(j£1 - wrpcwrpc.gov.in/ccm/57ccm_agenda.pdf · 2011-01-04 · getco 1 220 kv s/c...

~ : q~ /CllfOjf~Cf) -I/ ~:lhnQ)~/ Cf)14~-4l1201O- ~ :1"4No. : WRPC/Comml.-I/CCM/AgendaJ2010- if 6 ..;;.,.:::-...O!!e: ""'

Ben 1:f / To,

~JAf\, 2D11

~~

~mcf)R ~

(j£1fIIr:r:;/=a ~Central Electricity Aut~O~Rt

~ ~ ~ ~ lJ;U i3lr 8 9001-2008Western RegionalPower Committee ISO: 9001-2008

~ -3, t:('f~~, mro (~), ~ - 400 093F-3, MIDe Area, Andheri (East), Murnbai - 400 093

~ Phone: 022- 28353222; 28200194; 28200195; ~ Fax: 022 - 28370193Website: www.wrpc.gov.in E-mail: [email protected]

(~<fi~)

~ : 57 err CllfUl~Cb ~ Cbl ~ Cbl Cf)14~-4l ISub : Agenda Notes for 5ih Commercial Committee Meeting.

~/Sir,

~ l:f;f <fi m~ ~ 11 101 12011 c€r 1100 ~ q a1 fcJ ~ ~ 1:f mcmrfr, CllfUl~Cf) ~ Cbl 57 err ~ Cbl Cf)P..r~-4l~ ~ ~ 0TICr~~ Cf)1{ClI~

~~~I

Please find enclosed herewith Agenda Notes for the 5ih CommercialCommittee Meeting of WRPC to be held on 11.01.2011 at 1100 Hrs at WRPC

office, Mumbai for your information and necessary action.

~ / Yours faithfully,

~:- '3Q(IGR1lj(1l{ /As above

~'\ ~0\ "l "--(\3lt gm/O. P. Singh)

~afUT ~ (CllfUl~Cb)Superintending Engineer (Comml.)

Mailing list for 57th CCM 1. Executive Director (Finance), Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd., Vadodara-390 007 2. Chief Engineer (LD), Gujarat Energy Transmission Corpn. Ltd., Vadodara- 390 021 3. Executive Director (L & RA), Madhya Pradesh Tradeco., Jabalpur-482 008 4. Chief Engineer (LD), M P Power Transmission Company Ltd.,SLDC, Jabalpur 482 008. 5. Chief Engineer (Comml), Chhattisgarh State Power Distribution Co. Ltd., Raipur – 492 013 6. Chief Engineer (LD), Chhattisgarh State Power Transmission Co. Ltd., Bhilai-490 024. 7. Chief Engineer (PP), Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd., Mumbai-400 051 8. Chief Engineer (LD), State Load Despatch Centre, MSETCL, New Mumbai - 400 708 9. Chief Electrical Engineer, Panjim, Goa-403 001 10. Executive Engineer, Electricity Department, Daman-396 210 11. Executive Engineer (Elect),Electricity Department, Silvassa-396 230 12. Addl. General Manager (Comml), Nuclear Power Corpn. of India Ltd., Mumbai-400 094 13. General Manager (Comml), NTPC Ltd., New Delhi-110 003 14. Regional Executive Director (West), NTPC Ltd., Mumbai-400 093 15. General Manager (Com. & CP), NTPC SAIL Power Co. Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi -110 066 16. Executive Director (Comml), PGCIL, Gurgaon, Haryana-122 001 17. General Manager, WRTS-I, PGCIL, Nagpur-440 026 18. Addl. General Manager (Comml), WRTS-I, PGCIL, Nagpur-440 026 19. Executive Director, POSOCO,WRLDC, Mumbai-400 093 20. Dy. General Manager (Comml), Ratnagiri Gas & Power Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai-400 093 21. Vice President, Adani Power Limited, Ahmedabad – 380015 22. Addl. Chief Engineer (R & C), Gujarat Energy Trans. Corpn. Ltd., Vadodara-390 007 23. Chief Engineer (Trans. O&M), MSETCL, Mumbai-400 051 24. General Manager (Comml), LANCO Amarkantak Power Private Ltd., Gurgaon – 122 016 25. Member(Power), Narmada Control Authority, Indore.