iuooouclsl(jslwuus~dvif11etvisuwub1nb 24 77 - 2530*

24
'I W. Fl. 24 77 - 2530* BUtJ UJI)fi EllSStill.1** d' CJ I "' a 'l 1 "'"' .. o '\J 'Yl Fl 113-J UFI fl 'tf1 n11u11 eJ\1 "b:!.J eJ\1 11 i51U" m u1::1 1?1 Fl1 1?11U vm i5 b 'Yl CJ 2477 - 2530 'Yii\ln11b 24 7 5 'l .... FlUeJ'\J 11 i51Ub F1 eJU 1 'YI1'Yl1\l n11 el\1 Ui5113-J fl n11 b t.1 bb eJ 1?13-J fl11 ru q q 1 'Yl 11?1 m::!?lu 'l FJu't1 eJ\1 Fl1 eJ\II?IUbeJ\1 Ll?l t.1 .... q . . ' dl cCV d'dCV CV d' QJ I dl CV d cf i.J c fl'\J Fl 1 13-J1\I b q q 3-J nuttu 111ru 1U:!.J1 fl 1?1\1 CJ1 FlU't1eJ\I 2500 2530 q ... l el'\J 1 n11 q .... m t.1 i?l1'Y11 \1 n11 n'lf1 Yh 'l 'YilF11 \1 b El\I\11Ub F11 1?1 { B'\J o1UeJ t.1 'l 'Yl q .. flli 1 'Yl t.1 :!.J1 Uel fllil1 Ln 1?1 t.11 t.1 fl11 b CJ1 fl'\J el\1 el'\J .... q .. fl11't1 el\1 nf1\lm1\l Fi1d1f>i'ru: .. q * th:alihHb!1 ::L ife:r'YI1 L 'Yi qlL 1'111 1-1 qJ1itV'lUtl A1 (Yl.Fl . 2477 - U'i:: n1'iLL!1::tfl '1-i'L iiuie:r liiV'l!11 n1 'i r:JU 1n nuie:r,j1 n t !1::'i1 n1'i L **

Upload: others

Post on 28-Nov-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

IUOOOUClSl(jSlWUUS~dViF11EtVISUWUB1nB 'I

W.Fl. 24 77 - 2530*

BUtJUJI)fi EllSStill.1**

d' CJ • I "' a 'l • 1 "'"' .. o ~ '\J 'Yl Fl 113-J UFI fl 'tf1 n11u11 fl.£]~ eJ\1 "b:!.J eJ\1 ~'\J ~ 11 ~ i51U" m u1::1 1?1 Fl1 ~ 1?11U vm i5 b 'Yl CJ

~.Fl . 2477 - 2530 ~uwYinLI?lCJF1Wt1B\I~u 113-J~\I~fl'lf1'Uiii~CJ~ri\I~~~Elfl11UwYin ~~n11~fl'lf1~'1J'"h 'Yii\ln11b u~CJUbbU~\In11UflF11eJ\I ~.Fl. 24 7 5 ~\IA:~.Jflliu1::~1~1~bteJ 'l ~ .... FlUeJ'\J ~ 11 ~ i51Ub F1 ~ eJU 1 'YI1'Yl1\l n11 b~ el\1 bb~::1 ~ Ui5113-J ~ fl ~\I n11 b ~ t.1 bb ~~ eJ 1?13-J fl11 ru

q q

~1 ~UCJ:!.J~B\Iflli 1 'Yl mL~:: ~11 11?1 m::!?lu 'l ~ FJu't1 eJ\1 ~ub ~3-J ~fl'lf1U1::1~ Fl1 ~~?~{~ eJ\II?IUbeJ\1 Ll?l t.1 .... q . . '

dl cCV d'dCV CV d' QJ I dl CV d cf i.J c

bQ~1::b 1el\1~11?l~Ui5'Yl ~3-J~UiS fl'\J ~11 Fl 113-J1\I b 1el\I'Yl1\11~Ui5113-J 11fl113-J~el\111~U'Ylel\l ~m q q

~~el 3-J nuttu 11?1ieJ~U 111ru fll13-J~WU1Wii1U 1U:!.J1 fl bb~ 1?1\1 ~\I F1113-J~ CJ1 CJ13-J~el\l FlU't1eJ\I ~U b~el~~1\ll?i'11?1UL~a:ili!l?l~U'\JU~U~flliu1 ::~1~1~ ~El:!.J11::'YI'J1\I ~ . Fl. 2500 ~\1 ~.Fl. 2530

q ...

fl11~ ~U1't1eJ\I~WYi1 l ~F1113-J ~:!.J~UtS~eJ\Ib~eJ\1 el'\J ~11~i51Ufl'Uflli 1 'YlCJaYUFl\I~U ~ fl~\1 n11 q ....

~ m t.1 i?l1'Y11 \1 n11 ~ n'lf1 Yh 'l 'YilF11 \1 b ~ El\I\11Ub ~ t.~u u1::1'~ F11 ~ 1?1 { B'\J ~11 ~ o1UeJ ~.n1 t.1 'l ~'\J~'\J 'Yl q ..

flli 1 'Yl t.1 :!.J1 fl~U Uel fllil1 nd~\1 Ln 1?1 fl11~ t.11 t.1 fl11 ~fl'lf1 b ~ CJ1 fl'\J b~el\1 b~ el\1 el'\J ~11~i51Uri .... q ..

Ufl1~1 fl11't1 el\1 ~Uel ~1\1 nf1\lm1\l

Fi1d1f>i'ru: b~eJ\IeJ'\J~11~o1U , U1::1~F11 ~1?l{u~utfl'Ylt.~, ~~u1n11 , U11~ru~11u1u .. q ~

* th:alihHb!1 ::L ife:r'YI1 ~ 1'1-!. L 'Yi qlL WU 'YII'l 1 1~ ifdiu 1'111 1-1 Lb!1::tl i'mJ ~~L ~ ~ L ~ ~ 'i11n U~qj qJ1itV'lUtl ll1!11 U 'i::l~ A1 lllili?Je:r~ ~L~~u~ri1 ~~th e:r ~L~e:r~ "lVr;!JU1 n1 'l?Je:r ~'ll 'l::1~ A1ll iii iil.V'lutiLi~e:r ~~u!1'i11151 il. (Yl.Fl. 2477 - u'il~uu)" L~m !l ue:r~e:r u(lolon1111'YI~ 1 ~~ ~'YI11'YI~1~~Ahl'lhm1t'l r;)J ; LL!1 ::&i'1 ~ ie:r 1'il1'lnAL~ ~ L~ ~ ?Je:r ~ crm~ l'l (lol1roi ~t,.;ie:r Fi 111Lii u~b\h U'i:: t~tJU'YI !11 ~U 'l:: n1'iLL!1::tfl '1-i'L iiuie:r ~ liiV'l!11 (;l'lJ1~U'l:: n1'i r:JU 1n nuie:r,j1 n r;r&i'1UU~~1(loi'IJ'1l~~'YII'l11 ~ t u~d'~~ !1::'i1 ~ !1::La~ (;l'lJ1~U'i:: n1'i ~~~L~ ~ U'ii::L!l'l-ttl L UU~qjqJ1itV'lUtl

** uillil'i::r;lu tl~ qJ qJ1 L'YI ll 11l1'll'l::1~F11lllili m l'l 1111'll'l::1~ F11!llili l'l(loi::ff~l'l ~F11lllili ~'YI11'Yim~~F1hl'l~um1hr;)J

2 'l1'Hi1'ith::1~1'11flj;j~ 2557 JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

Abstract

This article aims to examine the appearances of "Ubon Ratchathani" in Thai

historiography during 1934 - 1 987 A.D. recorded by locals, and also study factors

affecting to record. This article also aims to find out, after the 1 932 Revolution, the

National state allowed people in Ubon Ratchathani had political and cultural movement.

In addition, the locals had been triggered by the propagation of nationalism in the Thai

and Lao states to study their own history, especially ethnic relationsh ips wit h Lao,

cultural prosperity, local heroes, and restored a lot of local literatures. These reflected

that the locals strived to create their own identities in the National state. Consequently,

from 1957 to 19 87 , the local development has caused much stable relationship

between Ubon Ratchathani and the Thai state . Besides, education improvement has

made outline of Ubon Ratchathani history much more under the context of t he Thai

state. More complicated perspectives on Ubon Ratchathani were introduced , which

helped local scholars to expand their research in the area of Ubon Ratchathani Studies.

Keywords : Ubon Ratchathani, Thai historiography, Development, Local Ph ilosopher

tb::-J~ Ff1 ~l?l~Flel fl11 FlU'r'l1 Fl113-J~~\1~1 fl'r'l ~ flf\i1U~ 3-JWI~~ ~~1\1 ~11Fl~U fl11~fl1.~1 ... q

tb::1&i Ft1 ~l?l~uvm5'r'l~v\11Ub ~ I:Jutb::i'&i F11 ~ 1?1~~~ ~?~tb::~\1 F1 b ~ v 1 id1~?~ F111a.J b ~11~ b~v\1111 q

'Yl1\1tb::-J&\ Ff1 ~1?1~~1 fl e.J f1 e.J ~ l?l'Yl1\1 Fl113-J Fi l?l'flel\1 FlU 1 U~\1 Fla.J 3 fl~\1~11:J ~::li'eJUF1113-J~U 11il'fleJ\1

eJ~fl'M-1th::-J~ Ff1 ~l?l~bb~ f1:: ~iJ'I:J fl ~11 Fl eJ b tJUA113-J~ I:J11:J13-J b ~111il\11Ub ~ I:JUtb::-J~ Ff1 ~1?1~-J1 .. ~lil1~1?lfl11b~I:Juv~1\1h uliJ~I:J1~?~u1\1~~~'Yl5~f1~vm1b~I:Ju ~b~l:lu~A11a.JFi~?~b~mntJv~l?l~ b ~ I:JUeJ ~1\1 h ~1 B ~fl'M-1 AUFll1 b ~I:JtJ b ~I:J\1 eJ ~1\1 h 3 fl~\1 fl11b ~ I:JUth::1~ Ff1 ~1?1~~ fl11

bU~I:JUbbUf1\11u&1'1beJ\1eJ~1\1h (~11:l~f1 111~~1?1\Z 2522: 1 50) ~1'r'l~tJtb::1~Ff1~1?1~ u~um'Yll:lel11ilbbU\11?11a.JlBfl11v5tJ11:lv~~?~1~ 4 'l11::bJ1'Y1 Fiv lil1~fl ~1u1u (uml:l'll~a.J'l111

U'Yl1U~UU1U) ~\1Ff111?111 bbf1::U1::1&1Ft1~1?1~ (U1{JlJl1 ~~1?11UU~ 2524: 19) t~?~I:J~fl11 uuYi n~\1'l11::1'&i F11 ~1?1~~1 &i bbf1 ::li' v\1 ~u ~\1'l11::1'&i Ff1 ~ ~?~~u~uBl 'Yll:l n1:: bb~'r'l ~ n rff\1 bb~ ~iT 1:J

~~fl1 f1~ 5 U\1UiillilUU t~?~I:J 3-J1 fllil::b UUeJ 5tJ11:Jb~eJ\1FfU~el1U 11il~f\i 1 'Yli:J rff\1 bb~ ~iri:J~ t'f! 't11:JU\l~iJI:J q QJ do9 q

~ ~?mtn ~U'Yl~ b~ m ntJ ~mUUfl,;l?l~ ~ bbf1:: fl ~ 3-J eJU fl A1v\l1 Ufllil fl113-J ~1Ufl 11 b~ eJ\l fl11 q ..

~ \l Fl113-J bb f1:: fl11 Ff 1 ~ u 1 b tJ u 'r'l ~ fl b tJ u ~ u 1 ~ \l b fll?l11 b ~ eJ \lli' eJ \l ~ u 5 u '1 ~~ fl u u Yi n1 u

'l11::1'&i Ft1 ~~?~ ~it~uo1 'Yli:J ~'l111 fl!J v ~1\l b~ vU11\l rK\l~u n111 i A11a.J ~1 F1 qJ Lbri b~ v\lli' v\1 ~u

'Zl e:J'U b 'Zl ~n m1Fi n 'H-11 i n11\I'Zl11 \l eJ eJ n 1 tJ

~nmlmri~~ ~\l~cmand U1~ b~uFhma-~~ tJb~tJU'U'YlF1113H~uh~e:J il~~tle:J~ h~eJ~ .. ~e:J n11 e:1 B'U1tJ'YI~ e:J m1'\JwYi n b ~e:J\1 b~e:J \Ie:J'U ~11tfi:nil.1 utJ1d'~ F11 G'l~n {itvm5l 'YltJ bb~~~ n'H-ru~

q

b~U'Zle:J\ItJ 1d'~ F11 G'l~n {itvm5l 'YltJ~·;h ~1m~e:J\Ib~e:J\Ie:J'U~11t!Ei1Ub 'YI ~1,.fub tlue:J ~1\111Jl1tJ11?1 q

u~u'Yl 'Yl1\lir\1Aa-~ b F1 1 'H-~n~ bb~~m1b~e:J\11::'YI 1 1\I ~.Fl. 24 77 - 253o T~ntJ'U'YlF111a-~d~:: ... 1b A 11~i n11U11n{) 'Zle:J\Ib~ e:J\I~'U~11tf51U1 utJ1:: 1'~ F11 G'l~n{it~u51 'Yl tJ * ~\lbb~ ~ . Fl. 24 7 7

~\I ~\11utJ 1 ~1~ F1 1 G'ltn { it ~u 51 'Yl tJ b ~e:J\1 b~ e:J\1 e:J'U ~1 1t~ 51Ul u 1 tJ bb u u A11 3-l b ~ tJ\1 b ~\11t~1 n 11 q ..

~~a-~~Af\l bb1 n1u~ e:J tl';i~1&1f11 aGJ{~\1 'Vi'JGieJ'U~';i1'!151il 'Zle:J\1 it~ .Wu5b'W\I T~nmtlueJ~eJ~tn q q

'Zle:J\I U11tfqltf1TU1U~ e:J1 Amb u1Fi m 1e:J\I ~ ub tlubbnun ~1\11 um1e:1 B'U 1 tJe:J ~ tn'Zle:J\I rle:J\1 ~Ube:J\1 bb~:: ~ n11'Zl tJ1 tJU1~ b ~u Fi n'H-1 b ~ m~ a-~ eJ ~ 1\1 ~u b ite:J\1 ~u~\1 ~.Fl. 2 5 30 b ~ eJ n1 1 eJ ~ ~n \1 1 U

tJ1:: 1~ F11 G'ltn {it~u5 b ~ e:J\1 e:J'U ~ 1 1 t~ 51 Ub ~ a-~ ~tJ 1~ b~ U'YI ~1 n 'YI ~ 1 tJ n11'Yl F1111'H-rl eJ U'Y1u1d q

A1 e:Ju A ~ a-~ 1 ~~1~n t11 ~ .Wu5 bb~ ~1~nJ u5 11a-~ 11a-~ ~ \1 b ~ a-~ ~1Xn1t~1 m1111 t~ue:J mb ~ :: Jl1 tJ 1 u q q

ri' e:J\1 ~ UeJ ~ tn \11Ub~ m nutJ1::1~ F11 G'ltn { e:Ju ~11ti 51U3-11 n~u q

G'l1 b 'YI ~~ ~b~ tJUG'IU 1~ Fin'H-1 b ~e:J\1111'Zle:J\I b~e:J \1 ~u ~11 tf 5 1 u~tJ11 niJ 1 utJ1::1~ F11 G'Itn {

1 'Yl tJ 'YI ~ e:JtJ 1~1~ F11 G'l ~n{it~u51 'Yl tJ b ite:J\1~1 n tJb ~ tJUb ~u11 n11ri11'Yl tJ 1 it~u5'YI~e:J n11An'H-1 .. b ~e:J \1111'Zle:J\Ib~e:J\Ie:J 'U ~ 11tf51U1 UG'I1'ZJ1U 1::1~ F11G'Itn{,%u bbar~ :: ~e:J~Iii1U1 U'Yiit\l n ln13-l bb~ ~1U

q ..

1 m1h tl ub ~e:J\I'U'Yl'U1 'Yl m1 a-~ ~1 F1 qJ 'YI~e:J n11b tJ ~ ml> bb tJ ~\I'Zl e:J \1 ir\1 Fla-1 b~ e:J\11 uu~u'Yl ~ 1 \11 11 a-1

-#\I b ~e:J\1 bQ~1::~u 1 ~\ln11 A n 'H-11 b A11 :: ib ~\IU1~1~F11 G'I~n{it~u5tT\I hltJ11 n iJ ~ bb ~ b Ylt~\1 n11

Fi n 'H-1l UJl1~ 113-1~ Fl1 'U b ~ tJ1 n 'U b ~ eJ \1 b ~ eJ \1 e:J'U ~ 11 tf 5 1 U'YI~ eJ n11 Fin 'H-1 "'m UJ1 1 ~ Fl113-l ~ q ..

cf i.l I ~ 1

b'Ue:J\IInUb'Yl1UU bt!U

tl';i~~ f11 aGJi'il'Wufi~aTu : n1';iAn~1t cU\11 tfi>l';i1~~tl';i~t 'W &n1';iliiGIUu-ti ntl';i~~ f11 aGJ{

'i'J t3l eJ\1 ~a1uil\1~Ufi>l~aG!f1GJ 'J ';j';j~~ 20 T~nt~ e:111~ UU'Yl~n{ (2 5 29 ) ~\IAn'H-1oWI?lJU1n11 'Zle:J\1~1~ In n11'\Juri ntJ1::1~ F1 1 G'ltn{'ZJ e:J\1 FlU~Ub~ e:J\11 U'U~b 1 ru«1 b~ e:J\1 a G'I 1 U bb~~ ~11 ~\I bb~ tJ F1

q

b~a-ll?i'U~U~\1 n e:JUG'Iartl ~tfn1 ~~ 5 ~u111::tJ~bb 1n~1~1n n11'\Juri ntJ1~1~ F11 G'ltn{'Zle:J\1 FlU a G'I1U

* t,..~du,..YinL~eJ~Li1eJ~~uf1'l1!151'11'lwu'l::1~~1~twmvm6lvw 'YimtJ~~ ~11-l.LntJl-l.ti'l::i'~m~r;J{~art~'l'YI~'IleJ~AwneJ~~,.. ~tJf1'l1!151'l1111ti'YIIi'~m'lLU~tll-l.LLUf1~n1'lUnA'lil~ 'I'L~ . 2 4 7 5 'ill-l.~~ ~ - ~· 2 530 ~L~tl'"JL ii.eJ~rltJU'l::1~~1~r;J{Li11l~ ~u f1'l1!151'11'YI~eJ tl 'l::1~ ~1 ~r;J{u~l-l.BL ~il~ Li11l~ ~u f1'l1!151 '11;lutJmH11 'tltl n ~11 Fi eJ L Ul-l.n1'lAnH1nl-l.L ti tJl-l.m~ tl'l::1~~1~r;Jn 't1tJ'YI~eJtl'l::1~~1~r;J{it~'lw1 't1tJ~eJ5mt~~~m n 1'l~1,...r~ A a.J r~,..5'l'la.J m'lLi1eJ~m'ltl n A'leJ~ LLf1::

L ~'iHj n'il~ L ~ tJ'"JieJ ~ nu 1'111 j.J L Ul-l.a.Jl 'llil~ L311l~ ~ tJ f1 'i1 !151ULr;J tJ ~'tl 'i~IJ !Hl '!! '!Jl 'li'il~ ~ 1-l.'YI~ 1l ~Fi nH1 LLf1:: ~,.. L'il 'l,.. tl'l::1~ ~1 ~ [;] {'li'eJ~ ~,.. ~1~-ru li't15~ f1 'ill n 'i:: L .U t~u15% t~m~ tl 'l ::1~ ~1 ~ [;] { ~ar tJ 't '~'~ ~

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

fl~ .m~1~1~Uu11a.J~1U~1\I ~fla.J1~\I-r'U:u1~1nfll1DWnfWI13-lbL'U'U-r:ij 1 'Yl~ ~fla.J1 flU~In ~\I~ ~ ~ .

