iirnzcniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... ·...

100
~y~nad~~~"lun~~~~~awan~~3~a~~toll"~aY a Iwni.ri~nn:~Gop~y~u~tni.rr~flanaiu~uiu wani.rimsi:JiGa;a$$uI.a"K~$nw& ttnwn~iu~uiusii~ 7 kiolfld - X MUIU~~J +ILQ~U S.D. Mulflo'9 dlci?u~dfJ~iU~ula~~ (Standard Deviation) t PP u M~IU~'J di ~naoi~^a\l t - test F PP u M%Jlso'9 61 ~nm0-1~89 F - test MUIU~~J ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ M J R ~ ~ ' Y ~ T : ~ ~ ] .-.,-.d .05 aanisi~~ntHh'oya nii?inn:&Goyaqnrm~u o~smuuo~Cnbuw CnAnwaiB?4nw luci~n'n 5nsi6SuinnCn n~araiQ~dnwi rvani14nwi 7 maad 1 iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun (Check list) RO~~~UL~(~?~UT~~D~U~I~~~WI d~z~nnisi wclnl18nwuclroi~w(dnn.ro~ w UI mo~d 2 iinnz6qmm~u oismruuo~Cninlw Cnilnwoiir+inw ~~naansiKs ~nniin n.ruoiQaAnwi ~uani.rAnwi 7 &un?iu~uw^a.aou n3iudoi%d n-~iuii~~n: n1.r d.rztso"slua:ni~fi.re~flsuiCs moud 3 3 wam.r5~nnefi~lrssuiiu~lnaiu~~~nsii~uo~?mm~ qismsuuo~lint3au d d U ULI Cninw? oi.aawnwia~naansiKu~nnCn n~uoi!a4n~.7 ~uani.r?inwi 7 4iiiwntiliu~z6uni~ anw d.reinniai ueni.rAnwi iia:oi!w[dnnsor ~ ~ J J ~ U ~ R I ~ M ~ ~ R ~ A t -test uar F - test nanoun?iuuandi~nsd~atlI.a"?"animo9 Scheffe'

Upload: others

Post on 19-May-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

~ y ~ n a d ~ ~ ~ " l u n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a w a n ~ ~ 3 ~ a ~ ~ t o l l " ~ a Y a

Iwni.r i~nn:~Gop~y~u~tni .rr~f lanaiu~uiu wani.rimsi:JiGa;a$$uI.a"K~$nw&

t t n w n ~ i u ~ u i u s i i ~ 7 k i o l f l d - X M U I U ~ ~ J + I L Q ~ U

S.D. Mulflo'9 d l c i ? u ~ d f J ~ i U ~ u l a ~ ~ (Standard Deviation)

t P P u

M ~ I U ~ ' J d i ~ n a o i ~ ^ a \ l t - test

F P P u

M%Jlso'9 61 ~ n m 0 - 1 ~ 8 9 F - test M U I U ~ ~ J ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ M J R ~ ~ ' Y ~ T : ~ ~ ] .-.,-.d .05

aan is i~~n tHh 'oya

nii?inn:&Goyaqnrm~u o ~ s m u u o ~ C n b u w CnAnwaiB?4nw luci~n'n 5nsi6SuinnCn n~ara iQ~dnwi rvani14nwi 7

maad 1 i i R n z C n i w n i w u o ~ ~ a o ~ l ~ ~ u ~ ~ o u n i u ~ ~ u ~ ~ u u a ~ ~ ~ ) ~ o u n ~ n i ~

(Check list) R O ~ ~ ~ U L ~ ( ~ ? ~ U T ~ ~ D ~ U ~ I ~ ~ ~ W I d ~ z ~ n n i s i wclnl18nwuclroi~w(dnn.ro~ w U I m o ~ d 2 i i n n z 6 q m m ~ u oismruuo~Cninlw Cnilnwoiir+inw ~ ~ n a a n s i K s

~nn i in n.ruoiQaAnwi ~uani.rAnwi 7 &un?iu~uw^a.aou n3iudoi%d n - ~ i u i i ~ ~ n : n1.r d.rztso"slua:ni~fi.re~flsuiCs

moud 3 3 wam.r5~nnefi~lrssuiiu~lnaiu~~~nsii~uo~?mm~ qismsuuo~lint3au d d U U L I Cninw? oi.aawnwia~naansiKu~nnCn n~uoi!a4n~.7 ~uani.r?inwi 7 4iiiwntiliu~z6uni~

a n w d.reinniai ueni.rAnwi iia:oi!w[dnnsor ~ ~ J J ~ U ~ R I ~ M ~ ~ R ~ A t -test uar F - test

nanoun?iuuandi~nsd~atlI.a"?"animo9 Scheffe'

Page 2: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n a i n J 3 wuii 1:siunisinwiu~~ui7issw rininanwio~lus:siudrmiwGu1J"ms

'ilIl$w 157 RW i % ~ l q ~ < a ~ ~ f l t 42.5 U ~ ~ ~ S : ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ I R Q L I C ~ I ? " I I I Q W ~ U ~ ~ 212 ?IF~L!?W

Tuaflfl: 57.5

P i n a i n J 4 wuii rin fiow rininw6sduds:~nni"11idi~qmm~n~~u 266 nu

Tislrfluiatln=: 72.1 ds:~nn5"aiwif imnrn 96 nu iim~flu<atln: 26 ua:ds:~nn'im

flMnTTU 7 flM k l l ~ M < ~ t l n t 1.9

Page 3: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 4: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 5: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinnina 8 wu<i qmmu ~?oanu~'iwn?iudncin6~oaotb"n~h rindnlti

luniwnuo$usm'uuin ~dn~oisnrinau'owui1 IuAoa~Au?<uni~uo~~~iaou Pin

~ ~ o u n n i r i i ~ ~ a u ~ n i s ~ ~ ~ u ~ o ~ l u s : K u d i u n n i ~ ci?uao~ou A rl q ot,Jlu~:n'uainynu*n

Page 6: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

M' A a 2. ~finaiudau~~'7o~ounlnomfnu

3. L B U ~ O ~ - ~ L J ~ ~ L M ' ~ O $ W

4. Ifinaiudau~~'7o~iow 7 niunaiumuim

5. ~ u ~ n $ ~ J l l i k n i u undi&Iolunisrii~iu

~dodausau

6. I~naiuiauiioLiluo~ii~i~nnPd +inuiKu

Cafionssu

7. l~naiuTlau~~8auri~Gn sePT~~a:nu.ari

8. . a a ~ ~ l j ~ i [ u A ~ ~ a ~ i i ~ 7 IGL~DUO~LBIIO 9. i~uu~ l fo in6a~m~~od~ania

Page 7: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~ k Y orlimisu rinanw

luniw nuoilws-Kudiunnir ~do t is i~ ru imstwu~ i l u d o ~ d e ~ ~ u n i ~ d s l o u ~ ~ ~ u I

&uordorl$1or~ul~?%riuI6ai~c1;ua nis i lmi inn~ i r isa~df i id~~a~r~? ' nian"u~3u ~ d ~~'looinni3l%iislu~~tiin:?'u do&i~yqdnsdn13dnwddi~ilu ~~nrni3Fioi.rmia dir n ~ t Z u a r i o u < m ^ ~ u l d o i ~ ~ ~ r d i ~ q Gni~d~Uao(lu~:(iUuin

~

qrunnu ~ ~ o n s r u u a ~ C n ~ s u Cninwi

61~n"ld~t~$Gl

1. <auda~ i~qd~a iuh* . , ~ 1 i I ~ ~ ~ u 6 u ~ i u I%da:bu.nulk

2. LEY ~:~u~~ul3"iun:ii,a

3. a : ~ i f i u d ~ ~ ~ a a i n n i s ~ % d s ~ d i i ~ ~ d ~ i n n ~ i n i ~

4. r ? l t l M 6 ~ ~ r W ~ i ) ~ n l ~ ~ l ~ l U ~ 6 L ~ E I ~ ~ U L M G ~ )

$Jnn~ot

5. aoudalw$tuatdit q idal%ri?u&

6. a : ~ E u ~ ~ l r j ~ ~ d r h d ~ = : b s ~ u " b ~ akt8nnis

findfiu%i 7. F ~ : ~ O U L M ~ ~ J Y ~ J L ~ ~ ~ ~ I % Y ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ " L % J I M I ~

oirauo 8. scqm~onZi~jo1dfiid~qnirI3"

9. ~n"u~~udadosinni3I%ii LIIMLL~~:?'~ dodo?^ qdn~dnisinwdditf~u

10. a :6o i . rmia~ i tn:~Zu~r iouKm~9s~a~r~ ar

did 3 i an u

- x

3.34

3.42

2.78

3.09

3.09

3.37

3.69

4.20

3.67

4.09

3.47

S.D.

0.96

1.10

1.27

1.27

1.10

1.1 1

0.93

1.03

0.95

0.90

0.65

s:<unis

doll:

d l~na l9

d l~na l9

~ I M ~ W I J

~ I M ~ W I J

d i ~ n a i t

diunait

uin

uin

uin

uin

~ I M ~ F J I J

Page 8: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

p a n u jrsmmuatu'nirsu u'nlnwi Kiuni.si.s:~!uu?M"u

I. ~ i ~ i u l u u i ~ i I ~ ~ w d m ; ~ a u 2. d ~ ~ " n ~ l ~ ~ d l ~ ~ n n ' o ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ 1 ~ ~

3. o:~iiu~n~a~ija~dn.sm"IGa~lu~niw~~uiau~~~ LI ~ I ~ u n ~ i u ~ n n t ~

u d d w 4. ~ ~ U ~ J I M ~ ~ I U M W ~ ~ ~ Y ~ ~ ~ " I I E ) L I

5. ~ I J I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ I ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ ~ u ~ B ~ ~ ~ J

l o A I ~ J 6. ~IMMGJJ~O ~ l n l f 1 ~ ~ 7 ~ f l l ~ f l l f l ~ ~ f l ~ b ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ f l ~ ? "

CI

7. ~ ~ ~ L ~ L I U L ~ R L ~ ~ U R I I U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ ~ ' ~ J H ~ ~ ~

8. ~ a ~ i m a i u ~ a u m a u ~ u n i ~ Z & ~ " u a ~ ~ a u ~ a u

9. % o ~ ~ f l ~ " i i ~ c i l 1 ~ 1 ~ 8 : ~ n " i ~ M%WUUJM'~J~~UU a LI lo. ~ 5 1 u n n i u n p o n o ~ ~ w ~ ~ d s i u w i ~ u : ~ ~ n u u

rais

- X

2.79

4.07

4.18

4.28

3.99

3.63

4.12

4.12

2.15

1.14

3.75

S.D.

