iipotokoji .n'!! 2 - energia.ru fileiipotokoji .n'!! 2 paccmotpehhh u onehkh jahbok ha...
TRANSCRIPT
IIPOTOKOJI .N'!! 2 paccMoTpeHHH u oneHKH JaHBOK Ha yirncTue B KouKypce
r.Kopones M.O. «24» Mrur 2017 rona
1. HaHMeHosam1e npenMeTa KOHKypca:
ITpaso 3aIOII-011HTb KOHTpaKT Ha OKa.3aHHe ycnyr no ayn.11Ty fOllOBOH 6yxranTepCKOH (qnrnaHcosoi1) OT11eTHOCTH no PCEY, a TaK)J(e ayn11Ty KOHCOJJH.LJ.HpoBaHHOH qmHattcosoH: oT11eTHOCTH no MC<DO ITAO «PKK «3Heprmrn 3a 2017 ro.LJ..
2. COCTaB KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH.
Ha 3ace.namrn KoHKypcHoH: KOMHCCHH no paccMOTpeHHIO 3a.llBOK Ha yqacTHe B KoHKypce npHCYTCTBOBaJJH:
IIpeiJceiJameJZb KoHKypcHoii KOMuccuu:
HHKHTHH CepreH: AneKcattnpoBH11
lf JZeHbl KoHKypCHOU KOMUCCUU:
B1rnoKypOB ITasen BH11ecnaBOBH11
Koni,es ArreKcei1 EBreHheBHq
Ap.LJ.ees AH.LJ."peH: BnanHMHposw1
BaKynHH KoHCTaHTHH BnanHMHpoB1111
<DoMHHa TaTbHHa I1eTpoBHa
MeneHTheB ITaBeJI Bna.LJ.HMHpos1111
CHMaKoBa HHHa BanepbeBHa
CeKpemapb KoHKypcHoii KOMuccuu:
Eroposa lOJIHH Eop11cosHa
Ha 3acenaHim KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH no paCCMOTpeHmO 3aHBOK Ha yqacTHe B KoHKypce OTCYTCTBOBaJI qJieH KoHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH JieCHbIX 0KCaHa AneKCaH,npOBHa.
KsopYM nJIH npose,neHHH JacenaHHH KoHKypcHoH: KOMHCCHH HMeeTCH. KoMHCCHH npaBOMoqHa.
3 ITpoue.nypa BCKphITHH KOHBepToB c 3aJJBKaMH Ha yqacn1e s KoHKypce 6hma npose.LJ.eHa KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHeii c lQ qacos 24 MHHYT «24» MaH 2017 rona no 11 qacoB 00 MHHYT <<24» MaH 2017 roJ.la no aapecy: r.Kopones M.0 .. yn. JleHHHa. n.4A (ITpoTOKOJI NQ 1 scKphITHH KOHBepTOB c 3aHBKaMH Ha yqacTHe B KoHKypce OT «24» Ma.SI 201 7 fOJ.la).
4. Ha npoue.LJ.ypy paccMOTpeHHH 6brnH npe.n.ocrnsnetthI 3aHBKH Ha yqacT11e B KoHKypce cne-llyIOlllHX yqacTHHKOB KoHKypca:
l. 3AO "3 H:11 3n EH BHewaynHT" 2. 000 "KCK AY,LIJ1T" 3. 000 "Konnenrn Hanorosi,1x KOHcynoTaHTos" 4. AO "E,[(O lOHHKOH 11
1
N!! n/ n
I
2
3
4
5. KoHKypCHOH KOMMCCMe.H 6r:.um pacCMOTpeHbI 3aRBKH yqacTHMKOB KoHKypca Ha COOTBeT
CTBMe Tpe6oBaHMRM KOHKypCHOH .UOK)'MeHTaUHH (Ta6JIHUbI 1 H 2).
Ta6n11ua 1 Per. CooTBeTCTBHe YKa3aHHe He npeBhJ- Bb1pa)Ke- 0TI<JIOHe- BHe N!! HaHMettosattHe H noq- OilHCaHH51 uetthI rneHHe HHe uetthI HHe qm- ce-
TOBblH a.upec ay,UHTOp- HalJaJibHOH HHC OKa3hIBaeMbIX KOHTPaKTa, KOHTPaK- HaHCOBOfO Ja-
CKOH opraHH3aUHH ycnyr, HX KO- BKJIJO':laH (MaKCH- Ta npe.uno- naT JIHlJeCTBeH- HL(C 18% MaJihHOH) B py6JIHX )KeHHH OT Ka HhlX H Ka'!e- uetthI Ha'iaJibHO-
CTBeHHbIX xa- ro (MaK-paKTepHCTHK CHMaJibHO-Texttw1ecKo- ro) pa3Me-MY 3a.uaHHJO pa onJiaTbI
ycnyr, %
1339 3AO "3if'i 3n Ew + + + + 29,98 + Btternay.11.11T" MocKBa, Kpac-HOnpecHeHCKaJI Ha6., 12
1372 000 "KCK AY)JJ1T" + + + + 29,5 + MocKaa, H11KOJIORMCKa11 yn., .11..52, CTP.2, od>.20
1373 000 "KoJIJlerl1JI HaJIOfOBblX + Ee3 H,L\C + + 29,51 + KOttcynbTaHToa" MocKaa, yn. ileyPOBKa, ,D, . I 9' CyP.6
1389 AO "E.[\O lOH11KOH11 + + + + 29,81 + MocKaa, ITpeo6pa){(ettcKaR nnoma.D.b, .11..8
Ta61111ua 2 N2 Per. HaHMeHoBaHHe H notITOBhIH a.upec Tpe6osaHHH K 01 JOPMJieHHIO 3aHBKH n/n N2 ay.UHTOpCKOH CooTBeT- HanH'IHe Bee .uoKy- HanH'rne
opraHH3aUHH CTBHe .UO- OilHCH MeHTbl 3a- netJaTH H KyMeHTOB .UOKyMeH- HBKH, a IlO,UilHCH
3aHBKH 06- TOB TaK)Ke yIIaCTHHKa
pa3UaM B 3aHBKe OOH Cb Ha 3aHBKe cpopM H .UO- ,UOJI)KHbl
KyMeHTOB, 6bITh ClllH-npe.uycMOT- Thi B e,UH-
peHHhlM HYJO KHHry KottKypc-HOH ,UOKy-MeHTaUHeH
1 1339 3AO "3 ii'i 3 11 E11 Btternay.11.11T11 MocKaa, + + + + KpacttonpecHeHcKaR tta6., 12
2 1372 000 "KCK AY .[\11T" MocKBa, H11Ko- + + + + JIOHMCKaR YJI., .11..52, CTP.2, od>.20
3 1373 000 "Komier11J1 ttanoroBbIX KOHCYJlb- + + + + TaHTOB11 MocKBa, yn. ITerpoBKa, .11..19, cm.6
4 1389 AO "E.[\O l0tt11KOH 11 MocKaa, ITpeo6- + + + + pa){(ettcKrui nnoma.D.b, .11..8
6. Ilo pe3yJibTaTaM paCCMOTpeHHR KOHKypCHblX 3aRBOK KoHKypCHaR KOMHCCJrn rrpHH51Jia
pernem1e:
6.1. ,[(onycTHTh K yqacnuo B KoHKypce 11 npH3HaTh yqacTHHKaM11 KoHKypca cne.nyiom11x yqacTHHKOB, no.nasurnx 3aHBKH Ha yqacTHe s KoHKypce:
1. AO "E,[(0 IOHHKOH 11
2. 000 "KCK AY,[(HT"
3. 000 "Konnerm1 Hanoros1>1x KOHcyn1>TaHTOB 11
no npwrnHe HeCOOTBeTCTBHH TPe6oBaHHHM KOHKypCHOH .l{OKYMeHTaUHl-f 0 Han11q1111 JIHU:eH-3HH Ha pa6oTy co cse.neHHHMH, COCTaBJIHIOlllHMH roC.TaHHy, .neHCTBHTeJihHYJO Ha Beeb nep110.n ay.n11-Ta, yqacTHHK 3AO "3J.i11 3n E11 BHernay.n11T11 He .nonycKaeTcH K yqacTHIO B KoHKypce.
6.2. Ilporonocosan11: Ta6mnw 3
qJieHbl KOMI1CCHH:
«3a» <<IlPOTHB» <<B03,nep)l(anHCh» HHKHTHH C.A BHHOKypOB IT.B Kon1>es A.E Ap.nees A .B BaKyJIHH K.B <l>OMHHa T.IT MeneHTheB IT.B C11MaK0Ba H.B
6.3. 0TKa3aTb B .nonycKe K yqacTHIO B KOHKypce cne.nyiolllHM yqaCTHHKaM KOHKypca, no.nasllIHM 3aHBKI1 Ha yqacTHe B KOHKypce:
Ta6Jnrua 4
N2 Ha11MeH0BaH11e <l>aMHJIHH, HMH, OTqeCTBO n/ Per. yqacTHMKa KoHKypca qJieHa KOMHCCHH, OTKa-
060CHOBaHHe OTKa3a B .uo-n N2 Jasrnero B .nonycKe K yqa-
nycKe CTHIO B KoHKypce
1 1339 3AO "3J.iq 3n EH HHKMTHH C.A BHernay.u11T11 BHHOKypOB IT.B ITO np11q11He HeCOOTBeT-
KonbeB A.E CTBHH TPe6osattHHM KoH-
Ap.nees A .B KypCHOH .UOKYMeHTaU11H O
BaKynHH K.B Han11q1111 m1ueH3HH Ha pa-
<l>oMHHa T.IT 6oTy co cse,neHHHMH, co-
MeneHTheB IT.B CTaBJijJIOlllHMH roc.TaHHy,
C11MaKosa H.B .neHCTBHTeJibHYJO Ha BeCb nepHO.U ay.UHTa, yqacTHHK 3AO "3J.iq 3n oH BHernay.u11T11 He .uonycKa-eTcH K yqacTHIO B KoHKyp-ce
6.4. Ilporonocosamr:
Ta6m1ua 5 qJieHbl KOMHCCIUI:
«3a» «11POTHB» <<B03}lep)l<aJIHCb» HHKHTMH C.A BHHOKypOB IT.B KonI>eB A.E
Ap.nees A.B BaKymrn K.B <DoM11Ha T.IT
MerreHTbeB Il.B C11MaK0Ba H.B
7. ITpoue.nypa oueHKM 3aHBOK Ha yqaCTHe B KOHKypce npOBO}lHJiaCb KOHKypCHOM KOMHCCMeH B nep110.n c ll qacos 30 MHHYT «24» MaH 2017 ro.ua no U qacoB Ql MHHYT «24» MaH 2017 rona no a.npecy: r .KoporreB M.O., yrr.JleHHHa, n.4A.
8. Ha npoue.n;ype oueHKH 3aHBOK Ha yqacTMe B KOHKypce 6DrnH paccMOTpeHbl 3aHBKH crre.n.yioLUHX yqaCTHHKOB KOHKypca:
Ta6rr11ua 6
N!! Ha11MeHosaHHe IToIITOBbIM anpec n/n yqacTHHKa KOHKypca
1 000 "KCK AY,[(MT" MocKsa, HMKOJI051MCKa51 yrr., .n:.52, crp.2, o¢.20
2 000 "KorrrrerM51 HaJIOrOBblX KOH- MocKsa, yrr. IlerposKa, .n:. 19, cTp.6 cyJibTaHTOB 11
3 AO "E,[(O I0HMKOH11 MocKsa, I1peo6pa)KeHcKa51 nrrom.a.n:b, .n..8
9. KoHKypCHOH KOMHCCHeM npOH3Be.n.eHa oueHKa 3aHBOK no Kp1nepmo <<UeHa KOHTpaKTa» (I..JJ>i) B COOTBeTCTBHH c Tpe6osaHHHMM KoHKypCHOM JJ;OKYMeHTaUMH.
~ i =Umin x 100 Ui
r.n.e: U i- npe.n.rro)l<em1e yqacTHHKa 3aKynKH, 3aHBKa (npe.n;JIO)l<eHMe) KOToporo oueHMBaeTcH; u min - MMHHMaJibHOe npe.n.JIO)KeHMe H3 npe}lJIO)KeHMH no KpHTepmo oueHKH, c.nenaHHblX yqaCTHHKaMM 3aKynKH.
Pei1TMHr, np11c~.n.aeMI>IH oueHHBaeMOH 3aHBKe no .n.aHHOMY KpMTepmo, onpe.ne;rneTcH nyreM yMHO)l(eHMH KOJIMIJecrna np11cy)l(J(eHHbIX 6arrnos Ha 3HatJMMOCTb KpMTepMH, ycrnHosnettttoro KoH
KypcttoH: ]lOKyMeHTaUHeH (50%).
Ta6m1ua 7
KoJIH'IecTBo 6an- 3Ha'IHMOCTb Pdinrnr i-ii 3aRBKH nos i-ii KpHTepm1 UEi, no
N!! HaHMeHoBaHHe yqacTHHKa KOHKypca 3aHBKH no % KpHTepmo UEi, n/n KpHTepmo UEi, 6aJIJibl
6annb1
1 000 "KCK AYLU1T" 99,57 50 49,79
2 000 "Korrrrer.1u1 HaJIOfOBhIX KOH- 84,39 50 42,2 cyrrhTaHTOB11
3 AO "E,ZJ;O !Om1KoH11 100 50 50
ITporonocoBaJIH: Ta6n11ua 8
qneHhI KOMHCCmi:
<Ca» «IIPOTHB» <<B03,nep:>Kan11cb»
HHKHTHH C.A B11HOKypOB IT.B KonheB A.E Ap)J.eeB A.B BaKyn11H K.B cDoMHHa T.IT MeneHTOeB IT.B C11MaKOBa H.B
10. KoHKypCHOH KOMMCC11ei1 npOl13BeL(eHa oueHKa 3aaBOK IIO KpHTepmo «KaqecTBeHHhJe xapaKTep11CTI1Kl1 06beKTa TOproB» B COOTBeTCTBI111 c Tpe6oBaHHHMI1 KoHKypCHOH L(OK)'MeHTaUI111.
Pei1T11Hr, npHCY:>K.D.aeMhIH 3aaBKe no KpHTepmo «KaqecrnettHhie xapaKTep11CTHKH o6oeKTa 3aKynK11» onpe)J.enaeTca KaK cpe)J.ttee apmpMeT11qecKoe oueHoK a 6annax scex qnettos KoHKypcHoii KOMHCCHH, npHCY:>K)J.aeMbIX i-H 3aHBKe IIO YKa3aHHOMY KpHTepmo.
C)'MMa MaKCHMaJihHbIX 3HaqeHHH Bcex ycrnHosneHHhIX )J.JIH oueHKH no KpHTepmo <<Kaqe
crneHHhie xapaKTepHCTI1KH 06beKTa 3aKynKH» 6aJIJIOB COCTaBJIHeT 100 6aJIJIOB. PacqeT KOm1qecrna 6annos, np11cy)J(.D.aeMbIX 3aaBKe no KpHTepmo «KaqecrneHHbie xapaKTepH
CTHKH o6oeKTa 3aKynKH» (H 1 Ei) ocyr.uecTBJrneTca no cpopMyne:
r.ne:
K - KOJUl'ieCTBO 'iJieHOB KOHK)'PCHoli KOMHCCHH;
EK - KOJIH'ieCTBO 6annoB, npHcBoeHJJbJX 'iJiettoM KOHKypCttoli KOMHCCHH, ouemrnaeMoli 3MBKe.
Peiinrnr, np11cy:>1<)1.aeMhIH oueH11saeMo'H 3aaBKe no .n.aHHOMY Kp11Tepmo, onpe.D.enaeTca nyTeM J'MHO)J(eH11a KOJrnqecrna np11cy)K)J.eHHbIX 6aJIJIOB Ha 3Haq11MOCTb Kp11Tep11a, ycrnHoarreHHoro KoH
KypCHOH )J.OKy:MeHTaUHeii (10%). PellleHHH qrreHOB KOMHCCHH 06 oueHKe 3aaBOK IIO Kpinepmo «KaqecTBeHHhie xapaKTepHCTMKH
o6oeKTa 3aKynKH>) oTpa)J(eHhI B OueHoqHhIX n11crnx (I1p11rro>KeH11a 1 K HacTOaweMy ITpoTOKorry) .
OueHKH acex qneHOB KoHKypcHoii KoM11cc1111 no Kp11Tepmo H 1Ei 11 pacqeT cpe.D.Hero ap11cpMen1qecKoro 3Haqemrn oueHOK no Kp11Tepmo H 1 Ei oTpa>KeHhI s Be)J.OMOCTH oueHKH 3aaBOK no Kp1nepmo «KaqecrneHHbie xapaKTep11cTHKH o6oeKTa 3aKynKH>> (H1Ei) (I1pHnO)J(ett11e 2 K HacTOaweMy ITpo
TOKony). Ta6mn.la 9
N~ Ha11MeH0BaH11e yqacTHHKa Kon11qecTBO 3HaqJ1MOCTh Pe'HTHHr i -11 3aaBK11
n/n KOHKypca 6annoB i-ii 3a- KpHTep11a no Kp11Tepmo H 1 Ei,
RBKH no KpHTe- H 1Ei, % 6aJIJihl
pmo H1Ei. 6arr-JI hi
1 000 "KCK AY,D;HT" 87,5 10 8,75
2 000 11Korrner11a HaJIOfOBhIX KOH- 87,5 10 8,75
cynhTaHTOB11
r
3 IAO "B.[(0 IOHMKOH 11
98,75 10 9,88
Tiporonocosa.rrn:
Ta6mu(a 10 qJieHbl KOMHCCIHI :
<Ca» HHKHTHH C.A
<<IIPOTHB» «B03JJ:em1<aJIHCb»
BHHOKypOB TI.B
Komes A.E
Ap.n:ees A.B
BaKyJJHH K.B
©oMHHa T.II MenettTheB TI.B
CHMaKosa H .B
11 KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHeH npOM3Be.n:eHa ou.eHKa 3a51BOK ITO Kp1nepmo «KsanmpMKaU.H51 11 onbIT )'l.JaCTHMKa KoHKypca» B COOTBeTCTBMH c rpe6osattH51MH KoHKypCHOH JJ:OKYMeHTaU.HM.
Ou.eHKa Ka)l(.n:oii 3a51BKH no .n:aHHOMY KpHTepmo ocymecrnJI51eTc51 c np11Mettett11eM ITOKa3aTe
neii, pacKpbIBaIOI.l.{HX co.n:ep)KaHMe 3TOro HeCTOMMOCTHOro KpHTepH51 ou.eHKH H )'l.JHTbIBaIOI.l.{HX oco-
6eHHOCTH ou.eHKH ay.n:MTOpCKHX ycnyr (.n:anee - nOKa3aTeJJH).
YKa3aHHbie ITOKa3aTeJJM ITpHse.n:eHbI B TipMJJO)KeHHH 3 K HaCTO.HI.l.{eMy TipoTOKOJJY (ra6JJHU.a <<l10Ka3aTeJJH oueHKH, ITPHMeH.HeMbie JJ:JI.H ou.eHKH ITO KpHTepHIO «Ksam1qmKaU.H.H 11 OffbIT )'l.JaCTHHKa KOHKypca»).
CyMMa MaKCHMaJibHhIX 3HaqeHHH scex ycrnttosneHHhIX .n:n.H ou.eHKH no KpHTep1110 «Ksan11qrn
KaU.H.H H onoIT )'l.JaCTHHKa KOHKypca» nOKa3aTenei1 COCTaBJJ51eT 100 6aJJJJOB.
