impact: triple bottom line performance - lulu gordon
TRANSCRIPT
triple bottom line performanceCost-effectively providing desirable housing for people with workforce incomes
IMPACT:
DREVER CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
2
Drever Parallel FundsMarket Driven:
Impact Driven:
• The new rentership paradigm
Performance Driven:• Significant Cash Distributions• Above Market Returns• Minimized Risk
• Serving the Underserved• Transforming Communities• Greening Communities • New developments LEED certified
Our club fund of life insurance companies and pension funds (New York Life and TIAA CREF) agree: Out of 60 funds ours is the only one in which they have reinvested.
Market Driven: The new rentership paradigm
DREVER FUND STRATEGY: MARKET DRIVEN
3
Drever Capital provides desirable apartments for the two most underserved populations:
Projected Occupancy Rates
���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����
����
����
����
����
����
���
���
���
���
���������������������������������������
���������������������������������������
Graph reflects estimates of under-supply of rental housing over the next 2 decades: Harvard JCHS/ U.S. Census Bureau
• Families with workforce incomes• Seniors
Best-in-Class
DREVER FUND STRATEGY: PERFORMANCE AND IMPACT
4
Transforming workforce apartments• Acquiring underperforming multifamily assets or NPLs at
a significant discount to replacement cost
• Cost effectively redeveloping with impact• Acquired, developed, transformed and managed more than 71,000 apartments
Demonstrated Performance• Out-Performed consistently through multiple market cycles• Generating significant cash distributions• Property level above market average annual returns of 16.6% over 25 years
Impact Driven—Value Add Triple Bottom Line Strategy• Profit boosting 2nd and 3rd bottom line programs
Vertically Integrated Team
DREVER FUND STRATEGY: PERFORMANCE AND IMPACT
5
With sustainable and cosmetic improvements, Orchard’s NOI monthly average jumped from $148,000 in 2010 to $217,000 in Q3 2012.
The Orchard, Austin, TX
NOI: 46% increase
DREVER FUND STRATEGY: PERFORMANCE AND IMPACT
6
Honey Creek’s NOI monthly average was $51,000 in 2011 and $112,000 in Q3 2012.
Honey Creek, Dallas, TX
NOI: 120% increase
Social Programs
• On-site financial planning• On-site job fairs
• On-site Health and wellness seminars
• On-site tutoring for school-age children
• On-site police and fire educational sessions
• Community involvement projects
SOCIAL IMPACT: TRANSFORMING PROPERTIES AND COMMUNITIES
7
Huntington Farms,Atlanta, GA
AT ACQUISITION WITHIN 18 MONTHS
ACTIVITY CENTER Boarded up Management efforts attracting newtenet base
SAFETY On-site gangs accountable for 40% of the town’s crime rate
Crime free
OCCUPANCY An abysmal 40% occupancy rate Raised to 91%
Activity Center
“Profi ts for your investors and enrichment of our urban environment go hand in hand...”
SOCIAL IMPACT: TRANSFORMING PROPERTIES AND COMMUNITIES
8
“... This has not only ensured the very survival of neighborhoods, ... with others now following your lead ... Their turnaround into viable communities.”*
* Drever entities have successfully redeveloped over 60 challenged apartment communities in Houston.
Weatherization• Exterior wall/ceiling insulation• Re-seal doors and windows• Dual pane or low-e glass windows
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: REDEVELOPMENT CHECKLIST
9
Energy Consumption• Replace HVAC equipment with 13 SEER energy
efficient models• Replace incandescent lighting with fluorescent
or LED• Replace appliances with Energy Star rated• Energy Star rated appliances and water heating
Materials and Resources• Install hard surface flooring• Install Green label carpet
Transportation/Connectivity• Provide preferred parking for low emission &
fuel efficient vehicles
Water Consumption• High-efficiency drip irrigation• Irrigation controllers• Low-flow fixtures for all bathrooms and kitchens• Dual flush toilets• Treat storm water on-site to reduce demands
Indoor Environment• MERV rated filters• Install fresh air intake system for outside air use
with HVAC• Use low-VOC paints, sealants and adhesives for
all interior spaces• Water filtration system
Exterior Improvements• Landscaping• Storm water drainage and/or erosion control• Roofing material having a solar reflectance index
Signature Enhancements
CASE STUDY: SUBURBAN THE ENCLAVE | HOUSTON TX
10
• Inviting curb appeal
• Resort-style amenities
• Strategic, quality, deferred maintenance cures
• Social programs and sustainability measures
• NOI• $154,000 in Q3 2011—at acquisition • $179,000 in Q3 2012—upgrades continue in process
• Stabilized cash flow distributions on track to exceed baseline projections of 9% per year
Performance
Plank Flooring Program
CASE STUDY: SUBURBAN THE ENCLAVE | HOUSTON TX
11
• Improves ambient air quality
• Eliminates CFCs and reduces energy consumption and C02 emissions
• Avoids future use and disposal of chemically treated (formaldehyde, etc.), non-degradable carpeting
* Plank Flooring enables a $25/month rent increase ** Based on a 7% cap rate.
