joo aufl - national bureau of economic research · 2020. 3. 20. · tufla' zjsti6 miia...

47
UOCC !AGU O 1JJ 2OIILCC bibp wA pc dcioq mipor1 Qxbpci buinrou bLoAiqcq tpI fIJJ CLQqW !UCIfldllU © © Jt P ic Q!UU Hn1X VI! '4P 2P°'4 2CC110U2 O 1GXf UO1 O cxcccq tMO O JJC M!0UI BnL O ECOUOW!C J2GLCJJ bLo1uj !u OUcWLA Ecouow!c uX obiuou cxbLcq m po oj JJG rntpoL uq uoi tpo rp ffccu ujc o r cJcuoMJqGq jp bIthcL bi.i o I4flE LQQUlC tow lpG CQUi oL uiqA o Ecouow? uuq tQ 2W o ip nuIAQL2IIA o ciico uq r'o COU GUC ou ECOUOUJ!C bojIcA joi. pcjbpj couJu.u uq an oua juucj anbbol4 bjwcrbiua 9i JJQ qGuq cu oaq uq buc!bnua ip jcacu uJc oj, 2 JWOU QTJCJJT4 VUIT Kpb DOU J,qoLu QJUu nqQpnacJr i.ncc uipp acwiua O 4CM AOLI( I '' 10 VHU BLCL bP!II!b C9U jçJCpLq CIU1O V.I14C GQU1QL V2aOctQ Mg1!OUI J3flLGfl1 OJ ECOUOUJ!C CIJJ uq A2!1!U 2CP0J IqT BU1 wiaii r' C2OU bL0OL 0 ECOUOIIIC2 nuq JJUUC COJfJWPW flUIAGL21A icp DQCQWPGL wpqq AIV OT18 Joo AUfl wvnovr BflJEVfl OE ECOI.4OWIC MOLICIU bbQL M0 4X jç QJCWJ wppq hog VIOI#1E1VKA bOFICk 12 IIIEJE V CHVVI14EF VBEg MOBK1140 bVbE 2EKIE2

Upload: others

Post on 26-Feb-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

UOCC !AGU O 1JJ 2OIILCCbibp wA pc dcioq mipor1 Qxbpci buinrou bLoAiqcq tpI fIJJ CLQqW !UCIfldllU ©© Jt P ic Q!UU Hn1X VI! '4P 2P°'4 2CC110U2 O 1GXf UO1 O cxcccq tMO

O JJC M!0UI BnL O ECOUOW!C J2GLCJJbLo1uj !u OUcWLA Ecouow!c uX obiuou cxbLcq m po oj JJG rntpoL uq uoi tporp ffccu ujc o r cJcuoMJqGq jp bIthcL bi.i o I4flE LQQUlCtow lpG CQUi oL uiqA o Ecouow? uuq tQ 2W o ip nuIAQL2IIA o ciico uqr'o COU GUC ou ECOUOUJ!C bojIcA joi. pcjbpj couJu.u uq an oua juucj anbbol4bjwcrbiua 9i JJQ qGuq cu oaq uq buc!bnua ip jcacu uJc oj, 2JWOU QTJCJJT4 VUIT Kpb DOU J,qoLu QJUu nqQpnacJr i.ncc uipp acwiuaO 4CM AOLI( I '' 10 VHU BLCL bP!II!b C9U jçJCpLq CIU1O V.I14C GQU1QL

V2aOctQ Mg1!OUI J3flLGfl1 OJ ECOUOUJ!C CIJJ uq A2!1!U 2CP0J IqT BU1wiaii r' C2OU bL0OL 0 ECOUOIIIC2 nuq JJUUC COJfJWPW flUIAGL21A icp

DQCQWPGL

wpqq AIV OT18Joo AUfl

wvnovr BflJ�EVfl OE ECOI.4OWIC

MOLICIU bbQL M0 4X

jç QJCWJ wppq

hog VIOI#1E1VKA bOFICk12 IIIEJ�E V CHVVI14EF

VBEg MOBK1140 bVbE 2EKIE2

Page 2: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

VVQ 1qE nthoW 5I3M Q1 1c!m3U

'J3T4T4AHD TIU3IMD A 351E[HT I cyDuOq Y$IAT3T4OM $1O1

TDA$ITHA

!1w i3wIs ion 51B "wiv' 1ib13" bn "wiv ',nom" &rrii di iir1i UU$ l3qEq idT

.(3i1oq '(thlnom lo mini3dm noiirnnii rli vo a3Edb th*iiqm bn ts3ü1orfJ iti bnihb

n1u1u 31li lua 2ihsm Ith3nEnfi ni 2rn3ldolq viinni bnR noiimio1ni lo 2Lbom in5I -viIoq lo oi biB15I no :thfiq owl olni rnin&bm noiim2nii Hi nioqrnoob 10

Iiin&riT1" ol bisIi no bnE bnu1 lo 21203 thai lo 13v31 1!Eivo dl no nEth bijbni

lo 2noiriaoq thi3nirnil 3rIi no 2noi3B iIoq lo 2lqmi moil nimmi2 2i31h "1oJJnI33B

nthnq2 3± i&h s3bi 3111 noqqu2 5r3u1 b3in3a1q a11ui 311T .hib3rrr13lni io 2-I3wol-Iod

.noiiibno3 ir12 33nEIsd li3rLi d b33n3uflth m iwoiiod lo quoi inii1ini2 £ lo 2noi2ib

3111 i n3biv3 ol3im 5loM .iv3wor1 u13 2231 i 3vihn3qo i 1nnrb nibn31-Ac1Bd i iodir1W

.noiiup 2i111 3v1o23i ol b3bn 2i 2noii32nIi 13bn31-l3woTIod LBubivibni lo 13v31

blBdduH flfl3ID .51

22OtIi2IJH lo 1o0f13 3irnJbJnO 'ii2I3vinU nidmuloD

lthH thU QO VOOI Y14 MoY w*I

SiEIffT4 bnI3

Page 3: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

LJç6Lm6gL62AoJrnhIe couaiqeLa cp6 bo2pjçA ot g ceqç CLflUCJJ tOL uoupiijcxo.j (i) jJJe bgber. pX cguço uq J�oqLâne2 T'. OflC Legug j1g;om (5) gLJg 2çnq62 pi LGgGLgr J626LA6 D9IJ O 4GM

OL gi) 91Jg172T2 O •sCL6qç CLITuCp, 6b2Oq6 266 kJt626IJ

(T88) uq 96LUUJC6 (13)JEOL qeecL]-bçrou2 o qepçe 266 6LUU)C6 ug DJJ6L

cpe coUAeJJçToUJ ruçeLe2ç—Lgçe wecpguiaiir TJJnJgL

acLgTapcoLMgLq g6Tii6 g meuuarr]- ,cL6qTç AT6I'11 Jç6LugçTAe Co

L6ce22TOu) HOMGA6L' ge I ejgpogçe p6JOt' IC T uoç jit7e

6A6U2 (68L 20_cgj]6q ,1CL6qç CLITUCJJ11 ql7L ia

cor.boLgçe IJIJC6 P44JJ IIJgCLO6CO1JOJIITC moqeja) uq L6C6U

moqej (pi iuLLae ot inoqeja ot ruoLmçToIJ nbeLecCToIJ2 v'

b2ç 26A6LJ 7eL2 JuOcAg;eq poçp pA qeAeJobweuça TU 6COIJOJJJTC

LJJ6LG pga P6611 g aLegç geg O TUCGL62C 111 CPT2 dcIe2çTou p

CjJgJJiiej1

cpguuej bL62611C6q 111 1JJO2 C6XOOJ2 T grzamelJçeq pA g CL6q]ç A161k&1

gjeg g2 t.tJJ6çJJGL CJJ6 PJCGLG2C LgCe OL 11J0136A ATGtlt,1

YC 4JJ6 LT2J O oAGLaTJIJbJTtATud pie qepgçe' CP6 drzeaçTou 12 OtC6U

couaedneucea Tu gqqrçrou JJO26 tOL ObGIJ mgceç TIJç6L6aç Lç62

CJJTC 6XCpLJde P6ç1'tGGlJ ceuçgj pujc guq CJJ6 pijc1ua 2A2ç6JJi pge

111 cq6Jlic uq bITpTTC IDOITCA CTLCT62 ILl L6C6U X69L2 Ta MJJ6JJ6L

gccowbguArjjd L6qJ-ICCOIJ o pujc L626LA62 0116 dneçrou OL qepgç

E6qGLgJ J626LA6 1J11b1162 g agje O poiiqa pA JJ6 EGg ug gu

yç gu obeLçToug 16A61' g 11ç1djiçeuiid11 O JiloU6çLA boilcA pA CP6

JJJgCLOGCOIJOIIJTC2 guq g C61JLJ eT6m6JJ4 O GCOLJOIUTC bojicA gUgjAa]2

g6CC2 6COIJOWTC AgLrgp]6e JJS2 joud 66U g ]C6A L626LCJJ ,pobc 111

flh3q6L2çLJqruä 4JJ6 CJJgUU6I2 1'JJTCP UOU6çgLA bojlcA

Page 4: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

B6tOL6 qacr1eeua bL€qcçoua tOL eecça o moueçL7 boJTcA

HOA EYBOI1YBFE 12 LKE .,XOkEX AIEà&..3

TwbJTcçroua or. JzJoueçL? boJTc

cLguamTaaTou mecpgurans 6IIJbTLTcJ L626LCJJt LJq 6XJllU6P

qacna262 LOW Jc6LUcA6 moqea oiøoqeja ot pLJJc-qebeuqeuç1 poLLomeLa jjJe p]uce o bb6L

piibjcçoiJa o iuoqe]-e o 1ugucrr couaçLTuça ou pOLLOI't6La guq

.çL1J21il2aOIJ mecjiuem uq pA qeacLpp3a gaarnilbçroua guq

aenwbcou2 ug pubJcçoua Ot 11w0u6A AT6M. O IUOU6ç9LA

We bb6L Ta oLasueq ga OJ]OI2 I pepi LGAT6ITUa

bLomTaTua IJ LeaLq•

201116 Leceuç iuoqeja uq 6iIJbTLCj tox.jc gi.e boç6uçJJAugLLoz •,piJjC jeiiqua1, cpguue] O WOU6ç9LA boilcA Ta 1110L6 qcnç

cOUAGuçrOugJ ruc6Leaç—Lgc6 cpguueja bTubOTucTua 66C42 o g

eecça ot moueçi.A bojcA peXoug AoLJqua

couaçLgruça11 ou L1u21 qeceoua TJHbjA boçeuçJAgugjAara g pçt I gr.dne LeTacc moqeja o ruucrj

riubjrcgçroua O C1J086 tLTGCIOU2 JO 1JcCbç6bLCCJiJL tLTCcTOIJ2 iJ igucr gLLguaeueuça uq OIl q6AeobpJd

11cLeqc ATet11 judnde beL 26' uq u2çeq ocn2 ou eoJcua

moueçgLX wecjJuam ui ao qouc1' i aq6aceb

abeceq A6L2TOU O cLeq; AT6U gJpeLugçTAe COUA6IJçO1JI

LPT2 bgber. qeacTpea uq gujAsea g poq acTII P6H-woqeja

L26 T1J EcLnccnLTLla 6mbLC o 11cr.eqç Are!

3

Page 5: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

g226ç2etecca OU 2beuqIJä Laud tLOJJJ guA cpguaG2 T L6TA6 bLTce2 Otonq g221a13 o 4Lgu2mT22roLJ Wecpuiem

4N0L6 d6IJeLgA' IJ g mogj JJ 11J1JA gaaec& IJJT2 g6acLbfl-ou66Cç2 013 TU162C0L boLctorroaguq LopTu (rea) moueçi.A bojicA csu pe ujAGq c2

3Egwg. p.iedpç mbiree GL1GL COUcLTPflcTolJ Ot BLT1JLc1

po1qud2 LebLeeeuça g gecrue T L6 mOIJ6A pjuc62 jo Leçoi.

q]neç cJJUa6a T JUOIJGA anbbiA' cJJe t11 Tu jonpojg JUOUGA

1622 JJJOIJ6A U flJ6L boLctojroe It bic qo uoç pJ2cuçu6onaJA

qeboPrça DeboaTcoLa (11poriaepojqa11) Jun2ç poq wore pouq gug

LGfTCG2 L626LA62 TTIUTCTUa pujqua aAaCeiiia 9PTITcA cO 2611

•4iuoueA1 guq 11poug11, ]u moLJGçLA couçLgcçrout .çJJ6 C6UçLgJ puc

jo jceeb Bçoi.A a]mbJe 2rlbbo2e L6 geça —-

m6LGJA g A6TJpge 130 66Cç 013 L6 OflçCOIU62t T2 1JUCJ 2A246JJJ TaboLctojTo bLeteLeucea IzJoLJà puc qeboac& pouqa oL açocjca aponq

pujcat gwg (18o) aoueq aPTtca 1 cpe bnpjc5a

WTII6L (1a28) YbbIATUd TucnTclOu O woqdTTguT-wTJJ6L

q6CaOLJ2 O POLLOM6L2 giJq JGIJq6L& L62f1J O WoqâTLJT giiq

POLL0tk6L2 Ta qe Cb1çJ açLnCçIlLea go uoç TutinGucs L6g1

JIJOIJ6A pA TaanTIJà qewuq q6boaça n13q6LrXua aariwbç1oua ponçaJJeec' pgiijca bGLtoLzJs g ab6cTgJ L0J6t pujqua 2A2ç61JJ CL662

eq6 0 cJsGTL pgjguce apeGç OU rPrcX aqe O cJJGTL pgjguceTucGLmeqTgr.T68 (11piijca,1) Ott6L 130 2b6CTJ 26LATC6B 011 aaç0 4JJ6 w0u6çLA cLguamTaaTOu mecpguranr III AT6Pt niucrgj

uc6L1u6qTgLT62 gug pOLLOItGL2 1J pe cLgq0ug1 ruceLGac-Lgçe AT6P

0 JçeLugCTAe bbLocp6at T2 naerij o L6AT6t aer1mbcoua ponç3

Page 6: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

(Taao) giiq CpL2CuO giiq ECJJ6UPflJ.U (Taa5)ee' or. 6xmbJ6t l.11m1C6q woqa g2 1L rncg

wnjcob (mo)cJJe COIJ6X O EGq6L J$62GLAG12 OL6cg2çrua mOq6Tt 266

gij 6mbrLrc qG2cLrbçyou O meCpguT2m

ECP6UpnIU iaas)'moqe]2 (e joçemp6Ld T84t ug CpL2çruo gug

Hrzppgrq' raae cpbç6L ) ucrnqpJa gAuiuc GdnTJTpLTnhlJ cap-u-JceLugcrAe moqej peXoug ;JJG moqej (ee eâ'ATGM 12 pTdpTA 2çATSGq' •2 COIJ2T2çGlJç zçp g ijriwper. ot

MJJTT6 CPT2 2TWbTG ;Io-g22e;-moq6J qeEcLb.çou ot moueX

140U6c1J6T622' JGàgJ L62çLTCçTOU2 (sa' L626LA6 L6dflTL6meJJça) iuA

jjgjç1Ø o J.UIICJJ O JHOU6çgLA P26 2 TT]C61A P6 euqoaeioria

cpude pi cpe uompwj anbbA o Onç2q6 moueA Ot COJ7L8G

Iii CJJT2 2çAJ6q AT6 IilO1J6çLA bOJTCA11 12 LGbLeeBIJç6q PA g

oriçbnç L62b0u262 2flCJJ p.JuOAcOu2

iiioueçi.A bojcA piuoçoii nigçcp L6g2oupJA z'ii 'c.' oJerieqJrI2rpJe cpIJä62 iii 1UC6L62c—26U21C1A6 ebeuqrud fU L62b0U26 g

TuflneucTua ponaepo]-q ug pn2u62a abeugpia g6caoua ()

aJJOLç—çeLIu IIJCGLG8C L62 g6Cç JouaeL—çeLm TUC6L62P gçea

go uoç qJrzaç pJ2çuç9u6on2JA () boflcA-uqnc6q cJJuàe2 Tu Leg).

