*&H!

'$!'C2!L"4!4$>>%&*D%E?@;\^!`*&'!42/I!*&-*#('2-!'C('!C2!9$%+-!+*K2!'$!GC(82!(&!%1!$/!-$9&!8$'2!('!

'C2!;<!F(,!F22'*&H?@;\A!_$C&!_2II/2,!(+0$!0'('2-!'C('!'C('!G'C2!34F!82/0*$&!V$I!'C2!1/$1$02-!

(H/22>2&'WO!*&#+%-*&H!(!+2''2/!I/$>!34FO!9$%+-!)2!1%)+*0C2-!+('2/!'C('!-(,!I$/!1%)+*#!

#$>>2&'?@;\\!

F$C(>2-!aC(/*+!.(/>*U*O!9C$!9(0!1/202&'!('!'C*0!Q$(/-!>22'*&HO!G/2D%20'2-!(&!%1-('2!$&!

9C2'C2/!'C2/2!9$%+-!)2!(!/201$&02!'$!'C2!L"4!/2H(/-*&H!'C2!*'2>0!'C('!02'!$%'!*&!'C2!

4$>>%&*D%E!*&!N2++*&H'$&?@!T(%+!.9$>2,!0'('2-!'C('!G(!/201$&02!9$%+-!)2!1/$8*-2-!)2I$/2!'C2!

;<!F(,!F22'*&H?@;\B!]82/!'C2!/2>(*&-2/!$I!'C2!Q$(/-!>22'*&HO!'C2!>*&%'20!*&-*#('2!'C2!Q$(/-!

>2>)2/0!-*0#%002-!#$&#2/&0!/2H(/-*&H!'C2!1/$1$02-!/2H*0'/,!(H/22>2&'O!*&#+%-*&H!'C2!>(&&2/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

135!3)*-?!!136!3)*-?!!137!3)*-?O!^bA?!!138!34"55O!GF22'*&H!$I!'C2!Q$(/-O!N2++*&H'$&O!5cO@!F(/#C!A;O!^<<MO!C''16dd999?*#(&&?$/Hd2&d>*&%'20d>*&%'20bA;>(/<M?C'>?!139!3)*-?!!140!3)*-?!!141!34"55O!Ga12#*(+!F22'*&H!$I!'C2!34"55!Q$(/-O@!;S!"1/*+O!^<<MO!C''16dd999?*#(&&?$/Hd2&d>*&%'20d>*&%'20b;S(1/<M?C'>?!!142!3)*-?!!143!3)*-?!!144!3)*-?!!145!3)*-?!!

Page 112: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;;<!

$=!#$>1+*(&#2!(&-!9?2'?2/!1$+*#,!2&=$/#2>2&'!1/$8*0*$&0!9$%+-!)2!0%==*#*2&'!'$!#$82/!(!

#$>>%&*',!@(0!#$>1+2A!(0!'?2!(-%+'!2&'2/'(*&>2&'!#$>>%&*',BC;DE!

F(%+!.9$>2,!02&'!(!+2''2/!(--/2002-!'$!.(/>*G*!(&-!>2>)2/0!$=!'?2!H"4!$&!I(,!DJ!KLLEB;DM!.?2!

+2''2/!0'('2-!'?('!.9$>2,!9(0!9/*'*&N!*&!/201$&02!'$!'?2!H"4O0!/2P%20'!=$/!*&=$/>('*$&!

/2N(/-*&N!'?2!-2#*0*$&!'$!1/$#22-!9*'?!'?2!BAAA!&2N$'*('*$&0!*&!Q%&2!KLLRB!3&!'?*0!+2''2/!'?2!34"55!

S$(/-!(N(*&!-*/2#'2-!'?2!H"4!'$!'?2!@;;!T2)/%(/,!+2''2/!'$!2A1+(*&!U'?2!S$(/-!-2#*0*$&J!

1(/'*#%+(/+,!9*'?!/2N(/-!'$!'?2!01$&0$/2-!#$>>%&*',!(&-!1%)+*#!*&'2/20'!#/*'2/*(BC;DV!.?2!+2''2/!

=%/'?2/!0'('2-!'?('!@*'!*0!*>1$/'(&'!'$!&$'2!'?('!'?2!S$(/-!-2#*0*$&!(0!'$!'?2!BAAA!(11+*#('*$&!*0!0'*++!

12&-*&NC!(&-!'?('!'?2!Q%&2!KLLR!-2#*0*$&!$&+,!12/>*''2-!'?2!34"55!0'(==!'$!2&'2/!*&'$!

&2N$'*('*$&0!=$/!(!1/$1$02-!/2N*0'/,!(N/22>2&'B!.9$>2,!2A1+(*&2-!'?('!'?*0!-2#*0*$&!-*-!&$'!

1/2W%-*#2!@'?2!S$(/-O0!/*N?'!'$!28(+%('2!'?2!/20%+'*&N!#$&'/(#'!(&-!'$!-2#*-2!9?2'?2/!*'!>22'0!(++!

$=!'?2!#/*'2/*(!)2=$/2!'?2!S$(/-!*&#+%-*&N!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!(-8*#2!0%#?!(0!'?2!S$(/-!2*'?2/!(11/$820!

$/!/2W2#'0!'?2!/2N*0'/,!(N/22>2&'!/2+('*&N!'$!'?2!BAAA!(11+*#('*$&BC;DX!.?2!/2>(*&-2/!$=!'?2!+2''2/!

2A1+(*&2-!'?2!1/$#200!$=!28(+%('*$&!(N(*&!(0!2A1+(*&2-!*&!'?2!T2)/%(/,!;;!+2''2/!(&-J!*&!

1(/'*#%+(/J!&$'2-!'?('!@*&!(++!*&0'(&#20!9?2/2!'?2!28(+%('$/0O!&2N('*82!/21$/'0!92/2!/228(+%('2-!

),!'?2!S$(/-!$=!Y*/2#'$/0J!'?2!(11+*#(&'0!(&092/2-!(++!P%20'*$&0!(&-!#+(/*=*2-!*00%20!'?('!?(-!

)22&!$=!#$&#2/&!'$!'?2!28(+%('$/0!'$!'?2!0('*0=(#'*$&!$=!(!>(W$/*',!$=!'?2!S$(/-BC;RL!

Z&!I(,!XJ!KLLEJ!I(/'*&!S$,+2J!'?2![\!721/202&'('*82!'$!'?2!H"4J!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!]*&'!42/=!(0!(!

=$++$9^%1!'$!'?2!-*0#%00*$&0!?2+-!('!'?2!_2++*&N'$&!>22'*&NB;R;!.?2!+2''2/!-20#/*)20!'?2!@=*/>!

8*29!`$=!'?2![\a!'?('!*=!'?2!-$'BAAA!-$>(*&!&(>2!*0!'$!)2!(%'?$/*G2-J!*'!9$%+-!)2!*>1$/'(&'!'?('!

34"55!2&0%/20!'?2!)2&2=*'0!(&-!0(=2N%(/-0!1/$1$02-!),!'?2!/2N*0'/,J!34IJ!*&#+%-*&N!'?2!

>$&*'$/*&N!(++!-$'BAAA!#$&'2&'!(&-!/('*&N!$=!#$&'2&'!$&!(++!02/82/0!1$*&'2-!'$!),!-$'BAAAJ!(/2!

N2&%*&2+,!(#?*282-!=/$>!-(,!$&2BC;RK!S$,+2!(+0$!1$*&'2-!$%'!'?('!@*'!9*++!)2!*>1$/'(&'!=$/!'?2!

*&'2N/*',!$=!34"55O0!1$0*'*$&!(0!=*&(+!(11/$8*&N!(%'?$/*',B!B!B!'$!)2!022&!(0!()+2!'$!*&'2/82&2!

1/$>1'+,!(&-!2==2#'*82+,!*=!=$/!(&,!/2(0$&!=(*+%/2!$&!'?2!1(/'!$=!34I!*&!(&,!$=!'?202!=%&-(>2&'(+!

0(=2N%(/-0BC;Rb!

"+0$!$&!I(,!XJ!KLLEJ!.*>!7%*GJ!]*#2!F/20*-2&'!$=!H$Y(--,J!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!34"55!'$!@2&#$%/(N2!

'?2!34"55!S$(/-!'$!#$&0*-2/!'?2!1/$1$02-!BAAA!72N*0'/,!"N/22>2&'!$&+,!*&!/2N(/-0!'$!?$9!*'!

(--/20020!'?2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!#$&#2/&0!/(*02-!),!'?2!H"4BC;RD!7%*G!(+0$!0'('2-!'?('!'?2!#%//2&'!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

146!3)*-B!!147!Q$?&!Q2==/2,!'$!I$?(>2-!c?(/*+!.(/>*G*!(&-!>2>)2/0!$=!'?2!H"4J!I(,!DJ!KLLEJ!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2J!?''16dd*#(&&B$/Nd#$//201$&-2&#2d'9$>2,^'$^'(/>*G*^LD>(,LEB1-=B!c22!(+0$!F(%+!.9$>2,!'$!I$?(>2-!c?(/*+!.(/>*G*J!T2)/%(/,!;;J!KLLEJ!?''16dd*#(&&B$/Nd2&d#$//201$&-2&#2d'9$>2,^'$^'(/>*G*^;E=2)LEB1-=B!148!3)*-B!!149!3)*-B!!150!3)*-B!!151!I(/'*&!S$,+2!'$!]*&'!42/=J!I(,!XJ!KL;LJ!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2J!?''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Nd#$//201$&-2&#2d)$,+2^'$^#2/=^LX>(,LEB?'>B!!152!3)*-B!!153!3)*-B!!154!.*>!7%*G!'$!34"55J!I(,!XJ!KL;LJ!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2J!?''16dd999B*#(&&B$/Nd#$//201$&-2&#2d/%*G^'$^)$(/-^LX>(,LEB1-=B!!

Page 113: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

/$%&-!$>!.?@!2A1(&0*$&!9(0!0'*++!&$'!#$B1+2'2!(>'2/!'9$!,2(/0!(&-!&$'20!'C('!D'C*0!>(#'!9*++!

#2/'(*&+,!-*0#$%/(E2!>%'%/2!(11+*#(&'0!>$/!&29!01$&0$/2-!$/!%&F01$&0$/2-!E.?@0GH;II!

J&!K(,!;LM!<LLNM!'C2!O$(/-!C2+-!(!012#*(+!B22'*&E!(&-!8$'2-!$&!'C2!1/$1$02-!GAAA!/2E*0'/,!

(E/22B2&'M!>$++$9*&E!(!D-2'(*+2-!-*0#%00*$&H!$>!'C2!(E/22B2&'!'2/B0M!*&#+%-*&E!'C2!1/$B*020!

B(-2!),!34K!*&!0%11$/'!$>!'C2!1/$1$0(+M!#$&#2/&0!/2E(/-*&E!34"55P0!()*+*',!'$!2&>$/#2!'C2!'2/B0!

'C/$%EC!(!#$&'/(#'%(+!>/(B29$/QM!'C2!01$&0$/0C*1!#/*'2/*(M!R"4!(-8*#2!(&-!#$BB%&*',!*&1%'G;IN!

O,!(!STI!8$'2M!'C2!34"55!O$(/-!/20$+82-!'$!/2U2#'!'C2!#%//2&'!-/(>'!$>!'C2!GAAA!/2E*0'/,!(E/22B2&'!

V)%'!&$'!34KP0!(11+*#('*$&!(0!(!9C$+2WM!#*'*&E!#$&#2/&0!()$%'!'C2!(E/22B2&'P0!2&>$/#2()*+*',M!'C2!

01$&0$/0C*1!#/*'2/*(M!(&-!$'C2/!#$&#2/&0!8$*#2-!*&!'C2!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!/2#2*82-G;IX!34K!>*+2-!(!

72Y%20'!>$/!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!$&!'C2!0(B2!-(,Z;I[!C$9282/M!(>'2/!34"55!*&8*'2-!34K!'$!0%)B*'!(!

/28*02-!-/(>'!$>!'C2!/2E*0'/,!(E/22B2&'M!34K!9*'C-/29!*'0!72Y%20'G;IS!!

\'%(/'!?(9+2,M!]/20*-2&'!$>!34KM!02&'!(!+2''2/!'$!^*&'!42/>!$&!K(,!_LM!<LLN!2A1/200*&E!C*0!

-*0(11$*&'B2&'!('!'C2!O$(/-P0!-2#*0*$&!(&-!('!D'C2!+(#Q!$>!#$BB%&*#('*$&!>/$B!34"55H!$&!'C2!

#%//2&'!0'('%0!$>!'C2!(11+*#('*$&G!?(9+2,!&$'2-!'C('!(>'2/!/28*29*&E!'C2!O$(/-P0!8$'*&E!'/(&0#/*1'!

C2!9(0!D#$&8*&#2-H!'C('!D#2/'(*&!B*0#$&#21'*$&0!1/282&'2-!'C2!O$(/-!>/$B!/2(#C*&E!(!)(+(&#2-!

(&-!2Y%*'()+2!U%-EB2&'!$&!'C2!(E/22B2&'GH!3&!1(/'*#%+(/M!?(9+2,!-20#/*)2-!'C2!K(,!S!+2''2/!>/$B!

K(/'*&!O$,+2M!'C2!`a!R"4!/21/202&'('*82M!(0!)2*&E!DB*0#C(/(#'2/*b2-GH!?(9+2,!(+0$!0'('2-!'C('!

34K!9(0!0'*++!#$BB*''2-!'$!'C2!1/$U2#'!(&-!C(-!>*+2-!(&!2A12-*'2-!/2Y%20'!>$/!/2#$&0*-2/('*$&G!

c*&(++,M!?(9+2,!$%'+*&2-!(&!34K!*&*'*('*82!'C('!D2&()+2d0e!#2/'(*&!/201$&0*)+2!B2B)2/0!$>!'C2!

$&+*&2!(-%+'!2&'2/'(*&B2&'!#$BB%&*',!G!G!G!'$!0%)B*'!(!/2Y%20'!'$!/202/82!(!1(/'*#%+(/!-$B(*&!>$/!

'C2*/!0%)02Y%2&'!/2E*0'/('*$&!0C$%+-!34"55!(%'C$/*b2!34K!'$!$12/('2!GfffH;NL!!

O2'922&!g%&2!<LLN!(&-!g(&%(/,!;M!<LLXM!34"55!C(0!&$!1%)+*#!/2#$/-0!$>!R"4!#$//201$&-2&#2!

/2E(/-*&E!'C2!1/$1$02-!GAAA!/2E*0'/,!(E/22B2&'!$/!'C2!0.?@!(11+*#('*$&G!"--*'*$&(++,M!'C2!GAAA!

1/$1$02-!/2E*0'/,!(E/22B2&'!9(0!&$'!B2&'*$&2-!*&!(&,!O$(/-!B22'*&E!B*&%'20!-%/*&E!'C*0!'*B2!

12/*$-G!!

!"#$%&'$()*'$)+$,&'$-./$01$,&'$"222$34)5'667$!889$

J&!g(&%(/,!IM!<LLXM!34"55!1$0'2-!(!D/28*02-!1/$1$02-H!GAAA!/2E*0'/,!(E/22B2&'!)2'922&!34"55!

(&-!34K!>$/!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!%&'*+!c2)/%(/,!IM!<LLXG;N;!J&!c2)/%(/,!<M!<LLXM!.(/B*b*!02&'!(!

+2''2/!'$!^*&'!42/>!*&!/201$&02!'$!'C2!g(&%(/,!I!(&&$%&#2B2&'G;N<!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

155!3)*-G!!156!34"55M!D\12#*(+!K22'*&E!$>!'C2!O$(/-MH!K(,!;LM!<LLNM!C''16hh999G*#(&&G$/Eh2&hB*&%'20hB*&%'20F;LB(,LNGC'BG!!157!34"55M!D^$'*&E!./(&0#/*1'!$>!O$(/-!K22'*&EMH!K(,!;LM!<LLNM!C''16hh999G*#(&&G$/Eh2&hB*&%'20h8$'*&EF'/(&0#/*1'F;LB(,LNGC'BG!158!34KM!D72Y%20'!>$/!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!$>!O$(/-!"#'*$&MH!K(,!;LM!<LLNM!C''16hh999G*#(&&G$/Eh2&h#$BB*''220h/2#$&0*-2/('*$&h*#BFLNFih12'*'*$&F<LB(,LNG1->G!159!34KM!D72Y%20'!>$/!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!LNFi6!?2''2/!>/$B!gG!O2#Q9*'C!O%//!'$!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!4$BB*''22MH!J#'$)2/!<SM!<LLNM!C''16hh999G*#(&&G$/Eh2&h#$BB*''220h/2#$&0*-2/('*$&h9*'C-/(9(+F$>F/2Y%20'FLNFiF<S$#'LNGC'BG!160!\'29(/'!?(9+2,!'$!^*&'!42/>M!K(,!_LM!<LLNM!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2M!C''16hh999G*#(&&G$/Eh2&h#$//201$&-2&#2h+(9+2,F'$F#2/>F_LB(,LNGC'BG!161!34"55!"&&$%&#2B2&'M!D34"55!]%)+*0C20!728*02-!]/$1$02-!"E/22B2&'!$&!GfffMH!g(&%(/,!IM!<LLXM!C''16hh999G*#(&&G$/Eh2&h(&&$%&#2B2&'0h(&&$%&#2B2&'FLIU(&LXGC'BG!!

Page 114: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

.>2!+2''2/!0'('2-!'>('!'>2!?@"4!#$&82&2-!(!'2+2#$&A2/2&#2!$&!;B!C(&%(/,!DEEB!'$!-*0#%00!*'0!

/2(#'*$&!'$!F'>2!#(++!A$/!#$GG2&'0HI!(&-!'>('!'>2!1(/'*#*1('*&J!@"4!G2G)2/0!$&!'>2!#(++!?&$'2-!

'>('!'>2!G$-*A*#('*$&0!'$!'>2!1/$1$02-!(J/22G2&'!(/2!*&'2&-2-!'$!(--/200!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20!

/(*02-!),!'>2!@"4!*&!*'0!K2++*&J'$&L!529!M2(+(&-!4$GG%&*N%O!$A!P(/#>!DEEQRI!.>2!+2''2/!(+0$!

1$*&'2-!$%'!'>('!?*'!*0!%&+*S2+,!'>('!'>2!@"4!9*++!)2!*&!(!1$0*'*$&!'$!1/$8*-2!(&,!#$GG2&'0!$&!RTTTL!

()$82!(&-!)2,$&-!'>('!1/$8*-2-!*&!'>2!K2++*&J'$&!4$GG%&*N%OL!)2A$/2!'>2!&2T'!G22'*&J!*&!

U*0)$&RI;Q<!

.>2!+2''2/!(+0$!0'('2-!'>('L!-201*'2!'>2!34"55!V/20*-2&'W0!+2''2/0!02&'!$&!X2)/%(/,!;;!(&-!P(,!YL!

DEEQL!'>2!@"4!>(-!/2N%20'2-!?9/*''2&!#+(/*A*#('*$&!A/$G!'>2!34"55!Z$(/-!/2J(/-*&J!*'0!-2#*0*$&!

C%&2!;!DEE[I!(&-!?/2*'2/('2F0H!'>2!@"4W0!/2N%20'!A$/!(!#+2(/!2T1+(&('*$&!$A!9>,!'>2!34"55!Z$(/-!

*0!0('*0A*2-!'>('!'>2!RTTT!(11+*#('*$&!>(0!$82/#$G2!'>2!-2A*#*2&#*20!/2+('*&J!'$!'>2!1/$1$02-!

01$&0$/0>*1!#$GG%&*',RI;QY!.>2!+2''2/!(+0$!/2N%20'2-!'>('!34"55!1/$8*-2!'>2!@"4!9*'>!

#$&A*/G('*$&!'>('!'>2!1/$1$02-!RTTT!/2J*0'/,!(J/22G2&'!#$&'(*&2-!2&A$/#2()+2!1/$8*0*$&0!

#$82/*&J!?(++!$A!34P!72J*0'/,W0!#$GG*'G2&'0RI!

X*&(++,L!.(/G*\*W0!+2''2/!0%JJ20'2-!'>('!*'!9$%+-!)2!(11/$1/*('2!A$/!'>2!@"4!(&-!'>2!34"55!Z$(/-!

'$!>$+-!?A(#2]'$]A(#2!-*0#%00*$&0I!*&!U*0)$&!*&!P(/#>!DEEBR!3&!>*0!#$&#+%-*&J!/2G(/S0L!.(/G*\*!

(J(*&!0'('2-!'>('!0282/(+!@"4!G2G)2/0!/2G(*&2-!?2G1>('*#(++,!$11$02-!A/$G!'>2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!

12/012#'*82!'$!'>2!*&'/$-%#'*$&!$A!(&!RTTT!0.U^I_(0!9(0!&$'2-!*&!'>2!K2++*&J'$&!4$GG%&*N%O_

(&-!'>('!0%#>!02&'*G2&'0!92/2!&$'!#$&'*&J2&'!$&!'>2!?012#*A*#*'*20!$A!'>2!(J/22G2&'RI;Q[!!

.9$!012#*(+!G22'*&J0!$A!'>2!34"55!Z$(/-!92/2!>2+-!)2'922&!X2)/%(/,![L!DEEB!(&-!'>2!P(/#>!

DEEB!U*0)$&!G22'*&J0R!.>2!A*/0'!G22'*&JL!>2+-!$&!X2)/%(/,!;DL!DEEBL!*&#+%-2-!(!+2&J'>,!

-*0#%00*$&!$A!'>2!1/$1$02-!RTTT!(J/22G2&'L!9>*#>!#$82/2-!#$GG%&*',!(&-!1%)+*#!#$GG2&'0L!

0'('%0!$A!(-8*#2!A/$G!'>2!@"4L!*&#+%-*&J!(!?#+(/*A*#('*$&!$A!'>2!+2''2/!A/$G!'>2!@"4!4>(*/!(&-!

4>(*/]`+2#'I!(&-!9>2'>2/!(--*'*$&(+!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!(-8*#2!9(0!'$!)2!2T12#'2-L!(&-!>$9!34P!

G2(0%/20!%1!'$!'>2!7XV!#/*'2/*(R;QQ!!

a$G2!$A!'>2!&$'()+2!1$*&'0!/(*02-!-%/*&J!'>*0!G22'*&J!92/2!'>('!G$/2!'>(&!DEELEEE!2G(*+0!>(-!

)22&!02&'!'$!34"55!(&-!G$/2!'>(&!;L<EE!#$GG2&'0!>(-!)22&!0%)G*''2-!'$!'>2!1%)+*#!#$GG2&'!

A$/%G0!0*&#2!'>2!*&*'*(+!34P!(11+*#('*$&R!bA!'>202L!QEE!#$GG2&'0!(&-![[L[Bc!2G(*+0!>(-!)22&!

/2#2*82-!0*&#2!'>2!C(&%(/,![L!DEEB!1$0'*&J!$A!'>2!1/$1$02-!/2J*0'/,!(J/22G2&'R!.>2!Z$(/-!(+0$!

-*0#%002-!'>2!2T'2&'!$A!'>2!)%/-2&!)2*&J!1+(#2-!$&!34P!'$!0>$9!'>('!'>2!2&'*/2!01$&0$/*&J!

#$GG%&*',!0%11$/'0!'>2!#/2('*$&!$A!'>2!RTTT!-$G(*&R!a$G2!Z$(/-!G2G)2/0!/(*02-!9>('!'>2,!

-20#/*)2-!(0!(!/2#2&'!+(#S!$A!0%11$/'!A$/!'>2!-2A*&2-!#$GG%&*',!$)02/82-!*&!&2J('*82!2G(*+0!(&-!

1%)+*#!#$GG2&'0R!d+'*G('2+,L!'>2!Z$(/-!/20$+82-!'>('!?(!G(e$/*',!$A!'>2!Z$(/-!>(0!02/*$%0!

#$&#2/&0I!()$%'!'>2!%&-2/+,*&J!01$&0$/2-!#$GG%&*',!0%11$/'L!(&-!'>('!34P!0>$%+-!1/$8*-2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

162!P$>(G2-!a>(/*+!.(/G*\*!'$!f*&'!42/AL!X2)/%(/,!DL!DEEBL!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2L!>''16gg999R*#(&&R$/Jg2&g#$//201$&-2&#2g'(/G*\*]'$]#2/A]EDA2)EBR1-AR!163!3)*-R!!164!3)*-R!!165!3)*-R!!166!34"55L!?a12#*(+!P22'*&J!$A!'>2!Z$(/-LI!X2)/%(/,!;DL!DEEBL!>''16gg999R*#(&&R$/Jg2&gG*&%'20gG*&%'20];DA2)EBR>'GR!!