~111tu (2553) An~1 tl-at1GlA16f&l{ilcwutHht1U 'W.A. 2475 tl\liU'l'lA'J'a'a~ 2520

~\In ~11~\1~ ~u1 m1~ eJ\1 fll1L ~ ~wth::1~ Fl1 ~~n-fmr ~ 1 'YI~~ eJ\1 Au~ud~eJ\I~·;h 11i'1m~eJ\I 8 ~1u ..t1 1 tJt~ ~Jl1'W11a.J ~\11 i A11 3-l ~1 Fl qj tl'U fll1 An~1l LA11 ::~\11UL ~ ~U~ Fl'U'W'U LL~d111i'1~ L ~fl\1111 1 u~u~ EJ ~1UL 'YIUfl LL~::Ei ~1Uin eJUn ~1\1 ~\11 i.n1'WU1::1~ Fl1 ~ ~n{it'WUB L ~fl\1 L~ fl\1

fl'U ~11~u1Uir\11~~~ L:uuun • 2. n ~3-I\11U~ An~16fr11U.f11'Wn1-aAn~1tl-at1Gi A16f&l{bil o\1 ou t'i"a1'l15Til L ~u

q q

"~rnu.n1'Wm1Fin~1tl1::1~F11~~n-fL~eJ\I~'U~11~u1itt~mr\IL~tl" t~~ eJ11!;1 uu'Yl~n{ (2537),

"~mU.fl1'W~fl\lfll1l~~U1::1~Fl1~1n'f't1eJ\I~U : m&EJ~1U 1::'YI'J1\I 'W.Fl. 2503 - 2535"

t~~ Q~fl\1 ~u'Y11111&~ti ( 2544 ), tl-at1GiA1a&l{no\15u t~~ ~111-r~nu La.J~n~n1~muwn (2548), 6fr!1U.f11'Wfi'J13-1i'tl-at1GiA16f&l{bilo\leJ'Ut'i'a1'lf51U t~~ ~a.JF!~ ~m&~m LL~::

~ q

A ru:: ( 2 5 50), fl~\1 A&l'J'a'a~bb 14\1 n1'aFJU'Vi1 bbt'itbaU'¥11\1 tleJU1fl&lU'at1Gi A16f&l{no\15U ~

1 'l1 t1 : ·;h ~'J t1 fi'J13-I b tlua-~1 6fr!1U.n1cw bb u 1 Fi ~ 15 n1-aAn~1 bb6l t'U'¥1 'U1'l1 b u a \I fla-1

U~~,Ju t~~ ~\I~'Ylu ~LLlU (2551) LL~:: bbU'JFi~bb6ltbbU'J'l11\ln1'aAn~1tloat1GiA16f&l{ q • ~

no\liiu t~~ 'Yll~~U ~'U1~u:: (2554) LtlU~U ~\1111i'11'U11a.J ~~n~a.J LL~::lLFI11::~ ~ ~u1 fll1~fl\I\11UL ~~utl1::1'~ Fl1 ~~n{eJ'U ~11~u1U~ ffa.J~UB n'U n11An~1tl1::1'~ Fl1 ~~nft 'Yl ~ • ~ar ~1 'YI ~1 U~1\l~ ~ n11 (:..! ~ ln\11Ua.J1 n LL~:: L UULQ'W1:: L ~ 3-l ~1 F1 qJ1 ULL 'YI ~\I Ln'U Lfl n ~11~ fl\1

't1 fl\1 ~U~\1 !;1 ml1\l ~\ILL 'W~'YI ~1 ~ t~ ~ iJ'\1 ~111:U 1~ A1fl'U A~ a.J\11UL ~ ~UEJ mhU1U'YI'ct\l~\l !;1 n t:.J ~In ~ . ~

t~ ~FIU~UL~fl\1 LL~::\11UL ~ ~U~fl\1Unl~1fll11 ULL'YI ~\I Ln'U Lfl n ~11ri1un ~1\1 LL~::~L~~Ua.Jfl\111 LLar:u:: ~ n11tl1:: L~U~ mU.fl1'W fll1 A n~1tl1::1'~ Fl1 ~In {eJ'U ~11~ (JlU ~~~An ~11~ ~ tl'Ua.J1 LL~1 . .. LL~t:.J ~fll1An~1tl\l~~mhn~ L~U 'U1\It:.J~\11WYll 11u1ULL~1 1~-n'un'U A11a.JLU~~ULLU~\I

' ' d1 I iJ iJ I o d d I I oc o d'

'll\11?1 fJ a.J1 fll1'YIU 1 fJ ~1\1 a.J1 n 'U1\I t:.J ~\11U~1 ~ fll1'Yl1\11U'Yl ~:: Lfl ~ ~ fJ flU In fJ fll1'WU:U'W LA 11 ::'VI

113-l~\1 A11 a.1 1~LA~~un'UK n~ru::LQ'W1::~eJ\I't1eJ\I~u ~\l~u tl1::L~u~mu.n1'W1~~u1 m1

fll1DWYi ntl1::1'~ Fl1 ~1?1-ffl'U ~11~u1Utl\l ~ LL U1'Yl1\llLA11::~ ~fl 1 tl111i'Ein • 11i'1~L 'YIIn~Jl1'W~eJ\IL~eJ\IeJ'U~11~o1U~ b tlu.n1'Wfl11\11 eJUb tlu~U:ij1U1 un11An~1 . . ~

tl1::1'~ Fl1 ~~n-fit'Wuo1 'Ylm~eJ\1 b~eJ\Ifl'U ~11~u1Uil\1~1 ~'Y\1 ~ 1 tl1 um1Fin~11~~ 'YI1 n:u::~n ~11 • ~\IU1\I nlii'1 n ~f)~ bL~ L ~fl\1111~fl\l b~ fl\l~ffa.J~UB tl'UU1::1~ Fl1 ~1?1{~1 ~ b tlu'YI K n bb~::bbar11 fll1

Fin~ 1 U1:: 1~ Fl1 ~In {it 'W u B f) 'U ~ 11 ~ u 1 it~ n 11 btl ~ ~ u bL tl ~ \1 bb 'U 'U b ~ ~ 1 n 'U n 11 Fin~ 1 • tl1::1'~ Fl1 ~~n{it'Wum 'Yl~~ar ~1 'YI~ bb~tl1:: b~Ub ~fl\1 b~fl\lfl'U ~11~51'1%1 utl1::1'~ F11 ~~n-fit'WUB • 1 'Yl ~'YI~fl~ ~U1 n11\11Ub ~ ~utl1::1'~ Fl1 ~In {b~ fl\1 fl'U ~11~ u1UtJ\11~~ ~A n~1 eJ ~1\I:U~\1~\1 . .. ~\I~U ~b~~U~\1 ~U h FlUA11 b~fl\IL~fl\I~'U ~11~u1U~ ~ n'tJwYi n t~ ~ AU~Ub~fl\1 bb~::tl11 fl£]1 U

\11UU1::1~Fl1~1n'fit'Wuo1'Yl~~a1'~1'YI~ ('YIK\1 'W.Fl. 2475 ~\1111~U'Y1Fl111~ 2520) 11~

L~a~~1.Jll'l1!1B1'ahoth::1&il'f1alil{U'W'Il.m'YW 'W .I'f. 24 77 - 2 530 5 5\l.~YNA <m~'",,

FJ11amJ~~UbbUt'i\11 ua~1\11 1.m~hi'u~u'Yl~eJ\I~\I Fl a.J1 '1'1~ uanlin nd' ~b~~u1~u1b~ua~\11 'VI~ 1 U1::b u~u161~~ 1'11\1~1 ~ Fl113-l ~1 ~ ru tl'U n111 bF111::~\11Ub~~Ub ~el\lb~el\lel'U t'i11~B1U~ t:J~ 1'1

~ q

Trn ~u11~ru b~ a \I au t'i11~o1uTrn ~ 1'11\1 ~\lb uum1uwYi n~1 ~'VI~ n lli1U'f1 a \I ~Ubbt'i:: Fl11a.J b ~a~ ~ q ~

u 11 nn 1 u'f1 a \1 ~ub tlu'VI ~ n ~1a.1 nu bel n ~11 ri1un t'i1\l T rn m b D\1 b uu 3 ~1\11'113-1 ~ n"H-ru:: n1'j

uuri n bbt'i::'j:: ~:: b 1 t'i1 ~\ld'lil:: n ~11 ~\I n11UUri n b ~el\1 b~ el\1 el'U t'i11 ~ B1U1 UU1::1~ Fl1 ~1'11 q

i'i.~u6~1U~1\Ibbt'i::1'Ylmb'U'Uiil1~1'lb~a.J ~a "~U" bbt'i:: "~\IFI11rn11b~el\l" ~el~\lb~U~1~ b~el b ~a 3-1 L~\1 nuu1::b~u~n"H-1 (;]\li{

1 . dl eJ \1 eJ'U a ~1'l1fi1i'l'h.~tl~:d'~ fl1 &H;1·Hlvn.1 fi ~1'Laf1\l ua~ti ~~-JGi fl1 aGli'il'Wufi q

1 'YI tlbb 'U'Ulil1 ~ G1

1 u\11uu1::i'~ Fl1 ~~'~1i'i.~u61 'Y1 ~ b~ a \I au t'i11 ~o1ub uub~ a \I~ ria &f\1~1a.~ ~ar~ nu q

m..:~ b '1'1~"1 bb~1 umrlh~a\1111b~eJ\IeJ'U t'i11~o1u.m~1f?i' n11b~~uu1::i'~ Fl1 ~1'11bb 'U'Uiil1~1'1 riau q q

I I I I

~1u~1\lri d1 mb ua\1 nu b~eJ\1 ~'Ut'i11~o1u) b UeJ\IIil1 nll1 FJa~1U'VI~eJJl1 FJI'I :: i'ua a mQ~\1 b 'VIUeJ

~el\JU'j::b 'Yl FllYI~ 113-1~\lell nA1'U~b 1nAD1Ub~el\I~'Ut'i11~B1u1 Uel ~ 1'1 ( ri au&f\1 b~el\1) b uuri1U

'VI~\1'1'11\1 n11b~ el\1 bbt'i::li?!JUB113-I~ el\lel1 ru1~ m~1U~1\I~ ~mUU1~U'Y11\I ~\l'lf1 mb~J'1 L ~\11 U

11 1 ~'Y1BFI1'1111'H-~ 1 9 a:lb~el\lb~~\lrn\1 b~~\I'Ylel\1 'VI~elb~el\1~11 ('VI t'i 1\1~1::'U1\I) bUU

~utint'i1\IF1113-Iblil~ty (~1'Ylti ~hFI1Fill'l 2 5 4 9 : 56) [;]\IJu FlU~'Ut'i11~B1U~\Ia:lF1113-I ~ '

QJ QJ d' I GJ q, QJ QJ QQ.I" d' o d cv d d

~3-I~UBbbU'UbbUUn'UF1Ut'i1U~1\I 'Yl\1~11'1~UB Jl1'H-1 Fli'IF1113-Ib~el 11?!JUB113-I 113-ltl\ln113-l q

F1113-I 'Y1 1\1~1'Y11\I ~\I F13-1~13-l nu (;]\IU11 n{) 1 um1uuri nu 1::1'~ Fl1 ~ 1'11 bb 'U'U "~U"* eJUb tlu

U 1:: b ~ rui'i,~ 3-1 ~ eJ \1 eJ Fl Ubbti'U d'1 uf?i'u~ 'Yl B Fl1'11 11'H-~ 24 b UUf?i'Ua.J1 1~bbri "~Ub~ el\1 el'U t'i" .. q q

( eJ1'jtl UU'Yl~n1 2 5 3 7: 2 5) b UU\11Ub~~mM mnuu1::1~ Fl113-l b UU3-11~ el\1 F1Ut'i11 n ~3-1~1:: 1eJ~'j:: 1'11 m 1 ~~1\ID1Ubb u\1 b~ eJ\1 au t'i 11~ o1u b ~eJ\1111 m ~ 1d't1 n FJ t'i:: bFl ~11 u nu 1Pi1u 1u

q ..

~u't11u Fl ~ o1'ja.J Fh~au bbt'i::u1::b ~ & ~1\11 ~ bb 'Y11na ~1 uJu bbt'i::'V\1 n~liJ1'jnA1 rn bb~1 b 'VI ~au .. .. b uum1 ~ n"H-1u1::i'~ Fl1 ~1'11 ~1u~1\l ~\ltZU FJ \11~ ~ rn b ~11:: m:: bb~n11 b Fl ~ auti'1 ~~ eJ\1 n ~a.~

q

~1::1e:J~1:: 1'11 n b UU~~m 1 n11'Y11\I n11b~e:J\I~ e:J\1 el1 nA1~ m~1U~1\I a mn n'VI~\ItZUbe:J\1 a n~\1

• .fu 'YI ~1 El ~~ th::1&i '"'1 ~ L U'll.~1tta~ L 'YIIil n1'l rnU1'1l.L ~ a~ L'll.t!'ll.U n1'lUWn mh::1&i 1'11 alili LL umni lil L'll.i'inmB'l'l~ <i1'1l. '

n1~ ~~LU'Il. Fi1~th1n:!J'lmana1'lLU111'1l.5a1 '1l.ath~ n11 ~ tt 11~ LLll::'"'lau'"!l~m1~'YimEJ!ii1'1l.1'1l.LL!l::w~ l'f 111il1'l~'ln '

An'IY1tl'l::1&i 1'11 a111iL~a~ 't uu~L 1 o.~ '=)'ll.1i"Ei1'1l.1'ili',:i1 'YI EJ ~ a L \Jun1'luwn m ~a~ L~a~ ~u ll'l1!1B1ii'l uth::1&il'f1 a111iii.wu6

<i1'1l.n1~~t;m 'ln ttn.~::L~EJ1n'll.uwnn L~a~dla~~Ull'l1!1B 1 ii't ... th::1&i l'f1aliliii.w'll.Bl 'YIEJth~ii'nL~~~ th1n:!JLL<i1 MLLri

'il1inn1'la~1~1~mll::w'l::w 'YI B'lti ~'Yl1i.,. r;i,m'YIIil c.J ll 'Y11 ~ 1'f 1a'll.1 l~n~11~~L~a~111~~uL ii.a~ uam WEJ~L'"'la~1~a:: 1 'l . ~ ' L~a h L~aa:: hL 'YhJ.,. r;l~,f.,. 'il1in~~a~'ll.anttauLttliln1'lAn,1 cJL~EJ ... ~~L ~~n~11~~uwnm ~a~L~a~au!l'l1nB1ii't.,.

~ ~ ' ti'l::1liiFI1<il1liii.vmBl'YIEJ!li11LL'ln ~a w~l'11 71nn!iJD~ Ltlu~1 ~ru . .

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

~1~!9ln11'1Turimbuu "~u" dtT\1~~~~\1'Yl~1m~m~mnh~~1un~~nu~ud:Je:~\1~ 'Yl ~1n'Yl~1~ • • • 1 ibn~ ~1itn Fl11 ~ b uu~11~1~nun1~1r;lei1u1~-r~~ n1111~~1utl1\1 r;l1~ ( e:111 ~ uu'Yl~n~

2537 : 47)

1ul91e:~un~1\1~'YloF1191111~~ 25 (1~'Yll1\1 w.Fl. 2430 - 2437) -r~1'Y1~1r;ltJ~:p.J u1~b 'Y1 Flb ~e:~~~1\1-r~~ar~1 'Yl~r~~m1~~m1unA1e:J\1bbuub 'Y1F11ilu1~ ( ~m~n w.Fl. 24 76)

~'Yh 1 id:j e:J\1 e:JU ~11no1U~ n ~U1 m ~1 nun~ F11 ~ 191~-r:u 1 'Y1 ~ rff\1 bb~ 'W. Fl. 24 36 b uur;i'u~1 q q,f cu do9

(1wt11!!J ~~Fl~ 2515: 57) bb~~b~e:~1itJ1~n1nu~1itn1uA11~btlun1~~1~nu -r~1'Y1~1r;l ci1 ~'Yl eJ ~ F111 ~~'Y11\1il1~1 bb~~119!luo11~ri't1 e:J\1 ~u 11~~\1 n11b ~~u b ~~\1U1~1~ F11 ~ 191~\twum 'Y1 ~ .. .. 1 U1Ubb UU "'W\1 Fl11 ~11 b3:je:J\I" ~ ~ eJ b tlun11 ~~1\1 Fl 11 ~-ru~b~ ~1 nun~ ~nU1e:JU ~1\I~-r:u

cu cu q do9

~uu~'i'u1i~111nm1'1'1e:J\I~Ub~~m~~\I~U (e:111~ uu'Yl~n~ 2535: 1) ~m 1~~'Yle:JU u-r~u11Fl~ b~U 19f1U1Un11bn~bb~J'1L~\I bb~::U'Y11U~WU1U~U1 ~\lbUUF111 ~ 'Y11\1~1~1~ ~ eJ \1 FlU't1 eJ \1 ~u 1 U\11 Ub ~ ~U~\1 r~ m UUb ~ eJ \1 ~~~U5il1'W 1~'Yll1 \1 b3:j e:J\1 e:JU ~1 1 n 51 unu • ri1un~1\1~1n~u UUbUUF111~'W~1~1~~e:J\I-r:u 1 'Ylm~e:J~~'Yle:JUFl11~bUU~11 bb~1~1m1u ... Fl11 ~ b uu 1 'Y1 ~ r;l1~ bb uu bb~un11'1Turi nw\1 Fl11 ~11 1 i Au'l'1 e:J\1 ~u bb~ ~~1 n n11~ b ~e:J\1 111 b3:j e:J\1

e:~u ~11 no1u~ n11 ~ b ~1 rin11 b ~ ~utJ 1~1~ F11 ~ 191~n1 ~,Xu '¥1·11 ie:~\1 F1 Fl11 ~~b ~e:J\1 b3:je:J\I q cu cu cu

e:JU ~11n 51U~ Fl11 ~ b tJ ~~Ubb tJ ~\11 U'W~e:J ~ nu nl~bb~n11b tJ ~ ~UbbU1 n11b ~ ~UU1~1~ F11 ~191~ • 1 'Yl~r;l1~ b ~u~1n'!J'urim~e:J\Ib3:je:J\Ie:JU~11no1u1 utJ1~1~ Fl1~191~itwuB1 'Yl~ b~u 'W\1A1'Jr;J1':i • cH'Jtahl \1 3HU"rla~hnu ~e:J\1 'Yl~e:J~e:Jm11'1r11~1911 (~ . 1 . 1.'\J~~ FlbU~1) bb~~ 'W\1A1'Jr;J1 ':i.fl1fil