Leg). ga I'6JJ ga uoJilrugJ 2pOL-ç6LJu TUCGLG2C LgçGat a' bLIcea

JJ6L6 gLe TWb6L6CC anpaccnc6a (3) jpe CGU4LgJ puj cu gGCçceiçj pujc wrrnç COULO). cpe anbb).A o 11onçaqe usoueA'1 tOL IpTcp

ecoIJoIuTc 9cçrArçXt IC L61162 ou onr. jceA aenJilbçOu2: ().) Lpe

uCGXCP0O]Cu woqe7 tOL UIA1IJa 66Cç2 O mOu6çgLA boTIcA ou

MJJTTG JIJOIJ6A AT6Pi 12 i'tqeA ccebçeq g2 4J16 peIJcpmgL)c OL

CçTArçea ug TUCGLG2C-26u2Tc1A6 2bGLlqTIJd IJ221126L CO2 O cgbiçj tOL Y L1sae O biiiieq TUAG2CmGIJC

6dnTITPLTSTJUt pJJ6 Leg). TUC6L62C L46 01.1 •1pouga1, TUCL6g262 LgT2TLla

Page 7: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

(iai)P3A62c1U611c P' CJJTLTUJCO (Iaa3) gug cnmmpia' Haa6ç' guq HflppgLq266 jao CJJ6 LGATGA o GJUbTLTcgJ aCnqTGa ot pnaTueae Tx6qapAb' 2C6T13' gug MITC0X (raa5) guq CGLCIGL guq CTTCJJLT2C (i)

8266 0L GXSJøbJG' 1JJA26a O TIJA6IJCOLA TIJA62CDJ6UC T

JJJOU6çLA C01JCLCçO1J gebLeaa qeaLeq TUA62CmGUC pA TLW2 guq

T6A' JITdJJ6L q6gnJc-LaJc-L66 LSC62 0 T13c6L62C t0TTOIT1Jd g

obboeeq co q c0LJ26df1613c62 o bojcA cçToua iu CJJT2

I Bpg]] CJJLCç6LTS6 1JilOIJ6A AT61 0cfl2TUä 011 SaaLe&çe ga

62Cpllç6q Gtt6CC2 O 1126L CO22 0 cbç9j 013 TUAG2Cm6UC8

Jil01J6çLA IJIJOACOU2 L6 gLd6 L6T9CTA6 CO fl16 âeu6LA amgx6g TLJAG2CJIJ6IJC' guq TUA6UC0LA TIJA62Cm6IJC)' O11CbS1 L62b011262 0p1C6L62c—86U2TCTAG (aricp ga COIJ211ID6L qnLgprea' poneTIJa' P112T13622

TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA

COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja' iaao)

rzuga gzq JJ6 LL6g2rILA pouq L6 (266' Gt'

2TàIJTtC1JC bO2TCTA6 L6JçToU2J3Tb p6ç16611 CJJ1Jc16E TI) CJJ6 (uomiugj)

2CL11CCJ1L6 E1UbLcT acnqTaa' 0!6A6L' pgA6 0CflihJ6LJ6 g

0PA10112 g bLTOT4 pgaeq 013 COIJA6JJCTOIJgJ Iuoq6Ja O CJJG 6LJJJ

bLeqcpJA TI) L62b0JJ26 g cpgiide pi aJJor.c—CGLW LC62 a UOIIJIJA aAud guq TUAGECWGUC q6caoua ajonjq UCL626 OL qGCL6g26

alnr-uTud CO JJ6 OCJJ6L 2aflWbCoIJa' CJJC To13a—CGLIu L62 iiaeq TI)

BJug6L'

cuiqa L6 Leabouqa g epTtC u boilcA (266' e& BeLugujce gug

Ta 11IJC0UCLOA6L2TgT Jj36L6 T ao 6Aq6uC6 LegI eqeLg]

TUCGL62C L62 (eà' JJ6 Gq6LgJ nuga L6 T CJJ6 flUç6q 2çgçGa)

bLgcçrce' C6IJL pguJca TLJI116IJC6 OA6L UOJJJTIJg] 2JJOLC—C6LIIJ

Combej d6IJCa 1126 CP6 Onçarqe gaeeç tOL 20106 CLgu2gcCo1J2 Iii

2

Page 8: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

TTc6L9crlL6 T2 6L1Jgu)ce (ras)yi GgLJA coi3cLpncou couç6JsboLgLA cL6qTc A6L

(ia.s) bi.oAq6 gii embLrcgT UA2T o flhI,OU6Afl uq 11pu]c jeuqp.idq6acLbcou tOL flJG DI5I iuoqej u ECJC26TU guq exJg TaeQ) gàgurugucrgj cçoe T bLobdçou mecpguraiue (meet eâ(ra8o) 20G 6CO13OJD6çLC toL6c2cud woqe JJSA6 J2O ocnaeq 013CnLT&, gug pgi (Ta22 iaeo)t MT1J1CA (iaei Ia.2)t guq MOuTJOA6LWCLO6COIJOJJJC2 MTfJ1 TWb0L;gU.c COucLPnpOue P7 ETBP6L (j-j)

8LJsTe t!LL613 g2prou gcçngjjX pga g ioua b6qaL66 T13

uioqea 6XbJSTIJ TUA62cIØGUC qgçg L6JCA6J?I Z6TT8 Iuqeeq' IL6JcrAeJA ewjj apocjce gcçoa C0LL6BbOIJq cC6]eLçoL1

mcLOeCouOJu2.ce qeuctA ugucI U bLobgdgCrud

cpuaee TU LGgJ TU6L62 Lgç62 LJJfE IJg? bn8peq 201U6

mOu6cgLA boJTcX gcçiou2 pge uoç d6ueLgA req gLd6

ruA6IJçOLJ Tc''c -- bb6L coo JLa6 P6 exbipieq p2

aaL6agçe q6J.uuq -- bLçcnjsLA PflPJIJG22 xeq uA62çm61J.ç guq

111llgcLo11 COUC6LU weuçou6q 6gLfl6L T cXccgj WOA61liGU2 T13

q6acLp6g L6tJ6CE 4b%O COLJC6LIJ8 0136 JcLo11 guq 0136 oWTCLOj LP6

jjie aegLcJJ )OL g JU6CPUJJI pLoqer. nçROil KEY8OMYBFE 18 3.HE .sC1EDI AIEM.

0136 ondjJç exbecç .pjjgç gi.e picowbjeç6

mecpguTem gLe TUCOLL6Cc' pci; 2nâà62c 2cLolJdTX

anaae2ç ;jjgç 1; 6ç—L9ç6 bbxocp62 moueçgLA

r1ubJTcçrou2 O cJJTa JJ6cGLoa6UGTcA I LGAT6M boluca uoç

o b0JTC g7QJt IJOL 0 ääLeâ9çebLo6cç ncp g AT6z.t O6L2 130 guJA2r2 o q cLpncour oL

pnaTueae guq ponepojq cbCj 013 bLoqncçA6

ponaepojqe MpTI6 qeaeq TUAE2;m6u; ;pe Leqslcflou T13

Q

Page 9: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

qecaoua ILl Jç6r.çnr.6 011 mOuGçgLA dLobçJJ moq6I2t BoXq uqaeueLJA bgLTJ GdflTJTpLTflIU wqeja O tTLflJ-16A61 T11A62cW6Uc

JJ2CLTCCT7, 2b6)cruat fllOqGJa U JrceLgçnLe L6gijg 2c1a11cs (T88 raaa)' guq rgmouç (Taa3)NOOLG ()' j<AOc)q gug wooe (Taa3) CGLCJGL (Taa5) eLe6utgTq(T8t Tao) cglozsn-Lra guq nppq (iaao) JJLbe (iao) HL guq(ra83) L6L (1a82)t MTIIgwaoLI (ra8.) B6LIJLlJC6 iq CGLCT6LJJlogGJ& ucinguâ o joz'wuq (ia)' 9JIJqGL uq CTdTTC() LJJ6ee TwbTTc9CToue gLe C011272ç61J; ATçp g zjqe cjge oao66 gjao L6ATeL' TU B6LIJJJ)C6t C6LCT6L ig CTTCJJLT2C

ejçeq usoq6] o TLJoL1JJgçToug TmbGLt6cCTOu2 p., cbrçgj wgjceceBGLUU)C6 (3) uq KTIJd gug repJe (r3) bLoAg6 L6AT6b2 OtcouçLpnçTou O ']6U261J gLYq 146c]CITUd (ia.xe) C6LCJGL (iaes)ou bLrucTbgJ—gaeuç bLopema v psuce pa ojjoieq .çJJG() gijq edniç7 mceça pA MAGL8 uq wjn (Ta9') eaecpjou mgjceç pA gee uq J5fl8jj (ic) guq aqdj ug M6T22(ia.xo) giig J�ocpecJJJq iq 2CTTC (ia.e) uq pge peeu bbJ6qrrocgcou JJgA6 peGu qqeaeeq 111 wboLçuç bb6La PA vi.erTot

oçGJJçTgj G6Cç2 O qeae 2616C4T011 bLOPT6JII2 OIl 1ilL)C6ç

JJgA6 6JIJGLdeq tLOIU iuoqeja O 4J16 igucj cceJeLgçoL0 ILJJE

bgber. i z'tguç meuçou PLG6 counsiou 6wbrLrcg JubTcçou2

MJJTIG g L6AT61 0 CPT TTCLgCnLe Ta p6AOLYq BCOb6 oqeceroue a

cpg].t L4JJTCP qoea Lloc couaTqer. jpjca 6M66U LegJ guq ruuc]-g

flJLJC642 bbLogcJJ nuqeLTApJâ 4J36 CO1JA6IJçTOLJg uç6Leaç—Lgç6

CO2CTA 6X6L1JJ puguce açuga T11 couçaç CO .JJ6 WOL6 cowbjeçe—

CO2 O 6X6L1JJ iuguce uq TUcer.ugj TuguCe JjJ6 IJOçTOU O

UOLJUçOU P6Ct66U POLLOb6L2 gug JelJq6La eq g ab P6CM66U cPe

CL6gç wL]eç2 IL' CPT 11U6 O TUdnTLA bLop]ema o 9aAmmeçLTc

TTcGLg.cJ-1LG açnqAua ruoLwcoug TmbeLtecCT0ua TL' TU2ITLgIJC6 guq

JIJJ6 11JUTCLO,i COIJC6LU LGJçGa 40 emeLaGuce 0 g aLoz.Tua

I1TCT ajocjce pA T1JIJCTgT mgjceç couqçoua

C6LCTGL guq CTICPLT2C' ia't) O L6tGL CO JJ6 IUdLYTTcçTou ot1726 JJ6 C6LJJJ 11 iiic j SCC6T6L9COLII (bnç tOLCJJ pA 6LUU6

Page 10: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

6LJA exbo2TcTou o g L016 tOL 14cL6qT4 ATIprTçA,1 bb6L2 TUC6LT6L guq CTTCPLT2c (Iaa3)' gijq gajAgb siiq 2çepJ (raa3) vuBGLIJY3J)C6 (T3) ELTeglugu guq Jfl.IJ6L (ra) eer-cIeL (T3)TOL pogge q62cLJbcoua o 1cL6qrc AT6tsi gL1nw6uçe 266

bLeqccoujp6 ybb6uqx bLeaeuça g eTmbIe 1110q6] cJJc TTTflPL62 JJ626

ponepoq pguc 2JJ66 couqçoua ou courne. 6XbeugçciLea(ia. is) uq erge (ra8a) bLoiqqe eAq6uce o 66Cç2 otuq beceLe6u (Ta)t uq pr.be (iaa'z) or. pon2ejJojqa' wTep]cTu(iaa'flt CITJIWJTIJ2 aaecc uq nppq (iaait)t cLbeuçeI(Taa3) nppq gpgb% gug yceq (toLcpcomTua) ouq ug WGaJJTLg2JJAb (raa5)t OTTuØL uq nqepncp (Ià5)t ggi- uq b66L26U2CpL2C61J (iaai) t CJOJilLa uq jjnppg () t appq guqC6LT6L guq unppgi.g (1a88)t cguo (ao)t H02p1' Kg2JJXbt uq

OL exgwb& .ggLr nppgLq gug b66L26U (T88)tOL TIJgUcTgJ uceLw6qL62ceqc mLJceçet g cL6qc nJjceç LTccTou uq gu gIrocgçAe LOJ6iqçp () q6LA6 g deueL ednrJTpLrnm IuoJJscgLA moqej cp

11wou6cgLA boJTcAIIH Iii JJ6 WOUGA AT6M bOJTC CçTOIJ2 gecçrc 3116 IJO 6Xç6Ug gr.änm6uç ucjnge g cpuusj tOL

ObbOLçnu]çr62) JJgAe p6613 COLLOPOL6 P1 g UfT11J6L O 6IJJbTLTC9I

guq Tu6acm6uc pLogg]-A qsueq (poJqua couaçguç TuAG2cm6IJc

gu -uç-j pocjc usc btOLçJJ rT1J12 peçiseu TuçeLugJ usc ocj

bJu2 JjJr2 cpguuej bLoAqee ugucrgj gcceJGLgçoL 1uäuTAruà

0LLOI6L TIIlbTemGuc TUAG2cw6uc embJOAmsuc' guq bLoqc1ccou

rlJcLegaea cpe coap O 6Xç6LU puguce guq 6CL6262 gpTTTc? ot

L6dnLeq ajJLg g gqeae 2JJOC)C Co g pOLLOz6L12 usc ocpL62017LC62 —— L6gçTA6 pJG giIioiiuç O nuqa

TuA6L26TA I*tTcJJ CJJ6 pOLLOt6L12 1J6C OLJJ —- uc6LugT nuq gug2bLegq 6M6613 CO2 O GX6LIJJ gug T3Jp6LuJ TLJguC6 AgLT62

tuuc6 3110L6 sxbeuerAs iuCeLlJgj iugucs 5coug%

tTL2c LWTCP I I12ç uoçeq aUco]T]gç6LgjiGg excer.Jgj

8

Page 11: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

jooeg (1a21)

zzzLdruj coaç O eXçGLug] uguc6 gug L6gnCIJä tTLJIJ21 prc?bLsaGlJç Ag]n6 O coJJçeLg]rspJe UGç btoLjJ' 4JJGL6PA ucL6auaCOIJ4LgCçTOU JCL626 POLLOA6L81 q6p-a6LAC6 PnLqGLJ2 IJq L6flC6

TucL6g2 TU L6 uçeLeaç Lg.6 u Lsabouae g moueçLX

I'OLCJJ (266' eâ' C6LJ6L guq HnppgLg' iase) iiJcncpejA'

boJc?t-p.Jqnc6q CJJIJd68 TU TUcGLG8C gçea 96C POLLOM6L21 U6ç

Ta CJJT2 LOJ6 O ijeç MOL MPTCJJ OttGL2 g CJJLJLJ6J I4tPTCP

Tjc6jjgI JnhJqa AL62 TUA6L2GTA z.tTcp 4JJ6 POLLOA6L21 UGç PIOLçJJ icCC66LOL Lâr1G cpe abL6g peçz.eu coaç ot exç6.tuJ uqo exçeuj UUC6' Ii qgçou' moqja o gJJgAe ga Tc2 Onuqsçou cpe q6 eouse OLLOA6L2 ce pTap coaça

YIJ 2çOL qeecr.pud g cqç cpguuej OL wOueçgLA boJTc? zzinaç

LJJfUCI C034 011 OLLO*•LB

uq () .çJJG eXac6uC6 O pgLJ]c—qebeuq6IJ4 POLLOPi6L2

qacsg pi egL]-rer. oLjc: (ii tTiJgcTgi couaCLg]-uça ou poLLol'tGLe'

qeL6uc C7bea O POLLOI'tGLa JMO BIICJJ cpgLwGJa pgs p66u

ccoua' P6Cfl26 coaca O uguce L62b0Uq qttGLeucr2 oi.

c1J6 cL6qç AlGA eucoiøbaaea qaçLpnç-ougj COuaGdnGucGa ot boTTc?

obeLgçToIJa OL L6angçoL7, gccroua) cu ecç Ta'

OttGL2 cpuuja AJJTCJJ IØOUGçgL?t boilcA (obGu wgjceç

t1JUCG tOL IØIJX POLLOAGL2 IL cpTa COIJçGXç' .ppe cLeqc ATGPI

tLTCcTOU2 Ta g db P6AG6JJ coaç O 6X6LLJJ ug piceujabeuqua LJJ6 CLJIX 0 iuogGJa O UOL1Ug.flOU—L6Jgç6q I3Uc1gI

OA6LJ JGAGJ O LGgI TUP6L624 LgçGe ig TU.P6L62c—2GU2TcTA6

Page 12: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

tTICTT uceL1u6gLe8 OL OJJ6L BOflLC62)' () i.peçpr. exoaeuone

cwgpe cca obeu iuLceç ceqç OL OLLObt Lom iJoupiiy

.ço: (i) t.tpA CGLU OLLOA6L2 Big?, pG 11pujc—qebeuqeuç11 (çpgç 12

e wnçeq jijJa pgac eçoLA Lgeee LGG dneeCToua' LeJcud

COLJçLgCçOIJt giiq JJG 66CC O JJG couçLgcçTou OLI L6J TUCcmgdurA qGCJpJG T'J oflCbflC ga g L62J1J o UIOLJ6çL?

uq flJ6 2bGUqUd ot pujc-gebeuqeuç p0LL0AGL2 ncp pgujc jeuqpid

gqAGL2G epocjc pu)c8 cbiçgr conq qeceae poçp pgu]c21 reuqua

JJ6 J6 TU LG2bOIJ8G O g WOUGçSLA coucLgcçrolY YJC6LI3CAGJA gu

ot 6LIJLI]C6 giq BJuqeL (Ia88) JOJJ CJJG j gjjq p CITLA62 2PTtC O

CP626 pOLLOZ't6L2 O CnLC9TT PJJ6TL 2b6IJqUa Iii cJJG j- LJ.U6PiOL)

CLGqc gjjocgçeq CO pgu]c-qeb6uqGuc OLLObtGL2 w gj]' crT2uaLG26LAG& boaaTpJA qecLeap3a pgu]ca1 PTTX CO J6IJq y2 g L621JC

LG&ITL6JIJ6XJCB OU g wOuGçgLA couçLccou qLgu2TWb9CC ou 7e anbbiA o jogu MJJGU pujca gLe 11P6C LGE6LAG

pic tOL GX6LUJ nuq guq CPg; boJTcX CçOua cu JJ9AG g qrLGCc

LuG acouq cpuuei 2L622G2 pgç ROJJJG OLLOPt6L2 qebeuq ithou

P. EXTOUC. O BVIJJ—D.b.Uq.33 BOLLOA.L

IJGC iocu)