Page 115: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

>%/'?2/!*&>$/@('*$&!'$!34"55!'$!?2+1!-2'2/@*&2!9?2'?2/!'?2!01$&0$/0?*1!#/*'2/*(!?(-!)22&!@2'A!

.(/@*B*!0'('2-!-%/*&C!'?*0!@22'*&C!'?('!'?2!D2)/%(/,!EF!EGGH!+2''2/!02&'!'$!I*&'!42/>!02/82-!(0!'?2!

J"4K0!$>>*#*(+!(-8*#2!$&!'?2!#%//2&'!1/$1$02-!/2C*0'/,!(C/22@2&'A!!

34L!/201$&-2-!$&!L(/#?!MF!EGGH!'$!'?2!N$(/-K0!/2O%20'!>$/!*&>$/@('*$&!(&-!1/$8*-2-!(!+*0'!$>!

P1/2Q/202/8(&'0R!#$@1*+2-!>/$@!'?2!+(0'!0*S!@$&'?0A;TH!.?*0!+*0'!9(0!C2&2/('2-!'?/$%C?!34LK0!

P1/2Q/202/8('*$&R!*&*'*('*82F!9?*#?!U'%(/'!V(9+2,!?(-!-*0#%002-!*&!?*0!L(,!WGF!EGGT!+2''2/!'$!I*&'!

42/>A;TM!"''(#?2-!'$!'?2!+2''2/!92/2!$82/!HXFGGG!1/2Q/202/8('*$&0!$>!-$@(*&!&(@2!0'/*&C0!

012#*>*#(++,!/2O%20'2-!),!92)@(0'2/0F!'$'(+*&C!X<T!1(C20A!"!&%@)2/!$>!0'('*0'*#0!*&!>(8$/!$>!

#$@@%&*',!01$&0$/0?*1!92/2!(+0$!&$'2-!*&!'?*0!+2''2/A!

.?2!N$(/-!?2+-!*'0!&2S'!012#*(+!@22'*&C!$&!L(/#?!;EF!EGGHA!"'!'?*0!@22'*&CF!'?2!N$(/-!2&C(C2-!*&!

(&$'?2/!+2&C'?,!-*0#%00*$&!#$&#2/&*&C!'?2!1/$1$02-!ASSS!/2C*0'/,!(C/22@2&'!(&-!9?2'?2/!'?2!

01$&0$/0?*1!#/*'2/*(!?(-!)22&!@2'A!.?2!N$(/-!@22'*&C!@*&%'20!&$'2-!'?('!@$0'!@2@)2/0!>2+'!'?2!

N$(/-!0?$%+-!?$+-!$>>!8$'*&C!$&!'?2!(11+*#('*$&!%&'*+F!$/!(>'2/F!'?2!V*0)$&!@22'*&CF!9?*#?!9(0!'9$!

922Y0!(9(,A!.?2!@*&%'20!(+0$!*&-*#('2-!'?('F!(C(*&F!.(/@*B*!&$'2-!'?('!'?2!N$(/-!#$%+-!022Y!

P(--*'*$&(+!(-8*#2!>/$@!'?2!J"4R!1/*$/!'$!'?2!V*0)$&!@22'*&C0F!)%'!0%#?!(!/2O%20'!9$%+-!&22-!'$!

)2!@(-2!P2S12-*'*$%0+,AR!.(/@*B*!(+0$!&$'2-!'?('!0$@2!J"4!@2@)2/0!/2@(*&2-!(-(@(&'+,!

(C(*&0'!'?2!#/2('$&!$>!'?2!ASSS!0.VZA;T[!

.?2!J"4!/21/202&'('*820!('!'?*0!@22'*&C!\.(/@*B*!(&-!](&*0!^(/Y+*&0_!(0Y2-!*>!(!/201$&02!'$!'?2!

J"4K0!/2O%20'!>$/!@$/2!*&>$/@('*$&!$&!'?2!N$(/-K0!]%&2!EGGX!-2#*0*$&!9$%+-!)2!1/$8*-2-!1/*$/!

'$!'?2!V*0)$&!@22'*&C0A!3&!/201$&02F!P'?2!4?(*/@(&!0(*-!'?('!(!/201$&02!9$%+-!)2!1/$8*-2-R`!'?2!

@*&%'20!0'('2-!'?('!P'?*0!9(0!#$&>*/@2-!),!a(%+!.9$@2,FR!9?$!1$*&'2-!$%'!'?('!0$@2!1/28*$%0!

+2''2/0!92/2!/201$&0*82!'$!'?2!J"4K0!/2O%20'0!(&-!0$@2!P(--*'*$&(+!#+(/*',!(/$%&-!'?2!J"4K0!

(-8*#2!#$%+-!)2!1/202&'2-!$&!'?*0!@(''2/AR;HG!

.?2!J"4!/2O%20'!9(0!(&092/2-!$&!L(/#?!;<F!EGGHF!*&!(!$&2Q1(C2!+2''2/!>/$@!I*&'!42/>A;H;!42/>!

(C(*&!&$'2-!'?('!'?2!#$@@%&*#('*$&0!>/$@!34"55!$&!D2)/%(/,!;;!(&-!L(,!<F!EGGT!#$&'(*&2-!'?2!

*&>$/@('*$&!'?2!J"4!/2O%20'2-A!42/>!(+0$!0'('2-!'?('!'?2!N$(/-!9(0!P0'*++!/28*29*&C!'?2!@('2/*(+0!

(&-!?(b-c!&$'!@(-2!(!-2'2/@*&('*$&!(0!'$!9?2'?2/!'?2!/28*0*$&0!'$!'?2!34L!72C*0'/,!#$&'/(#'!

#$&'(*&!'?2!&2#200(/,!2&>$/#2()+2!1/$8*0*$&0AR!42/>!(#Y&$9+2-C2-!'?('!0$@2!@2@)2/0!$>!'?2!J"4!

92/2!$11$02-!'$!'?2!#/2('*$&!$>!'?2!ASSS!0.VZ!(&-!'?('!'?2,!?(-!/2O%20'2-!'?('!'?2!>*&(+!-2#*0*$&!

)2!-2+(,2-!%&'*+!'?2!V*0)$&!@22'*&C0A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

167!U'%(/'!V(9+2,!'$!I*&'!42/>!(&-!34"55!N$(/-F!L(/#?!MF!EGGHF!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2F!?''16dd999A*#(&&A$/Cd#$//201$&-2&#2d#$82/Q+2''2/Q1/2Q/202/8('*$&Q((''A1->A!!168!U'%(/'!V(9+2,!'$!I*&'!42/>F!L(,!WGF!EGGTF!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2F!?''16dd999A*#(&&A$/Cd2&d#$//201$&-2&#2d+(9+2,Q'$Q#2/>QWG@(,GTA1->A!169!3)*-A!170!3)*-A!!171!I*&'!42/>!'$!L$?(@2-!U?(/*+!.(/@*B*F!L(/#?!;<F!EGGHF!34"55!4$//201$&-2&#2F!?''16dd999A*#(&&A$/Cd#$//201$&-2&#2d#2/>Q'$Q'(/@*B*QY(/Y+*&0Q;<L(/GHA1->A!!

Page 116: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

.>2!?"4!@*0)$&!A22'*&B0!92/2!>2+-!*&!+('2!C(/#>D!.>2!@*0)$&!4$AA%&*E%F!9(0!*00%2-!$&!C(/#>!

GHI!GJJKD;KG!L*'>!/2B(/-!'$!DMMMI!'>2!@*0)$&!4$AA%&*E%F!/2A(/N2-!'>('!'>2!OL2++*&B'$&!

4$AA%&*E%F!/2A(*&0!(!8(+*-!(&-!*A1$/'(&'!2M1/200*$&!$P!'>2!?"4Q0!8*290!$&!DMMMR!(&-!'>('!'>2!

?"4!O-$20!&$'!#$&0*-2/!'>2!*&P$/A('*$&!1/$8*-2-!),!'>2!S$(/-!'$!>(82!(&092/2-!'>2!?"4!

#$&#2/&0!(0!'$!9>2'>2/!'>2!34C!(11+*#('*$&!A22'0!'>2!01$&0$/0>*1!#/*'2/*(DR;KT!!

.>2!4$AA%&*E%F!(+0$!)/*&B0!(''2&'*$&!'$!'>2!4(&(-*(&!B$82/&A2&'Q0!#$AA2&'0I!9>*#>!>(-!)22&!

1$0'2-!'$!'>2!34"55!1%)+*#!P$/%A0D!.>202!#$AA2&'0!/(*02-!#$&#2/&0!'>('!34"55!9(0!A$8*&B!

'$9(/-0!(&!O$&B$*&B!A(&(B2A2&'!(&-!$82/0*B>'!/$+2!/2B(/-*&B!3&'2/&2'!#$&'2&'I!9>*#>!9$%+-!)2!

*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!*'0!'2#>&*#(+!A(&-('2DR;KU!

V$++$9*&B!'>2!?"4!A22'*&B0!*&!@*0)$&I!'>2!34"55!S$(/-!(+0$!>2+-!(!A22'*&B!$&!C(/#>!TJI!

GJJKD;K<!W%/*&B!'>*0!A22'*&BI!'>2!S$(/-!-2'2/A*&2-!'>('!'>2!34C!(11+*#('*$&!P(*+2-!'$!A22'!'>2!

01$&0$/2-!#$AA%&*',!#/*'2/*(!*&!'>2!7VX!012#*P*#('*$&!(&-I!)(02-!$&!'>2!2M'2&0*82!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!

*00%20!/(*02-!*&!'>2!?"4!4$AA%&*E%F0I!*'!9$%+-!&$'!)2!(11/$1/*('2!P$/!'>2!S$(/-!'$!(11/$82!'>2!

34C!(11+*#('*$&!$/!'>2!/28*02-!(B/22A2&'D!4$&02E%2&'+,I!'>2!S$(/-!8$'2-!'$!/2Y2#'!'>2!34C!

(11+*#('*$&!*&!*'0!2&'*/2',D!

!"#$$%&'(&)*+,-.$,/$*0&$1234.$5,6&$+-$*0&$"777$%',(&..$89.&:$,-$8&';<9-$39.&$

=*>:?$@-*&'A+&B.$

3&-*8*-%(+0!9>$!>(82!)22&!*&'2/8*292-!*&!'>2!#$%/02!$P!-282+$1*&B!'>*0!#(02!0'%-,!0>(/2-!

-*PP2/2&'!$)02/8('*$&0!/2B(/-*&B!'>2!*&'2/(#'*$&!)2'922&!'>2!?"4!(&-!'>2!34"55!S$(/-!-%/*&B!

'>2!28(+%('*$&!$P!'>2!DMMM!(11+*#('*$&D!Z$A2!*&'2/8*29220!0%BB20'2-!(!#+(0>!$P!*&0'*'%'*$&(+!

#%+'%/20!'>('!*&>*)*'2-!)2''2/!#$AA%&*#('*$&D!['>2/0!#*'2-!(!+(#N!$P!(11/2#*('*$&!$&!'>2!1(/'!$P!

'>2!34"55!S$(/-!P$/!'>2!/$+2!$P!'>2!?"4!(&-!'>2!-*PP*#%+'!1$+*'*#(+!#>(++2&B20!P(#2-!),!(&!*&'2/\

B$82/&A2&'(+!)$-,I!(++!9*'>!-$A20'*#!#$&0'*'%2&#*20!'$!9>*#>!'>2,!A%0'!(&092/D!['>2/!$)02/82/0!

*&-*#('2-!'>('!'>2!0#>2-%+2!$P!'>2!1$+*#,\A(N*&B!1/$#200!-*-!&$'!(++$9!0%PP*#*2&'!'*A2!P$/!?"4!'$!

$PP2/!(-8*#2!'$!'>2!34"55!S$(/-D!Z$A2!$P!'>$02!*&'2/8*29220!-20#/*)2-!(!+(#N!$P!#+(/*',!/2B(/-*&B!

9>('!#$&0'*'%'2-!?"4!(-8*#2!'$!'>2!34"55!S$(/-D!['>2/0!0%BB20'2-!'>('!'>2!?"4!-*-!&$'!$PP2/!

'*A2+,!(-8*#2!$&!'>2!DMMM!-2#*0*$&!)2#(%02!A2A)2/0!)2+*282-!'>('!'>2!#(02!9(0!#+$02-D;K]!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

172!?"4I!O4$AA%&*E%F!GH^@*0)$&IR!C(/#>!GHI!GJJKI!UI!>''16__B(#D*#(&&D$/B_0,0'2A_P*+20_?"4`GH`@*0)$&`4$AA%&*E%2D1-PD!!173!3)*-D!!174!3)*-D!('!<D!!175!34"55I!OC22'*&B!$P!'>2!34"55!S$(/-I!@*0)$&IR!C(/#>!GHI!GJJKI!>''16__999D*#(&&D$/B_2&_A*&%'20_/20$+%'*$&0\TJA(/JKD>'Aa`.$#T]HK]<GUD!176!3&'2/8*290I!Z21'2A)2/!(&-![#'$)2/!GJ;JD!

Page 117: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

!""#$%"&'(%)%'(%'*"+%,-%."/0'%12"&34",5"&3677"

!"#$%&'()(&'(&*$+(,-(.$+(/0(1*1$2&'$*3($%&'()(&'(&*$+(,-(.$42&(5$-&$

%678891$:;52.1$

.>2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!?(&2+!@37?A!*0!$&2!$B!'>/22!2C*0'*&D!E2#>(&*0E0!1%/1$02-!B$/!'>2!

/28*29!$B!34"55!F$(/-!(#'*8*'*20!(&-!-2#*0*$&0!@'>2!$'>2/!'9$!E2#>(&*0E0!(/2!'>2!GE)%-0E(&!

(&-!72#$&0*-2/('*$&!72H%20'0AI!"/'*#+2!3JK!L2#'*$&!M!$B!'>2!34"55!F,+(90!0'('20!'>('K!N(&,!12/0$&!

E('2/*(++,!(BB2#'2-!),!(!-2#*0*$&!$/!(#'*$&!),!'>2!F$(/-!'>('!>2!$/!0>2!(002/'0!*0!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!

'>2!"/'*#+20!$B!3&#$/1$/('*$&!$/!F,+(90!E(,!0%)E*'!(!/2H%20'!B$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29IO177!G&#2!

0%)E*''2-K!(!/2H%20'!B$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29!*0!N/2B2//2-!'$!(&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!?(&2+!@37?AO!

9>*#>!#$E1(/20!'>2!N#$&'20'2-!(#'*$&0!$B!'>2!F$(/-!'$!'>2!"/'*#+20!$B!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!F,+(90O!

(&-!%+'*E('2+,!-2#+(/20!N9>2'>2/!'>2!F$(/-!>(0!(#'2-!#$&0*0'2&'+,!9*'>O!'>2!1/$8*0*$&0!#$&'(*&2-!

'>2/2*&I178!

"'!'>2!/2H%20'!$B!2*'>2/!-*01%'*&D!1(/',K!'>2!/2H%20'!B$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29!#(&!)2!>2(/-!),!(!

'>/22PE2E)2/!1(&2+!$B!(/)*'2/0Q!>$9282/K!*B!'>2!1(/'*20!-$!&$'!$1'!B$/!(!'>/22PE2E)2/!1(&2+K!'>2!

/2H%20'!*0!#$&0*-2/2-!),!(!$&2PE2E)2/!1(&2+I179!3&!2*'>2/!#(02K!'>2!1(&2+!'>('!#$&0*-2/0!'>2!

/2H%20'!B$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29!>(0!'>2!1$92/!'$6!!

(A /2H%20'!(--*'*$&(+!9/*''2&!0%)E*00*$&0!B/$E!'>2!1(/',!022R*&D!/28*29K!'>2!F$(/-K!'>2!

L%11$/'*&D!G/D(&*S('*$&0K!$/!B/$E!$'>2/!1(/'*20Q!

)A -2#+(/2!'>('!(&!(#'*$&!$/!*&(#'*$&!$B!'>2!F$(/-!9(0!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!'>2!"/'*#+20!$B!

3&#$/1$/('*$&!$/!F,+(90Q!(&-!

#A /2#$EE2&-!'>('!'>2!F$(/-!0'(,!(&,!(#'*$&!$/!-2#*0*$&K!$/!'>('!'>2!F$(/-!'(R2!(&,!

*&'2/*E!(#'*$&K!%&'*+!0%#>!'*E2!(0!'>2!F$(/-!/28*290!(&-!(#'0!%1$&!$1*&*$&!$B!'>2!37?I180!

.>2!37?!E(R20!N*'0!B*&(+!-2#+(/('*$&!)(02-!0$+2+,!$&!'>2!-$#%E2&'('*$&K!0%11$/'*&D!E('2/*(+0K!

(&-!(/D%E2&'0!0%)E*''2-!),!'>2!1(/'*20O!(&-!N012#*B*#(++,!-20*D&('2T0UO!(!1/28(*+*&D!1(/',I181!.>2!

N1(/',!&$'!1/28(*+*&D!0>(++!$/-*&(/*+,!)2!/201$&0*)+2!B$/!)2(/*&D!(++!#$0'0!$B!'>2!37?!?/$8*-2/KO!(&-!

N2(#>!1(/',!0>(++!)2(/!*'0!$9&!2C12&020IO182!

.$!-('2K!34V!8I!34"55!*0!'>2!$&+,!/2H%20'!B$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29!'>('!>(0!)22&!>2(/-!),!(&!37?!

$&!'>2!E2/*'0I183!3&!'>*0!#(02K!'>2!37?!#$&0*0'2-!$B!(!'>/22PE2E)2/!1(&2+!$B!(/)*'/('$/0!#$&'/(#'2-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

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

Page 118: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

),!'>2!3&'2/&('*$&(+!42&'/2!?$/!@*01%'2!720$+%'*$&A184!.>2!1(&2+!*&#+%-2-!B%-C2!D'21>2&!EA!

D#>92)2+F!B(&!G(%+0$&F!(&-!B%-C2!@*#H/(&!.28/*I*(&A185!

!"#$$%&'()$*+,-+).$/01$%23+4+23+2.$*+56+7$

J&!B%&2!KF!LMMNF!34E!0%)O*''2-!(!/2P%20'!?$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29F!(++2C*&C!'>('!34"55!(#'2-!*&!(!

O(&&2/!Q*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!*'0!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!R,+(90S!),!*O1/$12/+,!(-O*&*0'2/*&C!

'>2!LMMT!7UG!(&-!/2V2#'*&C!34EW0!AXXX!(11+*#('*$&!*&!E(/#>!LMM<A186!34E!/2P%20'2-!?$/!'>2!37G!'$!

-2#+(/2!'>('6!Y;Z!34"55W0!E(/#>!LMM<!/2V2#'*$&!$?!'>2!34E!(11+*#('*$&!9(0!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!'>2!

34"55!R,+(90!(&-!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&F!YLZ!34"55!QO%0'!*OO2-*('2+,!2X2#%'2!(!/2C*0'/,!

(C/22O2&'!$&!'2/O0!(&-!#$&-*'*$&0!0%)0'(&'*(++,!0*O*+(/!'$!34EW0!-/(?'!/2C*0'/,!(C/22O2&'!

1$0'2-!$&!34"55W0!92)0*'2!$&!U2)/%(/,!KF!LMM<FS!(&-!YTZ!'>2!37GW0!Q-2'2/O*&('*$&!/2C(/-*&C!

9>2'>2/!(&,!$?!34"55W0!(#'*$&0!92/2!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!34"55W0!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!

R,+(90!*0!!"#$"#%!$&!34"55AS187!

3&!0%11$/'!$?!'>202!(++2C('*$&0F!34E!(/C%2-!'>('!0282/(+!282&'0!'>/$%C>$%'!34"55W0!28(+%('*$&!$?!

'>2!AXXX!(11+*#('*$&!92/2!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!'>2!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!R,+(90A!

"--*'*$&(++,F!34E!(/C%2-!'>('!'>2!?*82!/2(0$&0!34"55!C(82!*&!0%11$/'!$?!*'0!/2V2#'*$&!92/2!

*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'>!'>2!"/'*#+20!$?!3&#$/1$/('*$&F!R,+(90F!(&-!'>2!9(,!'>2!$'>2/!(11+*#(&'0!92/2!

'/2('2-A188!!

G/*O(/*+,F!34E!(/C%2-!'>('!'>2!B%&2!;F!LMM[!R$(/-!-2#*0*$&!#$&0'*'%'2-!(&!(11/$8(+!$?!'>2!34E!

1/$1$0(+!*&!+*C>'!$?!'>2!7UG!#/*'2/*(F!*&#+%-*&C!'>2!01$&0$/0>*1!#/*'2/*(A189!34E!(/C%2-!'>('!34"55!

>(-!%02-!(!Q'9$\0'21S!1/$#200!9*'>!'>2!$'>2/!(11+*#(&'0F!9>2/2),!(11+*#(&'0!92/2!?*/0'!(11/$82-!

$&!'>2!O2/*'0!$?!'>2!7UG!#/*'2/*(F!Q?$++$92-!),!/2C*0'/,!(C/22O2&'!&2C$'*('*$&S!(&-!2X2#%'*$&A190!

"##$/-*&C!'$!34EF!'>2!AXXX!(11+*#('*$&!9(0!'>2!$&+,!(11+*#('*$&!'>('!-28*('2-!?/$O!'>*0!1/$#200!),!

/2$12&*&C!'>2!01$&0$/0>*1!#/*'2/*(A191!34E!(+0$!0'('2-!'>('!'>2/2!9(0!(!+(#H!$?!Q28*-2&#2!)2?$/2!

'>2!R$(/-!'>('!34EW0!0%11$/'!*&!'>2!#$OO%&*',!9(0!2/$-*&CAS192!]+'*O('2+,F!34E!#+(*O2-!'>('!

Q34"550!/2$12&*&C!$?!'>2!01$&0$/0>*1!#/*'2/*(^9>*#>!*'!-*-!$&+,!'$!34E^9(0!%&?(*/F!

-*0#/*O*&('$/,F!(&-!1/2'2X'%(+F!(&-!(!-21(/'%/2!?/$O!'/(&01(/2&'F!?(*/F!(&-!92++!-$#%O2&'2-!

1$+*#*20AS!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

184!D22!34"55F!Q720$+%'*$&0!"-$1'2-!('!D12#*(+!34"55!R$(/-!E22'*&CS!D12#*(+!E22'*&C!$?!'>2!R$(/-!8*(!.2+21>$&2!;_!"1/*+!LMM`!>''16aa999A*#(&&A$/Ca2&aO*&%'20a/20$+%'*$&0\;_(1/M`A>'OF!9>2&!'>2!34"55!R$(/-!-20*C&('2-!'>2!3&'2/&('*$&(+!42&'/2!?$/!@*01%'2!720$+%'*$&!(0!'>2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!G/$8*-2/AA!185!@2#+(/('*$&!$?!'>2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!G(&2+F!34@7A!4(02!5$A![M!;;<!.!MMLL`!MNF!YU2)/%(/,!;_F!LM;MZ!Y>2/2*&(?'2/!/2?2//2-!'$!(0!'>2!Q37G!@2#+(/('*$&SZF!(8(*+()+2!('!>''16aa999A*#(&&A$/Ca2&a*/1a*#O\8\*#(&&a*/1\1(&2+\-2#+(/('*$&\;_?2);M\2&A1-?A!186!34EF!Q72P%20'!?$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!G/$#200FS!B%&2!NF!LMMNF!>''16aa*#(&&A$/Ca2&a*/1a*#O\8\*#(&&a*#O\*/1\/2P%20'\MKV%&MNA1-?A!!187!3)*-AF!;\L!Y2O1>(0*0!(--2-ZA!188!37G!@2#+(/('*$&F!`[A!189!3)*-A!D22!(+0$!34EF!Q72P%20'!?$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!G/$#200AS!190!34EF!Q72P%20'!?$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!G/$#200FS!L[\LKA!191!3)*-A!192!37G!@2#+(/('*$&F!`[A!

Page 119: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

.>2!37?!/2@%20'!(+0$!#+(*A2-!'>('!'>2!*&-212&-2&'!28(+%('*$&0!*-2&'*B*2-!C/2('2/!-2B*#*2&#*20!*&!

$'>2/!0.DE!(11+*#('*$&0!F*&#+%-*&C!GH$)0!(&-!GA$)*I!(&-!(##21'2-!'>$02!1/$1$0(+0!9*'>!

#$A1(/('*82+,!+*''+2!/20*0'(&#2!B/$A!34"55G;JK!L$/!2M(A1+2N!34O!0'('2-!'>('!PB$++$9*&C!'>2!