-452 010 26. Asst. Vice President, Jindal Power Ltd., Tamnar, Raigarh, Chhattisgarh – 496 001 27. Executive Director (Comml), Torrent Power Ltd., Ahmedabad- 380 009 28. CEO, Reliance Energy Trading Ltd., New Delhi-110021 29. Member Secretary, Northern Regional Power Committee, New Delhi 110 016 30. Member Secretary, Southern Regional Power Committee, Bangalore 560 009 31. Member Secretary, Eastern Regional Power Committee, Kolkata-700 033 32. Member Secretary, North Eastern Regional Power Committee, Shillong 793 303 33. Member (GO & D),Central Electricity Authority, New Delhi –110 066 34. Chief Engineer (GM), Central Electricity Authority, New Delhi –110 066. 45. DGM(Power Systems), SAIL, Bhilai Steel Plant, Bhilai-490001, Chhattisgarh 46. Chief Engineer (Comml),NHPC Ltd., NHPC Complex Sector-33, Faridabad-122001,Haryana

AGENDA OF 57th MEETING OF COMMERCIAL COMMITTEE TO BE HELD ON 11th JANUARY 2011 AT WRPC OFFICE, MUMBAI

ITEM No.1: CONFIRMATION OF THE MINUTES OF THE 56th MEETING OF

COMMERCIAL COMMITTEE Minutes of the 56th meeting of Commercial Committee held on 22.10.2010 at

Mumbai were circulated to the constituents vide WRPC letter No.WRPC/Comml-

I/CCM/Min/2010-10016 dated 29.10.2010.

M/s Torrent Power vide letter No. TPL/SUGEN/COMMERCIAL/10-11/0162 dated

8.11.2010 (enclosed at Annexure-1) have sent their comments on item No. 7 of

the 56th CCM wherein M/s TPL have observed and requested amendment in

para as below :

Quote:

“GM, Torrent Power, stated that Torrent did not agree with decision of WRPC in

13th meeting and now they have filed petition in CERC against above decision for

sharing of inter-regional transmission charges and wheeling of ISTS power to DD

& DNH through GETCO transmission system and wheeling of ISTS power to

Goa & DNH through MSETCL transmission system.” -Unquote

to be amended to:

“TPL representative, who attended the 56th Commercial Committee meeting,

represented that WRPC should direct CTU/PGCIL to stop charging of (a)

Transmission charges for inter-regional links between WR and other regions i.e.

ER/NR/SR and (b) wheeling charges payable to Gujarat and Maharashtra for

wheeling of Central Sector power to DD, DNH and Goa until necessary

clarification is obtained from the Honorable CERC, for which TPL has submitted

its petition.”

Committee may like to discuss and confirm the minutes of 56th CCM

Agenda notes for 57th Commercial Committee Meeting to be held on11.01.11 at Mumbai 1

ITEM No.2: SIGNING OF PPA WITH RGPPL (FOR 5% ALLOCATED CAPACITY) AND ITS SCHEDULING

2.1 The matter regarding signing of PPA by RGPPL with DD, DNH and Goa to

enable scheduling of 5% capacity of RGPPL power, to the above beneficiaries as

per MoP order i.e. 2% each to DD & DNH and 1% each to Goa had earlier been

discussed in meeting held on 31.8.2010 and in 56th CCM where in for review of

status of scheduling of RGPPL, wherein the RGPPL had intimated that signing of

PPA may be done by end of November, 2010. WRPC vide letter No.

WRPC/Comml-I/Alloc.2010/1467 dated 28.10.10 had requested RGGPL to

expedite finalization of the PPA as the scheduling of 5% allocated power from

RGPPL could commence only after completion of all formalities viz., signing of

PPA, obtaining necessary open access, opening of Letter of Credit by the

beneficiaries of the generating station commensurate with the allocated power,

completion of all formalities by the beneficiaries etc. RGGPL and the

beneficiaries concerne viz. DD, DNH and Goa are requested to intimate current

status on above.