1.08

0.78

0.78

0.78

0.83

0.88

0.82

0.77

1.25

0.90

0.44

3zCuni3 d8u.l

d iunni~ u i n

u i n in

u i n u i n u i n u i n l.kl u u i n u in

Page 9: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 10: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

qmrssu -aistissuudtCnfisu Cngnwi

Giunaiur"LIinaau

1. ~ 4 l i l l " s f l r d l ~ $ ? l ~ 4 ~ " ~ ~ ~

2. rn11-a1i~a~u~1undlGT"uuau~u1~

3. mui~ni~~iu~6n"uniu~ivlun u

4. ?u%u~iu~~6 j?6a~~ i~~~1 ,~a~6 i ln iu~ iv lun

5. ~ ~ i l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n l d i ] J 7 ~ ~ ~ 6 r " ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 1 ~ 1 ~

~fincinwnin

6. n a d a n ~ u ~ i u ~ ~ i i ~ a ~ ~ ~ u a

7. ~ c ~ ~ I u ~ T : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Y M Z U ~ I T ~ S I J I U ~ ~ ~ ~ T " L I uauvluis119"1~-alns~?a

d 8. ~ f i d ~ u l ~ % u ~ ~ ~ $ d n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l d d i ] c f ~ . a " L d i ]

~findip~'nevli s

9. wiouun%~iu6irnwainI~"gn60~

10. f i 1 3 7 ~ 6 i i ~ 7 L ~ B & ~ ~ U ~ ~ ' I H U & I ~ ? U ~ U L E I J ..I

L Q ~ U

z:Cu dm. s:Ku d ? ~ . t - value

-1.947

-0.601

-0.232

-1.085

-0.580

-1.393

-0.235

-0.124

-2.169*

0.898

-1.232

- x

3.99

4.11

4.18

4.1 0

3.66

4.06

4.05

3.55

3.91

4.04

3.97

- x

4.14

4.17

4.20

4.1 9

3.73

4.18

4.07

3.57

4.09

3.97

4.03

Sig.

.052

.548

.817

.279

.562

.I65

.815

.go1

.031

.370

.219

S.D.

0.78

0.85

0.77

0.86

1.11

0.85

0.81

0.88

0.82

0.84

0.52

S.D.

0.73

0.76

0.72

0.76

1.18

0.82

0.79

0.93

0.79

0.81

0.48

Page 11: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o l n n m c 14 w u i ~ p m s u ~ t e m s u h u n a i u ~ o ~ n r ~ ' ua~cinAeu ~ n 4 n w t h s=6udsen1~Jsu'ni?aIBw ~~nts:n'uds:nl~~su'ns?'IIiiiw~u~~ ~ur iwsau lJunnd~~5w ~ d o f i o i s ~ m s ~ o w u i ~ ~ m u otsasruuotrimieu rin~nw1~~s=:6uds=:ni~1Js1J'ns5'111~w

t: .=.-A u~rsrR'udsrnm~~sY'61~?m~w'IIu~~ u ~ n h ~ % o d i ~ ~ & h < q n i ~ m n n s r ~ u .05 l u d o ~ I

t: ~i(oa5u nlsua~~d~nauomdau~asJiu~iu"o~au u ~ = : n i s u ~ ~ e w n s ~ n ~ u ~ a s J ~ d ~ i ~ ~ u n wanwu wu41\J~~nndianUW

Page 12: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinAina 15 wuii qamsu oismsu~iumaiu~i(~~rva:uoaCn~?LIU CninwirJ t s:~uds:niw%s~ai5~i~w ~~a:s:Kuds:niwQe~s5'1113wnu~~ luniwnu~~mndiaCuadi~i

- - A Csk~~n i tmnn lm<u 0.5 bsqrumu oismsuuot Cn$nws:n'udsmiwGsY"a~5%13w t a u ~ a ~tniiqrumsu oiomsuuotCn~ini3su s:Guds:niwQelias5ni~w ~dorioimcmo~a

wu~iqru~rsu aismsuuat Cnbsu CnGnw ~as:<udscniwGtr1~"as5ni~w ~~a:s:<u -ad dnniwGsli~i5n3w~uga ~ ~ a n s i i a n i t o d i ~ i ~ h ~ n i ~ ~ n m n s : ~ ~ 0.5 ludotr~san'u

t d m U U I naiu~lulodo:d=l?a~~~o$u nisl~ma~u~auiia~~uodia~yznns~n~nsias~an~nssu nis

iaulminla~a\do~onirv uamis~~:niw~~au~i~do.rtau~~4a~ds~mn"s~inmsu~i3 uon$uwuiillj~~andian'~

Page 13: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 14: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 15: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinminJ 18 wuii ~rusnar o5isosnuuorCn~;uu CnPinwi n"'ssen dsmi~lffuu'niim3w ~~~:s:n'udsrninffu1J"mr^7~i~wir"u~~ luniws?ulrinnnh~n"u~do

doisminuniu w ~ i l qotmu o ~ s m u 6 l u n ? l u ~ ~ u ~ ~ : b b m n d l ~ n " u o d i ~ i ~ u ~ ~ ~ n i ~ ~ ~ ~

ir:gu .05

Page 16: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 17: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinnisir 19 wuii yuanu ~5iroanu~iun?iuiuirn'11ou"uorod"n~"5iu r i n d n w i d r r ~ n n i n d i ~ q a m ~ n s s u wirirrrsnnuoern~nrsuluniws~u~~aneiirn"uodi~

- a d %i&i<~nirannns:6u .05 ~no?rusrsu o5uroarsuuooCnfiuu rin8nmdr:~nniai wit%rrron.rruaern~nrsu c ~ n i i C n ~ i o u C n d n a i d r r ~ n n i r i r i i ~ q a m ~ n s ~ u

~ d o ~ o i s m i n o u ' ~ w u i i qrumsu oiomuuotCnfiou Cnftnai "

M"Jmuds:rnnirrri a n n d i ~ ~ o d i ~ ~ ~ o ~ i ~ " ~ ~ i ~ a ~ ~ d r : ~ u .05 1udo~li(o?n'unis~oi1o1deio6u~1ud ~ $ s " u u o u ~ u i ~ n i s ~ ~ ~ i u ~ ~ n " u n i u ~ i ~ u m n i s s " ~ ~ u ~ i u ~ h ~ o ~ ~ i ' b v \ " ~ ~ a " ~ a ~ " ~ o a ~ u ~ i ~ u a

n i s l d ~ n o 6 m w e u v \ ~ n n I % o J i u ~ l $ s " ~ u o ~ ~ u i ~ ~ i i m ~ m ~ ~ i a ~~etn i snoo~mmiu~iud<i~ L: od~aua uanuuwuii~riuaneii~rYu

Page 18: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinsnnd 20 wui7 qma-irn oiosnu6~wnaiuiuir~'11au11a~Cn~~uu Cninwi

d-ir~nni~in~n-i-iu lu~~oc~i/saCuninail~lida~~~~u6163'uuau~u1u~~ni1 rinliou AAd

r i n i n ~ i u~~unndl~~uodi~iM"uhQiqn7J~nmn~::~u .05 ~ih~fiuu?-Yulinfisu ~n8nwi

Page 19: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

nns l i s i~ 21 wuii qormru ~?umuniwnaiuiuijn'~~ou~a~PdUnfi~u

rinAnw dse~nni~~wici.aunssu l u d o ~ ~ ~ s a n ' u n i s d ~ ~ i u l 6 n " u ~ i u ~ i ~ u ~ ~ ~ n i i LLRZ ,ad unnsi i~&odi~i i&hniyni~~nnnst&~ .05 do~fisuihrinfisu rindnwidszmnia~

lli~pmwn.isu

Page 20: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

n i z w 22 qrua33u oPsea3.iuuo~Gnfiuu Gn Wnwioil2 Wnw kn'nfnuiiYumniin n ~ u o i l a d n w i ruanizdnwi 7 ~ i u n a i u ~ ~ f l ~ a . n o u L1-m ~ I S T U U . ~ ~ ; M J I M ~ ~ S ~

G o ~ ~ i ~ K r r ~ ~ r ~ " T o m i u R i ~ ~ m 41rrunaiudz:rnwfm

Page 21: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

mnmins 23 wui i qormsu -a iuar~ur i iun~ iu?ui jm~o~~o~Cnl iu~ rinanltl

ds::rnn^3.6iwifi.6un33u ~ u r ~ o ~ r d u ~ < u n i d d r n u ~ m w a ~ w ~ n ~ ~ o s i u d ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ u w u i u -ad ~ f i m ~ m n a i m ~ s n ~ i ~ ~ a : : r r m n ~ i s < ~ o ~ i ~ d M " u ~ ~ q ~ i ~ ~ n m w 3 : : ~ ~ .05 Ld~ l fhL I~LI~nf i~U

Cnanwi d~r::~nw?aihsqnmwn~~u

Page 22: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinninr 24 W U ~ I qncanu ~l?uarsuniun~iu i~~Ram uorrinfiuu

rinGnwids:~nniaiwifiaunssu Iu ldsa~~i;u-aCunis~n~iur iu i~1" i~a~~~ua p-rii and a~:anndirCuali ir iGa~6y~i3~na'y1~::6~ -05 ~~otdun~uriniruu w'n6nwi dszmn

iaidirqnmnn33u

Page 23: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

qrua

rru

~fum

uuo~

Cnf

iuu C

nRnw

si

~unm

u"i1

&15

n

LI

1. dsrwq~dgunrnung3=~fiuuu'

arJ'

~6uu

a~~n

7u~n

'137

2. tilm93cPQmadn3d~'13~3n~1uati1~m~~\d~~~7

1 1

3.