&2C$'*('*$&0N!'>2!1/$1$02-!G'/(82+!(&-!GH$)0!/2C*0'/,!(C/22A2&'0!92/2!1$0'2-!$&!'>2!34"55!

92)0*'2!$&!QR!O(/#>!QSSTN!(&-!92/2!(11/$82-!'9$!922U0!+('2/N!$&!<!"1/*+!QSSTGV;JR!"##$/-*&C!'$!

'>2!37?!/2@%20'N!P'>2!1/$#200!B$/!2(#>!(11+*#('*$&!0'*++!B$++$92-!'>2!$/*C*&(+!'9$W0'21!1/$#200!$B!

#/*'2/(!(11/$8(+!B$++$92-!),!/2C*0'/,!(C/22A2&'!&2C$'*('*$&V!(&-!*&!P&$!#(02!$'>2/!'>(&!9*'>!'>2!

GMMM!(11+*#('*$&V!-*-!'>2!X$(/-!+('2/!/282/02!*'0!-2#*0*$&!(B'2/!*'!>(-!8$'2-!*&!B(8$/!$B!

&2C$'*('*$&0G;JT!

"0!(--*'*$&(+!28*-2&#2N!34O!#+(*A2-!P0282/(+!34"55!02&*$/!$BB*#*(+0!(&-!X$(/-!A2A)2/0NV!

*&#+%-*&C!Y*&'!42/BN!Z%/'!?/*'[N!(&-!\$*#>*!3'$!A(-2!#$AA2&'0!'>('!/2B+2#'2-!'>('!'>2!\%&2!;N!QSST!

-2#*0*$&!9(0!(!-2'2/A*&('*$&!'>('!34O!>(-!0('*0B*2-!'>2!7L?!#/*'2/*(G;J]!3&!1(/'*#%+(/N!34O!#+(*A2-!

'>('!42/B!>(-!P*&B$/A2-!'>2!^"4!'>('!34O_0!(11+*#('*$&!>(-!0('*0B*2-!'>2!02+2#'*$&!#/*'2/*(V!('!'>2!

\%+,!QSST!34"55!A22'*&C!*&!D%M2A)$%/CG;J`!!

L*&(++,N!'>2!37?!/2@%20'!1$*&'2-!$%'!'>('!P'>2!^"4!9(0!*&8*'2-!'$!(&-!9(0!$B'2&!/21/202&'2-!('!

A22'*&C!*&!9>*#>!34O_0!(11+*#('*$&!F(&-!$'>2/0I!92/2!-*0#%002-!(&-!-2)('2-V!(&-!B%/'>2/A$/2!

Pa'>2!^"4b!9(0!/2C%+(/+,!1/$8*-2-!9*'>!)/*2B*&C!1(12/0!/2C(/-*&C!'>2!0.DE!7L?!1/$#200N!(&-!*'!

9(0!12/A*''2-!'$!1(/'*#*1('2!*&!'>2!X$(/-_0!-*0#%00*$&0!/2C(/-*&C!34O_0!(11+*#('*$&GV;J<!.>2!#$/2!

$B!'>*0!(/C%A2&'!B$#%020!$&!'>2!+(#U!$B!P(&,!$)H2#'0!'$!'>2!GMMM!0.DE!G!G!G!('!'>2!$%'02'N!9>2&!'>2!

0.DE!28(+%'('*$&!#/*'2/*(!92/2!-2)('2-!(&-!%+'*A('2+,!(11/$82-V!(&-!9>2&!P34"55!/20$+82-!'$!

#$AA2&#2!/2C*0'/,!(C/22A2&'!&2C$'*('*$&0!9*'>!34OGV;JJ!34O!(++2C2-!*&!'>2!37?!72@%20'!'>('!'>2!

^"4!/(*02-!&$!$)H2#'*$&0!'$!'>2!#/2('*$&!$B!GMMM!(&-!'>('!*'!9(0!$&+,!(B'2/!'>2!c&*'2-!d'('20!

E21(/'A2&'!$B!4$AA2/#2!)2C(&!8$*#*&C!*'0!#$&#2/&0!*&!O(/#>!QSS]!'>('!'>2!^"4!)2C(&!'$!'(U2!(!

-*002&'*&C!8*29N!2M1/2002-!A(*&+,!*&!*'0!#$//201$&-2&#2!9*'>!34"55!(&-!*&!'>2!e2++*&C'$&!(&-!

D*0)$&!4$AA%&*@%f0GQSS!!

.>2!37?!/2@%20'!(+0$!/2B2/2&#2-!0'('2A2&'0!B/$A!34"55!X$(/-!A2A)2/0!9>$!/(*02-!-$%)'0!

()$%'!'>2!-2#*0*$&!$&!O(/#>!KSN!QSS`!'$!/2H2#'!34O_0!1/$1$0(+G!?2'2/!E2&C('2!.>/%0>!9(0!@%$'2-!

(0!0(,*&C!'>('!34"55_0!(/C%A2&'!'>('!GMMM!-$20!&$'!/21/202&'!(!P01$&0$/2-!#$AAA%&*',V!9(0!

P1(/'*#%+(/+,!'>*&NV!(&-!'>('!P*B!34"55!*0!C$*&C!'$!/(*02!'>*0!U*&-!$B!$)H2#'*$&N!'>2&!*'!)2''2/!'>*&U!

02/*$%0+,!()$%'!C2''*&C!$%'!$B!'>2!)%0*&200!$B!*&'/$-%#*&C!&29!.DE0GVQS;!d*A*+(/+,N!d%0(&!

4/(9B$/-!(/C%2-!'>('!*B!&$!#$&02&0%0!2M*0'2-!(C(*&0'!'>2!GMMM!.DE!*&!'>2!(-%+'!#$AA%&*',N!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

193!3)*-GN!QTG!194!3)*-G!!195!3)*-GN!QTWQ]G!196!3)*-GN!QJG!197!3)*-GN!QJG!198!3)*-GN!KSG!199!3)*-GN!K;G!200!3)*-GN!K`G!201!3)*-GN!R]G!

Page 120: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;;<=!

'>2&?@A*82&!$%/!B(&-('2!'$!#/2('2!.CD!#$B12'*'*$&?!92!>(82!&$!(%'>$/*',!'$!)+$#E!'>2!(--*'*$&!$F!

'>*0!.CD!'$!'>2!/$$'GHIJI!

34K!(+0$!(/A%2-!'>('!34"55!>(-!&282/!1/2#*02+,!*-2&'*F*2-!9>('!@1%)+*#!1$+*#,H!*00%20!92/2!

/(*02-!),!'>2!34K!(A/22B2&'!'>('!9$%+-!9(//(&'!'>2!/2L2#'*$&!$F!'>2!(11+*#('*$&!*&!*'0!2&'*/2',G203!

3&!1(/'*#%+(/?!34K!#+(*B2-!'>('!34"55M0!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$F!'>2!N2++*&A'$&!4$BB%&*O%P!(&-!

A$82/&B2&'(+!#$//201$&-2&#2?!9>*#>!>(-!(002/'2-!'>('!34K!9(0!'$!'(E2!/201$&0*)*+*',!F$/!

@2&F$/#*&A!'>2!9$/+-M0!8(/*$%0!(&-!-*FF2/2&'!+(90!#$&#2/&*&A!1$/&$A/(1>,H!9(0!@0%FF*#*2&'+,!

()0%/-!(0!'$!>(82!)22&!B(-2!*&!)(-!F(*'>H!(&-!-*0#/*B*&('$/,G204!

"B$&A!'>2!/2B(*&*&A!(/A%B2&'0?!34K!(+0$!#$&'2&-2-!'>('!*'0!1/$1$02-!/2A*0'/,!(A/22B2&'!

#$&'(*&2-!0%FF*#*2&'!1/$8*0*$&0!'$!(--/200!#>*+-!1$/&$A/(1>,!*00%20!(&-!-2'(*+2-!B2#>(&*0B0!

'>('!9$%+-!12/B*'!'>2!*-2&'*F*#('*$&!(&-!F*+'/('*$&!$F!*++2A(+!$/!$FF2&0*82!#$&'2&'G!K$/2$82/?!34K!

#+(*B2-!'>('!34"55M0!8*29!'>('!'>2!34K!1/$1$0(+!/(*02-!@0*A&*F*#(&'!+(9!2&F$/#2B2&'!#$B1+*(&#2!

*00%20H!*&-*#('2-!'>('!'>2!@Q"4!9(0!/2O%*/*&A!34K!'$!2&F$/#2!+$#(+!/20'/*#'*$&0!$&!(##200!'$!*++2A(+!

(&-!$FF2&0*82!#$&'2&'!(&-!*F!R34KS!1/$82-!%&()+2!'$?!34"55!9$%+-!>(82!'$!-$!0$GH!"##$/-*&A!'$!

34K?!'>2!Q"4M0!(-8*#2!/2O%*/2-!34"55!'$!*B1$02!/201$&0*)*+*'*20!$&!34K!'>('!92/2!*&#$&0*0'2&'!

9*'>!34"55M0!'2#>&*#(+!B(&-('2G!!

!"!##$%&''()#*+),-.)+#/-#$%0()#*+12+)/#3-4#$.5+,+.5+./#*+67+8#

34"55!F*+2-!*'0!@7201$&02!'$!34KM0!72O%20'!F$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29H!$&!T21'2B)2/!U?!IJJUG205!3&!

/201$&02!'$!34KM0!(++2A('*$&0!$F!*&#$&0*0'2&#,?!34"55!(/A%2-!'>('6!V;W!34"55M0!#$&0*-2/('*$&!$F!

'>2!34K!1/$1$0(+!9(0!@9-4+!$12&!(&-!'/(&01(/2&'!'>(&!$&2!9$%+-!F*&-!*&!8*/'%(++,!(&,!$'>2/!

#$&'2X'!*&!#$&L%&#'*$&!9*'>!(&,!$'>2/!$/A(&*Y('*$&HZ!VIW!'>2![%&2!;?!IJJ\!-2#*0*$&!'$!2&'2/!*&'$!

&2A$'*('*$&0!-*-!&$'!)*&-!34"55!'$!(9(/-!34K!(!/2A*0'/,!(A/22B2&'!(&-!/2'(*&2-!'>2!()*+*',!'$!

/2L2#'!34KM0!(11+*#('*$&Z!(&-!V]W!34"55!#$%+-!>(82!/2L2#'2-!'>2!(11+*#('*$&!0$+2+,!)(02-!$&!'>2!

/2#$BB2&-('*$&0!F/$B!'>2!3&-212&-2&'!^8(+%('*$&!_(&2+?!)%'!*&0'2(-!(''2B1'2-!'$!9$/E!

@#+$02+,!(&-!*&!A$$-!F(*'>!9*'>!34K!'$!#%/2!(11(/2&'!1/$)+2B0!9*'>!'>2!(11+*#('*$&!(&-!

%+'*B('2+,!-2#*-2-!0%#>!1/$)+2B0!#$%+-!&$'!)2!(--/2002-!),!'>2!(A/22B2&'GH206!!

"--*'*$&(++,?!34"55!(/A%2-!'>('!'>2!@`,+(90!0%11$/'!(!-2F2/2&'*(+!0'(&-(/-!$F!/28*29H!'$!)2!

(11+*2-!*&!'>2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!_/$#200?!@1(/'*#%+(/+,!9*'>!/2012#'!'$!34KM0!#+(*B0GH207!a&!'>*0!

1$*&'?!34"55!(/A%2-!'>('!@(0!+$&A!(0!'>2!`$(/-M0!-*0#%00*$&0!(/2!$12&!(&-!'/(&01(/2&'?!*'0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

202!3)*-G?!bcG!203!3)*-G?!bdG!204!3)*-G!205!34"55?!@34"55M0!7201$&02!'$!34KM0!37_!72O%20'?H!T21'2B)2/?!U?!IJJU?!>''16ee999G*#(&&G$/Ae2&e*/1e*#Bf8f*#(&&e*#(&&f/201$&02f'$f*#Bf/2O%20'fJU021JUG1-FG!!206!3)*-G?!]fbG!207!3)*-G?!bG!

Page 121: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

-2#*0*$&0!(/2!?(-2!*&!@$$-!A(*'BC!(&-!'B2!/2+28(&'!1(/'*20!B(82!)22&!@*82&!(&!$11$/'%&*',!'$!)2!

B2(/-C!'B2/2!*0!(!0'/$&@!1/20%?1'*$&!'B('!'B2!D$(/-E0!-2#*0*$&0!(/2!(11/$1/*('2FG208!

3&!0%11$/'!$A!'B202!(/@%?2&'0C!34"55!*&#+%-2-!(&!2H1+(&('*$&!$A!*'0!I-2#*0*$&J?(K*&@!1/$#20020G!

(&-!I1/$#200!A$/!*&-212&-2&'!/28*29G!9*'B*&!*'0!/201$&02F<=L!3&!'B*0!02#'*$&C!34"55!(/@%2-!'B('!

I'B2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!M/$#200!*0!&$'!(!A$/?!$A!'/(-*'*$&(+!-*01%'2!/20$+%'*$&C!*F2FC!?2-*('*$&!$/!

(/)*'/('*$&CG!(&-!-20#/*)2-!'B2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!M/$#200!(0!(!?2#B(&*0?!I*&'2&-2-!'$!

1/$8*-2!'B2!#$??%&*',!9*'B!(!A$/?(+!1/$#200!A$/!/28*29*&@!012#*A*#!-2#*0*$&0!$A!'B2!34"55!

D$(/-FG!34"55!1$*&'2-!'$!"/'*#+2!3NC!O2#'*$&!PQ;RS!$A!*'0!D,+(90!(&-!#+(*?2-!'B('!'B2!I37ME0!

-2#+(/('*$&!*0!&$'!)*&-*&@!$&!'B2!1(/'*20G!(&-!I'B2!D$(/-C!T9B2/2!A2(0*)+2CEG!*0!$&+,!/2U%*/2-!'$!

I#$&0*-2/!'B2!37ME0!-2#+(/('*$&!('!'B2!D$(/-E0!&2H'!?22'*&@FG<;=!34"55!(+0$!1$*&'2-!$%'!'B('!I'B2!

D,+(90!2H1/200+,!1/$8*-2!'B('!'B2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!0B$%+-!)2!#$&-%#'2-!8*(!T2?(*+!(&-!

$'B2/9*02!8*(!'B2!3&'2/&2'!'$!'B2!?(H*?%?!2H'2&'!A2(0*)+2FG!V&!'B*0!1$*&'C!34"55!(/@%2-!'B('!I'B2!

3&-212&-2&'!728*29!M/$#200!-$20!&$'!012#*A*#(++,!#$&'2?1+('2!'B2!&22-!A$/!(!+*82!B2(/*&@FG<;;!

34"55E0!#2&'/(+!A(#'%(+!#$&'2&'*$&!9(0!'B('!*'0!*&*'*(+!(11/$8(+!$A!'B2!34W!1/$1$0(+!*&!<==R!(&-!

'B2!0%)02U%2&'!#$&'/(#'!&2@$'*('*$&0!92/2!'2&'('*82!(&-!-*-!&$'!#$&0'*'%'2!(!#$??*'?2&'!'$!

(9(/-!(!/2@*0'/,!(@/22?2&'F!34"55!(/@%2-!'B('!*'0!&2@$'*('*$&0!9*'B!34W!92/2!*&'2&-2-!'$!

-2'2/?*&2!9B2'B2/!'B2!'2/?0!$A!(!/2@*0'/,!(@/22?2&'!#$%+-!0('*0A,!'B2!34"55!D$(/-E0!#$&#2/&0!

()$%'!'B2!1/$1$0(+E0!#$?1+*(&#2!9*'B!'B2!0.XY!01$&0$/0B*1!#/*'2/*(F!I.B2!2&'*/2!1/2?*02!$A!34WE0!

/2U%20'Z'B('!1/$#22-*&@!'$!#$&'/(#'!&2@$'*('*$&0!(?$%&'2-!'$!(!@%(/(&'22!'B('!34W!9$%+-!

$)'(*&!(!#$&'/(#'!A$/!'B2!F[[[!.XYZ*0!0*?1+,!A(+02FG<;<!

34"55!(/@%2-!A%/'B2/!'B('!*'0!A*&(+!/2\2#'*$&!$A!34WE0!1/$1$0(+!*&!<==]!I#(?2!(A'2/!2H'2&0*82!

/28*29C!(&(+,0*0!(&-!-2)('2!(?$&@!34"55!D$(/-!?2?)2/0G!(&-!9(0!&$'!(!0*@&!$A!#(1/*#*$%0&200!

*&!*'0!-2#*0*$&J?(K*&@!1/$#20020F!3&0'2(-C!34"55!(/@%2-!*'0!-2#*0*$&!/2A+2#'2-!'B2!A$++$9*&@!

/2(0$&06!

(S 34WE0!(11+*#('*$&!(&-!/28*02-!(@/22?2&'!A(*+2-!'$!?22'C!(?$&@!$'B2/!'B*&@0C!'B2!

I01$&0$/2-!#$??%&*',G!/2U%*/2?2&'!$A!'B2!7^M!012#*A*#('*$&_!

)S `.B2!D$(/-E0!-2#*0*$&!9(0!)(02-a!$&!'B2!2H'2&0*82!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!(&-!'B2!b"4E0!

4$??%&*U%c0C!'B2!(@/22?2&'!/(*02-!#$&0*-2/()+2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!*00%20d#$&#2/&0F!.B2!

(11+*#('*$&!(&-!(@/22?2&'!-*-!&$'!/20$+82!'B2!*00%20!/(*02-!),!'B2!b"4E0!4$??%&*U%c0C!

(&-!'B2!D$(/-!-*-!&$'!)2+*282!'B2!1%)+*#!1$+*#,!#$&#2/&0!#$%+-!)2!#/2-*)+,!/20$+82-!9*'B!

'B2!?2#B(&*0?0!1/$1$02-!),!34W_!!

#S .B2!(11+*#('*$&!/(*02-!0*@&*A*#(&'!+(9!2&A$/#2?2&'!#$?1+*(&#2!*00%20!)2#(%02!$A!

#$%&'/*20E!8(/,*&@!+(90!/2+('*&@!'$!#$&'2&'!(&-!1/(#'*#20!'B('!-2A*&2!'B2!&('%/2!$A!'B2!

(11+*#('*$&_!(&-!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

208!3)*-F!209!3)*-FC!RF!210!3)*-FC!LF!211!3)*-FCLF!212!3)*-FC!eF!

Page 122: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<;=!

-> .?2!@$(/-!(A/22-!9*'?!'?2!B"4C0!D*0)$&!4$EE%&*F%GH!'?('!%&-2/!'?2!/28*02-!

(A/22E2&'H!'?2/2!(/2!#/2-*)+2!0#2&(/*$0!'?('!+2(-!'$!#*/#%E0'(&#20!*&!9?*#?!34"55!

9$%+-!)2!I$/#2-!'$!(00%E2!(&!$&A$*&A!E(&(A2E2&'!(&-!$82/0*A?'!/$+2!/2A(/-*&A!

#$&'2&'!$&!'?2!3&'2/&2'H!9?*#?!*0!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'?!*'0!'2#?&*#(+!E(&-('2J<;K!!

34"55!/2F%20'2-!'?('!'?2!37L!-2#+(/2!'?('!'?2!34"55!@$(/-C0!-2#*0*$&0H!M()02&'!(!0?$9*&A!$I!)(-!

I(*'?HN!(/2!2&'*'+2-!'$!-2I2/2&#2!I/$E!34O!(&-!'?2!37LJ<;P!"--*'*$&(++,H!34"55!(/A%2-!'?('H!

#$&'/(/,!'$!34OC0!#+(*E0H!*'!(#'2-!*&!I%++!(##$/-!9*'?!*'0!@,+(90!(&-!*'0!"/'*#+20!$I!3&#$/1$/('*$&J<;Q!

!"#$$%&'()*+&,+-.$',/$012$2345/&&$

.?2!37L!1/$#200!*0!A$82/&2-!),!'?2!3&'2/&('*$&(+!"/)*'/('*$&!7%+20!$I!'?2!"E2/*#(&!"/)*'/('*$&!

"00$#*('*$&C0!3&'2/&('*$&(+!42&'/2!I$/!R*01%'2!720$+%'*$&!S34R7>!9*'?!0%11+2E2&'(/,!1/$#2-%/(+!

E$-*I*#('*$&0!012#*I*#(++,!'(*+$/2-!'$!34"55J216!.?2!34"55!@,+(90!$II2/!'?2!37L!1/$8*-2/H!34R7H!

#$&0*-2/()+2!+('*'%-2!'$!M20'()+*0?!$12/('*&A!/%+20!(&-!1/$#2-%/20JN!3&!'2/E0!$I!'?2!1/$#2-%/(+!

(012#'0!$I!'?2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29H!'?2!34"55!@,+(90!0'('2!'?2!I$++$9*&A6!

!"#$%&'%#($#)''*#(+'#,$-(-#."&#/0%&'"-#$1#2"&'*'"&'"(#%'32'4#.-#5$4#.-#*$--2/5'6#(+'#!78#

-+$05&#,$"&0,(#2(-#*%$,''&2"9-#/:#';<.25#."&#$(+'%42-'#32.#(+'#!"('%"'(#($#(+'#<.=2<0<#

'=('"(#1'.-2/5'>#?+'%'#"','--.%:6#(+'#!78#<.:#+$5&#<''(2"9-#/:#('5'*+$"'>217#

3&!*'0!M7201$&02!'$!34OC0!72F%20'!I$/!3&-212&-2&'!728*29HN!34"55!(/A%2-!'?('!'?*0!1/$8*0*$&!

*&-*#('2-!'?('!'?2!M3&-212&-2&'!728*29!L/$#200!-$20!&$'!012#*I*#(++,!#$&'2E1+('2!'?2!&22-!I$/!(!

+*82!?2(/*&AJN218!"--*'*$&(++,H!34"55!(/A%2-!'?('!'?*0!1/$8*0*$&!(+0$!1/$8*-2-!'?2!$1'*$&!I$/!(!

F%*#TH!+$9!#$0'!/28*29H!#$&-%#'2-!$82/!'2+21?$&2!(&-!2E(*+J!!

.?2!@2/TE(&!'2(E!9(0!%&()+2!'$!+$#('2!(&!$II*#*(+!-$#%E2&'!$&!/2#$/-!*&!9?*#?!'?2!37LH!34OH!$/!

34"55!(#T&$9+2-A2!(!/20$+%'*$&!'$!'?202!F%20'*$&0!/(*02-!),!34"55J!U$9282/H!(##$/-*&A!'$!

*&'2/8*29220H!'?2!37L!(11(/2&'+,!-2'2/E*&2-!*&!(&!%&1%)+*0?2-!-2#*0*$&!'?('!(+'?$%A?!'?2!

@,+(90!(&-!V%11+2E2&'(/,!L/$#2-%/20!2&#$%/(A2!#$&-%#'*&A!'?2!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!F%*#T+,!

$82/!'2+21?$&2H!3&'2/&2'H!(&-!$'?2/!2+2#'/$&*#!E2(&0H!'?2!1/$#2-%/20!A*82!'?2!34R7!1(&2+*0'0!

#+2(/!-*0#/2'*$&!'$!?$+-!+*82!?2(/*&A0J219!3&-22-H!9?('!I$++$92-!9(0!(!'92&',WE$&'?!I%++!

(/)*'/('*$&!1/$#200!9*'?!I%++!-$#%E2&'('*$&H!9*'&200!'20'*E$&,H!2X12/'!$1*&*$&!(&-!#/$00W

2X(E*&('*$&J!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

213!3)*-JH!KYZK[J!214!3)*-JH!K[!IIJ!215!3)*-JH!PK!IIJ!216!34R7H!MV%11+2E2&'(/,!L/$#2-%/20!I$/!34"55!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!L/$#200HN!?''16\\999J(-/J$/A\01J(01]*-^K<;[_J!217!34"55!@,+(90H!"/'*#+2!3`H!V2#'*$&!KS;a>H!"%A%0'!QH!<a;aH!?''16\\*#(&&J$/A\2&\A2&2/(+\),+(90J?'EJ!218!34"55H!M34"55C0!7201$&02!'$!34OC0!37L!72F%20'HN!V21'2E)2/!YH!<aaYH!?''16\\999J*#(&&J$/A\2&\*/1\*#EW8W*#(&&\*#(&&W/210$&02W'$W*#EW/2F%20'WaY021aYJ1-IJ!219!3&'2/8*290H!V21'2E)2/!(&-!b#'$)2/!<a;aJ!