COJJçLCçTOLJ (CO JJ6 6XGU CPG COIJCLCO1J qncea pOLLObGL21

tTTI T TTJC6V O gjj toTjoIflJd g woueçgL?t

WOLGOA6L CPT2 bbLogcp TmbTT62 abGuqpJa p7t IOt-IJ6C-MOLCJJ

ugAs uo qLGcc dnuçC? GttGCC on puJca PflCA O jeuq

bbLocp oL2 g 1,cLGqc cJJguuGJ 6A6U Tt oben JIJLJCGç ObGLgçTOUa

CLL? Oflç qeaLeq TUAG2CWGUC uq GJØbJOAW6UC bLOaLgJila' JJJT2

To

Page 13: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

mea (r8) uq rnww6r. uq WCCOJJLI6TT (ra8o) piq.pgç puja OeL abecJ BGLATCGB pi cp reuqpiä bLoceaa

y BnpaçuçrgJ poq2. o 6wbLrc 6AqeLcG enbboLç2 ]qe

p0 uguc6 pujc jeuqu81CT1TLT2 uq pu (iaai) O6L g moq ot qemuqpj qepç

IpGLIiçAG BOITLCGB O jjgjjCTmb6Lt6Cc BrlPacTcnce tOL oçper. 226B uq OLLObt6L2 jcc

TB L6dnL6q 2 jJgp rogue O J7626 POLLOI'&GLB gLe gLyL6dflL6q tOL pu)c-qebeuqeuç..poLLoA6L cpuuej pe ob6LgçTA6TuceLeec LgçeB L6fTCG2 jou anbbjA cLeqc LcoIJud T iio.pclLonap APTCP u TucLesas TU JGAGJ o qesnJç— T2]c—tr.ee L65JaeieCçou (e 2cTdITc sug 14GT2B 1a81) oei. suoçpei. n,ecpsuraiu

4oq6]B O 6dflTJTpLTflJli ceqç LscoupJd nuqe 5A6LB6

qebeijqeijç nboi pJc6Lm6qsL62 tOL exceLugj TU5UC6 suq coac

POLLOIdI6LB tOL IPTCP mourçoLnia CO2B SLE aiäuitrcguc tTTI PG

TBanGq qepcj a,JJT2 JpJG o L6a6sx.cp sL8nea LTdoLoflaT2

jojq g qTAeLaeq josu boLcoJTo usuceq bLTucTbsJJA p7 brIpTTcjA

sç pJJG IJç6LmeqgL7. IGAGT SLG eqaceq p2 PSATIJ8 je uc6LweqsL7jogija gLig gcç 52 5 11gejeasçeq 1001 TPOLi1 bOceucrsr sdeiic bLopJGmB

bLopJeJo TB JIJcdsç6q pA PSATIJd 5 IJSUCTSJ 1Jç6L1JJGqTgLX pojq

JJO6A6L' TU bnPTTC 10gK6cB bTPP S JgLde UJIJIJP6L O cLeqçOLB JIJJ6

ebeuqud LGBOJTLGGB OIl mOuTcoLTut y Lee—Lq6L bLOPIGIn GJIIeLaeat

TIJtOLJJJSCTOLJSI tLTCcTOIJ& Uou-JHoLJJçoLeg TUSUCG 6UcSTT2 ge5qt.ieâpc

JOA-cOaç JIJG5IJB O JlloIJTcoLTua 201116 CJ52262 O pOLLOZ'6L2 B6Cfl26 0

Dswo1Jq Ta8tt sug BoAq suq bL62COCC iase)' uc6LmeqrsLTe2 OttGL

U5UCT5J T1Jc6LI06q5LG21 IU IUJICJJ O .JJ2 L62G9LC (266 eabecTgJJX

L62OA6 pA pj TTcGLscnLG Oil JJ6 q6A6Tobweuç ot

We 7TL2C dnG2cT0U T2 sggeaaeq uoç UGCGB2SLTJA

0 BOflLC6B O rniqa uoç BnpeCç p0 LGB6LAG L6dflTL6m6Uc2

SLJSTABTB O ObGiJ IIJgLJCGç ObGLSçTOIJB) ltJJGçJJ6L pSU]Ca JJgAG 5CCGBB

cjisudea TU p5IJJC2 SPTJTCA reLq csu PG qeLicpeq' suq () (tot.TI

Page 14: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

cpbçer. 5,lcL6qTc CLflIJCJJ6211 266 J2O q62cLbçou pi Hnppq (i'i

1OM6IJ2 guq (iao) o(Taal)

18266 OL 6XJUbJ6' q2Cna2Ou T1J b66L26U gug g)gu

oii TOCgJ pujca oL 6Xç6Liigj nuq2bG6L26U guq igJgii (]f) 8JJObt 2mgjj pr121U62262 ;euq co L6JAOLLOM6L2 JJJfl2ç uoç JJgAG 62A cceee OJJ6L 2OflLC62 O nuqa)pegL p3cqsuce o LG26LAG L6dnTL6meIJc2 (pJqcçuâ(mB.\) ruq pgujce OLLO6L2 Lçpex. puJc81 q6boecoL&

pgu]c12 s22622W6LJç Iij g emIr 2bTLTc' gmg (1a82) uq .gmeeO poLLoztTud TLJJJ TT]C6fl LeJJ6cCTIJä r omcou couçeuç ogUlJOflIJC6flJeU4 o g pgujc jou' gjj 6)26 flg]% LgT2Ga apge bLTC6

cprnej T2 drITce eçLoud wTLqt BT6L(T3) 2naa62

TI gijg b66]C guq Jço26uaLeu EUJbLCT 6Aq6IJC6 OL

guq Ledrzrgcou o cgbgj qednsc7 (2G6 eâ' 6LU1JJ6 guq roi'w'

2CJJL6tC Taaot g2pb uq 26PJ TS guq O11I6L gig J�O1JJ6L I3)ppJqua J6dr1gçTou ö C6flJJd2 TU flhJç6q (26e e8

26COU gLdIIIZJGIJç 6wbp262 L6anJçoLx gccTou2' ancp g rnigei.

cgTomL2 gug HnppgLq' iaa OL 4ç1oiJj Bu]qua b6Loq) y

6LIJUJC6t I83t guq 6LUU]C6 ug '331062' TT' tOL 18302 guq

qepç —- L6flC62 pu]ce8 p1cA jeuq (toL 6mbLc1 6Aq6uc6' 266

dnJçA —— couAeLcTua puc q6boaca CflLL6UC7t OL doAeLIJm6uç

013 I.0J6 bjAeq p7 pujcpia bguTca' T13 tjncp q6bo2coL2. TTdpc

cpLJâG2 AG P6611 6x1JJTU6q T13 bL6ATOJI2 L626LCJY LJJ6 TL2ç t0Cfl262

q6ucA exoaGuone cpua62 T13 pgu]c21 pjçX jeuq onr. 2fljJ

9L6 pgujcqebeuqeuc T JJ6 261326 62CLP6 6L16L' 0136 10fIE

6coL7q' 6A61J Tt 0116 gCc6bç2 bL6mT2G 20106 pOLLOt'6L2

pJc6Lm6qL62 uguceq pA uou-g6bo2c q6pC)

1J6C622LTA Lan6 OL pu'c qebGuqelJcG (eâ' uguc6 combguTG2 g

O 2tTccpTua J6U6L2 'T1T p6 JJTdP18 ic O62 1104' pOt6A6L'

15

Page 15: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

gxjq wcDoIJq iaas) ii.' qqcout ga ro a oiue pujca ceiiOL6 piuqa .e Laq (a&e' ea w2si.a giiq wpi iasi guq rncga

bLopJeIua £JJ UCL6g?6 IULd1JT coaç o exçeuj uJJce ga

ponç gç egaç g boLclou o ogu boLoJTo' A6L26 aeT6ccTou

O 4316 TaanTd pgu]c1a boLcoJTo CIAGu pujca5 bLpwçe ruoLJxJgçTou

qeboaç fLJanLguce bLoabeccTAe 16uq61.a mnaç g2ceLçru dnJTçA

JgLaG—qGxJowrugçrou CD2 L6 uoc TUL6q gç JJJgLdTu p? 6q6LgJ

anbbjA acpeqne tOL CD2 gç bL6ATJJd CD TU6L62 Lgç6 TUC6

pLO]C6U JJJCa L6 rIIJJT)C6JA pOPt6A6L gc6 g beLteccJA 6J2çTC

ObeLgçrOua guq aflbbiA O CL6qT co pU)c—q6b6ug6LJç pOLLOIi6L2

gijq CD2 ga b6Ltecc arzpaçrçn4e& ITU)C p6C1'6613 0b613 mgtjceç

(raao) pe bouc6g onç' tOL 6xmbJ6t puja 266 qeboaça

ot q6boaJç cDa) tJJ6U .p6 E6q 6CL6262 L626LA62 J�01D6L iiq

piijca cu La6 nuqa Lon, uou—qsboac aonLcea (eâ c6LçTTcgç6a

anLtgcea T' qqL6aaua cpLq dfl62cTOU O 4JJ6 6926 tçp

VU JJfl2çL9OU O d9b peçieeu woqja giiq bL9cçrce

acOLTea gLe à6U6L9TJA cgaç LJ o obeu iujeç obeLçroua

äeueLgJjA Oaec pA obeu mgjceç obeL9cToua' pgu)c—JeuqnJa—cJJguueJ

eecça OLY L626LA62 O cp9LJc6a L626LA6 L6dflTL6JiJ6IJce 9L6

JugL)ceç Ob6LgçTOU OL cJJgude T' L626LA6 L6dI1TL6IUGIJc2 86C9f126

cjiude TU 6q6LJ nuqa L96 TU o qAUflJc 0b6U

ancp g 2PTtc Tu JiloueçgLA boiTcA corijq pe geuc6q q2cL6c6

L626LA62 g g L62tTIC O 2JJTt4 TU moueçgLA boiicA iu bLTucTbJet

JjJ6 tOJ1LJJ 9LänmeLJç 2L62262 exodeuoiie cpgLYdea pi 9LJ]

TU 69LJA ]O2t gJJ 6126 edni

pieaeq LedsTgçOLA 2CLIIcTLJA qecegaeq pguja1 I'TIITUaU622 euq

13

Page 16: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

bLseuccou bbei pejoz

Lgm6 4PT8 qT2cIT2aToJJ n21138 g eTJJIbTG moge gu rucnrcTA6

woIJecgLX boITcX pe7ouq eecç 013 TuceLc Lgçea J1p6 ybbeiiqx

POLLOM6L2 LJgLJCTgJ OL poçp OGL cpguueI2 OLGxbIoL6 JJOM AOTgçTOue OL IJoJ.JTLJgucrgcL022—2eCçrougJ V2 I 6XJliIJ6 cPT2 rceLgcnL6' I

yccoLquàIA embLcI L626LCJJ6L2 A6 oCO2 40 boflc?—LJqflc6q cpgude2 P3 TUçGL62ç Lgçea

qP6LGUC62 P3 tTLI apqo coaç o pjguc gug pJ L6eboue o

jGUqpJa cpguJJGJ11 JJJGCJJgUTaflJa piibjA 2TdUTTcUç CL022—a6cçrougJ

904J1 pJIJc]-gr C0UcLgTUc2 013 POLLOM6L211 guq 11pgujc

001110 LKOW XODE8 LO EWbIEICY E8EYCR

qebeuq ouj.7 oii exT?pGuce o pIJJc-.geb6uq6uç poLLoz,r.a.

130 JouaeL c6UcLgT' guq 66CcTA6ue2 O 2flcp LeanJg4oL?, gcçToua

2TUCG cJ36 dneacTou o ;pe coaç o uou—qeboac onLcea o rniga T2

6 JJJOL6 bLOuOrnJCGq OL cae ot obeu iiiL)C6 obeLcou&

q6c2oIrn o puJc—qebeuq6uç POLLOMGL2 H6LG 66Cç2 gL6 JflC6JA

boJTcA cgij pgA6 L6J eGCç8 cJJLonaJJ TUtTn6UCTJä 76 ebeuqpiâ

COULOJ2 tOL 6xIIJbjG —— L6bL626IJç uoçpe MA U MPTCJJ mou6ç9L7

ob6LgçTou2t L6aflJçoLA ccou pA C6LJL p9U) —— CLGqç

14J3TJ6 cp6 toLGäoTIJd qcr722ou C6IJ6L2 013 Ob6LJ mjeçP0LL0M6L2 g pujc J6IJqIJd cJJuu6J MTIT pG obeLgçrAe

c0I32çLTuç? 013 T22ITUd CD2 IJq pujc rgq pujc—qebeuqeijç

Page 17: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

cpuaee osr.. cpis Tu IuTX.1 pçieeu puc joua gug coww6x.cigj

coucx.gcciud JO COIJ26L cPT boçeiiç1 co-moAem6uç R2M tOCST2 OU

22ITUC6 12 L121Ud mldpc 2naaeaç pujc jou nbb 12cLGQfç HOM6A6L g ILl pgujc jeuqua MJJTTG COWIM6LCJ bgbex.

COJJJ1JJ6LCT bb6L 122ng1jc6 TTJC6TA L6tTGC. cpudea TU qeuuq 'ox.

K2M exbeLTmeuc nbmvx.q ox. qoAubtgLq ' poçp pujc reuqud uqcroa obeu—mgx.jceç 2flP2ç7;nçet 122fl9UC6 O COmm6LCgJ bgbex. iuGxgmTLJG L6JgçrAe jncçngçioua ILl AOJflllIG O pgujc joIJ2 guq g

2cITq6 K2pAb' 21' giiq MTTCOX (3) -- P61JC6tOL4JJ j --

g CTGA6x. bbex. pg eçpisnçq g urnøpsx. ot embTx.TcgJ

qmuq fox. 10gU2

q6bLGee qex.q couarnisbclou uq TuA62Cw6uc 2b6ugua% L6qncud

6xJiJb6 LuG GttGCc O fJJ6 coUçLYcçToLlO1J Tcrac x.gce COn]cj

bIO226x. Ta81) couaq6r. cp cae o g iuouecgxJ couçx.cçiout tox.

LG2bOUqLJa piiice GXbGCçGq tncnx.e onçbriç (ga ILl KIud ug

cOu22c6uç I#tTCP g ]22 O woqeje T'' MPTCP cLGqc T b22AG'cx.qç m6anx.ea orzçbriç ILl ddLedçG cpJJG-26x.162 qgçg 12 go

puJc-q6b6uq6JJç pox.x.oPex.2) LednTLe2 ax.egç cgx.e TwbJA uqpJaaaLeagç6 qgçg (Tçp gu ee açnq7qua Loje bjAeg p7

ITU]C2 peçz#66u .çJJG AOIflhJJG O cx.eqc guq 6C0U0W1C CçTATç7, ILl

ucex.meqx.ea) cua TLJCOJIJbJ6c6 UUCJ 1JLGB EXJJIIJIJä

ax.onba ot poLLo,.tex.2 (beLpgb2 ucjnqud pujc or. opex. uucjmoqea uq cLeqc ei o woueçx.7t bojic7 uniae 013 ceLçgru

LJJ6 JJITCLO6COUOIUTC nuqex.buiiuâe 0; poçp ;ruucTg cceex.gçox.

%crlqTe2 u& yaaLe&gçe

EwbLcgT .aevLcp ou ;p. ,1cL.qc AbA,.

Page 18: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

TdPOflc ou coumlrçIu6uçe L6C61A6 g awgj. 2L6 o pujc TOguaCoIwIJTcJIJsuca v6L gu 6baog6 o moueçgLA couçLgcçou% L1i12

WoLdu (ia) uqa g aTmrJgL Lea1IJç 111 gu LJgTA2T2 o jogu

pujc ouaTIJCL6g26 pj COmIU6LCT] bb61. raanguc6 LJJ6L pA g 6CL626 111

qnLud g L6C6aaT0u apItca T'' cPG mIx L6 6xbru6q pA gu2flp2TçflçTOU p6çt'66U pujc jogue ug CO1WIJ6LCI bb6L LdIT6pge qabn;eq JJ6 k2M ud6LbL6çgOu o mix ga 1uear1Lud g

o 0111161. uq fl6Pti2C (ra3) guq EL6qiiigu uq KnccuGr.. (r3)

poLLoATud pA gLd6 TLm2 ATçp eaX CC622 JJ6 COJIJDJGLCTJ bgber.