JI)'l.JlllMM ycJJOBHeM HCnOJIHeHH.H KOHTpaKTa ITO KpHTepHIO «KBanmpHKau.1rn )'l.JaCTHHKa KOHKypca» npH3HaeTC.H HaH60JJblllee 3HaqeHHe KpHTepH.H.
PettTHHr, np11cy)KJJ:aeMblH 3a.HBKe no KpHTepHIO «KBanmpHKaU.1151 )'l.JaCTHMKa KOHKypca», onpe
.n:en51eTC.H nyreM YMHO:>KeHH.H Kon11qecrna ITpHC~JleHHhIX 6annos npH oueHKe no KpHTepHIO «KBanH
qnrnar.u,rn )'l.JaCTHHKa KOHKypca» Ha 3ttatrnMOCTb KpHTepH51 ou.eHKH, ycrnHOBJJeHttoro B KottKypcttoi1 JlOKYMeHTaU.HM (40%).
OueHKa no KpHTep1110 «Ksanmp1mau.H5I 11 OITbIT )'l.JaCTHHKa KOHKypca» ocymecrnn.HeTC.H no
lllKaJJe ou.eHKM, ycTaHOBJJeHHOH B HaCT0511.U.eH KOHKypCHOH JJ:OKYMeHTaUHH.
PellleHH.H qneHOB KOMHCCHH 06 ou.eHKe 3a.HBOK no KpHTepHIO <<KBanHCpHKau.1151 H onb!T )'l.JaCT
HHKa KOHKypCa» OTpa:>KeHbl B Ou.eHoqHbIX JJHCTax (TipHJIO:>KeHHe 4 K HaCT051I.l.{eMy TipoTOKOIIy).
Ta6m1ua 11 Kon11qecrno 6annos 3ttaqJ1MOCTb PeiiTHHr i-i1 3a.HBKM
NQ HaHMeHosam1e yqacTHHKa KoH- i -H 3a51BKH no KpH- KpHTepH51 ITO KpHTep1110 H 2Ei,
n/ IT Kypca TepHIO H2Ei, 6annh1 H 2Eb % 6annb1
1 000 "KCK AY)J;IIT" 20 40 8
2 000 "KonnerH.H HaJJOrGBbIX KOH- 1 40 0,4 cyJJhTaHTOB 11
3 AO "B.[(O I01rnKOH 11 100 40 40
TiporoJIOCOBaJJH: Ta6nHua 12
6
qneHbI KOMHCCHH:
<oa» <<npOTHB» <<B03.LJ.ep)l(anHCI»>
HHKHTHH C.A BHHOKypOB TI.B KonbeB A.E
Ap.neeB A.B BaKyn11H K.B <l>oMHHa T.TI
MeneHTheB TI.B
C11MaK0Ba H.B
12. Tiocne oueHKM 3aHBOK no Kp11Tep11HM: - <<ueHa KOHTpaKTa» (l(E i); - «KaqecTBeHHbie xapaKTepHCTHKH npe.nno>KeHHH yqacTHHKa B oTHOUieHHH npe,nMeTa KottKyp-
ca» (H1E i) - «KBanHCpHKaui:rn 11 OnhIT yqaCTHHKa KOHKypca»(H2E i), HTOrOBbIH peHTHHr (HP i) 3a5IBKH BbJqJiCJUieTC5I KaK CYMMa peHTHHrOB no KpHTepH5IM oueHKH
<<l(eHa KOHTpaKTa», <<KaqecTBeHHbie xapaKTepHCTHKH o6oeKTa ToproB» H «KBanHq:rnKaUH5I yqaCTHHKa KOHKypCa».
HP i = (1(13 ix 0,4) + (H1E ix 0, 1) + (H2E ix 0,5), r,[{e
r)le:
I(B i - KOllH'-IeCTBO 6annoa, npHC)l)lmaeMblX i-H 3aHBKe no KpHTepHIO «UeHa KOH'rpaKTa»;
H1B i - KOJmlfeCTBO 6annoa, npHC)l)K.llaeMbIX i-if 3aHsKe no KpHTepHIO «Ka':lecTBeHHble xapaKTepHCTHKH npe)lilO)f{eHHH
yqaCTHHKa B OTHOWeHHH o6'beKTa 3aKynKH»;
H2B i - KOJJH'ieCTBO 6annoa, npHC)l)lmaeMbIX i-if 3MBKe no KpHTepmo <<l<BanH<PHKal.lHH H onbIT y<1acTHHKa KOHKypca» .
Ta6m1ua 13
NQ Ha11MeH0BaH11e yqacTHHKa Pei1THHr i-H: 3a- Pei1THHr PeJ:iTHHr
n/n lfroroBbIH KOHKypca 51BKH no i-H 3a5IBKH no i-ii 3a5IBKH no peHTHHr 3a5IB-
KPHTepmo 11.6 i ' KPHTepmo H 1 Di , KpHTepmo Kt! f\<1 TT rn.r
1 000 "KCK AY,[(HT" 49,79 8,75 8 66,54
2 000 "KonnerH.sI HaJIOfOBbIX 42,2 8,75 0,4 51,35 KOHcynhTaHTOB"
3 AO "E,[(0 lOHHKOH11 50 9,88 40 99,88
Tio6e.U.HTeneM npH3HaeTC5I YqaCTHHK OTKpbITOro KOHKypca, npe.nno>KHBllIHH nyqUIHe ycnOBH5I HCnonHeHH.SI ,[(orosopa H 3a.SIBKe KOToporo npHCBOeH caMhIH BbICOKHH HTOfOBbIH peHTHHr. 3a.SIBKe TaKOro yqacTHHKa 3aKynKH npHCBaHBaeTC.sI nepBbIH nop5I.U.KOBbIH HOMep.
13.Tio pe3ynhTaTaM oueHKH KoHKypCHa5I KOMHCCH5I npHH.SIJla peUieHHe:
13 .1. TipHCBOHTb nepBbIH HOMep 3aHBKe H npH3HaTb no6e.UHTeneM KOHKypca AO «1>110 IOHHKOH»
(Ha11;11e1106QllUe J'IQCnl/11/KQ KOHKypc a)
MocKBa, Ilpeo6pa1KencKaH mrnwa.llh, Jl.8
(flO'llll08blli aiJpec Y'IOClllHUKQ KOHKypca)
np11CBOl1Th BTOpoM: HOMep 3a.SIBKe: 000 «KCK AY IlHT»
(Ha11Ate110Ba1111e y'l(1cmn11Ka K011Kypca)
M oc1rna, H n K OJIOHMCKaH yJI., ll.52, cTp.2, od>.20 {flO'l /1106blll ai)pec Y'IOClllHl/KQ KOHKypca)
13.2. OcTaJihHhIM 3a.SIBKaM Ha yqacT11e B KOHKypce npHCBOl1Th nop.SI,llKOBhle HOMepa (no Mepe }'MeHbllleHl1.SI CTerreHH BhirO,llHOCTl1 co.uep)J(aU.lMXC.SI B Hl1X ycJIOBHH 11CITOJIHeHH.SI KOHTpaKrn):
Ta61mua 14 .N°Q
HattMeHoBaHHe yqacTH11Ka KOHKypca ITpttcsoeHHhie rrop.si:nKOBbie
n/n HOMepa l 000 "Kom1enrn Hanoroshrx KOHCYJibTaHToa" 3
14. ITpoTOKOJI paccMoTpeHH.SI H ou.eHKH 3a.SIBOK Ha yqacT11e B KoHKypce cocrasneH B .usyx 3K-3eMnn.si:pax, O,ll11H H3 KOTOpbIX OCTaeTC.SI B Koprropau.1111. BTopoM: 3K3eMITJI.Sip rrpOTOKona B TeqeHHe Tpex nHeH co ,llH.SI rronrrttcaHH.SI nepenaeTc.si: rro6e,UHTemo KoHKypca.
15. Hacrn.si:m11ii rrpoTOKOJI 6y.ueT pa3MemeH Ha 0¢11u.11anhHOM caiiTe Pocc11M:cKoii <l>enepawm He no3,UHee pa6oqero .UH.SI, cnen}'lOmero 3a naToM: rro.urr11caH11.si: HacTo.si:mero rrpoToKona.
16. H acTo.si:m11ii rrpoTOKon rronne)J(l1T xpaHeHmo B TeqeH11e Tpex neT c naTb1 rro.use.ueHH.SI HToros HacTo.si:mero KoHKypca.
17. I1onm1c11:
ITpencenaTeJih ~ KoHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH (OT 3aKa3q11Ka): -~--
~..- (floiJ1111c&) /HHKHTHH C.A./
lJneHbl KOHKypcnoii KOMHCCHH: ~ /BHHOKypOB IT.B./
/KorrbeB A .E./
/A pnees A.B./
/BaKyn11H KB./
/<l>oMHHa T.IT./
/MeneHTbeB IT.B./
/CHMaKosa H.B./
CeKpernph KoHKypcHOH KOM11cc1111 /Eroposa IO.E./
Ou,euoqubJii JJHCT no KpnTepu10
Tip11J101KeH11e I K npoTO KOJJY N22 paCCMOTpeHHll 11 oueHKH 33l!BOK Ha )"-laCTHe B
KoHKypce
«KaqecTBeHHhie xapaKTepHCTHKH npe)l,JlOiKeHHSI yqacTHHKa B OTHOIIIeHHH
06beKTa 33KYTIKH»
N2 Per. HaHMeHoBamfe yqacTHHKa KottKypca 3tta'IeHHe KpHTepmr H 1B i, 6aJ1JibI
rr/n N2 (MaKc. 3Haqemre - 100 6aJ1JIOB)
1 2 ,.,
4 .)
1 k_c_I(''- ~'j ~c~s Ir
(OD :JOO / 1
2 ooo i.· k [-( K 4 - koi....c_s J..\L,u• { C) 0
3 5 Do L VOL4-<v-o H " t (!) D
4 -
w ~k~J (110)1,ITHCb qJieHa KOMHCCHH) (pacunr<lJpoBKa no HCH)
Ou:euoquh1ii JIHCT no Kp11Tep1110
Dp11noJKem1e I K TipoTOKOJIY N£2 paCCMOTpeHl1ll 11 oueHKl1
33llBOK Ha yqacT11e B
KottKypce
«KaqecTBeHHhle xapaKTepHCTllKll npe)l,JJOJKeHllH yqacTHHKa B OTHOllleHHH
o6beKTa 33KYDKH»
.~lf~wJ<'.Lk (<t>.H.O. qrreHa KOMI1CCHI1)
N2 Per. HattMeHoBaHtte yqacn-mKa KoHKypca 3HaqeHtte KpttTepm1 H 1.6 i, 6arrrrhI rr/rr N2 (MaKC. 3HaqeHtte - 100 6arrJIOB)
1 2 3 4
1 2- ()JJ ~Ck J~\w- ~ (j() 'I
2 3 ooo ~ ki1 l.( _ ~"-C-0-1\'TlA.0'1. 1o ~ fill ~ ~J~UA-lkJLA " /00 3
4
(pacrnmppOBKa IIO)J;III1CI1)
I1p1rno)Kemre I K npoTOKOJJY N22 paCCMOTpemu1 11 oueHKM 3al!BOK Ha )"laCTMe B KoHKypce
Ou,euoquhlii JIHCT no KpHTepuro
«KaqecTBeHHhle xapaKTepHCTHKH npe,ll,JI0'1\:eHHSI yqacTHHKa B OTHOllleHHH
o6beKTa 33KYDKH»
Ce,c~~ MJ (<l>.I1.0. qJieHa KOMHCCHH)
N2 Per. Ha11MeH0BaH11e yqacTHHKa KottKypca 3tta'-IeHHe KpHTepmi: H1E i, 6anJihI
rr/rr N2 (MaKc. 3Haqemie - 100 6an110B)
1 2 3 4 r
1 !/?120 J/ce;tc - ~ /7' , Cr" j~f "?' ·~,./" - '
(/V' 7 I
2 ~ -Yc!/12- ~£1-Ec~ y /vi; ,, ~
v I -' ,,VOu~ fao;{ .:;
4
( IIO)lIIHCh (pacwmppOBKa IIO)lIIHCH)
Ou,euoquhlil JIHCT no KpHTepuro
np11no:a<em1e I K TipoToKony NQ2 paccMoTpemrn H oueHKH 3a5!BOK Ha j"-laCTHe B
KoHKypce
«KaqecTBeHHhie xapaKTepHCTHKH npeLJ.JIOm'.eHHH yqacTHUKa B OTHOllleHUH
o6beKTa JaKynKH»
N2 Per. HaHMeH0Bam1e yqacTH11Ka KoHKypca 3HaI.JeH11e Kp11Tepmr H 1 E i, 6aJUihI rr/n N2 (MaKC. 3HaI.JeH11e - 100 6aJIJJOB)
1 2 3 4
1
2 ICC(_ f\~r3LK\ so 3 to f--/\.e_cv.. ~ 1:-\Gl t<..QX--06 I<:>\)( f {)
1?-0 I-{ CY .I\ i='TC>,-t-1 'TO b
4 bAo vo Hu.. r:-oH (00
(pacurn¢poBKa no.n:nttrn)
OueHoqHhIH Jn1cT no KpHTepmo
npttJJO)({em1e I K TipOTOKOJJY N~2
paccMOTpemrn 11 oueHKH 3ai!BOK Ha y•rncTHe B KottKypce
«KaqecTBeHHbie xapaKTepHCTHKH npe;:i;Jio~eHHH yqacTHHKa B OTHOllleHHH
o6beKTa 3aKynKH»
NQ Per. HattMeHoBami:e yqacTHHKa KottKypca 3ttaqett11e Kp11Tepm1 H1E i, 6aJIJihI rr/rr NQ (MaKC. 3HaqeH11e - 100 6aJIJIOB)
1 2 3 4
1 {l!Jv /fCk ci?& 2 /3/)0 /ctf c3 ,.., vf&J(!; K/IK /ctJc,7 .)
4 /,.--
/ / /; cy k 't .k '4 k" %_/) (rrp;:i:rr11Cb ;d!etta KOMI1CCI111) (pacIImcp~Ka IIOJJ:III1CI1)
J
f J
OuettO'IHhIH JIHCT no KpHTepmo
Dpm10)Kem1e I K CTpoToKony N22 paccMOTpemrn H O[\eHKH 3a11BOK Ha y'iaCTHe B KoHKypce
«Ka'leCTBeHHble xapaKTepHCTHKH npe~JIO~eHHH yqaCTHHKa B OTHOllieHHH
o6'heKTa JaKynKH»
~meae&?t fi~Y (<l>.H.O. qJieHa KOMHCCHH)
NQ Per. Ha11MeH0Bamre yqacTHHKa KottKypca 3ttaqett11e Kp11Tep1u1 H1E i. 6aJIJihI n/n NQ (MaKC. 3HaL£eHHe - 100 6anrrOB)
1 2 3 4
1 l oo~ te:e c#ffvU-u '7 30
2 ? OC()" ;Cc~cffta;f~ go ~
{/
3 l; di 0 -i /Jj)(} /cJacvaru '1 go
4
¢vauMt?T/Z (rro.n;rr11ch qnetta KOM11cc1rn) (pacrnmppoBKa rro.n;rr11c11)
ff
Tip11JJO)!(eH11e I K IlpOTOKOJlY N~2 paCCMOTpemrn 11 oueHKH 3al!BOK Ha ycrncTHe B KoHKypce
Ou.ettoqtthJH JIHCT no KpHTepmo
«KaqecTBeHHbie xapaKTepHCTHKH npeAJIO~eHHSI yqacTHHKa B OTHOllICHHH
ofrheKTa 3aKynKH»
! - /)
{c/164 4.t: ' (<I>.H.O. qJieHa KOMHCCHH)
N2 Per. HaHMeHOBaHHe yqacTHHKa KoHKypca 3ttaqeHHe KpHTepH5I H1E i. 6anJihI n/n N2 (MaKc. 3HaqeHHe - l 00 6anrroB)
1 2 .,
4 -'
1 D00 !DM~J/ ,(Cb
2 KCK ro11 c ?/[///?/If~ OU .., }CoAM 'lti"l M4D?c~1,,r};;~ -luV -'
4
(pacrnmppoBKa no;::i:mrc11)
Oueuoquh1ii JIHCT no KpHTepmo
TipHJJO)!{eHHe I K TipoToKony N22 paccMOTpemrn 11 oueHKM 3a51BOK Ha y11acn1e s KoHKypce
«KaqecTBeHHble xapaKTepHCTHKH npe)J,JIOmeHHH yqacTHHKa B OTHOIIIeHHH
o6beKT3 3aKynKH»
/L_~q (<l>.H.O. qJieHa KOMHCCirn)
N2 Per. HaHMeH0Bam1e yqaCTmma KoHKypca 3Haqemre Kp1nepmr H 1E i, 6arr11b1 rr/rr N2 (MaKc. 3Haqem1e - 100 6arrnoB)
1 2 3 4
£CK 4;7// . .-;: // 1 ,, I ' re --,. ,,, (, L../
,
2 ~-v&cL0~ ~IY o· ,,.. .
,t>C--~£ ~ :--< ,,, _.,,r--"" 77 '---'
, ?