Page 123: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<<=!

!"#$$%&'()*+,$(-$./&$%&)*.01$2*.-&00$3.+.&'&-.01$+-4$567&).$8&7().0$

>&!?(&%(/,!<<@!<AAB@!34C!D*+2-!*'0!E2E$/*(+!$&!'F2!E2/*'0@!$%'+*&*&G!34"55H0!$/G(&*I('*$&(+!

F*0'$/,!(&-!*'0!0%##200*82!#(++0!D$/!1/$1$0(+0!D$/!&29!.JK0L!34C!/2(DD*/E2-!*'0!(/G%E2&'!'F('!

34"55!F(-!8*$+('2-!*'0!"/'*#+20!$D!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!*'0!M,+(90!(&-!'F('!34"55H0!(#'*$&0!92/2!

*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'F!N/2+28(&'!1/*&#*1+20!$D!3&'2/&('*$&(+!J(9O!(&-!N/2+28(&'!1/*&#*1+20!$D!4(+*D$/&*(!

+(9LO<<A!34C!(+0$!0%)E*''2-!'20'*E$&,!D/$E!P'%(/'!J(9+2,!Q4F(*/E(&!(&-!R/20*-2&'!$D!34CS@!?L!

M2#T9*'F!QNM2#T,OS!M%//!QD$/E2/!(-8*0$/!'$!'F2!U.4@!D$/E2/!(-8*0$/!'$!'F2!5.3"@!(&-!+2G(+!

#$%&02+!'$!34C!*&!#$&&2#'*$&!9*'F!*'0!<AAV!0.JK!0%)E*00*$&S@!W+*I()2'F!X*++*(E0!Q#$&0%+'(&'!'$!

34"55!-%/*&G!*'0!0$+*#*'('*$&0!D$/!.JK!1/$1$0(+0S@!C*+'$&!C%2++2/!Q1/$D200$/!('!'F2!P,/(#%02!

Y&*82/0*',!P#F$$+!$D!3&D$/E('*$&!P'%-*20S@!(&-!?(#T!Z$+-0E*'F!Q1/$D200$/!('![(/8(/-!J(9!

P#F$$+SL<<;!!

3&!*'0!/201$&02!'$!34CH0!E2E$/*(+!$&!'F2!E2/*'0@!34"55!(/G%2-!'F('!34C!F(-!E*0#F(/(#'2/*I2-!

'F2!+(90!(11+,*&G!'$!'F2!37R!1/$#22-*&G0@!'F('!34CH0!D(#'%(+!#+(*E0!92/2!*&#$//2#'@!(&-!'F('!

34"55!F(-!(#'2-!*&!#$E1+2'2!(##$/-!9*'F!*'0!"/'*#+20!$D!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!*'0!M,+(90L<<<!34"55!

(+0$!0%)E*''2-!'20'*E$&,!D/$E!\*&'!42/D!Q'F2&]\R!('!Z$$G+2@!D$/E2/!4F(*/E(&!$D!'F2!M$(/-!('!

34"55S@!R(%+!.9$E2,!Q'F2&]4W>!(&-!R/20*-2&'!$D!34"55@!D$/E2/!4F(*/E(&!$D!'F2!Z"4S@!

"+2^(&-/$!R*0(&',!QD$/E2/!M$(/-!E2E)2/!$D!34"55S@!(&-!K(8*-!4(/$&!Q1/$D200$/!$D!+(9!('!Y4!

M2/T2+2,@!(/)*'/('$/SL<<_!

!"9$:/&$;8<=0$>&?,+)+.*(-$

>&!U2)/%(/,!;`@!<A;A@!'F2!37R!-2#*-2-!<a;!*&!D(8$/!$D!34CL224!.F/22!T2,!F$+-*&G0!#(E2!D/$E!'F*0!

-2#*0*$&L!U*/0'@!'F2!1(&2+!-2'2/E*&2-!'F('!'F2!F$+-*&G0!$D!'F2!37R!(/2!(-8*0$/,!*&!&('%/2!(&-!-$!

&$'!#$&0'*'%'2!)*&-*&G!(/)*'/(+!(9(/-0L225!P2#$&-@!'F2!1(&2+!-2'2/E*&2-!'F('!N'F2!(#'*$&0!(&-!

-2#*0*$&0!$D!'F2!34"55!M$(/-!(/2!&$'!2&'*'+2-!'$!-2D2/2&#2!9F2'F2/!),!(11+*#('*$&!$D!'F2!

b)%0*&200!^%-GE2&'!/%+2H!$/!$'F2/9*02c!'F2,!(/2!'$!)2!(11/(*02-!&$'!-2D2/2&'*(++,!)%'!

$)^2#'*82+,LO226!U*&(++,@!'F2!37R!(+0$!-2'2/E*&2-!'F('!N'F2!M$(/-!$D!34"55!*&!(-$1'*&G!*'0!

/20$+%'*$&0!$D!?%&2!;@!<AAd@!D$%&-!'F('!'F2!(11+*#('*$&!$D!34C!72G*0'/,!D$/!'F2!Leee!.JK!E2'!'F2!

/2f%*/2-!01$&0$/0F*1!#/*'2/*(LO227!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

220!34"55@!N34CH0!C2E$/*(+!$&!'F2!C2/*'0@O!?(&%(/,!<<@!<AA`@!F''16gg999L*#(&&L$/Gg2&g*/1g*#E]8]*#(&&g*#E]E2E$/*(+]$&]E2/*'0]<<^(&A`]2&L1-D@!*8!a!8L!221!34"55@!NX*'&200!P'('2E2&'0!(&-!We12/'!721$/'!P%)E*''2-!*&!P%11$/'!$D!34CH0!C2E$/*(+!$&!'F2!C2/*'0@O!?(&%(/,!<<@!<AA`@!F''16gg999L*#(&&L$/Gg2&g*/1g*#E]8]*#(&&g0%11$/'*&G]-$#%E2&'('*$&]D$/]*#EE2E$/*(+]<<^(&A`]2&L1-DL!222!34"55@!N34"55H0!7201$&02!'$!34CH0!C2E$/*(+!$&!'F2!C2/*'0@O!C(,!B@!<AA`@!F''16gg999L*#(&&L$/Gg2&g*/1g*#E]8]*#(&&g*#(&&]/201$&02]D$/]*#E]E2E$/*(+]$&]E2/*'0]ABE(,A`]2&L1-DL!223!34"55@!NX*'&200!P'('2E2&'0!(&-!We12/'!721$/'!0%)E*''2-!*&!0%11$/'!$D!34"55H0!7201$&02!'$!34CH0!C2E$/*(+!$&!'F2!C2/*'0@O!C(,!B@!<AA`@!F''16gg999L*#(&&L$/Gg2&g*/1g*#E]8]*#(&&g0%11$/'*&G]-$#%E2&'('*$&]*#(&&]/201$&02]ABE(,A`]2&L1-DL!224!34"55@!N3&-212&-2&'!728*29!R(&2+!K2#+(/('*$&@O!U2)/%(/,!;`@!<A;A@!F''16gg999L*#(&&L$/Gg2&g*/1g*#E8]*#(&&g*/1]1(&2+]-2#+(/('*$&];`D2);A]2&L1-DL!225!3)*-L@!hAL!226!3)*-L!227!3)*-L!

Page 124: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

.?2!37@!&$'2-!'?('!(+'?$%A?!'?2/2!B*0!(!C2(0%/2!$D!(C)*A%*',!*&!'?2!12/'*&2&'!1/$8*0*$&0!$D!'?2!

E,+(90FG!'?2!%02!$D!'?2!1?/(02!B!"#$%&'()%!9?2'?2/!(&!(#'*$&!$/!*&(#'*$&!$D!'?2!E$(/-!9(0!

*&#$&0*0'2&'G!0%11$/'2-!(&!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!'?('!37@!-2#*0*$&0!92/2!*&'2&-2-!'$!)2!(-8*0$/,F!(&-!

&$'!)*&-*&A!$&!'?2!34"55!E$(/-H!3&!1(/'*#%+(/F!'?2!37@!+*I2&2-!'?*0!'$!(!/2#$CC2&-('*$&!/('?2/!

'?(&!(!)*&-*&A!$/-2/H!J$/2$82/F!'?2!37@!(+0$!-20#/*)2-!'?2!1/$8*0*$&!$D!"/'*#+2!3KF!L2#'*$&!=M;NOF!

9?*#?!0'('20F!B9?2/2!D2(0*)+2F!'?2!E$(/-!0?(++!#$&0*-2/!'?2!37@!-2#+(/('*$&!('!'?2!E$(/-P0!&2Q'!

C22'*&AG!(0!(!B/2+(Q2-!'2C1$/(+!1/$8*0$G!9?2/2!'?2!E$(/-!?(0!B'$!-$!&$!C$/2!'?(&!&"*+,$%)!'?2!

37@!-2#+(/('*$&HG 228

!R+'*C('2+,F!'?2!E$(/-!D$%&-!'?('!'?2!+$$02!&('%/2!$D!'?2!+(&A%(A2!

B2C1?(0*S2T-U!'?('!T'?2!37@!-2#+(/('*$&U!*0!&$'!)*&-*&AHG229!52Q'F!'?2!37@!-2'2/C*&2-!'?('!

3&-212&-2&'!728*29!*0!#$&-%#'2-!$%#*"-"!(&-F!'?%0F!B34"55!E$(/-!-2#*0*$&0!-$!&$'!2&V$,!(!

-2D2/2&'*(+!0'(&-(/-!$D!/28*29HG230!W&!'?*0!1$*&'F!'?2!37@!-2'2/C*&2-!'?('!'?2!"/'*#+20!$D!

3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!E,+(90F!9?*#?!/2X%*/2F!(C$&A!$'?2/!'?*&A0F!B34"55!'$!#(//,!$%'!*'0!(#'*8*'*20!

*&!#$&D$/C*',!9*'?!/2+28(&'!1/*&#*1+20!$D!*&'2/&('*$&(+!+(9F!-$!&$'!012#*D,!$/!*C1+,!'?('!'?2!

3&'2/&('*$&(+!728*29!@/$#200!1/$8*-2-!D$/!0?(++!M$/!0?(++!&$'O!(##$/-!-2D2/2&#2!'$!-2#*0*$&0!$D!

'?2!34"55!E$(/-HG!.?2!37@!(+0$!D$%&-!'?('!'?('!(0!(!4(+*D$/&*(!#$/1$/('*$&F!34"55!C(,!#(++!$&!'?2!

B)%0*&200!V%-AC2&'!/%+2G!9?2&!/2+28(&'!1/$8*0*$&0!*&!'?2!"/'*#+20!$D!3&#$/1$/('*$&!(&-!E,+(90!

(/2!$'?2/9*02!()02&'H231!

"D'2/!(&(+,S*&A!'?2!282&'0!0%//$%&-*&A!'?2!Y%&2!;F!<ZZN!E$(/-!-2#*0*$&!'$!2&'2/!*&'$!&2A$'*('*$&0!

9*'?!34JF!'?2!37@!-2'2/C*&2-!'?('!'?2!B/2#$&0*-2/('*$&!$D!01$&0$/0?*1!#/*'2/*(F!$&#2!'?2!E$(/-!

?(-!D$%&-!'?2C!'$!?(82!)22&!C2'F!9(0!&$'!*&!(##$/-!9*'?!-$#%C2&'2-!1$+*#,HG232!!

!"#$$%&'$'()*+,,$-.,+(/012)3,$40,+5$)3$4+(6703$80,+$91:5;$%31+(/2+<,$

As previously noted, the ICM request for independent review was the first to be heard by an IRP. The

case poses several questions related to the IRP process and the interpretation of the relevant sections of

the Bylaws.

Given the cost and lengthiness of the IRP proceedings, several interviewees questioned whether the

IRP provides an accessible and widely applicable means for reviewing the ICANN Board’s decisions.

Some interviewees stated that the high cost of the proceedings meant that it offers a venue for only the

wealthiest of participants and is not a viable option for the vast majority of ICANN stakeholders.

Others asserted that the cost, risk, and duration of the IRP will mean that no others will be likely to

appeal ICANN decisions via this mechanism, even among those with the financial resources to do

so.233

3&!(--*'*$&!'$!'?2!X%20'*$&0!/(*02-!()$%'!+*C*'0!$D!'?2!37@!(0!(&!(##$%&'()*+*',!C2#?(&*0CF!$'?2/0!

X%20'*$&2-!?$9!34"55P0!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$D!'?2!1/$#200!/2D+2#'0!$&!34"55P0!#$CC*'C2&'!'$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

228!3)*-HF![;!M2C1?(0*0!(--2-OH!229!3)*-H!!230!3)*-H!231!3)*-HF![<H!232!3)*-HF![\H!233!3&'2/8*290F!L21'2C)2/!(&-!W#'$)2/!<Z;ZH!

Page 125: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

(##$%&'()*+*',?!@$A2!*&'2/8*9220!2B1/2002-!'C2!)2+*2D!'C('!34"55E0!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$D!'C2!37FG

'C('!'C2!1/$#200!0C$%+-!&$'!2&'(*+!+*82!'20'*A$&,H!'C('!34"55!0C$%+-!)2!$DD2/2-!-2D2/2&#2!%&-2/!

'C2!)%0*&200!I%-JA2&'!/%+2H!(&-!'C('!'C2!37FK0!-2#*0*$&!0C$%+-!&$'!)2!)*&-*&J!$&!'C2!34"55!

L$(/-G9(0!*&#$&0*0'2&'!9*'C!(&!$/J(&*M('*$&!9*'C!(!A(&-('2!'$!2&0%/2!'C('!*'!*0!(##$%&'()+2!'$!

*'0!0'(N2C$+-2/0?<O=!!

F2/#21'*$&0!(+0$!8(/*2-!9*'C!/2J(/-!'$!'C2!%+'*A('2!2DD2#'*82&200!$D!'C2!37F!(0!(&!(##$%&'()*+*',!

A2#C(&*0A!*&!'C*0!012#*D*#!#(02?!@$A2!(002/'2-!'C('!'C*0!1/$#200!-2A$&0'/('2-!(##$%&'()*+*',H!

J*82&!'C('!(&!(11+*#(&'!D$/!(!&29!.PQ!9(0!()+2!'$!*&*'*('2!'C2!/28*29!1/$#200!(&-!(/J%2!'C2*/!#(02!

$&!'C2!A2/*'0!)2D$/2!*&-212&-2&'!(/)*'/('$/0H!(&-!*&!-$*&J!0$!#$A12++2-!34"55!'$!-2D2&-!'C2!

)(0*0!$D!*'0!(#'*$&0?!R$/2$82/H!37FK0!-2#*0*$&!(112(/0!'$!C(82!#$&8*&#2-!34"55!'$!/282/02!*'0!

-2#*0*$&?!S'C2/!*&'2/8*29220!2B1/2002-!'C2!$1*&*$&!'C('!'C2!()02&02!$D!(!)*&-*&J!/20$+%'*$&!D/$A!

'C2!37F!*0!*&-*#('*82!$D!'C2!D%&-(A2&'(+!+(#N!$D!(##$%&'()*+*',!('!34"55?<OT!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

234!3&'2/8*290H!@21'2A)2/!(&-!S#'$)2/!<U;U?!235!3&'2/8*290H!@21'2A)2/!(&-!S#'$)2/!<U;U?!

Page 126: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!

!""#$%&'()*(+,#(-./01)2+(345"5678(

!

"#$%&'(%!

34"55?0!@5AB4C7.!1/$1$0(+!(-8$#('20!'D2!#/2('*$&!$E!(&!$/F(&*G('*$&!'$!(&(+,G2H!(00200H!(&-!

/201$&-!'$!F+$)(+!@5A!02#%/*',!'D/2('0I!.D*0!#(02!0'%-,!)2F*&0!9*'D!(&!$82/8*29!$E!34"55?0!@5A!

02#%/*',!J(&-('2!(0!-20#/*)2-!*&!*'0!K2J$/(&-%J!$E!L&-2/0'(&-*&F!9*'D!'D2!L&*'2-!A'('20!

@21(/'J2&'!$E!4$JJ2/#2H!*'0!M,+(90H!(&-!*'0!<NNO!"$4I!"!0%JJ(/,!$E!'D2!@5AB4C7.!1/$1$0(+!

E$++$90H!)(02-!$&!34"55?0!PQ/$1$02-!A'/('2F*#!3&*'*('*820!E$/!@5A!A2#%/*',H!A'()*+*',H!(&-!

720*+*2&#,R!(&-!*'0!P@5AB4C7.!M%0*&200!4(02IR!.D2!0'%-,!'D2&!'/(#20!'D2!$/*F*&0!$E!'D2!

#$&'/$82/0,!0%//$%&-*&F!'D2!@5AB4C7.!1/$1$0(+H!)2F*&&*&F!9*'D!34"55?0!1%)+*#('*$&!$E!'D2!

1/$1$0(+!(&-!'D2!/2J(/S0!J(-2!*&!5(*/$)*!),!*'0!4CTH!7$-!M2#S0'/$JH!(&-!'D2!#$&'/$82/0,?0!

-282+$1J2&'!'D/$%FD!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'0H!#$//201$&-2&#2H!(&-!J('2/*(+!F('D2/2-!*&!*&'2/8*290!

9*'D!'D2!@5A!#$JJ%&*',I!!

.D2!/28*29!$E!'D202!J('2/*(+0!0%FF20'0!'D/22!S2,!*00%20!%&-2/+,*&F!'D2!#$&'/$82/0,6!U;V!'D2!

J2/*'0!(&-!#+(/*',!$E!34"55?0!(00200J2&'!$E!'D2!#%//2&'!0'('2!$E!@5A!02#%/*',!(&-!*'0!1/$1$0(+!E$/!

'D2!#/2('*$&!$E!(!#2&'/(+*G2-!4C7.W!U<V!8(/,*&F!*&'2/1/2'('*$&0!$E!34"55?0!@5A!02#%/*',!J(&-('2W!

(&-!UXV!1/$#2-%/(+!*00%20!/2+('2-!'$!$12&&200H!'/(&01(/2&#,H!1%)+*#!*&1%'H!(&-!0'(S2D$+-2/!

1(/'*#*1('*$&I!

)'$*!+%,-.!+/,&(*$!'0-!1*%2/-/3/4.!

!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"($"($",#$-",#.&-$*(/$%&+0"/"1"234$51&*-&$-&&$655&(/'7$68$

.D*0!#(02!0'%-,!*0!)(02-!$&!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!J('2/*(+0H!*&#+%-*&F!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'0H!34"55!

-$#%J2&'0H!(#(-2J*#!0'%-*20H!J2-*(!/21$/'0H!(&-!2Y12/'!$1*&*$&0I!3'!1/$8*-20!(!0%JJ(/,!$E!'D2!

E(#'0!/2F(/-*&F!34"55?0!@5AB4C7.!1/$1$0(+I!"0!12/!CYD*)*'!MH!02#'*$&!;!$E!'D2!A2/8*#20!

"F/22J2&'!)2'922&!'D2!M2/SJ(&!42&'2/!(&-!34"55H!*'0!F$(+!*0!'$!D2+1!*-2&'*E,!S2,!*00%20H!

#D(++2&F20H!(&-!(/2(0!$E!-*0(F/22J2&'!/2+('2-!'$!34"55?0!@5AB4C7.!1/$1$0(+I!.D2!$)02/8('*$&0!

)2+$9!9*++!#$&'/*)%'2!'$!'D2!M2/SJ(&!'2(J?0!E*&(+!/21$/'I!

3&!(--*'*$&!'$!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!0$%/#20H!'D*0!#(02!0'%-,!*&#+%-20!0'('2J2&'0H!$1*&*$&0!(&-!

12/#21'*$&0!$E!'D$02!92!*&'2/8*292-!*&!'D2!#$%/02!$E!-282+$1*&F!'D*0!#(02I!.D202!12/#21'*$&0!(&-!

$1*&*$&0!1+(,!(&!*J1$/'(&'!/$+2!*&!'D2!*&'2/1/2'('*$&!$E!34"55!-2#*0*$&0!(&-!'D2*/!/2#21'*$&!),!

'D2!#$JJ%&*',I!.D2!0'('2J2&'0!$E!*&'2/8*29220!-$!&$'!/2E+2#'!'D2!$1*&*$&0!$/!#$&#+%0*$&0!$E!'D2!

0'%-,!'2(JI!ZD*+2!92!D(82!J(-2!282/,!2EE$/'!'$!/2J$82!E(#'%(+!*&(##%/(#*20H!92!-$!&$'!(''20'!'$!

'D2!(##%/(#,!$E!'D2!$1*&*$&0!$EE2/2-!),!*&'2/8*29220I!.D2!*&'2/8*290!92/2!#$&-%#'2-!$&!'D2!

#$&-*'*$&!$E!#$&E*-2&'*(++,I!

9"+&:!"0!12/!'D2!A2/8*#20!"F/22J2&'H!'D*0!#(02!0'%-,!E$#%020!$&!282&'0!1/*$/!'$![%&2!;\H!<N;NI!

]$9282/H!'D2!@5AB4C7.!1/$1$0(+!(&-!/2+('2-!282&'0!(/2!0'*++!28$+8*&FI!"0!0%#DH!'D*0!0'%-,!J(,!

&$'!/2E+2#'!'D2!J$0'!/2#2&'!-282+$1J2&'0!*&!'D*0!#(02I!

Page 127: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!"#$%&#'()*!?/$@200$/!A$&('B(&!C*''/(*&D!E2/FG(&!42&'2/!H(#%+',!4$IJ*/2#'$/!(&-!4$K?/*&#*1(+!

3&820'*L('$/!$@!'B*0!/28*29D!*0!$&!'B2!E$(/-!$@!J*/2#'$/0!$@!'B2!3&'2/&2'!M$#*2',!N3MO4PQ!.B*0!0'%-,!

/2@2/0!'$!(!+2''2/!@/$G!R,&&!M'Q!"G$%/D!?/20*-2&'!(&-!4SO!$@!3MO4D!*&!20'()+*0B*&L!'B2!@(#'%(+!)(0*0!

$@!'B2!J5MI4S7.!#$&'/$82/0,Q!

Page 128: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&

-&&./)01234567&8)/559:&23;<&85&65:&:<)428!=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> -?@!

?&&3A<2A8<B&3C&8)/559:&65:D)<2!&E23E3:/;>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> -?F!

<?;!!@7A@ABCD!B.7".CE34!353.3".3FCB?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ;<G!

<?<!!D5BH4C7.!IJB35CBB!4"BC?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ;KL!

G&&!8H<;85<7&328185:&3C&!I<&)35!23A<2:= >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> -GG!

J&2</)!835:&C23H&!I<&8)/55&)3HH458!= >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> -GK!

M?;?!BJIB."5.3FC!3BBJCB ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ;KN!

M?<!34"55OB!D5B!BC4J73.P!Q"5D".C ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ;KR!

M?K!@7A4CDJ7"S!3BBJCB???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ;ML!

"#$#%#!&'())(**!+),!-.+)*'+.()/0 ###################################################################################################################### %"1!

"#$#2!34567/!8)'49!+),!:9+;(<=6,(.!3+.97/7'+97=) ######################################################################################## %"%!

&

Page 129: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!""#$%&'()*+,-"./01123"4)56"7+"819"96%*(7:;"

3&!*'0!$/*?*&(+!@2A$/(&-%A!$B!C&-2/0'(&-*&?!D@$CE!9*'F!'F2!C&*'2-!G'('20!H21(/'A2&'!$B!

4$AA2/#2I!34"55!9(0!'(0J2-!9*'F!'F2!'2#F&*#(+!A(&(?2A2&'!$B!'F2!H$A(*&!5(A2!G,0'2A!

DH5GEK!34"55!(00%A2-!/201$&0*)*+*',!B$/!B$%/!(/2(0!$B!H5G!A(&(?2A2&'6!L0'()*+*',I!#$A12'*'*$&I!

)$''$AM%1!#$$/-*&('*$&I!(&-!/21/202&'('*$&KN;!34"55O0!#$AA*'A2&'!'$!H5G!0'()*+*',!9(0!

/2B+2#'2-!*&!*'0!$/*?*&(+!P,+(90I!*&!9F*#F!'F2!7$$'!G2/82/!G,0'2A!"-8*0$/,!4$AA*''22!D7GG"4E!

9(0!20'()+*0F2-!'$!L2Q(A*&2!(&-!(-8*02!$&!'F2!02#%/*',!(012#'0!$B!'F2!/$$'!&(A2!02/82/!0,0'2AKN<!

3&!<RR;I!34"55!2Q'2&-2-!*'0!#$AA*'A2&'!'$!H5G!02#%/*',!9F2&!'F2!P$(/-!-*/2#'2-!34"55O0!