~a1cu ~e:J\1 w1~m~u'Y1111nb~n (bb~ tJ1~~~n1~ ) btlur;i'u ~n~11~\l~~~uofi1'W 1~'Yl111'1 b3:je:J\Ie:JU~11no 1 unu-r:u 1 'Ylm tlu'Yl~n . ...

eJ ~1\1 hn 1911 ~ tJ\I'WUl1 \11'1-hb ~~UU1\I~UtJ\I Fl \1 ~ n~tu~~ e:J\1 "~U" e:J~L~ ~ tJ-ru 1 ib ~1 nu~1~ 191"11\1 Fl11~11 1r;lbbn 'W\1 A1 'J !;11 -:ib a:i a\1aua-:i1t~fi1u QUU be:J n ~11-Vl ~vr~ ~n ~ m~~1~ • • ~~\l~e:J\Ibb~Un n~ ~'YIU\1 ~e:J ~1b~~Ubb~~~1~n ~1Un'Yl e:J ~~ ~ bb vl\ln1 ~ (1~U11 n n ~bb~\1 U~bb~\1

q q ~ cu

bb~~ 1~1r;l-ru m1~Yl~tr) ~uit~~1Ul1bUu~~\11U~e:J\Inu#uu1n11'1 b 'Yl'W"l ~b~1 ~ 1 tJ~u~m1 1 U~U~b3:je:J\Ie:JU~11no1U ~\I ~b'i{e:J'Yl1~e:J ~ Fl ~e:J\1 rlU\11'1-h~e:J\I'Yl ~El~El ~11\1 rfi~ 1911'Yl ~1 m bvl\1 bb~ • ri1U~ b ~ ~ b ~1m A eJ n11b~~ r;lub ~e:J\1111r;11~1911U1U'W1~ b~1 b~ t.IU r~ n n11b~~~~ e:J\I'W 1~~'Y15 e:J\1 F1~vi1 1 ibn ~w1~ o1191 b~ ~ !!J ~1\11 bb~~w1~w'Y1o1tJ ~1 ~ ru~e:J\1 b3:j e:J\1 EJu w1 ~1 n,%ub~ 1 ~\I

q q cu Q,l q

CL.1 d d ~ I ~ .r:::::! d !t.l I !t.l !t.l I~ 'W19!JU1 n11b~e:J\Ie:JU ~11n51U 191\1 bbl91n11191\I~U:U1U'Y1U1U~U1Ubbn 'Yl1mb~1~bb~ ~ \le:J ~\I ~U

q do9 cu cu

bUub3:je:J\Ie:JU~11no1u~ar~-rnm~~ 1 ~\1-rnm~~ 5 (e:111~ uur1~n~ 25 37 : 55 ; ~tlm • • 'Y11U'Y11 2 548 : 6 3 ) Tr;1~1 u~EJ A11~1~\!~r;] b~U~\1 m1ril'l~111nm1~1\I'W1~bui91 1'W1~m1tu

b~1~1 1 Uil1 Fl~~1Ubb~~e:JU~11no1U ~\I'WElb~e:J 1r;111 btl n ~11~ud'Fl11UUYin'Yl ~\lb'Yl l91 n11rW • • ,fur;l1~ tt'uFie:~r;le:~\luurin'Yl~\1 w.Fl. 2434 b'W11~btluu~w1::b~1U1ml'lr1boe:J m~'Yl~1\1Yl~191

Lilfl~~Ufl'i1'!H:m1hn.h::~A1!l!il{itYnl.tfl'Yla W.A. 2477 - 2530 7 d\ww~ l'i awi'lll"l-i

tJ~~1 fl1b~ ~~ mtJ 1::'t1u~ b~ EJ\1 EJ'U ~ 11~ oTCh • b~mn ~ fl11b tJ ~£JUbb tJ ~\lm1tJn Fl1eh'l vul 24 7 5 m1b~EJ\I~EJ\I-rjtb::~1~1 ~ 11?i'btEJ

L ~ FIUEJ'U ~11~o1itbFI ~EJU 1 'V\1'1'11\1 fl11 b~ El\1 bb~::11?lJUEi11 :1-l b ~ El ~ El1El\l b ~1 b UUri1U'VIif,\l~ El\1 •

~1 ~ 11:1-l ~\I fl11UU-ti flU1::1~ F11 ~1?1{~ ~ El b UUfl11EJB'U1 £] El ~ 1?1 bb 'U'UL 'VI a.l.n1 £] L~1::'U'U Fi ~ bb~:: ~1~ 1?1 n11b~ £1'1-tbb 'U'U 1?1::1ul?l fl r~ £] ~El\1 fl11U1 b~umr 1?1 K m~ru'VI~El 1?11 1?1'1-t~ El\1 FIU't1EJ\I ~u~ ~~1 :1-l

rl'UF111:J.lbUU~11 b~e:Jb~1~'Y1F1111El- 2500 ~U~\I~U'Y1F1111El- 2520 fl11~1?llUTth::b'YlF111?i' 'VI ~El'VI ~ El :J.JL ~ FIUEJ'U ~11~ o1it~ ~1Ufl Fl11 :1-l b tJu 1 'Y1 £] :J.l1 fl~U u 1 :J.l1 rifl11~-r1\l e) 1?1 K fl EJ.ru'VI~El 1?11 . ~

1?1UFI11 :1-l b UUFIUEJ'U ~ 11~ Ei1 it~\I'UUFI11 :J.l'Y11\1~1 bb '\1\1~1 ~~ El \1-rl\i 1 'Y1 £JEJ ~1\1 ~\I 1?11 . ... 2. L ~ £h'Hl 'U a ·n '!1 BTil'h~ tJ 'a~ -Jm fil16l Gl"fil 'W 'I.Ufl 't1 £16{ af £~ i' ~ 'lh ~ 'H1 'H 1 m 'a~ ·wh \1

~ ~ ... 'W.fil. 2477 ~l\l 'W.fil. 2500

~ ~ b tJ ~ £JU~1 F1 ru ~ 'Yi1L ~ 1:: b u £Ju15 bb~:: Fl1 1 :J.J Fi ~ 1 un11 b ~ £JutJ 1::1~ Fl1 ~ 1?1 {it~ u6 . ~

~ ar £JL 'VI a.) bbl?l fl ~1\1~1 flb~ :1-l bb~:: ri\1 eJ ~ ~ El fl11UU-ti fl b ~El\1 b~ El\1 El'U ~11~o1itL UU1::1~ F11 ~ 1?1 { • it~uo1 'Y1 £J~b 'i4ub~Ui~.n1 £J'VIK\I fl11b tJ ~ £1'1-tbb U~\1 fl11Ufl FI1El\l ~-Fl. 24 7 5 b UU~U:J.l1 r~ £] ~ :J.J ~ b 'VII?l~1 ntl~:S' £Jfl1 £J 1mb~ ::.n1 £JUEJ n~1a.J b .W £1\1 bb~ ri\1 eJ ~ ~ EJ n11 b tJ ~ £JUbb tJ ~\1'1'11\1 «\I Fl :J.J bb~:: ~ . fl11 b~ EJ\11 'Y1 m rhJ u 'VI1 n t:i'\111 :J.J ~ \1 n11 b tJ ~ £JUbb tJ ~\I~ 1?1 ~1itn bb~:: :J.J t u 't1 Aun11-ru -r EJ ~ 1?1 .. ~\lri\1 eJ ~ ~El n11UU-ti flEJ ~ 1?1~ ~::'t1EJU~ n ~ fl11:J.l F111:J.lb ~El u-r~ru1~ll?l Fhit£J:J.J bb~::EJ ~ :1-l fl11ru 01 ~ •

~ El\1 FlU 't1 El\1 ~ul?i'1 £J

~1 fl Fl 11 :1-l «:J.l~U61::'VI11 \1 ~fl1~ «\I Fl :1-l ~ El \1-rl\itJ 1::~1~1 ~~ b ~ :J.J1 tJ 1?11 £J fl11 bFI ~ EJU 1 'VI1 ... ~ El1 El \1 ~ El \1 Flu fl ~ :1-l ~ 1 \1 1 t ~ £] b Q ~ 1:: fl11 b Fl ~ El u 1 'VI 1 '1'11 \1 fl11 b ~ El \1 bb ~:: 11?ll u Ei 11 :1-l ~ El \1 Flu • 't1EJ\I ~u 1 u~u~ n11b~ EJ\11::uu1 'VI a.J~u11 tJ ~ n11u11 n!J~ EJ\1 "b~ EJ\1 ~u ~11~o1it" 1 u

tJ 1::1~ r11 ~ l?l{it~u61 'Y1 £J1u bb uu Fl11 :J.J b ~£1\1 ~ar £JL 'VI a.J b ~\11~1 n11 ~\I ~1\1 ~1 ntJ1::1~ r11 ~ 1?1{ .. . c (j'd c:f d eve o cv dcvcvd'cv cvd

U~UEi b:J.l El\1 El'U ~ 11~ Ei1U£J Fl~111?1 ~ \1~~11 ru 1~1 fl'U1'U'Yl'Y11\I ~\I F1 :J.l'Yl ~:J.l~UEi fl'U fl11'UU'Yl fl • • u1::1~ r11 ~l?l{~EJ\1 FJu't1EJ\I ~u~ar£J-rl\iu1::t~1t~1 ~ ...

2. 1 'U~'U'n't11\1 a\1 F13-l~ a\1 t.1 a Gleln1'aUUn ntl-a~-JGl fil16lGI{tJ£J\1 FIU£l'U a-a1'HBTU ~

~u6 n ~1\1 b dEJ'V11L utJ1::1~ r11 ~ 1?1 {it~u61 'Y1 £J ~ar £J 1 'VI a.JJu~1 :J.J11tl bb u1 b tJ ~ £JU1?11 :J.J

m ~ b 1 ~1 bb~::u~u'Yl~ b u ~ £1'1-tbb u ~\11 u r~ £] bQ ~1::~'1'16~ ~~1 n fl11b u ~ £1'1-tbb u ~\I n11u n FI1El\l

bUU1::UEJ'UU1::'ZI16u11?1£JLU ~ . Fl. 24 75 11?i'ri1'VIU~~ubb'U'U«\IFI:J.J~UL'VIa.l ~\lu-r'Ubu~£Ju Fl 11 :1-l 'VI :J.l1 £] ~ El \1 -z~1 ~ ~ b ~ El :1-l t £] \1 n u ~ tl1 u u n,; 1?1 ~ 6 :J.l1 b u u -z~1 ~ ~ El \1 tJ 1:: -z~1 -z~ u 'VI~ El

"-rl\iu 1::t11 tl1 ~" 'U~'U'Yl fl11 b~ El\1 b ~wdb tEll ~b fl ~ fl11 b Fl ~ El U 1 'VI 1~ El\1 F1 UEJ 'U ~ 11 'ZI Ei 1 itu U ... . ~Uj1U~1Ufl't1EJ\I ~Ub ~ El b ~11 tJ b tJuri1U'VIif,\l~ El\I'ZI1 ~ ~ ru:: b ~ m nu 1i?lri\l eJ ~ L ~\11'1-tb ~ £JU

~Ub~El\IEJ d1 u~ ~'t1EJ\I ~uit£J:J.J !?11£1 ~\I ~'U~'U'Yl 2 u1:: n11~ri\l eJ ~ ~El fl11UU-ti ntJ1::1~ F11 ~1?1{ d' "'

~El\IFIU~Ub:J.JEJ\1

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

•t.htnT'Ht ~n A t1 n1'HFI ~m-l> 1 'Y!1'Y11\l nl';ib~ tl\l 1 unTH ~11 tJ ~ ~1'!-d 'H.J1 U';i~'U'U U';i~~15tJ1111~?Jt1\ln~a.J~bb'YlU';i1~iJ';ib~t1\l~'U~';i1~EilU hi'bbrl 'Yltl\l~U'Yli JJ~oWI?!lu b ~ ~\l1~~m~ bb~~m~ ~~3-11 t~~FIUn~a.Jd'LtT~lli~il1bUU~U~U1b~um~tl\l'Yltl\l~U b~~n{t~\l1'1-i'~lli 'U1~1~1lil

q q "" dt.9

oW i?!!U1:5'\l'Y!l ~ 111U t~~lil~ b ~u11il1~'Y! ~\! nl';ib tJ ~~Ubb tJ ~\l nl';iU n Fi';itl\l ~mu1'Yl ~ m~lil1 m~~\l q

?J tl\l~] ~';i1 ~ nl';i 1 'Yl ~~ b ~qj ~bb 'Y1U';i1~i]';i3-l1'U';i1 ~1 ~ t1 t1 n til m Fl'Y11\l1'Yl ~1 U~1~t1U';i::l~ bb~:: F1113-lb Uut~d?Jt1\l11~i]1:5'\l'Y!l ~ ~1\l '1 Uti nlil1 nd'm1~ ~- ~-~'U ~11~51Ub~1~1 3-l?J'U1Unl1 b~~1 'Y1 ~ nuu1 ~tJ~ ~ ~ua.J ~\I A b ~ t1 Fl~ A1Un1';i'Y11 ~\I Fl ';i1a.J nu ~1 mla.JoWU 5 ~ 1111~1\l ~\lFI113-l f~nFI{\l~ 2 'Yll1 itJ1::b'YlF11 'Yl~ 1~111nt1~1 Ul\i1U::U1::b'Y1Fle4'm·r~\lFI113-l ~\lnl1b~13-l1~ .. ... .. 'U'Yl'U1'Yl?J tl\l ~- ~- ti'U ~11~51U!?l\l n ~11 bb~~\11 '1-i'b ~Unl1 ~u!?l1?Jtl\l F!Uti'U ~';i1~ 51U~ t1 n11~

q q

~1U~1a.J1Unl1b~tl\lbb'U'U1'Yl~ (~111~111U b3-l1111111~nlUWYl 2543: 5) ~\l'Y!3-l1~ ';i 13-l~\lnl1 '!JwYi ntJ1~1~ F11~111i~ &lt~\l m1~-r1\l 1?11 111u'Ylt~\l~u 111 utJ';i::1~ r11 ~111i~1 ~[;]1m~unu

•thtm~~aeHI A t1 nl11rl.!1\l A ~'Y1B~1 ~it~a.J?Jtl\lliltl a.J~ ~ tJ:wu ~~\! Fl 11a.J1::'Yl11\l .. ~\lF1113-lT~nF1{\l~ 2 (~.Fl. 2484 - 248 8) ~&i't~\lm11'1-i''YJnFIU1111~'Y!un~\lF1113-l bUU1'Yl~ 'Y11\l b tt~~1 ~ t~ ~ n°1'Y!U~ ~1U~]it~ 3-11 '1-i'Fiu 1 U~\l Fla.JU~D~ 11113-l Uti nlil1 n it~\! b ~ ~u tJ1::1'~ F11 ~111i~1 ~it~a.J b ~t1tJ ~ m {1~ 111~1\tm tt~~1 ~1 'Yl~~ ~FI11a.J~n~1 ~U1Ub~ tl\l ~\I m:: &lu