3 S /Jc ~K~# '1:'cu;
4
-~~~~~-~---·-----(IIO,ll,IIHCb qneHa KOMHCCHH)
/#~~~ (pacrnmppOBKa IIO,ll,IIHCH)
ft'
N!! n/n
1
2
3
np"11lO>t<eH"1e 2 K n p o TOKOllY l\IQ2 paCCMOTp eH"1R "1
ou,eHK"1 3a RBOK Ha yyacrne B KOHKypce
BeAOMOCTb ou.eHKll1 3aHBOK no Kp1 ... nep11110 1KaL1eCTseHHb1e xapaKTep111cT111K111 o6beKTa 3aKynK111
1 (H16 i)
CyMMa Cpem1ee 01..1eHK111 '4neHOB KoHKypcHoili KoM111cc111111 no Kp111Tep111t0 H16i, 6annb1 (MaKC.3Ha4eH111e -100) ou enoK no ap111jlMeTH'feCKOe
KpHTepHHI oue11 0K n o Y'43CTHlllK KOHKypca Hl lii e Kp1nepmo HI Iii e
HlllKlllTlllH c. A B111H0Kypos n. B KonbeB A. E ApAees A. 8 BaKyn111H K. B <l>OMlllHa T. n MeneHTbeB n. B C111MaKosa H. B 6aJ1Jlax 6aJ1Jl3X
000 "KCK AYAV1T" 80 100 80 90 100 80 90 80 700 87,5
000 "Ko1111en1rn
Ha/lOrDBblX 60 100 100 80 100 90 90 80 700 87,5 KOHCYllbTaHTos"
AO "E>AO IOHltl KOH" 100 100 100 100 100 90 100 100 790 98,75
CeKperapb KOHKyprnoi< KOMHCCHH;. ~ /Eroposa IO. 6/
N~
rr/rr
1
2
3
4
Ilp1111o)l(em1e 3
K IIpoToKony N2 2 paccMOTPettm1 11
ol.(eHKH 3a.11soK Ha yqacrne B KottKypce
Ta6mn~a «I10Ka3aTemI ouettKH, rrp11Mem1eMbie ;::i:;u1 ouettKH no Kp11Tepmo
«KBamr¢HKau;mr H orrbIT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca>>, Ou;eHoqHbIH JIHCT
I10Ka3aTem1 ou;eHKH no
Kpinepmo «KBaJIHcpHKaUIUI H
OilbIT yqaCTHHKa TOproB»
)J;oKyMeHTaJlbHO ITO,llTBep)l(,!l;eHHb!H
OITb!T yqaCTHHKa 3a 201 l-2016rr.
no npose.nettmo B COBOKYITHOCTH
He Mettee 5 ay.z:i;HTOB fOAOBOM
6yxranTepCKOM (¢11ttaHCOBOH)
OTqeTHOCTH, ITO,!J;fOTOBJieHHOH B
coorneTcrn1111 c PCEY, aKUHOHepHblX o6mecTB ( c BamOTOH
6aJiattca He Mettee 5 / 15/ 30 Mnpa.
py6.), ocymeCTBJI.!llOIUHX
.nel!TeJlbHOCTb B 06nacT11
MaWHHOCTpoemu1
,ll,oKyMeHTaJibHO nO,!l;TBep)!(.lleHHblH
onbIT yqacrnrrKa Ja 2011 -20 l 6rr.
no nposeaettrr10 ayarrrn ro.nosoi1
KOHCOJlHAI1pOBaHHOH ¢rrttaHCOBOH
OTqeTHOCTH,
COOTBeTCTBHH
opratt11Jau11i1,
)le.!!TeJibHOCTb
nO,!l;fOTOBJleHHOH B
c MC<l>O, ocymecTBJI.!llOJUHX
a 06rracT11
MaWHHOCTPOeHii.!I
)J;oKyMeHTaJibHO nO,!J;TBep)!(,!l;eHHb!H
onbJT yqacrn11Ka Ja 2011 -20 l 6rr.
no npose.nett1110 06.HJaTeJlbHOro
ay.n11Ta rO)lOBOH 6yxranTepcKOH
(¢11ttaHCOBOH) oTqeTHOCTH,
no.nroTOBJleHHOH B COOTBeTCTBHH c
PCEY, KOMnatt11i1 c ronosoi1
Bb1pyqKoi1 He Mettee 20 Mnpa. p y6.,
aKUHH KOTOpblX KOTiiPYIOTC.!I Ha
pOCCHHCKOH 6Hp)!(e
Ha.JI11q11e y pyKoso.z:i;11TeJU1
ay.n11TopcKoi1 nposepKH e.n11ttoro
KBaJimj:J11Kau110Httoro arrecrnrn
ay.z:i;11rnpa 11 ceprndmKarn ACCA
KonHqecTBeHHoe/
KaqecTBeHHOe
3HaqeHHe
fIOKa3aTe.JUI
YKa3bIBaeTcll KOJJH'!ecTBO npose.ueHHbJX
Y'laCTHHKOM 3a 201 l-2016rr. ay.UHTOB
rD.llOBOH 6yxraJJTepCKOH (qrnHaHCOBOH)
oTqeTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJJeHHOH B
coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, aKUHOHepHbIX
o6wecTB, ocywecTBJllllOIUHX .llellTeJJbHOCTb
B o6JJaCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHHll, H BaJJIOTa
6anaHca. B 3a'!eT npHHHMaJOTCll TOJJbKO Te
nposeaeHHbJe
npeacrnsneHo
ay.llHTbl , no KOTOpblM
.llOKyMeHTaJJbHOe
n0.1ITBep)l(.lleH11e B COOTBeTCTBHe c
Tpe6oBaHHllMH KOHKypcHOH .llOKyMeHTaUHH
YKa3bIBaeTCll KOJIH'leCTBO nposeneHHbIX
Y'laCTHHKOM 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. ayn11rns
rD.llOBOH KOHCOJIH.1111pOBaHHOH cjJ11HaHCOBOH
OT'leTHOCTH, noaroTOBJJeHHOH B
coorneTCTBHH c MC<PO, opraH11Jau11tt ,
ocywecTBJllllOIUHX nellTeJlbHOCTb B
06nacT11 Maw11HocTpoeH11ll. B 3a'leT
npHHHMalOTCll TOJlbKO Te nposeneHHbie
ay.llHTbl , no KOTOpblM npe.llCTaBJieHO
noKyMeHTaJJbHoe nonrneplK.1IeH11e s
COOTBeTCTBHe c Tpe6oBaHHllMH
KOHKypCHOtt .llOKYMeHTallHH
YKa3bIBaeTCll KOJIH'leCTBO KOMnaHHtt c
fO.llOBOH Bblpj"IKOtt He Mettee 20 MJJp.ll .
py6., aKUHH KOTOpblX KOTHPYIOTCll Ha
pocc11ttcKOtt 6HplKe, B OTHOWeHHH
KOTOpbIX Y'laCTHHKOM 3a 2011-20 l 6rr.
nposeaeH ayn11T ronosott 6yxranTepcKott
(cjJ11HaHCOBOtt) OT'leTHOCTH,
nonrornsneHHOtt B coorneTcrn1111 c PCEY.
B 3a'!eT np11tt11Ma10TCll TOJJbKO Te
nposeaeHHbie ayn11Tb1 , no KOTOpbIM
npeacTaBJJeHO .llOKyMeHTaJJbHOe
n0.1ITBeplK.1IeH11e B COOTBeTCTBHe c
Tpe6oBaHHllMH KOHKypCHOH .llOKyMeHTaUHH
YKa3bIBaeTcll, HMeeT JJH 3allBJJeHHbIH
pyKOBOJ:IHTeJJh ay.u11TopcKOH nposepKH
e.llHHbltt KBaJ1HcjJ11Kau110HHbltt arreCTaT
aya11Topa H cepT11¢11KaT ACCA (The
CooTBeT
CTBHe 3HaqeHHjl
fIOKa3aTe.JUI
orrpe,neneH
HOMY YpoBHIO no
IIIKane ou;eHOK
N2 n/n
7
8
9
IloKa3aTerr11 ou.eHKH no
1qmTepmo <<l<.Brun1¢.11Kau.mr H OnbIT yqacTH:HKa TOproB»
(The Association of Chartered
Certified Accountants - Member of
the association 11n11 Fellow of the
association) HJIH CPA (Certified
Public Accountant)
OnhIT pa60Th1 pyKoso.u1ue.JU1
ay.UHTOpCKOH npoaepKH B ay.u11Te
He Mettee 10 neT
IIpoXO)l(.!lem1e BHeurnero KOHTpOJIR
Kal.feCTBa
C)'MMa o61l(ero JittMttTa
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 crpaXOBll(ttKa (113
pacyern Ha I ro.u) no nom1cy
crpaxosaHIDI npo¢ecc110HaJihHOi1
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH yl.faCTHttKa,
pei1TttHr tta.ue)!(HOCTH crpaxosoi1
opraH113au1111, npHCBOeHHhIH
Pei1THHrOBhIM areHTCTBOM
«3KcnepT PA», 3acTpaxoaaawei1
npo¢ecc110HaJihHYIO
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh yYaCTHHKa
KOHKypca».
KoJrnqecTBeHHoe/
KatieCTBeHHOe 3HatieH11e
IIOKa3aTeJUI
1-horo, 6arrrrI>I
KoMMeHTap11if
Association
Accountants
of Chartered
- Member
Certified
of the
association 11n11 Fellow of the
association) 11n11 CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
YKa3hIBaeTc11, 11MeeT n11 3a11sneHHhIH
PYKOBO)l11Teni, ay)l11TopcKoi1 nposepK11 onhIT pa60Th1 s ay1111Te He MeHee I 0 neT
YKa3hlBalOTCll 11aHHhie o pe3yJJHarnx BHeurnero KOHTpOJJJI Ka'!eCTBa, JallBJJeHHhie Y"aCTHl1KOM B COCTaBe JallBKl1 Ha Y"aCTtte B KOHKypce .
.[lOCTOBepHOCTh 11aHHhlX, 3allBJJeHHhIX Y"aCTHl1KOM, npoBepl!eTCll no )laHHhlM PeecTPa ay)l11TopcK11x opratt11Jau11i1 M11ttcjmtta Pct>
I. YKaJhJBaeTcll Ha11MeHOBaH11e
CTPaXOBIU11Ka 11 ero pei1T11Hr tta)lelKHOCTl1.
2. YKaJi,rnaeTCll 06m11il JJ11Ml1T OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 CTpaXOBlUl1Ka 11 JJl1Ml1T OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no O)lHOMY CJJy<IalO .
3. YKaJbJBaeTcll , npeJlcrnsneH JJH Y"aCTHHKOM )lOKyMeHT, nO)lTBeplK)lal01Ul1H onJJaTy CTpaXOBOH npeMl111 B nOJJHOM ofrheMe B COOTBeTCTBl111 c norosopoM cTpaxosaH11ll
CooTBeTCTBHe
3Haqemrn:
TIOKa3aTeJUI onpe;:i;erreH
HOMY YpoBHID no
lIIKarre oueHoK
N!! n/n
I
2
3
4
I1p1mm1<em1e 4 K TipOTOKOJJY }fa2 paCCMOTpemfll H
ouettKM 3allBOK Ha yqacTHe B KottKypce
Oueuoqub1ii JIHCT no KpnTepu10 «KBaJIH<l>HKaQHSI H OilbIT yqaCTHHK3 KOHKypca»
e~ Jt~ ,6u_~p_
(tta11Me ~rne)TllllCTHHKa KoHKypca)
flo,n.Kp1nep1111 YposeHb YposeHh 4 YposeHh 3 YposeHb 2 Yposetth l
(100 6arrnos) ( 60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6armos) (1 6arm) I1Mee1 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhJT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cny'rne npoBe)].emno B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBlUI tte Mettee 5 ay.n.111os ro.z:i;osoi1: Tpe6osaHHllMyposttei1: 6yxrarnepCKOH ( qrnttaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT'ieTHOCTH, no.z:i;rOTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCBY, aKQHOHepttbIX 06I.UeCTB ( c san101ol1 6anattca He Mettee X MJlPA py6. ), ocyI.UeCTBJlllJOI.QHX -+ ,n.el!TeJlbttOCTh B 06nacn1 Maumttoc1poemrn, r.n.e X-sarnora 6anattca, MJlp,D. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C flp11nm1<ett11eM N!! 3 K 3al!BKe) I1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He MeHee 5 He MeHee 4 npose.n.emu1 B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee x ay.z:i;HTOB rOAOBOH KOHCOJlHAHpOBaHHOH cp1rnattCOBOH OTl!eTHOCTH, no.n.rOTOBJleHHOH B coorne1crnm1 c MCcDO, opraHH3aQHH, ocyI.UeCTBJlllIOI.QHX
T .z:i;el!TeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTl1 MallJHHOCTpoeHHSI, r)].e X-Kon1111ec1so ay)].HTOB (s COOTBeTCTBl111 c flp11JlO)l(ett11eM N!! 3 K 3al!BKe) llMeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. omn He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ayAHTa fOJ].OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OTlJeTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY, He Mettee x KOMna1mi1: c rOAOBOH BhIPYLJKOH He Mettee 20 MJIPA py6., aKU,1111 KOTOpblX KOTHpy!OTCll Ha poCCHHCKOH -r fo!p)Ke, r.n.e X-Konw-1ecTBo KOMnatt11H (B COOTBeTCTBHl1 C f1pJ.1JlQ)KeH11eM N!! 3 K 3aSIBKe)
PyKoso.n.111enh ay,n.1-nopcKOH ,D,a ,D,a ,D,a
nposepKH o6na,naeT e,nMHbIM -
KBaJIHqmKal.J,HOHHhIM arrecTaToM aym1Topa 11
ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered -Certified Accountants -Member of the association MJlH Fellow of the association) HJIH
·-t CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKoBOAHTem1 L{a L{a • L{a ay,nHTOpCKOH nposepKH B ayAHTe He MeHee 10 JieT -t-
6 B oTHowettHH y•mcTHHKa ,l(a L{a ,D;a npose.n.eH BHeWHHH KOHTpOJlb
. Ka'!eCTBa, no pe3y11bTaTaM ,naHHOro KOHTpOml Ka'!eCTBa B OTHowemrn Y'!aCTHHKa He BblHOCHJlOCb npe.n.n11caHHe HJlH t peweHHe 0 npHOCTaHOBKe ero .neHTenhttocTH
7 TipocpeCCHOHaJlbHaH X: He MeHee X : He MeHee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yqacTHHKa 800 500 400 -3aCTpaxoBaHa cTpaxosoii Y: He MeHee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee opraHH3au,11ii, HMe10mei1 600 300 150 .uefiCTBHTeJlbHbIH pei:h1rnr Ha,D,e)l<HOCTH peHTHHfOBOro areHTcTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He HH)l<e «A++», c 06m11M JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBlQHKa no no1111cy cTpaxosatt11~ (113 pacqeTa Ha I ro.n), He Mettee X 11 Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no
·f OAHOMY CTpaXOBOMY cny'lalO He MeHee Y, r,ne X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM
ao&v o6pa30M, !£~
KoHKypca
N2 n/n
1
2
3
4
DpHJIO)l(eHHe 4
K DpoTOKony N22 paccMoTpemrn H oueHKH JaHBOK Ha yqacrne B KoHKypce
O u.euoqnbJH JIHCT no KpuTepum «KBaJI1t<l>1tKaU,1tSI It OilblT yqacTHHK'.a K'.OHKypca»
~ J/c-t.-e_~-edL ~~
(HaHMeHOBaHHe yqacTHHKa KottKypca)
CTO.D,Kp11Tepm1 Yposetth YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3 YpoBeHb 2 YposeHb 1
(100 6arrnos) (60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6aJIJIOB) (1 6arrn) 11MeeT Ja 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT no He MeHee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cnyLJae npose.n.emuo B COBOKynHOCTM HeCOOTBeTCTBMii He Mettee 5 ay)J.MTOB fO)J.OBOH Tpe6oBaHMHMypOBHeH 6yxraJITepcKOH (qrnttaHCOBOH) 2-4 OTLJeTHOCTM, no.n.roTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTcTB1111 c PCEY,
aKu11ottepttb1x o6mecTB ( c BaJIIOTOH 6anattca He Mettee X MJIP.U py6.), ocymecTBJIHIOIUMX )J.eJJTeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTl1 MallIHHOCTpOeHHJI, r.n.e X-BaJIJOTa 6aJiattca, MJIPJJ. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C
,J__ Do11nm1<ett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe) 11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npose.n.eHHH B COBOKynHOCTM He Mettee x ayJJ.MTOB ro.D,OBOH KOHCOJIH.UMpOBaHttOH cp1rnaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJlettHOH B coorneTcTs1111 c MC<l>O, __ L opraH11Jau11i1, ocymecTBJIHIOIUMX .n.eiiTeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHHH, r.n.e X -Konw-1eCTBO ayJJ.HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBMH C Dp11nm1<ett11eM N2 3 K 3a.11a1<e)
11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onblT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2
aynMTa ro.D,OBOH 6yxraJITepCKOH OTl.JeTttOCTM, no.n.roTOBJieHHOH B coorneTcTs1111 c PCEY, He Mettee x KOMnaHHH c fO)J.OBOH Bb1py'IKOi1 He Mettee 20 Mnp.n.
t py6., aKu1111 KOTOpbIX KOT11py10TCH tta poccMi1cKoi1 611p:>Ke, r.n.e X -KoJI11LJeCTBO KOMnatt11i1 (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Tip11JlO)KeH11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
PyKOBOJJ.HTeJib ay.LJ.MTOPCKOH ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a
5
6
7
nposepKH o6na,UaeT e,UHHbIM KBaJIHqrnKal..lHOHHblM arreCTaTOM ay)lHTOpa H ceprncpHKaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association mrn Fellow of the association) HJIH CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKoBO)lHTenSI ay)lHTOpCKOH nposepK11 B ay,U11Te tte Mettee I 0 neT
B OTHowett1111 Y'IaCTHHKa npoBe)leH BHeillttl1H KOHTpOJib KaYecTBa, no pe3yJibTaTaM .uaHHOfO KOHTpOJI>l KaYeCTBa B
OTHowett11H YYaCTHHKa He BblHOCHJlOCb npe,UnHCaHHe HJIH pewem1e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero )leHTeJlbHOCTH
Tipo<t>ecCHOHaJlhHaH OTBeTCTBeHttOCTb y'laCTttHKa 3acTpaxosatta CTpaxosoJ1 opraH113au.11M:, 11Me10mei1 .ueticrB1.ffeJlbHbIH petlnrnr Ha)le)KttOCTH pei1THHfOBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-P A» He HH)Ke «A++», c o6mHM JIHMHTOM OTBCTCTBCHttOCTH CTpaXOBW.HKa no OOJIHCY cTpaxosaHHH (113 pac4eTa Ha 1 ro)l), He MeHee X H JIHMHTOM OTBeTCTBettttOCTl1 no O.UHOMY CTpaxoBOMY cnyYalO He Mettee Y, r.ue X,Y - cyMMa, Mlltt. py6.
TaKHM /:;' az.--0
l'o,,,o /V
)J,a ;D,a ;D,a
j,6J,O
;D,a ;D,a )J,a
f X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee 800 500 400 Y: He MeHee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee 600 300 150
i
KoHKypca y
rrpHCBaHBaeTC.sI ypoBeHb _ _ ....,/~--' '-ITO COOTBeTCTByeT ou.eHKe --~:r~-___ 6aJUIOB.
~ (rro)lIIHCh "1.JJI~OMHCCHH) (pacrnmpposKa rro.urr11c11)
N2 n/n
l
2
3
4
flp11JIO)Kem1e 4 K flpoToKony NQ2 paccMoTpettHR 11 ouettKH 3aRBOK tta yyacrne B KottKypce
Ou.euoquhIH .rn1cT no KpuTepmo «KBaJIH<l>HKaU.HSI H OilblT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
~(___-~~ t/~ If~~
bQo (Ha11MeH0Bam1e yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
OOJJ.Kp11Tep1111 Yposettb
Yposetth 4 Yposetth 3 Yposetth 2 YpoBettb 1 ( 100 6a.rrnos) (60 6anJJOB) (20 6anJJOB) (1 6ann)
VfMeeT 3a 2011 -20 I 6r1. onbIT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cny•rne npoBeJ],emno B COBOKynttOCTl1 HeCOOTBeTCTBl1H He Mettee 5 ayJJ.11TOB rOAOBOH Tpe6osami.s1M yposttei1 6yxranTepCKOH (qrnttaHCOBOH) 2-4
OTYeTHOCTl1, nOJ],fOTOBJJeHHOH B
coorneTCTB1111 c PCBY,
3KU,HOttepttbIX o6ll.(eCTB ( c
BMIOTOH 6an3ttC3 tte Mettee X + MJJPA py6.), ocyll.(eCTBJlSl!Oll.(HX J],eRTeJJbHOCTb B o6J13CTl1
ManmttocTpoemrn, r.11.e X-san10Ta 6anattca, MilP.11. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C
f1p11nm1<ett11eM N2 3 K 3a51BI<e)
11MeeT 332011-2016rr. OnbIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe)J,eHl151 B COBOKynttOCTl1 tte
Mettee x 3Y,D,11TOB fOJ],OBOH KOHCOJ111)J.11pOBattHOH
cp11H3HCOBOH OTYeTHOCTl1, no.11.roTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTCTB1111 c MC<l>O,
opratt113au,11i1, ·f-ocyll.leCTBJ151!0ll.ll1X )J.eSITeJJbHOCTb B o6naCTl1 Maw11HOCTpoett11H,
r.11.e X-Kon11L1eCTBO ay.11.11ToB
(B COOTBeTCTBl111 C
f1p11JJO)l(ett11eM N2 3 K 33.HBKe)
.11MeeT 33 2011-2016rr. onbIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2
3YJJ.11T3 rOJ],OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH
OTYeTHOCTl1, no)J,rOTOBJJeHHOH B
cooTBeTCTB1111 c PCEY, tte
Mettee x KOMn3Hl1H c fOJ],OBOH
BbtpyYI<OH He Mettee 20 MJJPA
i py6., 3KL.J,1111 KOTOpblX KOT11p)'lOTC51 Ha pocc11HCKOH
611p)1<e,
r)J,e X-KOJ111YeCTBO KOMnatt11i1
(B COOTBeTCTBl111 C
f1p11JJO)!<ett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
PyKOBOJJ.11TeJJb 3y.11.11TopcKOH ,ll;3 ,ll;3 ,ll;3
•
nposepK11 0611a)l.aeT e)l.11HbIM KBaJI11cp11Kal(l10HHblM
arrecTaTOM ay,ll,11Topa 11 cepT11cfmKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association 111111 + Fellow of the association) 111111 CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnhIT pa60ThI pyK0Bo,ll,11Tem1 ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a ay)l.11TOpCKOi1 nposepK11 B
I ay)l.11Te He MeHee I 0 11eT
6 B OTHoweHirn y'lacn-111Ka ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a npose)J,eH BHeWHl1H KOHTp011b Ka'leCTBa, no pe3y11hTaTaM )].aHHOro KOHTp01151 Ka4eCTBa B OTHoweH1111 Y4aCTHl1Ka 1-1e
i BhIHOc1111och npe)l.m1cam1e 111111 pewe1-111e o np11ocTa1-10BKe ero )l.e51Tel1bHOCTl1
7 flpocpecc110HaJibHa5! X: He MeHee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y'laCTHl1Ka 800 500 400 3acTpaxosa1-1a cTpaxosoi1 Y: He Mettee Y: He MeHee Y: He Mettee opra1-1113au.11i1, 11Me10w,ei1 600 300 150 )l.ei1cTs1-ne11hHhlH pei1nrnr Ha)].e)KHOCTl1 pei1T111-1rosoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He Hl1)l(e «A++», c 06w,11M 1111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 CTpaXOBW,11Ka no no1111cy + cTpaxosaH115! (113 pac4eTa Ha I roA), He Mettee X 11 1111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no 0)].HOMY CTpaXOBOMY c11y'la10 tte Mettee Y, r)J,e X, Y - cyMMa, M11H. py6.