Iuaç6q' P6 p.JCL6g26 TU COWW6LCTJ bb6L Taeflguc6 L6t16Cd2

40 dP6 COWJJI6LCTJ bb6L iiigjcec tOJIOMTud g uroueçgLA couçr..cçrou

ic g1ao qoGa uoç gbbegi. pgu]-q6b6uqeu POLLOt.6L2 2t.1ccp

mxa16 12 jejq couaçuç uJou6çgLA bojcA cpgud6a go uoç g]çGL dP6

nJco1.bo1.g6q 111 JJ6 qeruiçioiJ ot awgj TLm2, g6pç guq ouce tTLm

uq uqccea cpgc OUCG Cge CL6qç 2C6LdT6L uq eTTcpLT2d I40L6OA6L 4P6 6Aq6uC6 111 0111161.

toiiot.trud g wouGçgLA COLJdLC;O1J T2 P01.116 pA amgJJ6r. tTLJØ2 (266

JJ6ç6LOd6JJ6TçA pOM6A6L 3j76 Pt1L6U o g q6GT1J6 111 pgujc joua

W6 dd1.6dgç6 2çoLA pA K2M majca aiduircguç TLm-J6AeI

T11A62dm611d JJOJqpJd couaçguç 0JJ6L q6c6Lmuguca30

dJJG iiqx pe uqeb6ug6uç bLeqccA6 boMeL tor. TuAeucoLA guq x6q

dr.qnjA qecru6 j1peA gjao uq boJcA-ugr1c6q cpgud6a Tu

JJ6 AO1il6 ot cOmm6LCIgI bber. Taanea r.Ta6a Mp116 puc rogJa

couçr.cçiougr.A bolIcA aIJTtda Tq611d1t6q pA Om6L ug om6Lt Ta8a)'

eqer.gj nuga r.çe (or. 1622 couçrunonajA gç d1JJ6 O JJ6

COJHJ1I6LCT bb6L) j,p6A tug dpgc 111 r.eabouae rucr.egaea 111 JJ6bgb6r.. (q6tu6q ga pujc 1ogue qpqeq pA aiim ot pujc ogua guq

Page 19: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

pA eqej niiqa r.gçe uuoAcoua OL pA qçea q6ucTreq pA

TLI 412iUjT1, guq 1JgLd61 TLJDa1 L62b0U262 Co dJJç moueA (ga ineaneq1Gb0L qgçg' C6LCT6L iiq CTTCPLT2C COIJaq6L 6L61JC6

6 P6JJA0L O murzgcçnLrud tTLma 2flhJJ1ilSL6 u cigijg CTTcJJLT2C (iaa) a bLçrci1JLjA combejjrua J16L6 yugAsruäqAqeuq—bAua TLJII2 qni.ud LGCG22TOU2 ILJJG 6Aq6uC6 O CGLCT6L

6dngJ TIJC6LUgJ nuqa jJg6 g dLGgçGL 6ttGCC OU TuAeaCJiseuc pA uou—

pjuc apeeça CGLCJGL uq Hnpprq (1a89) coucpiqe eee

Tmb6L6ccToua tOCflaea oIJ 66C2 O wou6çgLA bOITCA ou pootei.a

pe eecouq poqA o embLcJ ujAe1a o

TuçeL6aç—Lgçe 66C6 O 0B61J mgjceç Ob6L9CTOU2 MiTT pe wdueq6X6LJ moueçgLA boircA cu gecç poLLoz6Le4 iJ6 zoLçp' bnLecouaçiiç TUAGaCmGUC obboLçnuiçrea) JIPT2 aflaaGaça

ueç—MoLçp POLLOft6L or. pdp-LJeç-Lb%oLçp OLLOM6L2 (poJqua

bLoxrea tOL pOLLOt6La1 UGç !'OLJJ gecç TIJAG2CW6UC IUOL6 tOL TOt—

Jj36L6 Ta g anpaçiiçrj poqA o eJJJbLcj eAq6uc6 gocnmeuçTua6XT2çTIJd cLoaa—aGcçToIJgJ embrr.icj açflqTea JJgA6 p661.1 ancceeatn]-:

qecJaoua o aome OLLObt6L2 WOLG cpgu ocpeLa yç 01.16 J6A6J

JIJgLJC6c pIJbeLtecCToua gecc TuA6acIu6uc eiubioAmeuç 01. bLoqncçou

pzibcçou o flUqGLJApJa CJJG0LT6B -- 13u16JA cL6qç-WOLG COIJATIJCTUd 61UbLCJ CeaCa OCfl2 01.1 cLOa—ecçTous

ocnu ou cLoa—ecco13g jbrQ9çTou

co amje tTLma (gJowLet HTmi1JeTp6Ld guq MgCPCGI' iaai)

6Luuaa qGCJTue (LL6qwu guq KflCCLJ6L ra3) oi.

O awooçp Jncçngçroiia T13 CJJ6TL tro! o nuqa MJJGU

Page 20: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

äeuetj moqej TU APTCJJ TOA-U6C-AOLJJ LW2 tC6 11101.6 C02ç]AcoLJçx.gcçrou HOLbt6A6L xr L62ITT2 LG cOueTeçeIJç Arcp g J110L6

g pujc jeuqpid CUU6 M92 ob6LçAe TU LGaboIJa6 JUOU6çLAt;eq ot tçeq combu6a jpea bçç6Lua ]6q RPB po coucjriq6eCç O cep porquàe 01, TIJA6IJcOLA TJJA88W6U tOt 6TCPGL 13011—(z.tpcp xra qeuçA ATçJJ u eeX woueA 6beoge) pJq ITccTeTUAeUc0LA TUA62CIUGUc PA tçeq t1Lw8 iu enpeedn6uç pooJ,s11 Aegta

LIU2 oAu cgep poquae% gu eecç uoç bteeeuç oLTuAeecweuc pA 1JoU—Lç6q tTT.me Age ut]nGIJC6qt gjj 6J26 GdnsJt pAtOITOATUd g cTdJJc moueA ebeoqe) ;peA uq TuAeucoLA

83 teceeBToIl (ge g piqL6cç meua ot qeucAud g betoqz'tTcjionc pouq tgcua& ge g btoxA tot pujc qebeugeuce EocneTud 013

açnqA TUA6UCOLA TLJA62cm6Uc pA bnpITcIA utma ATcP gugcoueçtueq (T cgeet pu1c-qebeuqeijç) 01. uoç lu btCcnJt'bbtocp ot cJ8?Aud dtocibe o tme ge s boi.r tTuguc6-jJeUceotçp KP2 -- 0JJObt (1a88)netud tTLIØ—TGAGT qgçg' KsepAbt psmouç' uqpu)c-qebeugeLJç guq uou-puc—qebeuqeuç 0LLOA6L2 pge P6GLJ oJ6teq

LoMLq eug' 1001.6 qL6cç CO1JJbL2O1J2 ot pottoATud pA

apAb' rgiuouç' guq cepi (iaa') 1 qqçou' jgmeA ()pA orTuet guq jnqepnep () guq tot TUAGIJC0LA TUA6acw6uc pA

CCGJGLçOL IuoqGJe' pge 0L1J6 017 tot acnqee 0J xeq TUA62c10613c

CbTLTc 0 egLJTeL CL02e—26CçO1Jg]- ceepa 0 tnJ1JCJJjJ6 6Lç]6t-JCJJL2ç Lsen]ç2' AJJCP gLG A6LA IUIICJJ P3

eiUj' pfTç io oL jgtde' JJ1Ufltcçf1t1Jd t11I2

cbccA) Te eeocçeq bO8TcTA6TA ATcP T6LcO.7 ccnmnrcoIJ toto ceji t10b o qepç—aetce

;ru1.Jcr gcceetgçot bbtocp T13gA% CJJOA Lgçro

26COt ge g 14Ji0J6 8 dtoMTIJd 11101.6 2JOAJAt gjao COUCTCC6ZJC

2IIJgJJ-TLIII ALTp]6e te eptb6L Tu btoqe M6U ewjj—tiisgjeo qemouaçtçe 6tt6C2 o 2jJçe P3 W01J6çLA boiTcA 013 fl36

teeriça COueTeçeuç ATcJJ TuucTj ccetgçot bbtocp jpeAjgtde tTLJIJ2 OAGt S b€Loq torloAlud g JIIOU6çSLA cTdJJcGuTUa'

T.A6uc0tT62' guq epotç—çGTJJ gepç q6CIu6 t6TgcTAe totI0W6L uq JO1116L' iasa) lu btçrcnjgr.' 210511 agree

18

Page 21: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

6C6LU9I tTIJ9JJC6 1 qoIUçnLJJa

Lm2 9L6 100L6 TT)C6T7 6 JJ6 jou Cfl2OJJI6L2 O 2JTCJ pgucatOL 1Lm8, 6COLJ T2 6A6I3C6 cjjgc awgJJ OL JOPt—U6—MOLp

tOT C6LS1J dLoflba O psy T 861326 JJ9 J39A6 P6613 q6uc6q

6Aq6UCG o aTduTtTcguC q6b9Lf1L6a tLOW WOqdT9LJ-WJJ6L L621TTC2

i couaqi. CIJT2 dnea;Tou P6TOM 711 4JJL66 aç6ba ETLac Ta JJ6L6

wou6çgL7 couçL9cçroue' drfeaçTou O JJ6 LOT6 O 913C2 L6ILIgTLI2

uq ToM-1J6C-borCp Lm2 gbbegr. Leabouq q-eLeucgrTA

9cceJeL9çor. 9bbLo9cp pie peu T wcLo—qgc9 açng-ea

41JT16 JJ6 bLrucTbgJ embrLYcgJ bLeqcçoL2 o iiguci-gj

yes sc euquâ cp9ul3e

IgLaG TL1U—21U9TT tTLJD qt6L61Jc62

CXCTTCT tJffccn9cTOIJa T13 m9un9cpnLua 29J62 C911 6 6xbIgpJ6q

O 29J62 O J36 mgIrntgccnLTuä 2GCCOLt LonaJJjx oI36—çJJLq o

tTLJII2s agIGa (ga JJGA q6LJ6 eusgrr tTLW2) combLTaG ponç ou6—cpLg

aaLea9ç6 JJnCçngçTOIJ2 tOL CJJ6 m9unt9cCnLpJä 26cçoL 6C9fl26 2U19fl

LonapJ fl36 291156 2T6 92 tTflCcfl9;10112 T' COLLG2bOIJqJLJa

Tuq cjJgc tInCPI9CTOU2 T13 JJ6 rgLae tiLIJJ-alugJJ tTLJJI q6LeuC6a 9L6

q6L613c62 T13 uq TUA6UC0LTG2 p uqracLA JJJ6A

uq CTTCJJLT2C (Taa) sugfle J9Lae—aiusJT iii9lilltgCcrlLTua TLm

13 fl9T4GL eboLç2 6LU91JJC6 C6LCT6L

ETU9TTX rzaTua JJ6 tTLIU-16A61 qçg rnJq6LrAu8 JJ6 gaaLeagçea

IJOLWçO1J poriç tTflL6 CDb

Ot 8111911 tTLma O 4JJ9 tOL IgLa6 tTLMI2 O6L2 aTauTt]-cguc

2OM2 OL toLGcg2cflJa B11L1D0262' JJ6 LgçTO O 4J76 29162 aLoAçp

Page 22: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

JJOM6A6L TU .JJ6 L62b0U26 O 4JJ6 IOJfUUG O reuqua g cpgude pJ

rjieA ijq aTdUtcguC pGçGLoa6U6TçA coaa pujc ai- cjgaaedLobçJJ Lg;6 o uouquj cox.e qeboaca OL gjj pujc aT6 cTgaaGa

3 ;eqej nuqe Lg;e) jeqa ;o g ajjjjg Leqnccou pi JJ6

apozt co1JçLcçToJJLA woueçgLA bojicA (JsJegasiLGq pA gu TI3CL6g26

gç oL pejoM cp' aoj' ô2çp or. ber.ceucrea) LJJGA tTLac

pu]ca1 (Tu ber.ceucrie) ug 1amjj14 pujca (qeru6q ga

apAgb ug 2ceTu coiaçr.ncç aeeç aTe ar.osib1uaa tOL 1JLa61cj iebor.ca.1 cojjec;eq pA eqer.j IeaeLAe

aT6 jo go nee ggçg qLu Low dnr.cer.jA

qGLGUCGa p3 IJIJCiJà IJq Teuqua qGCT2TOIJ2 O P13'C OCt q6L6uc aTG xajAgb uq CLOa2—26Cç]Oug

q6L6uc62 pi piucpa guq LGJ qecaoua O IL13

I6LIqua naç ga 6LJ6L anqTea ocnaeq 013 cLOa2—2eCcOuJJ6 6tt6C O cpLJa62 T.1 JJ6 ug1JCTua WTX 013 AOTflJU6 O pgujc

cpeTL TULJCpJd LUTX 1 r.eebouae o g cpguäe pgujc L626LA62 guq

aeugg pcne c gqqr.eaaea pp6 eae MJJ IWTCJJ pujce cgu jçer.

rmbor.çguç JpJe o TudTL pi •1pL1 jeuqpia cp9rnJGJ,1 L626LCJJ

açnqA p3ucpJa iiq jeuqpia q6caoua pA pu'c LJ112 Ta guruçer.ugj IJ6ç or.çp 013 TUA62JIJGIJ q6C2Ou2 pA IJOUIJUCØI tTLma co

246TU (i') bbJA Tucncou 0 woqeja ot eGC4a o

ybbpi oq 9u-wueL peoLen gapAgb gijq

crxç O pA couapr.gTLJeq tuUc-gT TuacTcncToua.

aflpaflçnçe cr.eqç Lom nucouaçr.piq uiJcT]- p.12cçnçoua %JJ6U

EpJgTJA go roM-136c-Mor.cJJ tTLma pge Tmceq ObboLc!lUTcTea

50

Page 23: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

pguja OA6L JJ6 iao—iaai L6cGB2T0IY JJJ6TL L62rIIC2 pqTCC6I�o2euaLeu (toLCpcomTud) gugJ76 JJ6 jeuqpid peJJAroL O MGM EUaJUq

CPT2 cOuc6Xc pgujc cb1çj mX 6 g 66L bLoxA b66JC guq

cp6oLecTcgl moq6]& PtJJTCP 2CL622 1UbOLç1JC6 O 1U6ç MOLçp11 ILl

qtt6L6uC62 qoe UOC COLL62b0Uq bL6CT26T O nuq6LIAud

ILPG 1126 O puj 8T6 g g 62flL6 deuGIgç6 CLO22—26CçTOIJT

qTt6L6Uc)

2GcnLTcT6a polgpJa2 (çporiap cpe Leabouaea gLe uoç aCgçr2CrcgJ]-A

JJoJqua2 gLe J622 2elJ2TçTA6 WOIJGçLA bojcA JLde p1ije,

CO1JCLCçTO1J JJJ6A cçnjJ?t Liq 2Ju]J puj1 26C11L1CT62

pojqpid? O 26C11L1C162 L6JçTA6 O ]gLae IJJC2 qnLud g JliO1J6çL7

K2JJA9b gug 2c61u gugjAe AJJGçJJ6L emgjj pujc LlCL626 CPGTL

L62bOLJ262 iioçeq pA aJJAgb guq 2C6T11 JO 6XJ1J1J6 CJJT2 boaaTpTJTCAt

2111g17 pglJ)c2 conjq 6 COU2T2C61JC ACJJ JJ6 q6LGuc9] I6uqLldO JgLäe pgyja g gj Tu jou qewiiq (pA awgj poLLobtGLe)

C112C0106L2 O 2TT pujce gug JLà6 tTLJJJ2 6U O p6 JJ6 C1T2OJD6L2

TLma LsJgçrA6 40 gLd6 tTLJJJ2 It ewjj tTLMI2 .çeuq P6 JJ6

g mou6çgLA couç.cou teg)eu2 pjuce apec boaTCToua ot mjj

0116 boaeTpIG eXb]gu9çrou tOL cp6 apAb-çsru bgçç6Lu ia

uqn2çLg] 10gu2.