UD

J~

A~

~D

~O

~~

L~

OU

L?

~~

~~

~Q

ON

~U

4.

d~

d~

l~h

l?9

~3

~~

7u

~~

JlU

d

5.

C

n~

ru7

fiu

~n

~n

7u

~~

nin

Ain

um

8.

P:~

RU

F!~

OJO

?J

li~~

$nrn

nnna

-

x 4.

15

4.09

2.66

4.11

4.17

S.D

.

0.82

0.85

1.06

0.76

0.77

wir

icau

nnu

-

x

4.46

3.70

2.39

4.31

4.45

S.D

.

0.63

1.03

0.94

0.62

0.71

nnn3

3u

F

6.01

5*

7.20

8*

2.88

2

2.76

7

4.96

8*

-

x 4.43

4.29

2.29

4.14

4.29

Sig

.

.003

.OO

I

.057

.064

.oo7

S.D

.

0.53

0.76

0.49

0.90

0.76

Page 24: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 25: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinnisiJ 26 wv i i ? w m u i 3 ~ ~ n s s u ~ i u n ~ i u ~ o ~ n U ' ~ o ~ ~ " n f i u u rin8nwi e -

is:~nniTiiwiiicaonssu ~ u P ; o c ~ i ( u ~ ~ u n i s i ~ v n n i u n ~ ~ : : ~ ~ u ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ < u " ~ o ~ ~ n ~ u ~ n ~ nn.4 ~~nJ"iir~arunnrii~orii~dM"oh<~ni~~nnns::Gu .05 ~%o~~uur7u~ 'n l "~uu Cndnwi

~l5=~nn?.ai$i~qnrn~nssu

Page 26: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 27: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 28: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

olnnlnr 29 ~ u i ~ qmmsu oiu~ssu~i1~ma1~4a~mrJ"?1a~Cnfiotb Cnflnu~ dsr~nniv~w~f ivannu ludnc~fhri'u n1ilri~ui~a~~n"fotfiariotbI6~"ua~y1n~~ni1

P P d ustunnd~~nitad~~iira"uh<qn~~~nmns=:<u .05 da~fisurYuCnliuw Cndnw dst~nn ia~d~agnman.rsu

Page 29: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 30: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 31: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 32: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

PinainJ 32 wuii ~o l s r su ~ ~ ~ a n u ~ i u n a i u l o ~ ~ : ~ o ~ M ' n I " T e r u rininai t: dA

d3t~nniaiwifiaun33u ~ u d o ~ L i / o a < u n i 3 1 t s " n a i ~ ~ a u d o L ~ u o d l ~ ~ -ad

inAon33u ~ ~ n i l u A : u n n ~ l ~ < u o d l ~ ~ M ' ~ h ~ ~ n l ~ R n a ~ f t 6 u .05 ~Jstfiuur~urimiuu r i n i n ~ i d . i r ~ n n i n i d i ~ ~ a m ~ n ~ ~ u ~ ~ 6 ~ r n ~ n ~ ~ u

Page 33: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 34: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 35: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 36: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n a i l i J 35 wui i q m m u oiaanuFiiuni~d~:~o"n~~~Cn~5uu Cnanw d ~ c ~ n n i a i l i i ~ q a m m n ~ ~ u ~ u ~ o ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ u n i n i i ~ ~ u f i ~ ~ ~ w . ~ i l u n i s m i ~ i u l ~ ~ ~ o d ~ u ~ ~ ~ o

P P d $ l n n ~ o ~ $~n~ lLL~ :LL~nd l~n"~ i ld l~~ C u h i c y n i ~ ~ n n n . i : u .05 d o ~ f s u < u ~ n i S u u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . I ~ . ~ : L ~ ~ ^ ~ % I w I ~ " I I u ~ T T ~ ~ J L L A : n ~ n ' i ~ u

Page 37: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

n i n r 36 qmsrrn 6us s ru~a rGnn i rou Gndnwiai8ldnwi Rjn ln inuiLtnnQn n rua i+Anwi r ~ n n i r Z n w i 7 6 i u n i r d r c ~ E m d a r n i r d a u ~ ~ q u i r m r l d a r ~ h a r n u l ~ ~ f i i u ~ 6 a ~ ~ ~ u a i j i ounn iuds t rnn i a i

Page 38: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 39: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 40: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinninc 38 wuii qmmu oinm3uniuni3ii3:~fiuu?M'u uocGn~ou P LQ u d d

cn6nw d3 :~nn?a iwic i ra sn~~u~~~:n~nr~u ~ u d a ~ ~ d s a ~ u n i s d ~ u a c i u n i u ~ ~ i n n P P d

i u Anaou ~ ~ n ~ i u ~ ~ u a n ~ i ~ n i r ~ ~ i e ~ M ' u ~ R " ~ n i e ~ n a n ~ ~ ~ u .05 ~do~iuuriirinisou

M'ninanwd3:~nniaih~?am~nr~u

Page 41: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

pinmisip 39 w u i i qcuassu ~?uasruniunisiise~fuu?Cu u a ~ C n f i u u a n d Cndnwdrr~nn?viwici%onssu ~ ~ n i l u a r u m n d l ~ n i r o r i i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ n n n ~ ~ ~ u .05

~:ociuun'tlrimiuu Cn~nwidsr~nn?vidi~qm~iwnssu

Page 42: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 43: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

sinmisiJ 40 wuii qorassn siuanuuo~rinduu rindnw dse~nwinini~

$RRIMnSSU W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ S S U U Q ~ R ~ ~ T T B J ~ U ~ I W T ~ B J ' ~ . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ " U b d ~ ~ ~ 1 3 ~ 1 5 1 ~ ~ 1 ~ W U ~ I

?NE35U s i u ~ s s ~ ~ i u ~ 3 i ~ ~ ~ m ~ o u G I W R ~ I U ~ O K ~ ~ ~b~e~iunisds~~duu~u"uuo~ a: ,,d

u"ntuu u"nfinwiws~iudse~nw^ani b b a n d i ~ n " u o ~ i ~ d ~ u ~ i ~ ~ w i ~ ~ n m w s e ~ u .05 kau

Giudu q wuiild~uniirlfYu

Page 44: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

u'ou

niq

2.00

2.

00 - 2.

50

2.51

- 3.

00

umni

q 3.

00

qm

mu

ois

muv

aori

nmis

u ri

nln

w 6

~unm

uiui

inaa

u -

-

-

-

F

Sig

. x

S.D

. x

S.D

. x

S.D

. x

S.D

.

I. ~

olo

~eu

luih

lu~

mis

u

3.62

0.

80

3.99

0.

76

4.06

0.

73

4.38

0.

67

7.71

0*

.ooo

2.

~a

~lo1

Ado

$u~l

u#\6

~u

uau

~u7t

l 3.

48

0.93

4.

03

0.79

4.

22

0.72

4.

42

0.75

9.

939*

.O

OO

3.

m~

13n

A447~

\6n

'~617~

fi7~

uti

l 3.

52

0.81

4.

14

0.78

4.

21

0.70

4.

46

0.58

9.

931*

.O

OO

4.

%$

%4

7~

~~

h6

a~

fl7

'IM

'~$

3~

&0

61

7~

fi7

~~

fl

3.48

0.

81

3.99

0.

86

4.27

0.

71

4.46

0.

64

12.7

04*

.OOO

5.

\d~n

nGnn

au~'

Rn ~

da

o~

ui\

n~

u

uou~

u7s~

iitilf

61

wa-16

1 3.

52

1.12

3.

55

1.16

3.

66

1.19

4.

09

1.01

4.

081*

.o

o7

6.

FIO

IIR

IRIU

J~

U~

~~

J~

?L

HU

~

3.52

0.

98

4.15

0.

72

4.08

0.

87

4.33

0.

85

5.53

2*

.001

7.

UD

UM

u7 II

'IM'L

~ la

~1

%

3.52

0.

81

3.99

0.

84

4.12

0.

76

4.26

0.

72

5.63

0*

.001

8. ~~~~au~~.au~~nadn~d~n~aoflo~'I~~da~ii61~7~61~~11~711

ll

3.38

0.

97

3.54

0.

94

3.54

0.

91

3.68

0.

84

0.78

5 5

03

9.

wia

uu

fio

~d

iin

wa

~a

I~~

n~

ao

3.

38

1.07

3.

95

0.77

4.

05

0.79

4.

28

0.70

7.

813*

.o

oo

lo. f

ii~

iud

io 3

L~

O~

~~

IU

~~

H~

G~

~~

~G

I~

L~

J

3.43

0.

87

3.86

0.

85

4.05

0.

77

4.34

0.

68

9.95

7*

.ooo

lad

tl 3.

48

0.54

3.

92

0.47

4.

02

0.46

4.