2.2 WRPC vide WRPC/Comml-I//6/Alloc-2010/1265 dated 15.09.2010 had also

requested RGPPL to intimate the date on which power station started operating

at full load (1940 MW) to enable effecting of the 5% allocated power to

beneficiaries vide MOP allocation order dated 29.3.2010. During 56th CCM

RGPPL has intimated that power station started operating at full load (1940 MW)

in April 2010 however they would intimate the date and time for the same. A

communication from RGGPL in this regard is awaited.

RGPPL may indicate the status of signing of PPA and date on which power station started operating at full load (1940 MW).

2.3 ED, WRLDC vide letter no WRLDC/OS/1664/2010/2312 dated 24.12.2010

addressed to Secretary, CERC (enclosed at Annexure-2) have sought direction

of the Commission on transfer of Jurisdiction of RGPPL from SLDC to WRLDC


with reference to the para 98 of the Commission’s order dated 18.08.2009 in

petition No. 283/2009.

Committee may like to note. ITEM No. 3: ISSUES RELATED TO SHIFTING OF CONTROL AREA OF

NSPCL FROM SLDC, CSPTCL TO WRLDC The matter related to shifting of shifting of control area of NSPCL from SLDC,

CSPTCL to WRLDC was deliberated in 55th Commercial Committee Meeting and

in a meeting held on 27.09.10. In 55th CCM representative of Chhattisgarh

agreed for shifting of control area in respect of 2x250 MW Bhilai Expansion

power plant of NSPCL to WRLDC for scheduling, controlling etc. CSPTCL

representative had added that 220kV lines from NSPCL-BSP are dedicated links

meant for drawal of NSPCL share by SAIL-BSP and any reversal of power flow

on these links shall be treated as a drawal of power by BSP from CSTPCL grid.

A meeting among SLDC, CSPTCL, CSPDCL, NSPCL, BSP, WRLDC and WRPC

was held on 27.09.2010 to discuss various issues concerning shifting of control

area of 2x250MW NSPCL power station at Bhilai from SLDC, CSPTCL to

WRLDC ( record notes enclosed at Annexure-3.1) . In this meeting, it was

agreed that emerging issues between NSPCL, CSPDCL and BSP SAIL

regarding any ISTS transmission charges or losses applicable to BSP, STU

transmission charges or losses applicable to BSP, bifurcation of combined UI

accounting for CSPDCL and BSP by SLDC etc. will be sorted out and thereafter

the subject matter of shifting of control area will be taken up.

NSPCL vide letter 01:CP&C:103 dated 3.12.10 has enclosed a copy of the

minutes (enclosed at Annexure-3.2 ) of the meeting held between CSPDCL,

NSPCL, BSP & SLDC on 23.11.10 at Raipur to decide modalities for transfer of

control area of NSPCL from SLDC to WRLDC.


ED, WRLDC vide letter no. WRLDC/OS/1610/2010 dated 24.12.2010 (enclosed

at Annexure- 3.3) has communicated views of WRLDC on the minutes of the

meeting held on 23.11.10 at Raipur.

SLDC, Chhattisgarh vide letter No. CGLD/WRPC/NSPCL_SHIFTING/CCM-4736

dated 3.01.2011 have requested that the matter may be put up in CCM for

review. Committee may like to discuss. ITEM No.4: INCLUSION OF NON-ISTS ASSETS FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF

POINT CONNECTION METHOD FOR POINT OF CONNECTION CHARGES

CERC Regulations, 2010 on "Sharing on transmission charges and Losses"

regulation 2010 are to come in force from 1.1.2011. The determination of

transmission charges as per this Regulation is required to be limited to the

network owned, operated and maintained by the ISTS Licensees or those

transmission licensees / SEBs whose assets have been certified by RPCs as

being used for inter-state transmission.

