instantons whittaker states of cft - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 riken,...

58
雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno, M.T., arXiv:1203.1427]

Upload: nguyenngoc

Post on 09-Mar-2019

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab

2012. 7/27 @ YITP

Instantons&

Whittaker states of CFT

based on [H.Kanno, M.T., arXiv:1203.1427]

Page 2: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

(simple version of) AGT correspondence

Instanton partition function

Whittaker state

4D

2D

Page 3: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

(simple version of) AGT correspondence

Instanton partition function

Whittaker state

4D

2D

Page 4: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

What is the Whittaker state !?

Page 5: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

What is the Whittaker state !?

: coherent state of annihilation operators of 2D CFT

Page 6: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Today I will talk on

Instanton partition function

Whittaker state

4D

2D

Page 7: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Today I will talk on

Instanton partition function

Whittaker state

4D

2D

generalized Whittaker state

Page 8: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

from M5 to N=2 gauge theories

6=4+2 :

Page 9: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

! "! "! "

Page 10: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

! "! "! "Gaiotto used

me to get N=2 theories

Page 11: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

M5 on Cylinder 4D Gauge Theory

M5sNc SU(Nc)

R4 ×

Page 12: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

M5 on Cylinder 4D Gauge Theory

M5sNc SU(Nc)

Quarks ?

R4 ×

Page 13: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Quarks ?flavors live on the edges

flavors flavors

R4 ×

Page 14: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Flavors via Boundary Conditions

R4 ×

Page 15: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Flavors via Boundary Conditions

quarks quarksNInNOut

R4 ×

Page 16: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Flavors via Boundary Conditions

susy QCD

quarks quarksNInNOut

NOut + NIn = Nf

R4 ×

Page 17: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

How to describe BCs?

Page 18: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

How to describe BCs?

not easy at all (in M5 language)

Page 19: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

How to describe BCs?

not easy at all (in M5 language)

But, we have a nice description!

Page 20: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

gauge theory via 2d CFT

2. AGT correspondence

Page 21: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

� Out | | In �

Boundary Condition as a State

Page 22: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Gauge Coupling is the Length

� Out | | In �� =

1g2

YM

Page 23: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Partition function is Matrix Element

� Out | | In �� =

1g2

YM

Z 4D = � Out |Λ2NcL0 | In �

Page 24: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

[Ln, Lm] = (n − m)Ln+m

What’s the state?

Page 25: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

[Ln, Lm] = (n − m)Ln+m

L 1,2,3,···

L −1,−2,−3,···

L 0 = H

a

a†

: annihilation op.s ( )

: creation op.s ( )

. . . harmonic oscillators

What’s the state?

eigenstates

Page 26: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Whittaker states for gauge theory

3. flavorful states

Page 27: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Nc

Nf

0

1

2

3 42

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 28: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

0

1

2

3 42

[AGT, ’09]

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 29: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

0

1

2

3 42

[AGT, ’09]

[Wyllard, ’09]

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 30: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

0

1

2

3 42

[Gaiotto, ’09]

[AGT, ’09]

[Wyllard, ’09]

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 31: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

0

1

2

3 42

[Gaiotto, ’09]

[AGT, ’09]

[M.T, ’09]

[Wyllard, ’09]

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 32: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 33: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

[Keller-Mekareeya-Song-Tachikawa, ’12]

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 34: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

[Keller-Mekareeya-Song-Tachikawa, ’12]

[Kanno-M.T, ’12]

| Nf �Landscape of

Page 35: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(2)

Page 36: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

0

1

2

3 42

[Gaiotto, ’09]

SU(2) with 0 Flavors

Page 37: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(2) with 0 Flavors

L2| 0 � = 0

Nf = 0

L1| 0 � = | 0 �

Page 38: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(2) with 0 Flavors

L2| 0 � = 0

Nf = 0

L1| 0 � = | 0 �

It means 0-flavor, not vacuum*

Page 39: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(2) with 0 Flavors

L2| 0 � = 0

Nf = 0

L1| 0 � = | 0 �

ZNf =0

SU(2) = � 0 | 0 �

Page 40: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3)

Page 41: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

0

1

2

3 42 [M.T, ’09]

SU(3) without Flavor

Page 42: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3) Whittaker state without Flavor

Lm Wn

[Lm, Wn] = (2m − n)Wn+m

: theory with and

[Wm, Wn] =

Page 43: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Lm Wn

[Lm, Wn] = (2m − n)Wn+m

: theory with and

[Wm, Wn] =

SU(3) Whittaker state without Flavor

Page 44: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3) Whittaker state without Flavor

L1| 0 � = 0 W1| 0 � = | 0 �

Nf = 0

Page 45: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

L1| 0 � = 0 W1| 0 � = | 0 �

Nf = 0

ZNf =0

SU(3) = � 0 | 0 �

SU(3) Whittaker state without Flavor

Page 46: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3) Whittaker states with 0,1 Flavors

L1| 0 � = 0 W1| 0 � = | 0 �

Nf = 0

Nf = 1

L1| 1 � = | 1 � W1| 1 � = m| 1 �

Page 47: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

ZNf =1

SU(3) = � 0 | 1 � = � 1 | 0 �

ZNf =2

SU(3) = � 1 | 1 �

SU(3) Whittaker states with 0,1 Flavors

Page 48: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

ZNf =1

SU(3) = � 0 | 1 � = � 1 | 0 �

ZNf =2

SU(3) = � 1 | 1 �

ZNf =2

SU(3) = � 0 | 2 � = � 2 | 0 � ?

SU(3) Whittaker states with 0,1 Flavors

Page 49: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

[Kanno-M.T, ’12]

SU(3) with 2 Flavors

Page 50: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3) with 2 Flavors Trouble !?

Page 51: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3) with 2 Flavors Trouble !?

| 2 � L1, L2, W2, W3must be eigenstate.

W2 = [L1, W1]

3W3 = [L2, W1]

But

Qestion.

Page 52: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

SU(3) with 2 Flavors Trouble !?

| 2 � L1, L2, W2, W3must be eigenstate.

W2 = [L1, W1]

3W3 = [L2, W1]

But

Qestion.

Answer.

[Ln, L0] = nLn

(W1 + L0)| 2 � ∝ | 2 �

Page 53: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

generalized Whittaker states

{L1, L2}

{L−1, L−2}

{L0} : Cartan

eigenstate of linear combi.

of them

This is actually very ubiquitous B.C. for M5s !

}

Page 54: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

Landscape of flavorful AGT

Generalized

G

G

G

G

Page 55: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

4. Summary

Page 56: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

“Generalized” is ubiquitous M5 configuration

generalized Whittaker states :

surface operators4D SCFTs

flavorful cases of colorful ABCDEFG{

Page 57: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

GaugeTheory

Next step : feedback to M-theory

M5 branes

Page 58: Instantons Whittaker states of CFT - 京都大学sokened/sokendenshi/vol13/qft...瀧 雅人 RIKEN, Hashimoto Lab 2012. 7/27 @ YITP Instantons & Whittaker states of CFT based on [H.Kanno,

M5 branes GaugeTheory

FIN