27

0.44

18

.763

* .O

OO

Page 45: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 46: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n e i n J 42 w v i i qmmsu oiuassuRiun2iujuRnaau~a~M"nfiuu Cnfinwi #ilwanisdnwism6uuinnii 3.00 1udo~~i(u2~unis$~10~uu1u.i;7~1u~~3uu pni iua: :

PP.4 unnd i~6u~ t i i ~ i i bh i i ~n i~~n~ns : : 6u .05 ~ d a ~ ~ u u C u C n f i u u Cndnw d ~ w a n i s dnwiailus:6uill'ou 9 qmarsu oiuanuniunaiuiu~naou~a~~np~uu ~ n f i n w d i i w ~ n i s ~ n w i s : : ~ ~ ~ ~ 2.00 1udoJ~iu2~unis$~1ofiuuIu.i;721u~fi~1~ i i n i i ~ ~ a z u ~ n d l ~ n i t o h ~ 2 i ~ u h i i ~ n i ~ ~ ~ ~ # s z 6 u .05 L & L ~ ? ~ U ~ ~ C ~ E O M Cnfinwi diiunnis dnwa$u-i::6udu 9

w anisfinwi

Gaunii 2.00 2.00 - 2.50 2.51 - 3.00 u i n n i i 3.00

- X

3.62

3.99

4.06

4.38

Gaunii 2.00 3.62

- - -

2.00 - 2.50

3.99

-.37 *

2.51 - 3.00

4.06

-.44 *

-.07

-

u i n n i i 3.00 4.38

-.76 *

-.39 *

-.32 *

-

Page 47: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

sinnisic 43 wuii q m u siosnuniun~iuiuiinaau mcCnGuu l ininm dijwan~rinwrisz~uuinnii 3.00 ~ w d o ~ ~ i ; l u ? n ~ ~ n i s r o i ~ s ~ i ~ o ~ w c i w d ~ & i u

and uounuiu ~cni-~~~nz~~anrii~n"wariiciW"u~<qnic~nnnsz~u .05 ~da~iuu<ulin~;uu

cininwidi w n n i s ~ n w i o ~ ~ ~ s z ~ u ~ o u n i i 2.00 unz-ieiii 2-00 - 2.50 qmnrru

. j iu~rru~iun~iu9"yi iaaou~o~l in~uw l i n f l n ~ ~ i w n n i s i n w ~ s z K u w ' a u n i ~ 2.00 Iu

d a ~ ~ i i u ? n " u n i s ~ o i ~ s ~ ~ i o ~ ~ ~ i ~ d ~ & i u u ~ u n u i u hniiunrunncil~od7~d~ur&<q AA.4 nitmnns:Ku .05 ~do~!su<ulin~uu ~nflnwd8wnnisf lnwia~1w~z6u~~ 7

Page 48: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n n i n t 44 wuii qrusrru o5unrruriiunqiuiufin~ou uotCniiuu Cndnwiddwanirdnwir::CuCounii 2.00 ~uPro~~~u~<uniri~tiuIGCumiu~i~un

AAd dinii~~aeannsii~<uodit~~uh6~ni~~nmn~::di~1 .05 ~do~~uu<uCnisuu lindnln dil wanirdnwi,loiIur::Cuiu 7 ua::x+iiJuinnii 3.00 qmmm o i o s r s u ~ i u n - ~ i a ~ 3'Yfinaouun~CniTuu Cndnwidilwani~dnwif::diuuinni7 3.00 Iudot~du-uYunir

AAd i ~ ~ i u ~ n i i u a i u f i i ~ u a ~ ~ n i i u ~ r u n n d i ~ o d i ~ d ~ u h ~ q n i ~ N n n n f : : d i u .05 d o ~ ~ i e u < u Cnisuu Cndnwi diiwanirdnmoiIurr<udu 7

Page 49: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

wani3inwi

h t r n i i 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

uinni i 3.00

- X

3.48

3.99

4.27

4.46

uinni i 3.00

4.46

.98 *

.47

.19

Gaernii 2.00

3.48

2.00 - 2.50

3.99

.51 *

-

-

2.51 - 3.00

4.27

.79 *

.28 *

-

Page 50: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 51: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

s i n n i n J 47 wuii qtunssu ~?unssuniun~iuiuw^n'nou wocrininliuu rindnwi diiwanisdnwis:<uri:ounii 2.00 ~ u d n ~ ~ i ( s ~ < u n i s ~ n n i u ~ i u d 6 i ~ i l ~ ~ 1 u ~

a a d d in i iu~ :unn i i~n i tad i~~r iu~~yn i~~nnns :6u .05 ~:o~Ciuu<urint?su rindnaidii wanisdnwio~9us:iYuh ~qnrsrru oiuassu niun2iuiuirnaouuo~rininliuu rindnlvi

diiaanisdnwst<uuinnii 3.00 I u d o ~ ~ i ( u ~ < u n i s ~ n t i l i u ~ i u d 6 i ~ o ~ ~ ~ u o g ~ n i i u a t - A d ~~~nii~hodi~ii~u~6yni~~ntilns:6u .05 ~do~Ciuu<urinnliuu ui7dnlvidiiwanis

4nwirt6utb'ounii 2.00 uacrt<u 2.51 - 3.00

Page 52: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

eranisGnwi

Gaunii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50 2.51 - 3.00

uinnii 3.00

- x

3.52

3.99

4.12

4.26

0d"ounii 2.00

3.52

-

2.00 - 2.50 3.99

.47 *

- -

2.51 - 3.00

4.12

.60 *

.13

-

uinnii 3.00

4.26

.74 *

.27

.14

-

Page 53: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

" U P

m i n d 49 qmarru oisarruua~Cnnisow Cninwia iQ?inwi ~~nn3nsiiYertnnfin

nruaiQ-Ginwi rumnirinwi 7 6 i u n ~ i u ? u i m a a u do4 n~iuw5aurrn"lu~iw dirnweiml~!n6a~ ~ i n w n n i u w s n i s d n w ~

wanirdnwi

Mvoernii 2.00 2.00 - 2.50 2.51 - 3.00 u i n n i i 3.00

- x

3.38

3.95

4.05

4.28

Caern i~ 2.00 3.38

-

2.00 - 2.50 3.95

-57 *

-

2.51 - 3.00 4.05

-.67 *

-. 10 - -

u i n n i i 3.00 4.28

-.90 *

-.33 *

-.23 *

Page 54: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n n i n ~ 50 wuii qmmu oiurssuAiun3iuiuijaqau uo~wlnfiuu

rindnwi ~iiwanisfinlr7a<uC~unii 2.00 I u k o ~ ~ i ( o ~ ~ u n i s r l i ~ i u d i ~ 7 ~&omu A A d r l i ~ u a h s n w ~ o ~ ~ i n i i u a t u n n d i ~ n i t o d i ~ ~ ~ ~ h ~ ~ n i ~ ~ n m n ~ = : < u .05 ido~isun'u

CnEow rinfinwildii~~nisfinwi0~I~~::<u6~ 7 qmmu oisassu niun~iufiFiasou

uo~linfiew rinfinwildwanisfinwiuinnii 3.00 I w : 5 a ~ ~ i o ~ C u n i s ~ i i ~ i u ~ i . j 7 1f i -a AAd

niufii~wasi?onu~o~ ~~nhuar~~nndidCw o d i d i i f i hniyni~~nnns::;~ .05 l do

~CiauCurinRuw linfinltildiiwanisfinwio~I~~=:~uif~ 7

Page 55: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

qrum

su o

ism

uat

u'n

liau

u'n

dnw

siiu

n?

iud

a~*n

i

I. ds

:wql

di]~

miun

~s:~

i3s~

u'aY

'~~~

uodm

~udn

wi

2.

mno

~Rq$

dnsd

u~sd

~ndi

uori

itm

sd~d

msd

ui

3.

uo

~~

~in

ou

oin

~d

ou

~~

ai~

i~'o

~~

~

4.

~~U

IRJI

U~L

~~R

MC

~I~J

'IY~I

U

5, a

Tnow

ifisu

ms~

miu

~3ai

6~1~

um

6.

0:'I%

T~~8

nodi

ddf M&

7.

~:

~l

~l

fi

~d

l~

's

~t

~~

ri

~~

~~

Y~

)~

~l

~

8.

O:~

Gl~

ldd

~d

~~

d

9.

lriT

iaul

uei@

n~~s

J'o:

dlan

i~

lo. C

norf

tuva

~ ~d

ai$y

dn

snlu

o~n

$dm

ui

LQ

~

tl

Coo

nil 2

.00

-

x

3.86

3.81

3.19

3.81

3.71

3.43

3.71

3.76

3.48

4.10

3.68

S.D

.

1 .ol

1.

08

0.93

0.87

0.85

1.16

1.31

0.89

1.72

1.14

0.62

2.00

- 2.

50

-

x 4.16

3.99

2.76

4.06

4.14

3.66

3.74

3.86

3.32

4.07

3.78

S.D

.

0.82

0.91

0.95

0.81

0.80

0.85

1.23

0.85

1.77

1.12

0.54

2.51

- 3.

00

-

x 4.27

4.04

2.45

4.22

4.32

3.86

4.00

3.84

3.82

4.46

3.93

S.D

.

0.71

0.93

0.99

0.59

0.73

0.77

1.03

0.85

1-51

0.94

0.46

uin

nii

3.00

F

3.46

2'

0.39

3

7.06

6*

4.97

2*

6.77

2*

3.71

7*

2.04

3

0.15

9

7.90

0*

4.73

4*

5.76

3*

-

x

4.41

3.99

2.29

4.37

4.45

3.95

4.07

3.89

4.38

4.50

4.03

sig.

.017

.758

.OOO

.002

.OOo

.012

.lo

7

.924

.ooo

.0

03

.001

S.D

.

0.70

0.86

1.13

0.67

0.62

0.80

1.00

0.83

1.17

0.84

0.44

Page 56: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

sinnlsid 51 wuii qmarru a~umruniun~iu4mineJ""11o~Cnfiuu rininwi P.Pd

~8wanirflnwidi~nir luniwr~uunndid6uedi~~M'ufi i~iynid~nn~s:~u .05 lnu

qruassu aiuassuue~rinfiuu Cninuiiiiwamrflnwis:diuuinn.11 3.00 ~~ni iGni3uu

rinflnwidiiwanisflnwio~~us:Kuiu 7 ~ie~aistuinuCo wuiiqmassu ~iruassuniu

n~iudorinSuo~Gnirllu rinflnwdiiwanisinwiii~n"~ a:unnsi~~nitodirCGuhBiy m n d nir nnnnsGh .05 ~iisunnCs un~ ju ~ u i f u ~ ~ ~ a - a n i ~nimsaaa"~~~dnsslb" odirnsdld

nmui niilrj~h8r~n';ordnrioulC?uo~yin ~ ~ a z n i s ~ n ~ ~ i 6 o r a i r

Page 57: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinni-iir 52 wuii qnrm-iu o?uassu~iun7iu~s k6~orod"nfiuu od"n8nwi

diwani-ifin~szeillrioenii 2.00 ~u~o~~~uan'unisdaw~fid~u%~~iun~-iz~duu A A ~ d h % ~ u u a t ~ n i u f i n w i d i n i i ~ r s ~ u n n d ~ r ~ u o t i i r d M ' u h ~ ~ n i ~ ~ n n ~ f r ~ u .o5 ~ u o

rftuun"uM'nfiuu Cnfinwi ddwsnir8nwirzCu 2.51 - 3.00 unzrr6uuinnii 3.00

?ruassu~iunr-iu~iun~iu~o~nu"~a~u"nfiuu u"nfinwid~wanidnwi~~~uuinni i 3.00

lurdro~rduan"~ A Lq ni-idszwqAd~unniunpsz~iluuu"oY"riiu~or~niu8nwi~o~u"nPruu

~nfinwidiwani.rfinwi-iz~iuuinnii 3.00 pn i iuazu~nr i i~n i to l i i ~ iu "u f i i i ~n i~~dG

drz6u .05 rdorftuuCuw"nPruu u"nfinwidd wani.rflnuisz6uu"ounii 2.00 ~~az.rzQill

2.00 - 2.50

wanirfinw

Caunii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

u inni i 3.00 4

- X

3.86

4.1 6

4.27

4.41

Caunii 2.00

3.86

2.00 - 2.50

4.16

-.30

-

2.51 - 3.00

4.27

-.41 *

- . I 1

-

uinni i 3.00

4.41

-.55 *

-.25 *

. I 4

-

Page 58: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n n i n t 53 nu41 qmmu oiusrsu6iiun~iu~oCnlJ"~o~M'nfluu rindnwi

diunmrAnwir:Kuuinnii 3.00 I u ~ a ~ r ~ u ~ n ' u n i . r u o ~ ~ F j i a o u ~ i n ~ ~ o u nn i r f i a-d