Only such assets as above will be included in for implementation of point

connection method for point of connection charges. Preparation of a cogent

network requires consideration of state owned lines also. The YTC for such lines

shall be based on the YTC of the transmission licensee / SEB as approved by

the Appropriate Commission.

The philosophy for inclusion of non-ISTS assets of WR for POC charges were

discussed in 56th Commercial Committee meeting of WRPC held on 22.10.2010

which were approved in 15th WRPC meeting. WRPC has submitted the list of the

lines certified for inclusion of non-ISTS assets to implementing agency and all the

constituents.


GETCO vide letter No.SLDC/MIS/1509 dated 3.12.2010 and MPPTCL vide letter

No.04-02/PSP-386/1408 dated 9.11.10 have requested inclusion of following

lines for certification as non-ISTS assets of WR for POC charges :

Sr. No. Line GETCO 1 220 kV S/c Navsari-Chikhali-Vapi 2 220 kV S/c Navsari-Bhilad 3 220 kV S/c Vav-Sachin-Navsari 4 400 kV S/c Jetpur-Hadala-Chorania 5 400 kV S/c Jetpur-Amreli-Chorania 6 400 kV D/c Asoj-Chorania 7 400 kV S/c Kasor-Chorania 8 400 kV D/c Vadavi-Dehgam 9 220 kV D/c Kansari-Palanpur-Kheralu-Jamla-Soja 10 220 kV D/c Vadavi-Mitha-Soja 11 220 kV S/c Soja-Mehsana-Radanpur-Deodar-Kansari 12 400 kV S/c Asoj-SSP 13 400 kV S/c Kasor-SSP 14 220 kV S/c Tarapur-Bhilad 15 220 kV S/c Tarapur-Vapi MPPTCL 1 400 kV S/c Seoni-Satpura 2 400 kV D/c Nagda-Rajgarh 3 400 kV D/c Rajgarh-SSP 4 220 kV D/c Satpura-Pandhurna

Committee may like to discuss. ITEM No.5: TRANSMISSION CHARGES FOR USE OF MSETCL

TRANSMISSION SYSTEM FOR CONVEYANCE OF CENTRAL SECTOR POWER TO GOA AND RGPPL POWER TO GOA, DD & DNH FOR THE PERIOD 1.04.10 TO 31.03.2011

5.1 The above issue for calculation of transmission charges for use of MSETCL

transmission system for conveyance of Central Sector power to Goa for the year

2010-11 was discussed during 13th WRPC meeting and 55th Commercial

Committee Meeting.

Chief General Manager (L&RA), MP Tradco vide letter dated 20.09.2010 have

submitted their observations on computation of above transmission charges

which are briefly highlighted below :


1. Return on Equity (ROE) calculated on the basis of tax rates received from

MSETCL (33.2175 %) while those should have been calculated at MAT rates of 11.33 %.

2. Interest of loan considered by WRPC as SBI PLR @12.25 as on 1.04.2009 while those should have been considered as it is claimed by PGCIL in its petition for the year 2010-11.

3. Depreciation not to be allowed after useful life of the transmission line is ended.

During 56th CCM MSETCL representative clarified that they are paying income

tax at corporate tax rate of 33.2175 % which has been communicated vide letter

MSETCL/STU(R&C)/ WRPC/16409 dated 20.10.2010 and this tax rate

@33.2175 % is applicable to MSETCL for FY 2010-11.

Further, Commercial Committee during 56th meeting expressed that issue can be

discussed in presence of MPTradco and as MPTradco was not represented in

the 56th CC Meeting discussion was deferred for next meeting.

Committee may discuss. ITEM No.6: LEVY OF TRANSMISSION CHARGES & LOSSES OF GETCO

NETWORK FOR TRANSMISSION OF 100 MW CONTRACTED POWER TO MP FROM SUGEN POWER PROJECT OF TPCL

6.1 The matter regarding levy of transmission charges & losses of GETCO

network for transmission of 100 MW contracted power to MP from Sugen power

project of TPCL MP TRADECO was discussed during 55th Commercial

Committee of WRPC held on 15th July 2010 and also during 14th WRPC meeting

held on 19.08.2010 wherein WRP Committee deliberated the matter and

Chairman, WRPC/CMD, MPPTCL directed both parties i.e. Torrent Power Co.