TaKHM 3llilBKe yqacTHHKa KoHKypca ~y
rrpHcBairnaeTc.sr ---+---' qTo COOTBeTCTByeT oueHKe _ __,,,,(.b-""J:Q=->--0 ___ 6aJIJIOB.
(IIO,[(IIHCh q . (pacurncppOBKa 110)],HHCH)
N!~
n/n
1
2
3
4
ITpmro:>Kem1e 4 K ITporoKony N22 paccMorpemrn tt
oueHKl1 JaHBOK Ha yqacn1e B KoHKypce
000 ,, @~0· ";f~x Pw~a-?ead• (HaHMeHoBamie y~acTHH:Ka KoHKypca) 7
Ilo.n.Kp1nep1111 YpoBettb YpoBeHb 4 YpoBetth 3 YpoBetth 2 YpoBetth 1
(100 6aJIJ10B) ( 60 6aJIJ10B) (20 6aJIJ10B) (1 6ann) 11MeeT 3a 201 l-2016rr. onhIT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cnylfae npoae.n.emuo B COBOKynttOCTH tteCOOTBeTCTBHH He Mettee 5 ay.D,HTOB fO.D,OBOH Tpe6oBaHHHM ypOBtteH 6yxrrulTepcKOH ( cpHttaHCOBOH) 2-4 QTlJeTHOCTH, no)J.rOTOBJlettttOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCBY, aKUHOHepttblX o6mecTB ( c BaJIIOTOH 6anattca He Mettee X MJIP.D. py6.), ocymecTBJlHIOlll.HX )J.eHTeJlbHOCTb- B 06J1aCTH MaWHttOCTpoettHH, rJJ.e X-BaJIIOTa 6anattca, MJlPJJ. py6. ( B COOTBeTCTBHH C IlpHnmKettHeM NQ 3 K 3aHBKe) 11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He MeHee 5 He Mettee 4 '
npoBe)J.eHHH B COBOKynttOCTH He Mettee x ay.D.HTOB fO)J.OBOH i KOttCOJlH.D,HpOBaHHOH cj)HHaHCOBOH OTlleTHOCTH, nO)J.fOTOBJlettttOH B coorneTCTBl1H c MC<I>O, opraHH3aUHH, ocyw.ecTBJIHIOlll.HX )J.eHTeJlbttOCTb B o6Jiacni MallIHHOCTpoemrn, r)J.e X -KOJIH'-IeCTBO ay.D.HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C IlpHJIO)f(ettHeM NQ 3 K 3aHBKe)
l1MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 aymna fO)J.OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OT"leTHOCTl1, no)J.rOTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTcTBHH c PCEY, tte Mettee x KOMnaHl1H c fO)J.OBOH BbIPYYKOH He Mettee 20 MJIP.D. py6., aKI..J.HH KOTOpblX KOTHPYIOTCH tta pocc11i1:cKoi1: 6Hp)!<e, r.ue X-KOJlHllecrno KOMnattHli (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C flp11nmKemieM NQ 3 K 3aHBKe) ~. PyKoBO.JJ.HTeJlb ay)J.HTO_DCKOH , JJ:a 'J JJ:a JJ:a
~
npoBepK11 o6nanaeT en11HbIM KBaJI11cp11KaUHOHHbIM
arrecTaTOM ay.rmrnpa 11 ceprncp11KaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association HnH Fellow of the association) HJIH
CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
~ 5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKoso.D,11Tem1 1J:'l )];a )];a
aymnopcKoH nposepKH a ayn11Te He Mettee 10 neT
,,....._ 6 B OTHO!lleH1111 y4acTH11Ka ~6'' ,L(a ,L(a
npose.D,ett Btte!llHl1H KOHTpOJib KallecTaa, no pe3yJihTaTaM ,AaHHOro KOHTpOJUI KalleCTBa B OTHOllleH1111 YqacnrnKa tte BblHOCl1J!OCh npe,An11caH11e MJ!M pe!lleH11e 0 npHOCTaHOBKe ero
Ae»TeJibttocT11 () . }tJ, IJ. /fz
7 I1pocpecc110HaJibtta» X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y4aCTHl1Ka 800 500 400 3acTpaxoaatta cTpaxosoii Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee opratt113au11H, 11Me10ruei1 600 300 150 neHCTBHTeJ!bHblH peHTHHr tta.D,eJKttocT11 pet!T11ttrosoro i areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He HmKe «A++ », c 06ru11M /
Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM CTpaXOBIU11Ka no TIOJ!l1CY CTpaxosaH11H (113 paclleTa Ha l ro,D.), He Mettee X 11 Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no OAHOMY cTpaxosoMy cnyLiaIO He Mettee Y, r.D,e X,Y - cyMMa, MJIH. py6.
rrp:HcBmrnaeTC51 ypoBeHb ..£ 7 , qTo coorneTCTByeT oueHKe
TaKHM o6pa.30M, 3a51BKe yqacTHHKa KoHKypca
K CU;&?£&tfn1< ~O-C-<--U&efYH«~~ :( 6aJIJIOB.
~ONf///'O" T 17 (rro.ri;rrHCb qJieHa KOMHCCHH) (pacnrn:cppoBKa ITO,[t;ITHCH)
:.
N2 n/n
l
2
3
4
Op11JJo)!(em1e 4 K npoTOKOJJ y N22 pacCMOTpeHH)I 11 oueHKH 3a)IBOK Ha rrncrne B KoHKypce
Oi_.euoqubJii JIHCT no KpuTepuw
«KBaJIH<l>HKaQHSI H OTihlT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
~OU"-e?Ue6[' ,f aetl'~C! ~~
f10,UKpHTepHH YposeHb YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3 YposeHb 2 YposeHb I
(100 6arrnos) (60 6aJlJJOB) (20 6arrnos) ( 1 6ann) HMeeT 3a 20 I 1-2016rr. om1T no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyYae npose.ueHHIO B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBH51 He MeHee 5 ay.u11Tos ro.uosoi1 Tpe6oBaHH51M ypoBHeH 6yxranTepcKOH ( cjrnHaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, aKUHOHepHbIX 06!lleCTB ( c BaJJIOTOH 6anaHca He MeHee X MJJPP. py6 .), ocy!lleCTBJ1511{)!llHX
$ .ueHeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTH
0 MaWHHOCTpoeHH51, r,1.1.e X-BaJJIOTa 6anaHca, MJlp,U py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C f1p11no:t1<eH11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe) YIMeeT 3a 201 1-2016rr. onhIT He MeHee 6 He MeHee 5 He MeHee 4 npoBe,UeHH51 B COBOKynHOCTH He MeHee x ay,1.1.HTOB rO,UOBOH KOHCOJlH.UHpOBaHHOH cjJHHaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c MC<DO, f opraHH3aUHH, ocy!lleCTBJ1511{)!llHX .ue51TeJlbHOCTb B o6JlaCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHH51, r.ue X-KOJlHLfeCTBO ay.u11TOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C f1p11no:t1<eHHeM N2 3 K 3a51BKe)
I1MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT He MeHee 5 He MeHee 3 He MeHee 2 ay.u11rn ro.uosoi1 6yxranTepcKoi1 OT4eTHOCTH, no,1.1. rOTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, He MeHee x KOMnaHHH c ro,UOBOH BbIPY4KOH He MeHee 20 MJlP.U J py6., aKUHH KOTOpbIX KOTHPYIOTC51 Ha pocc11i1cKoi1 6Hp)l{e, r .ue X-KOJlH4eCTBO KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBHH C f1p11nmKeH11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe) -PyKOBO,UHTeJlb ay.u11TopcKoi1 ,D;a } ,D;a ,D;a
\___/
5
6
npoaepK11 0611aJ].aeT eJJ.11HbIM KBaJHIQH'1KaU110HHbIM
arrecTaTOM aynHTopa 11 cepT11cp11KaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered
Certified Accountants -
Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 11n11
CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
OnbIT pa60Tb1 pyKoBOAHTeJisi ay.UHTOpCKOH npoBepKH B aymne tte Mettee 10 neT
B OTHoweH1111 yYaCTHHKa npoBe,D.eH BHeWHHH KOHTpOJib KaYeCTBa, no pe3y11bTaTaM .n.attttoro KOHTpon.SI KaYeCTBa B 0Tttowett1111 YYaCTHHKa He Bbl ttoc1111ocb npe)J,n11catt11e HJl 11 pewett11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero ,Ue.SITeJlbHOCTl1
7 Tipocpecc110HaJlbHa5! OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yYaCTHl1Ka 3aCTpaxoBaHa CTpaXOBOH opraHH3aUHH, HMelOw,eii
,D.eHCTBHTeJibHblH pei1nrnr Ha,D.e)l<HOCTH peHTl1HfOBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He Hl1)l<e «A++», c 06w,11M Jll1MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 CTpaxoaw,11Ka no no1111cy CTpaxoBaH11.S1 (113 pacYeTa Ha I ro.n.), He MeHee X 11 J111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O,!J.HOMY CTpaxOBOMy CJiyYalO He Mettee Y, r.n.e X,Y - cyMMa, MJIH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M,
(!V .IJ:a
.IJ:a
X: He Mettee X: He Mettee 800 500 Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee 600 300
yqaCTmma KoHKypca
rrpHCBa1rnaeTC5I ypoBeHh __ ()(/ ____ , qTo COOTBeTCTByeT ou,eHKe
~'-e-e~~c-e (rro;::i;rrHCh qrreHa KOMHCCHH)
cz?o N {-!'//"CJ' T / 7. (pacnrncppOBKa ITO,IJ;ITHCH)
.IJ:a
,Ua
X: He Mettee 400 Y: He Mettee 150
om 11 cc:;e d~e~ 1
ZO 6arrrroB.
NQ n/n
1
2
3
4
ITp1111o:a<ett11e 4 K ITpoTOK011y NQ2 paccM0Tpett11H 11
oueHKH 3aHBOK Ha yqacT11e s KottKypce
Ou,euoqnhIH JIHCT no KpHTepmo
«KBaJIH<}>HKaIJ,HH H OilbIT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
CJ-7{7~ ;!; o:W6-d!UC? J{ Ue;;/ ~U?
(tta:rrMettoBattHe yqacTHHKa KottKypca)
f1on Kp11Tep1111 YposeHb YposeHb 4 YposeHh 3 YposeHb 2 YposeHb 1
(100 6annos) (60 6annos) (20 6aJlJ10B) (1 6ann) VfMeeT 3a 20 l l -20 I 6rr. onhIT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He Mettee 5 B c11yyae nposenemno B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBHSI He MeHee 5 ayn11Tos ronosoli Tpe6osaHHSIM ypoBHeH 6yxra11TepCKOH (cpHHaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTl1, nonroTOBJleHHOH B
coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, aKu110HepHb1x o6mecrn (c BaTJIOTOH 6anaHca He MeHee x Mnpn py6.), ocyLI.leCTBJl5!10W.11x 1 neHTeJlbHOCTb B o6JlaCTH MaWHHOCTpOeHH.51, rne X-sanmrn 6anaHca, MJlPA py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C [1p1111mKeHHeM NQ 3 K 3aHBKe)
T1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He MeHee 6 He MeHee 5 He Mettee 4 nposeneHH51 B COBOKynHOCTH He MeHee X aynHTOB ronosoti KOHCOJll1)1.11pOBaHHOH cp11HaHCOBOH OTL£eTHOCTl1, nonroTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTcTB11H c MC<DO, lj opraH113au11li , ocyllleCTBJl 51 IOW.HX neHTeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHl151, rne X-Kon11YecTBo ayn11TOB (B COOTBeTCTBHl1 C CTpHJlO)f(eHHeM M~ 3 K 3aHBKe)
l1MeeT 3a 2011 -2016rr. onbIT He MeHee 5 He MeHee 3 He MeHee 2 ayAHTa ronoBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OT4eTHOCTH, nonrOTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTcTB1111 c PCBY, He MeHee X KOMnaH11i1 c ronosoli BbIPYYKOH He Mettee 20 Mnpn ! py6., aKUHH KOTOpbIX KOT11py10TC5l Ha pocc11iicKOH 611p)f(e, rne X-Kon11L£eCTBO KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBHH C CTp11110)l<eH11eM NQ 3 K 3aHBKe)
·~ PyKOBOAHTeJlb ayn11TopcKoti )J,a )} )J,a )J,a '---..#
npoBepK11 o6na)J,aeT e)J,HHblM
KBaJIHclJHKa~HOHHblM
aTTeCTaTOM ayJJ.HTOpa 11 ceprn¢HKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 11n11
CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
~
5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKOBOJJ.HTem1 ~ ,[!;a ,[!;a ay)J,HTOpCKOH npoBepK11 B ay.n.11Te He MeHee 10 neT
6 B OTHoweH1111 yYaCTHHKa J ,n:a ,n:a npoBe)J,eH BHeWH11H KOHTpOJlb KaYecTBa, no pe3yJlbTaTaM )J,aHHOro KOHTpom1 Ka'-leCTBa B
OTHoweH1111 YYaCTHHKa He BhlHOCHJlOCbnpe.n.n11caH11e11J1 11 peweHHe o np11ocTaHOBKe ero )J,eHTeJlbHOCTl1
7 npo¢ecCl10HaJlbHa51 X: He MeHee X: He MeHee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb )"'laCTHHKa 800 500 400 3aCTpaxosaHa CTpaXOBOH Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee opraH113a~11i1 , 11Me1ow,ei1 600 300 150 )J,eHCTBHTeJlbHblH peHTl1Hr Ha)J,e)I<HOCTl1 peHTl1HrOBOro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He HmI<e «A ++», c 06w,11M J111MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaxOBl.L\HI<a no non11cy /
CTpaxosaHH51 (113 pac'-!eTa Ha I ro.n.), He MeHee X H v Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O)J,HOMY CTpaxOBOMY CJl)"'lalO He MeHee Y, r)J,e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M, 3a5IBKe KoHKypca
rrpMCBaI-1BaeTC5! ypoBeHh --~--' qrn COOTBeTcTByeT oueHKe --.,,L.J~""'----6arrnoB.
$0,eu,cet~ ~~Or 7:/J~ (TIOJJ.IIMCh qneHa KOMMCCHM) (pacwmppOBKa IIOJJ.IIHCH)
Dp1111o)!(emie 4 K IlpoTOKOJJY NQ2 paccMorpemrn H
oueHKM 3a1rnoK Ha yLJacn1e e KoHKypce
OueuoquhIH JJHCT no KpnTepmo «KBaJIH<l>HKa[(HH H OIIblT yqaCTHHKa KOHKypca»
A/~~LL-/7' c~ ,·Y _ IJ_'_ / / ----...,., /._~," --~-(-ct>_._11_.o_._q_JI_eH_a_K_O_M_H_cc_H_H_) _____ _ __B_L,, K. ~lfY~4f
(/ ?I (HaHMeHOBamrn rmcTHHKa KoHKypca)
N2 f10JJ.Kpl1Tep1111 Yposetth n/n YposeHh 4 YposeHh 3 YposeHh 2 YposeHh 1
( 100 6aJIJlOB) (60 6aJIJlOB) (20 6aJIJ10B) ( l 6a.rrn ) 1 11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cny'-iae
npose.n.eHHIO B COBOKYOHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBl151 He MeHee 5 ay.UHTOB fO,!J.OBOH Tpe6oBaHHHMypOBHeH 6yxramepCKOH ( qmttaHCOBOH) 2-4 OTlJeTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCBY,
aKUHOHepHbIX o6mecTB ( c v BaJllOTOH 6aJ1attca He Mettee X MJIPA py6.), ocymecTBJIH10m11x )J,eHTeJibHOCTh B o6JiaCTH MaWHttOCTpoemrn, r)J.e X-BaJllOTa 6aJ1attca, MJlp.U py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C ITp11nm1<ett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
2 11MeeT 3a 20 l 1-2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He MeHee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe)J,eHHH B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee x ay)J,HTOB fO)J,OBOH
KOHCOJlH)J.HpOBaHHOH cjrnHaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJleHHOM B coorneTCTBHH c MC<l>O, v opratt113al{HH, ocymecrnm110m11x )J,eHTeJJhHOCTh B o6JJaCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHHH, rp,e X-Konw.iecTBO ay.UHTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C ITp11J1o)Kett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
3 11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay,D.HTa fO,!J.OBOH 6yxranTepcKOH OTYeTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJieHHOH B cooTsercTBHH c PCEY, He
MeHee x KOMnaHHH c fO,!J.OBOH v BbIPYYKOH He Mettee 20 Mnp.n. py6 ., aKU.HH KOTOpblX KOT11py10TCH Ha pocc11i1cKoi1 6Hp)l{e,
r.n.e X-KoJiwrncrno KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C IlpHJIO>KeHHeM .N°!:! 3 K 3aHBKe) ~
4 PyKOBOJlHTeJih ay.u11TopcKOH )];a/ )];a )];a \._/
5
6
7
npoBepKH o6na,Ll,aeT e,Ll,HHbIM KBaJu1cp11KaU,l10HHblM
arrecTaToM ay,LJ,1-nopa 11
ceprncp11KaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association HJJH Fellow of the association) 1-1n11 CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
Onb1T pa6oTbl pyKOBO,LJ,11Tem1 ay,Ll,11TOpCKOH npoBepKH B ay.J:111Te tte Mettee I 0 neT
B OTHowettHH yYaCTH11Ka npoBe,LJ,eH BHeWHl1H KOHTp011b KaYeCTBa, no pe3ynbTaTaM .JJ,aHHoro KOHTp01151 KaYeCTBa B OTHOweH1111 YYaCTHl1Ka He BblHOCl1J10Cb npe.JJ,m1cam1e HJ111 peweH11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero ,Ll,e51TeJl bHOCTl1
Ilpocpecc110HanbttaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yYaCTHHKa 3acTpaxoBaHa CTpaXOBOH opratt113au,11H, l1Me10w,eH
,LJ,eHCTBl1TeJ1 bHbIH pei1nrnr Ha.JJ,e)l(HOCTH peHTHttroBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He ttm1<e «A++», c 06w,11M Jll1MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaxoBUJ,ttKa no non11cy cTpaxoBatt115I (113 pacYeTa Ha I ro.u), He Mettee X tt
Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBettHOCTl1 no O)J,HOMY CTpaxoBOMY CJlyYalO He Mettee Y, r.JJ,e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M, 3a.5IBKe
X: He Mettee 800 Y: He Mettee 600
yqacTHHKa
LJ:a Li:a
LJ:a LJ:a
X: He Mettee/ X: H.e Mettee D 500 400 Y: He Mette1 Y: He Mettee
300 \,_ 150 i'-.,_ ___/
KottKypca
npHCBaJ1BaeTC5I .ypoBeHb _ _ z ____ , qTQ COOTBeTCTByeT oueHKe __ 2-__ C_> __ 6annoB.