CDNDU ~ l ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ L L ~ ~ d l ~ n i ( ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ h ~ ~ n l ~ ~ n ~ .05 Ld~L~lt l~n*~¶h&l~

Cnznwi dijunni.rdnw.r:&~unii 2.00 LLR:~:~" 2.00 - 2.50 p m ~ u oS~1rn.r~

~ i u n ~ i u 4 o C a U " v o t r i n ~ u u Cninwi i%wnnir~nwirtKu 2.51 - 3.00 Iudot~du-~~u - a d nirua~~Fjiaouointdour?nirfi~aau ~ i n 4 i n n : u a n d i ~ ~ o d i ~ ~ M ' u h ~ ~ n i ~ ~ o n n

d r, rrKu 0.5 ruocnuunir~'niitl~ u'Tl?nw~ diw~nisflnwr:KuCotlni7 2.00 rtn:

T:&J 2.00 - 2.50

wani.rdnwi

Counii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

uinnii 3.00

* P < .05

x

3.19

2.76

2.45

2.29

Gounii 2.00

3.19

-

2.00 - 2.50

2.76

.43

- -

2.51 - 3.00

2.45

.74 *

.31 *

uinni i 3.00

2.29

.90 *

.47 *

.16

-

Page 59: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o l n a l n r 54 w u i ~ ?rum~u ~5un~suniun?1udorinrJ"uo~M"nfiuu Cndnwi idwam~~nw13tCuu1nni1 3.00 ludadi~e?5un1sdau~~1uh~?o nsdaluludiu

nnd pnirneniansi~~<uoti~~dM"uh~qn~~~nan~::Gu .o5 ~ d o ~ ~ u u ~ u r i n f i u u Cn8nwi diiwnn13Wnw13efituni12.00 ue=:s=:$u 2.00 - 2.50 qru653u ~ ~ U ~ S U ~ I W F I ? I U

( i io~arJ'~o~~"nfiuu ~ n f l n w ~ d d w e n ~ ~ d n w ~ ~ = : ~ u ~ " a u n i ~ 2.00 Z U ~ ~ J L # U ? ~ U L ~ ~ I T n .Q and d g u n ~ i u h d o a s ~ a i u l u ~ ~ u ~ ~ n i ~ r ~ e r u a n d ~ d ~ ~ t i ~ d d M " u h $ ~ " q n ~ d ~ n a n ~ = : ~ u .05

rdorGuun'~~Mun~?w M"n~nw1idwen1~4nw1~=:6u 2.51 - 3.00 iin=:~=:6uu1nni1 3.00

Page 60: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinainJ 55 wuii ?omnu oismu&unaiu~a~mu"~~a~rinGou rindnwi

dd wnnisfinwis:~u~"aunii 2.00 ~ u L d S o ~ ~ ~ o a n ~ ~ l n i s ~ i E u u ~ s ~ a i u ~ a ~ i d ~ i ~ u a a-d ~ i n i i u n : u m n ~ i ~ ~ a d i ~ ~ ~ h ~ ~ n i ~ ~ n a n ~ : : ~ u .05 do~f!au~u~nflou Gnfinwi

d i w~nisdnwod~u.r:Cuiu 7 qruns~u o3uassusiiunnudari~u"11a~rinflou rinfinw

diiwnnis~nws:silluinnii 3.00 ~ u ~ o J ~ ~ o a ~ u n i s u l ~ ~ u a ~ d a i u L ~ n l d f i l ~ u a ipni i a-d un:umndi~hadi~~u"tlh~~ni~1n61ns:6u .05 ~do~fiourYulinflou rinAnwd2iwnnis

finwis:6uUYOunii 2.00 ~~n:s:Cu 2.00 - 2.50

Page 61: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n n i n J 56 w u i i ycuar-iu oiua33uniun2iu4n~ntJ"~o~~"n~uu Cnndnwi #ii wani3 inwi~=:Cu~"ouni i 2.00 ludo~~du~~unii[.a"?"~?8norii~d~=:~u"n ~ i n i ~ o e r

nn A ~ n n 6 i J ~ ~ ~ d i ~ ! ~ ~ h n i y n i ~ R n ~ n 3 = : < ~ l .05 ido~~iuu+iiM"nGuu w'nfinwdiiwenis dnwo$lu-iriYudu 7 qocns3u oiunnusiiun~iu4o~ntJ"~o~u"n~~uu ~ n d n w d i i w e n i s Inw3=:n*u 2.00 - 2.50 Iudo~~ils~n'unisI.a"~~?8norii~11s=:~~'n i i n i i ~ ~ e t u n n i i ~ n i c

AA.4 odiriit2niYyni~mnn~=:iYu .05 do~~sun 'ur inGuu 1mAnwi#dweni3Anwi s t c u Gaunii 2.51 - 3.00 ~ ~ a c s c 6 u u i n n i i 3,00

wani.rAnwi

Counii 2.00 2.00 - 2.50 2.51 - 3.00 u i n n i i 3.00

- x

3.43

3.66

3.86

3.95

Counii 2.00 3.43

- - -

2.00 - 2.50

3.66

-.23

-

-

2.51 - 3.00

3.86

-.43

-.20

-

u i n n i i 3.00 3.95

-.52

-.29

-.09 A

-

Page 62: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

m i n J 57 qmns3u Q ? L I ~ ~ J U Y ~ J ~ % ~ L I W rin~nwioi87dnwi i i~r%~inerif i~nn$n

nsu oii%4nwi ~vnnisdnw 7 siiun7iu&arin 6 d o g nis~iAm~Iuer?~$Jn

ui'-a:iIonifi ~iuunaiuwsnisdnwi

wsni~dnwi

Counji 2.00

2.00 - 2.50 2.51 - 3.00 u inn i i 3.00

- x

3.48

3.32

3.82

4.38

Coernii 2.00

3.48

-

2.00 - 2.50

3.32

.16

-

2.51 - 3.00 3.92

-.34

-.50

-

u inn j i 3.00

4.38

-.90 *

-1.06 *

-.56 *

-

Page 63: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

mint 58 qruarru ~?aarruvotlinfiou tinfinwioiir~finwi kr-Yminu~tTu~nnGn nrusiBGnwi ~umnisdnui 7 ~ i u n ~ i u d n k d doc nirduunt~dnf<i $ d n r d u o t n u ~ u ~ n u i d-1~runniuw~nir8nwi

Pinmint 58 w u i i qocarru ~ioarruniun~iu4otinU"11ilt~"n~ruu rinfinwi di?waniranwir::~uuinnii 3.00 ~uda~~iIu~<uni.rCuuot~dafii ~ n r l u a t n d u

nnd tinui ~~niIr~a~rrmnditnitaLji~dM"uhdi~ni~~nnnr::6u .os rdartuu<urinliuu rin~nwAiiwanirinwir::Gu~'aunii 2.00 uarr::&u 2.00 - 2.50 qmmru Q%~IU fiun~iuda~mu"uotM"np~uu rin~nw-7Adwanirdnwi.r::Gu 2.51 - 3.00 hrdsotri(u?rk ni.rduu an:aiii ~ d n m h o t n u ~ u t i m u i ~ ~ n i i n a ~ u n n d i t ~ u a r i i ~ d ~ ~ h d i ~ n i ~ ~ ~ ~

d . r = ~ u .05 r d a r t u u n ~ ~ ~ n i s u u ~un~nwiAiwani .r tnwir=:~u 2.00 - 2.50