q q

1 'l-i'U11~ ru~11U1Ub~ tl\l ti'U ~11~ 51U '!JwYi ntJ1::1~ F11 ~ 111 i'Yl tl\l ~u~u b ~ tl bb~~\l ~\I Fl113-l ~1 Fl ru ~ q ~

~~~t1~1~ b~Ulil1n it~ 'W'u5d~\l b~~Ub~tl\l "U1::1~F11~111i:5'\l'Y!l~ti'U~11~ 5 1U" ~\!~ q q

b d't~'Y\1 b ~ ~1 n 'U n11 ~{1\lU1 Ubb tJ \l b~ t1 \l?J t1 \l FIU~1 1 n ~ 3-1~ 1::1 t1~1:: 1111 bb~ ~'U'Yl'U 1 'Y1 b:5'1U 1 ~ q

~ub~tl\l 4 rhu~tl n Flltl\l b~tl\lti'U ~11~51UeJUb uue.~ ~lil1 n nl1b~1 m~\l~1::'U13-l T ~ 5~3-11111 q

n,;111~~~lli1'Yl~~ar~~111uTn~u'Yli111t~u&lu (it~ 'W'u5b~\l 2477: rohu1'Y!u1 n) bb~::~ ';i::~ 1'Yla.Ja.Ju ... q q

(el1U ~~f~) b~~Ub~tl\l Gl1U1'l,\'J~ t!il :!JU1~13-I l~bb'YI\litbUUh\lb~~U~tiUil1~11'Yl~ bb'YI\lbb1n bb~::~u~n~1\l?Jtl\lF11~U1~'Y15511a.J~~nitm~1u~~1u (~1~~1'Y!a.J~it ( 51u ~~T~)

· 24 79: rohu1) \l1Ub~~u~t~\lb~t~\ld'buu~i:5'mb~~'Yl~1~ !?l\l~ b~a.J 1n1FI~~lilun lil n~1111 "n11b ~~u b ~~\I b ~tl\l b~tl\lti'U ~ "1 d'erb ~ ~u 1 tTbt~ n ~11~ub~ t1\ltJ1::n t~u [;]1 ~ 'Ylit \11 u~uA t1

q ..

eJ ~ \11 u ?J t1 \13-l 'Y!1 it~ Fl1 'Y! a.J u bb ~ :: ~ a.J b ~ lil 51 u ~ 1H u u eJ ~ \11 u ~ ~ .W a.J ~ b eJ mb ~ ~ bb ~ :: t1 n f u { cu q QJ cu

nl1\l?Jd1\l1un~a.JFIUli?!JU5113-l1'Yl~- ~11" (b~a.J1il1FI~~li1Ufllil 251 3: FhU1 )

Uti nlil1 nit n1:: bb~~1 ~it~a.J ~11 ~\1~1~ ~{1\l'U11m n1 Fln11bFI ~tilt 1 'Y\1 1 U'Y! ~FlU t1 u ~ 11 ~51 it[;]1 ~ b ~unu T ~ ~1 u'Yl F111';i~ 2 4 80 Fl ut~u ~11 ~51 itu 1 \l n ~ a.J 1 [;]~1 a.J nu

q q q

?J'U1Unl1Q~1~~11 1 um1tJ~ ~bbtlnlil1nn11b uumru1itF1a.J?Jt1\leJ~\lbFl~ ( .Wa.J~1 111 .W 'W'~?!!u~~ 2544: 18) ~n~\l~1\ld'~\lbn~m1{ti~U1';i1rl.!m1a.J~~1u - ~11 ~m1:5'~rff\lh \l .Wa.J~1u b~ tl\l ti'U ~11~ 51U 1[;]bbrl h\l.W 3-l~ ~. 'W'u5 b ~\I h\l.W 3-l~,ieJ ~ 111\l1Ub ~ ~utJ1:: bil 'Yl L9i1U1U

q q

~UU1U 111rum1a.JFh~t1UbUU:il1U1Ua.J1n 113-l~\l~Ub~tl\lti'U~'U1\JQD'U[;]1~ ~1u1m1huu q ~

e.J~I11Ut~al1 it~ .Wu5b~l1 b~mn'-t.J11'H1W113-I~UU1U~~1U113-1~11A~hWUL~~1111 ( ~3-IL~ q

Fh~::Jl~ 2 541: 37 - 4 7) 5uril1e.J~~am1uwYim~al1b~al1au~11nBTa1uth::1~F11~~{ ~ q

itvmBli'lt~~am

2.2 t3leHie:J'Ua <;i1 tlo1i1Lcu'lh:::-i'~A1liHil i"ih'4 cu fil't1tllifartli'lii'lh:t: tt1tt1~ <;i :t:'H';h\1 q M

'V4.A. 2 477 - 2500

1"1113-1 ~ a11 n11,Z1 b~Ua't.h::1~ F11 ~~{bb~:: t9i'1 ~Wn a11 ~U L i ~a~ A~ a11 rlU Fl'J13-I Fl ~ U~:: «11 Aa-~f~·t.h::n1n1 ~ ~ ~'YI ~ 1 n'YI ~1 tJ J11 b ~a11 bm 1 F\ ~th::n1 ihl1~ tJ ~i'lB'YI'l-t'1~t~ a\1'W ~ b~ a11 ... th::b~Ub ~a11n1 ~.Wu5 bb~::1 ~UB11a-Jt~ a\1th::n1nu 11a-1 ~111"1113-1 F\ ~t~a\1 AUt u«11 A a-~~ furl u

q ~

~a b fi~~~\1 b ~11th::~ mJb ~ 3-I~U ~Jl11::b ~U dri\1 e.J ~ L iAUaU ~11nBTa, fu15 n11i'l111'\.h::1~ F11 ~~{ q

~ar tJ L m-h ~13-11UfU~1UF1113-Ifb ~a11 a~~ 1 U "~U/'W\1 F111 ~11" ~~h n ~ bQ'W1:: b ~a11 n11b~ a11 ... ~

1::vd111 ~,Z1'Yi' a11 ~unu ~,Z1f~ t i~ b da'YI1t~ mt~ ~b~a11'Yi' a11 ~ua-~1 n~u a ~111 hn ~ m1tl11 n!J

b ~a11 b~ a11 ~u ~ 11nB1ut utl1::1'~ F11 ~ ~ {it'Wu Bl i'l t1~111d~ F1 au~111ua tJ 1?111tfu ~11 bb 'I.J11111U

b ~ t~u hi'b ~ t~11tl1:: btli'lb~ tJ1 A a 111Ub ~ t~utl1::1'~ F11 ~~{u1Ub~ a11~ ~ ~ n~rn:: m1uwYi n bb uu

"~U/'W\1 F111~11" bb~::~a ~bb i'l1n\11UAUA11!?i'1u1~uB11a-J'Yi'al1~uHtl1tJ1 u ( a11C1 uui'l~n{ 2540: 6 )

\11'Ut ti ti'U ·t.h::: t.n't1'll ';i ::: -r~ A1lif (;l iu1cut~ a\1

\11Ub ~ t~utl1::btli'ld«uit~~1WJ11-b~::.W ~u1 n11~1 n "'WI1 F111 ~11b~ a11" ~ar tJ m1 ... ~ ~ n11U n A1al1 bbUU b i'l F11ilU1 ~ r~ mci1 b ~a\1 ~13-1 ~11?lu b 1~1 ri1U 1 'YI qJ b UUb ~El\1 ~1 bb 'YI1n111 Fi er,z1 b~ a11 b tlu'YI ~ n bb~I11Ub ~ t~u~art~d~ n11a 6u1 t~a ~ ~~ b uutl1::1'~ F11 ~ ~{1n1 n11u uu ~

1"1113-1 b ~tl\1 ~art~1 'Y!a-l~b UUA'J13-I (] n ~anb b ~a~ Eltl EJI1iaa-~ ~ r~ t~1 ~ 1"1113-1 ~1 Fi'ru rlU'YI ~ n ~1U cu Ql Ql do9

Fi'uA11~1U'YI~n~1U~1111 'Yh1i~11tJ~::b~tJ~b~a-Jb~a-Jlil1n "'W\1F111~11b~a\1" ~bb~b~u ... «11 Aa-~1 u~ ~ ~1111 b ~a-~~u 111Ub ~ t~u~1 it11'W n11b tl~ tJU~1u~1~~ n1TuwYi n 1?111 n ci11a ~111 ?J'~b~U 1!?i'bbn 'll <;i :t:-JG1A1lif[;!-f!ij'\1'H-Jr;~a 'U a<;i1tl51U t!El\1 it~ .Wu5b~l1 ~,Z1b~Um~El11111n11

q q

tl1::n au~ tu111a-~ 1"1113-l~t~ EJ\1bli11u 1tJ~Ub~a11J11 4 'Yi1u~1!?i'fu'W1::u1a-~11n ta11 n11bb~l1 rff11~1 n

11n~1unn111bi'l'W"1 n11~~n11An~1 n11'W 1:: F11~u1 ~nJ11tT11,Z1b~um~a11AU~11tl b~u m1rff11~a-11 FJa-~au ~11nBTa,t~ai1U11~1vla Fi'1bb~::i111nm11 u~\1'YI1~11a-J ~11n11bA ~au 1 'YI1

q

t~al1nU!Jn11U1 ~11b~a-JFha5u1tJ~1n "~U/'WI1F111~11" ~11a-JEJI111 d1~~1nA11a-Jtdl1a-JI11tJ1u ~i'lBF11 ~U1t!EJI1n1TU1U3-11 rim11 ib VI~ e.J ~ l U3-1 3-13-IEJI1bb~::FJ113-If~a~Jl1tl1 u'Yi'ai1~U3-11 n~u

QJ q q cu cu

t~ tl,Z1 b~UEJU~Ui'l bb 1~ ~El 3-I~'Yh 1 ib ~El 1!?i'11 nU!Jn11U1b 'Y!ci1~Ubfl ~~1 n 1"1113-113-J'WEJ h ~El n11bU~tJUbbU~I1n11UnA1Ell1 'W.Fl . 2475 (it~ .Wu~b~l1 2477: 93)

1 0 11'HI1~th::1~FI1~1Wi 2557 JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

l'ln'l'l~'Zifl~~'l::U'l::'Yl~'"l'l'l1'1l~~tm'\J (L:S'1 fl1~N) eJnfl~~La1 fl~fl'IJ~"1 , , cu ,

L U'\.l,L ~fl~'l1'"l'Zifl~ La1 fl~ flU ~'l1'1lo1it ~ (1 nuwYi n 1 '\.1,th::11ii 1'11 ~ lil{ ' ~

il.~'\.1,BlmHiart~rJ,_h::'111'1111ii

(:u1nm~) fl~fi11~eJ~'l::th::YJm'l'l1'1l~~ti·N'IJ (L:S'1f11~N)

ru 'Yi~l'f~La1fl~ i~·r,.)lilflU~'l 1'1lo1ii ' '

tb::nuuvH'htllilfl~1~LU'\.1,m~m'lL~fl1'\.1,~ 31 a~'Yl1F1~ ~.1'1. 2532

-----·­-. ----__ ...

'Ylir~~fl tl'i~1GIA161'1il.r,r\I'H161ii\J~·n'!I5Tu 1lfl~ il,~ ~'\.j,rh\ll~ ~.1'1. 2477 ' '

~flLU'\.1,n1'lflBU1t1El~lilLLUUL'Yla.iL'\.1,~thLuuth::11iil'f1~1il{il.~'\.1,ti1'Ylt1

~ L U'\.1,Fl'"l1~ L ~tl~ L tl~1'111 nl'l L~ ~ LL 'in L~ tl1 nuL ~f)~ La1 eNEJU ~'l1'1lo1it '

ueJmnnd ~\1~ &i1u1u1'r116fU:!JU1';i1~ ~eJ\1~~::~1'YI3HfU (5·.m ~~Ta) ~\lllar:u:: n ~11~\ltb::1~A1auamu ll~l ~fl1~«\IA3-Ila'ieJ\IeJU~111J5TUtl1\IU fl1tl11?i'l UUeJ~1\I ~ r~~

q ~~

n ~11 ~\I n11~\l ~Wii1U~eJ\11J11l3'J eJ\IeJU ~111J5TU ~ ~U1 n11~eJ\I-J' ~au I1U1113-Ill~ ~::aar~ ~ q q ~

m1:5' ~ m1 An'H-1 aar~t m-h::~::ll1n m1le.J ml ~~FJ1 au1~'Y16 5~1a-~ ~ ~ nitm ~ 11a-~ ~\I m1 q q

ll 'Yl1 n ln ~ ~ A11a-~fn ~u ru ru1't1 eJ\1 ~u 111 u,Xu ll~:: l iteJ'YI1U1 \1 ci1ul uum1 ~u'Yl eJ ~~ uu m 1 QJ QJ Q,o Q,o

UWn ntJ1::-J'~ F11 a(;l{~\l l~ 3-1 r~ ~A \Ill UU lleJUn1~UWnn ft1U1Ufl1'H-1 ~U ll~:: ~ A ~'1'11\1 Fl1 au1 "1 cf I cf "' d' ~I 0 d 0 d d "1 I T

ll'Yl1n bUbUeJ'YI1 ll(;l "~U/~\IF111~11" aa-~~UluUn11U1\11Ul~~Ul~3-13-11l1~Ul1~\l b'Yia-1 ~~

1'li'mrmnu5umtl1::neJul~m~a-~A113-IU1l~eJ~eJ ltlu "~u~uu1a-~" "~1U1Ue.J1ll~\IU1\11~" ~ q

~\ll UU~1U1Um~af1\ltJ1Ull U\lla'ieJ\I~eJ\1 n ~3-11JU~ 3-llla-hl 1 r~\I:UU~\IU1 na-~~ -~ t~mla~\1 ~\I q q ~

e11~~ 5~~3-1~\ll vmJ~eJ\1 n ~a-~1JueJu ~~1115Tu - ~11~ ~m uuAu1 'Yl~n~ a-~'Yiit\1 ll~::~ lb't-1.1 ~~ Q,o q q q

auu auum~~13-ll~11 'Yl ~~ eJ\I-r~u1 ~:UeJ 3-1~ ~ tJ. Vlu ~a \I A113-ll?i'1 ~ ~\In ~1111l UUn1~ q ... ~

tl1m 'YI~eJ qJ1 ~~ueJ\1 ~\I ~111 ~~u:u1 n m~n ~~~ eJ\IeJ1t:J.nitA a-~ ~~\llAa llar m::~\ll ~eJ\1~11ci1u 'Y!it\111?1~ m~~ul~~\I:U1 meJ n a11 ~ut 1~HI l Uul~eJ\1~11m~tl~::n eJu~hn~~a-~eru~11'YI1 qJ

~ el\ll:ij1 eJU1\I At Un1'j ~ eJ ~1ttehtt1~ ~:0 1 'Yl tJ t~ tJ ~ Flttm.J ~'j1~61Ul uuri1 ~\I~~ ri1tt'Yiit\l q ... q

(~'j::~'j'Yia-~~it (ehu &~~t~) 2479: 38 - 47) !?l\ln~11~muuri1tt'Yiit\l~eJ\IuwYim~eJ\I l~eJ\IeJU ~'j1~ u1U1 Wt.h::1&\ f011~l'!~it~utfl 'Y1 tJ ~1 m~unu ~\ll tlu~ff\llfll'!';h \11Ul ~ tJUl ~el\1,1'

q

~e) ~'j'I.J'YI~el fl1'j~Ufl ~eJ\11 ~ ~i:l ntt1'j13-lll~:: l~ el\1~ i\11 ~~:: l UU~\Il~ tJ1 nu 1 Ull~ ~ [11'1-l,~ q cu q ~

r'rn ~ fl'Yl gll~:: ~ F1113-l ~1 F1 ru ~ e1 f011 ~tt1~'Ylu iJ'j'ja-!tJ &I nitm tJ 1 ua ~1u l ~ tJ\Ill~1l1'J'1'YIUfl~ fl1'j ~ q q

eJ 6u1 tJ Fl113-ll uua-~1ll~:: Fl113-l ~1 F1 qJ~ eJ\11 ~ ~unu 1'j13-13-11 n n11 1?11 l~ eJ\1 ~u ~'j1 ~u1it ~\lit l ~eJ~ tJ1tl13-l ~1'1\1 F1113-l f01~'Ylu1 ~ e1 F1113-l r'rn ~ ft'Yl g~eJ\11 ~ ~i:l{Jtt1'j13-lll~::~'j::~qj qJ16 fl1'j~eJ\I ~'j::U1'Yl ~3-ll~~~'j:;~eJ 3-llfl ~1l:ij'1eJ~..r1 1 U:01U:: eJ'I.J fl FJ'jeJ\1 m\ll 'Yl~":: ~'Yl'j\J~l ~a-~1l1~ fl1'j~f1\l

cu do9 Ql q

ll~::\!'j flJ'I.J~ff\J~'jfl! ri1ttl~eJ\J'j11~U 1 ~~ flUWn fl~:: 1 ~ Fl113-l Gi1 Fl qJ nu1 ~UiJ'j'ja-lvleJ\1 ~U~~ ~13-lrlU~11lUU~1Flqj (~'j:;~'j'\13-I~U [eJ1U &J~t~] 2479: 1 09) ~\l~::rleJU~\ItFJ'j\Jl~eJ\I\11U l~ tJU~Ul~eJ\1~~ tJ1tJ13-IeJBU1tJb~eJ\J'j11~ l~ela-1 ttJ\IrlU~:O 1 'YltJ ll~ tl\ll UUl~eJ\11~ULi'j'j3-j~11 ... lel1 11 t~tJ~::~fl1'jl'I.J~tJUll'I.J~\I~UUfl1'jUWnfleJ~1\I'lf~l~U1 UtJFl~ela-11

q

Gi1U1U1(;l'!il£1U1'11~ :wtruYla.JWFl~~bb"in ~.Fl. 2479 bbG'!::Yla.JwFl~~~ 2 ~.Fl. 2496 T~nt~'t'li'~u-h 'l.h::19i1 Iii GtU£1U1'11~ bbflln~ ~~11uu n11tl'wYi n b~EJ~ ba:i EJ~ EJU G'l11'1l oTit'i u thd'lii F11 f!~n{il. ~,.51..., tJ f!!Y tJ 'l 'VI~ tJ Fl bb 1 n . . . b~a.J~CJ~ (;] Lintl FlUli'EJ~ ~,. ~~'l-i1bf!UEJ~1'1-tthd'liiF11fl'l-tfl(l1'1-t~1 ~rut ut;l·;aa:iEJ~ el'l-tb uut;l'Jbb'I1U1~uo11a.Jn1~ b '11~"1

~ . ci'JUL ~EJ~ La:i EJ~~u G'l11'1lo1ib~ n 'l 'r1 Fl'J1 a.J ~1 ~ (!!1EJ~ G'l~ m 'l Uj1U:: La:i EJ~~ i~11u~1' ~n ~U!JU111 a.J

~1 fl~1\l ~u~::l ~u 11 l ~eJ\J'j11~ eJ\Il~eJ\1 eJU ~'j1~61Ul tt'I.J'j::1&1 ro11 ~l'!~it~uu1 'Yl tJ~ fl n q ..

uwn n t ~ tJ Flttrl eJ \1 ~u~af tJd*U1l~UeJ Fl 113-1 ~\11 'Y1 qj 'Yl1\ll te1 ~1 &\~ eJ\1 ~11 ( ~11) a ~1U eJU~'j1~61U ~ ~ Fl113-ll UUa-11~13-1 nu~U~1 &~1 'Yl tJ i\lll~ Fl~\1~'1-l,U'ja-1 ll~::fl1'j'I.J'j:; fl eJUi'jfl'j'j3-j

q q

~eJ\Ji'j~Uvl el\1 ~U~'Yi1 Fl flJ'I.J'j:; ttJ~1%~ el1J1Ul~ el\lll~ ~:: ~af tJ 'j1 3-1 ~\I fl1'j~1 ~UiJ'j'ja-I'I.J'j:; l ~ ru q

rleJ\I~UeJU~\113-1 ~\llUU~fl~flJdFJ'j\Jl~eJ\I'Yl1\J'I.J'j::1&\f011~l'l~eJU~'j1~61U - ~11 1umeJU q

'I.J'j::1&1 ro11 ~~'~~l te1~1 &~1 'Yl tJ eJttll~~\l ~\ll~ 1'1~1tt\lll 'Yi'~~\11 ttfl1'j~ eJ l~11 'I.J ~ ri1u~1 a-~1 u~u~

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

ir\1 F1 :IHJEJ\1 tl1'H~EI\11::'U'U1 'Yl a.J bb~::"il:: b ~u-h ~HllU.fll~ tll1Atl~Tt.hd'~ Al ~~n{e:J'U ~ 1l~olU q

~1\ld"il::b ~a.J"ill tl"iltn 1 b~ tl1flU Am ~e:J\1 m11 ti'Yi'e:J a.J ~"illtlrle:J\1 ~u1 um1Fin~1 b ~e:J\11111::tJ::bb 1n q ..

(;]\I ,XU ~Ubb 'U'Ubb~::b de:J'Yll~ e:Je:J tl :1-Jl~\lb UUbbU 1b~ mnwrr\I~U "il::~~bbln tl ~l\IDl\1 A eJ tll1Atl~l ~1\I'Yl~\11 ~~tll11tlYlEI:IJ~"illtlri1Utl~l\l (n 1 \lb'Yl~"1) bYlla.JlU1::tle:J'U e:J~l\lhn~ "illtl\llU

b~tJU~Ub~e:J\1-rt\1 2 b~EI\I~la.Jl1tl ~::ri'e:Jw;h \llUi~l tll1U1::1~ Al ~~n{b~e:J\1 b~EI\IEI'U~1l~LJlU q