!'JJ6JJ oua gLG q29ääL6âC6q O ucIrsq6 J12ç COJIJTH6LCT9T uqOLl2 iiq pA JgLde gug eJøgjj pujca y 2rwrJL bçç6Lu GJJJGLdG2

pguJc2 1jJ626 qo UOC 2TIUbJA LGtT6CC tt6L6UC62 T11 JJ6 CAb6 ot

Tu COLICL2 g qeCTu6 Tu jeuquä IJ JJ6 2JJOL LIIU pA

JJCL626 P' r6uqi.id 711 JJ6 2JJOL LuLl pA A6LX jgtae pgujc ILJJT2 T2

JMOIJ6çLA botcA iu bgL7cngL g JuJOu6çLA CO1JCLCOU iegq O gil

3]-

Page 24: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ncJ.T gu ujArVJJJ xeAb D9LTJ12 guq I L6 CflLLGIJcTA 6uaaeg

edcigj 11cgbrçgj 2flLbTfl21 TU8cT4flcToLeqnceg cpsi. ci jou LGPbOIJ2S pA TSLdGL gIuonuç2' gjj 6126LGdnTLemeLlce p6A uq 1cbcj apoLçgJJ1 Tu2cTcncTouaLG2b0U2TAGUG22 ot boLctojTo comboelcTou cpudee ii cbçthTLçeLJA qgçg ou IJqqrzI pu]c81 boLcoJToacLeqc IJoccou Hgucocjc' pgpiâ' giiq MTTCOX (ia) gjo 1126ucLoqnccou o Lf2)c-pg2eq cbç9J LGd11TL6WGUc2 bei. e 9ecçeqbeLoq' BGLdGL uq qejj (m) oiuq ITccIG eqeuce

3n2Tud qsçg OIl COJIJJilGLCTØI pgIJ]C8 IJçOIJMfq6 OAGL

bgr.ç o moueçgLA 1U6cJ1g11T2w cgca bjceLeTgcTOIJeprb2 YIUbjA 211CJJ eAcCp6a gLe coa]A uq nu]rcejA i

JJJ6OLT62 6Iilbp2pJd cp6 wboLcuce o oiJoud pOLLOt.6L-6LYg6L

11rnJcou2çLgruGg,1 psujce qnLud eb2oqe2 o nJoueçgLA coIJçLgcçroue

IJJ6JJ6L 11coIJaçLpJGq11 tTLJIJ2 2MTcCIJ tLOW ,.cou8cLgueq14 pujce

1cozJacLu6q0 tTLZJJ2 gLe Cff2OflJ6L2 O 11COU2çLgU6q,, puy

T6IJc6L giig jeuqu8 ceLI oue conq eacprep MJJG6Lou CPLCç6L8çC9 o POLLOA6L

TLJd11TLA LednrLea gu exmuçou o qç ou uqAqnJ jogup9IJ]2 2IICJJ g2 qeiçeq PA Kg2pAgb guq ceu 31PT2 ITUG o

couaçLg]-1J6q11 gLe jou cnecOJzJeLa o cou2çLgrueq (2JHJJ)

P6 tTLm2 q6Uçeq pA 6mbLCJ L626LC6L2 ga iugijce-40 JIIçCJJIJa O POLLOI6L2 guq jeiiqeLe IJJ6 OLIU6L gejca P4J6JJ6L

wsçcpp oozet guq eqet jpe dnGecTou2 LGJgçG

2JJ66c2 O pJc6Lm6ggLG2 g AGIT g2 pOLLOb6L2

TmbeLteccToua TU tiiJucr wjceça oil pjuce

tTuquda cJJGTL eAq6uce anbboLça cpe q6 o e6cç obooLJA H6UC6 i'tçjJ apAb-çeru

rogue o cbrçgreq pu]c2 eii pA 1622 iogu o

55

Page 25: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

Teanea O tTLm2J61J6L8 d6IJ6LJJ7I' pJcLeud qewguq oL comm6r..cJ bb6LbO2rrOu2 O JDIIA poor bLGcybT;gC62 g -jpç dnçA11 pA

yuoçpet boa2TpTJTcA a egyeueq puce peeç

uegeq L620JA6 cPTB dnee;Tou

;iLm2 (OL6 61ilbTLTCJ IJAeaçäcou 0

g qouçnu pA Lg2pJd coç o nuq tOL cou2cLgTu6g

.4TUceLeqLA LOJG L6JncçI3çJA' A6LA coagjA cL6qç mA

oçjier. psuq' It JLde' bbeL-22n1ua tTLIU8 gccebç

ceqç CflafOmGL2'11 6uçgTe AGLA TmTc6q JIJgCLOGCOIJOIUTC 66Cç2 ou

atçcp O POLLOA6L2 tLOW pGTLJa ,1pujc CflaçOm6T.2, PGTLJd 1çLq6

6LW2 L6 130 OL6 CO?fJA pujc uceLmeqLA TLJIJC6' cpeLj

rGLJIIE pubo2eq pA pJçeLmeqL6a i' oii 0136 pguq' ricj

cpguu6j' Tc puboLçuç eaçpjp pgç pgbbeu2 coç gijq

tTLma pJ 20G beLoqa r.oiø 2cuqbopJc ot pic jeuqpa

CJ3626 LJII2 iiigA 26LA6 92 ceqç .4uceLweq9L6211 OL 2109T16L

L6C6TA9pTG 1.126 tOL b9bGL—T22flTIJa r.w' 2nbbotcpiä liocloLl .çpç

tTIJgIJC6 jogue 4o 211191161. tTLJ11 LJJGA LJO6 ccoriuça

TaanTUà JL102 T1JCL6926 b9beL poLLo1.T1J82 gnLud qol.tuçnLua p3 oLq6r.

T22flg1JC6 iiq 9LdnG J9La6' JJIap-dfI9IicA collflUELcTgI-bgb6L

gug cpçej (i) ugAe tTLW-T6AGT qç 013 COUIIØ6LCT9I bgber.

JIJO1J6ç9LA bOITCA 18 tLn2cLgceq Iii JJ18 A6113' cgiomTLTa' HTJUm6TP6La'

toiioirua S DJOIJ6çSLA COIJcLSC;TOIJ' USLLobt S1J)C ceqç CJJSIJU6I 011cou2çLSpJ6q11 pgu]2 csu i.çcp sç ro, coaç uoupsi,c 6UGL2

pogqe CJ922 ot JGU6L2 pgu]ca11 It P0LLO6L2 tLOIIJ

JJJ6 TScceL 0 dn6acToua anaaeeçe u66q 2çr!qA g

cptondp L6qf1CTou2 T iogu aribbjA pA ,4COU2çLSpJ6q1 pSU)C2

53

Page 26: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

MGLIIJTIJdGL (Ta3)giig RGTTGPGL (iaao)t bGLLA giiq 2CJJflJC6 (Taa5) uq COPGU uqCITLL6IJ beioq gLiq qeuope Ja2• 266k tOL 6x1UbJ6' IITLCTGpriqdep 2nLbJn& . 1 JJ6 cpguâe 1" eqeLj riuqa Lgç6t c I CJ6CDbt 1 12 JJ6 b6LC6IJd6 CJJSUdG T CJJ6 pTdp-6mbToAJeuC ;qejJJ6L6 ]. 2 beLc6uçâe CJJSLJa6 'i '.ej CDb rercAe boç6uç1j

—c(ç— —gjç—is.2P L6JgcOuBpb2 gLe eeçpuq g2:

j�ome.ta1 bbLocp(raa',) HOOA6L guq B6LG (Iasf) O6L g Ufllup6L O CLTCTCT2JJI2 otE66LJ ObGLJ WL)C6 COJIJJJJTCC6Gt 266 gieo CJJ6 q2cr12aOu TU CGCCIJ6CCTo nuewbjoAmeuç uq TIJtJ9CTOU g2 qGCGLmTuguca O gC4TOIJ8 PAJsAboçpeeTa 26A6L IOJil6L qçe gLe bL6qTCCpJ6 n21uâ W62(TL62(J) gx.âaee 6Xwb]6' eJIJbLcgI GATqGIJCG AOL8 fIGuq j�omex. (I9a) JJA6 d6uGL46q 2ducguç couçLoAeL2A 2pbLo

Lp6 qçe o JiloU6çLA boilcA COUCLcCOLJ8 2flaae2çeq pA ome

COLJLOU CP6 bO22TPTTTCA ;jjgç CJJG iueaneq TUCGL62C 26IJ2TCTATCA ot

guq CJ76 cpgude TU CJJG eqegj nuqe L6 2ICP aCnqTGE 1Ur12.p tTL2C

P6Pi66U CJJ6 b6LC6IJça6 cJJ1JaG IJ L6J CDb LeJgçTA6 4O boCeuçrj 0Db

qocnweuç g 2raIJTrcguç ueâgçAe L6JsçTou2pTb TU dnLç6LJA

Iii qqC013' L6C6IJ uAeee OJ boflcA-L6qflc6q-OLJil moqej

2CnqAIJd CJJ6 66C42 O JJJOU6çLA bojcA 2p0c)c2

ECJJGUp17JJI guq EA1J2 (toLCpcomlua) o;i. bLoT21ua acLCeae2 tOL

J�6C6UC LG26LCJJ pA BGLLJSU)C6 guq DTTuqeL (j) cpLeçguoqeuçALJd 6XOä6IJO112 cpglJaea ILl uJOU6çLA bOITCA 12 qTuTcnJcOA6L MJJJCJJ JJG C6JJLg] pgujc cu 6X6LC126 exoaeuoJT2 CO1JçLOJ ETL2C

Onc2q6 iijoueA gqt mboL;uçJXt ou comboLlGuC2 O Orzc2q6 mOUGA

qeacLbcou O6L6 ILl 26COU II 2fldd6aC2 gu GJisbpg2ra

embLCJ 2Cflq62 OCfl2 011 JøOU6çgLA 9aaLeaçe2 2rICJJ ga CP6

O 4J36 P2C JHOIJ6A ATGM y C61JLJ bLoplew Ta t'tJJTI6 JIIO2

WOT6 6IilbLCT L626LCJJ 12 glao UGeqeg Co aaeaa JJ6 AIqcAEWbTLTCVT KSBSVLCP OD COUAOIITOJJVT xuceeac-vce CPVDUOTe

Page 27: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ruaçegq o .çpe 6q6LJ nuqa Lç6ecça z.tjseu wOu6çLA dâL6dçee gLe naq ga ;pe boilcA uqcgcoL

58COAGL () ;pqa 8f111 ?4LOIJa6L eAq61Jc6 0 9aAmm6cLTC

JbO OpaeLAgçToua 6meLae CJ6LJA LOm ITc6Lcf1L6: ETLac

guq\oL TIJçGLXil6qTgLTG2

rmbgcça ot boTTcA gcoua ou Cp6 tTIJgIjcTgI boaToua ot poLLoz'tei.e

(or. ;Tuucrg] CC6T6L9çOLS4) e6cça aceJlmisTua tLOII,

OA6LSJJ T6AGT O L6J CO842 O JflhJq2 iiq OIJG r.ejçeqTuco bgr.ça: 0136 r.eTg;eq o boJcA—uqncGg cpguâea 013

anaaeaç fl6tflTIJG22 O q6cOmbO2IJd ;LglJawTaarOu m6CpureJJJ

luoq6]2 o psoL1uçou guq TUcGUCTAG br.opjema T13 p3UCTJ iør.jeça

qepgçsa OA6L CLgIJaIIIT22TOU JJJ6CPIJ2In O WOIJ6çgLA boJTcA jecsuç

A761"k41 gr.e iioç ji.tAa M6JJ U cpeOL6çCgr gug 6JilbLcgJ

JJJra 2fILA6A Ldn6a pjjgç 11mOu6A ATGA11 gug 11cLGqTç

COMCFflBIOII yw IwbrIcYIoSta LO WOMELYA orxcz

TucGLeac r.çea (1'pTcp ecç tTLma1 coaç o cbrCgj)

uun6uceq pA boiTcA ccoua) guq cpgiiaea u roua—cer.iø r.egj

1 apoLç-ç6Lm LGJ TcLc LçGa (ApTcp r.e aauricguçA

iq 6iiibrr.rcj L626LCJJ Ta ueeqeg 6XJJJT1J6 TTIJ]C2 psçeeu cpgud6a

qr.eaea T13 eq6L9J nuga Lgç68 TuJJA IJJOL6 cJJ6OL6cCgI

0 gjj 2AJIJ1U6çLTC r.eaboiiae 0 6COIJOWTC cçrArçA rucr.egaea OL

JLd6 ueâçrA6 6L1.OLa qnL1Jâ L6C622T0U2 BJldc3GaçTIJd boaapJçAr.eaqngia tLOJJJ 6acmceq boIcA—L6gncegoLm edncoua qabJ9A

wor.agu (raa3) guq COPGIJ guq MGUUTUd6L (T3) Ta &ISLçGLJA

0L C6LçgTIJ ar.onba o poLr.oMeLa\ebGuqeLa• 26C01J Taen6 LJ06 pA

onçbrzç LGJ6C2 ITU]Ca p64M6613 TU46L62c r.e giiq iJ6ç btOLçJJ cjiuaea

Page 28: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

cpuiiej O L6C6U LJgLJCTg] IJ1JOAçOI12jpoLuçou (i) qacnaa62 ITJC6V 6tt6C8 ou pguc T6uguä6LJUccJJT (raa3) EML2 (1a3) guq BOAq L7q C6LT6L (iai)

L6C6IJ gUJA26e O tfl4flL6 O pguyriid' 266 COL0U Suq

6COLJOJ11C JIIOq6JeLa guq bojcJ)c6Lauq ceqç uq u oL6caçpJâ T2 u wboL;guc bLgccrcgj 4g2c tOL

pJcoLboLce poLLot6r. pecsLoaeuecX TU po;ji 6COIJOWTC woqej O JJJOLJGA

tTLW2 I'TcP ,egJc pjguce pee boercloua DeAerobTua Ag72

jieapceiieq L0J6 OL moueçLA bojic1 TU ecçrLJà LegI qGcTaToua o

ugLLoz.6L DOcJJ opa6LAgçToU2 uoceq gpOAe L6 cOu22ç6uç MTçJJ g

8COb6 tOL woueçgLA boilcA geCç LegJ OIICOJJJ62 T2 pecoMlTua

TgJcTgT 2eçeIu gcgqemrca uq boJc?uis]ceL2 gLe giigj?rud !JJ6JJ6L

b9Lç pecgnae O COIJCGLJJ OA6L 66Cç2 O ru2çrçncrougj CJJLJà6 IJ JJ6gjceLugçrAe AT6M2 O 4J6 WOIJ6çSL?t cLguamr22rOu W6GpSUT2IU iq TU

tOL gç jeç 201116 pOLLO1s6L2 ILl bLç P6Cfl26 O TUC6L62c U

eb6cTgJrrua u;eLm6qLea gLe jjceflt o cLeqc

26COU enaaeaC2 LeànJgcoL? bolIclee g6Ccud TLJOLIugcTO1J_

iTJc6T1 O coiJçune g L0J6 TU p0211J6?2 JnCçngçTOu2 3JJ16

JjJ6 L2ç Opa6LAçTOU anàdeaç2 TU1JCTJ COL2 gLG

cpee

plJ)C2 OL 0JJ6L IGIJqGL2) MJJC02ç qiguçâea TU beLtoLmTua

CL6gc bLOC62at pLJbLçpJd g 412b6cTJ1 LOT6 tOL uc6LmeqgL62 (pe

flJtOLJDgçTOIJ C0242 0 acLeeuTud egJflgçrou% guq wouTcoLTua IL;

moLe 2obp]-acc9c6g ugucrr gLLguaeweuça JJ6L6 gLe 2]JPA gCC6I6LgcOL woqeJB. c0L;q% 6A613 T bL626UC6 opjneuceq pA cJJGTL pjgiJce 2JJ66 COlJqfflOIJ T !#A2 qe2cLp6q

ebeuqua qec2ouE o g 2rduTTGguç aLonb 0 POLLOPL6L2 gL6

SQ

Page 29: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ceLçgTu cjeaee ot poLLoz't6La

eeCça ou onçbnç LGtTGC JgLä6 G6Cç O bOJCA 013

JJJoueçgLA bOITCA guq cjJG GX46IJ btPTCP OP26LA6 ruceLeac—Lgc6

poçj CLO22-GCçOIJgJ pGcGLoa6LJGTcA T13 L1U21 L62b0U26

anJJbTe2c cJJLcc6LTgçToJ3 ot g ruç6L6ç—Lgç6 cpuuej wnaç gqeaa

LGOJA6 flJ dflG2cTOlY yç cpe aiue cTJ11G bLoboueuç2 oS4 J6A6J O flJqAcJflJ pOLLOI6L-J613g6L ;Lu2gcçTou2 T2 LJGGqGq

2beuq —— a obeLçA6 a uoç cj6gL' poz't6AGL wor..e mTcLo 6AqeuCe

qecegaea P04:13 P1JICa1 PJç7 j6uq guq p0LLOt6La1 pTJTçA

puca1 LG6LA62 tojjobtllia coucLcço13gLA obEu mgL]c6ç ob6Lço13a

MJJ64:JJ6L 4:136 aTlUbI6aç 11pgii]c I61Jq1Ja CJJUU6J11 -- g jJ T

Page 30: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

O CJqcäo bL682 TTrug13cTg w9Lyeçe gijq Epsuc7g CLT262 cprcgäo: nurAeLarç?IUçGLL'gçrOugJ co1ubL2ou11 iii i� C161313 }jnpp9tq' 6quq EUUG9J CLT?Ta 1 JJ6 eL6gç D6bL6a2Tou: 113

96LI3LJ)C6t 9613 guq 2gm68 4aJJ16 eojq D6JgçTOLJ'

oLcpcowTua TJ J�6ATGA O ECOUOTC gug 2cgcT2cTcbgb6L 140 L8' MPTOU1 BflL6fT O ECOLIOIilTC J626gLCJJ% 1IT1A

YCC6J6LOL guq }JTaIJc 40 M0L]cTIJa9eLJJguJc& u WL]C C6LçJ6L' IJq 2TWOIJ CTTCPLT8c uJlP6

(6pLngLA iaao): 9—T1V ______________________________ECOIJOJifIC 6LoLWIJc61, pflLç6LJA 1Oflt13 O ECOUOIØTC2

96L1JLJ]C6 9613 2 guq L)C esLçJ6L seIIJg1JCTgJ ELâJçA gug

ra8a): i—r _______________________Bfl?1U628 JflcçflçTo1Ja ymeLcgu ECOUOmTC 1�6AT6

96LIJu)ce' 9611 2' iiq (LC CGLçJGL 1yaeiic? COac 46ç MOLIP gug

1�6A16M 83 (2ebcemp6L ias): aoi-ar _________________CPg1313612 O Wou6çLA LgI32wT2To1J YBJ6LTCgU ECOIJOZUTCB6LI31J]CG 9613 gig YJI3 BTpJqGL a1pe E66LT rnqa gçe guq

ydaL6aç6 D6JggUq. ylUeLTcgIJ ECOUOJMTC J6AT6t.! .8 (wA i):B6LUU]C6 9611 2 guq Y]IJ B1uq6L 14CL6gç' 4OU6A gug