Page 64: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

U -

I

min

t 59

qm

mu

~ir

rmu

~o

trin

hu

ri

n8nm

oi32

dnw

~tn

nm

rriL

mn

iin

n~

uai

%d

nw

~~

mn

i.rd

nw

7

61un

aiu~

lffaa

a::

ii~~u

nmiu

wnn

i3fin

r?n

* P <

.05

---

-

--

--

--

-- -

--

- -

Page 65: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

sinnisic 59 wui i ?marso ~?smsuniwn~iu~~u~a:"uoeP]bUnduw P]bUn$nwi

~uniws?u~~nndic~wodic~P]bUsh~ynicafi~~s::~f~ .05 ha?massu ~?uanuuoc

rindew rindnwid~wanisdn'w.i~:tr"uuinnii 3.00 fcnhrinduw rindnwi diwanis

dnwio~lust6u~w 7 d a 6 i s i s m o ~ a w u i i rindsw rinflnwidiw~nisdnwidicn"w

iqmassu ~~sassu~ii~n~iu~~~~a:~~nnei~cn"~oeiicdP]bUuk~~ynic~fiG~~:~u .OS Iudac

~ i ( u ~ n " u n i s ~ u m ~ c n ' i & n i u ~ a : i i i a ' c ~ s ~ ~ n i ~ ~ i ~ i w ~ d o d ~ w s w nid$n?iui?u& U d P ~1lwneiic~~nn~c~~nsia'u4wiii]n~su nis~icilw~cuacsiic 7 l~$nuo$auo

~~~:n isna:n%~~?uh1dod?u1~8s@s:~un 'u~ ina~~u?11~ uonituwuii~iunndi~nic

Page 66: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

wani~4nwi

Gaunii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50 2.51 - 3.00 uinnji 3.00

- X

3.71

3.94

3.96

4.25

2.00 - 2.50

3.94

-.23

-

Counii 2.00 -

3.71

-

- -

2.51 - 3.00 3.96

-.25

-.02

-

uinnii 3.00

4.25

-.54

-.31

-.29

Page 67: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

U U P n i n J 61 qruassu g?unnuua~o.b"nfiuu CnAnwioiB2Anwi ~ ~ n n ~ n u i B ~ n n i t n

nsuoi%i?nwi bunnisAn'w.i 7 6iua?iub%~~at bdjm nisl$a?iuiauiob!h.t, z A n U U P a d i ~ ~ y n n w n ? n u i a o s n n o n ~ T u -4-~uunniuuanisdnwi

oinninJ 61 wu i i qmassu jsuassusiiua?iu~Bu~a=:uo~M"r1~7uu

u"n4nwidd wani~dnwi~t<u~ouni i 2.00 2 u P s o ~ ~ ~ u ? ~ u n i ~ 2 t ; i n ~ i u i ~ u d o ~ i l u ~ ~ i i ~ ~ t d n u u n a n d ynmJnanuisuonnonnu ~7niiuatunnh~n'wod7~dM"uh~iyni~~61nns=:~u.05 bin

~$trun"lJu'nPstru u"ndnwiddwanis4nwis=:<u 2.51 - 3.00 ~ ~ a 1 ~ ~ 6 " u i n n i i 3.00

?msnu oiumusiiunaiu~Bu~a=:~o~M"nfiuu rindnwi~iwanis4nwiuinnii 3.00 t: d ~ . u u n l u ~ o ~ ~ d t r ~ n ' u n i s l ~ n a i u i a u 3 o ~ ~ u o d i ~ ~ y n n s ~ n a n u i a u ~ n n ~ n s s u p n i i bba::

a- ..I unnsilJ~uod1~i~h~yn7~Rn61nst<u .05 ~ i o ~ $ u u C u ~ n ~ ? s u ~nndnwdiiwani.r

9?nw.rc<uu'otrni12.00 rra:.r:<u 2.00 - 2.50

Page 68: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

wanis6nwi

Caunii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

u inni i 3.00

- x

3.33

3.76

3.89 '

4.03

Counii 2.00

3.33

- - -

2.00 - 2.50

3.76

-.43 *

2.51 - 3.00

3.89

-.56 *

-. 13

- -

uinn<i 3.00

4.03

-.70 *

-.27 *

-.I4

Page 69: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinniric 63 wudi qrumu o5urirrusiiunaiut8u~a::~o~M"nI"Tuu u"lldnwii wwnir?nlti~:~uuinnii 3.00 ~ U ~ ~ J L ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~ J ~ I T ~ Q : ~ T " W U ' ~ ~ U ~ ~ L ~ ~

.datrLMbo~d3:N~n"~1i)inri~~~%18 U ~ c n i i u w : u n n i i c h o d i ~ d M " u h ~ ~ n i ~ ~ ~ 8

~r:Gu.o5do~Cluun"usb"nEuu M"ndnwidiiwwnirdnw~o~~ur:G~~~~~mri~ru o?umru riiunaiut8una:u~~M"n~uu M"ndnwi~iwanirdnwir:6uri:ounii 2.00 ludoc~fh~an"~ n i r ~ ' r u d ~ m i i u ~ d ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ a u ~ ~ ~ o ~ d ~ : ~ n " u o i n r i ~ r u ~ i 8 dindiaw:~~nndi~nitodic

r r d iu"Lld~K~ni~~nmn~tG" .05 tdoL~luu~urinisuu r in~nwid i iwwnir~nwio~ lu w d

3ttlllOU 3

Page 70: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

+jmam

u ai

rrm

uuot

rim

isu

Cni

nwi 6

iun

il.r

:~h

1.

5~ LL

~R

JT

R~

~~

~E

I$

L~

R~

~

IIM

'L~

~U

~U

JIU

'I.~

'~~

:~O

%U

"~~

2.

L

~~

IR

NU

L~

U~

~~

EJ

:~

~~

3.

9:di

~jud

~~

~~

oin

ni~

'I~

d3

:ii?

'u~

dd

inm

m~

4.

~

i~iu

fi~

~w

~il

~n

i~~

inrr

~6

~d

od~r

r~n

~atd

nn

3a~

5.

ao

ud

olw

id~

~o

~h

~

7 ~d

o'I.a

'~+-

~uni

6.

~

:~fi

u~

~~

~~

dfi

iil~

~:I

o~

u"

l6

n~

j~~

nn

i3?

~n

~1

i]~

i 7.

P~~~uu~u~J~~JL~~~J'I.~'Y~J~u'I~.~'JIu~~~~LNu~

8.

o:tlm

fion~

i~3o

ldfli

d~tlm

A~l

?'

9.

~fi

u~

3u

d~

~o

oin

ni~

'I~

iiu

'Iu

~~

ia:T

u

~da$

oT~?

~dm

nl

nirf

inw

iii~

ilu

lo. u

'no:

fioi

~rui

odi~

a:~~

rr61

riou

~m~'

I0~o

d~va

~di~

7

lad E

l

u'ou

nii

2.00

-

x

3.24

3.10

2.62

3.10

3.05

3.05

3.33

3.67

3.29

3.71

3.21

S.D

.

1.00

1.18

1.40

1.26

1.24

1.20

0.91

1.32

1.27

1.10

0.81

2.00

- 2.

50

-

x 3.

27

3.59

2.93

3.12

3.08

3.33

3.67

4.16

3.58

4.01

3.47

S.D

.

1.00

1.12

1.36

1.21

1.11

1.12

0.90

1.02

0.97

0.94

0.65

2.51

- 3.

00

-

x 3.

34

3.30

2.64

2.94

3.02

3.34

3.72

4.19

3.79

4.10

3.44

S.D

.

0.97

1.14

'

1.25

1.31

1.10

1.11

0.95

1.01

0.92

0.90

0.62

uinn

ii

3.00

F

1.08

1

2.25

4

1.27

7

1.25

1

0.69

4

1.60

1

1.24

4

3.52

8*

2.55

6

3.62

4*

2.39

7

-

x 3.

50

3.41

2.75

3.29

3.25

3.58

3.76

4.45

3.76

4.34

3.61

Sig

.

.357

.082

.282

.291

.556

18

9

.294

.015

.055

.013

.068

S.D

.

0.86

0.97

1.06

1.33

1.03

1.05

0.96

0.91

0.83

0.72

0.60

Page 71: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 72: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

s i n a i n J 65 w u i i q c u m u aisarrun'iuni~lJ~:~u'ava~rin~uu r i ndnw~ Ciiwan~sdnl?n.rziYuuinnii 3.00 l u d o ~ ~ d u ~ n ' ~ n i ~ ~ a n " o n t o ' i ~ 4 o l d f i i d ~ ~ a ~ ~ l 7 '

..Pd ~ ~ ~ ~ l l l ~ : l l ~ n d l ~ n " ~ ~ ~ l ~ d ~ t l h $ ~ n l ~ I ~ W ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ .05 d o ~ ~ i t l u n ' u r i n ~ t l u rindnwi diwani~dnm.iriYu~'otlnii 2.00 ueran'u 2.00 - 2.50 qrusrsu ~ i t lmu6 i i lwn i r i 3 t ~ ~ a sln~rinnistrilw rindnl?ndijwanirdnwis::Cu~"ounii 2.00 I M P T O J L ~ U ~ ~ Y U ~ I ~

P P d ~niionri ir i3nldfi16~~a&~~?" c i i n i i u e t u ~ n ~ i ~ n i c o i i ~ i r i u ~ ~ ~ n i ~ ~ ~ n n ~ r C u .05

~ d a ~ f i u u ~ u ~ n ~ s u ~ n d n m 6 ~ w a n i . r d n w i n ~ ~ ~ 3 : : ~ ~ ~ u q

w a n i s d n ~ i

Gaun i i 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

u innd i 3.00

- X

3.67

4.16

4.19

4.45

Gounii 2.00

3.67

-

-

2.00 - 2.50

4.16

-.49 *

2.51 - 3.00

4.19

-.52 *

-.03

- -

uinndi 3.00

4.45

-.78 *

-.29 *

-.26

-

Page 73: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n n i ~ i ~ 66 wuii qmnnu ofoarruniunisdszvrCnua~Cniiuu Cnqnw iiwanisAnwiszmu~uinnii 3.00 I ~ r d s a ~ r 6 u ~ ~ n i s f i o i ~ n a i a r i i ~ ~ z ~ ~ u & 1 r i ~ u ~ & 1 ~ u 1 o

1-4 &I~;J~JoJ~IJ 7 ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ L L R ~ ~ ~ J < ~ Q ~ I J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ .05 L~QLC~LIU<U

Cniiou CnflnwiCIiwanis~nwsz6u~aonii 2.00 uaza6u 2.00 - 2.50 qmmu

~?urrssufiuninJszvrCmun~Cnriuu CnAnw f!iwenisAn~sz6uGounii 2.00