Crro~a KOMHCCIIII) /~~~
(pacrnmppOBKa TIO.UTIIICH)
NQ n/n
1
2
3
4
npHilO)f(em1e 4 K npoTOKOJJ Y N22 pacCMOTpeHHll H
ou,eHKH 3al!BOK Ha )"laCTHe B KoHKy pce
Ou,euoqnh1ii JJHCT no KpnTepu10
«KBaJJn<l>nKaU,HSI H OUhIT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
/-f/f/U/~ a
IT0JJ,Kp11Tep1111 YposeHb
YposeHb 4 YposeH& 3 YposeH& 2 YposeH& 1 (100 6rurnos) (60 6rurnos) (20 6anJJOB) (1 6ann)
HMeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onbJT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyl.fae npoBe)J,eHHIO B COBOKynHOCTl1 HeCOOTBeTCTBl151 He MeHee 5 ay)J,MTOB ro.D,OBOH Tpe6osaHl151M ypoBHeH 6yxranTepcKOH ( cjmHaHCOBOH) 2-4
OTl.feTHOCTl1, no)J,roTOBneHHOH B
cooTBeTcTs1111 c PCEY, aKu,110HepH&1x o6w,ecTB ( c BaJllOTOH 6anaHCa He MeHee x Milp)J, py6.), ocyw,ecTBJl51IOW,11X )J,e51TeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTl1 MaWl1HOCTpOeHl151, rJJ,e X-san10Ta 6anaHca, Milp,ll, py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C ITp11no)!<eH11eM N!! 3 K 3a51BKe)
HMeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. on&IT He MeHee 6 He MeHee 5 He MeHee 4 npoBe)J,eHl151 B COBOKynHOCTl1 He MeHee x ay)J,HTOB ro)J,OBOH KOHCOJl11,ll,11pOBaHHOH cp11HaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTl1, ,j no)J,roTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTCTBtt11 c MCCDO, opraHl13all,11H, ocyw,ecrnn5110w,11x ,ll,e51Ten&HOCT& B 06nacn1 MaWl1HOCTpOeHl151, r,ll,e X-Kon1111ecTBo ay,ll,ttTOB (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Tip11no)!(eH11eM NQ 3 K 3a51BKe) l1MeeT 3a 201 1-2016rr. onbJT He MeHee 5 He MeHee 3 He MeHee 2 ay,ll,11Ta rO,ll,OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OT4eTHOCTl1, no)J,rOTOBJleHHOH B coorneTcrn1111 c PCEY, He MeHee x KOMnaHl1H c rO)J,OBOi1 BblPYl.fKOi1 He MeHee 20 M11p,ll, py6 ., aKLl,1111 KOTOpblX KOTl1PYIOTC51 Ha pocc11i1cKol1 611p)Ke, rJJ,e X-KOJT1111ecTBO KOMnaH11H (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C np11J10)f(eH11eM NQ 3 K 3a51BKe) -PyKOBO,ll,11TeJTb ay)J,11TopcKoi1
I ,[(a ) ,[(a .LJ:a
...____..,-
]y
nposepKH o6na)J.aeT eJJ.HHhIM
KBaJ1HQH1KaUHOHHhIM
aTieCTaTOM ayA11Topa 11 ceprncl>11KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association mm Fellow of the association) 11m1 CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
/\ 5 Onh!T pa60T&1 pyKoao.n;11Tem1 ~[V ,[(a ,[(a
ayJJ.11TOpCKOH npoBepK11 B ayJJ.11Te He Mettee 10 neT
,,.---....._
6 B OTHowett1111 yi.mcTHHKa ~ JJ:a JJ:a npoBeJ).eH BHeWHl1H KOHTpOJlb Ka'leCTBa, no pe3yJlhTaTaM JJ.aHHOro KOHTpOJ151 KalJ.eCTBa B OTttowett1111 Y4aCTHHKa He Bb1Hoc11110cb npe.n;n11catt11e 11n11 pewem1e o np11ocTattoBKe ero J).e51TeJlbHOCTH
7 ITpocpecc11ottaJlhHa5! X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yLJaCTHHKa 800 500 400 3aCTpaxoBaHa CTpaXOBOH Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee opraH113aU.HH, 11MelOW,eH 600 300 150 )J.eHCTBHTeJlbHhIH peHTHHr
HaJJ.e)f<HOCTH pei:ITl1HfOBOro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He
·J HmI<e «A++», C 06w,11M JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaxOBlll,11Ka no IlOJ111CY cTpaxoBaHHR (113 pac4eTa Ha
1 roJJ.), He Mettee X 11 J111MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no OJJ.HOMY CTpaXOBOMY cny4a!O He Mettee Y, rJJ.e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM
fr~· M, 3MBKe y11acTHHKa KoHKypca _ . _ ~ ~(_ re-x ~~v-~J
rrpHCBaHBaeTC'}l
ffiR~~u# (pacnnuppoBKa rro.n;rrnc11)
- ,.
N2 n/n
1
2
3
4
np1rnoJKem1e 4 K DpoTOKOJJY N22 paccM0TpeH1rn 11 oueHKH 3aHBOK Ha y'lacnie B KottKypce
OneHoqHhiii JIHCT no KpnTepuio
«KBaJIH<l>HKaQHSI H OilhIT yqaCTHHKa KOHKypca»
&-~~zeAC ?fl(
(Ha:IIMeHoBamrn yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
00,11.Kpli!TepHH Yposettb
YposeHb 4 Yposetth 3 Yposettb 2 Yposetth 1
(100 6aJIJIOB) (60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6aJIJIOB) (1 6rum)
11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onbJT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cnriae npose.n.ettmo B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBHH He Mettee 5 ay,11.HTOB f0,11.0BOH Tpe6oBaHHHMypOBHeH 6yxraJITepCKOH ( cpHHattCOBOH) 2-4 OT'leTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJJettttOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY, aKLVIOHepHb!X o6mecTB ( c
·j BaJIIOTOH 6anattca He Mettee X MJIP.11. py6.), ocymecTBJIH!Oll..{HX ,11.eHTeJibHOCTb B o6JJaCTH
MalllHHOCTpOeHHH,
r.n.e X-BaJIIOTa 6anattca, MJIP.11. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Opm10>1<ett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe) 11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npose.11.eHHH B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee x ay,11.HTOB f0.11.0BOH KOHCOJIH,11.HpOBaHHOH qnrnaHCOBOH OT'leTHOCTH, nO)J,fOTOBJieHHOH B
') cooTBeTcTBHH c MC<DO, opraHH3aU.HH,
ocymeCTBJIHIOLUHX .11.ejJTeJibHOCTb B o6JJaCTH Mall111HOCTpoeHl1H, r,D;e X-KOJJl14eCTBO ayJJ.11TOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C DpHJIO)l(ett1-1eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay)J.HTa fO)J.OBOH 6yxraJITepCKOH
OT4eTHOCTH, OO)J.fOTOBJJeHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, He v Mettee x KOMnaHHH c f0.11.0BOH
BhIPY4KOH He Mettee 20 MJJPA py6., aKU.1111 KOTOphlX KOTHPYIOTCH Ha pocc11i1cKoi1 6Hp)I<e,
r.n.e X-KOJIH'lecrno KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Tipl1JJQ)I<eH11eM N'!~ 3 K 3aHBKe) ~\
PyKOBO.IT.HTeJJb ay.11.11TopcKoi1 ll:cl )J;a )J;a \J
]{)
nposepKH o6na.uaeT e.UHHhIM KB arm cp 11KaU.H 0 HHbIM
arrecrarnM ay.u11Topa 11 ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association HnH Fellow of the association) Hm1 CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
~
5 On&IT pa60Tb1 pyKoBO.UHTen.H ~ )J;a )J;a ay.UHTOpCKOH nposepKH B ay.u11Te He Mettee I 0 neT
//'\ 6 B OTHOlllemm yqacTHHKa I~ ,[(a ,[(a
npose.ueH BHellJHHH KOHTpOnb Kat.!ecTsa, no pe3ynhTaTaM .uaHHOro KOHTpOn51 Kat.!eCTBa B OTHOllleHHH Y'laCTHHKa He BblHOCHnOCb npe.umi:caHHe HnH pellletttte o np11ocTaHOBKe ero .ue.HTenbHOCTH v ~
7 Dpoqiecc11ottanhttaH l X: He Mettee ~X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yqacTHHKa 800 500 400 3acTpaxosatta cTpaxosoi1 I
~ Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee
opraHtt3au11i1, 11Me10mei1
""' 0 300 150
.ueHCTBHTenbHblM peiinrnr tta.ue)l<HOCTH pei1nrnrosoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He HH)l<e «A++», C 061UHM nHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaxOBlUHKa no noJrncy CTpaxoBaHH51 (H3 paC4eTa Ha I ro.u), He MeHee X H
nHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O)lHOMY CTpaxoBOMY cnyqaIO He Mettee Y, r.ue X,Y - cyMMa, MnH. py6.
TaKMM o6pa.30M, 3aHBKe yqacTHMKa KoHKypca Ljov~ /V~aK-e:*r
rrpHCBa1rnaeTC5I ypoBeHb -~9-/_. ___ , l{TO COOTBeTCTByeT oueHKe ~ 6aJIJIOB .
. _/_~.~~-~_:::-~-- -
-'/ •. ~"i"
/7"'??/(..aF~ ~;7/ -~-----------
(rroJJJIHCb •rneHa KOMHCCHH) (pa c unr cp po BK a IlO.UilHCH)
N2 n / n
1
2
3
4
np11JIO)l(eH11e 4 K ITpoTOKOJJY N22 paccMOTpemrn 11 oueHKH 3aHBOK Ha yqacrne a KottKypce
(tta11Mett0Bamre yqacTHI1Ka KottKypca)
DoAKPHTepHH Yooaettb
YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3 YposeHb 2 YposeHb 1
( 100 6anJIOB) (60 6anJIOB) (20 6aJIJlOB) (1 6ann)
11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cny1rne
np0Be,[(em110 B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBH.H
He Mettee 5 ayAHTOB fO,[(OBOH Tpe6oBaHH.HMypOBHeH
6yxramepCKOH ( qnrnaHCOBOH) 2-4
OT11eTttOCTH, no,[(roTOBJieHHOH B
cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY,
aKUHOHepHblX o6w.ecTB ( c
aan10Toii 6anattca He Mettee X MJIPA py6.), ocyw.ecTBJI.HIOW.HX
Ae~JTeJibHOCTb B o6nacTH
MaWHHOCTpOeHH.H,
rAe X-BaJllOTa 6anattca, MJIPA
py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C
nownmI<ettHeM N!! 3 K 3a.HBKe)
11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. OObIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe,[(ettH.!I B COBOKynttOCTl1 He v Mettee x ayAHTOB fOAOBOH
KOttCOJlHAHPOBattttOH
¢1rnattCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH,
no,[(rOTOBJieHHOH B
cooTBeTcTBHH c MC<l>O, opraHH3aUHH,
ocymecTBmnom11x
.ueHTeJlbHOCTb B o6JiaCTH
MaUIHHOCTpoeHH.H,
r,[(e X-KoJI1111ecrno ayAHTOB
(B COOTBeTCTBHH C
Tip11J1o)l(em1eM NQ 3 K 3a.srnKe)
11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2
ayAHTa fO,[(OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH
OT11eTHOCTH, 00,[(fOTOBJieHHOH B
cooTaeTcTBHH c PCEY, He
Mettee x KOMnaHHH c fOAOBOH
BbIPY11KOH He Mettee 20 MJIPA
py6., aKU.HH KOTOpblX
KOrnpylOTC.H Ha poCCHHCKOH
611p)!(e,
rAe X-KOJ11111ecTBO KOMnaHHH
(B COOTBeTCTBIU1 C
Tip1111m1<eHHeM N2 3 K 3aHBKe) ,....---....,..
PyKOBOAHTeJlb ay}J.11TopcKoi1 ( ,[(a ) ,[(a ,[(a --=-
nposepKH 06na,1J,aeT e,IJ,HHhIM KBaJIHcjH1KaUHOHHblM arrecTaTOM ay,1J,11Topa 11 ceprncp11KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association HJlH Fellow of the association) mm CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
/~
5 OnhIT pa6oThI pyKOBOJJ.HTem1 v JJ:a ,[!,a ay,IJ,HTOpCKOH npoBepKH B ay,1J,11Te tte Mettee 10 neT
- ' 6 B OTttowemm y'iaCTHHKa l/_na .) ,[!,a ,[!,a
npoBe,IJ,eH BHeWHHH KOHTpOJlb 'f-----/ Ka'ieCTsa, no pe3ynhTaTaM }J,aHHOro KOHTpomI Ka'leCTBa B 0Tttowett1111 Y'laCTHHKa tte BhlHOCHJlOCb npe,1J,n11cam1e HJlH pewett11e o np11ocTattOBKe ero ,1J,e.s1TeJ1bHOCTl1
7 Tipocpecc11ottanhttall X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y'iaCTHHKa 800 500 400 3acTpaxosatta cTpaxosoH Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee
opraH113aU.HH, HMe10mett 600 300 150 JJ.eticrn1..neJ1bHb1tl petlnrnr Ha}J,e)KHOCTH peHTHHfOBOro v areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He Hl·DI<e «A++», c o6lllHM Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBl.lU1Ka no nom1cy cTpaxosaHHll (113 pac"!eTa tta 1 ro,IJ,), He Mettee X 11 Jil1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O,IJ,HOMY CTpaXOBOMY cJiy'lalO tte Mettee Y, r,IJ,e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa.3oM, 3a5IBKe yqacTHHKa KottKypca
Ko /\AE'.11.A.'?- t-\ ~t'O\O I?:>>;,\ ).( '?o KC Y/\.bTO.rt\OfS rrpHCBaHBaeTC5I )j'{JOBeHb ---"-i ___ .. qTQ COOTBeTCTByeT oueHKe --~.i"--___ 6annoB. . /
(no;a: (pacrnmppoBKa no,1J,m1c.11)
2
3
4
Ilp11no)l{ett11e 4 K IlporoKOny N~2 paccMorpett1rn 11 ouettK11 3al!BOK Ha y4acr11e B KottKypce
(tta11MeH0Bamre ycracrn11Ka KoHKypca)
Tio.nKpMrepMH Y OBeHb YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3 YposeHb 2 YposeHb 1
( 100 6aJIJIOB) (60 6anJJOB (20 6annos ( 1 6ann) I1Meer 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyyae npose.nettmo B COBOKYOHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBH)i He Mettee 5 ay.n11TOB fO.[J,OBOH rpe6oBaHH)iM ypOBHeH 6yxranrepcKOH ( cjrnHaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTl1, no.nroTOBJieHHOH B coornercrs1111 c PCEY,
/~ aKu,11ottepttb1x o6mecrn ( c BaJllOTOH 6anattca He Mettee X MJIPA py6.), ocymeCTBJI)iJOl.Ll,11X .neHeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTl1 MaWHHOCTpoeHM)i , -~ rAe X -san10Ta 6anattca, MJIPA py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C TI HJIO)!(eHMeM Ng 3 K 3a)iBKe) I1Meer 3a 2011-2016rr. onb1T He Mettee 6 He MeHee 5 npose.neHH)i B COBOKynHOCTH He MeHee x ayAHTOB fO.[J,OBOH KOHCOJIMAHpOBaHHOH cjrnHaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTl1, nO)lfOTOBJieHHOH B coornercrn1111 c MC<DO, opratt113au,11ii , ocymecTsnmomttx .[le)iTeJibHOCTb B o6naCTl1 MaWHHOCTpoeHH)i , rAe X-Kon114ecrso ayAMTOB (s COOTBeTCTBMH c TI 11nm1<ett11eM Ng 3 I< 3a)iBKe)
I1Meer 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT He MeHee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay.nMTa fO)lOBOH 6yxranrepCKOH OT4eTHOCTM, no.nroTOBJieHHOH B coornercrn11M c PCEY, He Mettee x KOMnaHMH c fO.[J,OBOH \( Bb1py4KOH He Mettee 20 MJIPA py6 ., aKU,HH KOTOpblX KOT11py10TC)i Ha pocc11iicKOH 611p)1<e, r)le X-KOJIM4ecrso KOMnaHMH (s COOTBeTCTBHH c TI 11JIO)!(ett11eM Ng 3 K 3a)iBKe
p KOBOAMTeJib a AMTO CKOH ,[(a ,[(a
npoBepK11 06na.1J,aeT e.1J,11HbIM KBaJT 11QJJ1KaU110HH bl M
aTTeCTaTOM ay,llJ1TOpa 11 ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -
Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 11n11
CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa6oTbl pyKOBO.IJ.HTem1 !(a x ,Ua ,Ua
ay.UHTOpCKOH npoBepKH B ay.1J.11Te He Mettee I 0 neT
6 B 0Tttowett1111 y4acTttHKa ,Ua ,Ua ,Ua npose.uett BttewttHH KOttTpOilb Ka4ecrna, no pe3ynbTaTaM < )J,aHHOrO KOttTpom1 Ka4eCTBa B OTttOWeH1111 y 4aCTHHKa He BhlHOCl1JlOCbnpe.1J.n11caH11e11JJ11 peweH11e o np11ocTattOBKe ero .IJ,eRTeJlbttOCTH
7 llpocpecc11ottanbttaR X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y'-laCTttHKa 800 500 400 3acTpaxosaHa cTpaxoBOH Y: He MeHee Y: He Mettee Y: He MeHee opratt113au11!1, 11Mel{)ll(eH 600 300 150 )J,eHCTBHTeJlbHblH peHTHlff Ha)J,e:>KHOCTH peHTHHrosoro arettTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He < Hl1)f<e «A++», c o6w,HM Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBettHOCTH CTpaXOBW,HKa no non11cy cTpaxosatt11~ (113 pac'-leTa Ha I ro.1J.), He Mettee X 11 Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHttOCTH no O)J,HOMY CTpaXOBOMY cny4al{) tte Mettee Y, r.ue X,Y - cyMMa, MJltt . py6 .
TaKHM a30M, 3a51BKe KoHKypca
- ---- ' qTO COOTBeTCTByeT ou:eHKe _ __ ..,..,.. ___ 6aJIJIOB.