I�6A161.1 (')rni T83): 5—5QJJ6 bLobgdcou O PP6 CL6Sc D6bL6a2TOU.. ymGx.rcgu ECOUOIIITC

B6LJJU]6 9613 11MoUJilou6çLX E6Cc? O ETIJI3CTT CT-121a 111

OCOP6L Ia8a): s-is _____________626LA6 Dgu)c O bpJq6Jbp 9fl211362E J�6ATG1 (6bçempeL-9GLIJgIJ]c& 9611 2 •I2 IJJGLG JOO wlcp coLboLgçe D6Pc,.1 E6geLgj

DgLl]c O 462 AOL)C p1'1LGLTA J�6ATGZ' (2bLrud i): 2o-.o96L1JU)C6 9613 2 11creqc TU gCLO6COuOm?,1 I.6q6Lg1 626LA6

3): 282—Q38onLugj O 4oiJ6A' cr-eg.c' iig BL1JCUâ (yndneç bgLcyocçe 9gujc cr.egç guq cge g 1cr.eqrc CLnIJCJJI T JJe96LdGLt 111611 i4 1Jq eL6aoL E qejj 1,Dq cbcr(1ijir.q 17gLç6L iaas): .T-8V _____________2b6cT11 6q6LJ 626LA6 Bgu]c O xgueg CTcA ECOLJODJTC J�GATS4M

96CJc6ççT g13% sug CJJ5LT6 WOLLT2 11yL6 Bs13]c rogua 2cTi

To): 99—2OO ______________________________cp wsr..jcec wGcpgIJTaJsI•ii pnsr46LJA pnLugJ o ECOUOIiITcE (ynän2ç

)C6LJO eeoLa6 JJJ6 W5LJC6 tOL remoue: öflsITcA flIJC6LcsTucA siq

ELEE1CER

58

Page 31: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ioo (wgxcp iao): _______________Iuc6L'JgT jpiuce uq 1cLeqTç ECOIJOJJJTC 1OfTLLJcTomL& CLJ68 t4 uq I� ereuu }jnppLq •IETLIU HGcGL0dGJJGTcA'

bOTTC ___________________________________________toLcpcomlua 3 CgLUGcITG-J�oCpG2cGL COIJtGLGUCG 26LT62 OIJ btJPflCB6LBbGCcTA611 WpUGodLbp' flUTA6LaT4X O ITITUOT8t 2JITA Taat41commGr-cT gbeL ijq coLborgpe LTU9UcG: y I4TcLoecouomlc

cJomrr cpjee M cpije r HTwwerpeLa guq nj CJJç6flGt A0LJC: coTrnhIpg fluTAeLefcA bL6B

cgdgij' bpTITTb pe cpuueja ot oU6çgLA EttGCc2 oii IuceLeac jgçG2

I�GATGI't (i.gA 1ae3): 383—'lOO ________________EttGccTAGLJG22 O tjoueçLA COucrOTa.1 YGLTCVU ECOIJOUITC

BrgTugLq jgw' guq 'me j1oppi IucsLm6q9;ou uq

DebgLçJllGuç' Gq6LT J6B6LA8 gu]c O WIJ1JGbOT yndriçg wozJ6çgLA eLotçp .joq6]11 MoLJqua gbsL Mo 33Bo?q' OJJ1J IF iiq BLITC6 D 2"JTJJ 11CbcT WgL)CGc IIøbeLteccToue 1"

335. ______________________________coJrç'o'J2 '1oiThuj O COUOJJ1TC JJJGOLA (YbLIT T8Q): I-

o?q iopu gug EML bLG2CO IILJIJCTgJ IIJc6Lweq9LA-

D6bgLçmGIJç E66LJ 6GLA6 9g1JC Ot WLJIJ6bOJ& wgAI6boLc2 cL6gcT? ExgaaeLs4eq wTJu6OaLgbIJ l�6a6gLCJJ

oAq oPJ H guq jc CGLcJ6L' 11yLe BUJC2 or. LG JJ6

(laga: i): .—i5i• ____________________________________NoiJ6çLA bOTTC7II BLOOICTUcI2 gDGL2 01) ECOIJOIIITC yC.TATcA

BO2MOLçJ' 9g1.LA 11I132ççflçOIJJ cpude gIJq JJ6 EtCgcA ot

(ybLTJ Iaa'Il): ________________________JJ6 ETLJIJ42 ETUgIJCTgT bOTTCA.4 16AT6A Ot ECOUOmTC 2(1gT6 21

ouq Cebpeu gug coçg w6dpTL' 1DAuwC IuA6acweIJc woqe] gug

(wg? Th83): —3O5 ______________________coIJ2cLp)c& gug EcoLJoJIJTc yccTATcA1 ymGLcu ECOIJOWIC 6AT6A

B1uqeL' yjgu guq .oabp E 21cT8TTc .1WOLJG? cL6qc

Mgpuâcou DC ybi.TI 1aa3M0L]cTud bgbeLt fl 6CnLTcTG2 guq EXcJJ1Jd6 commTa2rou

RT6L' •1IcednrgçoLA DTCLG4TOU gug cLeqç cr.nucJJ.1

DLOO)CTucla gbe 013 ECOUOIUTG YccTATcA (Ta3: 5) 5o2—53aB6LUUJC61 B61J ' guq cgrg ro,'w uaJJG cLeqc crnucIJ.1

Page 32: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

(MoAemp6r. iaas): isei—i585WOIJ6X nbbj7 JOC)Ca1 ptI9LçGLJA onii o ECOLIOIIJTC2 Toe

COA6Lt aopu b6LLA y2ADflU6CLTC EttGC.2 O bOeTcTAe ug I46dcA6

E66LJ j626LA6 9gU]C O 46b1 AOLIC DGC6PGL T3E66LJ rniqe I�6 guq ECOUOIUTC yCcTAicA. nueodLgbp

COJJ6LJ' CGLJq guq 1opu MGUUTLId6L sWG B6cbl6GU

fluqa11 1�6AT6I Ot ECO13OTC2 guq 2cgcTacTc2 toLcpcolJlTuaEtt6C.P2 O WoU6çLA OJTCX 2JJoc)C8: EAqeuC6 LOIJI .çJJ6 LTOb Ocpr.raçri3o rgMLeucG' WLcTU ETCPGUPgnm gijq CJJLJ68 EAgua 1JjJG

J6AT6A 85 (wgA Teas): 3Q—33 ________________gug o1J6çLA JLIJ2m28O1J 6cJJIJT2JLf, YIIIGLTCgU EC01301111C

cJJL2cTuot P%L6UC6 gug wcu 2 ECP6UPnW rdnqcA E6C2Taa3): T8.2—1a1T ______________________________Cr-TçTcgT 2flLA6A1. onLu3 Ot ECOIJOWTC rTcaLgcnLe r (Decempe'

CPTLTJJ)CO HOP6LP 2 11RnTue8e rxeq I1JA6CW6LJc 2b6Ugua: y

ynanaçJLgU21IJT2T0U wecpguram rweodr.bjst opo flUAGL2TçA

C6CCJJGccT' 26bP6LJ C 1DT2cTudnTaPTud LJJGOLT62 O cpe woLleçgLA

4p6 Bfl2TU62 CACT6.4 BLOO)CTIJ'12 bgbGLa 013 EcO1JO1UTC YCcTATIA11IuAeucoTA (DT) TuAeecmeuc pjç6Lugj uuce Jnccncou2 sug

cgLbeuceL IcOpGLct W LgL' suq BLfIC6 C becGL6u

BguJ o MGt xoLJ' ]Vot me-iaas cLeqTc ozqot'u3 jjez A0L)c: 66L5JcJ16 CL6qTc Joz'tqoMLI1 ILl ecnge 013 C517262 suq C01326pn613c62cgucoL IcJsgLg sug yuçpouA ogLTdfl62 1oiips1c 6IJ6L2 sug

J6AT6M (2rrn'm6L jo): 3T—'r _________HILTUd D6CTTOUi, 6q6L5J 626LA6 1J]C 0 46b AOLJC pflsLçGLJA

csUcoL' I�TcpsLq 11Et6cca ot pGAGLgaG 013 col.boLgce 113A62Pil6uc sigECOUOIUTC J�6AT6bt 81 (nue iaar): 1—2I3 _______D6P 1 ;LnCcnLTUa obcTJiisi BgIJ]CTud yLLsuäem6uç1 YWBLTCgLJ

csIom7LT2' CJJSLTG2 M 5LJ CPSLTG9 KJJU uJ&P6 J�016 Ot DGJJJ13c5P16

9IL65fl O ECOUOWTC I�626SLCJJ' WgLCJJ T3bLOt2 1gx 0 Ie-3 MoLlcTud bgbeL j4o '588 I4gcTougTE1J1JC6 siiq IuA62cw6IJp: EAq6uC6 tLOllJ flUq2fLpflCGq

csrowrLT2' CPSLI6B w' suq w ejeuu urippgr.q iigx o1rc IUceLIJgT

TO1 (ynarc2ç rasa): ___________________________fliJeq Tsa4-raoa1 On5Lç6LJA 'lofrLlJsJ 0 ECOLJ0JUTC2

cLeqT suq ECOLJOIUTC ETflccf1scTou: EAq6LJC6 tLonicgIomTr.Tat CJJSLTG2 M siiq I�• 0161313 HnppgLq .bLTC6 EJ6xTpTJTcX

30

Page 33: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

1a3—5e2. _______________________________________nguçrçrea1 BLOO]TU gb6Le 011 ECOUOJIJTC YccTATcA (Iaa3: ):uq por.ç-eLns cLeqç wsrceç: yu yug]2?Te ot bLTC62 uqLqJJJgL,t B6IJW1J W giig K6UU6JJ M Kf1ç41J6L a,ECOJJOflJTC yccTATcA

Ecouo'uecr-Tcg (ocçopex. 1a33):ETBJJ6L ILATUa ..LJJG Depç-DeJ4rou JJJ6OLA O eregç D6bL622T0IJ21

couaedn6ucep ot pe mga-ma3 cgç joLqozi,' EGPLn9LX raaE66L9J I68GLA6 BgU)C O 4GA AOLJC 2fflgG2 011 Cgriee iiq

gbeLe 011 couowc yccTATcA (i: i): TT-T2 ________51ruguciud coueçr.gruca guq coLboLgce I1JA6cw6UC1 BLOOlCflJda

EggL1' aceAeu w ic T61JJ3 ijnppq ijg BLflCG c b6cGL2GLJ

BY}ID '1oflLUI ot ECOUOWTC9 (ynçrnliu Taa3): 358-3'15EX6 IuAeacmGuc: MGM EAqeuce ou LuucpJd cou2cLuc21

ggLT' 26A6U W guq BLflC6 C JGc6L6IY 1MoL)q1Ja CbçJ guq

I6ATGM o EcOUOWTc 2çflge2 (njA 1a82):guq uyLnbçc1: aje EGCç ot IUCGL62 gçea ou r?otta1.

JfoäeL EY 11IwbTTcTc couçgcça I.tTCP YJ1JJJJecLTC IutOLwgcToLy

wouecgLA couomca ('inue 1382): 33-33 __________gmg EfTaGLJG E 1Mpgç12 DTtt6LGUP yporrç gu]c21 or1Lug1 O

ouecgL/. ECOUOIIITC2 (lgUflgL? 1380): m- _________gwg ErraeLJG E 11BU]CIJd 111 LJJ6OLA O T1JgUC611 'ocitugj ot

boTTcX: V CLT4TCT (TLAGAt iaaoMeL.t OLjC IuceLmeqTcG L9LcIGc2 guq IL1qcgcoLa o 40Ii64gLAAeIq C1ILAG T11 woueçLA boTTcX'1 ILl GqeLg] KG2GLAG BguJc o

E2çLGTIgt VLITLO guq eg LqoaAGJr2 iibO2eTPTG OJ6 OJ5626LA6 gujc o xguge cicA raarImDcgçou2 pL oueçgLA BOITCA xg112g2 CTc1: eq9L9]DGCTTIJ6 ot commeLcr BgIi)CIJd 111 cpJJcp3a CDT wgLJc6ç:

Eqz'tLq& ELIJ)C]T1J 15 1jUgucj wgLJ6c8 T'' LLgIJ2TçTou -- OL

nLqA6LacA o cjrcdo aet 138eyIueLfcgu Bf1TU6aa cAcle: COUiJncA gq cpgucte cjicao:cAcie pi oaçt ELg jopeLç '.• oqou eg

Ec]2ceTu occo uq Yrieli ru J.jJ6 W6CLJ2J1J2 O P6 DJ1T1J62

______________________________wouTcoLTuâ1, IGATG1t 0 ECOUOWTC pcnqGe 21 (lflJA 138):

DgIuoug Donag2 14 1ETIJ11CTT Iuc6Lm6qc0I3 gug DeJGdgçGq

(ia'i: 5) __________________________________EXbGLTIU6IJca BLooJcTuae bgb6L2 011 ECOLIOWTC VCCTATcA

1�6C0U2q6Lç011 0 IUA6PUGU epgAToL n2Tua jgx g2crrn1uITL12 aou e KGATU y gaeç gug CI6IJLJ HflPPgLq fly

31

Page 34: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ECOIJOmTC2 (epLnL Ta3): -]iV __________________IwbeLteccToz gijq BfI2TIJG8a CACIG2II pnr.çeLA ponr.ugj o

CLG6UMT BLIICG C ug 10a6bP E 24TarT; WgLKGc

YCcAçA oxoLq: oxtoLq n1JTAGL2TcA bL622 Ta88L2ua eqe piuce coUecLT1JcB' ExDeccgcTou' uq ECOLIOIJJTCcouaçLuçat guq ECOUOTC yccTATcA iii welL xopu gug c

cLeeuz'tgJg BLITCG c 91iq ao2Gbp E 2cTaTTc 11Iuormcout TUYIJCG

HOJiJ6MOOq IT: ILATIJ br1pTTapTU8 bb• T.3-5T'uq FMLG1JCG t4JJT46 eqa 2çLflCçsTLgj jguâe u gujcruâcombgurea: YL6 LJJ&i BgLJ]C O EJ7cnL6. IU WCJJ6J <Jfl2U6L

eocoi egL iig CeoLâe bGUL1CCJJ ,I4OLJ6A )L]C6 jTi3q2 iig rijguce

gug piucj CLT26 cpcdo: flhJJA6LecA o cwrc1o bL62atEJnccncou8 jc cieuu HrJPpgLqt eq• T1jgUTgT wgL)C64eicgce Dtt6L6JJçI& CL6qT COUBCLU2 gug IIJAG2CIUGIJC

e6LcT6Lt wLJc' !� CTGJJU nnppgLq' guq lull K g2pAgb .1iucer-ec

CTc ETUIJCTI wgL]ce AOTSTTTcA ias8B1TTU6a2 Elf1CcflgTOU2.1 113 eqeL] 1G2GLA6 BLJ)C O xguge

CGLCIGLt wgr.jc' guiq J� CT&IJU HnppgLq 1ETugucrgI cçoLa p3

s (2nmmeL Iaa3): 58Q—303 _______________________JgxgçyoJJ% guq 4gcLoecouowrc JT)C.1 I�YMD 1OflL13J Ot ECOIJOIIJTC2

C6LcT6Lt wgjc guq ic cTeuJu HnppLq jcoLbor.gç6 u3uci-j boITcA

(raa3): '13—ev _______________________________yLarlmeuç2 ig EAqeuc6 '1OflL13 O ECOUOmTC2ImbeLteccTou2 T13 .çpe wouegi.X jj..gu2m].erou 146cpgu12w:

C6LCIGL g)t gug 2Tm01J CTICJJLT8c ,1Jj36 JO]6 O ceqc wjceç

pnLçerjA ontu o ECOU0TC8 ioa (wgA iaai): 3o-ocAciee ujq BepgAOL ot jjgjj uncçnLpJd LJD2

cei.clei.t WL)e uiq TmOu eTTcpLTBc wouergLA bOTTCX' BJT2TU622

62GLA6 suJc o guega ctcA iaarImDTTCcTOU2 OL WOU6LA bOTTCA' guage cTcA:

LLguaweeou acpuew11 I" cpuctpJci cbcgr r..Jceça:ci.eqrç cpuuej OL CLGqTç yccTou: vu Iuc6LbLeccou o

CGLTGL wg aCOIlflhIGLJ4n 013 cJJLacu D OW6L gug DAq H I�O1U6L

ECOLIOJIITC acngea a (raas): 22- ________ECOIJOJUA TçIs wnT;T-beLog LuucT JeJcou2pba . 1�TGI 0

eLçJeL' wgr. 14uucr cbccA gug oncbnc Encçnçroua p., gui

B]J)CL1ä 50 (yndn2ç ra88 gLç ): 22a-88ycçYArçA: LJ OAGLAT6t11 'jpnLug ot woLeA' LGqTç gug

CGLJGL' NL)C u3gucgj 2LITCRL6 gug yaaL6açe ECOUOJIJTC

35

Page 35: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ECOL'OWTCa (MoAemp6L rae): 221-2ev __________________nuceLçruç7 uq ceqç Jcçouua1 pWL6L]A onLIJg] o