~ u ~ a ~ l 6 u ? < u n i s ~ o i ~ n a i a ~ i i ~ n z ~ ~ u & 1 ~ a ~ 6 & 1 ~ u 1 o ( m " a d ~ u a ~ 1 ~ q ~ i n i i u e z ~ ~ ~ n h ~ f k 11 J odidi~uk.l~~nl~Rn61ns::6u .05 ~da~Ciuu<uCnt%u ~n~nwidiwenis~n1313=:6u

2.51 - 3.00 rrnz3r6'uuinnii 3.00

wani~flnwi

Gaunii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

uinni i 3.00

- X

3.71

4.01

4.10

4.34

Gaunii 2.00

3.71

- - - -

2.00 - 2.50

4.01

-.30

-

2.51 - 3.00

4.10

-.39

-.09

-

ninni i 3.00

4.34

-.63

-.33

-.24

Page 74: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 75: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinninc 67 wuii ?nrmsu ~~irnsu~iunis~sr~~uu^7od"uuacod"n~uu a n d rin~inwidiiwsnis~nwieiic<u ~umws?u~~~nciicnitariiciiod"i~iQi~nic~nnns~~u .05

hoqruassu 6oassuuacod"nisuu od"nflnmdiiwanisflnwist5uuinnh 3.00 p n i i

Cnisuu rin~nuid~wsnislnwia$Iusr~u~u 9 L&W o i s r u i ~ i l u n n ~ w x h q m m u ~ ~ U ~ ~ T T B J ~ I M ~ ~ I T ~ T ~ L!uY^~M"UUOJO~U~L%IM od"n8nwid8wanis8nwid7cn"od I~bdT~dLnd~?n"y

n i s ~ ~ c i u ~ u u i f i ~ I u u r u ~ ~ n ~ ~ a u n ~ ~ i g u ~ ~ ~ u a r i i ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ n i u I u ~ ~ u d f i i ~ ~ ~ nis~Au P LQ u d d ~ n ~ s c i i a ~ d n s d ~ a ~ l u ~ n i w d o u i n u ~ k d ~ d n ~ n n b n1sigunciun7unuinn

T"y!m.aau ~~arnisdiuvrfd"si?m f i inisf iuniunisicdnu~ac~i~un~3" ~~nndicnUOdatiicii P a d t: r i~rhQi~mt~nans :6u .05 uonuuwuii!rjunndieni(

Page 76: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

w ~ n i s f i n w i

Caundi 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 -- 3.00

uinndi 3.00

X

2.81

3.03

2.54

2.72

Caundi 2.00

2.81

-

uinndi 3.00

2.72

.09

.31 *

- . I8

-

2.00 - 2.50

3.03

.22

- - -

2.51 - 3.00

2.54

.27

.49 *

-

Page 77: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n n i n t 69 wuii qnrar3u o'suanuGiuni~d~r~fluu3riu~atCnGou a LQ

lindn~idiiweni3dn~i~rCuuinn.ii 3.00 ~ u i f a c ~ d u ~ K u n i s t l ~ l l ~ ~ i u o L i i ~ ~ n 6 o ~ AAd

niuIuciudriiawn ~~niiuerunnciitKuoLii~dliu~(iynit~nnn~tCu .05 ~ J o ~ i u u K u

linnuu lininluldiweni3~inwi3r~u~aunii 2.00 uer3rCu 2.00 - 2.50 y u m u

.;iu~rru~ium3ijrr~~uuiCuuatlin~uu u "ndnw i~dwwn i3dnw i~ t~u 2.51 - 3.00 IU a .Q d o ~ ~ ~ u ? ~ u n i s ~ ~ u n ~ i u o ~ i ~ ~ n ~ a ~ n i u ~ u ~ i u d f i i ~ u n ~ ~ n i i u ~ r ~ ~ a n ~ i ~ ~ u o ~ i ~ d ~ u

AAd kn iyn i tnnnnszCu .o5 rdotduuKulinduu lin4nlr.1ddweni.r4n~i.rrCuu'a~nii 2.00

rrnrs:Cu 2.00 - 2.50

w ~ n i ~ i n w i

Gouni i 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

uinni i 3.00

- X

3.86

3.90

4.16

4.33

Gaunii 2.00

3.86

- -

2.00 - 2.50 - 3.90

-.04

-

2.51 - 3.00

4.16

-.30 *

-.26

- -

u inni i 3.00

4.33

-.47

-.43

* -.I7

Page 78: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinnind 70 wuii qmar3u ofrrn13uhun13d3erduu^?ib"u11a~u'niiuu

ui74nwdiiw~ni34nwi3t~uCaunii 2.00 ~ u ~ o ~ r d r r ? < u n i ~ r f i u ~ m ~ a d d o ~ d n ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ L:

Iu~mw~?uuiaun~jd~u3~iup1nm~~ c i i n i i ~ ~ a t u n n d i ~ n ' w o r i l ~ d i b " ~ h ~ ~ n l d ~ ~ ~

d ~ t b .05 ~dar!uu<uib"niiuu ~ n ~ n w d i i w a n i ~ ~ n w i a ~ ~ u ~ t 6 u ~ u q ?mamu

~usr3u6iunl3d3t~duui~u1Iadib"niiuu ~ n d n w d i j w a n i n i z u 2.00 - 2.50 Iu

do~~~u?n'uninfiu~mf o ~ d o ~ r l n ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ u a n i w r " ~ ~ ~ u ~ o s n ~ ~ ~ f i u ~ ~ i u ~ n m T " ~ h n i i and u ~ r n ~ n d i ~ n i r o d ~ ~ d i b " s h ~ q n i ~ ~ n ~ n ~ ~ $ i u .o5 rGor!suCuib"n~isu rininwdiiunn~.r

wanisdnw.~

C~rrnii 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

uinnii 3.00

- X

3.81

4.08

4.28

4.30

Carrnii 2.00

3.81

- -

-

uinnii 3.00

4.30

-.49 *

-.22 *

-.02

-

2.00 - 2.50

4.08

-.27 *

-

2.51 - 3.00

4.28

-.47 *

-.20 *

- -

Page 79: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

m i n J 71 qrn~3~a.1 Q ? ~ E ~ J U Y O J G ~ ~ ~ L I U Gndnwiai$?Wnwi &<ainuicu~nnQn P OQ n~ua15-adnwi nnni.rdnui 7 fiuni3ii-rz~5uuiCu d a ~ n i 3 d ~ u a ~ i u m i u

u d d u e Muinnsuwnmu Biuunmiu w a n i ~ d n w i

inni in^ 71 wuji q m s s u Jismu6iuni3G3:~ii uuiii'u~o~rinfiuu ~ n ~ n w k j w w n i . r ~ n w i ~ : C u 2.51 - 3.00 us3:~:Cuuinn-ii 3.00 Iudo~~i(L13~ii1

P C I Y . u d d u P P ~ ni~d~um~iuniu~uinn~ui ja"~~ou ~n-iius3:~~mncii~~uotii~dM"u~$i~ni~~nmn~::Cu .05

~do~fiuun"uM"nfirru M"n5nwid~wani~dnwi~:~iu~'ounii 2.00 LL~~:T:<u 2.00 - 2.50

ws3ni~dnui

Counji 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3.00

u i n n i i 3.00

- X

3.95

4.15

4.38

4.46

Carrnii 2.00

3.95

2.00 - 2.50

4.15

-.20

2.51 - 3.00

4.38

-.43 *

-.23

-

u i n n i i 3.00

4.46

-.51

-.31

-;08

-

Page 80: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

uinni i 3.00

3.82

-.87 *

- . I8

-.20

-

eranirdnwi

Cauni i 2.00

2.00 - 2.50

2.51 - 3;OO

uinnii 3.00

- x

2.95

3.64

3.62

3.82

Counii 2.00

2.95

2.00 - 2.50

3.64

-.69 *

- -

2.51 - 3.00

3.62

-.67 *

.02

-

Page 81: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 82: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 83: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 84: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 85: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 86: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 87: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

OO'C-

60.

LC'

LO'-

OZ'P

~LRL~

- -

+ 60' 1

11'1

• €6'

OZ'E

~yrbup

81'-

1E'P

LULWUI

- -

10'

91'-

6Z'P

bgMuL

ELILLU .. aLrnr 0

-

E1'P

PL~A

oz-P OZ'E

62-P

1 E'P

E L'P

X -

ra L~L!

nyLhun n

aymut,E,s/r~ua~rn;

LULlJAUl

P L,@n,S

reruupj~a~o

Page 88: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

rurunui~~~o:~nrt~n~~~~ororuup~p

~~upu_n nnyu_nn,unn~iopi so. nu:r~yprtu~~~n_ngr~~on,ur~~u~~~:~ii~,turk n

nosq~~~suno~iu~onou~&~un,utn~ir~s,ipi~ agriru_n~yororuupPp~nu~u~

nn~unro~~~~o~n~~u~~~nr~ns,~ n nunm t LF~M LL PULIULL

roruup$ug~on~aunn~p no.esLbLeL1

nou~u~anor~gkr~u roy yomtLuny L LRuptuusr L+cuELgLonru P P

~~JuIAI~L~~~u~~ ~+cu~~g~o~~ulaun F n noy unrenrtrnln~o n nrruwt LL

- 98'

LO'

ZZ'-

91'-

PL ' Z

~LRLU

6L'-

* 80' 1-

ah ZC'C-

09'E

L~L~U.

- - -

6Z'-

EE'-

L 8'1

BLJl/lUL

E'ILLU aLsn;ls

- PO'-

ZSmZ

LULYRUI

n L~L!

oyrbu.

~LJ~U~~!&/LLU&LL~~

LULIAU1

PLyl$

roruup$uye

-

8P'Z

CL~I_L

PL ' z 09.c

C8.Z

ZS'Z

8P'Z-

X -

Page 89: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 90: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

3uY

3ian

i31

J ~

nw

m~

nf

rin

~A

o

ei7.

uiu

tp~

an

u

P~

u~

~~

uY

~J

I~

~u

u

rinnd

nmci

lunn

udu~

a:

?$%

n~fiq

F

si

g.

-

-

-

-

x S.

D.

S.D

. x

S.D

. x

S.D