(no
Yf
.N!! Ilo.nKpHTepmt n/n
1 11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onbIT no npoBe,[(emuo B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee 5 ay.[(HTOB rO.[(OBOH 6yxra11TepCKOH ( qrnttaHCOBOH) OT'leTHOCTH, no.nroTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY,
aKUHOHepHblX o6mecTB ( c BaJllOTOH 6a11attca He Mettee X MJIP.ll py6. ), ocymecTBJillJOI.UHX )lel!TeJJbHOCTb B o6JJaCTH MaWI1HOCTpoeHH.SI, r.ne X-BaJlJOTa 6a11attca, MJIP.ll py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Ilp11nmI<ettHeM M~ 3 K 3al!BI<e)
2 11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. on11T npoBe,[(eHH.Sl B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee x ay.[(HTOB fO)lOBOH KOHCOJll1)l11pOBaHHOH qnrnaHCOBOH OT'leTHOCTH, no.nroTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTcTBHH c MC<l>O, opram13ai.1,11i1, ocymecTBJJ.SIIOI.UHX )le51TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHH51, r,[\e X-KOJIH4eCTBO ay.[(HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C I1p1rnm1<ettHeM .N!! 3 K 3al!BKe)
3 l1MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. on1IT ay.n11rn fO,[(OBOH 6yxraJ1TepcKOH OT'leTHOCTH, no.nroTOBJJeHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, tte Mettee x KOMnaHHH c rO)lOBOH s11pyl!KOH He Mettee 20 Mnp.n py6., aKUHH KOTOpb!X KOT11py10TC.SI Ha pocc11i1cKoi1 611p)!(e, r.ne X-KoJI114ecTBO KOMnatt11i1 (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Ilp11JIO)J<ett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
4 PyKoso.n11Ten1 ay.n11TopcKOH
YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3
(100 6arIJIOB) ( 60 6aJlJIOB) He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15
He MeHee 6 He Mettee 5
i/
He MeHee 5 He Mettee 3
'/
1r?\ ~a ) ~a -
flp11JIO)l(em1e 4 K DpoTOKOJJY NQ2 paccMoTpeHHll 11 oueHKH 3al!BOK Ha y'-!acrne B KoHKypce
YposeH1 YposeHb 2 YposeHb I (20 6aJlJIOB) (1 6rurn)
He MeHee 5 B cny4ae HeCOOTBeTCTBH.SI Tpe6oBaHHl!MypOBHeH 2-4
\/
He Mettee 4
He Mettee 2
~a
nposepKH o6JiaAaeT eAHHbIM
KBaJ111cpl1Kau110HHblM
aTTeCTaTOM ayAHTOpa H cepmcp11KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association HJIH Fellow of the association) HnH CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
~
5 OnbIT pa6oTbl pyKoBOAHTem1 I .[{a J ,[(a ,[(a ay.n.HTOpCKOH npoBepKH B ~ ay.n.11Te He Mettee 10 neT
r'-..
6 B OTttowett1111 yqacTttHKa If ,[(a .[{a ,[(a npose.n.ett BtteillttHH KOHTpOJib
I
Ka11ecTBa, no pe3yJibTaTaM .uattHOro KOHTpOml Kal.!eCTBa B OTHowemrn Y11acTH11Ka He Bb1Hoc11nocb npe.un11camrn 11n11 pewett11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero .n.e.ineJibHOCTH
,.,.,-----., 7 I1pocpecc110ttaJlbttaH X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: -1 · e Mette(j,
OTBeTCTBettttOCTb yqaCTHHKa 800 500
b 3aCTpaxoBatta CTpaXOBOH Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee oprattH3aUHH, HMe!Olll,eH 600 300 0 nei1CTBl.ffeJibHblH peHTHHr Ha)J,e)KHOCTl1 peHTHHrOBOrO arettTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He ttm1<e «A++», c 06w11M JIHMHTOM OTBeTCTBettttOCTH CTpaXOBIUHKa no non11cy CTpaxosaHHH (113 pac11eTa Ha I ro.n.), He Mettee X 11 J111MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHttOCTH no 0,UHOMY CTpaXOBOMY cny11a10 He Mettee Y, r.n.e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa.30M, KottKypca
(pacrmupposKa no,L1:rmc11)
N2 n/n
l
2
3
4
Tip11nolKett11e 4 K flpOTOKOJJY N22 paccMOTpemrn 11 oueHKH 3airnoK Ha yyacT11e B KottKypce
Ou,euoqnhlii JUICT no KpHTepHIO
«KBaJiml>ttKaU,HSI H OTibIT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
tJ ~ ) I Q-"'J-b ~ ,IJ
IlOJJ.Kp11Tep1111 YposeHh YposeHb 4 YposeHh 3 YpoBeHh 2 YposeHh I
(JOO 6aJU10B) ( 60 6aJ1JlOB) (20 6MJ10B) (I 6an11) 11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhJT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyYae npose)J.emuo B COBOKynHOCTH tteCOOTBeTCTBl151 He Mettee 5 ay)J.11TOB ro)J.OBOH Tpe6osattHllM yposttel-1 6yxramepCKOH (cj:Ji-1HattCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTH, nO)J.rOTOBJlettHOH B coorneTcrn111-1 c PCEY, aKu,11ottepttbIX o6w.ecrn (c v samoTOH 6anaHca He MeHee X MilPJJ. py6.), ocyw.eCTBJ15l'IOllll1X )J.e51TeJlbHOCTb B 0611aCTl1 MaWHttOCTpoeHHll, r)J.e X-san10rn 6anaHca, MilPJJ. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Ilp1rnm1<eH11eM N2 3 K 3allsKe) 11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He MeHee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe)J.eHH51' B COBOKynttOCTH He MeHee x ay)J.HTOB rO)J.OBOH KOHCOJI H)J.HpOBaHHOH qrnttattCOBOH OT4eTHOCTl1, v no)J.rOTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTB1111 c MC<PO, opratt113au,11ii,
ocywecrn11ll10W.11x )J.ellTeJlbHOCTb B 0611aCTl1 MaW11HOCTpoeHHll, r )J.e X-KOJIHLJecrno ayJJ.HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Ilp1-1no)f(eH11eM N2 3 K 3allBKe)
l1MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT He Mettee 5 He MeHee 3 He MeHee 2 aym1Ta rO)lOBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OT4eTHOCTH, no)J.rOTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, He MeHee x KOMnaHHH c ro)lOBOH
\) BhIPYYKOH He MeHee 20 Milp)l py6., aKLJ,1111 KOTOpbIX KOTHPYIOTCll Ha pocc11iicKoH 611p)f(e, r)J.e X-KOJIH4eCTBO KOMnaH11i1 (B COOTBeTCTBl1H C Ilp1111mKeH11eM N!! 3 K 3al!BKe) /\ PyKOBOJJ.11Tenh ay)J.HTOPCKOH 11,[(a/ ,[(a ,[(a
.:c__-
npoBepK11 0611a)J,aeT e)J,11HbIM
KBaJil1cjmKal(l10HHbJM
arreCTaTOM ay)J,11TOpa 11 ceprncpY!KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association Y11111 Fellow of the association) HJlH CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
~
5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKOBO,ll,HTem1 ~~ .D:a .D:a ay)J,YITOpCKOH npoBepKH B ay,ll,11Te He MeHee 10 neT
~ 6 B OTHoweH1111 y4acTH11Ka ( ~ .D:a ,na
npoBe)J,eH BHeWHl1i1 KOHTpOJlb Ka4ecrna, no pe3yJlbTaTaM )J,aHHOro KOHTpon.si Ka4eCTBa B OTHowemrn YL1acTH11Ka He BbIHOCHJlOCb npe,ll,n11caH11e 111111 pewemie o np11ocTaHOBKe ero )J,e.siTeJlbHOCTl1
-7 n pocpeCCl10HaJ1 bHa.sI ~eMeHe~ X: He MeHee X: He MeHee
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y4acTHHKa 800 500 400 3aCTpaxoBaHa CTpaxOBOH I Y: He MeHe Y: He MeHee Y : He MeHee opraH113au,11i1, 11Me1-0mei1 f'6Q_o 300 150
-)J,ei1CTBHTeJlbHbli1 pei1Tl1Hr Ha)J,e)KHOCTH peHTHHfOBOro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He Hl1)Ke «A++», c 06m11M J111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 cTpaxoBm111<a no no1111cy CTpaxosaHH.sI (113 pac4eTa Ha I ro,ll,), He MeHee X 11 J111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no 0)1,HOMY CTpaxOBOMY CJTY4aI-O He MeHee Y, r)J,e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M, yqacTHHKa KottKypca
rrpHCBaHB~ypoBeHb 4 ' 'ITO COOTBeTCTByeT oueHKe -~l~O~C~J _ __ 6annoB.
qnetta KOMHCCHH) (pacnmcppoBKa TIO)]JIHCH)
N2 n/n
I
2
3
4
CTp11JJO)f(ett11e 4 K CTpoTOKOJJY N~2 paccMOTpeH11H 11 oueHKl1 3aHBOK Ha yyacrne B KOHKypce
Ou,euoqub1ii JIHCT no KpnTepuro «KBaJIH<l>HKaQHH " OilbIT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
/~0 "rt0,_r1-r / ~.
Oo,uKp11Tep1111 YpoBett6 Yposettb 4 YpoBeHb 3 YpoBeHb 2 YpoBeHb 1
(I 00 6aJJJIOB) ( 60 6aJJJIOB) (20 6aJJJIOB) ( 1 6aJJJI)
HMeeT 3a 201 l-2016rr. onbIT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cnyyae npoBe,uemno B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBml He Mettee 5 ay,uttTOB rO,UOBOH Tpe6oBaHl151M ypOBHei:i 6yxraJJTepCKOH ( cjrnHaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTH, no,uroTOBJieHHOH B
1' coorneTCTB1111 c PCEY, aKu11ottepttb1x o6mecrn ( c BaJJIOTOH 6aJJattca He Mettee ~ MJIP.U py6.), ocymeCTBJI51IOl.llHX ,ue51TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTl1 MaWl1HOCTpoeHl151, r.ue X-BaJJIOTa 6aJJattca, MJIP.U py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Op11JIO)!(ett11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe)
HMeeT 3a 201 l-2016rr. onbIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe,UeHtt51 B COBOKynHOCTl1 He Mettee x ay.u11TOB ro,UOBOH KOHCOJll1,UttpOBaHHOH cj:n1HaHCOBOH OTYeTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJieHHOH B )< coorneTCTB1111 c MC<l>O, opratt113au11i1, ocymecTBJI51IOl.llttX ,Ue51TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTH MaWl1HOCTpoeHH51, r.ue X-KOJIH'·IeCTBO ay.u11ToB (B COOTBeTCTBHl1 C Op11nm1<ett11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe) HMeeT 3a 20 I 1-2016rr. onb!T He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay.u11rn ro,UOBOH 6yxraJJTepCKOH OT4eTHOCTl1, no.uroTOBJieHHOH B coorneTcrn1111 c PCEY, He >( Mettee X KOMnatt11i1 c ro.uosoi1: BhIPY4KOH He Mettee 20 Mnp.u py6., aKU1111 KOTOpbIX KOT11py10TC5! Ha poCCHHCKOH 611p)f<e, r,ue X-KoJ1114ecTBO K0Mnatt11i1 (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C ITp1rnm1<emteM N2 3 K 3aHBKe) \ ..,,,..-...-PyKOBO.UttTenb ay.u11Topc1<oi1 .IJ:a x .IJ:a .IJ:a
/
nposepK11 o6na.naeT e,n11HbIM
KBaJJ 11cp11KaU,l10HHblM
arreCTaToM ay.n1n opa 11 ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The A ssociation of Cha1iered Certified Accountants -Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 11n 11 CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
5 Om1T pa60Tb1 pyKOBOAHTem1
~· x: )],a )],a
ay,n11TOpCKOH npoBepK11 B ay,n11Te He MeHee I 0 neT
6 B OTHoweH1111 Y'"'aCTH11Ka ,n:a ,n:a ,n:a npose,neH BHeWHYIH KOHTpOJJb KaYecTsa, no pe3yJJ bTaTaM
)( .naHHOro KOHTpon.si KaYeCTBa B OTHOWeHHH YLlaCTHHKa He BblHOCYIJIOCb npe.nn11caH11e YIJI YI peweH11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero ,D,e.sITeJJbHOCTl1
7 I1pocpecc110HanhHa.si X: He MeHee X: He MeHee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yYaCTHYIKa 800 500 400 3acTpaxosaHa cTpaxosoii Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee opraH113au,11i1, 11Me10w,ei1 600 300 150 .neHCTBYITeJJbHblH peiinrnr y Ha.[\e)f(H0CTl1 peHTl1HroBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He Hl1)f(e «A ++», C 06w,11M
Jl11Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 CTpaXOBW,11Ka no non11cy cTpaxoBaH11.si (113 pacYeTa Ha 1 ro.n) , He MeHee X 11 JIYIMYITOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no OAHOMY CTpaXOBOMy CJTY'"!3IO He MeHee Y, r .ne X,Y - cyMMa, MJJH. py6.
TaKttM 3lliIBKe yqaCTHHKa KottKypca
(no~ Ch qJ,{etta KOMttcc1m) (pacnrncpp Ka no~nttctt)
N2 n/n
1
2
3
4
CTp11J1o)Kem1e 4 K npoTOKOJlY N22 paCCMOTpemrn H oueHKH 3a51BOK Ha yyacrne B KoHKypce
Ouettolltthlii JJHCT no KpHTepuio
«KBaJJH<l>HKaQHH " OilhIT yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
/:JVJ j/g Pl IA)( ~ ;j
(ttattMeHoBami:e yqacTHHKa ottKypca)
DoJ.J,Kp11Tep1111 YpoBeHb YpoBeHb 4 Y poBeHb 3 Y poBeHb 2 YpoBeHb I
( 100 6a.nnoB) ( 60 6annoB) (20 6annoB) (I 6ann)
YIMeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. omtT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyyae npoBeJ.J,emno B COBOKynHOCTl1 HeCOOTBeTCTBl151 He MeHee 5 ayJ.J,HTOB roJ.J,OBOH Tpe6oBaHH51M ypoBHeH 6yxranTepcKOH (cjnrnaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTH, noJ.J,rOTOBJleHHOH B coorneTcTB1111 c PCEY, aKuHOHepHblX o6w.ecTB ( c BaJJIOTOH 6ana1-1ca He MeHee X
( MilPJl py6.), ocyw.ecTBJ1 5llOW,11X )J,e51TeJ1 bHOCTb B o6naCTl1 MaWHHOCTpoeHH51, r )J,e X-san10rn 6a.naHca, Milp)J, py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Op1rnmKeH11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe)
l1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhtT He MeHee 6 He MeHee 5 He MeHee 4 npoBeJ.J,e!-11151 B COBOKynHOCTl1 He Mettee x ayJ.J,11TOB ro)J,OBOH KOHCOJ1 11)J,11pOBaHHOH cp111-1aHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTl1,
I noJ.J,roTOBJleHHOH B coorneTCTB1111 c MC<l>O, opra1-1113au11H, ocy w.ecTBJ151IOW.HX )J,e51TeJl bl-IOCTb B o6naCTl1 MaWHHOCTpoeHl151, r J.J,e X-Kon114ecTBO ay,lJ,HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C f1p11nm1<e1-111eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe) I1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Me1-1ee 5 He Me1-1ee 3 He Mettee 2
ay)J.11Ta rOJ.J,OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OT4eTHOCTl1, no)J,rOTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTcTB1111 c PCEY, tte MeHee x KOMnaHHH c rOJ.J,OBOH I Bb1pyYKOH 1-1e Me1-1ee 20 MJJPJ.l py6. , a1<u1111 KOTOpblX KOT11py10TC5! 1-1a pOCCl1HCKOH 611p)Ke, r J.J,e X-Kon114ecTBO KOMna1-111i1 (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Op11JTO)KeH11eM N2 3 K 3a51sKe) ' ,/
PyKOBOJJ.HTenh ayJ.J,11Topc1<oi1 ,[(a x ):(a ):(a \
nposepK11 o6na.naeT eJJ,11HhIM KBaJJ11cjmKaQl10HHblM
arrecTaTOM ayJJ.11Topa 11 cepT11qrnKaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association 1-111 1-1 Fellow of the association) 11n11 CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyK0BoJJ.11Tem1 ~· ;( .IJ:a .IJ:a ayJJ,11TOpCKOH nposepK11 B ayJJ.11Te He MeHee I 0 neT
6 B OTHoweH1111 yYaCTH11Ka ,D,a ,D,a .IJ:a nposeJJ,eH BHewH11tl KOHTponh K34eCTBa, no pe3yJ1bT3T3M JJ,aHHOro KOHTpom1 KaLJeCTBa B
G OTHoweH1111 YYaCTHttKa He BhlHOCl1JlOCbnpeJJ,n11caH11e11n11 peweH11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero JJ,e51TeJlbHOCTl1
7 flpo¢ecCHOHaJ1 bH351 X: He MeHee X: He Mettee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y4acTH11Ka 800 500 400 3aCTpaxosaHa CTpaXOBOH Y: He MeHee Y : He MeHee Y: He MeHee oprnH113au,11tl , 11Met0w.et1 600 300 150 JJ,eHCTBl1TeJ1bHblH peHTl1Hr Ha)J,e)l{HOCTH peHTHHrosoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He HmKe «A ++», c o6W,11M J111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 CTpaXOBW,HKa no non11cy ! CTpaXOB3Hl151 (113 pac4eTa Ha I roJJ.), tte MeHee X 11 Jll1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no 0.[(HOMY CTpaXOBOMY cnyYalO He MeHee Y, rne X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM 06P,l).30M, 3a5IBKe y'laCTHHKa KottKypca %JIK
- -=----' 'ITO COOTBeTCTByeT oueHKe ---~ ___ 6amrnB.