S/20*-2&'!L'$!(11$*&'!(!S/20*-2&'O0!0'(&-*&?!#$AA*''22!$&!'F2!02#%/*',!(&-!0'()*+*',!$B!'F2!

3&'2/&2'O0!&(A*&?!(&-!(--/200!(++$#('*$&!0,0'2A0KNT!"!,2(/!+('2/I!*&!@(,!<RR<I!'F2!P$(/-!/20$+82-!

'$!#$&82/'!'F2!0'(&-*&?!#$AA*''22!*&'$!'F2!12/A(&2&'!LG2#%/*',!(&-!G'()*+*',!"-8*0$/,!

4$AA*''22N!DGG"4EI!9F*#F!/2A(*&0!(!#$/&2/0'$&2!$B!34"55O0!H5G!02#%/*',!2BB$/'0KU!.F2!L&29!

P,+(90IN!1%)+*0F2-!0$$&!'F2/2(B'2/I!#$&B*/A2-!H5G!02#%/*',!(0!$&2!$B!34"55O0!#2&'/(+!

$/?(&*V('*$&(+!?$(+0K!.F2!B*/0'!$B!34"55O0!L4$/2!W(+%20IN!(##$/-*&?!'$!'F2!/28*02-!P,+(90I!*0!

LX1Y/202/8*&?!(&-!2&F(&#*&?!'F2!$12/('*$&(+!0'()*+*',I!/2+*()*+*',I!(&-!?+$)(+!*&'2/$12/()*+*',!$B!

'F2!3&'2/&2'KNZ!

34"55O0!"BB*/A('*$&!$B!4$AA*'A2&'0!D"$4EI!1%)+*0F2-!*&!G21'2A)2/I!<RR[I!$&#2!(?(*&!

/2(BB*/A2-!34"55O0!#$AA*'A2&'!'$!H5G!02#%/*',K!L34"55!F(0!-282+$12-!(!1+(&IN!*'!/2(-0I!!

!"#$%&'%($#!&$#")$*'!+"%',#-!'.+,+!/0#*$,+'.+,+!/0#*$-+,+$%(/0#-$(1*+!/0#'%2#3,".',#

+%!$*")$*'.+,+!/#"4#!&$#5670#8&+(&#8+,,#.$#*$31,'*,/#1)2'!$2#!"#*$4,$(!#$9$*3+%3#!&*$'!-#!"#

!&$#567:#;<=66#8+,,#"*3'%+>$#'#*$?+$8#"4#+!-#$@$(1!+"%#"4#!&$#'."?$#("99+!9$%!-#%"#,$--#

4*$A1$%!,/#!&'%#$?$*/#!&*$$#/$'*-:#B&$#4+*-!#-1(&#*$?+$8#-&',,#("99$%($#"%$#/$'*#4*"9#!&$#

$44$(!+?$#2'!$#"4#!&+-#=44+*9'!+"%:C##

.F2!34"55!1+(&!B$/!1/202/8*&?!H5G!02#%/*',I!0'()*+*',I!(&-!/20*+*2&#,!F(0!'F/22!(/2(0!$B!B$#%06!D;E!

?2&2/(+!(''2&'*$&!'$!1F,0*#(+!(&-!&2'9$/J!02#%/*',!$B!'F2!H5GI!D<E!#$&'*&?2&#,!1+(&&*&?I!(&-!DTE!

LA(*&'(*&*&?!#+2(/!1/$#20020KN\!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;!34"55I!L@2A$/(&-%A!$B!C&-2/0'(&-*&?!P2'922&!'F2!C&*'2-!G'('20!H21(/'A2&'!$B!4$AA2/#2!(&-!3&'2/&2'!4$/1$/('*$&!B$/!"00*?&2-!5(A20!(&-!5%A)2/0IN!5$82A)2/!<ZI!;[[=I!F''16]]999K*#(&&K$/?]2&]?2&2/(+]*#(&&MA$%M<Z&$8[=KF'AK!

<!34"55I!LP,+(90IN!5$82A)2/!^I!;[[=I!F''16]]999K*#(&&K$/?]2&]?2&2/(+](/#F*82M),+(90]),+(90MR^&$8[=KF'AK!

T!34"55I!L.F*/-!"&&%(+!@22'*&?!$B!'F2!34"55!P$(/-!*&!@(/*&(!-2+!7(,!S/2+*A*&(/,!721$/'IN!5$82A)2/!;ZI!<RR;I!F''16]]999K*#(&&K$/?]2&]A*&%'20]1/2+*AM/21$/'M;Z&$8R;KF'A_G'(&-*&?4$AA*''22$&G2#%/*',(&-G'()*+*',K!

U!34"55I!LG12#*(+!@22'*&?!$B!'F2!P$(/-!S/2+*A*&(/,!721$/'IN!@(,!;TI!<RR<I!F''16]]999K*#(&&K$/?]2&]A*&%'20]1/2+*AM/21$/'M;TA(,R<KF'A_G2#%/*',4$AA*''22K!

Z!34"55I!LP,+(90IN!H2#2A)2/!;ZI!<RR<I!F''16]]999K*#(&&K$/?]2&]?2&2/(+](/#F*82M),+(90]),+(90M;Z-2#R<KF'AK!

^!34"55I!L"BB*/A('*$&!$B!4$AA*'A2&'0!),!'F2!C&*'2-!G'('20!H21(/'A2&'!$B!4$AA2/#2!(&-!'F2!3&'2/&2'!4$/1$/('*$&!B$/!"00*?&2-!5(A20!(&-!5%A)2/0IN!G21'2A)2/!TRI!<RR[I!F''16]]999K*#(&&K$/?]2&]-$#%A2&'0](BB*/A('*$&M$BM#$AA*'A2&'0MTR021R[M2&KF'AK!

\!3)*-K!

Page 130: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!""#$%&$'%(")*"+,-../0"1.23,456"7&)8)09:"

?%/0%(&'!'$!'@2!#$AA*'A2&'0!-20#/*)2-!*&!'@2!"$4B!34"55!1%)+*0@2-!(!-/(C'!$C!*'0!D?+(&!C$/!

E&@(&#*&F!3&'2/&2'!G2#%/*',B!G'()*+*',B!(&-!720*+*2&#,H!*&!I(,!<JJ=KL!.@2!-/(C'!1+(&!-20#/*)20!

34"55M0!@*F@N+282+!02#%/*',!$)O2#'*820B!#+(/*C*20!*'0!/$+2!9*'@*&!'@2!)/$(-2/!3&'2/&2'!02#%/*',!

#$AA%&*',B!(&-!1/$8*-20!(&!$82/8*29!$C!*'0!(&'*#*1('2-!02#%/*',N/2+('2-!1/$O2#'0!C$/!'@2!<JJ=P

<J;J!$12/('*&F!,2(/Q*&#+%-*&F!'@2!*A1+2A2&'('*$&!$C!R5GGE4!C$/!'@2!(%'@$/*'('*82!/$$'!S$&2B!

2&@(&#2-!02#%/*',!A2(0%/20!C$/!&29!F.TR0!(&-!3R50B!(&-!(#'*82!#$++()$/('*$&!9*'@!(!9*-2!/(&F2!

$C!02#%/*',!0'(U2@$+-2/0K!

3&!R2#2A)2/!<JJ=B!34"55!1%)+*0@2-!(!-/(C'!$C!*'0!<J;JP<J;V!0'/('2F*#!1+(&K!.@2!-/(C'!1+(&!

A(U20!/2C2/2&#2!'$!DR5G!4E7.!#$&#21'!-282+$1A2&'H!(0!(!1+(&!%&-2/!'@2!@2(-*&F!$C!!DW1X/202/82!

R5G!0'()*+*',!(&-!02#%/*',BH!)%'!1/$8*-20!&$!(--*'*$&(+!-2'(*+K!.@2!C*&(+!-/(C'!$C!'@2!1+(&B!

1%)+*0@2-!$&!Y2)/%(/,!<<B!<J;JB!*&#+%-20!(!)/*2C!$82/8*29!$C!'@2!(&'*#*1('2-!1/$O2#'6!

!"#$$%&'((%&)*+%',%-.*/,0*12'-%&'/2%)/20*%)*3.,'4./'),1%/)%5060()-%.,%.--*).72%/)%/20%

01/.8('1290,/%):%.%;$<%"=>?%',%)*50*%/)%.55*011%),0%):%/20%8*).50*%'11@01%):%!,/0*,0/%

107@*'/AB%?2'1%1A1/09%&)@(5%0,.8(0%.%9)*0%7))*5',./05%.,5%0::07/'60%*01-),10%/)%',7'50,/1%

.,5%.//.7+1%),%/20%;$<B%!,%.55'/'),C%!"#$$%&'((%80%&)*+',3%&'/2%/20%!,/0*,0/%7)99@,'/A%/)%

0,2.,70%7),/',30,7A%-(.,,',3%.,5%0D0*7'101%/)%.55*011%*'1+1%.,5%/2*0./1%/)%/20%;$<BE%

Z&!Y2)/%(/,!;<B!<J;JB!34"55!1%)+*0@2-!'9$!(--*'*$&(+!02#%/*',N/2+('2-!-$#%A2&'06!'@2!

D?/$1$02-!G'/('2F*#!3&*'*('*820!C$/!3A1/$82-!R5G!G2#%/*',B!G'()*+*',!(&-!720*+*2&#,H;J!(&-!'@2!

D[+$)(+!R5GN4E7.!\%0*&200!4(02KH;;!.(U2&!'$F2'@2/B!'@202!'9$!-$#%A2&'0!-2C*&2!'@2!#$&'$%/0!$C!

34"55MG!R5GN4E7.!*&*'*('*82B!9@*#@!(*A0!'$!C(#*+*'('2!'@2!#/2('*$&!(&!*&-212&-2&'!$/F(&*S('*$&!

'$!(&'*#*1('2B!28(+%('2B!(&-!/201$&-!'$!'@2!C%++!/(&F2!$C!R5G!02#%/*',!'@/2('0K!

!"#$$%&'(')*+$,-&.-*/01$230-0.-04*)$

.@2!?/$1$02-!G'/('2F*#!3&*'*('*820!-$#%A2&'!)2F*&0!9*'@!(!02/*20!$C!0'('2A2&'0!()$%'!'@2!#%//2&'!

0'('2!$C!R5G!02#%/*',K!Y*/0'!(A$&F!'@2A!*0!'@2!$)02/8('*$&!'@('!'@2!R5GQ(!C%&-(A2&'(+!

#$A1$&2&'!$C!'@2!A(O$/*',!$C!%02/!(11+*#('*$&0!$&!'@2!3&'2/&2'Q2]*0'0!D*&!(&!2&8*/$&A2&'!$C!

*&#/2(0*&F!'@/2('0!(&-!/*0U0KH;<!.@2!*&#/2(02!*&!'@2!DC/2^%2&#,!(&-!02/*$%0!&('%/2H!$C!#(++0!'$!

(#'*$&!9*'@*&!'@2!R5G!02#%/*',!#$AA%&*',B!*'!(/F%20B!*&-*#('20!(!F/$9*&F!&22-!C$/!0,0'2AN9*-2!

/201$&02!#(1()*+*'*20K!3'!#+(*A0!'@('!#%//2&'!2CC$/'0B!@$9282/B!(/2!D&$'!0,0'2A*#(++,!C$#%02-KH!

Z82/(++B!34"55!'(U20!'@2!1$0*'*$&!'@('!'@2!R5G!D+(#U0!0,0'2AN9*-2!C$#(+!1$*&'0!C$/!(##$%&'()*+*',!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

L!34"55B!D?+(&!C$/!E&@(&#*&F!3&'2/&2'!G2#%/*',B!G'()*+*',B!(&-!720*+*2&#,BH!I(,!;_B!<JJ=B!@''16``999K*#(&&K$/F`2&`'$1*#0`00/`00/N-/(C'N1+(&N;_A(,J=N2&K1-CK!

=!34"55B!Da%+,!<J;JPa%&2!<J;V!G'/('2F*#!?+(&BH!Y2)/%(/,!;=B!<J;JB!@''16``999K*#(&&K$/F`2&`0'/('2F*#N1+(&`0'/('2F*#N1+(&N<J;JN<J;VN;=C2);JN2&K1-CK!

;J!34"55B!D?/$1$02-!G'/('2F*#!3&*'*('*820!C$/!3A1/$82-!R5G!G2#%/*',B!G'()*+*',!(&-!720*+*2&#,BH!Y2)/%(/,!;<B!<J;JB!@''16``999K*#(&&K$/F`2&`'$1*#0`00/`0'/('2F*#N00/N*&*'*('*820NJ=C2);JN2&K1-CK!

;;!34"55B!D[+$)(+!R5GN4E7.!\%0*&200!4(026!3A1/$8*&F!'@2!G2#%/*',B!G'()*+*',!(&-!720*+*2&#,!$C!'@2!R5GBH!Y2)/%(/,!;<B!<JJ=B!@''16``999K*#(&&K$/F`2&`'$1*#0`00/`-&0N#2/'N)%0*&200N#(02N;=A(/;JN2&K1-CK!

;<!34"55B!D?/$1$02-!G'/('2F*#!3&*'*('*820BH!<K!

Page 131: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

/2+('2-!'$!?2,!#(1()*+*'*20!*&!/*0?!(00200@2&'A!#$&'*&B2&#,!1+(&&*&B!(&-!2C2/#*020A!(&-!-2-*#('2-A!

0%0'(*&2-!/201$&02DE;<!

.F2!-$#%@2&'!(/B%20!'F('!34"55G0!$)+*B('*$&!'$!H5I!02#%/*',!J(0!-2K*&2-!*&!'F2!"$4!(&-!$'F2/!

1$+*#,!-$#%@2&'0L!#$@12+0!*'!'$!M2&0%/2!20'()+*0F@2&'!$K!0,0'2@N9*-2!(11/$(#F20!'$!(00200!/*0?A!

'$!1+(&!(&-!2C2/#*02!#$&'*&B2&#*20!(B(*&0'!1$'2&'*(+!'F/2('0!(&-!'$!$/#F20'/('2!#$++()$/('*82!

*&#*-2&'!/201$&02!#(1()*+*'*20!'$!*@1/$82!'F2!$82/(++!02#%/*',A!0'()*+*',!(&-!/20*+*2&#,!$K!'F2!H5I!

0,0'2@DE;O!

34"55!$%'+*&20!'F/22!',120!$K!#%//2&'!H5I!02#%/*',!/*0?06!@(+*#*$%0!(#'*8*',!/*0?0!J*&#+%-*&B!HH$I!

(&-!#(#F2!1$*0$&*&B!(''(#?0LA!'2#F&*#(+!/*0?0!J*&#+%-*&B!'F2!H5I!1/$'$#$+!8%+&2/()*+*'*20!

*-2&'*K*2-!),!H(&!P(@*&0?,LA!(&-!$/B(&*Q('*$&(+!K(*+%/20!J0%#F!(0!9F2&!(!/$$'!02/82/!$12/('$/A!

/2B*0'/,A!$/!/2B*0'/(/!#(&!&$!+$&B2/!12/K$/@!*'0!K%&#'*$&LD;R!

.F2!-$#%@2&'!1/$1$020!'9$!*&*'*('*820!*&!/201$&02!'$!'F202!/*0?0D!.F2!K*/0'!*0!(!1/$B/(@!'$!

#$$/-*&('2!M0,0'2@N9*-2!H5I!/*0?!(&(+,0*0A!#$&'*&B2&#,!1+(&&*&BA!(&-!2C2/#*020DE;S!"&!2C12/'!

(-8*0$/,!B/$%1A!#$@1$02-!$K!H5I!$12/('$/0!(&-!'F2!)/$(-2/!#,)2/02#%/*',!#$@@%&*',A!9$%+-!

$82/022!/*0?!(00200@2&'!(&-!#$&'*&B2&#,!1+(&&*&B!(#'*8*'*20D!"!H5I!/$$'N0,0'2@!*&K$/@('*$&N!

0F(/*&B!@2#F(&*0@!9$%+-!K(#*+*'('2!(&(+,0*0!(&-!*&#*-2&'!/201$&02D!T*&(++,A!34"55!9$%+-!+2(-!(!

02/*20!$K!@%+'*N0'(?2F$+-2/!2C2/#*020!'$!*-2&'*K,!92(?&20020!*&!#%//2&'!H5I!02#%/*',!/201$&02!

1/(#'*#20D;U!

.F2!02#$&-!1/$1$02-!*&*'*('*82!*0!'F2!#/2('*$&!$K!(!H5IN4V7.!$/B(&*Q('*$&A!'$!02/82!(0!(!#2&'/(+!

1$*&'!$K!#$&'(#'!*&!#$$/-*&('*&B!/201$&020!'$!H5I!02#%/*',!*&#*-2&'0D!.F2!H5IN4V7.!1/$1$0(+!*0!

-20#/*)2-!K%++,!*&!'F2!H5IN4V7.!)%0*&200!#(02D!

!"!##$%&'()*+#,-./01..#(2.1#

.F2!H5IN4V7.!)%0*&200!#(02!)2B*&0!9*'F!(!-2'(*+2-!28(+%('*$&!$K!'F2!#%//2&'!0'('2!$K!1+(,!*&!H5I!

02#%/*',D!3'!)2B*&0!9*'F!(&!$82/8*29!$K!'F2!0'/%#'%/2!(&-!*@1$/'(&#2!$K!'F2!H5ID!.F2!2002&'*(+!

/$+2!$K!'F2!H5IA!*'!(/B%20A!F(0!-/*82&!(&!*&#/2(02!*&!@(+*#*$%0!(#'*8*',!(*@2-!('!-*0/%1'*&B!$/!

#$@1/$@*0*&B!'F2!0,0'2@G0!02#%/*',D!"'!'F2!0(@2!'*@2A!'F2!*&#/2(0*&B!*@1$/'(&#2!$K!'F2!H5I!'$!(!

/(&B2!$K!8*'(+!(11+*#('*$&0!F(0!/(*02-!'F2!0'(?20!$K!$'F2/!0'/%#'%/(+!/*0?0A!0%#F!(0!'2#F&*#(+!(&-!

$/B(&*Q('*$&(+!K(*+%/20D!

4*'*&B!(!/21$/'!K/$@!'F2!W==X!Y+$)(+!H5I!I2#%/*',A!I'()*+*',A!Z!720*+*2&#,!I,@1$0*%@!J(!

B('F2/*&B!$K!'F2!B+$)(+!#$@@%&*',!$K!H5I!02#%/*',!0'(?2F$+-2/0!F2+-!*&!"'+(&'(!*&!T2)/%(/,!

W==XLA!'F2!1/$1$0(+!#$&'2&-0!'F('!M*&K$/@('*$&!0F(/*&B!9*'F*&!'F2!H5I!#$@@%&*',!*0!0$/2+,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;<!3)*-DA!<D!

;O!3)*-DA!OD!

;R!3)*-DA!O[\D!

;S!3)*-DA!XD!

;U!3)*-DA!X[;;D!

Page 132: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<;=!

+(#>*&?@!(&-!'A('!02#%/*',!/201$&02!#(1()*+*'*20!(/2!B+*C*'2-!('!(++!+282+0D@;E!F%#A!+*C*'('*$&0!(/2!

&$'!&2#200(/*+,!-%2!'$!(&,!*&21'*'%-2!$/!'$/1$/!9*'A*&!'A2!G5F!#$CC%&*',H!)%'!/('A2/!C(,!/20%+'!

I/$C!?2$?/(1A*#!#$&0'/(*&'0!$/!+*C*'('*$&0!*&!/20$%/#20H!(0!92++!(0!'A2!I(#'!'A('!+$$02+,!

#$$/-*&('2-!/201$&020!'$!02#%/*',!'A/2('0!A(82H!%&'*+!/2#2&'+,H!9$/>2-!(-2J%('2+,!92++D!

.A2!1/$1$0(+!+*0'0!(!02/*20!$I!1/28*$%0!G5F!02#%/*',!*&#*-2&'0K*&#+%-*&?!'A2!4$&I*#>2/!9$/CH!'A2!

L(C*&0>,!8%+&2/()*+*',H!-$C(*&!A*M(#>*&?H!(&-!'A2!"8(+(&#A2!(''(#>0K'$!C(>2!'A2!#(02!'A('!(!

#2&'/(+*N2-!)$-,!*0!&22-2-!'$!#$$/-*&('2!/201$&020!'$!0%#A!282&'0D;O!.A2!1/$1$02-!G5FP4Q7.!

$/?(&*N('*$&!9$%+-!C22'!'A*0!&22-D!.A2!$/?(&*N('*$&!9$%+-!/21/202&'!'A2!*&'2/20'0!$I!)/$(-!(&-!

A*?A+,!-*82/02!/(&?2!$I!0'(>2A$+-2/0H!*&#+%-*&?!G5F!/$$'!$12/('$/0H!.RG!/2?*0'/*20!(&-!/2?*0'/(/0H!

3FS0H!2T*0'*&?!4Q7.0H!?$82/&C2&'0H!82&-$/0H!(&-!2&-P%02/0DUV!3'0!C*00*$&!9$%+-!)2!'A2!I$++$9*&?6!

!"#$%&'()*'+,&%-.+%#'-"/'#$,,+%.0"1'+%1-"02-.0+"#'3-4&'-'#&5$%0.6'5++%/0"-.0+"'5&".&%'

70.3'#$88050&".'&9,&%.0#&'-"/'%&#+$%5&#'.+'&"-:;&'.0<&;6'-"/'&88050&".'%&#,+"#&'.+'.3%&-.#'.+'

.3&'#&5$%0.6='#.-:0;0.6'-"/'%&#0;0&"56'+8'.3&'()*>?@''

.A/22!?$(+0H!9*'A!(##$C1(&,*&?!$)M2#'*820H!9$%+-!'$!0%11$/'!'A2!C*00*$&6!

!D!"#$%&!W(*&!0*'%('*$&(+!(9(/2&200!(&-!0A(/2!*&I$/C('*$&D!

'()*+,-.*&!Q0'()+*0A!#$CC%&*#('*$&0!C2(&0!(&-!1/$#2-%/20!'$!C(T*C%C!&%C)2/!$I!

1+(,2/0X!2T2/#*02!/2?%+(/+,D!!

/0!"#$%&!3C1/$82!#$$/-*&('*$&!9*'A*&!'A2!G5F!$12/('*$&(+!#$CC%&*',D!

'()*+,-.*&!Q&()+2!C2(0%/2C2&'!(&-!I(#*+*'('2!*&I$/C('*$&!0A(/*&?!()$%'!'A2!A2(+'AH!

0'()*+*',!(&-!/20*+*2&#,!$I!'A2!G5FD!Q&?(?2!*&!(11/$1/*('2!0*'%('*$&06!0%11$/'!

#$&'*&?2&#,!1+(&&*&?!(&-!2T2/#*020X!%&-2/'(>2!"I'2/!"#'*$&!721$/'*&?!Y""7ZD!Q&?(?2!

9*'A!G5FP["74!(&-!73FWH!(C$&?!$'A2/0!#$++()$/('$/0H!'$!+282/(?2!2T12/'*02!(&-!2T*0'*&?!

$12/('*$&(+!/201$&02!#(1()*+*'*20!/2+('2-!'$!*&I$/C('*$&!0A(/*&?!(&-!(&(+,0*0D!!

102"#$%&!3C1/$82!#$$/-*&('*$&!9*'A!'A2!)/$(-2/!02#%/*',!#$CC%&*',D!

'()*+,-.*&!Q0'()+*0A!/2+('*$&0A*10!9*'A!>2,!1(/'&2/0!Y4Q7.0H!02#%/*',!/202(/#A2/0H!>2,!

02#%/*',!+*0'0H!82&-$/0H!(&'*8*/%0!#$C1(&*20H!+(9!2&I$/#2C2&'!(&-!?$82/&C2&'0ZX!

1(/'*#*1('2!*&!#$&'*&?2&#,!1+(&&*&?!(&-!2T2/#*020X!2&?(?2!*&!(11/$1/*('2!0*'%('*$&0X!

%&-2/'(>2!"I'2/!"#'*$&!721$/'*&?!Y""7ZDUU!!