. x

S.D

.

I. d3

u~nf

to@

uIm

uI~n

?'~u

nmou

~~nu

4.

18

0.88

4.

18

0.88

4.

24

0.76

4.

20

0.45

4-

24

0.77

0.

077

.989

d

d

d

2.

~G

-niu

d3

u~

nib

y

ou

n~

ma

n?

ou

3.

98

0.87

4.

02

0.80

4.

17

0.73

3.

40

0.55

4.

04

0.87

1.

128

.343

3.

~~

ul

~~

o~

$?

u~

nB

o~

u

4.16

0.

82

4.28

0.

74

4.17

0.

76

4.20

0.

45

4.11

0.

85

0.70

1 .5

92

4.

1~

~9

1u

d3

u~

n~

o~

do

w

q n

iun

?iu

mu

i3o

4.

23

0.75

4.

23

0.71

4.

14

0.75

4.

00

0.71

4.

04

0.92

0.

759

.553

5.

qu

Ln

$JT

il~jn

iLI

uR

:~

~J

~~

~~

ni

3~

iJ

i~

~d

i1

~~

33

~

3.94

0.

84

4.02

0.

80

4.00

0.

86

3.80

0.

84

4.07

0.

74

0.31

5 .8

68

t: d

n

uu

n

6.

I$n

nu

f?u

da

~il

un

h~

I~~

n~

n~

i~~

om

ni]

n~

3~

3.

90

0.96

3.

87

0.79

3.

90

0.82

3.

60

0.89

3.

98

0.91

0.

305

.875

7.

IM'n

~iu

d3

u~

nQ

ou

i~G

n

~n

?u

a:n

ua

n

3.77

0.

77

3.77

0.

79

4.05

0.

79

3.40

1.

14

4.00

1.

01

1.97

0 -0

99

8.

ao

u~

d~

fiu

i~~

a~

di~

9

I~ld

ou

o{l

~u

o

3.91

0.

86

3.77

0.

89

4.05

0.

79

3.40

0.

89

3.74

0.

95

1.46

5 .2

12

9.

i3u

u%

inIn

~m

~d

oiI

an

i~

2.40

1.

45

2.74

1.

42

3.10

1.

27

2.60

1.

14

2.70

1.

50

1.87

7 .I

I~

lo. ~

arn

iwJ

d3

un

i~d

ad

3u

~~

'lo

~

dr:

m~

uo

ina

nu

aiG

3.

02

1.12

3.

22

0.97

3.

57

0.70

3.

40

0.89

3.

46

1.09

2

.8~

3~

.om

la

d u

3.75

0.

62

3.81

0.

55

3.94

0.

47

3.60

0.

43

3.84

0.

65

0.97

7 .4

20

Page 91: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n m i n J 79 wuii q m m u o i o a r s u n i u n ~ ~ u ~ B s ~ a ~ ~ o ~ C n A e r u Cn&!nw d$dnnso~ijs-Gw 6 i~ f iun iws~u ld~~mnd i~n"ob ~ifevirisrui~ilunau'ow~lh qmmsu o3oassuniun~im~onar~o~fs"nPruu ~ d n l r . ~ d $ n n ~ o J d ~ i ~ ~ r n ' i J n " ~ iudo~~iiuw~u n i s n a t n i w 6 i ~ u n i ~ ~ o d a o ~ ~ ~ o ~ d s ~ ~ u n " e r o i n ~ ~mnrii~nitsrii~dCerhQiq

and Y

ni~as)mn.rr$u .05 uonCuwuiildumneii~n"u

Page 92: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

oinminJ 80 wuii ?NISIU o5tlmsu~iun~iu~Q~~~::~~~tinI"T~~ tinAnw

~~dnnso~oiirwiunnni~1i~5mnfio I u do~~do3Cunis~~rniw rJ"Fi3~~3~dod3tl~nija P a d ri #ds:~uCuoinmum ~~nii~i~::umnhdnitariidflM'u~6qnid~nnn~::~u .05 u o

~fluuCurinissu Cnlnw C(#dnnso~aifw~di~ uaroifw~nwmms qocmsu oissrsu

R'iun3iu~inln~t~o~tinfitlu u'ndnwd~dnn~o~oiirwT'uiid Iuda~~7(u~Cunis~n::n?wrJ'

Fi~u&dohu~n~o#dsrmn'tloinm~uni~ d i n i i ~ ~ ~ t u m n d i ~ ~ o r i i ~ ~ ~ u h ( r ~ n i ~ ~ t i ~

ds::~u .05 idoi~uuCuCnfitlu ~ n d n ~ d $ n n ~ ~ d o i i r w ~ ' u ~ 7 ~ n i ~ / T ' ~ ~ m ~ i i 0 oi i rw u'npiiaii~:oiirw&iulu

Page 93: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 94: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

sinnisiJ 8l wuii t-p.&tissu ~~uassu&uni~sr~~n"uo~f tb"n~uu rindnwi

C(@nnsa~Joidwdi~rYu I u n ~ w s ~ u l l i ~ ~ n n d i u ~dof is iscuinu~wui i ?massu

o^ruarru6iunisdrr~$n ~u~o~~~u~6~nis~i~3ud~~~~sinni~1.a'ds::6i?"u~dd1n

auinis u n n d i ~ ~ a d i ~ ~ ~ u h $ i ~ n i J a ~ ~ ~ ~ : : ~ u .05 uon~uwuii~tj~~nndia-Yu

Page 95: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

m i n t 82 qrua33u oioanur atrinfiou rinGnwiaiB2Gnwi ~t5minsiii'ornniin

n ~ u aiBa6nw rumni14nw 7 & u n i ~ d ~ = ~ f m dat n i ~ ~ i b ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ $ a i ) i n

ni3l$dill-bi%ddinauini'i i i r runmiua i~w~dnn~a~

Page 96: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

a .Q

2.

dg

un

riu

arh

r~n

~'o

rniu

luri

u6r

ii~

un

3.

~a

fiu

~n

~a

rfla

$d

n3

cu

"1

~'a

~~

u~

niw

~s

u~

as

~&

d~

~

t:

riu

yn

n3

r 4.

14

0.81

4.

20

0.81

4.

17

0.70

4.

20

1.10

4.

17

0.71

0.

110

.979

a .Q

u d

du

I

4.

dg

un

riu

niu

~u

inn

~u

~n

na

u

4.22

0.

88

4.34

0.

74

4.14

0.

72

4..4

0 0.

89

4.28

0.

78

0.74

8 .5

60

5.

fiir

iu6

Ifiu

au

~u

is0

in~

~n

n~

a~

lns

lris

io~

sa

~ik

3.

93

0.89

4.

03

0.84

3.

93

0.71

3.

60

1.14

4.

04

0.76

0.

608

.657

6.

diu

~fi

fh

~~

I~IT

Y~

U~

IU~

I~J

~~

UL

~J

~IM

U~

~?

3.

47

0.86

3.

68

0.88

3.

64

0.69

3.

00

1.41

3.

80

0.91

2.

089

.082

I .Q

7.

$:~i

lsuu

~:dg

unni

ungu

arM

'ar~

yn

3.99

0.

86

4.25

0.

77

4.07

0.

78

3.60

0.

55

4.00

0.

94

2.60

8*

.035

8.

6a~

dn

~iu

3au

n3a

ulu

ni3

l&~

~a~

hu

sau

4.

14

0.67

4.

20

0.76

3.

95

0.79

3.

60

1.14

3.

98

0.91

1.

950

.lo

2

9.

nn

ud

nb

su

niu

l~l~

fii8

M

~E

I w~

M'a

rfia

u

2.20

1.

23

2.08

1.

21

2.45

1.

33

1.80

1.

30

2.11

1.

34

0.90

1 .4

63

a C

1

i o.

~g

~~

~~

un

g~

n~

~~

~~

i~

~~

~~

~~

t~

~n

~~

4.

12

0.88

4.

12

0.94

4.

12

0.92

4.

20

0.84

4.

26

0.77

0.

266

.goo

lad

0

3.70

0.

48

3.78

0.

41

3.74

0.

42

3.46

0.

36

3.75

0.

49

1.11

3 .3

50

Page 97: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n m i n J 83 wuii +prrs3u o?istla~~uniuni~J~e~iuu^afd"u"uo~fd"nbclTuu

rindnwd(dnnso~"ui~wdi9n"u luniw~?u\J~~nnd~~nic doi~n~oris iu~wui1

qmxu oiu~~~uniurnsii~:~iuuSCu"uo~fd"nbdTuu rin8nw$(dnnso~iio15wi19n"u lu 4 OQ 442 ~ n ~ ~ ~ u ? n " u m 3 ~ 3 e ~ ~ ~ u ~ b ~ e d ~ u ~ m i u n ~ " u 0 9 ~ o 9 ~ ~ m ~ b m n d 1 9 n " u o ~ i 1 9 ~ f d " u ~ ~ i ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ n m ~

3z~u .05 uoniuwu~i\oj~(ilnii~~u

Page 98: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~

o i n m i ~ i d 84 wuii ?mm3u o~un33~61un1~63:~duu?M"u~odu"n~uu ~nfin~dci l lnnsodai irw~'n~f io ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ? ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : : L B U U L L ~ : ~ ~ ' U ~ ~ I B J ~ ~ Y E ~ ~ A -n

Y Aad Go~aym hnlian:~~mnd~~n'woti~d6M"uh<yn1~anan3:<u .05 ~do~iuu~uriniseu

rinfinw~C((dnnso3o~~w3"114qj m$w~nwm3n3 ~~n:oi$wiunanl3/?~?m~fio ?mm3u

o^sumuhun~sii~:~iiuu?u"u~o~u"niiuu r i n f i n w d ~ d n n ~ o ~ o l 5 w 6 ~ ~ ~ u luL1383 a -n ~ d u ~ C u n ~ ~ $ : ~ ~ u u u s : d ~ u a m ~ u n ~ ~ o ~ G o 3 ~ ~ m pnl~na:umnh~hodi~ i ju"uh6~

nlwfiad3:~~ .o5 ~do~Ci~~15~rimitlu u"nfinlviC(~dnn3o~o1iiwu"n~fio qrum~u

aiua~~uRiun~~ds:~iiuu?w'u~~l3u"niiuu u"nfinwC($nnsa~oiiiw~nwm3n~ ludo~ a LI ~ d u ~ C u n i ~ $ : ~ ~ u u ~ ~ n : d ~ u m m i u n ~ ~ o 3 ~ o 3 ~ ~ m ~~nilunt~~mnsii~orii3!M"uh6q

aaJ n7~~omnan'u .05 ~do~ciuuCu~niuu rinfinwdyilnnso~o~~w~u<13

Page 99: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~
Page 100: iiRnzCniwniwuo~~ao~l~~u~~ouniu~~u~~uua~~~)~oun~ni~etheses.psru.ac.th/lib-irpsru/sites/default/files/site/default/thesis/... · 9. i~uu~lfoin6a~m~~od~ania . sinninr 10 wuii ?manu sisar~un5uni3d3:~