'igee DMTdpc uq jsoiue jn6JJ 11iwbettecc IuoLmgçTou'

toLclJcoDJTIJa _____________________________EIJuCG guq LW IUA68çW6IJç onLugJ o WOU6A' CLGqTç' uq

nppq w eieuii' Y11TT IC gepAgb' uq 1LOUT t4pTcGq 1,IIscGLugI

onuj ot OJflCJ ECOIJOWA Too (irrne ra): 2oQ—23I1JA62WGUC bLoce9e: VU ybbTCçOU J1 yaLTctyTcnL6•,

nppgq J� ejeuu' guq YLJTT x 2pAb ,IuceLugj eç MOLJJ gug

ceqvia: yqqJaou—M6aJeA iaai•flnppgq% Ic cJ6UIY WOUGA' 4pe ugucj 2AapGm' uq cpe ECOUOmA'

raar): 33—eo ____________________________1J6J Dç'1 pnLeLJA OflLIJ O ECOUOmC2 102 (spLngL

rdrvrqcA uq IUAeacmGuc: EATcIGUC6 Lom '2bgueeHOaJJt j)ceot YiJT x pAb' uc D9Aq 2CJJL2ç6U ,1coLboLgçe

(ynana; i): \—:'t' ___________________________gpe 2bTLT.c o me ILOPTU8I ponu o WOUGLA EC0UOJDTcE 3oiice woLe: yii Ajniou o DOG2 wou6çgLA bOITCA wgççeL1 TU

HOOAGL K6ATIJ D' suq 2cGbJJ6U r beLes oc 'i.o obçeT.. oc

J�66LA6 BgIJlC O J4G AOL)C pJ1Lç6I.A j6AGA (2nmm6L io): -EAOIncTOIJ uq IU6L68 2GU2TcTATcA o oncbric' 66LJHTLc16 D6AGLTA guq ')egueçç6 K6116P6L •ETugUCrgJ jceç

ETUgUCTgI WT]C64 CLO1' rOUqOIJ 2CJ3001 O ECOUOWTC raarOt wnøgLl Cb4T1 DTCIT22TOU bgbeL jo' i

HgLc O1A6L' guq OJJU W00L6 V JIJJEOLA O D6P4 3g26q oU

28 __________________GGLA6 DgUJc O fl6 AOL)C O179L6LTA I�GATGt (ynçtiiuu ]a5): 2-Cb4T tOT wgLapJT ETLm QAGL BnaTueae C?CTGU E66LJ

HLqorzAerT2' rjcg& uq 1LpT6LL7t MsJUU' 4JJy6 JçGTgçA6 C02P O

yrTacz2ç iarwTm6oâLbp' ogq O OAGLUOL2 O E6BLJ l66LA6 2A2c6JilJJocJca: D7'JJ1UTC Ett6CP8 OIJ GcnLTcT6at rogua guq cgbrçg11

HIJCOC]Ct DTgug yuqe 1 rpJc1t uq gwee Y MTTCOX 111J)C Cbc1

MaJJudcoU: DLoo)crUa2 IuacTcncTOU iaeoCnLTGA' 'opu guq EqPtLq WOU6A T g pGor.A O .TUgUCG

212—238 _________________________D6A6TObmGU4 ymercu couomc IeATeM (26bc6mp6. 1a22):

enLTe?' viopu guq EqAgrq ugucrgj y2becça O ECOUOJIJTC

33

Page 36: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

EcOuOmC LJJ6OLA 20 (iaao):rricg& joper..ç E ar 11rJdnq4A guq Iu6Le2c gçea11 ionLligj o

AnTU6L9PTITc?,I Wm6odLbJJ W I L' 1aa3rmouç' OAGU 11coLboLçe D6P OAGLJJgIJd guq WgCLO6COUOJHTC

J�eATGb% (2ebcGzupeL\occopeL Iaa5): T8-32J316 I4GaJGccGq DTWGU2TOU2U eq6Lgj- K6GLA6 U)C O 2 rorq8

RiTeaGut KGATU r.t uq aoji" y aigcow s.We ieceuc cL6qp cLflUcJJ:

rouqou acpoor o EcoLJoJuTcat WLcp Tha3.iAoçgjci j4opnj.qLot uq OJJU WOOLG 1cLeqrc CACT62. W1JJ6OâLbp'

iast): 323—390TU g 16J BflaTIJ6aa CACTGU YW6LCLJ ECOIJOmTC I6ATGI't (nuKyudt J5O6L e' gug CpLJGa b10226L 11WOUGAt Leqçt uq bLTC62

i): T.—39 _______________________________WTàJJC B6 Icldpc51 Of1L6LJA '].OflLIJJ O ECOUOmCa T0. (vnanac

KTUdt J5O6L e giiq JO2 reATue 11EIJIJC6 guq eLoIcJJ: CJJr1Iilb6ç6L

Iaa3): 9—a8O EX46LIJT ELJUC611 YJfl6LrcgIJ ECOIJOJIJTC 6AT6P 93 (LcJJbOITCA uq c6qc coIJqcoua: EAq6UC6 tLOJJJ comboaTclolj

gapkgbt YLITI K '16L6Iil7t C 2c6TJ3 giiq DgATq MTTCOX 14oUGçgLA

cicao: flhJA6LaçA o cJJTcâo bL6aat IàV______________reugrua1, Iii J4 eLeaoL?t wgu]ci, eq' wouecgLA bOTTCA•

KapAgbt y1J1j K giiq aGLS&t C 2c6TIY woIJeçgLA bo]TCA gxiq gujc

COL16LGUCG GLTGa OLJ ITpJTC bOJTCA __________________CJJTC98Ot 9LC T1t OLJJCO1iITUà TU CLIJ6c16-cOCpGaçer.boTTcA ou 9IJ)C gjguce peçe WpliGoaLgbJJt flUTA6L2TcA o

epAbt VuTI x guq 'lGLGmA c 2p6Tu 4Lp6 imbcç ot woueçLA

OflL6LJA aoriugj O ECOIJODITC2 ica (yndrzaç ra): 2e2—2a5cOuqcOua iq C7CTTc BGJJAOI. O IUAGUcOLTGa.1

gapAgbt YIJTT K' 0A61J y rgwou.pt guq '1eL6w7 2cGTIJ 1eCL6qTc

(M0AGWp6L Ta9a) 13-3VECOI3OIUA 6q6L I66LA6 BgIJJc O j<gijage cTc7 ECOLtOIØTC 16AT6A

xpiit eeoLäe Y JjJ6 cpuduâ iuceac 2GUaTcTATcA O JJ6 flaorzLugr o EruucJ ECOUOJIJTC2 i (ocçopei. i): 302—320wgugdeweuç 96pgTot yaeucA COacat guq ObwGLapTb acLnccnLe.Il

lGlJaGLJt WTcpej' uq MTIIgUI WGc]CITUa LJJGOLX o JJ6 ETLW:

rogua11 'lonLugi o EuucJ EcououzTca ():'igjjjea' CJJLT2cObJJGL 2OW6 EAq6xJce 011 flhJTdfl6IJ6aa o U]C

Page 37: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

(m8't): I8.—55I ______________________________IUA62OL2 DO MO HA6 ¶1oflL1J O riJucgr £COUOIJITC2IUAG2flJ6I3 DGCTaTOIJ2 j.JJeu iiAe Iuormçou

weI.a' xiq cpoja wn; flcothoLç6 Ep3ucuâ gijq

On9LcGr. Taa3): ST—33 ______________E6q6LgT I6GLA6 BgIJ]C O I(I32 CT;7 ECOI3OIØTC I�6AT6I (ecoiiqejor.dgij Do1JJq •1ye7ur,meçLrc EtteCca o woueçgLA bOTTC?

guga CTçAt iniArog'.i COmmTcm6Uca1 t.IOL)qua b6L E6GL9J IGa6LA6 BgIJ]C O

woLägu ouq b ,,JpG reuqud ATGbt o woueçgLA boJTc guq gI3)c

ECO1JOIUTC 6AT6! (.nu 1a28): eI-5a. _______corboLCou ruguce gug peo.A o iuecmuc ymeLcu

LUCO gug I46LcOIJ )4TJJ6L •4JjJ6 C08ç OJ GbCTECOUOmTC yccTATcA (rafl: i): 153—TQV _________________BgJSIJCG peeç gug jJ6 ra.3-.2 I6CG82JO1J DLOOJCTlJâ2 ØbGLa 013

WT2J3YT1J ELeqeLc Mpc D6bLG2Gq PPG couanmeL,: IIJJG HOtI26JJO

D6bL622TO1Y1 OflL1J9J 0 ECOUOTC HT2cOLA (Ta.8): aTs-a3WT2PICTIJ Ir.eqeLc u1P6 HOfl26POJ BJI3CG jieeç giig QLG9

cwcdo bL62& aaV _____________CLGa0LA wguTbt eq oueçLA boflcA cpcao: fluTAeLaTC?t ob6L2bGccTI6 ou woueçgLA jguamra ou ecpur2nP11 iii w

NTL0U' 2GLGA CJJL8P1J D OW6L' guq DgAq M61T 11Hc0LCI

flIJTABL2TcA bLGa& I2wTu]cA' Amgu OjJ1J WA1NL k6A1362' MGM A0LJC: GOIrnhIpTg

h16La&: breucce—HJrt iaercLeqc' bTA cbcr wrce42 EIJd76t0Oq CITtt2 146M6L0LJII1JC6 O JJ6 ECOIJO&i1. Iii COIJJIilT28TOU 013 WO1J6A guq

WTU2)Q H?3zgU b 11ETIJ913CTYT CLT2T2' 1.TUU13CT 2?2c6m2 gijq

iao): ô82—1008 ______________________HOP ILPGX HA6 C3ud6q14 J6qGL JG26LAG BnTJpçps (DecGmpeL

gjicob ETT6GJJ 111jJ6 guamTaerou CJJLJLJ6J2 0 W01J6çgL7 OJTct:

135 _________________________________yaL6eJlieuç2, lOflLUSJ O TU9UCTYT ECOUOmTC2 (): -r6ugua bI.oce guq cbiT jceç j�eabouee co L1JC rogu

rrrnnueL' acoci guq IOJJIJ WCCOIJUGTT 1iEnr-cpeL EAq6uCG 011 BU]C

nTcA1 J�YI4D 1OflL13T Ot ECOIJOWICE (uçeL iaai) 82—102IIJA6EC1UGIJ DGCTaTOLJ2 MTcP yeAWmGcLTC IuoLmçrou yponç pogu

rncga D6OL 1 guq jopeç p wcouJq •1ujc nJgucT13d guq

32

Page 38: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

ECOUOJJJTC ycAA (iaao: i): ______________________wouecrJ aLguwraarOu K6CpIJaIU1 9L00]CT1JI2 b9t2 013

omeL' cJJL2çyug D' guq DgATq H 1�0W6L .M6M EAq6UC6 013 JJ6

WgCLO6C0IJ0WTC2 yuun iasa cmpLqae: WIJ bLGaa' 1a8aIii OITAT6L '1 BTUCIJYLq JJq 2cLJJ6X LTCJJ6L' 6q2' MDEIwçç6L: y eeç T bTLTc o ,L6qmu guq

IOJIJ6L' CJJLTeCTIJ9 D' ug DAq }1 }Om6L D062 NOIJ6çLA bOTTC?t

COLJ6L61JC6 26L162 013 bflpflC bO]fCA (D6cezuper. 1aa3): T-12J,Lgu2mr221ou o oueçLA boJTcA,.4 cL1i6c1G—1ocpeeçGL

jgmeA' AgT6L6 WHOM IwboLçgu T2 11J6 CL6qc cpguuGT T JJ6

n (isa): ___________________________IUtOL1flcTOU HXbOcPeBT2,1 onLUgI O 9u)cTu8 guq LTUSIJCG

Ett6C2 O COJJIJJJ6LCT Bgu)c eCnLTcT62 ot6LT1Ja2: ' JI62 ob01011CP6]C' '1OpIJ' }ALOIJ 2TOATIJ' gijg WL6 E 2n1JJc gjngçrouDgçg1, onugj o uuce (r.cj.i iaai): 3-38Lm-cL6qçoL J6JcO1J2JJb2 EA61JC6 tI.ow wjj

b6c6L26LJ' wTcCpeii y uq apflL1U c jggu 11JjJ6 DGUGtTce OECOIJOWTC YCcTATcA (raa3: i): 142—511 __________________DTtt6L6uc. YLG LPGX YTI DTtt6L6UI3is BL0o]CTUa D6L2 013

bGLLA' CeoLde r' gjjq CjJLr6a r Cj3nTçse 1M2 JIJJ12 J�6C622T013

B1J1C1Jd.' Tt' OLflJCOWTUc1 ____________________________BOLLOb%6L 140L g p'3q6L B6 '1OtILIJ Ot W0136A' cL6qc' gijqb66]c' aOe' uq ELTC I�o2eudLezy jpe cbrcgj cLaucji: I4GTcJJGL

JcSATGA (gA-.'1nu6 iô): SI—31 ___________________EudJuq11 E66L 6?6LA6 gujc o 9O?OU MGbt Eua.Juq EcouoJuTcb66JC' '106' iJq ELTC 1soeuaLeu• uJJJS cbcr CLIIIJCJJ T MGbt

I626LA6 gujc 0 IJCJ7WO1Jq ECOI3OIUTC J6AT6A (raa)0M6132' i�?mouq' guq ecc&t ecpr-etc 11IqeucApJa cL6qc CLflIJCPG2u

ECOLIOWTC2 iig eçfC2 (oAewpeL ia3):rIJgL,crud H6LLCJJA 0L 9112T1J628 ILJA62W6IJC I6AT6M 0OTTLJGL' D' gug C161313 D wTqepn2cp 0flLC62 o

COAGLLJOL2 0 66L 1�66LA6 2X26W'cL6qç CJJgULJGJ 0L 0U6çLA b0JTCA,11 WW6oäLbJJ' BOgLg 0

011136L' D' giq CTGIJIJ D Jnq6pn2cp •I2 JjJ6L6 g BU)C

EeqeLgJ J�66LA6 Aeçexu' '1gUngL7 iaa1DTAT2TOU 0 JfG6LC giiq 2cccce' 0 COA6LIJOLB 0cL6qc CpguueI OL woueçgL7 boTTcA.11 Mor]qua gber. jo re'

OTTIJGL' 2cebpeu D' guq eieuu D jnqepnecp I2 jjsr.e g pog

3e

Page 39: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

HoIqua cOxub9ut6s1 onL1Jj o; uucj Jçe2eLcp isAngçrou Ett6Cf2 OL 26C1TLTc? OttGLTJJàa O COJMJD6LC1 BSIJY

gJ2eA' '1JIIG2 M uq nbuqeL DTTIOIr 6ç6LmrLszJça o

(ra.a): _________________________coeci7 lpnLugr O ECOUOIJITC JJJ6OLA 51

ou2euq' JopGLc 1obipui couçgcçe gug cowb6;TcTA6 WL)CG2 MçJJ

ror'ra eAT6M (gungLX\epLngLA iaa't): 31-4acL6qTc AT6I O WOU6çLA bOTTC E66LJ jGB6LAG gu]c o p

JJJOLUçOIJ' DIJT61 r TUiJCi I3JUOAcOUt D6LeanIcou ug

.i ('arnie ra81): 3—(y ______________________wjceçe içp ImbeLtec Iuormcow41 ymeticgu EcouomTc eiie

2cTaTTc 'aoaebji E uq yuqLeii M6122 iicr-egTc Jcouua TU

tor.cpcomyua ________________________guq cAcJcJcA O EJlibiO7J116Uc11 ymer-cgu ECOUOWTC 7�6AT61.t'

JJLb6t 2CGAGZY 11ETIJgUCTgI wgjceç ImbeLteccToue' ETLm reAeLgae'

jeJçrouEJJrba11 f]onLUg o uuce 2 (iaao): ioea—io8ImbTTcTc couçLgcç2: y woqe ot GJlacOW6L

pgb% 26A6IY .y7mm6cLTc iiomp-ou' ujc reuqpid uq

O CJiTcgdO bL622 iaa't• ______________14 eLedoLA NgU]CTb1 eq W013649LA bOITCA CJJTC9dO: fluiAeL?Tçl.