tT\11 i F11l :1-J ~l F1 ru bbn u Ttl'U 1 tJ~ e:J\1-r'i\i'Ul ~ 1 'Yl tJ~ ~ ~ eJ b~ eJ \1 e:J'U ~ 11 ~ ol it 'Yl ~ eJ b ~e:J\1-r'i\i 1 'Yl t1 T ~n t1 ~ Ql d.S 'I do9

b ~ eJ \1 eJ 'U ~11 ~ LJlU~ b tJ Ub ~ e:J\1 ~l Fl ru 1 u 11?!JU611 :1-J 1 'Yl tJ - ~ 11 b uuri1UU1:: tl e:J'U TIn tJ 1a.J11?! q ~

'W"ill1nJl b~e:J\Ie:JU~1l~Lnit1 Ubbd ~1rle:J\I ~Ube:J\1 u'U·;htl1::b~utl1::1~ Al~~;J{e:J'U ~1l~olUtJ\11a.l q q

rll1'YIUla.Jlnun (E111tl uu'Yl:S'n{ 2537: 9)

3. t:il eHI eJ'U lil'a1t~B1i11:u'll'at1'Gi A16H~li'il cvn,uft 't'lt~aar mi ~cu1 tl1'a 'at'VI11\1 'W. A • • "" 2500 ~HI 'W.A. 2530

n11 tJ 11 'U tJ 11 a.J u '!! '!! 1 n u bb ~:: ,;r n n11 b ~ eJ \1 ~ 1 tJ YT 1 tJ eJ ~ 1 \1 'Yl ,;r n .n1 tJ 'Yl ~ \1 n11

-r~tl1::'Yll1~e:J\I"ile:Ja.J~~~~~~ ou::-rn~n1u ~.A. 2501 Ula.Jltinl1bFJ~e:Ju1'Yl1bYll~1a.J ?J'U1Utll1 Fl eJ :1-J ~1U~t?l?J e:J\I~l1e:J'U ~1l~EilU T~n tJ1 tlb ?J lnil~lUb uu~ atu~l Fl rub~ eJ ~-rl\1 Fl1l :1-J

q .. ~

n n ~1 U'Yl a.ltl1::~1~U 1 i~\ltu b ite:J\1 l?i'1tJJltJ F1 tl Fll :1-J"ill n ~'YlB F1 eJ a.J~1u~t?l t:JU1 n n'U tll1~ b~e:J\1 .. .. q

e:J'U ~11~o1it~~u~ ~ ~n n'U~a.J1il ~~uT~n~u rh 1 '1-i'b~ e:J\1 bb 'Yl\ldti?l-ru FJ1l a.J ~u 1"il"ill n-r"'i'Ul ~ m ntu q .. ...

-r "'i 1 i?lu1 bb u 1'Yll \1~ l?!lu 1 b A1~"1i n "il bb 'U'U'Yl u utJ :1-J a.Jl1 ti'b uu u T tl'Ul tl'Yl ~ n b ~ e:J'U~'Yll1'll 1:: b 'Yl A ... ... q

rh 1 i ira.J~UEiill~1::'Yl'Jl\l FlUEI'U~1l~EilUn'U ri1un ~l\lb 'YIUtl1 bbuutu ~\I ri\1 t:J ~ ~EI tll1DWn n q

b ~e:J\1 b~ e:J\1 e:J'U ~11~ olit1 utl1::1'~ Al ~ ~n{il.~uBl 'Yl tJ1 i e:J~1 u TF11\I b ~e:J\Itl1::1~ Al ~~n{~l ~ i?l1tJ q ..

3. 1 u~'U't1't11\1 a\1 F13.1~ a\1 eJ 61 ~e1n1'aucuii nu'at-JGi A1aG1i'"ll el\1 Fl'Uel'U 61'a1t!B1i1 • tl11~1?!lUlillFJa~lU!nl:I-Jbbt:JU~I?!lUlbA1~~fi"ilQD'U~ 1 (~.A. 2504 - 2509)

n eJ 1 ibn In tl11b tJ ~ tJUbb tJ ~\I'Yll\1 ir\1 Fl a.Jtu 1 Ub~e:J\1 e:J'U ~11~61U'Yl~l tJU1::tll1 .rr\1 l?i'lUtll tlill~ q

bA1~"1i fl"il In ~e:J ln"ilUF11l :1-J-r~nun ~In~ EI\IU1::~1~U rl\1 t:J ~ 1 'l'i'\llUb~tJU~Ub~EI\I!n tle:J ~1~ m::bb~ ... .. .. tl1::1'~ Al~~n{'Yll\1 b~e:J n'Yl~\I'Yl A1T'~~ 2 500 b uu~ua.Jl TtnmQ~l::tll1~ b~e:J\1111e:J~1 u~~ .. tl1::1'~ Al~~n{~l ~ 1 u~d"il::tl ~l1fi\lu"il:S'tJ~~t:J ~ ~ eJ tll1U-r'U btl~ tJU~lUtl F!Urle:J\1 ~u bb~::tll1 '\JuYintl1::1~Al~~n{brh,!u ~\1~ 3 tl1::m1

U'atm~u'an Ae:J ~1\I'Yl~\I~\IFJ1la.JT~nFJ{\I~ 2 "ilUfi\I~U'YlA111~ 2520 t:J~m::'Yl'U "illtl~tllUtll1rn~\IF11la.Jb1tJtnUla.J (~.A. 2500 - 2520) rl\lt:J~1'1-i'b~EI\I~'U~1l~EilU~\IbUU ~Ubbtnu~ ~ ~n n'U ~a.J1il ~ ~uT~n~u 11?1-r'U FJ11 a.J ~u 1"il"ill n-r"'i'Ul ~ i?l1tJ b 'Yl~n~ b tluil ~ill FJ ~ eJ bb 'Yl ~ a.J

qJ d..9 q QJ

~ eJ m1 a.J aruFJ\I'Yll\1 tll1b~e:J\I ill~~ n~clb~ e:J\1 e:J'U ~11~EilUb ~e:J\11~~1~n~e:J\I FlU 1 u~u~ 1 bFJ tJ q

\] tlb~Ue:J ~lU~ill ~bb 'YlU1l~.[J1bb~::~e:J :I-J1~~Uilltl'Yl ~\1 ~-A. 24 7 5 11?1 tl ~'U :1-Jli;Je:Jtl J1a tl Fl{\1

L~1l~~1.Hl'i1t151UL'\.btl'l::1~1'l1~~n{\l.-w'\.1.5lrw -w .l'l. 2477 - 2530 1 3 li'll!l~~Fi Awl''"l4

(b~tJ\1 h!tJm~ 2539: 14) U~~tJ~\In~11~\l~~~eJn1''HJWnfl'Lh::1~A1~1?1{~eJ\IFIU~Ub;jeJ\I 1 ~eJ~!l1tJhi' mmJ Fl11a.J A~ n11b tlu~'Ju'Yiit\l~eJ\1~1 ~ b~unu ..

tl~::: n1~if iife:J\1 A eJ m1t ~ Fl11 a.J "h Fi' ru~ eJ \1-rlli ~ eJ n 11 A n'IY1 th::1~ A1 ~ 1?1 { bb~:: ., ... t U11 IJJFI ~'l1u\I~Ul Ubti\ln11~1nJU1 bA1'1Ylli fl~bb~::n11b~eJ\I t~mQYll::[;llUeJ 1?1~1'YI nd1a.Jn11

... q

'YieJ\Ib ~tJ'J ~\I~~ t ~tJ11~ru~11u1ub;JeJ\IeJU ~11~oTa.uwYimh::1~ m ~~?~{~u b ~e1~~1u t ~ ., q

b ~ur~11 a.J ri'1 Fi' ty~ eJ\1 '11 eJ\1 ~u~ ;J r111 a.J btl Ua.J1'Y11\I tJ1::1'~ A1 ~ 1?1 { eJUtJ11u1u ;JtJ 1:: b ~ & 1tnJUEi11a.J~U1~U t~ b ~u~1 n n11b~tJUU1::1~ A1 ~l?l{b~eJ\IeJU~11~Ei1U~bb ~~'VI ~1 tla.J1 n 1 u

q

~armi b~u ti ~:::-JGi-Jj;}!Of~'ml\1 bba:::b3la\1au a~1'l1tnil (a~1\1a\1b'21tl) ~eJ\1 'Yia.Ju t~a.J::~~ q q ...

bb~ ::\111-tb ~ tJUb ~eJ\1 ~\1'H-J j;}e:J\J a~1'l1fnUb 'U aar !J~ ~:::b~1\J'aa.l1\1 li>fbt)e:J O'aa.I'Ha1\1 iif'a~'W a't'IB q

"t.h:::a\1fi 't1-a\1 1Pi1-a\11Pi1bb 'HU\1"li'1'Ha1\1GJ1\1'W-a:::a\1fi ffuil."~Y~TI-rJ1 b tlu~ ~\11U~u\l b~a.J t~ ~\I~"~Y! 1?1

btlU~U

tl-a:::m-aif iif13-l A eJ n11~ tJ1 tJ ~'J~eJ\1 n11An1Y11::rKu eJ ~ a.J An'IY1 1 u'l1 eJ\1 ~u ~\I~ m1 q

IJ c IJ c c:!1 cQJ QJ c cv tJ" cv

'Y1 eJ\1 r!U~1U1~1 n11 n11 An 'IY11~ tJ n11~ :1-l :1-l'~-~. 11~1 n11 n11 eJU1 n'IY~\11U1 n'IY1 a.J1 ~ n q

1tnJUEi11a.J bb~::m1tff\leJ\IFim ~a.J1Fia.J 'YI~eJ~a.J13-1~1\I) t~m{1\11U~13-IrlU!l1FI-r~ ~\lb~~a.J n11 tff\1 Au~1tnJ uo 11 a.JtJ 1:: ~01 ~\I 'VIi'~~ u 11 a.J ~\I~ n 11 An 'IY1 AUFI'J1 bb~:: ~ ~ 1?1 111 u[;]1 u .. tJ1::1'~A1~1?1{btlwii1u1umn (u1~eJu11Fi A~'Y11uwn 2557: ffa.~.n11Yru) b~u 1::~n o1u

b~tJUb~eJ\IU1::1~FI113-Ibtlua.J1~eJ\I~\I'YI1~eJu~11~o1U U1b~ru ~JJ eJu~ b~tJUb~eJ\Ib;JeJ\1 q ., q

eJU~11~Ei1Ubb~::b;JeJ\I tJ T~o1 ~u A~!l1 b ~tJUb ~u\IU1::1~ F111 m tlum~eJ\11 ~ bb~::~ lnlU1 n11 q

~eJ\1~1::~'Yl Ei A1~U 1 l U~\I'YI1 ~ eJU ~11~Ei1U b tlu~u q q

'W.!Ol. 2 500 - 2530

n11b tJ ~ tJUbb tJ ~\I ff\1 F1 :1-l b ~1 ~tl F1 1 'VI a-J~ b;J eJ\1 eJU ~111.1 Ei1Unu-rlli 1 'Y1 tJ tJ Fl~ tnJU 1 ~ F111 :1-l ~ q q doS q

b tluunbb~uaYuFJ\I'Y11\I n1t1.n1~ n11~\1~1UFI11a.J A~ F111a.~.rt UFI113-Ib tlu 1 'YltJ'Y11111tnJuo11a.~ ..

~~n11An'IY1 u~::n11~~ n~ nd13-l~\lb~~a-~1tnJuo113-l'l1eJ\I~U ~\I~~ 1 ~ n11uwYi ntJ1::1'~ A1 ~1?1{ ~ eJ\1 FIU'I1 eJ\1 ~utJ-rm tJ ~ tJU r~ tJ-ru15 ~31 tJ l 'VI aJ b ~1 a.J1 l Ti'a.J1 n ~U b ~ eJtJ-ru l\i1UFI113-I .rl ~ ... .. ~eJ ~ Fl ~eJ\1 nuu~u'Ylff\1 Fla.J r~tJ~1:!-l11mb U\IU1:: b!l'Yl\11Ub~tJU 1rK 3 U1::b!l'Yl AeJ

.. tl .J' 3. 2. 1 \11'Ub '21 !J'U ~:::bll't'I'W'U/'W\1 !OT11 j;}1'a

b tlUn11flU'YleJ ~~1~1?1 n11UWn ntJ1::1'~ A1 ~l?l{i\1 b~ :1-l l~ tJ FI\1~1U1U!l1'1Y1 bb~::~UU bbUU "~U/~\IA11m1" ~~\IFI~A1~u1H bb~~a1m'flm5m1An'IY1bbUUl'Yia-l f~n1Ti'mfnlli1U .. ...

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

'YI~mm rn m1~b rhiu 111ub~ tJUbb uu 1'11u1u~armiriT1-1>1 'VI rub tlub ~a11n~nut u-a1 ~1 Ub~a11 .. . au ~11n51il, Trn m~ua-J1 b~a11au ~11Ti51Ub tlubb 'VI ~11a11tJ5-a1~ bn1bbn ~1 riau b ~Wil1 n111u • • b ~ tJmJ a11 A~~ ~11~-lrn '1'111 A~b~ a11 b ~ tJUb ~a11 tl~~iGhahHI flu~~1"l151ilu~~-r ~'VI" fl'~ tih1" • • • b uub ~a11111 Fl11 ~ bn1 bbn~ a11 a1 ~ 1u~b 1 ~-u1 ub~ a11 au ~-a1n 51u~ ~u a1 tJ 1j;m11 ~art] • • a1 ~1~n1eJ1 tJ~11 ~11a11 F1 F111 ~:rb ~al1b~al1~tJ ~11Ti51U~tl11 n£1 ~1UI11Ub ~tJUU1~1&1 Fl1~rn{ ~ n11u-ru b u ~tJu1~tJ~n11bn rn~al1b~al11 ~u1u~u bb~~ti'11n ~11~111.11~1'&1 A1~~n{bb~~~a~ ~ .. ~11 u~al1b~al1atJ~11Ti51U b~U m-ai11~u~nu ~1r;i'ub~1b~al1 b'YI~nm-aru~1~rubMm~aM1u

q diS 'I Q.l

g., d d o I c3 QJ QJ I d d i.J

b~1 b~a11 u~~ ~fl1~ b~al1tJ Fl ~~on~ b 'Yl A1fltJ1 ~ bb~~ n ~111:111~ ~u1 m-a~al111?l'Y111 A1b~al11?11tJ • • (F1~~~11~1'rn~11FI~b~a11 2513: 5-6) b~a11 ti~~1'Gii~'H~'J\1t~fi\1~\J~ 'YI~a "u1~1'&lb~a11 ~tJ~11Ti51Ufl1'1Y1Ti115~1U" ~a11 ~'YI1~au Fl~ban (~'Y11~au Fl~ban 2506: 1) bb~~b~a11 "b~a11~1~1a~-a~~n1" b~tJtJb~tJI1bb~~f:larnFJ11~trntJ ~1u1u ~u5~du U1b~ua1u~u1~Ti~ • • 1n1m1 "b~al1bb~~n~nut u-a1~1 Ufl1FJ~n~1uaa mQtJI1b'Yiua" ~11'YI1rn~aubbnu 1~'Y111111'u~ • 26 - 29 ~11't'I1FJ~ ~.A. 2529 Fin1Y1b~a11b~a11au~-a1n51u~armb1nrff11 ri1u1't'lrubtlum-a . .. i1tJ11man~1i 1 tJ~1U~u1 't'\3~ 't'l~a~tJFlUUJn~111 tJ~1U "~Ub~al1atJ~" ~1th1~ 11 ~11m~ • bn rn~1 n m1Fi'uFJ1'1 bb~~~aum ~ erin ~~rn b 't'lln m1ru~1tJ trntJ n~11~11 FJ11 ~ b tlu~1~a11b~a11 .. . atJ~i1Ti51U~ b UU~Uri1b itrn~al1 b~ai1'YI ~1t.Jbbvll11 UtJ~b 1~~~J1~ ~ - tl~nau~111 (~1U1U . . .. ~u~~du 2529: 2 - 3)

ua n~1 nd' ti'11 ~ eJ ~111Ub ~a11 ti~~1'Git~ fl\1 fi\J~~1"l15Tihi1-u'Ju~hnufi'~lil1n 1. u ~Tu • eJ~111u~a11 ~1~-a1n-r~ntuu~ (~~vr u11T'Yl) ~~vrbuuu11~1n11111u~~tnnm~ FJ1u 6 1au

~-a~-a1n-r~ntuu~ (~~vr u1-aL'Y1) b~1FJ~~~I1wfrn~u~11Ti51u 1u~ 6 b~'IY1t.Ju ~.A. 2530

~ m1u1~~um u1u bbuuu'Y!~at.Jmal1~~ bbuuQuu,b~u1~ b ~u b~~u'Yluar ~m1 trnt.Jm-a 1 't'li' .. 0' Q.l c3 cf I d ~ d

~1~~'Yl5 ~1~511~ ~1~~11~ 1?11~~UtJn11tJU'YlnbbUtJ "~U" bb~~n~111:111n111?111b~al1~al1 • ~a~ L U11~~~·hi1~11FlF111 ~~l1b~a11111 Ubb~U~UaU~11Ti51U bb~~n~~FJU~111f?i\~1~1~U • • • 'i,l I '1.1 !L1 I

I ld CVdddJ QJCj daJQ.Id d Q.l

~naFJ11~il1b'aai1UU ~UbUal11:111n111?111b~al1e:JU~11Ti51U 1?111b~1b~al1 n1~n11b~al1 ~Un1~'Yll1 • • n111b'Yl~":: rffl1~1't'I~111~1U1~~1~b~al1aU~i1'ZI51U1u ~.Fl. 2425 Aa ~1~tJ1FI~~I1't'lb'Yl~ • • ( 't1rn 1n 1 ~ n ,;) bb~ ~~';i~ tl1Jl n ~ ~ ';i\1 Fl ( ~U 1n ';i ~ n,;) ~U~I1 ~ ar tJ~ ';i~ b~1tJ 1 ~111 Ftb 5 a

n-a~'t'1~111~~~nu~n1m (~.A. 2434 - 2436) (~1~11n-r~ntuu~ (~~vr u1-aL'Yl) 253o:

Fh'l-i1) ban~1-ab't'1~1d'ri1u1 't'lqj~nf:le:JrnFJ11~bb~~~~~vrbeJmb~~bb~1 ~111~uwYim~a11-a11~1111 ~~11?1~11~11Fn1~bUU "au~" ~a~1 ri1Uban~11bb11?l~a~~U1 hi'bUUbe:Jn~1iln11~~au •

t1" d Q.l I tl' QJ GJ Q.l d Q.l

b 't'\1?1 n11~'t'l"aa Fln11Ti bTiU ~1~';i1Ti~1 ~Ubb~~~ l?l't'\~1 tJb 't'll?li1 tJ1U'Yl~ ~~ tJ 5UU1 bb~~~~tJ • • • -r~nutn~u'Yl{ b tlui?i'u ~11111Ub~t.Jub~al1d'b tlui?i'ubbuu1 ~bbn\l1U ti~~1'Gh~fl\1fi\J~~Ttlfi1il : • a1'U'J'U~Gf1'Ufl~lil1nb\J~1'U (i?i'UQUU~~u~n1 ~~'Yla\l) ~~~~~1ub~au~~1Fl~ ~.Fl.

2530 (~vhn~·.J18nFJ{\11u w.f01. 2535) EJ~111hn~ n11An"~YTth::1~f011~1?1~5um1u1u ~ EJ\1 L~ EJ\1 EJ'\J ~·1111 61 un eJ 1 ~Ln ~ n 1 1-r'I.J{LL~:: t~ n 't1 f01U '1'11 \IU 1::1'~ f011 ~ 1?1 ~~ EJ\1 FlUrl EJ \1 ~ U 1 U

q ~

1tJ~EJ\I "~u;l?i1u 1u" r~ ~~'VlU1~ L uuLFl~eJ\1 ~f) ~{1\I'\J1on n11'Yl1\11~u611~ 1 u'Yi'EJ\I~u~'\J ~ ~

~1~\IUlillilUU • d nl nl QJe> .,., d

3. 2. 2 \11,Wll ti'UlJ'atb.fl'VIlJ'at'J Gl A1 GIGI'a'U1'Ub3Hh1

L UU\11UL~~u~~lil1~1?1l111 n11EJ~3-n n r~~~n11An'IY1 FlUFll1 LL~::L~~'\JL~~\I~EJ ~~ ~ ~

L UU1::'\J'\J ri1u1 'Vltlh UUL~EJ\IU1::1~ f011 ~l?l~L~EJ\1 ~\I'Vl1~ LL~::.n~.fl1 Fl r~ m UUL d'EJ'Vl1 !?l1Un11 ~ ~

tJ n Fl1EJ\I U'\J ~\ILL~ n11 ~\1 L~ EJ\1 LL~::L:5'1 L~ EJ\1 1?1 ~EJ ~lilU~1 LL'Vl1n1\l F!~ EJ\1 L:5'1 L~ EJ\1 uT~'\J1~~ EJ\1

-r~~ ri111 tJci'\I'Yi'EJ\I~ut~ ~ LQW1:: 'l u~ar~-r'f:lm ~~ 5 n11tJ n Fl1EJ\IrlEJ\I~ LL~::e.~ ~ m::'Yl'IJ~ Li1 ~~u ... uEJ nlil1 n d cJ\1 ~~EJ ~ ~~U~1ULL~ ~::rlEJ\1~ 5utJ 1:: n EJ'\J 1?11 ~ ~.n1w.n ~ f011 ~ 1?1 ~ 'Yl-rw en n 1

~ ... ~

~mu~a1 F1 qj~\1 611~'f:l1 ~ LL~::1~U6113-J \11UL~~UU1::L.n'Yld~ a1F1 qj L~U ~\1'll11bba.hh L'll\1

(L~~geJ Gfel\1~\1L'll\1) ~EJ\1 L~~ l.fl1Fltl'Y'IlilUflliJ ~\IL~~uufin 'Y'I.f01. 2490 LL~::~~~~ 'V'I.f01.