.A2!1/$1$02-!G5FP4Q7.\0!#$/2!/201$&0*)*+*'*20!9$%+-!)2!'$!1/$8*-2!1/$(#'*82!02/8*#20K

*&#+%-*&?!2-%#('*$&H!'/(*&*&?H!#$&'*&?2&#,!2T2/#*020H!(&-!#$&'*&%$%0!C$&*'$/*&?!$I!G5F!A2(+'AK

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;E!34"55!2'!(+DH!B.A2!W+$)(+!G5F6!F2#%/*',H!F'()*+*',!]!720*+*2&#,!F,C1$0*%C6!F%CC(/,H!./2&-0H!(&-!52T'!F'210H@!"1/*+!UH!UVVOH!A''16^^999D?'*0#D?('2#AD2-%^1-I^G5F_FF7_F,C1$0*%C_F%CC(/,_721$/'D1-ID!

;O!34"55H!BG5FP4Q7.!`%0*&200!4(02H@!ab;VD!

UV!3)*-DH!Ob;VD!

U;!3)*-DH!;;D!

UU!3)*-DH!;Vb;;D!

Page 133: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

(&-!/2(#'*82!02/8*#20?!*&#+%-*&@!02/8*&@!(0!(!A%)!B$/!#$$/-*&('*&@!/201$&020!'$!C5D!02#%/*',!

*&#*-2&'0E=<!

"+'A$%@A!'A2!1/2#*02!/2+('*$&0A*10!9*'A!#$&0'*'%2&'0!(&-!0'(F2A$+-2/0!/2G(*&!%&-2B*&2-?!'A2!

1/$1$0(+!2&8*0*$&0!C5DH4I7.!(0!(!#2&'/(+!&$-2!*&!'A2!@('A2/*&@!(&-!-*0'/*)%'*$&!$B!*&B$/G('*$&!

()$%'!C5D!02#%/*',!'A/2('0?!9A*#A!*'!*++%0'/('20!*&!'A2!B$++$9*&@!-*(@/(G6=J!

!

!

!

34"55!+(,0!$%'!(!02/*20!$B!0'210!'$!20'()+*0A!'A2!$/@(&*K('*$&?!)(02-!$&!@%*-2+*&20!1%)+*0A2-!),!

4I7.L44E=M!.A202!0'210N)2@*&&*&@!9*'A!'A2!*-2&'*B*#('*$&!$B!0'(F2A$+-2/0!(&-!1(/'*#*1(&'0?!(&-!

2&-*&@!9*'A!'A2!-2B*&*'*$&!$B!/$+20!(&-!/201$&0*)*+*'*20N(/2!-20#/*)2-!*&!'A2!/2G(*&*&@!1$/'*$&!

$B!'A2!1/$1$0(+?!(+'A$%@A?!(0!*'!&$'20?!'A2!1/$1$0(+!*0!*&'2&-2-!(0!O'A2!)(0*0!B$/!B%/'A2/!

-282+$1G2&'!$B!'A*0!2BB$/'!'A/$%@A!#$GG%&*',!0%11$/'!(&-!B22-)(#FEP=Q!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=<!3)*-E?!;=E!

=J!3)*-E?!;JE!

=M!4I7.L44!A(0!1%)+*0A2-!(!02'!$B!@%*-2+*&20!B$/!'A2!20'()+*0AG2&'!$B!&29!4$G1%'2/!D2#%/*',!3&#*-2&'!7201$&02!.2(G0!R4D37.0SE!D22!4I7.L44?!OT$9!-$20!(&!$/@(&*K('*$&!0'(/'!(!4D37.U?P!A''16LL999E#2/'E$/@L#0*/'0L#0*/'VB(WEA'G+X;QE!

=Q!3)*-E?!;ME!

Page 134: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<<=!

.>2!-$#%?2&'!2&-0!9*'>!(!)/*2@!$82/8*29!$@!A5BC4D7.E0!1/$1$02-!@%&-*&F!0$%/#20G!F$82/&(&#2!

?$-2+G!(&-!$/F(&*H('*$&(+!0'/%#'%/2I!"&!20'*?('2-!JKIL!?*++*$&!(&&%(+!)%-F2'!*0!0%FF20'2-!@$/!'>2!

$/F(&*H('*$&G!(+$&F!9*'>!(!0'(@@!$@!@*@'22&G!(!0'22/*&F!#$??*''22G!(&-!(!M$(/-!$@!N$82/&$/0I!34"55!

9$%+-!02/82!(0!'>2!1/$O2#'E0!*&*'*(+!01$&0$/!P%&'*+!'>2!$/F(&*H('*$&!#(&!0'(&-!$&!*'0!$9&IQLR!

34"55E0!/$+2!*&!'>2!F$82/&(&#2!(&-!$12/('*$&0!$@!'>2!1/$1$02-!$/F(&*H('*$&!*0!&$'!#+2(/+,!

(/'*#%+('2-!*&!'>2!1/$1$0(+I!3'!/2(-06!

!"#$%&'$()*(*+,-./'*(#$*(%0'/+-1/#-%+(2*-+'(*.#/2"-.$*3()-#$(-+-#-/"(.&44%0#(50%6(78!99:(

#$*(;9<=8>?@(-.(-+#*+3*3(#%(%4*0/#*(/.(6&A$(/.(4%..-2"*(/.(/(50**.#/+3-+'(%0'/+-1/#-%+:(

+%#(3-0*A#"B(3*4*+3*+#(&4%+(/+B(%+*(%0'/+-1/#-%+(5%0(-#.(3-0*A#-%+(/+3(%4*0/#-%+C(

@$*0*5%0*:(#%(2*(.&AA*..5&":(#$*(;9<=8>?@(6&.#(2*(A0*/#*3()-#$(/('%,*0+/+A*(.#0&A#&0*(

#$/#(6/D*.(-#(/AA%&+#/2"*(#%(D*B(.#/D*$%"3*0.(/+3(#%(#$*(4&2"-A(/#("/0'*C((

!""#$%&'$(&)"*+$,$(-"./"01&"2.(0+.3&+-4"

34"55!)2F(&!@$/?(+!-*0#%00*$&0!9*'>!0'(S2>$+-2/0!()$%'!'>2!A5BC4D7.!1/$1$0(+!*&!A2#2?)2/!

LTTU!V022!11I!KWX!()$82YG!9>2&!*'!9(0!@*/0'!*&#+%-2-!*&!'>2!-/(@'!LT;TWLT;<!0'/('2F*#!1+(&I!

"+'>$%F>!'>2!&22-!@$/!(&!$/F(&*H('*$&!0*?*+(/!'$!A5BC4D7.!>(-!)22&!*-2&'*@*2-!('!'>2!Z2)/%(/,!

LTTU!A5B!0,?1$0*%?G!'>2/2!9(0!&$!*&-*#('*$&!$@!(!-*/2#'!/$+2!@$/!34"55!%&'*+!A2#2?)2/!;!$@!'>('!

,2(/I!34"55!>(0!*&-*#('2-!'>('!'2&!1/*8('2!#$&0%+'('*$&0!#2&'2/2-!$&!A5BC4D7.!$##%//2-!-%/*&F!

'>2!@$++$9*&F!922SG!9*'>!(!>(&-@%+!?$/2!'(S*&F!1+(#2!*&![(&%(/,IL\!!!

.>2!-/(@'!LT;TWLT;<!34"55!B'/('2F*#!]+(&!9(0!1$0'2-!@$/!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!$&!A2#2?)2/!;G!LTTU!

(&-!#+$02-!$&![(&%(/,!L;G!LT;TILU!!B282&!$@!'>2!'92&',C&*&2!1%)+*#!#$??2&'0!/2#2*82-!*&!

/201$&02!'$!'>2!LT;TWLT;<!0'/('2F*#!1+(&!-*/2#'+,!(--/2002-!A5BC4D7.!1/$1$0(+I<T!.>202!

#$??2&'0!(/2!F2&2/(++,!0%11$/'*82!$@!34"55E0!0'('2-!*&'2&'*$&!'$!-282+$1!(!012#*@*#!1/$1$0(+!

/2+('2-!'$!A5BC4D7.^!'>2!#$??2&'0!?(*&+,!(--/200!'>2!$82/(++!&22-!@$/!)2''2/!#$$/-*&('*$&!*&!

A5B!02#%/*',!/201$&02!2@@$/'0I!.>2!$&+,!$12&+,!#/*'*#(+!#$??2&'!#(?2!@/$?!D/*#!M/%&&2/C

_*++*(?0G!9>$!9/$'26!

7(/6(A%+A*0+*3(2B(#$*(3*#/-"-50**(4"/+(#%(A%4B-/-8*0#CCCC@$*(4%-+#(-.:(8>?@.(/0*(+%#(/('-,*+(

#$-+':(#$*B(/0*(/(2%E(-+#%()$-A$(.%6*(6%+*B(/+3(.%6*(4&04%.*(-.(4&#C(F*(.$%&"3(3*A-3*(

$%)(6&A$(6%+*B(/+3()$/#(4&04%.*.:(+%#(G&.#(H.#/0#(/(8>?@ICCCC75()*(/0*(+%#(A/0*5&":(/+((

H78!99(8>?@I()-""(J2*K(A/4#&0*3:(6&A$("-D*(#$*(78!99(<<!8(5&+A#-%+(3&0-+'(#$*(5/.#-5"&E(

$%.#-+'(*55%0#:(2B(0*#/-"(A%4.-/+3-0%22*0.(A%+A*0+.(#$/#(6-..*3(#$*(5&+3/6*+#/"(-..&*.(%5(

0/4-3(&43/#*(2B(0*'-.#0-*.(/.(/(5&+3/6*+#/"(#%%"(%5(6%3*0+(3+.(*E4"%-#-+'(.B.#*6.:(/+3(

1*0%(*55*A#-,*(A%.#(%5(0*'-.#0/#-%+:(/'/-+(2B(6%3*0+(3+.(*E4"%-#-+'(.B.#*6.C(!#(#$/#(4%-+#()*(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LR!3)*-IG!;`I!

L\!34"55G!PB%??(/,!$@!4$&0%+'('*$&0!(&-!4$??2&'0!/2+('2-!'$!'>2!34"55!N+$)(+!A5BC4D7.!M%0*&200!4(02GQ!a(,!LKG!LT;TG!>''16bb999I*#(&&I$/Fb2&b1%)+*#C#$??2&'b0%??(/,C(&(+,0*0C0'/('2F*#C00/C*&*'*('*820C(&-C-&0C#2/'C)%0*&200C#(02CLK?(,;TC2&I1-@I!

LU!34"55G!P]%)+*#!4$??2&'!72c%20'2-!$&!A/(@'!LT;TCLT;<!B'/('2F*#!]+(&GQ!A2#2?)2/!;G!LTTUG!>''16bb999I*#(&&I$/Fb2&b(&&$%&#2?2&'0b(&&$%&#2?2&'CT;-2#TUC2&I>'?I!

<T!B22!/2#2*82-!1%)+*#!#$??2&'06!34"55G!Pd0'/('1+(&CLT;Te!4>/$&$+$F*#(+!3&-2fGQ!>''16bb@$/%?I*#(&&I$/Fb+*0'0b0'/('1+(&CLT;TbI!

Page 135: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

!"#$%&'()*&(&+,-./0&!'12'&+3(4*5&6'*&5#165&531$*0&7#6&%"*5&#5&8"&9""%&!'*8&2"3:*6*86&(8%&

3"61)(6*%&:;"9;(33*;5&6(;9*6&18<;(56;#26#;*=>?&

34"55!1%)+*0?2-!*'0!@A5BC4D7.!E%0*&200!4(02F!(&-!*'0!@G/$1$02-!B'/('2H*#!3&*'*('*820F!I$/!1%)+*#!

#$JJ2&'!$&!K2)/%(/,!;LM!LN;NO!P&'*+!Q(/#?!LRM!?$9282/M!$&+,!$&2!#$JJ2&'!?(-!)22&!

0%)J*''2-M!#$//2#'*&H!(!I(#'%(+!-2'(*+!*&!'?2!0'/('2H*#!*&*'*('*820!-$#%J2&'O<L!

"'!+2(0'!(0!I(/!(0!1%)+*#+,!(##200*)+2!J('2/*(+0!(/2!#$&#2/&2-M!'?2!A5BC4D7.!1/$1$0(+!/2J(*&2-!

+(/H2+,!%&#$&'/$82/0*(+!%&'*+!34"55S0!J22'*&H!*&!5(*/$)*!*&!Q(/#?!LN;NO!A%/*&H!(!T$*&'!U"4V

E$(/-!J22'*&H!$&!Q(/#?!WM!'?2!4DX!$I!34"55M!7$-!E2#Y0'/$JM!#$&82,2-!(!02/*20!$I!9(/&*&H0!

()$%'!'?2!?2(+'?!$I!'?2!H+$)(+!A5BO<<!@Z?('!3!9(&'!'$!0?(/2!9*'?!,$%MF!?2!0(*-M!

(5&(&;*:;*5*86(61)*&"<&3(8@&2"#86;1*5&"<&6'*&!";$%&15&6'(6&6'*&%"3(18&8(3*&5@56*3&15&#8%*;&

(66(24&6"%(@&(5&16&'(5&8*)*;&7**8&7*<";*=&A&'()*&:*;5"8($$@&2"85#$6*%&!16'&")*;&BC&,-D05&"<&

6'*&6":&.*9156;1*5&(8%&.*9156;(;5&9$"7($$@E&($$&"<&!'"3&(;*&5**189&182;*(5189&(66(245&(8%&

2"3:$*F16@&"<&(66(245&(8%&!'"&(;*&*F6;*3*$@&2"82*;8*%=&

/'*&%"3(18&8(3*&5@56*3&15&3";*&<;(91$*&(8%&)#$8*;(7$*&6"%(@&6'(8&16&'(5&*)*;&7**8=&

A6&2"#$%&56":&(6&(8@&91)*8&:"186&18&613*&$16*;($$@=&A6&'(5&8*)*;&56"::*%E&16&'(5&7**8&

5$"!*%&%"!8&6';"#9'&(66(245&(8%&6'*&G"31854@&*F:$"16&6'(6&!(5&%152$"5*%&"8$@&?H&

3"86'5&";&5"&(9"&2"#$%&'()*&7**8&#5*%&6"&<#8%(3*86($$@&2;1::$*&6'*&%"3(18&8(3*&

5@56*3=&/'(6&5@56*3&15&#5*%&?&6;1$$1"8&613*5&:*;&%(@&(8%&@"#;&*2"8"31*5&%*:*8%&#:"8&

16=&A6&2(8&56":&";&16&2(8&3(6*;1($$@&7*&%(3(9*%&(8%&'(;3*%=&A6&15&#8%*;&(66(24=&=&=&=&&

A03&5'(;189&6'15&7*2(#5*&A03&9;()*$@&2"82*;8*%&(8%&!*&8**%&@"#;&'*$:=&I"&!*0;*&

9"189&6"&7*&(54189&@"#&<";&@"#;&(%)12*&"8&%"3(18&8(3*&5*2#;16@&(8%&"8&6'*&JKI&

I-./&(8%&!'(6&2(8&7*&%"8*&(8%&:(;612#$(;$@&6"&$*(;8&6'*&$*55"85&<;"3&@"#&(5&!*$$=&

L'(6&'(5&7**8&(22"3:$15'*%&18&@"#;&2"#86;1*5M>N&

Q/O!E2#Y0'/$JS0!/2J(/Y0!1/$8$Y2-!0'/$&H!/2(#'*$&0!I/$J!'?2!34"55!#$JJ%&*',O!"I'2/!'?2!

5(*/$)*!J22'*&H0M!34"55!2['2&-2-!'?2!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'!12/*$-!$&!'?2!A5BC4D7.!E%0*&200!4(02!

(&-!*'0!G/$1$02-!B'/('2H*#!3&*'*('*820!-$#%J2&'0!'$!"1/*+!;=M!LN;NO<R!3&!'$'(+M!34"55!/2#2*82-!;<!

#$JJ2&'0!$&!'?2!0'/('2H*#!*&*'*('*820!-$#%J2&'!(&-!LR!#$JJ2&'0!$&!'?2!A5BC4D7.!1/$1$0(+O!

3&#+%-2-!*&!'?2!#$JJ2&'0!92/2!I$/J(+!+2''2/0!I/$J!'?2!U5BXM!##5BXM!(&-!"\"4O!]B22!)2+$9M!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<;!D/*#!E/%&&2/CZ*++*(J0M!@X&!^A5BC4D7.!#$&#21'!-282+$1J2&'S!(&-!^;NN_!%1'*J2MSF!`(&%(/,!LaM!LN;NM!?''16bbI$/%JO*#(&&O$/Hb+*0'0b0'/('1+(&CLN;NbJ0HNNNLcO?'J+O!

<L!.*++!A$2/H20M!@4$JJ2&'6!G/$1$02-!B'/('2H*#!3&*'*('*820!I$/!3J1/$82-!A5B!B2#%/*',M!B'()*+*',!(&-!720*+*2&#,!]BB7dMF!K2)/%(/,!LcM!LN;NM!?''16bbI$/%JO*#(&&O$/Hb+*0'0b0'/('C*&*C00/bJ0HNNNNNO?'J+O!

<<!34"55M!@./(&0#/*1'!$I!'?2!U"4!E$(/-!Q22'*&HMF!Q(/#?!WM!LN;NM!?''16bbH(#O*#(&&O$/Hb0,0'2JbI*+20b'/(&0#/*1'CH(#C)$(/-CJ22'*&HCNWJ(/;NC2&O1-IM!LeO!

<=!.?*0!1(00(H2!*0!#$1*2-!82/)('*J!I/$J!34"55S0!%&2-*'2-!'/(&0#/*1'!$I!'?2!J22'*&HO!

<R!.?2!$/*H*&(+!0$%/#2!$I!'?2!/2f%20'!'$!2['2&-!'?2!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'!-2(-+*&2!*0!%&#+2(/O!.?2!34"55!0%JJ(/,!$I!'?2!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'0!#*'20!@/2f%20'0!I/$J!'?2!#$JJ%&*',F!9*'?!&$!I%/'?2/!-2'(*+!]022!)2+$9M!&O!=NdO!.?2!I*/0'!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'!0%)J*''2-!$&!'?2!A5BC4D7.!)%0*&200!#(02g(!T$*&'!+2''2/!I/$J!'?2!4?(*/0!$I!'?2!H5BXM!##5BXM!(&-!"\"4g/2(-0M!@Z2!

92+#$J2!'?2!2['2&0*$&!$I!'?2!#%//2&'!1%)+*#!#$JJ2&'!12/*$-0!$&!34"55S0!1/$1$02-!0'/('2H*#!*&*'*('*820!I$/!*J1/$82-!A5B!02#%/*',M!0'()*+*',!(&-!/20*+*2&#,!(&-!'?2!H+$)(+!A5BC4D7.!)%0*&200!#(02!-$#%J2&'!'$!;=!"1/*+!LN;NF!]022!()$82M!&O!RcdO!

Page 136: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

?72(#'*$&0!@/$A!'B2!34"55!4$AA%&*',CD!@$/!(&!$82/8*29!$@!'B2!0%)0'(&#2!$@!#$AA2&'(/,!@/$A!

'B2!34"55!#$AA%&*',EF!

.B2!#$AA2&'0!G2&2/(++,!'(H2!'B2!@$/A!$@!@$/A(+!*&1%'!@/$A!$/G(&*I('*$&0!$@!8(/*$%0!',120E!J&+,!

@$%/!*&-*8*-%(+0!0%)A*''2-!#$AA2&'0E!.B/22!$@!34"55K0!(-8*0$/,!#$AA*''220!(&-!0%11$/'*&G!

$/G(&*I('*$&0!0%)A*''2-!#$AA2&'06!"L"4C!##5MJC!(&-!G5MJE!N*82!#$AA2/#*(+!0'(H2B$+-2/0!

0%)A*''2-!#$AA2&'06!".O.C!52'!4B$*#2/C!P(,P(+C!P7QMQ5MQ!.2#B&$+$G*20!RA)SC!(&-!TM43UE!

R$82/&A2&'0C!&('*$&(+!4Q7.0C!/2G*0'/,!$12/('$/0C!.LV!(00$#*('*$&0C!(&-!$'B2/!3&'2/&2'!

$/G(&*I('*$&0!0%)A*''2-!'B2!/2A(*&-2/!$@!'B2!#$AA2&'0E!!

J&!"1/*+!WXYC!34"55!B$0'2-!(!1/*8('2C!*&8*'('*$&Z$&+,!9$/H0B$1!$&!V5M!02#%/*',!*&![(0B*&G'$&C!

VE4EE<W![$/H0B$1!1(/'*#*1(&'0\#$A1/*02-!$@!/21/202&'('*820!@/$A!8(/*$%0!#$/&2/0!$@!'B2!V5M!

02#%/*',!#$AA%&*',\-*0#%002-!(!02/*20!$@!/2(+!(&-!B,1$'B2'*#(+!V5M!02#%/*',!0#2&(/*$0!*&!$/-2/!

'$!*-2&'*@,!G(10!*&!2]*0'*&G!02#%/*',!/201$&02!A2#B(&*0A0E!"!-/(@'!$@!'B2!@*&-*&G0!$@!'B2!9$/H0B$1!

9(0!1$0'2-!@$/!1%)+*#!#$AA2&'!$&!^(,!_`C!_a;aE<Y!.B2!-/(@'!/21$/'!*&#+%-20!(!0%AA(/,!$@!'B2!

9$/H0B$1!1/$#22-*&G0C!(!+*0'!$@!'(H2(9(,0C!(&-!(!-*002&'*&G!?A*&$/*',!/21$/'D!@/$A!$'B2/!

9$/H0B$1!1(/'*#*1(&'0E!34"55!0$+*#*'2-!1%)+*#!#$AA2&'0!$&!'B2!-/(@'!/21$/'!'B/$%GB!b%+,!_C!

-%/*&G!9B*#B!*'!/2#2*82-!0*]!#$AA2&'0!*&!'$'(+E<c!

J&!^(,!_`C!34"55!1%)+*0B2-!'9$!(--*'*$&(+!-$#%A2&'0!/2+('2-!'$!V5MZ4Q7.E<d!.B2!@*/0'!9(0!(!

0*]'22&Z1(G2!0%AA(/,!$@!1%)+*#!#$AA2&'0!/2#2*82-!*&!/201$&02!'$!'B2!0'/('2G*#!*&*'*('*820!(&-!

'B2!V5MZ4Q7.!)%0*&200!#(02E`a!.B*0!0%AA(/,!1/$8*-20!0,&$1020!$@!(++!1%)+*#!#$AA2&'0!/2#2*82-C!

B*GB+*GB'*&G!'B/22!$82/(/#B*&G!'B2A206!e;F!'B2!&22-!@$/!(!?-2212/!%&-2/0'(&-*&G!$@!'B2!'B/2('0!

(&-!/*0H0!'$!'B2!V5MD!)2@$/2!(!012#*@*#!V5MZ4Q7.!1/$1$0(+!#(&!)2!%02@%++,!1/$1$02-f!e_F!'B2!&22-!

@$/!A$/2!*&@$/A('*$&!()$%'!2]*0'*&G!02#%/*',!/201$&02!A2#B(&*0A0!(&-!$11$/'%&*'*20!'$!2&B(&#2!

2]*0'*&G!2@@$/'0f!(&-!e<F!'B2!8*29!'B('!20'()+*0B*&G!(!V5MZ4Q7.!A(,!)2!)2,$&-!34"55K0!A*00*$&!

(0!(!'2#B&*#(+!#$$/-*&('*&G!$/G(&*I('*$&E`;!!

.B2!02#$&-!-$#%A2&'!1%)+*0B2-!$&!^(,!_`'B!9(0!(!_WZ1(G2!/2#$/-!$@!34"55K0!#$&0%+'('*$&0!

/2G(/-*&G!V5MZ4Q7.C!-*8*-2-!*&'$!'B/22!(/2(06!e;F!#$&0%+'('*$&0!1/*$/!'$!'B2!1%)+*#('*$&!$@!'B2!

)%0*&200!#(02f!e_F!#$&0%+'('*$&0!/2+('2-!'$!'B2!-/(@'!_a;aX_a;<!0'/('2G*#!1+(&C!$@!9B*#B!V5MZ

4Q7.!9(0!(!1(/'f!(&-!e<F!*&1%'0!/2#2*82-!(@'2/!'B2!)%0*&200!#(02!9(0!1$0'2-!@$/!1%)+*#!/28*29E`_!

.B2!#$&0%+'('*$&!/2#$/-!0B$90!0282/(+!1/*8('2!#$&0%+'('*$&0!9*'B!V5M!0'(H2B$+-2/0!1/*$/!'$!'B2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<W!34"55C!?"1/*+!_a;a!V5MZ4Q7.!J12/('*$&(+!72g%*/2A2&'0!(&-!4$++()$/('*$&!"&(+,0*0![$/H0B$1!721$/'CD!^(,!_`C!_a;aC!B''16hh999E*#(&&E$/Gh2&h'$1*#0h00/h-&0Z#2/'Z#$++()$/('*$&Z(&(+,0*0Z_`A(,;aZ2&E1-@E!