Ltd. and MPTRADCO, to sit together with the relevant documents and sort out

the issue amicably at the earliest.

6.2 Subsequenty, Torrent Power Ltd. vide letter No. TPL/Sugen/Commercial/10-

11/0200 dated 31.12.2010(copy enclosed at Annexure-6) intimated that the

meeting in this context was held on 15.11.10 at Jabalpur between MPTradco,


TPL and PTC India Ltd.(PTC) for sorting out the issue for initiation of 100 MW

power to MP. Torrent Power Ltd. further intimated that the issue wad discussed

and resolved between the parties and MPTradco agreed to start the off-take of

power from 1.12.10 and has yet to initiate off-take of 100 MW contracted power.

MPTRadco & Torrent Power Ltd. may indicate the status on above.

ITEM No.7: DECLARATION OF TRANSMISSION ELEMENTS INTO COMMERCIAL OPERATION BY PGCIL

7.1 PGCIL vide letter No. WR-II/VDR/510 dated 1.11.2010 have intimated that

125 MVAR, 400 kV bus reactor at Dehgam under WRSS-VII has been put into

regular operation. Accordingly, the monthly transmission charges of the above

reactor will be payable by concerned WR constituents w.e.f. 1.11.2010

7.2 PGCIL vide letter No. WR-II/VDR/509 dated 1.11.2010 have intimated that

315MVA, 400 kV transformer at Bina (MP) has been put into regular operation.

Accordingly, the monthly transmission charges of the above reactor will be

payable by concerned WR constituents w.e.f. 1.11.2010

Committee may like to note. ITEM No. 8: POWER PURCHASE AGREEMENT IN RESPECT OF SUBANSIRI

LOWER HE PROJECT (2000 MW) Chief Electrical Engineer, ED, Goa, Vide letter No. 101/01/CEE/Tech/1435 dated

24.11.2010 addressed to Chief Engineer (Comml), NHPC with a copy to Member

Secretary, WRPC have intimated that they had requested NHPC for holding a

meeting amongst the beneficiaries of Subansiri Lower HE Project in WR for

completing the formalities viz. signing of PPA etc. and so far no reply/comments

have been received from NHPC. A copy of above referred letter is enclosed at

Annexure-8).

Committee may like to discuss.


ITEM No.9: PAYMENTS OF UI AND REACTIVE ENERGY CHARGES As per the information received from WRLDC, the status of payment to UI pool

account and Reactive Energy Pool account as on 28.12.2010 i.e. upto week

6.12.10 to 12.12.10 of the current financial year is given below: -

UI Pool Account Reactive Energy Pool Account

Constituents Dues (in Rs.) Constituents Dues (in Rs.)CHHATTISGARH -46,683,102 CHHATTISGARH -3,317,288MADHYA PRADESH 16,241,385 MADHYA PRADESH 5,211,447GUJARAT -147,403,671 GUJARAT -206,838MAHARASHTRA -76,832,652 MAHARASHTRA -707,658GOA 10,307,883 GOA 148,337DD 80,419,321 DD 2,555,087DNH 26,634,699 DNH 834,143NTPC -31,493,999 NR Exchange 294,206,634 SR Exchange -29,226,253 ER Exchange 303,870,679 Jindal Power -1,162,703 HVDC Vindhyachal -91,562 HVDC Bhadravati -377,908 Lanco Amarkantak -83,984,084 Diff. Amt : capping due to O.inj >101/105 % -50,887,028 Diff. due to Addl. UI -369,901,622 Diff. Amt : capping due to O.inj & U.drl -172,929,857 Net Total -281,293,841 4,517,230

Committee may like to note. ITEM No. 10: GENERATING UNITS COMMISSIONED IN WESTERN REGION The generating units commissioned during last quarter are as follows:

Name of the Power Projects Unit No.