2499 ~EJ~1 ~~a-JW1 'Vl~1 UgeJ tl-atf~A1GIGI{~a1'U LL~::L UUFJ~Jl~L~a-Ja1 Flqj~EJ\I€i ~1U~ n ~11 ~\I L ~EJ\1111 L~ EJ\1 ~'\J ~ 1111 Ei1u11 L~ tJLQ'Y'I1:: n11U lhtJ 3-1 OJ 'rl ~ 8 ~1u~ar ~'Y'I1:: L:5'1'1J1m\l Fl L 6 eJ

n13-l'Vl ~1\1 ~11'Y'I ~'YlBU1:: ~\ll"i LL~:: n1 1U n F1 1EJ\I ~ OJ'rl ~ 8 ~1U~ ar ~ 3-1 OJ'rl ~ L 'Yl f011ll'\J 1 ~ ( L~ ~

l.fl1Fltl'Y'Ili1Ufllil 2513: 45) L~EJ\1 'll-adli-JGJA~'VIel\1 bb~tb3lfl\1il'U~'a1"lJfiTU (mh\1a\1b'll'll)

'V'I.f01. 2505 ~EJ\1 'Vl~U t~~::~~ ~\ILUUn11An'IY1U1::1~1~LL~::L~EJ\I'Vl~EJ113-l'f:!U'Vlit\11UEJ'\J~":1 q doS q q

~1\1~ n1\l L 'Yl'Y'I":: L ~3-1~ tJ1 mJ'1U1lilL~11 tJ~ar~-rl?luLn ~U'Yl~l?lEJUI?i'U n ~11~\ll?i1U1ULL~:: L ~EJ\1 L~1 • ~'YlBU1 fi'Vl1~ti~ EJ\IW1::LLrl1'\J'IY11 Fla-~ ~\IEJ1 Am'l ~n ~1u~ L tluLEJ n ~11'Yi' EJ\1 ~uL tlu'Vl ~ n~1~ n'\J

~ . ... LEJ n ~11ri1un ~1\1 L UUn11a-JEJ\IJJ~UqjqJ1~11?1-r'Ulil1 n.n1~UEJ n ( 1~U611~'Vl ~111) 1 u~111 L 1~1 ~1111 ('Vl~u T~a-~::!~ 2505: 5) ~11d'luL~EJuw~f01~m~u w.f01. 2505 ~\11UW1::11'f:l'Yl1U L'Y'I~\If01W 'Vl~EJ~'\Jru~u 'f:l~w~ OJ EJ~6tn OJ 1~~nnn,;'l?l~m113-J 'luTEJm~d~m1~~~a-~~

q Q.l q q q~

'VlU\1 ~m ~EJ\1 ~\1'Vi1 GJau~-a1'!1oTut -uaaft~ n-aa.~'Vi~'J\1 a-a-a~ a 'VI fi'll-ata\1 Fi 'VI'a\1 r?i1-a\1 Gl'1 u 'ViU\1 • ~1'Vi ~1\1 Gl1\1~'atel\1 Fi t~ ~~ EJ:I.-j ~ LL~:: L it'EJ'Vl1 ri1u 1 'VI tY L ~~'\J L ~ ~\llil1 n'VlU\1 ~EJ~ EJ\1 L ~ 3-1 l.fl1 F1 tJ 'Y'IlilUfllil ( ~\I'Vl1 ~ ~'\J ~11'f:l61Ul u~ar~ m~'Vl ~1\1~11'Y'I ~'YlBU1::~\II"i '1'11\1 1?111\1 1?11 LL 'Vl'U\1~1'1-'l ~1\1

~1\I'Y'I1::EJ\110i 2505: FiTt.Z1) 'Vl~mLafLL~ il'U~'a1'!ffi1cU1-ua6iGJ (~.A. 2335 - 2475) ~EJ\1

1:: ~ n 61U fi1 ~~EJ3.-j ~ L 'VI ~1d'L ~unu r~ ~\11UL ~ ~UL ~f) \ld~ m UUU1::1~ f011 ~1?1~ L~ f) \1

EJ'\J ~111161UQU'\J'Yl1\l n11L~ a-~ LL 1n L w11:: n ~11 ~\ltJ1::1'~ L~EJ\1 ~1111 1 uri' EJ\1 ~UEJ'\J ~11'f:l61U • • f) ~1\1 Fl1'\J Fl-ru r~ m UU~\1 n11~{1\IU1ULL U\1 L~EJ\I~EJ\1 FlU~11n ~ ~ ~1\11 ~ar~-rl?luTn ~U'Yl~ • 1?1 EJUI?i'U LL~:: n1 1~ ~ n 1 1U n F1 1 eJ \1 LL '\J'\J L 'Yl f011ll'\J1 ~ ~ ar ~-r'f:l n1 ~ ~ 5 ~ L UUn1 1113-1'141 L~ EJ\1

eJ '\J ~ 11 'f:l 61 U L ~ 1 tl '\J .fl ~ f011 ~ 1?1 ~ -r ~ 1 'Yl ~ lil U ~ \1 n1 1 L tJ ~ ~ U LL tJ ~ \1 n1 1 tJ n F1 1 eJ \1 'Y'I. f01. 2 4 7 5 . ~ ... ~\I~ m.-J ~ ri1u'Vlit\l L ~~'\JL ~~\llil1 n111u 1~ ~~ EJ\1 1 'Y'I1J1tl ~ ~ f01~ L ~ EJ\1 n1-a'llij~'ll m-a'll n FJ'aeJ\1

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

3.j wo;, ~ ~ a"1uaar t~if~-ag:t~1\J'aa.I'J{I ffu:m n-aa.I 'H ~'J\1 a-a-a~ a't1fitJ-ag:a{l fii' 't1'a\1 t tlu"li'1'H~ 'J{I b 'Hqi

(~.A. 2436-2453) lU Yl . Fl. 2515 (1::~n o1u 2524: 5 - 7) n1';ili';i 1 EJ~::b~EJ~

eJ ~1 \1 Fl ';j e:J'U Fl ~ :I.J b ~wd''Yi1l i\11 Ub ~ EJW~J eJ \1 ';i:: ~ n 1 r;l~u m ';j 51\1 €l \I:U1 n \11 Ub ~ EJU~ eJ \l un eJ u ~ • • AmY1 bb~::un ~ ~1uAmy1~u'Y1 ~\1 eJ ~ b ~:I.J e:J:uu~ \l i:l:u:uuu . .. .

eJ ~1\11 ';in~ \111-tb ~ EJUtJ';i:: bJl'Yltl';i:: bJl'Yltl';i::1~ Fl1 ~In {D1Ub~ e:J\1~1\1-d'b ~ :I.J n ~11 ~\I b~e:J\I';i11lUtJ';i::b~UgU1 ~e:J\Ib~e:J\I:I.J1n~U b~U tJ-ag:-J~hileNeJ\J~ "J ~e:J\1 b~U e:J U1';i::FI~ •

' " " d ld 'i,IQJCj QJO I QJd

'YlUe:J n:u1 n n ~11 ~\I m ';je:JYl EJV~ b ~1111\1 b:I.J e:J\I'YIUe:J\I'U1 ~1Jl~ e:J\1 Flun ~ :I.JV~';i::1e:JV~';i:: 1111 n1';i 111\1 b:I.J e:J\1 .. . e:J'U ~';i1~51U bb~:: n1';i~ ~ n11tl n me:J\1 b 'Yl A1ilu1 ~~e:J\1 b~e:J\Ie:J'U ~ n1';i~ ~ n1';iAm~ntl';i::~1'U1 ~ • • 1u~\I'YI1~e:J'U~';i1~o1uuurff\lbb~~arEJ~~m~~ 5 :uu~\1 Yl.Fl. 2509 Yl1::';i1~ururu~ n1lAn~1 . " "

QU'U ~1\11 n1';irff\l h\lb~EJU n1';i~~n1';ib~EJ'\.tn1l~e:JU bb~::uru'Y\1 bb~::e:Jtl~';i';iFil Un1';i~~ n1';i " .

An~1bbGl1 ~\ln~11~\1~11n1l'Yi1\11U~e:J\Ii1l1~n1';il1-t~u~ n1';i'IJ';jrJJ::Tu';i1rJJ~mu - 1~n~ .. . lU...le:J\1~1-1> ';i1:1.J~\Ifl:Unl';i:I.J~e:J\I~nb~e:J~11D1Ubb~::b'YI~1n1~1~r;j'1EJ (b~Ue:J U1';i:: FI ~ 2516:

Fhtl';i1';iJl~e:J\I ~b ~EJU)

tl.J(Oi5J;:Jtl~il~ CJ1U iu~~~

.uJ l~"hiJltntO~ nl~lall~ll:U~IIO~J:~~ ,-,u:~hu~ihtzn t;~.;,.,.~·Hrh.J~ul: 3.J;

uuiau~;y~u ~uwi'l ru <~~O"'

ru llJj i'f'W9DntiffiVll1W

iu~ ... wqtl'im~:• w.V. . .,.I .. ~

~1a ~1\IU'I-l.Yi n b ~a \I ba:l a \I au 11 'l1tf o1 il.L 'fl. tl 'l::i'~ I'll fl (;! {i'i.~'fl.o1 'Yl EJ'!I €1\II'IWn a \I ~'fl. ' 'l::"r'rll\1 ~ . l'f . 2500 - 2530

'l QJ cf d dl i.J i.J I fZI d ~ tJ .. I QJQ f1"

b U~ :I.J EJU:I.J n 11 Fl n ~1 FIUFI11 eJ EJ1\I b u U1::'U'U :I.J b Ue:J'Y\1 b UUu 1::1111 Fl1 ~In 1~ :I.J~U

~\luwYi mb~::b ~EJu b ~EJ\I:U1 n'YI ~ mi1utl1:: bJl'Yl Fi1u eJ m~1 bb~::Yl\1 Fl11 ~1';j...l e:J\1 ~u 'Yi1l in1Y~ ... eJ ~ ~n~ e:Je:J n :I.J1 bbln n ~1\I:U1 ntl1::1'~ Fl1 ~~n{b~e:J\1~ b uub~e:J\1 ~'1-b t~EJ\111-l>b ~EJUtl1::bn'YldU1b~Ue:J b~e:J\In1';irff\I~:I.J~u n1';i'Yi1:1.J1'YI1flU FI~FI11:1.Jb~e:J tl1::bY1& bb~::~Bnl';i:I.J~e:J\I~un~mte:JEJ bU1-t • • ~'1-lmr\l b n!n ';h lU~1\In~1\I'YlFI1';i';i~ 2500 ~\I~U'YlFI1';i';i~ 2510 \11Ub~EJUtl1::1~Fl1~!n{

~:I.J~U~1U 1 'YI rub UUb ~e:J\1111 n ~ :I.J~1 ~<Wu5 bb~'U...le:J\1 ~Ue:J'U ~11~51U~ ~ ~ rl'U bb~J1 t ~\I eJU q Ql q q q

ir:~.J<W'u5nu n ~ :I.J~1 ~<W'UBbb~'U b Vi eJ m~1JlYl11-t~\l b UUb ~In n1';i~~ Fl1e:J\I~e:J\I Fle:J :i.J:lhu~ l91 bb ~~\ll 'It . . ..

bliu11 m1b~~uth::1~FI1fll'li~rl1u«a-rwu6num"H~{1\lF111a.JaYuFJ\lJl1~1u~~ b~u ~TuTu baleHieJ'U61 t~a\l ~u fl\lbF111::li bb~:: •t.ht-wi1'1P111 A1aU1bileJ\leJ'U61 t~a\l ~u FI~Jl1 n~11~11

q q

th::1~ m1 ~" b~a\la'U~11'rloTa,t~?J m im11 rofy.j1::1 EJV'j1:; 1'11 b ~a\l111'Yla\l ~ubb~::'rl1 ~-W'u6 bb~'U q q

b~EI\l'rl1mbl?lUTt~\lb~~3-l bb~::th::1~1~?J,hF1~1ub~a\l~'U~"1 b~U 1~?J~U!JU1113-I i'1?13-!'Vl11U1113-I

( i'~?Jth 1 'Vl qJ) bb~::i'~?J~\1 Fl~b~ EJ\l b UUI?i'U ua fl"il1 fl i{ I'J\l !;l:;y] aUJl1y.j Fl113-l fl1 af Fl ~1 uri' a \I ~U ~1wrl6m1a.J'Yl1\lFI1flU1~1~ (~u fl\lbF111::li 2504: 2; ~u FI~Jl1 251 3: rhu1) mt11~a

b ~a \I -w-at'I.J-at-J~ bb61 t'W"atn·ar;ih.liilii'W 611Pl~ 'W"atbt5'1'U"aa.l1 \l flbBeJ noaa.~ 'Vi 611\l a-a-a ow tht fi

'I.J-ata\1 fl ~ua mn n b tlub ~a\lth::1~ Fl1 fll'lifl11b~a\l m1tl n FJ1a\lt~ a \I b~ a \I au ~11'rlo1itbb~1 q

I'J\lU1bflUa 1 rftl1::'rl1'r!Ubb~::fl ~3-l'rl1 ~-W'u6 ~11111 Ub~a\la'U ~11'rlo1itflU'UflUUn11oW~U1t~a\l q q q q

~~ 113-1~\l m1u1 bflua'rla 3-1 ~-k11 tlt~a\1:5'\l'Vli'l?l au ~11'rlo1it 1~bbri flJl1y.jJliJ Fl1 fll'li tl1::'r!1 m do9 QJ q QJ

tl1::1'~t u11 ru11'1 ~~ ~1 F1 ru tJ1:: b i"j &bb~ ::1 ~UB11a.J'Yi' a \I ~u tJ1::1'~t~ a\li"j1:; b:5'1'U13-11\l rolbo a q ~

ma.J'Vl ~1\l fl11i"j ~'Y16tJ1::fl\l Fi tJ1::1'~ fl11fl{1\l aufl11~t:J bb~:: b ~a \I b~1b~ m nu F1113-l Fin~ ~'Yl t q

t~a\laUfl11~t:l (a.Jru'rl~'Yl'Vl11'Ufl~ 6 "Fh~fl11i"j~'YlBU1::fl\lA" :5'11'Vl1~?Ja'U~11'rlo1it 2513: q q

9) 'Vl~\llil1mfu~1\lfl~1\l'YlFI111~ 251 o btlui?i'ua.J1 u1::b~Ub~a\lb~a\l~'U~11'rlo1it~~n uwYi n1 UU1::1~ Fl1 fll'l{Uy.jUtfl 'Yl~nt~m~rlb~a\1111 fl~3-l'rl1 ~'W'u6'Yla\l~U b~U\l1Ub~~U'U1\l

.. q q

rl1Utl El\l b~ 3-1 1111 Fl t:Jy.jliJUnlil b ~a \I a a1u 1 uaar ti'W'atbt5'1'U'aa.l1\l f"TbfieJ fi'aa.I'Vi 611\l a"a'a'W a't1B u oat a \l fl 't1 -a \l i1 -a \l i1 bb 'VIoU\l ~1'VI 611 \l Gi1 \low-at e1 \l fl bit' a 'Vl1 u 1" rl1 u n ~ 11 ~" ~ tJ 1'11 .. d QJ t:ff cf CJ C3d cf d a i-1 I o d QJ eff q., I QJ d

eJ 3-1 b 'Vl Fl fll?l bfle:Jba.J a \I bb~:;y.j B fl113-l b~ ~\I eJ bfll?llil bliJ1y.j a 'VI a Fl1 ( eJ 3-1 b 'Vl Flfll?l [bliJ1y.j a 'VI~ flba.J a \I]

b~a\l~u~11no1it) (b~a.J 1Jl1FJ!:Ty.jli!Unlil 2514: 5) \l1Ub~~ut~a\l1::~n o1it b~a\l u1uoli't11u

n ~11~\lm1~\l~U~1ut~a\lFJUfl ~ a.J ~1111 1 wu1u~'Y11u ei1bJlm~a\l1 u :5'\l'Vli'~?Jau ~11no1it ... q q

bb~::~fl11:5'~?Jrh~1r?i''Ufl1~1'11::Q~~~ubiafl1~nua.J1bUU~1r?i''U (1::~n o1it 2527: rhu1

mX1 F1) \l1Ub ~ ~Ufl ~ a.Jdfl::'Yi' au~\l fl11 b ~3-lt~ ~1 ~t~ au b t1 1'1 fl11 ~fl~1tJ1::1'~ Fl1 fll'lilil1 fl~ bFl ~ o.i1 tl l?la ~1 uil ~ fl11b~a\lbb~::'r!u#uu11 tJ ~fl11bbfl1\l'Vl1 Fi1a B 'U1 ~ b~a\l'Yla\1 ~UEI'U ~11'rlo1it1 U

.. .. q

tJ1::b~ugu 1 t~?J m.wi"j1::tJ1::1'~ Fl1 fll'li1 ~Uo11a.Jt~a\l'Yla\l~uau ~11no1it q

lil1fl'rl1\li?i'Ulil::b~U11 U'U~\Ibb~ y.j.Ff. 2500 bUUI?i'Ua.J1 fl11U1bflUaJl1y.jtJa\lEJ~l'l~ bFl ~au 1 'Vl11 tJ m 1 ut~ EJ'Ub t~ l'l~U~ b~a\l~'U ~11'r!o1it~tJ11 nn1 utJ1::1'~ Fl1 fll'l{Uy.juo1 'Yl~~m1 b tJ ~ ~Ubb tJ ~\I ~\I ri aumX1tfUJl1y.j n11bFl ~au 1 'Vl11 ua ~ l'lt~a\leJ FJUI'J\l Fl\l'ri'1a.Jy.j13-J bb1?1U'rl1 ~-W'u6

.. q

1 tla.J11::'Vl11\11 'Yl~ nu G111 bb~ flaf~d' flmu::'Yl1\lU1::1~ Fl1 fll'lit~a\lb~a\lau ~11no1it~ b uu~1u q

'Vlit\lt~ a\I~J 1 'Yl ~~ Fl113-l~l?l bliiU ~\I b ~a \It~ EI'U b tJ 1'1 ~Ubbi?JU bb~::Fl113-l «3-loWU6t~ a \I FlU'Yi' a \I ~Utl'U ~~ 1 'Yl~~ ~ Fl11a.Jb uum'Yl1\ltl1::1~ Fl1 fl1'1{~13-l nua.J1'Yl n flaf~ t~?JmQV'j1::flaf ~~l'lutn ~u'Ylil'l au

... q

i?i'u~\lflaf~~nm~~ 5 liiU~\lfl11~1~uo113-leJUbUUeJI'l~fl~rutJ1::o.i1~U ~\lb'Vl~1i{bUUF1113-l i"j m ~13-1u1 bflua 51'1 ~ n~ru'Vl~a ~11'1U'Yl1\IU1::1~ Fl1 fll'lit~ a \I b~a\l au ~11'rlo1it1 u~ FloW ~u 1

q q

18 11'HI1~th ::1~A1atn~ 2 557 JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

~__,b~eJ\1eJu ~~1~oTu~Frn a-n uu5u'V!it-,5ub~ tJ1nu -r~ 1 'YltJeJ~1\1bb 'l'1~~__, €1~1-.11 ~ fi ~ bbar-.11u q ...

b ~tJUtb::i'~ Fl1~!n{1:: tJ::it~-, hhh1 fl!J-.11U~mn b ~eJ-.11~~1L91 FlU 1 u't1eJ-.1 ~UeJtJ ~11~ 5 TU€1~1\1 q

b~ u~L91 bb~ b ~eJ\1111'Y11-.1th::1~ Fl1 ~ L9l {~ eJ-.1 FlUb 'VI ~1d'~-, FJ-.1th1 n!J b uuri1u'V! -d-.1 ~ eJM 1 u tl1::i'~ F11 ~ L9l {itYlutfl 'Y1 tJ ~ar tJ 1 'VI~ eJ ~ b ~ a.J e1 bbar ~:: 1~ a.J1 n a.J1 tJun bb~ nYl eJ'Yi11 i FJ u 'l'1 eJ-, ~u .. b ~11~ b ~€1\11111 U€1 ~In~ €J\11nU hi'~L91b~U~U

m1~n~1b~eJ-.1111~eJ-.1b~eJ-.1eJtJ ~11~o1u~t1nuwYi n 1 utl1::i'~ A1~~n{it'rlu51 'YltJ~1-.1~u q ..

~__, b tlu11 n~1u~1F1ru 1 um1~~11ru1 Fl11 a.J «a.J~u5~1 a.J1::'VI'J1\1~u~~1 mbL91U~n~1 ~eJ \1 ~FlU~ ... ~ .. b Fl tJ ~tl1::1~ Fl1 ~ L9l {~1 a.J tlUa.J 1 'VI~ 1 tJ ~ ar tJ T L9l tJU11 Fl ~ 1 n Yl1 a.J bbL91 u~ 11\1 «u T L9l tJ bQ Yl1::

~ ~U1 n11'Y11\1U1::l~ Fl1 ~~n{~eJ\1 b~€1\1 eJtJ ~11~51U~\1 bb~ ~ar tJ ~1U~1\1~U~\1 ~ar tJoUtJ~ bb~:: q q

~artJf~nuTn ~u'Y1{~1 meJn ~11tl1::i'~ A1~~n{ 5u~::u1a.J1riFJ11 a.Jb tlubeJnJl1YlL um1 "~~1-.1 .. m1 a.J~ b tJ L91tl1::~n riTeJ m ~1 'VI~" nutl1::b 'Y1 Fib ~eJWU1UeJ ~1-.1~ n~m ru~ ~n1~1a.J nu .. .. ..

~1 n n11 ~n~1 n11tl~1 n!J~ eJ-.1 b~ eJ\1~tJ ~1 1 ~o1u1 utl1::i'~ Fl1 ~~n{it'rl utfl 'Y1 tJ~ ~ n