<Y!34"55C!?P%)+*#!4$AA2&'6!"1/*+!_a;a!V5MZ4Q7.!J12/('*$&(+!72g%*/2A2&'0!O!4$++()$/('*$&!"&(+,0*0CD!^(,!_`C!_a;aC!B''16hh999E*#(&&E$/Gh2&h(&&$%&#2A2&'0h(&&$%&#2A2&'Z_`A(,;aZ2&EB'A!

<c!34"55C!?-&0Z#$++()Z(&(+,0*0CD!^(,!_`C!_a;aC!B''16hh@$/%AE*#(&&E$/Gh+*0'0h-&0Z#$++()Z(&(+,0*0hE!

<d!34"55C!?P%)+*#!4$AA2&'6!"1/*+!_a;a!V5MZ4Q7.!J12/('*$&(+!72g%*/2A2&'0!O!4$++()$/('*$&!"&(+,0*0CD!^(,!_`C!_a;aC!B''16hh999E*#(&&E$/Gh2&h(&&$%&#2A2&'0h(&&$%&#2A2&'Z_`A(,;aZ2&EB'AE!

`a!34"55C!?M%AA(/,!O!"&(+,0*0!$@!4$AA2&'0!$&!'B2!M2#%/*',!M'/('2G*#!3&*'*('*820!(&-!R+$)(+!V5MZ4Q7.!U%0*&200!4(02!1(12/CD!^(,!_`C!_a;aC!B''16hh999E*#(&&E$/Gh2&h1%)+*#Z#$AA2&'h0%AA(/,Z(&(+,0*0Z0'/('2G*#Z00/Z*&*'*('*820Z(&-Z-&0Z#2/'Z)%0*&200Z#(02Z_`A(,;aZ2&E1-@E!

`;!3)*-EC!;X_E!

`_!34"55C!?V5MZ4Q7.!4$&0%+'('*$&!/2#$/-CD!^(,!_`C!_a;aC!B''16hh999E*#(&&E$/Gh2&h'$1*#0h00/h-&0Z#2/'Z#$&0%+'('*$&Z/2#$/-Z_`A(,;aZ2&E1-@E!

Page 137: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

1%)+*#('*$&!$?!'@2!)%0*&200!#(02A!(0!92++!(0!0282&!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!/2C(/-*&C!'@2!*&*'*(+!

0%CC20'*$&!?$/!D5EF4G7.!*&!'@2!HI;IJHI;<!0'/('2C*#!1+(&K!!

!"#$%&'()*+",-)."'/$"01233"1)..4*('5"

.@2!?$++$9*&C!02#'*$&0!-20#/*)2!'@/22!(/2(0!$?!'@2!34"55!#$BB%&*',L0!/2(#'*$&0!'$!'@2!

D5EF4G7.!1/$1$0(+!(&-!M/K!N2#O0'/$BL0!5(*/$)*!/2B(/O06!P;Q!*00%20!$?!0%)0'(&#2A!

*&#+%-*&C!34"55L0!(00200B2&'!$?!'@2!#%//2&'!0'('2!$?!D5E!02#%/*',!(&-!'@2!-2'(*+0!$?!'@2!

0$+%'*$&!*'!1/$1$020R!PHQ!'@2!2S'2&'!'$!9@*#@!D5E!02#%/*',!$12/('*$&0!?(++!9*'@*&!34"55L0!

B(&-('2R!(&-!P<Q!*00%20!$?!1/$#2-%/2A!*&#+%-*&C!$12&&200A!'/(&01(/2&#,A!1%)+*#!*&1%'A!(&-!

0'(O2@$+-2/!1(/'*#*1('*$&K!

!"#"$%&'()*+),-.$/((&.($

.@2!B$0'!*BB2-*('2!0%)0'(&'*82!*00%2!*0!'@2!4GTL0!#@(/(#'2/*U('*$&!$?!'@2!?/(C*+*',!$?!'@2!D5EK!

M(&,!0'(O2@$+-2/0V*&#+%-*&C!1(/'*#*1(&'0!?/$B!'@2!5(*/$)*!B22'*&CV?2+'!'@('!34"55L0!4GT!

2S(CC2/('2-!'@2!'@/2('0!?(#*&C!D5E!02#%/*',!(&-!%&-2/0'('2-!'@2!2??2#'*82&200!$?!2S*0'*&C!02#%/*',!

/201$&02!B2#@(&*0B0K!.9$!-(,0!(?'2/!'@2!B22'*&CA!?$/!*&0'(&#2A!4@/*0!D*001(*&!P$&!)2@(+?!$?!'@2!

##5ETQ!1%)+*0@2-!(!0@(/1+,F9$/-2-!+2''2/A!#(++*&C!M/K!N2#O0'/$BL0!/2B(/O0!W*&?+(BB('$/,X!(&-!

W(+(/B*&CKXY<!.@2!&2S'!B$&'@A!Z,&&!E'K!"B$%/!9/$'2!'$!'@2!34"55!N$(/-!$&!)2@(+?!$?!'@2!3&'2/&2'!

E$#*2',!P3ET4QA!0'('*&C!'@('!M/K!N2#O0'/$BL0!9(/&*&C!()$%'!'@2!?/(C*+*',!$?!'@2!D5E!W@(0!/(*02-!

#$&#2/&!(B$&C!B(&,A!,2'!'@2!?(#'0!'$!0%)0'(&'*('2!'@('!0'('2B2&'!@(82!&$'!)22&!B(-2!(8(*+()+2!

'$!'@2!#$BB%&*',KXYY!W[M\(&,!/2#$C&*U2-!2S12/'0!*&!D5E!02#%/*',AX!0@2!9/$'2A!!

!"#$%&'%#$(&#)%*"+,'-%./".%./$+%)&%'&.%"-#$$%./".%./$%0'.$#'$.%,*%*1))$'2+%$34$#,$'(,'-%

)#"5".,("22+%-#$".$#%&#%'$6%.+4$*%&7%".."(89%&#%./".%./$%:;<9%&#%./$%0'.$#'$.%,.*$279%"#$%

2,8$2+%.&%(&22"4*$%".%"'+%5&5$'.=%

]28*&!M%/1@,!('!:&5",'%0'(,.$!%&0,B1('@2'*#(++,!#(++2-!'@2!/2B(/O0!W1(/'!#(++!'$!(/B0A!1(/'!

4@*#O2&!Z*''+2KXY^!M/K!N,/$&!_$++(&-A!4GT!(&-!`/20*-2&'!$?!'@2!4(&(-*(&!3&'2/&2'!72C*0'/('*$&!

"%'@$/*',A!9/$'26!

./$%.&'$%&7%./$%5$**"-$%(&12)%>$%(&'*,)$#$)%*&5$6/".%,'72"55".&#+=!?"'+%4$&42$%,'%./$%

#&&5%7$2.%./".%@$(8*.#&5%6"*%*4$"8,'-%&1.%&7%.1#'%"')%),*#$-"#),'-%./$%6&#8%./$%

(&551',.+%,*%"2#$")+%1')$#."8,'-%.&%$'*1#$%./$%*.">,2,.+%"')%./$%*$(1#,.+%&7%./$%:;<=ABC%%

72(#'*$&0!'$!'@2!0%)0'(&#2!$?!'@2!D5EF4G7.!1/$1$0(+V(0!2S1/2002-!*&!1%)+*#!#$BB2&'0!'$!

34"55!(&-!$)02/8('*$&0!B(-2!*&!*&'2/8*290!?$/!'@*0!#(02!0'%-,V@(82!8(/*2-!0%)0'(&'*(++,A!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Y<!34"55A!WZ2''2/!?/$B!4@/*0!D*001(*&!'$!7$-!N2#O0'/$BXA!M(/#@!;;A!HI;IA!@''16aa999K*#(&&K$/Ca#$//201$&-2&#2a-*001(*&F'$F)2#O0'/$BF;;B(/;IF2&K1-?A!;K!

YY!34"55A!WZ2''2/!?/$B!Z,&&!E'K!"B$%/!'$!34"55!N$(/-!$?!D*/2#'$/0AX!"1/*+!;YA!HI;IA!@''16aa999K*#(&&K$/Ca#$//201$&-2&#2a(B$%/F'$F-2&C('2F'@/%0@F;Y(1/;IF2&K1-?A!;K!

Y^!]28*&!M%/1@,A!WN2#O0'/$B6!D5E!*0!%&-2/!(''(#OAX!:&5",'%0'(,.$A!M(/#@!;;A!HI;IA!@''16aa-$B(*&*&#*'2K#$Ba)2#O0'/$BF-&0F*0F%&-2/F(''(#OaK!

Y=!N,/$&!_$++(&-A!WD5EF4$BB%&*',!GB2/C2&#,!7201$&02!.2(BA!$/!4G7.AX!D1>2,(%:&5",'A!M(/#@!H=A!HI;IA!@''16aa)+$CK#*/(K#(aHI;IaI<a-&0F#$BB%&*',F2B2/C2&#,F/201$&02F'2(BF$/F#2/'aK!

Page 138: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

/(&?*&?!@/$A!#(%'*$%0!0%11$/'!$&!$&2!2&-!$@!'B2!012#'/%A!'$!8*?$/$%0!0C21'*#*0A!$&!'B2!$'B2/D!

.B202!/2(#'*$&0!#2&'2/!$&!'9$!A(*&!E%20'*$&06!@*/0'F!9B2'B2/!(&!$/?(&*G('*$&!0%#B!(0!H5IJ4K7.!

*0!&2#200(/,F!?*82&!'B2!#%//2&'!+(&-0#(12!$@!H5I!02#%/*',!/*0C0L!(&-!02#$&-F!9B2'B2/!'B2!

1/$1$02-!$/?(&*G('*$&F!(0!012#*@*2-!*&!34"55M0!)%0*&200!#(02F!*0!(11/$1/*('2+,!#$&#2*82-D!

34"55M0!(/?%A2&'N(0!2O1/2002-!*&!'B2!P/$1$02-!I'/('2?*#!3&*'*('*820!(&-!'B2!H5IJ4K7.!

)%0*&200!#(02F!(&-!$%'+*&2-!),!*'0!4KQ!*&!5(*/$)*N*0!0'/(*?B'@$/9(/-6!(&!*&#/2(02!*&!'B2!

@/2E%2&#,!(&-!#$A1+2O*',!$@!(''(#C0!$&!'B2!H5I!B(0!+2-!'$!'B2!&22-!@$/!(!#2&'/(+*G2-!)$-,!'$!

#$$/-*&('2!1/$(#'*82!(&-!/2(#'*82!/201$&020!'$!H5I!02#%/*',!'B/2('0D!4$AA%&*',!A2A)2/0F!*&!

#$&'/(0'F!-*01+(,!(!/(&?2!$@!/2(#'*$&0!'$!34"55M0!#B(/(#'2/*G('*$&!$@!'B2!/*0C0!@(#*&?!H5I!02#%/*',!

(0!'B2!@$++$9*&?!0'('2A2&'0!*++%0'/('2D!

.B2!4$%&#*+!$@!K%/$12(&!5('*$&(+!.$1J+282+!H$A(*&!72?*0'/*20!RS4K5.7TU!9/$'2!'B('!S34"55!

0B$%+-!@$#%0!@*/0'!$&!0B(/*&?!*&@$/A('*$&T!()$%'!02#%/*',!'B/2('0!(&-!2O*0'*&?!/201$&02!

#(1()*+*'*20!S*&!$/-2/!'$!)%*+-!(!#$AA$&!(00200A2&'!$@!/*0C0!(&-!92(C&20020DTV=!W,&&!I'D!"A$%/F!

E%$'2-!()$82F!E%20'*$&2-!9B2'B2/!34"55M0!(00200A2&'!(+*?&2-!9*'B!'B2!X%-?A2&'!$@!'B2!H5I!

02#%/*',!#$AA%&*',D!3&!B*0!/201$&02!'$!Y0D!I'!"A$%/F!Y/D!Z2#C0'/$A!2#B$2-!'B2!#(++!@$/!A$/2!

*&@$/A('*$&F!)%'!0B*@'2-!0$A2!$@!'B2!)%/-2&!'$!'B2!H5I!#$AA%&*',6!S[2!B(82\)22&!*&@$/A2-FT!

B2!9/*'20F!!

!"#!$%#&'$()*+,!(+),$"#-)$)./)(+)&0)1$+&0()#,),$+&$23!&)!$#!!#04,5$26!$&3&)$"#-)7$,3$8#(7$

2))&$9+::+&*$!3$03%)$83(!"$#&1$,"#()$!")+($1#!#;<=!$936:1$2)$-)('$"):/86:$+8$9)$036:1$93(4$

!3*)!")($!3$*#!")($#11+!+3&#:$1#!#$3&$#!!#04,$3&$()*+,!(+),7$#&1$3&$"39$!"#!$+&83(%#!+3&$+,$

2)+&*$,"#()1$#&1$%)#,6()1$3&$#$*:32#:$2#,+,<$=!$936:1$*()#!:'$03&!(+26!)$!3$36($>3+&!$

)883(!,$!3$)-#:6#!)$!")$,)(+36,&),,$38$!")$!"()#!$#&1$033(1+&#!)$36($83(0),$%3()$)88)0!+-):'$

!3$%))!$+!<?@$$

5%A2/$%0!#$AA%&*',!A2A)2/0!B(82!2O1/2002-!'B2!8*29!*&!*&'2/8*290!(&-!1%)+*#!#$AA2&'0F!

9B*#B!34"55!(112(/0!'$!0B(/2F!'B('!@%/'B2/!*&@$/A('*$&!*0!&22-2-!)2@$/2!'B2!@/(?*+*',!$@!'B2!H5I!

#(&!)2!(##%/('2+,!(002002-D!

.B2!02#$&-!1$*&'!$@!#$&'2&'*$&!*0!9B2'B2/F!?*82&!2O*0'*&?!C&$9+2-?2!()$%'!'B2!'B/2('0!'$!H5I!

02#%/*',F!(!#2&'/(+*G2-!H5IJ4K7.]+*C2!$/?(&*G('*$&!0B$%+-!)2!20'()+*0B2-D!"0!34"55M0!4KQ!A(-2!

#+2(/!*&!B*0!+2''2/!'$!3IQ4F!34"55!#$&0*-2/0!2O*0'*&?!02#%/*',!/201$&02!A2#B(&*0A0!'$!)2!+(/?2+,!

*&(-2E%('26!S3!(A!&$'!#$&8*&#2-!'B('!92!(/2!,2'!-$*&?!2&$%?BFT!9/$'2!Y/D!Z2#C0'/$AF!S$/!A$8*&?!

E%*#C+,!2&$%?BDTV^!Y(&,F!B$9282/F!2O1/2002-!#$&#2/&!'B('!'B2!A$-2+!34"55!-20#/*)20!*&!*'0!H5IJ

4K7.!1/$1$0(+!*0!&$'!(&!$1'*A(+!(11/$(#BD!_$/!*&0'(&#2F!'B2!72?*0'/*20!I'(C2B$+-2/!`/$%1F!*&!(!

%&(&*A$%0+,J(11/$82-!0'('2A2&'F!(/?%2-!'B('!2O*0'*&?!H5I!02#%/*',!/201$&02!A2#B(&*0A0!(/2!

92++J20'()+*0B2-!(&-!$@'2&!B*?B+,!/$)%0'D!.B2!/201$&020!'$!'B2!4$&@*#C2/!9$/A!(&-!'B2!a(A*&0C,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

V=!4K5.7F!S4K5.7!4$AA2&'!*&!/201$&02!'$!'B2!#$&0%+'('*$&!$&!'B2!H$A(*&!5(A2!I,0'2AJ4$A1%'2/!KA2/?2&#,!7201$&02!.2(A!RH5IJ4K7.U!Z%0*&200!4(02FT!Y(/#B!bVF!bc;cF!B''16dd@$/%AD*#(&&D$/?d+*0'0d-&0J#2/'J1/$1$0(+d1-@PeKV*f`873D1-@D!

Vg!7$-!Z2#C0'/$AF!SW2''2/!@/$A!7$-!Z2#C0'/$A!'$!W,&&!I'D!"A$%/FT!h%&2!;gF!bc;cF!B''16dd999D*#(&&D$/?d#$//201$&-2&#2d)2#C0'/$AJ'$J0'J(A$%/J;gX%&;cJ2&D1-@D!

V^!3)*-D!

Page 139: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

8%+&2/()*+*',?!(0!$&2!2@(A1+2?!B-2A$&0'/('2-!(!82/,!2CC2#'*82!+282+!$C!#$$/-*&('*$&?!*&C$/A('*$&!

0D(/*&E?!(&-!(#'*$&FGHI!J*A*+(/+,?!4K5.7!(/E%20!*&!*'0!#$AA2&'0!'D('!'D2!#$AA%&*',L0!/201$&02!'$!

4$&C*#M2/!*0!

!"#$%&$'(")**+,(%!()-."-&"(/$"&!'("(/!(",$'+%)(0"%$*)$,"&+.1!2$.(!**0"-."'--#$%!()-."!.1"

'-**!3-%!()-."!2-.4,("1)&&$%$.("$5#$%(,"!.1"(/!(6,"/-7"(/$"'+%%$.(",$'+%)(0".$(7-%8"),"

3+)*1"+#9":.",+'/"!"&%!2$7-%8"1)&&$%$.(",$'+%)(0").')1$.(,"'!."3$"!11%$,,$1"2-%$"$&&$'();$"

<,)'="!.1"-."(/$"*-.4"%+."2+'/"2-%$"$&&)')$.("(/!."7)(/"(/$"#%-#-,$1"'-.'$#("-&"!">?@A"

&-'+,).4"-."-.$",).4*$"!%$!"7)(/"#-($.()!*",$'+%)(0"#%-3*$2B"*)8$"CDE9FG""

N0F!J'F!"A$%/!(E/220!9*'D!N/F!O2#M0'/$A!()$%'!'D2!*A1$/'(&#2!$C!P5J!02#%/*',?!)%'?!/2E(/-*&E!

'D2!012#*C*#0!$C!34"55L0!P5JQ4K7.!1/$1$0(+?!&$'20!'D('!B92!(/2!#$&#2/&2-!'D('!'D2!#%//2&'!

1/$1$0(+0!-$!&$'!0D$9!#$&8*&#*&E+,!'D('!'D2/2!D(0!)22&!(!C%++!(&(+,0*0!$C!(+'2/&('2!(11/$(#D20FGHR!!

S&!'D2!$'D2/!D(&-?!0$A2!*&'2/8*29220!C/$A!'D2!#,)2/02#%/*',!(&-!P5J!$12/('*$&(+!#$AA%&*'*20!

D(82!2&-$/02-!'D2!*-2(!$C!(!#2&'/(+*T2-!4K7.FH<!N%#D!$C!'D2!*A12'%0!C$/!'D2!*-2(!-2/*82-!C/$A!

'D2!C*/0'!BU+$)(+!P5J!J2#%/*',?!J'()*+*',?!V!720*+*2&#,!J,A1$0*%AG!$C!W2)/%(/,!RIIXF!.D2!/21$/'!

C/$A!'D2!0,A1$0*%A!(/E%20!'D('!

(/$"CDE"($'/.)'!*B"-#$%!()-.!*B"!.1",$'+%)(0"'-22+.)()$,"!%$"1),H-).($1"!.1").".$$1"-&"!"

1$1)'!($1").&-%2!()-.",/!%).4"!.1").')1$.("%$,#-.,$"'!#!3)*)(09"A/$,$"&+.'()-.,"!%$"

4$.$%!**0"#$%&-%2$1"30">?@A,B"3+(".-",+'/"'!#!3)*)(0"$5),(,"$5#%$,,*0"&-%"(/$"CDE"

'-22+.)(09IFJ""

J*A*+(/+,?!Y(%+!Z*@*2?!C$%&-2/!$C!P5JQS"74?!D(0!(-8$#('2-!1%)+*#+,!C$/!'D2!#/2('*$&!$C!(!P5JQ

4K7.!$/E(&*T('*$&6!B[2!&22-!(!R\@]!A$&*'$/*&E!(&-!/201$&02!(&-!#$$/-*&('*$&!C%&#'*$&?G!D2!

9/*'20?!B9*'D!C%++!'*A2!(&(+,0'0!+$$M*&E!('!/2(+!'*A2!P5J!282&'0!(&-!1(/'*#*1('*&E!*&!(!E+$)(+!A20D!

$C!P5J!5S40FGHH!"+'D$%ED!P5J!02#%/*',!9(0!$/*E*&(++,!(!#$A1$&2&'!$C!S"74L0!A(&-('2?!N/F!Z*@*2!

9/*'20!'D('!BJ$A29D2/2!(+$&E!'D2!9(,!92!E$'!-*0'/(#'2-F!F!F!F!P5JQS"74!9(0!(!D%E2!%&-2/'(M*&E?!

(&-!$&2!'D('!3!0*E&*C*#(&'+,!%&-2/20'*A('2-FG!!

!"#$%&'(()*$+(,$,-./0123$456752-$

34"55!1/$1$020!'$!$82/022!'D2!E$82/&(&#2?!$12/('*$&0?!(&-!C%&-*&E!^$C!'D2!&$&'/*8*(+!_\FR!

A*++*$&!(&&%(+!)%-E2'`!$C!'D2!$/E(&*T('*$&!B%&'*+!'D2!P5JQ4K7.L0!*&*'*(+!$12/('*$&(+!#(1()*+*',!*0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HI!7,JU?!B72E*0'/*20!J'(M2D$+-2/!U/$%1!J'('2A2&'0!72E(/-*&E!'D2!aY/$1$02-!J'/('2E*#!3&*'*('*820!C$/!3A1/$82-!P5J!

J2#%/*',?!J'()*+*',!(&-!720*+*2&#,!^JJ7`L!(&-!aU+$)(+!P5JQ4K7.!O%0*&200!4(02?LLL!"1/*+!;\?!RI;I?!D''16bb999FE'+-/2E*0'/*20F$/Eb92)CAc02&-b]XF!

H;!4K5.7?!B4K5.7!4$AA2&'?G!;F!

HR!d,&&!J'F!"A$%/?!Bd2''2/!C/$A!d,&&!J'F!"A$%/!'$!7$-!O2#M0'/$A?G!RF!

H<!3&'2/8*29?!J21'2A)2/!RI;IF!

H\!34"55!2'!(+F?!B.D2!U+$)(+!P5J!J2#%/*',?!J'()*+*',?!V!720*+*2&#,!J,A1$0*%A6!J%AA(/,?!./2&-0?!(&-!52@'!J'210?G!"1/*+!R?!RIIX?!D''16bb999FE'*0#FE('2#DF2-%bFFFbP5JcJJ7cJ,A1$0*%AcJ%AA(/,c721$/'F1-CF!

HH!Y(%+!Z*@*2?!BY2/012#'*820!$&!(!P5JQ4K7.?G!N(/#D!;R?!RI;I?!D''16bb999F*0#F$/Eb#$AA%&*',b)+$EbRI;II<b12/012#'*820Q-&0Q#2/'F!

Page 140: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

(#?*282-@ABC!D$9282/E!'?2!1/$1$0(+!-$20!&$'!0'*1%+('2!?$9!34"55!9*++!-2'2/F*&2!9?2&!'?*0!

#(1(#*',!?(0!)22&!/2(#?2-G!*&!(--*'*$&E!'?2!12/F(&2&'!0'/%#'%/2!$H!'?2!$/I(&*J('*$&K0!

I$82/&(&#2E!$12/('*$&0E!(&-!H%&-*&I!/2F(*&!%&-2H*&2-@!

L(&,!#$FF%&*',!F2F)2/0!?(82!/2M2#'2-!'?2!*-2(!$H!34"55!1+(,*&I!(&!$12/('*$&(+!/$+2!*&!N5O!

02#%/*',@!3&!(!M$*&'!+2''2/E!'?2!I5OPE!##5OPE!(&-!"Q"4!9/$'2!'?('!R3&!I2&2/(+!'2/F0E!34"55!1+(,0!(!

#$$/-*&('*&IE!&$&S$12/('*$&(+!/$+2!*&!F(&(I*&I!3&'2/&2'!&(F*&I!(&-!&%F)2/*&I!/20$%/#20@!

D$9282/E!92!(/2!#$&#2/&2-!'?('E!*&!'?*0!1(/'*#%+(/!#(02E!34"55K0!1/$1$02-!/$+2!/2F(*&0!