2JsbLo1 wgççpei D eqegj J686LA6 bojicA: cgnae uq EtteCP1, iu

o cJ3wouq ECOUO3flTC I�GAT6I (l'ioAewpeL-DecempeL iao):cpLeçt cr.eqc coucl.o12: iaso4, eqeLi 626LAG

(1.joAeuspeL i): Q3O—8 ______________________________ImbeLteCc IutOLxugcTouI O(WLCGLTA 1OI1LLJJ Ot ECOLJOIØTC2cOmbecTcTAe IUaflLgUCG 4LJCeçe: Vii E22gA 013 ECOIJOJJJTC2 ooçjiacpq wrcpgejt gug 'aOaebp E 2cTdITcs ,EdflT1TPLTflhJJ P'

(E6pLngLA ias): '1O—28 _______________________________J1LgIi?gc.çToIJ2 CO2c2H 'aOflLUJ O toJTçrcgJ ECOUOJIJA 5

']01T° 'a V woueçgr-A EdflTJTPLTflW Woqe] MTcP

MT1J1II2 I4Gbt A0L]c: wcwjju 1a21.JLgge' gug ECOIJOWTC CL0McV: E22A8 T HOJJOL ot 'aopu H

oo2g' jsopeç A uhU6L62P j�gçe guq C6ucLgj BguJc Iii WOUeA'

CTcAt 1aa3WoIJe;gLA boJTcA xguga CTcA: EeqeLgJ J626LA6 BgIJ]c o xgugaWeCpguiaiir11 III cJJuaI3a CDrcSJ wgr.jcep2: ImbJcçou2 oLycou: yu huceLbL6cgcou ot oçzgL LLuemaaiouJ�OJIJ6L' CJJL2CIJ D guq DAq 14 KOWGL 11CLGqTp cjiuuei OL cr.eqc

Page 40: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

(iaso: ): 5.—5•EL7LJCJ HT24OLA.. Bi.ooJqL'ct gD6L2 Oh ECOLIOWTC YCcTATcA

MOIJTJOb%6L YJP6Lç 1,LJJG ceiiçgj J50J6 o CLqç CLnUCJJ62 Tu iceuc

(EGpLrIgLA Ia8.)EdflTTTPLTflJiJ cLeq j�courua1 pngLceLJA aonugj O ECOLIOIIJTC2

MTTIIli2OLJ co2cIA wourcoLrua obçwJ coucLgcçat gug

38

Page 41: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

A = ',cp bLopgprjiçA (y)

bLçTcnJgLt 16C onçbnç

p7 g TGA6I br.oboLçouJ dnuççX ot pgq cb1çj fl26q i.

antTcT6uc dnuçiç7 o aotc cgbçgJ% tper.e I2nTCT6UCII 12 q6Ju6q

cu TucLGg2G cpe cpuce 0j g aooq onçbnç LeJrgçrou It IC 17262 g

j1o mgje exgw1]-6 ge 211Ib]6 g2 boaaTpJs anbboa6 rmqecjou 12 iuqe

bLoqncçArçA nuC6LçgIJçA 2 L6gJT6g gc6 cp 1UA62cw6uc

Jp6 bLoqnccou 12 La)c7 ztcp •dooq1 uq ,1pgq1, bo2apJ6

pq cb1çj (2ncp a or. wuçe1Juc6 6xbGugrçnLe2)

-- guq eoç cb1ç c -- pibnça IpTcp pilbLoA6 pje br.oqncçptçA ot

ecouq b6Log p626 TubilCa r.e pr.g cbçj —— 2gA mgcJJru6LA

1J6J7LgJ pOLLOAGL (1262 TiJbflça bLoqnc6 onçbnç 26T1 TU JJ6

COUaTqGL cMo ber.oq -— 6LO guq 01J6 ILl JJ6 tTL2Ct g LTR]-

;i.'.' TUA62CWGUC qecaoue gqgbeg r.ow eGLcjer.. uq gnppgr..q (1a88)

eubrr.rcgj 622 O CL6qç AT6M4I IilOg6T2) P6TOA jJ g 21111bT6 iuoqe o

obbor.çnu1ç1ea I TTfl2L6 JJ626 COUCJIT2TOU2 (gug TTU)C

pOLLOi6L? 2b6uqua poiqud coiçguç nuqer.jApia TUA62Cm6uC

IJç6LUI jiuqet uq () g r.qncçou 3 nJç6Lug] nug2 L6flC62

pJç6ruJ fI1Jq2 AgLisa u6dgçTA6J7 "TCP CJJG J6A6J Ot CJJG pOLLO!6L42

nicer.ugj truYucet (s) 2bLegq 6Pi66U JJ6 CO2 O 6X6LUJ gLJq

J6uq6L2: (i) flUCOJJ6LJ6q exer.ugj t1JIJC6 Ta 100L6 coaçjA cputLTccToua L6TcJJa O geAJuIuGCLTc IJtOLmc]-Ou P6b661J pOLLO1.6L2 guq

L1J6L6 r.e 4J1L66 p2c COUCJ172TOUE O JliOq6a O tUgJJcg

YbbEMDIX: JHE .1LThYRGIYP YccErEy&oL. iw JUE .ICEDIJ MEL.

Th

Page 42: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

CJJC JJ6 bbI62(y) —— cj IC 1 —- qoea uoç q6beuq 013 uA tuucT AgLTpJ62tmr.arugj COBC O TUA6açTud LJJG AgJilG O1 1( 2C2tTG2 edngç1ou

combJeJllGuCgLA qqCOiJ O 171JC2 Ot 2Oç cgbTçgj) ednga CP6

P6IJGtTC tr.olu qqCTou9J TC o pgr.q cbrçj (aTAGU g(y5) BTJIJbjA 2CC62 pgc gç obTwnnz' 6Xb6Cçeq mr.apij

Pp6L6 L 2 dLoaB TIJC6L62C r.çe pA cpe r.m Ednçou+ — (:J+ = 0' (ys)

qeceoij TB TUC11TCTAG IC COO262 I CO BCTBA

It CJJGL6 PI6L6 130 Ut0LmcO13J TWbGLtGcCToUBt JJ6 tTL11J2 T13A62cm61Jc

LEdJlTL6a 0116 CO E2111U6 JJgC (t + + c >

IC TB ItAa GttTCTGJJC CO 6lJJbJOA BOtC CbTCSJ (or.wJA CPTB1126 fl1( JTIJTCB O 20 CbCT Or. 1J0116 EOL 2T1UbITCTCA gaBrnJJG

JjJ6 BCLJTCCrILG OJ CP6 bLopieUi dngLguCeeB CpgC 4JJ6 tT11 "TIT 67CJJ6L

br.oqnccACA LegTTgcTou T qo2AucLCc-, 0 2 -. a)t + = it o < < it r, > t gug CP6 r.guqoin

TUCL6gBTLJà' guq BCLTCCTA C0UCA6 (t.tper.€ i(o = jo = uqIJJ6L6 L)1( TB CfTC6 COUCTU11OrIBJA qt6r.6uCpJ6' BCLICCTA

It

= (yip)guq

c5 nI

A = .(IU ITCP br.oppj1çA 'guq

'10

Page 43: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

q62cLbço1J O L0J6 O pJç6LIJgJ lJGç MOL4JJ T'.' cp COLJçLCçruc1

it Tet cj.e tTLIØ onjq jice pOLLObY (E0L g LTCJJ6L

ueç zoçp ÷ jo mjc 2çoL? TuceL6acTua anme

beLoq OIJ6 bOLçJJ g bLG2GIJç AgJne O A\L H6JJCG .JJ6 TLm2 pJcTrdnq geç boaTclou uq coJJgçeLipJ6 ncr1Le bi.orç j\ Tu

g combeçTçiAe uceeqL? LuG tTLJIJ jJe 20mG T1Jç]-gJ

pOLLOb6L12 ueç AOLçJJ 2flbbOGG tTLW 2tau2 g jou couçcç

exceeg cçnj cb1ç] y uq cpa IJJ qebeuq 1UA6L261A 0U

couaedneuce o T2 q6Leq cgbiçgj

couçcç mcdçe TUC6UcTA6B cp6ç 2 2JJObUJ p6JO& 01J6

reuqeLe nuqeçguq cp12 gjjq nioqrA ruucigj

gccociuç) eJq 9 aLo82 T.cGLc Lgce

922H6 pe ;nuq (a p.' g zaa puj

beLdrrT2Tce cou2rnubcToLl cu g UflWGL ot toLmt oL 2TwbJTcTcA

iug?. pe aotc csbpj piuqa bGLaougJ agT1J 2flCP

exbeuqçrzLee ou ,otc cgbci.1 VLG uoç iii cge m91J986L

IlJJgLq cgbT.f9J.1 9L6 O26LA9JG p onCqe 6U6L2 tPTIG

cou2q6L exmb1e g apisbje gô.Guc? bLopjem: ExbGJJcrrnL6e 01.'

(1U6L 92AWuiG4LTc TutOLmgcTOu' BçoLA WOLG cowbc9çeq

cpuuej oL moueçiJ boTTcA'

TUA62CW6UC qewgtq t9112 JjJJT2 Ta nansj pJceLeac-Lgce

J6IJqLJd jio exçeuç gu obeu iugjceç agje L91262 t

6LO 20 L LebLeaGuça aLoaa L6dflL6q L946 O L6flLU 01.'

2rIbboaG oL 2T1I1bTTCTC cu TulGLeac Lgcs bgq ou qeboaç2 T

4JJ6 JJJ0LJGX ATGP mecpuraw TB GaA o TTTITBcL9cG T'.' CJJT2 exgwbiG

1jJ6 cL9qcouT TUc6L62c-L9c6 CJJ9IJLJGJ Otc6LJ qeuc]-eq t'trcp

'U

Page 44: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

tTLns msT2ç bg7i TUçGLW6gTL7 '- 6A6LJ.p o g pgg

GIJçLGbLGUGnL,2 p0 cpegç 12 O TUCLGg2G gizsorniç

oue zgA pi MJJTCJJ cJJe uC6LweqL7 conq L6f1C6 fl36

r1uq2 beL2ou 1126.

poLl6aç gcçioi., 6XC668 .PJ6 1u tLOIU qA6Lcrua pp6 aoç CbTCr

EdnCou (v2) n2c 2cgc62 CpG uggugdGL12 exbecç6q du .om

+ - + ((I(.) + + L1( (ye)

,1Tuc6uC1e c0JJ2CLgTUCII:

tubnC pq Lpç T9t couçLgcç flJ(Taç 2gçT2A cJj

CPG tTLI1 CJJG 1UC6U41A6 p0 TAC Iii aoç cb1çj g g combr6m6uçL7

CTAGU J6 nuqeLT7uà TUC6UCTAG bLopTeIu couçLgcç iuneC tIAG

CIJIJ6J2 nuqa LO1D 2A6L? POLLOfk6L2 iq 11262 110 L62011LC62

apgç T2 toT. apubjccA' nme uc6Lw6gL7 ?pJJbJA

(vi)

edrij dLO uçLeC Lç6 L driuçTçA pOLLOt't6q:

OttGL gLy exbeceq L6pnLu edn p0 1C2 obboLCrzulCA co2ç o nuqa

i.ow .ppe uceLm6qLA12 bGLab6cCTA6' jou couçLc.p iuneç

+ - - (y3)

Gxb6cç6q bLotTC2:

LJJ626 couçucçnj 6flL62 9L6 CJJO26U p0 WXJil6 PP6 tTLJIJ12

I6A6T guq g bAmeuç T JJG 6AGIJC O PJJ6 •1pgq OfTbrIç 16A6J

UC6L1IJ6gLX T 6A6U CP6 bLo6cç A6q2 cP6 1ooq onçbn.p

POLLOPi6q (1" CPT8 Cg26 t + c'i - ' g bAm6uç O JJ6

JJJ6 tLm—uC6Lm6qgL7 jou coucLgcc 2becItTc2 iuonuç

266 C6LCT6L T5)

15

Page 45: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

JjJ6 GXbJgLJgTOIJ tOL JJ12 66Cç 72 jgç PIJJ6IJ TIJC6UCTA6

TUAG2CW6LIC ObboLçrIuTçrGa:

tflLJCCTOLJ o pOLLOI6L12 ueç toçp + \' jiojqpi coueçuç

ya jouâ ga 6dr1cou (y) pojqa' pieaçnieuç T gjj ucLeaua

(ta + — + A)]K+ L(-i- t'\'.) = 0 (y)

LejgçrOu gnioud uceeac gçe uq uç6LuJ ueç oLcjJ:

GJTJIJTUgçG b L1q LOIØ 6dITCOU (ye) uq CJJGL6p7 OpçiiJ g

couaptniç (pi (ye)) giBo ppiqa flaTuâ (ye) guq (yQ)' OUG cgIJ

jisgxnurnii exçiJç boeaTpjet cpe TTJ1IC61 JPIçApeu CJJG TIJC6IJCTA6 colJBcLgTUC pTUq' T2 qGBTLgPTG .ço Lg76

TIJAGaçwGuç qGCTBTOUB L6 IJO JOIJdGL uq6beuq6uc ETLBC UOCG

MIJEIJ PPG TUC6UCTAG couaçLruç (Tu (v2)) puqe tL1IJcUd gijq

JTCp g CLegçwGuç)

couarqGLgçrouat 26Gb tOL exgmbje eeLCr6r uq HrzppgLqt ]3 for..zonjq jq poçp qep; uq ednTç7 couçcça gug

(EoL aTmbTTcTcA ze ge pacLCçud ;Lom g LTcPGL BLflCflL6 ;JJgC

iu qqcou bççeLu ot coiçcç bsAmeuça a uq6ceLwrugçe

ppiq gcçngj TIcW6UC i apJJb]A qJnaça qeaeq TuAeaCeuc 1

OUG Cg26 TB 6g27: ya roi.ia gB T1JC6U4TA6 COL12L97IJC qOeB uoç

o y uq mxse (y3) anpeCç (ye)' (v2)' uq (y)

J10 2rIJllJHgLTSG' coucLcçuä bLOpJ6IZJ 1UA0TA62 JJ6 B6IGCCTOIJ

+ I' (ye)

coIJaCLgyuc TUtTflGUC62 CP6 couçLgcç:

gaaepa TU CJJ6 pgq açgçe jpç TB' g jpçeq TpTJCA41

OflCCOJUG JJ6 tTLJJJ' JJOM6AGL' cu ou]-? CLeq]-pTA bLomTae CO bX

Page 46: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

pOLLOz.t6L2 o g dTAGU cAbs (s Mçp aJiijgL

eponjq 6cç TUAGCCWGUC (pt.oggrA qetpisg) armit.jA tot.

TU LegJ TUC6L62C t.gçse tojjoApiâ g uoueçgt.A couct.ccou

(i) MJJGU Twb6Lt6cc10u2 âuoL6q gLI

gt.drnusuça:

bt.eqccoua t.ejçeq •1mousX AT6M. uq 1cLeqç ATGZ't,.

abeuqpi8 gjj eae ednj pe Lm6toLjc g]eo Aejqe aTuJbJ6

pOLLOZ'6Lt guq g qcjp U U64 ot.çp L6flC62 pOt.Loi'6L21

tTuguc6 CJJ2 äb gLrea TUA6L26TA ATW Cue 1uc6Lugr U64 ttot.çp onucojjgceLgjieq exçet.uj tTULIC6 exceega pjjgç picet.ugj

CJJ6 11tTuuciI ccejet.gçot. wecJJu2us: jpe coaç o

LJJT2 2TmbI6 tL9Jil6bOL)C Ta C0u212C613c ATCu C1J6 q62cLbçOIJ otJ0M6L2 pocjj qeaLeq uq cçnj TUA62cw6Uc

pot.t.ozet.a jcjc cceae uou—psu]c tuucs) T' .bet.tecçjA 6TaçC enbBJA aCjJ6qiij6 tot. inueq (gug

g utapet. Jilgt.dTugJ ObbOLCnuTCA coaç o nuqe pecgnae o g eaaJ,O 266 JJ6 jgcceL' IJO6 çpgç gC6

TUAGCCDJ6UC i (epics Ta q6ceLmueg pA ( + = ,i +

nuqa ou cconuç o g woueçgt.A couçLgcçroii t.eqncee qeaLeq266 tOt.JJJ6L IJOçG gu TIJCL6gC6 T' J6IJ6L21 obboLCilIJTCA coeç o

TUC6t.68c—t.SC6 cpuue uox. puc Ieuqua cjsiiue Jo

JjJ6 6xTaceIJce O CJJG IJ6 ot.p cpiiuej bL6cflq62 136TCP6L

gmorniç ot TI62c111613c t68pJ6

coI32çLuç ppiqa gu 1JCL6g26 TU pict.ugi ueç Ot.çp UCt.6g262 CJJ6

9K= [(i + - + \) > 0 (w8)

Page 47: Joo AUfl - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2020. 3. 20. · TuflA' zJsTI6 miiA COJIJbOUGUCB O dâL6dgç6 qiiigug L6 gLângpJA COPGIJ guq I46UUTIJd6L' T3 guq E2L6JJ gijq HLqorTA6Ja

aTAGu 0b6u mgL]cGç TcTc Lç6) poLLoter..

T.qTATqT JGU6L2 gecc cLeqç (gç gupuboLcuç pocjc o

(2) it LeI;oueJJb2 P6P661J POLLOI.t6La uq 8b6CTtTC psujc L6

qebeugeuç POLLObt6L LT262

Cpe CD iøgr.jceç) y g r.eanjç coeç ot flU2

o 6X6LU rniq (29? v'

uouruguc]-gJ poLLoz.eL? y qcjpi Tu pujc1 U6 MOLJJ

() pe moqej1 TucnTcTou cu bbjA puc g2 M6JJ gaPOLLOP6L2 tTIJIJC6 2b6L7qUa

pujc csqç cu TJJtTJIGIJCG cJJe pr]rç? o pu)c-q6beug6uç

tOL TuçGLIJgJ 6M POLçJJ cjguàea Tu A TpTJTçX otmoucoLeq pujc CL6qC cu 6 Ot g 2flP2CTCfIC6

() Eor pgu)c-qeb6uqeuç pOLLOA6L2t JJ6 ot

Tuc6LuT IJGC MOLçJJ

L6TçAG Co ab6uqUa pA pOLLOPiGL2 PITCJJ PTaPGL 16A612 O"TCP JOMGL J6A6J2 O Tuc6LIJ9I U6 !oLçp aponjqJJ6 POLLO6L 2g6 gjj 6J26 sdrij' ab6uqud pA poi.r.oi'x.e

(s) It T6LtGGctou L6 aiduiicguç ouTAguq LT2JC cpLcçeLaCrca)

'12