uwYinTL9ltJFIU~Ub~eJ\11::'VI'J1\1 Yl.FI. 2477 - 2 530 ~1nT~'YltJ~~-,11'~neJUbb1fl ~::bliw-h ~1-.1 bb 1n~eJ\1 n11b~a.J ~urin11tl n Fl1eJ\11::uu1 'VI~ 5ub tlut:J ~~1 n n11b tl ~ tJUbb tl ~__, m 1tl n Fl1eJ\1 ..

eJ u ~ 11~ o1u~-.1'W tJ1 tJ1 a.J~1-, ~-, n11ittJ1 a.J F111 a.J'VI a.J 1 tJ ~1~n u 'Y11 -.1tl1::i'~ F11 ~ L91 { TL91 tJ~ eJ ~u q

Fl11 a.J b tlu~111 U\11Ub ~tJu ~-,1 Ubbd bb uu bbt:Jun11 b ~tJu~ Fl-.1 ri'1u1uTFJ ~__, n ~ eJu't1eJ -.1 ~Ubb~:: Fl ~Utla.J bbtJtJ i?l'1U1U 11' bb~::n11~~ b d'eJ'VI1~U1 b~U€J ~\1 Fl11 a.J b UUa.J1'Y11\1U1::1~ Fl1 ~~n {~1a.J nu

~U~1~~11

b~€Jb~1ri~artJ~~u11U'YlFI111~ 2 5 0 0 ~\1~U'Y1FI111~ 2520 «a.J~U5Jl 1Yl 1::'VI'J1\1 .. Fl u'l'1 €) \1 ~ unu ri1Ufl ~ 1\1 ~ a.J1 n~u 'Yi11 i F!UeltJ ~ 11 ~ 51U~~1\1 ~1 L91UFI11 a.J b UUF! Ub ~ €) \1

q

m.J ~11~51U~ b tluri1WV1-d-.1~ eJ\1{~ 1 'Y1 tJ eJ ~1\I~L91 b~U ~\I b ~€l\11U bb 'U'U n11b~ tJUU1::l~ Fl1 ~1?1{~ q ... ..

u1 b~UeJ TL91 tJJl1~11 'Y1 tJ n ~1\1~ b tlua.J11n1~1U n11~ b d'eJ'VI1 b uu~1-.1~ b~eJ\1eJtJ ~ 11~o1ut1n ... q ..

t:JU1nb~1 nuf~ 1 'YltJtl ~1tJ~artJoUtJ~~\I~artJf~m ~~ 5 elUb UUt:J~~1nuTtJtJ1tJ~ eJ-.1f~ 1 'YltJL u ... q ...

m1~~u1~u~111FJ5~1u ~-,11?i'tl~n ~-,€) L9la.Jm1ruFJ11a.Jbtlu1 'YltJ~-,ri'l'1eJ\I~u1 tl 'W ~eJ a.J nu TL9ltJ .. q ..

~1uuTtJU1tJfl1 1~L91n11~n~1 fl111tl.!1\IFibt:JtlbbYl~ma.J~eJ~1\1 "1 €1~1\ln-5'1\1~11\1 neJtl1nu

t:J ~ n1::'Ylu1 U~tl1Ufl11 ru ~\1 Fl11 a.J b1 tJ L91U1 a.Jri11 ib~€J\1€JtJ ~11~51U~\1 b UU~UbbL91 U~ L9l nu q

~a.J1fJ ~~uTL9l~U 11?i'fu FJ11 a.J~u1~~1 nfjtJ1 ~~?11m 'VI~ t:J ~~ b tlu~u~ "1 ~eJ bb'VI ~ a.J ~ eJ Fl11 a.Jai'uFJ\1

'Y11\I fl1~b~eJ\I 'Yi11 ~\11UU~::1~ F11 ~~n{'Yi'eJ\1 ~UeJ'IJ (;1~1'rlo1Url fl ~ ~ !nfl1'W~1a.J 3-11 fl~U fl ~11 ~el q ..

fl1"H tJ ~~u~1 ~fl'Ufl1~~ ~ !n\11UU~::1~ Fl1 ~~n{u'V'lUtS~b~a.J~U~::b~WVI ~1 fl'YI~1 ~ b~U fl1~ Afl'IY1 «\I Fla.J 'rla.J'r!U 1 ~~1~n FJUyJeJ\J~U r~~~'rl1TU1Ub tluFtutin ~1\1 fl1~Afl'IY1 bb~::tJ\I'Yllil1~tl.!1

q ..

Fl11a.J «a.J~u5~eJ\I b~ eJ\IeJ'IJ ~~1no1itnu b~eJ\Igu 1 ~\lb tluu~::1~ Fl1 ~~n{~Vl:u1~tl.!1'V'l ~1~n~ bi1 ~ q

~u1 UeJ'IJ~11'rlo1UbeJ\I bb 'YlU~Iil::a.JeJ\IIil1 fl FIUtieJ1U11iJ~:ij 1 'Yl~ q .. ~

n1~ b ~ ~uu~::1~ Ft1 ~ ~n{~ b uuFJ11a.J ~1 F1 ru~ e1 \JyJeJ\1 ~ ud~\1 b D\I'IJ1 ub~ e1 b if1 ~~1\1 v ..

'Y1 F11~~1Y 2 5 30 ~\IDiillilUU ~\I m::bWfl1~Afl1Y1'Yi'eJ\I ~u 1~~u F111a.J~U 1:um n~u u~::b~Ufl1~ q

Fln1Y1 b~ en nuu~::1~ F11 ~~n{eJu ~~1n o1itn1~~u e11u~\l Gl ~\I~~ 1 ibn~ n1~~ m ~ F111a.Jf q ..

U 1::1~ F11 ~In { b~ eJ \1 bb~ ::'Yi' el\1 ~ Uel'IJ ~ ~1 'rl o1 u1 U'YI ~1 ~ ~1 U -#\I «\I Fla.J bFI~'JY:ij fl lil 1 ~Uo ~~ 3-1 q ~

u~::b 'W & ~13-1 ~\I Afl'IY11il1 flU~::1~ F11 ~~n{ueJ fl b~1'lleJ\JyJeJ\J~UeJ'IJ ~~1'rlo1Ubel\l r~ ~el1 A~ fllel'IJ q

'Y11\Ia.J1U'IY~1'Yl m 1 um~Afl'IY1Jl ~il ru ru1'Yi'e1\l ~u -#\I~ r~ n ~ ~ ~n 1 Ulil1~ln\11U1'rl1 fl1~a.J1 n~uT~ ~ q QJ Q.l "" QJ

U~1'rlqJ'rl1TU1U un1'rl1fl1~-#\11 Ubb~::ueJ flyJeJ\1 ~Uel~1\l n11\lm1\l bb~::\11U~ Fl1'1Jb~ ma fl ~1U 'YI~\I:u:: b tlu\11u1~~~eJ\IU tJ.~oi1~n1'Ylm ~~ a.J'YI11'Yl m ~~~1\1 '1 b tlu~1u1 m1] 'Yi11 ~u~::1~ Fl1 ~~n{ e1u ~~1'rlo1Ub tluu~::1~ Fl1 ~~n{'Yi'eJ\1 ~u'YI~\I~eJ\1'\.J~::b 'Y1 A1 'Yl~~~1~1 ~bif1 he1 ~ ~n~eJ\I'rl1 ~eJ ~1\1

q

... cf ~el'IJ~1U~U

IK\I,!U uurim~eJ\Ib~eJ\1 "el'U~~1'rlo1it1uu~::-wim~~n{u'WUoL'YltJ 'W.FI. 2477- 2530" q

r~m UUeJ B'IJ1 m~eJ\1 b~ el\1 el'IJ ~~1'rlo1Ub~el Flf\1 b tluFtuti fl ~1\13-1 (1.!1] ~a~1U 1 Uel ~ ~n,Xu 1~~{1\1 q ..

F111a.J b ~eJ a.J T ~\I'Y11\I'll~::1~ F11 ~~n{~ e1 Elu1 ~~\I rP11 b~ eJ\1 e1u ~ ~1n o1ub if1 nu m ~eJ Elu1 ~ ~\I'Yl eJ\1 ~u q

eJ'IJ ~~1n o1Ufl1 ~'VI ~\I 'V'l. Fl. 2 5 30 ~\lil:u:uuu ~ tl.!:: b~ en nutT\1 b tlun1 ~~1'1J~1a.JeJ\I ri m1a.Jf q q ..

bb~::iJeJ a.J ~\11u'll~::1~ F11 ~~n{u'V'lu51 'Yl~~ b~ ~1ife1\l nub~eJ\IeJ'IJ ~~1no1u1 u~1\l Fin'IY1 e1 ~1\lb tlu .. q

~::'IJ'IJ ~1tl a n-#\ltl\1 b ~m U ~'\.J~::b~U 1 ~~ fl1~rl flb~~\I\11Ub~ ~UU~::bJl'Yl,i eJUiiJ::b UUU~:: t~nU 1 un1~u11 u b tJu:ij1uiJ eJ a.J ~ ~ a.JJ1 T ~\I Afl'IY1 ~eJ 1 u bb(;1:: Fl1~~ m~~ m CJ'V'l~a.J bb~Ufl1~Afl'IY1~1a.J

~ .. q

nu~::'YI'J1\I fl1~Afl1Y1 ~1uu~::1~ F11 ~~n{bb~:: F11 ~~n{~1mgu~ b~miJeJ\1 ~eJ 1 u

1un1~Afl1Y1'll~::1~F11~~n{eJu~~1'rlo1it~~::'Yi'eJu:u1n'll~::1~F11~!n{u'V'lu5 q

eJ'IJ~~1'rlo1uneJu'Yl FI1~~1Y 2 5 30 e11:u n ~111~11 ~~ ~u1 n1~'V'l e1 ~:N FJ1~ b ~u:u1 n n1~ Afl'IY1 q

~ ReJUiJ1\I ~m \ie1\l bbar:u:: 1~ 3-11 flUfl bb~ n bb~~\11 ~b ~UF111a.J'V'lm m 3-1 biJ1 1:u b ~el\1 ~1\1 '1 bb~:: fl1~ U1 b~Uel Fl #\I dFJ \1 b UUbb U1'Y11 \I'YI~\1 ~ eJ \1 fl1 ~ AU'YI1 Fl113.J lil~\1~ \1 &1 eJ \I'Yi1 ~ eJ 1 u b 'W~1 ::'VI ~U1U m fla.J1~1 u~ ~1U~tJ\I~fl'IY1fl~i1 ruru1n11u1u11 ~\ltJ\1 A'u 1~'V'l'IJ IK\I,!u ~\I b 11 Afl'IY1'rla.Jnu

QJ Q.l Q,l q

r~ m if 1 ~\I rPl1 «\I b fl!n bb ~:: « a.JJl1'!Yru 'rl11U1 Ub ~ eJ ~{1\1 el\1 ri Fl113.J -r Fl113.Jiil ~\I~ b n ~ ~ u~ eJ 3-1 .. ~ '

Go<' d V i.l co d o I

'VI (;11 fl'YI ~ 1 ~ bb~:: Fl11a.J 'VI~ 1 fl'YI ~1 ~u UbeJ\1 Fl eJ Fl11a.J fl11'YIU 1 b n \11'rl1 n1 ~'Yl FJ1~ m::'Y11 eJ ~1 \1

20 11'Hf1'ith::11iiA11;1iii{ 2557 JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

n11Afl~1~~U1 fl11~fl\l n11b ~ tJUt.hd'~ Fl1 (;l!wh1fl\l ~U~\1~1 b tlu~ fl n11An~1 't.hd'~ Fl1 {;li?Jft 'Yl tJ ~1~b YitJ\I~'"JtJ1 'Yil'fi'\11Ub ~ tJUb 'YI ~1if1 U~1U~'YI ~ fl~1Utbd'~ Fl1 {;li?J{fl ~1\1 ~ ... ... U1~~'Yl BJl1~ 'YI1 fltl\1~1tJ1 ib ~UJl1~fl ~ l?l'lTI?l b~U~Ut«1tJ b ~11~\11Ub ~tJU'Y11\I'lb~1~ Fl1 {;li?J{

~flU1~l~ Fl1 {;li?J.fi u&11~fl\larubfl\lfl ~bb~1

eJb~tJU~fl~fl'U~1~Fltl.!eJ~1tJFI1{;li?J11~11!:J l?l1. Fl~~1 l?l1'\.Jb~'Zl1 fl1~11!:J~tl~fl~1 ~ . ~

tl~ru ru1il.~uB~bb u~u11 'YiibF111~~bb~~b~tJu b ~tJ\I\11Ufl~1\lm~'liu 1?11\IU1~b~u 11a-nf11 mru1 ~ ~ .

~1tJ 1?111~ bbrl'U'Yl rll?l~fl ~fl'U~1~Flru Fl ru1~11!IT~1 n (;lmuueJ l?l :J.J Fin~1 ~1111 1 uifl\1 ~u~1 i • • Fl. 1 bb u ~ u 1 bb ~ ~ 1 ~ ~· 1 n l?l n1 flu n11 Fi l?l b ~ t1 1 n u n111 b F111 ~ ~ tl1 ~ 1~ F11 {;li?J {it~ u t5 b ~ fl 11

"b~fl\lfl'U ~11'Zl Ei1U" ~ fl'U~1~Fl t\JeJ'Yl1\l Fl tJJ119!1~~~11t\J1U1~b~U'U'Yl Fl11 :J.J bb~~ 1 i Fh bb U~U1 q q Q.l q q

1 Ufl11tl-rutl1\l bbm ~ fl ~1\1 ~ ~ ba tJ l?l bb~ t« 1 tJi fl~1 n l?l'YI ~1 tJU1~ fl11 eJb ~ tJWYh 1t«b Vi tJ\ItJ-rutl1\l . ~ . U111ri1u 1~{;l1:J.J11t~tl-rutl1\lhl1?11:J.JA1bm~u1"rf\I'YI:J.JI?l ~fl'U~1~Flru~n l?l~il.~ut5 ~~U'Y11Jl~ . . ~

~fl\!Fi 'U11~U bb~~~ru~1'Yl!:J ~:J.Jvr'Ylfl\1 ~U~:J.J'YI1Utl.!-nl?l(;l1mtl1~l~FI1{;li?J{ :J.JFI1 bb~~b~flU1 . ... . tl~ru ru1 t 'Yl (;l1~1t!1~1'~ F11(;ll?l{ tJ m1Fin~1 2 5 54 n ~ m ru~ 1?11eJ~~1~FJru~ Flfl t1~1m 'YI ~fl.,f\1

Q.l Q,l Q.l q

bb 111 n1 tJ bb~~ ri1~111~ fl ~ b{;l:J.J fl 1 u~1\I~'U b ~\I~ (;ll?l~ fl \1 n11 bbfll ~u'Yl Fl11 :J.Jd bb~~~flu~1~ Fl ru ~ . .

eJ1~11!:J l?l1.6mu&i Fl~u111 'U11ti.!1Bfl11111(;l11U1~l~FI1(;ll?l{ 2557 ~bbU~u11ie1b~tJU ~

u-rutl1\li f) b(;lUfl'U1\I ri1U~1 ntl~ru ru1U~UB~ ri1 ~\I'Yh f) ~:J.J1 b ~tl'U b ~tl\1 b UU'U'Yl Fl11 :J.J bt:.J tJ bb ~~ q cu QJ QJ

1 uFlf\ld f) ~1\1 hfi m:J.J iflu n~~fl\l~m~~ b uuFJ11:J.J-ru ~ l?l'Zlfl'\.J~fl\1 ~b~tJu

"'"" 'H'U\16Hl

FJ ru ~ {;l\J~ l'l?l 'Yi11 A~ d~ fl \1. ti~:::-J~h!i eJ\1 e~u 61~1'!1fiTihu.uaJ~:::-JG11' ~?~'ti\1 l"l~dl eJ\1. :J.J. tJ. ~ .. • • • 2513.

~\I 'Hi 1?1 fi'U 61 ~1'!16Til1 'U aar ~'W~::: L:ij1'U~:J.I'J\I ALfie! n~:!-1 'H 611\1 a~~'W a'Yifitl~::: 6{\1 fl'YI~\1 ~1~\1 • ' o I ., I d' .I ("' <9 1 l?l1U 'H'U\Iti1'H61'J\II?l1\I'W~:::eJ\IFl. fl1\lb 'Yl~:J.J'YI1UF11: :J.J. u.~ . 'Y11~~ fl U\11U~1~11'Zl'Y11U

b~~\IFI~ 'YI~fl:J.J'Uru~u 'Zl:J.J~~ ru fltJEitl1 ru ll?l:J.Jnnn-JI?l~tl111:J.J ~.Fl. 2505) q cu q q q~

~1 &lfl'U L,., ~ n1~ WtJ eJ\1 a a.~ L~ lii'W~:::a.~'H11~'J \1 A ( .Wa.~.W 53-f :~-~ fi h). 11111 b 'Yl ~ :J.J'YI1 UF11

h\I~:J.Jvrnfl\l'ti'~fl1fl1FI, 2509.

~n1'a1i'~u b~~~1~muul'l. 'l.h:d'mA1aG1i"'ti'e~<~~u . 'f!EIUbbnu : TR'a\lfl1'ae.J~~bt~n~1'a'Yl1\l 1~1fl1'a ~1'f!Tt.h~l'~F11~~{bb6'ld tJ'a1tJJFl~ ~vn1mn~tJ'f!EIUbbrlU, 2 548.

b~~ 1n1Fl~Yl~un~. u"a::1mA1aG1i"~a1u. m\lb'Yll'l~'V11uFl'a : ~~1Fl~ff\!Fl~F11~~{bb'VI\l • th~b'YlF11'YltJ, 2513.

b~ ~ 1n1 Fl ~Yl~Un~. a6J1UL uaarvcw"a::t~lTU"aa.I'N Atfifl n';i3-I'ViGI'J<l6f"a';i'Wa't15U"a::6J<JFJ 'tl';i\1 0 0 I IV I d' Q..l d' I

G11"a<l G11 U 'ViU<lti1'Vi GI'J <I G11<l'W"a::fi<J Fl. nl \l b 'Yll'l ~ 'VI1UF1 'a : ~ ~ 1 Fl ~ ~ \l Fl ~ F11 ~~'a bb'VI\l • t.h~b'YlF11'YltJ, 2514. (bif.EJ\llU\l1Ul'l'a~'a1~'Yl1Ubl'l~\lF1YlU1tlb~~ 1Jl1Fl~Yl~Ufl~ tu w1t.lu~mu l'~n~'a~bnFll'u~ 19 ~~U1tJU Yl.Fl. 2514)

u1n1n1 ~~~1uul'l. 'l.J"a::-lmA16JG1{ilcwu6l'tlv. n1\lb'Yll'l~'VI1UFJ'a : 3Jml6TR'a\lfl1'a~1'a1

ff\!Fl~F11~~{bb6'l~~U~tJF11~~{ 2524 . • u6'l ~u5b .Yh \J';i::-Jmfl16JG1i"~<~'VI1Gle~'Ua"a1'H51'il . Yl'a~UFl'a : h11~ ~~'Yl'a\l o'a'a~. 24 7 7. • •

~U'YlU6'l.

t.l~~1 ~tu'Yltl\l. 'l.J"a::-JGid~e~<JeJ'Ua"a1'l.151U : Gi1U'JU~6J1UAGllil1nLua1u. EJU6'l'a1~o1U : • • h11~~~Fl~o'a'a~. 2535.

cw<~A1'JG11"a111Fiaa1u LGlv cw"a::G!U'tl';i';i1'rHGl'H (u'l1 \J';i::'tla.~'H1m) . Yl'a~uFJ'a: ~ . t.l . Yl.

( ~~Yl1 U\l1Un]UYl'a~'a1~'Yl1U Yl'a~'J'a'J\l AbEitl Yl'a~tl\l Fl b~1 oTa.u-r~ Yl. Fl. 24 7 2)

Yl'a~Yl'a'VI~~u (eJ'JU ~~T~). r;i1U1U1Gl'!U!JU1"a13-l. ~.t.l.Yl. (~~~bUUmt~'atu1Ufl1'aQ6'ltl\l

Yl'a~t~Tu~mb6'l~e.Jn~'Ylo~~1l!n~unu1'a1~ ~\l'VIllnt~U6'l'a1~o1U tul'u~ 12 b~~1t1u q cu q ~ q

Yl.Fl. 2479)

Yl'a~'a1~-r~ T uu 6'l ( ~ ~~ u 1'a T 'Yl ). U"a::1Git3l fl<l ~'U Gl"a1'H51UGi1U'JUa6J1UAGllil1 n t 'U GI1U.

Rt.l.Yl .,2530.

~ tu"1'16'l 'Yl'V\1 'aU n ~ 6 "~1 tJ ~'a'aYl ~'Y16t.l 'a~~\! F1" ~\l'VIl ~ t1 u 6'l 'a1 ~ o1u. 'W"a::'l.J"a::-JGi ua ::cw';i:: • n"aWtl nlii'W a Gl~ 'W';i::t~1'U"a3-I'J<l Atfifl n';ia.I'Vi GI'J<l6f';i";j'W a'tltlU';i::6J<J Fl. ~- t.l. Yl. ( ~ ~~

b if.t~\l l U\l1Ul'l'a~'a1~'Yl1Ub Yl ~\! Fll'l 'VIa-It~~ b~1'VI ~\!'4 qj~'a1 Ei'a ( ~~Yl6'l) ~"1'11 ~~ ~- t.J. ~- 'Yl .

~.1 . tu b~'a'VIU1Yl~tJYl6'l1~Fl~tl1Jl'arnllnb'Y1YlA~U'Yl'a111 ~. 24 ~f:lU1tJU 251 3) • • 3-I'VI1~EIU Fl~btln . 'l.h::-JGi-JGl'ViGI'J<Jt3lfi<Jfi'Ua. EJU~':i1~Ei1U : h\l~~~A~Ei'a'a~. 2506. • • tl\l tl'Yl Ei ~bdU. fil~<l fTGl'J"a"a~U oH<ln1';ifi'i'U'Vi1UGI::taU't11<1 !iffiU1FIGIU"a::1ifl16JGl{'ti'e~<Jriu 1 'tltl : . ~ ~

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

d c (V Q.l d

Fln"M-1 Ei n11lil\JYI1~ fl'l.H'l11~Ei1U, 2 5 24 . • ca::~n BTU. 1Y1cucU't1"J'U. m.H'l11~BTU : a..~.'lht (~a..~·vhtlu~ca::~nlu\11UtJn~eJtheJT'lHHlbb~:: • •