Capacity (MW) Date of Commissioning

GUJARAT Mundra TPP Ph-I, APL 4 330 24 Nov. 2010 MAHARASHTRA JSW Energy, Ratnagiri (4x300) 2 300 9 Dec. 2010


ITEM No. 11: TRANSMISSION LINES COMMISSIONED IN WESTERN REGION

The following lines that were commissioned during the last quarter as below :-

S.No. Line Implementing Agency

Anticipated target

1 400 kV Tappar( Varsana)-Hadala line Gujarat Charged on 02.11.10

2 220 kV V D/C Varsana (Tappa)-Morbi Gujarat Charged on 31.3.2010

3 400 kV D/C Ranchi – Rourkela PGCIL Charged on 30.11.10

4 400 kV D/C Raigarh – Raipur PGCIL charged on 30.09.10

Committee may note. ITEM No. 12: GRANT OF LTA FOR GENERATION DEVELOPERS IN SR. PGCIL granted LTA to following generator developers of SR as per the following details:

Quantum allocated to

Sr. No.

Generation Developer

Installed Capacity

LTA granted

SR WR NRPGCIL letter no. C/ENG/SEF/TA/L/S/10/008 dated 10.12.2010 : Vemagiri Area in Andhra Pradesh 1 Thermal Powertech

Corporation India Ltd. 1320 1320 1125 115 0

2 Meenakshi Energy Pvt. Ltd.

300 273 273 0 0

3 Nelcast Energy Corporation Ltd.

1320 1240 840 400 0

PGCIL letter no. C/ENG/SEF/TA/L/S/10/009 dated 10.12.2010 : Nagapattinam/Cuddalore Area in Tamil Nadu 4 NSL Power Pvt. Ltd. 1320 800 267 267 2665 PEL Power Ltd. 1050 987 700 0 2876 IL&FS Tamil Nadu Power

Co. Ltd. 1200 1150 575 575 0

PGCIL letter no. C/ENG/SEF/TA/L/S/09/001(R3) dated 10.12.2010 : Krishnapatnam Area in Andhra Pradesh 7 Simhapuri Energy Pvt. Ltd. 600 491 356 135 0 8 Meenakshi Energy Pvt.

Ltd. 600 546 186 177 183


Quantum allocated to

Sr. No.

Generation Developer

Installed Capacity

LTA granted

SR WR NR9 Krishnapatnam Power

Corporation Ltd. (Navayuga)

1320 925 725 200 0

10 Kineta Power Pvt. Ltd. 1320 925 625 300 0 11 Thermal Powertech

Corporation India Ltd. 1320 1240 1125 115 0

12 Nelcast Energy Corporation Ltd.

1320 1240 840 400 0

13 Meenakshi Energy Pvt. Ltd.

300 273 273 0 0

14 Andhra Pradesh Power Development Co. Ltd.

1600 175 0 0 175

PGCIL letter no. C/ENG/SEF/TA/L/S/10/007 dated 10.12.2010 : Vemagiri Area in Andhra Pradesh 15 Spectrum Power

Generation Ltd. 1400 1350 1120 330 0

16 Reliance Infrastracture Ltd. 2400 2200 1500 700 0 17 GVK Gautami Power Ltd. 800 800 433 100 26718 GVK Power (Jegurupadu)

Pvt. Ltd. 800 800 520 100 180

Details of above LTA are available as additional annexure on WRPC website. Committee may like to note. ITEM No.13: ANY OTHER ITEM ITEM No. 14: DATE AND VENUE OF NEXT MEETING

* * * * *


RECORD NOTES OF DISCUSSION OF MEETING HELD ON 27.09.10 AT WRPC OFFICE, MUMBAI TO DISCUSS ISSUES RELATED TO SHIFTING OF

CONTROL AREA OF NSPCL FROM SLDC, CSPTCL TO WRLDC

List of participants is enclosed at Annexure-I.