%&#+2(/@ABT!L0@!O'@!"F$%/!9/*'20E!R92!#$&'*&%2!'$!)2!#$&#2/&2-!'?('!34"55!F(,!)2!)/$(-2&*&I!

$%'!H/$F!*'0!1/*&#*1+2!F(&-('2!(0!#$$/-*&('$/!$H!'?2!I+$)(+!/20$%/#2!'?('!*0!'?2!-$F(*&!&(F2!

0,0'2F!*&'$!'?2!F(&(I2F2&'!$H!&29!(&-!12/*1?2/(+!$12/('*$&(+!H%&#'*$&0@ABU!.?2!72I*0'/*20!

O'(V2?$+-2/!W/$%1!1/$8*-20!(!0*F*+(/!(/I%F2&'6!

!"#$$%&'()*+%*'%(*+%,-./0+%/)1%*23%#44(56/*(')%'4%"'66(*63)*+%7#'"8%*'%134()3%(*+%

53+&')+(9(.(*-%*'%3)+:53%*23%+*/9.3%/)1%+3;:53%'&35/*(')%'4%*23%!)*35)3*<+%:)(=:3%(13)*(4(35%

+-+*36+>%!)%?3)35/.%*356+@%!"#$$%&./-+%/%;''51()/*()?@%)')A'&35/*(')/.%5'.3%()%6/)/?()?%

!)*35)3*%)/6()?%/)1%):6935()?%53+':5;3+>%B'03C35@%()%*23%DDE%/)1%F$DA"GEH%1';:63)*+@%

!"#$$<+%&5'&'+31%5'.3%+336+%9'*2%:);.3/5%/)1%'C35A95'/1>%H23%E-DI%+2/53+%*23%;');35)%

/.53/1-%C'(;31%9-%+'63%()%*23%;'66:)(*-%*2/*%!"#$$<+%5'.3%()%*23+3%&'*3)*(/.%()(*(/*(C3+%

/)1%:)135*/J()?+%)'*%;5'++%'C35%()*'%/)%'&35/*(')/.%;/&/;(*->%!"#$$%+2':.1%:)135*/J3%

/;*(C(*(3+%*2/*%/53%;')+(+*3)*%0(*2%(*+%.(6(*31%*3;2)(;/.%;''51()/*(')%5'.3>%H2353%+2':.1%93%/%

+-+*36/*(;%3K/6()/*(')%'4%*2/*%5'.3%()%53./*(')%*'%*23%DDE%/)1%F$DA"GEH@%:+()?%3K(+*()?%

;'66:)(*-%&5';3++3+>%!"#$$%6:+*%93%/9.3%*'%3K&./()%(*+%536(*%/)1%0'5J%0(*2()%(*@%5/*235%

*2/)%3K&/)1()?%(*+%6(++(')%*'%633*%:)53/.(+*(;%'5%:)()4'5631%3K&3;*/*(')+@%'5%()*'%/53/+%

93+*%4(..31%9-%'*235%3)*(*(3+>LM%%

.?2!72I*0'/*20!O'(V2?$+-2/!W/$%1!1$*&'0!'$!'?2!'?*/-!$H!34"55K0!#$/2!8(+%20E!(0!0'('2-!*&!'?2!

34"55!X,+(90E!'$!0%)0'(&'*('2!*'0!(/I%F2&'!'?('!34"55!0?$%+-!(8$*-!1+(,*&I!(&!$12/('*$&(+!/$+2!

9?2/282/!1$00*)+2@CY!.?*0!#$/2!8(+%2!*06!

H'%*23%3K*3)*%43/+(9.3%/)1%/&&5'&5(/*3@%13.3?/*()?%;''51()/*(')%4:);*(')+%*'%'5%53;'?)(N()?%

*23%&'.(;-%5'.3%'4%'*235%53+&')+(9.3%3)*(*(3+%*2/*%534.3;*%*23%()*353+*+%'4%/443;*31%&/5*(3+>OP%%

.?2!#$&#2/&0!/2I(/-*&I!34"55K0!N5O!02#%/*',!F(&-('2!F(,!(+0$!0'2F!H/$F!%&#2/'(*&',!

0%//$%&-*&I!*'0!*&'2&'*$&0@!P&2!*&'2/8*2922!-20#/*)2-!N5O!02#%/*',!(0!(&!*00%2!$&!9?*#?!34"55!

?(0!R/2(+!+2I*'*F(#,A!(&-!(&!(/2(!9?2/2!*'!#$%+-!0%##200H%++,!H(#*+*'('2!(!)$''$FS%1!-2#*0*$&S

F(V*&I!1/$#200!(F$&I!*'0!H%++!/(&I2!$H!0'(V2?$+-2/0@!Q(#V!$H!#+(/*',!/2I(/-*&I!34"55K0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BC!34"55E!RN5OS4Z7.!X%0*&200!4(02EA!;B[;C@!

BT!I5OPE!##5OPE!(&-!"Q"4E!R\$*&'!+2''2/!H/$F!4?(*/0!$H!'?2!I5OPE!##5OP!(&-!"Q"4EA!L(/#?!]BE!]Y;YE!?''16^^I&0$@*#(&&@$/I^#$//201$&-2&#2^#?(*/0S+2''2/S/2S-&0S#2/'S]BF(/;YS2&@1-H@!

BU!Q,&&!O'@!"F$%/E!RQ2''2/!'$!7$-!X2#V0'/$FEA!]@!

B=!7,OWE!R72I*0'/*20!O'(V2?$+-2/!W/$%1!O'('2F2&'0EA!]@!

CY!7,OWE!R72I*0'/*20!O'(V2?$+-2/!W/$%1!O'('2F2&'0@A!

C;!34"55E!RX,+(90EA!O2#'*$&!]@<@!

Page 141: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

?$'*8('*$&0@!A$9282/@!A(0!?(-2!'A2!B5CD4E7.!1/$1$0(+!FG22+!+*H2!(!+(&-!I/()@J!#(%0*&I!(!F?*002-!

$11$/'%&*',J!*&!'A2!/2(+?!$G!B5C!02#%/*',@!(##$/-*&I!'$!'A*0!*&'2/8*2922KLM!!

.A2!(?)*I%*',!0%//$%&-*&I!34"55N0!/$+2!*&!'A2!1/$1$02-!$/I(&*O('*$&!*0!-*01+(,2-!*&!'A2!34"55!

4EPN0!+2''2/!'$!3CP4K!FQRS2!A(82!&282/!1/$1$02-!'A('!34"55!0A$%+-!)2!'A2!$12/('$/!$G!0%#A!(!

4E7.@J!A2!9/$'2@!F)%'!/('A2/!A(82!(0H2-!'A2!#$??%&*',!G$/!'A2*/!8*29!$&!'A2!1/$1$0(+!'A('!0%#A!(!

I+$)(+!B5C!4E7.!0A$%+-!)2!20'()+*0A2-KJLT!3&!'A2!0(?2!1(/(I/(1A@!A$9282/@!A2!9/$'2@!F3!'A*&H!

'A('!34"55!0A$%+-!1/$)()+,!A(82!(!/$+2!*&!'A2!$12/('*$&!$G!0%#A!(!4E7.@!*G!/2U%*/2-!),!'A2!

#$??%&*',@!)%'!*&!(&,!#(02@!92!+$$H!G$/9(/-!'$!'A2!#$&'*&%*&I!-*0#%00*$&0KJ!.A2!B5CD4E7.!

)%0*&200!#(02!-$20!&$'!#+2(/+,!-20#/*)2!9A2'A2/!34"55!0A$%+-!)2!'A2!$12/('$/!$/!?2/2+,!A(82!(!

/$+2!*&!'A2!$12/('*$&!$G!'A2!4E7.K!

!"#$%&'()*+&,-$.//+)/$

.A2!/28*29!$G!(!-*82/02!02'!$G!1%)+*#+,!(8(*+()+2!?('2/*(+0!V022!()$82W@!(0!92++!(0!(!02/*20!$G!

*&'2/8*290@!0%II20'0!'A('!'A2!/$$'!$G!'A2!B5CD4E7.!#$&'/$82/0,!*0X'$!8(/,*&I!-2I/220X

(''/*)%'2-!'$!G(#'$/0!0%#A!(0!+*?*'2-!'/(&01(/2&#,!*&!'A2!-282+$1?2&'!$G!'A2!B5CD4E7.!

1/$1$0(+@!'A2!12/#2*82-!()02&#2!$G!$11$/'%&*'*20!G$/!1%)+*#!*&1%'!1/*$/!'$!'A2!1%)+*#('*$&!$G!

'A2!-2'(*+2-!)%0*&200!#(02@!(&-!'A2!(11(/2&'!+(#H!$G!(-2U%('2!1/*$/!#$&0%+'('*$&!9*'A!'A2!

#$??%&*',!$G!B5C!02#%/*',!0'(H2A$+-2/0K!

!"#"0"$12)33)//$,3*$4&,3/2,&)3(5$

"0!'A2!()$82!/2(#'*$&0!*&-*#('2@!(!12/#2*82-!+(#H!$G!$12&&200!(112(/0!'$!A(82!G%2+2-!(--*'*$&(+!

#$&#2/&0K!721$/-2-+,@!B5C!0'(H2A$+-2/0!92/2!&$'!*&G$/?2-!'A('!Y/K!Z2#H0'/$?!9$%+-!)2!?(H*&I!

(&,!/2?(/H0!/2+('2-!'$!B5C!02#%/*',!*00%20!1/*$/!'$!'A2!5(*/$)*!?22'*&IKL<!.A*0!#+(*?!*0!

0%11$/'2-!),!'A2!G(#'!'A('!B5C!02#%/*',!9(0!&$'!?2&'*$&2-!$&!'A2!["4!?22'*&I!(I2&-(K!!

34"55N0!4EP!$12&2-!A*0!/2?(/H0!9*'A!'A2!#+(*?!'A('!A2!A(-!F12/0$&(++,!#$&0%+'2-!9*'A!$82/!M=!

4EPN0!$G!'A2!'$1!72I*0'/*20!(&-!72I*0'/(/0!I+$)(++,KJ!"0!$&2!*&'2/8*2922!&$'2-@!A$9282/@!Y/K!

Z2#H0'/$?!A(0!/2G%02-!'$!-*0#+$02!'A2!&(?20!$G!'A2!/2I*0'/,!(&-!/2I*0'/(/!?2?)2/0!9*'A!9A$?!

A2!#$&0%+'2-K!\%/'A2/?$/2@!34"55!A(0!#$&-%#'2-!0%/82,0!9*'A*&!I$82/&?2&'0!()$%'!B5C!

02#%/*',!*00%20@!%&)2H&$9&0'!'$!?2?)2/0!$G!'A2!B5C!#$??%&*'*20!9*'A*&!'A$02!#$%&'/*20KL]!"0!

Y/K!B*001(*&!2^1/2002-!*&!A*0!+2''2/!G/$?!Y(/#A!;;@!M=;=@!'A2!5(*/$)*!/2?(/H0!A(82@!'$!8(/,*&I!

-2I/220@!%&-2/?*&2-!'A2!#/2-*)*+*',!$G!##._B!$12/('$/0!$&!B5C!02#%/*',!*00%20!*&!'A2!2,20!$G!

I$82/&?2&'0@!*?1+(&'*&I!%&&2#200(/,!)(//*2/0!'$!B5C!1$+*#,!I$(+0K!P&2!*&'2/8*2922!0%II20'2-!

'A('!34"55N0!A(&-+*&I!$G!'A2!1/$#200!+2-!'$!'A2!-2?*02!$G!(&!*-2(!'A('!$'A2/9*02!#(//*2-!(!I$$-!

(?$%&'!$G!+2I*'*?(#,!(&-!?(,!A(82!+2-!'$!1/$-%#'*82!#$++()$/('*$&0!)2'922&!34"55!(&-!'A2!B5C!

02#%/*',!#$??%&*',KLL!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LM!3&'2/8*29@!C21'2?)2/!M=;=K!

LT!7$-!Z2#H0'/$?@!F_2''2/!'$!_,&&!C'K!"?$%/@J!MK!

L<!3&'2/8*29@!C21'2?)2/!M=;=K!

L]!3&'2/8*29@!C21'2?)2/!M=;=K!

LL!3&'2/8*29@!C21'2?)2/!M=;=K!

Page 142: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<;=!

>282/(+!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!0%)?*00*$&0!2@1/2002-!0*?*+(/!#$&#2/&0!()$%'!(!A2&2/(+!+(#B!$C!

$12&&200!(&-!'/(&01(/2&#,!'D/$%AD$%'!'D2!E5>F4G7.!1/$#200H!A2&2/('*&A!#$&C%0*$&!(&-!

?*0'/%0'!()$%'!34"55I0!*&'2&'*$&0J!!

!"#"$%&'()*+%,-.'/%0-1%2/03456)147%&07/*+*.0/*6-%

3&'2/8*290!(&-!1%)+*#!?('2/*(+0!D(82!/(*02-!'D2!*00%2!$C!'D2!-2A/22!'$!9D*#D!34"55!0$+*#*'2-!(&-!

(--/2002-!*&1%'!C/$?!E5>!02#%/*',!0'(B2D$+-2/0!(&-!'D2!1%)+*#!('!+(/A2!-%/*&A!'D2!E5>F4G7.!

1/$#200J!K/J!E*001(*&H!C$/!*&0'(&#2H!9/$'26!

!"#$%&'%(#')$*+($'&,$-+,.$/&"#$0&%")$&'$)(%"#+,/$+))"()1$2",$-+,.$/&"#$3#(%+3+,4,(5$

"'+*4,(#4*$4'4*/)+)$&0$)"%.$4'$+63&#,4',$+))"($4'5$,.($3"2*+%$4'5$+'0*4664,&#/$64''(#$2/$

-.+%.$/&"#$7+(-)$.47($2(('$%&66"'+%4,(58$

9($4:#(($,.4,1$4)$;<!$&0$=;>??1$+,$+)$/&"#$#()3&')+2+*+,/$,&$455#())$,.()($+))"()1$2",$+,$+)$

(@"4**/$/&"#$#()3&')+2+*+,/$,&$5&$)&$,.#&":.$=;>??A)$2&,,&6B"31$%&')(')")B24)(5$

6"*,+),4C(.&*5(#$6&5(*8$=,$+)$4*)&$,.($#()3&')+2+*+,/$&0$,.&)($+'$3&)+,+&')$&0$+'0*"('%($-+,.+'$

=;>??$,&$).&-$5"($%4#($-.('$64C+':$),4,(6(',)$&'$%&63*(D1$%#&))B%",,+':$+))"()$,&$

(')"#($(00(%,+7($4'4*/)+)$4'5$),4C(.&*5(#$(':4:(6(',$-+,.&",$"''(%())4#/$%&'0")+&'$&#$

%&'%(#'8EF$$

K0J!>'J!"?$%/!2#D$20!K/J!E*001(*&!*&!2@1/200*&A!L0'/$&A!#$&#2/&0M!()$%'!'D2!?2(&0!),!9D*#D!'D2!

E5>F4G7.!1/$1$0(+!9(0!-282+$12-H!(/A%*&A!'D('!34"55!D(0!C(*+2-!'$!-2?$&0'/('2!(!#$??*'?2&'!

'$!L$12&H!C/22+,!(##200*)+2H!?%+'*F0'(B2D$+-2/H!(&-!B&$9+2-A2F)(02-!1/$#20020JMNO!3&!(--*'*$&!'$!(!

+(#B!$C!0'(B2D$+-2/!*&8$+82?2&'H!K0J!>'J!"?$%/!(+0$!#$&'2&-0!'D('!34"55I0!02#%/*',F/2+('2-!

1/$1$0(+06!!

5&$'&,$).&-$%&'7+'%+':*/$,.4,$,.(#($.4)$2(('$4$0"**$4'4*/)+)$&0$4*,(#'4,($6&5(*)8$=G!;$

2(*+(7()$,.4,$,.($3#&3&)4*)$.47($2(('$3",$0&#-4#5$3#(64,"#(*/H-+,.&",$,.($0"**$24%C+':$

&0$,.($)"33&#,+':$&#:4'+I4,+&')$4'5$457+)&#/$%&66+,,(()$+'$=;>??1$'&#$-+,.$,.($2#&45(#$

%&66"'+,/1$+'%*"5+':$,.($,(%.'+%4*$%&66"'+,/8EJ$$

"'!'D2!=',(#'(,$K&7(#'4'%($L#&M(%,H!K*+'$&!K%2++2/!)+$AA2-6!

!'($6&#4*$&0$,.+)$),&#/$+)$,.4,$,.(#($+)$),+**$4$#()+5"($&0$)")3+%+&'$-+,.+'$,.($,#45+,+&'4*$

+',(#'(,$,(%.'+%4*$%&66"'+,/$42&",$=;>??$4'5$+,)$462+,+&')8$>'&,.(#$+)$,.4,$4'$=;>??$

;<!$-.&$%.4**(':()$,.(6$&#$-.&$64C()$,.(6$*&&C$4)$+0$,.(/$4#('A,$5&+':$,.(+#$M&2)$#+:.,$

-+**$.47($.(**$,&$34/8$

P&2!*&'2/8*2922!#$??2&'2-!'D('!L34"55I0!$12&&200!*0!#$??2&-()+2HM!/2C2///*&A!1(/'*#%+(/,!'$!

'D2!1%)+*#!#$??2&'!12/*$-!C$/!)$'D!'D2!LQ/$1$02-!>'/('2A*#!3&*'*('*820M!(&-!'D2!LE5>F4G7.!

R%0*&200!4(02M!(&-!34"55I0!9*++*&A&200!'$!2@'2&-!'D2!-2(-+*&2!('!'D2!1%)+*#I0!/2S%20'J!.D2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NT!4D/*0!E*001(*&H!LU2''2/!C/$?!4D/*0!E*001(*&!'$!7$-!R2#B0'/$?JM!

NO!3)*-JH!VJ!

NW!3)*-J!

Page 143: ICANN final report v3 · 4..*5$,%/#&#,6!%$7!8+%$9)%+($.6!%,!:;4

! ! "##$%&'()*+*',!(&-!./(&01(/2&#,!('!34"556!"&!3&-212&-2&'!728*29!

!

:;<=>!

*&'2/8*2922!2?1/2002-!#$&#2/&@!A$9282/@!'A('!34"55!BA(0&C'!-$&2!D%#A!'$!0A$9!'A('!*'C0!

/201$&0*82!'$!*&1%'!E/$D!'A2!1%)+*#FGHI!

J$D2!K5J!0'(L2A$+-2/0!A(82!2?1/2002-!0'/$&M!#$&#2/&!()$%'!'A2!+(#L!$E!$11$/'%&*'*20!'$!

1(/'*#*1('2!1/*$/!'$!'A2!5(*/$)*!D22'*&MF!N$/!*&0'(&#2@!'A2!##5JOC0!+2''2/!'$!'A2!34"55!4PO!/2(-06!

!"#$%&'$()*!++,-(.+/0*123(4&-567--(8"96(9:;6%<"7='7-(7>5-#56'(-7:&?5#@(-#9;7$%"=7?-(

-&:$(9-(*123A**(96=(#$7(*123(67#<%?;B(C)2/3(96=(.+/0D!2*(96=(%#$7?(56E%"E7=(89?#57-(

-&:$(9-(2)2-B(.+/(2%%#(D87?9#%?-B(?7'5-#?9?-(96=(::3F.(96=('3F.(?7'5-#?57-B("5##"7(7GG%?#(

98879?-(#%($9E7(4776(H9=7(#%(76'9'7(#$7-7('?%&8-(56(=7E7"%856'(#$7(.+/0*123(8?%8%-9"I(

3$5-("9:;(%G(=59"%'&7("79=-(#%(#$7(8%#76#59"(G%?(=&8"5:9#5%6(%G(7GG%?#-(96=(:%6G&-5%6B(?9#$7?(

#$96(:"9?5G5:9#5%6B(%G(-87:5G5:(?%"7-(96=(?7-8%6-545"5#57-IJK(

3&'2/8*290!(&-!9/*''2&!0%)D*00*$&0!),!34"55!0'(EE!0$+*#*'2-!E$/!'A*0!#(02!0'%-,!$EE2/!(!D(/L2-+,!

-*EE2/2&'!12/012#'*82!$&!'A2!$11$/'%&*'*20!E$/!*&1%'!(&-!0'(L2A$+-2/!*&8$+82D2&'!-%/*&M!'A2!

-282+$1D2&'!$E!'A2!K5JQ4P7.!1/$1$0(+F!34"55!0'(EE!1$*&'!'$!(!+$&M!02/*20!$E!#$&0%+'('*$&0!(&-!

1%)+*#!0%)D*00*$&0!-('*&M!'$!2(/+,!=IIR@!-%/*&M!9A*#A!'A2,!#$&0%+'2-!9*'A!&%D2/$%0!&2'9$/L*&M!

(&-!02#%/*',!2?12/'0!S022!"112&-*?!;!E$/!(!'*D2+*&2!(&-!/2E2/2&#20TF!3&!'A2!=IIR!K5J!0,D1$0*%D!

A2+-!*&!"'+(&'(@!1(/'*#*1(&'0!2?1+*#*'+,!*-2&'*E*2-!'A2!&22-!E$/!(!#2&'/(+*U2-!4P7.Q+*L2!#$$/-*&('*&M!

)$-,F!.A2!/21$/'!E/$D!'A2!=I;I!K5J!0,D1$0*%D@!A$9282/V9A*#A!$##%//2-!1/*$/!'$!'A2!5(*/$)*!

D22'*&MV'$$L!(!D$/2!D2(0%/2-!1$0*'*$&@!2D1A(0*U*&M!()$82!(++!'A2!&22-!E$/!E%/'A2/!/202(/#A!

(&-!*&E$/D('*$&Q0A(/*&M!)2E$/2!(!012#*E*#!1/$M/(D!#$%+-!)2!1/$1$02-F!

34"55C0!#$&0%+'('*$&!/2#$/-0!0A$9!'A('@!1/*$/!'$!'A2!5(*/$)*!D22'*&M!(&-!'A2!1%)+*#('*$&!$E!'A2!

K5JQ4P7.!1/$1$0(+@!1(/'*#*1('*$&!E/$D!'A2!34"55!#$DD%&*',!('!+(/M2!9(0!D*&*D(+F!34"55!

#$&0%+'2-!9*'A!(!/(&M2!$E!K5J!02#%/*',!0'(L2A$+-2/0@!)%'!'A2!D(W$/*',!$E!*&'2/(#'*$&0!9*'A!'A2!

K5J!#$DD%&*',!'$$L!1+(#2!*&!1/*8('2!#$&0%+'('*$&0F!.A2!-/(E'!=I;IX=I;Y!0'/('2M*#!1+(&!0%MM20'0!

'A2!#/2('*$&!$E!(!K5JQ4P7.!1/$W2#'@!)%'!$EE2/0!&$!-2'(*+0!'$!9A*#A!'A2!1%)+*#!#$%+-!/201$&-F!

"E'2/!5(*/$)*@!D(&,!0'(L2A$+-2/0!#$&'*&%2-!'$!)2!-*00('*0E*2-!9*'A!'A2!+(#L!$E!$11$/'%&*'*20!'$!

1(/'*#*1('2FH=!34"55C0!"1/*+!ZXH!9$/L0A$1!*&![(0A*&M'$&@!KF4F!(*D2-!'$!#$&82&2!(!/(&M2!$E!

1(/'*#*1(&'0!E/$D!'A2!K5J!02#%/*',!#$DD%&*',!012#*E*#*(++,!'$!0A(/2!*&E$/D('*$&!(&-!*-2&'*E,!'A2!

M(10!*&!#%//2&'!K5J!02#%/*',!D2(0%/20F!\$9282/@!'A2!9$/L0A$1!9(0!A2+-!1/*8('2+,@!(&-!E292/!

'A(&!'A*/',!1(/'*#*1(&'0!92/2!*&8*'2-@HY!#(%0*&M!0$D2!'$!8*29!'A2!9$/L0A$1!9*'A!0L21'*#*0D!

/('A2/!'A(&!2&'A%0*(0DF!!

!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HI!3&'2/8*29@!J21'2D)2/!=I;IF!

H;!##5JO@!B4$DD2&'0!$&!34"55!K5JQ4P7.!]/$1$0(+@G!;F!

H=!3&'2/8*29@!J21'2D)2/!=I;IF!

HY!34"55@!B"1/*+!=I;I!K5JQ4P7.!O12/('*$&(+!72^%*/2D2&'0!(&-!4$++()$/('*$&!"&(+,0*0![$/L0A$1!721$/'G!S022!'A2!+*0'!$E!1(/'*#*1(&'0!('!'A2!2&-!$E!'A2!/21$/'TF!