(rro.n; HCb qn eHa KOMHCCirn)
N2 n/n
l
2
3
4
np11no>1<em1e 4 K TipOTOKOJIY }fa2 paccMorpemrn H oueHKM 3airnoK Ha y4acrne B KoHKypce
(HaHMeHoBamre yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
l1o.n,KpHTepHI1 Yposettb YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3 YposeHb 2 YposeHb 1
(100 6aJIJJOB) (60 6aJIJJOB) (20 6aJIJ10B) (1 6a.rrn) HMeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhIT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyqae npose.n,emuo B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBH51 He Mettee 5 ay.n,HTOB ro.n,OBOH Tpe6oBaHH51MYPOBHeH 6yxraJITepCKOH ( qmHaHCOBOH) 2-4 OTlJeTHOCTH, no.n,rOTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTcTBHH c PCEY, aKUHOHepHblX o6mecTB ( c BaJIIOTOH 6aJiaHca He Mettee x MJipA py6. ), ocyI.QeCTBJ151JOI.QHX ,lle51TeJibHOCTb B o6nacTH MaWHHOCTpOeHH51,
r,lle X-BaJIIOTa 6anaHca, MJlP.ll py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHl!I C I1p1111m1<eH11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe) HMeeT 3a 2011 -2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He MeHee 5 He MeHee 4 npose.n,eHH51 B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee x ay,D.HTOB ro.n,oBOH
T KOHCOJIHAHpOBaHHOH qnrnaHCOBOH OTlJeTHOCTH, no.n,roTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTcTBHH c MC<l>O, opraHl13au,11l1, ocymecTBJI51IOI.QHX .n,e51TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTH MallJHHOCTpOeHHSI,
r.n,e X-Kon1111ecTBO ay.n,HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBl!IH C I1pttJlO)Kett11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe)
HMeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay.n,11Ta ro.n,osol1 6yxranTepcKol1 OTlJeTHOCTH, no.n,rOTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTcTBHH c PCEY, He
Mettee x KOMnaim.H c ro.n,OBOH BhIPYYKOH He Mettee 20 MJJPA py6., aKI..J,HH KOTOpblX KOT11py10TC5! Ha pocc11J:icKol1 6Hp)Ke, r.n,e X-KOJIHYeCTBO KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBHH C l1pHJJO)J<eHHeM N2 3 I< 3aHsKe)
PyKOBO.llHTeJib ay.n,11TopcKoi1 )]:a )]:a )]:a
'·
nposepKH o6na.uaeT e)lHHbIM KBaJU1QJ11KalU10HHhlM aTieCTaTOM ay)lHTOpa H ceprncp11KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association mrn Fellow of the association) mrn CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKOBO)lHTern1 ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a ay)lHTOpCKOH nposepKH B ay.u11Te He MeHee I 0 neT
6 B OTHOlllemm yYaCTH11Ka .[(a ,D;a ,[(a npoBe)leH BHellIHl1H KOHTpOJib Kat.ieCTBa, no pe3yJibTaTaM )laHHOro KOHTpOJI.Sl Kat.ieCTBa B OTHOllleH11H YllaCTH11Ka He BblHOCHJIOCb npe)lmicaH11e HJIH pewett11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero )l,e~neJibHOCTH
7 I1pocf>ecc110HanhHaH X : He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb )"laCTHl1Ka 800 500 400 3acTpaxosaHa cTpaxoBoi1 Y : He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He MeHee opratt113aUHH, HMe10mei1 600 300 150 JJ,eHCTBHTeJibHhIH petinrnr Ha)l,e)KHOCTH peHTHHfOBoro arettTCTBa «3KcnepT-P A» He HH)!(e «A++», c 06m11M JIHM11TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBlll,HKa no nOJIHCY cTpaxosaH11H (113 pact.ieTa Ha I roJJ.), He Mettee X 11 JJHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O)lHOMY CTpaxoBOMY cnyt.ia!O He Mettee Y, r.ue X,Y - cyMMa, MJJH. py6.
KHM o6pa30M, f//£'~ tf!.
y cTH11Ka1 /' KottKypca (~"-W_-_' ________ _ v x /Vi)tr / 0 /lt h'~
6aJIJIOB. ---~---
, qTO COOT~CTByeT oueHKe
/<:v?1'4 4,9_ rrpHCBaHBaeTCH
(pacnrncppoBKa rro,n:rrnc11)
M~
n/n
1
2
3
4
llpHJJO)l(em1e 4 K llporoKony NQ2 paccMorpeHl1JI H
oueHKH 3a5!BOK Ha yyacrne B KoHKypce
Ou,ettoqtthIH JIHCT no KpttTepuro
«KBaJitt<l>ttKaIJ,HH " OIIblT qacTHHKa ~HKypca»
~/J~ k~ 1V44~
(ttaHMettoBamie yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
00,UKpHTepl·HI YpoBeHh
YpoBeHh 4 YpoBeHh 3 YpoBeHh 2 YpoBeHh I (100 6aJ1JlOB) (60 6annoB) (20 6aJ1JlOB) ( 1 6ann)
ilMeer 3a 20 I 1-2016rr. onhIT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cnyyae npoBe,uemuo B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBIHI He MeHee 5 ay,UHTOB ro,UOBOH rpe6osaHHHM yposHei1 6yxranrepCKOH ( cjJY!HaHCOBOH) 2-4 OTYeTHOCTH, no,urOTOBJleHHOH B coornercrn111-1 c PCEY, aKL(HOHepHbIX ofauecTB ( c 30~/J BaJllOTOM 6anaHca He Mettee X MJlPLl py6. ), ocymecTBJl.S!lOIUHX
bay? ,ne.SITeJlbHOCTh B o6naCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHH5!, r,ue X-BaJlIOTa 6anaHca, MJlp,U py6. (s COOTBeTCTBHH c CTp11JlO)l(eHHeM N2 3 K 3a51BKe) J1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhlT He MeHee 6 He MeHee 5 He MeHee 4 npoBe,UeHH5! B COBOKynHOCTH He Mettee x ay,UHTOB ro,UOBOM KOHCOJlH,ll.HposaHHOM
1?cu;~? cp1rnaHCOBOM OTYeTHOCTH, no,UroTOBJleHHOM B coornercrnHH c MC<PO,
oprattH3auHi1, ocymecTsnmomHx neHTeJlbHOCTh B o6naCTH MaWHHOCTpoeHMSI, r,Ue X-KOJlHYeCTBO ay,UHTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C CTp1-1nm1<eHHeM N2 3 K 3aHsKe) 11Meer 3a 201 l-2016rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He MeHee 2
ayn11rn ronosoi1 6yxranrepcKoi1 OTYeTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJleHHOM B
U vt4/J coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, He MeHee x KOMnaHHH c ronoBOH BhIPYYKOH He MeHee 20 MJlp,U
jay?-py6. , aKLVHI KOTOphlX KOT11py10TC5! Ha pocc11i1cKoi1 6Hp)l(e, rne X-KOJlHYecTso KOMnaHHH (s COOTBeTCTBHH c HpHJlO)l(eHHeM N2 3 K 3a.SisKe) PyKOBO,UHTenh ay.u11ropcKoi1 ,[(a 1 ,[(a ,[(a
npoBepK11 0611a.naeT e.n11HbIM KBaJl 11cjmKaIJJ!OHHbl M
aTTeCTaTOM ay.n11Topa 11 ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association 111111
Fellow of the association) 1111 11
CPA (Certified Public
Accountant) ;~
5 Onb!T pa6oTbI pyKoso.n11Tem1 v .Ua ,r:i:a ay.n11TOpCKOH npoBepK11 B ay.n11Te He MeHee I 0 11eT
,.......""" 6 B OTHoweH1111 )'1-laCTH11Ka
~ ,r:i:a ,II:a
npoBe,UeH BHeWHl1H KOHTp011b Ka'-leCTBa, no pe3y11bTaTaM .naHHOro KOHTp011.sI Ka'-leCTBa B OTHoweH1111 YYaCTH11Ka He BbIHoc1111ocb npe.nn11caH11e 111111 peweH11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero .ne.siTe11bHOCTl1
7 CTpocpeCCl10Ha11bHa.sI X: He MeHee X: He MeHee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yYaCTHl1Ka 800 500 400 3aCTpaxoBaHa CTpaxOBOH Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee opraHl13al\11H, 11MelOW,eH 600 300 150 .nei1CTBl1Te11bHblH peHTl1Hr
+ Ha.ne)!<H0CTl1 peHTl1HrOBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA » He HmKe «A ++», c o6W,11M 1111Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 CTpaXOBW.11Ka no no1111cy cTpaxoBaH11.si (113 pacYeTa Ha I ro.n), He MeHee X 11 1111MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 no O.UHOMY CTpaxOBOMY c11y'-laf0 He MeHee Y, r .ne X,Y - cyMMa, M11H. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M, yqacTHHKa
- - +---- ' qTO COOTBeTCTByeT ou;eHKe ---~~ __ 6aJIJIOB.
~6?£(
N2 n/n
I
2
3
4
CTp11JIO)l(eH11e 4 K ITporoKony N22 paccMorpemrn H oueHKH 3aRBOK Ha yyacrne B KottKypce
(HaaMeHoBamre yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
DoJJ.Kp11Tep1111 YposeHb
YposeHb 4 YposeHb 3 YposeHb 2 YposeHh I (100 6annos) (60 6anJIOB) (20 6aJIJ10B) (I 6ann)
11MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT no He MeHee 30 He MeHee 15 He MeHee 5 B cny1rne npose)leHHIO B COBOKynHOCTH HecooTBeTCTBH51 He MeHee 5 ay)lHTOB fO)lOBOH Tpe6osaHHRM yposHeH 6yxraJJTepCKOH (cjrnHaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT1leTHOCTH, nO)lfOTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY, aKu.110HeptthIX o6mecTB ( c '
sanIOTOH 6anattca tte Mettee X - \ MJip,n; py6.), ocymecTBJI51IOW.HX ,n;eJITeJibHOCTb B o6nacTH MallIHHOCTpOeHH51,
r.n;e X-samora 6anaHca, MJJP.D. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C CTp11nm1<em1eM N2 3 K 3a~rnKe) l1MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npose.n;emrn B COBOKynttOCTH He MeHee x ay.D.HTOB fO,D.OBOH KOHCOJJH,ll;HposaHHOH qnrnaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH, no.n;rOTOBJJeHHOH B + cooTBeTCTBHH c MC<l>O, opraH113au.11i1, ocymecTBJJRIOIUHX ,n;e51TeJibHOCTb B o6naCTH MaWl1HOCTpOeH11H, r,D.e X-KoJ1111leCTBO ay.D.HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C CTp11JIO)!<ett11eM N2 3 K 3a11sKe)
l1Meer 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay,n;HTa fO)lOBOH 6yxranTepcKOH OT1leTHOCTH, no.n;rOTOBJieHHOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY, He Mettee x KOMnattHH c fO)lOBOH
+ BhIPYYKOH He MeHee 20 MJlp)l py6., aKU.HH KOTOpb!X KOTHPYIOTCR tta pocc11i1cKoH 6Hp)!(e, r.n;e X-KoJ1111leCTBO KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBHH C CTp1rnmKem-ieM N2 3 K 3aHsKe)
PyKoso.n;11TeJih ayn.11ropcKow ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a
npoBepK11 o6na.naeT e,n11HhIM KBaIIHcpHKaI.UifOHHblM arrecTaToM ay.i:u1Topa 11 ceprncp11KaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered •
Certified Accountants - t Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 1rn11 CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
5 OnhIT pa6oThI pyKoBOAHTen.SI )];a )];a )];a ay,lJ.HTOpCKOH npoBepK11 B aymne He MeHee I 0 neT
6 B OTHOWett1111 yiciacTHHKa )];a )];a )];a npoBe,nett BHeWHl1H KOHTpOnh Kat.iecTBa, no pe3ynhTaTaM .n.aHHOro KOHTpOn.H Kat.ieCTBa B
t OTHOWett1111 YYaCTHHKa He BhIHoc11nocb npe,D,n11caH11e 11n11 pewett11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero ,D,eHTenhHOCTH
7 Tipocpecc110HanhHa.S1 X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yt.iaCTHHKa 800 500 400 3aCTpaxoBatta CTpaXOBOH Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He MeHee opramnau.11i1, HMe1-0mei1 600 300 150 .uei1CTBHTeJibHblH peHTHHr tta,ne)f{HOCTH peiinrnroBoro arettTCTBa «3KcnepT-P A» He Hl1)!(e «A++», c 06m11M nJilMJilTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTJil + CTpaXOB111.11Ka no non11cy cTpaxoBaH11.S1 (113 pact.ieTa Ha I ro.D.), He MeHee X 11 nl1Ml1TOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no 0,D,HOMY CTpaxOBOMY cny4al-O tte Mettee Y, r.ne X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKMM o6pa30M, y1:IaCTHMKa KoHKypca
__ 2 ____ ., 1:ITO COOTBeTCTByeT ou;eHKe __ "_2;0 ___ __ 6an:JIOB.
(pacnrn:cppoBKa rro,JJ;mrc11)
N2 n/n
1
2
3
4
no.n.KpHTepHH
// ( 1j(j.
llMeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT no npose.ueHHIO B COBOKynttOCTH He MeHee 5 ay.UHTOB ro.uosoii 6yxraJ1TepcKOH ( cp11HaHCOBOH) OT'1eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJiettttOH B cooTBeTcTBHH c PCEY, aKUHOHepHb!X o6w.ecTB ( c BaJIIOTOH 6anaHca He MeHee X MJlPJJ. py6.), ocyw.ecTBJlHIOUJ,HX .ueHTeJibHOCTb B o6naCTH MallIHHOCTpoemrn, r.ue X-sanJOTa 6anaHca, MJTP.U py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C ITp11nmI<ett11eM N'!! 3 K 3a51BKe) llMeeT 3a 201 l-2016rr. onhIT npose.ueHH51 B COBOKynttOCTH He Mettee x ay.UHTOB ro.uoBOH KOHCOJIHJJ.HpOBattHOH cp1rnaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJTeHHOH B cooTseTCTBHH c MC<l>O, opraH113a~11l1,
ocyw.eCTBJlHIOUJ,HX .ueHTeJlhHOCTb B o6naCTH MaWHHOCTpOeHH.s!, r.ue X-Kon1111ecTBO ay.u11TOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C ITpHJIO)l(eHHeM N2 3 K 3aHBKe) llMeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhlT ay.u11rn ro.uosoii 6yxranTepcKOH OTl!eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJiettHOH B coorneTcrn1111 c PCEY, He
MeHee x KOMnaHHH c rO.UOBOH
BhIPYllKOH He MeHee 20 MJTP.U py6., aK~HH KOTOpblX KOT11py10TC5! Ha pocc11i1cKoi1 611p)J(e, r.ue X-KOJlHl!eCTBO KOMnaHHH ( B COOTBeTCTBHH C ITp11no>KeH11eM N!i 3 K 3a.sisKe)
PyKOBOJ.J.HTenh ayn11TopcKoi1
Yposettb 4 YposeHb 3 ( 100 6aJIJIOB) (60 6aJIJIOB) He MeHee 30 He Mettee 15
He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5
v
He MeHee 5 He MeHee 3
v JJ:a JJ:a
Dp11nmKett11e 4 K DpoTOKOJJY NQ2 paccM01pemu1 H oueHKH 3a51BOK tta yIJacrne B KottKypce
Yposetth Yposettb 2 Yposettb I (20 6aJIJIOB) (1 6ann)
He Mettee 5 B cny11ae HeCOOTBeTCTBHH Tpe6osaHH51MYPOBHeH 2-4
v
He Mettee 4
He MeHee 2
JJ:a
nposepKH o6na.uaeT e.u11ttbIM KBaJI11qmKaUl10HHbIM
aTTeCTaTOM ay,n.HTopa H ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The
~/ Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 11Jrn CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa6oThI pyKoBO.llHTern1 )];a )];a
11,\ / ay,!l.I1TOpCKOH nposepKH B ay.1u1Te tte Mettee 10 neT
6 B OTHowett1111 y'iaCTHHKa 11,a 11,a )];a npoBeAeH BHelllHHH KOHTpOJlb Ka4eCTBa, no pe3yIIbTaTaM
~1 .uaHHOro KOHTpOJl.Sl KaYeCTBa B OTHowett1111 Y4aCTHHKa He l; BblHOCHJlOCb npe.1J.nHCaH11e HJIH peweHHe 0 npHOCTaHOBKe era .1J.eS1TeJlbHOCTH
7 ITpocpecc110HanbttaS1. X: He Mettee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yYaCTHHKa 800 500 400 3acTpaxoBaHa CTpaXOBOH Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee opratt113au,11i1, 11Met0w.ei1 600 300 150 .uei1crn11TeJlbHbIM petlnrnr Ha)J,e)KHOCTH peHTHHfOBOfO v areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-P A» He mrn<e «A++», c 06w.11M Jll1MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBill,HKa no non11cy cTpaxosatt11~ (113 pac4eTa Ha 1 roA), He Mettee X 11 JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O)J,HOMY CTpaXOBOMY CJly4al-O He Mettee Y, rAe X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M, yt-IaCTHHKa KoHKypca
,N°Q
n/n
1
2
3
4
f1pHJIOlKeHHe 4 K ITpOTOKOJIY NQ2 paccMorpemrn H oueHKl1 3allBOK Ha y4acrne B KoHKypce
On:ettoqHhlii JIHCT no KpnTepmo - BaJim}nn~aQHSI H Oilhl yqacTHHKa KOHKypca»
~ k VWv ! . , <DJ1.0. qJieHa KOMHCCI1H) /, vu l ( lJj;j l,l
(ttaHMeHoBaHHe yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
flo.n.Kp11Tep1111 Yposettb YposeBb 4 YpoBeHb 3 YpoBeHh 2 YpoBeHb I
(100 6a;rnos) (60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6aJIJ10B) (1 6aJin) HMeeT 3a 201 l-2016rr. om1T no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cny1-iae npose.n.eHHIO B COBOKYOHOCTl1 HeCOOTBeTCTBHll He Mettee 5 ay.n.11TOB fO,D.OBOH Tpe6oBaHHllMYPOBHeH 6yxraJITepcKOH ( cp11HaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT'-!eTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJ1eHttOH B cooTBeTcTB1111 c PCEY,
aKU.HOHepttbIX o6w.ecTB ( c v BaJIIOTOH 6aJiaHca He Mettee x MJIP.D. py6.), ocyuWCTBJUIIOW.HX .n.esnenbttOCTb B 06nacT11 MalllHHOCTpOettHH,
r.n.e X-BaJIJOTa 6aJiattca, MJIP.D. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBHH C TIPlrnm1<ett11eM ,N°Q 3 K 3a.llBKe) HMeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npose.n.ettHll B COBOKynHOCTl1 He Mettee x ay.n.11TOB f0,1J.OBOH KOHCOJ111.D.11pOBaHHOH cp1rnaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTl1, no.n.roTOBJ1eHHOH B v cooTBeTCTB1111 c MC<l>O, oprattH3aU.HH, ocyw.ecTsnsi:JOm11x .n.e.siTeJlbHOCTb B 06nacn1 MaWHHOCTpOeHHH, r.n.e X-Kon111.JeCTBO ay.n.11TOB (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Tip1rnm1<ett11eM ,N°Q 3 K 3a.sisKe)
11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. om1T He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 aymna ro.n.osoi1 6yxraJITepcKoi1
OT4eTttOCTH, no.n.roTOBJlettHOH B coorneTCTB1111 c PCEY, He
v Mettee x KOMnattHH c fO}J.OBOH
Bb1py1.JKOH He Mettee 20 MJTP.ll. py6., aKU,HH KOTOpblX KOTHp)'IOTCll Ha pocCHHCKOH 611p:>Ke, r.n.e X-KOJ1HYeCTBO KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C fipirnmI<ett11eM ,N°Q 3 K 3a.llBKe)
PyKOBO.D.HTeJlb ay.n.11TOPCKOH ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a
5
6
7
npoBepKH o6naJJ,aeT eJJ,HHhIM KBaJil1cPl1Kau110HHblM arrecTaToM ay,D.HTOpa 11 ceprncjrnKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association HJlH Fellow of the association) mm CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
OnhIT pa6oThI pyKOBOAHTem1 ay)J,HTOpCKOH nposepKH B ay;:u-ne tte Mettee 10 neT
B OTHornett1111 yYaCTttHKa npoBe,D.eH BHeWHHH KOHTpOJlh KaLJeCTBa, no pe3yJlhTaTaM ,D.aHHOro KOHTpom1 KaqecTBa B
OTH0111em111 YqacTHHKa He BhlHOCHJlOCh npeJJ,n11camrn HJlH pewett11e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero )J,e51TeJ1bHOCTH
Ilpocpecc11ottanhtta5! OTBeTCTBeHttOCTb yLJaCTttHKa 3aCTpaxoBaHa CTpaXOBOH opraHH3aUHH, HMeKH.QeH .ueiilCTBI1TeJlbHblH peHTJ.rnr
Ha,D.e/I<HOCTH peHTHHfOBOfO areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He mrn<e «A++», c 06m11M JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBI.QHKa no nOJlHCY cTpaxoBaHl151 (113 pacYeTa Ha 1 roJJ.), He Mettee X 11 JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O)J,ttOMY CTpaxoBOMY cnyLJalO He Mettee Y, rAe X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
v
,[la
v ,[la
l!