A meeting among SLDC, CSPTCL, CSPDCL, NSPCL, BSP, WRLDC and WRPC

was held on 27.09.2010 to discuss various issues concerning to shifting of control

area of 2x250MW NSPCL power station at Bhilai stations from SLDC, CSPTCL to

WRLDC.

Member Secretary, WRPC welcomed the participants from SLDC, CSPTCL,

CSPDCL, NSPCL, BSP, WRLDC in the meeting. Initiating the discussion, M.S.,

WRPC stated that as per IEGC 2010 the control area for NSPCL station which is a

central government owned company comes under jurisdiction of WRLDC and

neither party viz. SLDC, CSPTCL and WRLDC have any objections to it. SLDC,

CSPTCL had agreed for shifting of control area earlier in 55th CCM held on

15.07.2010. SLDC, CSPTCL has requested deliberation vide letter dated 23.09.10

on following issues related to the matter which may be discussed:-

1. Deletion of meter No. NP-2302A & NP-2178A for the drawal energy mechanism of CSPDCL.

2. Deletion of setoff of DD-DNH scheduling from the net drawal schedule of SCPDCL.

3. Inclusion of CSPDCL share in the NDS of the CSPDCL from the central sector.

4. The beneficiaries from the NSPCL Bhilai 2 x 250 MW Power Project shall remain the existing one only i.e. SAIL. UT-DD, UT-DNH & CSPDCL.

5. NSPCL be clearing all the dues on them in the form of UI and SLDC charges etc. before the shifting.

6. The drawal from the 220kV (or at any EHV voltage level) from the CSPDCL end to NSPCL shall be treated as power drawn by NSPCL from the CSPDCL network for which necessary agreements copies has to be made available to SLDC and WRLDC for needful reference.

7. To decide the effective shifting date.

ED, POSOCO, WRLDC stated that NSPCL is CGS captive plant and whether it

should be considered as a generating station unlike others, needs clarification.

However, if both CSPTCL and NSPCL agree, WRLDC will not have any problem

in carrying out scheduling, controlling etc. of NSPCL station. Further apart from

the agenda items given in SLDC letter dated 23.09.10 the periphery of NSPCL

2

where the scheduling & injection would be done and loss application on these

parameters are of most importance.

General Manger (CP & Comml.), NSPCL stated that CERC regulations do not

differentiate between captive plant and generating station GM (CP & Coml.),

NSPCL referring to IEGC 2010 stated that NSPCL being ISGS station owned by

Government Company is to come under control area jurisdiction of WRLDC in line

with Clause 6.4.2(a) of IEGC. He said that during 47th CCM held on 19th

September 2007 it was intimated that WRLDC have worked out the requirement

of SEMs to be provided along with their locations for accounting of energy injected

into the grid from NSPCL and approval for procurement of 13 Nos. SEMs and 4

Nos. DCDs were accorded. These meters are available with PGCIL and can be

used for metering. He added that DD, DNH, CSPDCL and BSP have firm

allocations of 100, 70, 50 & 192.5 MW respectively from NSPCL and balance 87.5

MW (surrendered by BSP) have again allocated to DD, DNH, CSPDCL as 39, 36

and 12.5 MW respectively wherein for CSPDCL power there is no STOA. He

further added that agreement for above 12.5 MW with CSPDCL is applicable up to

21.10.10 and the same will be reallocated to DD and DNH w.e.f. 22.10.10. GM,

NSPCL informed that as per MoM of the meeting held on 28.11.2008 between

CSPDCL, BSP and CSTPCL there will not be any UI applicable to BSP.