TOTAL INSTALLATION
COST
CARPET REPLACEMENT
PLANK FLOORING*
$1465
$1920
0
$360
ADDITIONAL INCREMENTAL
COST
RELATED ANNUAL INCREASE IN NOI
($25/MONTH RENT INCREASE)
NA
$300
PAYBACK PERIOD
INCREASE IN VALUE PER
UNIT**
RETURN ON INVESTMENT(incremental
cost)
NA
1.2 YEARS
0
4,300
0
11.9x
• Increased Distributable Cash Flow• Increased Property Value• Improved Capitalization
Only $25/month: Creates significant additional profits
Creates significant positive environmental impact
• Reduces energy consumption and C02 emissions
***Based on an average 2 bedroom
Energy Star Appliances Program
CASE STUDY: SUBURBAN THE ENCLAVE | HOUSTON TX
12
• Increased Distributable Cash Flow• Increased Property Value
• Improved Capitalization Rate
** Based on a 7% cap rate.* New Energy Star appliance package enables a $90-120/month rent increase.
TOTAL COST
RELATED ANNUAL INCREASE IN NOI*
PAYBACK PERIOD
INCREASE IN VALUE**
RETURN ON INVESTMENT
ENERGY STAR APPLIANCE PACKAGE
PER UNIT
ENERGY STAR APPLIANCE PACKAGE
ALL 348 UNITS
$2,250
$783,000
$1,285
$446,800
8.15x$18, 340
$6,383,000
1.8 YEARS
1.8 YEARS
Only $90/month: Creates significant additional profits
Creates significant energy savings • 30% reduction in utilities
8.15x
Advantageous NPL Buy
CASE STUDY: URBAN 415 PREMIER APARTMENTS | EVANSTON, IL
13
On acquisition, replaced all un-insulated poured concrete exterior walls of all apartment units:
• 221-unit, 17-story high-rise in an urban redevelopment district in Evanston, IL • Acquired for $100,000 per unit less than the original cost• Redeveloped into a core, class A- asset
• Increasing R-Factor from <2 to >11• Resulting in a 20% savings on resident utilities
ORIGINAL DEVELOPER
OUR COST (APRIL 2010)
LENDER APPRAISAL (OCT 2010)
COST $55,000,000 $31, 500, 000 $44,000,000
UNIT $249,000 $84,000 $199,000
Energy Transformation
Best-in-Class Redevelopment
CASE STUDY: URBAN 415 PREMIER APARTMENTS | EVANSTON, IL
14
• +30% occupancy increase within 6 months
• Net income increase in excess of 300% within 6 months
• Proactive lease-up strategy
415 Premier Apartments
• Drever team rented 111 apartments in first 4 months after acquisition
• Prior management rented only 5 apartments in the 4 months prior
415: Additional Sustainable Improvements
CASE STUDY: URBAN 415 PREMIER APARTMENTS | EVANSTON, IL
15
Carpet ‘tiles’ to extend lifespan (by 2x) and reduce landfill burden
Repaired and reprogrammed greater efficiency air conditioner systems
Replaced black EPDM roof with white EPDM roof reducing urban Heat Island effect
LED lighting entry sign/canopy; dedicated control programming
Installed exhaust demand engaged system (variable speed)
Upgraded high efficiency heat systems
Installed microwaves through out
Installed energy star refrigerators
Triple bottom line
CASE STUDY: SPECIAL OPPORTUNITY ASSET NYLO HOTEL | SAVANNAH, GA
16
• Total investment $40,950,000• Unleveraged IRR at 16.51%
• 5-year cumulative net income $27,824,573
• Historic tax credits available $4,968,000
• 32% LEVERAGED IRR at 78% LTV• RETENTION OF REAL ESTATE AFTER REIMBURSEMENT• ANNUAL CASH FLOW
• ADDITIONAL PROFIT AT SALE
• STIMULATE LOCAL ECONOMY• LOCAL TAX ROLL INCREASE• CONSTRUCTION JOB CREATION• SERVICE INDUSTRY JOB CREATION• LOCAL ART COLLEGE (SCAD) CONTRIBUTION IN DESIGN AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION
• PLATINUM LEED CERTIFICATION
• ENERGY CONSUMPTION CONTROL
• RECYCLED BUILDING MATERIALS• LOW VOC PAINTS, SEALANTS AND ADHESIVES FOR ALL INTERIOR SPACES• NYLO HOTEL – DESIGNED ACCORDING TO 2009 GOLD LEVEL LEED RATING SYSTEM
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILITYFOR THE INVESTOR
THIRD BOTTOM LINE SECOND BOTTOM LINE FIRST BOTTOM LINE
PARALLEL FUND I: PERFORMANCE PROJECTIONS
17
Parallel Fund I: 7 PropertiesOpen 2009/ Closed 2011
Parallel Fund I Units Total Cost Redev/UnitEquity
Funds & JVIRR
Equity Multiple
Total/Average 2,462 $211,500,000 $3,000 $72,900,000 23% 1.9x
Mira Loma, San Antonio, TXBaseline Projected Cashflow: 9% per year
PARALLEL FUND II: PERFORMANCE PROJECTIONS & TERMS
18
• Asset Type: Apartments/NPLs/Special Opportunity Assets • Fund Size: +100 Million• Project Leverage : Target 50-75%• Investment Hold : ± 5 years • Anticipated stabilized cash flows of 7% to +11% per year• Targeted Total Returns: Mid-teens at the property level• Preferred Rate of Return: 9% per annum, compounded annually
Fund II: Key Terms
Parallel Fund II UnitsHold Period
(Years)Total Cost Redev/Unit
Equity Funds & JV
IRREquity
Multiple
Total/Average 1,316 3-5 $118,700,000 $6,300 $48,100,000 17% 2.0x
Current Drever Fund Opportunity: Parallel Fund II
Mitchell Lofts of Dallas, Texas, and a night view of Dallas from the Lofts’ rooftop.
NOAH DREVERManaging Director / Parallel Funds 415.789.1773 / [email protected]
LULU GORDONVice President / Investor Relations415.789.1773 / [email protected]
The material presented herein is for informational purposes only and is not an off er to sell or a solicitation of an off er to buy any security or to invest in any fund managed by, or otherwise affi liated with, Drever Capital Management, LLC (“DCM”). This material may not be relied upon in connection with the purchase or sale of any security or investment in any fund. Securities and fund investments, if off ered, will only be available to persons who are “accredited investors” (as defi ned in Rule 501 of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended) and will be made only to qualifi ed prospective investors pursuant to a prospectus or private placement memorandum and a subscription agreement duly accepted by DCM. Potential investors must read and fully understand any and all prospectuses or private placement memoranda prior to purchasing any security or making any investment. This material may contain certain forward-looking statements concerning future fi nancial and business performance. Such statements may contain words such as “may,” “expects,” “should,” “believes,” “estimates,” “likely,” “potential,” “strong,” “favorable,” or similar expressions. These statements are opinions and beliefs of DCM as of the date of the material. They are subject to business, economic, and competitive uncertainties beyond the control of DCM, or are subject to change, and actual results may be materially diff erent. DCM undertakes no obligation to update these forward-looking statements.
Investment Disclaimer
Drever Family CapitalDrever Capital Management, LLCThe Boat House2900 Paradise DriveTiburon, CA 94920
SHERRI HASKELLSenior Vice President / Portfolio Manager415. 789.1773 / 415 [email protected]