X: He Mettee 800 Y: He Mettee 600
l!
,[la
,[la
X: He Mettee 500 Y: He Mettee 300
TaKHM o6pa30M, 3a.HBKe Y'claCTHliKa KottKypca
T 51 ypoBeHb _ __ 4_1
__ c;;r:;T OUOHKO (pacurn:cppoBKa no,1:i;irnc11)
,[la
,[la
X: He Mettee 400 Y: He Mettee 150
ru ~ 6aJIJIOB. ---- ---
M! n/n
1
2
3
4
ITp11JJO)Kemie 4 K ITporoKony N22 paccMorpemrn H oueHKH 33ilBOK Ha yyacrtte B KottKypce
Oueuoqublii JIHCT no KpttTeptt10 ~~JIH<lmrau:uH " OllhIT yqacTHUKa KOHKypca»
( /k-+A-- (!:,1 \S J~'A , L_ ooc
(HaHMeHoBamre yqacTHH'I\' KoHKypca)
f10.L\Kp11Tep1111 YposeHb
YposeHb 4 Yposettb 3 Yposettb 2 Yposettb 1 (100 6annos) ( 60 6annos) (20 6annos) ( 1 6ann)
l1MeeT 3a 2011-20 I 6rr, onb!T no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cnyYae np0Be)J,em110 B COBOKYTIHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBl151 He MeHee 5 ay)J,HTOB ro)J,OBOH Tpe6osaHl1HM ypoBHeH 6yxranTepCKOH ( cp11ttattCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTl1, TIO)J,fOTOBJlettttOH B cooTBeTcTB1111 c PCEY, aKu,11otteptthIX o6wecTB ( c Ban10Toi1 6anattca He Mettee X Mnp.L\ py6 .), ocywecTBJUIEOlilHX )J,e51TeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTl1 M3Wl1HOCTpOeHl151, r)J,e X-samoTa 6anattca, MJlP.L\ py6. (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Tip11no)l{ett11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
( l1MeeT 332011-2016rr. OTibIT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe)J,eHl151 B COBOKYTIHOCTl1 He Mettee x ay)J,HTOB ro)J,OBOH KOHCOJ111)J,11pOB3HHOH cp11HaHCOBOH OTLJeTHOCTl1, TIO)J,fOTOBJleHHOH B i;ooTBeTcTs1111 c MC<l>O, opratt113aUHi1, ocyw.ecTBJ15!10W.HX )J,e51TeJlbHOCTb B o6naCTl1 MaWHHOCTpoeHHH, r)J,e X-Kon114ecTBO ay.L\HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Tip11nm1<eH11eM N2 3 K 3a51BKe) l1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onhIT He MeHee 5 He MeHee 3 He MeHee 2 ay)J,HTa fO)J,OBOH 6yxranTepCKOH OTLJeTHOCTH, TIO)J,fOTOBJleHHOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY, tte MeHee x KOMTI3Hl1H c ro)J,OBOH Bbrpy4KOH He Mettee 20 MJJP.L\ py6. , 3KL(l111 KOTOpblX KOT11py10TCH Ha pocc11i1CKOH 611p)l{e, r)le X-Kon11LJeCTBO KOMnatt11i1 (B COOTBeTCTBHl1 C l1p11nm1<eH11eM N2 3 K 3aHBKe)
Py1<0BO)J,11TeJTh ay,lJ,11TopCKoi1 ):(a ):(a ):(a
nposepKH o6na,JJ,aeT e)J.HHbIM KBan11cp11Ka~HOHHblM
arrecTaTOM ay.UHTOpa H ceprncpHKaToM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -
Member of the association 11m1 Fellow of the association) 11JT11
CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa6oTbI pyKOBO.llHTem1 )J,a )J,a )J,a ay.u11TopCKOH nposepKH B ay.u11Te He MeHee I 0 neT
6 B OTHoweHHH y<JaCTHHKa )J,a )J,a )J,a npose.ueH BHeWHHH KOHTpOJTb Ka<JeCTBa, no pe3yJTbTaTaM .uaHHOro KOHTpOI151 Ka4eCTBa B OTHoweHHH Y4aCTHHKa He BbIHOCHJlOCb npe.un11caH11e 11Jll1 peweHHe o npHOCTaHOBKe ero ,JJ,e51TeJlbHOCTH
7 ITpocpeccHoHaJlbHa51 X: He MeHee X: He MeHee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y<JaCTHHKa 800 500 400 3aCTpaxosaHacTpaxosoi1 Y: He MeHee Y: He Mettee Y: He MeHee opraH113a~11i1, 11Me10w,ei1 600 300 150 .uei1CTBHTeJlbHblH pei1T11Hr Ha,lJ,e)l(HQCTH peHTHHroBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He Hl-DI<e «A++», c 06w,11M JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBUJ,HKa no nOJTHCY CTpaXOB8HH51 (H3 pac<JeTa Ha 1 ro,D,), He Mettee X 11
0 JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no 0,lJ,HOMY CTpaxoBOMY cny'-lalO He Mettee Y, r,JJ,e X,Y - cyMMa, MITH. py6.
(no.n: I
(pacumcppoBKa rro,n:rrncn)
0
NQ n/n
1
2
3
4
11p11JIO)KeHJ.!e 4 K ITporoKony NQ2 paccMorpemrn H
ou.eHKl1 3airnoK Ha y4acrne B KottKypce
c 'I\ If) (<D.H.O. qneHa KOMHCCHH) \) U 0 f-v LLl..{ \Lo\-\
(HaHMeHOBamre yqacTHHKa KoHKypca)
flo.n.Kp11TepHH YposeHh YposeHh 4 Yposetth 3 Yposetth 2 Yposetth 1
(100 6arrnos) (60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6aJIJ10B) ( 1 6a.rrn) 11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhlT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Menee 5 B cny4ae npose.n.emuo B COBOKynHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBHil He Mettee 5 ay.n.HTOB ro,n:OBOH Tpe6osaHHilMYPOBHeH 6yxranTepCKOH ( qrnttaHCOBOH) 2-4 OT4eTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJieHHOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY,
aKUHOHepHhIX o6mecTB ( c + BaJIJOTOH 6anattca He Mettee X MJIP.D. py6 .), ocymecTBJiillOI.UHX ,ne.s!TeJihHOCTh B o6naCTl1 MallmHOCTpOeHH.il, rJJ.e X-sanJOTa 6anattca, MJIP.D. py6. (s COOTBeTCTBl111 c flpm1m1<eHHeM N2 3 K 3asrnKe) 11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onhlT He Mettee 6 He Mettee 5 He Mettee 4 npose.n.ettH.il B COBOKynHOCHI He Mettee X ay.n.HTOB ro.nosoti KOHCOJIH.D.HpOBaHHOH qnrnaHCOBOH OTlleTHOCTH, nO}l,fOTOBJiettttOH B coorneTCTBHH c MC<l>O,
+ opratt113au,11l1, ocymecTBJISIJOI.UHX .n.e11TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTl1 MalllHHOCTpoeHlHI, r}l,e X-KOJltt4eCTBO ay,n11TOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Tip1rnmKett11eM NQ 3 K 3asisKe)
11MeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2
ay.n.11rn ro.n.osoti 6yxranTepcKo11 OT4eTttOCTl1, nO}l,fOTOBJieHttOH B coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, tte Mettee x KOMnaHHH c ro,noBOH BhIPY4KOH He Mettee 20 MJIPJJ.
-f-py6., aKl.VIH KOTOpblX KOT11py10TC.il Ha pOCCHHCKOH 6Hp)J(e, rJJ.e X-KOJ1H4eCTBO KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBl111 C Tip1111m1<em1eM N2 3 K 3asrnKe) PyKOBOJJ.HTeJib ayJJ.HTOPCKOH ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a
..
npoBepK11 o6nanaeT en11HhIM KBaJUtqrnKaUHOHHbIM
arrecTaToM ayn11Topa 11 ceprncp11KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -
·+-Member of the association HJIH Fellow of the association) 11n11 CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
s OnbIT pa6oTbl pyKoBOJlHTeJISI ,n:a ,n:a ,n:a ay}lHTOpCKOH nposepK11 B t ay;:une He Mettee I 0 neT
6 B OTttoweH1111 y 1-rncTtt11Ka ,n:a ,n:a ,n:a npoBe)l,eH BHellJHl1H KOHTpOJib Ka'-leCTBa, no pe3ynhTaTaM )J.aHHOro KOHTpOJISI Ka4eCTBa B
0Tttornett1111 YqacTHHKa He t BblHOCHJIOCb npenn11catt11e HJil1 pewett11e o np11ocTattOBKe ero }leHTeJibttOCTl1
7 Tipocpecc110Ha.rihHaH X: He MeHee X: He Mettee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb yqacTHHKa 800 500 400 3acTpaxosaHa cTpaxosoti Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He MeHee opram13au,11ti, HMeIOw.eii 600 300 150 .neHCTBHTeJlbHblH pet:mrnr ttane)KHOCTH peMnrnrosoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He
+ HmI<e «A++», c 06w.11M Jll1MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBll.(11Ka no non11cy cTpaxosattHH (113 pacYeTa Ha I rop,), He MeHee X 11 JIHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O}lHOMY CTpaXOBOMY cnyqaJO He Mettee Y, r,ll,e X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
TaKHM 06pa30M, yqacTHHKa KoHKypca
( ) 6aJ1JIOB.
(rro.z:i:irncb qneHa KOMHCCHH) (pacrnmppoBKa no
(J
N!! n/n
l
2
3
4
Tip11JIO)l(eH11e 4 K ITporoKony NQ2 paccMorpemrn 11 oueHKH 3al!BOK Ha yqacT11e a KoHKypce
OueuoqnhIH JIHCT no KpHTepmo
«KBaJiry;>HKaUHH" OilblT yqaCTHHKa KOH, pca»
b ~ K-O \c- cJ< fT e; Ve ~ b ;i -u7 c ~ c:. f!o ~ t, (___
ODo (HaHMeHoBamrn yqacTHHKa Kom(
IT0.n.Kp11Tep1111 YpoaeHb YpoaeHb 4 Ypoaettb 3 Ypoaettb 2 Ypoaettb 1
(100 6aJIJlOB) (60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6aJIJIOB) (l 6rurn) HMeer 3a 2011-2016rr. onbIT no He Mettee 30 He Mettee 15 He Mettee 5 B cny•rne npose.n.emno B COBOKynttOCTH tteCOOTBeTCTBH.ll He Mettee 5 ay,ll,HTOB ro,ll,OBOH Tpe6oBaHH.l!MypoBHeH 6yxraJITepCKOH ( cp1rnaHCOBOi1) 2-4 OTt:feTHOCTH, no,nroTOBJieHHOM B cooTBeTCTBHH c PCEY, aKUHOHepHbIX o6mecTB ( c BaJIJOTOH 6aJiattca He Mettee X MJip,n py6.), ocymecTBJI.l!J01UHX ,ll,e.l!TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTl1 MaWHHOCTpOettH.ll, r.n.e X-BaJIJOTa 6aJiattca, MJIP.11. py6. (B COOTBeTCTBim c IlpHJim1<em1eM NQ 3 K 3a.l!BI<e) HMeer 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. onbIT He Mettee 6 He MeHee 5 He Mettee 4 npoBe,ll,eHH.ll B COBOKYOHOCTH He
i Mettee X ay.n.11TOB ro.n.osoi1 KOHCOJil1,ll,11pOBaHHOH qrnHaHCOBOH OT4eTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJieHttOH B cooTBeTCTBHH c MC<t>O, op ratt 113aUH ti, ocymecTBJI.l!IOIUHX ,ll,e.l!TeJibHOCTb B o6JiaCTH MaWJ1HOCTpoeHl1.ll, r.n.e X-Kon11Y:eCTBO ay.n.HTOB (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Ilpm1m1<ett11eM NQ 3 K 3a.sisKe)
HMeeT 3a 2011-2016rr. OOblT He Mettee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay.n.11rn ro.n.osoi1 6yxraJITepcKoi1 OTY:eTHOCTH, no.n.roTOBJiettHOH B cooTBeTCTB1111 c PCEY, He Mettee x KOMnaHHH c fO,ll,OBOH BblPYYKOH He Mettee 20 MJip,ll, py6., aKUHH KOTOpblX KOTHPYJOTC.ll Ha poccHi1cKoi1 6I-1p)!(e,
r.n.e X-KOJIH4ecTso KOMnaHHH (B COOTBeTCTBHH C Ilp1rnQ)1<ett11eM N!! 3 K 3a.l!BKe)
Py1<oso.n.11TeJib ay.n.11Topc1<oi1 ,L(a ,L(a ,L(a
._,
nposepK11 o6na.uaeT e.u11HbIM KBaJIJilQJI1KaI(HOHHbIM
arrecrnToM aymnopa H ceprncp11KaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants -Member of the association mrn Fellow of the association) :mrn CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
~
5 OnbIT pa6oThl pyKOBO.UHTern1 (!) ,na ,na ay.n11TopCKOH npoBepK11 B ay.n11Te He Mettee 10 neT
~
6 B oTHOlllettHH yl.!aCTtt11Ka (CV ,na ,na npose.nett BttelllttHi1 KOttTponh
c-Kal.!eCTBa, no pe3ynhTaTaM .nattHoro KOttTpOJlH Ka'leCTBa B OTHOlllett1111 YYacTtt11Ka He Bb!HOCl1Jl0Cb npe.JJ,nHCaHHe Ji!JlH pewett11e o npttocTattOBKe ero ,[(eHTeJlbHOCTH
7 Tipocpecc11ottanhttaH X: He MeHee X: He Mettee X: He Mettee OTBeTCTBettHOCTb yYaCTtt11Ka 800 500 400 3aCTpaxosatta CTpaXOBOH Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee Y: He Mettee opramnautti1, ttMeIOmei1 600 300 150 )J.eHCTBHTeJlbHbIH peHTHHr Ha.JJ.e)lrnocn1 petinrnroBoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He
1 Hl1)1(e «A++», c 06m11M Jl11MHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaXOBll(HKa no noJmcy cTpaxosaHHH (H3 pacYeTa Ha I roA), He Mettee X 11
JlHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no 0.llHOMY CTpaxoBOMY CJly'lalO He Mettee Y, r.ne X,Y - cyMMa, MJlH. py6.
KoHKypca
T OI(eHKe 6amIOB. -------
(nO,llJIHCb ~rneHa KOMHCCHH)
N!! n / n
1
2
3
4
CTp1rno)l(eH11e 4 K Opormmny NQ2 paccMoTpemrn 11 oueHKH 3asrnoK Ha Y'JaCT11e B KottKypce
(tta11MeHoB'a~11e yqacTHHKa KottKypca)
Tio.uKpHTepHH YpoBeHb
YposeHb 4 YpoBeHb 3 YpoBeHb 2 Yposettb 1 (100 6aJIJIOB) (60 6aJIJIOB) (20 6aJIJTOB) (1 6aJIJI)
l1MeeT 3a 201 l-2016rr. onhIT no He Mettee 30 He MeHee 15 He Mettee 5 B cnr iae
npoae.uemuo B COBOKYOHOCTH HeCOOTBeTCTBH.sI
He Mettee 5 ay.u11TOB ro,UOBOH Tpe6oBaHH.sIMypoBttei1
6yxraJITepcKOH ( qnrnaHCOBOH) 2-4 OTY:eTHOCTH, no.uroTOBJieHHOH B
coOTBeTCTBHH c PCEY,
aKUHOHepttbIX o6meCTB ( c
+ BaJIIOTOH 6anaHca tte Mettee X MJIPA py6. ), ocymecTBJl.sIIOI..U.HX
)J,e.siTeJibHOCTb B 06nacn1
MaWHttOCTpoemrn,
r)J,e X-BaJIIOTa 6anaHca, MJIP.U
py6.
(B COOTBeTCTBHH C
Tip11JI0)1<ett11eM N!! 3 K 3a.sisKe)
l1MeeT 3a 2011-20 l 6rr. OObIT He MeHee 6 He MeHee 5 He Mettee 4 npoae.ueHH.sI B COBOKYOHOCTH He
Mettee x ay.UHTOB rO)J,OBOH KOHCOJIH,ll,HpOBaHHOH
cpHHaHCOBOH OTY:eTHOCTH,
OO)J.rOTOBJieHHOH B + coorneTCTBHH c MC<DO,
opraHH3aU,HH,
ocymeCTBJI.sIJOI..U.HX
,ll,e.sITeJibHOCTb B o6naCTH
MaUJHHOCTpoeHml,
r)J,e X-KOJIH<J:eCTBO ay.UHTOB
(B COOTBeTCTBHH C
Tip11nmKett11eM N!! 3 K 3asrnKe)
l1MeeT Ja 201 l-2016rr. om1T He MeHee 5 He Mettee 3 He Mettee 2 ay.u11rn rO)J,OBOH 6yxranTepcKOH
OT<J:eTHOCTH, OO)J.rOTOBJieHHOH B
coorneTCTBHH c PCEY, tte
Mettee x KOMna1mi1 c fO.UOBOH
BblPY<J:KOH He Mettee 20 MJIPA
+ py6 ., aKUHH KOTOpblX
KOT11pyIOTC.si tta pocc11i1cKoi1
6Hp)Ke,
r)J.e X-KonwrncTBO KOMnaHHH
(B COOTBeTCTBHH C
Tip11nmI<eH11eM M> 3 I< 3aSIBKe)
PyKoBO.ll.HTeJih ay.u11TopcKoi1 ,[(a ,[(a ,[(a
nposepKM o6na.uaeT e,UHHbIM KBaJTHqrnKal(HOHHblM
arrecTaToM ay.u11Topa H cepTHQJHKaTOM ACCA (The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants - + Member of the association 11n11 Fellow of the association) 11n11 CPA (Certified Public
Accountant)
5 OnbIT pa60TbI pyKOBO.UMTem1 _na _na _na ay,UHTOpCKOH nposepKH B ·t ay.u11Te He MeHee 10 neT
6 B OTttowemrn y1.rncTHHKa ,z::i:a ,z::i:a )];a npose.ueH BHeWHHH KOHTpOJJb Katiecrna, no pe3yJJbTaTaM ,[l,aHHOro KOHTpOJ151 Ka'leCTBa B
+ OTHoweH1111 Y'!aCTHHKa He BbIHOCHJlOCb npe.urr11caH11e HJ!H pewem1e o np11ocTaHOBKe ero ,Ue51TeJlbHOCTH
7 Dpocpecc11ottanbHa5! X: He MeHee X: He Mettee X: He MeHee OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb y'laCTHHKa 800 500 400 3aCTPaXOBaHa CTpaXOBOH Y: He MeHee Y: He MeHee Y: He Mettee opraHH3aUHH, MMeIOmeii 600 300 150 .uetiCTBHTeJlbHblH peMTHHr Ha.ue:>I<HOCTH peHTHHroaoro areHTCTBa «3KcnepT-PA» He HH)l(e «A++», c o6IUHM JlHMMTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH CTpaxOBillHKa no rron11cy cTpaxosaHH51 (H3 pac'leTa Ha + I ro.D.), He Mettee X H JIHMHTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH no O,ll,HOMY CTpaxoBOMY cny'lalO He MeHee Y, r.ue X,Y - cyMMa, MJJH. py6.
TaKHM o6pa30M, KottKypca ODO rc_(z A j~c.)
rrpRCBairnaeTCH ypoBeHb ----='---- Yi T ou;eHKe - - --'l=-) __ 6aJIJIOB.
(nO.UTIHCb qrreHa KOMHCcm1)