~~~nu~~n 1'~o1tn;;t1u~n1~ ~Tu~~rnu ei1bJlm~eJ\JLu lij\JYil~eJu~ca1~oTCi. 6-7-8 .. . . ba..I'M-1tJU 'W.Fl. 2527)

b;;tUeJ u11~F1 ~. 'll'l~1'~h:ila\1a'UG~ n1'lAm~1'll'l~'H1'U1G~'l.la\1a'UG~'l1tf5Til f11"J13-16hFirut~a\1 . . .. n1"aAm~n'll'l~'H1'U1 G~ 'li a bb cu~U1'U1\1U'l~n 1'lb~f.I"J nu 6l'llfi1'W bbG~~ hf11fi f.ll'lib~ 'U . • n1\Jb'Yl'Wa..IYI1UF11 : h\J~a..!~'l-i'1\J'l-i'U~1W;hn~U~'UF1Fl~Utla..!1'YltJ1 , 251 6. (~ca::~n • • • \11U'W1::11~'Yl1Ub'V'l~\JFl'WU1tJnun carutJ'YlB ru ba..~ca1~;;tilnu111m11YI11 ei1bJlflb~fl\J

• • • ';,.J

lij\JYil~~'U~11~EiTU 3 'W~Fl~n1tJU 'W.F1.2516)

~'\-!, Fl~Jl1 . U'l~1'G11'~"J1 A16l'U1 b:ileJ{IeJ'UGI"L f}'\J~11~Ei1U: a..~.ti.'W. (~a..!~bUU'U11t\.!1n11 • • LU\11un~wrhuv5u~ncam:h1arbb~~~1th;;t1arFl~ 'Ylfl~ ru 1m1\1Fl~b~fl\J eJ.b~eJ\1

~ . lil.~u~ca1~o1u 1 'W~Fl~mtJu 'W.Fl. 2513)

~U ;;t\JbF111::~. Gi1'U1'Ub:ileJ{IeJ'UGI. 3-I.U.'W., 2504 . • ;;ttltJ1 'Yl1U'Yl1. 'll'l~1'ffiA16lGl'h1a\1~cu~a1cubbG~~auG~'l1tf51U. vu~·n~o1U : a-.~.ti.Y-1., • • •

2548.

Y~a..~u T;;ta..~::~~. 'll'l~-rnr~A~'t1a\1uG~~b:ila\1a'UG~'l1tf5Til (ad1{1ii{lb'll'll) . nca\Jb'Yl'V'la..~YI1UF11 : " do9 q q

h\J~a..l~n11~a..I~'W1&~t1. 2505.

eJ11t;l uu'Yllijn{ behwcufi1...,~.ntcu a'll'll. G~1"J : 3-13-13-la\1'2.1a{lf11'Ub~cu...,, {l. a..~Y~1;;t1caFJ1a..~ • • a..IYI11'YltJ1~tJFl~UFl~U'Yl11hoo.J a..IYI1;;t11Fl1a..l, 2535.

'U't1f11"J13-I t 'U"J1'l6l1'lbbG~~'WU\1 a a

~1'1-l.'JU 'iuoa..~d U. "b~fl\J'W1::1fl'W1::tn1." L U n1'lU'l~tf3-11tf1n1'l b:ileJ\1 bbGI~tf3-ltf'U L 'U'l1W • • • tcu.n1f11

' Gl~-lcuaam~f.l{l b'Hua -Jcuii 2s - 29 a\1'H1f11 3-l 2529 , 1 oo - 1 32. ~~~n ~t~Fl':i':i?itn,

uca1ru16mca. ~eJUbbnu: a..~Y~11'Ylm~tJ~e:Jubbnu, 2529.

Q~fl\1 ;;tU'Yl1111rll~tJ. ";;tt;l1UJl1'W~fl\Jn1111ij'tJtl1::l~Fl1;;ttn{'f1eJ\J~U : ncarua;;t1U 1::YI11\J • 'W.Fl. 2503 - 2535." lu ar~1'Ufi1'W\11CU1~f.la1t~1'll'l~1'ffiA1aG~i'lu'll'l~b't1A1't1f.l

'l~'l-'111{1 'W.A. 2503 - 2535, 1 39 - 1 73. bbt;la..~;;t~ '1-ia..~uwn, ucacaru16mca. • • m\Jb'Yl'Wa..IYI1UF11 : Tm~tJu;;tT~n{ 2535 . •

"'W\JF111~1ca..r1b~fl\Ja..~ru'r!~a;;t1u." lu 'll'l~tf3-I'W{IA1"J~1'l.n1f11 4 b~3-l 3, 1 7 - 53 . •

L~!l~~uwntf51il.tuth::11iif'111it;~{i'tvn•5l't1£J ~.A. 2477- 2530 23 01-I~W~A 111~~'"-.t

1 Y~'fl'Hi ~ n FTt1 . "bb u1 ~ 1?1 bbt1::: bb U1'Yl1\11 unT'j ~n~1n a:lu ru ru1't1fl \1 ~u." 'JTH~1-aa L'tl't1t~ QJ q QJ Q,l Q,l q

B-a-aa.nfi-a1'!1 20. 2 (mn.£J1FI3-I- BU11FI:I-J 2550): 21 - 39.

b~ EJ\1 1 'l!EJ n1 t1. "th ~n m b ~fl\1 t1"Jl1'W~\I'Yl11?1 flU t1'j1'lfo1'ti,." 1 u 'lhijm11'tl eHI e'rtt 'YI'U'a1'1!1-!)'a d.9 q IIIJS cu

t~e::J~6ffl1V4'tleh1i~vl'rr?u~h~ 'J . ~a-~~FJf\1~ 2 , a - 19. t1"3-11FJ3-Ia:il?l'jfl1~~~u- 1'YlEJ,

U'j'jt\.!1Bn1'j. nd\lb'Yl'W3-I'Yl1UFJ'j: fl3-I~U'Y11'W~U~\IbbflU~~U~'l!~\l ~1rll?l (3-1'Yl1'l!U), 2539 . •

t1"1 EJ'l!~ 'J'j'j(U-rl?liL "m'j~n~1th:::1~ FT1 t1"1?11itY~uBL mh:::b 'Yl FT1 'Yl EJ." 'J1'a6f1-aB-a-aa.~ A"1a~-f

9,1 (mn.[J1FI:I-J- rlUEJlEJU 2522): 150- 166.

fl'j'j t1 uu'Yl~ n { "t1"tnUJl1'W n1d ~n~1t.h:::-J~ FT1 t1" 1?11d~ fl\1 flU w1." 1 u -a1 3-I'U'YI fl'J13-I'YI1~ • Q d dd ll.J' Q,.l (J' 0

'J'l11n1'a : e::J6{1'Ufll?lA"n'l!l-1, 25 - 32. fl'j'jtJ UU'Yl~n':i, U'j'j(U15n1'j. 3-I'Yl1t1"1'jFJ13-I:

Jl1 F11'll1'lh:::-J~FT1 t1"1?11 FJ(U:::Gf\IFI3-IFT1 t1"1?11 3-I'Yl11'Ylm ~El FT~UFI~U'Yl'j1h~n.~ 3-I'Yl1t1"1'jFJ13-I ,

2537.

o a f1' aa..t

'J'YI ti1'UV4'U B u~ ~\:11'U'Jlil t1

i?l1'j1-rl?lu ba-~l?lm~muwri. m-a'a'Ja.~mia.~'YI1\:In1'at~e::J"'tle::J~ a.aJia1u V4.A". 24 76 - 2494. q

1'Yl mitY~u55 n~'j FT1 t1" 1?1 'j ~ ~~11 (Uon 1?1 t1"1~11'll1t.h:::1~ FT1 t1" 1?11 FJ (U:::5 n~'j FT1 t1" 1?11

~l:t1~\lmf:l!m·n1'Ylm~EJ. 2543 . • ~ a-~vhl?l ~~~n.~un ~. 'U'YI'U1'YI'tle::J\:Ji'5'U1~ tt~~iru1'YI1\:I m-at~e::J\:1 1 'Yitl !Pie::J'ti'U'Jum-a!Pimft i4e::~

q ..:9 qJ qJ

te::Jn'a1'l1~1'J-a~·vd1\:l V4.A". 2483-V4.A". 2492. 1'YlmitY~u55n~'jFf1t1"i?l'j3-I'Yl1D(Uonl?l

t1"1~11'll1th:::1~FT1t1"1?11 FJ(U:::5n~1FT1t1"1?11 ~l:t1~\ln1ti!a-~'Yl11'Ylm~EJ. 2544 . • 1 'W t! 1 ~ ~ ~ FT t1. n1 'aU ii ~u n1 'aU n f1 'a e::J" 3-1 w "t1 ~ 0 6{1 'U b 'U aar tl ~ \'4 'a~ t~1'U 'aa.l 'J" flt fie::J

n-aa.~ 'VI ~'J" a'a'a\'4 a'YI fiu 'a~ a" f'i'YI 'a \:It \JutYTYi ~'J" t 'VI qJ ( \'4. A". 2 4 3 6 - 2 4 53).

tJ~ ry ty1itY~u5 n11 ~ m!I-13-I'Yl1D (U on 1?1 t1"1~11'll1'lh:::1~ FT1 t1" 1?11 FJ (U::: ~ n~1 FT1 t1" 1?11 0 Q..l 0 d

1'Ylm~m'll1n11Fln~1. 2515.

t1" a-~ FT ~ ir m & 'll EJ 1 bb ~ ::: Fl (U ::: . a r11 u .n 1 V4 f1 1 1a.1 i' u 'a~ 1~ A" 1 a~ -f t ~ e::1 " e::1 'U ~ -a 1 t1 B Til. ... q

flU ~'j1'lfo1'ti, : F1 (U:::A~u FT1 t1"1?11 3-I'Yl11'Ylm~ElflU ~'j1'lfo1'ti,, 2 5 50. • • t1"1'Yl~ 1hFT1FTi'1?1. 'a1ti\:11U1it~U'a~1iA"16f~-foa1'U 2322 - 2488. ~flUbbnU : Jl1FI1'll1 •

U'j:::-J~ Fl1 t1" 1?11 bb ~::: T u 11 (U Fl ~ Fl (U::; 3-IU~EJ Fl1 t1" 1?11 bb~::: Gf\1 Fla-1 Fl1 t1" 1?11 3-I'Yl11'Yl EJ1 ~ EJ • ~ flUbbnU bbt1::: FTU~1~EJ'W'YI ~ n~ti! Gf\1 Fla-1 ~ :I-J J1 T ~\I Fl (U::::I-JU~EJ Fl1 t1"1?11bb~:::Gf\l Fla-1 Fl1 t1"1?1{

QJ q q q

3-I'Yl11'Yl Ell ~EJ~ flUbbnU, 2 549.

~ a-~1~ Fh~:::Jl a:l. n1'aUi''U t u ~ti'U'J'a'awn-a'aa.~l 'Yitl.fl1 f1 n ~1\:1 t U'U'J'a-awn-a'aa.~'ti' e::J\:1 ~uo a1u . .. 1'Yl mit~u6Fit1u FT1 t1" i?l'j 3-I'Yl1D (U on 1?1 t1"1~11'll11 'Yl EJ FJ ~ ~ n~1 ( b '!Zua-~~~EJ FT1 t1" 1?11)

JOURNAL OF HISTORY 2014

e.J't-t~(;l ~\1,.;~11'H1J. '\.J';ig:-JG}FJ1iii'GJ{ilwurHia1u 'W.FT. 24 75 il\I~U'VIFf'J';j';j~ 2520. • • 1'Yltnitv·m55 fl'lo}1Fl1 ~(;]13-I'YI1U f:IAi1 (;] ~T~n1~Tt.h::1&i F11 ~(;l~Afl'lo}1 F1 f:IJ::eJfl'lo}1F11 ~(;]~

3-I'YI11mn~~~m.hm, 2553.

e.J11(1 uu'Y1:5'n{ '\.J';ig:-JGiFT1iii'GJ{ilwufi~a1u : n1';i~Jtf'l';j1g:oH'l.J';jg:tcwwn1';ifi!GIUUiin

U';ig:-JG}A1iii'GI{~'Jt~~\l~iii'1Uil\I~Uf'l~iii'~FTGI'J';i';i~~ 20. 1'Y1~1U~'t-tBeJfl'lo}1Fl1~(;]1 3-I'YI1U f:Ui1 (;] ~T~n1~1th::1&i Fl1 ~ (;] ~ Le.J L ~ ~ ~n ::1ua a flbQ ~\I hi' A f:IJ:: 5 n 'lo}1 F11 ~ (;] ~

3-I'YI11'Yltn~~~~tJ1m, 2529.

"' .. iii'3Ul1~W

u1~au\1Fi F1~'Y11uul1. (28 ~wn~u5 2557). iraun~w. ?i'111~m1thu1ty Af:IA::

3-1'1-t 'to}~ Fl1 ~(;]~ LL~::«\1 Fla-1 Fl1 ~in~ 3-I'YI11'Yl m ~ ~11~Jl n e.JU ~11 ~ 61 U. ~1Ufl ~~tJ:: LL~:: • ':,1 •