ED, POSOCO, WRLDC stated that control area of NSPCL will be taken over by

WRLDC only when WRLDC is requested by SLDC, CSPTCL for this and action is

initiated by SLDC for the same. Further, when WRLDC commences the

scheduling of NSPCL then CSPDCL & BSP, SAIL will be considered as

embedded utility as per notional model. Combined scheduling for UI accounting

for CSPDCL and BSP, SAIL will be issued and bifurcation would be done by

SLDC. He further stated that UI for NSPCL will be calculated at the periphery as

presently being done by SLDC but in addition WR transmission losses will be

required to be booked on SAIL, BSP transactions.

ED, WRLDC stated that as there is no direct line (STU line) from NSPCL to

CSPDCL therefore CSPDCL should draw its share of 50 MW either through long

term open access agreement or short term open access agreement, otherwise

WRLDC will not be able to schedule power for CSPDCL. LTOA / STOA for

scheduling power to CSPDCL would require payment of the charges by it

2

3

including the transmission charges & losses as per OA regulation provisions. He

further added that no previous minutes of the meeting between NSPCL, CSPTCL

and BSP dated 28/11/2008 or related decisions governing conditions when

NSPCL had been under control jurisdiction of Chhattisgarh would remain effective

after the control area is shifted to WRLDC. BSP drawl will be shown as CSPDCL

drawl and BSP load will be considered as embedded load of CSPDCL. The

surrendered share of 87.5 MW will be scheduled through STOA provisions to DD,

DNH or CSEB and the scheduling will be done on NSPCL bus. He further stated

that registration at WR pool & other formalities would require to be completed with

WRLDC by NSPCL before commencement of the scheduling of NSPCL.

It was expressed during the meeting that Unit wise scheduling of NSPCL, Bhilai

2x250 MW plant by SLDC, Bhilai will not be possible and scheduling is to be done

for the power station as a whole only.

Addl. Chief Engineer, CSPDCL agreed to apply to CTU for Long Term Open

Access for 50 MW power from NSPCL.

The matter regarding utilization of un-requisitioned power from NSPCL was

discussed and the committee was of the view that URS is applicable only for

allocated portion of power and not for the surrendered portion which was

reallocated by NSPCL.

DGM (Power Systems), BSP, Bhilai stated that with the shifting of control area

jurisdiction to WRLDC, there should not be any additional transmission charges or

losses applicable to BSP. He further expressed that they would not like transfer of

the control area from SLDC, CSPDCL to WRLDC before the issue involved are

amicably addressed. The subject matter was deliberated and it was agreed that emerging issues

between NSPCL, CSPDCL and BSP SAIL will be discussed among themselves

and will be shorted out preferably by the end of October 2010. There after action

plan for shifting of control area jurisdiction of NSPCL from CSPTCL to WRLDC

may be initiated.

* * * * *

3

4

Annexure - I

List of the Participants

I CHHATTISGARH STATE POWER TRANSMISSION CO. LTD. Shri B. R. Soni, Superintending Engineer, SLDC, Bhilai Shri Girish Gupta, EE, SLDC, Bhilai II CHHATTISGARH STATE POWER DISTRIBUTION CO. LTD. Shri G. C. Mukherjee, Addl. Chief Engineer III POSOCO, WRLDC Shri M. G. Raoot, Executive Director

Shri U. K. Verma, AGM Shri S. R. Narsimhan, DGM(OS) Mrs. S. Usha, Manager (OS)

IV NTPC SAIL POWER COMPANY LIMITED

Shri G. Basu, General Manager (CP & Comml.), HQ, New Delhi Shri S. D. Jha, DGM(CP & Comml.), HQ, New Delhi

Shri P. K. Dutta, DGM(TS), NSPCL, Bhilai V BHILAI STEEL PLANT Shri K. Harinarayana, DGM (Power Systems), BSP, Bhilai VI WESTERN REGIONAL POWER COMMITTEE

Shri Manjit Singh, Member Secretary Shri O. P. Singh, Suptdg.Engineer (Commercial) Shri M. M. Dhakate, Executive Engineer (Comml.-I)

.

4

(j£1 - wrpcwrpc.gov.in/ccm/57ccm_agenda.pdf · 2011-01-04 · getco 1 220 kv s/c...

Documents